Copyright © Siemens AG 2008. All rights reserved. Short Circuit Calculation Sector Energy D SE PTI NC Steffen Schmidt
5/21/2018 Short-Circuit-Calculations.pdf
1/72
Copyright Siemens AG 2008. All rights reserved.
Short Circuit Calculation
Sector Energy
D SE PTI NC
Steffen Schmidt
5/21/2018 Short-Circuit-Calculations.pdf
2/72Page 2 28.06.2008Copyright Siemens AG 2008. All rights reserved.
E D SE PTI NCSteffen Schmidt
Standards and Terms
5/21/2018 Short-Circuit-Calculations.pdf
3/72Page 3 28.06.2008Copyright Siemens AG 2008. All rights reserved.
E D SE PTI NCSteffen Schmidt
Purpose of ShortCircuit Calculations
Dimensioning of switching deices
Dynamic dimensioning of switchgear
Therma! rating of e!ectrica! deices "e.g. ca#!es$
Protection coordination
%a&!t diagnostic
In'&t data for
Earthing st&dies
Interference ca!c&!ations E(C '!anning
)..
5/21/2018 Short-Circuit-Calculations.pdf
4/72Page * 28.06.2008Copyright Siemens AG 2008. All rights reserved.
E D SE PTI NCSteffen Schmidt
ShortCircuit Calculation
Standards
IEC 60+0+,Short-Circ&it C&rrent Ca!c&!ation in Three-Phase .C. Systems
E&ro'ean Standard EN 60+0+ /erman Nationa! Standard DIN DE 0102 f&rther Nationa! Standards
Engineering ecommendation /* "45$Proced&re to (eet the e&irements of IEC 60+0+ for theCa!c&!ation of Short-Circ&it C&rrents in Three-Phase C Power
Systems
NSI IIEEE Std. C3.7 "4S$IEEE /&ide for Ca!c&!ation of %a&!t C&rrents for ''!ication of a.c.igh o!tage Circ&it 9rea:ers ated on a Tota! C&rrent 9asis.
5/21/2018 Short-Circuit-Calculations.pdf
5/72Page 7 28.06.2008Copyright Siemens AG 2008. All rights reserved.
E D SE PTI NCSteffen Schmidt
ShortCircuit Calculations
Standard !"C #0$0$
IEC 60+0+ , Short-circ&it c&rrents in three-'hase a.c. systems
Part 0, Ca!c&!ation of c&rrentsPart 1, %actors for the ca!c&!ation of
short-circ&it c&rrentsPart 2, E!ectrica! e&i'ment; data for
short-circ&it c&rrent ca!c&!ationsPart 3, C&rrents d&ring two se'arate
sim&!taneo&s !ine-to-earth shortcirc&its and 'artia! short-circ&itc&rrents f!owing thro&gh earth
Part *, E
5/21/2018 Short-Circuit-Calculations.pdf
6/72Page 6 28.06.2008Copyright Siemens AG 2008. All rights reserved.
E D SE PTI NCSteffen Schmidt
ShortCircuit Calculations
Scope of !"C #0$0$
three-'hase a.c. systems !ow o!tage and high o!tage systems &' to 700 : nomina! fre&ency of 70 = and 60 = #a!anced and &n#a!anced short circ&its
three 'hase short circ&its two 'hase short circ&its "with and witho&t earth connection$ sing!e 'hase !ine-to-earth short circ&its in systems with so!id!y
earthed or im'edance earthed ne&tra! two se'arate sim&!taneo&s sing!e-'hase !ine-to-earth short circ&its
in a systems with iso!ated ne&tra! or a resonance earthed ne&tra!"IEC 60+0+-3$ ma
5/21/2018 Short-Circuit-Calculations.pdf
7/72Page 28.06.2008Copyright Siemens AG 2008. All rights reserved.
E D SE PTI NCSteffen SchmidtCopyright Siemens AG 200%. All rights reserved.
ShortCircuit Calculations
Types of Short Circuits
&phase
2phase
'phase
5/21/2018 Short-Circuit-Calculations.pdf
8/72Page 8 28.06.2008Copyright Siemens AG 2008. All rights reserved.
E D SE PTI NCSteffen Schmidt
(ariation of short circuit current shapes
fa&!t at o!tage 'ea: fa&!t at o!tage=ero crossing
fa&!t !ocated inthe networ:
fa&!t !ocatednear generator
5/21/2018 Short-Circuit-Calculations.pdf
9/72Page + 28.06.2008Copyright Siemens AG 2008. All rights reserved.
E D SE PTI NCSteffen Schmidt
ShortCircuit Calculations
)arfromgenerator short circuit
I:> Initia! symmetrica! short-circ&it c&rrenti' Pea: short-circ&it c&rrentI: Steady-state short-circ&it c&rrent
Initia! a!&e of the d.c com'onent
5/21/2018 Short-Circuit-Calculations.pdf
10/72Page 10 28.06.2008Copyright Siemens AG 2008. All rights reserved.
E D SE PTI NCSteffen Schmidt
ShortCircuit Calculations
*efinitions according !"C #0$0$ +!,
initial symmetrical shortcircuit current I->r.m.s. a!&e of the a.c. symmetrica! com'onent of a 'ros'ectie"aai!a#!e$ short-circ&it c&rrent? a''!ica#!e at the instant of short circ&it ifthe im'edance remains at =ero-time a!&e
initial symmetrical shortcircuit poer S->fictitio&s a!&e determined as a 'rod&ct of the initia! symmetrica! short-circ&it c&rrent I:>? the nomina! system o!tage Unand the factor @3,
NATE, S:> is often &sed to ca!c&!ate the interna! im'edance of a networ: feeder at the
connection 'oint. In this case the definition gien sho&!d #e &sed in the fo!!owing form,
B
:n
B
: I43S =
B
:
2
n
S
4cC
=
5/21/2018 Short-Circuit-Calculations.pdf
11/72Page 11 28.06.2008Copyright Siemens AG 2008. All rights reserved.
E D SE PTI NCSteffen Schmidt
ShortCircuit Calculations
*efinitions according !"C #0$0$ +!!,
decaying +aperiodic, component id.c.of shortcircuit current
mean a!&e #etween the to' and #ottom ene!o'e of a short-circ&itc&rrent decaying from an initia! a!&e to =ero
pea- shortcircuit current ipma
5/21/2018 Short-Circuit-Calculations.pdf
12/72Page 12 28.06.2008Copyright Siemens AG 2008. All rights reserved.
E D SE PTI NCSteffen Schmidt
ShortCircuit Calculations
/eartogenerator short circuit
I:> Initia! symmetrica! short-circ&it c&rrenti' Pea: short-circ&it c&rrentI: Steady-state short-circ&it c&rrent
Initia! a!&e of the d.c com'onentI9 Symmetrica! short-circ&it #rea:ing c&rrent
t
9I22
5/21/2018 Short-Circuit-Calculations.pdf
13/72Page 13 28.06.2008Copyright Siemens AG 2008. All rights reserved.
E D SE PTI NCSteffen Schmidt
ShortCircuit Calculations
*efinitions according !"C #0$0$ +!!!,
steadystate shortcircuit currentI-r.m.s. a!&e of the short-circ&it c&rrent which remains after the decay ofthe transient 'henomena
symmetrical shortcircuit 1rea-ing current I1r.m.s. a!&e of an integra! cyc!e of the symmetrica! a.c. com'onent of the'ros'ectie short-circ&it c&rrent at the instant of contact se'aration ofthe first 'o!e to o'en of a switching deice
5/21/2018 Short-Circuit-Calculations.pdf
14/72Page 1* 28.06.2008
Copyright Siemens AG 2008. All rights reserved.E D SE PTI NCSteffen Schmidt
ShortCircuit Calculations
Purpose of ShortCircuit (alues
(inim&m symmetrica! short-circ&it c&rrent I:Se!ectie detection of 'artia!short-circ&it c&rrents
Protection setting
(a
Potentia! rise;
(agnetic fie!ds
Earthing? Interference? E(C
Initia! symmetrica! short-circ&it c&rrent I:>
%a&!t d&ration
Tem'erat&re rise of e!ectrica!
deices "e.g. ca#!es$
Therma! stress to e&i'ment
Pea: short-circ&it c&rrenti'%orces to e!ectrica! deices
"e.g. #&s #ars? ca#!es)$(echanica! stress toe&i'ment
Symmetrica! short-circ&it#rea:ing c&rrent I#
Therma! stress to arcing
cham#er; arc e
5/21/2018 Short-Circuit-Calculations.pdf
15/72Page 17 28.06.2008
Copyright Siemens AG 2008. All rights reserved.E D SE PTI NCSteffen Schmidt
Standard !"C #0$0$
Simplifications and Assumption
ss&m'tions &asi-static state instead of dynamic ca!c&!ation
no change in the ty'e of short circ&it d&ring fa&!t d&ration
no change in the networ: d&ring fa&!t d&ration
arc resistances are not ta:en into acco&nt im'edance of transformers is referred to ta' changer in main 'osition
neg!ecting of a!! sh&nt im'edances e
5/21/2018 Short-Circuit-Calculations.pdf
16/72Page 16 28.06.2008
Copyright Siemens AG 2008. All rights reserved.E D SE PTI NCSteffen Schmidt
"uivalent (oltage Source
5/21/2018 Short-Circuit-Calculations.pdf
17/72Page 1 28.06.2008
Copyright Siemens AG 2008. All rights reserved.E D SE PTI NCSteffen Schmidt
Shortcircuit
"uivalent voltage source at the shortcircuit location
E
E CFCTC/
%
G
IB33
.n
Uc
rea! networ:
e&ia!ent circ&it
A'erationa! data and the 'assie !oad of cons&mers are neg!ectedTa'-changer 'osition of transformers is dis'ensa#!eE
5/21/2018 Short-Circuit-Calculations.pdf
18/72Page 18 28.06.2008
Copyright Siemens AG 2008. All rights reserved.E D SE PTI NCSteffen Schmidt
Short circuit in meshed grid
"uivalent voltage source at the shortcircuit location
rea! networ: e&ia!ent circ&it
5/21/2018 Short-Circuit-Calculations.pdf
19/72
Page 1+ 28.06.2008Copyright Siemens AG 2008. All rights reserved.
E D SE PTI NCSteffen Schmidt
(oltage )actor c
c is a safety factorto consider the fo!!owing effects, o!tage ariations de'ending on time and '!ace? changing of transformer ta's? neg!ecting !oads and ca'acitances #y ca!c&!ations? the stransient #ehaio&r of generators and motors.
1.001.10(edi&m o!tage 1 : H 37 :
0.+70.+7
1.071.10
Fow o!tage 100 H 1000
-systems with a to!erance of 6-systems with a to!erance of 10
1.001.10igh o!tage 37 :
minim&m short circ&it c&rrentsma
5/21/2018 Short-Circuit-Calculations.pdf
20/72
Page 20 28.06.2008Copyright Siemens AG 2008. All rights reserved.
E D SE PTI NCSteffen Schmidt
4a5imum and minimum ShortCircuit Currents
sha!! #e neg!ectedsha!! #e considered(otors
(a
5/21/2018 Short-Circuit-Calculations.pdf
21/72
Page 21 28.06.2008Copyright Siemens AG 2008. All rights reserved.
E D SE PTI NCSteffen Schmidt
Short Circuit !mpedances and Correction )actors
5/21/2018 Short-Circuit-Calculations.pdf
22/72
Page 22 28.06.2008Copyright Siemens AG 2008. All rights reserved.
E D SE PTI NCSteffen Schmidt
Short Circuit !mpedances
%or networ: feeders? transformer? oerhead !ines? ca#!e etc.
im'edance of 'ositie se&ence system K im'edance of negatiese&ence system
im'edance of =ero se&ence system &s&a!!y different
to'o!ogy can #e different for =ero se&ence system
Correction factors for
generators?
generator #!oc:s? networ: transformer
factors are a!id in =ero? 'ositie? negatie se&ence system
5/21/2018 Short-Circuit-Calculations.pdf
23/72
Page 23 28.06.2008Copyright Siemens AG 2008. All rights reserved.
E D SE PTI NCSteffen Schmidt
/etor- feeders
t a feeder connection 'oint &s&a!!y one of the fo!!owing a!&es is gien, the initia! symmetrica! short circ&it c&rrent I:> the initia! short-circ&it 'ower S:>
If LM of the networ: feeder is &n:nown? one of the fo!!owing a!&es can#e &sed, LM K 0.1 LM K 0.0 for high o!tage systems 37 : fed #y oerhead !ines
B:
2n
B:
n
E S
4c
I3
4c
C
=
=
2
EE
$ML"1
CM
+=
5/21/2018 Short-Circuit-Calculations.pdf
24/72
Page 2* 28.06.2008Copyright Siemens AG 2008. All rights reserved.
E D SE PTI NCSteffen Schmidt
/etor- transformer
Correction of !mpedance
T5K T5T
genera!
at :nown conditions of o'eration
no correction for im'edances #etween star 'oint and gro&nd
T
ma
5/21/2018 Short-Circuit-Calculations.pdf
25/72
Page 27 28.06.2008Copyright Siemens AG 2008. All rights reserved.
E D SE PTI NCSteffen Schmidt
/etor- transformer
!mpact of Correction )actor
The Correction factor is 5T1.0 for transformers with
5/21/2018 Short-Circuit-Calculations.pdf
26/72
Page 26 28.06.2008Copyright Siemens AG 2008. All rights reserved.
E D SE PTI NCSteffen Schmidt
Generator ith direct Connection to /etor-
Correction of !mpedance
/5K /5/
genera!
for contin&o&s o'eration a#oe rated o!tage,
4r/"1O'/$ instead of 4r/
t&r#ine generator, M"2$ K M"1$
sa!ient 'o!e generator, M"2$ K 1L2 "MdBO MB$
r/d
ma