Simulating new logistics of Le Havre port D. Leriche, J.F. Emery
OUTLINE
• INTRODUCTION
• LE HAVRE PORT LOGISTICS
• SIMULATION SCENARIO
• MANAGEMENT RULES
• RESULTS
• CONCLUSION AND PERSPECTIVES
11/05/2015 2
INTRODUCTION SIMULATION SCENARIOLE HAVRE PORT LOGISTICS CONCLUSION AND PERSPECTIVESMANAGEMENT RULES RESULTS
Presentation
• Leriche David
• Engineer
• PhD student
– MAS
– Le Havre Port (GPMH)
– IRSEM
11/05/2015 3
INTRODUCTION SIMULATION SCENARIOLE HAVRE PORT LOGISTICS CONCLUSION AND PERSPECTIVESMANAGEMENT RULES RESULTS
Introduction
• Maritime Transport 80 % world share
• Vessel capacity increase involves :
– The need for storage in maritime terminal
– Efficiency
– Punctuality
• Sustainability (green transport, modal shift)
11/05/2015 4
INTRODUCTION SIMULATION SCENARIOLE HAVRE PORT LOGISTICS CONCLUSION AND PERSPECTIVESMANAGEMENT RULES RESULTS
Modal split (2008)
11/05/2015 5http://www.developpement-durable.gouv.fr/Rapport-sur-la-desserte.html
INTRODUCTION SIMULATION SCENARIOLE HAVRE PORT LOGISTICS CONCLUSION AND PERSPECTIVESMANAGEMENT RULES RESULTS
DCAS Project
• Promote rail transport through the introduction of new logistics organizations
• Remotely operated railway coupon, automatic un/~coupling for maneuvering in the ITE
11/05/2015 6
INTRODUCTION SIMULATION SCENARIOLE HAVRE PORT LOGISTICS CONCLUSION AND PERSPECTIVESMANAGEMENT RULES RESULTS
Current logistic System
11/05/2015 7
MT : Maritime-Terminals
INTRODUCTION SIMULATION SCENARIOLE HAVRE PORT LOGISTICS CONCLUSION AND PERSPECTIVESMANAGEMENT RULES RESULTS
911/05/2015
INTRODUCTION SIMULATION SCENARIOLE HAVRE PORT LOGISTICS CONCLUSION AND PERSPECTIVESMANAGEMENT RULES RESULTS
Multimodal terminal design
11/05/2015 10
INTRODUCTION SIMULATION SCENARIOLE HAVRE PORT LOGISTICS CONCLUSION AND PERSPECTIVESMANAGEMENT RULES RESULTS
11/05/2015 11
INTRODUCTION SIMULATION SCENARIOLE HAVRE PORT LOGISTICS CONCLUSION AND PERSPECTIVESMANAGEMENT RULES RESULTS
Motivation
• Understanding the new system :
– Cost
– Number of containers in time
– Filling rate of shuttle
– Number of handling per container
• Communicate pedagogically with stakeholders
11/05/2015 12
INTRODUCTION SIMULATION SCENARIOLE HAVRE PORT LOGISTICS CONCLUSION AND PERSPECTIVESMANAGEMENT RULES RESULTS
Methodology
1. UML approach
2. Management rules definition
3. Build a hybrid model in AnyLogic tool :
– Multi-agent system
– Discrete Event system
4. Performance evaluation
11/05/2015 13
INTRODUCTION SIMULATION SCENARIOLE HAVRE PORT LOGISTICS CONCLUSION AND PERSPECTIVESMANAGEMENT RULES RESULTS
14
Shuttle 1
Shuttle 2
Shuttle 3
11/05/2015
INTRODUCTION SIMULATION SCENARIOLE HAVRE PORT LOGISTICS CONCLUSION AND PERSPECTIVESMANAGEMENT RULES RESULTS
Handling rules in rail yard
11/05/2015 15
Left to left
Less distance without come-backLess distance
INTRODUCTION SIMULATION SCENARIOLE HAVRE PORT LOGISTICS CONCLUSION AND PERSPECTIVESMANAGEMENT RULES RESULTS
Parameters optimization progress
11/05/2015 16
++ 321
i
i
ii
inc
nc
dtedP
Freight trains assignment by:
13,2,1/ ii i
++ 321
i
i
ii
inc
nc
dtedP
++ 321
i
i
ii
inc
nc
dtedP
++ 321
i
i
ii
inc
nc
dtedP
++ 321
i
i
ii
inc
nc
dtedP
++ 321
i
i
ii
inc
nc
dtedP
1 Export deadline
2 Import deadline
3 Number of container
INTRODUCTION SIMULATION SCENARIOLE HAVRE PORT LOGISTICS CONCLUSION AND PERSPECTIVESMANAGEMENT RULES RESULTS
Optimization approach
11/05/2015 17
OptQuestOptimizer
Simulation Model
Best Solution
Objective function
Stopping criteria
INTRODUCTION SIMULATION SCENARIOLE HAVRE PORT LOGISTICS CONCLUSION AND PERSPECTIVESMANAGEMENT RULES RESULTS
Objective function progress
11/05/2015 18
1 2 3Nb iteration
Nb iteration
Nbcontainer
INTRODUCTION SIMULATION SCENARIOLE HAVRE PORT LOGISTICS CONCLUSION AND PERSPECTIVESMANAGEMENT RULES RESULTS
Output generation
11/05/2015 19
Stochastic variation
Evaluation with Simulation
Model
robustness
Stopping criteria Acceptable
transfer rate
New parameters
test
replication iteration
Stopping criteria
INTRODUCTION SIMULATION SCENARIOLE HAVRE PORT LOGISTICS CONCLUSION AND PERSPECTIVESMANAGEMENT RULES RESULTS
Number of handling per container
11/05/2015 20
INTRODUCTION SIMULATION SCENARIOLE HAVRE PORT LOGISTICS CONCLUSION AND PERSPECTIVESMANAGEMENT RULES RESULTS
Shuttle filling progress
11/05/2015 21
INTRODUCTION SIMULATION SCENARIOLE HAVRE PORT LOGISTICS CONCLUSION AND PERSPECTIVESMANAGEMENT RULES RESULTS
Cost per container
11/05/2015 22
Less distance without come-back
Less distance
Left to left
INTRODUCTION SIMULATION SCENARIOLE HAVRE PORT LOGISTICS CONCLUSION AND PERSPECTIVESMANAGEMENT RULES RESULTS
Conclusion
• Test different management mode of future logistic pattern with multimodal terminal
• Simulation results were used to validate the economic equation
• Performance indicators given by the simulation are a valuable source for the Port Authority to make good predictive study of operations management
11/05/2015 23
INTRODUCTION SIMULATION SCENARIOLE HAVRE PORT LOGISTICS CONCLUSION AND PERSPECTIVESMANAGEMENT RULES RESULTS
perspectives
• optimize management rules of simulation model
• seek improvements and more efficient exploitation
• adapt the simulation tool to use it in operation :
– as a tool for resource reservation on the horizon of a week
– transform the simulation model to a decision support tool in the real-time operational decision.
11/05/2015 24