ZEF Zentrum für Entwicklungsforschung Center for Development Research University of Bonn Fabian Scholtes: On Moral Values and Solar Panels: Moral knowledge in technology-based development – STEPS, Oct. 31, 2008 Outline Fabian Scholtes, Centre for Development Research, Bonn Moral values and Solar Panels: moral knowledge in technology-based development 1. Introduction: why look at the morality- technology nexus 2. Observations: development and the practice of moral norms and values 3. Moral knowledge: a concept for empirical research 4. The moral facet of solar panels
14
Embed
Seminar: Fabian Scholtes on moral knowledge in technology-based development
Fabian Scholtes, Centre for Development Research, Bonn gives a STEPS Centre seminar entitled Moral values and Solar Panels: moral knowledge in technology-based development For more information see: http://www.steps-centre.org/events/stepsseminars.html
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
ZEFZentrum für EntwicklungsforschungCenter for Development ResearchUniversity of Bonn
Fabian Scholtes: On Moral Values and Solar Panels: Moral knowledge in technology-based development – STEPS, Oct. 31, 2008
Outline
Fabian Scholtes, Centre for Development Research, Bonn
Moral values and Solar Panels:
moral knowledge in technology-based development
1. Introduction: why look at the morality-technology nexus
2. Observations: development and the practice of moral norms and values
3. Moral knowledge: a concept for empirical research
4. The moral facet of solar panels
ZEFZentrum für EntwicklungsforschungCenter for Development ResearchUniversity of Bonn
Fabian Scholtes: On Moral Values and Solar Panels: Moral knowledge in technology-based development – STEPS, Oct. 31, 2008
Background
General objective: understand better how micro interaction works in development practice
• Focus 1: moral values as ubiquitous but ambivalent aspect in a moral-political field
• Focus 2: technology-based development – renewable energy technologies (RETs)
• Focus 3: hinterland of Northeast Brazil – the poorhouse in a regional superpower
• Focus 4: local practices around the socio-cultural installation and integration of tangible technological systems
Link to STEPS: the S/sustainability of RETs
ZEFZentrum für EntwicklungsforschungCenter for Development ResearchUniversity of Bonn
Fabian Scholtes: On Moral Values and Solar Panels: Moral knowledge in technology-based development – STEPS, Oct. 31, 2008
The morality/technology nexus
Insights from STS
• The ‚morality‘ of a weighty hotelroom key and a fast-closing door-spring: pre-scription and ethics delegated to things
• Socio-cultural life-cycle of technological devices/systems:
– from design to use and re-configuration
– co-constructions of/according to purposes and meanings
• The morality of green technology: ‚morality made durable, and to be installed durably‘ – but subject to life-cycle
=> nexus for this research: ambivalence of ‚good technology‘ as a materialisation of the ambivalence of ‚development‘
ZEFZentrum für EntwicklungsforschungCenter for Development ResearchUniversity of Bonn
Fabian Scholtes: On Moral Values and Solar Panels: Moral knowledge in technology-based development – STEPS, Oct. 31, 2008
Development and morality
Assumptions
• Moral: oughts/obligations, as related to (interaction with) others => formal, analytical, external concept
• Practice of moral norms/values vs. moral practice
‘Evidence’ from the literature: strands of ambivalence– Undermining/instrumentalising e.g. ‘participation’
– Moral discrepancies and struggle at social/cultural interfaces
– Brokerage/translation: moral boundary concepts
– Emergence of moral order from contestation and improvisation
– Discursive moral structure
– Limits to ‘orderly’ and moral practice
ZEFZentrum für EntwicklungsforschungCenter for Development ResearchUniversity of Bonn
Fabian Scholtes: On Moral Values and Solar Panels: Moral knowledge in technology-based development – STEPS, Oct. 31, 2008
The ‚technical code‘
• A classical double-bind of donor agencies‘ policy:
• Get them in the driver‘s seat (it‘s about their ownership/Sustainability)...
• ... to go the way we want them to (we have to account for success)
• Stage development as technical fix/support
• Hide donor‘s influence in technical rationality of means
• Maintain partner‘s autonomy
• Technical code as meta-code that enables negotiation (rather than depoliticisation)
=> Technical, but nevertheless moral (liberally ‚neutral‘) discourse as constructive repertory
ZEFZentrum für EntwicklungsforschungCenter for Development ResearchUniversity of Bonn
Fabian Scholtes: On Moral Values and Solar Panels: Moral knowledge in technology-based development – STEPS, Oct. 31, 2008
Facets of practice
• Moral values as social structure:
• restrictive (norms) and enabling (orientation) frame
• repertory: strategic and cooperative (boundary objects)
=> ontologically, separating these is wrong! It is dialectical analysis.
ZEFZentrum für EntwicklungsforschungCenter for Development ResearchUniversity of Bonn
Fabian Scholtes: On Moral Values and Solar Panels: Moral knowledge in technology-based development – STEPS, Oct. 31, 2008
Application
Where to find and research moral knowledge?
• ask for judgements/arguments; check moral codes
• analyse performance of ethics in ‚moral breakdowns‘
• observe management of daily dilemmas, conflicts etc.
• explicitly ethical set-ups (participation) vs. others
• document developments of practice and of the moral
status of
– a policy, a practice, a project
– an artefact or a socio-technological system ???
ZEFZentrum für EntwicklungsforschungCenter for Development ResearchUniversity of Bonn
Fabian Scholtes: On Moral Values and Solar Panels: Moral knowledge in technology-based development – STEPS, Oct. 31, 2008
Decentralised RETs: installed morality?
“Worldwide more than 1,6 billion people do not have access to electricity. 80 % of those live in rural areas. […] The provision of a stable and reliable access to electricity in rural areas […] becomes the foundation for development and progress. Electricity […] enables poor communities to take their destiny in their own hands.
[…] How can access to electricity and the fight against climate change be reconciled? Renewable energies are the solution. […]”