ORIGINAL PAPER Sedimentary evolution of the Mesozoic continental redbeds using geochemical and mineralogical tools: the case of Upper Triassic to Lowermost Jurassic Monte di Gioiosa mudrocks (Sicily, southern Italy) Francesco Perri • Salvatore Critelli • Giovanni Mongelli • Robert L. Cullers Received: 16 December 2009 / Accepted: 19 September 2010 Ó Springer-Verlag 2010 Abstract The continental redbeds from the Internal Domains of the central-western Mediterranean Chains have an important role in the palaeogeographic and palaeotec- tonic reconstructions of the Alpine circum-Mediterranean orogen evolution since these redbeds mark the Triassic- Jurassic rift-valley stage of Tethyan rifting. The composi- tion and the sedimentary evolution of the Middle Triassic to Lowermost Jurassic continental redbeds of the San Marco d’Alunzio Unit (Peloritani Mountains, Southern Italy), based on mineralogical and chemical analyses, suggests that the studied mudrock sediments share common features with continental redbeds that constitute the Inter- nal Domains of the Alpine Mediterranean Chains. Phyllo- silicates are the main components in the mudrocks. The 10 A ˚ -minerals (illite and micas), the I–S mixed layers, and kaolinite are the most abundant phyllosilicates. The amount of illitic layers in I–S mixed layers coupled with the illite crystallinity values (IC) are typical of high degree of diagenesis, corresponding to a lithostatic/tectonic load- ing of about 4–5 km. The mineralogical assemblage cou- pled with the A-CN-K plot suggest post-depositional K-enrichments. Palaeoweathering proxies (PIA and CIW) record intense weathering at the source area. Further, the studied sediments are affected by reworking and recycling processes and, as consequence, it is likely these proxies monitor cumulative effect of weathering. The climate in the early Jurassic favoured recycling and weathering occurred under hot, episodically humid climate with a prolonged dry season. The source-area is the low-grade Paleozoic metasedimentary basement. Mafic supply is minor but not negligible as suggested by provenance proxies. Keywords Mesozoic continental redbeds Á Mudrocks Á Provenance Á Source-area weathering Á Southern Italy Á Recycling Introduction After the Hercynian orogeny, and starting from the Trias- sic, the western Mediterranean region was fragmented by rifting and transform faulting, giving rise to the western Tethyan Ocean, and several new lithospheric plates (Biju- Duval et al. 1977). One of these lithospheric plates was the Mesomediterranean Microplate (Guerrera et al. 1993), comprising the internal zones of the Betic–Rif, Tellian, Kabylian, Calabria–Peloritani and Southern Apennine chains, built up after the alpine compressive Tertiary phase related to the Mediterranean opening. The continental rift- valley phase and the proto-oceanic phase of the Tethyan rifting in the western-central Mediterranean region play an important role for the deposition of the continental redbeds, which mark the base of the Meso-Cenozoic sedimentary covers. In fact, in many internal units of the Betic (Spain), Rif (Morocco), Tell (Algeria), and Apenninic (Italy) chains, the onset of Mesozoic-to-Cenozoic sedimentation was marked by deposition of these continental clastic sediments. F. Perri (&) Á S. Critelli Dipartimento di Scienze della Terra, Universita ` degli Studi della Calabria, 87036 Arcavacata di Rende, CS, Italy e-mail: [email protected]G. Mongelli Dipartimento di Chimica, Universita ` degli Studi della Basilicata, Campus di Macchia Romana, 85100 Potenza, Italy R. L. Cullers Department of Geology, Kansas State University, 108 Thompson Hall, Manhattan, KS 66506-3201, USA 123 DOI 10.1007/s00531-010-0602-6 Int J Earth Sci (Geol Rundsch) (2011) 100:1569–1587 / Published online: 19 October 2010
19
Embed
Sedimentary evolution of the Mesozoic continental redbeds using geochemical and mineralogical tools: the case of Upper Triassic to Lowermost Jurassic Monte di Gioiosa mudrocks (Sicily,
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
ORIGINAL PAPER
Sedimentary evolution of the Mesozoic continental redbeds usinggeochemical and mineralogical tools: the case of Upper Triassicto Lowermost Jurassic Monte di Gioiosa mudrocks(Sicily, southern Italy)
Francesco Perri • Salvatore Critelli •
Giovanni Mongelli • Robert L. Cullers
Received: 16 December 2009 / Accepted: 19 September 2010
� Springer-Verlag 2010
Abstract The continental redbeds from the Internal
Domains of the central-western Mediterranean Chains have
an important role in the palaeogeographic and palaeotec-
tonic reconstructions of the Alpine circum-Mediterranean
orogen evolution since these redbeds mark the Triassic-
Jurassic rift-valley stage of Tethyan rifting. The composi-
tion and the sedimentary evolution of the Middle Triassic
to Lowermost Jurassic continental redbeds of the San
Marco d’Alunzio Unit (Peloritani Mountains, Southern
Italy), based on mineralogical and chemical analyses,
suggests that the studied mudrock sediments share common
features with continental redbeds that constitute the Inter-
nal Domains of the Alpine Mediterranean Chains. Phyllo-
silicates are the main components in the mudrocks. The
10 A-minerals (illite and micas), the I–S mixed layers,
and kaolinite are the most abundant phyllosilicates. The
amount of illitic layers in I–S mixed layers coupled with
the illite crystallinity values (IC) are typical of high degree
of diagenesis, corresponding to a lithostatic/tectonic load-
ing of about 4–5 km. The mineralogical assemblage cou-
pled with the A-CN-K plot suggest post-depositional
K-enrichments. Palaeoweathering proxies (PIA and CIW)
record intense weathering at the source area. Further, the
studied sediments are affected by reworking and recycling
processes and, as consequence, it is likely these proxies
monitor cumulative effect of weathering. The climate in
the early Jurassic favoured recycling and weathering
occurred under hot, episodically humid climate with a
prolonged dry season. The source-area is the low-grade
Paleozoic metasedimentary basement. Mafic supply is
minor but not negligible as suggested by provenance
In the M.te di Gioiosa section the continental sediments
are particularly thick (over 100 m) and they are well
exposed. The sedimentary succession is characterized by
Upper Triassic lenticular conglomerate and sandstone
strata, representing fluvial channel-fill, interbedded with
thin clay layers (Fig. 3). The main lithofacies are fine
grained, represented by massive and laminated sandy
mudstones and siltstone beds, associated with stratified,
graded or rarely massive sandstone stratal-sets (Fig. 3a and
b); their internal structures are normal grading, parallel
laminae, sinusoidal ripples and cross-laminae. The silici-
clastic deposits show small-scale cross lamination and
small channels, characterized by variations in grain size
with quartz-grain commonly rounded that indicates
reworking. Decimetre-thick to metre-thick, sheet-like
massive sandstones are frequently alternated with thin-
bedded mudstones and siltstones (Fig. 3c). Palaeocurrents
indicate a dominant terrigenous clastic rocks supply
derived from rapid erosion of highland area located to the
north, northwestern and western of the present-day
Fig. 1 a Geological sketch map of the Peloritani Thrust Belt
(Southern Sector of the Calabria-Peloritani Arc—CPA). Legend: 1Etna volcanics (Pleistocene-Holocene). 2 Alluvial and coastal
deposits (Holocene) and Pleistocene-Miocene deposits. 3 Calcarenitidi Floresta Fm. (Serravallian-Langhian) and ‘‘Antisicilide Variegated
Clays’’ (upper Cretaceous-Paleogene). 4 Aspromonte Unit (Paleo-
zoic). 5 Mela Unit (Paleozoic). 6 Mandanici Unit (Mesozoic
sedimentary cover and Paleozoic basement). 7 Alı Unit (Mesozoic
sedimentary cover and Paleozoic basement). 8 Fondachelli Unit(Mesozoic sedimentary cover and Paleozoic basement). 9 Epimeta-
morphic units and their Meso-Cenozoic sedimentary cover (SanMarco d’Alunzio, Longi-Taormina and Capo Sant’Andrea Units). 10Sampling area. 11 Stratigraphic contact. 12 Tectonic contact.
Modified after Messina et al. 2004. b Detailed geological map of
M.te di Gioiosa area and location of the studied samples (San Marco
d’Alunzio Unit). Modified after Lentini et al. (2000)
123
Int J Earth Sci (Geol Rundsch) (2011) 100:1569–1587 1571
The average LaN/YbN ratio and the Eu anomaly sizes are the
same as those of the PAAS (LaN/YbN = 9.2; Eu/Eu*PAAS =
0.66). Rare earth elements and yttrium, which behave like
heavy rare earth elements (HREE), show no correlation
with Al2O3; this is consistent with the observation that in
fine grained sediments these elements may be hosted in
accessory phases (Mongelli et al. 1996, 2006).
Discussion
Source-area weathering, sorting and recycling
Variable degrees of weathering in source areas may have
an important influence on the abundances of alkali and
alkaline-earth elements in siliciclastic sediments. Rubidium
and barium are often fixed in weathering profiles, whereas,
cations with smaller ionic radii, such as Na, Ca and Sr, are
easily removed from weathering profiles (Nesbitt et al.
1980).
A common approach to quantifying the degree of
source-area weathering is to use the chemical index of
alteration (CIA; Nesbitt and Young 1982). The chemical
compositions of studied samples are plotted as molar pro-
portions within Al2O3, CaO*?Na2O, K2O (A-CN-K)
compositional space, where CaO* represents Ca in silicate-
bearing minerals only. The CIA values of analyzed mud-
rocks are homogeneous (average = 70.1 ± 3.1) and in the
A-CN-K triangular diagram the samples plot in a tight
group on the A-K join close to the muscovite-illite point
(Fig. 7). Illite and other illitic minerals (I/S mixed layers)
are the dominant clay minerals that characterize the studied
mudrocks. The weathering trend for Upper Archean crust,
predicted from kinetic leach rates (Nesbitt and Young
1984; Nesbitt 1992), is directed towards the processes of
illitization (Fig. 7 point 1; e.g., Fedo et al. 1995). The
studied mudrocks plot below this trend since many samples
contain considerable K2O because they may have under-
gone K metasomatism (Nesbitt 1992). Both the amount of
K enrichment and the palaeoweathering index prior to such
enrichment can be ascertained from the A-CN-K plot. As K
involves addition of K2O to aluminous clays, the studied
samples follow a path toward the K2O apex of the triangle,
and the line from the K apex through the mudrock samples
Fig. 5 Normalization of major and trace elements to upper conti-
nental crust averages (after McLennan et al. 2006; diagram after
Floyd et al. 1989). The plot of the Post-Archean Australian Shales
(PAAS; Taylor and McLennan 1985) is shown for comparison
Fig. 6 Rare earth element compositional ranges, chondrite-normal-
ized (Taylor and McLennan 1985). The plot of the Post-Archean
Australian Shales (PAAS) is shown for comparison
Fig. 7 A-CN-K diagram (Nesbitt and Young 1982) for studied
samples. Studied samples are probably related to a initial weathering
trend (point 1) and subsequent a metasomatic trend (arrow 3) to attain
their current position. Point 2 is the probably CIA of weathered
residues (before metasomatism). Note only top 60% of the triangle is
shown. Legend: A, Al2O3; C, CaO; N, Na2O; K, K2O; Gr granite; Msmuscovite; Il illite; Ka kaolinite; Ch chlorite; Gi gibbsite; Smsmectite; Bi biotite; Ks K-feldspar; Pl plagioclase. UC Upper Archean
Crust (Condie 1993)
123
Int J Earth Sci (Geol Rundsch) (2011) 100:1569–15871580
intersects the predicted weathering trend at a point repre-
senting its premetasomatized composition (Fig. 7, arrow 3
and point 2). The palaeoweathering index corrected for K
enrichment can then be determined by reading off the CIA
value, and the premetasomatized CIA value of 80 indicates
that the studied mudrocks have gained about 10% K2O
during metasomatism (e.g., Fedo et al. 1995).
Since the CIA index is not sensitive to the weathering
degree when K reintroduction occurs in the system, as in the
present case, alternative indices can be used to monitor
palaeoweathering at the source. Harnois (1988) proposed the
CIW index (Chemical Index of Weathering), which is not
sensitive to post-depositional K-enrichments. The CIW
similarly to the CIA, is a molecular immobile/mobile ratio
based on the assumption that Al remains in the system and
accumulates in the residue while Ca and Na are leached
away. The studied mudrocks show very uniform CIW values
(average = 97.7 ± 0.7). This indicates a source area with
intense weathering in steady-state conditions where material
removal rate matches the production of mineralogically
uniform weathering products generated in the upper zone of
soil development (Nesbitt et al. 1997). Furthermore, the
mudrocks show high PIA (Plagioclase Index of Alteration;
Fedo et al. 1995) values (average = 96.2 ± 1.1) that indi-
cate intense weathering at the source area and that most of
the plagioclase has been converted to clay minerals.
The presence of sorting-related fractionations is evalu-
ated when the Zr/Sc ratio (a useful index of sediment
recycling; e.g. Cox et al. 1995; Hassan et al. 1999), is
plotted against the Th/Sc ratio (indicator of chemical dif-
ferentiation; McLennan et al. 1993). The mudrocks are not
clustered along the primary compositional trend but fall
along a trend involving zircon addition and thus sediment
recycling (Fig. 8).
Constraints on provenance
The geochemical signatures of clastic sediments have
been used to find out provenance (Taylor and McLennan
1985; Condie et al. 1992; Cullers 1995; Madhavaraju
and Ramasamy 2002; Armstrong-Altrin et al. 2004).
Rare earth elements (REE) and Th, among the HFSE,
and some transition elements, including Sc and Cr, can
provide an insight into the provenance and are thus
useful to constrain the average source-area composition
(e.g., Taylor and McLennan 1985; Floyd et al. 1989;
McLennan et al. 1993; Fedo et al. 1996; Cullers and
Berendsen 1998). The abundance of Cr and Ni in silic-
iclastic sediments is considered as a useful indicator in
provenance studies. According to Wrafter and Graham
(1989) a low concentration of Cr indicates a felsic
provenance, whereas high contents of Cr and Ni are
mainly found in sediments derived from ultramafic rocks
(Armstrong-Altrin et al. 2004). The Cr/Ni ratios (aver-
age = 2.76) are low for the studied mudrocks. However,
the Th/Cr ratio (average = 0.16) is quite similar to the
PAAS (Th/Cr = 0.13; Taylor and McLennan 1985) and
to the UCC (Th/Cr = 0.13; McLennan et al. 2006).
Ratios such as La/Sc, Th/Sc, Th/Co, and Th/Cr are
significantly different in felsic and basic rocks and may
allow constraints on the average provenance composition
(Wronkiewicz and Condie 1990; Cox et al. 1995; Cullers
1995). The Th/Sc, Th/Co, Th/Cr, Cr/Th, and La/Sc ratios
of shales from this study are compared with those of
sediments derived from felsic and basic rocks as well as
to upper continental crust (UCC; McLennan et al. 2006)
and PAAS (Taylor and McLennan 1985) values
(Table 3). This comparison also suggests that these ratios
are within the range of felsic rocks. In addition, the La/
Sc and Th/Sc ratios are fairly constant in sedimentary
rocks (2.4 and 0.9, respectively; Taylor and McLennan
1985). The La/Sc and Th/Sc ratios of the studied mud-
rocks are close to those of the PAAS and UCC
(Table 3), suggesting a felsic nature of the source rocks.
This agrees with petrographic data obtained from the
sandstones interbedded between the studied mudrocks,
which are quartzarenite-to-quartzolithic in composition
(Critelli et al. 2008). They are characterized by abundant
monocrystalline and polycrystalline quartz, whereas feld-
spars are minor or absent. Sandstone suites plot within the
provenance fields for both continental blocks and recycled
orogens (Critelli et al. 2008).
Provenance proxies including triangular relationships
of Th-Sc-Zr and the Cr/V and Y/Ni ratios have been also
used to discriminate the source area composition and the
tectonic setting. The Th-Sc-Zr/10 diagram (Fig. 9) may be
used to discriminate sediments from felsic sources to
progressively more mafic sources (e.g., Bhatia and Crook
Fig. 8 Th/Sc vs. Zr/Sc plot (after McLennan et al. 1993). Samples
depart from the compositional trend indicating zircon addition
suggestive of a recycling effect. Rock average compositions (Rhy-
olite, Dacite and Andesite) are from Lacassie et al. (2006)
123
Int J Earth Sci (Geol Rundsch) (2011) 100:1569–1587 1581
1986; Cullers 1994). In this diagram the studied mudrocks
plot in the silicic rock field, close to the PAAS and UCC
point (Fig. 9). Moreover, the studied samples follow a
trend towards a continental environment, far from the
oceanic arc-related field suggesting a mainly felsic source.
The Cr/V ratio is an index of the enrichment of Cr over the
other ferromagnesian trace elements, whereas Y/Ni moni-
tors the general level of ferromagnesian trace elements (Ni)
compared to a proxy for HREE (Y). Mafic–ultramafic
sources tend to have high ferromagnesian abundances; such
a provenance would result in a decrease in Y/Ni (e.g.,
Hiscott 1984; McLennan et al. 1993). At the same time,
high values in Sc/Th are related to a mafic–ultramafic
supply. The Cr/V vs. Sc/Th and Cr/V vs. Y/Ni diagram
(Hiscott 1984) indicates the lack of a marked mafic–
ultramafic detritus input for the studied samples (Fig. 10).
The Eu/Eu*, a more conservative provenance proxy
(e.g. McLennan et al. 1993; Mongelli et al. 1998; Cullers
2000), vs. LaN/YbN plot add insights on the chemical
affinity when studied samples are compared to the base-
ment terranes (Messina et al. 2004). The mudrocks are
generally similar in composition to the felsic rocks of the
Paleozoic basement (Fig. 11) and only few have higher Eu/
Eu*. Moreover, a minor contribution from a mafic com-
ponent may be assumed in few samples, as deduced by the
amount of Sc and Nb. These values, however, are lower
than the Sc and Nb values of the amphibole-rich basement
terranes (Messina et al. 2004). Furthermore, the Eu
anomaly is not correlated with both the Sc and the Nb
values. Thus, the higher values of the Eu/Eu* proxy
observed in few samples, likely record a mixed source
including felsics and a definitely minor imput of mafic
detritus.
An estimation of the composition of sedimentary rocks
can be showed using the ratios Nb/Y vs. Zr/Ti (after
Winchester and Floyd 1977; Fralick 2003; Zimmermann
and Spalletti 2009; Fig. 12) as these elements are strongly
immobile. Most of the studied samples fall in the rhyoda-
cite/dacite composition. They are partly enriched in Nb
over Y following a rhyolitic/dacitic trend, although some
samples seems to be influenced by a mafic input as showed
by the andesitic/basaltic trend (Fig. 12). This points to the
Table 3 Range of elemental ratios of studied samples compared to the ratios those of felsic and mafic rocks, upper continental crust (UCC;
McLennan et al. 2006), and Post-Archean Australian shale (PAAS; Taylor and McLennan 1985)
Elemental ratio Range of studied
mudrocks
Range of sedimentsa Upper continental crustb Post-Archean Australian
average shalec
Felsic rocks Mafic rocks
La/Sc 3.45 ± 0.77 2.5–16.3 0.43–0.86 2.21 2.4
Th/Sc 0.87 ± 0.20 0.84–20.5 0.05–0.22 0.79 0.9
Th/Co 0.78 ± 0.19 0.67–19.4 0.04–1.4 0.64 0.63
Th/Cr 0.16 ± 0.04 0.13–2.7 0.43–0.86 0.13 0.13
Cr/Th 6.63 ± 1.51 4.00–15 25–500 7.69 7.53
a Cullers (1994, 2000), Cullers and Podkovyrov (2000), bMcLennan et al. (2006), cTaylor and McLennan (1985)
Fig. 9 Th-Sc-Zr/10 diagram (after Bhatia and Crook 1986). The
mudrocks fall in a region close to the PAAS and the UCC point that
rules out important mafic supply
Fig. 10 Analysing the provenance by using relations of Cr/V vs. Sc/
Th and Cr/V vs. Y/Ni (after Hiscott 1984). Curve model mixing
between granite and ultramafic end-members. Ultramafic sources
have very low Y/Ni and high Cr/V and Sc/Th ratios. Arrows indicate
the direction of the mafic–ultramafic source end-members
123
Int J Earth Sci (Geol Rundsch) (2011) 100:1569–15871582
mixing of a closely related volcanic detritus or mafic
component with a typical UCC (‘granitic’) source. The
source of the felsic-to-intermediate volcanic detritus is
might be related to some units that characterize the base-
ment rocks (e.g., metavolcanic rocks of the Mandanici,
Longi-Taormina, San Marco d’Alunzio and Capo San-
t’Andrea basements; Fig. 1 and Fig. 13). The felsic input is
explainable by the regional geology and the palaeogeo-
graphic evolution (Fig. 13) of the rocks that nowadays
characterize the paleozoic basement of the Internal
Domains of the Alpine central-western Mediterranean
Chains involved in the Meso-Cenozoic basin evolution
(e.g., Perrone et al. 2006; Mongelli et al. 2006; Critelli
et al. 2008; Perri 2008; Perri et al. 2008a, b).
Conclusions
The chemical and mineralogical composition of the studied
terrigenous sediments depends on the source-area compo-
sition, palaeoweathering, sorting and recycling processes
and in some cases, burial history. Thus, these processes
must be evaluated and hopefully minimized to monitor
provenance.
The geochemistry and mineralogy of Mesozoic conti-
nental mudrocks from the M.te di Gioiosa stratigraphic
section of the Peloritani Mountains suggest a complex
history. The mudrocks have concentrations very similar to
those of the UCC (McLennan et al. 2006) for Si, Ti, Al, Fe,
Mg, K, HFSE, and transition metals, whereas, Ca, Na, P,
Ba and Sr are strongly depleted. Cesium and rubidium are
enriched to the UCC and show a positive correlation with
potassium, suggesting these trace elements are mostly
hosted by dioctahedral mica-like clay minerals. This in turn
indicates that illite and illitic minerals (I/S mixed layers)
have played an important role in the distribution of ele-
ments in these rocks, since these minerals are abundant in
the studied samples. Furthermore, the mudrocks fall in a
tight group on the A-K join, in the A-CN-K triangular
diagram (Fig. 7), close to the muscovite-illite point, in
agreement with the mineralogical data.
The source area for the studied mudrocks should have
similar features to those of the pre-Mesozoic basements
of many Calabrian-Peloritanian tectonic units, which are
predominantly composed of felsic rocks with lesser
amounts of intermediate and mafic rocks (Fig. 13). Geo-
chemical proxies consistently suggest a felsic nature of the
source area, with a minor but not negligible supply from
mafic metavolcanic rocks.
As for palaeoweathering both the PIA and the CIW
proxies suggest intense weathering at the source area. The
studied sediments seems to be affected by reworking and
recycling processes and, as a consequence, it is likely these
proxies monitor cumulative effects of weathering (e.g.,
Mongelli et al. 2006; Critelli et al. 2008; Perri et al. 2008a,
2008b).
Wet-humid conditions favored the formation of stream
channels that eroded the soil profiles, whereas, the partially
Fig. 11 Eu/Eu* vs. (La/Yb)N plot (modified from Cullers and
Podkovyrov 2002) showing the composition fields of the Peloritani