Top Banner
The world leader in serving science Common sources of errors in viscosity measurements Seminar Basics on Rheology
22

Seminar Basics on Rheology - personal.icv.csic.espersonal.icv.csic.es/reo2013/pdf/07_Measuring_Errors_e_20110614.pdfSeminar Basics on Rheology . 2 Overview Reasons for measuring errors

Jun 13, 2018

Download

Documents

buitruc
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Seminar Basics on Rheology - personal.icv.csic.espersonal.icv.csic.es/reo2013/pdf/07_Measuring_Errors_e_20110614.pdfSeminar Basics on Rheology . 2 Overview Reasons for measuring errors

The world leader in serving science The world leader in serving science

Common sources of errors in viscosity

measurements

Seminar

Basics on Rheology

Page 2: Seminar Basics on Rheology - personal.icv.csic.espersonal.icv.csic.es/reo2013/pdf/07_Measuring_Errors_e_20110614.pdfSeminar Basics on Rheology . 2 Overview Reasons for measuring errors

2

Overview

Reasons for measuring errors

- Instrument related

- Handling related

- Sample related

Page 3: Seminar Basics on Rheology - personal.icv.csic.espersonal.icv.csic.es/reo2013/pdf/07_Measuring_Errors_e_20110614.pdfSeminar Basics on Rheology . 2 Overview Reasons for measuring errors

3

Source of trouble

Handling Sample Instrument

Reasons

Torque measurement

r.p.m. measurement

Geometry factors (A, M)

Geometry

Choice of sensor

Test definition

Sample history

Sample loading

Gap setting

Temperature control

Zero point

Friction heat

Particles, trapped air

Solvent loss

Chemical reaction

Swelling / shrinking

Slipping

Elasticity

Taylor vorticis

Sedimentation

Page 4: Seminar Basics on Rheology - personal.icv.csic.espersonal.icv.csic.es/reo2013/pdf/07_Measuring_Errors_e_20110614.pdfSeminar Basics on Rheology . 2 Overview Reasons for measuring errors

4

Error sources DIN 53018

Viscosity = Geometry * Md/n

• Geometry +/- 0.5 % ABS

- Tolerance of the dimensions (diameter, radius, length, angle)

- Tolerance of positioning (excentricity, inclination, distances)

• Revolutions n +/- 0.5% ABS

- the speed is very accurately recorded with digital encoders (+/-1bit)

- speed is very constant and accurate with stepper motors

- tachometer generators are less accurate

-Torque M+/- 1% FSD or +/-0.5 % ABS

- +/- 1% for traditional instruments and +/- 0.5% for modern rheometer

- Full Scale Deflection leads to greater tolerance range

Page 5: Seminar Basics on Rheology - personal.icv.csic.espersonal.icv.csic.es/reo2013/pdf/07_Measuring_Errors_e_20110614.pdfSeminar Basics on Rheology . 2 Overview Reasons for measuring errors

5

Mess-Unsicherheit der Viskosität

400,0

420,0

440,0

460,0

480,0

500,0

520,0

540,0

560,0

1,E-01 1,E+00 1,E+01 1,E+02 1,E+03 1,E+04

Shear rate (1/s)

Vis

co

sit

y (

mP

as)

RS300 C35 /2 RV1 C35 /2

Soll- V isosity 500 mPa s +/ - 5% Error

ThermoHaake

RS 300 with C35/2 RV 1 with C35/2

Measuring uncertainty („error trumpet“)

Page 6: Seminar Basics on Rheology - personal.icv.csic.espersonal.icv.csic.es/reo2013/pdf/07_Measuring_Errors_e_20110614.pdfSeminar Basics on Rheology . 2 Overview Reasons for measuring errors

6

Air bearing friction

Air bearing friction

is proportional to:

• rotational speed

• viscosity of air

Remedy: friction correction

Air

Rotating

bearing shaft Measuring

gap

Thin liquids and low shear

Page 7: Seminar Basics on Rheology - personal.icv.csic.espersonal.icv.csic.es/reo2013/pdf/07_Measuring_Errors_e_20110614.pdfSeminar Basics on Rheology . 2 Overview Reasons for measuring errors

7

Position-dependent torque

The torque value is dependent on:

• excentricity of the rotating shaft

• tolerance of the bearing housing

Remedy: Micro Stress Control

Thin liquids und Low Shear

Page 8: Seminar Basics on Rheology - personal.icv.csic.espersonal.icv.csic.es/reo2013/pdf/07_Measuring_Errors_e_20110614.pdfSeminar Basics on Rheology . 2 Overview Reasons for measuring errors

8

Torsion of the shaft

If samples are very rigid and a

high torque is applied there is a

torsion shaft to be observed

Remedy: compensation of the

torsion

Torque

Shaft

Page 9: Seminar Basics on Rheology - personal.icv.csic.espersonal.icv.csic.es/reo2013/pdf/07_Measuring_Errors_e_20110614.pdfSeminar Basics on Rheology . 2 Overview Reasons for measuring errors

9

Inertia correction

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500

Á [1/s]

0

5

10

15

20

25

‚ [Pa]

HAAKE RheoWin Pro 2.6

Flow curve

Without inertia correction

With inertia correction

I_on_2‚ = f (Á)

I_off_2m‚ = f (Á)

Page 10: Seminar Basics on Rheology - personal.icv.csic.espersonal.icv.csic.es/reo2013/pdf/07_Measuring_Errors_e_20110614.pdfSeminar Basics on Rheology . 2 Overview Reasons for measuring errors

10

Source of trouble

Handling Sample Instrument

Reasons

Torque measurement

r.p.m. measurement

Geometry factors (A, M)

Geometry

Selected geometry

Test definition

Sample history

Sample loading

Gap setting

Temperature control

Zero point

Friction heating

Particles, trapped air

Solvent loss

Chemical reaction

Swelling / shrinking

Slipping

Elasticity

Taylor vorticis

Sedimentation

Page 11: Seminar Basics on Rheology - personal.icv.csic.espersonal.icv.csic.es/reo2013/pdf/07_Measuring_Errors_e_20110614.pdfSeminar Basics on Rheology . 2 Overview Reasons for measuring errors

11

Type - factor [-]

- factor [Pa/Nm]

Min. Viscosity [mPas]

Max. Viscosity [mPas]

DG41 72.67 3701 0.5 1.0 10+4

Z40DIN 12.29 6029 5 1.0 10+5

Z20DIN 12.29 48230 50 1.0 10+6

DC60/1 57.3 6796 1 1.0 10+4

C35/2 28.65 89090 100 1.0 10+6

PP60 30 23850 2 1.0 10+5

PP20 10 636600 500 1.0 10+8

Z43DIN/E 12.29 4746 10 1.0 10+5

HS25 440.5 88090 1 1.0 10+2

Consideration of

- Measuring range

- Sample properties

Handling – Selection of measuring geometry

Page 12: Seminar Basics on Rheology - personal.icv.csic.espersonal.icv.csic.es/reo2013/pdf/07_Measuring_Errors_e_20110614.pdfSeminar Basics on Rheology . 2 Overview Reasons for measuring errors

12

Measuring range

in comparison with RS1&PP20+ RS1&PP60

PP20 PP60

RS1 RS1

PP20 PP60

636600 A 23580 A

10 M 30 M

Gp (1/s) Gp (1/s)

Eta (mPas) Eta (mPas)

Tau (Pa) Tau (Pa)

ThermoHaake Rheometer Measuring Range

1,0E-04

1,0E-02

1,0E+00

1,0E+02

1,0E+04

1,0E+06

1,0E+08

1,0E+10

1,0E+12

1,E-04 1,E-03 1,E-02 1,E-01 1,E+00 1,E+01 1,E+02 1,E+03 1,E+04

Shear rate (1/s)

Sh

ea

r st

ress

(P

a)

1,E-04

1,E-02

1,E+00

1,E+02

1,E+04

1,E+06

1,E+08

1,E+10

1,E+12

Vis

co

sity

(m

Pa

s)

RS1

PP20

RS1

PP60

Handling – Selection of measuring geometry

Page 13: Seminar Basics on Rheology - personal.icv.csic.espersonal.icv.csic.es/reo2013/pdf/07_Measuring_Errors_e_20110614.pdfSeminar Basics on Rheology . 2 Overview Reasons for measuring errors

13

Cone & Plate Gap Error / Platte-Kegel

Abstandsfehler

0,0%

0,5%

1,0%

1,5%

2,0%

2,5%

3,0%

3,5%

4,0%

4,5%

0 5 10 15 20 25

Gap error / Abstandsfehler (microns)

Vis

co

sit

y E

rro

r / V

isk

os

itä

tsfe

hle

r (%

)

A Winkel 1,0° Radius 30,0mm

B Winkel 2,0° Radius 30,0mm

C Winkel 4,0° Radius 30,0mm

4 °

1 °

2 °

Cone

angle

Handling – Gap Setting and Error

Page 14: Seminar Basics on Rheology - personal.icv.csic.espersonal.icv.csic.es/reo2013/pdf/07_Measuring_Errors_e_20110614.pdfSeminar Basics on Rheology . 2 Overview Reasons for measuring errors

14

Reduced effective Radius / Einschnürungsfehler

0,0%

5,0%

10,0%

15,0%

20,0%

25,0%

30,0%

35,0%

40,0%

0 0,5 1 1,5 2

Reduced effective radius / Einschnürung (mm)

Vis

co

sit

y e

rro

r / V

isk

os

itä

tsfe

hle

r (%

)

A Winkel 1,0° Radius 10,0mm

B Winkel 2,0° Radius 17,5mm

C Winkel 4,0° Radius 30,0mm

60 mm

35 mm

20 mm

Handling – Sample Loading and Error

Page 15: Seminar Basics on Rheology - personal.icv.csic.espersonal.icv.csic.es/reo2013/pdf/07_Measuring_Errors_e_20110614.pdfSeminar Basics on Rheology . 2 Overview Reasons for measuring errors

15

Handling – Lost of gap filling

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0.1

1.0

10.0

[Pas]

Flow- and Viscosity curve

CR-Modus

[Pa]

[1/s] .

Page 16: Seminar Basics on Rheology - personal.icv.csic.espersonal.icv.csic.es/reo2013/pdf/07_Measuring_Errors_e_20110614.pdfSeminar Basics on Rheology . 2 Overview Reasons for measuring errors

16

Measurements on viscoelastic materials:

measuring geometry plate / plate 35mm with different gaps (0.3 …. 1.0 mm)

Handling – Lost of gap filling

Page 17: Seminar Basics on Rheology - personal.icv.csic.espersonal.icv.csic.es/reo2013/pdf/07_Measuring_Errors_e_20110614.pdfSeminar Basics on Rheology . 2 Overview Reasons for measuring errors

17

Friction heating

0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000

Á [1/s]

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

‚ [Pa]

2.5

3.0

3.5

4.0

4.5

ƒ [Pas

]

19.9

20.0

20.1

20.2

20.3

20.4

20.5

20.6

T [°C]

HAAKE RheoWin Pro 2.6

Flow and viscosty curve

ViscosityShear stress

Temperature

Fr-heat1‚ = f (Á)ƒ = f (Á)T = f (Á)

Page 18: Seminar Basics on Rheology - personal.icv.csic.espersonal.icv.csic.es/reo2013/pdf/07_Measuring_Errors_e_20110614.pdfSeminar Basics on Rheology . 2 Overview Reasons for measuring errors

18

Source of trouble

Handling Sample Instrument

Reasons

Torque measurement

r.p.m. measurement

Geometrya factors (A,M)

Geometry

Selected geometry

Test definition

Sample history

Sample loading

Gap setting

Temperature control

Zero point

Friction heating

Particles, trapped air

Solvent loss

Chemical reaction

Swelling / shrinking

Slipping

Elasticity

Taylor vorticis

Sedimentation

Page 19: Seminar Basics on Rheology - personal.icv.csic.espersonal.icv.csic.es/reo2013/pdf/07_Measuring_Errors_e_20110614.pdfSeminar Basics on Rheology . 2 Overview Reasons for measuring errors

19

Slippage CS/CR-Measurement

Shear Rate

Shear

Str

ess

Page 20: Seminar Basics on Rheology - personal.icv.csic.espersonal.icv.csic.es/reo2013/pdf/07_Measuring_Errors_e_20110614.pdfSeminar Basics on Rheology . 2 Overview Reasons for measuring errors

20

1 10 100 1000 0

0.0005

0.0010

0.0015

0.0020

0.0025

0.0030

0.0035

0.0040

0.0045

0.0050

0.0055

Taylor1

= f ( )

[Pa·s

]

[1/s] .

.

Taylor vortex

Page 21: Seminar Basics on Rheology - personal.icv.csic.espersonal.icv.csic.es/reo2013/pdf/07_Measuring_Errors_e_20110614.pdfSeminar Basics on Rheology . 2 Overview Reasons for measuring errors

21

Loss of solvent

Page 22: Seminar Basics on Rheology - personal.icv.csic.espersonal.icv.csic.es/reo2013/pdf/07_Measuring_Errors_e_20110614.pdfSeminar Basics on Rheology . 2 Overview Reasons for measuring errors

22

Thank you for your attention

Any questions ?