SE AE Comparison

8/14/2019 SE AE Comparison

1/10

http://sikailash.wordpress.com Mail to :[email protected]

COMPARISON ON TRI CYCLE & PUSH CARTSAS AVAILABLE IN MARKET

Tri Cycle companies Push Carts companies

TANSI JamesVadahangulam

Co- Operative

TANSI SintaxSNo

Parameters

ComparedA B C A B

1 Suitabil ity type ofvehicle andmarket supplies

Suitable to collect theGarbage in the streetshaving less then 15 width.

Suitable to collect the Garbage in thestreets having less then 15 width.

Suitable to collect theGarbage in the streetshaving less then 15width.

Suitable to collect theGarbage in the lanes havingless then 10 width.

Suitable to collect the Garbagein the lanes having less then10 width.

2 Specification Tipping : AvailablePayload : 200 KgMake : Hero

Body :Outer - Mild steelInner Aluminum

18 gaugesheets

Tipping : AvailablePayload :Make : Hero

Body :Outer - Mild steelInner Mild STEEL

Not furnished Chassis :25 x 25 x 18 Gauge thicktwo compartments

Bucket :Fiber glass buckets 45 LitcapacityBell : Bronze bell 4 diaWheel :2 nos trolley wheel12 x 12

Chassis :25 x 25 x 18 Gauge thick twocompartments

Bucket :Fiber glass buckets 45 LitcapacityBell : Bronze bell 4 diaWheel :2 nos trolley wheel12 x 12

3 Usage for SWM For door to door collection. For door to door collection. For door to doorcollection.

For door to door collection. For door to door collection.

4 DGS & D pricedVehicles

Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available

5 Service Centre Does not arise Does not arise Does not arise Does not arise Does not arise6 Response time

for serviceEasy to rectify the repair bythe user themselves

Easy to rectify the repair by the userthemselves

Easy to rectify the repairby the user themselves

Easy to rectify the repair bythe user themselves

Easy to rectify the repair by theuser themselves

7 Annual O&M cost Depending on the user. Depending on the user. Depending on the user. Depending on the user. Depending on the user.

8 Entry tax Does not arise Does not arise Does not arise Does not arise Does not arise9 Rate to includes

registration taxfor the first time

Does not arise Does not arise Does not arise Does not arise Does not arise

10 Training toDrivers

Does not arise Does not arise Does not arise Does not arise Does not arise


2/10


3/10


4/10


5/10


9 Rate to includes

registration taxfor the first time

Not Included extra charge will

be collected as applicable

Not Included extra

charge will becollected asapplicable

Not Included extra charge

will be collected asapplicable

Not Included extra

charge will becollected asapplicable

Not Included extra

charge will becollected as applicable

Not Included

extra charge willbe collected asapplicable

10 Training toDrivers

Does nor arise Does nor arise Does nor arise Does nor arise Does nor arise Does nor arise

Note : 1 The DGS&D rate furnished in the comparison statement has to be ascertained and time of purchase by the commissioners concerned.If the DGS&D rate is not available tender procedure may be adhered.

2 The O& M tabulated in the above statement may be re calculated by the commissioner concerned with the latest DGS&D rate / with the latest ratereceived by tender.

COMPARISON ON 6 WHEELER DUMPER PLACER & WATER TANKERAS AVAILABLE IN MARKET

Dumper Placer companiesS No ParametersCompared

MANIARAhmedabad

EICHERChennai

1 Suitability type of vehicleand market supplies

Suitable for collecting garbages at thecollection points such as street corners,Markets, Bus- stand, Slums.

Suitable for collecting garbages at the collection points such as streetcorners, Markets, Bus- stand, Slums.

2 Specification Container : Twin typeChassis : 6 Ton CapacityEngine : Diesel 72 HpPayload : 2.5 MT

Container : Twin typeChassis : 6 Ton CapacityEngine : Diesel 72 HpPayload : 2.5 MT

3 Usage for SWM Dumper Placer use full to increase theefficiency of the transportation of garbages bycollecting the high capacity litter bins in thecorners in streets, Markets.

Dumper Placer use full to increase the efficiency of the transportation ofgarbages by collecting the high capacity litter bins in the corners in streets,Markets.

4 DGS & D priced Vehicles Not available For ChassisDGS & D rate is Rs. 489177.00Add LST 10% Rs. 61636.00For Twin Dumper PlacerDGS & D Rate Rs. 370075.00


6/10


Incidental 10 % Rs. 37007.00

Re-sales tax 1 % Rs. 4070.83Container 2.5 cu.m.Cost Rs. 28575.00Incidental 10% Rs. 2857.50Re-sale 1% Rs. 314.33Total Cost Rs. 993713.44

5 Service Center Not Available 20 service centres Available

6 Response time for service AMC details not furnishedWarranty for chassis for 12 months

AMC Available, with 48 hrs repairableWarranty for chassis for 12 months

7 Annual O&M cost / Ton /

km

Not Given 0.25

8 Entry tax Not Mentioned Not Mentioned

9 Rate to includesregistration tax for the firsttime

Not Mentioned Not Mentioned

10 Training to Drivers Required Required

Note : 1 The DGS&D rate furnished in the comparison statement has to be ascertained and time of purchase by the commissioners concerned.If the DGS&D rate is not available, tender procedure may be adhered.

2 The O& M tabulated in the above statement may be re calculated by the commissioner concerned with the latest DGS&D rate / with the

latest rate received by tender.

COMPARISON ON SIX WHEELERS ( TIPPERS )AS AVAILABLE IN MARKET

EICHERS TATA 902 AL 709 AL 909A B C D

1 Suitabil ity type ofvehicle and marketsupplies

Suitable for secondarycollection of garbage

Suitable for secondarycollection of garbage

Suitable for secondary collection ofgarbage

Suitable forsecondary collectionof garbage

2 Specification Tipping : AvailablePayload : 6000 KgTurning Radios : 6m

Tipping : AvailablePayload : 3900 KgTurning Radios : 6m




7/10


3 Usage for SWM Can be used to transport the

garbage from transfer stationto compost yard

Can be used to transport the

garbage from transfer station tocompost yard

Can be used to transport the garbage

from transfer station to compost yard

Can be used to

transport the garbagefrom transfer station tocompost yard

4 DGS & D pricedVehicles

Rs.7,58,120Excluding Tax



Rs. 7,303,315Excluding Tax

5 Service Centre Service centre available withall dealers 20 Nos

Service centre available with alldealers 25 Nos.

Service centre available with alldealers 12 Nos.

Service centreavailable with alldealers 12 Nos.

6 Response time forservice

Serviceable with in 48 hrsAMC available



Serviceable with in 72hrsAMC available

7 Annual O&M cost Rs.0.20 Rs.0.25 Rs.25 Rs. 0.20

8 Entry tax Separate Separate Separate Separate9 Rate to includes

registration tax for thefirst time

Separate Separate Separate Separate

10 Training to Drivers Training for 7 days Training for 7 days Training for 7 days Training for 7 days

Note : 1 The DGS&D rate furnished in the comparison statement has to be ascertained and time of purchase by the commissioners concerned.

If the DGS&D rate is not available, tender procedure may be adhered.

2 The O& M tabulated in the above statement may be re calculated by the commissioner concerned with the latest DGS&D rate / with the latest ratereceived by tender.

COMPARISON ON COMPACTOR

AS AVAILABLE IN MARKET

Compactor companiesS No ParametersCompared

KAM AVIDAREL 12

Chennai 17

FAN NSRREL 12Guindy

MEGA PACMarathon

EquipmentSingapore

GlobalWaste Management

Mumbai

Jai Deep TechnoEnterprises

ChennaiEICHERChennai


8/10


9/10


10/10


Speed : 15 Km / Hrs

Engine CC: Krilosker 72 HPTuring Radius :4000 5750 mmFuel consumption : 7 Hrs/Lit

Speed : 16 Km / Hrs

Engine CC: Perkin 82 HPTuring Radius : 4000 5750 rpmFuel consumption : 6 Hrs/Lit

Speed :14 Km / Hrs

Engine CC: Krilosker 72 HPTuring Radius : 4000 5750 rpm Fuel consumption :6.30 Hrs/Lit

3 Usage for SWM Useful for loading purpose at transferstationUseful to turn the garbage at compost yard

Useful for loading purpose at transfer stationUseful to turn the garbage at compost yard

Useful for loading purpose at transfer stationUseful to turn the garbage at compost yard

4 DGS & D priced Vehicles DGS & D rate is availableIncluding all taxes total cost comes tors.14,00,000.

DGS & D rate is availableIncluding all taxes total cost comes tors.13,00,000.

DGS & D rate is availableIncluding all taxes total cost comes to rs.14,00,000.

5 Service Center AvailableCab be serviceable in the local service

center

AvailableCab be serviceable in the local service

center

AvailableCab be serviceable in the local service center

6 Response time forservice

AMC details not furnishedWarranty not mentioned



7 Annual O&M cost Rs. 94.20 / Hour Rs. 88.38 / Hour Rs. 94.30 / Hour8 Entry tax Included with total cost Included with total cost Included with total cost9 Rate to includes

registration tax for thefirst time

Not mentioned Not mentioned Not mentioned

10 Training to Drivers Required Required Required

Note : 1 The DGS&D rate furnished in the comparison statement has to be ascertained and time of purchase by the commissioners concerned.If the DGS&D rate is not available, tender procedure may be adhered.

2 The O& M tabulated in the above statement may be re calculated by the commissioner concerned with the latest DGS&D rate / with the latest rate receivedby tender.

SE AE Comparison

Documents