Page 1
Senate
Record of Committee Proceedings
Committee on Workforce Development, Forestry, Mining, and
Revenue
Senate Bill 1 Relating to: regulation of ferrous metallic mining and related activities,
procedures for obtaining approvals from the Department of Natural Resources for
the construction of utility facilities, making an appropriation, and providing
penalties. By Senators Tiffany, Gudex, Darling, Farrow, Kedzie, Lasee, Lazich, Leibham
and Vukmir; cosponsored by Representatives Suder, Honadel, Williams, August,
Ballweg, Bernier, Bies, Born, Craig, Czaja, Endsley, Hutton, Jacque, Jagler,
Kapenga, Kaufert, Kerkman, Kestell, Kleefisch, Klenke, Knodl, Knudson,
Kooyenga, Kramer, Kuglitsch, T. Larson, LeMahieu, Loudenbeck, Murphy,
Murtha, Nass, Nygren, A. Ott, J. Ott, Petersen, Petryk, Pridemore, Ripp,
Sanfelippo, Schraa, Severson, Spiros, Steineke, Stone, Strachota, Stroebel,
Swearingen, Tauchen, Thiesfeldt, Tittl, Vos, Weatherston and Weininger.
January 18, 02013 Referred to Committee on Workforce Development, Forestry,
Mining, and Revenue
January 23, 2013 Public Hearing Held
Present: (5) Senator Tiffany; Senators Darling, Grothman,
Jauch and Lehman. Absent: (0) None.
Excused: (0) None.
Appearances For
Tom Tiffany - Senator
Scott Suder - Representative
Mark Honadel - Representative
Bill Williams - Gogebic Taconite
Timothy Myers - Gogebic Taconite
Bob Seitz - Gogebic Taconite
Gary Pelkda -
Kathleen Walesewicz -
Chris Kelly -
Mark Saari -
Kourtney Zacharias -
Cameron Rowe -
Rebekah Harrington -
Chris Patritto - Hurley School District
Page 2
Wayne Nasi -
Lelsie Kolesar - Iron County Local Mining Impact
Commision
Steven Ewing -
Ronda Olkonen -
Scott Manley - WI Manufacturers and Commerce
Larry Youngs -
John Sendra -
James Miller -
Shirl LaBrarre -
Jeff Nass -
Annette Olson - United Sportsmen of WI
Richard Galardo -
Leonard Sheard -
John Wiener -
Dan Allen -
E Ronald Miller -
Pat Nelson -
Brent Gardner - National Rifle Association
Pat Nelson -
Ross Peterson -
Robert Walesewicz -
Ed Brandis -
Steve Binz -
Ted Bingham -
Joseph Koback - Safari Club International, Wisconsin Bear
Hunters
Rob Stafsholt -
Ron Bihansky -
Appearances Against
Hallis Mailen - U.S. Army Chemical Corps. Retired
Don Roberts -
Betty Kerr -
Michael Isham - Lac Countre Drielles Chippewa
Carl Doerselt - Ashland City Council
Nick Milroy - Representative
George Meyer - Wisconsin Wildlife Federation
Chuck Matyska - Wisconsin Wildlife Federation
Erik Schyuinck - ATWA
Eric Chapman - Lac du Flambeau Tribal Council
Brooks Big John - Lac du Flambeau Tribal Council
Mark Gokee -
Eric Chapman - Lac du Flambeau Tribe
Page 3
Dennis Grzezinski - Bad River Band of Lake Superior
Marcia Bjornernd - Lawrence University - Geology Dept.
Mike Wiggins - Bad River Triber
Rae Maday - Bad River Tribe
Marvin DeFoe - Red Cliff Tribe
George Pnewago -
Bryan Bainbridge - Red Cliff Tribe
Tyler Thorp -
Paul DeMain - LCO Mining Impact Committee
Alan Van Raalte -
Frank Connors - Bad River Tribe
Justus Grunow -
Pete Rasmussen -
Mary Lou Salewater -
Gloria Rodriguez - Bad River Tribe
Beatrice Bender - Bad River Tribe
Frank Koehn - Save the Water's Edge
John Patrick -
Anthony Corbine - Red Cliff Band of Lake Superior
Chippewa
Katrina Shankland - Representative
Kaeleen Ringberg -
Scott Griffiths -
Alexander Waters -
MacKenzie Hogfeldt -
Allie Raven - Bad River Ojibwa
Kristy Heidenreich -
Andrew Bottew -
Lillian Joshnik-Tanquist -
Erika Zocher -
Louise Ladenthin -
Stacy Craig -
LeeAra Clark -
Luanne Wiggins - Bad River Tribe
Kevin Etlicher -
Kelly Westlund -
Charles Ortman -
Sarsh Martines -
Madelyn Wiggins -
Barbara With -
Margaret Koosmann -
Eric Iversen -
Jill Hartlev -
Michael Wurl-Koth -
Page 4
John Kruemer - League of Conservation Voters
Joan Arnold -
George Guyant -
Edie Ehlert - Crawford Stewardship Project
Victoria McMurray -
Celeste Lourigan -
James Zorn - Great Lakes Indian Fish and Wildlife
Commission
Diana Miller - Menominee Nation
Sharon Davis -
Appearances for Information Only
Ann Coakley - WI Department of Natural Resources
Russ Rasmusson - WI Department of Natural Resources
Peter Barca - Representative
Robert Marn - Ho-Chunk Nation
Robecca Graser - U.S. Army of Corps. Engineers
John Cannon -
Registrations For
Terry McGowan - #139 Operating Engineers
Carl Schoettel - Vice President WI Bear Hunters
Terry Hayden - WI Pipe Trades Association
Bill Jaeck -
Andy Pantzlaff - Maribel Sportsman Club
Peter Gilbert -
Peter Sartori -
Steven J. Wekenbach -
Michael Besonen -
Orville Seymer - CRG Network
William D. Weitzel -
Ramona Weakland-Warden -
Sara Lammers -
Jayne Gohr -
Tami Rongstad -
Robert Lammers -
Barbara Dillow -
Meg Ellefson -
Monica Suemnicht -
Susan Cain -
Robert Fassbender - WI Economic Development Association
Pat Osborne - Aggregate Producers of Wisconsin
Chris Martinson - Wolf River Patriots
Deborah Ellefson -
Page 5
John Danneker -
Richard Wood -
Nancy Dannecker -
Tom Braesch -
Shannon Ehn -
Rita Sharp -
Maude Dahlberg -
Jim Coursolle - Hartland Communications, Group LLC
Janna Yderstad -
Jim Maerzke -
Teresa Maerzke -
Karen Braesch -
David Zeman -
Don Monson -
Marc Bialeck -
Ed LaBarre -
Bill Guiliani -
Liz Guiliani -
Keith Best -
Pete Hanson -
Don Curogn -
Logan Olkonen -
Scott Maues - USW
Kathy Maues - USW
Kelly Klein -
Carri Hewitt -
Brad D - Fabco Caterpillar
Dan DeVault - Fabco
Robert Morrenti -
Doug Dickrell Jr. -
Curtis Lusaa - 139
Randall Schultz -
Dave Masko - Labors 268 Eau Claire
Gary Elleuman -
Steve Baas - MMAC
Pat Nelson -
Michael Saari -
Jeff Swartz -
Mitch Koski -
Stacy Ofstad - Iron Co. EMT Saxon FD
John Wischhuff -
Doug Parrott - WI Petroleum Marketers and Convenience
Store Assoc.
James Schildbach -
Page 6
Nick G - Midwest Food Processors Assoc
Andy Peterson - Fabco, Caterpillar
Bruce Johnson - Fabco Equip Inc
Leah Vukmir - Sen
Pat Finnegan -
Taylor McFadden -
David Luepke -
Brian Dake - WI independent Businesses
Jack Dillon -
Lorri Pickens -
Elizabeth Lewandowski -
Lana Raffensperger -
Nancy Milholland -
Amy Loudenbeck - Rep.
Robert Dezotell -
Tim McFadden -
Vernon Fernholz - AFP
Iva Fernholz -
Brad Boycks - WBA
Katy Loucks -
Elizabeth Raff -
Jim Boullion - AGC of WI
Mark Reihl - WI State Council of Carpenters
Robert Dennik - VJS Construction
Todd Stuart - WI Industrial Energy Group
Kevin Traas - Wi Transportation Builders Assn
Joe Handrick -
Robert Ziccarelli - AFP
Anthony Piccone -
Dianne Slater -
Bill McCoshen - Mechanical Contractors Assoc of WI
Registrations Against
Jon Richards - Representative
James O'Neill -
Deborah Gibbons -
Peter Slaby -
Ryan Raschke -
Thomas Wik Sr -
William Wasser -
Kittie Murray -
Arthur Kohl-Riggs -
Nathaniel Haack -
Brett Hulsey - State Representative
Page 7
Dona Yahola -
Wenona Morningstar Gardner -
Janice Rouse -
Sharon Gulseth -
Greg Gordon -
Regina Westemeier -
Gregory Francis Bird -
Judy Skog -
Elaine Swanson - PEPL of Rosendale
Mike Smith -
Kenneth Suchy -
Ben Yahola -
Mark Fuller -
Dan Collins -
Ethan Plursek -
William Fetty -
Wajid Jenkins -
Dennis Lowder -
Theresa Lowder -
Nancy Schmelzer - Raging Grannies
Sharon Nash - Raging Grannies
Gerree Martine - Raging Grannies
Deborah Lofgren - Raging Grannies
Paula Benton - Raging Grannies
John Patterson -
Thor Backus -
Ann E. Fleischh -
Carl Glassford -
Susan Johnson -
James Congdon -
Christian Hansen -
Karen Tuerk -
Brian Delrue -
Zahner Zahner -
Anne Chacon -
Anita Nelson -
Susan Cohen -
Kevin Coleman -
Sierra Powers -
Rebecca Alwia - Raging Grannies
Bonnie Myhre -
David Blouin - Sierra Club
Tom O'Grady -
Kevin Moll -
Page 8
OmaVic McMurray -
Deborah Mulligan -
Frank Gloss -
Carl Sinderbrand -
Lucy Gibson -
Clyde Winter -
Bruce Noble -
Scott Wehaufer -
Mary Maronek -
Liz Bruno -
Thistle Pettersen -
Amy Mondloch - Save the Waters Edge
Jessica St. John -
Sarah Rogers -
Melissa Smith -
Lilah Myhre -
Kristi Hart -
David Cole -
Erik Pettersen -
Carl Glassford -
June Fox -
Elizabeth Scudder -
Patricia Loew -
Gordon Stevenson -
Jennifer Epps-Addison - Citizen Action of Wisconsin
Mike Wilder - African American Roundtable
Arlene Kanno -
Scott Michalak -
Jayme Montgomery Baker -
John Barnes - Prairie Spirit Land Trust
Daniel Holzman -
Will Sandetrom - Dr.
Jessica Roulette -
Patricia Barwig -
Terry Parisi -
Nicole Spoon -
Melissa Warner - Sierra Club
Jay Warner -
Ben Jones -
Tim White -
Deb Biechler -
Joseph Skulan -
Andrea Iravani -
Jesse Gurman -
Page 9
John Laun -
Carl Sack -
Will Stahl - Sierra Club
Nathan Beck -
Curt Meine -
Elizabeth Lyons -
Eve Emshwiller -
Katy Reeder -
John Lane Hall -
Joe Brusky -
Patricia Hammel - National Lawyers Guild Madison
Edward Kuharski -
Jennifer Giegerich - WI League of Conservation Voters
Helen Sarakinos - River Alliance of WI
Amber Meyer Smith - Clean Wisconsin
Erin O'Brien - WI Wetlands Association
George Mickelson -
David Rieckmann -
David Heaster -
Lori Compass - Wisconsin Business Alliance
Alice Thompson -
Elizabeth Doyle -
Angela Thorp -
Kathleen Vincent -
Christina DeSpears -
Tom Kriegl -
Esie Leoso-Corbine -
Aurora Conley - Bad River
Linda Wyeth -
Melissa Engels-Lewis -
Wayne Olson -
Craig Butler -
David Tremble -
Dana Churness -
John Kramer -
Randy O'Connell -
Chuck Matyska - WI Wildlife Federation
John Herbst -
Robin Amado -
Susan Power -
Jefren Olsen -
Jason Kemper -
Evan Hurley -
Ben Ratliffe - AFSCME Local 60
Page 10
Ariel Snowder-Gold -
Christie Elizabeth Mathee -
Michael DeMain - LCO Tribe
Dan Wallace -
Rob Jach -
Laura Smith -
Kyle Bartowitz -
Richard Ruecking -
Lily Johnson -
Nora Jungbluth -
Joseph D. Friesen -
Steve Brooks -
Tom Thrall - Southern WI Trout Unlimited
Lance Green -
Natalie Byrne -
Amanda Zaremba -
Steve Reinhardt -
Daniel Mortensen -
Amanda Goetsch -
William Albright -
Hans Larsen -
Jenifer Thompson -
Cheryl Boyd -
Sherri Jones -
William Harrison -
Benjamin Van Thiel -
Sharon Stewart -
Stephen Arnold - Ald.
Shahla Werner -
Dan Hedtcke -
Alison Werner -
Hana Marino -
Austin Pethan -
Mariah Clark -
Elizabeth Ward -
Peter Ostlind -
John Bayley -
Lars Prip -
Duncan Menelly -
William Schultheis -
Katy Reeder -
Thomas Niebler -
Taylor McCabe-Juhnke -
James Mueller -
Page 11
Robert Liska -
Kennedy Rubert-Nason -
Mary Maradik -
Mitchell Nussbaum -
Rebecca Denenne -
John Enk - NAOMI
Linda Atkins - Accola Family Farms LLC
Jane Jiumaleh -
Barbara Smith -
Martha Eberle -
Mary M. Kolar -
Chris Hoffman -
Angela Walker - ATU Local 998
David Kriesman -
Frank Polizzi - Mulberry Pottery
Scott Foval - People for the American Way
Kayne Neigherbauer -
David J. Eagan -
Justin Helickson -
Thomas D. Marks -
Heather Gates -
Kevin W. Corrado -
Jacob Immel - Clean Wisconsin
Scott Cardiff -
Steven Neary -
Joe Brusky -
Harriet Rowan -
Jodi Nachtwey -
Rachel Nachtwey -
Carolyn Thanig -
Pavel B -
M Daggett -
Dan Ferber - Sierra Club
Sarah Elise Mathee -
Ryan P. Fay -
Mitchell Katt -
Sharon Anita Bocian -
Susan Hessel -
Sara Moore -
Sarah Foster -
Susan Graham -
Lea Zeise -
Jasmyni Dias -
Rebecca Haefner MD -
Page 12
Rebecca Ann Otte -
Brandon Barwick -
Jane Richard -
Jonathan Cooper -
Ryan Wherley -
Marena Kehl -
Elizabeth A. Tujon -
Anita Weier -
Kay Houston -
Daniel Trifone -
Larry Orr -
Nadine Wright -
Sara Roberts -
Tom Kuplic -
Louise Robbins -
Christine Taylor - State Rep.
Peppi Elder -
Linda Pluemer -
Sarah Hastings -
Melanie Foxcroft -
Tim Wong -
Stephen Burns -
Susan Nossal - Dr.
Brianna Fiene -
Justin Hughey -
Michelle Miller -
Christopher Wagner -
Rebecca Power -
Carrie Bohman -
Mark Felton -
John H Pope Jr -
Mark Redsten -
Daniel Cook -
Erica Case -
Debra Biechler -
Dawn Matlak -
Micah Kloppenburg -
Daniel Nordstrom -
Judy K. Olson -
Christina Hansen -
Sue Trace -
Scott Carraday -
Nathan Beck -
Julie Smith -
Page 13
Laurie Szpot -
Craig Spaulding -
Ron J. Konkol -
Lawrence J. Skupien -
Anjali Bhasin -
Kim Benich -
Michael Matheson -
Daina P Zemliauskas-Juozaicms -
John Peterson -
Jennifer Gilchrist-Walker -
Karen Meulendyke -
Robert Wemerehl -
Stacy Harbaugh -
Erin McMahon -
Lyudmila Yasko -
Tobin Manley -
Kevin Clark -
Ann Behrmann MD - Physicians for Social Responsibility &
Wisconsin Environmental Health Network
Jenny Hayes -
Veronica Hayes -
Abbey Davidson -
Carl Berglund -
Monica Vohmann MD -
Jeff Lunz -
Nicole Soulier -
Margo Ptacek -
Jennifer Lydon -
Melanie Kohls -
John Souther -
Cindy Breunig -
Leif Brottem -
Patricia Kelly -
James Daehn -
Camille Bernier -
Wyatt Allan - Bad River Tribal Member
Kim Wright -
Carson Main -
William Edward Grogan -
James MacDonald -
Collin Schwantes -
Mary Trainer -
Heidi Heller -
Peter Swift -
Page 14
Seth McElhinney -
Ron Schultz -
Helen Kitchel -
Karen Geszvair -
Joseph Michael Rausch -
Amanda Steagall -
Bambi Lynn Tischer -
Wil Blouin -
Jeffrey Ekola -
Elizabeth Ekola -
Rachel Byington -
Alita Tidelao -
Lisa Moline -
Ann E. Fleischli -
Linda Lehman -
Emily TenEyek -
Nancy Aten -
Liz Wessel - Sierra Club
Gary Werner - Partnership for the National Trails System
Janice Ketelle -
Craig Brandfass -
Laura Brown -
Timothy Riley -
Jayme Montgomery Baker -
Robert Block, MD -
Amanda White -
Bernie Schlafke -
Jane Jensen -
Louis Solomon -
Martha Florey -
Brad Palmer -
Kathleen Palmer -
Genie Ogden -
Michelle Nelson -
Karyn Rotker -
Hildy Feen -
Allan Goetsch -
Lil Pipping -
Thistle Pettersen -
Deborah Burns -
Regina Westemeier -
Amy Owen -
Adrian King -
Phiomena Kebec -
Page 15
Toni Good -
Mark Servertson -
Abbie Kurtz -
Melissa Sargent - State Rep.
Fred Schepartz -
Mark Fuller -
Nick DeMarsh -
Christine Renee Anderson -
Gregory Francis Bird -
Meg Turville-Heitz -
Denise McCutcheon-Cloud -
Michael Rodriguez -
Susan Broden -
Michael Von Schneidemesser -
Laura Priebe -
Suzanne Gore -
Peter Adamczak -
Victory Odwazny -
Clarence Royston -
Kathy Liske -
Jack Mussen - Wisconsin Wildlife Federation
Larry Vanderhoef - WI Wildlife Fed
Rick Lazarcyk - Wisconsin Wildlife Federation
Terry Ross -
Carolyn Brown - Wisconsin Wildlife Federation
Charlie Brown - Wisconsin Wildlife Federation
Norb Moes - Wisconsin Wildlife Federation
Russ Hitz - Wisconsin Wildlife Federation
Dean Borofka - WI Wildlife Fed
Larry Laehn - WI Wildlife Fed
Jim Huhn - WI Wildlife Fed
Tom Nissen - WI Wildlife Fed
Janet Batitista -
Dan Gries - WI Wildlife Fed
Dale Zaug - WI Wildlife Fed
Andy Lewandowski - WI Wildlife Fed
John Wagner - WI Wildlife Fed
George Borchert - WI Wildlife Fed
Betty Borchert - WI Wildlife Federation
Keith Pamperim - WI Wildlife Fed
John Wetzel - WI Wildlife Federation
Jeff Merryfield -
Carrie Scherpelz -
Mark Sethne -
Page 16
Melissa Malott -
Michael Berk -
Don Wyeth -
Caroline Greenwald -
Raymond Nashold -
Ann Knapstein -
Willa Schmidt -
Virginia Farwell Lwickey -
Lindsay Wood Davis - River Alliance of Wisconsin
Sara Blackthorne -
Robert Reuschlein -
Sarah Wilkins -
Kathryn Satewicz -
Nicole Hull -
Frankie Fuller -
Robert J. Bergman -
Susan Fey -
Dana Losse -
Stephanie Losse -
Trevor Irving -
Christine White -
Ian Anderson -
Dana Hanaman, Esq - Central Sands Water Action Coalition
Joanne Swartzberg -
Jeremy Ryan - Defending WI PAC
B Pierce -
Jo Garrett -
Sharon Gaskill -
Dennis Zuniga -
Erin Courtenay -
Karen Kinslay - NORML
Karen Matteno -
John Peck - Family Farm Defenders
Greg Kinsley - NORML
Ron Grassnoff -
Rick Hanson -
Donna Vukelich -
James Mankopf, PHD -
Deborah Magnuson -
Arhely Bermudez -
Erin Murphy - We Are Wisconsin
Elizabeth Day -
Sharon Snowder-Smith -
Christine McDonough -
Page 17
Siobhan Marks -
Ken Skog -
Amanda Wegner -
Chelsea Snowder-Smith -
Katherine Rasmussen -
Elizabeth Wheeler -
Joan Arnold -
Craig Butler -
William O'Brien -
Jayne Meyer - Dane County Conservation League
Sunshine Jones -
Rick Plonsky -
Jessica St. John -
Sarah Ralmanson -
Roger Springman -
Juliana Reimann -
Jenifer Horne -
Andrew M Allan -
Beth Drake -
Megan Syverson -
Pamela Kleiss - Physicians for Social Responsibility
Dee Ann Allen - Lac du Flambeau Tribe Member
June Fox -
Ronalee Monroe -
Catherine Parks Snider -
Judith Detert-Moriarty -
Thomas Thoresen -
Elisa Miller -
Erin Sievert -
Linda Horvath -
Joyce Ellwanger -
Martha Sauter -
Larry Wawronowicz -
Bryan Hoover -
Tom Robson -
Pam Robson -
Todd Ambs -
Kristine Harrison -
Cheryl Agen -
Karen Bassler -
Jim Firdman -
Bart Mungiv -
Whitney Steffen -
Carm Frank -
Page 18
VJ Link -
Therese Ahlers -
Dian Farsetta -
Sarah Manski -
Denise O'Meara - Wi League of Conservation Voters
Maria Powell - Midwest Environmental Justice Org
Jillian Clever -
Judy Miner -
Dave Schindele -
AMy Mauer -
Kelly Campbell -
Maggie Thomas -
Kathey Simmers -
Mary Devitt -
Paula Cooper -
Sharon Swiggum -
Denise Brown -
Andrea Irravarri -
Jeff Smith - Trout Unlimited
Theodore Cochrane -
Lori degayner -
Karen Pope - Sierra Club, Clean WI, LCV, LWVDC
Mike Monkce -
Colleen Leinberger -
Carly Snider - Midwest Enviromental Advocates
Mark Everson -
Dave Matteoni -
Chris Taylor - Rep.
Wendy Kloiber -
Rebecca Payne -
Staush Gruszynski - Wi League of Conservation Voters
Emigh Cannaday -
Janet Myhre -
Lilah Myhre -
Jerry Knuth - WWF
Glenna B - Grannies
Diane Smidt -
Lois Langenfeld -
Dan Fields -
Nancy Schmelzer -
Laura Campbell - Midwest Environmental Advocates
Kevin Maulson - Lac du Flambeau Tribe
Joe Schmitt -
Jerry Zwicky - Brown County Conservation Association
Page 19
Joan Widy - Brown County Conservation Association
Christine Morrissey -
Elizabeth Arant -
Elizabeth Diver - Lac Du Flambeau Tribe
Kurt Ellison -
Katherine Conley -
James Huhn - WWF
Olav Bjornerua -
Chelrea Johnson -
Jaes Bjorneruo -
Brad Geyer -
Jeff Johns - WLCV
Kristy Pfaffinger -
Kiel Simmons - WI League of Young Voters
Rosalynn Wolfe - League Of Younge Voters
Tracy Hames - WI Wetlands Assoc
Ada Deer -
Kenyetta Lewis - League of Young Voters E.F.
Ruben Santiesteban - Lac du Flambeau Tribal Council
Sarah Wagner -
Ed Jeannette -
Gary Glover -
Kathy Walsh -
Jeff Blume -
Omar Poler -
Matthew Kozlowski - Treasurer, Progressive Dane
Tia Nowack - Co-Chair Progressive Dane
David Fallow -
Martha Pincus -
Dave Hanson - Sen
Allissa Stutte - Morthland College
Hilary Carroll - Wi League of Conservation Voters
Josh Brown -
Evan Flom - Northland College
Michael Martin -
Shula Newago -
Destiny Mayotte - Bad River Tribe
Mishka Newago - Bad River Tribe
Vanesa Scott - Bad River Tribe
Ethern Peweshek -
Jade Livingston - Odanah
Janine Mayotte - Bad River Tribe
Alicia Mayotte - Bad River Tribe
Paul Lochner -
Page 20
Holly Smith - River Alliance
Lars Smith -
Eleen Hanneman -
Mary Miller -
J Miller -
Kathy Kane -
Lenore Lee -
Rebecca Freund -
Karen Etter Hale - Madison Audubon Society
Sharon Moon -
Randy Losse -
Juoy Sebranek -
Pat Sebranek -
Jim Rosenberg -
Kaye Lee -
William Gruber - FUW INC
Arvina Martin -
Katharine Odell -
Mark Young -
Mike Dietrich -
Pamela Ritger - Wi League of Conservation Voters
Jonathan Beers -
Deena BRazy -
Matt Dannenberg -
Angela West Blank - Wi League of Conservation Voters
Jacinda Tessmann -
Thomas Heiber-Cobb -
Kathie Walker - MICAH
Charles Hanson -
Kelly osborn -
Mary Lundquin -
Leonel Lopez -
David Lundquir -
Ed Blume - Midwest Energy Associates
Kelly Forman -
Pat Clemens - ATU Local 998
Ken Earl - Midwest Environmental Advocates
Sarah Williams - Midwest Environmental Advocates
R Fuitsch -
Scott Tate - ATU 998
Chad S. -
Mike Marhal -
Jeff Scott G. -
Kathi Zoern -
Page 21
Josie Lathop -
Susan Day -
Sevevin Swauson - Wi League of Conservation Voters
Marilyn Knuth -
Sandra Chessare -
Irene Temple -
Amanda Leipold -
Steve Drake -
Marcia Schenkel -
Denny Caneff -
Sheila Lenius -
Joanne Jacobsen -
Ryan Henke -
Diane Hesselbein - Rep
Andrew Knutson -
Gail Moede ROgall -
John Patterson -
Monka Blay -
Cecilia Leon -
Nathan Germain -
Santera Michels -
Carl Owen - DeForest Area Progressives
Anthony Pietsch -
Carol Pope -
Carol Enseki - Sierra Club
Cedric Carr -
Michael Noyce -
Francise Klien - Pirate Party Cooperative
Michael O'rourke -
Keith Crum -
Casey Egglestin - The nature conservancy
Luella Allen -
Zach Schuster -
Tamara Baustupesis - WLCV
Reid Haines -
Michelle Louis -
Joseph Minik -
Scott Van Egeren -
Jefferey Granby -
Jessica Banks -
James P. -
David Sanders - Southern WI Trout Unlimited
Kathy Albright -
Chris Deisingen -
Page 22
Sheila Kelly -
Marga Krumins -
John Alberts - St Croix Chippewa Tribe
John Coleman -
Terese Berceau - Rep
Cheryl Congdon -
Shirly Haidinger -
Cassandra Dixon -
Doreen Kuzent -
Sharon Vankealte -
Lawrence Landwehr -
Darcy Gustausson - Grassroots North Shore
Noah Siler - Westby
Harlene Edwards -
Norm Littlejohn -
Brian Crawford -
Krista Pleviak -
Torrance Scott -
Marissa DeGroot -
Danielle Dannenberg -
Esty Dihieo -
Favian McMurray -
Stephen Barlament -
David Livingston -
Miranda Delgado -
Cristian Gayton -
Sheridan Bearheart -
Christina DeSpears -
WEnema Wolf -
Thomas Hermann -
Diane Hermann -
Nick Kuhn -
Rachel Fish -
Finn Ryan -
Brynn Bemis -
Lauren Wojcik -
Kelsey Tracy -
Gerald Mconough -
Deborah Seiler -
Thomas Stolp -
Kerry Schumann -
Samantha Venne -
Wilson Seely -
Peter Ferguson -
Page 23
Kathleen Walters -
Angeline Hougas -
Anneke Mohr -
Emily Jones -
Tyler Hendrichs -
Aron Bibb - Madison
Claire Camaeron - Sierra Club
Dawt Chin -
Laura Smith -
Emily White -
Lara Carlson -
Christine Belleu Cirra -
Kristen Felten -
Megan Barros -
Acaua Latka -
Nicholas Utnhall - Rev
Stuart Utley -
Laura Boomsm -
Elizabeth Schrader -
Pauline Holmes -
Corban Liebherr -
Evan Melch -
Maggie Sepot -
Jared Sandlin -
Russell Novkov -
Tressie Kamp -
Girard Gorelick -
Michelle Lee -
Greg Lee -
Kristen Crowell -
Kathryn Walter -
Chris Clayton -
Faye Flesia -
Peter Owens -
Courtland White -
Kasandra Brown -
Katherine Loving -
Jessie Conaway - Nelson Inst UW Madison
Carolyn Welter -
Sean Griffin -
Sam Inleis - Clean WI
Jennifer Lynes -
Colleen Hayes -
Maria Denz -
Page 24
Michael Linter -
Registrations for Information Only
Irving Smith -
CJ Terrell -
Larry Young -
Linda Sundstrom -
Fred Olsen -
Roger Buffett -
February 06, 2013 Executive Session Held
Present: (5) Senator Tiffany; Senators Darling, Grothman,
Jauch and Lehman. Absent: (0) None. Excused: (0) None.
Moved by Senator Darling, seconded by Senator Grothman that
Senate Substitute Amendment 1 be recommended for adoption.
Ayes: (2) Senators Jauch and Lehman.
Noes: (3) Senator Tiffany; Senators Darling and
Grothman.
SENATE SUBSTITUTE AMENDMENT 1 ADOPTION NOT
RECOMMENDED, Ayes 2, Noes 3
Moved by Senator Grothman, seconded by Senator Darling that
Senate Amendment 1 be recommended for adoption.
Ayes: (5) Senator Tiffany; Senators Darling,
Grothman, Jauch and Lehman.
Noes: (0) None.
SENATE AMENDMENT 1 ADOPTION RECOMMENDED,
Ayes 5, Noes 0
Moved by Senator Grothman, seconded by Senator Darling that
Senate Amendment 2 be recommended for adoption.
Ayes: (3) Senator Tiffany; Senators Darling and
Grothman.
Noes: (2) Senators Jauch and Lehman.
Page 25
SENATE AMENDMENT 2 ADOPTION RECOMMENDED,
Ayes 3, Noes 2
Moved by Senator Darling, seconded by Senator Grothman that
Senate Amendment 3 be recommended for adoption.
Ayes: (3) Senator Tiffany; Senators Darling and
Grothman.
Noes: (2) Senators Jauch and Lehman.
SENATE AMENDMENT 3 ADOPTION RECOMMENDED,
Ayes 3, Noes 2
Moved by Senator Darling, seconded by Senator Grothman that
Senate Amendment 4 be recommended for adoption.
Ayes: (3) Senator Tiffany; Senators Darling and
Grothman.
Noes: (2) Senators Jauch and Lehman.
SENATE AMENDMENT 4 ADOPTION RECOMMENDED,
Ayes 3, Noes 2
Moved by Senator Grothman, seconded by Senator Darling that
Senate Amendment 5 be recommended for adoption.
Ayes: (5) Senator Tiffany; Senators Darling,
Grothman, Jauch and Lehman.
Noes: (0) None.
SENATE AMENDMENT 5 ADOPTION RECOMMENDED,
Ayes 5, Noes 0
Moved by Senator Lehman, seconded by Senator Darling that
Senate Amendment 7 be recommended for adoption.
Ayes: (5) Senator Tiffany; Senators Darling,
Grothman, Jauch and Lehman.
Noes: (0) None.
SENATE AMENDMENT 7 ADOPTION RECOMMENDED,
Ayes 5, Noes 0
Moved by Senator Grothman, seconded by Senator Darling that
Senate Amendment 6 be recommended for adoption.
Page 26
Ayes: (3) Senator Tiffany; Senators Darling and
Grothman.
Noes: (2) Senators Jauch and Lehman.
SENATE AMENDMENT 6 ADOPTION RECOMMENDED,
Ayes 3, Noes 2
Moved by Senator Darling, seconded by Senator Grothman that
Senate Amendment 8 be recommended for adoption.
Ayes: (4) Senator Tiffany; Senators Darling,
Grothman and Lehman.
Noes: (1) Senator Jauch.
SENATE AMENDMENT 8 ADOPTION RECOMMENDED,
Ayes 4, Noes 1
Moved by Senator Darling, seconded by Senator Grothman that
Senate Amendment 9 be recommended for adoption.
Ayes: (3) Senator Tiffany; Senators Darling and
Grothman.
Noes: (2) Senators Jauch and Lehman.
SENATE AMENDMENT 9 ADOPTION RECOMMENDED,
Ayes 3, Noes 2
Moved by Senator Darling, seconded by Senator Grothman that
Senate Amendment 10 be recommended for adoption.
Ayes: (3) Senator Tiffany; Senators Darling and
Grothman.
Noes: (2) Senators Jauch and Lehman.
SENATE AMENDMENT 10 ADOPTION RECOMMENDED,
Ayes 3, Noes 2
Moved by Senator Grothman, seconded by Senator Darling that
Senate Amendment 11 be recommended for adoption.
Ayes: (3) Senator Tiffany; Senators Darling and
Grothman.
Noes: (2) Senators Jauch and Lehman.
Page 27
SENATE AMENDMENT 11 ADOPTION RECOMMENDED,
Ayes 3, Noes 2
Moved by Senator Jauch, seconded by Senator Lehman that
Senate Amendment 12 be recommended for adoption.
Ayes: (2) Senators Jauch and Lehman.
Noes: (3) Senator Tiffany; Senators Darling and
Grothman.
SENATE AMENDMENT 12 ADOPTION NOT
RECOMMENDED, Ayes 2, Noes 3
Moved by Senator Lehman, seconded by Senator Jauch that
Senate Amendment 13 be recommended for adoption.
Ayes: (2) Senators Jauch and Lehman.
Noes: (3) Senator Tiffany; Senators Darling and
Grothman.
SENATE AMENDMENT 13 ADOPTION NOT
RECOMMENDED, Ayes 2, Noes 3
Moved by Senator Lehman, seconded by Senator Jauch that
Senate Amendment 14 be recommended for adoption.
Ayes: (2) Senators Jauch and Lehman.
Noes: (3) Senator Tiffany; Senators Darling and
Grothman.
SENATE AMENDMENT 14 ADOPTION NOT
RECOMMENDED, Ayes 2, Noes 3
Moved by Senator Jauch, seconded by Senator Lehman that
Senate Amendment 16 be recommended for adoption.
Ayes: (2) Senators Jauch and Lehman.
Noes: (3) Senator Tiffany; Senators Darling and
Grothman.
SENATE AMENDMENT 16 ADOPTION NOT
RECOMMENDED, Ayes 2, Noes 3
Moved by Senator Lehman, seconded by Senator Jauch that
Senate Amendment 15 be recommended for adoption.
Page 28
Ayes: (2) Senators Jauch and Lehman.
Noes: (3) Senator Tiffany; Senators Darling and
Grothman.
SENATE AMENDMENT 15 ADOPTION NOT
RECOMMENDED, Ayes 2, Noes 3
Moved by Senator Grothman, seconded by Senator Darling that
Senate Bill 1 be recommended for passage as amended.
Ayes: (3) Senator Tiffany; Senators Darling and
Grothman.
Noes: (2) Senators Jauch and Lehman.
PASSAGE AS AMENDED RECOMMENDED, Ayes 3, Noes 2
______________________________
Eric Searing Committee Clerk