This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
1
krebulSi gamoqveynebulia erTgvarovani sasamarTlo praqti-kis Camoyalibebisa da samarTlis ganviTarebisaTvis mniSvne-lovani gadawyvetilebebi. am da sxva saqmeTa moZebna SesaZle-belia saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos veb-gverdze:http://www.supremecourt.ge/default.aspx?sec_id=133&lang=1
kasatorma saCivriT iTxova obieqturi gadawyvetile-bis miReba. man aRniSna, rom sasamarTlom saqme ganixilasaproceso kanonmdeblobis darRveviT. Sprici, romelicpolicielebma miitanes, misi ar iyo. mas igi ar SeuZenia.aseve gayalbebulia misi Cveneba da xelmowera.
la saqmis masalebi, Seamowma saCivris safuZvlianoba damiaCnia, rom misi moTxovna ar unda dakmayofildes, xologasaCivrebul ganaCenSi unda Sevides cvlileba Semdeg ga-remoebaTa gamo:
palata iziarebs saapelacio sasamarTlos motivaciasmsjavrdebulis saCivris dakmayofilebaze uaris Tqmis Se-saxeb da aRniSnavs, rom sasamarTlom yovelmxriv da obi-eqturad Seamowma saqmeSi arsebuli mtkicebulebebi, Sea-fasa TiToeuli maTgani saqmesTan maTi relevanturobis,dasaSvebobisa da utyuarobis, k. x-is damnaSaved cnobi-saTvis sakmarisobis TvalsazrisiT, ris Sedegadac mividaim daskvnamde, rom erTmaneTTan SeTanxmebul mtkicebu-lebaTa erTobliobiT, kerZod, mowmeebis: samarTaldam-cavebis _ g. x-is, i. a-isa da g. q-as CvenebebiT, dakavebisa dapiradi Cxrekis oqmebiT, narkologiuri Semowmebis, qimi-uri eqspertizis daskvnebiTa da saqmis sxva masalebiT go-nivrul eWvs miRma dasturdeba, rom misTvis bralad Se-racxuli marTlsawinaaRmdego qmedebis Cadena dadastu-rebulia.
sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom saapelacio sasamarTlomsasjelis daniSvnisas gaiTvaliswina Cadenili danaSaulismotivi da mizani, qmedebaSi gamovlenili marTlsawinaaR-mdego neba, movaleobaTa darRvevis xasiaTi da zoma, qme-debis ganxorcielebis saxe, xerxi da marTlsawinaaRmde-go Sedegi, damnaSavis pirovneba, misi ojaxuri mdgomare-oba, k. x-is pasuxismgeblobis Semamsubuqebeli da damam-Zimebeli garemoebebi, ris safuZvelzec mis qmedebas mis-ca swori samarTlebrivi Sefaseba, rasac palatac eTanxme-ba.
amasTan, sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom `saqarTvelossisxlis samarTlis kodeqsSi cvlilebis Setanis Sesaxeb~
Ceni darCa ucvlelad.9. kasatori _ msjavrdebuli S. d-e sakasacio saCivarSi
aRniSnavs, rom saqmeSi ar arsebobs mtkicebulebaTa er-Toblioba, romelic obieqtur pirs daarwmunebda S. d-sbraleulobaSi; ukve nasamarTlevi S. d-s gamoZalviTmsjavrdebiT martivad daifara b. S-s braleuli qmedeba _mis mflobelobaSi arsebuli „...~ kuTvnili fulis miTvi-seba-gaflangva.
10. kasatoris azriT, mowmeebi _ T. q-e, e. a-e, a. f-e, b. a-e da T. S-e samarTaldamcavi organos muSakebi arian da ma-Ti Cvenebebi exeba sagamoZiebo moqmedebebs, xolo danar-Ceni mowmeebi b. S-s axloblebi arian da maTi Cvenebebi b. S-s sasargebloa.
11. rac Seexeba mowme m. f-s, misi Cvenebebi iribia; mow-meebis _ v. f-s, m. T-sa da m. S-s Cvenebebi ar Seicavs aranairinformacias gamoZalvis faqtebze, xolo v. T-e atyuebsmarTlmsajulebas, a. b-s CvenebaSi ki ar ikveTeba S. d-smxridan Zaladobis muqara, rac Tan erTvis Tanxis moT-xovnas; S. d-s mimarT gamamtyunebeli ganaCeni dadga mxo-lod imitom, rom igi warsulSi mkvlelobis mcdelobisaT-visaa nasamarTlevi da ar arsebobda b. S-s qmedebis kanoni-erad Sefasebis mizani.
12. yovelive zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, msjav-rdebuli S. d-e iTxovs quTaisis saapelacio sasamarTlos2015 wlis 2 ivnisis ganaCenis gauqmebas da gamarTlebas.
ma sakasacio saCivris safuZvlianoba da mivida daskvnam-de, rom msjavrdebul S. d-s sakasacio saCivari ar undadakmayofildes, xolo gasaCivrebul ganaCenSi unda Sevi-des cvlileba Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. sakasacio palata srulad iziarebs saapelacio sasa-marTlos argumentebs S. d-s mier gamoZalvis Cadenis Tao-baze da miaCnia, rom kanonis moTxovnaTa sruli dacviT,srulyofilad da obieqturad gamokvleul, utyuar, ur-TierTSejerebul da sakmaris mtkicebulebaTa erTobli-obiT, maT Soris _ dazaralebulebis _ b. S-sa da a. b-s Cve-nebebiT, mowmeebis _ v. f-s, m. T-s, v. T-s CvenebebiTa daamoRebuli videoCanawerebiT _ gonivrul eWvs miRma das-turdeba S. d-sTvis bralad Seracxuli qmedebis Cadena.
4. saqmeSi arsebuli da mxareTa SeTanxmebis safuZvel-ze udavod cnobili mtkicebulebebiT, mowmeebis _ ubnisinspeqtor-gamomZieblebis _ j. m-sa da g. b-s CvenebebiT
13
dadgenilia, rom 2014 wlis 27 maiss, daaxloebiT 06:30 sa-aTze, miiRes Setyobineba, rom q. baTumSi, ... quCis #...Simdebare barSi, savaraudod, daWrili iyo i. b-a. daaxloe-biT erT wuTSi isini Sevidnen barSi, sadac dainaxes, romTurqi erovnebis mamakaci scemda qals, kerZod, mas xele-bi hqonda i-sTvis yelze mokidebuli da Tavi miartymevi-na kedelze, ra drosac i. Zirs daeca. o. S-ma Tavi daanebaqalis cemas maTi xmamaRali SeZaxilis gamo.
5. amrigad, sakasacio palatas dadasturebulad miaC-nia, rom o. S-s waaswres danaSaulis Cadenisas, rac gamo-ricxavs mis mimarT saqarTvelos ssk-is 50-e muxlis me-5nawilis safuZvelze sasjelis nawilis pirobiT CaTvlas.
6. sakasacio palata ar iziarebs saapelacio palatis das-kvnas imis Sesaxeb, TiTqos saapelacio palata ar iyo uf-lebamosili, gaeuaresebina msjavrdebulis samarTlebri-vi mdgomareoba (gaeuqmebina ganaCeni o. S-sTvis sasjelisnawilis pirobiT CaTvlis nawilSi) im motiviT, rom proku-rori saapelacio saCivriT amas ar iTxovda. sakasacio pa-lata miuTiTebs, rom saxelmwifo bralmdebeli saapela-cio saCivarSi (iseve, rogorc sakasacio saCivarSi) mkafi-od uTiTebs imis Sesaxeb, rom pirveli instanciis sasamar-Tlom daarRvia saqarTvelos ssk-is 50-e muxlis imperati-uli moTxovna, ris gamoc ganaCeni ukanonoa. aqedan gamom-dinare, prokuroris moTxovna o. S-sTvis samarTliani sas-jelis gansazRvris Sesaxeb (saCivris Sinaarsidan da mo-tivebidan gamomdinare) ar zRudavda saapelacio palatas,emsjela xsenebul sakiTxzec.
7. rac Seexeba kasatoris moTxovnas msjavrdebulis-Tvis sasjelis gamkacrebis Taobaze, aRniSnuls palata ariziarebs da miaCnia, rom 6 TviT Tavisuflebis aRkveTa Se-esabameba o. S-s pirovnebas da mis mier Cadenili qmedebisxasiaTsa da simZimes.
6. kasatorebi _ msjavrdebuli g. g-e da advokati g. Z-i
16
sakasacio saCivrebSi aRniSnaven, rom saapelacio sasamar-Tlos ganaCeni ewinaaRmdegeba saqarTvelos konstituci-as, sisxlis samarTlis saproceso kodeqss da saqmis faq-tobriv garemoebebs; ganaCeni dadgenilia sssk-is 259-e,269-e, 273-e muxlebis uxeSi darRveviT; sasamarTlom argaiTvaliswina g. g-s mier bralis aRiareba da ZiriTadi aq-centi gadaitana mis nasamarTlobaze; aRsaniSnavia, rommsjavrdebuls pirobiTi sasjelis gamosacdeli vada amo-ewura 2014 wlis 3 oqtombers, anu pirveli instanciis sa-samarTlos mier ganaCenis dadgenamde; igi sruli mocu-lobiT asrulebda pirobiTi msjavris farglebSi masze da-kisrebul valdebulebebs; saapelacio sasamarTlos ga-dawyvetilebiT mas orjer mouwevs Tbilisis saqalaqo sa-samarTlos 2008 wlis 29 Tebervlis ganaCeniT daniSnulisasjelis moxda, rac ewinaaRmdegeba kanonmdeblobas dasayovelTaod aRiarebul principebs.
7. kasatorTa azriT, rodesac saxelmwifo auqmebs pi-robiT msjavrs im piris mimarT, romelmac, marTalia, sis-xlis samarTlis kanoniT gaTvaliswinebuli axali marTlsa-winaaRmdego qmedeba Caidina gamosacdeli vadis damTav-rebamde, Tumca mis winaaRmdeg jer ar damdgara gamamtyu-nebeli ganaCeni, es warmoadgens piris udanaSaulobis pre-zumfciis darRvevas; mxolod mas Semdeg, rac sasamarTlogamoitans gadawyvetilebas piris damnaSaved cnobis Se-saxeb, iwyeba sasjelis gansazRvra da msjeloba mis mimarTsasjelis dawesebaze, maT Soris _ wina ganaCeniT daniSnu-li pirobiTi msjavris gauqmebis Taobazec, Tuki, ra Tqmaunda, axali ganaCenis gamotanamde ukve amowuruli ar iyogamosacdeli vada. Sesabamisad, danaSaulis Cadenad undaCaiTvalos ara qmedebis faqtobrivad Cadenis momenti,aramed aRniSnul faqtTan dakavSirebiT sasamarTlos mi-er miRebuli gamamtyunebeli ganaCeni, vinaidan amis gaT-valiswinebis gareSe ilaxeba piris udanaSaulobis prezum-fcia.
8. garda aRniSnulisa, kasatorebs miaCniaT, rom g. g-sar unda damZimeboda pirveli instanciis sasamarTlos mi-er gansazRvruli sasjeli, radgan, marTalia, saqarTve-los ssk-is 67-e muxli ganaCenTa erTobliobiT iTxovs sas-jelis daniSvnas, magram imperatiulad ar aris dawesebu-li, rom aseT dros axali danaSaulisaTvis sasjelis saxedaucileblad gamoyenebuli unda iyos Tavisuflebis aR-
17
kveTa, miT ufro, rom im danaSaulis saqmeze, romlis Se-utyobineblobisaTvisaa msjavrdebuli g. g-e, sasamarTlom2013 wlis 2 seqtembris ganaCeniT braldebulebs daumtki-ca saproceso SeTanxmeba da TiToeul maTgans sasjeladganusazRvra 3000 lari jarima da pirobiTi msjavri Sesa-bamisi gamosacdeli vadiT; araTanabar pirobebSi g. g-s ua-ri eTqva saproceso SeTanxmebis damtkicebaze da daeniS-na bevrad ufro mkacri sasjeli, vidre im braldebulebs,romlebmac Caidines mZime danaSauli; amasTan, sasamar-Tlos unda gaeTvaliswinebina g. g-s pirovneba, misi oja-xuri da ekonomikuri mdgomareoba, is, rom hyavs mSoblebida misi ojaxi aRricxulia socialurad daucvelTa baza-Si.
9. zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, kasatorebi iTxovenquTaisis saapelacio sasamarTlos 2015 wlis 24 TebervlisganaCenis Secvlas, g. g-saTvis wina ganaCeniT daniSnulipirobiTi msjavris moxdilad CaTvlas, xolo axali dana-SaulisaTvis sasjelis saxed jarimis gansazRvras; im Sem-TxvevaSi ki, Tu aseTi gadawyvetilebis miReba SeuZlebe-li iqneba, iTxoven ganaCenTa erTobliobiT, 1 wliT Tavi-suflebis aRkveTasTan erTad, jarimis gansazRvras,msjavrdebulis pirovnebis, misi ojaxuri da ekonomikurimdgomareobis gaTvaliswinebiT.
ma sakasacio saCivris safuZvlianoba da mivida im daskvnam-de, rom gasaCivrebul ganaCenSi unda Sevides cvlilebaSemdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. sakasacio palata srulad iziarebs saapelacio sasa-marTlos argumentebs g. a-s mier 12,48 grami narkotikulisaSualeba `marixuanis~ ukanonod SeZena-Senaxvis Taoba-ze da miaCnia, rom kanonis moTxovnaTa sruli dacviT,srulyofilad da obieqturad gamokvleul, urTierTSe-jerebul da sakmaris mtkicebulebaTa erTobliobiT das-turdeba g. a-s bralad Seracxuli qmedebis Cadena, ker-Zod:
3. mowmis saxiT dakiTxuli, saqarTvelos Sinagan saqme-Ta saministros samtrediis raionuli sammarTvelos de-teqtivis TanaSemwe-gamomZieblis, m. d-s CvenebiT dadge-nilia, rom 2014 wlis 8 oqtombers, daaxloebiT 18:00 saaT-ze, sammarTveloSi Sevida operatiuli informacia imis Se-saxeb, rom q. s-i, T-s quCaze, `rompetrolis~ benzingasa-marTi sadguris mimdebare teritoriaze moZraobda g. a-i,romelsac Tan hqonda narkotikuli saSualeba `marixua-na~. am informaciis safuZvelze Seiqmna operatiuli jgu-fi misi, o. T-s da g. l-s SemadgenlobiT, romlebic `Sko-das~ markis samsaxurebrivi avtomanqaniT gavidnen miTi-Tebul misamarTze. benzingasamarTi sadguris ukan, sar-kinigzo gadasasvlelTan, maT dainaxes fexiT mimavali g.a-i, ris gamoc gaaCeres avtomanqana da samiveni Cavidnen.
22
maT danaxvaze igi Seecada gaqcevas, magram o. T-m da g. l-adaakaves. g. a-s man ganumarta uflebebi da winadadeba mis-ca nebayoflobiT warmoedgina narkotikuli saSualeba, ra-zec uari ganacxada da Tqva, rom aseTi ar hqonda. igi maTmimarT agresiulad iyo ganwyobili, ayenebdaT sityvierSeuracxyofas da eZaxda ZaRlebs. g. a-s Cautarda piradiCxreka, ris Sedegadac g. l-a mas lurji feris qurTukismarjvena jibidan amouRo qaRaldSi Sexveuli momwvano-moruxo feris masa, romelic mis win dado miwaze. misivequrTukis marcxena jibidan amoRebul iqna ori mobiluritelefoni, xolo jinsis Sarvlis jibidan _ fuladi Tanxa,ris Semdegac, vinaidan igi agrZelebda maTTvis sityvieriSeuracxyofis miyenebas, iqnevda xelebs da sagamoZiebomoqmedebis CatarebaSi uSlidaT xels, man gamoiZaxa dam-xmare jgufi. gamoZaxebidan daaxloebiT 5 wuTSi adgilzemividnen v. x-e, s. k-i da m. n-e. TviTon adgenda oqms da maTraime sagamoZiebo moqmedebaSi monawileoba ar miuRiaT.Cxrekis Sedegad amoRebuli nivTebis daluqvisa da oqmisSedgenis Semdeg g. a-i gadaiyvanes sammarTvelos SenobaSi.mowme m. d-s ganmartebiT, SemTxvevis adgilze moqalaqee-bi ar imyofebodnen.
4. mowmis saxiT dakiTxuli, saqarTvelos Sinagan saqme-Ta saministros samtrediis raionuli sammarTvelos ub-nis inspeqtor-gamomZieblis, g. l-s CvenebiT dadgenilia,rom 2014 wlis 8 oqtombers, sammarTveloSi Sevida opera-tiuli informacia imis Taobaze, rom g. a-s hqonda narko-tikuli saSualeba. amis safuZvelze Sedga operatiulijgufi da is, m. d-i da o. T-e `Skodas~ markis samsaxurebri-vi atomanqaniT gavidnen T-s quCaze, `rompetrolis~ ben-zingasamarT sadgurTan. adgilze misulebma dainaxes, rommiTiTebuli sadguris ukana mxares midioda g. a-i, romel-sac mouwodes SeCerebuliyo, razedac am ukanasknelma wi-naaRmdegoba gauwiaT, ris gamoc man da o. T-m xeli Caavlesda daakaves. igi kvlav winaaRmdegobas uwevdaT, uwmawurisityvebiT mimarTavda da eZaxda ZaRlebs, Tan yviroda _mideben, miSveleTo. am dros im teritoriaze maT gardaaravin iyo, xolo moSorebiT 4-5 xnieri adamiani imyofebo-da. g. a-s m. d-a ganumarta, rom mas unda Catareboda Cxrekada Tan mouwoda damSvidebuliyo, magram igi piriqiT, uf-ro agresiuli gaxda. g. a-s Cautarda piradi Cxreka, ra dro-sac misi momwvano feris qurTukis marcxena jibidan man
23
amoiRo mobiluri telefoni, sanTebela da sigareti, xo-lo marjvena jibidan _ raRac Sexveuli nivTiereba, razecg. a-a yvirili daiwyo _ narkotiki CamideTo. man amoRebu-li nivTi imwamsve iqve, win daagdo, rasac g. a-i cdilobdafexiT miswvdomoda. vinaidan igi agrZelebda winaaRmde-gobis gawevas, gamoiZaxes damxmare jgufi. daaxloebiT 5wuTSi mividnen v. x-e, s. k-i da m. n-e. am dros dakavebuliyviroda, uZaliandebodaT da ar emorCilebodaT. Cxrekisdasrulebis Semdeg man, o. T-m da m. d-a g. a-i gadaiyvanessammarTveloSi, Semdeg ki _ q. q-i, narkologiur Semowme-baze, sadac daudginda marixuanis moxmarebis faqti. mow-me g. l-s ganmartebiT, g. a-s dakavebisas saxeze aReniSne-boda nakawrebi, razedac ganacxada, rom aRniSnuli dazia-neba miiRo ojaxSi muSaobis dros.
5. mowmis saxiT dakiTxuli, saqarTvelos Sinagan saqme-Ta saministros samtrediis raionuli sammarTvelos ub-nis inspeqtor-gamomZieblis, o. T-s CvenebiT dadgenilia,rom 2014 wlis 8 oqtombers sammarTveloSi Sevida opera-tiuli informacia, rom g. a-i iyo narkotikuli nivTiere-bis zemoqmedebis qveS da qalaqSi moZraobda narkotiku-li saSualebiT. aRniSnulis safuZvelze xelmZRvanelo-bis davalebiT Sedga operatiuli jgufi misi, m. d-a da g.l-s SemadgenlobiT. isini `Skodas~ markis samsaxurebriviavtomanqaniT gavidnen im teritoriaze, sadac g. a-i undayofiliyo. igi SeniSnes T-s quCaze mdebare `rompetrolis~benzingasamarTi sadguris ukan, rkinigzis gadasasvlel-Tan, ra drosac mas xelSi mobiluri telefoni eWira. man-qanis gaCerebisTanave is da g. l-i gadavidnen avtomanqani-dan. maT danaxvaze g. a-i Secba da daapira gaqceva, magramdaakaves. m. d-a mas ganumarta uflebebi da SesTazava dam-swreebis mowveva, razec uari ganacxada da Tqva, rom ara-feri hqonda. igi uwevdaT winaaRmdegobas da agresiuladiqceoda, ris gamoc is da o. T-e xeliT akavebdnen. mas saxe-ze hqonda mcire zomis nakawrebi, romlebic, misive gan-martebiT, saxlSi SeSis Cexvis dros miiRo. g. a-s Cautardapiradi Cxreka, ra drosac g. l-a muqi lurji feris spor-tuli qurTukis wina, marjvena jibidan amouRo qaRaldSigaxveuli sagani da iqve miwaze dado, razedac man daiwyoyvirili _ ZaRlebma wamali Camides, miSveleTo da amoRe-bul nivTze fexis dartymas cdilobda, risi saSualebacar misces. am dros iqve, maT siaxloves aravin imyofeboda,
24
xalxi moSorebiT, rkinigzis gadasasvlelTan iyo. amoRe-buli nivTiereba daluqa m. d-a da oqmis Sedgena daiwyo.vinaidan g. a-i agresiulad iqceoda da uZaliandebodaT, m.d-a gamoiZaxa damxmare jgufi. daaxloebiT 5 wuTSi movid-nen v. x-e, s. k-i da m. n-e, ra drosac Cxreka ukve damTavre-buli iyo. g. a-i policiis muSakebs ar ucemiaT da mis mi-marT sxva raime kanonsawinaaRmdego qmedeba ar Caudeni-aT. igi damxmare jgufis daxmarebiT Casves samsaxurebrivavtomanqanaSi da man, m. d-a da g. l-a gadaiyvanes sammar-TveloSi, Semdeg ki _ q. q-i, narkologiur Semowmebaze, sa-dac daudginda marixuanis moxmarebis faqti.
6. mowmis saxiT dakiTxuli, saqarTvelos Sinagan saqme-Ta saministros samtrediis raionuli sammarTvelos uf-rosis moadgilis, v. x-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2014 wlis8 oqtombers sammarTveloSi Semovida operatiuli infor-macia, romlis Tanaxmad, narkotikebis aqtiur momxmare-bel g. a-s hqonda narkotikuli saSualeba, ris Sesaxebacacnoba deteqtivebis ganyofilebas. informaciis gadasa-mowmeblad gavida operatiuli jgufi m. d-s, g. l-a da o. T-s SemadgenlobiT. TviTon samsaxurebrivi avtomanqaniT ga-vida qalaqSi Semovlaze, mas axldnen policiis TanamSrom-lebi _ s. k-i da m. n-e. 18-dan 19 saaTamde periodSi daurekam. d-a, rom dakavebuli uwevdaT winaaRmdegobas da iTxovadaxmareba. daaxloebiT 5 wuTSi mividnen SemTxvevis ad-gilze, `rompetrolis~ benzingasamarT sadgurTan, radrosac moqalaqeebi iq ar daunaxavs. gamomZiebeli m. d-iatarebda sagamoZiebo moqmedebas. manqanis e.w. kapotzeelaga amoRebuli narkotiki da ori telefoni. amis Sem-deg g. a-i Casves manqanaSi da gadaiyvanes sammarTveloSi.
7. mowme s. k-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom igi muSaobs sa-qarTvelos Sinagan saqmeTa saministros samtrediis raio-nul sammarTveloSi ubnis inspeqtor-gamomZieblad. 2014wlis 8 oqtombers imyofeboda samsaxurSi. daaxloebiT 18saaTisTvis v. x-a da m. n-n erTad gavida qalaqis centrSiSemovlaze. cota xanSi v. x-s daurekes telefonze. rogorcman saubris dasrulebis Semdeg uTxraT, policiis Tanam-Sromlebs dakavebuli hyoliaT g. a-i, romelic uwevdaTwinaaRmdegobas da unda daxmarebodnen maT. Sesabamisad,isinic mividnen SemTxvevis adgilze, `rompetrolis~ ben-zingasamarTi saduris ukan, sadac dakavebuli hyavdaT g.a-i. maTi misvlisas narkotiki amoRebuli iyo da moTavse-
25
buli hqondaT polieTilenis paketSi. Tavad sagamoZiebomoqmedebaSi monawileoba ar miuRiaT, is da m. n-e daexmar-nen g. a-s manqanaSi CasmaSi. misive ganmartebiT, SemTxvevisadgilze moqalaqeebi ar iyvnen, mxolod gadasasvlelTanSeniSna sami adamiani.
8. mowme m. n-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom igi muSaobs sa-qarTvelos Sinagan saqmeTa saministros samtrediis raio-nuli sammarTvelos ubnis inspeqtor-gamomZiebelis Ta-namdebobaze. 2014 wlis 8 oqtombers s. k-n erTad asruleb-da samsaxurebriv movaleobas da isini periodulad gadi-odnen qalaqis teritoriaze prevenciis mizniT. daaxloe-biT 18 saaTisTvis v. x-n erTad isev gavidnen sammarTve-los Senobidan qalaqSi Semovlaze. qalaqis teritoriazemoZraobisas v. x-s daurekes telefonze. saubris dasru-lebis Semdeg man Tqva, rom policiis TanamSromlebs da-kavebuli hyavdaT g. a-i da TviTonac mividnen dakavebisadgilze _ `rompetrolis~ benzingasamarTi sadguris ukan.am dros m. d-i avsebda oqms, xolo g. l-a da o. T-s dakavebu-li hyavdaT g. a-i. igi winaaRmdegobas uwevda policiis Ta-namSromlebs. TviTon, s. k-i da v. x-e daexmarnen maT g. a-smanqanSi Casmasa da policiis SenobaSi gadayvanaSi. misiveganmartebiT, dakavebis adgilas sxva aravin iyo, xolo mo-cilebiT moZraobda 2-3 adamiani.
9. mowmis saxiT dakiTxuli, saqarTvelos Sinagan saqme-Ta saministros samtrediis raionuli sammarTvelos de-teqtivis TanaSemwe-gamomZieblis, d. f-s CvenebiT dadge-nilia, rom 2014 wlis 8 oqtombers sammarTveloSi Semovi-da operatiuli informacia imis Sesaxeb, rom g. a-i undayofiliyo q.s-i, T-s quCaze, avtosadguris mimdebare te-ritoriaze da unda hqonoda narkotikuli saSualeba, rissafuZvelzec Seiqmna operatiuli jgufi v. x-s xelmZRva-nelobiT. SemTxvevasTan dakavSirebiT gavidnen v. x-e, g.l-i, m. d-i, m. n-e, s. k-i da o. T-e. maT g. a-i miiyvanes polici-is sammarTveloSi, ra drosac igi igineboda uSveri sit-yvebiT da hqonda pretenzia, rom narkotiki policieleb-ma Caudes. masve saxis marcxena mxares aReniSneboda fuf-xiT dafaruli nakawrebi. narkotikul Trobaze Semowme-bis Sedegad g. a-s daudginda narkotikis moxmarebis faq-ti.
10. samtrediis raionuli sammarTvelos deteqtivisTanaSemwe-gamomZiebel m. d-s mier Sedgenili dakavebisa
26
da piradi Cxrekis oqmiT dasturdeba, rom g. a-i daakaves2014 wlis 8 oqtombers, 18 saaTsa da 50 wuTze, q. s-i, T-squCaze, `rompetrolis~ benzingasamarTi sadguris mimde-bare teritoriaze, ra drosac Catarebuli piradi CxrekisSedegad misi naWris qurTukis marjvena jibidan amoiReswarwerebian qaRaldSi gaxveuli momwvano-moruxo ferismasa, jinsis Sarvlis ukana jibidan _ sami cali erTdola-riani, erTi cali oclariani da ori cali xuTlariani kupi-urebi, xolo qurTukis wina jibidan _ `samsungis~ da `so-nis~ firmis mobiluri telefonebi.
11. mowmis saxiT dakiTxuli eqspertis, m. W-s CvenebiTada mis mier gacemuli #460/sq sasamarTlo-qimiuri eqsper-tizis daskvniT dadgenilia, rom g. a-s piradi Cxrekis Se-degad amoRebuli momwvano-moyavisfro, specifikuri su-nis mqone daqucmacebuli mcenareuli masa, mSral mdgo-mareobaSi, warmoadgens narkotikul saSualeba gamomSral`marixuanas~, woniT 12,48 grams.
12. mowmis saxiT dakiTxuli eqspertis, g. f-s CvenebiTada mis mier gacemuli narkologiuri eqspertizis #8015903daskvniT dasturdeba, rom dakavebis dRes _ 2014 wlis 8oqtombers Catarebuli narkologiuri gamokvlevis Sede-gad, g. a-s daudginda swored im saxeobis narkotikuli sa-Sualebis _ `tetrahidrokanabinolis~ (`marixuanas~) mox-mareba, romelic amoRebuli iqna misi piradi Cxrekis dros.
13. mowmis saxiT dakiTxuli Sps `j-s~ eqim-reanimato-log e. s-s CvenebiT dasturdeba, rom igi 2014 wlis 9 oq-tombridan 10 oqtombramde iyo morige. am periodSi saa-vadmyofoSi saswrafo daxmarebis brigadam policielebisTanxlebiT miiyvana pacienti g. a-i, romelic uCioda tki-vils Tavis, mkerdisa da muclis areSi. masve saxis areSietyoboda fufxiT dafaruli eqskoriaciebi. pacienti iyogaRizianebuli da agresiuli. mas Cautarda gamokvlevanevrologis da qirurgis mier, aseve Tavis tvinis kompiu-teruli kvleva, ris Sedegadac mwvave dazianebebi da nev-rologiuri paTologiebi gamoiricxa, gaukeTda gamayuCe-beli da vinaidan, misi stacionarSi datovebis aucileb-loba ar iyo, gaiwera saavadmyofodan. analogiuri Sinaar-sis informacias Seicavs Sps `j-s~ mier gacemuli cnoba g.a-s janmrTelobis mdgomareobis Sesaxeb.
14. yovelive zemoaRniSnulis gaTvaliswinebiTa da ase-ve, saqmeSi arsebul sxva mtkicebulebaTa Sefasebisa da
7. d. z-s mimarT Sefardebuli aRkveTis RonisZieba _girao gauqmda.
8. ganaCeniT msjavrdebulebis _ v. i-s, g. i-a da d. z-smier Cadenili danaSauli gamoixata SemdegSi: 2013 wlis 22dekembers v. i-a, g. i-a da d. z-a fizikuri Seuracxyofa mi-ayenes g. C-s, ris Sedegadac man miiRo sxeulis msubuqi xa-risxis dazianeba janmrTelobis mouSlelad da ganicadafizikuri tkivili. imave dRes v. da g. i-a samsaxureobrivimovaleobis Sesrulebisas, sazogadoebrivi wesrigis dac-visaTvis xelis SeSlis, maTi saqmianobis Sewyvetisa da Sec-vlis mizniT, sityvieri da fizikuri Seuracxyofa miaye-nes Sss goris raionuli sammarTvelos TanamSromlebs daemuqrebodnen fizikuri ganadgurebiT.
ma sakasacio saCivris safuZvlianoba da mivida im daskvnam-de, rom sakasacio saCivari ar unda dakmayofildes, xologasaCivrebul ganaCenSi unda Sevides cvlileba Semdeg ga-remoebaTa gamo:
2. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom warmodgenilia sakma-risi da utyuari mtkicebulebebi, romlebiTac udavoddasturdeba, rom msjavrdebulma v. i-a namdvilad CaidinagasaCivrebuli ganaCeniT misTvis bralad Seracxuli sa-qarTvelos ssk-is 273-e muxliTa da 125-e muxlis 1-li na-wiliT gaTvaliswinebuli danaSaulebi, rasac arc mxaree-bi xdian sadavod.
33
3. rac Seexeba v. i-s saqarTvelos ssk-is 353-e muxlisme-2 nawiliT (policiis muSakebis mimarT winaaRmdegobasazogadoebrivi wesrigis dacvisaTvis xelis SeSlis, maTisaqmianobis Sewyvetis an Secvlis mizniT, Cadenili Zala-dobis muqariTa da Zaladobis gamoyenebiT, jgufis mier)msjavrdebas, sakasacio palata srulad iziarebs saapela-cio sasamarTlos argumentebs v. i-s mier misTvis braladSeracxuli danaSaulis Cadenis Taobaze da miaCnia, rom aR-niSnuli gonivrul eWvs miRma standartiTaa dadasture-buli kanonis moTxovnaTa sruli dacviT, srulyofiladda obieqturad gamokvleuli, utyuari, urTierTSejere-buli da sakmarisi mtkicebulebebis erTobliobiT, ker-Zod: mowmeebis _ g. C-s, a. e-s, t. q-s, g. s-s, g. m-s, d. W-s, z. d-s, T. k-s, g. n-s, v. c-a da sxvaTa CvenebebiT, sasamarTlo-samedicino eqspertizis daskvnebiT, trasologiuri, sa-saqonlo da biologiuri eqspertizis daskvnebiTa da saq-meSi arsebuli sxva mtkicebulebebiT.
7. saqmeze darTuli sagnebi da nivTebi: SemTxvevis ad-gilis daTvalierebisas amoRebuli sisxlis laqebi (1 pa-keti), g. C-s, a. e-s, t. q-s, v. i-a da g. i-s sisxlis nimuSebiganadgurdes; g. i-a da v. i-n amoRebuli tansacmeli (2 pake-ti), t. q-a da a. e-n amoRebuli policielis formis qurTu-kebi (2 paketi) daubrundes maT kanonier mflobelebs.
li da #... piradobis mowmoba unda daubrundes m. q-s anmisi ndobiT aRWurvil pirs; dazaralebul a. f-is tansac-meli unda daubrundes a. f-is, xolo misi sisxlis nimuSi(gamSrali dolbandiT) da ori Rili unda ganadgurdes.
4. msjavrdebul m. q-is mier Cadenili danaSaulebriviqmedeba gamoixata SemdegSi: m. q-ma 2014 wlis 29 maiss, da-axloebiT 14.00 saaTze, ...-dan ...-is mimarTulebiT avtobu-siT gadaadgilebisas, urTierTSelaparakebis dros, racCxubSi gadaizarda, TurqeTis respublikis moqalaqe a. f-s danis gamoyenebiT, sxeulis dazianebis mizniT, miayenamarcxena plevrisa da muclis RruSi Semavali, sicocxli-saTvis saxifaTo, janmrTelobis ganzrax mZime dazianeba.
5. baTumis saqalaqo sasamarTlos 2015 wlis 20 Teber-vlis ganaCeni saapelacio wesiT gaasaCivres aWaris a/r-isprokuraturis prokurorma _ f. q-m da msjavrdebul m. q-is interesebis damcvelma, advokatma d. j-em.
ma sakasacio saCivrebis safuZvlianoba da mivida im das-kvnamde, rom aWaris a/r-is prokuraturis prokuror f. q-isa da msjavrdebul m. q-is interesebis damcvelis, advo-kat d. j-is sakasacio saCivrebi ar unda dakmayofildes,xolo gasaCivrebuli ganaCeni unda darCes ucvlelad Sem-deg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. msjavrdebulma m. q-ma Tavi ar cno damnaSaved war-dgenil braldebaSi. man uaryo dazaralebul a. f-is daniTdaWris faqti da ganmarta, rom a-s sxva pirma miayena dazi-aneba. man mxolod xelSi aiRo avtobusis iatakze dagde-buli dana da moiTxova damnaSavis dakaveba.
3. mowmis saxiT dakiTxul, dazaralebul a. f-is Cvene-biT dadgenilia, rom ramdenime Turqi erovnebis mamakac-Tan, maT Soris m. q-Tan erTad, dasasveneblad Camovida q....-Si. iseirnes qalaqis quCebSi, Semdeg ki parkSi daliesalkoholuri sasmelebi, Tavad _ ludi, xolo danarCeneb-ma _ arayi. avtobusSi m. q-i Zalian xmamaRla laparakobda.avtobusSi myofTagan erT-erTma iyvira, ris gamoc a-ma Se-niSvna misca m-s da Seecada mis dawynarebas. m. q-ma ki sapa-suxod pirze xeli mouWira. a-ma m-s xeli ubiZga da „aliyu-ri~ gaawna. amis mere m-is xelSi dainaxa dana, romlis pirigaxsnili iyo. m-i mas Tavs daesxa da orjer daartya dana.am dros maT SuaSi Cadga m-a. m. da a. Caerivnen. TviTon kisavarZlebs Soris Cavarda, ris Semdegac avtobusi gaCer-da da gareT gadmovidnen.
4. mowmis saxiT dakiTxuli m-a f-is CvenebiT dadgeni-lia, rom 2014 wlis maisSi, SuadRis saaTebSi, mgzavrobdaavtobusiT ...dan ...-is mimarTulebiT. amave avtobusiTmgzavrobda m. q-ic. sanam miuaxlovdebodnen ...-is centrs,mTvralma m. q-ma jibidan amoiRo dakuWuli qaRaldebi daZirs dayara, razec qarTvelma axalgazrdam SeniSvna mis-ca. m. q-i ganawyenda da maT Soris daiwyo kamaTi, rac Cxub-Si gadaizarda. axalsoflis centrTan ukve xelCarTuliCxubi mimdinareobda. m. q-s surda dana daertya qarTvelibiWisTvis, ris saSualebasac ar aZlevdnen da fizikur wi-naaRmdegobas uwevdnen misi Tanmxlebi Turqi erovnebismamakacebi, maT Soris dazaralebuli _ a. f-ic. dazarale-bulma saxeSi xeli gaartya m-s. am dros, rodesac m. q-i da-niT xelSi miiwevda qarTveli axalgazrdisaken, dana da-artya a. f-is, xolo qarTveli axalgazrda Cavida gaCere-buli avtobusidan da Semdeg aRar gamoCenila. Turqebic
5. mowme _ r. x-is CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2014 wlismaisSi, SuadRis saaTebSi, mgzavrobda avtobusiT. gzaSi m.q-ma jibidan amoiRo qaRaldebi da Zirs dayara, razec qar-Tvelma axalgazrdam SeniSvna misca. m. q-i ganawyenda damaT Soris daiwyo kamaTi, rac Semdeg CxubSi gadaizarda.erTmaneTSi Cxubi daiwyes Turqma mamakacebmac, isini cdi-lobdnen m. q-is dawynarebasa da misTvis danis warTmevas,Tumca ver axerxebdnen. m-is xelSi dainaxa dana, romlispiri iyo daaxloebiT 5-7 santimetri sigrZis, Tumca masuSualod dazaralebulis daWris momenti ar daunaxavs.mxolod SeniSna, Tu rogor waarTves xelidan dana m. q-s.
6. analogiuri Sinaarsis Cveneba misca da igive faqtob-rivi garemoebebi daadastura mowme _ j. s-em.
7. sasamarTlo sxdomaze gamoqveynebul mowme _ a. k-ismier micemuli CvenebiT dasturdeba, rom 2014 wlis 28 ma-iss Camovida saqarTveloSi ...-mis dasaTvaliereblad Ta-vis megobar a. f-sTan, aseve _ m. q-Tan, i-sTan, m-asa da ki-dev erT m-asTan erTad, romlebic mgzavrobisas gaicno.daaTvaliera qalaqi, meore dRes ki gadawyvites gamgzav-reba. gamgzavrebamde isadiles da dalies ludi, xolo m.q-ma ludTan erTad _ arayic. m-i iyo Zlier mTvrali. sar-famde avtobusiT mgzavrobisas m. q-sa da f. a-s Soris war-moiSva uTanxmoeba, konkretulad ra mizeziT, ar icis, rad-gan maTgan moSorebiT ijda. kamaTi fizikur dapirispire-baSi gadaizarda. mZRolma avtobusi gaaCera, danarCenimgzavrebi Cavidnen avtobusidan, xolo m. q-i da a. f-i kiganagrZobdnen Cxubs da miuxedavad maTi Carevisa, m-ikvlav ganagrZobda a-is mimarT fizikur angariSsworebasada Zaladobas. dazaralebulis daWris momenti mas ar dau-naxavs. mogvianebiT a. f-isagan Seityo, rom m. q-ma avto-busSi Cxubis dros daWra muclis areSi.
8. mowme g. m-is CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom SemTxvevisdRes idga avtomanqaniT, ra drosac gaCerda avtobusi, sa-idanac Camovidnen mgzavrebi. avtobusis kibis safexurzedainaxa m. q-i. igi iyo mTvrali da xelSi eWira dana, uknidansxvebi eqaCebodnen, Semdeg ki dana waarTves.
9. mowme e. d-is CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom aris baTumis
10. mowmis saxiT dakiTxul eqspert R. u-is CvenebiTada mis mier gacemuli sasamarTlo-samedicino eqsperti-zis 2014 wlis 17 ivnisis #... daskvniT dadgenilia, rom a.f-is sxeulze aReniSneboda: marcxena plevrisa da muc-lis RruSi Semavali Wriloba, marcxenamxrivi hemopnevmo-Toraqsi, hemoperitoniumi, diafragmis, didi badeqonis,kuW-kolinjis iogis, wvrili nawlavis jorjlis daziane-ba. arsebuli dazianebebi ganviTarebulia raime mCxvle-tav-mWreli sagnis zemoqmedebiT da miekuTvneba daziane-baTa mZime xarisxs, rogorc sicocxlisaTvis saxifaTo. da-zianebis xandazmuloba ar ewinaaRmdegeba dadgenilebaSimiTiTebul TariRs.
11. zemoaRniSnuli mtkicebulebebidan gamomdinare,sakasacio palata yuradRebas miaqcevs rogorc pirveliinstanciis, aseve saapelacio sasamarTlos ganaCenSi ar-sebuli daskvnebis Seusabamobaze, erTi mxriv, braldebisSesaxeb dadgenilebaSi mocemuli braldebis formulire-basTan, xolo, meore mxriv, ki saqmeSi arsebul mtkicebu-lebebTan. braldebis Sesaxeb dadgenilebis mixedviT, m.q-s brali edeba imaSi, rom mas 2014 wlis 29 maiss, avtobu-siT mgzavrobisas, urTierTSelaparakeba mouxda Turqe-Tis moqalaqe a. f-sTan, rac Semdeg CxubSi gadaizarda. Cxu-bis dros m. q-ma danis gamoyenebiT, ganzrax mokvlis miz-niT, a. f-is miayena marcxena plevrisa da muclis RruSiSemavali Wriloba.
12. saapelacio palatam ki, iseve rogorc pirveli in-stanciis sasamarTlom, dadasturebulad miiCnia, rom kon-fliqturi situacia Seiqmna m. q-sa da qarTvel axalgaz-rdas Soris (romelic wesrigis dacvisken mouwodebdamsjavrdebuls), rac CxubSi gadaizarda. Cxubis dros m. q-i iyo agresiuli da daniT xelSi iwevda SeniSvnis mimcemiucnobi pirisken da rom misi agresia mimarTuli iyo ara a.
50
f-is, aramed _ qarTveli erovnebis mamakacis mimarT. sapi-rispiros ganmartavs dazaralebuli, romlis Cvenebis Ta-naxmad, man SeniSvna misca m-s da Seecada mis dawynarebas.m. q-ma ki sapasuxod pirze xeli mouWira. man m-s xeli ubiZ-ga da „aliyuri~ gaawna. amis Semdeg m-is xelSi dainaxa dana,romlis piri gaxsnili iyo. m-i mas Tavs daesxa da orjerdaartya dana. is faqti, rom avtobusSi Cxubi moxda aramxolod Turqi erovnebis, aramed aseve qarTveli da Tur-qi erovnebis mamakacebs Sorisac, garda dazaralebulisCvenebisa, aseve dadasturebulia mowmeebis _ m. f-is, r. x-is, j. s-is, a. k-is CvenebebiT. ar aris gamokvleuli is faq-tobrivi garemoeba, Tu ra momentSi daWra m. q-ma dazara-lebuli. igi moqmedebda arakonkretizirebuli ganzrax-viT da bundovania surda sxeulis dazianebis miyenebisgziT Tavidan moeSorebina a. f-i, romelic xels uSlidaqarTveli mamakacis daWraSi, Tu Tavad a. f-is daWra undo-da SurisZiebis motiviT, vinaidan am ukanasknelma ar mis-ca SeniSvnis mimcemi qarTveli axalgazrdisaTvis pasuxisgacemis saSualeba. garda amisa, aseve winaaRmdegobriviadazaralebul a. f-is Cveneba da sasamarTlo-samedicinoeqspertizis daskvna, radgan dazaralebuli aRniSnavs,rom msjavrdebulma mas orjer daartya dana, xolo sasa-marTlo-samedicino eqspertizis daskvniT ki dadgenilia,rom a. f-is sxeulze aReniSneba mxolod erTi Wriloba.
13. rogorc braldebis Sesaxeb dadgenilebiT, aseve sa-apelacio sasamarTlos daskvnebiT saqmis faqtobrivi ga-remoebebi araTanmimdevruli da bolomde dauzustebe-lia, Tumca saqmeSi arsebuli mtkicebulebebi aSkarad mi-uTiTebs m. q-is mier danaSaulis Cadenis faqtze, ris ga-moc eWvi unda gadawydes msjavrdebulis sasargeblod daZalaSi unda darCes quTaisis saapelacio sasamarTlos ga-dawyvetileba. ar unda dakmayofildes aWaris a/r-is pro-kuraturis prokuror fridon qarcivaZis sakasacio saCi-vari msjavrdebulisaTvis msjavris damZimebis moTxovnisSesaxeb. sakasacio palata aseve ver gaiziarebs dacvis mxa-ris pozicias, rom msjavrdebulma dazaralebuls jan-mrTelobis dazianeba miayena gaufrTxileblobiT, radganar gamomdinareobs saqmeSi arsebuli mtkicebulebebidan.
14. yovelive zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, sakasa-cio palatas miaCnia, rom gasaCivrebuli ganaCeni kanonie-ria da unda darCes ucvlelad.
7. kasatori _ prokurori l. x-e sakasacio saCivarSi aR-niSnavs, rom sasamarTlos mosazrebebi dausabuTebelia,ewinaaRmdegeba sisxlis samarTlis saqmeSi arsebul mtki-cebulebaTa erTobliobas, amitom gasaCivrebuli ganaCe-ni unda gauqmdes da T. j-s mimarT dadgindes gamamatyu-nebeli ganaCeni Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
8. dazaralebul n. j-s CvenebiT, romelic sasamarTlo-Si daadastures mowmeebma: q. b-ma, g. g-m, a. l-ma, g. l-m, m. x-ma, d. e-m, Catarebuli sagamoZiebo eqsperimentis oqmiT,sasamarTlo-samedicino da trasologiuri eqspertizebisdaskvnebiT, SemTxvevis adgilidan amoRebuli nivTebiTdadasturebulia T. j-s mier misTvis inkriminirebuli da-naSaulis Cadena, magram sasamarTlom es mtkicebulebebiar gaiziara da mosamarTlem Tavisi ganaCeniT faqtobri-vad Tqva, rom dazaralebulma yvelaferi moigona, TumcasaerTod ar imsjela misi aseTi qcevis motivze; sasamar-Tlom ar gaamaxvila yuradReba T. j-s mier gamoZiebasa da
53
sasamarTloSi micemul Cvenebebs Soris arsebul sxvaoba-ze; man sasamarTloSi mtkicebulebaTa gamokvlevisas „aa-go~ SemTxvevis axali versia, romelic ar dasturdeba mtki-cebulebebiTa da logikis kanonebiT.
9. kasatoris azriT, mocemul SemTxvevaSi braldebamsasamarTlos warudgina faqtebisa da mtkicebulebebis er-Toblioba, romelTa Sefasebis Sedegad obieqturi piridarwmundeba, rom T. j-ma realurad Caidina misTvis bra-lad Seracxuli danaSauli.
10. yovelive zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, proku-rori l. x-e iTxovs Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos 2015wlis 14 aprilis gamamarTlebeli ganaCenis gauqmebas da T.j-s damnaSaved cnobas saqarTvelos ssk-is 19,137-e mux-lis 1-li nawiliT gaTvaliswinebuli danaSaulis CadenaSi.
11. gamarTlebuli T. j-i da misi interesebis damcveli,advokati l. k-e SesagebliT iTxoven prokuror l. x-s saka-sacio saCivris dauSveblad cnobas.
prokuror l. x-s sakasacio saCivari, Seiswavla saqmis ma-salebi, Seamowma saCivris safuZvlianoba da miaCnia, romigi unda dakmayofildes Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. rogorc dazaralebul n. j-s Cvenebidan irkveva, 2014wlis 27 Tebervals mis ojaxSi stumrad mivida misi biZaS-vili T. j-i. saRamos misma mamam da T-ma dalies alkoholu-ri sasmeli. meore dRes mamisa da T-s TxovniT gahyva amukanasknels pasportis asaRebad, Tumca gzaSi T-ma SesTa-vaza, eWamaT xinkali. am mizniT mividnen `xinklis saxlSi~,sadac braldebulma dalia ramdenime Wiqa arayi. saxinkleSimisvlamde maT Seiares aseve `vagzalze~, sadac T-ma Svilsuyida mobiluri telefoni. saxinkleSi yofnisas man T-stelefoniT gaacno Tavisi Seyvarebuli. `xinklis saxli-dan~ gamosvlis Semdeg, T. j-s iniciativiT, wavidnen ...isparkSi, sadac cota xans iseirnes, xolo Semdeg bralde-
54
bulma SesTavaza ... eklesiaSi Sevla. isini gaemarTnen kibe-ebiT eklesiis mimarTulebiT, ra drosac braldebulma da-zaralebuls SesTavaza kibeebis gverdis avliT, tyis gav-liT wasuliyvnen, vinaidan ase ufro Seimoklebdnen gzas.mas Semdeg, rac gadavidnen bilikidan, garkveuli manZi-lis gavlis Semdeg, moulodnelad, T-ma SeaCera igi da xe-lebiT dauwyo Sexeba sxeulis sxvadasxva adgilze. daza-ralebulma scada Tavidan moeSorebina braldebuli, risgamoc igi brazdeboda da cdilobda misTvis xelebi gaeka-vebina. am dros, vinaidan imyofebodnen ferdobze, Taviver Seikaves da waiqcnen. n. j-i zurgiT iwva miwaze, xoloT. zemodan daawva da jer fexsacmeli gaxada Zalis gamo-yenebiT, Semdeg kolgotic da cdilobda sacvalic gaexa-da, ra drosac n. j-ma iqve dagdebuli minis qila CaartyaTavSi, aseve urtyamda qvasac. am dros braldebuls mar-jvena xelis mtevnidan wamouvida sisxli, rac, albaT, nam-sxvrevebze daiziana. gaweuli winaaRmdegobis gamo, bral-debulma Tavi daaneba mas da cota moSorebiT dajda miwa-ze, riTic isargebla dazaralebulma da Caicva fexsacme-li. am dros braldebulma kvlav scada mis mimarT Zalado-ba, Tumca ver moaxerxa, vinaidan n. j-ma qviSa Seayara Tva-lebSi da gaiqca. braldebuli ukan mihyveboda. ferdobisbolos n. j-ma dainaxa sacxovrebeli saxli, sadac enTo Su-qi. im mizniT, rom saSvelad vinmesTvis moexmo, daiwyo bra-xuni karze, ra drosac gamoxeda qalbatonma, romelsac da-uZaxa `miSveleT, am kacTan marto ar damtovoTo~, ris Sem-degac braldebuli gaiqca. amis Semdeg gamoCndnen ... par-kis dacvis TanamSromlebi da waiyvanes igi molare opera-toris oTaxSi, sadac mouyva momxdaris Sesaxeb molare go-gonasa da im qalbatons, romelsac pirvelad sTxova dax-mareba. dazaralebulma ganmarta, rom Zaladobisas gauvar-da T-s mier nayidi telefoni, romelic mas eWira xelSi.aseve dakarga `metromani~, piradobis mowmoba da sayure.
3. mocemul CvenebasTan dakavSirebiT sakasacio pala-ta aRniSnavs Semdegs: gansaxilveli danaSauli, Tavisi bu-nebidan da xasiaTidan gamomdinare, rogorc wesi, ar arissajaro da ar gamoirCeva TviTmxilvel mowmeTa simravliT;Sesabamisad, aseTi kategoriis saqmeebSi gansakuTrebiTmniSvnelovania dazaralebulis Cvenebis Tanmimdevrulo-ba, Sesabamisoba sxva mtkicebulebebTan da iseTi motivisararseboba, ramac sasamarTlos SesaZlebelia, afiqrebi-
55
nos dazaralebulis mikerZoebulobis Sesaxeb braldebu-lis sawinaaRmdegod. swored aseT sando Cvenebas warmo-adgens dazaralebul n. j-s Cveneba. anu, sasamarTlos aR-niSnuli Cveneba utyuar mtkicebulebad miaCnia, vinaidanmis mier miTiTebuli faqtebi dasturdeba saqmeSi arse-buli Semdegi mtkicebulebebiT:
4. mowme q. b-s CvenebiT, romlis mixedviTac, man 2014wlis 28 Tebervals, daaxloebiT 17:00-dan 19:00 saaTamdeperiodSi, gaigona braxuni ezos rkinis karze, gavida ga-reT da dainaxa misTvis ucnobi piri, romelmac hkiTxa, Turogor SeiZleboda Robeze gadmosvla. amavdroulad gai-gona gogonas xma `miSveleT, am kacTan marto ar damtovo-To~, ris gamoc q. b-i Cavida dacvis TanamSromlebis dasa-Zaxeblad. g. g-a, g. l-e da a. l-i mividnen dazaralebulTan,gadmoiyvanes parkis teritoriaze da Seiyvanes molare-operatoris oTaxSi, sadac n. j-ma mas da m. x-s mouyva, rombiZaSvilma scada misi gaupatiureba.
5. mowmeebis _ q. b-s, m. x-s, g. g-s, g. l-sa da a. l-s Cvenebe-biT, romelTa mixedviTac, n. j-i iyo Sokur mdgomareoba-Si, namtiralevi, caxcaxebda, fexebi dakawruli hqonda daar ecva kolgoti, rac maTTvis gasakviri iyo, vinaidan Te-bervali iyo da sakmaod cioda.
6. sagamoZiebo eqsperimentis oqmiT, saidanac irkveva,rom ...is parkSi, n. j-s mier miTiTebuli adgilidan, nanaxida amoRebul iqna n. j-s kolgoti, romelsac aReniSnebo-da dazianebebi da sisxlis laqa, romelic biologiuri eq-spertizis #.../sb daskvnis Tanxmad (romlis sisworec sa-samarTlo sxdomaze daadastura eqspertma n. e-ma), emTxve-va n. j-sgan aRebuli sisxlis nimuSis jgufs; amoRebul iq-na aseve n. j-s sayure, `metromani~, piradobis mowmoba daT. j-s mier nayidi mobiluri telefoni Tavisi yuTiT.
7. trasologiuri eqspertizis #.../tr daskvniT, rom-lis sisworec daadastures sasamarTlo sxdomaze eqsper-tebma _ s. e-m da n. k-m da romliTac dadgenilia, rom n. j-squrTuks, sacvalsa da kolgots aReniSneboda dazianebe-bi (nakeris garRvevisa da gaxevis saxiT), romlebic war-moqmnilia fizikuri Zalis zemoqmedebis Sedegad.
8. dacvis mxaris mier warmodgenili trasologiuri eq-spertizis #... daskvniT, romlis sisworec daadastura sa-samarTlo sxdomaze eqspertma n. o-m da romliTac dadge-nilia, rom n. j-s qveda bolosa da kolgotze arsebuli da-
16. palatis SefasebiT, T. j-s zemoaRniSnuli Cvenebaaradamajerebelia, ar gamomdinareobs gamokvleul mtki-cebulebaTa erTobliobidan da Sesabamisad, ver akmayo-filebs mtkicebulebis utyuarobis kriteriums. palatasmiaCnia, rom misi versia mogonilia pasuxismgeblobisganTavis aridebis mizniT, Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo: T. j-maaRniSna, rom is apirebda n. j-s SeyvarebulTan Sexvedras(da swored amitom waiyvana n. ... parkSi), Tumca es faqti ardaadastura Tavad mowme d. e-m (n. j-s Seyvarebulma), ro-melmac sasamarTlos ganumarta, rom igi namdvilad esaub-ra telefoniT T. j-s, magram Sexvedraze uari uTxra, vi-naidan ar ecala.
17. sasamarTlos aseve aradamajereblad miaCnia T. j-sganmarteba imis Taobaze, rom TiTqos mas SeeSinda, n-s Ta-vi ar moekla da amitom gahyva ukan, tyisken. Tumca, gauge-bari rCeba, ratom erTxelac aRar moikiTxa T. j-ma aRniS-nuli SemTxvevis Semdeg n. maSin, rodesac igi aseTi aRel-vebuli ucxo adamianTan (q. b-Tan) datova.
18. sakasacio palatisTvis aralogikuri da aradamaje-rebelia aseve T. j-s miTiTeba imis Sesaxeb, TiTqos n. immotiviT abralebda Zaladobas, rom ar gaeTqva misi (n. j-s)piradi cxovrebis detalebi maSin, rodesac T. j-i Tavadacxadebs, rom mTelma sofelma icis n-s `uweso~ saqcielisSesaxeb. sasamarTlosTvis aseve gaugebaria, T. j-s dapa-timreba rogor Seuwyobda xels n-s piradi cxovrebis de-talebis dafarvas.
19. yovelive zemoxsenebulidan gamomdinare, sakasa-cio palatas dadgenilad miaCnia, rom kanonis moTxovnaTasruli dacviT, srulyofilad da obieqturad gamokvle-ul, utyuar, urTierTSejerebul da sakmaris mtkicebu-lebaTa erTobliobiT gonivrul eWvs miRma dasturdebaT. j-sTvis bralad Seracxuli qmedeba.
20. saqarTvelos ssk-is 53-e muxlis Sesabamisad, sakasa-cio palata mxedvelobaSi iRebs T. j-s pirovnebas, mis mi-er Cadenili qmedebis xasiaTsa da simZimes, qmedebaSi ga-
60
movlenil marTlsawinaaRmdego nebas da ise ganusaz-Rvravs mas samarTlian sasjels.
4. ganaCeni saapelacio wesiT gaasaCivres msjavrdebul-ma r. p-m da misma advokatma s. j-m. apelantebma iTxoveszugdidis raionuli sasamarTlos 2014 wlis 4 dekembrisganaCenis gauqmeba da r. p-s gamarTleba.
9. garda aRniSnulisa, aSkara Seusabamobaa dakavebisada piradi Cxrekis oqmsa da mowme _ policiel g. q-s Cvene-bas Soris; am monacemebis gaziarebis SemTxvevaSi gamodis,rom policia qurdobis faqtamde imyofeboda SemTxvevisadgilze da iqve daakava qurdi, rac aSkara siyalbea; saa-pelacio sasamarTlom ar gamoikvlia da eWvgareSe stan-dartiT ar daadgina dakavebis kanoniereba da dasabuTe-buloba; sasamarTlom aseve ar dakiTxa d. n-a da sapatru-lo policiis ekipaJis wevrebi, romlebic policiis mis-vlamde imyofebodnen dazaralebulis saxlTan da romel-Ta dakiTxvac aseve daadasturebda r. p-s udanaSaulobas;sasamarTlos ar unda gaeziarebina dazaralebul d. C-s ur-TierTsawinaaRmdego da aradamajerebeli Cvenebebi, rad-gan, rogorc Cans, mas daemuqrnen sisxlis samarTlis pa-suxisgebaSi micemiT, amitom sasamarTlo procesze gansax-vavebuli pozicia daafiqsira.
10. saqmis faqtobriv garemoebebs ewinaaRmdegeba mow-meebis _ z. p-sa da r. l-s Cvenebebi, SemTxvevis adgilisdaTvalierebis oqmi da d. C-s axsna-ganmarteba; aRsaniSna-via isic, rom dazaralebulis saxlis pirvel sarTulzeganTavsebuli fanjrebi (e.w. „fortoCkebi~) imdenad viw-roa, rom masSi verc adamiani SeZlebs gadaZromas da vercTxiliT savse tomara gaeteva; sasamarTlom uaryo dacvismxaris mier warmodgenili mtkicebulebebi, kerZod, mow-meebis _ n. o-s, s. a-s, p. b-s, n. l-s, n. k-s Cvenebebi, romlebi-Tac dadasturda policielTa mxridan r. p-s cemisa da wa-mebis faqti, Tumca ganaCenSi ar dausabuTebia, raSi gamoi-xata es winaaRmdegoba; saapelacio sasamarTlom ar daak-mayofila dacvis mxaris Suamdgomloba mowmeebis damate-biTi dakiTxvis Sesaxeb, riTac SeuzRuda samarTliani sa-samarTlos ufleba.
11. saapelacio sasamarTloSi saqmis ganxilvisas, saka-maTo sityvebis stadiaze, t. y-m (romelic sxva sisxlis sa-marTlis saqmeze braldebulia da moTavsebulia quTai-sis #2 dawesebulebaSi) gancxadebiT mimarTa saqarTvelosmTavar prokuraturas imis Sesaxeb, rom danaSauli misi Ca-denilia, r. p-s ukanonod dasdes msjavri da moiTxova saq-mis gamoZieba da r. p-s gaTavisufleba ukanono patimrobi-
64
dan; sasamarTlom ar daakmayofila dacvis mxaris Suam-dgomloba axal garemoebaTa gamo mowmis dakiTxvis Sesa-xeb, xolo mTavarma prokuraturam t. y-s gancxadeba Sem-dgomi reagirebisaTvis daawera zugdidis raionul pro-kuraturas, romelic bralmdebelia sasamarTlo proce-sebze da logikuria, rom darRvevebisaTvis sakuTar Tavsar dasjis. es saqme unda gamoiZios miukerZoebelma da da-moukidebelma prokuraturam.
12. saapelacio sasamarTlom dacvis mxaris arc erTi ka-nonieri moTxovna da Suamdgomloba ar daakmayofila, „da-akopira~ pirveli instanciis ganaCeni da saqmis ganxilvi-sas daarRvia Sidasaxelmwifoebrivi da saerTaSoriso sa-marTliT sayovelTaod aRiarebuli principebi; sasamar-Tlos r. p-saTvis zugdidis raionuli sasamarTlos 2008wlis 22 oqtombris ganaCeniT daniSnuli damatebiTi sas-jeli _ 5000 lari jarima „amnistiis Sesaxeb~ 2012 wlis 28dekembris saqarTvelos kanonis safuZvelze unda moex-sna da ar unda daematebina bolo ganaCeniT daniSnuli sas-jelisaTvis.
13. yovelive zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, msjav-rdebuli r. p-a da advokati x. T-e iTxoven quTaisis saape-lacio sasamarTlos 2015 wlis 21 maisis ganaCenis gauqme-bas, r. p-s gamarTlebasa da ukanono patimrobidan dauyov-nebliv gaTavisuflebas.
ma sakasacio saCivris safuZvlianoba da mivida daskvnam-de, rom msjavrdebul r. p-sa da misi interesebis damcve-lis, advokat x. T-s sakasacio saCivari ar unda dakmayo-fildes, xolo gasaCivrebul ganaCenSi unda Sevides cvli-leba Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. sakasacio palata ar iziarebs kasatoris poziciasmsjavrdebul r. p-s udanaSaulobis Sesaxeb da miaCnia, romkanonis moTxovnaTa sruli dacviT, srulyofilad da obi-eqturad gamokvleul, utyuar, urTierTSejerebul dasakmaris mtkicebulebaTa erTobliobiT dasturdebamsjavrdebul r. p-s mier qurdobis Cadenis faqti, kerZod:
3. dazaralebul d. C-s CvenebiT dasturdeba, rom 2014wlis 22 agvistos imyofeboda saxlSi, muSaobda kompiu-terTan da gvian dawva dasaZineblad. daaxloebiT 04:00 sa-
65
aTze gaaRviZa xmaurma, mixvda, rom pirvel sarTulze vi-Rac moZraobda, SeeSinda da dareka 112-Si, Semdeg fanjri-dan gadaixeda da dainaxa mamakaci, romelsac xelSi toma-ra eWira, safrTxe igrZno da dabla mxolod Zalovanistruqturis warmomadgenlebis mosvlis Semdeg Cavida.eseni iyvnen g. q-a da S. k-a. maT d. C-s ganucxades, rom daa-kaves pirovneba r. p-a. dakaveba moxda Txilianad misi sac-xovrebeli saxlis ezoSi. sacxovrebeli saxli aris orsar-Tuliani, orive sarTuls iyenebs sacxovreblad, fanjre-bi aqvs Cveulebrivi, adamians Tavisuflad SeuZlia gadas-vla. saxlidan gatanilia 3 tomara Txili, ori tomara sax-lis marjvena mxares ewyo, mesame ki _ dakavebulTan naxa.
4. mowmeebis g. q-sa da S. k-s CvenebebiT dadgenilia, rom2014 wlis 23 agvistos asrulebdnen samsaxurebriv mova-leobas ... quCaze. am dros daukavSirdaT morige, romel-mac acnoba, rom ... q. #...Si d. C-a iTxovda daxmarebas. daax-loebiT 5 wuTSi mividnen adgilze, ezoSi naxes mamakaci,romelsac tomara hqonda gadakidebuli. pirovnebam maTidanaxvisas gaqceva scada, magram daakaves da Cautares pi-radi Cxreka, ra drosac amoiRes 1 tomara Txili.
5. mowmeebis _ p. j-sa da e. g-s CvenebebiT dadgenilia,rom 2014 wlis 23 agvistos saeqsperto-kriminalistikursamsaxurSi Sesuli Setyobinebis safuZvelze gavidnen Sem-Txvevis adgilze ... quCaze, daaTvalieres ezo, orsarTu-liani saxlis marcxena mxares, kedelTan, naxes ori poli-eTilenis tomara TxiliT, romelsac gadauRes foto, Se-fuTes da daluqes.
6. mowme g. x-m daadastura mis mier gacemuli sasaqonloeqspertizis #... daskvnis siswore, romlis Tanaxmadac, eq-spertizaze wardgenili Txilis Rirebuleba SesaZloa, ga-nisazRvros 559,7 lariT.
liT gaTvaliswinebuli danaSaulis Cadenas. am kodeqsissxvadasxva muxliT gaTvaliswinebuli ori an meti danaSa-uli mxolod maSin CaiTvleba araerTgzis danaSaulad, Tuamis Sesaxeb miTiTebulia am kodeqsis Sesabamis muxlSi.saqarTvelos ssk-is 177-e muxlis SeniSvnis me-2 nawilSimiTiTebulia, rom ssk-is 177-186-e muxlebiT gaTvaliswi-nebuli danaSauli arerTgzisad CaiTvleba, Tu mas win us-wrebda am muxlebiTa da 224-e, 231-e, 237-e da 264-e muxle-biT gaTvaliswinebuli romelime danaSaulis Cadena.msjavrdebuli r. p-a quTaisis saolqo sasamarTlos sis-xlis samarTlis saqmeTa sasamarTlo kolegiis 2002 wlis11 ivnisis ganaCeniT cnobil iqna damnaSaved saqarTvelossisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 78-e muxliT da, imis gaTva-liswinebiT, rom mocemul konkretul SemTxvevaSi kano-niT gaTvaliswinebuli wesiT ar aris dadgenili saqarTve-los ssk-is 78-e muxlis (1960 wlis redaqcia) Sesabamisobamoqmedi sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 224-e muxlTan,msjavrdebul r. p-sTvis aRniSnuli makvalificirebeli ga-remoebis bralad Seracxva moklebulia samarTlebriv sa-fuZvels.
9. sakasacio palata ar iziarebs aseve gasaCivrebul ga-naCens im nawilSi, rom msjavrdebul r. p-s mier CadeniliadamTavrebuli danaSauli, kerZod: palata miuTiTebs, romqurdoba damTavrebulad iTvleba im momentidan, rode-sac damnaSave daeufleba sxvis qonebas da realuri SesaZ-lebloba aqvs, gankargos igi Tavisi Sexedulebisamebr, mi-uxedavad imisa, moaxerxa/moaxdina Tu ara man am SesaZleb-lobis realizeba. gamokvleuli mtkicebulebebiT udavoddadasturebulia, rom msjavrdebulma r. p-m d. C-s sacxov-rebeli saxlidan gamoitana 3 tomara Txili, 2 saxlis ke-delTan miayuda, xolo erTi mxarze hqonda gadakidebu-li; swored aseT viTarebaSi _ sxvisi qonebis farulad da-uflebis procesSi _ d. C-s sacxovrebeli saxlis ezoSi da-akaves igi samarTaldamcvelebma, ris gamoc palatas miaC-nia, rom r. p-s mier Cadenilia danaSaulis mcdeloba, vina-idan man ver moaxerxa danaSaulebrivi qmedebis bolomdemiyvana.
10. msjavrdebul r. p-s advokatis _ x. T-s mosazrebas,rom msjavrdebuli r. p-a SemTxvevis adgilze policiis Ta-namSromlebma miaTries, umowyalod scemes da awames _ sa-kasacio palata ver gaiziarebs, vinaidan 2014 wlis 23 ag-
67
vistos dakavebulis garegnuli daTvalirebis oqmiT ir-kveva, rom Catarda r. p-s garegnuli daTvaliereba: mas mar-jvena xelze, mtevnis areSi aReniSneboda Wriloba, mar-cxena mxares safeTqlis are hqonda Calurjebuli da Se-wiTlebuli, muclis areSi _ nakawrebi, xolo marcxena xe-lis cera TiTze _ Wriloba, aRniSnulze r. p-m ganmarta,rom dazianebebi miiRo dakavebamde; klinikuri saavadmyo-fo „respublikidan~ 2014 wlis 25 agvistos gacemuli same-dicino dokumentaciiT (forma IV-100/a registraciis #…)irkveva, rom r.p-s Cautarda Tavis tvinis kvleva, Tavistvinis travmuli dazianeba da qalas Sida hipertenzia argamovlinda, qalas sarqvelis dazianeba ar aReniSneba, mwva-ve neiroqirurgiuli paTologia ar aReniSneba, staciona-ruli mkurnalobis aucilebloba ar aris; klinikuri saa-vadmyofo „respublikidan~ 2014 wlis 25 agvistos gacemu-li samedicino dokumentaciiT (forma IV-100/a registra-ciis #...) irkveva, rom r. p-s daesva diagnozi _ anayvlefiWriloba marjvena mtevnis areSi, Tavis tvinis daxurulitravma, pacientma stacionarul mkurnalobasa da rentge-nologiur gamokvlevaze ganacxada uari. palata aseve yu-radRebas miapyrobs mowmeebis _ m. k-s, v. C-s, m. g-sa da j. z-s Cvenebebs, romelTa ganmartebiTac, dakavebul r. p-s ce-mis an cudad mopyrobis Taobaze aranairi pretenzia argamouTqvams.
11. rac Seexeba kasatoris miTiTebas saqmeSi arsebulsaproceso darRvevebze, palata aRniSnavs, rom saqmis ma-salebis Seswavlisa da gaanalizebis Sedegad raime arse-biTi xasiaTis saproceso darRveva ar gamovlenila. sasa-marTlo srulad iziarebs saapelacio sasamarTlos Sefa-sebas mowmeebis _ n. o-s, s. a-s, p. b-s, n. l-sa da n. k-s Cvene-bebis arasarwmunoobis Sesaxeb, maT Soris arsebuli arse-biTi xasiaTis winaaRmdegobebis gamo.
12. usafuZvloa aseve kasatoris pozicia, rom saapela-cio sasamarTlos r. p-saTvis zugdidis raionuli sasamar-Tlos 2008 wlis 22 oqtombris ganaCeniT daniSnuli dama-tebiTi sasjeli _ 5000 lari jarima „amnistiis Sesaxeb~ 2012wlis 28 dekembris saqarTvelos kanonis safuZvelze un-da moexsna da ar unda daematebina bolo ganaCeniT daniS-nuli sasjelisaTvis, vinaidan „amnistiis Sesaxeb~ 2012 wlis28 dekembris saqarTvelos kanonis me-18 da me-20 muxle-bis Tanaxmad, kanonis moqmedeba ar vrceldeba sasjelis
68
saxiT Sefardebul/aRsrulebul jarimaze.13. rac Seexeba sasjels, sakasacio palata aRniSnavs,
rom miuxedavad braldebis moculobis Semcirebisa, pala-ta kanonismierad moklebulia SesaZleblobas, Seumsubu-qos r. p-s Tavisuflebis aRkveTis saxiT daniSnuli 5 weli,vinaidan, saqmis masalebiT irkveva, rom r. p-a nasamarTle-via ganzraxi danaSaulebis CadenisTvis (ssk-is 118-e, 236-eda 353-e mux.), ris gamoc saqarTvelos ssk-is 58-e muxlis1-li nawilis moTxovnebidan gamomdinare, mas sasjelis sa-xiT unda ganesazRvros Sesabamisi muxlis sanqciis minima-lur zRvarze sul mcire 1 wliT meti; aRniSnulidan ga-momdinare, imis gaTvaliswinebiT, rom saqarTvelos ssk-is 19,177-e muxlis me-3 nawilis „g~ qvepunqtis sanqciis qve-da zRvari 4 wliT Tavisuflebis aRkveTaa, r. p-sTvis gan-sazRvruli sasjelis _ 5 wliT Tavisuflebis aRkveTisSemcireba kanonSeusabamo iqneba.
m. oSxareli (Tavmjdomare),p. silagaZe,g. SavliaSvili
zepiri mosmenis gareSe ganixila msjavrdebul g. g-a damisi interesebis damcvelis, advokat m. n-s, msjavrdebuld. q-s interesebis damcvelis, advokat a. C-s, msjavrde-bul l. C-a da misi interesebis damcvelis, advokat l. a-s,msjavrdebul a. u-s interesebis damcvelis, advokat l. a-s, msjavrdebul g. q-s interesebis damcvelis, advokat s.j-s, msjavrdebul v. b-s, msjavrdebul T. k-s interesebisdamcveli advokatebis _ k. b-a da l. x-s, msjavrdebul g. q-s, msjavrdebul d. q-s interesebis damcvelis, advokat d.s-s sakasacio saCivrebi quTaisis saapelacio sasamarTlossisxlis samarTlis saqmeTa palatis 2015 wlis 17 agvistosganaCenze.
aRwerilobiTi nawili:1. braldebis Sesaxeb dadgenilebis mixedviT: T. k-a aris
qurduli samyaros wevri, romelic aRiarebs qurdul sam-yaros, moqmedebs maT mier dadgenili specialuri wesebisSesabamisad da iCens aqtiurobas qurduli samyaros miz-nebis gansaxorcieleblad; g. q-a aris qurduli samyaroswevri, romelic aRiarebs qurdul samyaros, moqmedebs maTmier dadgenili specialuri wesebis Sesabamisad da iCensaqtiurobas misi miznebis gansaxorcieleblad. g. q-m da-udgenel dros ukanonod SeiZina narkotikuli saSualeba`heroini~ _ 0,034 gramis odenobiT, rasac aseve ukanonodinaxavda marcxena fexze Cacmul windaSi, 2014 wlis 10 seq-tembramde. v. b-a aris qurduli samyaros wevri, romelic
70
aRiarebs qurdul samyaros, moqmedebs maT mier dadgeni-li specialuri wesebis Sesabamisad da iCens aqtiurobasmisi miznebis gansaxorcieleblad. v. b-m daudgenel drosukanonod SeiZina narkotikuli saSualeba `heroini~ _0,0569 gramis odenobiT, rasac aseve ukanonod inaxavdaSarvlis wina marjvena jibeSi, 2014 wlis 10 seqtembramde.l. C-i aris qurduli samyaros wevri, romelic aRiarebsqurdul samyaros, moqmedebs maT mier dadgenili specia-luri wesebis Sesabamisad da iCens aqtiurobas qurdulisamyaros miznebis gansaxorcieleblad. l. C-a daudgeneldros ukanonod SeiZina narkotikuli saSualeba `heroini~_ 0,035 gramis odenobiT, rasac aseve ukanonod inaxavdaSarvlis wina marjvena jibeSi da narkotikuli saSualebagamomSrali `marixuana~ _ 13,085 gramis odenobiT, rasacaseve ukanonod inaxavda sacxovrebeli saxlis saZinebeloTaxSi mdgari sawolis leibis qveS, 2014 wlis 10 seqtem-bramde. g. k-a aris qurduli samyaros wevri, romelic aRi-arebs qurdul samyaros, moqmedebs maT mier dadgenilispecialuri wesebis Sesabamisad da iCens aqtiurobas qur-duli samyaros miznebis gansaxorcieleblad. g. k-m daud-genel dros ukanonod SeiZina narkotikuli saSualeba `he-roini~ _ 0,056 gramis odenobiT, rasac aseve ukanonod ina-xavda Sarvlis wina marjvena jibeSi, 2014 wlis 10 seqtem-bramde. g. q-a aris qurduli samyaros wevri, romelic aRi-arebs qurdul samyaros, moqmedebs maT mier dadgenilispecialuri wesebis Sesabamisad da iCens aqtiurobas qur-duli samyaros miznebis gansaxorcieleblad. g. q-m daud-genel dros ukanonod SeiZina cecxlsasroli iaraRi _ qar-xnuli wesiT damzadebuli, 1974 wlis nimuSis, `AK-74~ mo-delis, 5,45mm. kalibriani `kalaSnikovis~ konstruqciis av-tomati, nomeri FF8865 da 1974 wlis nimuSis, 5,45mm. kalib-riani 20 cali vazna, rasac aseve ukanonod inaxavda sac-xovrebeli saxlis meore sarTulze arsebul saZinebeloTaxSi, 2014 wlis 10 seqtembramde. g. g-a aris qurdulisamyaros wevri, romelic aRiarebs qurdul samyaros, moq-medebs maT mier dadgenili specialuri wesebis Sesabami-sad da iCens aqtiurobas qurduli samyaros miznebis gan-saxorcieleblad. g. g-m daudgenel dros ukanonod SeiZi-na narkotikuli saSualeba gamomSrali `marixuana~ _ 171,19gramis odenobiT, rasac aseve ukanonod inaxavda sacxov-rebeli saxlis saZinebel oTaxSi mdgari sawolis baliSis
52. nivTieri mtkicebulebebi: msjavrdebulebis kuT-vnili mobiluri telefonebi, simbaraTebi, kompiuterisprocesori, portatuli kompiuterebi (e.w. `nouTbuqebi~),ID baraTi, ID baraTis asli, sasignalo pistoleti _ saqme-ze saboloo gadawyvetilebis miRebis Semdeg unda daub-rundes maTi mesakuTreebis ndobiT aRWurvil pirebs; la-zeruli, CD da DVD diskebi unda daerTos sisxlis samar-Tlis saqmes, misi saqmis Senaxvis vadiT; Cxrekis SedegadamoRebuli cecxlsasroli iaraRebi da vaznebi saqmeze sa-boloo gadawyvetilebis miRebis Semdeg unda gadaegzav-nos saqarTvelos Sinagan saqmeTa saministros Sesabamissamsaxurs, maTi Semdgomi gankargvis mizniT; xolo Cxre-kis Sedegad amoRebuli narkotikuli saSualebebi saqme-ze saboloo gadawyvetilebis miRebis Semdeg unda ganad-gurdes kanoniT dadgenili wesiT.
53. msjavrdebuli g. g-a da misi interesebis damcveli,advokati m. n-a sakasacio saCivriT iTxoven quTaisis saa-pelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saqmeTa palatis2015 wlis 17 agvistos ganaCenis gauqmebasa da g. g-s gamar-Tlebas.
54. msjavrdebul d. q-s interesebis damcveli, advoka-ti a. C-i sakasacio saCivriT iTxovs quTaisis saapelaciosasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saqmeTa palatis 2015 wlis17 agvistos ganaCenis gauqmebasa da d. q-s gamarTlebas.
55. msjavrdebuli l. C-i da misi interesebis damcveli,advokati l. a-a sakasacio saCivriT iTxoven quTaisis saa-pelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saqmeTa palatis2015 wlis 17 agvistos ganaCenis gauqmebasa da l. C-s gamar-Tlebas.
56. msjavrdebul a. u-s interesebis damcveli, advoka-ti l. a-a sakasacio saCivriT iTxovs quTaisis saapelaciosasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saqmeTa palatis 2015 wlis17 agvistos ganaCenis gauqmebasa da a. u-s gamarTlebas.
57. msjavrdebul g. q-s interesebis damcveli, advoka-ti s. j-a sakasacio saCivriT iTxovs quTaisis saapelaciosasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saqmeTa palatis 2015 wlis17 agvistos ganaCenis gauqmebasa da g. q-s gamarTlebas.
ma sakasacio saCivrebis safuZvlianoba da mivida im das-kvnamde, rom sakasacio saCivrebi ar unda dakmayofildes,xolo gasaCivrebul ganaCenSi unda Sevides cvlileba Sem-deg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. sakasacio palata srulad iziarebs saapelacio sasa-marTlos argumentebs msjavrdebulebis _ T. k-s, g. q-s, v.b-a da l. C-s qurduli samyaros wevrobis Taobaze da miaC-nia, rom kanonis moTxovnaTa sruli dacviT, srulyofi-lad da obieqturad gamokvleul, urTierTSejerebul dasakmaris mtkicebulebaTa erTobliobiT dasturdeba maTmier saqarTvelos ssk-is 2231-e muxlis 1-li nawiliT gaT-valiswinebuli danaSaulis Cadena, kerZod:
lobas. Semosuli informaciebi exeboda yvela bralde-buls. qurdul samyarosTan maTi kavSirebi dadasturebu-li iyo satelefono saubrebiTa da faruli miyuradebiT.krebsebSi aSkarad iyo saubari adamianebis daSinebaze, fu-lis gamoZalvasa da sxvadasxva danaSaulis niSnebze. am sa-ubrebSi qurdul samyarosTan kavSiri gamoixateboda sa-erTo fulis SegrovebaSi, Tanxis gamoZalvaSi. saubrebSisaxeldebodnen kanonieri qurdebi. pirveli informaciamiiRo daaxloebiT 3-4 TviT adre, vidre braldebulebsdaakavebdnen. am periodSi xdeboda informaciis gadamow-meba, Seswavla da dadgena. gadamowmebis Sedegad damtkic-da is, rac weria patakSi _ fulis gamoZalvis faqti. TiT-qmis yvela braldebulze dadasturda informacia. pira-dad man ki daadastura informacia v. b-a da T. k-e. saxel-deboda gamoZaluli Tanxa _ 2000, 500, 600 laris odeno-biT, rasac adasturebdnen pirovnebebi, vinc awvdida in-formacias piradi saubris dros. bolo patakSi saubariauSualod im danaSaulze, romlis Cadenasac braldebule-bi apirebdnen meore dRes da saWiroebda gadaudebel Ro-nisZiebebs, ris gamoc mimarTa s-s samxareo sammarTvelosxelmZRvanelobas da daiwyo gamoZieba. gasatarebeli Ro-nisZiebebi dagegma uSualod sammarTvelos ufrosma.
4. mowme z. l-s mier micemuli CvenebiT dadgenilia, romSemosuli iyo informacia, rom T. k-a danaSaulebriv kav-SirSi imyofeboda g. q-n, rac gamoixateboda imaSi, rom isi-ni zewolas axdendnen moqalaqeebze, sZalavdnen maT fulsda s-i marTavdnen qurdul garCevebs sazRvargareT myo-fi qurdebis davalebiT. misive ganmartebiT, yvela wyaro-dan momdinare informacia erTiandeboda mis patakebSi.xelmZRvanelobisTvis miwodebuli aqvs 5 pataki, radganinformaciebi Semodioda etapobrivad. patakis miwodebisSemdeg xelmZRvanelobidan iRebda davalebas, rom daed-gina, Seeswavla da Seemowmebina informaciebi. uSualodman Seamowma ori informacia v. b-a da T. k-e, danarCenebssxvebi ikvlevdnen. krebsebiT daadgina, rom adgili hqon-da fulis gamoZalvas da saerTo fulis Segrovebas. kon-fidentma daasaxela is pirebi, romlebic dazaraldnen sa-varaudo damnaSaveebisgan. aRniSnuli pirebi sxvadasxvaraionSi cxovrobdnen, magram yvela maTganma kategoriu-li uari ganacxada gamoZiebasTan TanamSromlobaze.
5. mowme p. l-s mier micemuli CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom
83
s-s samxareo mTavari sammarTvelos s-s Ss raionuli sam-marTvelos deteqtivis TanaSemwe-gamomZieblis Tanamde-bobaze muSaobis periodSi mas hqonda operatiuli infor-macia imis Taobaze, rom q. s-i mcxovrebi T. k-a da g. q-a mo-nawileobdnen qurdul garCevebSi. aRniSnuli faqtebi ga-damowmda operatiulad, sxvadasxva wyaros meSveobiT, risSedegadac dadasturda piradi kontaqtisgan miRebuli in-formacia. misive ganmartebiT, T. k-s da g. q-s kavSirebihqondaT kanonier qurd `W-n~, romlisganac iRebdnen da-valebebs. mowme p. l-s CvenebiT, 2014 wlis 11 seqtembersmiiRo davaleba, rom Sss s-s samxareo mTavar sammarTve-loSi qurduli samyaros wevrobis faqtze aRZrul sisxlissamarTlis saqmeze unda daekavebinaT T. k-a. aRniSnulTandakavSirebiT sammarTveloSi moewyo operatiuli TaTbi-ri da sammarTvelos ufrosis davalebiT Seiqmna 3-kacianijgufi _ misi, i. g-s da g. n-s SemadgenlobiT, romlebic ga-vidnen davalebis Sesasruleblad. q. s-i, v-s quCaze, Se-niSnes fexiT mimavali T. k-a da daakaves igi. gamomZiebel-ma T. k-s ganumarta uflebebi, ris Semdegac mas Cautardapiradi Cxreka, ra drosac raime kanonsawinaaRmdego nivTiar amoRebula. sagamoZiebo moqmedebis oqmi Seadgina i. g-m, romelzec T. k-m xeli ar moawera.
6. mowmis saxiT dakiTxuli s-s samxareo mTavari sammar-Tvelos s-s Ss raionuli sammarTvelos ubnis inspeqtor-gamomZieblis, i. x-s mier micemuli CvenebiT dadgenilia,rom 2011 wlis 8 dekembridan 2014 wlamde muSaobda Sss s-s Ss raionul sammarTveloSi ubnis inspeqtor-gamomZieb-lad. misi samuSao ubani iyo qalaqis centri, sadac cxov-robs ramdenjerme nasamarTlevi T. k-a, romelic mis xelTarsebuli informaciiT, iyo qurduli tradiciebis mata-rebeli. igi monawileobda qurdul garCevebSi da kavSirihqonda sazRvargareT da saqarTveloSi mcxovreb kanoni-er qurdebTan. aRniSnuli informacia man miiRo piradi wya-roebidan da Seatyobina xelmZRvanelobas, Seadgina sai-dumlo pataki da moaxsena zepirad, Semdeg ki misca Cvene-ba.
7. mowme d. m-s mier micemuli CvenebiT dadgenilia, rommuSaobda s-s samxareo mTavari sammarTvelos s-s Ss raio-nuli sammarTvelos ubnis inspeqtor-gamomZiebelad. missamoqmedo teritoriaze cxovrobda warsulSi ramden-jerme nasamarTlevi g. q-a, romelic aris qurduli menta-
84
litetis mqone piri da mas kavSiri hqonda kriminaluri sam-yaros warmomadgenlebTan, ris Taobazec informacias aw-vdida saidumlo piri.
8. mowmis saxiT dakiTxuli s-s samxareo mTavari sammar-Tvelos s-s Ss raionuli sammarTvelos TanamSromlis _ m.j-s mier micemuli CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom arsebobdaoperatiuli informaciebi g. q-s qurduli samyaros wev-robis Taobaze.
9. mowme d. o-s mier micemuli CvenebiT dadgenilia, rommuSaobda Sss s-s samxareo mTavari sammarTvelos s-s Ssraionul sammarTveloSi da icnobda g. q-s, icoda misi cxov-rebis wesi da warsuli. Sesabamisad, masac hqonda infor-macia g. q-s qurduli samyaros wevrobis Taobaze.
10. mowme i. c-s mier micemuli CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom2005 wlidan muSaobs s-s samxareo mTavari sammarTvelosw-s Ss raionuli sammarTvelos j-s policiis ganyofile-baSi da icnobs v. b-s, romelic aris qurduli samyaros mim-devari. igi monawileobda araerT qurdul Sekrebasa dagarCevaSi. operatiuli informaciis mixedviT, v. b-a kano-nieri qurdis, r. u-s miTiTebiTa da davalebiT axorcie-lebda qurduli samyaros mimdevrobas da awyobda Sekre-bebs, sadac xdeboda qurduli garCevebi. mowmis ganmar-tebiT, es ar iyo erT pirze dafuZnebuli informacia, ara-med aRniSnuli informacia miRebuli hqonda mravali wya-rodan. erT-erTi aseTi Sekrebis dros gadaamowma da Tvi-Tonac naxa, rom Sekrebil pirTa Soris iyo v. b-a. amdenad,operatiuli informacia aRmoCnda swori.
11. mowme m. q-s mier micemuli CvenebiT dadgenilia, romigi muSaobda s-s samxareo mTavari sammarTvelos w-s Ss ra-ionuli sammarTvelos j-s policiis ganyofilebis ufro-sad, erTi periodi iyo operatiuli samsaxuris ufrosi. imperiodSi iyvnen pirebi, romlebic operatiulad sainte-resoni iyvnen da maT mimarT xorcieldeboda operatiulisaqmianoba. daba j-i v. b-a iyo `kanonieri qurdis~ _ r. u-smier daniSnuli „mayurebeli~ da cxovrobda qurduli sam-yaros wesiT. amis Taobaze arsebobda operatiuli infor-maciebi, romlebic miewodeboda xelmZRvanelobas. mowmem. q-s CvenebiT, daaxloebiT 1 wlis win, sofel W-i, r. u-ssasaflaoze iyo garCeva, romelsac eswreboda misi konfi-denti. garCeva Seexeboda imas, Tu visTan unda misuliy-vnen da visTvis unda waerTmiaT e.w. „saerTos~ fuli. gar-
85
Cevas eswreboda daaxloebiT aTamde piri, v. b-a aZlevdadavalebebs sxvebs. es yvelaferi xdeboda mis dakavebam-de 5 TviT adre. mayurebeli unda misuliyo erT-erT sa-warmoSi da unda moeTxova fuli. unda misuliyvnen engur-hesSi direqtorTan da saamqroebSi, romlebic j-i funqci-onirebs.
12. mowme l. g-s mier micemuli CvenebiT dadgenilia, rommuSaobs s-s samxareo mTavari sammarTvelos w-s Ss raio-nuli sammarTvelos j-s policiis ganyofilebis ubnis in-speqtor-gamomZieblis Tanamdebobaze. mas gaaCnda infor-macia, rom daba j-i mcxovreb e.w. `mayurebels~ _ v. b-s ur-TierToba hqonda sazRvargareT myof kriminalur avto-ritetTan, kanonier qurd r. u-n da misgan iRebda davale-bebs. qurduli gavlenis gaZlierebisa da qurduli xazi-nis Segrovebis mizniT is awyobda qurdul garCevebs. in-formacias imis Sesaxeb, rom v. b-a eweoda qurduli samya-ros wevrobas, 2 Tvis ganmavlobaSi awvdida konfidenti,TviTon ki am informacias saidumlo patakiT awvdida Ta-vis xelmZRvanelobas. 2014 wlis 10 seqtembers samxareomTavar sammarTveloSi Catarda TaTbiri, ra drosac cno-bili gaxda, rom mimdinareobda gamoZieba qurduli samya-ros mimdevrebis mimarT da asayvani iyo v. b-a. am mizniToperatiuli jgufi gaemgzavra q-s raionis sofel w-i, sa-dac daakaves v. b-a.
13. mowmis saxiT dakiTxuli Sss s-s samxareo mTavarisammarTvelos ubnis inspeqtor-gamomZiebelis _ z. q-s mi-er micemuli CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom mas hqonda infor-macia, rom l. C-i iyo qurduli samyaros aqtiuri wevri, ro-melic CarTuli iyo e.w. ̀ obSiakis~ Segrovebis saqmeSi. axal-gazrdebSi avrcelebda qurduli samyaros mier aRiarebulwesebs, aqezebda maT da keTilad ganawyobda qurduli sam-yaros mimarT. axalgazrdebi masTan ikribebodnen, agro-vebdnen fuls, apirebdnen iaraRis mobilizebas.
14. mowme g. p-s mier micemuli CvenebiT dadgenilia, rommuSaobs s-s samxareo mTavar sammarTveloSi ubnis inspeq-tor-gamomZieblis Tanamdebobaze da icnobs l. C-s, rom-lis Taobazec hqonda informacia, rom igi iyo qurdulisamyaros wevri da urTierToba hqonda sazRvargareT myofkanonier qurdebTan.
15. mowme m. b-s mier micemuli CvenebiT dadgenilia, rommuSaobda Sss s-s samxareo mTavari sammarTvelos z-s Ss
86
raionul sammarTveloSi ubnis inspeqtor-gamomZieblisTanamdebobaze da asrulebda samsaxurebriv movaleobasTavis samoqmedo teritoriaze, kerZod, faifuris dasax-lebaSi da mis mimdebare teritoriaze. awarmoebdnen ub-nis mosaxleobis aRweras da ubnis pasportSi Setanas. gan-sakuTrebul aRricxvaze hyavdaT nasamarTlevi pirebi daqurduli tradiciis matarebeli xalxi. misive CvenebiT,mas piradi kontaqtisgan, romelic icnobs l. C-s, hqondainformacia l. C-s qurduli samyaros wevrobis Taobaze,rom is kriminaluri avtoritetis davalebiT, qurduli„saerTos~ Segrovebis mizniT awyobda garCevebs.
16. #... fonogramiT dadgenilia, rom T. k-a g. q-s tele-fonidan esaubreba Tavisuflebis aRkveTis dawesebule-baSi moTavsebul b-s da eubneba, rom cxovrobs kai biWiscxovrebiT da ideologiiT, rom Tu gawires, samjer arisnamyofi cixeSi da meoTxedac wava, magram mainc gamova iqi-dan da sanam aris, s-s saxe unda misces, s-n mainc raRacarom gadiodes. yvela qalaqidan gadis `racxa~. aqve Tana-mosaubres awerinebs Tavisi telefonis nomers _ ..... sau-barSi T. k-a ambobs: `sanam ager var, ager var da Tu iqaneviqnebi, iqane viqnebi TqvenTan erTad~. b-s imave telefo-niT esaubreba sxva piri, romelsac b-a avalebs, gverdSidaudges T-s, vinaidan T-o misi Zmaa. mosaubre ki eubneba,rom sul T-a. amis Semdeg b-a isev T-s esaubreba, romeliceubneba, rom 150 lars gadmoqaCavs da piradad mas Seug-zavnis yovel kviraSi, razec b-a pasuxobs, rom ganaburaddaadgams magas Tavs. T-o b-s aseve Txovs misTvis mimarTu-lebis micemas da eubneba, rom misi davalebebis Sesasru-leblad maqsimalurad gamova kanidan. b-a davalebas aZ-levs, rom mis gverdSi dgomaze uaris mTqmeli pasiuri ada-mianebi kalapotSi Casvas. T-o pasuxobs, rom sanam gareTaris, yvelafers gaakeTebs da Tu Caketaven, kidev `gaiCi-Teba~ misnairi viRaca, Tan amatebs: ̀ xom ici, mouSleli var,mouSlelia Cveni azrovneba~. amis Semdeg T-o moikiTxavsb-n myof mis Zmebs. b-a pasuxobs, rom misi Zmebi masTan ari-an axla da rom `palaJenecia~ masTan, ris Semdegac T-o pa-suxobs, rom wameba da wvaleba gadaitanes warsulSi yve-lam erTad da momavali awi win aqvT.
17. zemoaRniSnul saubarSi rom swored T. k-s xma fiq-sirdeba, amas adasturebs mis mier dasaxelebuli sakuTa-ri mobiluri telefonis nomeri, romlidan ganxorciele-
87
bul saubrebSic, fonoskopiuri eqspertizis daskvnis Ta-naxmad, figurirebs T. k-s xma, aseve saubarSi misi saxeliTmoxsenieba da g. q-n misi axlo urTierToba, rac dastur-deba saqmeSi arsebuli sxva fonogramebiT da g. q-a da T. k-s CvenebebiT.
18. #... fonogramaSi asaxulia T. k-s kuTvnil telefo-nis nomerze ganxorcielebuli saubrebi, romlebic aseveadasturebs kriminaluri avtoritetis, saxelad `W-s~ da-valebiT b-n g. i-a da e-s yovelgvari laparakis gareSe, pir-dapir `damtvrevis~ davalebis miRebas da davalebis Ses-rulebis dapirebas, am mizniT garkveuli gegmis SemuSave-bas da aqtiuri qmedebis ukve dawyebas, `dviJeniis~ moyva-nas.
19. T. k-s mier qurdul samyaroSi miRebuli wesebis pa-tiviscema ikveTeba #... fonogramidan, sadac igi ambobs,rom 34 welia qurdulSi sisufTave aqvs. imave fonograma-Si acxadebs: `qurduli aris erTi, swori da erTi muWa, yve-la erTad Cven varT magrebi~. iqve b-a ekiTxeba T. k-s, TuSeZlebs e-s `daTrevas~ da uxsnis, rom misi daTreva saWi-roa, radgan `ZmisTvis~ Seuginebia. amis Semdeg T. k-a pasu-xobs, rom roca Sexvdeba, is misi cxovrebis bolo dRe iq-neba, misi cxovrebis Sinaarsidan gamomdinare da `dabri-davs~, razec b-a eubneba, rom `dabredva~ ar aris saWiro,sakmarisia daiWiros da mas daurekos. saubris bolos T. k-a ambobs, rom ZvelbiWurad cxovrobs, radgan jer patim-rebze fiqrobs, maT ugzavnis fuls da mere fiqrobs saku-Tar Tavze.
21. #... fonogramaSi dafiqsirebulia g. q-s saubrebi,romlebiTac dasturdeba, rom igi kargad erkveva qurdu-li samyaros wesebSi, qurdebis istoriebSi, qurdul sam-yaroSi arsebul dapirispirebebSi da maT Sida samzareu-loSi. imave fonogramiT dadgenilia, rom cixis sakanSi pa-timris datovebis konkretuli sakiTxis gadawyvetaSi mo-nawileoba g. q-s sTxoves patimrebma da am mizniT gamoiy-vanes saknidan. iqvea saubari cixeSi g. q-a da `mayurebels~Soris momxdari Selaparakebis Taobaze. amave fonogrami-dan irkveva, rom g. q-a saqmis „kursSia~ qurdobis msurvelromel avtoritetze romel qurds Tu kriminalur avto-
88
ritets aqvs `pretenzia~.22. #... fonograma adasturebs g. q-a da sxva kriminalu-
ri avtoritetebis kavSirs, romelTa wreSic is miRebuliada maTTan erTad sufrasTan zis, eswreba maT saubrebs kon-kretuli Temis garCevaze. magaliTad, is imyofeboda g. k-s, e-s da vinme g-n erTad sufrasTan, sadac saubari iyoavtomanqanis dabrunebis moTxovnasa da misi warTmevis ga-marTlebaze.
23. #... fonogramis Tanaxmad, g. q-a eubneba Tavisufle-bis aRkveTis dawesebulebaSi moTavsebul b-s, rom misgverdSia da T. k-n erTad gaakeTebs rac gasakeTebelia, imi-saTvis, rom cixeSi s-n yovelkvira Sevides Tanxa da qalaq-Si situacia daawyos.
24. #... fonogramis mixedviT, Tavisuflebis aRkveTisdawesebulebidan b-a davalebas aZlevs g. q-s, orive piri`datexon~ ise, rom fexze ver gaiaron. amave saubridan ir-kveva, rom g. q-a aqtiurobas iCens am davalebis Sesasru-leblad, eZebs `dasamtvrev~ pirebs, iRebs informaciebsmaTi adgilsamyoflis Sesaxeb, monawileobs im pirebTanSexvedris organizebaSi, rCevebs aZlevs Sexvedris saRa-mosTvis gadatanis Taobaze da b-s hpirdeba, rom saqmiskursSi Caayenebs movlenebis ganviTarebis Taobaze. b-a g.q-s eubneba: `magi, CaTvale, Cveni yvelas mteria, daJe iqam-de rom ver Cavides, ise unda gaakeTo, gaige?~ da mis dain-validebas Txovs. #... fonogramiT dadgenilia, rom igiveb-a g-s da e-s moZebnis, g-s janmrTelobis dazianebis dava-lebas gascems g. q-s telefonze ganxorcielebuli sate-lefono saubrisas. #... fonograma adasturebs aseve kri-minaluri avtoritetis, saxelad `W-s~ davalebiT, b-n g. i-ada e-s yovelgvari laparakis gareSe, pirdapir `damtvre-vis~ davalebis miRebas da davalebis Sesrulebis dapire-bas, am mizniT garkveuli gegmis SemuSavebas da aqtiuriqmedebis ukve dawyebas. aRniSnul saubrebSi rom g. q-a mo-nawileobs, dasturdeba rogorc fonoskopiuri eqsperti-zis daskvniTa da eqspertebis CvenebebiT, aseve imiT, romsaubris dros mas b-a moixseniebs misi gvaris Semoklebu-li formiT _ `q-i~. amasTan, igi karnaxobs sakuTari tele-fonis nomers _ .... romlidan ganxorcielebul saubrebSig. q-s xmis arseboba aseve dadasturebulia fonoskopiurieqspertizis daskvniT.
25. #.... fonogramiT dadgenilia, rom v. b-a esaubreba l.
89
C-s kuTvnil telefonis nomerze, romelic sTxovs sasaf-laoze misvlas, radgan fulis Taobaze aqvs saubari. v-ipasuxobs, rom mivida da sasaflaozea isic. mosaubre te-lefons miRma ambobs: `v-a b-a qurdi kacia~. aRniSnuli fo-nogramidan irkveva, rom v. b-s sTxoven qurdul garCevaSimonawileobas.
26. #.... fonogramaSi v. b-a ambobs, rom qurdulad arisda rom kiTxva, Tu rogor aris, esec ki ukve pretenziaamisTvis, rac miuTiTebs v. b-s mier qurduli samyaros we-sebis pativiscemasa da aRiarebaze.
27. #.... fonogramiT dadgenilia, rom Tanamosaubre v.b-s sTxovs fulis `dviJeniasTan~ dakavSirebiT saqmis qur-dul garCevas `j-s~ sasaflaoze, razec v. b-a pasuxobs: `ex-la ver mival~, Tumca sabolood Tanxmdebian, rom moaxer-xeben rames. aqve v. b-a mosaubres acnobs sxva garCevis de-talebs, rom saerTo nacnobs man dartymis neba misca, Tum-ca man ar daartya da `gauTvaliswina~.
28. #... fonogramidan irkveva, rom v. b-s urekaven imisgasarkvevad, ramdenad Seesabameba konkretuli piris qme-deba maT mier aRiarebul wesebs da ekiTxebian rCevas, ro-gor moeqcnen mas.
29. #... fonogramidan irkveva, rom v. b-s saubari aqvsrusi erovnebis qurdTan, romelic sTxovs mas misi mego-bari qurdis gverdSi dgomas da hpirdeba, rom awi yvela-feri iqneba. v. b-a gamoTqvams maTTan yofnis survils.
30. #... fonogramidan irkveva, rom v. b-a eswreboda vin-me m-s Temaze arsebul araerT qurdul garCevas, sadac sa-ubari iyo Tanxis motanaze.
31. #... fonogramaSi saubaria konkretuli saqmis qur-dulad garCevaze. iqve mosaubre qurdul samyaroSi win-svlas uwinaswarmetyvelebs v. b-s da eubneba: `Sen male mo-giwevs iqiT wasvla. erTi `dviJenia~, erTi saqmis mogvarebada iq iqnebi Senc, didi xani ar gWirdeba, damSviddeba j-isamudamod~. v. b-a pasuxobs, rom amas didi xania, elodeba.mosaubre agrZelebs: `Sens mere vin iqneba j-i Sennairi, ma-gaze Tu gifiqria?~ v. b-a axsenebs vinme g-s. mosaubre pasu-xobs: `magic magari saqmis gadamwyvetia da mere yvelaferierTad rom ar daiSalos, magic safiqralia~. v. b-a eTanxme-ba da ambobs, rom didi xnis nawvalebi ar unda daiSalos.iqve gamoTqvams survils garkveuli piris mimarT: `moaTa-vebdes qe mainc, moaTavebdes~, razec mosaubre pasuxobs:
90
`moaTavebs biWo magi, TviTonac iseTi xasiaTis aris. exlacmoaTavebs magi uceb. rom ityvis vsio, me is var, vinc... mor-Ceba mand bazari. aris iq raRac niuansebi, situaciebi,wvrilmanebi, magram magis mere j-i is xom ar aris, xelwamo-sakravi.~
32. #... fonogramaSi asaxulia, v. b-s rogor sTxoven saq-mis qurdulad garCevas, ris pasuxadac v. b-a iTxovs saub-ris dawyebiT dainteresebul pirebTan dalaparakebas dahpirdeba, rom amis mere daibarebs xalxs da daadgams Tavsyvelafers.
33. #... fonogramidan irkveva, rom v. b-a qurduli sam-yaros wevrebs icnobs da maTTan kontaqtebi aqvs. am saub-rebSi v. b-a mosaubres sTxovs g-i karcerSi moTavsebulipiris interesebis dasacavad g-s `mayureblis~ telefo-nis nomris gagebas.
34. #... fonogramaSi asaxulia v. b-n saubari w-s dabare-bis da sasaflaoze saqmis garCevis Taobaze.
35. #... fonogramaSi r-i ekiTxeba v. b-s: `iq raRac qur-duli rom gaqvs, is ratom ar migaqvs adgilze, sadac dasa-debia?~, razec v. b-a pasuxobs: `ki, magi adgilzea, kaco~.amave saubrebSi r-i eubneba v. b-s, rom `ZaRlebi~ da saswa-uli ambavi yofila, ris gamoc urCevs, wavides da daima-los.
36. #... fonogramidan irkveva, rom v. b-a acnobebs mosa-ubres, rom maT saerTo ZmasTan kargi ambavia, kerZod man`daamTavra laparaki~, rasac ulocaven. mosaubre v. b-susurvebs, misTvisac male mielocos igive.
37. #... fonogramiT dadgenilia, rom v. b-a esaubrebapirovnebas, romelsac amcnobs, rom r-s kargi ambavi Seem-Txva, kerZod, `Cajda CeqmaSi~, rasac ulocaven. #... fo-nogramaSi grZeldeba saubari imave Temaze, kerZod, v. b-amosaubres eubneba, rom r-s ambavi marTalia, rom 2 kacsgaukeTes, meoremac moagvara, misma Zmam, i. j-m, romelsacskaipiT elaparaka wina RamiT. v. b-a ambobs: `j-i ar iyo er-Ti saxeliani, yvela j-s Cagravda, rac dasruldeba awi~.
38. #... fonogramiT dadgenilia, rom r-i esaubreba v. b-s da aZlevs davalebas d. z-s povnis Taobaze, xolo v. b-a r-s naTqvams gadascems o-s da eubneba misi saxeliT, Tu ragaakeTos. kerZod: `karoCe, Cvenma Zmam r-m, bozi ariso. az-rze xom xar ra unda qna?.. Tan manqanac hyolia, mokled,waarTviT ra~. imave Temas exeba #... fonograma, romlis mi-
91
xedviTac v. b-a o-s eubneba, rom d. z-a pirdapir j-i wamo-iyvanos da iq scemon erTad, 20000 $ hqonia mosatanio. #...,#... da #... fonogramebidan irkveva, rom v. b-a o-s eubneba,rom d-o unda Semoityuon da r-s saxeli jer ar uxsenos.#... fonogramaSi asaxulia, rom v. b-a saqmis kursSi ayenebsr-s d. z-s Sesaxeb misi davalebis Sesasruleblad gadace-mis Taobaze. d. z-s Sesaxeb davalebis Sesasruleblad misivinaobisa da misamarTis dazustebazea saubari #... fonog-ramaSi, sadac v. b-a azustebs, rom is cixeSi ijda da misiazriT, ~saxelze fiqrobda~.
39. #... fonogramis mixedviT, v-i esaubreba pirovnebasr-s davalebaze, m-n arsebuli problemis mogvarebamdeTanxis Segrovebis SeCerebis Sesaxeb. rogorc saubridanirkveva, r-i davalebas aZlevs, rac m-s aqvT micemuli, imodenobis Tanxa iSovon da Tan hqondeT, aseve Tan hqon-deT qaRaldebi da Tu m-i `atkazze wava~, mere TviTon mi-xedavs yvelafers. #... fonogramis Tanaxmad, grZeldebaimave Temaze saubari, sadac v. b-s eubnebian r-s danaba-rebs, rom Tu Zmakacebi arian, erTad gaakeTon ise, rogorcsaWiroa. amis mere v. b-a uxsnis, Tu ra gaakeTos, rom Camo-weros isini, vinc mas fuli misca. aqve afrTxilebs, rom esTamaSi ar aris da rom aravin ar unda icodes, rom aravis aruTxras, alal Zmasac ki, Camoweros es yvelaferi da Tvi-Ton daexmareba romel TveSi ra rogor gaakeTos. mosaub-re eubneba, rom telefoniT ar unda amaze saubari, razecpasuxobs, rom vin ra icis, razea saubari, iqneb sulac or-mocis Tanxazea laparaki. mosaubre eubneba _ ho, sworedim ormocze Caweril Tanxaze geubnebi, vin ra icis razevsaubrobTo. Semdeg mosaubre eubneba, rom g-s `mayurebe-li~ dainteresebula amiT. v. b-a ambobs, rom g-s `mayurebe-li~ misi Zmakacia da misi nomeri misces, is daelaparakeba.imave Temaze grZeldeba saubari #... fonogramaSi, sadacorive mosaubre, maT Soris, v. b-a gamoxataven SeSfoTebasimis Taobaze, rom viRaca cdilobs pasuxi mosTxovos v-smaSin, roca qurdebi ar sTxoven mas pasuxs. am saubrebSiaris aseve cemisken mowodebac: `ceme ra magas vinc get-yvis, pirdapir ceme, nu elodebi. qurdi ar mismevs SekiT-xvebs da Tqven vin xarT-Tqo~.
40. #... fonogramaSi asaxulia qurdad axlad monaTlu-li pirebis Sesaxeb saubari. v. b-a eubneba r-s cixis `mayu-rebels~, rom m. j-m, m-s Svilma, i. j-m da r-a erTad `daas-
92
rules saubari~, rom i-a da r-i misi Zmebi arian da rom r-isul urekavs skaipiT. iqve v. b-a gamokiTxavs mosaubres sxvacixeebis `mayureblebis~ vinaobas. r-s cixis `mayurebeli~urCevs, droze wavides warmatebulad, xolo axalgazrdabiWebi daaxasiaTos da datovos, razec v. b-a pasuxobs, romgareTac magari Zebna unda iseTis povnas, vinc sistemaswauZRveba.
41. #... fonogramis Tanaxmad, l. C-i saxeliTa da gvariTecnoba mosaubres da mimdinareobs Semdegi saubari: `kaibiWebs veranairi dro ver Seexeba~, `axla cota svabodagvaqvs~, `erTmaneTs unda vicnobdeT~, `iseTi `krugi~ gava-keToT, rom Cveni eSinodes xalxs~, `erTad unda viyoT, er-Ti saZmo varT~. imave fonogramiT irkveva, rom l. C-s saq-mis garCeva hqonda daniSnuli garkveul pirebTan da mivi-da kidec SeTanxmebul adgilas, Tumca meore mxaris war-momadgenlebi ar mividnen. am garCevaze unda momxdariyomaTi damtvreva, Tumca l. C-i ambobs, rom misTvis daure-kia Zmakacs _ l-s da mouTxovia, ar daemtvriaT da mxolod`daeyenebinaT~.
42. #... fonogramiT dadgenilia, rom l. C-i esaubreba v.b-s da eubneba: `gasalaxad aayenes kaci da ar davartymevi-ne. Cemi laparaki iyo, me mexeboda. im kacs velaparake, iseki ara, xelis dartymiT da imiTi, Cemi Zmuri davanaxe. Senes gekuTvnoda, magram me mainc ar vikadre-Tqo es da krun-CxvebSi Cavarda nerviulobis fonze... yvelas erTnairadar unda mosTxovo. isic unda icode, vis ramdeni esmis...~ v.b-a l. C-s eubneba: `amas iTxovs Cveni qurduli~, rasac l. C-i udasturebs. amis Semdeg saubari Seexeba `kai biWebis~ da-yofas `komersant kai biWebad~ da `arakomersant kai biWe-bad~.
43. #... fonogramiT dadgenilia, rom v. b-a esaubreba l.C-s nomerze pirovnebas, romelic eubneba, rom sasaflao-zea, fulis ambavze laparaki aqvs da sTxovs sasaflaozemisvlas. saubari rom l. C-s telefonis nomerze mimdina-reobs, dadasturebulia Sps `m-s~ Sesabamisi samsaxuridanmiRebuli informaciiT. amasTan, amave telefonis nomri-dan ganxorcielebul sxva saubrebze fonoskopiuri eq-spertizis daskvnis Tanaxmad, aRbeWdilia l. C-s xma.
44. #... fonogramiT dadgenilia, rom l. C-s telefoni-dan ganxorcielebulia zari v. b-n, ra drosac v. b-s eubne-ba, rom d. g-a darekavs `am ambebis guliza~, mis `dviJenia-
93
ze~, rom masTan salaparako aqvs da mere masac Caayenebssaqmis kursSi. imave Temaze grZeldeba saubari #... fonog-ramaSi, sadac l. C-s telefonis nomerze rekavs v. b-a da l-s ekiTxeba d-n saubris Sedegs. l-a uxsnis, rom jer ar usa-ubria, rom gaerkveva yvelaferSi da gaagebinebs. l-a aseveeubneba, rom p-a W-a, k-a, o-e arian masTan, rom `ori kakali~davrCiT da unda Tavs mixedos.
45. #... fonogramiT dadgenilia, rom l. C-s telefonisnomridan ganxorcielebulia zari v. b-n, sadac v-s eubne-ba, rom vinme v-s `ekaifebian~ is, o-e, p-a da l. g-a. saubrisbolos eubneba v. b-s, rom yvelafris saqmis kursSi Caaye-nebs, Tu rame ar moewoneba da iseTi saubari Tu iqneba,miscems sakadris pasuxs. v. b-a daxmarebas hpirdeba l-s.
46. #... fonogramidan irkveva, rom m-s Tanxis micemisada mis mier amis uaryofis Temaze, `furclebis~ ambavzedaurekes r-s. mosaubre ambobs, rom masTan erTad iyo ase-ve l. C-i da eubneba v. b-s, rom l-s igi magrad uyvars. v. b-apasuxobs, rom l-a misi Zmaa. #... fonogramaSi mosaubre eub-neba, rom r-m l-s uTxra, Zalian kargi, Tu is fuli m-n armiutania, exla aiRos da miitanoso v-n. aqve mosaubre eub-neba v. b-s, rom yvela gaeqca, marto o-e da l-a mis gverdiT.
47. 2015 wlis 27 ianvris #13/f fonoskopiuri eqsper-tizis daskvniT dadgenilia, rom eqspertizaze gamosak-vlevad wardgenili zemoT ganxiluli Canawerebi vargisiasaidentifikacio gamokvlevisaTvis xmis da metyvelebismixedviT. eqspertizaze gamosakvlevad wardgenil Cana-werebs montaJis kvali ar aReniSneba. sadavo 45 fonogra-maSi (maT Soris, #...., #....., #...., #....., #....., #...... fonogra-mebSi) monawile diqtori mamakacis xma da metyveleba da g.q-s xmis nimuSis fonogramidan g. q-s xma da metyveleba er-TmaneTis identuria; sadavo 18 fonogramaSi (maT Soris,#...., #...., #.... fonogramebSi) monawile diqtori mamakacisxma da metyveleba da T. k-s xmis nimuSis fonogramidan T.k-s xma da metyveleba erTmaneTis identuria; sadavo 3 fo-nogramaSi (#....,#....,#....) monawile diqtori mamakacis xmada metyveleba da l. C-s xmis nimuSis fonogramidan l. C-sxma da metyveleba erTmaneTis identuria; sadavo 62 fo-nogramaSi (maT Soris, #......, #....., #....., #......, #....., #.......,#......, #....., #....., #......, #....., #...., #...., #....., #......, #......,#....., #......, #....., #....., #....., #......, #....., #......, #..... fonog-ramebSi) monawile diqtori mamakacis xma da metyveleba
94
da v. b-s xmis nimuSis fonogramidan v. b-s xma da metyvele-ba erTmaneTis identuria. amave daskvnis Tanaxmad, eqsper-tizaze wardgenil sadavo fonogramebze saidentifika-cio kvlevis Catareba g. k-s, g. q-s, a. u-s, g. g-s, d. q-s da g. r-s xmisa da metyvelebis mixedviT ver moxerxda, vinaidanver akmayofilebda Sesabamis meTodikaSi miTiTebul sa-Wiro moTxovnas, sadavo fonogramebi ver akmayofilebdasaidentifikaciod vargisianobis erT-erT aucilebel pi-robas _ reprezentatulobas, rac mTavari pirobaa pirov-nebis saidentifikaciod. Canaweri ar iyo reprezentatu-li, anu ar gaaCnda pirovnebis Tavisufali metyvelebis Ca-weris damakmayofilebeli xangrZlivoba.
48. mowmis saxiT dakiTxulma eqspertebma _ T. b-m, e. k-ada d. g-a srulad daadastures maT mier gacemuli daskvnisutyuaroba da siswore.
49. yovelive zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, sakasa-cio palatas dadgenilad da dadasturebulad miaCnia, romswored msjavrdebulebi _ T. k-a, g. q-a, v. b-a da l. C-i mona-wileobdnen zemoT ganxilul saubrebSi, ra drosac sate-lefono saubrebis faruli miyuradeba-Caweris Sedegadmopovebuli audioCanawerebis mixedviT, aRiareben qur-dul samyaros, maT urTierToba hqondaT qurduli samya-ros wevrebTan da aqtiurad moqmedebdnen qurduli sam-yaros miznebis gansaxorcieleblad. Sesabamisad, saapela-cio sasamarTlom srulad gamoikvlia saqmeSi arsebuli,kanonis moTxovnaTa dacviT mopovebuli mtkicebulebebida msjavrdebulebis _ T. k-s, g. q-s, v. b-a da l. C-s mierCadenil danaSaulebriv qmedebas am nawilSi mieca sworisamarTlebrivi Sefaseba, ris gamoc ar arsebobs maT mimarTgasaCivrebuli ganaCenis gauqmebis safuZveli.
50. sakasacio palata aseve srulad iziarebs saapela-cio sasamarTlos argumentebs msjavrdebulebis _ d. q-s,g. q-s, v. b-a da l. C-s mier narkotikuli saSualebis ukano-no SeZenisa da Senaxvis, msjavrdebulebis _ a. u-s, g. r-a dag. g-s mier narkotikuli saSualebis ukanono SeZenisa daSenaxvis, aseve sabrZolo masalis marTlsawinaaRmdego Se-Zenisa da Senaxvis, xolo msjavrdebul g. q-s mier cec-xlsasroli iaraRisa da sabrZolo masalis marTlsawina-aRmdego SeZenisa da Senaxvis Taobaze da miaCnia, rom ka-nonis moTxovnaTa sruli dacviT, srulyofilad da obi-eqturad gamokvleul, urTierTSejerebul da sakmaris
75. mowmis saxiT dakiTxuli s-s samxareo mTavari sam-marTvelos w-s Ss raionuli sammarTvelos TanamSromle-bis _ a. Z-s, g. f-a da g. k-s CvenebebiT dadgenilia, rom d. q-s piradi Cxrekis Sedegad, misi Sarvlis ukana marjvena ji-bidan amoRebul iqna Sav parkSi Sexveuli momwvano-moru-xo feris specifikuri sunis mqone fxvieri mcenareuli
100
masa, rac adgilze dailuqa erT paketad.76. mowme g. k-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2014 wlis 10
seqtembers izolatorSi Seyvanil iqna braldebulis sa-xiT dakavebuli d. q-a, ra drosac morigeebi iyvnen is da d.s-a. vizualuri daTvalierebisas d. q-m Sarvlis ukana ji-bidan amoiRo da warmoadgina mwvane feris mcenareuli ma-sa.
genilia, rom d. q-n droebiTi moTavsebis izolatorSi amo-Rebuli momwvano feris, specifikuri sunis mqone mcena-reuli masa, mSral mdgomareobaSi warmoadgens narkoti-kul saSualeba gamomSral `marixuanas~, woniT 0,79 grams.aRniSnuli daadastures eqspertebma _ m. m-m da d. g-m.
82. mowmis saxiT dakiTxuli s-s samxareo mTavari sam-marTvelos w-s Ss raionuli sammarTvelos TanamSromle-bis _ p. f-s, d. W-a da a. k-s CvenebebiT dadgenilia, rom 2014wlis 10 seqtembers, q.T-i, m-s quCaze daakaves a. u-a, ro-melsac piradi Cxrekis dros aRmoaCnda da misgan amoRe-bul iqna pistoleti erTi cali vazniT da narkotikulisaSualeba _ marixuana.
83. dakavebisa da piradi Cxrekis oqmiT dadgenilia, roma. u-a 2014 wlis 10 seqtembers, 18:42 saaTze, dakavebuliqna q.T-i, m-s quCis mimdebare teritoriaze. Catarebulipiradi Cxrekis Sedegad amoRebul iqna a. u-s jinsis Sar-valsa da masze Semortymul yavisfer qamars Sua CarWobi-li pistoletis msgavsi sagani, warweriT ̀ BORA Mod. SK 200~,#44790, moyavisfro tariT, masSi moTavsebuli mWidismsgavsi sagniT da mWidSi moTavsebuli erTi cali sagani,aseve misi jinsis Sarvlis marjvena jibidan amoRebul iq-na moTeTro qaRaldSi Sexveuli momwvano feris mcenare-uli masa, rac dailuqa cal-calke paketebad.
is 301-e muxliT, 307-e muxlis 1-li nawilis `g~ qvepunqtiT,me-2, me-3 nawilebiT, 309-e muxliT da
d a a d g i n a:
1. msjavrdebul g. g-a da misi interesebis damcvelis,
104
advokat m. n-s, msjavrdebul d. q-s interesebis damcve-lis, advokat a. C-s, msjavrdebul l. C-a da misi interese-bis damcvelis, advokat l. a-s, msjavrdebul a. u-s inte-resebis damcvelis, advokat l. a-s, msjavrdebul g. q-s in-teresebis damcvelis, advokat s. j-s, msjavrdebul v. b-s,msjavrdebul T. k-s interesebis damcveli advokatebis _k. b-a da l. x-s, msjavrdebul g. q-s, msjavrdebul d. q-sinteresebis damcvelis, advokat d. s-s sakasacio saCivre-bi ar dakmayofildes.
4. ganaCeni saapelacio wesiT gaasaCivra msjavrdebulisinteresebis damcvelma, advokatma v. g-m, romelmac iTxo-va zugdidis raionuli sasamarTlos 2015 wlis 3 aprilisganaCenis gauqmeba da r. W-s gamarTleba.
5. quTaisis saapelacio sasamarTlos 2015 wlis 9 ivni-sis ganaCeniT saapelacio saCivari ar dakmayofilda da ga-saCivrebuli ganaCeni darCa ucvlelad.
6. kasatori _ msjavrdebuli r. W-e sakasacio saCivarSiaRniSnavs, rom saapelacio palata ganaCenis dadgenisas da-eyrdno mxolod braldebis formulirebas, mTlianad gai-ziara pirveli instanciis sasamarTlos ganaCeni, xolodacvis mxaris mier warmodgenili mtkicebulebebi ar ga-nixila da ar Seafasa; sasamarTlom arc erTi eWvi ar gan-marta r. W-s sasargeblod, ar gamoikvlia arsebiTi xasia-Tis iseTi garemoebebi, romelTa gareSec SeuZlebelia swo-ri gadawyvetilebis miReba; gaiziara mxolod braldebisurTierTgamomricxavi mtkicebulebebi, riTic, faqtobri-vad, uari Tqva marTlmsajulebis ganxorcielebaze damsjavrdebuls waarTva samarTliani sasamarTlos ufle-ba.
7. kasatoris miTiTebiT erTaderTi mtkicebuleba, ri-Tic dadginda r. W-s braleuloba, aris avtoteqnikuri eq-spertizis daskvna, romelic, kasatoris azriT, Sedgeni-lia araobieqturad, zereled aris aRwerili da zogjerdamaxinjebulia faqtebi, calmxrivadaa gamoyenebuli saq-mis masalebi, romlebic mimarTulia mxolod r. W-s bral-debis dasadastureblad; mowmed dakiTxulma eqsperteb-ma calsaxad aRiares, rom, Tu avtomanqana dasaxlebulpunqtSi moZraobs 100 km/sT siCqariT, es darRvevaa, asevedaadastures, rom gzajvaredinze gauCereblad gavla ak-rZalulia da rom ... quCidan momavali mZRoli, Tu undoda... quCaze gavla, pirdapir ver wavidoda, unda Seesrule-bina garkveuli manevri marjvniv moZraobiT; sasamarTlomar gamoiyena da ar Seafasa eqspertTa Cvenebebi da z. r-s
111
qmedeba; sasamarTlom ar Seafasa is faqti, rom, Tu z. r-eimoZravebda dasaSvebi _ 60 km/sT siCqariT, ar moxdebodaZlieri Sejaxeba da ar dadgeboda aseTi savalalo Sedegi.aravin dainteresebula, gzajvaredinze Semosvlamde, ...quCaze idga Tu ara sagzao niSnebi. eqsperti ar dainte-resda, estakadis dasawyisSi arsebuli sagzao niSani 5.20.1TeTr fonze ras niSnavda da ra upiratesobas aZlevda r.W-s.
8. saCivris avtoris azriT, mas sagzao moZraobis wesebiar daurRvevia, e.i. misi qmedeba ar aris marTlsawinaaR-mdego; niSani „sdeq~ dadges ... quCaze, anu z. r-s samoZraomonakveTze. saqmeSi ar arsebobs gamamtyunebeli ganaCe-nis gamotanisaTvis sakmarisi mtkicebulebaTa erTobli-oba, romelic gonivrul eWvs miRma standartiT daarwmu-nebda obieqtur pirs r. W-s braleulobaSi.
9. yovelive zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, msjavrde-buli r. W-e iTxovs quTaisis saapelacio sasamarTlos 2015wlis 9 ivnisis gamamtyunebeli ganaCenis gauqmebas da ga-marTlebas.
6. sakasacio palata miuTiTebs, rom amave mimarTvidanirkveva, rom sagzao-satransporto SemTxvevis dRes, 2013wlis 24 oqtombers, zemoaRniSnuli quCebis gadakveTa arregulirdeboda Sesabamisi sagzao niSnebiT. Sesabamisad,palata ver gaiziarebs kasatoris pozicias, rom aRniSnu-li weriliT dasturdeba, rom igi moZraobda mTavar gza-ze, da, Sesabamisad sargeblobda gavlis upiratesobiT, vi-naidan „sagzao moZraobis usafrTxoebis Sesaxeb~ saqarTve-los kanonis pirveli muxlis h1 punqtis Tanxamad, mTavargzad iTvleba 2.1, 2.3.1, 2.3.2, 2.3.3 an 5.1 sagzao niSniT aR-niSnuli gza gadasakveT _ (mierTebul) gzasTan SedarebiT,an gza _ mimdebare teritoriidan gamomaval gamosasvlel-Tan SedarebiT, an mkvrivsafariani gza -gruntovanTan Se-darebiT, rasac mocemul SemTxvevaSi adgili ar hqonia.
7. sakasacio palata miuTiTebs, rom mZRoli yovel kon-kretul SemTxvevaSi valdebulia, imoZraos im niSnebis Se-sabamisad, romlebic im konkretul SemTxvevaSi areguli-rebs sagzao moZraobis wesebs, rodesac igi gadaadgilde-ba da ara raime sxva faqtorebis gaTvaliswinebiT.
8. usafuZvloa aseve kasatoris miTiTeba imis Sesaxeb,rom mZRoli z. r-e moZraobda 100 km/sT siCqariT da masdasaSvebi siCqariT rom emoZrava, ar moxdeboda ZlieriSejaxeba da ar dadgeboda aseTi savalalo Sedegi, vinai-dan saqmis masalebiT ar aris dadgenili Tu ra siCqariTmoZraobda z. r-e. metic, eqspertma d. g-ma Cvenebis mice-misas ganmarta, rom warmodgenili videomasalidan aSka-rad Canda, rom r. W-e z. r-ze gacilebiT didi siCqariT moZ-raobda.
9. amdenad, sakasacio palata ver gaiziarebs kasatoris
114
mosazrebas misi udanaSaulobis Taobaze, vinaidan es ewi-naaRmdegeba sasamarTlo sxdomaze kanoniT dadgenili we-siT gamokvleul utyuar da sakmaris mtkicebulebaTa er-Tobliobas.
1. zepiri mosmenis gareSe ganixila saqarTvelos sis-xlis samarTlis saproceso kodeqsis (1998 wlis 20 Teber-vali) 113-e muxlis me-4 nawiliT gaTvaliswinebuli sakiT-xi gamarTlebul l. W-sa da msjavrdebulebis _ d. g-is, d. b-is, T. k-asa da l. k-is sisxlis samarTlis saqmeebze.
2. Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos 2010 wlis 2 martisganaCeniT damtkicda prokuror i. S-sa da l. k-es, d. b-es, T.k-asa da d. g-es Soris dadebuli saproceso SeTanxmebebi.
5. saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos 2015 wlis 19 no-embris ganCinebiT dazaralebul ss `bazisbankis~ warmo-madgenlis _ b. b-is sakasacio saCivari Tbilisis saapela-cio sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saqmeTa palatis 2015wlis 21 aprilis ganaCenze ar iqna daSvebuli saqarTvelosuzenaesi sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saqmeTa pala-tis sxdomaze gansaxilvelad.
6. saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis saproceso kodeq-sis (1998 wlis 20 Tebervali) 113-e muxlis me-4 nawilis Ta-naxmad, gamoTxovil iqna l. k-is, d. b-is, T. k-asa da d. g-issisxlis samarTlis saqme, romelzec Tbilisis saqalaqo sa-samarTlos mier 2010 wlis 2 marts gamotanilia gamamtyu-nebeli ganaCeni (saproceso SeTanxmebiT).
7. sakasacio palatam Seiswavla saqmis masalebi da
117
g a m o a r k v i a :
1. saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis saproceso kodeq-sis (1998 wlis 20 Tebervali) 113-e muxlis me-3 nawilis Ta-naxmad, preiudiciulad dadgenili faqti SeiZleba uar-yos mxarem, sasamarTlos ganaCenma, sxva Semajamebelma ga-dawyvetilebam an dadgenilebam, Tu es faqti ewinaaRmde-geba sasamarTloSi mtkicebulebaTa gamokvlevis Sedegebsada mosamarTleTa Sinagan rwmenas. amave muxlis me-4 nawi-lis Tanaxmad, am muxlis me-3 nawilSi aRniSnul SemTxveva-Si gamomZiebelsa da prokurors ufleba aqvT uaryon pre-iudicia da saqme gadascen sasamarTlos TavianTi Sinaganirwmenis safuZvelze. sasamarTlos, romelic Sinagani rwme-niT Seafasebs mtkicebulebebs, ufleba aqvs gamoitanosganaCeni an sxva gadawyvetileba preiudiciis miuxedavad.aseTi ganaCeni an gadawyvetileba kanonier ZalaSi Sesvlis-Tanave saqmesTan erTad igzavneba saqarTvelos uzenaesisasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saqmeTa palataSi, rome-lic gamoiTxovs im saqmes, romlis preiudiciuli mniSvne-lobac uaryofilia, da im mtkicebulebis Sefasebis Sem-deg, romelic safuZvlad udevs urTierTsawinaaRmdegosasamarTlo gadawyvetilebebs, auqmebs an cvlis erT maT-gans da ZalaSi tovebs meores.
2. mocemul SemTxvevaSi l. W-is sisxlis samarTlis saq-meze Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlissaqmeTa kolegiam 2015 wlis 5 ianvars gamoitana gamamar-Tlebeli ganaCeni (ZalaSi darCa zemdgomi instanciis sa-samarTloebSi) da am saqmeze uaryofil iqna preiudicia _l. k-is, d. b-is, T. k-asa da d. g-is mimarT Tbilisis saqalaqosasamarTlos 2010 wlis 2 marts gamotanili ganaCeni.
3. sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom d. b-es, T. k-asa da d.g-es msjavri daedoT ssk-is 180-e muxliT _ TaRliTobi-saTvis. maT mier Cadenili danaSaulis erT-erT makvali-ficirebel garemoebas warmoadgens am danaSaulis Cadenawinaswari SeTanxmebiT jgufis mier. Tbilisis saqalaqo sa-samarTlos 2010 wlis 2 martis ganaCenis aRwerilobiT-sa-motivacio nawilSi miTiTebulia, rom d. b-m, T. k-am da d. g-em danaSauli Caidines winaswari SeTanxmebiT jgufis mierl. W-sTan erTad, da es im pirobebSi, rodesac l.W-is sis-xlis samarTlis saqme am droisaTvis ar iyo ganxiluli dasasamarTlos kanonier ZalaSi Sesuli gamamtyunebeli ga-
118
naCeniT, ar dasturdeboda mis mier am danaSaulis Cadena.sawinaaRmdegod, mogvianebiT, l. W-is mimarT 2015 wlis 5ianvars gamotanil iqna gamamarTlebeli ganaCeni. zemoaR-niSnulidan gamomdinare, saksacio palatas miaCnia, romTbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos 2010 wlis 2 martis gana-Cenis aRwerilobiT-samotivacio nawilSi unda Sevidescvlileba da unda amoiricxos miTiTeba l. W-ze, rogorcwinaswari SeTanxmebiT jgufis mier TaRliTobis CamdenerT-erT pirze. Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos 2010 wlis2 martis ganaCeni sxva nawilSi unda darCes ucvlelad.
6. kasatori _ msjavrdebulis interesebis damcveli,advokati T. g-i sakasacio saCivarSi aRniSnavs, rom sasa-marTlom r. a-s kuTvnilebad CaTvala misi mamis _ a. a-s sac-xovrebeli saxlis Cxrekis Sedegad amoRebuli iaraRi; ardaukiTxavT am saxlSi mcxovrebi a. a-i da misi meore Svili_ m. a-i imis gasarkvevad, iqneb, es iaraRi romelime maTga-nis iyo; amoRebul iaraRsa da sabrZolo masalaze ar Cata-rebula daqtiloskopiuri eqspertiza TiTis anabeWdebisaRmoCenis mizniT.
7. advokatis azriT, r. a-s dakavebisas da Cxrekis Cata-rebisas dairRva saqarTvelos sssk-is moTxovnebi.
8. garda amisa, r. a-i daakaves Cxrekis dawyebamde, xolodakavebis oqmSi miuTiTes, rom Cxrekis Catarebis Semde-gaa dakavebuli; Cxrekis dawyebamde policielebma gareTgaiyvanes saxlSi myofi yvela piri, Cades sabrZolo masa-la da cecxlsasroli iaraRi, a-s ojaxis wevrebi isev daab-runes da amis Semdeg Caatares Cxreka-amoReba.
9. yovelive zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, advokatiT. g-i iTxovs r. a-s mimarT Tbilisis saapelacio sasamar-Tlos 2015 wlis 28 aprilis gamamtyunebeli ganaCenis ga-uqmebas da gamamarTlebeli ganaCenis dadgenas.
6. amasTan, sakasacio palata srulad iziarebs kasato-ris pozicias im nawilSi, rom gamoZiebam utyuarad ver da-adgina, Tu vis ekuTvnoda r. a-s sacxovrebeli saxlidanamoRebuli cecxlsasroli iaraRi da sabrZolo masala,kerZod:
7. sasamarTlo sxdomaze mowme m. q-m aCvena, rom saxli,saidanac amoiRes cecxlsasroli iaraRi, ekuTvnis mis me-
122
uRles _ a. a-s, romelic cxovrobs xsenebul saxlSi Tavispirvel colTan, meore colTan _ m. q-sTan, SvilebTan _ r.da m. a-ebTan da umcros, 4 wlis gogonasTan erTad. misiveganmartebiT, m. a-i (r. a-s Zmas) im oTaxSi iZinebda xolme,saidanac amoiRes iaraRi da sabrZolo masala.
8. analogiuri faqtobrivi garemoebebi daadastura sa-samarTlo sxdomaze mowme a. b-ma.
9. braldebulma r. a-ma sasamarTlo sxdomaze ganmarta,rom aRniSnul saxlSi mis garda cxovroben misi mama _ a. a-i colebTan erTad, Zma _ m. a-i da umcrosi da. amoRebuliiaraRi da sabrZolo masala ar aris misi da miaCnia, romisini policielebma Caudes.
10. saqarTvelos sssk-is me-5 muxlis Tanaxmad, aravinar aris valdebuli, amtkicos Tavisi udanaSauloba dabraldebis mtkicebis tvirTi ekisreba bralmdebels.braldebis mxarem ki ver warmoadgina raime mtkicebulebaimis Sesaxeb, rom amoRebuli iaraRi SeiZina da Seinaxa r. a-ma. braldebis mxarem aseve ver warmoadgina raime mtkice-buleba, rac sasamarTlos eWvs Seataninebda dacvis mxa-ris mier warmodgenil mowmeTa CvenebebSi, rom saxlSi (sa-idanac amoiRes iaraRi da sabrZolo masala) r. a-s gardakidev sxva pirebic _ maT Soris misi mama da Zma cxovrob-dnen. aRniSnulidan gamomdinare, daskvna rom amoRebuliiaraRi da sabrZolo masala SeiZina da Seinaxa r. a-ma, arismxolod varaudi, rac safuZvlad ver daedeba gamamtyu-nebel ganaCens, vinaidan saqarTvelos sssk-is me-13 mux-lis me-2 nawilis, 259-e muxlis me-3 nawilisa da 273-e mux-lis 1-li nawilis Sesabamisad, ganaCenSi Camoyalibebuliyvela daskvna dasabuTebuli unda iyos. gamamtyunebel ga-naCenSi unda aRiniSnos utyuari da sakmarisi mtkicebu-lebebi, romlebsac emyareba sasamarTlos daskvna. saqar-Tvelos sssk-is 82-e muxlis me-3 nawilis Tanaxmad ki, ga-mamtyunebeli ganaCeniT piris damnaSaved cnobisaTvis sa-Wiroa gonivrul eWvs miRma arsebul SeTanxmebul mtkice-bulebaTa erToblioba.
11. yovelive zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, sakasaciopalatas miaCnia, rom r. a-i unda gamarTldes saqarTvelosssk-is 236-e muxlis 1-li nawiliT wardgenil braldebaSi.
iswavla saqmis masalebi, Seamowma saCivrebis safuZvlia-noba da miaCnia, rom misi moTxovna unda dakmayofildesSemdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
126
2. sasamarTloSi saqmis ganxilvisas a. C-ma Tavi ar cnodamnaSaved wardgenil braldebaSi da ganmarta, rom 2014wlis 27 maiss ...-is moednis mimdebare teritoriaze Sexvdaa. C-rs, romelsac xelSi eWira magida. a. C-i dainteresda,Tu saidan hqonda mas magida. a. C-rma upasuxa, rom aCuqesda surda misi miyidva yvavilebis bazrobaze Tavisi nac-nobisaTvis. a. C-ma daijera misi naTqvami, ris Semdegac ma-gida erTad miitanes da 5 larad mihyides a-is nacnobs.
3. braldebul a. C-ris CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2014wlis 27 maiss a. C-Tan erTad TbilisSi, ...-is quCidan faru-lad daeufla magidas, romelic meore dRes erTad waiResda 5 larad mihyides mis nacnob d. d-s.
4. mowme _ gamomZiebel m. a-is CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom2014 wlis 27 maiss man daaTvaliera Sps „...-as~ saTvalTva-lo kameris videoCanaweri. Canaweridan Cans, rom a. C-i da a.C-ri imyofebian Sps „...as~ kuTvnil teritoriaze, ra dro-sac a. C-ri farulad daeufla magidas da a. C-Tan erTadganagrZo gza.
6. mowme _ d. d-is CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2014 wlis27 maiss a. C-isa da a. C-risagan 5 larad SeiZina magida, ro-melic maTi ganmartebiT iyo naCuqari. Tanxa ki gadauxadaa. C-s.
7. sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom a. C-is mier magidisqurdobis Cadenis faqti dasturdeba mxolod braldebul_ a. C-ris CvenebiT. sxva pirdapiri mtkicebuleba, rome-lic daadasturebda a. C-is mier danaSaulis Cadenas, saq-mis masalebSi ar moipoveba. rac Seexeba mowme m. a-is Cvene-basa da videoCanaweris daTvalierebis oqms, saqarTvelossssk-is 72-e muxlis 1-li nawilis Tanaxmad „am kodeqsis ar-sebiTi darRveviT mopovebuli mtkicebuleba da amgvarimtkicebulebis safuZvelze kanonierad mopovebuli sxvamtkicebuleba, Tu is auaresebs braldebulis samarTleb-riv mdgomareobas, dauSvebelia da iuridiuli Zala ar ga-aCnia~. saqarTvelos konstituciis me-40 muxlis me-3 nawi-
127
lis Tanaxmad, `...gamamtyunebeli ganaCeni unda emyarebo-des mxolod utyuar mtkicebulebebs~. saqmis masalebiTdadgenilia, rom Sps „...-as~ saTvalTvalo kameris video-Canaweri sasamarTlom cno dauSvebel mtkicebulebad. Se-sabamisad, sakasacio palata m. a-is Cvenebasa da mis mierSedgenil daTvalierebis oqms ver miiCnevs a. C-is braleu-lobis damadasturebel mtkicebulebebad, radgan es in-formacia mopovebulia dauSveblad cnobili videoCana-weridan (diskebidan). garda amisa, videoCanaweris daTva-lierebis oqmSi gamomZiebeli xazgasmiT aRniSnavs, rom Ca-nawerSi dafiqsirebuli pirebis saxis nakvTebisa da vizu-alis garCeva Znelia, savaraudod, isini unda iyvnen mama-kacebi.
wavla saqmis masalebi, Seamowma saCivris safuZvlianobada miaCnia, rom saCivris moTxovna unda dakmayofildes,Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom j. o-is mier narkoti-kuli saSualebis ukanono SeZena da Senaxva didi odeno-biT, dasturdeba gonivrul eWvs miRma arsebuli, sakmari-si, utyuari da SeTanxmebuli mtkicebulebebis erTobli-obiT _ mowmeTa CvenebebiT, Cxekis oqmebiTa da eqsperti-zis daskvnebiT. saqmeSi ar arsebobs sxva iseTi mtkicebu-lebebi, romlebiTac gabaTildeboda, anda eWvqveS dadge-boda j. o-is mimarT ganaCeniT am nawilSi Seracxuli bral-deba. amasTan, didi odenobiT narkotikuli saSualebisukanono SeZena-Senaxvis nawilSi msjavrdebas sadavod arxdis arc dacvis mxare.
3. rac Seexeba j. o-is msjavrdebas didi odenobiT nar-kotikuli saSulebis gasaRebaSi, sakasacio palata aRniS-navs, rom mocemul SemTxvevaSi saxeze ar gvaqvs mtkice-bulebaTa erToblioba, romelic gonivrul eWvs miRma da-adasturebda j. o-is mier narkotikuli saSualebis gasa-Rebis faqts, kerZod:
4. sakasacio palata yuradRebas amaxvilebs im garemoe-baze, rom saapelacio sasamarTlo narkotikuli saSuale-bis gasaRebis faqtis dadasturebisas daeyrdno msjav-rdebul i.g-is Cvenebas, romelmac miuTiTa, rom narkoti-kuli saSualeba SeiZina j. o-sagan; Semavali da gamavalizarebis detalur nusxas, romliTac dasturdeba, rombraldebulebi ukavSirdebodnen erTmaneTs; i. g-isa da j.o-is piradi Cxrekisa da dakavebis oqmebs, romlebiTac das-turdeba, rom isini erTad daakaves da amouRes erTi saxe-obis narkotikuli saSualeba; aseve im faqtobriv garemo-ebas, rom j. o-is saxlidan amoiRes fuladi Tanxa _ 700 la-risa da 600 aSS dolaris odenobiT.
5. sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom Semavali da gamava-li zarebis detaluri nusxa ar warmoadgens imgvari xasia-Tis mtkicebulebas, romliTac obieqturad SesaZlebeliakomunikaciis mxareebs Soris arsebuli saubris Sinaarsob-rivi mxaris garkveva. igi adasturebs mxolod i. g-sa da j.o-s Soris satelefono kavSirs (Sinaarsi ucnobia) da Sesa-bamisad, aRniSnuli mtkicebulebis safuZvelze im faqtis
134
dadgena, rom j. o-ma i. g-ze gaasaRa narkotikuli saSuale-ba, obieqturad SeuZlebelia. rac Seexeba im garemoebas,rom braldebulebi erTad daakaves, TavisTavad ar gulis-xmobs imas, rom romelime braldebulma meores gadascanarkotikuli saSualeba. aRniSnuli warmoadgens varauds,romelic unda dadasturdes sxva utyuari mtkicebule-bebiT. amasTan, braldebulis sacxovrebeli saxlidan fu-ladi Tanxis amoReba, aseve i. g-is piradi Cxrekisas da j. o-is sacxovrebeli saxlis Cxrekisas erTi saxeobis (`bupre-norfini~) narkotikuli saSualebis amoReba ar SeiZlebamiCneul iqnes narkotikuli saSualebis gasaRebis faqtisdasadgenad utyuar mtkicebulebad. rac Seexeba i. g-is Cve-nebas, romelic miuTiTebs, rom narkotikuli saSualebaSeiZina j. o-sagan, is warmoadgens erTaderT pirdapiri xa-siaTis mtkicebulebas, romelic ar aris gamyarebuli sxvamtkicebulebebiT. aRsaniSnavia, rom 24.06.2014 wlis gamo-Ziebis dawyebis aRricxvis baraTsa da patakSi miTiTebu-lia, rom i. g-e inaxavs ukanonod SeZenil narkotikul sa-Sualebas, romelic unda gadasces ucnob pirs. am infor-macias policielebic adasturebdnen mowmis saxiT dakiT-xvisas. aRniSnuli garemoeba kidev ufro mkveTrad usvamsxazs imas, rom j. o-is mier narkotikuli saSualebis i. g-zegasaRebis faqti, braldebul i. g-is Cvenebis garda, saWi-roebs sxva utyuari pirdapiri mtkicebulebis arsebobas,rac saqmeze warmodgenili ar yofila.
6. saqarTvelos sssk-is 13-e muxlis me-2 punqtis Tanax-mad, `gamamtyunebeli ganaCeni unda efuZnebodes mxoloderTmaneTTan SeTanxmebul, aSkara da damajerebel mtki-cebulebaTa erTobliobas, romelic gonivrul eWvs miRmaadasturebs piris braleulobas~. mocemul SemTxvevaSi ararsebobs SeTanxmebuli, aSkara da damajerebeli mtkice-bulebebis erToblioba, romliTac utyuarad dadastur-deboda j. o-is mier i. g-ze narkotikuli saSualebis gasa-Reba.
amasTan, sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom am kategori-is saqmeebze saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos mier dad-genilia praqtika (saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos2008 wlis 11 noembris #736ap ganCineba; 2013 wlis 28 ivni-sis 40ap-132 ganaCeni) da ganmartebulia, rom mxolod er-Ti mowmis (meore msjavrdebulis) Cveneba ar aris sakmari-si mtkicebuleba narkotikuli saSualebis gasaRebis faq-
135
tis dasadastureblad da gamamtyunebeli ganaCenis gamo-satanad.
7. amdenad, sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom j. o-i udana-Saulod unda iqnes cnobili da gamarTldes didi odeno-biT narkotikuli saSualebis gasaRebis nawilSi. Sesabami-sad, quTaisis saapelacio sasamarTlos 2015 wlis 16 apri-lis ganaCeni unda Seicvalos: j. o-i cnobil unda iqnes uda-naSaulod da gamarTldes ssk-is 260-e muxlis me-2 nawilis`a~ qvepunqtiT _ narkotikebis gasaRebis nawilSi.
a) sasamarTlos kanonier ZalaSi Sesuli ganaCeniT dad-genilia, rom yalbia mtkicebuleba, romelic safuZvladdaedo gadasasinj ganaCens;
b) arsebobs garemoeba, romelic mowmobs sasamarTloskanonier ZalaSi Sesuli ganaCenis damdgeni sasamarTlosukanono Semadgenlobas an im mtkicebulebis dauSveblo-bas, romelic safuZvlad daedo gadasasinj ganaCens;
g) sasamarTlos kanonier ZalaSi Sesuli ganaCeniT dad-genilia, rom mosamarTlem, prokurorma, gamomZiebelma,naficma msajulma an nafici msajulis mimarT sxva pirma am
e) arsebobs adamianis uflebaTa evropuli sasamarTloskanonier ZalaSi Sesuli gadawyvetileba (ganCineba), ro-melmac daadgina adamianis uflebaTa da ZiriTad Tavisuf-lebaTa dacvis evropuli konvenciis an misi oqmebis dar-Rveva am saqmesTan dakavSirebiT, da gadasasinji ganaCeniam darRvevas efuZneba;
v) axali kanoni auqmebs an amsubuqebs sisxlissamar-Tlebriv pasuxismgeblobas im qmedebisaTvis, romlis Ca-denisTvisac pirs gadasasinji ganaCeniT msjavri daedo;
z) warmodgenilia axali faqti an mtkicebuleba, rome-lic gadasasinji ganaCenis gamotanis dros ar iyo cnobilida TavisTavad, Tu sxva dadgenil garemoebasTan erTadamtkicebs msjavrdebulis udanaSaulobas an mis mier imdanaSaulze ufro msubuqi an ufro mZime danaSaulis Ca-denas, romlisTvisac mas msjavri daedo, agreTve amtki-cebs gamarTlebulis braleulobas an danaSaulis im pirismier Cadenas, romlis mimarTac sisxlissamarTlebrividevna Sewyvetili iyo;
3. saqmis masalebiT cnobilia, rom kasatori axlad ga-movlenil garemoebaTa gamo ganaCenis gadasinjvas iTxovssaqarTvelos sssk-is 310-e muxlis „d~ da „z~ punqtebis sa-fuZvelze, Sesabamisad, Suamdgomloba emyareba ganaCenisgadasinjvis or sxvadasxva samarTlebriv safuZvels.
palata iziarebs saapelacio sasamarTlos motivaciassaqarTvelos sssk-is 310-e muxlis „z~ punqtTan mimarTe-biT da aRniSnavs, rom dacvis mxaris mcdeloba, braldebagaeqarwylebina maT mier warmodgenili „...-is~ 2006 wlis 3oqtombris #... eqspertizis daskvniT (romlis Catarebadacvis mxares ufro adrec SeeZlo), ver iqneba miCneuliiseT axal mtkicebulebad, romelic ganaCenis gadasinjvissafuZveli gaxdeba.
SuamdgomlobaSi miTiTebul, 2015 wlis 26 aprilis _ r.m-is, 2015 wlis 5 maisis _ q. u-isa da n. k-is gamokiTxvis oq-
145
mebTan dakavSirebiT, saapelacio palata ganmartavs, romganaCenis mixedviT, r. C-is mimarT Seracxuli danaSaulisCadena, sxva mtkicebulebebTan erTad, dadgenilia aRniS-nul mowmeTa CvenebebiT. mocemul SemTxvevaSi ki sasamar-Tlos kanonier ZalaSi Sesuli ganaCeniT ar aris dadgeni-li, rom maT mier micemuli Cvenebebi yalbia an kanonis dar-RveviT aris mopovebuli, rac sssk-is 310-e muxlis Tanax-mad, am safuZvliT ganaCenis gadasinjvis aucilebeli wi-napirobaa.
amdenad, saapelacio sasamarTlo miiCnevs, rom Suam-dgomlobis avtorma ver warmoadgina raime axali faqti anmtkicebuleba, romelic gadasasinji ganaCenis gamotanisdros ar iyo cnobili da TavisTavad, Tu sxva dadgenilgaremoebasTan erTad amtkicebs msjavrdebulis udanaSa-ulobas an mis mier im danaSaulze ufro msubuqi danaSau-lis Cadenas, romlisTvisac mas msjavri daedo.
sakasacio palata miuTiTebs, rom kasatoris mier miTi-Tebuli zemoaRniSnuli safuZveli warmoadgens saqarTve-los sssk-is 310-e muxlis `d~ qvepunqtiT (arsebobs saqar-Tvelos sakonstitucio sasamarTlos gadawyvetileba, ro-melmac arakonstituciurad cno am saqmeSi gamoyenebulisisxlis samarTlis kanoni) gaTvaliswinebul kanonier Za-laSi Sesuli ganaCenis gadasinjvis safuZvels.
sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom saapelacio sasamar-Tlom msjavrdebul m. d-s Suamdgomlobis dasaSvebobisSemowmebis etapze, saqarTvelos sakonstitucio sasamar-Tlos zemoxsenebuli gadawyvetilebis gaTvaliswinebiT,Seafasa saqmeSi arsebuli mtkicebulebebi maTi utyuaro-bisa da sakmarisobis TvalsazrisiT da miiCnia, rom Tbili-sis saapelacio sasamarTlos 2012 wlis 10 maisis ganaCenikanonieri da dasabuTebulia.
sakasacio palata miuTiTebs, rom saapelacio sasamar-Tlo Suamdgomlobis dasaSvebobis etapze ar iyo ufleba-mosili, Seefasebina mtkicebulebebi, romlebsac efuZne-ba gadasasinji ganaCeni. gadawyvetileba imis Taobaze, iribiCvenebebis gauziareblobis SemTxvevaSi sakmarisia Tu arasaqmeSi arsebuli sxva mtkicebulebebi gamamtyunebeli ga-naCenis gamosatanad, saapelacio palatam unda miiRos mxo-lod Suamdgomlobis daSvebisa da kanoniT dadgenili we-siT ganxilvis Sedegad.
yovelive aRniSnulis gaTvaliswinebiT, sakasacio pa-latas miaCnia, rom msjavrdebul m. d-s Suamdgomloba ax-lad gamovlenil garemoebaTa gamo mis mimarT arsebuliganaCenis gadasinjvis Sesaxeb iyo dasabuTebuli, ris ga-
150
moc unda gauqmdes Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos 2015wlis 20 maisis ganCineba msjavrdebul m. d-s Suamdgomlo-bis dauSveblad cnobis Sesaxeb da Suamdgomloba daSve-bul iqnes gansaxilvelad.
sad, sakasacio palatam Seamowma saqmis masalebi, gaaanali-za sakasacio saCivris safuZvlianoba da mivida daskvnam-de, rom igi unda dakmayofildes Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom msjavrdebuli S. b-imis mimarT dadgenili ganaCenis gadasinjvis safuZvlad,sxva safuZvlebTan erTad, miuTiTebs aseve im garemoeba-ze, rom ganaCeni eyrdnoba 13 mowmis irib Cvenebas.
saapelacio sasamarTlo ki msjavrdebul S. b-s Suam-dgomlobis dauSveblad cnobis erT-erT safuZvlad miu-
153
TiTebs im garemoebaze, rom msjavrdebuli konkretuladar miuTiTebs, romeli mowmis Cvenebaa iribi. aqve sasamar-Tlo aRniSnavs, rom S. b-s bralis damadasturebel mtki-cebulebebad Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos 2014 wlis22 maisis ganaCenSi miTiTebulia rogorc dazaralebule-bis Cvenebebi, ise Tavad S. b-s Cveneba, aseve fotosura-TiT amocnobis oqmi, videoCanaweris daTvalierebis oqmi,telefonis daTvalierebis oqmi da sxva araerTi mtkice-buleba. rac Seexeba msjavrdebulis mier warmodgenil do-kumentebs, Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlo miiCnevs, romaRniSnuli dokumentebi, informaciuli TvalsazrisiT, arSeicavs raime iseT garemoebas, rac S. b-s mimarT arsebuliganaCenis gadasinjvis safuZveli gaxdeboda.
sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom kasatoris mier miTi-Tebuli zemoaRniSnuli safuZveli, rom ganaCenSi miTiTe-buli iyo 13 mowmis iribi Cveneba, warmoadgens saqarTve-los sssk-is 310-e muxlis `d~ qvepunqtiT (arsebobs saqar-Tvelos sakonstitucio sasamarTlos gadawyvetileba, ro-melmac arakonstituciurad cno am saqmeSi gamoyenebulisisxlis samarTlis kanoni) gaTvaliswinebul kanonier Za-laSi Sesuli ganaCenis gadasinjvis safuZvels.
sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom saapelacio sasamar-Tlo Suamdgomlobis dasaSvebobis etapze uflebamosiliiyo, ganaCenSi miTiTebul mtkicebulebebTan dakavSire-biT emsjela mxolod im SemTxvevaSi, Tu kasatoris mierSuamdgomlobaSi aRniSnuli garemoeba, rom misi braldebaeyrdnoba 13 mowmis irib Cvenebas, gaxdeboda ganaCenis ga-dasinjvis safuZveli Suamdgomlobis daSvebisa da kano-niT dadgenili wesiT ganxilvis Sedegad.
yovelive aRniSnulis gaTvaliswinebiT, sakasacio pa-latas miaCnia, rom msjavrdebul S. b-s Suamdgomloba ax-lad gamovlenil garemoebaTa gamo mis mimarT arsebuliganaCenis gadasinjvis Sesaxeb iyo dasabuTebuli, ris ga-moc unda gauqmdes Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos 2015wlis 15 ivlisis ganCineba msjavrdebul S. b-s Suamdgom-lobis dauSveblad cnobis Sesaxeb da Suamdgomloba daS-vebul unda iqnes gansaxilvelad.
a) sasamarTlos kanonier ZalaSi Sesuli ganaCeniT dad-genilia, rom yalbia mtkicebuleba, romelic safuZvladdaedo gadasasinj ganaCens;
b) arsebobs garemoeba, romelic mowmobs sasamarTloskanonier ZalaSi Sesuli ganaCenis damdgeni sasamarTlosukanono Semadgenlobas an im mtkicebulebis dauSveblo-bas, romelic safuZvlad daedo gadasasinj ganaCens;
g) sasamarTlos kanonier ZalaSi Sesuli ganaCeniT dad-genilia, rom mosamarTlem, prokurorma, gamomZiebelma,naficma msajulma an nafici msajulis mimarT sxva pirma am
e) arsebobs adamianis uflebaTa evropuli sasamarTloskanonier ZalaSi Sesuli gadawyvetileba (ganCineba), ro-melmac daadgina adamianis uflebaTa da ZiriTad Tavisuf-lebaTa dacvis evropuli konvenciis an misi oqmebis dar-Rveva am saqmesTan dakavSirebiT, da gadasasinji ganaCeniam darRvevas efuZneba;
v) axali kanoni auqmebs an amsubuqebs sisxlissamar-Tlebriv pasuxismgeblobas im qmedebisaTvis, romlis Ca-denisTvisac pirs gadasasinji ganaCeniT msjavri daedo;
z) warmodgenilia axali faqti an mtkicebuleba, rome-lic gadasasinji ganaCenis gamotanis dros ar iyo cnobilida TavisTavad, Tu sxva dadgenil garemoebasTan erTadamtkicebs msjavrdebulis udanaSaulobas an mis mier imdanaSaulze ufro msubuqi an ufro mZime danaSaulis Ca-denas, romlisTvisac mas msjavri daedo, agreTve amtki-cebs gamarTlebulis braleulobas an danaSaulis im pirismier Cadenas, romlis mimarTac sisxlissamarTlebrividevna Sewyvetili iyo;