This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
1
s i s x l i s s a m a r T a l is i s x l i s s a m a r T a l is i s x l i s s a m a r T a l is i s x l i s s a m a r T a l is i s x l i s s a m a r T a l i
k e r Z o n a w i l e b ik e r Z o n a w i l e b ik e r Z o n a w i l e b ik e r Z o n a w i l e b ik e r Z o n a w i l e b i
krebulSi gamoqveynebulia erTgvarovani sasamarTlo praqti-kis Camoyalibebisa da samarTlis ganviTarebisaTvis mniSvne-lovani gadawyvetilebebi. am da sxva saqmeTa moZebna SesaZle-belia saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos veb-gverdze:http://www.supremecourt.ge/default.aspx?sec_id=133&lang=1
5. quTaisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlissaqmeTa palatis 2016 wlis 18 noembris ganaCeni sakasaciowesiT gaasaCivra ozurgeTis raionuli prokuroris moad-gile malxaz siraZem. kasatori saCivriT iTxovs gasaCivre-buli ganaCenis gauqmebasa da g. t-s damnaSaved cnobas sa-qarTvelos ssk-is 19,108-e muxliT, Semdegi safuZvlebiT:sasamarTlom msjavrdebulis qmedeba arasworad daakvali-ficira, radgan ar gaiTvaliswina braldebis mxaris mier war-dgenili da sasamarTlo sxdomaze gamokvleuli mtkicebu-lebebi, romlebiTac utyuarad dasturdeba, rom g. t-s hqon-da dazaralebul g. T-s mokvlis ganzraxva, rac dasturde-ba mowmeebis _ i. g-s, g. T-sa da m. T-s erTnairi da Tanmimdev-ruli CvenebebiT; aseve sagulisxmoa sasamarTlo-samedi-cino eqspertizis daskvna da eqim l. T-s Cveneba, romlebi-Tac dadgenilia, rom Wrilobis arxis mimarTuleba iyo wina
5
mxridan, maxvilisebri morCidan zemoT da ukana mimarTu-lebiT (gulis mimarTulebiT), xolo Wrilobis arxis sigrZeiyo 15 sm da dazianeba iwyeba muclis aridan. trasologiu-ri eqspertizis daskvniT dadgenilia, rom g. T-s tansac-mels aReniSneba iribad mdebare, napraliseburi gamWolidazianeba. zemoaRniSnuli ki imaze miuTiTebs, rom dazara-lebuli am saxis dazianebas ver miiRebda im viTarebaSi, ro-melic msjavrdebulma g. t-m aRwera.
ma sakasacio saCivris safuZvlianoba da daaskvna, romozurgeTis raionuli prokuroris moadgile malxaz sira-Zis sakasacio saCivari ar unda dakmayofildes, xolo ga-saCivrebuli ganaCeni unda darCes ucvlelad, Semdeg ga-remoebaTa gamo:
2. msjavrdebulma g. t-m sasamarTlo sxdomaze ganmar-ta, rom SemTxvevis dRes ..... imyofeboda ojaxis naTesavis _g. m-s dabadebis dReze. daaxloebiT 20 adamiani saRamos 7saaTisaTvis dajda sufrasTan. saxlSi myofi pirebidan ic-nobda mxolod: a. m-s, a. m-s, g. m-s da mezobel k-s, danarCene-bi misTvis ucnobebi iyvnen. sufras TviTon Tamadobda. i. x-m erT-erT sadRegrZeloze SeniSvna misca. musikis CarTvarodesac gadawyvita, i. x-m kvlav SeniSvna misca da uTxra,rom daleva surda. aRniSnulze Selaparakdnen da gavidnenoTaxidan. gareT sityvierad kamaTobdnen TviTon, i. x-i, i-sZma da v. b-i. fizikurad ar Sexebian erTmaneTs. saubris Sem-dgom dabrundnen sufrasTan da gaagrZeles qeifi. rode-sac cekva daiwyo, i. x-m sityvieri Seuracxyofa miayena, risgamoc kvlav daiwyes kamaTi. i. x-s sufris yvela wevri miex-mara da dauwyes cema. cemis dros davarda Zirs, miuxeda-vad amisa, ar gaCerdnen da kvlav Zlierad urtyamdnen. ce-mis Sedegad sxvadasxva dazianeba miiRo da sdioda sisxli.Cxubis dasrulebis Semdeg, dam _ l. t-m da a. m-m aiyvanessaxlis meore sarTulze. daaxloebiT 20 wuTSi i. x-m, i-s Zmamda orma pirma zemoT aakiTxes da pirdapir sawolSi dauw-yes sityvieri Seuracxyofis miyeneba da cema. aRniSnulisgamo gamoiqca samzareuloSi danis asaRebad da maT SesaSi-neblad, rom am gziT mainc daenebebinaT Tavi. rodesac Se-vida `...~ oTaxSi, iq imyofebodnen g. T-i, misi meuRle da g. T-i. Sevida samzareuloSi, aiRo dana da dabrunda `...~ oTaxSi,
6
radgan gareT gasvla undoda. marjvena xelSi eWira dana,piriT _ qvemoT. oTaxidan aivanze gasasvleli kari mixuru-li iyo. mivida karTan, marcxena xeliT gaaRo da vidre kar-Si gavidoda, g. T-m uknidan daiWira, welze xeli Semoxvia daar uSvebda. mis win da gverdiT, aseve karTan axlos aravinidga. g-m aswia cota zeviT, ise, rom miwas aacila, radganmisi SigniT Seyvana undoda. TviTon ki yviroda, rom gaeSvaxeli da iqnevda xelebs. am dros uknidan biZgi igrZno, g-mucabedad xeli gauSva, gaTavisuflda da gavida gareT. amdros ar daunaxavs g. T-i. gza rom gaagrZela ezoSi da 5-6metri gaiara, atyda yvirili, motrialda da maSin dainaxakaris zRurblze waqceuli g. T-i, romelsac sisxli sdioda.danas gauSva xeli, daagdo da g-sTan mivida. amSvidebda, wya-li gamoitana, Tavisi telefoniT saswrafoSi araerTxel da-reka, radgan igvianebda saswrafo daxmareba da momxdarsganicdida. misive ganmartebiT, g. T-i sufrasTan daaxloe-biT naxevari saaTi ijda. Semdgom ki Tavisi ojaxis wevreb-Tan erTad, sxva oTaxSi imyofeboda. g. T-i arc erT CxubSiar monawileobda da maT Soris dapirispireba ar arsebobda.
3. saqmeze mowmis saxiT dakiTxuli dazaralebulis _ g.T-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2015 wlis 13 noembers, g. m-s dabadebis dReze, imyofeboda mSoblebTan: i. g-sa da g.T-Tan, aseve debTan: m. da v. T-Tan erTad. rodesac stum-rad mividnen, saxlSi daxvdnen a. m-a, g. m-a, m. da mezoblisbiWebi. aq gaicno g. t-i. sufrasTan rodesac dasxdnen, g. t-s auSardnen iq myofi axalgazrdebi. dazaralebulis gan-martebiT, igi didxans ar gaCerebula sufrasTan, male ad-ga da mamamisTan _ g. T-Tan erTad gavida e.w. `...~ oTaxSi,sadac imyofeboda TviTon, dedamisi da ojaxis ufrosi _m.. g. t-s sufrasTan scemes, Semdeg igi aiyvanes meore sar-Tulze dasawolad, sadac kvlav aakiTxes biWebma da iqacscemes. aRniSnulze g. t-i gamwarda, Camoirbina kibe, Sevi-da e.w. `...~ oTaxSi, saidanc Sevida samzareuloSi da aiRodana. samzareulodan gamosul g. t-s surda gareT gasvlada karisken wavida. am dros uknidan mivida g. T-i da xele-bis SemoxveviT daakava igi. g. t-i eubneboda g-s, rom gaeSvada Tan iqnevda xelebs. misive ganmartebiT, dana dainaxamaSin, roca g. ukan iqnevda danian xels. mamas dauZaxa, romg-s dana hqonda xelSi, gaiqca mamisken da xeli ubiZga, Tvi-Ton ki veRar moaswro gaweva da am dros moxvda moqneulidana. dazaralebulis ganmartebiT, g. t-i wuxda misi daW-
7
ris gamo da mis mimarT raime pretenzia ar gaaCnia.4. mowme g. T-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom igi imyofebo-
da g. m-s dabadebis dReze _ 2015 wlis noemberSi meuRles-Tan _ i. g-sa da SvilebTan _ g-sTan, m-sa da v-sTan erTad.Tavdapirvelad wveuleba normalurad midioda, Semdeg kisufraze myofebma fizikuri Seuracxyofa miayenes g. t-s.igi `...~ oTaxSi gavida meuRlesa da SvilTan, g. T-Tan er-Tad. g. t-i ki l. t-m da a. m-m meore sarTulze aiyvanes.meore sarTulzec gagrZelda Cxubi da xmaurze misi meuR-le da m. gareT gavidnen. ucabedad wels zemoT SiSveli g.t-i Semovarda e.w. `...~ oTaxSi da pirdapir samzareuloSigavarda, saidanac puris saWreli dana gamoitana. am drosTviTon savarZelSi ijda, gaifiqra, rom daakavebda mas damivida g. t-Tan, uknidan welze Semoxvia xelebi da daiWi-ra. am dros ki gareT dainaxa i. x-i, romliskenac cdilobdat-i wasvlas. rodesac Svilma, g.T-m ubiZga beWebSi xeli,ausxlta t-ze Semoxveuli xeli. rogor da rodis moxvdamis Svils, g. T-s dana, ar daunaxavs. misive ganmartebiT, g.t-Tan raime uTanxmoeba an konfliqti ar hqonda.
5. mowme i. g-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom igi aris g. T-sdeda. g. t-i pirvelad 2015 wlis noemberSi g. m-s dabadebisdReze naxa, sadac imyofeboda meuRlesTan _ g. T-Tan daSvilebTan: g-Tan, m-sa da v-sTan erTad. sufrasTan g. t-ida adgilobrivi biWebi jer wakinklavdnen, Semdeg ki ga-davidnen Cxubze. man, meuRlem da Svilma _ g-m, adre da-toves sufra da e.w. `...~ oTaxSi gavidnen, sadac aseve imyo-febodnen m. da g. m-a. a. m-m da g. t-s dam _ l-m, g. t-i dasaZi-neblad saxlis meore sarTulze aiyvanes. 10 wuTis Semdegmeore sarTulzec atyda xmauri. konfliqtis dros misiSvili da meuRle gareT ar gasulan. TviTon ki gavida ga-reT da dainaxa, rom g. t-i kibeze Camorboda da e.w. `...~ oTa-xidan pirdapir samzareuloSi Sevarda. am dros TviTonda m-c Sevidnen e.w. ̀ ...~ oTaxSi. roca g. samzareulodan dab-runda, xelSi eWira dana. g. T-i wamoxta savarZlidan da g.t-s uknidan moxvia xelebi, romelsac saxe gasasvleli ka-risken hqonda. roca g. T-i akavebda g. t-s, igi g-s sityvierSeuracxyofas ayenebda. am dros misma Svilma dainaxa, romdaniani xeli mamisken hqonda mimarTuli da xeli ubiZgamamas gverdidan. swored am dros moxvda dana. misive gan-martebiT, uSualod danis dartymis momenti ar daunaxavs.g. t-m rom dainaxa g. T-s mdgomareoba, Zalian inerviula.
8
mowmis ganmartebiT, g. t-sa da g. an g. T-ebs Soris raimeSelaparakeba ar momxdara da g. t-s gamiznulad ar undodamisi SvilisaTvis danis dartyma.
6. mowme m. T-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom igi aris daza-ralebul g. T-s da, xolo g. m-a aris misi mamidaSvili. 2015wlis noemberSi stumrad iyvnen g. m-sTan dabadebis dRisaRsaniSnavad. sufris dros ar moewonaT erTmaneTis sau-bari g. m-s mezoblad mcxovreb biWebs da msjavrdebuls,rasac mohyva Cxubi. g. t-s scemes, daaxloebiT 7 kaci er-Tad scemda mas, romelsac mxolod misi da icavda. g. T-i kiadre adga sufridan da wavida im oTaxSi, sadac Rumeliiyo. g. t-s dam da misma mamidaSvilma _ a-m daawynares g. daaiyvanes meore sarTulze, sadac 5 wuTis Semdeg kvlav at-yda xmauri. cota xanSi g. t-m Camoirbina qvemoT da Sevar-da samzareuloSi, saidanac igi daniT gamovida, RumelTanmjdomi g. T-i wamoxta da gamoekida g-s, romelic win midi-oda, karisken. g. daewia mas da uknidan daukava xelebi. g.t-s dana marjvena xelSi eWira, uazrod iqnevda xelebs dayviroda. am dros g. T-m ifiqra, rom g-s SeiZleboda danamoxvedroda, mivida da xeli hkra mamas, ra drosac Sem-TxveviT TviTon daiWra.
7. mowme m. m-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom g. T-i aris misimazlis SviliSvili, xolo g. t-i maTTan bevrjer iyo namyo-fi stumrad. 2015 wlis 13 noembers SviliSvils _ g. m-s 18weli Seusrulda. dabadebis dReze stumrad iyvnen b-i, l.da b. b-ebi, k. C-e, i. da g. x-ebi, g. T-i col-SviliT. sufrazepirvelad patara Cxubi moxda da dawynardnen. Semdeg ki di-di Cxubi atyda. g. t-s sufris wevrebi eCxubnen, ris gamocigi avida meore sarTulze dasawolad. g-s zemoT ahyvnen a.m-a da misi da _ l.. arc meore sarTulze moeSvnen g. t-s,sadac aakiTxes biWebma. kvlav gaisma Cxubis xma. am dros g.t-i qvemoT aRelvebuli Camovida, Sevida e.w. `...~ oTaxSi daSemdeg, samzareuloSi. g-m aiRo dana da dabrunda `...~ oTax-Si, sadac imyofebodnen g. T-i, i., m., v. da g.. m. m-s ganmarte-biT, dauZaxa biWebs, rom braldebuls dana hqonda xelSi. g-s dana ise eWira, rom danis wveri qvemoT iyo mimarTuli.rodesac g. t-m `...~ oTaxidan gareT gasasvleli kari gamoa-Ro, am dros xeli ukan waiRo, karTan axlos idga g. T-i, ro-melsac SemTxveviT moxvda danis wveri. g. t-s g. T-Tvis danaar mouqnevia. g. t-i ar gaqceula, iTxovda saswrafos gamo-Zaxebas, patronobda daWrils da ganicdida momxdars. mi-
9
sive ganmartebiT, g. t-i da g. T-i erTmaneTs ar icnobdnenda raime saxis Selaparakeba maT Soris ar momxdara.
8. mowme a. m-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom igi cxovrobs ...,... quCis me-... Sesaxvevis #...-Si, bebiasTan _ m. m-Tan, ZmasTan_ g. m-sTan, deidaSvilTan _ a. m-sa da deidaSvilis SvilTan_ l. e-Tan erTad. 2015 wlis 13 noembers, g. m-s dabadebisdReze, sufrasTan isxdnen: v. b-vi, i. da g. x-ebi, b. b-e, naTe-savebi: g., g., i., v. da m. T-ebi, g. da l. t-ebi da ojaxis wverebi.wveulebis dros v. b-i da i. x-i cinikurad uyurebdnen g. t-s.Semdeg g. t-s mimarT gamoTqves SeniSvnebi, Tu ratom ar am-bobda sadRegrZelos. Tavidan sityvierad Selaparakdnen,Semdeg ki g. t-s scemes sufris wevrebma. g. Cxubis dros wa-iqca da waqceuls urtyamda yvela. rodesac misi cema Sew-yvites, meore sarTulze aiyvana da daawvina. cota xanSi avi-da g. da _ l. t-i. daaxloebiT 8-10 wuTSi maTTan avida g. x-a,romelmac dauwyo saqmis garCeva g. t-s. am saubrisas asevezeviT avidnen i. da g. x-ebi. i-m dauwyo gineba da atyda Cxu-bi. uceb i. qvemoT gaiqca da g-c gavida gareT. TviTon ki g-seCxubeboda, Tu ratom avidnen zemoT da uceb gaigona saSi-neli kivilis xma. rodesac qvemoT Cavida, naxa rom g. T-isaZineblis karTan iyo waqceuli da sisxli sdioda, g. t-i kiyviroda, rom saswrafoSi daerekaT. g. T-s saswrafos mos-vlamde g. t-i wyals asxamda da elaparakeboda, rom gonebaar daekarga. igi TavSi icemda xels, ganicdida da ver mim-xvdariyo, rogor moxda es SemTxveva.
9. mowme i. x-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2015 wlis 13noembers, g. m-s dabadebis dReze, igi mivida daaxloebiTsaRamos 5-6 saaTze, iq daxvdnen: v. b-i, k. C-e da misi Zma,sxvebi ki ver icno. sufrasTan dasxdnen daaxloebiT 6 sa-aTze. Tamada iyo g. t-i, romelsac aseve ar icnobda. suf-rasTan g. t-s eCxuba, radgan sadRegrZelosTan dakavSi-rebiT ver SeTanxmdnen. Cxubi daaxloebiT 10-20 wuTsgrZeldeboda. g. t-s mxolod erTxel eCxuba, ra drosac g.Zirs daeca. amis Semdgom ki saxlSi wavida. rodesac dab-runda ezoSi gaigona yvirilis xma. saxlSi g. T-i Zirs iwva.m-gan ki gaigo, rom igi daniT iyo daWrili.
10. mowme b. b-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom g. t-i sufras-Tan gaicno, g. m-s dabadebis dReze, 2015 wlis 13 noembers.saRamos mivida maTTan, sufra ukve gaSlili iyo. saxlSi iy-vnen misi mezoblebi: k. C-e, g. da i. x-ebi, a. m-a da ucxo pirebi.sufrasTan daaxloebiT naxevar saaTs gaCerda da Semdeg
10
wavida. sufrasTan kamaTi iyo mosmena _ ar mosmenis gamo dasadRegrZeloebTan dakavSirebiT. Tamada iTxovda wesrigs,rasac sufris wevrebi, ar emorCilebodnen. Tamadis mowo-deba sufris wevrebisadmi g. T-s ar exeboda. mogvinebiT m.m-sgan gaigo Tamadis _ g. t-s mier g. T-s daWris faqti.
11. mowmis saxiT dakiTxuli qirurgiuli ganyofilebisxelmZRvanelis, l. T-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom g. T-s Wri-loba hqonda muclis zemo naxevarSi da gaWrili iyo mar-jvena parkuWi. Wrilobis mimarTuleba iyo qvemodan ze-moT. ultrabgeriTi gamokvleviT dadginda, rom gadide-buli iyo gulis sazRvrebi. Wriloba maxvili sagniT, al-baT, daniT iyo miyenebuli da Wrilobis arxi sakmaod grZe-li, daaxloebiT 15 sm mainc iqneboda.
21. palata iziarebs saapelacio sasamarTlos ganmarte-bas, rom pirisaTvis sicocxlisaTvis saxifaTo dazianebismiyenebis SemTxvevaSi unda gairkves, hqonda Tu ara bral-debuls misi mokvlis an/da misTvis janmrTelobis mZime da-zianebis miyenebis ganzraxva, rac unda dadgindes ara mxo-lod miyenebuli Wrilobebis lokalizaciisa da simZimis mi-xedviT, aramed _ Cadenili danaSaulis yvela faqtobrivigaremoebis erToblivi analizisa da urTierTSejerebis sa-fuZvelze, kerZod: unda Sefasdes Wrilobebis raodenobada xasiaTi, danaSaulebrivi qmedebis Cadenis garemoebebida qmedebis Sewyvetis mizezebi, braldebulisa da dazara-lebulis urTierTdamokidebuleba, maTi qmedebebi dana-Saulis Cadenamde da mis Semdeg. saapelacio sasamarTlomgansakuTrebuli yuradReba gaamaxvila im garemoebaze, romg. t-s g. T-s ganzrax mokvlis raime sababi ar gaaCnda, rasacmTlianad eTanxmeba sakasacio palata.
22. sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom qmedebis ganzraxmkvlelobad (mcdelobad) dakvalificirebisaTvis auci-lebelia, dadgindes subieqtis ganzraxva, misi mizanmimar-Tuli qmedeba dazaralebulis sicocxlis mosaspobad,amasTan, unda dadgindes faqtobrivad ganxorcielebulqmedebasa da damdgar Sedegs Soris mizezobrivi kavSiri,romelTa gareSec qmedebis ganzrax mkvlelobad (mcdelo-bad) dakvalificireba samarTlebriv safuZvels moklebu-li iqneba.
23. palata srulad iziarebs pirveli da saapelacio sa-samarTloebis motivacias da dadgenilad miaCnia, rom g. t-s ar hqonda dazaralebul g. T-s mokvlis ganzraxva, rac da-dasturebulia Tavad dazaralebul g. T-s, misi mSoblebis_ g. T-sa da i. g-s, dis _ m. T-s, mowmis _ m. m-sa da msjavrde-bul g. t-s CvenebebiT. kerZod, miTiTebuli mowmeebis Cve-nebebiT, romlebic arian SemTxvevis TviTmxilvelebi, ir-kveva, rom g. t-i samzareuloSi Sevida `...~ oTaxis gavliT,aiRo dana, dabrunda imave oTaxSi da undoda gareT gasvla,sadac imyofeboda i. x-i. ̀ ...~ oTaxSi gavlisas man dainaxa oTax-Si myofi mama-Svili _ g. da g. T-ebi, Tumca g. t-m arc erTmaTgans ar miaqcia yuradReba da wavida pirdapir karisken,raTa gasuliyo gareT da enaxa i. x-i. amdenad, im viTarebaSi,rodesac g. t-m `...~ oTaxSi dainaxa g. T-i, Tuki marTla iyomasze ganawyenebuli da hqonda misi mokvlis ganzraxva, ma-Sin mas ar Cauvlida gverdiT, wavidoda pirdapir misken an-
14
gariSsworebis mizniT da ara _ karisken. dadgenilia is faq-tic, rom g. t-i uknidan SeboWa mxolod g. T-m da swored manar misca gareT gasvlis saSualeba, xolo g. T-i wavida mamis-ken, raTa mas ar moxvedroda dana da xeli hkra ara g. t-s,aramed mamas _ g. T-s. aRniSnuliT dasturdeba is faqti, romg. T-i winaaRmdegobas ar uwevda msjavrdebuls. Sesabami-sad, g. t-i g. T-ze ver ganawyendeboda im momentSi, rodesacmas ar mieca gareT gasvlis SesaZlebloba da, bunebrivia arwarmoeSoboda survili, daeZlia dazaralebulis winaaR-mdegoba da daniT gasworeboda mas.
24. amdenad, sakasacio palatas dadgenilad miaCnia Sem-degi: msjavrdebuli g. t-i da dazaralebuli g. T-i g. m-sdabadebis dRis aRsaniSnav wveulebamde erTmaneTs ar ic-nobdnen. wveulebaze msjavrdebulsa da g. T-s Soris Sela-parakeba ar momxdara. dapirispireba gamokveTilad arse-bobda i. x-sa da g. t-s Soris. sufris ramdenime wevrma fizi-kuri Seuaracxyofa miayena g. t-s, ris Semdegac igi gaari-des dapirispirebas da aiyvanes saxlis meore sarTulze,Tumca ramdenime wuTSi iq mas kvlav miayenes fizikuri Seu-racxyofa. aRniSnulze ganawyenebuli g. t-i Camovida pir-vel sarTulze, e.w. `...~ oTaxidan Sevida samzareuloSi, ai-Ro dana, daapira gareT gasvla da i. x-Tan misvla. am dros g.T-i imyofeboda `...~ oTaxSi da ijda savarZelSi. g. T-m daina-xa gasasvleli karisken mimavali g. t-i, romelsac xelSi eWi-ra dana, wamoxta savarZlidan da gaiqca misi mimarTulebiT,raTa ar mieca misTvis gareT gasvlis saSualeba. daewia, xe-lebi moxvia uknidan da Seakava. g. t-m Tavis daRwevis miz-niT, umisamarTod daiwyo xelebis qneva, ra drosac mis winda gverdiT aravin idga. am dros g. T-m dainaxa g. t-s xelSidana, ris gamoc mamis _ g. T-s dacvis mizniT, mivida mamas-Tan, uknidan ubiZga xeli g-s da am dros mas SemTxveviT mox-vda g. t-s mier moqneuli dana. mas Semdeg, rac g. T-m g. t-sxelebi gauSva, g. t-i gaiqca gareT i. x-s mimarTulebiT, mag-ram ramdenime metris gavlis Semdeg, kivilis xmaze isevukan dabrunda da dainaxa daWrili g. T-i, daxeda danas, ro-melsac sisxli hqonda, daagdo da mivida masTan. msjavrde-buli Sewuxda, wyali miutana dazaralebuls da Seecada mismosulierebas, rac metyvelebs imaze, rom g. t-s ar hqondamisi mokvlis an janmrTelobis dazianebis ganzraxva. amas-Tan, g. t-s, Tuki marTlac hqonda dazaralebulis mokvlisganzraxva, SeeZlo misi sisruleSi moyvana da g. T-Tvis kvlav
15
dazianebebis miyeneba, Tumca man araTu agresia gamoxatadazarallebulis mimarT, aramed gaocda da Sewuxda mom-xdari faqtis gamo.
25. zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, usafuZvloa bral-debis mxaris pozicia, rom g. t-i ganawyenebuli iyo g. T-zeTavdapirvelad, zogadad, rogorc sufris erT-erT wev-rze, xolo mogvianebiT _ im mizeziT, rom man ar misca oTa-xidan gareT gasvlis saSualeba, ris gamoc gauCnda g. T-smokvlis ganzraxva. aRniSnuli warmoadgens braldebis mxa-ris varauds, ar gamomdinareobs saqmeze Sekrebili mtki-cebulebebidan da ewinaaRmdegeba mowmeTa Cvenebebs.
27. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom mocemul saqmeze qu-Taisis saapelacio sasamarTlos mier g. t-s mimarT gamo-tanili ganaCeni aris kanonieri da ar arsebobs misi gauq-mebis safuZveli.
2. p. f-s mier Cadenili qmedebebi gamoixata SemdegSi:
17
2015 wlis 31 maiss, saRamos saaTebSi, ... raionis so-fel ... p. f-e mivida mezoblad mcxovreb d. b-s ojaxSi, sa-dac im dros marto imyofebodnen d. b-s arasrulwlovaniSvilebi _ a., v. da m. b-ebi. p. f-m Tavdapirvelad a. b-s, xoloSemdeg v. b-s uTxra, rom sigaretis SesaZenad maRaziaSigahyoloda. aRniSnulze maTgan uari miiRo, Tumca sabo-lood maRaziaSi gayolaze daiTanxma 10 wlis m. b-e. masTanerTad, p. f-e fexiT gaemarTa ..., ... quCaze mdebare `...~ af-TiaqSi, sadac SeiZina sqesobrivi potenciis asamaRlebe-li 2 abi medikamenti `...~, saidanac nawili p. f-m miiRo, xo-lo nawilis miReba m. b-s mosTxova, romelmac mas medika-menti gamoarTva, magram ar daulevia da misgan faruladgadaagdo. amis Semdeg p. f-e m. b-Tan erTad, fexiT gaemar-Ta sofel ... mimarTulebiT. p. f-m, surda ra 10 wlis asakisumweo mdgomareobaSi myof m. b-Tan sqesobrivi kavSirisdamyareba, romelsac mcire asakis gamo ar SeeZlo winaaR-mdegobis gaweva da aseve ar SeeZlo gaeTviTcnobierebina,Tu ra xdeboda mis Tavs, igi gadaiyvana gzis piras arsebulvenaxSi. p. f-m m. b-s mosTxova miwaze dajdoma, rac man Se-asrula. amis Semdeg Caxada Sarvali da trusi, SeSinebul-ma m. b-m uTxra, rom undoda debTan wasvla, razec p-m uT-xra, rom gaCumebuliyo, Torem moklavda, gagudavda, ma-le morCebodnen da wavidodnen saxlSi. Tavad p. f-m wel-qvemoT gaixada, ris Semdegac m. b-e muxlebze daayena. p. f-m sasqeso organoze moirgo prezervativi da arasrulwlo-van m. b-Tan, sicocxlis mospobis muqariT daamyara sqe-sobrivi kavSiri, riTac m. b-s saqalwulo apkis mimdebared,lorwovanze miayena dazianebebi muqi mowiTalo feris sis-xlCaqcevebis saxiT. sabolood, p. f-m m. b-s gaupatiure-biT daikmayofila sqesobrivi Jini da adgilze CaeZina, xo-lo m. b-e ki saxlSi gaiqca. aRniSnulis Semdeg p. f-e miima-la da gatarebuli RonisZiebebis Sedegad igi daakaves 2015wlis 4 ivniss ... raionis sofel ...-Si.
2015 wlis 31 maiss, saRamos saaTebSi, ... raionis sofel... p. f-e mivida mezoblad mcxovreb d. b-s ojaxSi, sadac imdros marto imyofebodnen am ukanasknelis arasrulwlo-vani Svilebi _ a., v. da m. b-ebi. p. f-m Tavdapirvelad a. b-s,xolo Semdeg v. b-s uTxra, rom sigaretis SesaZenad maRa-ziaSi gahyoloda. aRniSnulze uari miiRo, Tumca sabolo-od maRaziaSi gayolaze daiTanxma 10 wlis m. b-e. masTan er-Tad p. f-e fexiT gaemarTa ..., ... quCaze mdebare `...~ afTiaq-
18
Si, sadac SeiZina sqesobrivi potenciis asamaRlebeli 2 abimedikamenti `...~, saidanac nawili p. f-m miiRo, xolo nawi-lis miReba m. b-s mosTxova, romelmac mas medikamenti ga-moarTva, Tumca ar daulevia da misgan farulad gadaag-do. amis Semdeg p. f-e m. b-Tan erTad fexiT gaemarTa so-fel ... mimarTulebiT. p. f-m, surda ra 10 wlis asakis umweomdgomareobaSi myof m. b-Tan sqesobrivi kavSiris damya-reba, romelsac mcire asakis gamo ar SeeZlo winaaRmdego-bis gaweva da aseve ar SeeZlo gaeTviTcnobierebina Tu raxdeboda mis Tavs, m. b-e gadaiyvana gzis piras arsebul ve-naxSi. p. f-m m. b-s mosTxova miwaze dajdoma, rac man Seas-rula. ramdenime xanSi Caxada Sarvali da trusi, SeSine-bulma m. b-m uTxra, rom undoda debTan wasvla. p. f-e dae-muqra mokvliT, uTxra, rom gaCumebuliyo, Torem gagu-davda da moklavda, ris Semdegac m. b-e muxlebze daayena.amis Semdeg p. f-m xelis TiTze moirgo prezervativi damoaTavsa jer m. b-s sasqeso organoSi, xolo Semdeg _ ukanatanSi. tkivilis gamo m. b-e tiroda da debTan wasvlas iT-xovda, Tumca p. f-e mas gagudviT daemuqra. aRniSnulisSemdeg p. f-m Tavis sasqeso organoze moirgo prezervati-vi, dajda da m. b-s ukana tanSi moaTavsa sasqeso organo. p.f-s mier m. b-s ukana tanSi sasqeso organos moTavsebiT, m.b-m ukana tanis areSi miiRo dazianebebi naskdomebis sa-xiT, mimdebared _ muqi mowiTalo feris sisxlCaqcevebiT.ramdenime xnis Semdeg, kvlav gagudvis muqariT, p. f-m Ta-visi sasqeso organo moaTavsa m. b-s piris RruSi. aRniSnu-liT p. f-m m. b-Tan gaukuRmarTebuli formiT daamyara seq-sualuri kontaqti, ris Semdegac adgilze CaeZina, xolom. b-e saxlSi gaiqca. aRniSnulis Semdeg p. f-e miimala dagatarebuli RonisZiebebis Sedegad igi daakaves 2015 wlis4 ivniss ... raionis sofel ....
p. f-m gamoZiebiT daudgenel garemoebebSi ukanonodSeiZina da Seinaxa didi odenobiT narkotikuli saSualeba_ 0.251027 grami `heroini~, romelic ... raionis sofel ... Ca-tarebuli misi piradi Cxrekisas amoiRes policiis muSa-kebma.
nivTieri mtkicebulebebi: `...~ afTiaqis saTvalTvalosistemis daTvalierebisas amoRebuli videoCanaweri DVDdiskze, romelic erTvis sisxlis samarTlis saqmes, Sena-xul unda iqnes saqmis Senaxvis vadiT; sagamoZiebo eqspe-rimentis (m. b-s Cvenebis Semowmeba) dros gadaRebuli fo-tomasala CD diskze, romelic erTvis sisxlis samarTlissaqmes, Senaxul unda iqnes saqmis Senaxvis vadiT; ss `...~saTvalTvalo sistemis daTvalierebisas amoRebuli vide-oCanaweri DVD diskze, romelic erTvis sisxlis samar-
20
Tlis saqmes, Senaxul unda iqnes saqmis Senaxvis vadiT;adgilmdebareobis daTvalierebis dros gadaRebuli fo-tomasala CD diskze, romelic erTvis sisxlis samarTlissaqmes, Senaxul unda iqnes saqmis Senaxvis vadiT; p. f-sada m. b-gan aRebuli biologiuri kvlevis (nerwyvis) nimu-Sebi, romlebic inaxeba ... Ss raionul sammarTveloSi, un-da ganadgurdes saqmeze saboloo gadawyvetilebis miRe-bis Semdeg; m. b-gan aRebuli sisxlis nimuSi, romelic ina-xeba ... Ss raionul sammarTveloSi, unda ganadgurdes saq-meze saboloo gadawyvetilebis miRebis Semdeg; p. f-s pi-radi Cxrekisas amoRebuli narkotikuli saSuleba _ `he-roini~, romelic inaxeba Ss saministros Sesabamis samsa-xurSi, unda ganadgurdes saqmeze saboloo gadawyvetile-bis miRebis Semdeg; p. f-s piradi Cxrekisas amoRebuli p.f-s CanTa da masSi arsebuli tansacmeli, TeTreuli, pir-saxoci da sayofacxovrebo nivTebi, mobiluri telefoni`samsungi~, Savi tyavis safule da masSi moTavsebuli `lai-lais~ ori simbaraTi, bilainis erTi simbaraTi, liberTibankis erTi da `psp~-s erTi baraTi, erTi `marwyvi~ baraTi,romlebic inaxeba ... Ss raionul sammarTveloSi, unda da-ubrundes p. f-s an/da misi ojaxis wevrs, saqmeze saboloogadawyvetilebis miRebis Semdeg; sagamoZiebo eqsperimen-tis (m. b-s Cvenebis Semowmeba) dros amoRebuli ori pre-zervativi, boTlis erTi Tavsaxuri da namwvavis nimuSi,romlebic inaxeba ... Ss raionul sammarTveloSi, unda ga-nadgurdes saqmeze saboloo gadawyvetilebis miRebis Sem-deg; daTvalierebis dros amoRebuli m. b-s qveda sacvali,romelic inaxeba ... Ss raionul sammarTveloSi, unda ga-nadgurdes saqmeze saboloo gadawyvetilebis miRebis Sem-deg; daTvalierebis dros amoRebuli m. b-s maisuri, rome-lic inaxeba ... Ss raionul sammarTveloSi, unda ganadgur-des saqmeze saboloo gadawyvetilebis miRebis Semdeg; m.b-gan eqspertis mier aRebuli nacxis nimuSi, romelic ina-xeba ... Ss raionul sammarTveloSi, unda ganadgurdes saq-meze saboloo gadawyvetilebis miRebis Semdeg.
ma sakasacio saCivrebis safuZvlianoba da daaskvna, rommsjavrdebul p. f-s interesebis damcveli advokatebis _d. s-s, T. n-sa da zestafonis raionuli prokuraturis pro-kuror koba siraZis sakasacio saCivrebi ar unda dakmayo-fildes, xolo gasaCivrebuli ganaCeni unda darCes ucvle-lad, Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
3. arasrulwlovani dazaralebulis _ m. b-s sasamarTlosxdomaze mowmis saxiT micemuli CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom2015 wlis 31 maiss maTTan saxlSi mivida p. f-e, romelmacjer mis debs _ a. da v. b-ebs sTxova maRaziaSi gayola, vina-idan vali hqonda da TviTon ver Sedioda, xolo maTganuaris miRebis Semdeg mas sTxova maRaziaSi gayola sigare-tis sayidlad. m. mas dasTanxmda da wahyva, vinaidan dar-wmunebuli iyo, rom namdvilad vali hqonda da ver Sedio-da maRaziaSi. gzaSi p. ekiTxeboda, ra erqva da ra gvari iyo,mkerdi hqonda Tu ara gazrdili, menstruacia Tu hqonda.Tavdapirvelad `...~ afTiaqTan mividnen, ra drosac is sa-darbazosTan datova, p. f-m ki raRac iyida. maRaziaSi Se-vidnen, Sokoladebi iyides, Semdeg isev `.~ afTiaqTan mi-vida p.f-e, m. ki gverdiT mdebare bankTan daayena, uTxra,ar ganZreuliyo, dalodeboda da isic male mividoda. ro-desac gamovida, wamali amoiRo parkidan, naxevari mas mis-ca, naxevari TviTon dalia da uTxra, daelia. gza ganag-rZes, man wamali Cumad gadmoagdo, p. rom ar daenaxa. `...parkSi~ rodesac Sevidnen, dainaxes gogo da biWi, erTma-neTs exveodnen, p-m uTxra, `ase varT Cvenc~. gza ganagrZessoflis mimarTulebiT, ra drosac SexvdaT TeTri manqanada SesTavazes p. f-s saxlamde miyvana, Tumca man uariTupasuxa, vinaidan ukve axlos iyvnen saxlTan. Cavidnen ve-naxebSi, sadac muxa dgas, p. f-m uTxra damjdariyo. ramde-nime xanSi Sarvali da sacvali Caxada. SeeSinda, uTxra, romdebTan undoda, p-m ki upasuxa, gaCumebuliyo, Torem ga-gudavda da moklavda, morCebodnen da male wavidodnen.uTxra xelebze da fexebze damdgariyo, mas SeeSinda daSeasrula. marjvena saCvenebl TiTze raRac wamoicva p-mda jer ukana tanSi, xolo Semdeg win moaTavsa, igrZno tki-vili da uTxra, rom debTan undoda, p-m ki upasuxa, gaCum-di, Torem gaggudav da mogklavo. aRniSnulis Semdeg p. f-m Sarvali da sacvali gaixada, sasqeso organoze raRac wa-moicva da jer ukana tanSi moaTavsa, xolo Semdeg _ missasqeso organoSi. m. b-m igrZno Zlieri tkivili da sisxliwamouvida, momxdaridan male msjavrdebuli balaxze daw-va da aiZula m. b-e, rom misi sasqeso organo moewova. ram-
4. mowme a. b-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2015 wlis 31maiss maTTan saxlSi mivida p. f-e. mas da v-s sTxova maRazi-aSi gayola, vinaidan vali hqonda da TviTon ver Sedioda.a-m da v-m uari uTxres. aRniSnulis Semdeg p. f-s TxovniTm. b-e gahyva maRaziaSi, miuxedavad imisa, rom man dauSala.saxlSi darCa v. b-sa da g. m-Tan erTad. m-s saxlSi misvladaagvinda. g. m-m uTxra, rom telefoniT esaubra p-s da ma-le dabrundebodnen. miuxedavad aRniSnulisa, m. ar dab-runda. Semdeg g-m kvlav daureka p-s. a-s uTxra, rom ... iy-vnen p. da m. da male dabrundebodnen. Rame, gvian dabrun-da m. saxlSi, romelic ezoSi msxlis xesTan idga da tiro-da. misi dis _ v-s kiTxvaze, Tu ra moxda, pasuxs ar scemda.meore diliT, rodesac is da m. skolaSi midiodnen, hkiT-xa, ra moxda wina dRes, ra drosac m-m upasuxa `ar undodagaxseneba, daviwyeba undoda~ da tiroda. mis kiTxvebze`Cagxada~, `Segexo~ _ m-m dadebiTi pasuxi gasca. skolaSiklasels _ m. g-s mouyva momxdaris Sesaxeb, romelmac, Ta-vis mxriv, maswavlebels uambo a-s naTqvami.
5. mowme r. C-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2015 wlis 2ivniss, sami ricxvi rom Tendeboda, mas daukavSirda misida _ k. C-e da uTxra, rom misi Svili m. b-e viRacas hyavdawayvanili da nawvalebi iyo. 3 ivniss, saRamos, debTan _ f.da e. C-Tan erTad mivida ... raionis sofel ..., d. b-s sacxov-rebel saxlSi. Tavidan araferi uTqvamT, xolo mas Semdeg,rac ezoSi yofnis dros Semoesma kivilisa da tirilis xma,Sevida saxlSi da debisgan gaigo, rom 2015 wlis 31 maiss,daaxloebiT 23:00-00:00 drois monakveTSi p. f-m m. b-e waiy-vana maRaziaSi da kanfetebi uyida, Semdeg afTiaqSi wama-li da prezervativi iyida. m. miiyvana venaxebSi, muxasTanda sqesobrivi kavSiri daamyara. mowmis ganmartebiT, sanamsqesobriv kavSirs daamyarebda m-Tan, p.f-e daemuqra mok-vliT.
6. mowme m. t-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2015 wlis 1 iv-niss mis rZals, T.(T.) b-s daukavSirdnen skolidan da uT-xres, rom misi ZmisSvili SeSinebuli iyo. a., v. da m. b-ebi
25
miiyvanes maTTan saxlSi, .... 2015 wlis 3 ivniss, rodesac im-yofebodnen ... raionis sofel ..., n. b-gan gaigo, rom p. f-m m.b-e waiyvana RamiT, afTiaqSi raRac iyida, m-s wamali misca,Tumca m-m ar dalia. Semdeg venaxebSi Seiyvana da masTan wi-nidan daamyara sqesobrivi kavSiri. efereboda, tuCebSikocnida, aseve moefera sxeulis qveda nawilSic. mamakacissasqeso organo miado winidan, ra drosac m-s sisxli wamou-vida da tkivili igrZno. mowmis ganmartebiT, rodesac m. b-e miiyvanes maTTan saxlSi, bavSvma uTxra, rom `qveviT efxa-neboda~, Sevida abazanaSi da ibanava. momxdaris Sesaxeb 2015wlis 3 ivniss telefoniT mouyva T. (T.) b-s.
7. mowme T. T-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2015 wlis 1ivniss skolis maswavleblebma misi ZmisSvilebi _ a., v. da m.b-ebi miuyvanes saxlSi,... raionSi. mis kiTxvaze m-m ar upa-suxa. rodesac bavSvebi, dedamisi da m. t-e ... gamouSva, Sem-deg gaigo, rom p. f-m m. b-e saxlidan waiyvana 31 maiss. m-swamali miawoda dasalevad, m-m ar dalia, Cumad gadmoag-do. Semdeg venaxebSi, muxasTan, m. b-Tan sqesobrivi kavSi-ri daamyara wina mxridan. p. f-e mokvliT emuqreboda m. b-s, rom ar eTqva momxdaris Sesaxeb. mowmis ganmartebiT,rodesac m. b-e abazanaSi Sevida, uTxra, rom marto ibana-vebda da Seyola ar undoda. saxlSi naxa sacvali, romeliciyo TeTri da qveda mxares vardisferi iyo mTlianad. aR-niSnuli sacvali gamomZieblma amoiRo,xolo man Sesabamisdokumentze xeli moawera.
8. mowme g. g-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom muSaobs ... sko-laSi pedagogad. 2015 wlis 1 ivniss skolaSi a. b-e tiroda.miuxedavad misi kiTxvisa, pasuxs ar scemda. Semdeg masTanmivida moswavle m. g-e da uTxra, rom m. b-e Rame, gvian me-zoblis kacma waiyvana da masze iZalada. aRniSnuli gadaa-mowma a-Tan, rac a-m daudastura. mogvianebiT direqto-risgan gaigo (romelic esaubra T. b-s), rom m. b-e gaaupati-ura mezobelma p. f-m. tansacmeli gaxada m-s da Zala ixma-ra. m-ze ganxorcielda seqsualuri Zaladoba.
9. analogiuri faqtobrivi garemoebebi daadasturesmowmeebma _ ... raionis sofel ... skolis direqtorma e. e-mda amave skolis pedagogma n. m-m.
10. mowme d. b-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom igi aris m. b-smama. 2015 wlis 1 ivniss, orSabaTs, saRamos, daureka Zmis-Svilma da uTxra, Casuliyo ubanSi da gaerkvia, ra xdebo-da bavSvebTan dakavSirebiT. rodesac mivida saxlSi, m. b-
26
sa da S-gan Seityo, rom p. f-m m. b-e gaaupatiura. ambis ga-sarkvevad daureka p-s, Tumca mas telefoni gamorTulihqonda. mogvianebiT Tavad p. daukavSirda da uTxra, romnaxva undoda. Semdeg piradad m-m detalurad uambo mom-xdari faqtis Sesaxeb. mowmis ganmartebiT, igi Sexvda p. f-s, Tumca man yvelaferi uaryo.
11. mowme m. m-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom muSaobs ..., ...quCaze mdebare `...~ afTiaqSi. 2015 wlis 31 maiss igi morigeiyo, am dros afTiaqSi mivida mamakaci, romelmac ikiTxawamali _ `...~ da ra dozebi hqondaT, razec upasuxa, romhqondaT _ 50 da 100 _ miligramiani abebi. momxmarebelmamoiTxova _ 50 _ miligramiani ori abi. m. m-m gamouwera dagadasca. daaxloebiT 15 wuTSi isev mivida aRniSnuli pirida iyida wyali. igi iyo 40 wlamde asakis mamakaci, saSualoaRnagobis, Savi zeda ecva. gamomZiebelma afTiaqis video-kamerebi ramdenime dRis Semdeg daaTvaliera, romelSicmonawileobdnen _ afTiaqis menejeri, l. p-i da Tavad igi.Sedga dokumenti, romelsac man moawera xeli. gamomZie-bels gadasces 31 maiss gamowerili faqtura da Ceki.
12. mowme T. k-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom muSaobs ... qu-Caze mdebare `...~ afTiaqSi. 2015 wlis ivnisSi gamomZiebel-ma daaTvaliera da amoiRo miTiTebuli afTiaqis gare saT-valTvalo videokamerebis Canawerebi. gamomZieblma Sead-gina oqmi, rac daadastura xelis moweriT.
13. mowmeebis: l. p-s, a. v-s, p. l-s, a. a-s, z. g-sa da T. S-sCvenebebiT dadgenilia, rom isini muSaoben ... Ss raionulsammarTveloSi da p. f-s mimarT sisxlis samarTlis saqme-ze Caatares sxvadasxva sagamoZiebo moqmedebebi.
14. p. f-s dakavebisa da piradi Cxrekis oqmis Tanaxmad,misi piradi Cxrekisas amoiRes telefoni, sigaretis ver-cxlisfer qaRaldSi moTavsebuli fxvnilisebri masa, tya-vis Savi safule da momwvano xelCanTa, romelSic moTav-sebuli iyo tansacmeli, TeTreuli, pirsaxoci da sayofac-xovrebo nivTebi.
15. 2015 wlis 4 ivnisis daTvalierebis oqmiT dadgeni-lia, rom RamiT, xelovnuri ganaTebis pirobebSi daTvali-erda T. b-s mier warmodgenili, m. b-s kuTvnili qveda sac-vali, romelic aris movardisfro, Ria mwvane sartyele-biT, gamWvirvale da wiTeli Tvlebis ornamentiT. qvedasacvalze aRiniSneba sisxlismagvari laqebi. daTvaliere-bis Semdeg gamomZiebelma m. b-s qveda sacvali amoiRo da
genetikuri profili identuria. ob. #5,6,7-is profileb-Si p. f-s (ob. #26) genetikuri Tanamonawileoba gamoric-xuli ar aris.
20. aRniSnuli eqspertizis daskvnis siswore daadas-tures sasamarTlo sxdomaze mowmis saxiT dakiTxulma eq-spertebma _ i. m-m da T. g-m.
21. mowmis saxiT dakiTxuli eqspertis _ T. g-s ganmar-tebiT, m. b-s sacvlis Sida nawilze aRmoCenili biomasala,romelic ekuTvnis p. f-s, savaraudod, SeiZleba darCeni-liyo biomasalis uSualo SexebiT da SesaZlebelia, is war-moadgendes nerwyvs an gamonadens.
22. Sps `...~ farmacevt m. m-s mier wardgenili faqturisdaTvalierebis oqmiT dadgenilia, rom p. f-m aRniSnul af-TiaqSi 2015 wlis 31 maiss SeiZina medikament `...~ ori abi.
23. preparat `...~ gamoyenebis instruqciiT dadgenilia,rom misi Cveneba aris sxvadasxva etiologiis ereqciulidisfunqcia, xolo miRebis wessa da dozirebaSi miTiTe-bulia, rom sildenafilis efeqturobis aucilebel piro-bas warmoadgens seqsualuri stimulacia.
24. 2015 wlis 31 maiss Sedgenili, afTiaq `...~ videoCana-weris daTvalierebis oqmiT dadgenilia, rom 2015 wlis 31maiss, Ramis saaTebSi, p. f-e midis `...~ afTiaqis sarkmel-Tan. lodinis Semdeg sarkmlidan mas awvdian pakets. amdros m. b-e imyofeba sadarbazos SesasvlelTan. videoma-salaze aseve aRbeWdilia m. b-sa da p. f-s moZraoba maRazi-idan afTiaqis mimarTulebiT, ra drosac p. f-e `xelis moZ-raobas axorcielebs m. b-s mimarTulebiT~.
25. 2015 wlis 31 maiss Sedgenili, `...~ videoCanawerisdaTvalierebis oqmiT dadgenilia, rom 2015 wlis 31 maissp. f-e moZraobs m. b-Tan erTad. garkveuli periodis Sem-deg kadrSi Cndeba m. b-e, romelic aris marto da elodebap. f-s. misi gamoCenisTanave, m. b-e masTan erTad agrZelebsmoZraobas.
26. 2015 wlis 5 ivnisis daTvalierebis oqmiT dadgeni-lia, rom gamomZiebelma daaTvaliera da Semdeg amoiRo m.b-s kuTvnili maisuri, romelic mas ecva 2015 wlis 31 maiss.
27. 2015 wlis 4 ivniss Sedgenili sagamoZiebo eqsperi-mentis oqmiT dadgenilia, rom mowme m. b-e nebayoflobiTmonawileobda sagamoZiebo eqsperimentSi, ra drosac ga-moZiebas TanmimdevrobiT uCvena is adgilebi, sadac p. f-Tan erTad imyofeboda, maT Soris _ is adgilic, sadac p.
toriuli fsiqiatriul-fsiqologiuri eqspertizis das-kvnis Tanaxmad, dadgenilia, rom m. b-s, mcirewlovani asa-kisa da asakobrivi infantilizmis gamo, ar SeuZlia swo-rad aRiqvas, daimaxsovros da gadmosces movlenebi, mo-nawileoba miiRos sagamoZiebo da sasamarTlo moqmedebeb-Si da misces Cveneba. mocemuli eqspertizis daskvnis miu-xedavad, m. b-e warmoadgens braldebis mxaris erTaderTpirdapir mowmes da mtkicebulebas, rac dauSvebelia, vi-naidan saqarTvelos sssk-is 75-e mxulis safuZvelze mow-mis Cveneba mtkicebulebad ver CaiTvleba, Tu dadginde-ba, rom mas fsiqikuri avadmyofobis an fizikuri naklisgamo ar SeuZlia _ sworad aRiqvas, daimaxsovros da aRid-ginos faqtebi.
_ garda amisa, arasrulwlovani dazaralebulis _ m. b-sCveneba aris aradamajerebeli da formaluri xasiaTis, racdaadastura sasamarTlo sxdomaze mowveulma fsiqolog-ma; dazaralebulma sasamarTloSi Cvenebis micemis drosver gaixsena, Tu ra nivTebi darCa mamidasTan da ra nivTe-bi SeiZina maRaziaSi p. f-Tan erTad, erTmaneTisagan verganasxvava marjvena da marcxena xeli, ver gansazRvra, ramanZili iqneboda misi saxlidan sasamarTlomde; m. b-m sa-samarTloSi dakiTxvisas ganmarta, rom man momxdari faq-tis Sesaxeb uambo mamidas _ T. b-s, romelmac mowmis saxiTdakiTxvisas ar daadastura aRniSnuli; aradamajerebeliam. b-s Cveneba im nawilSic, rom man Sarvali, romelic mom-xdari SemTxvevis dRes ecva, dawva, vinaidan miTiTebulnamwvze ar aris Catarebuli Sesabamisi eqspertiza.
_ mowmeebis _ m. t-s, r. C-sa da d. b-s Cvenebebi aris ur-TierTsawinaaRmdego, xolo pedagogebis Cvenebebi ki arisiribi mtkicebulebebi.
29. kasatorebis aRniSnul mosazrebebTan dakavSirebiTsakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom sqesobrivi Tavisufle-bisa da xelSeuxeblobis winaaRmdeg mimarTuli danaSau-lebi, rogorc wesi, ar aris sajaro xasiaTis, ris gamoc mi-TiTebuli kategoriis saqmeebze umetes SemTxvevaSi da-naSaulis Semswre uSualo TviTmxilveli mowmeebi ar ar-seboben. Sesabamisad, msgavsi kategoriis saqmeebSi gansa-kuTrebuli mniSvneloba eniWeba dazaralebulis Cvenebas
30
da mis Tanxvedras saqmeSi arsebul sxva mtkicebulebeb-Tan. dazaralebul m. b-s Cveneba sakasacio palatas miaCniasarwmuno da utyuar mtkicebulebad, Semdeg garemoebaTagamo:
_ sakasacio palata iziarebs saapelacio sasamarTlosSefasebas sasamarTlo fsiqiatriul-fsiqologiuri eq-spertizis daskvnasTan dakavSirebiT da miuTiTebs, Sem-degs: eqspertizis daskvniT dadgenilia, rom m. b-e fsiqi-kurad daavadebuli ar aris. igi aris sruliad janmrTeli.daskvnis siswore daadastures misma gamcemma eqsperteb-ma _ T. W-m da e. a-m. saqmis sasamarTloSi ganxilvis dros T.W-m ganmarta, rom dazaralebul m. b-s Tavisi asakis Sesaba-misad SeuZlia momxdari faqtebis gadmocema. mas ar SeuZ-lia polemika gamarTos sxvebTan sadavo sakiTxebis gada-sawyvetad da garkveul sakiTxebze imsjelos rogorczrdasrulma pirma, ara fsiqikuri naklis gamo, aramed mi-si asakidan gamomdinare. aRniSnuli aseve daadastura mow-mis saxiT dakiTxulma eqspertma e. a-m, romelmac calsa-xad miuTiTa, rom m. b-e aris asakis Sesabamisad ganviTare-buli. mas SeuZlia momxdari faqtebisa da movlenebis gad-mocema da aRwera.
_ rac Seexeba dacvis mxaris mosazrebas, rom arasrul-wlovanma dazaralebulma sasamarTloSi mowmis saxiT Cve-nebis micemis dros ver gaixsena zemomiTiTebuli deta-lebi, sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom mocemul SemTxve-vaSi gansakuTrebuli yuradReba unda gamaxvildes daza-ralebulis asakze. igi aris mcirewlovani _ 20.. wels daba-debuli. mis mier sasamarTloSi micemuli Cveneba saeWvoda aradamajerebeli swored maSin iqneboda, Tu mcirew-lovani dazaralebuli yvela detals amomwuravad da zed-miwveniT sworad gaixsenebda. amasTan, aRsaniSnavia is ga-remoebac, rom dacvis mxaris mier miTiTebuli garemoebe-bi ukavSirdeba mxolod iseT detalebs, romlebsac araaqvT arsebiTi mniSvneloba da gavlenas ver moaxdens p. f-s damnaSaveoba /udanaSaulobaze. garda amisa, saqmeSi ararsebobs raime damadasturebeli mtkicebuleba, romelic,Tundac varaudis doneze, miuTiTebs, rom arasrulwlo-vani dazaralebuli m. b-e aris dainteresebuli piri, rommas gaaCnda raime mizezi da sababi imisaTvis, rom mieca cruCveneba p. f-s winaaRmdeg da misTvis daebralebina aRniS-nuli qmedebis Cadena.
31
_ saqmeze `SN SvedeTis winaaRmdeg~1 adamianis ufleba-Ta evropulma sasamarTlom yuradReba gaamaxvila sqesob-riv danaSaulTa saqmeebis ganxilvis Taviseburebebze daaRniSna, rom msgavs saqmeebze, rogorc wesi, saqmis sasa-marTloSi ganxilvas dazaralebuli aRiqvams rogorc um-Zimes gamocdas, gansakuTrebiT maSin, rodesac mas uwevsbraldebulTan dapirispireba, rac ufro mZafrad iCensTavs maSin, rodesac saqme exeba arasrulwlovan dazara-lebuls. mocemul saqmeze adamianis uflebaTa evropul-ma sasamarTlom konvenciis me-6 muxlis darRveva ar da-adgina, miuxedavad imisa, rom saqmis sasamarTlo ganxil-visas mcirewlovani dazaralebuli ar dakiTxula. p. f-smsjavrdebis saqmeSi arasrulwlovani dazaralebuli m. b-e sasamarTlo sxdomaze daikiTxa mowmis saxiT, ra drosacdacvis mxares hqonda SesaZlebloba, misTvis daesva kiT-xvebi da Seemowmebina misi Cvenebis sandooba. m. b-m Tan-mimdevrobiT da srulyofilad aRwera p. f-s mier mis mi-marT ganxorcielebuli danaSaulebrivi qmedebebi da mxo-lod is faqti, rom man ver gaixsena umniSvnelo detalebi,ar SeiZleba gaxdes misi Cvenebis utyuarobaSi eWvis Seta-nis safuZveli.
30. amdenad, garda imisa, rom dazaralebulis Cvenebaaris Tanmimdevruli, sarwmuno da damajerebeli, igi sru-lad Tanxvdenilia saqmeSi arsebul sxva mtkicebulebeb-Tan, kerZod:
identuria, xolo sacvalze aRmoCenili sisxli m. b-s (ob.#25) genetikuri profilis identuria; m. b-s maisurze er-Ti nawili misi genetikuri profilis identuria (ob. #35),(ob. #6.7)-is profilebSi ki p. f-s (ob. #26) Tanamonawile-oba ar gamoiricxeba;
_ `...~ afTiaqidan da `...~ amoRebul video CanawerTan,romliTac dadgenilia, rom danaSaulis Cadenis dros p.f-e m. b-Tan erTad gadaadgildeboda; sagamoZiebo eqspe-rimentis oqmTan, romelSic m. b-m TanmimdevrobiT uCvenayvela is adgili, sadac p. f-Tan erTad imyofeboda da sa-dac am ukanasknelma Caidina danaSauli.
_ mowmeebis: a. b-s, r. C-s, m. t-s, T. b-s, g. g-s, e. e-s, n. m-s,T. b-s, d. b-s, T. k-s, m. m-s, l. p-s, a. v-s, p. l-s, a. a-s, z. g-s,eqspertebis _ m. n-s, T.g-s, i. m-s, T. W-sa da e. a-s Cvenebeb-Tan.
31. garda amisa, sakasacio palata ar iziarebs dacvismxaris sakasacio saCivarSi warmodgenil sxva motivebsac,kerZod: kasatorebi uTiTeben, rom samedicino eqsperti-zis Camtarebelma eqspertma ver upasuxa dazaralebulissxeulze arsebuli dazianebebis gamomwvev mizezebTan da-kavSirebul dacvis mxaris mier dasmul kiTxvebs, rac usa-fuZvloa, radgan sasamarTlo sxdomaze dakiTxulma eq-spertma m. n-m daadastura misi monawileobiT CatarebulisasamarTlo-samedicino eqspertizis daskvnis siswore daamasTanave _ amomwuravad ganmarta Catarebuli eqsperti-zis detalebi da Sedegebi; kasatorebs aseve aeWvebT bio-logiuri eqspertizis daskvnis kanonierebis sakiTxi, Tum-ca saqmis masalebis Seswavlisa da gaanalizebis Sedegadraime saxis saproceso darRveva maTi mopovebisa da gamok-vlevisas ar gamovlenila; isini aseve uTiTeben, rom mow-meebis _ m. t-s, r. C-sa da d. b-s Cvenebebi aris urTierTsa-winaaRmdego, rasac sakasacio palata ar eTanxmeba da miu-TiTebs, rom maT Cvenebebs Soris arsebiTi xasiaTis wina-aRmdegoba ar aris.
32. rac Seexeba braldebis mxaris sakasacio saCivrismoTxovnas saqarTvelos ssk-is 260-e muxlis me-3 nawilis`a~ qvepunqtiT wardgenil braldebaSi p. f-s damnaSavedcnobis Sesaxeb, sakasacio palata am nawilSic mTlianadiziarebs pirveli da saapelacio instanciis sasamarTlo-ebis argumentebs msjavrdebul p. f-s mocemul bralde-baSi udanaSaulod cnobis Sesaxeb da miuTiTebs: p. f-s da-
33
kavebisa da piradi Cxrekis oqmiT dadgenilia, rom misganamoRebuli nivTebi: telefoni, sigaretis vercxlisfer qa-RaldSi moTavsebuli fxvnilisebri masa, tyavis Savi sa-fule moTavsda polieTilenis parkSi, romelic dailuqa#... luqiT da, Sesabamisad, gakeTda saTanado xelmowera.p. f-s Tan hqonda aseve momwvano xelCanTa, romelSic mo-Tavsebuli iyo tansacmeli, TeTreuli, pirsaxoci da sa-yofacxovrebo nivTebi, romlebic aseve dailuqa #... lu-qiT. aRniSnuliT calsaxad dgindeba, rom gamoyenebuliiyo mxolod ori luqi. sasamarTlo sxdomaze nivTmtkice-baTa daTvalierebisa da gamokvlevis Sedegad dadginda,rom zemoaRniSnuli nivTebi (mobiluri telefoni, tyavissafule da fxvnilisebri masa) daluquli iyo cal _ calkepaketebad, riTac dgindeba, rom piradi Cxrekis dros ga-moyenebuli iyo # ... _ 4 (oTxi) luqi, saqmeSi ki ar moipove-ba mtkicebuleba, romelic daadasturebda piradi Cxre-kis Sedegad amoRebul nivTmtkicebaTa ganluqvisa da ma-Ti cal-calke daluqvis faqts. saqarTvelos sssk-is 72-emuxlis me-2 nawilis Tanaxmad, mtkicebuleba `dauSvebe-lia, Tu igi mopovebulia am kodeqsiT dadgenili wesis dac-viT, magram uaryofili ar aris gonivruli eWvi misi SesaZ-lo gamocvlis, misi niSan-Tvisebebis arsebiTi Secvlis anmasze darCenili kvalis arsebiTi gaqrobis Sesaxeb~. Sesa-bamisad, vinaidan ar aris uaryofili gonivruli eWvi niv-TmtkicebaTa SesaZlo gamocvlisa da misi niSan-Tvisebe-bis aSkara Secvlis Taobaze, xsenebuli Cxrekis oqmi sa-fuZvlad ver daedeba p. f-s mimarT saqarTvelos ssk-is260-e muxlis me-3 nawilis ̀ a~ qvepunqtiT wardgenili bral-debis nawilSi gamamtyunebeli ganaCenis gamotanas.
33. sisxlis samarTlis saproceso kodeqsis 259-e mux-lis mixedviT, sasamarTlos ganaCeni unda iyos kanonieri,dasabuTebuli da samarTliani. ganaCeni dasabuTebulia,Tu is emyareba sasamarTlo ganxilvis dros gamokvleul,gonivruli eWvis gamomricxav mtkicebulebaTa erTobli-obas. amasTan, ganaCenSi Camoyalibebuli yvela daskvna dagadawyvetileba dasabuTebuli unda iyos. saqarTveloskonstituciis me-40 muxlis me-3 nawilis Tanaxmad, gamam-tyunebeli ganaCeni unda emyarebodes mxolod utyuarmtkicebulebebs. yovelgvari eWvi, romelic ver dadas-turdeba kanoniT dadgenili wesiT, unda gadawydes bral-debulis sasargeblod.
34
34. saqmeSi `feodorovi moldovis winaaRmdeg~2 evro-sasamarTlom aRniSna, rom saqmis garemoebebis dasadge-nad sasamarTlo iTvaliswinebs `gonivrul eWvs miRma~standarts, rom aseTi mtkicebuleba warmoiqmneba mxolodSeTanxmebuli, sakmarisad Zlieri, aSkara da damajerebe-li daskvnebiT an gaubaTilebeli prezumfciiT.
liT, 307-e muxlis 1-li nawilis `d~ qvepunqtiT, me-2, me-3nawilebiT da
d a a d g i n a:
1. msjavrdebul p. f-s interesebis damcveli advoka-tebis _ d. s-s, T. n-sa da zestafonis raionuli prokura-turis prokuror koba siraZis sakasacio saCivrebi ar dak-mayofildes.
3. dazaralebul m. b-sa da mis kanonier warmomadgenelsganemartoT arasrulwlovanTa marTlmsajulebis kodeq-sis 25-e muxliT zianis anazRaurebisa da kompensaciismoTxovnis uflebis Sesaxeb.
SemTxvevis adgilis daTvalierebisa da sagamoZiebo eq-sperimentis dros gadaRebuli fotosuraTebis amsaxve-li CD diskebi, romlebic erTvis sisxlis samarTlis saq-mes, Senaxul unda iqnes saqmis Senaxvis vadiT;
daTvalierebis Sedegad amoRebuli s. k-s tansacmeli(Savi jinsis Sarvali da nacrisferi TeTrzolebiani peran-gi), romlebic inaxeba zestafonis raionul sammarTvelo-Si, saqmeze saboloo gadawyvetilebis miRebis Semdeg un-da daubrundes s. k-s anda misi ojaxis wevrs.
2. aRniSnuli ganaCeniT sasamarTlom dadgenilad miiC-nia, rom s. k-m Caidina: gaupatiurebis mcdeloba, ese igisqesobrivi kavSiris mcdeloba ZaladobiTa da ZaladobismuqariT, Cadenili araerTgzis; seqsualuri xasiaTis Zal-momreobiTi moqmedeba, anu seqsualuri kontaqti gaukuR-marTebuli formiT, Cadenili ZaladobiTa da ZaladobismuqariT.
msjavrdebulis mier Cadenili qmedebebi gamoixata Sem-degSi:
zestafonis raionuli sasamarTlos 2007 wlis 25 seq-tembris ganaCeniT s. k-s msjavri daedo saqarTvelos ssk-is 19, 137-e muxlis me-3 nawilis `a~ qvepunqtiT da sasje-lad ganesazRvra 11 wliT Tavisuflebis aRkveTa. s. k-e pe-nitenciuri dawesebulebidan sasjelis moxdisagan gaTa-visuflda 2015 wlis maisSi, ris Semdegac, gaupatiurebis-Tvis nasamarTlevma, kvlav Caidina danaSauli, kerZod: 2016wlis 12 agvistos z-s raionis sofel S-i imave sofelSimcxovrebma mTvralma s. k-m ganizraxa sqesobrivi Jinis dak-mayofilebis mizniT, ZaladobiT, sqesobrivi kavSiri da-emyarebina mezobelTan, 62 wlis m. s-n. isargebla imiT, romm. s-s meuRle samsaxurSi imyofeboda da im dros m. s-e sax-lSi marto iyo, xolo TviT s. k-s meuRle da Svili saxlSi
38
ar iyvnen da daaxloebiT 21:00 saaTze mivida m. s-n saxlSida moatyua, rom TiTqosda misi meuRle, i. k-e SeuZlodgaxda da sTxova misTvis nemsis gakeTeba. m. s-m daijeramisi naTqvami da gahyva s. k-s saxlSi. oTaxSi Sesvlisas m. s-m naxa, rom i. k-e saxlSi ar imyofeboda. vinaidan s. k-s adreCadenili hqonda mezoblis, asakovani qalbatonis gaupa-tiurebis mcdeloba, m. k-e mixvda s. k-s danaSaulebriv gan-zraxvas da gamoiqca saxlidan. mas daedevna s. k-e, romel-mac xeli Zlierad daartya zurgSi da igi kibeze waaqcia,ris Semdegac ezoSi uTxra, rom surda masTan sqesobrivikavSiris damyareba. amasTanave, s. k-e mas saxeSi urtyamdaxels da emuqreboda SviliSvilebisa da meuRlis mokvliT,saxlis gadawviT, Tu momxdaris Sesaxeb vinmes etyoda. Sem-deg m. s-m moaxerxa s. k-n Tavis daRweva da gaiqca, Tumca s.k-e daedevna, daimorCila, miwaze waaqcia, Semoaxia tansac-meli da gaxada trusi. s. k-m Tavadac gaixada tansacmelisqesobrivi kavSiris dasamyareblad. vinaidan m. s-m aqtiu-ri winaaRmdegoba gauwia s. k-s, romelmac imavdroulad verganicada ereqcia misgan damoukidebeli aRniSnuli gare-moebebis gamo, s. k-m ver SeZlo ganxorcielebuli Zalado-biTa da Zaladobis muqariT m. s-n sqesobrivi kavSiris dam-yareba. amis miuxedavad, sqesobrivi Jinis dasakmayofileb-lad, s. k-m m. s-e ZaladobiT daimorCila, Tavisi sasqesoorgano ZaladobiT moaTavsa m. s-s piris RruSi, xolo xe-lis TiTi _ mis sasqeso organoSi, ris Semdegac man dazara-lebuli Seiyvana Tavisi sacxovrebeli saxlis ezoSi, sa-dac damxmare saTavsebis kedlebs Soris, ZaladobiTa damokvlis muqariT muxlebze daaCoqa, xeli mouWira ybeb-ze, ZaliT gaaRebina piri da Tavisi sasqeso organo kvlavmoaTavsa m. s-s piris RruSi, ra drosac m. s-e gaxda cudad.s. k-m m. s-e Seiyvana mis sacxovrebel saxlSi, SiSveli daaw-vina sawolze da TiTi moaTavsa mis sasqeso organoSi. Sem-deg s. k-s SeeSinda mxilebis da miimala SemTxvevis adgi-lidan, xolo m. s-m momxdaris Sesaxeb Seatyobina mezob-lebsa da ojaxis wevrebs.
3. zestafonis raionuli sasamarTlos 2016 wlis 20 de-kembris ganaCeni saapelacio wesiT gaasaCivres msjavrde-bulma s. k-m da misma interesebis damcvelma, advokatma T.o-m, romlebmac moiTxoves gamamtyunebeli ganaCenis ga-uqmeba da mis nacvlad gamamarTlebeli ganaCenis dadgena.
7. habitoskopiuri eqspertizis daskvnis Tanaxmad, rom-lis siswore sasamarTlos sxdomaze daadastura eqsper-tma d. T-a, gamokvlevaze warmodgenil videogramaze da-fiqsirebuli gamoZiebisTvis saintereso avtomobilebissanomre niSnebis garCeva SeuZlebelia. aseve SeuZlebeliadadgindes, gamoZiebisaTvis saintereso pirebs uWiravTTu ara xelSi raime sagnebi da e.w. Jiletze aris Tu araraime warwera.
8. amocnobis oqmebis Tanaxmad, n. k-a amosacnobad war-dgenili pirebidan amoicno g. x-a, s. T-i da o. m-i.
9. qimiuri eqspertizis daskvniT, romlis siswore sasa-marTlo sxdomaze daadastura eqspertma l. k-a, dadgeni-lia, rom n. k-s manqanis salonis e.w. `bardaCokidan~ amoRe-bul Savi plastmasis yuTismagvari sagnis Sida qsovilzedafiqsirda rkinis metalizaciis kvali.
10. qimiuri eqspertizis daskvniT, romlis siswore sa-samarTlo sxdomaze daadastura eqspertma s. e-m, dadge-nilia, rom n. k-s Sarvlis zedapiridan daqtilofirebiTamoRebul nacrisfer, polieTerul boWkos mikronawila-kebsa da a/manqana `bmv-s~ savarZlis SaliTis qsovilis ni-muSis SemadgenlobaSi Semaval nacrisfer polieTerulboWkoebs gaaCniaT saerTo gvareobiTi kuTvnileba.
50
11. qimiuri eqspertizis daskvniT, romlis siswore sa-samarTlo sxdomaze daadastura eqspertma m. C-m, dadge-nilia, rom n. k-s tansacmelze rkinis metalizaciis kvalidafiqsirda Sarvalze, welis areSi wina, marjvena gare mxa-res, aseve _ wina marjvena da marcxena jibeebSi, alag-alagkoncentrirebuli, arasagnobrivi gamosaxulebiT. maisur-ze rkinis metalizaciis kvali ar dafiqsirda.
12. braldebulma g. x-m mowmis saxiT Cvenebis micemisasganmarta, rom 2015 wlis 24 ivliss, 01:00 saaTamde, imyofe-boda k-s mimdebare teritoriaze arsebul launj-bar `n-i~, romlis damfuZnebelic TviTon aris. barSi esaubrebo-da megobar s. T-s. am dros maTTan mivida momsaxure perso-nalis warmomadgeneli z. b-i da ganucxada, rom vercxlis-feri `mersedesis~ firmis a/manqanis mflobels, romelicmegobrebTan erTad tovebda bars da jdeboda a/manqana-Si, SekveTis safasuri hqonda gadasaxdeli. man Tavis Ta-namSromels ganucxada, rom samsaxurebrivi movaleoba ga-egrZelebina da am problemas Tavad moagvarebda. aRniS-nulis Semdeg is, s. T-i da o. m-i am ukanasknelis a/manqaniTukan gayvnen vercxlisfer `mersedesis~ firmis a/manqanas,Tumca miuxedavad araerTi mcdelobisa, ver moaxerxes misigaCereba. maT SeamCnies, rom xsenebuli a/manqana gaCerdar-s gamzirze mdebare `x-n~, saidanac gadmovida oTxi piri.is da s. T-i gadmovidnen manqanidan, Tumca ver SeniSnes,sad wavida `mersedesidan~ gadmosuli oTxi piri, ris ga-moc gadawyvites dacda. daaxloebiT 20 wuTSi axalgazrdabiWi mivida `mersedesTan~ da Cajda. am dros is mivida mas-Tan, gaecno da hkiTxa, vin iyo, imyofeboda Tu ara k-e mde-bare launj-bar `n-i~ da hqonda Tu ara Tanxa gadasaxdeli,razec am ukanasknelma upasuxa launj-bar `n-i~ imyofebo-da, magram SekveTa arc mas da arc mis megobrebs ar miuci-aT, Tumca situaciaSi garkvevis mizniT is dasTanxmda Se-Tavazebas da gadawyvita maT gahyoloda barSi. imavdrou-lad, vinaidan n. k-i iyo nasvami, man s. T-s uTxra, rom poli-cia gamoeZaxebina, razec n. k-a Secvala pozicia da ganu-marta, rom ar surda policiis Careva, radgan warsulSiproblemebi hqonda, xolo Tanxas, Tuki rame hqonda gada-saxdeli, aucileblad gadaixdida meore dRes. vinaidan n.k-i dasTanxmda Tanxis gadaxdas, maT saWirod ar CaTvalessapatrulo policiis gamoZaxeba. manqana n. k-a gaaCerebinav-s parkis mimdebare teritoriaze, sadac Cavida manqani-
51
dan, xolo is megobrebTan erTad dabrunda. k-e. meore dResdaibares Zveli Tbilisis sammarTveloSi, sadac daxvdnenufrosebi, uTxres, rom viRac uCioda da unda moeyola, ramoxda wina Rames. amis Semdeg daureka s. T-s da o. m-s, sTxo-va, rom misuliyvnen ganyofilebaSi, sadac isini daakaves.manve ganmarta, rom policiis TanamSromlis maisuri arscmia.
analogiuri Sinaarsis Cveneba misces sasamarTlo sxdo-maze braldebulebma _ s. T-a da o. m-a. s. T-a damatebiTganmarta, rom is n. k-s a/manqanaSi Caujda, rom mas manqanaar daeZra da isev ar dasWirvebodaT gamodevneba. isini ia-raRiT ar damuqrebian da n. k-s arc fizikuri da arc sit-yvieri Seuracxyofa ar miuyenebiaT. vinaidan is nasvami iyoda a/manqanis saWesTan ver jdeboda, maT SesTavazes saku-Tari a/manqana, raTa asuliyvnen k-e da iq gaerkviaT gada-saxdeli Tanxis sakiTxi. aranairi iZuleba mis mimarT argamouyenebiaT.
13. mowme z. b-s Cvenebis mixedviT, 2015 wlis 24 ivlissimyofeboda samsaxurSi, launj-bar `n-i~, sadac is muSaob-da barmenis poziciaze. daaxloebiT 01:00_02:00 saaTisaT-vis barSi Sevida oTxi adamiani, romelTagan erTi iyo mded-robiTi sqesis. isini iyvnen nasvamebi, maTgan erT-erTmaaxalgazrda biWma _ n. k-a, romelsac ecva TeTri maisuri,SeukveTa koqteili `lond ailendi~. im dros mas ecva mim-tanis uniforma da man n. k-n miiRo SekveTa. rodesac mivi-da Cekis Sesavsebad da `lond ailendis~ wasaRebad, Seam-Cnia, rom is piri, vinc SekveTa misca, Tavis megobrebTanerTad tovebda bars da jdeboda vercxlisfer `mersedes-Si~. aRniSnuli Seatyobina Tavis ufross _ g. x-s da dacvisufross _ s. T-s da uTxra, rom SekveTis Tanxa ar iyo ga-daxdili. g. x-m da s. T-a ganucxades, rom es ar iyo misiproblema da Tavad mixedavdnen am sakiTxs, mas ki gaegrZe-lebina muSaoba.
14. sakasacio palata ar eTanxmeba msjavrdebulebis _s. T-a da g. x-s interesebis damcvelis, advokat m. w-s,msjavrdebul o. m-s interesebis damcvelis, advokat i. g-s sakasacio saCivrebis moTxovnas msjavrdebulebis gamar-Tlebis Taobaze, vinaidan igi aris usafuZvlo da ar ga-momdinareobs saqmis masalebidan.
Saulod cnobis Sesaxeb, rom mocemul epizodSi bralde-bis mxares warmodgenili aqvs mxolod dazaralebul n. k-sCveneba da sxva mowmeebis iribi Cvenebebi, romlebic sa-fuZvlad ver daedeba gamamtyunebel ganaCens. g. x-s, s. T-a da o. m-s mier (gamoZiebiT daudgenel pirTan erTad) n. k-s kuTvnili `ekol maJoris~ firmis pistoletisa da 25 la-ris aSkara dauflebis faqti ver dgindeba sakmaris mtki-cebulebaTa erTobliobiT. rac Seexeba qimiuri eqsperti-zis daskvnebs, metalizaciis kvalis dafiqsireba, rogorcSavi plastmasis yuTismagvari sagnis Sida qsovilze, ise _n. k-s tansacmelze, pirdapir ar miuTiTebs dazaralebu-lis kuTvnili iaraRis aSkara dauflebis faqtze.
16. rac Seexeba saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeq-sis 143-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `g~ da me-3 nawilis `a~ da `e~qvepunqtebiT wardgenil braldebas, sakasacio palatasmiaCnia, rom prokuroris saCivris moTxovna am nawilSi na-wilobriv unda dakmayofildes Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
17. sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom saapelacio sasa-marTlom saqmis faqtobrivi garemoebebi sworad daadgi-na, magram arasworad Seafasa sisxlissamarTlebrivi kva-lifikaciis TvalsazrisiT. saapelacio palatam dadastu-rebulad miiCnia, rom g. x-a, s. T-i da o. m-i daedevnen la-unj-bar `n-n~ gamosul pirebs, vinaidan maT ar gadaixadesSekveTis Tanxa. samive maTganma miuTiTa, rom icodnen, Turis gamo misdevdnen SemdegSi dazaralebulad cnobilpirs. rodesac msjavrdebulebma n. k-i ipoves, igi gadmo-iyvanes `mersedesis~ markis avtomanqanidan da Casves `bmv-s~ markis avtomanqanaSi, rac saapelacio palatam Seafasaara rogorc n. k-s nebayoflobiTi qmedeba, aramed _ misiZulebad, rom Seesrulebina sakuTari neba-survilis sa-winaaRmdego moqmedeba da gadamjdariyo maT avtomanqa-naSi.
18. palatam aseve yuradReba gaamaxvila dazaralebuln. k-s Cvenebaze, rom mas masTan misuli pirebi egona poli-ciis TanamSromlebi, ris gamoc maTTvis aranairi winaaR-mdegoba ar gauwevia, ris mizezadac maTi mxridan fsiqiku-ri zewola daasaxela. saapelacio palatis mosazrebiT,msjavrdebulebs n. k-s ar aRukveTavT sxva raime ufleba,garda uflebisa, rom dazaralebuls aerCia, wasuliyo Tuara konkretul adgilas; msjavrdebulebs arc telefonimouTxoviaT da, miT umetes, arc SeumowmebiaT, hqonda Tu
53
ara mas is, rac imaze mianiSnebs, rom maTi mizani iyo aradazaralebulis Tavisuflebis ukanono aRkveTa, aramedmisi qmedebis, Tavisi survilisamebr gadaadgilebis _ Ta-visuflebis ukanono SezRudva, vinaidan mocemul Sem-TxvevaSi dazaralebuls SeezRuda mimosvlis Tavisufle-ba fsiqikuri iZulebis gamoyenebiT.
19. palatam daaskvna, rom dazaralebuls hqonda gada-adgilebis obieqturi SesaZlebloba, radgan, misi ganmar-tebiT, is miiyvanes T-i, w-s q. ...-is mimdebare teritoria-ze, mdinare v-s xeobaSi da iq datoves.
20. sakasacio palata miuTiTebs, rom saqarTvelos ssk-is 143-e muxlis Tanaxmad, Tavisuflebis ukanono aRkveTaaris ganzraxi qmedeba, romelic dakavSirebulia piris iZu-lebiT dakavebasTan, roca mas faqtobrivad warTmeuliaqvs Tavisufali gadaadgilebis yvelanairi SesaZleblo-ba (Caketilia oTaxSi, damwyvdeulia sardafSi da a.S.). qme-debis aRniSnuli muxliT dakvalificirebisaTvis aucile-belia, rom pirs ar hqondes gadaadgilebis aranairi obieq-turi SesaZlebloba. saqarTvelos konstituciis Tanaxmad,adamianebs aqvT qveynis mTel teritoriaze Tavisufalimimosvlis ufleba, rac imas niSnavs, rom aravis aqvs uf-leba, Tavisufleba aRukveTos an sxvagvarad SeuzRudosigi pirs. danaSaulis ZiriTadi obieqtia adamianis xelSeu-xebloba da misi Tavisufali gadaadgilebis ufleba.
21. sakasacio palata ver gaiziarebs saapelacio sasa-marTlos daskvnas, rom dazaralebuls hqonda gadaadgi-lebis obieqturi SesaZlebloba, radgan is miiyvanes mdi-nare v-s xeobaSi da iq datoves, vinaidan Tavisuflebis uka-nono aRkveTa miekuTvneba formalur danaSaulTa kate-gorias da igi damTavrebulia Tavisuflebis ukanono aR-kveTis momentidan, romlis xangrZlivobas qmedebis kva-lifikaciisaTvis mniSvneloba ara aqvs. garda amisa, daza-ralebulis CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom igi sakuTari nebiTar gahyva msjavrdebulebs da uCvena, rom isini mas warud-gnen rogorc policiis TanamSromlebi, ganucxades, romiyo dakavebuli da mosTxoves narkologiurSi Sesamowmeb-lad gayola. amitom mas winaaRmdegoba ar gauwevia, TavisifexiT gadavida avtomanqanidan, Semdeg romeliRacam xel-kavi gaukeTa, waiyvanes da Casves maT avtomanqanaSi. amas-Tan, dazaralebulis Cveneba am nawilSi damatebiT dastur-deba videosaTvalTvalo kameris CanaweriT, romelic sru-
54
lad Tanxvdenilia mis CvenebasTan. Canaweridan naTladCans, Tu rogor mihyavT g. x-s, gamoZiebiT daudgenel pir-sa da s. T-s n. k-i avtomanqana `bmv-s~ ukana karTan da svamenmanqanaSi. rac Seexeba im faqts, rom msjavrdebulebs mis-Tvis ar mouTxoviaT telefoni, dazaralebulma uCvena,rom igi daemorCila maT moTxovnas, winaaRmdegoba ar gau-wevia, vinaidan isini egona policiis TanamSromlebi. Sesa-bamisad, mas saerTod ar ucdia telefoniT vinmesTan da-kavSireba. amdenad, is faqti, rom mas telefoni ar mos-Txoves, ar miuTiTebs imaze, rom mas SesaZlebloba hqon-da, esargebla telefoniT. zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdina-re, msjavrdebulebis qmedeba warmoadgens ara iZulebas,aramed _ Tavisuflebis ukanono aRkveTas.
22. amasTan, braldebis mxare iTxovs msjavrdebulebisdamnaSaved cnobas Tavisuflebis ukanono aRkveTaSi Sem-degi makvalificirebeli niSnebiT: sxva danaSaulis Cade-nis gaadvilebis mizniT, winaswari SeTanxmebiT jgufis mi-er da sicocxlisaTvis da janmrTelobisaTvis saSiSi Za-ladobis gamoyenebis muqariT, rasac sakasacio palata ase-ve ver gaiziarebs da TiToeul maTganze dawvrilebiT im-sjelebs:
sakasacio palata iziarebs msjavrdebulTa Cvenebebsim nawilSi, sadac isini aRniSnaven, rom launj-baridan ga-mosul pirebs daedevnen im mizniT, rom maT SekveTis sa-fasuri ar gadaixades, ris gamoc surdaT am sakiTxis gar-kveva. sakasacio palatas dadgenilad miaCnia Semdegi faq-tobrivi garemoebebi: msjavrdebulebi o. m-s marTvis qveSmyofi `bmv-s~ markis avtomanqaniT `fexdafex~ daedevnen`mersedesis~ markis avtomanqanas, romelsac marTavda da-zaralebuli n. k-i, magram miuxedavad araerTi mcdelobi-sa, ver moaxerxes misi gaCereba. mogvianebiT maT dainaxes,rom xsenebuli avtomanqana gaCerda r-s gamzirze, e-s aR-marTTan mdebare restoranTan. n. k-i Sevida iqve mdebarebarSi da rodesac iqidan gamovida, Cajda avtomanqana `mer-sedesSi~. am dros g. x-a gadmovida `bmv-s~ markis avtoman-qanidan, mivida dazaralebulTan da gaaRo mZRolis kari,xolo s. T-i dajda mZRolis gverdiT, raTa mas ar daeZraavtomanqana da ar wasuliyo. Semdeg avtomanqana `bmv-dan~gadmovida gamoZiebiT daudgeneli piri, isic mivida `mer-sedesTan~ da dadga g. x-s ukan. g. x-m avtomanqanidan gad-moiyvana n. k-i da TviTon da gamoZiebiT daudgenelma pir-ma igi miiyvanes `bmv-s~ markis avtomanqanasTan da Casvesukana savarZelze, Semdeg Tavad g. x-a da misi Tanmxlebipirebic Casxdnen avtomanqanaSi da igi daiZra m-s quCis mi-
56
marTulebiT. sakasacio palata ganmartavs, rom, marTalia,mocemul SemTxvevaSi, im momentSi, rodesac g. x-m `merse-desis~ markis avtomanqanidan gadmoiyvana dazaralebulida gamoZiebiT daudgenel pirTan erTad Casva `bmv-s~ mar-kis avtomanqanaSi, msjavrdebulebi moqmedebdnen erTma-neTTan SeTanxmebulad, magram es SeTanxmeba maT Soris ararsebobda arc maSin, rodesac msjavrdebulebi daedev-nen dazaralebuls da arc im dros, rodesac g. x-m aRniS-nuli danaSaulis Cadena daiwyo, radgan igi moqmedebdaindividualurad da jgufis danarCeni wevrebi mogviane-biT SeuerTdnen mis mier dawyebul danaSauls. Sesabami-sad, rogorc ukve zemoT aRiniSna, jgufis mier winaswariSeTanxmebiT danaSauli maSin CaiTvleba Cadenilad, ro-desac aseTi SeTanxmeba danaSaulSi monawile pirebs So-ris miRweulia da arsebobs sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsiskerZo nawilis Sesabamis muxlSi miTiTebuli qmedebis Se-madgenlobis ganxorcielebis dawyebamde, xolo im Sem-TxvevaSi, rodesac uSualod danaSaulis dawyebis Semdeg,Tundac erT-erTi amsrulebeli daiwyebs qmedebis Semad-genlobis ganxorcielebas, misi Cadenis procesSi damna-SaveTa Soris SeTanxmeba erToblivi moqmedebis Taobazear SeiZleba CaiTvalos winaswar SeTanxmebad, vinaidan, wi-naaRmdeg SemTxvevaSi, saerTod ver iarsebebda saqarTve-los sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 27-e muxlis pirveli na-wiliT gaTvaliswinebuli iseTi SemTxveva, rogoricaa wi-naswar SeuTanxmeblad jgufis mier danaSaulis Cadena,romelSic erToblivad monawileobda ori an meti amsru-lebeli.
da bolos, mesame makvalificirebeli niSani _ Tavi-suflebis ukanono aRkveTa Cadenili sicocxlisaTvis dajanmrTelobisaTvis saSiSi Zaladobis gamoyenebis muqa-riT. dazaralebulis Cvenebis garda, sxva raime mtkicebu-lebiT ar dasturdeba, rom msjavrdebulebs _ g. x-a da s.T-s hqondaT iaraRebi. iaraRis arseboba ar dgindeba vide-oCanaweriT da aRniSnuls kategoriulad gamoricxavenmsjavrdebulebi. aseve, ar aris dadasturebuli dazara-lebulisaTvis fizikuri Seuracxyofis miyenebis faqti,radgan saqmeSi ar moipoveba samedicino eqspertizis das-kvna n. k-s sxeulze arsebul dazianebebTan dakavSirebiT,xolo Tavad dazaralebulma ganmarta, rom mas dazianebe-bi ar etyoboda, ris gamoc uari ganacxada Semowmebaze. rac
57
Seexeba muqaris Sinaarss, TviTon dazaralebuli uTiTebs,rom isini daemuqrnen ara sicocxlisaTvis da janmrTelo-bisaTvis saSiSi Zaladobis gamoyenebiT, aramed _ daWeriT,`wamlis~ CadebiTa da narkologiurSi Sesamowmeblad ga-dayvaniT.
24. adamianis uflebaTa evropuli sasamarTlo mtkice-bis standartad ganixilavs `gonivrul eWvs miRma stan-darts~ da ganmartavs, rom aseTi mtkiceba SeiZleba gamom-dinareobdes sakmarisad Zlieri, naTeli da urTierTda-kavSirebuli daskvnebidan, romlebic udavo, sakmarisadmtkice da zust xasiaTs atarebs da ar SeiZleba efuZne-bodes mxolod Teoriul hipoTezas1.
25. mocemul SemTxvevaSi saqmeze mopovebuli da gamok-vleuli mtkicebulebebis erTobliobiT sakasacio pala-tas gonivrul eWvs miRma standartiT dadgenilad miaC-nia, rom g. x-m, s. T-a da o. m-a Caidines saqarTvelos ssk-is143-e muxlis 1-li nawiliT gaTvaliswinebuli danaSauli _Tavisuflebis ukanono aRkveTa, vinaidan sisxlis samar-Tlis kanoni am danaSaulis makvalificirebel niSnad armiiCnevs mis Cadenas jgufurad, winaswari SeTanxmebis ga-reSe.
26. rac Seexeba sasjels, saqarTvelos ssk-is 53-e mux-lis Sesabamisad, sasjelis daniSvnis dros sasamarTlo iT-valiswinebs damnaSavis pasuxismgeblobis Semamsubuqebelda damamZimebel garemoebebs, kerZod, danaSaulis motiv-sa da mizans, qmedebaSi gamovlenil marTlsawinaaRmdegonebas, movaleobaTa darRvevis xasiaTsa da zomas, qmede-bis ganxorcielebis saxes, xerxsa da marTlsawinaaRmdegoSedegs, damnaSavis warsul cxovrebas, pirad da ekonomi-kur pirobebs, yofaqcevas qmedebis Semdeg, gansakuTre-biT _ mis miswrafebas, aanazRauros ziani, Seurigdes da-zaralebuls.
1 ix. adamianis uflebaTa evropuli sasamarTlos gadaw-yvetilebebi saqmeebze: „el-masri yofili iugoslaviisrespublika makedoniis winaaRmdeg~, punqti 151 (El-Masriv The Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia), „hasani gaerTia-nebuli samefos winaaRmdeg~, punqti 48 (Hassan v The UK).
58
an gaufrTxilebeli danaSauli da igi aRiarebs danaSaulsan/da TanamSromlobs gamoZiebasTan, sasamarTlo ufle-bamosilia, daadginos, rom daniSnuli sasjeli CaiTvalospirobiTad, Tu msjavrdebuli warsulSi nasamarTlevi aryofila gansakuTrebiT mZime an ganzraxi mZime danaSau-lis CadenisaTvis.
28. Tavisuflebis ukanono aRkveTa ganekuTvneba nak-lebad mZime danaSaulTa kategorias. s. T-i da o. m-i war-sulSi ar arian nasamarTlevni, marTalia, maT ar aRiaresdanaSauli, magram Tavidanve iTanamSromles gamoZiebas-Tan da ar uaryves saqmis faqtobrivi garemoebebi, Tumca,maTi azriT, maTi qmedebebi ar warmoadgens danaSauls. sa-kasacio palatas maTi ojaxuri da o. m-s janmrTelobismdgomareobis, maT mier Cadenili qmedebebis saxis, qme-debaSi gamovlenili marTlsawinaaRmdego nebis, xarisxi-sa da rolis gaTvaliswinebiT, mocemul konkretul Sem-TxvevaSi mizanSewonilad miaCnia maTTvis msjavrad Serac-xuli muxlis sanqciiT gaTvaliswinebuli minimaluri sas-jelis gansazRvra da saqarTvelos ssk-is 63-e-64-e mux-lebis gamoyenebiT _ pirobiT CaTvla; rac Seexeba g. x-s,imis gaTvaliswinebiT, rom man ar aRiara danaSauli, arismiTiTebuli danaSaulis organizatori da sakasacio pala-tis sxdomaze Tavi aarida gamocxadebas, sakasacio pala-tas miaCnia, rom saqarTvelos ssk-is 39-e muxliT gaTva-liswinebuli sasjelis miznebis _ samarTlianobis aRdge-nis, axali danaSaulis Tavidan acilebisa da damnaSavis re-socializaciis misaRwevad mas sasjeli unda ganesazRvrosrealurad mosaxdelad.
5. quTaisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlissaqmeTa palatis 2016 wlis 8 dekembris ganaCeniT ar dak-mayofilda msjavrdebul n. k-is interesebis damcvelis,advokat i. S-s saapelacio saCivari da quTaisis saqalaqosasamarTlos 2016 wlis 18 maisis ganaCeni darCa ucvle-lad.
6. kasatori _ msjavrdebul n. k-is interesebis damcve-li, advokati v. k-i sakasacio saCivarSi aRniSnavs, rom n. k-is qmedeba arasworad Sefasda. mas ar gaaCnda saxlSi da-sabrunebeli Tanxa, ris gamoc w-Si, k-is quCaze mdebare sa-erTo binis mimdebare teritoriaze mdgar mikroavtobus-Si arsebuli garkveuli odenobis Tanxis daufleba ganiz-raxa. man danaSauli individualurad Caidina da policie-lebis Cveneba, rom TiTqosda, dainaxes ori piri, romle-bic maT danaxvaze gaiqcnen, emsaxureboda n. k-is arasaxar-bielo samarTlebriv mdgomareobaSi Cayenebas. amasTan, da-naSaulis jgufurad Cadenis SemTxvevaSi gamoZiebas ekis-reboda meore piris dadgenis da dakavebis valdebule-bac. gasaTvaliswinebelia, rom n. k-is mizans warmoadgen-da mxolod mikroavtobusidan Tanxis daufleba da ara _Tavad avtomobilis raime nawilis an/da misi daZvrisa dawayvanis survili, miT umetes, rom man avtomanqanis mar-Tvac ki ar icis.
7. kasatoris miTiTebiT, n. k-em aRiara danaSauli, iTa-
63
namSromla gamoZiebasTan, igi ar aris nasamarTlevi da mismier Cadenili danaSauli naklebad mZime kategoriis da-naSaulTa ricxvs ganekuTvneba.
bargulis karTan. miTiTebulma pirebma policielebi verSeamCnies. k. m-e da t. t-e SeCerdnen. maT TavdapirveladegonaT, rom aRniSnuli pirebi avtomanqanis mflobelebiiyvnen da masSi Casxdomas an raime sagnis gadmoRebas api-rebdnen, magram Semdeg dainaxes, rom mesame sadarbazo-dan ezoSi saSualo simaRlis mamakaci gamovida, romlisdanaxvazec TeTr mikroavtobusTan mdgomi sami piri Sem-Txvevis adgilidan k-is quCis bolosken gaiqca. k. m-e da t.t-e mixvdnen, rom gaqceuli pirebi TeTri mikroavtobu-sis gaRebasa da gaqurdvas cdilobdnen, ris gamoc aedev-nen, xolo raciiT operatiul moriges daxmarebis Txov-niT daukavSirdnen. asi metris sirbilis Semdeg, k. m-e dat. t-e gaqceul pirebs wamoewivnen, dauZaxes, rom iyvnenpolicielebi da SeCerebisken mouwodes. SemTxvevis ad-gilidan gaqceulma pirebma ukan moixedes, magram ar dae-morCilnen policielTa mowodebas, erT-erTi maTgani gzismarcxena mxares, xolo meore marjvena mxares, sibneleSigaiqca. rac Seexeba mesame pirs, man sirbili k-is quCis bo-losken ganagrZo. vinaidan adgilze iyo ori policieli dasibneleSi gaqceuli pirebi SesaZloa, verc moeZebnaT, k.m-e da t. t-e k-is quCis mxares gaqceuls daedevnen da Se-Cerebisken uSedegod mouwodebdnen. sabolood, polici-elebma igi b-is quCis #..-Si mdebare korpuris win daaka-ves. dakavebuli piri n. k-e aRmoCnda.
4. mowme t. t-is dakiTvxis oqmiT igive faqtobrivi ga-remoebebia dadasturebuli.
5. mxedvelobaSia misaRebi dazaralebul b. q-is dakiT-xvis oqmic, romlis Tanaxmadac, dazaralebulma 2016 wlis25 ianvars, misi qaliSvilis binidan gamosvlis dros, mar-cxniv, meoTxe sadarbazosken wasvla daapira, ra drosackuTvnili avtomanqanis mxridan adgilidan uecrad gaqce-visa da fexis xmebi Semoesma, Semotrialda, gaixeda misimanqanisaken, sadac bneloda da veravin dainaxa, Semdeg kimisi manqanis ukan, k-is quCis bolosken gaixeda (saidanacfexis xmebi ismoda) da ramdenime gaqceuli adamianis si-lueti dainaxa.
6. sakasacio palata, dasaxelebuli mtkicebulebebidangamomdinare, ver gaiziarebs dacvis mxaris pozicias imfaqtTan dakavSirebiT, rom policielTa mxridan n. k-ismier qurdobis mcdelobis jgufurad Cadenis miTiTeba misarasaxarbielo mdgomareobaSi Cayenebasa da bralis dam-
65
Zimebas emsaxureboda. gansaxilvel SemTxvevaSi k. m-isa dat. t-is udavod cnobili dakiTxvis oqmebi urTierTSeTan-xmebulia da maTSi asaxul faqtobriv garemoebebs Sorisar arsebobs raime saxis winaaRmdegoba. sisxlis samarTlissaqmeSi warmodgenil masalaTa analizis Tanaxmad, ar ar-sebobs mtkicebuleba, romelic Tundac iribad daadastu-rebda policiis TanamSromelTa mikerZoebas, saqmiT da-interesebasa da Sesabamis organoebSi ganzrax cru Cvene-bis micemas. amasTanave, policielTa Cvenebebis utyuaro-bis dasadastureblad sakasacio palata yuradRebas miaq-cevs Tavad dazaralebulis dakiTxvis oqms, kerZod, mar-Talia, dazaralebulma uSualod n. k-e da misi Tanmxlebipirebi ver dainaxa, magram kuTvnil avtomanqanasTan masSemTxvevis dRes fexis xmebi moesma da dasaxelebul ad-gilze misulma dainaxa, Tu rogor garboda ramdenime ada-mianis silueti k-is quCis bolosken. amdenad, b. q-is Cve-nebiT ar ikveTeba danaSaulis erTi piris mier Cadenis faq-ti, vinaidan igi miTiTebas fexis xmebze, xolo Semdeg kiramdenime adamianis siluetze akeTebs. aRniSnulTan er-Tad, sayuradReboa, rom ramdenime siluetis gaqcevis mi-marTuleba (k-is quCa) emTxveva policielTa mier miTiTe-bul sami piris gaqcevis mimarTulebas. mocemuli garemo-ebebi ganamtkicebs k. m-isa da t. t-is mier dasaxelebulfaqtobriv garemoebas, rom SemTxvevis adgilze n. k-e mar-to ar moqmedebda.
7. rac Seexeba qmedebis subieqtur Semadgeblobas, sa-kasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom pirTa SemTxvevis adgilzeerToblivad yofna, maTi rolebis gadanawileba (ori piriaRebda fanjaras, xolo erTi idga avtomanqanis ukana sa-bargulis karTan) da maTi SemCnevis Semdeg erTad gaqce-va, miuTiTebs danaSaulis jgufurad Cadenis ganzraxva-ze.
8. sakasacio palata ver daeTanxmeba aseve dacvis mxa-res, rom vinaidan sagamoZiebo organom ver daadgina daver daakava jgufis sxva wevrebi, aRniSnulis gamo danaSa-ulis jgufurad Cadena unda gamoiricxos. k. m-isa da t. t-is dakiTxvis oqmebidan gamomdinare, policielTa mxri-dan ar SeiniSneba, rom jgufis sxva wevrebis dasakavebladpolicielebi umoqmedobas iCendnen. mxedvelobaSia misa-Rebi is garemoeba, rom maT dadevnebisTanave raciiT mo-uxmes damxmare Zalas, xolo gaqceul pirebs SeCerebisa-
66
ken mouwodebnen. pirTa sami sxvadasxva mimarTulebiT gaq-cevis Semdeg k. m-e da t. t-e mxolod erT-erT maTgans _ n.k-es, policielTa raodenobidan da quCaze arsebuli ga-naTebidan gamomdinare, daedevnen.
11. saapelacio sasamarTlos miRebul gadawyvetileba-Si makvalificirebeli garemoebebis _ `mniSvnelovani zia-nisa~ da `satransporto saSualebis winaaRmdeg~ mimarTu-li qmedebis _ qurdobis mcdelobis subieqtur Semadgen-lobaze ar umsjelia. sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom yo-veli saxis makvalificirebeli garemoebis bralad Serac-xvisas aucilebelia, Semowmdes qmedebis Semadgenlobisobieqturi da subieqturi mxareebi. amasTan, aucilebelia,rom pirs obieqturi Semadgenlobis yoveli niSnis mimarTgaaCndes ganzraxva.
12. aRsaniSnavia, rom qurdoba, Cadenili satranspor-to saSualebis winaaRmdeg, gulisxmobs rogorc uSualodsatransporto saSualebis, aseve misi Semadgeneli nawi-lebis dauflebas. faqti, rom n. k-is ganzraxva moicavdasatransporto saSualebis an misi romelime nawilisa Tunawilebis dauflebas, warmodgenili mtkicebulebebiTdadasturebuli ar aris, kerZod: n. k-is dakiTxvis oqmiTdgindeba, rom 2016 wlis 25 ianvars, gvian RamiT, babuissaxlidan wyaltubos mimarTulebiT gamovida. taqsismZRolma quTaisamde mgzavrobis safasurad 8 lari dausa-xela da vinaidan mas mxolod 5 laris gadaxda SeeZlo, 3laris Sovna gadawyvita. gzas gauyva, Seuxvia 20-30 metrSida erT-erTi korpusis win, gzis piras, TeTri samgzavromikroavtobusi SeniSna. n. k-em Tannaqoni saxraxnisiTa da
67
daniT avtomanqanis gaReba scada, vinaidan Tu salonSixurda fuli daxvdeboda, amoiRebda da saxlSi wasvlas SeZ-lebda. dakiTvxis oqmis Tanaxmad, im SemTxvevaSi, Tu n. k-eavtomanqanis gaqurdvas SeZlebda, igi mxolod taqsismZRolisaTvis gadasaxdel 3 lars amoiRebda, danarCenski manqanaSi datovebda.
13. gasaTvaliswinebelia, rom o. s-is (n. k-is papa) uda-vod cnobili dakiTxvis oqmiT dgindeba, rom 2016 wlis 25ianvars mas namdvilad stumrobda SviliSvili n. k-e. ro-desac daRamda, man uTxra, rom saxlSi unda wasuliyo.
14. mowmeebis _ t. t-isa da k. m-is dakiTxvis oqmebis Ta-naxmad, maT dainaxes, rom ori piri aRebda avtomobilisfanjaras, xolo erTi ki manqanis ukana sabargulis karTanidga... amasTan, policielTa miTiTebiT, gaqceuli pirebi`SesaZloa, cdilobdnen TeTri mikroavtobusis gaRebasada gaqurdvas.~
15. aRsaniSnavia, rom zemomiTiTebuli dakiTxvis oqme-bis garda, sxva mtkicebulebebi, romlebic daadastureb-dnen n. k-is ganzraxvas, mimarTuls avtosatransporto sa-Sualebis farulad dauflebis mcdelobisaken, saqmis ma-salebSi ar moipoveba. Sesabamisad, qmedebis subieqturiSemadgenloba bundovania. sakasacio palata aRniSnavs,rom, zogadad, braldebulma SesaZloa, uaryos danaSau-lebrivi qmedebis Cadenis ganzraxva an misi CvenebiT ardgindebodes subieqturi damokidebuleba bralad Serac-xuli qmedebisadmi, magram saqmeSi arsebuli yoveli faq-tobrivi analizis erToblivad Sefaseba qmnides mtkice-bulebiT standarts. gansaxilvel SemTxvevaSi, policiel-Ta dakiTxvis oqmebiT dadasturebuli ar aris, rom n. k-eTanmxleb pirebTan erTad avtomobilis an misi romelimenawilis dauflebis mcdelobis dros dainaxes. t. t-em dak. m-em ganmartes, rom ori piri fanjarasTan idga da misgaRebas cdilobda, magram sadarbazodan mamakacis gamos-vlis Semdeg isini gaiqcnen. maT agreTve ganmartes, romgaqceuli pirebi SesaZloa, cdilobdnen TeTri mikroav-tobusis gaRebasa da gaqurdvas da ara, Tavad avtomobi-lis an misi romelime konkretuli nawilis dauflebas. racSeexeba dazaralebul b. q-es, misi dakiTxvis oqmiT dadge-nilia, rom gaqcevis xmebis Semdeg, avtomanqanasTan mis-vlis dros, man naxa, rom ukana marjvena karis saketi da-zianebuli, amave karis mina sanaxevrod gaRebuli, xolo
68
ukana sabargulis karis saxeluri aweuli iyo. avtomanqa-nis salonSi yvela sagani da nivTi adgilze daxvda. niSan-doblivia, rom braldebuli n. k-e dakiTxvis oqmSi TavadaRwers, Tu konkretulad, romeli nivTis daufleba sur-da da amasTan, ra iyo misi mxridan danaSaulebrivi qmede-bis Cadenis mizezi. dakiTxvis oqmis Tanaxmad, misi ganzrax-va moicavda Tanxis dauflebas, raTa saxlSi dabrunebu-liyo. maSasadame, mtkicebulebaTa erToblioba, romelicutyuarad daadasturebda, rom n. k-e Tanmxleb pirebTanavtomanqanis an misi romelime nawilis dauflebis cdi-lobda, gansaxilvel saqmeSi warmodgenili ar aris.
16. rac Seexeba saqarTvelos ssk-is 19.177-e muxlis me-2nawilis `a~ qvepunqtiT gaTvaliswinebul makvalificire-bel garemoebas _ mniSvnelovani zianis SesaZlo dadgomas_ sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom gansaxilvel SemTxve-vaSi agreTve ar arsebobs gonivrul eWvs miRma mtkicebu-lebiTi standarti. saqarTvelos ssk-is 177-e muxlis Se-niSvnis Tanaxmad, ziani mniSvnelovania, Tu nivTis Rire-buleba aRemateba 150 lars. rogorc aRiniSna, n. k-is miergamoZiebiT daudgenel or pirTan erTad avtomanqanis fa-rulad dauflebis mcdeloba, saqmis masalaTa mixedviTdadasturebuli ar aris. amasTan, zemomiTiTebuli mowme-ebis dakiTxvis oqmebiT (b. q-e, k. m-e, t. t-e) ar dgindeba,rom n. k-e 150 lars zemoT Rirebulebis nivTis dauflebascdilobda. dazaralebul b. q-is dakiTxvis oqmis Sesabami-sad, gaqcevis xmebis gagebis Semdeg avtomanqana maSinvedaaTvaliera da yvela nivTi adgilze iyo. mas raime mate-rialuri ziani ar misdgomia da fanjara gaRebisas ar dazi-anebula. ukana sabargulis karis saketi da saxeluri ag-reTve ar iyo dazianebuli. saqmeSi warmodgenili masale-bis Tanaxmad, braldebulma ganacxada, rom mas namdviladgaaCnda qurdobis ganzraxva, magram mxolod danaklisi 3larisa, romelic taqsis mZRolisaTvis unda gadaexada, ra-Ta saxlSi dabrunebuliyo.
17. amdenad, faqti, rom n. k-e danaSaulebrivi qmedebisCadenis mcdelobisas 150 lars zemoT Rirebulebis nivTseufleboda, warmoadgens varauds, romelic ver dastur-deba aSkara, damajerebel da urTierTSeTanxmebul mtki-cebulebaTa erTobliobiT. Sesabamisad, mocemuli eWvi,sisxlis samarTlis erT-erTi fuZemdebluri principis (`Indubio pro reo~) Sesabamisad, braldebulis/msjavrdebulis
69
sasargeblod unda gadawydes.18. rac Seexeba sasjelis zomas, sakasacio palata mxed-
velobaSi iRebs saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeq-sis 39-e muxlisa da amave kodeqsis 53-e muxlis Sinaarss daindividualurad afasebs n. k-is pirovnebas. gansaxilvelSemTxvevaSi msjavrdebulma, marTalia, Caidina ganzraxi,mZime kategoriis danaSauli, magram amavdroulad palataiTvaliswinebs im garemoebas, rom n. k-es msjavridan orimakvalificirebeli garemoeba, kerZod, saqarTvelos ssk-is 19.177-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `a~ qvepunqti da amave mux-lis me-3 nawilis `d~ qvepunqti unda amoericxos. mocemu-li garemoeba ki amcirebs n. k-is qmedebis saSiSroebis xa-risxs. amasTan, sakasacio palata mxedvelobaSi iRebs n. k-is mZime ekonomikur pirobebsa da danaSaulis Cadenis mo-tivsa da mizans, kerZod, imas rom msjavrdebuls saxlSidasabrunebeli Tanxis daufleba surda. gasaTvaliswine-belia, rom n. k-e ar aris nasamarTlevi. rac Seexeba mar-TlsawinaaRmdego Sedegs, rogorc dazaralebul b. q-is da-kiTxvis oqmiT dadginda, mas raime materialuri ziani armisdgomia da, amdenad, ar arsebobs misi anazRaurebis sa-Wiroebac.
19. yovelive zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, sakasa-cio palatas miaCnia, rom danaSaulis nawilobrivi aRiare-bis, movaleobaTa darRvevis xasiaTis, zomis, marTlsawi-naaRmdego Sedegis, damnaSavis piradi da mZime ekonomi-kuri pirobebisa da nasamarTlobis arqonis gaTvaliswine-biT, n. k-es sasjelis zomad unda ganesazRvros sanqciisminimumi _ 4 wliT Tavisuflebis aRkveTa.
d. k-as qmedeba saqarTvelos ssk-is 178-e muxlis me-2nawilis `a~ qvepunqtidan da amave muxlis me-3 nawilis `a,~`g~ qvepunqtebidan gadakvalificirda saqarTvelos ssk-is 177-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `a~ qvepunqtsa da amave mux-lis me-3 nawilis `a,~ `g~ qvepunqtebze. d. k., _ dabadebuli_ wlis ...-s, _ cnobil iqna damnaSaved saqarTvelos ssk-is177-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `a~ qvepunqtiTa da amave muxlisme-3 nawilis `a,~ `g~ qvepunqtebiT gaTvaliswinebuli dana-Saulis CadenisaTvis da saqarTvelos ssk-is 177-e muxlisme-3 nawilis `a,~ `g~ qvepunqtebiT miesaja TavisuflebisaRkveTa 4 wliTa da 6 TviT. gauqmda msjavrdebul d. k-asmimarT SerCeuli aRkveTis RonisZieba _ girao da yadaRamoexsna giraos uzrunvelsayofad n. d-is (p/n -) saxelzesakuTrebis uflebiT ricxul, 30 000 laris Rirebulebiswil uZrav qonebas (mdebare: b-Si, z. g-is q. ..., sarTuli ...,bina #...-Si, 80.31 kvadratul metrs _ zona b. _ ..., seqtori..., kvartali ..., nakveTi ..., kodi ..., sakadastro kodi ...). aR-kveTis RonisZiebasTan erTad agreTve gauqmda msjavrde-bul d. k-as mimarT gamoyenebuli valdebuleba _ paspor-tisa da piradobis mowmobis gamomZieblisaTvis Cabareba.d. k. daakaves sasamarTlo sxdomis darbazSi da sasjelismoxdis aTvla daewyo ganaCenis gamotanis momentidan _2016 wlis 23 maisidan. d. k-as sasjelis moxdis vadaSi Ca-eTvala patimrobaSi yofnis dro _ 2015 wlis 21 maisidanimave wlis 1 seqtembris CaTvliT.
2. sasamarTlom dadgenilad miiCnia, rom 2015 wlis 21maiss, daaxloebiT 20:00 saaTze, T. g-ma, d. k-Tan erTad,winaswari SeTanxmebiT, ukanonod SeaRwia x-is raionis so-fel x-Si mdebare n. b-is sacxovrebel saxlSi da marTlsa-winaaRmdego misakuTrebis mizniT, farulad daeufla n.b-is kuTvnil, 800 larad Rirebul `Lenovo-s~ firmis no-uTbuqs da 800 laris Rirebulebis or wyvil oqros sayu-res, riTac dazaralebul n. b-es jamurad _ 1600 laris mniS-vnelovani ziani miadga.
4. ganaCeni saapelacio wesiT gaasaCivra msjavrdebul-ma d. k-am da misma interesebis damcvelma advokatma, d. j-em, msjavrdebul T. g-is interesebis damcvelma, advokat-
73
ma n. r-em da x-is raionuli prokuraturis prokurorma da-viT xarZeiSvilma.
5. msjavrdebulma d. k-am da misma interesebis damcvel-ma, advokatma d. j-em iTxoves xelvaCauris raionuli sasa-marTlos 2016 wlis 23 maisis ganaCenis gauqmeba da d. k-asgamarTleba. msjavrdebul T. g-is interesebis damcvel-ma, advokatma n. r-em iTxova xelvaCauris raionuli sasa-marTlos 2016 wlis 23 maisis ganaCenis gauqmeba da T. g-isgamarTleba. prokurorma daviT xarZeiSvilma iTxova xel-vaCauris raionuli sasamarTlos 2016 wlis 23 maisis gana-CenSi cvlilebis Setana, msjavrdebulebis damnaSavedcnoba saqarTvelos ssk-is 178-e muxlis me-2 nawilis ̀ a~ qve-punqtiTa da me-3 nawilis `a,~ `g~ qvepunqtebiT da ufromkacri sasjelis daniSvna.
nixila sakasacio saCivari, Seiswavla saqmis masalebi, Sea-mowma saCivris safuZvlianoba da miaCnia, rom xelvaCau-ris raionuli prokuraturis prokuror daviT xarZeiSvi-lis sakasacio saCivari unda dakmayofildes, xolo msjav-rdebul T. g-is sakasacio saCivari ar unda dakmayofil-des, Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. dazaralebulma n. b-em ganacxada, rom 2015 wlis 21maiss, daaxloebiT 20:00 saaTze, naTeli dRe iyo, rodesacx-is raionis sofel x-Si mdebare Tavis sacxovrebel sax-lSi dabrunda. man gaaRo ezoSi Sesasvleli WiSkari, Sevi-da da dainaxa, rom misi sacxovrebeli saxlis aivanze idgaucnobi axalgazrda mamakaci, romlis danaxvaze dauZaxa _Tu ras Svreboda igi am adgilas. am dros sacxovrebelisaxlis fanjridan kidev erTi axalgazda mamakaci gadmox-ta, romelsac xelSi misi nouTbuqi eWira da orive sawina-aRmdego mxares gaiqca. saxlSi Sesulma mowmem aRmoaCina,rom xsenebulma pirebma `Lenovo-s~ firmis nouTbuqi da oriwyvili oqros sayure waiRes. momxdaris Taobaze ramdeni-
75
me wuTSi policias Seatyobina. man aseve ganacxada, rom isaxalgazrda mamakaci, romelic ezoSi Sesvlis dros pir-velad SeniSna misi sacxovrebeli saxlis aivanze, iyo d. k.,xolo meore axalgazrda mamakaci, romelic gadmoxta oTa-xis fanjridan Tavisi kuTvnili nouTbuqiT, iyo T. g.. ori-ve maTgani man policiaSi amoicno, iseve rogorc misi sax-lidan gatacebuli nivTebi. man aseve ganacxada, rom bral-debulebisaTvis misi kuTvnili `Lenovo-s~ firmis nouTbu-qisa da ori wyvili oqros sayuris waRebis ufleba ar miu-cia. dazaralebulis miTiTebiT, misi kuTvnili `Lenovo-s~firmis nouTbuqisa da oqros sayureebis saerTo Rirebu-lebaa _ 1600 lari.
3. mowme i. i-em, romelic dazaralebulis rZalia, gan-marta, rom 2015 wlis 21 maiss, daaxloebiT 20:00 saaTze, n.b. avtomanqaniT x-is raionis sofel x-Si mdebare Tavis sac-xovrebel saxlTan miiyvana da daaxloebiT 20 metris mo-SorebiT Camosva, xolo TviTon ki gza gaagrZela. ramdeni-me wuTSi dabrunda ukan, ra drosac saxlis win, gzaze, dax-vda SeSinebuli dedamTili, romelmac uambo, rom maTTansaxlSi Sesuli yofila ori mamakaci, romlebmac nouTbuqida oqros sayureebi gaitaces. aRniSnulis Semdeg mowmemn. b. x-is raionul sammarTveloSi miiyvana, sadac man mom-xdaris Taobaze ganacxada.
4. T. g-sa da d. k-as amocnobis oqmebis Tanaxmad, dazara-lebulma n. b-em kanoniT dadgenili wesis Sesabamisad amo-icno isini da aRniSna, rom xsenebuli pirebi swored is ma-makacebi, romlebmac misi kuTvnili `Lenovo-s~ firmis no-uTbuqi da ori wyvili oqros sayure gaitaces.
5. avtomanqanis (`folksvagen jeta~, saxelmwifo nome-ri: ...) Cxrekis oqmis, mowmeebis v. T-sa da d. i-is CvenebebisTanaxmad, avtomanqanidan amoiRes `lenovos~ firmis SavinouTbuqi da ori wyvili oqros sayure.
6. mowme z. g-ma ganmarta, rom avtomanqana `folksvagenjeta,~ saxelmwifo nomriT _ `...~, aris misi sakuTreba, ro-melic 2015 wlis 21 maiss Tavis Zmas _ T. g-s aTxova.
7. mowme d. i-em agreTve ganmarta, rom 2015 wlis 21 ma-iss, daaxloebiT 21:00 saaTze, x-is raionul sammarTvelo-Si gamocxadda n. b., romelmac Seatyobina ori axalgzrdapiris mier nouTbuqisa da oqros samkaulebis misi sacxov-rebeli saxlidan gatacebis faqti. n. b-em garegnulad aR-wera dasaxelebuli pirebi da amasTan, miuTiTa maTi gaq-
76
cevis mimarTulebaze. operatiuli jgufi dauyovneblivgavida n. b-is mier miTiTebuli mimarTulebiT da f. x-isgamzirze, e.w `n-Tan~, gzis piras gaCerebuli Savi avtoman-qana `folksvagen jeta~ SeniSnes, romelTanac ori axal-gazrda mamakaci idga. maTi garegnoba n. b-is mier aRwerilgaregnobas emTxveoda. maTTan mividnen da aRniSnuli pi-rebi T. g. da d. k. aRmoCndnen.
8. amdenad, palatas miaCnia, rom zemoaRniSnul mtki-cebulebaTa erToblioba (kanoniT dadgenili wesiT mopo-vebuli werilobiTi mtkicebulebebis zepir mtkicebule-bebTan Sesabamisoba) gonivrul eWvs miRma adasturebs T.g-sa da d. k-as mier n. b-s sacxovrebeli saxlidan nivTebisdauflebas marTlsawinaaRmdego misakuTrebis mizniT,magram rac Seexeba qmedebis farul xasiaTs, sakasacio pa-lata mocemul nawilSi ver daeTanxmeba saapelacio sasa-marTlos msjelobas da miaCnia, rom msjavrdebulebis qme-deba, gaTvaliswinebuli saqarTvelos ssk-is 177-e muxlisme-2 nawilis `a~ qvepunqtiTa da amave muxlis me-3 nawilis`a,~ `g~ qvepunqtebiT, unda gadakvalificirdes saqarTve-los ssk-is 178-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `a~ qvepunqtsa da ama-ve muxlis me-3 nawilis `a,~ `g~ qvepunqtebze, Semdeg gare-moebaTa gamo:
9. sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom qurdobis obieqtu-ri mxaris savaldebulo niSani misi faruli xasiaTia, ro-melic qmedebis sxva pirTagan SeumCnevlad Cadenas gulis-xmobs. rac Seexeba Zarcvas, misi obieqturi mxaris saval-debulo niSania danaSaulis aSkarad, sxva pirTaTvis xi-lulad Cadena. orive maTgani damTavrebulad iTvleba masSemdeg, rac piri marTlsawinaaRmdegod daeufleba sxvisnivTs da misi gankargvis realuri SesaZlebloba eqneba.gansaxilvel SemTxvevaSi, marTalia, qmedebis Semadgenlo-bis ganxorcieleba n. b-is sacxovrebel saxlSi faruladdaiwyo (rodesac SemTxvevis adgilze damnaSaveTa garda,aravin imyofeboda), magram qmedebis Semadgenlobis das-rulebamde obieqturi mxare uwyvetad faruli ar iyo. da-zaralebulis Cvenebis Tanaxmad, saxlSi misvlis dros mandainaxa Tavisi sacxovrebeli saxlis aivanze mdgari ucno-bi axalgazrda mamakaci. sasamarTlo yuradRebas amaxvi-lebs im garemoebaze, rom dazaralebulis daZaxebis Sem-deg (Tu ras Svreboda ucnobi piri am adgilas), sacxovre-beli saxlis fanjridan gadmoxta kidev erTi axalgazrda
77
mamakaci, romelsac Tan nivTi eWira. sakasacio palata aR-niSnavs, rom damnaSavis fanjridan gadmoxtomis dros qme-debis Semadgenloba dasrulebuli ar iyo, radgan nivTisTavisufali gankargvis SesaZlebloba damnaSaveebs jer ki-dev ar hqondaT. amdenad, aRniSnuli momentidan (dazara-lebulis saxlSi dabrunebidan, ucxo piris aivanze SemCne-vidan, daZaxebidan da meore piris nivTiT xelSi fanjri-dan gadmoxtomisas) damnaSaveTa qmedebis subieqturi Se-madgenloba _ ganzraxva danaSaulis farulad CadeniskenmimarTuli aRar iyo. is faqtobrivi garemoeba, rom meorepiri fanjridan n. b-is daZaxebis Semdeg gadmoxta miuTi-Tebs SemTxvevis adgilas sxva piris yofnis gacnobierebisfaqtze. aRniSnulis miuxedavad, damnaSaveebma SemTxve-vis adgili sirbiliT, nouTbuqiT xelSi datoves, rac maTmier qmedebis Semadgenlobis ganzrax, aSkarad dasrule-bis gacnoebierebas gulisxmobs. maSasadame, marTalia,msjavrdebulTa ganzraxva Tavdapirvelad swored sxvisinivTis farulad dauflebisken iyo mimarTuli, magram masSemdeg, rac isini dazaralebulma n. b-em SeamCnia, vinai-dan danaSauli jer kidev dasrulebuli ar iyo, maT nivTisaSkarad dauflebis ganzraxva gauCndaT. yovelive zemo-aRniSnulidan gamomdinare, sakasacio palatas miaCnia, romT. g-ma da d. k-am n. b-is sacxovrebeli saxlidan nivTebisdaufleba marTlsawinaaRmdego misakuTrebis mizniT aS-karad Caidines.
10. qmedebis makvalificirebel garemoebebTan mimar-TebiT sakasacio palata miuTiTebs, rom zemoaRniSnulimtkicebulebebi gonivrul eWvs miRma adastureben maT ar-sebobas da aRniSnul nawilSi sakasacio palata eTanxmebapirveli instanciisa da saapelacio sasamarTloebis argu-mentacias.
11. msjavrdebulis sakasacio saCivarSi miTiTebul pro-cedurul darRvevebTan dakavSirebiT sakasacio palataaRniSnavs, rom igi warmodgenili sisxlis samarTlis saq-mis masalebiT dadasturebuli ar aris.
da d. k-as Zaladobrivi xasiaTis danaSauli ar CaudeniaT.danaSaulis Cadenis gamo asanazRaurebel SedegTan mimar-TebiT sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom vinaidan sagamoZi-ebo organom aRniSnuli nivTebi kanoniT dadgenili wesiTamoiRo, ziani asanazRaurebeli ar aris.
13. aRsaniSnavia, rom d. k-as pasuxismgeblobis damamZi-mebeli garemoebebi ar gaaCnia, xolo T. g-Tan mimarTebiT,vinaidan gamokveTilia danaSaulis recidivi, mas kanoniTgaTvaliswinebuli sasjelis minimalur zRvarze erTiwliT meti unda daeniSnos.
14. amdenad, Cadenili qmedebis xasiaTis, movaleobaTadarRvevis xasiaTis, zomis, ganxorcielebuli qmedebis sa-xisa da marTlsawinaaRmdego Sedegis gaTvaliswinebiT, T.g-s sasjelis saxed da zomad unda ganesazRvros _ Tavi-suflebis aRkveTa 6 wliT, xolo d. k-as _ TavisuflebisaRkveTa 5 wliT.
7. kasatori _ prokurori dariko vadaWkoria iTxovs qu-Taisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saqme-Ta palatis 2017 wlis 10 Tebervlis ganaCenSi cvlilebisSetanas, z. q-is damnaSaved cnobas saqarTvelos ssk-is 179-emuxlis 1-li nawiliT da kanoniT gaTvaliswinebuli sasje-lis Sefardebas; quTaisis saapelacio sasamarTlos msje-loba, rac safuZvlad daedo ganaCens, ar gamomdinareobssaqmeSi warmodgenili mtkicebulebebidan da sasamarTlomdausabuTeblad mxedvelobaSi ar miiRo konkretuli mtki-cebulebebi, romlebic sxva mtkicebulebebTan erTobli-vad gonivrul eWvs miRma adasturebda z. q-is braleulo-bas yaCaRobaSi; i. b-em da J. b-em z. q-is xelSi arsebuli nivTidanad aRiqves da SeeSindaT. yaCaRoba dasrulebulia Tav-dasxmis momentidan da z. q-is xelT arsebuli vercxlisfe-ri sagani aRqmul iqna danad. amdenad, dazaralebuls, misiobieqturi aRqmidan gamomdinare, SeeSinda.
8. kasatori _ advokati g. C-e iTxovs z. q-is mimarT Se-fardebuli sasjelis Semsubuqebas, kerZod, misi jarimiTSecvlas im motiviT, rom z. q-es hyavs ojaxi da mezoblebiaxasiaTeben dadebiTad. aRiarebs da gulwrfelad inaniebsCadenil danaSauls. amasTan, z. q-e ar aris nasamarTlevi.
nixila sakasacio saCivrebi, Seiswavla saqmis masalebi, Se-amowma saCivrebis safuZvlianoba da miaCnia, rom quTaisisraionuli prokuraturis prokuror dariko vadaWkoriassakasacio saCivari unda dakmayofildes, xolo msjavrde-bul z. q-is interesebis damcvelis, advokat g. C-is sakasa-cio saCivari ar unda dakmayofildes, Semdeg garemoebaTagamo:
2. dazaralebulma i. b-m sasamarTlo sxdomaze ganacxa-da, rom 2015 wlis 5 dekembers q-Si, m-is #-Si mdebare mar-
82
ket _ `j-Si~ staJior-molared muSaobda. im dRes masTanerTad, amave marketSi x-a, igive J-a b-e muSaobda. daaxlo-ebiT 23:00 saaTze, rodesac J-sTan erTad daxlze produq-tebs alagebda, marketSi misTvis ucnobi, nasvami, sustiaRnagobis biWi Sevida. mas Savi kapiuSoni exura, romelicSemdeg gadasZvra. axalgazrdas Txeli wveri da Tma hqon-da, Sublze odnav meloti iyo da mogrZo saxe hqonda. igisalarosTan mivida da sigareti iTxova. mowmem miawoda dasafasuris gadaxda sTxova, ra drosac biWma jibeSi xeliCaiyo, moulodnelad priala zedapiris mqone, wvetiani sa-gani (misi aRqmiT, dana) amoiRo da Tanxis gadacema moiT-xova. i. b-e daniT SeiaraRebuli mamakacis danaxvaze ZlierSeSinda da iq myof J-as yviriliT mouxmo dasaxmareblad.J-a marketidan gaiqca. mowmem Tavdamsxmels uTxra, romfuli ar hqonda da sTxova marketidan gasuliyo, magrambiWi danis qneviT salarosken daiZra, mivida salaros ma-gidasTan da i. b-es dazianebiT emuqreboda. am dros daza-ralebulma biWi moigeria da plastmasis skami TavSi Caar-tya. man jer ukan daixia, xolo Semdeg salaros daxlzedadebuli, mowmis kuTvnili `huaveis~ mobiluri telefo-ni aiRo da gaiqca. mowmis monawileobiT amocnoba Catar-da, sadac i. b-em z. q-e amoicno.
3. mowme J. b-em ganacxada, rom 2015 wlis 5 dekembers,daxloebiT 23:00 saaTze, is da i. b-e marketSi iyvnen daTaroebze nivTebs alagebdnen. am dros maTTan 25-30 wlam-de asakis, susti aRnagobis, Savwveriani biWi Semovida. misdanaxvaze i. salarosTan mivida, misi moTxovnis Sesabami-sad, sigareti miawoda da sanacvlod safasuri mosTxova.biWma i-s uTxra, rom Tanxa ar hqonda, xolo Semdeg xelSipatara, wvetiani sagani daikava da i-s navaWri Tanxis gada-cema mosTxova. am dros biWi salarosken gaemarTa, xolo i-m iyvira da Svela iTxova. J. b-es SeeSinda da daxmarebissaTxovnelad mopirdapire maRaziisken gaiqca. igi am maRa-ziaSi momuSave qalbatonTan erTad marketisaken gaemar-Ta, ra drosac dainaxa, rom biWi marketidan gamovida dagaiqca. mowme biWs saxeze sakmarisad kargad ver daakvir-da, magram mogvianebiT Seityo, rom igi marketis mezobe-lad mdebare ubanSi cxovrobda.
lad muSaobda. xsenebul dRes moxda yaCaRoba. dazarale-bulma policias aRuwera Tavdamsxmelis garegnoba. amdros TanamSromlebTan _ a. m-sTan, o. g-sa da g. s-sTan er-Tad imyofeboda a-is quCaze, sadac policiis ganyofile-bidan acnobes operatiuli informacia, rom dazaralebu-lis mier miTiTebuli aRwerilobis piri b-as quCaze gada-adgildeboda. im adgilze male mividnen da iq arsebul lu-dis barSi SesvlisTanave biWi daakaves, romelic z. q-e aR-moCnda. dakavebuls piradi Cxrekis dros `huaveisa~ da `no-kias~ firmis mobiluri telefonebi da `vinstonis~ firmissigareti amouRes. maTTvis cnobili iyo, rom dakavebulmam-is quCaze mdebare marketis gamyidvels danis gamoyene-biT sigareti da telefoni gastaca.
5. mowme o. g-is Cvenebis Tanaxmad, muSaobs quTaisis sa-qalaqo sammarTvelos policiis me-3 ganyofilebis ubnis in-speqtor-gamomZieblad. 2015 wlis 6 dekembers, gvian RamiT,a. m-sTan da g. s-sTan erTad imyofeboda a-is quCaze, sadacmaTTan policiis muSaki d. b-e mivida, uambo danaSaulis Se-saxeb da Tavdamsxmelis garegnoba aRuwera. ramdenime xan-Si d. b-es acnobes, rom danaSauli SesaZloa, z. q-s Caedinada is, savaraudod, b-as quCaze moZraobda. isini wavidnen ammisamarTze, sadac ludis barTan SeniSnes dasaxelebuliaxalgazrda, romelic d. b-em daakava da ZiriTadi uflebe-bi ganumarta. dakavebulma piradi Cxrekisas nebayoflobiTwarmoadgina `huaveisa~ da `nokias~ firmis mobiluri tele-fonebi da `vinstonis~ firmis sigareti.
6. sasamarTlo sxdomaze analogiuri xasiaTis Cvenebamisca mowme g. s-em.
q. s-e cnobil iqna damnaSaved: saqarTvelos ssk-is 180-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `a~ da me-3 nawilis `b~ qvepunqtebiT(2015 wlis 28 oqtombris _ m. R-s, l. m-sa da z. q-s epizodi)da sasjelad ganesazRvra 6 wliT Tavisuflebis aRkveTa;
saqarTvelos ssk-is 363-e muxlis me-2 nawiliT (2015 wlis24 seqtembris _ z. s-s epizodi) da sasjelad ganesazRvra9 TviT Tavisuflebis aRkveTa;
saqarTvelos ssk-is 363-e muxlis me-2 nawiliT (2015 wlis28 oqtombris _ m. R-s, l. m-sa da z. q-s epizodi) da sasje-lad ganesazRvra 9 TviT Tavisuflebis aRkveTa;
ma sakasacio saCivrebis safuZvlianoba da daaskvna, rommsjavrdebul q. s-s, msjavrdebul r. R-s interesebis dam-cvelis, advokat e. m-sa sakasacio saCivrebi ar unda dakma-yofildes, xolo gldani-naZaladevis raionuli prokura-turis prokuror levan JorJolaZis sakasacio saCivari un-da dakmayofildes da gasaCivrebul ganaCenSi unda Sevi-des cvlileba, Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. mxareTa mier udavod cnobili sesxisa da ipoTekisxelSekrulebiT dadgenilia, rom 2015 wlis 24 seqtembersl. s-s saxeliT z. s-Tan gaformda sesxisa da ipoTekis xel-Sekruleba da gamsesxebelma z. s-m gasca sesxi _ 10 000 aSSdolari, xolo sesxis uzrunvelyofa moxda msesxebl l.s-s kuTvnili uZravi qonebiT, mdebare _ q. TbilisSi, ... q.#...-Si.
3. aRniSnuli xelSekrulebis siswore daadastura no-tariusma m. a-m, romlis Cvenebac aseve udavod iqna cnobi-li da mieniWa preiudiciuli mniSvneloba.
4. sasamarTlos sxdomaze mowmis saxiT dakiTxul daza-ralebul l. s-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom q. s-e aris misida. TbilisSi, ... q.#...-Si mdebare bina registrirebulia missaxelze, romelic SeiZina erTi wlis win 45 000 aSS dola-rad. misTvis cnobili gaxda, rom aRniSnuli bina aris ipo-TekiT arakanonierad datvirTuli im SeTanxmebis safuZ-velze, romelSic monawileobdnen k-e da R-e, aseve misi da_ q. s-e. dazaralebulis ganmartebiT, 2015 wlis 24 seqtem-bersa da 2015 wlis 28 oqtombers notariusTan ar misulada Sesabamisad, mindobiloba misi gacemuli ar aris; asevexeli ar mouweria sesxisa da ipoTekis arc erT xelSekru-lebaze. xelSekrulebis gaformebis Sesaxeb gaigo boloxelSekrulebis gaformebidan meore dRes, maSin, rode-sac notariusma daureka da hkiTxa vinaoba da iyo Tu ara
94
masTan misuli wina dRes, rac man ar daudastura. misTvisaseve cnobilia, rom misi piradobis mowmoba moipares sax-lidan da moparuli piradobis mowmobis gamoyenebiT, misnacvlad sxva piris xelmoweriT, gaformda sesxisa da ipo-Tekis xelSekrulebebi da mindobiloba. mas surda pira-dobis damadasturebeli mowmobis Secvla, ris gamoc mivi-da iusticiis saxlSi, sadac gairkva, rom misi piradobismowmobis Secvlas cdilobdnen _ r. R-e da q. s-e. manve gan-marta, rom mas daukavSirda r. R-s mama da uTxra, rom da-ubrunebda im Tanxas, romelic q. s-s hqonda gadaxdili r.R-Tvis.
5. mowme z. s-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2015 wlis 24seqtembers notarius m. a-s sanotaro biuroSi masa da l. s-s Soris gaformda sesxisa da ipoTekis xelSekruleba, rissafuZvelzec l. s-s sesxis saxiT gadasca _ 10 000 aSS do-lari. 2015 wlis 28 oqtombers mas daurekes da uTxres,rom l. s-e amatebda Tanxas da mas srulad ubrunebda mismier gacemul Tanxas. Semdeg gaformda sesxisa da ipoTe-kis axali xelSekruleba, xolo mas daubrunda sesxis sa-xiT gacemuli _ 10 000 aSS dolari.
6. mowme m. a-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom igi aris nota-riusi da muSaobs ... `... Teatris~ mimdebare teritoriazearsebul sanotaro biuroSi. 2015 wlis 24 seqtembers mas-Tan mividnen da-Zma q. da l. s-ebi. maT warudgines l. s-skuTvnili, 2007 wels gacemuli piradobis mowmoba. man mo-axdina l. s-s pirovnebis identificireba Suamavalsa daipoTekarebTan erTad, ris safuZvelzec imave dRes gaa-forma sesxisa da ipoTekis xelSekruleba, romlis Tanax-mad, l. s-m sesxis saxiT miiRo 10 000 aSS dolari, ... quCazemdebare binis uzrunvelyofiT. 2015 wlis 28 oqtombersmasTan kvlav mividnen _ l. da q. s-ebi, kvlav warudgines l.s-s saxelze gacemuli piradobis mowmoba da moiTxoves q.s-s saxelze mindobilobis gacema, vinaidan maTi ganmar-tebiT, l. s-e saswrafod midioda q. baTumSi. 15:00 saaTzeman gaaforma mindobiloba, xolo 17:00 saaTze masTan xel-meored mivida q. s-e, ipoTekarebTan _ z. q-Tan, m. g-sa da l.m-Tan erTad da moiTxova sesxisa da ipoTekis xelSekru-lebis gaformeba. imave dRes man Seadgina xelSekruleba,ra drosac mas q. s-s qcevaSi Seepara eWvi da meore dResgadawyvita mis ojaxTan dakavSireba. meore dRes is Tav-dapirvelad daukavSirda q. s-s mamas, romelmac uTxra, rom
95
mis Svils _ l. s-s dakarguli hqonda piradobis damadas-turebeli mowmoba, ris gamoc l. s-e ver SeZlebda sanota-ro biuroSi misvlas da xelSekrulebis gaformebas, xolomogvianebiT esaubra Tavad l. s-s, romelmac daadasturamamis naTqvami da aRniSna, rom wina dRes igi saxlidan argasula da arc sanotaro biuroSi yofila dasTan erTad.
7. mowme v. m-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom muSaobs uZraviqonebis saagentoSi. q. s-e gaicno maSin, roca binis sanaxa-vad iyo misuli masTan. misi monawileobiT notariusTanmomzadda da daibeWda sabuTebi, ris Semdeg mividnen q. dal. s-ebi da xelSekruleba gaformda 10 000 aSS dolarze.ori Tvis sargebeli gadaixades winaswar, xolo Tanxa ga-daeca q. s-s notariusis TandaswrebiT. l. s-c iq imyofebo-da da Tanxa q. s-s gadaeca misi TanxmobiT. man icoda, roml. s-e iyo binis mepatrone, xolo q. s-e ki _ misi da. xelSek-rulebis gaformebidan daaxloebiT erTi Tvis Semdeg da-ukavSirda gamsesxebeli z., romelmac uTxra, rom Tanxasubrunebdnen da rogorc misTvis cnobilia, mas aRniSnuliTanxa daubrunda, xolo q. s-m xelaxla datvirTa bina ipo-TekiT _ 20 500 aSS dolarad. ipoTekiT xelaxla datvir-Tva da z-s Tanxis dafarva moxda erTdroulad, Sesabami-sad, mas ziani ar misdgomia. mogvianebiT mas daurekes po-liciidan da dakiTxes mowmis saxiT, sadac naxa binis nam-dvili mepatrone da is aSkarad gansxvavdeboda im pirisa-gan, romelic manamde l. s-e egona.
8. mowme l. m-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom surda dagro-vili danazogis _ 5000 aSS dolaris gasesxeba, ris Sesaxe-bac icoda uZravi saagentos mflobelma i. v-m. 2015 wlisoqtomberSi i. v-e daukavSirda da acnoba, rom SeeZlo fu-lis gasesxebaSi daxmareba da daibara notariusTan. nota-riusTan misulma naxa i. v-e da kidev ori ipoTekari, rom-lebic uars acxadebdnen sesxisa da ipoTekis xelSekru-lebis gaformebaze mindobilobis safuZvelze, ra dro-sac notariusma i-s uTxra, rom mindobilobis safuZvelzexelSekrulebis gaformeba problemas ver Seqmnida, miTumetes pirveli xelSekrulebac misi gaformebuli iyo.Semdeg dasTanxmdnen da gaformda xelSekruleba. iqve iyoaxalgazrda gogo, rogorc SemdgomSi misTvis gaxda cno-bili, q. s-e, romelmac uTxra, rom mas unda gadaexada ses-xi da Tanxa ZmisTvis sWirdeboda. Tanxas gadauxdida masSemdeg, rac gayidda quTaisSi mdebare saxls. xelSekru-
96
lebaze xelis mowerisas man icoda, rom bina, romelic ipo-TekiT daitvirTa, ekuTvnoda q. s-s Zmas, xolo rogorc mis-Tvis SemdegSi gaxda cnobili, s-s Zmis nacvlad, mindobi-lobas xeli moawera r. R-m. man Suamavals gadasca 5000 aSSdolari.
9. mowme z. q-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2015 wlis oq-tomberSi daureka megobarma i. v-m, romelmac uTxra, romdaexmareboda sesxis gacemaSi, binis uzrunvelyofiT. aR-niSnulis Semdeg mivida notariusTan, sadac gaigo, rom min-dobilobiT formdeboda sesxisa da ipoTekis xelSekru-leba, Tavad iyo ipoTekari. sesxisa da ipoTekis xelSek-rulebis gaformebisas notariusma ganucxada, rom binismesakuTre iyo masTan misuli, Tumca, vinaidan hqonda ga-daudebeli saqme, gaaforma mindobiloba da wavida. Sem-deg gaformda xelSekruleba, romelsac moawera xeli.xelSekrulebis gaformebisas sul hqonda _ 12 000 aSS do-lari, maT Soris _ 6 000 aSS dolari iyo Tavisi, xolo _ 6 000aSS dolari misi dis. amasTan, xelSekruleba gaformda ki-dev _ 3500 da _ 5000 aSS dolarze, saerTo Tanxa gamovida _20 500 aSS dolari. Tanxa notariusis TandaswrebiT gadas-ca q. s-s. mowmem aseve ganmarta, rom rodesac mindobilo-bis gayalbebis faqti gairkva, mas daukavSirdnen r. R-sojaxis wevrebi da uTxres, rom gadaixdidnen im Tanxis na-wils, rac r. R-m waiRo.
10. mowme m. R-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom mas daukav-Sirda megobari m. T-i da SesTavaza Tanxis gasesxeba, binisuzrunvelyofiT. 2015 wlis oqtombris bolos mivida no-tariusTan, sadac gairkva, rom sesxisa da ipoTekis xel-Sekruleba unda gaformebuliyo mindobilobis safuZvel-ze, razec uaryofiTi reaqcia hqonda z. q-s. notariusmaganmarta, rom mindobiloba problemas ar warmoadgenda,vinaidan igi Tavad gaaforma da masac Cveulebrivi iuri-diuli Zala hqonda. mas Semdeg, rac gairkva, rom mindobi-loba iyo yalbi, situaciis garkvevis mizniT avidnen q. s-sTan saxlSi, sadac misma dedam auRelveblad uTxra, romproblema ar iyo, radgan q. s-e apirebda italiaSi wasvlasda gadaixdida vals. mogvianebiT saubarSi CaerTo l. s-c.maT l. s-s da mis dedas SesTavazes, rom gauformebdnenerTwlian uprocento xelSekrulebas, rom q. s-s nawil-nawil daebrunebina Tanxa, razedac l. s-m uari ganacxada.
11. analogiuri faqtobrivi garemoebebi daadastures
97
mowmeebma _ l. d-m, m. T-m da i. v-m (Suamavlebi).12. mxareTa mier udavod cnobili, 2015 wlis 28 oqtom-
bers notarius m. a-s mier gacemuli mindobilobiT dadge-nilia, rom q. s-s mieniWa uflebamosileba ganekarga, q. Tbi-lisSi, ... q. #...-Si mdebare l. s-s sakuTrebaSi arsebuli uZ-ravi qoneba.
13. mxareTa mier udavod cnobili, 2015 wlis 28 oqtom-bers gaformebuli sesxisa da ipoTekis xelSekrulebiTdadgenilia, rom q. s-s sesxis saxiT gadaeca _ 20 500 aSSdolari, xolo sesxis uzrunvelyofa moxda l. s-s sakuT-rebaSi arsebuli, TbilisSi, ...q. #...-Si mdebare uZravi qo-nebiT.
14. q. s-m wardgenil braldebaSi Tavi nawilobriv cnodamnaSaved, aRiara dokumentis gatacebis orive epizodida aCvena Semdegi: mas surda sesxis aReba, ris gamoc ga-dawyvita Zmis saxlis ipoTekiT datvirTva. daxmarebis miz-niT, daukavSirda megobar n. k-s, romelmac uTxra, rom hyav-da nacnobi, romelic mis Zmas Zalian hgavda da wahyvebodanotariusTan. aseTi saxiT sesxis aReba gadawyvita imitom,rom Zma ar dasTanxmdeboda saxlis ipoTekiT datvirTvas.Semdeg n-m gaacno r. R-e, romelsac auxsna saqmis viTarebada sTxova daxmareba, rasac r-c dasTanxmda. SeTanxmdnen,Tu visi roli unda Seesrulebina r. R-s. 2015 wlis seqtem-bris bolos notarius m. a-Tan gaaformes sesxisa da ipoTe-kis xelSekruleba _ 10 000 aSS dolarze. r. R-m icoda, ra-sac awerda xels da Tavisi surviliT moawera xeli xel-Sekrulebas. aRebuli Tanxidan gadaixada ori Tvis pro-centi, saSuamavlo, notariusis xarjebi, aseve n. k-s gada-uxada _ 500 aSS dolari, vinaidan maT am saqmeSi daxmarebissanacvlod mosTxoves _ 500 aSS dolaris gadaxda. darCe-nili Tanxa daitova TviTon da gamoiyena valebis dasafa-ravad. imis gamo, rom srulad ver moaxerxa valebis gas-tumreba, oqtomberSi kvlav sTxova daxmareba n. k-s, romgaeformebinaT axali xelSekruleba, ris Semdegac daukav-Sirda Suamaval l-s da sTxova axali ipoTekis gaformeba.l-m uTxra, rom SesaZlebeli iyo gaekeTebinaT Canacvle-ba. xelSekrulebis gasaformeblad mividnen sxva notari-usTan, romelmac uari Tqva mis gaformebaze, vinaidan pi-radobis mowmobiT r. R-e ver miamsgavsa l. s-s. aRniSnulzel-m uTxra, rom gaekeTebinaT mindobiloba, romlis safuZ-velzec Tavad moawerda xels xelSekrulebaze, an axali
98
piradobis mowmoba aeRoT. Semdeg wavidnen iusticiis sax-lSi piradobis mowmobis asaRebad, sadac ganacxades, rompiradobis mowmoba iyo dakarguli da surdaT axlis aReba.saRamos daukavSirdnen iusticiis saxlidan da uTxres,rom moxda gaoreba, wardgenili foto ar iyo l. s-s, iyosxva piris, ris gamoc misuliyvnen da Tavad ganecxadebi-naT amis Sesaxeb, winaaRmdeg SemTxvevaSi miiRebdnen uf-ro mkacr zomebs. Semdeg Zveli piradobis mowmobiT daiusticiis saxlis mier gacemuli samaxsovro baraTiT wa-vidnen notarius m. a-Tan, romelsac uTxres, rom pirado-bis mowmobaze ganacxadi, marTalia, gakeTebuli hqondaT,magram Zalian eCqarebodaT da sTxoves mindobilobis ga-formeba. notariusi dasTanxmda, vinaidan pirveli ipoTe-kis xelSekrulebac misi gaformebuli iyo. mindobilobisgaformebidan daaxloebiT erT-or saaTSi gaformda meo-re xelSekruleba, romelsac eswrebodnen Suamavlebic.xelSekrulebas xeli TviTon moawera da sesxis Tanxa mii-Ro, ramac Seadgina _ 20 500 aSS dolari. am Tanxidan gadai-xada pirveli ipoTekis Tanxa _ 10 000 aSS dolari, notari-usis momsaxurebis Rirebuleba da saSuamavloebi, xolodarCenili, daaxloebiT Svidi aTasi dolaridan, winaswa-ri SeTanxmebis safuZvelze _ 2000 aSS dolari misca r. R-sa da n. k-s. q. s-m aseve ganmarta, rom notariusTan gamoi-yenes Zmis _ l. s-s piradobis mowmoba, romelic Zmisganmalulad aiRo misi oTaxidan. mas sesxis saxiT miRebuliTanxis marTlsawinaaRmdegod misakuTrebis mizani ar hqo-nia, vinaidan surda samuSaod italiaSi wasvla da sesxis amgziT dafarva.
15. sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom TaRliTobis, ro-gorc sakuTrebis winaaRmdeg mimarTuli danaSaulis, obi-eqturi Semadgenlobis savaldebulo niSans warmoadgensmarTlsawinaaRmdego misakuTebis mizniT sxvisi qonebisdaufleba an qonebrivi uflebis miReba motyuebiT. mar-TlwinaaRmdegoba gulisxmobs, rom piri ar aris mesakuT-re an misi kanonieri mflobeli da mis mier qonebis dauf-leba, an qonebrivi uflebis miReba xdeba ukanonod. aR-niSnuli danaSauli warmoadgens Sedegian deliqts da dam-Tavrebulia sxvisi nivTis dauflebis an qonebrivi ufle-bis miRebis momentidan. TaRliTobis subieqturi Semad-genloba ki pirdapir ganzraxvaSi gamoixateba, ra drosacdamnaSaves gacnobierebuli aqvs, rom igi TaRliTobiT mar-
99
TlsawinaaRmdegod eufleba sxvis qonebas, riTac ziansayenebs mis mesakuTres da surs am Sedegis dadgoma. amas-Tan, qmedebis ganxorcielebisas damnaSaves unda amoZra-vebdes angarebis motivi da mizani.
16. saapelacio sasamarTlom msjavrdebulebi _ q. s-eda r. R-e udanaSaulod cno saqarTvelos ssk-is 180-e mux-lis me-2 nawilis `a~ da me-3 nawilis `b~ qvepunqtebiT war-dgenil braldebaSi (2015 wlis 24 seqtembris _ z. s-s epi-zodi) im motiviT, rom q. s-sa da r. R-s qmedebaSi ar arse-bobda marTlsawinaaRmdego misakuTrebis mizani, vinaidansesxisa da ipoTekis xelSekrulebis gaformebidan erTiTvis Semdeg q. s-m sesxis Tanxa srulad daubruna ipoTe-kar z. s-s da mas raime ziani ar misdgomia. garda amisa, sasa-marTlom r. R-s qmedeba saqarTvelos ssk-is 362-e muxlisme-2 nawilis `b~ qvepunqtidan (2015 wlis 24 seqtembris _z. s-s epizodi) gadaakvalificira imave muxlis pirvel na-wilze, radgan miTiTebul epizodSi ar dadasturda msjav-rdebulebis mimarT wardgenili TaRliTobis braldeba daSesabamisad _ miyenebuli mniSvnelovani ziani. misi qmede-ba dakvalificirda _ yalbi oficialuri dokumentis dam-zadebad, gamoyenebis mizniT (rasac mniSvnelovani zianiar gamouwvevia).
17. sakasacio palata ver daeTanxmeba saapelacio sasa-marTlos aRniSnul dasabuTebas da miuTiTebs Semdegs:saqmeSi udavod cnobili da sasamarTlo sxdomaze gamok-vleuli mtkicebulebebiT dadgenilia, rom q. s-s sWirde-boda Tanxa valebis dasafarad. sacxovrebeli bina warmo-adgenda misi Zmis _ l. s-s sakuTrebas. q. s-m icoda, rom l.ar dasTanxmdeboda saxlis ipoTekiT datvirTvas, ris ga-moc man gadawyvita sesxis misgan malulad, motyuebiT aRe-ba, misive binis uzrunvelyofiT. q. s-s mizans warmoadgen-da Zmis sakuTrebaSi arsebuli uZravi qonebis gamoyene-biT qonebrivi sargeblis miReba motyuebiT, ris Sesaxe-bac ara mxolod icoda r. R-m, aramed Tavidanve aqtiuradmonawileobda mis ganxorcielebaSi. is faqti, rom q. s-msrulad daubruna Tanxa ipoTekar z. s-s, msjavrdebule-bis qmedebaSi ar gamoricxavs marTlsawinaaRmdego misa-kuTrebis mizans. 2015 wlis 24 seqtembris epizodSi gamok-veTilia danaSaulis Semadgenlobis yvela niSani da igidamTavrebulia 2015 wlis 24 seqtembridan, anu im momen-tidan, rodesac q. s-m da r. R-m Seacdines notariusi da
100
viTomda l. s-s saxeliT, motyuebiT gaaformes 2015 wlis24 seqtembris sesxisa da ipoTekis xelSekruleba, ris Se-degadac l. s-s ipoTekaris sasargeblod warmoeSva _ 10 000aSS dolaris valdebuleba. Sesabamisad, danaSaulis Semad-genlobisaTvis mniSvneloba ara aqvs, Tu rodis, an saer-Tod daubruna Tu ara q. s-m nasesxebi Tanxa ipoTekar z. s-s. aRsaniSnavia is garemoebac, rom q. s-sa da r. R-s qmedebe-biT danaSaulis orive epizodSi ziani miadga swored l. s-s, radgan pirvel epizodSi mas warmoeSva _ 10 000 aSS do-laris, xolo meoreSi _ 20 500 aSS dolaris valdebulebaipoTekarebis sasargeblod, ris safuZvelzec gansaxil-vel sisxlis samarTlis saqmeze dazaralebulad cnobilial. s-e da ara _ ipoTekarebi.
18. msjavrdebulebis marTlsawinaaRmdego misakuTre-bis mizanze aseve metyvelebs Tavad q. s-s Cvenebac, rommas valebis dasafarad ar eyo pirveli sesxiT miRebuliTanxa da garkveuli drois gasvlis Semdeg igi iZulebuligaxda xelmeored aeRo sesxi, risTvisac aucilebeli iyopirveli sesxis srulad gadafarva da ipoTekar z. s-TvisTanxis dabruneba, romlis gareSec meore xelSekrulebaver gaformdeboda. am miznis gansaxorcieleblad igikvlav daukavSirda r. R-s da maT isev erToblivad Caidi-nes meore danaSauli.
19. zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, sakasacio palataiziarebs prokuroris argumentebs da miaCnia, rom q. s-mda r. R-m 2015 wlis 24 seqtembris epizodSi Caidines TaR-liToba, e.i. marTlsawinaaRmdego misakuTrebis mizniTsxvisi nivTis daufleba da qonebrivi uflebis motyue-biT miReba, Cadenili winaswari SeTanxmebiT jgufis mier,didi odenobiT, danaSauli, gaTvaliswinebuli saqarTve-los ssk-is 180-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `a~ da me-3 nawilis `b~qvepunqtebiT. miTiTebul epizodSi palatas aseve dadge-nilad miaCnia, rom r. R-m Caidina yalbi oficialuri doku-mentis damzadeba, gamoyenebis mizniT, ramac mniSvnelo-vani ziani gamoiwvia, danaSauli, gaTvaliswinebuli saqar-Tvelos ssk-is 362-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `b~ qvepunqtiT,vinaidan dadasturebulia, rom msjavrdebulebis qmede-bebis Sedegad l. s-s ipoTekar z. s-s sasargeblod warmo-eSva _ 10 000 aSS dolaris valdebuleba, riTac mas miadgamiTiTebuli Tanxis mniSvnelovani ziani.
20. sakasacio palata ar iziarebs dacvis mxaris mosaz-
101
rebas, rom r. R-m Caidina ara TaRliToba, aramed, kredi-tis ukanono miRebaSi daxmareba, danaSauli, gaTvaliswi-nebuli saqarTvelos ssk-is 24-e-208-e muxlis pirveli na-wiliT. palata am nawilSi eTanxmeba saapelacio palatismsjelobas, rom saqarTvelos ssk-is 208-e muxlis pirvelinawiliT gaTvaliswinebuli danaSaulis obieqturi mxaregamoixateba sameurneo an finansuri mdgomareobis Sesa-xeb bankis an sxva kreditorisaTvis yalbi cnobis miwode-baSi, kreditis miRebis mizniT. aseT SemTxvevaSi kredi-torisaTvis miwodebuli informacia Segnebulad aris da-maxinjebuli da ar asaxavs msesxeblis qonebrivi mdgoma-reobis Sesaxeb (Semosavlebi, valdebulebebi da sxva) obi-eqtur suraTs. mocemul SemTxvevaSi r. R-s finansurimdgomareobis Sesaxeb yalbi informacia ki ar miuwodebia,aramed _ notariusis SecdomaSi SeyvaniT oficialuri do-kumenti gaayalba, sxvis qonebas daeufla da qonebrivi uf-leba miiRo motyuebiT. garda amisa, krediti aris fuladisaSualeba, romelsac gascems banki an sxva sakredito or-ganizacia, rac mocemul SemTxvevaSi ar momxdara.
21. adamianis uflebaTa evropulma sasamarTlom ganmar-ta, rom ganaCeni unda emyarebodes saqmeSi arsebul mtki-cebulebaTa Tavisufal Sefasebasa da daskvnebs, romle-bic gamomdinareobs faqtobrivi garemoebebidan da mxa-reebis mier wardgenili mosazrebebidan. mtkiceba SeiZ-leba gamomdinareobdes sakmarisad naTeli da dasabuTe-buli daskvnebis an faqtis Taobaze gauqarwylebeli vara-udebis erTobliobidan1. saqarTvelos sssk-is me-3 muxlisme-13 nawilis Tanaxmad, gonivrul eWvs miRma standartiaris sasamarTlos mier gamamtyunebeli ganaCenis gamota-nisaTvis saWiro mtkicebulebaTa erToblioba, romelicobieqtur pirs daarwmunebda piris braleulobaSi. saqar-Tvelos sssk-is 82-e muxlis 1-li nawilis Sesabamisad, mtki-cebuleba unda Sefasdes sisxlis samarTlis saqmesTan mi-si relevanturobis, dasaSvebobisa da utyuarobis Tval-sazrisiT, xolo amave muxlis me-3 nawilis mixedviT, ga-
1 ix: adamianis uflebaTa evropuli sasamarTlos gadaw-yvetilebebi saqmeebze: „el masri makedoniis winaaR-mdeg~ (El-Masri v the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia,ECtHR, (GC), 13/12/2012) da „hasani gaerTianebuli samefoswinaaRmdeg~ (Hassan v the UK, ECtHR, (GC), 16/09/2014).
pirobiT msjavrdebulebis _ d. s-a da g. s-s yofaqceva-ze kontroli da daxmareba daevala saqarTvelos sasje-laRsrulebisa da probaciis saministros probaciis erov-nuli saagentos teritoriul organos, msjavrdebulebis
ma sakasacio saCivris safuZvlianoba da daaskvna, rommsjavrdebulebis _ g. s-a da d. s-s interesebis damcve-lis, advokat l. k-s sakasacio saCivari ar unda dakmayo-fildes, xolo gasaCivrebuli ganaCeni unda darCes ucvle-lad, Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. sakasacio palata srulad iziarebs saapelacio sasa-marTlos argumentebs msjavrdebulebis _ g. s-a da d. s-sbraleulobis Taobaze da miaCnia, rom kanonis moTxovna-Ta dacviT, srulyofilad da obieqturad gamokvleul,utyuar, urTierTSejerebul da sakmaris mtkicebuleba-Ta erTobliobiT gonivrul eWvs miRma standartiT das-turdeba maT mier Cadenili danaSauli, kerZod:
3. saqmeSi arsebuli mtkicebulebebiT, romlebic mxa-reebs sadavod ar gauxdiaT da preiudiciulad iqna miCne-uli, kerZod: mowmeebis _ s. m-s-b-s, d. k-s, u. o-s Cvenebe-biT, daTvalierebis, Sps `j-s~ ofisisa da sawyobis CxrekisoqmebiT, nivTieri mtkicebulebebis, saqpatentidan miRe-
109
buli momarTvis, operatiul-samZebro RonisZiebebis am-saxveli masalebiTa da sxva mtkicebulebebiT dadastu-rebulia, rom g. s-a da d. s-a Caidines danaSauli, gaTvalis-winebuli saqarTvelos ssk-is 196-e muxlis me-3 nawilis`g~ qvepunqtiT.
4. saqpatentis sasaqonlo niSnebisa da geografiuli aR-niSvnis ganyofilebis specialistis, u. o-s mowmis saxiTmicemuli CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom `inteleqtualur sa-kuTrebasTan dakavSirebul sasazRvro RonisZiebaTa Se-saxeb~ saqarTvelos kanonis Tanaxmad, nebismieri saqone-li, maT Soris SesafuTi saqoneli, romelzec unebarTvo-daa moTavsebuli im sasaqonlo niSnis identuri sasaqon-lo niSani, romelic kanonierad aris registrirebuli amsaqonelTan dakavSirebiT an arsebiTad ar gansxvavdebaaRniSnuli sasaqonlo niSnisagan da, aqedan gamomdinare,arRvevs saqarTvelos kanonmdeblobiT dadgenil sasaqon-lo niSnis mflobelis uflebebs, warmoadgens kontrafaq-ciul produqcias. miuxedavad imisa, rom `F-Y-is~ SemTxve-vaSi, TiTqosda, Secvlilia saxelwodeba `F-Y-iT~, arsebu-li sxvaobis gamovlena vizualurad faqtobrivad SeuZle-belia dadgindes detaluri dakvirvebis gareSe. aseve xse-nebul niSnebs Soris arsebobs fonetikuri msgavseba, racCveulebrivi momxmareblisTvis praqtikulad SeuZlebelsxdis maT gansxvavebas. `sasaqonlo niSnebis Sesaxeb~ saqar-Tvelos kanonis me-5 muxlis `g~ qvepunqtis Tanaxmad, me-same piris saxelze registrirebuli, ufro adrindeli pri-oritetis mqone sasaqonlo niSnis msgavsia, xolo saqone-li _ identuri an imdenad msgavsi, rom Cndeba am sasaqon-lo niSnebis aRrevis, maT Soris asocirebis Sedegad aRre-vis SesaZlebloba. imavdroulad, amave kanonis me-6 mux-lis me-2 punqtis Tanaxmad, gansakuTrebuli uflebis mqo-ne pirs SeuZlia, aukrZalos mesame pirs, misi TanxmobisgareSe samoqalaqo brunvaSi gamoiyenos iseTi niSani, ro-melic ganskuTrebuli uflebis mqone piris, am SemTxveva-Si ki `z-r & g-s~ mier daculi (registrirebuli) sasaqonloniSnis identuri an msgavsia imdenad, rom Cndeba am niSne-bis aRrevis, maT Soris _ vizualuri asocirebis SedegadaRrevis SesaZlebloba. amave kanonis me-6 muxlis me-3 pun-qtiT, amave muxlis me-2 punqtiT gaTvaliswinebul Sem-TxvevebSi, sxva SesaZlo akrZalvaTa garda, ikrZaleba: a)sasaqonlo niSnis datana saqonelze an mis SefuTvaze, b)
110
iseTi saqonlis SeTavazeba, samoqalaqo brunvaSi Setanaan sawyobSi am mizniT Senaxva, importi an eqsporti, rome-lic niSandebulia am niSniT, garda im SemTxvevisa, rode-sac es qmedeba xorcieldeba sasaqonlo niSanze gansakuT-rebuli uflebis mqone piris mier niSandebuli saqonliT.zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, aravis aqvs ufleba, `z-r& g-s~ Tanxmobis gareSe, samoqalaqo brunvaSi gamoiyenos`F-Y-is~ dasaxelebis an misi msgavsi sasaqonlo niSnebi.
8. zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, sakasacio palatasmiaCnia, rom mocemul saqmeze Tbilisis saapelacio sasa-marTlos mier msjavrdebulebis _ g. s-a da d. s-s mimarTgamotanili ganaCeni aris kanonieri da ar arsebobs misigauqmebis safuZveli.
ma sakasacio saCivris safuZvlianoba da daaskvna, rom fo-Tis raionuli prokuroris moadgile feliqs jalaRoniassakasacio saCivari unda dakmayofildes da gasaCivrebulganaCenSi unda Sevides cvlileba, Semdeg garemoebaTa ga-mo:
2. sakasacio palata pirvel rigSi aRniSnavs, rom quTai-sis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saqmeTapalatis 2016 wlis 20 dekembris ganaCens braldebis mxareasaCivrebs kvalifikaciis nawilSi da, amdenad, sakasaciopalata msjelobs mxolod mocemul sakiTxze.
3. saqmeze Sekrebil mtkicebulebaTa erTobliobiT,kerZod: dazaralebul j. a-s, mowmeebis _ a. J-s, d. o-s, l. q-s, n. g-s, g. l-s, g. l-s, x. S-s, a. l-s, o. s-s, e. Z-s, l. n-s, z. e-s,eqspertebis _ l. m-s, m. k-s, p. j-s, l. S-s, n. n-s CvenebebiT,SemTxvevis adgilisa da adgilmdebareobis daTvaliere-bis, sacxovrebeli binisa da piradi Cxrekis oqmebiT, nimu-Sis aRebis oqmebiT, balistikuri, trasologiuri, biolo-giuri (genetikuri), fonoskopiuri da video-teqnikuri,habitoskopiuri da kompiuterul-teqnikuri eqspertize-bis daskvnebiTa da saqmis sxva masalebiT gonivrul eWvsmiRma standartiT dadasturebulia, rom g. f-a gamoZie-biT daudgenel pirTan erTad maRazia `...~ marTlsawinaaR-mdegod daeufla 5750 laris Rirebulebis, srolisaTvisvargis cecxlsasrol iaraRebs.
4. gansaxilvel SemTxvevaSi sakasacio palatam unda Se-afasos, g. f-m aRniSnuli qmedeba Caidina jgufis mier wi-naswari SeTanxmebiT, Tu winaswari SeTanxmebis gareSe,romlis dasadgenadac mTavar mtkicebulebas warmoadgensmaRazia `.~ gare da Sida perimetrebis videoCanawerebi.
7. saapelacio palatam Seafasa videofirebSi asaxuligaremoebebi da miuTiTa, rom maTi gamokvlevis Sedegaddadginda mxolod is faqti, rom g. f-a da gamoZiebiT da-udgeneli piri erToblivad axorcielebdnen qmedebis obi-eqtur Semadgenlobas, rasac arc saapelacio palata miiC-nevs sadavod, Tumca, xsenebuli mtkicebulebebiT ar das-turdeba maT Soris winaswari SekavSirebis arseboba; ker-Zod, gamokvleul videofirze ar Cans maT Soris raime ise-Ti tipis komunikacia, rac saapelacio palatas saSuale-bas miscemda, gonivrul eWvs miRma standartiT erwmunamaT Soris winaswari SeTanxmebis arseboba; arc sxva mtki-cebulebebiT dasturdeba raime msgavsi faqtis Sesaxeb in-formacia. amdenad, saapelacio sasamarTlom miiCnia, rommocemul SemTxvevaSi qmedeba Cadenilia jgufis mier wi-naswari SeTanxmebis gareSe.
8. sakasacio palata ar iziarebs saapelacio sasamar-Tlos aRniSnul daskvnas Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo: vide-ofirebis daTvalierebis oqmiTa da misi gamokvlevis Se-degad dadgenilia, rom masSi asaxul orive pirs ukeTianiRabi da orive maTgani sworedac rom qmedebis obieqtu-ri Semadgenlobis dawyebamde moqmedebs erToblivad, wi-naswari SeTanxmebiT, rac naTlad dasturdeba videoCana-werebiT (gansxvavebiT saapelacio sasamarTlos mier moS-veliebuli saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos 618-ap-15gadawyvetilebaSi aRwerili faqtobrivi garemoebebisgan);maRaziis gare perimetris pirveli Canaweri iwyeba _ 03:26:34saaTidan da bolo, 23-e Canaweri sruldeba _ 03.50.30 saaT-ze. Canawerebidan irkveva, rom orive mamakaci erTdrou-lad midis maRazia _ `...~, Tavdapirvelad susti aRnagobismamakaci midis karTan da cdilobs mis gatexvas, ra dro-sac Cafskvnili mamakaci Cerdeba maRaziis kuTxesTan, mis-gan daaxloebiT 2 metrSi da pirdapir uyurebs mas da ase-ve aTvalierebs perimetrs. susti aRnagobis mamakaci pa-
120
tara zomis nivTis gamoyenebiT damoukideblad cdilobsmaRaziis karis gatexvas. kadrSi aseve naTlad Cans maT So-ris sityvieri komunikacia da Jestikulacia, rodesac sus-ti aRnagobis mamakaci Cafskvnils xeliT uTiTebs karismimarTulebiT da uxsnis raRacas. karis gatexvis proces-Si orive maTgani araerTxel, erToblivad imaleba maRazi-is kuTxeSi da Semdeg frTxilad, fexakrefiT isev ukanbrundebian karTan. mogvianebiT susti aRnagobis mamaka-cis dasaxmareblad modis Cafksvnilic da isini ukve er-Toblivad cdiloben karis gatexvas, Cafskvnili mamakaci_ Zalayinis, xolo susti _ patara zomis nivTis gamoyene-biT. Semdeg Cafskvnili mamakaci Zalayinis gamoyenebiTaRebs kars, ra drosac susti mamakaci qurTukis jibeSiidebs patara nivTs da Serbis maRaziaSi, xolo Cafskvniliki sirbiliT imaleba maRaziis kuTxeSi. susti mamakaci ma-Raziidan gamorbis Sesvlidan 16 wamSi da aseve sirbiliTimaleba imave mimarTulebiT, maRaziis kuTxeSi. amdenad,sakasacio palatisaTvis gaugebaria, im viTarebaSi, rode-sac ori niRbiani piri erTsa da imave dros, erTdrouladmidis maRaziasTan, jer erTi cdilobs karis gatexvas, me-ore ki am dros uyurebs mas, Semdeg ramdenjerme erTadimalebian maRaziis kuTxeSi da isev ukan brundebian, Sem-deg ukve erToblivad cdiloben karis gatexvas da texenkidec mas, rogor SeiZleba, rom maT Soris winaswari Se-Tanxmeba ar arsebobdes.
9. adamianis uflebaTa evropulma sasamarTlom araerTgadawyvetilebaSi ganmarta, rom ganaCeni unda emyarebo-des saqmeSi arsebul mtkicebulebaTa Tavisufal Sefase-basa da daskvnebs, romlebic gamomdinareobs faqtobrivigaremoebebidan da mxareebis mier wardgenili mosazrebe-bidan. mtkiceba SeiZleba gamomdinareobdes sakmarisad na-Teli da dasabuTebuli daskvnebis an faqtis Taobaze gau-qarwylebeli varaudebis erTobliobidan1. saqarTvelossssk-is me-3 muxlis me-13 nawilis Tanaxmad, gonivrul eWvsmiRma standarti aris sasamarTlos mier gamamtyunebeli
1 ix: adamianis uflebaTa evropuli sasamarTlos gadaw-yvetilebebi saqmeebze: „el masri makedoniis winaaR-mdeg~ (El-Masri v the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia,ECtHR, (GC), 13/12/2012) da „hasani gaerTianebuli samefoswinaaRmdeg~ (Hassan v the UK, ECtHR, (GC), 16/09/2014).
nixila sakasacio saCivari, Seiswavla saqmis masalebi, Sea-mowma saCivris safuZvlianoba da miaCnia, rom sakasacio
125
saCivris moTxovna unda dakmayofildes da m. v-is mimarTdadgenili gamamarTlebeli ganaCeni unda gauqmdes Sem-deg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. sasamarTlo sxdomaze mowmed dakiTxuli mowmeebis_ g. S-is da m. g-as CvenebebiTa da piradi gasinjvisa da niv-Tebis gasinjvis 2015 wlis 14 dekembris #... oqmis Tanax-mad, m. v-is piradi gasinjvisas Sarvlis wina, marcxena ji-bidan amoRebul iqna samzareulos dana, romelic krimi-nalistikuri eqspertizis 2015 wlis 18 dekembris ... das-kvnisa da eqspert d. k-is Cvenebis Tanaxmad, damzadebu-lia qarxnuli wesiT, aris mCxvletav-mWreli da miekuT-vneba civ iaraRTa kategorias. eqspertma d. k-em mowmeddakiTxvis dros damatebiT ganmarta, rom kvlevis drosdanebi ar daiyofa sanadirod gankuTvnili, samrewveloTu sayofacxovrebo daniSnulebis mqoned, aramed kvle-visas sagnis mWreli da mCxvletavi TvisebebebiT gamoic-deba. mowmis ganmartebiT, eqspertizaze warmodgenili da-niT zianis miyeneba SesaZlebelia.
3. mowme T. C-is CvenebiT dgindeba, rom igi cxovrobs T-Si, g-as quCa #...-Si. m. v. misi megobaria da masTan axloscxovrobs, Tumca maTi saxlebi garkveuli intervaliT er-TmaneTisagan daSorebulia. 2015 wlis 14 dekembers m. v.imyofeboda masTan, ra drosac sayofacxovrebo daniSnu-lebisaTvis iTxova da waiRo samzareulos dana. mogviane-biT man Seityo, rom m. v. sapatrulo policiis TanamSrom-lebma gaaCeres.
4. m. v-is CvenebiT dgindeba, rom 2015 wlis 14 dekem-bers, rodesac sapatrulo policiis TanamSromlebma Sea-Ceres, misi megobris, T. C-is saxlidan modioda. mizezad,Tu ratom mohqonda samzareulos dana megobrisgan, ganac-xada, rom erTaderTi dana, romelic manamde hqonda, gai-Runa da gamosayeneblad gaxda uvargisi. mezoblisagan mi-si Txoveba ar ufiqria. vinaidan dasaxlebuli adgili un-da gaevlo, dana jibeSi Caido da arc ucdia misi polieTi-lenis parkSi an Tundac qaRaldSi gaxveva, radgan kanonismoTxovnebi misTvis cnobili ar iyo. garda amisa, dana sa-yofacxovrebo daniSnulebis iyo da ar hqonda e.w `fiqsa-tori~, an Tundac danaSaulis Casadenad gankuTvnili da-nisaTvis damaxasiaTebeli niSnebi, ris gamoc mas ar ufiq-ria, rom danaSauls sCadioda. amdenad, patrulis ekipaJi-saTvis mas ar gauwevia winaaRmdegoba da metic, maT neba-
126
yoflobiT warudgina samzareulos dana. m. v-es danaSau-lis Cadenis ganzraxva ar amoZravebda.
3. mowme r. d-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom igi muSaobs Sss..... saqalaqo sammarTveloSi inspeqtor-gamomZieblis Tanam-debobaze. 2015 wlis 26 oqtombers sammarTveloSi Sevidaoperatiuli informacia, rom moqalaqe g. v-s, romelic iyonarkotiuli saSualebis momxmarebeli, SeZenili hqonda daTan unda hqonoda narkotikuli saSualeba. igi unda yofi-liyo baTumSi, ... q. #...-is mimdebare teritoriaze. am infor-maciis safuZvelze imave sammarTvelos TanamSromel l. j-Tan erTad gavida SeTxvevis adgilze, sadac SeniSnes g. v-e.isini mividnen masTan, SeaCeres, warudgines Tavi da amavedros r. d-e mobiluri telefoniT esaubra gamomZiebel a.r-s, romelic maleve mivida maTTan. gamomZieblis miTiTe-biT, g. v-s Cautarda piradi Cxreka. r. d-m igi piradad gaC-xrika da misi Sarvlis marjvena jibidan amoiRo vercxlis-fer qaRaldSi gaxveuli abis natexebi. amoRebul nivTebsgamomZiebelma a. r-m gadauRo suraTebi da daluqa. g. v-s
134
winaaRmdegoba ar gauwevia. man sagamoZiebo moqmedebebisamsaxvel dokumentebze xeli ar moawera. Cxrekis Semdeg g.v-e gadaiyvanes policiis ganyofilebaSi.
4. mowme l. j-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom igi muSaobsSss ..... saqalaqo sammarTveloSi inspeqtor-gamomZieblisTanamdebobaze. 2015 wlis 26 oqtombers iyo morige, radrosac sammarTveloSi Sevida operatiuli informacia,rom moqalaqe g. v-s, romelic unda yofiliyo misi sacxov-rebeli saxlis mimdebare teritoriaze, SeZenili hqondanarkotikuli saSualeba da apirebda mis gadacemas daud-geneli pirisaTvis. aRniSnulis safuZvelze jgufis uf-ros r. d-Tan erTad gavida SeTxvevis adgilze, sadac ram-denime wuTSi gamoCnda g. v-e. isini mividnen masTan, SeaCe-res, warudgines Tavi da amave dros r. d-m daureka gamom-Ziebels, romelic maleve mivida. gamomZiebelma ganumar-ta uflebebi da dadgenilebis safuZvelze mas Cautardapiradi Cxreka, ra drosac r. d-m g. v-s Sarvlis marjvena,wina jibidan amoiRo vercxlisfer qaRaldSi gaxveuli abis-magvari natexebi, ris Semdegac igi gadaiyvanes policiisganyofilebaSi. Cxrekis dros g. v-s winaaRmdegoba ar gau-wevia, Tumca arc Tanxmoba ganucxadebia sagamoZiebo moq-medebis Catarebaze. mas aRniSnuli nivTiereba sakuTarixeliT ar amouRia jibidan, igi r. d-m amoiRo.
5. mowme a. r-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom igi iZiebda mo-cemul saqmes. 2015 wlis 26 oqtombers imyofeboda samsa-xurSi, ra drosac Sevida informacia, rom g. v-s Tan hqondanarkotikuli nivTiereba da apirebda mis gadacemas sxvapirisTvis. aRniSnulze daiwyo gamoZieba, daigegma Sesaba-misi RonisZiebebi, mowmis saxiT dakiTxa `patakis~ inicia-tori, SemTxvevis adgilze gauSva operatiuli TanamSrom-lebi da Semdgeg isic gavida. telefoniT daukavSirda jgu-fis wevrebs, romlebmac Seatyobines, rom dainaxes g. v-e.man uTxra, rom SeeCerebinaT da isic mividoda. igi mividaramdenime wuTSi, g. v-s gaacno dadgenileba gadaudebeliaucileblobis SemTxvevaSi piradi Cxrekis Catarebis Se-saxeb, razec man ganacxada, rom xels araferze moawerda.Semdeg Catarda misi piradi Cxreka, romelSic monawile-obdnen policiis TanamSromlebi _ l. j-i da r. d-e. piradiCxreka Caatara uSualod r. d-m, ra drosac man g. v-s Sar-vlis wina, marjvena jibidan amoiRo vercxlisfer qaRal-dSi gaxveuli, 4 TeTri gatexili abi. amis Sesaxeb bralde-
135
buls araferi ganumartavs. man gadauRo suraTebi da Se-adgina oqmi. Semdeg braldebuli daakava. adgilzeve Sed-ga dakavebis oqmi. arc erT sagamoZiebo oqmze braldebulmaxeli ar moawera. igi gadaiyvanes sammarTveloSi. misi dad-genilebis safuZvelze g. v-s Tavdapirvelad Cautardanarkologiuri Semowmeba, xolo mogvianebiT daniSna qimi-ur-toqsikologiuri eqspertiza. manve Caatara sxvadas-xva sagamoZiebo moqmedeba.
6. g. v-s piradi Cxrekis oqmiT dadgenilia, rom gamomZi-ebelma a. r-m, r. d-sa da l. j-s monawileobiT Catarebulipiradi Cxrekisas, g. v-gan amoiRo vercxlisfer qaRaldSigaxveuli, 4 calad dafasoebuli TeTri abis natexis mag-vari masa.
7. saqmeze Catarebuli qimiuri eqspertizis daskvniTdadgenilia, rom g. v-s piradi Cxrekisas amoRebuli 4 abisnatexi Seicavs _ 0. 01991 gram narkotikul saSualeba `bup-renorfins~. aRniSnuli eqspertizis daskvnis siswore da-adastura eqspertma m. m-m.
8. saqmeze Catarebuli qimiur_toqsikologiuri eqsper-tizis daskvniT g. v-s daudinda narkotikuli saSualeba`tetrahidrokanabinolis~ moxmarebis faqti. aRniSnulieqspertizis daskvnis siswore daadastures eqspertebma_ n. f-m da T. b-m.
14. aRniSnulTan dakavSirebiT, sakasacio palata miu-TiTebs, rom igi sadavod ar miiCnevs biologiuri da daq-tiloskopiuri eqspertizebis daskvnebiT dadgenil faq-tebs, rom gamosakvlev obieqtze g. v-s genetikuri Tana-monawileoba ar gamovlinda da aseve, masze xelis TiTiskvlebi saerTod ar aRmoCnda, Tumca aRniSnavs, rom saape-lacio sasamarTlom ar imsjela da yovelgvari SefasebisgareSe datova eqspertebis Cvenebebis is umniSvnelova-nesi nawili, Tu ra SemTxvevaSi SeiZleba darCes, an ar dar-Ces gamosakvlev obieqtze kvali, kerZod:
eqspertma q. q-m daadastura biologiuri (genetiku-ri) eqspertizis daskvnis siswore da miuTiTa, rom gamo-sakvlev obieqtze (obieqti #1) aRmoCnda erTze meti pi-ris Sereuli profili, Tumca g. v-s genetikuri profilimasSi ar aRmoCnda. eqspertma ganmarta, rom SesaZlebelia,obieqtze ar aRmoCndes biologiuri masala, miuxedavadmasze xeliT Sexebisa, im SemTxvevaSi, roca sxva biologi-uri masala bevrad aRemateba mas. am dros sxva biologiu-ri masala SesaZloa, iyos imdenad meti, rom gadafaros igida ar gamovlindes genetikur profilSi. manve miuTiTa,rom obieqtze biologiuri profilis SenarCunebis vadadamokidebulia sxvadasxva garemoebaze, Senaxvis pirobeb-ze, vargisi iqneba Tu ara genetikuri kvlevisaTvis, risSedegadac biologiuri masala SesaZlebelia, darCes wle-bi, an _ erTi dRe. masze sxva eqspertizis Catarebis Sem-deg SesaZlebelia, darCes, an ar darCes kvali.
eqspertma i. m-m aseve daadastura biologiuri (gene-tikuri) eqspertis daskvnis siswore da miuTiTa, rom ga-mosakvlev obieqtze (obieqti #1) aRmoCnda erTze metipiris Sereuli profili, magram g. v-s genetikuri profi-li ar aRmoCnda. eqspertma ganmarta, rom dnm-is nimuSi Se-saZlebelia, nivTze moxvdes, an ar moxvdes, miuxedavadnivTTan kontaqtisa, rac damokidebulia kontaqtis xasi-aTze. nimuSi SeiZleba moxvdes uSualo, an raime biologi-
139
uri siTxis kontaqtis Sedegad. Tu adamians xelTaTmaniekeTa, am SemTxvevaSi ar darCeba kvali, xolo winaaRmdegSemTxvevaSi dnm-is kvalis darCenis SesaZlebloba _ 50/50-zea. prokuroris kiTxvaze, nivTze xelis mokidebis Sem-TxvevaSi SesaZlebelia Tu ara, rom ar aRmoCndes dnm-isminimaluri koncentracia, man ganmarta, rom aRniSnulidamokidebulia individualur situaciaze da mocemul sa-kiTxze kategoriul daskvnas ver gaakeTebs, es iqneba mxo-lod varaudi.
eqspertma b. n-m daadastura daqtiloskopiuri eqper-tizis daskvnis siswore da miuTiTa, rom gamosakvlev obi-eqtze TiTis kvlebi ar aRmoCnda, Tumca man ganmarta, romSesaZlebelia, pirma xeli mohkidos nivTs, magram kvali ma-inc ar darCes, rac damokidebulia bevr faqtorze, kerZod,imaze, Tu ra ZaliT mohkida pirma xeli mas, rogor gamoiyo-foda is nivTiereba, romelic TiTis kvals tovebs, rogorSefuTes da warmoadgines nivTmtkiceba kvlevisaTvis.
14. amdenad, im pirobebSi, rodesac arsebobs: mowme po-licielebis _ r. d-s, l. j-s, a. r-sa da T. k-s Tanmimdevru-li, Tanxvdenili Cvenebebi, romelTa obieqturobasa da mi-ukerZoeblobaSi eWvis Setanis safuZveli sakasacio pala-tas ar gaaCnia; braldebulis piradi Cxrekis oqmi, rome-lic Sedgenilia saproceso normebis sruli dacviT; qimi-uri eqspertizis daskvna; saqmeze saproceso moqmedebe-bi Catarda kanonis moTxovnaTa dacviT da policielTamxridan g. v-s mimarT raime interesi ar ikveTeba; mxolodbiologiuri (genetikuri) da daqtiloskopiuri eqsperti-zis daskvnebi, miT ufro im mocemulobiT, rodesac eq-spertebi ganmartaven, Tu ra SemTxvevaSi da ra albaTo-biT aris SesaZlebeli, rom gamosakvlev obieqtze darCeskvali da romeli garemoebebi gamoricxavs kvalis darCe-nis SesaZleblobas, ar warmoadgens upirobod gamamarTle-beli ganaCenis gamotanis safuZvels.
15. rac Seexeba dacvis mxaris mier mopovebuli eqsper-tizebis daskvnebis procesualur mxares, prokurori sa-kasacio saCivarSi uTiTebs, rom mosamarTlem daarRvia mxa-reTa Tanasworobisa da SejibrebiTobis principi, rode-sac dacvis mxaris mier saqmis arsebiTi ganxilvis dros sa-qarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis saproceso kodeqsis 239-emuxlis me-2 nawilis uxeSi darRveviT warmodgenili mtki-cebulebebi (biologiuri da daqtiloskopiuri eqsperti-
140
zebis daniSvnis Sesaxeb gancxadeba da mis safuZvelze mo-povebuli mtkicebulebebi _ eqspertizebis daskvnebi) da-saSvebad cno.
16. sakasacio palata miuTiTebs, rom adamianis ufle-baTa evropul sasamarTlos mravaljer aqvs ganmartebu-li, rom, Tumca adamianis uflebaTa evropuli konvenciisme-6 muxli icavs piris uflebas samarTlian sasamarTloganxilvaze, aRniSnuli muxli ar adgens mtkicebulebaTadasaSvebobis wesebs. igi Sidasaxelmwifoebrivi kanonmdeb-lobis prerogativaa, xolo evropuli sasamarTlos fun-qciaa, mTlianobaSi Seafasos samarTalwarmoebis samar-Tlianoba (`frumkini ruseTis winaaRmdeg~ (Frumkin v. Rus-sia), ganacxadi no. 74568/12,). evropuli sasamarTlo miiC-nevs, rom Sidasaxelmwfoebrivi sasamarTlo ukeTes pozi-ciaSia evropul sasamarTlosTan SedarebiT, raTa Seafa-sos mtkicebuleba, daadginos faqtebi, an ganmartos Si-dasaxelmwifoebrivi kanonmdebloba (`buliCevi ruseTiswinaaRmdeg~ (Bulychevy v. Russia), ganacxadi no. 24086/04).
17. samarTliani sasamarTlo ganxilvis uflebis erT-erTi fundamenturi aspeqti imaSi mdgomareobs, rom sis-xlis samarTalwarmoebis procesi, maT Soris procesualuraspeqtebTan dakavSirebuli elementebi, SejibrebiTi un-da iyos da braldebisa da dacvis mxareebis Tanasworobaunda iyos uzrunvelyofili. SejibrebiTi sasamarTlo gan-xilvis ufleba gulisxmobs, rom sisxlis samarTalwarmo-ebis procesSi rogorc braldebas, aseve dacvas meore mxa-ris mier wardgenili mtkicebulebebisa da mosazrebebisgacnobis saSualeba unda hqondes (Rowe and Davis v. the UnitedKingdom [GC], § 60).
18. mxareTa Tanasworobis principi gulisxmobs, romyvelas, vinc samarTalwarmoebis mxarea, sasamarTlosaT-vis Tavisi saqmis wardgenis gonivruli SesaZlebloba un-da hqondes im viTarebaSi, romelic mas ar ayenebs arsebi-Tad araxelsayrel pirobebSi meore mxaris sapirispirod.mxareTa Soris samarTliani wonasworoba unda damyardes(`de haesi da giizelsi belgiis winaaRmdeg~ (De Haes andGijsels v. Belgium) 19983/92).
kasacio saCivari, Seiswavla saqmis masalebi, Seamowma sa-Civris safuZvlianoba da miaCnia, rom misi moTxovna ar un-da dakmayofildes Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
8. sakasacio palata eTanxmeba dacvis mxares, rom moce-mul SemTxvevaSi uZravi Zeglis demontaJis brZaneba ga-moica sabWos dadebiTi daskvnis safuZvelze, Tumca ar izi-arebs mis pozicias, rom aRniSnuli garemoeba g. T-is pasu-xismgeblobas gamoricxavs.
8.1. palata miuTiTebs: is faqti, rom SesaZloa, sxva mo-xeleebmac gamoiCines daudevari damokidebuleba saqmi-sadmi, ar gamoricxavs g. T-is valdebulebas, keTilsindi-sierad Seesrulebina dakisrebuli samsaxurebrivi mova-leoba da jerovnad gamoekvlia sakiTxebi. g. T-es ar undamieca eleqtronuli Tanxmoba im brZanebaze, romelic Se-usabamo iyo `kulturuli memkvidreobis Sesaxeb~ saqar-Tvelos kanonis moTxovnebTan.
447476.06 lari da Sesrulebuli samuSaoebis RirebulebausafuZvlod gazrdilia 423 465 lariT.
4. Tavad braldebulma u. R-am ar uaryo zemoaRniSnulimtkicebulebebiT dadgenili faqtobrivi garemoebebi,Tumca ar daeTanxma misi qmedebebis Sefasebas, kerZod: u.R-am aCvena, rom Sps `ma.~ daafuZna 2008 wels da aris 100%-is mflobeli, direqtori da finansuri direqtori. 2011wlis agvistoSi gadawyvita monawileoba mieRo eleqtro-nul tenderSi, romelic ...-is m-ma gamoacxada. saqme iyosarisko, vinaidan igi exeboda kldeebze badis gadakvrasada qvaTacvenis SeCerebas, Seiswavles es saqme, moiZies kva-lificiuri mTasvlelebi, monawileoba miiRes tenderSi,`dades TavianTi fasi~ _ 945000 lari da gaimarjves. 2011wlis 1 seqtembers daibares q-is guberniaSi sadac daxvdagubernatoris moadgile, ramdenime maRalCinosani, p. C. dateqnikuri zedamxedvelebi ...-dan. dausves kiTxvebi, visunda gaekeTebina, romeli badiT, sad unda eyida bade daamasTanave, kategoriulad mosTxoves fasi daewia, Tu da-bal fasSi ar gaakeTebda, `cudad daamTavrebda~. bolosSeTanxmdnen, rom fass daswevda 800 000 laramde. vinai-dan iuridiulad warmoudgeneli da gaugonari faqti iyo,TviTon didxans fiqrobdnen, ra formiT unda daewiaT mo-gebul tenderze fasi, roca igi ukve fiqsirebulia. neba-yoflobiT dawera werili, rom Tanxma iyo 145 000 lariTiafad Seesrulebina SekveTa, razec ...-is municipalitetidaeTanxma da xelSekrulebaSi saboloo fasad mieTiTa 800000 lari. tenderSi monawileobis dros atvirTes mwarmo-eblis sertifikati, es aris Turquli kompania `k.~, rome-lic evropis bazars awvdis evrostandartebis Sesabamisbades. muSaobis wina etapze yvelam, maT Soris ...-is m-ma,icoda, romeli mwarmoeblis bade unda gakruliyo, radganiTxovdnen konkretul sertifikatebs. mwarmoeblisganmoiTxova 50X50 mm. diametris badis gamogzavna, romel-mac moswera, rom bunebaSi ar arsebobda msgavsi bade, ro-melsac eqneboda msgavsi Sida zomebi. vinaidan bade izo-meba diagonalsa da vertikalze, erTi zoma yovelTvis me-tia meoreze, arsebobs badeebi, 5/7 mm, 6/8-ze, 8/10-ze da10/12 mm, magram ar arsebobs bade 50X50 mm. vinaidan ...-is m-s miTiTebuli hqonda 50X50 mm. bade 3 mm, maT gazomes ba-dis ujredi da aRmoCnda, rom misi gverdi daaxloebiT aris5 sm. CaTvales, rom bades ase zomavs damkveTi da evrope-
171
lebi Signidan zomaven 8/10-ze. Sesabamisad, maTi azriT,bade aris igive, Tu mas gverdebidan gazomav. meore ten-deri dekemberSi gamocxadda. gadawyvites iqac mieRoT mo-nawileoba. winaswari xarjTaRricxva Seadgina dadgeniliwesis mixedviT. rodesac mewarme iTvlis konkretul obi-eqtze gaweuli samuSaoebis winaswar xarjebs, iTvaliswi-nebs aseve risks, ramdenad SeiZleba winaswari xarji gai-zardos an Semcirdes. winaswari xarjTaRricxva atvirTeseleqtronul tenderSi, sadac daafiqsires TiToeulpunqts ra fasad Seasrulebdnen, amas daemata gegmiurimogeba, zednadebi xarjebi da e.w. dRg. maT gaimarjves, xo-lo Sesabamisi xarjTaRricxva koreqtirebis gareSe dam-tkicda. samuSaoebis miReba-Cabarebis aqtis angariSfaq-turas ...-Si agzavnida, iq daTvlidnen marTla gaikra Tuara miTiTebuli odenobis bade, marTla Caisxa Tu ara mi-TiTebuli odenobis betoni; Tu moculoba emTxveoda mismier wardgenil moculobas, xels uwerdnen da SesabamisTanxas SeTanxmebuli fasis mixedviT uricxavdnen angariS-ze. mowmis ganmartebiT, yvela saqmes, garda uSualo xar-jebisa, aqvs kidev arapirdapiri xarji, es xarjebi gaiwe-reba zednadeb xarjSi. man moiTxova ...-is m-sgan 10% zed-nadebi xarjisTvis, xolo gegmiuri dagrovebisTvis _ 8%,rac dakmayofilda. Tu kompania ukeT imuSavebs, sakuTarZalebs an sakuTar manqanebs gamoiyenebs da darCeba metimogeba, es niSnavs, rom gegmiuri mogeba rCeba igive, xolooperatiuli (faqtobrivi) mogeba kompaniisa izrdeba. ad-re gegmiur ekonomikaSi ar SeiZleboda migeRo 8%-ze metimogeba, vinaidan yvela fasi iyo fiqsirebuli. dRevandelekonomikaSi, rodesac sworebaa evronormebTan 8%-ianigegmiuri dagroveba mainc arsebobs, Tumca kanoniT ar arisakrZaluli, rom miiRo 20-30 procenti operatiuli moge-ba. wlis bolos mis kompanias darCa daaxloebiT 200 000lari mogeba. am proeqtidan daaxloebiT 150 000 lari, racasaxa deklaraciaSi da oficialurad waradgina sagadasa-xadoSi da es mtkicebuleba prokurorma Tavad daurTosaqmes. mowmem ganmarta, rom xelSekrulebis dadebis drosSeafases TiToeuli erTeulis fasi. tenderis dros Tan-xmdeba winaswari fasi, rac formdeba xelSekrulebiT daSeTanxmebuli fasis cvlileba aris SeuZlebeli. mxareebiSeTanxmdnen, rom WiaTuris municipaliteti maTgan erTkvadratul metr bades Seisyidda pirobiTad 110 larad
172
da rodesac es bade miitanes, Caweres, rom es is badea, ro-melzec SeTanxmdnen, rom 110 larad iyiddnen. ar igulis-xmeba, rom es bade 110 larad iyida. iyo bevri produqcia,romelic met fasad Seisyida, vidre ...-is m-ma gadaixada.raRac SeiZleba gaZvirdes, raRac gaiafdes, magram aTan-xmeb iseT fass, rom saboloo jamSi ar izaralo, risks iRebsakuTar Tavze. SeTanxmebul fasSi raime cvlilebis Seta-na dauSvebeli iyo. razec SeTanxmdnen ...-is m-Tan, is fasigadmoitanes. Sesabamisad, mas bralad Seracxuli danaSa-uli ar Caudenia.
5. sakasacio palata nawilobriv iziarebs braldebulisCvenebas da ar eTanxmeba saapelacio palatis daskvnas imisSesaxeb, rom u. R-am zemoaRniSnuli qmedebebi Caidina mismarTlzomier mflobelobaSi arsebuli saxelmwifos kuT-vnili Tanxebis marTlsawinaaRmdegod miTvisebis mizniT,Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
9.2. Sps `m.~ da ssip TviTmmarTveli erTeuli _ ...-is m. iy-vnen nardobis xelSekrulebis safuZvelze warmoqmnil val-debulebiT-samarTlebriv urTierTobaSi da xelSekrule-bis Tavisuflebis principidan gamomdinare, Sps `m-s~ hqon-da ...-is m-Tan rogorc xelSekrulebis dadebis, ise urTier-TSeTanxmebiT misi Sinaarsis gansazRvris Tavisufleba.
9.3. palata ar iziarebs braldebis mxaris pozicias, romSps `m-s~ damkveTisTvis wardgenil forma #...-Si realurixarjebis miTiTebas avaldebulebda xelSekrulebebSi asa-xuli SeTanxmeba, romlis Tanaxmadac, samuSaos etapis Ri-rebulebis SemsruleblisTvis anazRaurebis safuZvels,miReba-Cabarebis aqtTan erTad, warmoadgens xarjTaR-ricxva (forma #...), romelic, samSeneblo sferoSi dam-kvidrebuli praqtikiT, faqtobrivad Sesrulebul samu-SaoTa amsaxveli dokumentia da miuTiTebs, rom saqarTve-loSi moqmedi arc erTi normatiuli aqti ar gansazRvravsforma #...-is arss, mis savaldebulo da fakultatiur rek-vizitebs da ar ukrZalavs mxareebs forma #...-Si Sesru-lebuli samuSaos mTliani Rirebulebis gaangariSebisasixelmZRvanelon erTeulebis (xelfasis erTeulis, masa-lis erTeulis, samSeneblo meqanizmebisa da transporti-rebis erTeulis da sxv.) ara faqtobrivi, aramed SeTanxme-buli fasebiT. garda amisa, Sesrulebuli samuSaos Rire-buleba rom Sps `m-is~ mier realurad gaweul xarjebs un-da Seadgendes, amis Taobaze arc forma #...-ebsa da arcxelSekrulebebSi miniSnebulic ki ar aris.
9.4. saxelmwifo Sesyidvebis Sesaxeb #... da #... xelSek-rulebebis analizi cxadyofs, rom damkveTsa da Semsru-lebels Soris dadebuli iyo nardobis xelSekrulebebi,sadac winaswaraa SeTanxmebuli Sesasrulebeli samuSaoe-bis moculoba da Rirebuleba. Sesabamisad, is damokide-buli ar aris Semsruleblis mier aRniSnuli xelSekrule-bis SesrulebisaTvis gaweuli xarjebis odenobaze da anaz-Raurebis odenobac ar aris damokidebuli SesrulebulisamuSaoebis TviTRirebulebaze. vinaidan, saqarTvelossamoqalaqo kodeqsis 629-e muxlis pirveli nawilis Tanax-mad, menarde kisrulobs, Seasrulos xelSekrulebiT gaT-valiswinebuli samuSao. SemkveTi valdebulia, gadauxados
176
menardes SeTanxmebuli sazRauri. palata yuradRebas mi-aqcevs im garemoebasac, rom saxelmwifo Sesyidvebis Se-saxeb #... da #... xelSekrulebebSi ar aris miTiTebuli imisSesaxeb, rom saboloo angariSsworebisas gaweuli momsa-xurebis Rirebuleba unda anazRaurdes mimwodeblis mi-er faqtobrivad gaweuli danaxarjebis mixedviT da ara _xelSekrulebiT dadgenili fasis Sesabamisad.
9.5. kanonSeusabamod ver miiCneva aseve Sps `m-is~ mierforma #...-ebSi gegmiuri dagrovebis maCveneblad 8%-is mi-TiTeba, miuxedavad imisa, rom `m-ma~ realurad ufro metimogeba miiRo, vinaidan Sps `m-s~ arc xelSekrulebiT da arcraime normatiuli aqtiT ar ekisreboda valdebuleba, 8%-iani zRvris zeviT miRebuli mogebis Tanxa daebrunebinaSemsyidveli organizaciisaTvis. rac Seexeba saqmeSi war-modgenil saqarTvelos ekonomikisa da mdgradi ganviTa-rebis ministris 2012 wlis 12 ivlisis #... brZanebas `samSe-neblo samuSaoebis saxelmwifo Sesyidvisas zednadebi xar-jebisa da gegmuri mogebis gansazRvris wesis damtkicebisSesaxeb~, romlis Tanaxmadac dadginda gegmuri mogebiszRvruli 8%-iani maCvenebeli, palata miuTiTebs, rom ama-ve brZanebis me-2 punqtis mixedviT: `am brZanebis moqmede-ba ar vrceldeba ama wlis ivlisamde aRiarebul samuSaoeb-ze~. Sesabamisad, dadgenili gegmuri mogebis zRvruli 8%-iani maCvenebeli gavrcelda 2012 wlis 1 ivlisis Semdeg aRi-arebul samuSaoebze da ara im droze, rodesac Sedga Sua-leduri da saboloo miReba-Cabarebis aqtebi da aRiarebuliqna Sps `m-is~ mier Sesrulebuli samuSaoebi.
9.6. amdenad, imis gaTvaliswinebiT, rom braldebis mxa-rem ver miuTiTa iseT samarTlebriv aqtze, romelic Sps`m-s~ avaldebulebda, samuSaoTa Sesrulebis miReba-Caba-rebis aqtebSi mieTiTebina mis mier masalebSi faqtobri-vad gadaxdili Rirebuleba, sakasacio palata ver gaizia-rebs saapelacio palatis daskvnas imis Sesaxeb, rom gawe-uli xarjebis usafuZvlod gazrdis gziT u. R-am marTlsa-winaaRmdegod miiTvisa saxelmwifos kuTvnili qoneba.
9.7. yovelive zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, sakasa-cio palatas miaCnia, rom u. R. cnobil unda iqnes udanaSa-ulod saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 182-emuxlis meore nawilis `d~ da mesame nawilis `b~ qvepunqte-biTa (ori epizodi) da ssk-is 362-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `b~qvepuntiT (#... xelSekrulebis epizodi) wardgenil bral-
177
debebSi da unda gamarTldes.10. amasTan, sakasacio palata gverds ver auvlis im faqts,
rom u. R-am ##... xelSekrulebis safuZvelze W-is m-saTvisSesrulebul samuSaoTa Cabarebisas gaayalba SesrulebulisamuSaoebis miReba-Cabarebis saboloo aqti (e.w. forma #...),kerZod: 2011 wlis 14 dekembris saboloo miReba-Cabarebisaqtis me-14 grafaSi miuTiTa, rom, TiTqosda samuSaoebi Se-asrula 50X50 mm diametris zomis badiT, maSin, rodesac sa-muSaoebi Sesrulebuli iyo 80X100 mm diametris zomis ba-diT da miuTiTebs, rom braldebis am epizodTan dakavSire-biT ver gaiziarebs u. R-as Cvenebas, rom TiTqos man gverde-bidan gazoma bade da miiCnia, rom 50X50-Si igulisxmebodagverdebis zomebi, Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
10.1. l. samxaraulis saxelobis sasamarTlo eqsperti-zis erovnuli biuros sainJinro eqspertizis #... daskvniT(romlis sisworec sasamarTloSi daadastura eqspertmam. t-em) dadgenilia, rom eqspertizaze warmodgenili,kldidan qvaTacvenis sawinaaRmdego da SemaCerebeli li-Tonis eqvskuTxa (eqvsgverdiani) badis gverdebis saSua-lo zomebia: oTxi grZeli gverdis sigrZea _ 63 mm+/-2 mm,xolo ori mokle gverdis sigrZea _ 33 mm+/-2 mm. xsenebulidaskvnis Sesabamisad, u. R-as ganmarteba, rom bade gver-debidan azoma da amitom Secda, safuZvels moklebulia,vinaidan arc gverdebis zomaa 50X50.
10.2. u. R-am rom ganzrax Seadgina da samuSaoTa miReba-Cabarebisas, 2011 wlis 14 dekembers, ...-is m-s warudginayalbi saxarjTaRricxvo dokumenti (forma #..., sadac mi-uTiTa, rom ...-is m-s miawoda da samuSaoebi Seasrula pro-eqtis Sesabamisad _ 50x50 mm diametris badiT, maSin, ro-desac man Sps `k-gan~ SeiZina sxvagvari _ d-3 80X100 mm dia-metris bade, dasturdeba imiTac, rom Sps `k-sgan~ SeZeni-li d-3 80X100 mm diametris badis nawili u. R-am gamoiyena#...-e xelSekrulebis farglebSi, me-3 seqtorze Catare-buli qvaTacvenis salikvidacio samuSaoebis drosac, sa-dac miReba-Cabarebis aqtze TandarTuli saxarjTaRric-xvo dokumentSi (forma #...) miuTiTebs d-3 80X100 mm dia-metris badeze. amdenad, imave parametris mqone badis Se-saxeb sxvadasxva aqtSi gansxvavebuli monacemis miTiTebasarwmunod miuTiTebs u. R-as ganmartebis aradamajereb-lobaze, rom is srulyoflad ver gaerkva proeqtSi miTi-Tebuli badis parametrebis sakiTxSi da teqnikuri Sec-
178
doma dauSva.10.3. Tavad u. R-as ganmartebac, rom mcdelobis miuxe-
davad, ver SeZlo proeqtSi miTiTebuli parametris badismoZieba, radgan aseTi bade realurad arsad mzaddeboda,miuTiTebs imaze, rom man danamdvilebiT icoda, Tu ra pa-rametris bade unda gamoeyenebina samuSaoebisaTvis daTuki obieqturad SeuZlebeli gaxda proeqtSi miTiTebu-li badis moZieba, mas SeeZlo, winadadebiT miemarTa dam-kveTisaTvis xelSekrulebaSi cvlilebis Setanis mizniT,rac ganzrax ar Seasrula im motiviT, rom Tavidan aeride-bina xelSekrulebiT nakisri valdebulebis Seusruleb-loba, rac SesaZloa, ...-is m-s mier badis SeZenaze uarisTqmis safuZveli da, amasTanave, Sps `m-is~ mimarT xelSek-rulebiT gaTvaliswinebuli sanqciebis amoqmedebis sa-fuZveli gamxdariyo.
11. amdenad, sakasacio palata gonivrul eWvs miRmastandartiT dadasturebulad miiCnevs, rom u. R-am Cai-dina saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 362-e mux-lis pirveli nawiliT (#... xelSekrulebis epizodi) gaTva-liswinebuli danaSauli _ yalbi dokumentis damzadeba dagamoyeneba, rac gamoixata mis mier yalbi saxarjTaRric-xvo dokumentis Sedgenasa (romelSic ganzrax miuTiTa,rom ...-is m-s miawoda da samuSaoebi Seasrula proeqtis Se-sabamisad _ 50X50 mm diametris badiT, maSin, rodesac re-alurad samuSaoebi Seasrula d-3 80X100 mm diametris ba-diT) da 2011 wlis 14 dekembers ...-is m-Tvis wardgenaSi.
12. sasjelis gansazRvrisas sakasacio palata, saqar-Tvelos ssk-is 53-e muxlis Sesabamisad, mxedvelobaSiiRebs im garemoebas, rom u. R-as ar gaaCnia pasuxismgeblo-bis damamZimebeli garemoebebi, mis mier Cadenilia nakle-bad mZime kategoriis, araZaladobrivi xasiaTis danaSau-li, ris gamoc samarTliani iqneba misTvis am muxliT gaT-valiswinebuli arasapatimro sanqciis _ jarimis gamoye-neba im odenobiT, rac damafiqrebeli iqneba msjavrdebu-lisTvis da uzrunvelyofs SemdgomSi danaSaulebriviqmedebisgan Tavis Sekavebas.
d a a d g i n a:
1. msjavrdebul u. R-sa da misi interesebis damcvelis,advokat g. g-is sakasacio saCivari dakmayofildes nawi-
6. kasatori _ prokurori g. saxiaSvili sakasacio saCi-varSi aRniSnavs, rom TviTon danaSauli da ara _ misi Ti-Toeuli komponenti dadasturebulia saqmeSi arsebulimtkicebulebebis erTobliobiT, amitom d. v. cnobil undaiqnes damnaSaved saqarTvelos ssk-is 3771-e muxliT da ga-nesazRvros Sesabamisi sasjeli.
ma sakasacio saCivris motivebis safuZvlianoba da daas-kvna, rom saCivari ar unda dakmayofildes, xolo gasaCiv-rebuli ganaCeni unda darCes ucvlelad Semdeg garemoe-baTa gamo:
2. sakasacio palata srulad iziarebs saapelacio sasa-marTlos argumentebs d. v-is udanaSaulobis Taobaze damiaCnia, rom kanonis moTxovnaTa dacviT, srulyofiladda obieqturad gamokvleul mtkicebulebaTa erToblio-biT ar dasturdeba d. v-is mier danaSaulis Cadena.