THE EFFECT OF NUMBERED HEADS TOGETHER TECHNIQUE ON
READING COMPREHENSION ACHIEVEMENT OF THE EIGHTH GRADE
STUDENTS AT SMP NEGERI 1 PANCUR BATUA THESISSubmitted in Partial
Fulfillment of Requirement for the for the Degree of English
Education
BY:
INDAH PERTIWI
REG NO: 143306021018
English Department
Faculty of Teaching and Education
University of Prima Indonesia
Medan
2015CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION
1.1. The Background of the Study
English is an International language which is used by people in
the world as a means of communication .It is widely used by most
countries for international trades, science, economy, diplomacy,
and tourism. It means that English is very important for every side
of this life. Because of the importance of this language, so that
it has to be learned by the people who are not familiar with the
language, especially for countries which have determined English as
the first foreign language.There are four language skills in
learning English namely listening, speaking, reading, and writing.
Reading is one of the most important skill of those .Reading is an
essential skill for all students at all level. The students are
required to be able to read and understand the content of the next
level. Arthur (2013:5) states that reading is an active and ongoing
process that is affected directly by an individuals interaction
with his environment. Grabe and Stoller (2002:9) state reading is
the ability to draw meaning from the printed page and interpret
this information appropriately.Reading is not just saying the words
. Reading must always be a meaning getting process, so that people
faced some difficulties when they want to get information through
reading. Similarly, when the students also fond some difficulties
while reading the text. For example, students get some difficulties
in drawing the meaning, finding the main ideas and interpret the
information of the text. They couldnt grasp the ideas and answer
the question on the text. It means they cant comprehend the text.
Reading Comprehension is one of the skills that must be mastered by
students, the fact show that teaching reading comprehension is not
an essay task, because the teacher must face learning reading
comprehension. In teaching reading, student can not comprehend
English text well, because student do not have good motivation to
read and they should comprehend every word of text, so they keep on
looking up to the words in a dictionary to find out a meaning of
the text. Since comprehending text is not essay, expert, such as
Will and Grabe recommend ways of Improving the reader s skill to
comprehend the text as well as speed up reading process. They state
in reading comprehension ,students are able to comprehend and
understand about the context that has explained in the text. It
means that students need to learn a considerable amount of
information from text. Therefore, students require abilities to
comprehend and remember main ideas as well as number of details
that elaborate the main and supporting ideas in text. They also
need to link the text to their knowledge base.Harmer (2003:208)
states the student have low expectation of reading. Reading passage
is bound to be difficult for them and they predict that the whole
experience will be frustrating and de-motivating. Such attitude
often due to unsuccessful in reading. Educational unit Curiculum
(KTSP: Kurikulum Tingkat Satuan Pendidikan) about standard in
reading states the students must be able to comprehend the meaning
of the text in form of recount ,narrative, procedure, descriptive,
and report in the context of daily life. It can be concluded that
is very important for students to master reading comprehension in
order to enable them to get success in learning process.
Based on the writers experience in PPL (Teacher Training
Practice),it was difficult for the students to comprehend English
texts. When she/he told them to tell some information from their
reading text, most of them did not have any ideas or opinions to
clarify the information in the reading text .It proved that they
were not interested in learning reading comprehension and the
process of teaching reading did not run well. This situation
happened because the teaching method or technique which was not
suitable. Usually, teacher teaches reading comprehension by
translating the reading text. Therefore, the students open the
dictionary when they want to understand the text and most of them
had difficulties in searching the meaning of the text. They could
not grasp the main idea and answer question based on the text and
even they got bored. In this case, the teacher should make
variations and choose a suitable technique in teaching reading
comprehension in order to make students interested. At this time,
there has already been implemented Learning Revolution in teaching
and learning that is learning is no longer centered on teachers. So
the teacher is only as a facilitator and a provider of solutions in
learning is no longer only as a source of knowledge in learning
process. Considering the condition above ,we need to provide a
structure for helping students learn reading comprehension skill.
One of appropriate and comprehensive methods for teaching reading
is Numbered Heads Together (NHT) technique. Numbered Heads Together
(NHT) technique is an excellent structure for combining learning
partnership into groups or teams of four (Kagan,1989,12). It can be
used early in the development of the co-operative and Think, Pair,
Share offers a high degree of engagement but slightly higher order
interpersonal and small group skills are needed .Through Numbered
Head Together (NHT) technique, the students are expected to be
enthusiastic to learn writing activity and they can explore their
idea, feeling and thought in their group.
Based on the background above, the writer is interested in
conducting a research entitledThe Effect Of Applying Numbered Heads
Together on Students Reading Comprehension in Descriptive text.
1.2. The Problem of the StudyIn related to the background of the
study, the problem of the study is formulated as follows:Does the
Numbered Heads Together (NHT) technique significantly affect the
students reading comprehension?
1.3. The Objective of the Study.
The objective of the study is to find out the effect of NHT
(Numbered Heads Together) on students reading comprehension.1.4.
The Scope of The StudyThe study focuses on student reading
comprehension on descriptive text. There are four level of
comprehension namely; Literal, Inferential, Critical, and Creative
Reading. Concerning with that, the scope of this study is limited
in inferential level because most of students of junior and high
school find difficulties in doing reading comprehension in level.
In this study, the writer focuses on NHT (Numbered Head
Together)technique in order to make students reading comprehension
better.1.5.The Significance of the StudyThere are some
significances of this study which are expected the readers to be
useful for:1 .The English teacher to improve students reading
comprehension through NHT technique,2 .The students ,to encourage
them to be more active and highly motivated students ,especially to
work in groups, 3 . Other researchers who are interested in doing
the related study, enlarging their knowledge, and understanding
about reading comprehension strategies.
To give further information to those who interested in learning
and teaching English.CHAPTER II
REVIEW OF LITRATURE
2.1 The Theoretical Framework
In conducting a research ,theories are needed to explain some
concepts applied in the research concerned. The term have to be
made clear to avoid misunderstanding .The following terms are used
on some basic theories in relation to the study.2.1.1. Reading
a. Defenition of Reading
Generally, reading can be taugth as a way to draw information
from a text and to form an interpretation. Reading was one of the
basic communicative skills but it was a very complex process. It
was difficult arrive at a precise definition of the reading
process. According to Deborah Daik and Nancy Anter (2013:5) state
reading is an active process that depends on both an authors
ability to convey meaning using words and your ability to create
meaning from them.In additional, As Grabe and Stoller (2002: 9)
state that reading is ability to draw meaning from the printed page
and interpret this information appropriately. It means that when a
reader ineracts with printed pages, their perior knowledge combine
with the visual or written information result in his comprehending
the massage.
By looking the explanation above, it can be conclude that
reading comprehension is an active cognitive process of interacting
between a reader and text which monitoring interpretation or
understanding to establish meaning from the text.
2.2.1. The Purposes of Reading
The reader should be able to get the points out as well as to
get the points out as well as the meaning and information from the
text their read. When the students can get comprehension from the
text, they understand the massage of the text. Willan and Frederica
(1988:13)
1) Reading to search for simple information and reading to
skim
Reading to search simple information is a common reading reading
ability; through some researchers see it as relatively independent
cognitive process. It is used so often in reading tasks that it is
probably best seen as type of reading ability. In reading to
search, we typically scan the text for a specific piece of
information or a specific word. Similarly, Reading to skim is a
common part of e reading tasks and a useful tasks and a useful in
its own right. It involves, in essence, a combination of strategies
for guessing where important information might be in the text, and
then using basic reading comprehension skills on those segments of
the text until a general idea is formed.
2) Reading to learn from text
Reading to learn typically occurs in academic and professional
in which a person needs to learn a considerable amount of
information from a text. It requires abilities to:
a) Remember main ideas as well as a number of details that
elaborate the main and supporting ideas in that text.b) Recognize
and build rhetorical frames that organize the information in the
text.c) Link the text to the readers knowledge base.3) Reading to
integrate information, write and critique texts
Reading to integrate information require additional decisions
about the relative importance of complementary, mutually supporting
or conflicting information and the likely restructuring of
rhetorical frame to acomodate information from multiple sources.
Both reading to write and reading to critique texts may be task
variants of reading to integrate information. Both require
abilities to compose, select, and critique information from a
text.
4) Reading for general comprehension
Reading for general comprehension is the most basic purpose of
reading, underlying and supporting most other purpose for reading.
General reading for comprehension, when accomplished by a skilled
fluent reader, requires very rapid and automatic processing of
words, strong skill in forming a general meaning representation of
main ideas, and efficient coordination of many processes under very
limited time constraints.2.2.2. Kinds of Reading
1) Extensive Reading materials
one of the fundamental conditions of a successful extensive
reading program is that students should be reading material which
they can understand .if they are struggling to understand every
word they can hardly reading for pleasure .This mean that we need
to provide books which either by chance because they have been
specially written are readily accessible to our students. Specially
written material for extensive reading what Rhicard Day and Julian
Bamford call language learner literature (1998:61)- are often
referred to as readers or simplified readers. they can take the
form of original fiction and non fiction books as well as
simplifications of esthabilished work of literature .
2) Setting up a library
in order to set up an extensive reading program , we need to
build up a librarysuitable books. Although this may appear costly
.t will be money well spent. If necessary, we should persuade our
schools and institution to provide such funds ,or raise money
through other sources. we need to devise some way of keeping track
of the books in the library a simple signing out system should
ensure that our collection does not disappear overtime .All this
setting up procedures take time .but we can use students to help us
administer the scheme .If our students take part in extensive
reading program, all the time we have spent on setting up a library
will not have been wasted .
3) The role of the teacher in extensive reading program
Most students will not do a lot of extensive reading by
themselves unless they are encouraged to do so by their teachers .
Clearly then our role is crucial . we need to promote reading and b
our own espousal in reading as a valid occupation ,persuade
students of its benefits .Having persuaded our students about the
benefits off extensive reading ,we can organize reading program
where we indicates to students how many books we expect them to
read over a given period. We can explain how they can make their
choice of what to read , making it clear that the choice is theirs
. but that they can consults other students reviews and comments to
help them make that choice.
4) Extensive reading task
One approach is to set aside a time at various points in a
course say every two weeks at which students can ask question and
tell their classmates about books they have found particularly
enjoyable ,or noticeably awful. However ,if this is in appropriate
because not all students read the same speed or because they often
d not have much to say about the book in front of their collegues
we can asked them to keep a weekly reading diary either on its own
,or as part of any learning journal maybe in writing.
2.3 Reading Comprehension
a) Defenition of Reading Comprehension
Reading without meaning is an unsatisfying and inconsequential
exercise. One who is reading is suppose to be able drive meaning
from what is read. Being able to derive meaning from a text means
comprehending the text. Therefore, the goal of reading should be
aimed toward comprehension.
The primary purpose of reading comprehension is to extract
meaning from text indeed. As Rubin (2000 p.171) correctly states,
reading comprehension is a complex intellectual process involving a
number of abilities. Furthermore proficient reader with efficient
word identification skills ,a rich vocabulary and good background
knowledge. According to Lubliner and Smetana (2005) ,students with
good vocabularies find reading easier ,read more widely and do
better in school, while children who enter school with limited
vocabulary find reading difficult ,resist reading, learn fewer
words and consequently fall further behind. So in this situation
there is a need to devote more time to word study and vocabulary
building when comprehension activities are used in the classroom.
There is also need to preteach difficult vocabulary to such
children before a textbook Is read.Furthermore reading
comprehension skill can be increased when teachers spent time
Modelling and demonstrating effective strategies for processing
text (Westwood,2003a), such as:
strategies must encompass
a. Previewing material before it is read to gain an overview
b. locating main idea in a passage
c. Thingking aloud and generating questions about the
material
d. predicting what may happen or suggesting possible causes and
effects
e. summarising or pharaprasing main ideas.
Whereas dialogue also serves a diagnostic purpose by allowing
the teacher o appraise students existing strategies for
comprehending (westwood,2003a)
2.3.1. Levels of Reading Comprehension
There are three levels of comprehension are identified. In a an
errort to discipline our thinking regarding the process of
comprehension, a long listing of skills is not given. Only those
ability at the core of understanding and reacting to information at
different levels of thinking are presented.
2.3.1.1. Literal Comprehension
Understanding the ideas and information explicity stated in the
passage. Literal comprehension focuses on ideas and information
explicitly stated in the selection
Abilities:
Knowledge of word meanings.
Recall of details directly stated or paraphrased in own
words.
Understanding of grammatical clues-subject, verb, pronouns,
conjunctions, and so forth.
Recall of main idea explicity stated.
Knowledge of sequence of information presented in passage.
2.3.1.2. Interpretative Comprehension
Understanding of ideas and information not explicitly stated in
the passage.Abilities:
Reason with information presented to understand the authors
tone, purpose, nd attitude.
Infer factual information, main ideas, comparisons, cause-effect
relationships not explicity stated in the passege.
Summarition of story content.
2.3.1.3.Critical Comprehension
Analyzing, evaluating, and personally reacting to information
presented in a passage.
Abilities:
Personally reacting to information in a passage indicating its
meaning to the reader.
Analyzing and evaluating the quality of written information in
terms of some standards.
2.3.1.4.Creative Reading Comprehension
Creative reading involves going beyond the materials presented
by the author. It requires readers to think as they read ,just as
critical reading does and it also requires them to use their
imagination. Teacher must carefully nurture creative reading
,trying not to as only question that have absolutely answer ,since
this these will tend not to encourage the diverse processes
characteristic of creative reading.
Creative readers may able to see how a story could be improved
in order to make it more interesting. Genre
Genre is a text type which function as a frame of reference
(Pardiyono, 2007:2), a text should be based on the genre, so the
text can arrange effective, effective in the purpose, diction and
arrangement of the element of the text and the using of grammar.
Based on this fact, it can be difficult to ignore how many kinds of
genre certainly.
(Pardiyono, 2007:2), states that genre is divided into nine
types. They are;
1. Narrative
Narrative is the most famous type of any text. Various purposes
are
communicated in a narrative type.
Generic structure
a. Orientation : sets the scene and introduces the
participants
b. Evaluation : a stepping back to evaluate the plight
c. Complication : what happens with the participants
d. Resolution: this is the phase where the participant solve the
problem aroused by the conflict.
e. Re- orientation : optimal
Significant Lexicon grammatical features
a. Focus on specific and usually individualized participants
b. Using past tense
c. Using action verb
d. Chronologically arranged
2. Recount
The purpose of recount text is to retell something that happened
in the past and to tell a series of past event.
Generic structure:
a. Orientation : provides the setting and introduces
participants
b. Event : tell what happened, in what sequence
c. Re-orientation : optimal- closure of events
Significant Lexicon grammatical features
a. Using past tense
b. Using action verb
c. Using adjectives
3. Descriptive
A descriptive text is a text which lists the characteristics of
something.
Generic structure
a. Identification: in identification paragraph, descriptive text
will explore to answer the question of who, what, when and
where.
b. Description : to answer how it looks, where it is sees, what
it does and what it make it special.
Significant Lexicon grammatical features
a. Using simple present tense
b. Using action verb
c. Using passive voices
d. Using adverbial phrase
e. Using conjunction of time and cause-effect
4. Report
The purpose of report text is to present information about
something, as it is.
Generic structure
a. General classification : tells what the phenomenon under
discussion is
b. Description: tell what the phenomenon under discussion is
like in term of parts, qualities, habits or behaviors.
Significant Lexicon grammatical features
a. Introducing group or general aspect
b. Using conditional logical connection
c. Using simple present tense
5. Explanation
The purpose of explanation text is to explain the process
involved in the formation or working of natural or socio-cultural
phenomena.
Generic structure
a. General statement
b. Explanation
c. Closing
Significant Lexicon grammatical features
a. Using simple present tense
b. Using action verbs
c. Using passive voice
d. Using noun phrase
e. Using general and abstract noun
f. Using conjunction of time and cause-effect6. Discussion
The purpose of discussion is to present information and opinion
about issues in more one side of an issue.
Generic structure
a. Issue
b. Arguments for and against
c. Conclusion
Significant Lexicon grammatical features
a. Using simple present tense
b. Use of relating verb/to be
c. Using thinking verb
d. Using general and abstract noun
e. Using conjunction/ transition
7. Hortatory exposition
A hortatory exposition is a type of spoken or written text that
is intended to explain the listeners or readers that something
should or should not happen or be done.
Generic structure
a. Thesis : statement or announcement of issue concern
b. Arguments: reasons for concern that will lead to
recommendation
c. Recommendation : statement of what ought not to happen
Significant Lexicon grammatical features
a. Focuses on generic human and non human participants
b. Use of mental processes, material processes, relational
processes
8. Anecdote
Anecdote text is a funny ridiculous story.
Generic structure
a. Abstract : signals the retelling of an unusual incident
b. Orientation : sets the scene
c. Crisis : provides details of the unusual incident
d. Reaction : reaction to crisis
e. Coda : reflection on or evaluation of the incident
Significant Lexicon grammatical features
a. Using exclamations, rhetorical question or intensifier
b. Using material process
c. Using temporal conjunction
9. Procedure
Procedure is a text that show a process in order. Its social
function is to describe how something is completely done through a
sequence of series.
Generic structure
a. Goal: showing the purpose
b. Material : telling the needed materials
c. Step 1-end : describing the steps to achieve the
purposeSignificant Lexicon grammatical features a. Using temporal
conjunction
b. Using action verb
c. Using imperative sentence
d. Using simple present tenseDescriptive Text
According to Saggam (2007:89), description is a written English
text in which the writer describes on object. In this text, the
object can be a concrete or abstract. It can be a person ,or animal
or a thing. Descriptive text contains two components:
Identification and Description.Description is a kind of writing
that tries to put a picture in the readers mind. It tells how
something looks or sound, or tastes. This concept has same meaning
with Pradiyonos (2006,165) concept about description presented
before. Descriptive always has primary purpose, either to present
an accurate description of something real or a picture that reveals
the authors feeling or beliefs Scott foresman (1997). A good way of
descriptive paragraph is to start with definition, which is the
description object.There are 4 types of description
Carroll(2001,97): (1) person, place or things, contain sensory
details that bring to life actual people, places, or things;(2)
Observation ,describe an event the writer has witnessed;(3) travel
brochures, contain factual information as well as persuasive
language to encourage tourism, and(4) character sketches, describe
fiction character, their appereances, personalities,hopes,and
dream.Identification is to identify the object. Description
describes parts, qualities, and characteristics of the parts of the
object.In teaching descriptive text ,we can concern with sentences
using simple present tense or past tense ,adjective to show the
quality, and linking verb following is generic structure of
descriptive paragraph: (1) identification ; show the definition of
the object being described, and (2) Description ; contains the real
object ,such as quality ,quantity, etc, related to the
object.Example of Descriptive TextExample of Descriptive Text: The
City of Rome
Example of Descriptive Text City of Rome
Italy has some famous cities. One of them is Rome. It is a very
historical city. If you visit Rome, you will have plenty of chances
to see all sorts of great sights.Rome can be traced through its
mythology when it was founded on . It was said that twins of
Romulus and Remus has founded the city in 753 BC, on the date of
April 21st. This corresponds fairly closely to archeological
evidence, which shows farming communities in the area. As the
Catholic Church grew, Rome became more and more important in both
religion and politics.Rome was one of the central leading cities in
the Renaissance. It is seen when visitors walk through the streets
and see the various buildings. The style was profoundly affected by
the work of the artists of the time. Visitors can see evidence of
all sorts of artistic influences, such as the Baroque palaces, the
huge squares and obelisks, and other structures throughout the
city.Rome is well known for its architecture. The colosseum is one
sample of famous Roman structures. It was once a grand,
ground-breaking amphitheatre, and was at the forefront of
architectural advancements in 70 AD. Since then it has fallen apart
slightly, but it still an astounding and imposing structure.Modern
Rome is a very busy place to go. It is considered a cultural center
for the region, and offers all the arts in various forms. It has a
thriving music scene, with several major concert halls. Rome puts
out a lot of movies every year, more so than any other region of
Italy. It is home to Cinecitt studios, the biggest facility in
Europe.
Note on Generic Structure of Descriptive TextGeneric
StructureDetails
IdentificationThe text above is clearly about a specific place,
Rome, an ancient City from Italy.
DescriptionFirst part which is described is Rome historical
background. It was founded in 753 BC. Second description is about
Romes role in Renaissance age. Then it is described through it
famous architectural buildings. The last part is about its role in
modern age.
http://freeenglishcourse.info/example-descriptive-text-city-of-rome/Method
of Language Teaching
a. Approach Approach refers to theories about the nature of
language and language learning that serve as the source of
practices and principle in language teaching ( Rhicards and Rodgers
1986:16). An approach describe how language is used and how its
constituent parts interlock in other words it offers a model of
language competence .An approach describes how people acquire their
knowledge of the language and make statements about the conditions
which will promote successful language learning.
b. Method
According to Harmer (2003: 78) A method is the practical
realization of an approach. The originators of a method have
arrived at decisions about types of activities , role of teachers
and learners , the kind of material which will be helpful and some
model of syllabus organization.
and some model of syllabus organization .Method include various
procedures and technique as part of their standard fare. When
method have fixed procedure ,informed by a clearly articulated
approach ,they are easy to describe .
c. Procedure: A procedure is an ordered sequences of techniques.
For example , a popular dedication procedure starts when students
are put In small groups. A procedure is a sequence which can be
described in terms such as first you do this, then you do that.
d. Technique
A common technique when using video material is called silent
viewing .This is where the teacher plays the video with no sound.
Silent viewing is a single activity rather then a sequence and as
such is a technique rather than a whole procedure . Likewise the
finger technique is used by some teachers who hold up their hands
and give each of their five fingers a word , e.q he is not playing
tennis and then by bringing and the is and the not fingers
together, show how the verb is contracted isnt.
e. strategy
Strategies are those specific attacks that we make on a given
problem and that vary considerably within each individual. They are
the moment by moment technigue that we employ to solve problems
posed by second language input and output . Chamot (2005:112)
defines strategies quite broadly as procedure that facilitate a
learning task . Strategies are most often conscious and goal
driven. The field of second language acquisition has distinguished
between two types strategy :learning strategies and communication
strategies . the former relate to input to processing , storage
,and retrieval, that is ,to take in messages from others. The
latter pertain to output, how we productively express meaning , how
we deliver messages to others. We will examine both types
strategy.
Cooperative LearningCooperative learning can be as a simple as
two students pairing up to discuss a piece of learning. It can also
be complex and can include team development activities ,cooperative
classroom atmosphere through class building activities ,special
training in social roles and social skills, specialized tasks for
teams, and special scoring ,recognition and reward systems
structured for individuals ,teams, and classes. There are four
elements which define characteristics of cooperative learning, they
are:(1) Team formation: teams 2-4 with students of different
abilities, mixed ethnicity & gender; (2) Positive
Interdependence : the gain of one student is associated with gains
for other students. It also can take several different forms; (3)
individual is made known to learn. It also can take several forms
and reward accountability; (4) Socials Skills : are developed and
practice based on the structure used. The students can learn how to
listen to each other, resolve conflicts, set and revise agendas,
keep on task encourage each other, Kagan (1989,4).Class activities
that use cooperative learning among others are: (1) Jigsaw,(2)
Think-Pair-Share; (3) Three Step Interview;(4) Round Robin
Brainstorming ;(5) Three Minute Review;(6) Numbered Heads
Together(NHT)
1.Jigsaw
Groups with five students are set up. Each group member is
assigned some unique material to learn and then to teach his group
members. To help in the class learning students across the class
working on the same sub-section get together to decide what is
important how to teach it. After practice in these expert groups
the original reform and students teach each other(Lie
,2002,69).
2.Think Pair-Share
Involves a three steps cooperative structure. During the first
steps individuals think silently about a question posed by the
instructor. Individuals pair up during the second step and exchange
thoughts. In the third steps, the pair share their responses with
other pairs, other teams, or the entire group (Lie,2002,57).
3.Three Steps Interview
Each member of team chooses another to be a partner. During the
first step individuals interview their partners by asking
clarifying questions. During the second step partners reverse the
roles. For the final step, members share their partners responses
with team.
4.Round Robin Brainstorming
Class divided into small groups (4-6) with one person appointed
as the recorder. A question is posed with many answers and students
are given time to think about answer. After the think time members
of team share responses with one another round robin style. The
recorder writes down the answers of the group members. The person
next to the recorder starts and each person in the group in order
an answer until time are called.
5.Three-Minute Review
Teachers stop any time during a lecture or discussion and give
teams three minutes to review what has been said, ask clarifying
questions.
6.Numbered Heads Together (NHA team of four is established. Each
number is given numbers of 1,2,3,4 questions are asked of the
group. Groups work together to answer the question so that all can
be verbally answer the question. Teacher calls out a number (three)
and each is asked to give an answer.
Numbered heads together (NHT) is an excellent structure for
combining learning partnership into groups or teams of four.
According to Kagan (1994) Numbered Heads Together is a learning
method in which each of the students are given a number and they
make a group of work and then the teacher will call the number of
student randomly. The purpose of this method is the students are
able to process information ,and communication. They also can
develop their thinking, review material and check their prior
knowledge. Numbered Head Together can serve any activities in the
classroom. It means that there are many other ways of ensuring the
teacher cues in the students into collaborative activity. The
students work together. They quite literally put their heads
together in order to solve the problem and also ensure that
everyone in the group can answer the question. The teacher in this
case asks for answer by calling the number and the students with
the number called, and then take turn to answer. If they are not
enough students ready to respond to the teacher ,the teacher may
give a little more time. When the teacher is for satisfied the
answer which can be taken ,there are a number choices:1)select one
student,2)select one but ask others to elaborate, comment
,etc,3)ask different students to give a particular part the
answer.The procedure in Applying of Numbered Heads Together (NHT)
techniqueNumbered Heads Together (NHT) is an essay ways to do in
the classroom. It can derive the students to be more active in the
class. According to Anita Lie (2002) there are some steps of
Numbered Heads Together, they are :(a) Teacher divides the students
into group work; (b) Teacher numbers the students from 1 to 4 each
group ;(c) Teacher gives a simple question or problem, example:
what is the main idea of the first paragraph ?;(d) In presenting
the result of students work ,the teacher calls a number of students
from 1 to 4 randomly;(e) For each team, the student whose number
was called reads their answer among their friend. They may not
receive any help from their team at this point. If he did not pay
attention during the discussion, its too bad;(f) when all teams
have shown their own work, teacher can check each teams answer for
accuracy;(g) the teacher can give the other question or problem if
time allows.The Advantages of Numbered Heads Together (NHT)
Numbered Heads Together (NHT) has the advantages as Trianto
(2002: 38) states that;(1) it is consider to help the students are
ready to give the solution to each question or problem which is
given ;(2) All of the students can do the discussion intensively.
They can share their ideas; felling and thought without any
authority form the others;(3) this method gives the possibility to
students know his progress based on his ability ;(4) The students
who can do the test can teach the other friend in getting the
solution ;(5) Students become more actively involved in the
learning process;(6) This learning focused on the teacher centered
in which between students work in group and teacher participate
each other to solve the problem;(7) The teacher feels more freedom
in the instructional process.Conceptual Framework
Reading is as mentioned previously , reading is a complex
process, which involves readers interpretation and comprehension of
the idea, symbolized by written and printed language. Therefore, it
is very crucial to make the students aware about the language in
the text. The main goal of teaching reading is improving reading
comprehension, which is the students competence in comprehending
the passage. Reading includes not only moving out eyes from printed
passage, but it needs comprehension of the text material.
Comprehension includes all of the processes related to deriving
meaning from written language and constructing meaning from written
language. Deriving meaning indicators that reader go beyond the
meaning explicitly in the text.
Reading comprehension is process of readers combining
information from a text and their own prior knowledge to build
meaning. Reading comprehension can be described as a consisting of
parsing sentence, understanding sentence in discourse, building a
discourse structure and then integrating this understanding with
one already know.
Description is kind of writing that tries to put a picture in
the readers mind. It tells how something looks or sounds or tastes.
This concept has the same meaning.Numbered Head Together (NHT) is
one of the cooperative learning that is designed to motivate
students to be active in classroom. Teacher as the facilitator and
guide takes the student into the real meaning by giving the
instruction first. Then the students work in their groups to solve
the problem which is given.In this application, Numbered Head
Together (NHT) has created a comfortable reading learning
condition. All components of Numbered Heads Together (NHT) involve
many activities such as:
1. Teacher divides the students into group of work,
2. Teacher numbers the students from 1 to 4 each group,
3. Teacher gives a question or problem, in presenting the result
of student working
4. Teacher calls a number of students from 1 to 4 randomly and
so on.
Students enjoy the activities because they can work and complete
in team as well as individually .They achieve greater success
because they are a part of the teaching learning
process.Hypothesis
Based on the explanation of both theoretical and conceptual
framework above, the writer formulated the hypothesis as the
following:Ho: There is no significance effect of using Numbered
Head Together (NHT) Technique on the students comprehension in
reading Descriptive text. Ha: There is significant effect of using
Numbered Head Together (NHT) on the student comprehension in
reading Descriptive text
CHAPTER III
RESEARCH METHOD
A. Research Design
This study was conducted by using experimental design with
pre-test and post-test design. The design was applied in order to
investigate the effect of applying Question Answer Relationship
(Numbered Head Together) technique on student comprehension in
reading especially in descriptive text. This study was dealt with
two groups, they are experimental group and control group.
Experimental group was taught by using Numbered Head Together
technique . and another one as a control group taugth without
Numbered Head Together technique Reading (NHT). Both of groups
given pre-test and post-test with same items. The design can be
seen in table 3.1
Table 3.1 Research Design
Randomly Assigned Pre-test Treatment Post-test
Experimental GroupT1EUsing Numbered Head Together technique
ReadingT2E
Control Group T1CWithout Numbered Head Together technique
ReadingT2C
B. Population and Sample1. Population Arikunto (2006:130) says
that population is all the subject of a research. The study
conducted students at SMP Negeri 1 Pancurbatu, in second years
junior high school academic year 2014/2015. Population on the study
consists of two classes are VIII 1 and VIII 3 and each class
consists of 40 students. The students divided into two groups were
experimental group and control group.
2.Sample
A sample is some or the representative of population which is
going to be observed. It means that the sample is limited number of
cases representative of the total sampling. The writer used total
sampling because the second year of junior high school at SMP
Negeri 1 Pancurbatu had two classes. The writer applied total
sampling for divided sample into two groups are experimental group
is VIII 2 and VIII 3 is the control group.
C. The Instrument of Collecting Data
The data of this study was collected by applying multiple
choice-tests. As Brown (2004) state that multiple choice formats
are practical reliable and they give the possibility of an easy and
consistent process of scoring and grading. The test consist of 20
items. Each item of test consist of four option namely, a, b, c,
and d. Researcher realize that multiple-choice test are the most
widely and highly regarded among the selection type of items for
test development. The arranging and producing the instrument taken
from english text book material of grade VIII of Junior High School
that adjusted with the syllabus.There are some reasons why
researcher used multiple choices to measure students achievement in
reading comprehension:
1. Effective for measuring
2. Objective scoring which is quick, easy, and consistent.
D. The Procedure of the Test
This part is divided into four steps, they are try out the test,
pre-test, treatment, posttest.
Pre-Test
The study revised pre-test to both groups; experimental group
and control group. The function of pre-test to know level of
achievement before treatment and collected the mean scores of
pre-test.
Treatment for Experimental Group
The treatment is taught in experimental group only. In this
research, the writer was taught reading comprehension to the
experimental group by Numbered Head Together(NHT) as
following:MeetingTeacherStudents
First
Before learning reading
1. The teacher gave greeting to students, preparing the students
to already study and ask the students to open their book.
During reading activity
2. The teacher asks the studentsto divide them into 5 groups
3. The teacher introduces the students plan for reading
4. The teacher explain a familiar reading passage to the
students
5. Then, the teacher reads example of text aloud and ask the
student to follow it.
6. After that, the teacher asked the students to find out what
is the passage talking about, who is the writer, what is the
purpose and what does the writer want from the readers after
reading the passage.
After reading activity
7. The teacher gave the right answer and discuss together with
the students
8. The teacher closed the lesson with makes a conclusion and
made the students happy about this topic.1. The students response
and opened the their book
2. The students gave response and do the teacher ordered
3. The students give attention
4. The students gave response to teacher explanation
5. The students do the teacher comment.
6. The students gave response to teacher by using answer the
question orally in each group, so other groups which present their
answer.
7. The students listening the teacher said and write the right
answer
8. The student give their attention to the teacher.
Second
Third Before learning reading
1. The teacher gave greeting to students and gave the students
motivation
During reading activity
2. The teacher ask the students to sit or back in their group
yesterday.
3. The teacher explains about how is to be good in reading maybe
about the kind of text etc.
4. The teacher give another example about reading passage to the
students
5. The teacher read the text and ask the student to follow when
he/she read the text aloud and carefully.
6. After read the text, the teacher ask them to find out the
question. For example, what is passage talking about, what is the
writer purpose and who is the writer.
After reading activity 7. The teacher ask to leader of the group
to collects their answer and ask them to retell t their
paragraph.
8. The teacher evaluated the result of students reading and give
score for each group.
9. The teacher closed the lesson and made the students happy
about this topic.
Before learning reading
1. The teacher gave greeting to students, preparing the students
to already study and ask the students to open their book.
2. The teacher give the students motivation
During reading activity
3. The teacher ask the student to back in their group and
distributes a text and a test material to the groups.
4. After that, the teacher tried to explain how to do the test
and how to be good in reading comprehension.5. The teacher
supervises the students activity while they do the test
individually.
After reading activity
6. The teacher gave 30 minutes and after that, the teacher
collect the students paper.
7. The teacher evaluated the result of students test and check
their paper and also gave scoring the students paper.
8. Then, the teacher closed the lesson and gave the students
motivated to be more active in reading activities. 1. The students
gave response the teacher by answer greeting
2. The students do the teacher ordered
3. The students gave attention to the teacher explanation.
4. The students gave response to the teacher said
5. The students do the teacher comment
6. The students gave attention to teacher by using answer the
question orally in each group, so other groups which present their
answer.
7. The students do the teacher comment
8. The students received the result and their score.
9. The students not bored during the lesson finishing.
1. The students gave response the teacher and do the teacher
comment
2. The students listening the teacher said about motivation
3. The students do the teacher ordered
4.The students listening the teacher said and tried to
understand.
5. The students do the test after they get the explanation from
the teacher.
6. The students collect their paper7. The students received the
result and score in test reading.
8. The students listening the teacher said.
Treatment for Control Group
In this study, the writer conducted control group is given by
other ways or without using discussion method. The treatment in
control group is done as follows:
MeetingTeacherStudents
First
Before learning reading
1. The teacher gave greeting to students, preparing the students
to already study
During reading activity
2. The teacher gives a text to the students
3. The teacher ask some students to read the text aloud with a
good intonation
4. The teacher ask the students to translate the text word by
word.
After reading activity
5. The teacher closed the lesson with makes a conclusion and
made the students happy about this topic.1. The students response
and opened the their book
2. The students gave attention
3. The students give attention
4. The students gave response to teacher comment.
5. The student give their attention to the teacher.
Second
Third Before learning reading
1. The teacher gave greeting to students and gave the students
motivation.
During reading activity
2. The teacher ask the students to make a small group consist of
4 students.
3. The teacher give text about reading to the students.
4. The teacher ask the student to read the text aloud and
carefully.
5. The teacher asks the students to make a text, which related
to the topic is about reading.
After reading activity
6. After 30 minutes, The teacher ask to leader of the group to
collects their answer
7. The teacher evaluated the result of students reading and give
score for each group.
8. The teacher closed the lesson and made the students happy
about this topic.Before learning reading
1. The teacher gave greeting to students, preparing the students
to already study and ask the students to open their book.
2. The teacher give the students motivation
During reading activity
3. The teacher distributes a text
4. After that, the teacher ask the students to do the test after
the teacher explains how the students should the test.
5. The teacher supervises the students activity while they do
the test individually.
After reading activity
6. The teacher gave 30 minutes and after that, the teacher
collect the students paper.
7. The teacher evaluated the result of students test and check
their paper and also gave scoring the students paper.
1. The students gave response the teacher by answer
greeting.
2. The students do the teacher ordered.
3. The students gave response to the teacher said.
4. The students do the teacher comment .
5. The students do the teacher comment.
6. The students do their teacher ordered
7. The students received the result and their score.
8. The students not bored during the lesson finishing1. The
students gave response the teacher and do the teacher comment
2. The students listening the teacher said.
3. The students gave attention
4. The students listening the teacher said and tried to do the
test individually.
5. The students do the test carefully.6. . The students collect
their paper
7. The students received the result and score in test
reading.
1. Post test
After conducting the treatment, both of the group was given
post- test. The post-test is exactly the same as the pre-test way.
It is intend to find out the mean scores of experimental and
control group.
E. The Validity and the Reliability of the Test
Validity and reliability of a test is very important in
research. It purposed to know what the accuracy of measurement and
the concistency of the test.
1. The Validity of the Test
The concept of the validity is reffered to the text measured.
Jeremy Harmer (2003: 322) state that a test is valid if it tests
what it is supposed to test. There are three types of validity
namely: content validity, criterion-related validity and construct
validity. Content validity used in this research. It is concern
with how well the content instrument represents the entire universe
of content that might be measure. The items of the test are
representative in behavioral objective, content, and
curriculum.
2. The Reliability of the Test
According to Jeremy Harmer (2003: 322) reliability is enhanced
by making the test instructions absolutely clear, restricting the
scope for variety in the answers, and making sure that test
conditions constant. Reliability is necessary characteristic of any
good test. It refers to the consistency of measurement. The same
test given to the same person on another day in other setting or
scored by different rate is likely to yield the same or similar
result. It means that the test is reliable, because the test is an
accurate and stable measure of individual performance. The test
will show the students score is always consistent all the time,
whenever they have test for now, tomorrow, and soon.
To achieve the reliability and consistency of measurement, Kuder
and Richardson (KR 21) as following:
Where : k : number of th test item
M : The mean of the score
S : The square of standard deviation of the test score
According to Arikunto
F. Technique for Analyzing the Data
To find out the difference means of scores of the test between
the experimental and control group, researcher used t-test formula.
The formula of the t-test as following:
Where : t : Total score
Ma : The mean of experimental group
Mb : The mean of control group
Da : The standard derivation of experimental group
Db : The standard derivation of experimental group
Na : The total sample experimental group
Nb : The total sample control group