Top Banner

of 20

Shared Decision Making in Patients With

Feb 25, 2018

Download

Documents

Giyani Suebu
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
  • 7/25/2019 Shared Decision Making in Patients With

    1/20

    Shared Decision Making in Patients withOsteoarthritis of the Hip and Knee

    Results of a Randomized Controlled Trial

    Kevin J. Bozic, MD, MBA, Jeffrey Belkora, PhD, Vanessa Chan,MPH, Jiwon You, MD, M!, "ianzan #hou, B!,

    John Du$ai%, MD, An&ela 'ava Bye, MA, A"C, Clarence H.Bra((ock ))), MD, MPH, Ka*e +resian Chenok, MBA,

    an( Jaes ). Hu((les*on ))), MD

  • 7/25/2019 Shared Decision Making in Patients With

    2/20

    s*eoar*hri*is of *he hi$ an( knee affec*sillions of Aericans.

    "he clinical anifes*a*ions ran&e froil( $ain causin& inial i$airen* *o

    severe $ain an( (isa-ili*y, resul*in& inlii*e( o-ili*y an( $oor uali*y of life.

  • 7/25/2019 Shared Decision Making in Patients With

    3/20

    "rea*en* al*erna*ives /0 Ac*ivi*y o(ifica*ion,

    0 1ei&h* loss,0 Physical *hera$y, an(

    0 'ons*eroi(al an*i2inflaa*ory e(ica*ions

    0 More invasive *hera$ies, such as in3ec*ions,

    os*eo*oy, an( *o*al 3oin* ar*hro$las*y.

  • 7/25/2019 Shared Decision Making in Patients With

    4/20

    "hese *rea*en*s e%$ose $a*ien*s *o$o*en*ial risks as well as $ossi-le -enefi*s.Physicians shoul( incor$ora*e $a*ien*

    $references a-ou* *he value, *iin&, an(likelihoo( of *hese risks an( -enefi*s when

    (evelo$in& a *rea*en* $lan wi*h *heir$a*ien*s.

  • 7/25/2019 Shared Decision Making in Patients With

    5/20

    ackground

    Des$i*e evi(ence *ha* share( (ecision2

    akin& *ools for *rea*en* (ecisionsi$rove (ecision uali*y an( $a*ien*en&a&een*, the! are not commonl!

    emplo!ed in orthopaedic practice.

  • 7/25/2019 Shared Decision Making in Patients With

    6/20

    The purpose of this stud! "0 *o evalua*e *he i$ac* of (ecision an(

    counica*ion ai(s on $a*ien* knowle(&e,0 efficiency of (ecision akin&,

    0 *rea*en* choice, an(

    0 $a*ien* an( sur&eon e%$erience in $a*ien*s

    wi*h os*eoar*hri*is of *he hi$ or knee.

  • 7/25/2019 Shared Decision Making in Patients With

    7/20

    Materials and Methods

    #$% $a*ien*s referre( *o *wo aca(eice(ical cen*ers 4*he 5niversi*y of California,

    !an 6rancisco an( !*anfor(5niversi*y78ecrui*e( -e*ween !e$*e-er 9:;; an(

    May 9:;9Consi(ere( e(ically a$$ro$ria*e for hi$ or

    knee re$laceen*.8an(oize( *o ei*her a shared decision&

    making inter'entionor usual care.

  • 7/25/2019 Shared Decision Making in Patients With

    8/20

    (nter'ention group

    8eceive( a (i&i*al vi(eo(isc an( -ookle*(escri-in& *he na*ural

    his*ory an( *rea*en*al*erna*ives for hi$ an(knee os*eoar*hri*is.An( (evelo$e( a

    s*ruc*ure( lis* of

    ues*ions for *heirsur&eon in consul*a*ionwi*h a heal*h coach.

    Control group

    8eceive( infora*iona-ou* *he sur&eon

  • 7/25/2019 Shared Decision Making in Patients With

    9/20

    Bo*h &rou$s re$or*e( *heir knowle(&e an(s*a&e in (ecision akin& an( *heir

    *rea*en* choice, sa*isfac*ion, an(counica*ion wi*h *heir sur&eon.!ur&eons re$or*e( *he a$$ro$ria*eness of

    $a*ien* ues*ions an( *heir sa*isfac*ionwi*h *he visi*.

  • 7/25/2019 Shared Decision Making in Patients With

    10/20

    Po*en*ial su-3ec*s were i(en*ifie( froclinic sche(ules an( were calle( *o assess

    *heir neli&i-ili*y an( *o o-*ain ver-alconsen*.1hen $a*ien*s cae for *heir clinic visi*,

    wri**en consen* was o-*aine(.

  • 7/25/2019 Shared Decision Making in Patients With

    11/20

    Pa*ien*s were eli&i-le for *he s*u(y if /0 *hey ha( a $riary (ia&nosis of os*eoar*hri*is

    of *he hi$ or knee,0 firs* *ie seein& an or*ho$ae(ic sur&eon for*his $ro-le, an(

    0 *hey ha( no his*ory of a lower2e%*rei*y 3oin*

    ar*hro$las*y.

  • 7/25/2019 Shared Decision Making in Patients With

    12/20

    Pa*ien*s were ineli&i-le if /0 *hey coul( no* rea( or s$eak +n&lish or

    0 ha( a $revious a$$oin*en* wi*h ano*heror*ho$ae(ic sur&eon for evalua*ion of *hear*hri*ic hi$ or knee.

  • 7/25/2019 Shared Decision Making in Patients With

    13/20

    Results

    !i&nifican*ly ore $a*ien*s in *hein*erven*ion &rou$ 4=>?7 reache( an

    infore( (ecision (urin& *he firs* visi*co$are( wi*h *he con*rol &rou$ 4@@?7 4$ :.::=7.

  • 7/25/2019 Shared Decision Making in Patients With

    14/20

    "he in*erven*ion &rou$ re$or*e( hi&herconfi(ence in knowin& wha* ues*ions *o

    ask *heir (oc*or 4$ :.::@7.Af*er *he a$$oin*en*, *here was no

    si&nifican* (ifference -e*ween &rou$s in*he $ercen*a&e of $a*ien*s choosin&sur&ery

    4$ :.>7.

  • 7/25/2019 Shared Decision Making in Patients With

    15/20

    !ur&eons ra*e( *he nu-er an(a$$ro$ria*eness of $a*ien* ues*ions

    hi&her in *he in*erven*ion &rou$ 4$ :.:::;7, re$or*e( hi&her sa*isfac*ion wi*h*he efficiency of *he in*erven*ion &rou$visi*s 4$ :.:::;7, an( were oresa*isfie( overall wi*h *he in*erven*ion&rou$ visi*s 4$ :.:::;7.

  • 7/25/2019 Shared Decision Making in Patients With

    16/20

  • 7/25/2019 Shared Decision Making in Patients With

    17/20

  • 7/25/2019 Shared Decision Making in Patients With

    18/20

    Conclusions

    Decision an( counica*ion ai(s use( inor*ho$ae(ic $rac*ice ha( -enefi*s for -o*h

    $a*ien*s an( sur&eons."hese fin(in&s coul( -e i$or*an* in

    facili*a*in& a(o$*ion of share( (ecision2akin& *ools in*o rou*ine or*ho$ae(ic$rac*ice.

  • 7/25/2019 Shared Decision Making in Patients With

    19/20

    )e'el of *'idence

    "hera$eu*ic evel ). !ee )ns*ruc*ions forAu*hors for a co$le*e (escri$*ion of

    levels of evi(ence.

  • 7/25/2019 Shared Decision Making in Patients With

    20/20

    TH+,K-O.