Smart Citizens - Ethical Assessment & Artistic Interventions

Grande FestaMay 13, 2016Rio de Janeiro

#ResilientRio

Friday - Grande Festa

Time Topic / Activity

10:00 – 11:00 Recap & intervention techniques

11:00 – 13:00 Preparing public intervention

13:00 – 14:00 Lunch break

14:00 – 16:00 Public intervention

16:00 – 17:00 Final presentations

Resilient Cities Seminar• Arjen Uijterlinde, Dutch Consul-General in Rio de Janeiro, Brasil• Han Peters, Ambassador of the Kingdom of the Netherlands to Brazil• Claudia Gintersdorfer, Deputy Head of the European Union Delegation in Brasilia.• Pedro Junqueira, CEO, Center of Operations Rio de Janeiro• Frank Kresin, Research Director, Waag Society• Tina Billeter Weymann, Sustainability Consultant• Catarina Selada, Head of Cities Department, INTELI Innovation Centre• Luciana Nery, Deputy Chief Resilience Officer, Center of Operations Rio de Janeiro• Marco Contardi, Strategic Advisor, FGV Projetos• Ricardo Ruiz, Project Coordinator, InCiti Research and Innovation for Cities &

Federal University of Pernambuco• Clarisse Linke, Country Director, Institute for Transportation and Development

Policy Brasil • Mark van der Net, Founder, OSCity• Pieter van Boheemen, Programme Manager, Waag Society• Gabriela Augustini, Founder and Director, Olabi Makerspace• Chloe Dickson, Co-Founder, BeMap• Ronaldo Lemos, Founder and Director, ITS Rio• Fabio Palma, Director, Istituto Europeo di Design• Washington Fajardo, President, Rio World Heritage Institute and Mayors’ Special

Advisor for Urban Issues• Luisa Santiago, Managing Director, Ellen MacArthur Foundation

http://resilientcities.com.br/index.php/programme-info/

Smart Citizen Exhibition

• Memory• Structuring• Sharing• Improving the process• Reproducibility• Engaging• Pride / fun

Why document?

For Smart Citizens sharing is a strategy

Mediated Morality

People Technology World

Ethical frameworks

•Consequentialism

•Utilitarianism (means-end argument)

•Normative ethics

•Kantian theory (universal law)

•Virtue ethics

Classical Ethics: Ethical Matrix

• Columns: relevant principles• f.e. autonomy, justice, etc

• Rows: relevant stakeholders (max 4)• f.e. parents, neighbours, policy makers, etc

Stakeholders/actors

(human + non-human)

Consequentialistic principles

(arguments that concern the outcomes of an act)

Deontological principles

(arguments that concern the act itself)

https://www.lincoln.ac.uk/home/lifesciences/visitingscholars/professorbenmepham/

Example: Food Industry

Wellbeing Autonomy Justice

People in the industry

Income & working

conditions

Freedom of action Fair trade

Citizens Food safety & quality

Informed choices

Availability & Affordability

Farm Animals Animal welfare Behavioural freedom Intrinsic value

The environment Conservation Biodiversity Sustainability

The Triangle

• Acknowledging our duty to follow (principle(s) X) and our estimation of (the facts Y) it follows that .. is (not) morally allowed.

Based on: Daniels, Norman, "Reflective Equilibrium", The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Winter 2013 Edition), Edward N. Zalta (ed.) URL: http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/reflective-equilibrium/

Examplesof artistic interventions

AirVisual

https://airvisual.com

Physikit

http://physikit.stevenhouben.be

BrokenCityLab: air quality

http://www.brokencitylab.org/notes/diy-air-quality-balloons/

Free Tattoo

http://www.brokencitylab.org/

Thought provoking t-shirts

http://www.brokencitylab.org/

Text in the public space

http://www.brokencitylab.org/

More texts

http://www.brokencitylab.org/

Declaration

http://www.brokencitylab.org/

Air purifying plants

http://cascoland.looze.net/2015/#/projects/hoestende-heesters-en-ander-geluid/

Pull me out

http://koasas.kaist.ac.kr/bitstream/10203/24897/1/chi2009_minjung.pdf

Follow me garbage

http://koasas.kaist.ac.kr/bitstream/10203/24897/1/chi2009_minjung.pdf

Street graffiti

http://visualisingmillroad.com

Projection

http://ninavalkanova.com/2011/07/reveal-it/

Story telling

• Add a sentence to this story…

Share documentation

• [email protected]

• #ResilientRio

• http://slideshare.net/ptmvanboheemen

These slides are licensed under

CC - BY - SA 3.0