Top Banner
SDSS, IPHAS and GALEX Photometry of post-AGB and Centrals Stars of Planetary Nebulae Simon Weston, Ralf Napiwotzki University of Hertfordshire
27

SDSS, IPHAS and GALEX Photometry of post-AGB and centrals …star.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessI/weston.pdf · of post-AGB and Centrals Stars of Planetary Nebulae Simon Weston, Ralf

Aug 16, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: SDSS, IPHAS and GALEX Photometry of post-AGB and centrals …star.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessI/weston.pdf · of post-AGB and Centrals Stars of Planetary Nebulae Simon Weston, Ralf

SDSS, IPHAS and GALEX Photometry of post-AGB and Centrals Stars of

Planetary Nebulae

Simon Weston, Ralf Napiwotzki

University of Hertfordshire

Page 2: SDSS, IPHAS and GALEX Photometry of post-AGB and centrals …star.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessI/weston.pdf · of post-AGB and Centrals Stars of Planetary Nebulae Simon Weston, Ralf

Outline

• PN – formation, evolution and observational problems

• IPHAS (INT Photometric Hα Survey)‏

• Distance determination methods

• CSPN synthetic photometry in GALEX/SDSS/IPHAS

• Post-AGB halo stars using GALEX/SDSS

• Outcomes & Future work

Page 3: SDSS, IPHAS and GALEX Photometry of post-AGB and centrals …star.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessI/weston.pdf · of post-AGB and Centrals Stars of Planetary Nebulae Simon Weston, Ralf

Low and Intermediate Mass Stellar Evolution

• All single stars with M < 8.0Mּס

• Mass loss and envelope ejected in thermal pulse phase

• As central star contracts and heats up, the ejected nebula is illuminated.

Evolutionary tracks from Blöcker (1995)‏

Page 4: SDSS, IPHAS and GALEX Photometry of post-AGB and centrals …star.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessI/weston.pdf · of post-AGB and Centrals Stars of Planetary Nebulae Simon Weston, Ralf

PN Observational Problems

• Birthrates uncertain

• Local density difficulties

– Incompleteness and morphological bias

– Distances notoriously difficult to determine.

• Many PN non-spherical

– Difficult to explain with single star scenario

Formed by single or binary stellar systems?

Page 5: SDSS, IPHAS and GALEX Photometry of post-AGB and centrals …star.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessI/weston.pdf · of post-AGB and Centrals Stars of Planetary Nebulae Simon Weston, Ralf

IPHAS

• Galactic plane survey (b < |5|)‏

• Hα, r’ and i’ band down to r’≈20 (10σ)‏

• Found 233 unknown PN candidates in RA =18-20hr region alone (Zijlstra, priv. comm.)

Page 6: SDSS, IPHAS and GALEX Photometry of post-AGB and centrals …star.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessI/weston.pdf · of post-AGB and Centrals Stars of Planetary Nebulae Simon Weston, Ralf

PN Size Distribution

Figure taken from Zijlstra (Priv. comm.)‏

Page 7: SDSS, IPHAS and GALEX Photometry of post-AGB and centrals …star.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessI/weston.pdf · of post-AGB and Centrals Stars of Planetary Nebulae Simon Weston, Ralf

PN distance determination

IF central star is known:

• Reddening distance from 3D dust map

• UV and optical colours of central stars

Survey data often sufficient for these two methods

Page 8: SDSS, IPHAS and GALEX Photometry of post-AGB and centrals …star.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessI/weston.pdf · of post-AGB and Centrals Stars of Planetary Nebulae Simon Weston, Ralf

Locating the Central Star

There is one candidate CSPN

Page 9: SDSS, IPHAS and GALEX Photometry of post-AGB and centrals …star.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessI/weston.pdf · of post-AGB and Centrals Stars of Planetary Nebulae Simon Weston, Ralf

Distance Estimate

Prince’s‏Nebula‏in‏IPHAS‏- Figure from Sale (Priv. Comm.)‏

Page 10: SDSS, IPHAS and GALEX Photometry of post-AGB and centrals …star.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessI/weston.pdf · of post-AGB and Centrals Stars of Planetary Nebulae Simon Weston, Ralf

Synthetic Photometry

• Kurucz ‘Atlas9’ O and B stars and Koester white dwarfs model atmospheres.

• SEDs folded with GALEX/SDSS/IPHAS filters giving UV/optical and near-IR magnitudes.

• Calibrated with hot DA WDs

• Synthetic photometry for GALEX and IPHAS bands will be made public soon.

Synthetic Photometry may be extended to post-AGB stars

Page 11: SDSS, IPHAS and GALEX Photometry of post-AGB and centrals …star.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessI/weston.pdf · of post-AGB and Centrals Stars of Planetary Nebulae Simon Weston, Ralf

Post-AGB stars in Galactic halo

• Teff and logg can be estimated using UV and optical photometry alone.

• We will find post-AGB stars combining SDSS and GALEX photometry – if they exist.

Page 12: SDSS, IPHAS and GALEX Photometry of post-AGB and centrals …star.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessI/weston.pdf · of post-AGB and Centrals Stars of Planetary Nebulae Simon Weston, Ralf

Post-AGB stars in Galactic halo

• Standard evolution models expect all low and intermediate mass stars to go through a post-AGB phase.

• Simulation of the Galactic population predicts many in the halo (Napiwotzki 2009).

• Torun catalogue of post-AGB stars (Szczerba et al. 2007) finds very few in the halo.

Page 13: SDSS, IPHAS and GALEX Photometry of post-AGB and centrals …star.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessI/weston.pdf · of post-AGB and Centrals Stars of Planetary Nebulae Simon Weston, Ralf

Galactic Post-AGB Stars (V=16)‏

Page 14: SDSS, IPHAS and GALEX Photometry of post-AGB and centrals …star.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessI/weston.pdf · of post-AGB and Centrals Stars of Planetary Nebulae Simon Weston, Ralf

Galactic Post-AGB Population

Figures 2 and 3 from Szczerba et al (2007)‏

Page 15: SDSS, IPHAS and GALEX Photometry of post-AGB and centrals …star.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessI/weston.pdf · of post-AGB and Centrals Stars of Planetary Nebulae Simon Weston, Ralf

Possible Outcomes

1. Expected number of post-AGB stars found

• Standard scenario

• Systematic search for PN around them

• Check of predicted evolutionary timescales possible

2. Results confirm deficit of post-AGB stars

halo stars avoid the AGB and evolve directly from the horizontal branch to the white dwarf sequence

Page 16: SDSS, IPHAS and GALEX Photometry of post-AGB and centrals …star.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessI/weston.pdf · of post-AGB and Centrals Stars of Planetary Nebulae Simon Weston, Ralf

Summary & Future Work

• Locate and determine distances to CSPN in SDSS/GALEX

• Also IPHAS with UVEX – U, g’, r’ photometry in IPHAS field

• Start systematically look for halo post-AGB stars in SDSS with GALEX

• Spectra of CSPNe in MASH survey from ESO UT2 telescope.

• Look at revised PN space densities and birthrates

Page 17: SDSS, IPHAS and GALEX Photometry of post-AGB and centrals …star.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessI/weston.pdf · of post-AGB and Centrals Stars of Planetary Nebulae Simon Weston, Ralf

Questions?

Page 18: SDSS, IPHAS and GALEX Photometry of post-AGB and centrals …star.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessI/weston.pdf · of post-AGB and Centrals Stars of Planetary Nebulae Simon Weston, Ralf
Page 19: SDSS, IPHAS and GALEX Photometry of post-AGB and centrals …star.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessI/weston.pdf · of post-AGB and Centrals Stars of Planetary Nebulae Simon Weston, Ralf
Page 20: SDSS, IPHAS and GALEX Photometry of post-AGB and centrals …star.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessI/weston.pdf · of post-AGB and Centrals Stars of Planetary Nebulae Simon Weston, Ralf

NGC6781‏image‏taken‏from‏Nick‏Wright’s‏webpage‏

Page 21: SDSS, IPHAS and GALEX Photometry of post-AGB and centrals …star.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessI/weston.pdf · of post-AGB and Centrals Stars of Planetary Nebulae Simon Weston, Ralf

NGC 6781image‏taken‏from‏Nick‏Wright’s‏webpage‏

Page 22: SDSS, IPHAS and GALEX Photometry of post-AGB and centrals …star.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessI/weston.pdf · of post-AGB and Centrals Stars of Planetary Nebulae Simon Weston, Ralf

Sh2-188‏image‏taken‏from‏Nick‏Wright’s‏webpage‏

Page 23: SDSS, IPHAS and GALEX Photometry of post-AGB and centrals …star.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessI/weston.pdf · of post-AGB and Centrals Stars of Planetary Nebulae Simon Weston, Ralf

Sh2-188 image‏taken‏from‏Nick‏Wright’s‏webpage‏

Page 24: SDSS, IPHAS and GALEX Photometry of post-AGB and centrals …star.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessI/weston.pdf · of post-AGB and Centrals Stars of Planetary Nebulae Simon Weston, Ralf

Galactic Post-AGB Stars

Page 25: SDSS, IPHAS and GALEX Photometry of post-AGB and centrals …star.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessI/weston.pdf · of post-AGB and Centrals Stars of Planetary Nebulae Simon Weston, Ralf

Simulated post-AGB populations

• Monte Carlo simulation of thin disc, thick disc and halo stars (Napiwotzki 2009).

• Stars are created with initial masses drawn from a Salpeter IMF

• Stars distributed randomly based on standard model of Galactic structure (Robin et al. 2003)‏

• Detailed simulation of stars evolved to post-AGB phase and beyond.

• Calibrated with observed WDs from the ESO SN Ia Progenitor Survey (SPY)‏

Page 26: SDSS, IPHAS and GALEX Photometry of post-AGB and centrals …star.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessI/weston.pdf · of post-AGB and Centrals Stars of Planetary Nebulae Simon Weston, Ralf

M32 UV CMD

Figure taken from Brown (2005)‏

Page 27: SDSS, IPHAS and GALEX Photometry of post-AGB and centrals …star.herts.ac.uk/ewass/talks/sessI/weston.pdf · of post-AGB and Centrals Stars of Planetary Nebulae Simon Weston, Ralf

GALEX/SDSS Synthetic Photometry of post-AGB stars