1 SMALL-SCALE STONE QUARRYING: IT’S CONTRIBUTION TO PEOPLE’S LIVELIHOODS. A CASE STUDY OF GA EAST MUNICIPAL ASSEMBLY BY John Mbah Aduku & Fred Awaah ABSTRACT Stone quarrying is an economically important and widespread activity in Ghana and has existed since historical times. However, in spite of its remarkable contribution towards economic development, some adverse impacts have been noticed, especially where extraction is carried out without proper planning and use of modern technology and scientific methods. The main objective of the study is to assess the contribution of small scale stone quarrying towards the people’s livelihoods in the Ga-East Municipality of Ghana. In all 190 respondents were contacted out of which 180 were made out of stone quarry workers and 10 stakeholders. Questionnaires administration records obtained from the communities revealed notable deteriorations in the health of the people as a result of the quarrying activities in the area. Notable among these is the prevalence of malaria though not related to dust emissions; it results from mosquitoes breeding in the stagnant pools of water found in pits created as a result of the mining activity. Other common health cases recorded were acute respiratory tract infection, ear and eye infections, cough and pneumonia. In view of this, the study recommends official recognition of small scale quarrying so as to enhance sustainable development in harvesting of a non-renewable natural resource.
21
Embed
Small Scale Quarry and Its Effects on the Livelihood of the People in Ga-East Municipality in Ghana.
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
1
SMALL-SCALE STONE QUARRYING: IT’S CONTRIBUTION TO PEOPLE’S
LIVELIHOODS. A CASE STUDY OF GA EAST MUNICIPAL ASSEMBLY
BY
John Mbah Aduku
&
Fred Awaah
ABSTRACT
Stone quarrying is an economically important and widespread activity in Ghana and has
existed since historical times. However, in spite of its remarkable contribution towards
economic development, some adverse impacts have been noticed, especially where
extraction is carried out without proper planning and use of modern technology and
scientific methods. The main objective of the study is to assess the contribution of small
scale stone quarrying towards the people’s livelihoods in the Ga-East Municipality of
Ghana. In all 190 respondents were contacted out of which 180 were made out of stone
quarry workers and 10 stakeholders. Questionnaires administration records obtained from
the communities revealed notable deteriorations in the health of the people as a result of
the quarrying activities in the area. Notable among these is the prevalence of malaria
though not related to dust emissions; it results from mosquitoes breeding in the stagnant
pools of water found in pits created as a result of the mining activity. Other common
health cases recorded were acute respiratory tract infection, ear and eye infections, cough
and pneumonia. In view of this, the study recommends official recognition of small scale
quarrying so as to enhance sustainable development in harvesting of a non-renewable
natural resource.
2
1.0 Introduction
Quarrying is the process of obtaining quarry resources, usually rocks, found on or below
the land surface (Banez, 2010). The difference between mining and quarrying is that
quarrying extracts nonmetallic rocks and aggregates while quarrying excavates the site
for metallic mineral de-posits. Some of the stones extracted are stones, lime-stone,
perlite, marble, ironstone, slate, granite, rock salt and phosphate rock. The suitability of
the stone for quarrying depends on its quality, the possibility of cheap and ready
conveyance to a large market; and its inclination and depth below the surface.
Rock quarrying and stone crushing is a global phenomenon, and has been the cause of
concern everywhere in the world, including the advanced countries. Quarrying activity is
a necessity that provides much of the materials used in traditional hard flooring, such as
granite, limestone, marble, stones, slate and even just clay to make ceramic tiles.
However, like many other man-made activities (anthropogenic factors), quarrying
activities cause significant impact on the environment (Okafor, 2006). In particular, it is
often necessary to blast rocks with explosives in order to extract material for processing
but this method of extraction gives rise to noise pollution, air pollution, damage to
biodiversity and habitat destruction.
The significant contribution of small scale stone quarry to the world production was
noted early on by quarrying engineers (Noestaller, 2009). These quarries are part of the
burgeoning informal or ‘unorganised’ sector of third world economies; however the term
‘informal’ is often used synonymously with ‘illegal’. The strong anti-quarrying
movements led by pro-environment groups have generally focused on three main areas:
3
the negative aspects of unregulated mineral extraction; not differentiating between small
scale and large-scale quarrying and overlooking the question of livelihoods of the large
numbers of people involved and their livelihoods in Small Scale Quarrying (Bhanumathi,
2004).
The official attitude is often to regulate, regularize and formalize the supply chains and
links especially in the high value mineral products such as gold and diamonds (CASM,
2005). It is well-known that Small Scale Quarry (SSQ) comprise a significant part of the
labour force in the informal income-generating activities and SSQ workers do indeed
constitute a large segment of workers in the informal mines all over the world. This study
examines this area of work and livelihoods of SSQ workers, the regional focus being
South Asia. The patriarchal social structure of South Asian societies tends to obscure the
contributions made by the SSQ workers in these mines, and the roles and livelihood
concerns of SSQ workers.
This study presents a review of the emerging issues related to livelihoods around quarries
in the Ga-East Municipality in Ghana and addresses a gap in existing knowledge in Small
Scale Quarrying and on gender roles in the informal mines. It is part of a wider,
exploratory and ongoing research based on the case study method by several partners and
myself in selected locations. Although a large number of lives depend on the incomes
generated from small-scale quarry extraction, and community members perform a range
of productive or income-generating activities around these mines including those at
home, this study focuses only on the contribution small scale quarry impacts on the
livelihood of SSQ workers working in Small Scale Quarrying business.
4
In the Greater Accra Region of Ghana in particular where the land mass is already over-
populated, commercial gravel extraction to supply aggregates to the construction industry
has been on the increase in recent years. This has to a large extent contributed to land
degradation and desertification through the destruction of economically important trees,
mostly indigenous in nature. This practice leaves behind bare soil and a large expanse of
gullies which can collect water during rainy seasons. This can result not only in health–
related problems for neighbourhood communities, but can cause negative impacts on the
environment as well (Warhurst, 2009, 2012).
The Ga East Municipal Assembly is located at the northern part of Greater Accra Region.
The Administrative capital of the District is Abokobi. The municipality forms part of
sixteen (16) Metropolis, municipalities and Districts in the Greater Accra Region. The
Municipality shares boundaries with Akuapim South Municipal to the North, Ga East
Municipal to the West, Adentan Municipal to the South and La-Nkwantanang-Madina to
the East.
This is due to the enabling factors for development coupled with the infrastructural set-up
and the municipality’s proximity to the nation’s capital, Accra. Most people in the
municipality engage in four main economic activities including commerce, agriculture,
service provision and industry.
Nonetheless, gravel sites from the study area are a particularly attractive source of
aggregates as they are relatively well sorted, easily accessible and cheap to extract (Sear
& Archer, 2008). This has potentially adverse impacts on the natural environment,
5
society and cultural heritage, the health and safety of mine workers, and communities
based in close proximity to operations (Moody & Panos, 2007) and dislocation (Akabzaa,
2000). While the people in general are familiar with the need and importance of stone and
gravel quarrying for construction material, the awareness of the negative impact this has
on the environment, biodiversity and food security may not be as commonly known.
Again, like many other man-made activities, quarrying involves the production of
significant amounts of waste. Some types of quarries do not produce large amounts of
permanent waste, such as stone and gravel quarries, whereas others will produce
significant amounts of waste material such as clay and silt (Wang, 2007).
The good news is that they are generally inert and non-hazardous, unlike the waste from
many other processes. However, there is still potential for damage to the environment
particularly with water contamination. Plants are major components of the ecosystem – a
complex interaction between the biotic and abiotic entities of the environment. The
industry, unfortunately discharge dust that settles not only on land, plants and trees but
also on surface waters used for drinking and other domestic chores by the community
(Osha, 2006).
The green plants especially, by virtue of their photosynthetic activities occupy an
important position in the existence of life because of their ability to maintain a balance in
the volume of Oxygen and Carbon dioxide which leads to the purification of the
environment. They supply man with food, drugs, fibres, fuel, building and other raw
materials and serve as ornamentals. The plants, by their activities, influence and
determine to a large extent, the type of fauna to be expected and any change or tilt in their
6
composition either vegetation, affects the animal life in terms of food, shelter, security
and comfort. Such vegetation changes are the main concern of environmental botanists
and ecologists in recent years who have advocated the careful and cautious approach to
activities promoting such changes (Wang, 2011).
Air pollution generally and especially dust from quarry sites are known to be responsible
for vegetation injury and crop yield loss and thus become a threat to the survival of plants
in industrial areas (Iqbal & Shafig, 2011). Such dusts reduce plant cover, height and
number of leaves. Apart from the dust emitted, toxic compounds such as fluoride,
Magnesium, Lead, Zinc, Copper, Beryllium, Sulphuric acid and Hydrochloric acid are
injurious to the vegetation.
1.2 Problem Statement
Most studies Aboagye (2006), Midamba and Ekechi (2005) show the prevalence of the
informal sector in urban areas. Odongo (2011) acknowledges the significance of the
sector in Ghana which supports close to 800,000 enterprises; and provides employment to
an estimated population of 1.5 million people, which amounts to about ninety percent of
the non-farm workers. However in spite of the high underemployment and
unemployment rates in the rural areas where most of the youth are found, most studies
relating to the informal sector have been carried out in the urban areas (MLSW, 2011).
Recent studies by Bryceson (2011, 2012), Ellis (2008, 2010), Gordon and Craig (2011)
among others have shown that rural economies are not only based on agriculture.
Evidence from this documented information shows the need to acknowledge non-farm
7
activities as a source livelihood to rural households. This is especially relevant to Ghana,
where close to 88 percent of the population is rural based and depends on agriculture as
the main source of income (Adjei, 2011).
While quarries can cause significant impact to the environment, with the right planning
and management, many of the negative effects can be minimized or controlled and in
many cases, there is great opportunity to protect and enhance the environment, such as
with the translocation of existing habitats or the creation of new ones. Therefore to
achieve the equilibrium between natural ecosystems, project planning, formulation and
implementation is needed.
In spite of the dangers of the dust emission resulting from limestone quarrying, there has
not been any study on the effects of this activity on the environment and the health of the
people living in this community. The objectives of this study are therefore to assess the
contribution of Small Scale Quarrying activities towards the livelihood of the people of
Ga East Municipality. It is hoped that the results of this study will not only help
environmental scientists but also politicians in policy formulation.
1.3 Objectives of the Study
The main objective of the study is to assess the contribution of small scale stone
quarrying towards the people’s livelihoods in the Ga-East Municipality of Ghana.
However the study seeks to achieve the following specific objectives:
1. Find out why people engage in small scale stone quarrying in the Ga-East
Municipality.
8
2. Identifying the constraints associated with small scale stone quarrying in relation
to the vulnerability context.
3. Assessing the effects of processes, institutions and policies on small scale
quarrying in Ga-East Municipality.
4. Exploring the outcomes of small scale stone quarrying activities in Ga East
Municipality.
1.4 Research Questions
1. Who are involved in stone quarrying and why are they engaged in small scale
stone quarrying, particularly Ga-East Municipality?
2. What constraints limit small scale stone quarrying and what coping strategies do
the workers use?
3. Do laws, policies or institutions hinder or enhance stone quarrying?
4. How have culture and gender roles affected quarrying activities and consequently
livelihood outcomes of the stone workers?
5. What livelihood outcomes have the workers attained from engaging in stone
quarrying the in Ga-East Municipality?
1.5 Significance of the Study
The result of this study will therefore help to identify contribution small scale stone
quarrying to people’s livelihoods in the Ga-East Municipality and the effects of quarry
activities on the livelihood of stone quarry worker and recommend alternative solutions
that will help improve small scale quarry business in Ghana.
9
The study will also be of immense contribution, to knowledge and will provide a
background for further studies in assessing the extent to which contribution small scale
stone quarrying has affected people’s livelihoods in the Ga-East Municipality and to the
Ghanaian economy as a whole.
On the general level, such an investigation has implications for developing country
governments and policy makers who are trying to establish effective strategies to assist
the stone quarry sector of their economy and for academics interested in understanding
the relevance of stone quarry extraction as a means of increasing market value of quarry
sector in developing economies such as Ghana.
2.0 Methodology
The researcher adopted descriptive survey design and a case study in the mentioned
locality. Descriptive research method is an approach to research to systematically
investigate people, group or pattern of behaviours. The main purpose of using descriptive
research method is to obtain first hand data from respondents. Also, due to the flexibility
of this method it can use either qualitative or quantitative data or both, hence it was
considered for this study. A case study method is an approach to studying a social
phenomenon through a thorough analysis of an individual case. This study broadly
examines the contributions of Small Scale Quarrying activities towards the livelihood of
the people in the Ga East Municipality, and hence the choosing of the case study
approach.
Two hundred (200) residents in Ga East Municipality were selected for this study. This
large number respondent represents the sample size. The large sample size helped in
10
minimizing sampling error and the results represents the true views of the entire
population. The study used the non probability sampling technique, that is, the quota
sampling and the purposive sampling method was used to choose respondents on random
basis as they have similar characteristics.
The completed questions were collected, checked and properly edited before data entry
was carried out. The data was analyzed with Statistical Package for Social Scientist
(SPSS). Descriptive statistics such percentages and frequencies were used to represent the
data in the form of tables.
3.0 Results and Discussion
This section deals with the presentation and discussion of the results as provided by the
respondents. Two hundred (200) respondents were targeted but only one hundred and
ninety 190 responded representing 95% of the respondents.
Table 4.1: Socio-demographic Characteristics of Respondents
Respondents Age in Years No of Respondents Percentage
Under 20 5 2.63
20 - 30 40 21.05
31 - 40 125 65.79
41 - 50 10 5.26
51 and above 10 5.26
Education
Primary 120 63.16
JHS 21 11.05
SHS/voc/technical 5 2.63
No education 44 23.16
Marital Status
Single 15 7.89
Married 40 21.05
Divorced 25 13.16
Widower 72 37.89
Separated 38 20.00
Family Size
1-3 12 6.32
11
4-6 81 42.63
7-9 65 34.21
10 and above 32 16.84
Sex
Female 150 78.95
Male 40 21.05
Column Totals 190 100
Source: Field Survey 2014
The study reveals that out of 190 residents interviewed 150 were males representing
78.95% of the respondents, and the remaining 40 were females representing 21.05%. As
can be seen from the table majority of the respondents are in the age range of 31-40 years
representing 65.79% of the respondents. This agrees with the results obtained in the 2000
national population and housing census, indicating that the communities are
economically less developed. Only 2.63% of the respondents are below 20 years. Also
the high number of people ranging between ages 20-30 must be as result of the influx of
the stone wining activities. The 5.26% of elderly signifies low life expectancy.
The study also revealed that, 21.05% of the respondents are married with only 7.89%
who are single. The table also shows that 13.16% of the respondents are divorced and
37.89% are widows or widowers. The remaining 20% of the respondents are separated. It
can therefore be inferred that majority of the respondents are married with the minority
either being widows or widowers. This may be as result of the nature of the quarry
activities in the community. It can be deduced that majority of the respondents have a
family size ranging from 4-6 which forms 42.63% of the participants.
12
The table shows that majority of people questioned had formal education but with
different levels of educational backgrounds. It is clear from the table that out of the 190
residents interviewed 120 people, representing 63.16% had primary education with
11.05% and 2.63% attending JHS and Secondary/Vocational/Technical/Commercial
School respectively. Almost 23.16% respondents have not had formal education. The
high proportion of respondents with primary level of educational background might be
due to poverty.
3.1 Reason why People Engage in Stone Quarrying Activities in the Ga East
To understand the underlying causes why people take part in stone quarrying activities as
a livelihood the study sought to explore the people’s knowledge about the business. The
result is presented in the table below.
Table 3.2: Respondents Knowledge on Stone Quarrying
S/N Response Frequency Percentage
1 Yes 188 99
2 No 2 1
Column Total 190 100
Source: Field Survey 2014
It was discovered that nearly all (99%) participants claim they are fully aware of stone
quarrying activities in the area. From the table it can be concluded that respondents are
fully aware of stone quarrying activities in their communities.
Table 3.3: Perceived intensity of the stone quarrying activities
S/N Response Frequency Percentage
1 High 126 66.31
2 Moderate 49 25.78
13
3 Low 15 7.89
Column Total 190 100
Source: Field Survey 2014
The perception of the respondents as presented in the table shows that stone quarrying
activities are highly intensive. About 66.31% acknowledged that, stone quarrying
activities are intensive, with 25.78% and 7.89% of the respondents saying that the
activities are moderate and low respectively. This agrees with the statement that, stone
quarrying is very lucrative. This may largely account for its intensity. Despite the
devastating nature of stone quarrying which the respondents complained of, it is severe
because people care less about their environment.
Table 3.4: Main factors contributing to stone quarrying
S/N Duration Frequency Percentage
1 Lucrative 156 82.10
2 Land not Fertile 10 5.26
3 Increase in Estates 22 11.58
development
4 Poor Weather Pattern 2 1.05
Column Total 190 100
Source: Field Survey 2014
The study reveals that there is ready market for stone and the business is highly lucrative
as well. Increase in estate development had a significant influence on the rate of stone
quarrying. This shows that the ready market for stone work together with its lucrative
nature as the main contributing factors for stone quarrying in Ga East Municipalities.
14
Table 3.5: Effects of Stone quarrying on the livelihood of the people
S/N Factors Frequency Percentage
1 Stone quarrying will lead to
hunger
134 70.52
hunger
2 Renders farmers jobless 33 17.36
3 Results in poverty among
residents
21 11.05
4 Increase in cost of living 1 0.52
Residents
5 Lead to diseases 2 1.05
Column Total 190 100
Source: Field Survey 2014
The table displays the various effects of stone quarrying on the livelihoods of residents. It
reveals that majority of respondents representing 70.52% believe stone quarrying will
lead to hunger .17.36% of participants complained that it results in rural urban drift with
most people responding that it renders farmers jobless. Some of the communities claimed
there were no farmlands at all and farmers had to depend on other neighboring
communities for farmlands. 11.05% of participants said it results in poverty among
residents. Only 1.05% of the respondents said it may also lead to increase in food prices,
malaria and respiratory diseases.
Table 3.6: Effects of Stone quarrying on the Environment
S/N Effects Frequency Percentage
1 Air Pollution 127 66.84
2 Noise 10 5.26
3 Create Pits 41 21.57
4 Make soil not fertile l2 6.35
Column Total 190 100
Source: Field Survey 2014
15
The pits dug during stone quarrying may serve as breeding place for mosquitoes and dust
from stone may result in the above disease respectively. Almost 0.52% stressed that the
activity will bring about increase in cost of living. This point buttresses the issue of
hunger raised by majority of respondents. Despite all the negative and positive effects
raised it can be concluded that stone quarrying could in the long term lead to food
insecurity.
The table below shows the effects stone quarrying has on the environment according to
the respondents. Majority of the respondents representing 66.84% complained that air
pollution is the main environmental defect that comes out of stone quarrying. Almost
5.26% said noise, whiles 21.57% of the participants said it create pits as an effect of stone
quarrying has on the environment.
Table 3.7: Effects of Stone quarrying on farm and food production
S/N Effects Frequency Percentage
1 Food shortage 143 75.27
2 Loses of soil fertility 17 8.94
3 Increase in food prices 28 14.74
4 Reduction in food production 2 1.05
Column Total 190 100
Source: Field Survey 2014
The table reveals that 75.27% of the respondents claim that stone quarrying leads to food
shortage. 8.94% of the group relates the issue as the cause of loses of soil fertility with
about 18.74% saying that the act may result in the reduction on availability of fertile land
for farming. About 27 % also said that the stone quarrying will ultimately lead to an
increase in food price.
16
4.4 Regulatory Bodies for Stone Quarrying
Table 3.8: Existence of regulatory bodies to regulate the activities of stone winners
S/N Respose Frequency Percentage
1 Yes 56 29.47
2 No 134 70.53
Column Total 190 100
Source: Field Survey 2014
The table above shows that over 60 percent of the respondents are not aware of any
regulatory body controlling stone quarrying activities in the Ga East while 35.9 percent
claim they are aware of such bodies.
Table 3.9: Stone quarrying regulatory bodies in the study area
S/N Regulatory Bodies Frequency Percentage
1 Police 121 63.69
2 EPA 33 17.37
3 Mineral Commission 2 1.05
4 Municipal Assembly 34 17.89
Column Total 190 100
Source: Field Survey 2014
The table reveals that 63.69% of respondents are of the view that the police are the main
regulatory body with 17.37% and 10.5% of the respondents are of the view that, the EPA
and the Minerals commission are responsible. Whiles 17.89% said the municipal
assembly is responsible. The police happen to be the main regulatory body because they