-
Hi h S d R il i B ilHigh Speed Rail in BrazilSão Paulo - Rio de
Janeiro TAV Project
Compare and Contrast StudyCompare and Contrast Study
Steve Clark, PERail Business Leader Americas RegionRail Business
Leader, Americas Region
The Western High-Speed Rail Alliance Conference 2010October 13,
14 and 15October 13, 14 and 15
-
Today’s Presentation
• Arup: Who We Are
B il TAV P j t O i d C t• Brazil TAV Project Overview and
Cost
• The Bigger Picture
-
ARUP – Who we are
-
Who We Are Principal Fields of Activity
• A global, integrated, multidisciplinaryfirm of professionals
working togetherto tackle the complex building, designand systems
issues
• Buildings
• Consulting
• Infrastructure
• Over 10,000 engineers, designers,planners,
managementconsultants and economists
Infrastructure
• 90+ networked offices in 40+ countries
-
Arup Office Locations
90+ Offices Worldwide
-
Brazil TAV Project Overview and Cost
-
Region of Sâo Paulo and Rio de Janeiro
Region of the States of São Paulo and Rio de Janeiro
-
The Key Cities in the Region
• Campinas (1,064,669)• São Paulo (19,889,559)• São José dos
Campos (2 243 687)São José dos Campos (2,243,687)• Rio de Janeiro
(11,513,000)
-
Distances Between the Cities• Driving Distances
• Campinas to São Paulo: ≈100 km• São Paulo to São José dos
Campos: ≈100 kmSão Paulo to São José dos Campos: ≈100 km• São José
dos Campos to Rio de Janeiro: ≈340 km
• Length of Project: ≈518 kmLength of Project: 518 km
-
Principle Airports
• Campinas: Viracopos
• São Paulo: Guarulhos and Congonhas (city)g ( y)
• Rio de Janeiro: Galeão and Santos Dumond (city)
-
Competition: Flights per Day• Over 100 return flights per day
between São Paulo and Rio
de Janeiro• TAM Airlines: 40+ return flights per day (about
2/hr)g p y ( )• Ocean Air: 10+ return flights per day (about 1/hr)•
GOL: 50+ return flights per day (about 2/hr)• Price: US$120 to
US$750 per round-trip$ $ p p
• TAV Express Ticket = US$220 per round trip (estimated)
-
BNDES – Banco Nacional do Desenvolvemento
• Estimated Price of Project• R$34.6 billion (US$19.2
billion)
C t k• Cost per km• R$66.8 million (US$37.1 million)
• BNDES Share (60%)• BNDES Share (60%)• R$20.8 billion (US$11.5
billion)
• Ridership ForecastRidership Forecast• 90,000 passengers per
day
• Total BNDES Infrastructure Budget (2010-2013)• R$274 billion
(US$164 billion)
• Percent of BNDES Infrastructure Budget12 6%• 12.6%
-
The Bigger Picture
-
The Cities
• Step
-
Metrô Rio
-
São Paulo Metrô and Commuter Rail
-
Traffic – Worst Top 20p
• Sâo Paulo and Rio both rank!
#3 São Paulo #19 Rio de Janeiro#3 São Paulo #19 Rio de
Janeiro
-
London Underground and Commuter Rail
-
Transit and Commuter Rail
• São Paulo• Pop. 19 million• 65 km metro65 km metro• 260 km
commuter
• Rio de Janeiro• Pop. 11 million• 25 km metro• 265 km
commuter
• London• Pop. 13 million
00• 400 km metro• 1000+ km commuter
-
São Paulo Metrô – Line 4
• Line 4 Via Amarela (Yellow Line)• 14 km metro• Sub-phase 1.1
opened June 2010Sub phase 1.1 opened June 2010
• Two stations (Faria Lima and Paulista)• Sub-phase 1.2 in
November 2010
• Two more stations (Pinheiros and Butanta)Two more stations
(Pinheiros and Butanta)• Sub-phase 1.3 in April 2011
• Final two stations (Luz and Republica)• Phase 2 in 2015 – Five
additional stations• Phase 2 in 2015 – Five additional stations
-
São Paulo Metrô – Line 4
São Paulo Metrô Line 4
Phase 1São Paulo -
Rio HSR
Total Cost (US$ billions) 1.3 19.2
Project Length (km) 14 518
Cost per km (US$ millions) 93 37
U d ( ti t d) 700 000 90 000Users per day (estimated) 700,000
90,000
-
Genuine Trade-offs
• São Paulo – Rio TAV• US$19.2 billion• 518 km of HSR518 km of
HSR• 90,000 riders per day• 12.6% of federal transport budget
• São Paulo Line 4 Subway• US$1.3 billion• 14 km of subway•
700,000 riders per day•
-
A Better Way?• Three Cities
• Campinas, São Paulo, São José dos Campos• Approximately 200
km• Catchment area includes approximately 22 million people
• Cost estimated at $7.4 billion• Leaves $11.8 billion for
critical transit (= 126 miles subway!)
-
Links for More Information
• http://www tavbrasil gov br (Halcrow-Sinergia Report)•
http://www.tavbrasil.gov.br (Halcrow-Sinergia Report)
• http://inter.bndes.gov.br/english/
htt // b d b /Sit BNDES/b d /b d t•
http://www.bndes.gov.br/SiteBNDES/bndes/bndes_pt
• http://www.arup.com
• [email protected]