Top Banner
36

Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

May 05, 2023

Download

Documents

Khang Minh
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

��������� � ����������� ����� ����������! "�#��$&%'�(�)�* +�,

-�.0/ 1�2*34*54�687:9;=<?>@ 68<A3?687CBEDGFIHKJ*J*L

M)N8OQPSR�TVUCPWYXQZ\[^]`_)a`bdcfe`gihfjkgi]lnm!ZilC]`]ogim!lCZqprlse`_fXQprlse`gim!lCZKpnbYtuXQZ^bCv*_fb�wx]yXQZ\v{z|gih:eyX!aoXQ]yeyXQt�cu]yX!ao]prgijd_:e

a`bdcfeyX}eya�ls~�m"e`_fa`bdcujd_�lrm�bdhfjCXQ]`eyXQt�hfX!e0wAbCao�^��?_fX}bdcue`m�bdpnX�bCv�]yXQZ\[^]`_�a`bdcfe`gihujrgi]�jCXQhfX!aolCZ�Z\�gihfX!~�m!giXQh:e!�Ygihne`_ulseg\e�v�lCgiZi]�eyb�bC�ue`gip�g\�!X�hulse`cfa�lCZfbC���yXQm�e`g\�CX+v�cuhum�e`gibdhu]!�*�?_fX��Vaogim�X�bCv�lChulsaom�_:�gi]�lr�YculCh�e`g\e`lse`g\�CX�pnXQlC]ocfa`X"bCv*e`_ugi]�gihuX!~�m!g\XQhum��C�

� X�]`cfa`�CX!��aoXQm�XQh:ekw�bCa`��e`_ulseklChulCZ\�Y�!XQ]�e`_uX��uaog�m�X�bCv?lChulsaom�_:��bCv?]yXQZ\[V]o_�a`bdcfe`g�hfjf� � XlCZi]ybrtfXQ]om�aog\�qX�a`XQZilseyXQt�a`XQ]ocuZ\e`]�bdh��qbdcuhVtugihfj�e`_fX}w�bCao]ye�z��qbd]`]`g\�^Z\X"]yX!�CX!aog\e0�)bCv*ln�V_uXQhfbdpnXQhfbdhm!lCZiZ\XQt ��aolsXQ]`]!¡¢]"£*lsaolCtfbS¤=��lChVt�bdh e`_faoX!X�eyXQm�_uhugi�YcfXQ]Iv{bCa�a`XQtVcum!gihfj�e`_fX��Vaogim�X�bCvGlChulsaom�_:��bCv]yXQZ\[V]o_(a`bdcfe`gihfjf�¥�?_ugi]�]`cfa`�CX!�¦m�bdhum�XQh�eyaolseyXQ])bdh§e`_fX�m�bdh:eyaogi�Vcfe`g\bdhu]rbCvIe`_uX�lCcfe`_fbCaQ¡¢]�£G_u¨e`_fXQ]`gi]Q�f�Vcfe�lCZi]yb�tVgi]`m!cu]`]`XQ]�]`X!�CX!aolCZKpnbCaoX}a`XQm�XQh�e?a`XQ]`cuZie`]�gih�e`_fX�lsa`XQl��

© ª�«�¬­�®�¯¦°¦±}¬²³®�«

´�µ�¶�·k¸�¹q¶�ºq»Y¼�¸r¼�¶�µ�¶�·�»Y½A¾�¶s»�·¿¼³À*¸¿¹q¶³·�¶�¹Á»Y¼kÂK¶³¶�ÃÄ» ¸�·¿¶�Å�¶�ÃqÆqÇ�È=¼k¼¿Èq·�É�¶�ÇYÊ+»YËS¸�Ì{µVÌ�¸y¾�»:¸k¸�¹q¶)ÌÍÃf¸�¶�·�Ê|»YË�¶ÇYÊ�˳ÇYÅ�ºqÈ^¸�¶³·n¼�˳Ì{¶³ÃqË�¶�»�ÃqƧ¶³Ë³ÇYÃqÇ�Å�ÌÍ˳¼�Î)Ï"¹qÌ{¼n¼¿Èq·oµ�¶S¾¦Ìͼr»�Âq·�ÌͶSÊ+Ì{Ãf¸�·¿ÇVÆqÈqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ã(¸�Ç�¸yÐ+Ç�Ì{Ãf¸�¶³·o¸yÐ}ÌÍÃq¶�ÆÊ|»YË�¶�¸�¼�ÇYʸ�¹=Ìͼ�¶�Å�¶�·¿É�Ì{ÃqÉ ·�¶³¼�¶s»Y·�Ë!¹Ñ»�·¿¶s»^ÀAÒÔÓÁÕ�ÖK×QØÚÙ!ÕÜÛ`Ý�ÞYßKÞY×�Ù!ÓVà�»YÃqÆÑáCÕSâ ãá!Ó�×�Û:äVÒ0ØÔßVåYÎ�Ï"¹q¶�ºq·�ÌÍ˳¶�ÇYÊ»YÃÁ»�·¿Ë!¹f¾�À?æÁ·¿¼o¸ÜÆq¶�æqÃq¶³ÆçÂf¾éènÇ�È=¸¿¼¿Ç�Èqº=Ì�»Y¼�»�ÃqÆçê�»YºÁ»�ÆqÌÍÅ�Ì{¸¿·¿ÌÍÇYÈìëîíYï=À�ð�ï�ñ0À�Å�¶³»Y¼¿Èq·�¶³¼�¸�¹=¶�¶SòV¸�¶�Ãf¸�¸¿ÇÐ}¹qÌ{Ë!¹ÑË�Ç�Å�ºK¶�¸¿Ì{¸¿ÌÍÇ�ç»Yº=ºq·¿Çsò^ÌÍÅ�»�¸�¶�¼n˳ÇVÇ�ºK¶³·�»:¸�ÌÍÇYÃ*Î�ó�¸rÌͼrÅ�ÇY¸�Ì�µY»:¸�¶³Æ¦Âf¾(¸¿¹q¶ÜÐI¶�½Í½�ô�õuÃqÇCÐ}ÃÄÊ|»YËS¸n¸�¹Á»:¸ÃqÇ�Ã=˳ÇVÇ�º8¶�·�»�¸¿Ì{µY¶"¶³öuÈqÌͽ{ÌÍÂq·�Ì�»�Ës»YÃÜÂK¶nØÔß÷Õ�øùÙSØÚÕSßÁÒ|ÀfÌÍÃ�¸¿¹Á»�¸�¸¿¹q¶�¾)Ãq¶³¶�Æ�ÃqÇ�¸?Ç�º=¸�Ì{Å�Ì{ú³¶+ÃÁ»�¸�È=·�»Y½qÇYÂVû�¶³ËS¸�Ì{µY¶Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼�ëîüYü=ÀGý�ídñ0Πþ^¶³½�æÁ¼¿¹Ñ·¿Ç�È=¸¿ÌÍÃqÉ�·�¶�Ê�¶³·�¼�¸¿Ç�»�Å�»�¸�¹=¶³Å�»�¸�Ì{Ës»Y½AÅ�ÇVÆq¶³½�Ç�Ê+¸¿·�»�ÿ�ËÜÌÍÃÑ»�Ë�Ç�ÃqÉ�¶�¼�¸¿¶³ÆÃq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õ�ÎÏ"¹qÌͼGÅ�Ç^Æq¶�½u¹Á»Y¼A»�½ÍÇYÃqÉ}¹qÌͼo¸�Ç�·o¾rÌÍÃr¸�¹q¶�¸�·�»�Ãq¼¿ºKÇ�·�¸�»�¸�Ì{Ç�Ãr¼¿Ë�ÌͶ³Ã=˳¶I½{Ì{¸¿¶³·�»:¸�Èq·�¶�ë��=À��CüVÀYý��^À������:ñ»YÃqÆ�¹Á»Y¼k»�½Í¼¿Ç Â8¶�¶³Ã�Ð}Ì{Æq¶³½�¾�¼o¸�ÈqÆ=ÌͶ³Æ�Âu¾�¸�¹=¶�˳Ç�Å�ºqÈ=¸¿¶³·�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õuÌ{ÃqÉ�˳ÇYÅ�Å�È=ÃqÌ{¸y¾�¼¿¶³¶)¶YÎîÉqÎ�ë����YÀ��Cð=À �^À ü=ÀÁðfýVÀ�ýYü�ñ��SÎ?Ï"¹q¶rºq·�ÌÍ˳¶rÇYÊ�»YÃÁ»�·¿Ë!¹f¾�¹Á»Y¼}·�¶³Ë³¶�Ãf¸�½{¾�ÂK¶³¶�Ã�¶QòV¸�¶³Ã=¼¿Ì{µY¶³½�¾�¼�¸�È=ÆqÌͶ�Æ�Ì{Ã�¸¿¹qÌͼ"Å�ÇVÆq¶³½0Î

Ï"¹qÌͼn¼�Èq·�µY¶�¾§Ë�Ç�Ãq˳¶�Ãf¸�·�»:¸�¶³¼rÇ�渿¹q¶�˳Ç�Ãf¸¿·¿ÌÍÂ=È=¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼kÇYÊ?¸¿¹q¶Ü»YÈ=¸¿¹qÇ�·��î¼rê�¹�� ¸�¹q¶�¼¿Ìͼ�ë����CñÚÀ�ÂqÈ^¸�»Y½Í¼�ÇÆqÌ{¼¿Ë³È=¼¿¼¿¶�¼I¼�¶�µ�¶�·�»Y½�Å�Ç�·¿¶"·�¶³Ë�¶³Ãf¸I·�¶³¼�Èq½{¸¿¼�ÇYÃ�¸¿¹q¶}ºq·¿Ì{˳¶"ÇYÊ÷»YÃÁ»Y·�Ë!¹f¾ÜÇYÊ÷¼�¶³½�æÁ¼¿¹�·¿Ç�È=¸¿ÌÍÃqÉ=ÎAóyÃ�Å�ÇY¼�¸?Ës»�¼¿¶³¼�ÀÐ+¶kºq·¿ÇCµVÌÍÆ=¶�¼¿¶�½{Ê�ô�˳Ç�Ãf¸!»�ÌÍÃq¶�Æ�ºq·¿ÇVÇYÊ�¼�Î���»YÃf¾�Å�Ç�·�¶�Æq¶S¸!»YÌ{½Í¼�ÀV·�¶³¼�Èq½{¸¿¼³Àq»�ÃqÆ�·¿¶SÊ�¶³·¿¶�Ãq˳¶�¼"Ës»YàÂ8¶�Ê�ÇYÈqÃqÆ�Ì{ø�¹=¶�·�¶³Ë�¶³Ãf¸�ÂKÇVÇ�õ¦ë���ð�ñ0À=Ð}¹qÌ{Ë!¹�Ìͼ}»�Ã�¶Qò^ºÁ»YÃqÆq¶�Æ(»YÃ=Æ�·�¶�µVÌͼ�¶³Æ�µY¶³·�¼¿ÌÍÇYÃ�ÇYÊ�ë����dñ0Î

��������� �"!"#$��%&!�')(+*,'&#$�.-�!"���0/�1324��%513�)67/�!8�)%�(9')�;:=<+%.24>)���8?"2@!BA)6�C�D&EGFH�I!"�J?�KL-.24M4:�24%.N56PO&Q)OG/����8�8�GRS� M4MT6U/�!;� %�(9'&�8:�6*LVXW)C&O)Y�Q�Z[/\-��.�5'&�]!8��:^24%_��� �"!+`\A^acbedfN&�8�)%�!�b�Y)Y&Y.g�C hiY C h;g3hiY�j)E)Q\6&�+V�d+k�VXN)�;� %�!mlnW.g)gJb�oPhiY C hiWIhiY)Y&Y.g&6&� %5:G�)%be/.op*LV�d�q[q[drV+st� �;:�Z�qu#v�)2@MTw�x�y{z�|�}\~7�8~Ix.�)�.�\�&���[�B���)��Z

Page 2: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

ts

(x) = 1

(x) = x

c

c

� ���tk[2@N&')-�� ?L���.� #$�.M4�

ts

(x) = 1

(x) = x c

c

p

� `��tV %.'&%.M@24%.�J� �m>I� �824�)%�!

� Ì{É�Èq·¿¶_�ê�ÌÍÉ�ÇYÈt� ¼�¶Qò=»YÅ�º=½Í¶}»YÃqÆ�»rÃqÇ�Ãq½{ÌÍÃq¶³»Y·�µ�»Y·¿ÌÍ»YÃf¸sÎAÏ"¹q¶�Ë�Ç�¼�¸?Ê�ÈqÃ=Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�Ã���� ,�Æq¶³¼�˳·¿Ì{Â8¶�¼�¸¿¹q¶}˳Ç�¼o¸ÌÍÃ=˳Èq·�·¿¶³Æ�Âf¾�Èq¼�¶³·¿¼�ÇYÊ�»YÃ�¶³ÆqÉ�¶�À�»Y¼�»�Ê�ÈqÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�ÇYÊG¸�¹=¶�»�Å�Ç�È=Ãu¸}Ç�ÊA¸¿·�»�ÿ�Ër·¿Ç�È^¸�¶³Æ�Ç�Ã�¸�¹q¶r¶�ÆqÉ�¶YÎ

����� ������� ��������� ���"!$#&%(')�+*�,.-"/102 ¶nÃqÇCÐEÌ{Ãu¸¿·¿ÇVÆqÈqË�¶n¼¿¶³½�æÁ¼¿¹�·�Ç�È=¸�Ì{ÃqÉÜ»YÃqÆ�Å�ÇY¸¿Ì{µ�»�¸�¶�¸�¹q¶n·�¶³¼�Èq½{¸¿¼"Æq¶³¼�˳·¿Ì{Â8¶�Æ�ÌÍÃ�¸�¹=Ìͼ�¼�Èq·�µY¶�¾�Âf¾�ÌÍÃ^Ê�Ç�·oôÅ�»Y½Í½�¾�¶Qò=º=½ÍÇ�·�ÌÍÃqÉ�¸yÐIÇ�ÌÍÅ�º8ÇY·�¸!»�Ãu¸r¶Qò=»YÅ�º=½Í¶³¼�Î�ê�ÌÍÉYÇ�ÈÑÆ=Ìͼ¿Ë�ÇCµ�¶³·�¶³Æ¥¸¿¹q¶ÜæÁ·¿¼o¸�¶Sò=»YÅ�ºq½{¶�Ì{à �sï����Äë ý��:ñ435 ·¿»Y¶³¼�¼�Ê�Ç�È=ÃqÆ�¸�¹q¶r¼¿¶�˳Ç�Ã=Æ�ÌÍÃX�CïYð���ë9� ñÚÎ687:9�;=< >@?�ACBDA�E"FHG@IKJML+NPOQ?R7:9C;=<S>D?UTWVCX�Y[Z]\ ÇYÃq¼¿Ì{Æq¶³·G¸�¹q¶+¼¿ÌÍÅ�ºq½{¶�Ã=¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õ�¼¿¹qÇCÐ}Ã�Ì{à � Ì{É�Èq·¿¶ ��|»��SÎÏ�Ð+Ç�ÆqÌ{¼�û�Ç�Ì{Ãf¸"¶³ÆqÉY¶³¼}˳Ç�Ã=Ãq¶³ËS¸�»�¼�Ç�Èq·�˳¶nµ�¶�·�¸�¶Qò_^r¸¿Çܻܼ�ÌÍÃqõ�µ�¶�·�¸�¶Qòa`QÎ+b?»YË!¹�¶�ÆqÉ�¶rÌͼI½�»YÂK¶³½{¶³Æ�Ð}Ì{¸¿¹�»Ù!ÛCáSÒ8ÝQäVß÷ÙSÒ|ØÚÛ:ßc�5"d��QÀqÐ}¹qÌÍË!¹�Æq¶³¼�˳·�ÌÍÂK¶³¼�¸¿¹q¶�˳Ç�¼o¸ �¶YÎîÉqÎ{ÀÁ¸¿·�»sµ�¶�½�¸¿ÌÍÅ�¶��IÌ{Ãq˳Èq·�·¿¶�Æ�Âf¾�Èq¼¿¶�·¿¼�ÇYÊ�¸¿¹q¶�¶�ÆqÉ�¶�À»Y¼�»�Ê�ÈqÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�ÇYÊA¸�¹q¶�»YÅ�Ç�ÈqÃf¸}ÇYÊ�¸¿·�»�ÿ�Ër·¿ÇYÈ=¸�¶�Æ�Ç�Ã�¸�¹q¶�¶³Æ=É�¶YÎ+Ï"¹q¶�È=ºqº8¶�·�¶�ÆqÉ�¶�¹Á»Y¼"¸�¹=¶�Ë�Ç�Ãq¼�¸�»YÃf¸Ë³ÇY¼�¸)Ê�È=ÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã=��� ,�He ��À�»YÃqÆѸ¿¹uÈq¼�·¿¶�ºq·¿¶�¼¿¶�Ãu¸¿¼Ü»�·�Ç�È=¸�¶�¸�¹Á»:¸)Ì{¼�·�¶³½�»:¸�Ì{µY¶³½�¾¦½ÍÇ�Ã=É�ÂqÈ^¸�ÌÍÅ�Å�ÈqÃ=¶Ü¸¿Ç˳ÇYÃqÉ�¶³¼o¸�Ì{Ç�Ã*Î�Ï"¹q¶Ü˳Ç�¼o¸)ÇYÊ�¸�¹=¶�½{ÇdÐ+¶³·r¶�ÆqÉ�¶YÀGÂf¾§Ë³Ç�Ãf¸¿·�»Y¼o¸sÀGÌͼnÉ�ÇCµ�¶�·¿Ãq¶�Æ Âf¾¦¸�¹q¶�Ê�ÈqÃ=Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�Ã���� ,�.ef »YÃqÆ�¸¿¹VÈ=¼"ÌÍÃqË�·¿¶s»�¼¿¶³¼}»�¼�¸�¹q¶n¶�ÆqÉ�¶nÉ�¶S¸�¼"Å�Ç�·¿¶�˳Ç�ÃqÉY¶³¼�¸¿¶³Æ*Î�óyÃ�ºÁ»Y·o¸�ÌÍË�Èq½�»�·³Àu¸�¹q¶k½{ÇCÐI¶�·"¶³ÆqÉ�¶nÌ{¼�Ë!¹q¶³»Yº8¶�·¸�¹q»YÃ�¸¿¹q¶rÈqºqºK¶³·}¶³Æ=É�¶rÌ{ÊA»YÃqÆ�Ç�Ãq½�¾�Ì{ÊA½Í¶�¼¿¼�¸¿¹Á»YÃ�Ç�Ãq¶rÈqÃqÌ�¸}ÇYÊA¸¿·�»�ÿ�ËrÈq¼�¶³¼�Ì{¸sÎ

þ^ÈqºqºKÇ�¼�¶}¸¿¹q¶³·�¶}ÌͼÇ�Ã=¶�È=ÃqÌ{¸�Ç�ÊK¸¿·�»�ÿ�Ë�ÀV·�¶³ºq·�¶³¼�¶³Ãf¸�Ì{ÃqÉ)»�µY¶³·o¾Ü½�»Y·�É�¶�ºKÇ�ºqÈq½Í»�¸�Ì{Ç�Ã)ÇYÊ8Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õ�Èq¼�¶³·¿¼�À»YÃqÆ�¸¿¹Á»�¸?¶³»YË!¹ÜÈq¼¿¶�·�Ë!¹qÇ^ÇY¼¿¶³¼?Ì{ÃqÆq¶³ºK¶³Ã=Æq¶³Ãf¸�½�¾�ÂK¶�¸yÐ+¶³¶�Ã�¸¿¹q¶�¸yÐIÇr·�Ç�È=¸�¶�¼Ê�·¿Ç�Åg^}¸¿Ç$`QÎ h�¼¿¼¿È=Å�Ì{ÃqÉk¸�¹Á»:¸¶s»�Ë!¹�Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õ�Èq¼¿¶�·�»�ÌÍÅ�¼I¸�Ç�Å�Ì{ÃqÌÍÅ�ÌÍú�¶�Ì�¸�¼"Ë�Ç�¼�¸³À�Ð+¶�¼¿¹qÇ�È=½ÍÆ�¶Sò^ºK¶³Ë�¸�»Y½{½÷¸�·¿»�ÿ�Ër¸¿Ç�Ê�ÇY½Í½ÍÇCÐù¸�¹=¶�½{ÇCÐI¶�·¶³Æ=É�¶YΦóyÃqÆ=¶³¶³Æ÷À�¶³»YË!¹éÃq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õ¥Èq¼�¶³·�¼�¹qÇ�Èq½{Æé·¿¶³»Y¼¿Ç�à »Y¼)Ê�Ç�½{½ÍÇCÐ}¼i�¸¿¹q¶�½ÍÇCÐ+¶³·�·¿Ç�È=¸¿¶�Ìͼ�Ãq¶�µY¶³·�Ð+Ç�·¿¼�¶¸�¹q»YÃ�¸�¹q¶�ÈqºqºK¶³·�Ç�Ã=¶YÀq¶Sµ�¶³Ã�Ð}¹q¶�Ã�Ì{¸�Ì{¼IÊ�Èq½{½{¾Ü˳ÇYÃqÉ�¶³¼o¸�¶�Æ*À�»YÃqÆ�Ì�¸IÌ{¼�¼¿ÈqºK¶³·�ÌÍÇ�·�Ð}¹q¶³Ã=¶�µ�¶�·�¼�Ç�Å�¶�ÇYÊ�¸�¹=¶ÇY¸¿¹q¶³·�È=¼¿¶³·�¼}»Y·¿¶�Ê�Ç^Ç�½{Ìͼ�¹ ¶³Ã=Ç�ÈqÉ�¹�¸¿Ç�¸!»Yõ�¶k¸�¹q¶kÈ=ºqº8¶�·�·¿ÇYÈ=¸�¶�Î�óyÃ�¸¿¹q¶aj�¼�¶³½�æÁ¼¿¹�·�Ç�È=¸�Ì{ÃqÉ�Ç�È^¸�˳ÇYÅ�¶�kqÀ^Ð+¶¸�¹=¶³·¿¶SÊ�Ç�·¿¶r¶Qò=ºK¶³ËS¸k»�½Í½*Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇY·¿õu¼�È=¼¿¶³·�¼�¸¿ÇÜÌÍÃqË�Èq·}Ç�Ãq¶rÈqÃqÌ�¸}ÇYÊ�Ë�Ç�¼�¸³Î

l ÇCÐ ¼¿ÈqºqºKÇ�¼�¶�¸¿¹Á»�¸³À�Âu¾¥Ð}¹Á»�¸�¶Sµ�¶�·�Å�¶s»�Ãq¼³ÀÐ+¶�Ës»YÃéË!¹qÇVÇ�¼�¶�¹qÇCÐ ¸¿¹q¶�¸�·¿»�ÿ�Ë�Ìͼ)·�Ç�È=¸¿¶³Æ*Î \ »YÃÐ+¶�½Í¶Sµ�¶³·¿»YÉ�¶ ¸¿¹qÌͼ�º8ÇCÐ+¶³·�¸¿Ç(ÌÍÅ�ºq·¿ÇCµY¶ ÇCµ�¶�·�¸�¹q¶�¼¿¶³½�æÁ¼¿¹x·�Ç�È=¸�Ì{ÃqÉ�ÇYÈ=¸�Ë�Ç�Å�¶nm ÏGÇ(¼¿¶�¶�¸�¹Á»:¸)Ð+¶�Ës»YÃ*À˳ÇYÃq¼¿Ì{Æq¶³·�»Y¼�¼¿ÌÍÉYÃqÌÍÃqÉn¹q»Y½{ÊKÇYÊK¸�¹q¶"¸¿·�»�ÿ�Ë"¸�Çr¶s»�Ë!¹�ÇYÊK¸�¹=¶}¸yÐ+Ç�·¿Ç�È=¸¿¶³¼�Î�Ï"¹q¶}Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õ�È=¼¿¶³·�¼�Ê�ÇY·¿Ë³¶�Æ�ÇYÃu¸¿Ç¸�¹=¶�ÈqºqºK¶³·n¶�ÆqÉ�¶�¶Qò=ºK¶³·�ÌͶ�Ãq˳¶�Ç�Ã=¶�ÈqÃqÌ�¸kÇYÊ�˳ÇY¼�¸sÀ*»YÃqƧ»Y·�¶�¸�¹uÈq¼nÃ=Ç�ÐIÇ�·�¼¿¶�Çoĸ�¹q»YæÌÍÃ�¸¿¹q¶�ºq·�¶�µVÌÍÇYÈq¼Ç�È=¸¿Ë³Ç�Å�¶YÎ(´kÃ¥¸�¹q¶�ÇY¸�¹=¶³·)¹q»YÃqÆ*À�Èq¼�¶³·�¼�º8¶�·¿Å�Ì{¸�¸�¶³ÆÑÇ�Ã¥¸¿¹q¶�½ÍÇCÐ+¶³·�¶³ÆqÉ�¶�ÃqÇCÐ ¶³Ã:û�ÇC¾Ñ½ÍÌÍÉY¹u¸¿¶³·r¸�·¿»�ÿ�Ë˳ÇYÃqÆqÌ{¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã=¼³ÀÁ»YÃ=Æ�Ì{Ãq˳Èq·�»ÜÅ�¶�·¿¶ �qp��ÜÈqÃ=Ì{¸}ÇYÊA˳Ç�¼o¸sÎ 2 ¶r¹Á»sµ�¶r¸�¹=¶³·¿¶SÊ�Ç�·¿¶�½ÍÇCÐ+¶³·�¶³Æ�¸�¹q¶�˳Ç�¼o¸�ÇYʹÁ»�½{ÊGÇYʸ�¹=¶�Èq¼�¶³·�¼�Ð}¹qÌ{½Í¶rÅ�»YõuÌÍÃqÉ�ÃqÇ�Ç�Ãq¶nÐ+Ç�·¿¼�¶)ÇoAÎ$��Ç�·¿¶�ÇdµY¶³·�ÀK¸¿¹q¶)»sµY¶³·�»�É�¶�Ë�Ç�¼�¸�Ì{Ãq˳Èq·�·¿¶�Æ�Âf¾�¸�·¿»�ÿ�Ë�¹Á»�¼Æq¶�˳·¿¶³»Y¼¿¶�Æ�Ê�·¿ÇYÅ �n¸�Ç�üRp Î

Page 3: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

ê�ÌÍÉ�Ç�ÈL� ¼�¶Qòq»�Å�ºq½{¶"Æq¶³Å�Ç�Ãq¼o¸�·¿»�¸�¶�¼¸�¹Á»�¸?¼�¶³½�æÁ¼¿¹�·¿Ç�È^¸�ÌÍÃ=ÉnÃq¶³¶�Æ�ÃqÇ�¸?ºq·¿ÇVÆqÈqË�¶�»�Ã�ÇYº=¸�Ì{Å »Y½VÇ�È=¸¿Ë³Ç�Å�¶YÎÏ"¹qÌ{¼�ºq¹q¶�ÃqÇ�Å�¶³ÃqÇ�Ãx˳»YÃxÂ8¶�»�Å�ºq½{Ì{æÁ¶�ÆÑÐ}Ì�¸�¹x»(¼¿¶�¶³Å�ÌÍÃqÉY½{¾ÑÅ�Ì{ÃqÇ�·�Å�ÇVÆqÌ{æqËs»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãĸ�Ç]b�ò=»YÅ�º=½Í¶r�YÎ ��Îþ^Èqº=º8Ç�¼�¶�Ð+¶�·¿¶³º=½�»YË�¶Ü¸¿¹q¶Üºq·¿¶SµVÌÍÇ�Èq¼�½{¾¦½{ÌÍÃq¶³»Y·kË�Ç�¼�¸rÊ�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ã=�5@ ,�8ef ¥Ð}Ì�¸�¹§¸�¹q¶Ü¹qÌ{É�¹q½�¾�ÃqÇYÃq½ÍÌ{Ãq¶s»Y·Ç�Ãq¶)�5@ ,�+e � Ê�Ç�·�� ½�»Y·�É�¶ � Ì{É�Èq·¿¶S���Âu�J�QÎ h�¼+ÌÍà b�òq»�Å�ºq½{¶S��Î �YÀ^¼�¶³½{æq¼¿¹ È=¼¿¶³·�¼IÐ}Ìͽ{½�»Y½Í½^¸�·�»sµY¶³½÷ÇYÃ�¸�¹=¶½ÍÇCÐ+¶³·}·¿ÇYÈ=¸�¶�ÀÁÌÍÃqË�Èq·¿·�ÌÍÃqÉÜ»�˳ÇY¼�¸�ÇYÊ$�YÎ�´nÃ�¸�¹=¶�Ç�¸�¹q¶�·"¹Á»YÃqÆ*ÀÁÌ�ÊAÐ+¶r˳Ç�È=½ÍÆ�Ê�Ç�·¿Ë�¶r»�¼�Å »Y½{½��"Ê�·�»YËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�ÇYʸ�¹=¶}¸¿·�»�ÿ�Ë}¸�Çn¸�·¿»sµ�¶³½K»Y½{Ç�ÃqÉn¸�¹=¶�È=ºqº8¶�·+·�Ç�È=¸¿¶YÀf¸�¹q¶�Ã�¸¿¹q¶�»CµY¶³·¿»YÉ�¶�˳Ç�¼o¸�Ð+Ç�Èq½{Æ�Æ=·¿Ç�ºÜ¸�Ç���� ����I� � ��� ÀÐ}¹qÌ{Ë!¹�»Yº=ºq·¿Çf»�Ë!¹q¶³¼ �Ü»Y¼��}¸¿¶³ÃqÆq¼}¸�Ç �Ü»YÃqÆ���¸�¶�ÃqÆq¼}¸�ÇÜÌÍÃ=æqÃqÌ{¸y¾YÎ

óyà þ^¶³ËS¸�ÌÍÇYà �^ÀÐI¶�Ð}Ì{½Í½�Æq¶�æÁÃ=¶�¸�¹q¶�ºq·�ÌÍË�¶�ÇYÊ�»YÃÁ»Y·�Ë!¹f¾éÇYÊ�¼¿¶�½{æÁ¼�¹ç·�Ç�È=¸¿ÌÍÃqɦ»�¼)¸�¹q¶�»sµY¶³·�»�É�¶�˳Ç�¼o¸ÇYÊ"¸¿·�»�ÿ�Ë Ì{Ãé»�¼�¶³½{æq¼¿¹éÇ�È=¸¿Ë³Ç�Å�¶ Æ=Ì{µVÌÍÆq¶�Æ¥Âf¾Ä¸�¹q¶�Å�ÌÍÃ=ÌÍÅ�ÈqÅ�ôyºKÇ�¼�¼¿ÌÍÂ=½Í¶�»sµ�¶�·�»YÉY¶�˳Ç�¼o¸sÎ(ó�Ê"¸¿¹q¶�ºq·�ÌÍË�¶ÇYÊI»YÃÁ»Y·�Ë!¹f¾¦ÇYÊ+»�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õ¦Ì{¼k˳½{Ç�¼¿¶�¸¿Ç ��À*¸�¹q¶�ÃÄÐ+¶Ü˳Ç�Ã=˳½ÍÈ=Æq¶�¸�¹Á»:¸n¸�¹q¶ÜÃq¶�Éf»�¸�Ì�µ�¶�Ì{Å�ºÁ»�Ë�¸nÇYÊ�¼�¶³½{æq¼¿¹·¿ÇYÈ=¸�Ì{ÃqÉ�ÌͼI·¿¶³½Í»�¸�Ì�µ�¶�½{¾�¼¿Å�»Y½Í½0Î�Ï"¹q¶nºq·�ÌÍË�¶nÇYÊA»YÃÁ»Y·�Ë!¹u¾ ÌÍÃab�ò=»YÅ�ºq½Í¶=�YÎ �nÌ{¼"»�¸"½{¶s»Y¼o¸ pYü=À=»YÃqÆ�Ì{¸I¸�¶³Ã=Æq¼¸�ÇÜÌ{Ã=æÁÃqÌ�¸y¾ Ð}Ì{¸¿¹���Ì{Ã�¸¿¹q¶rÃqÇ�Ãq½{ÌÍÃq¶³»Y·Iµ�»Y·�Ì�»YÃf¸"ÇYÊê�ÌÍÉ�Ç�ÈL� ¼"¶Qòq»�Å�ºq½{¶YÎ

Ï"¹q¶�ºq·¿Ì{˳¶"ÇYÊ8»YÃÁ»�·¿Ë!¹f¾ÜÇYÊ8¼¿¶³½�æÁ¼¿¹�·¿ÇYÈ=¸�Ì{ÃqÉnËs»YÃ�¸¿¹q¶³·�¶�Ê�Ç�·�¶�ÂK¶"½�»�·¿É�¶"Ì�ÊK¸¿¹q¶"Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õ�˳Ç�¼o¸?Ê�ÈqÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã=¼»Y·�¶ j�¼�È=ÿ�˳ÌͶ�Ãf¸�½{¾�ÃqÇ�Ã=½ÍÌÍÃ=¶s»Y·�kqÎGê?Ì{É�Ç�Èt�î¼�¶Qò=»YÅ�º=½Í¶�»�ÃqÆ�Ì{¸¿¼AÃqÇYÃq½ÍÌ{Ãq¶s»Y·�µ�»Y·¿ÌÍ»YÃf¸�Å�ÇY¸¿Ì{µ�»�¸�¶?¸�¹=¶IÊ�Ç�½Í½{ÇCÐ}ÌÍÃqÉöuÈq¶³¼o¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼³À�Ð}¹qÌ{Ë!¹Ä»Y·¿¶�Ë�¶³Ãf¸�·¿»Y½�¸�Ç�þV¶³Ë�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã� ÇYÊ?¸¿¹qÌͼn¼�Èq·�µY¶�¾�Î \ »�縿¹q¶�ºq·�ÌÍ˳¶)ÇYÊ+»YÃÁ»Y·�Ë!¹u¾(Â8¶�½Í»Y·¿É�¶¶�µY¶³Ã¦Ð}¹q¶�æ˳Ç�¼o¸kÊ�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃq¼k»Y·�¶ j�Ã=ÇY¸�¸¿Ç^Ç�Ã=Ç�Ãq½ÍÌ{Ãq¶s»�· k�m¥óy¼�¸¿¹q¶�ºq·�ÌÍË�¶)ÇYÊ�»YÃq»Y·¿Ë!¹f¾�½�»Y·�É�¶³·�ÌÍÃ(Â=ÌÍÉ�É�¶�·³ÀÅ�Ç�·¿¶+˳Ç�Å�ºq½ÍÌ{Ës»�¸¿¶³Æ�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õV¼ m�óy¼Ì�¸�½Í»Y·¿É�¶�·AÌ{Ã�Å�Èq½�¸�Ì{˳Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ�¸y¾�Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇY·¿õu¼³ÀfÐ}¹q¶�·¿¶I¸¿·�»�ÿ�Ë�¶�Å »YÃq»�¸�¶�¼Ê�·¿ÇYÅ »�ÃqÆ�¸�¶�·¿Å�ÌÍÃÁ»�¸¿¶³¼I»�¸�Å�È=½{¸�Ì{ºq½Í¶}½{Ç^˳»�¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼ m�óyÃ�þ^¶�Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�Ãn��Ð+¶�Ð}Ìͽ{½8º=·¿ÇCµ�¶�¸¿¹Á»�¸�¸¿¹q¶n»YÃ=¼�Ð+¶³·�¸�Ç�»Y½Í½ÇYÊ?¸�¹=¶³¼¿¶ÜöuÈq¶�¼�¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼nÌ{¼aj�ÃqÇ k��ùÌÍÃ�Ê|»YË�¸³À�ê?Ì{É�Ç�Èt�î¼k¶Qòq»�Å�ºq½{¶�»YÃqƦ¼�ÌÍÅ�ºq½Í¶�µ�»Y·¿ÌÍ»YÃf¸�¼n»Y·�¶�ÌÍæ¼�Ç�Å�¶)¼¿¶³Ã=¼¿¶ÈqÃqÌ�µ�¶�·¿¼�»�½�ÂÁ»YÆ�¶Sò=»YÅ�ºq½Í¶�¼}Ê�ÇY·�¸�¹q¶rºq·�ÌÍ˳¶nÇ�Ê»YÃq»Y·¿Ë!¹f¾�ÇYÊA¼¿¶�½{æÁ¼�¹�·�Ç�È=¸�Ì{ÃqÉqÎ

2 ¹qÌͽ{¶�¸¿¹q¶�ºq·¿Ì{˳¶�ÇYÊ?»YÃÁ»�·¿Ë!¹f¾�Ì{Ã�ÇYÈq·�Ãq¶QòV¸k¶Sò=»YÅ�ºq½{¶�Ì{¼�Ã=Ç�½�»Y·�É�¶³·"¸¿¹Á»YÃ�Ì{Ã(ê�ÌÍÉYÇ�Èt�î¼�¶Qòq»�Å�ºq½{¶YÀ�Ì{¸Ìͼ}»�·¿É�ÈÁ»�Âq½{¾�»ÜÅ�Ç�·�¶n¼�¸!»�·�¸�½{ÌÍÃqÉÜ»�ÃqÆ�ÈqÃqÌÍÃf¸¿ÈqÌ{¸¿Ì{µ�¶nÆ=Ìͼ¿º=½�»s¾�ÇYÊA¸�¹q¶r¼�ÈqÂ8ÇYº=¸�Ì{Å »Y½{Ì{¸y¾�ÇYÊA¼¿¶�½{æÁ¼�¹�·�Ç�È=¸�Ì{ÃqÉqÎ687:9�;=< >@?�ACB X E���� 9 ? OiONPO�F$9�� 9�� J 7 T A��CY�Z \ Ç�Ãq¼�ÌÍÆq¶�·�¸�¹=¶¥Ê�Ç�Èq·`ôyÃqÇVÆq¶¥Ã=¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õ ¼¿¹qÇCÐ}à ÌÍà � ÌÍÉ�ôÈq·�¶G�U0»��QÎ�Ï"¹q¶�·¿¶�»Y·¿¶"¸yÐ+Ç�ÆqÌ{¼�û�Ç�Ì{Ãf¸?·¿Ç�È=¸¿¶³¼�Ê�·¿ÇYÅf^}¸¿Ç `QÀu¶s»�Ë!¹�Ð}Ì�¸�¹�˳Ç�Å�Â=ÌÍÃq¶�Æ�Ë�Ç�¼�¸ ���a �ÀfÐ}¹q¶�·¿¶ �Ì{¼¸�¹=¶�»YÅ�Ç�ÈqÃf¸Ç�Êq¸�·¿»�ÿ�Ë+¸�¹q»�¸Èq¼�¶³¼¸¿¹q¶I·�Ç�È=¸�¶�Î�Ï"¹q¶I·¿Ç�È=¸¿¶³¼�»�·¿¶?¸�¹q¶�·¿¶�Ê�ÇY·¿¶�Ì{Æq¶³Ãf¸�Ì{Ës»Y½0ÀY»�ÃqÆ�¼¿¶�½{æÁ¼�¹�¸�·¿»�ÿ�˼¿¹=Ç�Èq½ÍÆ¥¼¿ºq½{Ì{¸�¶�µ�¶�Ãq½{¾ÑÂK¶�¸yÐ+¶³¶³Ã鸿¹q¶³Å�Î_h�¼¿¼¿È=Å�Ì{ÃqÉ�¸�¹q»�¸)¸¿¹q¶³·�¶�Ìͼ�Ç�Ãq¶�È=ÃqÌ{¸�ÇYÊ"¸�·¿»�ÿ�ËYÀ�»�½Í½?Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õÈq¼�¶³·¿¼�¶Sò^ºK¶³·�ÌͶ³Ã=˳¶�üRp���ÈqÃqÌ�¸�¼"ÇYÊA˳Ç�¼o¸�ÌÍÃ�¸�¹q¶r¼�¶³½{æq¼¿¹�·¿Ç�È=¸¿ÌÍÃqÉÜÇ�È^¸�˳ÇYÅ�¶�Î

l ÇCÐ ¼¿È=ºqº8ÇY¼¿¶)¸¿¹Á»�¸sÀKÌÍÃ�»YÃ(¶ o÷ÇY·�¸�¸�Ç Æ=¶³Ë³·�¶s»Y¼�¶)¸�¹=¶)˳ÇY¼�¸k¶�Ãq˳ÇYÈqÃf¸�¶³·�¶³Æ¦Âf¾�¸�¹q¶�¸�·�»:ÿ�Ë�ÀKÐ+¶)Â=ÈqÌͽ{Æ»�¼¿¹qÇ�·o¸sÀ�¹qÌ{É�¹^ôy˳»YºÁ»YË�Ì{¸y¾�¶³ÆqÉ�¶�˳ÇYÃqÃq¶³ËS¸�Ì{ÃqÉ�¸¿¹q¶�Å�Ì{Æqº8ÇYÌÍÃf¸�¼kÇ�Ê+¸¿¹q¶�¸yÐ+Ç�¶Sò^Ìͼo¸�ÌÍÃ=É�·�Ç�È=¸�¶�¼³Î�Ï"¹q¶�Ãq¶�ÐÃq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õìÌͼ�¼¿¹qÇCÐ}ÃùÌÍà � ÌÍÉ�Èq·�¶ �7�Âu�SÀ"Ð}Ì�¸�¹ì¸�¹=¶(Ãq¶�Ð ¶³Æ=É�¶ �� �"!^�ܺKÇ�¼¿¼�¶³¼�¼¿ÌÍÃ=Éx¸¿¹q¶¦Ë³ÇYÃq¼�¸�»YÃf¸�˳Ç�¼o¸Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ã(��� ,��e �=Î$#�ÇCÐEÐ}Ì{½Í½8¼¿¶³½�æÁ¼¿¹�¸�·¿»�ÿ�Ën·¿¶s»�Ë�¸ m

2 ¶+Ës»YÃ=ÃqÇY¸A¶Sò^º8¶�Ë�¸¸¿¹q¶Iº=·¿¶�µVÌ{Ç�Èq¼�¸�·�»:ÿ�Ë+ºÁ»�¸�¸�¶³·�Ã�¸¿Ç�ºK¶³·¿¼�Ìͼo¸�Ì{Ã�¸�¹=¶+Ãq¶SÐçÃq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õ�Î h�¼�Ì{Ã)ê�ÌÍÉYÇ�Èt�Sò=»YÅ�ºq½{¶YÀÁ¸�¹q¶�˳Ç�¼o¸�Ç�ʸ�¹q¶�Ãq¶�Ð ·�Ç�È=¸¿¶Q^&% �'% !(% `"Ì{¼�Ã=¶�µ�¶�·�Ð+Ç�·¿¼�¶�¸�¹q»YÃ�¸¿¹Á»�¸�»Y½ÍÇ�Ã=É�¸¿¹q¶�¸yÐ+ÇÇ�·�ÌÍÉ�Ì{ÃÁ»Y½VºÁ»�¸�¹=¼³ÀV»YÃqÆÜÌ{¸?Ì{¼�¼�¸¿·¿ÌÍËS¸�½�¾)½{¶³¼¿¼�Ð}¹q¶�Ãq¶�µY¶³·+¼¿Ç�Å�¶�¸�·¿»�ÿ�Ë�Ê|»YÌͽ{¼�¸�ÇrÈq¼�¶�Ì�¸sÎ 2 ¶"¸�¹=¶³·¿¶SÊ�Ç�·¿¶}¶Qò=ºK¶³ËS¸»Y½{½"Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õxÈq¼�¶³·�¼ ¸�ÇÄÆq¶�µVÌÍ»�¸�¶�¸�Çĸ�¹q¶�Ãq¶�Ð ·�Ç�È=¸¿¶YÎ 5 ¶�Ës»YÈ=¼¿¶(ÇYÊ�¸�¹q¶�¶³Ãq¼�ÈqÌÍÃ=É¥¹q¶³»Cµu¾ç˳ÇYÃqÉ�¶³¼o¸�Ì{Ç�ÃÇ�æ¸�¹=¶�¶³ÆqÉ�¶�¼ 4^)�"�P��»YÃ=Æ *!+� `��QÀ�»Y½{½�ÇYÊ?¸�¹=¶�¸�·�»:ÿ�Ë�Ã=ÇdÐ ¶Sò^ºK¶³·�ÌͶ³Ã=˳¶³¼r¸yÐ+Ç�È=ÃqÌ{¸¿¼nÇYÊ�˳Ç�¼o¸sÎ 5 ·�»Y¶�¼¿¼��î¼ê�»�·�»YÆqÇsò§¸¿¹VÈ=¼�¼�¹qÇCÐ}¼�¸¿¹Á»�¸n¸�¹=¶�Ì{Ãu¸¿ÈqÌ{¸¿Ì{µY¶³½{¾�¹q¶�½Íº=Ê�Èq½?»�Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�çÇYÊI»YÆqÆqÌ{ÃqÉ�»�Ã=¶�Ð ú�¶³·¿Ç:ôy˳ÇY¼�¸�¶³ÆqÉY¶�˳»YÃÌÍÃ=˳·¿¶³»Y¼¿¶n¸¿¹q¶r˳Ç�¼o¸�¶Qò^º8¶�·¿ÌͶ�Ãq˳¶�Æ�Âf¾�»Y½{½÷ÇYÊG¸�¹q¶n¸¿·�»�ÿ�Ë-,b�ò=»YÅ�º=½Í¶p�YÎ ��¼�¹qÇCÐ}¼k¸�¹Á»:¸n»YÆqÆ=ÌÍÃqÉ�»�Ãq¶�Ð�¶³Æ=É�¶�¸�Ç�»�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õ�Ës»YæÌ{Ãq˳·�¶s»Y¼�¶)¸�¹=¶)˳ÇY¼�¸nÌ{Ãq˳Èq·�·¿¶�ƦÂu¾¼¿¶�½{æÁ¼�¹�¸¿·�»�ÿ�ËYÎ b?öuÈqÌ�µ�»Y½Í¶�Ãu¸¿½{¾YÀÁ×!Õ . Û0/CØÔßVå"Ç�Ãq¶�¶³Æ=É�¶"Ê�·¿Ç�Å »rÃq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õ�Ð}Ì{¸�¹�½ÍÌ{Ãq¶s»�·Ë³Ç�¼o¸+Ê�È=ÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãq¼?˳»YÃÆq¶�˳·¿¶³»Y¼¿¶�¸�¹qÌ{¼�Ë�Ç�¼�¸�Âf¾�»ÜÊ|»YË�¸¿Ç�·�ÇYÊ�»�¸�½Í¶³»Y¼�¸ pYü^Î \ »YÃ�·�¶³Å�ÇCµ^Ì{ÃqÉ ¶�ÆqÉ�¶�¼�Ê�·¿ÇYÅ »�Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇY·¿õ�Æq¶³Ë�·¿¶s»�¼¿¶¸�¹=¶ Ë³ÇY¼�¸�Ì{Ãq˳È=·¿·¿¶�Æ¥Âf¾Ñ¼¿¶³½�æÁ¼¿¹Ñ¸�·�»:ÿ�Ë�Âf¾ »�½�»Y·�É�¶³·nÊ|»YËS¸�Ç�·�ÌÍÃѽ�»Y·�É�¶³·rÃq¶S¸yÐIÇY·¿õu¼³À�Ç�·rÐ}Ì{¸¿¹¥ÃqÇYÃq½ÍÌ{Ãq¶s»Y·

ü

Page 4: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

s t

w

v

(x) = 1

(x) = x

(x) = x

(x) = 1 c

c

c

c

� �i���i%.2@!"2 � M�%.��!Bs,'&���

s t

w

v

(x) = 1 (x) = x

(x) = 1

(x) = 0

(x) = x c

c c

c

c

� `�mV+-.N&#$��%�!"�J: %.��!Bs,'&���

� Ì{É�Èq·¿¶ � 5 ·�»Y¶�¼¿¼&� ¼�ê�»Y·¿»YÆqÇsò8Î?Ï"¹q¶)»�ÆqÆqÌ{¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�Ç�Ê»YÃ�Ì{Ãu¸¿ÈqÌ{¸¿Ì{µY¶³½{¾�¹q¶�½Íº=Ê�Èq½�¶�ÆqÉ�¶rËs»�Ã�»YÆ^µ�¶³·�¼¿¶�½{¾�»�o8¶³ËS¸»Y½{½÷ÇYÊA¸�¹q¶n¸�·¿»�ÿ�ËYÎ

˳ÇY¼�¸�Ê�ÈqÃ=Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼�À^Ç�·�Ð}Ì{¸¿¹�Å�Èq½�¸�Ìͺ=½Í¶}˳Ç�Å�Å�Ç^ÆqÌ�¸�Ì{¶³¼³ÀfÇY·�Ð}Ì�¸�¹�Å�È=½{¸�Ì{ºq½Í¶}¶�ÆqÉ�¶�·�¶³Å�ÇCµY»�½Í¼�»�½Í½ÍÇCÐ+¶³ÆKm�ó�Ê�¼¿ÇqÀÂf¾�¹qÇCÐ Å�È=Ë!¹Km�óyÃ(þV¶³Ë�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�ü�Ð+¶�É�Ì�µ�¶rºq·�¶³Ë³Ì{¼¿¶�»YÃq¼oÐI¶�·¿¼}¸�Ç�»Y½{½*ÇYÊG¸�¹q¶�¼¿¶�öVÈ=¶³¼�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã=¼³Î

����� � � /����)�"/:�2 ¶IÂK¶³É�Ì{Ã�Ì{Ã�þ^¶�Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�à �}Âf¾�º=·¿ÇCµVÌÍÃqÉ�Å »�¸¿Ë!¹qÌÍÃ=É�Èqº=º8¶�·»YÃqÆ)½ÍÇCÐI¶�·AÂKÇ�ÈqÃ=Æq¼�Ç�Ã�¸�¹q¶+ºq·¿Ì{˳¶�ÇYÊ�»YÃq»Y·¿Ë!¹f¾�ÇYʼ¿¶�½{æÁ¼�¹�·�Ç�È=¸¿ÌÍÃqÉqÎ1h�ÊÔ¸�¶³·�Æ=¶�æÁÃqÌ{ÃqÉ"¸�¹q¶�Ë�½�»Y¼�¼¿Ì{Ës»Y½�Å�ÇVÆq¶³½�ÇYÊ=¼�¶³½�æÁ¼¿¹r·¿ÇYÈ=¸�Ì{ÃqÉ�¸�¹Á»:¸�ÐI¶?¼�¸¿ÈqÆ=¾YÀ:Ð+¶�Ê�ÇY·¿Å�»Y½ÍÌ{ú³¶¸�¹=¶�½ÍÇCÐ+¶³·+Â8Ç�È=ÃqÆ�Ç�Ã�¸¿¹q¶kºq·�ÌÍË�¶�ÇYÊ�»�ÃÁ»Y·¿Ë!¹f¾�ºq·¿ÇCµVÌÍÆ=¶³Æ�Âf¾�¼¿ÌÍÅ�ºq½{¶�µ�»Y·�Ì�»YÃf¸�¼�ÇYÊGê�ÌÍÉYÇ�Èt�î¼+¶Qòq»�Å�ºq½{¶YÎ h�¼¼¿È=É�É�¶³¼o¸�¶�ÆEÂf¾ b�ò=»YÅ�º=½Í¶ ��Î �¥»�ÃqÆ&¸�¹q¶§¼¿È=Âq¼¿¶�öVÈ=¶³Ãf¸¦ÃqÇ�Ã=½ÍÌÍÃ=¶s»Y· µ�»Y·�Ì�»YÃf¸¿¼³À�¸¿¹qÌͼ�½{ÇCÐI¶�·�ÂKÇ�ÈqÃ=ÆùÐ}Ì{½Í½Æq¶�º8¶�ÃqÆ�Ç�Ã�¸�¹=¶�¼�¶�¸�ÇYÊ»Y½Í½{ÇdÐI»YÂq½{¶k¶³Æ=É�¶r˳Ç�¼o¸�Ê�È=ÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãq¼�Î 2 ¶n¸�¹q¶�Ã�¼�¹qÇCÐ »ÜÅ »�¸¿Ë!¹qÌÍÃ=É�ÈqºqºK¶³·�Â8Ç�È=ÃqÆÊ�Ç�·�¶³¼¿¼�¶³Ãf¸�ÌÍ»Y½Í½�¾Ä¶�µ�¶�·�¾é¼�¶�¸�Ç�Ê�»�½Í½ÍÇCÐI»YÂq½{¶�Ë�Ç�¼�¸�Ê�È=ÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãq¼�Î � Ç�·�¶Qò=»YÅ�º=½Í¶YÀ¸¿¹q¶�ºq·�ÌÍË�¶�ÇYÊ�»YÃÁ»�·¿Ë!¹f¾ Ì{ö�µY¶³·o¾�Å)Èq½{¸¿ÌÍ˳ÇYÅ�Å�Ç^Æ=Ì{¸y¾�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õÜÐ}Ì�¸�¹�½ÍÌ{Ãq¶s»Y·�Ë�Ç�¼�¸�Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼ �ìÊ�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃq¼+Ç�Ê÷¸�¹=¶�Ê�Ç�·�Å ����IÐ}Ì{¸¿¹ � ��� ���ùÌ{¼ »�¸ Å�ÇY¼�¸ pYü=ÎEÏ"¹uÈq¼�¸¿¹q¶�º=·¿ÌÍË�¶�ÇYÊ�»�ÃÁ»Y·¿Ë!¹f¾ ÌÍà ¼�ÈqË!¹ùÃq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õV¼�Ì{¼ Å�»:ò^ÌÍÅ�ÌÍú�¶³ÆçÂu¾ê�ÌÍÉ�ÇYÈt� ¼�¶Sò=»YÅ�ºq½{¶ Db�òq»�Å�ºq½{¶S��Î ���SÎ?þ^Ì{Å�Ì{½�»Y·�½{¾YÀ:¸¿¹q¶�ºq·�ÌÍË�¶�Ç�Ê�»YÃÁ»Y·�Ë!¹f¾�Ç�Ê*Å�Èq½�¸�Ì{˳Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ�¸y¾�Ã=¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õu¼Ð}Ì{¸¿¹§Ë³Ç�¼o¸�Ê�ÈqÃ=Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼n¸�¹q»�¸�»Y·¿¶ÜºKÇ�½{¾VÃqÇYÅ�ÌÍ»Y½Í¼�Ð}Ì{¸�¹§ÃqÇYÃqÃq¶³É�»�¸�Ì�µ�¶Ü˳ÇV¶�ÿ�˳Ì{¶³Ãf¸�¼�»YÃqÆÄÆq¶�É�·¿¶�¶ »�¸�Å�Ç�¼�¸�(Ì{¼�Å�»:ò^ÌÍÅ�ÌÍú�¶³Æ�Âf¾�¸¿¹q¶)Ã=Ç�Ãq½ÍÌ{Ãq¶s»�·�µ�»Y·�Ì�»YÃf¸�ÇYÊ?ê�ÌÍÉYÇ�Èt�î¼�¶Qòq»�Å�ºq½{¶)¼�¹qÇCÐ}Ã(ÌÍà � ÌÍÉ�È=·¿¶ ��|Âu�QÎ 2 ¶)»Y½Í¼�ǶSò^ºq½{ÌÍË�Ì{¸�½�¾n˳ÇYÅ�ºqÈ^¸�¶+¸¿¹q¶�½Í»Y·¿É�¶�¼�¸oôyºKÇ�¼¿¼�ÌÍÂq½{¶�º=·¿ÌÍË�¶IÇYÊK»�ÃÁ»Y·¿Ë!¹f¾�Ð}Ì{¸¿¹�·¿¶�¼¿ºK¶³Ë�¸�¸¿Ç�¼�¶�µ�¶�·�»Y½=ÆqÌ o8¶³·�¶³Ãf¸¸y¾Vº8¶�¼ÇYÊA˳Ç�¼o¸}Ê�ÈqÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã=¼³Î

þ^¶³ËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�ü)¼�¸¿ÈqÆqÌ{¶³¼�¸�¹=¶�ÐIÇY·¿¼�¸oôyºKÇ�¼¿¼�ÌÍÂq½{¶�¼�¶�µ�¶�·¿Ì�¸y¾�ÇYÊ 5 ·¿»Y¶³¼�¼��î¼}ê�»Y·¿»YÆqÇsò8Î 2 ¶k¼�¹qÇCÐ ¸¿¹Á»�¸ 5 ·�»Y¶�¼¿¼��î¼ê�»�·�»YÆqÇsòÑËs»�à Â8¶ »Y·¿Â=Ì{¸�·¿»Y·¿Ì{½{¾�¼¿¶�µY¶³·�¶YÀ�¶�µY¶³ÃxÌÍÃѼ¿Ì{ÃqÉ�½Í¶QôyË�Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ{¸y¾�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õV¼�À�ºq·¿ÇCµVÌÍÆ=¶³Æ ÃqÇYÃq½ÍÌ{Ãq¶s»Y·Ë³ÇY¼�¸Ê�ÈqÃ=Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼�À�½�»Y·�É�¶�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õu¼�À^»�ÃqÆ�Å�Èq½�¸�Ìͺ=½Í¶?¶³ÆqÉY¶�·¿¶�Å�ÇCµ�»Y½Í¼A»Y·�¶�º8¶�·¿Å�Ì{¸�¸�¶³Æ÷Î�ê�·¿¶�˳Ì{¼¿¶³½�¾�ÀYÊ�ÇY·�¶�µY¶³·o¾� � �^À�¸�¹=¶³·¿¶ÜÌ{¼�»�¼�ÌÍÃqÉ�½{¶Sô�˳Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ�¸y¾�À � ô�µY¶³·�¸¿¶SòÑÃq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õ¦¼¿ÈqË!¹Ñ¸�¹Á»�¸�·�¶³Å�ÇdµVÌ{ÃqÉ�� � p����& ��¶³ÆqÉ�¶�¼Æq¶�˳·¿¶³»Y¼¿¶�¼�¸¿¹q¶�Ë�Ç�¼�¸�Ì{Ãq˳Èq·�·¿¶�Æ Âf¾x¼¿¶�½{æÁ¼�¹ ¸¿·�»�ÿ�Ë�Âf¾ç»YÃ�� � p�����Ê|»YËS¸�Ç�·�Î 2 ¶�»Y½Í¼�Çļ�¹qÇCÐ ¸�¹q»�¸Ü¸�¹qÌ{¼Ë³ÇYÃq¼�¸¿·¿ÈqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃéÌͼ)ÇYº=¸�Ì{Å »Y½?Ì{à ¼¿¶Sµ�¶³·¿»Y½�¼�¶³Ãq¼�¶³¼³À+ÆqÌͼ�˳Èq¼�¼�¶SòV¸�¶�Ãq¼¿Ì{Ç�Ãq¼�¸¿Ç(Å�Èq½�¸�ÌÍË�Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ{¸y¾�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õV¼�À»YÃqÆ�¼¿¹=ÇdÐ ¸�¹Á»:¸ 5 ·�»Y¶�¼¿¼��î¼�ê�»Y·¿»YÆqÇsò�Ìͼ"Ì{Å�ºKÇ�¼�¼¿ÌÍÂ=½Í¶�¸¿Ç�Æ=¶�¸�¶�Ë�¸�¶�ÿ�˳Ì{¶³Ãf¸�½�¾ 0»�¼¿¼¿È=Å�Ì{ÃqÉ����e���� �QÎ

þ^¶³ËS¸�Ì{Ç�à ¸�»YË!õu½Í¶�¼�¸�¹=¶ ºq·�Ç�Âq½Í¶�Å'ÇYÊ"·¿¶�ÆqÈqË�ÌÍÃqÉ�¸�¹q¶�ºq·¿Ì{˳¶ Ç�Ê}»YÃÁ»Y·�Ë!¹f¾¥Ì{ÃÑÃq¶S¸yÐIÇY·¿õu¼�Ð}¹q¶³·�¶�Ì{¸�Ì{¼ÈqÃÁ»�˳˳¶�º=¸!»�Âq½{¾�¹qÌÍÉ�¹÷Înó�¸n¼¿Èq·oµ�¶S¾^¼�ºKÇ�¼¿Ì�¸�Ì{µY¶)·�¶³¼¿È=½{¸�¼�Ê�Ç�·�¸�¹=·¿¶³¶)ÆqÌͼo¸�ÌÍÃ=Ë�¸r»Yº=ºq·¿Çf»�Ë!¹q¶³¼��ÌÍÃ=˳·¿¶³»Y¼¿Ì{ÃqÉ�¸�¹=¶

Page 5: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õ¥Ë³»YºÁ»YË�Ì{¸y¾�À�·�Ç�È=¸¿ÌÍÃqɦ»�¼¿Å�»Y½Í½?ºKÇ�·�¸¿ÌÍÇ�ÃÑÇYÊ"¸�¹q¶�¸�·�»:ÿ�ˠ˳¶³Ãf¸¿·�»Y½{½{¾�À»YÃqÆéÌÍÃ��ÁÈq¶³Ã=˳ÌÍÃ=É(Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õÈq¼�¶³·¿¼�Âf¾�¸!»dò=Ì{ÃqÉÜÃq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õ�¶³ÆqÉ�¶�¼³Î

� ÌÍÃq»Y½Í½�¾�ÀAþ^¶³ËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ãéí�Æ=¶³¼¿Ë�·¿Ì{Â8¶�¼�¸�¹=¶�Âq·¿Ç�»YÆq¶³·�·¿¶�¼¿¶³»Y·¿Ë!¹éË�Ç�Ãf¸�¶SòV¸�Ê�ÇY·�¸¿¹q¶ ·�¶³¼¿È=½{¸�¼�ÇYÊ"¸�¹=Ìͼ�¼¿Èq·oµ�¶�¾YÀ»YÃqÆ�Æ=Ìͼ¿Ë�Èq¼¿¼�¶³¼}ÇY¸¿¹q¶³·"·�¶³Ë³¶�Ãf¸"ÐIÇ�·�õ�¸¿¹Á»�¸"öuÈÁ»YÃf¸¿Ì{æÁ¶�¼�¸�¹q¶nÌ{Ãq¶�ÿ�˳Ì{¶³ÃqËS¾�ÇYÊGÃqÇYÃq˳ÇVÇ�ºK¶³·�»:¸�Ì{µY¶k¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌ{Âq·¿ÌÍ»=Î

� � ®�°¦«¦¯¦²³«�� ¬���� ­?²s±� ®��� «���­?±����

Ï"¹qÌ{¼�¼�¶³Ë�¸¿ÌÍÇ�ÃÄÊ�Ç�·¿Å�»Y½{½{¾(Æ=¶�æÁÃq¶�¼�¼¿¶�½{æÁ¼�¹¥·�Ç�È=¸�Ì{ÃqÉ�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õu¼�À�¶³öuÈqÌͽ{ÌÍÂq·�Ì�»=À�»�ÃqÆ¥¸�¹=¶�ºq·�ÌÍË�¶�ÇYÊ"»YÃÁ»Y·�Ë!¹u¾ÚþVÈqÂq¼¿¶�Ë�¸¿ÌÍÇ�à �VÎ �.� 3�Ì{Ãf¸�·¿ÇVÆqÈqË�¶³¼ »Ñ¼¿Ì{Å�º=½Í¶�½ÍÇCÐ+¶³·�Â8Ç�È=ÃqÆìÇ�Ãç¸�¹q¶�ºq·¿Ì{˳¶�ÇYÊr»YÃÁ»�·¿Ë!¹f¾ ¸¿¹Á»�¸�Ìͼ�ÂÁ»Y¼�¶³ÆÇ�Ã¥ê?Ì{É�Ç�Èt�î¼�¶Sò=»YÅ�ºq½Í¶fÚþVÈqÂq¼¿¶�Ë�¸¿ÌÍÇ�à �VÎ ��� 3»YÃ=Æ¥ºq·�ÇdµY¶³¼�»�Å »:¸�Ë!¹qÌ{ÃqÉ�È=ºqº8¶�·�ÂKÇ�ÈqÃ=Æ¥Ç�Ãĸ�¹q¶�ºq·¿Ì{˳¶ÜÇYÊ»YÃÁ»�·¿Ë!¹f¾Úþ^È=Âq¼¿¶�Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�Ãr�^Î ü��SÎ

� ��� � �C/ -"��*��"!$� �K�"/10� ? >�� O����cJ L�� G��1I �(?!�#"HJ �%$ O2 ¶�ÂK¶³É�Ì{Ã�Âf¾�·¿¶SµVÌͶ�Ð}Ì{ÃqÉ�¸¿¹q¶r¸�¶³·�Å�Ì{ÃqÇ�½{Ç�ÉY¾�Ç�Ê˳½Í»Y¼¿¼�ÌÍ˳»Y½�Å�Èq½�¸�ÌÍË�Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ{¸y¾��ÁÇCÐ Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇY·¿õu¼³Î�þ^¶�¶�ë �:ñÚÀÊ�Ç�·�¶Sò=»YÅ�ºq½Í¶�ÀKÊ�ÇY·�Å�Ç�·¿¶�Æq¶S¸!»YÌ{½Í¼�»YÃqÆ�Ê�ÇY·�¹qÌ{¼�¸¿Ç�·¿Ì{Ës»Y½�ÃqÇ�¸�¶³¼�Ç�Ã�Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇY·¿õ&�ÁÇCÐ}¼³Î8h Å�Èq½�¸�ÌÍË�Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ{¸y¾�ÁÇCÐ Ã=¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õ¦Ì{¼nÆq¶³¼�˳·¿Ì{Â8¶�ÆÑÂf¾§»�ÆqÌ{·¿¶�Ë�¸�¶�ÆÑÉY·�»Yºq¹('&e �)$�+*=�SÀ�Ð}Ì�¸�¹¦µ�¶�·�¸�¶Qòļ¿¶S¸,) »YÃ=ÆĶ�ÆqÉ�¶Ü¼¿¶S¸*�À^»YÃqÆ »�¼�¶�¸^4^ � � ` � � ��-�-�- �.4^�.0� `/.\��ÇYÊ�¼�Ç�Èq·�˳¶Sô�¼¿Ì{Ãqõ�µ�¶³·o¸�¶Qò ºq»YÌÍ·�¼³À^»Y½Í¼�Ç�˳»Y½Í½{¶³Æ(Ù!Û0.�. Û10YØÔÒ0ØÚÕ!áSÎ�ê�»Y·¿»Y½Í½{¶³½¶³Æ=É�¶³¼�»Y·¿¶r»�½Í½ÍÇCÐ+¶³Æ*Àq»YÃqÆ�»�µY¶³·o¸�¶Sò�˳»YÃ�ºÁ»Y·�¸¿ÌÍË�ÌͺÁ»�¸¿¶nÌÍÃ�Å�È=½{¸�Ì{ºq½Í¶�¼¿Ç�È=·¿Ë³¶Qôy¼�ÌÍÃqõ�ºÁ»�ÌÍ·¿¼�Î

� Ç�·�»�Å�Èq½{¸¿ÌÍË�Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ{¸y¾�Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õ�'ÜÀ8½{¶�¸3254Æ=¶³ÃqÇY¸¿¶�¸¿¹q¶)¼�¶�¸nÇYʼ¿ÌÍÅ�ºq½{¶H^14�ô `64ºq»�¸�¹q¼�»YÃqÆ72 ¸�¹=¶ÈqÃqÌ{Ç�Ã98 .4;: � 254�Î 2 ¶�»Y½�Ð�»s¾V¼Ü»Y¼¿¼�ÈqÅ�¶�¸�¹Á»�¸<254 �e>=(Ê�Ç�·)¶Sµ�¶³·o¾@?¿Î]hBA}Û%C Ì{Ã@' Ì{¼�»(ÃqÇ�ÃqÃ=¶³Éf»�¸¿Ì{µY¶µ�¶�Ë�¸¿Ç�·³ÀGÌÍÃqÆ=¶Sò^¶³ÆÑÂu¾D2 Î � Ç�·r»��ÁÇCÐFEé»YÃqÆÑ»�ºÁ»:¸�¹ �HG9254yÀ�ÐI¶�ÌÍÃf¸¿¶³·¿º=·¿¶�¸<EJI »�¼r¸¿¹q¶�»YÅ�Ç�ÈqÃf¸rÇYʸ�·¿»�ÿ�Ë�ÇYÊ?Ë�Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ{¸y¾K?+¸�¹Á»�¸�Ë!¹qÇVÇ�¼¿¶�¼k¸�¹q¶�ºÁ»�¸�¹ � ¸�Ç ÃÁ»sµ^Ì{Éf»�¸¿¶�Ê�·¿ÇYÅ ^14A¸�Ç `64yÎ8hL�ÁÇCÐMEÑÌÍÃ=ÆqÈq˳¶�¼»NA�Û%C Û:ß ÕO0CåVÕ!áQPRE%SUTJSWV1XÀ�Ð}¹q¶³·�¶�EJS eZY I[V]\^_SWV1I E%IçÆq¶�ÃqÇY¸�¶�¼�¸¿¹q¶Ü¸�ÇY¸�»Y½?»YÅ�Ç�ÈqÃf¸�ÇYÊ`�qÇdÐ Èq¼¿Ì{Ãqɸ�¹=¶�¶�ÆqÉ�¶Qa�Î � Ì{ÃÁ»Y½{½{¾�ÀVÐI¶�Èq¼�¶<b�¸�ÇÜÆq¶�ÃqÇY¸¿¶)»ÜÃqÇ�ÃqÃ=¶³Éf»�¸¿Ì{µY¶�µY¶³Ë�¸¿Ç�·�ÇYÊ�Ò|×�Þ�øùÙ�×�ÞYÒyÕ!áSÀÁÌÍÃqÆq¶Qò^¶³Æ�Âf¾�¸�¹=¶Ë³ÇYÅ�Å�Ç^Æ=Ì{¸�Ì{¶³¼�ÇYÊc'�Î�hd�ÁÇCÐeE�ÌÍÃ&' Ì{¼ÝsÕ¿Þ:áSØgf³âÍÕ?Ê�Ç�·hb)Ì�ÊAÌ�¸"·¿ÇYÈ=¸�¶�¼�»�½Í½÷Ç�ÊG¸¿¹q¶nºq·�¶³¼¿Ë�·¿Ì{Â8¶�Æ�¸¿·�»�ÿ�ËÊ�ÇY·¶s»�Ë!¹i?jGkP��)� � ��-�-�- �UlmTuÀ Y I[V]\!n E%I eob14ÚÎ

ÏAÇ�Å�ÇVÆq¶�½¸�¹q¶ÜÃq¶�Éf»�¸�Ì�µ�¶�˳Ç�Ã=¼¿¶³öuÈq¶�Ãq˳¶�¼�ÇYÊ�Ì{Ãq˳·�¶s»Y¼�ÌÍÃqÉ�˳ÇYÃqÉ�¶³¼o¸�Ì{Ç�Ã*À�ÐI¶�É�Ì{µY¶Ü¶s»YË!¹ ¶�ÆqÉ�¶pa�ÇYÊ�»Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õq' »�Ã=Ç�ÃqÃq¶�Éf»�¸�Ì�µ�¶�À*˳Ç�Ãf¸¿ÌÍÃuÈqÇ�Èq¼�À�»YÃqƦÃqÇYÃqÆq¶³Ë�·¿¶³»Y¼¿Ì{ÃqÉ Ù!ÛCáSÒ*ÝQä^ß÷ÙSÒ|ØÚÛ:ß(�#SSÎ h ˳Ç�¼o¸kÊ�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�US\�d���Æq¶�ÃqÇY¸�¶�¼�¸�¹q¶}˳ÇY¼�¸G|¶�Î ÉqÎ�¸�·�»sµY¶³½Á¸�Ì{Å�¶\�GÌÍÃ=˳Èq·�·¿¶³Æ�Âf¾�¸�·¿»�ÿ�Ë"¸�¹Á»�¸�¸¿·�»sµ�¶�·¿¼�¶³¼�¶³ÆqÉ�¶3a�ÀV»Y¼?»kÊ�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�ÃÇYÊ�¸¿¹q¶ ¶�ÆqÉ�¶�˳Ç�ÃqÉY¶³¼�¸¿ÌÍÇ�ÃkE%SSÎah ¼¿¶�½{æÁ¼�¹ ·¿ÇYÈ=¸�Ì{ÃqÉ�Ã=¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õÄÌͼr¸�¹q¶�à É�Ì�µ�¶³Ã¥Âu¾Ñ»�¸�·¿Ì{ºq½Í¶ÜÇYÊI¸�¹q¶�Ê�Ç�·¿Å�'��+b�� �&�SÀ=Ð}¹=¶³·¿¶r' Ì{¼}»�Å�Èq½�¸�ÌÍË�Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ{¸y¾N�qÇdÐ Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õ�Àmb)Ìͼ}»)µ�¶�Ë�¸¿Ç�·�Ç�ÊG¸¿·�»�ÿ�Ër·�»:¸�¶³¼�ÀÁ»YÃqÆ ��Ì{¼"»µ�¶�Ë�¸¿Ç�·�Ç�Ê�Ë�Ç�¼�¸}Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼³À=ÌÍÃqÆq¶Qò^¶³Æ�Âf¾�¸¿¹q¶r¶³ÆqÉY¶³¼�ÇYÊs'ÜÎ 2 ¶nÇ�ÊÔ¸�¶³Ã�Ës»�½Í½*¼�ÈqË!¹(»�¸�·�Ìͺq½{¶n»YÃÄØÔß=áSÒ�ÞYß÷Ù!ÕSÎ

6ut L GD> Gwv � G@92 ¶IÃq¶Qò^¸�ÆqÌͼ�˳Èq¼�¼�¶�öVÈ=ÌͽÍÌ{Âq·¿ÌÍ»"ÌÍÃ�¼¿¶³½�æÁ¼¿¹)·¿Ç�È=¸¿ÌÍÃqÉ�Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õu¼³Îjx�¶�¸sE�ÂK¶I»�ÁÇCÐéÊ�¶s»Y¼�ÌÍÂq½{¶�Ê�Ç�·G¸¿¹q¶IÌ{Ãq¼�¸�»YÃqË�¶�'��+b�� �&�SÎ�Ï"¹q¶nÇCµY¶³·�»�½Í½*Ë�Ç�¼�¸ �UI�yEL�+ÌÍÃqË�Èq·¿·�¶³Æ�Âf¾�¸�·¿»�ÿ�ËnÇ�Ã�¸�¹=¶�ºq»�¸�¹ ��ÌÍÃ�¸�¹=¶z�qÇdÐdE�Ìͼ"Æ=¶�æÁÃq¶�Æ�»�¼¸�¹=¶�¼�ÈqÅ ÇYÊI¸¿¹q¶�˳Ç�¼o¸�¼�ÇYÊI¸¿¹q¶Ü˳Ç�Ãq¼o¸�Ì�¸�Èq¶�Ãu¸�¶³Æ=É�¶³¼� �#IHyEt�.e Y SWV1I �#S�yEJS �QÎ l »�¸�Èq·¿»Y½Í½�¾�À*Ð+¶ ¶Qò=ºK¶³ËS¸¼¿¶�½{æÁ¼�¹(¸�·¿»�ÿ�Ë)¸�Ç�»�¸�¸�¶�Å�º=¸�¸�Ç�Å�ÌÍÃ=ÌÍÅ�ÌÍú³¶rÌ�¸�¼�Ë�Ç�¼�¸³ÎrÏ"¹qÌͼk½{¶s»YÆ=¼�¸�Ç�¸¿¹q¶)Ê�Ç�½{½ÍÇCÐ}ÌÍÃ=É�Æq¶SæÁÃqÌ�¸�ÌÍÇYÃ*ÀKÐ}¹=ÌÍË!¹ÐI»Y¼�æq·¿¼�¸}Ê�Ç�·�Å�Èq½Í»�¸�¶�Æ�Âu¾ 2 »Y·�Æq·¿ÇYº ë������dñÚÎ

í

Page 6: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

� ?!�s� Gw� GDJm� X BDA EqT A�����Y�Z x�¶�¸QE ÂK¶Ü» Ê�¶s»Y¼�ÌÍÂq½{¶<�ÁÇCÐ Ê�Ç�·�¸�¹q¶ÜÌÍÃ=¼�¸!»�Ãq˳¶ g' �+b�� �&�SÎ�Ï"¹q¶N�ÁÇCÐ E Ì{¼n»� ÞY×O0Y×�Û!Ö&Õ��³äVØÔâ\Øgf³×QØÔä . Ì{Ê`À�Ê�Ç�·n¶Sµ�¶³·o¾Ä˳Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ�¸y¾�?uG�P��)�I� ��-�-�- �UlmT »YÃqÆĶ�µY¶³·o¾Ñºq»YÌÍ· � ���� G 254�ÇYÊ^14{ô4`64Aºq»�¸�¹q¼"Ð}Ì�¸�¹iE%I �=À

�UI yEL��� �� I �Et�#-óyà ÇY¸¿¹q¶³·�ÐIÇY·¿Æq¼�À?»Y½Í½?ºÁ»�¸¿¹q¼)Ì{Ã¥Èq¼�¶�Âf¾ » 2 »Y·�Æq·¿ÇYº¥¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌ{Âq·¿Ì{ÈqÅ E ¹Á»sµY¶�Å�Ì{ÃqÌÍÅ)ÈqÅÜô�º8ÇY¼¿¼¿Ì{Âq½Í¶�˳Ç�¼o¸|ÉYÌ{µ�¶�Ã�¸¿¹q¶³Ì{·+¼�Ç�Èq·¿Ë�¶YÀ^¼¿ÌÍÃ=õKÀ^»YÃqÆ�¸�¹q¶�˳Ç�Ã=É�¶³¼o¸�ÌÍÇYàËs»�Èq¼¿¶�Æ�Âu¾ Et�QÎóyàºq»Y·�¸¿ÌÍ˳È=½�»Y·�Àu»Y½Í½ÁºÁ»:¸�¹q¼+ÇYÊ�»�ÉYÌ{µ�¶�Ã˳ÇYÅ�Å�Ç^Æ=Ì{¸y¾ÄÈq¼¿¶�Æ Âf¾x» 2 »Y·¿Æq·�Ç�ºx¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌÍÂ=·¿ÌÍÈ=Å ¹q»CµY¶�¶�öuÈÁ»Y½"˳ÇY¼�¸sÎéóyÃ鸿¹q¶�¸�¹q¶�Ç�·¿¶S¸�ÌÍ˳»Y½�Ë�Ç�Å�º=È=¸�¶�·¼¿Ë�ÌͶ�Ãq˳¶�½{Ì{¸�¶�·�»�¸¿Èq·¿¶�À 2 »Y·�Æq·¿ÇYº¦¶³öuÈqÌͽ{ÌÍÂq·�Ì�»Ü»Y·�¶�»Y½Í¼�Ǡ˳»Y½Í½{¶³Æ��nÞ:á!Ó,A}Û%C�áSÎ #�»YÈq·�ÌͶ�»�ÃqÆX��»Y·�˳ÇY¸�¸�¶�ë ý:ñÊ�Ç�·�Å »Y½{ÌÍú�¶³Æ¥¸¿¹q¶�ºq·¿¶�˳Ìͼ�¶�˳Ç�·�·¿¶³¼�º8ÇYÃqÆq¶³Ã=˳¶�Â8¶S¸yÐI¶�¶³Ã 2 »Y·�Æq·¿Ç�ºx¶�öVÈ=ÌͽÍÌ{Âq·¿ÌÍ»(»YÃqÆ l »Y¼¿¹ç¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌÍÂ=·¿Ì�»�ÇYÊæÁÃqÌ�¸�¶nÃqÇY·¿Å�»Y½�ôÚÊ�Ç�·¿Å Éf»YÅ�¶³¼�ë¢ð�ð�ñ0Î�c? ;=9��J$ X B X óyÃn�k¶�æÁÃqÌ�¸�Ì{Ç�à �VÎ ��ÀVÐI¶k»Y·¿¶kÌ{Å�º=½ÍÌÍË�Ì{¸¿½{¾)»Y¼¿¼�ÈqÅ�Ì{ÃqÉ�¸¿¹Á»�¸"¶Sµ�¶�·�¾�Ã=¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õ�Èq¼¿¶�·�˳Ç�Ãf¸¿·¿Ç�½{¼» Ãq¶�É�½ÍÌ{É�ÌÍÂq½{¶�º8Ç�·o¸�Ì{Ç�ÃìÇYÊr¸�¹=¶(ÇCµ�¶³·¿»Y½Í½�¸�·¿»�ÿ�ËYÀ�¼¿Çé¸�¹Á»:¸�¸�¹q¶(»YË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãq¼ ÇYÊ�»YÃ&ÌÍÃqÆ=Ì{µVÌÍÆqÈq»Y½�È=¼¿¶³·�¹q»CµY¶¶³¼�¼¿¶�Ãu¸¿Ì�»Y½{½{¾�ÃqÇ�¶�o8¶³ËS¸rÇ�æ¸�¹q¶�Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇY·¿õ(Ë�Ç�ÃqÉ�¶�¼�¸�Ì{Ç�Ã*Î�óyæ¸�¹q¶�Éf»�Å�¶)¸¿¹q¶³ÇY·�¾(½{Ì{¸¿¶³·�»:¸�Èq·�¶YÀ÷É�»YÅ�¶�¼�Ð}Ì{¸¿¹¸�¹=Ìͼ)º=·¿Ç�ºK¶³·o¸y¾é»Y·�¶ Ës»�½Í½Í¶�Æìß÷Û:ßKÞYÒyÛ0.�ØÚÙ�ëîïP�³ñÚΦþ^¶�µY¶³·�»�½�·¿¶�˳¶³Ãf¸ÜºÁ»�º8¶�·¿¼�¹Á»sµY¶�»YÃÁ»Y½�¾^ú�¶³Æ ¸¿¹q¶�ºq·�ÌÍ˳¶�ÇYÊ»YÃÁ»�·¿Ë!¹f¾�ÌÍÃ�»�¸¿Ç�Å�Ì{Ë�µ�»Y·¿ÌÍ»YÃf¸�¼}ÇYÊG¸�¹q¶r¼�¶³½{æq¼¿¹�·�Ç�È=¸¿ÌÍÃqÉÜÅ�Ç^Æq¶�½*¼�¸¿ÈqÆqÌ{¶³Æ�ÌÍÃ�¸�¹qÌ{¼"¼¿Èq·oµ�¶�¾ 3K¼¿¶�¶�þ^¶�Ë�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�íÊ�Ç�·"·�¶�Ê�¶³·�¶³ÃqË�¶³¼�Î

5 ¶³Ë!õuÅ�»YÃqÃ*ÀG��Ë��rÈqÌ{·¿¶�À}»YÃqÆ 2 ÌÍÃ=¼�¸�¶�Ã�ë �:ñ�·�¶³¼¿ÇY½{µ�¶�Æì¸�¹q¶�ÌÍÅ�º8Ç�·o¸!»YÃf¸�Ìͼ�¼¿Èq¶�¼�ÇYÊr¶Sò^Ì{¼�¸�¶�Ãq˳¶§»�ÃqÆÈqÃqÌ{öuÈq¶³Ãq¶�¼¿¼�ÇYÊ 2 »Y·�Æq·¿Ç�º�¶�öVÈ=ÌͽÍÌ{Âq·¿ÌÍ»=ÎF � JK<�J OnG��qG@J � X B�� EqT�� Y�Z�� ÕSÒvg' �+b�� �&�rfSÕ�ÞYߦØÔß=áSÒ�ÞYß÷Ù!Õ��� Þ����*ÓÁÕrØÔß=áSÒÚÞYß÷Ù!Õ g' �+b�� �&�)Þ!0-.�ØÔÒÔá�ÞYÒ�âÍÕ¿Þ:áSÒ}Û:ß÷Õ � ÞY× 0Y×�Û!ÖéÕ��³ä^ØÔâ\Øgf³×QØÔä .��� f ��!ÔÝ3EìÞYßm0 �EìÞY×�Õ � ÞY× 0Y×�Û!ÖéÕ��³ä^ØÔâ\Øgf³×QØ|Þ�ÝsÛ:× �'��+b�� �&�#"?ÒÔÓÁÕSßa�US\�E%S��+e �#S& �E%SJ�?ÝsÛ:×�Õ /YÕS×Qà�ÕO0CåVÕ3a��Ï"¹q¶)æq·¿¼�¸kºÁ»Y·�¸�ÇYÊ�ê�·¿Ç�ºKÇ�¼�Ì{¸�Ì{Ç�Ãr�^Î ü�É�ÈÁ»Y·¿»YÃf¸�¶³¶�¼�¸�¹q»�¸n» 2 »Y·�Æq·¿Ç�º�¶³öuÈqÌͽ{ÌÍÂq·�ÌÍÈqÅ ¶Qò^Ìͼ�¸¿¼kÌÍÃ�¶�µY¶³·�¾�ÌÍÃ^ô¼�¸�»YÃqË�¶YÎÏ"¹q¶I¼¿¶³Ë�Ç�ÃqÆܺÁ»Y·o¸¼o¸!»�¸¿¶³¼�¸¿¹Á»�¸�¶Sµ�¶³·o¾)¸yÐ+Ç 2 »�·¿Æq·�Ç�º�¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌ{Âq·¿ÌÍ»�Ì{ÃqÆqÈqË�¶IÌÍÆ=¶³Ãf¸�Ì{Ës»Y½V¶³ÆqÉY¶�˳Ç�¼o¸�¼�Î2 ¹qÌ{½Í¶�¸yÐ+Ç 2 »�·¿Æq·�Ç�º§¶³öuÈqÌͽ{ÌÍÂq·�Ì�»ÜÃq¶³¶�ÆÑÃ=ÇY¸nÌÍÃ=ÆqÈq˳¶�Ì{Æq¶³Ãf¸¿ÌÍËs»�½ �ÁÇCÐ}¼rÇ�æ¶�ÆqÉ�¶³¼�ÀGê?·�Ç�ºKÇ�¼¿Ì�¸�ÌÍÇYà �^Î ü�|Â��Ìͼ"¼o¸�·�Ç�ÃqÉ�¶³ÃqÇ�È=É�¹�Ê�ÇY·"Ç�Èq·"ºqÈq·�º8ÇY¼¿¶³¼�Î

Ï"¹q¶�ºq·¿ÇVÇYÊAÇYÊê�·�Ç�º8ÇY¼¿Ì{¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãf�^Î ü�ÌÍÃÑë���ñ�Ìͼ"·�¶³Å�»Y·¿õ:»YÂq½{¶YÎ 5 ¶�Ë!õuÅ »YÃ=Ã*À,��Ë$�nÈqÌÍ·�¶YÀ�»YÃ=Æ 2 Ì{Ãq¼�¸¿¶³Ã¥ë ��ñ¼¿¹=ÇdÐ+¶³Æ÷ÀÂf¾§ÌÍÃfµ�Ç�õuÌ{ÃqÉ�¸¿¹q¶�è�»�·¿Èq¼�¹^ô`ènÈq¹qÃVôyÏGÈqË!õY¶�·)˳ÇYÃqÆqÌ{¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã=¼p�¼¿¶�¶�¶�Î ÉqÎ+ëîýP��ñ��SÀ�¸�¹q»�¸r¸�¹q¶ 2 »�·¿Æq·�Ç�º¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌ{Âq·¿ÌÍ»�ÇYÊG»�Ã�ÌÍÃq¼o¸!»YÃ=˳¶ g' �+b�� �&�?»Y·¿¶kº=·¿¶³Ë�Ìͼ�¶³½{¾Ü¸¿¹q¶ �ÁÇCÐ}¼�¸�¹q»�¸�Å�ÌÍÃqÌ{Å�Ì{ú³¶�¸¿¹q¶�ÖÁÛ:ÒyÕSßÁÒ0Ø|ÞYâdÝQä^ß÷ÙSÒ|ØÚÛ:ß

% yEL��e�&SWV1X('*),+- �US\� ,�/. ����

ÇCµ�¶�·�»Y½Í½"Ê�¶³»Y¼¿Ì{Âq½Í¶7�ÁÇCÐ}¼ Ê�Ç�· g' �Ob0� ���QÎ þ^Ì{Ãq˳¶�˳Ç�¼o¸�Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃq¼�»Y·�¶�Ë�Ç�Ãf¸�ÌÍÃuÈqÇYÈq¼�»YÃqÆ ¸�¹q¶(¼�ºÁ»YË�¶(ÇYÊ»Y½{½ �ÁÇCÐ}¼�Ìͼ�Ë�Ç�Å�ºq»YË�¸³À 2 ¶³Ì{¶³·¿¼o¸�·¿»Y¼¿¼&� ¼�Ï"¹q¶³ÇY·¿¶³Å ¸�¹q¶�à Ì{Å�ºq½{ÌͶ�¼�ê�·¿Ç�ºKÇ�¼�Ì{¸�Ì{Ç�à �^Î ü�|»��SÎ þ^ÌÍÃqË�¶¦Ë³Ç�¼o¸Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼r»Y·�¶�ÃqÇ�ÃqÆ=¶³Ë³·�¶s»Y¼�ÌÍÃqÉ=À�¸¿¹q¶�Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�à % Ì{¼k˳ÇYÃuµY¶Sò8ÀA»YÃqÆÄê�·¿Ç�ºKÇ�¼¿Ì�¸�Ì{Ç�ÃX�^Î ü�|Â���¸�¹q¶�æÊ�Ç�½Í½{ÇdÐ}¼Ð}Ì{¸¿¹qÇ�È=¸�Å�ÈqË!¹¦Æ=Ì{ÿ�˳Èq½�¸y¾�Î}Ï"¹qÌ{¼�Èq¼�¶�ÇYÊ?»�º8ÇY¸¿¶³Ãf¸�ÌÍ»Y½�Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃ(¹Á»Y¼�Â8¶�¶³Ã(Ì{à �ÁÈq¶�Ãu¸¿Ì�»Y½�Ì{Ã�ÂKÇY¸�¹(É�»YÅ�¶¸�¹=¶³Ç�·o¾(»YÃ=Æ(¸�¹q¶�Ç�·¿¶S¸�ÌÍ˳»Y½G˳Ç�Å�ºqÈ=¸¿¶³·�¼�˳Ì{¶³ÃqË�¶YÎrx�¶³Æ(Âf¾�¸¿¹q¶)Ð+Ç�·¿õ�ÇYÊ10}Ç�¼¿¶�Ãf¸�¹Á»Y½�ë ýYý:ñ»�ÃqÆ ��Ç�ÃqÆ=¶³·¿¶�·»YÃqƦþ^¹Á»Yºq½{¶�¾¥ë¢ðfí:ñ0À8ºKÇY¸�¶�Ãf¸�Ì�»�½�Ê�È=ÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãq¼�¹Á»sµ�¶�ÂK¶³Ë�Ç�Å�¶�»�¼o¸!»YÃ=ÆÁ»Y·¿Æ�¸�ÇVÇ�½�ÌÍÃ�Ã=Ç�Ãq˳ÇVÇ�ºK¶³·¿»�¸�Ì�µ�¶)É�»YÅ�¶¸�¹=¶³Ç�·o¾�Ê�Ç�·+ºq·¿ÇCµVÌÍÃ=É)¸�¹q¶�¶Sò^Ìͼo¸�¶³Ã=˳¶nÇYÊ�ºqÈ=·¿¶Sô�¼�¸¿·�»�¸¿¶³ÉY¾ l »Y¼�¹�¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌÍÂ=·¿Ì�»rÌÍà˳¶³·o¸!»YÌ{Ã�˳½Í»Y¼¿¼�¶³¼�Ç�Ê�Éf»YÅ�¶³¼³ÎóyÃ¥¸¿¹q¶³Ç�·�¶�¸¿ÌÍËs»�½�Ë�Ç�Å�ºqÈ=¸�¶�·)¼�˳ÌͶ�Ãq˳¶�À�º8Ç�¸�¶³Ãf¸¿Ì�»Y½�Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼�¹Á»sµ�¶�ÂK¶³¶�ÃéÈq¼¿¶�Æ ¸�Ç�ÂKÇ�ÈqÃ=Æ¥¸�¹q¶�ºq·¿Ì{˳¶�ÇYÊ

ð

Page 7: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

»YÃÁ»�·¿Ë!¹f¾(Ì{Ã�¼¿¶Sµ�¶�·�»Y½�»�ºqºq½ÍÌ{Ës»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã=¼�ë¢ü=À÷í��^À,���=À,��ï�ñ0ÎkóyÃf¸�ÈqÌ�¸�Ì{µY¶³½�¾�ÀKÌ{Ê�¶�öVÈ=ÌͽÍÌ{Âq·¿ÌÍ»�ÇYº=¸�Ì{Å�Ì{ú³¶�» º8Ç�¸�¶³Ãf¸¿Ì�»Y½Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ã(¸�¹Á»:¸rÌͼaj�Ë�½ÍÇ�¼�¶)¸�Çk�¸�¹q¶�Ç�Âuû�¶³Ë�¸¿Ì{µY¶ÜÊ�È=ÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã*À8¸�¹q¶�ÃĶ�öuÈqÌͽ{ÌÍÂq·�Ì�»�˳»YÃqÃqÇ�¸rÂ8¶�¸¿Ç^Ç�Ì{Ãq¶�ÿ�˳Ì{¶³Ãf¸sÎóyÃqÆq¶�¶³Æ*ÀV¸�¹q¶�ºq·�ÇCò^Ì{Å�Ì�¸y¾�Â8¶S¸yÐI¶�¶³Ã ¸¿¹q¶�ºKÇY¸¿¶³Ãf¸�ÌÍ»Y½qÊ�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYà % Ì{à 3�.��»YÃqÆ�Ç�Èq·?Ç�ÂVû�¶�Ë�¸�Ì�µ�¶�Ê�ÈqÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãr0ü��ÂK¶³½ÍÇCÐ Ì{Å�º=½ÍÌͶ�¼"Ãq¶s»�·oôyÇYº=¸�Ì{Å »Y½÷ÈqºqºK¶³·�ÂKÇ�ÈqÃ=Æq¼�Ç�Ã�¸�¹q¶�ºq·¿Ì{˳¶�ÇYÊ?»YÃq»Y·¿Ë!¹f¾�ÇYÊ�¼¿¶�½{æÁ¼�¹(·¿ÇYÈ=¸�Ì{ÃqÉ(ë���ï�ñ0Î}óyø�¹=Ìͼk¼�Èq·�µY¶�¾¦Ð+¶�Ê�Ç^Ë�Èq¼nÇ�Ãq½�¾�Ç�æÇYº=¸�Ì{Å »Y½�ÂKÇ�ÈqÃqÆ=¼³À�¹qÇCÐI¶Sµ�¶�·³À�Ð}¹qÌÍË!¹¦Ê�Ç�½{½ÍÇCÐ Ê�·¿ÇYÅ »�ÆqÌPo÷¶�·¿¶�Ãu¸rº=·¿ÇVÇYÊ»Yºqº=·¿Çf»YË!¹÷Î

þ^ºK¶s»YõuÌÍÃ=É�ÇYÊ*Ð}¹qÌ{Ë!¹*Àu¸�¹q¶�Ê�Ç�½Í½{ÇdÐ}Ì{ÃqÉ�/:ÞY×QØ|ÞYÒ0ØÚÛ:ßKÞYâ�ØÔß÷Õ��³ä=ÞYâ\ØÔÒ0à}Ë!¹Á»Y·¿»YË�¸¿¶³·�ÌÍús»:¸�ÌÍÇYàÇYÊ 2 »Y·�Æq·¿Ç�º�¶³öuÈqÌiô½ÍÌ{Âq·¿ÌÍ»=ÀfÆqÈq¶�¸�ÇÜþ^Å�Ì{¸¿¹¦ë¢ï�ü�ñ0À^Ð}Ì{½Í½�ºq½�»s¾ »)˳·�Èq˳ÌÍ»Y½K·¿Ç�½{¶�ÌÍÃ�Ç�Èq·�È=ºqº8¶�·IÂKÇ�ÈqÃqÆ�ÇYÃ�¸�¹q¶�ºq·¿Ì{˳¶kÇYÊG»�ÃÁ»Y·¿Ë!¹f¾YÎF � JK<�J OnG��qG@J � X B � EqT�����Y[Z�� A�Û%C@E�ÝsÕ¿Þ:áSØgf³âÍÕÝsÛ:×_�'��+b�� ���kØÍá�Þ � ÞY× 0Y×�Û!Ö Õ��³äVØÔâ\Øgf³×QØÔä . Ø ÝrÞYßm0�Û:ßÁâ\àØ Ý &

SWV1X�#S�yEJS � E%S�� &

S/V�X�US\�E%SJ�OE��S

ÝsÛ:×�Õ /YÕS×QàA}Û%C9E � ÝsÕ¿Þ:áSØgf³âÍÕÝsÛ:× g' �Ob0� ��� �ê�·¿Ç�ºKÇ�¼�Ì{¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�^Π˳»YÃѶ³»Y¼¿Ì{½{¾¦ÂK¶ÜÆq¶³·�Ì{µY¶³Æé»Y¼�»YÃÑÇ�º=¸¿ÌÍÅ�»Y½ÍÌ�¸y¾�Ë�Ç�ÃqÆqÌ�¸�Ì{Ç�æÊ�Ç�·rÅ�Ì{ÃqÌÍÅ�ÌÍú�¶³·¿¼�ÇYÊI¸¿¹q¶�º8Ç�ô¸�¶�Ãf¸�Ì�»�½÷Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYà 3�.�SÎ � Ç�·"¼�ÌÍÅ�ºq½ÍÌ{˳Ì�¸y¾�ÀuÐI¶�ÌÍÃq¼o¸�¶³»YÆ�É�Ì{µY¶�»�¼�¹qÇ�·�¸�ÆqÌ{·¿¶�Ë�¸}ºq·�Ç^ÇYÊ`Î� ×�ÛCÛ`Ý�� �k¶�æqÃqÌ{¸¿ÌÍÇ�à �^Î �r¶s»Y¼�Ìͽ�¾�ÌÍÅ�ºq½{ÌͶ³¼�¸�¹Á»:¸�»��ÁÇCÐeE¦Ì{¼}» 2 »Y·�Æq·¿ÇYº�¶�öVÈ=ÌͽÍÌ{Âq·¿Ì{ÈqÅ Ì{Ê�»YÃqÆ�Ç�Ãq½�¾�Ì{Ê&

I[V]\�#IHyEt� E%I� &

I[V1\�UI�yEL�OE��I 8���

Ê�Ç�·}¶�µY¶³·o¾i�ÁÇCÐLE � Ê�¶s»Y¼�ÌÍÂq½{¶nÊ�Ç�· �'��+b�� ���QÎ 2 ·¿Ì{¸¿ÌÍÃqÉ��UI�yEL� e Y SWV1I �US\�E%SJ��»YÃ=Æ�·¿¶Sµ�¶�·¿¼¿Ì{ÃqÉ�¸¿¹q¶)ÇY·¿Æq¶�·ÇYÊA¼¿ÈqÅ�Å�»�¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�Ç�Ã�Â8Ç�¸�¹�¼¿Ì{Æq¶³¼�ÇYÊ "���+¸�¹q¶�Ã�º=·¿ÇCµ�¶�¼�¸¿¹q¶rºq·¿Ç�ºKÇ�¼�Ì{¸�Ì{Ç�Ã*Î

� �1? F � G � ?(J����K�19����%���2 ¶k˳Ç�Ã=˳½ÍÈ=Æq¶�¸�¹=¶kºq·¿¶�½ÍÌ{Å�Ì{ÃÁ»Y·¿Ì{¶³¼�Âf¾�Æq¶�æÁÃ=ÌÍÃqÉ�¸¿¹q¶kºq·�ÌÍ˳¶�ÇYÊG»YÃÁ»�·¿Ë!¹f¾�Î+þ^Ì{Ãq˳¶�¸¿¹qÌͼ+Æq¶�æqÃqÌ{¸¿ÌÍÇ�à»YÌÍÅ�¼�¸¿ÇöuÈÁ»YÃf¸�Ì�ÊÔ¾�¸�¹q¶�Ì{Ãq¶�ÿ�Ë�ÌͶ³Ã=Ë�¾�ÇYÊ�»YÃ(¶�öVÈ=ÌͽÍÌ{Âq·¿Ì{ÈqÅ�ÀÁÌ{¸�·¿¶³öuÈqÌ{·¿¶�¼n»YÃ(Ç�Âuû�¶³Ë�¸¿Ì{µY¶�Ê�ÈqÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã÷Î 2 ¶�»YÆqÇYº=¸k¸�¹=¶Èq¼�ÈÁ»Y½*Ç�Âuû�¶³Ë�¸¿Ì{µY¶kÊ�ÈqÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�Ê�·¿Ç�Å Å�Ì{Ã^ôyË�Ç�¼�¸+Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õ �ÁÇCÐrÀÁ»YÃ=Æ�Æq¶�æÁÃ=¶k¸�¹q¶�Ù!ÛCáSÒ��p�Et��Ç�Ê�»<�qÇdÐ�E�Ì{Ã�'��+b�� �&��»Y¼

� yEt�+e &I[V1\

�UI�yEt� E%I e &S/V�X

�US\�E%SJ�OEJS]- 0ü��

Ï"¹q¶ÜæÁ·¿¼o¸�¶³öuÈÁ»Y½{Ì{¸y¾¦Ì{à |ü��kÌͼr»�Æq¶�æqÃqÌ{¸¿ÌÍÇ�à 3�¸¿¹q¶�¼�¶³Ë�Ç�ÃqÆÑÊ�ÇY½Í½ÍÇCÐ}¼kÊ�·�Ç�Å ¸¿¹q¶�¼¿»YÅ�¶�·�¶�µY¶³·¿¼¿»Y½?ÇYÊ�¼�ÈqÅ�¼»Y¼�ÌÍÃѸ¿¹q¶ º=·¿ÇVÇYÊ"ÇYÊ�ê�·¿ÇYº8Ç�¼�Ì{¸¿ÌÍÇ�à �^Î Îah �ÁÇCÐ Ê�¶s»Y¼�ÌÍÂq½{¶�Ê�ÇY·)»YÃ¥ÌÍÃq¼o¸!»YÃqË�¶ g' �+b�� �&�nÌͼ�Û!ÖKÒ0Ø .�ÞYâ*Ì�Ê"Ì{¸Å�ÌÍÃqÌ{Å�Ì{ú³¶³¼r¸�¹=¶�˳Ç�¼o¸ÜÇdµY¶³·�»Y½{½�Ê�¶³»Y¼¿Ì{Âq½Í¶ �qÇdÐ}¼�Î 5 ¶�Ës»YÈq¼�¶�˳Ç�¼o¸�Ê�ÈqÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã=¼Ü»Y·¿¶�Ë�Ç�Ãf¸�Ì{ÃVÈ=Ç�Èq¼�»YÃqÆé¸�¹=¶¼¿ºq»Y˳¶�ÇYÊ �ÁÇCÐ}¼�Ì{¼}˳Ç�Å�ºÁ»YËS¸sÀq¶Sµ�¶³·o¾�ÌÍÃq¼o¸!»YÃ=˳¶�»YÆqÅ�Ì{¸¿¼"»YÃ�Ç�º=¸�Ì{Å »�½ �ÁÇCÐrÎ

2 ¶+ÃqÇCÐxÆq¶�æqÃq¶+¸¿¹q¶Iºq·�ÌÍË�¶+ÇYÊÁ»YÃÁ»Y·�Ë!¹u¾�»Y¼G¸�¹q¶+·�»�¸¿ÌÍÇ}ÂK¶�¸yÐ+¶³¶³Ã�¸¿¹q¶+Ë�Ç�¼�¸�ÇYÊ�» 2 »Y·�Æq·¿ÇYº)¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌ{Âq·¿Ì{ÈqÅ»YÃqÆ�ÇYÊ�»YÃ�Ç�º=¸¿ÌÍÅ�»Y½ �ÁÇCÐrÎ� ?!�s� Gw� GDJm� X B�� EqT��������� Y[Z Ï"¹q¶kÖK×QØÚÙ!Õ�Û`Ý�ÞYßKÞY×�Ù!ÓVà��[�'��+b�� �&�IÇYÊ�»YÃ�Ì{Ãq¼�¸�»YÃqË�¶pg' �Ob0� ���IÌ{¼

�[g' �+b�� �&��e � yEL�� yE � � �

Ð}¹q¶�·¿¶E�Ì{¼�» 2 »Y·�Æq·¿ÇYº�¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌÍÂ=·¿ÌÍÈ=Å »YÃqÆ�E � Ìͼ�»YÃ�Ç�º=¸¿ÌÍÅ�»Y½ �ÁÇCÐxÊ�Ç�· �'��+b�� ���QÎAÏ"¹=¶+ÖK×QØÚÙ!Õ�Û`Ý�ÞYßKÞY×!Ù!ÓVà�[�� ��ÇYÊ�»�Ã=Ç�Ã^ôy¶�Å�º^¸y¾�¼¿¶S¸��ìÇYÊ�Ì{Ãq¼�¸�»YÃqË�¶³¼}Ìͼ"¼�Èqº��! �" #$" %'& V)( �[�'��+b�� ���QÎ

ý

Page 8: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

�k¶�æqÃqÌ{¸¿ÌÍÇ�à �VÎ ��»YÃ=Æ ê�·�Ç�º8ÇY¼¿Ì{¸¿ÌÍÇ�à �^Î ü7|Âu�)¶³»Y¼¿Ì{½{¾ÑÌÍÅ�ºq½{¾§¸�¹q»�¸Ü»Y½{½ 2 »Y·¿Æq·�Ç�ºx¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌÍÂ=·¿Ì�»�¹Á»sµ�¶�¶³öuÈÁ»�½Ë³ÇY¼�¸sÀK»YÃ=Æ�¸�¹uÈq¼}¸�¹=¶�ºq·�ÌÍË�¶�Ç�Ê�»YÃÁ»�·¿Ë!¹f¾�ÇYÊ�»YÃ�ÌÍÃ=¼�¸!»�Ãq˳¶�Ìͼ"Ð+¶³½Í½�Æq¶SæÁÃq¶�Æ(ÈqÃq½{¶³¼¿¼}¸�¹=¶³·¿¶�Ìͼ�»N�ÁÇCÐ Ð}Ì{¸¿¹ú³¶�·¿ÇÜ˳ÇY¼�¸sÎ�óyÃ�¸¿¹qÌͼ�˳»Y¼¿¶�À�»Y½Í½ 2 »Y·¿Æq·�Ç�º�¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌÍÂ=·¿Ì�»�»Y½{¼¿Ç�¹Á»sµ�¶rú�¶³·¿Ç�Ë�Ç�¼�¸³À�»YÃqÆ�Ð+¶rÆq¶�æÁÃ=¶k¸�¹q¶nºq·�ÌÍË�¶kÇYÊ»YÃÁ»�·¿Ë!¹f¾�ÇYÊG¸�¹q¶rÌÍÃ=¼�¸!»�Ãq˳¶n¸�ÇÜÂK¶ ��Î

� ��� ���$/ �=��#������U���.!��� ?!�s� Gw� GDJm� J���J�1?_F GDIKJ L �QJ L � �ê�ÌÍÉ�ÇYÈt� ¼n¶Qò=»YÅ�º=½Í¶Ü»YÃqÆÄÌ{¸¿¼nÃqÇ�Ãq½{ÌÍÃq¶³»Y·�µ�»Y·�Ì�»YÃf¸ ÚþVÈqÂq¼¿¶�Ë�¸¿ÌÍÇ�à ��Î �.��¼¿¹qÇCÐ ¸¿¹Á»�¸n¸¿¹q¶Üºq·¿Ì{˳¶ÜÇYÊI»YÃÁ»Y·�Ë!¹u¾ÇYÊr¼�¶³½{æq¼¿¹&·¿ÇYÈ=¸�Ì{ÃqÉ¥Æq¶�º8¶�ÃqÆq¼�À�»�¸�¸�¹q¶�µ�¶³·o¾ì½{¶s»Y¼o¸sÀ"Ç�à ¸¿¹q¶�¸y¾VºK¶(ÇYÊr˳ÇY¼�¸ Ê�È=ÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãq¼�»Y½Í½{ÇdÐ+¶³Æ÷Î 2 ¶Ð}Ìͽ{½A¸¿¹q¶³·�¶�Ê�Ç�·�¶ »YÌ{Å Ê�Ç�·r»�ÂKÇ�ÈqÃqÆÄÇ�æ¸�¹q¶�ºq·�ÌÍ˳¶�Ç�Ê"»YÃÁ»�·¿Ë!¹f¾¦¸�¹Á»:¸rÌͼrºÁ»Y·¿»YÅ�¶S¸�¶�·¿ÌÍú�¶³Æ§Âf¾¦¸�¹q¶Ü¼�¶�¸�ÇYÊ»Y½{½ÍÇCÐ�»�Âq½Í¶�˳Ç�¼o¸�Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼³À=»YÃqÆ�¸¿¹Á»�¸"Ì{¼IÇ�º=¸¿ÌÍÅ�»Y½ÁÊ�Ç�·I¶³»YË!¹�¼¿ÈqË!¹�¼�¶�¸sÎ \ Ç�Å�Å�Ç�à¶Qòq»�Å�ºq½{¶³¼�Ç�Ê�¼¿¶�¸¿¼"ÇYÊ˳ÇY¼�¸}Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃq¼}ÌÍÃqË�½ÍÈqÆq¶n½{ÌÍÃq¶³»Y·IÊ�ÈqÃ=Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼�Àqº8ÇY½{¾VÃqÇ�Å�Ì�»Y½{¼³À^»YÃqÆ�öuÈq¶³È=¶³ÌÍÃ=É Æq¶�½�»s¾ Ê�ÈqÃ=Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼�Î

� Ç�·�¶Sµ�¶�·�¾(¼�¶�¸éÇYÊ?»�½Í½ÍÇCÐI»YÂq½{¶�Ë�Ç�¼�¸�Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃq¼³À8ê�ÌÍÉ�Ç�ÈVôy½ÍÌ{õY¶r¶Sò=»YÅ�ºq½{¶³¼�ºq·¿ÇCµVÌÍÆq¶)»�ÃÁ»:¸�Èq·¿»Y½A½{ÇCÐI¶�·ÂKÇ�ÈqÃqÆ�Ç�Ã�¸¿¹q¶rºq·¿Ì{˳¶rÇYÊ»YÃÁ»Y·�Ë!¹u¾�Ç�ÊÌÍÃ=¼�¸!»�Ãq˳¶�¼�Ð}Ì�¸�¹�˳Ç�¼o¸�Ê�ÈqÃ=Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼}ÌÍÃ�Î"þ^ºK¶³Ë�Ì{æÁ˳»Y½Í½�¾�Àq¼�ÈqºqºKÇ�¼¿¶�˳ÇYÃu¸�»YÌÍÃ=¼r»Y½Í½AÇYÊ+¸¿¹q¶�˳ÇYÃq¼�¸�»YÃf¸�Ë�Ç�¼�¸nÊ�È=ÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãq¼�ÀG»YÃqƧË!¹qÇVÇ�¼¿¶�»�˳ÇY¼�¸rÊ�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃ]�� NG� »YÃqÆÄ»�¸�·¿»�ÿ�Ë·�»:¸�¶ b � �=Î7x�¶�¸ � � G� Æq¶³ÃqÇ�¸�¶ ¸¿¹q¶ Ë�Ç�¼�¸�Ê�ÈqÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�ÃѶ�µY¶³·�¾uÐ}¹q¶�·¿¶�¶³öuÈÁ»�½�¸¿Ç �� �gb��SÎ \ Ç�Ãq¼�ÌÍÆq¶�·�¸�¹=¶Èq¼�ÈÁ»Y½¸yÐ+Ç�ôyÃqÇVÆq¶�À�¸yÐ+Ç�ô�½ÍÌÍÃ=õ�Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇY·¿õ¦ÇYÊ+ê�ÌÍÉ�ÇYÈt� ¼n¶Qò=»YÅ�º=½Í¶ � ÌÍÉ�Èq·�¶ �.�QÀ�É�Ì{µY¶�¸�¹q¶ÜÈqºqºK¶³·�»YÃ=ÆĽ{ÇCÐI¶�·¶³Æ=É�¶³¼}¸�¹q¶�˳ÇY¼�¸�Ê�ÈqÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã=¼)� � »�ÃqÆ_�� CÀÁ·¿¶�¼¿ºK¶³ËS¸�Ì{µY¶³½�¾�À8»YÃqÆ�¼¿¶�¸�¸�¹=¶�¸¿·�»�ÿ�Ë�·�»�¸¿¶r¸¿Ç�ÂK¶rb^Î 0�ÇYÈ=¸�Ì{ÃqÉ�»Y½Í½¸�·¿»�ÿ�Ë}Ç�Ã�¸¿¹q¶}½ÍÇCÐ+¶³·?¶³ÆqÉY¶}¾VÌ{¶³½ÍÆ=¼?» 2 »Y·¿Æ=·¿Ç�ºÜ¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌ{Âq·¿Ì{ÈqÅ�Ð}Ì�¸�¹Ü˳ÇY¼�¸ �� .wb��/b^ÎAÏ"¹q¶�ºq·¿Ì{˳¶"ÇYÊ*»YÃÁ»Y·�Ë!¹u¾ÌÍÃ�¸¿¹qÌͼ"Ì{Ãq¼�¸�»YÃq˳¶rÌ{¼�¸�¹uÈq¼

Å�»:ò-������ # b8d �� �wb�� cd �� �@ ,��� gb � ,�"�� .wb�� -

�k¶�æqÃqÌ{¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãn�VÎ ð�ÂK¶³½ÍÇCÐ Èq¼¿¶�¼�¸¿¹qÌͼI¶Sò^ºq·¿¶�¼¿¼�ÌÍÇ�Ã�ÂqÈ=¸}ÆqÇV¶³¼}ÃqÇY¸}Ë�Ç�Ãq¼o¸�·�»�ÌÍà �Ê�·�Ç�Å »�Â8ÇCµ�¶rÂf¾Kb 3q¼¿Ì{Ãq˳¶ �� Ìͼ"Ã=Ç�ÃqÆq¶�˳·¿¶³»Y¼¿Ì{ÃqÉqÀq¸¿¹qÌͼ}Å�Ç^ÆqÌ�æÁËs»:¸�ÌÍÇYÃ�ÆqÇV¶³¼}ÃqÇY¸�»�o8¶³ËS¸}¸�¹q¶nµ�»Y½ÍÈ=¶nÇYÊA¸¿¹q¶rÅ »dò=Ì{Å�ÈqÅ�Î

2 ¶r˳»YÃ�ÃqÇCÐ Ç�Â=¸�»YÌÍÃ�»�½{ÇdÐ+¶³·}ÂKÇ�ÈqÃqÆ�Ç�Ã�¸¿¹q¶rºq·¿Ì{˳¶nÇYÊ�»YÃÁ»Y·�Ë!¹f¾�Âf¾�Ë!¹qÇVÇ�¼¿Ì{ÃqÉ�¸�¹q¶r˳ÇY¼�¸"Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�� �»YÃ=Æ�¸¿¹q¶n¸�·�»:ÿ�Ën·¿»�¸�¶zb�Ì{Ã�¸�¹q¶rÅ�Ç�¼�¸}ºK¶³·�ÃqÌÍË�ÌÍÇ�Èq¼�ÐI»s¾�º8ÇY¼¿¼¿Ì{Âq½Í¶�Î� ?!�s� Gw� GDJm� X B�� EqT XMV ����� Y[Z x�¶�¸� ÂK¶�»¦ÃqÇ�Ãq¶�Å�º=¸y¾ ¼¿¶�¸�ÇYÊ�Ë�Ç�¼�¸ÜÊ�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼³Î¥Ï"¹q¶ � Ø�åVÛ:ä9fSÛ:äVßm0� ���+Ê�Ç�·�ÑÌ{¼

� �+��eù¼¿Èqº% V�� ¼�Èqº� " #�� - b8dq�5gb�� dq��� ,��� gb � ,���5gb�� � �

Ð}Ì{¸¿¹�¸�¹q¶rÈqÃqÆ=¶³·¿¼o¸!»YÃ=ÆqÌÍÃqÉܸ�¹q»�¸ �Rp�� e ��Î

687:9�;=< >@? O2 ¹qÌ{½Í¶ ¸¿¹q¶�Æq¶�æqÃqÌÍÃqɧ¶�öVÈq»�¸�Ì{Ç�à �)ÇYÊ}¸¿¹q¶�ê?Ì{É�Ç�ÈéÂKÇ�ÈqÃqÆxÅ�»s¾é»YºqºK¶s»�·�Ê�¶s»Y·�¼¿Ç�Å�¶ ¸�ǧ¶SµY»�½ÍÈÁ»�¸¿¶YÀ?Ì{¸¼¿Ì{Å�º=½ÍÌ{æq¶³¼I¸¿Ç�»�Ë�½ÍÇ�¼�¶³Æ^ôÚÊ�Ç�·¿Å ¶Sò^ºq·¿¶�¼¿¼�ÌÍÇ�Ã�Ê�Ç�·"Å »�Ãu¾�ÌÍÃf¸�¶�·¿¶³¼o¸�Ì{ÃqÉܼ¿¶�¸¿¼�Ç�Ê�Ë�Ç�¼�¸}Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼³Î687:9�;=< >@? X B V E T ��� � ��� Y[Z ó�Ê� e P�R �� �] � � � � T)Ì{¼�¸�¹q¶�¼¿¶S¸�Ç�ʽÍÌ{Ãq¶s»�·�˳Ç�¼o¸}Ê�ÈqÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã=¼³Àq¸�¹=¶³Ã¶³½{¶³Å�¶³Ãf¸!»�·�¾�˳»Y½ÍË�Èq½�»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã=¼I¼¿¹=ÇdÐE¸�¹Á»�¸ � �+��e pYü=ÎÏ"¹uÈq¼)bò=»YÅ�ºq½{¶ ��Î �rÆq¶S¸�¶�·¿Å�ÌÍÃq¶�¼}¸¿¹q¶�ê�ÌÍÉ�Ç�È�ÂKÇ�ÈqÃqÆ�Ê�Ç�·"½{ÌÍÃq¶³»Y·�˳ÇY¼�¸}Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃq¼³Î687:9�;=< >@? X B � E T XMV Y[Z þVÌÍÅ�Ìͽ�»�·¿½{¾YÀuÌ{Ê�ÑÌͼ�¸�¹=¶�¼�¶�¸�ÇYÊA˳Ç�Ãq˳»sµ�¶�˳Ç�¼o¸�Ê�È=ÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãq¼�Àq¸�¹q¶�à � �+��e pYü=Î

Page 9: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

687:9�;=< >@? X B�� E T ��� Y[Z ó�Ê (Ìͼ?¸�¹q¶�¼¿¶S¸�ÇYÊ�ºKÇ�½{¾VÃqÇYÅ�ÌÍ»Y½Í¼�Ð}Ì�¸�¹�ÃqÇ�ÃqÃq¶�Éf»�¸¿Ì{µ�¶�˳ÇV¶�ÿ�˳Ì{¶³Ãf¸�¼�»YÃqÆ�Æq¶�É�·¿¶�¶»�¸}Å�Ç�¼�¸ �*Àq¸�¹q¶�Ã

� ���+e ë�� ��d �+� �.� � � � ��� & � � ñ � � - Úí��h�¼ ��É�·¿ÇCÐ}¼}½�»�·¿É�¶�À^¸�¹=¶�·�ÌÍÉ�¹f¸oôy¹Á»YÃ=Æ�¼�ÌÍÆq¶rÇYÊSÚí��+¸¿¶³ÃqÆq¼}¸�ÇÜÌ{Ã=æÁÃqÌ�¸y¾�»Y¼ � p½Íà � ë���ü=Àqï�ï�ñ0ÎÏ"¹q¶r·¿Ì{É�¹f¸�ô�¹Á»YÃqÆ�¼�ÌÍÆq¶nÇYÊSÚí��IÌ{¼�¼¿Ì{Å�ºq½�¾�¸¿¹q¶rºq·¿Ì{˳¶nÇYÊA»YÃq»Y·¿Ë!¹f¾�ÌÍÃ�¸¿¹q¶rÃqÇ�Ãq½{ÌÍÃq¶³»Y·+µ�»Y·�Ì�»YÃf¸}ÇYÊAê�ÌÍÉYÇ�Èt�Sò=»YÅ�ºq½{¶kÆqÌͼ�˳Èq¼�¼¿¶�Æ�ÌÍÃ�þVÈqÂq¼¿¶�Ë�¸¿ÌÍÇ�à ��Î ��Î�Ï"¹q¶�ê�ÌÍÉ�Ç�È�ÂKÇ�ÈqÃ=Æ�Ê�ÇY·S|ÃqÇYÃqÆq¶³Ë�·¿¶³»Y¼¿Ì{ÃqÉ���Â8ÇYÈqÃqÆq¶�Æ^ôyÆq¶�É�·¿¶�¶ºKÇ�½{¾VÃqÇ�Å�Ì�»�½Í¼�Ð}Ì�¸�¹ »�·¿ÂqÌ�¸�·�»�·�¾¦Ë�Ç^¶Sÿ�Ë�ÌͶ�Ãu¸¿¼)Ì{¼�ÃqÇ�¸�Ð+¶³½{½�È=ÃqÆq¶³·�¼�¸¿Ç^ÇVÆ*ÀA¸¿¹qÇ�ÈqÉY¹¥ºÁ»Y·o¸�ÌÍ»Y½�·¿¶�¼¿Èq½�¸�¼)¹q»CµY¶·¿¶�˳¶�Ãu¸¿½{¾�ÂK¶³¶�Ã�Ç�Â^¸!»YÌ{Ãq¶³Æ�Âf¾�þ^Ç�ëîï ñÚÎ�c? ;=9��J$ X BDA � ´kÃq¶�Ç�Ê�¸¿¹q¶�Å�Ç�¼�¸�º8Ç�º=Èq½�»Y·�¸y¾Vº8¶�¼�Ç�Ê�Ë�Ç�¼�¸�Ê�È=ÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãq¼)ÌÍà ¸�·¿»YÃq¼�º8Ç�·o¸!»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã¥¼¿Ë³Ì{¶³ÃqË�¶»Yºqº=½ÍÌÍ˳»�¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼�Ìͼ�öuÈÁ»�·�¸�Ì{Ë�Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼�Ð}Ì{¸¿¹&ÃqÇ�ÃqÃ=¶³Éf»�¸¿Ì{µY¶(˳ÇV¶�ÿ�˳Ì{¶³Ãf¸�¼�¼¿¶³¶¦¶�Î É=Î}þ^¹q¶Sÿ ë¢ï��:ñ��SÎ�Ï"¹q¶ê�ÌÍÉ�ÇYÈ�ÂKÇ�ÈqÃ=Æ 0í��+Ê�Ç�·"¼¿È=Ë!¹�Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼"Ìͼ"·�Ç�ÈqÉ�¹=½{¾n�VÎ �díVÎ

´kÈq· æÁÃÁ»�½�¶Qòq»�Å�ºq½{¶�Ì{¼�Ê�Ç�·�¸�¹q¶(Æ=¶³½�»s¾xÊ�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼ Ç�Ê �������P�¦öuÈq¶�Èq¶³¼ �ùöuÈq¶�Èq¶³¼�Ð}Ì{¸¿¹&êAÇ�Ì{¼¿¼�Ç�ûY·�·¿Ì{µ�»Y½{¼�»YÃqÆ�¶Sò^ºKÇ�Ãq¶�Ãu¸¿Ì�»Y½{½{¾�ÆqÌͼo¸�·¿Ì{ÂqÈ=¸¿¶³Æ�¼¿¶³·oµVÌÍ˳¶�¸¿ÌÍÅ�¶³¼ �ìÐ}¹qÌÍË!¹�»Y·�¶�Ë�Ç�Å�Å�Ç�ÃnÌ{Ãr˳Ç�Å�ºqÈ=¸¿¶³·�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õ»Yºqº=½ÍÌÍ˳»�¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼ |¼�¶³¶+¶YÎîÉqÎqë����=À�����ñi�QÎ�Ï"¹q¶�¼¿¶�Æq¶�½�»s¾rÊ�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃq¼�Ë�Ç�·¿·�¶³¼¿ºKÇ�ÃqÆ�¸�Ç�Ë�Ç�¼�¸AÊ�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃq¼�ÇYÊ=¸�¹q¶�Ê�Ç�·¿Å�5@ ,�$e �qp7�� U ,�SÀ�Ð}¹q¶�·¿¶��¥Ë³»YÃÑÂK¶�ÌÍÃf¸¿¶³·¿º=·¿¶�¸¿¶³Æ¥»Y¼r»YÃĶ³ÆqÉ�¶Ü˳»YºÁ»YË�Ì{¸y¾(ÇY·r»�öuÈq¶�Èq¶�¼¿¶³·oµVÌÍ˳¶�·�»:¸�¶YÎÏ"¹q¶�µ�»Y½{Èq¶�ÇYÊn¼¿È=Ë!¹ù»ÄÊ�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�à Ì{¼�Æq¶SæÁÃq¶�Æù¸¿Ç¥ÂK¶ �� Ð}¹q¶�à ���Î h�½Í½{ÇCÐ}ÌÍÃqɧÌÍÃ^æÁÃqÌ{¸¿¶�Ë�Ç�¼�¸¿¼·¿¶�öuÈqÌÍ·�¶³¼ ¼�Ç�Å�¶�¸�¶�Ë!¹qÃqÌ{Ës»Y½�Å�ÇVÆqÌ�æÁËs»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã=¼�¸�ÇѸ¿¹q¶�¼�¶³½�æÁ¼¿¹ì·�Ç�È=¸¿ÌÍÃqÉÄÅ�ÇVÆq¶�½}¸¿¹Á»�¸�ÐI¶�ÌÍÉ�ÃqÇY·¿¶�ÌÍÃx¸�¹qÌ{¼¼¿È=·�µ�¶S¾ 38¼�¶³¶ ë ���Cñ�Ê�Ç�·"Å�Ç�·¿¶nÆq¶S¸!»YÌ{½Í¼�Î

Ï"¹q¶(ê�Ì{É�Ç�ÈçÂ8Ç�È=ÃqÆ Ê�Ç�·�¸¿¹q¶�¼�¶�¸ ÇYÊS�������P��Æ=¶³½�»s¾éÊ�ÈqÃ=Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼�Ìͼ'�� ë �:ñ0ÎìóyÃf¸�ÈqÌ�¸�Ì�µ�¶³½�¾�À�¸�¹qÌ{¼Ê�Ç�½{½ÍÇCÐ}¼+Ê�·�Ç�Å�bò=»YÅ�ºq½{¶S�^Î ï)Â8¶�Ës»YÈ=¼¿¶�»Yà �������P�nÆq¶³½Í»s¾�Ê�ÈqÃ=Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�ÂK¶³¹Á»sµY¶³¼}½ÍÌ{õY¶k»�ºKÇ�½�¾^Ã=Ç�Å�ÌÍ»Y½qÐ}Ì{¸¿¹»Y·�ÂqÌ{¸¿·�»Y·�Ìͽ{¾)½�»Y·�É�¶}Æq¶³ÉY·¿¶³¶�Ð}¹q¶³Ã�Ì�¸+Ì{¼IÃq¶³»Y·¿½�¾Ü¼�»�¸¿Èq·�»:¸�¶³Æ÷Î�óyÃ�»YÃÁ»Y½{Ç�ÉY¾�¸¿Ç�·¿¶�¼�¸¿·¿ÌÍËS¸�Ì{ÃqÉ�¸¿¹q¶kºKÇ�½{¾VÃqÇYÅ�ÌÍ»Y½Æq¶�É�·¿¶�¶�Ì{ÃUbò=»YÅ�ºq½{¶r�VÎ ï=À�Ð+¶�Ì{Å�ºKÇ�¼�¶�»§½{ÇCÐI¶�·�ÂKÇ�ÈqÃ=Æ��� 4��¦Ç�à »Y½Í½+öuÈq¶³Èq¶�¼¿¶�·�µVÌÍË�¶�·¿»�¸�¶�¼�»YÃqÆ »YÃÈqºqºK¶³·}ÂKÇ�ÈqÃqÆ��� �� � Ç�Ã�¸�¹q¶nµ�»Y½{Èq¶k¸�¹Á»:¸"¸�¹q¶n¸�·¿»�ÿ�Ër·�»�¸¿¶rb)Ës»YÃ�¸!»Yõ�¶rÇ�Ã�ÌÍà �QÎ687:9�;=< >@? X BDAKA�EqT���� Y[Z þ^È=ºqº8ÇY¼¿¶��� �� ��� �� 4���»YÃ=Æѽ{¶�¸ e PP��� ,� � � � ���� 4���T Â8¶Ü¸�¹=¶¼¿¶S¸rÇYÊ �������P��Æq¶³½Í»s¾�Ê�ÈqÃ=Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼�Ð}Ì�¸�¹(¼�¶³·oµ^Ì{˳¶�·¿»�¸�¶�»:¸k½Í¶³»Y¼�¸��� 4��VÎrx�¶�¸ � ���}Æq¶³Ã=ÇY¸�¶�¸¿¹q¶�½�»�·¿É�¶�¼�¸�ôºKÇ�¼¿¼�ÌÍÂq½{¶�ºq·�ÌÍË�¶�ÇYÊ�»�ÃÁ»Y·¿Ë!¹f¾�ÌÍÃ�ê�ÌÍÉ�Ç�ÈVôy½ÍÌ{õY¶rÃq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õu¼kÐ}Ì{¸�¹�˳Ç�¼o¸�Ê�ÈqÃ=Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼�ÌÍà x»YÃqÆ�¸�·�»:ÿ�Ë�·�»�¸¿¶)»:¸Å�Ç�¼�¸��� �� � Î � Ç�·�Å »Y½{½{¾YÀ � ����Ì{¼�É�Ì{µY¶³Ã�Âf¾ �AÐ}Ì{¸¿¹�¸�¹q¶�»YÆqÆ=Ì{¸�Ì{Ç�ÃÁ»Y½V·¿¶�¼�¸¿·¿ÌÍËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�¸�¹Á»�¸� �Ob ���� �� � Î4�Ï"¹q¶�Ã

� ����e �� � �"! �� 4#��� 4#� $�� �� �&% - 0ð��

Ï"¹q¶�·�ÌÍÉ�¹f¸oôy¹Á»YÃ=Æ�¼�ÌÍÆq¶�ÇYÊ 0ð���¸�¶�ÃqÆq¼�¸¿Ç ÌÍÃ^æÁÃqÌ{¸y¾�»Y¼��� �� � % �� 4#�=À8ÂqÈ=¸kÌ{¼�ÂKÇ�ÈqÃ=Æq¶³Æ(Âf¾�»�Ë�Ç�Ãq¼�¸�»YÃf¸Ì{Ê��� �� � Ìͼ}»:¸}Å�Ç�¼o¸�»�Ë�Ç�Ãq¼o¸!»YÃf¸}Ê�·�»YËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�ÇYÊ'�� 4��VÎ� G ;=<S>@?)( J ��O#�+*-, 9CO�?�� ?!�U"QJ �J$:OÏ"¹q¶"ê�Ì{É�Ç�È)ÂKÇ�ÈqÃ=Æ�Èq¼¿¶�¼�Ç�Ãq½�¾r¼¿ÌÍÅ�ºq½{¶�Ã=¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õu¼¸�Ç�ºq·¿ÇCµVÌÍÆq¶I»�½ÍÇCÐ+¶³·AÂ8Ç�È=ÃqÆ�Ç�Ã)¸¿¹q¶Iº=·¿ÌÍË�¶IÇYÊK»�ÃÁ»Y·¿Ë!¹f¾YÎþ^ºK¶³Ë�Ì{æÁ˳»Y½Í½�¾�À^¸¿¹q¶rÃq¶SòV¸�ºq·¿ÇYº8Ç�¼�Ì{¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�Ê�Ç�½{½ÍÇCÐ}¼�Ì{Å�Å�¶³ÆqÌÍ»�¸�¶�½{¾�Ê�·�Ç�Å ¸�¹=¶�Æ=¶�æÁÃqÌ�¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�ÇYÊG¸�¹q¶rÂKÇ�ÈqÃqÆ*ÎF � JK<�J OnG��qG@J � X B A X EqT�� � Y[Z�� ÕSÒ efSÕ�Þ�áCÕSÒ�Û`Ý Ù!ÛCáSÒ*ÝQäVß÷ÙSÒ|ØÚÛ:ß=áÜÒ�Ó=ÞYÒ}ØÔß÷ÙSâ\ä 0VÕ!á�ÞYâÔâ?Û`Ý�Ò�ÓÁÕ�Ù!Û:ß=áSÒ�ÞYßÁÒÝQäVß÷ÙSÒ0ØÚÛ:ß=á#"AÞYßm0râÍÕSÒ �o0VÕSß÷Û:Ò`Õ�Ò�ÓÁÕ�áSØÔßVåYâÍÕ/.¿Ù!Û0.�. Û10YØÔÒ|àkØÔß=áSÒÚÞYß÷Ù!Õ!á5C�ØÔÒÔÓ�ÞrÒ�CIÛ0.yß÷Û10VÕ#"�ÒgCIÛ0.yâ\ØÔß21�ß÷ÕSÒ�CIÛ:×31ÞYßm0�Ù!ÛCáSÒ�ÝQä^ß÷ÙSÒ|ØÚÛ:ß=árØÔß �� �*ÓÁÕSß

�[!� � � � �+�#-

ï

Page 10: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

s t

� Ì{É�Èq·¿¶�ü 2 ÇY·¿¼�¸oôy˳»Y¼¿¶�Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õu¼�Ê�Ç�·�Ì{Ãq¹qÇ�Å�Ç�É�¶�Ãq¶³ÇYÈq¼�¼¿¶S¸�¼�ÇYÊ�Ë�Ç�¼�¸ÜÊ�ÈqÃ=Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼�Î Ï"¹q¶�ÃVÈ=Å�Â8¶�·�ÇYʺÁ»�¸¿¹q¼�»YÃqÆ�¸�¹q¶rÃuÈqÅ�ÂK¶³·}ÇYÊA¶³Æ=É�¶³¼�ÌÍÃ�¶³»YË!¹�ºÁ»:¸�¹�Ës»YÃ�ÂK¶�»�·¿ÂqÌ�¸�·�»�·¿Ìͽ�¾�½�»Y·�É�¶YÎ

ó�Ê?¸�¹q¶�¼�¶�¸ çÆ=Ç^¶�¼kÃqÇY¸nË�Ç�Ãf¸!»YÌ{ç»Y½Í½GÇYÊ?¸�¹=¶�˳Ç�Ã=¼�¸!»�Ãu¸rË�Ç�¼�¸nÊ�È=ÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãq¼�À÷¸�¹=¶³Ã¦ÐI¶�˳»YæÇ�Â=¸�»YÌÍÃ�¼¿ÌÍÅ�ÌͽͻY··¿¶�¼¿Èq½�¸�¼�È=¼¿ÌÍÃ=ÉéÅ�ÇVÆq¶³¼o¸�½�¾ Å�Ç�·�¶�˳ÇYÅ�ºq½{¶Sò Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õu¼³Î � Ç�·�¶Sò=»YÅ�ºq½Í¶�À"¼¿Èqº=º8Ç�¼�¶(¸�¹q¶¦¼�¶�¸ ÇYÊr˳Ç�¼o¸Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼�ÌͼD0YØ /YÕS×!áCÕ�ÌÍÃx¸�¹q¶�¼¿¶�Ãq¼¿¶�¸�¹Á»�¸7P �5"��� (� G cT e ë ��� � �SÎìÏ"¹q¶�Ã&»Yà ¶³ÆqÉ�¶�Ð}Ì{¸¿¹ ¸�¹=¶Ë³ÇYÃq¼�¸�»YÃf¸�˳ÇY¼�¸)Ê�È=ÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã=��� ,�He�¦Ës»YÃ÷ÀAÊ�Ç�·�»Y½Í½?ºq·¿»YË�¸¿ÌÍ˳»Y½?ºqÈq·¿ºKÇ�¼�¶³¼³À�Â8¶�j�¼¿Ì{Å�Èq½�»:¸�¶³Æ k�Âf¾Ñ»�½Í»Y·¿É�¶ÃuÈqÅ�ÂK¶³·?ÇYÊ÷ºÁ»Y·�»�½Í½Í¶�½=¶�ÆqÉ�¶³¼?¸�¹q»�¸�¶s»YË!¹�¹Á»sµ�¶�»�Ë�Ç�¼�¸�Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃ�¼¿»�¸�Ì{¼�ÊÔ¾VÌÍÃ=É �5"����e ÁÎÏ"¹qÌͼ?Ç�Â=¼¿¶³·oµ�»�¸�Ì{Ç�ÃÅ�¶s»YÃq¼?¸�¹q»�¸�»�ê�ÌÍÉ�Ç�ÈVôy½ÍÌ{õY¶"Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇY·¿õÜÐ}Ì{¸�¹ »�Ë�Ç�Ãq¼�¸�»YÃf¸�Ë�Ç�¼�¸�Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYàËs»�Ã�Â8¶�·¿¶�ºq½�»�˳¶³Æ�Âf¾ »�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õÐ}Ì{¸¿¹�¸yÐ+Ç Ã=Ç^Æq¶�¼³Àc0»YÃ�ÈqÃq·�¶³¼o¸�·¿Ì{Ë�¸¿¶³Æ(ÃuÈqÅ�ÂK¶³·�ÇYÊ ��ºÁ»Y·�»�½Í½Í¶�½÷½{ÌÍÃqõu¼³ÀK»YÃ=Æ�Ë�Ç�¼�¸�Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃq¼�Ì{à ÄÐ}Ì�¸�¹qÇ�È^¸»�o8¶³ËS¸�ÌÍÃ=Éܸ¿¹q¶rºq·¿Ì{˳¶nÇYÊ�»YÃÁ»�·¿Ë!¹f¾�ÎF � JK<�J OnG��qG@J � X B A � EqT�� � Y[Z�� ÕSÒ� fSÕÄÞ 0YØ /YÕS×�áCÕ�áCÕSÒ Û`ÝÄÙ!ÛCáSÒ�ÝQä^ß÷ÙSÒ|ØÚÛ:ß=á#" ÞYßm0çâÍÕSÒ � 0VÕSß÷Û:ÒyÕ¦ÒÔÓÁÕáSØÔßVåYâÍÕ/.¿Ù!Û0.�. Û10YØÔÒ|à�ØÔß=áSÒ�ÞYß÷Ù!Õ!ázC�ØÔÒÔÓ�Þ�ß÷ÕSÒgCIÛ:×31�Û`ÝIÖ=ÞY×�ÞYâÔâÍÕSâ*â\ØÔß21Cá)ÞYßm0�Ù!ÛCáSÒ�ÝQä^ß÷ÙSÒ|ØÚÛ:ß=árØÔß 1� �*ÓÁÕSß

�[!� � � � �+�#-Ï"¹q¶�¼¿¶S¸�Ç�Ê�Ë�Ç�¼�¸}Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼}ÌÍÃ(b�ò=»YÅ�º=½Í¶ �^Î ���rÌͼ"ÃqÇ�¸�Æ=Ì{µ�¶�·¿¼�¶rÐ}¹=¶³Ã��� 4�� �^ÀÁÂqÈ=¸�Ì{¸"Ì{¼rØÔß=ÓÁÛ0. Û¿åVÕ/.ß÷Õ!Û:äfá�Ì{Ã�¸�¹=¶�¼¿¶³Ã=¼¿¶�¸�¹Á»:¸nÌ{¸�˳Ç�Ãf¸!»�ÌÍÃq¼n» Ê�È=ÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã]�rÐ}Ì{¸�¹]�5"��� �^Î h�¼nÌÍæê�·�Ç�º8ÇY¼¿Ì{¸¿ÌÍÇ�à �^Î �sü=À÷¸�¹=¶ê�ÌÍÉ�ÇYÈ ÂKÇ�ÈqÃqÆ�·�¶³Å�»YÌÍÃq¼?µ�»Y½ÍÌ{Æ�Ê�ÇY·I¼¿È=Ë!¹�¼¿¶�¸¿¼"ÇYÊ�Ë�Ç�¼�¸�Ê�È=ÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãq¼+ºq·¿ÇCµVÌÍÆ=¶³Æ�Ð+¶n»Y½Í½{ÇCÐ켿ÇYÅ�¶SÐ}¹Á»�¸"Å�Ç�·¿¶Ë³ÇYÅ�ºq½{¶Sò§Ã=¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õu¼³Î�þVº8¶�˳Ì{æqËs»Y½{½{¾�À�½{¶�¸�»§ä^ßÁØÚÛ:ß Û`Ý�Ö=ÞYÒÔÓfánÅ�¶s»�Ã¥»�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õ§Ð}Ì�¸�¹ÄÇ�Ãq¶�¼¿Ç�È=·¿Ë³¶�À�Ç�Ã=¶¼¿Ì{Ãqõ�À»YÃ=Æé»Yà »�·¿ÂqÌ�¸�·�»�·¿Ìͽ�¾(½Í»Y·¿É�¶ÜÃuÈqÅ�ÂK¶³·�ÇYÊ"Ì{Ãu¸¿¶³·�ÃÁ»Y½Í½�¾�µY¶³·�¸¿¶SòuôyÆ=Ìͼ�û�ÇYÌÍÃf¸�ºÁ»:¸�¹q¼�ÆqÌÍ·�¶³Ë�¸¿¶³ÆÄÊ�·¿Ç�Å ¸�¹=¶¼¿ÇYÈq·¿Ë�¶�¸¿Çܸ¿¹q¶r¼¿Ì{ÃqõX � ÌÍÉ�Èq·�¶nü��QÎF � JK<�J OnG��qG@J � X B A�� EqT�� � Y[Z�� ÕSÒ 9fSÕ�ÞYß�ØÔß=ÓÁÛ0. Û¿åVÕSß÷Õ!Û:äfáIáCÕSÒ�Û`ÝkÙ!ÛCáSÒfÝQä^ß÷ÙSÒ|ØÚÛ:ß=á#"ÞYßm0�âÍÕSÒ �e0VÕSß÷Û:ÒyÕÒÔÓÁÕ�áSØÔßVåYâÍÕ/.¿Ù!Û0.�. Û10YØÔÒ|à�ØÔß=áSÒ�ÞYß÷Ù!Õ!á`C�ØÔÒÔÓ�Þkß÷ÕSÒgCIÛ:×31�ÒÔÓ=ÞYÒ*ØÍá�Þnä^ßÁØÚÛ:ß�Û`Ý�Ö=ÞYÒ�Ófá�ÞYßm0 C�ØÔÒÔÓ�Ù!ÛCáSÒ:ÝQä^ß÷ÙSÒ|ØÚÛ:ß=áØÔß 1� �*ÓÁÕSß

�[!� � � � �+�#-Ï"¹q¶nÌ{Æq¶s»�ÇYÊ�¸¿¹q¶kºq·�Ç^ÇYÊGÇYÊGê�·�Ç�º8ÇY¼¿Ì{¸¿ÌÍÇ�à �^Î � ÌͼI¸¿Ç�ÌÍÅ�º8ÇY¼¿¶�Æ=Ì{µ�¶�·¿¼�Ì{¸y¾�Âf¾ Ë³Ç�Ãq¼�ÌÍÆq¶�·¿Ì{ÃqÉ�¸�¹q¶�˳½ÍÇY¼¿Èq·�¶ ÇYÊ �ÈqÃqÆq¶�·�Å)Èq½{¸¿Ìͺq½{ÌÍËs»:¸�ÌÍÇYÃ�Âf¾�ºKÇ�¼¿Ì�¸�Ì�µ�¶"¼¿Ë³»Y½�»�·¿¼³Àu»�ºqºq½{¾�ê�·¿Ç�ºKÇ�¼¿Ì�¸�Ì{Ç�à �^Î �Cü=Àu»YÃqÆÜÈq¼�¶�Å)Èq½{¸¿Ìͺq½{¶I˳ÇYºqÌͶ�¼ÇYÊA¶³ÆqÉY¶³¼}Ð}Ì{¸�¹�Ë�Ç�¼�¸}Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼}ÌÍà ĸ�Çܼ�ÌÍÅ�Èq½Í»�¸�¶�¶³ÆqÉ�¶�¼�Ð}Ì�¸�¹�˳ÇY¼�¸}Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃq¼}ÌÍà �Î�c? ;=9��J$ X BDA � Ï"¹=¶ ê�ÌÍÉYÇ�ȦÂ8ÇYÈqÃqÆÄÆqÇ^¶�¼�Ã=ÇY¸�»Yºqºq½�¾�¸¿Ç�¹qÇYÅ�Ç�ÉY¶³Ãq¶�Ç�Èq¼r¼¿¶S¸�¼ çÇYÊ�Ë�Ç�¼�¸rÊ�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼³ÀÐ}¹q¶�·¿¶ �5"���ae �§Ê�Ç�·�»Y½Í½ �kG �Î Ï"¹q¶(º=·¿ÌÍË�¶�Ç�Êr»YÃÁ»Y·�Ë!¹f¾ ÇYÊk¼¿¶³½�æÁ¼¿¹&·�Ç�È=¸¿ÌÍÃqÉÄÌͼ�ÃqÇY¸�˳Ç�Å�ºq½Í¶S¸�¶�½{¾

���

Page 11: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

ÈqÃqÆ=¶³·¿¼o¸�ÇVÇ^ƦÊ�Ç�·�¼¿ÈqË!¹Ä¼¿¶S¸�¼i3�¸�¹=¶�ÈqºqºK¶³·nÂKÇ�ÈqÃqƧÌÍÃ(¸¿¹q¶�Ãq¶Qò^¸r¼�ÈqÂq¼�¶³Ë�¸¿ÌÍÇ�ÃĹqÇ�½{Æq¼�Ê�Ç�·�¸�¹q¶�¼¿¶Ü¼¿¶S¸�¼³À�ÂqÈ^¸Ì{¸�Ì{¼�ÃqÇ�¸�Ç�º^¸�ÌÍÅ�»Y½0Î�þ^¶�¶�ë ���:ñGÊ�Ç�·}·¿¶SæÁÃq¶�Æ(ÈqºqºK¶³·�Â8Ç�È=ÃqÆq¼�ÇYÃ�¸�¹=¶�ºq·�ÌÍË�¶�ÇYÊ�»YÃÁ»Y·�Ë!¹u¾�Ð}Ì�¸�¹�·�¶³¼�º8¶�Ë�¸�¸¿Ç¹qÇ�Å�Ç�É�¶�Ãq¶³ÇYÈq¼}¼¿¶�¸¿¼}ÇYʼ�È=ÿ�˳ÌͶ�Ãf¸�½{¾�½ÍÇCÐ�ôyÆq¶�É�·¿¶�¶nº8ÇY½{¾VÃqÇ�Å�Ì�»Y½{¼³Î

� ��� � ,)�C�"*��+-"� ��� ���c� �$/ ���"#������U���.!��2 Ì{¸¿¹�»Y½Í½�¸�¹=¶nºq·¿¶�½ÍÌÍÅ�ÌÍÃq»Y·¿Ì{¶³¼?ÌÍÃ�ºq½Í»Y˳¶�À^Ð+¶rËs»YÃ�ÃqÇCÐ ¶s»Y¼�Ìͽ{¾�ºq·�ÇCµ�¶�»YÃ�ÈqºqºK¶³·"ÂKÇ�ÈqÃ=Æ�ÇYÃ�¸�¹q¶nºq·�ÌÍË�¶kÇYÊ»YÃÁ»�·¿Ë!¹f¾(ÇYÊ?¼�¶³½�æÁ¼¿¹§·¿ÇYÈ=¸�Ì{ÃqÉ ¸�¹q»�¸kÅ�»�¸�Ë!¹=¶³¼�¸¿¹q¶Üê�ÌÍÉ�Ç�È�Â8Ç�È=ÃqÆ*Î � Ç�·�Ë�Ç�Ãfµ�¶�ÃqÌͶ�Ãq˳¶�À�Ð+¶�æÁ·�¼�¸n¼o¸!»�¸¿¶�»½Í¶�Å�Å�»�¸¿¹Á»�¸}Ê�Ç�½Í½{ÇCÐ}¼�ÌÍÅ�Å�¶�ÆqÌ�»:¸�¶³½�¾�Ê�·¿Ç�Å �k¶�æÁÃqÌ�¸�Ì{Ç�à �^Î ð=Î�+? ;=;=9�X:BDA � � ÕSÒ fSÕ�Þ�áCÕSÒ�Û`Ý�Ù!ÛCáSÒ*ÝQä^ß÷ÙSÒ|ØÚÛ:ß=á�ÞYßm0 � ����ÒÔÓÁÕ � Ø�åVÛ:ä(fSÛ:ä^ßm0kÝsÛ:× ����AÛ:×8�NG ÞYßm0 �+b � ��"

cd �5@ ,� � b$dq�5gb��� �+� � � b����5gb��#-

2 ¶ ÃqÇCÐ Èq¼¿¶ ¸¿¹qÌͼ�½Í¶�Å�Å�»�»�ÃqÆ¥¸�¹=¶�µ�»Y·¿ÌÍ»�¸�Ì{Ç�ÃÁ»Y½�ÌÍÃq¶�öVÈq»Y½ÍÌ�¸y¾§ÇYÊ�ê�·¿Ç�ºKÇ�¼¿Ì�¸�Ì{Ç�à �VÎ ¸¿Ç�ºq·�ÇCµ�¶�¸�¹=¶Ç�º=¸¿ÌÍÅ�»Y½ÍÌ�¸y¾ÜÇYÊ�¸¿¹q¶�ê�ÌÍÉ�Ç�È�ÂKÇ�ÈqÃ=Æ*Î� �1?�J � ? ; X BDA�V EqT X V � � � Y[Z � ÕSÒ fSÕnÞ�áCÕSÒIÛ`ÝnÙ!ÛCáSÒ=ÝQä^ß÷ÙSÒ|ØÚÛ:ß=ánÞYßm0 � �+��Ò�ÓÁÕ � Ø�åVÛ:ä&fSÛ:ä^ßm0IÝsÛ:× 1�!�ÝS�'��+b�� ���rØÍá�ÞYߦØÔß=áSÒÚÞYß÷Ù!ÕzC�ØÔÒ�Ó�Ù!ÛCáSÒKÝQäVß÷ÙSÒ0ØÚÛ:ß=á�ØÔß "�ÒÔÓÁÕSß

�[�'��+b�� �&� � � ���#-� ×�ÛCÛ`Ý��7x�¶�¸ E � »YÃ=Æ�E ÂK¶�»YÃxÇ�º=¸�Ì{Å »�½ �ÁÇCÐ »YÃqÆ » 2 »Y·�Æq·¿Ç�ºx¶�öVÈ=ÌͽÍÌ{Âq·¿Ì{ÈqÅ�À·¿¶�¼¿ºK¶³Ë�¸¿Ì{µY¶³½{¾YÀ�Ê�ÇY·Ü»YÃÌÍÃ=¼�¸!»�Ãq˳¶ �'��+b�� �&�+Ð}Ì{¸¿¹�Ë�Ç�¼�¸}Ê�ÈqÃ=Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼}ÌÍÃ�¸¿¹q¶r¼¿¶S¸Î�Ï"¹q¶�¸¿¹q¶³ÇY·¿¶³Å Ê�Ç�½Í½{ÇdÐ}¼"Âf¾�Ð}·�Ì{¸¿ÌÍÃqÉ

�p�E � � e &SWV1X

�#S�yE �S �OE �S

��

� ��� &S/V�X

�US��E%SJ�OEJS � &S/V�X

�E �S @E%SJ���US\�E%SJ�

��p�Et�� �+� �

Ð}¹q¶�·¿¶)Ê�Ç�·�¸�¹q¶�æÁ·¿¼o¸nÌÍÃ=¶³öuÈÁ»Y½{Ì{¸y¾�Ð+¶�¹Á»sµ�¶�»�ºqºq½ÍÌ{¶³ÆDx�¶�Å�Å�» �VÎ �Cðܸ�Ç�¶³»YË!¹¦¶³Æ=É�¶Na)Ð}Ì{¸¿¹_ eME �S »�ÃqÆb edEJS�Àq»YÃqÆ�¸�¹q¶r¼¿¶�˳Ç�Ã=Æ�ÌÍÃ=¶³öuÈÁ»Y½{Ì{¸y¾ Ê�ÇY½Í½ÍÇCÐ}¼IÊ�·�Ç�Å ê�·�Ç�º8ÇY¼¿Ì{¸¿ÌÍÇ�à �VÎ Î

Ï"¹q¶³ÇY·¿¶³Å �^Î �dý�ÌÍÅ�ºq½ÍÌ{¶³¼�¸¿¹Á»�¸r¸�¹=¶�½{ÇdÐ+¶³·rÂKÇ�ÈqÃqÆ=¼�Ç�Ãĸ�¹q¶�ºq·�ÌÍ˳¶ÜÇYÊ�»YÃÁ»Y·�Ë!¹f¾ÑÌ{à bò=»YÅ�ºq½{¶³¼ �^Î ý�^Î ����»Y·¿¶�¸¿¹q¶ÜÂ8¶�¼�¸�ºKÇ�¼¿¼�ÌÍÂq½{¶YÎ�Ï"¹uÈq¼r¸�¹q¶Üºq·�ÌÍË�¶�ÇYÊ�»�ÃÁ»Y·¿Ë!¹f¾§ÇYÊ+Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õu¼�Ð}Ì�¸�¹§½ÍÌ{Ãq¶s»Y· |Ç�·nË�Ç�ÃqËs»sµY¶��˳ÇY¼�¸ÜÊ�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃq¼ÜÌͼ�ºq·�¶³Ë³Ì{¼¿¶�½{¾ pYü 3I¸�¹q¶�ºq·�ÌÍË�¶�Ç�Êk»YÃq»Y·¿Ë!¹f¾xÇYÊ�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õu¼�Ð}Ì{¸�¹xË�Ç�¼�¸ÜÊ�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼�¸�¹Á»:¸»Y·�¶�º8ÇY½{¾VÃqÇ�Å�Ì�»Y½{¼kÐ}Ì{¸¿¹ ÃqÇ�ÃqÃ=¶³Éf»�¸¿Ì{µY¶�˳ÇV¶�ÿ�˳Ì{¶³Ãf¸�¼Ü»�ÃqÆ Æq¶�É�·¿¶�¶�»�¸�Å�Ç�¼�¸ �éÌͼ�ºq·¿¶�˳Ì{¼¿¶³½�¾Ñ¸¿¹q¶�·�ÌÍÉ�¹f¸�ô¹Á»YÃ=Æ(¼¿Ì{Æq¶�Ç�Ê=0í�� 38»YÃqÆ�¸�¹q¶�ºq·¿Ì{˳¶�ÇYÊ?»YÃÁ»�·¿Ë!¹f¾�ÇYÊ�ÌÍÃ=¼�¸!»�Ãq˳¶�¼�Ð}Ì{¸¿¹�¼�ÈqÅ Ç�Ê?»Y½Í½*¸¿·�»�ÿ�Ë�·�»�¸¿¶³¼�»�¸kÅ�Ç�¼�¸�� �� � À÷˳Ç�¼o¸kÊ�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃq¼�¸�¹q»�¸n»Y·�¶ �������P��Æq¶³½Í»s¾�Ê�ÈqÃ=Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼�À*»YÃqƦ¼�¶³·oµ^Ì{˳¶�·¿»�¸�¶�¼kÂ8ÇYÈqÃqÆq¶�ƦÂ8¶�½ÍÇCÐ�Âu¾�� 4#� �� �� � Ìͼ"ºq·�¶³Ë�Ìͼ¿¶�½{¾�¸¿¹q¶r·¿Ì{É�¹f¸�ôy¹q»YÃqÆ�¼¿Ì{Æq¶rÇYÊ |ð��SÎ

��Ç�·�¶³ÇCµ�¶�·³ÀV¼¿ÌÍÃ=˳¶"¸�¹q¶�ê�ÌÍÉYÇ�È�Â8ÇYÈqÃqÆ�ÌͼÂÁ»�¼¿¶³Æ�Ç�Ãq½�¾)Ç�Ãܸ�¹=¶"¼¿ÌÍÅ�ºq½{¶³¼�¸ÇYÊ÷Ì{Ãq¼�¸�»YÃqË�¶³¼³Àf¸¿¹q¶}Å »�¸¿Ë!¹qÌÍÃ=ÉÈqºqºK¶³·�ÂKÇ�ÈqÃ=ÆéÇYÊ�Ï"¹q¶³Ç�·�¶³Å �VÎ �dý�Ì{Å�º=½ÍÌͶ�¼�¸¿¹Á»�¸�¼�ÌÍÅ�ºq½Í¶�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õV¼�»Y½�Ð�»s¾V¼�Ê�Èq·�ÃqÌͼ�¹ ÐIÇ�·�¼�¸oôyºKÇ�¼¿¼�ÌÍÂq½{¶¶Sò=»YÅ�ºq½{¶³¼nÇYÊ�¸�¹q¶�Ì{Ãq¶�ÿ�Ë�ÌͶ³Ã=Ë�¾¦ÇYÊ+¼¿¶�½{æÁ¼�¹§·¿Ç�È=¸¿ÌÍÃqÉ=Î�ê�·¿¶�˳Ìͼ�¶³½�¾�ÀGê�·¿Ç�ºKÇ�¼¿Ì�¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼S�^Î �.��P�^Î � »YÃqƧÏ"¹q¶³Ç:ô·¿¶�Å �^Î �dý�É�Ì{µY¶n¸�¹q¶nÊ�Ç�½{½ÍÇCÐ}ÌÍÃqÉ�˳Ç�·�Ç�½Í½Í»Y·�¾YÎ

���

Page 12: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

, J � J >D>D9�� � X BDA � � ÕSÒ fSÕ)ÞÜáCÕSÒ}Û`Ý�Ù!ÛCáSÒ�ÝQäVß÷ÙSÒ0ØÚÛ:ß=á��� Þ���!ÔÝ Ù!Û:ßÁÒÚÞYØÔß=á�ÒÔÓÁÕ�Ù!Û:ß=áSÒÚÞYßÁÒ�ÝQä^ß÷ÙSÒ|ØÚÛ:ß=á#"�Ò�ÓÁÕSߥÒ�ÓÁÕkÖK×QØÚÙ!Õ�Û`Ý�ÞYßKÞY×�Ù!ÓVà¦Û`Ý�ØÔß=áSÒ�ÞYß÷Ù!Õ!á,C�ØÔÒ�Ó Ù!ÛCáSÒÝQäVß÷ÙSÒ0ØÚÛ:ß=á�ØÔß ØÍá�ÞVÙ!ÓVØÚÕ /YÕO0 "�äCÖ Ò`ÛÄÞYß ÞY×1f³ØÔÒ|×�ÞY×QØÔâ\à¦á .�ÞYâÔâ8Ý�ÞVÙSÒ`Û:× "Nf³à¥ÞÄáSØÔßVåYâÍÕ/.¿Ù!Û0.�. Û10YØÔÒ|àØÔß=áSÒÚÞYß÷Ù!ÕzC�ØÔÒÔÓ�Þ�Ò�CIÛ0.yß÷Û10VÕ#"�Ò�CIÛ0.yâ\ØÔß21Üß÷ÕSÒgCIÛ:×31 �� f ��!ÔÝ ØÍá 0YØ /YÕS×�áCÕ#"�ÒÔÓÁÕSß ÒÔÓÁÕ�ÖK×SØÚÙ!Õ¥Û`ÝÑÞYßKÞY×!Ù!ÓVàìÛ`ݧØÔß=áSÒÚÞYß÷Ù!Õ!á C�ØÔÒÔÓ Ù!ÛCáSÒ�ÝQäVß÷ÙSÒ0ØÚÛ:ß=á¦ØÔß ØÍáÞVÙ!ÓVØÚÕ /YÕO0 "ädÖ§ÒyÛ ÞYߧÞY×]f³ØÔÒ|׿ÞY×QØÔâ\à�á .�ÞYâÔâ�Ý�ÞVÙSÒyÛ:× "`f³à ÞÜáSØÔßVåYâÍÕ/.¿Ù!Û0.�. Û10YØÔÒ0à)ØÔß=áSÒ�ÞYß÷Ù!ÕzC�ØÔÒÔÓ�Þ�ß÷ÕSÒ�.CIÛ:×31�Û`Ý�Ö=ÞY×�ÞYâÔâÍÕSâ*â\ØÔß21Cá��� Ù ��!ÔÝ ùØÍá�ØÔß=ÓÁÛ0. Û¿åVÕSß÷Õ!Û:äuá#"�Ò�ÓÁÕSߦÒÔÓÁÕ}ÖK×SØÚÙ!Õ�Û`Ý�ÞYßKÞY×�Ù!ÓVà�Û`ÝrØÔß=áSÒ�ÞYß÷Ù!Õ!árC�ØÔÒÔÓ¦Ù!ÛCáSÒ�ÝQä^ß÷ÙSÒ|ØÚÛ:ß=á�ØÔß ØÍá�ÞVÙ!ÓVØÚÕ /YÕO0 "�ädÖ ÒyÛ§ÞYß ÞY×]f³ØÔÒ0×�ÞY×QØÔâ\à�á .�ÞYâÔâÁÝ�ÞVÙSÒyÛ:×#"uf³à§Þ�áSØÔßVåYâÍÕ/.¿Ù!Û0.�. Û10YØÔÒ|à�ØÔß=áSÒÚÞYß÷Ù!ÕpC�ØÔÒ�Ó Þß÷ÕSÒgCIÛ:×31ÜÒ�Ó=ÞYÒ+ØÍá�Þ äVßÁØÚÛ:ßÑÛ`Ý�Ö=ÞYÒ�Ófá��

óyÃ=Ê�Ç�·�Å »�½Í½{¾YÀ \ Ç�·¿Ç�½{½�»Y·o¾X�^Î ����¼�¸!»:¸�¶³¼�¸�¹Á»:¸�¸¿¹q¶ ºq·�ÌÍË�¶�ÇYÊ"»YÃÁ»Y·�Ë!¹u¾ÑÌͼ�˳ÇYÃu¸¿·¿Ç�½{½Í¶�ÆùÛ:ßÁâ\àÜÂf¾Ñ¸¿¹q¶�¼¿¶�¸)ÇYÊ»Y½{½ÍÇCÐ�»�Âq½Í¶�˳Ç�¼o¸nÊ�ÈqÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã=¼³À�»YÃqƧÌ{¼k¶³¼�¼¿¶³Ãf¸¿Ì�»Y½{½{¾(Ì{ÃqÆq¶�º8¶�ÃqÆq¶³Ãf¸�ÇYÊ?¸�¹=¶�ÃVÈ=Å�Â8¶�·nÇYÊ+˳Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ�¸�ÌͶ�¼�»�ÃqÆÇYÊG¸�¹q¶rË�Ç�Å�º=½Í¶Sò^Ì�¸y¾�ÇYÊG¸�¹q¶�»Y½{½ÍÇCÐI»YÂq½Í¶�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õ�¸¿Ç�ºKÇ�½ÍÇ�ÉYÌͶ³¼�Î�c? ;=9��J$ X BDA � Ï"¹=¶³Ç�·�¶³Å �^Î �Cý�¹Á»Y¼�ÈqÃqÆq¶�·¿É�Ç�Ã=¶�¼¿¶Sµ�¶³·¿»Y½Ì�¸�¶³·¿»�¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼}ÌÍÃÜû�Èq¼�¸k»�Ê�¶�Ð ¼�¹qÇ�·�¸�¾�¶s»�·¿¼³Î�ó�¸ÐI»Y¼+æÁ·�¼�¸+ºq·¿ÇCµY¶³Æ�Ê�Ç�·�¸�¹=¶�¼¿ºK¶³Ë�Ì�»Y½�˳»Y¼¿¶�ÇYÊ*½{ÌÍÃq¶³»Y·?˳Ç�¼o¸+Ê�ÈqÃ=Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼�ÌÍà 0�Ç�È=É�¹qÉf»Y·�Æq¶³Ã »YÃqÆ�Ï�»Y·�ÆqÇ�¼�ë �Yï�ñÚÎ0}Ç�ÈqÉ�¹qÉ�»Y·¿Æq¶�à ëîýYï�ñ�¸¿¹q¶³Ã�ºq·¿ÇCµ�¶�Æ(Ï"¹q¶�Ç�·¿¶�Å �VÎ �dý�Ê�Ç�·}ÂKÇ�ÈqÃqÆq¶�Æ^ôyÆ=¶³É�·�¶³¶�º8Ç�½�¾VÃqÇ�Å�Ì�»Y½{¼IÐ}Ì{¸¿¹�ÃqÇYÃqÃq¶³É:ô»�¸¿Ì{µ�¶�˳ÇV¶�ÿ�Ë�ÌͶ³Ãf¸¿¼³Î?Ï"¹q¶�º=·¿ÇVÇYÊ�ÌÍÃ(ë ý�ï:ñKÐ�»Y¼�Ê|»YÌÍ·�½{¾�Ë�Ç�Å�ºq½Í¶Qò�»YÃqÆ�ÆqÌ{Æ ÃqÇ�¸I¶Qò=º=½ÍÌÍË�Ì{¸¿½{¾�¸�»YõY¶�»YÆ=µ�»YÃf¸!»YÉY¶ÇYÊ�¸�¹=¶kµY»�·¿Ì�»:¸�ÌÍÇYÃÁ»Y½ÁÌÍÃ=¶³öuÈÁ»Y½{Ì{¸y¾�É�Ì{µY¶³Ã�ÌÍÃ�ê�·�Ç�º8ÇY¼¿Ì{¸¿ÌÍÇ�à �^Î Î�0�ÇYÈqÉ�¹qÉf»�·¿Æq¶�ÃÄë �U��ñ*¶SòV¸¿¶³ÃqÆq¶�Æ�¸¿¹qÌͼ�º=·¿ÇVÇYÊ»YÃqÆ ¶³¼�¸�»YÂq½{Ìͼ¿¹=¶³Æ Ï"¹=¶³Ç�·�¶³Å �^Î �CýrÊ�Ç�·+»Y½Í½�¼�¶�¸�¼IÇYÊ�˳ÇY¼�¸IÊ�È=ÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãq¼�¸�¹Á»:¸I¼¿»�¸�Ì{¼�ÊÔ¾�»�Ð+¶s»Yõܸ�¶�Ë!¹qÃqÌ{Ës»Y½K˳Ç�ÃVôÆqÌ�¸�ÌÍÇYà |Å�¶�¸�Âf¾�¶�¼¿¼¿¶�Ãf¸�Ì�»�½Í½{¾�»Y½{½AË�Ç�¼�¸�Ê�ÈqÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã=¼�¸�¹Á»:¸n»Y·�Ìͼ¿¶�ÌÍæ»�ºqºq½ÍÌ{Ës»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã=¼I�SÎ 0}Ç�Ãq¶³ÃçëîýYð�ñAºKÇ�ÌÍÃf¸�¶�ÆÇ�È=¸�¸�¹q»�¸kê�·�Ç�º8ÇY¼¿Ì{¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãf�^Î Ë�Ç�Èq½{Æ�ÂK¶�Èq¼�¶³Æ(¸¿Ç�µ�»Y¼o¸�½{¾�¼�ÌÍÅ�ºq½ÍÌ�ÊÔ¾ ¸¿¹q¶)ºq·�Ç^Ç�ÊÇYÊ�Ï"¹=¶³Ç�·�¶³Å �^Î �dý^À�ÈqÃqÆq¶�·¸�¹=¶"¼�»YÅ�¶I¸�¶�Ë!¹qÃqÌ{Ës»Y½qË�Ç�ÃqÆqÌ�¸�Ì{Ç�Ã*ÎGÏ"¹qÌͼ·�¶�µVÌͼ�¶³Æ�»YÃÁ»Y½�¾V¼¿Ìͼ�»YºqºK¶s»Y·�¼�ÌÍÃ�ë���ü�ñ0Î \ Ç�·�·¿¶³»=Àuþ^Ë!¹uÈq½{úYÀV»YÃqÆ�þV¸¿ÌͶ�·��Ç�¼�¶³¼)ë@�Yýdñ*¸¿¹q¶³Ã�¼¿¹qÇCÐ+¶³Æ�¸�¹Á»�¸³ÀqÇ�ÃqË�¶n¸�¹q¶rºq·�Ç^ÇYÊGÌ{¼"ÂÁ»Y¼¿¶�Æ�ÇYÃ�ê�·�Ç�º8ÇY¼¿Ì{¸¿ÌÍÇ�à �^Î ÀqÌ{¸"˳»YÃ�Â8¶nÅ�Ç^Æ=Ì{æÁ¶�Ƽ¿Ç(¸¿¹Á»�¸)ÃqÇ�¸�¶�Ë!¹qÃqÌ{Ës»Y½+˳Ç�ÃqÆ=Ì{¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼�Ð}¹Á»�¸�¼�Ç^¶Sµ�¶�·Ü»Y·¿¶�Ãq¶³¶�Æq¶³Æ*ΧÏ"¹q¶�º=·¿ÇVÇYÊ"ÇYÊ}Ï"¹q¶�Ç�·¿¶�Å �^Î �dý�ÉYÌ{µ�¶�ûYÂKÇCµ�¶�Ì{¼�¸�»YõY¶�Ã(Ê�·¿Ç�Å ë ��ýdñ0Î_��ÇY·¿¶)·�¶³Ë�¶³Ãf¸�½�¾�À÷¸yÐ+Ç�Å�Ç�·¿¶�ºq·¿ÇVÇYÊ�¼�ÇYÊ�Ï"¹q¶�Ç�·¿¶�Å �^Î �dý�¹q»CµY¶�ÂK¶³¶³Ã¦ÉYÌ{µ�¶�ÃÂf¾�ÏA»Y·¿ÆqÇY¼)ë¢ï�ð�ñG»�ÃqÆ \ Ç�·¿·�¶s»=ÀKþ^Ë!¹uÈq½{úYÀK»YÃqÆ�þV¸¿ÌͶ³· ��Ç�¼¿¶�¼�ë ���:ñ0Î

� � ®�°¦«¦¯¦²³«�� � ­��<���������>��)­j�)¯(®��

Ï"¹qÌ{¼�¼¿¶�Ë�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã(¼o¸�ÈqÆ=ÌͶ³¼�¸�¹q¶�ÐIÇY·¿¼�¸oôyºKÇ�¼¿¼�ÌÍÂq½{¶�¼�¶�µY¶³·¿Ì�¸y¾(ÇYÊ 5 ·�»Y¶�¼¿¼&� ¼nêA»Y·�»�ÆqÇsò÷Îkþ^ÈqÂq¼�¶³ËS¸�ÌÍÇYæü=Î �)É�Ì�µ�¶³¼�»Ë³ÇYÃq¼�¸¿·¿ÈqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃ¥¸�¹Á»:¸�¼¿¹=ÇdÐ}¼�¸¿¹Á»�¸�¸�¹q¶�¼�¶�µY¶³·¿Ì�¸y¾ ÇYÊ 5 ·�»Y¶�¼¿¼��î¼Üê�»�·�»YÆqÇsò¥Ës»YÃ¥É�·¿ÇCÐ Ð}Ì{¸¿¹¥¸�¹q¶�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õ¼¿Ì{ú³¶"Ð}¹q¶�Ã�ÃqÇ�Ãq½{ÌÍÃq¶³»Y·Ë�Ç�¼�¸�Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃq¼�»YÃqÆ�Å�Èq½{¸¿Ìͺq½{¶�¶³Æ=É�¶}·¿¶³Å�ÇCµ�»Y½Í¼?»Y·�¶�ºK¶³·�Å�Ì�¸¿¸¿¶³Æ*Îþ^ÈqÂq¼�¶³Ë�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�ü=Î4�ºq·�ÇdµY¶³¼kÅ�»�¸¿Ë!¹qÌÍÃqÉ�ÈqºqºK¶³·�Â8ÇYÈqÃqÆq¼�Ê�Ç�·�¼�ÌÍÃqÉY½Í¶Sô�˳Ç�Å�Å�Ç^ÆqÌ�¸y¾�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õu¼�Înþ^ÈqÂ=¼¿¶³ËS¸�Ì{Ç�æü=Î ü�É�Ì�µ�¶�¼k»�Â=·¿ÌͶSÊÇCµ�¶�·�µVÌͶSÐ ÇYÊ 5 ·�»�¶³¼¿¼&� ¼�ê�»�·�»YÆqÇsò�Ì{Ã�Å�Èq½�¸�ÌÍË�Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ{¸y¾�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õu¼�Î � Ì{ÃÁ»Y½Í½�¾�À^þ^ÈqÂ=¼¿¶³ËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�ü^Î ºq·�¶³¼¿¶�Ãf¸�¼Ãq¶�Éf»�¸�Ì�µ�¶r·¿¶�¼¿Èq½�¸�¼"Ê�Ç�·�¸¿¹q¶r˳Ç�Å�ºqÈ=¸�»�¸�Ì{Ç�ÃÁ»Y½8ºq·¿Ç�Â=½Í¶³Å ÇYÊA¶�ÿ�˳Ì{¶³Ãf¸�½�¾�Æq¶�¸¿¶³ËS¸�ÌÍÃ=É 5 ·¿»Y¶³¼�¼��î¼�êA»Y·�»�ÆqÇsò÷Î

� ��� � ��# #�/�� � �C��/ 0 0�@0��_� �C� �.�1'Ï"¹q¶rÆqÌ{¼¿Ë³ÇCµY¶³·�¾�Ç�Ê 5 ·¿»Y¶³¼�¼��î¼�êA»Y·�»�ÆqÇsòÑë9� ñ�ÌÍÅ�Å�¶³ÆqÌÍ»�¸�¶�½{¾�ÌÍÃf¸�·�ÌÍÉ�È=¶³Æ�·¿¶�¼¿¶³»Y·¿Ë!¹q¶�·¿¼�»YÃqÆ�Ës»�¸�»Y½{¾Vú�¶³Æ�ÃVÈVôÅ�¶³·¿ÇYÈq¼�·�¶³¼¿¶³»Y·¿Ë!¹§ÆqÌ{·¿¶�Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼=|¼¿¶�¶�ëîý���ñGÊ�Ç�·�»�¼¿Èq·oµ�¶�¾U�QÎ�#�ÇCÐI¶Sµ�¶³·�À�Ãq¶s»�·¿½{¾�»Y½{½�ÇYÊ�¸�¹qÌ{¼�Ð+Ç�·¿õ�Ê�ÇV˳Èq¼�¶³Æ

�.�

Page 13: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

Ç�à 5 ·�»Y¶�¼¿¼��î¼kÇ�·�ÌÍÉ�Ì{ÃÁ»Y½÷Ê�ÇYÈq·oô�ÃqÇ^Æ=¶�Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇY·¿õ � Ì{É�Èq·¿¶ ���}»YÃqÆ�µ�»Y·�Ì�»YÃf¸¿¼�¸¿¹q¶³·�¶³ÇYÊ`Î 2 ¶�Ãq¶SòV¸�¼¿¹qÇCÐ ¸�¹Á»:¸5 ·¿»Y¶³¼�¼��î¼�Ç�·¿Ì{É�ÌÍÃÁ»�½f¶Sò=»YÅ�ºq½Í¶�ÌͼAÅ�¶�·¿¶³½�¾r¸�¹q¶I¸¿Ìͺ�ÇYÊÁ¸�¹q¶+ÌÍË�¶³ÂK¶³·¿É 5 ·¿»Y¶³¼�¼��î¼?ê�»Y·¿»YÆqÇsò)Ës»YÃ�ÂK¶"»Y·�ÂqÌ{¸¿·�»Y·�Ìͽ�¾¼¿¶Sµ�¶�·¿¶)Ì{Ã�½�»Y·�É�¶k¼¿Ì{ÃqÉ�½{¶SôyË�Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ{¸y¾ÜÃ=¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õu¼³Î

2 ¶nÅ�¶s»�¼¿Èq·�¶�¸�¹q¶n¼�¶�µY¶³·¿Ì�¸y¾�ÇYÊ 5 ·¿»Y¶³¼�¼��î¼}ê�»Y·¿»YÆqÇsò�Ð}Ì�¸�¹�¸�¹=¶��}×�ÞVÕ!á!ák×�ÞYÒ|ØÚÛ"�&¸�¹=¶kÊ|»YË�¸¿Ç�·IÂf¾ Ð}¹=ÌÍË!¹¸�¹=¶�Ë�Ç�¼�¸�ÇYÊ�» 2 »�·¿Æq·�Ç�º�¶�öuÈqÌͽ{ÌÍÂq·�ÌÍÈqÅ ¶Sò^Ë�¶³¶³Æ=¼�¸�¹Á»:¸}ÇYÊ»�Ã�¶�öuÈqÌͽ{ÌÍÂq·�ÌÍÈqÅ ÌÍÃ�»�¼¿ÈqÂ=Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õ�Î� ?!�s� Gw� GDJm�*� BDA Ï"¹q¶��}×�ÞVÕ!á!ár×�ÞYÒ0ØÚÛ�� �'��+b�� �&�IÇYÊ»�¼�ÌÍÃqÉ�½{¶Sô�˳Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ�¸y¾ÜÌÍÃq¼o¸!»YÃqË�¶ �'��+b�� ���IÌ{¼

� �'��+b�� �&��e Å »dò���

�p�Et�� yE � � � Úý��

Ð}¹q¶�·¿¶� ·¿»YÃqÉ�¶�¼�ÇCµ�¶�·�¼¿ÈqÂ=Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õu¼�ÇYÊr' ¸�¹Á»:¸�˳ÇYÃu¸�»YÌÍà »Yà ^�ô `�ºq»�¸�¹*À�»YÃ=Æ EE»YÃqÆ E � Æ=¶³ÃqÇY¸¿¶2 »Y·¿Æq·�Ç�º�¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌÍÂ=·¿Ì�»�Ê�Ç�· �'��+b�� �&��»YÃqÆ � �Ob0� ���QÀq·¿¶�¼¿ºK¶³Ë�¸¿Ì{µY¶³½{¾YÎh�¼Ð}Ì�¸�¹ �k¶SæÁÃqÌ�¸�ÌÍÇYà �^Î í^ÀY¸�¹=¶ 5 ·�»�¶³¼¿¼?·¿»�¸�Ì{Ç�ÇYÊ8»YÃ�Ì{Ãq¼�¸�»YÃq˳¶_�'��+b�� ���GÌͼAÐ+¶³½{½qÆq¶SæÁÃq¶³ÆÜÈqÃ=½Í¶³¼�¼�Ì{¸»YÆqÅ�Ì{¸�¼»,�ÁÇCÐ Ð}Ì{¸¿¹�ú³¶³·�Ç�Ë�Ç�¼�¸³ÀÁÌÍÃ�Ð}¹qÌ{Ë!¹�˳»Y¼¿¶nÐ+¶�Æq¶SæÁÃq¶�� �'��+b�� ���?¸�ÇÜÂ8¶ ��Î�c? ;=9��J$ � B X � ÇY·�ÃqÇCÐrÀ�Ð+¶+Ç�Ã=½{¾nÆq¶SæÁÃq¶?¸�¹q¶ 5 ·¿»Y¶³¼�¼A·¿»�¸�Ì{Ç}Ê�ÇY·�¼¿ÌÍÃ=É�½Í¶Qôy˳ÇYÅ�Å�Ç^Æ=Ì{¸y¾�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õV¼�Î�Ï"¹q¶³·�¶»Y·�¶�Å�È=½{¸�Ì{ºq½Í¶�Ð�»s¾V¼�¸¿Ç�¶Qò^¸¿¶³ÃqÆX�k¶SæÁÃqÌ�¸�ÌÍÇYÃ�ü^Î �r¸�Ç�Å�Èq½�¸�ÌÍË�Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ{¸y¾�Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇY·¿õu¼i38¼¿¶³¶�þ^ÈqÂq¼�¶³ËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃ(ü=Î üÊ�Ç�·"Æq¶S¸!»YÌ{½Í¼�Î

Ï"¹q¶ 5 ·�»Y¶�¼¿¼�·¿»�¸�Ì{ÇÄÌ{à b�ò=»YÅ�ºq½Í¶ ��Î4�§Ì{¼ ��ü=Î l Çѽ�»Y·�É�¶³· 5 ·¿»Y¶³¼�¼ ·�»:¸�ÌÍÇÄÌͼ�ºKÇ�¼¿¼�ÌÍÂq½{¶�Ì{à ¼�ÌÍÃqÉY½Í¶Sô˳ÇYÅ�Å�Ç^Æ=Ì{¸y¾�Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇY·¿õu¼�Ð}Ì{¸¿¹�½{ÌÍÃq¶³»Y·}˳Ç�¼o¸�Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼³Î}Ï"¹qÌ{¼�Ê|»�Ë�¸�Ìͼ�»�˳ÇYÃq¼¿¶�öVÈ=¶³ÃqË�¶�Ç�ʸ�¹q¶�Ê�Ç�½Í½{ÇCÐ}ÌÍÃqÉ˳½{Ç�¼¿¶rË�Ç�ÃqÃq¶�Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�Â8¶S¸yÐI¶�¶³Ã�¸¿¹q¶rºq·¿Ì{˳¶nÇYÊ»YÃÁ»Y·�Ë!¹f¾�»YÃqÆ�¸�¹q¶ 5 ·¿»Y¶³¼�¼�·¿»�¸�Ì{ÇqÎF � JK<�J OnG��qG@J � � B�� !ÔÝ �'��+b�� �&�rØÍá)Þ�áSØÔßVåYâÍÕ/.¿Ù!Û0.�. Û10YØÔÒ0àÜØÔß=áSÒÚÞYß÷Ù!Õ#"?Ò�ÓÁÕSß

� �'��+b�� ��� � �[g' �Ob0� ���U-� ×�ÛCÛ`Ý�� � Ç�·�¶�µ�¶�·�¾�¼¿ÈqÂqÉY·�»Yºq¹�� ÇYÊj'ÜÀ*» 2 »Y·¿Æ=·¿Ç�º(¶�öuÈqÌͽ{ÌÍÂq·�ÌÍÈqÅ E � ÇYÊ � �+b�� �&��Ì{¼�»�Ê�¶s»Y¼�ÌÍÂq½{¶r�ÁÇCÐÊ�Ç�· g' �Ob0� ��� 3*Âf¾�¸�¹=¶�Æq¶�æÁÃ=Ì{¸�Ì{Ç�Ã(ÇYÊ?¸¿¹q¶�ºq·�ÌÍ˳¶)ÇYÊ+»YÃÁ»Y·�Ë!¹u¾YÀ*¸�¹q¶�Ë�Ç�¼�¸kÇYÊ�E � Ì{¼n»�¸nÅ�Ç�¼�¸k» �[�'��+b�� �&�Ê|»YËS¸�Ç�·"½{¶³¼¿¼"¸¿¹Á»YÃ�¸�¹Á»�¸}Ç�Ê» 2 »Y·¿Æq·�Ç�º�¶³öuÈqÌͽ{ÌÍÂq·�ÌÍÈqÅ Ê�Ç�· g' �Ob0� ���QÎ

h�¼nºq·�Ç�Å�Ìͼ¿¶�Æ*À*Ï"¹q¶�Ç�·¿¶�Å �^Î �dý�»YÃ=Ƨê?·�Ç�ºKÇ�¼¿Ì�¸�ÌÍÇYÃ(ü=Î ü�ÌÍÅ�ºq½{¾�¸¿¹Á»�¸n¶Sµ�¶�·�¾¦¼�ÌÍÃqÉ�½{¶Sô�˳Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ�¸y¾�ÌÍÃ^ô¼�¸�»YÃqË�¶ Ð}Ì{¸¿¹é½ÍÌÍÃ=¶s»Y·r˳ÇY¼�¸�Ê�ÈqÃ=Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼�¹q»Y¼�» 5 ·¿»Y¶³¼�¼�·�»:¸�ÌÍÇ�ÇYÊ�»�¸)Å�Ç�¼o¸ p�ü=Î(Ï"¹q¶�È=ºqº8¶�·�ÂKÇ�ÈqÃqÆéÌ{Ãê�·¿Ç�ºKÇ�¼�Ì{¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�ü=Î ü�Ìͼ�»Y½Í¼�Ç�¸�Ì{É�¹f¸sÀKÈqº�¸¿Ç Ë³ÇYÃq¼�¸�»YÃf¸kÊ|»YË�¸¿Ç�·¿¼�À8Ê�Ç�·�Å�»YÃf¾�Ç�¸�¹q¶�·�¸y¾Vº8¶�¼kÇYÊ?Ë�Ç�¼�¸�Ê�ÈqÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã=¼|¼�¶³¶(0�¶�Å »�·¿õ�ü^Î ð�ÂK¶³½ÍÇCÐ �QÎ

b�ò=¹=ÌÍÂqÌ�¸�ÌÍÃ=É�»�Ê|»YÅ�Ìͽ�¾�ÇYÊ�Ì{Ãq¼�¸�»YÃqË�¶³¼IÐ}Ì�¸�¹�»�·¿ÂqÌ�¸�·�»�·¿Ìͽ�¾�½Í»Y·¿É�¶ 5 ·¿»Y¶³¼�¼�·�»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�¼�·¿¶�öuÈqÌÍ·�¶³¼"»)Ã=¶�ÐrÀqÅ�Ç�·¿¶Ë³ÇYÅ�ºq½{ÌÍ˳»�¸�¶�Æ�˳Ç�Ãq¼o¸�·�ÈqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãܸ�¹Á»�Ã�¸¿¹qÇ�¼¿¶"Ð+¶�¹q»CµY¶�¼�¶³¶�༿ÇrÊ|»Y·�Î�ê�·¿Ç�ºKÇ�¼¿Ì�¸�Ì{Ç�ÃÜü=Î ürÌ{Å�º=½ÍÌͶ�¼A¸¿¹Á»�¸�¼¿ÈqË!¹ »Ê|»YÅ�Ìͽ�¾kÅ�Èq¼o¸�Å�»Yõ�¶IÈq¼�¶IÇYÊÁË�Ç�¼�¸AÊ�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃq¼AÆ=·�»sÐ}Ã)Ê�·¿ÇYÅ »�¼¿È^ÿ�Ë�ÌͶ�Ãu¸¿½{¾�·¿Ì{Ë!¹)¼¿¶S¸ �¼¿ÈqË!¹�»�¼�ºKÇ�½{¾VÃqÇ�Å�Ì�»�½Í¼Ð}Ì{¸¿¹�ÈqÃuÂ8ÇYÈqÃqÆq¶�Æ�Æq¶�É�·¿¶�¶��QÎ 2 ¶"¶�Ãq˳ÇYÈqÃf¸�¶³·�¶³Æ�Ç�Ãq¶�¼�ÈqË!¹ÜÊ|»YÅ�Ì{½{¾rÌ{Ã�¸�¹q¶�Ã=Ç�Ãq½ÍÌ{Ãq¶s»�·Aµ�»Y·¿ÌÍ»YÃf¸ÇYÊ8ê�ÌÍÉYÇ�Èt�Sò=»YÅ�ºq½{¶ ÚþVÈqÂq¼¿¶�Ë�¸¿ÌÍÇ�à ��Î �.�QÀ^ÂqÈ^¸"Ì{¸+Ìͼ+¶s»Y¼o¾�¸¿Ç�¼¿¶�¶k¸�¹Á»�¸�»Y½Í½�ÇYÊ�¸¿¹q¶³¼�¶kÌÍÃ=¼�¸!»�Ãq˳¶�¼�¹Á»sµ�¶r» 5 ·�»Y¶�¼¿¼�·¿»�¸�Ì{ÇÇYÊ �YÎ�Ï"¹q¶³·�¶kÌͼ+»Y½Í¼�Ç�»Yà»YÃÁ»Y½{Ç�É�Ç�È=¼+ÃqÇYÃq½ÍÌ{Ãq¶s»Y·�µ�»Y·�Ì�»YÃf¸+ÇYÊ1b�ò=»YÅ�º=½Í¶ ��Î �VÀ^Ç�Â^¸!»YÌ{Ãq¶³Æ�Âu¾�·¿¶�ºq½�»�˳ÌÍÃ=É�¸�¹=¶½ÍÌ{Ãq¶s»�·�Ë�Ç�¼�¸�Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃq¼�Ç�Ã�¸�¹q¶)¶³ÆqÉ�¶�¼ ^�� �U�}»YÃqÆ �!+��`��"Ð}Ì�¸�¹�¸¿¹q¶�Ê�È=ÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãq¼8��� ,� e � Ê�Ç�· �(½�»Y·�É�¶YÎÏ"¹q¶ 5 ·�»Y¶�¼¿¼�·¿»�¸�Ì{Ç�¼+Ç�Ê�¸�¹q¶�¼¿¶kÌ{Ãq¼�¸�»YÃq˳¶�¼"»Yºqº=·¿Çf»YË!¹ �)»Y¼ � % �EÎ�h�¼+Ð+¶�Ð}Ì{½Í½�¼¿¶�¶kÌÍÃ�þ^ÈqÂq¼�¶³Ë�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�ü^Î �^À» 5 ·�»Y¶�¼¿¼I·¿»�¸�Ì{Çr½�»Y·�É�¶³·�¸�¹q»YÃn�nËs»YÃqÃ=ÇY¸"»Y·�Ìͼ�¶}Ð}Ì�¸�¹qÇYÈ=¸�»�½Í½ÍÇCÐ}Ì{ÃqÉn½�»Y·�É�¶³·?Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇY·¿õu¼}»YÃqÆ�Å�Èq½{¸¿Ìͺq½{¶�¶³Æ=É�¶·¿¶�Å�ÇCµ�»Y½{¼³Î

´kÈq·}Å »YÌ{Ã�·¿¶�¼¿Èq½�¸}ÌÍÃ�¸�¹qÌ{¼"¼¿ÈqÂ=¼¿¶³ËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�Ì{¼�¸�¹q¶nÊ�Ç�½{½ÍÇCÐ}ÌÍÃqÉ=Î

�Cü

Page 14: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

s t

1v

w2

1wv2

A

A

C

C

B

B

C

C

B

� �������v1

v2

v3

w1

w2

w3

s tA

A

C

C

C

B

C

C

B

B

C

B A

� `������� ÌÍÉ�Èq·�¶ ?Ï"¹q¶r¼¿¶�˳Ç�Ã=Æ(»YÃqÆ�¸�¹=ÌÍ·¿Æ 5 ·�»Y¶�¼¿¼�É�·�»Yº=¹q¼³Î�b�ÆqÉ�¶�¼�»Y·�¶n½�»YÂK¶³½{¶³Æ�Ð}Ì�¸�¹�¸�¹q¶�ÌÍ·�¸y¾Vº8¶�¼³Î

� �1?�J � ? ; � B � EqTWV � Y�Z �AÛ:×rÕ /YÕS×Qà � � ��"Ò�ÓÁÕS×�ÕrØÍárÞ�áSØÔßVåYâÍÕ/.¿Ù!Û0.�. Û10YØÔÒ|à�ØÔß=áSÒÚÞYß÷Ù!Õ �'��+b�� �&� C�ØÔÒ�Ó �/YÕS×QÒ0ØÚÙ!Õ!á�ÞYßm0

� �'��+b�� ��� ��� � �� -� ×�ÛCÛ`Ý�� 2 ¶nËs»YÃ�»�¼¿¼¿È=Å�¶k¸¿¹Á»�¸ � Ì{¼�¶�µY¶³Ã*ÀÁ¼�ÌÍÃqË�¶�¸�¹=¶nÇ^ÆqÆ�˳»Y¼¿¶n·�¶³ÆqÈ=˳¶³¼"¸¿Ç)¸�¹q¶n¶Sµ�¶�Ã�˳»Y¼¿¶nÂf¾�»�ÆqÆqÌÍÃ=É»YÃ�Ìͼ�Ç�½�»�¸¿¶³Æ�µY¶³·�¸¿¶Sò8Î 2 ¶rËs»YÃ�»Y½{¼¿ÇÜ»Y¼�¼¿ÈqÅ�¶�¸¿¹Á»�¸ � Ìͼ}»:¸�½{¶s»Y¼o¸ Î 2 ·¿Ì{¸¿¶ � e � l&� �)Ê�Ç�·}»Üº8Ç�¼�Ì{¸¿Ì{µ�¶ÌÍÃf¸¿¶³É�¶�·3l8Î

2 ¶¦Ã=¶SòV¸�Æq¶�æqÃq¶(¸�¹q¶(lu¸�¹ �}×�ÞVÕ!á!á�åY×�ÞSÖÁÓ� . Î þV¸!»�·�¸�Ð}Ì�¸�¹&» ¼�¶�¸�ÇYÊ � l � �ѵ�¶�·�¸�Ì{˳¶�¼7) . eP�^)�"� � ��-�-�- �"�%. �"! � ��-�-�- �"!h. ��` TuÎÏ"¹q¶�¶³ÆqÉ�¶}¼�¶�¸�*

. Ìͼ¸¿¹q¶�È=ÃqÌÍÇ�ÃÜÇYÊK¸�¹=¶�¼�¶�¸�¼PP4^)�"�J4B� �.��J4 � !54i� �.�!54 � `��a� �d?�� lmTuÀ PP��J4 �"!54 � � � � ��?�� lmTuÀ*»�ÃqÆ PP�� � � `�� T38 PP4^)�"!h.��UTf�¼¿¶�¶ � ÌÍÉYÈq·¿¶ �SÎ \ »Y½{½G¶�ÆqÉ�¶�¼kÇYʸ�¹=¶�Ê�Ç�·¿Å ��J4 �"!54���¸�¹q¶�Ò|à!ÖÁÕ � ÕO0CåVÕ!áSÀ*¶³ÆqÉY¶³¼nÇYÊ?¸�¹=¶�Ê�Ç�·¿Å ��J4 �"!54 � � �SÀ� ^�� !h.\�QÀ�»YÃqÆ �� � � `���¸¿¹q¶�Ò0à!ÖÁÕ� ÕO0CåVÕ!áSÀÁ»�ÃqÆ�¶�ÆqÉ�¶�¼�ÇYÊG¸�¹=¶�Ê�Ç�·�Å ^�� �%4i�}»�ÃqÆ *!54 � `��+¸¿¹q¶�Ò0à!ÖÁÕ � ÕO0CåVÕ!áS�¼¿¶�¶ � Ì{É�Èq·�¶ �SÎ l Ç�¸�¶n¸�¹Á»:¸ � Ìͼ�¸¿¹q¶rÉ�·�»Yº=¹�Ì{Ã�¸�¹q¶rÇ�·�ÌÍÉ�Ì{ÃÁ»Y½ 5 ·�»Y¶�¼¿¼��î¼�ê�»Y·¿»YÆqÇsò � ÌÍÉ�Èq·�¶ �7|Â��J�SÎ

�k¶�æÁÃ=¶�Ë�Ç�¼�¸�Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼"Ç�Ã�¸�¹q¶r¶�ÆqÉ�¶³¼}ÇYÊ� . »Y¼�Ê�Ç�½{½ÍÇCÐ}¼³ÎDh^��Ï?¾Vº8¶ h ¶³ÆqÉ�¶�¼�»Y·¿¶rÉ�Ì�µ�¶³Ã�¸¿¹q¶r˳Ç�¼o¸�Ê�ÈqÃ=Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�Ã(� .S @ ,�+e �^Î 5 ��Ï?¾Vº8¶ 5 ¶³ÆqÉ�¶�¼�»�·¿¶rÉ�Ì{µY¶³Ã�¸�¹=¶�Ë�Ç�¼�¸�Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ã(� .S @ ,�+e ��Î \ � � Ç�·*¶³»YË!¹<?jG P��-� � ��-�-1- �Ul TuÀd¸¿¹q¶¸y¾Vº8¶ \ ¶³ÆqÉ�¶�¼$*!54 � `��*»�ÃqÆ 4^)�"�%. � 4 ��� �*»Y·�¶?É�Ì{µY¶³Ã�»"˳Ç�Ãf¸�Ì{ÃuÈqÇ�Èq¼�ÀÃqÇYÃqÆq¶³Ë�·¿¶³»Y¼¿Ì{ÃqÉ�Ë�Ç�¼�¸}Ê�ÈqÃ=Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�Ã(� .S @ ,�IÐ}Ì{¸¿¹(� .S yl�p7�l � �.���+e ��»YÃqÆ(� .S ��.��e ?¿Î� Ç�· ? e �-��-�-�- �Ul8À*½{¶�¸ � 4Æq¶³ÃqÇ�¸�¶�¸�¹q¶�ºq»�¸�¹�^�% �%4 % !54$% `QÎ � Ç�· ? e � �1-�-�- � l8À�½Í¶S¸��z4?Æ=¶³ÃqÇY¸¿¶¸�¹=¶ ºÁ»�¸¿¹ ^�% �J4 % !54 � � % `QÎ �k¶�æqÃq¶�� � ¸�Ç�Â8¶�¸�¹q¶�ºÁ»�¸¿¹ ^ % � � % `�»YÃ=Æ��r. ��� ¸�¹=¶ ºÁ»�¸¿¹^ % !h. % `QÎ�´nÃ�Ç�Ãq¶�¹Á»YÃ=Æ*À�·¿Ç�È=¸¿ÌÍÃqÉÜÇ�Ã=¶�È=ÃqÌ{¸�ÇYÊ �ÁÇCÐ Ç�Ã�¶s»YË!¹�ÇYÊ � � ��-�-�- � � .n¾VÌͶ�½ÍÆq¼�» 2 »�·¿Æq·�Ç�º¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌ{Âq·¿Ì{ÈqÅ E�Ê�ÇY·_� . �Ul�� � . ��Ì{Ã�Ð}¹qÌ{Ë!¹�»Y½Í½Á¸¿·�»�ÿ�Ë�Ì{Ãq˳È=·¿¼IË�Ç�¼�¸l�� � � ÌÍÉ�È=·¿¶�í70»����SÎ?´kÃ�¸�¹q¶kÇ�¸�¹q¶�·¹Á»YÃ=Æ*À÷Ì�Ê�� Ì{¼�¸¿¹q¶�¼¿È=ÂqÉ�·�»�ºq¹(Ç�Â=¸�»YÌÍÃ=¶³Æ�Ê�·�Ç�Å� . Âf¾�Æq¶³½{¶�¸¿ÌÍÃqÉ�¸�¹q¶,l�¸y¾Vº8¶Qh ¶³ÆqÉY¶³¼³À8¸�¹q¶�Ã(·¿Ç�È^¸�ÌÍÃ=Él�p7�l � �.�AÈqÃ=Ì{¸�¼�ÇYÊ �ÁÇCÐ Ç�Ãܶ³»YË!¹ÜÇYÊ�� � ��-1-�- ���z. ��� ¾VÌͶ�½ÍÆq¼» 2 »Y·�Æq·¿Ç�º�¶�öuÈqÌͽ{ÌÍÂq·�ÌÍÈqÅ E � Ê�Ç�· � �Ul�� � . �

Page 15: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

v1

v2

v3

w1

w2

w3

s t

1

1

3

2

1

2

3

1

0

10

0

1

� �i�[l=� �;:��8')�G����-.24M@24`.�82@-�# 2@% � � ���"O���� �"�v1

v2

v3

w1

w2

w3

s t

1

1

0

0

0

0

0

0

1

1

� `��Ul=� �;:��8')� ����-.24M@24`.�82@-.# 2@% !��.�m'&��!"24#v� M.?"-.`�hN)�;� ���

� Ì{É�Èq·¿¶�í (ê?·�Ç^Ç�ÊnÇYÊnÏ"¹q¶�Ç�·¿¶�Å ü^Î À+Ð}¹q¶³Ã l e#ü=Î þ^Ç�½{ÌÍÆx¶³Æ=É�¶³¼�˳»Y·¿·o¾x¸�·�»:ÿ�Ë�ÌÍÃç¸�¹q¶ 2 »�·¿Æq·�Ç�º¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌ{Âq·¿Ì{ÈqÅ�ÀVÆÁ»Y¼�¹q¶³Æ�¶³Æ=É�¶³¼�ÆqÇ�ÃqÇY¸sÎ+b�ÆqÉY¶�Ë�Ç�¼�¸¿¼�»�·¿¶kÐ}Ì{¸¿¹�·¿¶³¼�º8¶�Ë�¸�¸�Ç�¸�¹=¶ 2 »Y·�Æq·¿Ç�º�¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌ{Âq·¿Ì{ÈqÅ�Î

ÌÍÃ�Ð}¹qÌ{Ë!¹�»�½Í½8¸¿·�»�ÿ�ËrÌÍÃ=˳Èq·�¼�ÇYÃq½{¾ Ç�Ãq¶rÈqÃqÌ�¸}ÇYÊ�Ë�Ç�¼�¸ � ÌÍÉ�È=·¿¶rí7�Âu�J�QÎ?Ï"¹VÈ=¼� g' �+b�� �&� � � yEt��p �p�E � �+e�l&� �8e � p�� �

˳ÇYÅ�ºq½{¶�¸¿ÌÍÃqÉ�¸¿¹q¶rºq·¿ÇVÇYÊ`Î

�c? ;=9��J$ � B�� óyÃ¥¸�¹q¶�ºq·�Ç^ÇYÊ�ÇYÊ"Ï"¹q¶�Ç�·¿¶�Å ü^Î ÀG¸�¹q¶�¼¿ÈqÂ=É�·�»Yº=¹ � ÐI»Y¼)ÇYÂ=¸!»YÌ{Ãq¶³ÆÄÊ�·¿Ç�Å . Âf¾Ä·¿¶QôÅ�ÇdµVÌ{ÃqÉ l�¶³ÆqÉ�¶�¼³Î?Ï"¹uÈq¼³ÀÁÊ�Ç�·I¶�µ�¶�·�¾�ºKÇ�¼¿Ì�¸�Ì�µ�¶nÌÍÃf¸¿¶³É�¶�·l8Àq¸�¹=¶³·¿¶nÌ{¼}»�¼¿ÌÍÃ=É�½Í¶Qôy˳ÇYÅ�Å�Ç^Æ=Ì{¸y¾�Ì{Ãq¼�¸�»YÃq˳¶kÊ�ÇY·Ð}¹qÌ{Ë!¹�·¿¶�Å�ÇCµVÌÍÃqÉ,l�¶³Æ=É�¶³¼�˳»YÃ�Æq¶�˳·�¶s»Y¼�¶k¸�¹q¶�˳Ç�¼o¸�ÇYÊ�» 2 »Y·�Æq·¿ÇYº�¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌÍÂ=·¿ÌÍÈ=Å Âf¾�»�Ê|»YË�¸¿Ç�·+Ç�Ê l � ��Î�c? ;=9��J$ � B�� Ï"¹q¶}˳Ç�Ãq¼o¸�·�ÈqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�ÃÜÌÍÃ�¸¿¹q¶"ºq·�Ç^ÇYÊKÇYÊ8Ï"¹q¶�Ç�·¿¶�Å ü=Î Ës»YÃ�»Y½Í¼�ÇnÂ8¶}»�ÆÁ»Yº=¸¿¶³Æ�¸�Çr¼¿Ë�¶³ÃÁ»�·¿ÌÍÇY¼Ð}¹q¶�·¿¶(»�·¿ÂqÌ�¸�·�»�·�¾éË�Ç�¼�¸�Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃq¼ »�·¿¶�ÃqÇY¸ »Y½Í½{ÇCÐI¶�Æ*Î � Ç�·Ü¶Sò=»YÅ�ºq½{¶YÀI¼�ÈqºqºKÇ�¼¿¶�˳Ç�¼o¸�Ê�È=ÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãq¼�»Y·�¶·¿¶�¼�¸¿·¿ÌÍËS¸�¶�Æĸ¿Ç�ÂK¶Üº8ÇY½{¾VÃqÇ�Å�Ì�»Y½{¼�Ð}Ì�¸�¹§ÃqÇ�Ã=Ãq¶³Éf»:¸�Ì{µY¶Ü˳ÇV¶�ÿ�˳Ì{¶³Ãf¸�¼�»YÃqƧÆq¶�É�·¿¶�¶�»:¸�Å�Ç�¼o¸ ��Î \ Ç�Ãq¼�ÌÍÆq¶�·¸�¹=¶�ÌÍÃ=¼�¸!»�Ãq˳¶=� . �Ul�� �&�SÀfÐ}¹q¶�·¿¶zl � p½Íà �*Àq»YÃqÆ�Ð}¹q¶³·�¶�¸�¹=¶�˳ÇY¼�¸IÊ�È=ÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãq¼ �}Ê�ÇY· . »Y·�¶�ÌÍÆ=¶³Ãf¸�Ì{Ës»Y½¸�Ç ¸¿¹qÇ�¼�¶ÄÌ{Ãì¸�¹q¶¦º=·¿ÇVÇYÊrÇYÊ�Ï"¹q¶³Ç�·�¶³Å ü^Î À}¶Qò=Ë�¶³º=¸�¸�¹q»�¸�»¥¸y¾Vº8¶ \ ¶³ÆqÉY¶¦ÇYÊ�¸¿¹q¶(Ê�Ç�·�Å *!54 � `���ÇY·4^)�"�%. � 4 ��� ��·�¶³Ë³¶�Ì{µY¶³¼�¸�¹=¶�˳ÇY¼�¸�Ê�ÈqÃ=Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�à ?D � Î h�·�É�ÈqÌÍÃ=É�»Y¼+ÌÍ฿¹q¶�ºq·�Ç^Ç�Ê�ÇYÊ�Ï"¹q¶�Ç�·¿¶�Å ü=Î ¼�¹qÇCÐ}¼I¸�¹Á»:¸¸�¹=¶ 5 ·�»�¶³¼¿¼�·¿»�¸�Ì{Ç�ÇYÊ . �Ul�� �&��Ì{¼��SylU� e �S � p½Íà �[��»Y¼ � % �EÎ(Ï"¹qÌ{¼ 5 ·�»�¶³¼¿¼)·�»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Å�»�¸¿Ë!¹q¶³¼�ÀÈqºx¸�ǧ»¦Ë³ÇYÃq¼�¸�»YÃf¸�Ê|»YËS¸�Ç�·�À�¸�¹q¶�ÈqºqºK¶³·�ÂKÇ�ÈqÃ=ÆçÊ�Ç�·�¸¿¹qÌͼ)¼¿¶�¸�ÇYÊ�˳ÇY¼�¸ÜÊ�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃq¼�¸�¹Á»:¸�Ê�Ç�½Í½{ÇdÐ}¼�Ê�·¿Ç�ÅÏ"¹q¶�Ç�·¿¶�Å �^Î �CýÜ»�ÃqÆ�ê?·�Ç�ºKÇ�¼¿Ì�¸�ÌÍÇYÃ�ü=Î ü^Î�þ^¶³¶ ë ý5��ñ*Ê�Ç�·"Å�Ç�·¿¶nÆ=¶�¸!»�Ìͽͼ�»YÃqÆ�Ê�Èq·�¸¿¹q¶³·}¶Sò=»YÅ�ºq½{¶³¼³Î

� ��� � � ��� �.�"!$#�� ,.,H/�� �U���.!��Ï"¹qÌ{¼�¼¿ÈqÂq¼�¶³ËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃ)¼¿¹=ÇdÐ}¼�¸�¹q»�¸sÀ:»YÅ�Ç�ÃqÉ"¼�ÌÍÃqÉ�½{¶Sô�˳Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ�¸y¾}Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õu¼�À�¸�¹=¶ 5 ·�»Y¶�¼¿¼�·�»�¸¿ÌÍÇ"Ì{¼�Å »:ò^Ì{Å�Ì{ú³¶³ÆÂf¾�¸�¹=¶�Ã=¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õu¼�Ë�Ç�Ãq¼o¸�·¿È=Ë�¸�¶�Æ�Ì{Ã�¸¿¹q¶rºq·¿ÇVÇYÊAÇYÊAÏ"¹q¶³Ç�·�¶³Å ü=Î Î

�dí

Page 16: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

� �1?�J � ? ; � B V EqTWV � Y�Z !�Ý g' �Ob0� ���rØÍá�Þ�áSØÔßVåYâÍÕ/.¿Ù!Û0.�. Û10YØÔÒ0à�ØÔß=áSÒÚÞYß÷Ù!ÕzC�ØÔÒÔÓ � /YÕS×QÒ|ØÚÙ!Õ!á#"?Ò�ÓÁÕSß� �'��+b�� ��� � � � �� -

� Ç�½Í½{ÇdÐ}Ì{ÃqÉ x�Ì{Ã*À 0�ÇYÈqÉ�¹qÉf»�·¿Æq¶�Ã*À�»�ÃqÆ&Ï�»�·¿ÆqÇ�¼¦ëîðU��ñÚÀ"Ð+¶(Ð}Ìͽͽ�Ç�Â=¸�»YÌÍà Ï"¹q¶³Ç�·�¶³Å ü^Î ý¥»�¼�» ˳Ç�ÃVô¼¿¶�öuÈq¶³ÃqË�¶�ÇYÊ�»¦Å�ÇY·¿¶�É�¶�Ãq¶³·¿»Y½�¸�¹q¶�Ç�·¿¶�Å�ÎéÏ"¹=¶�¼o¸!»�¸¿¶³Å�¶³Ãf¸�ÇYÊ�¸�¹qÌ{¼�Å�Ç�·�¶�É�¶�Ãq¶³·¿»Y½"·¿¶�¼¿Èq½�¸�È=¼¿¶³¼Ü¸�¹=¶Ê�Ç�½{½ÍÇCÐ}ÌÍÃqÉ)Æq¶�æÁÃ=Ì{¸�Ì{Ç�Ã*Î� ?!�s� Gw� GDJm�*� B � x�¶�¸fg' �+b�� �&��ÂK¶�»(¼¿Ì{ÃqÉ�½{¶SôyË�Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ{¸y¾(ÌÍÃq¼o¸!»YÃqË�¶�»YÃqÆ�� »(¼¿ÈqÂq¼�¶�¸�ÇYÊ}¸�¹=¶�¶³ÆqÉ�¶�¼ÇYÊ 'ÜÎ�Ï"¹q¶n¼¿¶S¸��éÌ{¼�áyÖ=ÞY×�áCÕ+Ì{Ê�ÃqÇ�¸yÐ+Ç�¶³ÆqÉY¶³¼}ÇYÊ��鼿¹Á»Y·�¶r»YÃ�¶³Ã=Æqº8ÇYÌÍÃf¸sÀÁ»�ÃqÆ�ÌÍÃ�»�ÆqÆqÌ{¸¿ÌÍÇ�àÃqÇ�¶³ÆqÉY¶kÇYÊ�çÌ{¼"ÌÍÃqË�ÌÍÆq¶�Ãf¸�¸¿Ç ^�Ç�· `QÎóyÃ�ÇY¸�¹=¶³·�Ð+Ç�·¿Æq¼�ÀK»�¼¿¶�¸�ÇYÊA¶³Æ=É�¶³¼}ÌͼI¼¿ºÁ»Y·�¼¿¶rÌ{ÊA»YÃ=Æ�ÇYÃq½{¾ Ì{Ê�¸�¹=¶�¾�Ê�Ç�·�Å »YÃ�ÈqÃqÆqÌ{·¿¶³ËS¸�¶�Æu��Å »�¸¿Ë!¹qÌÍÃ=É�ÇYÊ)��uP�^)� ` TuÎ

´kÈq· É�¶�Ãq¶³·¿»Y½�ÂKÇ�ÈqÃ=ÆìÇ�à 5 ·¿»Y¶³¼�¼��î¼�ê�»Y·¿»YÆqÇsò ¼�¸�»�¸�¶�¼ ¸�¹Á»:¸ ¸�¹=¶(¼¿Ì{ú³¶�Ç�Êk¸�¹q¶�½�»Y·�É�¶³¼o¸ ¼�ºÁ»Y·¿¼�¶(¼¿¶S¸·¿¶�Å�ÇCµY¶³Æ�˳Ç�Ãf¸�·�Ç�½Í¼}¹qÇCÐEÅ�ÈqË!¹�¸�¹q¶r˳ÇY¼�¸�ÇYÊ�» 2 »Y·¿Æ=·¿Ç�º�¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌ{Âq·¿Ì{ÈqŠ˳»YÃ�Æq¶³Ë�·¿¶³»Y¼¿¶�Î� �1?�J � ? ; � B�� EqT��:AY�Z � ÕSÒv�'��+b�� �&�,fSÕ�Þ�áSØÔßVåYâÍÕ/.¿Ù!Û0.�. Û10YØÔÒ0àÜØÔß=áSÒÚÞYß÷Ù!Õ#" � Þ áSä fyåY×�ÞSÖÁÓ§Û`Ý3' ""ÞYßm0ExÞYßm0 �E � ÞY×O0Y×�Û!ÖÑÕ��³ä^ØÔâ\Øgf³×QØ|Þ�ÝsÛ:×_�'��+b�� �&�nÞYßm0p � �+b�� �&�#"�×�Õ!áyÖÁÕ!ÙSÒ0Ø /YÕSâ\à � � ÕSÒ���0VÕSß÷Û:ÒyÕnÒÔÓÁÕ�ÕO0CåVÕ!á�ØÔß'Hf³ä^Ò�ß÷Û:Ò � � !�Ý�Õ /YÕS×Qà�áyÖ=ÞY×�áCÕnáSä fSáCÕSÒ�Û`Ý�� Ù!Û:ßÁÒ�ÞYØÔß=á�ÞYÒ . ÛCáSÒ lxÕO0CåVÕ!á#"?ÒÔÓÁÕSß

� yEL� � yl � �.�Sd � �EL�#-5 ¶�Ê�ÇY·¿¶Üºq·¿ÇCµVÌÍÃ=É�Ï"¹q¶³Ç�·�¶³Å'ü=Î ï=À*Ð+¶Ü¼¿¹qÇCÐ ¸¿¹Á»�¸rÌ�¸n¶s»Y¼�Ìͽ�¾�Ì{Å�ºq½{ÌͶ�¼�Ï"¹q¶�Ç�·¿¶�Å ü=Î ý^À�»Y¼kÐ+¶³½Í½?»�¼r»YÃ

ÈqºqºK¶³·)Â8Ç�È=ÃqÆ Ç�à ¸¿¹q¶�¼¿¶Sµ�¶�·¿Ì{¸y¾¥ÇYÊ 5 ·¿»Y¶³¼�¼��î¼Üê�»Y·¿»YÆqÇsò ¸¿¹Á»�¸)Ìͼ)ºq»Y·�»YÅ�¶�¸¿¶³·�ÌÍú³¶�Æ Âf¾Ñ¸¿¹q¶�ÃuÈqÅ�ÂK¶³·�ÇYʶ³Æ=É�¶³¼�·¿¶�Å�ÇCµ�¶�Æ*Î� ×�ÛCÛ`Ý�Û`Ý �*ÓÁÕ!Û:×�Õ .���� �Üþ^Ì{Ãq˳¶�¸�¹q¶�·¿¶�»�·¿¶�Ç�Ãq½{¾ � ��µ�¶�·�¸¿ÌÍ˳¶�¼)ÇYÊh' ¸¿¹Á»�¸)»Y·¿¶�ÃqÇY¸Q^ Ç�· `QÀ�¶�µY¶³·o¾¼¿ºq»Y·¿¼�¶�¼¿¶S¸�ÇYÊ*¶³ÆqÉ�¶�¼I¹Á»�¼I»�¸+Å�Ç�¼�¸ �� � ��� p�� �.e � � p���� �k¶�ÆqÉ�¶�¼³Î�Ï"¹q¶�Ç�·¿¶�Å ü^Î ï�ÃqÇCÐùÌÍÅ�ºq½ÍÌ{¶³¼¸�¹=¶¸�¹=¶³Ç�·�¶³Å�Î

Ï"¹q¶�Ãq¶SòV¸�˳Ç�·�Ç�½Í½Í»Y·�¾�Ì{Å�ºq½{ÌͶ�¼+¸�¹q»�¸"¸�¹q¶rÇ�Ã=½{¾ ÐI»s¾�¸�Ç�»YË!¹qÌ{¶�µY¶�»�·¿ÂqÌ�¸�·�»�·¿Ìͽ�¾�½�»Y·�É�¶ 5 ·¿»Y¶³¼�¼�·¿»�¸�Ì{Ç�¼�Ì{¼¸�Ç�»Y½{½ÍÇCÐ »YÃ�ÈqÃq½ÍÌ{Å�Ì�¸�¶�Æ�ÃuÈqÅ�ÂK¶³·}ÇYÊA¶³ÆqÉ�¶r·�¶³Å�Çdµ�»Y½{¼³ÀÁ»�Ãq¼�Ð+¶³·�ÌÍÃqÉ�»�öVÈ=¶³¼�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�ÇYÊ�èr»YÅ�¶�ÆÁ»�ë í�ü�ñÚÎ, J � J >D>D9�� � � BDA�� EqT��:A Y[Z�� Õ . Û0/CØÔßVåil ÕO0CåVÕ!ákÝQ×�Û0.�Þ¦áSØÔßVåYâÍÕ/.¿Ù!Û0.�. Û10YØÔÒ0à(ß÷ÕSÒgCIÛ:×31(0VÕ!ÙS×�Õ¿Þ:áCÕ!á�ÒÔÓÁÕÙ!ÛCáSÒ"Û`Ý�Þ � ÞY× 0Y×�Û!ÖéÕ��³äVØÔâ\Øgf³×SØÔä . f³à ÞYÒ . ÛCáSÒIÞ�Ý�ÞVÙSÒyÛ:×�Û`Ý l � ���� ×�ÛCÛ`Ý��I´kÂfµ^Ì{Ç�Èq¼"Ê�·¿ÇYÅ �k¶�æqÃqÌ{¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�ü=Î@�Ü»YÃqÆ�Ï"¹q¶³ÇY·¿¶³Å ü^Î ï=Î

óyÃ�ºÁ»Y·o¸�ÌÍË�Èq½�»�·³À�Ð+¶�ÃqÇ�¸�¶³Æ�¶³»Y·¿½{ÌͶ�·G¸¿¹Á»�¸�¼�ÌÍÅ�ºq½Í¶�ÃqÇ�Ãq½{ÌÍÃq¶³»Y·�µY»�·¿Ì�»�Ãu¸¿¼�Ç�à 5 ·�»Y¶�¼¿¼��î¼�Ç�·�ÌÍÉ�Ì{ÃÁ»Y½f¶Sò=»YÅ�ºq½{¶»YË!¹qÌ{¶�µY¶r» 5 ·�»�¶³¼¿¼"·¿»�¸�Ì{Ç�»Y·�ÂqÌ{¸¿·�»Y·�Ìͽ�¾�˳½{Ç�¼¿¶�¸¿Ç � 3^Ì{Ê�Ç�Ãq½�¾�»�¼¿ÌÍÃ=É�½Í¶�¶³ÆqÉY¶n·¿¶³Å�ÇCµ�»Y½8Ì{¼�»Y½{½ÍÇCÐ+¶³Æ*ÀV¸�¹q¶�Ã�ÃqǼ¿Ì{ÃqÉ�½{¶SôyË�Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ{¸y¾�ÌÍÃ=¼�¸!»�Ãq˳¶k¹q»Y¼�»�½�»Y·�É�¶³· 5 ·�»�¶³¼¿¼I·�»�¸¿ÌÍÇqÎH��Ç�·¿¶�É�¶³Ã=¶³·�»�½Í½{¾YÀf¸�¹q¶kË�Ç�Ãq¼o¸�·¿È=Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�àÌ{à¸�¹=¶ºq·�Ç^ÇYÊAÇYÊAÏ"¹q¶³ÇY·¿¶³Å ü^Î Å�»�¸�Ë!¹q¶�¼"¸�¹q¶rÂKÇ�ÈqÃqÆ�ÇYÊ \ Ç�·¿Ç�½{½�»Y·o¾�ü^Î ����Ê�Ç�·"¶Sµ�¶�·�¾il |¼¿¶�¶ 0�¶�Å »Y·�õ�ü=Î í��SÎ

2 ¶�ÃqÇCÐ&¸�È=·¿Ã�¸¿ÇCÐ�»Y·�Æ�¸¿¹q¶�º=·¿ÇVÇYÊ*ÇYÊ÷Ï"¹q¶³ÇY·¿¶³Å ü=Î ï=ÎÏ"¹=Ìͼ�ºq·¿ÇVÇYÊ÷Ð}Ì{½Í½qÂK¶�Å�Ç�·�¶}Æq¶³½{ÌÍËs»:¸�¶"¸�¹Á»�Ã�¸�¹=¶ÈqºqºK¶³·nÂKÇ�ÈqÃ=Æq¼kÇ�Ã(¸¿¹q¶�ºq·¿Ì{˳¶�Ç�ÊI»�ÃÁ»Y·¿Ë!¹f¾�É�Ì{µY¶³Ã¦ÌÍÃÄþV¶³Ë�¸¿ÌÍÇ�à �VÎnóyÃĺq»Y·�¸¿ÌÍ˳È=½�»Y·�À8Ç�È=·kºq·¿ÇVÇYÊ?Å�È=¼�¸rÂK¶¼¿¶�Ãq¼¿Ì�¸�Ì�µ�¶k¸�Ç�¸¿¹q¶kÃuÈqÅ�ÂK¶³·"Ç�Ê�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õ�µ�¶³·o¸�Ì{˳¶³¼�ÀqÐ}¹q¶³·�¶s»Y¼"¸yÐ+Ç�ôyÃ=Ç^Æq¶�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õu¼"¸y¾VºqÌÍ˳»Y½Í½�¾�Æq¶�¸¿¶³·¿Å�ÌÍÃ=¶¸�¹=¶�ºq·�ÌÍ˳¶�ÇYÊr»YÃq»Y·¿Ë!¹f¾ \ Ç�·�Ç�½Í½Í»Y·�¾ �^Î �\���SÎ 5 ¶�Ës»YÈq¼�¶(ÇYÊn¸¿¹qÌͼ�À�Ç�Èq·Ü¸�¶�Ë!¹qÃqÌÍöuÈq¶�¼�Ð}Ìͽ{½"¹Á»sµ�¶¦»ÄÅ�ÈqË!¹¼�¸¿·¿Ç�Ã=É�¶³·}˳ÇYÅ�ÂqÌÍÃq»�¸�Ç�·�Ì�»Y½ ��»sµ�ÇY·}¸¿¹Á»YÃ�¸�¹qÇY¼¿¶rÌÍÃ�þ^¶�Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�Ãf�^Î

�Cð

Page 17: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

5 ¶³Ë³»YÈq¼�¶�˳ÇY¼�¸?Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃq¼�»Y·¿¶�»Y·�ÂqÌ{¸¿·�»Y·o¾�ÌÍÃÜÏ"¹q¶�Ç�·¿¶�Å ü=Î ï=À�ÐI¶}¸!»�õY¶�»rÅ�ÇVÆq¶³¼o¸I»�ºqºq·¿Ç�»YË!¹�¸¿Ç�½{ÇCÐI¶�·ÂKÇ�ÈqÃqÆqÌ{ÃqÉ ¸¿¹q¶�˳ÇY¼�¸nÇYÊ�» 2 »Y·�Æq·¿Ç�º�¶³öuÈqÌͽ{ÌÍÂq·�ÌÍÈqÅ EÄÌÍÃ�¸¿¹q¶�Ç�·�ÌÍÉ�Ì{ÃÁ»Y½�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õ�·¿¶�½�»�¸¿Ì{µY¶�¸�Ç�¸¿¹Á»�¸�ÇYÊ�»2 »Y·¿Æq·�Ç�º(¶�öVÈ=ÌͽÍÌ{Âq·¿Ì{ÈqÅ �EÑÌ{æ»�¼¿ÈqÂ=Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õ�Î 2 ¶�Ð}Ìͽͽ�Ì{Æq¶³Ãf¸�Ì�ÊÔ¾�¶³ÆqÉ�¶�¼nÇ�Ã�Ð}¹qÌ{Ë!¹ �EÑ·¿Ç�È^¸�¶³¼k»�¸k½{¶s»Y¼o¸»Y¼+Å�ÈqË!¹�¸�·¿»�ÿ�Ëk»Y¼5EAÎ?þ^Ì{Ãq˳¶�˳Ç�¼o¸IÊ�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼�»�·¿¶�Ã=Ç�ÃqÆq¶�˳·¿¶³»Y¼¿Ì{ÃqÉqÀV¸�¹q¶kË�Ç�¼�¸IÌÍÃqË�Èq·¿·�¶³Æ�Âf¾ �E�Ç�฿¹q¶³¼�¶¶³Æ=É�¶³¼�Ìͼ}»�¸}½{¶s»Y¼o¸"¸�¹Á»:¸�Ì{Ãq˳È=·¿·¿¶�Æ�Âu¾iEGÎ�Ï"¹q¶rÃq¶SòV¸�Æq¶�æÁÃ=Ì{¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�Ìͼ"½Í»Y·¿É�¶�½{¾�Å�Ç�¸�Ì{µ�»�¸¿¶³Æ�Âf¾�¸¿¹qÌͼ"Ì{Æq¶s»=Î� ?!�s� Gw� GDJm�*� BDAKA x�¶�¸ E¦»YÃqÆ �E¦ÂK¶nÊ�¶s»Y¼�ÌÍÂq½{¶ �ÁÇCÐ}¼}Ê�Ç�·�¸�¹q¶rÌ{Ãq¼�¸�»YÃq˳¶ g' �+b�� �&�SÎ0»��ah�Ã&¶³ÆqÉ�¶�a(ÇYÊQ' Ì{¼ yE � �Et� .yâ\Ø�å:ÓVÒ�Ì�ÊrE%S�� �EJS »�ÃqÆ �E%S� �=À yE � �Et�/.ÚÓÁÕ¿Þ-/Cà�Ì�ÊQE%S �E%SSÀ�»�ÃqÆ

�E � �Et� .yäuáCÕSâÍÕ!á!á+Ì�Ê�EJS+e �E%S�e �=Î|Â��ah�Ã�ÈqÃ=ÆqÌÍ·�¶³Ë�¸¿¶³Æ(ºq»�¸�¹�Ìͼ yE � �EL� .oÞYâ\Ò`ÕS×QßKÞYÒ|ØÔßVå�Ì�Ê�Ì�¸�Ë�Ç�Å�ºq·¿Ì{¼¿¶³¼}Ç�Ã=½{¾�Ê�Ç�·oÐ�»�·¿Æ yE � �Et�yô�½ÍÌÍÉY¹u¸�¶³ÆqÉ�¶�¼

»YÃ=Æ�ÂÁ»�Ë!õuÐI»Y·�Æ yE � �EL��ôy¹q¶³»sµV¾�¶�ÆqÉ�¶�¼³Î2 ¹q¶�ÃѸ�¹=¶�Ë�Ç�Ãf¸�¶SòV¸)Ìͼr˳½{¶s»Y·�ÀGÐ+¶ Æq·�Ç�º§¸�¹q¶�Æq¶³ºK¶³Ã=Æq¶³ÃqË�¶�Ç�ÃkEç»YÃ=Æ �EéÊ�·¿Ç�Å ¸¿¹q¶Ü¸�¶³·�Å�¼rÌ{à �k¶SæÁÃqÌ�ô¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�ü=Î ����Î687:9�;=< >@? � BDA X \ Ç�Ãq¼�ÌÍÆq¶�·G¸¿¹q¶ 5 ·¿»Y¶³¼�¼��î¼êA»Y·�»YÆ=ÇCò�Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇY·¿õp � Ì{É�Èq·¿¶ �7�Âu�J�QÎcx�¶S¸jE�Â8¶�¸�¹q¶ 2 »�·¿Æq·�Ç�º¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌ{Âq·¿Ì{ÈqÅ »YÃqÆ �E ¸¿¹q¶ÜÇ�º=¸¿ÌÍÅ�»Y½ �qÇdÐrÀ�Ð}¹qÌ{Ë!¹Ñ¼�ºq½ÍÌ�¸�¼k¸¿¹q¶�¸�·¿»�ÿ�Ë�¶Sµ�¶�Ãq½{¾§ÂK¶�¸yÐ+¶³¶�ÃѸ�¹=¶�ºq»�¸�¹q¼ ^�%� % `r»YÃ=Æ�^ % ! % `QΠÏ"¹q¶�Ã*À�¶�ÆqÉ�¶³¼p4^)�"�P�QÀ$*� � !_�SÀ�»�ÃqÆ *!+� `��k»Y·�¶fyE � �Et�yô�¹q¶s»sµu¾¦Ð}¹qÌͽ{¶Ü¶³ÆqÉ�¶�¼4^)�"!^�I»YÃqÆ �� � `���»�·¿¶ yE � �EL��ôy½ÍÌ{É�¹f¸sÎÏ"¹=¶�È=ÃqÌÍöuÈq¶ yE � �Et��ô`»Y½�¸�¶³·�ÃÁ»�¸¿ÌÍÃqÉ ^�ô4`IºÁ»:¸�¹�Ìͼ ^ % ! % ��% `QÎ

Ï"¹q¶"Ãq¶Qò^¸?½{¶³Å�Å »}¼�¸�»�¸�¶�¼¸�¹Á»:¸sÀYÊ�Ç�·A¶�µY¶³·�¾)ºÁ»YÌ{·�ÇYÊÁÊ�¶³»Y¼¿Ì{Âq½Í¶ �ÁÇCÐ}¼³ÀV»Yà ^�ô `A»Y½�¸�¶�·¿ÃÁ»�¸¿ÌÍÃqÉ�ºÁ»�¸¿¹�¶Sò^Ìͼo¸�¼�Îó�¸�Ìͼ}»YÃ�¶³»Y¼�¾�Ë�Ç�Ãq¼¿¶�öuÈq¶³ÃqË�¶)ÇYÊ �ÁÇCÐ Ë�Ç�Ãq¼¿¶�·�µ�»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�»Y·�É�ÈqÅ�¶³Ãf¸�¼�Î�+? ;=;=9 �:BDA � � ÕSÒ E¦ÞYßm0 �EqfSÕ A}Û%C�áKÝsÕ¿Þ:áSØgf³âÍÕÁÝsÛ:×+ÒÔÓÁÕ?áSØÔßVåYâÍÕ/.¿Ù!Û0.�. Û10YØÔÒ0à}ØÔß=áSÒÚÞYß÷Ù!Õ �'��+b�� �&��� �*ÓÁÕSß "ÒÔÓÁÕS×!Õ"ØÍá�ÞYß �E � �Et� .oÞYâ\Ò`ÕS×QßKÞYÒ|ØÔßVå8^ . `�Ö=ÞYÒÔÓ ���ÄÛ:×�Õ!Û0/YÕS× "GØ Ý E§ØÍá30YØÔ×!Õ!ÙSÒyÕO0�ÞVÙSàfÙSâ\ØÚÙ#"�ÒÔÓÁÕSß�Õ /YÕS×Qà�áSä�Ù!ÓkÖ=ÞYÒÔÓfSÕÚåYØÔß=á�ÞYßm0�ÕSßm0:áuC�ØÔÒ�Ó�ÞYß �E � �E,�/.yâ\Ø�å:ÓVÒ"ÕO0CåVÕ��� ×�ÛCÛ`Ý���þVÈqºqºKÇ�¼¿¶"Ê�Ç�·�Ë�Ç�Ãf¸�·�»�ÆqÌÍËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃܸ¿¹Á»�¸�¸¿¹q¶³·�¶�Ì{¼�ÃqÇ yE � �Et�yôy»Y½{¸¿¶³·¿Ãq»�¸�Ì{ÃqÉ ^�ô `AºÁ»�¸¿¹ »YÃ=Æ�½{¶�¸ �ÄÆ=¶³ÃqÇY¸¿¶¸�¹=¶�¼�¶�¸�ÇYÊAÃqÇVÆq¶³¼}·¿¶³»YË!¹Á»YÂ=½Í¶kÊ�·¿ÇYÅ ^rµVÌͻܼ�ÈqË!¹�ºq»�¸�¹q¼�Î?Ï"¹q¶r¼¿¶�¸ �x˳Ç�Ãf¸!»�ÌÍÃq¼ ^)»�ÃqÆ*ÀqÂf¾�»Y¼�¼¿ÈqÅ�º=¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã*ÀÆqÇV¶³¼}ÃqÇY¸}Ë�Ç�Ãf¸!»YÌ{Ã(`QÎ�þVÌÍÃqË�¶ �xÌͼ}»YÃ_^�ô `+˳È=¸³Àq¸�¹q¶rÃq¶S¸ E�ô �ÁÇCÐ »YÃqÆ �E�ô �qÇdÐE¶Sò^Ì{¸¿ÌÍÃqÉ �çÌͼ"ºq·�¶³Ë³Ì{¼¿¶�½{¾KbVÎ

þ^ÌÍÃ=˳¶"µ�¶�·�¸�Ì{˳¶�¼�Ì{à �Ä˳»YÃÜÂ8¶}·¿¶³»YË!¹q¶�Æ�Ê�·�Ç�Å ^"µ^ÌÍ» yE � �EL�yôy»Y½{¸¿¶³·�ÃÁ»�¸�Ì{ÃqÉkºÁ»:¸�¹q¼?»YÃ=Æ�µY¶³·�¸¿ÌÍË�¶³¼?Ç�È=¸¿¼¿ÌÍÆ=¶�ç˳»YÃqÃqÇ�¸sÀÁ¶³Æ=É�¶³¼}¸�¹Á»:¸}¶Sò^Ì{¸ �ç˳»YÃqÃqÇ�¸�ÂK¶ yE � �EL��ôy½ÍÌ{É�¹f¸sÀ=»YÃqÆ�¶³ÆqÉY¶³¼}¸�¹Á»�¸}¶�Ãf¸�¶³· �ç˳»YÃqÃqÇ�¸�ÂK¶ yE � �Et�yô¹q¶³»Cµu¾YÎ"þ^Ì{Ãq˳¶n¸�¹=¶�Ã=¶�¸�ÁÇCÐ »YË�·¿Ç�¼�¼ �xÌͼ}º8ÇY¼¿Ì{¸¿Ì{µY¶ 0»Y¼�¼¿ÈqÅ�ÌÍÃqÉ�b ���SÀq¼�Ç�Å�¶rÃqÇYÃ^ôyÈq¼�¶³½{¶³¼¿¼ 0»�ÃqÆ�¸¿¹uÈq¼yE � �Et��ôy¹q¶³»Cµu¾U��¶�ÆqÉ�¶�¶Qò=Ì�¸�¼ �"Î�Ï�»�õY¶³Ã¦¸¿Ç�É�¶�¸¿¹q¶³·�À8¸¿¹q¶³¼�¶�Ê|»YË�¸¿¼�ÌÍÅ�ºq½�¾�¸�¹Á»�¸�¸�¹q¶�Ãq¶�¸zE�ô �ÁÇCÐ ¶Qò=Ì�¸�Ì{ÃqÉ �Ìͼ"¼o¸�·�ÌÍË�¸¿½{¾ É�·¿¶³»�¸�¶�·}¸¿¹Á»YÃ�¸�¹=¶�Ã=¶�¸ �E�ô �qÇdÐE¶Sò^Ì{¸¿ÌÍÃqÉ ��ÀÁ»Ü˳ÇYÃu¸¿·�»YÆ=ÌÍË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã÷Î

��Ç�·�¶³ÇCµ�¶�·³À�Ì{Ê E(ÌͼIÆqÌÍ·�¶³Ë�¸¿¶³Æ�»YËS¾^Ë�½ÍÌ{ËYÀ=¸¿¹q¶³Ã�Ì{¸�¼¿¶³Ã=Æq¼}ÃqÇN�ÁÇCÐEÌ{Ãu¸¿Ç�^�Ç�·IÇ�È=¸}ÇYÊ1`QÎ?Ï"¹uÈq¼³Àq¸¿¹q¶kæÁ·¿¼o¸»YÃqÆ�½�»�¼�¸"¶�ÆqÉ�¶³¼�ÇYÊA¶�µY¶³·�¾ �E � �E,�yô`»�½{¸�¶�·¿ÃÁ»:¸�ÌÍÃ=É ^�ô `�ºq»�¸�¹�Å�Èq¼o¸�Â8¶ yE � �EL��ôy½{ÌÍÉ�¹f¸sÎ

´kÈq·ºq·�Ç^ÇYÊ�Ç�Ê�Ï"¹q¶³Ç�·�¶³Å ü=Î ï�Ð}Ìͽͽuºq·�Ç^Ë�¶³¶�Æ�Âf¾�ÌÍÃqÆ=ÈqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�»�½ÍÇ�ÃqÉ�»YÃÜ»Y½�¸�¶³·�ÃÁ»�¸¿ÌÍÃqÉ�ºÁ»�¸¿¹*Àf·¿¶�º8¶³»�¸�¶�Æq½{¾Èq¼�ÌÍÃqÉ�¸�¹=¶�¼¿¹qÇ�·o¸�¶�¼�¸�ô�ºÁ»�¸¿¹Ñ¼o¸�·¿È=Ë�¸�È=·¿¶ÜÇYÊI» 2 »Y·�Æq·¿Ç�º§¶�öVÈ=ÌͽÍÌ{Âq·¿Ì{ÈqÅ�Î�Ï"¹=Ìͼn¼�¸¿·¿ÈqËS¸�Èq·�¶ÜÌͼn¼¿È=Å�Å�»Y·¿Ì{ú³¶�ÆÂf¾�¸�¹=¶rÊ�ÇY½Í½ÍÇCÐ}Ì{ÃqÉ�Ë!¹Á»Y·¿»YË�¸¿¶³·�ÌÍús»:¸�ÌÍÇYÃ�Ç�Ê�¼�ÈqË!¹�¶�öVÈ=ÌͽÍÌ{Âq·¿ÌÍ»=Î�+? ;=;=9 �:BDA�� � ÕSÒuE fSÕ�Þ A}Û%CìÝsÕ¿Þ:áSØgf³âÍÕrÝsÛ:×�ÒÔÓÁÕ�áSØÔßVåYâÍÕ/.¿Ù!Û0.�. Û10YØÔÒ0àÄØÔß=áSÒÚÞYß÷Ù!Õf�'��+b�� �&��� �AÛ:×�Þ/YÕS×QÒ`Õ�� ��ØÔß ' "�âÍÕSÒ�.[��P� 0VÕSß÷Û:ÒyÕ�Ò�ÓÁÕ�âÍÕSßVåYÒÔÓ "cC�ØÔÒÔÓ ×!Õ!áyÖÁÕ!ÙSÒAÒ`ÛÜÕO0CåVÕ�âÍÕSßVåYÒÔÓfá �US�yE%SJ�#"�Û`Ý�Þ�á!ÓÁÛ:×SÒyÕ!áSÒ:^ . �Ö=ÞYÒÔÓ�ØÔßK' � �*ÓÁÕSß .[�!^� .[��P� � �#S&�E%SJ�

�dý

Page 18: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

ÝsÛ:×ÑÕ /YÕS×Qà ÕO0CåVÕ�a e �� �"!_� "�ÞYßm0 E ØÍá§Þ � ÞY×O0Y×�Û!Ö Õ��³ä^ØÔâ\Øgf³×QØÔä . Ø Ý¦ÞYßm0ìÛ:ßÁâ\àéØ ÝÄÕ��³äqÞYâ\ØÔÒ|à¥ÓÁÛ:â 0:áC�ÓÁÕSß÷Õ /YÕS×3E%S � �x�¶³Å�Å »�ü^Î � Ê�Ç�½{½ÍÇCÐ}¼IÊ�·�Ç�Å �k¶�æqÃqÌ{¸¿ÌÍÇ�à �^Î ��»YÃqÆ�ÂÁ»Y¼�ÌÍËrºq·�Ç�º8¶�·�¸¿ÌͶ³¼"Ç�Ê�¼�¹qÇ�·�¸¿¶³¼o¸�ºÁ»:¸�¹q¼�Îx�¶³Å�Å »�ü=Î � À=Ç�·"¸�¹q¶nÊ|»YËS¸"¸�¹Á»�¸ 2 »Y·�Æq·¿Ç�º�¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌ{Âq·¿ÌÍ»�Å�ÌÍÃqÌ{Å�Ì{ú³¶�¸¿¹q¶rº8Ç�¸�¶³Ãf¸¿Ì�»Y½KÊ�ÈqÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�Ì{à 3�.�SÀ

¶s»�¼¿Ìͽ�¾ÜÌÍÅ�ºq½ÍÌ{¶³¼�¸�¹=¶�Ê�Ç�½{½ÍÇCÐ}ÌÍÃqÉr¼o¸�·¿¶�ÃqÉY¸¿¹q¶³ÃqÌ{ÃqÉ�ÇYÊ�ê�·�Ç�º8ÇY¼¿Ì{¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãp�^Î ü�Ê�Ç�·�¼¿Ì{ÃqÉ�½Í¶QôyË�Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ{¸y¾)ÌÍÃq¼o¸!»YÃqË�¶³¼�Î�+? ;=;=9 �:BDA ��� /YÕS×Qà�áSØÔßVåYâÍÕ/.¿Ù!Û0.�. Û10YØÔÒ0à�ØÔß=áSÒÚÞYß÷Ù!ÕÜÞ!0-.�ØÔÒÔá�Þ � ÞY× 0Y×!Û!ÖxÕ��³äVØÔâ\Øgf³×QØÔä . Ò�Ó=ÞYÒIØÍáÜÞ&0YØ .×�Õ!ÙSÒ`ÕO0�ÞVÙSàfÙSâ\ØÚÙ�A}Û%C1��k¶�¸�»YÌͽ{¼ÜÇYÊk¸�¹=¶�ºq·�Ç^ÇYÊ�¼�ÇYÊzx�¶�Å�Å�»Y¼�ü=Î � »YÃ=Æ&ü=Î �díÄ˳»YÃìÂK¶�Ê�Ç�È=ÃqÆìÌÍà ë ý5�^À ��ð:ñ0Î 2 ¶(»�·¿¶�æÁÃÁ»Y½{½{¾ºq·�¶³ºÁ»Y·�¶³Æ�¸�Ç�ºq·¿ÇCµY¶�Ï"¹q¶�Ç�·¿¶�Å ü=Î ï=Î� ×�ÛCÛ`Ý)Û`Ý �*ÓÁÕ!Û:×�Õ . ����� � x�¶�¸ E�ÂK¶r»�ÆqÌÍ·�¶³Ë�¸¿¶³Æ�»YËS¾^Ë�½ÍÌ{Ë 2 »Y·�Æq·¿ÇYº�¶³öuÈqÌͽ{ÌÍÂq·�ÌÍÈqÅ Ê�Ç�·_�'��+b�� ���+»YÃqÆ �E(»2 »Y·¿Æq·�Ç�º�¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌ{Âq·¿Ì{ÈqÅ Ê�Ç�· � �+b�� �&�SÎ 2 ¶�µVÌͶSÐ �E�»Y¼?» �ÁÇCÐ Ì{Ã)¸�¹=¶"½�»Y·�É�¶³·AÃq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õ,' ÌÍÃ�¸¿¹q¶"Ç�ÂfµVÌÍÇ�È=¼ÐI»C¾YÎ � Ç�·�»�µ�¶�·�¸�¶Qò ��ÀK½Í¶�¸ .[��P�"Æq¶³ÃqÇ�¸�¶)¸¿¹q¶�¼¿¹=Ç�·�¸¿¶³¼�¸oôyºÁ»:¸�¹(ÆqÌ{¼�¸�»YÃq˳¶�Ê�·¿Ç�Å ^)¸�Ç ��Ð}Ì{¸�¹�·¿¶³¼�º8¶�Ë�¸k¸¿Ç¶³Æ=É�¶�½Í¶�ÃqÉY¸�¹=¼ �#S&yEJS ��Ì{Ãq'ÜÀ�»YÃqÆ �.[��P��¸¿¹q¶�^�ô ��ÆqÌͼo¸!»YÃ=˳¶�Ð}Ì{¸¿¹¦·¿¶�¼¿ºK¶³Ë�¸r¸¿Ça�#S� �EJS ��Ì{Ã��¥Î l ÇY¸¿¶)¸�¹Á»:¸�k¶�æqÃqÌ{¸¿ÌÍÇ�à �^Î �k»YÃ=Æ�¸�¹=¶�Æq¶SæÁÃqÌ{¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�ÇYÊ�Ë�Ç�¼�¸^0ü��?Ì{Å�ºq½�¾)¸¿¹Á»�¸ �p�Et��eob�d .[@`���»YÃqÆ �p �EL�+eob+d �.[@`��QÀ^¼�Ǹ�¹=¶r¸¿¹q¶³ÇY·¿¶³Å ·¿¶³Æ=Èq˳¶�¼�¸�Çܺq·�ÇCµ^Ì{ÃqÉ�¸�¹Á»:¸ .,�`�� � yl&� �.� d �.u�`��SÀqÐ}¹q¶�·¿¶<l�Ìͼ"¸�¹q¶r¼�ÌÍú³¶nÇ�Ê�¼�Ç�Å�¶r¼�ºÁ»Y·¿¼�¶¼¿¶S¸�ÇYÊ�¶�ÆqÉ�¶�¼�ºq·�¶³¼�¶³Ãf¸�Ì{Ã7' ÂqÈ=¸}ÃqÇY¸ �¥Îx�¶�¸ � Â8¶�»Yà yE � �EL�yôy»Y½{¸¿¶³·�ÃÁ»�¸�Ì{ÃqÉ(^�ô `�ºÁ»�¸�¹÷ÀGÐ}¹qÌ{Ë!¹¥¶Qò=Ì{¼�¸¿¼�Âf¾(x�¶³Å�Å »�ü=Î �Cü=Î h áCÕÚå-. ÕSßÁÒ�ÇYÊ �

Ìͼ}»ÜÅ�»:ò^ÌÍÅ�»Y½÷¼�ÈqÂqºÁ»�¸¿¹�Ç�Ê � ¸¿¹Á»�¸�˳Ç�Ãf¸�»YÌÍÃq¼"ÇYÃq½{¾ �E � �E,�yô�½ÍÌÍÉY¹u¸�Ç�·}Ç�Ãq½{¾ yE � �Et�yô�¹q¶s»sµu¾�¶�ÆqÉ�¶³¼�Î b�ÆqÉ�¶�¼¸�¹q»�¸n»Y·�¶)Ì{Ã�' ÂqÈ=¸nÃqÇ�¸ � »�·¿¶)˳»Y½Í½{¶³Æ Þ!fSáCÕSßÁÒ0Î�þ^ÌÍÃ=˳¶ �EJS ��Ç�à yE � �Et��ôy½ÍÌ{É�¹f¸�¶³ÆqÉ�¶�¼³À�»�Âq¼¿¶�Ãu¸k¶³ÆqÉ�¶�¼Ës»�Ã�ÇYÃq½{¾�·¿¶�¼¿Ì{Æq¶nÌÍÃX�E � �EL�yôy¹=¶s»sµu¾�¼¿¶�É�Å�¶³Ãf¸�¼�Î�Ï"¹=¶�õ�¶�¾ Ë³½�»�ÌÍÅ ÌͼI¸¿¹Á»�¸"Ì�Ê ��Ì{¼"»)µ�¶�·�¸¿¶Sò�»�¸I¸�¹q¶k¶�ÃqÆ�ÇYÊ»�¼¿¶�É�Å�¶�Ãf¸�Ç�Ê �ÜÀÁ»YÃqÆ&? �¹q¶s»sµu¾U�}¼�¶³É�Å�¶³Ãf¸�¼}ÇYÊ � ÂK¶�¸yÐ+¶³¶�à ^�»�ÃqÆ ��˳Ç�Ãf¸�»YÌÍÃ�»YÃ�»YÂq¼�¶³Ãf¸�¶³ÆqÉY¶YÀq¸�¹=¶³Ã.[��P� � �.[��P���@?:d �.,�`��#- "���

Ï"¹qÌ{¼�Ë�½�»YÌ{Å Ì{Å�º=½ÍÌͶ�¼+¸¿¹q¶n¸�¹q¶�Ç�·¿¶�Å�Î�ÏGÇ�¼�¶³¶rÐ}¹f¾�ÀÁæÁ·¿¼o¸�»Yºqºq½�¾ "���+¸¿Ç�`�¸�Ç�Ç�Â=¸�»YÌÍÃ.,�`�� � �.,�`���� lQd �.[@`���e �l&� �.� d �.u�`�� � 0ï��Ð}¹q¶�·¿¶Ql ÌͼI¸¿¹q¶kÃuÈqÅ�ÂK¶³·"Ç�ÊA¼�¶³É�Å�¶³Ãf¸¿¼"ÇYÊ ��¸�¹q»�¸"ÌÍÃ=˳½ÍÈ=Æq¶k»YÃ�»�Âq¼¿¶�Ãu¸�¶�ÆqÉ�¶YÎ?óyÃq¶�öuÈÁ»Y½ÍÌ�¸y¾X|ï��+·¿¶�ÆqÈqË�¶³¼¸�¹=¶)ºq·�Ç^ÇYÊÇYʸ�¹=¶)¸�¹q¶�Ç�·¿¶�Å ¸�Ç�¶Qò=¹=ÌÍÂqÌ�¸�ÌÍÃ=É »�¼¿ºÁ»Y·�¼¿¶�¼�¶�¸nÇ�Ê l�»YÂq¼�¶³Ãf¸n¶�ÆqÉ�¶³¼�Înþ^Ì{Ãq˳¶,EÑÌͼ�» ÆqÌ{·¿¶�Ë�¸�¶�Æ»YËS¾^Ë�½ÍÌ{Ë&�qÇdÐrÀ �k¶SæÁÃqÌ�¸�ÌÍÇYà ü^Î ����»YÃqÆ x�¶³Å�Å »Äü=Î �CüÄÌ{Å�º=½{¾¥¸¿¹Á»�¸Ü¸�¹=¶ yE � �EL��ôy¹q¶³»sµV¾ç¼�¶³É�Å�¶³Ãf¸�¼�ÇYÊ �»Y·�¶)ÆqÌ{¼�û�Ç�Ì{Ãu¸�Ê�·¿ÇYÅ ¶³»YË!¹¦ÇY¸¿¹q¶³·n»�ÃqÆ�Ê�·¿ÇYÅ ^�»YÃ=Æ_`QÎnê�ÌÍË!õuÌÍÃ=É�Ç�Ãq¶)»YÂq¼¿¶�Ãf¸r¶³ÆqÉ�¶�Ê�·¿Ç�Å ¶³»YË!¹§ÇYʸ�¹=¶�lyE � �Et��ôy¹q¶³»Cµu¾�¼�¶³É�Å�¶³Ãf¸¿¼�ÇYÊ � ¸¿¹Á»�¸}˳ÇYÃu¸�»YÌÍÃ�Ç�Ã=¶r¸¿¹uÈq¼�º=·¿ÇCµVÌÍÆq¶�¼}¸¿¹q¶rÆq¶³¼�ÌÍ·�¶³Æ�¼¿ºÁ»Y·�¼¿¶�¼¿¶S¸sÎ

2 ¶}ÃqÇCÐ ºq·¿ÇCµY¶ ]���AÂf¾�Ì{ÃqÆqÈqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃ�Ç�Ã�¸�¹q¶"¼�¶³É�Å�¶³Ãf¸�¼?ÇYÊ �ÜÎ�Ï"¹q¶}Ì{Ãq¶³öuÈÁ»Y½{Ì{¸y¾�¸�·�Ì{µVÌ�»Y½{½{¾n¹=Ç�½ÍÆq¼Ð}¹=¶³Ã� eg^fÀ8¼¿Ç�¼�ÈqºqºKÇ�¼¿¶�Ì�¸k¹qÇY½ÍÆq¼�Ê�Ç�·k»�µY¶³·o¸�¶Sò ��¸�¹Á»�¸kÌͼ�½Í»Y¼�¸�Ç�ç» ¼�¶³É�Å�¶³Ãf¸nÇ�Ê ��ÀKÇ�·kÌ{¼�¸�¹=¶)¼¿ÇYÈq·¿Ë�¶�^fÎ2 ¶�Ð}Ì{¼¿¹Ñ¸¿Ç�º=·¿ÇCµ�¶ "���kÊ�Ç�·&!)ÀGÆq¶�æqÃq¶³Æé»�¼�¸¿¹q¶�½Í»Y¼�¸rµY¶³·�¸¿¶SòÑÇ�Ãĸ�¹q¶�Ãq¶SòV¸)¼¿¶³ÉYÅ�¶�Ãu¸³ÎKx�¶�¸Q?�Æ=¶³ÃqÇY¸¿¶¸�¹=¶kÃuÈqÅ�ÂK¶³·�ÇYÊG¶³»Y·¿½{ÌͶ³·�¼¿¶�É�Å�¶³Ãf¸�¼"ÇYÊ � ¸�¹q»�¸"˳ÇYÃu¸�»YÌÍÃ�»�¸�½{¶s»Y¼o¸"Ç�Ãq¶n»�Âq¼¿¶�Ãu¸}¶�ÆqÉ�¶�Î 5 ¾ ¸¿¹q¶kÌÍÃ=ÆqÈqË�¸¿Ì{µY¶¹f¾Vº8ÇY¸¿¹q¶³¼�Ìͼ�À �.u*�P��� .[*�U� �9?1d �.u@`��QÎ

Ï"¹q¶�Ì{ÃqÆqÈqËS¸�Ì{µY¶)¼o¸�¶³º¦¹q»Y¼�¸yÐ+Ç�Ës»Y¼�¶³¼�Î � Ç�·�¸¿¹q¶�æq·¿¼�¸kËs»Y¼�¶YÀ÷¼�ÈqºqºKÇ�¼¿¶�¸�¹Á»�¸�¸�¹q¶�¼¿¶�É�Å�¶�Ãf¸nÂ8¶S¸yÐI¶�¶³Ã�(»�ÃqÆ ! Ë�Ç�Ãf¸!»YÌ{Ãq¼r»�¸r½{¶s»Y¼o¸rÇ�Ãq¶�»YÂq¼�¶³Ãf¸)¶�ÆqÉ�¶�Î h�¼�»YÂq¼�¶³Ãf¸)¶�ÆqÉ�¶�¼�˳»YçÇ�Ãq½{¾�Â8¶f�E � �Et��ôy¹q¶³»sµV¾YÀ�¸�¹qÌ{¼¼¿¶�É�Å�¶³Ãf¸}˳Ç�Å�ºq·�Ìͼ¿¶�¼IÇ�Ã=½{¾ yE � �Et�yô�¹q¶s»sµu¾ Âq»YË!õfÐ�»Y·�Æ�¶�ÆqÉ�¶�¼³Î+þ^ÌÍÃ=˳¶�¸¿¹q¶³·�¶nÌͼ�»�ºq»�¸�¹�ÇYÊ �¹q¶s»sµu¾U��¶³ÆqÉ�¶�¼Ê�·¿ÇYÅ ! ¸�Ç ��ÀÁ¶s»YË!¹�Ës»Y·�·�¾VÌÍÃqÉpE�ôy�ÁÇCÐrÀ x�¶³Å�Å »Üü=Î � ÌÍÅ�ºq½ÍÌ{¶³¼I¸¿¹Á»�¸ .[�!^� � .[*�U�QÎ+þ^ÌÍÃqË�¶n¸�¹q¶�ºÁ»�¸¿¹ �ÂK¶³É�Ì{Ãq¼GÐ}Ì�¸�¹)»Yà �E � �Et��ôy½{ÌÍÉ�¹f¸�¶³Æ=É�¶^gx�¶³Å�Å »�ü=Î �Cü��SÀ0� �e ^�»YÃqÆ)¸¿¹q¶³·�¶IÌͼG»Yà yE � �Et�yô�½ÍÌ{É�¹f¸�¶³ÆqÉ�¶+¶³Ãf¸�¶�·¿Ì{ÃqÉ

���

Page 19: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

��ÎkþVÌÍÃqË�¶ �EÑ·�Ç�È=¸�¶�¼ �ÁÇCÐ�ÌÍÃf¸¿Ç ��À8Ì�¸�Å)Èq¼�¸�·¿Ç�È=¸¿¶Q�ÁÇCÐ Ê�·�Ç�Å ��¸�Ç `QÎ 5 ¾Dx�¶�Å�Å�»�ü=Î � À �.[*�U� � �.[@`��SÎ\ Ç�Å�Â=ÌÍÃqÌ{ÃqÉ�Ð}¹Á»:¸kÐI¶�õuÃqÇCÐ�Ð}Ì{¸¿¹�¸�¹q¶)ÌÍÃqÆqÈ=Ë�¸�Ì�µ�¶�¹f¾VºKÇY¸�¹q¶�¼¿Ì{¼³À*¸�¹=¶�ºq·¿ÇVÇYÊ?ÇYÊ�¸¿¹q¶�Ì{ÃqÆqÈqËS¸�Ì{µY¶�¼�¸¿¶³º¦Ì{¼Ë³ÇYÅ�ºq½{¶�¸¿¶ .[�!^� � .[��P� � �.[��P���9?1d �.u�`���� w?�� �.�Sd �.[�`���� �.[*!_��� g? � ��� d �.,�`��#-

� Ç�·A¸¿¹q¶�¼¿¶�˳Ç�Ã=Æ�˳»Y¼¿¶�Ç�ÊK¸¿¹q¶�Ì{ÃqÆqÈqËS¸�Ì{µY¶�¼�¸¿¶³º�Ê�Ç�·v"���!À�¼¿È=ºqº8ÇY¼¿¶�¸�¹q»�¸¸�¹=¶�˳Èq·�·¿¶�Ãu¸?¼�¶³É�Å�¶³Ãf¸ ��� �˳ÇYÃu¸�»YÌÍÃ=¼�Ã=Ç�»�Âq¼¿¶�Ãu¸�¶³Æ=É�¶³¼�Î 2 ¶nÐ}Ìͽ{½*ºq·¿ÇCµY¶YÀ�Âf¾�ÌÍÃqÆ=ÈqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�Ç�Ã�¸�¹=¶rµY¶³·o¸�ÌÍË�¶³¼�ÇYÊ���Àq¸¿¹Á»�¸.[� ,��� �.[� ,���9?:d �.[@`�� ������

Ê�Ç�·?»Y½{½^µY¶³·�¸¿ÌÍË�¶³¼� �ÇYÊ��ÜÎÏ"¹q¶}ÂÁ»Y¼�¶}Ës»Y¼�¶ � (e �P�AÊ�Ç�½{½ÍÇCÐ}¼�Ê�·�Ç�Å ¸¿¹q¶"Ç�È=¸¿¶³·?ÌÍÃqÆ=ÈqË�¸¿Ì{µ�¶"¹f¾VºKÇY¸�¹q¶�¼¿Ì{¼G]���SÎ� Ç�·�¸¿¹q¶ |Ì{ÃqÃq¶�·I��Ì{ÃqÆqÈqËS¸�Ì{µY¶�¼�¸¿¶³º*À�¼�ÈqºqºKÇ�¼¿¶ .[� ,� � �.[@ ,� � ? d �.,�`���Ê�Ç�·n» µY¶³·o¸�¶Sò ÑÇ�Ê � »YÃqƦ½{¶�¸��Æq¶�ÃqÇY¸�¶n¸¿¹q¶rÃq¶SòV¸�µ�¶³·o¸�¶Qò�Ç�Ã�¸¿¹q¶r¼¿¶�É�Å�¶�Ãf¸sÎ

ó�Ê�¸�¹q¶�¶³Æ=É�¶ � ���7�G � Ì{¼=�E � �E,�yôy½{ÌÍÉ�¹f¸³Àq¸�¹q¶�à �#S�yEJS � � �US\ �E%SJ��»�ÃqÆ �E%S �=Î�þ^ÌÍÃ=˳¶NEÄ»YÃqÆ �EÑ»Y·�¶2 »Y·¿Æq·�Ç�º�¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌÍÂ=·¿Ì�»^À x�¶³Å�Å�»�ü^Î � »�ÃqÆ�¸¿¹q¶rÌÍÃqÆ=ÈqË�¸¿Ì{µ�¶r¹f¾Vº8Ç�¸�¹q¶�¼¿Ìͼ�ÌÍÅ�ºq½�¾�¸¿¹Á»�¸.[��U� � .,� ,��� �US\�E%SJ� � �.u@ ,� � �US\ �E%S�� �9?:d �.u�`���e �.u��U���9?:d �.[@`�� �Ð}¹qÌ{Ë!¹�¶�¼�¸!»�Âq½ÍÌ{¼¿¹q¶�¼ 3�����+Ê�Ç�·�¸¿¹q¶nµ�¶�·�¸�¶Qò��8Î

ó�Ê�¸¿¹q¶r¶³ÆqÉ�¶ra8e �� � ,��G � Ìͼ yE � �Et��ôy¹q¶³»Cµu¾YÀ�¸¿¹q¶³Ã.[��U� e .[@ ,� U�US\�E%SJ� ����.�� �.[@ ,���@? d �.u�`�� �#S� �EJS � ��.���� �.[��U���9?1d �.[�`�� � ��Cü��Ð}¹q¶�·¿¶)¶�öuÈÁ»�¸�Ì{Ç�à ����.��Ê�Ç�½{½ÍÇCÐ}¼�Ê�·¿Ç�Å ê?·�Ç�ºKÇ�¼¿Ì�¸�ÌÍÇYÃ�ü^Î � »YÃqÆ�¸�¹q¶�Ê|»YË�¸}¸¿¹Á»�¸ E%S �=À�ÌÍÃq¶�öVÈq»Y½ÍÌ�¸y¾��.���Ê�Ç�½{½ÍÇCÐ}¼�Ê�·¿Ç�Å ¸¿¹q¶�ÌÍÃqÆqÈ=Ë�¸�Ì�µ�¶r¹f¾Vº8ÇY¸¿¹q¶³¼�Ìͼ�»YÃqÆ�¸¿¹q¶rÊ|»YË�¸}¸�¹q»�¸ �EJS �dEJS�ÀK»YÃqÆ�ÌÍÃ=¶³öuÈÁ»Y½{Ì{¸y¾��sü��IÊ�Ç�½Í½{ÇdÐ}¼Ê�·¿ÇYÅ ê�·¿Ç�ºKÇ�¼�Ì{¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�ü=Î � Î

óyÃ�¶³Ì{¸¿¹q¶³·IËs»Y¼�¶YÀ=¸¿¹q¶nÌÍÃqÃ=¶³·IÌ{ÃqÆqÈqËS¸�Ì�µ�¶n¼�¸¿¶³º��\����¹qÇY½ÍÆq¼�Î�Ï"¹qÌͼ�Ë�Ç�Å�ºq½Í¶S¸�¶³¼+¸�¹q¶kº=·¿ÇVÇYÊGÇYÊ�¸�¹q¶nÇYÈ=¸�¶�·ÌÍÃ=ÆqÈqË�¸¿Ì{µY¶�¼o¸�¶�º ]����»YÃqÆ�ÇYÊG¸�¹q¶n¸�¹=¶³Ç�·�¶³Å�Î

� ��� � �.- �C� �:� * *f� � �[� ��� / � �=� � 0þ^Ç}Ê|»Y·³Àd¸�¹=ÌͼG¼¿¶³ËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�¹q»Y¼AÇYÃq½{¾n¼o¸�ÈqÆ=ÌͶ³Æ 5 ·�»�¶³¼¿¼&� ¼�ê�»Y·¿»YÆqÇsò�ÌÍÃr¼¿Ì{ÃqÉ�½{¶SôyË�Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ{¸y¾�Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇY·¿õu¼³Î 2 ¶+Ã=¶SòV¸Âq·�ÌͶ]�=¾(¼¿È=·�µ�¶S¾(µ�¶�·�¾¦·�¶³Ë�¶³Ãf¸�·¿¶³¼�Èq½{¸¿¼kÇYÊ`x�ÌÍæ¶S¸�»Y½ÚÎ�ëîð��dñ�Ç�à 5 ·�»Y¶�¼¿¼��î¼�ê�»Y·¿»YÆqÇsò¦Ì{æÅ�Èq½�¸�ÌÍË�Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ{¸y¾Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õu¼³Î 2 ¶ÜÆq¶SæÁÃq¶�¸�¹q¶ 5 ·¿»Y¶³¼�¼r·�»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ê�Ç�·n¼�ÈqË!¹¥Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇY·¿õu¼)»�¼rÊ�ÇY½Í½ÍÇCÐ}¼�Î � Ç�·r»�Å�Èq½�¸�ÌÍË�Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ{¸y¾ÌÍÃ=¼�¸!»�Ãq˳¶p�'��+b�� �&��»YÃ=Æ(»�Ë�Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ{¸y¾ ?¿ÀK½Í¶S¸ . 4{�'��+b�� ����Æq¶�ÃqÇY¸¿¶�¸�¹=¶)˳ÇYÅ�Å�Ç�Ã�˳Ç�¼o¸kÌ{Ãq˳Èq·�·¿¶�Æ�Âf¾�»Y½Í½¸�·¿»�ÿ�ËrÇYÊ�Ë�Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ{¸y¾p??ÌÍÃ�» 2 »Y·�Æq·¿ÇYº�¶�öuÈqÌͽ{ÌÍÂq·�ÌÍÈqÅ Ê�Ç�· �'��+b�� �&�SÎ l ÇY¸�¶ . 43g' �+b�� �&�IÌͼ"Ð+¶³½{½�Æq¶�æÁÃ=¶³ÆÂf¾n�k¶�æqÃqÌ{¸¿ÌÍÇ�à �^Î ��»YÃqÆ�ê�·¿Ç�ºKÇ�¼¿Ì�¸�Ì{Ç�à �^Î ü=Î� ?!�s� Gw� GDJm�*� BDA � Ï"¹q¶��}×�ÞVÕ!á!ár×�ÞYÒ0ØÚÛ�� �'��+b�� ���IÇ�Ê»�Å�Èq½�¸�Ì{˳Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ�¸y¾ÜÌÍÃq¼o¸!»YÃqË�¶ �'��+b�� ���IÌ{¼

� �'��+b�� ����eùÅ »dò���

.Å�ÌÍÃ4;: �

.!4;�'��+b�� �&�. 4;� �Ob0� ��� �

Ð}¹q¶�·¿¶ �'·¿»YÃqÉ�¶�¼}ÇdµY¶³·}¸�¹q¶r¼�ÈqÂqÃq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õu¼�ÇYÊc' ¸�¹Á»:¸}˳Ç�Ãf¸!»�ÌÍÃ�»YÃ_^�4�ô `64�ºÁ»:¸�¹�Ê�Ç�·"¶s»YË!¹7?¿Î

�Cï

Page 20: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

Ï"¹uÈq¼)¸¿¹q¶ 5 ·¿»Y¶³¼�¼)·¿»�¸�Ì{Ç�ÇYÊ"»�Å�Èq½�¸�Ì{˳Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ�¸y¾�Ì{Ãq¼�¸�»YÃqË�¶ Ìͼ�½�»�·¿É�¶ÜÇ�Ãq½�¾§Ì{ÊI·¿¶³Å�ÇCµVÌÍÃqÉ�¼¿Ç�Å�¶�¼¿¶�¸)ÇYʶ³Æ=É�¶³¼�Æq¶�˳·¿¶³»Y¼¿¶�¼�¸¿¹q¶¦Ë³ÇY¼�¸�ÌÍÃ=˳Èq·�·¿¶³Æ&Âf¾ì¸¿¹q¶(¸�·¿»�ÿ�˦ÇYÊ�¶�µY¶³·�¾ì˳Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ�¸y¾ Âf¾ù» ½Í»Y·¿ÉY¶(»YÅ�Ç�ÈqÃf¸sÎ�k¶�æqÃqÌ{¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãq¼�ü=Î ��»YÃqÆ�ü=Î �Cð�˳ÇYÌÍÃqË�ÌÍÆq¶nÌ{Ã�¼�ÌÍÃqÉY½Í¶Sô�˳Ç�Å�Å�Ç^ÆqÌ�¸y¾ÜÃq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õV¼�Î�c? ;=9��J$ � BDA�V þVÌÍÃqË�¶�·�¶³Å�ÇCµ^Ì{Ãqɧ¶³ÆqÉY¶³¼ÜÊ�·¿Ç�Å�»§Å�Èq½�¸�Ì{˳Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ�¸y¾§Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õx» o÷¶�Ë�¸�¼Ü¸�·¿»�ÿ�Ë�Ê�·¿Ç�ÅÆqÌPo÷¶�·¿¶³Ãf¸�˳Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ�¸�ÌͶ�¼"ÌÍÃ�ÆqÌ o8¶³·�¶³Ãf¸�ÐI»s¾^¼�À÷¸�¹=¶³·¿¶)»Y·¿¶�¼¿¶Sµ�¶³·¿»Y½�ºKÇ�¼�¼¿ÌÍÂ=½Í¶�Å�¶³»Y¼¿Èq·�¶³¼�Ê�ÇY·�¸¿¹q¶)¼�¶�µ�¶�·¿Ì�¸y¾ÇYÊ 5 ·¿»Y¶³¼�¼��î¼�êA»Y·�»�ÆqÇsòéÌÍÃ¥¼¿ÈqË!¹çÃq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õV¼�Î � Ç�·�¶Qòq»�Å�ºq½{¶YÀ�Ç�Ã=¶�ÃÁ»�¸¿Èq·�»Y½+Å�¶³»Y¼¿È=·¿¶�Ìͼ)É�Ì{µY¶³ÃéÂf¾ ¸�¹=¶¼�»�Å�¶(Æ=¶�æÁÃqÌ{ÃqÉx¶³öuÈÁ»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�à 0ý�� »Y¼�Ì{Ãì¸�¹q¶�Æq¶�æÁÃ=Ì{¸�Ì{Ç�Ã&ÇYÊr¸�¹=¶ 5 ·�»Y¶�¼¿¼�·¿»�¸�Ì{Ç¥Ê�Ç�·�¼�ÌÍÃqÉ�½{¶Sô�˳Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ�¸y¾Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õu¼ "�k¶SæÁÃqÌ{¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�ü=Î �.�QÎ���Ã=Ê�Ç�·o¸�ÈqÃq»�¸�¶�½{¾�ÀÁÐ}¹qÌ{½Í¶�ê�·¿Ç�ºKÇ�¼�Ì{¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�ü=Î ü�¼�¸¿Ìͽ{½�¹qÇ�½ÍÆ=¼}Ê�ÇY·�¸¿¹qÌͼ�Å�¶³»Y¼¿È=·¿¶YÀÃqÇ�Ì{Ãf¸�¶³·�¶³¼o¸�ÌÍÃ=É�Â8ÇYÈqÃqÆq¼r»Y·�¶)ºKÇ�¼¿¼�ÌÍÂq½{¶�Ê�Ç�·�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õV¼kÐ}Ì�¸�¹¦»�·¿ÂqÌ�¸�·�»�·�¾�˳Ç�¼o¸kÊ�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼i}¶Sµ�¶³Ã§Ì{Ã�¸yÐIÇ:ô˳ÇYÅ�Å�Ç^Æ=Ì{¸y¾�À�¸¿¹q·¿¶�¶Sô�ÃqÇ^Æ=¶�Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇY·¿õu¼³Àq·�¶³Å�ÇCµ^Ì{ÃqÉ�»�¼¿Ì{ÃqÉ�½{¶�¶�ÆqÉ�¶�Ës»YÃ�Æq¶³Ë�·¿¶s»�¼¿¶�¸¿¹q¶�Ë�Ç�¼�¸IÇYÊ�» 2 »�·¿Æq·�Ç�º¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌ{Âq·¿Ì{ÈqÅ Âf¾�»�Ã�»Y·�ÂqÌ{¸¿·�»Y·�Ìͽ�¾Ü½�»Y·�É�¶kÊ|»YË�¸¿Ç�·³Î

Ï"¹q¶�ÈqºqºK¶³·�Â8ÇYÈqÃqƦÇ�Ã�¸¿¹q¶ 5 ·¿»Y¶³¼�¼k·�»:¸�ÌÍÇ�ÌÍÃ(Ï"¹=¶³Ç�·�¶³Å ü=Î ý�ÆqÇ^¶�¼kÃqÇY¸�Ës»Y·�·�¾�ÇCµ�¶³·�¸�Ç�Å�È=½{¸�Ì{˳Ç�Å�ôÅ�Ç^ÆqÌ�¸y¾�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õV¼�ux�ÌÍÃ(¶S¸r»Y½0Îë¢ð��:ñA¼¿¹qÇCÐ+¶³Æ§¸�¹Á»:¸k¸�¹q¶ 5 ·�»Y¶�¼¿¼n·¿»�¸�Ì{Ç Ës»�æÉ�·¿ÇCÐ�¶Sò^ºKÇ�Ãq¶³Ãf¸¿Ì�»Y½{½{¾�Ð}Ì{¸¿¹¸�¹=¶�Ã=¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õ�¼�ÌÍú³¶�ÀÁ¶�µY¶³Ã�Ì{Ã�¸yÐIÇ�ô�˳Ç�Å�Å�Ç^ÆqÌ�¸y¾ Ã=¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õu¼³Î� �1?�J � ? ; � BDA � EqT�� X Y[Z �*ÓÁÕS×!ÕkØÍá�Þ�Ý�Þ-.�ØÔâ\à Û`ÝnÒgCIÛ0.¿Ù!Û0.�. Û10YØÔÒ|à�ß÷ÕSÒ�CIÛ:×31Cá PPg' � �+b � � � � � T��� : � áSäÁÙ!ÓÒÔÓ=ÞYÒc' ��Ó=Þ:á�� � � /YÕS×QÒ|ØÚÙ!Õ!á�ÞYßm0�ÕO0CåVÕ!á�ÞYßm0�� �' � �+b � � � � �+e ��� � � & Þ:á � % � �óyÃ�Ê|»YËS¸sÀÁ¸�¹=¶)˳ÇYÃq¼�¸¿·¿ÈqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃ(ÌÍÃ�¸�¹q¶�ºq·¿ÇVÇYÊ�ÇYÊ�Ï"¹q¶�Ç�·¿¶�Å ü=Î ���ܼ¿¹qÇCÐ}¼�¸¿¹q¶�Ê�ÇY½Í½ÍÇCÐ}Ì{ÃqÉ��»YÆqÆqÌ{ÃqÉ�»�¼¿Ì{ÃqÉ�½Í¶¶³Æ=É�¶�¸¿Ç)»n¸yÐ+Ç�ôyË�Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ{¸y¾�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õrg' � �+b � � � � ��Ð}Ì{¸¿¹��p � �AµY¶³·o¸�ÌÍË�¶³¼I»YÃqÆ�¶³ÆqÉ�¶�¼³À . � �' � �+b � � � � ��e�=À÷»YÃqÆ. .�' � �+b � � � � � e ��Ës»�Ã(ÌÍÃqË�·¿¶³»Y¼¿¶)¸¿¹q¶�Ë�Ç�Å�Å�Ç�Ã�˳Ç�¼o¸nÌÍÃqË�Èq·¿·�¶³Æ¦Âf¾�¸�·�»:ÿ�Ë)ÇYÊ�¸�¹q¶�¸yÐIÇ�Ë�Ç�ÅÜôÅ�Ç^ÆqÌ�¸�Ì{¶³¼+¸¿Ç�·�Ç�ÈqÉ�¹=½{¾ ¸¿¹q¶ � �.�y¸�¹�»YÃqÆ � ¸¿¹ � ÌÍÂKÇ�ÃÁ»YË�˳Ì÷ÃuÈqÅ)Â8¶�·¿¼³À�·�¶³¼¿ºK¶³ËS¸�Ì�µ�¶³½�¾�δkÃ�¸¿¹q¶rÇY¸�¹q¶�·}¹Á»YÃqÆ*Àq¸¿¹q¶ 5 ·�»�¶³¼¿¼}·¿»�¸�Ì{Ç�Ìͼ}»Y½�Ð�»s¾V¼�»:¸}Å�Ç�¼o¸}¶Sò^ºKÇ�Ãq¶³Ãf¸¿Ì�»Y½�Ì{Ã�¸¿¹q¶rÃq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õ�¼¿ÌÍú�¶YÎ� �1?�J � ? ; � BDA � EqT�� X Y[Z �*ÓÁÕS×!Õ ØÍá�ÞéÙ!Û:ß=áSÒÚÞYßÁÒ � �¥áSäÁÙ!Ó ÒÔÓ=ÞYÒ�ÝsÛ:×�Õ /YÕS×Qà7l�� � � �¥ÞYßm0¥Õ /YÕS×SàØÔß=áSÒÚÞYß÷Ù!Õ �'��+b�� �&�zC�ØÔÒÔÓ lxÙ!Û0.�. Û10YØÔÒ|ØÚÕ!á�ÞYßm0 � /YÕS×QÒ|ØÚÙ!Õ!á#" � �'��+b�� �&� � � % . � �Ï"¹q¶�º=·¿ÇVÇYÊ}ÇYÊ}Ï"¹q¶�Ç�·¿¶�Å ü=Î �Cï(»YËS¸�ÈÁ»�½Í½{¾§¼�¹qÇCÐ}¼�¸�¹q¶ ¼�¸�·�Ç�ÃqÉ�¶�·)¼o¸!»�¸¿¶³Å�¶³Ãf¸�¸�¹q»�¸�Ì{ÊE Ìͼ)» 2 »�·¿Æq·�Ç�º¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌ{Âq·¿Ì{ÈqÅ Ê�Ç�·)¸¿¹q¶7luôyË�Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ{¸y¾YÀ � ô�µ�¶�·�¸¿¶SòxÌ{Ãq¼�¸�»YÃq˳¶ g' �Ob0� ���)»�ÃqÆ �E Ìͼ)Ê�¶³»Y¼¿Ì{Âq½Í¶�Ê�Ç�· g' �+b�� �&�SÀ¸�¹=¶³Ã ¸¿¹q¶�Å�»:ò^ÌÍÅ�È=Š˳Ç�¼o¸�Å�»:ò 4 . 43�'��+b�� �&�?Ì{Ãq˳È=·¿·¿¶�Æ�Âf¾Ü¸�·�»:ÿ�Ë�ÌÍÃ�E�Ìͼ �� � . � & ¸�Ì{Å�¶�¼�¸�¹q¶�Å »:ò^Ì{Å�ÈqÅ˳ÇY¼�¸�ÌÍÃqË�Èq·¿·�¶³Æ�Âf¾�¸�·¿»�ÿ�Ë�Ì{à �EAÎÏ"¹q¶}öuÈq¶³¼o¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�Ç�Ê8Ð}¹q¶S¸�¹q¶�·+ÇY·�Ã=ÇY¸�¸�¹q¶}½Í»Y·¿É�¶�¼�¸oôyºKÇ�¼¿¼�ÌÍÂq½{¶ 5 ·�»�¶³¼¿¼?·¿»�¸�Ì{ÇÇYÊAÅ�Èq½�¸�ÌÍË�Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ{¸y¾ÜÃ=¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õu¼�Æq¶³ºK¶³ÃqÆ=¼�Ç�Ã�¸�¹=¶�ÃuÈqÅ)Â8¶�·�Ç�Ê�Ë�Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ{¸¿ÌͶ³¼+Ìͼ"Ç�ºK¶³Ã÷Î

� �� � / � / � ���"!$# � �C��/ 0 0�@0 � � �C� �.� '� R0�� � � �ê�·¿¶Sµ^Ì{Ç�Èq¼Ü·¿¶�¼¿Èq½�¸�¼�ÇYÊ�¸�¹=Ìͼ�¼¿¶�Ë�¸¿ÌÍÇ�ÃéÐ+¶³·¿¶�Æq¶Sµ�ÇY¸¿¶³Æ ¸¿Ç¦¸�¹q¶�»YÃq»Y½{¾V¼¿Ì{¼�ÇYÊ}¸�¹q¶�Ð+Ç�·¿¼o¸�ô�Ës»Y¼�¶�¼�¶�µ�¶�·¿Ì�¸y¾éÇYÊ5 ·¿»Y¶³¼�¼��î¼Üê�»Y·¿»YÆqÇsò8Î 5 ·¿»Y¶³¼�¼��î¼Üê�»Y·¿»YÆqÇsò¥»Y½Í¼�Ç�¼¿È=É�É�¶³¼o¸�¼Ü»�ÃÁ»�¸�È=·�»Y½+»Y½ÍÉYÇ�·¿Ì�¸�¹qÅ�ÌÍË�öuÈq¶�¼�¸¿ÌÍÇ�à ÜÉ�Ì�µ�¶�Ãé»Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õ�À�Ìͼ�Ì�¸�¼�È o8¶³·¿Ì{ÃqÉ Ê�·�Ç�Å ¸¿¹q¶)ºq»Y·�»YÆ=ÇCò�m ó�Ê?¼�ÇqÀ÷Ð}¹qÌ{Ë!¹(¶³Æ=É�¶³¼n¼�¹qÇ�Èq½{Æ(Â8¶)·¿¶³Å�ÇCµ�¶�Æ(¸�Ç�·�¶³Ë³ÇCµY¶³·¸�¹=¶�ÂK¶³¼o¸�ô�º8Ç�¼�¼¿Ì{Âq½Í¶ 2 »Y·¿Æ=·¿Ç�º�¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌÍÂ=·¿ÌÍÈ=Åcm

Ï"¹qÌͼ�ÌÍÃqÃ=Ç^Ë�ÈqÇ�Èq¼�öuÈq¶³¼o¸�ÌÍÇYà ¸�Èq·�Ãq¼�Ç�È^¸�¸¿Ç¥ÂK¶�¶SòV¸¿·¿¶³Å�¶³½�¾çÆqÌ{ÿ�˳È=½{¸Ü¸�Çé»�Ãq¼�Ð+¶³·�À�Ì{à »Ñ¼¿¶³Ã=¼¿¶�Ð+¶Å�»YõY¶nºq·�¶³Ë�Ìͼ¿¶rÂK¶³½{ÇdÐrÎ�ÏGÇÜõY¶�¶³º�¸�¹qÌ{ÃqÉ�¼"¼¿Ì{Å�º=½Í¶YÀuÐ+¶rÐ}Ì{½Í½8ÌÍÃqÌ�¸�Ì�»�½Í½{¾�˳Ç�Ãq¼�ÌÍÆq¶�·"Ç�Ãq½�¾ ¼�ÌÍÃqÉ�½{¶Sô�˳Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ�¸y¾Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õu¼�Ð}Ì�¸�¹§½ÍÌ{Ãq¶s»Y·�˳Ç�¼o¸�Ê�È=ÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãq¼�Î �k¶�¸¿¶³Ë�¸¿ÌÍÃqÉ 5 ·�»Y¶�¼¿¼��î¼�ê�»Y·¿»YÆqÇsò§Ës»�ÃÑÂK¶�ºq¹q·¿»Y¼¿¶�Æ »Y¼r»YÃÄÇ�º^ô¸�Ì{Å�Ì{ús»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�ºq·¿ÇYÂq½Í¶�Å »Y¼nÊ�Ç�½Í½{ÇCÐ}¼inÉ�Ì�µ�¶³Ã¥»�¼¿ÌÍÃ=É�½Í¶Qôy˳ÇYÅ�Å�Ç^Æ=Ì{¸y¾�ÌÍÃq¼o¸!»YÃ=˳¶f�'��+b�� �&��Ð}Ì{¸�¹Ä½ÍÌ{Ãq¶s»�·k˳Ç�¼o¸

���

Page 21: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼³À�æÁÃqÆ(» ¼¿ÈqÂ=Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õ�¸�¹Á»:¸�Å�ÌÍÃqÌ{Å�Ì{ú³¶�¼�¸�¹q¶�˳Ç�¼o¸kÇYÊ?» 2 »�·¿Æq·�Ç�º(¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌ{Âq·¿Ì{ÈqÅ Ê�Ç�· � �+b�� �&�ÇCµ�¶�·»Y½{½�¼¿ÈqÂ=Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õu¼ � � 'ÜÎ 2 ¶+˳»Y½Í½�¸¿¹qÌͼ�Ç�º^¸�ÌÍÅ�ÌÍú³»�¸�Ì{Ç�Ãkºq·�Ç�Âq½{¶³Å������������ ���������������������Î

����������� � �!�"�#����"� ��������Ës»�Ã)ÂK¶+¼�Ç�½{µY¶³Æ�Âf¾�¶³ÃuÈqÅ�¶³·¿»�¸�Ì{ÃqÉ�»�½Í½f¼¿È=ÂqÉ�·�»�ºq¹q¼ � ÇYÊ 'ÜÀYË�Ç�Å�ºqÈ=¸�ôÌÍÃ=É�» 2 »Y·�Æq·¿Ç�º ¶³öuÈqÌͽ{ÌÍÂq·�ÌÍÈqÅ ÌÍÃ�¶s»YË!¹*À=»YÃqÆ�º=ÌÍË!õuÌÍÃqÉ�¸�¹q¶�Â8¶�¼�¸I¼¿Ç�½{È=¸�Ì{Ç�Ã*Îv0þ^ÌÍÃ=˳¶ 2 »Y·�Æq·¿Ç�º ¶³öuÈqÌͽ{ÌÍÂq·�Ì�»»Y·�¶�¸�¹=¶)Å�ÌÍÃqÌ{Å »�ÇYÊ�¸¿¹q¶)Ë�Ç�Ãfµ�¶Qò(Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�Ì{à ����QÀ8Ç�Ãq¶)˳»YÃ(ÂK¶)Ë�Ç�Å�º=È=¸�¶�Æ(Èq¼¿Ì{ÃqÉ Ë�Ç�Ãfµ�¶Qò¦ºq·�Ç�É�·�»�ÅÜôÅ�ÌÍÃqÉqÎ4��´nÃ�¸�¹q¶�Ç�¸�¹q¶�·�¹Á»YÃ=Æ*À8¸¿¹q¶³·�¶�Å »s¾�ÂK¶�»YÃ(¶Qò^º8Ç�Ã=¶³Ãf¸�ÌÍ»Y½AÃuÈqÅ)Â8¶�·kÇYÊ�˳»YÃqÆqÌ{ÆÁ»�¸�¶�¼¿ÈqÂ=Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õu¼�¥Î #�ÇCÐ Ð+¶³½{½G˳»YÃ�ÐI¶�¼¿Ç�½�µ�¶r¸�¹qÌ{¼}Ç�º=¸�Ì{Å�Ì{ús»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�àºq·¿Ç�Â=½Í¶³Å Ì{ÊGÐI¶�Èq¼¿¶�Ç�Ãq½�¾�»�·�¶s»Y¼�Ç�ÃÁ»YÂ=½Í¶�»YÅ�Ç�ÈqÃf¸}ÇYÊ˳ÇYÅ�ºqÈ^¸!»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�ÃÁ»�½÷·¿¶�¼¿Ç�È=·¿Ë³¶�¼ m

2 ¶�Ð}Ì{½Í½�È=¼¿¶�ÂÁ»Y¼¿Ì{Ë�˳Ç�Ã=˳¶³º^¸�¼�ÇYÊ�Ë�Ç�Å�º=È=¸!»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãq»Y½AË�Ç�Å�ºq½Í¶Qò=Ì�¸y¾�¸¿¹q¶³Ç�·o¾§»Y¼rÆq¶�¼¿Ë³·�ÌÍÂK¶³ÆÑÌÍÃ*À*Ê�Ç�·n¶Qòuô»YÅ�ºq½Í¶�À ��»�·¿¶�¾�»�ÃqÆ%$YÇ�¹=Ãq¼¿Ç�æë � ñÚÎ 0}¶³Ë³»Y½Í½q¸¿¹Á»�¸I»'& .oÞSÖfÖK×�Û ��Ø .�ÞYÒ0ØÚÛ:ß�ÞYâîåVÛ:×QØÔÒÔÓ . Ê�Ç�·�»�Å�Ì{ÃqÌÍÅ�ÌÍú³»�¸�Ì{Ç�úq·�Ç�Âq½Í¶�Å ·¿ÈqÃq¼�ÌÍÃ(ºKÇ�½{¾VÃqÇYÅ�ÌÍ»Y½÷¸�Ì{Å�¶�»YÃqƦ·�¶�¸¿Èq·¿Ãq¼k» ¼¿Ç�½{È=¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�Ã=Ç�Å�ÇY·¿¶�¸¿¹Á»YÃ�&§¸¿ÌÍÅ�¶³¼k»�¼�˳ÇY¼�¸�½�¾(»�¼»YÃ�ÇYº=¸�Ì{Å »Y½=¼¿Ç�½{È=¸�Ì{Ç�Ã*Î�Ï"¹=¶�µ�»Y½ÍÈq¶(&�Ìͼ?¸�¹q¶�ÞSÖfÖK×�Û ��Ø .�ÞYÒ0ØÚÛ:ß�×�ÞYÒ0ØÚÛ�ÇY·?ÖÁÕS×ÔÝsÛ:× .�ÞYß÷Ù!Õ�åYäqÞY×�ÞYßÁÒyÕ!Õ?ÇYÊ�¸�¹=¶»Y½{É�Ç�·¿Ì�¸�¹qÅ�Î

2 ¹qÌͽ{¶"ÐI¶�ÐIÇ�È=½ÍÆ ÇYÂuµVÌ{Ç�Èq¼¿½�¾Ü½ÍÌ{õY¶"¸�Ç�¼¿Ç�½�µ�¶)������� ��*�+������#��,������������Ç�º=¸�Ì{Å »�½Í½{¾�ÌÍÃ�ºKÇ�½{¾VÃqÇ�ôÅ�Ì�»Y½�¸¿ÌÍÅ�¶YÀ�»�ÃÁ»�¸¿Èq·�»Y½fÐ+¶s»Yõ�¶³·�É�Ç�»Y½uÌͼA¸¿Ç�Æq¶�¼¿Ì{É�Ã�»-&Áô`»�ºqºq·¿Çsò^ÌÍÅ�»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�»Y½{É�Ç�·¿Ì�¸�¹qÅ Ð}Ì{¸�¹'&�»Y¼�Ë�½ÍÇ�¼�¶+¸�Ç �»Y¼nºKÇ�¼¿¼�ÌÍÂq½{¶YÎ)´�Ê+Ë�Ç�Èq·�¼¿¶YÀ�¶Sµ�¶³Ãĸ�¹q¶�Ò|×QØ /CØ|ÞYâ�ÞYâîåVÛ:×QØÔÒÔÓ .�À÷Ð}¹qÌÍË!¹Ä»Y½�Ð�»s¾V¼r·¿¶S¸�Èq·�Ãq¼k¸�¹q¶�¶�Ãf¸�ÌÍ·�¶�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õ'ÜÀÁËs»YÃ�Â8¶nµVÌͶSÐI¶�Æ(»Y¼�»YÃ�»Yºqºq·�ÇCò^Ì{Å »�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�»�½ÍÉ�Ç�·�Ì{¸¿¹qÅ Ê�ÇY·.������� ��,�+������#��/��� �0������Î 5 ¶�Ës»YÈ=¼¿¶¸�¹=¶ 5 ·¿»Y¶³¼�¼I·�»:¸�ÌÍÇrÇYÊ*¶�µ�¶�·�¾�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õ�Ð}Ì�¸�¹�½ÍÌÍÃ=¶s»Y·?˳ÇY¼�¸IÊ�È=ÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãq¼�Ìͼ�»�¸+Å�Ç�¼�¸ pYü 0ê�·¿ÇYº8Ç�¼�Ì{¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�ü=Î ü��SÀÐ+¶�¹Á»sµY¶�¸¿¹q¶nÊ�Ç�½Í½{ÇdÐ}Ì{ÃqÉ)ÉYÈÁ»Y·�»�Ãu¸¿¶³¶�Ç�Ã�¸�¹q¶n¸¿·¿Ì{µVÌÍ»Y½*»Y½{É�Ç�·�Ì{¸�¹=Å�ÎF � JK<�J OnG��qG@J � � B X � �*ÓÁÕrÒ|×QØ /CØ|ÞYâGÞYâîåVÛ:×QØÔÒ�Ó . ØÍá)Þ213 .oÞSÖfÖK×�Û ��Ø .�ÞYÒ|ØÚÛ:ߧÞYâîåVÛ:×QØÔÒ�Ó . ÝsÛ:×.������� ��,�+��!4������5�"� ���������

l ¶�¶³Æq½{¶³¼¿¼?¸�Çn¼¿»s¾�ÀfÐI¶}¼�¹qÇ�Èq½{Æ�»�¼¿ºqÌ{·¿¶�¸�ÇnÆ=¶³¼¿Ì{É�ÃÜÂ8¶S¸¿¸¿¶³·³ÀuÅ�Ç�·¿¶I˳½Í¶Sµ�¶�·+»�ºqºq·¿Çsò^ÌÍÅ�»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�»�½ÍÉ�Ç�·�Ì{¸¿¹qÅ�¼�Îh�½Í»Y¼³À=ÃqÇ�Ãq¶r¶Sò^Ì{¼�¸sÀ�»�¼¿¼¿È=Å�Ì{ÃqÉ ���e�� �ÜÎ� �1?�J � ? ; � B X1A�EqTWV � Y[Z �AÛ:×�Õ /YÕS×Qà � � "�ÒÔÓÁÕS×�Õ�ØÍá�ß÷Û 1 3� � �/.oÞSÖfÖK×�Û ��Ø .�ÞYÒ0ØÚÛ:ß&ÞYâîåVÛ:×SØÔÒÔÓ . ÝsÛ:×���������6� ���������7����������� � äVßÁâÍÕ!á!á � e � � � �� ×�ÛCÛ`Ý�� 2 ¶ É�Ì{µY¶�»(ºKÇ�½{¾VÃqÇ�Å�Ì�»�½�ô�¸¿ÌÍÅ�¶ j�É�»Yº ·¿¶�ÆqÈqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃ�k�Ê�·¿ÇYÅ'¸¿¹q¶ l êô�˳Ç�Å�ºq½{¶�¸�¶�ºq·¿ÇYÂq½Í¶�Å987�"�:4�� ;���� <��"����=>�������@?��A��B��,CD8E���"?'F�ë ��ñ )É�Ì�µ�¶³Ã »�ÆqÌ{·¿¶³ËS¸�¶�Æ¥É�·¿»Yºq¹k' e �)$� * ��»�ÃqÆ ÆqÌ{¼�¸�Ì{ÃqË�¸µ�¶�·�¸¿ÌÍ˳¶�¼ ^ � � ^� � ` � � ` 3G )ÜÀq»Y·�¶�¸�¹q¶�·¿¶ ^14�ô `64*ºq»�¸�¹q¼ � 4*Ê�Ç�· ?Se �)� �VÀ^¼�ÈqË!¹�¸�¹Á»�¸ � � »YÃ=Æ � }»Y·�¶�µ�¶�·�¸¿¶SòuôÆqÌ{¼�û�Ç�Ì{Ãu¸ m 2 ¶�Ës»�Ã�ºq·�ÇdµY¶�¸¿¹q¶r¸�¹q¶�Ç�·¿¶�Å Âu¾�¼�¹qÇCÐ}ÌÍÃqÉ�¹qÇCÐ »f 1 3 �I�yôy»Yºqºq·�ÇCò^Ì{Å »�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�»�½ÍÉ�Ç�·�Ì{¸¿¹qÅ Ê�ÇY·���������G� ���������/�"� �������Ä˳»YÃ�ÂK¶�È=¼¿¶³Æ�¸�Ç�ÆqÌ o8¶³·�¶³Ãf¸�ÌÍ»�¸�¶rÂK¶�¸yÐ+¶³¶³Ã j`¾�¶³¼�k�»YÃ=Æ j�ÃqÇk�Ì{Ãq¼�¸�»YÃq˳¶�¼ÇYÊH8E�"��? Ì{Ã�º8Ç�½�¾VÃqÇ�Å�Ì�»Y½�¸�Ì{Å�¶�Î

\ Ç�Ãq¼�ÌÍÆq¶�·�»�Ã�ÌÍÃq¼o¸!»YÃqË�¶ �ìÇYÊI8E�"��?�Àq»�¼}»YÂ8ÇCµY¶YÎ�h�ÈqÉ�Å�¶³Ãf¸�¸¿¹q¶nµ�¶�·�¸�¶Qò�¼¿¶S¸ ) Âu¾�»YÃ�»YÆqÆqÌ�¸�ÌÍÇYÃÁ»Y½¼¿ÇYÈq·¿Ë�¶ ^(»YÃqÆ ¼¿Ì{Ãqõ�`QÀ"»YÃqÆ ÌÍÃqË�½ÍÈqÆ=¶�¸¿¹q¶�Æ=ÌÍ·¿¶�Ë�¸¿¶³Æ ¶�ÆqÉ�¶�¼ 4^)� ^ � �QÀS4^)� ^� �QÀ_�` � � `��SÀ"»�ÃqÆ �` � `�� |¼¿¶�¶� Ì{É�Èq·¿¶Üð��SÎ �k¶�ÃqÇY¸¿¶Ü¸¿¹q¶�Ãq¶�Ð Ã=¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õ§Âf¾('KJ e y)'J � *'J��r»�ÃqÆ¥¶�ÃqÆqÇCÐ ¸�¹=¶�¶�ÆqÉ�¶³¼�ÇYÊ5*'JGÐ}Ì{¸�¹§¸�¹=¶Ê�Ç�½{½ÍÇCÐ}ÌÍÃqÉ�½ÍÌ{Ãq¶s»�·�˳ÇY¼�¸�Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼��qA¶�ÆqÉ�¶�¼�ÇYÊ * »Y·¿¶IÉ�Ì{µY¶³Ã�¸�¹=¶"˳Ç�¼o¸Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYà ��� ,��e �=À�¶³Æ=É�¶³¼ ^�� ^ I�»YÃqÆr@` � � `���»Y·¿¶"É�Ì�µ�¶�Ã�¸¿¹q¶}˳Ç�¼o¸�Ê�È=ÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã��5@ ,�+e �ÀV»YÃqÆܶ³Æ=É�¶³¼G4^)� ^ � �»YÃ=Æ �` � `��»Y·¿¶}É�Ì�µ�¶�Ãܸ¿¹q¶}˳Ç�¼o¸Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ã(��� ,��e ��Î�Ï"¹q¶rÌÍÃq¼o¸!»YÃ=˳¶ �')J �\�-� ���I˳»YÃ�Â8¶r˳ÇYÃq¼�¸¿·¿ÈqËS¸�¶³Æ�Ê�·¿Ç�Å �&ÌÍÃ�ºKÇ�½{¾VÃqÇYÅ�ÌÍ»Y½K¸¿ÌÍÅ�¶YÎ

2 ¶�Ës»Yå˳Ç�Å�ºq½Í¶S¸�¶�¸�¹=¶ ºq·�Ç^ÇYÊ�Âu¾Ä¶�¼�¸!»�Âq½ÍÌ{¼¿¹qÌ{ÃqÉ�¸yÐ+Ç(¼o¸!»�¸¿¶³Å�¶³Ãf¸�¼��Ì{Ê ��Ì{¼)» jo¾�¶�¼ k¦ÌÍÃ=¼�¸!»�Ãq˳¶�ÇYÊ8E�"��?�À³¸¿¹q¶³ÃQ'KJ�»YÆ=Å�Ì�¸�¼�»"¼¿ÈqÂ=Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õ�� ¼¿ÈqË!¹�¸�¹Á»:¸G» 2 »Y·¿Æ=·¿Ç�º�¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌÍÂ=·¿ÌÍÈ=ÅùÊ�ÇY·0� ���)� �&�÷¹Á»Y¼�˳Ç�¼o¸üRp�� 3Á»YÃqÆ�Ì{Ê �ìÌͼ"» j�ÃqÇk�ÌÍÃq¼o¸!»YÃqË�¶YÀq¸¿¹q¶³Ã�Ê�Ç�·�¶Sµ�¶³·o¾�¼¿ÈqÂ=Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õ � ÇYÊ ' J ÀÁ» 2 »Y·¿Æ=·¿Ç�º�¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌ{Âq·¿Ì{ÈqÅÊ�Ç�· � �\�)� ���I¹Á»�¼�Ë�Ç�¼�¸�»�¸}½{¶s»Y¼o¸ �^Î

�P�

Page 22: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

s s1

2t

s2

1t

t

G1

xx

1

� Ì{É�Èq·¿¶�ð nê�·¿ÇVÇYÊ�ÇYÊ�Ï"¹q¶³ÇY·¿¶³Å'ü^Î �P�YÎ�óyÃÑ»Uj�ÃqÇ k�Ì{Ãq¼�¸�»YÃq˳¶�Ç�Ê(8E���"?�ÀK¸�¹q¶Ü¶Qò=Ì{¼�¸¿¶³ÃqË�¶�Ç�Ê ^ � ô4` � »�ÃqÆ^� �ô ` �ºÁ»�¸¿¹q¼}ÌÍÅ�ºq½ÍÌ{¶³¼�¸�¹q¶r¶Sò^Ì{¼�¸�¶�Ãq˳¶�ÇYÊ»Yà ^ oô ` � ºÁ»�¸�¹÷Î

� ÌÍ·�¼�¸+¼¿Èqº=º8Ç�¼�¶�¸�¹=¶³·¿¶k»Y·¿¶}µ�¶�·�¸�¶QòuôyÆqÌ{¼�û�Ç�Ì{Ãu¸ ^ � ô ` � »YÃ=Æ ^� ¿ô ` �ºq»�¸�¹q¼ � � »�ÃqÆ � IÌÍÃ�'ÜÀV·¿¶³¼�º8¶�Ë�¸¿Ì{µ�¶�½{¾YδkÂ=¸!»�ÌÍà ��Âu¾§Æ=¶³½Í¶S¸�Ì{ÃqÉ�»Y½Í½¶�ÆqÉ�¶�¼�ÇYÊ�' ÃqÇY¸�Ë�Ç�Ãf¸!»YÌ{Ãq¶³ÆÄÌÍ缿ÇYÅ�¶ � 4ÚÎ�Ï"¹=¶³Ã*À � Ì{¼r»�¼�ÈqÂqÉ�·¿»Yºq¹ÄÇYÊ')J*Ð}Ì{¸¿¹(¶Sò=»YËS¸�½{¾�¸yÐ+Ç(^³ô4`}ºÁ»�¸¿¹q¼³À�»�ÃqƦ·¿Ç�È^¸�ÌÍÃ=É ¹Á»Y½�Ê�» ÈqÃqÌ�¸kÇYÊ��qÇdÐ »Y½{Ç�ÃqÉ�¶s»YË!¹¦¾VÌͶ�½ÍÆq¼�» 2 »�·¿Æq·�Ç�º¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌ{Âq·¿Ì{ÈqÅ Ð}Ì�¸�¹�˳ÇY¼�¸�üRp��n|ËSÊ`Î{À � ÌÍÉ�È=·¿¶ �7|»��J�QÎ

l ÇCÐ ¼¿ÈqºqºKÇ�¼�¶ � Ì{¼�» j�ÃqÇ k�ÌÍÃq¼o¸!»YÃqË�¶�»YÃqÆéË�Ç�Ãq¼�ÌÍÆq¶�·�»(¼¿ÈqÂ=É�·�»Yº=¹ � ÇYÊ3'KJ�Î 2 ¶�˳»YÃx»Y¼�¼¿ÈqÅ�¶¸�¹q»�¸ �'Ë�Ç�Ãf¸!»YÌ{Ãq¼�»YÃ_^³ô4`Iºq»�¸�¹*Î�ó�Ê � ¹Á»�¼�»�à ^�ô `IºÁ»�¸¿¹ � Ë�Ç�Ãf¸!»YÌ{ÃqÌÍÃ=ÉÜ»Yà ^� �ô4` � ºq»�¸�¹*ÀÁ¸¿¹q¶³Ã�·¿Ç�È^¸�ÌÍÃ=É»Y½{½*ÇYÊG¸�¹q¶u�ÁÇCÐ Ç�Ã�� ¾VÌͶ�½ÍÆq¼�» 2 »Y·¿Æq·�Ç�º�¶³öuÈqÌͽ{ÌÍÂq·�ÌÍÈqÅ Ð}Ì{¸¿¹�˳Ç�¼o¸_�n|ËSÊ`Î{À � ÌÍÉ�Èq·�¶ �7|Â��J�SÎ+´�¸�¹=¶³·�Ð}Ì{¼¿¶�À¼¿Ì{Ãq˳¶ � Ìͼ�»�j�ÃqÇk ÌÍÃ=¼�¸!»�Ãq˳¶�ÇYÊ�8E�"��?�Àq¸yÐ+Ç�¼¿Ç�½{¶�ºKÇ�¼¿¼�ÌÍÂqÌ{½ÍÌ�¸�ÌͶ�¼�·¿¶�Å »�ÌÍà |¼¿¶�¶ � Ì{É�Èq·¿¶�ð�� �¶³Ì�¸�¹q¶�·�Ê�ÇY·ºq·�¶³Ë³Ì{¼¿¶�½{¾�Ç�Ãq¶r?5G P��)� � TuÀ � ¹Á»Y¼�»Yà ^³ô4`�ºÁ»:¸�¹�� Ë�Ç�Ãf¸!»YÌ{ÃqÌÍÃ=É »Yà ^14{ô `64AºÁ»�¸¿¹*À�Ç�·�»Y½Í½1^�ô4`"ºÁ»�¸¿¹q¼ � Ì{Ã� Ë�Ç�Ãf¸!»YÌ{æ»YÃ]^ � ô4` kºÁ»�¸¿¹(ÇYÊ 'ÜÎ�óyÃ�¶³Ì{¸¿¹q¶³·�Ës»Y¼�¶YÀ*·�Ç�È=¸¿ÌÍÃqÉ�Ç�Ãq¶�È=ÃqÌ{¸�ÇYÊs�ÁÇCÐ »Y½{Ç�ÃqÉ ¼�ÈqË!¹§» ºÁ»:¸�¹ �ºq·�ÇdµVÌ{Æq¶³¼�» 2 »Y·�Æq·¿ÇYº�¶�öuÈqÌͽ{ÌÍÂq·�ÌÍÈqÅ Ð}Ì{¸¿¹�Ë�Ç�¼�¸G�^Î

Ï"¹uÈq¼³ÀÁÃqÇܺKÇ�½{¾VÃqÇYÅ�ÌÍ»Y½�ôÚ¸�ÌÍÅ�¶"»Y½{É�Ç�·�Ì{¸�¹=Å Ê�Ç�· ��������� � � �!�"�#��7�"� �������(¹Á»Y¼}»YÃ�»�ºqºq·¿Çsò^ÌÍÅ�»:ô¸�Ì{Ç�ÃÜ·�»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�¼¿ÈqºK¶³·�ÌÍÇ�·�¸¿Ç�¸¿¹Á»�¸�ÇYÊ÷¸¿¹q¶}¸�·¿Ì�µVÌ�»Y½Á»�½ÍÉ�Ç�·�Ì{¸¿¹qÅ�Î b�öuÈqÌ{µ�»Y½{¶³Ãf¸�½�¾�ÀuÌ{¸?Ì{¼ l ê�ôy¹Á»�·¿Æ�¸¿Ç�Æ=Ìͼ�¸¿ÌÍÃqÉYÈqÌͼ�¹ÂK¶�¸yÐ+¶³¶³Ã=j�ºÁ»�·�»YÆqÇsòuô�Ê�·�¶³¶�knÌÍÃq¼o¸!»YÃqË�¶³¼ ÔÐ}Ì{¸¿¹ 5 ·�»Y¶�¼¿¼�·¿»�¸�Ì{Ç �.�G»YÃqÆ�ÌÍÃ=¼�¸!»�Ãq˳¶�¼�¼¿È o8¶³·�ÌÍÃqÉkÊ�·�Ç�Å ¸�¹q¶"Å�Ç�¼�¸¼¿¶Sµ�¶�·¿¶)Å�»YÃqÌ�Ê�¶³¼o¸!»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãq¼+ÇYÊ�¸¿¹q¶rºÁ»Y·¿»YÆqÇsò�Ð}Ì�¸�¹ 5 ·¿»Y¶³¼�¼�·¿»�¸�Ì{Ç pYü��QÎ

2 ¹qÌͽ{¶�Ð+¶n¹Á»sµ�¶rÇ�Ãq½�¾ ¶�¼�¸!»�Âq½ÍÌ{¼¿¹q¶�Æ�¸¿¹q¶kÇ�º^¸�ÌÍÅ�»Y½{Ì{¸y¾ÜÇYÊ�¸�¹=¶k¸�·¿Ì�µVÌ�»Y½8»Y½ÍÉYÇ�·¿Ì�¸�¹qÅ Ê�Ç�·IÃq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õu¼"Ð}Ì{¸¿¹½ÍÌ{Ãq¶s»�·AË�Ç�¼�¸Ê�È=ÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãq¼�À�¼¿Ì{Å�Ì{½�»Y·�·�¶³¼�Èq½{¸¿¼¹qÇ�½{Æ)Ð}Ì{¸¿¹�ÇY¸�¹=¶³·¼�¶�¸�¼�Ç�ÊK»Y½Í½{ÇdÐI»YÂq½{¶?¶³ÆqÉ�¶"Ë�Ç�¼�¸�Ê�ÈqÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã=¼³Î � Ç�·¶Sò=»YÅ�ºq½{¶YÀd½Í¶S¸�������� ��� � ��������� ��� �0������ÂK¶?¸¿¹q¶�»YÃÁ»Y½{Ç�É�Ç�È=¼*Ç�º=¸¿ÌÍÅ�ÌÍús»:¸�ÌÍÇYÃ�ºq·�Ç�Âq½Í¶�Å Ê�Ç�·�¼�ÌÍÃqÉY½Í¶Sô˳ÇYÅ�Å�Ç^Æ=Ì{¸y¾ Ã=¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õu¼�Ð}Ì{¸¿¹ »�·¿ÂqÌ�¸�·�»�·�¾éË�Ç�¼�¸�Ê�ÈqÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã=¼³Î&Ï"¹q¶�Ç�·¿¶�Å ü=Î ý¦ÌÍÅ�ºq½ÍÌ{¶³¼�¸�¹q»�¸�¸¿¹q¶�¸¿·¿Ì�µ^ÌÍ»Y½»Y½{É�Ç�·¿Ì�¸�¹qÅ�Ìͼ�»�� � p����sô`»�ºqºq·¿Çsò^ÌÍÅ�»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�»�½ÍÉ�Ç�·�Ì{¸¿¹qÅ�Ê�ÇY·���� ��� ���"� ��������� �"� �������À�Ð}¹q¶³·�¶ � Ì{¼¸�¹=¶�ÃuÈqÅ�ÂK¶³·kÇYÊ?Ã=¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õ�µ�¶³·o¸�Ì{˳¶³¼�Î�´nÃ(¸¿¹q¶�ÇY¸¿¹q¶³·�¹Á»YÃqÆ*ÀK¸�¹q¶�Ê�Ç�½Í½{ÇdÐ}Ì{ÃqÉ�ÌÍÃÁ»Yº=ºq·¿Çsò^ÌÍÅ�»YÂqÌ{½ÍÌ{¸y¾ ·¿¶�¼¿Èq½�¸¹qÇ�½{Æq¼³Î� �1?�J � ? ; � B X X EqTWV � Y[Z � á!áSä .�ØÔßVå � �e � � "�ÝsÛ:× Õ /YÕS×Qà � � ÒÔÓÁÕS×�ÕéØÍáxß÷Û �� � p����� � �/.ÞSÖfÖK×�Û ��Ø .�ÞYÒ0ØÚÛ:ß(ÞYâîåVÛ:×QØÔÒ�Ó .EÝsÛ:×���� ��� ���2� � �!�"�#��5�"� ���������Ï"¹q¶�ºq·�Ç^Ç�Ê?ÇYÊ?Ï"¹q¶³ÇY·¿¶³Å ü=Î4����Ìͼ�¼¿Ç�Å�¶�Ð}¹q»�¸nÌÍÃfµYÇ�½{µY¶³Æ§»YÃqƦÅ�»Yõ�¶³¼kÈq¼�¶�ÇYÊ�¸�¹=¶ 5 ·�»�¶³¼¿¼nÉY·�»Yºq¹=¼�¸�¹Á»:¸Ð+¶³·¿¶�ÌÍÃf¸¿·¿ÇVÆqÈq˳¶�Æ�Ì{Ã�¸�¹q¶}ºq·�Ç^ÇYÊ8ÇYÊ8Ï"¹q¶³ÇY·¿¶³Å ü^Î Î � ÇY·�¸�¹q¶�ºq·�Ç^ÇYÊ`À�»YÃqÆ�¼¿ÌÍÅ�ÌͽͻY·�·�¶³¼�Èq½{¸¿¼?Ê�ÇY·�ÇY¸�¹q¶�·?¼¿¶�¸¿¼ÇYÊ�»�½Í½ÍÇCÐI»YÂq½{¶"˳Ç�¼o¸IÊ�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼³ÀV¼¿¶�¶�ëîý���ñ0Î � Ç�·+»YÃÁ»Y½{Ç�É�Ç�Èq¼?Ì{Ãu¸¿·�»YËS¸!»YÂ=ÌͽÍÌ�¸y¾�·�¶³¼¿È=½{¸�¼?Ê�Ç�·�Å�Èq½�¸�ÌÍË�Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ{¸y¾Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õu¼³À8Ð}¹=ÌÍË!¹�Â=ÈqÌͽ{Æ�ÇYÃ�¸¿¹q¶�¸yÐ+Ç�ô�˳Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ�¸y¾�Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õu¼k»Y½{½ÍÈqÆq¶�Æ�¸¿Ç�Ì{Ã�Ï"¹q¶³Ç�·�¶³Å ü=Î �Cï=ÀÁ¼�¶³¶,x�Ì{ö�¸�»Y½0Î�ë¢ð��:ñ0Î

���

Page 23: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

� � ®��¦²s«�� � ²�¬�� �K���� �s�¦«������� �#®�� �ç® �H�k¯¦°¦±3� ¬���� ­?²s±�® �� «��)­?±����

2 ¶�¹Á»sµ�¶�¼¿¶³¶�Ã&¸�¹Á»�¸�¸�¹=¶(ºq·¿Ì{˳¶�ÇYÊ�»YÃÁ»�·¿Ë!¹f¾ Ç�Ên¼¿¶�½{æÁ¼�¹&·¿Ç�È=¸¿ÌÍÃqÉÄËs»�ÃìÂ8¶�½�»Y·�É�¶�ÌÍà Ã=¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õu¼�Ð}Ì{¸¿¹¹qÌ{É�¹q½{¾�ÃqÇ�Ã=½ÍÌÍÃ=¶s»Y·�˳Ç�¼o¸nÊ�ÈqÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã=¼³À�ÌÍÃ=˳½ÍÈ=ÆqÌÍÃqÉ�Ð}Ì{¸�¹(Ê�È=ÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãq¼k¸¿¹Á»�¸�»Y·�¶�˳Ç�Å�Å�Ç�Ã(ÌÍç»�ºqºq½ÍÌ{Ës»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã=¼³À¼¿È=Ë!¹E»Y¼ �������P�¦Æ=¶³½�»s¾çÊ�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃq¼³Î Ï"¹qÌ{¼ æÁÃÁ»Y½�¸�¶³Ë!¹=ÃqÌÍ˳»Y½�¼�¶³Ë�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãù»�¼¿õu¼i Ç�¸�¹q¶�· ¸�¹Á»�Ã&¼¿Ç�Å�¶³¹qÇCж³Ã^Ê�Ç�·¿Ë�ÌÍÃqÉ�Ç�º=¸�Ì{Å »�½V·�Ç�È=¸¿ÌÍÃqÉqÀdÐ}¹Á»�¸�Ës»YÃ�Ð+¶�ÆqÇk»YÂ8ÇYÈ=¸�Ì�¸ m \ »YÃ�Å�Ç^Æ=¶³¼�¸�ÌÍÃf¸�¶�·�µY¶³Ãf¸�Ì{Ç�Ã*ÀYÐ}¹q¶�Ã�Ê�¶s»Y¼�ÌÍÂq½{¶YÀ¼¿Ì{É�ÃqÌ�æÁËs»YÃf¸¿½{¾�·¿¶³Æ=Èq˳¶r¸�¹q¶rºq·�ÌÍË�¶nÇYÊ»�ÃÁ»Y·¿Ë!¹f¾ m 2 ¶rÂq·�ÌͶ#�q¾�ÆqÌ{¼¿Ë�Èq¼¿¼}¸�¹q·�¶³¶n¸�¶�Ë!¹qÃqÌ{öVÈ=¶³¼}Ê�Ç�·"Å�Ì�¸�Ì{Éf»�¸�Ì{Ãqɸ�¹=¶�Ì{Ãq¶�ÿ�˳Ì{¶³ÃqËS¾§ÇYÊ�¼�¶³½�æÁ¼¿¹Ñ·¿Ç�È=¸¿ÌÍÃqÉ �Ì{Ãq˳·�¶s»Y¼�ÌÍÃqÉ�¸�¹=¶�˳»YºÁ»YË�Ì{¸y¾§ÇYÊ+¸�¹q¶�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õ 0þ^ÈqÂq¼�¶³ËS¸�ÌÍÇYà Π�.�SÀ·¿ÇYÈ=¸�Ì{ÃqÉ�»�¼¿Å�»Y½{½Á»YÅ�Ç�ÈqÃf¸�ÇYÊ÷¸¿·�»�ÿ�Ë�˳¶³Ãf¸¿·�»Y½{½{¾ 0þ^ÈqÂq¼�¶³Ë�¸¿ÌÍÇ�à Î4���SÀV»YÃqÆ�ÌÍÃ��ÁÈq¶³Ã=˳ÌÍÃ=É�¸¿·�»�ÿ�Ë}Ð}Ì{¸�¹�¶³Æ=É�¶¸!»dò=¶�¼=0þ^ÈqÂq¼�¶³ËS¸�ÌÍÇYà Πü��QÎ

)��� ���+,$� �1� ��� �$# *f/ ! � � ���"� !� Ç�·I¸¿¹q¶r·¿¶³¼o¸�ÇYÊA¸¿¹qÌͼ"¼�Èq·�µY¶�¾�Ð+¶�¼o¸�ÈqÆ^¾�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õV¼}Ð}Ì{¸¿¹�»Y·¿ÂqÌ�¸�·¿»Y·�¾ Ë³Ç�¼o¸"Ê�ÈqÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã=¼³ÀqÐ}¹q¶�·¿¶n¸�¹q¶rºq·�ÌÍË�¶ÇYÊ�»YÃq»Y·¿Ë!¹f¾�Ìͼ�È=ÃVÂKÇ�ÈqÃ=Æq¶³Æ*Î 2 ¶)Ãq¶QòV¸r¼¿¹qÇCÐ ¸�¹Á»:¸n» ÂKÇ�ÈqÃqƦÇYÃ�¸�¹q¶)ÌÍÃq¶Sÿ�Ë�ÌͶ�ÃqË�¾�ÇYÊ?¼¿¶�½{æÁ¼�¹¦·¿Ç�È^¸�ÌÍÃ=ÉÌÍÃ�¼¿ÈqË!¹�Ã=¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õu¼�Ì{¼+ÃqÇYÃq¶�¸¿¹q¶³½{¶³¼¿¼Iº8Ç�¼�¼¿Ì{Âq½Í¶�ÀVµVÌ�»�»�¼�Ç�ôy˳»Y½Í½{¶³Æ�ÂqÌÍË�·¿Ì{¸¿¶³·�Ì�»r»Yºqºq·�Çf»YË!¹*Î�þVº8¶�˳Ì{æqËs»Y½{½{¾�ÀuÇ�È=·Ãq¶Qò^¸�·¿¶�¼¿Èq½�¸ÜÌͼ�¸¿¹Á»�¸Ü¸�¹q¶�Ë�Ç�¼�¸�ÇYÊ�» 2 »Y·�Æq·¿Ç�ºx¶�öVÈ=ÌͽÍÌ{Âq·¿Ì{ÈqÅ Ìͼܻ�¸ÜÅ�Ç�¼�¸�¸¿¹Á»�¸�ÇYÊ�»YÃçÇ�º=¸�Ì{Å »�½ �ÁÇCи�¹q»�¸}ÌͼIÊ�ÇY·¿Ë³¶�Æ�¸�Ç�·¿ÇYÈ=¸�¶k¸yÐ}Ì{˳¶r»Y¼"Å�È=Ë!¹�¸¿·�»�ÿ�ËnÂK¶�¸yÐ+¶³¶³Ã�¶s»�Ë!¹�¼�Ç�Èq·¿Ë�¶Sô�¼¿ÌÍÃ=õ�ºÁ»YÌ{·³Î 2 ¶kÐ}Ìͽ{½8¼�¶³¶n¸�¹Á»:¸¸�¹=Ìͼܷ¿¶�¼¿Èq½�¸ ¹Á»�¼�¸¿¹q¶�Ê�ÇY½Í½ÍÇCÐ}Ì{Ãqɧ»Y½{¸¿¶³·�ÃÁ»�¸�Ì�µ�¶�ÌÍÃf¸¿¶³·¿º=·¿¶�¸�»�¸�Ì{Ç�à �ÌÍÃç½ÍÌ{¶³ÈçÇYÊkË�¶³Ãf¸�·¿»Y½ÍÌ{ú³¶³Æ ˳Ç�Ãf¸¿·¿Ç�½0À+¸�¹=¶ÌÍÃ=¶�ÿ�˳Ì{¶³ÃqËS¾�ÇYÊA¼¿¶³½�æÁ¼¿¹�·¿Ç�È^¸�ÌÍÃ=É�Ës»YÃ�Â8¶rÇo8¼¿¶S¸�Âu¾�»ÜÅ�ÇVÆq¶³·¿»�¸�¶nÌ{Ãq˳·�¶s»Y¼�¶�Ì{Ã�½ÍÌÍÃ=õ ¼¿ºK¶³¶�Æ*Î687:9�;=< >@? �1BDA \ Ç�Ã=¼¿ÌÍÆ=¶³·�¸�¹q¶"Ã=Ç�Ãq½ÍÌ{Ãq¶s»�·�µ�»Y·¿ÌÍ»YÃf¸�ÇYÊ8ê�ÌÍÉ�Ç�ÈL� ¼�¶Qòq»�Å�ºq½{¶S � ÌÍÉ�Èq·�¶^���Âu�J� »�¸yÐ+Ç�ôyÃqÇVÆq¶�À¸yÐ+Ç�ôy½{ÌÍÃqõ�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õ)Ð}Ì{¸¿¹�˳Ç�¼o¸�Ê�ÈqÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã=¼+��� ,��e �}»YÃqÆ��5@ ,�+e � Ê�Ç�· ��½�»�·¿É�¶�Î 0}¶³Ë³»Y½Í½V¸�¹Á»�¸�Ð}Ì{¸�¹ÜÇ�Ã=¶ÈqÃqÌ�¸}ÇYÊ�¸�·¿»�ÿ�ËYÀq¸�¹=¶ 2 »Y·�Æq·¿Ç�º�¶�öVÈ=ÌͽÍÌ{Âq·¿Ì{ÈqÅ ·¿Ç�È^¸�¶³¼�»Y½{½ �ÁÇCÐEÇ�Ã�¸�¹q¶n½{ÇdÐ+¶³·}¶�ÆqÉ�¶YÀqÐ}¹=ÌͽͶ�¸�¹q¶rÇ�º=¸¿ÌÍÅ�»Y½�ÁÇCÐ ·¿Ç�È=¸¿¶³¼&�kÈqÃ=Ì{¸�¼�ÇYÊj�ÁÇCÐ Ç�Ã(¸¿¹q¶�Èqº=º8¶�·n¶³ÆqÉ�¶Ü»�ÃqÆ(¸�¹q¶�·�¶³¼o¸rÇ�Ã(¸�¹q¶)½ÍÇCÐI¶�·k¶³Æ=É�¶ �Ð}¹q¶�·¿¶ � % �»Y¼ � % � �QÎ 2 ¹q¶�Ã縿¹q¶�¸�·¿»�ÿ�Ë�·�»�¸¿¶�b(¶Qò=Ë�¶³¶�Æq¼�ÇYÃq¶YÀ�»YÃxÇ�º=¸¿ÌÍÅ�»Y½j�ÁÇCÐ »Y¼�¼¿Ì{É�Ãq¼�¸�¹=¶�»YÆqÆqÌ�¸�ÌÍÇYÃÁ»Y½b ��ÈqÃ=Ì{¸�¼nÇ�Ê�¸¿·�»�ÿ�Ë�¸¿Ç�¸�¹q¶�Èqº=º8¶�·n½ÍÌÍÃ=õKÀ÷ÌÍÃqË�Èq·¿·�ÌÍÃqÉ�»�Ë�Ç�¼�¸n¸¿¹Á»�¸k¸¿¶³ÃqÆq¼n¸¿ÇKb� ��»Y¼ � % �EÎ�óyúÁ»Y·o¸�Ì{˳Èq½Í»Y·³À=Ê�ÇY·�¶Sµ�¶�·�¾��(»�Ã�Ç�º^¸�ÌÍÅ�»Y½[�qÇdÐEÊ�¶s»Y¼�ÌÍÂq½{¶kÊ�Ç�·"¸yÐ}ÌÍ˳¶r¸�¹=¶�ÇY·¿ÌÍÉYÌÍÃÁ»Y½K¸�·¿»�ÿ�Ë�·¿»�¸�¶ gb e ����¹Á»�¼Ë³ÇY¼�¸�»�¸}½Í¶³»Y¼�¸S�YÀqÐ}¹qÌÍË!¹�¶³öuÈÁ»Y½{¼"¸�¹q¶r˳ÇY¼�¸�ÇYÊG¸�¹q¶ 2 »Y·¿Æq·�Ç�º�¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌÍÂ=·¿ÌÍÈ=Å Ì{Ã�¸¿¹q¶rÇ�·¿Ì{É�ÌÍÃq»Y½8Ì{Ãq¼�¸�»YÃqË�¶YÎ2 ¶�Ã=ÇdÐE¼¿¹qÇCÐ ¸¿¹Á»�¸"¸¿¹q¶rÂ8Ç�È=ÃqÆ�¼o¸!»�¸¿¶³Æ�ÌÍÃ(b�ò=»YÅ�º=½Í¶ Î �r¹qÇ�½ÍÆ=¼}Ê�ÇY·�ÞYâÔâ^Ì{Ãq¼�¸�»YÃq˳¶�¼³Î� �1?�J � ? ; �1B X EqT���� Y�Z !�Ý E�ØÍáIÞ � ÞY× 0Y×�Û!Ö�Õ��³äVØÔâ\Øgf³×SØÔä .¥ÝsÛ:× �'��+b�� �&�+ÞYßm0hE � ØÍáÁÝsÕ¿Þ:áSØgf³âÍÕÁÝsÛ:× �'�� �Rb�� �&�#"ÒÔÓÁÕSß

� yEt� � � yE��I�#-� ×�ÛCÛ`Ý���x�¶S¸DE�»YÃ=ÆeE � Æq¶³Ã=ÇY¸�¶¥» 2 »Y·¿Æ=·¿Ç�º ¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌÍÂ=·¿ÌÍÈ=Å Ê�Ç�·g' �+b�� �&��»YÃqÆE»xÊ�¶³»Y¼¿Ì{Âq½Í¶��ÁÇCÐ Ê�ÇY·�'�� �Rb�� �&�SÀ:·¿¶�¼¿ºK¶³ËS¸�Ì{µY¶³½�¾�Î � Ç�·G¶s»YË!¹)˳Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ�¸y¾u?¿À�½Í¶�¸ . 43g' �+b�� �&��Æq¶³ÃqÇ�¸�¶+¸¿¹q¶IË�Ç�Å�Å�Ç�Ã�˳ÇY¼�¸Ì{Ãq˳È=·¿·¿¶�ÆÂf¾é¸�¹q¶�¸¿·�»�ÿ�Ë�ÇYÊ�Ë�Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ{¸y¾ ?rÌÍÃx¸�¹q¶K�ÁÇCÐ E �¼¿¶³¶f�k¶�æqÃqÌ{¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãçü=Î �Cð��QÎ �k¶SæÁÃqÌ�¸�ÌÍÇYà �^Î ��»YÃ=Æ ¸�¹=¶Æq¶SæÁÃqÌ{¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�ÇYÊA˳ÇY¼�¸ 0ü��IÌ{Å�º=½{¾�¸�¹Á»�¸ � yEL��e Y 4 b14 . 4{�'��+b�� ���QÎ

Ï"¹q¶�õY¶S¾xÌÍÆq¶³»(Ìͼ)¸¿ÇÄÆ=¶�æÁÃq¶�»(¼�¶�¸�ÇYÊ�˳Ç�¼o¸ÜÊ�ÈqÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã=¼����¸�¹q»�¸Ü¼�»�¸¿ÌͼoæÁ¶³¼�¸yÐ+ÇѺ=·¿Ç�ºK¶³·o¸�ÌͶ�¼i�½{ÇCÐI¶�·ÂKÇ�ÈqÃqÆqÌ{ÃqÉ�¸¿¹q¶�˳ÇY¼�¸ÜÇYÊ E � ·�¶³½Í»�¸�Ì�µ�¶�¸¿Ç(¸�¹Á»:¸�ÇYÊ E Ìͼ�¶s»Y¼o¾¥Ð}Ì�¸�¹é·¿¶�¼¿ºK¶³ËS¸�¸�Ç���q3I»�ÃqÆ ¸�¹q¶�Ã=¶�Р˳Ç�¼o¸Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼���n»Yºqºq·�Çsò=Ì{Å »:¸�¶k¸�¹=¶�ÇY·¿ÌÍÉYÌÍÃÁ»Y½KÇ�Ãq¶�¼8�dÀÁÌÍÃ�¸¿¹q¶r¼¿¶³Ã=¼¿¶�¸¿¹Á»�¸}¸�¹=¶�Ë�Ç�¼�¸�ÇYÊ�E � Ð}Ì{¸�¹�·�¶³¼¿ºK¶³ËS¸�¸¿Ç

�Yü

Page 24: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

fe

flow

fe ��������co

st

c ( ) e

� ��� Fc�;� � � ')([!���� 13'&?]!H(9-.%�13!"24')% � � � %�:2 !;?m>I� M4-.� �I!m!�������'Is >I� M4-.��� �fe

flow

fe ������

cost

ec ( )

� `��mFc�;� � � ')(P!��.��13'�?B!t(9-.%�13!"24')%�� �� Ì{É�Èq·¿¶�ý \ Ç�Ãq¼o¸�·¿È=Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�ÃÄÌÍÃ(¸�¹=¶�º=·¿ÇVÇYÊIÇ�ÊIÏ"¹q¶�Ç�·¿¶�Å Î4��ÇYÊ+¸¿¹q¶ÜÅ�ÇVÆqÌ�æÁ¶³Æ¦Ë�Ç�¼�¸rÊ�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�à ��#SkÉYÌ{µ�¶�ø�¹=¶�ÇY·¿ÌÍÉYÌÍÃÁ»Y½V˳ÇY¼�¸?Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYà �US?»YÃqÆ�¸¿¹q¶ 2 »Y·�Æq·¿ÇYº�¶�öVÈ=ÌͽÍÌ{Âq·¿Ì{ÈqÅ µ�»Y½ÍÈq¶3EJS�Î�þ^Ç�½ÍÌ{Æ�½ÍÌ{Ãq¶³¼Æ=¶³ÃqÇY¸¿¶�ÉY·�»Yºq¹=¼ÇYÊGÊ�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃq¼³Î

���Ì{¼k˳½{Ç�¼¿¶�¸�Ç�Ì{¸¿¼kÇ�·�ÌÍÉ�Ì{ÃÁ»Y½�˳Ç�¼o¸sÎ)þ^ºK¶³Ë³Ì�æÁËs»�½Í½{¾YÀ8Ð+¶ÜÆq¶�æÁÃ=¶�¸�¹q¶�Ë�Ç�¼�¸nÊ�ÈqÃ=Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�Ã���US�Ê�Ç�·�¶s»YË!¹§¶³Æ=É�¶�a�»�¼Ê�Ç�½{½ÍÇCÐ}¼i

��US\� ,�+e � �#S�yEJS � Ì{Ê1 � EJS�#S�@ ,� Ì{Ê1 � E%S#-

� Ì{É�Èq·¿¶�ý¦Ìͽ{½ÍÈq¼o¸�·¿»�¸�¶�¼)¸�¹qÌ{¼Ü˳Ç�Ãq¼o¸�·�ÈqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã*Î x�¶�¸ �� "d��)Æ=¶³ÃqÇY¸¿¶�¸¿¹q¶�˳Ç�¼o¸�Ç�Ên»��ÁÇCÐ ÌÍÃ鸿¹q¶�Ì{Ãq¼�¸�»YÃqË�¶�'��+b�� ��&�SÎ l ÇY¸�¶n¸�¹q»�¸ ��p�E � � � � yE � �+Ð}¹=ÌͽͶ �� yEL��e �p�Et�SÎ

2 ¶�æÁ·�¼�¸�È=ºqº8¶�·�ÂKÇ�ÈqÃ=Æ ¸�¹=¶�»YÅ�Ç�ÈqÃf¸�Âf¾xÐ}¹qÌÍË!¹ç¸�¹q¶�Ãq¶�Ð Ë�Ç�¼�¸ �� yE � ��ÇYÊuE � ˳»Yà ¶Qò=Ë�¶³¶�ÆìÌ{¸¿¼Ç�·�ÌÍÉ�Ì{ÃÁ»Y½Á˳ÇY¼�¸ � yE � �QÎ � Ç�·I¶Sµ�¶�·�¾�¶�ÆqÉ�¶ua�À ��#S�@ ,��]�#S�@ ,��ÌͼIú�¶³·�Ç�Ê�Ç�· �� EJSI»�ÃqÆ�Â8ÇYÈqÃqÆq¶�Æ�»�Â8ÇCµ�¶�Âu¾�US\�E%SJ�+Ê�Ç�· � EJS�ÀÁ¼�Ç e ��US�@ ,� U�US\� ,�J� � �#S�yEJS � E%S �� �Ê�Ç�·�»Y½Í½ � �=Î�Ï"¹q¶�½Í¶SÊÔ¸�ôy¹q»YÃqÆ¥¼�ÌÍÆq¶�ÇYÊp�� � �ì¸�¹q¶�ÆqÌͼ�˳·�¶³ºÁ»YÃ=Ë�¾ÄÂ8¶S¸yÐI¶�¶³Ã ��US\� ,��»YÃqÆ �#S\@ ,� �ùÌͼÅ�»:ò^ÌÍÅ�ÌÍú³¶�Æ Ð}¹q¶�à �Ìͼ"¼¿½{ÌÍÉ�¹f¸¿½{¾�¼¿Å�»Y½Í½{¶³·+¸¿¹Á»YÃiE%S}»�ÃqÆ�Ð}¹q¶³Ã �#S�@ ,�+e �^Î�óyÃ�¸¿¹qÌͼ"˳»Y¼¿¶�Àq¸�¹q¶nµ�»Y½ÍÈ=¶kÇYʸ�¹=¶�½{¶�ÊÔ¸oôy¹Á»YÃ=Æ�¼�ÌÍÆq¶rÇYÊ 3� �IÌ{¼�¶�¼¿¼�¶³Ãf¸�ÌÍ»Y½Í½�¾ ¸�¹=¶)»Y·�¶s»�ÇYÊA¸�¹q¶r·¿¶�Ë�¸�»YÃqÉ�½{¶�¶�Ãq˳½{Ç�¼¿¶�Æ�Âf¾�ÆÁ»�¼¿¹q¶�Æ(½ÍÌ{Ãq¶³¼"Ì{Ã� Ì{É�Èq·¿¶ký70»��SÀ=Ð}¹qÌ{Ë!¹�ÌÍ฿Èq·¿Ã�Ìͼ+¸�¹q¶nË�Ç�¼�¸}Ì{Ãq˳Èq·�·¿¶�Æ�Âu¾ ¸�¹q¶ 2 »Y·¿Æ=·¿Ç�º�¶�öVÈ=ÌͽÍÌ{Âq·¿Ì{ÈqÅFE�Ç�Ã�¸�¹=¶n¶³ÆqÉ�¶za�ÎÏ"¹uÈq¼

�� �E�� � � yE��I�+e &SWV1XE��S ��US\�E��S � U�US\�E��S ��� � &

SWV1X�US�yE%SJ�OEJS+e � yEt�U- ��d�

óyÃÄÇY¸�¹q¶�·nÐIÇ�·�Æq¼³À�¶SµY»�½ÍÈÁ»�¸¿ÌÍÃqÉ7E � Ð}Ì�¸�¹§Ë³Ç�¼o¸rÊ�ÈqÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã=¼ ��dÀ�·�»:¸�¹q¶�·r¸¿¹Á»YÃ��:À�Ì{Ãq˳·�¶s»Y¼�¶³¼�Ì{¸¿¼n˳Ç�¼o¸�Âf¾§»:¸Å�Ç�¼�¸�»YÃ�»YÆ=ÆqÌ{¸¿Ì{µ�¶ � yEL�+Ê|»YË�¸¿Ç�·³Î

l ÇCÐ Ð+¶�½{ÇCÐI¶�·�ÂKÇ�ÈqÃ=Æ �� yE � �SÎ 5 ¾éË�Ç�Ãq¼�¸¿·¿ÈqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ã*À+¸¿¹q¶�Å�ÇVÆqÌ{æq¶³Æé˳ÇY¼�¸ ��#S�"d ��ÇYÊk»�à ¶�ÆqÉ�¶7a�Ì{¼»Y½�Ð�»s¾V¼n»�¸�½Í¶³»Y¼�¸$�#S�yEJSJ�QÀ÷¼�Ç ¸�¹q¶�Å�ÇVÆqÌ�æÁ¶³Æ�˳Ç�¼o¸���#IH"d ��ÇYÊ?»�ºÁ»�¸�¹�� G 2�4�Ìͼ�»Y½{ÐI»s¾V¼n»�¸�½Í¶s»�¼�¸.�UI �Et�SÀÐ}¹qÌ{Ë!¹�Ì{Ã�¸¿Èq·¿Ã�Ìͼ}»:¸}½Í¶s»�¼�¸ . 43g' �+b�� �&�SÎ�Ï"¹=¶³·¿¶SÊ�Ç�·¿¶�À

��p�E��I��e &I[V]\

��#I��E��I� E��I �.&4;: �

&I[V1\!n

. 43�'��+b�� �&�OE��I e .&4;: �

�Rb14 .!4{�'��+b�� �&��e � � yEt�U- ��Cð��

Page 25: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

Ï"¹q¶r¸�¹q¶�Ç�·¿¶�Å ÃqÇCÐEÊ�ÇY½Í½ÍÇCÐ}¼�Ì{Å�Å�¶³Æ=Ì�»�¸¿¶³½{¾ÜÊ�·�Ç�Å Ì{Ãq¶³öuÈÁ»Y½{Ì{¸¿ÌͶ³¼_��dí���»�ÃqÆ 3�Cð��!Î �c? ;=9��J$ �1B � bò=»YÅ�ºq½{¶ Î �r¼�¹qÇCÐ}¼�¸¿¹Á»�¸}¸�¹q¶rÂKÇ�ÈqÃqÆ�Ì{Ã�Ï"¹=¶³Ç�·�¶³Å Î4��Ìͼ�¸�¹=¶�ÂK¶³¼o¸�ºKÇ�¼�¼¿ÌÍÂ=½Í¶YÎ

h�ÃqÇ�¸�¹q¶�·�ÌÍÃf¸�¶�·¿ºq·�¶�¸!»:¸�ÌÍÇYÃ�ÇYÊKÏ"¹q¶³Ç�·�¶³Å Î ��Ì{¼�¸�¹Á»:¸¸�¹q¶"ÂK¶³Ã=¶�æq¸?ÇYÊKË�¶³Ãf¸�·¿»Y½ÍÌ{ú³¶³ÆÜË�Ç�Ãf¸�·¿ÇY½qÌͼ¶�öuÈÁ»Y½Í¶�ÆÇ�·"¶Qò=Ë�¶³¶�Æq¶³Æ(Âf¾�¸¿¹q¶rÂ8¶�Ãq¶�æq¸�ÇYÊ�»Ü¼¿È=ÿ�˳Ì{¶³Ãf¸�ÌÍÅ�ºq·¿ÇCµY¶³Å�¶³Ãf¸�ÌÍÃ�½ÍÌ{Ãqõ�¸¿¶³Ë!¹qÃ=Ç�½ÍÇ�É�¾�Î, J � J >D>D9�� � �1B � E T �KX Y[Z � ÕSÒ_g' �Ob0� ���pfSÕ�ÞYßxØÔß=áSÒÚÞYß÷Ù!Õ ÞYßm0q0VÕ�ã?ß÷Õ�Ò�ÓÁÕ'. Û10YØ ã�ÕO0ÄÙ!ÛCáSÒ�ÝQä^ß÷ÙSÒ|ØÚÛ:ß ��#Sf³à ��US�@ ,� e �US�@ Mp�����p���ÝsÛ:×�Õ¿ÞVÙ!Ó¦ÕO0CåVÕ a�� � ÕSÒ �E�fSÕ�Þ � ÞY× 0Y×!Û!ÖxÕ��³äVØÔâ\Øgf³×QØÔä . ÝsÛ:× �'��+b�� ��&�rC�ØÔÒÔÓÄÙ!ÛCáSÒ�� �Et� "+ÞYßm0NE � Þ�ÝsÕ¿Þ:áSØgf³âÍÕsA�Û%C(ÝsÛ:× g' �+b�� �&�rC�ØÔÒÔÓ(Ù!ÛCáSÒ �p�E � � � �*ÓÁÕSß ��p �Et� � � yE � � �þ^Ì{Å�ºq½{¶�Ës»Y½{˳Èq½Í»�¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼�¼�¹qÇCÐ ¸�¹Á»�¸�Ï"¹q¶�Ç�·¿¶�Å Î �Ä»YÃqÆ \ ÇY·¿Ç�½{½�»Y·o¾ Î »Y·�¶�¶�öuÈqÌ{µ�»Y½{¶³Ãf¸n3}Ê�Ç�·ÜÆq¶�¸�»YÌͽ{¼³À¼¿¶�¶�ë����Cñ�Ç�·�ë �Yð�ñÚÎ

\ Ç�·¿ÇY½Í½�»�·�¾ Î ¸!»Yõ�¶³¼)ÇYà »�ºq»Y·�¸¿ÌÍ˳È=½�»Y·�½{¾(Ã=ÌÍ˳¶ÜÊ�Ç�·�Å ÌÍÃÄÌÍÃq¼o¸!»YÃqË�¶³¼�ÌÍçÐ}¹qÌÍË!¹é»�½Í½Ë�Ç�¼�¸�Ê�ÈqÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã=¼»Y·�¶ �������P��Æq¶³½Í»s¾�Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃq¼ b�ò=»YÅ�º=½Í¶ �^Î ���.�QÎ�óyÃ�¸�¹=Ìͼ"Ës»�¼¿¶YÀ�Ì�ÊA¸¿¹q¶r˳Ç�¼o¸�Ê�ÈqÃ=Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�Ã(�#S"Ç�Ê�¶�ÆqÉ�¶ra�Ì{¼�US\� ,�$e �� S U ,� � � À*¸¿¹q¶³Ã§¸�¹=¶�Å�ÇVÆqÌ{æÁ¶�Æ�Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�à ��#SkÌ{¼ ��#S�@ ,�)e � p��7�� S$U Mp����$e �qp7"� � S$ ,�SÎ\ Ç�·�Ç�½Í½Í»Y·�¾ Î ¸¿¹VÈ=¼�Ço8¶³·�¼}¸¿¹q¶rÊ�Ç�½Í½{ÇdÐ}Ì{ÃqÉÜ»YÆ=µVÌ{˳¶nÊ�Ç�·}Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õV¼�Ð}¹q¶³·�¶)Ë�Ç�¼�¸}Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼�»Y·¿¶ �������P�Æq¶�½�»s¾�Ê�È=ÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãq¼�»YÃqÆ�˳»YºÁ»YË�Ì{¸y¾�ÌͼAË!¹q¶s»Yº IÒyÛ)Û:äVÒiÖÁÕS×ÔÝsÛ:× . Û!ÖKÒ|Ø .�ÞYâ=×�Û:äVÒ0ØÔßVå "��QäfáSÒ 0VÛ:ä f³âÍÕ�Ò�ÓÁÕ�Ù¿ÞSÖ=ÞVÙSØÔÒ0àÛ`Ý�Õ /YÕS×Qà�ÕO0CåVÕ��)��� � ��� � �/ -��H/��C#�� ���)����!$#h ¼�¶³Ë�Ç�ÃqÆ »Yºqºq·�Çf»YË!¹ì¸¿Ç ·¿¶�ÆqÈq˳Ì{ÃqÉ¥¸¿¹q¶(ºq·�ÌÍ˳¶�ÇYÊ�»YÃÁ»�·¿Ë!¹f¾�À�»Y½Í¼�Ç¥¶Qò=º=½ÍÇ�·�¶³Æ&ÌÍà ë ���:ñÚÀ}Ì{¼�¸¿Çé»Y½Í½{ÇCÐ »¼¿Å�»Y½{½"º8Ç�·o¸�Ì{Ç�à ÇYÊ�¸�¹q¶�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õx¸�·¿»�ÿ�Ë�¸¿Ç¥ÂK¶�·¿ÇYÈ=¸�¶�Æì˳¶�Ãu¸¿·�»Y½{½{¾YÎ 2 ¶�Ð}Ì{½Í½}Ës»�½Í½"¸�¹qÌ{¼���ÒÚÞVÙ 1fÕSâ fSÕS×0å×�Û:ä^Ò|ØÔßVåYÀ�»�ÊÔ¸¿¶³·}»Ü˳Ç�ÃqË�¶³º=¸}Ê�·�Ç�Å ÃqÇ�Ã=˳ÇVÇ�º8¶�·�»�¸¿Ì{µY¶nÉf»YÅ�¶k¸�¹q¶�Ç�·�¾�˳»Y½Í½{¶³Æ�þV¸�»YË!õY¶�½ÍÂK¶³·¿É�Éf»YÅ�¶³¼�ë¢ï���ñ0Î?óyø�¹=¶�Ì{Ãu¸¿¶³·�¶³¼�¸�ÇYÊ�¼¿ºÁ»YË�¶YÀ�ÐI¶�Ç�Ãq½�¾�Æq¶³¼�˳·�ÌÍÂK¶)Ç�Èq·}Å�Ç^Æ=¶³½�ÇYÊ�þV¸!»YË!õ�¶³½{Â8¶�·¿É ·�Ç�È=¸¿ÌÍÃqÉ�ÌÍÃ=Ê�ÇY·¿Å�»Y½Í½�¾�Àuµ^ÌͻܸyÐ+ǶSò=»YÅ�ºq½{¶³¼³Î687:9�;=< >@? �1B�� ÏGÇÜÈqÃqÆq¶�·¿¼�¸�»YÃqÆ�¸�¹q¶nºKÇY¸¿¶³Ãf¸�ÌÍ»Y½÷ºKÇCÐI¶�·"ÇYÊ�þV¸!»YË!õ�¶³½{Â8¶�·¿É�·¿Ç�È=¸¿ÌÍÃqÉ=À^Ë�Ç�Ãq¼¿Ì{Æq¶³·�¸¿¹q¶nÃqÇ�ÃVô½ÍÌ{Ãq¶s»�·rµ�»Y·�Ì�»YÃf¸�ÇYÊ}ê�Ì{É�Ç�Èt�î¼�¶Qò=»YÅ�º=½Í¶r � Ì{É�Èq·¿¶n���Âu�J�kÐ}Ì{¸¿¹ �¥½�»Y·�É�¶YÎ�þ^È=ºqº8ÇY¼¿¶�Ð+¶�»�·¿¶ ÉY·�»YÃf¸�¶�Æ¥¸�¹=¶»YÂqÌ{½ÍÌ�¸y¾�¸�ÇÜ·¿Ç�È^¸�¶n» &�Géë �����³ñ÷Ê�·¿»YË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�ÇYÊ�¸¿¹q¶k¸�·¿»�ÿ�Ër»Y¼IÐ+¶rÐ}Ì{¼¿¹*À=õVÃ=ÇdÐ}Ì{ÃqÉ�¸�¹Á»:¸�¸�¹q¶nÇ�¸�¹q¶�· �� �&L�Ê�·�»�Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�ÇYÊ�¸�¹=¶k¸�·�»:ÿ�ËkÐ}Ì{½Í½K¸�¹q¶�Ã�Ë!¹=Ç^Ç�¼�¶r·¿Ç�È=¸¿¶³¼"¼�¶³½{æq¼¿¹q½�¾�ÀÁ»Y¼"È=¼¿ÈÁ»Y½0Î "�k¶SæÁÃqÌ{¸¿ÌÍÇ�à �^Î �n¸¿¹VÈ=¼"É�ÇCµ�¶³·�Ãq¼¸�¹=¶�·�Ç�È=¸¿¶³¼ÜË!¹qÇ�¼�¶³Ã Âf¾x¼�¶³½{æq¼¿¹x¸�·�»:ÿ�Ë�À+Â=È=¸�ÃqÇY¸�Âf¾ ¸�¹q¶�Ë�¶³Ãf¸�·¿»Y½Í½�¾ ·¿ÇYÈ=¸�¶�Æ縿·�»�ÿ�ËYÎ4� 2 ¶�Ð}Ì{½Í½�˳»Y½Í½»(·¿ÇYÈ=¸�Ì{ÃqÉ(ÇYÊ}¸�¹=¶�˳¶³Ãf¸¿·�»Y½{½{¾Ñ˳Ç�Ãf¸�·�Ç�½Í½{¶³Æ¥¸¿·�»�ÿ�Ë�»��ÒÚÞVÙ 1fÕSâ fSÕS×0å(áSÒ|×�ÞYÒ`ÕÚåYà:Îé´kÂq¼�¶³·�µY¶�¸�¹Á»�¸)Ê�Ç�·�¶�µY¶³·o¾þV¸�»YË!õY¶�½ÍÂK¶³·¿É¥¼�¸�·¿»�¸�¶�ÉY¾�À�¸¿¹q¶�¼¿¶³½�æÁ¼¿¹ì¸¿·�»�ÿ�Ë�Ð}Ìͽ{½"Èq¼¿¶�¸�¹q¶�½ÍÇCÐI¶�·�¶�ÆqÉ�¶ �&¸�¹=¶�ÈqºqºK¶³·�·¿Ç�È^¸�¶�Ì{¼ÜÃq¶�µY¶³·»�¸�¸�·�»�Ë�¸�Ì�µ�¶n¸�Çܼ�¶³½{æq¼¿¹�Èq¼¿¶�·¿¼³ÀK¶�µY¶³Ã�Ì{ÊG¸�¹q¶r½ÍÇCÐ+¶³·}Ç�Ãq¶rÌ{¼�Ê�Èq½Í½�¾ Ë�Ç�ÃqÉ�¶�¼�¸�¶�Æ*ÎI´nÃ�¸�¹=¶�Ç�¸�¹q¶�·�¹q»YÃqÆ*ÀÁÌ�ÊAÐ+¶·¿ÇYÈ=¸�¶n¼�Ç�Å�¶k¸¿·�»�ÿ�ËrÇ�Ã�¸�¹=¶nÈqºqºK¶³·}¶³ÆqÉY¶�ÇYÈq·¿¼�¶³½{µY¶³¼�À�¸¿¹q¶n˳ÇY¼�¸�ÇYÊG¸�¹q¶nÇCµ�¶�·�»Y½{½*¼¿ÇY½ÍÈ=¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�Æq¶�˳·�¶s»Y¼�¶³¼³Î+óyúÁ»Y·o¸�Ì{˳Èq½Í»Y·³À�Ì{Ê&�Ìͼ¼�È=ÿ�˳Ì{¶³Ãf¸�½�¾�½�»�·¿É�¶�À�Ð+¶"Ës»YÃ�Å�ÌÍÅ�ÌÍË�¸�¹=¶"Ç�º=¸�Ì{Å »�½ �qÇdÐ Ç�Ã�¸¿¹q¶�ÈqºqºK¶³·�¶�ÆqÉ�¶S�·¿Ç�È^¸�ÌÍÃ=ɶSò^Ë�¶³¼¿¼}¸�·¿»�ÿ�ËnÇ�Ã�¸�¹q¶n½{ÇCÐI¶�·"¶³ÆqÉ�¶\��»YÃqÆ�ÌÍÃ=ÆqÈq˳¶k¸¿¹q¶nÇ�º=¸¿ÌÍÅ�»Y½ �ÁÇCÐrÎ�Ï"¹uÈq¼�þV¸�»YË!õY¶�½ÍÂK¶³·�É�·�Ç�È=¸¿ÌÍÃqÉ�˳»YÃÆq¶�˳·¿¶³»Y¼¿¶�À�Ç�·}¶�µ�¶�Ã�¶�·�»YÆqÌ{Ës»�¸¿¶YÀ=¸¿¹q¶rÌÍÃq¶Sÿ�˳ÌͶ�ÃqË�¾�Ç�Ê�¼�¶³½{æq¼¿¹�·¿Ç�È=¸¿ÌÍÃqÉ�Ì{Ã�¸�¹qÌ{¼"¶Sò=»YÅ�ºq½Í¶�Î687:9�;=< >@? �1B�� þV¸�»YË!õY¶�½ÍÂK¶³·�É�·¿Ç�È^¸�ÌÍÃ=É)»Y½{¼¿Ç�¹Á»Y¼�Ì{¸�¼�½ÍÌ{Å�Ì�¸!»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã=¼³ÎGþ^Èqº=º8Ç�¼�¶�Ð+¶�Å�Ç^Æ=Ì{ÊÔ¾ b�ò=»YÅ�ºq½Í¶ Î íÂf¾Ü·¿¶�ºq½�»YË�ÌÍÃqÉk¸¿¹q¶}˳Ç�¼o¸?Ê�ÈqÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã��5@ ,�+e � ÇYÊ÷¸¿¹q¶}½ÍÇCÐ+¶³·?¶³ÆqÉY¶�Ì{à � ÌÍÉ�È=·¿¶^���Âu�Âf¾�¸�¹q¶}Ë�Ç�¼�¸?Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�5@ ,�+e � p73� %&L� � ÀuÐ}¹q¶³·�¶ &�Ì{¼�¸�¹q¶}Ê�·�»YËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�Ç�Ê÷¸�·¿»�ÿ�Ë"¸�¹Á»�¸�Ð+¶�»Y·�¶�ºK¶³·�Å�Ì�¸¿¸¿¶³Æܸ�Ç�·¿Ç�È=¸¿¶�Ë�¶³Ãf¸�·¿»Y½Í½�¾�ÎÏ"¹q¶rõY¶S¾�Ç�Âq¼�¶³·oµY»:¸�ÌÍÇYÃ�ÌͼI¸¿¹Á»�¸"ÃqÇÜÅ�»�¸¿¸¿¶³·+¹qÇCÐE¸�¹=¶n˳¶³Ãf¸¿·�»Y½{½{¾�˳Ç�Ãf¸�·�Ç�½Í½{¶³Æ ¸¿·�»�ÿ�ËnÌ{¼�·¿Ç�È^¸�¶³Æ÷À=¸�¹q¶�·¿¶nÌ{¼¶³Ã=Ç�ÈqÉ�¹�¼¿¶³½�æÁ¼¿¹�¸�·�»:ÿ�Ër¸�Ç�Ê�Èq½Í½�¾�Ë�Ç�ÃqÉ�¶�¼�¸�¸¿¹q¶)½{ÇCÐI¶�·�¶�ÆqÉ�¶YÎ"Ï"¹=¶³·¿¶SÊ�Ç�·¿¶�À*þu¸!»YË!õ�¶³½ÍÂK¶³·�É�¼�¸¿·�»�¸¿¶³É�Ì{¶³¼}¸�¹Á»:¸

��í

Page 26: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

·¿ÇYÈ=¸�¶Ü»�¸kÅ�Ç�¼o¸ & È=ÃqÌ{¸¿¼nÇYÊ?¸�·�»:ÿ�Ë�˳»YÃqÃqÇ�¸rºq·¿ÇVÆqÈqË�¶Ü»K�qÇdÐ�Ð}Ì{¸¿¹¦Ë³Ç�¼o¸r½Í¶�¼¿¼n¸�¹Á»�à ��Î�´kæ¸�¹q¶�Ç�¸�¹q¶�·¹Á»YÃ=Æ*À8¸¿¹q¶)Ç�º^¸�ÌÍÅ�»Y½[�qÇdÐrÀKÐ}¹qÌÍË!¹�·¿Ç�È=¸¿¶³¼ &'� ��ÈqÃqÌ�¸�¼�ÇYÊs�ÁÇCÐ Ç�Ã�¸¿¹q¶)È=ºqº8¶�·�¶�ÆqÉ�¶�»�ÃqÆ�¸�¹=¶)·¿¶�¼�¸�Ç�ø�¹=¶�½{ÇCÐI¶�·�¶�ÆqÉ�¶�ÀÁ¹Á»Y¼}˳Ç�¼o¸�»Yºqºq·�Çf»YË!¹qÌ{ÃqÉ &§»Y¼ � % � »YÃqÆ � % �=ÎþV¸�»YË!õY¶�½ÍÂK¶³·¿É�·¿Ç�È^¸�ÌÍÃ=É�ÐI»Y¼?æÁ·¿¼o¸�ºq·�Ç�º8ÇY¼¿¶³Æ�Âf¾�èrÇY·¿Ìͽ{Ìͼ�À!x�»Yús»Y·�ÀV»YÃqÆ�´k·�ÆÁ» ëîí���ñ0ÀuÐ}¹qÇ�Ð+¶³·�¶�Å�ÇY¸�Ì�µY»:¸�¶³ÆÂf¾(¼�Ç�ôy˳»Y½Í½{¶³Æ�µVÌÍ·o¸�ÈÁ»�½�ºq·�Ì{µ�»�¸�¶)Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õu¼ |¼�¶³¶�¶�Î ÉqÎ 5 Ì{·¿Å�»YÃxë��.�:ñ�Ê�ÇY·n»�ÆqÌͼ�˳Èq¼�¼¿Ì{Ç�æÇYÊ��nê l ¼ �SÎ�Ï"¹q¶Å�»YÌÍÃrÉ�Çf»�½�ÌÍàë í5�:ñuÐ�»�¼G¸¿Ç�Ë!¹Á»�·�»YËS¸�¶³·�ÌÍú�¶�¸¿¹q¶+Ì{Ãq¼�¸�»YÃqË�¶³¼GÌÍÃnÐ}¹qÌÍË!¹�¼¿Ç�Å�¶+þV¸!»�Ë!õY¶³½{Â8¶�·¿É�¼�¸�·¿»�¸�¶�ÉY¾rÌÍÃ=ÆqÈq˳¶�¼»YÃ(ÇYº=¸�Ì{Å »Y½ �ÁÇCÐ |»Y¼�ÌÍà b�ò=»YÅ�ºq½Í¶ Î í��SÎ}Ï"¹qÌ{¼�ºq·�Ç�Âq½{¶³Å ¹Á»Y¼�»Y½Í¼�Ç�ÂK¶³¶�æ¼�¸�È=ÆqÌͶ�Æ(Å�ÇY·¿¶r·¿¶�˳¶³Ãf¸¿½{¾�Âu¾èr»YºKÇ�·¿Ì{¼³À�êAÇY½ÍÌ{¸¿Ç�ºKÇ�Èq½ÍÇYÈ*ÀÁ»YÃqÆ(þ^ºqÌ{·�»YõuÌͼ�ëîí ñ0Î #�¶�·¿¶�ÐI¶�Ê�Ç�½Í½{ÇdÐ 0}Ç�ÈqÉ�¹qÉ�»Y·¿Æq¶�Ãéë��fí:ñA»YÃqÆ�¼¿¶�¶³õ�ÐIÇ�·�¼�¸oôËs»�¼¿¶kÂKÇ�ÈqÃqÆ=¼�Ç�฿¹q¶�·¿»�¸�Ì{Ç)ÂK¶�¸yÐ+¶³¶³Ã�¸¿¹q¶�Ë�Ç�¼�¸"Ç�Ê*¸�¹q¶�Â8¶�¼�¸5�ÁÇCÐùºKÇ�¼¿¼�ÌÍÂq½{¶�Ð}Ì�¸�¹�þu¸!»YË!õ�¶³½ÍÂK¶³·�É�·¿Ç�È^¸�ÌÍÃ=É»YÃqÆ�¸�¹Á»�¸�ÇYÊ�»YÃ(ÇYº=¸�Ì{Å »Y½ �ÁÇCÐrÎ.b�ò=»YÅ�ºq½Í¶ Π𠼿¹=ÇdÐ}¼k¸¿¹Á»�¸³À8Ê�Ç�·�¶s»YË!¹�& G "� �\�³ñ0À8¸�¹=Ìͼ�·¿»�¸�Ì{Ç�˳»YæÂK¶»Y·�ÂqÌ{¸¿·�»Y·�Ìͽ{¾)˳½{Ç�¼¿¶}¸�Ç �qp0&GÀ^¶Sµ�¶�Ã�ÌÍÃܸyÐIÇ�ô�ÃqÇVÆq¶YÀV¸yÐIÇ�ô�½ÍÌ{Ãqõ�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õV¼�Î+´nÃ=¶�ÇYÊ*¸¿¹q¶�Å�»YÌ{Ã�·�¶³¼�Èq½{¸¿¼IÇYÊ�ë��fí:ñÌͼ}»�Å�»�¸�Ë!¹=ÌÍÃqÉÜÈqºqºK¶³·}ÂKÇ�ÈqÃqÆ�Ê�Ç�·"Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇY·¿õu¼�Ç�ʺÁ»Y·¿»Y½Í½{¶³½K½ÍÌ{Ãqõu¼³Î� �1?�J � ? ; �1B V EqT���� Y�Z �AÛ:×�Õ /YÕS×Sà�ØÔß=áSÒÚÞYß÷Ù!Õ �'��+b�� �&�zC�ØÔÒÔÓ�Þ�ß÷ÕSÒgCIÛ:×31�Û`ÝIÖ=ÞY×�ÞYâÔâÍÕSâ*â\ØÔß21Cá�ÞYßm0�Õ /YÕS×Sà&qG ]���\�³ñ "�Ò�ÓÁÕS×�ÕnØÍánÞ ��ÒÚÞVÙ 1fÕSâ fSÕS×0å�áSÒ|×�ÞYÒ`ÕÚåYà�ÒÔÓ=ÞYÒ�×�Û:ä^ÒyÕ!á &mb�äVßÁØÔÒÔá)Û`ÝkÒ|×�Þ�ø&Ù�ÞYßm0�à�ØÚÕSâ 0:ánÞA}Û%C C�ØÔÒÔÓÙ!ÛCáSÒIÞYÒ . ÛCáSÒ��qp0&çÒ|Ø . Õ!árÒÔÓÁÕ�Ù!ÛCáSÒ}Û`Ý�ÞYßÑÛ!ÖKÒ|Ø .�ÞYâ A}Û%C(ÝsÛ:× �'��+b�� ��� �Ï"¹q¶�Ç�·¿¶�Å Î ý�ºq·¿ÇCµVÌÍÆ=¶³¼�»�¼�Å�ÇVÇY¸�¹�¸¿·�»YÆq¶QôyÇo§ÂK¶�¸yÐ+¶³¶�Ã(Ç�º=¸¿ÌÍÅ�»Y½[�ÁÇCÐ}¼�»YÃqÆ 2 »Y·�Æq·¿ÇYº�¶�öVÈ=ÌͽÍÌ{Âq·¿ÌÍ»=Àq»�¼»(Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃéÇYÊ}¸�¹q¶�Ê�·¿»YË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�ÃéÇYÊ�Ë�¶³Ãf¸�·¿»Y½Í½�¾ ˳ÇYÃu¸¿·¿Ç�½{½Í¶�Æ¥¸�·¿»�ÿ�ËYÎ 2 ¹q¶�à & e �=À�ÐI¶�»Y·�¶�¼�¸¿ÈqË!õ¥Ð}Ì{¸¿¹» 2 »Y·¿Æ=·¿Ç�º(¶�öuÈqÌͽ{ÌÍÂq·�ÌÍÈqÅ�ÀqÐ}¹qÌÍË!¹¦Ë³»YÃ(Ë�Ç�¼�¸r»�·¿ÂqÌ�¸�·�»�·¿Ìͽ�¾�Å�Ç�·¿¶r¸�¹Á»�æ»YæÇ�º=¸¿ÌÍÅ�»Y½ �ÁÇCÐ�ÌÍÃ�» Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õÐ}Ì{¸¿¹�»Y·�ÂqÌ{¸¿·�»Y·o¾Ü˳Ç�¼o¸�Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃq¼³Î 2 ¹q¶�à &(e �k»YÃqÆ�Ð+¶k˳Ç�Ãf¸¿·¿Ç�½÷»Y½Í½�ÇYÊ�¸¿¹q¶�¸�·¿»�ÿ�ËYÀVÐI¶k˳»YÃ�ÇYÊ�Ë�Ç�Èq·¿¼�¶·¿ÇYÈ=¸�¶k¸¿¹q¶k¸�·¿»�ÿ�ËkÇ�º=¸¿ÌÍÅ�»Y½Í½�¾�ÎSbò=»YÅ�ºq½{¶ Î ð�»YÃqÆ�Ï"¹q¶³ÇY·¿¶³Å Î ý)º=·¿¶³Ë�Ìͼ�¶³½{¾ öuÈÁ»YÃf¸�Ì�ÊÔ¾�¸¿¹q¶nÌÍÃq¶Sÿ�˳ÌͶ�ÃqË�¾ÇYÊA¼¿¶�½{æÁ¼�¹�·�Ç�È=¸�Ì{ÃqÉ�Ê�Ç�·}»Y½{½÷ÌÍÃf¸¿¶³·¿Å�¶³Æ=Ì�»�¸¿¶kµY»�½ÍÈq¶�¼"ÇYÊ#& |ÌÍÃ�Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇY·¿õu¼�Ç�Ê�ºÁ»�·�»Y½{½Í¶³½8½ÍÌ{Ãqõu¼I�SÎ�c? ;=9��J$ �1B � Ï"¹q¶Iºq·�Ç^Ç�Ê=ÇYÊqÏ"¹q¶³Ç�·�¶³Å Î ý}Ì{¼�˳Ç�Ãq¼o¸�·�ÈqË�¸¿Ì{µ�¶�Àf»YÃqÆ�Èq¼¿¶�¼»�¼¿ÌÍÅ�ºq½{¶�Ì{¸�¶�·�»�¸¿Ì{µY¶+»�½ÍÉ�Ç�·�Ì{¸¿¹qŸ�ÇÜË�Ç�Å�º=È=¸�¶r»�É�ÇVÇ^Æ�þu¸!»YË!õ�¶³½ÍÂK¶³·�É�¼o¸�·¿»�¸�¶�ÉY¾�Î?Ï"¹qÌ{¼}»Y½ÍÉ�ÇY·¿Ì{¸¿¹qÅ ·¿ÈqÃ=¼�Ì{Ã�º8Ç�½�¾VÃqÇ�Å�Ì�»Y½Á¸�Ì{Å�¶k»Y¼}½ÍÇ�ÃqÉÜ»�¼¸�¹=¶�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õ�˳Ç�¼o¸�Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃq¼¼�»:¸�ÌͼoÊÔ¾�»kÅ�Ìͽ{Æ�Ë�Ç�Ãfµ�¶Qò=Ì�¸y¾�˳ÇYÃqÆqÌ{¸¿ÌÍÇ�à |¼¿¶�¶�ë ��í:ñ=Ê�Ç�·AÆq¶�¸�»YÌͽ{¼I�QÎ 2 ¹qÌ{½Í¶�¸�¹qÌ{¼»Y½{É�Ç�·¿Ì�¸�¹qÅùÌ{¼�¼¿È=ÿ�˳Ì{¶³Ãf¸�¸�Ç}Ç�Â=¸�»YÌÍÃn¸¿¹q¶?Â8¶�¼�¸�ô�º8ÇY¼¿¼¿Ì{Âq½Í¶AÐIÇ�·�¼�¸oôyËs»�¼¿¶�É�ÈÁ»Y·¿»YÃf¸�¶³¶?Ì{ÃnÏ"¹q¶³Ç�·�¶³Å Î ý^ÀdÌ{¸*ÆqÇ^¶�¼ÃqÇY¸�Ë�Ç�Å�º=È=¸�¶�¸�¹=¶�ÇYº=¸�Ì{Å »Y½þV¸!»�Ë!õY¶³½{Â8¶�·¿É�¼�¸¿·�»�¸¿¶³ÉY¾§Ì{ÃĶSµ�¶�·�¾ÄÌÍÃq¼o¸!»YÃ=˳¶YÎÜóyÃqÆ=¶³¶³Æ÷ÀA¸�¹=¶�ÇYº=¸�Ì{Å�Ì{ús»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�úq·�Ç�Âq½Í¶�Å Ç�Ê�Ë�Ç�Å�º=È=¸�Ì{Ãqɦ»YÃxÇ�º=¸¿ÌÍÅ�»Y½+þV¸!»�Ë!õY¶³½{Â8¶�·¿Éļ�¸¿·�»�¸¿¶³ÉY¾¥Ìͼ l êô�¹Á»Y·�ÆEë��fíCñÚÀ?¸�¹qÇYÈqÉ�¹éÌ{¸�Ës»YÃxÂK¶Ë³½{Ç�¼¿¶�½{¾�»Yºqºq·�ÇCò^Ì{Å »�¸¿¶³Æ�ÌÍÃ�ºKÇ�½{¾VÃqÇYÅ�ÌÍ»Y½K¸¿ÌÍÅ�¶Üë¢ð���ñ0Î

Ï"¹q¶³ÇY·¿¶³Å Î ýk»�ºqºq½ÍÌ{¶³¼ÇYÃq½{¾�¸�ÇnÃq¶S¸yÐIÇY·¿õu¼?ÇYÊKºÁ»Y·�»�½Í½Í¶�½^½{ÌÍÃqõu¼�Àf»YÃqÆ�¸¿¹q¶"º8ÇCÐ+¶³·?ÇYÊ÷þV¸�»YË!õY¶�½ÍÂK¶³·¿Ér·�Ç�È=¸�ôÌÍÃ=É�ÌÍÃ�Å�Ç�·�¶kÉ�¶³Ã=¶³·�»�½÷Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õu¼�Ì{¼�ÃqÇY¸IÊ�Èq½Í½�¾�È=ÃqÆq¶³·�¼�¸¿Ç^ÇVÆ*Î�Ï"¹q¶ �qp�&�Èqº=º8¶�·�Â8ÇYÈqÃqÆ�ÇYÊGÏ"¹q¶�Ç�·¿¶�Å Î ýÆqÇV¶³¼�ÃqÇY¸�¹qÇ�½{ÆÑÌ{ÃÑÉ�¶�Ãq¶³·¿»Y½?¼¿Ì{ÃqÉ�½Í¶QôyË�Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ{¸y¾�Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õu¼³À?»YÃqÆÑÃqÇ�ÌÍÃf¸�¶�·¿¶³¼o¸�Ì{ÃqÉ�ÂKÇ�ÈqÃqÆ=¼)»Y·�¶�ºKÇ�¼�¼¿Ì�ôÂq½{¶ ÌÍÃ¥Å�Èq½{¸¿ÌÍË�Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ{¸y¾�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õV¼�ë���ð:ñ0Î��?¶³·o¾¥·�¶³Ë�¶³Ãf¸�½�¾�À � ½{¶³Ìͼ�Ë!¹q¶³·)»YÃqÆçþVÐI»YÅ)¾ìë¢ü�ï�ñ+ºq·¿ÇCµ�¶�Æç»YûYÃÁ»�½ÍÇ�É�È=¶nÇYÊÏ"¹q¶�Ç�·¿¶�Å Î ý^ÀqÐ}Ì{¸¿¹�qp�&¦·¿¶�ºq½�»YË�¶³Æ�Âf¾�»�¼�Ç�Å�¶SÐ}¹Á»�¸�½�»Y·�É�¶³·�Ê�È=ÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�ÇYÊ#&AÀqÊ�ÇY·�»�Ð}ÌÍÆ=¶Ë³½Í»Y¼¿¼�ÇYÊ8Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õV¼�ÀqÌÍÃ=˳½ÍÈ=ÆqÌÍÃqÉn¼�¶³·�ÌͶ³¼`ôyºÁ»�·�»Y½{½Í¶³½=Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õu¼"»�ÃqÆ�¸¿¹q¶ 5 ·�»Y¶�¼¿¼+É�·�»Yº=¹q¼?ÇYÊ�þ^È=Âq¼¿¶�Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�ü^Î ��ÎÏ"¹q¶köuÈq¶�¼�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�ÇYÊ�Ð}¹=¶�¸�¹=¶³·�Ç�·+ÃqÇY¸I¼¿ÈqË!¹�»)·�¶³¼¿È=½{¸�¹=Ç�½ÍÆq¼�Ê�Ç�·IÉY¶³Ãq¶�·�»Y½K¼¿Ì{ÃqÉ�½Í¶QôyË�Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ{¸y¾)Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õu¼"Ì{¼Ç�ºK¶³Ã*Î

)��� � �K� �1�"!$# � / � �=� � % �.#�/102 ¶�Ë�Ç�Ãq˳½{ÈqÆq¶rÐ}Ì{¸¿¹�»Ü¸�¹qÌ{·¿Æ*ÀqµY¶³·�¾�ÃÁ»:¸�Èq·¿»Y½G»Yºqºq·�Çf»YË!¹�¸¿Ç�·�¶³ÆqÈ=˳ÌÍÃ=É�¸�¹=¶�ºq·�ÌÍË�¶�Ç�Ê�»YÃÁ»�·¿Ë!¹f¾�ÇYʼ�¶³½{æq¼¿¹·¿ÇYÈ=¸�Ì{ÃqÉ��Ì{à �ÁÈq¶�Ãq˳Ì{ÃqÉ ¼�¶³½{æq¼¿¹(ÂK¶³¹Á»sµVÌÍÇY·�Ð}Ì{¸¿¹�¶�ÆqÉ�¶)¸�»:ò^¶³¼³Î 2 ¹qÌͽ{¶rÃqÇY¸kÆ=Ìͼ¿Ë�Èq¼¿¼�¶³Æ¦Ì{Ãéë����:ñ0ÀK¸¿¹qÌͼ�ÌÍÆq¶³»

�Yð

Page 27: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

¹Á»Y¼nÂK¶³¶�ÃѶQòV¸�¶³Ã=¼¿Ì{µY¶³½�¾¦¼�¸¿ÈqÆqÌͶ�Ƨ¼¿ÌÍÃ=˳¶�¸�¹q¶�¶³»Y·¿½{ÌͶ�¼�¸nºÁ»�º8¶�·¿¼nÇ�缿¶�½{æÁ¼�¹Ñ·�Ç�È=¸¿ÌÍÃqÉqÎ�Ï"¹q¶Ü½ÍÌ�¸�¶�·�»�¸¿Èq·¿¶�Ç�úq·�ÌÍ˳Ì{ÃqÉk¼�¶³½{æq¼¿¹Ü·¿Ç�È^¸�ÌÍÃ=ÉnÃq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õu¼?ÌͼAµY»�¼�¸sÀu»�ÃqÆ�ÐI¶"Ð}Ìͽ{½^Ë�Ç�Ã=æÁÃ=¶"Ç�Èq·?»�¸�¸�¶³Ãf¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�¸¿ÇnÇ�Ãq½{¾�Ç�Ãq¶I˳½�»�¼¿¼¿Ì{Ës»Y½·¿¶�¼¿Èq½�¸}»YÃqÆ�¸yÐ+ÇÜ˳Èq·�·¿¶³Ãf¸¿½{¾�»�Ë�¸�Ì�µ�¶n·�¶³¼¿¶³»Y·¿Ë!¹�ÆqÌ{·¿¶³ËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼³Î�þ^¶³¶��+»YÃ=ÉÜ»YÃqÆ #�ÈÁ»�ÃqÉ�ë9�\��ü�ñ0À=Ê�Ç�·I¶Qò=»YÅ�º=½Í¶YÀÊ�Ç�·}»YÃ�ÌÍÃf¸¿·¿ÇVÆqÈqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�¸¿Ç�¸�¹qÌ{¼"·¿¶³¼�¶s»Y·�Ë!¹(»Y·�¶s»=Î

ê�ÌÍÉ�Ç�Èéë ý��dñ¼¿È=É�É�¶³¼o¸�¶�ÆÄÐ}¹Á»:¸r»Y·¿¶)ÇYÊÔ¸�¶�æËs»Y½{½Í¶³Æ .�ÞY×0åYØÔßKÞYâ?Ù!ÛCáSÒ"ÒÚÞ �^Õ!á�Ç�· � Ø�åVÛ:ä /CØ|ÞYߥÒÚÞ �^Õ!áSÎnÏ"¹q¶ÌÍÆ=¶s»�ÇYÊÅ�»Y·�É�ÌÍÃÁ»�½÷˳ÇY¼�¸�ºq·¿Ì{˳Ì{ÃqÉÜÌͼ"¸�ÇÜË!¹Á»Y·�É�¶�¶s»YË!¹�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õ�È=¼¿¶³·�Ç�Ã�¶s»YË!¹�¶³ÆqÉY¶�Ê�Ç�·�¸¿¹q¶�»YÆqÆqÌ�¸�ÌÍÇYÃÁ»Y½Ë³ÇY¼�¸+Ì{¸�¼?ºq·�¶³¼�¶³ÃqË�¶�Ës»�Èq¼¿¶�¼+Ê�Ç�·�¸�¹=¶�ÇY¸¿¹q¶³·?Èq¼�¶³·�¼IÇYÊ8¸�¹q¶�¶³ÆqÉY¶YÎ�ÏGÇ�ÆqÌ{¼¿Ë�Èq¼¿¼�¸�¹qÌ{¼�Ì{Æq¶s»kÊ�Ç�·�Å »�½Í½{¾YÀYÐ+¶�ÃqÇCлY½{½ÍÇCÐE¶³»YË!¹�¶�ÆqÉ�¶Qa)ÇYÊ»�¼�¶³½{æq¼¿¹�·�Ç�È=¸¿ÌÍÃqÉ�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õ�¸¿Ç�ºKÇ�¼�¼¿¶³¼�¼k»ÜÃqÇ�ÃqÃ=¶³Éf»�¸¿Ì{µY¶�ÒÚÞ ���]S�Î 2 ¶�Æq¶³Ã=ÇY¸�¶�»¼¿¶�½{æÁ¼�¹§·¿Ç�È=¸¿ÌÍÃqÉ�ÌÍÃq¼o¸!»YÃ=˳¶ �'��+b�� �&�}Ð}Ì�¸�¹¦¶³Æ=É�¶)¸!»dò=¶�¼��¦Âf¾ g' �+b�� � �����SÎ h 2 »Y·¿Æq·�Ç�º¦¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌ{Âq·¿Ì{ÈqÅÊ�Ç�·�¼¿ÈqË!¹§»�Ã(ÌÍÃq¼o¸!»YÃ=˳¶ g' �Ob0� �$���u�}Ìͼ�Æq¶�æÁÃ=¶³Æ§»Y¼�ÌÍà �k¶SæÁÃqÌ�¸�ÌÍÇYà �^Î ��À�Ð}Ì{¸¿¹(»Y½{½*¸�·�»:ÿ�Ë�¸�·¿»CµY¶³½{ÌÍÃqÉ�Ç�÷¿ÇYÈ=¸�¶�¼?¸¿¹Á»�¸�Å�ÌÍÃqÌ{Å�Ì{ú³¶?¸�¹q¶}¼¿È=Å ÇYÊ8¸¿¹q¶}¶³ÆqÉY¶�Ë�Ç�¼�¸¿¼I»�ÃqÆ�¶�ÆqÉ�¶"¸!»dò=¶�¼³Î+b�öuÈqÌ{µ�»Y½{¶³Ãf¸�½�¾�ÀfÌ�¸?Ìͼ?» 2 »�·¿Æq·�Ç�º¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌ{Âq·¿Ì{ÈqÅ Ê�Ç�·}¸�¹q¶�ÌÍÃq¼o¸!»YÃ=˳¶ g' �Ob0� �����SÀ�Ð}¹q¶³·�¶)¸�¹q¶)˳Ç�¼o¸�Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�à ���Ì{¼�» ¼�¹qÌ{ÊÔ¸¿¶³Æ�µY¶³·�¼¿ÌÍÇYÃ(ÇYÊ�¸�¹=¶Ç�·�ÌÍÉ�Ì{ÃÁ»Y½K˳Ç�¼o¸�Ê�È=ÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã(�US���� S @ ,�+e �#S�@ ,� ��]SIÊ�Ç�·}»�½Í½ � �=Î

��»�¸¿¹q¶³Å�»�¸�Ì{Ës»Y½{½{¾YÀ8¸�¹=¶�ºq·¿Ì{Ãq˳Ì{ºq½Í¶�Ç�Ê+Å�»Y·�É�ÌÍÃÁ»�½AË�Ç�¼�¸�ºq·�ÌÍ˳Ì{ÃqÉ�»Y¼�¼¿¶�·�¸�¼r¸�¹q»�¸kÊ�Ç�·r»��ÁÇCÐBE Ê�¶³»Y¼¿Ì{Âq½Í¶Ê�Ç�·I»YÃ�ÌÍÃ=¼�¸!»�Ãq˳¶ g' �Ob0� ���QÀ^¸�¹=¶�¸!»:ò��]S�»Y¼�¼¿Ì{É�Ãq¶³Æ�¸¿Ç)¸�¹=¶k¶³ÆqÉY¶uan¼¿¹qÇ�È=½ÍÆ�ÂK¶��]S�e�E%S:d � J S �E%S��SÀVÐ}¹q¶³·�¶ � J SÆq¶�ÃqÇY¸�¶�¼A¸¿¹q¶IÆq¶�·¿Ì�µY»:¸�Ì{µY¶+Ç�ÊK�#SQÎ$Dh�¼�¼¿ÈqÅ�¶+Ê�ÇY·A¼�ÌÍÅ�ºq½ÍÌ{˳Ì{¸y¾�¸�¹q»�¸A¸¿¹q¶IË�Ç�¼�¸AÊ�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃq¼�»�·¿¶�ÆqÌ o8¶³·�¶³Ãf¸�ÌÍ»YÂq½Í¶�Î �Ï"¹q¶�¸�¶³·�Å�� J S yEJS ��˳Ç�·�·¿¶�¼¿ºKÇ�ÃqÆq¼I¸¿Ç�¸¿¹q¶�Å�»Y·¿ÉYÌÍÃÁ»Y½ÁÌ{Ãq˳·�¶s»Y¼�¶�Ì{Ã�Ë�Ç�¼�¸IËs»YÈq¼�¶³Æ�Âf¾�Ç�Ãq¶�Èq¼¿¶�·IÇYÊ*¸¿¹q¶�¶�ÆqÉ�¶�À»YÃqÆ�¸¿¹q¶�¸¿¶³·�Å EJSIÌͼ�¸�¹q¶k»YÅ�ÇYÈqÃf¸IÇYÊ�¸¿·�»�ÿ�Ë�¸¿¹Á»�¸I¼¿È o8¶³·�¼�Ê�·¿Ç�Å ¸�¹=ÌͼIÌ{Ãq˳·�¶s»Y¼�¶YÎ�ê�ÌÍÉ�ÇYȦëîý��:ñ8¼¿ÈqÉ�ÉY¶³¼�¸¿¶³Æ¸�¹q»�¸�¸�¹=¶³¼¿¶�¸�»:ò^¶³¼�¼�¹qÇ�Èq½{Æ鶳½ÍÌ{Å�Ì{ÃÁ»�¸¿¶�»�½Í½?ÇYÊ}¸�¹q¶ ÌÍÃq¶Sÿ�Ë�ÌͶ�ÃqË�¾¥ÇYÊ}¼¿¶�½{æÁ¼�¹ç·�Ç�È=¸¿ÌÍÃqÉqÀ»YÃqÆ 5 ¶�Ë!õVÅ�»YÃqÃ÷À��Ë��rÈqÌ{·¿¶�ÀÁ»YÃqÆ 2 ÌÍÃq¼o¸�¶�à ë���ñ�Å�»YÆq¶k¸�¹=Ìͼ"ÌÍÆ=¶s»�·¿Ì{É�Ç�·¿ÇYÈq¼³ÎF � JK<�J OnG��qG@J � �1B � EqT�� ��V�X Y�Z � ÕSÒ �'��+b�� ���qfSÕ§ÞYß ØÔß=áSÒÚÞYß÷Ù!ÕqC�ØÔÒÔÓ 0YØ �kÕS×!ÕSßÁÒ|Ø|Þ!f³âÍÕÄÙ!ÛCáSÒ�ÝQä^ß÷ÙSÒ|ØÚÛ:ß=á#"Þ!0-.�ØÔÒ|Ò0ØÔßVå(ÞYß Û!ÖKÒ|Ø .�ÞYâ A}Û%C E � � � ÕSÒ �1S.e E �S d � J S yE �S �p0VÕSß÷Û:ÒyÕÜÒÔÓÁÕ .�ÞY×ÚåYØÔßKÞYâ�Ù!ÛCáSÒ�ÒÚÞ �)ÝsÛ:×�ÕO0CåVÕraC�ØÔÒÔÓ�×!Õ!áyÖÁÕ!ÙSÒ E � � �*ÓÁÕSß&E � ØÍá)Þ � ÞY× 0Y×!Û!Ö¥Õ��³ä^ØÔâ\Øgf³×QØÔä . ÝsÛ:× �'��+b�� � ������óyÃ�ÐIÇ�·�Æq¼³À�Å�»Y·¿ÉYÌÍÃÁ»Y½K˳ÇY¼�¸}¸!»:ò^¶�¼�Ì{ÃqÆqÈqË�¶�»�Ã�ÇYº=¸�Ì{Å »Y½m�ÁÇCÐ »Y¼�» 2 »Y·¿Æq·�Ç�º�¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌÍÂ=·¿ÌÍÈ=Å�Î

2 ¹qÌͽ{¶rê�·¿Ç�ºKÇ�¼¿Ì�¸�Ì{Ç�à Πï�Å »s¾�»Yº=º8¶³»Y·�¸�ÇÜÂK¶�»�Ë�Ç�Å�º=½Í¶�¸¿¶n¼¿Ç�½{È=¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�¸�Ç�¸¿¹q¶rºq·¿Ç�Â=½Í¶³Å ÇYÊA·¿¶³Æ=Èq˳Ì{Ãqɸ�¹=¶�ºq·¿Ì{˳¶�ÇYÊ�»YÃÁ»Y·�Ë!¹f¾ ÇYÊ}¼�¶³½{æq¼¿¹é·¿ÇYÈ=¸�Ì{ÃqÉqÀ�Ì�¸�ºKÇ�¼¿¼�¶³¼�¼¿¶³¼Ü¼�¶�µ�¶�·�»Y½IÆq·�»sÐ}ÂÁ»YË!õu¼�ÎÑÏ�Ð+ǦÇYÊ"¸�¹=¶³¼¿¶�¹q»CµY¶·¿¶�˳¶�Ãu¸¿½{¾&Å�ÇY¸¿Ì{µ�»�¸�¶�ÆìÅ�ÈqË!¹ ·¿¶�¼¿¶³»Y·¿Ë!¹ ÌÍÃ츿¹q¶¦¸�¹q¶�Ç�·¿¶S¸�ÌÍ˳»Y½�Ë�Ç�Å�ºqÈ=¸�¶�·�¼¿Ë�ÌͶ³Ã=˳¶Ä»YÃqÆùÅ�»�¸�¹q¶�Å »:¸�ÌÍ˳»Y½ºq·�Ç�É�·�»�Å�Å�ÌÍÃqÉ)˳Ç�Å�Å�ÈqÃqÌ�¸�Ì{¶³¼³Î

� ÌÍ·�¼�¸³À^¸�¹=¶nÆq¶�æÁÃ=Ì{¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�ÇYÊA» 2 »Y·¿Æ=·¿Ç�º�¶�öVÈ=ÌͽÍÌ{Âq·¿Ì{ÈqÅ ÌÍÃ�ê�·�Ç�º8ÇY¼¿Ì{¸¿ÌÍÇ�à Πï�ÌÍÅ�ºq½ÍÌ{˳Ì{¸¿½{¾�»Y¼¿¼�ÈqÅ�¶�¼�¸�¹Á»:¸»Y½{½�Ã=¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õÑÈq¼¿¶�·¿¼�¸�·¿»YÆq¶�Ço Ë�Ç�¼�¸�»YÃqÆ¥¸�»:ò^¶³¼�Ì{Ãé»Yà Ì{Æq¶³Ãf¸�Ì{Ës»Y½�ÐI»s¾�Î � Ç�·�¶Sò=»YÅ�ºq½Í¶�ÀÌ{Ê"¶�ÆqÉ�¶�Ë�Ç�¼�¸¿¼·¿¶�ºq·¿¶�¼¿¶�Ãu¸�¸�·¿»CµY¶³½�¸�Ì{Å�¶�À�¼¿Ç�Å�¶ÜÈq¼¿¶�·¿¼�Å�Ì{É�¹f¸rÂ8¶ÜÅ�Ç�·¿¶�¼�¶³Ãq¼�Ì{¸�Ì�µ�¶Ü¸�Ç�¸�Ì{Å�¶�Æq¶�½�»s¾V¼³À�Ð}¹qÌͽ{¶�ÇY¸�¹=¶³·¿¼�»Y·�¶Ë³ÇYÃq˳¶�·¿Ãq¶�Ʀºq·¿Ì{Å »Y·�Ìͽ�¾�Ð}Ì�¸�¹(Å�Ç�Ãq¶S¸!»Y·o¾�¶Sò^º8¶�Ãq¼¿¶�¼³ÎrþV¶�µ�¶�·�»Y½GºÁ»YºK¶³·�¼k¹Á»sµ�¶�˳Ç�Ã=¼¿ÌÍÆ=¶³·¿¶�Æ(¸�¹q¶�Ê�Ç�½Í½{ÇCÐ}ÌÍÃqÉÅ�Ç^Æq¶�½÷ÇYÊ?ÓÁÕSÒyÕS×!Û¿åVÕSß÷Õ!Û:äfá�¸�·¿»�ÿ�Ë�¶s»�Ë!¹�Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇY·¿õ�Èq¼�¶³·}Ë!¹qÇVÇ�¼¿¶�¼�»Üºq»�¸�¹�¸�¹q»�¸"Å�ÌÍÃqÌ{Å�Ì{ú³¶³¼+»�ÐI¶�ÌÍÉ�¹f¸¿¶³Æ¼¿È=Å ÇYÊG¸�¹q¶n¶�ÆqÉ�¶r˳Ç�¼o¸�¼�»YÃqÆ�¸¿¹q¶n¶³ÆqÉY¶r¸�»:ò^¶³¼�Î�óyÃ�ÇY¸¿¹q¶³·�Ð+Ç�·¿Æ=¼³Àq¸�¹=¶�º=·¿¶�Ê�¶�·¿¶�Ãq˳¶�¼�ÇYÊ�»�Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õ�Èq¼¿¶�·»Y·�¶k¼¿ÈqÅ�Å�»Y·¿Ì{ú³¶³Æ Âu¾�»�¼¿Ì{ÃqÉ�½Í¶�¼¿Ë³»Y½�»Y· �&¸¿¹q¶kÅ�Ç�Ãq¶�¸�»Y·�¾�µ�»Y½ÍÈ=¶�¸�Ç�¸¿¹q¶nÈq¼�¶³·"ÇYÊGÇ�Ãq¶�ÈqÃqÌ{¸�ÇYÊ�˳Ç�¼o¸sÎ?Ï"¹qÌ{¼Å�Ç^Æq¶�½�Ð�»Y¼�æÁ·¿¼o¸�ºq·¿ÇYº8Ç�¼�¶³Æx»YÃ=Æ ¼�¸¿ÈqÆqÌͶ�Æ ÌÍÃѸ�¹q¶�¸�·�»�Ãq¼¿ºKÇ�·�¸�»�¸�Ì{Ç�Ã¥¼�˳Ì{¶³ÃqË�¶�½ÍÌ�¸�¶³·¿»�¸�È=·¿¶�ëîü��VÀü��uÀý ñÚÀÂqÈ=¸�»YÃÁ»Y½{Ç�É�Èq¶�¼)ÇYÊ�ê�·�Ç�º8ÇY¼¿Ì{¸¿ÌÍÇ�à Πï�Ð+¶³·¿¶ Ç�Ãq½{¾Ä·�¶³Ë³¶�Ãf¸�½{¾ÑÉ�Ì�µ�¶³ÃÑÊ�Ç�·)¹q¶S¸�¶�·¿Ç�É�¶�Ãq¶³ÇYÈq¼�¸�·¿»�ÿ�ËYÎ \ ÇY½Í¶YÀ�kÇVÆqÌͼ�Àf»YÃqÆ�0}Ç�ÈqÉ�¹qÉ�»Y·¿Æq¶�Ã�ë@���dñÁºq·¿ÇCµY¶³Æܸ�¹Á»�¸³ÀfÌÍÃܼ¿Ì{ÃqÉ�½{¶SôyË�Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ{¸y¾kÃq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õu¼�Ð}Ì{¸�¹�¹=¶�¸�¶�·¿Ç�ÉY¶³Ãq¶�Ç�Èq¼¸�·¿»�ÿ�ËYÀf¸�¹=¶³·¿¶�Ìͼ?»�½{ÐI»C¾V¼+»�¼�¶�¸�ÇYÊ8¸!»:ò^¶³¼?¸�¹q»�¸?ÌÍÃqÆ=Èq˳¶�¼�¸¿¹q¶�ÇYº=¸�Ì{Å »Y½ �ÁÇCÐ&»Y¼�» 2 »�·¿Æq·�Ç�º�¶�öuÈqÌͽ{ÌÍÂq·�ÌÍÈqÅ�ÎÏ"¹qÌ{¼�·¿¶³¼�Èq½{¸?ÐI»Y¼?¶SòV¸�¶�ÃqÆq¶�Æ�¸�ÇrÅ�È=½{¸�Ì{˳Ç�Å�Å�Ç^ÆqÌ�¸y¾nÃq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õu¼IÌÍÃ=Æq¶³ºK¶³ÃqÆ=¶³Ãf¸�½�¾�Âf¾ � ½Í¶�Ìͼ�Ë!¹q¶³·�À $�»YÌÍÃ*Àu»�ÃqÆ��»Y¹=ÆqÌ�»YÃÑë¢ü���ñ0ÀÁèr»Y·�»�õYÇ�¼o¸!»Y¼�»YÃqÆ�ènÇ�½Í½{ÌÍÇ�ºKÇ�Èq½{Ç�¼�ë íYðdñÚÀ�»�ÃqÆ��+»�ÃqÉ�»YÃqÆ #�ÈÁ»YÃ=É�ë������dñÚÎ

þ^¶³Ë�Ç�ÃqÆ*ÀAÌÍÃÄÃq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õV¼�Ð}¹q¶³·�¶ Ë�Ç�¼�¸rÊ�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼�Ës»YÃĹÁ»sµ�¶�½�»Y·�É�¶�Æq¶³·�Ì{µ�»�¸¿Ì{µ�¶�¼³À�¸�¹q¶ÜÅ�»Y·¿ÉYÌÍÃÁ»Y½A˳Ç�¼o¸¸!»dò=¶�¼�ÇYÊ^ê?·�Ç�ºKÇ�¼¿Ì�¸�ÌÍÇYà Πï�Ës»YÃrÂK¶�¶SòV¸�·�¶³Å�¶³½{¾�½�»Y·�É�¶YÎAþ^¶Sµ�¶�·�»Y½f¼�Ç�½ÍÈ=¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã=¼*¹Á»sµ�¶?·¿¶�˳¶�Ãu¸¿½{¾nÂK¶³¶�Ãrºq·¿Ç�ºKÇ�¼�¶³Æ

��ý

Page 28: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

Ê�Ç�·�¸�¹=Ìͼ?ºq·¿ÇYÂq½Í¶�Å�ÀfÌ{Ãq˳½{ÈqÆqÌÍÃ=É�Ë�Ç�Å�ºqÈ=¸�Ì{ÃqÉ�»�¸�»:ò�¸�¹q»�¸IÌ{ÃqÆqÈqË�¶³¼+»YÃ�Ç�º=¸�Ì{Å »�½ �ÁÇCÐ&ÂqÈ=¸I»Y½{¼¿Ç�Å�Ì{ÃqÌÍÅ�ÌÍú�¶³¼¸�¹=¶�¸�»:ò^¶³¼�ºÁ»YÌÍÆ¥ë¢ï=À ��ñ 3�ÌÍÃqË�Ç�·¿ºKÇ�·�»:¸�ÌÍÃ=É�¸�¹q¶r¸!»:ò^¶�¼�ºÁ»�ÌÍÆ�ÌÍÃf¸�Çܸ�¹=¶�Ç�Âuû�¶³Ë�¸¿Ì{µY¶�Ê�ÈqÃ=Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�Ã¥ë@���VÀ[� ñ 38»�Ãqƺq·�ÇdµVÌ{ÃqÉ�ÐIÇ�·�¼�¸oôyËs»�¼¿¶�Â8Ç�È=ÃqÆq¼}Ç�Ã�¸�¹q¶r½�»�·¿É�¶�¼�¸"¸!»dò�Ãq¶�¶³Æq¶�Æ�¸�ÇÜÌÍÃ=ÆqÈq˳¶�»YÃ�Ç�º^¸�ÌÍÅ�»Y½m�ÁÇCÐ ë ���^ÀÁüfýVÀ�ü��:ñ0Î

� �H�n±3�k«�¬ �H���1��¬c�n¯ � ®�­��

Ï"¹qÌ{¼k¼¿Èq·oµ�¶S¾(Æq¶�¼¿Ë³·�ÌÍÂK¶³¼k¸¿¹q¶�ÂÁ»Y¼�ÌÍË�·¿¶³¼�Èq½{¸¿¼kÇ�Ã(¸¿¹q¶�ºq·�ÌÍ˳¶�ÇYÊ�»YÃÁ»�·¿Ë!¹f¾(ÇYÊ?¼�¶³½�æÁ¼¿¹¦·�Ç�È=¸�Ì{ÃqÉqÎ #�ÇCÐI¶Sµ�¶³·�ÀÐ+¶�¹q»CµY¶rÇ�Ãq½{¾�¼¿Ë�·�»�¸¿Ë!¹q¶³Æ�¸�¹q¶n¼�Èq·�Ê|»�˳¶rÇYÊ�»�Âq·¿Çf»�Æq¶³·"Ì{¼¿¼¿È=¶?öuÈÁ»YÃf¸�Ì�ÊÔ¾^Ì{ÃqÉ�¸�¹=¶nÌÍÃq¶Sÿ�Ë�ÌͶ�ÃqË�¾�Ç�ÊAÃ=Ç�Ãq˳Ç:ôÇ�ºK¶³·¿»�¸�Ì�µ�¶Ü¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌÍÂ=·¿Ì�»�ÌÍÃÑ»Yºqºq½{ÌÍËs»:¸�ÌÍÇYÃq¼�Ð}Ì{¸¿¹Ñ¼�¶³½�æÁ¼¿¹ÑÈq¼¿¶�·¿¼³Î�Ï"¹qÌͼrÊ�ÈqÃqÆq»YÅ�¶�Ãf¸!»Y½�ºq·�Ç�Âq½{¶³Å ¹Á»�¼�ÇYÃq½{¾·¿¶�˳¶�Ãu¸¿½{¾�Â8¶�¶³Ã�¼o¾V¼�¸�¶�Å »:¸�ÌÍ˳»Y½Í½�¾Ü¼�¸¿ÈqÆqÌͶ�Æ*À=Â=È=¸I¸¿¹q¶³·�¶�ÌͼI»Y½Í·�¶s»YÆ^¾�»)½�»Y·�É�¶}½ÍÌ�¸�¶³·¿»�¸�È=·¿¶�»YÆqÆq·�¶³¼¿¼�ÌÍÃqÉ)Å »YÃf¾»Y¼�º8¶�Ë�¸�¼�ÇYÊÌ�¸sÎ 2 ¶)˳ÇYÃq˳½{ÈqÆq¶r¸�¹qÌ{¼�¼�Èq·�µY¶�¾(Âf¾�Âq·�ÌͶ]�=¾�Æ=Ìͼ¿Ë�Èq¼¿¼�ÌÍÃqÉ�¼¿Ç�Å�¶�ÇYʸ�¹=¶)·¿¶�˳¶�Ãu¸�ÐIÇ�·�õ�ÌÍÃ�¸�¹qÌ{¼½ÍÌ�µ�¶�½{¾�·¿¶³¼�¶s»Y·�Ë!¹¦»Y·�¶s»=Î

� ÌÍ·�¼�¸³À�¸�¹q¶�ºq·¿Ì{˳¶}ÇYÊ*»YÃÁ»Y·�Ë!¹u¾Ü¹q»Y¼?Â8¶�¶³Ã�»�ÃÁ»Y½{¾Vú�¶³Æ�ÌÍÃ�ÃVÈ=Å�¶�·¿Ç�Èq¼�µ�»Y·�Ì�»YÃf¸�¼�»YÃ=Æ�É�¶�Ãq¶³·¿»Y½ÍÌ{ús»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã=¼ÇYʸ�¹=¶�ÂÁ»Y¼�ÌÍË)¼�¶³½�æÁ¼¿¹¦·�Ç�È=¸�Ì{ÃqÉ Å�ÇVÆq¶³½G¼�¸¿ÈqÆqÌͶ�Æ(ÌÍÃ�¸�¹qÌ{¼�¼¿È=·�µ�¶S¾�Î�þ^¶Sµ�¶�·�»Y½·�¶³Ë�¶³Ãf¸nºÁ»YºK¶³·�¼k¹Á»sµ�¶�¶QòV¸�¶³Ã=Æq¶³ÆÏ"¹q¶�Ç�·¿¶�Å �^Î �dýܸ¿Ç�Å�Ç�·¿¶�É�¶³Ãq¶�·�»Y½A˳½Í»Y¼¿¼�¶³¼kÇYÊ?É�»YÅ�¶�¼�ë��dýVÀ÷ý��=À8ï���ñ0ÎkÏ"¹q¶)ºq·¿Ì{˳¶)Ç�Ê�»YÃÁ»Y·�Ë!¹u¾�ÇYÊ?¼�¶³½{æq¼¿¹·¿ÇYÈ=¸�Ì{ÃqÉ�¹Á»Y¼r»Y½{¼¿Ç�ÂK¶³¶�Ãļo¸�ÈqÆ=ÌͶ³Æ§Ð}Ì{¸¿¹¦Ç�ÂVû�¶�Ë�¸�Ì�µ�¶�Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼nÇY¸¿¹q¶³·k¸¿¹Á»Yà 0ü���ë@�YðVÀ�ð��^Àt���^Àm� Àc���P�³ñ43Ð}Ì{¸¿¹�¶³Æ=É�¶kËs»�ºÁ»Y˳Ì�¸�Ì{¶³¼�»�ÃqÆ�ÇY¸�¹=¶³·I¸y¾VºK¶³¼"ÇYÊ)j�¼�ÌÍÆq¶�˳Ç�Ã=¼�¸�·¿»YÌÍÃf¸¿¼ k�ë ��ýVÀ ï=À=í�í:ñ 3^Ð}¹q¶�Ã�¸¿¹q¶�¸¿·�»�ÿ�Ëk·¿»�¸�¶�¼Ës»�Ã�µ�»Y·�¾�Ð}Ì{¸¿¹�¸�¹=¶)Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õ�Ë�Ç�ÃqÉ�¶�¼�¸�Ì{Ç�Ãxë��dýVÀL�Yü�ñ 38Ð}¹=¶³Ã¦Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õ�Èq¼�¶³·�¼kËs»YÃ�¹Á»sµ�¶�ÃqÇYÃ^ôyÃq¶�É�½ÍÌ{É�ÌÍÂ=½Í¶¼¿Ì{ú³¶�ëîüVÀ=ð=À^ý^ÀP�P�YÀU�Yí^ÀP���=À ��À^í�ý^À �fýVÀP�Yï=ÀVïfí:ñ 3=»YÃ=Æ Ð}Ì{¸¿¹ Æq¶SæÁÃqÌ{¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã=¼+ÇYÊ÷ºÁ»�¸¿¹�˳Ç�¼o¸ �UI �Et�?Ç�¸�¹q¶�·+¸�¹q»Yø�¹=¶�¼�ÈqÅ ÇYÊ»Y½Í½8¶³ÆqÉY¶�Ë�Ç�¼�¸¿¼�ëîý^Àu��ü�ñÚÎ

þ^¶³Ë�Ç�ÃqÆ*À:¸�¹q¶�º=·¿ÌÍË�¶?ÇYÊ^»YÃÁ»Y·�Ë!¹u¾rÌ{¼�»�µ�¶³·o¾nÉ�¶�Ãq¶³·¿»Y½f˳Ç�Ã=˳¶³º^¸ � »�ºqºq½ÍÌ{Ës»YÂ=½Í¶�¸¿Ç�¶Sµ�¶�·�¾rÃqÇ�Ã=˳ÇVÇ�º8¶�·�»�¸¿Ì{µY¶Éf»YÅ�¶�Ð}Ì{¸¿¹ »�Ã=ÇY¸�Ì{Ç�ÃÑÇ�Ê�¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌ{Âq·¿Ì{ÈqÅ »YÃ=Æé»�Ã=Ç�ÃqÃq¶�Éf»�¸�Ì�µ�¶�Ç�ÂVû�¶³ËS¸�Ì�µ�¶�Ê�È=ÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã*Î�óyÃÑÉf»YÅ�¶³¼rÐ}¹q¶³·�¶ÆqÌPo÷¶�·¿¶³Ãf¸�¶³öuÈqÌͽ{ÌÍÂq·�Ì�»"Ës»�Ã�¹Á»sµ�¶�Æ=Ì o8¶³·¿¶�Ãf¸Ç�ÂVû�¶�Ë�¸¿Ì{µ�¶�Ê�ÈqÃqËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃ�µ�»Y½ÍÈ=¶³¼³À�¸�¹q¶+ºq·¿Ì{˳¶�ÇYÊK»YÃÁ»Y·�Ë!¹f¾�Ì{¼�Èq¼�ÈÁ»Y½{½{¾Æq¶SæÁÃq¶³Æ�»Y¼¸¿¹q¶"·�»�¸¿ÌÍÇkÂK¶�¸yÐ+¶³¶�Ã�¸¿¹q¶"Ç�ÂVû�¶�Ë�¸�Ì�µ�¶�Ê�ÈqÃ=Ë�¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�µ�»Y½ÍÈ=¶�ÇYÊ�¸�¹q¶�Ð+Ç�·�¼�¸�¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌÍÂ=·¿ÌÍÈ=Å »YÃqÆ�¸�¹Á»:¸�ÇYÊ»YÃ�Ç�º^¸�ÌÍÅ�»Y½u¼¿ÇY½ÍÈ=¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�ëîíYï�ñ0Î�Ï"¹=¶"·¿¶³½Í»�¸�¶�Æ�˳Ç�Ã=˳¶³º^¸?ÇYÊ�¸�¹q¶+ÖK×QØÚÙ!ÕkÛ`Ý�áSÒ�Þ!f³ØÔâ\ØÔÒ|ànë¢ü�ñ=ÌÍÃq¼o¸�¶s»�Æ�Ë�Ç�Ãq¼�ÌÍÆq¶�·¿¼¸�¹=¶Ç�ÂVû�¶�Ë�¸¿Ì{µ�¶rÊ�ÈqÃqËS¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�µY»�½ÍÈq¶rÇYÊG¸�¹q¶rÂK¶³¼o¸�¶�öVÈ=ÌͽÍÌ{Âq·¿Ì{ÈqÅ�Î�Ï"¹q¶�ºq·¿Ì{˳¶rÇYÊ�»YÃÁ»Y·�Ë!¹f¾�»YÃqÆ�ºq·¿Ì{˳¶rÇYʼo¸!»YÂ=ÌͽÍÌ�¸y¾¹Á»sµ�¶rÂK¶³¶�Ã�¼�Èq˳Ë�¶³¼¿¼oÊ�Èq½Í½�¾�»YÃÁ»�½{¾Vú³¶�Æ�Ì{Ã�»�ÆqÌ{µY¶³·¿¼�¶�»Y·¿·¿»C¾ ÇYÊA»Yºqºq½{ÌÍ˳»�¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼+Ð}Ì�¸�¹�¼¿¶�½{æÁ¼�¹�Èq¼¿¶�·¿¼�ÇdµY¶³·"¸�¹=¶ºÁ»Y¼o¸)Ê�¶SÐ ¾�¶s»�·¿¼³Î�Ï"¹q¶�¼¿¶�Ì{Ãq˳½{ÈqÆq¶�¼¿Ë!¹q¶�ÆqÈq½ÍÌ{ÃqÉ �¼¿¶�¶¦ë �Yï=ÀGüfí:ñ+»YÃqÆѸ�¹q¶�·¿¶�Ê�¶�·¿¶�Ãq˳¶�¼)¸�¹q¶�·¿¶�ÌÍÃu�QÀAÊ|»YË�ÌͽÍÌ�¸y¾½ÍÇVËs»:¸�ÌÍÇYÃéë¢üU��À í^À*ð À*ïfý:ñ0À�Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õ(Æq¶�¼¿ÌÍÉYÃçëîü=À Àc���^À*ü À÷ü�ð�ñ0À*·¿¶�¼¿Ç�È=·¿Ë³¶�»Y½{½ÍÇVËs»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã¥ëîí��=À�í��^Àc��� ñÚÀ»YÃqÆ�ÇY¸¿¹q¶³·"Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇY·¿õuÌÍÃqÉ�Éf»YÅ�¶³¼�ë���À�í^À ð^ÀKíP�SñÚÎ

Ï"¹qÌÍ·�Æ*À·�¶³¼¿¶³»Y·¿Ë!¹=¶³·¿¼�¹q»CµY¶�ÂK¶³É�ÈqÃѸ�Ç�¼o¸�ÈqÆ^¾Ñ¸¿¹q¶�ÌÍÃ=¶�ÿ�˳Ì{¶³ÃqËS¾ÑÇ�Ê"ÆqÌ o8¶³·�¶³Ãf¸�Ã=ÇY¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼�ÇYÊ�»�¼�¶³½{æq¼¿¹Ç�È=¸¿Ë³Ç�Å�¶YÎ � Ç�·�¶Sò=»YÅ�ºq½Í¶�À �rÇV¶³Å�»YÃq¼�À���ÌÍ·�·¿Ç�õuÃqÌ0À�»YÃqÆ �?¶�¸�¸!»Ñë íuÀ�ð ñ?¹q»CµY¶�¶QòV¸�¶³Ã=Æq¶³Æĸ�¹q¶Ü˳ÇYÃq˳¶�º=¸ÇYʸ¿¹q¶)º=·¿ÌÍË�¶)ÇYÊ�»YÃÁ»Y·�Ë!¹u¾�¸¿Ç�Éf»YÅ�¶³¼�ÌÍÃ�Ð}¹qÌÍË!¹(¶�öuÈqÌͽ{ÌÍÂq·�Ì�»�Ãq¶³¶�Æ(ÃqÇY¸�¶Sò^Ìͼo¸sÎ}Ï"¹q¶)Ð+Ç�·�õ�Ì{Ãéë í^ÀKð ñGÌ{¼»Y½{¼¿Ç�Å�ÇY¸¿Ì{µ�»�¸¿¶³Æ§Âf¾¦¸�¹q¶�ÌÍÅ�º8ÇY·�¸!»�Ãu¸rº=·¿Ç�Âq½{¶³Å Ç�Ê�ÈqÃqÆ=¶³·¿¼o¸!»YÃ=ÆqÌÍÃqÉ�Ð}¹q¶³Ã »�¼�Å »Y½{½ºq·�ÌÍ˳¶�ÇYÊ�»YÃÁ»Y·�Ë!¹u¾ÌÍÅ�ºq½{ÌͶ³¼k¸¿¹Á»�¸)¼¿¶³½�æÁ¼¿¹¥Èq¼¿¶�·¿¼�˳»Yà j�½{¶s»Y·�Ã�kqÀGÂu¾ÑÌÍÃ=Æq¶³ºK¶³ÃqÆ=¶³Ãf¸Ü»YÃqÆÑ·¿¶�º8¶³»�¸�¶�Æé¶Sò^º8¶�·¿Ì{Å�¶�Ãu¸�»�¸�Ì{Ç�çÊ�·¿Ç�Å»YÃ�»Y·¿ÂqÌ�¸�·¿»Y·�¾�Ì{ÃqÌ{¸¿Ì�»Y½8¼�¸�»�¸�¶�À÷»YÃ�»Yºqº=·¿Çsò^ÌÍÅ�»�¸�¶�½{¾�Ç�º^¸�ÌÍÅ�»Y½*ÇYÈ=¸�Ë�Ç�Å�¶�Î h�Ã=ÇY¸�¹q¶�·�¶Qò=»YÅ�º=½Í¶�Ìͼ}É�Ì{µY¶³Ã�Âu¾\ ¹q·�Ìͼ�¸¿Ç^Æ=Ç�Èq½ÍÇYÈ�»�ÃqÆ�ènÇ�È^¸�¼¿ÇYÈqºqÌ�»�¼)ë ����ñ0ÀqÐ}¹qÇ�¼�¸�È=ÆqÌͶ�Æ�¸¿¹q¶�Ì{Ãq¶�ÿ�Ë�ÌͶ³Ã=Ë�¾�ÇYÊA˳Ç�·�·¿¶�½�»�¸¿¶³Æ�¶³öuÈqÌͽ{ÌÍÂq·�Ì�»�Ì{ü¿Ë!¹=¶³ÆqÈq½{ÌÍÃqÉ�Éf»YÅ�¶³¼�Î

� ÌÍÃq»Y½Í½�¾�Àf»YÃ�¶³Å�¶³·�É�ÌÍÃ=É�·�¶³¼�¶s»Y·�Ë!¹�ÆqÌÍ·�¶³ËS¸�ÌÍÇYÃ�Ì{¼�¸�Ç�Èq¼¿¶}¸�¹q¶}ºq·�ÌÍË�¶�ÇYÊ÷»YÃÁ»�·¿Ë!¹f¾�»Y¼�»�Å�¶s»Y¼�Èq·¿¶}Ê�Ç�·�¸�¹=¶ºK¶³·�Ê�ÇY·¿Å�»YÃq˳¶�ÇYÊ�»�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õ�ºq·�ÇY¸�ÇV˳Ç�½�¸�¹q»�¸�Ì{Ãf¸�¶³·¿»YË�¸¿¼�Ð}Ì�¸�¹�¼�¶³½�æÁ¼¿¹¦Èq¼�¶³·�¼³Î�Ï"¹=Ìͼ�Ì{Æq¶s»�˳Ç�Ã=Ãq¶³ËS¸�¼k¸�¹=¶»YÃÁ»�½{¾V¼¿Ì{¼�ÇYÊI¸�¹q¶�ÌÍÃq¶Sÿ�Ë�ÌͶ�ÃqË�¾ÄÇYÊ"É�»YÅ�¶Qô�¸¿¹q¶³Ç�·�¶�¸¿ÌÍËܶ³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌÍÂ=·¿Ì�»�Ð}Ì�¸�¹ . Õ!Ù!Ó=ÞYßÁØÍá . 0VÕ!áSØ�åYßÁÀ�»�˳½�»�¼¿¼¿Ì{Ës»Y½¼¿È=Â=æÁ¶³½{ÆxÇYÊ�Å�ÌÍË�·¿ÇV¶³Ë�Ç�ÃqÇ�Å�ÌÍË�¼�¸¿¹Á»�¸�¼o¸�ÈqÆqÌ{¶³¼Ü¹qÇCÐ ¸�ǦÆq¶�¼¿ÌÍÉYÃçÉ�»YÅ�¶�¼)¸�¹q»�¸Üº8ÇY¼¿¼¿¶�¼¿¼Ü¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌ{Âq·¿ÌÍ»�Ð}Ì{¸¿¹É�ÇVÇ^Æéº=·¿Ç�ºK¶³·o¸�ÌͶ�¼ |¼�¶³¶�¶YÎîÉqÎ}ë¢ð�ü=À \ ¹Á»Yº^¸�¶³· �Yü:ñ�Ç�·�ë¢ð��^À \ ¹Á»Yº^¸�¶³· �\��ñi�QÎ � Ç�·�¶Qòq»�Å�ºq½{¶YÀ $YÇ�¹q»Y·¿Ìrëîí��=À\ ¹Á»Yº^¸�¶³·ní:ñ�Ë�Ç�Ãq¼�ÌÍÆq¶�·¿¼n» Ë�½�»Y¼�¼�ÇYÊ?Ã=¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õ�·¿¶³¼�Ç�Èq·�˳¶Ü»Y½{½ÍÇVËs»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�ºq·�ÇY¸�ÇV˳Ç�½{¼³ÀK¶s»YË!¹¦Ç�ÊÐ}¹qÌÍË!¹¦Ë³»YæÂK¶

���

Page 29: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

µVÌͶSÐI¶�Æ�»Y¼G»}Éf»YÅ�¶Ð}Ì{¸�¹r¼�¶³½{æq¼¿¹)È=¼¿¶³·�¼³ÀY»YÃqÆ)º=·¿ÇCµ�¶�¼G¸¿¹Á»�¸A»�Ãq»�¸�Èq·¿»Y½1j�º=·¿Ç�ºKÇ�·�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãq»Y½Y¼�¹Á»Y·¿Ì{ÃqÉ k}ºq·�ÇY¸�ÇV˳Ç�½Å�ÌÍÃqÌ{Å�Ì{ú³¶³¼�¸�¹q¶r�Ð+Ç�·¿¼o¸�ô�Ës»Y¼�¶���Ì{Ãq¶�ÿ�Ë�ÌͶ³Ã=Ë�¾§ÇYÊI¶³öuÈqÌͽ{ÌÍÂq·�Ì�»=Î h ¼¿¶�˳Ç�ÃqÆ¥¶Sò=»YÅ�ºq½Í¶ÜÌͼn¸¿¹q¶�·�¶³Ë�¶³Ãf¸)Ð+Ç�·¿õÂf¾ \ ¹q¶�Ã*À 0}Ç�ÈqÉ�¹qÉ�»Y·¿Æq¶�Ã*À�»YÃ=Æ���»Y½ÍÌÍ»YÃf¸�ë��Cï�ñA¸�¹Á»�¸n»YÃÁ»Y½�¾^ú�¶³¼n¹qÇCÐ ¸�¹=¶�ºq·¿Ì{˳¶�ÇYÊ?¼o¸!»YÂ=ÌͽÍÌ�¸y¾�ÌÍæ»�Ë�½�»Y¼�¼ÇYÊAÃq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õ�Æq¶³¼�ÌÍÉ�Ã�Éf»YÅ�¶³¼�ë¢ü�ñ�Æq¶�º8¶�ÃqÆq¼�Ç�Ã�¸�¹q¶rË!¹qÇ�Ì{˳¶rÇYÊ�»YÃ�ÈqÃqÆq¶�·¿½{¾VÌ{ÃqÉÜ˳Ç�¼o¸�ôy¼�¹Á»Y·�ÌÍÃqÉܺq·�ÇY¸�ÇV˳Ç�½0Î

� !$� � -�/ �.# / *f/S! � 0ó*¹Á»sµY¶�Â8¶�¶³Ã�½{ÈqË!õf¾r¸�Ç�ÂK¶³Ã=¶�æq¸AÊ�·¿Ç�Å ¸¿¹q¶I»�Æ=µVÌÍ˳¶I»YÃqÆ)»Y¼¿¼�Ìͼ�¸�»YÃqË�¶IÇYÊÁÅ�»YÃf¾rÌÍÃ=ÆqÌ{µVÌÍÆ=ÈÁ»Y½Í¼*Ð}¹=ÌͽͶ�Ð+Ç�·¿õuÌ{ÃqÉÇ�Ã�¸�¹=¶�·�¶³¼�¶s»Y·�Ë!¹ Æq¶�¼¿Ë³·�ÌÍÂK¶³Æ�ÌÍÃ�¸�¹=Ìͼ?¼¿Èq·oµ�¶S¾�Î�Ï"¹q¶�½ÍÌ{¼�¸�Ì{¼¸�ÇVÇ�½{Ç�ÃqÉk¸¿Ç�ÉYÌ{µ�¶"¹=¶³·¿¶�À^Â=È=¸�óAÅ�È=¼�¸�Å�¶�Ãf¸�ÌÍÇYÃ�bµ�»�ÏA»Y·¿Æ=Ç�¼³À�Ð}¹qÇ�¼¿ÈqºK¶³·oµVÌͼ¿¶�Æ¥Å)¾(ÆqÇ^ËS¸�Ç�·¿»Y½�¸¿¹q¶³¼�Ìͼ�ë ���:ñ�»YÃqƧ˳ÇY½Í½�»�Â8Ç�·¿»�¸�¶�Æ(Ð}Ì{¸¿¹ÄÅ�¶ÜÇ�çÅ�ÈqË!¹ÄÇYʸ�¹=¶�ÐIÇY·¿õ Æ=¶³¼¿Ë�·¿Ì{Â8¶�Æ�ÌÍ฿¹qÌͼ�¼�Èq·�µY¶�¾ 3mx�¶³Ç�ÃÁ»�·¿Æ�þ^Ë!¹uÈq½{Å »�Ã*À=Ð}¹qÇ�Ì{Ãu¸¿·¿ÇVÆqÈqË�¶³Æ�Å�¶�¸�Ç)¼¿¶³½�æÁ¼¿¹�·�Ç�È=¸�Ì{ÃqÉ�3»YÃqÆ \ ¹q·�Ìͼ�¸¿Ç�¼�ê�»Yºq»YÆqÌÍÅ�Ì{¸¿·¿Ì{Ç�È*ÀfÐ}¹qÇ�»Y¼¿õ�¶³Æ(»�Â8Ç�È^¸"¸�¹q¶rºq·�ÌÍ˳¶rÇYÊ�»YÃÁ»�·¿Ë!¹f¾�ÇYÊA¼¿¶³½�æÁ¼¿¹�·¿ÇYÈ=¸�Ì{ÃqÉqÎ

óyÃ¥»�ÆqÆqÌ{¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã÷À÷ó}¸�¹Á»YÃ=õ $YÇ�¼ �¶ \ ÇY·¿·¿¶³»=À #�¶�Ãq·�¾qx�Ì{Ã*À���ÈqõuÈqÃ=Æ þ^È=ÃqÆÁ»Y·¿»Y·�»dû¿»�Ã*À�»YÃqÆ �n·¿¶³É ��»Y½{Ì�»YÃf¸Ê�Ç�·�¹q¶³½{º=Ê�Èq½�Ë�Ç�Å�Å�¶�Ãu¸¿¼kÇ�ç»Y涳»Y·¿½{ÌͶ�·�Æq·¿»�ÊÔ¸sÎ � Ì{ÃÁ»Y½{½{¾�À�ó"¸�¹q»YÃqõ_h�½ÍÂK¶³·o¸�Ç \ »Yº=·�»Y·¿» Ê�Ç�·�Ì{ÃuµVÌ�¸�ÌÍÃ=É Å�¶¸�Ç�Ð}·�Ì{¸�¶n¸¿¹qÌͼ"¼�Èq·�µY¶�¾�ÀK»YÃ=Æ�Ê�Ç�·"¹=Ìͼ"ºÁ»�¸¿ÌͶ�Ãq˳¶n¸�¹=·¿Ç�ÈqÉY¹qÇ�È=¸}¸�¹=¶rÐ}·�Ì{¸¿ÌÍÃqÉ�ºq·�Ç^Ë�¶³¼�¼³Î

�H� � �k­j�k«¦±3���

ë��³ñ ��Înh�˳¶�Å�Ç�ÉY½ÍÈr»YÃqÆ h�Îd´kú³ÆÁ»YÉY½�»Y·�Î � ½{ÇCÐÑË�Ç�Ãf¸�·�Ç�½ÚÀd·¿ÇYÈ=¸�Ì{ÃqÉqÀd»YÃqÆrºK¶³·oÊ�Ç�·¿Å�»YÃqË�¶�ÈqÃqÆq¶�·GÅ�Ç�ÃqÇYº8Ç�½�¾ºq·�ÌÍË�ÌÍÃqÉqÎ�ÏA¶�Ë!¹qÃqÌÍ˳»Y½ 0�¶�º8ÇY·�¸ 2 ê�ôI�CðYï�ð=Àu��óyÏ�x�ó3�rþ8À[������ü^Î

ë �:ñ 0rÎ�è�Î h�¹uÈ:û¿»^ÀGÏnÎ x?Îm��»YÉ�ÃÁ»�Ãu¸¿ÌÚÀ�»YÃ=Æ $=Î 5 Î�´k·¿½{ÌÍÃ*Î ��ÕSÒgCIÛ:×31 �?âÍÛ%C�á � �*ÓÁÕ!Û:×Qà " � âîåVÛ:×QØÔÒÔÓ .)á#"ÞYßm0 � ÖfÖKâ\ØÚÙ¿ÞYÒ0ØÚÛ:ß=áSÎê?·�¶³Ãf¸�Ì{˳¶Qô #�»�½Í½ÚÀ,�Cï�ï�ü^Î

ë¢ü�ñ b"Î h�Ãq¼�¹q¶³½{¶�µVÌÍË!¹*Àh)Î��n»Y¼¿ÉYÈqº=¸!»^À $=Î:èn½Í¶�ÌÍÃuÂ8¶�·¿ÉqÀ �b"ÎdÏ�»Y·�ÆqÇ�¼�À�ÏnÎ 2 ¶Qò=½{¶³·�À�»YÃqÆ�ÏnÎ 0}Ç�ÈqÉY¹qÉf»Y·�Æq¶³Ã*ÎÏ"¹q¶�ºq·�ÌÍ˳¶}ÇYÊ÷¼�¸�»YÂqÌͽ{Ì{¸y¾�Ê�Ç�·�Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õÜÆq¶³¼�ÌÍÉ�ÃÜÐ}Ì{¸¿¹�Ê|»YÌ{·Ë³ÇY¼�¸+»Y½Í½{Ç^˳»�¸�Ì{Ç�Ã*ÎÁóyà � ×!ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:ánÛ`Ý}ÒÔÓÁÕ��� ÒÔÓ � ßÁßÁä=ÞYâ ��à0.�ÖÁÛCáSØÔä . Û:ß �GÛ:ä^ßm0fÞYÒ|ØÚÛ:ß=á�Û`Ý �+Û0.�ÖKäVÒ`ÕS× �*ÙSØÚÕSß÷Ù!Õ � ��� � � �:ÀCºÁ»YÉ�¶�¼��Yïfí�Vü�� À����� Î

ë ñ b"Î h�Ãq¼�¹q¶³½{¶�µVÌÍË!¹*À h)ÎP�n»Y¼¿É�È=º=¸!»=À �b"Î^ÏA»Y·�ÆqÇ�¼³À^»YÃqÆ ÏnÎ 2 ¶Sò^½Í¶�·³Î l ¶³»Y·oô�Ç�º=¸¿ÌÍÅ�»Y½ÁÃq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õ�Æq¶�¼¿Ì{É�ÃÐ}Ì�¸�¹�¼¿¶�½{æÁ¼�¹�»YÉY¶³Ãf¸�¼�Î�óyà � ×�ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:á)Û`ÝrÒÔÓÁÕ � � Ò�Ó � ßÁßÁä=ÞYâ � � � ��à .�ÖÁÛCáSØÔä . Û:ß �*ÓÁÕ!Û:×Qà�Û`Ý�+Û0.�ÖKäVÒ0ØÔßVå � � ��� � �:ÀqºÁ»YÉ�¶�¼�íP��� =í����=À��5����ü=Î

ëîí:ñ $=Î�h�¼¿ºqÃ=¶³¼³ÀKè�Î \ ¹q»YÃqÉqÀÁ»�ÃqÆah)Î �+»�Å�ºKÇ�½Í¼�õuÌ{¾�ÎGóyÃqÇV˳Èq½Í»�¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�¼o¸�·�»:¸�¶³ÉYÌͶ³¼�Ê�ÇY·IµVÌÍË�¸¿ÌÍÅ�¼IÇYÊ�µVÌÍ·�Èq¼¿¶�¼»YÃ=Æĸ¿¹q¶�¼�ÈqÅ�ôyÇYÊ�ô�¼¿öuÈÁ»Y·�¶³¼rºÁ»Y·o¸�Ì{¸¿ÌÍÇ�æº=·¿Ç�Âq½{¶³Å�Î�óyà � ×�ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:á�Û`Ý�ÒÔÓÁÕ��:ÒÔÓ � ßÁßÁäqÞYâ � � ��.� ! � � ��à .�ÖÁÛCáSØÔä . Û:ß��rØÍáCÙS×�ÕSÒyÕ � âîåVÛ:×QØÔÒ�Ó .)á � � ��� � �:À=ºÁ»�É�¶³¼ ü ^í��^Àu�����fí^Î

ë¢ð�ñ 5 Î�h�ÐI¶�·¿ÂqÈ=Ë!¹*À ��Î�h�ús»Y·�À�»YÃqÆ x�Î+b�ºq¼�¸¿¶³ÌÍÃ÷Î Ï"¹q¶�ºq·�ÌÍË�¶�Ç�Êk·¿ÇYÈ=¸�Ì{ÃqɦÈqÃq¼�ºq½ÍÌ�¸¿¸!»�Âq½Í¶��ÁÇCÐrÎçóyÃ� ×�ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:á�Û`ÝÜÒÔÓÁÕ � sÒÔÓ � ßÁßÁä=ÞYâ � � � ��à0.�ÖÁÛCáSØÔä .#Û:ß��*ÓÁÕ!Û:×Qà¦Û`Ý �+Û0.�ÖKä^Ò|ØÔßVå � � ��� � �:ÀºÁ»�É�¶³¼�í�ý�Vð�ð=Àu�����fí^Î

ëîý:ñ 0rÎ 5 »�ÃqÃq¶³·�»YÃqÆ�h�Î�´k·¿ÆÁ»^Î 5 ÇY¸�¸�½{¶³Ãq¶�Ë!õ¥·¿ÇYÈ=¸�Ì{ÃqÉ�Éf»�Å�¶�¼)ÌÍå˳Ç�Å�Å�ÈqÃqÌ{Ës»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�ÃÄÃq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õu¼³Î§óyÃ� ×�ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:á�Û`ÝrÒÔÓÁÕ�� � Ò�Ó ! � ��� ��� � �+Û:ßsÝsÕS×�ÕSß÷Ù!ÕSÀ������Yð=ÎÏGÇ »Yº=º8¶³»Y·³Î

ë���ñ �ÑÎI$=Î 5 ¶�Ë!õVÅ�»YÃqÃ÷À \ Î 5 Î ��Ë$�nÈqÌÍ·�¶YÀ?»YÃqÆ \ Î 5 Î 2 Ì{Ãq¼�¸¿¶³Ã*Î ��Ò|ä 0YØÚÕ!á ØÔß ÒÔÓÁÕ � Ù!Û:ß÷Û0.�ØÚÙ!á�Û`Ý�=׿ÞYß=áyÖÁÛ:×QÒÚÞYÒ0ØÚÛ:ßÁÎ �+»Y½Í¶ ��ÃqÌ{µY¶³·¿¼�Ì{¸y¾�ê�·�¶³¼¿¼�Àe�sïfíYð=Î

�Yï

Page 30: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

ë¢ï�ñ�êGÎ 5 ¶�·¿É�¶�ÃqÆqÇ�·"o�ÀH��Î 2 Î #�¶³»Y·¿Ã÷À�»YÃqÆ �ÄÎ �)Î 0�»YÅ�»YÃÁ»=Î \ ÇYÃqÉ�¶³¼o¸�Ì{Ç�Ã¥¸�ÇY½Í½�ºq·�ÌÍ˳Ì{ÃqÉ�Ç�Ê�¸�·¿»�ÿ�ËÃq¶S¸yÐIÇY·¿õu¼³Î óyà êGÎ �ÑÎ�ê�»Y·�ÆÁ»Y½ÍÇY¼³À_��Î 2 Î�#�¶³»Y·¿Ã*Àr»�ÃqÆ 2 Î 2 Î�#�»YÉY¶³·³À�¶³ÆqÌ�¸�Ç�·�¼³À ��ÕSÒ�CIÛ:×31�AÖKÒ|Ø .�Ø��CÞYÒ0ØÚÛ:ßÁÀ=ºÁ»YÉ�¶�¼�í � =ýP��Îqþ^ºq·�ÌÍÃqÉ�¶�·³Àm�CïYïfý^Î

ë�����ñ ��Î�êAÎ 5 ¶�·�¸¿¼¿¶³õ:»Y¼ »YÃqÆ 0�Î ��Î1��»Y½{½�»YÉY¶³·³Î ��ÞYÒÚÞ���ÕSÒgCIÛ:×31CáSÎ&ê�·¿¶�Ãu¸¿ÌÍË�¶Sô #�»Y½Í½0À �sï��fý^Îìþ^¶³Ë�Ç�ÃqÆb�ÆqÌ�¸�ÌÍÇYÃ*Àt�Cï�ïP��Î

ë����³ñ ��ÎVêAÎ 5 ¶�·�¸�¼�¶³õ:»Y¼"»�ÃqÆ%$=Î l ÎuÏ"¼¿Ì�¸�¼�ÌÍõu½ÍÌ{¼³Î � ÞY×�ÞYâÔâÍÕSâ8ÞYßm0 �rØÍáSÒ|×QØgf³ä^ÒyÕO0 �+Û0.�ÖKä^ÒÚÞYÒ|ØÚÛ:ß ����ä . ÕS×QØÚÙ¿ÞYâ�ÄÕSÒ�ÓÁÛ10:áSÎ�ê�·¿¶�Ãf¸�ÌÍË�¶Sô #�»Y½{½ÚÀL�sï���ï=Î?þV¶³Ë³ÇYÃqÆ b�ÆqÌ�¸�ÌÍÇYÃ*À h�¸¿¹q¶³ÃÁ»�þ^Ë�ÌͶ³Ãf¸¿Ì{æÁË�Àm�Cï�ïfý^Î

ë��.�:ñ�è�Î�êAÎ 5 ÌÍ·¿Å�»YÃ*Î��}äVØÔâ 0YØÔßVå �*Õ!ÙSä^×�Õ)ÞYßm0 � ÕSâ\Ø|Þ!f³âÍÕ ��ÕSÒgCIÛ:× 1 � ÖfÖKâ\ØÚÙ¿ÞYÒ|ØÚÛ:ß=áSÎ0��»YÃqÃqÌ{ÃqÉqÀt�sï�ï�ð=Îë��Cü�ñ ��Î b"Î 5 ÇC¾V˳¶�À #�Î�þKÎv��»Y¹=Å »Y¼�¼�»YÃ=ÌÚÀ"»YÃ=Æ h)Î l »YÉ�È=·¿Ãq¶S¾�Î h ·¿¶S¸�·¿ÇY¼¿ºK¶³Ë�¸¿Ì{µY¶(ÇYÊ 5 ¶�Ë!õVÅ�»YÃqÃ÷À

��Ë��rÈ=ÌÍ·¿¶�ÀG»YÃqÆ 2 ÌÍÃq¼o¸�¶³ÃL� ¼ ��Ò0ä 0YØÚÕ!á�ØÔß ÒÔÓÁÕ � Ù!Û:ß÷Û0.�ØÚÙ!á Û`Ý �q×�ÞYß=áyÖÁÛ:×QÒÚÞYÒ0ØÚÛ:ßÁÎ � ÞSÖÁÕS×�áÜØÔß � Õ/.åYØÚÛ:ßKÞYâ �*ÙSØÚÕSß÷Ù!ÕSÀ7� ���� @�fí�[���Yü=À7�5���fí^Î

ë�� ñ ��Î 5 ·�»Y¶�¼¿¼�Î����Â8¶�·�¶³ÌÍÃxê?»Y·¿»YÆqÇsò^Ç�Ãx»YÈq¼�Æ=¶³· �k¶�·¿õ�¶³¹q·�¼¿ºq½Í»YÃuÈqÃqÉqÎ��GßÁÒyÕS×Qß÷Õ!Ó . ÕSß=á�ÝsÛ:×!áCÙ!ÓVäVßVåYÀ�.� ��í5� U�Yð��^ÀL�Cï�ð��=Î�b�ÃqÉ�½{Ìͼ¿¹�¸¿·�»YÃq¼�½�»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�Ì{ÃÑë9�díCñÚÎ

ë��dí:ñ ��Î 5 ·�»Y¶�¼¿¼³Î�´kÃÄ»�ºÁ»Y·�»�ÆqÇsò§ÇYÊ?¸�·¿»�ÿ�Ë�º=½�»YÃqÃ=ÌÍÃqÉqÎ��q×�ÞYß=áyÖÁÛ:×QÒ�ÞYÒ|ØÚÛ:ß �*ÙSØÚÕSß÷Ù!ÕSÀ*ü�ï� � � ð í��=À�����fí^Î

ë��Cð�ñ ��Î �ÜÎ \ »YÃf¸�Ç�·}»YÃ=Æ �ÑÎ��n¶³·¿½Í»=Î�´nº^¸�ÌÍÅ�»Y½�·¿ÇYÈ=¸�Ì{ÃqÉ�ÌÍÃ�»�ºq»YË!õY¶S¸�ôy¼oÐ}Ì{¸¿Ë!¹q¶³Æ�˳Ç�Å�ºqÈ=¸¿¶³·�Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇY·¿õ�Î! � � � �q×�ÞYß=á³ÞVÙSÒ|ØÚÛ:ß=á)Û:ß �+Û0.�ÖKäVÒ`ÕS×�áSÀu��ü������� ����ð���u����ð�ï=Àu�Cï�ý Îë��dý:ñ \ ÎYèÜÎ \ ¹Á»YÈÜ»�ÃqÆ�è�Î��ÄÎ�þ^Ì{Å�ÎVÏ"¹q¶�º=·¿ÌÍË�¶IÇYÊK»�ÃÁ»Y·¿Ë!¹f¾�Ê�Ç�·�Ã=Ç�Ã^ô`»:¸�Ç�Å�ÌÍË?˳ÇYÃqÉ�¶³¼o¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�Éf»YÅ�¶³¼�Ð}Ì{¸¿¹

¼o¾^Å�Å�¶�¸�·�ÌÍË?˳ÇY¼�¸Å�»Yºq¼G»YÃ=Æ)¶³½Í»Y¼�¸¿ÌÍË?Æq¶�Å »YÃ=Æq¼³Î �AÖÁÕS×�ÞYÒ0ØÚÛ:ß=á � Õ!áCÕ¿ÞY×�Ù!Ó � ÕSÒ|Ò`ÕS×�áSÀYüU��Úí�� ü���ý�^üYü À������ü=Î

ë�����ñ #�Î \ ¹=¶³Ã&»YÃ=Æ ÏnÎ10}Ç�ÈqÉ�¹qÉ�»Y·¿Æq¶�Ã*Î l ¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õxÆq¶�¼¿Ì{É�à Ð}Ì�¸�¹xÐI¶�ÌÍÉ�¹f¸�¶�Æìºq½Í»C¾Y¶³·�¼³Îùþ^È=ÂqÅ�Ì�¸¿¸¿¶³Æ*À�����fí^Î

ë��Cï�ñ #�Î \ ¹=¶³Ã*À�ÏnÎ 0�ÇYÈqÉ�¹qÉf»�·¿Æq¶�Ã*À�»YÃqÆ �ÜÎ ��»�½ÍÌ�»�Ãu¸³Î�þ^¹Á»Y·�ÌÍÃqÉ�˳ÇY¼�¸�¼}¸�Ç�Å�ÌÍÃqÌ{Å�Ì{ú³¶�¸¿¹q¶rÌÍÃq¶Sÿ�˳ÌͶ�ÃqË�¾ÇYÊA¼¿¶�½{æÁ¼�¹�Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇY·¿õ�Æq¶�¼¿ÌÍÉYÃ*Î�óyÃ�º=·¿¶³ºq»Y·�»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã÷Àu������ð^Î

ë ����ñ(��Î \ ¹q·�Ìͼ�¸¿Ç^Æ=Ç�Èq½ÍÇYÈ�»YÃqÆ(b"Î�èrÇYÈ=¸�¼�Ç�ÈqºqÌÍ»Y¼³Î?´kÃ�¸�¹=¶�º=·¿ÌÍË�¶nÇYÊA»YÃÁ»Y·�Ë!¹f¾�»YÃqÆ�¼�¸�»YÂqÌͽ{Ì{¸y¾�ÇYÊA˳Ç�·�·¿¶Qô½Í»�¸�¶�Æ�¶�öuÈqÌͽ{ÌÍÂq·�Ì�»)ÇYÊA½ÍÌ{Ãq¶s»�·�˳Ç�Ã=É�¶³¼o¸�ÌÍÇYÃ�Éf»�Å�¶�¼³Î0��»YÃuÈq¼�˳·�Ìͺ=¸³À[�����fí^Î

ë �P�³ñ(��Î \ ¹q·�Ìͼo¸�ÇVÆqÇ�Èq½{Ç�ÈÜ»YÃqÆ b"ÎfènÇ�È=¸¿¼¿Ç�È=ºqÌ�»Y¼�ÎÁÏ"¹q¶}ºq·¿Ì{˳¶�Ç�Ê÷»�ÃÁ»Y·¿Ë!¹f¾�Ç�ÊKæqÃqÌ{¸¿¶�˳Ç�Ã=É�¶³¼o¸�ÌÍÇYÃ�Éf»YÅ�¶³¼³Îóyà � ×!ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:á�Û`Ý}Ò�ÓÁÕ � sÒ�Ó � ßÁßÁä=ÞYâ � � � ��à .�ÖÁÛCáSØÔä . Û:ß �*ÓÁÕ!Û:×Qà�Û`Ý��+Û0.�ÖKä^Ò|ØÔßVå � � ��� � �:ÀºÁ»�É�¶³¼�ðfý�^ýYü=Àu�����fí^Î

ë ���:ñ 0rÎ \ Ç�½{¶YÀ ��Î.�kÇVÆqÌͼ�Àd»YÃqÆrÏnÎ 0}Ç�ÈqÉ�¹qÉ�»Y·¿Æq¶�Ã*Î�ê�·�ÌÍ˳Ì{ÃqÉ"Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õn¶³ÆqÉY¶³¼�Ê�Ç�·*¹q¶S¸�¶³·�Ç�É�¶�Ãq¶³Ç�È=¼A¼�¶³½{æq¼¿¹Èq¼�¶³·�¼³Î�óyà � ×�ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:á Û`Ý�ÒÔÓÁÕ � � ÒÔÓ � ßÁßÁäqÞYâ � � � ��à0.�ÖÁÛCáSØÔä .'Û:ß �*ÓÁÕ!Û:×Qà§Û`Ý �+Û0.�ÖKä^Ò|ØÔßVå� � ��� � �:Àqºq»YÉ�¶³¼�í�� � =íYü��^À������Yü=Î

ë �Yü�ñ 0rÎ \ Ç�½{¶YÀ ��Ît�kÇVÆqÌ{¼³À8»YÃqƦÏnÎ 0}Ç�ÈqÉY¹qÉf»Y·�Æq¶³Ã*Î 5 ÇY¸¿¸¿½Í¶�Ãq¶³Ë!õ�½ÍÌÍÃ=õV¼�ÀKµ�»Y·�Ì�»YÂ=½Í¶�Æq¶³Å�»YÃqÆ*À*»YÃqÆ(¸�¹=¶¸¿·�»YÉ�¶�Æ=¾(Ç�Ê�¸¿¹q¶�Ë�Ç�Å�Å�Ç�Ãq¼�Îróyà � ×�ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:á�Û`Ý�ÒÔÓÁÕ �:ÒÔÓ � ßÁßÁä=ÞYâ � � ��. � ! � � ��à .�ÖÁÛCáSØÔä .Û:ß��rØÍáCÙS×�ÕSÒyÕ � âîåVÛ:×QØÔÒ�Ó .)á � � ��� � �:À�������ð=Î�ÏGÇ�»�ºqº8¶³»Y·³Î

ü��

Page 31: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

ë � ñ 0rÎ \ ÇY½Í¶YÀ ��Îe�kÇ^Æ=Ìͼ³ÀA»YÃqÆÑÏnÎ 0}Ç�ÈqÉY¹qÉf»Y·�Æq¶³Ã*Î #�ÇCÐ Å�È=Ë!¹ Ës»YÃѸ!»:ò^¶³¼�¹q¶³½{º ¼¿¶�½{æÁ¼�¹ ·¿ÇYÈ=¸�Ì{ÃqÉ�m� Û:äV×SßKÞYâ�Û`Ý �+Û0.�ÖKäVÒyÕS×�ÞYßm0 ��àdáSÒyÕ .)á �*ÙSØÚÕSß÷Ù!Õ!áSÀ��5����ð=Î�ÏGÇ�»YºqºK¶s»Y·�Î

ë ��í:ñ 0rÎ \ Ç�Å�Ì{Ãq¶�¸�¸�Ì0À $=Î 0rÎ \ Ç�·¿·�¶s»=À�»YÃqÆ l Î b"Î�þV¸¿ÌͶ�·oô���Ç�¼¿¶�¼³Î l ¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õ�É�»YÅ�¶�¼�Ð}Ì{¸�¹)»�¸�ÇYÅ�Ì{Ë�ºq½�»s¾�¶�·¿¼�Î��»�ÃVÈ=¼¿Ë³·�Ìͺ=¸³À,�����fí^Î

ë �Yð�ñ $=Î 0rÎ \ Ç�·¿·�¶s»=À�h)ÎVþKÎ=þVË!¹VÈ=½ÍúYÀ^»YÃqÆ l Î b"ÎVþV¸¿ÌͶ³· ��ÇY¼¿¶³¼�Î \ Ç�Å�ºqÈ=¸!»:¸�ÌÍÇYÃÁ»Y½=Ë�Ç�Å�ºq½Í¶Qò=Ì�¸y¾�ÀfÊ|»YÌ{·¿Ãq¶�¼¿¼³À»YÃ=Æ�¸¿¹q¶nºq·�ÌÍ˳¶nÇ�Ê�»�ÃÁ»Y·¿Ë!¹f¾�Ç�ÊG¸¿¹q¶nÅ�»:ò^ÌÍÅ�ÈqÅ ½Í»�¸�¶�ÃqË�¾ ºq·¿Ç�Â=½Í¶³Å�Î�óyà � ×�ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:á�Û`ÝkÒ�ÓÁÕ ���:ÒÔÓ�+Û:ßsÝsÕS×�ÕSß÷Ù!ÕkÛ:ß !SßÁÒyÕÚåVÕS× � ×!Û¿åY×�Þ-.�.�ØÔßVå�ÞYßm0��+Û0. f³ØÔßKÞYÒyÛ:×QØ|ÞYâ �AÖKÒ|Ø .�Ø��CÞYÒ0ØÚÛ:ß � ! � ��� �:À�µ�Ç�½{ÈqÅ�¶ü��Yð ÇYÊ � Õ!ÙSÒ|ä^×�Õ ��Û:Ò`Õ!á�ØÔß �+Û0.�ÖKäVÒyÕS× �*ÙSØÚÕSß÷Ù!ÕSÀ^ºÁ»YÉ�¶�¼�íYï =ýYü^Àu����� Î

ë ��ý:ñ $=Î�0rÎ \ ÇY·¿·¿¶³»=À h)Î}þ8Î"þ^Ë!¹uÈq½Íú�À�»YÃ=Æ l Î b"Î"þV¸¿ÌͶ�·n��Ç�¼�¶³¼³Î þ^¶³½�æÁ¼¿¹ù·�Ç�È=¸�Ì{ÃqÉéÌÍà Ës»YºÁ»�˳Ì{¸�»�¸�¶�ÆÃq¶S¸yÐIÇY·¿õu¼³Î �§ÞYÒÔÓÁÕ .�ÞYÒ0ØÚÙ!á)Û`Ý �AÖÁÕS׿ÞYÒ|ØÚÛ:ß=á � Õ!áCÕ¿ÞY×�Ù!ÓVÀu�Yï� � ï�ðU� ^ïfýYð=ÀU����� Î

ë ����ñ $=Î 0rÎ \ ÇY·¿·¿¶³»=ÀKh)Î8þ8Î8þ^Ë!¹uÈq½{úYÀ8»YÃqÆ l Î b"Î÷þu¸�ÌͶ�· ��Ç�¼¿¶�¼³Î�´kÃ�¸¿¹q¶�ÌÍÃq¶Sÿ�Ë�ÌͶ�ÃqË�¾�ÇYÊ�¶³öuÈqÌͽ{ÌÍÂq·�Ì�»�Ì{ÃË�Ç�ÃqÉ�¶�¼�¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�Éf»YÅ�¶³¼�Î�óyà � ×�ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:á�Û`Ý�ÒÔÓÁÕ � �YÒÔÓ �+Û:ßsÝsÕS×�ÕSß÷Ù!ÕrÛ:ß !QßÁÒ`ÕÚåVÕS× � ×!Û¿åY×�Þ-.�.�ØÔßVå�ÞYßm0�+Û0. f³ØÔßKÞYÒyÛ:×QØ|ÞYâ �AÖKÒ0Ø .�Ø��CÞYÒ|ØÚÛ:ß � ! � ��� �:ÀqºÁ»YÉ�¶�¼S�Cðfý�[�\�U��À��5���fí^Î

ë �Yï�ñ h�Î \ ú³ÈqÅ�»dû�Îuþ^¶�½{æÁ¼�¹�·�Ç�È=¸¿ÌÍÃqÉ"Ç�Ãn¸¿¹q¶?óyÃu¸¿¶³·�Ãq¶�¸³Îfóyà $=ÎJx�¶³È=ÃqÉqÀ:¶³ÆqÌ�¸�Ç�·�À��rÞYßm0!fSÛCÛ 1nÛ`Ý �*Ù!ÓÁÕO0YäVâ\ØÔßVå �� âîåVÛ:×QØÔÒÔÓ .)á#" �ÑÛ10VÕSâ á#"IÞYßm0 � ÕS×ÔÝsÛ:× .�ÞYß÷Ù!Õ � ßKÞYâ\àCáSØÍáSÀqË!¹Á»Yº^¸�¶³· �VÎ \ 0 \ ê�·¿¶�¼¿¼�ÀL�5��� Î

ë¢ü���ñ�þ8Î \ Î[�n»�Ê�¶³·�Å�ÇY¼³Î h Å�Èq½{¸¿ÌÍË�·¿Ì{¸¿¶³·�Ì�»)·�Ç�È=¸�¶QôyÅ�Ç^Æ=¶�Ë!¹=Ç�ÌÍË�¶�¸�·¿»�ÿ�Ë�¶�öuÈqÌͽ{ÌÍÂq·�ÌÍÈqÅ Å�ÇVÆq¶³½0Î�óyà � ×�Û0.Ù!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:á�Û`Ý�ÒÔÓÁÕ �÷×�Û:ßÁÒ0ØÚÕS×�áIØÔß �q×�ÞYß=áyÖÁÛ:×QÒÚÞYÒ0ØÚÛ:ß � �³ä^ØÔâ\Øgf³×QØÔä . ÞYßm0 ��äCÖfÖKâ\à �ÄÛ10VÕSâ á ��à0.�ÖÁÛCáSØÔä .�À�Cï��U��Î

ë¢üU�³ñ l Î 0rÎ��k¶�µ�»YÃuÈq·³À l Î �r»Y·¿ÉqÀ 0rÎ�èn¹Á»�ÃqÆq¶³õ:»Y·�À �)ÎYêA»YÃqÆqÌ�¸sÀ h)ÎYþ=»YÂK¶³·¿Ì0ÀY»�ÃqÆ �)Î �)Î ��»�ú³ÌÍ·¿»YÃqÌ0Îuê?·�ÌÍË�¶ÇYÊI»YÃÁ»�·¿Ë!¹f¾�ÀA½ÍÇVËs»Y½{Ì{¸y¾�Éf»Yº*ÀG»YÃ=ÆÑ»�Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õ¦¼¿¶�·�µVÌÍË�¶�ºq·�ÇCµ^Ì{Æq¶³·rÉf»�Å�¶�Î�óyà � ×�ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:á�Û`Ý�ÒÔÓÁÕ�?ØÔ×�áSÒ � ßÁßÁäqÞYâ !SßÁÒyÕS×QßKÞYÒ0ØÚÛ:ßKÞYâ � Û:×31Cá!ÓÁÛ!ÖùÛ:ß !QßÁÒ`ÕS×Qß÷ÕSÒkÞYßm0 ��ÕSÒgCIÛ:×31 � Ù!Û:ß÷Û0.�ØÚÙ!á � � !#� � �:ÀµYÇ�½ÍÈqÅ�¶rü����5�ÜÇ�Ê � Õ!ÙSÒ|ä^×�Õ ��Û:Ò`Õ!á�ØÔß �+Û0.�ÖKäVÒ`ÕS× �*ÙSØÚÕSß÷Ù!ÕSÀ^ºÁ»YÉ�¶�¼ �\� ð [�\�fí�í^À7�����fí^Î

ë¢ü��:ñ 0rÎ 5 Î��kÌÍ»Y½ÚÎ hìÅ�ÇVÆq¶�½Á»YÃqÆ�»Y½{É�Ç�·¿Ì�¸�¹qÅ Ê�ÇY·�Å�Èq½{¸¿ÌÍË�·¿Ì{¸¿¶³·�Ì�»}·¿Ç�È=¸¿¶Sô�Å�ÇVÆq¶�Ë!¹qÇYÌÍ˳¶�Î��q×�ÞYß=áyÖÁÛ:×QÒ�ÞYÒ|ØÚÛ:ß� Õ!áCÕ¿ÞY×�Ù!Ó " �*ÕS×QØÚÕ!á �}Àm�Cü7 � üU��� ^üU�Cð^À,�Cï�ýYï=Î

ë¢ü�ü�ñ�êGÎ.�kÈqÂ8¶S¾�ÎfóyÃq¶Sÿ�˳ÌͶ�ÃqË�¾�ÇYÊ l »�¼¿¹�¶³öuÈqÌͽ{ÌÍÂq·�Ì�»=Î �¦ÞYÒ�ÓÁÕ .�ÞYÒ|ØÚÙ!á}Û`Ý �AÖÁÕS׿ÞYÒ|ØÚÛ:ß=á � Õ!áCÕ¿ÞY×�Ù!ÓVÀ ������.� � �=Àm�sï���ð=Î

ë¢ü ñ h�Î � »�Âq·¿Ì{õ�»�Ãu¸³À:h)Î x�È=¸¿¹q·�»^ÀSb"Î���»�Ãq¶�µ�»=À \ Î #�Î�êA»YºÁ»YÆ=ÌÍÅ�Ì{¸�·�ÌÍÇ�È÷À*»YÃqÆÑþ8Î�$=ÎGþV¹q¶³Ãqõ�¶³·�Î�´kÃÄ»Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇY·¿õ�˳·�¶s»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�Éf»�Å�¶�Î�óyà � ×�ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:á)Û`ÝrÒÔÓÁÕ � �fßm0 � � � ��à .�ÖÁÛCáSØÔä . Û:ß � ×QØÔß÷ÙSØ ÖKâÍÕ!á�Û`Ý�rØÍáSÒ|×QØgf³ä^ÒyÕO0 �+Û0.�ÖKäVÒ0ØÔßVå � � ��� � �:À=ºÁ»YÉ�¶�¼�ü ý�^üfí ��À�������ü=Î

ë¢üfí:ñ 0rÎ � ¶³½{ÆqÅ�»YÃqÃ*À��ÑÎ �r»YÌ{·¿ÌÍÃ=ÉqÀdÏnÎ x �ÈqË!õuÌÍÃqÉqÀ 5 Î���Ç�ÃqÌͶ�Ã*Àf»YÃ=Æ �ÑÎ 0}ÇVÆq¶YÎ�þV¶³½{æq¼¿¹�·�Ç�È=¸�Ì{ÃqÉkÌ{Ã)ÃqÇ�ÃVôË�Ç^Ç�ºK¶³·¿»�¸�Ì�µ�¶�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õu¼�$h ¼�Èq·�µY¶�¾�Îróyà � ×�ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:á�Û`Ý)ÒÔÓÁÕ ����ÒÔÓ !QßÁÒ`ÕS×QßKÞYÒ|ØÚÛ:ßKÞYâ ��à .�ÖÁÛCáSØÔä .Û:ß �¦ÞYÒÔÓÁÕ .�ÞYÒ0ØÚÙ¿ÞYâ �AÛ:äVßm0fÞYÒ0ØÚÛ:ß=á�Û`Ý �+Û0.�ÖKäVÒ`ÕS× �*ÙSØÚÕSß÷Ù!Õ � � � � � �:À�µ�Ç�½{ÈqÅ�¶ ��ý ý Ç�Ê � Õ!ÙSÒ|ä^×�Õ��Û:Ò`Õ!á�ØÔß �+Û0.�ÖKäVÒyÕS× �*ÙSØÚÕSß÷Ù!ÕSÀ^ºÁ»YÉ�¶�¼ �P� íVÀu������ü^Î

ë¢ü�ð�ñ�êGÎc�ÄÎ � ¶�·¿·¿¶�ÌÍ·¿»=Î !QßÁÒ`ÕS×�Ù!Û:ßÁß÷Õ!ÙSÒyÕO0 �+Û0.�.�ä^ßÁØÚÙ¿ÞYÒ|ØÚÛ:ß ��ÕSÒ�CIÛ:×31Cá � ×�Û0/CØÍáSØÚÛ:ß÷ÕO0��*ÕSâ ãá!ÓVâ\à:Î�ê�¹��¸¿¹q¶³¼�Ìͼ³À \ »�·¿Ãq¶�É�ÌͶ ��¶�½Í½ÍÇYà ��ÃqÌ�µ�¶³·�¼¿Ì�¸y¾�À,����� Î

üU�

Page 32: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

ë¢üfý:ñrx�Î?è�Î � ½{¶³Ìͼ�Ë!¹q¶³·�Î x�ÌÍÃq¶³»Y·�¸�ÇY½Í½Í¼�¼¿È=ÿ�Ë�¶ l ¶�Ð Â8ÇYÈqÃqÆq¼�»YÃqÆç»Y½{É�Ç�·�Ì{¸�¹=Å�¼�Ê�Ç�·�¸�Ç�½{½Í¼�ÌÍÃx¼¿Ì{ÃqÉ�½Í¶¼�Ç�Èq·¿Ë�¶�Ã=¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õu¼³Î �*ÓÁÕ!Û:×�ÕSÒ0ØÚÙ¿ÞYâ �+Û0.�ÖKä^ÒyÕS× �*ÙSØÚÕSß÷Ù!ÕSÀqü �78�dôyü�� 4�P�dý�P����í^ÀU�����fíVÎ

ë¢ü���ñrx�Î�è�Î � ½Í¶�Ìͼ¿Ë!¹=¶³·³ÀIè�Î�$�»�ÌÍÃ*À+»YÃqÆ �ÑÎ ��»Y¹qÆqÌÍ»YÃ*ÎçÏAÇY½Í½Í¼�Ê�ÇY·�¹=¶�¸�¶�·¿Ç�ÉY¶³Ãq¶�Ç�Èq¼�¼�¶³½{æq¼¿¹ È=¼¿¶³·�¼ Ì{ÃÅ�È=½{¸�Ì{˳Ç�Å�Å�Ç^ÆqÌ�¸y¾ÄÃq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õu¼�»�ÃqÆ É�¶�Ãq¶³·¿»Y½ÍÌ{ú³¶�Æ Ë³ÇYÃqÉ�¶³¼o¸�Ì{Ç�à Éf»�Å�¶�¼³Îìóyà � ×�ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:á(Û`Ý�ÒÔÓÁÕ��� ÒÔÓ � ßÁßÁäqÞYâ ��à0.�ÖÁÛCáSØÔä . Û:ß �AÛ:äVßm0fÞYÒ0ØÚÛ:ß=á�Û`Ý �+Û0.�ÖKä^ÒyÕS× �*ÙSØÚÕSß÷Ù!Õ � ��� � � �:À�ºÁ»YÉ�¶�¼ ��ý�ý����í^Àu����� Î

ë¢ü�ï�ñrx�Î�è�Î � ½{¶³Ìͼ�Ë!¹q¶³·�»YÃ=Æ \ ÎKþuÐ�»YÅ�¾�Î�ê�·¿Ì{µ�»�¸¿¶n˳Ç�Å�Å�ÈqÃ=ÌÍËs»:¸�ÌÍÇYÃ*À h�ÈqÉ�Èq¼o¸sÀ[������í^Îë ��ñ�þ8Î � Ç�·o¸�ÈqÃ=¶YÀ�$=Î+b"Î #�Ç�ºK˳·�ÇYÊÔ¸sÀ+»YÃqÆ,$=Î 2 ¾V½{½ÍÌͶ�Î¥Ï"¹q¶�ÆqÌ{·¿¶�Ë�¸�¶�Æx¼¿ÈqÂqÉY·�»Yºq¹ç¹qÇ�Å�¶³ÇYÅ�Ç�·�ºq¹qÌ{¼¿Å

ºq·�Ç�Âq½{¶³Å�Î �*ÓÁÕ!Û:×�ÕSÒ0ØÚÙ¿ÞYâ �+Û0.�ÖKäVÒyÕS× �*ÙSØÚÕSß÷Ù!ÕSÀ,����"��� ����� u�.�P��À,�Cï����=Îë �³ñ ��Î � Ç�¸!»YõuÌͼ�À�þ8Î \ Î*èrÇYÃu¸¿Ç�É�ÌÍ»YÃqÃqÌ{¼³À*»�ÃqÆÄêAÎ ��Î�þ^º=ÌÍ·�»�õVÌ{¼³Î�þ^¶�½{æÁ¼�¹ÄÈ=Ãq¼¿ºq½{Ì{¸�¸!»YÂq½{¶Q�ÁÇCÐ}¼�Î �*ÓÁÕ!Û0.

×�ÕSÒ|ØÚÙ¿ÞYâ �+Û0.�ÖKä^ÒyÕS× �*ÙSØÚÕSß÷Ù!ÕSÀÁü �78�dôyü�� 4���Yð P�Yü�ï=ÀP������í^Îë �:ñ b"Î$=Î � ·¿ÌͶ�ÆqÅ�»YÃ*Î �n¶³Ãq¶�·¿ÌÍË�Ì{¸y¾�»YÃqƠ˳Ç�ÃqÉY¶³¼�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�Ë�Ç�Ãf¸�·�Ç�½8Ì{Ã�¼¿¶�½{æÁ¼�¹�·¿Ç�È^¸�ÌÍÃ=ÉqÎ�óyà � ×�ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:árÛ`Ý

ÒÔÓÁÕ � ��× 0 � ßÁßÁä=ÞYâ ! � � � �+Û:ßsÝsÕS×�ÕSß÷Ù!Õ�Û:ß ��Õ!ÙSØÍáSØÚÛ:ß(ÞYßm0 �+Û:ßÁÒ0×�Û:â � � � � �:À^ºÁ»�É�¶³¼ ðYðfý� ð�ý��^À����� Î

ë ü�ñ 0rÎ ��Î ��»�½Í½�»�É�¶³·�Î h Å�ÌÍÃ=ÌÍÅ�ÈqÅ Æq¶�½�»s¾(·�Ç�È=¸¿ÌÍÃqÉ�»Y½{É�Ç�·�Ì{¸�¹=Å È=¼¿ÌÍÃ=É�Æ=Ìͼ�¸¿·¿Ì{ÂqÈ=¸�¶�Ʀ˳Ç�Å�ºqÈ=¸�»�¸�Ì{Ç�Ã*Î! � � � �q×�ÞYß=á³ÞVÙSÒ|ØÚÛ:ß=á)Û:ß �+Û0.�.�äVßÁØÚÙ¿ÞYÒ0ØÚÛ:ß=áSÀ7��í73�.� ýYü P��í^À,�sïfý�ý^Îë � ñ �ÑÎ 0rÎ ��»Y·�¶�¾�»YÃ=Æp��Î^þ8Î $YÇ�¹=Ãq¼¿Ç�Ã÷Î �+Û0.�ÖKä^ÒyÕS×�ánÞYßm0 !QßÁÒ0×�ÞVÙSÒÚÞ!f³ØÔâ\ØÔÒ0à � ��� ä^Øg0VÕ�Ò`Û�ÒÔÓÁÕ��*ÓÁÕ!Û:×Sà

Û`Ý � � . �+Û0.�ÖKâÍÕSÒ`ÕSß÷Õ!á!áSÎ � ·�¶³¶³Å�»YÃ*ÀL�CïfýYï=Îë í:ñ �ÑÎ���Î �nÇ^¶�Å »�Ãq¼³À �)Î�þ8Î ��ÌÍ·�·¿Ç�õuÃqÌ0Àn»YÃqÆ h)Î �?¶�¸�¸!»=Î þ^ÌÍÃqõ&¶�öuÈqÌͽ{ÌÍÂq·�Ì�»é»YÃqÆ Ë³Ç�ÃfµY¶³·¿ÉY¶³ÃqË�¶YÎ

óyà � ×�ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:á�Û`Ý�ÒÔÓÁÕ � :ÒÔÓ � ßÁßÁä=ÞYâ ��à .�ÖÁÛCáSØÔä . Û:ß �GÛ:ä^ßm0fÞYÒ|ØÚÛ:ß=á�Û`Ý �+Û0.�ÖKäVÒ`ÕS× �*ÙSØÚÕSß÷Ù!Õ� ��� � � �:À=ºÁ»�É�¶³¼S� �[�díP��À7�����fíVÎë ð�ñ �ÑÎ��ÑÎ #�»�½Í½ÍÆ �Ç�·¿¼�¼¿Ç�Ã*ÀE$=Î ��Î�#�»�½ÍºK¶³·¿Ã÷À�b"Î x�Î x�ÌÚÀ^»YÃqÆ �)ÎÁþ8Îu��ÌÍ·¿·�Ç�õuÃqÌÚÎ�´kÃ�¼¿ºK¶³ËS¸�·¿È=Å ¼¿¹Á»�·¿ÌÍÃ=É

Éf»�Å�¶�¼³Î�óyà � ×!ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:á"Û`Ý?ÒÔÓÁÕ�� ��× 0 � ßÁßÁäqÞYâ � � ����à0.�ÖÁÛCáSØÔä . Û:ß � ×QØÔß÷ÙSØ ÖKâÍÕ!á"Û`Ý �rØÍáSÒ|×QØgf³ä^ÒyÕO0�+Û0.�ÖKäVÒ0ØÔßVå � � ��� � �:ÀqºÁ»YÉ�¶�¼S���fý�[��� À��5��� Îë ý:ñ h�Î #�»YÈ=·¿ÌͶr»�ÃqÆ�êAÎu��»�·¿Ë³Ç�¸¿¸�¶�Î�´kÃ�¸¿¹q¶n·¿¶�½�»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã=¼¿¹qÌ{º�Â8¶S¸yÐI¶�¶³Ã l »Y¼¿¹Vô \ Ç�Èq·�ÃqÇY¸�»YÃ=Æ 2 »�·¿Æq·�Ç�º

¶�öVÈ=ÌͽÍÌ{Âq·¿ÌÍ»=Î1��ÕSÒgCIÛ:× 1CáSÀm�Cí70ü�� ��ïfí�^ü����=À,�sï��fí^Îë ��ñ ��Î 2 Î #�¶s»Y·�à»YÃ=Æ �ÑÎ 5 Î �nÌͽ{ÆqÌÍ·�ÌÍÅ�Î h&¸�ÇY½Í½=º=·¿ÌÍË�ÌÍÃqÉnÊ�·¿»YÅ�¶SÐIÇY·¿õ)Ê�Ç�·¸¿·�»�ÿ�Ë�»Y¼�¼¿ÌÍÉYÃqÅ�¶�Ãf¸?ºq·¿Ç�ÂVô

½{¶³Å�¼rÐ}Ì�¸�¹Ä¶³½Í»Y¼�¸¿ÌÍË�Æq¶�Å »YÃ=Æ*Πóyà �q×�ÞYß=áyÖÁÛ:×QÒ�ÞYÒ|ØÚÛ:ßéÞYßm0 ��ÕSÒ�CIÛ:×31 � ßKÞYâ\àCáSØÍá �ä^×Q×�ÕSßÁÒ �q×�ÕSßm0:á ���ØÍáCÙ!ÕSâÔâ�ÞYß÷Õ¿Þ�ØÔß ��Û:ß÷Û:×)Û`Ý �(ØÚÙ!Ó=ÞVÕSâ ��âÍÛ:×SØ|ÞYßÁÀ=Ë!¹Á»Yº=¸¿¶³·�ï=Î�èn½ÍÈfÐ+¶³·³À[�5�����^Î

ë ï�ñ�´�Î $�»Y¹=Ã*À�0�Î�� �Ç�¹q·�ÌÍÃqÉqÀ h)Î�þKÎKþ^Ë!¹uÈq½Íú�À�»YÃqÆ l ÎCb"ÎKþV¸¿ÌͶ�· ��Ç�¼�¶³¼³Î+þV¾V¼o¸�¶³Å�ôyÇYº=¸�Ì{Å »Y½8·¿Ç�È^¸�ÌÍÃ=É�ÇYʸ¿·�»�ÿ�Ë,�ÁÇCÐ}¼nÐ}Ì{¸¿¹ÄÈ=¼¿¶³·nË�Ç�Ãq¼o¸�·�»�ÌÍÃf¸�¼rÌÍæÃ=¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õu¼rÐ}Ì{¸�¹¦Ë�Ç�ÃqÉ�¶�¼�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã*Î��AÖÁÕS×�ÞYÒ0ØÚÛ:ß=á � Õ!áCÕ¿ÞY×�Ù!ÓVÀíYü7 � ð���� ^ðU�Cð^À�������í^Î

ëîí���ñ 0rÎ $YÇ�¹Á»Y·�ÌÚÎ � øùÙSØÚÕSß÷ÙSà � ÛCá!á�ØÔß �§ÞY×31fÕSÒ �ÄÕ!Ù!Ó=ÞYßÁØÍá .)á�ÝsÛ:× � Õ!áCÛ:äV×�Ù!Õ � âÔâÍÛCÙ¿ÞYÒ0ØÚÛ:ßÁÎ8ê�¹�� ¸¿¹q¶³¼�Ìͼ�À��óyÏnÀ,����� Î

ü��

Page 33: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

ëîíP�³ñ 0rÎ $YÇY¹Á»Y·¿ÌV»YÃ=Æ $=Î l Î�Ï"¼�Ì{¸¿¼¿ÌÍõu½{Ìͼ³Î 0}Ç�È=¸¿ÌÍÃqÉ�»YÃqÆ�ºK¶³¶�·¿ÌÍÃ=É�ÌÍÃ)»�Ë�Ç�Å�ºK¶�¸¿Ì{¸¿Ì{µ�¶�óyÃf¸�¶�·¿Ãq¶S¸sÎqÏG¶³Ë!¹qÃ=ÌÍËs»�½0}¶³ºKÇ�·�¸G��íYý��=À���óyÏex�ó3�rþ8Àu�����Yü=Îëîí��:ñ 0rÎ�$YÇ�¹Á»�·¿Ì»�ÃqÆ*$=Î l Î*Ï"¼�Ì{¸¿¼¿ÌÍõu½{Ìͼ³Î bÿ�˳ÌͶ�ÃqË�¾(½ÍÇ�¼�¼kÌÍç»�Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇ�·�õ(·¿¶�¼¿Ç�È=·¿Ë³¶�»Y½{½ÍÇVËs»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã�Éf»YÅ�¶YÎ

�¦ÞYÒ�ÓÁÕ .�ÞYÒ|ØÚÙ!á�Û`Ý �AÖÁÕS×�ÞYÒ|ØÚÛ:ß=á � Õ!áCÕ¿ÞY×!Ù!ÓVÀ��Yï�0ü�� �fý� üfí^ÀU����� ÎëîíYü�ñ #�Î�è�»�Å�¶�ÆÁ»=Î?ê�·¿Ì�µY»:¸�¶n˳ÇYÅ�Å�È=ÃqÌÍ˳»�¸�Ì{Ç�Ã*ÀE$YÈqÃq¶YÀ[�5�����^Îëîí ñ h�Î \ ÎÁèr»YºKÇ�·¿Ì{¼³À b"Î=ó!ÎqêGÇ�½ÍÌ�¸�Ç�ºKÇ�Èq½{Ç�È*Àu»YÃ=Æ�êAÎ���ÎqþVºqÌÍ·¿»YõuÌͼ³ÎGÏ"¹q¶kº=·¿ÌÍË�¶kÇYÊGÇ�º=¸¿ÌÍÅ�È=Å ÌÍÃ�þV¸�»YË!õ�ô

¶�½ÍÂK¶³·¿ÉÜÉf»�Å�¶�¼³Î�ÏG¶³Ë!¹qÃqÌ{Ës»Y½ 0}¶³ºKÇ�·�¸}Ï 0 �fídô{�fí�í^À b \ \ \ Àt�����fí^Îëîí�í:ñ(��ÎCèr»Y·�»�õYÇ�¼o¸!»Y¼�»YÃ=Æ)þKÎ �ÜÎsèrÇY½Í½ÍÌ{Ç�ºKÇ�Èq½ÍÇY¼³Îdþ^¶�½{æÁ¼�¹r·¿Ç�È=¸¿ÌÍÃqÉ"Ì{Ãk¸�¹q¶�º=·¿¶³¼�¶³ÃqË�¶+Ç�Ê=¼�ÌÍÆq¶Ë�Ç�Ãq¼o¸�·�»�ÌÍÃf¸�¼�Î

ÏG¶³Ë!¹qÃ=ÌÍËs»�½ 0}¶³ºKÇ�·�¸ \ hnþuô{��ü:ô �Cü:ô �rè�À��k¶³ºÁ»�·�¸�Å�¶³Ãf¸+ÇYÊ \ Ç�Å�ºqÈ=¸¿ÌÍÃqÉ�»YÃqÆ�þVÇYÊÔ¸yÐ�»�·¿¶YÀ7��Ë���»Y¼�¸¿¶³·��ÃqÌ{µY¶³·¿¼�Ì{¸y¾YÀL�5����ü=Î

ëîíYð�ñ(��Î÷èr»Y·¿»YõYÇY¼�¸!»�¼k»YÃqƦþ8Î���ÎKèrÇY½Í½ÍÌ{Ç�ºKÇ�Èq½ÍÇY¼³Î b�ÆqÉ�¶�ºq·¿Ì{˳Ì{ÃqÉ ÇYÊÅ�Èq½{¸¿ÌÍË�Ç�Å�Å�ÇVÆqÌ{¸y¾�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õV¼kÊ�ÇY·¹q¶S¸�¶�·¿Ç�É�¶�Ãq¶³ÇYÈq¼"¼¿¶�½{æÁ¼�¹�Èq¼¿¶�·¿¼³ÎAóyà � ×�ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:á�Û`Ý�Ò�ÓÁÕ ��� Ò�Ó � ßÁßÁä=ÞYâ ��à0.�ÖÁÛCáSØÔä . Û:ß �AÛ:äVßm0fÞ .Ò|ØÚÛ:ß=á�Û`Ý �+Û0.�ÖKäVÒ`ÕS× �*ÙSØÚÕSß÷Ù!Õ � ��� � � �:À^ºq»YÉ�¶³¼ �Yð�� U��ýYð^Àu����� Î

ëîí�ý:ñ�þ8Î \ Î8èrÇYÃu¸¿Ç�É�ÌÍ»YÃqÃqÌ{¼}»YÃqƦêGÎ ��Î8þ^ºqÌ{·�»YõuÌͼ�Î h�¸�Ç�Å�ÌÍËr¼�¶³½{æq¼¿¹(·�Ç�È=¸�Ì{ÃqÉ Ì{Ã�Ã=¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õu¼i h ¼¿Èq·oµ�¶�¾YÎóyà � ×�ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:á Û`Ý�ÒÔÓÁÕ �?ØÔ×�áSÒ � ßÁßÁä=ÞYâ�!SßÁÒyÕS×QßKÞYÒ0ØÚÛ:ßKÞYâ � Û:×31Cá!ÓÁÛ!Ö Û:ß !SßÁÒyÕS×Qß÷ÕSÒ�ÞYßm0 ��ÕSÒ�CIÛ:×31� Ù!Û:ß÷Û0.�ØÚÙ!á � � !#� � �:À÷µ�ÇY½ÍÈqÅ�¶Üü�������Ç�Ê � Õ!ÙSÒ|ä^×�Õ ��Û:Ò`Õ!á�ØÔß �+Û0.�ÖKä^ÒyÕS× �*ÙSØÚÕSß÷Ù!ÕSÀ*ºÁ»�É�¶³¼�ï���ï��������^Àu�����fí^Î

ëîí���ñ���Î h)Î^ènÇ�·¿Ì{½ÍÌ{¼³À�h)Î h)Î xG»�ús»Y·�Àq»YÃqÆ h)ÎÁ´k·�ÆÁ»=Î1h�Ë!¹qÌ{¶�µVÌÍÃ=É�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õ�Ç�º=¸¿ÌÍÅ�»�Èq¼�ÌÍÃqÉ�þV¸!»YË!õ�¶³½{Â8¶�·¿É·�Ç�È=¸�Ì{ÃqÉܼ�¸¿·�»�¸¿¶³É�Ì{¶³¼³Î1! � � ��� � � � �q×�ÞYß=á³ÞVÙSÒ|ØÚÛ:ß=á)Û:ß ��ÕSÒ�CIÛ:×31:ØÔßVåYÀKí73�.� �CðU� [�dýYü=À[�Cï�ï�ý^Î

ëîíYï�ñ b"Î�ènÇ�È=¸�¼�Ç�ÈqºqÌÍ»Y¼�»YÃqÆ \ Î$#�Î�ê�»�ºÁ»YÆqÌ{Å�Ì�¸�·¿Ì{Ç�È*Î 2 Ç�·�¼�¸�ô�Ës»Y¼�¶�¶³öuÈqÌͽ{ÌÍÂq·�Ì�»=Î¥óyà � ×�ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:á�Û`ÝÒÔÓÁÕ �:ÒÔÓ � ßÁßÁäqÞYâ ��à .�ÖÁÛCáSØÔä . Û:ß �*ÓÁÕ!Û:×!ÕSÒ|ØÚÙ¿ÞYâ � áyÖÁÕ!ÙSÒÔá(Û`Ý �+Û0.�ÖKäVÒ`ÕS× �*ÙSØÚÕSß÷Ù!Õ � � � � � � �:ÀµYÇ�½ÍÈqÅ�¶ �díYðYüÜÇ�Ê � Õ!ÙSÒ|ä^×�Õ ��Û:Ò`Õ!á�ØÔß �+Û0.�ÖKäVÒ`ÕS× �*ÙSØÚÕSß÷Ù!ÕSÀ^ºÁ»YÉ�¶�¼ � �sü=ÀL�CïYï�ï=Î

ë¢ð���ñ �)Îþ8Î h�Ã=Ìͽ+èrÈ=Å »Y·�»YÃqÆ �ÑÎ �)ÎH��»Y·�»�¸¿¹q¶YÎ�óyÅ�º=·¿ÇCµ�¶�Æé·¿¶³¼�Èq½{¸¿¼�Ê�Ç�·)þV¸�»YË!õY¶�½ÍÂK¶³·¿É¦¼�Ë!¹q¶³Æ=Èq½ÍÌ{Ãqɼo¸�·�»:¸�¶³ÉYÌͶ³¼�Î�óyà � ×�ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:á�Û`ÝrÒÔÓÁÕ � �YÒ�Ó � ßÁßÁä=ÞYâ !SßÁÒyÕS×SßKÞYÒ|ØÚÛ:ßKÞYâ �+Û:âÔâÍÛ��³äVØÔä . Û:ß � äVÒ`Û0.�ÞYÒÚÞ "� ÞYßVåYä=ÞCåVÕ!á#"�ÞYßm0 � ×�Û¿åY×�Þ-.�.�ØÔßVå � ! � � � � �:ÀGµ�Ç�½{ÈqÅ�¶ �Yü�����ÇYÊ � Õ!ÙSÒ|äV×!Õ ��Û:ÒyÕ!á�ØÔß �+Û0.�ÖKäVÒ`ÕS×�*ÙSØÚÕSß÷Ù!ÕSÀqºq»YÉ�¶³¼�ý�ý�ð =ý��fýVÀ��������^Î

ë¢ðU�³ñ #�Îhx�ÌÍÃ*À�ÏnÎ 0�ÇYÈqÉ�¹qÉf»�·¿Æq¶�Ã*À�»�ÃqÆ �b}Î"ÏA»Y·�ÆqÇ�¼³Î h ¼�¸¿·¿Ç�ÃqÉY¶³·�Â8ÇYÈqÃqÆùÇ�à 5 ·�»�¶³¼¿¼&� ¼�ê?»Y·¿»YÆqÇsò8Îóyà � ×�ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:áÑÛ`Ý�Ò�ÓÁÕ � � Ò�Ó � ßÁßÁä=ÞYâ � � ��. � ! � � ��à .�ÖÁÛCáSØÔä . Û:ß �rØÍáCÙS×�ÕSÒyÕ � âîåVÛ:×QØÔÒÔÓ .)á� � ��� � �:À=ºÁ»YÉ�¶�¼�üYü�ü ^ü�ü À������ Î

ë¢ð��:ñ #�Îcx�ÌÍÃ÷À�ÏnÎ 0}Ç�ÈqÉY¹qÉf»Y·�Æq¶³Ã*À �b"Î�ÏA»Y·¿ÆqÇY¼³À�»YÃ=Æ�h)Î 2 »�½ÍõYÇCµY¶³·³Î 5 ·�»�¶³¼¿¼&� ¼�ê�»Y·¿»YÆqÇsò8À � ÌÍÂKÇ�ÃÁ»YË�˳ÌÃuÈqÅ�ÂK¶³·�¼³À�»�ÃqÆ¥¶Qò=ºKÇ�Ãq¶�Ãf¸�Ì�»�½�Ì{ÃÁ»Yºqº=·¿Çsò^ÌÍÅ�»YÂqÌͽ{Ì{¸y¾YÎ�óyà � ×!ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:á Û`Ý�ÒÔÓÁÕ � �fßm0 � ßÁßÁäqÞYâ !Qß�.ÒyÕS×QßKÞYÒ0ØÚÛ:ßKÞYâ �+Û:âÔâÍÛ��³äVØÔä . Û:ß � ä^ÒyÛ0.�ÞYÒ�Þ " � ÞYßVåYäqÞCåVÕ!á#"ÞYßm0 � ×�Û¿åY׿Þ-.�.�ØÔßVå � ! � � � � �:Àfµ�Ç�½{ÈqÅ�¶üfí5����ÇYÊ � Õ!ÙSÒ|ä^×�Õ ��Û:Ò`Õ!á�ØÔß �+Û0.�ÖKäVÒyÕS× �*ÙSØÚÕSß÷Ù!ÕSÀ^ºÁ»YÉ�¶�¼ ïfý�=í �.�^À��5���fí^Î

ë¢ð�ü�ñ h�Î0��»Y¼oô \ Ç�½Í¶�½Í½0À �ÄÎ���Î 2 ¹qÌÍÃq¼o¸�Ç�Ã÷ÀI»YÃ=ÆG$=Î�0rÎ1�r·�¶³¶�Ã*Î �(ØÚÙS×�ÛCÕ!Ù!Û:ß÷Û0.�ØÚÙ �*ÓÁÕ!Û:×Qà:Î ´�òVÊ�Ç�·�Æ��ÃqÌ{µY¶³·¿¼�Ì{¸y¾�ê�·¿¶�¼¿¼�À��sï�ïfí^Î

ü�ü

Page 34: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

ë¢ð ñ �)Î=þKÎ7��Ì{·¿·�Ç�õuÃqÌ�»YÃqÆch�Î �?¶�¸¿¸�»=Î \ Ç�ÃfµY¶³·¿ÉY¶³ÃqË�¶nÌͼ¿¼�Èq¶³¼+ÌÍÃ�˳Ç�Å�ºK¶�¸�Ì�¸�Ì�µ�¶}Éf»YÅ�¶³¼�Î*óyà � ×�ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:áÛ`Ý�ÒÔÓÁÕ sÒ�Ó !SßÁÒyÕS×QßKÞYÒ0ØÚÛ:ßKÞYâ � Û:×31Cá!ÓÁÛ!Ö Û:ß � ÖfÖK×!Û ��Ø .�ÞYÒ|ØÚÛ:ß � âîåVÛ:×QØÔÒÔÓ .)árÝsÛ:× �+Û0. f³ØÔßKÞYÒyÛ:×QØ|ÞYâ�AÖKÒ|Ø .�Ø��CÞYÒ0ØÚÛ:ß � ×�Û f³âÍÕ .)á � � �� � ��� �:ÀqºÁ»YÉY¶³¼S����ü u�Cï À7����� Î

ë¢ðfí:ñ ��Î���Ç�ÃqÆq¶�·¿¶³·�»YÃ=Æ x�Îþ8Î?þ^¹Á»�ºq½Í¶S¾�ÎéêGÇY¸�¶�Ãu¸¿Ì�»Y½IÉf»YÅ�¶³¼³Î � Þ-. Õ!á�ÞYßm0 � Ù!Û:ß÷Û0.�ØÚÙ �kÕ!Ó=Þ-/CØÚÛ:×QÀ� ��.� �.� [� ü^ÀL�Cï�ïYð=Î

ë¢ð�ð�ñ $=Î � Î l »Y¼�¹*Î l Ç�Ã^ô�˳ÇVÇ�ºK¶³·�»:¸�Ì{µY¶nÉf»YÅ�¶³¼�Î � ßÁßKÞYâ á�Û`Ý �§ÞYÒÔÓÁÕ .�ÞYÒ|ØÚÙ!áSÀ�í "��� 4����ð P�Yïfí^À[�CïfíP�YÎë¢ðfý:ñ h�Î÷´k·�ÆÁ»=À 0�Î 0}Ç�Å�À�»YÃqÆ l Î8þ^¹qÌÍÅ�õuÌÍÃ*Î \ Ç�Å�º8¶S¸�Ì�¸�Ì{µY¶r·¿Ç�È=¸¿ÌÍÃqÉ�ÌÍÃ�Å�Èq½�¸�Ì{Èq¼¿¶�·"˳Ç�Å�Å�ÈqÃqÌ{Ës»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã

Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇY·¿õu¼³Î ! � � � � � � � �=׿ÞYß=á³ÞVÙSÒ|ØÚÛ:ß=á)Û:ß ��ÕSÒgCIÛ:× 1:ØÔßVåYÀL��Úí�� í ��� =í�� ��ÀL�CïYï�ü=Îë¢ð���ñ �ÑÎ�$=ÎK´k¼�Â8Ç�·�Ãq¶�»YÃqÆ(h)Î 0}ÈqÂqÌ{Ãq¼�¸¿¶³Ì{Ã*Î � �+Û:äV×�áCÕrØÔß � Þ-. Õ �*ÓÁÕ!Û:×Qà�Î0��óyÏ ê�·¿¶³¼�¼³À+�Cï�ï Îë¢ð�ï�ñ \ Î #�ÎqêA»YºÁ»YÆqÌ{Å�Ì�¸�·�ÌÍÇ�È*Î h�½ÍÉYÇ�·¿Ì�¸�¹qÅ�¼³ÀuÉf»YÅ�¶³¼�Àq»YÃ=Æ�¸�¹q¶kóyÃf¸¿¶³·¿Ã=¶�¸sÎ�óyà � ×�ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:á�Û`ÝkÒÔÓÁÕ � ��× 0

� ßÁßÁä=ÞYâ � � � ��à0.�ÖÁÛCáSØÔä . Û:ß �*ÓÁÕ!Û:×Qà�Û`Ý �+Û0.�ÖKä^Ò|ØÔßVå � � ��� � �:ÀqºÁ»�É�¶³¼�ý ï�=ý�íYü=À7�����U�YÎëîý���ñ(��ÎGêA¶³·¿»YõuÌͼ�Î�Ï"¹q¶ ºq·�ÌÍË�¶�ÇYÊ�»YÃÁ»Y·�Ë!¹f¾ÄÐ}¹=¶³Ãé˳ÇY¼�¸�¼�»Y·�¶�ÃqÇYÃ^ôy¼�¶³ºÁ»Y·¿»YÂq½{¶ »YÃ=Æ »Y¼o¾^Å�Å�¶�¸�·�ÌÍË�Î�óyÃ

� ×�ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:á�Û`Ý ÒÔÓÁÕ ���:ÒÔÓ �+Û:ßsÝsÕS×!ÕSß÷Ù!Õ�Û:ß !SßÁÒyÕÚåVÕS× � ×�Û¿åY×�Þ-.�.�ØÔßVå§ÞYßm0��+Û0. f³ØÔßKÞYÒ`Û:×QØ|ÞYâ �AÖ&.Ò|Ø .�Ø��CÞYÒ0ØÚÛ:ß � ! � ��� �:ÀqµYÇ�½ÍÈqÅ�¶�ü���ð Ç�Ê � Õ!ÙSÒ0äV×�Õ ��Û:Ò`Õ!á)ØÔß �+Û0.�ÖKäVÒyÕS× �*ÙSØÚÕSß÷Ù!ÕSÀKºÁ»YÉ�¶�¼ ð�=í��=À����� Î

ëîýP�³ñ h�Îhx�Î�êA¶�·¿¶�¼¿¼¿Ì{ÃqÌÚÀ � Î b"Î}þVÈq½Í½{Ì{µ�»YÃ*À"»�ÃqÆ $=Î($=Î ��¹q½ÚÀ-$Y·³Î �*ÓÁÕ �§ÞYÒÔÓÁÕ .�ÞYÒ0ØÚÙ!áÄÛ`Ý ��Û:ßÁâ\ØÔß÷Õ¿ÞY×� ×�Û¿åY×�Þ-.�.�ØÔßVåYÎ?þ^ºq·�ÌÍÃqÉ�¶�·³Àm�Cï����=Î

ëîý��:ñ h�Î \ Î�ê?Ì{É�Ç�È*Î �*ÓÁÕ � Ù!Û:ß÷Û0.�ØÚÙ!á�Û`Ý � ÕSâ Ý�ÞY×�ÕSÎ0��»�˳Å�ÌͽͽͻYÃ*À[�Cï����^ÎëîýYü�ñrx�Î��kÌÍÈ*À ��Î�0rÎ �+»YÃqÉqÀ ��Î��÷¹Á»�ÃqÉqÀ�»�ÃqÆìþKÎIþV¹q¶³Ãqõ�¶³·�Îù´kà ¼�¶³½{æq¼¿¹ ·�Ç�È=¸¿ÌÍÃqɧÌÍÃçóyÃf¸�¶�·¿Ãq¶S¸�ôy½{ÌÍõ�¶

¶�ÃuµVÌ{·¿Ç�ÃqÅ�¶³Ãf¸¿¼³Î�óyà � ×�ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:á�Û`Ý � ! � ��� � ��ÀqºÁ»YÉY¶³¼S�díP� u�Cð��^À7������ü=Îëîý ñ 0rÎ b}Î��kÈÁ»YÃqÆ^¸sÎ h ºq·¿Ç�Âq»YÂqÌͽ{Ìͼo¸�ÌÍË�»YÂq¼�¸¿·�»YËS¸�Å�Ç^Æ=¶�Å�ÇVÆq¶³½0Πóyà ��Ò|ä 0YØÚÕ!á�ØÔß �=׿Þ-/YÕSâ �)Õ .�ÞYßm0 "

� Û:â\ä . Õ !�!QÀ=ºÁ»YÉY¶³¼�ï�� [���Cü=Îu��»:¸�¹q¶�Å »�¸¿ÌÍ˳»=ÀL�CïYðfý^Îëîý�í:ñ h�Î 0�»Yº8ÇYº8Ç�·o¸�»YÃ=Æ h)Î��ÄÎ \ ¹Á»YÅ�Å�»Y¹*Î � ×QØÍáCÛ:ß÷ÕS×�� á �rØÔâÍÕ .�.�ÞYÎ ��ÃqÌ�µ�¶�·¿¼¿Ì�¸y¾)Ç�Ê,��ÌÍË!¹qÌ{Éf»YÃ�ê�·�¶³¼¿¼�À

�CïYðfí^ÎëîýYð�ñ h�Î�0�Ç�Ã=¶³Ã*Î�ê�·¿Ì�µY»:¸�¶n˳ÇYÅ�Å�È=ÃqÌÍ˳»�¸�Ì{Ç�Ã*ÀU��»Y·¿Ë!¹÷ÀL�5�����^Îëîý�ý:ñ 0rÎ 2 Î 0}Ç�¼¿¶�Ãu¸¿¹Á»Y½0Î�h�Ë�½�»Y¼�¼"ÇYÊAÉf»YÅ�¶³¼"ºKÇ�¼¿¼�¶³¼¿¼�ÌÍÃqÉ�ºqÈq·�¶Sô�¼�¸�·¿»�¸�¶�ÉY¾ l »�¼¿¹�¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌÍÂ=·¿Ì�»^Î !SßÁÒyÕS×QßKÞ .

Ò|ØÚÛ:ßKÞYâ � Û:ä^×QßKÞYâ�Û`Ý � Þ-. Õ �*ÓÁÕ!Û:×Qà:Àu�7���� ðfí�^ðfýVÀL�Cïfý�ü=Îëîý���ñrÏnÎ 0}Ç�ÈqÉ�¹qÉ�»Y·¿Æq¶�Ã*Î �k¶�¼¿ÌÍÉYÃqÌÍÃqÉ�Ãq¶S¸yÐIÇY·¿õu¼)Ê�Ç�·r¼¿¶�½{æÁ¼�¹ Èq¼�¶³·¿¼�Ìͼr¹Á»Y·�Æ*Πóyà � ×�ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:á�Û`ÝÜÒÔÓÁÕ

� � 0 � ßÁßÁä=ÞYâ ��à0.�ÖÁÛCáSØÔä . Û:ß �GÛ:ä^ßm0fÞYÒ|ØÚÛ:ß=ánÛ`Ý �+Û0.�ÖKä^ÒyÕS× �*ÙSØÚÕSß÷Ù!Õ � ��� � � �:À�ºÁ»�É�¶³¼ ý��� �U��À�����U��Î � Èq½Í½Kµ�¶�·¿¼¿Ì{Ç�Ã�¸�Ç�»YºqºK¶s»Y·"Ì{à � Û:äV×QßKÞYâ�Û`Ý �+Û0.�ÖKä^ÒyÕS×�ÞYßm0 ��àCáSÒ`Õ .)á �*ÙSØÚÕSß÷Ù!Õ!áSÎ

ëîýYï�ñrÏnÎ�0}Ç�ÈqÉY¹qÉf»Y·�Æq¶³Ã*Î Ï"¹=¶(ºq·¿Ì{˳¶(Ç�Ê�»YÃÁ»Y·�Ë!¹u¾ìÌÍÃìÃq¶S¸yÐIÇY·¿õu¼�Ð}Ì{¸�¹ º8Ç�½�¾VÃqÇ�Å�Ì�»Y½"¶�ÆqÉ�¶¦½�»:¸�¶³Ã=Ë�¾�ÎÏG¶³Ë!¹qÃ=ÌÍËs»�½ 0}¶³ºKÇ�·o¸ �����U��ô ��� ýVÀ \ Ç�·�Ãq¶³½{½ ��ÃqÌ�µ�¶�·¿¼¿Ì�¸y¾�À[�����U��Î

ë�����ñrÏnÎ�0}Ç�ÈqÉY¹qÉf»Y·�Æq¶³Ã*Î+#�ÇCÐ ÈqÃ=Ê|»YÌ{·kÌͼkÇYº=¸�Ì{Å »Y½G·¿ÇYÈ=¸�Ì{ÃqÉ�m óyà � ×�ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:á�Û`Ý)Ò�ÓÁÕ � ��ÒÔÓ � ßÁßÁä=ÞYâ� � ��. � ! � � ��à0.�ÖÁÛCáSØÔä . Û:ß��rØÍáCÙS×�ÕSÒ`Õ � âîåVÛ:×SØÔÒÔÓ .)á � � ��� � �:À^ºÁ»YÉ�¶�¼ ����ü U�5� À��5�����^Î

ü

Page 35: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

ë��U�³ñrÏnÎ�0}Ç�ÈqÉ�¹=Éf»Y·¿Æ=¶³Ã*ÎÑÏ"¹q¶�ºq·¿Ì{˳¶�ÇYÊ�»YÃÁ»�·¿Ë!¹f¾éÌͼ)ÌÍÃqÆq¶�º8¶�ÃqÆq¶�Ãu¸�ÇYÊ}¸¿¹q¶�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·¿õѸ�Ç�ºKÇ�½ÍÇYÉY¾�ÎÄóyÃ� ×�ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:á�Û`ÝÜÒÔÓÁÕ � � ÒÔÓ � ßÁßÁä=ÞYâ � � � ��à0.�ÖÁÛCáSØÔä .#Û:ß��*ÓÁÕ!Û:×Qà¦Û`Ý �+Û0.�ÖKä^Ò|ØÔßVå � � ��� � �:ÀºÁ»�É�¶³¼ ���� üfý^À7�������VÎ?ê?·�¶³½{ÌÍÅ�ÌÍÃÁ»Y·o¾Üµ�¶³·�¼¿Ì{Ç�Ã�Ç�Ê"ë���ü�ñ0Î

ë����:ñrÏnÎ�0}Ç�ÈqÉ�¹=Éf»Y·¿Æ=¶³Ã*Î �*ÕSâ ãá!Ó � Û:äVÒ0ØÔßVåYÎ?ê�¹�� ¸�¹q¶�¼¿Ìͼ�À \ Ç�·¿Ã=¶³½Í½ ��ÃqÌ�µ�¶³·�¼¿Ì�¸y¾�À[�������^Îë���ü�ñrÏnÎ 0}Ç�ÈqÉY¹qÉf»Y·�Æq¶³Ã*ÎÁÏ"¹=¶"ºq·¿Ì{˳¶IÇ�Ê÷»�ÃÁ»Y·¿Ë!¹f¾)ÌͼÌ{ÃqÆq¶³ºK¶³Ã=Æq¶³Ãf¸?ÇYÊ�¸�¹=¶�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õ)¸�Ç�ºKÇ�½{Ç�ÉY¾�Î � Û:ä^×QßKÞYâ

Û`Ý �+Û0.�ÖKäVÒ`ÕS×�ÞYßm0 ��àCáSÒyÕ . �*ÙSØÚÕSß÷Ù!Õ!áSÀÁðfý7"��� ü � ^ü�ð ÀU�����Yü=Îë�� ñrÏnÎ 0}Ç�ÈqÉ�¹qÉ�»Y·¿Æq¶�Ã*ÎIÏ"¹=¶�Å�»:ò^ÌÍÅ�È=Å ½�»:¸�¶³Ã=Ë�¾�ÇYÊ�¼¿¶�½{æÁ¼�¹�·¿ÇYÈ=¸�Ì{ÃqÉqÎ?óyà � ×�ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:á�Û`Ý�Ò�ÓÁÕ � � ÒÔÓ

� ßÁßÁä=ÞYâ � � ��. � ! � � ��à0.�ÖÁÛCáSØÔä . Û:ß �rØÍáCÙS×�ÕSÒyÕ � âîåVÛ:×QØÔÒÔÓ .)á � � ��� � �:ÀsºÁ»YÉ�¶�¼ïfý�ü ^ïfý À��5��� Îë��fí:ñrÏnÎ 0�Ç�È=É�¹qÉf»Y·�Æq¶³Ã÷ÎEþu¸!»YË!õ�¶³½ÍÂK¶³·�É ¼¿Ë!¹=¶³ÆqÈq½{ÌÍÃqÉ¥¼�¸�·¿»�¸�¶�É�ÌͶ�¼³Î � ! � � � Û:äV×SßKÞYâkÛ:ß �+Û0.�ÖKäVÒ0ØÔßVåYÀ

ü�ü78��� ü�ü���^üfí��^À������ Îë���ð�ñrÏnÎ�0}Ç�ÈqÉ�¹=Éf»Y·¿Æ=¶³Ã*Î �*ÕSâ ãá!Ó � Û:äVÒ0ØÔßVå�ÞYßm0�ÒÔÓÁÕ � ×QØÚÙ!Õ�Û`Ý � ßKÞY×�Ù!ÓVà�Î0��óyÏEê�·¿¶³¼�¼³ÀL�����fíVÎë��fý:ñrÏnÎ 0�ÇYÈqÉ�¹qÉf»�·¿Æq¶�Ã*Î^þ^¶³½�æÁ¼¿¹�·�Ç�È=¸¿ÌÍÃqÉ}Ð}Ì{¸¿¹)»�¸¿Ç�Å�ÌÍË�ºq½Í»C¾Y¶³·�¼³Î=óyà � ×!ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:á}Û`Ý+Ò�ÓÁÕ��:ÒÔÓ � ßÁßÁä=ÞYâ

� � ��. � ! � � ��à0.�ÖÁÛCáSØÔä . Û:ß��rØÍáCÙS×�ÕSÒ`Õ � âîåVÛ:×SØÔÒÔÓ .)á � � ��� � �:À^ºÁ»YÉ�¶�¼S����� u�����fí^À7�����fíVÎë�����ñrÏnÎ�0}Ç�ÈqÉ�¹=Éf»Y·¿Æ=¶³Ã*Î�êAÇ�¸�¶³Ãf¸¿Ì�»Y½÷Ê�È=ÃqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ãq¼�»YÃ=Æ�¸¿¹q¶rÌÍÃq¶Sÿ�˳ÌͶ�ÃqË�¾�Ç�Ê�¶�öVÈ=ÌͽÍÌ{Âq·¿ÌÍ»=ÎGóyà � ×�ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:á

Û`ÝrÒÔÓÁÕ !SßÁÒyÕS×QßKÞYÒ0ØÚÛ:ßKÞYâ��+Û:ßVåY×!Õ!á!á)Û`Ý �§ÞYÒÔÓÁÕ .�ÞYÒ0ØÚÙSØ|ÞYß=á � ! � ���:Àu������ð^ÎÏAÇ�»YºqºK¶s»�·³Îë���ï�ñrÏnÎ 0�Ç�È=É�¹qÉf»Y·�Æq¶³Ãx»�ÃqÆ �b"Î�ÏA»Y·¿ÆqÇY¼³Î #�ÇdÐ ÂÁ»�ÆéÌͼ)¼�¶³½�æÁ¼¿¹x·¿ÇYÈ=¸�Ì{ÃqÉ�m � Û:äV×SßKÞYâ"Û`Ý�Ò�ÓÁÕ � � �(À

ï78��� �YüYð U��íYï^À��������^Îë¢ï���ñrÏnÎ 0�Ç�È=É�¹qÉf»Y·�Æq¶³Ã(»YÃqÆ �b"Î÷ÏA»Y·�ÆqÇ�¼³Î 5 Ç�ÈqÃqÆ=ÌÍÃqÉ�¸�¹q¶�Ì{Ãq¶�ÿ�Ë�ÌͶ³Ã=Ë�¾�ÇYÊ?¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌÍÂ=·¿Ì�»�Ì{Ã(ÃqÇ�ÃÁ»:¸�Ç�Å�ÌÍË

Ë�Ç�ÃqÉ�¶�¼�¸�Ì{Ç�Ã�Éf»YÅ�¶³¼³Î � Þ-. Õ!á�ÞYßm0 � Ù!Û:ß÷Û0.�ØÚÙ �kÕ!Ó=Þ-/CØÚÛ:×QÀ ï78��� ü��Yï ��ü^À������ Îë¢ïU�³ñ ��Î^þ^Ë!¹qÅ�¶³Ì{Æq½Í¶�·³Î:b�öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌÍÂ=·¿ÌÍÈ=Å ºKÇ�ÌÍÃf¸�¼�ÇYÊ÷ÃqÇ�ÃÁ»�¸¿Ç�Å�ÌÍË}Éf»YÅ�¶³¼�Î � Û:ä^×QßKÞYâ*Û`Ý ��ÒÚÞYÒ|ØÍáSÒ0ØÚÙ¿ÞYâ � ÓVàdáSØÚÙ!áSÀ

ý7 � 4�Yïfí^ü����=À,�CïfýYü^Îë¢ï��:ñ���Î?þ^¹q¶Sÿ�Î ��×1f!ÞYß �q×�ÞYß=áyÖÁÛ:×QÒ�ÞYÒ|ØÚÛ:ß ��ÕSÒgCIÛ:×31Cá � � �³äVØÔâ\Øgf³×QØÔä . � ßKÞYâ\àdáSØÍá C�ØÔÒÔÓ �¦ÞYÒ�ÓÁÕ .�ÞYÒ|ØÚÙ¿ÞYâ

� ×�Û¿åY×�Þ-.�.�ØÔßVå �ÑÕSÒÔÓÁÛ10:áSÎ?ê�·¿¶�Ãu¸¿ÌÍË�¶Sô #�»Y½Í½0ÀL�Cï��fí^Îë¢ï�ü�ñ �ÑÎ0$=ÎCþ^Å�Ì�¸�¹*Î:Ï"¹q¶?¶Sò^Ì{¼�¸�¶�Ãq˳¶�ÀYÈqÃ=ÌÍöuÈq¶³Ã=¶³¼¿¼A»YÃqÆr¼o¸!»YÂqÌ{½ÍÌ�¸y¾�ÇYÊu¸¿·�»�ÿ�Ë?¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌÍÂ=·¿Ì�»^Î �q×�ÞYß=áyÖÁÛ:×QÒ�ÞYÒ|ØÚÛ:ß

� Õ!áCÕ¿ÞY×�Ù!Ó " � ÞY×QÒ �}Àt�sü� � ��ïfí�^ü�� À,�sïfýYï=Îë¢ï ñ �ÑÎCh�ÎKþ^ÇqÎ?ê�·¿Ì�µ�»�¸�¶nË�Ç�Å�Å)ÈqÃqÌÍ˳»�¸�Ì{Ç�Ã*À7��»Y·¿Ë!¹÷À[�����fí^Îë¢ïfí:ñ�þ8Î�þ^Èq·¿Ì0À \ Î�Ï �ÇY¸¿¹*À�»YÃqÆ ��Î �÷¹qÇ�È*Î)þ^¶³½�æÁ¼¿¹§½{Çf»YƦÂÁ»Y½Í»YÃqË�ÌÍÃqÉ�»�ÃqÆÄ»�¸�Ç�Å�ÌÍË�˳Ç�Ã=É�¶³¼o¸�ÌÍÇYæÉf»YÅ�¶³¼³Î

� âîåVÛ:×QØÔÒÔÓ .�ØÚÙ¿ÞYÀu������ð^ÎÏAÇ�»YºqºK¶s»�·³Îë¢ï�ð�ñ �b"ÎÁÏA»Y·¿ÆqÇY¼³Î \ þ=ð�� ˳ÇYÈq·¿¼�¶�Ã=ÇY¸�¶�¼³Î \ Ç�·¿Ã=¶³½Í½ ��ÃqÌ{µY¶³·�¼¿Ì{¸y¾YÀ[����� Îë¢ïfý:ñ h�Î �?¶S¸¿¸�»=Î l »Y¼¿¹Ñ¶³öuÈqÌ{½ÍÌÍÂ=·¿Ì�»�ÌÍÃÄ˳Ç�Å�º8¶S¸�Ì�¸�Ì{µY¶�¼¿ÇV˳Ì{¶�¸�Ì{¶³¼�À�Ð}Ì�¸�¹Ñ»Yºqºq½{ÌÍ˳»�¸�Ì{Ç�Ãq¼�¸¿Ç�Ê|»YË�Ìͽ{Ì{¸y¾�½ÍÇVËs»:ô

¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã*À�¸�·¿»�ÿ�Ë�·�Ç�È=¸¿ÌÍÃqÉ�»YÃqÆ¥»YÈqË�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã=¼³Î�óyà � ×�ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:á�Û`Ý�ÒÔÓÁÕ � ��× 0 � ßÁßÁä=ÞYâ ��à .�ÖÁÛCáSØÔä .#Û:ß�GÛ:ä^ßm0fÞYÒ|ØÚÛ:ß=á�Û`Ý �+Û0.�ÖKäVÒyÕS× �*ÙSØÚÕSß÷Ù!Õ � ��� � � �:À^ºÁ»YÉ�¶�¼ �Cð ��í^À��5�����^Î

ë¢ï���ñ #�Îqµ�Ç�Ã�þV¸!»�Ë!õY¶³½{Â8¶�·¿ÉqÎ��¦ÞY×31:ÒîÝsÛ:× . äVßm0 � âÍÕSØÚÙ!ÓYåVÕ#C�ØÚÙ!ÓVÒ0Î?þVºq·¿Ì{ÃqÉ�¶³·�Àm�Cï�ü Î

üfí

Page 36: Selfish Routing and the Price of Anarchy - Tim Roughgarden

ë¢ï�ï�ñ 5 ÎqµYÇ�Ã�þV¸�¶�ÃqÉ�¶³½0Î�ê?·�Ì{µ�»�¸¿¶n˳Ç�Å�Å�ÈqÃqÌ{Ës»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�Ã÷ÀA$YÈq½�¾�Àu�5��� Îë�������ñ $=Î �ÜÎ 2 »Y·¿Æq·�Ç�º*ÎAþ^Ç�Å�¶�¸¿¹q¶³ÇY·¿¶�¸¿ÌÍ˳»Y½÷»�¼¿ºK¶³Ë�¸¿¼�ÇYÊ�·�Çf»YÆ ¸¿·�»�ÿ�Ë�·¿¶³¼�¶s»Y·�Ë!¹*Î�óyà � ×�ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:á�Û`Ý�ÒÔÓÁÕ!Qß=áSÒ0ØÔÒ|ä^ÒyÕÜÛ`Ý �Ø /CØÔâ � ßVåYØÔß÷Õ!ÕS×�á#" � Ò ��!/!SÀ=µYÇ�½ÍÈ=Å�¶ ��À=ºÁ»YÉ�¶�¼�ü���í�^üfý5�=ÀL�Cï�í��^Îë����U�³ñ ��Î 2 ¶³Ì�¸�ú�Î�Ï"¹=¶�º=·¿ÌÍË�¶rÇYÊ»�ÃÁ»Y·¿Ë!¹f¾YÎ ��»YÃuÈq¼¿Ë�·¿Ìͺ^¸sÀ,�����U�YÎë������:ñ #�Î �+»YÃ=É�»YÃqÆ #�Î #�Èq»YÃqÉqÎ�Ï"¹q¶�Å�Èq½{¸¿Ì�ô�˳½�»�¼¿¼³ÀYÅ�Èq½{¸¿Ì�ô�˳·¿Ì�¸�¶�·¿Ì�»�¸�·�»:ÿ�Ë�Ãq¶�¸yÐ+Ç�·�õ�¶�öVÈ=ÌͽÍÌ{Âq·¿Ì{ÈqÅ »�ÃqÆ

¼o¾^¼o¸�¶�Å�¼�Ç�º=¸¿ÌÍÅ�ÈqÅ ºq·¿ÇYÂq½Í¶�Å�Î �=×�ÞYß=áyÖÁÛ:×SÒÚÞYÒ|ØÚÛ:ß � Õ!áCÕ¿ÞY×!Ù!Ó " � ÞY×QÒ �}ÀÁü��7��.� � u�dí^À��5��� Îë�����ü�ñ #�Î �+»�ÃqÉ�»YÃqÆ #�Î #�ÈÁ»�ÃqÉqÎ �¦ÞYÒÔÓÁÕ .�ÞYÒ0ØÚÙ¿ÞYâKÞYßm0 � Ù!Û:ß÷Û0.�ØÚÙ �*ÓÁÕ!Û:×Qà�Û`Ý � Û³Þ!0 � ×QØÚÙSØÔßVåYÎ b�½Í¼�¶�µVÌͶ�·

þ^Ë�ÌͶ�Ãq˳¶�ÀL�5���fí^Îë���� ñrx�Î �÷¹Á»�ÃqÉqÎ Ï"¹q¶§¶Sÿ�Ë�ÌͶ�ÃqË�¾ù»�ÃqÆ Ê|»�ÌÍ·¿Ã=¶³¼¿¼�Ç�Ê�»¥æ=ò^¶�ÆEÂqÈqÆ=É�¶�¸�·¿¶�¼¿Ç�È=·¿Ë³¶Ä»Y½{½ÍÇVËs»�¸¿ÌÍÇ�à Éf»YÅ�¶YÎ

óyà � ×�ÛCÙ!Õ!ÕO0YØÔßVå:ákÛ`Ý�ÒÔÓÁÕ�� �fßm0 � ßÁßÁäqÞYâ !QßÁÒ`ÕS×QßKÞYÒ|ØÚÛ:ßKÞYâ��+Û:âÔâÍÛ��³ä^ØÔä . Û:ß � äVÒ`Û0.�ÞYÒÚÞ " � ÞYßVåYä=ÞCåVÕ!á#"ÞYßm0 � ×�Û¿åY×�Þ-.�.�ØÔßVå � ! � � � � �:ÀYµ�Ç�½{ÈqÅ�¶"üfí����kÇ�Ê � Õ!ÙSÒ|ä^×�Õ ��Û:Ò`Õ!á�ØÔß �+Û0.�ÖKäVÒyÕS× �*ÙSØÚÕSß÷Ù!ÕSÀ�ºÁ»YÉ�¶�¼ ��í� ï�ð^À�������í^Î

ü�ð