Top Banner
Session 09-05: Effectively strengthening indigenous rights HISTORIC TENURE CERTAINTY PROJECT – A TOOL FOR SHARING THE KNOWLEDGE, SHARING THE FUTURE RAELENE WEBB QC President, National Native Title Tribunal Australia [email protected] Prepared for presentation at the “2015 WORLD BANK CONFERENCE ON LAND AND POVERTY” The World Bank – Washington DC, March 23-27, 2015
25

Session 09-05: Effectively strengthening indigenous rights HISTORIC TENURE CERTAINTY PROJECT – A TOOL FOR SHARING THE KNOWLEDGE, SHARING THE FUTURE RAELENE.

Dec 16, 2015

Download

Documents

Anne Horton
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Session 09-05: Effectively strengthening indigenous rights HISTORIC TENURE CERTAINTY PROJECT – A TOOL FOR SHARING THE KNOWLEDGE, SHARING THE FUTURE RAELENE.

Session 09-05: Effectively strengthening indigenous rights 

HISTORIC TENURE CERTAINTY PROJECT – A TOOL FOR SHARING THE KNOWLEDGE, SHARING THE FUTURE

RAELENE WEBB QCPresident, National Native Title Tribunal

[email protected]

Prepared for presentation at the “2015 WORLD BANK CONFERENCE ON LAND AND POVERTY”

The World Bank – Washington DC, March 23-27, 2015

Page 2: Session 09-05: Effectively strengthening indigenous rights HISTORIC TENURE CERTAINTY PROJECT – A TOOL FOR SHARING THE KNOWLEDGE, SHARING THE FUTURE RAELENE.

 

Page 3: Session 09-05: Effectively strengthening indigenous rights HISTORIC TENURE CERTAINTY PROJECT – A TOOL FOR SHARING THE KNOWLEDGE, SHARING THE FUTURE RAELENE.
Page 4: Session 09-05: Effectively strengthening indigenous rights HISTORIC TENURE CERTAINTY PROJECT – A TOOL FOR SHARING THE KNOWLEDGE, SHARING THE FUTURE RAELENE.
Page 5: Session 09-05: Effectively strengthening indigenous rights HISTORIC TENURE CERTAINTY PROJECT – A TOOL FOR SHARING THE KNOWLEDGE, SHARING THE FUTURE RAELENE.

Pre 1788

Page 6: Session 09-05: Effectively strengthening indigenous rights HISTORIC TENURE CERTAINTY PROJECT – A TOOL FOR SHARING THE KNOWLEDGE, SHARING THE FUTURE RAELENE.

1788

Page 7: Session 09-05: Effectively strengthening indigenous rights HISTORIC TENURE CERTAINTY PROJECT – A TOOL FOR SHARING THE KNOWLEDGE, SHARING THE FUTURE RAELENE.

1825

Page 8: Session 09-05: Effectively strengthening indigenous rights HISTORIC TENURE CERTAINTY PROJECT – A TOOL FOR SHARING THE KNOWLEDGE, SHARING THE FUTURE RAELENE.

1829

Page 9: Session 09-05: Effectively strengthening indigenous rights HISTORIC TENURE CERTAINTY PROJECT – A TOOL FOR SHARING THE KNOWLEDGE, SHARING THE FUTURE RAELENE.

1993

Page 10: Session 09-05: Effectively strengthening indigenous rights HISTORIC TENURE CERTAINTY PROJECT – A TOOL FOR SHARING THE KNOWLEDGE, SHARING THE FUTURE RAELENE.

19932015

Page 11: Session 09-05: Effectively strengthening indigenous rights HISTORIC TENURE CERTAINTY PROJECT – A TOOL FOR SHARING THE KNOWLEDGE, SHARING THE FUTURE RAELENE.

Native Title Act 1993 (Cth)s 223(1)

The expression native title or native title rights and interests means the communal, group or individual rights and interests of Aboriginal peoples or Torres Strait Islanders in relation to land or waters, where:

(a) the rights and interests are possessed under the traditional laws acknowledged, and the traditional customs observed, by the Aboriginal peoples or Torres Strait Islanders; and

(b) the Aboriginal peoples or Torres Strait Islanders, by those laws and customs, have a connection with the land or waters; and

(c) the rights and interests are recognised by the common law of Australia.

Page 12: Session 09-05: Effectively strengthening indigenous rights HISTORIC TENURE CERTAINTY PROJECT – A TOOL FOR SHARING THE KNOWLEDGE, SHARING THE FUTURE RAELENE.

Traditional Connection

Under the traditional laws and customs of the group of indigenous people claiming native title, are their claimed rights and interests based on their traditional connection to the claimed area? 

Page 13: Session 09-05: Effectively strengthening indigenous rights HISTORIC TENURE CERTAINTY PROJECT – A TOOL FOR SHARING THE KNOWLEDGE, SHARING THE FUTURE RAELENE.

Extinguishment

Is “recognition” refused because of actions the government has taken, or allowed others to do, over a particular areas that are inconsistent with native title? 

Page 14: Session 09-05: Effectively strengthening indigenous rights HISTORIC TENURE CERTAINTY PROJECT – A TOOL FOR SHARING THE KNOWLEDGE, SHARING THE FUTURE RAELENE.

Prohibition on making native title claims

Page 15: Session 09-05: Effectively strengthening indigenous rights HISTORIC TENURE CERTAINTY PROJECT – A TOOL FOR SHARING THE KNOWLEDGE, SHARING THE FUTURE RAELENE.

31 December 2014

263 native title determinations made

• 33 litigated

• 230 by agreement 

Page 16: Session 09-05: Effectively strengthening indigenous rights HISTORIC TENURE CERTAINTY PROJECT – A TOOL FOR SHARING THE KNOWLEDGE, SHARING THE FUTURE RAELENE.
Page 17: Session 09-05: Effectively strengthening indigenous rights HISTORIC TENURE CERTAINTY PROJECT – A TOOL FOR SHARING THE KNOWLEDGE, SHARING THE FUTURE RAELENE.

31 December 2014

328 Current claimant applications • < 5 years - 115 (35%) 

• 5-10 years - 40 (12%) 

• 10 - 15 years - 105 (32%) 

• > 15 years - 68 (21%)

Page 18: Session 09-05: Effectively strengthening indigenous rights HISTORIC TENURE CERTAINTY PROJECT – A TOOL FOR SHARING THE KNOWLEDGE, SHARING THE FUTURE RAELENE.

19932015

Page 19: Session 09-05: Effectively strengthening indigenous rights HISTORIC TENURE CERTAINTY PROJECT – A TOOL FOR SHARING THE KNOWLEDGE, SHARING THE FUTURE RAELENE.

Potential native title extinguishment by current tenure type

Page 20: Session 09-05: Effectively strengthening indigenous rights HISTORIC TENURE CERTAINTY PROJECT – A TOOL FOR SHARING THE KNOWLEDGE, SHARING THE FUTURE RAELENE.

Kooma People #4 

Page 21: Session 09-05: Effectively strengthening indigenous rights HISTORIC TENURE CERTAINTY PROJECT – A TOOL FOR SHARING THE KNOWLEDGE, SHARING THE FUTURE RAELENE.

  

Page 22: Session 09-05: Effectively strengthening indigenous rights HISTORIC TENURE CERTAINTY PROJECT – A TOOL FOR SHARING THE KNOWLEDGE, SHARING THE FUTURE RAELENE.

Current Titles

Meeting Place(Web based GIS)

Property boundaries

Digital CadastralDatabases

Historical TenureInstruments

Historical TenureDatabases

Stories(Content Providers)

Conversations(Collaboration Services)

Knowledge(Decision Products)

Agreements

Project focus‘Gather stories to 

support Agreements’

Page 23: Session 09-05: Effectively strengthening indigenous rights HISTORIC TENURE CERTAINTY PROJECT – A TOOL FOR SHARING THE KNOWLEDGE, SHARING THE FUTURE RAELENE.

 

Page 24: Session 09-05: Effectively strengthening indigenous rights HISTORIC TENURE CERTAINTY PROJECT – A TOOL FOR SHARING THE KNOWLEDGE, SHARING THE FUTURE RAELENE.

Peter Yu

A series of maps based on traditional indigenous knowledge, Western science and official data would be overlaid as comprehensive database of cultural, social, historical and environmental evidence that could form an important element of a postcolonial relationship. These maps should be fundamental to future regional planning and development methodologies. 

Page 25: Session 09-05: Effectively strengthening indigenous rights HISTORIC TENURE CERTAINTY PROJECT – A TOOL FOR SHARING THE KNOWLEDGE, SHARING THE FUTURE RAELENE.