SB Atmobisworoner Darshonik

7/31/2019 SB Atmobisworoner Darshonik

1/31

::::

() - - , , - , i-- , - , -

(?) , , -

( ) ?- ("- )

, - - - " " ,

- ; - , - - , v - ,

-, - , ,-,- : () , -

7/31/2019 SB Atmobisworoner Darshonik

2/31

- - - , , - - - -, , - , ,

/self /being - apriori apriori - , ,

, , , '' , - - , - M , v,

: - '' 'Afterword' () Sibaji BandyopadhyayReader () "A Return to Now" - " "

,, , , - -,

7/31/2019 SB Atmobisworoner Darshonik

3/31

, - - - - - - - - - - , , (intersubjective) - ,, - ,

, - - , , , , ,,genealogy- - genealogy- ,

,, ,

, - - '' - - - q , fse - - - - ,-

7/31/2019 SB Atmobisworoner Darshonik

4/31

--

,

'subjugated knowledges' ' ' - - - - '' " () " "

) " , ") " , , , ?"

- BLr // - , - - -La ' ' - - "'' " - " , , ''"(" , : ) ' '

- - :

, , , , ,

7/31/2019 SB Atmobisworoner Darshonik

5/31

7/31/2019 SB Atmobisworoner Darshonik

6/31

? ?, womb-complex ? : , , , - (", :f: ) - - , ,

-

"

" ()

,

(Tel Quel) , genealogy , , , , paleonymy-

genealogy / , /, , - - '' '' ' ' '' ? :

'' - - : ,

7/31/2019 SB Atmobisworoner Darshonik

7/31

,- (" ",, f: )

'' - '', '', '' - -,-,-- 'ressentiment' ! -'ressentiment' - ? , , ,

, , - , - ,, - , - , - ressentiment, , ,

- , ?/,/ ,:

, - ''- ? '', '', '' - '' - , , '' ?... , ,

'', ? , -

, , noble, , '' (" ", , f:)

ressentiment - , ? -

7/31/2019 SB Atmobisworoner Darshonik

8/31

, ,ressentiment - - - - -- Ressentiment-, , - - fL - ,

"" , , - :

: 'flhS''always wandering from place toplace'/ 'wandering constantly' ,

- , , , ( - ) (" : ,f: )

- - -- ,,, -

; , '' , ? ''

7/31/2019 SB Atmobisworoner Darshonik

9/31

'' - - gift - - - ressentiment- , -, - n

ayl "A Critique of Non-Violence"- (2010)

/ - - - - ' '

- - '', '' - jaoZ , , jaoZ , -

"Defining Terror : 'A Freudian Exercise'" () -

7/31/2019 SB Atmobisworoner Darshonik

10/31

- (eros) jaoZ(thanatos)- , , - -- jaoZ, , - - counter-wish- Pleasure Principle -

Unpleasure Principle - - pleasure unpleasure - , - jaoZ - , , counter-wish - - - repressed unconscious - (condensation) (Displacement-) - jaoZ , -,

ego- ? Pleasure Principle ThanatosjaoZ? - - primary

7/31/2019 SB Atmobisworoner Darshonik

11/31

projection- , , - - sadist Thanatos ---

'' ' -' - ( ) - ( ) -

,

?

(fright), (fear),(anxiety) ,, 'terror' - - terror

global -,

-, - - Global Thanatos -jaoZ - -- - - -- /-,-

-terror reification -- - -'',, ,, ,,

7/31/2019 SB Atmobisworoner Darshonik

12/31

jaoZ --- - -- ? , -

jaoZ - - - ; - - - - ! - - jaoZ -

jaoZaLfC - - jaoZ - - , - " "() -

- ,, - - - ?

- - - - - - -

, , , - , dlZ , , ,

7/31/2019 SB Atmobisworoner Darshonik

13/31

" ? ?" ( , )

- - -- - --- - : -- " - , , ,, , , - - , - , -

- ,- , - , - - - ,- - - - - - - ! -- - , /, , , - - , - - , - - - / - - / , theist atheist ; - - , ,

, , - , - , ; emperics -

7/31/2019 SB Atmobisworoner Darshonik

14/31

- - - hc-fs ,- , ,-( ) - - - -, ,-Truffaut-400 Blows - - - , - , , ,

- (closure) - - - - - - , , , Deconstruction'- ',:

Deconstructionist - - , , , - - -, -- , , ,, (, , , ) (, , , ) difference-deference- , deconstruction- , , (

), , deconstruction - '' '' :- ("-- , f:)

7/31/2019 SB Atmobisworoner Darshonik

15/31

-() '' '' , , (), 'revolution' revolution-'Revolution' ,copernican revolution , - -?? , ,

, ?Thomas K. Kuhn-Nature of Scientific Revolution paradigm-shift - paradigm-drift-,- - - - -,-Ame- -,-paradigm-driftparadigm-- , paradigm-shift - -, , ,- /world-spirit-

' '

' ' ( :- ) , -

Le ?Le - , ,

7/31/2019 SB Atmobisworoner Darshonik

16/31

? '' " - ( ) '', ''- (" " , f:) '' - :

'',-;, '' , . , '' (" ", f: )

- , -'' ' ' , - -,, ,, , - - - -

- - -

"Will to Record" (A brief note on the Will to record, 2001)

phonocentrism , , -, !

7/31/2019 SB Atmobisworoner Darshonik

17/31

, , - recording- representation- Recording- - - -'trace' representation - , Sign trace - - ,

" " (, ) - - ,

(Derrida 1992, P. 34)

--- " " , - , - " , - , - , ; , , " ' ' -

ideology- - - - ---- - ' '- , , '' - - - - - " ; - - , -"! --" "

7/31/2019 SB Atmobisworoner Darshonik

18/31

Evp , , - , ethnic, , - , - , - -

Producing and Re-producing the New Woman: A Note on the Prefix re

() reform, restoration, return, renew, rebirth,recover renaissance - ? (colonial

masochism-)

, - , ? , ? New Woman

- , , ( ) , ,-, -

7/31/2019 SB Atmobisworoner Darshonik

19/31

7/31/2019 SB Atmobisworoner Darshonik

20/31

-, , , - - , , - , --, -, -, - - - , - - , , Heterosexual homosexual , - - - - hetero/homo/bi - - - ,

Le , - - , - , - , - --- - ?

liberalism / () , - , - : ( - ) ,' ' " "- " ()

7/31/2019 SB Atmobisworoner Darshonik

21/31

, , -, - ( ) , : " , ..."

BLru

, ,

,

- - (world -spirit) - - - -

, , , , , , -

, , , , - -,

, - , - - - , - - -

7/31/2019 SB Atmobisworoner Darshonik

22/31

- - ,- -- , '''' - ayl- - ( ) -, - - - , , , - , - , - ,

" "( f:) - -, - - - ?- , , - --, - , - ? ?

(), - ' ' - heu , ' ' - -

7/31/2019 SB Atmobisworoner Darshonik

23/31

() () -- , / ,/ ,/, /- ' ' ' '- '' '' ''- ----- - -- - , '' ,-, ,' '

, - '' -- - - - -''- - -- , - - , - - ! - - :

- - - , - , ,

; , ;-

...- , '',- - - - , ,- - '', , ' '- ( , )

7/31/2019 SB Atmobisworoner Darshonik

24/31

7/31/2019 SB Atmobisworoner Darshonik

25/31

- '', ,/- , , - -

- - , -, - , -,

,

" : ( , ) - - - -- , -- , - - - - ; - - ayl- -! - - -, - - - - - - - - "ij:"(//),-" " (//), " " (//)! -

, - -- - , - -,- - -- - - - - , , ""

7/31/2019 SB Atmobisworoner Darshonik

26/31

- - , ,- ,- - - - " - - ()-- () - , , - , -- - , ,-" ... " - - --! - - --- - - - ,

- - - - / - "" -

- -

''-, - ? ? , , ? , "-"- , , -, , ( ) , - ' '- - , (); - 'Translating 2/47 or Inventing the National Motto' (Studies in Humanities and Social

Sciences, 2009), ,

7/31/2019 SB Atmobisworoner Darshonik

27/31

- ' ' - , -, - - - , - , -, ,-,- - - - - - [/] '' /- , ''- , ''- - : - ,

- , ; - - " =" - , " - '' , - - " - " ''- " " - - - / - ! , " , , " ( ) - , -,

! - ; - , - !- , - - - , : -: , ?" - , !(, ), , - - , - - -

7/31/2019 SB Atmobisworoner Darshonik

28/31

, - - - , k - :" , hQLvp

; ,

, , ; , , ?" , - - --;- - -

, , , - ; "- , , [-] , -

/ (

)

- ,

, - : ?" - , - ? - -- - , - , , - - - - ' ' -,- ,

,- - :

/ / -, -- ,

7/31/2019 SB Atmobisworoner Darshonik

29/31

, - : , : , ,

_________________ : ,:,

_________________ ,: :

_________________, ( ), : ,

_________________ , (),

_________________ ,:NPQm,

_________________" : ", , , ,

________________ , ( ) :NPQm,

_________________" ", , ( ) :NPQm,

_________________"--, , ( ) :NPQm,

7/31/2019 SB Atmobisworoner Darshonik

30/31

_________________ : - , , ( ) :NPQm,

_________________" ", , ( ) :NPQm,

_________________"-",:,

_________________"-", , ( ) : ,

_________________" ", , ( ( : ,

_________________ , , ( ( : ,

_________________ - , , ( ) : ,

_________________ ? ? : ,

_________________" : : ,_________________ ,Technologies of Revolution, UGC Sponsored StateLevel Seminar Organized by Barasat Government College, ,

_________________

: , : ,

Sibaji Bandyopadhyay, Producing and Re-Producing the New Women: A Note on thePrefix 'Re', Social Scientist, Vol. 22, No. 1/2 (Jan. - Feb., 1994)

________________ A brief note on the Will to record, From the Margins (On

History, Memory, Nostalgia), Calcutta, February, 2001

7/31/2019 SB Atmobisworoner Darshonik

31/31