75 Volume 19, Fall 2007 Social Justice Lenses and Authentic Student Voices: Enhancing Leadership for Educational Justice Jose Lalas University of Redlands & Eva Valle University of Redlands Abstract: In addressing the issue of educational inequality and achievement gap, this research article demonstrates that critical implications could be gleaned from listening to the authentic voices of students by using a social justice lens. A social justice perspective in educational leadership is essential in evaluating the impact of race, ethnicity, class, gender, sexual orientation, poverty, and disability on the educational outcomes of students in urban schools. Recent studies have documented that students in urban schools face many educational, social, economic, and cultural challenges that are as- sociated with race,ethnicity,and poverty (Haycock,1998;Haycock,Jerald, and Huang, 2001; Singham, 2003). In addition, it is common knowledge now that achievement gap is a reality between mainstream students and minority students and many efforts are underway to study, understand, and dismantle the existing educational inequality (Lopez, Magdaleno, & Reis, 2006; Barone, 2006; Portes, 2005). There is also no disagreement that we need to learn as much as we can about the growing numbers of Educational Leadership and Administration
28
Embed
Social Justice Lenses and Authentic Student Voicesresearch article that critical information could be gleaned from listening to the authentic voices of students by using a social justice
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Jose Lalas & Eva Valle
75Volume 19, Fall 2007
Social Justice Lensesand Authentic Student Voices:Enhancing Leadership for Educational Justice
Jose LalasUniversity of Redlands& Eva ValleUniversity of Redlands
Abstract: In addressing the issue of educational inequality and achievement gap, this research article demonstrates that critical implications could be gleaned from listening to the authentic voices of students by using a social justice lens. A social justice perspective in educational leadership is essential in evaluating the impact of race, ethnicity, class, gender, sexual orientation, poverty, and disability on the educational outcomes of students in urban schools.
Funds of Knowledge Itreferstotheinterconnectionsornetworksofthestudents’iden-tities,schools,families,neighborhoods,communities,andoveralllivedexperiences that they have acquired through life. Minority studentshaveavarietyofcommunityandhouseholdexperiencesthatshapethestrengthstheybringintheclassrooms.Therearealwaysnetworksoffriends,relatives,andcommunitycontactsthatfacilitatedifferenttypesofeconomicassistance,laborcooperationandreferral,andsocietaladvance-mentandparticipation.Itisimportantthatschoolleadersacknowledgethese“fundsofknowledge”andusetheseresourcestofacilitatestudentlearningandintellectualadvancement.Thestudents’multipleidenti-ties,socialbackgrounds,andlivedexperiencesaredynamicsourcesof“fundsofknowledge”(Moll&Gonzalez,2001;Moll,1994).
Resiliency Itisaprocessbywhichpoor,diverse,andimmigrantchildrenandtheirfamilieslearntorelyupontheirculture,family,peers,andethniccommunityassourcesofsupport,framesofreference,andshieldsfrommanyof thenegativeattitudes that instilldiscriminationand fostermarginalization.Ithasbeenshownthatstudentswhomaintainastrongself-identitywiththeirsocialandculturalcommunityareabletodowellinschoolinspiteofsocialinequitiesandotheroddsagainstthem(Trueba,1999).Schoolleadersshouldrecognizethenotionofresiliencysothattheymaybeguidedonhowtocomplementandbuildthestrengthofstudents’positivepersonaltraits,self-esteem,anddispositions.
Politics of Caring and Connectedness Valenzuela(1999)highlightedtheimportanceofwhatshereferstoasthe“politicsofcaring,”aconceptthatemphasizestheneedtoestab-lishreciprocalrelationsofrespectandsupportbetweenstudentsandeducators.Sheexplainedthatstudentsandteachersneedtodeveloppositivefeelingsoftrustandnurturemeaningfulrelationshipsinordertoenhancetheirlearningandacademicsuccess.Ithasbeenfoundthatstudentswhohavestrongconnectionswithfriendsandschoolpersonnelincludingtheirteachersandcounselorsare“morelikelytoresistthepullofgangsthatofferanalternativeformofconnectionforalienated
Social Networking Stanton-Salazar(2001)recognizedthevaluableroleofparentsandencourageslanguageminoritystudentstodevelopbilingual-biculturalformsofidentitythatcanservetostrengthentheirsocialvalues,bridgecultures,andallowthemtoexcelacademically.Recognizingthatganas(motivation)andpotentialsarenotalwaysenoughtoproducepositiveresultsinahighlycompetitiveeducationalenvironment,Stanton-Sala-zaralsostressedtheneedtonurturelinksorsocialnetworkingwith“institutionalagents“suchasteachers,counselors,andmentorswhocanguidethewayforneweducationalopportunities.Thesupportprovidedbytheseinstitutionalagentscanservetodefendtheirinterests,providethemwithconstructiveadvice,andguidetheiroverallprogress.
Participants in the Study Weasked35post-secondarystudentswhorecentlygraduatedfromurbanhighschoolslocatedinsouthcentralLosAngelestowriteabouttheireducationalexperiences.Allthirty-five(35)studentsattendedur-banpublicschoolsandmanagedtograduatefromhighschool.TheyallattendedanurbanuniversityinLosAngeleswheretheresearchersorauthorsofthisarticletaught.Althoughalltheparticipantsinthestudyattendedauniversitywhenthisstudywasconducted,theirrelativelysuccessfuleducationaljourneyswereneithersmoothnorseamless.Mostof thesestudentswereolder,non-traditionalstudentsofcolorwhoseeducationalexperiencesweretatteredandthwartedbyseriousobstaclesrelatedtotheattributesofpoverty,genderbiasorracialdiscrimination.While thousands of students in similar circumstances overwhelmedbysocialinequitiesinurbanschoolsdroppedoutofschool,ouruniqueparticipantsinthestudydecidedtostayinschoolandfightfortheirrighttoachieveaqualityeducation.Asaresult,theygainedacriticalunderstandingoftheneedforeducationalreformandsocialjustice. Theirpersonalexperiencesandattributesprovideduswithlessonsthatwecanusetoimprovetheschoolingofstudentsinurbanschools.Theselessonscouldservesasinspirationforotherstudentswhonevermadeitto,orthroughcollege.
Theoverallobjectiveofthispromptistoelicitamongthestudentstheirpersonalexperienceswhichmayincludethemajorevents,people,rolemodels,teachers,subjects,peergroupsandothersocialchallengesthatcharacterizedtheirschoolingfromelementarythroughcollege.Thewritingpromptwasdesignedtoprovidetheparticipantswithanoppor-tunitytointerprettheirownlivedexperiencesusingtheirownauthenticvoices and to reveal their recollections of their schooling experienceswithemphasisontheirperceptionsofthe“inequities”citedinpublishedliterature.Moreimportantly,thepromptwascreatedforparticipantstodescribehowthese“inequities”builttheircharacterandresiliency.Asaqualitativestudy,theauthorsexaminedtheeffectsofurbansocialcontexts,events,objects,andideasintheirsuccessesandfailures.
Data Collection and Data Analysis Allthenarrativeswerereadbythetworesearchersfocusingonthe
Description and Analysis of Findings from Students’ Stories Thestudents’detailedessayswereread,synthesized,andanalyzedcarefullyforsocialthemesreflectedintheirlifeexperiences.Manyformsofsocialinequitieswereidentifiedandsortedintocategories.Thenarra-tivesprovidedrichsourcesanddescriptionsof“inequities”thattheyhavefacedinurbanschools.Becausetheseinequitiesarecommontermsandoccurrences,theresearcherswereabletoalmostliterallyidentifytheminthenarrativesasthetermswereexplicitlyandattimes,implicitlymentionedbytheparticipantsthemselves.Itissignificanttopointouthere that theresearchersof thecurrentstudycarefullyreadall thenarrativestogetherandalwaysreachedaconsensusinidentifyingandcategorizingtheinequitiesexpressedinthestudents’narratives.Table1 lists the social inequities students mentioned in their narratives.Themaincategorieswereracialprejudice,religiousprejudice,genderprejudice, classdifferences,andcultureand languageprejudice.Theotherissuesmentionedthatdidnotfitthecategoriesidentifiedintheparticipants’narrativesweredrugandalcoholuse,generationaldiffer-ences,andgangparticipation.Havingtheseperceivedsocialinequitiesreflectedintheparticipants’narrativesisanindicationofhowseriousandimportantitisforschoolleaderstolistentotheauthenticvoicesofurbanstudents. Fromthiscollectionofthirty-five(35)narratives,six(6)representa-tivenarrativeswereselected.Thesixnarrativeswereselectedonthebasisoftheirappropriateness,clarity,andrelevanceinrevealingtheirperceptionsofsocialinequitiesinschools.Theresearchersestablishedconsensusinselectingthesixnarrativesthatprovideavarietyofsocialexperiences,perceivedsocial inequities, studentsuggestions throughtheirownwords,andlessonslearned.Thebasicsetofcriteriausedbythe
Social Justice Lenses
82 Educational Leadership and Administration
researchersinselectingthesixnarrativeswerevarietyofissues,studentsuggestions,andlessonslearned.Duplicationofissues,suggestions,andlessonslearnedwerecarefullyavoided.Theselectedsixstudentswereallfirstintheirfamiliestoattendcollege.Theessaysreflecttheauthenticvoicesoftheparticipantsandhighlightthestudents’“perceivedsocialinequities,” “words of wisdom,” and “lessons learned” in their schoolexperiences.Allnamesinthenarrativeshavebeenchangedtoprotecttheconfidentialityoftheparticipants.
Presentation and Analysis of Findings from 6 Selected Case Studies
(1) Pascual—Navigating Through the Systemwith Determination and Support PascualM.wasborninEcuadorbuteducatedintheUnitedStates.Heisfirstinthefamilytoattendcollegeandhashighhopesofbecomingafamousanthropologist.Hismotherraisedhimasasingleparentandworkedhardtoprovidehimwiththebasicnecessitiesoflifeandwasastrictdisciplinarian. Perceived Social Inequities.HecametotheU.S.speakingonlySpan-ish.Inhisnarrative,henotes“inthosedaystheydidn’thaveteacher’sassistantstohelptheLatinochildrenthatspokeSpanish.”HehadtostumblethroughschooluntilhegainedfluencywithEnglish.PascualacknowledgedthatheadmiredateachernamedMrs.R.,forsheinstilledhimwithconfidenceandinspiredhimtoexcel.“ShewasaLatinaandshewouldtellmymotherthatIwassmartandIwouldbeaprofes-sionalintheworld,someday.”PascualalsoenjoyedthesupportofaLatinacounselor,namedMrs.L.Shehelpedguidehiscurriculum,gavehimadviceaboutcollegeandmoreimportantly,“shecaredabouthowIwasdoinginschool.”Thepersonalattention,guidanceandsupporthereceivedfromthisteacherandcounselorhelpedbuildhisconfidence,self-esteemandensurehissteadyacademicadvancement. AlthoughPascualwasfluentandtookprideinspeakingSpanish,“[he]soonlearnedthatitwaspreferabletospeakEnglishandtheuseofSpanishwasnotreallyappreciated.”Hekeenlyobserved,“thatalltheLatinokidswouldspeakEnglishtolookgoodandrelatetothe‘whitekids’becauseweallwantedtobelikethe‘whitekids’becausetheyhadallthenicematerials.”Hedepictedtheracialclimateoftheschoolastense.Itincludedthepresenceofvarioussocialgroupingssuchasgangmembers, skaters,whitepower,gothic, ravers, rebles (boysandgirlsthatwear605jeans,tightclothesandleatherboots),ballers,(thosewhoworeexpensivebrandnameclotheslikeGuess,Nautica,etc),andthechuntis,(Nortenos—thosewhorecentlycamefromMexicodressinglikecowboys).Pascualneverjoinedanyofthembutinsteadplayedsportsandjoinedthesalsaclub.Intheeleventhgrade,hedescribedhowsomemembersofthewhitepowergroupspray-paintedethnicslursontheschoolwalls.Theythreatenedtobombtheschoolonacertaindaybut,fortunately,itneverhappened. Pascual’s Words of Wisdom and Lessons.Pascualstressedtheneedto“defineandexpandourselves,forexamplelearnmoreaboutpeople,placesandevents.Also,wehavetoconfrontourownracismandbiases,honestly acknowledge these biases and begin to question them, and
(2) Elsa J.—Affirming the Importanceof Culture, Language and Ethnic Pride ElsaJ.wasbornandraisedinSouthCentralLosAngeles,wheresheattendedthelocalpublicschools.AfterafewyearslivinginsouthcentralLosAngeles,herfamilymovedoutofthe“barrio”intoamoremiddleclasscommunityknownasPicoRivera.Thistransitioncausedhertoundergoadramaticrevelationconcerningherculture,language,andethnicidentity.Shewrote:
Perceived Social Inequities.Inhernarrative,ElsarevealedhowsheenjoyedherkindergartenteacherMs.B.because“shemadeusfeelwel-comedandwaspatientwithus.”ThekindnessexhibitedbyMsB.,stoodinstarkcontrasttothemean-spiritedbehaviorofMs.G.,herfourthgradeteacher.Ms.G.“mademylifemiserableandruinedthelittleconfidenceIhadasachild.”Since,Elsa’sfirstlanguageisSpanish,Ms.G.ridiculedherbysaying“Can’tyouread,areyoustupid?IrememberprayingtoGodforhernottopickmebecauseIdidnotwanthertomakefunofmeorcallmenamesinfrontoftheclassroom.” Soonthereafter,Elsalostthedesiretolearnandherschoolgradesdroppeddramatically.Herparentsnoticedhernegativeattitudetowardsschoolandtransferredherintoanotherclassroomwhereshecheerfullyasserted,“Myteacherdidnotmentallyabuseme.”Elsaclaimedthatthenegativelearningexperiencelefthermentallyandemotionallyscaredandisoneofthereasonswhysheisstillnot“abletospeakinfrontofagroupofpeople.”
Jose Lalas & Eva Valle
85Volume 19, Fall 2007
Elsa’s Words of Wisdom and Lessons.Atthisimportantjunctureinhereducation,Elsa’sfatherdirectlyintervened.HeemphasizedtheneedtopreservetheMexicanlanguageandcultureinordertoinstillherwithasenseofprideandself-esteem.Headoptedstrictrules—demandingthatSpanishbethelanguageofthehomeandthemeansofcommunicationamongthefamilyandinsistedthatEnglishbereservedforonlythoseindividualsunabletospeakSpanish.AlthoughElsaandhersiblingsresentedthisimpositionofSpanish,itforcedthemtopracticetheirna-tivelanguage. Elsa eventually realized that cultural assimilation was not theanswertoherproblems.Sheadmittedthat,“IwasdenyingmycultureanditwasfoolishofmenottowanttospeakSpanishifitwaspartofmyidentity.”Moreover,shewasashamedandembarrassedbythere-sentmentanddiscriminationperpetuatedbyherChicana/oclassmates.Theyridiculedand insultedrecentMexican immigrants (whomtheyreferredtoas“wetbacks”)strugglingtolearnEnglish.TheseChicana/os,Elsanoted,“hadel nopal en la frente(themapofMexicoimprintedontheir face)”yethypocriticallyrefusedtospeakSpanish.Theseracialattitudesinspiredhertogainarenewedsenseofethnicprideandtodeclare,“Afterwards,IpromisedmyselfthatIwouldspeakSpanishandcontinuemyMexicantraditionsandwouldnotdenymi gente.” Elsa’sgreatculturalawakeninginspiredhertoenrollinChicana/oStudiesclassesattheuniversityandbolsteredheracademiccapabilityanddiffusedthehurtandshamecausedbyMrs.G.’snegativecommentsduringherearlyyearsofelementaryschool.Insteadofgivinguphopesheadvisesthatweuniteandadvocateforchange.Shewrote:
(3) Jonathan—Fighting Racial Segregation and Appropriating His Own Ethnic Identity JonathanH.beganhiseducationinaninnercityschooldistrictinLongBeach.Attheageofsix,Jonathan’sfatherwasshotintheheadanddied.Thistragiceventcausedhisfamilytobe“thrownintoawhirlwindofconfusionandinstability.”Hisimmigrantmotherimmediatelyaban-donedtheU.S.anddecidedtotakeherchildrenbacktoherhomelandofTrinidadandTobago.HisfamilyeventuallyreturnedtotheUnitedStates,whereJonathanwasbussedtoamiddleclassschoolandtrackedintoalowreadinggroup.Hequicklynoticedhisabilitygroupwasoften
Social Justice Lenses
86 Educational Leadership and Administration
neglectedandexcludedfromthesimpleprivilegesofferedtothehighabilitygroup.Heexplainedthathelearnednothingwhenheattendedhisneighborhoodelementaryschoolsituatedinamajority“black”area.Heclaimedthattheteacherallowedthechildrentosimply“playaroundintheclass.”ThislackofmotivationcausedJonathantofeel“confused,badandhopeless.” Perceived Social Inequities.Toimprovethequalityofhiseducation,Jonathan’smotherenrolledhiminamagnetschoollocatedinaveryaffluent,“White”neighborhood.Jonathanexplainedthat“despitethehugebusingeffortforinnercitystudentswewerestillclandestinelysegregated from ourWhite counterparts. Even lunch was indirectlysegregated.”TheprivilegesofWhitestudentsthatheobservedcausedJonathantodesiretobe“justliketheWhitekids”andheexplains:
Jonathan’s Words of Wisdom and Lessons.Aftergraduatingfromhighschool,Jonathanenrolled ina fewcoursesata localcommunitycollege.However, he soon discovered he lacked the organization and necessary“criticalthinkingskills”toadvancehiseducation.Headmitted,“Ifailedallmyclassesthatyearanddroppedout.”Inreflectinguponhispublicschooldifficulties,Jonathanholdstheschoolresponsibleforhewas“encouragedto
Jonathanlamentedthelackofethnicrolemodelsandrecallsthat“mostoftheprofessionalstaffintheschoolsIattendedwherefemaleandWhite.”The lackof critical inquiryapparent inhis coursesalsofrustratedhim.Hedecried“thecurriculumgiventousleftmewithasensethatnothingwaswrongwiththeworldandallproblemsweresolved.Ididnotrealizethatthereweredissentingviewstowhatwewerelearning.” FormanyyearsJonathandeniedhisownheritageanddesiredtobe“justliketheWhitekids”butknewhewouldneverbe“goodenough”tobe fullyacceptedbythem.Hewrote:“Iwantedtoski,haveblondstraighthair,andaskateboard.IwantedtobejustliketheWhitekids.”This“Whiteprivilege”instilledhimwithself-hatredthatcausedhimtoremaindistantfromotherAfricanAmericans.AlthoughJonathanhasgraduatedfromtheUniversityandmaintainsadiversecircleoffriends,hehasnotyetfullycometotermswithsomeofthepastinequitiesandthepainfulexperiencesheendured.Jonathan’snarrativeilluminateshisstruggleagainstracialsegregationandtheculturalalienationthatstudents of color experience within the Eurocentric culture in mosturbanschools.
(4) Michael H.—Political Activismas a Viable Alternative to Poverty and Crime MichaelH.isanAngloAmericanwhodepictshisearlyeducationalexperienceas“chaotic,”causinghimtomoveover30times.Sometimeshe moved down the block; other times all the way across town. Hisfamily’slifewasnotthemostwholesome.Hisfatherservedtimeinjailforseveraldrinkinganddrivingcitationswhilehismotherspentmostof
Social Justice Lenses
88 Educational Leadership and Administration
hertimeworkingtosupportthefamily,leavingMichaelandhisbrotherunsupervised.AsMichaelexplained,“Wewerealwaysdoingsomethingthatmightbeconstruedasillegal.”Atfirst,theydidsimplethingslikebreakingintoschoollockers,butsoonbegantobreakintolocalschools,houses,andcars.Thislandedhisbrotherintoprisonwherehespentmostofhishighschoolyearsandearlytwenties.Hisbrother’smember-shipinadeadlyurbangang,however,earnedMichaeltherespectandprotectionheneededatschoolandonthestreets. Perceived Social Inequities.Duringhiselementaryeducation,Michaelenrolledinsixdifferentschools.Thismadeitdifficultforhimtounder-standthesubjectmatterorthegoalsofinstruction.Hewasneveragoodstudentnotearningmorethana“D+”averageandconsideredhimselfluckytohavegraduatedfromhighschool.Hissinglemom’slonghoursatworkforcedhimtoraisehimself.Heplayedwiththeotherpoorandethnicallymixedkidslivinginthesamesmallmodestapartments.Inclassherarelypaidattentionandwasoftenplacedindetention.Ratherthandohisassignedhomework,heplayedoutdoorsuntilhisparentreturnedhomefromaharddayofwork. DuringmiddleschoolhelivedinWhittierandLaHabra,orwhatheclaimsthelocalsreferredtoas“GuadaLaHabra”duetothelargenumberofLatina/orecentimmigrantsresidinginthisarea.Michaeldescribesthisasatimeandplacewherehesimply“didn’tlikeanybody.”Despitethislevelofsocialdiscomfort,MichaeldistinctlyrecalledhowrichkidswerebussedinfromaffluentneighborhoodsinanattempttointegrateWhittierschools.Henotedhowdifferentthesekidswerefromtherestofthemandthat“theyassociatedonlywiththemselves.Ifyouwereluckyenoughtoassociatewiththem,youcouldnothavefriendsfromyouown[local]neighborhood.” MichaeldidmanagetoestablishfriendshipsamongsomeoftheseeliteWhitestudents.Inordertospendmoretimehangingoutatthehomesoftheserichkids,hesoonstartedskippingclasses.Hislackofeconomicprosperity,however,madethewealthyWhiteparentsapprehensiveandtheyeventuallyprohibitedhimfrominteractingwiththeirchildren. Upongraduationfromhighschool,Michaelclaimedhe“hadnofu-ture”anddepictedhimselfas“aloneandhopeless”withoutthesupportofhispeergroup.Confusedandalienatedhebeganexperimentingwithdrugs.Hisfamilysituationhadbecomeevenmorechaoticandofferedhimlittlesupport.Michaelexplainshowisbrotherhadbecome“morepsychoticafterbeingshotbyarivalgang.”Michael‘smotherkickedhimoutofherhouse,forcinghimtomove-inwithhisstep-fatherwhohadsincebecomeaddictedtoheroin.Livinginthisenvironment,Michaelalsobegantoget“hassledbythecops”andstartedtopursuethesame
Michael’s Words of Wisdom and Lessons.Michaelcontinuedtoenrollinpoliticalsciencecoursesandbecameabsorbedinpoliticalideas.Hewasabletoregaincontrolofhislifeandpursuedacareerthatprovidedhimaclearsenseofpurposeandcommitmenttosocialchange.Whenaskedhowandwhathemightchangeaboutthepresenteducationalsystem,Michaelinsistedthatthefirstandmostbasicstepwastointro-duceracial/ethnicdiversityinhistorycoursesandtextbooksthroughoutthecurriculum.Hebelievedschoolsshouldpaymoreattentiontothecontributionsandlegacyofpeopleofcolor,womenandpoorpeoplebe-cause“fortoolongthesecommunitieshavebeensteppedonandgivenaforcedhopelessness...”Hesharedhisowncriticalreflectionsconcerningtheorganizationofschooling:
Michael’s intellectual development embodied Freire’s notion ofconscientization.Hisacquisitionofknowledgeledtoahigherlevelofself-awarenessandinspiredhimtoimplementpoliticalaction.Hisup-bringingreflectedsomeofwhatStanton-Salazar(2001)depictedasamixtureof“hopeanddespair.”Hisraceaffordedhimacertainamountofprivilegeandmembershipwithinthedominantculture,yethiswork-ingclassbackgroundplaceddefinite limitationsonhisopportunitiesforsuccessandhappiness.Althoughheinitiallyrejectedschooling,heeventuallylearnedhowtoembraceeducationasasourceofknowledge,power,andliberation.
Social Justice Lenses
90 Educational Leadership and Administration
(5) Tamara J.—Motherhood Provides Heran Inspiration to Learn TamaraJ.isatallandleanAfricanAmericanwomanwhoinheryoungerdayswas“veryathletic,participating in sprints, relaysandmarathonsaswellasthelongandhighjump.”ShewasborninIndi-anawhereshespentmostofherearlyelementaryschoolyears.Sheattendedalocalpublicelementaryschoolwhere,exceptforoneIndiangirl,allthestudentswhoattendedwereBlack.Shewrotethat“allofuschildrenwereinawebecausewe’dneverseenarealliveIndianpersonbefore.Everythingthatwe’dheardorseenofIndianswasintextbooksandintheirnativeregalia.WhenWhitestudentswerebusedintoherneighborhoodschool,Tamarawasshockedbecause“forthefirsttimeWhitepeopleattendedourschool.” Perceived Social Inequities.Tamaraeventuallymoved fromIndi-anatoSouthCentralLosAngelesandattendedalargeraciallymixedurbanpublicschoolwithover2,000students.ShedepictedtheracialcompositionasmostlyBlacksandLatinoswithasprinklingofWhitesandAsians.Sheexplained,“ItwasherethatIexperiencedmyfirstsocialinteractionswithHispanics.Infact,IhadneverevenseenaHispanicuntilImovedtoCaliforniaandIliterallyhadtoasksomeoneonedaywherehewasfrom.”Shebegantoexperienceracialtensionsonadailybasis.Shebecamefamiliarwithstudents“whodefiantlyidentifiedthem-selvesasgangmembers,andwherethesocioeconomicbackgroundoftheresidentsrangefrompovertylevel,workingclassandtheverylowendofthemiddleclass.” WhenTamarabecamepregnantasateenager,shedescribeditasa“bitter-sweettimeofmylifebecausewhileIwasdoingthingsthatIenjoyed,IhadtogiveupbasketballbecauseIbecamepregnant.IamhappythatIdidnothavetodropoutofschoolassomanyothershavebecausethe fatherandIhadaverysupportive family.” Instead,sheenrolledinanacademicallydemandingmagnethighschoolwhereshemetateacherwhoadvisedhernotonlyaboutacademicsbutalsoabouthowtoadvanceinlifeasayoungmotherwithhighaspirations. Tamara’s Words of Wisdom and Lessons.Aftergraduation,TamaradecidedtoattendaLosAngelescommunitycollege.Oneofthemajorobstaclessheencounteredwasthelackofinstitutionalsupportandanymeaningfulacademicadvice.Shenotedthat“noneofthecounselorsdidanycounselinginyourfavor...thereIlearnedIhadtowantsuccessformyself,notdependoneveryoneelseexpectingitorwantingitforme,ifsuccessformewastrulygoingtohappen.”ThiscommitmentreflectswhatRicardoStanton-Salazar(2001)hasconceptualizedas“unsponsoredself-reliance.”Tamaranotonlygraduatedfromthecommunitycollege
Itrulyappreciateeachandeveryoneofmyacademicmomentsofex-posurebecausethosemomentshelpedtoshapethepersonIamtoday.Althoughparentsareourfirstteachers,schooliswherewespendthemajorityofourwakinghours.Schooliswheremyskillsofdiscipline,compassion,timemanagement,goalsetting,socialization,andaccep-tance of differences and similarities were enhanced, developed andfine-tuned.
(6) Parla K.—Struggling to BalanceCultural Traditions and Gender Equality ParlaK.wasbornandraisedinCalifornia,butherparentsfoughtdiligentlytopreservetheirIndianculture.Theyrequiredtheirchildrentodress inIndianclothes,demandedthat theyspeaktheirnativelanguageathome,andforcedthemtogiveprioritytotheneedsanddesiresoftheirfamilyandminimizedtheimportanceoftheirfriends.Parlaunderscored this cultural conflict,“I am Indian throughmybloodandAmericanthroughmyupbringing.”However,herparentsresentedAmericaforitsbrokenpromisesofeconomicprosperityandthesocialinequalitythattheyexperienced.Theyhadtoworkthelandandpickfruitintheburningsunforlowwagesinordertosupporttheirfamily.Sheexplainedthesenseofrejectionexperiencedbyherparents:
Americawasn’ttoofriendlytothembecausetheydidn’tlooklikeotherAmericans, theydidn’tdress like them, theydidn’t speak thesamelanguageasAmericans,andtheydidn’tknowthelifestylesorman-nerismsofAmericans.
Perceived Social Inequities.Parlaexplainedthatadjustmenttoschoolwasdifficult.Shewrote:
Culturally, Indian parents have always praised boys so much morethangirlsandhavethesesetgenderinequalitiesthatit’sextremelydisgustingtoeventhinkaboutit.Soknowingthatmybrotherhadall
Inaddition,Parla’sparentsexpectedhertoreturntoIndiaandmarryapersontheyhadselected.ThisglaringgenderinequitycausedahighlevelofmentalandemotionalstressforParla.Ultimately,shedecidedtogainmorecontroloverherlifeanddemonstratetoherparentsthatshewasn’tlosingher“Indian-nessbyaddingsome“American-ness”intoherwayoflife. Parlarefusedtoacceptthistraditionalroleofwomen.Shemovedawayfromherfamilytoattendauniversitywhereshejoinedseveralcampusorganizations,includinganIndianclubandaGreeksorority.Theseclubsinstilledherwithastrongersenseofidentityandtheop-portunitytoreconcilebothherIndiancultureandAmericanupbringing.RatherthantheconstantclashofculturesthatfueledherdisdainforIndiantraditions,shegainedarenewedsenseofethnicprideandcul-turalappreciationforherethnicheritage.“IamfinallyproudtoclaimmyIndianheritageandatthesametimeknowtheAmericanculture.” Parla’s Words of Wisdom and Lessons.Parlaacknowledgedthat,“Iwasjustassolidinmywaysasmyparentswereintheirs.”However,timeanddistance enabledher to critically reflectuponher culturalheritageandprovidedherwithadifferentorientation. Parla’sstruggletodefendherownvoiceandindependenceinlifemadeherastrongerperson.Shegainedanappreciationforwhatitmeanstobeamulticulturalperson.Sheplanstobecomeateacherandshareherunderstandingofculturaldiversitywithotherstudentsofcolorwhomayfacelanguagebarriers,culturalmiscommunication,genderbias,orgen-erationalgaps.ItistimeasParlastated,“toteachstudentsthetruth.”
Students PerceivedInequities QuotesofWisdom LessonsLearned
Pascual uSpanishlanguage “Confrontourown Questionand bias racism” discussourbiases. u Lackofinstructional “ShewasaLatina Seekhelpbyusing helpinSpanish andshewouldtell institutional u Racialprejudice mymotherthatI agents—teachers, u Violenceatschool wassmartandI counselors,and u Poverty wouldbea coaches. professionalinthe world,someday.”
Elsa u Spanishlanguage “Weneedtounite Speakoutagainst bias andbeour injustices. u Lowteacher children’svoices.” Throughparental expectation “Afterwards, influence,use u Humiliationfrom promisedmyself ofSpanishat teacher thatIwouldspeak homestrengthens u Poverty Spanishand self-conceptand continuemyMexican identity. traditionsandwould notdenymi gente.”
Jonathan u Fatherwasvictim “Replacethe Buildselfconcept ofviolence educationalsystem toavoidself-hatred u Trackinglow withacritical anddisconnection abilitystudents andmulticultural fromone’scultural u Lowteacher paradigm.” heritage. expectation “Iwantedtoski, Honoring u Racialsegregation haveblondstraight differences— u Racialviolence/ hair,anda notbeingWhite— tension skateboard.I buildingties u Disconnectionfrom wantedtobejust acrosscultures hisBlackidentity liketheWhite andlearninglevels. u Poverty kids.”
Michael u Familydisconnection “Educationisthe Infusediversity u Lowteacher keytoliberation.” andethniccontent expectations “Ultimately,Iwould intohistoryand u Lackofparental liketoseethewhole othercourses. support systemreworked Treatallchildren u Racialsegregationsothatchildren equally. andbias wouldn’thaveto u Drugs gothroughthis u Gangaffiliation mazeofprivileged/ u Poverty nonprivileged.”
Social Justice Lenses
94 Educational Leadership and Administration
quotesor“wordsofwisdom”expressedbythesixrepresentativeurbanstudents.Whilebroadarraysofthemeswereidentifiedinthe35narra-tives,theselectedsix(6)narrativesrepresentedaninterestingcontrastandvarietyintermsofthesocialinequities,students’wordsofwisdom,andlessonslearned. InTable2,forexample,PascualM.underscoredtheimportanceofnurturingrobustsupportnetworksandestablishingcloseandcaringrelationshipswith teachers, counselors,andcoaches.ElsaJ.’snarra-tivedepictedthetremendousinfluenceoflanguage,cultureandethnicidentityinthelearningprocessaswellasnurturingstrongself-esteem.JonathanH.openlyandcandidlydiscussedtheimpactofracismanddiscriminationandadvocatestheneedtocreateamorediverse,inclusive,and hospitable learning environment where all students’ knowledgeandlivedexperiencesareequallyaccepted.MichaelHendersonvividly
Students PerceivedInequities QuotesofWisdom LessonsLearned
Tamara u RacialSegregation “Itrulyappreciate Adversitybuilds u Racialviolence eachandeveryone strength. andtension ofmyacademic Self-relianceto u Teenagepregnancy momentsof achievesuccess. u Poverty exposurebecause thosemoments helpedtoshapethe personIamtoday.” “IlearnedIhadto wantsuccessfor myself,notdepend oneveryoneelse expectingitor wantingitforme, ifsuccessformewas trulygoingtohappen.”
Parla u Genderbias “Iamfinallyproud Appreciation u Racialbias toclaimmyIndian forbeinga u Culturalconflict heritageandatthe multicultural sametimeknowthe person. Americanculture.” Balancing “Iwanttoteach cultural students…thetruth, traditions thatwearereallya andgender heterogeneoussociety.” equality.
Jose Lalas & Eva Valle
95Volume 19, Fall 2007
describedthe impactofclassbackgroundandhoweconomicscarcitycoupled with negative familial influences can encourage students toengageingangs,drugs,andcrime.However,hispoliticalactivismandpositivepeerinfluenceinspiredhimtoredirecthislifetowardseduca-tion.TamaraJ.becameanAfricanAmericanteenmombutratherthansuccumbtodefeatanddrop-outofschool,sheutilizedthissituationasa“wakeupcall”thatinspiredhertolearnandexcel.ParlaK.strugglednotonlytobalanceherIndianheritageandherAmericanupbringingbutalsotofightforgenderequalityandherrightasanIndianwomantosecureacollegeeducation.
Implications for Teaching and Leading for Educational Justice
There were several important lessons gained from the personalstrugglesandeducationaljourneysreflectedinstudentnarrativesthatwereexaminedusingthesocialjusticelenses:theroleoffundsofknowl-edge,resiliency,connectednessandcaring,socialnetworking,criticalpedagogy,andinquiryasstance.Theuseoftheselensesinunderstandingandexaminingthestudents’narrativesmadethecurrentstudyunique.Ratherthannegatetheirsocialbackgroundanddiverselivedexperi-ences,theylearnedtoembracethemaspowerful“funds of knowledge”thathelpeddirectthemthroughthetrialsandtribulationstheywereforcedtoendure.Theyexhibitedahighsenseofresiliency duetothesourcesofsupportprovidedbytheirculture,familypeersandethniccommunity.Thesocial networksandstrongconnectionstheynurturedwiththeirteachers,counselorsandfellowstudentsshieldedthemfromviolenceand crimeoftenprevalentwithin their ethnic communities.Utilizinginquiry as a stance,theparticipantswereabletoreflectandre-examinetheirpasteducationalhistoriesandidentifypatternsofso-cialinequities.Usingtheviewpointofcritical pedagogy,theresearchersandtheparticipantswereabletounderstandthesocial,political,andculturalcontextsthatinfluencetheirpersonaldevelopment. Whattheparticipantsinthestudysharedwerethevaluablelessonstheyhaveacquiredthroughyearsofstruggleandtheirnarrativescanhelppavethepathtowardsocialandeducationaljusticeforotherstofollow.Theirauthenticvoicesofferedimplicationsforimplementingasocialandeducationaljusticeperspectiveintheclassroomandinleadingschoolsthroughopenconversation,articulationoftherichnessofdiversity,useofinequitiesastopicsforsocialandmulticulturalawareness,emphasisonpositivebehaviorandcaringconnection,anduseofcriticalliteracy.Basedonthefindingsofthisstudyweofferthefollowingrecommendations:
(1) Provide opportunities for students to discuss their experiences with
Social Justice Lenses
96 Educational Leadership and Administration
social inequities including racism and discrimination they perceive in school.Thenarrativesbroughttheexperiencesandemotionsoftheurbanstudentstolifebyportrayingtheirneighborhoods,homelife,varioustypesofparentalsupportorinvolvement,theirsocialgroups,andtheirparticipationwithinschool-sponsoredactivities.Throughtheseessays,thestudentsprojectednotonlytheirfrustrationsbutalsotheirtriumphsandproudlyacknowledgedthoseteachers,counselors,ormentorswhomadeadifferenceintheirlives.Studentssharedthechallengestheyconfrontedalongsidethecopingstrategiestheydevisedtohelpensuretheiracademicprogress.Althoughmostunderscoredtheneedtochangetheeducationalsystem,theydidnotknowhowtoinitiateinstitutionalreforms.Therefore,studentsneedtohaveopportunitiestospeakopenlyabouttheirownexperienceswiththevarietyofinequitiesthattheyper-ceiveinschools.Oneofthewaysforstudentstohavetheopportunitytovoicetheiropinionsisthroughteacher-drivenclassroominstructionalstrategies.Theteachercanusetheperceivedsocialinequitiesastopicssuchasracialprejudiceandgenderprejudiceorclassdifferences,forexample,forthematiclanguageartsandsocialstudiesunits.Whetheritisdoneasawholeclassactivityorindividualactivity,readingfictionandnon-fictionbookswithcarefullychosensocialjusticethemescouldstimulatethinkingandconversationaboutthesetopics.
(2) Students also need to become aware of the different ways in which racism interacts with other forms of inequities based on class, gender, language, and religious differences that can impede their self-esteem and academic achievement.Theycanbemadeawareoftheseissuesthroughdistrict-widediversityprogramsforteachers,staff,andstudents,aswellasthroughcarefullyplannedclassroomreading,writing,andorallan-guagedevelopmentactivitiesbytheteacher.AbookStirring Up Justice: Writing and Reading to Change the WorldwrittenbyJessicaSinger,forexample,hasmanysuggestionsforteachersonhowtocreatelearningenvironmentsthathonordiversityandencouragesocialjusticeactivism.Unfortunately,thestandards-basedteachingpracticesinmanystatesincludingCaliforniaarelackingin“stirringupjustice”curriculumandinstruction.
(3) Articulate with the students the richness of the diversity they bring in the classroom.Byexpressingtheir“voicesofpainandvoicesofhope”(Rabow,2004)throughwriting,weprovidetheopportunityforstudentstobreaktheir“silence”andtoconstructtheirowninterpretationsofknowl-edge,grapplewithissuesofpower,andestablishtheirethnicidentities.These narratives demonstrated how students directly experience thepainofracism,theabuseofsexism,andotherformsofinequitiesthat
(4) Use the perceived social inequities as topics for social and multi-cultural awareness.Whilethenarrativesimplythatadversitycanbuildstrength,theyalsosuggestthatteachersneedtounderstandthischallengeinordertoprovidestudentstheassistanceandresourcesthatcanhelpthemadvanceintheirschooling.Thecriticalsocialissuesandinequitiescouldserveasdialoguetopicsforreflectivediscussiontoraisethestudents’levelsofsociopoliticalconsciousnessaswellastheirpersonal,commu-nity,andglobalawarenessforpotentialtransformationandsocialaction(Banks,2002;1996;Lalas,1991).Schoolleadersincludingpreserviceandinserviceteachersneedtoacknowledgethevalueofmulticulturalismanditsinfluenceindevelopingthestudents’positiveattitudestowarddifferentethnic,cultural,andreligiousgroups.Awarenessofone’sculturalidentityandthepositiveinfluencefundsofknowledgehaveonurbanstudentsdevelopthestudents’confidenceintheirabilitytosucceedacademicallyandsocially.
(5) Use critical literacy in expanding students’ responses.Criticalthinkingineducationmeansthatthecriticalpersonhasthecapacityanddesiretoseekreasons,truth,andevidence.Tobecriticalbasicallymeanstobemorediscerning inrecognizing faultyarguments,hastygeneralizations,assertionslackingevidence,truthclaimsbasedonun-reliableauthority,andambiguousorobscureconcepts.Inthelanguageofcriticalpedagogy,thecriticalpersonisonewhoisempoweredtoseekjusticeandemancipationfromoppressiveconditions.Criticalliteracyisapowerfulapproachinworkingwithallstudents,includingurbanstudentsandsecond language learners,becauseof theprime impor-tanceitgivestosocialengagement,authenticity,respectfordiversityinworldviews,andreflection.Schoolleadersincludingadministratorsandpreserviceandinserviceteachersneedtolearntheperspectiveofviewingcriticalliteracyasanaturalpartoflearninganduseteachingstrategiesthatfostercriticalliteracysuchasjuxtapositioning,theme-basedfocusgroups,problem-posing,andcreatingalternativetextsacrosscontentareas(McLaughlin&DeVoogd,2004).
Social Justice Lenses
98 Educational Leadership and Administration
Conclusion
Thedominantthemesexpressedinthestudents’educationalnar-rativesdemonstratethehistorical,social,political,economic,andcul-turalcontextsthatinfluencetheirpersonaldevelopmentandschoolingexperiences.Racialviolence,stereotyping,bullying,racialsegregation,poverty,languagebarrier,gangparticipation,anddrugandalcoholusearespecificcommonexamplesofsocialinequitiesthattheparticipantsinthestudydiscussed.Thismeansthatschoolleadersandteachersmustexertconcertedeffortstostudythehistorical,social,political,economic,andculturalconditionsthatpavethewayfortheexistenceofinequitiesand“savageinequalities”inmanyurbanschools. Thestudentnarrativesalsosuggestthattheschoolcultureandlearn-ingenvironmentsarenotconducivefortheeducationofethnicminorities,especiallytheEnglishlanguagelearners(ELL).RumbergerandGandara(2004),forexample,explainedthatthe“seveninequitableconditions”thatexistinCaliforniaaffectingtheopportunitiesoftheELLtolearnincludeinequitableaccesstotrainedteachers,inadequateprofessionaldevelopmentforteachers,inequitableaccesstoappropriateassessment,inadequateinstructionaltime,inequitableaccesstoinstructionalmate-rials,inequitableaccesstoadequatefacilities,andintensesegregationinschoolsandclassrooms.Theseinequitableconditionsandperceivedsocialinequitiesbythestudentsinthestudymustserveas“redflags”forschooladministratorstoenhancetheirunderstandingofinner-cityschoolcontextsandtoleadforsocialandeducationaljustice. Leadingforeducationalandsocial justice,accordingtoCochran-Smith(2004),mayincludeculturallyresponsiveteaching,makingcontentcomprehensible and accessible, effective and purposeful questioning,useofdifferentformsofassessmenttoinforminstruction,supportforstudents,collaborationwithparents,communitymembers,andotherprofessionals,knowinghowtointerpretdata,maintaininghighacademicstandards,beingateacher-researcher,andstrongadvocacyforequityanddemocracy. Asidefromdemocraticcitizenshipandafocusondemocracy,oth-erssuggestthatteachingand leading forsocial justicealso includes“anti-oppressioneducation”whichhighlightsdiversityinschoolsandproposesdifferentwaysofconfrontingtheinequitiesfacedbystudentsinurbanmulticulturalenvironments (Brandes&Kelly,2004).Manyclassroompractitionershavealsobegundesigningandimplementinginstructionthatreflectssocialjusticeinstructionandcriticalteachingthroughstudents’personalstories,useofliterature,criticalliteracyascomprehension(McLaughlin&DeVoogd,2004),“actingforjustice”les-
Jose Lalas & Eva Valle
99Volume 19, Fall 2007
sons(Christensen,2001),thematicunits(Beale,2004),servicelearning(Lucas, 2005), cooperative learning (Sapon-Shevin, 2004), and otherlearningstrategiesacrossdifferences(Shor&Pari,1999). Inconclusion,programsdevelopingschoolleadersshouldemphasizeanadvocacyforsocialandeducationaljusticeforallstudents,positivebehavior,andeffectivelearningthroughcarefulattentiontotheneedsofitsurbanstudents.Respectingthediversityofstudentvoicesintheclassroomshouldbeahighpriorityforschoolleadersincludingadmin-istratorsandpre-serviceandin-serviceteachers.Educationalleader-ship,educationalfoundation,andteachingmethodscoursesaswellasstaffdevelopmentworkshopsforadministratorsandteachersshouldintegratediversityandhowtomakecaringconnectionswithdiverseurbanstudentsastopicsfordiscussionandimplementation.Thesocialjusticelensesconsistofcriticalpedagogy,fundsofknowledge,resiliency,politics of caring and connectedness, social networking, and criticalinquiryasstanceprovideschoolleaderswithaconceptualframeworkand“skill-set”forenhancingtheirself-awareness,attitudes,behaviors,andperceptionsregardingtheschoolingofdiversestudentsinurbanschools.Theurbanstudents’“voicesofpainandvoicesofhope”needtobeheardinorderforschoolleaderstounderstandthestudentsandcreateacaringenvironmenttopavethepathforacademicexcellenceandeducationaljusticeinschools.
References
Anyon, J. (2005).What “counts” as educational policy? Notes toward a newparadigm.Harvard Educational Review,75,65-88.
Aronowitz,S.&Giroux,H.(1985).Education under siege.NewYork:NewWorldFoundation.
Banks,J.(Ed.)(1996).Multicultural education, transformative knowledge, and action.NewYork:ColumbiaUniversityTeachersCollege.
Banks,J.(2002).An introduction to multicultural education.Boston:Allyn&Bacon.
Barone,D.(2006).Narrowing the literacy gap: What works in high-poverty schools.NewYork:TheGuilfordPress
Beale,U.(2004).Familyissomeonetotuckyouintobed:Teachingaunitonfamilydiversity.InM.Shamnsher,E.Decker,G.Brandes&D.Kelly(Eds.),Teaching for social justice.Vancouver,Canada:BritishColumbiaTeachers’Federation.
Christensen, L. (2001). Acting for justice. Rethinking schools online, 15(2),Winter2000/01.
Cochran-Smith,M.(2004).Walking the road: Race, diversity, and social justice in teacher education.NewYork:ColumbiaUniversityTeachersCollege.
educational success for language minority students. In California StateDepartment ofEducation,Schooling and language minority students: A theoretical framework(pp.3-49).LosAngeles:Evaluation,DisseminationandAssessmentCenter,CaliforniaStateUniversity.
Cushman,E.,Kintgen,E.,Kroll,B.,&RoseM.(Eds.)(2001).Literacy: A critical source book.NewYork:Bedford/St.Martin’s.
Deveaux,M.(2000).Cultural pluralism and dilemmas of justice.Ithaca,NY:CornellUniversityPress.
Dewey,J.(1916).The School and society and the child and the curriculum.Chi-cago:TheUniversityofChicagoPress.
England,C.(2005).Divided we fail: Issues of equity in American schools.Ports-mouth,NH:Heinemann.
Diller,J.,&Moule,J.(2005).Cultural competence: A primer for educators.Bel-mont,CA:ThomsonLearning—Wadsworth.
Fehring,H.&Green,P.(Eds.).(2001).Critical literacy: A collection of articles from the Australian Literacy Educators’ Association.Newark,DE:Interna-tionalReadingAssociation.
Freire,A., & Macedo, D. (Eds.). (1998). The Paulo Freire reader. NewYork:Continuum.
Freire,P.(1974).Pedagogy of the oppressed.NewYork:SeaburyPress.Freire,P.,&Macedo,D.(1987).Literacy: Reading the word and the world.South
Hadley,MA:Bergin&Garvey.Gadotti,M.(1994).Reading Paulo Freire: His life and work.NewYork:State
UniversityofNewYorkPress.Gandara,P.(1995).Over the ivy walls: The educational mobility of low income
Chicanos.NewYork:StateUniversityofNewYorkPress.Giroux,H.(1983).Theory and resistance in education.SouthHadley,MA:Bergin
&Garvey.Giroux,H.(1988).Teachers as intellectuals: Toward a critical pedagogy of learn-
istheroleofleadershippreparationprograms?Educational Leadership and Administration: Teaching and Program Development,18,11-19.
Lucas, T. (2005). Fostering a commitment to social justice through servicelearninginateachereducationcourse.InN.Michelli&D.Keiser(Eds.).Teacher education for democracy and social justice.NewYorkandLondon:Routledge.
Macedo,D.(1994).Literacies of power.Boulder,CO:WestviewPress.Marshall,C&Oliva,M.(2006).Leadership for social justice: Making revolutions
in education.Boston:Allyn&Bacon.McLaren,P.(1989).Life in schools: An introduction to critical pedagogy in the
foundations of education.WhitePlains,NY:Longman.McLaughlin,M.&DeVoogd,G.(2004).Criticalliteracyascomprehension:Ex-
pandingreaderresponse.The Reading Teacher,48,52-62.Miller, P. & Endo, H. (2004). Understanding and meeting the needs of ESL
approach.InR.Ruddell,M.Ruddell,&Singer,H.(Eds.).Theoretical models and processes of reading.Newark,DE:InternationalReadingAssociation.
Moll,L.&Gonzalez(2001).Lessonfromresearchwithlanguage-minority.InE.Cushman,E.Kintgen,B.Kroll,&M.Rose. (Eds.).Literacy: A critical sourcebook.Boston,MA:Bedford/St.Martin’s.
Nieto,S.(2003).What keeps teachers going?NewYork:TeachersCollegePress.Nieto,S.(2000).Affirming diversity: The sociopolitical context of multicultural