S I T E S E L E C T I O N A N D E V A L U A T I O N I N T H A I L A N D

Technical Meeting on Tropic Issue on Infrastructure Development Technical Meeting on Tropic Issue on Infrastructure Development : : Common Challenge on the Site Selection for Nuclear Power Plant Common Challenge on the Site Selection for Nuclear Power Plant

IAEA, VIENNA,6IAEA, VIENNA,6--9 JULY, 2010 9 JULY, 2010

SITE SELECTION AND EVALUATION IN SITE SELECTION AND EVALUATION IN THAILANDTHAILAND

SUPAPOL RATANAKORN SUPAPOL RATANAKORN THE ELECTRICITY GENERATING AUTHORITY OF THAILANDTHE ELECTRICITY GENERATING AUTHORITY OF THAILAND

Thai Nuclear Power ProgramThai Nuclear Power ProgramThai Nuclear Power ProgramThai Nuclear Power ProgramThai Nuclear Power ProgramThai Nuclear Power ProgramThai Nuclear Power ProgramThai Nuclear Power Program

Nuclear Engineering DivisionNuclear Engineering DivisionElectricity Generating Authority of ThailandElectricity Generating Authority of Thailand

CONTENTCONTENTTHAI NUCLEAR POWER PROGRAMTHAI NUCLEAR POWER PROGRAMSITE SELECTION AND EVALUATION IN SITE SELECTION AND EVALUATION IN THAILANDTHAILAND

PREVIOUS SITING STUDYPREVIOUS SITING STUDYCURRENT SITING STUDYCURRENT SITING STUDY

SITE SURVEY CHALLANGESSITE SURVEY CHALLANGES

Nuclear Power and National Energy PlanNuclear Power and National Energy Plan

�� National Energy Policy Council approved ThailandNational Energy Policy Council approved ThailandPower Development Plan 2007Power Development Plan 2007--2021 (PDP 2007) 2021 (PDP 2007) On June 4, 2007On June 4, 20074x1,0004x1,000--MWe NPP in 2020 (2 units) and 2021 (2 units)MWe NPP in 2020 (2 units) and 2021 (2 units)

�� Cabinet approved Revision 2 of PDP 2007Cabinet approved Revision 2 of PDP 2007On March 24, 2009On March 24, 20092x1,0002x1,000--MWe NPP in 2020(1 unit) and 2021(1 unit)MWe NPP in 2020(1 unit) and 2021(1 unit)

�� Cabinet approved New PDP 2010 (2010 Cabinet approved New PDP 2010 (2010 –– 2030) 2030) On March 30, 2010On March 30, 20105 NPP units (2020, 2021, 2024, 2025, 2028) 5 NPP units (2020, 2021, 2024, 2025, 2028)

PDP 2010 Thailand Fuel Mix for Power GenerationPDP 2010 Thailand Fuel Mix for Power Generation

Cabinet ApprovedCabinet ApprovedOn October 30, 2007 and December 18, 2007On October 30, 2007 and December 18, 2007

Nuclear Power Infrastructure Establishment Plan (NPIEP)Nuclear Power Infrastructure Establishment Plan (NPIEP)Nuclear Power Infrastructure Establishment Plan (NPIEP)Nuclear Power Infrastructure Establishment Plan (NPIEP)Nuclear Power Infrastructure Establishment Plan (NPIEP)Nuclear Power Infrastructure Establishment Plan (NPIEP)Nuclear Power Infrastructure Establishment Plan (NPIEP)Nuclear Power Infrastructure Establishment Plan (NPIEP)Setup of Setup of Setup of Setup of Setup of Setup of Setup of Setup of Nuclear Power Program Development Office Nuclear Power Program Development Office Nuclear Power Program Development Office Nuclear Power Program Development Office Nuclear Power Program Development Office Nuclear Power Program Development Office Nuclear Power Program Development Office Nuclear Power Program Development Office (NPPDO)(NPPDO)(NPPDO)(NPPDO)(NPPDO)(NPPDO)(NPPDO)(NPPDO)Appointment of Appointment of Appointment of Appointment of Appointment of Appointment of Appointment of Appointment of Nuclear Power Infrastructure Nuclear Power Infrastructure Nuclear Power Infrastructure Nuclear Power Infrastructure Nuclear Power Infrastructure Nuclear Power Infrastructure Nuclear Power Infrastructure Nuclear Power Infrastructure Establishment Cooperation Committee (NPICC)Establishment Cooperation Committee (NPICC)Establishment Cooperation Committee (NPICC)Establishment Cooperation Committee (NPICC)Establishment Cooperation Committee (NPICC)Establishment Cooperation Committee (NPICC)Establishment Cooperation Committee (NPICC)Establishment Cooperation Committee (NPICC)Implementation plan and budget for preImplementation plan and budget for preImplementation plan and budget for preImplementation plan and budget for preImplementation plan and budget for preImplementation plan and budget for preImplementation plan and budget for preImplementation plan and budget for pre--------project activities project activities project activities project activities project activities project activities project activities project activities (2008(2008(2008(2008(2008(2008(2008(2008--------2010)2010)2010)2010)2010)2010)2010)2010)Public education and participation programPublic education and participation programPublic education and participation programPublic education and participation programPublic education and participation programPublic education and participation programPublic education and participation programPublic education and participation program

Ministry of EnergyMinistry of Energy

Nuclear Power Program Development Office (NPPDO)Nuclear Power Program Development Office (NPPDO)

National Energy Policy Council (NEPC)National Energy Policy Council (NEPC)

Dr.Norkun SitthiphongDirector

Assistant Director

Nuclear Power Infrastructure Cooperation Division

Central Management

Division

Public Communication and Acceptance

Division

Nuclear Power Utility Planning Cooperation Division

Nuclear Power InfrastructureEstablishment Cooperation Committee

Experts

Setup on Jan 31, 08 Setup on Jan 31, 08

Nuclear Power Infrastructure Establishment Nuclear Power Infrastructure Establishment Cooperation CommitteeCooperation Committee

appointed on December 26, 2007appointed on December 26, 2007�� Comprises 5 subComprises 5 subComprises 5 subComprises 5 subComprises 5 subComprises 5 subComprises 5 subComprises 5 sub--------committees (SC) :committees (SC) :committees (SC) :committees (SC) :committees (SC) :committees (SC) :committees (SC) :committees (SC) :

1. Legal system, regulatory system and international 1. Legal system, regulatory system and international 1. Legal system, regulatory system and international 1. Legal system, regulatory system and international 1. Legal system, regulatory system and international 1. Legal system, regulatory system and international 1. Legal system, regulatory system and international 1. Legal system, regulatory system and international protocolsprotocolsprotocolsprotocolsprotocolsprotocolsprotocolsprotocols

2. Nuclear power utility planning2. Nuclear power utility planning2. Nuclear power utility planning2. Nuclear power utility planning2. Nuclear power utility planning2. Nuclear power utility planning2. Nuclear power utility planning2. Nuclear power utility planning3. Industrial infrastructure, technology transfer, technolog3. Industrial infrastructure, technology transfer, technolog3. Industrial infrastructure, technology transfer, technolog3. Industrial infrastructure, technology transfer, technolog3. Industrial infrastructure, technology transfer, technolog3. Industrial infrastructure, technology transfer, technolog3. Industrial infrastructure, technology transfer, technolog3. Industrial infrastructure, technology transfer, technology y y y y y y y

development, and human resources developmentdevelopment, and human resources developmentdevelopment, and human resources developmentdevelopment, and human resources developmentdevelopment, and human resources developmentdevelopment, and human resources developmentdevelopment, and human resources developmentdevelopment, and human resources development4. Nuclear safety and environmental protection4. Nuclear safety and environmental protection4. Nuclear safety and environmental protection4. Nuclear safety and environmental protection4. Nuclear safety and environmental protection4. Nuclear safety and environmental protection4. Nuclear safety and environmental protection4. Nuclear safety and environmental protection5. Public information and national participation program5. Public information and national participation program5. Public information and national participation program5. Public information and national participation program5. Public information and national participation program5. Public information and national participation program5. Public information and national participation program5. Public information and national participation program

SC 6SC 6SC 6SC 6SC 6SC 6SC 6SC 6 Readiness report preparation Readiness report preparation Readiness report preparation Readiness report preparation Readiness report preparation Readiness report preparation Readiness report preparation Readiness report preparation is created is created is created is created is created is created is created is created to finalize theto finalize theto finalize theto finalize theto finalize theto finalize theto finalize theto finalize theReadiness Report (19 items of IAEA) within November 2010Readiness Report (19 items of IAEA) within November 2010Readiness Report (19 items of IAEA) within November 2010Readiness Report (19 items of IAEA) within November 2010Readiness Report (19 items of IAEA) within November 2010Readiness Report (19 items of IAEA) within November 2010Readiness Report (19 items of IAEA) within November 2010Readiness Report (19 items of IAEA) within November 2010

InfrastrucutreInfrastrucutre Development Development ProgrammeProgramme

7-2010

2007 2011 2014 2020

NuclearNuclear PowerPower Project ScheduleProject Schedule

Preliminary PhasePreliminary PhasePreliminary PhasePreliminary PhasePreliminary PhasePreliminary PhasePreliminary PhasePreliminary Phase 1 year1 year1 year1 year1 year1 year1 year1 year 20072007200720072007200720072007PrePrePrePrePrePrePrePre--------Project Activities PhaseProject Activities PhaseProject Activities PhaseProject Activities PhaseProject Activities PhaseProject Activities PhaseProject Activities PhaseProject Activities Phase 3 years3 years3 years3 years3 years3 years3 years3 years 20082008200820082008200820082008--------20102010201020102010201020102010

GO NUCLEAR ! GO NUCLEAR ! GO NUCLEAR ! GO NUCLEAR ! GO NUCLEAR ! GO NUCLEAR ! GO NUCLEAR ! GO NUCLEAR ! –––––––– Government to approve the projectGovernment to approve the projectGovernment to approve the projectGovernment to approve the projectGovernment to approve the projectGovernment to approve the projectGovernment to approve the projectGovernment to approve the projectProject Implementation PhaseProject Implementation PhaseProject Implementation PhaseProject Implementation PhaseProject Implementation PhaseProject Implementation PhaseProject Implementation PhaseProject Implementation Phase 3 years3 years3 years3 years3 years3 years3 years3 years 20112011201120112011201120112011--------20132013201320132013201320132013Construction PhaseConstruction PhaseConstruction PhaseConstruction PhaseConstruction PhaseConstruction PhaseConstruction PhaseConstruction Phase 6 years6 years6 years6 years6 years6 years6 years6 years 20142014201420142014201420142014--------20192019201920192019201920192019Commercial OperationCommercial OperationCommercial OperationCommercial OperationCommercial OperationCommercial OperationCommercial OperationCommercial Operation 20202020202020202020202020202020

Utility Preparation Utility Preparation For PreFor Pre--Project Activities Phase (2008Project Activities Phase (2008--2010)2010)

Electricity Generating Authority of Thailand (EGAT)Electricity Generating Authority of Thailand (EGAT)Electricity Generating Authority of Thailand (EGAT)Electricity Generating Authority of Thailand (EGAT)Electricity Generating Authority of Thailand (EGAT)Electricity Generating Authority of Thailand (EGAT)Electricity Generating Authority of Thailand (EGAT)Electricity Generating Authority of Thailand (EGAT)is responsible for is responsible for is responsible for is responsible for is responsible for is responsible for is responsible for is responsible for the first nuclear power station the first nuclear power station the first nuclear power station the first nuclear power station the first nuclear power station the first nuclear power station the first nuclear power station the first nuclear power station under the supervision of Nuclear Power Utility Subunder the supervision of Nuclear Power Utility Subunder the supervision of Nuclear Power Utility Subunder the supervision of Nuclear Power Utility Subunder the supervision of Nuclear Power Utility Subunder the supervision of Nuclear Power Utility Subunder the supervision of Nuclear Power Utility Subunder the supervision of Nuclear Power Utility Sub--------Committee Committee Committee Committee Committee Committee Committee Committee �� planning, feasibility study, site selection, project planning, feasibility study, site selection, project planning, feasibility study, site selection, project planning, feasibility study, site selection, project planning, feasibility study, site selection, project planning, feasibility study, site selection, project planning, feasibility study, site selection, project planning, feasibility study, site selection, project

implementation, construction and operationimplementation, construction and operationimplementation, construction and operationimplementation, construction and operationimplementation, construction and operationimplementation, construction and operationimplementation, construction and operationimplementation, construction and operationEGAT is currently conducting EGAT is currently conducting EGAT is currently conducting EGAT is currently conducting EGAT is currently conducting EGAT is currently conducting EGAT is currently conducting EGAT is currently conducting Nuclear Power Plant Nuclear Power Plant Nuclear Power Plant Nuclear Power Plant Nuclear Power Plant Nuclear Power Plant Nuclear Power Plant Nuclear Power Plant Feasibility StudyFeasibility StudyFeasibility StudyFeasibility StudyFeasibility StudyFeasibility StudyFeasibility StudyFeasibility Study

Nuclear Power Plant Feasibility StudyNuclear Power Plant Feasibility Study1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1. Energy Economics and FinancingEnergy Economics and FinancingEnergy Economics and FinancingEnergy Economics and FinancingEnergy Economics and FinancingEnergy Economics and FinancingEnergy Economics and FinancingEnergy Economics and Financing

National Energy Market AnalysisNational Energy Market AnalysisNational Energy Market AnalysisNational Energy Market AnalysisNational Energy Market AnalysisNational Energy Market AnalysisNational Energy Market AnalysisNational Energy Market AnalysisElectric System AnalysisElectric System AnalysisElectric System AnalysisElectric System AnalysisElectric System AnalysisElectric System AnalysisElectric System AnalysisElectric System AnalysisChoice of Unit SizeChoice of Unit SizeChoice of Unit SizeChoice of Unit SizeChoice of Unit SizeChoice of Unit SizeChoice of Unit SizeChoice of Unit SizeNuclear Cost EstimatesNuclear Cost EstimatesNuclear Cost EstimatesNuclear Cost EstimatesNuclear Cost EstimatesNuclear Cost EstimatesNuclear Cost EstimatesNuclear Cost EstimatesGeneration CostGeneration CostGeneration CostGeneration CostGeneration CostGeneration CostGeneration CostGeneration CostFunding ReviewFunding ReviewFunding ReviewFunding ReviewFunding ReviewFunding ReviewFunding ReviewFunding Review

2.2.2.2.2.2.2.2. Technical and Safety Aspects of Technical and Safety Aspects of Technical and Safety Aspects of Technical and Safety Aspects of Technical and Safety Aspects of Technical and Safety Aspects of Technical and Safety Aspects of Technical and Safety Aspects of Nuclear PowerNuclear PowerNuclear PowerNuclear PowerNuclear PowerNuclear PowerNuclear PowerNuclear PowerTechnical AspectsTechnical AspectsTechnical AspectsTechnical AspectsTechnical AspectsTechnical AspectsTechnical AspectsTechnical AspectsSafety AspectsSafety AspectsSafety AspectsSafety AspectsSafety AspectsSafety AspectsSafety AspectsSafety AspectsSecurity and SafeguardsSecurity and SafeguardsSecurity and SafeguardsSecurity and SafeguardsSecurity and SafeguardsSecurity and SafeguardsSecurity and SafeguardsSecurity and Safeguards

3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. Fuel Cycle and Waste ManagementFuel Cycle and Waste ManagementFuel Cycle and Waste ManagementFuel Cycle and Waste ManagementFuel Cycle and Waste ManagementFuel Cycle and Waste ManagementFuel Cycle and Waste ManagementFuel Cycle and Waste Management4. 4. 4. 4. 4. 4. 4. 4. Reactor Technology, Reactor Supplier Reactor Technology, Reactor Supplier Reactor Technology, Reactor Supplier Reactor Technology, Reactor Supplier Reactor Technology, Reactor Supplier Reactor Technology, Reactor Supplier Reactor Technology, Reactor Supplier Reactor Technology, Reactor Supplier

and Fuel Supplier Selectionand Fuel Supplier Selectionand Fuel Supplier Selectionand Fuel Supplier Selectionand Fuel Supplier Selectionand Fuel Supplier Selectionand Fuel Supplier Selectionand Fuel Supplier Selection

5.5.5.5.5.5.5.5. Site and Environmental StudySite and Environmental StudySite and Environmental StudySite and Environmental StudySite and Environmental StudySite and Environmental StudySite and Environmental StudySite and Environmental StudySTEP 1 STEP 1 STEP 1 STEP 1 STEP 1 STEP 1 STEP 1 STEP 1 –––––––– Identification of Identification of Identification of Identification of Identification of Identification of Identification of Identification of Candidate SitesCandidate SitesCandidate SitesCandidate SitesCandidate SitesCandidate SitesCandidate SitesCandidate SitesSTEP 2 STEP 2 STEP 2 STEP 2 STEP 2 STEP 2 STEP 2 STEP 2 –––––––– Evaluation of Candidate Evaluation of Candidate Evaluation of Candidate Evaluation of Candidate Evaluation of Candidate Evaluation of Candidate Evaluation of Candidate Evaluation of Candidate SitesSitesSitesSitesSitesSitesSitesSites

6.6.6.6.6.6.6.6. Human Resources Development Human Resources Development Human Resources Development Human Resources Development Human Resources Development Human Resources Development Human Resources Development Human Resources Development and Management Aspectsand Management Aspectsand Management Aspectsand Management Aspectsand Management Aspectsand Management Aspectsand Management Aspectsand Management Aspects

Human Resources Development Human Resources Development Human Resources Development Human Resources Development Human Resources Development Human Resources Development Human Resources Development Human Resources Development Plan Plan Plan Plan Plan Plan Plan Plan Project DevelopmentProject DevelopmentProject DevelopmentProject DevelopmentProject DevelopmentProject DevelopmentProject DevelopmentProject DevelopmentLegal Framework and licensing Legal Framework and licensing Legal Framework and licensing Legal Framework and licensing Legal Framework and licensing Legal Framework and licensing Legal Framework and licensing Legal Framework and licensing processprocessprocessprocessprocessprocessprocessprocessPublic Information and National Public Information and National Public Information and National Public Information and National Public Information and National Public Information and National Public Information and National Public Information and National ParticipationParticipationParticipationParticipationParticipationParticipationParticipationParticipation

Work ProgressWork ProgressNuclear Power Plant Feasibility StudyNuclear Power Plant Feasibility Study

TaskTaskCummulate Status Cummulate Status

(Oct 1, 08 (Oct 1, 08 –– June 20, 10)June 20, 10)% Complete% Complete

1.1. Energy Economics and FinancingEnergy Economics and Financing 99992.2. Technical and Safety Aspects of Nuclear PowerTechnical and Safety Aspects of Nuclear Power 1001003.3. Fuel Cycle and Waste managementFuel Cycle and Waste management 1001004.4. Reactor Technology Supplier, and Fuel Supplier Reactor Technology Supplier, and Fuel Supplier SelectionSelection 100100

5.5. Site and Environment StudySite and Environment Study 94946.6. Human Resources Development and Management Human Resources Development and Management AspectsAspects 100100

Total ProjectTotal Project 9595Note: % complete is measured in terms of budgeted cost of work.

Site selection and evaluation

Previous Siting Study

Site selection and evaluation

Current Siting Study

STEP 1 - Identification of candidate sitesPerform assessments on safety, economic and environmental aspects of the 17 potential sites identified by EGATIdentify at least 5 candidate sitesIdentify at least 5 candidate sitesIdentify at least 5 candidate sitesIdentify at least 5 candidate sites for further consideration

STEP 2 - Evaluation of candidate sitesConduct in-depth investigation and analyses to rank the 5 candidate sites from STEP 1 and identify 3 preferred sitesidentify 3 preferred sitesidentify 3 preferred sitesidentify 3 preferred sitesObtain design basis parameters for NPP

Site and Environmental Assessments Site and Environmental Assessments Site and Environmental Assessments Site and Environmental Assessments Scope of Works for Step 1

Part 1: Data Preparation:a. Engineering aspects such as topography, oceanography, hydrology, geology, geotechnical, seismology,b. Environmental aspects such as man induced events, demography, meteorology, land and water use, endangered species and sensitive items, ecology, andc. Cost Estimate for the installation of NPP

Part 2 : Composite Ranking for Identification of Candidates Sites

a. Preparation of criteriab. Evaluation criteriac. Comparison and ranking

Composite Ranking: CriteriaThe criteria is classified into three groups as:Group A: Engineering Aspects

Topography,Oceanography,Geology and Geotechnical,Hydrology and Hydrogeology,Seismology,Man Induced Events.

Group B: Environmental AspectsDemography,Meteorology,Land and Water Uses,Endangered Species, Historical Monuments, Other Sensitive Items,Ecology.

Group C: Cost Estimation for power plant components as cooling water system, transmission line, access road and etc.

RESULT OF WEIGHT SCORE OF 17 POTENTIAL SITES(STEP 1)

Table 7.3-1 RESULT OF ENVIRONMENTAL (ENV) AND ENGINEERING (ENG) SCORES AND COST OF 17 POTENTIAL SITES WITH INDIVIDUAL RANKS

Site 1 Site 2 Site 3 Site 4 Site 5 Site 6 Site 7 Site 8 Site 9 Site 10 Site 11 Site 12 Site 13 Site 14 Site 15 Site 16 Site 17Fang Daeng

Bang Boet

Ban Leam Thaen

Ban Laem Yang

Ban Pak Nam Lamae

Ban Talet

Ban Thong Not

Ban Thong Ching

Ban Thong Nian

Ban Thung Sai

Takrob Khan Thuli

Makham Thao

Hat So Ban Mai Rut

Phanom Rok

Sirin dhorn

• ENG 500 295 299 312 285 324 286 295 290 287 303 275 339 258 277 331 351 399

Rank 9 8 6 14 5 13 9 11 12 7 16 3 17 15 4 2 1

• ENV 500 329 324 305 342 368 311 306 315 305 311 354 391 291 201 362 387 342

Rank 8 9 14 6 3 11 13 10 14 11 5 1 16 17 4 2 6

• ENG+ENV 1,000 624 623 617 627 692 597 601 605 592 614 629 730 548 478 693 738 741

Rank 8 9 10 7 5 14 13 12 15 11 6 3 16 17 4 2 1

• ECO(Cost) m. Baht 11,163 12,782 14,745 13,877 29,623 28,582 29,542 25,941 30,371 15,516 25,706 22,087 16,488 13,536 19,519 18,560 5,254

Rank 2 3 6 5 16 14 15 13 17 7 12 11 8 4 10 9 1

R e m a r k : S i t e N o . 1 a n d 2 a r e l o c a t e d i n P r a c h u a p K h i r i K h a n P r o v i n c e S i t e N o . 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 a n d 1 0 a r e l o c a t e d i n N a k h o n S i T h a m m a r a t P r o v i n c e S i t e N o . 1 3 i s l o c a t e d a t A . W a t s i n g , C h a i N a t P r o v i n c eS i t e N o . 3 , 4 a n d 5 a r e l o c a t e d i n C h u m p h o n P r o v i n c e S i t e N o . 1 1 a n d 1 2 a r e l o c a t e d i n S u r a t T h a n i P r o v i n c e S i t e N o . 1 4 i s l o c a t e d a t A . S a t t a h i p , C h o n B u r i P r o v i n c eS i t e N o . 1 5 i s l o c a t e d i n T r a t P r o v i n c e S i t e N o . 1 6 i s l o c a t e d i n N a k h o n S a w a n P r o v i n c e S i t e N o . 1 7 i s l o c a t e d a t A . S i r i d h o r n , U b o n r a t c h a t h a n i P r o v i n c e

ScoreCriteria

Weighted Score and Cost of Each Site

Site and Environmental Assessments SIMILARY RANKED

SITE NO NAME OF SITE ENG. ENVI. ECO ENG. ENVI. ECO ENG. ENVI. ECO ENG. ENVI. ECO50 40 10 45 45 10 40 50 10

Site1 B.FANG DAENG, PRACHUAP 2 4 4Site2 B. BANG BOET, PRACHUAP 2 4 4Site3 B. LAEM THAEN, CHUMPHON 2 3 4Site4 B. LEAM YANG, CHUMPHON 1 4 4Site5 B. PAK NAM LAMAE, CHUMPHON 3 5 1Site6 B. TALET, NAKHON SRI 2 3 1Site7 B. THONG NOT, NAKHON SRI 2 3 1Site8 B. THONG CHING, NAKHON SRI 2 3 1Site9 B. THONG NEIN, NAKHON SRI 2 3 1Site10 B.THUNG SAI, NAKHON SRI 2 3 3Site11 B. TAKROB, CHAIYA, SURAT 1 4 2Site12 KHANTULI, THA CHANA, SURAT 3 5 2Site13 MAKHAM TAO, CHAINAT 1 3 3Site14 B. HAT SO, SATTAHIP 1 1 4Site15 B. MAI RUT, TRAD 3 5 3Site16 PHANOM ROK, NAKHON SAWAN 4 5 3Site17 SIRINDHORN 5 4 5

QUANTITATIVE SITE EVALUATION INDIVIDUAL (USED COST10%)

460 455 450

130

240

390

440435

230

130380

430

370

200130390

245

130380

400

240240

235

210

255

280

240

260260

380

310

265260250

250

230

230230

235

360

235370

230235

310300300

320320

265 270

SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS

Site and Environmental Assessments SIMILARY RANKED

SITE NO NAME OF SITE ENG. ENVI. ECO ENG. ENVI. ECO ENG. ENVI. ECO ENG. ENVI. ECO50 30 20 40 40 20 30 50 20

Site1 B.FANG DAENG, PRACHUAP 2 4 4Site2 B. BANG BOET, PRACHUAP 2 4 4Site3 B. LAEM THAEN, CHUMPHON 2 3 4Site4 B. LEAM YANG, CHUMPHON 1 4 4Site5 B. PAK NAM LAMAE, CHUMPHON 3 5 1Site6 B. TALET, NAKHON SRI 2 3 1Site7 B. THONG NOT, NAKHON SRI 2 3 1Site8 B. THONG CHING, NAKHON SRI 2 3 1Site9 B. THONG NEIN, NAKHON SRI 2 3 1Site10 B.THUNG SAI, NAKHON SRI 2 3 3Site11 B. TAKROB, CHAIYA, SURAT 1 4 2Site12 KHANTULI, THA CHANA, SURAT 3 5 2Site13 MAKHAM TAO, CHAINAT 1 3 3Site14 B. HAT SO, SATTAHIP 1 1 4Site15 B. MAI RUT, TRAD 3 5 3Site16 PHANOM ROK, NAKHON SAWAN 4 5 3Site17 SIRINDHORN 5 4 5

QUANTITATIVE SITE EVALUATION INDIVIDUAL (USED COST20%)

460 450

240 270

470

210 220 230

360

230250 260 270

210 220 230210 220

210

200 220 240

420 430410

160

230210 220

380 400

340 360 380

160 160

SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS

300 320 340

320 340 360

320 340300280 290270

250 280 310

CONCLUSION OF SISRFIVE TECHNICAL GOOD SITES(After taking Site-17 into account)

1. SITE- 17: Sirindhorn, A. Sirindhorn, UbonRatchatani

2. SITE-16: Phanom Rok, A. Thatako, Nakornsawan,

3. SITE-15: Mai Root, A. Khlong Yai, Trad,4. SITE-12: Khantulee, A. Thachana, Surattani,5. SITE-5: Pak Nam Lamae, A. Lamae,

Chumporn,

SCOPE AND SCHEDULE OF STEPSCOPE AND SCHEDULE OF STEPSCOPE AND SCHEDULE OF STEPSCOPE AND SCHEDULE OF STEP----2222Most of STEP-2 works are detailed study which involved with primary data gathering; field survey and investigation namely:a. Topographic Field Mappinga. Topographic Field Mappinga. Topographic Field Mappinga. Topographic Field Mappingb. Oceanographyb. Oceanographyb. Oceanographyb. Oceanographyc. Geology and Geotechnical Studyc. Geology and Geotechnical Studyc. Geology and Geotechnical Studyc. Geology and Geotechnical Studyd. Hydrologyd. Hydrologyd. Hydrologyd. Hydrologye. Seismologye. Seismologye. Seismologye. Seismologyf. Dose Assessmentf. Dose Assessmentf. Dose Assessmentf. Dose Assessmentg. Land and Water Useg. Land and Water Useg. Land and Water Useg. Land and Water Useh. Endangered Species and Ecologyh. Endangered Species and Ecologyh. Endangered Species and Ecologyh. Endangered Species and Ecologyi. Socioi. Socioi. Socioi. Socio----economic and Cultural Impactseconomic and Cultural Impactseconomic and Cultural Impactseconomic and Cultural Impactsj. Cost Estimation j. Cost Estimation j. Cost Estimation j. Cost Estimation

Site Survey ChallengeSite Survey Challenge

�� Having difficulties accessing some potential sites Having difficulties accessing some potential sites Having difficulties accessing some potential sites Having difficulties accessing some potential sites Having difficulties accessing some potential sites Having difficulties accessing some potential sites Having difficulties accessing some potential sites Having difficulties accessing some potential sites due to local community opposition caused by:due to local community opposition caused by:due to local community opposition caused by:due to local community opposition caused by:due to local community opposition caused by:due to local community opposition caused by:due to local community opposition caused by:due to local community opposition caused by:

Bad experience on past industrial development projectsBad experience on past industrial development projectsBad experience on past industrial development projectsBad experience on past industrial development projectsBad experience on past industrial development projectsBad experience on past industrial development projectsBad experience on past industrial development projectsBad experience on past industrial development projects�� Pollution, Corruption, Unfair CompensationPollution, Corruption, Unfair CompensationPollution, Corruption, Unfair CompensationPollution, Corruption, Unfair CompensationPollution, Corruption, Unfair CompensationPollution, Corruption, Unfair CompensationPollution, Corruption, Unfair CompensationPollution, Corruption, Unfair Compensation

Concerns on public safety (radiation leak and past nuclear Concerns on public safety (radiation leak and past nuclear Concerns on public safety (radiation leak and past nuclear Concerns on public safety (radiation leak and past nuclear Concerns on public safety (radiation leak and past nuclear Concerns on public safety (radiation leak and past nuclear Concerns on public safety (radiation leak and past nuclear Concerns on public safety (radiation leak and past nuclear accidents), possible contamination on agricultural and accidents), possible contamination on agricultural and accidents), possible contamination on agricultural and accidents), possible contamination on agricultural and accidents), possible contamination on agricultural and accidents), possible contamination on agricultural and accidents), possible contamination on agricultural and accidents), possible contamination on agricultural and fishing products, and possible decrease in number of fishing products, and possible decrease in number of fishing products, and possible decrease in number of fishing products, and possible decrease in number of fishing products, and possible decrease in number of fishing products, and possible decrease in number of fishing products, and possible decrease in number of fishing products, and possible decrease in number of touriststouriststouriststouriststouriststouriststouriststourists�� Lack of basic understanding on radiation and nuclear powerLack of basic understanding on radiation and nuclear powerLack of basic understanding on radiation and nuclear powerLack of basic understanding on radiation and nuclear powerLack of basic understanding on radiation and nuclear powerLack of basic understanding on radiation and nuclear powerLack of basic understanding on radiation and nuclear powerLack of basic understanding on radiation and nuclear power

25

NGO leaders in the area of Site 12 has led to people holding protest signs of a nuclear power plant at district office.

26

Other Challenging IssuesOther Challenging Issues

Political instabilityPolitical instabilityPolitical instabilityPolitical instabilityPolitical instabilityPolitical instabilityPolitical instabilityPolitical instabilityPublic education and acceptancePublic education and acceptancePublic education and acceptancePublic education and acceptancePublic education and acceptancePublic education and acceptancePublic education and acceptancePublic education and acceptanceHuman resources developmentHuman resources developmentHuman resources developmentHuman resources developmentHuman resources developmentHuman resources developmentHuman resources developmentHuman resources developmentLaws and regulations for nuclear power Laws and regulations for nuclear power Laws and regulations for nuclear power Laws and regulations for nuclear power Laws and regulations for nuclear power Laws and regulations for nuclear power Laws and regulations for nuclear power Laws and regulations for nuclear power Capability of nuclear regulatory bodyCapability of nuclear regulatory bodyCapability of nuclear regulatory bodyCapability of nuclear regulatory bodyCapability of nuclear regulatory bodyCapability of nuclear regulatory bodyCapability of nuclear regulatory bodyCapability of nuclear regulatory body

28

Thank you Thank you forfor your attention your attention