Top Banner
SELECTION STUDIES Comparison between Ctalk, No Ctalk, first pad selected 22/05/2008 1 Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara
19

SELECTION STUDIES Comparison between Ctalk, No Ctalk, first pad selected 22/05/20081Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara.

Dec 14, 2015

Download

Documents

Yadiel Weir
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: SELECTION STUDIES Comparison between Ctalk, No Ctalk, first pad selected 22/05/20081Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara.

SELECTION STUDIES

Comparison between Ctalk, No Ctalk, first pad selected

22/05/2008 1Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara

Page 2: SELECTION STUDIES Comparison between Ctalk, No Ctalk, first pad selected 22/05/20081Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara.

OUTLINE

22/05/2008 Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara 2

1.B off

Aligned scenario

Misaligned scenario in X:M4Aside=3mm, M4Cside=-6mm

2.B on

Aligned scenario

Misaligned scenario in X:M4Aside=3mm, M4Cside=-6mm

Three differents possibility for each of them (in order of analisys):

1.Ctalk (big pad);

2.No Ctalk;

3.First pad selected;

New geometry and the last version of Gauss, Boole, Brunel are used in all the scenarios . M1-M5 are the fixed stations.

Page 3: SELECTION STUDIES Comparison between Ctalk, No Ctalk, first pad selected 22/05/20081Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara.

22/05/2008 Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara 3

X residual distributions Boff, Aligned

No C

talk first pad

Ctalk

Page 4: SELECTION STUDIES Comparison between Ctalk, No Ctalk, first pad selected 22/05/20081Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara.

22/05/2008 Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara 4

X residual distributions Bon Aligned

Ctalk

No C

talkF

irst pad

Page 5: SELECTION STUDIES Comparison between Ctalk, No Ctalk, first pad selected 22/05/20081Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara.

22/05/2008 Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara 5

Y residual distributions Boff, Aligned

Ctalk

No C

talkF

irst pad

Page 6: SELECTION STUDIES Comparison between Ctalk, No Ctalk, first pad selected 22/05/20081Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara.

22/05/2008 Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara 6

Y residual distributions Bon Aligned

Ctalk

No C

talkF

irst pad

Page 7: SELECTION STUDIES Comparison between Ctalk, No Ctalk, first pad selected 22/05/20081Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara.

22/05/2008 Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara 7

X residual distributions Boff, Misaligned

Ctalk

No C

talkF

irst pad

Page 8: SELECTION STUDIES Comparison between Ctalk, No Ctalk, first pad selected 22/05/20081Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara.

22/05/2008 Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara 8

X residual distributions Bon, Misaligned

Ctalk

No C

talkF

irst pad

Page 9: SELECTION STUDIES Comparison between Ctalk, No Ctalk, first pad selected 22/05/20081Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara.

22/05/2008 Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara 9

Y residual distributions Boff, Misaligned

Ctalk

No C

talkF

irst pad

Page 10: SELECTION STUDIES Comparison between Ctalk, No Ctalk, first pad selected 22/05/20081Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara.

22/05/2008 Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara 10

Y residual distributions Bon, Misaligned

Ctalk

No C

talkF

irst pad

Page 11: SELECTION STUDIES Comparison between Ctalk, No Ctalk, first pad selected 22/05/20081Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara.

B off, A

ligned, first pad, Ctalk

22/05/2008 Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara 11

M5

M4

M3

Page 12: SELECTION STUDIES Comparison between Ctalk, No Ctalk, first pad selected 22/05/20081Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara.

22/05/2008 Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara 12

B on, A

ligned, first pad, Ctalk

M5

M4

M3

Page 13: SELECTION STUDIES Comparison between Ctalk, No Ctalk, first pad selected 22/05/20081Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara.

B off, Misaligned, first pad (R1 black, R2 red, R3 green, R4 blue), Ctalk the others one in each region 1/2

22/05/2008 Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara 13

Page 14: SELECTION STUDIES Comparison between Ctalk, No Ctalk, first pad selected 22/05/20081Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara.

22/05/2008 Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara 14

B off, Misaligned, first pad (R1 black, R2 red, R3 green, R4 blue), Ctalk the others one in each region 2/2

Page 15: SELECTION STUDIES Comparison between Ctalk, No Ctalk, first pad selected 22/05/20081Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara.

B on, Misaligned, first pad (R1 black, R2 red, R3 green, R4 blue), Ctalk the others one in each region 1/2

22/05/2008 Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara 15

Page 16: SELECTION STUDIES Comparison between Ctalk, No Ctalk, first pad selected 22/05/20081Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara.

22/05/2008 Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara 16

B on, Misaligned, first pad (R1 black, R2 red, R3 green, R4 blue), Ctalk the others one in each region 2/2

Page 17: SELECTION STUDIES Comparison between Ctalk, No Ctalk, first pad selected 22/05/20081Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara.

# Of tracks comparison

22/05/2008 Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara 17

  B off Aligned B off Misaligned B on Aligned B on Misaligned

Region Ctalk No Ctalk % Ctalk No Ctalk % Ctalk No Ctalk % Ctalk No Ctalk %

R1 5416 2536 46 5344 2493 46 5518 2325 42 10846 4565 42

R2 15357 7427 48 15426 7443 48 19340 8120 42 38465 16187 42

R3 40804 16037 40 40838 15938 39 52800 16062 30 103267 31922 32

R4 80869 52317 65 81268 56640 70 101536 58372 57 200793 116268 58

The total number of processed tracks are not the same for all the cases

Page 18: SELECTION STUDIES Comparison between Ctalk, No Ctalk, first pad selected 22/05/20081Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara.

RESULTS FROM THE COMPARISONS

Case Ctalk No Ctalk First pad

X, B off, Aligned Ok

X, B on, Aligned Ok

Y, B off, Aligned Ok

Y, B on, Aligned Ok

X, B off, Misaligned

Ok

X, B on, Misaligned

Ok

Y, B off, Misaligned

Ok

Y, B on, Misaligned

Ok

22/05/2008 Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara 18

But I think that rebbining for the chamber dimensions in the case of Y, we can use the Ctalk (big pad) without troubles

Page 19: SELECTION STUDIES Comparison between Ctalk, No Ctalk, first pad selected 22/05/20081Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara.

CONCLUSIONS

• I think that the best selection for us is to use the “PADONE” for several reasons:

- Shape of X (Y rebbining) residual distributions

- Number of tracks respect No Ctalk selection

22/05/2008 Simone Brusa, INFN-Ferrara 19