Top Banner
PErIOHAJ1bHblE 1CCJ1EAOBAHM51 BCEMI4PHOrO BAHKA 16714 Russian POCCH45I Jiecnaw nodlumuKa 6 nepexodHbl# nepuod 4 < / f , - > ^ *, , - ,. g , '3, ^ p ' t' - ,;~~417 i S t '; 'R '[ 1 ' ^ wJLE ,t Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized
348

Russian - World Bank Documents

Feb 21, 2023

Download

Documents

Khang Minh
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Russian - World Bank Documents

PErIOHAJ1bHblE 1CCJ1EAOBAHM51 BCEMI4PHOrO BAHKA

16714Russian

POCCH45I

Jiecnaw nodlumuKa 6 nepexodHbl# nepuod

4< / f , - > ^ *, , - ,. g , '3, ^ p ' t' - ,;~~417

i S t '; 'R '[ 1 ' ^ wJLE ,t

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Page 2: Russian - World Bank Documents

- -

Page 3: Russian - World Bank Documents

PErHOHAJbHblIE HCCAEflOBAHHA BCEMHPHOrO BAHKA

PoccwqJIecHafi J7O,THTKa B fIepeXOCI Il1HepHO)T

BCCMHPITH.if 6aHKBaHHrrOH, OKPYT Koj]yM6Hq

Page 4: Russian - World Bank Documents

O AzropcKoe ripaBo 1997 r.

MernyapoAHmU 6aHK pOKOHC1PpyxwU

H pa3rKlM/BccMHpHwft 6aHK

1818 H Street, N.W.Washington, D.C. 20433, U.S.A.

Bce ripaBa coxpaHnorcsIH3DaHO B COCnHHeHHUX IIlTaTax AmepluK

lepBoe H3sHHC - HIOHb 1997 r.

PerHoHanbHue HCCJICAOBIHH* BcomupHoro 6aHxa BlUIIOTCsI acwmio MHOrOqjHCnHHh1X

AnOJIOB (nepBoHanamnHo rioAnrOoBeHHux AiS cJyxe6Horo OIM1b3oBOHRR) B XoAC IOCTOSHHO

DeMMyRettc B BaHKe anainMIqecXoit pa6oTw no H3yqWHH)O 3KoHoMuHecKoro rioJioxeHSK u powix

yCJoBuA B pa3BHBwiouwXCq c7paHax-vIeHax BaHKa H juanora c upB m 3TUX CTpaH. PRA

AOKIMOB HacTosmett COpHU rry6JiKyeTc C MHHHManSHott 3aAepXKOA H npeAHa3Hawaercq Ana

npaBHThCBeHHblx OpraHoB, HayYHUx, ACJIOBbNX H *HHaHCOBUX KpyrOB, a TaiKKe opraHH3mxKHt,

3aHHMaiouHXcn BoripoCaMU pa3BrHTm. nocKoAbKy pyKonucb Hwamsnuero ccjie0oBaHuS He 6una

noAroToBJeHa ciporo B coarmeTcTBH c rOPSoIKOM rry6mncauHm 04HWUIaJbHUX T oKCToB, BCCMHpHuJ

6aHK He HeCeT OTBTCMTBCHHOCTH 3a ZonylyeHHbLC oUuI6KH. HeKoTopme Hc'ro'HHK, ULTuPyeMUe B

HacTos=et pa6ore, SMXorci Ho04UH1UaAbHwMH, ManOAOCTynHhiMH AoYyMeHTaMx.

BCeMHpHuA 6aHK He rapaHTUpyeT TOYHOCTH AaHH=X, COAepXaBUHXCs B HacTO=lMeft

ny6JiHKaRu, H He HeCeT OTBTCTBeHHOCTU 3a nOCjieACTBHR UX crronA3oBaHHH. rpaHMUU, iWB,

o6o3H8aeHHA H CBeAeHUH, npUBoAUMbwe B KapTax, BKJlOYeHHUX B Hacroaiyo ny6iuuaiumo, He

o3Ha'48IoT MHCHHA rpynri BCeMWpHOro 6aHKa OTHOCWTeJbHO ripaoBoro cTaTyca KaKot-nH6o

TeppHTopuH KHDSe rroAwBCpAeHHK Unl HpH3HaHHn o6O3HaqCHHhIX rpaSHu.

Marepmani HacToguero H3,RaHSI oXpaHAfoTcA H3arTenbcKxM npaBom. 3a pa3pCemHMeM Ha

neperenaTKy 0TrAe3bHUx MmaTepHIoB o6paujaTbmc B H3naTa7tCKHft OTJrcJ no aapecy, YKB38HHOMY B

B&uInpHBCAeHHOM yBIAomieHHH o6 aBropcKxU npanax. BCIMHpHuit 6aHK ripxBeivryeT

pwCnpmOTpaHCHHe ry6AHKyeMbix HM MaTrpHIoB, H, KaK npaBHJo, pa3pe11ICHHC Ha nepeneLaTKy

MarepHaJIOB BbUlJaTCR OrIepaTHBHO, a B CAYryaC HeKOMMepYeCKOro HCnr11b3OBaHHSl - 6ecnrUlaHO.

Pa3peuleHHe Ha nepenevarKy oTrrAbHux maTepHaIOB B yqe6HMx uennx MOXHo nonyqwrs no aApecy:

Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., Suite 910, 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, Massachusetts 01923, U.S.A.

(1)orIpa4fH Ha o6noxKe: JIyu Kap6oHbe

ISBN: 0-8213-4005-0 (HrAaHHe Ha PYCCKOM s3uKe)

ISSN: 0253-2123

PeKBNnUn H3JaHH no KcaTanory BH6JIOTCKH KoHrpecca CIIA:

RusiaW forest policy during transition.p. cm. - (A World Bank country study)

Includes bibliographical references. (p.).ISBN 0-8213-3896-X1. Forest policy-Russia (Federation)-20th century.2. Forest management-Russia (Federation)-20th century.3. Forest products industry-Russia (Federation)-20th century.

1. World Bank. 11. Series.SD629.R87 1997333.75'0947-dc21 97-1111

CIP

Page 5: Russian - World Bank Documents

iii

Orj]ABEHHE

BcHyncN..e...viii

BCA...HH. X

AHH ltSUH...Xi

BMp=ecHme npmH3H=TIbHmOCH. xii

CnucoK npUHsITX COPaCHK...l.. xiv

BaEKoTHMC 9KB. ..N..HTI. XV

P ....... I

1. JICCHMC peCyppCb H XapapTCpHCTHKa .TeCHOrO CeKpa. .31

A. Ilpo6.ieMbneC..eoro cepa. .36

nocneacomTDH 'pe3MepHoig 3KcnfyaTaUuuHH iiCOB .36

nIpOTHBOpemmHS B .IeCHOM 3aKoHoAaTejibCTBe. .37

TPY.AHOCTH B BbIlOJIHCHHH nlpHpOAOOXpaHHb1X O6SI3aTeJibCTB .39

OFpaHHqeHHaR AOCeTynHOCTb H ocJia6JIeHHoe cOCTOSHHC JICCHbIX peypcoB .42

4pe3MepHblg ypOBeHb Ao6bilH AHKHX UKHBOTHbJX, pbi6b H ApyrHX HeApeBeCHbiX ileCHbIXpe e yp e os.47

Ocjia6neHHe rioTcHumana JIeCHOu HaYKH .48

B. 3KohioruqecKoe 3HaqCHme AeCHoro ceKTopa .49

CHCTeMa 4qeZepanbHbix oco6o oxpaHSeMbix npHPOAHIuX TeppHTOpHI =.R coxpaHeHHS6Hopa3moo6pa3.....49

Jleca PoccHH H rao6anbHbUA yrAepoAHubi 6aaHC. .51

l.pyrHe HCTO'HHKH Bo3AeRCTBHS Ha OKpYXpmOWYIO cpey .52

B. 3KOHOMHmeCKoe 3Ha'eHHe .iecHoro ceTopa .52

rloTeHuHan npOH3DoACTBa ApeBecHHbi .53

OTpaCJIH, 3aBHCsiuHe OT J1econpoMb1u1jeHHori npOayKuli . .............................................................. 553KcnopThbi nOTeHumal .55

HaniOrH H noneHHaS niiaTa .59

3aroToBwTenrbHbe H AepeBonepepa6aTbiBaiouHe npeanpHRTHS .62

TexHojiorHLecKme H HHBeCTHUHOHHbie npo6neMbl aepeBonepepa6aTniBaIoLuegnpoO . . . . . . . . . . ... 643apa6oTiHSa niiaTa H 3aHRTOCTb ................................................................................................ 66

r. COLtHanbHoe 3HaLieHHe JIecHoro ceKTopa ............................................................................................... 67HaceAeHHe necHHux patoHOB H cmcTeMa couHanbHoro o6c eicHHSI. .68

HenpaBwTeinbCTSeHHble OpraHH3aUHH: CBM3H H COTpyAHmICcTBO ........................................................ 69

PI.. JlccoynpasneHHe .70

(PHHaHCHpoBaHHue JecHoro XO3SlcTBa. .70

Page 6: Russian - World Bank Documents

iv

JlecoycTpoH cTso ............................................................................. 71

Pa3MeweHHe JeCHb1X pecypcoB ............................................................................. 72

Jleco3aroToBKa, BocnPOH3BOACTBO neca H yXOA 3a HaCax)aeHHS1MH ..................................................... 72Bopb6a C JieCHbIMH no)KapaMH, HaCeKOMbIMH H 6oJie3HqMH ............. ................................................. 79

E. BiHnAHtie nepexoaa K pbIHOqHOtH 3KOHOMHKe ....................................................................................... 80

11. KAoqeBEle 3aAaH JieCH oro c eKTopa B nepexoAHEu r nepHoA ............................................................................ 84

A. BeaoMcTBeHHo-npaBoBble ycJoBHSi pauHOHanbHoro ynpaEmeiH ........................................................ .85

'lacTHasA Hn rocynapcTBeHHas co6cTBeHHocTb ............................................................................. 86

Onpe,aeJeHHe poAn rocCyapCTBeHHbrX CTpyKyp B JeCHOM ceKTope ...................................................o. 87

B. CoxpaHeHHe YCTOHMHBOCTU pecypca H uenoCTHOCTH OKpyxaKoWer cpeabi .........................................Coca.I 90

YTOxHeHHe napameTpoB peCYPCHol 6a3bi Am c6aaAaHcuHpoBaHHoro UP0H3BOACTBa ApeBcuHbl........ 90

CoxpaHeHHe 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3Hi ............................................................................. 92

CoxpaHeHHe YCTOixHBOCTH peCYPCOB Ha OCHoBe pacnpeaeAeHHeH 3eMenJb no BHlaMnonb30oBaHH ............................................................................. 93

CoBepwueHCTBOBaHHe cTpaTeFHH BOCnpoH3BOaCTBa J1eCHb1X pecypcoB ................................................ 96

CoKpawueHHe ywep6a OT no)KapoB, BpeaUTTeieg H U6one3He .............................................................. 99

BBeaeHHe npHpofooxpaHHbIX HopMaTHBOB B BapyrHx oTpacix ......................................................... 100

B. YCTO1qHBOCTb H 3KoHoMHq'eCKaq )KH3Hecnoco6HocTb KaK ueJnu peopraHM3auHH ceKTopa ............... 02

CoBepweHcTBOBaHHe MexaHH3Ma ycTaHoBAeHHq LeH Ha necHbie pecypcbi ........................................ 102

Pa3rpaHHMeHHe MmeKay peHTHoH i naTo1 3a i 3a pecypcbi H Haioroo6AoxKeHHeM npeanpHATHA ............. 103

OcJla6neHHe Bi4ac MOHonojHm ............................................................................. 105

r. CoutiaribHoe o6ecnetleHHe B iiecHoM ceicrope ..................................................................................... 106

OnpeaeAeHHe npaB 3eMjienoAb3oBaHH9 KOpeHHOrO HaceCJeHHA Ha cneULaJIbHO oTBeaeHHbiXTePPHTOPHAX ............................................................................. 10706ecneqeHHe HaCei1eHHA JIeCHbIX paHOHOB a4eKBaTHblMH COuHa4JbHb[MH ycnyraMH ........................ 108

Co3aaHHe nporpamM 3aHJTOCTH HAM HaceJeHHR, noTepABuwero pa6oTy B CBH13H C peC4opMamH ....... 109

YaoMeL opeTpHme noTpe6HocTeA B couHaLJbHOM o6ecnetieHHH KOpeHHorO HaceneHHH9 ..................... 110

111. HeKmoopbie npeAnoxeHHS rio npoBeOAeHHo pedFopmbE iiecHoro ceKTopa . ................................

A. 1IHTerpauHq iiecHoro ceKropa B CHCTeMy 3KOHoMH4ecKHx pe4opM .................................................. I

B. nlepeXOa K c6aniaHciipoBaHHoMy ynpaBneHH)o JiecaMH ....................................................................... 114

B. PaLoHamn3aumH rocyaapCTBeHHbIx KanHTaBjbHbIX H TeKyUHX 3aTpaT ............................................... I18

r. POJb MeXLyHaPOaHOrO coo6iuecTBa .................... 120

KpaTKocpoHbHue MepbI noAaep)KKH ped4OpMbI (B TeqeHHe cieay]OIuHx aByX SieT) .............................. 24

CpeAHecpo4HbJe MepbI nOAaep)KKH (B TeYeHHe 6nH)KawuHx ABYX-nqTH neT) ................................... 127

AoArocpO4Hbie mepbl noaaepKKH (B Te4eHHe fixarlwero AeCqTHJeTHq) .......................................(B l127

,. rlpeanoeeHni no aanbHeCWHM HccneaoBaHHIM ..................................................................... 129

JhiipaTypa .............................................................................. 132

roccapdHl iecHux TepMHHOB ........................................................................................................................... 135

IppHjoKeHHsH ................................................................... 141

Page 7: Russian - World Bank Documents

v

npJRoxeHwR ........................................................................... 141

lpHnoxeHHe A: AlecHHe pecypcu H JiecHoe Xo3mCTBO ........................................................................... 142

rpDaoxKeHHe B: OpraHH3awroHHa[ cTpyKTypa ilecHoro ceKTopa ................................................................ 180

rpHnoxceHHe B: Pa3BmTme necHOro 3aKOHoAaTeJHCTBM B POCCHiCKOt1 e)eAepaUK t ..................................... 207

npioxeHHe r: CocTostHe necOnpomMUmICHHoro KoMnnTIeKca: TOprIOBJI, 1xeHb1 H HajioroBLIe

nocTymneHHg ........................................................................... 225

rIpHIoxeHHe A: 3HaYeHue TpaHCHOpT2 H nOpTOBUX CoopyxceHHA IS yCTOAIBOro pa3BHTHS

eCOIIpOML eHHOro KoMuieKca ............................................................................ 257

lpfuIoxceHHe E: lIpHBaTH3aiwA B neCHOM ceKTope H 3KOHoMHqecKHe peC4OpMb1 Ha ypOBHe

ripeArnpHu sr ............................................................................................................. ................. 264

rpunoxeHHe XC: YpoBeHE 6eAHocTH, 6e3pa6oTHua H c4cTeMa coHaHaJThHOt 3aluTbI B nieCHbIX pakOHaX.... 273

rlpHnoxeHHe 3: CHcTeMa oco6o oxpaHsqeMux npHpOAHUx TePPTopHA B paMKax iiecHoro ceropa ........... 293

HpIuoaIceHHe 14: YnpaBnKeHHe pecypcamHaRKHx )KHBoTHbIx H ycwti4'IHBoe pa3B C JIeCHor-o cecropa ...... 297

IlpvIoxeHHe K: MexliyHapoxuHik onuT ycneMHott peanjH3a8ULH nporpaMM Ho yCTotqIBoMy pa3BHTiuo

JIecHOro ceCK Opa ............................................................................................................. 311

npHnoxeHHe Jl: MeaWyHapogHme nporpaMMe B HecHom ceKHepe Poccuu . ................................................I 330

Kapmi:

IBRD 228760: .......... lepeBo1 reorpa4)HecKmx o6o3HaqeHHI

IBRD 27086R: ............. THrin AecoB H oxpaHAemue eppwropHH

IBRD 27087R: ............. JIecHaS HHAYCTpHS H nOTOKH JieCHUX rpy3oB

IBRD 28353: ......... OxpaHa IecoB OT noxapoB

IBRD 28354: ......... OpraHH3auu iiecoycTpoftcTa H JiecHotl HayKH

Page 8: Russian - World Bank Documents

vi

ClHCOK TAEKUL, CnIPABOK 1 PHCYHKOB

Ta6nuua 1. KAio'eBbIe peKoMeH.aamm no pe4lopMHpOBaHHio AecHoro ceicropa PoccHu ............... 25

Ta6JiHua 1.1. HJlowuaQb JIeCOB H aanac ApeBeCHHbi B oTaeAbHbIX cTpaHax, 1990 r ............................... 40Ta6niuua 1.2. OueHKa 3anaca CBSI3aHHoro yriiepoAa B 6opeabIbHblX neCHbIX 3KOCUCTeMax .................. 42Ta6Jnuua 1.3. PacnpeaneaeHe neCHbIX 3eMeJb POCCIiH no perHoHaM H KaTeroptImM 3eMeAb,

1993 r ............................................................................... 45Ta6inrua 1.4. OueHKa 6HojIoruHeCKOro noTeHuHaAa JieCOB B pa3HbIX perHoHax PoccuH ........ ............ 54Ta6nuua 1.5. IloTpe6neHHe ApeBecHOui npOJYKUMH B POCCHu B 1989 H 1993 rr ................................. 56Ta6inuua 1.6. 3KcnOPT H3 PoccHu Kpyrnioro neca H nHJIoMaTepHanoB, 1992-1995 rr .......................... 57Ta6.nuua 1.7. 9KCnopTn iCeconpoMbIWneHHoH npO.YKUH1H 3 Pocciu, 1995 r ..................................... 60Ta6inuua 1.8. HoTeHiuHaJ]bHbie roaoBbie HanioroBbIe aoXabi OT JieCHoro ceicropa PoccuH ................ 63Ta6inua 1.9. 14HBeCTIUHOHHbIe noTpe6HOcTH ileCHoro ceicropa Poccuu, no pacqeTam

PocnecnpoMa ............................ .. 66Ta6rnuta 1.10. BlQoL1KeT AecHoro Xo3qARCTBa B 1991-1996 rr ................................................................... 75Ta6Anuua 1.11. QLonii pa3HbJX BHAOB npOH3BoacTBeHHOH .ieRTeIbHoCTH B o6feM 6ioixeTe

AecHoro XO3Rt1CTBa B 1991-96 rr .76

Ta6nuua 2.1. nAnouaAb HenpoMbIuweHHbIX 'acTHbIX neCHblX 3eMenbB OT2ReAbHbiX ctpaHax MHpa, 1983 roa ....................................................................... 87

Ta6iuiua 2.2. OxoT a B KpaCHOSPCKOM Kpae, 1993-1994 rr ................................................................... 93

Ta6rnuua 3.1. 14HTerpauPq J1eCHoro CeKTopa B npoUecc 3KOHOMHqeCKHX pefopm ........................... 112Ta6mnua 3.2. nepexOa K pauHOHaJIbHOMy ynpaBneHHIo JiecaMl ....................... ................................. 115Ta6rnuua 3.3 PauHoHaJnH3atHw rOCcylapCTBeHHb1X KarHTa8JbHb1X 14 TeKYlUHX 3aTpaT ........ ................ 120Ta6niuua 3.4. JAecoXo3JrncTBeHHbie npoeKTbI, ocyluecTBAAemble MeeXyHapO2Hb1M

coo6LuecTBoM ............... 121Ta6nuua 3.5. Pob MeeKyHapOHoro coo6luecTBa .......................................... 123

CnpaBKa 1. 1. rjio6ajlbHoe 3HaqeHHe nTeCOB POCCHu ..................................... 34CnpaBKa 1.2. O6.q3aTenbcTBa POCCHu no BbHOJIHeHHiKO MmeXKZyHaPOaHbIX coriaweHHui no

AeCHbIM pecypcaM ..................................................... 40CnpaBKa 1.3. KpacHospcKHA H Xa6apoBcKHR Kpaq: KapTHHa pa3Hoo6pa3Hq ..................................... 46CnpaBKa 1.4. Korna ociia6eBaeT noTeHuani ieCHOC HaB HaYKH ................................................. 4.8............ 48CnpaBKa 1.5. CHcTeMa oco6o oxpaHqeMb1x HpHPOaHb[X TeppC1Top11i Pocciu ..................................... 50CnpaBKa 1.6 PeiuKMbi niecHoro XO3fl.cTBa B pa3Hbix rpynnax niecOB rocyaapcTBeHHorO

iecHoro 4OHJaa ............. ,53CnpaBKa 1.7. CHHKKeHHe U ycTpaHeCHJie 3KCrOpTHbIx 6apbepoB D eCHori npoAyKUHH .......nna............ 59CnpaBKa 2.1. Tpe6oBaHrH. BceMHpHoro 6aHKa no paLLHOHaJbHOMY ynpaBJeHHIo 4

HeHcToLUMTeCJbHoMy noJIb3oBaHlIO JecaMH ................ .............................. 91CnpaBKa 2.2. CoxpaHeHHe 6mopa3Hoo6pa3Hq .............................................. 94CnpaBKa 2.3. POCCUUCKU1U onbiT B o6nacTm pacnpeaeneHHus H nJiaHHpoBaHHq

MCrIOAIb3OBaHH.S 3eMeJlb .94CnpaBKa 2.4. $11HaHCUpOBaBuIIWmcs BceMipHblM 6aHKoM npOeKT nO BoccTaHoBn1eHHIO

KiTaIiCKHX AecOB, nocTpa.aBuWHx OT noxcapa ................................................ 101.

PHCYHOK 1.1. 061beMbi .jecO3aroTOBOK B Poccuiur, 1980-96 ................................................. 33PHCYHOK 1.2. HeKoTopble xapaKTepHCTUKH COCTOSIHHq MlipOBb]X HU pOCC4ICKHX necoB B

1990-x r.r .41PUCYHOK 1.3. PacnpeaeneHme nfoWaaH nieCHblX 3eMenib B Pocciitu no perHoHam u

KaTeropmMm, 1993 r ........................................................................... 43PHCYHOK 1.4. KaTerop1H 3eMeCJb B cOCTaBe rocyXaapCTBeHHoro iieCHoro 4)OHaa PoccHui .................... 44PHCYHOK 1.5. CTpyKTypa H TeHaSeHUH4 3KcnopTBa ecoMaTepHaAoB U3 PoccHH ................................... 58

PHCYHOK 1.6. nocTynAlleHeaeHe)KHbIX cpeaCTB Ha 4jHHaHcHpoBaHHe n1ecHoro ceKTopaPoccuH B 1993-95 rr .73

Page 9: Russian - World Bank Documents

vii

PHCYHOK 1.7. nociynnIeHHe cpeACTB Ang fUHaHCHpOBaHHR nJcHoro ceKTopa coriiacHonpoeKTy AecHoro KoaeKCa POCCHUCKOt 0PcnepaUHH (lonb 1996) ........................... 74

PHCYHOK 1.8. MeToAb BocnPOH3BO)ICTBa neCHbX peCYPCOB B KpaCHOqPCKOM Kpae, 1985-96 ........... 78PHCYHOK 1.9. npmqHHbi rH6nH neCHblX HacaceHM9, 1984-95 r.r ..................................................... 81PUCYHOK 2.1. npeAnaraeMbaA npouecc nJIaHMpOBaHHR 3eMjienojib3OBaHHR Ha nOKpblTbIX

JiecoM 3eMjnx .98

Page 10: Russian - World Bank Documents

viii

BCTYnAEHJE

J1eCHOr4 CeKTop POCCHH UMeeT o6iueeMHpoBoe 3HateHHe, -TO o6ycnoBJIeHo ero

pa3mepami (22% MI4pOBOrO 3anaca nIeCHbIX peCypCoB), o6beMoM yrnepoaHoro 3anaca

(15% pacqeTHbIX Ha3eMHbIX 3aFIacOB u 75% o6iuero 3anaca yrmepoaa B 3OHe

6opeajlbHblx nIecOB), npOH3BOaCTBeHHbIMH B03MO)KHOCTRM1 (no H MeiOmuMCq

oueHKaM 21% o6iueMHpoBoro pacqeTHoro 3anaca neca Ha KOpHIO H iao nocnJeaHero

BpeMeHi 6o0nee 10% MHPOBOro npo43BOaCTBa apeBecHbl), 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3HeM

(BaXIHeriwHe paiiOHbI EBpa3HrcKoro 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3Hq). He MeHee Ba)KHbIM

RBjS1eTC5I HauHOHanJbHoe 3Ha'eHHe AecHoro ceKTopa B CBS3H C ero BKJIaaOM B

4OPMHpOBaH4e BajiOBorO HaLUHOHajibHoro npoayicra (6o0nee 2%), 3KCnOpTHbIX

nocTyniieHHr4 (6o0ee 5%), o6ecneqeHHe 3aHATOCTH HacejieH[4i (2 MJIH. qejioBeK), H

orpoMHOr4 POJIbIO B )KH3HH KOpeHHbIX HapoaOB, HaCeiJqiOLU14X 3TH TeppHTOpHH.

5naroaapsq cBoeMy 4CTOpH'ecKoMy onbITY BeLeHH5 iiecHoro XO3.qr4CTBa PoccHR

cTaIia flpH3HaHHbIM JiH2epOM B cd)epe oxpaHbl JIeCOB, HaY4HbIX HccJieaOBaHHrl H

pa3pa6oToK. OAHaKO nOJIHTHKa UeHTpaJIH3OBaHHOrO nJ1aHHpOBaHH$ HPH4BeJIa K

npaKTHKe HCTOLUHTenJbHOrO AeconoJIb3oBaHH5, o6HapycKHBuwercA Ha 3Tane nepexoza

K pbIHO'-HO 3KOHOMHKe. HecMOTps5 Ha OrpOMHbie 3aflaCbi JeCHbIX peCypCOB H

yCTOWIHBbl cnpOC Ha JieconpoMbwllJeHHYIO npOLyK1UHIO Ha MUpOBOM pbIHKe,

neeCHOU CeKTOp POCCHuu HCHbITbIBaeT Cepbe3Hbie Hpo6JIeMbl B o6JIlaCTH

necoynpaBseHHR, npeaUaCTaBjimmuX yrpo3y Xni$ coUHaJ1bHo-3KoHoMH4ecKo0

CTa6HJIbHOCTH ceKcopa H 3KOJlOrHqeCKOrU L1eJIOCTHOCTH IieCOB. 3TH nipo6n1eMbl

ABJISHOTCA Cepbe3HbIM ipenATCTBHeM Ha riyTr K YCTOfiwBOMY pa3BHTHIO AecHoro

ceKTopa H Tpe6yloT CpO4Horo nOHCKa nyTeu Hx pelueHHI.

B 3TOU CBA3H npaBHTejibCTBO POCCHUiCKOri (DeaepaLUHH o6paTHnocb KO

BceMHPHoMy 6aHKy C npocb6or C(DopMHpoBaTb rpynny Mew)yHapoAHbIx 3KcnepTOB

11HA npoBeaeHHA BCeCTOPOHHerO aHaJIH3a iieCHoro ceKcopa H ieCHOi nOOJIHTHKH,

onpegemnoLuerl OCHOBHble HanpasBJeHH5 ero pa3BHTH51. COTPYP,HUKU BceMHpHoro

6aHKa pa6oTaTI B TeCHOM B3aHMoaer1CTBHI C pOCCUUCKHMH cneuHaj]HCTaMH,

BHecwIHMH HeoLxeHHMbli BKjnan B nOarOTOBKy HacTo0ILuero aoKna,a. B aomnaae

ocBeeuaeTcs 3HaMeHHe nIeCHbIX peCypCoB POCCHu, paccmaTpHBaeTc. noJoKXeHHe AeA B

ceKTope, onpelejiAloTcs OCHOBHbIe npo6.neMbl H B03MO)KHOCTH CeKTOpa B nepeXOL,HbIri

nepHo,a. KpoMe Toro, npexiaraioTcs5 Mepbi no peqIopMHpOBaHHIO necHoro ceKTopa H

aaeTCA oUeHKa noTpe6HOCTH B roCyLapCTBeHHbIX HHBeCTHUHIX, a TaKwe

TeXHH4eCKOrO H q HHaHCOBOrO COae9CTBHsI CO CTOPOHbl Me)KAyHapOAHoro

coo6wecTBa.

OpHeHTaUHA Ha yCTO941Boe pa3BHTHe neCHOrO CeKTOpa B nepHOL nepexoaa K

pbIHOHHOUi 3KOHOMHKe noTpe6yeT ae9CTBHir nO MHortIM HanpaBnIeHHSM.

npaBHTenibCTBy HeO6XORHMO pa3pa6oTaTb H Ha npaKTHKe peauH3OBaTb J1eCHYIO

nOJIHTHKY H lpaBOBbIe HOpMbI, 6JiaronpHs4TCTByIOLuHe yCTONMHBOMy ynpaBJAeHHIo

JIeCHbIMH pecypcamH H o6ecneqHBaioUHe MaKCHM[43aUHIO Bbiroa, nOJly1aeMbIX B

pe3yJIbTaTe HCInOJib3OBaHH5 H OXpaHbI JieCHbIX peCypCOB. PSAi mep B 3TOM

HanpaBJieHHi npeaJIaraeTCA B HOBOM JIeCHOM KOaeKCe POCCHUCKOUt (Deaepautu.

OziHaKo fIA BbinOJIHeHHT TaKOg pa6oTbl noTpe6yeTCA TBeplaa HpUBep)KeHHOCTb BCex

Page 11: Russian - World Bank Documents

ix

ypOBHeU rOCyXapCTBeHHOU BjiaCTH KyPCY YCKOpeHHOrO HpOBeAeHHR KOpeHHbIXpe4opM B o6nacTH ynpaBiieHHq H oxpaHbl neCHbIx pecypcoB, a TaK)Ke TecHoeCOTPY,aHHUeCTBO rocyAapCTBeHHOrO H 'aCTHOrO CeKTopa.

HacTo.wHU14 1 aoKAaa npeacTaBjsineT HHTepec XIR rocy1apCTBeHHbIX,4O0JKHOCTHbIX JIHU POCCHfCKOiI O1eaepaLuHH, HX COBeTHHKOB, a TaK)Ke railAnpe,acTaBHTeneri pa3J!HqHbIX coLuHaJbHbix rpynri H opraHH3aLxHif, HenocpeacTBeHHo3aHHTepeCOBaHHblX B pa6oTe nieCHoro celcropa, BKJloqas KOpeHHOe HaceJIeHHe,HerIpaBHTeJIbCTBeHHbIe, HayqHbIe H yme6Hbie opraHH3aLtHH, pOCCHIICKHe HMex2yHapOaHble 'aCTHbIe KOMnaHHr4, areHTCTBa, ocyLIeCTBJSlOwUHe npOrpaMMbI,AByCTOpOHHero COTpyAHH4eCTBa, H Mex(AyHapoaHbie 4uHHaHCOBbie yqpexzIeHH4. MbIHaAeeMCA, 'TO aoxiiaa 6yaeT 1OJie3HbIM aUSI BCeX, KTO 3aHHTepecoBaH B cogetiCTBHHYCTOAM1HBOMy pa3BHTHIO pOCCHr4CKOrO niecHoro ceKTopa H nOBblwleHHH ero pOjiH BycieWuHOM ocyL1eCTBjieHHH nepexoaa K pbIHO'IHOA 3KOHOMHKe.

IOKOH XyaHr,LaHpeKTop I l-ro cTpaHoBoro,aenapTaMeHTa perHOHaEBporIbI H UeHTpanbHOtu A3uuBceMHpHoro 6aHKa

Page 12: Russian - World Bank Documents

x

BBEAEHHE

npeAnaraeMbitS 4HTaTeniio AoKnaA BCeMHpHOrO 6aHKa tPoccHH: JiecHaS

nlOJIHTHKa B nlepeXOAHbik nIepHOAJ npeACTraBneT Ha CerOAHfWHHU AeHb YHHKalbHylO

nOnbITKy BCeCTOpOHHerO aHaJIH3a nlpO6ieM, CTOiWuHX nepeA KpyniHCeIHM B Mmpe

HaLUOHaJlbHbIM JleCHbIM KOMnYUeKCOM B YCJOBHSIX AMHaMH'eCKHX m3MeHeHHU Ha

nOpOre HOBOrO TbIcRq,e'ieTHS.

CneAyeT noAqepKHyTb, 4TO OCHOBHbIe BbiBOAbi H peKOMeHAauUH AOK^aAa

oTpaxKaxor nO3HLIHIO COTPYAHHKOB BceMHPHoro 6aHKa H ripH 3TOM Heo6sl3aTeJlbHO

IIOJIHOCTbIO pa3AeJiRiOTC 0eAepaBAbHog cAyx6og iieCHoro X03HSitCTBa POCCHICKOri

OeAepaUHH. TeM He MeHee, BblCOKO OLUeHHBaiO CaM 4)aKT nOAf'OTOBKH H

CBOeBpeMeHHOrO Ony6jTHKOBaHHH AoKIaAa. Oco6yio BaXHOCTb, Ha HawU B3riHA,

HMeeT aAeKBaTHa5 OueHKa rjio6ajibHOr 3HaBHMOCTH iiecHoro KoMnIeKca POCCHH, a

TaKoKe HHTerpHpOBaHHbik, Me)KoTpacAeBot nOAXOA K aHaHM3y 3KojiorHqecKHx,

PeCYPCHblX, COUUHabHO-3KOHOMHMeCKHX, (bHHaHCOBbIX H aAMHHHCTpaTHBHo-

npaBoBbix acnecKToB ero ycTokqHBoro pa3BHTHq.

noAroToBKa TaKOro AoKJiaAa He 6biua 6bl B03MOxHoI 6e3 aKTHBHOrO BKJiaAa

pOCCHUCKHX CnleUHaJIHCTOB - JlecoBOAoB, 3KOHOMHCTOB, 3KOjiOrOB, COUHOAOiOB H

IOpHCTOB, BbIPa3HBwIerOCR B nlOArOTOBKe HMH o6HpHbIX MaTepHajioB no BceM

noxoTpacism neCHOrO KoMnUieKca H B nocAeAY0IOUeM peiteH3HpOBaHHH pa6oqero

BapHaHTa aoKuaAa. XoTen1ocb 6bl Bbipa3HTb yBCpeHHOCTb B TOM, 'rTO ny611HKauHq

aoKuaAa H ero WIHuOKoe o6cyKxAeHHe 6yAyF CnOCo6cTBOBaTb yrjiy6JIeHHIO AHaaorapOCCHUCKHX fleCHbIX BeAOMCTB C Me)KAYHaPOAHbIMH 4 UHaHCOBO-3KOHOMHqeCKHMH

OpraHH3aUH.IMH, areHTCTBaMH ABYCTOpOHHerO COTPYAHHMeCTBa, HenpaBHTenb-

CTBeHHblMH OprBaHH3aUHAMH H 'acTHbIM ceKTopoM. HaAebocb, qTo TaKOR AHajlornpHBeAeT K pa3pa6OTKe COBMeCTHbiX npOeKTOB H nporpaMM, HanpaBJ1eHHbIX Ha

yCTOt'qUBOe pa3BHTHe necHoro KoMnneKca.

BaMepHu WJY6HH,

PYKOBOAHTeCb (eAepaJbHOf cny2ix6bInecHoro X03.tACTBa POCCHUCKOA cDeAepatHH

Page 13: Russian - World Bank Documents

xi

AH HOTALI141

JeCHOR ceKTop PoccHH HMeeT OrpOMHOe HaUUlOHajibHOe H MHpOBOe 3HaJeHHe,nOCKOAbKy o6na,iaeT KpyHHeHlIUHMH B MHpe JIeCHbIMH pecypcamU H UeHHOCT.9MHo6iijeMHpOBOrO 3HaMeHMS1 B niiaHe COXpaHeHH5 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3H4 HU npeaOTBpaLUeHHq

H3MeHeHH$ MHPOBoro KJIHMaTa. Bnaroiaps MepaM no cTa6HAH3auLHH 3KOHOMHKH HCTPYKTYPHbIM ped)OpMaM, npOBeaeHHbIM B POCCHu 3a nocileaHHe nHTb JIeT,CyileCTBeHHO pacWLHpHJIHCb nepCrieKTHBbi nOBbleHUHH5I 344eKTHBHOCTH pa6oTblceKTopa. TeM He MeHee, npeACTOHT 6o.nbwasi pa6oTa B nnaHe COaeCCTB14AyCTo0u4HBOMY pa3BHTHIO iiecHoro ceKTopa. B HacToHLLueM 1oKJIaAa aaAH3HpyeTcAnojiHTHKa B o6ilaCTH JieCHOrO CeKTOpa B nepHoa nepexoaa K pbIHO4HOrU 3KOHOMHKe H

B nocneAyloUHe rOJbi.

B oKma,4e 1AaeTcs xapaKTepHCTKa IeCHbIX peCYpCOB H aHanuH3HupyOTC5nOKa3aTeniH niecHoro ceKTopa, a Taic)Ke OCHOBHbie TpyHOCTTH, C KOTOpblMH

CTaJIKHBaeTcCS ceKTOp Ha nepexoaHoM 3Tane; npexiara1oTc51 BapUaHTbl peweHHSOCHOBHblX nlpo6ieM; OCBeiiaeTCs pOJAb 'aCTHOrO CeKTopa, HeHipaBHTeJIbCTBeHHbIXopraHH3aUHri, areHTCTB aBYCTOpOHHero COTpyaHHMeCTBa H MeeA(AyHapOaHbIX(bHHaHCOBbIX yqpe)geHHui. B aoKmaae coaepKaTcsq peKoMeH,auuHH no coXIeuCTBHIOyCTOrUHBOMy pa3BHTH1O iecHoro KoMHneKca Ha nepexoaHoM 3Tane H

nOTv4epKHBaeTCSI, 'ITO Bce 6yywuHe nleCHbie nlporpaMMbi aOJDKHbl pa3pa6aTbIBaTbCs Buejisjx coaeAiCTBHA peanUaUuu AeCHbIx rpoeKTOB, )KH3Hecnoco6HbIx B3KOJIOrH4eCKOM, COLUHanJbHOM H 3KOHOMHUeCKOM riaHe HCXOL5 H3 HPHUHnIHOB

3KOHOMHMeCKOi 3I"eKTHBHOCTH H AOJ1rOCpOMHbIX pe3yJIbTaTOB. PeKOMeHaaUH4BKJiOMalOT HHTerpauHIO neCHoro ceKwopa B o6uwH npouecc 3KOHOMH'eCKHx ped)opM,nepexoA K yCTOWlHBOMy yHpaBJeHH10 ieCCoHOAOb3oBaHHeM, paLIHOHM13ammH

rocyLrapCTBeHHbIX HHBeCTHuHui H pacXOAOB, H 6onee 3(bd)eKT4BHoe BoBJeIeHtlemeAlZyHapOAHOM coo6iuecTBa Ha OCHOBe KOHCYJIbTauHI4 C 3aUHTepeCOBaHHblMH

CTOpOHaMH.

OCylueCTBjieHme peKOMeHayeMbiX mep lpHBefeT K Bbipa6OTKe OCHOBHaUHOHajIbHOU AeCHOu roJIHTHKH, o6ecne4LBamouer paLuHOHanbHoe HcHojib3OBaHHeH coxpaHeHue JIeCHbIX peCypcoB, oxpaHy oKpyKaioiueri cpeabi, yKpernieHI4oTpaIHUHOHHbIX BHUOB X03A9CTBeHHOrU ReqTeJIbHOCTH H o6eCnIel4T aOflrOCpO4HblinpOH3BOACTBeHHbl4 noTeHuHn JIeCHoro ceKTopa KaK Ha perHOHaJbHOM, TaK H Ha4e,aepaAbHOM YPOBHe. B aoKnaae coaepKaTc. OaIHHaLtUaTb npHj1oxeHiri, B KOTOPbIXnpeaCTaBJIeHa no,po6Hasl TeXHH4CecKaq HH4OpMaUUA H aHllaHj134pyIOTC OTTaeAbHbieacneKTbi pocciricKoro necHoro ceKTopa, a HMeHHO: neCHble peCypCbl, necCHoeX03SACTBO, J1eCHbIe BeLOMCTBa, JieCHoe 3aKOHofaTeJIbCTBO, iieCHas HpOMbilwieHHOCTb,TOprOBJHI, LIeHbl, HaJIoroBble noCTyrAeHHA, CHCTeMa oco6o oxpaHAemMbIx npHpOaHbIXTeppHTOpHi1 H HCnOJIb3OBaHHe pecypcoB KHBOTHoro MHpa,a aTaKKe .jy4wHHe npMmepblH3 MeXAyHapO1Horo onbITa no peanji3aouH KOHIeriUHHH YCTOWIHBoro pa3BHTH5

IieCHoro KOMnHIeKca.

Page 14: Russian - World Bank Documents

xii

BbIPA)KEH4E nPH3HATEJIbHOCTH

CoBMecTHoe pyKOBOCTBO npoeioKTOM ocyicaTBsLmH MoxHHAep MyARaxap HXopCT BarHep, a XmnMap CDeCjMH KOOpAHHHpOBanI pa6oTy rio nipoeKTy. HimrioAroToBjieH nepBoHa4anJbHbI ap HapuaHT HacToqiLxerO AoK1naAa. MoxrimAep MyAaxapBo3rfnalnB o6cyAeHHe AoKJraAa c POCCHi4CKHM uIpaBHTeiBbCTBOM H nOArOTOBKyoKoH'aTeJThHoro BapHaH'a HacroiUero AoKna,Aa. 0630p JieCHoro ceKToparorATOBHAH c)eieyomHe COTpyARHHKH BceMHpHoro 6aHKa: PoWKep BaTcroyH, ilyHKapO6oHbe, JT3BHA Kaccen, AHAupeii KyuJHH, BHnbqM MarpaT, JIKaCTHH MYHAH,EBreHHA HIIO.nKoB; Me)IAyHapoAHbIe KOHCyJIbTaHThI: KeCiTH A6yCOB, HHKoJ[aac EeK,Cio3aH rHerH, Kapjn Kep, roTmx ImyepxoAi,i H BHJbSM TepHep.

CymecrBeHHIMi BKnaA B rlOZAWOTOBKy oKna,iaa BHecCia poccHJicKa5I pa6oqaqrpynria rIOA pyKOBOACTBoM AneKcaHAgpa HcaeBa H HHKoJIai BypxHHa. B CoCTmB 3ToiirpynrmI BxoAHJM: raIiHHa BepXeBHKHHa, reoprHd KOPOBHH, ,AMHTpHIi MoxCaeB,HHKoJIaii MoHceeB, AHaTojiHi rIeTpOB, AHaToiHil PbDKCHKOB, EneHa CaMoAeToBa,rIaBeni CoKonoB, BaJIeHTHH CTpaxOB, BacHniifu CyxHx, BHKTop TeriJSKoB, BJIaAD4MHpHIInJKOB, AHaToJIHi 5IMCKOB.

ABTopuL BbipaxaloT 6AaroAapHocTb iipaBHTeCICTBy POCCHUCKOIi DeAepaLiHH 3aOKa3aHHyio noAixepicKy, 6e3 KOTOpOU ocyixecTBeHHe SToro npoeKTa 6ibIio 6bIHeBO3MO)KHIM. ABTOpbI BbMpaxcamT nPH3HaTejibHOCTb (D)eepaJI1bHoi ciiyxK6e necHoroxo3sIicTBa 3a y'acTHe B iioAro'roBKe H peLKeH3HPOBaHHH AoKmaAa, a TaJKceFocyAapcTBeHHOMy KOMHTCTy no oxpaHe oKpyKa1oiueui cpeAibI, POCCHUICKOUi aKaAeMHHHayK, MHHHCTepCTBy 4)HHaHCOB, MHHHCTepCTBy SKOHOMHKH H 6IBIlleli PoccHicKoiroCyAapcTBeHHOri AeCOInpOMmbiueHHOR KoMriaHHH (PocJiecnpoMy. ABTopNIripH3HaTeAbH1I AHaTojiHio lHcapeHKo (necHoe X03sIiiCTBO) H AMHpXaHy AMHpXaHOBy(oxpaHa oKpyiKaioiueg cpeAnx), CmIrpaBIU1HX HeOixeHHMYIO pOJb B KOOPAHHaLIHH

pa6oTmI oT niuLa npaBHTejibcTa POCCHACKOi OeAepaLlH. BinaroAapHocmBLIpacKaeTCs TaKeCC a,MHHHCTpauH5iM H perHOHWJbH1)IM HHCTHTYTaM Xa6apoBcKoro HKpaCHOslpCKoro KpaeB.

oKxiaA peetCH3HpoBancsq cneAyCoiuHMH creC HaJHOcrTaMH BceMHpHoro 6aHKa:MspH K3HHHHr (COLLHajThbHIe cu1y1K6bI, 3aHSITocTb), [IenIToH aefuBHC

(coiHojiorHqecKHe BOPIC1b1 H npo6fleMM KopeHHorO HaceJIeHHS), (DnuHn JlIe Ypy(MaKpO3KOHoMwiecKJGe H CoLiHa)TbHble aCrieKTbI), ACHHHC YHTrr(MaKpO3KOHOMHqeCKHe acneKThI), JIeB 'OlpeMHKMaH (4HHaHCOBMe BOripOCm). JlyHcKOHCTaHTHHH, KeTJIHH MaKKHHHOH H 9HApIO B1OHA BbICTrylHJIH B ponH BHyepCHHHX

peLIeH3eHTOB AoKYIaAa. IleHHbIe 3aMeCaHHS no coAepxCaHHIO AoKmaAy BHecJ[H MafiK]Fynji, rlpaAHn MHrpa, KocTac MHKaJIonynoc, MapYeflo CejiOBCKH, JIopa TaK.PeAaicrop AoKnIaAa - MeTaaxe KoKepoMoH, 1ioArOTOBKa K nyY6AHKaUHH - PaTHa MHHHaH mUapH4a Kanana. Onbra CqCCHOBHq H HipHHa SAKoBBeHKO KOp1uHHHpOBamIIIePeBOA AOKJ1aAa Ha PYCCKUU M3IK. HayqHoe peAaKTHpOBaHHe PYCCKoro nepeBoAIa -AHApefi KyULmHH H EBreHHA nOlIsIKOB npH yqacTHH Hropa KocmHa, BHKropaTenrLIAoBa H B8agAMHpa IIIuIKOBa.

[jeHHbIe 3aMeqaHHS BHeCJIH: CTeH HHJbCCOH, Me)KyHapoAHbIk HHCTHTyTrpHKIia1Horo cHCTeMHoro aHaiH3 (poccHricmue JICCHBIC pecypcbi); rein OiiepeHKo,H4HCTHTyT ApKTHwecKHx HccJ1eAoBaHHI, aapTMyrCKHi KoJLTteAxK (KOpeHHbMe HapOAm H

Page 15: Russian - World Bank Documents

xiii

TpaAHLtHoHHbIe BHUbI XO3.cTBeHHOR AesTejibHocTH); AJ,ar HopAeH, THxooKeaHcKHfiLieHTp oKpy)Kailiuert cpeAL H pecypcoB (oxpaHa H 3aIHT aneCOB CH6HpuH H IaamHero

BocroKa); n3T PacmycceH, ripoeK TraeKHbIx IieCOB Earthkind, CIIA H Eartlikind,PoccHA; JxoIu Hbloeni, CH6HpCKHii npoeKT nowiapoonacHbIx yqacTKoB neca .Jpy3bA3eMjiH* - AiioHHI; R93BHA OcTepreH, mTAenJeHHC necHoro xo3sIr4cTBa YHHBepcHTera

3anaiHoii BHPAK,HHHH H Kapn (pDHMeH, Or2ej1eHHe 6HojiorwqecKHx HayK YAHcKororocyAapcTBeHHoro YHHBepcHTCrTa. CTHBeH .KOHCOH, MexqgyHapogHaq OpraHmaLtmrponHqecKor ApeBecHHbI, H ToMac BarreHep, KoimeMK iiecHux pecypcoBBaluHHrroHcKoro yHHBepcH4TeTa, noMora0J B nOHCKe dHHopMaitHm o LCeHaM Ha

urecHylo npoJyKuIXHo.

CyiuecTBeHHy1o nOMOI4b B r1ORrOTOBKe AoKiiaja OKa3ajiH poccHcKKHe HMeRYHaPOAHbie HeripaBHTeJIIcTBeHHbIe opraHH3agHH. HpH 11olrO`OBKe AoKiia,a

CBHq3b C yKa3aHHbIMH OpraHH3aLxH$MH ocyiUecBTsmlacb epe3 AneKcesi FpHropbeBa,CoiHaniHo-3Konorwqecxmfi C0103 (MocKBa). [LeHHbIe 3aMeCaHHS npeAcraBmnaCHH,H BIOJr, 4HHOpMaauHOHHLIU ueHTp BceMHpHoro 6aHKa (BauIHrrOH), OHa TaiKcenoMorJIa nOJrY'HTm 3ameqaHHq MegyHapO,HbIX CrieuHaJIHCTOB. B o6CYyeHHHOKOHMaTeJ1bHorO BapHaTra Aoina.na, cocToqBa erocs B MocxBee, HpHH5loiH y'acTHeCepreu flOHoMapeHKO, BceMHPHbIr 4)OHA AHKOH IIPHPOAI (WWF), PoccH4r; Cepreii

LIbrLTIeHKoB, FPHHIHC, PoccHI, H EBreHHli CHMOHOB, 1jeHTp oXpaHbI ARBORnpHpoUI, Pocciur. [lOMOuTh B opraHm3aumH JAHcKyccHfH 11o0 oKna,y OKa3a1 J1KOH

KnrapK, oT.eji no CBI3SIM C HeT1paBHTeCjbCTBeHHbIMM opraHH3aUHSIMm BceMH4pHoro

6aHKa.

B pa6oTe Ha, InpOeKTOM OKa3aJim co,eRcTBHe COTPYAHH4KH rIOCT0SHHoro

iTpezc-TaBHTweJbCETBa BCeMHpHoro 6aHKa B MocKBe. ABTopII rlpH3HaTeCEbHbI MHorHMCOTPYAHHK4M BaHKa, pOCCHRCKxM CeLuHajuHCTaM, a TaoKxe mCAyHapOAHblM

3KCHepTaM 11o J1eCHOMY XO3SIHCTBy 3a UeHHbIl BKYJ1a B pa6OTY Ha, aOKma.OM.

IIOMHMO BaHKa, cyleCTBeHHoe AOOJIHHTelbHoe 4MHaHCHpOBaHMe 6bIo

iTpeCocTaBneHO npaBHTembcTBaM4 KaHa,m H HHAepniaHAoB 11o JIHHHHKOHCYJH,TahHOHHbIX TpaCTOBMX 4)OHAOB.

06iuee pyKoBO1cTBo pa6oToii Ha, npoeKToM ocyiUxecTBJ151H MafiY., rynyA,Kocmac MHxKalonynoc H1 IOKOH XyaHr.

Page 16: Russian - World Bank Documents

xiv

CnHCOK nPUHHTbIX COKPAUEHHR

EBPP EBponeAcKMH 6aHK peKOHCTPYKUHH H pa3BHTHR

BBn BaMOBOH BHyTpeHHHA npOayK1'

rmc reOHHfopMaumOHHaq CHcTema

BHn BaMOBOH HatHOHanbHblA npoAyKT

rYAqo roCyAapCTBeHHbIA yLieT ilecHoro 4OHAa

BTO BCeMHpHaS ToproBaq opraHH3aUHq

E3K EBponeHCKaC 3KOHOMHqecKaq KOMHCCHS1 (OOH)r3D) rAO6aUbHbIA 3KOIiorHqeCKHM @OHA

PAH POCCHHcKaM aKaAeMHR HaYK

PACXH POCCHfkcKa.I aKa3jeMHR cejibcKoXo35ItcTseHHbEX HayK

PM1 PacmeTHaS necoceKa

P4' PoccHAcKaq 4)eAepauHA

inuJ UHAeKc nmOpC6HTejibCKHX ueH

JiYUi JIeCOyC1pOHTeCbHbiA npoeKT

OBOC OUCHKa BO3AeCCTBHH Ha OKpy)KaiomUyio cpeAy

H,LC Hanor Ha Ao6aBneHHyIo CTOHMOCTb

HACA HaUHOHa.nbHoe YnpPaBeHHe ClUMA no a3pOHaBTHKe H Hcc;neAoBaHHIO KOCMHCecKoro npoCTpaHCTBa

M BO MexwcyHapOAHNAI BanMTHbIA (POHA

onin 0 6 3op JieCHoH nOJIHTHKH

IIASA MeWAYHaPOAHbIdr HHCTHTyT nPHKnaAHHOO CHTeMHoro amaRH3a

HnO HenpaBHrenbCTBeHHble OPraHH3aUHH

OonT Oco6o oxpaHneMbie npHPOaHbie TePPHTOPHH

MOT MexayHapoAHas opraHH3aUHs Tpyia (OOH)

MOT.t MezXAYHaPOAHa.s opraHH3aULHR no TpOnHqeCKO, 1peBeCHHe

MCOIn MeCeAyHapoAHbIA COK03 OXpaHbi npHPOAbl

M0bK MeXayHapoaHasq fHHaHCOBM KopnopaUHS1

nYoc flpoeKT no ynpaBneHHIo oKpyxKaolueA cpenoH

03CP OpraHH3aUHs 3KOHOMHmeCKOrO COTPYAHH1CcTBa H pa3BHTHR

CHr CoApyxec'rBO He3aBHCHMbiX rocyaapcTB

cnc CTpaTerHsl nOMOWH crpaHe

Co3C COUHaJlbHO-3KonorH4eCKHH C0103

(PAO npOAoBOJbCTBeHHasl H CeAbCKOX03S,lcTBeHHaSI OpraHH3aUHSI OOHDCJIX 4'eAeapanbHaR cjiy)K6a necHoro X03RACTBa POCCHH

TUOCP THXOOKeaHCKHH UeHTp no oxpaHe OKpyKaoIoueA CpeAbl H pecypcaM

TACIS nporpaMMa TVXHHLeCKOA nOMOWH CTpaHaM CHr

UNCED KOHtepeHUHS OOH no OKpy)KaioWeie CpeAe H Pa3BHTHI0

USAID AreHTCTBO CWA no MeAAyHapOAHoMy pa3BHTHIO

WWF BCeMHpHbIA (OHA AHKOH npHp0Abl

IOHErl IlporpaMMa OOH no oKpyKaiowueA cpeAe

MEPbl lvrHHbl H BECAMeTpHqecKa.s CHCTeMa

(DKHAHCOBbIR ro,I HHBapS - 31 aeKa6pR

BAJIIOTHBIE 3KBHBAJIEHTbi

Page 17: Russian - World Bank Documents

xv

AeHexKHas eAUHHHLa = py6rn6 (py6.)

06MeHHbli Kypc: py6.nel 3a AoAuap CHWA(no AaHHbIM MOCKOBCKOR Me)K6aHKOBCKOA BaAlOTHOti 6Hp,KH H

BHelC3KOHOM6aKa POCCHH)

RepIo,4 Cpe4MJ KyA 38a J7epMog Kypc Ha KOHeLf JCpHO5W

1989 9 91990 19 231991 62 169

1992

I KBapmTa 177 1601I KBapTan 134 144III KnapTan 178 254IV KBapTan 396 415

1993

I KBapTan 580 684I KBapran 968 1060

111 KBaprTA 1028 1169IV KBapTani 1206 1247

1994

I KBapTaA 1591 175311 KBapran 1877 1989III KBapTan 2166 2633IV KBapTan 3191 3550

1995

I KBapTaJi 4311 4899I KBapTan 4931 4539

I KBaPTan 4467 4499IV KBapTaJJ 4554 4640

1996

I KBapTan 4764 48561I KBapraii 4980 5105111 KBapTan 5271 5407IV KBapTan1 5463 5525

'Ha 10 AeKa6pq 1996 r.

Page 18: Russian - World Bank Documents

Iii

Page 19: Russian - World Bank Documents

PE310ME'

PoccHA o6naaaeT orpoMHbIMH 3aflacaMH aeciHbix peCypcoB. Ha aonio PoccHunPKXOIU4TCA 22% MUpOBOU nIeconfOKPbITOu TeppHTopH1, o6u.eg nAoiUaabio 764 MJIH. ra, u

npHMepHo 21% pac4eTHbIX 3aHacoB pacTyIuX AeCoB. Kpome 3Toro, ee nieca lBASHOTCAcaMbIM KpynHbIM Ha3eMHbIM "'xpaiiHuiiXeM" yrAepoaa B M4pe. 78% o6Lueg nnouaa,t

pOCCHUCKOU4 TeppHTOPHH, nOKpbITOfl IiecoM, HaXOaliTCS B Cu6upu H Ha JisanbHeM BocToKe, a22% - B EBponeicKoi 4aCTI POCCHH. XOTA MHOrI'MH 3TU nieca paCCMaTpUBalOTCR KaK

OrpOMHbll pe3epB apeBecHHbl, KOTOpbIU MOA(HO HcnOJTb3OBaTb flA5 y,OBAeTBOpeHHS HYAKI

MUpOBOU4 AeCHOUi npoMblwJeHHOCTH, HeO6XoaHMo y4HTbIBaTb, YTO CYWeCTBeHHaH qaCTb

AecHbIX 3anacoB POCCuH HaxoaHTcs B oTaaAeHHbIX pailoHax, xapaKTePH3ylOmutXCS HU3KHMrOTeHUHanOM pOCTa H XpynKOCTbIO oKpyxKaio11eH CpeRbl, KOTOpa>q OqeHb qyBCTBHTeAbHa K

nuo6oMy BMewIaTeAbcTBy. pA51i 3THX TeppHTopHti xapaKTepHO HaAmi4e 6onbLmoro 'HcCja

KOpeHHbIX HapOaHOCTeU, MHOFHMH H3 KOTOPbIX AO CHX nOp HCIOAb3ylOTCS TpaaHuLIHOHHblg

yKIaI )KH3HH H qOpMbl Xo3SIiCTBeHHoii ae$TeAbHOCT4, 6a34pyiou14ecs Ha OXOTe, pbi6HOU4

nioBJIe, pa3BeIaeHHH CeBepHbIX oAeHeu H HcHOJb3OBaHHH BCeBO3MO)KHbIX .YeCHbIX pecypcOB.

EiAaro,aapA TOMY, 'ITO B TeCeHHH )uIHTeCJbHOFo BpeMeHH POCCHS HaKonuna

6OnbWOr4 OHbIT B ynpanBeHIHH AeCHbIMH pecypcaMH, OHa cTaiia nPH3HaHHbIM AIHaepoM B

pa3Be,IeHHH H coxpaHeHHH AeCOB, a TaKXe B npOBeaeHHH HayqHblX HccAeCaOBaHHA H

pa3pa6oTOK B o6naCTH AecHoro XO3rIICTBa. B TO )Kce BpeM5i noJIHTHKa ueHTpaAni3OBaHHOFO

niIaHHpOBaHHAi rPHBeCJa K HCnOnb3OBaHHIO HCTOUlMtTeJbHbIX MeTO,OB BeaeHH5I XO3ArCTBa,

HexKHcHecnoco6HOcTb KOTOPbIX OTMeTAHBO o6Ha)KHjiacb puH iepexoae K pbIHO4HOr4 MoaeAnl

3KOHOM4KH. MHorme npenpHqTHfl AeCHOM rpOMbmllbweHHOCTH oKa3aniHCb H3OJIHPOBaHHbIMH

OT 3KOHOMH'eCKH ROCTYnHbIX AeCHbIX peCYPCOB, KaK TOAbKO rPearpHHTHAI,aepeBoo6pa6aTbIBaio[LeH npOMbbIwIeHHOCTH JIHn1HJIHCb B03MO)KHOCTH noriyqaTb 3HeprHiO,

TpaHCIOPTHbiC H apyrue rpOH3BoaCTBeHHbIe ycAyrm H CbIpbe no HCKYCCTBeHHO 3aHH)KeHHbIM

iteHaM. B pe3yJbTaTe 3a nocACeaHHe HeCKOIbKO nIeT npou30wCeA pe3KHA ciTaa o60beMOBAeCO3aFOTOBOK. HpOH3BOaCTBO KpyrAoro nieca COKpaT4JIOCb C 375 MAH. Ky6oMeTpOB B ro, B

1989-91 rr. ao 115 MJIH. Ky6oMeTpOB B 1995 r. CorAacHO nporHO3aM, B 1996 roziy o6feM3arOTOBKH Kpyrjioro nieca oniOKeH COCTaBHTb 110 MJIH. Ky6oMeTpOB. POCC1SA, HeKor,sa

3aHHMaBwaIq BTOpOe MeCTO nocne ClWA no nPO43BOaCTBY nejiOBO4 apeBecHHbl, Tenepb3aHM4aeT TpeTbe MeCTO (nocne CLIA H KaHaabl) H CYiUeCTBeHHO OTCTaeT OT 3TU4X CTPaH no

o6WueMy nPO43BOaCTBY apeBec4Hbl. CnaA nHpo43BoaCTBa apeBeCHHbl B OTTajieHHbIX paioHax

H OTCYTCTBHe TaM co3aaiLOuHx ao6aBJieHHylO CTOHMOCTb nepepa6aTblBalolux MOUWHOCTeU

4aKTH4eCKH H30JIHPOBaYH 3TH PaUOHbl OT OTeCeCTBeHHbIX H MeC)IyHapOaHbIX pbIHKOB

c6blTa. TaKas 1305JI,UHq co3Iajia 4OnOJIHHTeJIbHbie 3KOHOMHqeCKHCe H COUHBaJbHbie

npo6fleMbl H npHBejia K pOCTy Harpy3KH Ha 3aUWHTHbie KaTeropHH JTeCOB, HaxoAL1UHXCA B

6o0iee ,OCTYHHb[X paf4oHax.

POCCHr4CKi4e ieca C COXpaHHBUJHMHC5 B HHX o6UIUpHbIMU aeBCTBeHHbIMH

TePPHTOPHSMHU HMelOT OrpOMHOe o6LLeMHpOBoe 3HaqeH4e, o6ycnoBAeHHoe o6UIUpHbIM

I HacTosuwa1 ny6jn4Kauti3 mBuisTCœi nepesaoM c aHrJumCKoro MHblKa opmHnaHabHOMO aoKmaLaBceMHpHoro 6aHKa, CaaHHOrO B nefaTb 10 aeKa6pq 1996 roaa. n1ocneayio.wme I3MeHeHSH B opraH113auHH m4YHKUIIOHHpOBaHUHh AeCHorO KOMn4iUeKCa PocCUH, nppOH30oweawe B nepBoi nIOnOBHHe 1997 roAa, He nOny4HJ1HOTpa)KeHU4HI B aaHHOri ny6JIHKaUUHH. (nlpHMe'aHHe pewaKTopa pyCCKOrO m3AaHM51).

Page 20: Russian - World Bank Documents

2

nIeCHbIM nOKPOBOM, 6Uopa3Hoo6pa3UeM, POJ1bIO B rno6arlbHoM KpyrOBOPOTe yrnepoRa H

rOTeHUHaSJbHbIM BAISHHHeM Ha Me)fYHapOAHyIO TOprOBjTiO JieCHbIMH rpoAyKTaMH.HeCMOTPH Ha TO, 'ITO B EBponerlcKori 'IaCTH POCCHH MielOTCA 60nbmUe ruoiua,HCTapopacTyiUHx AeCOB H YHHKaJIbHbie 3KOCHCTeMbl, HYKLaiOLUHeCA B oco6oM BHHMaHHH,

OCTpYIO 03a60oeHHOCTb HaMHHaeT Bbl3blBaTb 3KojiorHqecKoe COCTOAHHe OrpOMHbIX JIeCHbIX

nnoL1iaaerl Cu6upH H uaajbHero BocToKa, npeaCTaBJSAO[LUHX co6o0 TeppHTOpHH, Ao CHX nopHe 3aTpOHyTbIe 4HHyCTpHaj1H3auHeA. HnoLua,b JieCoB, HaXOaAM1IHXCA K BOCTOKY OT

YpaYIbCKHx rop, COCTaBJISeT HpH6jiH3HTeJIbHo 600 MJTH. ra, RpHueM oKoJIo 85% 3TOUlTePPHTOPUH nOKPbITO JieCaMH, B 6ojibUIHHCTBe H3 KOTOPbIX rpOMbbIwhjeHHaA 3arOTOBKa nieca

HHKOr,aa He BeJiacb.

B HacToswee BpeMS B HeKOTOpbIX H3 HaH6onee 3KojiorIHeCKH Ba)KHbIX par4OHOB

oxpaHa JieCOB OCYlueCTBJqeTCA B paMKax pOCCUiUCKOUl CHCTCMbl oco6o oxpaHAeMbix

IPHPOQIHbIX TePPHTOPIH. FocyaapCTBeHHaA CHCTeMa 3anOBeaH4KOB, CO3XaaHHaq B COBeTCKOe

BpeMs, OKa3aniaCb noa yrpO3Or4 pa3pyweHHSl, 'TO o6ycnOBMeHO 3KOHOM[4eCK4MH

TPY,AHOCTAMH nepexoia K pbIHO4HOU 3KOHOMHKe. OimmnbWHe njioWaaiH 3KOHOMH'-eCKH

JierKoJOCTYHHbIX nIecOB 3eJIeHOr4 3OHbl H 3alUlHTHbIX nIecOB BOKpyr KpynHbIX HaCeCJeHHbIX

HyHKTOB cTaHOBHTCH o6IbeKraMH 6onee HHTeHCHBHOrO HCrIIOJb3OBaHfli. B TaKHX cjiy'aAx

pe3KO Bo3pocnia qaCTOTa BO3HHKHOBeHH5 rO)KapOB H BCrbIlUeK 6oAe3Heri, a TaiOKe

Ha6nio,aaJIOcb yc4JIeHHoe pa3MHoKeHHe BpeaHTeJier4 nIeca. no oLIeHKaM (Deaepa)bHoHcJIy)K6bi IeCHOrO XO3AACTBa POCCHH, u3-3a OTCYTCTBHS aAeKBaTHOrH opraHH3aLuHH OXpaHbI

nIeCOB OT nO)KapOB H 3aUHTbl OT BPeJHTeier H 6ojie3HeUi e)KeroaHO nOrH6aeT OKOJIO 2 MJIH.

ra nieCOB. 14 XOTA riO)Kapbl, BPeaHTeIiH H 6ofle3HH ABJSAOTCS eCTeCTBeHHbIM 3J1eMeHTOM

6opeanbHblx JIeCHbIX 3KOCHCTeM, He3cIeKTHBHoe ynpaBneHHe JIecaMH np4BO,aHT K

HeO6paTHMOMy pa3pyweHHIO 3KOCHCTeM B OTHOC4TenJbHO JIerKOfOCTYnHbIX pa4OHax.

He,aaBHHrl pe3KHA cnag nPO43BOLCTBa B JieCHOM ceKTope 5BJIAeTCA TaiOKe

CJIegCTBHeM XH4UHHqeCKoH 3KCnnYaTaLIUH nIeCHbIX PeCYPCOB B nepHOa LIeHTpaniH3OBaHHOro

nniaHHpOBaHHS H MHoroJIeTHerO HrHOPHPOBaHHA iHecoyrppaBeHqecKox u opHpoooXpaHHbIX

MepOnpHSTHH. 9TOT KpU3HC ycyry6nsleTcA cepbe3HbIMH 4lHHaHCOBbIMH TpyilHOCTAMH, C

KOTOpbIMH CTaJIKHBalOTCA KaK rOCyLIapCTBeHHbIe BeLOMCTBa, 3aHHMaloIu4HeC BOnpOCaMH

IieCHoro ceKTopa, TaK H 'aCTHbIe npeAnpHATHA. HecMOTps Ha Bce npo6.neMbI, JIeCHOH

CeKTOP BCe )Ke o6jiaAaeT 3Ha'iHTeAbHbiM rOTeHUHJaIOM iomAJ COaeHCTBH4A aOCT14)KeHHIO

o61LeHauuHoHaAbHbIX uejieri 3KojiortMecKoro, couiHaJlbHoro H 3KOHOMH4ecKoro pa3BHTHA,BKJIIOx-aH HaniorOBbie BbInHJaTbl roCyaapCTBY, B TOM 'HCJIe B 4DOpMe HanjOrOBbiX nOCTYnJIeHHHB 61ioKeTbl BCeX ypOBHeI4, KOTOPbie npuH OHTHManbHOM pa3BHTHH iecHoro KoMnieKca moryTAOCT4rHyTb nopsAAKa 5,5 Mjipa. aonjiapoB CIA. OXHaKo AnA Toro, HTO6bI POCCHA cmornapeWLIHTb nOCTaBJIeHHbie 3alaqH 3auLHTbI 3KOJorFtHeCKOi LIeHHOCTH nieca H yCTOr4'HmBoro

pa3BHTHA ieCHoro CCKTOPa B nep4oa nepexoIIa K PbIHOqHOf4 3KOHOM4Ke, Tpe6yeTCA BHeCTH

CYiueCTBeHHbIe H3MeHeHUH BO BCIO CHCTeMY YnPaBJIeHHA AeCHbIMU pecypCaMH.

AAAH AOCTH)KeHHA 3THX uejieri HeO6xOaHMbl KOPeHHbie H3MeHeHHS B

AeCOynpaBJIeHHH, B HaCTHOCTH, B MeTOAaX AeCO3arOTOBKH H BOCHPOH3BOACTBa nIeCHbIX

pecypcOB. OCBoeHHe HOBbIX y4aCTKOB nieca IaOJnKHO orpaHH'IHBaTbCA TeMuH nJIoILaaAmLi,KOTOpbI HaH6ojlee npHrOaHbl gAAA npOH3BOACTBa apeBeCHHbl C 3K0JIorFqecKoH, COuLiaHjbHOA

H 3KOHOMHqeCKOA TOqeK 3peHHA, H OCHOBbIBaTbCA Ha HCnOFOb3OBaHHH o6oCHOBaHHbIX

nieCOXO3HAUCTBeHHbIX MeponpHATHl. HPOMbI11neHHbie MOIUHOCT4 H of6eMbl nPOH3BOEACTBa

AOJDKHbl COOTBeTCTBOBaTb 3KOjiOrHMeCKHM HOpMaM H Tpe6OBaH5HM yCTOlMHIBOrO

Page 21: Russian - World Bank Documents

3

HCnOJJb3OBaHH>R peCypCOB. npH TaKOM noAxoae BO MHOrHX o6JIaCTTX ypOBeHb FIpOH3BO24CTBa

6yneT HH)Ke paiee AocTHrHyroro. HpeaBapHTenbHble XaHHbie no COCTOqH14IO J1eciHbixpeCYPCOB H HMeiLOuaACA HH4bOpMawU4 0 COCTOSHHH PbIHKOB yKa3blBalOT Ha TO, 'TO o6lu.A

HeHCTOLUHTeJibHblUi YPOBeHb j1eCO3arOTOBOK B POCCHH Ha npOTqDKeH4H HeCKOJAbKHX

nocneyioLiUx AeCATHJ1eTHui, cKopee Bcero, no-ripe)KHeMy 6yaeT HH)Ke, qeM ao 1991 roga,TaK KaK H3-3a HCnOJIb3yeMbIX B HpOWAJOM MeTO,OB 3KCnjiyaTaUHH J1eCHbIX peCYPCOB

6oAnbwaA mlaCTb nerKoJocTyrHbIX 3KcjiyaTaLUHOHHbIX niecoB MO)CeT CTaTb HenpHroJrHOri iAni

HOBbIX JecO3arOTOBOK, H yBenAMHaTCH pacCTOSHH5 MexKAy rIpHrOAHbIMH A11 3arOTOBOK

flecHbIMH MaccHBaMH H oTe'eCTBeHHbIMH HuiH MeXAYHaPOaHbIMH pb1HKaMH c6biTa.

B HaCTO5LueM aoKnaae, riIaBHbIM o6pa3OM, o6cyx(aeTcq noAo)KeHHe aen BCH6HpH H Ha ,aaAbHeM BocToKe, T.e. Ha Bcel TeppHTOpHH, pacnoAo)4KeHHoH- K BOCTOKY OT

YpaJbcKHx rop, B CHJIY Heo6xoAUMOcTH CpO4HOrO peilueHHA ripo6JieM, cBA3aHHbIX C

3KOJ1orH,MeCKOr yCTOAP1HBOCTb1O OCTaBLUHXCR aOCTyrHbiX aeBCTBeHHbIX necoB A3HaTCKOR

'IaCTH PoccHH, oco6o y53BHMbIX B nepeXOAHblA nepHoA. TeM He MeHee, npe,Ao)KeHHA no

pe(bopMHPOBaHHIO HaLUHOHaJIbHOfl IieCHOii HOAHTHKH H MHorHe peKomeHAaLuH OTHOCSTCS K

JIeCHOMY ceKCOpy B ueJIOM. B aaj1bHeRiiLeM Heo6XOlHMo 6yaeT npOBeCTH 6onee geTaBJbHbie

HccjieAOBaHH5I Bcero ceKTopa H ero oT,ejibHbIX orpacneri KaK AIS A3HaTcKo i, TaK H AAs

EBponerieCKOU 'aCTH POCCHH.

HPH nOarOTOBKe HaCTO5ierO AoKJiaaa HCnOJ1b3OBaJIocb HecKOJ1bKO HCTOqHHKOB

HH4OpMaauHH, BKJIoMa5: (a) AaHHbIe, co6paHHbie B 1995 rogy B xoae noe31aKH aejieraUuHBceMHpHoro 6aHKa B KpacHoqpcKHf (CH6Hpb) H Xa6apoBcKHR (,LanbHHA BOCTOK) Kpaq;(6) MHOrO4HCjieHHbie BCTpeUH B MocKBe Co cneiHHaJHcTaMH H rpeACTaBHTenHA

rocy,apCTBeHHbIX BefOMCTB, CBW3aHHbIX C J1eCHbIM CeKTopoM; (B) o6o6LueHHbie AaHHbie,rpe,aoCTaBJIeHHbie (IeaepaIbHOil cnyK6og IieCHoro XO3A]RCTBa POCCHH, OTHocSIUXHeCR Kpa3HblM acreKTaM JIeCHOrO ceKTopa cTpaHbl; (r) LOKIia,Xbl Ha KOHKpeTHb1e TeMbi,

nolrOTOBneHHb1e 4JIeHaMH pa6o0eri rpyflHbI, B KOTOPYIO BXOaHJIH HAITHaauaTb POCCUHCKHX

cneHLaJI1HCTOB no niecy H o4bHuHia.jbHbIX JIHU, OTBeqaolWUX 3a pa3pa6oTKy H npoBeAeHHeieCHOri rOJIHTHKH, H (A) KOMMeHTapHH rocyOapCTBeHHbAX OJI)KHOCTHbIX JIHU, cneLuHaJHCTOB

JieCHoro ceKTopa H rpeACTaBHTeJ1eui HenpaBHTenJbCTBeHHb1X opraHH3auu4i (HaUHOHanbHblX HMeKIIyHapOAHbIX), 03HaKOMHBUIHXCS C npOeKTOM aaHHOrO aoKJiaa. 9ToT aoKj1aa, OQHaKo,

He npeTeHAyeT Ha peweHHe Bcex npo6JIeM, CTOSIUHX nepeA jTeCHblM CeKTopoM. OCHOBHoe

BHHMaHHe B HCM COCpeAOTO4eHO Ha HeCKOJIbKHX KjnOMeBbIX npo6JleMax, KOTOpbIe

nperInTCTBYIOT 3KOJTorHueCKH, COUHa1JbHO H 3KOHOMHMeCKH yCTOR4IHBOMy pa3BHTiuO n]ecHoroceKTopa, a TaKwKe Ha peKoMeHaaUHsx, CO,erCTBYIOWUX TaKOMy pa3BHTHIO B nepHoll

nepexo,a K pbIHO4HOU 3KOHOMHKe. HeO6XOaHMO npOBeCTH AOnlOJIHHTelbHyiO pa6oTy no

onpepeneHHIO B03MO)KHOCTerH nOBblliUeHHU YCTOiNHBOCTH Tpa,HUHOHHbIX 3KOHOMtiMeCKHX

yKABa,aOB CH6HpH H ,aIbHero BocToKa.

OCHOBHbie acreierK alHwAK3a J1eCHOro cewropa

,;i.sq nepecTpoilKH niecHoro ceKTopa H nepeBo,ga ero Ha MoAeflb yCTOr4qHBoropa3BKTHA Heo6xoaHMo 6yaeT JaeACTBOBaTb no MHOrHM HanpaBjieHHSM. ,AAs npaBHTejibCTBacamas BaxKHas 3aAaqa COCTOHT B pa3pa6oTKe H peajiH3aUHH TaKOHl HOJIHTKKH K CKCTeMperyJIHpoBaHHs, KOTOpb1e o6ecnet4HBaloT pa1uHOHanbHoe ynpaBseHHe JieCHbIMH pecypcaMH KrIOMOralOT npeAeJIbHO yBeJIHUHTb BblrO2bI OT HCHOJ1b3OBaHKS H COXpaHeHHA 3THX peCypCOB.

Page 22: Russian - World Bank Documents

4

PSl mep B 3TOM HanpaBjieHHH npeayCMaTpHBaeTcS npOeKTOM HOBOrO JleCHoro KoaeKca

(HIonb 1996 r.).2 O,HaKo 1AA 3aBepwllleHH 3TOH pa6OTbl HeO6XOaHMO nocJIefOBaTeAbHoe

nipoBeAeHHe yCKOpeHHbIX 4)yHaaMeHTajibHbIX pedopm KaK B o6naCTH agMHHHCTpaTHBHOrO H

X03AACTBeHHOrO ynpaBjieHH5 fieCHbIMH pecypcaMH, TaK H B c4bepe HX OXpaHbl Ha BCeX

YpOBH5X ynpaBJeHHA. KpoMe 3TorO, HeO6XOaUMO BCeMepHO COaeRCTBOBaTb npaKT4UeCKOMy

OCyiueCTBjieHHIO 3THX pe4bOpM H o6ecne4HTb TeCHOe B3aHmoeHCTBHe Mexy

rOCy,aapCTBeHHbIM H 'laCTHbIM ceKTOpOM.

Co3aaHHC BC0,'oMcTCHHO-HpaBoBLJx YCJOBHO

Ths' pa3peileHHA KOH4)JIHKTOB, BbI3BaHHbIx HpeTeH3HHAMH Ha npaBa Bjia,eHHuI

JieCaMH H aocTyna K JIeCHbIM pecypcam H B03HHKlUIHX Me)Ay rOCyA,apCTBeHHbIMH

cTpyKcypaMH pa3nuHoro YPOBHA yripaBjieHHS (4eaepaJIbHoro, perHOHaJIbHorO H MeCTHOrO)

H KOpeHHbIM HacenIeHHeM JIeCHbIX TeppHTOpHU, Heo6xoaHMo npoBeAeHHe npaBOBOH

peqlopMbi iiecHoro ceKTopa. cDeJaepanlbHbie BeaoMCTBa AtOJDKHbl cjieTDHTb 3a TeM, '4TO6bi

pa3pa6OTKa COOTBeTCTBylOIIer HOJIHTHKH no HcHoAb3OBaHHIO IieCHbIX pecypcoB npOBOIHJ]acb

He TOJnbKO npH ylaCTHH BceX 3aHHTepeCOBaHHbIX CTOpOH (oco6eHHO 3TO OTHOCHTC$ K

KOpeHHOMY HaCeiJeHHIO H ApyrHM )KHTeXAM AaHHbIX TeppHTOpHr), HO H o6ecneLHBaAa 6bl

yCJIOBHA KaK IAn AOCTH)KeHHq co6cTBeHHbIx HaLtHOHanYbHbIX HHTepeCOB POCCMH, TaK H

BblnOJIHeHH5 o6SI3aTeJIbCTB nepea MeXAYHaPO21HbIM coo6wecCTBoM. npouecc nprHHATH

pewleHU aOJIKeH 6bITb rJIaCHbIM, a o6S3aHHOCTH pa3HbIX ypOBHeH ynpaBJeHHS qeTKO

Onpe,aeJ1eHbl, 'TO RBJIqeTCq oco6eHHO BaXHbIM ripMHeHHTeJlbHO K MexaHH3MY

ocyHueCTBjieHHA yKe HpHHSATOH HOJIHTHKH. nepBbIM waroM B 3TOM HanpaBJIeHHH AOJDKHO

6bITb peweHHe npaBOBbIX BOnpOCOB. 3JaeCb Tpe6yeTCA qeTKO OnpeaeJIHTb MeXaHH3M

pacnpe,aenieHHs OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH H KOHTPOJIS 3a HCnOJIHeHHeM npHHATbIX peuleHUH4. Hy)KHa

TaKiKe 'leTKasI rocyaapCTBeHHaH cTpaTerHA pa3BHTHS B CooTBeTCTByioIWUeg o6jiacTH H CICTeMa

ynpaBJIeHHSI, co3AaHHaS c ytleTOM OTHOweHHi co6CTBeHHOCTH, ROAHOMo0HH no

peryJIHPOBaHHIo H KOHTPOJIO 3a ocyuleCTBJIeHHeM np4HHTOH nporpaMMbl, a TaKxe

onpe,aenoluasm H peryjiipyioiasA BeJOMCTBeHHbie, X03sltrCTBeHHbIe, aaMHHHCTpaTHBHbie H

qHHaHCOBble o6SI3aHHOCTH BCex cy6'beKTOB X0351rCTBeHHO AeSATeAbHOCTH H OpraHOB

rocy,LapCTBeHHOrO ynpaBJIeHHsl, npHHHMaoluHx yqacTHe B pa6oTe ZiecHoro ceKTopa.

TaKas coriiacoBaHHas cTpyKTypa rocyaapCTBeHHoIR nOJIHiTHKH B o6.nacTH

HCnOJIb3OBaHHR JIeCHbIX pecypcoB CTpaHbl AOJDKHa yKpenHTb nO3HULHH perHOHanJbHbIX H

MeCTHbIX opraHoB BjiaCTH B nniaHe onepaTHBHOrO ocyiueCTBJIeHHq COOTBeTCTByloLueH

cTpaTerHH, o6ecneMeHHA npsmoro a2MHHHcTpaTHBHoro ynpaBJIeHH5I JIeCHbIMH pecypcaMH.

KpoMe TOrO, HeO6XOAHMO pa3pellHTb HPOT4BOpeqMU Me)Ky IieCHbIM 3aKOHOIaTeAbCTBOM H

3aKoHOA,aTeJIbHbIMHa oKyMeHTaMH, Kaca1oLUHMHC5 npHpOAHbIX peCYPCOB H HaceJIAIOUtHX 3TH

TeppHTOpHH KOpeHHbIX HapOaOB. 3Ta cTpyKTypa A0oDKHa TaKKe BKJIIOMaTb 3lXeKTHBHbie

HHCTpyMeHTbI KOHTPOJIA H CTHMYJIbl AAS npi4BJIeMeHHA MaCTHOrO CeKTOpa, oTpa)Kas

3KOHOMH,ecKHe H3MeHeHHR, ripoHcXoASuHe B PoccHH no mepe ee nepexoaa K PbIHOMHOH3KOHOMHKe. B 6o0ee LlHPOKOM niiaHe, 4aCTHbll CeKTOp ROjDKeH OTBeMaTb 3a COAeHCTBHe

yCTO4qIHBOMY pa3BHTHio, a TaK)Ke 3a nepepa6oTKy H c6blT JieCHbIX peCYPCOB B parlOHax,

npOH3BOLSlUHX )apeBecHHy.

2 "JIeCHOH KOaeKC POCCHACKOA ce.epaLuHH" B OKOHqaTejIbHOIH PeaaKUlH 6bln npHHSIT rocyaapCTBeHHOH

,ayMoil 22 SHBapS 1997 rona H BCTYnHH B cHAy 4 4eBpaiiA 1997 roia. (flpHMeqaHu4e peaaKcopa pyccKoro

tnaaHHA) .

Page 23: Russian - World Bank Documents

5

noMHMo pa3pa6oTKH o6uieu cTpaTerHH, 43eLepajibHoe npauB4Te.RbCTBO aonlOHO

Co3LaaTb H nO2WeP)KHBaTb o6lueHaLtHOHaJibHyiO 6a3y aaHHbIX, HeO6XOatiMyiO AnsKpyHHoMacWlITa6Horo CTpaTerH'eCKOro nJlaHHpOBaHHR H KOHTPOJIA 3a pa60Tor neCHoroceKTopa. B BeaeHHI qeaepaAbHoro npaBHTejibCTBa 6YAyr HaXOAHTbCH BonpOCbl ynpaBJIeHuH

JIeCHbIM X03Af1CTBOM H o6'beKTaMH (BKJIioMas 3anlOBeaHble TeppHTOPHU CTpaHbI), HMeioIUHMHo6wuerocy,aapCTBeHHOe 3HaqeHHe, a TaKwe BonpoCbI, CB53aHHbie C BbirFOJIHeHt4M perKOHamUHx MewayHapOAHbIX o6si3aTenbcTB rio JieCHOMY ceKopy H oxpaHe oKpy)KaooweA cpeabl.Oe,epaAbHoe npaBHTeJibCTBO aOJIOKHO TaK)Ke CAieHTb 3a TeM, 'lTO6bi npIu npHSATHH4peweHHUi BeaOMCTBeHHbIe HHTepeCbI jieCHOfU HpoMb1lwjeHHOCTH He AOMHHUPOBaJI4 B yLuep63KojiorHqecKHM H COuHajibHbIM HyAcaaM. UejieBbIe nporpaMMbl H4ccAeaOBaTeCjbCK4X pa6oTno niecy, BKJIOMS aAnporpaMMy c03AaHH5 ceTH MoaejibHblX jiecoB, TaKKe aOJI)KHbl HaxoaHTbC5IB BeaeHHH 4)eaepajibHoro npaBHTejibCTBa, 4TO aaeT 6oJbwe B03MO)KHOCTeU ansAKOOPaHHaLuHH HayqHbIX pa6OT H pacipocTpaHeHX u Hpe3ynJbTaToB nO Bceri cTpaHe.

PerHOHaJIbHbie opraHbl BJIaCTH aOJDKHbl B3STb Ha ce6s OCHOBHYIO raOJuOo6Al3aHHocTeru nO nOBceaHeBHoMy amMHHHcTpaTHBHo-xo3SfiCTBeHHoMy ynpaBJ1eHHIO H4HHaHCHPOBaHHio pa6OTbI JleCHoro ceKropa B paMKaX o6LuerocyaapCTBeHHbIX Tpe6OBaHHrU.PerHoHbl AOADKHbl o6naaaTb nOJIHOMO4qHMH no pa3pa6oTKe HOpM H Tpe6oBaHH4, He

npOT4BOpel4uWHx 4)eaepanbHOMY 3aKOHOaaTejibCTBy H COOTBeTCTBYIOLUIHX IPHHUHnaM

paLuHOHaJbHOrO pecypcoynpaBJeHHs; npHHHMaTb pewIieHHS Ha pertoHaHJbHoM YPOBHe noBOnpOCaM a,MHHHCTpaTHBHOrO yrpaBjieHHs, oxpaHbl, 3alUHTbl, HCHOjIb3OBaHHA H

BOCnpOH3BOJICTBa JieCHbIX peCypCOB. PerHoHarIbHbie opraHbl BjiaCTH AOJDKHbI TaKxeKOHTPOJIHPOBaTb H OLxeHHBaTb pa6oTy 'aCTHoro ceKTopa, o6ecnequsBaTb co6jiloAeHHe3aKOHO,aaTeJTbHb[X Tpe6oBaHHri H HpHpOaOOXpaHHbIX HOpM X03Af4CTBeHHOfl aeSITeCjbHOCTH, aTaioCe B3HMaTb apeHAHylO nuIaTy 3a nOJIb3OBaHHe pecypCaMH H pacrpeaejIiTb noJyIeHHbIe

d)KHaHCOBbie CpeaCTBa. X03.IriCTBeHHaS aeATeJIbHOCTb H HHTepeCbi Tpai4uLHOHHbIXnoAb3oBaTeAeg 3eMeJIbHbIx, JIeCHbIX H apyrHX peCYPCOB Ha MeCTHOM YPOBHe aOfDKHblrOJIHOCTbIO Y'HTbIBaTbC5 B rOCyaapCTBeHHOrl rOJIHTHKe H nporpammax.

HOBaA cTpyKTypa aaMHHHCTpaTHBHOrO H X03AHCTBeHHOrO yripaBjieHHi4 .1eCHbIMHpecypcamU Tpe6yeT pa3pa6oTKH HOBOU Haj1OrOBOUi cHCTeMbi, HO3BOJI3qOwerU yHH4bHUHPOBaTb

H YnPOCTHTb CH4CTMy nocTynHJIeHH5[ aOXOAOB OT HCHOJlb3OBaHHI JieCHbIX peCYPCOB (Ha

OCHOBaHHH pbIHOqHOrO lIeHoo6pa3oBaHHA) H pacripeaeJiqTb aOXOabI MeWKy pa3JIHqHbIMHYPOBHRMH ynpaBJleHHs, OTBeTCTBeHHbIMH 3a JieCOXO3SrluCTBeHHyIO aesTenbHOcTb.(DHHaHCHPOBaHHe perCOHajibHbIX H MeCTHbIX opraHOB Bj1aCTH AOJDKHO 6blTb SCHbMM H

qeTKHM, KaAKJblIi YPOBeHb 11ojKeH 6blTb B COCTOSHHH OTqHTbIBaTbCq no pacxoaaM H p RoXoaMieCHOrO ceKTopa, KpOMe 3TOrO, BCS CHCTeMa cUHHaHCHpOBaHHsl aOA)KHa COOTBeTCTBOBaTbpaUHOHanJbHOMy ynpaBieHH1O pecypcaMH. CneayeT H36eraTb co3laaHHIA TaKHX yCJIOBHii, npHKOTOpbIX y OpraHOB ynpaBJeHHA iieCHb[M X03ArSCTBOM nIOoBJiqflJaCb 6bl MaTepHaJIbHas3aHHTepecOBaHHOCTb B 3arOTOBKe apeBeCHHbl B o6'beMax, fipeBblaiO1UHX pa3yMHble C3KOnoruH,ecKoiH unI4 3KOHOMHMeCKOri TOMKH 3peHHA, ripm KOTOpbIX qj14HaHCHpOBaHHe

rocynapCTBeHHOrO ceKTopa 3aBHCHT HCKJIIOMHTeJlbHO OT o61beMa 3arOTOBJ1eHHOH apeBeCHHbl.TaM, rae 3TO OrlpaB.aHHO, 'aCTb AOXOaOB OT FIPOH3BOaCTBa apeBeCHHbl cJieayeTHCnOJIb3OBaTb AAA yKpeniieHHA CHCTeM XO35HCTBOBaHHA KOpeHHbIX MaIo4HcJieHHbIX HapO,aOBH MeCTHOrO HaceJieHHS.

AeATeJlbHOCTb qaCTHoro ceKTOpa 6yaeT B OCHOBHOM OHpeeJIflTbCq YCJIOBH4IMHpbIHKa B npeeRenax o6iUerocygapcTBeHHor4 (4e1AepaAbHor) CTpyKTypbI neCHoi HOjiHTHKH H

Page 24: Russian - World Bank Documents

6

CHCTeMbi peryJIHpOBaHHq. YCTOWiHBoe HCnOAb3OBaHHe J1eCHbIX peCypCOB ,LOJDKHO 6blTb

rnIaBHbIM opHeHTHPOM pa6oTbl, a ILorOBOpbl o nepeiaae npaB nOnJb3OBaHH51 2OJDKHbIoTpa)KaTb npaBa H o6H3aHHOCTH o6eux CTOpOH: Aep)KaTenH KOHUeCCHH U 3eMj1eBjia,eJ1b1ta.

JorOOBOpbI O nepegame npaB noj1b3oBaHHS AOJDKHbi 6blTb OCHOBaHbl Ha noKa3aTeniqx pa6oTbl

H onFipaTbCA Ha noapo6Hy1o HH4JopMauLHo o pecypcax, tTO crioco6cTBoBarlo 6bl

aKTHBH33auULHH JIOnrOCpOMHO npeAnpHHHMaTej1bCKOui eASTeJAbHOCTH H rlOBbluieHH1O

3¢4eKTHBHOCTH onepaTIBHoro BTOaHHHOBaHI4R B paMKaX o6ulerocyAapcTBeHHori CHCTeMb1

peryJIHpoBaHH5I. CneayeT cnoco6CTBOBaTb TOMy, 'lTO6bl 4aCTHbIir CeKTop,

PYKOBO,aCTBYIOWHUICR ctTyaLuHei Ha pblHKe, HHBeCTHpOBail 3HaqHTenJbHbie Cpe1,CTBa B

nepecTporiKy npOMbilIiJeHHOCTH AASA o6ecneLeHHI peHTa6eJIbHOcTH H yCTO4tlHBOCTH

pa3BHTH5 H COXpaHeHHA npOH3BOACTBeHHbIX H nepepa6aTbiBaolitUX MOWHocTeU, a TaiOKe AIn9

pacuJHpeHH.q H CO,ep)KaHHA TpaHCnOpTHOA HH(paCTpyKTypb1 ,AAS 3arOTOBKH nieca. '-TO6bT

HipHBACMb K pa6oTe 'aCTHbIr ceKTop H He aaTb KoMMeptecKHM HHTepecaM nOCTaBIBTb nOA

yrpo3y 3KOJ1orHMecKyio YCTORI4BOCTb, CaMOBOCCTaHOBjieHHe niecOB, TpaAilUHOHHbie yKJaLbi

H )KH3Hb MeCTHOrO HaceJieHHR, HY)KHbl LeiieBbie rOCyIapCTBeHHbie HHBeCTHUHH.

06wneCteBwe HeHC7OmlM7 HOCTm .IecHblX peCypcOB, 1e(IOCTHOCTH OA pyxmawO(cA cpe,A H

9KOHOMtIYCCKONI JUI3HeC7OC6HOCT

UeHTpaAbHoe MeCTO B HOBOU¶ cTpyKType nOJIHTHKH 11o ynpaBjieHliO JIeCHbIM

CeKTopoM aOAXDHbI 3aHHMaTb 3IXeKTHBHoe pacnpeAejieHHe 3eMeJIb H pecypcOB H

paLuHOHaAbHoe ynpaBjieHH5 HMH. CoriacHo MHmelOWUHMc nporHO3aM, cnpOC Ha apeBeCHHY6yAeT paCTH KaK BHYTpH cTpaHbl, TaK H Ha MHPOBOM pbIHKe, a nocTyriiieHHe ,ApeBeCHHbI H3

Tpa,1HUHOHHbIX ieCOCbipbeBbiX 6a3 B KpaTKOCpO4HOH H cpeaHeCpOlHHoR nepcreKTHBe, cKopee

Bcero, 6yaeT H Aanee coKpaIiIaTbcsl. PauHoHanbHoe, HeHCTOIUHTeJIbHoe ynpaBsieHHe

JieCHbIMH pecypcaMH ROJDKHO 6blTb AOMHHHpy1oiueIU 3aAaqeu OxpaHbl, 3aBULTbl H

HCnOJlb3OBaHHS 3THX peCYPCOB B 3KoJIOrUHeCKHX H KoMMepteCKHX LXenlx. HpH npaBHJ1bHOM

ynpaBJieHHH, LleHHbIe neCHble peCypCbl 6yayT B H3o6HJHH nocTaBJIqTb 3KOHOMHMecKHe,

coUHaJIbHb1e, 3KOnor'H'ecKHe H peKpeaUHOHHbie 6nara. flonIb3OaTeniH AOJDKHbi 6yayT

YqlHTbIBaTb KaK 3KOJ1OFH4eCKHe 4)aKTopbi, TaK H 3KOHOMHuecKHe 3aTpaTbI, H TaKOrl noaxoa

npHBe,aeT K 3HaMHTeJnbHOMy coKpauileHH1o njiotuaaei, KOTOpbIe B HaCTo05U.ee BpemsAOCTynHbl fISl npoMblujieHHo04 3arOTOBKH nieca. JleCHOi ceKTop coxpaHAeT CBOUI CHJIbHbflU

3KOHOMHMeCKHr HOTeHUHaL J HeCMOTIp Ha TO, 4TO OrpOMHbie njioluaaH JieCOB ABJISIOTCS

3KOHoMH,eCKH HeAOCTynHbiMH, a Ha 3HatHTenJbHOR HX 'aCTH iieco3arOTOBHTeJIbHaS,ae5iTeJIbHOCTb 6yAeT 3anpewieHa B CBH3H C Heo6xolHMOcTbIO COXpaHeHHS U 3a1HTbl nieCOB.

KpoMe Toro, HeO6XOAHMO pa3BHBaTb KaK BTOpHUHyio nepepa6oTKy ApeBeCHHbl, TaK H

rIPOH3BOACTBO 3aMeHHTenJei JIecHOfl HpOAyKUH4H XIA51 HCOJIb3OBaHH51 B KaqeCTBecTporiMaTepHajiOB H 6yMaxKHOU flpOAyKLUHH.

OcHoBononiaralou.HM YCJIOBHeM aOCTH)KeHHS 3THX uejieri qsBIfeTcT 6o0iee qeTKoeonpeAej1eHHe KaTeropHH, MeCTOHaxo)KeHHSA H pacnpeAeJIeHHA JIeCHbIX peCypCoB B

3KoJIorFHtecKoM, 3KOHOMHMeCKOM H COUHaAbHOM KOHTeKcTax. 'qTO6bi onpeaej1HTb,

HaCKOJ1bKO HY)KHO yBeCH4HTb nflOLUaAH 3anOBseHb1X TeppHTOpiR ,AAA COXpaHeHH5

3KojiorH4ecKH ueHHbIX nieCOB, Heo6xoaHMo npOBeCTH aHlai3 npo6enloB B HMe1lu0UXc51AaHHb1X. TaKa5 pa6oTa ceRNac ywe BeaeTCA B paMKax PoccHrcKoro npoeKTa no

coxpaHeHHio 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3fl, KOTOpbil ocyiueCTBjiSeTcq npH noaAep)KKe rUno6anibHoro

3Ko0JormqecKorro oioHa (Fr3q). Heo6XoAiHMo pa3pa6oTaTb 6o0nee TO4Hoe onpe,AejeHHe

KpHTepHeB pauHOHanbHoro BeAeHHU1 X03HflCTBa, no3BOJIsll01uee HAeHTWjUHULHpOBaTb

Page 25: Russian - World Bank Documents

7

pecypcHyio 6a3y, KOTOpaR Mor.ia 6bl CTaTb o61beKToM OTBeTCTBeHHOrO npOMbblUwjeHHOrOIieconojib3oBaHH4,q a TaK)Ke Te noIlauH, KOTOpbIe AOA)KHbi no-npe)KHeMy HCnOflb3OBaTbCAAAS fIpOH3BOACTBa B LefAlX yaoBAeTBOpeHHS HY)KZt MeCTHOrO HaceJieHHA. 9Ta HHd)OpMauHHHeo6xo,aHMa =nq o6ecneqeHHs azeKBaTHOr npeACTaBAeHHOCTH 64opa3Hoo6pa3Hs B CHCTeMeoxpaHbI npIpOabl H 3aLUHTbI XpynKHX 3KOCHCTeM. BblsIcHeHHe TOYHbiX napaMeTpoBpecypcHori 6a3bl Tpe6yeTCs H JAnM coaegCTBHA B nHaHHpOBaHHH KanNTaJIOBJ1O)KeHHU HnepecTpouKn HpOMbiHIJieHHOCTH.

Heo6xo,aHMa TaKaq peopraHH3auHS npeanpHIuTH9 JiecHo0i npOMblwJIeHHOCTH,KOTOpa. caeniauTa 6bl HX 3aUHTepeCOBaHHbIMH B COKpalleHHH peaJlbHbIX 3aTpaT HHapalUHBaHHU aOXOaOB H CTHMYJIHPOBBaa 6bl 6o0nee 3I4eKTHBHoe HCnOnb3OBaHHe pecypcoB1apeBecuHbl, a TaioKe o6Jier'Hua 6bl nepexog OT HCTOlUHTeJIbHOrO K yCTO9i'-IBOMyHeHCTO1UHTeJbHOMY pecypcoHonJb3oBaHHIO. ,Anq AeCHOr' npOMbiUiJeHHOCTH OITHM343aUH.9npH6bIlJH OT HcUiOJlb3OBaHHq peCypCOB 6yaeT O3HaYaTb aaanTaUHIo K Tpe6oBaHHRM pbIHKa HCHCTeMaTHUeCKOe HCnOJnb3OBaHue COOTBeTCTBYOIOUHX npaKTH'eCKHX MeTOAOBBOCCTaHOBJleHH5 peCYPCOB (B paMKaX 3KOJIOrH4eCKH o6oCHOBaHHOrO HeHCTOIUHTeJTbHOrOpecypcoynpaBjieHH4u). HOBaSI TeXHOJIOFH5 nepepa6oTKu, co3laioueg ,ao6aBAeHHy1oCTOHMOCTb, 5iBjSieTCS Ba)KHbIM uwaroM Ha nyTH K rOBblUeHHIO 43j4eKTHBHOCTHHCnOnb3OBaHHS peCypCOB H COBepeHCHCTBOBaHHIO perHOHaJIbHbIX 3KOHOMH'eCKHX CHCTeM, aTaK)4e K nOBblLweHHIO KoHKypeHTocHoco6HocTH HpOayKUxH J1eCHOi npoMbbUIwCHHOCTH,npOH3BOLaHMO4 B palOHax C OrpaHH4eHHbIMH J1eCHb[MH pecypcaMH.

Ba)KHylo POJb B o6ecneqeHHH PpaUHOHajlbHOCTH BeaeHH5 X035IiCTBa 6yaeT HrpaTbOT'IHcneHHe 3HaM4TeAbHO9 0oJ4 CTOHMOCTH iieCHblX pecypcoB rocyaapCTBy (KaK BjiaaeJbLuypecypca). Heo6xoaHMO TaK YCOBCpwI1eHCTBOBaTb CHCTCMY HajIoroo6jio)KeHHS4 B jieCHOrInpoMbilIueHHOCTH, WTO6bi MO)KHO 6buio OTaeUlHTb npo6JieMbi apeHfiaHO9 flYIaTbI 3a pecypcblOT npo6neM HaJoroo6jio)KeHHS npearnpHITHC. HbIHe ae9CTBYLLtaq CHCTeMaHanoroo6jio)KeHHH H pa3MepbI TaKHX c6opoB, KaK, HanpHMep, noneHHaq niiaTa, 3aHH)KalOTCTOHMOCTb jiecHoro IieCHbIX pecypcoB (BKInlo4as HeapeBecHbie ;IeCHbIe npoayKTbi H apyrHeHpOTIyKTbI), npHBOAST K ero 'pe3MepHOr4 3KcrijyaTauLH H CHH)Ka[OT 3aHHTepeCOBaHHOCTb BHHBeCTHPOBaHHH. KpoMe TOrO, 6onbWuie B03MO)KHOCTH nonjyTeH14HH HaTIOFOBbIX aOXOAOBTepf5IOTCS H3-3a He3aKOHHbIX py6oK H nJToXoro BeaeHHS y4eTa. CTpyKTypa AOXOLaOB OTapeKrabI pecypcOB aOJDKHa o6ecne'usBaTb riOJIHbli BHyTpeHHI4U yqeT 3aTpaT(HHTepHariH3alLHIo), HeHCTOLUHTeAbHOCTb peCYPCOB H CnpaBeHJIHBbie BblrIHTaTbl B flOJb3yAecoBfaZ1eAbLteB, KOTOpbie COOTBeTCTByOWUHM o6pa3OM pacnpeaen5HoTCq Mme)KLy BCeMHYPOBH5MH ynpaBjieHH5, T.C. Mew)y 4DeaepaJbHbIMH, o6JiaCTHbIMH H MeCTHbIMH opraHamuBJiaCTH. HaJIorOBble CTaBKH X151 JIeCHbIX npealrpHATHH aOJIKHbi 6blTb TaKHMH )Ke, KaK IAnsBcex OCTaBJbHbIX oTpacneri npOMblwieHHOCTH POCCHu.

BopeajibHble nieca PoccHu HMelOT BaKHoe 3Ha'leHHe an] cTa6uJIH3auH aTMoccIepHb[Xra3OB H r.no6aAbHbIx KIMHaTH4eCKHX yCJIOBHsu. gA5i yruy6iieHHqS FOHHMfaHHS 3aBHCuMOCTHMex(gy rno6a;IbHbIM KhHMaTOM H 6opeanbHbIMH iecaMH Heo6xoaWMo npOBeCTHIOIIOJIHHTeJIbHbie HayYHbie 4CCjieaOBaHH5, HO y)Ke cerFiac ACHO, YTO Ha KOJIH'IeCTBO

yrnepoaa, BbIAeji5eMOrO B aTMOCd)epy, 60JbLoe BJIHAHHe MOryT OKa3blBaTb cnoco6bl HKaqeCTBO JIecOHOJnb3OBaHH5I, TeXHHKa 60pb6bl C JieCHbIMH rOixapaMH H MeTOAblBOCrPO43BOACTBa JeCHbIX peCypCOB. COBepweHCTBOBaHHe CICTeMbi yrlpaBIBeHJIA Hi HX3alHUTbI JieCOB mrpaeT KPHTH4eCKH Ba)KHYIO pOJlb B CB534 C TeM, YTO e)KerORHOJIeCo3aroTOBKaMH, noxKapaMH H ApyruHMH aKTopaMH YHH4TO)KxaeTC5 2-3 MJH. ra. 3TU

Page 26: Russian - World Bank Documents

8

noTepH Mo6HJH3yloT yriiepoR, KOTOpblH B TOT MOMeHT XpaHHJICA B 6HoMacce H nOqBe Ha

3THX nnomaaqlx. 3nopoBbie HacawaeHHA 6yayT yBeCjiH4HBaTb nornoLueHHe H ,onrocpoqHoe

xpaHeHHe yrIepoxa.

COL(H,aIHaff 3aIW(M7 H8CeIeHHff, VP0AWB8Il0LrWF B JIeCHMX pai#oHax

ELue oAHa Ba)KHaSl 3aAaqa CB53aHa C peumeH4em npo6.neM 3KOHOMHLeCKH

YH3BHMbIX COUHaJIbHbIX rpynr HaceJieHHM JieCHbIX paUOHOB B nepHoa 3KOHOMHMeCKHX

npeo6pa3oBaHlH. JIeCO3arOTOBHTejibHbie noceJIKH, HaXOlIuWHecH B OTAaZjeHHbIX paiUOHaX

A3HaTcKori qaCTH PoccHH, 59BARIOTCH MeCTOM npOHKBaHB4HR 6onee, qem 1,8 MJIH. '4efloBeK. B

CBR3H C nepexoLoM K pbIHOMHOA 3KOHOMHKe H Heo6XoaiMOcTbio y"eTa pOCTa

npOH3BOX1CTBeHHbIX 3aTpaT, MeCTHbie rpeanrpH5ITH 6bilnH BbIHyW)KeHbI O4eHb CHjIbHO

COKpaTHTb npoH3BOACTBO ApeBcCHHbl, 'qTO npsHBeO K naaeHNIO YPOBHA 3aHATOCTH, AOXO,IOB

H KaqeCTBa COLU1aHJbHbIX ycjiyr, qTO B CBOIO oqepeab o6ycjiOBuJIo rOBbiLUeHHe YPOBHA

6eRHOCTH. Oco6eHHO OCTPO 3Ta rlpo6neMa CTOHT B HacenJeHHbIX nyHKTax,

KOHUeHTPHPYO1LUHXCS BOKpyr OtHOrO riperinpHATHA JieCHOlr npOMbIUJIeHHOCTH, rAe )KHTenAH

3aBHCIT HCKJIO'qHTeJIbHO OT aeHTeCAbHOCTH 3TOrO HpeAnpH51TH51 B nnaHe B03MO)KHOCTH

nojiyqeHH51 cpeRCTB K cylweCTBOBaHHIO. Mepbl no o6ecHeqeHI4O HacenieHHR COLuajibHblMH

YCyraYMH H CHHxeKHHIO YPOBHS 6ezHocTH Tpe6yIoT paCCMOTTpeHH B o6werocyaapCTBeHHOH

nepcnieKirBe. Co3xaaH4e yCTOHM4BOHA CTPyKTYPbI 3aHAITOCTH 3a C'eT HHBeCTHLkHH CpeaCTB B

pa3iiHMHbie peHTa6eJIbHbie rpoH3BO.fCTBa H B nepepa6oTKy HeapeBeCHbIX rpOioyKTOB B

JTeCHOM ceKTope JDO)KHO CTaTb aOJIrOCpO4HOA 3aAaqeA. O0,HaKO o6ecne4eHHe HacenjeHHq

COUHanJbHbIMH ycjiyrami Tpe6yeT He3aMeAnnTenjbHbIX aeACTBHA, KOTOpble roMoorniH 6bl

HaH6onee OCTPOHyxAlaioLLuMcq rpynnaM HaceAeHHS4, BKJIo4aSA KOpeHHoe HaceneHHe 3TWXpaHiOHOB. IlpaBa KOpeHHOrO HacenieHHH Ha 3eMAIo H4 JIeCHbIe peCypCbl aOfDKHbi 6blTb

3aKOHoAaTenJbHO yTOqHeHbI H 3aIuxlLeHbl, KpOMe TOrO, HeO6xOaHMbl Mepbi no noNaep)KKe

TpaHULHOHHbIX 3KOHOMHqeCK4X YKJAlaOB H MeTOaOB X035flHCTBeHHOrU aeqTejIbHOCT4 H

pa3BHTHIO COOTBeTCTBYIOLUHX KOHCyJIbTaLuiOHHbIX MexaHH3MOB, B TOM 'Hcjie HcnOJib3OBaHHe

pbIHOMHbIX MeXaHH3MOB XIA HeHCTOHTenJbHorO HCnOJIb3OBaHH51 He1peBeCHbix nIeCHbIX

npO,RyKTOB.

HporpaMMa pe4opMHpoBaHHA JieCHoro cecropa

FporpaMMa peqjOpMbi iecHoro ceKTopa cocpeAoToqeHa Ha qeTbipex rFfaBHbIX

npo6ieMax: HHTerpauHq iieCHoro CeKTOpa B o6we3KOHOMHiecKyio pe¢OpMy, nepexoR K

pauHOHaJIbHOMY BeaeH11O IieCHoro X03AACTBa, paUHOHajiH3auuH rOCyLaPCTBeHHbIX

KanHTa8JbHbIX H TeKYLUHX 3aTpaT H 'eTKoe onpe,eJIeHHe poJIH Meex,yHapOaHoro coo6wuecTBa.

Yrny6neHHe HHTerpauH nieCHoro CeKTOpa B npouecc npOBeAeHHA

3KOHOMH4eCKHX ped3OpM MBJIAeTCq oco6eHHo aKTyaJlbHOH 3a,aMeg B CBi3H C HaCJieaHeM

CHCTeMbl ueHTpaSU3HBaHHOAO niaHHpOBaH4H. pHp CHCTeMe, aeriCTBOBaBmeri B FIPOWUIOM,

3KOHOMHqeCKHe 3aTpaTbl H pe3yflbTaTbl He BJIHAJIH Ha peweHHA, lHHHmHMaeMbIe B cqepe

pacnpeneneHHA AeCHbIX pecypCOB, TaK KaK neCHbIe njioLLaAH BbiAeJIAA1HCb B nOjib3OBaHHe

rocyIapCTBeHHblM aepeBonepepa6aTbIBaIoLuHM npeanpHS1THAM Ha OCHOBaHHH aBTOPHTaPHO

YCTaHOBjieHHbIX npOH3BoACTBeHHbix niiaHOB H npH OTCYTCTBHH KOHKypeHUHH. FepeXOa K

pblHOqHOHi 3KOHOMHKe B 3Haql4TeJlbHOr4 CTeneHHH pa3pylUflU npeKHIOlO CHCTeMy

pecypCOrIOIb3OBaHHA, rIOCKOJ]bKy JieCOnpOMbbIwJeHHHKaM IpHUWJIOCb BKJllOxIHTb B CBOH

Page 27: Russian - World Bank Documents

9

paCqeTbl aHHbie, 6jiH3KHe K peajibHb[M 3aTpaTaM Ha npOH3BOaCTBO. OAHaKo, aoJirocpoqHaqHeHCTOULUHTeJ1bHOCTb J1eCHbIX peCypCOB 6yaeT 3aBCceTb KaK OT JIHKBH,LRaUH cOxpaHAIOLUHXCSnepeKocoB pbIHO4HbIX ueH, TaK H OT pa3BHTHSI KOHKypeHUHH HyTeM npOBeCeHHS34"eKTKBHor4 aHTHMOHonOJIbHori noJIHTHKH B nepepa6aTbIBaIoLuHx oTpacnRlx.KOHKypeHTHMIe pbIHKH, coaei4CTBHe CBo6OaHoMy BcTynineHuI0 B HHX HOBbIX KOMnaHuH HOpraHH3arUH KOHKYPCOB Ha npHo6peTeHHe npaBa noAb3oBaHH$ JieCHbIMH pecypcaMH,AOJDKHbl aaTb HpaBHTejibCTBY B03MO)KHOCTb IOJIn"aTb rOTeHUHajIbHO 6oAbltue HanoroBbie,aoxo,abi, o6pa3yloLurecsl 3a CMeT 3KCnjiyaTaluH pecypcoB, H HCnOJIb3OBaTb HX AAA4HHaHCHPOBaHHR paCXOaOB Ha Ba)KHbie AeCOXO3ArCTBeHHbie MepOnpHATHI,o6ecneqHBalotouHe HeHCTOLUHTejibHOe BOCHPOI3BOACTBO peCypCOB.

Ponib rocyaapcTBeHHoro ceKTopa 3aKYIIo'aeTcA B 3alulJTe Tex acneKTOBo6iueCTBeHHbIX UeHHoCTeU, KOTOpbIe CBA3aHbi C 3KOOTrH4eCKHMH U COLLHajTbHbIMi4YHKUH4MH JIeCOB, H B co3flaHH4 COOTBeTCTBY1Omer4 cpeAbi AAA npHBjieIeHH4I qaCTHbIXHHBeCTHUHIi B yCTOUMHBOe lpO13BOACTBO. 3Ta pOjib HMeeT 6oJIbUIoe 3HaqeH4e, HOTOMY 'TO,KaK nOKa3blBaeT MeAKLyHapOaHblfi OrbIT, 'aCTHbIrl CeKTOp peaKO COaefiCTByeT YCTOfiMHBOMyoTpacnieBoMy pa3BITHIO, ecnIH OH rpeAOCTaBneH caMoMy ce6e H AeflCTByeT Ha CBoeyCMOTpeHHe. OaHaKO npaBHTenJbCTBY HaAO yCOBepweHCTBOBaTb CHCTeMy 43HHaHCHpOBaHH,rOCy,aPCTBeHHbIX KarUHTanJbHbIX H TeKylI1HX 3aTpaT H oripeAenHTb ux npHOp4TeTbl;o6ecne4HTb, qTo6bI pa6oTa Bcex ypOBHefi ynpaBJIeHHSq Bseacb B pamKax paiL4OHanJbHoroynpaBneHH.q JlecaMi. 9To HoTpe6yeT nepecmoTpa KpHTepHeB paCnpeaeJIeHHsI 3eMeJIb,KOppeKTHpOBKH MeTOIOB BeaeHHA X03SIHCTBa H yBeJmIHeHHuA rOcyaapCTBeHHbIX KaniTaBjbHbIX3aTpaT Ha oxpaHy H 3aLuLTy JIeCOB. B 3TOU CBS3H TaloKe Heo6xoaHMo 6o0ee 51CHOonpeLejiHTb POJIb Mex(LyHapoQHoro coo6wecTBa B npeaOcTaBjieH44 TeXHH4eCKOi H4JHHaHCOBOR noMoWu. npH BBeaeHHI HU ocyweCTBJIeHHH HOBOU4 CTpyKTypHOr nOAHTHKH HperyJIHPOBaHH5 iiecHoro ceKcopa npaBHTenbCTBO AOJDKHO ripOBeCTH BCeCTOPOHHIOIO OUeHKyBO3MO)CHbIX nocie1ACTBHg npOBeaeHHA KOpeHHbIX pe43opM.

HHTCpaIrHJI JIeCHOrO CeKTOpa B 0&6He3KOHoMHIreCKIo peM4OpMy

CTpaTenHH pa3BHTHA1 JTeCHOrO ceKTopa AOJIXHa COOTBeTCTBOBaTb 6ojiee 1UHpOKHM3KojiorHtIecKHM, 3KOHOMHMeCKHM H COuHaJ]bHbIM ueJISM rocyaapcTBa, a pecopMbl IieCHOu H,aepeBOo6pa6aTbIBaloLUHX oTpacneri aOJDKHbI CTaTb 4aCTbio rpOrpaMMbl 3KOHOMH'eCKOUpe4JOpMbi CTpaHbl B uejioM. CneayeT riOCTenIeHHO yCTpaHHTb MexperHOHaJlbHbie TOprOBble6apbepbl H OTKa3aTbC5 OT elixe OCTaBUJHXCA aOTau[iHf (Ha 3HMepri0 H TpaHcrlOpT) H apyr4xKOCBeHHbEX 43OPM 3KOHOMi4eCKOrO rPOTeKUHOHH3Ma, HCKaLKaio0uHX peweHH1s nopacnpejejieHulo peCypCOB H HHBeCTHpOBaHHIO. rOCyaapCTBeHHbie opraHbl ynpaBjieHt,i HeAOJIXHbI 3aHHMaTbCS KOMMep4eCKOU AesTej1bHOCTb1O B iieCHOM ceKTope, a aesTe.JbHOCTbMaCTHbIX KOMnaHHUU AOA)KHa BlHHCblBaTbC51 B paMKH 'eTKO OflpeAeJieHHOU CHCTeMbipeiyJIHpOBaHH5I, MTo6bi o6ecneHmTb OTKpbITOCTb, COXpaHeHHUe uejiOCTHOCTH OKpyxaiomeUCpenbl H yCTOr4MHBOCTb peCypCOB. Tpe6yloTcR cneuLiaY1bHbie Mepbi AuI peLueHHA npo6JIeMCOutiaJibHOi4 a,aHTaaau B OTgaJieHHbIX paUOHax, 'eTKOrO oripe1eJ1eHHH ripaB KOpeHHOrOHaceJieHu> Ha 3eMnlo, yKpeHiieHH51 TpaHULHOHHbIX YKnaTOB H co3AaHHI4 nporpaMMnepenpo43H.nHpOBaHHAU H nepeo6yqeHHR, KOTOpbie HOMOrmJI 6bl pa6oTHHKaM npHo6peCTHApyrlyO CneuLHaJIbHOCTb B CBA3H C peOpraHH3aUtie CeKTOpa.

C 1992 roAa B pe3ynJbTaTe ffm6epafm3aL(HHn L(eH HMeeT MeCTO pe3Koe rOBblwleHHexKeie3HOAOpOxcHbIx TapHUbOB, o6ycjioBeHHoe npH6i6H)KeHHeM ueH Ha 3HeprOHOCHTeAH K

Page 28: Russian - World Bank Documents

10

MHPOBOMY YpOBHIO, B CB513H C 4eM BO3pocJIa ueHa H COKpaTHJIC5I cnpoc Ha apeBeCHHy.

HecMOTpR Ha TO, WTO HeKOTOpbIe 3aUHTepeCOBaHHbie KpyrH Ha y)e npHBaTH3HuOBaHHbIX

FIpeAnpUHTHS1X Tpe6yWOT OT npaBHTejibCTBa BO3o6HOBJIeHHq npeaoCTaEBeHJ4HS cy6cH,flHi Ha

3HeprH1O H TpaHCnOpT, npaBHTejibCTBO AOJDKHO HanpaBHTb CBOH YCHJIHS1 Ha TO, qTO6bi

3aCTaBHTb npeanpHSTHA OCTaBaTbCI B ")KeCTKHX YCJIOBHSX" PbIHO4HbIX UeH. BHyTpeHHHe

LxeHbI Ha ApeBeCHHY HoKa eLue ropa3Ao HH)Ke MHpOBbIX, ITO OT4aCTH o6bsqcHHeTcs HH3KHMU

YPOBHIMH rOCyyLapCTBeHHbIX C6opOB.

MexaHm3mJ peHTHmx )JaTexef, B KOHeqHOM HTore, aOJD)KHbl o6ecneMHBaTb

IOCTyriieHHe B rOCY apCTBeHHblU CeKTOp (KOTOpblU IBjnieTcq JiecoBnaaejibueM H oTBeqaeT 3a

ynpaBneHHe necaMu) ropa3,ao 6oAbmuer aojii 3KOHOMHqeCKOU CTOHMOCTH JieCHbIX peCypCOB,

3KCnnIYaTHpyeMbIX Ha KOMMep4eCKOri OCHOBe. OAHaKO, nepCneKTHBbl 3HaqHTeJIbHOrO

yBeniH4qeHHA peHTHbIX nocTyHJiCeHHu B 6iHuKaginee BpeMq orpaHH4,eHbl, qTO CBq3aHO C

CyLLteCTBYIOLUHMH HeAOCTaTKaMH 3TOU C4CTeMbi, BbICOKHMH HaIorIaMH C npeanplU4THA npH

oqeHb HU3KUX q)aKTHqeCKHX HanorOBbIX c6opax HU cnaHoM npOH3BOACTBa ApeBeCHbIX H

He,apeBeCHbIX nIeCHbIX peCypCOB. TeM He MeHee, no Mepe o3AopoBAieHH4 ceKTopa

npaBHTejibCTBO LIOJD4HO 6o0ee cMeJIo 3KcnepHmeHTHPOBaTb C pa3HbIMH HHCTpyMeHTaMH

nOjiyqeHHS1 peHTHbIX AOXOaOB, oco6eHHO C TaKHM, KaK nIOBbIleHHe YPOBH5l

rOCy,aapCTBeHHblX c6opoB. Pa3MepbI 3THX c6opoB AOJDKHbl OTpa)KaTb He TOJIbKO CTOHMOCTb

BOCnPOH3BOILCTBa neca, HO H HeH36exKHbie nOTepH, CBq3aHHbIe C yTpaTorl onpe,eJIeHHbIX

nofle3HOCTef nieca, BKRio4a5 HeupeBeCHbIe nIeCHbIe npoayKTbi.

BBe,aeHHe H o6ecneMeH4e BblnOJIHeHHUI amTmoHoHOJHb Tpe6oBaHmW TaK)Ke

AOJIXHO cnoco6CTBOBaTb npOBeaeHH10 pe4opMbl B JieCHOM CeKTOpe. HeCMOTpI Ha ycnex B

npO,ABH)KeH4H riO nyTH npHBaTH3aULH4 B JieconpoMbiwjieHHOM KOMriieKce B LuenoM,

KBa3HMOHOnOAHCTHMqeCKHKe XOJIAHHrOBbIe KOMiaHHH B perHoHax Bce eute, KaK npaBuJIO,

nOJb3ylOTC5I He3acjiy)KeHHbIM npeHMyiueCTBOM npH KOHKypeHLUHI. IICnOJIb3yq CBOe BJIUSiHH4e,

OHH OKa3blBalOTCq B nprHBHerJ4POBaHHOM noJIo)KeHHH npH BbIlenjeHuH 3eMeJlb, Ha nieCHbIX

Toprax H npH nepepa6oTKe H 3KCnOpTe npo1yKu4H. MHorHe U3 HUX npOaO)xKalOTL4OMHHHpOBaTb B JIecHof npOMblwJIeHHOCTH CBOHX perHOHOB U MaCTO MOFYT BJTH5lTb Ha LeHy

nieca Ha KOpHIO H UeHbl Ha CBOio npoLyKuHio, KpOMe TOrO, OHH MOryT AOrOBapHBaTbCq 0

nbrOTHbIx, 6oJIee HH3KHX no CpaBHeHHIO C pbIHO4HbIMH, TpaHCnOpTHbIX TapHc4ax. XOT5 B

KaW,AOM KOHKpeTHOM cny'ae apryMeHT B HOJb3y 3c4eKTHBHOCTH KpynHoMaCLuTa6Hbix

npeanpHATHA Mor 6bl 6bITb CJIY)KHTb XIA npaBHTenJbCTBa BeCKOU nptiHtHOA OTCpOqKH

pa3yKpynHeHH51 MOHOHOJIHr, o6pa3OBaBuJHXCR B OTAajieHHbIX JeCHbIX pa4OHax, OHO 4O0JKHO

nO3a6OTHTbCS O .wUeHHH 3THX periOHaBJbHbIX XOJIRlHrOBb[X KOMHaHHUU KaKHX 6bl TO HU

6bu0o npMBuJerlH H o cTporoM co6jnoaeHKH aHTHMOHOnOJIbHbIX Tpe6OBaH4r B JieCHOM

ceKTope. Bce 3TO nOBbICHuo 6bl 344eKTHBHOCTb 3a cqeT pa3BHTH51 KOHKYPeHLtH4 BHYTPH

ceKTopa B pe3yJbTaTe roqBJIeHHSI HOBbIX )HpM H OpraHH3aUHH KOHKypCOB 3a npaBa

nOJnb3OBaHHA JieCHbIMH pecypcaMH. FpOCTa5l 3aMeHa rOCyXapCTBeHHbIX MOHoroJInir

qaCTHbIMH He cnoco6cTByeT HU HO5BJAeHHI0 KOHKypeHUHH, HU YCTOrNHBOMY pa3BI4THIO

ceKTopa.

3Ha4HTejIbHbIri 6iojxCeTHbIU aeHLUUHT Ha BCeX YPOBHAX ynpaBjieHHH CKa3blBaeTCH

Ha B03MO)KHOCTSIX BbinOJIHeHHM o65l3aHHOCTer4 no ynpaBJIeHIHHO .ieCHbIM CeKTOpOM. J,rn

nepeBo,aa niecHoro ceKTopa Ha nyTb yCTORqHBOrO pa3BHTH1 Tpe6ylOTCsI 4onOAHHTeJ1bHbie

peCypCbl. OIHaKo B npozrecce BJwefIeHHI 6,oa,TxenmCx cpecCT 4IHaHCOBbie nOTpe6HOCTH

ceKTopa cjiexyeT paCCMaTPHBaTb B KoMnHieKce. PaCxoAbl Heo6xoUHMo KjiaCCHUHU4POBaTb no

Page 29: Russian - World Bank Documents

II

3a,aaqaM ynpaBjieHHS KOMnHieKCOM C onpeaejieHHeM oTpacJieBbIX H BHYTPHOTpaCJTeBbIXnpHopHTeToB. B JieCHOM ceKTope K npHOpHTeTHbIM LLeISM AOJDKHbl OTHOCHTbCA:onpeLejieHHe COCTOSHHI AeCHbIX pecypCOB, oxpaHa, 3aWUTa H BOCrIpOH3BOaCTBo JIeCHbIXpecypcoB, a TaioKe co3AaHHe yCJOBHu AnIA BbIlOJIHeHHH 3KOJIorFHecKHx H AeCOBoLIqeCKHxTpe6oBaHHA, oroBapHBaeMbIX B noroBopax o npoaaxe neca Ha KOpHIO. B CBq3H C nepeaa4erinOAHOMO4Hr4 no ynpaBjTeHHlo iiecaMH perHOHajibHbIM H MeCTHbIM aaMlHHHCTpaLtHAmM Hpa3pa6oTKoA HOBbIX HaIorOBbIX cXeM pacnpeAej1eHHA aOXOaOB OT JIleCHbIX pecypCOB Horpe,aeAeHHA o6sI3aHHocTeA no HX ynpaBJIeHHIO Heo6xOaHMo npHHHMaTb 6onee34*eKTHBHbie peLueHHA no pa3MeILeHHIO pecypcoB Ha MeCTHOM ypOBHe. Pa3MepbIBbliAejiseMbiX 6 10LPeTHbIX CpeaCTB He aO,I)KHbI CBl3blBaTbCH HCKJIIO4HTejibHO c o6ibeMaMHJeCo3arOTOBKH, HIOCKOJbKy 3TO Bbl3blBaeT He3AOpOByIO 3aHHTepeCOBaHHOCTb B yBeJHMeHHHo6'beMoB 3arOTOBKH aO HCTOLUi4TeAbHbIX ypOBHer. 3HaqHTeflbHble H3MeHeHH5 B ripouecceBbAejAeHHS1 6iooKeTHbIx CpeaCTB Ha necHoe X03AACTBO npeayCMoTpeHbl B npoeKce HOBOrOJ]ecHoro KoaeKca (Hno.nb 1996 r.).

B nepexoaHblri nepHoa MHOrHM OTTaajieHHbTM paHOHaM, CyuXeCTBYIOLUHM 3a C'eTnecoB, CpO4HO Tpe6yeTcs npeaocTaBjieHHe ajTbTepHaTHBHbIX BO3MO)KHocTer4 3aHSTOCTH HCOLpif8JbhH yCJIT, (HHaHCHpyeMbix rocyaapCTBOM. B nocneaHee BpeMS COCTOSHHecoLLHajibHOi cCepbI B 3THX paiOHax O4eHb CHAbHO yXYaWHJIOCb, 'TO npHBeJIO K CHHKeHHIO)KH3HeHHoro YpOBHS, H K TOMy, 'ITO MHOrHe JAIOIH OKa3aJHCb 3a 4epTOA 6eaHoCTH.Bo3MOlKHO, wTo6bi o6ecne4HTb cpelHecTaTHCTHxecKHR YpOBeHb )KH3HH H yaOBjieTBOpHTboco6ble noTpe6HocTH HaceJTeHH5 B 3THX pa"OHaX, MeCTHbIM BJIaCTqM HOHaAo6HTbCS B3STb Hace6si 6o.nblue OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH 3a c4)epy COLUHajibHbIX ycjiyr HacenieHHS1 COOTBeTCTBylOLUHXTeppHTOpHUi. Heo6xoaHMo OaHo3HaqHO npH3HaTb 6onbuoe 3HaqeHHe 3aLUL4Tbl HyKpenreHHA TpaAHLHuOHHbIx YKJIaAOB KaK OHOro H3 nyTeri 3KOHOMHqeCKorO HecTeCTBeHHOrO BbLXHBaHHA KOpeHHbIX HapOAHOCTeri H ApyrHx rpynn HaceJieHHs, )KH3HeHHblgyKJIai KOTOpbIX HaHp5IMylO 3aBHCHT OT HCrIOJlb3OBaHHA JieCHbIX peCypCOB. HeO6XOaHMOpa3peuIHTb BOnpOC 0 npaBax KopeHHOrO HacefieHHA Ha 3eMAenojb3oBaHHe, qTo6bl KOpeHHbleKHTeIiH B MeHbweri cTeneHH o1LywaiH Ha ce6e 3KOHOMHqecKUe nepeMeHbl H MornJI

OCyUbeCTBJIsTb npaBo HOj1b3OBaHHA HpHHaHaAJexaLixeU HM 3eMnH. )i4iA CHHXCeHHS YpOBHA6e,HocTH nepBooqepeaHoe BHHMaHHe Heo6XOLHMO yaeflTb co3aaHHIo HOBbIX pa6oqHx MeCT.,UAsi ocywecTBJIeHI4.q HaLUHOHaJbHOr4 H perHoHanbHou cTpaTerHu H nOJIHTHKH JlecHoroceKTopa Hy)KeH ieJIbIir pSLA HOBbIX pa6o4Hx MeCT H BHLOB LeATenbHOCTH, BKnTIo4aApacuHpeHHe nepepa6oTKH apeBeCHbIX H HeLpeBecHbIx fleCHbIX pecypcoB, co3AalOLUerlLIo6aBJeHHyIo CTOHMOCTb. 9 To co3AaCT HOBbIe B03MOXCHOCTH 3aHSTOCTH H CHH3HT3aBHCHMOCTb OT CHCTeMbM COLHajibHorO o6ecne'eHHR, a TaKwKe 6yaeT cnoco6cTBoBaTbCOKpaLueHI4O MacCOBOI MMrpaUlHH HaceneHHR H3 ceBepHbIx par4OHOB B y)Ke RepeHaceJIeHHbIeropO,aCKHe H 6onee OCBoeHHbie parOHbl Ha lore.

JlepCXo, K YCTO,#lBoMyynpawBICMff Jfecaw

YCTO4IHBoe ynpaBjleHHe JiecaMH ABnASeTc5i OCHOBOU 3KoHoMHqecKoronpOUBeTaHHUA H COIUHaAbHOUi cTa6HJIbHocTH B pafloHax, rle )KH3Hb H aeATejibHOCTb Iloaer3aBHCHT OT IieCHbIX pecypcoB. B CBH3H C 3THM Heo6xorbHMo rOBbICHTb 3jXeKTHBHOCTbynpaBjieHHS JeCHbIMH 3eMnIMH Ha OCHOBaHHH nHaHHpOBaHHR 3eMnenonib3oBaHHH H CHCTeM3KoJorHqecKoro ynpaBweHHSI AnA o6ecneMeHHSI 3aWHTbI Bcex JIeCHbIX ueHHOCTei HKoMnHIeKCHOrO pa3BHTHAa LpyrHX BHaOB XO3ArfCTBeHHo aeSTejibHOCTH, BMIHSIOL(HX Ha jIecHoflceicrop. BBeaeHHe pa3AH4HbIX cjOpM KOHCyJIbTaUHr C MHOrO'HCJAeHHbIMH

Page 30: Russian - World Bank Documents

12

3aHHTepecoBaHHbimH CTOpOHaMH SBReTCSA OCHOBonojiaraioIUHM 4DaKTOpOM a,iJ nepexoaa K

paLLHOHaJbHOMY ynpaBnieHHIo JiecaMH. Jleca CH6upuH H aabHero BocToKa SIBJIqIOTCA OAHHM

H3 nocJIe,HHX nOJIHrOHOB, Ha KOTOPOM MO)KHO npOBep4Tb cnoco6HOCTb flpealnpHITH4

niecHoro ceKTopa 3aHHMaTbcS YCTOr4MHBbIM npOH3BOICTBOM 6e3 yiuep6a a.v

6Hopa3Hoo6pa3HA.

nlepBbIl mnar - yroIHcHHe COCToJHHRf pwCpCHOg 6a3m H npHSHTHe peweH[4r no

rOCy,aapCTBeHHOMy pecypcoynpaBjieHHIo H HHBeCTHpOBaHHIO CpeaCTB 'IaCTHOrO ceKTopa Ha

OCHOBaHHH HIeHTH43HKaLiHH nnoLa1aeri, npHrOILHbIX AAA YCTOr4IHBOrO npoH3BOJLCTBa

LapeBeCHHbl C 3KoJIorHqecKoui, 3KOHOMHUeCKOU H COuHaBjbHO1i TOMeK 3peHHq. EBonibwaq

tlaCTb nHou1aAi4 JieCOB POCCuH HaXOaHTCq B yaJIeHHb[X H TPYRHOaOCTynHblX parHOHax HuH B

YCJOBHUX npOH3paCTaHHH c nOBbiueHHOi 3KoJorHqecKoI 1yBCTBHTeAbHOCTbiO, He

noAxoaSmux LiR npoMbIlwJeHHoro npoH3BoaCTBa apeBecHHbl. BaKHerulyio POJIb IAs

394eKT4BHorO ynpaBACeHHS1 H aHanJH3 aaHHbIx no nIeCHbIM pecypcam HIrpaeT HcnoJIb3oBaHHe

COBpeMeHHbIX TeXHOJ1Orl4A AHCTaHUHOHHOrO 30HaHpOBaHH4I H reorpa)H'4ecK4x

4HH)OpMaUHOHHbIX CHCTeM ([mC). 9TH CHCTeMbl TaioKe HMelOT 6o0b0oe 3HaMeHHe AIS

BblS1BjieHHS TeppHTOpHd, Ha KOTOPbie npeTeHILylOT KOpeHHbIe )KHTeJIH, HAH 4ce KOTOpble

HCIIOjb3ylOTCA MeCTHbIM HaCeCIeHHeM B ueji5ix yaoBneTBOpeHHS co6CTBeHHbIX Hy)Q.

FIJraHmpoBaHe HCHOJII23aHI 3eMenb 5 eBJmIRTCS KJIIOHOM K LLeCOCTHOMY

MHOFOuejieBOMY nOaXOAY K yripaBJieHHIO JieCHbIMH peCypCaMH, HeO6XORHMOMY llJlf

OFTHMH43aUHH 3KOIorH'{eCKHx, COLUaHJbHbIX H 3KOHOMHUeCKHX BblrOA, yCTOr4HMBOrO

HCnOJIb3OBaHH51 nieCHbIX pecypcos HaceJieHHeM PoccHH, a TaKwe AqS 3aiuHTbl npHPOaHoro

HacnieAHS CH6HpH H LIajabHero BocToKa. KoMniieKcHoe nLTaHHPOBaHHe H HCnoJb3OBaHH14

3eMeJIb HeO6xoai4Mo IAn HIeHTHq)HKauiHH H 3aLWHTbl TeppHTOpHU, npeACTasBjioL$utx

3HaqHTeCJbHYIO UeHHOCTb C TOqKH 3peHHS 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3HA, pa3JIH4HbIX o6lueCTBeHHbIX

ueHHOCTeU HunH 3aBLU1THbIX 4yHKUH4I, a TaKie TeppHTOpHR, oTjiH4,aioUHXCq nOBblweHHOH

BOCnpUHHMMHBOCTbIO K HeraTHBHbIM nOCJIeACTBH$M, Bbl3blBaeMbIM npOMbIUJleHHb1MH

jieCO3arOTOBKaMH. MHPOBOH OnbIT noKa3blBaeT, 'TO ycnex B rmaHHPOBaHH4H HCHoJIb3oBaHH5

3eMejfb O6bIqHO OCHOBbiBaeTCS Ha CHCTeMaTH'eCKOM BblIBBJieH4H 3aHHTepeCOBaHHbIX CTOpOH,

KOHCYJTbTaUHqX C HHMH H HpHBJieMeHHH HX K 3TOH pa6oTe.

Jaa)Ke Ha TeppHTOpHqx, rae XO3SICTBeHHaS aeqTeJIbHOCTb BeaeTCq, B OCHOBHOM, C

ueLJblO npOMblUJTeHHOr4 3arOTOBKH apeBeC4Hbl, nO BMCKiM 3KOHOMH4eCKHM H

3KOJIOrH4eCKHM npH'IHHaM Heo6XORHMO BHeapITb h9KOCHCTMHMI1 IvOa K YIpaBIHMIo,

npH KOTOpOM MeTKO onpeAen5ilOTcA KaK 3KojiorHMeCKHe, TaK H 3KoHOMH'eCKHe uenIH

ynpaBjieHH51 JecaMH. 9TOT noaxoa 6yaeT iyquwe o6ecneiHBaTb coxpaHeHie

6Hopa3Hoo6pa3HH, MHHHMH3auLHlo HeTTo-3MHCC4H yrJiepoaa, coxpaHeHHe nonyjiRU1Hi AHKHX

)KHBOTHbIX H OXpaHy nO-I B H BOI, a TaKwe y,oBJIeTBOpeHHe MeCTHblX noTpe6HocTerH B

pecypcax aHKHX )KHBOTHbIX H apyrHX HeapeBeCHbIX nieCHbIX npoayKTaX. JecHoe

3aKOHOflaTeJlbCTBO aOJDKHO 6blTb HIOJIHOCTbIO COrFiaCOBaHO CO CTpOriHMH Tpe6oBaHHqMH4

4e,epanbHorO 3aKOHoaaTeAbCTBa no oxpaHe oKpy)KaioLUeri cpeabi - 3TOT npUHHuHn nOKa B

HeC2OCTaTO'IHOr4 CTeneHU peajiH3OBaH B nPOeKTe HOBOrO JIeCHoro KoaeKCa. MeCTHbIe

3aHHTepeCOBaHHbie CTOPOHbI )OJIXHbl Ha CHCTeMaTtiqeCKOrU OCHOBe np4HHMaTb yqaCTHe B

niaHHPOBaHHH H npOBeaeHH4 neCOBOCCTaHOBHTenJbHblX MeponpH5THg. B MeponplHHTH5x no

nAaHHPOBaHHIO HcnOJIb3OBaHHR 3eMenJb ,40A)KHbI npHHHMaTb y4aCTue cJIeaylo[uHe BeAOMCTBa:

FOCy1aapCTBeHHbl4 KOMHTeT POCCHACKOR cDeAepauHi no 3eMenJbHbIM pecypcam H

3eMjieyCTpOrUCTBY (POCKOM3eM), cIeaepaAbHas cnyxK6a iieCHoro xo3SICTBa, rocyRapcTBeHHblH

Page 31: Russian - World Bank Documents

13

KoMHTeT POCCHRCKOR (DejaepaLtuH no oxpaHe oKpy)Kaiouea cpeLbi, perHoHanfbHbie opraHbiBJaCTH, KOpeHHOe HaceJieHHe, Hay4HO-HccAeaoBaTejibcKHe y,-pe1(neHSA,HenpaBHTenbcTBeHHbie OpraHH3aUHH H apyrie 3aHHTepeCOBaHHbie CTOpOHbl.

Heo6XOzaHMO paccmoTpeTb HopMl H Mpe6oBsaHHJ 1o j1ecoC3ao0ToHNeIHmmpa6f77w, o6pa&me Hot0BM Ha BIpy6KaX H BOC11POH3BO,4CTBY IICCHLX pJCypCOB H BHeapi4TbcHcTeMbi, o6ecneqHBaioutHe 60oee nonHoe BbilOJIHeHHe yCTaHoBjieHHbIX Tpe6oBaHHA. BPoccHH pa3pa6oTaHo MHO)KeCTBO HOpMaTHBHbIX IOKyMeHTOB no JieCHOMY XO3ArUCTBy, HO HX,nO Bcei BHLHMOCTH, He yaaeTCS 3)4)eKTHBHO Hcnojib3OBaTb Ha npaKTHKe. AAS nOBbIleHHS13aHHTepeCOBaHHOCTH HpealpHMATHR B co6moaeHHH HOpM H Tpe6OBaHHr rOCyaapCTBeHHbieBeAOMCTBa AOJDKHbI HCnOJb3OBaTb CHCTeMy cneLHaHJIbHbIX 3aJIOrOBbIX CepTHUHKaTOB(60H,aoB), BO3MemLaeMbix necononb3oBaTenlo B cjiyqae yaoB)leTBO CO6JI4O6oeHHA UMYCJIOBHi goroBopa o6 apeHLe .JeCHbIX peCypCOB. nPHHHMaSA BO BHHMaHHe HeaOBepHe K'aCTHOMy HHBeCTHpOBaHHIO B jieCHOR CeKTOp, ripaBHTeJbCTBO AOJIXHO paccMOTpeTb BOHpOCo He3aBHCHMOr4 cepTH44HKaUHH IAR ouIeHKH CTeneHH co6nmoaeHHA Tpe6oBaHHf4 K yKa3aHHOriJae.HTenJbHOCTH C yMaCTHeM COBMeCTHbiX npeanpH51THU H np4BjieeqeHHeM HHOCTpaHHOFO4HHaHCHpOBaHHM. He3aBHCHMYIO CepTHcIHKaUHo MOXHO 6buLo 6bl opraHH3OBaTb npucogeACTBHH HPH3HaHHbIX Ha Me)KIyHapOAHOM YPOBHe opraHH3a[uiHf THna CoBeTa noynpawAeHHIO .necaMH (Forest Stewardship Council), ITO o6ecneqHJo 6bI MaKCHMaIbHYIOOTKpbITOCTb H 3aHHTepeCOBaHHOCTb BO BHeapeHHH OnTuJManbHbIX MeTOAOB pa6oTbl.

Tpe6oBaHwI no npoBeaeHHIo IecO3arOTOBHTenJbHbIX pa6oT, o6pa6oTKe nO4IBbI HaBbipy6Kax H BOCnPOH3BOaCTBY nIecOB aOJDKHbI crioco6CTBOBaTb COXpaHeHH1O HeO6XOfl4MbIXnoKa3aTejieA pereHepauHH H HCnOJIb3OBaHHio )KeiiaTenlbHbIX MeTOAOB BOCnpOH3BOaCTBa,cornacHo rInaHy 3eMJIenoJIb3OBaHHS. OpraHaM ynpaBjneHHA nIeCHbIM XO3AriCTBOM HaaOonpe,aejiHTb rPHOPHTeTbl nO fIJIOLLaALM, Tpe6yioWHM JIecoBoccTaHoBJIeHHAS, H yKa3aTbMeTO2Ibl, KOTOpbIe cJeayeT HCHOJIb3OBaTb AnS ,OCTH)KeHHS 3KOHOMH'IeCKHX H 3KojIorRHeCKRXueAer.

COTpy,aHi4eCTBO POCCHu C APYI'MH cTpaHaMH4, HMe1OIUHMH 6opeajIbHbie nieca, Bo6niaCTH 1OBblw1eHHA 344oeKTHBHOCTH oXpaHm H 3ilf7f Tm fecCHx peCypCoB MorJo 6bicnoco6CTBOBaTb coKpaLieHHIO Toro, OIpOMHOrO yiuep6a, KOTOpblUI e)KeroaHo HaHOCS1T niecaMno)Kapbl, BpealfTeuH H 6oJIe3HH. HaH6onee rpHopHTeTHor4 3aAaqeg cneayeT C'H4TaTb paHHeeo6HapyxceHHe o4aroB H onepaTHBHy1o Mo6HAH3aLUHIO pecypcoB ARS npOBeaeHH4[ pa6oT no3aXlHTe neca B paMKaX )KeCTKOrl CHCTeMbI KOHTrpOJA 3a HX COCTOAHHeM, XOTS Me*(LyHapOaHOeCOTpy,aHH4eCTBO AOJDKHO OXBaTbIBaTb 6o0ee UJpOKHi CneiKTp npo6neM. TaKoit o6MeHTeXHoJ1orHAMH H Hoy-xay B 3TOU o6JIaCTH 6bu1 6bl none3eH WAR Bcex CTOpOH.

3Ha'-rTenbHylo onaCHOCTb ASA nIeCHbIX 3KOCHcTeM npeACTaBJISHoTnpOH3BOlICTBeHHaA H XO3flCTBeHHaJ AMMLHOMPCT rpyIX 0TPoCJI, B qaCTHOCTH,Hed)Tera3OBOA H ropHoao6blBamouer npOMbiUIeHHOCTH H UHH4paCTpyKTypbl. npH BCeeaAeKBaTHOCTH npHpoaooxpaHHOrO 3aKOHoaTenbCTBa H nOJ1HTHKH HX npaKTuHeCKOenpHMeHeHHe H KOHTpOJ1b 3a co6AIoeneH4eM HaXOASTCA Ha CJIHIIKOM HH3KOM ypOBHe, 4To6bIo6ecCHeqTb 344eKTHBHyIO OXpaHy 1 3aUiHTy feCHb[X peCypCOB. HepBbIM BaXHbIM waroM1Bj1SeTCS yTOIHeHHe Bonpoca, nOL 'blO IOPHC2WKLIHIO noanaa,afOT Te unu4 HHbIe 3eMenlbHbIe H

AeCHbIe peCypCbl, 'ITO nO3BOJIHjio 6bl OTBeTCTBeHHbIM BeCoMCTBaM npoaojDaTb pa3pa6oTKy Ho6eCne'mBaTb,aehCTBeHHOCTb lpHpoaooxpaHHblX HOPM H Tpe6oBaHHI4.

Page 32: Russian - World Bank Documents

14

PacWHpeHHe nHoLga,aH CfC?eMm oco6o oxpaxHelMx ffpHpOAOHhmX 71ppn'opig

(BKJnloqa.l Te Tepp4TOpHH, rMe xo3rIIcTBeHHaA aeATeJIbHOCTb MO)KeT ycrIelWHO

OCyLueCTBMITbCA KOpeHHbIMH HapOaHOCTqMH) AOJUHO CTaTb HeoTbeMj1eMor4 qaCTbIO

npouecca rUaHHpoBaHHS, HanpaBjieHHOrO Ha paUHOHanbHoe ynpaBneHHe iiecaMH. IO)KHaS

3aWHTHaR nonioca nPHTyHAPOBbIX .iecoB ROJIDKHa 6blTb CaBHHyTa K iorY B COOTBeTCTBHH c

o6O3HaMeHHOR pOCCHUCKUMH yqeHbIMH JTHHHeg. B 3TOU1 HOBOA OXpaHReMori 3OHe 6yayr

3anpeiueHbI npoMbllumeHHbie py6KH .neca Ha HaH6oJlee 3KoJIorHqeCKH XpynKHX TePPHTOPHA1X

BewHOti Mep3ioTbI, 3aHHMaioLuHx oKoJIo 15-20% IieCOnOKpbITOi TePPHTOPHH Cu6uPH H

laJIbHero BocToKa. napaMeTpbl CeTH oxpaHHeMbIx TeppHTOpHUi MOrJIH 6bl nocTeneHHo

MeHATbCA no mepe nocTynnieH1H HH4IOpMalUHH 0 IeCHbIX pecypcax, Heo6Xo'uMo0 WAn

OLleHKH 3KonorHqeCKOrO 3HatieHHA H 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3H5 AaHHOUi TeppHTOp4H.

PJ%ffOH&I3aLJNZ IVCYWpCTBCHHMIX KalH7TWJ.bhI X H ThIeALY 3Tp9fT

ByAyqH OCHOBHbIMH Co6CTBeHHHKaM4 3eMeJlbHbIX H JieCHbIX peCypCOB, opraHbl

rocyuapCTBeHHOrO ynpaBjieHHS pa3HbIX ypOBHerl AOJDHbl BbiAeHJITb 3HaqHTejibHbIe CpeaCTBa

Ha aAMUHHCTpaTHBHoe H X03rIiCTBeHHOe ynpaBsieHHe )K43HeCnocO6HbIM4

3KCnJnyaTaILHOHHbIMH flecaMH, Hx oxpaHy H 3alluTy; onpeaeneHHe 6a3 IieCHoro CbIpbS B

pamKax niiaHHpOBaHHS pal1HOHanJbHOrO HCnOHb3OBaHHS 3eMemlb; BOCnPO43BOaCTBO nIeCOB Ha

y)Ke uerpaAuHPOBaBLuIHX HuH HenpOAYKTHBHb[X nleCHbIX yrOAbAIX; pacwHlpeHue njiolua,AeH,

oxpaHy H 3aIuHTy JIeCOB, He npeIHa3HaqeHHb5X ARM npOMbILUeHHOFO HCHOAb3OBaHHI4 H

OXPaHReMblX TeppHTOpHri; yKpeniieHHe HayqHorO H ynpaBiieHqecKoro nOTeHumania

rOcynapCTBeHHoro CeKTopa; co31aHHe COOTBeTCTBYIOLUHX yCJIOBUHli A1A np4BJIeqeHHS

qacTHoro ceKTopa; a TaKKce Ha Apyrme cnyiK6bi, Heo6XOuHMbIe Rjn5 pa3BH4TH5 npouecca

peOpraHH3aLXHH.

OueHKa 3aAaq, Tpe6yioLuix 6e3oT.naraTenbHoro pewHeHHq, H B03MO)KHOCTerU HX

BblnOJIHeHHA rioKa3aIia, MTO B TeYeHHe HeCKOjibKHX CjieaYIolUHX JieT B J1eCHOR CeKTOP MO)CHO

6bnO 6bl yCneUHO HHBeCTHpOBaTb AOnOJIHHTenJbHbIe rocyaapCTBeHHbie CpeACTBa B nPHAaqy K

TeKyUtHM 6iouceTHbiM aCCHrHOBaHH5M. TaKHe ircyaapCTHHIe HHBCCTIIIH AOJDKHbl

pacnpeaenATbcA no n0pHOpHTeTHbIM o6IiaCTqM, KOTOpbIe B HaCTOARuee BpMem HCnbiTblBalOT

He,OCTaTOK B 4UHHaHCHpOBaH4H. Pa3BHTHe 3THX o6.nacTerl Morno 6bl croCO6CTBOBaTb

npHBexieHHIO qaCTHOrO ceKropa H OKa3blBaTb HenOCpeaCTBeHHOe BJIH5HHe Ha yCTOiqtiBOCTb

peCypCOB. K TaKHM n1PHOPHTeTHb1M o6nacTHM OTHOCATCR: pa3pa6OTKa nOjiHTHKH,

yKpeniieHue HHCTHTyTOB yripaBneHHsA, YTOqHeHHe napameTpoB pecypCHorH 6a3bl zinIA

yCTOR'qHBorO 11POH3BOCTBa ApeBeCHHbl, paculupeHue CeTUi oco6o oxpaHgemMbix npHpOAHbIX

TeppHTOpHu, coBepLueHCTBOBaHHe OXpaHbl IieCOB OT nOXcaPOB H 3alUHTbI OT apPYrHX BpeAHbIX

aicropOB (TaKHX, KaK BpeaHTeJiH, 6one3HH H 3arpq3HeHie cpeabi), pacwuipeHie nporpamm

no BOCnpOH3BOLCTBY necoB, ycHneHHe HayK1HOrO nOTeHuHaHia iAn LeiieBbIX 4ccAeIeOBaHH4,

pa3pa6oTKa U o6ecneieHHe co6nloAeHHr npH4pOaOOXpaHHbIX HOpM H Tpe6OBaHHI41 AAA apyrHx

oTpacjiek, a TaK)Ke noaAep)KKa KopeHHorO HacenieHH5 H yKpenJIeHHe TpaAiHLLHOHHbIX

yKnaJOB. XOTR OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a OCyuteCTBJ1eHHe 3THX HHBeCTHU1HI4 nptHAeTCq B35Tb Ha

ce6s rniaBHbIM o6pa3oM rocyIaPCTBeHHOMY ceKTOpy, Bce )Ke cylUeCTByeT IlHPOKHHl A1Hana3OH

B03MO)KHocTel =An 3aKJIIO'IeHHR lIOrOBOPOB C MeCTHb1MH opraHamH BJIaCTH H 'aCTHbIMH

OPraHH3aLH5MH AAA5 peUJeHH51 MHorHX 13 rocTaBJ1eHHb1X ynpaBJIeHweCKHx 3aIaq. TaM, rae

3TO B03MOKHO, TaKHe HHBeCTHUHH cle,AyeT nPHBR3blBaTb K ywce aerCTBYIOLUHM POCCHUCKHM

H MeCAUyHaPOAHbIM nporpaMMaM.

Page 33: Russian - World Bank Documents

15

TsA peanjiH3auiH 3c"eKTHBHOR npOrpaMMb[ rocyaapcTBeHHoro HHBeCTHpOBaHHSnOTpe6yeTCsI BHeCTH 3Ha,tHTeJibHbie H3MeHeHHA B npUHHATYIO B PoccuH CHCTeMypacnpe,aejleHHA H HCHnoAb3OBaHHA rOCyaapCTBeHHbIX CpeaCTB, BbLLejIJeMbIX Ha HyAKAbi3aXL1UTbl H pa3BHTHI .ieCHbIX pecypcOB. HyxHO pa3pa6OTaTb TaKHe MCTOL,bl COCTaB.eHHUI6jo,AKeTa, KOTOpbIe nO3BOAIqJU4 6bl 'eTKO pa3rpaHHMHBaTb TeKyutHe paCXOabl H KarHTaJfbHbie3aTpaTbl, a TaioKe nepHoaHqeCKH H pOBO,HTb oIIeHKy pe3yJIbTaTOB HCHOJib3OBaHH5 3THXcpe,acTB. B KaqecTBe nepsoro wuara, (beaepanbHoe npaBHTeJIbCTBO aOJnDKHO caeflaTb nOJTHblIaHaJIH3 rOCya4PCTBCHHIX paCXO,4BO B AeCHOM ceKTope H paCCMOTpeTb B03MO)KHOCTHCOBeplueHCTBOBaHHSI ynpaBneHHq, onpeaenieHHA H nepepacnpeaenieHus4 COOTBeTCTBYIOIUHXrIpHOpHTeTOB.

Focy,apcTBeHHoe HHBeCTHPOBaHHe B oxpaHy H 3aza1HTy VnecoB MorFo 6blnpHHHOCTb npH5MbIe BbIrOAbI 3a cqeT cnaceHHA eCTeCTBeHHbiX nIeCOB OT YHHqTO)KCHH5Ino)KapaMH, HaCeKOMbiMH U 6o.ne3HRMH H 3a CqeT COXpaHeHHU1 YHHKanjbHbiX no CBOeMy6Hopa3Hoo6pa3lIo yqaCTKOB cpeabi o64TaHHq. ThsA pa3pa6oTKH KoMnJIeKcHoro noaxoaa KynpaejieHHIo fleCHbIMH no)KapaMH HY)KHO npOBOAHTb cneuHUanJbHbie HayqHO-HCCJieCOBaTejibCKHe pa6oTbl, T.K. TaKOH HOaxoa aoniOKeH OCHOBbIBaTbCS Ha BCeCTOPOHHeMnOHHMaHHH 3KJojiorH noxKapOB H uHHaMHKH HX pacnpocTpaHeHHX (noBeaeHH5 noKapoB).CneayeT pa3pa6oTaTb riinaHbi HO BceM acneKTaM KOHTPOIS JIeCHbix noKapoB, BKJIIOqaAciie,ypowHe cTpaTerHH: TywIeHHe, HeBMewlaTenjbCTBO H HCnOJTb3OBaHHe ynpaBJiAeMbIx nanTOBKaK B LCeAlAx CHH)KeHHA ro)KapooHacHOcTH, TaK H B ueiAx BO3AeACTBHI4 Ha cpeay o6HTaHHA.Fopa3no 6ojibUe BHHMaHH5 ceayeT COCpeaOTOq4Tb Ha H3yqeHHH H BHeapeHHHHHTerpHPOBaHHbIX MeTOaOB 6opb6bl C BpeaHTeAsMH iieca, BKJ1io4aA HCHOJIb3OBaHHe9KojIorHqecKH 6e3onacHblx rperapaTOB, 344eKTHBHoe o6opyaoBaHHe AAS o6pa6oTKH nIeCOBH KOMnHieKCHbie CHCTeMbi iieCO3HTOMoJIorHqecKoro MOHHTOpHHra. C.neayeT OTMeTHTb, YTOno npocb6e npaBHTejibCTBa H o6LuecTBeHHblx opraHH3auHfi PoccuH, JieTOM 1996 r.BceMHpHbiP1 6aHK 4fHHaHCHpOBaA 3aKynKy 6HoiorHqecKoro npenapaTa auA roLaaEeHHi4BClbIIlIKH MaCCOBOrO pa3MHO)KeHHS Bpe1IHTejiek B KpaCHO0lpCKoM Kpae H HayqHOeo6ecneHeHme AnS CHCTeMbi MOHHTOP1Hra 34J4eKTHBHOCT4 npenapaTa H CB53aHHbIX C HHMHccJieTaOBaHHr4 no oueHKe 3KOJIOFH[4ecK4x riocieaCTBH'4.

Ha YPOBHe npeanIpHATHR-inecorojib3OBaTeeiieu IpOTHBOI7OXapPHIe Tpe6OBaHHJ,aOJI)KHbi npeayCMaTpHBaTb 3arpeT Ha HaKonHieHie H36blTOqHbIX 06'beMOB JiecoceqHbIXOTXOAOB, KOTOpoe nOBbHwaeT YPOBeHb nIeCHbIX ropioqix maTepHarIoB, a B cny'iaeBO3HHKHOBeHHA no)Kapa yBeCJH4iHBaeT ero pa3pyHHTejTbHyIO CHJIy. CJiegyeT paccMoTpeTbBOlpOC O pIorpaMMaX HOAFOTOBKH H rlpOCBeTHTejibHbIX KOMnaHHAX, HalpaBJleHHbIX Ha TO,4qTo6bl HacenieHHe J1yuwe nOHHMJaio onaCHOCTbH riociieaCTBH4A roKapOB. ,1A o6HapyXeHH4no)KapOB H cJexKeH 14S 3a CHTyaULerl ciieayeT HCnOJ1b3OBaTb CnyTHHKOBbie MeTOabl HKOMrlbIOTepHYIO TeXHOJIOrHio. CJIeayeT npOOJDKaTb H paCWUHpTb pa6oTy B paMKaXMeACAyHapOLaHbIX riporpaMM THra COBMeCTHOrO pOCCHriCKO-aMep4KaHCKOrO npoeKTa (coCTOpOHbl CWIA B HeM yqaCTByeT HauHOHaJibHoe yripaBjieHHe CWIA no a3POHaBTHKe Hmccj1e,oBaHKIO KOCMHqeCKOFO rIpOCTpaHcTBa, HACA), KOTOpblU4 HanpaBAeH Ha H33yteHHeBO3MO)KHOCTerh HCHOJb3OBaHHiA CnYTHHKOBbIX CHHMKOB AIs o6Hapy)KeH H KpynHblX nO)KapOBH cieX)KeHHA 3a HHMH, cJieayeT TaKcKe ripoao1i)KaTb H pacl4UpATb pa6oTy HO KOOP,HHaLHMUpa3pa6OTKH TeXHoAorFHr ynpaBjieHHA JieCHbIMH no)KapaMH H o6MeH UMH. rocyRapcTBeHHaAnporpamma Ho 6opb6e c JTeCHb1MH noKcapaMH Ha 1993-1997 rr. MorFJa 6bl CTaTb HCXOAHOAOCHOBOUi nriaHa HHBeCTHUHOHHbIX H HPlOH3BOACTBeHHblX MepOnpHATHI4 B CeKTOpe.

Page 34: Russian - World Bank Documents

16

./!CHMe HayJwHo-mccJe,4oBaATLbcKJe 4HCTHTyTbl, 3a)KaTbie B THCKU 6o0nee qem

CKpOMHOrO 61oaIUICeTHoro 4)HHaHCHpOBaHH5, TepAlOT CBOH Kaapbi c 6blCTpOTOU, Bbl3blBaiouer4

03a6oqeHHOCTb, YTO CH.JbHO orpaHHqHBaeT B03MO)KHOCTH HX y4aCTH51 B npouecce

nnIaHHPOBaHHA nieco- H 3eMJIenoJIb3OBaHHS. ro3ToMy cneayeT o6ecne4HTb a,eKBaTHoe

HHaHCHpOBaHHe Ba)KHbIX ueJIeBb1X Hay4HblX pa6oT, CnOCo6CTByIOLUHX BblnOAHeHH1o 3aAaq

ynpaBJieHHi JieCHbIMH pecypCaMH, oco6eHHO 3TO OTHOCHTCS K c6opy H perHcTpaUHH 6a3oBbIx

AlaHHb1X ARS HHBeHTaPH3aLHHj iecoB, KapTorpa4)HpOBaHH peCYPCOB H pa3Hb1X BHLOB OUeHKH

COCTOSHHS oKpyxcaioiiei cpeabi. OJHHM U3 nepBooqepeaHbIX yCJTOBHir nOBbiLueHH5

3cfrleKrHBHOCTH ynpaBneH HA IBjieTCq Hcnojib3OBaHHe 7xHOJIOrH# NHH4OpMaLHOHHOrv

o6ecceeHem xiA JIHuL, npKHiMaKoiuHx pewIeHH, H ApyrHX 3aHHTepeCOBaHHbIX B pa6oTe

ceKropa CTOpOH, KOTOpb1e C HX nOMOLIblO MornIH 6bi HMeTb LOCTYn K 6o0iee nOJIHOg

HH4OpMaLUHH. CeTb MoLeJIbHbIX AeCOB, KOTOpy1O Hamana co3J1aBaTb (DeaepanjbHas ciiyxc6a

JieCHoro xO3suqcTBa, morna 6bl CTaTb cBoero poaa gapOM pa3pa6OTKH npoLiecca

nIiaHHPOBaHHS Ha YPOBHe parfoHa HJIH TePPHTOPHH H HCTOYIHHKOM X1OnOJHHTeJbHOrl

3KojorFH4ecKor H 3KOHOMH4ecKori HH4)opMauH AnA ynpaBneieH HiecaMH.

ARA5 HeHCTOLUHTeAbHoro JIeconojb3OBaH H45 Heo6xtoaMo, 4To6bI JiecHas nOJIHTHKa

uLeHoo6pa3OBaHHS npe,ycMaTpHBaJia BO3MeiieHe uHJnu y'eT 38TP8T Ha BOCIpOH3B0,CTBO neca

3a cMeT 3aFOTOBKH jieca B 6yayweM, TaKHM o6pa3oM, qTo6bl B KOHeYHOM HTOre aTH 3aTpaTbi

HecIiH noTpe6HTeJiii apeBeCHbix npoayKTOB. Thy' iieCOBOCCTaHoBjneHH5 Ha TeX nnoLuaaux,

KOTOpble nociie jieco3aroToBKK OCTalOTC51 HerPO,yKTHBHbIMH H3-3a HeBO3MO)CHOCTH

o6ecne4eHHsI ecTecTBeHHorO BO3o6HOBneHHS unm nocaKM, cKopee Bcero nOTpe6yeTcs

rocyaapcTBeHHoe 4HHaHCHPOBaHHe. Ho 3aTpaTbI Ha JieCOBOCCTaHoBBJeHHe BbICOKH, H HoBbIe

IOCaBKH MOryT OKa3aTbcA y6blTo'rHbIMH. nO3TOMy lA5 TOIO, lTo6bi orpeaeJIHTb, Ha KaKHx

ruioLwagnx cJieayeT BeCTH 3arOTOBKY nieca, H KaKHe CHCTeMbl 3arOTOBKH H BOCnpoH3BoacTBa

nieca cJIeayeT HconJIb3OBaTb, npaBHTenJbCTBO AOJDKHO HCHOJb3OBaTb aHaJIH43 COCTOAHHA

oKpy)Kaio1ieH cpeabl H KoMniieKCHbIH aHanJH3 3aTpaT H pe3yjlbTaToB. HaH6o0nee noaxomu1Hri

MeToA BOcHpOH3BoACTBa (ecTecTBeHHoe HJIH HcKyccTBeHHoe) onpeaeJlieTcs THnoM

Hcnoflb3yeMoR CHCTeMbl 3arOTOBKH nieca. K BaXHblM daKropaM cJIeayeT OTHeCTH ycKopeHHe

npoH3BOACTBa apeBeCHHbl Ha nierKo aOCTYnHbIX nHJl0Baa1X H Heo6xo1HMOCTb 3aL14UTbl

UeHHbIX 3KoJorH'eCKIX CBOUCTB nIecoB. Cpeau apyrHx mep MO)HO Ha3BaTb nOBbuLICHHe

npOX1YKTHBHOCTH HacaxK1eHHI, oxpaHy JAeCOB OT noxKapoB, 3aMeHy HH3KOCOpTHbIX

JIHCTBeHHbIX HacamcAeHHI XBOU4HbIMH H COKpamLeHHe i4cnoJb3OBaHH14 HeCOBepwueHHb1X

cnoco6oB nieco3arOTOBKH.

AnA ycKopeHHA peopraHH3aUHH iiecHoro ceKTopa Heo6xoai4Mbi rocyLapCTBeHHble

HHBeCTHL1HH B KoMHLfeKCHoe JIHaHHs DHHeH HanpasneHHoe Ha yCTO4lYHBoe

HeHcToLUHTeJIbHoe pecypcorlojib3OBaHHe. HaH6onee BaX)HbIM nepBb1M wlaroM 1BJSeTCS

nOIIrOTOBKa cneHaUJICTOB H c3waHHe TexHHUeCKOu4 6a3bl aLm niiaHiHpOBaHH14 Ha

perHOHajibHOM H par4OHHOM YPOBH51X yrIpaBJieHHUI. AAH "MaCTH4l B TaKOM npouecce

niiaHHpOBaHH5 Ba)KHO He TOJIbKO o6.rfaaaHHe COOTBeTCTBY1OL14HM4 TeXHH4eCKHMH H

opraHH3aTOpCKHMH HaBbIKaMH, HO H HanHMHe HH4)opMaumi o apeBecHbIx 14 HeapeBeCHbIX

pecypcax, 3KojiorIHecKHx CBOPCTBax nieca a TaKse yKiia,ax H KYJnbTypHbIX Tpamu1HlHx

MeCTHOrO HaceJIeHH5l. OTCyTCTBHe TaKoi HHOPMOpauKLH Mo)KeT CTaTb 3HaLiHTeJIbHb1M

OrpaHUqHBaiOllmHM 4aKTOpOM H nO3TOMY 3acTyJ)KHBaeT BHHMaHH4A. 1 HaKOHeC, Ha KaAaOM

3Tane npoliecca rinaHHPOBaHHA cieayeT cTpeMHTbCH K TOMy, YTO6bI CBOU BKJ]aA BHOCHJIH

3aHHTepeCOBaHHbie npe,CTaBHTeniH MeCTHOrO ypOBHA.

Page 35: Russian - World Bank Documents

17

Paom M 4mxyOapqAHoro coo61wcrCa

HIPHBe,aeHHaS Bblwe CTpaTerFH nOJIHTHKH B o6iaCTH IieCHbIX peCypCOB qBJIAeTCAoqeHb cMeCbIM H ,aaeKO HAyIHM 3aMbicjioM. B PoccuH HMeeTCA xopowo pa3BBHTaA ceTbJeCHbIX HayqHO-HcciieaOBaTeJIbCKHX IHCTHTyTOB, y1IeHbie H TeXHHqeCKHe cHeUHaJIHCTbl.OAHaKO ceHqac OHH HaXOqSTCA B oqeHb TADKeAomM rojio)KeHuH B CBR34 c cepbe3HblM61oaxeTHbIM KpH3HCOM H HenOarOTOBAeHHOCTb1O K npeoaojneHHIO TpyaHOCTerl, BbI3BaHHbIXnepexoAOM K pbIHO4HOri 3KOHOMHKC. JA5I nOJIHOrO 3aBepCueHiHH npouecca peopraHH3auHH B6nuHalumHe HeCKOJqbKO nIeT y POCCHH HeT BCeX Heo6XOaU4MbIX peCypCoB. MexAgyHapogHoecoo6wLeCTBO, Ip43HaBaq CBOIO OrpOMHYIO 3aUHTCpeCOBaHHOCTb B 6yaylitM COCTOSHHUH HyCTOWqHBOCTH iiecHOu Cpeabl POCCHH H CTa6HJIbHOCTH npeaRPH4ITHI4 necHoro ceKTopa,npHHHMaeT yLaCTHe B pSAe rporpaMM, y)Ke npOBOJIHMbIX B 3TOM ceKTope. Y'aCTHeMeAKIyHapoAHoro coo6lUeCTBa COCpeaOTO4eHO Ha OKa3aHHH COcCe4CTBH5 B rpOBCeaeH4H Texpe4OpM, KOTOpble 6yayT cnoco6CTBOBaTb pauUHOHanJbHOMY y BpaBjTeHHlio IecaMHnpHpo,aooxpaHHOR OpHeHTaui4H.

PoccH.I Mo6KJIH3OBaYia BHeLUHi4e H BHyTpeHHCe CunJIbI Anl oKa3aHH51 noJaepKKH Bpa6oTe no OLueHKC COCTOAHHA JeCHbIX peCypCOB, paUU4OHaJlbHOMY BeaeHHIO SieCHOrOX03sArCTBa, BOCHpO3BOACTBY H 3aUIuTe JIeCHbIX peCypCOB, COXpaHeHH1O 64opa3Hoo6pa3Hs4,noaaep)KaHHIO yriepoAHoro 6aIaHca H pa3BHTHio HOTeHuHaYIa 3KOTYP43Ma H peKpeaUClH BpOCCHUCKHX niecax. XOTA 9TU npOeKTbl B LUHPOKOM CMblCjie COOTBCTCTBY1OT TOU o6iuegcTpyKType HOJIHTHKI, KOTOpaS npexnaraeTCS B aaHHOM goKmaae, 4YHKUHOHaBjbHO HreorpaqUMecKm OHM CJTHWKOM pa36pOCaHbI H He MOryT BbICTynaTb B pOn14 KaTaA3aTOpa

HepeCTpoKH iiecHoro ceKTopa H3-3a HeAoCTaTo'-HOFO YPOBHA CKOOPa,HH4POBaHHOCT4.

OT MHpOBOrO coo60LeCTBa Tpe6ylOTCH 6o0iee coriiacoBaHHbie Cre4CTBHM no

OKa3aHH1O rOMOILtH pOCCHriCKOMy npaBHTeJHbCTBY, KaK xpaHHTeCHo caMoro KpynHOrOHa3eMHoro "3anaca" yriiepoaa, B BbiHiOAHCHHH meCAyHqapoqzwLx o6&3aTeIscTB PoccHi noOxpaHe oKpy)KaOmurcJ CpeC4b, a TaKweBe B nHaaHHpOBaH4H, 4)H4HaHCHpOBaH4H H OCyLUeCTBJ1eHUHPeOPraHH3aLIHU iieCHOrO CeKTOpa. OAHOA U3 ueJleH HaCTOHLuerO o630pa JleCHOr4 HOjiHTHKHABjn1eTCS co3flaH4e OCHOBbl A]S BceOXBaTbIBaioLuero aliajiora nO IeCHOA HOJIHTHKe MmeA(ZynpaBHTenJbCTBOM POCCHu H Me)KayHapOaHbIM coo6iuecTBoM, KOTOpblH aOJDKeH HpUBeCTH Kpa3pa6OTKe COOTBeTCTBYIOLuei rpOirpaMMbl TeXHH4eCKOh H qHHaHCOBOr4 HOMOLU4.

PoccHH H Me)KayHapOIaHOMy coo6LUecTBy Heo6xoat4Mo HaTI4 o6LL[UU noaxog,KOTOpblUl B paMKaX onpeaeJieHHO4 H riOCJIeaOBaTeJIbHOA o6LuerOCyaapCTBeHHOr4 nOJTHTHKH6buL 6bl cocpeaoToqeH Ha ceneayioLUMX HarpaEuieHH5lX: bOPMYn4POBaHie H peana3auHKiTioqeBblX HanpaBJTeHH44 JIeCHOH HOJIHTHK4; aeUCeHTpanuh3aLtHA OTBCTCTBeHHOCTH nO

ynpaBjieHHIo neCHbIMH pecypcaMH, T.e. ee riocneaoBaTeJbHHori nepeaIaMH Ha perHOHaJIbHbIiypOBeHb; yKpenHieHHe HHCT4TYU1HOHaJ]bHOrO, aaMHHiCTpaTHBHOFO H yrpaBJeH4ecKoronOTeHuHaLHa Bcex YpOBHeC ynpaBneHHq; c6op H aHanH3 Heo6xoaHMbIx aaHHbIX no .JeCHbIMpecypcaM; peanfH3aIutH o6feg CHCTeMbI nHiaH4pOBsaHH41 HCnOIb3OBaHHSI 3eMeJib; BBeJaeHHeKOHLuenui4U pauHOHaIbHoro ynpaBjieHH51 necaMH; onpeaejleH4e ponm 'lacTHoro ceKTOpa,HpHBJe4eeHHe K pa6oTe pa3JIHqHbIX 3aUHTepeCOBaHHblX CTOpOH (oco6eHHo KOpeHHoroHaceiieHHuS); 3aLUHTa H nowepWKKa KOpeHHOrO HaceCjeHH51 H TpaaL4UHOHHb1X yKAaaOBXO3SIiCTBOBaHHA; co3flaHHe COOTBeTCTBYlOLUHX rojiHTH,eCKHX yCJOBH i InSI HpHsBJIe'4eHHl4YaCTHbIX HHBeCTHULtH4. 3TOT o 6 Luuir noaxoa aoniOeH npHBeCTH K pa3pa6OTKe TaKHXBapHaHTOB pa3BHTHA, KOTOpbie ripaBHTeAbCTBO CMO)KeT YqHTbIBaTb npu onpeaeJIeHHH

Page 36: Russian - World Bank Documents

18

3KoAorHMecKHx, 3KOHOMH4eCKHX H COUHaBJbHbIX LeJIerl, CBS3aHHbIX C neCHbIM ceKTopoM, H

npH BbinOJ1HeHHH MeexyHapOAHbIX o6A3aTenbcTB.

TeAwmvecKoe H 4/HHaHCOBOe COaeACTBHe Heo6XtoaHMo JiJ YCKOpeHHA HHTerpautm

AeCHOrO CeKTOpa B npouLecc o6we3KoHoMMwlecKog pe4DopMb1, nepexoaa K YCTOUIHBOMy

ynpasBjeHHIO IiecaMH, a TaKwce AI paLI14OHaJH3a[uHH rocy1apCTBeHHbIX pacXo4O0B H co3,aaHHA

Heo6xoAHMbIx yCJIOBHi ARSA npHBj1etieHIH iaCTHbIX HHBeCTHUHfl B yCTOAPHBbie npeanpH5THAiiecHor'o ceicropa. Pa3BMTHe nOTeHLuIHa AiOLoCKHX peCypCOB, OCo6eHHO KOpeHHOrO

HaceAeHHSl, IBnSeTCA OAHOA 13 3aAaq, Tpe6yioluHx 6e3oTjlaraTeflbHoro peliueHHs, rTO

Heo6xo,aMmo AnS CMArH'eHHR oTpHULIaTeJbHbMX coUHajbHbIx rioc1e2aCTBHi nepexoaa K

pblHOMHOr4 3KOHOMHKe H 6yayiuero pa3BHTHA ceKTopa, oco6eHHo Ha periHOHaJbHOM ypOBHe.

Ha Me)KAyHaPOaHOM YPOBHe Ha OCHOBe HHU4uiaTHBbl rpyninbi 3KCnepTOB no niecy

(F3JI), OpraHH3OBaHHOA COBMeCTHO MHOrOCTOpOHHHMH H ABYCTOpOHHHMH aOHOpaMH,3apo)KiaeTCA HOBblU, ynpaBJsieMbiu aaHHOrl KOHKpeTHOii CTpaHOii MexaHH3M

paIuHOHauIH3auHH COAer4CTBH5 yCTOUIHBOMy pa3BHTH1O iiecHoro ceKTOpa. BMeCTe C

npe,aCTaBHTeJlISMH pOCCHUiCKHX 3aHHTepeCOBaHHbIX yqaCTHHKOB, MeCaYHaPO2IHbUX H

AByCTOpOHH4X opraHH3aLuHA H o66eCTBeHHbIX rpynn PoccHS MO)KeT HCnOJIb3OBaTb

HacTouxHW aoKxIaA AAS OLLeHKH CBOHX HY)KA H KOOpAHHauLHH HCHOJIb3OBaHH5

Mex(LyHapoLHbIX CHJI H cpeACTB TeXHHMiCKORi H 4HHaHCOBORi noMoLU. TaKori

KOHCyJIbTaTHBHbIl npoLtecc npHBei 6bl K aOCT4)KeHHIO aOrOBOpeHHOCTH HO OTpacAeBOr4

nOTHTHKe uH rpHOpHTeTaM pa3BHTHS. KOHuenuHS corinacOBaHH5 BOnpOCOB COTpyaHHiqeCTBa

B HaCTOALuee BpeMA o6cyxAaeTCs B psAe CTpaH c TeM, 'ITo6bI ee MOKHO 6buio npeaCTaBHTb

Ha paCCMOTpeHHe Me)KnpaBHTenbcTBeHHori rpynribl 3KcnepTOB no iiecaM, Cd)OpMHpOBaHHOA

KoMHcc4ef OOH nO YCTO 4HBOMY pa3BHTHIO B anpene 1995 r.

n,aeA COTpy,4HH4eCTBa KpaRHe BaBKHa H uq5 HpOBOalHMOrO B paMKaX OOH,jCfCTHA'CeTHZq KOpcHHmX HapOI(HOCTeA MHpa, B KOTOPOM POCCHIcKaA (DegepaLum RpHUHHMaeT

aKTHBHOe yqaCTHe. MHorHe U3 npo6neM, CTOAIuHe nepea KopeHHbIMH HapoHOCTSAMH

CH6HpH HU aaJbHero BocToKa, MOXKHO pelUIHTb C nOMOIlblO aOrOBOPOB 0 COTPYaHH4eCTBe

MeCKy POCCHiCKOg ()eAepaLluei, o6'beAHHeHC4sMH KOpeHHbIX MajiOYHCjieHHbIX HapO,aOB,

npaBHTenJbCTBaMH ApyrHx CTpaH CeBepa (HanpHMep, KaHa,bil H CWHA).

B KaqeCTBe OCHOBbI IAS 6yayLuero ,Hajlora no noaaepxKKe pe4opMHpoBaHl4A

necHoro ceKTopa 6bwu Bb1lenJeHbl cnieAyoLutie npHOPHTeTHbie Mepbl coAefiCTBH5

yCTOrNHBOMy pa3BHTHIO CeKTOpa B riepexojHbIl nepHoj H HanpaBJIeHHS1 TeXHHMCecKOA H

43HHaHCOBOA noMoluH:

Kp,aTKOCpOqHMC MCPM HOUwepM19f pe&opMM (B 7TVCHHC CJIC4OfHXa'BYX JICT)

(a) TexKyllHif s=nu pcO4pMfpoBaHa IQnHo TH: KpaTKOCpO4Hble MepblnowepmCKK nOiHTHKH peC4OpMbi MOryT cnoco6cTBoBaTb ycKopeHHio repexo,fa

K HOBbIM 3KOHOMH4eCKHM YCIOBHAM H nOMO4b B o6ecne4eHH14 YCTOTqHBOCTH

JieCHOrO CeKTOpa H ero HHTerpaLUHH B CTpyKTypy o61LIe3KOHOMHMeCKOr4

pe4OpMbi. TaKHe MepbI MOriiHi 6bl BKJlOioaTb npOBeaeHtie IajibHeLUHXHccAeieOBaHHi no npeLanaraeMbIM BOnpocaM C uenJbiO JHKBHaaLXHH

HH4)OpMaUHOHHbIX npO6eJIOB H pa3pa6OTKH KOHKpeTHbIX BapHaHTOB

npOBCeAeHHAI pe4opMbI. B Ka'eCTBe cneapyiowero illara MO)KHO 6bUJO 6bl

Page 37: Russian - World Bank Documents

19

npOBeCTH B POCCHH pa 1 pe rHOHaJ]bHbIX H BCepOCCHUiCKHX KOH4bepeHUHR AMRo6Cy2K=eHHSI 3THX BapHaHTOB H aeTajibHoro onpe1ejieHHA mep noPeOpraHH3aUHH ceKcopa H HanpaBHTb HX Ha paccmoTpeHHe npaBHTeflbCTBa. BnepByio oqepeAb cnexAyeT:

* PaccMoTpeTb B03MO)KHOCTH o6pa3oBaHHs peHTHbIX aOXOLOB B OCHOBHbIXperHOHaX JieCOllPOH3BOACTBa H MeXaHH3Mbi nOJYMyeHHR peHTHbiX IniaTe)Keri, 3aC4eT KOTOpblX MO)KHO 6buio 6bl o6ecne4HTb paUHOHanjbHOe BeaeHHe XieCHoroX03AlACTBa. 3To O.Ha H3 CaMbiX nepBOO4epeLHblX Mep, T.K. nlpeaBaPHTeJIbHbIR

aHajH3 BbIABHA 6oJlbWOU nOTeHLIHaJ o6pa3oBaHHs HaJOrOBbIX AOXOaOB (KaK 3acqeT rOCycyapCTBeHHbIX C6opOB, TaK H 3a CqeT HaJIOrOB Ha npH6bIJlbnpeAnpHHTHui). 3Ta pa6oTa AOJDKHa CTaTb qaCTbIO Tex MepOnpHITHU, KOTOpblenpe,anaraeTCS npOBeCTH AAA YTOMHeHHA COCTOAHHR pecypcHoU 6a3bl U eeIOCTaTOqHOCTH AAS yxKe cywueCTByIOiUHX npeAnpHATHH H onpeaeJleHHqPbIHOHbIX rHepCneKTHB AJIA pOCCHRcKoro IecHoro ceKTopa. B paMKax TaKoroHccAe,AoBaHH51 cneAyeT TacK4e no KaxKoMy perHOHy BbienuHTb Ba)KHeALWHe3aamaqH, KoTopbie Heo6xoRHMO peLWIHTb npH nepexone K paUlHOHaJbHOMY

ynlpaBJeHHIO JIecaMH, C TeM, qTO6bi OnpeaeJIHTb pa3Mepbl H I1pHOpHTeTbI4)HHaHCHpOBaHHA neCHoro XO3SHCTBa 3THX perHOHOB.

* PaccMoTpeTb aHTHMOHOHOJIbHbIe Mepbl, HpHMHeHqeMbie B apyrmx cTpaHax c60JIbIIHMH 3anacaMH jieCHblX peCypCOB, c ueLjbIO BbIpa6OTKM COOTBeTCTBYIOIUHXMep ,AnA iecHoro ceicropa Poccuu (a TaiciKe Anu ApyrHx CBA3aHHbIX C HHMoTpacJier, TaKHX KaK TpaHCnOpT H 3HepreTHKa).

* H3yqHTb BJISHHHe MOHOHOJIHO4 B TpaHCnOpTHOHi H 3HepreTHqeCKOri OTTpaCiiX HayCTOiqHBOCTb 4YHKLXHOHHPOBaHHi necHoro ceKTopa.

* Pa3pa6oTaTb 3KoJIorHqecKHe, 3KOHOMH4eCKHe H COUHaHJbHbIe KpHTepHH HHHJAuKaTopbi, nO3BOnARlUuHe npoBOANTb aHaJIM3 HMeioiericA HH41opMaUHH 1ngonpeAeneHHUI COCTOSHHS H KaqeCTBa .JeCHblX peCYPCOB H UX pacnpeaejleHH4I nOCblpbeBbIM 3OHaM.

(6) YToweHNe COcTOfMHN 6&3M JICCHHX pCJypCOB H pMHOIHhMX HepCIeCKTHB:lepBbIM uiaroM B 3TOM HanpaBJIeHH[i AOJIXHa 6blTb CpO'qHas OueHKa

COCTOSHHH peCypCHOHl 6a3bl, Haxoaiquetkcs B pacnCpOpKeHHHH BCeXcyWeCTBYlOLUHX rpeAnpHTHri-noiTpe6HTejieA JIeCHb1X pecypcoB. 3ra oueHKanO3BOJIHJIa 6bl BbiJeJIHTb rpeLnpHSTHuS C )KH3Hecnoco6Horl 6a3oA pecypca,KOTOpaA MO)KeT C03gaTb YCJIOBHSI 11lf 6yAywHx HHBeCTHUHUI H yCTOiHqBOU

3aHSITOCTH. BbieReneHue )Ke He)KH3Hecnoco6Hbix npe1npHqTHri Heo6xoaHmoAAsA onpe1ejieHHR MacLuTa6a co[Ltaj1bHoH a,AanTauHH, KoTopaS nOTpe6yeTcs BCBSI3H C riepexofoM OT HCT01UHTeJlbHOrO KOMaHAHOrO H 6ecnopsaOHoronoiaxoaa B JieconOJTb3OBaHHH K 3KoJior4MeCKH, 3KOHOMHMeCKH H COUHaJlbHOyCTOrUHBOMy npOH3BO1CTBY. CneAyeT TaKwe npOBeCTH CpOLHylO OL1eHKYnepcrieKTHB c6blTa npOaYKTOB H3 OCHOBHbIX nieCHblx parOHOB POCCHu KaK HaOTeqeCTBeHHb[x, TaK H Ha Me2KIYHaPOAHbIX pbIHKax. B UenAoM 3T aaRaaCOCTOHT H3 xieTbIpeX pa3AeJIOB:

Page 38: Russian - World Bank Documents

20

* YKpenHTb noTeHua4il HaLHOHanbHoro cTpaTerTHecKoro nfJaHHPOBsaHH5 3a c'ieT

KBaJIHbHLUHPOBaHHOrl 3KCnepTHOA OL1eHKH B o6niaCTH 3KOjOirHH, 3KOHOMHKH,

COUHaJIbHoro Mo1eIHpOBaHHu, pa3BHTHA IieCHbIX paUOHOB, ynpawieHHq

fleCHbIMH pecypcamH H nIaHHpOBaHHA B JieCHOM ceKTope.

* Pa3pa6oTaTb COOTBeTCTBYIOILHUe perHOHanJbHbIM YCAOBHRM 3KCnpeCc-MeTOabI

OiLeHKH peCypCOB (Ha OCHOBaHHHU aHCTaHULHOHHOrO o6cjieaoBaH4R,

KapTorpaduHpOBaHH.q H aHKKeTIpOBaHHS npeanpHSTHA) AAA CHHTe3HpOBsaHK

HH41opMauuH H c6opa HeaOCTaowuHx AaHHbIx, xapaKTepH3ylOLUHX COCTO0lHHe,

pacnpejeJneHHe H KaqeCTBO J1eCHbIX peCypCOB B CblpbeBbIX 3OHaX

CYLUeCTBYIOLUHX npeanpH5THA. Tpe6yeTcA aaTb TO4HOe onpeAeneHHe npaB Ha

3eMJHlO H peCypCbl B pa3JIHMHbIX JIeCHbIX 3oHax, oco6eHHO B KOHTeKCTe ripaB

KOpeHHOIO HaCeIieHHA Ha 3eMJI1O H B OTHOLieHHH TeppHTOpHU, KOTOpbIe

Heo6xofHMo BbifejiHTb X11 coxpaHeHH5 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3sA.

* OnpeaenHTb OCHOBHbie HaflpaBjieHHH 4ccjieAoBaHH4i, Heo6xogtiMbIx AAA

Bb1iBAieHU14 CpaBHHTeJIbHO 6xraronpH5THblx H He6naronpHiATHblx ( aKTOpOB,

11eUCTByOWUHX Ha nOTeHL1HanjbHbIX OTeqeCTBeHHbIX H MexayHmpOAHbiX pblHKax.

B xoae 3THX HCCJ1eaOBaHHrU Ha,o OnpeaeHjiHTb rTpeaeJIbl 3KOHOMHUeCKOrO

peCypCorIOJIb3OBaHH51 B YCJIOBHAX pa3HbIX CueHapHeB aHHaMHKH 1LeH Ha

BBOAHMbie 4aKTOpbi HpOH3BOaCTBa (HaripHMep, IiecHbIe pecypcbl, 3Heprlio,

TpaHcnopT, Tpya) H BbIlycKaeMy1o npoayKumo. Oco6oe BHHMaHme ciieayeT

y1eflHTb 3HaMeH14io nOqBJleHHS B EBpone H apyri4x perHoHax rpynn

noKynaTeneu TOJIbKO cePT4bHLIHPOBaHHoro nieca (cepTHufKaTbl nOaTBepxKaaloTco6auoueHHe npuHHumrOB HeHcToLuHTeJ1bHocT4) H pOCTa cnpoca Ha n1ec,

KOTOpbIir CepTTH4(HULPOBaH He3aBHCHMbIMH 3KCnepTaMH TpeTberi CTOpOHbI.

TaKUe pbIHOMHbIe 4CCc1ieROBaHHUfl OJDKHbl BbISBHTb KaK B03MOXKHOCT4, TaK H

npenITCTBHH AAA5 pacuHipeHH5 aocTyra K pbIHKaM, KOTOpbIe 3TH TeHKeHulU

C03,aaAYT B 6yayweM.

* fIO0arOTOBHTb aOKJlaabl 0 COCTO5HHH nTeCHblX pecypcoB nO Ka)KZtOMy

npe,HnpHSTH4o H peFHOHy.

(B) Coc7TI1HHc IecoB, HX oxpaHa H 3aILrra: 34eKTHBHaS 6opb6a c fleCHbIMH

noKapaMH, Bpe,4HTeJIAM4 H ,apyrHM4 BpeaOHOCHbIM4 q)aKTOpaM4 6bmIa

nPH3HaHa BbICOKOnIpHOpHTeTHOH o6JIaCTbIO, HMemoWer 6onbluoe 3Ha'eHHe WsqCOXpaHeHHU UeHHbIX 3KOJ1orHqeCKHX H 3KOHOMHUeCKHX qjYHK1Hr4 JieCHbIX

pecypcoB POCCHH. )Ii pePuelllHH4 HeOTj1O)KHb[X 3a,ga4 H nOarOTOBKH K

J1OJ1rOCPOqHbIM cTpaTerHMeCKHM MepaM no peLmeHHIo 3THX ripo6feM, BKJIIOt aS(bHHaHCHPOBaH4e, HY)KHbl CpOMHb1e aeeicTBH1. B 6nHxarueM 6yAyLueM

Heo6xo,aHMO:

* PacwllpHTb B03MO)KHOCTH OpraHOB ynpalBjeHH51 .JeCHbIM X03.qrUCTBOM ,1IA

onpe,aeAeHH1 MacIIITa6oB H rpocTpaHCTBeHHO-BpeMeHHOrO pacnpe11eJneHH4

npo6neM 6opb6bl C no)KapaMH, Bpea1Ten5Mu H 6ojie3H51MH.

* CdopMyAHpoBaTb Tpe6OBaHH51 Ho ,oaHCTaHLUHOHHOMY o6c1e11oBaH4lo,

MOHHTOpHHry COCTOAHH5A peCYPCOB H HenocpeaCTBeHHOMY ynpasBAeHHIO LAL

34XeKTHBHOrO HinaHHpoBaHHA Hu opraHM3auim OXpaHbl H 3a11HTbI niecOB,

Page 39: Russian - World Bank Documents

21

oco6eHHo AAA HaH6ojTee yq3BHMbIX TeppHTOpHi H paUOHOB nOBblweHHOrO

picKa wis5 Toro, YTO6bI B cy'iae Heo6xoamMocTH MO)KHO 6b11o npUHiHMaTb

CBoeBpemeHHbie U 3c"eKTHBHbie Mepbl.

* Co3aaTb MHHHMYM TpH perHOHajIbHblX nllIHOTHbIX npoeKTa C LeJlblO pa3pa6OTKm

3jxeKT4BHbIX pe)KHMOB OXpaHbI H 3alUHTbl nIecOB H onpeaejieHHM

noTpe6HocTeA B ROJHOCpO4HbIX HHBeCTHLURHX B OXpaHy U 3aILHTy nIeCoB.

* YCKOpHTb ripOBeaeHi4e COOTBeTCTBYIO[UflX MepOHpH5THiI no coaeACTBHIOBO3o6HoBjieHH.q nieca Ha nOBpexaeHHbIX nTeCHbIX 3eMjisx.

Cpe)rHecpowuMe MepM njaaepxrut (B mrYeHHe 6JNaIlHx 2-5 JIeT)

* Co3,aaTb HHCTuTYUHOHanjbHbIe YCJIOBH51 AA5I BBeaeHH51 HOBOU HaUHOHaJlbHO-

perHOHajIbHOH CHCTeMb1 ynpaBjieHHA fleCHbIM X03AACTBOM,

npe,aycMaTpH4BaioiueH 'eTKoe pacnpeaejieHHe npaB H o6I3aHHocTer noniiaHHpOBaHHIO HCnOJIb3OBaHHSI H BOCHpOH3BO,4CTBa JIeCHbIX peCypCOB, HXpacnpeeaeneHHIO, nojiytIeHI4o AOXOAOB H npaKTH ecKOMY BeaeHHIOX035IUCTBeHHOA aeqTeJ1bHOCTH.

* BBeCTH aeTanJbHy1O OueHKY peCYPCOB 4 niiaHHpOBaHHe Hcnojib3OBaHHS 3eMeJIb

,RJIS CHCTeMbi rOCyIapCTBeHHbIX niecoB.

* Pa3pa6oTaTb COBpeMeHHbie CHCTeMbI ynpaBneHAs HH4)OpMaui4eA no pecypcam

AAA Bcex YPOBHeg OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH 3a ynpaBjieHie iiecaMH (4ieaepaibHoro,periHOHaAbHoro H MeCTHoro).

* floarOTOBHTb KaBpbl H co3ttaTb YCJIOB451U AU51 cTpaTerHiecKoro nniaHHpOBaHH41Ha 4beaepaAbHOM, perHOHaJlbHOM H MeCTHOM ypOBHSIX, B TOM qHcjie H ISA

KOpeHHOrO HaceJieH s1.

* rOloaOTOBHTb KaJpbI H co3,aaTb YCJIOBHAI ,w5 6onee 3I4eKTHBHoroOnepaTHBHOrO yHpaBJAeHH51 H HJaHHPOBaHH51 B niecxo3ax B COOTBeTCTBHH C

COBpeMeHHbIMH KOHUerIUHUMH HeHCTOHUHTeAbHOrO JTecorlOJIb3OBaHHl4,

OCHOBaHHOrO Ha ynipasieHuH 3KOCHCTeMaMH.

* C03,aaTb perioHaOJbHbie CHCTeMbI HH(OpMpaLUOHHOrO o6ecne'eHHIu jIs

'IaCTHbIX H rpyrInOBbIX (iMeeTcA B BH4Ay HaceJIeHHe nieCHbIX pariOHOB)

HHBeCTOPOB, npeAOCTasBji5ioiuHe AaHHble 0 PbIHKaX H B03MO)KHOCTAX

HHBeCTHPOBaHHA B yCTOINHBOe JieCOripOH3BOaCTBO H nepepa6oTKy apeBeCHHbl.

* Co3gaTb H pa3BHBaTb CHCTeMy He3aBHCHMOU 3KoIortHqecKoH CepTHc13HKaUHH

niecoMaTepmaTOB H apeBecHoR npOLIYKLUHH (Ha OCHOBe KpUTepHeB

paUUHOHaJIbHOCTH ynpaBBJeHHA JiecaM4) B LtenJqX BbinOAHeHH5 Tpe6oBaHHr

MeXKyHapORHOrO pbIHKa.

Page 40: Russian - World Bank Documents

22

,AaompoC-bJ IepI HoqCpweK (B 7mrcime 6ixaAiuro4ecrTwIeIRfIe

. Pa3pa6oTaTb KOMiiieKCHYIO CHCTeMy MeXaHH3MOB peHTHbIX nocTynneHAH XInsq

yBeJiH4qeHHR o6pa3OBaHHS HaJIOFOBbIX aOXOROB, rOBblIeHH5 3E4eKTHBHOCTH H

CO,aerCTBHI4 yCTOflHBOMy pa3BHTH1O iiecHoro CeKTopa.

* Pa3pa6oTaTb KOMnHieKCHbie CHCTeMbl BeefeHHif JieCHoro X035I4SCTBa Ha OCHOBe

ynpaBJIeHHs 3KOCHCTeMaMH IJIH Bcex c43ep AeCHOA H neconepepa6aTbmlalouLeH

HpoMbiHIjieHHOCTH, COCTOAWHX H3 'eTKHX H ROHSTHbIX CHCTeM rIJIaHHpOBaHHS,

KB9aH4UHt4pOBaHHbIX KaapoB, 3KoIorfH4eCKH npHeMneMoro o6opygoBaHHq, a

TaK)Ke 3KOAorHqecKH H 3KOHOMHMeCKH pa3yMHbIX MeTO,OB BOCCTaHOBIeHHU

6ojbmuHx nuioluaaeri noBpeA)aeHHbIX JIecoB.

* Pa3BHBaTb HOTeHUHaBJ npoO¢eCCHOHaiibHbIX KaApOB Ha Bcex ypOBHAIX: OT

KpaTKOCPOHbIX rporpaMM TeXHH4eCKOH rOirOTOBKH ao aOjIrOCpOqHbIXnporpaMMbI zLiJ CTyAeHTOB BY30B H acnHpaHTOB. FlpeaycMoTpeTb, 'lTO6bIo6y'qeHme no 3THM nporpaMMaM 6buio aocTynHO JA1 KopeHHorO HacenTeHHIN H

apyrmx )KHTeieri JIeCHbIX TeppHTopHli.

* YCOBepui.eHCTBOBaTb CHCTeMy Hay'qHO-HccIieZOBaTeJIbCKHX opraHH3aUuuH

jiecHoro ceKTopa c ueAb1o co31IaHHu H CoxpaHeHHA HaKonineHHOrO Hay'HoronOTeHuLiia MHpOBOrO ypOBHA AnI npOBeaeHHA uejieBbIx HCCJIeI4OBaHHi nO.ieCHbIM 3KOCHCTeMaM H HH41OpMaLHOHHOrO o6ecneteHHs, Heo6xoaHMoro AnA

pa3pa6oTKH HOJHTHKH, nO BCeM 3KOioruHecKHM, COUHanJbHb[M H

3KOHOMHMeCKHM acneKTaM ynpaBjieHH5 iieCHbIMH pecypcaMH.

* Co3xaTb KoMriieKCHYIO CHCTeMy AqJ nepexoAa K YCTOHMHBOMY COUHaJibHO-

3KOHOMH'4eCKOMy pa3BHTH1O B JIeCHblX par4OHaX.

Mepbl, cnoco6CTByIOuxHe nepexoAy K paUHOHajibHOMY ynpaBjTeHHIO lIeCHbIM

X03SH4CTBOM H yCTOW4HBOMY pa3BHTHIO JieCHoro ceKTopa, rloTpe6ylOT 3Ha4HTeJlbHOH

TeXHHMqecKoH H (HHaHCoBoH HOMOIUH. Ha OAHH TOJTbKO 3TH Mepbl MOXeT nOTpe6oBaTbC5

b4HaHCHpOBaHHe B pa3mepe nopAAKa 700 MJIH. aoAAapoB CWA Ha cJIeayiowYIiW

LReCSlTHJeTHH4l repHoa (oKono 70 MJIH. aonnapoB CWlIA B roa). KanHTaJIoBJoIKeHHq TaKoro

YPOBHA Heo6xoamMbi 1A5 nepexoja K paUHOHaJbHOMy yHpaBJleHH10 peCypCaMH H C03,LaHHS

yCJoBHH Lim npHBJIeIeHH5 qaCTHbIX HHBeCTHULHU B ieCHOri ceKTop. 3a OaHO aeCSTHjIeTHeTaKoH YPOBeHb KanlTajioBAo)KseHHI4 aoJnKeH noMo4b npeBpaTHTb 1ecHo0i ceKTOP H3 HeTTo-

noTpe6HTenISi CpeaCTB rocyaapCTBeHHoro 6ioIJKeTa B HeTTo-BKaa,UHKa B 3KOHOMHKY CTpaHbI,

'ITO aOJDKHO 6blTb o6ecne4eHo 3a cqeT nporpamm oxpaHbI, 3aLUHTbl H BOcnpoH3BO11CTBa Jleca,ocyLueCTBJIS1eMbIX Ha YCJIOBHMX caMo(bHHaHCHpoBaHHJq, B3HMaHHq peHTHbIX nFUaTe)Ker; 3a

pecypcbl, HaJIoroo6Jo)KeHH5 npeanrpH5THr CeKTOpa H o6pa3oBaHH4l pa6oqHx MeCT H aOXOaOB.

B xyaweM cjiy'iae, T.e. ecnH rOXOBbie o6beMbl npoH3BOaCTBa ApeBeCHHbi B AaJIbHe4UweM

coKpaTSTCM 1o 75 MJIH. Ky6oMeTpOB, B TeqeHHe cneaypowero aeCqTHjieTH5 HHBeCTHPOBaHIe

B 3TH MepOnpUHTHAI MoceT nOaep)KHBaTbCS 3a C'eT 1OnOFIHHTeJIbHblX peHTHbiX rIJIaTes)Ke 3a

pecypcbI B pa3mepe OKOJIO I aojinapa CWlA 3a Ky6oMeTp, 4TO BnOJIHe peabHo Au1 necHoro

CeKTOpa H COOTBeTCTByeT MHpOBOMy OnbiTy.

Bo BpeMS paccMoTpeHH1A laHHoro aoKma,aa HpaBHTenbCTBO PoccHH H BceMHpHblu

6aHK o6cyanHA B03MO)KHOCTH pean3LuiH nrJIOTHoro npoeKTa nO YCT09uHBOMY

Page 41: Russian - World Bank Documents

23

ieconoAb3OBaHI4O KaK HaLanJbHOFO 3Tana OKa3aHHq nOMOUlH POCCHu CO CTOpOHbl

BceMHpHoro 6aHKa. B xoae faabHerlwero o6cyxeHHA CTpaTerir4 noMOuH cTpaHe (CnC)npaBHTeAbCTBO o6paTrHAocb KO BceMHPHOMy 6aHKy C npoCb6or4 OKa3aTb coaeriCTBHe BnlOArOTOBKe aaHHOro npoeKTa. KaK TOJIbKO 3TOT npOeKT 6yaeT ONHUHaIbHO BKJliO4eH B

nporpammy KpeaKTOBaHH$ BceMHpHoro 6aHKa 3, OH CMOxKeT 6bITb HCnOJ1b3OBaH qnq

noIaUep)KKH p51na L1eJeBblX nporpaMM Ha 4)eaepaJIbHOM YPOBHe H B aByx uHAn Tpex perHoHax.

B ero paMKax npeanonaraeTCs npopa6oTKa BonpOCOB cTpaTerHeCKoro niiaHHpOBaH14 H

OT,aeflbHbIX npo6J¶eM peqOpM4pOBaHHS nOCpeaCTBOM HCHbiTaHH5 MoHolereu peq)OpM Hapenpe3eHTaTCBHbX CHTYaULHAX B ynpaBjieHHH iiecaMH. 3To npeanoJiaraeT pa3pa6oTKy H

anpo6HpoBaHHe HOBbIX 4)OpM opraHH3aLLH H ynpaBneHHs, HanpasBeHHb1X Ha YCTaHoBJIeHHeCBSI3H Me)cIy noJIyMeHHeM PeHTHbIX )IOXOAOB OT peCypCOB H OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb1O 3a

ynpaBAeHte iiecaMH. B KaxKOM 143 HnAOTHbIX perHOHOB npeanonIaraeTcA pa3pa6oTKa

KoMnHAeKCHO crpaTermH oxpaHbl 1 3aluHTbl neca H nHecopeCYPCHOu 4HHopMaLIHOHHoACHCTeMbi, KOTOpb1e aOJDKHbl nOMOraTb B AeCOXO3SACTBeHHOM H HHBeCTHULHOHHOM

nJiaHHPOBaHHH B ieCHOM ceKTope. B pamKax HoirOTOBHTeJIbHoro 3Tana 3Toro nHiOTHoronpoeKTa noTpe6yeTcA HPOBeCTH KoMnnieKCHbii alHanH3 Bbl6paHHblX perHOHOB no cJIeaylOWUMHanpaBJIeHH5M: COCTOAHHe AeCOB, CHcTeMa Hx OXpaHbI H 3aLUHTbl, AecopecypcHbieHH4)OpMaUHOHHbie CHCTeMbI H HepCneKT14Bbl pa3BHT14.q pblHKOB c6biTa JIeCHor4 npoIyKIuHH;

YTOqHeHHe HaUHOHanJbHbIX H perHOHanbHbMX OCHOB pallHOHaJIbHOrO BeaeHH51 niecHoro

X03sICTBa; onpeaeJIeHHe nyTerl yKpeniieHHSI CHCTeM peryflHpOBaHHS H o6ecneqeHHs

co6nlo,aeHHsl 3aKOHOaaTeJIbHbIX Tpe6OBaHHR, BKJHOiaSq pa3Hbie BapiaHTbl npOBeaeHHS

cepTH4lHKaUHH.

BJBOAbl H peKOMeHAaIUHH

JeCHOA CeKTOp PoccHH HMeeT orpoMHoe HaUHOHanjbHoe H MHPOBOe 3HaqeHHe.HpHMepHo 60% o6weu CYXOnYTHori nHJoIuaLH POCCHH noKpbiTo iecaMM. B IeCHOM ceKTope3HATO OKOJIo 2 MHJUIHOB qenoBeK, qTO cocTaBn5ieT 3% OT o6iuero KOJlH4eCTBa

Tpy,aocnoco6Horo HaceJIeHHSl cTpaHbl. JIecHoAi ceKTOP AaeT 6onee 2% BanjOBoroBHyeHHero npoayMca (BBI1). B 1995 ro,y BanJOTHa5 BblpyqKa OT 3KClOOpTa npOaYKUHHJieCHoi H aepeBoo6pa6aTbIBaioLueu npoMbiLujeHHOCTH COCTaBHj1a 4,2 mnIpA. aojlapOB CLIA,T.e. 5,4% o6weu 3KCHOpTHOi BbIpyqK4. KpoMe Toro, JeCHoil ceKTop RBJn9eTCq KpynHbIM

HCTO'qHHKOM nOTeHUManJbHbIX HanjOrOBbiX nocTyrIeHHW. Ha rno6anbHoM YPOBHe Ha aojnlonecHoro ceKTopa PoccHH RpHXOaHTCq 22% iieconoKpbiTori nHJouaAH nHiaHeTbl, nOKpblTOu

JecaMH (camblfi BbICOKHU npoueHT cpeaH Bcex cTpaH MHpa), 15% nnaHeTapHoro Ha3eMHoro

yrnepoAHoro nyjia, 75% nOTeHLxi4anIa norJolueHuHR yrnepona Bcex 6opeanbHblx nieCOB M4pa H21% MHpOBorO 3anaca neca Ha KOpHIO (caMbli BblCOKHU noKa3aTenJb no cpaBHeHHlo C

apyrUMm CTpaHaMH).

JIeCHoI ceKTop PoccHH o6naJaeT cyLLeCTBeHHbIM nOTeHLuaJIoM xJSi o6pa3OBaHH5

HaJIOrOBbIX nocTynHieHHH. ECTb nO KpagHer mepe TpH OCHOBHbIX liCTOqHHKa HanforOBbIX

AoXonOB: rocyIapCTBeHHbie c6opbl, Hamom C JieCO3aroTOBHTeJIbHbIX npeInpu14THiI H HaniorH C

JaepeBonepepa6aTblBaioLuHx npeanpHATHA. B HacTo5i.uee BpeMq cpeaHiue pa3MepblroCy,aapCTBeHHbIX c6opoB B POCCuH COCTaBJI5lOT MeHee I wionnapa CllA 3a Ky6oMeTp, Ha

3 B Mae 1997 r. B COCTaB yTBep2KAeHHOg nlpaBHTeCJbCTBOm npOrpaMMbi KpeaUTOBiHUia BceMHpHoro 6aHKaHa 1998 r. 6bm o04HuHaIlbHO BKJlioqeH IlIHIoTHbrli npoeKT no yCTOWmHBoMy JleCOIIOJIb30BaHH10 B

opueHTuPOBOqHOM o&beMe 60 MJIH. ,Qo. CLWA. (rIpHMe4aHHe penaKTopa pyCCKoro H3aaHum).

Page 42: Russian - World Bank Documents

24

ayK[uloHax xe BeJIHE4HHa 3THX c6opoB B POCCuH H HeKOTOpbIX CoceRHU4X CTpaHax npeBbIwaeT

10 aoJInapoB CWA 3a Ky6oMeTp. B CKaHAI4HaBH4 pa3mep c6opoB Mo)KeT aOCT4raTb 30,aoAfapOB CWA 3a Ky6oMeTp.

OUeHKH nIOTeHuHaJlbHbIX HaJIOrOBbiX riOCTyrJileHHU OT JieCHoro ceKTopa PoccuH

,TaaOT pa3Hbie UUHcpbl: OT 0,9 Mpga. go 5,5 MnLpa. aojijiapoB CWA B roa. EcnIipaBTJTeIbCTBO He cMo)KeT ped)OpMHpOBaTb HOojHTHKy niecHoro CeKTOpa, yBeCl4qHTb c6opbl H

rOBbICHTb YPOBeHb 4)aKT4MeCKHX HaJIOrOBbiX nOCTynlieH4U, TO OHO He CMO)KeT nOJIy'-aTb 3TH

HOTeHLuHaJbHbie HaniorOBbIe AOXOabl. 3THX InOTeHUmaJIbHbIX HaSjOrOBbIX aOXOaOB XBaTHJIO 6bl

He TOAbKO Ha UHiaHCHpoBaHUe BCex paCXOaOB, CBH3aHHbIX C BeaeHHeM necHoro X03siirCTBa,

BOCHpOH3BO,aCTBOM, oxpaHOil U 3aHuTOH nieca H YCTOr4MHBbIM .ieCOnoiIb3OBaHHeM, HO H Ha

TO, 'qTo6bl BHeCTH KpynHblu BKj1aB B rocyaapCTBeHHyIO Ka3Hy. KpoMe Toro, nOBbiweHHe

rOCy,aapCTBeHHbIX c6opoB JIHWHT noJIb3OBaTejieA 3aHTepeCOBaHHOCTU B 'Ipe3MepHOH

3KCnJ1yaTaUHH JIeCHbIX peCypCOB H COKpaTHT rOTepH 3arOTOBJMeHHOU apeBeCHHbI, 'TO B

KOHeMHOM HTore, 6yaeT cnoco6CTBOBaTb nOBbIweHHIO 3c"eKTHBHOCTI HCnOJIb3OBaHH 14

yCTOUUHBOMy pa3BHTHIO niecHoro ceKTopa.

npu 'eTKOM onpeaeneHu4 npaB Ha 3eMji1o H pecypcbI H 3I4eKTHBHOM

yipaBjieHHH JieCHbIe pecypcbi PoccHH MOryT no-rpe)KHeMy BHOCHTb UeHHbl BKYIaA B

HaLIHOHaIbHYO H peFoHaOIbHyIO 3KOHOMHKy CTpaHbl H CnOCo6CTBOBaTb COXpaHeHHIO

rjio6aIbHOri oKpy)KaioLuer cpeAbI, OAHOBpeMeHHO aaBas BO3MO)KHOCTb AAA 3aLU1TbI H

nO,3,gep)KKH KOpeHHbIX )KHTeiiek COOTBeTCTBYIOIUI4X perHOHOB H HX Tpa,ul4HOHHbIX yKIiaaOB.

B iepcHeKTBse )Ke HOBbILueHHe OTeIeCTBeHHOrO H MH4OBOFO cnpoca Ha npOayKTbl

neconepepa6oTK.H IONJKHO co3aaTb B03MO)KHOCTH nS! BbIrOAHOrO HHBeCTHpOBaHH5 B

3KojiorH'IecKH 6e3OnacHoe H co3,RaloLlee ao6aBJIeHHyWO CTOU4MOCTb npO43BO,nCTBO B pagoHax

C BbICOKHM peCYPCHbIM rOTeHuHaJIoM. Co3,raHHe Heo6xOHUMbIx yCJ1OBH4 ,AAA TaKOrO

npOH3BOACTBa, BepOATHO, npHBeAeT K pacUiHmpeHHIO HJIOLUaH 3KOHOMH4eCKH LOCTynHbIX

niecOB H cMo)KeT aaTb HOBYIO )KH3Hb HeKOTOpbiM H3 TeX par4OHOB, KOTOpbie OKa3anuHCb

3KOHOMH4eCKH HeaOCTynHbIMH B CBA3H C BbICOKHMH TpaHCnOpTHbIMH TapHd)aMH.

KpagHe Ba)KHOA H o'eHb TpyAHOA 3aaa4eh 6yaeT co32aHi4e CHCTeMbl

HaLIHOHaJIbHOf4 nOOUHTHKH B o6iiaCT14 pa3BHT1SI, COXpaHeHH51 H HCHOJ1b3OBaHH51 JleCHbIX

peCypCOB, o6eCnie'wBalOiue yCTOUr4HBOCTb 3THX peCypCOB, KOTOpaR HpeayCMaTpHBaeT

coxpaHeHHe 3KoJorH4qecKHx ueHHOCTeI nieca, noAaep)KKy KOpCHHOFO Hace.neHt4s 14

TpaAHIIHOHHbIX yKAa,OB H coxpaHeHHe npO43BOACTBeHHoro rOTeHuHaJia JICCHbIX peCypCOB

KaK Ha 4jeaepajIbHOM, TaK H Ha perioHaHJbHOM ypoBHe. B HaCTOSLLeM o63ope nOJIHTI4K[4

pa3BHTHS .iecHoro ceKTopa oTpa)KeHo 3HaqeHHe J1eCHb1X pecypcoB POCCuH, oqepqeHbIKAio4eBbie 3aXaa4H H B03MOXKHOCTH ceKTopa, riporpamma ero peq3opMHpOBaHHHq U

nOTpe6HOCTI4 B rOCyaapCTBeHHOM HHBeCTHpOBaHUH UI nOMOTIT (KaK TeXHH4eCKOrI, TaK U

q)HHaHcOBoI4) CO CTOpOHbl MeACyHapOaHoro coo6LuecTBa. B Ta6.TIHue I npeacTaBneH o6fuuP

o630p KjlO'IeBb[X BbIBOAOB, peKOMeH,DaLLHr H npo6JieM, KOTOpblC MOryT CTaTb HpeaMeTOM

,Riaora C pa3JiH'-IHHIMH bM CTOpOHaMH, ciLeHanJIHCTaMH H O4rnLIuHaTbHbIM4

JIHuLLaMH, OTBeTCTBeHHbIMH 3a pa3pa6OTKy U npOBeaeH4e nOjUtTHKH no pa3BHTHIO,

coxpaHeHHIO H Hcnojib3OBaHHIO JieCHbIX pecypcOB B POCCHI.

Page 43: Russian - World Bank Documents

25

Ta6nimia 1: KJiIoCeBbie peKoMeH,aInHH no pe(DOpMHpOBaHHIO

jiecHoro ceKTopa POCCHH

A. PIHHrIpaLfWH JCeCHOIr CeKTOpa B 7pOL(eCC 9KOHOM-VeCKHx pe o4p0M

Jpo6&eMa CoBpeMeHHoe COCTorHHe flpe,unaiae,me L(e f7peafarvaee cTpairnr,

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _np co6pa3oB aHIo I__ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

nM6epan3awHms nlpm6JmnKeHme K MUpOBblM BKnio4eHme D npouecc * flpOBOUTb ajibHeiuWyIo

OCHOBHblX ueH (B UeHaM npHBenO K nlpHHRTHM peWeH MAaaHHbIX JIH6epaJIH3aUHo UeH Ha MaTePHaJlbHbie

4aCTHOCTH, Ha 3HaqHTe1bHOMy O peaJlbHOA CTOHMOCTH cocTaBAiaiourne npOM3BQaCTBa H

3Heprmio H CoKpaiuIeHHIO BbinyCKa 3HepFOHoCHTeeAm H ux o6ecne'HTb co6njo,ieHHe PbIHO1HOI4

TpaHcnopT) npOYKUHH H CHHUKeHmio 34qeKTHBHOCT4; amCUmnjiHHbiYpOBHH 3aHRiTOCTH nOBbiweHHe * npOBO)HTb aaAbHeAWy*o

34*iCrtiBHOCTH nuH6epajIH3aumLo UeH Ha JiecHylo

npoMbILJIeHHOro npOaYKUHIONCnOAb3CBaHHs IecHbIX * YCTpaHHTb meKperHoHanbHbie 6apbepbl

peCYPCOB B ToproBne

PeHTHbie aOXOAbi OT'iicJieHHR Ha B3HMaHHe C nolB3obaTeieH * BBOaHTb PbIH04Hbie MexaHH3Mbl

OT JeCCHbIX BOCrlPOH3BOACTBO peCypCOB 3HaMHTejibHOH IaCTH (ayKUNOHbl, ToprH) aAn yBeniH4eHHq

pCCypCOB H COUHaT[bHbie Hy4Cbi CTOUMOCTH 3aroToBJ]eHHOR PeHTHbIX 2OXOAOB.

coCTaBJUloT JIHUb MaJiyIo apeBecHHbl, WTO6bl * BKnJoMaTb B uoroBopa C HHOCTpaHHbIMH

AOJIIO CTOU4MOCTH o6ecneqHTb H coBMeCTHbIMH npeanpHST[$IMH

3arOTOBneHH1lX BOCrlpON3BOACTBO pecypca H YCJIOBH5] 0 nOBbIlUeHHOH peHTHOUI rnlaTe

npOMbIlwhieHHbIX cnpaBeau1HBbl JIOXOa AAR 3a pecypcbl

niecoMaTepHaJIoB, 9TO J1ecoBjia.eJTbueB * 06ecneql4Tb 0oJKHoe

flplBOflUT K nepepy6aM q4yHKUHOHHpoBaHHe MeXaHl3MOB

necoceK, a TaK)Ke K peHTHbIX nJ1aTe)Ker H Co6jnOAeHHe

rieperpy3Kam H nnj1oXoMy 3aKOHOB 0 HanloraX RAMT HOBbiwCeHH

pa3Me WeHUio HanoIroBbIX AOXOIOB

nPOH3BORCTBCHHbIX

MouIHocTeH

AHTHMOHOnOJIb- Pe4)opMa Maflo noBjiHsia 934eKmHioe H * PaC4opMHpoRaTb MOHonoJuH, BKfiIoqaq

HbIe MepbI H Ha CTPYKTYPY yCT04'IHBOC nieco- aKU0oHepHbie o6iueCTBa (xoJntaHrH)

npHBaTH3aUH1 rlpO3BOACTBa rl0J1b3CBaHNe CO CTOPOHbI * Bonee 344eKTHBHo npHMeHHTb,aepeBonepepa6aTbIBaio- KOHKypeHToCnOCo6HbiX aHTHMOHOnOJbHbie Tpe6oBaHHiq Hi

uLeu OTpachiU, B 3TOU npernpPMTHA npHBaTH3aUHOHHb[e Mepbl RAS I

oTpachiH nO-npeIKHeMy rOBblwUIeHHS KOHKypCHTOCnOCo6HOCTH

£aOMHHHPY1OT AeecHou npOMbituAeHHOCTH

HH3Ko3("eKTMBHble, * OcJia6HTb orpaHHIeHSI no CO3,aaHI4O

B3aHMOCBr3aHHbiC H COBMeCTHbIX npeanpHATHu H

xOcAUiHroBble KOMnaHHHH HCnOJIb3OBaHNIO HHOCTpaHHbIX

MOHOnOflbHOrO THna HHBCCTHUUUU* rOBblCHTb 34freKTHBHOCTb

HCUnoAb3oBaHHS apeBecuCHbl H J1pyrHx

pecYPCOB B nepepa6aTbiBaaoIueg OTpacJ1H

* npOBOHTb KOHKYpCbi no npHo6pe-TeHH1o npaB nOJlb3oBaHHSi JiecoM

BioomeiHas1 CoKpaLieHHe 610oKeTOB BbinoJlHeHKe 3aLa' no * BcecTopoHHe H3y4MTb npouecc

cTecHeHHoCTb OTPHUaTCJ1bHo CKa3aJIoCb oxpaHe npHPOfbl H 3aLLuTe 4)OPMHpoBaHflH H nonOJIHeHCH

opraHoB Ha ynpaBjieHHH oTpaCIbIO, AeCOB * 6io,vieTa c ueCJblO yBenHiueHHiI

ynpaBAeHH.q oxpaHe H 3awLuTe nieCOB; peHTHbiX nOCTynnieHuHH u

JieCHbIM HH3Kme pCHTHbie MaKCHMH3aUMH 34XIIKTHBHOCTH ARs1

X03HUCTBOM nlOCTyriJleHH. OT peweHHU 3aAaq OXpaHbl nllppOAbl H

JleConoJIb3OBaHHsl 3aWUHTbi iecoCB

* YBeCjiHqHTb 6ioLKeT C TeM, WTO6bl |

o6ecneuTb YCTOHUIHBOCTb .ieCHoroXo3sIACTBa, ymaCTHe qaCTHoro ceKTopa H

.__ __ __ __ ___ _ __ __ ___ __ __ __ ___ __ __ __ ___ __ __ __ _ 3alUHTY niecoB

Page 44: Russian - World Bank Documents

26

Ta6AHnta 1: KAioqeBhbe peKOMeHAraLHH no ped)OpMHpoBaHHIOinecHoro ceicopa POCCHH (npolAonxKeHHe)

A. HHMpaI ICHOro cexMpa B .VpoL(ecc C,9KOHOMVecKpC4lOpM (HpOqaffrCHHe)

M7poema CoBpeMeHHoe cocToueM f7pcawue amu )7p=&weuc cTpaTewa_____________ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ilp_o5 p& w_ __

|34waaa MHoroMHcAeHHIe O6ecneqeHHe HaceJIeHHA, * O6ecneqHTb ueneByio noMoiLbCoUHaBJbHor0o CouHaJ]bHbie rpynnbi B nonAepraiouerocH TaKOMY HyAa.IOIHMCR CAOnM HaceAeHHR,o6ecne'eHHS 3THX paHoHax CTORT noa pHCKy, MHHHManbHOH ceTbIo HCnOAb3yA MeCTHbie CTpyKTypbi BAacTmoTnajieHHbIx yrpo3ol 6e3pa6OTHUbi H coU3aLU4THi; aOArOCpOqHaa nnIn uenesoro HanpaBBAeHHA peCypcOBJieCHbIX paHOHOB cnaAa npOH3BO0aCTBa B KoppeKTHPOBKa cHTyauHm * OCJa6HTb MHrpaUHOHHbie orpaHHmieHH5

nieCHbIX oTpacAfAX Ha PhIHKax TpyAa; pa3BHTHe * daTb TOfHOe onpeaneeHHe npaB HaPbIHKOB HeRpeeBCHbIX 3eMIIO, MTO6bi rOBbICHTb ypoBeHbnpOAyKTOB; noAaepmKKa )KH3HH KOPeHHOrO HaceJTeHRh 3a C'eTKOPeHHOrO HaceAeHHR H BbirO, HCnOJIb3OBaHHR KOPeHHbIMHTPa,.HUHOHHbIX YKJ1aAOB )KuTeAnqm CBOHX 3eMenbX<H3HH 0 nlepecTpoHTb cHcTeMy noco6UH no

6e3pa6oTmue, H3MeHHB pa3MepbInoco6uH U CPOKH HX HeHCTBHq

* Pa3pa6oTarb cHcTeMbi Cny)K6bi3aH.qTOCTH B COOTBeTCTBHH C MeCTHbIMHHy=aaMH

* OpraHH3oBaTb Heo6XoaiiMbie KypCbinepenonraroBKH u nporpaMMblo6yqeHHsi

* BBOQHTb CXeMbI KpeAHTOBaHHs Hpa3BHTHA TpaAlHUHOHHbIX BHUOBfljeJTeAbHOCTH H peMeceA Ha MeCTHOMYPOBHe

Page 45: Russian - World Bank Documents

27

Ta6muna 1: KJloeBsbie peKoMeHAa1WHH no ped)opmHpoBaHHIOiiecHoro ceKTopa POCCHH (npoJAoiIKeHHe)

E. Hepxxoa K PaWOH&'IiHOMy YnI7e&HIO JIeC8MH

17po6euma CoDPCMeHHOe flpe4wiaraeme Lf/H 17:pevamaeme cTpaTeFMH

cocrosHme npeo6pa3oafH __

K3y'qeHHe pecypcHoi HeaaeKBaTHaq Co3.aaHHe OCHOBbl JUM * BHeupsTb COBpeMeHHbie MeToabl

6a3b1 amarHOCTHKa COCTOSHHS PaUHOHaBJbHOrO ynpaBnBeH%H HH¢opMauHeri B ue.5nHx

niecHbix pecypcoB H mX ynpaBBeHAH pecypcaMH. 34Xl)eKTHBHoA OUeHKH peCYPCOB U

peaJibHoro nOTIeHuHanHa npeaycMaTpmBaiowuer nnjaHHPOBaHHR

3Ra pa33J1H1Hb1X BHAOB BbaejTeHHe Cpe2CTB Ha * flo.nyMHTb HaIe)KHyio HH(1OpMaumB o no

nOJlb3OBaH4SI, BKJ1IO'a5. npoeBeeHHe uX JIeCHbIM pecypcaM, KOTOPYIO MO)KHO 6bulo

npOI3BOBCTBO mHpoKoMactuTa6Horl 6bl ticnonb3oBaTb B uenj1ix niiaHHpOBaHMH

ApeBeCHHbl H oueHKH; cmcTeMa Ha pa3HbIX YPOBHSIXcoxpaHeHme OUeHKH PeCYPCOB C * npoaHam43HpoBaTbaaHHb1e H

6Hopa3Hoo6pa3Ha, Ha yqacTHeM Bcex nepeKjiaccCi4HUHPOBaTb BeCb JieCHoA

4eJiepanbHoM H 3aHHTepecoBaHHbIX 4~OHA, HCnOAb3y5l MeTOAbI pauHoHan]bHoro

perHOHaJlbHOM YPOBHAX CTOpOH, Heo6xoJ1HMag pacnpeaenieHuH5 3eMeJlbA21H PaUMoHanIbHOrO * rpOBeCTH CKOperliy[o oueHKy

ynpaBieHuH. pecypcaMH peCYPCHop 6a3b1 cylTuCTBYblHCHRXnlpeJ1flpKMTH4~, 4To6b1 BblSICHHTb

HHBeCTHUUOHHbie B03MO)KHOCTH H 3aRaam

nepeCTPOMiKH ceKropa

FIJiaHHpoBaHHe CicTeMa PaUHOHaAbHagI CHCTeMa * 06ecne'wTb COBMeCTUMOCTb KPHTCp14eB

HCnOflb3oBaHHsi 3eMeJlb KiiaccH4THKauHH nieCOB pacnpeaenieHMs 3eMeJIb, pacnpenenieHuH 3eMeAb C HHTepecaMH H

(neJeHHe JieCOB Ha TpU KOTOpaH cnoco6CTBOBaAa B03MO)KHOCTgMH npeaAaraeMorirpynnbi no HX 6bl 3alumTe UX CTPYKTYpbl ynpaMBieHHRHa3Ha4eHMIO: 31H 3KojiorHqecKoi * BKJ1o0'TTb B MeTOa npOeKTHpOBaHlH

3alUHTHbIX HJIH tleHHOCTH H nnioLua,eu npoMbluieHHoro3KcnniyaTaUHOHHbIX HeMcToluITeAbHoMy i1econoJIb3oBaHHq KOHuenurlHIo

BH2OB noJb3oBaHHF1) MHOrouenjeBOMY norHimecKori JieCOCb1pbeBOu 3OHbl

cTpaAaeT HeQOCTaTKOM ICnOJTb3OBaHHIO . OnpeaejitTb KAioqeBble nnouaauH nnHKOHKpeTHOCTH JIH4KBH.aauHH flpo6eJOB B cyLL1eCTByioLLieH

CHCTCMe OXpaH5eMb]X TeppHTOpHn* BInO4HTb npmpoaooxpaHHbibe KpHTepHH B

npouecc BblAeZicHSH nTeCOB nonnpOMbiwUCeHHoe non b3oBaHue

* O4siumanbHo 3aKpeCHHTb 3a KOpeHHbIM

HaceAeHHeM BbIJelieHHble AA1 Hero 3eMJIn

H o6eCneiC4Tb 3aUl4TY 3THX flpaB Ha3eMjlio

* 06ecne'iHTb yiaCTme MeCTHorO HaceCeHHSB npouecce nJiaHHPOBaHHH1 Ha Bcex

._________ __________ ___ ___ ___ ___ __ ___ _ YPOBHHX

OxpaHa cpenbl OT O2HOU H3 npH'HH npouecc * nepecMoTpeTb H YCOBepWeHCTBOBaTb

He6JiaronpMSTHbIX no)KapoB H apyrtx nJ1aHHpoBaHH%, MeTOAbi OBOCBo3AeRCTBHA, BpeMHb]X Bo3zeCCTBHA BKAlo'aIou1m B ce6H * rlepecMoTpeTb Be2oMCTBeHHbie

CBH3aHHbIX C Ha nieca siBnReTCR Heo6xoaHMbie o6H3aHHOCTH no BBeaeHHIO H

Ae.qTeCJbHOCTbIO nPYruX 3Ko31oruqeCKH onacHaA 3KoJiorm4eCKHe oueHKH, o6ecne4leHHio co6nuoaeHHs Tpe6OBaHHA

oTpacneg aeqTeCAbHOCTb B H BBeaeHHe H no pa6oTaM Ha TeppUTopUHsx, nOKpbITbIX3HepreTi4meCKOA H co6noaeHHe JiecoM, c uejiblo yqeTa aeueHTpaRM3aUHMropHo21o6bmBaIoweM Tpe6oBaHU no oTBeTCTBeHHOCTU H B03MOJKHOCTCeU

OTpaCA.qX H MHHHMH3aUHH

UHH4pacTpyKType nary6HblX BO3zaeAiCTBHUpa3HbIX BUJOB

I aeCTejibHOCTH

Page 46: Russian - World Bank Documents

28

Ta6nIHia 1: KmIoqCBEue peKoMeHA,agHH no pedXopmmpoBaHHIOnecHoro ceKTopa POCCHH (npoAonixeHme)

B. Hepexoa KpaL4HOHGJHOMy YI77p9eHNO ffecaM (n'po,9a9XeHNe)

npo6neMa CoBpeMeHHoe cocTomnHe l7p4v=awuc,e maw 7pewaiVI e c7pnowwm

3KocHcTeMHoe 3aroToBKa apeBeCHHbl H Bepe,KHoe Hcnojib3oBaHHe * nlepecMoTpeTb HOPMbl H Tpe6oBaHHRynpaBneHHe, 3KoJIorFHecKoe niecHblx 3eMenlb, oco6eHHO no ynpaeiieHHio JiecaMH, oCHoBaHHblxHanpaBjieHHoe Ha Bo3ae HCTBH eapyrHx 3KCnJyaTaUIHOHHbIX Ha KOHueCn UHSX 3KOCHCTeM HOrOCOXpaHeHHe scex orpaciier CHAbHO njioiLuaAei, o6ecneMHBaKoiuee ynpaBJIeHHR MHoroueiieBoronojie3HbIx CBOACTB pa3pywlaloT nieca H BblCOKHt1 YPOBeHb 3auHTbi nonib3oBaHHR, H o6ecnefiHTb HXnieca r1penlTCTBYIOT HX 3KojTorH'eCKHX ueHHocTert; co6JloaeHHe

YAOBJIeTBOPHTCAbHOMY 3KojiorHqecKH, * BBeAeHHe CHcTeMbI peryJupoBaHHSI HBOCnPOH3BOjCTBY 3KwHOMmmeCKH H COUHaBJbHO CTHMYJIHPOBaHH 3IA1AR KOHTPOA1,

HeHCTOIUHTenbHble MeTOfbI OueHKH U MOTHBa3UJ.I 3qlxeKTHBHOroAecoynpaBAeHun H BoCnpOH3BOACTBaAecononib30saHHn

BocnipOH3BoAcTBo EBonbIHue riIoJua1 u BoccTaHoBHTb * OnpeneAnHTb o'epenHocTbAecoB Bbipy6OK H raperi ocTaioTcC npOJYKTHBHOCTb BOCCTaHoBAeHHR jIerpauHPOBaHHbIX

6e3 aocTaTOl'HOrO CyIIeCTBYIOWIHX nAowuaieti Ha oCHoBaHHH OILeHKHBOCnpOH3BOjaCTBa; AerpazHPOBaHHbIX AeCHbIX 3KoJorHqecKHx noCAeACTBHu Hcnoco6bI leco3ar0'ToBKH He 3eMeJb jns BbinoAHeHHA 6yaymuero 3KOHoMH9ecKoro norTeHUHanaCOOTBeTCTBYIOT WIHPOKOMY 3KOHOMH9eCKHX H * BbiueAiTb rOcyUapcTBeHHbie CpeaCTBamcnoAb3OBaHHIO 3KoAorH,ecKHx 3aAaq; Ha BoccTaHoBneHHe cytuecTByiowuHxBo3M0oKHoCTeri cnoco6bl Aeco3aroToBKH aerpauHPoBaHHbIX 3eMeAb BeCTeCTBeHHOrO rlpHBCCTH B COOTBeTCTBHe C COOTBeTCTBHH C BbI6paHHbIMHBo3o6HoBAeHxA HOPMaTHBHbIMH MeTOfaMH rpHopHTeTaMH

BOCnPOH3BOACTBa neca * OrpaHHqlTb H perAaMeHTHpo0aTbpa3Mep cnAoLuHbIx py6 oK HKoHTpOJIHpoBaTb pa6oTbi no BoCflpoH3-BOACTBY PeCYPCOB AAA npelaOrBpaUzeHHHAaAbHerIweA jierpaAauHHrlepecMoTpeTE OCHOBbI BOCnpOH3BOACT-Ba AeCoB H PaUHoHaJibHoro yrIpaBAeHHHMH, BKJIOqHB B HHX KOHuenuHU3KOCHCTeMHOrO ynpaBneHHH

OxpaHa H 3aLUHTa EceroAHo oKojio 1,6 MJIH. loBblueieHe * Pa3pa6a1raTb KoMnAeKcHble c1paTerHHaeca ra necoB noBpeXaaeTcs 3WDCKTHBHOCTH H KaqecTBa MOHHTOPHHra COCTOSHHS1 AecoB H ynp-R

noxKapaMH, HaCeKombIMH H OXpaHbi H 3aULHTbl Aeca 3a a PacwuHpsrTb MexAyHaPOaHoe COTpyJHH-60AC3HSIMH CW1T HCdnOJb3oBaHHs 'eCTBO B o6nacTH nepeja'H TeXHojiorHfl

Heo6XOlHHMbiX TexHonorHi, * YBeAHHmTb nnoWutb Ieco3aLuTHbIXMeTo,aoAorHH H MepOnpWHTHA cornacHo yro'HeHHbIM4)HHaHCHpoBaHHR 3KOHOMHqeCKHM, COUHaJbHbIM H

I 3KoAorHqecKMM KPHTePHRM

Page 47: Russian - World Bank Documents

29

Ta6AHma 1: KJloqeBbie peKoMeHAaIHH rio pecfopMHPOBaHHIOniecHoro ceKTopa PoccHH (npoAonAXeHHe)

B. PaL(HoHaffM3aIatw rocyaaPCTBCHHA" KaIITAnH&X H 7rKYWDX 3aTpaT

Flpo6neMa CoBpeMeHaoe f7p=&anemwe udu' f7pe.afawMme cTpamnmCOCTOSHUe _ 7JpeO6pA3BORAIl

lAIaHHpoBaHHe, CAa6biR noTreHuLiaA 2u 06ecneIHTb YCAOBHq Ann * AeueHTpaAH3oBaTb cmcTeMyopHeHTHPOBaHHOe Ha Aonrocpo'Horo oueHKH nocAeJCTBHu nAaHHPOBaHHA H BOBjie'b B npoUeccycTogHtBocTb pecypca cTpaTerHmecKoro H3MeHeHHA B nOAHTHKe H KOMnJieKCHoro nAaHHPOBaHHA pecypcoB

nIaHHPOBaHBhH B pacnpOCTpaH51Tb ee Bce 3aHHTepeCOBaHHbie CTOpOHbl,KoHTeKCTe PbIHOMHOH Pe3YAbTaTbl CpeAH Bcex BKA10oaq KOPeHHOe HaceAeHHe3KOHOMHKH; B 3aHHTePeCOBaHHbIX6IoaKeTHoM npouecce opraHii3auHA H nHU,HeT npaBHAbHOrO oTBeTCTBeHHbIX 3apa3rpaHHqeHHH MexKy pa3pa6oTKY H npOBeaeHHeKanBTaAbHbIMH AeCHOI4 nOAHTHKH;3aTpaTaMH H TeKylaHMH o6ecneqHTbpacxo,aaMH, 'TO BeaeT K 3KOHOMH'eCKHXpOHH4eCKOMy nepeKocy paUHOHanJbHbie YPOBHH HB pa3MeCueHHH pecypca cxeMbi oTpacAeBoroB noJb3y npeInpHHTMA, peHHBeCTHpoBaHH5I HHe CnOCo6CTByIOWHUX nOTOKOB pecypCOBYCTOUIMHBOCTH ceKcopa

OxpaHa H 3a1u.Ta Aeca n1oxKapbI, BpejHTeCAH H KoMnAeKcHbI I nOaXOa K * IHBecTi4poBaTb cpeCCTBa B CHCTeMbi H6one3HH e)KerxoaHO 3alUHTe H oxpaHe AeCOB TeXHOJorHH MOHHTOpHHra, ynpasneHHMBbl3blBalOT H 6opb6bi c noKapaMUH, BpeHTreAMmH HCyWCCTBeHHbie 6oAe3HqMH, 'To6bi MHHHMH3HpOBaTb3KOHOMHqecKHe H 3KOHOMH'eCKHe U 3KOJorumCecKHe3KOnorHqecKMe noTrepH noTepm

HayKa H TeXHHKa BiooKeTHbie jAmi npaBHAbHOrO * PaumoHan3UHpomaTb BbiAeAeHHeorpaHH4eHHR COKPpaTHAH ynpaBAeHJHH AeCHbIMH CpeaCTB Ha HccfeloBaHHS B

KanHTajnoBAolKeHHR B pecypcaMui Heo6xoIIHMo COOTBeTCTBHH C LteASMm ynpaBAeHHs

IecHYIO HayKy H rnpOAOn)KaTb ueAeBbie AeCHblM XO3sIMCTBOMnpHBueA K 3aMejLeHHIO HCCJeaOBaHH5 * OKa3blBaTb noFAIep)KKy TeM Hay'HblM

BHeapeHHUSI pe3yJIbTaTOB pa3pa6OTKam, KOTOpbiC Ccnoco6cTByiOTHay'HbIX pa6oT yKpenAeHHIO TpaUlHUHOHHb]X YKJAAOB,

TeXHonorHri H MeTOIOBpecypconojb3WBaHHS

Page 48: Russian - World Bank Documents

30

Ta6nirna 1: KioqeBbie peKoMeHarIXHH 1 no peC)opmHpoBaHHIOJeCHorFo ceicropa PoccHH (ipoAroicKeHHe)

F Pom MmexVHapoAHorv cood6ema

l7po&eiA CospemeHHoe COCTOEHKC f7pw.a e _ ff/ 17peUrMme cr7p*n Nr

rno6aJ1bHaHq MeziyHapoaHan BblnOJIHCHme * AaanTHpoBaTb H nfp HUmeHTb3KoJIorH'eCKag 3aHHTepeCOBaHHOCTb B @HHaHCOBbWX H npo'Hx MeAWYHaPOaHbie CHCTeMbh KPHTCPHeB HcTa6HJIbHOCTb npHMeHeHUH npUHHuHfnOB o6.I3aTeJIbcTB no1 HAH,KaTOPOB HeCCTOlWHTeCJbHOCTH

HeHCTOLAHTeJIbHOCTH K ynpaBemHmio inecoynpaBMeHHa AAR pa3pa6oTKHynpaaneHuIo AecaMH He r'OCyBapCTBCHHbIMH HaLIHOHaibHOAi H perHoHanbHOro6ecneMHsaecTcI a8eKBaTHOA pecypcaMH B JieCHori nojiHTHKH, MeToaOB HTexHH'ecKOA HJnu @HHaHCOBOfl COOTBeTCTBHH C HHAHKaTOpOB 3"4eKTHBHOCTHn OMOWbKO AelKayHaPoaHbhIMU * OnpeJeJnHTb KOHKpeTHbie HanpasneCHHR

AOrOBOpeHHOCTSIMH no nOIHTHKN, HHBeCTHpOBaHUH HoxpaHe CpeJbI Xo3RACTBeHHOA aenTeJbHOcTH,

HMelOWHe Mee)layHapOaHble3KoAorFHecKme nOCAeAcTBHA,BbIXORWlue 3a PaMKH HaUHOHaBJbHbIX3KOHOMHqeCKHx npHOPHTCTOBrJPOBO.HTb BCTpeqH aOHOPOB AMMo6HAH3BaUHH pecypcoB =AnpHOPHTeTHbHX HanpaBMeHHiAe__STbHOCTH

TeXHHLieCKaBJ MexAyHapoAHal TeXHHqecKaC CocpeAoToqeHHe * BMecTe C npeAcTaBHTejiMHnOMOlub nOmOILub OXUaTuhacT WHPOKHfl MeCKAyHaPOJHO 3aHHTepeCOBaHHb[X CTOpOH, [OHOpaMH

Kpyr TeM H reorp84lH'ecKKx TeXHH'ecKo0k noMOLUH H HHBeCTOPaMH r1OArOTOBHTb OUCHKYpaAOHOB, HO OHa He Ha KJioeBbix Heo6xOUHMOAi TeXHHIecKog noMOLUH HCKOOpAHHHpOBaHa, H ee HaUHOHa8JbHb[X ee nepcnelCrHBHblX HCTO'IHMKOBBJISqHHe OrpaHH'eHO npHOpHTeTaX, KOTOpbie * Pa3BHBaTb CHCTeMy corJauleHHAk O

MOryr Bbl3BaTb COTPYAHH'IecTBe mexayCHCTeMHble H3MeHeHHR B o6beaHHeHHqMH KOpeHHbIX )KHTeCetknojiHTHKc H npaiCrHKe PoccmAcxoR 4CIeIepaUHH H APYrHXpecypcoyilpaBJeHHR CTpaH CeBepa ,n noa.aepKXKH

KOPeHHOrO HaceAeHHR HTp8AHUHOHHbIX yKJlAJOB

* Pa3BHBaTb CHCTeMy MHorOCTOpOHHHXcorMuaweHHR MecKAy AOHOpaMH 0CoTpyAHHteCTBe B OKa3aMHHCHcTCmaTHecKoA ueeBoA noMOWH

(cI>HaHCOBasl (DHHaHcofie HY)KabI, 4HHaHCOBbIe peCypCbi * 06ecneHmTb CKOOPAHHHpOBaHHOeIOMOLUb CBfl3aHHbie c aWi IocTm)eH) UflHUHaHCHpOBaHHe 3KOHOMHqeCKH,

BocCTaHOBJCHHeM H AonrocpO4HbIX ueneA 3KoAorFHCCKH H COUHBabHOcoxpaHieHHeM yCTOAIHBOCTH pecypcoynpaBBJeHHS UIKH3HeCnIOCo6HbiX npoeCKTOB Hpecypca, BbIXOJST 3a npeAejibi MepOnpH1THA, CnOCO6CTBYIOLIUHXCerOAHSlIIUHHX BO3MOKxHocTeA cTa6HJbHOCTH H 344eKTHBHoCTH BH rOTOBHOCTH 'aCTHOrO o6JacTTIx, KOTOpbie qlBanSioTCqcecKTopa HHBeCTHpOBaTb, a Knlo4eBbIMAfll 1 3aLIHTbl pecypcoB UMeCTHOrO rIOCyaapCTBeHHOrO o6eCnemeHHSI AOJUKHbIX YCJIOBHFI XK3HHCecKTOpa CTpaHbl - r[IaTHTb HaceJieHuHl oTaajieHHbIX AeCHbIX

paUOHOB H npHBJemeHHIO maCTHbIXHHBeCTHUMH

Page 49: Russian - World Bank Documents

I. AECHblE PECYPCbl 11 XAPAKTEPIICTIIKA JIECHOrO CEKTOPA

1MeAS Ha cBoeu TeppHTOPHH 22% Bcex MHpOBbIX IieCOnOKpblTbIX nnjioiUare (764MHJIJIHOHa ra, H3 KOTOPbIX 78% HaXOX4ATC5 B CH6HpH H Ha JaabHeM BocToKe H 22% - B

EBponericKoA tiaCTH cTpaHbI), PoccHA BEiaaeeT HaH6oJIbLueg aone iineCHbIX pecypcoBnIiaHeTbI, no cpaBHeHliO c mo6o0 apyrori cTpaHoii MHpa. JAeca PoccHu cbirpanHUeHTpaJlbHyIO POJlb B ee 3KOHoMHqeCKOM, COUH8aJbHOM H KYJIbTYPHOM pa3BHTHH H 5IBJI5HOTCSA

Ba)KHbIM KOMnOHeHTOM oKpyxKaiOWueH Cpeabl KaK XUIA POCCUUiCKOHi $DeaepaUHH, TaK H BceroMHpa. JAeCHbie peCypCbl POCCuH - 3TO He TOJIbKO HCTO4HHK apeBeCHHbl, HO H CaMb1H

KpynHblU B MHpe Ha3eMHblU HaKOlHHTeJb yrnepoaa, KpOMe TOrO, OHH ,aaOT MHO)KeCTBO

pa3HbIX HeapeBeCHbIX HpOayKTOB, BKJAiO4aq pbl6y, aU4qb, 5rO1abl, rpH6bI JileKapCTBeHHbie

TpaBbI, KOTOpbie HMelOT 60oblnoe 3Ha4eHHe B XH3HH KOpeHHOrO HaCeAeHHS JeCHbIX

TeppHTOpHH. 5naroaapqi CBoeMy orpoMHOMY HCTOpH4IecKoMy OnbITY ynpaaBJeHHq jIecaMHPOCCH14 CTa1ia OaHHM H3 HptH3HaHHbIX JiH1epOB B TaKHX o6JlaCT5[X, KaK COXpaHeH4e JlecOB,AecHaA HayKa, TeXHHKa H TexHoJIorHS.

B TO )Ke BpeM5 nepea AeCHbIM CCKTOpOM POCCHH CTOHT MHO)KeCTBO npo6JieM,Bbl3BaHHbIX CTpeMHTenJbHbIMH HOJATHTHeCKHMH H 3KOHOMHMeCKHMH nepeMeHaMH,

npOHCXO,a5uUHM4 B cTpaHe B nepHoa nepexoia K PbIHOMHOU 3KOHOMHKe. HecMOTpA Ha

OrPOMHbIe 3anacbI peCypCOB H 6oflbWOr4 cnpoc Ha npoayKuHo AeCHOA H

,aepeBOo6pa6aTbIBaloLueA rpOMbblwJ1eHHOCTH Ha MHPOBOM pbIHKe, pOCCHUICKUUr AecHOHi

CeKTOp nepeidlBaeT 60AbHWle TPYAHOCTH B ynpaBHeHHHH JIeCHbIMH OTpaCTIAMH, MTO CTaBHT

noa yrpo3y COUHaYbHO-3KOHOMH4eCKyiO CTa6lJIbHOCTb J1eCHbIX paUOHOB H 3KOJTOrFHeCKKIO

ueJTOCTHOCTb JieCOB. 9TH npo6nieMbl Tpe6yIOT KOpeHHOrO H3MeHeHHtB B noaxoae POCCHH K

ynpaBnieHHIo JIeCHbIMH pecypcaMH. B HaCTOALueM aoKiaae JiecHoli ceKTop PoccHH

paccmaTpHBaeTCA B KOHTeKCTe 3THX KpynHbIX HepeweHHblX npo6neM; npejRJaraeTCsueLiOCTHa5 OCHOBa afiuA pa3pa6OTKH CTpaTerwqecKoro noaxoaa, 3aKOHo:aTeJIbHbIX H

HOpMaTHBHbiX aKTOB, a TaioKe HHBeCTHUHOHHbIX nporpaMM, HaripaBieHHbIX Ha o6ecne4eHHeyCTOU'HBOrO pa3BHTH ceicropa B nepeXOaHbl nepHoa.

B aaHHOM aoKmaae riaBHbIM o6pa3oM o6cyxcaaeTcs noJo)KeHHe eJien B CH6HpH H

Ha LI,aabHeM BocToKe, T.e. Ha Bceg TeppHTOpHH, pacroAO)KeHHOri K BOCTOKy OT YpaJibCKHX

rop B CuJIy Heo6xoIHMOcTH CPO4Horo peueHu4A npo66JeM, CB5I3aHHbIX C 3KOJTorH4ecKoHyCTOlUHBOCTbIO OCTaBWHXCqI IOCTyIHbIX aeBCTBeHHbIX nIeCOB A3HaTCKOi 4aCTH POCCHH,

KOTOpbIe CTaniH oco6o YSI3BHMbl B repeXoLHbrlu riepHoa, HO npegLo)KeHH5i nO

peopOm4pOBaHHIO HaUHOHaJ1bHOU JlecHorl nOJIHTHKH H MHOrHe peKOMeHaaLuHH OTHOCSITCSA K

* eCHOMY ceIKTOpy B ueJIoM. B aaJnbHeUIweM Heo6xoIHMo npOBeCTH 6onee aeTajibHbieHccJie,aOBaHHAI nO BceMy ceKTopy H no ero oTaeJlbHbIM OTpaCJIAM KaK IAns A3HaTCKOA, TaK H

=Ia EhpOneNCcKON MaCTH POCCHH14.

HaCTO.HUH4A oaoKiaz, 6a3HpyeTCsl Ha HeCKOJIbKHX HCTOMHHKaX IHH4OpMaUHH,BKnHo4aA: (a) caHHboe, co6paHHble B 1995 roAy B xoae noe3AKH aenerautm BceMHpHoro6aHKa B KpacHoApcKHu (CH6Hpb) H Xa6apoBcKHi (a,anbHH9 BOCTOK) KpaSA, (6)MHOr'OMHCAeHHbIe BCTpeql4 B MOCKBe CO cneuHajiHCTaMH, JiHuaMH, OTBeTCTBeHHbIMH 3apa3pa6oTKy H npOBeaeHHe ieCHOu nOJIHTHKH, H rpe,RCTaBHTejiqMH rOCyRaPCTBeHHbIXBeAOMCTB, CBR3aHHbIX C pOCCHUCKHM ieCHblM CeKTOpOM, (B) BcrOMoraTCejbHbie ADaHHbIe,npeaocTaBJTeHHbie (DeAepaj¶bHoH cy)K6ori necHoro XO3HTiCTBa PoccHH no pa3HblM acneKTaM

Page 50: Russian - World Bank Documents

32

jiecHoro ceKTOpa CTpaHbI, (r) aoKAaabl Ha KOHKpeTHbIe TeMbi, noarOTOBReHHbie 4iJeHaMH

pa6o0ek rpynnbl, B KOTOPYIO BXOatHJIH4 nHTHaaLuaTb pOCCUiUCKHX cneHuaTiHCTOB no niecy H

O03HUHajibHbIX JIHU, OTBe4aKoLUHX 3a pa3pa6oTKy H npoBeaeHHe JTecHoH roJIHTHKH, H (xi)

KOMMeHTapHH rOCyaapCTBeHHbIX aOJ1)KHOCTHbIX AuLI, CneLHaBACTOB AeCHOrO CeKTOpa H

npe,aCTaBHTejIeA HenpaBHTeJIbCTBeHHbIX opraHH3auHu (HaUHOHajibHbIX H Mee)KyHapOaHbbX),

KOTOpbie npoaHaJIH3HPOBaAH npOeKT aaHHOrO aoKAaaa. 3ToT aoKAaa, OaHaKO, He qBJSIeTC5I

HOribITKOH HagTH peCwIeHH BCeM HpO6JieMaM, CTOIWHX nepea AeCHbIM CeKTOpOM PoccHH.

OcHoBHoe BHHMaHHe B HeM cocpCeoToOeHO Ha p5ijae Kj1O4eBbIX npo6fieM, KOTOpbIe

npeHrITCTBY1OT 3KojiorHMecKH, COIIHaBJbHO H 3KOHOMH4eCKH yCTOrYUHBOMy pa3BHTHJO JieCHoro

CeKTOpa H peKOMeHaaLuHRx no COIeIiCTBHIO yCTOW-IHBOMy pa3BHTHIO CeKTOpa B nepeXOAHblH

repHoa.

ao 1989 roaa POCCHa 3aHHMaIa BTOpoe MeCTo no npOH3BOILCTBY

ipoMbiiuJIeHHOu apeBecHHbl, ycTynasA HO 3TOMy nOKa3aTeZjiO TOJIbKO CLIIA. HpOH3BOaCTBO

apeBecl4Hbl B o6beMe CBblweC 300 MHJIAHOHOB Ky6oMeTpOB B roA COOTBeTCTBOBaJIO 6o0iee qeM

2% BaJIOBOrO BHyTpeHHerO HpOayKTa (BBn) POCCHH H o6ecne'qHBaYio 3aHATOCTb

npH6j]H3HTeJIbHO ABYX MHJIJIHOHOB qeIOBeK. JIeCHOA CeKTOp MBjniCTCq TalIKC OAHHM H3

OCHOBHbIX HCTO'-HHKOB 3KCHOPTHbix nOCTynineHHH H nOTeH[iHaAbHO 6ojibuIHx HajOIrOBbIX

AOXOAOB. OaHaKO C Ha'aYTa nepexora K pbIHO4HOH 3KOHOMHKe o61beMbl BbInYCKa

JieconpOTaYKUHH CHH3HJHCb riMpHepHO aO OAHOR TpeTH OT npC)KHerO ypOBHq. 06'bembi3arOTOBKH apeBecHHbl COKpaTHJnMCb C YPOBHq 375 MJIH. Ky6oMeTpoB (cpeaHeroaoBaq

oLieHKa) B 1989-1991 roaax ao 115 MJIH. Ky6oMeTpOB B 1995 rogy, a corniacHo nporHO3aM Ha

1996 r. o6beMbi npOH3BOaCTBa TaKoro nieca aOJI)KHbl COCTaBHTb 110 MJIH. Ky6oMeTpoB (PHC.

1.1). 1 CTOU14uTeabHaq CHCTeMa Jlecoao6biq4 H Unepepa6oTKH tapeBeCHHbl, cy11eCTBOBaBwaq

rpH ueHTPaJIH3OBaHHOM nHiaHHpOBaHH4, pacnaniacb rioa aaBjieHHeM pbIHO'-HOH

IIeACTBHTej1bHOCTM, Koraa rpOH3BOal4TejiH Haqa4BJ CTajKHBaTbCS1 C peaCjbHbIMH 3aTpaTaMH Ha

TpaHCROPT H aPYrHMMH qaKTopaMH. MHorHe npenpl4HSAT4H .YecHOFo ceKTopa, Haxoaq5[UHeCSC B

paHoHax C HH3KHM nOTeHLiUHajioM pOCTa H XpynKHMH YCJIOBHA1MH npHPOAHOA cpeabi,

'yBCTBHTeJbHOH K .jO6biM BMCewIaTeJIbCTBaM, OKa3aJIHCb IOJIHOCTbIO H30JIHpOBaHHbIMH OT

3KOHOMH4eCKH aOCTynHbIX peCypCOB.

POCCHiCiCKHe nieca HMelOT orpoMHoe rjio6anbHoe 3HaqeHHe, Ha HX ao.rHonpHXOLIHTC5 22% nlJIOlaaiH HnIaHeTbl, IlOKpblTOU ICcaMH (-TO COCTaBJI5ICT CaMblI BbICOKUU

npoueHT no CpaBHeHHIO C apyrHM4 CTpaHaMH MHpa), 21% MHpOBOrO 3anaca neca Ha KOpHlO

(caMble 3Ha4HTejibHbie 3anacbi B MHpe), 15% niiaHeTapHorO Ha3eMHoro yriiepoaHoro nyjia H

75% nOTeHLLHania norjioLueHHSI yriiepoaa BCeMm 6opeaJlbHbIMH YIecaMH MHpa. PoccHiCKHe

nieca HMeIOT OrpOMHOe MHpOBOe 3HaqeHHe TaK)Ke B nnIaHe HX 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3HA H

cnoco6HOCTH norAoLLaTb H CB5I3blBaTb yriepoa, oco6eHHO 3TO OTHOCHTCq K 3KOCHCTeMaM

o61HpHblX aeBCTBeHHbIX JIeCOB CH6HpU H IaalabHero BOCTOKa (CnpaBKa 1.1.). BEBponeicKofl 4aCTH PoCCuH B pe3yfJbTaTe 300-ieTHerl HHTeHCHBHOH neco3KCnjiyaTaL4iH

cBbiwe 60% necoB HCnbITaJiH Bo3LIeHCTBHCe npoMbiwiJeHHbIX py6oK H yTpaTHJIH

3Ha,HTeCjbHYIO 'iaCTb CBoero 64opa3Hoo6pa345.

OaHaKO K BOCTOKY OT YpaYIbCKHX rop 6onbWuHe njiomaaiu ,aeBCTBeHHbIX nIeCOB

OCTaKOTCA npaKTHm'eCKH HeTpOHyTbIMH. 3TU o6WHpHbie 3KOCHCTeMbi nPpeaOCTaBJIqlOT OaHy H3

nOCJICeHHX BO3MO)KHOCTeH coxpaHCHH4 yHHKajibHbIX BH,OB, KOTOpbie nO CBOeMy ypOBHIO

pa3Hoo6pa3HA H 3HaeMH3Ma, rpeBOCXO,DIT aHajToruHqHbie BRAbl, cyweCTBYIOIuHe B ApyrHX

.necax yMepeHHOA 3OHbl. Jleca Cu6upu H aaAbHero BocToKa TaKwKe ABJSl OTCS KpynHbIM

Page 51: Russian - World Bank Documents

PHC. 1.1: 061eMbI JiCcO3aFOTOBOK B POCCHH, 1980-96

400

354

350 328

304

300 269

250 238

200 175

150 IIi li119 115

10

50

0 -

00 00ONOONN

HcTmomrncu: rocy)apc1ueEHMi KomETeT PO no TamcTmxe u ODeAepaau.aam caiyu6a JecnEoro xo3IcTuS, 1996 r.

Page 52: Russian - World Bank Documents

34

HaKonHTeJieM yrAepoaa, 'TO O4eHb BaXHO amS rjlo6aflbHoro 6anaHca napHHKOBbIx ra3OB.

CnpaBiKa l.1: rAo6anbHoe 3HameHHe JIecoB POCCuH

06WHpHble, npaKTHqeCKH HenOBpe)KaeHHbIe 3KOCUCTeMbi PoccUHi npegLocTaBJlIoT co6o0 OaHy U13nocJlelHHx Bo3Mo)KHocTeA coxpaHeHmq npipOQHb1X naHIwiad)TOB B MacIwTa6ax, llO3BOJIHK)OUtX c6epeqb y'aCTKHHaCTO5Iuei AeBCTBeHHoH flPHPOAbl U aaTb 3KOJormt4eCKHM npoueccam U nonyJiquHqM HKHX )KHCBOTHblXpa3BHBaTbCM CCTeCTBeHHbiM nyTeM. YHHKanibHbie KOMnfeKCb] BKQOB Ha 5OJIbUOM KaBKa3e H ,aanbHeM BocToKePOccHH no CBoeMy YPOBHIO pa3Hoo6pa31H H 3H1eMH3Ma npeBOCXOa.9T aHanjorHqHble KOMnAeKCbl B iiecaxyMepeHHo4 30Hbi .mo6oro apyroro perUHoa MHpa. POCCHACKHe iieca RBJI$lOTCq TaKoce npfMepoM pa3Hoo6pa31HJqeJoBe'ecKHx KyJ]bTyp, B qaCTHOCTH KyAbTyp KOpeHHbIX )KHTeAeJi Cu6upui U4 )IaAbHero BocToKa (noapo6HocTHCM. B npiAoiceHHH )K).

AMypcKO-CaxanuHcKHu 614operHoH )RaJbHero BocToKa HMeeT oco6oe 3HaqeHHe B CBH3Ui C TeM, oT06o0JbwaA ero qaCTb M36e)Kana KOHTHHeHTaJIbHoro oAeaeHeHHA. 103TOMy 31T4 TreppHTOptuH CTanJ KIMmaTHqeCKHMnpm6e)KHiueM aAn MHorHX BHUOB H nonyJuqUH1, qeM H o6'bscHqeTcH BbICOKUU ypoBeHb 3HaeMH3Ma pacTeH14iU 6ecno3BoHoqHblx (Kiever et al., 1994; Charkiewicz, 1993). noao6&bie nieca HeKoraa noKpblBaIul TeppHTOpHiOKHTaSl, KopeH H 5mnOHH1, HO TaM OHH yxKe B OCHOBHOM yHHqTO)KeHbl. YHHKajibHaH 6Horeorpa(bmqecKa3iHCTopH4$ perHOHa o6%siCHaeT HaniHYHe 3JIeCb Heo6bi4HbIX CoqeTaHHI BH)OB pacTeHHA H )KUXBOTHbIX.YCCYPUICKHUi THrp, aMypCKHr1 neonapA, Ka6apra H rHManaJCKHti Me4BeAb aenJHT 3Xaecb cpeay o6HTaH1H4 c 6ypbiMMeABe,aeM, CeBepHb1M oneHeM H AOCOCeM.

HeTpoHyrble OCTpOBa 6opeanbHbIx iiecoB u apyrHe neca npHTHHapOBOA 3OHbl ToXCe npeaCTaBMIjOT6olbuWyIo ueHHHOCTb WAnH MOHHTopHHra Bo3,aeACTBHt rnIo6albHoro H3MeHeHHA Ki1HMaTa, nOCKOAbKy HXpenpOAyKT14BHoe COCTOAHHe AoJDKHO 6bITb 14HAUKaTopoM nuo6oro ycTouqHBoro nOBbUiweH1H TemnepaTypbl HaBbICOKHX ulipoTax (Nichols, 1993). OrpoMHbue JiecHbie npocTopb1 PoccHu TaKxKe BbInOj1HHOT pOjlb KpynHOrO

HaKOnHTeJs1 yrJlepoaa, KOTOpblUI npeaLcTaBJlSeT OdHy ceRbMylo Bcero Ha3eMHoro yrnepoAHoro nynia 3eM.nH(Koichugina and Vinson, 1993). npH npaB1nIbHoM noaxoae K peryJinpoBaHHlo npoayKTHBHoCTH HacawAeHHA,oxpaHe ijeCOB OT noxcapoB H Bbi6opy cnoco6o0 U CHcTeM Aeco3aroToBKH 3TH Aeca no-npe)KHeMy 6yAyTcnoco6cTBoBaTb MHH1MH3auti1 BbjaejieHHA napHHKOBbIX ra3oB. Ho 6e3 HaaAewKawtux Mep no coxpaHeHHno 3TUXnieCOB H ynpaBjleHH4O HMH, nOBblweHHaS HHTeHCHBHOCTb neconoJIb3oBaHHs H no)Kapbl MOryT o6oCTpUTb

npo6neMbl, CB93aHHb]C c rno6ahlbHbIM HaKonnieHHeM aTMoCd)epHoro yrAepoaa, Bbl3bIBasl BbIcBo6o)KueHHecyLueCTBYO01UHX 3anacoB (Krankina and Harmon, 1994; Krankina and Dixon, 1994; FIRESCAN, 1994).

Jleca PoccHui UMmeOT TaKwCe BaEKHOe 3HaBeHHe AnH MHpOBOIU 3KOHOMUKU ilecHoro ceKTopa. HecMoTpBHa naaeHHe YPOBHH npOH3BOaCTBa c 1980-x roaoB, orpoMHble nnoHuaaa pOCCHUiCKHX neCHblX pecypcoB npti

npaBHJIbHoM ynpaBJIeHHH AOJDKHbI nO3BOJlHTb oTpacJImM JieCHOH npoMbluwJeHHOCTu BHOCUTb 3Ha'4tTeJIbHbl1BKJIa. B pa3B1THe perHoHaJlbHo14 H HauJOHaAbHOPI 3KOHOMUKUK. 9,451 3TorO Heo6XoAHMO co3JIaTb OCHOBY nocoxpaHeHuHO yCTo14tJBOCT1 pecypca, KoTopaR o6ecneqHT coxpaHeHHe 3KoJlorHqecK1x UeHHoCTeC iAecoB 14 UxnpoH3BOLICTBeHHOrO noTeHIHuaJa.

EcJIH npo6IieMbl, oKa3bIBaioumle HeraTHBHoe BO3,ae4CcTBHe Ha neCHOi cecKTop PoccHuu,OCTaHyTCSl 6e3 aOAXKHorO BHHM4aHH5 H He 6yAyT npeanpHHqTbl Heo6XoaUHMbie aeACTBHS CO

CTOpOHbI KaK roCyXapCTBeHHOFO, TaK H4 qaCTHOrO CeKTopa, TO YCJlOBH4I B necax K BOCTOKY OT

YpaRa MOryT HeO6paTHMO yXyAWHTbCA, 'ITO HaHeceT 6OAbWoA yiuep6 3KOJIorFH H3KOHOMH4Ke ,aHHOrO perHOHa.

CerOLaH5 Cq)opMHpOBaj]HCb 6naronp[slTHble yCnOBHuA Ami npoBe,eHHq COBMeCTHbIXLIerCTBHA KaK Ha HaLUHOHajIbHOM, TaK H Ha MeKflyHapOQaHOM YPOBH9X no nepexoAy KpaUHOHaIbHOMy yrpaBseHH[o AeCHbIMH pecypcaMH POCCHH, opHeHTHpOBaHHbIX HacoxpaHeHie H CaMOBOCCTaHOBjieHHe neCOB. CTpyKTypa ceroAHAWSLHel HOjiHTHKH POCCHu Bo6JnaCTH JIeCHbIX peCYPCOB He o6ecne'HBaeT aegeKBaTHOA OCHOBbl AJI BbInOjIHeHHR

MeKLyHapOQHbIX o65I3aTeAbCTB npaBHTeJIbcTBa no oxpaHe oKpywKaloLuer cpeambI,

Page 53: Russian - World Bank Documents

35

o6ycjioBJIHBaIOT HepeLUHTenJbHOCTb uaCTHbIX HHBeCTOPOB B niiaHe BJo)KeHHA cpeACTB B 3TOTHOTeHUHaJIbHO npHBjieKaTenjbHblti CeKTOp H C03AaeT npenAITCTBHA He TOJlbKO3KOJIOrHqecKoMy, COUHaJlbHOMY H 3KOHOMH'eCKOMy pa3BHTHIO, HO U BbIllOJTHeHIO 3aAaMynpaBAeHHA J1eCHbIMH pecypcaMH. B HaCTOqieM aoKmaae pa3pa6aTbIBalOTCs BapHaHTblpe4OPMHPOBaH4R IOAuHTHK4 necoynpaBneHU4 PoccHu, KOTOpbie npegnara[oTcsA AnJpaccMoTpeHHS npaBHTejibCTBOM cTpaHbi. B AoKmaAe TaKwe paccmaTpuBaeTci nporpaMMaAeRCTBH9, HanpaBJIeHHbIX Ha BOCCTaHOBjieHHe HOpManjbHOrO 4)YHKUIiOHHPOBaHUq CeKTOpa HcoxpaHeHH5 ueLJOCTHOCTH oKpyKaolluefi CpeRbl Ha OCHOBe nepexoAa K paUHOHaAbHOMYynpaBjieHHIo necaMH.

Hau6o0ee Ba)KHbIMH ABnSAOTCS qeTbipe cneLyloLuHe npo6iieMbi:COBepweHCTBOBaHHe H AOBeaeHHe AO HY)KHOFO YPOBHR lp BOMBX OCHOB U CHCTeMblperyn pOBaHKA B o6jiacTH BjiaAeHHA, ynpaBnTeHBI4H H nOJTb3OBaHHA jieCHbIMu 3eMjiHMH,coxpaHeHHe yCTO9NHBOCTH pecypca H uenjOCTHOCTH oApyxaIroIfJc cpeIm, peopraHH3aLURceKTopa C uenbbo o6ecneMeHHiu ero 9KOHOmH*eCKOfl CTa6HJIbHOCTH H xH3HeCnOCO6HOCTH UyKpeniieHHe CHCTeMbi COJ4LSJbHO. 3aCuI1Tbl HaceneHHR CaMb1X YS3BHMbIX patOHOB,

noIIpa3yMeBaiolueH co3AaHHe ajibTepHaTHBHbIX BO3MO)KHOCTeri 3aHSTOCTH H YCAOBH4COXpaHeHHH npeeMCTBeHHOCTH B Tpa2HUH4OHHOM o6pa3e )KH3H4 KopeHHorO HacejIeHHs U eroyKiiagax. 9An peueHHA 3TWX npo6fleM Heo6xOAHMbl: HHTerpaUS IieCHOH nOJIHT4K4 B 6oneeo6WHpHblg npouecc COULHajbHO-3KOHOMH'-IeCKHX pe4DopM, nepexoA K paUHOHaJlbHOMYyripaBneHHlo pecypcaMH, onpeLejleHHe npHopHTeTOB rocyAapCTBeHHOrO HHBeCTHPOBaHHA BiiecHOt ceKTop H co3AaHHe COOTBeTCTBYIOIU1HX YCJOBHri (B rniaHe nOJIHTHK4 H cHcTeMbIperyjIHpoBaHHA) 21J151 fp4BAiMeeHH5 'aCTHbIX HHBeCTHU1Hr.

nIOCKOJIbKy HOJIHTHKa B o6JiaCTH JIeCHbIX peCypCOB SBJISqeTcS o6LeCTBeHHOBaXHbIM npOUeCCOM, TO AAA co3AaHHS COUHajIbHOui 6a3bl WHPOKOU nlOILepxKH ped)OpM,rocy2aPCTBeHHbie AeSTeJi, OTBeTCTBeHHbie 3a ee npOBe2eHHe, AOJDKHbI AeriCTBOBaTb HaOCHOBe OTKpbITOCTH H y4aCTHA B 3TOM npouecce BceX 3aHHTepeCOBaHHbIX CTOpOH. UAAonpe,eneHHA coaep)KaHHA COUHaHJbHO H 3KOJIorH'eCKH CTa6HUbHbIX pedopM H OLteHKH Upa3pa6OTKH nOJIHTHK4 HeO6xOaiMO npHBJieKaTb KaK MOXHO 60JIbWe 3aHHTepeCOBaHHblXopraHH3aUHi, a TaKxe KopeHHoe HaceiieHHe. AHanHiuTHeCKHKu nO,AXO2, npe,xnaraeMbirl BHaCTO51LeM 2OKJIa2e, MO)KeT nOMO4b POCCHUiCKHM rOCyaapCTBeHHb1M AeATeJl5M npHBHeCeHHU AOROJ1HeHH4r H H3MeHeHHri B CyWeCTBYIOUYIO cTpaTerHio pa3BHTHS4. npu

3Ko0HorHqeCKH H 3KOHOMH4eCKH pauLOHaJIbHOM yrpasBeHHH pecypcbi jiecHoro ceKTopaMOrYT He TOJIbKO COXpaHHTb CBOU rOTeHUHaLn AnA 6niara 6yAyLuLx roKoneHHu, HO Hnpo2AojDKaTb o6ecnequHBaTb HaceiieHHe POCCHuu u ce MHpOBOe coo6UweCTBo UeHHbIMHripoAyKTaMH nieca.

Page 54: Russian - World Bank Documents

36

A. Hpo6AeMbi iecHor'o ceKTopa

HOC.e,aCTB" Yp3MepHOII 9KCIHyWL(HH JICCOB

YpanbCKHe ropul HCTOptiqeCKH SB.JIIOTCA BaXcHOf JIHHHeu pa3nena Mew)y

EBponeRCKOR M A3HaTCKOri 'aCTRMH POCCHH. MeHee ABYX CTOJeTHrU TOMY Ha3aA nOqTH BCS

JieCOXo3sICTBeHHas H JIeCOnpOMbiiuIIeHHaB AeqTebHOCTb BeJlaCb TOJbKO B EBponeUcKOU

qaCTH PoccHH. B KOHLte 17-ro - HaqanIe 18-ro BeKOB B POCCUH Haqania HCnOJb3OBaTbCS

KOHLIeriLIR rocyIapCTBeHHOrO CyBepeHHOrO npaBa Ha AeCHbIe 3eMAH, 'ITO 6blJo

o6ycnoBeeHo pOCTOM 3aOHTepecOBaHHOCTH roCyfapCTBa B nOJIb3OBaHHH U BJiaaeHHH AeCaMH.

JecHas HOJIHTHKa, pa3pa6OTaHHas B TO BpeMsI, 6bula HaiHpaBJIeHa, rJaBHbIM o6pa3OM, Ha

ocylueCTB.JeHHe CyBepeHHOrO KOHTpOJIA Ha, AeCaMH B cTpaTerHqecKux aenqx (MopcKoUi

4f)OT, npOMbillJ1eHHOCTb H CTpOHTeAbCTBO CaHKT-neTep6ypra) H BKJIlOqHfa CBOa 3aKOHOB 0

npaBax H o6s3aHHOcTqx necoBnaaeJlbueB. Ha'HHaq c 1780-x rozioB, KJlo4eBoH UeJblo

JieCHOR nOIHTHKH CTaJIo nofy'eHHe npH6bmti, H 'IacTHbie AecoBa,aefbubi BepHyJH ce6e

nOJHbIlH KOHTpOJlb Hag IIpHHa=e)KaIUHMH HM paHee JiecaMi. 3Ha'HTenbHO B03pOCJIa

HHTeHCHBHaA npoMbiuIJeHHa5 3KCnAyaTaLHqS necoB, a KO BTOpOUi nO1OBHHe 19-ro BeKa oHa

npHBeea K MaCCOBOMY CBe,eHH10 AeCOB, B OCHOBHOM B EBpOnericKoUi 'aCTH POCCuH.

PedopMbi, nlpOBORUHMbIe B KOHiLe 1860-x - Haqane 1870-x roaoB, npIPBeJH B KOHeCHOM HTOre

K BBeaeHHIO "nOAOKeHHr o c6epeKeHHH ieCOB", 'ITO Ha nopore 20-ro BeKa 3anoAHJio

OCHOBYAJLA riepBbIX maroB K ynpaBAeHHIO AecaMH H HX oxpaHe.

PeBOmIOuuHu 1917 roaa paaHKaAbHO H3MeHHJIH CTpyKTypy niecHoro ceKiopa

POCCHH. B 1918 roAy B 3aKOHoLaTeAbHOM nOpqaKe 6bluiH OTMeHeHbi Bce npaBa 'aCTHOH

CO6CTBeHHOCTH Ha ieCHbie 3eMAi. Jiec 6b1 o6,b5iBJleH AOCTOAHHeM Hapola, KOTOpbIM HawO

6bU10o ynpasBnTb Ha OCHOBe nHaHOBorO Bocripo3Bo,BcTBa Ha 6naro Bceui cTpaHbl.

FOcy,aapCTBO TaloKe B3SIJIO B CBOe BeAeHHe BHeIIHIOIO TOprOBJllO ApeBecHHOri H

neconpoMbiwAeHHOHi npORyKLUHeg. B Haqane 1930-x roaOBr npeanpHSTHAs necHoro ceKTopa

6bllH BKJIio'eHbl B CHCTeMY ueHTpaJH3OBaHHoro nIAaHHpOBaHH5I, H AAA HUX 6bu114

pacnHcaHbi npoH3BOACTBeHHbie 3aaaHl4A. OaHaKo BMeCTO 6nara AAA Bcerl CTpaHbI 3TO

npHBeIO K HOBOU 3pe ",1o6blx[H" nieca, nOCKOnbKy B TO BpeMA He 6blnO HK

3aHHTepecOBaHHOcTH B 3KOHOMHi4ecKoH 3("4eKTHBHOcTH, HH CpeaCTB Ha paLUHOHanbHOe

ynpaBjieHHe AecaMH. K 1940 roay 3Ha'HTeJbHO paclIHpHAMCb nepepa6aTblBaloLuHe

MOWHOCTH.

B 1930-e H 1940-e roabl B JeCHoH nojiHTHKe noIBJIReTCS pa3eeHie JeCOB Ha

3KCnJyaTaLtHOHHbie H 3aluHTHbie, cHaqana B BOaOoxpaHHbIX ueAAX, a no3AHee U aAn 3aBLHTbl

neCHbIX 3KOCUCTeM. XOTA "Llo6bi'a" neca npoaoA)Kaxacb, cneKrp uejieu ceKTopa

pacwIIHPHACA H CTan BKJlOioaTb COBepweUHCTBOBaHHe TeXHonOFKr4 AeCo3arOTOBK4, MeTO,aOB

Be,aeHHA necHoro XO3sAcTBa H BOCnPOH3BORCTBa pecypca. HIocne BTOpOU MHpOBOU BOUHbI

3a,a'Ieg nepBOoqepeAHoro 3HameHHA CTaJO OCBoeHHe HOBbIX feCO3arOTOBHTeJbHbIX parioHoB

Ha ceBepe H BOCTOKe cTpaHbl. JIeCOX03SriCTBeHHblM npeanpHSTHHM 6bIflH LaHbl npaBa Ha

3aFOTOBKY neca, 'lTO6bi OHM MOrIH BbInOAHSITb nPO43BOaCTBeHHbie HOpMbl, H BMeHeHa

o6sI3aHHOcTb BOCCTaHaBnBBaTb iiec Ha BbIpy6KaX. K 1960 roay rOaOBOU o6beM fleCO3aroTOBKH

IIOCTHr 369 MHUAHOHOB Ky6HtieCKHX MeTpOB. YBeJHIHJIHCb rinoLiaaH noceBa, riOCa,KH H

,ApyrHX BHALOB Aecoxo3StiCTBeHHbIX MepOnpHATHI, B TOM 'HcAe eCTeCTBeHHOrO

BO3o6HoBJIeHHA, ocylulleHH H yxolla 3a necoM, WTO Tpe6OBajnO OFPOMHbIX KantTaOBJO)KCeHUi

Page 55: Russian - World Bank Documents

37

B HH¢paCTpyKTypy H HOBYIO TeXHHKY. OAHaKO, 3TH MepbI 6bulH HeAocTaTOqHbI tiTo6blcnpaBHTbCA C BbICOKHMH TemnaMH Bbipy6KM AecoB BO MHorHX Xo3SHCTBeHHbIX paroHax, H BKOH1e 1970-x rOaOB TeMnbl pocTa npOH3BOLCTBa B ceKTope HaqaJIH riaAaTb.

K KOHUY 1980-x rOaOB CeKTOp y)Ke He Mor yaoBEieTBOPHTb CnpOC Ha BHYTpeHHHX

H 3KcnOpTHbIX pbIHKaX, HeCMOTpS Ha AOCTaTO4HO 6onbulHe B03MO)KHOCTH npOMbIllieHHOUinepepa6oTKH. 1ICTO[ueHHe JierKo aocTynHbIX flecoce4HbX nrinoLaaAeri H npo6neMbl 3arOTOBKHH TpaHCnOPTHPOBKH CTanu nPH4HHaMH aaAbHeAiLero cnaaa npOH3BoaCTBa. 4AAsHcnpaBjieHuH noFioAeHOHH OpraHaM necHoro X03S9UCTBa 6buIo ,1aHo npaBo CaMHM 3aHHMaTbCqripoMb1U1AeHHOr4 3arOTOBKOPi neca. nocKonbKy 3aroTOBKa npHHOCHJ1a 3Hal4TeCJbHbie AOXOabI,eti cTaJIo yaenjiTbCH OCHOBHoe BHHMaHHe, npH nOMTH nOJIHOM HrHOPHPOBaHHH npo6neMynpaBAneHHA AeCHbIM X03.UiCTBOM. Bo3HuKHoBeHHe eienoro pqaa npo6neM B c4epe 3aUXHTbl UcoxpaHeHHA nIecoB, a TaioKe COUHaJbHO-3KOHOMHMeCKHe HyIUbI, npuBenu K pa3pa6oTKennaHa, npeaycmaTpu4aioLero onpeAeneHHoe pacwiupeHHe rAo[uaaH nIeCHbIX 3arOBeCHHKOBH HaUHOHaJbHbIX napKOB.

npHHHATHe PoccHeu1 HOBoU KOHCTHTYUUUi nocne pacnaga CCCP H riOpBXH)KeHHeK pbIHOM{HOri 3KoHoMHKe B 1991 roiy BbI3BanIH paLHKaflbHbie rTojiHTH'eCKHe, npaBOBbIe H3KOHOMH,eCKHe nepeMeHbl, noTpcIllHe Bce oTpaCJIH 3KOHOMHKH, BKnloqaA neCHou ceKTop.KoHuenLLHAs npoH3BoACTBa, Bbipa6oTaHHaS npH CHCTeMe LteHTpa.J]H3oBaHHoro nIiaH4poBaHH.9,oKa3anaCb HeCOCTOATeCbHOA H nepeCTaJia 34XeKTHBHO 4)yHKUHOHHpOBaTb, TO noBJIeKJO 3aco6o0 pe3KHR criaL IPOH3BOaCTBa H nOBceMeCTHoe o6ocTpeHHe couHBaIbHbIX npo6neM,oco6eHHo B oTajieHHbIX ieCO3aroTOBHTenJbHblX nocenKax Cu6upu H ,H aJ¶bHero BocToKa.

lpniOBOpCWiz B ffCCHOM 3aKOHO/aTaI,CFBC

CTpeMHTeJbHbie H rjiy6oKHe H3MeHeHH5 B 3KOHOMHKe H nOJIHTHKe PoccHHnpHBeAH K ycTapeBaHHIo H noTepe 3j1eKTHBHOCTH CoBeTcKoi4 HopMaTHBHO-npaBOBor 6a3bi4IYHKtHOHHPOBaHHA niecHoro ceKropa. B KaMeCTBe npoMexyTo'-HoH 3aKoHoRaTeAbHori 6a3blAAA ynpaBAeHHA H 3KcnJyaTaUHH iiecoB 6buIK npHHHqTbi "OCHOBbi JIeCHoro3aKoHo,aaTeJIbCTBa POCCHiCKOHa (PeaepalHH" (rIpHHsTbi BepXoBHbIM COBeTOM H BBeaeHbi B,aeACTBHe B MapTe 1993 roaa), 3TOT aOKyMeHT 3aMeHHJI Toraa CTapblfl JeCHOAi KOaeKCPC(DCP. Pa6oTa Haa npoeKTOM HOBoro JeCHoro KoaeKca Ha1aAacb B 1994 roay B nepyBYOoqepe,ab, AAA Toro 4TO6bI OTpa3HTb B iieCHOM 3aKOHoaaTenJbCTBe nohioKeHHS HOBOHiKOHCTHTYUUIH, rIpHHsTOfl B aeKa6pe 1993 roza. OAHaKo ,aaJbHeriwHe KpynfHble H3MeHeHHS BApyrHx cl3epax 3aKOHoaaTeAbHOrH CHCTeMb1 CTpaHbI (H3MeHeHHH B rpa)CiaHCKOM KO,eKce,HOBble npHpOLOOXpaHHbIe 3aKOHbl) H OTCYTCTBHe corJiacHA no apyrHmM OCHOBOrojnarafoLUHMnpaBOBblM BonpocaM (HanpHMep, HO BOnPOCY o co6CTBeHHOCTH Ha 3eMJHo) Bbi3BaBJH3Ha4HTeJbHyIO 3aaepxKy C npHH5THeM HOBOrO necHoro 3aKOHoRaTeJ1bcTBa. HO COCTOSHHHIOHa 10 aeKa6pq 1996 r., HOBblA 1ecHOr KoaeKC POCCHH ewe He 6bu1 nPHHS1T.]

B OCHOBax JiecHoro 3aKOHoaaTejibCTBa 1993 roza H B npOeKTe HOBOrO JleCHoroKo.eKca (cM. rpHjioXKeHHe B) nogqepKHBaeTCq opHeHTaU[H51 Ha HeHCTOLLHTeCJbHoefleconoib3OBaHHe H oxpaHy oKpyKaioweg cpeabi. CoriacHo CTaTbe 2 ripoeKTa JAecHoroKoAeKca (Hnoib 1996 roAa), necHoe 3aKOHoAaTeCJbCTBO HanpaB.TeHo Ha "o6ecneqeHHe

I OKOHqaTeCAbHbi, BapHaHT KoaeKca nPHHRT rocyaapcTBeHHoB J,yMon 22 SIHBaps 1997 roaa u BsCTynun BcHAy 4 4,cepaisi 1997 r. (npHMemaHHe peaaKTopa pyccKoro H3,aaHiR)

Page 56: Russian - World Bank Documents

38

paUHOHanbHOrO H HeHCTOLUHTeJIbHOrO HCnOAb3OBaHHA ieCoB, HX OXpaHy, 3aLUHTY H

BOCnPOH3BO,aCTBO, HCXOAS H3 nPHHUHnOB YCTOIPIHBOrO ynpaBJIeHH5l J eCaMH H COXpaHeHHSi

6HonorHweCKoro pa3HoO6pa3HH nieCHbIX 3KOCHCTeM, nOBbIweHH51 3KOnOrHIeCKOrO H

peCYPCHoro nOTeHUHania nIeCOB, yaOBJIeTBOpeHHHA nOTpe6HOCTeH o6weCTBa B n1eCHbIX

pecypcax Ha OCHOBe Hay4HO o6ocHoBaHHoro, MHoroUe.neBoro IieconoJIb3oBaHHs". Eoniee

Toro, qPeaepaflbHaq cnyx6a .necHoro XO3A9CTBa POCCHH onpeaenHeT OCHOBHYIO UeLlb

rocyAapCTBeHHbix nporpaMM Ha repHioa c 1994 no 1999 rr. KaK "ynpaBJIeHHe Jlecamu cLenlblO 3ailHTbI 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3Hq JieCHbIX 3KOCHCTeM, perynHpoBaHHA yrnepoaHoro 6loaxpeTa

H o6eCneMeHHS YCTOWIHBOrO pa3BKTHH ZieCHoro ceKTOpa 3KOHOMHKH" (LWy6HH, 1994).

XOTH BPeMeHHbie OCHOBbI iieCHorO 3aKOHOaaTeAbCTBa H COOTBeTCTBYIOT

CoBpeMeHHbIM Me)KAyHapOaHbIM COUHaJIbHbIM, 3KOHOMH'eCKHM H 3KoJIorHqeCKHM

KOHUenuHAM PaUHOHaWbHOrO H HeHCTOILHTeJIbHOrO OCBOeHHA JeCOB, OHH HeaOCTaTO4HO

KOHKPeTHbl B paMKax aAMHHHcTpaTHBHorO H 4DHHaHCOBoro ynpaBJIeHHR, a TaK)we OHH

HaaelAhIOT npaBOM pacnop5qKaTbCA .ieCHbIMH pecypcaMH CJIHUIKOM MHOrO 3aHHTepeCOBaHHbIX

CTOPOH 6e3 AOJDXHOCTHoro onpeaejieHHS cd)epbI MX OTBeTCTBeHHoCTH. CornacHo

KOHCTHTYU1H4, npHPOAHbie pecypcbl HaXOAATCA B COBMeCTHOM BeaeHHH 4eaepajibHbTX H

perHOHaSJbHbIX OpraHOB BJIaCTH. 3To nojio)KeHHue 0 COBMeCTHOM Bj!a,eHHH 6buio no-pa3HOMy

HHTepnpeTHPOBaHo nPHMeHHTenJbHO K rocyAaPCTBeHHOMY iieCHOMY ()OH,ay. 2 MHorHe U3

cy6¶beKTOB POCCHUCKOU 'DeaepauLnH (pecny6JlHKiK, KpaA H o6JTacTH) o6bAsBuIH ce6s

CO6CTBeHHMKaMH JIeCOB, HaXOA,LUHXCA Ha HX TePPHTOPHH, H nPHHSUI CBOH co6CTBeHHbIe

3aKOHbI. TaKHe OAHOCTOPOHHHe aeCCTBMR Bbl3Bai)H HanpH5KeHHOCTb MeCAy 4ieAepaj1bHbIMH H

perHOHanJbHbIMH OpraHaMH rOCyaapCTBeHHO0 BjiaCTH.

HOBblH JeCHOA KoaeKC, B BapHaHTe, HpHHITOM rocyaapCTBeHHOI RyMOR

(HHKHeH naniaTori napflaMeHTa) 5 MiojiS 1996 roaa, coIIep)KHT nojio)KeHHe, cornacHo

KOTOpOMY Bce neca rocyaapCTBeHHOrO niecHoro 4joHAa o6'bABMsunœcb XeaepanbHoA

co6CTBeHHOCTblO. O,HaKO CnyCTl aeCqTb AHeA COBeT cteaepaumi (BepXHAI nanaTa

napJaMeHTa, B COCTaB KOTOPOH BXOaqT PYKOBOAHTeiiH perHOHOB) OTKJIOHHJ] 3TOT

oao6peHHbIg )IYMOH npoeKT no npl14HHe ero HeCOOTBeTCTBHA KOHCTUTYUHH H

npHpOAOOXpaHHOMY 3aKOHoAaTeJbCTBY. JJa)IbHeHHUe KOHCYnbTauHH MexAY aBYM1 naIaTaMH

napnaMeHTa H nPaBHTenbCTBOM (B oKTq6pe-HoA6pe 1996 roAa), cornacHo HMeoLUoe4c

MH4)opMauHH, flPHBeJIH K CMAIrmeHHIO COOTBeTCTBYIOLUHX FOPMYAHPOBOK HOBOrO JeCHoro

KOAeKCa, OCTaBJIAS BO3MO)KHOCTb AAA cyLueCTBOBaHHA perHOHaJIbHoH co6CTBeHHOCTH Ha

.neca. TeM He MeHee, BpSA IJI OCHOBOFIOJiaraiOLUte BOnpOCbi CO6CTBeHHOCTH Ha 3eMJIO H

iieCHbie peCypCbI H CBA3aHHbie C 3THM o6SI3aHHOCTM no ynpaBneHIio 6yAyr peweHbI

AOJDcHbIM o6pa3OM A° TOrO, KaK BCTYll4T B aerUCTBHe COOTBeTCTBYIOLee 3eMefbHOe

3aKOHoLaTenbCTBO. (HOCJieC,HHe 13MeHeHHq B .IeCHOM 3aKOHO/aTeJlbCTBe POCCHH3 6o0ee

nO.apo6HO paCCMaTpHBaIOTCI B I1pHJIo)KeHHH B).

HecMOTp5 Ha TO, 'ITO 95% TeppHTOPHH JieCHbIX yrOaiiH POCCHU HaXOAHTCS B

BeAeHHH 4JeAepaJlbHoro nIpaBHTeJibCTBa, cor1iaCHO iieCHOMY 3aKOHoAaTeJibCTBy, npaBa H

2 rOCy4aPCTBeHHb/1, ACCHO0 4JOHa - 00HW1aA,bHbif pOCCIHCKHR TCpPMHH, 03Ha'alOW10K rOCyaapCTBCHHbJC

jecHCMe H HenIecHb.e 3eMAH, KOTOpblMlf yIp7iBTfqIOT Haa.JIeHHbIe COOTBCTCTBYIOUfHMH 170VIHOMOYHRMH OpraHbl

,7CCHOrO X03/lICTBa, B OCHOBHOM, 'C.epa,nbHa cffyx6a RecHoro xo3ickTBa. Okoao 60% o6we# TeppHTOPHfPOCCHM OTHOCHTCH K 3TOMY ePOHaY (60neCe 1o70po6Ho CM. f7pHlfoWeHHe A).3 f1CTOpUYCCKMI, o6 30p MCHOMo 3aKOHo4aRTVfbcTBa PoccHf c 1918 no 1993 rr., ocBeWaIorgu npo6AeMbf,

CBfl3.HHAfe c OCHOBaMH j1ccHoro 3aK0H0aaTenbcTBa 1993 ro4a, HpegacmaB.H TaKxe B: Sheingatiz, Nilsson and

Shvidenko, 1995.

Page 57: Russian - World Bank Documents

39

o6R3aHHOCTH no niecoynpaBjleHHIo nepeaaloTcs perHoHaM, BKAl0o4aq yCTaHoBAeHHe apeHAHbIXOTHOweHHU, pa3MeLueiHHe H onpeaejieHHe pa3MepOB nIecoceK H CTaBOK roCyRapCTBeHHbIXc6opoB. Ha cMeHy HbIHe cyweCTBYlOLueMy MeTOAY pa3MewleHHSl pecypcoB Ha OCHOBaHHHapeH,AHbIX ,OrOBOpOB Me)KIy co6CTBeHHHKaMH H nOJ1b3OBaTe.Ti5MH pecypca CpOKOM OT OLRHOrO

0 COpOKa aeBqTH JIeT, AOJDKHa nPHXTH HOBaS CHCTeMa apeHAbI. JleCHoe 3aKOHOaaTejbCTBOTaKiKe npef,ycMaTpHBaeT npoTaaxy neca Ha HaLUHOHaJbHbIX H Mex(AyHapOLHbIx ayKILHOHaX,rpOBOAHMb[X MeCTHbIMH aIMHHHCTpauLWSMH npH y4aCTHH $CeaepaJbHOA cAyK6bi niecHoroXO3Sl9CTBa. (IeaeparIbHaA cny)K6a niecHoro Xo3SACTBa AOJDKHa YCTaHOBHTb HOBYIO CHCTeMynHaTe)Kek 3a HcHoJIb3oBaHHe AeCHbIX pecypcoB, cornaaCoBaB ee C MHHHCTepCTBOM3KOHOMHKH POCCHH.

JecHoe 3aKOHOaaTeAbCTBO COaep)KHT Tpe6oBaHHe O BblReJieHHH onpeAej1eHHbIxTeppHTOpHf B HCKYlHOIHTeJIbHoe nOJIb3OBaHHe KOpeHHorO HaceJIeHH5, 4To6bl ynpaBnIAA3THMH 3eMJimiMH, KopeHHbIe )KHTeJIH MOrTH rpoaoniOKaTb BeCTH TpaaHUHOHHblg o6pa3 )KH3HH.Ho rOCKOJIbKY ,O CHX HOP HeT npaBOBOU OCHOBbl, KOTOpyIO aeriCTBHTeJTbHO MO)CHOpeanjH3OBaTb B TeX pagOHax, rae 3eMj1H H peCypcbl HMelOT 6o0ibwoe 3Ha'IeHHe aAs )KH3HHKopeHHOrO HaceJTeHHH, npoaoJnKaeTcs HCTOLLHTeJIbHas HpoMbIwiHeHHaS 3aroTOBKa nTeca.Onper,eneHHe H 3aWHTa npaB KOpeHHorO HaceiieHHI Ha 3eMJIIo H pecypcbI HMelOTKPHTH4eCKH Ba)KHOe 3Ha4eHHe 1nu paUHOHaTIbHOFO yHpaBJIeHHq .IeCHbIMH pecypcamHCH6HpH H aaJ]bHero BocToKa, 3Ty npo6&eMy HCo6Xoo4HMo pa3pelHHTb Ao HaqanaLUHpOKOMacuTa6Horo HHBeCTHpOBaHHq H OCBOeHHq nIeCOB. MeAAyHapoaHas opraHH3auLHATpy,aa (MOT), KOTOpaq npeaocTaBsIAeT POCCHUCKOU (DeaepauHM TeXHHLecCKyiO rOMOLLb 3Anpa3pa6OTKI 3aKOHoaaTeJIbCTBa Ho BOnpocaM KOpeHHorO HaceCeHH4A, o6naaaeTMe)KayHapO1aHbIM OnbITOM H HH1HopMaULHOHHO-TCXHHqeCKHMH B03MO)KHOCTAMH i3a15 rOMOULHB BblHOJ]HeHHH 3TOU 3a3aa4H.

Tpy4HoclH BIOJIHcHHff IPHpOa'OOxpaHHmx 06oV3aTefCJCTB

MeW,yHapOL1Hbie o6s3aTe.nbcTBa POCCHH no oxpaHe oKpy)KaIoLLuer cpeAbl(CnpaBKa 1.2) noMoralOT onpeae1J1HTb o61iyto OCHOBy iieCHOf nOAHTHKH cTpaHbl H 4UeJtH

iiecoyHpaBJeHHsI. Ho H3-3a HeonpeeleneHHoCTH B HauHOHajIbHOR HOJTHTHKe ynpaBjieHHsliiecaMH POCCHH B HacTosiiee BpeMS BO3HHKalOT TpyaHOCTH C BbIlOniHeHHeM 3THXo6z3aTeJbCTB.

Y MHPOBOrO coo6LuecTBa eCTb BeCKHe OCHOBaHH51 135 6ecnOKor4cTBa o 6yaylueMJieCHbIX pecypcoB POCCHH, 3anacbl KOTOpbIX Ho AIo6bIM MepKaM OrPOMHbI (Ta6nHiLa 1.1 HPHc. 1.2). HaBHcaeT yrpo3a 3KoJIorHqeCKOg xerpaaavuH 22% MHpOBOU iTAoLuaaH jnecoB,riOTepH yHHKaJ]bHblX 3KOCHCTeM H 1pyrHX THHOB 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3Hs H Hc4C3HOBeHHA KYJIbTypKOpeHHblX 3THHmeCKHX rpynn. POCCHACKHm 6opealbHble nieca, 3aHHMaiowHe r pHMepHoTaKylO Ke nJIOlUaab, KaK nieca 1jeHTpajibHoi H IO)KHOR AMepHKH, BMeCTe B3slTbie,COCTaBJwi,OT OKOJIO 60% Bcex 6opearIbHbIx iieCOB MHpa H 95% Bcex COMKHyTbix J1eCOBPOCCHH. 9TH .neca HrpalOT Ba)KHYIO POJlb B rAo6afibHoM 6a.naHce yrAepoaa, coriiacHooueHKaM, Ha HX ao.no np4HXOaXHTCA 75% HeTTO-3anacOB yrnepoaa BO Bcex 6opearIbHblX .necaxMHpa (Ta6rn4ua 1.2. H PHC. 1.2). B POCCHH HaXOaqTCA TaK)Ke TeppHTOpHH, KOTOpbieyHHKaJbHbI HO CBOeMy 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3Hlo H qBJ5TIOTC5 aOCTOSHHeM Bcero MHpa. B CBS3H C3THMH H JAPYFHMH KOMHiiCKCHblMH Hpo6JieMaMH, iecHasi nOJTHTHKa H AecHoe XO3,qriCTBOPOCCH4 HMelOT r.no6aibHoe 3HaqeHHe H 3acjyi4(HBa[OT HoaUePAKKH CO CTOpOHblMe)KAyHapO,4Horo coo6u1eCTBa.

Page 58: Russian - World Bank Documents

40

CnparKa 1.2: 06.l3aTenbCa POCCHH HO BblnOJIHeHHIO MexAyHapOAHbJX corJiawIeHHm no 1 eCHbliM pecypcaM

B Me)KayHapOaHbIX AHCKYCCUBX H CorJiaweHH$x no iiecHoMy Xo3RiCTBy npaBHTeJIbCTBO POCCuu

npeacTaBnJ1eT cDeAepaJibHas cAy)K6a .JecHoro xo3RIlcTBa. rIociie KOH9DepeHUHH OOH no oKpy,KaowueA cpeae H

pa3BHTIIO (UNCED) 1992 roaa PoccHB npUHHMaeT y'acTHe B XeCbCHHCKOM npouecce, MOHpeaJIbCKHX

ceMHHapax no paUHOHaOHbHOMY ynpaBJeHMIO necaMH yMepeHHOA H 6opeaJlbHoA 30H (1993 ron), 3aceAaHHsix

Me)KnpaBHTemcCTBeHHotA pa6o0eui rpynnbi no iiecam MHpa (1994 roA), CO3BaHHb1x KaHaaoA H ManaA3HeA;

BeAeT AmanorH B O0JHMnIHi no KPHTepfHqM H HHAHKaTopaM coxpaHeHHq H ynpaBJeHHR AeCaMH yMepeHHOAi H

6opeanlbHoS 30H (1994 roa), KpOMe Toro, oHa cTaJia OAHHM H3 CnOHCOpOB nptHHfTHS CaHTb5ircKoA AeKJiapaUHH

B paMKax MoHpea,nbcKoro npouecca B mapre 1995 ro,ia. npH 3aKhuo-eHHH Mez.AyHapoAHoro corAiaweHnq no

TpofnHqeCKO apeBeCHHe (snlBapb 1994 roaa) PoccHcKa.i 4OeaepaU9 cTania OAHOA H3 ABaAuaTUi qeTbipeX cTpaH-

noTpe6mTeAeA, KOTOPbIe o6sl3anJcb K 2000 roay nepeATH K pauLIHoHabHoMy H HeHcToIliHTeCJbHoMy

Hcnojib3oBaHHIO co6cTBeHHblx ilecOB. POCCHBI TaKIKe noanHcaJia U paTH(0HUHpoBaJia PaMoqHyIo KOHBeHUHIO no

MeHeHHlo KJnHMaTa H KOHBeHuHIO no coxpaHeHHro 6HoJuonrHecKoro pa3Hoo6pa3Hq. PoccHsl, KpoMe Toro,

HrpaeT 3Ha4HTeJlbHyIo POJib B pa60Te Me)KnpaBHTeJIbcTBeHHo0 rpynnbl cneuJHanHCToB no JiecaM, AelcTByIoue1i

B paMKax KOMHCCHH OOH no yCTotiqHBOMY pa3BHTHIo.

Ta6AHnia 1.1: lH oupA,zib necoB H 3anac ApeBecHHEJ B oTAejibHuX cTpaHaX, 1990 r.

CIpaHa 06li(H 4awfIf neco- 06Mf# 40oIft n 7pOm3Bw- 4afn B rJIO6/IbHNouiV1oiW444.b JIeCOB HIOKPM7 38va9i rJo6anfHoM CTBO I7pON CT5(%)|

(nH. in) Inoiwt AlpCeBWCMH 3Cane MpClCHNM B

Mpa (0%) (MfH. m3) ApeacnHHM 1989-91

(X) (Msw. liv')

POCCiUH 7646 22 82110 21 3756 II

Bpa3HJuiH 566 16 65088 17 262 8

KaHana 247 7 28671 7 179 5

CUWA 210 6 24730 6 508 15

KHTaB 134 4 9789 3 281 8

UH,aoHe3Hsi 116 3 19609 5 167 5

3aup 113 3 23108 6 39 I

CKaHAHHaBHR 53 2 4942 I 109 3

Bce ocTaJIbHb]e 1239 36 125979 33 1542 46

Becb MHP 3442 100 383726 100 3462 100

a UcKnio4an TponH'ecKHe nJIaHTauLiu.6 AaHHbte no TaKHM noKa3aTenAM, KaK InjoaaWH necoB H ofbeMbi nPOM3BOACTBa apeBeCHHbl, npHBeaeHHble B pa3BHqHbIx

HCTO'HHKaX, Moryr oTrjImHaxoTcR Apyr oT Apyra.

HcCTO0HmK: IpoAoBoJIbcTBeHHas H ceCbcKoxo3$IHcTBeHHa9 OpraaH3aUHR OOH ((0AO); HHCTUTYT M4pOBblX peCypCOB, 1994.

Page 59: Russian - World Bank Documents

PRC. 1.2: HeKOTOpbie XaPaKTHCTHKH COCTORHHU MHPOBblIX H POCCHRCKHXJieCOB B 1990-x rr.

a. MNpoBoe pacnpeaeAeRue nieCOnOKPbITOHl niowazwH B 90-x rr.

KaHazlaCWA 69 POCCHq

KHTag 6% 22%

HHaOHe3HA3%3aHp3% rpa3HuUlsH

npoMUe 16%38%

HcToiuiKN: 'DAO N HncTNTr MNpOBhX peCypCOB, 1994 r.

6. PacnpeienieHme rOAOnOrO 3anaca qHCTOrO yriiepOaa B 3KOC8CTeMaX 6opeaibHblX neCOB, 90-e rr.

KaHa,aa A315NCKa CKaHAHHaBHA

15% 2% 8%

75%

HcToqHnK: BemmaHH, 1995 r.

B. PacupeAejieHxe .iiecHofl nioioua,i 0o TeppnTopHH POCCrnH

,TQajibHHri CH6HpbBOCTOK 41%

37%

EBpon. q,

POcCHH

22%

Hci'o'UmKn: cDeJAepajIhHaa cJywK6a jiecHoro XO3C, 1996 r.

Page 60: Russian - World Bank Documents

42

Ta6AHIlsa 1.2: OLueHca 3anaca cBq3aHHoro yriiepoARa B 6opeaJbiblX AeCHbIx 3KOCHCTeMaX

(MuIH. TOHH yriiepo,Aza B roiA)

PeC fOH J1ecHue 3KocHcremw BOAIOTa | ARePBCcHe npiyxru | B LcJom

KOaifNecTCio KOJAH- X KOJI- KOJIII-

q7ecmBo qecTBO qecCTo

ATiRcKa 6 1 3 6 < I < I 9 2

KaHa.aa 63 10 26 57 19 33 108 15

Poccusn 493 82 II 24 26 46 530 75

CKaH11HaBUiR 43 7 6 13 12 21 60 8

Bcero 605 100 45 100 57 100 707 100

HCTO'i4HK: Bemmann, 1995.

OIpaH,HvcHHaHl ,aoCTy7lHOCTh H ocffa6fIeHHoc cocTIHMCe JIecHb xpecycoB

OKono 78% U3 764 MJIH. ra noKpblTbIX JIecoM 3eMenjb POCCHH HaXOaHTCS B

CHu6pu (318 MJIH. ra) H Ha )aabHeM BocToKe (279 MJIH. ra), OCTaJbHbie 22% (167 MJIH. ra)

- B EBponeAcKok 'aCTH POCCuH 4 (CM. PHC. 1.2). BOJIbWlHCTBO niecoB, npOl43paCTailLUHX K

BOCTOKy OT Ypa.na, KiiaccmPK1HUHPyIOTCS KaK Takra (6opeaibHble nieca, B COCTaB KOTOpblX

BXOAST B OCHOBHOM XBOriHbie BHtbl), KOTopaJq B Bo3paCTe cnenJOCTH AaeT OT 50 Ky6HtMeCKHX

MeTPOB apeBecHHbl c reKTapa Ha ceBepe, ao 200-250 Ky6wIecKHx MeTPOB c reKTapa Ha fore

Tae)KHOA 3OHbl. npHTyHTapoBbie neca (noaTmn Tae)KHb1X n1eCOB B nepeXoaHOA 3OHe MeC)ay

OTKpblTOU TYHAPOU H U pyrU4M4 Tae)KHb1MH necaMH) o6jlaaaloT HU3KHM rOTCHHuim1oM iAS

npOMbIUwIeHHOrO HPOH3BOACTBa apeBecHHbI. B,Jonb IO)KHblX rpaHH1U Cu6upu U LaajbHero

BocToKa BCTpeqalOTCq TaK)Ce WlHPOKOJIHCTBeHHbie iieca yMepeHHoro nosca. (floapo6Hble

xapaKTepHCTHKH 3THX THrOB nieca npe2CTaBJ1eHbl B npHJInKeHHH A; CM. TaK;Ke KapTy IBRD

27086R).

npu oueHKe 3KOHOMiMeCKOrO nOTeHiutanJa ACcHbIX pecypcoB POCCuH Ba)KHO

YqHTb1BaTb HX B03paCTHY1O CTPYKTYPY H BHIOBOH COCTaB. B 1993 roay 85% o6uieg

fleCOnOKpbITOA4 nnoulaaH B CH6upu H Ha aJ,¶bHeM BocToKe (K Ao 95% - B EBponer4cKori

'aCTH PoccHH) 6buLo 3aHSTO COMKHYTblMH eCTeCTBeHHb1MH apeBOCTO51MH H BTOpU44HbIMH

iiecaMH pa3Hb1X BO3paCTHbIX rpynn (P4c. 1.3). EcTecTBeHHbie (cnenble H nepeCTOikHble) neca

cocTaBnJI5OT 50% OT Bcex COMKHyTb1X ApeBOcToeB B Cu6upu U Ha )janbHeM BOCTOKe U 39% -

B EBponeicKoAi qaCTH PoccHu (Ta6.nHua 1.3). K apyriHM KaTeropuHM JieCHbIX 3eMenJb

4 17o OLcHKaM nwoLuawH ACCOnOKphiTOR TeppCTOpHH COCTaBJIOT OT 735 ao 770 M7H. ra, nlpu 3TOM 7296

9TOk IVoLULH 3aHmThi nota XBOHbliMf mecaMH. 06waq mqowatab cywf PocCff COCToazBAcT 1707,5 MIH. ra. To

ecTb, 45% o6feki iVoL(aaa TeppTfTopffM PoccmH ioKpbiTo jecoM. l7o oL(CHKaM, cpCIHHiA 3anac neca Ha KOpH1O

paBeH 106 M3 /ra. ,Zoi7oqHHTeJbHypo HHlpOpMaL(HIO 0 O aiHaMiKe H mcnmoIb3oBaHHm pOCCffiCKm1X JleCHbJX pecypcoB

MoxHO iIoJIyqHTb u13 pa6oT.: Strakhov auid Pisaren7ko (1996) H Isayev, peai. (1991); no0 cOL1aAbHO-3KOHOMHqecKOI1

oLieHKe 6opeambHbix .eCOB - Pisarenko an7d Strakhov (1996) H Ho nepmCeKTHBaM npo3BQiocTBa, norpe6qeHRnif H

3Kcaopra - Backmian (1996).

Page 61: Russian - World Bank Documents

Puc. 1.3: PacnpeAeeneHHe nnoui H JieCHbIX 3eMenih B POCCHH no perHoHaM H KaTeropHqM, 1993 r.

a. Pacnpe,eerRenHe o6meA niomiazH JIeCHhX 3eMenii no KaTeropHxm

HecoMKHyBlUHecsl He nOKpblTbTe JiecoMHacazKaeHHu H peeHHbl 3eMjiH

6% 7%

noKphlTble JieCOM 3eMnH87%

6. PacnpeeieeniNe nujoiuaiA .uecHrx 3eMeiE no pernoiaM H KaTerOpKflM

250 .

200 * HnOKpiimie .iecoM200 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~3emnuH

~~~~~150 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~0 HeCOMKHYBLUHecC

HacaKAeHHMR H100

peaUHHbi

_ He InOKphiTbhe50 JICCOM 3eMAH

0

EBponei- 3anannHaA BocToqHas TaJ1bHHiCKO- CH6Hpb CH6mpb BocToK

YpallbcKaa3oHa

HCTOqnHK: .JlecHofl (ona PoccNH, 1993 r.

Page 62: Russian - World Bank Documents

; *~~ *; *

-~~ 3 * 5 3x tAXg

oi2= ( °C !

i=3 4@ !0

o

1g= S- I~~

Page 63: Russian - World Bank Documents

45

OTHOCATCS: nHjouaauH, 3aHATbie HeCOMKHYBWIIHMHCR HaCa)KeHHAMH, BKJliOqa5i MOJO,LbieKyJIbTypbl H nHTOMHHKH (2% OT o6weH nAoLuaauH AeCHbIX 3eMenJb B EBponericKori 'aCTHPoccuu H 0,2% - B A3HaTCKOA taCTH), eCTeCTBeHHbie pe,flHHbl (OHU HaXOAA1TCA TOJlbKO BA3HaTCKOr4 'aCTH PoccuH H cocTaBJAIOT 6onee 10% o6iueri njioLuaaH nIeCHbIX 3eMeJb,LanbHero BocToKa), He noKpblTbie AecoM JeCHbIe 3eMJnH, BKnIoxiaq rapu H CyXoCTOH,BbIpy6K4,H nporanIHHbl H nyCTbIPH (3% - B EBponetcKori 4aCTH H 6onee 8% - B A3HaTCKOrtIaCTH PoccHH). KaTeropHH 3eMenJb nieCHoro bOHaa POD nOKa3aHbI Ha PHC. 1.4.

Ta6niuia 1.3: Pacnpe,eAeHHe nIeCHbrX 3eMenb POCCHH nO perHOHaM H KaTer¶OpHUM3eMenb, 1993 rOqA (MIIH. ra)

Peniof PoccH 0611O ) 1no- COMxHYrUC HCCOMKHY- EC7wTC1I-lii4b ifecmwx Hacam(eb Tue Hue

XMenb HmacBxAeiHH peCaHM JlHbcue sMJ 63 JIcHorO nOKpODa

Bcervo n7Ofl- Biup)y6 f7poiaB 1993 Lume -KMB 8 iXhfu/

r. HacaX- 1988 r. nycru-4CHHMJ B pH B1988 r. 1988 r.

EBpona/YpaJi 139,1 132,3 2,7 0,0 4.0 0,2 3,2 0,43anaamHa CUi6Hpb 78,4 73,9 0,4 I,I 3,1 1,0 0,9 0,4

BOCTo0HaS1 CH6Hpb 224,8 200,6 0,4 3,3 20,4 8,9 1,8 0,9JawbHHA BOCTOK 312,9 248,2 0,3 37,0 27,4 16,4 2,5 2,5

Bker,o 755,2 655,0 3,8 41,4 54,9 26,5 8,4 4,2

npiMearie: OTHOCHTCHl TOJlbKO K 3eMJiqM necHoro q&oHHa, HaXoQW1WHMCS1 B BeJ4eHHH Oeaepa)1bHOA c.nyK6bi iecHoroXo3sIAcTBa H ACconpombiLwieHHbtx npeanpmsiTluu. B 1988 roay ewue 94,4 MJIH. ra JlecHbix 3eMejnb ('nO cocTaBJlaeT OKOJIO 10,9%oT o6uleH n.notua.a1), Haxowa4ocb B BeCieHHu Apyrux Cy6beKTOB (FeaepaJ1bHbie BeaoMCTBa ti ceJlbCKOX03R4CTBeHHblenpeanpHRTHA).

UrCTOYHUK: JIecHOri qOHZ POCCHtCKOH dPeaepauHt, 1995.

OCHOBHblMH XBOIHb-IMH nopoaaMH B 3THX niecax SBJTHIOTCS COCHa (HecKonbKo BH,1OB),IHCTBeHHHua, enJb H nHxTa. CpeauH nuHCTBeHHbIX npeo6.naaaloT 6epe3a H OCHHa. 9TH BH4,Ibl

npOH3paCTaIOT KaK B Cu6upH, TaK H Ha AJajlbHeM BOCTOKe, XOTA UX paclpOCTpaHeHUe HCOCTaB JieCOB 3aBHCHT OT yCJIOBHr4 (CM. CripaBKy 1.3). '-To6bi o6ecneqHTb aneKBaTHyioPenPe3eHTaTHBHOCTb 6Mopa3Hoo6pa3MsI H 3aLUHTy XpynKHX yMaCTKOB CPelb1 B paMKaxrpIpo,aooxpaHHbix nHIaHOB, a TaKie 4To6bI HMeTb opmeHTHlpbl Jn5I HHBeCTMPOBaHH51 HnepeCTPOIKH B rpOMbIwAeHHOcT4, Heo6xoaHMo KaK MO)KHO 6o0ee CpO4HO YTO4HHTbnpHpoJy, pacrpOcTpaHeHHe, KaqeCTBO H COCTOAIHHe neCHblX pecypcoB POCCH4. HpaBHnbHbiepacMeTbl H TOqHble aaHHble TaKwe HMelOT cyLUeCTBeHHoe 3HMa4Hme npH rLaHHHOBaHHH HKOHTpOJIe npOMbljwJeHHOr4 aesTeAbHOCTH, OUCHKH 43aKTHMeCKoro noTeHuHazJa nTeCOB HHeHCToLLIHTeJibHoro YPOBH51 py6KH nieca.

Aeca BAAlIOTCH aHHaMH4eCKHMH 6HOjiOri4qeCKHMM CHCTeMaMH. TaKXCe M3BeCTHO,MTO Ha nleCHbie PCcYPCbl BJISHIOT KaK nPHPO,HbIe, TaK H aHTPOnOreHHble 4baKTOPbI. KpoMecnflJowHblx py6oK, KOTOpbIe c 1987 no 1993 rr. HPOBOal4Al4Cb B cpeaHeM Ha mnowaaiH860.000 ra B roL, orpoMHblg YPOH POCCHUACKHM JIecaM, oco6eHHo B CHM6HPH H4 Ha),aJbHeM

Page 64: Russian - World Bank Documents

46

CnpaBKa 1.3: KpaCHOSiPCKHA m Xa6apoBcKHI Kpaw: KaprHHa pa3Hoo6pa3HsI

)JJHE BbSlCHeHMR psAa BonpocoB perHoHMabHoro pa3Hoo6pa3I4sI B Ka4eCTBe penpe3eHTaTIBHbIX

TeppHTOpHA CH6HpH H )lajibHero BOCTOKa Hcnojwb3oBam, cooTBeTCTBeHHo, KpacHoqpcKHi H Xa6apoBcKiH4

Kpas. B Xa6apOBCKOM Kpae AOMHHHpyiO1' TaKHe KnHMaKCHble BN, KaK enJb H JIHcTBeHHtiua, a B KpaCH0ipCKOM

Kpae 6onee pa3H0o6pa3HbIA BHAOBOA cocTaB, BKnlioqlioWHi cocHy, enb, ntixTy, 6epe3y 1H OcUHy. OTHoCHTeflbHo

BbICOKa5S AoiS nHOHepHbIX BHAOB (6epe3bu H OCHHbI) B KpacHoslpcKoM Kpae bSIBjqeTcCS npSMbiM cneaCTBHeM

HH3KOrO YPOBHA BocnpOM3BOACTBa PeCYPCOB nocn1e nITHaCTH nieT HHTeHCHBHoA necO3KcnnyaTaUHH. B

KpacHo.qpcKoM Kpae cpeHHIA BO3pacT JiecoB - 104 roaa, B Xa6apoBcKoM - 82 roaa. Ho 6o0Jbwas qacTb cnenioro

iieca HaXOaHTCS B KpaAHe oTAaneHHblX paAioHax, KoTopbie, BepOsTHo, HHKoraa tie CTaHyT 3KOHOMH4eCKH

AOCTYnHbIMH HunH OCTaHyTCq 3aKpblTb]MH AnIS 3aroToBKH ApeBeCHHbl no 3KoJIorFHeCKHM npHtH4HaM. CpeaH

.lerKo aocTynHblX JiecoB yBeJIHMHBaeTCh ROJSI MOJIOAHS1KOB, paCTyLUMx p5lAOM c npoMbiwJJeHHb]MH

KoMnfieKcaMH, BLaOJb peK, )KeJie3HbIX Aopor H aBToAopor, HO 6ojbWUHHCTBO H3 HHX aoCTuHHyr BO3pacTa py6KH

TOJbKO iepe3 HeCKOJIbKO aeCSTHJ1eTrHI.

BocToKe, HaHOCRT noxKapbl, HaceKoMble, 6one3HH u 3arpq3HeHHe cpeAbi. Ho 04IHUHajibHbIM

AaHHb1M, B nepHoa C 1984 no 1992 rr. 3TH 4)aKTOpbl Bbl3bIBaJIH nOBpeK,aeHH4g jleCOB Ha

ImoIua,a,H B cpeAHeM 1,6 MnH. ra B roa. HeoHlHuHaJIbHbie oueHKH roBOPAT 0 ropa3,to 6o0ee

BbICOKOM YPOBHe noBpeKLeHHl, Bbl3blBaeMbix pa3j1HMHbIMH4 pa3pyUHTenJbHbIMH 4DaKTopaMH,

T.e. o 2 MJIH. ra B roa (IIASA, 1995). HO HeKOTOPbIM oLueHKaM COBOKynHblu 3c"eKT

noBpexfeHHri Ha ceroaHS paBeH 26,5 MJIH. ra norH6uHx iieCOB B POCCHH, npH'eM 99% H3

HHX npHXOAHTC5 Ha CH6Hpb H )aJIbHHiE BOCTOK (Krankina and Dixon, 1994). Bonee

noapo6Hoe OnHcaHC e 3TOrO yuxep6a npHBeaeHO B npHJioKeHHH A (CM. TaK)Ke Ta6niHuy 1.3

H PHC. 1.7 HHuKc B 3TOM pa3,aeale).

HoiKapbl H BpeaHTeiiH MOryT HaHOCHTb 3HaM4TenbHbll 3KOHOMKIeCKH4r ywep6,

pa3pyulaH KaK 3KOHOMHMecKyio 6a3y OTaeSJbHbIX HaCeiJeHHbIX nyHKTOB, TaK H CaMH

HaceneHHbie nyHKTbI. He MeHee cepbe3HoA qBjnqeTcq AerpaAaui4l cpeabI, yTpaTa MeCT

o6HTaHH51 AHKHX )KHBOTHbIX H naAeHHe YPOBHS 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3Hs, KOTOpbie CTOSIT 3a

ymuep6oM TaKoro MacLwTa6a. HanpiMep, BCnbilwKa maccoBoro pa3MHO)KeHHIN CH6HpCKoro

wenKonp.q,Ia (Dendrolimus sibiricus) B BOCTOMHOUi Cu6HpH (1994 - 1996 rr.) Bbl3BanJa

KaTaCTpowUHeCKHe noTepH: nopaxeHO, KaK MHHHMYM, 700.000 ra ueHHbIX XBOUHbIX

AeCOHacaKLeHHi, BKAio4afl 300.000 ra yiKe norH6aloIuHx aepeBbeB (oKono 40-50 MJIH.

Ky6oMeTpoB 3anaca neca Ha KOpHIO). 3ToT o6weM B 3,3 pa3a npeBblwaeT pacqeTHyIo

.necoceKy KpacHoqlpcKoro Kpafl H B 17 pa3 - 4aKTHqeCKHe o6ibeMbl 3arOTOBKH apeBeCHHbl

XBOtIHbIX BHaOB B Kpae B 1994 roay.

PoccHIcKoe npaBHTenjbCTBO o6paTHJIoCb BO BceMHpHbIi 6aHK c npoCb6or4 o6

oKa3aHHH CpOiHOr noMOiUH 4teaepaIbHoA cj1yK6e necHoro XO3.qrfCTBa u KpaeBoi

aRMHHHCTpaUHH B peaJIH3aUH nepBou 43a3b1 qpe3ablbqariHOr4 npOrpaMMbI HHTerpHPOBaHHOl4

6opb6bl c CU6HpCKHM UwenfKonpf1oM B necax KpacHo5ipcKoro KpaI B 1996/1997 rr. B OTBeT

Ha 3Ty npOCb6y H3 4OHaa npoeKTa no ynpaBneHHIo oKpyxKaioluei cpeaorl (FIYOC) J1eTOM

1996 roEa 6buLo BbIleJIeHO oKoJIo 5 MJIH. JOfjijapOB CLUA Ha 4UiHaHCHpoBaHHe 3aKYnKU

3KoJIoruHeCKH 6e3onacHoro 6HonpenapaTa H o6opy,4OBaHHI AflAR ero 344eKTHBHoro

npUMeHeHHl, a TaK)Ke npoBeaeHHRl 3KoJorH4ecKog OueHKH 344eKTHBHoCTH npHHlTbIX mep

H neCO3HTOMOnOrHqeCKorO MOHHTOPHHra. nHop5vKa 3 MuH. aOnjiapOB CWIA MOryT 6blTb

1OonOJIHHTenbHO BbileJleHbI KpacHoqlpcKoMy KpalO B Ka'eCTBe KpeILH4Ta POCCHUUCKOUA

nporpaMMbI OpraHH3auLi* KHBeCT1HLUK B o3TLopoBjieH4e oKpy)KaioiueA CpeabI (PHOII),

Page 65: Russian - World Bank Documents

47

aeACTBYIOuer B paMKax [lpoeKTa no ynpaEBeHHIo oKpy)Katoineg cpe,aog, Ans UIOMOLUH B4HHaHCHpOBaHHH npOBeaeHH1 caiHuTapHbIx py6oK H 3arOTOBKH noBpex.eHHoro Aeca.

qpeMCepHbIk YPOBCHb 4o6bm-i 1HKHX BO0THM,X pm6m apyrWX HCaXpBCCHMX JTeCHMXJXCYPCOB

OKOJIO 190.000 KOpeHHbIX )KHTeneri PoccHH LtenjiKOM 3aBHCqT OT JieCOB(xapeBecHbIx H HeapeBeCHbIx npO4yKTOB) =q noJyIeH HA cpeaCTB K cyLUeCTBOBaHHIO, a TaKiKeCOXpaHeHHA KyJIbTypHbIX H o61.eCTBeHHO-yKiiaAHbIX TpaatiUHfl. HeapeBeCHble .JecHbienpOayKTbIbl AAS MHorHx pOCCHHH ripeacTaBJTAIOT 3Hal4TenJbHyIO 3KOHOMHqecKyio HCOLIHanJbHYIO ueHHOCTb, a KOpeHHOMY HaCeJieHI10 OHH qaCTO HeO6XOaHMbi =An coxpaHeHHATpa,aHUHOHHOR CBq3H C JecaMH. Pbl6a H OXOTOHpOMbICJOBbIe )KHBOTHbie ABJIASOTCS UeHHbIMKCTOqHKKOM MAca H MeXOB IAn yoROBAeTBOpeHHq 6blTOBblX noTpe6HOCTeH, a HXKoMMepqeCKaS peanjH3auHS npHHOCHT HaceneHI4o cy1leCTBeHHb1e aOHOJIHHTenfbHble faOXOabl.JIerajIbHaA OXOTa npH onpeHenieHHbIX KBoTax pa3peuweHa npHMepHO Ha ceMbLeC5T BHUOB)KHBOTHbIX, HO ynpaEjleHHe, KOHTPOJIb H co6AloAeHHe npasBHJ OXOTbl H pbl6HOU JIOBJIHCepbe3HO yXyaUHJIHCb, qTO 3aqaCTylO nO3BOJAReT 3JloynoTpe6iAsTb ao6bi4er 3TUX peCypCOB. BCBA3H C naaeHHeM YPOBHA onHJaTbl TpyLa H 3aHATOCTH B iieCHOA, ropHoao6blBaloHueg HHebTera3OBOA npOMbIljieHHOCTH Haqa] Ha6nloaaTbCs nepexoa K CJIHU4KOM BbICOKOMYYpOBHIO ao6bI'qH peCypCOB aHKHX )KHBOTHbIX CO CTOpOHbI pa6OTHHKOB 3TUX OTpaCJIeU,BpeMeHHO rIPO)KHBaiOHLJHX Ha aaHHbIX TeppHTOpHAX, 'TO B CBOIO oqepeab, nPsBeJIO KyCHJneHHIO KOHKypeHLLHH C KOpeHHbIMH )K4TeASiMH, )K43Hb H 6flaronoJIyqi4e KOTOpbIXHenOCpe,aCTBeHHO 3aBHCHT OT Aeca H HeApeBeCHbIX ieCHblx peCypCOB.

,Lpyr4e He,apeBeCHbie JeCHbIe pecypcbl TaK1(e BHOCRT cyLueCTBeHHbl BKJiaa BpOCCHACKyIO 3KOHOMHKy. E)KeroaHo ,A1 H nQHHoro noTpe6JieHHs H Ha npoIa)Ky3arOTaBJIHBalOT H nepepa6aTblBalOT OT 5 ao 7 MJIH. TOHH HeapeBeCHbIX AeCHbIX npOayKTOBTaKHX, KaK nHJOabl uH ArObl, opexH, rpH6bI, Me2 H BceBO3MO)KHbIe .TeKapCTBeHHble TpaBbl HMaTepuanbl. KpHTH4eCKoe 3Ha4eHHe AAA 3TomO BHaa nOJIb3OBaHH14 HMeeT COCTOAHHe JTeCOB.(JionoAHHTeAbHas 4HH4opMaULH o6 HCnOJ1b3OBaHHH HeapeBeCHbIX npO14yKTOB COaep)KHTCq BI pHuoKeHHxx A H X). H3-3a HeaoCTaToqHoro 4 HHaHC4poBaHHA npoaorniaeTcspa3pylueHHe HeKOraa BeCbMa COBepweHHOU H CJIO)KHOA CiCTeMbi HHBeHTapH3auLmH H c6opaflaHHbIX. (bo.nee noapo6Hoe oniicafHfe ynpasBeHH5 pecypcami aHKHX AKHBOTHbIX BKOHTeKCTC HCHCTOIUHTenAbHoro OCBOeHH niecOBs aHO B HlpHJIoKeHH4 14).

Pecypcbl ,aHKHX )KHBOTHbIX, HX oxpaHa H paOHanbHoe HcroJIb3OBaHHe, BKJIIO4aqYCTaHoBJeHHe OXOTOrpOMb1CJIOBbIX KBOT, nOanaaalOT nOn IoPHC,IIHKgHIO HeaaBHO co3aaHHOrOFocy,aapcTBeHHOrO KOMHTeTa P(E) no oxpaHe oKpy)KaioLuer cpeRbi (ao aBrycTa 1996 roLba-MHHHCTepCTBO OXpaHbl OKpyKaioubeu Cpeabl H HP4POAHbIX pecypcoB 5 ) H aerapTameHTa nooxpaHe H paLUOHa&JbHOMY Hcnojib3OBaHHIO OXOTHHqbHX pecypCOB MHHHCTepCTBa ceCJbCKoroX03SWICTBa H nlpOOBOJIbCTBHSA. Pbi6Hbje peCypCbl (UX perysi]poBaH4e H KOHTPOJTb 3aHCnOJlb3oBaHHeM) HaXOASTCS B BeaeHH4 rocynapCTBeHHorO KOMHTeTa P$P nO pbi6oJIOBCTBy.HenpoMblCJloBble BHabl 3aKOHOM He OXpaHRIOTCq, H OCTaeTCR He SCHbIM, HaXOaqTCq JIH Bce

5 B pe3yabraTe Ho3MmHeHH CTpyKT7ypb/ apaBfTecbCTb B aBrycTe 1996 roaa 6bIrnuee MHHfcTepcTBo OxpaHbloKpyKaI0wieH Cpewab if HpfpowHbIX pecypcoB 6bllo peOpraHH3oBaHo H Ha ero 6a3e Co3TaaHbI aB HoBbIx/)eaepallbHbIX BeaoMcTBa: JocyaapcTreHHm,# KOMHTT 110 oxpaHe oKpyxaIoLueA cpeabl H MHHHCTepCTBOI1papoa'Hbix pecypcoB. Ho COCTOJIHHIf 4Ce. Ha OKTfl6pb 1996 roaa, pacipaewmmeHHC qyHK1lif# MeAKhy 39TMHf 7aByMBearomcMTBam He 6hwo eCue oKo0YHTCRbHo o6zmArHo.

Page 66: Russian - World Bank Documents

48

HenpOMblCJIoBbIe BMAb (Knliuo'asi 250 BHL4OB )KHBOTHbIX H 500 BHaOB paCTeHHi4, 3aHeceHHbIX

B KpaCHyIO KHHry) no110 lCpHCA4HKU4He BHOBb co311aHHOro [ocyaapcTBeHHoro KoMHTeTa P()

no oxpaHe oKpyKaioiuer CpeRbl. PoccHt1cKoe 3aKOHoaaTeAbCTBo nO OXOTe He ycneBaeT

OTpa)KaTb B CTpyKType UeH Ha Jn1ueH3HH H apeHRHbie AorOBopbl Te paaHKaJIbHbie nepemeHbi

B CTpaHe, KOTOpbIe npHBeiiH K yBejiHm4eHHIO Harpy3KH Ha HenpoMbICflOBbie BHRbl )KHBOTHbIX,

H3MeHeHHu B CHCTeMe IOJIHOMOMH9 no ynpaBneHuIlo pecypcaMH H coxpaHeHuliO

6Hopa3Hoo6pa3HI, nepeMeHbl, CBq3aHHbie C nfpHBaTH3aLWeri roCyyaapCTBeHHOrl

co6CTBeHHOCTH, a TaioKe B nOJIHOH mepe KoppeKTHpOBaTb HeraTHBHblC npoueccbi,

o6ycAoBneHHbIe pa3pylueHHem CyUieCTBYIOll1HX paHee CTpyKTyp ynpaEneHsI Ha

perHOHanbHOM ypOBHe.

Ocxa&iemie HomeHL(raja JiecHoI HmaKH

Laonrue ro1bl HayqHb1i noTeHuHa1n PoccuH pa3BH4BJaCSC Ha 6a3e MHoroqHcJieHHbIX

HayqHO-HCCne1eAOBaTeAbCKHX H TeXHH4eCKHX HHCTH1yTOB, KoTOpbIe nOqTH nOHOHOCTblO

4)HHaHCHpOBnUJHCb 3a c4eT OTq4cAeHH4i H3 4eaepanbHoro 61oaxeTa (CM. UIpHJIoKeHHe r, HKapTy IBRD 28354). Ho B nociieaHHe rOAbl B CB1R34 C CHnbHOA HeXBaTKOrH Cpe11CTB y

4)eAepanibHoro npaBHTenJbCTBa q)HHaHCHpoBaHHe pe3KO coKpaTHJIoCb, a KOJ1H4eCTBO JneCHbIX

HCcc3ieCaoBaTeJIbcKHx HHCTHTYTOB 3Ha'HTeSJbHO yMeHbWIH4JOCb. nOCKOJIbKy 610iDeTHbie

aCCHrHOBaHHH COXpaHHBUHMC$1 HHCTHTyTaM ceHi'ac COCTaBJqIlOT meHee 25% OT ypOBHeA 1o

1991 roAa, CTaHOBHTCI Bce TpyAHee yaep)KHBaTb yqeHbIX H cneuHiLaJiCTOB (CnpaBKa 1.4).

B neploa, Koraa OqeHb Ba)KHO nojiy4aTb KOHKpeTHYIO HHbopMaUHio no JIeCHblM

pecypcaM, CTOJIb 6OJTbWUie nOTepH Hay'HbIX KaJPOB H coKpaLueHHe o6'beMOB pa6oT

Bbl3blBalOT cepbe3HY1O o3a6oqeHHoCTb. B TO )Ke BpeM5l, Ba)KHbIMH npo6AeMaMH B JieCHOA

HayKe SIBIISIIOTCH OTCYTCTBHe uejieBoH op4eHTaui4H, HeonpeaeJIeHHOCTb npHOP1TeTOB H

cna6as KOOPa14HauiHSI HCCcjeaOBaHH4. Heo6xoatlMa TaKlKe TO4Haq H Hc4epnbIBaloHUaq

HH¢opMaLUH no COCTOAHHIO H paCnpocTpaHeHHIO JieCHbIX peCypCOB. ;IHS paCwipeHHR

nlAOllUaa4 CHCTeMbi npHpOAHbIX 3anOBeAHHKOB H Ha,Ae)KHOA 3aLuHTbl 3Konort4HMeCKH

YR3BHMbIX neCoB Tpe6yeTCS alHajiH3 Bceri COBOKYnHOCTH npo6neM, HMeioLIU1XCA B J1eCHOA

oTpaCJIH. KpoMe Toro, Hy)KHO o6ecne4HTb 6o0ee qleTKoe onpeeneneHHe MeCTHbIX KPHTepHeB

HeHCTOIUHTeAbHOCTH, KOTOpOe noMorJIo 6bl YCTaHOBHTb napaMeTpbl JiecopecypcHofl 6a3bl,

npHroAHori xLi5 paUHOHajIbHoro H 3KOHOMHMecKi4 K43Hecnoco6Horo rpOMbmbiwIeHHoro

nOJIb3OBaHHRA.

CnpaBKa 1.4: KorAa ocna6esaeT noflHu,HaJI iiecHoSl HayKH

OTcyrcTBHe cpeaCTB H pacnaa CTpyKTypbi 4MHHaHCOBO11 nHOAapLKKH CTaBqT noa yrpO3y npoaojiKeHtHe

15-neTHeA pa6oTU no c6opy KamecTBeHiibix 3KOJ]orFqeCKHX H 6HojiorFqecKHX HCXOaHbIX aaHHbix no BceM

OCHOBHbIM BHaaM npOMbIcJIOBbIX, a TaK)Ke peAKHX 14 HC4e3aioiuX BKROB ICHBOTHbIX B KpacHosipcKoM Kpae.

CHCTeMaTHqeCKHM c6opoM 3THX aaHHbIX 3BHmMBJThCb aBaAUaTb BbICOKOKBanIH41MuHpOBaHHbIX onbiTIibIx

cnelUHanHcToB HHCTH'yTa iieca UM. B.H. CyKaqeBa. 143-3a He.EOcTaTOx]HOrO 4MHHaHCHpOBaHHS, o6cjieaoBaHnH

ce$iac nlpOBOLRTCq B OCHOBHOM Ha 3eMjlsX, npeaHa3HaqeHHbIX ann cAatBH B apeHiay, a OCTajibHbie nniOluauh

HrHopHpyIO'Cs. Pe3y.nbTaToM npeKpalUeHIu pa6oT 6yAeT HapyweHuie uenOCTHOCTH 6a3b] PaHHUHX. BeayuLee

3BeHO y4eHbix 3Toro HHCTHTyTra Ha nOJIHylO CTaBKY pa6oTaeT B CH6HPCKOA TeXHonorHqecKo1i aKaaeMHH,

OAHoBpeMeHHo nbITaqCb npoaojDKaTb Ham6onee Ba)KHyIO pa6oTy no M3yqeHMlO H yqeTy pecypcoB AUKHX

IKHBOTHbUX AIM MeCTHOrO ynpaBJIeHHul OXOTHUqbHM XO3SJqCTBOM Ha JOrOBOpHOtU OCHOBe BO BHeypO'LHoe BpeMs.

Page 67: Russian - World Bank Documents

49

li. 9KonormecKoe 3HaqeHHe JieCHoro ceKTopa

Pa3Mep nnowarui necoB CH6HpH H ,aaAbHero BocToKa Ui pa3Hoo6pa3He HXpaCTHTeAbHOrO H )KHBOTHOrO MHpa H yCCJIOBH4 Cpe,4b[ aeialOT 3TH Jleca cpeaoo6pa3yloLu4M4aKTopoM, HMeiomLiM KojioccanJbHoe 3HaqeHHe AAA POCCuu H Bcero MHpa. Cepbe3Herl4wyloyrpO3y AA5 YHHKaJbHoro 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3HSI nIeCOB npeacTaBJI5eT pa3pyuweHHe YCJIOBHCpe,bi, Bbl3blBaeMOe py6KaMH, noAKapaMH, 6oAe3HqMH H HenpaBHAbHb1M BeaeHHeM .TecHoroxo3AAcTBa. JjiRA coxpaHeHI4A iHc'e3aoILH4X BH4,OB, Hanpi4Mep, yCCypH4CKorO TftrpaHeo6xo,aMo, 4To6bi 6onbulUHe nj1ouaBuH nIecoB OCTaBaJiHCb 6e3 KaKHx-JIH6o H3MeHeHHI4 HnoBpe)K.geHH4. Jipyrofi 3agameg oco6o0u Ba)KHOCT4 qBJIHAeTCq 3aLuHTa 3KOJoruHMeCKHyH3BHMb1X Be'-HOMep3JIOTHbix nJioiaaefi. He meHee Ba)KHOU SBJ11eTC5 POJb JeCOB BCBS3bIBaH4H yriepoaa H 3Ty 4jYHKUHIO Heo6xoatHMo coxpaHsTb. LaaHHbie 3KOJIorFHecKHe3a,aat H HeaoCTaTO'IHO OTpa)KeHbI B npoLtecce nHiaHHpoBaHH51, OHH TaKKe He nojly'laIoTIOJ1)KHOrO BHHMaHHS npuH rpOBeaeH4H iiecoXO354CTBeHHb[X H JIeCO3arOTOBHTenJbHbIX pa6oT.

06iuHM Tpe6oBaHHeM no pewneHHio 3TUX rip4poaOoXpaHHbIX npo6neM IBJE1eTC1 coxpaHeHHeKaK MO)KHO 6o0mbInx HnoowaaeH JieCOB B HeTpOHYTOM BHJe. nHP 3TOM HY)KHO y'-IHTbIBaTb,'ITO nieca, HaxofiuHeCSA 3a ripeaejiaMH oxpaHHeMb1X Tepp1TOpHR, TaIOKe HyWaaOTCq BfaOnOJIH4TeClbHOM BHHMaHHH B paMKaX iieCOynpaBeH4HS.

CxclvMa &,aepJbHbIx oco6o oXpa#HeHMIX IIpHp,OJHbIX TCppHWpHff 4Lw, CoXpaHCJHHHh6HOpa3H0o6pa3Hz9

B PoccHu oxpaHa AecoB ocyLueCTBJIq,CTC5I 'epe3 eaH4HyIo CHCTeMy oco6ooXpaHAeMbIX IPHPOIHbIX Tepp1TOpHR CTpaHbI H CHCTeMy KmacciuwHKaUH4 JneCOB JIeCHoro4oHxaa. CHCTeMa oco6o oxpaHReMbIx TeppHTOpHfl 6bmTa co3LaaHa ,AJI coxpaHeHIHH6Hopa3Hoo6pa3HsI H H3y'eHHS eCTeCTBeHHbIX npOI4eCCOB H MBJIeHHU (CripaBKa 1.5). OaHaKO,6oJlbLuylo O3a6o4eHHOCTb BbI3bIBaeT TO, 'TO TaKaS roCyaapCTBeHHas CHCTeMa oco6oOXpaHHCMbIX TeppHTOpHr HC o6ecneqHBaeT 344eKTHBHOA 3a1uIHTbI MHOrHX HYALam04XCA Boco6o0 3aUtHTe yIaCTKOB 6opea.nbHblx .JeCOB. FocyaapCTBeHHblr4 KOMHTeT Ho oxpaHeOKpy)KaioILerC CpCAbI Ha CpeaCTBa, BbiLeiCeHHbie rjio6anbHbIM 3KOJIorHi4eCKHM c1OHaOM(F90), B pa3mepe 20,1 MnAH. aoAjiapOB CWJA, npHcTynHJI K pa3pa6OTKe cTpaTeri4HCHCTeMaTHqeCKorO BKJIo4eHHH Mmep no coxpaHeHHio 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3HI B OTpacneBble HMec)KoTpacJieBbie nIaHbl, nporpaMMbl H COOTBeTCTBYIOltUHe pa3J,eJbi nOA4THKH. 6 3ToOTpa)KaeT HeO6XOamMOCTb pa3pa6OTKH periOHaIbHbIX cTpaTeruu CoXpaHeHHSI6Hopa3Hoo6pa3Hsl AAA TaKOR OrpOMHOA H pa3Hoo6pa3HOA B CMbic.e IPHPORHbIX YCAOBHHCTpaHbl, KaK POcCHA. PerHOHaJibHbie CTpaTeriH AOJIKHbI XOpOWO BnHCblBaTbCS Bo6Luerocy,aapcTBeHHyIo cTpaTerCHo H co3AaBaTbCs npH COBMeCTHOM y'aCTHH4 BcexnO.]b3OBaTejeie .)eCHbIMH peCypCaMH B ripouiecce KOMnn]eKCHoro nnIaH4pOBaHH4R

HcnOIb3OBaHH5l 3eMeAb.

Jleca, paCnOJ1O)KeHHbie B 3OHe BeqHOU Mep3JIOTbJ, npeaCTaBJiiIOT oco6yionpHpo,aooxpaHHyIo npo6JieMy. IoAosBHHa HOKpbITbIX nIecoM HuiowaLeu CH6Hp4 H JaajbHeroBocToKa HaXOaHTCA B 3OHe BeqHO9 Mep3JIOTbI, qyBCTBHTeClbHOUi K npHPOLHbIM HaHTpororeHHbIM HapywueHHAM paBHOBecCH (CM. KapTY IBRD 27086R). BeqHoMep3AoTHai

6 Rogpo6Hoe omfcaHHe PoccHrncKoro i7poeKra 11o coxpaHeHHuo 6Hfopa3Hoo6pa3xf MoxHo HaRiTH B ProjectDocument, World Bank (1996a). 0 63op HaH6oJ7ee BaxHbIx o6beKToB 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3HiR H fpOMbllW7eHHbiXpa3pa6oToK Ha q/gajTHeM BocToKe 1a3H B pa6ore- Newell and Wilson (1996).

Page 68: Russian - World Bank Documents

50

cpeLAa OTJTH'aeTCSl HecTa6HAbHoCTbIo nOBepXHOCTH 3eMJIH, o6ycAoBMeHHog nepHOXLH4eCKHM

nO2UbaMOM H OnYCKaHHeM Mep3JAOTHOrO rpyHTa H Tpe6yeT peweHHU9 OCo6bix npo6neM B

paMKax JIeCoynIpaBJIeHHA, BoCHpOH3BOACTBa (3aCblxaHHe, HaKJIOHHOpaCTyLLtHe aepeBbA) H

HH4JpaCTpyKTypbl (B YCJIOB14X BeMHOR Mep3JAOTbl aoporm pa36HBaioTcsI 6blcTpee).

C 1959 roaa Cy1UeCTByeT cneHLaJibHaq 3OHa 3aLHTHbIx npt4TYHaPOBbIX nieCoB, BKOTOpbIX He aonycKaTCm npoMbiiuIeHHaA 3aroTOBKa apeBeCHHbl (CM. KapTy IBRD 27086R).OaHaKO nOJIHOCTbIO HX 3aLUHTHTb He ynaaoCb, H npOMbilwieHHOe OCBoeHI4e ceBepHoro

patiOHa Be4HOA Mep3jiOTbI HpHBeJiO K pa3pyweHHO OKOJIO I MJIH. ra. go Tex nop, nOKa BpamKax J1ecoyripaBJIeH1A Ha BeMHoMepa3JOTHb1X nHfOLUaL5X He 6yaeT rapaHTHPOBaHO

HCnOflb3OBaHHe MeTOIOB 3aroToBKH, KOTOpbIe He HaHOCST HenonpaBH4Moro ywep6a cpeae,

cJie1yeT HpHMeHSqTb OCTOpO)KHbIi flOAXOA K BbiaX eri npaB Ha JieCO3arOTOBKy.

CnpaBKa 1.5: CucTeMa oco6o oXpaH11eMbIX npHpoAHblX TeppwTOpHi POCCuM

POCCH$CKaR cHcTeMa oco6o OXpaHqeMbiX npHpO21HblX TeppHTOpHU COCTOHT H3 leTbipeX KOMnOHeHTOB:

* 3anoBeaHHKu: cTporo oxpaHRembie npHPOaHbie o&fbeKmbl, rae 3anpewueHa mno6as XO3%ACTBeHHaHAeslTelbHoCTb, npeaCTaBoSllu0aS nOTeHUHBabHyIO yrp03y Am1 npHPOaHbIX 3KoCHcTeM. Ceumac BPoccum BoCeMbAeCCT TpU 3anoBeaHHKa, o6waq nfloiuaab KOTOpbiX - OKOIo 28 MJIH. ra (Krever andothers, 1994), T.e. HeMHOrHM 60oee 1% TepplMTOP1H PoccHHI (CM. Kapry IBRD 27086R). B HeaaBHeMyKa3e npe3tueHWa 6buio o6bqBseHO 0 HaMepeHuH npaBHTenbcTba paCIUHpHTb CHCTeMy 3anOBeaHHKOBTaK, qTO6bI oHa BKnJo1aAa 150 3anOBCe2HHKOB H 3aHHMana 3% TeppUTOpHH.

* HaUMOHa.nbHbxe H lpHPO2AHbie nlapKU - 3T0 o6%e1crb oco6o0i 3KoJ1orF4qeCKol, HCTOpHLIeCKOAr H1H

3cTeTH'eCKOA ueHHOCTH, npeAHa3Ha'LeHHbie Am1 3KoJ1orHqeCKHx, peKpeauHoHHbiX, npoCBeTHTeAbcKHX,Hay'HbIX H KynbTypHbIX ueneti. Jn1aHHpyeTcs K 2005 roay paCwHPHTb cyluecTBylOwylo CHCTeMy (24napKa, o6wam nfoulaab - OKOnO 13 MAH. ra) ao ceMmAeCqTH oAHoro napKa (15 MnH. ra).

* OxpaHAeMbie TePPHTOpHH unu11 3aKa3HHKH npeC2Ha3HaLieHbl A11 coxpaHeHH5 KOHKpeTHbix acneKToB6Hopa3Hoo6pa3m51: OT npHPOaHb]X 3KOCHCTeM ao oTnenbHblX BHaoB nocpeaCTBOM coxpaHeHHIM,BocnpOH3BO2aCTBa H BOCCTaHoBjieHHR npHPOAHbIX peCypCOB. 3aKa3HHKH, 3aHMMaloWuHe 11,5 MnH. ra,.qBJ151ITCSr noTeHuHaJbHo 60nee rH6KHM 14HCTpyMeHToM A11 coxpaHeH5 6iiopa3Hoo6pa3HJ9, nOCKOJbKyHx 6obIbwe B KOJHIqeCTBeHHOM OTHOweHIM, mX nerqe co3,4aBaTb, a pe)KHM oxpaHbI npowue npfBOaHTb BCOOTBeTCTBHe C KOHKpeTHbIMH ueHJMH npmpo0ooxpaHHO1i aeSTeC3bHOCTH.

* naM%THHKm npHPOAb1 - 3TO He6OJ1bWHe UCeHHbIe nllppOHbIe o6'beKTbi, KOTOpbIe COXpaH. IOTCSI BCBOeM eCTeCTBeHHOM COCTOSHHU. qacTo 3TH o6feKTbi nfoXo aoKyMeHTHpOBaHbl, t1 Ha UX oxpaHy U

ynpaBaieHHe BbuAenJ1eTcq o0eHb MaJO CpeaCTB.

* B nlpHno;KeHHH 3 coaep)KHTcq 6onee noxtpo6Haq HH4)opMauHs O ceroaHRuWHeM COCTOXHHH CHCTeMbioco6o oxpaHqeMbix npHPOAHbIX TePPHTOPHr4 PoccHH.

1 3TU LgHf5pu U3 pa6omi Krever et al., 1994 pacxo.aTcR c aaHHbMM, i7oJ1yvcHHFbMjf 6aHKoM, corwacHoKOTOPUJM B Poccrn ce1lcac 80 3awoewaHmKoB, 3mHHmf.aoLLHx !VwoLa/b 16 M)7H. ra.

OcHoBblBaRcb HaaDaHHbIX o6UIUpHbIX HCCJieaOBaHHg B paHOHaX Be4H0H Mmepa3OTbl

H Mo,eAH ceBepHoro perHoHa, yMeHble I4HCTHTyTa iieca UM. B.H. CyKaMeBa npeaIaraloTpacluHPHTb 3alI1HTHY1O 3OHy npHTyHApoBbIX necoB, CABHHYB ee rpaHHUY K IOryI, 'TO

Page 69: Russian - World Bank Documents

51

3Ha,HTenJbHO yBeJI4HHJ1o 6bl 3aU1HLueHHOCTb HeKOTOpbIX HaH6onee xpyrIKHx J1aHK1awbTOBCu6upH H aanbHero BOCTOKa. HaMeMeHHas rpaHHua 3OHbi nOKa3aHa Ha KapTe IBRD27086R.

JlCca Pocciff H rJIo6aiThHmi yTjiepoaHmf 6JInaHc

OrpoMHble ipoCTopbl pOCCHUCKHX JiecOB npeacTaBJlIoT co6o0 KpynHbl HaKorHTeJIbyrilepo,aa, 3anac KOTOPOrO COOTBeTCTBYeT He MeHee OAHOA ceabMOR Bcero Ha3eMHoroyrJlepo.RHoro nyna 3eMJrn (Kolchugina and Vinson, 1993) u oKoJio 75% pacqeTHoronoTeHLIuaia norj1o1LeHHA yrjiepoaa BceMH 3KOCHCTeMaMH 6opeanbHblx iecoB (cM. Ta6nHuy1.2). Jieca PoccHH HrpaIOT 3HaqHTeJIbHYIO POJIb B peryuHPoBaHHH co,ep)KaHAS yrnepoaa BaTMoc4)epe, H nO3TOMY 3acjiy)KHBalOT oco6oro BHHMaHHSI. Eonbomoe BJI4HH[4e Ha yrnJepo0HblI6aJiaHc oKa3bIBaOT HcnoJIb3oBaHi4e, BOCnpOH3BOCTBO H 3aLUHTa niecoB, a TaK)Ke Hx oxpaHaOT no)KapoB. nO o eHKaM HeKoTopbIX y'eHbIX (Krankina and Dixon, 1994), 3aMeHaeCTeCTBeHHbIx JIeCOB necaMH HHTeHCHBHOFO no.Ib3oBaHHA flAnS nIpoH3Bo.CTBa ,apeBecHHbI(c o6opoToM py6KH, paBHbIM 60-100 neT, npH npOBseeHHH o6pa6OTKuI nOsBbI Ha BbIpy6Kax,npo4bHnaKTi4ecKHx H caHHTapHbIX py6oK) np4BoAHT K coKpau1eHIlio o6LUero o6feMa.apeBeCHOA 6lloMaccbl B cpeAHeM 3a o6opoT py6KH Ha 10-25% no CpaBHeHHIO C TaKOBbIM BeCTecTBeHHbIx KopeHHbIX niecax. EoJIbUoe BJIHIHHe Ha BbLiaeAeHHe .necaMH yrJlepo,aOKa3bIBaIOT JIeCHbIe no)Kapbi H ApyrHe pa3pyYHTenJbHbIe ibaKTopbi. CornacHo oueHKaM,ypOBHH nO)KapHbIX 3MHCCUHU yrnepo,a B PoccuH COCTaBJWIOT OT 150 MJIH. T B roxi (Shvidenkoand others, 1995) ao 170-330 MJIH. TOHH yrnepoaa B roa (Krankina and Dixon, 1993).Cor.nacHo pe3yCJbTaTam ccneoBaHHA (Shvidenko and others, 1995), ewe 130-165 MJIH. TOHHyrJiepona B roA BbaejS1AeTCA B pe3ynJbTaTe aerICTBHR apyrHx 6HoT14ecKHx H a6HOTHMeCKHXfaKTOpOB (noMHMo no)KapoB).

no pe3yJIbTaTaM iCccjieaoBaHHi (Krankina and Dixon 1994), oKojio 17% yrnepoaa,BbUensAeMoro necaMH CH6HpH H la.nbHero BOCTOKa, IBJiSiOTCq nO)KapHbIMH 3MHCCHSMH.9TH Ke aBTOpbl CM4TaIOT, 'TO COBepueHCTBOBaHHe CHcTeM OXpaHbl AeCOB OT nO)KapOB UMCHOJIb3OBaHHe HX Ha HeOXBaIeHHbIX B HacTo,rniee BpeM5i Tepp4TOpH5X, npHBe'aeT KcoKpauWeHHIO nWIowaAH rapeu Ha 20% B roa, a 3T0 03HaqaeT coKpaeieHHe yrJlepO,HbIX3MHCCHU npHMepHO Ha 49 MJIH. T B roa. nO MHeHHIO yqeHbIX (Shvidenko and others 1995),npH BBeaeHHH B POCCHH CHCTeM oxpaHbI H 3aiHTbl iieCOB, aHaTioruiqHbIX KaHaACKHM HCKaHAHHaBCK4M, nolKapHbie 3MHCCHH yrnepoaa MoriIH 6bl COKpaT4TbCq Ha ABe TpeTH, a3MHCCHH, BbI3blBaeMbie 6HOTHi4eCKHMH 4)aKTopaMH, Ha OAHY TpeTb. no Hx OLIeHKaM, 3TOnpHBeno 6bl K CHH)KeHHIO o6uero YPOBHH 3MUCCHU npHMepHO Ha 150-170 MJIH. TOHHyrjlepo,aa B rog (CM. TaK)Ke MaTepHajibi KOHc1epeHLuHH E9K/()AO/MOT: ECE/FAO/ILO1996). B nlo6oM cjiyqae, ACHO, 'TO oxpaHa JIeCOB OT nOxapOB nOTeHUHaHJbHO MBJISeTCAO,aHHM 143 HaH6ojiee np5MbiX H 3freKT4BHbIX CpeRCTB CHHuKeHI4A YPOBHeU 3MUCCHUiyrnieKHcIoro ra3a.

E;opeanbHble iieca HrpaIOT Ba)KHYIO pOflb B rjio6aAbHoM yrIiepO,HoM 6a.naHce uKpYFOBOpOTe yrfiepoaa. 3Ty qJYHKUHIO MO)KHO YCHIJITb riyTem paLHOHajibHOrOnecoynpaBJIeHHA, T.e. c nOMOlUbiO Mep, HanpaBJIeHHbIX Ha yBenH4eHHe rnornjo1 eHHR HCBA3blBaHHS yrnepo,aa iecaMH. Ho MHeHHIO yqeHbIX (Shvidenko, Nilsson, Roshkov andStrakhov, 1996), HCnOAb3yeMyio ceg4ac CHCTeMy AeCOBoaqeCKHX MeponpHHTHi MO)KHO3Ha44TenJbHO yCOBepwIJeHCTBOBaTb. HoBa5 CHCTeMa aOJD)KHa BKlio04aTb cAeaytoLUHe Mepbl:nieCOBOCCTaHOBjieHHe Ha Heo6AeceHHb[x BbIpy6Kax H rapsix; 3aMeHa HH3KOnPOaYKTHBHbIX H

Page 70: Russian - World Bank Documents

52

MHFKOJIHCTBeHHbIX HacaeHIu41; peKOHCTPYKULA KOpeHHbIX HacawKeHtlk;

COBepweHCTBOBaHme 6opb6bl c no)KapaMH, BpeaHTeJIAM4 H 6oAe3HSMH; nrpoBeaeHienpoduHjTaKTHmeCKHX py6oK H pauuoHaOjbHoe HcnHoJb30BaHHe JICCHbIX peCypCOB.

HornoLteHHe H CBA3blBaHHe yriiepoaa B 6opeaJIbHb[x necax siBIAeTcs TeMoH,

Tpe6yioiueru 3Haq4HTeJbHOrO pacwmpeHuA HccJIeCoBaHHl4, H Bce CTpaHbl, BaiaaeioLui4e

6opeanbHbIMH JIecaMH, o6'beaHHlIOT yCHJIHA no KOOPaIIHaUuH aeACTBMA B o6.naCTTH .ieCHOU

HaYKH H ripaKTHKH. PoccHilcKaA )DegepaLuH NOnIHcania H paTH4(HWuPOBaAa PaMo4Hylo

KOHBeHULHIO no H3MeHeH41O KiiMmaTa H KOHBeHLLHio no coxpaHeHH1o 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3HA.

3TH KOHBeHUHH o6A3blBalOT qeaepajlbHoe npaBHTenJbCTBO BKTHlOq-ITb B nnJaH yripaBjieHH5

JiecaMH coxpaHeHHe Hx 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3IH, 3aLUHTY 3KOCUCTCM, peryjiHpOBaHHe coIepKaHHA

yriiepo,aa B aTMoc4epe H o6ecneMeHHe yCTOrF4HBOrO pa3BHTHH ceKTopa. Uejin O43LHuHajibHOA

HaUHOHaTIbHO¶ nOHOHTHKH POCCHu He npOTHBOpeCaT ee o6A3aHHocTqM no MeAKfYHapO,LaHbIM

KOHBeHLUHAM, HO IAn aOCTHUKeHHiq nOJIHOrO COOTBeTCTBHS Heo6xoai4Ma HOBaA OCHOBa

JIeCHo noJIHTHKH.

,4OpIWC HCTOYHHKN BOWCffCTBHff Ha OKpy,AalO4IOW cpe,qy

IOJIHTHKa H aeSTejibHOCTb ApyrFX oTpacjieri 3KOHOMHKU oKa3bIBalOT 6o0mbioe

BYI4HHHe Ha COCTOHHHe JieCHbtX pecypCOB PoccHH, oco6eHHO pa3pa6oTKa HecjTqHbIX

MeCTOpow,aeHH4. ,aoporm, nepBOHaMajibHO nOCTpOeHHble LJI5 OCBOeHHS He(TAHbWX

MeCTOpO)JeHHU, yBeJ]HqHBaIOT io)KapoonaCHOCTb H nO3BOJIAIOT Ha HeKOTOPbIX nHJOtaaflAX

BeCTH .JeCO3arOTOBHTeJbHbie pa6oTbl npu 6ojiee HH3KOM YPOBHe iiiaH4poBaHHa,

opraHH3auLH H KOHTpOJIS, qeM Ha O0l3uH4ajIbHO OTBeaeHHbIX IAn 3TOFO IAOLua,AX.

CTpOHTeCjbCTBO aopor H o6OpyAOBaHHe He4TAHbIX CKBa)KHH BJICKYT 3a co6o0u pa3pyuweH4e

MeCTHOH nJIOpbl. JIAJ1M pereHepaUiHu nOMB, H3pC3aHHbIX BZOab u nonepeK TpaHCnOPTHb]MH

cpe,aCTBaMH, noTpe6yloTcs aojirHe roabl, a TeM BpeMeHeM 3KoJIorIHeCKoe HapyLeHHe Mo)KeT

Bbl3BaTb Heo6paTHMylO noTepio 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3HA

Pa3pa6oTKa He(TAHbIX MeCTOPOKUHHU co3aaeT nperpanbl Ha nyTAX MIPaoLuHH

AHKHX )KHBOTHbIX H ABjiHeTCA pa3pyWHTeCJbHbIM q3aKTopoM B apyrHx OTHOweHHAX.

MOHTa)KHbie nHjouafaKH DnRA HecfTr5HbIX CKBa)K4H, aopor4, Tpy6oHpOBoAbl, TSDKenJbig

aBTOTpaHCnOpT, 6ypoBble BbIlllKH FOHST )KHBOTHbiX npOY4b, KpOMe TOrO, HKH4e AKHBOTHbie

MoryT nocTpaaaTb H3-3a YHH'TOxeHHH MeCTHOU paCT4TeJIbHOCTH, nIOCKOJIbKy Mexay HHMU

HaeT CHJbHaA1 KOHKypeHLUHA 3a CKyaHyiO 64oMaccy, KOTOpylO aalOT TaHira H TYHapa. [piH

BbDKHraHR14 pa3iHBOB He(DTH nIiaMS, OCTasBjeHHoe 6e3 np4CMoTpa, qacTo pacnpOCTpaHAIeTcA

3a npeaenibI nUUowaaH pa3nHBa. B HeKOTOpbIX paioHax KparHero CeBepa nocnie pa3BeAKH

MeCTOpoaeHKlH4 3eMJIA CTaHOBHTCS Henpi4roAHOA AnR OXOTbl H pbi6HOU JIOBJIH, H He MO)KeT

ywe CJIY)KlTb naCT6HLLtaMH aAs ceBepHoro oJIeHq, ITO CKa3bIBaeTCA Ha )KH3H4 H TpaaMUmH5X

KOpeHHOrO HaceIieHHS5.

B. 9KOHOMHqecKoe 3HaqeHHe JiecHoro ceKrTopa

CorniacHo cyiueCTBY1OLuLe KnaccW43HKaLtH nieCOB npHMepHo 70% HOKPbITOH

JiecaMH TeppHTOpHH CH6upu H LjaajbHero BocToKa CMHTaeTCA HOTeHL1UaHibHOH

3KcnjiyaTaUHOHHoH nnoiua,4bio (rpynna III); OCTaIbHbie 30% juH6o OTHOCATCS K

Page 71: Russian - World Bank Documents

53

oxpaHAeMbIM TePPHTOPH5IM (rpynna I), J1H60 nOBep)KeHbI onlpeaeJieHHbIM OrpaHH4eHH51M BnniaHe iieCo3aroToBHTeJIbHbIX pa6OT (rpynna 11) (CM. CnpaBKY 1.6 H npHJo)KeHHe A). OKOJIO

CnpaBKa 1.6: PeXUMbl SieCHoro X03.1rCTBa B pa3Hblx rpynnax nIeCOB rocy.apcTBeHHOro JecHoro d4oHAa

J|eca JAeCHoro 4OHaa P4) aeJ]ITCq Ha Tpm 6onbWue rpynnbl, Kaw)aq 43 KOTOpbIX aanee noapa3,aejiqeTcHno YpOBHqM 6Mopa3Hoo6pa3IH3, 3KOJlorH'eCKMM u COUHaJ]bHblM 4y-HKUIIqM.

JAeca nepBouk rpynnbu (21% nnioiuaaH ieCHoro q)OHaa) Ha3blBaioTcq "3aLuHTHblMM" necaMti. JAecanepBoHi rpynnb1 aeAlTCq Ha ceMb KaTeropH1i 3aUl4THOCTM H BKJlioqa]OT He3KcnJiyaTaULmoHHbie neca,BbinOJIHsHUlUHe TaKHe CpeaooxpaHHbie cIYHKUUH KaK oxpaHa BOA U nOqB Ha Bo,4oc6opax H 6eperax peK, 3auMTaOT 3pO3HH, coxpaHeHie J1aHawaq4ToB U apyrMx 3eMeJTb, a TaKKe npmpoaooxpaHHbie H caHHTapHO-O3,aOpOBHTeCJbHble qIyHKUHM, KOTOpbie o6ecnetNBaloTcs JIecaMH 3eJeHOA 3OHbl BOKpyr ropoaoB, ceJeHiu MnpoMblUiJeHHblX o6,beKToB. B 3THX niecax pa3pewUeHbl TOAbKO CaHUiTapHb1e py6KH (Bbipy6Ka gepeBbeB, Bo3pacTKOTOPbIX Ha 50 neT npeBblwIaeT Hx onTHManbHbili BO3paCT py6KH).

JAeca BropoUl rpynnbi (8%) HaXOaqHTC B rycToHaceneHHblx paHoHax, qTO orpaHHqHBaeT Uix noTeHuHaJInpOH3BOXaCTBa apeBecl4HbI. B OCHOBHOM 3T0 3aWUHTHbie neca orpaHH'IeHHoro 3KcnjiyaTauHoHHoro 3HaqeHH4. HaOT,1e1JbHbIX nAOLIaALX 3THX neCOB pa3peellCHbl py6KH rniaBHoro nojib3oBaHH34 npH co6j1oaeHHH npPiHuHnOBHeHCTOLUITeCJbHOrO Hcnolb3oBaHAs, XOTHq Ha HeKOTOPbIX yqacTKax 1 yBCTBHTCeIbHbix neCOB (Hanpilmep,npM6pe)KHblX) 3anpeLleHbI cnfjOWHb1e py6KH.

ieca Tperberi rpynnba (71%) - TaK Hu3blBaeMbie 3KCniyaTauHOHHbie nieca. OaHaKo, HX Ha3HatIeHMe6onbwe OTHOCUTCA K I1paBOBOMY cTaTycy, 'eM K 4)aKTHleCKOMy nlOTeHULHaJy npOMbliwJ1eHHOrO nlpOH3BOaCTBa,InOCKOJIbKy OHM BKJ]ioqalo' KaK 3KoHoMHt4eCKH aocTYynHbie, TaK H HeaocTyrIHbie nieca. BeAeHUe JiecHorox03%H4CTBa 3JIeCb opuieHTHPOBaHO B OCHOBHOM Ha npOMbilJieHHOe nPOI3BOACTBO apeBCCHHbl npulHe3HaqHTeCJbHb]X orpaHHqeHHAx no py6KaM rJiaBHoro noJIb3oBaHH. JAecoynpaBneHHe B 3T"X pailoHax aOJDKHOOCHOBblBaTbCHl Ha npHHumnaX HemCTOLLIHTeCJbHOrO HenpepbIBHO3O ro nOb3OBaHHq H CO6jIoaeHMS1npHpO,aOOXpaHHb1X Tpe6oBaHIH.

90% apeBeCHHbl 3arOTaBnHBaeTCA B niecax III rpynnbl, pac'eTHa1 JiecoceKa TO)Ke

onpe,LeJIAeTcH riIaBHbIM o6pa3OM Ha 6a3e 3TOU rpynnbi nieCOB.

HO7rHHLaJIff HpOH3BO,4CTBa 1pJXBCCHHM

Ha OCHoBaHHlH neC0YCTP0HTeJIbHblX aaHHblx, co6HpaeMblx no KaK.LorlKOHKpeTHOH ealHHHle JlecoyrpaBjieHHs45, $eepajlbHaS cjiy)K6a .YecHoro Xo3sACTBa POCCHHonpeeJlAleT pacqeTHyIo niecoceKy (noKa3aTe.nb o6wuero 6Hojiorw4iecKoro rioTeHu4ana gUl51HeHCTOIUHTejibHOrO H CTa6HnJbHoro jiecononJb3oBaHHSl) IAn BCeU CTpaHbl H aAl1 Ka*KJorooTJ1enJbHoro perHoHa. Ha TeKyiuHr rnInaHOBbflH repHoa YCTaHOBjneHa o6Luas 4jeaepaJbHa51paceieTHas IieCoCeKa, paBHaAI npHMePHo 530 MJIH. Ky6oMeTPOB B roa (B CePeaHHe 1980-xrOILOB OHa COCTaBJIlJIa CBbl11e 800 MnH. Ky6oMeTpoB); Ha aoiio CH6UpU H LaabHero BocToKaFIPHXO,aHTCA OKOJIO 63% OT o6wek pac4eTHof4 niecoceKH (332 MJIH. Ky6oMCTPOB; CM.Ta6.rHuy 1.4). PacqeTHas necoceKa, onpeaexieTcA Ha OCHOBaHHH aaHHb1X o6 H3MeHeHH51X3anaca nieca Ha KOPHIO BO Bcex niecax B LenJoM 3a onpeaejieHHbIA riepHoll (o6blqHo 3a 10leT), BKJliO4a5 3KOHOMHqeCKH HeaOCTynHbIe H He3KCnAyaTa oHHbie riJoLuaaH.

YIIeT HePoCTYnHblX H 3KOHOMHqeCKI4 HeBblrO,aHbIX nrJOLUa,eH, KOTOpblH HHKaK HeOTpa)KaeTCA B fly6JIHKyeMbIX aaHHbIX no pac'eTHOA JlecoceKe, HeH36eKHo BeCeT K

Page 72: Russian - World Bank Documents

54

3aBblUweHH10 YPOBHS nOJib3OBaHHS, KOTOpblUi MO)KeT "BbiaepxaTb" ,OCTynHaA HJIOWaaab

npoayuHpyoWuHX niecoB, a 3Ha4HT, 3TOT HOKa3aTeSjb He MO)KeT CJIYXKHTb Hage)KHOR OCHOBOU

aAA nnaHHPoBaHHS HeHCTouIHTeAbHOu H paUHOHaAbHOu jieCOX03JqruCTBeHHori aeATeCJbHOCTH.

Li,An coxpaHeHCHq yCTORsHBOCTH pecypca TO4HHoe onpeaenieHHe pac4eTHou AecoceKH HMeeTpelwaioiiee 3HaqeHHe (CM. FAaBy 2 H HpHAoKeH4e A). Ho HMe1oLU0Hec51 AaHHbIe He

HO3BOJInHOT npOBepHTb, HaCKOJ1bKO HeHCTOILUTenJbHb[MH ABJUIlOTCS Cy1ueCTBY1OLUHe HbTHe

YPOBHH ieCoIoJIb3oBaHHR. qTO6bi OrlpeeIjiTETb 3KOJIOrFmeCKH H 3KOHOMH4eCKH

HeHCTOIuHTeJAbHblU YPOBeHb CTa6HnbHoro npO43BOaCTBa apeBeCHHbl, CpO4HO HYXHa 6o0ieeTaeTaJ]bHaA zHHopMarnum no npOayKTsBHOCTH pecypcOB H 3aTpaTaM Ha OCBoeHHe AOCTynHbIX

njioLua,aerl npoLyuHpyioWuHx nieCoB. KpoMe Toro, anA peaT1HCTH4ecKoi outeHKH noTeHuaHaBanpoH3BOACTBa apeBeC4HbI Heo6xoaHMo TOMHO onpeaeJIHTb napaMeTpbl Tex njioluaaerl, Ha

KOTOPbIX B03MO)KHa 3KOjiOrHMeCKM H 3KOHOMH4eCKH HeHCT01UHTenJbHa. JieCOX03 UCTBeHHaH

,ae,qTeJ]bHOCTb. noKa 3TH niapameTpbl He 6yayT onpeaeJieHbl, CyLueCTBYIOWUUHi YPOBeHbpaCHeTHOUi JieCoCeKH POCCuH He MOxceT 6bITb OpHeHTHPOM ,nS YCTOquHBOrO pa3BHTHA

jiecHoro ceKTopa.

)lOHOJIHHTeJIbHy1O npo6JeMy B CBR3H C oLIeHKOfl rIOTeHuHaJIa lIpO03BOaCTBa

napeBeCUHbM npeaCTaBJI5eT "Hacneaue" HcnOJIb3OBaB1IU1XCA paHee MeTOaOB qpe3mepHou

JIeco3KcnJIyaTaLUHH. KaK y)Ke oTMeqaJIoCb, 6onbwas 'aCTb cienbIx n1eCOB HaxoAT4TCq BoT,1aajeHHbIX paioHax, KOTOpbie MOrYT HaBcerlIa OCTaTbCA 3KOHOMH"eCKKH He,fOCTynHbIM4 HAnu

Ta6JiHLAa 1.4: Oi.eHKa 6HoJIorHmecKoro noTeHilHan1a .necoB B pa3HbIX perHOHaX Poccuu(TbicSIqH Ky6oMeTpoB)

PeIwoH POCCHM 06a(as pacqemHag xBoEHHc T7ep,io- M.qrkafrnCTaeHHMe.'ecoceKa JIMCTBCHHfMC

CHi6Hpb 233 286 187 720 - 55 566

jQanbHmA BOCTOK 98 546 81 853 4 187 12 506

EBporna/Ypan 197 575 49 554 5 043 132 078

Bcero 529 407 319 127 9 230 201 050

HCTO4HIHK: JaHHbiC rocyaapCTBeHHoro yqeTa .neCHoro (poHia 3a 1993 roA.

3aKpblTbIMH aniA JIeCo3aroToBHTeAeH no 3KoJ1orFHeCKHM npHMHHaM. A 6oAbluiHcTBo

MOJIOAHIKOB, BbIpOCUHX Ha Bbipy6Kax, HaXOaALLHXCq B 6o0iee aocTyrHbIX parioHax

(He,aaTeKO OT npOMbIwJ1eHHbIX KOMnJ1eKCOB unu BaOflb TpaHCnOPTHbIX MaruCTpaneu),

,OCTHFrHYT BO3paCTa py6KH TOflbKo qepe3 HeCKOnbKO aeCATHAeTUil. KpoMe TOrO, B cny'4ae

npo,aoJuKeHHS HuH ycKopeHHA HHTeHCHBHOH 3arOTOBKH nieca B aOCTYrIHbIX niecax nepBou H

BTOPOU rpynn (oKouo 30% poccHuicKoro iecHoro qoHJIa) npo43Or4HeT 3HaqHTeCJbHa5 noTepAnpHPOAHbIX H COULaHJbHb1X noAe3HocTe ri.

YTO'HeHHe napaMeTpOB ceroaHWlmHero COCTOAHHS4 pecypcHOr 6a3bI

HeHCTOLUHTeJ]bHOIO H pauHoHaHbHOrO IeconOJ1b3OBaHHS ABj15eTCS Heo6XoalHMbIM YCJ1OBHCM

nlo6oUi HMeHoL1eU CMbiCn] OUeHKUI nOTeHLLHaiia rPOH3BOaCTBa 11peBeCHHbI B POCCHH. CPO4HO

Tpe6yeTCs noapo6Has HH4OpMoUuHq nO npOCTpaHCTBeHHOMY pacnpe,aeJleHH4o BO3paCTHbIX

Page 73: Russian - World Bank Documents

55

KJiaCCOB B 3KOHOM4qeCKH IOCTynHbIX necax, KOTOpble 3KOJIori4qeCKH rlOaXOIST Uqg

YCT0941Boro IpOH3BOACTBa apeBecHHbl. B KOHe4HOM HTore, .nS yCTO P1Boro npoH3BO CTBa,apeBeC4HbI o66l3aTejibHO noTpe6yeTcA KOMnnieKCHoe njiaHHpOBsaHHe HCnOJb3OBaHHq 3eMeflbAAA FIpoH3BOaCTBa jieCHbIX pecypcoB. B 6nuH)Ka4uwee BpeMA ATS 3T'oro Heo6XoaHMo CpO'IHO

npOBeCTH OueHKY COCTOAHHSI neCOB B JToruHeCKHX CbIpbeBbIX 3OHax CyILLeCTBYIOLUHX

npe,aripHATH49, '4TO6bI nOMO4b YCTaHOBHTb HHBeCTHULUHHb1e BO3MO)KHOCTN H orpeaeAIHTbMacuWTa6 Heo6XOaHMOA peopraHH3auLHH ceKTopa.

?pWacim, 3aBHCfI1(HC OT JICcoHpoMMJLleHHo4 IpOAVAWcHH

Ha aojnio neCHor4 npoMbiwHAeHHOCTH PoccuH npH4XOLHTCq oKoJIo 5% o6weroo6beMa rpoMbIwJIeHHoro npoH3BOaCTBa u 7% o6weg 4icAeHHOCTH pa6OTaIOwIIX B

npOMblwJIeHHOCTH. OXHaKO K 1993 roay o61beM BHyTpeHHerO npOH3BoLICTBa apeBeCHbIX

npOIIyKTOB (KpyrAblx JiecoMaTep4ajioB, nu4JIoMaTepHajioB, 4DaHepbi, apeBeCHbIX nFuHT uueAJnOJIo3Ho-6yMa)KHo4 npOaYKU4HH B YCJOBHblx eal4HHuax o6beMa Kpyrnoro .neca) ynan ,ao57% no CpaBHeHHIO C YPOBHeM 1989 roaa. Cnag IpOH3BOACTBa npoonJKaJIcq H B 1994-95rr., ycyry6nsiri npo6JIeMy aeb4UHTa CblpbS xiA aepeBonepepa6aTbIBaIOLUL4x npenl)pHsTHi. 3aHCKYIO,IeHHeM Me6eJIbHoH npoMbIHJIeHHOCTH, Bce KpynHble HpoH3BoXHTeJIHniecorHpoMbiwjieHHOH HpOAYKUHHu nepe)KHBaji4 3HaqHTenJbHoe coKpaumeHHe o6'beMOBnpoH3BOACTBa (CM. Ta6nwuy 1.5). BHyTpeHHee npOH3BOaCTBO OCHOBHbIX BH4IOBneco6yMa)KHorl HPO4yKU14 3a nepBbie n>sTb MecAueB 1996 roaa 6buO HH)Ke, qeM 3aCOOTBeTCTBy1OLUHUi nepHo, 1995 rojaa.

Oco6eHHo CHJIbHbIrH yaap coKpaweHi4e rIpO43BOACTBa gpeBeCHOR npOaYKLIH4HaHecjiO TaKHM OTpaCJSiM, KaK )KHJIHUIHOe H AKeCJe3HOaOPOAKHoe CTPOHTeJIbCTBO. B 1993 ro,ay)HJICTpOU 3aqBI4JI 0 TOM, xiTO HM He XBaTajiO KaK MHHHMYM 10 MIlH. Ky6oMeTpOB.necoMaTepHaYIOB, a rocyaapCTBeHHbie )Keie3Hbie aoporH r1oJIyqHJIH TOJIbKO n1OJ1OBHHYHeo6xo,aHMorO KOJH4qeCTBa aepeBAHHbIX wna1n H Bcero TpeTb aepeBSIHHbIX CBeTo(bOpHbIX

CTOJa6OB. H XOTA aefHULHT 3TUX MaTepHaJiOB, OUeHHBanJCS1 OTHOCHTeJlbHO B03HHKalOLWUX

noTpe6HocTeri repHoaa CHCTeMbI [eHTpajiH3OBaHHOrO nFUaHHpOBaH[4,q KOTOpble C Tex nopMOrJIH H3MeHHTbCA, pe3yJIbTaTb1 HeIaBHHX HCccj1eAoBaH14i nOATBepKwaIOT 3Ha'HTeJIbHbIrU1ae43HLvT CTpOuMaTepuaj1oB (World Bank, 1995) H HeyaoBJIeTBop4TeJ1bHbie o6ibeMbI 3aMeHb1KeAe3HO,4OPO)KHbIX wnan (Holt, 1993).

3KcHopTHmbl aOTeHLghaff

3Ha'HTen]bHa.q 'aCTb o6fero o6feMa npo43BOACTBa apeBeCHoA nIpoaYKLUH3KCUIOpTHpyeTCH H3 CTpaHbl H 5BJIReTCA CyLueCTBeHHb[M HCTO'HHKOM BaJIIOTHbIXnOCTyn.neHHr. KpyrJlble JieCOMaTepHaJIbl, 6yayMH OCHOBHOU CTaTbeii 3KCnOpTa neCHOA

npOAYKU4H, OTnpaBJlqIOTCS B COpOK cTpaH MHpa, a nHioMaTepHanbl, ueenjuolo3Ho-6yMaKHaxH Me6eJbHas UTpOaYKUHR - npHMepHO B CeMbaeCST cTpaH. B nocjieaHee BpeMA KpynHbIMHMf1OpTePOM Kpyrnoro .neca (Henepepa6oTaHHou4 apeBecHHbl) cTana AnOHHR. CornacHoObHuLU4JIbHbIM aaHHbIM, B nepHoa C 1990 no 1992 roa npok30oe.n pe3KH1 cnaa ypOBHA

3KCnOPTHblx nocTynjieHHuu: c 3,87 Mnpa. aoniiapoB CWIA ao 1,49 MAnpa. IaojInapoB ClWA,OCHOBHOU nP14HI HOH TaKoro COKpaWLeH H5 3KCIOpTHbiX nOCTYnh1eHU H BJ11J11aCbKOppeKTHPOBKa KypCa BaJIJOT. C Tex nop o6beMbI 3KCnOpTa apeBeCHoir npOayKUKH

Page 74: Russian - World Bank Documents

56

Ta6jiAna 1.5: HroTpe6neHHe ,ApeBeCHOI npOpyKIuHH B POCCuH B 1989 H 1993 rr.

(MJIH. Ky6HMecKHx MeTpoB)

j pym,a 7a/swoaTmeIeI 06wevM Io7pc6JeHHr B yCIOBHmX H3MCHeHHe B sejmHHIJBx o6hema KpY"Jorv neca

1989 1993

MaWHHocTpoeHHe 15,0 6,0 - 60,0

rioTpe6HTerIbcKHe TOBapbi 21,0 9,7 - 53,8

CTpoHTenbcTBo 49,0 26,2 - 46,5

)KeAe3Ho2IopowHbie wnaijbi 14,5 7,8 - 46,2

Ue.n.nioJo3a H 6yMara 44,5 24,0 - 46,1

PeMOHT 32,0 17,4 - 45,6

YnaKoBKa 38,0 24,7 - 35,0

Me6ejib 20,3 20,9 + 0,6

nlpoque nOJIb3OBaTeCj 23,0 10,3 - 55,2

Bcero 257,3 147,0 - 42,9

1HCTO'HHK: rOCKoMcTaT Pc1, 1995.

BOCCTaHOBHJIHCb H ,aa)Ke HeCKOJbKO BO3POCJIH (Ta6.iHua 1.6). B 1995 roay o6LuHig YPOBeHb

3KCnOPTHbIX nOCTyninIeHHH BbIPOC ,aO 4,2 Mj1pa. dojnjnapOB CHIA (Ta6nHiLta 1.7 H PHC. 1.5).CaMOA KpynHOH CTaTbCei 3KcHOpTa JiCCHblX npORYKTOB 6bmjla Henepepa6oTaHHas ApeBecHHa

(18,5 MJIH. Ky6oMeTpoB), ee yaeJIbHbIH BeC B o6[eM o6beMe 3KCHOPTa J]eCHOH npOa,YKUHH

COCTaBHZj 25%; 97% 3KCnOPTHPOBanjOCb 3a npeaejibi Coapy)KecTBa He3aBHcHMbIx rocyaapCTB

(CHr). apyrHMH Ba)KHbIMH BHaaMH 3KCnOpTHpyeMOk JieCHOH npORYKIUHH 6blAH

nIHnoMaTepHaJTbI, ueinloJIo3Ho-6yMa)KHaq rpodayKIHq H ra3eTHaq 6yMara. (loniee noapo6HaqHH4jopMauHq no MeCAyHapOaHOH TOPrOB1e JeCHbIMH npOayKTaMi npeacTaBAeHa B

npHHoAoeHHH r).

O,aHaKo PoccHH Mo)KeT coxpaHHTb HunH aa)Ke nOBbICHTb YPOBeHb CBOUX

3KCnOPTHbIX nOCTYrUTeHHI4 OT TOprOBJIH JieCHbIMH npOayKTaM4 3a c4eT yBenm4eHM4H B o6WeMo6beMe 3KCnOpTa ,aonH npOI1YKTOB ,aepeBOnepepa6OTKH, co3,aloLueH ,ao6aBneHHYIOCTOHMOCTb, H COKpaiueHHA ,aOJI KpyrnJblX nIecoMaTepHaTTOB, xITO nTo3BOJn14Jo 6bl eH CHH3HTb

CBOU HOTPe6HOCTH B apeBeCHOM CblPbe U YKPenUTb 3KOHOMUKY Ha MeCTHOM YPOBHe.

HenoBpeAneHHbie MeAneHHopacTyILHe ,aepeBbq B CeBepHbIX perHoHax POCCHH taalOT

LapeBeCHHY C MenJKHM TeKCTYpHbIM PHCYHKOM, y3KHMH rOUHqHbIMH KOJbUaMH H He6oJIbUHMH

xopowIo pacnpeaeAeHHbIMH cy'KaMH. Ha 3apy6e)KHbIx Pb1HKax oIeHb nOflyJnqpHaJIHCTBeHHHLua qnA oco6blX BH,aOB KOHeqHOrO HOJIb3OBaHHS, eCTb TaK)Ke cnpOC Ha enb H

nHXTy, a ApeBeCHHa C paBHOMepHOr4 TeKCTypOH TaKHX BU,D,OB, KaK KOpe1CKH14 Keanp H

Page 75: Russian - World Bank Documents

57

cU6UpcCKU4U Keap, y)Ke HMeeT pbIHKH C6blTa B 5lnOHHH iU BeJIHKO6pHTaHHH. HpOrHo3bl

cnpoca Ha Pb1HKax EBponbl H rocyaapCTB THxooKeaHcKoro perioHa yKa3blBalOT Ha

yBeJuIH-eHCe aedHLIUTa nOCTaBOK U3 Tpa,LULLHOHHbIX CTpaH - 3KCnOpTePOB IapeBeCHHbi

(TponHlecKoh H yMepeHHoi 30H), 'TO O3HaqaeT BO3MO)KHOCTb pacwUpeH[4,q pblHKOB gjS1

pOCCUUCKHX apeBecHbIx npOayKTOB. flpeKpacHyio riepcneKTHBY AAS 3KcnOpTa M1eeT K1Tau,nOCKOJIbKy TaM ceA4ac YpOBeHb noTpe6neHHA apeBeCHbix npOLyKTOB (BK1lio4as 6yMa;KHyio

npoTIyKUHIo) Ha ,yWHy HaceiieHHlq KpaAHe HU3OK, a C POCTOM aOXOaOB OH aoniOKeH Ha'{aTb

Ta6ntHUa 1.6: 9KCnOpT U3 POCCHH Kpyrjioro neca H HiKAoMaTepHaJIoB, 1992-1995(MJIH. Ky6. M)

9KcnoprTpyeMMe 1992 1993 1994 99H7PO2ZYKTU ____I_________ ____

Kpyrnbir leca 16,90 | 14,20 | 14,85 18,45

rtnuOMaTepHaAbi | 3,80 j 4,60 | 5,40 6,156

Bcero nUiOTHOM | 20,70 | 18,60 1 20,25 | 24,60JApCBeCHHbi j _ I J .

a Henepepa6oTaHHas apeBecliHa6 no oueHKaM.

ICTO0HHK: "3KOHOMHKa u )KM3Hb", 1995 U roCyaapCTBeHHblr TaMoKeHHbilH KOMHTeT P(D.

rOBblwaTbCSI. Ka3aXcTaH H apyrHe rocyRapcTBa IJeHTpaJIbHOr4 A3HH noc.ne BOCCTaHOBJIeHHq

CBOerl 3KOHOMUKH TO)Ke, cKopee Bcero, C(1OPMHPYIOT 3Hal4HTeJIbHbie rOTeHUHaj]bHble pblHKU

gAJA apeBeCHOA npOaYKUH44 143 POCCHu 7 .

ToprOBbIe 6apbepbl, orpaHHM'HBaiowiue 3KCHOPT JieconpoMbiLjieHHOu npO,aYKLH14,

6bmuH 3HatiTe1bHO CHHKeHbI uinu yCTpaHeHbl (CnpaBKa 1.7). OgHaKO, HecMOTPA Ha Ba)KHY1O

pOJIb, KOTOPYIO HrpaeT nIeCHoh ceKTOP B MeACAyHapOaHOfH TOprOBJle POCCUH, 3LaeCb

COXpaHAIOTCA CTpYKTYPHbie 6apbepbl: OT rocyaapCTBeHHorO KOHTpOJI5 B o6JiaCTH

npoH3BOACTBa nieca ao npaBOBOH CHCTeMbi H IIOJIHTUKU B o6.nacTH Hanoroo6jio)KeHt4I,

6aHKOBCKOA aeATeJIbHOCTH H iHuUeH3HpOBaHHSi npen,l4pHHHMaTeJlbCKO4 ReslTeJ1bHoCTM. Bce

3TH 6apbepbl MewalOT pa6oTe MexaH43MOB OTKPbIToro pbIHKa. B J1eCHOM ceKTope nOKa HeT

a,aeKBaTHb1X CHCTeM UHHpaCTpyKTypbl, opraHH3auHH, HHq)OpMau44H H CTHMyJIHpOBaHHS4,

KOTOpbIe Heo6xoatlMbl AAS YCTaHOBjieHHs4 CBo6oL4HbIX PbIHO4HbIX ueH, no5BJ1eHHe wKe TaKHX

CHCTeM 6yjxeT cnoco6CTBOBaTb HpH4Be'eHHIo 3HaqHTenJbHbIX qaCTHbIX HHBeCTHUUH U H

CTa6H4IbHoMy npo43BoaCTBy. Ho B 3TOM KOHTeKCTe HeO6xOai4MO TaKwe pewaTb BCe 6onee

cepbe3Hb1e flpo6JIeMbi He3aKOHHbIX j1ecO3arOTOBOK H TOprOBju apeBecHHOA,

6ecKoHTpoAbHoro 3KCnOpTa Henepepa6oTaHHoro KpyrnIoro Reca H OTCyTCTBHA KOHTpO1RH 3aco6.no,aeHHeM npHpoaooxpaHHbIX 3aKoHoB. KpoMe Toro, Bce 6o0ee Ba)KHoe 3Ha-eHHe AnA5

riojiyT4eH4S H pacwUpeH>HA aOCTyra K PbIHKaM (oco6eHHo B EBpone) 6yxaeT

7 ao0l70fITeH,bHbHAH allWH3 flCPCI7eKTHB TOproBnIH apc7ccHHoi Meay PoccHfeH H 6birnuHMf COIO3Ht7MUpec7y6dIHKaMif AfoxHO HaTH B.: Backiman (1995 and 1996). OLicHKa cnpoca H i7peC27oxeHHR ,e7oBoI apeBecHHbIH 2pyTifx BHa'oB mCCHOgI HpOqAyKiUfH 4aaeTC B: Nilsson7 (1996).

Page 76: Russian - World Bank Documents

PUc. 1.5: CTpyKrypa H TeH2ReHEIH 3KCNOPTa qecomaTepnaaOB H3 POCCHH

a. CTpyKTypa 3KCflOpTa

,QpyrHe 6yMaIcHhieH3AeJuSI

14%

ra3eTHaa 6yMara Heo6pa6oraHHaa

14% A _ peBecHHa

_ ~~~259%

UejmnOJlo3a FIH.JoMaTepHaAbi

22% 17%

,apyrue H3JaeAHA H3ApeBeCHHbl

8%

6. LIHHaMHKa 3KCnOPTa ApeBec8mi

25| Heo6pa6oTaHHaa apeBeCHHa * HnHAoMaTepHaiblI

20

'15

A1 0

5

0

1992 1993 1994 1995

HCTO'uIHK: rocynapcTBeHUnfl Tamo2iKeHHMI KOMUTTT POCCuu, 1996 r.

Page 77: Russian - World Bank Documents

59

npHo6peTaTb He3aBt4CHMaf cepTTH(HKaUHlA necHoU npOaYyKLLi4 C uenJblO KOHTPOJIl 3aco6.no,aeHHeM MeA)KYHapOAHbIX HOPM U Tpe6OBaHHir no HeICTOL[U1TCJIbHOMYjieconoJib3OBaHHIO.

CnpaBKa 1.7: CHHIKeHHe H yCTpaHeHHe 3KCIIOpTHbiX 6apbepOB AM nfleCHorH npO,YKULH

B npouecce o6wueri .iH6epau43auHH TOproBAJ B PoccuH 6blu ycTpaHeHbI MHorue 6apbepbl B3KcnopTupoBaHUU AeCHOU npoayKUHN. Zao npoBeaeHHl 3T14X pe()opm pOCCHI4CKHe 3KCnOpTepbl AecHoJ4npO1YKUHm 6bmu1 o6Ml3aHbI pertiCTpHpOBaTb CBOH KOHTpaKTbl B perfOHaAbHbIx npeaCTaBHTeJbCTBaxMHHHcTePCTBa BHeWuHe3KOHoM4eCKhX CBql3eI H B POCCHUICKOU rocyaapCTBeHHOA AeconpOMblwiJeHHOriKOMnaHHH "PocAecnpoM" H ee perHOHaHbHbIX (ul)Hlanax. 3KCnopTepbl TaKwKe aOAXKHbl 6bIJuH 3aKnioqaTbKOHTpaKTbi no npoAa)Ke qepe3 cnelUHaJbHbie 3KcnOPTHbie opraHH3auLmu (cnelC3Knopgrepbl). XOT$1 no 3aKOHYnnlaTa 3a ne'aTb Ha KoHTpaKTe cocTaBnflua He 6oAee 1,5% OT CTOHMOCTH npoaaBaeMbix no KOHTpaKTy ToBapoB,3TU opraHJ3auHI 'LacTo 6panH ropa3,ao 6ojiee BbICOKyKO ueHy 3a CBOIH "KoHCyHIbTaUHH" U apyrue ycAyrul.HeKoTopble M3 3TUX KoMnaHIHr co3AanuH 4MHJanbl, KOTOpbie 3aHHMaJHCb cTpaxoBaHmeM, 6aHKOBCKHM aeAoM,

MnolYpTHbIMu onepaLLHRMM, HaAeAHB Ux nOxTH MOHOIIOnbHblMH HOJHOMo04AMH nO 3KCnOpTHoMyAtnUeH3HpoBaHu4IO. OnHOA 13 TaKHX perHOHaAbHb1X opraHw3auLm ABAm3eTc3 "llaJbJec" B Xa6apoBcKoM Kpae,KoTopaSI, no CyTH, OMMHH4pyeT Ha 3KCnopTHOM PbIHKe KpyrAbIX AecoMaTepHanOB B 3TOM perlioHe. TaKHMo6pa3oM, KOHTpOAb 3a ocy1ueCTBneHHeM 3KcnopTHbIX onepauHiu npocTo npHBOAHA K yBeAuqeHHIO peHTHbIXI1OXOI1OB npHBHAerIpOBaHHblX KOMnaHHt.

3Ta CIIcTeMa "cneU3KcnopTepOB", .j1HueH3HpoBaHHSI 3KCnopTHbIX onepauLH, KBOT U o6%13aTeAbHoAiperucTpauHH KOHTpaKTOB 6bmia Ol4HuHaAbHO oTMeHeHa I anpeA.l 1995 rojaa. PerHcTpaujfl 3KCnOPTHbIXKOHTpaKTOB no-npe)KHeMy BeAeTCql B rOcyaapCTBeHHOM TaMo)KeHHoM KOMHTeTe Ha Ao6poBobHouA OCHOBe. Bce3KcnopTepbi o6H3aHbi npeacTaBAlATb B UeHTpaAbHblu 6aHK PoccHu oTqeTbl no BHeWlHeToprOBb1M cahAKaM amlJKOHTPOA.q penaTpHaUUiU MHOCTpaHHOri BaAJlOTbI. B anpeAe 1996 roaa 6biAH OTMeHeHbl 3KCnopTHbie nowumHbI(KoTopble paHbuwe cocTaBBj1AH 8% Ha KpyrAble 1 nHHJeHbI AlecoMaTepiaAbl iu 10% - Ha uenjiioJo3y). Ewue OaFHHMMHoroo6eLuaIouLHM npH3HaKoM pa3BHTHS1 KoHKypeHLLHH nBiJuSTc1 nepeMeHa, KOTOpaqS npOH30Aa B HaqaAe1995 rona: B Xa6apoBcKe 3aperFCTPHPOBBaJaCb POCCHICKaI AaTIbHeBOCTOqHaH accouHaUHqs MeJKIx qaCTHbIXAeconOJ1b3OBaTeges, o61blBHB 0 CBOeM HaMepeHHH COXpaHRTb HC3aBHCHMOCTb OT rIpaBBTeAJbCTBa H TaKPIXKpynHb1X yqpeaHTeAbHbIX npeanpHATHiA, KaK "Taanmec".

HafforHi H HoHeHHa8J Hviara

npe,rinpmqTHq niecHoro ceKTopa Poccuu )KayJIOTCA Ha KpaUHIOIO T$DleCTb cBoeroHanioroBoro 6peMeHH, yTBep)AaaA, 'TO 6onee 90% HX aOXOaOB yXOai4T Ha onIIaTy HanJorOB(o6Luee pocciAcKoe HanioroBoe 3aKOHoaaTeAbCTBO H npo6nieMbi opraHH3Bum c6opa Han0oroBpaccMaTpuBalOTCA B pa6oTax: World Bank, 1995c; Sunley, 1995; World Bank, 1996b). B TOAe BpeMl, o6fuHf o6beM 4aKTHMeCK4 co6HpaeMblx HaBjorOB npo,aojIxaeT OCTaBaTbCH HaomeHb HH3KOM ypoBHe. 3a riepBbie aeBATb MeCAHeB 1994 roaa o6'beM npH6bim AnecHoro

ceKTopa CoCTaBHJI 909,3 Mjipa. py6Aeri. 143 HUX 327,6 MJipa. py6nek (36%) 6bUro ynra4eHo BKaqecTBe Hariora Ha npH6buIb H 64,3 Mjipn. py6neii (7%) B KaqeCTBe HaJIorOB Ha 3apflJlaTy.

nO HenOaTBep)KzteHHbIM aaHHb[M, y npeanpHqTHi OCTaJIOCb TOJIbKo 517,4 Mjipa. py6Jei unJI4

npMHepHO OaHa 'ieTBepTaA 4aCTb OT CYMMbI, HCO6XOtaMO Ha BbInOJIHeHeC qUlHHaHCOBbIXo65I3aTeJ]bCTB nepea MeCTHbIMH 6ioaKeTaMH no coUHaIbHbIM, KyJIbTypHbIM, )K4JI1LUHbIM H

4HH4pacTpyKTypHbIM pacxoaaM, noraweHHe 6aHKOBCKHX KpeRHToB, BbirlJ1aTy FpoLLeHTOB Ho

Kpe,aHTaM H nHiaTe)KH B 4beaepanbHbiA 6ioaxeT ("H3BecTm'", 16 qeBpa.ns 1995 r.).

OI,HaKO, HeCMOTpAl Ha TADKejioe HanioroBoe 6peM5i npeaLIPHS4THA necHoro

KoMnHieKCa, 41aKTHqeCKHAi YpOBeHb HauOr'OBbIX ,OXOaOB OT SiecHoro ceKTopa B 1994 romy 6bI|

Page 78: Russian - World Bank Documents

Ta6AHI.a 1.7: 3 KcnopT AeeconpoMbmU eHHOt npO1AyKIHH H3 POCCHH, 1995 roA

Bs npozUIH Bceiv 3aa npe,eh CHr B cpaIHf CHr

Kau-sBo Cr0HmoT Kaf-Bo COHMOCTb Koff-Bo CTrMMTh

l {~~~~~~~~~~~TblC. T) (AIH, (ThUC. T) (MJ^H aaoml) (Tuc. T) (AMJI RaWo)J

| IpeBecHHa H apeBecHbie npoayKTbi - 2.107,9 - 1.940,3 - 167,6

TonJuHBHa.9 lIpeBecHHa 737,8 27,8 701,4 27,0 36,4 0,8

Kpyrjibig Aec (M3 ) 18.446,0 1.064,5 17.948,8 1.040,8 497,1 23,6

WInanbi 168,6 25,3 4,9 0,7 163,7 24,6

| nHinoMaTepHanb - 709,4 - 640,1 - 69,2

llpeBeCHOCTpyKe'iHbie nuHTbl 21,5 3,6 18,0

.lpeBecHoBonoKHliCTbie nAliTbl - 32,0 - 21,1 - 10,9

| qaHepa (M3) 670,5 193,2 657,0 188,9 13,5 4,3

AepeB$fHHaR Tapa 102,8 12,8 44,0 6,6 58,9 6,2

CTporMaTepHaj1bi 8,8 5,6 3,4 2,0 5,4 3,6

Uejulono3Haa npoayKuiH - 951,3 - 919,0 - 32,3

Cyjib4aTHa.I uejnmonlo3a, 79,5 85,8 76,7 82,5 2,8 3,3paCTBOpHMaa

CyJIb4aTHa.H uenono3a, 1092,7 762,7 1062,6 743,5 30,1 19,2HepaCTBoPHMaA

Cy.I4HTHaA uejnno.no3a, 159,6 96,4 151,5 90,7 8,1 5,8HepaCTBOpHMaSI

EyMaXHas. npoayKumu - 1.175,9 - 950,1 - 225,8

ra3eTHaH 6yMara 1005,1 598,3 916,4 542,3 88,7 56,0

ByMara u KaPToH 219,2 153,4 150,2 108,2 69,0 45,1HeMejiOBaHHbie

Kpad)T-6yMara H KapToH, 251,7 143,3 233,9 130,0 17,8 13,4HeMeAOBaHHbie

,fpyrHe BUAbl 6ymarw U KapToHa, 296,5 166,0 241,0 128,3 55,6 37,7HeMeCjOBaHHbie

ByMara H KaPToH MeqoBaHHbie 8,5 7,9 5,7 3,4 2,8 4,5

ByMara u KapToH npOnHTaHHbie 34,1 22,9 29,7 17,3 4,4 5,6

060ui 4,9 7,2 1,l 1,0 3,8 6,2

5yMaKiHbie cpeacTBa rFHHeHbI 3,6 4,8 1,5 2,2 2,1 2,6

EyMaxiuia. H KapTOHHa. Tapa 34,8 33,5 9,4 8,0 25,4 25,5

byMaKHasi U KaPTOHHaR - 4,5 - 0,1 - 4,4MapKHPOBKa

)ipyrHe BMubI 6yMa)KHO4 H 4,2 6,9 1,1 0,8 3,1 6,1KaPTOHHOi nlPOAYKUHH

Bcero[ 4.235,1 - [ 3.809,4 425,7

I4CTOIIHHK: TaMo3KeHHaA CTaTHCTHKa no BHeWHerU ToproeBe POCCHU1CKOt 'ie,AepauHH, 1995.

Page 79: Russian - World Bank Documents

61

HH3KUM B CB93H C HeyaoBneTBopHTeJIbHo4 pa6oToA ceKTopa, o6waw cyMMa HaniOrOBbIX

nocTynHieHHr cocCTaBnuina HeMHOrHM 6oaee I aojijapa CLHA Ha 1 Ky6oMeTp 3aroToBJeHHoglIpeBeCHHbl. CyaA no LuwpaM, npHBOHrMbIM B "H3BecTmHx, o6[uaM CyMMa (beaepaj1bHbIXHanOFOBbix nocTynnieH119 H3 IieCHoro ceKTopa CoCTaBHi4a Bcero oKoao 184 MJIH. aonaiapoBCIWA (npH Kypce 2125 py6neu 3a goAAap). TaKasl ie cyMMa AoJDKHa 6bm.na nocTynH1Tb BperHOHaBjbHbie H paUOHHbie 61io,leTbl Ha nOKpblTIe COLHaJIbHbIX, )KHJHLUHbIX,HH4)paCTpyKTypHbIX 14 CB13aHHbIX C HHMU paCXOaOB. Ho oLUeHKaM, pa3mep nOCTyntiBwei B

MeCTHbie 6ioaxeTbi noneHHOR rIiaTbl, B [IejoM COCTaBHJ1 OKOJIo 40 MJ1H. aojuiapoB (Hcxoas

13 Toro, xlTO CpeJHqS noneHHaH nniaTa 6bmqa paBHa 800 py6. 3a I Ky6oMeTp, a o6fut o06beMnpoH3BOflCTBa noKynaeMO9 Ha KOPHIO apeBeCHHbl - 123 MJIH. Ky6. M). 5%-HblA

be,aepaJIbHbIfi Hajior, KOTOpblU npeRHa3Ha4ajlc5 aAS nOKpblTlTHS pacXo,aOB HaJIecoBocCTaHoBJIeHe, B anpene 1995 r. 6bum oTMeHeH, nOCKOJ1bKy B 1994 r. COCTaBJIqJ] TOJIbKO6% OT rlpOH3BOaCTBeHHbIX 3aTpaT.

,io Tex nop, HOKa He Ha'HeT AeHCTBOBaTb HOBblh JIeCHoA Ko!aeKC, c

JieconOJ1b3OBaTeJIeI 6yRyT B311MaTbC5q HJaTe)KH Tpex BH4,OB: HoneHHaH nJIaTa, Hanjorl1 3a

HCHOJTb3OBaHHe 3eMenJb u niiaTa 3a apeHAy nieca. Pa3Mep HoneHHOA nHJaTbI YCTaHaBIHBBaeTCq

MeCTHbIMH opraHami BJIaCTH; OHa OT'qHCAHeTCS B HX bOHRbl o6WHx nocTynHjeHu4i 8 . CyAs no

BceMy, pa3Mep noneHHOH nHiaTbl YCTaHaBHBaeTC r nyTeM neperoBopoB, B KOTOpbIX

yqaCTBYIOT TOJIbKO rpegCTaBHTej1H MeCTHbIX aAMHHHcTpauHr1 H npeanpHqTllr4. BXa6apOBCKOM Kpae rOleHHaH riaTa 3aBHC14T OT nopoabI aepeBbeB (B 1994 r. oHa cocTaBAHJIa

OKOJIo 2000 py6./M 3 no eJu U1 500 py6neui no 6epe3e). HpH oHpeaeJIeHHH noneHHorl nHJaTbI

Ka'eCTBO U paCCTOHH4e OT pbIHKa C6blTa o6blmHO He y'qHTbIBaIoTCq. Hanor 3a HCnOJIb3OBaHHe3eMnJtI (5% OT noneHHoti nHIaTbl) oripeaensleTCH e)KeroaHo U B3M14aeTCq 3a npaBoHOflb3OBaHHR J1eCHbIMH 3eMniqMH. Pa3Mepbi HilaTbI 3a aonrocpo4Hyio apeH,Jy, c npaBOM Ha

3arOTOBKY nieca, 3aBHC51T OT OCHOBHbIX Jiecoo6pa3ylouWx BHUOB, Hpo43paCTaioluHX Ha

apeH1ayeMori 3eMjie, 4 OT cpoKa apeHabl. B Xa6apoBcKoM Kpae cpeRHHr4 pa3mep apeHaHor4nHIaTbl COCTaBjiqeT 40% OT roaoBor4 rioneHHOU HnIaTbl.

BBezeHHe B aefiCTBHe HOBOrO JIeCHOFO KoaeKCa aOJ1DKHO Bbl3BaTb 3Ha'qHTeJlbHbieH3MeHeHH.q B CHCTeMe nHjaTe)Keg 3a JIecoHonb3oBaHHe. HpeanonaraeTcq, ITO MHHI4MaJIbHbIeCTaBKH nIaTbI 3a ApeBeCHHy, OTHYCKaeMY1O Ha KOpHIO, 6yayT oripeaeJuiTbCH HpaBHTeJibCTBOMPOCCHUCKOU $Deaepa[uH, a nOCTynneHJ4HH 6yayr pacnpeeienqTbcq MeK,y 4eaepanbHbIM 11perFOHaJ1bHblMH 61o),xeTaM4 B YCTaHOBJIhHHOM COOTHOweHCHHI. JIeCHble HOaaTH, CTaBKH

KOTOpbIX onpeLens1eTcs no pe3yJIbTaTaM J1eCHb1X ayKLU1OHOB, aOJD)KHbi 6yayT HaripaBJI5TbCH

HeiOCppeaCTBeHHO B MCCTHb1e JieCXO3bI 3a BbI4eTOM 13 HHX MHHHMaj1bHOU CTaBKH nJTaTbI 3a

2apeBeCHHY (CM. rioapo6Hoe o6CyweHHe rIpoeKTa JieCHoro KOaeKCa B HpH1noKeHHH B).

B PoccHu eCTb CyWeCTBeHHbi1 COTeHLTuiuj roJTy'eHHq Hajior'OBbX aOXOAOB OTJleCHoro CeKTopa. CyLeCTByeT, KaK M4HHMyM, TpH OCHOBHbIX HCTOqHHKa HaJIOFOBbIX

AOXOO40B: rOioeHHaS HniaTa, HaSJOFH C J1eCO3arOTOBHTeJlbHbIX KOMHiaHHU H HaJIOri C

,aepeBonepepa6aTbIBaioILHx npe,anpHATHu. B CB5314 C BbICOKUM YPOBHeM HeoripeaejieHHOCTHB nH1aHe BO3MO)KHbIX 06'beMOB yCTOr'IHBOrO npoH3BOaCTBa apeBeCHHbl, 6yayLU4X 3aTpaT H

8 TepMtH "FoJ7eHHmA5 nnaTa" 3aiecb o3HmyaeT ypOBeH1 peHTHOhi !1E7aTM 3a 1ipaBo HCf7O1b3oBaHHR pecypca,KOTOpaSI B3wMaeTCJf 3a nec Ha KOpHIo, flpeaHa3HaveHHbik n7>7 3arOTOBKH gpeCBCCHmb. 9TH 3TIIJIaTexYCTaHHBBJHB81OTC.I B a4aMHHHCTpaTHBHOM llOPJWKC, 32aCCb TCpMHH "iOloeHHaI f7qara" TCXHH'eCKf 03HaVaeT HeCOBCeM TO noHITUe, KOTOpOe CTOHT 38 HHM B 381anaHOM lCcOyupaB/eHH H. B 7OCICIHeM cwywae pa3Mepw1oF1eHHoIl JnaTb onpeaaewniomcq iyTCM BbiHTaHmw 3aTpaT Ha 3aroTOBKy H TpaHc17OpTHpoBKy U3 LWeHUL Ha KpyJrbiC1CCOMaTepHag,W Ha OI7peZlCJeHHOM pMHKe (CM. ro0cCapHf CeCHbIX TepMHHOB).

Page 80: Russian - World Bank Documents

62

uIeH, oiLeHKa nOTeHLHanJbHbIX HaJIOrOBbIX AOXOOB B aoOJIAapax CWIA 1996 roAa ,AaeTcs ans

flByX YPOBHef npoH3BOACTBa ApeBeCHHbl H AiIS Tpex YPOBHei 3aTpaT H LeH. B HacToqweeBpeMS poccrHcKHe LueHbl HH)Ke, 'leM MHpOBbIe. OJHaKO npuH AanbHeiwLeri JIH6epaJIH3auHHLueH H TOprOBJH, pOCCHUICKHe UeHbI AOJDKHbi 6yjyT CpaBHqTbCS C MHpOBbIMH. HOCKOJIbKy B

OCHOBe pacqeToB Tex)KaT KOHCepBaTHBHbIe nporHO3bl, OUeHKH nOTeHUHaHJbHbIX HaSjOrOBbIX

LAOXOJAOB To)Ke HOCAT KOHCepBaTHBHbiU xapaKTep. HanpHMep, B HacTo3wee BpeMq Cpe1HHUUpa3mep noneHHOU FnIaTbI B POCCHH COCTaBJieT MeHee 1 AoJTAapa ClIA 3a Ky6oMeTp, a Ha

ayKUHOHax pa3Mepbi noneHHOS flaTbl B POCCHH H HeKOTOpbiX COCe1RHHX CTpaHax

npeBbInualoT 10 aojnapOB CLWA 3a Ky6oMeTp. B CKaHaHHaBHH ypoBeHb noneHHoIi nHJaTbI

Mo)KeT AOCTHraTb 30 aonnapOB CWA 3a Ky6oMeTp. KpoMe TOrO, B POCCHH O'eHb HU30K

YPOBeHb daKTH4eCKOil co6HpaeMocTH HanorOB.

I4CXOasi H3 HaH6oJIee KOHCepBaTHBHblX nporHO3OB, nOTeHUHaJIbHbIe HajiorOBbIe 1OXOJRbI OT

necHoro ceKropa B POCCHH OLLeHHBaiOTCH MHHHMyM B 0,9 MJIPA. aoJnapOB C A B roA. OHH

MO[JIH 6bl aOCTHraTb 5,5 MJipA. aonnapOB CWA B rof npH onTHManbHbIX AonyH(eHHAX nO

o6i,eMaM HpOH3BOaCTBa ApeBeCHHbl H peHTa6eJIbHOCTH JieCO3arOTOBHTeCbHbIX KOMnaHHg H

IaepeBOnepepa6aTbIBa1olUHX npe,anpUHTHU (cM. Ta6nHuy 1.8 H Ta6nH1Uy r.13 B HpHJIoKeHHH

r). Ecnu npaBHtTeJbCTBO He CMOIKeT pe(DOpMHpOBaTb HOJIHTHKY B .ieCHOM CeKTOpe,

yBeIHU4HTb pa3MepbI nOneHHOH UnAaTbI H nOBbICHTb co6HpaeMOCTb HaJIOFOB, TO OHO He

CMO)KeT HOJIYqaTb 3TH nOTeHItHaSJbHbie HaJIOrOBbie goXoabi. A 3THX nOTeHUHaJIbHbIXHanJorOBbIX AOXOAOB XBaTHno 6bl He TOAbKO Ha (JHHaHCHPOBaHHe Bcex pacxoAoB, CBI3aHHbIX

c opraHH3aLuHer H BseeHHeM niecHoro XO3siCTBa, BOCnpOH3BOLICTBOM, oxpaHoiu H 3aLUHToHnIeCOB H HX HeHCTOLU14TeJbHbIM HCnOJIb3OBaHHeM (6iojpxeTHbie paCXO,bl Ha BeAeHHe necHoro

XO35IACTBa B 1996 ro0y COCTaBJ1iHOT npHMepHO 425 MJIH. aojijiapoB CWA), HO H Ha TO,

'lTo6bl BHeCTI KpynHbli BKnaa B rOCyaapCTBeHHyIO Ka3Hy. KpoMe TOrO, nOBbIlUeHHe

noneHHOui nHJaTbl JIHLUHT nOAb3OBaTeiier 3auHTepeCOBaHHOCT B Mpe3MepHOi 3KcnJyaTaUH4

AeCHbIX peCYPCOB H COKpaTHT nOTepH 3aroToBseHHOu ApeBeCHHbl H TeM CaMbIM 6yAeT

cnoco6CTBOBaTb nOBbIIIIeHHIO 344eKTHBHOCTH H yCTOfiHBOMy pa3BHTHIO IieCHoro CeKTOpa.

Pe4opMbI, npeaiaraembe B AaHHOM aoKJiaae, oIeHb Ba)KHbl AJIA peanu3auHnOTeHUHaJlbHbIX HaJIOrOBbIX aOXOAOB OT yCTOiFIHBOrO pa3BHTHS .jeCHOrO CeKTOpa, H, KpOMe

TO[O, OHH COOTBeTCTBYIOT 3aaate COXpaHeHH5I 3KOj1OrFHeCKOrU uejiOCTHOCT4 JleCHbIX peCypCOB

CTpaHbl.

3aIvTBm7Hr7W Hme ,aepeBoHepepa6aTIBawoIIHCe npeHnpHRTmfh

B 1993 r. 6oJibLUHHCTBO niecO3aroTOBHTenbHbIx npearipHuTHr4 (necnpoMxo30B)

6buIH npHBaTH3HPOBaHbl H cTaJIH aKLLHOHepHbIMH o6iueCTBaMH. 'laCTb aKLuHg MHOrHX H3

3THX npeAfpœHATKA (20-30%) Ao cCHx nop HpHaLIH e)KT eAepaAbHoMy npaBHTeCJbCTBY H

HaXOX4HTCA B pacnopA5KeHHH rocKoMnecnpoMa, KOTOpbli B HIOHe 1996 roaa 3aMeHHJI

PocAecnpoM 9. HeaaBHo aKLUHH, HaxoAASUHeCq B pacnopq5KeHHH npaBsTeJTbCTBa, 6bmu

BbICTaBJieHb1 Ha npOaa)Ky, 'ITO MOWHO paccMaTpHBaTb KaK war K OrpaHHMeHH1OBMewllaTeJ]bCTBa rOCyUaPCTBa B KOMMepxeCKe aCnecKTbi JieCHOfi HpOMblUliieHHOCTH. Ha 1

9 rOCKOMICecPOM - OCyCaapCTreHHbIl KOMHTCT PDP fo AeCHO0, UelAA0A03Ho-6yMa9HoI, HlepeBonCpePa6a5aTfBaaloWe I7pOMMILUACHHocrT. 370 HoBoe *aqpaabHoeB eomcrBoM B 6l0o Co0aaHO B fIOHe 1996

ro,aa B pe3ywwbTa7w peOpFaCHI3aUmf 6sBwLeI roCyaapCTBeHHOA XOaHHroBO KOMIaHHH PocITecCPoM (CM.fpmwozeHre 5). (rocKoMAecnpoM 6bum JIHKBHAHpoBaH B xoae nocneAHeU peoprami3aumm npaBtiTejbCTBa B Mapre1997 r., a ero )YHKUHH nepenaHbl OaHOMY H3 noapa3aejieHHiA MuHHcTePCTBa 3KOHOMHKU - flpUMeHaHiUepe,aK'opa pyCCKoro H3AaHMR.)

Page 81: Russian - World Bank Documents

63

iioflSI 1995 r. 6buo npusaTu3uposaHo 62% jieco3arOToBHTenbHbix npeanplumTir, 95% -LaepeBonepepa6aTb1Baiouux, 95% - UeiAloJo03Ho-6yMaXHb1X H 100% - Me6enbHbIxnpe,anpHA5THA. (Bionee norpo6Hoe onHcaHHe npHBaTH3aUHH H peopraHH3aLuHH npeanpHuTHRnecHoro KoMnrJeKca IaHo B IpHu o)KeHHH E).

Ta6mnuxa 1.8: noTeHitHanbHb1e roZqoBbLe HaorOBbLIe )IOXOJAbl o jieCHoro ceKmpa PoCCHH(MJIH. AonJuiapoB CIIA 1996 rojAa)

CzeNapai o6pt OBAWI Ha5JOIBMX fplw oftemax IPMWCMTE JecJ , PAW .:,It0XO40tB

110 Mnn Ay6 M (cenwm um4 300 mmH. 19y6. M (mac,mwHo OmoxHmRypOHBeb) HeYCHCTOIII7lf7WbJ ypOBeHb)

noneHHaR nniaTaCueHapuri 1: 3 J1oJ./M

3 330 900

CueHapHl" 2: 6 aoau./M3 660 1.800

CueHapHir 3: 10 ao.j./M 31.100 3.000

Hanioru c neco3aroToBHTeJqbHbIxKoMnaHHtia

CueHapH"i I 77 210

CueHapHI 2 154 420

CueHapHi 3 193 525

Hanoru cnaepeBonepepa6aTbiBaiowuHxKOMnaHHU6

CueHapHi 1 514 1.400

CueHapHui 2 616 1.680

CueHapHig 3 719 1.960

06Wasl CyMMa HajiOrOBbIX AOXOAOB

CueHapKA 1 921 2.510

CueHapHR 2 1.430 3.900

CuCHapmg 3 2.012 5.485

a Ha OCHOBaHHH Tpex YPOBHeC 3aTpaT Ha 3arOTOBKY nieca.6 Ha oCHoBaHHH TpeX ypOBHeg UeH Ha ueCjijiojio3Ho-6yMaJKHyio npOaYKINIHO H nHjloMaTepHanbl.

nIpHMCMaHtHi: 1. Hanor c JIeco3aroToBMTejlbHblx u AepeBonepepa6aTblBalowHx npeanpM5PTHA - Hanjor Ha np6bilAb.

2. Sonee AeTaabHbli pac4eT pa3mepoB HanorOB CM. B Ta6iHuer. 13 (FlpHJ1osKeHHe r.)HCTOqHHK: PacBeTrb corrpyaHiKOB BceMUHporo 6aHKa, 1996.

B COBeTCKOe BpeMAI IIOMTH BCA ApeBeCuHa, npoH3BoLHMaq B CU6UpH H HaAajibHeM BocToKe, AH60 OTnpaBJiS1faCb Ha BOCTOK Ha 3KCnOPT KaK Cbipbe (KpyrnbleIiecoMaTepHajibI), 11H60 Ha 3anaa Ha nepepa6oTKy. CerOLS4HqSWH cTpyKTypa

,~~~~~~ -

Page 82: Russian - World Bank Documents

64

npOMbmbllieHHOCTH rio-npe)IKHeMy CHJIbHO 3aBHCHT OT TpaHCnOpTHOi CBH3H Mmex)y

npOH3BO,4HTeMAMH CbIpb$ Ha BOCTOKe H HrOMbploiweHHbIMH MO[UHOCTAMH, KOTOpbIe ao CHX

nop CKOHueHTPHPOBaHbl Ha 3araae. XOTA B EBpOneriCKOA qaCTH HaXOalHTCH meHee 40%nieCHbIX pecypcoB cTpaHbl (cM. Ta6JiHuy 1.4), Ha ee Rojuo IPHXOJWTCS 6o0iee 60% Bcex,aepeBonepepa6aTbIBaioLu4x npegnpHsTHA PoccHu (CM. KapTy IBRD 27087R). Ha LlaabHeM

BocToKe H B CH6UPH HaXOaATCA1 TOJIbKO 7 H3 25 KpynHbIX uejijilOJ1o3Ho-6yMa)KHbix

KoM6HHaTOB cTpaHbl, 14% ee npeanplHATHH nO npOH3BOaCTBy (DaHCpbI H 20% 3aBOaOB

LapeBeCHOCTpy)Ke4HbiX nnIHT. HpH ueHTpaiH3BaHHOM niiaHHpOBaHHH, Koraa UeHbI

peryJIHpoBaJ]HCb, a CTOHMOCTb TpaHCrOpTHPOBKH apeBeCHHbI Ha aaLJbHHe paCCTOSHHA ,AAA

nepepa6oTKH B OCHOBHOM HrHOpHpOBaJlaCb, OrpOMHbIe 3aTpaTbl, COrHpDKeHHbie C TaKHM

HepaLIHOHaAbHbIM pu3MeueHHHeM rpeanppHHTHA, 6brnH CKpbITbIMH. OTMeHa cy6ctH4iHiA H

3apo0ceHHe pbIHO'IHOH 3KOHOMHKH BblSBBHJIH HaCTOALUHe 3aTpaTbl Ha aOCTaBKy peBec4CHHblHa 3anaA, H OHH OKa3aJIHCb HenOMepHO BbICOKHMH (cM. npH.oOKeHHe ,a).

Ceriac YCHAHBaeTCH TeHaeHUHI K roMBjiCHH[O pa3HbIX qIOpM HHTerpaUHH Mu)ay

J1eCO3aroTOBHTenJbHbIMH H aepeBonepepa6aTbIBaiouUHMH npeanpHsiTH54MH Ha OCHOBe

npHo6peTeHHAl HMH aKUHH apyr apyra. 3Ta HHTerpa[4HS1 40OJDKHa HoMo4b CTa6HJIH3HpoBaTb

HOCTaBKH CblPbfl H rpOMbbIwIeHHOe rpOH3BOACTBO. lojao6HYIO HHTerpa1LHio nerme

OCyiueCTBJIATb B paiOHax C IIWHpOKHM Ha6opoM pa3HbIX nepepa6aTblBaiouwx MOLJHOCTeH.

OT,aaaneHHble pafUOHbI, rae HeT nepepa6aTblBalowHx npernpHATHH, BepOATHO, He CMOryT

HCnOJIb3OBaTb TaKOH noaxoia, no KpaHHeH mepe, B 6AHtKar4wee BpeMA. CeuFac rpOHCXO,nHT

3HaqHTeJbHbiH noasbeM B pa3BHTHH Mmajblx npeAnPHSlTHH B o6JlacTH JIecorHHieHHq, XOTS HX

ilOJI B npOH3BOaCTBe nOKa HeBenIHKa.

TexHohIorHcCIC H H MHBCCTWLfHOHHJC Hpo6ffemIaepeBoHCpepa6aTMBaIoL(eCfRpOMM1UIfeHHOCTH

npH COOTBeTCTByIOlLeCH OpraHH3alHH niecHoro X035HCTBa H peaAIH3auLHH nporpaMMyCTOIIMHBoro pa3BHTHA ceKTopa, JIeCHoH ceKTop CH6HpH H JaabHero BOCTOKa (oco6eHHo

JIanIbHero BocToKa) MoxeT BHOCHTb 3HaIHTeJIbHblH BKjiaa B o3,aopoBJTeHHe pOCCHUCKOU

3KOHOMHKH. OaHaKo ceKTop aojDKeH ripeoaonieTb TaKHe cepbe3Hbie rpenSTCTBHA, CTaBIuWHe

ero B OTHOCHTeAbHO HeBbIrOaHoe noJIo)KeHHe, KaK: BbICOKHe TpaHCnOPTHbie pacXOabl,

6bicTrpo ycTapeBaioLnHe TeXHojiorHH H o6opyaoBaH4e, He nO3BOJI5HoLUIHe npeHnpHHTHS4M

BbInyCKaTb npOiyKUMHO, COOTBeTCTBYIOLY1O MeA(AyHaPOaHbIM CTaHAapTaM, H HeiOCTaTOK

KanHTanTa, CBR3aHHblH oTTaCTH C Hepa3BHTOCTbIO BHyTpeHHeH CHCTeMbi KpeaHTOBaHH54 H

OT'-aCTH C OTHOCHTeAbHOH HepeHTa6eJIbHOcTbIo npOH3BOaCTBeHHbIX npeanpHSiTH9. B cpeaHe-

HnH aojirocpoOHOr nepcneKTHBe aAA npeoHojieHHH 3THX rpellqTCTBH4 H npHBJIeqeHH4

'aCTHoro ceKTopa K pa6oTe Ha CTa6HIbHoA OCHOBe noTpe6ylOTcs onpeaeneHHbie

peopraHH3aUHOHHbie H HHBeCTHULHOHHbie Mepbl.

,I1O KOHUa 1980-x roiaOB B POCCHH Ha6IofaACs HeyKJTIOHHblH POCT

npoH3BOLICTBeHHOH MOLLHOCTH npeRnPH5TTHH nO BbInYCKY KpyrnJbIX AecoMaTepHaYIOB H

uejijTIOJIO3Ho-6yMa,)KHOA HpOayKI4HH, 6naroaapq qeMy POCCHA 3aHHMaJIa BTOpoe MeCTO B

MHpe no o6'beMaM epeBoHepepa6oTKH. C Tex nop POCCHA OTCTaIa OT CBOHX KOHKypeHTOB

Ha MHpOBOM PbIHKe BO MHOrHX Ba)KHbIX o6AacTSx. O6beMbi rpoH3BOaCTBa KpyrAblx

JIeCOMaTepHaIOB, cocTaBji5BWHe B KOHUe 1980-x rOdOB CBbIle 300 MJIH. Ky6oMeTpoB, B 1995rony CHH3HAHCb ao 115 MnH. Ky6oMeTpoB (CM. PHC. 1.1). HPOH3BOaCTBeHHaH MOLUHOCTb

Page 83: Russian - World Bank Documents

65

ueJIJHlOO3Ho-6yMaXKHOA oTpacJIi, KOTOpa5 c 1976 no 1988 rOA B CpeaHeM e)KerOAHO

yBeJIM4HBaJacb Ha 2,7%, COKpaTHJIaCb a0 YPOBH 1960-x roaOB (Simons, 1992).

Ha 6oibWlHHcTBe aepeBoo6pa6aTbIBaioLIHx 3aBOaOB HCnOJ1b3yeTCq YCTapeBwaLTeXHOJIOrHSF, K TOMY Ace HX COaepxaHHe H peMOHT HaXOI5lTCA Ha O4eHb HH3KOM ypOBHe.npOH3BOLaCTBy apeBeCHbix npOaYKTOB Ha 3KCnOPT 3Ha'-IHTeJIbHO nperiqTCTByeT YCTapeBwaATeXHHKa Ha IeCoHnJIbHbIX, qBaHepHbIX H UeJIJ1IOJIO3HO-6yMa)KHbiX npeallpHATHRX. 13-3a

OTCYTCTBHM CTaH,apTHOrO o6opya0BaHHI THna KPYHHOnHJ]bHbIX o6pe3HbIX CTaHKOB HCYWMIIIbHOrO o6opyRoBaHHs, HaripHMep, nHjiOMaTep4HaAbI TpaHCriOpTHpyIOTCS B CbIpOM HJIH

He nOJIHOCTbIO BbICywlIeHHOM (Bo3,ymWHOA CYLUKOR) COCTOSH44 H iaCTO aOCTaBJTHIOTCs B

HepacCOPTHpoBaHHOM BHZe. B pe3ynJbTaTe pOCCHriCKMe jiecorpoMbluJIeHHble npOayKTbl HeCOOTBeTCTBYIOT Tpe6OBaHH5M meyHapORHOrO pbIHKa, Ha KOTOpOM YCHJIHBaeTCSOpHeHTauLA Ha Ka4eCTBO. OHM KOHKypeHTOCHOCO6Hbl TOJIbKO Ha HH)KHeM OTpC3Ke WKaJibIueH Ha MHpOBbIX pb[HKaX HO TaKHM npoayKTaM, KaK CTaHaapTHaq 4aHepa. Ha pgaeCOBMCCTHbIX (c yqaCTMeM 3apy6e)KHbIx napTHepOB) npeafpHMTH4 YCTaHOBJIeHO COBpeMeHHOeo6opy2RoBaHHe, OHH BbiryCKalOT BbICOKOKaIeCTBeHHYIO npOIYKUlIO, npeaHa3Ha eHHYlIO gA

3apy6e)KHbIX pbIHKOB, HO HX HpOH3BOaCTBeHHaS MOLJHOCTb noKa eule oqeHb orpaHHqeHa.

YcTapeBwa5 TeXHoJIorFM qBJI5eTCH niiperfiTCTBHeM H gl1 pa6OTbl 6o.nbWHHcTBanpe,RnpHs4TIHr, BbInYCKalOiUiX apeBeCHoCTpy)KeqHbie nJIMTbl H UeJIJIIOJ]O3HO-6yMa)KHyIOHIpO,RyKU1O. POCCHA HC B COCTOSHHH HIPOH3BOaHTb CTOJIlb IOHYZJIApHbie CerOAHA

,apeBeCHOBOJIOKHHCTbie HJ]HTbl cpeaHeH nJIOTHOCT4, nOJIb3YoLUHeCC BbICOKUM ClpOCOM HaMHPOBbIX pblHKaX. MHOrMe npeanpH5THUS eJmIIOJ1O3Ho-6yMaKHOA OTpaCAM pa6oTalOT HaCTapoM, nJIoxo coaep)Kaemcq o6OpyaOBaH4H, a HeCKOJIbKO 3aBOJaOB H3-3a CH4JIbHoro3arPA13HeHHS1 oKpyiKaioLuefi Cpeabi rpHWJIOCb 3aKpblTb. O6cneaoBaHMe CeMHaaLUaTMueJmlOJ1O3HO-6yMa)KHbiX npeanPUI4THU nOKa3aTIO, 'TO Ha UX gon1o npHXOaJ4TCR 50%6HoAorFHeCKoA HOTpe6HOCTH B KICAIOpOae, 90% XHMHqCCKOA HOTpe6HOCTH B KHCJ1OpOAe H

49% B3BelweHHbIX TBepabiX 'aCTHIU B COBOKYnlHOM CTOKe BCeX HPOMblwJieHHbIX rpCianpHATHA(Simons, 1992).

,J1Ji, OTpacJIH, HOJ1yqHBlIl4e TaK MaYo KanHTajioBJio)KeHHr1 3a nocneHHMe aBa)guaTbJTeT, TaKOe nHOJxeHHe He YaLHB4TeCJbHO. C 1989 roaa 6blJO HOCTpOeHO TOJlbKO TPH HOBbIX

3aBoaa nO BblnyCKy apeBeCHocTpy)KexHbIx nHJ1T: OaHH - B CH6HpH (MOLUHOCTbio 240000Ky6oMeTpoB) H aBa - B MOCKOBCKOH o6AacTM (o6Luaq MOLUHOCTb - 220000 Ky6OMeTPOB). C1989 roga He nocTpoeHo HH OaHOFO HOBOFO JIeconHJIbHOrO HJun LuejJlOJIO3Ho-6yMaXKHoronpeanpHTHAS, HO Ha 3aBoaax, BbInYCKaioIuHx nrHjoMaTepHaTibi, (paHepy,apeBeCHOCTpyxeqHbie H apCBeCHOBOJIOKHHCTbie nJIHTbI, 6bm.na rIpoBeaeHa MoaepHH3aUHAI H3aMeHa HCKOTOPOFO o6OpyaOBaH4H, KOTOPble 3aTPOHYJ1H OKOJIO 0,5% o6aLeHnpoH3BO,aCTBeHHOA MOLLHOCTH aepeBonepepa6oTKH. ORHa TpeTb 3TOg pa6OTbl nonepeo6opy,oBaHHIo npuilmaCb Ha CH6Hpb H aaJ]bHHr4 BOCTOK, a OCTanjbHaq ,ouis - HaEBponeHcKyio maCTb POCCUH. B ueji ilOJIO3HO-6yMa)KHYIO nPOMbiLUnJIeHHOCTb, KOTOpaAHaXO,LHTCSI B OCHOBHOM B EBpOneHCKOH qaCTH CTpaHbl, HHBCCTHPOBanjOCb OTHOCHTeJIbHOMaY1o CpeaCTB.

no OUeHKaM PocflecnpoMa, o6'beMbl HHBeCTHUHl4, Heo6XoaXHMblX JUl5 .necHoroceKTopa POCCHH, COCTaBnJIOT OKOJlO 8 Mapg. JaoaPOB CLIA Ha nePHOa ,aO KOHUa 3TorO,aeCsITHJIeTHs (1996-2000 rr.), ao 13 MjPJa. aoJulapOB CIWA B 2001-2005 rr. H aO 24 MJAp.,aojnnapOB CWLA B 2006-2010 rr. (Ta6iwua 1.9). 9TH UL4Hpbl, cKopee Bcero, oTpaKaloT

3aBbH.UeHHyIO OueHKy HOTpe6HOCTH B HHBeCTHUIHAX, nOCKOJIbKy B HX OCHOBe YeI)KaT CTapbie

Page 84: Russian - World Bank Documents

66

CTpyKTypbi LLeH, r1poH3BoACTBa, noTpe6JieHHs H TOproBJH, He peanHCTHMeCKHe

3KOHOMH'eCKHe nporHO3bI H meHee xKeCTKHe nporpamMHbie Tpe6OBaHHH K u1eCHOMy CeKTOpy

no coxpaHeHHIO ueJOCTHOCTH oKpy)KaioLueg cpenbi. CornacHo o)KH,aHHlM peaCTaBHTeAeA

rocynapCTBeHHblX BeaoMCTB H 'acTHbIX 3KcnepToB, OCHOBHaA aoJS[ 3THX HHBeCTHUHiH (80%)6y,aeT nocTynaTb H3 MaCTHoro ceKTopa, XOTS He 5lCHO, MOKHO nH OCTaBlUHtCec 20% OTHeCTH K

o6ocHoBaHHblM rocy,apCTBeHHbIM pacxoaaM. PoccHicKoe npaBHTJe1bCTBo npHnaraeT

3HaqHTeJbHbIe yciHJIH an1 Mo6HJH3auiHH aCTHblx HHBecTH4UHu, HO X15 co3,aHHq yCj1OBHH,

Ta6AHIua 1.9: HHBecTHuHOHHbLie noTpe6HocTm JeCHoro ceKTopa Poccuu, no pacqeTam

PocaiecnpoMa (mqpa,. ,aojUapoB CIIIA 1993 roiga)

. ommHutaJ,bHmg HYcTqHmK HHBecI 199-2000 2001-2005 2006-2010

Hepacnpe,ene.eHasI npti6blnb 5,27 7,67 13,46npeanpHRTI4I

BaHKOBCKlie Kpeau1Tbl 0,55 1,92 3,84

c:e,aepanbHblA i meCTHlbie 6Io2IeTbl 1,59 2,38 4,81

HOCTpaHHbIe MHBeCTHUHH 0,48 0,72 1,92

OueHKa o6wero ofbeMa HHBCCTH41JH 7,89 12,69 24,03

HcCTOqHMK: PocnecnpoM

CrOCo6CTByIOI.UHX yCTOiNHBOMY HOCTynJIeHHIO '4aCTHbIX 4HBeCTHUHI4, B nepBYBO o'4epeab

Heo6Xoa4Mo npOSCH4Tb rOji4THKO-HHCTHTyUH1OHaTIbHbie Bonpocbi. B HaCTo1filee Bpemq60nbluiHHCTBO IaCTHbIX H roCyaapCTBeHHblX npeanpuHTHH IIecHOro KOMn1neKca ABJ1ISOTC5

HepeHTa6eJIbHbIMH H nO3TOMY OHH Toxe He cMoryT (bHHaHCHPOBaTb KpynHbie KanU1Tan)bHb1e

3aTpaTbl3a c4eT CBoeri HepacnpeaejieHHoH npH6bmJIH.

3apa6omaff waa H 3NHHTOCTh

focAe pacnaaa CoBeTcKoro C0103a YPOBeHb 3aHqTOCTH ynani HOMTH BO BCeXoTpaCJIAX pOCCHACKOU 3KOHOMHKH, HO JieCHOA CeKTOp nOCTpaaaA oCO6eHHO CHJIbHO, flpHHp M

rniaBHblH yaap npHuwlejCq Ha CH6Hpb H aaJlbHiH4 BOCTOK. npH LieHTPaniH3OBaHHOM

rAaHHpOBaHHH ,fAn Ka)AOH npoH3BoaCTBeHHoH eRHHHUbi paCnHCblBaYiHCb LeiH no o6tbeMaM

rpoH3Bo11CTBa H nO KOAH4eCTBY pa6OMHx MeCT, TaK 'TO H TO H apyroe 6buIo rpeaCKa3yeMblM.

KaK TOJIbKo rocyapCTBeHHbe Cy6CHaHH 6bijiH OTMeHeHbI, a Ha aeITeJlbHOCTb npearipHSTHH

HaIaJIH BJHATb Pb1HOMHbie CHJIbl, HpOH3OUwo naaeHHe o61beMOB npOH3BOLCTBa H YPOBHq

3aHHTOcTH. 3a nepHoa c 1990 roaa no 1995 roa npoH3BOaCTBO KpyrnbiX AecoMaTepHan1OB B

POCCUHiCKOH (DeaepaLuu COKpaTHJOCb Ha 60%. CTaTHCTH'eCKHe aaHHbie nO 3aHRTOCTH B

KpacHORpcKOM Kpae noKa3bIBaloT, 'ITO C 1990 no 1994 roa YPOBeHb 3aH51TOCTH B JeCHOH H

,aepeBOo6pa6aTbIBaioLueH npoMbiLweHHOCTH CHH3HACAI Ha 19% (Ha 23% - Ha

iecO3arOTOBHTeAbHbix npenrpHATHAx, Ha 11% - B aepeBOnepepa6aTblBalolUer4 OTpacJIH, H Ha

21% - B uejulonO3HO-6yMa,KHOH); B TO BpeMA KaK B MaiuHHOCTpOeHHH YPOBCHb 3aHATOCTH

ynan Ha 14%, a B 3jieKTpO3HepreTHqecKoH oTpacAH B03pOC Ha 3%.

Page 85: Russian - World Bank Documents

67

Ho qaKTW4eCKOe nojoKxeHHe aenJ C 3aHAToCTbIO, BepoATHo, eiite xyiKe, 'LeMflOKa3bIBaIOT 3TH UH4)pbI, nOCKOJIbKy nO BCeMy CeKTOpy BbICOK TaKice YPOBeHb HenOAHOU3aHSToCTH, BO MHOFHX JieCO3arFOTOBHTenJbHbIX paRoHax, XOTS FpOH3BOLCTBO [lOJIHOCTbIOOCTaHOBJieHO, pa6OTHHKm npearpHu1TH4 Ha 6yMare OCTalOTCq "pa6oTalou.WMH". MHorHenpe,anpuHT4 pa6oTaloT HenOJIHyIO HeaeA[O HJIH RPOCTaHBalOT B TeIeHHUH IJHTeJlbHbIX

nepHoxaoB, a K HaiaJIy 1994 roaa aoniu y6bITo4Hbix npeInpHSTHf necHoro ceKTopa IOCTHriia36% ("H3BecTHH" 1995). I3ojibwe Bcero nocTpanaaa JIecO3aroToBHTenjbHaI oTpacJIb: 45%npeHanpHATHA, coriacHo OT'eTaM, HecyT y6blTKH. YpoBeHb 3aHqTOCTH ynan H BLaepeBOnepepa6aTblBaloweA OTpaCIiH, KOTOpa5 3aBHCHT OT HPO43BOXCTBa KpyrAJbIXnecoMaTepHaJIOB, KpOMC Toro, npou330umIO CHHxKeHHe 3KOHOMH4eCKHX noKa3aTeiier B TaKHXOTpaCAIiX, KaK )KAHJULUHOC H )Kejie3HOOpO)KHoe CTpOUTeJTbCTBO, KOTOpbIe 3aBHCAT OTnOCTaBOK apeBeCHOA npORyKUH4.

B 3apnnaTe pa6oTHHKoB JieCHoro ceKTopa cyweCTByIOT 3HaMHTeJIbHbIe pa3alilHSI.ro pe3yo6bTaTam CJieaoBaH4B, ripOBegeHHorO BCeMHpHbiM 6aHKOM B 4eBpaiie 1995 roaa BKpaCHOApCKOM Kpae, caMylo H43KYO 3apnriaTy noAy'ajH4 pa6oTHHKUi necHoro Xo3Iri4CTBa(110.000 py6nieui B Mec5uI, ITO HeMHormM Bblwe o4HLuHaIbHoro npO)4HTOHoro MHHHMyMaHO CTpaHe, KOTOpblU COCTaBjiqJl Toraa 105.300 py6AeHi B MecIu HunH oKojio 20 aojuTapoBCWHA). CpeaHqi 3apnuiaTa pa6OTHHKOB uelJuono3Ho-6yMaxHoru npOMblHIAeHHOCTHcocTaBEi,uia 312.000 py6neu, a aepeBorepepa6aTbIBaioHueg oTpacJIH - 315.000 py6nefl. pnsCpaBHeHMA HY)KHO CKa3aTb, 'TO pa6OTHHKI MeTajinyprHMecKori npoMblhIJeHHOCTH HOJIyMajTHToroa B cpeaHeM 330.000 py6nieu4 B MecqU, a pa6OTHHUK 3JIeKTpOCTaHUUHi - 728.000 py6neri.3apa6oTKH pa6o4HX Ha pa3Hblx rpegnpH5THAX ceKropa TO)Ke 6biu pa3HbIMH. npeanpHATH5

c yMaCTHeM 3apy6e)KHbIx napTHePOB o6brnHO JIaTHIH 6onbwle, ieM apyrHe. HanpHMep, HaO,AHOM COBMeCTHOM ripeHnpuHTHH Xa6apoBcKoro Kpas cpeaHeMecI'Has 3apriiaTa cocTaB.1qnia400.000 py6neui, B TO BpCMq KaK pa6oTHHKH o6blMHOrO pOCCIHCKOrO npeanpHUSTHS B TOM XeropoLIe B cpeaHeM nojiy4anj1 OKOJIO 110.000 py6nieu4.

F. CoI.HanIbHoe 3Ha'IeHHe iiecHoro ceKropa

B 6blBHeM CCCP nieca o6ecneI4BanH 3aHSTOCTb 6onee 7% pa6oTaloweroHaceJTeHHIu POCCHH H oKa3bIBajiH HerocpeaCTBeHHoe BJIHHHHe Ha )IU3Hb npHMepHO 10MHUAHOHOB lieJioBeK. OKOJIO 18% H3 HHX Hpo)KHBalOT B oT1aajeHHbIX neCo3aroToBHTeJIbHbIx

paiiOHax, KOTOpbIe CHJbHO nOCTpa,gaJ OT cnaaa npOH3BOaCTBa apeBecHHbl HCOHYTCTBYIOLUero laaIeHH51 YPOBH5I X143HH Hu coumaJbHoR cqepbl. B nepHoa, HafHHaSa c 1991roaa 3Ha'IHTejibHa5 aOJIS HaceJieHHS OKa3anJacb 3a xepToA 6eaHOCT 14 0 .

FOnbJasq aojiq OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH 3a (DHHaHCHpoBaHHe COUHaTibHOtH cd)epbInepeiuira OT q)eaepajIbHOrO npaBHTeJbCTBa K perHOHaJlbHbIM opraHam BJIaCTH. 3TOriepeMeLueHHe OTpa3HJIOCb B qCeaepaAbHOM 6ioaiKeTe 1994 roaa, KOTOpbIU YCTaHOBHJICOBMeCTHYIO (beaepajIbHo-perHOHanbHyIO) OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a cb1HHaHCHPOBaHHe nporpaMmno 3,apaBoOxpaHeHHIo, o6pa3oBaHHIO H BbiriBaTe Bcex noco6Hu coutHanbHoro CTpaxoBaHHiR -OT noco6Hu Ha aeTeg H onAaTbl aeKpeTHbIX OTrycKOB ao neHCHfi nO BO3pacTy. Cepbe3HbIMHe,aOCTaTKOM CylleCTByIlOLeA opraHH3auuHH qBj15eTCq OTCYTCTBHe qeTKoro pacnpeAeuieHu4so6H3aHHOcTef1 nO YPOBHqM rOCyaapCTBeHHOrO yHpaBJieHH5 H MexaHH3Ma, KOTOpbIi

10 OUcHKa ypOBH! 6eaHocTm, OCo6eHHO B KoHTeKCTe o6IueI3KOHOMHHecKo,l peoopMb,, iaaHa B: World Bank,1995a. CoIufaffHo-3KoHomifqecKaq oueHKa nlo paioHaM 6opeanwHblxIecoB iaHa B: Pisarenko and Strakhov 1996.

Page 86: Russian - World Bank Documents

68

o6ecneUtiHBaJi 6bl aaeKBaTHoe bHHaHCHpoBaHHe. HO3TOMy ypoBeHb 4aKTH'-IeCKH

1IeuCTBYIOLUHX coLuHanjbHb1X cnyK6 HeOaHHaKOB nO BceM paHoHaM, a 3aBHCHT OT HajTHqHH

qIHHaHCOBbIX CpeaCTB Ha MeCTaX.

HaceJIeHNw jiCHM paAOHOB i CHCTCMa CoL(fafJBHoIr) o6ecJneCHH

Kor,aa npenpHHTHAR np4HaMe)iKaiiH rocyaapCTBy, OHH o6ecnveHBaAH CBOHX

pa6OTHMKOB yCJTyraMH 32apaBOoxpaHeHHA, )KHJIbeM, TpaHCnOPTOM H cy6cHaHpOBaJIH

KOMMyHanYbHbie ycJyrH. FocAe npHBaT43auHM H OTMeHbI cy6cHRuH OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a 9TH

cjiy)K6bi 6bma nepeaaHa MeCTHbiM aaMHUHcTpaUHMM, KOTOpbIe 4bHHaHCHpyIOT HX 'aCTHqHO

3a c4eT HaJIOrOB Ha 3apnHIaTy, B3HMaeMbix C npeHnpH$THrI. Ho BO MHOI'HX H3 Tex

oTlaajeHHbIX paiOHOB, rae HaXOaATCS npeanpHATSA JlecHoro ceKTopa, nPOH3BOaCTBO Ha HHX

OCTaHOBJIeHO, HuiH )Ke OHM CTaJH y6blTO'IHbIMH, H 11O3TOMY He MOryT HH BbinHJaMHBaTb

3apninaTy CBOHM pa6oTHMKaM, HH uinaTHTb HaJ1OrH B MeCTHbiri 6ioaxeT. B 3TOM OTHOlUeHCHH

3TH nIeCHbie paiOHbI oqeHb CHJIbHo rocTpaaajiH. 143-3a HX H3OJI1POBaHHOCTH H

MaJIoHaceJIeHHoCTH 3aTpaTbl Ha coaep)KaHHe coU4aHJbHbIX cjiy)K6 3TLeCb BbIle, MeM B apyrHX

parloHax, B rPpowiJoM )Ke OHH nojiyIaTIH oteHb 6onbWue rocyaapCTBeHHbie ROTaUMH (Ha

TpaHCnOpT, npOaOBOAbCTBHe, Haa6aBKH K 3apriiiaTe Ani BbICOKOKBaiH4HIuHpOBaHHbIX

cneUHaHHCTOB 32apaBOoxpaHeHHA H o6pa3oBaHHs4). C OTMeHOHi cy6cMaHA MHorHe H3 3THX

oTLaajeHHbIX noceJieHHf CTanH euLe 60ofbwe OTOpBaHHbIMH OT BHeWHero MHpa, npH 3TOM

yBejlHHc.CSI q,e4e UHT TOBapOB H ycjiyr nepBoH Heo6xoR14MocTH.

143-3a TaKOrO ynaaKa B couMaHjbHO9 c(jepe B nepByIO oqepeab nocTpaaajlo

KOpeHHOe HacenieHHe (TaK Ha3blBaeMbIe "MaJToMHcJieHHbie HapOabi CeBepa"). [lepecTanH

pa6oTaTb JIHHH CBA3H H TpaHcrOpTa. B CBS3H C 3aMeaIieHHeM unJu npeKpaeHHem

jiecoxo3SACTBeHHbIX pa6oT pe3KO ynaii CnIpOC Ha MICO ceBepHOrO oJIeHS, pbl6y H ApyrHeiieCHbie HpOayKTbI, KOTOpbIMH paHbLue KOpeHHbie KHTenjTH CHa6)KaJiH 3TH paHOHbl.

Tpa,aMUHOHHbie BHAbl ae39Te11bHOCTH (OXOTa, pbl6Haa JIOBJI5i, ojieHeBOaCTBO) HMelOT

KP1TH4eCKH Ba)KHoe 3Ha4eHHe aAA 3KOHOMHLMeCKOrO Bbl)KtBaHH5 6onbWor4 'aCTH KOpeHHoro

HaCeieHHHH H COXpaHeHHA HX KyJbTypHOH npHHaHJe)KHOCTH K TOH HuH UHOH 3THH'IeCKOH

rpynne. OHH YCTOAJIH HpOTHB nepHoAH'eCKHx nonbITOK A3bIKOBOH H 3THHMeCKOH

aCCHMKAAIUHH. CpeaH KOpeHHbIX XKHTeneH rlpe3BbILaI4HO BbICOK YPOBeHb 6e3pa6OTHULbl, H

MHorHe ceMbH cyuXeCTBYIOT B OCHOBHOM 3a cqeT rOCyaapCTBeHHbIX neHCHH. POCT YPOBHeH

6e3pa6oTHUIibl H 6eAHHocTK npHBenjH K o6ocTpeHHlo coLuHaJbHbIx npo6fleM cpeIAH 3THX rpynn

HaceJIeHH5, BKJlio tLia anJKorojiH3M H )KeCTOKoe o6paLueHHe c )KCHaMti H eTbM4 (6ojiee

nor,po6HO CM. HpHJTOKeHHe )K).

Ha TePPHTOPHH KpacHoApcKoro H Xa6apoBcKoro KpaeB H Pecny6jiHKH Caxa

(5AKyTH4R) npOIKHBaeT OKOJIO TpauRaTH 3THHMeCKHx rpynn KOpeHHOFO HaceJTeHHR, KOTOpbie

ABJISIOTCS npSMbJMH nOTOMKaMH nepBbIX H3BeCTHbIX )K4TeiieH Cu6HpH H aLajibHero BoCToKa.

BO BpemeHa KojUTeKTHBH3auLH B KOHUe 1920-x roaOB 3THM rpynnam KopeHHorO Hacen1eHH5

6bImH aaHbI oco6ble npHBHier'HH no 3eMnerIoJIb3oBaHHio. B Xa6apOBCKOM Kpae HeaaBHO B

npHHLuHne coriiacoBaH BOnpOC o6 OTBoae "TeppHTOpHI4 nOI TPaaHUHOHHoe McnOJIb3OBaHHeflpHpOgHbIX peCypCOB KOpeHHbIM HaCeCIeHHeM". 9TH nHJOUWaaH Tenepb OTHOCHTCS1 K niecam

nepBoui rpynribi, CTaTYC KOTOpOU 3anpeLuaeT npoMbIlwjieHHyO 3aroTOBKy nieca. B CBA3H C

H3MeHeHHeM CTaTyca 3eMenJb CTaJIH BO3HHKaTb cepbe3Hbie KOH4UIHKTbI (H3-3a HcHOJib3OBaHKH

3TUX 3eMenJb) Me)uY nTeCO3arOTOBHTenbHbIMH nPeanPH5THAMMH H KOPeHHbIM HaCeAeHMeM.

KpoMe TOrO, KOH4)J]KTbI B03HHKalOT H Mu)ay CamRMH KOpeHHb[MH )KHTejI5MH, MeCKY TCMH,

Page 87: Russian - World Bank Documents

69

KTO 4aCTb cBoerl 3eMjTH xoMeT caaTb B apeHay AecO3arOTOBHTejibHbIM npeanpH5THIM, H TeMH,

KTO npOTHB 3Toro.

B OTJIHHMH OT 3THX 3THH'eCKHx rpynn, 4pyrHe MeCTHb1e KHTeJiH, BKlio'aq

PYCCKHX "CTapbIx noceneHueB", He cTpaaaXOT H3-3a npo6ieM, CBR3aHHbIX C accHMnJIAU14erH.9TH )KHTeJil 3aHHMaiOTCR KO4eBbIM )KHBOTHOBOACTBOM uuH BeaeHl4eM cMewaHHoro

xo35IAcTBa, a 4OnOJIHHTejibHbIM HCTO4HHKOM UX 4OXO,4OB BJIASIOTCH pbi6oAOBCTBo, OXOTa H

ojieHeBOACTBO. 3Ta KYJIbTypHaM H COuHanjbHa$ FIpHCHOCO6JiieMOCTb OTJIH4aeT UX OT

3THHqecKHx rpynn KOpeHHOrO HaceJIeHHH1, 4bA KyjibTypa 6onee TeCHO CBR3aHa c iiecaMH.

TpeTbio 6onbLUylo rpynny o6pa3yloT nepeceiieHubl (pyccKHe, yKpalHUbII, TaTapbiH npeaCTaBHTeCJH apyrHx EBponeiciuCx HapoaoB), KOTOpbIe npuexanjt B CH6Hpb H Ha

aa)jbHHri BOCTOK B 1930-x roaax 1xi, pa6OTbI B COBpeMeHHbIX oTpacnqlx 3KOHOM1KH, a nocJne

BTOPOH MUPOBOU BOUHbI pa6oTarnH B OCHOBHOM B ropHoao6blBaioleH rpoMbIwHleHHOCTH H

Ha TpaHcnopTe. JUl5A 3THX rpyinn HaceJieHHiA OXoTa H pbi6ojTOBCTBO ABA5HloTC39, rniaBHbIM

o6pa3oM, peKpeaUHOHHbIMH BHaaMH aeHTeJlbHOCTH. 3TH riepeceuieHLbi CbirpaRJ1 KJuO4eByiO

POJIb B ocylueCTBjieHHi rocyaapCTBeHHOH noAHTHKH TorO BpeMeHH B o6nacTH pa3BHTH14npoMbIwUeHHblX oTpacJerU HOCBoeHH5 nIecoB Cu6HpH H JaabHero BocToKa.

HeirpaBH7vI1ITBeHHIe OpIHN3aL(NH. CB1H3 N COTpyIffoHveCTBO

B npouecce COUHajibHOtH nH6epaAH3aUHH B POCCHH OaHOr4 H3 HOBbIX Ba)KHerLUHx

CTOpOH, 3aHHTepeCOBaHHblX B pa6oTe necHoro ceKTopa, CTaJI4 HeipaBHTJeIbCTBeHHble

opraHH3aLXHH (Hno), H cKopee Bcero, OHH cbirpaIOT Ba4Hy0 POJTb B 6yAy[ueM OCBoeHHH HcoxpaHeHHH AeCOB H npHpOaHbIX pecypcoB POCCHH. Bonee 200 pOCCUUiCKHX HnO B paMKaxCouHa)ibHO-3KoJuorHqeCKoro C0103a (Co3C) noAaep)KHBalOT TeCHbie CBq3H apyr C apyrom HMeXayHapoAHbIMH Hn0. OHH o6beaHHHJIH YCuHJH C rpynnaMH, 3aluWHUaioiuiMH HHTepeCblKopeHHbIX KHTeJ1ek B CBR3i C TeMH H3MeHeHHIRMH, KoTopbIe MOryT HapyLuaTb HX

Tpa.HUHIoHHbilH o6pa3 )KH3H4. Coo6LiieCTBo HnO 6y,eT nPHHHMaTb aKTHBHeHWee YMaCTHe

BO Bcex nporpammax OCBoeHH5 necoB POCCHH Hapgay C npaBuBTenJbCTBeHHbIMu

OpraHH3avUHMH H ApyrHMH 3aHHTepeCOBaHHbIMH CTOpOHaMH.

Cou4a,bHo-3Ko.norHqecKhH C0103 (Co3C) C caMoro Haqana np1HHtMma yMaCTHe B

no,arOToBKe AaHHoro o630pa no uiecHori nojiHTHKe, H eMy 6buma npeaocTaB.neHa 4HHopMau Hno MacWTa6y, uejiSmM H MeTO2I0JortiH pa6oTbi BceMHpHoro 6aHKa no JiecHoMy ceKTopy.Co3C TaioKe o4eHb onepaTHBHO H CBoeBpeMeHHo npHBjeK BHHMaHHe BceMHpHoro 6aHKa K

Kpar4He Cepbe3HOi BCnlbilKe MaCCOBOro pa3MHO)KeH H5 neCHorO BpeatHTeJTl B CH6HPH, H

BceMHpHbIir 6aHK HpO0UIIHaHCHPOBaJI qpe3BbiMiaHylO rpOirpaMMy .nCCO3aLUHTbI B

KpaCHOApCKOM Kpae ieToM 1996 roza. C nH6epajiH3a1xHeA o6LUecTBa nO5BHAaCb TaKiKe

TeHLteHUH31 K o6pa3OBaHHJO o6beaHHeHHA KOpeHHblX XHTeeiie, BKlIoxias C03LIaHHe

perHOHanJbHbIX H HaUHOHaJlbHb1X OpraHH3aLUHj KOpeHHOrO HaCeJieHH 1 H YCTaHOBJleHHe

HOBbIX CBR3eri C MeeAYHaPOLHbIMH OpraHH3aRLtHMH H rpynnaM4, 3aHHMalO1uHMHCA

npo6neMaMH KOpeHHOrO HaceieHHS.

Page 88: Russian - World Bank Documents

70

JA. JlecoynpaBeeHHe

OKono 95% ieCHbIX 3eMeJIb POCCHu HaXOaHTCs B BeaeHHH xeaepaJibHoro

npaBHTeflbCTBa. OCTanbHas 4aCTb npHHaAeU)KHT MYHHUUHUnabHbIM opraHam BAaCTH,

rOCy,aapCTBeHHbIM H 4aCTHbIM CejibCKOX03ArUCTBeHHbIM npeanpHS4THSAM 14 apyrHM

opraHH3aIusM. B BeaeHHH DeaepaAbHOR cjiyx6bi necHoro Xo3AIlCTBa HaxoAiuTcA 6oAbwas

iaCTb rocyLapCTBeHHbIX heCHbIX 3eMeJIb (89% JieCHbIX 3eMenJb PoccHu), AaHHoe Be,oMCTBO

yHOJIHOMO4eHO pa3pa6aTblBaTb HOJH4THKY B o6.naCT OXpaHbl JieCOB OT rIo)KapOB,

BOCnpOH3BOACTBa H HayKH. )apyraq MaCTb rOCyIaapCTBeHHbIX iiecoB HaxoAuHTCA B BeAeHH4

MHHHcTepCTBa cejibcKoro XO3rIiCTBa H npOAOBOAbCTBHu (4%), FocyjapcTBeHHoro KOMHTeTa

P(D no oxpaHe oKpy)KaioweA cpeabi (1%) H ZIpyrHX BeJoMCTB (1%).

OCHOBOU nJIaHHpOBaHHS1 Hcnojib3OBaHH5 ieCHbIX peCYPCOB B PoccuuH qBJSIeTCA

KJIaCCH4HKaUHA 3eMejib JIeCHOrO 4oHAa P Ha TpH rpynlnlbi (CM. CnpaBKa 1.6 H

IpHnoxKeHue A). Ho Ha npaKTHKe 3Ta CHCTeMa He o6ecneqHBaeT pal.HOHaJbHoro u

HeHCTOLUHTeAbHOrO AeconoJb3OBaHHS, OXpaHbl oKpyxaCo!eOu CpePAbl H CoxpaHeHH5

6Hopa3Hoo6pa3I4. HOMHMO 3Toro, nojiHTHKa ocTaeTCS Hepeani3MOaHHOA, 3aKOHOAaTejbHbie

Tpe6oBaHHS He BbInOJIHqIOTC5I, a He3aKOHHbie py6KH H OTCTpeJi )K4BOTHbIX Be,yTCS Ra)Ke TaM,

r,ae nonYJAIuH5M AUHKIX ACHBOTHbIX H 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3HIO yrpo)KaeT HcMe3HOBeHIe 1 1

0wHaHCHpOB&N Je JIecHoro xOalcTBa

He,aocTaToMHoe HHaHCHpOBaHHe ABIAeTCS OaHOri U3 npHMH4H

Hey,oBneTBopHTeAbHOrO BeLeHHI AecHoro XO3SICTBa. B HacTosrnee BpeMS pacxoAbI Ha

neCOXO33qrICTBeHHyIO AeqTej1bHOCTb 414HaHC4pyIOTCq 3a cqeT 61o0KeTHbIx aCCHFHOBaHHH4De,aepanbHorl cAyxK6b1 JieCHoro xO3.qriCTBa, 143 6ioaKeToB MeCTHbIX aaMHHHCTpaUHri U

,aOXO,aOB, o6pa3yiouHXcq Ha MecTaX B pe3yAbTaTe npoDaxc 1apeBeCHHbI OT CaHHTapHbIX py6oK

H py6oK yxoaa. )lAo 1994 ro.a (HcKniloqa 1992 ro,) 4eaepaAbHbie accHrHOBaHHR Ha BeaeHHe

necHoro xO3Sr4CTBa coxpaHAflHCb Ha 6o0ee Hnu MeHee nOCTOAHHOM ypOBHe, HO B 1995 14

1996 rojiax OHH COKpaTHAi4Cb nOqTH BABOe (B nOCTOSHHbIX ueHax 1991 rona). FIocne 1991

roAa B pe3yJTbTaTe HH4JI3qLIHH CHJlbHO COKpaTHUOCb KOJIHieCTBO aeHer (B peaJIbHOM

BbIpa)KeHHH), BbIlaeJIeMbIX Ha TaKHe onepaUHOHHb1e paCxoLbi, KaK UHBeHTapH3aUIH4i,

nocagKa M YXOX 3a Haca)ueHH51MH, H B TO )Kce BpeMA Bo3pOcnIa AonA cpeACTB, BbleJsleMblx

Ha 3apnIiaTy, noco6HA H HaKiaaHbie pacxoAbI (CM. Ta6nHUbl 1.10 ti .1 1). nOqBHBUIHeCA B

3TOU CBA3H AedUHLXHTbl B (bHHaHCHPOBaHHH nepexogAT OTMaCT4 B 3aaoLiOKeHHoCTb, a OTL4aCTH

nOKpblBaIOTC5 cy6cHgHHMH H aoxogaMH, o6pa3ylOuWHMHc 3a c4eT AeATeAbHOCTH, He

CBS13aHHOA C JiecoM.

OCHOBHaS aoJIS pacXOAOB Ha BeAeHie necHoro XO3SIi1CTBa 4)HHaHcHPpyeTCA 3a

cMeT cpeACTB, BbIAeAAeMbix 13 4egepajibHoro 61oAgxeTa (DeaepaJlbHOi cny)K6e necHoro

XO3SiflCTBa. Ho 3Ta aons 4)eepaJlbHoro 61ogxeTHorO 4)HHaHCMpOBaHHA pe3KO COKpaTHnaCb -

c 70% Bcex paCXOAOB B 1985 rogy ao 67% B 1992 roAy H 45% - B 1995 rogy. HeKoTopble

Aoxozbi JieCXO3bl noJ1yMalOT 3a cMeT nHaTexeri 3a n1ec (noneHHaq nnaTa, apeHaHaq nniaTa),

If AaiH3 HH HHTCpI7peTaL(HJ oofIuHanibHbX cTaTcfHCTIfVCCKHX AaHHblX 170 nCCHbM pecyp CaM POCCHH,

IpOBOA,7HMMbC pa3HblMM 38Ba4HblMM cI7eumaAHC7aMM, RAIOT p23Hbe OL(eHKH K0oIIHeCTBa 1 a4HHMHKH JeCHblIX

PeCyPCOb PoCC/If (CM., HanptMep, Barr and Braden, 1988; Shvidenko and Nilsson, 1996). Ho o6wenp3HamHHoTO, YTO 3a flocfACHHCe Tpm aeCITwRCeTH I7poM7O30LL cHH)xeHHe H KaJ1H'eCTB8 H KavecTBa 3anaca qeca Ha KOPHIO,

ocO6eHHO B A3mafCKoil vacTif PoccHH.

Page 89: Russian - World Bank Documents

7'1

wTpa(pOB 14 (HHoraa 3Ha,44TeJIbHble aOXOabI) 3a C4eT npOaa>KH apeBeCHHbI OT CaHUTaPHbIXpy6oK H py6oK yxoaa. CaHHTapHbie py6Kl4, CyAs no BceMy, npOBOaATCA cKopee AAsMaKCHMH3aLLHH TeKyLUHX IOXOAOB, 4eM aAA MaKCHMH3auLHH 6yayLueg CTOHMOCTH neca,BOnpeKH HaCTORLUeg uejiH 1aHHOrO MeporpH4ATHq. Ha P4c. 1.6 B o6o6LUeHHoM BHIenOKa3aHO THnHHqHoe aBH)KeHHe aeHe)KHbIx cpeaCTB B iieCHOM ceKTOpe PoccHH B 1993-1995rr., a Ha P4c. 1.7 OHO noKa3aHO TaKHM, KaKHM aOJI)KHO 6blTb, corJiacHo npoeKTy JlecHoroKo,aeKca OT HIoJIA 1996 roaa. (orononHHTeAbHyIo HHDopMaLuHo HO nPO43BOaCTBeHHbiM3aTpaTaM, 4CTO4H4KaM 4pHHaHCHpOBaHH4A H qUHHaHCOBbIM nOTOKaM MO)KHO HaRTH BnpHJoKeHHH 6, a noapo6Hoe oHcaHHue npoeKTa JlecHoro KoaeKca KIOJII 1996 roga - BnpHjiox4eHHHi B).

IICCOyC7pOCrCBO

JlecoycTpoACTBO Ha 70% nAowazu 3KCrIIyaTaLUHOHHb1X nIeCOB CU6HPU HJaan¶bHero BocToKa (III rpynna) OCHOBbIBaeTCI Ha TOU HH4)OpMaUl4I o pecypce, KOTOpylOco6HpaloT H o6o6LualoT TPHHaHaaTb JIecoycTpoHTenJbHbix rpeanpH5THIr (CM. KaPTY IBRD28354). 9TH nperiPHSAT14A HPOBOaAT nOJIHYIO HHBeHTaPH3aUHIO nleCOB, onpeaejinlOTpac4eTHyo niecoceKy H COCTaBJISIOT necoycTpo4TebHbie nIaHbi AAS Bcex AeCXO3OB. KaxabirlJ1ecoycTpoHTeJIbHblg rnnaH OXBaTbIBaeT OaHH JieCXo3 Hun OAHO IieCHHMeCTBO.

B JTeCOYCTpOHTenJbHOM nnaHe (KOTOpblU BKJiO'aeT noapo6Hble KapTbI) QaeTcsKpaTKOe oniHcaHHe KonorJi4HecKHx, KiiMmaTH4eCKHX H rOiBeHHbIX yCJIOBHr4; OUeHKaTaKCaUHOHHbIX HOKa3aTeAeg HO Kax)aOMy Hacaw)eHL1Ho (BL,aOBOA COCTaB, 60HHTeT H 3anacnieca Ha KOpHIO); onpeaeJIeH4e pac4eTHOr4 JIecoceKH Ha cjieayiouuH 10-AeTHH4r HepHoA HnepeqeHb MepOnpHSTHA, KOTOPbIe PeKOMeHaYeTCA nPOBeCTH B ciieapouIkie 10 nieT (6o0neenonpo6HYIo HH4)OPMaUmIO O KaPTaX CM. B nP4jiO)KeHHH A). JIeCOYCTPOHTCAbHbil riIaHcO,aepKHT TaKwe 3KOHOMH4eCKHe flporHO3bl H OueHKY 3HaqeHHH .TeCHOrO ceKTopa HaYPOBHqX par4oHa, o6iiacTH, KpaA H pecny6JIHKH. KaAbl4 JIeCoyCTpOHTeJIbHbiH rAaH aoJDeHyTBepw,aaTbCS $DeaepaJlbHOA cAy)K6or4 IiecHOrO XO3ArICTBa PoccHu.

HecMOTpS Ha BCIO CJIO)KHOCTb H KOMnHieKCHOCTb CHCTeMbl HHBeHTapl3auLtH Ho6ttunie tH4bopMauuH, co6paHHoA XIA COCTaBBneHHS1 jieCoyCTpouTeJIbHbix riiaHOB, 3THAaHHbIe peARKO HcnojTb3YIOTCH 344eKT4BHO. pnAA HX o6pa6oTKH HeaOCTaTOLIHO HCnOJIb3ylOTC5KOMnblOTepHbie TeXHOAOrHH, H B 6OJIbWlHHCTBe perHOHOB HeT BO3MO)KHOCTer4 npH4MeHeHHSAAA pecypcHoro aHauIH3a H nniaHHpoBaHHq reorpa(bH'ecKHx 4HHcopMaLuHOHHbIX cHcTeM(FHC). nO3TOMY TaKoi alHaji43 COCTOAHHAI peCYPCOB nOKa He CTaii Ba)KHOR qlaCTblOnpouecca J1ecoycTporcTBa. To.TbKO C nOMOLubiO CIYTHHKOBb1X TeXHOJIOFHui HreOrpa4H'-ieCKHX 4HHOpMaUL4oHHbIX CHCTeM (FHC) MO)KHO rOIoYiyaTb H alHlajn3HPOBaTbHHBeHTaPH3aLLHOHHbie daHHbie TaK, 'To6bI B pe3ynJbTaTe nOABHJaCb TOqHaA H noapo6HaS4HH4opMauHH anA np4HHTH5I pewIeHHH nO HCnOJIb3OBaHHIO AeCHbIX 3eMerIb, CoxpaHeHHuO HHCnOJnb3OBaHHIO .eCOB. 3TU HOBbie TexHoAorFHH aalOT TaKwKe npeKpaCHble B03MO)KHOCT4 AASKapTorpaq4pOBaHU4 TeX TCppHTOpHU, Ha KOTOpbIe HMelOT npaBo KOpeHHbiC )KHTenJH H rReipaKTHKyIOTCA TpaaHUHOHHbie BHLbl HCrIOJlb3OBaHHq AeCHbIX peCypCOB, KpOMe TOrO, OHU

MOrYT nOMO4b B rpHBjieCeHHH KOpeHHorO HacejieHH4A H npyrHx rpyinn MCCTHbIX )K4TeAeg KynpaBseHHIO JiecaMH H nJiaHHpOBaHI4O.

Page 90: Russian - World Bank Documents

72

Pa3MeueHHe JIeCHbX peCyc.COB

nocne 1993 roga necHoe 3aKoHoaaTenbcTBo npeRocTaB4no pero4Ham

3HaMHTeJIbHbie npaBa H o6S13aHHOCTH no ynpasBeHHIO JiecaMH, BKJHIO'aSl ycTaHoELTIeHHe

apeH,aHbIX OTHOUJeHH9, onpeaejieHHH CTaBOK noneHHOHi nniaTbi, a TaKKe pa3MeiueHi4e H

ycTaHoBneHHe pa3MepOB JiecoceK. HOBble apeHAHbie OTHOLueHHS4, no 3aMblcny, OJDICHbl

3aMeHHTb cTapyio cHcTeMy pacnpeAeneHlA pecypCoB. B apeHKHbIX aoroBopax OrOBapHBalOTCA

npaBa H o6Al3aHHocTH Kaw)iogi H3 CTOpOH, B COOTBeTCTBHH C 3aKoHoAaTeJIbHb[MH

Tpe6oBaHK4lMH. Pa3MepbI H MeCTOHaxoxLeHHe caaBaeMbIX B apeHRy nnou.a,er AOlXKHblonpe,aeJsATbC.q (DeaepaAbHo9 cAyxc6og AecHoro XO3.qACTBa BMecTe C ee TeppHTopHaIbHbiMH

opraHaMH. CefNac 4epeBoriepepa6aTbiBalouiHe npeanpHATH$ MoryT nojIyMHTb nec B apeHay

CpOKOM Ha COPOK geB5lTb jieT; o)Ki1AaeTcq, qTO Ha TaKylo apeHay 6yRyT HMeTb npaBO TaiOKe

HHOCTpaHHbIe KoMaHUHH H COBMeCTHbie (c 3apy6e)KHbIMH napTHepaMH) npeinpMslTrm.

B HeKOTOPbIX paHOHax ,AmS YCTaHOBAeHH1 LueH Ha nec (DeaepajlbHaq cJIy)K6a

jiecHoro XO3.qACTBa BBena KOHKypCHbie TOprH. B HUX MoryT npHHHMaTb yqaCTHe KaK

BHyTpeHHHe, TaK H 3apy6eXKHble noKynaTeJIH. UeHbl 1OXOAART ao 45.000 py6neg 3a Ky6oMeTp,

B TO BpeMA KaK oxwaemaw CpeaHq3l ueHa .neca Ha KOpHIO Ha 1995 rog cocTaeiisla 5.000py6neH 3a Ky6oMeTp. Ho pa3HHua B 4?aKTH4eCKHX 'HCTbIX Aoxo,xax MOxKeT 6biTb ropa3uo

MeHbuwe, B 3aBHCHMOCTH OT TOrO, KTO - noKyriaTeJIb HJIH npo;DaBeu - 6epeT Ha ce651

o6Al3aHHOCTH no iieCOBOCCTaHOBj1eHHIO H .jeCO3aLHTe.

JeCO3MFOTOBKa, BOCHpOM3BO,aCTBO neCCa H yXoa 3a Haca8X4eHNMf

JIeCO3arOTOBHTeJIbHbie pa6OTbl B CH6HpU 2o CHX nOp BeayTCl no MoIeJIH

"lof6blIq neca": BbIpy6HB cHejibirl nec Ha OAHO9 nHfOLaa2H, eCO3arOTOBiHTJeni CABHralOT

rpaHHUY CBOeri aeqTeJAbHOCTH Lajlbwe K apyrtM HnoLuaqSM cnenioro iieca. 143-3a

He344eKTHBHbIX cnoco6oB pa6oTbl HnoUolaAb e)KeroaHbIx 3arOTOBOK rpeBblwaeT

Heo6xO1HMylO, WTO O3HaqaeT aaJIbHe4lulee npO,BH)KeHHe jieCOCeqHbIX pa6OT BrJiy6b

eCTeCTBeHHbIX nieCOB. HpO43BOaCTBeHHble InOTepH MOryT AOCTHraTb OT 40 ao 60% 3anaca

neca Ha KOpHIO. KpoMe Toro, TaKHe nlOAXOAbl yBeJIH4HBalOT iiecoceYHylo Harpy3KY Ha JlerKO

LIOCTyflHbie nHjOUIafH H Ha nieca nepBOA H BTOpOH rpynn (oxpaHReMble H

He3KcnjiyaTaLUHOHHbie).

JIeCOBO21CTBeHHbie H apyrme HOpMbl no py6KaM rnaBHoro nOAb3OBaHH4 4aCTO

HrHOpHpylOTC.q. 06wHpHbie AiOlIwaaH JleCOB Cepbe3HO nOCTpaAaJIH OT KOHUeHTPHPOBaHHbIX

jiecO3arOToBOK, KpyHHOMacWTa6HbIx cHjiOWHbIX py6OK, KOTOpbIe BeJIHCb 6e3 yqeTa

oco6eHHocTerl 3KOCHCTeM, H HenOJIHOUeHHOCTH IieCOBOCCTaHOBHTenjbHbIX MeponpHqTHr. Bce

3TO llpBenjO K pa36aYIaHCHpOBaHHIO CTPYKTypbl HaCaAweHHri. aeq)HU14T peCypCOB CO

BpeMeHeM 3aCTaBHT YCOBeplwIeHCTBOBaTb 3TH MeTOAbl, HO, A0 TOrO, KaK 3TO npOH3o0AeT, B

CTpaTerHlo ynpasneHIsi iieCHbIMH pecypcamu cjie2yeT BHeCTH H3MeHeHHA, KOTOpbIe caenfallH

6bl iieCOnlpOMbIwHJ1eHHHKOB 3aHHTepeCOBaHHbIMH BO BHeapeHHHH 6onee COBpeMeHHblX

MeTOAOB 3arOTOBKH H nlepepa6OTKH ApeBeCHHbl, CnOCo6CTBYIOLuHX rIOBblweHHO0

3creKTHBHOCTH HCnOJIb3OBaHHR 2apeBeCHHbl H COXpaHeHHmo eCTeCTBeHHb[X nIeCOB.

Page 91: Russian - World Bank Documents

PHc. 1.6: locTynnieHHeaeHexKHhix cpeltcTB Ha 4)HHaHCHPOBaHHe IecHoro ceKTopaPOCCHH B 1993-95 rr.

0eaeparn.Hoe _ 7e1C_p__ __ _' ,Rpyrme 6ioaxKeTH1bC - HHaHCHpOBaHHC 6io0IeT ApyrHe ApyrHeotqI4cJeHHR

J -eapnHl_ I OXOlIb

/ )e,uepaAbHaI e,c cyHH6a anecHoro )

XO31i2CTBa /

flPS~MO~O Oaacwoui, PenroHanbHbe \np.q oro Ha -. (oncToioWP ruanHbl \ lOUqH-59 / 6KpaeBoiu)61oWKeT

I / , . HajiorI /TennHTonHan\ I Ha OXPaHy,lacTm

H BOCnpOH3-JIeCOyCTpO"- K opraH necHoro JICCHblX BOICTBO JCCTBO, aBHaJIe- nonaTe* HblIXpCCYp-cooxpaHa, \ Xo3WARCTBa / COB (5% OTHayqHblIe npoua"uHHCTHTyral,

rApeBeCcHHl)

KBaJnHuHKaU. IMCCTHbieI 4qaCm ACCHbiX _ (paioniwi) HaniOrH I

rioflaTe¢* 6 I

I .II /J\ eITpafu nciibleC noaaTH

(noneHHaA

AeCCOBOcCTaHOBHTCb-I 3CMeJbHblgHblIe pa6oTbm Hauior, apeHniHas _

ApeHaarnop yL,ac,mKa .ecfHoo (bondia |AOXO,U OT (Aecnpo-xo 3)JIecHaa HHCncK1uuA ICCOMaTCPHa,OB /

oxpaHa, H 3aTpBaOT Ha I IpopCxsaHHeBOCnPOH3BOXlCTBO JiecOB H POcaH1BHTaHic

py6KU) AOXO.Qb OTffi I I uInecomaTepHaqoo_' ~ JIeCHbLe3eAsIp I(Py6KH rAaBHoros ~~~~~~ / l ~~~~~~~L nonib3osaHHR)fecmbie3esmAu

*DHHaHcHpyeTcq nO YCMOTPeHH1O MeCTHOr aaMHHHcTpaUHH B o06eMe OT 0 Ao 100% iiecHbIX nogage.OTMCeHeH 3aKoHoM o 4)eAepajIbHoM 6ioaKeTe 3a 1995 r.L HCTOIHHX: 1e2eaepalbHaA cAy)K6a AecHoro XO31RiCTBa PoccHH, 1996 r.

Page 92: Russian - World Bank Documents

PHc. 1.7: IlocTynAeHme cpeiacTB AmJ (uHHaHCHpOBaHHS nieCHOFO ceKTopa cornacHo

npOeKTy JlecHorO KoLeKca POCCHUCKOU (DeaepaIluH (HnOAb 1996 r.)

491 CZ)e2epaflbHoC (DeAepaAbHufl 4 ezepaybHue4-Xu HaHcnpaaaHHe 6IoIeT HaJorH JiIpyFHe

,RpyrHe 6iozKeTHbie HHaHCK)K T .iOXOKabeoT4H4cAeHHA q 040 Unu Ob

4'e.LIepaAbHaH ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ mnuaAHO/ \ M~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~nambi aa

/ Pe,reanb \ peeecuuy*cny)K6a iieCHoro 60 unu 100%

X03SIHCTBa MUNUMaAbHau\ _ / ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~cmaeKut , / A ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~nnambw3aa

PruHaEnJbBuIi dpeeecuHy*

OpraH-ImHr PerloHaAbHoe _ (o6JoaCTo, PH

npAoHH-o HfHaHCHPOBaHHe KpaeBOfl) 610ioXeT perHOHajibHoe

~~ ' S Pt i ~~~~~~~~~~Hanorm

I TeppHTopHa.n.,.. opraH iiecHoro

ACCOYCTpOR- X \

cTBo, aBHaAe- X035HCTBacooxpaHa, \

Hay9HbC I -

HHCTHTyTbE,

nOBbluleHHe eCTHUNKBanHflHKau. _ Npyrfe

(patioHHKn MeCTHue

IDio61 eT Hanor I

/ TIecxo3 \ yKIWOHHaR MHHHMaibHaR i

\ ecxo3 AYKLtHoHHaA CTaBKa nntaTu MMa_I "

Ha2l6aBKa C B rT 3eifapeBcCHHYApeHAHasl nniaTa,

onpelieeIACMa3 Ha ayKUHOHe

I I I Heo6naraeMue Ape(H)alnop yqacnKa ,lecioleo (I)oHOa

JiecHaj NHCflKIUIR, HaAlorom (,Iect?PO;IX03) JIeCHaA HHCnCKLHAun j || XO.RU OT, lC]otX3

oxpaHa, H 3aTpaTbl Ha I oI Heona6Ku r ,

BOCnPOH3OJICTBO JiecoB I IIPCBeCHHbl 06naraembie,I Heo6iaroeMue

0 | " (npu PYGKax HanoXoflbI OT i lOXob OTn , flpoMeKyTo.qHoro H nponaxu npoAaXKH JpeBecHHUnpo4ero nOJ1b3OBaHH eCU I

JIeCUble 3emAu

* B OCHOBHbIX perHoHax jieCOnpOH3BOICTBa npeaiiaraeTca OTIHCJIqTb B 4peztepa2bHbir 61OaKeT 40% noneHHOR

nnaTbl; B tpyrHx npeJAaaraeTcn ocTaBjiqTb B perHOHaJibHOM 6ioaweTe 100% MHHHMaTbHOH nonelHHOi ninaTbi.

** PerHoHaixbHoe 4fUHaHcHpOBaHHe npeaycMaTPHBaeT B OCHOBHOM BOCHpOH3BORCTBO jiecoB, a 4)eaepajbHoe4pHHaHCUpOBaHHe - B OCHOBHOM al1MHHHCTpaUHIO H ynpaBjeHHe JieCHbIM cOHfaOM H Hay4Hbie KccjieaoBaHKA.

1HCTO'qHHK: 4)enepajibHa cwiyiK6a jiecHoro xo3A4cTBa Poccuu, 1996 r.

Page 93: Russian - World Bank Documents

Ta6BH4ia 1.10: BioAceT .ieCHoro XO3giCTBa B 1991-1996 rr.(B InOCTOS1HHhX ueHax 1991 ro,Aa)

Pacxau,w if nIoc7yIV1HfR 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996

JICCoHHBeHTapH3aumSI 55,7 43,5 49,6 60,0 30,5 31,9ABNautioHHafl oxpaHaunecoB 129,1 157,4 150,9 181,0 141,2 167,6_OT nlOKapOB

nlpoeKTHo-H3bIcKaTernbcKme 23,1 12,0 17,6 17,1 15,0 12,5pa6oTbi

Jlecoxo3flucTBeHHbie 292,6 220,4 298,1 156,6 159,5 140,7MeponpH4sqTHHa

6opb6a C BpeamTeJn4ii 6,8 4,4 4,7 7,3 11,8 12,9JlecoMenwopauH.q/ocyweHHe 8,5 5,0 7,5 16,9 2,3 2,0BocnpoI3BoacTBO neca 170,0 125,2 135,0 128,4 82,3 74,3Ha3eMHaf oxpaHa niecoB OT 73,4 71,2 146,9 59,1 50,9 63,5_ noKapoBArponecoMe.nopauHlA 10,4 4,6 7,3 15,5 10,5 5,2TpaHcnopTHble ycjlyrH 6,5 3,4 3,1 0,6 4,8 4,5(noTpe6Tre.nsjM)

HaKnaaHbie pacxoabi 109,6 299,9 167,3 179,9 142,2 135,1(TexHHKa 6e3onaCHocTU/nOfarOTOBKa KaapOB)

OnnaTa Tpyaa COTPYaHHKOB 509,8 374,9 694,1 652,7 476,8 400,6.JecHoro X03liUCTBa

06u1as cymMa pacxoAoB 1399,0 1331,8 1557,2 1538,1 1171,3 1058,9

'DenepanbHbzl 6ioaxeT 1080,0 892,6 1082,5 1127,8 522,5 510,4Co6cTBeHHbie cpencTBn 305,0 247,2 240,6 248,8 387,5 334,0necXo30B

Peanti3auti JapeBeCHHbi 3,0 1,2 0,0 3,7 2,8 2,3Per14oHah!bHb1ri 6joazeT 11,0 107,6 168,1 95,3 116,0 79,7O6uwaH cymma nocTylJIeHHl 1399,0 1248,5 1491,2 1475,6 1028,8 926,4

Y6hITKM OT OCHOBHOH (83,4) (66,1) (62,5) (142,5) (132.5)_ AeT6JIbHOCrH_ pHMeqaHme: 100 1454 14472 58350 168747 248733_ ~~~~CoBoKynHbitH UtHAeKc

IloTpe6wTeJibcKHx ueH (%)6(HfliU)

a TaKHe BHab' pa6OT. KaK yxoa 3a HacaKaeHHRMH, caHuTapHbie py6KH, cTpomTejibCTBO nopor.

6 Pacc'IIbiBaancs, HCXORA U3 oueHOK cpeAHeroaoBoro COBOKynlHOrO I4fU, nOJlymeHHbIX MB0)/BceMHpHblM 6aHKOM HaocnoBaHH anaHHbIx rocKoMcTaTa P4'. CpeaHeroaoBoA unu (B UmCTOm Btiae), no oUeHKaM, cocTaBAnfl 1354,0% B 1992 roay,895,3% - B 1993 roay, 303,2% - B 1994 rozy ii 189,2% - B 1995 roay. flo 1996 ro4y NCnOlnb3oBajiKCb oueHKH MHHHCTePCTBa3KOHOMHKi4 Poccuu, corJlaCHo KOTOpblM HrnU COCTaBaIH 47,7%.flpHmiMe9aHae: t1n, onpeaejeHHlq ueHHOCTH py6neri 1991 roaa B KaiecTBe aedinHTopa HCnoib3obafl unuL.HCTOBHUK: 0PegepaabHaH c.y,K6a .necHoro Xo03.ACTBa PoccHH, 1996 oa.

Page 94: Russian - World Bank Documents

76

Ta6nHua 1.11: lIojis pa3HELX BHAOB npoH3BoAcTBeHHofi AeJwenbHocTH B o6uteM 6ioApKeTe

necHoro xo3ItkcTBa B 1991-96 rr.Ha OCHOBaHHU pacCeTOB B IOCTOSHHUlX lUeHax 1991 roAIa)

PaCxQwj H noc7ynVCHHem 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996

JAecotHBeHTapH3auHfl 4,0 3,3 3,2 3,9 2,6 3,0

ABHaUHOHHaSi oxpaHa JieCOB 9,2 11,8 9,7 11,8 12,1 15,8

OT nO)KaPOB

npoeKTHo-H3bIcKaTejlbcKHe 1,7 0,9 I,I I,I 1,3 1,2

pa6oTbl

J]eCoxo3sH4cTBeHHbie 20,9 16,6 13,4 10,2 13,6 13,3

MeponpHiiTslna

5opb6a C Bpeai4TeAqMti 0,5 0,3 0,3 0,5 1,0 1,2

JlecoMejIopauHSI/ocyweHHe 0,6 0,4 0,5 I,I 0,2 0,2

BocnpoH3no3IcTBo neca 12,2 9,4 8,7 8,3 7,0 7,0

Ha3eMHasq oxpaHa JieCOB OT 5,2 5,3 9,4 3,8 4,3 6,0

noxKapoB

ArponiecoMe.nHopauHin 0,7 0,3 0,5 1,0 0,9 0,5

TpaHcnopTHble ycnyru 0,5 0,3 0,2 0,0 0,4 0,4

(noTpe6HTenBM)

HaKiia,aHbie pacxoabi 7,8 22,5 10,7 11,7 12,1 12,8

(TexHuKa 6e3onacHoCTH/nOarOTOBKa KaApOB)

OnilaTa Tpyaa COTPYJUHHKOB 36,4 28,1 44,6 42,4 40,7 37,8

JiecHoro xo3arCTBa

06uas CyMMa pacxojoB 100,0 100,0 100,0 100,0 100,0 100,0

c1e,mepanbHblg 6ioJvIeT 77,2 71,5 72,6 76,4 50,8 55,1

Co6cTBeHHbie CpeaCTBa 21,8 91,8 16,1 16.9 37,7 36.1

Aecxo3oB

Peaj1w3autisi apeBecfiHbl 0,2 0,1 0,0 0,3 0,3 0,2

PerHoHanbHb1A 6ioaxeT 0,8 8,6 11,3 6,5 11,3 8,6

06wua CyMMa nOCTynneHHMi 100,0 100,0 100,0 100,0 100,0 100,0

Y6M'TKH OT OCHOBHOH (6,7) (4,4) (4,2) (13,8) (14,3)

AeHTenjbHOCrH

rlpiMeIaHHe: 3Ta Ta6jiHua OCHoBaHa Ha AaHHbIX, npHBeAeHHbIX B Ta6nuue 1.10.

HpHMepHO B 90% Bcex Jieco3aroTOBHTeAbHbIX pa6OT B necax TpeTbei rpynnbl

npHMeH5l1OT CnJIOLUHbIe py6KH, a B OCTaJlbHb1X cJnyqaqx - BbI6opO4Hbie H nIOCTenIeHHble

py6KH. npHMeHeHHe CIIJIOWUHbIX py6OK nIpHBeJIO K o6pa3oeaHHlo o6uwHpHbIx nnowuaLaeH

cnniloWHb1X Bbipy6oK, no TbICqqe U 6onee reKTapOB, l1TO B KOPHe H3MeHHJIO cpeay o6HTaHHq

XRHKIX )KHBOTHbIX U ypOBeHb 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3H5, Bbl3Bajio aerpaJaLu4o nOI B H apyrme

Bpe,aHbie 3KOJIoruHeCKHe nocneacTBH5l.

Page 95: Russian - World Bank Documents

77

OKOJIO TpeTH BCerl ApeBCCHHbl 3aroTaBJiHBaeTCT C HOMOab1O mexaHwieCKoroAecO3arOTOBHTeCjbHoro o6opyAoBaHU4A (Bano1qHo-naKeT4pyoLutix u4 BaAO4HO-TpeJleBO'HbIXMawlmH); a OCTaJbHbie o6ieMbi - pyqHOh BaAKOr4 C nOMOLubiO LCenHbiX nuri. B 6ojIbLUHHCTBepaUiOHOB neCo3aroToBHTeJbHbie pa6oTbl BeAyTCq TOJTbKO B 3HMHIe MeCCIubl (npHMepHO AoceMH MecCUeB B rog), KorAa 3aMep3liHf rpyHT nO3BOJISeT NcHOJb3OBaTb TqDKeCjoeo6opyAoBaH4e C MHHHMaWbHbIM yLuep6oM IAS fIOMBbI, a HH3KHe TeMnepaTypbl co3AaIOTAeASHbie MOCTbl, nO KOTOpbIM AeCOBO3bI MOryT nepeceKaTb WHHpOKHe peKH (ux WIHPHHaHHorAa rpeBblwUaeT ABa KHunoMeTpa). ATn MaKCHMH3aUHH o6'beMOB ripo43BOnCTBa B 3HMH4eMeCALIbI Ha MHOrHX MawHHaX YCTaHaBJ1HBalOT npo)KeKTOpbl, H OHH pa6oTaloT KpyrJlOCyTO'HO.

HoBble Tpe6oBaHH4H orpaHH'HBaIOT njioLuaaH JiecoceHbIX y4aCTKOB go 50 ra(HanpHMep, 500 MeTPOB Ha 1000 MeTPOB) Ha paBHHHaX H Ao 25 ra - B rOpHblX pagoHax. J,Anpy6oK npoMeCKyToiHOrO nOJIb3OBaHH5 9THU npeenJIbl COCTaBJ5IOT 100 H 50 ra,COOTBeTCTBeHHO. B Kapa6yne (KpacHoA¶pcKH4 Kparl) JICCO3arOTOBHiTeCJbHbie pa6oTbl BegyTCSno cneyioLuerl cxeMe: BbIpy6aloT nOJIOCbl B 500 MeTpOB WHpHHOA, Mecly KOTOpbIMHOCTaeTC51 50-MeTpoBaq norioca nieca B KateCTBe HCTOqHHKa CeMqH aA5i eCTeCTBeHHoroBO3o6HOBJIeHUi5. XOTA Ha nCpBblU B3rJia 3TOT MeTOA COOTBeTCTByeT HOBbIM Tpe6OBaHH5AM,ero HCnOhb3OBaHHCe rpH,BeAeT K o6pa3OBaHHlo 6oJlbWu4x nniowaAeu C co'eHb MaJb1M 3anacoMocTaBllerocs nieca. HoBble Tpe6oBaHH4, KpOMe TOrO, AOJ)KHbl H3MeHHTb Bce napaMeTpbl3aroTOBKH nieca (a He TOJIbKO pa3Mepbi IecoceK): OT pa3mepa BbIpy6KH HU nAOLuaAHOCTaBIwerocA paCTH iieca Ao MeTOAoB H CpOKOB 3arOTOBHTeJbHb1X pa6oT H HaJuIWH5 Aopor cTeM, qTo6bI OHH COOTBeTCTBOBaiiH cTporHM np4poaooxpaHHbIM HopMaM.

,aAi6s CH6upH H ,lanbHero BocToKa BOCnpOH3BOACTBO JIeCHbIX peCYPCOB OKa3ajiOCboco6o BaXKHoA H TpyaHOR 3aAaqeA, KOTOpaR Ao CUX nOp He peweHa, HCCMOTpq HaHCnoJb3oBaHHe Bcex 'eTbipex MeTOAOB Bocnpo43BoICTBa Aeca: eCTeCTBeHHoroBo3o6HoBJIeHHA, AonnHeHtuA rocaaKok, HCKYCCTBeHHoro noceBa H noCaaKH. Cer4qac eCTb6onbWiHe nJIouaBu C HH3KHM unH HynJeBblM YPOBHeM BO3o6HOEAieHH5 unA c npeo6naAaHHeMMaJIOueHHb1X BU4,fOB. ECTeCTBeHHOe B03o6HOBJieHHe Tpe6yeT no MeHbwer4 Mepe 100-neTHeroo6opoTa py6KH, H CYAA HO Ha6JlIoAaiolUHMCS ceWqac TeHAeHUHAM, TaKHe neca cKopee Bcero6yAyr conep)KaTb MeHee UeHHMC BHeMbl, 'eM Bblpy6JeHHbie neca. B TaKHX necax BTOpOrOHOKOJIeHH4 npeo6iazalOT M5rKOJIHCTBeHHb1e BHRbI THMM 6epe3bl H OCUHbl, KOTOPbieno,aBaHnoT TaKHe XBOuHbie FOpOLAbl, KaK COCHa H eAb H3-3a Hx 6o0iee MeCAeHHoro POCTa BnepBbie 40-50 AeT. H103AHee, no mepe cMeHbl paCT4TeAbHOCTH, XBORHbie HOpO,Abl OrlqTbCTaHOBATCH aOMHHHPYIOIWHMH BHAaMH.

C 1992 roAa pe3KO Bo3POcna aonm eCTeCTBeHHOrO BO3o6HOBJIeHH4, 'TOnPou30umoO cKopee Bcero no npH4qHe OTCyTCTBHs cpeaCTB Ha FOCaAKY Aeca, a He BPe3YnbTaTe o6OCHOBaHHoro nHiaHa AeCOBOACTBeHHOA AeeTeAbHOCTH. B Xa6apOBCKOM 14KpaCHOAPCKOM KpaHX Ha aOJl1O eCTeCTBeHHOrO BO3o6HOBJIeHHU4 nPHXOAU4TCS 80% o6,beMOBBOcnpOK3BOACTBa Aeca (Puc. 1.8), HO, rIOCKOAbKy HCHOJIb3yeMbie TaM CHlOCO6blJIeCo3arOTOBKH He COBMeCTHMbl c eCTeCTBeHHbIM Bo3o6HoBAeHHCM (HanpHMep, Hpu py6KeCOBCeM He OCTaBJlIH0T CeMeHHbIX LepeBbeB UeHHbIX BH4AOB), MHOrUie U43 3TUX nAoLua,LeriSABASIOTC HenpOAYKTHBHbIMH unuH nOKpbbBalOTC5 HH3KonOAHOTHbIMH Haca)1CeH1MMH.(HpHAWKoeHHe A coaepxK4T 6o0ee noapo6Hoe onHcaHHe JIeCOBOACTBeHHbIX CI4CTeM HTpe6oBaHH4).

Page 96: Russian - World Bank Documents

Hlljioma,b, B TbCSIcax ra

W- s w v Ut @ 00 \O o

1985

1986

1987 \

1988 00

r 1989

1990

1991

1992

1993

1994

1995 _ Io1996 -

o ri w

vo . | . I U I ^ 1993

tD S~~~c~

Page 97: Russian - World Bank Documents

79

B Xa6apOBCKOM U KpaCHOAPCKOM KpaAX pacnpocTpaHeHbi 60JIbWtHe 3aryULLeHHbIeLapeBOCTOH, HO5RBHBWUeCH B pe3ynbTaTe ycneWHoro eCTeCTBeHHOrO BO3o6HoBJIeHHq. npHryCTOTe aO HeCKOJIbKHX TbICAI aepeBbeB Ha reKTape ocTpaA KOHKypeHUHSA 3a CBeT HnHTaTenJbHbIe BelUeCTBa rIpHBOaHT K pOCTY MeJIKHX aepeBbeB C HH3KOU KOMMep'eCKOr4UeHHOCTbIO. TOT 4aKT, qTO BO MHOrux H3 3THX Haca)K(feHHII HHKOraa He rPOBOaHAH py6OKyxoAa, rOBOPHT 0 TOM, qTo npH Bbi6ope nFiomaaerl IAn npOBseeHHA J1eCOBOACTBeHHbIXMeponpHSTHhi He ripoBo1HTCA alHBua3 rOTeHuHaHJbHbIX 3aTpaT H pe3yAbTaTOB. Boniee Toro, BnoroHe 3a npH6bLJlblo B xoae CaHHTapHb1X py6oK BMeCTO 6o0JbHbIX MaJOUeHHblX aepeBbeBBbipy6alOT BbICOKOKaqeCTBeHHble LUeHHbIe 21epeBbAI. B pe3ynJbTaTe 'iero npOHCXOgAHTnocTeneHHoe yXyawgUeHHe KaqeCTBa H u1eHHOCTH apeBOCTOA, ITO npOTHBOpe'lHT LeJIHnpoBegeHHs CaHHTapHb1X py6OK.

Eoph6a c IiecHJMhH HowapaMHf, m8aceKoMMH H 60J13HIm

HoKapbi npHPOaHoro ripomCXO)eHHAR acTo cnoco6CTByIOT Bo3o6HOBJieHHIo nlecaH 3BOJIOLIUH nIeCHbIX 3KOCHCTeM. B CeBepHbIX par4OHax no eCTeCTBeHHb1M ipHmmHaM o6blqHOB03HHKalOT HH3OBbie riO)KapbI Manou HHTeHCHBHOCTH, KOTOpbie yH4qTO)KalOT CKOnHBWIIHeCSopraHHqlecKHe MaTepHaIbi H TeM caMb1M co3naLaOT yCAOBHA1 JIA npopaCTaHuTH ceMSAH HaOTKpblTblX MHHepaJlbHbiX HIOqBax. Ho no)Kapbi MOryT TaK)Ke HaHOCHTb OrpOMHbIir ywep6.foxcapbl BbICOKO1i HHTeHCHBHOCTH MOryT BO3ropaTbCA Ha 60.IbWlx Bblpy6Kax, a 3aTeMpacnpocTpaHATbCA Ha ripHeIKeaiu nieca. KOHTpoAHpyeMoe cKmraHHe JiecoceCHbIX OTXOLIOBHCnOJTb3yeTCA peAKO, nO3TOMY Ha BbIpy6KaX OCTalOTCs 60JIbllHe 06-beMbl 3TUX OTXOaOB,ABISIOLUHXC5 HaeanbHbiM rOpiOqHM, oco6eHHo B YCJTOBH14X 3acyX4, CTOJIb THnHqHbIX 1A15MHOrHX paUOHOB CH6upH Hi aanbHero BocToKa. KpoMe TOIO, CyL1eCTByeT CHJ1bHaA3aBHCHMOCTb MeCKIy JieCHbIMH ro)KapaMH H HaBJH4HeM aopor H peK, co32aaBaA ycTOsBHA1 ,1pa3JlH'HbIX BHIOB aeAlTeJbHOCT4 'ejioBeKa.

Ho aaHHbIM 4)e,aepajbHOA CAy)K6bi nieCHoro XO3ArUCTBa B POCCHH e)KeFOaHOPeriCTPHPYeTCA go 34.000 JIeCHbix roxcapoB. npHMHHOA 6onee 70% J1eCHbix ro)KapoB, noOLIeHKaM cneuHaJIHCToB, ABJsAeTCA qeoeecKaA aeATeJIbHOCTb. MHorHe poCCHuuCKHefleCOBOAbl C4HTalOT rOixKapb UeHTpajIbHOrU ripo6JleMoo, OT peweHHR KOTOpOH 3aBHCHTCOCTOAHHe n1eCOB H oKpywKaiouwei Cpeabl. OrpoMHbie nrIOLLa,H nIeCHbIX pecypcOB, HeXBaTKaHeo6xoa4Moro o6opyaoBaHHA H 4FHHaHCOBbIX CpeaCTB OrpaHH4HBalOT oxpaHAemyio nAowaabCaMb1MH OnaCHbIMH B 3TOM OTHOweHHH TeppHTOpH4AMH. B IOXHbIX paroHax CH6HpH HgaajbHero BocToKa, OXBa'eHHbIX cJIy)K6aMH oxpaHbl nieca OT nO)KapOB, B CpeaHeMBO3ropaeTCA no 10.000-15.000 no)KaPOB B ro0, Ka,blii H3 KOTOpblX riopaKaeT 100 ra neca (BLtenJoM Ke ywep6 cocTaBj15eT 1,0-1,5 MnH. ra) H npHBOat4T K OrpOMHbIM 3KOHOMHMeCKHM,COUHaTbHbIM H 3KOJIorFHeCK4M noTepsM. (PacnpeaeneH4e pOCCUH4CKUX necOB no HXnpelpacHoJIO)KeHHOCTH K ro)Kapam H MecTa HaXOxKAeHH5i 6a3 aBHBaecooxpaHbi noKa3aHbl HaKapTe IBRD 28353).

HaceKOMble-Bpe,aTe.nH H 6ojie3HH TaK)Kxe ABAIOTCS npHPpOaHbIM4 4)aKTOpaMH,HrpaoLWHM Ba)KHYO pOJIb B 3BOjiOULHH JIeCHbIX 3KOCHCTeM, HO, KaK H B cJy"ae C rToxapaM,6e3OTBeTCTBeHHaA qeejo3eqecKas eAeTeCJbHOCTb MOxceT Bbl3BaTb 3HaqtTeCJbHoe yBenJI4eHHeHHTeHCHBHOCTH H xiaCTOTbI BCnbIleK MaCCOBOrO pa3MHo)KeHHR BpeaTeJleri HJIuHpacripocTpaHeHHA 6ofle3Heg. 94XeKT4BHOH 6opb6e C Bpeal4TeJmmiM H 60oe3HqM4,pery HPOBaHHIO HcJIeHHOCTH rIonyYjAHrUi HaceKOMbIX H npo4IHjiaKTH Ke 6oie3Herinpenr5TCTBYIOT nnioxoe nHJaHHPOBaHHe H HeaOCTaTOK cpegCTB. ExeroAHO BpeagTeJIH H

Page 98: Russian - World Bank Documents

80

6ojie3HH nopa)KalOT B cpeaHeM Lo 1,5-2,0 MUJIJIUOHOB ra JIeCHblx nHAoLuaReru. K HaH6oJIee

paclpocTpaHeHHbIM BHaaM HaCeKOMbIX OTHOCSTCH: cK6HpCKHii wejiKoflP5,a HenapHbIlu

IwejiKonpslg, uejiKonp5ia-MoHaiueHKa, nHIeHHUbl, COCHOBaq COBKa H o6bIKHOBeHHbIlA

COCHOBblUI nHHnnbMUK. 061umH ymep6, HaHOCHMbilk BpeD,HTeI5IMH H 6oAe3HqMH BO BpeMS

BCrbiuweK, He MeHbwue, eM ywep6, HaHocHMbIl no)KapaMH. FOMiMO noKapoB, BpeaiTeJleg

H 6one3HeA, B HeKOTOpblX paHOHaX Ha pOCT nieca H Ka'-eCTBO apeBec4Hbi noBJHitJIH TaKue

aHTponoreHHbie 4)aKTopbi, KaK 3arps3HeHHe Bo3yxa u4 3apaKeHHe paaHoHyKJH,anaMH

(Kharuk, 1993). OcTpoTa H onaCHOCTb TaKHx noBpeAKgeHHri H nJIoLuaab d)aKTYAieCKm

yHH'lTOWKeHHbIX (B OTJIHn44 OT riopa)KeHHbIX) B cHuy pa3Hbix 6eaCTBHr4 nieCOB no rogaM

pacnpeaejuiioTcsi HepaBHoMepHO (PHC. 1.9).

E. Bn iHHHe nepexoga K pUHOMHOA 3KOHOMHKe

C 1992 roga PoccHfil ao6HIaCb 3Ha4HTeCJbHbIX ycneXOB B pe4opMHpOBaHH4

3KoHoMH4ecKog nOA4THKH. Ebina npoBeaeHa KpynHeHiwaS B UCTOpUH nporpamma

npHBaTH3auHH; Cyl1eCTBeHHO fl6epajIH3oBaHbI UeHbl, BajilOTHblg KYPC H BHeWUHqI TOprOBJIA;

a TaiOKe 3Ha4HTeCJbHO yKpenneHa 3KOHOMHi4ecKaI H d HHaHCOBaq CTa6HJIbHOCTb. TeM He

MeHee, TpyRHOCTH nOJIHTHteCKOrO Bbi6opa CoxpaHqIOTCH. bIOaKeTHbIe OXOabl iH pacxoabi

no-npeXKHeMy Tpe6yIOT cyLueCTBeHHor4 KOppeKTHpOBK4, a eLUe He ocyLUeCTBAeHHbIe

KJiOMeBbie CTpyKTYPHbIe pe4DopMbi CTaHYT CYpOBbIM CHnbITaHHCM cnoco6HOCTH

npaBHTeSbCTBa aep)KaTb KyPC Ha 3KOHOMH'eCKyIO pe4)opMy.

3KoHoMH4ecKHe H couLHaJIbHbie npo6neMbl nepexogHoro nepHoaa 0Ka3anuJCb

BeCbMa cepbe3HbIMH. 1 2 no CpaBHeHI10 C 1991 roaoM, BBn COKpaTHACI npHMepHO Ha OaHY

TpeTb, B pe3ynbTaTe qero CHH3HJICS YpOBeHb )KH3HH H yXYaI4JIOCb pacnpeAenieH4e AOXOAOB.

EIoa eTHbie nIOCTyniieHH5 Ha beaepanlbHOM YPOBHe coKpaTHJIHCb npHMePHO c 16% OT BBn

(1992 rog ) go 10% (1995 ron). BJIaCTH nblTabiT4Cb HagTH rnTH coKpaiUeH[4s pacXoaOB, HO

AoCTHr'JH THWb tiaCT4qHoro ycnexa.

npH coxpaHeHH14 HeYCTOrMuHBOCT 3KoHoMH'eCKori cHTyaUHH Bce 6o0Iee

OT'leTJIHBO BbIpHCOBbIBaiOTCA TpH jaKTopa, KOTOpbIe MlelOT OCHOBonojiaralowee 3HaqeHHe

=A 6yayuAero poCCiUCKoU 3KOHOMUKU. Bo-nepBblX, CaBHI B CTOpOHy OpHeHTHpOBaHHOiI Ha

pbIHOK 3KOHOMHKH CTaJI Heo6paT4MbiM, a qaCTHbl ceKTop pa3BHBaeTCq ropa3ao 6blcTpee,

meM C'HTaJIOCb B03MOKHbIM paHee. Bo-BTOpblx, pe3KHK pOCT UeH (B KOHUe 1992 roaa Ha

rpaHH rHnep4HH4JILUHH4), KaxeTCH, y)Ke no3agH, a TeMnbI 4Hd)JSUIUH 3aMeWI4ii4cb. B

TpeTb4X, XOT$ B 1996 roay Bce eLue npoaoji)KnaTOCb coKpaMeHI4e 3KoHoMHteCKor4

esTenbHoCTH, Cnag npo03BoAcTBa, cyAs no Bcemy, npeKpaLuaeTcq, H o3gopoB.neHI4e

3KOHOMHKH npoHCXOaHT 3a c'leT Tex cAy)K6 H BKROB ae5iTeJIbHOCT4, KOTOpbIe, cKopee Bcero,

6y,ayT 4rpaTb Bce 6o0iee BaViHYIO POJlb B AOJIrOCpO'IHOM 3KOHOM4CeCKOM pa3BMTHH POCC4H.

PaLI4KanbHble 3KOHOMH'eCKHC nepeMeHbl, KOTOpbIe cer'-iac riepeu)KBaeT PocCHA,

6yayT HMeTb KaK KpaTKocpoIHbie, TaK H aoirocpoqHbie HocJieACTBUR XJI5 niecHoro ceKTopa.

Pe4opMa npHBeJia K o6oCHOBaHHOMy riOBbleHHI10 ueH Ha 3Hepri'io H TpaHCnOpT, Ha

KOTOpble go 3Toro BbiaenCJI5ACb 6oJIbWuie cy6cHgHH, a TaK)Ke K CHHUKCHH1O cnpoca Ha

,apeBeCHHY CO CTOpOHbl CTpOHTeJlbHOU H uejijifJO13Ho-6yMa)KH-O4 oTpaCJIeH. COKpalUeH4e

12 a'OIn0HMbHTenhyIo HHHOpMaL(HIO 170 3KOHOMif CCKOR CH1TyaL(IfR MOKHO HaOTH B I7OCJJeaHCM cTpaHOBoM

MeMopaHAyMe BceMHpHoro 6aHKa o6 3KoHOMHvecKoM no7a,oJeHHH PoccUH (World Bank, 1995e).

Page 99: Russian - World Bank Documents

PHc. 1.9: HpHqHHhi rH6eJIH iiecHbix HacaaQeHHH", 1984-95 rr.

500 .

450* HloAapbi

400

e 350 C- HpoMbihireHHbie300

Bbl6pOCblt 300 -* He6aaronpHsMble

F 250 -*yCJIOBHM IOrOal

_ HoBpeaeHHA200 -HKHMH AKHBOTHblMH

= 150 U *ojIe3HH jieca

100 _ BpeaHbHe

50 HaceKOm eL

0 LO (o oo C0 0) 0 N o) 10cO co co co co co 0) 0) 0) 0) C)0) 0) CY) 0) 0) 0) CY) 0) CY) 07) 0)

HCTOqHNK: 'Dejaepaiu,uan caIyw6a .iieCHoro x031UNcTa P(D, 1996 r.

Page 100: Russian - World Bank Documents

82

rocy,aapCTBeHHbIX pacXoAoB npHBejiO K CHmwKeHHIO pa3mepoe qpeaepaAbHoro 6ioaxeTHoro

4MHHaHCHpOBaHH4A (B peanbHbIx noKa3aTeiilx) necHoro ceKTopa. CoKpaLueHHe o6'beMOB pa6oT

B TaKHX o6JiaCTX XiecHoro XO351HCTBa, KaK oxpaHa, 3auHTa, BOCnpOH3BOaCTBo .neca H yXoa 3a

Haca)KaeH4IMH, a TaK)Ke cpeaCTB, BbiLeJSleMbIX Ha HayKy, noBJ]eqeT 3a co6o0 nOTeHLIUanJbHO

cepbe3Hbie, oJrocpoqHbie oTpHuaTejibHbie rocjieaCTBH5 451 yCTOHPiHBoro pa3BHTHR ceKTopa.

nepecTpoAKa TaK)Ke CTaiia OLHOA H3 npH4HH Hapyu1eHH5I nprTBbIqHOrO yKxiaaa )KH3HH OKOJIO

10 MJIH. qejiOBeK, )KH3Hb KOTOPbIX HenOCpeaCTBeHHO 3aBHCHT OT JieCHbIX peCypCOB. C

COKpaBUeHHeM 3aHATOCTH B JieCHOM CeKTOpe aKTHBH3HPOBanJHCb TaKHe BHRbi aesTenbHOCTH,

KaK OXOTa H lIpyrHe npoMbICJIbI, oco6eHHO B oTTajieHHbIX paioHax, rge Manjo

3KoHoMHqecKHx aAbTepHaTIB. TaKas 6ecKoHTpoAbHaq Harpy3Ka Ha nonYjIlLLHH ,aHKHX

)KHBOTHbIX, BepORTHO, 6yaeT HMeTb aoJIrocpoqHbie oTpuaTeHbHbOe nocJeaCTBHs AAR

6Hopa3Hoo6pa3Hs, oco6eHHO, 3TO CKa)KeTCS Ha pe)IK4X H Hc4e3ailOUX BH4,LaX CH6HpH H

JIaAbHero BocToKa (CM. npH4Io)KeHHe 1I). PHc.1.9

YcneuiHas MaKPO3KOHOMH4eCKaA pe4JopMa H COOTBeTCTBY1OWHe H3MmeHeHH5 B

necHof nOJIHTHKe MoryT o6JIerFHTb 6peMS nepexoAHoro nepHoaa H co3LaaTb OCHOBY Anu'

C6aJnaHCHpOBaHHOA I1OJ!rCpOvHO4 peopraH43auH iieconpoMbILwjeHHbIX oTpacneri POCCHH.

ToJnbKo B 3TOM cjiyiae nOqBATCS pecypcbI H CTHMyJIbl, Heo6xoaHMbIe x]5 coxpaHeHHHR H

3aLUJ4Tbl YHHKanJbHb1X IieCHbIX pecypcoB POCCuH. 14To6bi co3,aaTb B03MO)KHOCTH ,Ani

AoJlrocpoqHoro njiaHHpOBaHHUA AeCOX03sIiHCTBeHHOti aeqTeJ1bHOCT4, nOarOTOBKH KaaPOB,

Hay'HbIX HCCAieAOBaHHfl H )KI43Hecnoco6Horo npOMbiwIeHHOrO pa3B4THS, Heo6xoaHMO Ha

BCeX ypOBHSIX rocyaapCTBeHHOrO ynpaBjieHHuI npOMHO YTBePAHTb KOHUenuHio yCTOiNHBOrO

pa3B4TI4.S. F3oJTee COBepwueHHoe ynpaBjieHHe pecypcaMH H paUHOHajibHaS ripoMbIwUieHHaA

,ae.qTejibHOCTb CTa6HjiH3HpyIoT 6a3y 3aHqTOCTH B jieCHblX pakoHax.

CTHMynJbl, nOqB4BWH4eC5 B CBS3H C nepexo,oM K pbIHOqHOH 3KOHOMHKe, yBeJIuqaT

B03MO)KHOCTH HHBeCTHpOBaHHA B pa3BHTHe fleCOnpOMbIHjieHHbIX oTpacJ1eri B paHiOHax,

o6na,alowuHx OTHOCHTejibHbIM npeHmyleCTBOM B 3THX OTpaci5ix (HanpHMep, Ha CeBepe

EBponeHCKOHi MaCTH POCCHH H Ha ,LanbHeM BocToKe), H 6yayr cnoco6cTBoBaTb 3aKpbITHIO

YCTapeBLUHX 3aBOAOB H 3aMeHe cTaporo o6opyAoBaHHs B Ma0oJeCHbIX paiOHax.

Jleco3aroToBHTeJbHbie H aepeBonepepa6aTb1Baiolui4e npeRnp2HTTHH OKawKyTc5I nepea A1HLtoM

)KeCTKOr4 KOHKypeHLLHH Ha MHpOBbIX pbIHKax, m ripaBHtTebCTBY HY)KHO 6yCaeT YCTORTb nepe,n

HallC4MOM CO CTOpOHbI npOMbiUIJ1eHHOCTH nO Bo3o6HoBneHHiO TpaHCnOPTHbIX cy6cuuiW.

PeaiHCTH%MeCKHe ueHbI Ha 3HeprHio H TpaHCnOPT BHeCYT 3Haq4TeAbHbie H3MeHeH HR B

reorpaH4qecKoe pa3MeWeHHe ,aepeBonepepa6aTbIBaioLuHx npeanpl4pqTH4. no mepe

npH6JiH)KeHHA TaKHx npeanpHIATH4 K iiecaM 6yayr cyiUKeCTBeHHO yBeCIH4BaTbC5R

nepCneKTHBbI pa3BHTHlR KoHKypeHToCnoco6HoH HpoMbbliwjeHHOCTH B TaKHx paHOHax, KaK

EBponeAcKaR qaCTb POCCHu H )jUaj1bHHi BOCTOK (CM. HpHJIoKeHHe r).

B CBA3I C Heo6xoLi4MOCTbIO YCTaHOBJieHHH B 6flZHxaifteM 6yayueM )KeCTKOr4

MaKpo3KOHOMi'-IecKoI AHCUHnrIA4Hbl, iiuua, OTBeTCTBeHHbie 3a pa3pa6oTKy H npoBeaeHHe

AeCHOA nOOJIHTHKH, ROJIKHbl COCpeaOTO4HTbCH Ha pqae KJIIOqeBbIX 3afaa, KOTOPbIe MmelOT

HaH6onee Ba)KHoe 3HaqeHHe anR 6ynyLuero. K TaKHM 3anaqaM cJieCyeT oTHecTH: qeTKoe

onpe,aeAeHHe npHOPHTeTOB KaK Ha qLeRepaAbHOM, TaK H Ha MeCTHOM ypOBHqX, fSI

CO1eUCTBHS yCTO0I44BOMy pa3BHTHIO AeCHoro ceKTopa, MaKCHMH3aULtH5 BaJIOTHbIX

HOCTynrieHHH nyTeM oc1a6.neHHq Bcex OCTaBWHIXCA orpaHHqeHHri Ha 3KCnOpT necHou

npOAYKULuH, co3,aaHHe yCJIOBI4A, npH KOTOPbIX COKpaLUeHi4e 6toa)KeTHog nOIWep)KKH He

Page 101: Russian - World Bank Documents

83

nocTaBHT noa yrPO3Y LojirocpOqHYIO cTa6HJIbHocTb JieCHoro ceKTopa, a TaKxce co3LIaHKACHCTeMbi CO[UHaJIbHOgi 3aLUHTbl AAA HaCeJieHHA OTTaJieHHbIX feCHbIX patIOHOB.

B cpeaHeCpoyHog nepcneKTHBe, yBeiKHMeHHe lOXOAOB, OCTaiOWUHXCR nocnieynniaTbl HanOrOB, H HeKoTopoe nocna6neHHe 6ioaxeTHbIx orpaHK4eHHui npHBeaeT KO)KXHBeHKIO BHyTpeHHero cnpoca Ha ApeBeCHble CTPOHTeJfbHbIe MaTepHajbIH UejiAoJIo3Ho-6yMaNCHy[o npoAyKUHIO. H1oBbiweHHe cnpoca Ha apeBecKHYy npHBeaeT K nOBbilwleHHio ueH,MTO nO3BOJIHT HeKOTOpblM npeanlHpSTHSM 6onee oT2aneHHbIX pariOHOB Cu6upu K )anbHeroBOcToKa B03o6HOBUTb npOH3BOLCTBO K Co32aTb ztepeBOnepepa6aTbIeaiOuwe MO1LHOCTH,o6pa3ylOLUme Ao6aBMeHHyIO CTOHMOCTb. Yy'yqweHHe 3KOHOMH4eCKHX YCJIOBKU aOJIKHOTaioKe paCIIIWHHTb nepCnTeKTHBbl Ha PbIHKe 1 yBeJIHUHTb I1pH6bLJIH OT ApeBeCHbIX KHeapeBeCHbIX JieCHbIX HpOgYKTOB MeCTHOro npOH3BO,CTBa.

Page 102: Russian - World Bank Documents

84

1. KjllOMEBblE 3A'A11 J1ECHOrO CEKTOPA B nEPEXOAHbiA nEPOUOA

nlepexon K pbIHO4HOH 3KOHOMHKe BbIlBHJI B JieCHOM ceKTope POCCHu MHoro

CKpblTbIX npo6fieM. ,JH nepeBoaa ceKTopa Ha 3KoAorFHieCKH, 3KOHOMi4'IeCKH H couHanjbHO

3,LOpOByMO OCHOBy, nO3BOJISIOKWYIO BHOCHTb CTa6HJIbHbIr BKTIaa B 3KOHOMH4ecKoe pa3BNTHe

cTpaHbl, ero Heo6xoai4Mo CpO4HO ped)opM4pOBaTb. BonpoCbl co6CTBeHHOCTH H

OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH 3a yripaBnieme JIecaMH nOMTH Ha HOnOBHHe TePPHTOPHH POCCHUCKOU

(De,aepauHH Bce ewe He nOJIy'uH4JI 4eTKoro H SACHoro peweHH5, H eCJnu 3Ty CHTyaLI4IO He

HcnpaBHTb, OHa Mo)KeT npHBeCTH K ewe 6o0nee o6wmUpHOri AerpaRaLaHH oKpy)Kalowueg cpeabl.

HecMOTpS1 Ha 3Ha'HTeflbHyIO MOLUHOCTb npOCTaHBaioLui4x aepeBonepepa6aTbIBaIouHxHpeanpHA1THU, HeKOTOpbIe parOHbl HCHlbITbIBalOT Re)HU14T Cblpbq. FlpearipHS4THAI ZeCHOro

KOMnAeKca HeCYT TaKoe )Ke TADKejioe 6peMq HajioFOB H HeonpeaejieHHOCT4 B aeJIOBOM

KJiHMaTe, KaK rpeanpfl4THu1 apyrHx oTpacjierl, HO HX pa3MeLueHHe B oTaajieHHbIX paioHax H

oco6asi cTpyKTypa 3aTpaT ycyry6nRloT H 6e3 Toro TADKeCjoe norio)KeH4e. B To We BpeMA npu4CylleCTByIOweH CTpyKType 3aTpaT AeconpoMbIuwjeHHbIe npeanpH4ITHI4 He Bbiruaqi4uaioT

Bjla,eJlbuaM pecypcoB TOUi HOpMbI npH6buTH (B qopme noneHHOR nnaTbl, HaniorOB 3a

HCnOJIb3OBaHHe 3eMjiH H apeHaHoH nnIaTbI), KOTopaA COOTBeTCTBOBanTa 6bl 3aTpaTaM

nocneaHHx.

np4pOny Heo6xoaHMbix KopeHHbIX H3MeHeHHA B ynpaBneHH4H neCHbIMu

pecypcaMl4 POCCHH onpe,aenqIOT cieapyIowue qeTblpe 3a,aaqH:

* Co3,aaHHe BeILOMCTBeHHO-rTpaBOBbIX yCJIOBH gin paLIUHOHaJIbHoro ynpaBJeHCHi

AecaMH, T.e. ynopAaoqeHHe UpaWBOBO OCHOBbI co6CTBeHHOCTH Ha IieCHbie 3eMj1H H

yrpaBjieHHA HMH nO Bceri cTpaHe, BKAloaMA 4eTKoe onpeaeneHHe H

rapaHTpoaHHoe ocylWeCTBseHHe ripaB KOpeHHOrO HacenjeHHu1 Ha 3eMJiH H

pecypCbl.

* CoxpaHeHHe yCTOiqHBOCTH pecypca H ueJIOCTHOCTH OKRP_XaJOIWeJ Cpe,IX , T.e.

YTBep)ueHH4e nOAO4THKH H HHCTHTYUHOHanjbHbIX CTpyKTyp, o6ecne'u4BaiowHx

coxpaHeHHe H paUHOHanbHoe HcnOJIb3OBaHHe JTeCHbIX pecypcoB H LieTKO

oripeaeimnmoux ponH rocyaapCTBa, 4aCTHoro ceKTopa H KOpeHHbIX HapOAHOCTeH.

* YCTaHOBjieHHe TaKHX UeH Ha peCypCbl, KOTOpbIe MOryT o6ecneY4Tb

HeHCTOLLtHTeAbHOe H 3KOHOMIPIeCKH BbirOaHOe pecypconOJIb3OBaHHe, T.e. co3AaHHe

TaKHX yCJIOBH4, B KOTOpbIX KOMMep4eCKHC nOJlb3OBaTeJIH .TeCHbIX peCypCOB

npO4yBCTBOBaJIH 6bl Ha ce6e peanbHbie 3aTpaTbI H pe3ynJbTaTbI pa6oTbl necHoro

ceKTopa 3a c4eT OTx4HcAeHH5 rocyaapCTBy aOCTaToqHo 6oAbWori ,OJIH CTOHMOCTU

pecypca H nepeBOn BCeX 3aTpaT Ha aepeBonepepa6oTKy Ha KOMMepqeCKHX

nOJIb3OBaTeJieH.

* COL(HaffbHOc o6ecneqeHHe B JIeCHOM CeKTOpe, T.e. C03,aaHHe TaKHX yCJIOBHr4, npHKOTOpbIX COUHaJUbHO H 3KOHOMHWeCKH Y53BHMbie rpynnbl HaceJAeHHq, OCO6eHHO

KOpeHHbie HapOaHOCTH, He CTrpaaAiH 6bl BO BpeM5i nepexoaa K pb[HKy.

Page 103: Russian - World Bank Documents

85

A. BeAoMcTBeHHo-npaBoBbie yCJIOBHuS palXHOHabHoaO6HO ynpaBjieHHA

B nepeXOAHblrU nepHOA HeBO3MO)KHO H36e)KaTb HH oripeaejieHHbIX KOHWJnHKTOBMex(y 4be,lepajIbHbIMH, perHOHaTibHbIMH H MeCTHblMH HHTepecaMH, HH OCTpbiX npo6.neM(bHCKanbHoro veaepaHW3Ma.13 Ho 3THM KOH4JIHKTaM HeJIb3A nO3BOJIqTb 3acJOH5Tb co6o0OCHOBonojiaraFoLUY1O 3aiaay onpezenieHHA BeaoMCTBeHHbIX o6A3aHHocTeA H HOJ1HOMO4HIi no34XjJeKTHBHOMY yrpaBJeHHIO JIeCHbIM ceKTopoM.

B YCJIOBH51X pbIHO4HO9 3KOHOMHKH AAA OHTHMaibHoro pa3MeCueHH5I pecypcoBoqeHb Ba)KHa BO3MO)KHOCTb repe,aaqH npaB IOJIb3OBaHHA nIecaMH, 6AaroAapq KOTOpOUpecypcbi MOrYT OKa3aTbCA B pyKaX HaH6ojiee KBajiH4bH4uHpoBaHHbIX Xo3AeB, noJIy'alouIHX HXHa OCHOBaHHH KOHKYpCHbIX TOprOB, apeHRHbIX H apyrHX AOrOBOpHbIX MeXaHH3MOB. TaKHeMexaHH3Mbl nOBbliHalOT 3aHHTepeCOBaHHOCTb necoBnagenbueB H apeH,aTopoB B coxpaHeHHHKanHTaYIbHOH CTOHMOCTH nieca nyTeM paULHOHajlbHOrO yipaBjieHHS 3THMH XO3AiCTBeHHbIMHcy6beKTaMH. MeA1ayHapoAHbIH onblT OaHaKo roKa3al, ETO noLao6Hbie 34)4)eKTHBHbIepbIHO4Hbie CHCTeMbI peaKO pa6oTafoT npu OTCYTCTBHH CHnJbHOU H 4yHKQgHOHaAbHOACHCTeMbi rOCyaapCTBeHHbIX 3aKOHoaaTeJIbHbIX rpe6oBaHH4i H aeriCTByIOIUHX MeXaHH3MOBKOHTpOJIS 3a HX BblnOJIHeHHeM, o6ecneqHBaloLuHx 3aIUHTY HepblHOqHbiX riojie3HOCTeH JneCOBu ocna6neHHe MOHOnOJIHCTH4eCKOH BJTaCTH pbIHKa. TaKaA CHCTeMa ynpaIBeHHH aOJnXHa6blTb:

* VeTKoI K HoHoTHO-, OHa AOAI)KHa aaBaTb ACHoe H o6ocHoBaHHoenpe,aCTaBseHHe 0 npaBax H o65T3aHHOCTAX rOTeHUHaJbHbIX3aHHTepeCOBaHHbIX CTOpOH H OCHOBbIBaTbC5 Ha aoArocpO4HbIX3Ko0orJ11HeCKHX, 3KOHOMH4eCKHX H COU4HaJIbHbIX ueJIAx.

* CnpaBe,lNwBof H COBMeCTHMOA C HaUHOHaJIbHbIMH uenAMH pacrpeaeaeHHq,aOXOAOB, '-To6bi ee MO)KHO 6buio C4HTaTb 3aKOHHOA H CnpaBedVHBOi BW14pOKOM CMblcMc 3Toro cCoBa.

* KoHTpOJnpyeMOI0N, T.e. aeCMTeTbHOCTb pecypconoAb3OBaTeCJeg AOA)KHanoaAe)KaTb KOHTpOJIO H OUeHKe, oco6eHHo 3TO KacaeTcs TeX aeACTBHri,KOTOpbie MOrYT CKa3aTbCS Ha npyrHx pecypconoJIb3OBaTenAlX H ueHHbIX4byHKUHA1X pecypca.

* C6aJJaHCHpOWaHHOJ4, qTo6bi noTpe6HocT4, CBq3aHHbie C ynpaBJ]eH4empeCypCoM, COOTBeTCTBOBaJIH OwmUaeMbIM pacxoaaM Ha q3eaepanbHOM,perHOHaHubHOM H MeCTHOM ypoBHAIX.

$DenepanbHoe HpaBHTfelbCTBO He MOxKeT pa3BHBaTb CeKTOp TO.bKO CBOUMUCHJiaMH. Ho TOJbKO ipaBHTeSjbCTBO MO)KeT o6ecrje4MTb Bbl[OJIHeHHe 3THX YCJOBHH CrOMOWbIO COOTBeTCTBYIOwerH CTPYKTypbi npaB H pelyIHpoBaHHSI. TaKas CTpyKTypa O1JDKHanOMOqb rpaBHTeJIbCTBy B AOCTH)KeHHH 6o0iee MacWTa6HoA uenjH pbIHO'HOH peCJopMbl, CTaBOCHOBOH AAS yMHo)KeHH5, 3aWHTbl H HCnoJIb3oBaHHI JieCHbIX pecypcoB, nOCKOTIbKy OHaMOxCeT rOBbICHTb yBepeHHOCTb nOTeHUHtaAbHbIX HHBeCTOpOB B CTa6HInbHoCTH HOBOU CHCTeMbIHU nOJHTHKH. Be3 TaKoro 'IyBCTBa 3aLuHLueHHoCTH, pa3BHTHe AeCHoro ceKTopa, cKopee Bcero,norkaeT Mez)ieHHo, H cMeCTHTTCS B CTOpOHY KpaTKOCpoqHOh 3KcrinyaTaumH B yLuep6

13 06cyaeHMe Ipo6&eM B 3ToM pa3waeme OCHOBaHO B 3H8aVfTe7bHoAR MCpe Ha ?laHHblx H3: Wai1icih, 1994.

Page 104: Russian - World Bank Documents

86

,Rojnrocpo4HoiA 3a6oTe o6 oxpaHe, 3aLUHTe, BOCnPOH3BOaCTBe H HeHCTOLUHTenJbHOM OCBOeHHH

nieCOB.

'aCTHaf AM IOCY,aapCTBCHHaf C06CTBCHHOCTh

B POCCHu HeT HiKaKmx npH3HaKOB HaIiHqHA nAaHOB npHBaTH3uipOBaTb neCHble

yroQIbA, 3a HcKJIIoMCHHeM 3eMejib, TBepaO 3aKpenueHHbIX 3a ceAbCKOXO3IRiCTBeHHbIMH

npeC,npHTHSAM4. YKa3oM npe3HLeHTa OT 24 aeKa6pq 1993 roaa ckeaepanibHbie neca

OTHeCeHbI K o6fteKTaM, "He rioaJexaUHM lpHBaTH3aLui", ITO nOnopa3yMeBaeT coxpaHeHHe

4eaepanbHo4 rOCyaapCTBeHHORi Co6CTBeHHOCTH Ha IieCHbie 3eMjTH. PertioHbl ociapHBaIOT

TaKyIO TpaKTOBKy H CTpeMSTCq K 6o.nbmefi aBTOHOMHH B ynpaBAeHlB H CBOHMU iiecaMH.

Cer4qac y)Ke BeayTcq neperoBopbi no 3TOMY BOnpOCy. Jbo6oe H3MeHeHHe B (opmax

co6CTBeHHOCTH uuiH o65I3aHHocTqx no ynpaBnieHHIo noTpe6yeT KOppeKTipOBKH

HHCTHTYULLOHanJbHbIX 4YHKLUHH H tLIenie BceX 3aHTepecoBaHHbX CTOPOH (CM. HlpHAo)KeHHe

B).

Bonpoc o co6CTBeHHOCTH Ha JieCHbIe 3eMJIH Be3,ae lBJSieTCS npeameTOM CnOPOB H

npOTHBOpe'iHfl. B cTpaHax C OrpaHH'eHHbIM4 BO3MO)CHOCTqMK rocyaapCTBeHHoro

a,M4HHHCTpaTHBHOrO ynpaBjieHHu1 nOnbITKH UeHTPanJbHOrO npaBHTenJbCTBa YCTaHOBHTb

CTpOrHF[i KOHTPOJIb Haa nIecHbiMu pecypcaMH, ynpaBeieH4em HMU H c6bITOM 3TUX pecypcoB

4aCTO oKa3blBanJICb 6e3ycneWuHbIMH, H B KOHUe KOHUOB, 6bUIH npeKpaI1eHbI. CTpaHbI C

xopowIo OTJIaKeHHbIMH MeCTHbIMH CHCTeMaMH KOHTpOJI5 H yrnpaBJIeHH5, KOTOpbIe Co

BpeMeHeM pellaJIHCb Ha HanuoHanu3aLuHo nIeCoB, o'eHb CKOpO npHuJIH K pa3pyUeHHIO

CHCTeMbi ynpaBjieHHS Ha Bcex ypOBH3IX. ,la)Ke CTpaHbl C XOpOlIlo pa3BHTbIMH CHCTeMaMH

a,MHHH4cTpaT4BHOrO yripaBJTeHHA B ueHTpe, HanpHMep, KaHaa, ae,ueHTpan43OBarH

KOHTPOJIb Haf nIecaMH, 4laCTH4'Ho nepejaB ero o6lUHHaM KopeHHorO HaceCJeHHS4 H JIeCHbIM

npeanpivTHAM. B CHlA ao cHx Hop OCTaeTC Hepa3peeHHbM cnop o poJnu 4)eaepajibHOrO

npaBHTeTbCTBa B opraHH3auHH 3eMjienOJIb3OBaHHR H 0 B03MO)KHOCTH nepeaa'IH ynpaBJIeHH5

HaLIUHOHaJIbHb[MH rapKaMH B BeLeHHe WTaTOB. KaK nOKa3bIBaeT OnbIT 3anaaHori EBponbl, He

MeHeC Ba)KHO H TO, 4TO6bi npuH 'aCTHOA co6CTBeHHOCTH Ha JIeCHbIe 3eMJI cylueCTBOBaniO

,ROCTaTO4HO CHJIbHoe 3aKOHoaaTe TbHoe peryJIHpOBaHi4e, o6ecneHBalOLIee BbiHOJ1HeH He

J1OJ1FOCPO4HbIX HaUHOHanJbHbIX 3aAaq yrBpaJieHH5 pecypcaMH.

BbI6op CTpaTeriHH BAnaaeHH41 JIeCHbIMH 3eMjniMH He CBOa14TCS K pewleHHiO TI4na

"Bce nJIu HHqero". Beab riiaBHoe - He caM Bbi6op CTpyKTypbl co6CTBeHHOCT4, a TO, 'ITo6bI

Bbi6paHHal cTpyKTypa npH4MeH5iaCb cnpaBeaAJIBo H nocie.gOBaTejlbHO, 6bula 6bl sCHO9 H

HOHITHOH H HMena npaBOByl0 3aLuHTy. B TaKHX yCJIOBHIX ynpaBneHHe 6yaeT OlpeLeISTb

TeMrbI H HanpaBnieHHe pa3BHTH51 iecHoro ceKTopa. B CWA, HanpiMep, JTeCHble 3eMJIH

Haxo,1U1TC1 B CO6CTBeHHOCTH 4beaepaJIbHoro npaB4TeJIbCTBa, HpaBHTeJlbCTB WTaTOB, niiMeeH

KOpeHHOrO HaceJIeHHu, iieCOnpOMbIUjieHHbIX KOMnaHlH4 H Bna1enjbLteB TaK Ha3bIBaeMbIX

HenpOMblUjieHHbIX 4aCTHbIX nieCOB (BaaenbLueB He6OJIbLlux y'aCTKOB, Ha KOTOPbIX MO)KeT

npOBO1aHTbCSI aKTHBHaq XO3SACTBeHHaR aeqTeAbHOCTb C LeJIbio npo43BOLCTBa ApeBeCCHbl H

,apyr4x npODYKTOB HJun He rlPOBOal4TbCI. UIOMT4 BO BCeX CTpaHax M4pa HeflpOMbILUJIeHHbie

,-aCTHbie fiecoBsiaaeHuI4 qBJIqIIOTCq KpyHHOA KaTeropHeg Co6CTBeHHOCT4, BKIKIOua.OLeH KaK

rpo,ayLu4pyIoLue, TaK H HenpoayuHpyioLuHe iieca (Ta6nHiia 2.1). )J.oAq rocyaapCTBeHHOr4

co6CTBeHHOCTH 3Ha4HTeJIbHO pa3IiH'aeTcR Ho CTpaHaM: B KaHaue - 94%, B POCCHu - 95%, a

Ha ceBepo-3anaae THxOOKeaHcKoro no6epeKbq CWA - 35%.

Page 105: Russian - World Bank Documents

87

Ta6AnHua 2.1: Hnoua,Ab HenpoMbmyiJeHHLX qacTHELx iieCHbIX 3eMejibB OTarebHblIX cTpaHax MHpa, 1983 roA

CrpaHa VaciliMe JcXHre 3MffH (Mmn. ,) $ oT o6mek KOJINqeCTaO CPCaHHI1AneCHOi IZo0lJ4a/j Ri4Il4aafules P83MCP

(peCroH) (MsH.) Bfa4emmR (IN)

nlpo,ay- Heypqay- BceroLINPYIpo- LiipylOlLwfie

ABCTptiS 2,465 0,160 2,624 68 H.a. H .A.

KaHaaa 14,227 0,724 14,951 6 0,500 29,9

EBPOCOK)3 15,636 2,677 18,312 59 H.a. HJ.A

SnoHmh H.1. H.A. 14,706 58 5,650 2,6

CKaHAFIHaBHU 29,509 2,601 32,111 57 1,365 23,5

HCcnaHHR. 7,944 10,765 18,709 73 0,826 22,6

WlBeguapii.q 0,301 H.A. H.a. 26 0,252 1,2

CW1A 112,550 H.A. H.a. 58 7,558 14,9

H.A. HeT aaHHbIXHCTOrHHK: Plochmann, 1983.

)KH3HeCnOCo6HOCTb KpynHOMacwTa6HOA npHBaTH3alU14H J1eCHbIX 3eMenJb MOryTorpaHHQHBaTb onpeaeJeHHbie 3KOHOMHqeCKHe, a TaK)e nOJ1HTHqeCKHie aKTOpbI, HanpHMep,lJIHTeCJbHOCTb LIHKJIOB JIeCOBbipalLIHBaHHfl B POCCHH (100-120 nieT). TeM He MeHee, MHorie

4JYHKUHH lieCHOrO XO351HCTBa, HaXOUALu1HeC5i cerHYaC B pyKaX rocyaapcTBa, MoriiH 6blBblHOJIHSITbC5I 'aCTHbIM CeKTOPOM (OT c6opa H aHaIH3a HHBeHTapH3aLtHOHHbIX aaHHbIX aOJieco3aroToBHTeJIbHbIx pa6OT, OXpaHbl, 3aWHTbl H BOcnpoH3BO4CTBa J1eCHb1X peCYPCOB Hyxo,aa 3a nIecoM).

On'pI4CfefCHHe pOfff IocYaapCCHHMX C7pyKT7yp B JIeCHOM ceKTope

lJAJq FiiiaHHpOBaHH5 H ynpaBhIeH4H iieCHbIMH pecypcami POCCHH HYKHa ropa3ao6o0iee qeTKO CbOKYCHPOBaHHaS1 H CKOOP,l4HHpOBaHHaA1 cTpaTerHSI. B HacToAwee BpeM51Me)KY TpeM5i OCHOBHbIMH BeaoMcTBaMH, oTBeIaioLU1HMH 3a ynpaBJIeHHe nIeCHbIMHpecypcaMH, Ha6niioaaeTc3 BecbMa HH3KHA YPOBeHb B3aMHoaeACTBH4 H KOOpRHHaLUHHcTpaTerHi. $eaepanbHaR cly)K6a AecHoro X03ArHCTBa oTBeeaeT 3a opraHH3auLHO BseeHHiqJIeCHoro xo3s1HcTBa, rocyaapCTBeHHbIH KoMHTeT no oxpaHe oKpyxKa1ower CpeA,bl(3aMeHHBWHHA MHHHCTePCTBO oXpaHbl OKpy)Kaioluerl CpelIbl H 1 pH4pOUHbIX peCypCOB) - 3acoxpaHeHHe peCYPCOB H OXpaHy OKpyxcaiolueH cpeabl, a roCyAapCTBeHHbilU KOMHTeT noJ1eCHOH, aepeBOo6pa6aTbIBajou.e U H LueJI1 OJ1O3Ho-6yMa)KHOri lpOMbILwJ1eHHOCTH(rocKoMAecnpoM) ABAS1eTCS aepxaTeJTeM aKUHUi 60obWi4HCTBa aKUHoHepHbIX npeanpHSlTHi

Page 106: Russian - World Bank Documents

88

niecHoro ceKTopa H KOHTPOJ1HpyeT HCHOJIb3OBaHHe pecypca (6o0nee noapo6Hoe onicaHiHe CM.

B HptJiO)KeHI4I B). B npoLlecce np4H.T[H pelweHHi Ha npOT5DKeHHH BCeH' HCTOpHH

,aOM4HHPYIOT npoMbIUjiCHHbie HHTepecbi, a jiecOXo33IAcTBeHHbie H nppOpoOOXpaHHbie

ripo6AeMbi OCTaIOTCq 6e3 aOJDKHOrO BH4MaHH45. aO TCX nop, nOKa 3TTH TpH BeaOMCTBa He

Ha4HYT aeACTBOBaTb B3aHMOCBq3aHHO, nlpOBLBH)KeH4e K HeHCTOLaHTe.TbHOMy HOJ1b3OBaHHKO

JieCHbIMH pecypcamH 6y,LLeT KparlHe orpaHH4CHHbIM.

TaM, rAe pa3Hoo6pa3He ITeCHbIX pecypcoB npeanoAaraeT Ha.niiHe HeCKOIbKHX

anJbTepHaTHB OpraHH3auHH MHorouejieBoro noJIb3OBaHHS4, aAJ5 KOHKpeTHOrO yllaCTKa JIeCHOA

3eMJuH MO)KHO Bbi6HpaTb rniaBHYIO ueiib (cKa)KMe, coxpaHeHHe 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3H,l oxpaHa

nO4B H BOL Ha Boaoc6opax HniH pOMbmliwjieHHOe rpoH3BOaCTBO apeBeCHHbl). 3Ta riJaBHaq

eLenb BeLeHH4 XO3RIACTBa onpeaejiAiia 6bl H THn Heo6X,oaMok opraHH3aLUHOHHOI CTpyKTypbl,

a TaKiKe Tpe6oBaHHH no b4HaHCHpOBaHHiO. HanpHMep, opraHH3auHH, OTBeiaiowaa 3a

coxpaHeHHe KaKOrO-TO HaLIHOHanJbHOrO napKa HjiH apyroro 3anOBeaHOrO o6fteKTa, KaK

npaBHJIo, 6yaeT HMeTb OrpaHHi4eHHbie B03MO)KHOCTH AAA BO3MeCLeHH5I BCeX 3aTpaT.

PaLuHoHajnbHoe ynpaBJeHHe JiecaMH B03MO)KHO TOJTbKO B TaKOM KOHTeKCTe HCnOJIb3OBaHH45

3eMeJIb, KOTOpblU o6ecne4HBaeT 3KOJIorIHeCKH 3,apaBoe, 3KOHOMH4eCKH 4)KH3Hecnoco6Hoe H

COLLuaHbHO npHeMjieMoe pacnpejenieHHe pecypcoB no BHMaaM noJb3oBaHH4.

TaKH4M o6pa3OM, opraHH3auHH, oTBe4a1olLHe 3a 3aLuHTy nIeCOB, OJD)KHbl HMeTb

npe,aCKa3yeMbig HCTOHiHHK 6ioaxeTHoii noNLep)KK4,H npeCOCTaBJ1eMorI TeM YpOBHeM

rocy,aapCTBeHHOH BJIaCTH, KOTOpblU HeceT OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a 3Ty KOHKPeTHY1O ueeib

ynpaBjieHH.s. TpyTaHOCTH, CTOqLLHHC nepea 3anOBeaHHKaMH POCCHH (niloLua,iH,

npe,aHa3Ha4eHHbIe JAn51 COXpaHeHHH 64opa3Hoo6pa3H4I H noaUep)KaHHSI OXpaHeMblX

3KOCHCTeM), OTpaxKalOT noTpe6HocTb B HcHOJIb3OBaHHH o6iumx MeTOaOB ij1aH4pOBaHH41 H

bHHaHCHpOBaHHS4. 3anOBeaHHKH 4HHaHCHIpyOTCA1 H3 (beLepajibHoro 61oaKeTa, HO

br4HaHCOBbIe npo6neMbl, KopCHqLuH4eCq B cerOaH5HWHHX 6io0)KeTHbIX TpyaHOCTqX

43e,aepaJlbHOrO ripaBHTeJlbCTBa, rpO3IT CBeCTH Ha HeT BCe, 4To 6blJIO aOCTHrHYTO B 06.naCTH

OXpaHbl H 3aWLHTbI HpHpOLHbIX peCypCOB, BKJioLIaA nTeca.

TaM, r,e HpOMblwJleHHOe npOH3BOTUCTBO tlpeBeCHHbl MO)KeT CTaTb riiaBHOH ueJlblO,

rOCy,aapCTBeHHbl CeKTOp Mor 6bl COXpaHHTb npaBO CO6CTBeHHOCTH Ha 3eMj11O, nepeaaBaAi

ipaBO Ha HpOH3BOaCTBeHHyIO eAlTeJIbHOCTb, BKJIot ali nIiaHHpOBaHHe H yrpaBeHue

'IaCTHbIM rHpealHpH5ITHAM. aAJIS Toro, 'TO6bi OnpeCgejilTb, KTO 6yaeT BCCTU X03ArUCTBeHHyIO

,afleTeJIbHOCTb H npH KaKOM YPOBHC UHTeHCHBHOCTH, noTpe6yfOTCSI 3Ha'l4TeCJbHbie

rOCyLRapCTBeHHbie HHBeCTHUH4 B npouecc pacnpe,ejTeHHA 3eMeJib. [Iociie pacnpeaeneHHfA3eMejib B COOTBCTCTBHH C uejlfIMH yI1paBBAeHHl4 HpaBHTeJlbCTBO aOJIKHO p14H51Tb

o6ocHoBaHHble H peajiHCTH'-IHbie pewlleHHli nO YPOBH51M 6ioaeTHOA nrioaep)KKH, KOTOpy1O

CMOryT o6ecreiH4Tb JeLLepaJbHoe ripaBHTeJIbCTBO H perHOHbI ,D.Jfl ,OCTH)KeHH5 pa3jiH'IHbIX

ue.ieri. FOcyaapCTBeHHas co6CTBeHHOCTb Ha 3eMJIIo, HUcnOJIb3y5l CBOIO CHCTeMy

3eMjieIOJ1b3OBaHH H CTpyKTYPY peryjlHpOBaHHs4, MO)KeT 3aCTaBHTb npe,4lHPHI4THq aaBaTb

nOJIHbIi OTteT 0 CBOCU aefTeCbHOCTH. TaKHM o6pa3OM, rOCyaapCTBeHHbie paCXOabl (Ha

pa3HbIX ypOBH39X) MOrIJIH 6bl B OCHOBHOM HUTH Ha pa3pa6OTKy, BBeaeHHC H KOHTPOJilb 3a

co6rnoAJUeHHCM jieCOXO33I4CTBeHHbIX HOPM H Tpe6OBaHHA.

O6,q3aHHocTH PoccuH no nOanUHCaHHblM edo Me)KAyHapOLUHbIM KOHBeHUHSiM no

COXpaHeHHlO 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3Wq OKpy)KaIoLUeH cpeLLbl TO)Ke 6yayT OKa3blBaTb onpeaeneHHoe

BnUIHHe Ha npouecc npHHHlTtiq pewneHH4. PerHoHanbHble opraHbl BjaCTHu H -aCTHble

4l34pMbi MaJIO 3aHHTepeCOBaHbl B ao6pOBOJlbHOM BHeapeHd4H TaKHX JICCOX03,qkCTBeHHbIX

Page 107: Russian - World Bank Documents

89

CHCTeM, KOTOpbIe COOTBeTCTBYIOT 3THM o65I3aTeJIbCTBaM. )IJI5 BbinOJTHeHH5I Me)CAYHapOaHbIX

o6M3aTeJIbCTB cCeaepajibHOMY npaBHTeCJbCTBY npHaeTCq CaMOMy npHHHMaTb

HenocpeaCTBeHHoe "aCTHe B yHpaBJIeHHH JiecaMH, yqpCaHTb 344eKTHBHyIO CHCTeMy

perynHPOBaHHM H KOHTPOJIS 3a co6AioaeHHeM 3aKOHOB H ripaBUJI BeaeHH5I X035IHCTBeHHOU

IaeATeAbHOCTH Ha 3eMAe, a TaK)Ce 'eTKO onpeaeJIeHHyIo CHCTeMy MeK610j1KeTHb[XTpaHcqpepTOB, HnJI Bbi6paTb CO4eTaHHHe 3THX nOaXOaOB.

nocAe peCeHUni B sonpoca o d3opMe co6CTBeHHOCTH H ynpaBJeHHH3 cAegymoUerKpynHOH 3aaaqeg 5Bsn>eTCS pacnpeaeAeHiue JOXOaOB H paCXOROB B npeaejiax H cpeatL pa3Hb[X

ypOBHeU rOCyaapCTBeHHOrO ynpaBJeHHA - OT fegepaAbHOrO aO o6.nacTHoro H paHoHHoro. Bo6LeM, pacnpeaenieH4e pacxo4o0B aOJ1)KHO OCHOBbIBaTbCq Ha reorpa4bHqecKoMpacnpOCTpaHeHHH COOTBeTCTBYIOWIHX ripeHMylLteCTB, B COOTBeTCTBHH C TaKHM IIOaXOAOM

Ka)KxLlbH YPOBeHb aaMHHHCTpaTHBHOFO ynpaBeHiCHHI rpeaoCTaBJI5eT H qkHHaHCHpyeT Te

yCnyFH, BbIFOabl OT KOTOpbIX OCTalOTCA B npeaejiax ero rpaHHu. TaKHM o6pa3oM, Te

o6uIecTBeHHbie yCJIyrH, pe3yJlbTaTbl OT npeHOCTaBTeHBI4 KOTOpbIX He yXOaqT 3a npeAeenbipaHoHa, AOJDKHbI ripeHIOCTaBASTbCS par4OHHbIMH opraHaMH ynpaBAeHrs, ycJlyrH,OXBaTbIBaloLUHe HeCKOJIbKO paHOHOB, aOJDKHbI npeRoCTaBJIATbC5I Ha perHOHaJIbHOM ypOBHe, a

npeaoCTaBneHHe Tex YCJIyr, KOTOpbIe paCnpOCTpaHAIOTCH Ha BCIO CTpaHy, AOJDKHO

o6ecne, H BaTbCI 4Je4epajIbHbIM npaB4TejibCTBoM.

Ho 3TOT npoLjecc OCJIO)KHqeTCq 6blCTpbIM H3MeHeHHeM xapaKTepa npearipHRTHA H

opraHOB rocyaapCTBeHHOrO yrpaBAeHHm. HeKOTOpble o6'beKTbi COUHaAbHOA c4Depbi, KOTOpbie6buiH nepeaaHbl OT rocy,apCTBeHHblx ripearipH5THH MeCTHbIM opraHam BJTaCTH, MorJIH 6bl

6blTb Hlp4BaTH3HpOBaHbJ, XOTS MHoriHe 143 HUX OTHOCATCA K KaTerOpUH o6LueCTBeHHbIX 6niar HaOJTXKHbI ckHHaHCHpOBaTbCH rocyaapCTBOM. Bce 9TH (tYHKLUH4 HaUO onpeaeAHTb H

pacnpeieteiTb nO COOTBeTCTBYIOLLLHM YpOBH5IM rocyaapCTBeHHoro ynpaBJeHHI4. ,);InS TOrO,

'TO6bI KaK~ablH YPOBeHb 6bm1 o6ecne'eH aoxoaaMH, AOCTaTOxH4lMH b 5Aq BblnOJIHeHHH 3THX

paCXOaHblX o6B3aTeJlbCTB, Heo6xoai4Mo Co3aaTb CHCTeMy pacnpeaeeueHiHs HaJIOrOB, aOXOaOB H

Me)K610io eTHbIX TpaHc4bepTOB.

B nieCHOM ceKTope ceH'lac HeT aeHcTyCoIiwero MexaHu3Ma yCTaHoBJIeHHSI

COOTBseTCTBMH Mexuty o6Hq3aHHOCTqMM nO BblnOJIHeHHio 61ofceTa H HaiiHiHueM 4DHHaHCOBbIX

peCypCOB Ha MeCTHOM H1IH HauHOHanYbHOM ypoBHe. B nepByIo o4epeAb Haao peLuHTb, KaK

ciieC3yeT HCnOJb3OBaTb aOXOabl OT HpHpOLAHbIX peCypCOB, H KaKOBa AOJDKHa 6blTb CTPYKTypa

HaJIOrOB H PeHTHbIX HnnaTe)Keg 3a HCnOJIb3OBaHHe rHppOaHbIX peCypcoB, a TaK)Ke

CdjOpMHpOBaTb MexaHH3M c6opa HanoFOB H pacnpeaejeH4HH co6HpaeMbIX TaKHM o6pa3OM4HHaHCOBbIX CpeaCTB.

HOCTynIieHHS4 OT npoaaxH npHpOaHb[X peCypCOB 4aCTO ripeBblwalOT 3aTpaTbl Ha3KCnjiyaTauHio. '4aCTb 3TUX peHTHbIX nAaTe)Keh AOJDKHa 14aTH B rOCyaapCTBeHHYIO Ka3Hy.3KcnjlyaTaLunsi IpHPORHbIX pecypcoB -lacTO BAeqeT 3a co6ori 3Ha-HTCJIbHbIe 3aTpaTbl HaCOLIHaAbHbIC HyX4(bl: OT 3aTpaT Ha Co3,RaHHe o611eCTBeHHO9 HH4)paCTpyKTypbl 1O 3aTpaT,cBA3aHHbIx C gerpazaau4eg OKpyxKaiOLJer Cpe4bl, BKJlio'aR 3aTpaTbI Ha ee OqHCTKY H

BOCCTaHoBjieHHe. B KOHe4HOM HTore, BIa,aeJbubl pecypca (B 60obl4UHCTBe cjiy'-aeB - 3TO

rOCy,aapCTBeHHblrH CeKTop) aOJDXHbl nOJ1yqaTb OT nOAb3OBaTeAer4 KOMneHcaUH1Ho He TOAbKO 3a

HCHOJIb3OBaHHbie pCCypCbl, HO H 3a HapywJeHu>, OKpyxaioLteH cpeabi, CBq3aHHble C

npoueccoM 3arOTOBKH nieca, a TaK)Ke KOMneHcaHuClO 3aTpaT Ha JiecOBoCCTaHoBneHHe.I4CnOJIb3OBaHHe TaKO H CHCTeMbi Hl4PBCzeT K TOMY, 'ITO iaCTHbie npealHPHRTH41 6 yayT

Page 108: Russian - World Bank Documents

90

npO,aaBaTb noTpe6HTejiRM CBOIO npogyKutito no 6onee BbICOKHM ILeHaM, BKJlio4IaoLuHM TaKHe

HX 3aTpaTbi, KaK nriaTy 3a JHLHeH3HIo, noneHHyio nrnaTy, lilTpaqJbI H peHTHbie oTqHcjieHHI4.

Cpa3y nocnie YCTaHOBj1eHHq MexaHH3MOB, nO3BOJIS101UHx npaBU4TenJbCTBY B3HMaTb

peHTHyio niiaTy 3a 3KcnjiyaTauHio nIecoB, Heo6XO14MHo npHSHTb peuweHHe no pacnpeaeneHuIlo3THX aeHer. 9TU aOXOgbi MoryT BbiAejiqTbCS KopeHHOMY HaceJIeHHlO, npO)KHBalOLUeMy Ha

npoLyKTHBHbIX 3eMjiSx Hun HeLaaieKo OT HHX, Hun MYHHuHnaJIHTeTaM, pa4oHaM HA1

aBTOHOMHbIM oKpyraM. BBeaeHHe 6o0ee cnpaBeAe1iBoA H flpO3paqHOr4 cHcTeMbiMe)K6io,llKeTHbIX 4bUHaHCOBbIX OTHOweHHir 6yaeT cnoco6CTBOBaTb aOCTHXeHH10

AOrOBOpeHHOCTH nO nOAHTHueCKH CnOpHbIM Boripocam pacnpeaejieHHu OXOaOB OT

npHpOLHbIX peCypCOB.

B. CoxpaHeHHe yCTO 'HBOCTH pecypca H itejiOCTHOCTH oKpyxaoouKel cpeAbi

nepeXOx4 K 3KOAOHrqeCKH HeHCTOIUHTeJlbHOMY HCnOAb3OBaHH1O 3eMeJlb nOqTH Ha

nOAOBHHe Bceel TeppHTOpHH CTpaHbI ABJIqeTCS OqeHb Tpy1HHOr 3aAaqeu. Ha YPOBHe nOAMTHKH

camoe Ba)KHOe - onpeAeJIHTb napameTpbi pecypcHoi 6a3bI cTa6HAbHoro npOH3BOACTBa,

CpaTeruHo AecoynpaBJeHHS H ripaKTMHecKHe Mepbi no coxpaHeHHIO yCTOAP1HBOCTH pecypca H

enJIOCTHOCTH oKpy)KaioLueH cpeAbi. B pamKax pa3JIHqHbIX MeeKLyHapOAHb1X HHHuHaTHB

POCCHuR npMHHMaMia yqaCTHe B pa3pa6OTKe KpHTepHeB H HiHAHKaTOPOB paUHOHaJlbHOrO

yrIpaBJIeHHs AieCaMH (cM. nIpHiO)KeHHe 4). HX MOXHO 6bLno 6bl HCnOAb3OBaTb npul

pa3pa6oTKe KOMnHeKcHog CTpyKTypbI IOAHTHKH H nporpaMMbI ee peaAHu3aUHH B ueJIxCOXpaHeHH2 yCTOU'HBOCTH pecypca. B npouecce 3TOfi pa6oTbl POCCH4I MO)KeT TaKwe

o6pawaTbcA 3a nOMOI1bIO K MeXlaYHaPOIIHOMY coo6iueCTBy, BKAlOqaq BCeMHpHbli 6aHK

(CnpaBKa 2.1).

YToYHeHHe HapaMeTpOB pCCypCHON 6a3M4111 C6a/iaHCHpOBHHOlFt pOH3BO,CTB lpeCBCCHHM

HeCMOTpSI Ha TO, 'TO neca PoccHM 3aHMialOT orpoMHbie nHoOuaaH, MHorHe H3

HHX HaXOaSITCq B CYPOBblX KIHMHaTHqeCKHX YCAOBH5IX, 3Ha'HTeJAbHO orpaHMqHBaloiu4x HXHOTeHHuHaI pOCTa. MHoro nIeCoB HaXOaHTCS TaKlKe B oTAaJeHHb[X paHOHax, KOTOpble BpSUI

AH OKa)KYTCH 3KOHOMH-eCK14 aOCTyrHbIMH. KpoMe Toro, MHOrHle IeCHbie MaCCHBbl HMelOT

HaCTOAbKO BbICOKyIO 3KOJOrMqeCKYIO LeHHOCTb, 'ITO MX yHHqTO)KeHHe MO)ceT HaHeCTH

HenOnpaBHMblM Bpea 3KoAor0HH H WHBOTHOMY MUpy aaHHOA TeppHTOpHH. MHorHe H3 AerKO

,LOCTynHbIX AecOB, oco6eHHo Te H3 HHX, KOTOpbie HaxOa5lHTC5 B6AM3H UeHTPOB nepepa6oTKH

ARpeBeCHHbl H TpaHCnOPTHbIX KOpH2iOpOB, nO,LBepraJHCb Hpe33MepHOH 3KCnHyaTaL4K, B

pe3yAbTaTe nero 3aBHCHlLHe OT HHX npeAnpHMTHR necHoro ceKTopa OCTa1HCb 6e3HopManbHO4 necopeCYPCHOH 3OHbi. Bo MHOrHX 6onee AOCTynHbIX paHoHax qA5

BOCCTaHOBJeHHH HCTOiueHHbIX py6KaMH neCOBs RO ypOBHS, Ho3BOA.9IOLLerO BeCTH B HHX

HOBbie AeCo3aroTOBKH, noTpe6yioTCs aeCMTHueTH$I. ETLHHCTBeHHO BO3MO)KHbIM BbIXOLOM AAS

nepepa6aTbiBaiowHx rpeaUnpHSTHR 6e3 HaAe)KHOA CblpbeBOU 6a3bi RBnASeTCS HX 3aKpblTHe

HAH nepeMeLueH4e.

rpH onpeaenAeHHH pacqeTHoA AecoceKM CTpaHbI B ueLOM BonpOCbI

3KOHOMHtieCKOA ,OCTynHOCTH nieCOB H npOaYKTHBHOCTH fieCHbIX 3eMeAb, BnHqioLUHe Ha

Page 109: Russian - World Bank Documents

91

CnpaBKa 2.1: Tpe6oBaHatsi BcemHpHoro 6aHKa no PaIIHOHaB3bHOMY ynpaBneHHIo H HeHCTOIUHTenbHOMYnflJ1b3OBHH1i necaMH

Pa6oTa BceMHpHoro 6aHKa B iieCHOM ceicrope HanpaBneHa Ha cAep)KHBaHtie npouecca YHH4To)KeHlHi niecoB,nOBbiweHHe npHpOAOOXpaHHOH pojnu nOKpblTbIX 1ecoM lomWaaek, oKa3aHHe COaeHCTBIHI B jiecopa3BeZeHHI,CHHuKeHHe YPOBHq 6eAHOCTH u coaeACTBHe YCTOWsHBOMY 3KOHOMHqeCKOMY pa3BHTHIO (World Bank 1991). BaHKnpeAocTaBnHeT KpeuHTbI Ha pa3BHTHe AeCHoro ceKTopa TOAbKo npH yCJIOBHM, 'iTO nlpaBHTeJibCTBO B03bMeTo6a3aTeAbCTBO o6ecneqHTb co6rnoaeHHe npHHLLHnOB yCTO1qUiBOrO pa3BHTH,9 (T.e. paUHOHa31bHOCTH HHeHCTOILUHTeJbHOCTH JIeconojib30BaHHq) H npHpOaOoxpaHHYIO OpHeHTaUmiO ynpaBAeHIH JlecaMH.

3To O3Ha'aeT cjieJlyiomee:

* nOJIHTHKa H HHCTHTyUHOHaAbHaq cTpyKTypa OJA)KHbI o6ecneLiHBaTb coxpaHeHHe H HeHCTOUWHTeAbHOeHcnoIb3oBaHHe CyyIeCTBYIOLUHX nieCOB, C nOMOulblO COOTBeTCTBYIOWUX CTHMYJIOB cnoco6cTBoBaTb 6oneeaKrHBHOMy y4aCTHIO MeCTHOrO HaceAeHHA H U aCTHOrO ceKropa B aOj]rOCPO14HOM ynpaBjieHHHeCTeCTBeHHbIMH AecaMm.

* YTBepg,aeHHe KOMnAeKCHOrO H 3KOJoruHteCKH paUHoHanlbHoro niiaHa AeACTBHA no coxpaHeHHIO 11OCBoeHHIO neCOB C 'eTKHM onpe4ejleHHeM pojiH H npaB npaBHTejibcTBa, 'laCTHoro CeKTopa H MeCTHbIx)KHTeAeri.

* nlpoBeaeHHe COLIHaIbHbIX, 3KOHOMHmeCKHX H 3KojiorH'eCKHX OLteHOK COCTOHHUH Tex niecoB, KOTOpbIenpeanonaraeTci OTBecTH noa npoMbIlieHHoe HCnoJib3oBaHHe.

* OrBoR nnoiagem noA 3anOBelHbIe 3OHbl C UenjblO COxpaHeHHa 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3HH H 3aLJHTbI HHTepeCOBo6tiTaTeAei1 IeCOB, B 'aCTHoCT'r, HX npaB co6cTBeHHOCTHH aocryna K onpeaejieHHbiM y'aCTKaM Aeca.

3KOCHCTeMHoe yHpaBJIeHHe, ABHO He yMHTbIBaIOTCS, 'ITO npeyMeHbwIaeT aKTyaSjbHOCTbCpOlHOrO peweHHA H3AO)KeHHbIX BbIle rHpo6JieM. I4MeioIuH4ecq OUeHKH QaIOT HeaOCTaTOqHOHH4)OpMaLxHH aiiJ nHAaHHpoBaHHI. JllnH cTa6HnbHoro '4aCTHorO HHBeCTHPOBsaHH5 B JIeCHOr4CeKTop HHBeCTOpaM Ha,ao 6yaeT 3HaTb, y KaKHX ripeaITpHATHA B o6o3pUMoM 6yayiueM 6yaeTCOXpaHHTbCM )KH3Hecnoco6HaA pecypcHam 6a3a H rae B03MO)KHO co3,aaHHe HOBbIXCTa6HJIbHbIX npeHnpHsTHu.

Ji,AA 3Tomo Heo6XoaHMo HcnOJIb3OBaTb KOMrfleKCHbIir npouecc rTIjaHHpoBaHHH,OXBaTbIBa1OlWUH ripo6JieMbI, CBA3aHHbie C 3aKpbITHeM H nepeMetueHHeM rpOH3BOaCTBeHHbIXMOIuHOCTeH, H HO3BOJIAIOL[UHR BbUIejHTb Te rUIoluaa4,, Ha KOTOPbIX nlpOH3BOaCTBO IIpeBecHHblMO)KeT 6bITb 3KOHOMH'-eCKH H 3KoAorHeCKH )KH43HeCnOCo6HbIM H HMieOTCAI HaH6oJiee6naronpH>sTHbie BO3MO)KHOCTH ,DIAS yCTOAIHBOFo H 3KOJIorwHeCKH HelCTO1LHTeCJbHOFOnpOH3BOACTBa apeBeCHHbl. Bo H36e)KaH4e aaAbHeiiwei aerpagauHH iecopecypcHou 6a3bl KoKpyKaiolueg cpelabl Heo6XOrAHMbI KOpeHHbIe H3MeHeHH51 B jiaHHpOBaHH4H H HpaKTHKCJIeCO3arOTOBHTeJIbHbIX pa6oT.

TaKou KOMrAeKCHbli IOaXOa K ruaHHPOBaHHIO HCIOJIb3OBaHHA fleCHbIX 3eMenJbqBjiHeTCH Heo6xOJHMbIM yCJIOB1eM yCTOr4uHBoro pa3uBHTHii necHoro ceKTopa. Ho 3TOT nogxogMO)KHO BHe,p5lTb TOJIbKO riocTeneHHO, HoKa xe Heo6xoai4Mo HpuHHTb ueJ1blru PHX, peLUeH14AO 6yaylyeM KOHKpeTHb1X ripenpHsATHfI H o6pa3oBaHHblX BOKpyr HHX roceAKOB. Ho3TOMYceiqac Haao CpO'HO alaTb oLIeHKY peCypCHOU1 6a3bl CyWeCTBYIOIUHX ripearIpMRTHH HnpeKpaTHTb HCTOIUHTeAbHyIO 3KCrIJyaTa4UHIO aOCTyHbIX peCypcoB, o6o3Haq4Tb Te nnoLaati,

Page 110: Russian - World Bank Documents

92

riAe He3aMenLAHTeAbHoe BAo)KeHH4e CpeACTB B CHCTeMbi pauHoHajlbHoro ynpasBeHHiA .necaMH

Morno 6bilaaTb nOnOHKHTejbHbie npMbie COLuHajibHbie H 3KOior'HeCKHe BbIrOflbl.

'4To6bi oCyUeCTBHTb nepexoA K paUHOHajibHOMy 3KOHOMH4eCKOMy MeXaHH3MY B

cdiepe IiecHoH npOMbUwJIeHHOCTH, Ha OCHOBe pbIHO4Hb[X npHLHUHnOB, Ba)KHO o6o3Ha'w4Tb Te

npe,rnpHATHA H paHOHbl, y KOTOpbIX HMelOTCS aOCTaTO4qHbie 3anacbI JTeCHbIX peCYPCOB H Te,

4bA pecypcHaA 6a3a yxKe HCTOLueHa H AAA KOTOpbIX ea[iHCTBeHHbIM BbIXO,4OM 5BJIAeTCA

3aKpblTHe npeanpHATHAs H nOHCK aJIbTepHaTHBHbIX BO3MO)KHocTeg 3aHATOCT14 AAA ero

pa6oTHHKoB. BblAeJieHHe 3TUX aByX rpynri ripeanp4ASTHR noMo)KeT onpeaeIeA4Tb MacuTa6bi

Mep coLluanbHor a,anTaUHH, Heo6xoaHMbix IAS Toro, qTo6bI HlOMOMb 3TUM paKOHaM HarTH

aJbTepHaTHBbl HCTOIUHTenJbHOMY JieCHOMY rpOH3BOACTBy, KOTOpbIe 6yRyT nOAUeP)KHBaTb HAI

nOBbICAT CyiUeCTBYIOIlHe YpOBH4 3aHATOCTH H BbInYCKa ipoayKUHm. 9To rOMO)xeTOripe,aeJI4Tb B paMKax aoArocpoqHoro nniaHHPOBaHHS1 Tpe6oBaHHS no BoccTaHoBJIeHHIo

HCTOiIeHHbIX py6KaMH nJeCOB 1 nOCTeneHHOMY BKJloMeHHIO B rpO43BOACTBO B pe)KHMe

HeHCTOLLHTeJTbHOrO JIeconoHob3oBaHH4A. 3TOT nORXOa aojlXKeH TaKlKe BKJIIO4aTb AoJDKHoe

nPH3HaHHe npaB KOpeHHbIX HapOaOB H co3JIaH4e yCJIOBHfl A1i coxpaHeHHA1 H yCTOquHBOro

pa3BHTHS HX Tpa,AHL1UOHHbIX o6LUHH, CHCTeM 3eMJIe- H pecypconojib3OBaHH5 H yKmaaOB.

CoXpaHeHHe 6iopa3Hoo6pa3Hff

KaK H 60JIbI.UHCTBO cTpaH, PoccHA aoojiKHa CHCTeMaTHqeCKH oripeaeJ1ATb

OCHOBHbie TepPHTOpHH ,inH CoXpaHeHHA 64opa3Hoo6pa3H4, OXBaTblBaiOiUHe

penpe3eHTaTuBHblr Ha6op 3KOCHCTeM, H BBOAHTb Ha 3THX TepplHTOPHAX 344eKThBHble

pe)KHMbI ynpaBJIeHHI. B nocAieAH4e roabl B03MO)KHOCT4 POCCuH B 3TOM OTHoweHHH

3HaqIHTeCbHO ocna6niu, qTO CBA3aHO C KPH3HCOM B HayKe H Cyy.eCTBeHHOU yTpaTOU KOHTpOJ15

3a aeqTeAbHOCTbIO Ha OXpaHAeMb1X TeppHTOpHAIX. ,AnR pelimeHHA OCTperilUHX

npppo,gooxpaHHbIX H 3KOHOMH4eCKHX npo6JTeM POCCHH noHaao6HTcA 6o.nee

uejieHanpaBjieHHo HCHOAb3OBaTb CBOH HayIHo-HccIieCoBaTeJIbcKHe HHCTHTYTbl KaK A1A

pa3pa6oTKH COOTBeTCTBYIOLUHX MeTOAOB pecypcoynpaBJIeHHA, TaK H1 AAA onpee1eneHH5

KpHTepHeB H HHRHKaTOPOB AAA MOHHTOPHHra 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3HR H o6LUero COCTOASHHA

3KOCHCTeM.

B CBfl3U C 3KOHOM14qeCKHMH TpyAHOCTAMH, KOTOpbie iepe)KHBalOT MHorHe )KHTeJ14

OT21anjeHHbIX AeCHbIX pa4OHOB, yBeBiHqHJnaCb Harpy3Ka Ha peCypCbl pbi6bl H n,UKHX )K4BOTHbIX.

PacnaA CHCTeM perynHPOBaHuHH H KOHTpOJA npuHBenJ K pe3KOMY yBeJimqeHHIO MaCUTa6oB

6paKoHbepcTBa, AOnYCKaeTC5 H36blTOqHb1U npoMblceCi MHorHx nonynA5UHi OXOTHHqbHX

)KHBOTHbIX (Ta6J1uHa 2.2). OxpaHqeMble TePPHTOPuH He 6yayT o6ecneqIHBaTb AOJDKHoro

HOAO)K4TenJbHoro 39jeKTa B rinnaHe coxpaHeHH5 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3Hl4 H YCTO4N4BOCTH

pecypcoB, eCnH He 6yaeT o6ecneqeHa LejiOCTHOCTb HX 3KojIorHqeCKHX, 3KOHOMHqeCKHX H

COLUaHJbHbIX CHCTeM. (CnpaBKa 2.2). 3To Tpe6yeT BHHMmaHHU Ha CTUaaH nniaHHpOBaHH5 AAA

onpe,aenAeHHA nOJ11uTHKH niecHoro ceKTopa H npaKTH4qeCKHX cpeaCTB ee ocyIueCTBJeHRA,

YCTaHOBJeHHA npoCTpaHCTBeHHO-BpeMeHHbIX 3aBHCHMOCTeg Mex)ay pa3HbIMH B4aaMH

3eMjielOJIb3OBaHH5 H CpaBHeHHA 3aTpaT H BbIFO OT 3KCnJ1yaTaUHH peCYPCOB H HX

CoXpaHeHHA, H, 'ITO HaH6onee Ba)KHO, A1 CMCTeMaTHqeCKorO BbIABJIeHH5 3aHHTepecoBaHHbIX

CTOpOH, KOHCYJlbTaLuHU C HHMH H HX y4aCTHA1 B pa6OTe.

Page 111: Russian - World Bank Documents

93

COXp8HCHHC yCTONHBOCTNM pfCCCOB Ha OCHOBe paCHpeACe.IeHHq 3eMenIb 170 BHZaM,U0ffAWBaHNHf

,iLnsi BbilenJeHHS yqaCTKOB C onpeaeJIeHHbIMH xapaKTePiCT1KamH HnH H3BeCTHoriYM3BHMOCTbIO H BO H36exKaHHe HaJIo)KeHH5 B3aHMoHCKKToqaIOiU4X BHIaOB 3eMJlenOJlb3OBaHHSJ,Heo6xo,aHMo npOBOIHTb pacnpeaeAeHHe 3eMeJb c nOMO[ubiO oripeaeneHHoro MeTonaniiaHHPOBaHH51 HCnOJ1b3OBaHHq 3eMej1b. (opMaajbHbli npouecc pa3MelueHHH HnAaHHPOBaHHA HcIoAb3oBaHHS 3eMeJIb AaeT OCHOBY AIAS cTpaTerHi4, a TaKX(e KpiTePHKynpaBJIeHHA, Heo6xoaHMbIe pyKoBo,4HTeIiAM H cneuHa1HCTaM no pecypcoyripaBeIeHHIo XJCHcTeMaTmx4ecKoro onpeaeJIeH4H OnTHMaJIbHoro BHLa noJIb3OBaHHS Ha aaHHOM yqaCTKenIeCHOU 3eMnH. 9TH npoueccbi rpeRHa3HaqeHbl AA KJIaccCH)KauHm nIeCHbIX MaccHBOB no HX

Ta6.nIHa 2.2: Oxora B KpaCHOslPCKOM Kpae, 1993-1994 rr.

BAMu 1993 199 194 199 199

Olrlpc,7 (OTAOB) KBOM O1penff (orioB) Ow7pC# (OTAOB) Opcff (On'Oa)1o 04lwfLfalHmM 17 (4HIO hHIJbIu n 170 OLCHKBM 01OmOcI7obH

.gaHmwm KBOxM (%)

Ka6apra 91 oxpaieTcnc 0 2.000 oxpaHAeTcsq

Bo6p 53 258 54 2.000 +775

KocyJIA 1.200 2.000 1.132 10.000 +500

Mapajn 375 800 362 1.000 +25

JlOcb 1.255 300 1091 4.000 +14

Co6OAb 22.504 63.960 16.072 50.000 -22

CeBepHbiri OJeHb 251 1000 183 500 -50

Bypblui MeaBeAb 130 500 75 300 -40

Ka6aH 60 400 72 240 -40

a To.nbKo He3aKOHHaS OxOTa

HCTOqHHK: KpaCHOMpCKUU KpaCBOI KOMUTeT no necy, 1995.

3KOJ1OrK4eCKOUi 'IyBCTBHTeJIbHOCT4, npHpOpooXpaHHOA ueHHOCTH, COUHaWibHO-Kyj1bTypHOHiULeHHOCTH H 3KOHOMH4eCKOMY HOTeHUHaH]y rpOMblujjIeHHOrO HCHOJ1b3OBaHH5 C TeM, 'lTo6biOnTHMH3HpOBaTb BbIrOAbl HeHCTOJ.w4TejlbHOrO HCnOJ1b3OBaHH5I J1eCHblX peCypCOB (CnpaBKa2.3).

4aCTO pacnpeaej1eHi4e 3eMenjb H nniaHHPOBaHHe HX HCnOnb3OBaHH5 BKn1O4alOTpaCCMOTpeHHe B03MO)1(HOCTeU MHorouejieBoro nOJlb3OBaHHS Ha KOHKpeTHO4 njowaAmH.OpraHH3auH5 MHoroueneBoro IeconoJIb3oBaHHS conpsAxeHa c 60JIbUIHMH yripaBAeH4eCKMMH

Page 112: Russian - World Bank Documents

94

CnpaBKa 2.2: CoxpaHeHHe 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3mq

BHopa3Hoo6pa3He - HJIH MHoroo6pa3He paCT1eHH1, KHBOTHblX H jtpyrux )KHBbIX opraHH3MoB BO BCeX

4popMax H Ha Bcex YpOBHqX opraHH3auHH - BKniiomaeT MHoroo6pa3He reHOB, BHAOB, 3KOCHCTeM H CBR3blBalOAHX

HX 3BOJIIOUHOHHblX H 4yHKUHOHaJ1bHbix npoueccoB. Ue.nb COXpaHCHeH 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3Hsi - rapaHTHpoBaTb

6yaywee Ansi Bcex cpeA o6HTaHHI, BHaOB H HX reHeTH'eCKHX KOMnOHeHTOB, HaCKOJ1bKO 3TO npeaCTa&qqeTCq

B03MO)KHbiM 6H0cIH3HieCKH, 3KOHOMH4eCKH H nOJIHTHqecKH. TaK KaK 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3He pacnpocTpaHeHO Ha

nnaHeTe HepaBHoMepHO, Heo6XOJHMO BbiAeCjHTb H BKJIO'0HTb B XH3HecnOCo6Hy10 CHCTeMy OXpaHReMbiX

TeppHTopHri penpe3eHTaTHBHbIe 3KOCHcTeMbI H 3KOCHcTeMbl C oco60 6oraTbIM 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3HeM. XOTq

co3AaHHe H coaepAcaHHe KpynHbIX OXpaHSeMbiX TeppHTOpHti RBSICTCq KpaeyroJ]bHbIM KaMHeM mno6or

CHCTeMHO1i niporpammb oXpaHbi nlpHpoabi, 34IeicKTHBHOCTb coxpaHeHH.9 6mopa3Hoo6pa3Hq 3aBHCHT OT

3a6oTAHBoro H KBaJH4PHUHpoBaHHoro ynpaBneHHR BceM iaHKlIawarToM. B npeAeniax KOTOpOrO HaXOmiTCSi 3TH

oxpaH.embie TeppHTopHH.

npH noALep)KKe rjio6aJibHoro 3KonorHqecKoro 4)OHAa (r3F ), POCCHS pa3pa6aTblBaeT KOMnIieKCHYiO

nporpaMMy BOCCTaHoBMeHHS H coxpaHeHHq 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3HSI B paMKX flpoeKra no coxpaHeHH]o

6Hopa3Hoo6pa3HsI (World Bank, 1996a). 3Ta nporpamma AOJI)KHa o6ecnetHTb CHcTeMY 3aLUHTbI

6Hopa3Hoo6pa3Hiu Ha TeKyiUwti nepmoA, xapaKTepH3yIoLkHAcR 3KOHOMHueCKHMH TPYAHOCTqMH. OHa TaKwe

AOJDKHa nOMOIb B pa3pa6oTKe cTpaTerHri COXpaHeHH. 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3Ha Ha HaUHOHanbHOM H perHOHanJbHOM

YPOBHAX H nnaHOB Ae2cTBH, OCHoBaHHblIX Ha o6fbeKTHBHb1X 3KOHOMHteCKHX H 6HoniorHqecKHx oueHKax. B

paMKax aToro npoeKTa 6yaeT erYHKUHOHHPOBaTb nporpamma noaAeP)KKH HaH6oJIee Ba)KHbiX OXpaHqeMblX

TeppHTopHui, KOTOpbie HaH6oj0ee nocTpaAaRH OT HeraTHBHbiX n eOCJAeICTBHA, npOBOAIUAHXCS B cTpaHe

3KOHOMHueCKHX pe4opM; 6yAeT pa3pa6aTblBaTbcS KpynHas AeMOHcTpaUHOHHaSi nporpamma no coxpaHeHHio

6Hopa3Hoo6pa3H.s B 5aVkKarnbcKoM perHoHe.

TPYAHOCTAMH H B03MO)KHOCTAMH, camai riiaBHas H3 HHX, noKanyy, - o6ecneqHTb

nIOHHMaHHe 3HaIHMOCTH H yqeT HenpH6bLTibHbIX, HO 3KOHOMHqeCKH H COU1HaJbHO Ba)KHbIX

noJIe3HocTe 3eMeJIb Bcex KaTeropuHl. KpoMe Toro, coxpaHeHHe 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3Hq H

paUHOHanJbHoe pecypcoynpaBsieHHe Hejib3S ocyUeCTBHTb, COCPeaoToqHBa3 Bce yCHJIH5

CnpaBKa 2.3: POCCHHCKHHi onbuT B o6naCH paCnpeAejneHHn H nHiaHHPOBaHHR HCnOnjb3oBHHU 3eMeJIb

KoHuenuHs pacnpeaenieHH$I H nIIaHmpoBaHHSl Hcnojib3oBaHHR 3eMeJIb He BRnSeTcS HOBOi anS POCCHH.

OHa, B onpeAenieHHOri cTenCHH, npMHSmHnaCb ARM co3AaHHR cytuecTByioweA B HacTornuee BpeMH CeTH

oxpaHMembix TeppHTOpHri H pa3MeLueHHS pa3Hbix BUAOB necononb3oBaHHSl. B KatecTBe 3KcnepHMeHTa,

nporpaMMUI nIIaHHpoBaHHI H HCUnO1b3OBaHHR 3eMenJb coBMeCTHO C HeKoMMepqeCKOi KoMnaHHfeg "Ecologically

Sustainable Development" ("3KOJIorHUeCKH yCTOIIHBoe pa3BHTHe") ocyluecTBjsnliHCb B paioHe 03epa BatIKaJi H

Ha ,anbHeM BocToKe. ()eaepanbHaI c,iy)K6a JiecHoro XO3S0crBa ce1imac pacwHpqeT CeTb pOCCHtiCKHX

MO,aenJbHbIX nieCOB (ocHoBaHHylo Ha KaHaACKOli KOHUenlUHH MOAetjbHOrO iieca, OnHCaHHOAi B lnpHjo)KeHHXlx 11 H

K), nlpHMeHqS CHCTeMHbih MeTOA pacnpeAenieHHs H niiaHHpoBaHHH Hcnojib3oBaHHS 3eMeCJb H KPHTePHH

HeHCTOUUHTeCJbHOrO pecypconojib3oBaHHlq. raCCHHCKHUi MoAeIbHbiti niec yxe qBlSleTCSq aCTbIO Me)KAyHapoAHoA

CeTH MoaeJ[bHbIX nlecoB, KpoMe 30oro 4eXeAepanibHoii CJ1yK6oA JiecHoro X03 lcTBa Bbl6paH ETropor yqacToK

Mo1enJbHOrO nieca HeaaJIeKo OT MOCKBbl.

HcKJIIO4HTeAbHO Ha oxpaH5eMbix nJIoluaax. )I,JI 39("eKTHBHOR oxpaHbl cpeabl Heo6xoaHMo

npHMeH.qTb o6uHe MeToJAbl nnaHHPOBaHuH HcHonb3oBaHHR 3eMeJlb, OXBaTbiBaiouluHe Becb

naHAwLuaqT.

),,IA POCCuu nOriHoe npHMeHeHHe 3TOi KOHUen UHH 03HaLiaeT 3HaqHTejbHOe

paclUHpeHHe H yrny6jleHHe cyiuecTyBotuero noAxo,a K niiaHHpOBaHHIO H BKJlIOqeHHe B

npoLiecc pa3MeLUeHH.9 H niiaHHpOBaHHu MeAKLHCUHnJIHHapHbIx KpHTepHeB. npaKTH4qeCKHI

Page 113: Russian - World Bank Documents

95

OllbiT yKa3bIBalOT Ha TO, 'TO HcnoOjb3yeMaq HbIHe B POcCHH KJaCCH4)HKaUtiq iiecOB (CM.CnpaBKa 1.6, riiaBa 1) He npH.aeT OnJDKHFO 3Ha'eHH$1 BonpocaM oxpaHbl cpeabi U6Hopa3Hoo6pa3HI B iiecax TpeTbel rpynnbI H Ha 3KOor0HeCKH yA3BHMb[X TeppHTop[49X (B3KCnnyaTaLtHOHHbIX niecax), KOTOpbIe CAeayeT OTHeCTH K OXpaHAemMbmM HuH HCnOjib3OBaTb HaMHoroueLieBOH OCHOBe. KpoMe Toro, nieca I H 1I rpynn Bce 6o.nbue oKa3blBaloTC5 HoAHaTHCKOM CO CTOpOHbl BHJOB nOJIb3oBaHHSA, He COBMeCTHMbIX C HX 3KOjiOrHMeCKHM HCOUHaJIbHbIM ripeAHa3HaqeHHeM. CHCTeMa ynpaBJeHHsl fOnDKHa OCHOBbIBaTbCS Ha 3ajaaaxCOXpaHeHHR (DyHKUHOHaJbHOCTH BCerI JieCHOu 3KOCHCTeMbI.

POCCuH Hy)KeH 6onee ueAOCTHbl4 noAXoL K nriaHIHpOBaHHEO H ynpaHneHHIO,KOTOpbiU cnoco6CTBOBan 6bl ymaCTHIO pa3HbIX CTOPOH B npouecce pacnpeaeuieHHq 3eMeflb HrinaHHPOBaHH5I HCnOJIb3OBaHHS Bcex .TeCHbIX 3eMeab. Ha P4c. 2.1 cxeMaTHiqHO FoKa3aHOCHCTeMHoe pacnpeaeuieHHe npHOPHTeTOB B KcnOAb3OBaHH1 3eMeJIb. KPHTepHH Bbl6opanpHOpHTeTOB no pa3MeiueHHIO BHJOB 3eMjienOJIb3OBaHH5 AOJD)KHbl 6blTb pa3pa6oTaHblODeAepauibHoH cnyiK6oA .iecHoro XO3Sr4ICTBa BMeCTe C [ocyaapCTBeHHbrM KOMHTeTOM nooxpaHe OKpyxKaOLueU CpeAbi, perHOHaJbHbIMH opraHaMH BJIaCTH, npeacTasBHTeAIMHKOpeHHOrO HaceAeHH5, HayqHO-HCCAeaoBaTenbCKHMH HHCTHTYTaMH H apyrY4MH CTOpOHaMH,3aUHTePeCOBaHHblMU B ynpaBieHHHH IeCHbIMH pecypcaMH. OAHHM H3 npHMepOB qBASeTCAcTpaTerH3i pecypcoynpaBAeHHA no coxpaHeHHio 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3HA, KOTopaH B HaCTO,iweeBpeM5I pa3pa6aTblBaeTCq BMecTe c rsq) (CM. CnpaBKa 2.2).

B 3TOM npouecce nrioiuaAblo, npi4rOAHOA AAA HpOH3BOaCTBa neca HnIH apeBeCHoroCbIpbA, RBAAeTCS HIAOLUaAb, KOTOpaA OCTanTaCb B PC3YJnbTaTe CHCTeMHOU KnaCCH4¢HKaUtH Ho6o3Ha'IeHHr. rpaHiLu nocnIe oTJejieHH5 OXpaH5ieMbIX TeppHTopH4g, qyBCTBHTeAbHbix yHaCTKOBcpe,abi (BKilio1a,i Te 3eMJIH, Ha KOTOpbIe rpeTeHAYIOT KOpeHHbIe KHTeJIH), 443H'IeCK4 H3KOHOMH'eCKH HeaOCTyHHbIX nioiiaaeg H 30H OXpaHbl nO4BeHHbIX H BOaHbIX pecypcoB no6eperaM peK H Ha Boaoc6opax. HaJiHMHe HH4¢opMauH4 o6 YCJIOBHlX npOH3paCTaHIH4 HTO'IHbIX HHBeHTapH3aUHOHHb[X 1aHHbIX no pecypcy qBA5ieTCH HenpeMeHHbIM YCAOBHeMnpIMpeHeHHH 3TOrO noiaxoAa, KOTOpbli o6sl3aTe.nbHO npeArnoniaraeT AtoJIrOCpo4HblA nepHoarJIaHHPOBaHHS1 KaK B cTpaTerH4ecKHx, TaK H B OnepaTHBHbIX LueAHX. EcnH OCHOBHbIMKpHTepHeM BJI5IeTCI yCTOWIHBOCTb H HeHCTOLUHTCeJbHOCTb, TO oxpaHa oKpyxaloweU Cpeabi,npH3HaHHe npaB KOpeHHOrO HaceAeHHI H coxpaHeHiHe 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3Hs AOADKHbl 6blTb 5CHOC4DOpMyJ1HpOBaHHbIMH H OCyyweCTBHMbIMH IteAAIMH ynpaBJIeHHI4 Ha TeX TeppHTOpH4Ax, rae3arOTOBKa Aeca COCTaBnsIeT rjiaBHyio LLenIb pecypcoHoIJb3OBaHH4. Pa3Hbie BapHaHTbi 3TOronpouecca HuiaHHPOBaHiH5 npHmeHHiEOTCS BO MHorHx cTpaHax, HMelOKIHX Ha CBoerTePPHTOPHH 6opeaAbHble Aeca, H HX OnbiT Mor 6bl rpHrouHTbCS pOCCHICKHM pyKoBoaliTeASMvAAs pa3pa6OTKH 3xbdeKTHBHoro npouecca HCnOJIb3OBaHH5 3eMenb H rpHHSHTHI4 peweHHrI.

OTHeceHHe niecoB CeBepHbIX paBiOHOB Cu6HpH HU aanbHero BocToKa K KaTeroPHHHenpHroILHbIx AAA JIeCO3arOTOBKH Bp51A JnH BbI3OBeT MHOrO CHOpOB, nOCKOJIbKy C 1959 roxaOHH HMeEOT CTaTyC 3awHTHbIX necos, a TaKiKe H3-3a OTuajieHHOCTH H OTHOCHTeAbHO HH3KOUrKOMMep4eCKOr ueHHOCTH (B rTiaHe npOH3BOaCTBa apeBeCHHbl) 3THX IPHTYHaPOBb[X HceBepHbIX Tae)KHbIX AeCOB. TaKHM o6pa3oM, Laa)Ke ecnul 3aXLULTHbie nTeca pacl4upHTCH BIO)KHOM HaHpaBJIeHHH, KaK npejAaraioT yMeHbie IIHCTHTyTa Tieca HM. B.H. CyKaBeea,peaJIbHblr4 3KOHOMH1eCKHr4 344eKT cKopee Bcero 6yueT MIHHMaAbHbIM. CTaTYC 3aLUHTHbIXAecoB He HOBJIHquA 6bI Ha B03MO)KHOCTH HcnoJIb3OBaHHH apeBeCHHbl KOpeHHb]M HaceneHH4MAAns co6CTBeHHbIx 6blTOBbIX HyA.g. Crlopbl MOryT BbI3BaTb nOIIbITKH HCKJIIO'-ITb H3KaTeropHH 3KCHjinyaTaUHOHHb[X nieCoB YH3BHMbie yqaCTKH Cpeabl o6HTaHHR H

Page 114: Russian - World Bank Documents

96

Be'4HOMep3hiOTHbie TeppHTOPHH (KOTOpble B HaCTOBuCee BpeMA He IBEISIOTCS 'aCTbIO CHCTeMb1

oxpaHReMbIX TeppuHTOPH cTpaHbI), 4H343ecKH H 3KOHOMH4eCKH HeaocTynHbie nfloLuaaH H

30Hbl 3aLUHTbI nO4BCHHbIX H BOaHbIX pecypCoB 6eperos peK H BO0oc6OpOB B npeReIax

KOHKpeTHOH CblpbeBOH 6a3bl.

OT,aejieHHe TaKHX nAo0UaaeH COKpaT4jio 6bl pa3MepbI 3eMeCjbHo0u 6a3bi npH

onpeaeAeHHH pacqeTHoR iiecoceKCK u, TeM caMbiM, nOHH3HJIo 6bl nOTeHLtuani npOH3BOACTBa

1apeBec4Hbl. B HaCTO5Luee BpeMA pa3Mepbl pacxCeTHOH iiecoceKH YCTaHaBAHBatoTcq

(De,epajibHO9 ciTy)K6or JiecHoro Xo3XU03CTBa Ha ypoBHe, HH)Ke o6uiero roAoBoro HOBOro

o6beMa ecTecTBeHHoro npHPOCTa niecoB, a ro1oBoH pa3Mep 4aKTiqecKoro rniaBHoro

HOJIb3OBaHHS COCTaBjiqeT ao 60% pacqeTH0I JiecoceK4. Ho Ao Tex nop, noKa onpeaegeHHe

paCqeTHOUii ecoceKH He 6yaeT 6o0ee TeCHO CBA3aHO C peaTibHbIMH B03MOAKHOCTqMH

npoH3BO1CTBa apeBeCHHbI B KOHKpeTHbIX perHoHax, npo6AeMa j1oKaIbHbIX nepepy6o0 6yaeT

OCTaBaTbCH HepeuleHHOUI. ,aaHHbIX, noHyAeHHbIX B xoge nOarOTOBK4 3Toro o630pa,

OKa3aJlOCb HeaOCTaTo0MHO AAA OKOHWaTeJ1bHOR oueHKH peanibHoro rOTeHLuHania npoH3BOCTBa

ApeBec4HbI, XOTS HCHO, qTO HCnoHJb3yeMbIH cerFqac MeTOa He nO3BojiAeT ywHTbIBaTb Bce

3HaqHMbie 3KoJ1orHMecKHe napaMeTpbl. PeajiHCTHiqeCKaB pac4eTHas necoceKa OnJDKHa 6blTb

OCHOBaHa HCKJIIOMHTCjibHO Ha TOR nrio0LaAH, K0TOpaA oCTaeTCri nocnie oTaejieHHS Bcex

OCTa8JbHbIX BH4AOB noJIb3OBaHMA, H C'HTaeTCA npHroAHoH AnS npOMbillfleHHOH 3arOTOBKH

neca KaK nOKa3aHO Ha PHc. 2.1.

PbIHO4Has 3KOHOMmKa Tpe6yeT, qTo6bl 3eMjneycTpoHTejH OHHMaJIH u nOAHOCTbIO

y"HTbIBaJIH 3aBHC14MOCTH MeXlY 3aTpaTaMH H pe3yJIbTaTaMH. PeaKLIHA Ha CHTYLLUI10 Ha

pbIHKaX JIeCHbiX npOaYKTOB He 40TIHa oTpHuaTenjbHO CKa3bIBaTbCA Ha HepblHOHbIX

3Ko0jorH,qeCKHX U couHajibHbIX dyHKL14AX JTecoB. JIpS1 C03,aaHHl4 CTHMYJIOB K 3aLUTe

Henpx6bLllbHbix aCHCKTOB .IeCHbIX 3KOCHCTeM HY)KHbl pblHO'qHbie nOXOAb1 H

IpHpHXo0oxpaHHbIe HOpMbI H Tpe6oBaH4H. be3 rocyaapCTBeHHoro cy6cHaHpoBaHHRS XDIq

CHH)KeHHA 3aTpaT Ha o6ecne4eH4e aocTyna K JiecaM, JIeCHbIe nHjo0HaaH C MaprHHaHibHo0

3KOHOMH4eCKoH AOCTynHOCTbIO Bp51fa uIH 6yayT OCBaHBaTbCA, ecnuH 3TH 3aTpaTbl HenJb3A 6yaeT

nepeHecTH Ha CqeT rToTpe64Teiiq. TaKHM o6pa3oM, 3KOHOMH'qeCKHe Ciubi Mor0iH 6bl trpaTbBa)KHYIO POlb B CoXpaHeHHH 3KoJIorH4ecKHx LLeHHOCTeI, Tpe6y5l OT HHBeCTOpOB BKAIlO4eHHR

3aTpaT Ha OCBoeHHe pecypca B HOJIHOH Mepe. 9To nO3BOJiujio 6bl OCTaBHTb 1J51 aPYFHX BHaOB

nOJ1b30BaHH.q 6oJ1bLuHe yIaCTKH HaH6ojlee Y53BHMbIX CeBCpHbiX nieCOB, KOTOpbie He

npHBJIeKaTeJlbHbl XIA npoMbHwJIeHHOH pa3pa6OTKH. Anf o6ecneMeHHR yCTOWIHBOCTH pecypca

B 3KOHOMHqeCKH AOCTynHbIX niecax noTpe6yeTCs rocy1apCTBeHHoe peryjiHpOBaHHe uWHpoKoro

pHAa BHIOB KOMMep4eCKOH aeHTejibHOCT4. BaKHbIM CTHMYJIOM ABJiqeTCq 14CnO0Jb30BaHHe Mep

nO B0CnpoH3BoaCTBY pecypca H HHTeHCHBHoe BeReHHe iiecHoro Xo3AHcTBa, HanpaBsIeHHoe Ha

nOBblwueHHe npOaYKTHBHOCT4 nFerKOZoCTYnHbIx inouwaaek.

COBCpJIICHCTB0,WHHC CTpaT lIiff BOCI7pOH3BO4CTBH JIeCHMX pCCYPCOB

YCTO09lHBOCTb pecypca 3aBHCHT OT OnpeaejleHUHI COOTBeTCTBYlOUXUX YPOBHeH

3arOToBKH nieca m YTBepKLIeHHuI F0porpaMMbi CHCTeMaTH4eCKHX Mep no BOCUIpOH3BOACTBY

JIeCHbIX peCypcoB. HenpepblBHoe Bocnpo43BOaCTBO nieca KpaiHe Ba)HO Ans o6ecnemeHHq

paBHOMepHOro no0jb30BaHUH5 rpHrOaHbIM an] 3arOTOBKH niecoM Ha KaKOH-TO OrpaHHMeHHOH

npoH3B0oCTBeHHorH nHjoLuaaH H n03TOMY aOJDXHO 3aHiMaTb ueHTpaSjbHoe MeCTO B

iUiaHHpOBaHHH HCno0Jb30BaHMH oxpaHbI, 3aLUHTbI H BOCnpOH3BOACTBa pecypca. [IpH

pHmeHeHuHH npouecca ruiaHHpoBaH4H HCno0bm30BaHMH 3eMeAb, aHajiorH'qHoro nOKa3aHHOMY

Page 115: Russian - World Bank Documents

97

HcCKJiiO4eHbl H3 npoMblwJIeHHOrO nOJIb3OBaHU1 B CBA3H C Heo6xoaHMOCTbIO OXpaHbioKpy)KaIolueH cpeabi, 3aLUHTbl MeCT o6HTaHHS, coxpaHeHJA5 HeapeBeCHoA ueHHOCTH pecypcaH cTa6HuH3auHi rjio6anbHoro KJIHMaTa. KaK TOAbKO 3KOHOMH4eCKH HenpHrOaHbie nHjouaaH6 yayT i4CKJiiO4eHbl H3 pacqeTa roa1qHoHA JeCOCeKH, Heo6xoa4MoCTb Mep nO BOcripo43BOaCTBYneca CTaHeT eLie 6ooee oqesBH1HOR.

napaMeTpbl nPOH3BOaCTBa ApeBecHHbl aojiroe BpeMS onpeaeJI5IJ14Cb Ka)KyLuegcSHeHcI4epnaeMOCTbIO jiCCHblX peCypCOB POCCuu14 u LeCapbiMH rocyaapCTBeHHbIMU cy6cHAU4MM4,B CBSI3H C 4eM MepbI HO BOCrpOH3BOaCTBY neca OTOaBHraJ1HCb Ha 3aaHHI nJIaH. TpyaHOCTH, CKOTOpblMU4 JieCHOH CeKTOp CTOJIKHyJICq B riepeXOaHbiH repo4oa, 3Ha44TeCJbHO ycyry6JT5eTOTCYTCTBHe nocJieaOBaTeJ]bHO OCyLIeCTBJSieMOH npOrpaMMbI BOCHpOH3BOACTBa AeCHbEXpeCypCOB. C4JTbHbl Taei4HUI4T apeBeCHHbI B paHOHax aepeBOo6pa6aTbIBalOIU4X KOMnJieKCOB HHanumue 6onbLwux HnouiaaeH aerpaHpsOBWLUX 14 HerpoLyuHpyiowLUx JIeCHbIX 3eMeCb Co BceuO4CeBHHOCTb1O CBHAeTeCJbCTByIOT 0 Heo6XOAHMOCTH COOTBeTCTBYIOIuiCH CTpaTerHHBOCnPO43BOaCTBa neCOB. B Poccuu ripMieHRIOTCH BCe 4eTbipe OCHOBHbIX MeTOJaaBOCnpOH3BOaCTBa - CCTeCTBeHHOe Bo3o6HOBJieH4e, ripqMO noceB (c B03,ayxa), noca4Ka H4OnOJAHeH4e HIOCaAKOA, XOTq CaMbiM paCnpoCTpaHeHHbIM, HaMHOrO npeBblwaiOHIUM 06beMblBcex npOuHX MeToaOB, SAB5ieTCA eCTeCTBeHHoe Bo3o6HOBTieH4e. HO KaACAoMy MeTOayCyULeCTBYlOT onpe,aeneHHbie TCXHwMeCKHe, 64o04314ecKHe H 3KOHOMH4eCKHe Tpe6OBaHHR.

OnHO 143 OCHOBHbIX HpeHMyiueCTB eCTecTBCHHOr B03o6HoBICHHJI 3aKIIO4aeTCq BTOM, 'TO HOBbIe CeCHUbl HMClOT ripOCXO)4xxeHHe, COOTBeTCTBYIOuIee llpHpOdHO-Kj1MHaTt4eCKHM YCJIOBH4IM aaHHO9 TepPHTOPH4. npH Bbi6ope BbICOKOKa4eCTBeHHbIXceMeHHbIX aepeBbeB, ceMeHa HMelOT OnTHManTbHyIO reHeTHqecKyio CTpyKTypy, a npHrpaBHJIbHOM pa3MeueHHH H aOCTaTOqHOM KOJIH4eCTBe CeMqH HX BCXO)KeCTb H Bbl)KHBaeMOCTbMOryT 6blTb OqCHb BbICOKUMU. AnI eCTeCTBeHHOFO Bo3o6HOBYIeHHI4 Heo6xoa)HMO Bb[6paTbJiecoceKy, pa3mep H q)OpMa KOTOpOHi OTpaX)Ka)1 6bl XapaKTep H T aIbHOCTb paCCeHBaHHI4CeMAH HY)KHbIX BHaOB. CPOKH JieCOCce'HbIX pa6oT ROJDKHbl COBnaaaTb C UHKJIOMnnIOAOHOweHHI4 aepeBbeB, a Bbi6op AeCOBOLICTBeHHOrI CHCTeMbi JieCOCeCHbMX pa6OT(cnnioWHbre, Bbi6OpOpIHbIe, ceMeHHO-JiecoceCHbie HJiH paBHOMepHbie nocTeneHHbie py6KH) HCnoco6bi nOarOTOBK4 nOqBbl (CKapHqf1HKaui4, MHHepaiiH3aUH5i orHeM) 6yayT 3aBHCeTb OTTpe6OBaHUH K BCXO)KCCTH CeMqH.

,Ins ociia6JieHHq KOHKypeHUHH CO CTOpOHbl MaJiOueHHbIX BH1IOB (THria 6epe3bl HOCHHbl) Hy)KCH iCpHO4HqeCKHH yXoa 3a HaCa)KfteHHeM, HHaqe 3TH BHabl 3arOJ1HZT BCIOCBo6O,IHyIO HJ1oLuaab, TaK KaK HX POCT npOHCXOalHT 6blCTpee, qeM pOCT XBOUHblX nopoLI,aepeBbeB. Ecniu 3THM 6onee HerpHXOTJuHBbIM BH4aM nO3BOJIHTb paCripOCTpaHHTbCq, OHMMOrYT 3aWAP)KaTb CO3peBaHHe BbICOKOUeHHOrO apeBOCTOM Ha HeCKOJbKO aeCCT4JICeTH4. XOTAnpAMbie 3aTpaTbl Ha CCTeCTBeHHOe Bo3o6HoBJIeHHe M4H4Ma.ibHbl, KOCBeHHbIe 3aTpaTbl MOryT6blTb BbICOKHMH, qTO CBA3aHHO C yXOaOM 3a TIecoM, 3aaep)KKaMH B 3aKJIaaKe3KcnjiyaTaUHOHHbIX Haca w eHKH H3-3a KOHKypeHLU4H CO CTOpOHbi MaSjOUeHHbIX BHlROB HnOBblwleHHeM 3aTpaT Ha jieCO3arOToBHTeCJbHbie pa6OTbl, nOCKOJIbKy CCMeHHble aepeBbAOrpaHH4HBalOT HCrIOJlb3OBaHHC HeKOTOpbIX BHAOB TeXHHKH, a zixi pa3MeLueHHq JIecoceK

Page 116: Russian - World Bank Documents

CD 01

0~~~0 ~~~

w Mc~~~~~~~ Cb~~~~~~ Cb~

. C 0~~~~~-~~~~~~a

CD X~~~~~~~~~~~ft.

0 -m 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ CD ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ t 0~~~~~~~~

0~~~~~

ft.

Page 117: Russian - World Bank Documents

99

MeHbwJIerO pa3mepa H 6o0ee o6uHpHbIX y"aCTKOB ocTaiotueroci nieca Tpe6yIoTcs HOBbie,aoporH.

ipilMOk a3pOCCB HMHTHpyeT eCTeCTBeHHoe Bo3o6HoBEieHHe, HO B 3TOM cSylaeTpy,aHee KOHTpOJTHpOBaTb rpoHcxoAeHue H reHeTHqeCKHri OT6op. HpeHMyLueCTBOMnpsMoro noceBa ABJSAeTCS B03MO)KHOCTb OXBaTbIBaTb 6o0iee 3HaqtTenJbHbie njoiua,aH HnpHMeH5TbCA 3a npeaeJIaMH aHana3OHa eCTeCTBeHHOrO pacceHBaHHA ceMAH pacTylu.xAepeBbeB. IOCKOJIbKy OaHa H3 LUeIie pauHoHaHIbHoro JieCHoro XO3SAfCTBa 3aKJ1Jo4aeTCA BH36eAKaHHH KpynHOMaCWIJTa6Hb[X CnHJOWHHbIX py6OK, npAMOU noceB He cJieayeT HCHOJIb3oBaTbKaK "H36paHHbl" MeTOA JIeCOBOccTaHOBjieHHA B paifoHax npOMbIllJIeHHOfl 3arOTOBKH nieca.Ho B oco6blx yCOBHAlx, HaripiMep, Ha KpynHbIx rapAix H CTapblX BbIpy6Kax npHMeHeHHenp,qmoro noceBa BHOJIHe aOUyCTHMO.

flOCa4,i, XOTb H ABJIBeTCS CaMbIM aOpOrOCTOAHUHM MeTO,4OM BOCHlpOH3BOaCTBa,IlHpOKO npHMeHSACTCS B CeBepHOU AMepHKe H EBpone. KaHaga, HanpHMep, coriaCHOoLIeHKaM, eKeroAHo ca)KaeT iiec Ha njiowaaH 450 TbIC. ra, 'TO COCTaBJIAeT ripMiepHOrIOJOBHHY OT n¶oaLaKu py6oK rnaBHoro noAb3oBaHHM. nocaaKa HMeeT BaxHoerpeHMyLueCTBO AAA AecoynpaBJIeHHs, TaK KaK nO3BOAAeT HCnoJb3oBaTb HY)KHbie BHAbI HpaUL1OHaBbHY1O cHCTCMy Hx pa3Meu.eHHSI Ha aaHHOA nMoWaaH. focKoAbKy ceSHubi(ca)KeHUbl) Bbicac)KBalOTCS ywKe B 4ByXJIeTHeM B03paCTe, OHH o6AaaalOT npeHMyu1eCTBOM noCpaBHeHHIO C KOHKypHpyiOuefi4 paCTHTeCbHOCTbIO, 3a CxeT qero coKpaLLkaeTcA BpeMS,Heo6xo,1HMoe AnS aOCTHUeHUA HaCaAKeHHeM IOJIHOUl npOpyKTHBHOCTH. B 6opealbHbIxYCJOBHAIX nocaaKa Mo)KeT yKopa'HBaTb o6wHA o6OpOT py6KH Ha 10-20 neT, o6ecnetHBaAHOBblwUeHHe IpoOfyKTHBHOCTH neca. flpaBHnbHoe ynpaBjieHHe H nAaHHPOBaHHe MoryTHOMO4b CnpaBHTbCA C HeKOTOPbIMH TpyaHOCTS5MH, CBA3aHHbIMH C riocaAKoA.npoHcxo0xeHHe nocaaoqHoro maTepHana AOf)KHO COOTBeTCTBOBaTb YCAOBHAMrpoH3paCTaHHS, a pa6o'-He, 3aHHMaolUHeCSl nocaaKok, LOIJKHbI HMeTb onpeaeneHHyIoflO,arOTOBKy H HaBbIKH AAA npaBHJTbHOi1 nocaaKH. HpH eCTeCTBeHHOM JIecoBo3o6HoBjieHHH,nocne rOCaAKH Mo)KeT noTpe6oBaTbcs nepHoaH'IeCKHI yXo, 3a HacaxAeHHAMH )AAAoc.na6JIeHHs YpOBHA KOHKypeHLU1H CO CTOpOHbl He)KCeaTeflbHbIX BHAOB.

CoKpaLiLWHHe yJ4ep6a OT HoArapoB, BpeAw7rffh# U 61em3Heff

XOTA pearHpoBaTb Ha Bce IieCHbie no)Kapbi npaKTH4eCKH H TeXHH4eCKHHeBo3MoKHO, a 3KOHOMH4eCKH H 9KOJorIHeCKH He)KenaTeJbHo, 6onbwoe KOJHqeCTBO HonaCHOCTb nofKapOB, BO3ropalOUHXCA nO BHHe 'leioBeKa, H OrPOMHbIe noTepH ApeBeCHbIXpeCYpCOB H COUHaJlbHbIX, 9KOHOMH'ieCKHX H 3KOAIOrHMeCKHX ueHHoCTeri ABASIOTCS BeCKHMOCHOBaHHeM aAA ycHAeHHA aeACTBeHHbIX Mep no 6opb6e C ro)KapaMH. E)KeroaHo nO)Kapblnopa;KaloT CBb1UIe MHJJIHOHa ra AeCoB, T.e. HO'qTH BaBoe 6onbrue HuloutaatH nIeCOB,BbIpy6aeMbIX B xoge 3aFOTOBKH apeBeCHHbl. 9KOHOMHKa L1ejbIx paUiOHOB pa3pyLwanacb, ecnHnowap YHHqTO)Kan HX necoCbIpbeBylo 6a3y. B HeKOTOpbIX necXo3ax POCCuu Ha MeponPwmTiAno 6opb6e C JIeCHbIMH no)KapaMH YXOaHT ao 29% TeKYLuHX npOH3BOaCTBeHHbIX pacXoaOB. Bxone AByCTOPOHHHX aHCKYCCHr4 nO 3TOH npo6neMe c KaHagorl, CUWA, apyrHMH cTpaHaMH HMeKIYHaPO)lHbIMH OpraHH3aUHIMH THHna ctAO, £IezepanbHaA cnyiK6a iecHoro X0351iCTBaPOCCHH pa6oTaeT HaB4 TeM, qTo6bl Ha8aaHTb B3a4MOBbirO,4Hbl o6MeH TeXHHMeCKHMH Hoy-xayB o6naCTU o6Hapy)KeHH5, MOHHTOpHHra, TyweHHA nO)KaPOB H ynpaBAeHHS HMH(ECE/FAO/ILO 1996).

Page 118: Russian - World Bank Documents

100

OnacHocTb BO3ropaHHq nIeCHbIx no)KapoB qBASieTC.9 cepbe3HOR npo6JieMog ,wsl

MHOrHX JIeCHbIX paUOHOB H aaql mno6oro qaCTHorO HHBeCTOpa, KOTOpblU xaymaeT o6

HHBeCTHPOBaHHH B AeCHOi ceKTop. B CB5I3H C TeM, YTO B HacToqLuee BpeMS

rOCy,aapCTBeHHbl ceKTOp He cnoco6eH o6ecne'HTb 344eKTI4BHyIO OxpaHy JIeCOB OT

nO)KapOB, JuIo6oMy 'aCTHOMy HHBeCTOpy npHfleTCR BKJIIO'HTb 3aTpaTbI Ha pa3BHTHe H

coaep)KaHHe 3THX cjiyK6 B paCqeTbI npOH3BOaCTBeHHbIX TeKyLUHX paCxoROB. B MeHee

JIOCTynHbIX paiUOHax 9TH IOnOSHOHTenJbHbie 3aTpaTbI MOryT OKa3aTb BJIHRHHe Ha npHHH1THe

pelweHHs o6 HHBeCTHIUHHX B TOT HJI UHOUt npOeKT. HHxe (CnpaBKa 2.4) npHBOXLHTCS

npHmep ycnemuHou1 pa6oTbl no (DHaHCHpOBaBUIeMyCq BceMHpHbiM 6aHKoM npoeKTy

noclenlo]KapHoro BOCCTaHoBjieHHR nieCOB B KHTae.

AHajiorHqHbie Hpo6JIeMbl CB5l3aHbl H C BblIBAeHi4eM oqaroB BpeatTeier H

6one3HeA H 6opb6bi C HHMH. KaK H B o6JIaCTH OXpaHbl nieca OT nOxCapOB, 3LteCb TO)Ke eCTb

coriiauweHe o COTpy,4HHqeCTBe MeXAy PoccHeui H HeCKOJIbKHMH apyrHMH CTpaHaMH.

4DOpMOR COTPYaHH4eCTBa SBJI5eTCS o6MeH TeXHOJIOrUHMH XHMHMeCKHx, 6HOJIOrHMeCKHX H

TeXHHMeCKHX MeTOROB 60pb6bl, a TaKXKe o6OPyAOBaHHeM H HCnbITaHHbIMH xHMH4eCKHMH H

6HOJIOrii'eCKMMH rlpenapaTaMH. JOCTyn K COBpeMeHHbIM MeTOaaM pHmeHeHlHHR npenapaTOB

(HanpuMep, yJlbTpaMaIoo66beMHoe onpblCKHBaHHe B co4eTaH4H C CHCTeMorl rjio6anbHoro

reOnO3HUHOHHpOBaHH5) )aa 6bl BO3MO)KHOCTb 4TAf HcnOJnb3OBaiHHS 6o0iee 3g4eKTHBHbIX

npenapaTOB, no cpaBHeHHIO C npenapaTami lHupoKoro aefcTBH4A, HcnOilb3yeMbiMH ceiNac B

POCCHH. ln51 3("eKTHBHoro npHmeHeHUH HOBbIX MeTOAOB 60pb6bl noTpe6yeTCq, no KpaUiHefl

mepe BHa'ane, rocyLapCTBeHHoe E4HHaHc4poBaHHe; a B cpeaHeCpOlHHofr nepcneKTHBe, Kor,Aa

nOMBATCS pe3yJlbTaTbl HCI1OJIb3OBaHHS 3THX cTpaTerH4 60pb6bl, TaKHe MeponpHiATH5I aOJD4CHbl

npOBOXaHTbCA Ha OCHOBe CaMO4DHHaHCHpOBaHHU.

JIeTOM 1996 roaa B KpacHoApcKoM Kpae 6buia ocywecTBneHa nporpamma

HHTerpHpOBaHHOU 60pb6bl C BpeJaHTejiqMH, KOTOpyIO no npOCb6e pOCCHACKoro

npaBHTeAbCTBa H HenpaBHTenjbCTBeHHbIX opraHH3aLmUHi qHaHCHpOBani BceMHpHbiu 6aHK. B

xo,ae peanjH3aUHH 3TOU nlpOrpaMMbi 6bma npOaeMOHCTpHpOBaHa 344eKTHBHOCTb

COBpeMeHHbIX TeXHoaomUH H MeTOaOB o6pa6oTKM nieca. nporpaMMa 6bmiJa Heo6xoXWMOA B

CB$13H CO BCnbIlKOH MaCCOBOrO pa3MHO)KeHHq onaCHorO BpeAHTCeii - CH6HpCKOrO

wenKonpAuia (Dendrolimus sibiricus) B CH6HpCKHX Aecax H Tpe6OBaJIla CpO'IHbIX mep no

C,aep)KHBaHHIO pacnpocTpaHeH 3TOO BpeaMTem. npOeKT TaKXe BKJlioqaji LejieBbJe MepbI

6opb6bi, MOHHTOpHHr RHHaMHKH HOnyJiIUHh H 34)4eKT4BHOCTH o6pa6OTKH H pOprpaMMbl

o6y'eHHMw.

BBC)ICHHC HpHpOaOOXpaHHAfX HOpMaTMBOB B iIPYFIWX OTpaCJIiIX

Jho6ot4 BH4,R IeSTeJlbHOCTH, KOTOpblH MO)KeT HOBJIHHTb Ha COCTOSHi4e JleCHbIX

peCypCOB POCCHH, aOJIKeH nOJIyqaTb BCeCTOPOHHIOIO H CHCTeMaT4xeCKylO OLeHKy, H TOJIbKO

nocne 9TOrO MO)KHO aaBaTb pa3peuleHie Ha ero BeaeHHe. Oco6oro BHHMaHHl Tpe6ylOT

xLoporH, nocTpoeHHbie IAn OCBOeHMH Hed)TsHbIX MeCTOpOA(LeHMH, ao6bIHl RpyrHX nOJie3HbIX

HCKOnaeMbiX H o6LueCTBeHHoro TpaHCnOpTa, TaK KaK OHH AalOT yAo6Hblr ,ROCTyn B neca ans

3arOTOBKH apeBeCHHbl B TeX pailOHaX, KOTOpbie HHa'e He OCBaMBaJIHCb 6bl; KpOMe TOrO,

nOTeHUHa1JbHO OHH MOryT CTaTb npHMHHOU HeO6paTHMblX nOBpe)KReHHA JieCOB H

OKpy)KaiollUeM CpeabI B pe3yAbTaTe nO)KapOB.

Page 119: Russian - World Bank Documents

101

CnpasKa 2.4: (DHHaHCHpoBaBDHwmcR BceMHpHb1M 6aHKoM npoe,cr no BOCCTaHOBJeHHIO KHTaBCKHX necoB,nocTpaAaBuHX OT noxapa

nloKap Bceraa 6bim OdHOH U3 CaMbIX cepbe3Hbix onaCHoCTeA, rPO3.IWux npHaMypCK14M TaeXKHbIM necaMceBepHbix oTporoB EOJbllWoro XHHraHa (npoBuHuHH X3J1YHU3A1H, KHTaA). 143 22 MJIH. ra AecoB no)KapaMH BCpe,aHeM YHHqTO0)anOCb no 135.000 ra B rox. B Mae 1987 roaa CaMbUA KaTaCTpO(jHqeCK1H B HCTOpUU41 KHTaRnowap BbaiKer OKOnO I MAH. ra B npefeKType BoJ7bWOA XHHraH; 3ToT nowap yHec )KH3HM 193 qeJioEeK,OCTaBBnJi 6e3 KPOBa 67.000 tenoiBeK H pa3pywimii 6onbwIyio 4aCTb IiHd)paCTpyKTypbl.

06UIHH 0obeM aepeBbeB, nlOrH6wHX OT 3Toro nowKapa, CoCTaBHJ1 OKOJO 30 MJIH. Ky6oMeTpoB,nOJIOBHHa H3 HHX, no OueHKaM, npeIcTaBj1slnjI co6oH KoMMepCeCKH LtUHHbie J!ecoMaTepHaBJbi u3 JIHCTBeHHHULbiH COCHbi. '-To6bi npoBecTH caHHTapHbie py6KH H 3arOTOBKY noBpe)I(AeHHoro nieca ao Toro, KaK HaceKOMbie urpH6bl nlpH4YHHfT emy HenonIpaBHMble pa3pywIeHHsl, H Co3gaTb CHCTeMy OXpaHbl AeCOB OT no)KapOB,M1HHcTePCTBOM iiecHoro X03flHCTBa npui noaaepAKe BceMHptioro 6aHKa 6bula pa3pa6oTaHa nporpammaCpe3BblxiaAHb1X Mep. 3a TpH roaa 6bw3o 3aroToBneHo 12 MJH. Ky6oMeTpoB noBpex)eaHHOFO neca (caMoeKpynHoMacWTa6Hoe MepOnPHIlTHe TaKOrO po0a H3 BceX KOrAa-J1H6o npOBOQHMbIX), qTO npHHeCCo AOXO Bpa3Mepe 1,2 M.apa. aonuapoB CWA B pe3yAbTaTe npoaa1KH 3TOH ApeBecHHbl Ha Toprax H noMorAo co33aaTbCHCTeMy oxpaHbI JieCOB OT no)KaPOB nnf Bcero perHoHa, 6.naroaapq KOTOpOr ywep6, HaHOC14Mbil no)KapaMHcoKpaTHAcSl c 135 TbiC. ra 0o Bcero HCCKOnbKHX COTeH ra B Fo,.

Ycnex 3'roro npoeKTa 6bu3 o6ycnoBneH TpeMfl 4aKTopaMH:

* IlpoeKT 6bi opraHli3OBaH H ocyWecTTBneH COBMeCTHbIMH YCHAHflMH Bcex AeCHbix npe2npIflT1HpernoHa H KHTaHCKO wKeneM3HoA aoporor, a anIl pa6oT no 3arOTOBKe nOBpewaeHHorO neca 6bl.roMo6HJIH3OBaHo 25 TbIC. pa6oqHx.

* BbulJa coa3aHa MHoroCJIOHHasl CHCTeMa OXpaHbi JIeCOB OT nO)KapOB, BKJIIo'-aIowa5iHHTerpHPOBaHHYIO CHCTeMy CBfl3H; CnyrHHKOBbie H aBHaUHOHHb1e Ha6Io2AeH1n, no)KapHbie 6pHraabl6bicTporo pearmpOBaHHl, B pacnopflxeHH1 KOTOpblX tiMemOTCm BepTOJeTbi; BOeHll3HpOBaHHbieno,KapHbie KOMaHAbi, OCHaBueHHbIe Be321exoAaMH-aMdH61aMmH LAn nepeBo3KH nepcoHaAa, HriO2KapHbMMH MalwHHaMH. KpoMe TOrO, Ha noMOiUb npoq0eCCHoHanjbHbiM nO)KapHblM npIuiJloMeCTHoe HaceJieHHe: anH TYweHHS nO)KaPOB Mo6HJH3oBbIBajuHCb BCe B3pOCJble pa6o41He.

* BceMHpHbiA 6aHK o6ecneqHJI cneuHaJnH3UpoBaHHyio 3KCnepTHy1o nOMOLlb 14 d)IiHaHCOBble CpeaCTBa.

Tpe6yeTCs H3MeHHTb BCIO CHCTeMy 3aIUHTbl OKpyxaiolueUi Cpe,bl OT Bpe'HbIXBo3,eACTBHrl. npH oLteHKe Bo3,aeACTBHfl Ha oKpyKaioLuyio cpegy (OBOC) OCHOBHoeBHHMaHHe yZaenieTCs TeXHH4eCKHM YCJ1OBH5M H HOpMaM, KOTOpble B HeKOTOpb1X cjyta3xHepeaAbHO BbICOKU H TpyaHO HCnIOfb3yeMbi. Boniee WHPOKHM BOnpOCaMHHCTHTYUHOHaBJbHOrO yKpenJleHHA, AHHaMHKH COUUHaJbHO-3KOHOMHxeCKOrO pa3BHTHM,me)Koipac]eBbIM OTHOU1eHUHRM H 4 (bHaHCHpOBaHHIO OXpaHbl OKpywaOLLeg Cpeabi yeAmeHTCHJIHWUb MHHHMaJ]bHOe BHHMaHHe. HlpoueaypbI BBeeiReHif H KOHTPOJIA 3a co6moareHHeM HOpM HTpe6oBaHHAi cia6bi, a CHCTeMa wTpaq)oB H3-3a cBoeu1 Hecoo6pa3HocTH He cnoco6cTByeT3aHHTepeCOBaHHOCTH B CO6JnOaeHHH YCTaHOBJeHHbIX Tpe6OBaHHS. Heo6XotaiM qeTKOC4DOpMyJIHpOBaHHbIl JIiaH 3eMJIelOJlb3OBaH[iH, OCHOBaHHblUI Ha 3KOJIOrHqeCKHX HrpHpo2ooxpaHHb1X KpTTepHA1X H co3nawoutH KOMnHeKCHYIO CTPYKTYPY AIS oueHKH3KoJTorKlHeCKHX nocAe)ICTBsIA. TaKaq CTpyKTypa nO3BOJIHT yaeAITb JIOJUKHoe BHHMaHHeoxpaHe AeCOB OT lO)KapOB, COXpaHeHHio 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3HH H rlpOH3BOaCTBy apeBeCHHbi KaKB LUeJOM, TaK H no KaK,OMy H3 3THX HanpaBJleHUU B OTgeAbHOCT4, a TaK)Ke yKpenHTB03MO)KHOCTH pyKOBOJHTeJAei llpOMbiwJIeHHbIX rIpealIpHqTHi, MeCTHbIX H periOHaJlbHbIXBJacTeU H 4ieaepaJIbHbIX BeaOMCTB B niiaHe pa3pa6OTKH H npOBeaeHHH rOJIuTHKH.

Page 120: Russian - World Bank Documents

102

B. YcTokqUHBOCb H 3KOHOMHqeCKaA 2KH3HeCnoCo6HOCTb KaK [teJIH peOpraHH3agH ceKTopa

JIHua, OTBeTCTBeHHbie 3a pa3pa6oTKy H npoBeaeHHe nOJIITHKH, moryT nOMO4b

C03AaTb TaKHe YCAOB[4l AARfli necHoro ceKTopa, KoTopbie nO3BOJIHjIH 6bl emy oTpearupOBaTb Ha

H3MeHeHHAI, Bbl3BaHHbie 3KOHOMi4eCKOr H CTpyKTypHO nepeCTpORKOu, H nOBbICHTb

AojiroCpoMHy1o 3x"eKT4BHOCTb CBoeri pa6oTbI. ThH 3TorO HyXKeH pfla mep no

COBepllieHCTBOBaHHIO CHCTeMbI c6opa peHTHbIX niaTexKeg 3a HcnoJIb3OBaHH4e npHpOaHbIX

pecypcoB, aajIbHer4ueR JIH46epaJH3auHH MeWAyHapo,4HHor ToproBnJH H ocJIa6JIeHHIO BJ1aCTH

MOHOnOJIHi B iieCHOM CeKTOpe noCpeACTBOM BBe,eHHAl ,erCTBeHHbiX aHTHMOHOHOJlbHbIX

MexaHH3MOB. 9AAl 3TWow noTpe6yloTcq Mepb1 no COBepwleHCTBOBaHHIO pa6oTbI JiecHoro

ceKTopa, BKJHoqaioWue nepecTporiKy neCHo npoMbbiwJIeHHOCTH (CM. FnaBy I H np4Ao)KeHHe

F). B o6nacTH YCTaHOBjneHH41 ueH Ha pecypcbl HyxcHbl TaKHe peqopmbI nOJnHTHKH, KOTOpble

3aCTaBHJIH 6bl npOH3BOaHTenjeA H noJlb3oBaTeneA LIpeBecHHbI HeCTH Bce 3aTpaTbI Ha ee

npOH3BOACTBO. )OnbbUHM npenfqTCTBHeM Ha nyTH pe4DopM HBA1eTC51 CTpyKTypa HajiorOB,

KOTOpaqS aedeopMHpyeT o6pa3oBaHHe ueH Ha apeBeCHHY H coKpau.aeT aHana3oH

X1OnOJIHHTenJbHbIX niaTexeu, CBSI3aHHbIX C pecypcaMH.

CoBqpLueHcTBoBame MexaHH3M,a yc7aHoBJeHHX LfeH Ha iiecHme pecypchr

MeAIyHapo,aHbIi OnblT flCHO noKa3bIBaeT, TO KoHKypeHToCnoco6Haq necHa3i

npOMbbIwUieHHOCTb Tpe6yeT TaKOU CHCTeMbl YCTaHOBJIeHHl UeH Ha peCypCbI, KOTOpafl

3aCTaBAsieT xlepeBonepepa6oT4HKoB HeCTH nOJIHbIe 3aTpaTbI Ha npOH3BOACTBO apeBeCHHbl.1 4

MHorHe CTpaHbl C o6IUHpHbIMH AeCHbIMH YrOabSIMH, BKjnoqaf Pocciuo, cy6CHAI4poBaJIH

necHyio npOMbiwIAeHHOCTb, HCKYCCTBeHHO 3aHH)KaS 3aTpaTbI Ha npOH3BOACTBO ApeBeCHHbI,

JIH6o nocpeACTBoM BbiJejieHHS1 AeCHoA npoMbiwUieHHOCTH cy6cHaHri Ha 3HeprHio H

TpaHCnOpTHpOBKy, nH60 3a C'eT TOPrOBblX 6apbepoB. HeH36excHbIM pe3yflbTaToM TaKOrO

noa1xoAa flBHJIHCb KpynHbIe HellOCTaTKH B pa6oTe AepeBonepepa6aTbIBaiOLueA OTpaCJIH

He344eKTHBHOe pa3MeULeHHe HpOH3BOLCTBeHHbIX MOUitHOCTeH, K36bITO'qHasI

npoH3BoLICTBeHHaSi MOLUHOCTb oTpacJiH H HU3KHU YPOBeHb HHBeCTHpOBaHHH B

pecypcoynpaBsieHHe.

loueHHffHaf ia7m. CaMoA Ba)KHOU npHUH4HOU HH3KOU 34)eKTHBHoCTH 51BJIqeTCql

CHCTeMa onpeaeneHHsl CTOHMOCTH neca Ha KOPHIO (CM. Bbile, CHocKa 8). TaK, noneHHas

nnaTa IBnAfeTCR CIHIUWKOM HH3KOr4, HeT SlCHbIX H qeTKHX KPHTepHeB ee onpeaejieHHf, oHa

B3HMaeTC51 TOJIbKO 3a BbIBe3eHHYIO H3 nieca apeBeCHHY, a He 3a BeCb o6beM cpy6JieHHbiX

AepeBbeB, H BbIrO.Ha rlpealHpHAlTHSIM, nOTOMY ITO 3TO CHH)KaeT npOH3BOACTBeHHbie 3aTpaTbI

HuIH aaeT B03MO)KHOCTb noAyqaTb apeBecHHY ny'ywero KateCTBa. FlpaBHJIbHo noCTpoeHHasI

CHCTeMa onpeIeAeHHS5 CTOHMOCTH iieca Ha KOPHIO MO)KeT AaTb MOWHbIe HpOH3BOACTBeHHbIe

CTHMYJlbl K nOBblw1eHH1O 344qeKTHBHOCTH H nepexo1y K PaUHOHaJlbHOMY ieCoynlpaBJieHI4o.

CHCTeMy YCTaHOBwieHH51 ueH Ha peCypCbI MO)KHO nOCTpOHTb TaKHM o6pa3OM, '4TO6bI

o6eCne'nHTb 3aUIHTepeCOBaHHOCTb peCypCOnOJIb3OBaTeJieA B OnT4MIU3aRutH HCnOJIb3OBaHH51

peCYPCOB Ha HeHCToLUHTeAbHofi OCHOBe. KpoMe Toro, OTHOC4TeJ1bHO npOCTO MO)KHO

paCnpenefAITb AOXOAbI OT noneHHori nniaTbi no KOHKpeTHbIM 4)YHKU4l51M JIecoynpaBJeHHsI,

KaK 3TO neJAaeTCsI B KaHaaCKOA npOBHUHHUU BPHTaHCKaA KoJiyM6tSl B paMKaX nporpaMMbi

14 E5owee noapo6Ho oI7IcaHHbie 3aecb Meoamr naoyeHim peHTHhrxaoxoaoB paccMaTpBaIo0TCR aB M Gil/is,

"Forest Concession Management and Revenue Policies" B: N. Sharma, ed., 1992.

Page 121: Russian - World Bank Documents

103

BOCnPOH3BOIICTBa JieCOB, KOTOpaR 4,HHaHctipyeTCH HCKIIO'HTeAbHO 3a c'eT aOXOaOB OTnoneHHOu nHJaTbl (aBa MIpa. aoJIJIapOB 3a ns5THJeTHHi nepHoa).

EOJIbLIHHCTBO CHCTeM onpeaenfeHHS4 pa3mepa H 4CnOJIb3OBaHHR ToneHHOu nHfaTbInpe,anoaralOT, YTO peHTHbIe nAaTe)KH, nocTynaIoulHe BjiageJbuy pecypca, HBnIlOTcROCTaTOMHOti CyMMOA OT UeHbI peanjiH3aumH 3a BbIMeTOM npOH3BOaCTBeHHbIX 3aTpaT HnpH6buieg npeaHpH5ITHSI. CIIOHAb3oBaHHe TaKOR CHCTeMbI B POCCH4 Mornjo 6bl nO3BOJIHTbyCTpaHHTb HMelOueCSu riepeKOCbl B paCFIpeaeJieHHH peHTHbIX AOXOAOB. Oco6eHHO Ba)KHOTO, YTo6bi TaKas CHCTeMa aAeKBaTHO oTpa)KaAa perHOHaIbHb[e pa-3JuIH4i B CTOHMOCTHpecypca H TeKYLUHX rPOH3BOaCTBeHHbIX 3aTpaTax, BKJHotiaSi 3aTpaTbl Ha TpaHcnOpTHpOBKy.Ho InOCKOJIbKY CTOHMOCTb JeCHbIX pecypcoB 3aHH)KeHa, B POCCHH, BMeCTO 3Toro, qaCTbCTOHMOCTH pecypca OTqHcjiHeTCq 3a CqeT Haniora Ha npH6bLIb rpernppHjITHr. B apyr4xcTpaHax, rae B 3THX LUenAX TO)Ke uHCOAb3YIOT HaWOrH Ha rpH6biTIb, pa3pa6OTaHbl 6oneeCAO)KHbie CHCTeMbi HonyJeHH5I peHTHbIX AOXOaOB, Ha OCHOBe qaKTHqeCKOir pbIHO4HOr4CTOUMOCTH pecypca.

}IecHme roprH. Bce CTpaHbl opraHH3ylOT caMble pa3Hoo6pa3Hbie THnbl TOprOB(ayKuHoHbi, KOHKYPCHbie ToprH, rpoaa)KH AeCHbIX nAowaaer, BOnOmeTpH,4ecKHe npotaaKH,npoat)KH Ha OCHoBe oLteHKH CTOHMOCTH) C uejlbio oTqHcnJeHHA BIaaenbUy AeCOBCOOTBeTCTBYIOIeti aOIH peHTbl OT npoat)KH apeBecHHbI. Y POCCHH Majio npaKTH'eCKOFOOnbITa B npOBeaeHHH AeCHbIX TOprOB, HO ee 3KcnepHMeHT nO Ipoaa)KeC c ayKUHOHa HlpaB Ha3arOTOBKY .neca Ha J7aabHeM BocToKe aaeT xopowHe pC3yAbTaTbl (TaK, HaHpHMep, UeHbl HaHeKOTOpbIX Toprax AOXOAH4H ao 45 TbIC. py6neul 3a Ky6oMeTp). KOHKypcHble necHble ToprHnpH cnpaBeWiHBbIx YCAOBMHX MaKCHMH3HPY1OT aOXOabl co6CTBeHHHKa pecypca, HO B 3TOMcjiyqae He Bceraa yaaeTC51 yqHTbIBaTb apyrHe 3KOHOMHqecKHe, COUHMabHbie H Hp4pOaHbleLLeHHOcTH. KpoMe Toro, TaM rie 3TO B03MO)KHO H yMeCTHO, B CHCTeMe OUeHKH cieAyeTYqHTbIBaTb HeapeBeCHbie npoayKTbi H o6ecneqHB 6o0iee HOnHyIO HHTerpauHiopa3Hoo6pa3HbIX IeCHbIX peCypCOB B o61LUH npouecc AecoynpaBAeHHs.

Pa3rpamweHHNe MCeAIYXpHTHoI nlaT0o 38 pecyXCbI H H8101Oo6JOXeHHcM i4pe41ipHuITm

o7ffrnTKa B OTHOlffeHHH KOHIICCCHJL 90% BceU aeniOBOg apeBeCHHbl,IIpOH3BOiHMOA B MHpe Ha 3eMJASX, HaXOIAMU1HXCI B rOCyaapCTBeHHOA (o6IieCTBeHHOA)co6CTBeHHOCTH, 3aroTaBnuHaeTC9 nO KOHLeccHOHHbIM aoroBopaM c npearipH5THSMH,KOTOPbIM npeaoCTaTBJTlOTC5I HCKJHO'HTeJIbHbie ripaBa Ha 3KcnHyaTaUH1O Aeca HAnu BeeeHHeXO3.qACTBa Ha KOHKpeTHOr4 nHjowaam. KOHLeCCHH4 06blYHO npeaocTaBAsjoTCS HO YCMOTpeHHioa,aMHHHcTpauH HnHu no pe3yAbTaTaM KOHKYpCHb1x ayKUHOHOB, HAM )e Hc OAb3yeTC, HeKHuKOM6HHHpoBaHHbl noITxot.

HocKOJbKy npH nepeaaqe B KOHUeCCuiO 60.bWHX yYaCTKOB JeCHbIX 3CMeJb HaJIHTeAbHbie nepMoabl, KaK npaBHsO, rpaKTHueCKH HeBO3MO)KHO co3iaaTb YCJOBH$I anSflpOBeaeHHA ayKLtHOHa, KOHUeCCHOHHbie ripaBa o6blqHO onpeaeAqIoTcsi no ycMoTpeH[4oa,aMHHHcTpauuH nocAe fieperoBopoB Me)Ky npe)iCTaBHTeJi5MH opraHOB BIaCTH HnOiXOSaAwHMH npeTeHaeHTaMH. KOHKypCHbil aYKUHOH no npoiaae KOHueccHOHHbIx npaBMOXKHO FTpOBeCTH TOAbKO TOraa, KOraa eCTb aieKBaTHbie HHBeHTaPH3auHOHHbie aaHHbie OiapeBeCHbIX pecypcax, Koraa Ha ayKuHOHHOM pbIHKe aocTaTOqHO BbICOKa KOHKypeHuHH,Korita 3aTpaTbl Ha c6op H OUeHKY HHqPOpMauHHU nO Ka'eCTBy HacaAKieHHu OTHOCHTenbHOHH3KH, H4 KOraa B BeaOMCTBe, KOTOpOe OpraHH3yeT ayKLU1OH, CCTb COOTBeTCTBYIOWHecneuHaJIHCTbI. 3TOT MeTOa o6blqHo npHMeHqeTCR TOAbKO AiA He6oAbLUHx yqacTKOB,

Page 122: Russian - World Bank Documents

104

c,aaioLUHXC51 Ha OTHOCHTenjbHO KOPOTKme CpOKH. B KaHage, Maniau31uu iU BeHecy3ne

KOHKYPCHbie ayKU1OHbI HcnOJIb3yIOTCA WA15 npolLaxKH KpaTKOCpO4Hb1X i1uUeH3Hi9. B

HeKOTOpbIX cjiyqalix 3JIeMeHTbi ayKUUOHHOH C14CTeMbl MOryT CO'eTaTbCA C OrpaHHMeHHb1M

npaBOM Bbi6opa Co CTOpOHbI aaMHHHCTpaUmH, WTO nOBbIlaeT 34)eKTHBHOCTb KOHKypeHU4I4

MeKLly pa3J14qHbIMH KOHueCcHOHepaMH.

MHorHe CTpaHbl HaqHHajIH npaKTmKy ripeaOCTaBjeHHAs KOHueCCHrU C

HCnoJIb3oBaHusA HeaOCTaTO4HO 'ieTKO COCTaBJIeHHbIX KOHUCCCHOHHbIX xROrOBOpOB 14

nocTeneHHO repexoaH4ni K AOrOBOpaM, coaep)KaLUHM 6o0nee aeriCTBeHHbIe CT14MynJbl K

HeHCTOLUHTeSJbHOMY JieconOJ1b3OBaHH1O TOJTbKO TorAa, Kor,aa uX JIeCHbie peCypCbI

OKa3blBanJICb y)Ke B 3HaM4TeAbHOh mepe 4CTOIueHbi. Y PoccHH, c ee OrpOMHbIM14

nAO1.a,al5MH HeOCBOeHHbIX nJeCOB B CH6Hpul U Ha .,ajIbHeM BocToKe, noKa eCTb BO3MO)KHOCTb

H36e)KaTb TaKoro HCTOULeHHq. B HOBbIX KOHLUeCCHOHHbIX aoroBopax MO)KHO 3anH4caTb

YCJIOBHfl o co6AuozaeHHH npHHU14HOB HeHCTOlUHTeJIbHoro JIeconoAb3oBaHH5l, a KOHueccH1 C

eLue He HCTeKWHM CpOKOM, ecniH HX BJIa,eJbUbI He BbInOJIHqIIOT CBOU4X o65i3aTeJlbCTB no

JIecoynpaBjieHHIO, MO)KHO aHHYJ1HPOBaTb AAAI yjyquweHHS pa6oTbl B 6yaymeM. Bce 3TO

MO)KHO aOnOJIH4Tb XOpOwO npOAyMaHHbIMH MepaMH nO Haa3Opy H KOHTpOJHO 3a

BbIlOJIHeHHCM 3TUX Tpe6oBaHI4U. B HeKOTOPbIX cTpaHax aep)KaTejIlM KOHLIeCCHU pa3peweHo

rnepe,aaBaTb KOHueCCHOHHbie HpaBa, 'TO 5IBJIqeTCA1 CI4JIbHbIM CTHMYJIOM K 34leKTHBHoMY

pecypconojlb3OBaHIlo. HpH BO3MOKHOCTm nepeaaqu npaB, KOHIueCCUOHepbl MOryT

nO)KHHaTb nJIORbl CBOHX yCHunHu no no=ep)KaHHIO 1,onroCpo1IHok HpOTYKTHBHOCTH, TaKHX

KaK H36eLKaHHe paHHero Bo3BpalleHHAI Ha Bbipy6JieHHbie njioi,ua un1114 BHeapeH) e H LaAqIUHx

MeTO,aOB JIeCO3arOTOBKH, xITO criOCo6CTByeT 6onee WHpOKOMY HcrioJIb3oBaHHIO TaKHX

nOLaXOROB.

Haioroo6xomem,e. B 6ioaiKeTbi pa3JIHWHbIX ypOBHeU rocy,AapcTBeHHoro

ynpaBjieHH,9 HocTynaIOT BO3MeLgaeMbie H HeBO3meL aembie nHiaTe)KH OT fleCHoR

npOMbIWAIeHHOCTH. Bo3MeluaeMbie rinaTe)KH nocTynaIOT BsaaenbLtY pecypca OT

J1eCO3aFOTOBHTeClbHbIX HpeanlpHITHI4 B Ka'eCTBe KoMneHcau414 3a H3'bAITHe pecypca.

HeBo3MeiuaeMbie njiaTe)KH JieCO3arOTOB14TenJbHb1e npeanpH451T451 OTqUHCjI5OT npaBHTeSJbCTBY

Ha OCHOBaHH1 OCYlUICCTBJleHH5I HM CBoero CyBepeHHoro nlpaBa; aBYMSI CaMbIMH

paCnpOCTpaHeHHbIMH 14OpMaMH AIBJISIOTCA 3KCHOPTHbie HaJlorH H nOaOXOaHbie Haj0or4.

K B03MeULaeMbIM niaTe)KaM OTHOCITCA: nniaTa 3a HCnOJIb3OBaHHe apeBeCHbIX

pecypcoB, jiHueH3HOHHa5 nniaTa 1 nniaTa 3a IieCOBoCCTaHoBJIeHHe. nIiaTa 3a pecypcbi

Tpa,HUHOHHO COOTHoCHJIaCb CO CTOHMOCTbIO KpyrJIoro nieca, HO nOCKOJ1bKY CTpaHbl BCe

60Abwle npH6eraIOT K CaMOCTO,9TeJlbHOri nepepa6oTKe CBOUX apeBeCHb]X peCypCOB, 3Ta llnaTa

cTaiia onpealeji5TbCq no o6beMy npOaYKTOB nepepa6oTKH. 9To npHBeJIO K HeKOTOpOMY

3aCTOIO B nepepa6aTblBaloltX oTpachiix CTpaH, lPO143BOaSqLUIX apeBeCHHy. Pa3Mepbi nJ1aTb1

3a HC11OAb3OBaHHe iieCHbIX pecypcoB moryT onpeHjeJ5lTbCR no o6tbeMy 143'b.Toro pecypca,

KOJIHMeCTBY aepeBbeB (B COOTBeTCTBHl C BHLOBbIM COCTaBOM) HJ1H nO CTOU4MOCTUi 13bSqTOrO

pecypca. J]HueH3HOHHbie njiaTe'KH (oRHopa3oBbie 114 roaoBble) OCHOBb1BaTOTC5I Ha o6iuef

njIoLuaaL H MOrYT H3MeHAITbCA B 3aBHCHMOCTH OT CTelleHH aOCTynHOCTH U Ka'eCTBa

HacaAKfeHH51.

IOXOJAbl OT HeBO3MeluaeMbiX nHiaTexerl MOryT UCnOJlb3OBaTbC1 iA5 nOzaep)KKH

o6LUHx rOCyaapCTBeHHb1X nporpaMM. C yBeJH'qeHHeM HHBeCTHpOBaHHIA B OTeqeCTBeHHYIO

IaepeBonepepa6aTb1BaioLuyio npOMbILujieHHOCTb 6OAbLUHHCTBO CTpaH nepewiio OT

HCnOJIb3OBaHAS HaJTOrOB Ha 3KCnOpT KpyrFJbIX liecomaTepUaJIOB K HCHOJ1b3OBaRHHO HaJ1OrOB

Page 123: Russian - World Bank Documents

105

Ha aoXOa (tUi4 npU6blJlb) B KaqeCTBe OCHOBHOFO 14CTO4HHKa rOCyyapCTBCHHbIX AOXOaOB OTniecHoro ceKTopa. HanorH Ha 3KCnOpT Kpyrjioro .neca (KoTopble 6buAo JIerKO B3HMaTb, nOTOMY'TO KpyrfJbIe .eCOMaTepHajibi 3KCnOPTHPOBaJIHCb Bcero 'epe3 HeCKOJbKO IlOpTOB) Korga-TO6bulI OCHOBHbIM CT14MYJIOM 6blcTporo pa3BI4TI4l HH4AYCTpHaJIH343aUHK B iieCHOM ceKTope. HoTaKaSI rpaKTHKa noneieKna 3a co6ori BbICOKi4e o6mue 3KOHOMH4leCKHe H3nep)KKH. KpoMeToro, nIpaBHTejibCTBO HIOHeCjO 6oAJbWHe rIOTepH B aoxoaax OT CeKTOpa H3-3a O'CHb BbICOKOHCTeneHH4 npOTeKKuHOHH3Ma rIO OTHOUleHH1IO K aepeBonepepa6aTbIBaiowHM OTpaCJIAM Bpe3yJlbTaTe pa3JIH14qH B HarioraX Ha Cblpbe H1 Hepepa6OTaHHble MaTepHaJIbi.

KaKOA MeTOa rOJiy,4eHH5 rOCyaapCTBeHHbIX aOXOaOB OT iieCHOrO ceKTopa 5BJIqeTCqCaMbiM Jly-WHM, 3aBHC4HT OT YpOBHA 3KOJIOFH4eCKOrO pa3Hoo6pa3l4H, COCTOSHHSI neca H eronpeapacnoioKeHHOCTX K no)xapaM, BO3MO)KHOCTeh rocyzapCTBeHHOro CeKTOpaKOHTpOJHpOBaTb neCOX03SHCTBeHHYIO aeSATeCbHOCTb, HaWIHqHS noapo6HoAHHBeHTapH3aUHOHHOR HHcjOpMamHH, COCTOMHFH UHH¢paCTpYKTypbl 14 MHOrHX apyrKX4baKTOpOB. KJmIoweBOA nepeMeHHOUi B c6ope HajiorOB HBJ]SIOTCA aaMli4HHcTpaTHBHbieB03MO)KHOCTH npaBHTeJ1bCTBa. Y'IHTbIBaS4 HCTOPHIO paCTpaUHBaHH JIleCOB B POCCHH, MO)KeT6blTb, jiy-qwe Bcero yCTaHOBHTb peHTHbie raTeKI4KH 3a pecypc B BHae d14KCHpOBaHHOrUe)Kero2aHoA nHiaTbI 3a HcnOTb3yeMbIe njioiuaAH, OCHOBaHHOi Ha oueHKe CTOHMOCTH neca HaKOPHIO anTA5 KOHKpeTHOFO perHOHa. 3To 6blJo 6bl OTHOCHTeAlbHO rlpOCTO BBeCTH, H Bbl3BajiO6bl 3aHHTepeCOBaHHOCTb nepepa6OTqHKOB B yMeHbWeI4HHH KOJIH4eCTBa OTXOaOB. HOJIHTHKa Bo6JiaCTH HeB03meLuaeMblX HajOirOB H fJaTexCeK JIeCHbIX HpelripHATHH UOJIXHa 6blTb TaKOUX(e, KaK H ,nIq KOMMepqeCK14X rpeCgnpHATH4 B apyrHX OTpaciiqx.

Owia6ffeHHe wIcTJ MOHOmOImJf

CyLJeCTByeT KpaHlHe MajiO TaKHX CHCTeM pblHOqHOr4 9KOHOMHKH, lIpH KOTOpbIXHpaB14TeJlbCTBO yAep)KHBaeT B CBOerl Co6CTBeHHOCTH 3Ha'iHTeJIbHyIO 4aCTb aKTHBOB)aepeBonepepa6aTb1BaiOLueA npOMblwjieHHOCT4. BeCbMa 'iaCTO, KaK 3TO, HanpHMep, HMeeTMeCTO B CWIA H KaHaue, ipaBHTeTIbCTBO aKTHBHO pa3pa6aTblBaeT rOJIHTUKY rlpHBJleqeHHSHHBeCTHUHH B ripOMbIlllIeHHOCTb, OaHaKO qaCTHbIe qjHpMbl Bceraa HpHH4MalOT CBOUco6cTBeHHbie peLweHi45 Ho HHBeCTHpOBaH1IO H yrpaBjieHIH10, HCXOaq 143 KOHKpeTHbIX3KOHOMHqeCK14X YCAOBHH H Tpe6oBaHHr4 rocyaapcTBeHHoro peryJIHpoBaH4HM. B TO BpeMq,KaK lpaBHTeJlbCTBO B orpeaejieHHbIX cjiy4aqx coxpaH5ieT 3a co6og pery.nHpylouuHie 4YHKLIHHH HOJIHOMO4HS (HanpHMep, B OTHOUeJHHH 3afPM3HCHH5 BO;LOCMOB BCJICaCTBHe pa6OTbluejijlOaO3HO-6yMa)KHbIx rpeanpHsTHA), rpOMbbliweHHOCTb HeceT 3aTpaTb1 Ha pa3pa6OTKy Hocyi1eCTBAeHHe rporpaMM OMHCTKH. nAaTa 3a nOJlb3OBaHHe, JiHueH3HH H 1l4Tpa)b1 HBlAJISOTCSLAA ripaBHTeCJbCTBa HHcTpyMCHTaMH roJIy t {eHHR KOMreCHcauHH 3a BHeWiHHe 34(eKTbl pa6oTblrpoMbbLIwieHHOCTH, H OHH MoryT 6blTb CUJlbHbIM CTHMYJIOM K BHeCeHH1O HeO6XOaRMblXH3MeHeHHuI B npaKTHWeCKHe MeTOAb! ynpaBJIeHHS.

B pOCCUH4CKOM JIeCHOM ceKTopC npouecc aKLHOHHPOBaHHA H HpHBaTH3aLIHHnpOMb1lHweHHbIX rpeanpHITHA, no CpaBHeHH10 C apyrHMH OTpacmqMH, HiaeT 6biCTpO.Haq4HHaR C 1991 roaa KOJIiH4eCTBo rocyaapcTBeHHbIX npeanpHATHA niecHoro ceKTopa PoccHHCOKpaTHnOCb [1O0TH B 10 pa3. OaHaKO pertOHaOjbHbie H MeCTHb[e opraHbla,aMHHHCTpaTHBHOrO yripasBjeHHA ripoaojinKa1OT HrpaTb OqCHb BaXHyiO KaK bOpMajibHyio, TaKH He(OpManbHYO pOJIb B PYKOBOaCTBe BHOBb co3LaaHHbiMH iKLH14OHepHbIMH o6LUecTBaMH.lIx Ba)KHaS pOJIb B ynpaBjieHH4, npeaoripeaenAeTcA c1aKTOM BbilaeAeHHI4 MeCTHbIM KpynHb1MH4 HepeHTa6eJIbHbIM necoripoMbbLiweHHbIM npCanplIHSTHM 4bHHaHCOBb1X cy6cHaHA,

Page 124: Russian - World Bank Documents

106

npe,aHa3Ha,eHHbIX ARA TOrO, MTo6bl He aOnyCT4Tb HX 3aKpblTHq H TeM CaMbiM CMqrMHTb

COLLHanjbHbie npo6neMbb.

OpraHH3auHoHHa5i CTpyKTypa IeCHO npOMblwjleHHOCTM PoccHH B nocAelHHMe

ro,abl nepexoAHoro nepHoaa nOCTOAHHo npeTepneBaeT cyLueCTBeHHb[e M3MeHeHMR1

(noapo6HocT4 CM. B npUMoAoeHMH B). OaHaKO 3TU H3MeHeHH41 OKa3blBaiOT O4eHb

He3HalHTeCJbHOe BJnU4qHHe Ha PerFOHanJbHbie JieCOnpOMbbiwieHHbie MOHOnOjiHiU. B OTpaCniU

AOMHH4POBaJIH HeCKOJIbKO KpynHbIX perHOHaIbHbIX aKUHOHepHbIX o6LUeCTB THna

LaJbJIecnpOMa H )taJ¶bJleca B Xa6apOBCKOM Kpae (no2ao6Hbie RpyrtHM 6blBWHM 4matiaJiaM

o6wuepoccHfiCKof4 rOCyaapCTBeHHOU XOJUI4HrOBOA KOMnaHHH PoclecnpoM), KOTOpbIe, Cyaq

no BCeMy, 6bmuH cnoco6Hbl BJIH4ITb KaK Ha CTOHMOCTb nieca Ha KOpHIO, TaK H Ha IKeHbl Ha

BbInYCKaeMyiO npOIyKuUL1O B perHOHax. BHOBb Co3JaaHHbIe aKUHOHepHbie KOMnaHUHH aKTBHO

nbITalOTC,9 o6peCTH 3KOHOMM4eCKyiO CaMOCTOATeJlbHOCTb OT 3TUX MOHOnOAUHr, OAHaKO UX

YCHJIH,q 3atIaCTyIO HaTaJIKMBalOTC Ha npOTHBOaeACTBHe CO CTOPOHbl 4JleHOB npaBAeHHA,

3aHHMaBWHUX BbICOKH4e aAMHHHCTpaTHBHbie aOJIKHOCTH B PocJiecnpoMe.

XOTM coriaCHO npOeKTY JleCHOrO KoReKCa, "CTaPTOBbIe 6apbepbl" Aqq HOBbIX

npearLpH4HTHfi AecHoro ceKTopa 4O0JKHbi nOH434TbCq, nOJIHOCTbIO OHH He JIHKBHR4pyIOTC51.

Boniee TOrO, B npoeKTce JlecHoro KOaeKCa HeT ORHO3HaqHbIx aHTHMOHOnOJIbHbIX nojioKCeHiH,

KOTOpbIe 3anpeIaJI 6bl aCeCTBMi$ CO CTOpOHbl opraHoB rocy1apCTBeHHoro ynpaBJIeHHI4, no

orpaHuM'eHlIO BO3MO)IKHOCTe npMo6peTeHHA npaB JIeconOJIb3OBaHMR, M4JIM W4CKPM4HaULHIO

onpe,aejeHHbIX J1econpoMbIwIfeHHb1X npeHnpHATHR (noApo6HocTH CM. B nHpMoKeHtH4 B). K

TOMy wKe, 34xeKTMBHOCTb aepeBonepepa6aTbIBaioLuer oTpacim MO)KHO nOBbICMTb TOJlbKO

nyTeM pa3yKpynHeHHR TaKmx MOHonoHAHI, 6o0iee )KeCTKoro npi4MeHeHHS aHT4MOHOnOAbHoro

3aKOHo,aaTeAbCTBa H nOBblwleHMA ypOBHH KOHKypeHU4M. 9Tsq aOCTH)KeHM49 3TOU LejiH B

60obWlllHCTBe cniyqaeB noTpe6yeTcq H3MeHHTb CTPYKTYpY KOHUeCCHOHHbIX aOrOBOpOB C

aKUHOHepHb1MH o6LieCTBaMH co3TaaHHbIMH fJI$ HX peajH3auLHH.

MO)KeT OKa3aTbCS, WTO pOCCHrCKOe 4)eaepaAbHoe npaBMTeJlbCTBO, nepea KOTOPbIM

CTO01T O'eHb TpyfHbie 3aaaM4 H o6R3aHHOCTH B CTOJIb MHOrHX o6jlacTqX, npOCTO He MO)KeT B

OLIHOBpeMeHHO pewHTb BCe npo6JieMbl, CyWeCTByiOlUHe Ha pbIHKe, B CHCTeMe

LteHoo6pa3OBaHI4q H pacnpeaeJIeHH5l, KOTOpbIe qBJISHOTCq CAeaCTBHeM q1YHKUNOHMPOBaHHR

CMCTeMbl MOHOnOjiMCTMtieCKOrO KOHTpOJI5. OXHaKO npaBHTenjbCTBO MOxeT pa3yKpynHmTb

CyLueCTBYIOI1Me MOHOnOJIMH MJIH ycTpaHHTb HeKOTOpbIC M3 HaH6ojiee HeraTHBHbIX

nocAieACTBMd MOHonojiM3auMM PbIHKa 3a C4eT KOHKpeTH3aUHMH 3aKOHOB 14 BBeaeHMa

344eKTHBHOri CHCTeMbi perynUPOBaHU4 Ha PerHOHanjbHOM YPOBHe. B KaqeCTBe ieACTBYIOLULX

Moaejier4 MO)KHO McHOJIb3OBaTb naKeTbI aHTHMOHOnOJIbHbIX Mep, npHMeHeHHe KOTOpbIX y)Ke

anpO6MpOBaHO B JIeCHOM ceKTope apyrMX npOMblwjieHHbIX CTpaH.

r. CoLuHaJxbHoe o6ecneqeHue B JIeCHOM ceKTope

FOMMMO KOHcDARKTOB, CBq3aHHbIX C npaBaMM KOpeHHOrO Hacen1eHHf Ha 3eMJno,

CyLueCTByeT WHpOKMU pSa npo6JieM couo6ecneqeHM5I B .JeCHOM CeKTOpe, KOTOPble Tpe6ylOT

He3aMeAAHTeCJbHOrO paCCMOTpeHMH. B HaCTOAlitee BpeM5] HaXOAHTCR noa yrpO3OA

6JlarocOcTolHHe npHMepHO 10 MJUIAHOHOB 'ejiOBeK, 'IbM B03MO)KHOCTM nOJ]yqaTb CpeaCTBa K

CyllueCTBOBaHHIO 3aBMCHT OT JieCHbIX peCypCOB. Hoao6Haq CMTyauiR CB13aHa C nepe2aaerU

rOCy,aapCTBeHHOMY CeKTOpy OTBeTCTBeHHOCTM 3a COUMaJIbHbIe cjiy)K6bl U o6beKTbl

MHd)paCTpyKTypbl, npeIcae Haxoal4BuWeC5I Ha 6anaHce npeRHpHHTMu. TaKMe rpynnbi

Page 125: Russian - World Bank Documents

107

HacejieHHA oco6o YM3BI4MbI H3-3a OTaajieHHOCTH JieCHbIX paUOHOB U4 OTCYTCTBHRaBJbTepHaTHBHbIX B03MO)KHOCTerl 3aHATOCTH B MeCTaX HX npo)KHBaHHA.

Onpql(e.fIcHHe Jipa 3XmffeJiao3ORaHHI1 KopcHHoro HaceJe1JHh Ha cI7eLrmafanHo oTBAe4eCHHxTCppOpHJI

Hy)KHbl npOAyMaHHbie AeACTBMI, nAn Toro 4To6bi o6ecneMHTb CripaBeAJI4ByIO H34XeKTHBHyMO CHCTeMy 04HLUHabHOrO npH3HaHHR npaB KOpeHHbIX )KHTeJIerl Ha 3eMAHo.3aaepxKU C OqMHuaJibHblM FIpH3HaHHeM 3TKX nipaB He HO3BOJIMAOT BJlaCTAM nOAO)KHTb KOHeUHe3aKOHHOAi neco3aroTosuTenbHou AeATeJIbHOCTH Ha 3eMJI5X KOpeHHOrO HacejIeHHS,AesTeJibHOCTH, KOTOpaS MOxeT Heo6paTHMo oc.na6MTb nOTeHUHaJI JieCOB, KaK OCHOBbITpa,AHUMOHHOrO o6pa3a XKH3HH KOpeHHbIX HapOaOB (CM. npHioKeHHe )K).15 HeO6XOAHMO4eTKO onpeAeJIHTb, KTO KOHKpeTHO 6yAeT HeCTH OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a pa3pa6oTKy HnpoBeajeHHe OJI4THKH fecoynpaBjleHSA, pa3meueHHe pecypcoB H yqpexK eHHe CHCTeMueHoo6pa3OBaHHUq Ha TeppHTOpHAX, OTBeaeHHbIX IL5I o6ul4H KOpeHHOrO HaceJleHHR.

OpraHbl 3aKOHoAaTeibH BHnaCTH Xa6apoBcKoro KpaA npIHHAA KOMnIieKCHOpMaTHBHO-npaBOBbIx aKTOB, KOTOpbie cnpaBennusBO YqHTbIBalOT HHTepeCbi KOpeHHOrOHaCeJTeHMsI. 3THMU HOpMaTHBHO-npaBOBblMH aKTaMH ripeayCMaTp4BaeTCS BbileXjeHMCTeppHTopHH noA TpaaBHLHOHHbie H o6IUHHHbie BHAbl bIOJb3OBaHI4U H npeAOCTaBJIeHHerpynnam KOpeHHOfO HaCeJieHHS 4IaKTHIeCKOr aBTOHOMHH B peI1eHHH BOlpOCOB 0 3arOTOBKeHeapeBeCHbIX peCypCOB H aOnyCKe nOJIb3OBaTeJiefi He npHHaanTe)KaIUHX K COOTBeTCTBylOIIeiio6ujHHe (CM. HH;Ke). OAHaKO peajibHas aerlCTBHTeJibHOCTb AgajieKa OT npeAnHCaH4r 3T0orO3aKOHO.IaTeJIbCTBa, oco6eHHO, B OTHOLueHHM aeJTeJAbHOCTH 'aCTHbIX JleCO3aIOTOBHTeJlbHbIXrpearnplSATHR Ha TeppHTopHSX, npe,lHa3Ha4eHHbIX HCKJo4M4TenJbHO AAA Tpa,IIHLtOHHOrOHOJnb3OBaH4R. Cyu.iecTByeT HeCKOJIbKO 4jeaepaWbHbIX goKyMeHToB, H npOeKT d)eAepajibHoro3aKoHa, r[Le paCCMaTPHBalOTCS BOnpOCbl npaB Ha 3eMAjo H TpaLHUHOHHbie BHAblLaeATeAbHOCTM KopeHHOrO HacefleHHS, KOTOpble AO CUX nOp He npHsHTbl.JleCo3aroTOBHTeJlbHbie npeAnlpHSlTH, flOJIb3y.9Cb 3THM lpaBOBbIM BaKyyMoM, flpoaoJlWaJOT3arOTasBjiHaTb iiec Ha niowaIlSx oxpaHAeMb[X neCOB (I rpynna). BOjibWiMHCTBO rpynnKOpeHHorO HaceAeHHR 3aKpblBaeT rna3a Ha HapylIweHHM, HOTOMY 'TO TaKHe nperlPMHATHHLialOT HM pa6oTy, o6ecneMHBaloT TpaHCHOpTHYIO CBS3b C par4OHHbIMH UeHTpaMH Ho6ecnequBaloT MeCTHbie Mara3HHbi nOTpe6HTejibCKUMM TOBapaMH.

Heo6xoaMmo aaTb 6onee ACHoe orpeaeJIeH4e 3THX npo6AeM H CPO4HO nPHHATbHOBblri 3aKOH, AaiOUwHi npaBO KOpeHHblM )KHTeASiM Ha noj1y4eHMe oripeaeAeHHOr AOAMAOXOAOB OT ocBoeHHA JIeCoB, a TaiKCe nOjiyqaTb KOMHeHCaUHio OT HCnOJib3OBaHHAo6UIMHHbIX 3eMenJb H peCypCOB. HYKHO aaTb 4eTKMe onpeAejieHMR KniaHaM Junu "CeMbRM",'ITo6bI TeppJlTopHH, npeaHa3Ha'4eHHbIe HCKJIOMHTe;IbHO AAA TpaIHUUOHHOrU aeeTejibHOCTm,MO)KHO 6bUIO OTeIJIHTb OT TeppHTOpHR, HaXOAAILIHXCS B co6CTBeHHOCTH o6(UH, HOHCHOJIb3YeMb[X A15 npoMbIlwjeHHOrO nPOH3BOACTBa ApeBecHHbI. fJ4eneBaR noMOLubKopeHHOMY HaceneHuIO, HanpauBJeMaA qepe3 HenpaBuTenJbCTBeHHbIe opraHH3auMM, morna6bl 6bITb oco60 UeHHOiU A1A pa3BMTHA npeAnpRATHAi, CBA3aHHbIX C Tpaat4ULOHHbIMH BtigaMH

15 YKa3oM 7pe3HeHTa PO (Ao 397, 1992), 3Kci7popHaHLtH 3eMewb KopeHHoro HaceweHhi aVlRHe7paa7IL1HfoHHbix BifaOB 7o0130o8Hh1 6e3 f7poBeacHHR MeCTHoro peoepeHayMa 3agpeweHa (Cm. Fondahll, 1995).CoLIaWbHo-Iyg7bTypHoe B}JHlfC ffHTeHCHBHoro fc!1o0b3oBqHfH CeBepHoro MopcKoro f7yTH Ha xK3HbKOpeHHbiX HapoCoB paccMaTpifBaeTc.b: Osherenko, 1995.

Page 126: Russian - World Bank Documents

108

,ae TenJbHOCTH (HanpiMep, nepepa6oTKoA qroa Hun BbwaeflKOH Ko)KH), o6y"eHUI4 'UTeHOB 3THX

o6LwMH JieCOBOaCTBY, OXOTOBeaeHiIO H pbi6oJIOBCTBy.

T,]j 4cnOJnb3OBaHHq HHBeCTiU1HOHHbIX Bo3MoKHoCTe i, KOTOpbIe MoryT yKpenuHTb

Tpa,aHUHOHHbie BHRbl ae5lTeJAbHOCTM H o6LUHHbl KOpeHHb1X )KMTeAle, cJieayeT pa3BHBaTb

CHCTeMy MejiKOMaCUITa6HbIX KpeUHTOB, Co3L1aBaTb KOonepaTHBbI, COui4aJbHbie 4OHAbl H

apyrMe CTpYKTypbl AA1 pa3BHTHR paHOHOB H o6wHH. K 3THM HHBeCTHUHOHHbIM

B03MO)KHOCTSIM OTHOCATCH: COIep)KaHHe He6ojibwHX CTaa CeBepHbIX oneHeri,

aepeBoo6pa6oTKa H npOH3BOaCTBO TpaHUUHOHHbIX apeBeCHblX npOayKTOB, pbi6Has nojisBi,

o6pa6oTKa MeXOB 14 pemecJieHHOe npOH3BOI1CTBO. I4HBeCTLULHOHHbIe B03MO)KHOCTH eCTb

TaK)we B o6JiaCTH COBpeMeHHoro nepeaBH)KHoro o6opyAOBaHHS ais nepepa6oTKM H xpaHeHHS

M5TCa. Heo6xoAi4Moe o6y,leHHe KOpeHHbIX KHTefleft Hx TpaaHLUHOHHbIM BHaaM Ae3ITeJAbHOCTH

MO)KeT nOBbICHTb peajiH3yeMOCTb Hx npOayKTOB.

06ecneveHme HaceCjicHIf JCCHMxpaA*oHoB UcKBaTmmmi COIfwalbmmmf YCJyayrMf

PaHblwe, nOMHMO 3apnriaTbi, pa6oTa Ha npeanpHSTHH nieCHoro ceKTopa (KaK H Ha

mnO6oM apyrOM rOCyaapCTBeHHOM ripealHpHSTHH) B POCCHH 03Ha'aJIa rIoJiy'eHHe )KHJbI,

neHCH4, MeAHUH4HCKOFO o6CJiy)KHBaHHSI, B03MOXKHOCTH 3aHHMaTbCq CnOpTOM, OnIJlaqHBaeMbIX

OTnyCKOB, aowKKOibHoro o6pa3OBaHHS, aHeBHOrO npe6blBaHHq ReTef B wKOJIe, KpeAHTOB,

cy6cHAHpoBaHHe TpaHCnopTa H MHOroro Apyroro 31n5 )KHTeiiek 3THX OTgajleHHbIX iieCHbIX

pa4oHoB. 3a nocAieRHHe aBa roAa 3TH Cjiy)K6bi 6bUIH nepeAaHbl MeCTHbiM aaMHHHCTpauHIM,

KOTOpbIe CMOrJiH o6eCHe'IHTb TOJIbKO CaMbiH MHHHMaJIbHbIfl ypOBeHb OCHOBHbIX ycnyr.

CouMaJlbHble CJiy)K6bI CTaihH OgHOfl H3 CaMbIX Cepbe3HbIX "xepTB" 3KOHOMHqeCKOrO

ripeO6pa3OBaHHS B POCCHH.16 iI.nsi o6nerqeHHs cylueCTByioi3ero noJ1o)KeHtiq npaBHTenJbCTBO

MO)KeT MCnOJ1b3OBaTb oripeAeJIeHHbie HHCTpyMeHTbi nOJIHTHKH, HO COuHaHBbHaq cdiepa

TBJI,eTCTq o6weHauHOHaJibHorl npO6JieMog, KOTOpO Hejib3S1 pa3peKHTb C rIOMOIIblO

OT31eCJbHbIX pe(jOpM B KaKOM-TO O3HOM CeKiope. aojroCpOt1HOR UeflbIO OJ1DKHO CTaTb

BBeaeH4e TaKOH IOJIHTUKU, KOTopaR5 npHBeaeT K ynyqweHHIO HHBeCT1IUHOHHOrO KJ1HMaTa H

6yaeT cnoco6CTBOBaTb paUHOHaSbHOMY ynpaBjieHHIo JiecaMH, TeM CaMbIM, nOBbilaIR ypOBeHb

)KH3HM HaceiieHHA .YeCHbIX par4OHOB.

nOJIHTHKa, Jie)KamU,aq B OCHOBe nepeaaMH OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH 3a CoLLHanbHy1O cdiepy

C ypOBHA npeaHpnSHTHA Ha YPOBeHb MeCTHbiX aaMHHKCTpaLHMi, ao CHX nop nOJIHOCTbIO He

pa3pa6OTaHa, elue eCTb HeonpeIeJIeHHOCTb B pacnpeaeneeHH o6R3aHHOCTei no pa3HbIM

YPOBHRM ynpaBJIeHHi5. B HacTosAuee BpeMq 3Ta npo6neMa OCJO)KHqeTCH coKpa1ueHHeM

HaJIOrOBOr4 6a3bI B11 Bcex YPOBHeH ynpaBJeHHsI. npeanpH,sTu, KOTOpbIe Bce Ace

npo1oJInKaIOT pa6oTaTb, 14unu He 0on1iaq'4BaIoT CBOHM pa6OTHHKaM, Hnu Booo6Le He

BbInJia-MHBaIOT 3apniHaTbl. MHOrme npeanrpHAT14, Ha KOTOpbIX npOM3BORCTBO OCTaHOBJIeHO,

,aejiaoT Bce, atn TOro qTo6bI pa6OTHHKH MoriH noJyT4aTb COLtHaMJbHb1e Bb[nUiaTbl, KOTOpble

ewue npeaOCTaBJI5lOTC51 B aaHHOM parHOHe.

HH ceromaH, HH B o603pHMoM 6yayweM B POCCMu He MO)KeT 6blTb 4)HHaHCOBbIX

BO3MO)KHOCTer4 An1 peanj13auMH KOMnieKCHOii nporpaMMbI couo6ecneqeHM4l

16 MHlorHe npo6BeMM COliMAbHO ccbpbi, CBq3aHHble C npoLUCCCOM nepeCTpO.4KIf, B OCHODHOS OAUHaKOBH

BO BCCX OTpaCAJIX. fioaee i7oApo6Hoe paCCMOTrpeHe 3TUX BOnPOCOB !pHMCHfTCJTbHO K yrOAbHOR

HpoMib7ureHHocTif, a maKxe npo6AeM wepaAbHbiX g5OHaOB H cu,yw6 3BHRTOCT B LUaoM CM. B: World Bank,

1994.

Page 127: Russian - World Bank Documents

109

(pHHaHCHpyeMoul rocyaapcTBOM. EaI1HCTBeHHoe, 'TO MOKHO peajibHO OcyLUeCTBHTb, TaK 3TOco3,aaHHe 3nemeHTapHou ceTH COU3aWHXTbl JQ nioaer, MaTepHanibHoe noJIowKeHie KOTOpbIX BCBA34 C pe4lopmamH pe3KO yXyaWIuJIOCb. HeKoTopbie COU14aJbHbie ycjiyru 6yayTnpe,aOCTaBj15TbC.q q4opMHpyioui4mcA5 'aCTHbIM ceKTopoM. Ha HeKOTOpbIX npeanpHS4TSAXnocne ynpa3,aHeHHr couHaBJbHbIX cAy)K6 npOH3BOL4CTBeHHbie roKa3aTeJI4 pa6oTH14KOBHaCTOJibKO yXylIlWHJIHCb, 'TO HpeanpHATHm 6bum BblHy)KgeHbl BOCCTaHOBUTb CAyx6b[o6ecneKm.aIoiue pa6oTHHKoB pa3IH'IHbIMH ycjiyramH COUHaHibHoro xapaKTepa, gAnS Toro4To6bi nOBbICHTb npOH3BOal4TenbHOCTb Tpyaa. OaHaKO, nOCKOnbKy cpeacTi3a Hatipe,aOCTaBJieHRe 3THX yCJIyr I pHWJIOCb 3aHMCTBOBaTb HarPAlMYIO 143 4)IHaHCOBbIX 4)OHaOB,flpegHa3HaqeHHbIX Ha OCyIIeCTBJIeHUe HPO43BOaCTBeHHOU lReATeCAbHOCTH, TO pC3yJlbTaTOMcTano coKpalueHHe o6'beMOB Bb1nyCKaeMOri npOAyKU414.

* IAA MHOrUX 13 1,5-2 MHJIJIUOHOB moaefi, )KiBBywUX B Hai66oniee nocTpaRaaBIxOT,aanjeHHbIX CeBepHbIX ieCO3arOTOBH4TejibHbIX paiiOHax, oAIroCpoCHble nepCneKTHBbi BOTHOwIeHHH BO3MO)KHoro yly4LLIeHH4 cer4qac MajioyTeWHHTeJbHbli. YBCejit4'HBaeTCA MHrpautiq113 3THX paUOHOB, H no Cy11eCTBYIOIUHM OueHKaM, 6o0iee 30% HacejieHHM CeBepHbIX par4OHOB,L aabHero BocTOKa B KOHUe KOHLOB MHrpHpyeT B 6o0iee Io)KHbie paiOHbl. KaK MeCTHbIeopraHbl ynpaBJIeHHA 6yayT pearipoBaTb Ha 3Ty MHFrpaulio H ao6pOBOIbHoe nepeceAeH4e,HporHO3HpoBaTb TpYAHO. 3Ta npo6.neMa 3aTparHBaeT He TOJIbKO caMHx MHIpaHTOB, HO H Tex,KTO pewivi oCTaeTCq, a TaK)Ke HaceIieHHe, npo)KHBaioiuee B paHOHax, KyAa yCTpeMH4JICbOCHOBHbie HOTOKH MHrpaHTOB.

C40o,Mamie )I8pMpaMM 3a8HffTOCTH41 HaceeHH, HOTMpHBRIffelO pa6oTy B CBRU3M C Pe(0OpMaBMf

CHcTeMbI pbIHO'HO1U 3KOHOMHKU o6blIHO npeaycmaTpiBal0T OKa3aHHe pa3Horopo,aa nOMOWH B o6ecnetieHHH 3aHATOCTH HaceJieHHA Ha TeppHTOpHU par4OHOB, B KOTOPbIXOCyLUeCTBji5eTCA peopraHu3auKA npOMblwjieHHOCTH. TaKaA nOMOLUb MO)KeT OCyLUeCTBJTHTbCIKaK d)eaepaAbHbIM rpaBHTeJbCTBOM -- 'Iepe3 cneuHaniJ43HPOBaHHbie y"peaeHmsI,3aHHMIaouHeCSl TpyrOyCTPOPiCTBOM H nOarOTOBKOR KaapOB, TaK H qepe3 perj4OHaHbHbie HnmMeCTHbie OpraHbI BJIaCTH. TaKue nporpaMMbl o6blqHO 4 uHaHC4pYIOTCq 3a CqeT o6WuxHaJIOrOBbIX nOCTyHAeH4iI. B POCCHH eCTb aBa BO3MO)KHblX BapHaHTa peweHI4r npo6.neM6e3pa6OT4UbI, Bbl3BaHHOU peOpraHU3auUeU: 3TO nPOrpaMMbi nepenPo)OHJpOBaHH41 1UnpOrpaMMb1 o6wueCTBeHHbIX pa6oT. CHCTeMbI o61ueCTBeHHbIX pa6OT, ReACTByOLllU4e KaKnpaBHJIO Ha HpHHuHnax caMoynpaBJIeHHs, rpeaCTaBAI5oT 39JeKTHBHOe KpaTKOCpO4HOepewieHHe ripo6.ieM BpeMeHHO Hepa6OTaIOLuHx rpynn HaceCIeHHA. nporpaMMbineperipo4H.nHpoBaHHs4 pewialoT npo6.neMbl CpeaHeCpOqHOil H UaoJirocpoqHori 6e3pa6OTHLbl,,LaBas BO3MO)KHOCTb HOJIyqHTb HOBbJe HaBbIKH H 3HaHHA, HeO6xOtlHMbie ARA pa6OTbI rioHOBbIM cneUHaabHOCTHM, HanpHMep, nSA nIecHoro ceKTopa 3TO MO)KeT 6blTb pa6oTa Bo6.nacTI4 nnaHHPOBaHHA HCnOJIb3OBaHHlZ 3eMeAb, OXpaHbI oKpy)KalooueH Cpeab1, CoxpaHeH4516Hopa3Hoo6pa3H4I H paLRoHaHJbHoro nlecoynpaBneHu4.

tiMeloaericsI HHd1OpMaLuLH O nepcneKTHBax TpyaOyCTpOCTBa B paHOHax, rileFIpOH30WJIO CHJIbHoe coKpaLueHie pa6oqlx MeCT B IieCHOM ceKTope, HeaOCTaToq-HO AJ51 Toro,qTo6bl aaTb peKOMeHaauLH 0 Heo6XoattMoM MacLuTa6e rOCyaapCTBeHHOr4 1OMOLUN. HYKHOco6paTb HHqOpMaUH4o O pa3Hoo6pa3Hblx B03MO)KHOCTHX 3aHATOCTH B 3TUX H COCeaHHXpal4OHaX, o reorpa43HqeCKoM noJIo)KeHlHH H TpaHCnOpTHb1X CBA3SX, B03MO)KHOCTSX LA5IHOBbIX BHaOB aeMTeJlbHOCTH H pbIHKaX )KHJIbq. 9Ta 4HH4opMaaUlHA KpUTTHqeCKH Ba)KHa ZWISpa3pa6OTKU CTpaTerHn pa3BHTHAI H nporpaMM 3aHSTOCTH ARA molerl, nOTepqBWH4X pa6oTy.

Page 128: Russian - World Bank Documents

11o

HYIcHO TaloKe pa3peWLUTb BOnpOCbI, CBq3aHHbie C pacpeRjeneHHeM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH 3a

paCXO,abl Ha 4)HHaHCHpOBaHHe 3TUX 1IpOrpaMM Mexay pa3HblMH YPOBH1Mt4 roCyaapCTBeHHOrO

ynpaBAeHRs, 1 co03aHHeM aaeKBaTHO1 RaOXOIHOA 6a3bl Xus F1OKpbITH 3T1UX paCXOQOB.

HaH6onee 34jeKTHBHOri nOJIHTHKOu noMOuLH HacenIeH1l4O qBJIHeTCq nojiHT4Ka,

cnoco6CTBy1Owa5I aOJU7OCPOMHOMY POCTY U 3KOHOMHUeCKOMy pa3BHTHIO. noAnKTKa

3KOHOMH,ecKoro pa3BHTHR AOJDKHa 6blTb HanpaBJeHa Ha CTpOHTenJbCTBO MeCTHbIX

npe,anpH.qTHI, 'ITO aOJDKHO o6ecneqHTb YCJOBHqX AAS co311aHH14 HOBbIX pa6o'qHx MeCT U BH,4OB

I1eSATeAbHOCTH, KOTOpbIe MOryT 6blTb oco6eHHo Heo6xoaHMbI Anfl peanu3aRuu HaUULOHanJbHbIX

H perHOHaJbHbIX cTpaTerHfi pa3BHTHS. nepCneKTHBbl 3aHSITOCTH, KOTOpbIe nOSIBHJIHCb 6bl C

pOCTOM iieCHOM ripOMbmllbJIeHHOCTH H pa3BHTHeM pbIHKOB HeapeBeCHbiX JICcHbIX npoayKTOB,

MorIiH 6bl oKa3aTb MOUtHoe nO3HTHBHoe BO3,aeACTBe Ha 3KOHOMM4ecKoe pa3BUTTe,

oCo6eHHO B CH6HPH H Ha )JaibHeM BocToKe, rme Bbi6op 6o0iee orpaH4qeH, 'eM B

EBponercKor '-1aCTH CTpaHbl. 14 qTO camoe riiaBHoe, TaKoe pa3BHTHe yMeHblUHT

3aBmCHMOCTb oT)ajieHHbIX JIeCHbIX paIOHOB OT CHCTeMbi COULHJabHbIX cJIyIK6.

Y,gOBzeTBpcHHe norpe6HoClcII B COgImallTHOM o6eCCevCHHH KOpaHHOr HaCeJICHNI

KopeHHoe HaceneHHe H ApyrHe MeCTHb1e )KHTeIiH ceBepHbIX IieCHbIX pagOHOB

ceroxHs5 OTHOCATCS K HaH6oJIee yq3BHMbiM rpynnaM HaceineHHq POCC1H. MHorme

npe,4CTaBHTeJUH 3THX rpynn XOTIT BeCTH cBog TpaLLUUHOHHblr o6pa3 )KH3HH H He rOTOBbl K

nepeMeHaM. MaccoBas MHrpau.A npHBOAHT K ocJia6fleHHIo TpaHCHOPTHbIX CBq3eh C

BHeWIIHHM MHpOM, orpaHHqeHHIO aocTyna K TOBapaM H pblHKaM, noTepe pa6oqHx MeCT, a

TaicKe coKpaLueHHIO 'MHcj!a yqHTeAerk, MeaHUHHCKoro nepcoHajia H apyrHX pa6OTHHKOB

rocy1apCTBeHHbIX cJIyx6. EOJ1bWHHCTBO pa60Tocnoco6HblX MY)KqHH H )KeHIUHH B o6IUHHax

KopeHHbIX )KHTeieg noJyqaloT oqeHb HH3KY1O 3apnIiaTy. Bo MHOrHX CeMbqX OCHOBHbIMH

KOPMHJ1bUiMa wBiIOTCSi neHCMOHepbl.

A,MIS OCHOBHOUi MaCCbl PYCCKO.3blqHorO HaceJieHM.9, 3aHqTOCTb H CpeRCTBa K

CyWeCTBOBaHH1O KOTOpOrO 3aBHC5IT OT .JecHbIX peCypCOB, nepeMeHbl, npOHCXO511Wue B

J1eCHOM ceKTope, nocTaBHJUI noa yrpo3y 6.narococTo0sHHe HX ceMefl, He npeAOCTaCBHB UM

HHKaKHX )KH3Hecnoco6Hbix aJibTepHaTHB. Co BpeMeHeM I43MeHeHMS4, ocyUkeCTBJlqeMbie B xo,ae

npoBeIeHHS pbIHO4HbIX pe4OpM, CHHMYT OCTpOTy npo6neMbl 6e3pa6oTlr4bl, HO ao TOrO, KaK

3TO npOH304aeT, CouHaMJbHbIe H3lep)KKH 6yRyT HenpHeMJ1eMO BbICOKHMH. PbIHKH Tpyaa,

)KHJIbH H UMHaHCOB nOKa pa3BMTbl HeaoCTaTOqHO, 'ITO OrpaHI4qUBaeT MO6UJlbHOCTb TpyaOBbIX

pecypcoB HAM AOCTyn K cpeaHe- H IOjIroCpOqHbIM KpeaHTaM iLSi noJIy4eHHA cpeACTB Ha

nepemewLeHHe npe,anpHA1THA H CTapTOBOrO KanHTania ARA HOBbIX BHAOB aeATeA1bHOCTH.

Page 129: Russian - World Bank Documents

MI. Hecoiropue lpeAoeIJOCHHm no0 1poBe1eHHIO pe4Kopmbi iCeCHoro ceicrropa

Ho mepe nepexoaa K pbIHOYHOH 3KOHOMHKe, POCCHN Heo6XOLHMO H3MCHH4TbrOJIUHTHKY pa3BHTNS JieCHOrO ceKTOpa. 1I3MeHeHHe 3TOU nOAHITHKH HeO6XOaHMO AiscoxpaHeHHA peCypCHOu 6a3bI oTpacJiH H o6ecneieHHs yCJIOBHH, npH KOTOPbIX HaceJIeHHeTneCHbIX paUOHOB cMornjo 6bl BHOCHTb MaKCHMa)bHO B03MOXKHbIA BKfla, B 3KOHOMH'4eCKoePa3BHTHe o6weCTBa. XOTA nPOBOAtMbie ceuNac 3KOHoM4-eCKHe pe4fopMbl TaKwe OKa3ajiHcy1ueCTBeHHoe BA1S4HHe H Ha JIeCHoH ceKTOp, B OCHOBe ero npo6JieM JTeKaT nocAe,aCTBsA3KOHOMHUeCKORi H 3KOOFrHqeCKOUi 6eCXO3lIUCTBeHHOCTH, yHaCJTeaOBaHHbie OTueHTPanIH3OBaHHOrO nriaHHpoBaHHl, KOTopOe CTpeMHjiOCb nepeBeCTH npHpOaHbIir KanHTaniceKTopa B pa3BHTHe npoMbiLwUeHHOCTH 6e3 y,4eTa Heo6xoaHMocTH coxpaHeHiHH ycJoBHi nnflBOCInpOH3BOLaCTBa AeCHbIX HuH rlppOHaHbIX peCypCOB. OaHHM H3 pe3yIbTaTOB TaKOro noaxo,aCTaJia CTpyKTypa rpOMbliuIJJeHHOCTH, B KOpHe He COBnagaiouas c pacnpeaejieHHeM pecypCOB,H 3KOHOMH4eCKH He3qfeKTHBHoe HCROnb3OBaHHe apeBecHoro CbipbI yCTapeBBIHMH HHeKoHKypeHTocnoco6HbIMH npeanpHSTHqMH. 9Ta CHTyau[H ejue 6onbbwe o6ocTpHJIacb u3-3a| ed)HUHTa (bHHaHCHpOBaHH4 HaH6ojiee Ba)KHbiX MepOnpHITHA pecypcoynpaBJTeHHI4.

B npeabLigyiaeH rnaBe pacCMoTpeHa KOHUenLUHA CTPYKTYPbl pe4OpMbl neCHoroceKTopa POCCHH. HpoUecc pa3pa6oTKH 3TOU CTpyKTypbl Y)Ke Ha4aJCq, O 'eM rOBOPHTBBe4eHHe HOBOrO AeCHOrO 3aKOHoaaTeJIbCTBa (JleCHOe 3aKOHOaaTeJIbCTBO 1993 roaa H npoeKTJTeCHoro KoieKca 1996 roga) H npOBeaeHie 4aCTH14HOr 4PsHBaTH3aUH H peopraH3aIUHH B*AneCOnpOMbIwneHHbIX oTpacJIlx. B aJIbHeru4eM pefopma aoJnCHa npHsBJIe'b 6o0nee wHpOKHUKpyr 3aHHTepeCOBaHHbIX CTOpOH H HCnOJIb3OBaTb HOBbie HCTO4HHKH BHeWlHeu 4UHHaHCOBOAH TeXHHqeCKO4 rOMOmmuH. B 3TOHI rIiaBe HpeRCTaBIeHbi KAio0CBbie peKOMeHaaU14H H1p1HOPHTeTbl pedOpMbi B c43epe ynpaBnieHAs ieCHbIM ceKTopoM H opHeHTaUHHrocy,aapCTBeHHbIX paCXOaOB, KOTOpbIe BbITeKalOT H3 3TOfA KOHUenTyaJ1bHOii cxeMbi. 1 7

A. HHTerpanH: JieCHOro ceKTopa B CHCTemY 3K0HOmHMecKHx ped)opM

nI1OHTHKa B cdjepe ynpawieHHq JieCHb1MH pecypcami 1AOJDKHa COOTBeTCTBOBaTbo6ftHM 3KOJorH4qeCKHM, 3KOHOMH4ecKHM H couHanbHbIM 4eMJIM rocyaapcTBeHHoroynpaBHeHHH H npoLtecca 9KOHOMHMecKHx pe4JopM. nO3TOMY, cneAyeT H36eraTb TaKHXKOCBeHHbIX npOTeKUHOHHCTCKHX Mep, KaK TOprOBbIe 6apbepbl H Cy6CHIIHpOBaHHe LeH.rocy,LapCTBO aOJDXHO IOJIHOCTbIO yCTpaHHTbC5 OT KoMMCpMeCKOfl aeqHTeJbHOCTH B JleCHOMceKTope, flO3BOJISI PbIHO4HbIM CHJiaM CaMHM 34feKTHBHO pacnpeaeJlRTb peCypCbl. OAHaKOAmJ cMArIeHH4l riocJieRCTBsH4 nepecTpor4KH B HeKOTOpbIX OTaaBeHHbiX paiOHax Tpe6yeTCqpAa BpeMeHHb[X Mep, THna rlepeo6yqeHHU riepcOHafIa, qTo6bI InOMO'b JIIO5IM HaHTH HOBYKOpa6oTy. KJioMeBbie peKOMeHLaauH HO BKJlo t eHHIo uiecHoro ceKTopa B CUCTeMy3KOHOMHMeCKHX pe&jOpM KpaTKO H3JIO)KeHbl B Ta6uIUe 3.1.

17 CorMaacHo cTpaHoBof crpaTerrH BceMHpHoro 6aHKa. 17pHOpIpTeTHol? oTpacamio oga Poccifif RBn7.JeTcRceJ7bcKoe Xo3RIICTBo, a npeenaraeMbie peKoMmH,aaml110 no 7ecHoMy CeKTOpy COOTBeTCTBylOT 9To/ cTpaTerCff (WorldBank 1995b). B pawKax Te7ywuero izfanora BceCMPHOFO 6aHKa C flpdB1fT7]bCTB0M POCCH 110 1n0801Bo'y CTpaHBoI90cTpaTerrf/f OJM Pocc#H o6cyxaaIoTcH pom01f cCmmcKoro Xo3wiCTBa H 7ecHoro ceKTopa wZ 3KOHoMW1eCKropB3BT1frT CTpaHbl.

Page 130: Russian - World Bank Documents

112

Ha 4eaepaJIbHOM YPOBHe ypKe npOH30IJIna JiH6epafH3aiJHJ nOqT4 Bcex

BHytpeHHHX L1eH H MexayHapOAHOA ToproBJIH. B 1992 roay 6bmIuH OcBo6o0)aeHbI LeHbI

nOMTH Ha Bce TOBapbI, OAHOBpeMeHHo 6bmui cyLUeCTBeHHO COKpaLUeHbl Bce cy6ctwum.

OXIHaKO HeKOTOpbIe H3 HbIHe npH4BaTT3HPOBaHHbIX npernpHJqTH9 Tpe6yIoT YBseumeHHiq HuHu

BO3o6HOBJieHH4l cy6ciiaHu Ha 3HeprHiO H TpaHCnOpT. Y npaBHTenJbCTBa XBaTaeT MyapOCTH,

YCTO,qTb lpOTHB 3THX Tpe6oBaHH4A, OAHaKO Heo6XoaHMo HCKaTb aaJlbHefwlUHe noA1HTH4eCKHe

Mepbl, KOTOpbie 3aCTaBHJUI 6bl pYKOBOALHTeAeH npe1anpHATKA OCTaBaTbCqI B )KeCTKHX pamKax

pbIHO'4HbIX ueH. PoCCHH npHCTynUi4a K OCyluleCTBJleHHIO O,lHOU H3 CaMbIX

KpynHoMacuiTa6HbIX B UCTOpUH npOrpaMM Hl4pBaTI43aLUH 3eMJIH, iMyLWeCTBa H

npe,a,npHATKA.

Ta6nuHla 3.1: HHTerpaH w i necioro ceKTopa B npouecc 3KoHoMHqecKHx pe4)opM

f7po6.aema CoBpeMeHHoe cocronHHe flpuAalaemme Lewm flpeaffamemIe c7pa7rrw

HPeo6p&30BaHSR_

JIH6epaJII3auHsi npH6AHxKeHHe K MHpOBbIM BKjnlo'eHHe B npoLtecc * nlpOBOrHTb aaJbHeruiy1o

OCHOBHbIX ueH (B ueHaM npHBenO K flpHHRTHR peuweHHAi aaHHbX JuI6epanw3aulmo ueH Ha MaTepuanJbHbie

MaCTHOCTH, Ha 3HaMHTenjbHOMY o peajnbHO CTOHMOCTH cocTajsilIoulHe npOH3BOACTBa H

3HeprlIO H COKpaUeHLHIO BbIfYCKa 3HeprOHOCHTeneg u Hx o6ecneqtiTb co6juoneHue PbIHO0HOH

TpaHCnopT) npO1YKUH U cHUHKeH UHio 344eKTHBHOCTH; AuHCuRUnnUHbI

YPOBH.9 3aHFTOCTH nOBbIUweHHe * npOBOaHTb aanjbHeruwyio

3XeKTHBHOCTH JnH6epaII3auLHio ueH Ha jiecHyio

npoMblljieHHOrO npoalyumuo

HCIOJlb3OBaHHA ileCHbbX * YCTpaHHTb MCeKperCOHaSJbHbie 6apbepbi

peCYPCOB B Toprobjie

PeHTHble aOXo0bi OHCJmcneHHA Ha B3HMaHHe c nonb3oBaTenerl * BBoaHTb PbIHOqHble MexaHH3Mbl

OT niecHbix BoCnpoH3BOACTBO PeCYPCOB 3HaHTCnibHoA 'acTH (ayKuMoHbl, ToprH) axM yBeJH9meHHB

peCypCOB H COUHaJIbHble HY)KUbl CTOUMOCTU 3arOToW1eHHOi peHTHbIX aOXOAOB.

COCTaBJiioT JimUb maJyio apeBecHHbi, HTo6bi * BKJIoIaTb B aOrOBOpa C HHOCTpaHHbiMH

JaOJIIO CTOHMOCTH o6ecnemCHTb H CoBMeCTHbIMH npeanpMHTHHMH

3aroToBjieHHb]x BocnpOH3BOaCTBO pecypca H YCJ1oBHU o noBbiWICHHoK peHTHOAi nniaTe

npoMbIUwieHHbIX cnpaBeCanBblbi aOXO.a JI 3a pecypCbl

.TecoMaTepHafOB, 9TO jiecomnawenbueB 06ecne4UnTbaonKHoe

IlpHBO,HT K IIepepy6aM (pyHKUHoHHpOBaH4e MCXaHH3MOB

necoceK, a TaKlKe K pCHTHbIX nJlaTe)Ke11 H co6juoIeHHe

neperpy3Kam u niAoxoMy 3aKOHOB 0 HajiOraX ans1 noBblweH"n

pa3MeLLIeHH1o HajiOrOBbIX AOXOAOB

npOH3BO11CTBeHHbIXMOIUHOCTeH

AHTHMoHonojib- Pe4opMa MaJIo noBjinUTsa 901IeKTHBHoe H * Pac(FopMKpoBaTb MOHiiOnoJIH, BKJUo4a$

Hbie Mepbl H Ha CTPYKTYPY c6aJiaHCHpoBaHHoe aKuHoHCpHbie o6uieCTBa (xonUHHrH)

npHBaTH3aUH.S npOH3BOCTBa pecypconOJIb3OBaHHe Co * Boniee 3(FKpeKTH4BHo npHmeHMhTb

nepeBonepepa6aTblBalo- CTOPOHbI aHTHMOHonoJIbHble Tpe60BaHHq H

lueri OTpacJH, B 3TOU KOHKypCHTOCnIOCO6HbIX I1pHBaTH3aUHOHHbte Mepbl AM

oTpacniu no-npeKHeMy npeanpHsTHA noBblweHH.9 KoHKyPCHTOCnoco6HOCTH

£aOMHHHPYIOT JieCHoH npOMbIWUJeHHOCTH

HH3Kog4xbeKTHBHble, * OcJla6HTb orpaHHqeHHSi no co3JaHHIo

B3aHMOCBR3aHHbie H COBMeCTHbiX npeQnPHSTHA H

XOJIHHrOBbIe KOMnaHHH HCnOJIb3OBaHHIO HHOCTpaHHbIX

MOHOnOJlbHOrO THna UHiBeCTHULiH* nOBbICHTb 3*4eKTHBHOCTb

HCnOJIb3OBaHHI apeBeCHHbl H ApYrHX

pecypcoB B nepepa6aTblBalouePi oTpacjiH

* npOBOHmTb KOHKYPCbi no npHo6pe-

TeHHIO npaB noJIb3OBaHisF JiecoM

(Hpo,aoniKeHHe Ta6AHUbbl Ha cjTeRytoWeru cTpaHHuLe)

Page 131: Russian - World Bank Documents

113

Ta6rnu4a 3.1: HHTerpausH niecHoro ceicropa B npoItecc 3KOHOMHMeCKHX pefropM(npo.A,ojnKeHHe)

lpoiI7eMa CoBpeMeHHoe COcTOsHUCe J7peanae e mmeaep 17cpaanewme c7pamrwJf______________ HpCo6pa3oRaHitH _____________________17______H__BIOXCCTHaR CoKpawueHHe 6ioaKeToB Bbino.nHeHHe 3anaa no * BcecTopoHHe H3yq'iTb npoueccCTeCHeHHOCTh OTPHUaTeJTbHO CKa3aBjOCb oxpaHe npHpOab1 H 3aLUIHTe ropMHpOBBaHH5 H nononHeHHRopraHOB Ha ynpaBBjeHHH oTpacAbio, niecoB * 6ioaxeTa C ueCJbIO yBeCuHqeHHqynpaBneHH. oxpaHe H 3aLui4Te nTecoB; peHTHblX noCTYnlJeHuH; U_ieCHbIM HH3KHe peHTHb1e

MaKCHMH3aUmt 34i eKTHBHOCTH ARMX03SUqCTBOM nOCTyriCeHHq OT pewleNHS 3aAaq oxpaHbi lIPHPOabl UneconoJnb3oBaHHsq 3alUHTbl niecoB

* YBeCJHlUTb 6ioJxeT C TCM, 'To6blo6ecrieHTb YCTOAIHBOCTb neCHOrOxo3149icTBa, yqacTHe 'acTHoro ceKTopa H3atuHTY niecoB3aaaqm MHoro'iHCJleHHbie 06ecneqeHie HaceiTeHHsi, * 06ecrieHTb uenieByio nOMOLubcouHanbHoro COuHaJIbHbie rpyrinbl B nonAepraIowueroCs TaKOMY HyuaiLOLuHMcs CJIORM HacenieHHu,o6eCneFteHHS 3T14X paiOHax CTORT nOa pHCKy, M1HHHMabHOu ceTbIo HCHOJIb3yS1 MeCTHble CTPYKTYpbI BMaCTHoTraanjeHHbIX yrpo3oH 6e3pa6OTiUbl H cou3aLuHTbl; aoJirocpoqHaq 2)11 uenieBoro HanpaBBjeHHR pecypcoBniecHbix paBioHoB cnaaa HpOH3BOJICTBa B KOppCKTIHPOBKa CHTYaUHH * Ocjla6Tb Mi4rpaUHOHHb1e OrpaHwHietmnjecHbix oTpacJsiX Ha PbIHKaX TpyAa; pa3BHTme * ,aTb TO4Hoe onpezeneHue npaB Ha

PbIHKOB HeapeBecHbIx 3eMnUio, 'To6bi nOBbICHTb ypoBeHbnpOA4yKTOB; riozAep)KKa )KI43HN KopCHHOrO Hacen1eHHu 3a CWeTKopeHHOrO HaceCJeHHs H BbirOJI HCnOJb3OBaHHS KOpeHHbIMHTpa,IIUHOHHbIX YKJaaJOB KTfejISMH CBOHX 3eMe.nb)KH3HK * nepeCTpoHTb CHCTeMy noco6Hti no

6e3pa6oTHue, H3MCHHB Pa3Mepblnoco6Hu H CPOKH HX AeriCTBH1

* Pa3pa6oTaTb CHCTeMbi CJIy)K6bl3aHSTOCTH B COOTBeTCTBuH C MeCTHbIMHHy3KaaMH

* OpraHH3oBaTb Heo6XOUHMbie KYPCblnepenO2rOTOBKH u nporpaMMblo6yqeHHus

* BBOZHTb cXeMbI KpeaHTOBaHHf Hpa3BHTHR TpaLIHUHOHHbIX BHJAOBJiSeTeAbHOCTH H pemeceJi Ha MeCTHOM

I YPOBHe

Fopa3xao 6o0nee cyLaeCTBeHHaS aOJIA CTOHMOCTH JIeCHbIX peCypCoB,3Kcr.yaTKpyeMblX Ha KOMMepxeCKOH OCHOBe, aoiAcHa HanpaEBIATbCA Ha npOrpaMMbIrocy,apCTBeHHbIX paCXOQOB. bJHxcauHe iepCreKTHBbl CylIeCTBeHHOFO yBeH'meHHlpeHTHbx' IOCTyHfIeHH orpaHHqeHbl OT4aCTH H3-3a TOrO, '4TO peHTa 3a pecypc B3HMaeTCSI BOCHOBHOM KaK Harior C npearnpHMTHA, a He KaK noneHHas nfiaTa, 3aBHCAluaq OT KaBeCTBa HKOJHMecTBa pecypca. Ho mepe o3flopoBneHHH 3KOHOMUKH npaBHTenJbCTBY cAeqyeT 60oneecMejio 3KcepHmeHTHpOBaTb C pa3HbIMH HHCTpyMeHTaMH roAytiyeHHA peHTHbIX OXOaOB,BKJloa4q 6o0iee o6ocHoBaHHbie uiBaTe)KH 3a HCnOJIb3OBaHHe peCYPCOB Ha OCHOBe pacqeToBCTOHMOCTH nieca Ha KOpH1o.

HyIKeH 6o0nee rjiy6oKHA alHlaH3 3KOHOMHqeCKOH H HpOH3BOZaCTBeHHOrlAeSTeJAbHOCTH, KOTOpblH noMo)KeT onpeaejiHTb MepbI no C03waHHa o KOHKypeHUHH B,IepeBonepepa6aTbIBa14oueA OTpaCJIH H ocJla6HTb MOHOIOJIHCTHqleCKoe BaT1HHHe HCCKOJIbKHXKpynHbIX KOMnaHHI4 Ha paCripelaeJieHHe 3eMejib, JieCHbie TOprH, nepepa6oTKy H 3KClIOpT.CnleAyeT pa3yKpylHHHTb MOHOHIOJIHH H YCTaHOBHTb KOHTPOJIb 3a co6nioaeHHeMaIHmNAOHO)7O]ibHJx Tpc6oBaHHi. OcJla6JleHHe OrpaHHt4eHHii Ha o6MeH BanjlOTbi anJIHHOCTpaHHbIX KOMnaHHH MOrAO 6bl aOHO11HHTb BHyTpeHHHe aHTHMOHOnOJAbHbie MepbI H

Page 132: Russian - World Bank Documents

114

CnOCO6CTBOBaTb nOBbllUeHHIO 34xeKTHBHOCTI. 9TH Mepbl, KPOMe Toro, nOMOrYT BKJIO'IKTb

pe(opMy iiecHoro ceKTopa B o6uLeM npouecce ocyiueCTBseHH51 3KOHOMI'eCKNX pedopM.

B Hb1He1nHMi4 nepmoa OCTporo 61oaxeTHoro Kpt3Hca BO BCeX oTpacAqlx

3KOHOMUKU pa3MCI4cHme 6,Kaxemi CpeaCTm AOJ)KHO OCyLueCTBAITbCSl C yteTOM

KOHKpeTHbIX 4IHHaHCOBbIX noTpe6HOCTeg Ka)aog OTpacAiu. IpIOpHTeTbi 4M4HaHCHPOBaHHS

,AOA)KHbi 6bITb onpeaeAeHbl KaK Ha Me)K-, TaK H Ha BHyTpHOTpaCJAeBOM ypOBHe, a paCXO.abl

AOnDKHbl pacnpeaeAsiTbcSl nio ueASM ynpaBjieHHS. XOTA neCHOU ceKTOP He aOj)KeH

oCBo6o)KIIaTbCA OT HeO6XOaHMbIX COKpaLUeHi4h 610KeTa, 3TU COKPp1lUeH451 HeAb351

npOBOLIHTb B ywep6 yCTOH1MHBOrO pa3BMTHT14.JecHoro CeKTOpa, )KepTByq npH 3TOM

UeAOCTHOCTblO oKpy)KaaioUier CPeabi H CH)KCeHHeM YPOBH51 )KH3H4 HaceAeHHA OT.aajeHHbiX

IieCHbIX par4OHOB.

YR3BNmwm rpynaIm HaCeIeHK5 OTLaJaeHHbIX paiHOHOB Tpe6yeTCs nOMOIUb B

o6ecne4eHHH OCHOBHbIMH coui4anJbHb1MH ycAyraMH, TaKhMM KaK o6pa3oBaHHe,

3aPaBOOXPaHeHMe H T.A. Pe3Koe yxyauLieHHe COCTOSHU1I COUHaAbHOA C4epbi nOCTaBHAo

MHOrHX nioaeg 3a 'epTy 6eaHocTH. BO3MO)KHO, MTO AAA Toro, 'lTO6bi o6ecneMHTb yCAOBHA,

nPH KOTOpbIX COUMHabHbie nporpaMMbi 6yayT yaoBBjeTBOpSTb noTpe6HOCTM HMeHHO Tex

Aio,aeg, AAS KOTOPbIX OHU npeRHa3Ha4eHbI, OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a HX BblnOAHeHHe

HeO6Xo,LHMo 6yaeT B03JO)KtUTb Ha MeCTHbIe opraHbi BJIaCTH. FporpaMMa 3cXeKTHBHOrO

HcnOJb3OBaHH51 AOLACKKX pecypcoB morna 6bl TaKwe COKpaTHTb Mi4rpaLtHIO H3 CeBepHbIX

paiOHOB B yxKe nepeHaceneHHbie 10)KHbie pariOHbl. J]sI ocy eCTB eHM4. HOBOU nOHO4THKH B

o6naCT H ynpaBAeHMH JAeCHblM ceKTOpOM Tpe6ylOTCs HOBbIe MRAbN ae5TeJAbHOCT4, B 3TOS

CBR31 nepBoOmepeaHoe BHiM4aHMe cAeayeT yaeAlHTb co3AaHHIO HOBbIX pa6oqHx MeCT. 9TH

HOBble pa6o04e MeCTa ocna6srT 3aBHCHMOCTb HaceAeHMlA OT CHCTeMbl couo6ecneqeHHr. B

LAOnroCpOMHOri nepcneKTHBe OKa3aHHe TeXHH1eCKOH nOMOiUU MeCTHb1M

HenpaBHTeAbCTBeHHblM opraHM3auMSiM nOMO)KeT yKpenHTb HHCTHTYULHOHa1bHyio CTpyKTypy,

Heo6xoaRHMyio xiA HeceHMST OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH 3a npeaocTaBneHHe MHort4x U3 3TUX ycnyr.

06ecneqeHHe HaceneHH5 HeO6XoaHMbIMM COUHa1bHbIMM ycAyraMH aOnA)KHO BKAlO4oaTb MepbI

no yKpenAeHHIO TpaaNHLoHHbIX 3KOHOMHMeCKMX YKAa.OB ryTeM nOBblwueHHS HX

3j4eKTHBHOCTH U peHTa6eAbHOCTM.

Fi. HepeXOLI K c6anaHCHpoBaHHOMY ynpaBnieHHIO ieCaMH

Thsi nOBbIleHM51 3jXeKTHBHOCTH ynpaBneHHM necaMH Tpe6yeTcS npMHSHTb LLeJblb

pgia Mep. MO)KHO tCllOJb3OBaTb MHoro'MCIAeHHbie MOaeAiM CO6CTBeHHOCTH Ha 3eMJI1O,

IOPC4AHKUHH, uo6ULeCTBeHHoro yqaCTH51 1 OTpacAeBOH noANTMKu, KOTOpb1e y)Ke eCTb B apyrix

cTpaHax c 6onbWuMli 3anacaMH nieCHbIX pecypcoB. Ans Toro, 'To6bi yCTOIPIMBoe pa3BMTMe

AeCHOrO ceKTopa CTanO peajlbHOCTbIO, Tpe6yeTCs noaAaaolueecs KOHTPOJIO, 4eTKOe H4

nOH51THOe ynpaBsieHHe roCyaapCTBeHHbIMH 3eMJARMH, a TaKwKe CTpyKTypa nOAHTMKH,

Y'4MTbIBaiOiua5i HMeioLuHecA aed)HUHTbl. Heo6xoatMo nepeCMOTpeTb MeTOabl

HHBeHTapM3aUMMH AeCOB HU npoueaypbl perMcTpaUHH 3eMenb B KOHTeKCTe nAaHHPOBaHUR

HcnoAb3OBaHHA 3eMeAb, MHOrOLLeAeBOrO AeconoAb3OBaHMH5 H pa3B4TH51 CBR3aHHbIX C AecoM

oTpacAeri. Am4 nepexoaa K YCTOH{HBOMY pa3BITHIO CeKTOpa Tpe6yeTC5s He TOJbKO CTPOrHi4

KOHTPOAb 3a ocyLueCTBMeHHeM ieCHOHi nojiHTHKH, co6nloneHHeM 3aKOHOB H Tpe6OBaHHr, HO

H peryAqpHblA MOHHTOPMHF KPHTM4eCKMX .JeCHbIX 4HAHKaTOpOB, KaK nOCT-HHaKKaTOpOB, TaK

H npOrHO3HbIX HHAHKaTOPOB (CMrHaJIOB 0 BePO51THb1X npo6neMaX B 6yAyLueM). KJIIo'eBbIe

Page 133: Russian - World Bank Documents

115

peKoMeH1aaLtHH no nepexoiy K paLHOHaHbHOMY ynpaB^eHHIO ieCaMH KpaTKO K3J1O)KeHbl BTa6nImue 3.2.

Ta6AHnLa 3.2: nepexo, K paiWHOHaIbHOMy ynpaBeHHIo JiecaMH

7po6neMa CoBpemeHHoe l7pra/aeMme LeAH flpwaaewMe c7pa7VrnrCOC051HHC nIo6paSORaN/ff _

H3yqeHHC pecypcHoA HeaaeKBaTHaA Co3aaHHe OCHOBbi AMfl * BHe11plTb COBpeMCHHbie MeTOabi6a3bi aHarHOCTHKa CoCToJqHHN PaUHOHaJ]bHOrO ynpaBneHHq HH4IopMaumeu B ueisixJiCcHbIX pecypCoB H Hx ynpaBneHHM pecypcaMH, 3OkeKTHBHo0 OUeHKH pecypcoB HpeanbHoro nOTeHuHanJa npenycmaTpHBaaoweri nAaHHpOBaHtSiARA pa3nHHHbIX BHAOB BbLieCjeHHe CpeACTB Ha * flony'nHTb HaaeKHylo uHq)OpMaaumo nonoJIb3oBaHH%I, BKnloqaq npoBeaeHHe Hx JieCHbIM pecypcaM, KOTOpYpO Mo)KHo 6blAonpoH3BoncTOo WHpoKoMacwTa6Horf 6bl HcnoAb3oBaTb B uenflx nAaHHPOBaHH5,apeBeCHHbl H OueHKH; CHCTeMa Ha pa3HblX YPOBHRXcoxpaHeHHe oueHKH peCypCOB C * npOaHaAu3HpoqaTb 2aHHbIe H6Hopa3Hoo6pa3Hsi, Ha yqaCTmeM Bcex nepeKAaccH(JHumpoBaTb BCCb JIecHoA4ferlepaJbHoM H 3IHHTepecoBaHHb1X q)OHA, HCfO.nOb3yq MeTOabl paUHOHaj1bHoroperHoHanJbHOM YPOBHRlX CTOpOH, Heo6xoaHMaq paCnpefCenfeHHR 3eMeJlb

.A" PaUuoHaHbHOrO * npOBeCTH CKOpCeUJyIO OUeHKyynpaBneH5s1 pecypcamH pecypcHou 6a3bl CyWeCTBYIOULHX

npe,anpHsRTM, 4To6bl BbISlCHHiTbHHBeCTMLIHOHHbie B03MO)KHOCTH H 3aAaqHnepeCTPOHKH CeKTopaI1naHHpoBaHHe CiCTeMa PauHoHaJ)bHaS CHCTeMa * 06ecneqHTb COBMeCTHMOCTb KPHTepHeBHCnOJIb3oBaHHR 3eMeJ1b KJacccubMKauHH AeCOB pacnpeaelleHH%1 3eMeTb, pacrnpeaeAe1HHR 3eMeJb C HHTepecaMH H(j1eneHKe AecoB Ha TpH KOTOpafl cnoco6CTBoBaJa B03MO)KHOCTSIMm rpenaraemoA

rpynnbi no HX 6bl 3aLuHTe CTPYKTrypbl ynpaBJneHHsiHa3Ha4eHHIO: A11 3KoJIorHmeCKHx * BKJlo0HTb B MeToa npOeKTHpoBaHtBF3aWUHTHbIx HAM ueHHoCTei H nAoLuaAceu npoMbiwJeHHoro3KCnAyaTaUHOHHb]X HeMCTOUIHTCJbHOMY AeconOJb3OBaHHq KOHUenUmIoBHAOB nOnb3oBaHHqS) MHOrOUeCjeBOMy AorHmecKoA JICCOCbIpbeBOA 3OHbIcTpanaeT HeAOCTaTKOM nojib3oBaHHio 0 OnpeaejiHTb KJlioteBble nnoiuaaH nnflKOHKPeTHOCTH JAHKBHAaUHH flpO6eJIoB B cyULieCTByioIuer

CHCTCMe OXPaH51eMbIX TeppHTOpHU* BKJIlo4Hmb nptipOaOOXpaHHbie KPHTepHH B

npouecc BbizeAeHHqs AecoB noanpOMbluweHHoe nonb3OBaHHe

* 04HuHajIbHO 3aKpenHTb 3a KopeHHbIMHaceneHUeM BbLaeAeHHbIC £11l Hero 3emnuH o6eCneqtiTb 3alUITY 3THX npaB Ha3emAlo

* 06ecneiHTb yIacTHe MeCTHorO HaceJ1eHuiqB npoUecce nJaHHpoBaHlHS Ha BcexYPOBH5IX

OxpaHa cpeabi OT OAHOri H3 npHtHH npouecc * flepecMoTpeTb H ycoBepwUeHCTBOBaTbHe6J1aronpHlTHbIx nolKapoB H npyrux nfnaHHpoBaHH5, MeTOJbI OBOCBo3aeAcTBHf, BpeAHbIX Bo3meACTBHR BKUmowtaiOWHH B ce6i * fnepecMoTpeTb BeaoMCTBeHHbieCBR3aHHb[X C Ha Aeca qBRRcTTcS Heo6xoaHMbie o6513aHHOcTHi no BBeaeHmiO HaelCTeJTbHoCTbIO apyrux 3KonorHqeCKM ornacHas 3KoJ1orH'ecKHe oueHKH, o6ecae4eHHio co6JloaeHHS Tpe6oBaHHAOTpaCJ1eCi AC.9TenbHOCTb B H BBeaCHHe H no pa6oTaM Ha TeppHTOpH5sX nOKpbITbIX3HepreTHqeCKOri H co6jnOjneHHe neCOM c uen1blO yqeTa aeueHTPaJH3aUHHropHoao6bIBaIOwer Tpe6oBaHu no OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH H B03MO)KHocTeHOTpacAMqX H MHHHMH3aUHHu H(ppaCTPYKType nary6Hblx Bo3ae UCTBUA

Pa3HbIX BHUOB_npo__o___KeHHe__Ha_c__e__o__e__CTpaHfe5lTeJe bHOCTU

(HpoLzoJuIeHHe Ta6JIHUbI Ha cJ1eIyIoLueH cTpaHI4Ue)

Page 134: Russian - World Bank Documents

116

Ta6niuia 3.2: fepexoxA K paUHOHajibHOMY ynpaAneHuIo JIecaMH (npoARonuIeHue)

l7po&eMa COBpeMeHHOe cocToSHne l7pe=alameMble c.ffH f7pelgilameMme cTpaernif

_ __ _ 17pco6pa3oBaH__

93KocHcTeMHoe 3aroToBKa flpeBeCHHbl H Bepe)KHOe HcnOnlb3oBaHHe * flepecMoTpeTb HOPMbI tU Tpe6oBaHH.9 no

ynpaBjleHHe, 3KonlorHieCKOe .fecHbLX 3eMeJlb, OC06eHHO ynpaBJIeHHIo AecaMH, OCHOBaHHbIX Ha

HanpaBneHHoe Ha Bo3aeOCTBme apyrnx 3KCnAyaTauHOHHbIX KOHuenuH5x 3KOCHCTeMHOrO

coxpaHeHme BCCX oTpacJieri ciubHo nniouaaeu, yripaBJ]eHHH H MHorouejieBoro

nojle3HbIx CBOUICTB pa3pyuaioT nieca H o6ecne'HBaiomee BblCOKHU rioJlb3oBaH[Hs, m o6ecnemiTb HX

nieca npenHTcTBYIOT HX ypoBeHb 3alUiTbl co6mioaeHHey.iOBjiCTBOPHTeCJbHOMY 3KoJIorH'eCKHX uCHHOCTe; * BBeaeHie CHCTeMbl peryjilpoBaHm3i H

BocnpOH3BOJ1CTBY 3KoJIorWHeCKH, CTHMYJ1HPOBaH 2IJ.AnH KOHTPOJnH, OUeCHKH

3KOHOMlIeCKK4 H COUHaJIbHO H MOTHBaUm" 3(44(eKTHBHorO

HeHCTOWUHTCeJbHbie MeTOabl BOCn1pOH3BORCTBa

.JecoynpaBJeHHH H

__econojlb3oBaHH9S

BocnpoH3BoAcTBo Bo.nbwHe nnouwa.u BOCCTaHOBHTb * OnpeaenHTb oqepeaHOCTb

JlecoB Bblpy6OK H rapeu oCTaioTc$I npOaYKTH4BHOCTb BOCCTaHoBAeHH j aerpaaiHpOBaHIHbIX

6e3 aOCTaTo9Horo cyluieCTBYIOlIuX notmaaefi, Ha ocHoBaHHH oueHKH

BocnpOH3BOaCTBa; aerpaiHPOBaHHbIX JieCHbIX 3KonorwqecKHX nOCAeaCTBH4 H

cnoco6bl Aeco3aroToBKH He 3eMeJIb AAS BbInOJleHHSI 6yayiluero 3KOHOMHiqeCKoro noTeHuLLana

COOTBeTCTBYIOT UWHPOKOMY 3KOHOMHqCCKHX H * BbiaenHTb rocyaapCTBCHHbie CpeaCTBa Ha

HCnOJIb3OBaHHIO 3KOJIOrWqeCKHX 3a,am; BoccTaHoBAeHHe cyULieCTBYIOLuHX

BO3MOaKHoCTerl cnoco6bl .eco3arOTOBKH jierpaLHpOBaHHbIX 3eMeAb B

ecTecTBeHHoro npHBeCTH B COOTBeTCTBHe C cooTBeTcTBHH C Bbi6paHHbIMH

Bo3o6HobEneHMHf HOPMaTHBHbIMu MeToaaMH npHOPHTeTaMH

BOCnpOH3BOACTBa neca O OrpaHHmHTb H periaMeHTHPOBaTbpa3mep crIouWHbIx py6 OK HKOHTPOAnPOBaTb pa6oTbl no BOCnpoH3-

BOXCTBY peCypCOBa An npCaOTBpaLUeHMHjIaabHerlweH aerpanauHm

* nepecMoTpeTb OCHOBbl BOCnpOH3BOaCT-

Ba AeCOB H pauHOHan]bHoro ynpaBjieHH5

HMH, BKUKo'0B B HHX KoHuenuNH

3KOCHCTCMHOrO ynpasBeHH51

OxpaHa H 3aUHMTa E)KerOaHO OKoJIo 1,6 MAH. noBbliweHHe * Pa3pa6oTaTb KoMnAeKcHble CTpaTerCH

Aeca ra iiecoB noBpecaaeTC51 3XfrKTHBHOCTH H KaICCTBa MOHHTOPUHra COCTOSIHUH AeCOB H yrnp-H

noJKapaMH, HaCeKOMblMH H OXpaHbI H 3aLUHTbl nieca 3a * PacuwlpHTb Me)KayHaPOAHoe COTpyjiHH-

6ojie3H.iMH c4eT HcnoJIb3oBaHH4 'IeCTBO B o6JacTH nepeiiaqui TexHoJIorHUHeo6Xo2HMbIX TeXHoJIor4u, * YBeCJMUiTb nAOlUaab neco3awuHTHblX

MeT,oRoAorHm H MeponpulTHTu, corJiacHo yroqHeHHbIM

(pHHaHCHPOBaHHiR 3KOHOMH4eCKHM, COULaHJbHbIM H

3KonorHqeCKUM KPHTeptHiM

nlepBblM IuaroM Ha nYTH K yCTONHUBOMy pa3BHTH1O JieCHOrO CeKTOpa IBJIqeTCS

yTO-Hmc fe napaMerpoB pecypcHoH 6a3b1, '-To6bI MO)KHO 6buIo onpeaeJIHTb npHHOpTeTbl AASKOMnAeKCHOrO nnJaHHpOBaHH51 HCnOJ1b3OBaHH41 3eMeJlb. 9Ty OLeHKY aOJDKHbl npOBCCTH

POCCHICKHe CHeui4aiiHCTbl, KOTOpb1e XOpOWO 3HaKOMb1 C o6tumM HIOTeHuUaJIOM peCypCOB H C

npe)KHHMH CXeMaMH 3KCUijiyaTaUUH; OHM aOJDKHbI o6O3Ha'-ITb perUOHbl C HaU6oJiee

6JlaronpHHTHbIMH B03MO)KHOCTSIM[U aRR paoLtlOHaAbHoro .JecoynpaBJIeHHsl npi4poaooxpaHHOA

HanpaBJIeHHOCT4. 3aTeM Ha OCHOBaHHH IpUHOpHTeTOB ,ALJ]A 3TUX paHOHOB cJieayeT

pa3pa6OTaTb noapo6Hble rIiaHbl OpraHH3auLH 3eMJienOJIb3OBaHi5I, KOTOpble riOMOryT B

onpe,aeAeHHH KOHKpeTHbIX uejieu pecypcooxpaHHOui ae51Teh1bHOCT4 H CTa6iJ1bHoro

HHBeCTHpOBaHH51 B pa3BHTHe ZieCHoro ceKTOpa.

Y4HTbIBa51 OrPOMHb1e nHuotuaaH nIeCOB, MO)KHO TO'IHO CKa3aTb, HTO nOJ1HaS

npoueaypa no,apo6Horo nUaHHpOBaHHu 3auMeT 3HaqHTenTbHoe BpeM5I. MHorHe pewueHH5A 0

Page 135: Russian - World Bank Documents

117

6y,ayweM KOHKpeTHbIX npe,anpHSITHH npHJaeTCq nPHHHMaTb ao nOJYMyeHHM 3TOHHH(OpMoaLtHH, nO3TOMy noTpe6yeTcA TaKwe npOBeCTH 3Kcnpecc-oLueHKy COCTOSHHApeCypCHOH 6a3bl CyU1eCTBYIOLUHX npeanpHMTlH. 3ToT aHaiiH3 noMo)KeT onpeaenJHTbMaCUJTa6bi HepeCTpOAKH, HeO6XOaHMO B CBA3H C BJlUHHHeM pblHoIHOg aeUCTBHTeJAbHOCTH;nO3BOJIHT OL1eHHTb peaJabHbie HHBeCTHUHOHHbie B03MOKHOCTH U pa3pa6OTaTb CeTbCoU3aluHTbl An>H OKa3aHHSi noMOWH HacenieHHIO AeCHbIX pahOHOB B TpyaHblg nepHog3KOHOMHqecKoro rnepexoaa. nJIS BbIqBjTeHH 3aHHTepeCOBaHHbIX CTOpOH, nojTyeH14HHcIopMauLIH H HX peKOMeHaau4uH no oxpaHe OKpy)Kaioiueri cpeabl, nniaHHPOBaHHAHCnOAb3OBaHHH 3eMenJb H pauHoHaHnbHoro ynpasBeHuA JiecaMH cnieayeT HCnOJIb3OBaTbMeTo0o4ori4H4 COIuHaJbHoro aHanJ3a.

B cTpaTerwqx OplfHN3aJ4HH 3CMJIcIOJI3OBtaHHfi CeHiac aOMHHHpyeT rPOH3BOACTBO£apeBeCHHbI. OIHaKO aa)Ke Ha TeX TeppHTOpHMX, rae TeCOXO3SAACTBeHHaM aLeTejIbHoCTbBe,aeTCS, rJiaBHbIM o6pa3oM, C ueJIblO HpOMbIlJIeHHOrO npOH3BOACTBa apeBeCHHbl, nOBeCKHM 3KOHOMHUeCKHM H 3KOAorwHeCKHM npHqHHaM Heo6XORHMO HCnOJIb3OBaTb CTpaTerH4OynpaBneHHSI, BKJlioqaIolIYIO TaKHe ueJ1H, KaK oxpaHa noryjiAuHHu ARKHX )KHBOTHb1X, oxpaHa

Oq4BeHHbIX H BOAHbIX peCYPCOB H CoXpaHeHHe 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3wI. HpH liiO6oM nepecMOTpeOCHOBHbIX HaHpaBneHH9 J1ecoynpaBneHH.9 Heo6xoai4Mo yqHTbIBaTb MeCTHblu CnpoC HapeCypCbl aHKHX )KHBOTHbIX H apyrHe HeapeBeCHbie JIeCHbIe IpOAyKTbl, a TaKiKeCHCTeMaTHUeCKH pa6oTaTb C o6wueCTBeHHOCTbIO, bopMHppyA 6naronpHsTHoe o6LUeCTBeHHOeMHeHHe OTHOCHTeCJbHO cnoco6o0 nPOBseeHHq J1CCOX03SArCTBeHHblX pa6oT.

ZlAsA BbiaeneHH5 oxpaH5eMbIX TeppHTopHi, 3eMeTIb KOpCHHorO Hacen1eHH5I (y)KeHCHOJIb3yeMbIX H TeX, Ha KOTOpbIC OHH HMelOT HpaBa), y'aCTKOB, ripeaCTaEJi5omux oco6yioL1eHHOCTb C TOqKH 3peHH5 6mopa3Hoo6pa3Hl, TeppHTOpHU C HOBblweHHOrUqyBCTBHTeJlbHOCTbIO K TaKHM BMCewaTeJlbCTBaM, KaK llpOMbIwHleHHaS JieCO3arOTOBHTeJibHaS

eSATeJbHOCTb, a TaK)Ke TeppHTOpUU, npHrOaHbIX aAn CTa6HJIbHoro npOH3BOaCTBa apeBecHHbl,Heo6xoAiHMo npHmeHATb MeTOIbI KOM7ICeKCHO0 ILaHHPOBaHHR HC7Ob30WBHHh 3eMCJIb.TaKOA noAXo0L K nJ1aHHPOBaHHIO RCHOJ1b3OBaHHUA 3eMenJb A BRqeTC51 KJlOqOM K MaKCHMH3aLUHHCOULHaAbHbIX H 3KOHOMH'IeCKHX BbirOa HeCcTOLUHTenJbHOrO HCHOJIb3OBaHHiA ACCHbiX peCypCOB,14 B TO wKe BpeMq OH o6ecneqHT 3aLL1HTY 3KOJIOrFHeCKOrO H 6HonorUiqeCKorO HaCJleat45CH6HpH H JaanbHero BocToKa. B 3TOM npouecce nJIaHHPOBaHH5 AOJDKHbl y'aCTBOBaTb BCe3aHHTepeCOBaHHbie CTOPOHbl: (CeaepaJbHaA cjiy)K6a JieCHoro XO3ACTBa, HeaaBHO C03,aHHbieroCy,aapCTBeHHbl4 KOMHTeT no oxpaHe OKpy)KaIloLeH Cpeabl 1U MHHHCTepCTBo HpHpOaHbIXpeCypCOB, permoHaJ]bHbie BMaCTM, MeCTHOe HacenIeHHe J1eCHb1X paHOHOB, HayqHO-HccJie,aOBaTeJTbCKHe HHCTHTYTbl, o6UICCTBeHHbie H npo'He opraHH3auLH.

JIeco3aTroBKa, o6pa6oTKa 1viBw Ha Bbpy6KaX Hf CCTcTBcHHoe Bo3o6HoBJJcHIe:9TH BHabi pa6oT Heo6xoaHMo paccMOTpeTb B CBeTe HX COOTBeTCTBH51 YCTaHOBJ1eHHb1MHOPMaM H Tpe6OBaHHqM H o6ecnleqHTb 6onee cTporoe BbIlnOnHeHuHe nocCleaH4x. HYAHOBbliIeJIHTb Te paUOHbl, rae 3KOHOMH-eCKHCe H 3KOJ1OH'-IeCKHe 3agatm (Hpo03BoacTBoapeBecHHb, YMHO)KeHHe 64opa3Hoo6pa3H HJunH CBq3bIBaHHe yrmepoaa) MO)KHO pewlaTbrocpeCICTBOM neCOBOcCTaHOBJeHHA, H oripeaeJHTb nO HHM rpHOp1TeTbi. CTporoeperyAHpOBsaHHe niCcO3aIOTOBHTeAbHbIX pa6OT Heo6xoaHMo A,AA MOTHBMUHH1 npHMeHeHH51 TexMeTOIIOB BOCnpOH3BOACTBa, KOTOpbIe onpeaejieHbi nJiaHOM 3eMJeHOAb3OBaHH43. I]pU4rO£1HOCTbToro HuIH HHoro MeToaa BOCnpOH3BOaCTBa nieca 3aBHCHT OT per4OHa, H KaAKablh MeTO£ UMeeTCBOH TeXHHqeCKHC, 6iO4UH3H4eCKHC H 3KOJ1OrHL1eCKHe Tpe6OBaH IN. OQHaKO, CaMblMPaCnPOCTPaHeHHbIM MeTO£1OM B POCCH 141 ABjiCTC51 eCTeCTBeHHOC BO3o6HOBneCHUe.

Page 136: Russian - World Bank Documents

118

POCCHUH ciiexyeT paCaIHPTb COTPYAHH'-eCTBO C apyrUHM CTpaHaMH B o6jiaCTH

nOBblUweHHS 34xeKTHBHOCT4 3awHT H OXpaHm pcCypCOB. TaKHe o6MeHbl TeXHOJIOrFHMH H

Hoy-xay npHHOCqT nojib3y BCeM CTOpOHaM U MOryT aaTb POCCUH 3Ha'lHTeJIbHbIe

nojiO)KHTeCJbHbie pe3yJIbTaTbl, 6iaroaapq COKpaiueHHIO orpoMHoro yiUep6a, KOTOpblH4

e)KeroLaHo HaHOCST noKapbi, HaceKOMbie H 6o.ie3HH. HaH6onee npHOpHTeTHOfl 3aaamek

ABASeTCAI pa3pa6OTKa UHTerPHPOBaHHblX MeTOXOB OXPaHbl AeCOB OT no)KaPOB H 6opb6bl c

BpeglfTej1MH C aKLIeHTOM Ha paHHeM o6Hapy)KeHHH oHaroB H 6bICTpOH4 Mo6HJIH3auHH

pecypcoB 4,qI JIHKBHLaUHH4 OnaCHOCT4. 34XeKTHBHOCTb H KateCTBO MepOflpHATUH nO

3aHXUTe H oxpaHe nIeCOB MOryT 6bITb 3Ha4HTenJbHO nOBbIUweHbl 3a cdeT npeaBapHTenbHoro

Bbl5BJICeHHi, jiowuaaeH, KOTOpbIe Tpe6ylOT oco6oro BHHMaHHS4, coriacHo 3KoHoMH4eCKHM,

COUHanJbHbIM H 3KojTorH4eCKHM npHop4TeTaM.

HeKoTopble H3 HaH6onee cepbe3HbIX onaCHoCTeri, rpO3SlltWX nIeCHbIM

3KOCHCTeMaM CB53aHbl C HpOH3BOACTBeHHOA AegTeAIHOchiO apymx oTpacuie4, oco6eHHO,

HedTera3OBOA H ropHoao6blBaioiueA, a TaK)Ke HH4JpacTpyKTypbi. HeCMOTp. Ha TO, YTOcyLueCTByIou.ee ceutlac npHpoaooxpaHHoe 3aKoHoRaTeAbCTBO BnOJ1He COOTBeTCTBYeT LeJSIM

3auXHTbl peCYPCHOU 6a3bl, co6nmojDaeTCR OHO nJIoXo, B pe3yflbTaTeq ero iiecHbiM pecypcam no-

npe)KHeMy yrporKaioT no)Kapbl, pa3pyw eHHe HCTOLUteHHe. HeO6XOaiHMO npOBeCTH

yTO4HeHHe BonpoCOB IOPHCatHKUKH HaA 3eMAeC H pecypcaMH, 'HTO nO3BOAJo 6bl

npO,aOfl)KaTb pa3pa6OTKY H o6ecne4HTb co6moaneH4e HeO6XOgiHMbIX npHpO,OOXpaHHbIX HOPM

H Tpe6oBaHH9.

B. Pa1UOHaAH3aiUHS rOCyARapCTBeHHb]X KanHTanibHblX H TeKYIUHX 3aTpaT

MO)KHO O)KH,aaTb, 'ITO npH HaIHMHH COOTBeTCTBY1OuLer CTPYKTypbl nOAJTHTKH

YaCTHbI CeKTOP HalHeT UrPaTb Beeywyio POJnb B pa3BHTHU aepeBOnepepa6aTblBalOLuerl

oTpaciiH, BKJio'4aSA moepHH3a4Lmo CTapbIX H CTpOHTenJbCTBO HOBbIX 3aBo,4OB, yBejIH'eHHe

JieCO3arOTOBHTeCJbHbIX MOiUHOCTerH, a TaioKe yjiyqueHHe HuH pacwiiipeHHe TpaHCnOpTHOH

HH4)pacTpyKTypbl. MTo6bi KoMMep'eCK4e HHTepecbl He npecjieaOBaTiHCb B yLuep6

3KoRorHHeCKOu yCTOr4"HBOCTH, Tpe6ylOTCA TaoKce roCynapCTBeHHbie Kan4TajToBjio)KeHlHS B

o6iueCTBeHHo Hojie3Hbie TOBapbI H YCJIyru B JieCHOM KoMiiieKce. HaCTHbie 4DHpMbl laCTO

MOryT npeaOCTaB.iATb jieCOXO3S4CTBeHHbie ycJIyru Ha XaOrOBOPHOA OCHOBe.

,flI ycnewHoro OCyi1eCTBjieHHA nporpamMbI rocyaapCTBeHHbIX HHBeCTHULHI B

JeCHOM ceKTope noTpe6yloTcsl 3Ha4HTenJbHbie H3MeHeHKA B pacnpeaejleHH4

rocyLLapcTBeHHbIX paCXOROB Ha nieca H pacnopI)KeHHHH UMH. B npoueaypax COCTasneHlIH5

60o,gXeTa aOAI)KHO 6bITb 'eTKoe pa3rpaH'eHICHe Mme)ay TeKyuiHMH pacXoaaaMH H

KanUTanJbHbIMH 3aTpaTaMH, KPOMe TOFO, OHH AO0JDKHbI BKJInlOaTb nepHOawMeCKyIO OUeHKY

3("eKTHBHOCT4 3aTpaT. FpH paCCMOTpeHHH rOCcyfapCTBeHHbIX paCXO,aOB B ieCHOM CeKTOpe

4ezepajlbHoe npaBHTeJIbCTBO ROJI)KHO H3y'aTb B03MO)KHOCTH COBepUweHCTBOBaHUiq

ynpaBeieHH1, onpeaeji5Tb H nepepacnPeAeniTb npHiopHTeTbl TaK, WTO6bI OCHOBHOU aKUeiHT

,aeiiaic, Ha oxpaHe IecOB OT no)KapOB, ueCefBbIx i4ccjieaOBaHHl5X H co3LIaH44 OCHOB H

B03MO)KHOCTeri peryjinpOeaHHs H CTpaTerTHeCKoro rin1aHHpOBaHH5 Ha HaUHOHajIbHOM H

MeCTHOM YPOBHqX (Ta6jinua 3.3).

focy,apcroeHHmc HHBeCTwL (NH B OXpaHy I 3maJIy fCCOB, oco6eHHO B

COBepwIeHCTBOBaHHe TCXHH'eCKHX CpeaCTB H MeTOaOB o6HapyKeHH5 H TyweHliq no)KapOB,

MOryT npHHCCTH 6oflbWHe H CKOpbie BbirOfbl, cnoco6CTByq cnaceHHIo eCTeCTBeHHblX jTeCOB

OT pa3pyeHlHHS orHeM, HaCeKOMbIMH H 6one3HAMH H coxpaHeHtiq yHUBKaBbHOH nO CBOeMy

Page 137: Russian - World Bank Documents

119

3KOJ1orH4eCKOMY pa3Hoo6pa3HlO cpeabi o66TaHHq. M1HHHMH3aLIH,i yinep6a, HaHOCHMOrOniecam 3THMH pa3pyUWHTej1bHbIMH faKTopaMH, MO)KeT oKa3aTb HenOCpeaCTBeHHOe BJIHAHHe HaLonJIroCpOMHyIO yCTOWqHBOCTb peCypCOB, ecJH apyrHe uejiH pecypcoynpaBAeHie 6yayT HMeTb

OfaHy HanpaBjieHHOCTb C 3aWIHTHbIMH MepOnpHSTHAMH.

Ha YPOBHe npeanlipHATH MepbI rocyaapCTBeHHoro perynHPOBaH4, ,OJDKHbI 6blTbHanpaBJIeHbI Ha COKpaIueHHe Jiecoce4HbIX OTXOAOB, KOTOpbIe YBeCjHqHBa[OT o6beMbl neCHbIXropio4Hx MaTepHaJIOB, a B cny4ae BO3HHKHOBeHHS no)Kapa yBeniHqHBalOT eropa3pyUiHTeCJbHYIO cHJIy. B Tex paroHax, rae B niecax CKaniiHBaeTC5 o4eHb 6OflbWoeKOjiH'IeCTBO inecoce4HbIX OTXO2OB, ceieRyeT paCCMOTpeTb B03MO)4KHOCTb HcnOJIb3OBaHHRKOHTPOJIHPYeMbIX raJIOB KaK O,HOrO H3 JieCOXo3sACTBeHHbIX MeporIpHSTHH. Bo MHorHxcTpaHax ,eACTByIOT y'e6Hbie nporpaMMbl H npOCBeTTTenJbHbie KoMnaHHH, HanpaBJIeHHble HaTO, 4To6bl goBeCTH LO CO3HaH4R AHoaeH BCIO OnaCHOCTb H nOCJAeaCTBHS1 JIeCHbiX ro)iKapOB.)I,sA o6HapyIceHHs ro)KaPOB H Ha6JIIoaeHHSl 3a CHTyau[berl MOAHO HCnOJb3OBaTbCnYTHHKOBbie o6cieIIoBaHHA H KOMnblOTepHbie TeXHOjiOrHH. CineayeT nponaoAKaTb HpaciHHp5ITb pa6OTy B paMKax nporpaMM THna COBMeCTHoro poccHHiCKO-aMepHKaHcKoronpoeKTa (Co CTOpOHbl CWLA B HeM yqaCTByeT HaULHOHanbHoe ynpaBAneHe CWLIA noa3pOHaBTHKe H HCCJAeaOBaHHIO KOCM4qeCKOrO rIpOCTpaHCTBa, HACA), KOTOpblH HarTpaBjieHHa H3yqeHHe BO3MO)KHOCTeri HCnOJIb3OBaHHR CFTYTHHKOBbIX CHHMKOB AnA o6Hapy)KeHHAKpynHbIX riO)KapOB H Cie)KeHH51 3a HHMH; cneayeT TaKXKe rTPpOAOJKaTb H paCwLHpqTb Rpyruepa6oTbl no KOOPRHHauHHU pa3pa6OTKH TeXHOJIOriHf 6opb6bl C nIeCHblMH noKapaMH H o6MeHHMH. FocyaapcTBeHHas nporpamma no 6Opb6e C J1eCHbIMH noxKapaMH Ha 1993-97 rr. morna6bl CTaTb OCHOBOH AAS COOTBeTCTByIO1ueri HHBeCTHUHOHHOrH npOrpaMMbl.

BO3MO)KHOCTH y4aCTH5 iieCHbIX Haywo-HccJIAoBaTCJIbCKHX HHCTHTYTOB BnpouKecce nHJaHHPOBaHHA HCnOJIb3OBaHH45 3eMeCJb ceriac cepbe3HO ocina6AeHbi H3-3aOrpOMHOH1 noTepH HayqHHbIX KaJpOB. Heo6xoLbHMo o6ecneMHTb YCJOBHI H dUHaHCUpOBaHUeaR1l pa6oTbl JyqLWUHX cnetuHaiHCToB, npOBeaeHHI [eCjeBb[X Hccjle1aoBaHHA, CnOCo6CTBYIOLUIHXBblnOJIHeHHIO 3aAaq yHpaBJIeHHR JieCHbIMH pecypcamH, H AnS npoaon)KeHHS c6opaHHdJOpMauHH H perHCTpautHH 6a3oBbIX aaHHbIX (HHBeHTapH3aulHOHHbie aaHHbie, aaHHbieA2ICTaHUHOHHbIX o6CjieaOBaHHH H OLbeHKH COCTOAHRA OKpyxKaiolLteri CpeAbl). 9TH CHiCTeMblaaHHbIX AOJDKHbl npeAyCMaTpHBaTb pacnpocfpaHeH4e 4HH4OpMaLtHH CpeaH HaceCeHHR, 'To6bl

piHBjieMb K pa6oTe KaK 4aCTHblg CeKTOp, TaK H MeCTHbIX )KHTeJierl. 9c4eKTHBHOCTbynpaBJieHHA MOXHO 6buio 6bl 3HaM4TenjbHO nOBblCHTb C nOMOLUblO TeXHojiorH ynfpaBnJeH[4HHH4opMaLHe, npeWHa3HaIeHHbX AA yjiyqueHH$ HH(1opMa[HOHHoro o6ecne4eHtiq JILL,npHHHMalOLLHX pewIeHH5, H 3aHHTepeCOBaHHbIX CTOpOH. CeTb MOAeJIbHbIX JeCOB, KOTOpyIOHaqana co3JaaBaTb )PeaepanbHaH cAy)K6a niecHoro XO3AHCTBa, morna 6bl CJISYVHTb HCTOMHHKOMBaM(HOH 3KOJAOrH4eCKOr4 H 3KOHOMHMeCKOA HHbOpMau4HH, HeO6xoaHMoH bn5 yripasBjeHHqJiecaMH.

HpaBHTeJIbCTBO OJ DKHO B3SITb Ha ce6i nepBOHaManbHbie 3aTpaTbl Ha KoMnHieKCHOenHiaHHpOBaHHe HeHCTOLUHTeJibHOrO peCypCoHOJIb3oBaHHH. 9TOT BHI njlaHMPOBaHH5 qBnIqeTCSo6LUHM 6.naroM, Heo6XOaHMbIM aAn nepexoaa K YCTOA4HBOMY pa3BHTHiO SieCHoro CeKTopa.KpHT4qeCKH BaAKHbIH rIepBbli mar COCTOHT B co3XaaHHH yCJIOBHH AqS TaKoro nHaHHPOBaHHAB perHOHaX H MeCTHbIX aRAMHHHCTpaUHAIx, OHO AOJDKHO onpeAeAqlTbCS CTpyKTypOH1co6CTBeHHOCTH H aLMHHHCTpaTHBHO-XO35ir4CTBeHHb[MH o65I3aHHOCTMIMH KaX)Koro YPOBHRyripaBJieHHs. nOMHMO Heo6Xogi4Mbix TeXHHUeCKHX H OpraHH3aTOPCKHX HaBbIKOB, 3TOTnpoLuecc riiiaHHPOBaHH5 Tpe6yeT HaniH4HA UHd4OpMaLtHH o apeBeCHb[X H HCepeBeCHbIXpecypcax, 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3HH H apyrHX HPpHPOAHbIX rtOj1e3HOCT5IX iieca no BceM

Page 138: Russian - World Bank Documents

120

JieCOpaCTHTeSJbHbIM yCJIOBHHM. HeaoCTaTOK TaKOU UHHqOpMaLtHH MO)KeT CTaTb aOCTaTO4HO

3HaqHTeJIbHbIM OrpaHHqHBaiO1ui4M 4DaKTopoM. I' HaKOHeU, Ha BCeX 3TaHaX npouecca

lliaHMpOBaHK$1 ciieAyeT HCKaTb WUIpOKOrO y'aCTHS MeCTHbIX 3aHHTepeCOBaHHbIX CTOpOH,

BKJ11oMa,q o6LueCTBeHHbIe opraHU3auim, KOpeHHOe HaceleHiie 14 pecypconOJIb3OBaTeJeg.

Ta6nmHia 3.3: PaUHOHaAH3aiuHS rocyYAapcTBeHHb1X KanHTdJIbHbIX u TeKyuHx 3aTpaT

flpo6neMa COBPeMeHHoe 17pe=#laeMumc LIteHfff 17pwareMme cTparerff

CocToSIHHe _p o6pa3_aH

nIaHripoBaHHe, CJxa6bili nOTeHiUIan i u O6ecnem[iTb YCJnOBsun lAM * £IeueHTpaaiH3oBaTb CUiCTeMy

opmCHTIPOBaHHoe Ha noJ1rocpo'Horo OUeHKH nocieACCTH niiaHHPOBaHHsl H BOBjie4b B npouecc

yCTO1F4HBOCTb pecypca CTpaTerUMecKoro H3MeHeHmir B nOJIHTHKe H KOmniieKCHoro niTaHHpOBaHHuI pecypcoB

nniaHHPOBaHH.q B paCnpOCTpaHSITb ee Bce 3aHHTepeCOBaHHbie CTOpOHbi,

KoHTeKCTe pbIHO4HOU pe3yjibTaTbl cpeau Bcex BKJlio4aFl KOpeHHoe HaceJleHHe

3KOHOMHKW; B 3aHHTepecoBaHHbIX

6joiieTmoM npouecce opraHHau3Hr H jinu,HeT rlpaBHJ1bHOrO oTBeTCTBeHHb[X 3a

pa3rpaHumeHHH Me4(m y pa3pa6oTKy H npOBse,eHHKanHTaJIbHbIMI iiecHou nojiHTHKH;3aTpaTaMH H TeKYLUHMH o6ecne'ITb

pacxoaaMH, 'TO BeaeT K 3KOHOMH4ecKH

XPOHH'eCKOMY nepeKocy pauHOHaWbHbIe YPOBHH H

B pa3MetueH4H pecypca cXeMbI oTpac.neBoroB nOJTb3y npeanpHSlT1uu, peHHBeCTHpOBaHHA U

He COCOO6cTBylOLUHX nOTOKOB pecypcoBYCTOUIMBOCTH cexcopa

OxpaHa u 3aLUITa Aeca nloicapbl, BpeiflITenJTH U KoMnJTeKCHbI1 nOaXOa K * HHBeCTHPOBaTb CpeCCTBa B CHCTeMbi H

6oJie3iHK exerOaHO 3aluHTe H oxpaHe nIecoB TexHoJIorm MoHHTopMHra, ynpaBnleHuM

Bbl3blBalOT H 6opb6bi C nowKapaMm, BpeUHTemiMH U

CyLueCTBeHHbie 6ojne3HHMU, qTo6bl MHHU MH3HUpOBaTb

3KOHOMUiqeCKUe U 3KOHOMHqeCKHe H 3KonJorCqecKHe

3KoJIorHqecKHe nOTepU noTePH

HayKa H TCXHUKa BloaxiKeTHbie llnn npaBHJbHoro * PawLolHanH3HpoaTb BbLReJIeHHeOrpaHHUeHHU COKPaTHJIH yryaBMneHHl nIecHbIMH CpeaCTB Ha HCccieCOBsaHH51 B

KanHTaoBJoM)KeHH.q B pecypcaMH Heo6XoaHMO cOOTBeTCTBHH C ueji5MH ynpaBneHHsi

nieCHYIO HayKy H npOAOaJKzaTb ueJleBbie .ieCHbIM X03HUCTBOM

npHBueH K 3aMexaeHIIO HCCAeOsBaHN9 * OKa3blBaTb rio=ep)KKY TeM Hay'JHbIM

BHeApeHH5 pe3yj1bTaTOB pa3pa6oTKaM, KOTOpbie Cnoco6CTByIOT

Hay'IHbIX pa6oT yKpenneHH[O TpaaHUIIOHHb[X yKJIaaOB,TexHoJIorHri H MeTOJIOB

I pecypconojib30BaHHR

r. PoAb MexAyHaPOAHOrO coO6iiecTBa

Pa6OTa, KOTOpyIO HeO6XOAHMO npOBeCTH B .ieCHOM CeKTOpe POCCHt, qBHO

ripeBOCXOAHT CerOaHIWHHe BO3MO)KHOCTH CTpaHbI no ee 4)14HaHC4pOBaH14IO. Jleca PoccHuu

HMeIOT 6oJbuWoe 3HaqeHHe gAS COCTOlHU4H oKpy)KaioLueh Cpeabl 14 6t4opa3Hoo6pa3H1 Bcero

MHpa, nO3TOMY AecHOAi CeKTOp CTpaHbl npeIcTaBJsieT 3Ha'lHTeJIbHbl 14HTepeC jnJq

Me)AyHapOt1HOrO coo6u.1eCTBa U rIOJTy'aeT OT nociieRHero j)14HaHCHpOBaHHe Ha pqa

npoeKTOB (Ta6.nHua 3.4). OCHOBHoe BHHMaHi4e B 3TUX MeKLtyHapOaHbiX ripOeKTax

COCpe,aOTOMeHO Ha TeX npo6IieMax, KOTOpb1e COOTBeTCTBYlOT 3aaaqaM 1 rip4Opt4TeTaM,

paCCMOTpeHHb[M B aaHHOM aOKJImae, HO 3TU ripOeKTb nJnOXO CKOOPal4HHPOBaHbI 14 ManjO

B3aHMOCBR3aHHbl. 3freKT14BHOCTb 3TUX yCunAu MO)KHO 6bl 3Hai4TeCJbHo nOBbIC14Tb

nOCpe,RCTBOM 6onee TeCHoro COTpy,HHUMeCTBa BHYTPH MeKIyHapOaHoro coo6iuecTBa.

Page 139: Russian - World Bank Documents

121

Me)KayHapOAHoe coo6LueCTBO KpaHHC 3aUHTepeCOBaHHO B 6yaylueM COCTOqHHH HYCTOqHtBOCTH pOCCHHCKUX ZeCOB H CTa6HiUbHOCTH npeanpHATH9 neCHOrO ceKTopa (Ta6nHUa3.5). CegPac oMeHb noaxoamwee BpeMA anH coBMeCTHb[X YCHAHu Co CTOpOI-HbI POCCHH HMeW.AyHapotaHoro coo6LecTBa, COCpeAOTOqeHHbIX Ha KJiiOMeBbIX nPHoPHTeTax JIeCHoroCeKTOpa, BKJlio0aiOLUHX naHHpoBaHue u UHaHCHpOBaHHHe pa6oT, CBS3aHHbIX CBblnoJIHeH eM PoccHeu ee mcxzyHapoqHbx o6o3a7'cm TB 11o oxpaHe oKpyAraJomLe,l cpe,b.3a,aaa OXJI)KHa 3aKYHoqaTbCA B Bbipa6oTKe B03MO)KHbIX BapHaHTOB, KOTOpbie npaBHTejibCTBOMo)KeT paccmarpHBaTb npu npHHqTuH peweHH9 nO BbiHOJIHeHI10 CBOUX MeKfAyHapOAHbIXo6S13aTeJ]bCTB H npH Bbi6ope nyTeH COaeACTBHq yCTOr4tHBOMy pa3BHTHIO neCHoro ceKTopa BnepeXo,aHbiH riepHog.

Ta6nuiHa 3.4: Jlecoxo3SAcTBeHHbLie npoelcrbl, ocymecT MAb eme yHapoARHbMcoo6uecTBoM

Tema 7poexKa L(Wb MezayHaipaHMAf fapTHep

OueHKa AeCHbIX pecypCOB

* PaumoHanbHoe Hcnonb3oBaHHe * AHanH3 CoCTORHH5l necOB Cu6upu * MeIAWyHapoalHbjA HHCTUTYTnecCHbix pecypcoB CU6HpH npHK;na,aHoro CHCTeMHOrO aHaJIH3a

* CnyrHHKOBaR TeXHOJ1orHIS9 H 0 * 4cnOJIb3OBaHme CnyTHHKOBbIX * (DpaHUy3CKHI HccneJOBaTeCJbCKHAreorpaqpH'ecKasq NH4)OpMaUHOHHaq aaHHb1X anq HHBeHTapH3auUH H HHCTHTyT CeAbCKOrO H AeCHoroCHCTeMa (rHc) KaPTHPOBaHHS peCypCOB X03SH4CTBa (CEMAGREF)

PaUHOHaJIbHoe niecoynpaBjieHHe

* raccHHcKHu MoRenibilb niec * 4)yHKUHOHHpyioLuaq Mooejib * KaHancKan9 necHan ciy)K6apaUHOHaWbHorO AecoynpaBseHHR

* PauHoHalbHoe ynpaBneHHe * C03,AaHHe OCHOBbi LAf * USAID u TACISnpHPOQHbIMH pecypcaMH HeHcTOWHTeAIbHOro

pecypconOAb3OBaHHus

* HeHcTou0UTeAbHoe OCBoeHHe paroHa * CoTpyaHHnecTSo Mme)y BaCTHbIM * USAID03epa barKan ceKTopoM POCCHH H CWA c

UCe.jbio coaeHCTBqSHCHCTOUHTCJIbHOMY OCBOeH4IOpecypcoB

* flpoeKT r3D) no coxpaHeHHIo * rno6anbHbli 3KoJIoruWlecKIIH qOHR6"opa3Hoo6pa3lsl -Ear4KajbCKMA * PauLoHanH8ioe ynpaBAeHue (roH) H BceMHpHbir 6aHK; TACISKOMnOHCHT

BoccTaHOBJIeHHe AecOB Ha TpexOT,aejbHbIX Bf0ioc60paX

(npo,aoxjKeHHe Ta6.HLtbl Ha cieayloomerl CTpaHHue)

Page 140: Russian - World Bank Documents

Ta6.nIHla 3.4: JAecoxo3siicTBeHHube npoeKTbi, ocytecTeir5IeMbie MeXAYHaPOAHbLMcoo6utecmoM (npoqAonxeHHe)

Tema npoeK7a L(e|b 7poeAM MexayHpiAHMR 1napTHep

BocnpoH3oAcTbo JIeCHblX pccypcoB * BbIpaLuwBaHHe * MHHIcTepcTBo cenjbCKoro uH iecHoroBbICOKOKa qeCTBeHHOrO X03H5cTBa ONHnRH, 14

nOcaaOqHOro MaTePHaJa MRSAecoBOCCTaHoBMeHHH * KomnaHuHi Begepxay3ep

3aum H oxpaHa JIecHbix pecypcoB

* OxpaHa JieCOB OT InO)KaPOB * 06MeH lHH)opMaUmer H * KaHana; CWATeXHojiorHqMH B o6iacTH OXpaHbi

* CnyrHutKoBble CHHMKH AecoB OT nlO)KaPOB * HACA (CWA)

* MoHHTopHHr H 6opb6a c *HlcnOJb3OBaHHe CHUMKOB C * KaHazaa, CWA

Bpe.amTeU11MU BbICOKOU pa3peuwHTen bHOUcnOco6HOCTbIO H n4c xLqqH3yqeHHR 1 MOHHTOPHHraCOCTOSHHA AecoB

* nporpaMMa 1pe3BbIqariHb1X mep no * Caep)KHBaHHe BCnblbIKH * BceMMpHbiH 6aHKAeco3aluHTe MaCcoBoro pa3MHO)KeHHA

onacHoro BpeAHTeA% BKpaCHOslpCKOM Kpae c nOMOlUblO3KOJ1orH'eCKH 6e3onacHoro6uojiorH'ecKoro npenapaTa(opraHH3aumrnsl H fHaHCipOBaHHe3aKynKH npenapaTa)

OuieHKa YPOBHR 6mopa3Hoo6pa3Hg myriiepoAzHoro 6anaHca

* JlecoynpaEuleHHeueH COXPaHeHe * 1H4opMauMA no * rno6anbHblH 3KOmorHeCKHA (OHA6Iopa3Hoo6pa3H4s HeHCTOWUHTeCJbHOMy (r3qD) u BceMHpHbIAI 6aHK

HCnOJb3OBaHHIO 3eMeAbHb[X H Ap.

npHPOfHbIX pecypCOB

* CoxpaHeHHe 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3HR * OueHKH TeKyLuuix TeHAeHUHA * USAIDPa3BHTHR 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3Hsl BPOCCHH H HX CBS13H c yrniepoAHbIM * USAID

6aAaHCoM

* npoeKT CuxoTe-A.niHb * HHBeHTapm3aums

9KOTYpH3M H peKpeaCUHS

* 3KOTYPH3M B paroHe o3epa BaEKan * OueHKa noTeHuHa)ia H BbIrOA * BceMHpHblr 6aHK H InOHHuR3KOTyPH3Ma

* PeKpeauHoHHble pecypcbi H * KaHDacKaq AeCHaJq cny)K6a3KOTYPH3M B Xa6apoBCKoM Kpae * KoHuenTyanbHas MOAeJlb

3KoTypH3Ma, OCHOBaHHaR Ha rfc

Page 141: Russian - World Bank Documents

123

Ta6inui a 3.5: Pojib MexnyHaPOAHoro coo6igecTBa

f7po&iema COBPCMCHHOC COcToRHHCe l7pewnamemwe mef7 lpeJaiaemme cparerminmpo6pa3__aH__

rjio6aAbHaR MexayHapOaHaq Bbinon HeHHe * MannTHpOBaTb H nfptiMeHHTb3KoJlorHqecKasl 3aHHTepeCOBaHHOCTb B qIUHHHCOBbIX H npO'HX MeKIayHapOa1Hbie CICTeMbi KPHTCPHuB HcTa6H.qbHocTb npMmeHeHHH IpHHuH4noB o6.93aTeJ1bcTB no HH.OHKaTOPOB HeHCTOUIHTeJTbHOCTH

HeCcToLuHTeJ]bHocTH K ynpaoBeHHIO JlecoynpaaneHUH 9051 pa3pa6oTKHynpaBBneHHIO J1ecaMH He rocyaapCTBeHHbIMH HaUHOHanbHOA H perCOHaObHOAo6ecneqHBaeTcg aaeKBaTHOti pecypcaMH B JecHoH nouJIHTHKH, MeTOLIOB HTeXHWteCKOA HunH JiHHaHCoBOA cooTBeTCTBHH C iHa4KaToPOB 3(ieKTHBHOCTHnOMOLwbIO MmeXcaYHaPoAH HbIMH * OnpeaenHUTb KOHKpeTHblC H anpa HBJ1eHH

aOroBOpeHHOCTrMH no noAHTHKH, HHBecTHpoBaHNHS HoxpaHe CpeAbl xo3599CTBeHHou 2ieqTeAbHOCTH,

HMmmOHe Me)KayHap0,aHble3KonorHqeCKHe nocAea1CTBH5I,BbIXO2IwLeC 3a paMKH HaUHOHaflbHblx3KOHOMH'eCKHx flPHOPHTeTOB* npOBOaHTb BCTpeqH ROHOpOB ZJJH

Mo6JtHm3auHH pecypcoBn MRnpHOpHTeTHbIX HanpaBneHuuaeATeAbHOCTH

TexH CqeC KaB MeoxwyHapoHasa TeXHHqeCKaq CocpeJsoToqeHHe * BMeCTe C npCeCTaBHTeCiim UnOMOLIb nOMOLub OXBaTbIBaeT WIHPOKHl Mri Ke1yHaPOa1HOt 3aHHTepecoBaHHb]X CTOpOH, aIOHopaMH

Kpyr TeM H reorpOcaHbHqeCKIX TeXHHqeCKo0 nOmOIH H HHBCCTOpaMH nOarOTOBHTb OUeHKYpa0OHOB, HO OHa He Ha KjnloqeBb1x Heo6xo1HMOA TexHHqeCKoh noMowIS UCKOOpAHHHPOBaHa, 1 ee HaUHOHaOJbHb1X ee nepcrieKTHBHbIX HCTO4HHKOBBJIAHHue orpaHHqeHo rlpHopHTeTax, KoTopbIe * Pa3BWBaTb CHCTeMy coriTaweHHO 0

MOryr Bbl3BaTb COTPYaHHieCTBC MeC)yCHCTeMHb1e H3MeHeHIH B 06'bCeaHeHHHMH KOpCHHb1X AKTeJIeAnOJITHKe HK r npaicrHKe POCCHUCKOU (DPeaepauLLuH H 2pyri4xpecypCoynpaBjseHH.q CTpaH CeBepa 1m nOaeCP)KKH

KOpeHHOrO HaceJieHMH ATpa.ZHUHOHHbIX YKAaa0B

* Pa3BHBaTb CHCTCMy MHOrOCTOPOHHHXcorJaaweHHu MmeClJy AOHOpaMH OCoTpy)IHH4eCTBe B OKa3aHHHCHCTeMaTH'eCKOH ueAesBO rioMoLuiS

H)HHaHcoBaB 4>U4HaHCOBbie HyX(fbl, (DIHaHCoBbie pecypcbi * O6ecne'HTb CKOOPa2HHHpOBaHHOenOMOLUb CBq3aHHbie C M.H AOCTH)KeHH5 (qHHaHCHPOBaHme 3KoHoMH'ICCKK,

BOCCTaHoBneHueM UH aoJrrocpo'HbIX ueiegi 3KoJlor"4eCKH H COUHaAbHOCOXPaHeHmeM yCT014MBOCTH pecypcoynpasnieHuH )KH3HecnoCo6Hbix npOeKTOB Hpecypca, BbIXOA1T 3a npeaenJbl MeponpHIATHA, cnoco6cTByloLusxCerOLH5lWIHMX BO3MOIKHocTeA CTa6HIJbHOCTI H 3qi4qCKTUBHOCTU BH r'OTOBHOCTH qaCTHOrO o6J1aCT.9X, KOTOpbiC siBJAioTCqceKTopa HHBeCTHpOBaTb, a KJiIo'leBbIMH 215 3aLUHTbl pecypCOB HMeCTHOrO rocyaapcTBeHHoro o6ecne'eHlHi aO2121KHb]X YC21OBHi4 )KH3HHCeKTOpa CTpaHbl - nf]aTHTb HaceCieHHq OTaa2iCHHbIX J1eCHbIX

paOOHOB H ripHBjieqeHHIO 'aCTHbIXHHBeCTHIU1H

TexHHYCCKOe H 4iJHaHCOBOe CO0aCiiCTMIe HYXHO AAR YCKOpeHHR HHTerpauFHHnecHoro ceKTopa B npouecc o6lue3KoHoMtiecKoti peqopMbI, DAHs nepexoAa Kj pauHOH bHOMY ynpasneHHIo jiecamx, a TaKxce xH paLuHHaOH H3aLuHH I'rocy1apCTBeHHbIXpacXO,aOB H Co3,aHHA Heo6xoatMblX yCTIOBU4ii AhR npHBjieEeHHA 'aCTHbIX HHBeCTHUHii BcTa6HJbHbie npernpH5THI JIecHoro ceKTopa. O'eHb Ba)KHO, 'To6bl oco6oe BHIMaHmeyXejifOCb pa3BHTHIO nOTeHUHaJia JIIOACKHX peCypCOB, 3TO HeO6XOamHMO A5I cMRmeHHmOTPHuLaTenbHbIX COUHaIbHbIx rocjieaCTBHsu r nepexoaa K pbIHO4HOrH 3KOHOMU4KC H m a6y,ayutero pa3BHTHc CeKTopa.

Page 142: Russian - World Bank Documents

124

128

138

Hecnejnie neca: ,LpeBOCTOH, BeayIue BMAbN KOTOpblX MOjTO)Ke CBoero

BO3paCTa py6KH. Bo3pacT py6KH onpeaeniqeTc5i ueLigmi

iiecoynpaBAeHHR.

HeHcTomHTeJibHocTb HpOH3BOaCTBo 6HoJIorHqeCKoro pecypca TaKHMH MeToIaaMH

HCnOJL3sBaHHf pecypca: ynpaBMeHH5[, KOTOpbIe o6ecneuqHBaloT 3aMeHy Bbipy6J1eHHoR

MaCTM HOBbIMH ApeBOCTORMH HJIH BOCnPOH3BOaCTBO AO

npOBe,aeHH5i cJieAyiouLei py6KH.

06opoT py6Ku: 3annaHHpoBaHHbli nepi4oa (roabi) Mew)y 4OpMlpOBaHHeM

Hun BO3o6HOBseHHeM RpeBOCTOR HAH Haca)(eHH5 H

py6KaMH riiaBHOrO InOJb3OBaHHq B HeM B OnpeaeCjeHHOM

Bo3pacTe cnejioCTH.

OnepaiHoHHbie nLTiaHbI: B KOHTeKCTe OCHOBHbIX HanpaBJieHHUi X03.UiCTBeHHOR

IIe.qTeJIbHOCTH Ha KOHKpeTHOH nHjoLuaai1 onepauHOHHbIe

niaHbI noapo6Ho oTpa)Ka]OT MaTepHaAbHO-TeXHHMeCKyiO

CTOPOHY ocBoeHHA pecypca.

OxpaHl-eeMbe TeppHTopHH: TeppHTOpHH, OTBeaeHHbIe noa napKH, 3anoBeaHHKH,

3aKa3HHKH, TeppHTOPHH o6LueHauHOHaAbHoro HAn

perHOHa]bHorO 3HaMeHH3 H peKpeauHOHHbie 3OHbl.

nHOHepHblie BHAbl: EHOJIOrHMeCKHe BHRbl, KOTOpbIe lCePBbIMH 3aCeCiAlOT

OTKpblTb1e nloLuaa4H (HanpHMep, CBeToJIIo6HBbie BHRbl

paCTeHHiI).

no.ne3HocTH (n,eHHOCT) IpoayKTbl, TOBapbi H ycjnyrH, CBsl3aHHbie c ieCHbIMH

pecypca: 3eMji5MH H, B OCHOBHOM, 3aBHCHMbie OT 3KOAOorMeCKHX

npoueccoB. K HHM OTHOCITCA: 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3He,

CB53blBaHHe yrAepoRa, BoAa, aHKHe )KHBoTHbie, pbl6a,

peKpeaLuH5, XApeBecHHa, HeApeBeCHbie JIeCHbIe npOaYKTbI,

nacT6Hu4a H TpaaLuHUH.

Pac'qeTHaS iecoceKa: CpeaHeroRoBou o6tbeM .neca Ha KOpHIO, KOTOpblI MO)KHO

3aFOTasBHBaTb npH nOCTOSHHOM HeHCTOLtuTenAbHOM

Page 143: Russian - World Bank Documents

139

HewKenaTenbHbIx HilH nOBpeA)LeHHbIX AepeBbeB C uenJblOco,aeACTBR Bo3o6HoBJIeHH[O IiunH o3taopoBJeHHIO HnOBbllleHHIO UeHHOCTH OCTaBwerOCq HaCa)KaeHHq. BPOCCHH OHH qacTo HHTepnpeTHPOBETaHCb KaK yLaJIeHHeAepeBbeB, KOTOPbIe Ha 50 ieT cTapwie cBoero orTHMaAbHoroBo3pacTa py6KH.

CTaHAapTbu HcnoOJIb3ODaHH Pa3Mepbi (BbicoTa flHS, aHaMeTp B BepXHeM oTpy6e, IalaMeTpApeBeCHOIO CbipbSl: B HH)KHeM oTpy6e H AWHHa) H Ka4eCTBO LepeBbeB, KOTOpbie1OJLKHbI cpy6aTbcs H BbIB03HTbCI C JiecoceKH B xoae

3aroTOBKTejibHbIX pa6oT.

CTOHMOCTh neca Ha KOpHIO: CTOHMOCTb nieca Ha KOpHIO - 3TO pa3HHiIa MmeAI(ypbIHOtIHOi CTOUMOCTblO apeBeC4Hbl H TeKYlUHMHnpOH3BO2ICTBeHHbIMH 3aTpaTaMH, Heo6xoaHMbIM L AmSBbIB03KH H fOCTaBKH 3TOl apeBeCHHbl Ha OnpeAeJIeHHblHpbIHOK.

CxeMa JiecoceqHbX pa6oT: npOCTpaHCTBeHHOe pacnpeaeJeH4e niecoceK H y!aCTKOBnieca B npeAenax niecHoro AaHAluladTa.

Yr.nepoAa, 3anac: 3anac yrnepoga - 3TO KOJIHMeCTBO yrnepoaa, KOTOpoeHaxOLHTCsI B iieCHoI4 3KOCHcTeMe B mo6orl oT1eJIbHbliMoMeHT BpeMeHR. JIeCHoR yrAepoa XpaHHTCq KaK B )KHBbIX,TaK H B MepTBbIX paCTeHCHX (Har 3eMAefi HU noA 3eMaerl) H B.JeCHOf no4Be. no oILeHKaM, B pOCCHUiCKHX niecax B4iHToMacce (cHBbie pacTeHHsI) co0ep)KHTcq 47,1 MJAP. Tyriiepoua, B AeCHOIi noACTHAnKe - 26,0 MAPA. T yrmepoaa, a BJneCHOU nO4Be - 106,1 MAPA. T yrAepoaa (Krankina andDixon, 1994).

YrnepoAa, HCTOqHHK: Jlec sABseTcs HCTO4H4KOM yriepoaa, ecniH 3apaccMaTpHBaeMbifi nepHo1 npOH3OI0Io COKpau(eHHe 3ariacayrnepona, onpeensieMoro no 6anaHcy MeAy cBAW3bBaHHeMH 3MHCCHSMH yrnepoaa. K I4CTO4HHKaM YyrJePOaHb[X3MHCCHfl OTHOCATCA: abixaHKe AeCHblX paCTeHHUi, 2KHBOTHblXH MHKpOOpraHH3MOB, 3arOTOBKa AeCHb1X HpOayKTOB,pa3Ao)KeHHe MepTBbIX MaTepHanIOB H B HeKOTOpbIX cAy'asixrOpeHHe IieCHbIX maTepHanoB BO BpeMA roKapoB.HapyuweHHs, Bbl3blBaeMbie no)KapaMH, BpeaHTeJIMmH HneCo3aroToBKorl, MOryT Bbl3BaTb rIOBblwJeHHe TeMnepaTypbI BfleCHOA nOACTHJIKe H yBeiiHqHTb HHTeHCHBHOCTb npouecCoBAbiXaHHR H pa3Ao)KeHKH B ieCHOu noqBe. Jleca MoryT 6bITbnorAoTHTeASMH, HaKonHTenjiMH Hnu HCTOqHHKaMH

Page 144: Russian - World Bank Documents

140

yriiepoAa B 3aBHCHMOCTH OT ynpaBJieH45I HMH.

Yr.nepozAa, norjioTHTeIb: Jlec 1Bji5eTCq norJIOTHTeiieM yrjiepoaa, ecJIn 3a

paccMaTpHBaeMbIi nepHo,a npOH30uIO yBenJHueHHe 3anaca

yrnepoAa, onpeezeniseMoro no 6anaHcy Mex,y CB53bIBaHHeM

yrnepoxa H ero 3MHCCUmMi.

YriiepoAza, cBsl3blBaHHe: CBs3blBaHHe yriiepoaa - 3TO H3TSbTHe U3 aTMOC4epbl H

xpaHeHHe RByoKHCH yrnepoaa. CBq3bIBaH4e npOpCXOHMAT B

npoLlecce doToCHHTe3a, Korna 3eneHble pacTeHI4sl 3a6HpalOT

.aByOKHCb yriiepoia 43 aTMocqepbl H coeaHHASIOT ee c

BOAOrU, B pe3ynbTaTe 'ero o6pa3yioTcs yriieBoaopoabl,

KOTOpbIe MOryT XpaHHTbCq B TKaHJqX paCTeHH4A. J4Bi4KyLueri

CHJIorf 3Toro npoviecca qEL151eTc1 COJIHe'Ha5i 3HeprHs.

9KocHcTeMa: HpHpOX,Hblr4 KoMHnieKc, COCTOSIIUHUi u3 COBOKYRHOCTH

)KHBbIX OpFaHH3MOB (pacTeHHA, )KHBOTHbIX U

MHKpoopraHH3MOB) Ha aaHHOA TeppHTOPUUH U BCeX

4H3HqecKHx u Xi4MHmieCK4X 4baKTOpOB oKpyKaolueri Hx

CpeAbI, CBA3aHHbIX MeK.y co6oio KpyrOBOpOTOM

HHTaTenJbHbIX BeWieCTB H nOTOKaMU 3Heprtm.

9KOCHCTeMHoe ynpaBneHHe: LIejOCTHbiu nOA,XOa K ynpaBBjeHU1C O JieCOnOKpbITb[MH

3eMJiAMH, HanpaBj1eHHbli Ha YMHO)KeHHe pa3Hoo6pa3HblX

noAe3HOCTeu ACcHbIx pecypcoB. 3KOCHCTeMHOe ynpaBsieHHe

LOJD)KHO 1pHMeH5ITbC51 B npOCTpaHCTBe 1 BpeMeHH Ha

pa3HbIX ypOBHxx. Ha maKpoypOBHe OHO nOapa3yMeBaeT

nojaep)KaHHe perzoHanbHoro 6anaHca Meway CoxpaHeHi4eM

H Hcnojnb30BaHHeM pecypca B IeCjqx noLaepKaHH$1

64opa3Hoo6pa3wl, npOayKTHBHOCT4 14 3KOJ]oriuqeCKO

4yHKUHOHaRbHOCTH. Ha MHKpOYPOBHe OHO npeanojiaraeT

no,apo6Hoe neCOXO3.qACTBeHHoe nniaHHpOBaHHe 1 KOHTpOJ1b

c ueRbIO COXpaHeHHA CTpyKTypHOrO u 6MOTW4ecKoro

pa3Hoo6pa3ll.q, 3a CMeT npOpyKTt4BHOCTH BO BpeMeH14 14

rpOCTpaHCTBe, 3KojiorwHecKoH 4jYHKUHOHaJ1bHOCTH tu

Ba)KHb1X npHpOaOOXpaHHbIX 4)YHKUHA.

3H,eMH3M: 3HaeMHmeCKHe BH4AbI - 3TO BHAbl, pacnpOCTpaHeHUe

KOTOpblX orpaH4'lHBaeTCs onpea1eAeHHor4 TeppUTOpieg unu1HperHoHoM.

Page 145: Russian - World Bank Documents

141

nPHJIO)KEHHA1

CTP.

*HpHAoxeHHe A: ATecHbie pecypcbi U niecHoe Xo33iACTBO ................................................ 142*npHjioKeHHe B: OpraHH3aUHoHHas cTpyKTypa .necHoro ceKTopa ................................. 180HPJiWoxeHHe B: Pa3BHTHe niecHoro 3aKOHoaaTeJIbCTBa B POCCUUiCKoUi $PeReparHH ..... 207flnpHAoKeHHe r: COCTOSHHe JieCOnpOMbIwjieHHOrO KoMrineKca, TOPrOBJIS, LUeHbI HHanTOrOBbIe nOCTYnneHHA .................

225npHunoAceHHC )I: 3HaMeHHe TpaHcnopTa H nOPTOBbIX coopyxKeHHl4 AAS YCTOr4HBoropa3BKTKA .leCOripOMbIljieHHOrO KOMnneKCa .................................................................. 257Hp4jiOKeHHe E: HPHBaTH3aUtHS B JieCHOM CeKTOPe H 3KOHOMH'eCKHe Pe4bOPMbl HaYPOBHe npeaHPKHTHH ..................................................................

264npH.io)KeH4e )K: YpOBeHb 6eaHocTH, 6e3pa6oTHua H CHcTeMa CouHajibHOR 3a1LLUTblB JIeCHbIX paiioHax ............................................................................................ 273npHjoOKeHHe 3: CHcTeMa oco6o OXpaHAIeMbiX fllppOAHbIX TeppHTOpid B paMKaXieCHOrO ceKTopa .................................................................

293HpHjiOxeHUe 14: YnpaB]eHHe pecypcamH aHK4X )KHBOTHbIX H YCTOq4HBOe Pa3BHTReneCHOrO ceKTopa .................................................................

297HpHjioKeHHe K: Me)UyHapOaHbli Orib[T yCnleWHOU peami3auim nporpamm noYCTOUiHBOMY Pa3BHTHIO ieCHOrO ceKTopa .................................................................. 311fpHJiOKeHHe JI: MeXayHaPOgHbie nPOrPaMMbl B JneCHOM ceKTOpe POCCHU ................. 330

Page 146: Russian - World Bank Documents

nPHJO)KEHHE A

JIECHblE PECYPCbl U JIECHOE X03SIRCTBO

PoccHsi ocBaHBaeT CBOUI 3anacbi neca (rocyaapcTBeHHbIi ieCHOri 4OHA) BOT yKe

Ha npoTHDKeHHH 200 AeT. JleCHOU 4OHa (TepMHH, aHaTOorHqHbliU aHlArHCKHM

cAoBocoqeTaHHRM "''eCHbIe 3eMH" Hunu "''eCHbie yroabq") BKJnoqaeT B ce651 Bce 3eMIH,

npHrOIHbie aJIi npOH3BOLCTBa neca HJI lo=xoaLIuHe aLis1 BeAeHIH AeCHoro xo3$sHcTBa.

JecHoA djOHA PoccHH BKlio'aeT npocTpaHCTBeHHYIO MO3aHKy paCTHTeCbHOCTH, BOAoeMOB,

ceTH aopor, HaceneHHbIx nyHKTOB H npOMHX O6ibeKTOB, Cd)OPMHPOBaHHbIX 4eAOBeqeCKOr

Xe.qTeJlbHOCTbIO H nlpHpOAHbIMH IIpOLeCCaMH B npeeienax AeCHOr4 3OHbl. 3Ta MO3aiKa

COCTOHT H3 pa3HbIX yqaCTKOB Cpeabi o6HTaHlif, 3KonIorHqeCKHX HHIU H yCAOBHi4 ,LRn

MHrpaLLuHH H pacpocTpaHeHHR paCTeHA H )KCHBOTHbIX. CTpyKTypa H COCTOAHHe ieCHOFO

4DoHIaa OnIpeaeJWqOT YPOBHH 6HO1OFrHMeCKOrO pa3Hoo6pa34H H yCTOriqHBOCTH pOCCUIUCKUX

3KOCHCTeCM.

JleCHOe Xo3gtICTBO Ha )eAepajibHOM YPOBHe

cDeaepanbHasI cAy3K6a AeCHoro XO3.iqrCTBa POCCuHu ocyiueCTBJ5IeT ynpaBneHHe

JieCHbIM (DOHLOM 4epe3 MeCTHbie AeCOXO3SrICTBeHHbie opraHbl (Jlecxo3bl). JecHoe

3aKOHo,aTeAbCTBO POCCHUiCKOA )DeaepaUHH qwiBneTcS npasBOBOu 6a3o0i opFaHH3auLHH U

Be,aeHH.s AeCHoro XO3uRCTBa. OCHoBaMH AeCHorO 3aKOHOaaTeJlbCTBa (1993 roxa) npeiiyc-

MaTpHBaeTC.q, qTO 4)eaepaJlbHoe npaBHTeAbCTBO o6SI3aHO OCyLueCTBAIqTb KOHTpOJIb 3a

COCTOAHHeM, Hcnonib3OBaHHCMe BocnpoH3BOACTBOM, OXpaHOA Ui 3aIuiHTog neCOB C TeM, {To6bI

o6ecne'rHTb co6IouAeHHe BCeMH noTpe6HTeASiMH ieCHbIX peCypCOB YCTaHOBJIeHHbIX JTeCHb!M

3aKoHoaaTenbCTBoM npaBHn H HOpM necononb3OBaH4RS, BeaeHHA IieCHoro xO3SriCTBa, BOC-

npoH3BOaCTBa, OXpaHbl H 3aWHTbl AeCOB, npaunBH rOCyLapCTBeHHOrO yqeTa H OTMeTHOCTH.

064as, XapaiK7VpNCTKa IeCHOIV 40oHAa

3eMIH AecHoro 4OHAa noapa3aeniqAOTCS1 Ha AeCHbIe H HeAeCHbIe. JeCHbie 3eMJIH

BKlioqa[oT Te nioLuaAuH, rie neca y)Ke pacTyT (ecTecTBeHHbIM o6pa3oM, HCTOpH4eCKI4 unJu

noca)KCeHbl npOMbIwJAeHHbIM cnoco6oM), H 3eMAH, KOTOpbIe HaXOaqTCq MC)Keay AecaMH, KaK

eCTeCTBeHHbi KOMnOHeHT LaHHOrO AiaHAwauaTa, H Ha KOTOpblX Jnec Mo)KeT Koraa-HH6yAb

nO5lBiTbCq. JeCHbie 3eMJIH MOrYT Ha MOMeHT yteTa OTHOC4TbCS nu60 K "rIOKpbITbiM AeCOM"

HAoLua8,aqM, nu60 K "He llOKpblTbIM ieCOM" nIOluaaRM. BbipaKeHHe "nIOKpblTaS ieCOM

HAOLuMllb" O3HaCaeT TO we caMoe, qTO nlOHHMaeTCfl BO BCeM MHpe nox CJIOBOM "Aeca". He

noKpbITbie AecoM nrIOuafH - 3TO BpeMeHHO HeCpOXyKTHBHbie JIeCHbie njioLiaaH,

BKJioiaioLume rapH, Bbipy6KH, CyXOCTOH, nYCTbIpH H peaKoAecbq THna nporaiiHH, nyCTOweJ

H peAIuH. K HeCAeCHbIM 3eMA1M OTHOCRTCS naXOTHbie 3eMAH, CeHOKOCHble yrOabq, HaCT6LUa,

Bo,aoeMbI (03epa, py'bH, peKH, npyabl, njiOTHHbI), caabl (oropoxabl, nHAOaOBbie caabl,

nHaHTauHH ueiKOBHuubI H ap.), aoporH, aoMa, )lBOpbl, 6oAoTa, neCKH, 3eMAH, nOKpblTble

jbaOM, H npo4He 3eMAH (BKIcnoqas HeAeCHbie 3eMAH, HMeCOLUHe onpeCenCeHHoe np4pOaHoe,

HCTOPHqeCKOe HAH 3KOHOMHqeCKOe 3HaqmeHe). nO aaHHbiM rOCyaapCTBeHHOrO y-IeTa

Page 147: Russian - World Bank Documents

143 H1PHA1OKEHHEA

_eCHOrO 4)OHza (Ha I S1HBaPfl 1993 roaa), nOKPblTaAl iecoM J1oLUaab pOCCHUCKHX AeCHbIX3eMenJb COCTaBnJeT 764 MJIH. ra, a o6uiasi noLuaab JieCHoro 4oH)la paBHa 1181 MnH. ra.

JeeCHOUi dOHA 3aHHMaeT OKOJIO 69% n-gOWa,aH CYwUH POCCUUH (BKJlfo'a3iBHyTpeHHHe BoaoeMb[). CoMKHyTbie nieca 3aHHMaiOT 43% TePPHTOPHH CTpaHbl, Hpt4 3TOM78% 3THX necOB paCTeT B CH6upH H Ha J7aabHeM BOCTOKe. roniee rOjiOBHHbl Bcex nTeCOBPOCCHH paCTeT Ha HH3KOnpOayKTIBHbIX Be'.HOMep3JIoTHbIX nO4BaX B Cu6upH U Ha )IaAbHeMBocToKe. OKono 247 MJIH. ra nIOKPbITO HH3KOnOJHOTHbIMH peaC,fHaMH H KycTaPHHKOBOrpacTHTenbHocTblo, a HH3KOCTBOJIbHbie HacLAeHH51 (V mJlacc 60HHTeTa) 3aHMtalOT OKOJIO 122MJIH. ra. 3aroToBKa Aeca (H ao6bltia He()TH H ra3a) MO)KeT Bb13blBaTb 3HaqHTeJIbHbIeH3MeHeHHA B cpeae npOH3pacTaHH51 paCTeHHr H o6KTaHISql XKKBOTHbIX. B ceBepHoH UcpeAHeA Tarire 6oJIbLHal 'aCTb 3eMeJIb B pe3yAbTaTe OCBoeHHR flnpi4poHbix peCypCOB H py6oKHnpeBpaTAiacb B HenpoayuHpyiowHe 3a6oJIo4eHHbie 3eMIH.

Cpe,HHri 3anac nieca Ha KOPHIO B JeCHOM boHHae POCCHH COCTaBnqleT 170 M3 /ra noXBOU4HbIM HacaxaeHfl4HlM, 130 M 3 /ra - nO TBepaoiIHcTBeHHbIM 1 80 M 3 /ra - noMflrKOJIHCTBeHHbIM nopoaaM aepeBbeB. CpeafHHli BO3paCT XBOHHblX nOpOA CoCTaBJIneT 6onee150 jieT, TBepaOAHCTBeHHbIX - 100 nIeT H M51rKOJI4CTBeHHbIX - 40 JIeT. nPOCTHpaSICb BaOJIbWUHpOTHbIX HO31COB C ceBepa Ha 1or, nieca AeJIlTCA1 Ha ciieayio1uHe 3oHbI: np14TYHaPOBaf(nepeXO,rHal 30Ha OT TyHapbl K TaeKHbIM, HJIH XBOHHbIM, niecaM), TaeKHasI (KoTopaf aaaieeno,apa3,aeIlAeTCM1 Ha CeBepHYIO, CpeAHI010 H IOXHYIO nOI3OHbl), 3OHa UHPOKOJIHCTBeHHbIXnecoB H niecocTenHaf (nepexoaHaq 3OHa Mex)ay JiecomM H CTerblo). OUeHKH noLua,ekKaxKIorl U3 3TUX 30H npHBOaqlTCA B Ta6JI. A.1.

Ta6ArnHa A. l. CooTHouIeHHe nnooaAer AeCOB rIpHTyHApoBOr4H TaeAHOI 30H, B %

I4oamH B o6,ueIg Hffomliaf aazo7r B o6&teI7 IMOMafa'f R4an B o6[eCi w0LowLiiw.fleCH8a 3oHa JIecHoIU oIlla IeCHJX 3eMefb i7OKPbITTMX AeCOM 3eMeffbflpliTYHapO3a. 3OHa 14,2 17,0 13,5CeBepHasI TaUra 10,0 9,0 8.6CPCAHSq TaUra 33,5 37,8 41,5IO)KHasq Tarira 18,1 20,0 20,4

MJCTOIYHHK ci(eaepaJTbHam cjiyK6a niecHoro Xo3qiACTBa Poccui, 1996 r.

F7pm7yHApoBIe .cca 5IBEui,oTc.q 4aCTb1O niecoB I rpynnbi, Hx rpaHHub1 onpeaeJIqfoTYCJIOBHYIO nieCOXO351ICTBeHHYIO o6naCTb. 9TH rpaH-UKHb He COBnaaalOT C rPaHHHUaMHJIeCoTyH,apoBoA 3OHbi, KOTOpafl ABJfleTCA eIHHHueLH reorpadJHqecKoro paH4OHHpOBaHHf. BHacTosLuee BpeMA Be,aeTCsI pa6oTa no onpeaeJIeHHlo rpaHHLK 6opeanbHot 3OHbi.npTyHHApOBble neca OXBaTblBalOT 100-150-KHnoMeTpoBblH (no WlUpHHe) nOSIC paCTH-TeAbHOCTH, KOTOpblI o6pa3yeT UWHpOTHblH riepexog OT Tae)KHbIX JieCOB K TyHLape.

npHTyHrapoBble nieca HMelOT 6oraTble 3anacbl ripecHoj BOabl H 9BJSIqIOTC5I MeCTOMo6HTaHHR MHOTHX BH4,aOB )KHBOTHbIX H rTHU. Bce nacT6Hiiua ceBepHoro oJieH5 Ha ceBepePOCCHH HaXOaRATCA HMeHHO B 3THX niecax; KpOMe TOrO, B paCnOjIO)KeHHbIX TaM BOaoeMaxCKOHLLeHTPHPOBaHbl OrpOMHbIe pbi6Hbie 3anacbl, a B CaMHX iiecax - 3HaqHTenjbHble 3anacblUeHHbIX HeRpeBeCHblX neCHbIX npOAYKTOB. 3mT niecHbie 3eMJ1H 6oraTbI TaK)Ke He43TbIO, ra3oM,yrJleM, )KeAe3HOA H nojiHMeTajuTlHeCKHMH M1 pyaaMH H apyrHMH nOj1e3Hb1MH HCKoraeMbIMH.

Page 148: Russian - World Bank Documents

144 nPHIIJO)KEHHE A

np4TyH,pOBbie ieca 51BSIOTCq eaHHCTBeHHbIM no'-Boo6pa3ylouHM 4aKTOPOM B pakoHax

KpauHero CeBepa.

np4TyHHppoBbie neca peaKo 6blBaloT ryCTbmIM. 3Xaecb npeBanjHpylOT OlHO5RpyCHbie

Haca)KaeHH51 C npOCTOri CTpYKTYPOH H nOpOaHbIM COCTaBOM, COCTOR5UMM Bcero H3

HeCKOJIbKHx nopoa aepeBbeB ('iaLue Bcero BcTpeCalOTC51 HacaA)aeHHS5, coRepcKaLUHe TOJIbKO

OAHY u4n1u gBe rOpO1bi). Ho mepe npO,4BH)KeHH5I Ha ceBep 1 BOCTOK paCT14TCejbHOCTb Ha

nIeCHbIX 3eMji5x CTaHOBHTCq 6ojiee CKyRHoA, BHlLOBOU COCTaB 6oJIee oaHoo6pa3HbiM, a nonior

HacaAcaeHHf4 - Bce 6o0ee pa3pexKeHHbIM, yMeHbHaeTC51 aHaMeTp aepeBbeB, CTBOjibi aepeBbeB

4aCTO RCedOpMHpOBaHbl. npeo6Jlauaiotui4MI BU Mam 3XaeCb 5qBWlqOTCW: j1CTBeHH4U,a (Larix

Gmelinii, L. Sukaczewii), eib (Picea obovata Ledeb.), 6epe3a (Betula cajanderi Sukacz.) u

KeLIpOBbl CT.iIaHHK (Pinuspumila Rgl.).

B 3TUX CeBCpHbIX paiOHax nO4BeHHbl nOKpOB UrpaeT 6o0ee Ba)KHYio pOJIb, 'eM

CaMm aepeBbl, y KOTOpbIX KOPHeBaS CHCTeMa pa3BHBaeTC5 nponOHOUlOHanJbHo 60nee

3KCTeHCHBHO, a apeBeCHblu CTBOJI - MeHee 3KCTeHCHBHO, no cpaBHeHu1lo C epeBb5MH B

6o0ee IO)KHblX paRoHax. HpOnyKTHBHOCTb HaCaeKm4HUU H 3anac nieca BeCbMa HeOAHOpOaHbI,

HO3TOMY B LenJoM npHTyHapOBble nieca HMelOT HH3KYIO HJ1H HynJeBylo KOMMep4eCKyiO

UeHHOCTb, TaK KaK HX HflolJaab py6KI COCTaBJS1eT Bcero 43 TbIC. ra B roa. EonbuWHe

TeppHTOPHH 3THX iecoB TpyaHOaOCTynHbI; MHOrHe y4aCTKH neca noTcTynaloT K XlOJIHHaM peK

H BbInOJ1HqIOT Ba)KHYIO 3aLUHTHYIO 4byHKUHIO.

nOpOnHbIA COCTaB ceBepHMx TaeXCbX JeCCOB B 3HaqI4TeJlbHog CTeneHH 3aBHCHT

OT MeCTa HX npo43pacTaHH4l. OCHOBHbIMU nopoaamM B BOCTOMHOA 4aCTH CTpaHbI qBJI5qOTC51:

JIHCTBCHHHUa, KeApOBbl CTjiaHHK U enJb cH6HpcKaS. nOMTH nOBCIOay 3XaeCb BCTpe'aIOTCH

TaloKe COCHa o6bIKHoBeHHaI U 6epe3a nyl4HCTa5. CpeAHHII 3anac apeBOCToeB B ceBepHb1X

Tae)KHbIX niecax peaKo npeBbiuwaeT 50 M3/ra. CaMble npoayKTHBHbie y4aCTKH neca

pacnoJIo)KeHbI B ,OJIHHax peK. 3TU neca, B OCHOBHOM, 4cnOJ1b3y[OTCq MeCTHb1M Hacen1eHHeM

aR.q 6blTOBbIX HYW4. KaK U B npHTYHApOBbIX niecax, B niecax 3TOrO THna HaH6o0JIbHyIo

ueHHOCTb npeaCTaBJI5eT uX 3awLHTHa2 (yHKgUI.

B zecax cpCgHil Ta7irif B OCHOBHOM pacTyT: JIHCTBeHHHua, en1b c46HpcKaS U

HeGoJblHOe KOjiMeCTBO nflXTbl cH6HpCKoA (Abies sibirica Ledeb.). CpeaH J1NCTBeHHb1X BH11OB

HaH6oJIee pacnpOCTpaHeHHbIMH qBJ15IIOTCq 6epe3a U OCuHa (Popululs tremula).

rlpOaYKTHBHOCTb 3TUX JIeCOB COCTaBjigeT OKOJIO 80-150 M 3 /ra ('ITO COOTBeTCTByeT B CpeaHeM

I11-My KJiaccy 6oHuTeTa), XOTA 3JaeCb BCTpCeaIOTCq U 6ojiee nPORYKT4BHbie y'aCTKH (II H I

mJIaCCbi 6oHHTeTa) c 6oraTbiMH, XOpOwO apeH4pOBaHHbIMH nOoBaMH. Jleca cpeaHeg TamrH

noaBepraIoTcR HHTeHCHBHOU 3KcnHjyaTauL4, OCHOBHblC of6eMbi CnJIOUHb[X py6oK

CKOHUeHTPHPOBaHb1 HMeHHO 3XaeCb.

ffeca JOKHOif laIif COCTORT 143 BbICoKoKa'eCTBeHHbIX Haca)IeHtiI enu

o6blKHOBeHHOR, enIu Cc6HpcKoi, COCHbI, 6epe3bl nywL4CTOI, 6epe3bl riJaKy e1 (Betula

pendula) H OCUHbl. npH 6iiaronpH4HTHbIx YCJ1OBHSX 3TUT BHabl MOrYT LOCTHraTb I H la KJiaCCOB

60HHTeTa. npOaYKTHBHOCTb 3THX Haca)IeHHH xapaKTep43yeTCq 3anacoM no o6beMy Ao

200-250 M3 /ra H 6o0ee.

Page 149: Russian - World Bank Documents

145 1PlIJO)KEHHE A

KYaccifoifKaL(mv JIecoB

BeaeHHe necHoro X03SHCTBa rpeaycMaTp4BaeT orpeaefleHHblg KOMnineKC 3aLUHT-HbIX, rTpOH3BOACTBeHHbIX H ripHpoaooxpaHHbix ieCOXo3qriCTBeHHbIX MeporpHAsTHM, KOTOpbIeHe aOJ1KHbl HaHOCHTb Bpea OKpy)KaiomeH cpeae, )KHBOTHOMY MHPy H 3AOpOBb1O qejToBeKa.n[pH BeaeHHH jiecHoro X03AHCTBa Heo6XoaiHMo o6ecneqHBaTb:

* CoxpaHeHHe H pa3BHTHe 3KoJIorH4ecKHX, BOaOperyAHpyioLuHx, 3aHIHTHbIX,caHHTapHO-rHrHeHH'ieCKHX H )IpyrHx nojie3HblX qyHKUIHui AeCOB BHHTepeCaX OXpaHbI 3LaOpOBbq -enioBeKa.

* MHorouenleBoe HeHCTOIIHTeSJbHOe H paUHOHanJbHoe HCnOJIb3OBaHHe nIeCOB,HanpaBj1eHHoe Ha yaoBjieTBopeHRe noTpe6HocTeH 3KOHOMHKH CTpaHbl H eerpa)IaH B apeBecHHe H apyrHx neCHbIX npoRyKTax.

* BocrpoH3BoaCTBo H yjYMyqeHHe BHX4OBOrU CTpyKTypbl, rOBbIWeHHe Ka'eCTBaH HPpOaYKTHBHOCTH nIeCOB, HX 3aLuTy H OxpaHy.

* Co6fiozaeHe HpHHLuHrOB, Ae)KaILH4X B OCHOBe nOJIHTHKH yCTOrPqHBOrOpa3BHTHA, H BHeapeHHe LOCTH)KeHHH HayKH, TeXHHKH H nepeaoBoro OrbITaC LueJblO rOBbiweIIHH5 34"eKTHBHOCTH ynpaBneHHq JIecaMH.

* CoxpaHeHHe 6HoJorH4ecKoro, HCTOpH4eCKorO, KYJIbTypHOrO H npHpOaHOrOHacJie,aHA.

Bce neca JiecHoro foHaa aeji5TC5 Ha TpH 6OJIbLUHe rpynibI (I, 11 H 111) H ceMbKaTerOpHH B COOTBeTCTBHH C HX YPOBHMiMH 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3HH, 3KOJTorH'IeCKHMH HCOuLHaJbHbIMH q3YHKUHqMH H MeCTOM npoH3paCTaHHM. KpHTepHH OTHeCeHHA neCOB K TeMHJIH HHbIM rpyrinaM H KaTeropH5IM 3aLUtiTHOCTH, a TaioKe nepeBoaa nieCoB H3 OaHOA rpynnrHA14 KaTerOpHH B apyrylO, paCC'IHTbIBalOTCS Ha OCHOBe aaHHbIX JTeCoycTpoHCTBa. 9Ta KJac-CH14HKaLuHM onpeaenqeT o6muHe HaipaBJIeHHA H RopUIOK BeaeHHa niecHoro Xo303iCTBa,BKJlIO4iSa pa3peweHHbie THnbl py6oK (caHHTapHble py6KH, py6KH ripoMeKyTO'qHoronOjib3oBaHHH HuH py6KH rniaBHoro nOJIb3oBaHHI).

Jleca I rpyuimi: oxpaHifeMbie nieca. Jleca I rpynnbi oxpaHAIIOTC no3KOJIOrHqeCKHM npH'q-HHaM. K I rpynne OTHOCSTCS He3KcrJIyaTauLHOHHbie nieca,BblHlOJTHIOLLuHe npHpOaOOXpaHHble, BoaoOXpaHHbie H peKpea HOHHble 4yHKLUHH. 3Laecbpa3peuieHbi TOJIbKO CaHHTapHbie py6KH, BKlio4qaoLJLHe BbIpy6Ky aepeBbeB, BO3paCT KOTOpbIXHa 50 JneT npeBbILaeT OHTHMaIbHbIl BO3paCT py6KH. Jleca I rpynrnbl aeJiRTC5I Ha 5 KaTeropHA3aLUHTHOCTH:

* Boao3aLuTHbie nieca rio 6eperaM peK, 03ep H BO,4XpaHHJ1HWU H B paHOHaxHepeCTHJ4HLU pbl6.

* HpOTHBO3pO3HOHHbie iieca H AeCO3aLUHTHbie nOJIOCbl Ha KpYTb[X CKJIOHaX,CeJTbCKOX03SHCTBeHHbIX 3eMJI5X, BaOJIb aopor H Ha nyCTbIHHbIXTeppHTOpHAX.

* Jleca 3eCJeHbIX 30H BOKpyr rOPOaOB H npOMblwJIeHHb1X KOMiTAeKCOB,ripe,aHa3HaqeHHbie L1J1H 3aLUHTbl JilOLerl OT 3aFpq3HeHHOFO Bo3AyXa.

11 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ - - - -- - - -- -

Page 150: Russian - World Bank Documents

146 HPHJO)KEHHE A

* Oco6o oxpaHRembie Tepp4Top414, Hanpumep ueHHbie JleCHbie MacCIBbl,

jieca, HMelou.He Hay4Hoe unu HCTOpHmxecKoe 3HaqeHHe, opexoBo-npoMbic-

hOBble 3OHbl, neca HIpHTyHapOBO4 3OHbl U T.l.

* Jeca npHpoaooxpaHHoro 4)OHaa (npHpoxRHbie 3anoBeAHMKH, 3anoBeAHble

AecHble y'aCTKH H HaUlHOHaJIbHbte napKH).

Jleca 11 rpymmi: oxpaHiembie iieca c OFpaHHveHHMim 3KCiwya7aLJWoHHmm

3HaqeHHeM. Jleca II rpynnbI oxpaH5IIOTCq B CBq3H C MX ripoMblwjieHHO H peKpeau1MOHHOi

UeHHOCTbIO. 9TH neca HaXOaSTCq B MaJIoJAeCHbIX H rycTOHacenJeHHbIX paIloHax. K HUM

OTHOCATCH nieca, HMeKoUHe orpaHH4eHHoe 3KCnnyaTaLUu40HHoe 3Ha'eHMe, rae py6KM

rilaBHoro nI0b3OBaHHl pa3peinaioTcs TOAbKO npH YCJIOBHH co6JIoaeHH5i nplHfHHna

HeHCTOLUHTejibHoro, HenpepblBHoro nOJib3oBaHHq. OHM MorYT BKJlio4aTb nnoLiaaH niecoB

oco6eHHo MyBCTBHTeJIbHbI K BHeLHHHM BO3,aeACTBHRM (HanpMmep pacnoj1oxeHHbIX BaoAb

6eperoB peK), rae nOJIHOCTbIO 3anpelueHbl CnJIOWHbIe py6KH.

ffeca III ipyliM: 3KC1cyaz/ momeHHMC nIeca. Jleca III rpynnbi npeAHa3HaqeHbl AIAs

nIpoMbiUwAeHHoro HCnOJlb3oBaHHUI. OHM pa3XtejiI5OTCH Ha peH3epBHbe H OCBoeHHbie nieca.

Pe3epBHble nieca He noaIie)KaT npoMbiwLLeHHOMY OCBoeHHIO H3-3a CBoeri oT,aJIeHHOCTH HJIH

HeAOCTynHOCTH. Jleca III rpynHbl, HpOH3paCTalO1uHe B MHOro0jeCHbIX paiOHaX, MoryT

BblnOJIHfTb HeCKOJIbKO 4)YHKUUH, OCHOBHOA U3 KOTOpbIX ABAileTCl npOH3BOaCTBO aeJAOBOrU

,apeBeCHHbl. 3,aeCb pa3pemeHbI py6KH rJiaBHoro HoJlb3OBaHMH. 06'beMbl py6oK o6blqHO

onipe)iejisnOTCs ClpOCOM Ha apeBeCHHy CO CTOpOHbi JTeCOnpOMbilwJeHHbIX OTpaCJieU. 3TH neca

Toxe MOrYT BKJno4aTb 4yBCTBHTenbHbie K BHeWHHHM BO3aeACTBHS1M y4aCTKH (HanpuMep

B2IOAb peK), rae nOAHOCTbIO 3anpeuCeHblCnJIOUHble py6Ku.

I1OMHMO TaKoro aeJIeHH4I JieCOB Ha TpM 60JbWLHe rpylnllbl, B OCHOBe

xapaKTepHCTHKH U aHaJIH3a niecoB CH6HpM H UanlbHero BocToKa H ynpaBJIeHH5 HmH Jle)K aT

necopaCT4TenbHbie paUOHbl. JeCHoe pauoHupoBaHHe OCHOBaHO Ha KJaCCH MUKaLHH

HepapxUMeCKHx eAHH4U, OAHOpOAHblX nO CBOHM JieCOpaCTMTeJbHbIM yCJIOBHUIM,

3KOAOrH4eCKHM H nptppOaHbIM CBOACTBaM, TonoflorHqecKou CTpyKType, npOayKT4BHOCTH u

BHAOBOMy CocTaBy, a TaK)Ke no CBOeMY 3KOHOMHqeCKOMy H COUHanJbHOMY 3Ha'eHHIo.

OCHOBHbIMU BHaaMH pagOHHPOBaHHS 5BnIOTCS IieCopaCTMTeJIbHoe, JieCO3KOHOMH4eCKOe H

iieCOXo39rCTBeHHoe parioHHpoaHue. JIeCoXo35lACTBeHHoe pauoHupoBaHue He coBna.LlaeT C

aBMHHHCTPaTHBHbIMH rpaHHUaMH TeppHTOp1H H nloapa3.geiAseT 3TH TeppHTOpUH Ha

cJieAyloLLHe rpynnbl Xo3RflCTBeHHO-TeppHTopHaJIbHblx eaL4HHU (IIASA 1995):

CH6HpLb 4aa/hHHI BoCTOK

5 o6jiacTeg 8 o6jiacTeA

17 OKpyrOB 22 oKpyra

49 JieCOXo3SAfCTBeHHbIX palioHoB 44 iieCOXo3S.qiCTBeHHbIX par4oHa

Anqs necoB Cu6upu H aajlbHero BocToKa cyLueCTBYIOT noapo6Hble HaylHbie

onHcaHHA n1eCHbIX CHCTeM H HX 3KOJlortHMeCKHX c1YHKULiA, a TaKwe cxeMbl KmaccwH4KauMH

Page 151: Russian - World Bank Documents

147 HPHAO)KEHHE A

3THX JlecOB, npeaCTaBJlAIOUHe aOCTaTO4HO noapo6Hbie TeopeTHqeCKUe pa3pa6oTKH H 4IaHHbleHayMqHbIX HccjieLOBaHHA 3aKjiaabIalOIUHe OCHOBy AAS ynpasBeHHA jlecaMH.

CNcTCa yema ffecoB

CHCTeMa yqeTa niecoB npeano.laraeT rpoBeaeHHe pa6oT fieCOYCTpOHTejbHb1MHOpraHH3aUHAMH, HHBeHTaPH3aULUO ntecoB H rOCyaAPCTBeHHb1U yqeT JleCHoro 4IoHaa.

TpHHa,auaTb rOCyaapCTBeHHbIX JICCOyCTPOH7WLHMN Hpe4JpHRTA 3aHHMalOTCSC6opoM U aHajiH3OM aaHHbiX, noAy'IeHHbIX B xoae nHBeHTaPH3aUHH necoB, nO BCer CTpaHe.KaxAoe JiecoycTpoHTenbHoe npeanpHATHe o6cnyicHBaeT nuJOLuaab, paBHYIO npHMepHo 37MJIH. ra. B 3aBHCHMOCTH OT THna J1eCOXO3ARCTBeHHO aeSATeAbHOCTH Ha aaHHOR rioLWauH,JiecoycTporlCTBo nPOBOAHTCA BO Bcex noapa32LejieHISAX iiecoynpaBjieHHA C nepHOAUHqHOCTbIO10-20 J1eT. 9TH HHBeHTaPH3aUHOHHbie H neCOYCTPOHTenbHbie aaHHble HCnOJIb3ylOTCA IAnpa3pa6oTKH neCOyCTpOHTenJbHbIX npoeKTOB ~WA KaWO H3 TeppHTopHr, Ha KOTOpblXHPOH3BO,aHTCS JiecoCHOJb3OBaHHe ((DeaepanbHaA cjly)K6a jiecHoro Xo3SIflCTBa, 1994 roa).

fHBseHampH3aLH necoB HpOBOAUHTCA AnS nojy1MeHHA CTaTHCTHqeCKHX aaHHb1X nOn1UouaAH nieCOB, 3anacy ieca Ha KOpHIO, BHAOBOMy COCTaBy, BO3paCTHOH CTpyKType HapyrHM napameTpam iieCHoro 4joHaa. IIHBeHTaPH3aUHOHHbIe AaHHble o6ecneqtHaloT TaKweHH4opMaUH1O o6 H3MeHeHHS1X B COCTOSHHH JieCHoro 4bOHHa, BKJlO'oaq OUeHKH BJIHSHHURX03ArUCTBeHHOr4 aesTeJlbHOCTH, Ho)KapOB, HaBOMHeHHA, BpeRHTeniie H 6oJle3HeU. 3TaHH4)OpMaUiH4 nepeaaeTcs Ha perHOHaJ]bHblri H qeaepajibHblrl YPOBHH ynpasBjeHHH J1eCHbIMX03SHCTBOM B 4)opMe Ta6AHU C He6oJIbIlUHMH KapTorpa(4bHtecKHM Hunu aHlaAHTHqeCKHMHnpHJoKceHHuAMH HuH 6e3 TaKOBbIX.

B OTJIH4He OT 60JIbWIHHCTBa apyrHx CTpaH, 6oraTblx fleCHb1MH pecypcaMH, BPOCCHH OTCYTCTByeT CHCTeMa HHBeHTaPH3auHH, KoTopaS OXBaTbIBanJa 6bl Bce niecHbieniolua,zH. IocyAapcTBeHHmII yqeT JiecHoro OH4a B 3TORi CBA3H OCHOBb1BaeTCS HanepHoxuHqecKoAi 3KCTpanoJIsuHH aaHHblx, noJ1yqeHHbIX B xoae J1ecoycTporiCTBa, Ha nieca, noKOTOPbIM OqIHuH4ajibHbie necoycTpoHTenbHble aHHbie, paBHO KaK H aoKyMeHTaBJbHO3a(DHKCHpoBaHHbie UaHHble o6 H3MeHeHHAX OTCyTCTByIOT, a TaoKce Ha aaHHbIX CHHMKOB,roAyM4eHHb1X perHoHa.JbHbIMH iieCOYCTPOHTenbHbIMH npeAnpHqTHqMH. OLUeHKH COCTOS1HHRAeCOB H HHBeHTapH3aUUHH JeCHbIX peCypCOB llpOBOAsTCA BM3yaJAbHO, 4TO YBeJIH4HBaeTBePORTHOCTb cHcTeMaTHieCKHX OUWH6OK, oco6eHHo ipu4 oLjeHKe 3anaca neca Ha KOpHIO, noCpaBHeHH[O C OueHKaMH, npOBOaHMbIMH C rOMOlUblO cneHUHaJbHbIX HHCTpyMeHTOB. PeweHHAnO YCTaHOBJneHHIO ueHHOCTH pa3nIH4Hbix aTpH6yTOB apeBocToeB npuHHuMalOTC oTReJ]bHopa3Hb1MH YpOBHAMH ynipaBjieHHU (d)eaepaAbHbIM, perUlOHaJIbHbIM, paUOHHb1M), 'TO HpHBORHTK HpOTHBOpeCMHiM B 6a3e aaHHbIx. HcnoJnb3yeMas ceroHSA MeToXonjorHA c6opa H3KCTpaIOJIASU14H aaHHbIX no nieCHbIM pecypcam aaeT HeynoBMeTBOPHTeAbHYIO HHbopMaUlHIO oJ1eCHOM 43OHae PoccHH, OCO6eHHO 3TO KacaeTCA oUeHOK o6iuero 3anaca neca, npHpocTa HnpO,YKTHBHOCTH Haca),eHHH, a TaK)Ke npOyKTHBHOCTH .JeCHbIX 3eMeJIb.

I4HBeHTapH3aUHA, 3aBepwueHHaA I AHBaPS 1993 rojaa, noKa3aJia, WTO nH0I1LUabnIecHoro boHaa, Ha KOTOpOUi iiecHoe X03SlflCTBO BeieTcs 4beaepaflbHbiMH opraHaMHyripaBJieHHS, Ha TOT MOMeHT cocTaBaJlia 729,7 MJIH. ra, HnH 62% o6ineu njiowauH AeCHoro

Page 152: Russian - World Bank Documents

148 nPHJ]OKEHIIE A

(c)OHaa. OCTaJIbHbie 38% (451,2 MJIH. ra) - 3TO nlJiOUiuaaH, Ha KOTOpbIX iieCHoe XO3TOCTBO

BoofUte He BeJIOCb, H HO HUM HeT HHKaKOrO aOKyMeHTaSjbHOrO y'leTa, T.e. 3TH njioiu.aaK

OueHHBaZJHCb TOhbKO Ha OCHOBaHHI a3pOTaKCauHOHHbIX BH3yaAbHb1X Ha6juoaeHHA H

HHTepnpeTaguLH a3PO4bOTOCHHMKOB. K fleCHbIM 3eMjiSM, Ha KOTOpbIX ATeCHOe X03HUACTBO

Boo6iue He BeAeTCq, OTHOCHTCH TpyaHOaOCTynHbIe nHjoLuaaH, oco6eHHO B CH6UpU H Ha

al,AbHeM BOCTOKe (nOITH nOh1OBHHa Bcerl TeppHTOPUH BOCTOqHO-CU6HpCKOrO 3KOHO-

MHqeCKOrO perloHa H 3HaqHTeJIbHo 6oAbuLe HOJIOBHHbI TeppUTOPHUU JaajbHeBOCTOqHOrO

3KOHOMH4eCKOrO perHoHa).

JlecoycTpoHcTBo

TpHHa,LuaTb rOCyalapCTBeHHbIX ieCOyCTpOHTeAJbHbIX npenp4pHATHir OTBeKlalOT 3a

npOBe,aeHHe HHBeHTapH3aUHUH neCOB, HaA30p 3a ieCoxO3AACTBeHHOri aleTeAbHOCTbIO 14

HOArOTOBKy AeCOYCTPOHTenJbHbIX nIpOeKTOB pIAH JieCX030B (CM. Ta6ni. A.2). JIecHa5i nHJOutaab

Kai)K1OrO AeCXo3a aeJIHTC51 Ha KBapTaJIbI, pa3mep KOTOpblX o6blwHO paBeH I KM X 2 KM (200ra), XOTA UX pa3Mep MO)KeT 6blTb OT 0,5 X 0,5 KM go 2 x 4 KM, B 3aBHCHMOCTH OT T4na,

JieCOyCTpOAcTBa. JI,AA Ha4aJlbHOfi KJiaCC4d)HKaLjUm neca no 6o.nee HJIH meHee OfaHOpOAHbIM

HaCaKIIeHHAM HCnOJIb3ylOT a3pO4OTOCHHMKH. 3aTeM 14HxeHepbl-TaKcaTOpbl Ha MeCTe

OueHHBalOT nOTeHuHanJI u COCTOAHHe COOTBeTCTBY1O1Lero niecHoro MaccHBa. 3TOT MeTOA He

npe,anonaraeT HCHOJIb3OBaHH51 ynHOpaoqeHHO pa3MeHueHHbIX 3KCnepUMeHTaJTbHbIX

njiowua,aerl. lCcnOJIb3yq CBOPI npaKTH4eCKi4r OllbIT, TaKCaTOpbI BH3yaAJbHOonlpeIIejI5iOT TaKHe

napaMeTpbl, KaK B03paCT, CyMMa njoiu.aaeg ceqeHHI4 u of6em, 6iiaroRaps5 CBOeMy OnbITY H

nO,XrOTOBKe. HpaKTHKa nOKa3blBaeT, 'ITO TO4lHOCTb TaKOR OUeHKH COCTaBJIHeT nJIlOC-MUHyC

10%. 3aTeM 3Ta HHj3OpMaUUH BBO,I[TCH B KOMnblOTepHy1O 6a3y aaHHbIX.

Ta6.nHUa A.2. JlecoycTpowemIbHbie npeAnptS1THi Poccuu

)wM Ha3wrne 17p"gp,iirrr_ MecwHaxoxaeHe

I 1leHTpanbHoe r. MOCKBa

2 MocKoBcKoe r. WUep6uHKa, MOCKOBCKasq o6ni.

3 3anaaHoe r. EpnHCK, BpIHCKas o6n.

4 CeBepo-3anaaHoe r. CaHKT-rleTep6ypr, JleHHHrpaacKa%i o6n.

5 CeBepiioe r. Bojioria, BonoroacKas o6n.

6 KapenbcKoe r. fleTpo3aBojcK, Pecny6AmKa Kapejis

7 BopoHeIulecnpoeiT r. BopoHe)K, BopoHeWcKas1 o6jn.

8 Boi)kcKoe r. HUiKH)M HoBropoa, HHuxeropoacKasI o6ii.

9 3anaaiio-CH6mpCKoe r. HOBOCU6UPCK, HoBocti6HpcKaq o6n.

10 BocToMHo-CH6HpcKoe r. KpacHoIpcK, KpacHo5IpcKKHr Kpari

II flpI6aAKanbcKoe r. HPKYTCK, HPKyrCKaSq o6n.

12 AMYPCKoe r. Co6oaHb1ir, AMyPCKaS o6n.i

13 JPaanbHeBOCTO'Hoe r. Xa6apOBCK, Xa6apoBcKHiA Kpaui

PICTovHIIK: OeaepaAbHam c.nyiK6a JiecHoro xo3s9iicTBa POCCHU, 1996 roa.

Pac4eTHaHi necoceKa onpelaeJneTcA Ha OCHOBaHH14 JIeCOYCTPOHTeSjbHbIX aaHHbIX U

HcnOflb3yeTC51 KaK OCHOBa anA JTecoycTpoHTenJbHoro npoeKTa. B xoae peaJi3maUH

Page 153: Russian - World Bank Documents

149 nPHIIO)KEHHE A

iieCOYCTPOHTeAbHbix nporpamM TaKwe onpeaeflIoTcq o6fembi iu paioHbI npoDeaeHHAKOHKpeTHbIX MeponpI4THII nO BOCCTaHOBJAeHHIO JlecOB. B JIecoycTpoHTeJIbHbil npoeKTo6blqHO BKJlio4eHbl U apyrHe MeponpH4THA, HanpHMep nJiaHHPOBaHHe U CTpoHTejIbCTBOaopor. OCHOBHaA uejib J1eCOyCTPOiCTBa H COCTaBjieHRA JiecoycTpo0TenjbHoro npoeKTa3aKciioqaeTcA B onpefejieHHH 3anaca nIeca Ha KOpHio no nopodaM U rpynnam nIecOB AAAYCTaHOBAneHHA pa3MepOB pacqeTHoA niecoceKH, a He LIA5 COcTaBJIeHHA HeKoero eaHHoroniiaHa yrpanBeHHA sceu AecHOA 3KOCHCTeMOU.

PacqeTHaA JIecOceKa paCc-iHTbIBaeTCH, HCXOAA H3 o6wero 6HoJIorHMecKoro o6beMajiecoB. B Xa6apoBcKoM Kpae, HanpHMep, pacqeTHasi necoceKa 6bma onpeaeneHa B o6ieMe 56MJIH. M 3 . Ho TOJIbKO nOJIOBHHa 9Toro o6beMa ABnAfeTC51 3KOHOMH4eCKH4 aOCTynHOR, a U3 HeroTOJIbKO TpeTb (OKOAO 10 MJIH. M 3 ) npeacTaBJsIeT KOMMep4eCKyiO UeHHOCTb, ecni y4eCTbcyuLeCTByIOLuee .TeCo3arOTOBHTeAbHoe o6OpyaoBaHHe, MeTO,bil JecO3arOTOBKH, CTPYKTYPYHacaAKLeHHf H noTpe6HOCTH pbIHKa. B pe3ynJbTaTe 6oAbmHe o6beMbl cpy6JTeHHOA apeBeC4HblOCTalOTCA B necy KaK TaK Ha3blBaeMbie "Jecoce'Hbie OTXOabl". O0HU4anbHbie aaHHbie HoqjaKTw44eCKlM o6ieMaM py6KH O rOBOPAT o TOM, 'TO o6iuHk o6ibeM BbIBe3eHHOh U3 necaapeBecHHbl B Xa6apoBcKoM Kpae COCTaBJMeT 6 MJIH. M3. (DaKTpteeCKHt o6beM py6KHYqHTbIBaeT TOIbKO Ty apeBecHHy, KOTOpaA 6bUIa BbIBC3eHa 13 nieca, a He o6beM baKTH4eCKHcpy6AeHHoro neca, KOTOpbli Mo)KeT 6bITb HaMHOrO 60.zbwe (Ha 20-25% B o6lueM, a BHeKOTOpbIX ciyiasx Ha - 100%). B npowjmoM neconoJb3OBaTeniH nAaTuuHJI TOJIbKO 3aJ1peBecHHY y)Ke BbIBe3eHHYIO H3 neca, a He 3a baKTH4eCKH cpy6neHHblI4 ee o6feM. CeroAHAOHH niiaT5T noreHHYIO nAaTy, CTaBKH KOTOpOU oqeHb HH3KH, 'TO BeaeT K HcnOJIb3OBaHH1OHe3KOHOMHbIX croco6OB neCO3aroToBKH. Ho HeCMOTpA Ha TO, qTO (baKTKqeCKl4l of6eMpy6KH COCTaBIAeT TOJIbKO 10% paCqeTHOH niecoceKH (6 U3 56 MJH. M 3 ), B HeKOTOpbIXpar4oHax MoryT Ha6juoaaTbcs cepbe3HbIe nepepy6bl. TaK B KpacHoRpcKoM Kpae B HaCToqLueeBpeMSA HCnOJb3yeTCH Bcero 15% 6HoAorH'ecKori pacqeTHou TiiecoceKH.

JleCOyCTpOHTeJlbHbie ipoeKTbi COCTaBJISIOTCH Ha repHioa OT 10 'O 20 Jie. 0oHe,aaBHerO BpeMeHH B niecXo3e 6bmI TOJIbKO Oal4H 3K3eMnJIAP iiecoycTpOHTejibHoro npoeKTa,eLue OaHH 3K3eMHJIASP - B KpaeBOM yrpaBjieHHH H O,HH - B rocyaapCTBeHHOM opraHe noJ1ecHoH cTaTHcTHKe. B 6brBweM CCCP J1ecoycTpoHTenJbHbie npoeKTbi 6buIH O4DHL4ajibHbiM41aoKyMeHTaMH, HeaOCTYnHbIMH ISA HaceiieHHS4. JIeCHoe 3aKOHoaaTejibCTBO 1993 roaa caeflano3Ty HH4HopMauImo aOCTYHHOH4 A opraHI3aui g H rpaAnaH. Cor.nacHo 3TOMY3aKoHo,aaTeJIbcTBy, nieCOyCTpOHTeJIbHbie npOeKTbi AOJDKHbl BKJHO4aTb MepbI no o6ecne'eHHbo39 "eKTIBHOrO BeaeHHA niecHoro X035IACTBa, pauuoHanJbHOrO HCnOJIb3OBaHHS iieCHbIXpeCypCOB, BOcnpOH3BOaCTBa, OXpaHbl H 3aLUHTbI JneCOB H OCyLL!eCTBJ1eHHIo eaHHOrU HayIHO-TeXH4UqCKOH noJIHTHKH B JIeCHOM XO3SHCTBe:

* OripeaefleHHe rpaHLuU H BHyTpeHHeri CTpYKTypbl TeppHTOPHH niecHorocjOHna.

* BblnOJIHeHHe Tonorpacbo-reoae3HqecKHX pa6oT H cneU4aJIbHoe KapTorpa-4)HUOBaHHe neCOB.

* IIHBeHTapH3auHIO iecHoro cbOHaa c onpeaeAeHHeM npOLIHoro HB03paCTHOrO COCTaBa JIeCOB, HX COCTOSHHS, a TaKwe Ka'ieCTBeHHbIX HKOJIH'eCTBeHHb[X XapaKTepCCTHK JieCHbIX peCypCOB.

* BbISBJIeHHe y'aCTKOB .teCHOrO c1OHaa, Hy)KaliOUHXCS B HPOBCeeH4H py6OKH MeponpHSTHA no IeCOBOCCTaHOBjieHI4O H Aecopa3BeaeHHlO, BKJ]io4SaBbISBjieHHe HuioLuageC, Tpe6yloLUHx npoBeaeHHS4 py6oK rJiaBHoro HOnIb3O-

Page 154: Russian - World Bank Documents

150 HlPHAO)KEHHE A

BaHH5I H py6oK npoMeXKYTO4qHoro noJIb3oBaHH2, a TaKwKe MeponpH5ITHu no

BOCnppO43BOACTBy, MeJHopauuHH, oxpaHe H 3aIlHTe nIecoB.

* O6ocHoBaHHe KpHTepHeB, HCHOJIb3yeMbIX An,0I OTHeceHH5 JieCOB K rpynnaM

H KaTeropuHM 3alluHTHOCTH, H nOarOTOBKa npeAno)KeHHi 0 nepeBoae niecoB

13 OAHOA rpynnbi Hnu KaTeropnH 3alUHTHOCTH B apyryio.

* Onpej4eieHHe o6beMa MeponpSiTHfui no JIecoBoccTaHoBjieHHio H iiecopa3-

BeAeHHIO, oxpaHe JIeCOB OT lO)KapOB H HX 3aLUHTe OT BpeaHTeieri H

6one3Her.

* OnpeeneneHHe pa3mepa nOAb3OBaHH5 AeCHbMM d3OHAOM AA, HY)KA

OXOTHH'berO X035IiCTBa H KyJIbTypHO-03napOBHTeJIbHbIX H TYPHCTHUeCKHX

LejIerl, a TaKwKe uieneu coxpaHeHHii 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3wl.

* JIeco6HojiorH4ecKHe H apyrHe cneJu1anjbHbIe o6cAeaoBaHI4.q.

* Ha,430p 3a ocyWeCTBjieHHeM JIecoycTpoHTeIbHbIX npoeKTOB H pa6oT.

JIecHNe Kapm

KapTbi pOCCHtCKHX necoB MOXKHO pa3,aegJHTb Ha cJe,lyiouLHe KaTeropHH

(JlecoycTpoHTenbHa5s HHCTPYKLUSH, 1994 roa): iiecoycTpoHTeCJbHbie nHIaHiueTbl, nHaHbI AeCHH-

qeCTB, nfiaHbl Haca)KAeHH IieCHHMeCTB, KapTbl 3KcnrUyaTauHoHHoro 4oOHaa, KapTbl-CxeMbI

AeCXo30B, CXeMbI npOTHBOnO)KapHbIX MeponpHuTH4 JieCXo30B, KapTbl-CXeMbI a,aMH-

HHcTpaTHBHOR CTPyKTypbl H KapTa necoB CCCP 1990 roaa. XOTS B HeKOTOPbIX AecXo3ax

Y)Ke Ha,HHa]OT COCTaBJI5Tb KOMnblOTepHbie KapTbl, 6oAbluHHCTBO KaPT COCTaBJqeTCS

TpaLHUIiOHHbIMH MeTOAaMH Ha 6yMare.

JccoycpomwmHmc IaH1JCT. JIcoycTpoHTeJIbHbir nIiaHweT ABjiqeTCq

OCHOBHOU1 JieCHOui KapTor, CoCTaBAReMoo C nOMOUbio reoae3HMeCK4X HJI TOiorpa4bHqeCKHX

,DaHHbIX. MaCITa6bi 3THX KaPT PaBHbl 1:10.000 xiq I H 11 Pa3Pa3fOB iieCOYCTPOACTBa H

1:25.000 - urn III pa3pqaa JiecoycTpolrCTBa. papyrHe JieCHbIe KapTbI cocTaBnqlOTcq, KaK

npaBHjio, cnoco6om MOHTax(a yMeHbUweHHbIX KOnHri KapT 6o0iee KpynHoro MacWITa6a.

HOnHOCTbIO COCTaBjieHHblU opHirHHaii nnaHweTa o6bIMHO COaep)KHT KBapTanjbHbIe npoceKH H

rpaHHL1bI KBapTaJIOB, TaKCaUHOHHbie BU3Hpbl, rpaHHLLbl TaKCaLLHOHHbIX BbileAOB,

nOCTO.qHHbie npo6Hbie nIoLuaAH, nHTOMHHKH, JTecoceMeHHbIe y'aCTKH, 3anOBeaHbIe AeCHbie

o6beKTbi, nojiocbI OTqy)feHHS MarHCTpaJlbHbIX nyTeU TpaHcnopTa, npoe3)KHe AeCHble

1AoporH, nOCTOAHHbie Tponbi, pyMbH, peKH, MeAHOpaTHBHbie KaHanbl, 03epa, KpaH OBparoB H

o6pbIBOB (a TaioKe JAHHH Boaopa3JaejiOB B rOpHbIX paIUOHax), KOJIHMeCTBO H nHAoIlaRH

KBapTaJIOB H Bbil[eAOB, Ha3BaHHA peK, 03ep H KpyrHHbIX pyMbeB, rpaHHUbI a,MHHHCTpaTHBHbIX

paZoHoB, KaTeropiH 3aLuHTHOCTH nIeCOB H4 nJIuaauH, nepe,aHHble B aojnrocpOMHoe

noJb3oBaHHe, aaMHHHCTpaTHBHbie 3AaHHR jieCOX03AUCTBeHHblX H JieCo3arOTOBHTeCbHbIX

npe,anpHATHA, .ieCHu4eCTB, AeCO3arOTOBHTeCJbHbix noapa3LIeAeHHf, CTOAOBbie, KOp,D,OHbI,

3HMOBbSI, 6apaKH H p,pyrHe 3jaaHHq. Ha 3TUX inaHuleTax, KpOMe TOro, yKa3bIBatoT rolL py6KH

.neca HuH nana, a TaKwce THn Bbipy6KH. JleCHbie 3anOBeRHbie o6,beKTbi, nHAOLUaLb KOTOpbIX

CJIHUWKOM Maila, 'To6bl MX MO)KHo 6bu¶o nOKa3aTb Ha KapTe, o6o3HaMaloTCs BHeKOHTYPHbIMH

YCAOBHbIMH 3HaKaMH. Cioaa DOIKHbI TaKwe BKAIOoaTbCH H3pe)KeHHbIe KOHTYPHble AHNHM,

OCHOBaHHbIe Ha Tonorpa4HtieCKHX KapTax.

Page 155: Russian - World Bank Documents

151 HlPHJIOKEHHE A

IJJIaHH ffeCHJifeCTB COCTaBjiAlOTCq Ha OCHOBaHHH MOHTa)Ka JieCOYCTpOHTeJbHbIXnAaHuleTOB H aOHOAHqIOTCq YCJIOBHbIMH o6O3HaqeHHqMHi, HanpHHMep AAq HeCOMKHYBUWHXCMHacaM(eHHuu, MeCT CKOnnieHH5 nopy6o0HblX OCTaTKOB, Bblpy6OK, naXOTHbIX 3eMeJTb, 6oJzoT HnepeyBsaJ)KHeHHb[X y"aCTKOB, a TaKXwe Ha6opoM YCJOBHbIX 3HaKOB aAA yKa3aHH5 KJlaCCOBBO3pacTa H pocTa, OTHocHTeIbHori HOJIHOTbJ Haca)ueHHr H rpynn 3KCnHJyaTaUHOHHorocfoH,aa. 9TH rfaHbl aOJDKHbl cocTaBASTbCA B MacIJTa6e 1:25.000. OHH rpeaHa3Ha4eHbl AnAHCnOAb3OBaHHS npuH COCTaBJIeHHH nn1aHOB IiecoHacaxcAeHHH, cXeM AeCOXO3S1 HCTBeHHbIXMeponpHATHI H apyrHx nnaHOB Ha YPOBHe JIecHHqecTBa, a TaKx(e KapT-cxeMJTeCoXO35I4cTBeHHbIX npegnpHsTHi. Hlx TaK)Ke HcnoAb3yloT ripu rmaHHPOBaHtH pa3MeWLeHHH(H rpabDHecKoro npeacTaBj1eHHs) Bcex fleCOXO3AACTBeHHbIx MeponpH5THr4 H apyrtix pa6oT,rpOBO,aHMbIX B npeaejiax JIeCHoro oHKa aaaHHoro parioHa.

nFnaHm JICCOHaCaaelfHHi JeCHHCCTB COCTaBjSIOTC5 Ha OCHOBaHHH riiaHOBAeCHHUeCTB. Ka)uaA eaHHuHa KaPTHPOBaHHH HMeeT CBOHl [BeTOBOUi KOa Ajnu o6o3Ha eHH5npeo6nia,ataoluHx BH4,IOB H BO3paCTHbix rpaaaULH. EofloTa, BOaoeMbi U rpaHHUbl C COCeaHHMHBHLIaMH 3eMfTienojib3OBaHIAq Toxe o6o3HaaloTcCA c riOMOLubiO pa3HbIX UBeTOB. HnaHI9KCiyarYLJHOHHOrO ]IecHoro 5Oa4a COCTaBjiAHOTCq Ha OCHOBaHHH HJTiaHOB ACCHHUqeCTB cnOMOLUbKO OKpaCKH Bcex cneHJblX H nepeCTOiHbIX npOayUHPYIOLUHX JnecOB, BXOaHLUHX B3KcnHyaTauHOHHbIH J1eCHOH q)OHA. npeo6lanaIaoLuHe BHU,bl H BO3paCTHbie rpynnbl UMCIOTCBOH UBeTOBbie KOabl.

Kaprm-cxemm nJecxo3oB oTpaxaKIOT CTPYKTYpY jieCOXo3iHCTBeHHbIX npe)4npHl4THr4H HX pa3MeiueHHe. Ha 3THX KapTax HlOKa3blBaIOT rIOKPbITbie .JieCoM njioLuaaI4, 3eMJ1H,nOKpblTbie COMKHYTbIMH H HeCOMKHYBWHHMHCq AeCHbIMH KYJIbTypaMH H KyJIbTypaMH,Co3ZaaHHbIMH roa noJIoroM nieca B npouecce peKOHCTPYKLtUHH HacaxKfeHHi. KapTbI-cxeMblOKpaweHbl HO OCHOBHbIM apeBeCHbIM BHTaM H BO3paCTHbIM rpynnaM.

CXeMII npormTBonorapHmbx MepoIpHIwNff cocTaBji5lOT B MacHJTa6e 1:25.000 cOKpaCKOH Homaaerl noeKapoonaCHbIX yLaCTKOB B COOTBeTCTBHH C KAaCCaMH noxKapHOROnaCHOCTH H rpa4IH4CcKHM H3o6pa)KeHHeM npOTHBOrOiKapHbIX onywLeK H yKpbITHfl,KaHaJTOB, BOaOeMOB, rpaHHu ioKapOyCTOK4HBbIX nIecOB, npOTHBOnO)KapHbIX pa3pbIBOB,noxKapHbIX gopor, npoceK, rio)KapHbIX XHMmHeCKHX CTaHUH , CKJTBaOB npOTHBOno)KapHoroo6opyaOBaHH5,q Ha6KioaaTenbHblX BbIueK, 6a3 aBHaUHOHHOA OXpaHbi JieCOB OT nO)KCapOB(B!KuoMaH MexaHH3HPOBaHHbie OTpqabl 14 MeCTa pacnoAo)KeHHq noKapHbIX noapa3,aeAeHHri,noca,aoqHbIe rIJOLUaaKH JAn BepTojieTOB, MecTa 1A5 OTabiXa H KypeHHsI, TYPHCTHqeCKHeniareps H MapWpYTbl Ha3eMHOrO H aBHaUHOHHOrO naTpyJ4HpOBaHH5M).

KapTM-CXeMm 4aMHHHcrpaTrBHoIi cT7pyKryp COCTaB9HIOTC5i B MacWllTa6e1:200.000 HniH )Ke C HCnOJIb3OBaHHeM 6o0nee noapo6Horo MacWnTa6a. Bbl6op MacLITa6a3aBHCHT OT pa3mepa KOHKpeTHOU TeppHTOp4H. Ha TaKHX KapTax H3o6pa)KaloTc5l rpaHHuHbiTecOXO3qr4CTBeHHbIX npeanpHATHA, .ieCOnPOMblwjieHHbIX npeanpHPH4THh H JIeCH H-eCTB

(parioHoB), a TaKiKe ceTb aopor. nIpeo6jiagaiouH BH2bl H BO3paCTHaA rpaaaLLuH rOKa3aHbi CnOMOLLblO UBeTOBOrO KoAa. Kapm JJCCOB CCCP, Ony6jiHKOBaHHaS B 1990 ro4y, cocTaAneHa BMacdHTa6e 1:2.500.000. OHa AaeT o6uLHr o630p pacnpeaejieHAR AeCOB nlecHoro 4OHza6bABwero CCCP H HH4TopMauHo nO BCeM YCJIOBHAM npOH3paCTaHHSI, HanpHMmep LaHHbie oMecTax HpOH3paCTaHHA uCHHbIX ,peBeCHbIX nopo,, o pacHojoxKeHHH 6o.noT H 6o0bWHxraper.

Page 156: Russian - World Bank Documents

152 HPJ1O)KEHJIE A

Apeivja y'iaCTKOB JICCHOO 4oH4a

Bb,laaMa J1HueH3HA Ha iieconOJIb3OBaHHe OCyLitCCTBJ1I,9TCq paIOHHbIMH OpraHaMH

BjiaCTH npH yYaCTHH perioHaJnbHoro ynpaBjieHH5 JiecaMH (KoMHTeTa no niecy) Ha OCHOBaHlH

npHiMbiX neperoBopoB, ayKLUHOHOB HJI KOHKypCOB. Jlecopy6o'-Hble 6nieTbl (opaepa) H

necHbIe 6wieTbl (aaioute npaBO Ha HcnOJIb3OBaHHe HeapeBeCHbIX pecypcoB) yaOCTOBepqlOT

npaBO Ha KpaTKOCpOMHOe nOJIb3OBaHIe JTeCOM B COOTBeTCTBHH C yCJIOBH[5MMH, yKa3aHHbIMH B

3THX aoKyMeHTax. ApeHaa aaeT npaBO Ha aoArocpo4Hoe nOHJb3OBaHHe y'aCTKaMH Jneca H

MO)KeT npelaOCTaBJ1RTbC51 Ha CpOK OT OaHoro roaa ao 49 JIeT. ApeHaOg yMaCTKOB neca

3aHHMalOTCR Jiecxo3bI. JleconOJTb3OBaTeISiM BbiaalOT i1eCOpy6oqHblg 6HneT HJIH JleCHoh 6HA'eT

Ka)abIi roa aeACTBHA apeHabl, B 3TOM 6HjieTe oroBapHBaeTcsi pa3peweHHbl BMlA

noJIb3oBaHHA, yKa3blBalOTCH ero KOHKpeTHble o6,beMbl H pa3MelueHHe.

CorJiacHo OCHOBaM neCHoro 3aKOHoaaTeJlbCTBa 1993 roga, B o653aHHocTH ieco-

nOJIb3OBaTeJieg BXOaHT:

* He aoi-OycKaTb noBpeAaeHI OCTaBwLHerocS ApeCBOCTOl H eCTeCTBeHHoro

BO3o6HOBJieHHA H HpeaOTBpaLuaTb B03HHKHOBeHHe 3pO3UU HO'-B.

* npOBOL4HTb 3a CBOH c4eT JIeCoBoCCTaHoBHTeJIbHbie MepoHpH4ITt5I Ha nJIo-

uIa,afqx JlecHoro 4)oHaa, nOBpeAKaeHHbIX B pe3yJIbTaTe JieCO3arOTOBITejIbHO9

,ae,TeJIbHOCTH4.

* npOBOa4Tb AeCOBOCCTaHOBHTenJbHbie MeponpHATHI Ha BbIpy6KaX H Tex

nHoLua,aAx, rme nocne JieCO3arOTOBHTeCJbHOH aeSITeJIbHOCTH 6buio yHHITo)Ke-

HO eCTeCTBeHHoe Bo3o6HOBJIeHHe.

* npHHHMaTb npodunaKTu{eCKte npOTHBOnO)KapHbie Mepbl.

* HpOBOaHTb nlOJIHYIO O'-HCTKY iiecoceK OT HiOpy6O4HbIX OCTaTKOB H He

OCTaBJIATb 3arOTOBMeHHOA apeBeCHHbI Ha MeCTaX py6oK.

HOBbl JAeCHOH KOLaeKC (CTaTbq 83) npeaaaraeT paCwiHpHTb o6A3aHHoCTi4

JieconOJIb3OBaTeJIeC4, BKJIIOtHB B HHX cJIeayKoLJHe Tpe6oBaHHM: OCyIJeCTBJIATb nOJIb3OBaHHe

y4aCTKaMH JlecHCoro 4OHaa B COOTBeTCTB4H C IieCHbIM 3aKOHoqaTeAbCTBOM H C YCJIOBI4I,MM

,nOrOBOpOB apeHRbl, KOHuLeccHH Him aoiroCpOMHoro nOJIb3OBaHR5I; He aOHyCKaTb HaHeceHHA

Bpe,aa 3AOpOBbIO rpu)amH H OKpy)KaIoLueH npHPOAHOH cpeae; nOKpblBaTb paCXOabl Ha

nepeBoA y4aCTKOB JIeCHbIX 3eMeJnb, npeaOCTaBjieHHbIX B apemay, B KaTeropI4O, YKa3aHHYIO B

xaoroBope apeHRbl; caaBaTb apeHayeMbie y-IaCTKH nTeCHbIX 3eMenIb JIeCXo3y nIocnIe 3aBepLueHH5I

Ha HHX pa6oT; BO3MeLuaTb y6bITKH H nOTePH nIeCHoro xO3AH4cTBa; CBOeBpeMeHHO BHOCUTb

nAaTe)KH 3a nOJIb3OBaHie iiecaMH; co6JiioaaTb caHHTapHble npaBHJIa H BblHOJIHATb apyri4e

Tpe6oBaHHs4, YCTaHOBJAeHHbie 4beaepaJIbHbIM opraHOM ynpaBjieHHI JlCCHbIM X0351HCTBOM H ero

TeppHTOPHa)]bHbIMH opraHam ; He aOnyCKaTb HapyLueH Hi npaB apyrHx jieconOAb3OBaTeAeie;

npe,aOCTaBASITb HH43OpMaU4io 0 1OJ1b3OBaHHH AeCHbIM (DOHROM H 4Hq4OpMaUHmo,HeO6XOamMyto =,lq OnpeCeAeHHS pa3MepOB nJIaTe)Ker 3a JAeCOnOAb3OBaHHe, OpraHaM

ynpaBJleHHA JIeCHbIM X035iCTBOM 1 opraHam rOCyyapCTBeHHOR CTaTHCTHKI4.

Haa3op H KOHTpOAb 3a aeATeJbHOCTblO JeCOnIOJlb3OBaTeCAeR qB;IqIOTCA o6H3aH-

HOCTbIO IieCXO3OB. ,DJM onpeaeAeHHq HOTpe6HOCTH B J1CCOBOCCTaHOBHTeJlbHbIX MepOnllpHTH5IX

H 'qTo6bl yCTaHOB4Tb, Co6IluoaaI IM jieconOJIb3OBaTeCj npasunIa py6oK H BenJaCb Jnu uX

pa6oTa B COOTBeTCTBHM C HIJaHOM py6oK, HCIIOJlb3ylOT a3pOd)OTOCbeMKY JieCo3a-

Page 157: Russian - World Bank Documents

153 nPHJJOKEHHE A

FOTOBHTeJIbHbIX njioLuageH, KOTOpYIO npOBOAqT nIeCOYCTpOHTenJbHbie npe,nP4,Tu5 no3aBepLLUeHHH OCHOBHOFO nepHoaa JieCO3aFOTOBHTenJbHbIX pa6oT B BeceHHee BpCMq. HaOCHOBaHUHU TaK4X MaTepHaJOB perHoHabHoe ynpaBieHHe iecaMl (perioHalbHbiA KOMHTeTno iiecy) HpHHHMaeT, Hpu Heo6xoatHMOCTH, COOTBeTCTBYIOLUHe Mepbl.

rpH o6Hapy)KeH4H HapywCeHHuI JieCo3aroToBHTejie MOryT o6513aTb JCrIpaBUBTbnoo)KeH4e aeni nJIu 3arj1aTHTb WlTpa¢. CnopHble cJIyqaH moryT pa3pewaTbCA B cyae. HaipaKTHKe xKe WlTpa4bbI B314MalOTC5I peaKO, rOCKOJbKY JieCXO3bI nHJoXo OCHaLL1eHbl H He UIMeIOT

TCxHH4-ecKHx BO3MO)KHOCTeH OCyLweCTBJfIlTb 34"eKTHBHblH KOHTpOJIb. B Tex iKe cjTy'ialx,Korga wTpadibI Bce Ke Ha3HaIalOTCH, JIeconOJIb3OBaTenjT qacTo CTapaioTci OTCpO'-HTb onAaTyHa rog uHn 6ojiee, H Torla BbICOKHe TeMnbI HHJIASLUHH CHJIbHO CHtiKalOT CTOHMOCTHblHpa3Mep wTpada. Ho HIOCKOJ1bKy YPOBeHb WTpaq)OB oIeHb HU3KHA, HapyWHTeJiHnpe,Tno4HTalOT 3annjaTHTb WTpa(j BMeCTO TOrO, qTo6bI co6JnioaaTb YCTaHOBJeHHbiejieCOBOIICTBeHHbiC Tpe6oBaHHI4. HanpHMep, wTpa4 B 1995 roAy 3a I Ky6oMeTp JIecoceIHbIxOTXODOB, OCTaBj1eHHbIX Ha JIeco3aroTOBHTeJIbHOA flJ1OLIaJH, COCTaBJIiJA Bcero 1000 py6nieu(T.e. npMmepHo 20 ueHTOB).

JIccoBocc7THoaIeHHe

KaK npaBHnJo, cooTHoweHHe Meway eCTeCTBeHHbIM Bo3o6HOBJIeHHeM HHCKyCCTBeHHbIM JieCOBOCCTaHoBjieHHeM COCTaBJI5eT 70:30 B ceBepHOA H cpeaHeg TaHre,50:50 - B IO)KHOH Tagre ui 30:70 - B cMewJaHHbIX niecax, a B CTenHOr4 H jiecoCTenHor4 3OHaxHO'ITH HCKfIO'-H4TeJIbHO HCrIOJ1b3yeTCA HCKYCCTBeHHOe BbipailUHBaHHC ca)KeHueB. Ecnjil HaBCeU TeppUTOPHH CH6HPH H aaj1bHero BocToKa nfloluaEm iieCOBOCCTaHOBj1eHH5I (noceBaceMSH H nocaaKH caKeHLueB) COCTaBnqjiiJ B 1980-x roaax OKOJIo 215 TbIC. ra B ron(nHcapeHKo, PeabKO, Mep3AeHKo 1992), TO B BO BpeMq nepeXOaHoro nepHoaa 3TOT YpOBeHbewue 6oflbule CH4314JICA.

B KpacHO5IpcKOM Kpae o6Luaq nnjoLuaAb J1eCOBOCCTaHOBjTeHH5 (nOcaaKorH) B 1990-1994 rogax cocTaBnAlna 79 TbIC. ra, B cpeaHeM - nO'TH 16 TbIC. ra B rog, a eCTeCTBeHHoeBO3o6HOBJTeHHe npo4CXOlHJIO Ha nHjoutaadu 222,5 TbIC. ra, B cpeaHeM - HO'ITH 45 TbIC. ra BroI. aaHHbIX O nHp)KHBaeMOCTH (coxpaHHOCTH) paCTeHHU HeT, XOTM HeKOTOpbIe y4eHbieCqHTaIOT, '-TO lpHH JIeCOBOCCTaHOBJIeHHH nocnie iieCO3aFOTOBK4 pe3yJIbTaTbI 06blqHO 6blBaloTrIJIOXHMH, TaK KaK 3TO CB5I3aHO C ynJIOTHeHHeM H 3p03HmerlH nOB B pe3yJIbTaTeHCnOJlb3OBaHHSI TADKeJIOiI JieC03arOToBHTeJlbHOH TeXHHKH. ECTb CBeaeICH4R 0 TOM, qTOrPJ4)KHBaeMOCTb XBOUiHbIX KyAbTyp COCTaBJI5eT Bcero 20-40%. B xoae caMoh nocileIRHeHiHHBeHTap143aui4H B KpacHoMpcKoM Kpae (5IHBapb 1993 r.) 6buo o6Hapy)KeHO OKOJIO 2 MJ1H.ra 6e3necHO4 JieCHoi 3eMJnu, Tpe6yiouter AeCOBOccTaHOB14TeJIbHbIX MeponpHliTH1i.nporpaMMa no JIecOBOccTaHOBJIeHHlo, pa3pa6OTaHHaI Ha nep4oa c 1996 no 2000 roDa,rpe,aycMaTpHBaeT, qTO nlec Ha HfloL.LaAu B 1,4 MJH. ra MoweT B03o6HOBHTbCS eCTeCTBeHHblMnyTeM, a Ha OCTaJTbHOH HAoLuaaiH - B 0,6 MJIH. ra Tpe6yeTCq HCKYCCTBeHHoeBOCCTaHOBIeHHe Aeca (nocaaKO9). O0lHaKO, BO BpeMq roaa, npH4rQOHoe anqrTHpoBeaeHH5inoca,aOIHblX pa6oT ,OCTYnHaH, nHjouHaab COCTaBJIq eT TOJIbKO 170 TbIC. ra.

B Xa6apoBcKoM Kpae JieCOBOccTaHoBjieHHe HpOBOl4HTCq Ha njoLuaaiH OKOJIO 10TbIC. ra B roa. B OCHOBHOM TaM ca)KaIOT XBOHHbie BHAbl, KaK npaBsuIO, Keap (Pinus sibirica).TaKHe UeHHbIe apeBCCHbie riOpOlbI OieHb CHJlbHO nOCTpaaaAH OT 4pe3MepHOA3KCIiyaTauLi4. rpH OTCYTCTB14H aOCTaTO'IHOrO KOJIH4eCTBa CCMeHHbIX aepeBbeB 3TOT BHI

Page 158: Russian - World Bank Documents

154 HPHA1OKEHHE A

CTaHOBHTCH MaJIoMHcjieHHb[M H y)Ke OTHeceH K OXpaHieMbIM BiiRaM. Ho RaHHbIX o6 Uix

npH)KHBaeMOCTH HeT. MeponpI4.qTvlq no coaeRCTBHio eCTeCTBeHHOMY BO3o6HoBJ1eHHlO

OXBaTbIBalOT OKOJIO 90 TbIC. ra nieCHbIX 3eMenJb B roa. J1eCOBoaCTBeHHbie Meponp[4RTH MOryT

npeayCMaTpHBaTb CKapHqHKauHio, YXOa H 3aLUHTY Haca)KaeHHui. Flo HMeiOLUiMCA OUeHKaM,

o6utasi nJIoIlaab, Hy)aaiouLaqcs B HCKYCCTBeHHOM BOCCTaHOBjieHH14 nieca, B Xa6apOBCKOM

Kpae COCTaBJSieT 5 MJIH. ra.

/IcoBoccTHoBffeHmC (cKywccmeHHoe). HOqTH B Kaw.KOM niecXo3e HMteeTCA

60AbWO9 riUTOMHHK, B KOTOpOM e)KerORHo HPOH3BOART OT HeCKOJIbKHX COT TbICqI AO

HecKOJIbKHX MHJIJIH4HOB caxceHUeB HJIH ceRHueB. TaK, HanpHMep, B KpaCHOMpcKoM jiecXo3e

(147 TbIC. ra), B nHTOMHHKe npoR3BOAIHTCR OKOJIO 2 MJIH. Ca)KeHLteB H CeqHLHeB B roJa. 9TH

paCTeHH51 OCTa1OTCR B nHTOMHHKe aO 3-5 nieT H o6blqHO BbiCa)KHBaioTcA C OTKpbITOU

KOPHeBOH C4CTeMOH. CTaHaapTHbie Tpe6oBaHIH no KaA)aOMy BHILy aepeBbeB onpeReiRloT

MHH4MaJ]bHbIU pa3mep nocaaoqHoro MaTepHaJia, Heo6XOILHMbli IqLI BbDKHBaHBH pacCTeHHU B

YCJOBHHX KOHKypeHUHH C COPHOU paCTHTeJIbHOCTbIO. OCHOBHbIMH BHaaMH,

BbipaLUHBaeMbIMH B nHTOMHHKaX, RBARIOTCS COCHa o6bIKHOBeHHaA (Pinus sylvestris) H Keap(Pinus sibirica).

Ce3oH nocaBKH nieca HalIHHaeTCS B mapTe. KynbTypbl o6brIHO co3flalOTCs H3

paCTeHHrU ODHOU apeBeCHorl HOpOoabi. HlpaKTH4eCKH BCe MepOnpHSTHUR, CB53aHHbIe C

nOCaIKOH, nppOBOLSTCS Ha BbIpy6KaX, rIOTOMY 'ITO K HHM BeayT noafbe3AHbie aoporH, HO

JIeCOBOCCTaHOBHTenJbHbie HJun Bo3o6HOBHTeAbHbIe pa6oTbl 06bF'IHO OXBaTbIBalOT MeHee

nOAOBHHbl nJIOWaAH Bbipy6JleHHoro nieca, TaK KaK 6Onbwuas ee 'aCTb B ce3OH nOCaaKH

RBjSiCeTCH HeaocTynHO9. ,Dpyrue xKe (H 'acTo o6WHpHble) rUioUaauH, Ha KOTOpbIX nec 6bml

YHH'TO)KeH ro)KapaMH, HaCeKOMbIMH, 6o0ne3HHMH HunH BeTpOBajiOM, H3-3a CBOeUi HeIgOC-

TYFHOCTH He BOCCTaHaBJIHBaIOTCq. JIeCOBOCCTaHOBJIeHHe (noCaaKa) Ha Be4HOMep3IOTHbIX

nJIoLUa,a5IX TO)Ke TpyaHoocyLLeCTBHMa (ceAHUbl 3aqacTyIo KaK 6bl BbiLaBjiHBalOTCq H3 rpyHTa),

H nO3TOMY TaKHe nJIOLUaaH OCTaBjimlOT no, eCTeCTBeHHOe Bo3o6HOBJIeHHe.

EcTeCTBeHHOe B3o6HoBoeHe. CoaegCTBHe eCTeCTBeHHOMY BO3o6HOBJeHHIO

RBiASeTCH CaMbIM pacnpocTpaHeHHb[M MeTO,OM IieCOBOCCTaHOBJIeH HR. CoriacHo HpaBHi4aM

py6OK riiaBHoro nIOJIb3OBaHHi B .necax 3ana,AHou CH6HpH, YTBep)aeHHbM (DeaepanbHOH

cjiyxc6og iecHoro XO3A9CTBa AnAA CH6upu (1993 r.), B npoiKecce JIeCO3arOTOBHTenJbHbIX pa6oT

HeO6XOiLHMO npHHHMaTb onpeaeJIeHHbie MepbI 3aLUtTbI H COLcerUCTBHA pOCTy eCTeCTBeHHOrO

Bo3o6HoBJIeHH54. K TaKHM MepaM OTHOC5ITCq: coxpaHeHHe HeCKOJIbKHX ceMeHHbIX epeBbeB B

npe,aenax JiecoceKH (3TO OCO6eHHO Ba)KHO Ans BO3o6HoBJIeHHq COCHbl), coxpaHeHHe Ha

HeCKOJIbKO AeT B HeTPOHYTOM BH,e rpH)KealwHx jiecoceK, coxpaHeHHe noapoCTa B xoae

JIeCO3arOTOBHTenJbHbIX pa6oT, OM4CTKa Bblpy6KH nyTeM c6opa nopy6o'KHbIx OCTaTKOB B BanbI

HuIH OrHeM. OcyiuecTTieHHe 3THX Mep ABJIqeTCAI o653aHHOCTbIO JieCO3arOTOBHTeJlbHbIX

KoMnaHHi, a JeCOXO3SgCTBeHHbie OpraHbI aOJDKHbl HX KOHTpOAHpOBaTb. OTaen

JieCOBOCCTaHOBJieHHI4 B KpacHOqpCKOM Kpae o6blrHO HCnOJIb3yeT "y3KOnaceMHyIo" CHCTeMy

JIeCOCeCHbIX pa6oT, T.K. eCTb aaHHble 0 TOM, -TO 3Ta CHCTeMa 3arOTOBKH neca 6.naronpHqTHO

BHSHCeT Ha eCTeCTBeHHOe Bo3o6HOBJIeHHe.

lp1H4HTHe peuIeHHr ro coaegCTBHio eCTeCTBeHHOMY BO3o6HoBJIeHHIO BXOpUT B

o6sl3aHHOCTH ynpasBjeHH5 iieCOBOCCTaHOBJIneHHI H 3aWHTHoro necopa3BeIeHSA $eaepanbHOH

CJIyK6bI niecHoro X035IiCTBa. npoLuecc eCTeCTBeHHOrO BO3o6HOBAeHHA npeaycMaTPHBaloT

npoeeaeHme cJleayioluHX Mep: KOHTpOJ1HpyeMbie naJibl, CKapH()HKaLHtHo (o6Ha)KeHHe

Page 159: Russian - World Bank Documents

155 flPHJAOKEHHE A

MHHepaYIbHbIX cAoeB nO4Bbi AmR CoaeHCTBHR npopacTaHHIO CeMqH), yXOL 3a nOapOCTOM KCOnYTCTBYIOiLLUe MepoprHpHS5TH. CornacHo HMelOjuHMCq aaHHbIM, eCTeCTBeHHOeBo3o6HoBJIeHHe XOpOwUo H11eT B CBeTJIoXBor4Hb1X necax (Ha ilerKHX noMBax), HO ropa3,ao xyiceB TeMHoXBoriHbIX necax (Ha T5DeKjb1x nO4Bax), rje BCKope nocne CnJIoWHoui py6KHnOSBJISIIOTCA BbICOKHe TpaBbl, noAaBJIHiOU.lHe pOCT CeAHUeB. 3TH TpaBbl, KpOMe TOrO,yBeJiHMHBalOT OnaCHOCTb B03HHKHOBeHH51 paCTHTenJbHbIX rio)KapoB, KOTOpbIe yHHHTO)KalOT6oAblUHHCTBO CeSHLxeB H MOAoLbiX aepeBbeB.

THnHMHOu npo6neMori 3iBJIAeTCA TaK)Kwe yBenmeHH KoJIHMecTBa meHee UeHHbIXMOJOIHSKOBbIX H cpeaHeBO3paCTHbIX HacaeK1eHHii JIHCTBeHHbIX nopoa, KOTOpbie nOqBJSiiOTCAnocne Bblpy6KH 6o0ee ieHHblIX XBOHHbIX HacaKLeHHH. 3To 4aCTO npOHCXOalHT Ha nJIoLua,4ISx,ripOg,aeHHbIX KpynHOMaCITa6HbIMH CFIOIIIHbIMH py6KaMH, rge HaH6oAee )KH3HeHHOaKTHBHbie nopoJIbi aepeBbeB (TaKHe, KaK OCHHa H 6epe3a), cemeHa KOTOPbIX HPHHOCRTCqcio,aa BeTpoM, 6blCTpO KOJOHH3HPYIOT nJIolUaab, oco6eHHo nocne noKapa. Ho 3TO -eCTeCTBeHHaA CTaAH5Hr npoLtecca 3KoAHorFHecKoA BbDKHBaeMOCT4 B Jlecax, H 3TU HOBbierOCa,aK4 CO BpeMeHeM (Mepe3 10-30 neT) 3anOAHRqIOTCS XBOUHbiMH nopoIIaMH H o6pa3yloTcscMewLaHHbie nieca.

Pa3Bwwfe,ocoTyHa

EOJIbwHHCTBO ileHTpOB 3KOHOMH4eCKOrO pa3BHTHS H HaCeJJeHHbIX nyHKTOBHaXoflSITCS B IO)KHbIX paioHax CH6HpH, oco6eHHO B par4oHe K iory OT TpaHCCH6HPCKOri)KeJIe3HOr4 IopoFH, BFIJIOTb 1o rocyIapCTBeHHoi rpaHHLJbl, a TaKwKe npoCTuipaloTC K ceBepyOT IIopoFH Ha paCCTOSHme npHMepHO B 150 KM. IIMeHHo Ha 3TOU TePPHTOPHH 6bIAacocpe,aoToMeHa H OCHOBHaS ieCO3arOTOLTeIbHaA LeSITeJIbHOCTb. OmeHb MHoro iieca3aroTaBJIHBaJIni TaKxe BAOJIb 6eperoB KpynHbIX peK. B ripowJIoM 6onbwuas 'aCTb apeBeCHHbI,3arOTaBMHBaeMoU B CH6Hpu H Ha JlaabHeM BocToKe, cnnaiiiaBIacb no peKam 6peBHaMH ununniOTaMH (TaTapHHoB, 1992). CriaB 6peBeH B 6oHax, KOTOpblU BbI3b1Banj cepbe3Hb1e3KOJ1oruHeCKHe npo6neMbl H oTJIo)KeHHA opraHH4ecKHx OTXOLOB, ceWiac y)Ke 3anpeLUeH. Jlec11o CHX nop TpaHCnOPTHpyeTCSI nO KpyIHbIM peKaM B KpacHoApcKoM Kpae (no EHHcelo UAHrape) H B Xa6apoBcKoM Kpae (no AMypy H YCCYPH) Ha HOHTOHax.

OxpaHa nIecoB OT HOAKpOB

3a nepHog C 1975 no 1988 roI nofKapaMH, HaceKoMbiMH, 6one3HAIM4 K apyrrHMm4JaKTOpaMH (TaKHMH, KaK BeTpOBaAbi), HCKIuOIas CnJIOUHbie py6KH, YHHMTO)KaJIOCb Bcpe,aHeM no 1,04 MIH. ra neca B roa. 9Ta HAoLa,Ab 3KBHBanieHTHa cpeaHeMy o6beMy roaoBori3arOTOBKH neca. OaHH TOJIbKO nO)Kapbl B CH6upu H Ha JaaAbHeM BocToKe YHH4TO)KHJIH 30MJIH. ra. B 1995 roay 16% o611eH fluioUaHu nomf6LiHx necoB PoccHu HpHXo1HJIOCb HaIao.nlo He6JiaronpHsTHbIX KJTHMaTHqeCKHX YCJIOBHA (r.naBHbIM o6pa3oM, BeTpoBajnoB), 33% -noru6no no rpiH4He no)KapOB H 46% - H3-3a HaCeKOMbIX-Bpe1HTeJleH H 6ofle3Hek(rocyLapCTBeHHblI aoKJaL o COCTOSHHHH oKpyKaioLLei np4pOaHORi cpe11bl, 1996). JleTo 1996roga xapaKTepH3OBanOCb 3Ha4HTenJbHb1M rOBblwUleHHeM YPOBHI JIeCHOR nO)KapOOnaCHOCTH HaTePPHTOPHH POCCUH (Ha I HmOIo 1996 roaa OT nO)KaPOB roCTpa.aano 1,2 MAH. ra nieca).

I4MelOTCSA aHHbIe 0 TOM, 'TO py6KH H no)Kapbl CHiKxalOT YCTOH4HBOCTb nIeCoB K BeTpOBaJiaM.

Page 160: Russian - World Bank Documents

156 nP"IJO)KEHHE A

3oHa OXpaHbI JiiCOB OT no)KapOB OXBaTbIBaeT BCIO TeppHTOpui4O POCCUH, npu 3TOM

ceBepHas TYHapa H neca nepexoaHoR 3OHbl OTHeceHbl K HeOXpaHIeMbIM, a lO)KHbIe paUiOHbi -

K oxpaH5ieMbIM necaM. B ieJIoM CHCTeMOrl OXpaHbI AeCOB OT noxapoB B TOU JIH uu HOH

4opMe OXBateH 61% nUiouitaAHu necHoro 4OHaa; B 3anaAHoA CH6HPu - 78%, B BOCTOtHOH

CH6Hpu - 66%, Ha )jaAbHeM BocToKe - 52% (CM. Ta6ni. A.3). 3oHa OXpaHbi nieCOB OT

noxKapOB npOXOAHT nO rpaHHue ceBepHbIX Tae)KHbIX nIeCOB. K ceBepy OT 3TOUl TeppHTOpUH

npO4bHjiaKTMHecKHe pa6OTbl H TywleHHe nOxKapOB nPOBOARTCA TOJTbKO B HCKYHOM4TelIbHbIX

cjiy,iasix. Y4eHbie CH6UpCKHX H LaaUbHeBOCTOMHbIX Hay4HO-HccneaOBaTeJ]bCKM4X HHCTHTYTOB

npexiaraloT paCwlHlHTb oxpaHAeMyiO 30Hy, 3anpeTHTb 3IIeCb hieco3KcrIJIYaTaUHoHHYIO

aeATeJ1bHOCTb H, TaKHM o6pa3oM, 3alUHTHTb 3Ty XpynKyIO 3KOCHcTeMy. rpaHHua 3OHbI

OXpaHbl iieCOB OT nO)KaPOB nOIMTH coBnaaaeT C TepexoAHoui 3OHOU (OT JleCOTyHapbl H

peKoJiecHii K Tauire). TeppHTopMH, HaxoaAma5Cq K ceBepy OT 3TOU 3OHbI, TaKwe

xapaKTepH3yeTCA OMeHb BbICOKOUi tIyBCTBHTeJIbHOCTbIO K aHTpOnOreHHbIM HapyLUeHUHM H

Hy)2aeTCA B 3aLUKTe H BbinOJIHeHHH COOTBeTCTBY1OIUHX npeAnKcaHuii no ocytueCTBJIeHI4o

IIeCOBOCCTaHOBJIeHHA.

9KoAorHi noKapOB B ceBepHbIX paroHax mBmHeTCA CJIO)KHOr4 npo6ineMori. rlo)cap

C-IHTaeTC5i eCTeCTBeHHbIM KOMnOHeHTOM 3KOcHcTeMbI, oco6eHHO B ceBePHOH TaHfre H B

nepeXOJaHbIX pa roHax K J1ecoTyHapoBoH 3OHe. Bo BpeMM KOPOTKOrO BereTauHOHHoro nepHoIa

npOJOJnDK4TeCJbHOCTb CBeTOBOrO RHA BeCbMa BenIHKa, TO o6yc.noB.nnBaeT BbICOKY1O

npOIaYKTHBHOCTb 6MOMOB H HaKonieHHe opraHHqeCKHX BeIeCTB (pa3nIoKeHHe npOHCXOalHT

MeLAeHHO H3-3a HH3KHX TeMnepaTyp). no)Kapbl cKxHraTOT opraHHqeCKHe BeLieCTBa,

cnoco6cTByA TeM caMbIM npopacTaHuilO ceMAH Ha OTKpblTbIX MHHepajIbHbIX noMBax. CeMeHa,

rOaaMH npojie)KaBWLHe B 3aKOHcepBHPOBaHHOM COCTOHHHH no cJIoeM Be'IHOA Mep3JOTbI,

HaKOHeu noAyqaIoT BO3MO)KHOCTb npOpaCTH H o6pa3oBaTb paCTMTeAbHbliU HOKpOB,

cnoco6CTBy.I TeM CaMbiM ocyw1eHHIO BpCMeHHO o6pa3OBaBeHxcA Ha 3THX TCPPHTOPHHIX

nepeyBayaHeHHbIX "aCTKOB. TaKHM o6pa3oM, nO)Kapbl HrpaIOT Ba)KHYIO pOJIb B L4HHaMHKe

3TOU1 3KOc4cTeMbi, riomoraH C03,aaHHIO M03aHKH pa3JIH'qHbIX 4)OpMaumHHi H cpea o66TaHHq

niSI pa3HbIX 4bOpM )KH3HH, TeM CaMbIM nOXaep)KHBaA 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3Me. IIMeHHo B 3TOM

KOHTeKCTe cjieayeT npUHHMaTb o6ocHoBaHHble pewIeHHH 0 TOM, rae H KOrDa TywIeHHe

no)KaPOB uejiecoo6pa3HO, a rae HeT. KpynHbie H HeynpaBAHemble noHCapbI Tpe6ylOT

npUHH$ITHSI CeLUMaflbHbIX mep no MX TywUeHHIO H3-3a TOFO Bpeaa, KOTOPbIU OHM nPH'IHHqloT

IieCHbiM 6HoMaM H aTMocfepe, HO B cjiy'ae He6O.nbWUX rO)KapOB peLeHUHH nO BO3MO)KHbIM

MepaM 6yayT MeHee OaHO3Ha4HbIMH.

MHOrHe POCCMHiCKHe CneLiHaJICTbl-fleCOBO,Ubl CM4TalOT, 'TO KpylHbie nO)KapbI

5HBJ511IOTCA OCHOBHbIM OTpHLuaTeJlbHbIM 4baKTOpOM, BO3AerICTBylOLLlHM Ha COCTOqHHe jneCOB H

o6myio 3KojiorHqecKyio CHTyaUHIo. Ha 6o.nbulHx Bbipy6Kax (riocne cnHJOLWHbIX py6oK)

nO)Kapbi MOrYT AOCTHraTb O4eHb BbICOKOH HHTeHCHBHOCTH H UHpOKOrO paCnpOCTpaHeHHq,

pa3pyuwai npMJIeraIOluHe, He TpOHYTbie py6KaMH Hacam,IeHHA. Oco6eHHO nOaBep)KeHbl TaKOH

onaCHOCTH nAouaauH c 60obI.uHM KOjIH4eCTBOM .necOCe4HbIX OTXOAOB. JIeCHHKH He pewalOTCq

rlpH6eraTb K KOHTpOjiHpyMbeM b lmJnaM AqH OMHCTKH TeppMTOpHM, T.K. 6o5HTcH o6BHHeHHII B

TOM, qTO OHH BbI3BaJIH apyrHe JieCHbie nO)Kapbl. HeT H OaHO3HaqHbIX CBeaeHHHi 0 TOM,

pa3pewLeHbl JIH TaKHe MeTOabI BOo6Lie.

Page 161: Russian - World Bank Documents

157 IPHJIO)KEHHE A

Ta6nAHia A.3. ESa3bi aBHLatHOHHOr oxpaHbl AecoB OT nlO2aPOB B POCCHH

Il I IHa3BaiHfe 63A | MccmHaxoaweflae

| UeHTpaj]bHa5 aBHa6a3a r. flyWK4HO, MOCKOBCKaS o6JnaCTb

2 CeBepo-3anaaHaq aBHa6a3a r. nleTpo3aBoacK, Pecny6nHKa KapeiniH

3 CeBepHas aBHa6a3a r. ApXaHreAbcK, ApXaHreuibcKaA o6naCTb

4 CbIKTbIBKapCKaq aBHa6a3a r. CbIKTbIBKap, Pecny6.nHKa KOMUi

5 3ar7aaro-YpajicKasI aBHa6a3a r. flepMb, nlepMcKaq o6iiacTb

6 YpawbcKaq aBsia6a3a r. EKaTepHH6ypr, CBepAnoBcKaa o6.nacTb

7 TIOMeHCKaS aBma6a3a r. TJoMeHb, TioMeHCKaS o6nacTb

8 XaHTbl-MaHCHACKas aBUa6a3a r. XaHTbi-MaHcHlicK, XaHTbi-MaHCHiCKHi aBTOHOMHbiiH oKpyr

9 3anaaHo-CH6mpcKasi aBsa6a3a r. HOBOCm6mpCK, HoBocf6HpcKas o6iiacTb

10 ToMCKaI aBma6a3a r. TOMCK, ToMCKaq o6nacTb

I I KpacHo,9pcKasl aBma6a3a r. KpacHos9pcK, KpacHOs9pcKHA KpaH

12 MpKyrCKaa aBsa6a3a r. HpKyrCK, KpKyrcKaq o6.nacTb

13 3a6aAKan1bcKas aBma6a3a r. YjiaH-Ya3, Pecny6JuHKa Byp5THr |

14 'HlTUHCKaSl asHa6a3a r. 'IHTa, qHTHHcKaAI o6JaCTb

15 SKyrCKan asua6a3a r. 5]KyrcK, Pecny6.nHKa Caxa (3lKyrnsI)

16 AMYPCKaS aBma6a3a r. E.narooeweHcK, AMYPCKaq o6.naCTb

17 aanbHeBOCTO0Haq asua6a3a r. Xa6aposcK, Xa6apoBcKmh KpaHi

18 IlpHMOpcKaq aBma6a3a r. BJIatHBOCTOK, n1pHMOPCKHi KpaA

19 CeBepo-BocTo[HaR aBfia6a3a r. MaraaaH, MarawaHcKaA o6JiacTb

20 rOpHO-AJITaHCKOe aBHaKpblJO r. ropHo-AJITaACK, Pecny6jrnKa AnTaH

21 CaxajrnHcKoe aBlaKpb]IJO r. [O0KHo-CaxajulHcK, CaxaJ!HHCKaq o6hiaCTb

22 KaM4aTCKoe aBUiaKpblJIO r. rIeTponaBnOBCK-KaM'aTcKHi, KaM4aTcKaq o6iacTb

23 KOpAKCKoe aBUaKpbI.nO r. Occopa, KaM4IaTCKaq o6iacTb, KOPSKCKHi aBToHoMHbli OKpyr24 qyKOTCKoe aBUaKpblJIO r. AHaablpb, MaraaaHcKas o6jiacmb, '-YKOTCKHA aBToHoMHblH

I I ~~~~~~~~~~OKPYFUfCTo7HmK.: ($eaepajbHas cny)K6a iiecHoro xo3grcTBa POCCHH, 1996 r.

B paMKax CH6HpcKoro Mem)UyHapOaHOrO LueHTpa 3KojiorFHeCKHX HccJieaOBaHHA6opeanbHblX JieCOB B KpaCHOAPCKe aeACTBYeT nporpamma MOHITOPHHra nleCHbIX IowKapOB,UenblO KOTOPOH 51BJIqIOTCH o6HapyxKeHHe H PerCTPcLaUHS KPYnHbIX nO)KaPOB U C60p aaHHb1XHo KjuHMaTH4qeCKHM YCJIOBH1M, Koj]H4eCTBY B03ropaeMbix MaTepHaJIOB H RpyrHMaHaJIorIH'HbiM acreKTaM. ,LnS1 MOHHTOPHHra iieCHbix rioKxapOB HCHOJTb3ylOTCq TeXHOJ]orHHAHCTaHU[OHHOrO 30HaHPOBaHHq. B CBA3H C HeXBaTKOA CaMOJeTOB H BepTOjieTOB lvIR 6opb6blC no)KapaMN H He1aOCTaTKOM rPOH3BOICTBeHHbiX 6ioBxeTHbIx cpeLaCTB, B IO)KHbIX(oxpaHAeMblx) paHOHax TyIuaT TOnIbKO KPYnHble rO)Kapbl. B 3OHe OXpaHbl niecoB OT rO)KaPOBB CH6HpH H Ha arajbHeM BOCTOKe exCeroaHO BO3HHKaeT OT 10 TbIC. ao 15 TbIC. nO)KapOB.Yluep6 OT KaKaoro 43 HHX B CPe,4HeM COCTaBELiSeT OKOJIO 100 ra neca (IIASA 1995).BOJIbWUHHCTBO KpynIHbIX nO)KapOB npOHCXO,aHT B IO)KHOA H Cpe24Heri TaHre. CyAs no BceMy,cyuIeCTBYeT onpe,aeeneHHaS5 3aBHCHMOCTb Mex)Ay ryCTOTOHi nieca (Hiian;imeM BO3ropaeMbIXMaTepHaInoB) K KpynHbIMH nolKapaMH.

Page 162: Russian - World Bank Documents

158 nPHAO)KEHHUE A

Ho aaHHb1M [ocyaapCTBeHHoro aoKiiaAa O COCTOSHHH oKpyxaiOwer¶ rpHpO1HOUcpe,AbI POCCHICKOUi (DexepaLuH 3a 1995 roa, 90% no)KapoB B necax oxpaHqeMog 3OHbl 3a

npowuibie nSTb neT Bo3HHKaJIO no BHHeq enoBeKa. B KpaCHOqpCKOM Kpae no BHHe 'leJioBeKaB03HHKaeT 70% noiKapoB. npHMHHaMH OCTajibHbIX 30% noxKapOB SBJIAIOTC TaK Ha3bIBaeMb1e

cyxHe rpO3bI, KOTOpbIe THnHMHbl AAS ueHTpaJlbHbIX H CeBepHb1X paHOHOB Cu6uPH. YMeHbie

o6Hapy)KHAH npSMylO 3aBHCHMOCTb MeAAy no)KapaMH H HanJHqHeM HaCeieHHbIX nyHKTOB,1Aopor H 6o.nbWHX peK. KpoMe TOrO, eCTb CBeaeHHH 0 TOM, YTO 'acTOTa B03HHKHOBeHHR

nO)KapOB ropa3Ao BbIlUe Ha 6oAbLUHX Bblpy6Kax, o6pa3oBaHHblX CnJIOLUHbIMH py6KaMH.

BaIcHOr npeanocbCiiKoH ycneWlHOR peajiH3aLuHH 34xeKTHBHoA npOrpaMMbloxpaHbl nIeCOB OT no)KaPOB SiBJs1eTCM xopouwo pa3BHTaq CeTb aopor Ans OnepaTHBHOH

,aOCTaBKH riO)KapHblX K MeCTaM BO3ropaHHrl. OaHaKo nOBbiwlelHHe YPOBHR JOCTynHOCTH necoB

BCJIeACTBHe CTpOHTeAbCTBsa Aopor MO;ICeT He TO)lbKO YCKOpHTb npoLlecc pa3pyIIHTenbHOrO

Bo3XaeACTBHA Ha neca, HO H nOBbICHTb BePOATHOCTb BO3HHKHOBeHH5 noriapoB. KpoMe Toro,

UwHpoKO pacnpocTpaHeHHoe nojaaneHue noKcapoB B Cu6uPH H Ha,L)aJibHeM BocToKe Mo)KeT

yBeJIiHHTb BePO$THOCTb B03HHKHOBeHHS KpynHbIX noKapOB Ha o6wHpHbIX TePPHTOPHS1X

TOrO )Ke BO3paCTHOrO KJiacca coceAHHx nIeCOB, KOTOpb1e aOjDKHbi, KaK o)KHfaeTcS,

pa3BHBaTbCHi nocnie o6pa3OBaHiHS o611HpHbIX Bbipy6OK. Ha 3TUX TePP4TOPHqX Co32alOTCR

6naronpHATHbIe YCJIOBHS14 AS pacnpocTpaHeHHq HaceKoMbIX-Bpe1aHTeJ]eR H 6one3HeH, 'TO, B

CBOIO oqepeab, co3XaeT HfeaIbHble YCJIOBMH LIA BO3HHKHOBeHH51 KpynHOMacuWTa6HbIx

no)KapoB. B pe3yflbTaTe o6pa3yeTCs IlOpO4HbIlH Kpyr o6CTOATeJibCTB, 'ITO MO)KeT CTaTb

nplMUHHOH KpynHbIX rioTepb.

BoqgopeIyJIHpy,oIHe WH Io!Io38wTHMCe q5yHiHw nIecoB

Jleca, paCTYWHe Ha BOI,opa3,enax, HrpalOT Ba)HY1O BO,4operyjiHpyio0iyio H

nO4BO3aIlHTHY[o pOJIb. 9TH 4 )YHKUHH 3aBHCRT OT THia nieca, BHJOBoro COCTaBa aepeBbeB H

THnOB JIeCOX03sACTBeHHblX MepOnpUHTHA (oco6eHHo OT MeTOfloB U 'iaCTOTbi npOBeaeHHR

fleCO3aroTOBHTeflbHblX pa6OT). 3xaecb O'eHb Ba)KHO npOBeCTH pa3rpaHtqeHu MHeLy

lO'IBO3aIUHTHbIMH H BOaOpeIyJIHpyiOiUHMH 4)YHKUHSMH, XOTR OHH TeCHO CBR3aHbl Mex)ay

co6o0H. Jleca BO,opa3JlejiOB 6.naroaapsi CBoeMy COMKHyTOMY nonlory 3aUHLLualOT nO'By. Ho B

riepHoIAb1 npOBeAReHHq py6oK H B nepBbie ABa-TpK roaa nocne rOCaLKH Mo)KeT npOH3ORTiT

3Ha'-lHTeAbHoe yeenm4eHHe 3pO3HH nOMB, a TaKwKe yBeIH'eHHe nOano'lBeHHOrO HnOBepXHOCTHOrO CTOKa.

OKono nOJIOBHHbI BCeX necoB CH6HPH H ,ALajbHero BocToKa HaxoI5TCq B rOpHblX

par4OHax, KOTOpb1e o6na,aloT BaXHbIMH BOaOc6opHbIMH 4pyHKULHMH, oco6eHHo B CBq3H C

HaJIH4HeM BOXOxpaHJIHiu, rHJpO3JneKTpocTaHuHA, HCTOlLHHKOB nHTbeBOrl BOJabl H pbi6HblX

peCypCOB. MHorHe H3 3THX ropHb1X iieCOB pacTyT Ha MajiOMOUlHbix nOHBax, KOTOpbIe nocne

yRajieHHA necCHoro nOKPOBa noABepraioTcR 3pO3H4. CnnolWHble py6KH, Koraa-To

npOBOIHBUHeCA Ha 6onbmux TeppHTOpHAX, nOKpblTbIX KeApoBbiMH HacaKleHHqMH, Tenepb3anpeweHbl. Bbipy6Ku, o6pa3oBaBuiHeCH B pe3yJ1bTaTe npOBeaeHH5 CnJOUWHbIX py6oK Ha

CKAIOHaX B IO)KHblX paflOHax KpacHoqpcKoro KpaR, oMeHb CHJIbHO rOpa)KeHbI 3pO3HeR, a

pa6OTbl no iiecOBOCcTaHOBneHHIO oKa3blBaioTcAS no-npe)KHeMy 6e3pe3yJlbTaTHblMH.

Jlio6oe H3MeHeHHe B J1eCHOM noKpoBe 6yAeT OKa3blBaTb OlILyTHMOe BJMH1HHe Ha

MeCKHe Bonopa3,aejibi, HO BHAHHHe TaKHX H3MeHeHHA Ha KpynHb1e HJI4 KoMnHJeKCHbie

BO,Opa31eAbi 6yaeT ropa3LAo MeHee 3Ha'HTeflbHblM. 9TH K3MeHeHHS MoryT nOBJIHHTb Ha

Page 163: Russian - World Bank Documents

159 HPKPHO)KEHHE A

xapaKTep nOBepXHOCTHOrO CTOKa (BbI3blBas nOBbiweHHe 'aCTOTbl U HHTeHCI4BHOCTHnaBOJAKOB) H Ha Ka'eCTBO BORbl (B 'aCTHOCT4, Bbl3blBa5 yBeBiH4eHHe MYTHOCTH Uco,aepxaHu4A opraHHqecKux BeluecTB). B HeKOTOpb1X paUiOHax, nocne Toro KaK B pe3yJ1bTaTeKpynHOMacLlTa6HbIx CnJIOWHblX py6oK B 3OHe MHOrOJIeTHer Mep3JTOTbl Ha MeCTe necoBBO3HIKJIn 6onoTa, Hcme3IH YCJOB14A AAS HepeCTHHLULa JIOCOCA (IIHCTHTYT BOaHb1X U3KOJIorHqeCKHx npo6AeM B Xa6apoBcKe).

OCHOBHbIMU npHqHHaMH gerpaRaaUm cpeabl npoH3paCTaHH , CBS 3aHHOH CJeCO3arOTOBHTeCJbHOI4 aeATeAbHOCTbIO, IBJIAIOTCS nrioxoe Ka4eCTBO npoeKTHpOBaHHSl,CTpOHTeCJbCTBa H COaepxKaHHA aopor, HOBpeKeHHH lnO'Bbl Ha TpeJeBO4HbIX BOJOKaX H3-3aHcnOAb3OBaHHiu 6ynbao3epHbIx OTBanjOB Ha KPYTbIX CKJIOHax, a TaK)Ke ynJIOTHeHH4e nOMBbl H3-3a HcnOJIb3OBaHHS TADKeCoI4 TeXHHKH Ha y1aCTKaX HHTeHCHBHOr4 3KCnniyaTauLH (cmna,aax).YIUIOTHeHHe nO4BbI Mo)KeT Bbl3BaTb 3Ha4HTeCJbHoe CHK)KeHHe KO34HuHCeHTa UH-

rnJHbTpauHHY H BeJIHeHHe Mogymi nOBePXHOCTHoro CTOKa. Pe3yjnbTaTbl pqaa pOCCUUCKHX UMeAMyHapO,aHbIX HCCAe,aOBaHHUU RIOKa3blBalOT, qTO OKOIIo 20% njiOLaaH Bbipy6JeHHblx JiecOBCTpa,aaeT OT HeraTHBHorO Bo3aerCTBHq nOqBeHHbIX nOBpeK,eHHH, a eLue 10% - OTrpoKmaAKH aopor. aOpOrH, no o6feMy rpH3HaHHIo, ABAI1OTCA OaHOr4 U3 OCHOBHblX npHMHHyBeAJHeHHA CTOKa H CeUHMeHTaUHH. TaKHM o6pa3oM, K Ba)KHbIM YCAOBU14M COKpaLLteHH3pO3HH nO4B OTHOC5RTCS npasBHbHoe npOeKTHPOBaHHe CHCTeMbl Ropor H rpOBCeaeHHeJ1eCO3arOTOBHTeCJbHbIX pa6oT (Bbi6op o6opyx4oBaH4H, rioarOTOBKa nepcoHaTa, ymeTKJHMaTH'-IeCKHX yCJOBHi).

AeCHoe X03IHUCTBO B Xa6apoBcKoM H KpacHoslpcKoM KpaSAX

B Xa6apoBcKoM H KpacHoApCKoM KpaAx npeACTaBneHbl nO4TH Bce THnbl niecaPoccuu (pHc. A.1 H A.2). B Xa6apoBcKoM Kpae npeo6naziaaoT eCJb H JIHCTBeHHHua (pHc. A.3).B KpacHOApCKoM Kpae npeo6JIanaIaouute nopoabi aepeBbeB (cocHa, eJIb, nHxTa,JIHCTBeHHHua, CH6HpCKHU Keap, OCHHa H 6epe3a) pacnpe,eIenAoTcs 6o0lee paBHOMepHO, XOTS3,aeCb TaKwCe O4eHb BeJIHK yaeJbHblH Bec 6epe3bl u OCHHbI. I3epe3a U OCHHa 3aHHMmaOT MeHee20% nnoaaHn cneJIb[X nIeCOB, HO HX aOJA B o6LUeu rIJIOLUaaH MOJIOablX BO3paCTHbIX KJ1acCOBCOCTaBJIAeT nO1 TH 50% (CM. pHC. A.2). OT'aCTH 3To pe3yJbTaT fleCO3arOTOBHTeAbHOriLLeHTeCJbHOCTH, HMeBwei MeCTO B npoLIoM, KOTOpa5 co3LaJIa yCJIOBHS,6AaronpHATCTBOBaBWui4e pOCTy MajOLueHHbIX OCUHbl H 6epe3bl BMeCTO BbICOKOUeHHbIXXBOUiHbIX nopoa.

Bo3pacT cneJIOCTH nieca 3aBHCHT OT lOpOLabl aepeBbeB. HanpHMep, 6epe3OBbie 1UOCHHOBbie nieca Co3peBalOT 4epe3 40-60 neT, a KeapOBbie - qepe3 100-120 ACT. CpeaHHriBO3paCT JIeCOB KpaCHOqpCKOrO KpaM paBeH 104 roaam, XOTA 6OJAbwaA qaCTb cneJIbIx JileCOBHaXOAHTCA B KpaUHe oTLaJIeHHbIX paUiOHax, B TO BpeMA KaK B JlerKOaOCTynHbIX palOHaxpaCTeT 6oAbwasi qaCTb HecneJIbIx nIecoB. CpeaHHuu B03paCT neCOB Xa6apoBcKoro KpaACOCTaBnJ eT 82 rotaa. B KpacHospcKoM Kpae neca 3aHHMalOT 50,1 MJTH. ra, B Xa6apOBCKOM -

39,4 MJIH. ra.

3anlac neca H HpIpHoCT

3anac nieca Ha KOPHIO B 9THX IBYX perHoHax (4,6 Mwpa. M3

B Xa6apOBCKOM Kpae U

7,6 Mjlpa. M3

- B KpaCHOslpCKOM) COCTaBJAeT 28% o6wero 3anaca neca Ha KOpHIO B CH6Hpu

Page 164: Russian - World Bank Documents

160 HPIJIOWKEHHE A

H Ha saanbHeM BocToKe. B KpacHoqpcKoM Kpae cpeH4HHHr 3anac necoB BblwHe (151 M3/ra),

4eM B Xa6apoBcKoM (116 M 3 /ra). KpoMe Toro, B KpacHo0pcKoM Kpae BbIllwe cpeAHHK 3anac

cnenoro nieca, 'TO FOBOpHT o 6ojiee 6naronpHqTHb[x B cpeRHeM YCJIOBHqx npOH3paCTaHHi

(CM. pHC. A.4 H A.5). OTMaCTH 3TO pa-3IHqHe o6ibscHAeTcs 6onbweeu aoAeH cnenbix nieCoB B

KpaCHOApCKOM Kpae.

KaK 3TO BHaHO H3 fsaHHbIx, npUHBeaeHHbIX Ha pHC. A.4 H A.5, cH6HpCKHe XBoriHble

nieca TieMoHCTPHpyIOT caMbIi BbICOKHH YPOBeHb pocTa OCHOBHbIX BWIOB CepeBbeB.

A1HHaMHKa pocTa necoB SBJISeTcA 6o0iee CTa6HJ1bHor4 B Xa6apOBCKOM Kpae, HTO BepOATHO

o6ycnoBMeHo 6onee c6aJIaHcHpoBaHHbIMH KTiHMaTH'eCKHMH YCJTOBH5MH 3TOU TeppTTOPH H.

B TO A(e BpeMq, B uenjoM YCJIOBHS AIA pocTa nieCOB Ay'iwJe B KpaCHosIpCKOM Kpae, 4TO 5ICHO

BH,RHO npH CpaBHeHHU TeMnOB pOCTa OAH4X H TeX wKe aepeBbeB pa3JIH4HbIX BO3paCTOB H

BKROB B 3TOM Kpae no cpaBHeHHIO c Xa6apoBcKHM. CH6HpCKHe neca pacTyT oieHb

MelJIeHHO, HiTO 5BJISeTCA CePbe3HbIM HeROCTaTKOM C TOMKH 3peHH$ TeMnOB oKynaeMOCTH

KanHTajiOBAO)oeHHi4, HO 3TOT HeaOCTaTOK 4aCTH4HO KOMneHCHpyeTC5 3a c4eT BbICOKOrO

KaqeCTBa apeBeCHHbl, npoH3BOaHMOr4 B 3THX YCJIOBH14X. IJIoTHaSi LpeBeCHHa C paBHOMepHOHi

TeKCTYPO1 HMeeT 6o0iee Bb1COKlO PbIHOMHYIO LLeHy.

B POCCHK npHpOCT nieca onpeaenAseTc5i no 4DopMyjie, rpe B qiIcJIHTeJIe cTaB5ITCq

,aaHHbie o6 yBeCjH4eH4H 3anaca neca Ha KOPHIO 3a onpeeneneHHbir nepHOL (HanpHMep, 3a 10

neT), a B 3HaMeHaTeJie q-CHJIo AeT pacteTHoro nepHoLa. 9ToT MeTO):, ogHaKo, iaaeT

3aHH)KeHHYWO oueHKy 4aKT4CecKoro np4pocTa. Bonee TO'Hbie MeTOabl npernojiaraloT

H3MepeHHe npHPOCTa no aHaMeTpy C nOMOLiblO 3aMepOB 3Toro napameTpa y oTaenbHbIX

aepeBbeB UIPH npOBeaeHHH TaKcauHH neca HIiH pacxieT HpHpocTa nO Ta6AHLaM xoaa pocTa.

Ho pac4eTaM, o6LuHi ro,oBOiHBl npHPOCT B necax Xa6apoBcKoro Kpasq COCTaBJI5IeT 51 MJH. M3,

Hjun HpHMepHO 1,3 M 3/ra/roa, a B necax KpaCH05pCKorO Kpaq - 69 MJIH. M3 , HJIH

1,4 M3 /ra/ro,. 3To ropa3,ao HH)Ke, 'eM B 6onbulHHcTBe apyrHx JInCOB MHpa. npHHHTeHCHBHOM BeaeHHH .iecHoro XO3HACTBa Ha o6wUHpHbIX TePPHTOPHA1X MOAKHO noJIYMaTb no

3-4 M3/ra/roa.

O6wmz 3aroToBKif uieca B nHpoLuime )epCoHam

C HaianjoM nepexoaa K pbIHOIHOA 3KOHOMHKe npoH3OWJIO pe3Koe CHH)KeHHe

ypOBHeH 3arOTOBKH aTpeBec4Hbi. B 1994 roay rogoBoB o6feM JIeCO3arOTOBK4 B Xa6apOBcKoM

Kpae coKpaTHJIC5 d° O,DHOH TpeTH ypOBHA 1987 ro,a U C Tex nop He H3MeHH4JIcq. B

npoueHTHOM BbIpas)KeHHH CHH)KeHHe ypOBHA 3aroToBKH Aeca B KpacHoApcKoM Kpae 6bulo

npHMePHO TaKHM xe. Py6KH rnIaBHOro nojib3oBaHI1R, BKJlioqaf cnHAOLHbie H

BoccTaHoBHTeAbHbIe, COCTaBJI5IOT 6o0IbuyIo 0Al1o B o6LueM o6beMe JIeCO3arOTOBKH (oKono

95% - B Xa6apOBCKOM Kpae H 90% - B KpaCHOMpCKOM Kpae), 'TO yKa3blBaeT Ha

Onpe,aeJTeHHbli TeXHonorw-ieCKHR CT14TIb BeaeHH5l JIeCHOro X03AACTBa (CM. ptC. A.6 H A.7). 3a

nocJienH4e 10 ieT yaeflbHbiH BeC 3TUX BH4,aOB py6oK B03pOC. npH pa4uOHajibHOM H

HHTeHCHBHOM pecypcoynpaBjieHHH aOAH py6oK rIiaBHoro HOJIb3OBaHKI4S H apyrHX BHOB

py6oK (BKnioMasi py6KH yxoaa H CaHHTapHbie py6KH) a0JIKHbI 6bITb pllHMCpHO paBHbIMH. B

KOHfe 1980-x rOaOB o6'beMbl py6oK riaBHoro nOJIb3OBaHH4 B Xa6apoBcKoM Kpae npeBbILaiiH

pacMeTHbie JiecoceKH, HO ceroAHSA 4aKTHqeCKHrl o6ieM py6oK B o6oHX perHoHax

3Ha,HTenbHO HH)Ke ypOBHS pac4eTHOA necoceKH. OLeHKH roaoBoro npHpOCTa JIeCOB ropa3Iao

Page 165: Russian - World Bank Documents

PHc. A.1: BO3paCTHoe pacipeaeaJIeHHe JIeCOB Xa6apOBCKoro KpaSI,1993 r.

20.-2* ilpOqHe mirKo-

18 -JIHCTBeHHbie iOPOpobi

o OCHHa16-

* Bepe3a14-

0 12 -O TBepi30JrHCTBeHHbie

10 * Keap

8 - 0 JIICTBeHHHIa

6 - E rIHxTa= ~~4 --- 7/ 3OE.ib

21 U CocHa

MOJIO,HAKH I KSI. MOJIO,HqlKH II KJI. CpeaHeBo3paCTHbie HllcneBalouHe Cniejible HfiepecToHfHbIe

PacnpeaejieHHe no rpynnaM BO3paCTaHCTOqNHK: YrpaBneHHe nJeCaMH Xa6apOBCKOrO Kpan, 1995 r.

Page 166: Russian - World Bank Documents

Puc. A.2: Bo3pacTfoe pacflpeaeJieHHe niecoB KpaclHospcKoro KpasI,

1993 r.

35. j5 HpoqHe MSrKO-.IiHCTBeHHbie nOpOJbI

30 U Ocia

25 M Bepe3a

20 M KeAp

_ _-=,,.A. -^;'' J'HCTBCHHHUa

10

00

5 - 0 CocHa

MoJIomnKH I IKa. MojioaHiKsH II Ka. CpelweBo3pacTHble HpHcneBalonue Cnebie H

nepec'roHHbie

PacupeaejieHHe no rpynnaM Bo3pacTa11CTONHNK: KoMErci no necy KpacnoupcKoro Kpan, 1995 r.

Page 167: Russian - World Bank Documents

PHC. A.3: BHOBOe pacnpeaeJIeHHe JIeCOB Xa6apOBCKOrO KpaA,1993 r.

100 _* HPOqHe M511KO-

90 JIHCTBeHHbie fOpOabI

El OcHHa80

* B;epe3a70 2 0 ! H g;l TBepaoJncTBeHHble60

BH,|bl*

2 Keap50

IM JIHCTBeHHHUa40

30 0~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ nHxTa

20 I ii

10 + Cocda

0

HoKpEiTas IiecoM njinoHaJIb O6HtHd 3anac HacaxAeHHH

HCTOIHHK: YDPaBsaeHiHe JIecaMm X*6apoBcKoro xpau, 1995 r.

Page 168: Russian - World Bank Documents

PHc. A.4: B03paCTHal WHHaMHKa 3anaca Haca)eHHNH B

Xa6apoBcKoM Kpae, 1993 r. - CocHa

0l

- - - - - - . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .._.. . . . . . . . . . .... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .............. T

o t 4 l y a~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ReAcTBe HHue

IY _ /,,,, ,, ................. ...

... ... ... ..

- U=Ip - oqle mmo- |

O -l l

l S~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~HCTBeHHble nopop,bl

MonIo,IHAKH I KJI. MonioAHqKH II Ki. CpeAHeBo3pacTtiEie llpHceBaiowe Cneni le H

nepeewfiHmle

Pacnpe,aenieHHe nio rpynnaM so3pacT

HCTO'qHNK: YnpauneHHe AecamH Xa6apo cmoro Kpam, 1995 r.

Page 169: Russian - World Bank Documents

PHc. A.5: Bo3pacTHaf TwHaMKa 3anaca Haca)IeHH B

KpacHoApcKoM Kpae, 1993 r.300 - + CocHa

250 --------------------- -------------------- -------------------- -----------....-. E.Cu

,U *200

------

- - - ------------------- -

s100 - -- - -- - -- - -- - ;!.,.,..... ,,' ....................- -lepa50 -4/ Liz "i .- B - - _

- - - - -- - - - - - - -- OCHHa50--. -,i _ _ + pom - -- HpO'Ne MSDKO-

° < _ -- I ncTseHHue nopoAuMojoxHWKU I Kn. MoioaJHqKH II Ka. Cpeaeno3pacmHbIe lpHcueBaiouHe CnenbIe H

nepecToi{Hbe

Pacnpe,aeneHHe no rpynnaM BO3pacTaHCrOq0HK: KOMnTeT no niecy KpacHonpcKOro Kpan, 1995 r.

Page 170: Russian - World Bank Documents

166 nPtJIOKEH4E A

Bblwe roAOBoro o6'beMa jieCO3arOTOBKM B o6o0x KpaqX, HO paC4eTbI npUipOCTa BKJIIO4alOT U

Te nfloiWaaH, KOTOpbie oxpaH5lOTCqi (neca I ii 1I rpynn).

JeCOYMpOACTBO

11,MA Bcex 3KOHOMHieCKH aOCTynHbIX niecoB CyLueCTBYIOT neCOYCTP0uTenbHbie

npOeKTbl, B KOTOpbMX noapo6Ho pacnHcaHbi Bce neCO3arOT MjH eponpHqTUI U

,apyrHe pa6oTbl, 3anTaHHpOBaHHbie Ha aeC51THAieTHHAi nepHoa. 9TH FIpOeKTbl OCHOBbIBaiOTC5

Ha pe3ynbTaTax HHBeHTaPH3aLuHH .ecOB, B xoae KOTOpOA KaAcAbie 10 neT nPOBOANTC. yMeT

Kaxaoro oTAeAbHorO Haca)eHwq. B npHHUHre, B Te4eHHe 3TOFO aeCqTHJIeTHerO UHKJ]a

e)KeroAHo HHBeHTapH3HpylOT npHMepHo no 10% necHOi nAoutaaPl, COCTaBARSq 3aTeM

COOTBeTCTBYIOULUHf JieCOyCTpOHTeJlbHbiI npOeKT. UeJIb HHBeHTaPH3aUHH 3aKJ]I04aeTC51 B

oLeHKe o61eMa cnejiblX HacawaeHiH npH CTaHaapTHOr4 nOrpeWHOCTH B 10%, a TaK)Ke

o&beMa cpeaHeBO3paCTHbIX HUH npHcneBaolHOI X HacaHXeH npui CTaHaapTHOR

norpeWuHOCTH Ha YPOBHe 20%. IIHBeHTapH3au4H, TaKcauLHq H noarOTOBKa npoeKTOB

npOBOX45ITC.q rpOd)eCCHOHaAbHbIMH IieCOBoaaMH perHOHanbHbIX JieCOYCTPOHTeSJbHbIX

npe,ripHflTHi, KOTOpbIe BMJIOTCS qaCTbIO CHCTeMbl DeaepaAbHoA cjiyK6bi niecHoro

XO3AACTBa (CM. pHc. A.2 Bbiwe no TeKCTy).

HonHbl u ieCOyCTpOHTeJ1bHblHi npoeKc OXBaTbJBaeT O,4HH neCXo3 HnH JIeCHH'IeCTBO

H o6bIqHO BKlOtioaeT cuiepyouuHe aaHHbie: o6iuyio XapaKTepHCTHKY 3KoJorH4ecKHx,

KARMaTH,-eCKHX H nO4BeHHb[X ycnOBH4u; noapo6Hoe TaKCaUHOHHOe onHcaHHe Ka)1oro

HacawxceH9s (no noKa3aTensim: nOpOaHblg COCTaB, 6OHHTeT, 3anac .neca Ha KOpHIo) H

MeponpHRTHSl, 3annaHHpoBaHHble Ha cJepy1oLuHi aeC3qTHu1eTHHA nepHoa. B 3TOT aOKyMCHT

BKJIio4alOTC2 TaKXKe KpaTKHe CBeJ4eHHi4 nO 3anacy nieca Ha KOPHIO B nlecXo3e, pacnpeaeuIeHHIo

no Kiiaccam BO3paCTa H cpeaHeg npOf4yKTHBHOCTH, paBHO KaK H pacqeTHas niecoceKa AxAR

Ku(aoro roaa H3 cAeayoLuH xaeCqTH neT. K npoeKTy npunaraioT MHoro4HcjIeHHble KapTbl.

HpH pa3pa6oTKe 3THX llpOeKTOB KOHCYJIbTaUHi HH C MeCTHbIM HaceJeHHeM, HH C

TeppHTOpHaJIbHbIMH opraHami BJaCTH o6bIqHO He npOBOAHTC5I. J]eCOyCTpO0TeAbHblH npOeKT

HanpaBni.eTC.q B (DeaepaAbHyIO cjiyK6y necHoro Xo35IfCTBa B MOCKBY JAn5 OKOHtlaTeAbHOrO

yTBep)KaeHHIN; 3TO - 4bopMaj]bHaq npoueaypa, B xoxe KOTOpOU peaKO Bo3HHKaioT BOHpOCbI

HunH npOH3BOaRTC31 1I3MeHeHHR. B IPOWJIOM OKOHqaTeJTbHbIH BaPUaHT npoeKTa HarpaBjSiAiH

MeCTHbIM PYKOBOX1HTenAM B BHae riepenneTeHHbIx TOMOB. B nocneaHee BpeMq B

Xa6apoBcKoM Kpae HHqjOpMaLuHm no JeCOYCTpOHTeJbHbiM npOeKTaM XpaH14TC5 B

3JieKTPOHHOM 43opMaTe, Ha alHCKeTaX, KOTOPbie HiaripaBjqIOTC5 pyKOBOfl4Teji5M X03>HiCTB UAnq

HCnOJ1b3OBaHH5I B xoae npouecca onepaTBuHoro niaHHpOBaH4H3. O,RHaKo .THLUb HeMHorHe

perHOHbI HMIeOT COOTBeTCTBYIOL1U4e KOMrHbIOTepHbie C4CTeMbI. J,j5a HOBbIwCeHH14 Ka'eCTBa

ynpaBAeHHs, Heo6xoaHMO He TOJIbKO o6ecneMHmTb PYKOBOaHTeieg 6onee COBpeMeHHbIMI4

TeXHH4eCKHMH cpeACTBaMH, HO H npeaycMOTpeTb co3AaHHe KapTorpa4)H4eCKHx 6a3 ,RaHHbIX C

HCnOnb3oBaHHeM TeXHOJ]OrHH reorpa4HuqeCKHX HH4OpMaRULOHHbIX CHCTCM (FHC).

Onpe,aeJeHwe pacqenioft .iecoceKu. PacMeTHasl necoceKa (PJI) - 3TO

MaKcHManJbHbiI roaoBoo o6fteM neca, KOTOpblHi MO)KHO 3arOTasBJIHaTb B Te4eHHe

IeCRTHAIeTHero nepHoAa, coxpaH31.9 npH 3TOM aOnrOCpO4HyIO yCTOfliHBOCTb JTeCHbIX

pecypcoB. PJI onpeaeuiHeTcA Ha YPOBHe necxo3a HJIH JecHH4ecTBa, H 3aTeM Ha ocHoBe

COBOKynHOCTH 3THX OLeHOK nO BceM JieCXO3aM (necHuiecTBaM) onpeaenqeTCq per4OHanbHaq

Page 171: Russian - World Bank Documents

167 I1PHAO)KEHHE A

PI. HloKa3aTeJIH onpeieAflRIOTC KaK AnR py6OK riiaBHoro rlonb3oBaHHs4, TaK H Anq py6oKyxo,aa H lpO4HX BH4AOB py6oK.

PJI anm py6oK riiaBHoro nOJIb3OBaHHR9 onpeAeAgeTcs3 C nOMOLUblO qeTblpex pa3HbIX(JOpMyJI, B KOTOpbIX He3aBHCHMbIMH nepeMeHHbIMu 5IBJIIIOTCI 3anac cnenioro H cnejoLueroneca Ha KOPHIO H oueHKa BeJH-iqHHbl npHpOcTa. HCXoaHaA qopMyiia 6bmAa pa3pa6oTaHaMHOrO nIeT TOMY Ha3aA B repMaHHH H HCnOJIb3OBaAaCb AAAl pacqeTa pa3MepOB nOCTOSHHoro_HeHCTOLuuTenJbHOrO JeconOJIb3OBaHH5 C ueAbIO npOH3BORCTBa apeBecHHbl B TeqeHHe 20-30neT. npH onpeaeaeHHH PJI ciieayeT YqHTb[BaTb TOJlbKO 3KOHOMHqeCKH 4AOCTynHble nieca;neca, pacTy1iHe Ha CKJ1OHax, KpyTH3Ha KOTOpbIX rpeBbilaeT 210 H neca, OTBeheHHbie noa3arlOBe,aHbie H OXpaHAIeMbie TeppHTOpHH, AOJDKHbI 6blTb HCKjlOqeHbI U3 3TOH 4bOpMyJ1bl.

PJA nuif py6OK yxoaa H ApyrHX BHAOB py6oK onpenejiseTcs Ha OCHOBaHHHTaKCaUlUOHHbIX o6cAeaOBaHHA, B xoae KOTOpbIX YCTaHaBBJTBalOT TaKHe 6Ho.norH4ecKHenapaMeTpbl, KaK ROYHOTa apeBOCTOA H HY)KHoe CoqeTaHHe nopoa. PeKOMeHaauHHTaKcaTOPOB paccMaTPHBalOTCH TeppHTOpHaAbHblM OpraHOM ynpaBJIeHHSI JIeCHbIM X03AHrCTBOM,KOTOpblH4 npHHHMaeT peuleHue 0 TOM, qTO (baKTH44eCK4 6yaeT aCeaTbCq B LaHHblH nepHOA BYCJIOBH5IX KOHKpCTHbIX (HHaHCOBbIX H KaapOBbIX OrpaHHqeHHHH4. 3TOT THi P11 peAKo rAe-JIH6o ynOMHHaeTCq, riOCKOJbKy OH OXBaTbIBaCT CTOJIb MaTylO oioJio o60tero of6beMa py6oK.

XoTfl CyLueCTBYIOLuaq CHCTeMa onpeaeneHHfl paCqeTHoH necoceKH BnOJ1HeJIOFHqHa, Ha ripaKTHKe OHa HMCeT 4eTbipe HeaOCTaTKa, KOTOpbIe MOryT nIpHBOAHTb KnepeKocam H Bbl3blBaTb aoArocpOqHbie OTPHuaTeAbHbie nocnieACTBH5, HapywaioLutIeyCTOHMHBOCTb JieCHbIX peCypCOB:

* * 4aKTH4eCKOe OTCTpaHeHHe MeCTHOrO HaCeAeHHI OT rOiarOTOBKH.inecoyCTpOHTeJIbHbIX ripoeKTOB rIpHBOalHT K TOMy, ITO HaceAeHHe He3aHHTepeCOBaHO B ycnexe TaKHX npoeKTOB H He rOTOBO nOMOraTb BHpeo,aojieHHH TpyaHOCTerl, Bo3HHKaioLUHX B xoae ero ocylueCTBneHHuf. 9 TolBJI5ieTCSI cepbe3HbIM HeJaOCTaTKOM, oco6eHHo B TeX paHOHax, rae nec

npe,aCTaBjiAeT co6ori OCHOBHOHi HCTO4HHK aOXOaOB, HJH rae iieca paCTYTP5lLIOM C HacenCJHHbIMH nyHKTaMH. KOHCyJIbTaTHBHblHi nOaXoa Kpar1HeBa)KeH AflA YMeTa B nniaHe HpHpOaoOXpaHHbIX H jieCO3aLuRTHbIX ueAei.

* HecMoTpAi Ha 3aKOHoaaTeAbHble Tpe6OBaHHl4, 3anOBeaHble H oxpaHqeMbieTCppHTOpUUH 'aCTO aOJIXHbIM o6pa3OM He yq'HTbiBalOTCl npHH onpegeJieHiHPn.

* XOTAI Ka)LbIhl pyKOBOaHTeJb ieCxo3a JAOJDKeH HCXOaHTb U3 Pi gAql cBoeroKOHKpeTHoro JIeCXo3a, eCTb taHHbIe, CBHaeTeJTbCTBYIOLu4e 0 TOM, ITOHHOUma BMCCTO 3Toro HCflOJb3ylOTC5I COBOKyn1Hbie perHOHaJIbHbie Pji, 'TOnpHBOLaHT K qpe3MepHO9 Bblpy6Ke B OaHHX paHOHaX, B TO BpeM31 KaK BnapyrHx (MeHee aOCTyrHbIX) PJI HCHOJ1b3yeTC5l He riOJIHOCTbIO.

Page 172: Russian - World Bank Documents

PHC. A.6: (DaKTHqeCKHe O6beMbI JIeCO3arOTOBOK B Xa6apOBCKOM

Kpae, 1984-96 rr.16 - 140 _ ilPoqie py6KU

14 10

6.

12 Py6K yxoIIa H

O00 . .. -60 .......OprnHOIr

~~~~~~ io ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~caHHTapHbie80 ~~e py6KH

80

2 UJI_ I I _ L L l [20 1 3,6aOrOHOaIb30BaHHS1

40

4~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~4 a -.-- Cpe)XHHii

o6sem

2 20 3arOTOBOK nO

JiiaBHOMY

flOJII63oBaHHIo,

- -

0 Ky6. m/rain ~z t- 0 al V- eq n v n~

00 00 00 00 00 00 ON O 0 0 O

H4CT0IHUK: Xa6apoBcKoe yupagenue iecamiw, 1996 r.

Page 173: Russian - World Bank Documents

PHC. A.7: (PaKTHqeCKHe 06oeMbI JieCO3arOTOBOK B KPaCHOHPCKOMKpae, 1984-96 rr.

30 -300 1 _ IPOqHe py6KU

25- 250

eZ* Py6KU yxo!aa Hr 20 t - * * _ - * - = - b ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~Bbl60pOqHbie*2000 caHHTapHbie

m O py6K H

O 15 150 P6

~ - y6KH

rJiaBHoroNO3I3OBaHHR10

100 0

--w- CpeaHHiii5 - ~~~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~50 u o6,beM3aroToBoK norniaBHOMy0 -noJIl3oBaHHIO,

IV V) \o° t- XX CX o° > el en IV U>) \oz Ky6. M/ra

HCTOqHiNK: KOMNTeT HO niecy KpaCHOqpCKOrO Kpam, 1996 r.

Page 174: Russian - World Bank Documents

170 nPHJAOKEHHE A

*Asi MaKCuM13auim npoH3BOACTBa KawKoe HacawxeHHe T1OJDKHO

BbIpy6aTbC5I B TOM BO3paCTe, KOTOpbIU HaH6onee 6nm3OK K OnTHMajibHOMy

B03paCTy py6K4. CeroRHqWHi4e MeTOabI onpeaeAeHiqH PJI, BepOqTHO, .aalOT

3aHH)KeHHbie OLueHKH, T.K. pa3mep HenpepbIBHorO HeHCTOULUTenJbHOrO

nOh1b3OBaHHR onpeaecseTcA AXAR OTHOCHTeAbHo He6onbLwoH nniowaaui

(.recXo3 unu JIeCHHqeCTBO), 4CXOaqS 13 Toro, 'TO AoOJroCpOMHbIM

pe3ynJbTaTOM AIOJDKHO 6bITb HopMaJ]'Hoe BO3paCTHoe pacnpeReJIeHHe.

3aHHwKeHHbie OueHKH npHPOCTa TaloKe 6yayT npHBOU14Tb K CHH)KeH4IO

pa3mepa PJI.

)JnSI YCOBepwUeHCTBOBaH14,9 o6Luero npouecca pa3MemeHwl1 3eMeJb npH

nO,FOTOBKe JieCOYCTPOHTenJbHbIX npOeKTOB cJieayeT:

* C4opMi4poBaTb pa6oqHrw KOMHTeT, COCTOAWKA U3 MeCTHbix npeAcTaB14TeJieHi

I>eaepa.nbHOA CJIy)K6bI niecHoro XO35IICTBa, IieCHbIX Hay'4HO-

Hcciie,aOBaTenJbCK4X opraH1U3auHi4, aepeBOnepepa6aTbIBaloLHux oTpacJIer4,

Focy,aapcTBeHHorO KOMHTeTa no oxpaHe oKpy)KaloLuer cpeRbl,

MHHHCTepCTBa npHpORHb1X peCypCOB, MeCTHb]X opraHOB BJIaCTi4,

npe,acTaB14Teieri KOpeHHbIX HaPOAOB 14 HenpaBUTeibCTBeHHbX

opraH143auHi. 3ToT KOM14TeT AOJ)KeH pyKOBOaUTb pa3pa6OTKoru npoeKTa.

* OnpeeienHTb JiecocblpbeByio 6a3y, BKJlio'aloXYIO B CBOH COCTaB rpynny

niecXo30B, pacHonO)KeHHbIX B npeiejiax HpHpofAHoA BOAOc6opHorl njioWa.ua4

KaKoro-TO y)Ke cywecTByloluero aepeBoo6pa6aTb1Balousero LIeHTpa.

FapaMeTpbl JIeCOCbIpbeBb1X 6a3 MO)KHO 6bu1o 6bl H3MeHS1Tb npH roqBJ1eHH14

HOBbIX KpynHbIX aepeBOo6pa6aTbIBalouHxX npeHnpHlT1UH.

* OnpexaeHnTb Tpe6OBaHH5I no oxpaHe 14 3aLLt14Te niecoB, a TaKXce apyr14e

orpaHHu4eHH. Ha npoMbIwJIeHHoe JIeconOJnb30BaHi4e, OKa3bIBsaLOWe npsmoe

BJ1151HIe Ha YpOBHH 3arOTOBKH ApeBeCHHbl. Heo6xoa4MO TaKxe yqHTb1BaTb

Tpe6oBaHHR no npoH3BoaCTBy HeapeBeCHbIx npOAyKTOB 14 Hy)KAbl

KOpeHHOrO HaceiieHHuS.

* CMOae.U14pOBaTb pa3HbIe cueHapi4ii ypOBHeC 3arOTOBK14 apeBecHHbl Ha

OCHOBaHH14 nOapO6HOR KHq)OpMaLum, noJiyqeHHOri B xoae iieCOyCTpOiCTBa,

H 14CKJHO'IITb 13 paCqeTOB Te 3OHbl, r,e JieconOJlb3OBaHf4e orpaHuI4eHO unu114

3anpeiueHO. Pe3ynbTaTbi MoaeJIHpOBaHHs Kaworo CLieHapi451 aOADKHbl

o6cyxIIaTbCs pa6oq41M KOM4TeTOM, noCJieaHU4U B KOHe'IHOM HTore aoJ)KeH

npH1H5Tb HeKiri eR14Hblg CueHapt4i, KOTOPblU 14 MO)KeT CTaTb nJlaHOM

3arOTOBKH LpeBec4Hbl Ha nHTH- HJIH ,ACCTHJIeTHH9 nepi4ot.

* JIeCOX03SHICTBeHHbie opraHbl U J1eCO3arOTOB1TeJIbHbie u

AepeBOnepepa6aTbIBaioLut1e nlpeanlpSiT14I AOfDKHbl aeACTBOBaTb B paMKaX

YTBepeHHOrO niaHa. nIniaH aoOJiKeH TaK)e C03,aaBaTb OCHOBY Ul5

onepaTHBHOro nAaHHpOBaHH4 necO3arOTOBITeJlbHbIX 14 .JeCOBOACTBeHHbIX

Meporpi45THii Ha YPOBHe iecXo3a H =rn cTpaTeri4qecKoro nniaHI4pOBaHH45 B

xaepeBonepepa6aTbIBaioLLLeH OTpaCJIH. np14 143MeHeHUU14 HCXOAHbIX

napaMeTpOB, ie)KaLU4X B OCHOBC nruaHa, ero cjieRiyeT nepecMOTpeTb,

noBTOP1B Bce 3Tanbi ero pa3pa6OTKH.

Page 175: Russian - World Bank Documents

171 nPHI4O4CEHHE A

BocHpou3Bw4cTBo JIecHIx peCypCoB. B CH6HpU HCnOJ1b3yiOT nATb MeTOROBBOCrPOH3BO2ICTBa nieca: eCTeCTBeHHoe BO3o6HOBJIeHHe, Bbl6opo4Hbie py6KH, HCKyCCTBeHHblinoceB, rOCaaKy H coqeTaHHe eCTeCTBeHHOrO H HCKYCCTBeHHOrO Bo3o6HoBjieHH$.E-cecrseHHoe Bo3o6HoRfIeHme - 3geKTHBHblU MeTOA BOCnPOH3BOaCTBa Ha 60J1b[HXTeppHTopHAx, oco6eHHo TaM, rae npeo6Aa,aioLueri nopoaor4 ABJAeTCS cocHa. ,asA WToroMeTo,a THnIH4Hbl HK3KHe 3aTpaTbl, rIiaBHbIM o6pa3OM Ha npOBCeeHHe OCBeTAeHHS(HenpoMblwjleHHblx py6OK yxoaa) cpa3y noc.ne 3aKnTaaKH HOBbIX HacawczeHHA. B 3TOM cniyqaerapaHTHpOBaHO, MTO HOBaA reHepauHsi 6yaeT HMeTb TOT ice reHeTH'eCKHfl COCTaB, 4TO Hnpegbiaytuas, a 3TO MO)KeT 6biTb 6o.nbuHM npeHMyIIeCTBOM B TeX paiOHax, rue py6sTecTeCTBeHHblu n7eC H rae xKeiaTeAbHO coxpaHATb Te BHabl, KoTopbIe yuKe aaarITHPpoBait4Cb KaaHHb[M KJHMaTH4eCKHM H rIOqBeHHbIM yCJIOBHAM.

CeMeHHble aepeBsE cneayeT Bbl6HpaTb o4eHb BHHMaTeCJbHO. B HeKOTOpbIXpaUoHax B KaqeCTBe HCTO'HHKOB ceMSH ocTaBJIAAH cila6bie H roBpe)KWeHHbie aepeBbR,BMeCTO Toro qTo6bi OCTaBHTb CaMbIe CHAbHbie aepeBbq C 6o0iee KCeiaTeCjbHb1MHreHeTHMecKHMH xapaKTepHCTHKaMH. Ha pgae yqaCTKOB, npeHHa3HaqeHHbIX AAs rOCaaKH niecaB KaqeCTBe HCTO4HHKKa ceMSH HCnOJIb3OBaJIH He cpy6fleHHble nOJIOCbi eCTeCTBeHHoro niecaWHpUHOUi B 50 M, HO paCCTOSHHe MeC)ay 3THMH nojiocaMH oXoaHJIo o 300 M. 9TOT MeTOABpH,LL iH MO)KeT npHHeCTH yaOBjieTBOPHTeJIbHbie pe3yJIbTaTbl, TaK KaK K3BeCTHO, xiTOMaKCHMaJTbHaS 4aJlbHOCTb paCCeHBaHHA CeMSH COCHbl paBHa IHJIHe OgHoro aepeBa OTHCTO4HHKa ceMAH, cAeAOBaTejibHo 80% rJioLiauH ocTaeTCA HeoxBaqeHHOr4. aaKe ecJIH BAecoceqHb[X oTxoaax 6ygeT HaXOaHTbCA HeKOTOpOe KOJIH4eCTBO )KH3HecrOco6HblX CeMSH,eCTeCTBeHHOe Bo3o6HoBjieHHe, cKopee Bcero, 6yaeT OCyweCTBJIATbCA OqeHb HepaBHOMepHO,KaK C TOqKH 3peHH5 pacnpeaeJIeHHA ceMSH no uinoLuaaH y4aCTKOB, TaK H C TOqKH 3peHHSryCTOTbl nOCauKH.

Bm6opoqhmc py6KH HCnOJIb3ylOTC B OCHOBHOM ARA BOCnpOH3BOaCTBa nieca TaM,r,ae npeo6.naaalOT TeHeBbIHOCJIHBb1e BMAbN, HaripMiiep nxTa H eJlb. EciH MapKHPOBKaLaepeBbeB B py6Ky HlpOK3BOLIHTCA KBaJH4)4UHHPOBaHHbIMH CHeuLHanHCTaMH, a JleCo3a-rOTOBHTeiiH py65lT TOJIbKO nOMeqeHHbie aepeBbq, ripH 3TOM CTapaACb He nOBpeaLTb HHocTaBJI5eMbie LepeBbR, HH nIOqBy, TO 3TOT MeTO.1 MO)KeT aaBaTb BbICOKOKat[eCTBeHHbiepa3HOBO3paCTHble nieca. C TO'YKH 3peHHA 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3lR 3TOT BHR BOCrlpOH3BOACTBao6ecneiHBaeT coxpaHeHie cyLueCTBYIOLIHX 3KOCHCTeM B YCOBHsAx jiecorOOJb3OBaHHA.He,aOCTaTKaMH 3Toro meToga ABEIl5OTCAI BbICOKHe 3aTpaTbl Ha jieco3aroToBKy (HH3KHe o6'beMbl3arOTOBKH ApeBeCHHbl c reicrapa) H oriaCHOCTb paCTpaTbi reHeTHqecKoro KanHTaJia Bpe3yJIbTaTe rOCTeneHHOA Bbipy6KH JIyWuHX epeBbeB.

HCAyCCTBeHHJIIf HoceB MO)ceT aOnOnHATb eCTeCTBeHHOe BO3o6HoBJIeHHe, WTO aeTnpeKpacHbie pe3ynJbTaTbl npH OTHOCHTeCJbHO HU3KHX 3aTpaTax, ecAH OH npOBOlHTCA nonpaBHJIaM. 3ToT MeTOa Tpe6yeT HanHuIHA Haae)KHorO HCTO'IHHKa 6oJIbuHX 06'beMOBBb1COKOKa,eCTBeHHbIX ceMSH Ho ripHeMneMor4 ueHe. 'To6b1 o6ecneq4Tb COOTBeTCTBHe MeKayYCJIOBHAMH HPOH3pacTaHHS H ceMeHaMH, Heo6xoaHMo cTporo KOHTpoji4poBaTb npOuC-xo)LeHHe u pacnpocTpaHeHHe CeMflH.

JlOCa4,K ABJISeTCA npeanlOqTHTeJIbHbIM MeTOAOM B Tex paMOHax, rae cyLueCT-ByioLuHf nec HMeeT HeriOuXOuALUHA nOpO.lAHblI COCTaB B aaHHbIX YCJIOBHAX llPO43paCTaHHUAHuH CJIHllIKOM cna6, WTO6bI BO3o6HOBJI5TbCH eCTeCTBeHHbIM nyTeM, r4e Heo6xou4MoHHTPOAYUHpOBaTb HOBbIe BHabl iniH )Ke rue nO4BeHHbie YCJTOBHA He nOAXOAqT AnS apyrHxcnoco6OB BocnpoH3BOaCTBa nieca. nocauKa o6bIqHO ABnSeTCR HaH6oJlee aoporoCTOALUHM

Page 176: Russian - World Bank Documents

172 HlPRJO)KEHME A

MeTOXLOM BocnpoH3BoACTBa, H ee cneAyeT ICnOJlb3OBaTb TOAbKO TorFa, Kor,aa o6meCTBeHHble

BbIrolabl, He CB53aHHbIe C IiecoM, paBHbl HunH npeBblUwaiOT 3TH 3aTpaTbI.

COq'7CHfMC HCKYCCTBeHHOrO H eCTeCTBeHHOrO Bo3o6HoBAeHH5 WlHPOKO

npHMeHIeTC5 flJaIm nojiMyeHH HacaW)eHHA C KOHKpeTHblMu HOKa3aTenjiMti B XRaHHbIX

YCJ1OBH5IX npoH3paCTaHHA.

B nociieaHHe 50 nieT 6o0JbwaR aonsI Bo3o6HoBjieHHbIx necoB oTjiH4aJIaCb H43KHM

KateCTBOM, T.K. YXOay 3a iiecoM U neCOBOACTBeHHbIM MeponpHH5TH$M yaenjMnjOCb oeHb Manjo

BHHMaHH.q. I4cnoJIb3OBaHHe pa3HbIX MeTOaOB BOcnpOH3BOaCTBa AecoB 3a nociieAHHe 10 nieT

noKa3aHO Ha puc. A.8 (Ha npumepe Xa6apoBcKoro Kpasq) u Ha pHc. 1.8 B OCHOBHOM TeKCTe

aoKiiaAa (Ha npHMepe KpaCHOspCKoro Kpasl). HHKaKHX CTaTHCTHMeCKHX RaHHbIX nO

HcnOnb3OBaHH1O Bbi6OpO'IHbIX py6oK noJIy'tiTb He y)aajOCb. KaPTHHa npHMeHeHHiq pa3HbIX

MeTO1OB B 3THX aByX perHoHax npHMepHO OAHa H Ta Ice: c 1988 roaa npOHCXORHT CHH)KeHHe

o&fbeMOB nocaAKH H cyiueCTBeHHoe yBenjMieHHe njioiuaaeri, ocTaBjiqembix noa eCTeCTBeHHoe

Bo3o6HoBjTeHHe. B CBMI3H C COKpalueHHeM (j3HHaHCHpOBaHHU H3 epeaepaxibHoro 6ioaiKeTa,

KoTOpOe npOHCXOJ1HT B noceIHHe roMAbN, HeTpyaHO nOH5Tb, noMemy OCHOBHbIM

HHCTpyMeHTOM BOCnPOH3BOACTBa AecoB CTaHOBHTCM eCTeCTBeHHOe BO3o6HoBJIeHHe, oco6eHHO

ecAH y'leCTb, 'ITO B nepBbIe HeCKOnbKO neT eCTecTBeHHoe Bo3o6HoBJIeHHe Tpe6yeT o0eHb

He6onbuiux 3aTpaT. Ho TeHaeHUHM K CHH)KeHHio o6beMOB MepOnIpHifTHA nO yXoAy 3a

B03o6HOBHBWIHMHCMq nHjOIU]ixSMH Bbl3blBaeT o3a6oqeHHOCTb, nOTOMy 'TO eCTeCTBeHHOe

Bo3o6HoBjieHHe AOJDKHO CoqeTaTbC5i C COOTBeTCTBYIOWUHM yXOLOM 3a HOBbIMU

HacamKfeHHAMH4, MHame HeBO3MO)KHo 6yAeT BbipaCTHTb BbICOKOKaqeCTBeHHbl4 nec H

COXpaHHTb 6oraTCTBo 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3sl.

B 60JmbWHHCTBe paUiOHOB CH6HpH eCTeCTBeHHOe BO3o6HoBJIeHHe qBji5eTCM CaMbIM

noaxo,1ISutM cnoco6oM BOcnpoK3BOACTBa nieca, KaK nlOTOMy, 'TO MeaJeHHbl4 pOCT JIleCOB

eienaeT HeonpaBIaHHbIMH 6o0iee BbICOKHe 3aTpaTbl Ha apyrHe enoco6bi, TaK H 13-3a BbiroR

COXpaHeHHUM 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3Hi. ARnA Toro 4To6bi nOJIyqHTb xopouWHe pe3yJIbTaTbl, Heo6-

XO,HMO OCTaBj1iTb B Ka'-eCTBe CeMeHHHKOB JyqILHue LepeBbM, paBHOMepHO pa3MeCu1eHHbie Ha

,aHHOii njioluaam (cKa)KeM, 15-20 AepeBbeB Ha reicrape). 4)opMa H pa3Mep fecoceqHbIX

nnoua,aeri AOfDKHbl BbI6HpaTbcI TaK, qTo6bi OHH MorJiH MHHHMH3HPOBaTb BJIRHHe BeTpOB.

CeMeHHbie ,aepeBbq cieayeT cpy6aTb nocnie nOMBneHHm eCTeCTBeHHOrO Bo3o6HoBJIeHHiM H

Korja aOXO,bI MOryT KOMneHCHpOBaTb 3aTpaTbl Ha HeO6xOaRMbIe HerpOMbbIwJ1eHHble py6KI4

yxo,aa (ocBeTneH4e) 3a B03o6HOBHBUIHMCM Haca)KaeHHeM. HenpoMblmweHHble py6KH yxoxta

cnexyeT npoBoLHTb B onpeaenJeHHb[e CPOKU (cKaIKeM, qepe3 5-10 neT nocne JIecO3aroToBK4),

HHaqe 3aTpaTbl Ha npOBseeHiie py6oK yxoaa 3HaqHTenbHO BO3pacTyT, a ceMeHHbie AepeBbI

npH HX BajiKe HaHecyT 6onbwe noBpe)KleHHPk Bo3o6HOBHBuIUMCM1 HacaxcleHHRM.

BoJ1pocm BgCiACHHZ IecHror xo3afcTa

JIeCO3arOTOBHTeJlbHbie pa60Tbl B CH6HPH B 3HaMHTeJ]bHOR CTelleHH nlpCeCTaBJIlIOT

co6o0i "xao6blqy" neca - pecypc gKcnnyaTHpyeTCq ao Tex nop, noKa OH He UCTOUlHTCM, a

3aTeM npOH3BOACTBO nepeaBHraeTCA B ApyroFi patioH. rlpexwe 4eM B 3THX niecax MOKHO

6yneT BHOBb 3aFOTaBJIHBaTb apeBeCHHy, npOp21eT MHHI4MYM 100 JIeT, KpOMe TOrO, B HOBbIX

necax Mo)KeT co0epWaTbCA MeHbuwe UeHHbIx nopoA. CeroaHs IiecHbie 3eMJIH,

paCnOjiO)KeHHbie HeaajieKO OT npOMbbIwJieHHbIX UeHTPOB, llOJ1HOCTbIO JIHlUHJIHCb LeHHbIX

Page 177: Russian - World Bank Documents

173 nPRAO)KEHHE A

JAeCOB, H aepeBonIepepa6aTbIBaioLuaq OTpaCJlb BbIHyKLeHa OTXORU4Tb Bce RaajbWe H aauibwe OT9THX UeHTpOB, 4TO6bI HaUTH BbICOKOKaqeCTBeHHbie HCTO4HHKH tapeBeCHblX peCypCoB.

BO BTOpU{HbHX necax, BbIPOCUIHX Ha Bbipy6Kax, npeo6naaaloT MqrKOJiHCTBeHHbleBHlIbl THna 6epe3bl (Betula pubescens) H OCHHbI (Populus tremula). XOTS Ha 3TUX niouiaa3ixca)KajuI XBOHHbIe BH4,Ibl THna COCHbI (Pinus spp.) H HIXTbl (Abies sibirica), 6epe3a U OCHHa,noAsinsKoiurecCA 3aeCb CaMOCeBOM, pacTyr 6blcTpee, 'eM XBOiHbie. Co BpeMeHeM yrHeTeHHbleXBOUiHbie CMeHAT 9TH nHOHepHbie BHibl, HO H3Ha4aIbHoe npeo6AaaaH4e 6epe3bl H OCHHbIMO)KeT 3a.lep)KaTb CYKUeCCHIO Ha UenbIX 60 neT.

loca,aKa COCHbI Ha "'aCTKax nociie npopaCTaHu4s Ha HUX 6epe3bl H OCUHbiTpe6yeT o4eHb BbICOKHX 3aTpaT (OHH B TpH pa3a Bblwe, -eM 3aTpaTbl Ha nOCaAKY HaBbIpy6Kax) H BPAa 11nu npHHeceT )KeJiaeMbie pe3yJlbTaTbI JIY'IIHM peweHHieM MO7AeT 6blTbnpOBe,IeHHe py6oK yxoaa C uejibio yTaaeHHtI 3THX MqrHKOJIHCTBeHHb[X BHROB, ITO6bI MOJ[OqbleXBOUHbie paCTeHHA MorJiH roJIy'aTb aocTaTO11Ho CBeTa Ans cBoero 6blcTporo pa3BHTHI. CoBpeMeHeM py6KH yxoAa MorJiH 6bl CTaTb caMo4HHaHCHPYIOWuHMHCS pa6oTaMH, puH YCJIOBHHco3IaaHH.I pbIHKOB apeBecBHbi 6epe3bl H OCHHbl. B5epe3a cTania OleHb nOHyflSIpHoil roporogcpeiAH AepeBOnepepa6oTqHKOB EBponbl, KpOMe Toro, OHa aaeT npeKpacHyIo TonHJ1BHYIO.apeBeclHy. OCHHa xopowua AnS rpoH3BoaCTBa ULeJiJlOJIO3bl H apCBeCHbIX HpoayKTOB,HCnOflb3yeMbIX B creuHd)HxeCKX 4uenSIX THHa CTPOHTeCJbCTBa cayH.

Ywep6 OT JccHII Hoxapog, HeaceKoAa H ,H1yFfX KaKOpOB. BIOJIbWIHHCTBOJICCHblX noxKapOB BO3HHKaeT B CBI3H C qeAOBeqeCKoH aeqTeJlbHOCTb[O B paroHax, rge BeAeTCqnpoMbIUjIeHHaA 3arOTOBKa nieca. BoKpyr Xa6apoBcKa orpoMHbIe nHjouialiH npeBpaTHIHCb BrepeyBna)KHeHHbie peaHHbl, nOTOMY qTO qaCTbie nO)Kapbl He HO3BOJIqIOT nIeCaMBo3o6HOBJI,STbcSI. 3T0o ABneHHe, BepOAITHO, npeacTaBJsi5eT OJaHy U13 CaMbiX cCpbe3HbX yr'po3AnS paUHOHaTIbHoo ynpaEBieHHA JIecaMw CH6upH.

XOTS B Xa6apoBcKoM Kpae o6iuaA nwoaiaab cropeeBu4x nIeCOB 6oJbwe, 'eM BKpaCHosIpCKoM Kpae (pHc. A.9 H A.10), eCTb aaHHbie, CBiI2aeTCejbCTBYOLWU4e 0 TOM, '4TO BXa6apOBCKOM Kpae npeaOTBpaiueHHe ro)KapoB nOCpeaCTBOM HX paHHero o6HapyxeHwl HHHTeHCHBHOrO TYweHH4A UPHHeCJIO nOJO)KHTeCbHbie pe3yJnbTaTbl. HO TeHaeHU14,q K COKpawe-HHtO paCXOnOB Ha TyIwUeHHe HO)KapOB B o6o0x KpaqX B peanHbHOM BbIPa)KeHU1 Bbl3blBaeT03a6oqeHHOCTb. HanpHMep, Ha pHc. 1.9 (B OCHOBHOUI maCTH aoKnaaa) nOKa3aHO 6OnbUwoeyBeiHqeHHe flAOLLaauH YHHqTOxKeHHbIX nOKapaMH JIecoB POCCee B 1992 roay. 9KOHoMHqeCKHCaMbiM 3q4eKTHBHbIM pewleHHeM 6biAo 6bl COCpeaOTOq-4Tb pa6oTbl HO BOCCTaHOBACHHIO H3arOTOBKe noBpexKLeHHoro Aeca B PaUOHaX, 6AH3KHX K aepeBOnepepa6aTblBafOLugMrpeAnIpH35THl4M H HaceCJeHHbIM nyHKTaM, rae niec UeHHTCA H KaK HCTO'IHHK ApeBecHHbl, HKaK HCTO4HHK peKpeaUHOHHb1X B03MO)KHOCTeUi. B PoccuH eCTb 3HatoLuHe u KBaJmqHU4H POBaHHbie cneUHaIHCTbl, KOTOpb1e MorJii 6bl pa6oTaTb, HpHmeHAS COBpeMeHHbiePUHHLUHnbl H MeTOAbl nocJienocapHOR pea6HnUTaUUU AeCOB, HO 9TOMY MeIIIaeT Kpa4HqSAHe,aOCTaTOqHOCTb H HeorpeaenJeHHOCTb (bHHaHCHpOBaHHS1.

B cpeAHeM B 6OTbWUHCTBe paUOHOB nopaxCeHHe AeCOB HaceKOMbIMU-Bpe,wTenmMH, HO BceH BHAHMOCTH, ABJAeTCS OTHOCHTeAbHO MeHee 3Ha'IHTeJIbHORnpO6AeMOg, HO MeCTaMH HaCeKOMbie Bbl3blBalOT 6OnbUIUe TPYAHOCT4. HanpiMep,BepOATHOCTb Cepbe3HbIX BCnblweK pa3MHO)KeHHA HaceKOMbIX-KCHJIO4oarOB O-4eHb BeJ14Ka HaJieco3arOTOBHTeJbHb1X nJIowaUa3X, rae co)lep)KHTCAS 6OJbwoe KOIH'qeCTBO JiecoceqHbIX

Page 178: Russian - World Bank Documents

HlJIOllb, B TbIflcqaX ra

s ; o X o Go A1984

1985

1986

1987 _

1988

1989

1990

1991

o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o

1994

'0' E

1995

1996 t

LI

Page 179: Russian - World Bank Documents

175 UPHAO)IKEHuE A

OTXO,4OB. B 1995-1996 roaax OaHOA U3 OCHOBHbIX HPH-IHH BbICOKoro oTnaaa aepeBbeB BKpaCHOAPCKOM Kpae cTana HaTOnJrOIqecKaA BcnblWKa cH6HpcKoro wIenKonpgaa, y)Ke BTopax3a riocJIeaHHe 30 ijeT.

IeCconii4aLTui45, Bbl3blBaeMas npOMbIlwleHHbIMH Bbi6pOcaMit, CyaS nO BCeMy, Henpe,acTaBJneT cepbe3Houi npo6JieMbf B CH6HpH, 3a HcKJlo4eHHeM paIioHoB TaKHXrpoMbiwUieHHbIx ueHTpOB, KaK HOPHUbCKHA ropHo-MeTauiiypr41ecKHr KoM6HHaT BKpaCHOAPCKOM Kpae. OaHH TOJIbKO 9TU Bbi6pOCbi e)KeroaHo Bbl3blBaloT ae4joAHaLIaulo nieCOBHa njoHmaaH OKOJIo 500 TbIC. ra. CaMbiM cepbe3HbIM yluep6oM, HaHeceHHbIMnpOMbIlUjeHHbIMH Bbi6pocaMI4 3a OaHOJIeTHHUU nepHoa, no coo 6 1LeHHqM, IBJIMeTCSyHIqTo)KeHHe AeCOB Ha njiowaau OT 40 TbIC. ao 80 TbIC. ra. Pa3pa6oTKa H oCBoeHHeHeqYT.qHbIX MecTopo)weHHtg, ro noJIyqeHHbIM AaHHbIM, TaKwKe Bbl3blBaeT cepbe3HblenOBpew,aeHHR IieCOB CH6upH.

HftgpeBec,mJc npoAyKTm. HeapeBecHbie iieCHbIe npOayKTbI aaBHo HrpaloT BaAKHyioPOJIb B XO3SACTBe ceJibCKoro HaceJleHHA. Ha PbIHKe HeapeBeCHbIX rPORyKTOB TpaHULHOHHOnpeo6nagaloT HJ1ioabi H qroabI (npHMepHo 80%), HO cetiac Ha6 nmoJaeTca 6 bicTpoeyBeJH4qeHHe gojH JIeKapcTBeHHbIx TpaB (c 10% B 1991 roay tRo 24% - B 1993 roay). BHacToAuLee BpeMA npOH3BOQHTCA JHWb O4eHb mayiaA 4aCTb nOTeHUUHaJbHbTX 06'beMOBHPOH3BOAcTBa 3THX HpOQyKTOB, H Aa)Ke OHa ceritac coKpauIaeTcA H3-3a pa3pyuIeHIIACHcTeMbi c6blTa (pHc. A. 11). CornacHo o)KHtiaHHMM, no mepe cTa6HJIH3aUHH 3KOHOMHKHo6ieMbi npOH3BOacTBa H npoZaaKH 3THX npOaYKTOB 6yayr BOCCTaHaBJHBaTbCA.

B KpacHospcKoM Kpae npOH3BOAcTBo TieKapcTB, Ma3erl u Macel Ha OCHOBenieKapcTBeHHbIx TpaB CTaHOBHTCH BbiroAHbIM B14,IOM npOH3BOaCTBeHHOr4 CSeTeJbHOCTH.CpeaH pa3pa6aTbIBaeMbix rPpOayKTOB eCTb ae3oaopaHT ,tLTeCnbHoro aeACTBHS H Ma3H AnsCeqeHHA KO)KHbIX 3a6ojieBaHJ4i, OqHLueHHA KO)KH npH HcopHa3e H BOccTaHoBneHHR pOCTaBOJIOC. 9TH npOayKTbi MOrI)l 6bl iMeTb 3Ha'uTeJIbHbie noTeHuHaJjbHble B03MO)KHOCT4 HapbIHKe, ecJH 6bl HX :ieqe6Hbie CBORCTBa 6bUIH OnATBepxaeHbl pe3yJIbTaTaMH HccieaOBaHH14

OXOTa 5BJi51eTCq eLue OAHHM Ba)KHbIM HCTO'HHKOM aOXOaOB, CBH3aHHbIM C IecoM.HeKoTopble OXoTonpoMbIcJIoBbie paioHbl Cu6upu H Ugaj1bHero BOCTOKa nPeRCTaBJIAsOTBbICOKylO LteHHOCTb He TOJIbKO =AR MeCTHbIX KOpeHHbIX )KHTeJieg, HO H4 AAS TYPHCTOB(BKJloqaA 3KOTYPHCTOB).

HHBeCTHAHOHHbie BO3MOXHOCTH

4aHHbl alHlai3 Ho3BOjIHJI Bb[SBHTb TpU o 6 iaCTH, Tpe6yioiuHe rOcyaapCTBeHHOrOHHBeCTHPOBaHHA: OxpaHa H 3aLUMTa JICcOB (OT nOxapOB H BpeaHTeJ¶erl), HHTeHCHBHaqjiecOBOAcTBeHHaS CSeTeCJbHOCTb B paHOHax, 6 jJH3KHX K aepeBOriepepa6aTbIBalOUHM ueHTpaM,H ecopecypcHble HHqjOpMaUHOHHbie CHCTeMbI. CaMbiM npHOPHTeTHbIM 5AE5IeTCAHHBeCTHPOBaHHe B OxpaHy H 3aLUHTy nieCOB. OHO AOfDKHO BKAjOqaTb B ce6A HHBeCTHLUHH BcHcTeMbI, ripeaHa3HaqeHHbIe aAn paHHero o6 HapyxceHHR H TyweHi4SA roKapoB H =nqMOHHTOpHHra H peryjiHpOBaHHsI IOrTySAaUHH HaceKOMbiX. YCTOHt{HBoe pa3BHTHe .rlecHoroceKTOpa HeBO3MOIKHo 6e3 3THX Haae)KHO 4jYHKUHOHHPYIOLUIHX CHCTeM.

Page 180: Russian - World Bank Documents

PHC. A.9: JIeCHible nOwKaP6 B Xa6apOBCKOM Kpae, 1984-96 rr.

250 200

180

200 160 t HlopaeH-A14OX0

S 150 120

100 a X I- \\COTHOCH-

g 100 - -* 1 - \1 Q 80 TeJIbHbleroaoBbie

60 23aTPaTbl Ha

* ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~6 1l OOpb6yC

50 40 3 O)KPaMH

20

o - *0

'x0 t- 00 c7 X BO pa 19 xo

HCToqHNK: YupasnieHme niecamm Xa6aposcmoro KpaRI, 1996 r.

Page 181: Russian - World Bank Documents

PHc. A.10: JlecnbIe nO)Kapbl B KpaCHOIpCKOM Kpae, 1984-96 rr.160

180

140 160

- / f TlopawKeH-140- Hbic

12 , 0 inouxapaH

120 -| | | _ __ _ _ | -20100 1080 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~100 C~

80 o a* OTHOCH-60

TCJThHLIC60 rogoBbie

3aTp:TbI Ha40 60PE,6y C40 n oapamH20~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~20 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~20

0 0IV U) (0 r.. co 0 0 T- N co) IV LO (oo co co co co co 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0)0) 0) 0) CD 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0)

HeTo'mmK: Komrer no aecy KpacnioupcKoro Kpau, 1996 r.

Page 182: Russian - World Bank Documents

PHc. A. 11: rOAoBbie o6beMmI UpOH3BOTACTBa JieCHL6X HeCApeBeCHL6X

HpOJIaKTOB B POCCHH, 1966-95 rr.

35.-

30 - IIIL;25 - I * JIeKapcmemme TpaHB

E20 , rpH6El

15 t -|| *OpexH

10

X 1 0 -- -! lil _ _ _ _ .*un w M

0

1966 1968 1990 1991 1993 1994 1995

HcT,o'n.u: rocyAapCSmeUMI KomUTer PO cTacTuxe U cIO epaJimnaiI cjyx6a .iiecioro x03oicua, 1996 r.

Page 183: Russian - World Bank Documents

179 HPHAIOKEHHE A

I4HBeCTHUHH B HHTeHCHBHOe jieCOBOACTBO IOJDKHbI 6blTb HanpaBJIeHbl HayBenHv4eHHe noToKa apeBecHoro CbIpbA 13 nieCOB, pacTywuHx HeLaaJeKo OTxaepeBonepepa6aTbiBaiouHx iLeHTpoB, H nOBbluleHHe ero KaxIeCTBa. 9TH .neca CTaHOB5TC5 Bce6onee ueHHbIMH He TOJIbKO H3-3a ApeBeCHbiX HpOAyKTOB, HO H H3-3a HX np4poaooxpaHHbIX HpeKpeaUHOHHbIX 41yHKUHI. 1IHBeCTHUHH AOJXCHbl BKJlio4aTb B ce6s fUHaHCHpOBaHHeTeKYL1[HX npOH3BOICTBeHHbIX 3aTPaT Ha nepBbie py6Ku yxoga (ocBeTneHHe) H 04HCTKYnmiowa,aer, npe14Ha3HaqeHHbIX AAA BOCnPOH3BOaCTBa neca, a TaKiKe Ha npHo6peTeHHe Hco,epxKaHHe COOTBeTCTByIOLueH JTeco3arOTOBHTeJIbHOr1 TeXHHKH A[S TaKHX pa6oT.

14HBeCTHUHH B HH41OpMaU4OHHbie CHCTeMbT aAA ynpaBJTeHHR JiecaMH HMelOTcyiIeCTBeHHoe 3HaMeHHe. )iAsi HeHCTOIUHTeJIbHoro H pauHoHaOJbHoro HcnoJIb3OBaHHS orpoM-HbIX fleCHbIX peCypCOB CH6HpH Heo6xoaHMo rH6Koe H 3cfeKTHBHoe niiaHHpOBaHHe. JUnA3Toro noTpe6yOTcSA KoMnbioTepH3HuOBaHHbie CHCTeMbM HH4OPMaLKHH H ee pacnpocTpaHeHHA,CBI3aHHbIe C nyHKTMaH o6pa6oTKU H 6a3aMH .ieCOyCTpOHTeAbHbIX aaHHbIX Ha YpOBHeIieCHHqeCTBa.

JIHTeparypa

)De,aepajibHas cnyixc6a necHoro xO35IcTBa. 1993. fpaBHma py6oK rTaBHoro 11OJTb3OB8HHZ Bn7ecax 3anaaHoff CH6HpH. YTBep)ueHbi rIpHKa3OM (DeaepaJbHoR ciyxc6bi .TecHoroXO33iuCTBa PoccHH 29 oKrs6ps 1993 r., MOCKBa.

(De,epaJIbHaA cAyxK6a necHoro xO3AflCTBa. 1993. HpaBHffa py6oK r,aBHorv UOfW3OBaHHH Bnecax,ZanfHerO BocToKa. YTBepxiieHbl ripHKa3OM 0eAepanbHOru cj1y4c6bI JiecHoroXO3fl1CTBa PoccHH 30 14o05S 1993 r. MocKBa.

4)e,aepajibHas csiyxc6a necHoro XO35If4CTBa. 1993. JIecoBoacTBeHHbIe Tpe6OBaHHH KTexHo0iorwHecKHM fpol0eccam Jecoce0HIx pa60T. YTBepxAeHbl npHKa3OM(DeIepanbHOR cCJy)KE6b1 necHoro XO3AriCTBa PoccHH 29 HoA6p, 1993 r., MocKBa.

(DeaepaJIbHaA cjiy)K6a inecHoro xO3Ar1CTBa. 1994. JIecoycTpoHTCJTbHaq HfHCTPYKL (HA.YTBepxLIeHbI npiKa3OM (DeaepaAbHOi cJIyXc6bi qeCHoro XO3,IriCTBa POCCHH 15LIeKa6p.q 1994 r., MocKBa.

IIASA (International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis). 1995. Siberian Forest Study.Laxenburg, Austria: IIASA.

06bi,aeHHHKoB B.UH. OueHKa eCTeCTBeHHorO B03o6HOBJieHHSl neca B CBA3H C py6KaMHrAaBHoro nOJIb3OBaHHA. MocKBa, BHH14U4 iecpecypc, 1995.

flHcapeHKo, A.UH., F.14. PeAbKO, M.d. Mep3nieHKo. 1992. HCKyCCTBeHHbie neca (B 2-xToMax). MOCKBa, 1996.

rocyaapCTBeHHbIi aOKJIa,n O COCTORHHH OKpy)KaioWeUi npHpOXHOUi Cpeabl POCCHRCKOR'De,aepauHH B 1994 r., MocKBa, 1995.

TaTapHHOB, B.1H. 1992. J1ec Poccifw. CocToZHHe H j7epCnleKTHBbJ ero pa3BHTHA'. MocKBa,BHHn4H3.necnpoM.

Page 184: Russian - World Bank Documents

nPIIO)KEHME B

OPrAHH3AUHOHHAa CTPYKTYPA JIECHOrO CEKTOPA

06uxa.l xapaKTepucTHKa

B 6blBUIeM COBeTCKOM COIO3e nTecaMU BJTaaejiH H YnPaBJIl TePPUTOPHanbHbie

opraHbl MHHHCTepCTBa jiecHoro X0331ACTBa H MiHHHCTepCTBa JTecHoI4,

,4epeBOo6pa6aTbIBaioLueri U UeAnIOJTO3HO-6yMa)KHOA nPOMblUwIeHHOCTH. XOTS OCTaTKH

CTapbIx ueHTPanu3OBaHHbIX CTpyKTYP AO CHX nop CoXpaHAIOTCS, B CTPaHe He nOqBHJOCb

eAHHorO BeaOMCTBa, KOTOpOe BbiCTYnajiO 6bl B KaHeCTBe ABHOFO IiHJepa, cnoco6Horo

npOBeCTH nepecTporiKy necHoro KoMniieKca, Heo6xoaiHMyio Ans nepexoaa K YCTOUUHBOMY

pa3BHTHIO.

(De,aepaAbHoe npaBHTenJbCTBO B nHue cIeaepaj1bHo4 cnyK6b[ necHoro XO351iCTBa

(PociecXo3) H HeaaBHO yqpe)KueHHoro FocyaapcTBeHHoro KOMHTeTa no oxpaHe oKpy)Kaiouleri

cpeibi (paHee MHHHCTePCTBa OXpaHbI oKpyKaiomIeg Cpeabi H npfppOaHbIX pecypcoB)

ocy1ueCTBJISeT np51MOU KOHTpOJ1b 3a BeReHHeM iiecHoro X03R1CTBa H oxpaHOA niecoB. '-aCTbIO

nporpaMMb1 npHBaTH3auHH cTana nepeRaaa (byHKULirf npaBHTeJibCTBa nO KoHTpojilO Haa

n1eCOnPOMbIL1neHHbIM KOMnHJeKCOM Y4PeA<aeHHOMY HM POCCUUCKoU neCOnpOMbbiIIneHHOUi

KOMnaHUUH "PocnecnpoM". B HaCTOqii[ee BpeMem beaepanibHoe nPaBUTenJbCTBO npOBOaHT

CBOIO JieconpoMbIWJ1eHHYIO nOJIHTHKy H ocyuIeCTBAqeT KOHTpOJb 3a pa6oToR

iieconpoMbIwjieHHbIx npeanpHsTHi nOCpeaCTBOM pacnopDKCeHHS4 rOCyaapCTBeHHbIMH

aKLWHIMH. 3a HcnOJIb3oBaH4e, OXpaHy H BOCrTpOH3BOaCTBO OXOTOnpOMbICJIOBbIX H aUHKHX

)KHBOTHbiX, arpojiecoMeJiHopauHIo, co3JaHH4e H coaep)KaHHe jieCO3alUKTHbix noJIoc OTBseaeT

MHHHCTePCTBO ce.TbCKoro XO3ArICTBa H npOaOBOJTbCTBHiq. POCCHXCKaH aKaaeMHIu HaYK H pqa

cneUHaJIH3HPOBaHHbIX yMpex(KeHHri FocyaapcTBeHHoro KOMHTeTa no HayKe H TeXHOjIOrIHM H

MHHHCTePCTBO o6wlero H npobeccHoHanjbHoro o6pa3oBaHH5 aonOJIHSfOT B03MO)IKHOCTti

HHCTHTyTOB, .na6opaTopHu H yMe6HbIX 3aBeZeHHuu (DeaepajlbHoA cjiyK6bi necHoro X035rUCTBa H

FocyaapcTBeHHoro KOMHTeTa no oxpaHe oKpyKaloLueg CPceabl B o6JiaCTH (YH,KaMeHTaIbHOA H

npHKna,nHOH HayKH, o6pa3oBaHH4, o6y,4eHœHq H HOBbIweHUI4 KBaTu4HUHKaiUHH KaaPOB.

MUHHCTepCTBO 4HHaHCOB 60obwe He HrpaeT aKTHBHOAi POJnu B JAeCHOR

npoMbIlUjieHHOCTH, nOCKOJIbKy 3Ta HbIHe npHBaTH3HPOBaHHa5 OTpaCJAb 3KOHOMHKH rjojlyHaeT

Majio 4)eXepajlbHbix 6io0aeTHbix acc4rHOBaHHri. OaHaKO nOqTH nOAOBHuHa Bcex

JieCOXo3HgCTBeHHbIX pa6OT (45% - B 1995 roay H 48% - B 1996 rogy, no niiaHy) Ao CHX nop

4THHaHCHpyeTC5 U3 4eaepanbHOro 6IOaXeTa (CM. Ta6n. 5.1 H Puc. .1 Hi 5.2). MUHHCTepCTBO

3KOHOMHKH HMeeT AeAo C AleCHbIM KOMUnAeKCOM B uejioM. B 3TOM MHHHCTepCTBe eCTb

nojapa3aejieHHe, KOTOpOe KypHpyeT pa6oTy H KOOpAUHHIpyeT pa3pa6OTKy 4)eaepajIbHbIX

pOprpaMM UH nOJIHTHKH ieCHoro CeKTopa. OaHaKO 3TO MUHHCTepCTBO He o6JiaaaeT

,ROCTaTO4HbIMH o6LueOTpacAeBbIMH HCFIOJIH4TeAJbHbIMH nOJIHOMOMqHMH, H3-3a nero Bo3HHKaeT

pa3pbIB MewKy npoueccoM npHHHTH5I ynpaBjieHMeCKHX pewleHuil Ha BbICwleM YPOBHe H

Page 185: Russian - World Bank Documents

IHPHAO)KEHHE B

Ta6nlHila B).. oApeT'J necHoro xo3flHcTBa 3a 1985-1996 rowbi, MnIH. py6.

TKyzurme CpaCXOiW m 95r 1986r 1987'. 1988. r 1989 r 1990 r. 1991 F 1992 r 1993 r 1994 r 1995 r 1996 r.

JleCOlIHBeHTapw3aUiiR 33 33 33 34 34 38 56 633 7.182 35.034 51.418 79.436

ABmaumoHHam oxpaHa 69 76 75 83 66 74 129 2.289 21.832 105.602 238.231 416.902JneCOB Or no)KapOB

IlpoeKTHo- 7 6 6 6 6 10 23 174 2.553 10.000 25.309 31.047H3blCKaTeJlbCKHepa6OTbl

Jlecoxo3HmgTBeHHbie 138 133 133 137 131 165 293 3.205 30.109 91.384 269.167 350.000MeponpHTUH

6opb6a C 4 4 3 3 3 4 7 63 682 4284 19.901 3.200BpeCHTeCj1MM

JlecoMeAnopauti.q/ 13 9 8 9 6 5 9 73 1.080 9.880 3.810 4.953ocyweeHHe

Bocnpoti3oacTBo neca 93 86 85 86 78 100 170 1.821 19.531 74903 138895 184.730

Ha3eMHaq oxpaHa 34 35 37 41 34 40 73 1.036 21.257 34.467 85913 158.000necoB OT nlO)KaPOB

ArponecoMehIHopaumas 7 7 7 8 8 7 10 67 1.062 9.018 17.663 13.000

TpaHcnopTHble ycJnyr 5 4 5 5 4 4 7 49 449 340 8.079 11.300(noTpe6HTeJnM)

(TexHuKa 6e3onac- 45 44 46 46 61 61 110 4.361 24.208 104.968 239.946 335.924HOCTH /noIroToBKaKa4apoB)

OnTnaTa Tpy eca 204 197 199 206 193 206 510 5.451 10.044 380.831 804.509 496.304X03.qACTBa

061uaa CyMma 634 635 636 662 624 714 1.399 19.365 225.363 897.476 1.976.598 263.3800PaCXOAOB

41e,aepaanbHb[H 439 445 446 478 448 521 1080 12.978 156.661 658.060 881.640 126.95416iooxeT

Co6cTBeHHbIC 158 155 155 150 143 160 305 3.594 34.817 145.200 653.921 830.771cpeaCTBa nieCX030B

PeanH3auti 37 35 35 34 33 33 3 17 0 2.171 4.781 5.600PaeBeCHHbi

PerHoHanbHbli - - - - - II 1.564 24.326 55.592 195.801 198.2856#ozDKeT

061uaH cyImma 634 635 636 662 624 714 1.399 18.153 215.804 861.023 1.736.143 23D4.197nOCTyIJeHH_ Y6brrKHocHB- - - - - - - (1.212) (9.559) (36.453) (240.455) (329.603)ACJTe O6bHOCTH _ _ _ e 1

| IA Ncrymm-f (IPe epanbHaq cny7x6a iiecHoro X03slqiCTBa Poccu"i, 1996.

Page 186: Russian - World Bank Documents

HCTOqHHKH UHHaHCHPOBaHHf (%)

s M b sn~~~~i co o

-I I

CD -

00ED _ e~~~

coo~~ ___ I

CD c

S 0 _____ __ __

e t - ~~~_ _ 1 n U ' & - _J

(0 -l

co~~h

D CD

co

E --

co

CIQ

co~

cn~

Page 187: Russian - World Bank Documents

PHC. 1.2: CTPyKTypa TeKyHWX OflePaLIWOHHbiX pacXO,AOB JiecHoroXO3SIHCTBa B POCCII, 1985-96 rr.

100

_* HIpoue pacxoAu90

• Haiuai~wie pacxoiul~8O

o1 3apa6omHas i aTCa 70

50 -llHaBeOHaSH oxpaHac: 60

A_eCOB OT noaKapa

Q 50 -Ha.eM*am oxpaHao .~~~~~~~~~~'... ~~~~~~~~~~~~~ J~~~~iCecoB OT noxKapa

~40 * Bopb6a c BpeaHTeJii-m

30 0 BoCtupoH3BoACBOiican

20 * JICCOXO39iCTBeCHHhW

MepOBPHSITH$10

U JleCOyCTpOHCTBO

0

1985 1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996HCTo'HNK: OeAep*JiIHaB cayxa JIecHoro X0311flCTha PcJ, 1996 r.

Page 188: Russian - World Bank Documents

184 rlPKJI)OKEH1IE r

ynpaBneHHeM Ha YPOBHe oTpacjiH, B CBA3H C 'eM MHOrHM Kjuo4eBbIM BOnpocaM He yaensieTcs

,ROCTaTOtMHO BHHMaHHA H OHU OCTalOTCH HepeuieHHbIMH.]

OCHOBbl iieCHOrO 3aKOHoaaTeJ]bCTBa POCCH4iCKO4 (DeaepauHu (1993 r.) H HOBbIU

JIeCHoa KoaeKc oTpa)KalOT rpoT4Bopex-IHlq, BO3HHKwiHe nipu nepexore OT UeHTpaJIH3OBaHHOU

CHCTeMbi nJIaHHpOBaHHUA H yipaBJieHH41 6blBUlero COBeTCKoro Co0O3a K CBo6oaHOMy C0103Y

cy6ibeKTOB POCCUUCKOU $Deaepautu (pecny6n4K, KpaeB, o6iiacTeg, aBTOHOMHbIX o6YiacTek H

oKpyroB). OTCYTCTBHe 'eTKoro pa3.LeJIeHH5l o6,q3aHHocTer H pacLnbIB'laToe onpeaeJ1eHI4e

qjHHaHCOBbIX nIOJHOMO4HI 3THX pa3HbIX ypOBHeU ylpaBjieHCHH5 rOCyfapCTBOM BeIyT K

KOH4)JliiKTaM, T.K. 3TU cy61beKTbl DeaepaUHi4 CTpeMqTCq BBeCTH CBOH co6CTBeHHbie 3aKOHbl H

npaBHsa Ho ynpaBneHHIo jieCHblM CeKTopoM. BocnoAb3oBaBuiHXcA OTCYTCTBHeM aoJnKHoro

YPOBHA 43eaepaAbHoro KOHTpOJIA, HeKOTOpbiC cy6beKTbl Oeaepauiu B3SUIH Ha ce6A

pYKOBOlavlWYIO POflb B OCBoeHHH CBOHX JIeCHbIX peCypCoB. B MaCTHOCTH, OHH 3aqsBlnj1 0 CBOeM

CyBepeHHOM npaBe Ha nllppOaHbie peCypCbl, HaXOASHUeCA B npeaejiax UX rpaHHU, XOTA

TaKOe 3aSIBJleHHe npAMO rlPOTHBOpexiT nIOZo)KeHHIO 0 "COBMeCTHOM BeaeHH4", B KOTOpOM,

corFiaCHo KOHCTUTYUUU POCCHH, HaXORqfTCAl "rocyqapCTBeHHbie neca" (cM. HlpHAoWeHKe B).

CxeMbi JieCoynpaBieHHI4, npH4H5TbIe B pa3HbIX cy6BeKTax POCCUUCKOU DeaepaLIHH,

cyiueCTBeHHO oTj1H4aIOTCa pyr OT apyra. TaK B Xa6apOBCKOM Kpae, rtae npO43BOaCTBO Jneca B

OCHOBHOM opHeHTHPOBaHO Ha 3KcnOpT, KOMMep4ecKHe jieconOJIb3OBaTeJIH yKe cTanH 6o0ee

caMOCTOHTenJbHbIMH B niiaHe npOBeaeHH5 XO3Ar4CTBeHHOR aesTeJIbHOCT4 H (OpM

OpraHH3auHH npoH3BoacTBa. B BeaeHHH KpaeBoA KOMHCCHH no JIeconoJlb3oBaHI4o,

co3TaaHHO4 BaeKa6pe 1994 roaa, HaXOaATCq BOnpOCbl, CBq3aHHbie Co caaqeri nTeCOB B apeHay.

B COCTaB 3TOU KOMU4CCUH BXOaAHT npeaCTaBHTeH (DIeaepaj1bHOA cJ¶yK6bi niecHoro xo3A9CTBa,

a,MHHHICTpauHH KpaA, apyrHx KpaeBbIX opraHH3auLHr, HanpMCep KoMHTeTa no oxpaHe

oKpy)Kalouteg Cpeabl, YnpaBnCeHHH OXOTH14-IbHM X03AACTBOM, AHTHMOHonOJIbHorO KOMHTeTa

U I)OHaa rocyaapCTBeHHoro HmyiuecTBa, a TaioKe HpeACTaBHTeju1 JieconpOMbILuj1eHHoro

KoMniieKca u H eCHOu HayKH.

B KpaCHoslpCKOM Kpae TO)Ke CyweCTByeT KoMHTeT no niecy, KOTOpblU HHHUMHaeT

peweHu5i no iCIIOJlb3OBaHHIO JIeCHbIX peCYPCOB Ha TeppUTOpUH KpaA. 3ToT KOMHTeT M1eeT

jaBOAHoe noaqHHeHHe: aaMKHi4cTpauLH Kpaq H (DeaepajibHOA cJyxK6e niecHoro Xo3>qACTBa.

4Iepe3 CBOU KOHCYJIbTaUHOHHbl opraH (KonnerHlO) KOMHTeT KOOpaUHH4pyeT aeCTeCJbHOCTb C

KpaeBbIMH Be,OMCTBaMH no oxpaHe oKpy)KaioiiLeH CpeabI, 3eMejlbHbIM pecypcaM,

OXOTHHUbeMy, pbi6HOMy H BORHOMY X03Al"CTBy. KpoMe TOrO, OH B33Wf Ha ce6s o65I3aHHocT4

nO 3aKnlIo4eHHIO aOrOBOPOB 0 BblnOJIHeHCH onpeaeJIeHHbIx JieCoXo3AACTBeHHbIx q)YHKUL4H C

HaXO,aSLUl4M4CA B 1eaepajIbHOM nO,4'HHeHH4 6a3o0 aB4aniecooxpaHbl, JIeCOYCTPOHTenJbHbIM

npe,anpHATHeM, HayqHO-HCCAeaOBaTejibCK4Ml HHCTHTyTaMH H TexHoflorHMecKoA aKaaemt4eR

(CM. Puc. E.4).

BeAoMcTBa, oTBeqaiouAue 3a pa6bory JieCHoro ceKTopa

npH LeHTpaYIH3OBaHHOM nHjaHI4pOBaHHI4 ynpasiieHie neCHbIM CeKTOpOM 6blBLuero

CCCP CTponJIOCb Ha Tepp4TopHajIbHo-oTpacjieBoMy npuiHLuLny. B ueHTpe CTpyKTypbI

ynpaBjieHHA neCHoAi rpOMblwjleHHOCTbIO HaXOal4JIOCb M HHCTePCTBO iecHOA, LeJliiioJ1O3HO-

6yma)lHO4 H aepeBoo6pa6aTbIBaioweA npOMblwjieHHOCTH, onHpaioLueecs Ha

I B PC3YJnbTaTe peOpraHH3aJU nPaBUTenjbCTBa B mapre 1997 r. MUHHCTePCTBY 3KOHOMUKUI 6bfibU nepeaaHbl

4YHKUHM ynpa3AHeHHoro rocyaapcTBeHHoro KOMHTeTa no JiecHoA, aepeBoo6pa6aTbIBaioLuerl ii uenjloJIo3Ho-

6yMa)KHok npOMbIWJ1eHHOCTM. (npmMe'aHue peaaKTopa pyCCKorO H3JIaHHIS)

Page 189: Russian - World Bank Documents

185 nPHPAO)KEHME B

TeppHTopHanbHO-HpOH3BO,aCTBeHHbie o6'beaHHeHHS Ha perHoHaHbHoM ypOBHe. Bo rnaBeCHCTeMbI AecHoro xo3sIicTBa CTOAT rocyaapcTBeHHblg KoMHTeT no niecy, perHOHanbHbieKOMHTeTbl U ynpaBjieHH4 Ha o6naCTHOM H KpaeBoM YPOBHe H MHHHCTePCTBa JiecHoroXO3S1CTBa Ha pecny6jiHKaHcKoM ypOBHe.

B pe3ynbTaTe peqjopMbl, npOBeaeHHOrl B KOHLte 1980-x rogoB, ynpaB.neHHe JIeCHbIMceKTopoM npeTepnenio 3HaiHTeJlbHbie H3MeHeHH3. rocyaapcTBeHHblA KOMHTeT no necy 6buipeopraHH3OBaH B $DeaepaAbHyIO cjiyx6y ;iecHoro XO35H4CTBa. B 1991 roay 6buio ynpa3faHeHOM HH HCTePCTBO nIeCHOH, uennKJ1OnO3HO-6yMaXHOA H aepeBoo6pa6aTbIBaloLueArpoMbiLliJIeHHOCTH. C Tex nop npOBOaHJTOCb HeCKOJIbKO peopraHH3aLtHk BeaoMCTB,3aHHMaiOLUHXC.q JIeCHbIM CeKTOpOM, H 3TH peOpraHH3aUHH OniHCaHbl B cAeaploiux pa3LaejTax.

Pe,aepabHaH l cyyw)6a JecHomV Xo3mAi;CTBa PoccHH

B 1998 rogy cPezepajIbHOri ciiyK6e JieCHoro XO3SH4CTBa POCCHH (PocJiecXo3y)HcnOJTH.qeTc5I 200 JIeT. OpraHH3auHoHHaq CTpyKTypa cDegepajibHoA cJIyK6bI iiecHoroXO3SIqCTBa npeacTaBJIeHa Ha PHc. 1r.3. Ha PHC. 13.4 nOKa3aHO 3aHMaoaeACTBHe Mewyfe,aepajibHoR CJTy)K60or, perHOHaTIbHoA aaMHHHCTpaUHeA (Ha npHmepe KpaCHOqpCKoroKpa5), JeCXO3aMH H iiecononb3oBaTeCiiMH. Y $CeaepanbHOA cjiy)K6bi niecHoro XO3S3HCTBa - 81TeppHTOpH4anbHblH opraH: MHHHCTepCTBa, KOMHTeTbl H yripaBjieHHq, KOTOpbIe ripeaCTaBniqioTee HHTepeCbl BO BCCe POCCHH4CKOH (PeaepaJui. CTpyKTypa H (3YHKUHH BCex eeTeppHTOPHanJbHbIX opraHoB npHMepHO oal4HaKoBbl; ro (jopMe OpraHH3aLiHH 3TOperHOHanbHble KOMHTeTbl no nIecy. KoMHTeTbl OTBeqalOT 3a BeaeHHe niecHoro xo35IiCTBa H3aLUHTY neca no BceH POCCHHCKOH (PeaepauH4 B 1740 niecXo3ax H 8 TbIC. IiecHHHiecTB. BnOaHHHHfHe PocJlecXo3a HaXOqSTCA TaKX(e HeCKO;IbKO apyrHx JieCHb[X opraHH3aLHf,BKJ]io4aM nieCOYCTPOHTehibHbie rpeanpHqTHI, Hay4Ho-HccAeaoBaTeJIbcKHe HHCTHTYTbI Hy'e6Hbie ueHTpbl.

Poc.necxo3 oTBe'aeT 3a Me)KperHoHBaJbHyIO H MeKoTopacJieBYIO KOOPAHHauHmo HperYJIHPOBaHHe JIeconOJIb3OBaHHi, MeeKayHapo4Hoe COTpyaHHWeCTBO H HOaWOTOBKycieuHajiHCTOB. Ero o6A 3aHHOCTH io riiaHHpOBaHHilO H OpraHH3aUHH X03 4CTBeHHOH,aeAITeAbHOCTH nepeIalOTCS Ha peFHOHanjbHblI H MeCTHblH ypOBHH. OCHOBHbIMH bYHKLIH5IMHPocflecXo3a B o6jiacTH OXpaHbl OKpyiKafower Cpeabl H npHpoaOIOjIb3OBaHHM qBJIqIOTCq:

* Pa3pa6oTKa H npOBeaeH4HHe 4eaepaJJbHOA IOJ4HTHKH B o6iTacTHHCHOJlb3OBaHHR, BOCrlpOH3BOaCTBa, OXpaHbI H 3aLUHTbl ACCOB H pa3BHTHS.neCHOFo X03IHHCTBa.

* O6ecne4eHHe paLUHOHaTTbHOFO H HeHCTOLLtHTenJbHOFO HcHonJb3oBaHHM ;IecOBH coxpaHeHHA TeCHblx 6oraTCTB, a TaKKe yKpenJeHHe 3aLUHTHbIX,rHapoAorH4ecKKxX pCKpeaLuHOHHblX H npO'HX 4YHKUlH4 IeCOB.

* Pa3pa6oTKa H COBepweHCTBOBaHHe 3KOJ1OrH14eCKHX MeTOaOB, HMelOUWHXOTHOLweHHe K BeaeHHIO ieCHoro XO3AHCTBa.

* Pa3pa6oTKa H ocyLueCTBjieHHe rocyaapCTBeHHbix rporpaMM Hno ieCHOMYX03BHCTBY.

Page 190: Russian - World Bank Documents

1~ ~ ~ ~ ,

PHc. B.3: OpraHH3atti (DeIepajibHoH cjiyxK6bi necHoro x03.111cTBa

nlpaBwTejbCTBO POCCUUCKOU De)gepauHH

r ~~~~~~~~~~~~~MHHHCTePCTBO IPHPOflHbIX PCC.,IDe,epan Nan cayii6a .oecnoro KOOpRHHamUHSI roCKOMUTeTm no oxpaHe OKpYK.

XO3arcTBa POCCHH (Pocniecxo3) 4 - - - + cpealb, 1eCHOM, aepeBoo6p. nuciK.-6ym. npomEwIeHHOCTU M

Op3I- a it| TeppHTOpHpobHUe opraHu o| pjiMOFD nloaHHeHHq l l eJCeHOFO X03.qRCTBA (81) j

TCXIIIIABHU(HU) 4 aJIIcycTpO-_ _ H JHno IICHbIM -0 = Oe.l-l pcCypcam npeanp. (13)__l

JICCHMecCTBa

H n uJCCHOFO (8a wo)CCMeHOBOIICTBa Pocrunponiec _

'LeHTPQneCCCCM .

3OHaCbHbHK neco _ Jl cocyM1HHa% 1 r.

CCMCHHb[C OnblT- nniaHTaUuH 1

Hble CTaHBUUl (34) Jl¢CHble

l _ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~(9,740)

|3eHag maLilHHoUc-| Y9e6HO-MCTO lHM.|

nbiTaT. CTaHUNS r Ka6uHCT

JIClCX03EJ- PYKOBOnHTCICVi o 6Xob

|TCXHHKYMbl (23) | | | ceBaJnUCTO°B 56 | (%4X

| 4CT04Hl4K: <PeuepanIbHaq cniy)K6a nieCHOFO X03flAcTBa PoccHHM, 1996 r.

Page 191: Russian - World Bank Documents

PHC. B.4: CxeMa ynpaBjieHHH JiecaMH B KpaCHOqpCKOM Kpae

i 1 1Amc1p&

A| c |pa[ (eaepammqa ca y =6aKpaCHOSIPCKOrO xpa fiecHoro xo3Sflicm 1BMCB

KOm roneT Kno ns Jec e -aaeeus

PaVIOHHue KpaeCHOH KlpOM

JIcCHL < < KtCUyK10Kt

JlCC}lblC ab {UelUC. |Jlexo3b HCHcrm iec,. rio oxarIomm~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~rppm

KpacHoHo yKam 1

r~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~63 . KpaeBo

l l l 7 P~~~ocTneHmcx3 Ynp BRlO0S T.eg! . J , _ 06EzeZHHCHHe~~~~~~~~ieoycpor.~-

UCTOIIHHK: Kom1{TeT no iiecy KpaCHOqPCKOFO KpaA, 1995 r.

Page 192: Russian - World Bank Documents

188 H1PHJ1O)KEHIE r,

JlecoycTpoHTeflbHble npeHnpHqTHSI (CM. Ta6AiHua A.2 B FptinowceHiHuu A) npOBOART

HHBeHTaPH3aUHIO n1eCOB H COCTaBS1IOT aeCATHJ1eTHHe neCOyCTpoHTenJbHbie npoeKTb1 no

KaA~aOMy neCXo3y. Hay'.Ho-HccAeaoBaTenbcKHe HHCTHTYTbl 3aHHMaioTcq TeOpeTH'IeCKHMN

HCCJeILOBaHNAMH H yMaCTBYIOT B HerOCpeaCTBeHHOM pHMHeHeHHH npHHUHFIOB BeCeHHH

ZeCHoro XO3,qACTBa. HanpHMep, HayqHo-HCCnieaOBaTeJbCKKHe HHCTHTYTbI pa3pa6aTbIBalOT HOp-

MaTHBbl, KOTOpblMH AOJDKHbI PYKOBOACTBOBaTbCS5 niecoycTpoHTenbHble npeanpHST14.q 1

MeTofonorHio onpeAnejeHsH pacMeTHoi1 AecoceKH. Hay'1Ho-HccfleAoBaTenbcK4e HHCTJTYTbl

rOTOB5HT HOpMaTHBHO-npaBOBble aOKyMeHTbi no AeCHOMy XO3.qrUCTBy no 3aKa3aM Pocnlecxo3a

HunH OAHOrO U3 ero perHOHaHJbHb1X KOMHTeTOB.

FOCY,aaPCTBMHfNf KOMIHIT POCCNHCKOg (Pe4aepamwm no oXpaHe oKpyXarIoweii cpC4gb

B aBrycTe 1996 roaa Ha 6a3e 6blBmuero MHHHCTePCTBa oxpaHbl oKpyKaioL[eui

Cpe,abl H npHpO1HbIX pecypcoB H rocKoMUTeTOB no reojiorHu H BOAHOMY XO3,9rUCTBy 6burn

co3JaaHbl rocyaapCTBeHHbli KOMHTeT no oxpaHe oKpyxKaouLeii cpeabi U MHHHCTePCTBO

HpHpOfHbIX peCYPCOB. KaK pacnpeAeuIsoTc51 o6SI3aHHoCT4 MmeCLY 3THMUI HOBblMU

BegoMCTBaMH, aO KOHUa noKa He SCHO. Y 6bIBwero MHHHCTepCTBa ToWKe 6bulo HeCKOAbKO

perHOHanJbHbIX H MeCTHbIX KOMHTeTOB, npeACTaB5IRBHux ero HHTePCCbI BO BceU PoccHUcKOUi

cIe,aepauHH (cM. PHC. 1B.5). Ha I sAHapA 1994 roaa U3 21.174 COTpyaHHKOB CHCTeMb1 3Toro

MHHHCTepCTBa 9.443 'eJIoBeKa pa6oTanH B pa3HbIX peFiOHaJlbHbIX KOMHTeTaX U 1.255 menoBeK

- B HaylHo-HccJIeAoBaTeCJbcK4x HHCTUTyTaX. OCHOBHbIMH 4)YHKU1451MH 6blBwero

MHHHCTePCTBa (HeKoTopble U3 HHX Tenepb nepeumW K rocyaapCTBeHHOMy KOMHTeTy no

oxpaHe oKpyKaoie CpeabI) B o6nacTBo6aCT oxpaHbi CpeabI H npHpoonoJb3OBaHH 6bu1:

* OpraHH3auHA OXpaHbI oKpyXKaioiuer CpeabI H o6ecneqeHKe nPOBeaeHHq

e,UaHO Hay4HO-TeXHH4eCKOU IOJIUHTHKH B o6naCT14 OXpaHbl oKpy)Kaioiuek

cpe,abi H pecypconOJIb3oBaHHs.

* KoOp,nHHaLXUH pa6oTbl MHHHCTepCTB, ynpaBjseHuiu, r1pea,llpHITRA,

ylqpeAIIeHUHU H opraHH3aLUH B c4epe oxpaHbl oKpy)KaioILeri cpeabi U4

npHpOAHblX peCypCOB.

* OnpegeJneHHe HopMaTHBHO-MeTOgOJIOrUHeCKOUi OCHOBbl OXpaHbl

oKpy)KaoLueg cpeAbl, peryJ1HPOBaHHR pecypcono b3O1aH4 U

3KoJIorH1MeCKog 6e3onaCHoCTH.

* Co3,aaHHe H BBegeHHe e,aUHOA CUCTeMb1 3KoJIorHqecKoro MOHHTOpHHra.

* OpraHH3auwH H npOBe,AeHi4e roCygapCTBeHHOir 3KoAorFHtecKoA 3KCnepT43bI.

* OpraHH3aULH U ocyieCTB^eHHe rocyaapCTBeHHorO KOHTpOJ1I B o6JiaCTHOXpaHbl oKpyKaioluer4 CpeAb1 H npHupOAOnOHb3OBaHHH H o6ecneqeHue

co6uiio,aeHH.q HOpM H Tpe6oBaHUU no 3KoJIorHqecKog 6e3onacHocTH.

* AosBeaeHHe ao CBeaeH[S1 HacenieHHq COOTBeTCTBy1OlUeri 3KoJ1or[4qeCKOri

4HH4opMaUHM.

* OpraHH3aUHs 3alOBeAH14KOB H ynpaBAeHUe U4MU, cocTaBJIeHUe KpaCHOA

KHHFH POCCHUCKOoU DeagepaiuwH.

Page 193: Russian - World Bank Documents

PHc. Ii.5: OpraHH3aituH 6blBiuero MHHHcTepcTBa oxpaHbI oKpy]KaIomeii cpeAiH npHpoaHbLx pecypcos POCCHUICKOiI cDeaepaIum

| IpaB}ITejibCTBO POCCHffCKOji DeaepaEu I

MNnncTepcTBo oxpaHUi oKpy]aiouieN CpeJ A H rocxoMUT¶Trl no reojiorHH*,N UPPOARX peypc PAKHUHR pbI6oAiOBCTBY, 3emCflI,HbIM pe-

cypcaM, BOAHOMY X03MHCTBY*,(Muuup.pOAR) * IeaepaAbHaa cnyiK6a iiecHoro

xo3LflcTBa H ,pO,. Be.romcTBa

PerwOHRAnHue KomNTeTU nlo YnpaBAeHNJl H oeuNKMCN oxpaNe oKpyxKaionie cpeAm . enapu MeHTw C.T ., .OHC

BaM o KOrHqCCKOHI 3oorH4ecKS[ lpHpo1onoAb3o- 3KOJIOrH'leCKOlcnevTH3u (DOHA

I OxpaHi,b OKP. CpCLI MoHHTOpHHrajMHT.lOOXp0K13.pCIUJj

1 HcTaH1lapTH3BUH ox.pyi cpejulPaAOHHbie (MeCCTHUe) KO- UCHJpT3.UHU| 4- OKpy)K. cpAu lMHT. no oxp. OKp. Cpenul l lI(rC OHCU o

J o j3KoIorHecKorO HayHo-nex. oA3. HCKOHTpOnIR oGecneeHCHHS

9KoAorHq. npor- I I ri|| paMM U pOrMH 1 71oxpaHaeM. TeppHT. 3oiorHH H npHP.

CBH3ei c o6luecTB. BHewHII HXH 3KOJI. o6pa3OB. CBM3C; 1

l I I l { C~~~~~~~~~~neu. onepaTmB.

Koopi-s B pa6omi XHaHbi nO4BCHHNXI -naI n0 CB|3CCerUOH. npHPOltOOXl . UH nPHPOAHb1X H n CTpaHBMH cHrpaHHlX yCpew. . pecypcoB I _ H

MaTrrxcHa6a H IMHC.yn-CTPOHTeBbCTBa AaMHHCTP. ynp-e

* npHMeqaHHC: B CBH3H C 3MHCeHmeM cTpyKTypbi npaBHTeAbcTBa B aBrycTe 1996 r. 6bmH ynpa3flHeCHi MHHHcTepcTBo OXPSHbloKpyXIaJowfl cpe,ab H KOMHTeTbl no reoSorHH H BOUHOMY X03AtkCTBY. 1Hx 3aMeHHJIH aBa HOBbiX 4)eaepan,bHbIx BeCOMCTBa:MHHHCTePCTBO nPHPO.IHMX pecypcoB H rocyAapCTBeHHMnf KOMHTeT no OXpaHe OKpy KaiowueA cpeJW . nO COCTOHHUIO aej HaoKTHq6pb 1996 r., o pacnpejieaeHHH 4YHKUHA MeKjy 3THMH JABYMR BCAOMcTBaMH 04HUHajibHbIX CBe2ieHHl euCt HC 6uIo.

H4CTOqHHK: E.IBiee MHHHCTepCTBO oxpaHbl OKpy)Kaiowei cpeabI H rpHpO,4HbIX peCypCOBPOCCHHCKOSi (DegPaUHH, 1996 r.

Page 194: Russian - World Bank Documents

190 ' I nPJIO)KEHHE r,

* BblnonHeHHe o6s3naTe.nbcTB POCCHH nepei MeXCAyHapOaHbIMH opraHH-

3aUHSIMH, yqacTHe B Mex(AyHapOAHbIX corniaLueHHAiX H COTpyAHHU4eCTBO C

MeA)LyHapOlHbIMH OpraHH3aUHqMH B o6JiaCTH OXpaHbi npHpOAHbIX pecypCOB

H ynpaBjleHHA oKpyiKaioweA cpegoW.

* Pa3BHTHe H 39X"eKTHBHoe HcnOJ1b3OBaHHe MaTepHaJIbHO-TeXHHWecKoH

noAlIep)KKH peFHOHaJlbHbIX KOMHTeTOB H ApyrFx opraHH3amLHH,

nO,MqHHSlIOWHXC.q 6bIBweMy MHHHcTepCTBY OXpaHbl oKpyXaioLmeH Cpeabi H

npHpO,HbIX peCypCOB.

PerHoHanbHble KOMHTeTbI BbInOJIHqHOT MHorHe U3 3THX 4)YHKUHR Ha YPOBHe

CyfbeKTOB POCCHiHCKOH (DeaepauHH. OHH TaioKe OTBeMalOT 3a CeTb Me)KpaMOHHbIX KOMHTeTOB

OXpaHbI npHpOAbl, KOTOpbIe BbInOJHqIOT 4)yHKUHH HaA3opa H HaKa3blBalOT HapyWHTeJIeH.

Focy,aapcMHHMiI KOMMTrT 170 IeCHOI )pOMMILCHHOCTH

CTpyKTypa ynpaBaieHHq neconpoMbIwjieHHbIMH oTpacISAMH Poccuu nOCTOAHHO

MeHHeTc.I. B 1993 roay no peiieHHio FocyaapcTBeHHoro KOMHTeTa no ynpaBnIeHHlo

roCy,aapCTBeHHbIM HMyUleCTBOM POCCHRCKOU (JeAepauM 6bmTa co3.aaHa PoccmJcKaS

.neconpoMbiunleHHa3 KOMnaHHR (Poc.necnpoM), KOTOpa AoJDKHa 6bmLa ynpaHBJTITb

.neCoripOMbIlwleHHbIM KOMniieKCOM. 0o3aHee, YKa3oM npe3uHeHTa P(D, oHa nonyqHjna CTaTyC

roCyAapCTBeHHOH KOMnaHUH. BMeCTe C ApyrHMH 4eaepaJIbHbIMH opraHaMH PocnecnpoM

yqaCTBOBaJI B npouecce npHHATHA peweHHt no npo6JieMaM, CBR3aHHbIM C

neconpoMblluTIeHHbIMH oTpacASIMH; Bbipa6aTbIBaI Mepbi no pa3BHTHio iOTeHuHaJIa 3KcnopTa

AeconpOMbIlwjieHHOH npOJyKUHH; pYKOBOIHJI HCnoJIb3oBaHMeM oTpacIieBoro BHe6ioA)eTHoro

43oHxaa IAH 43HHaHCHPOBaHHS HayKH; npeACTaBJIsu CBOH npeIno)KeHHA no aXfH epeHUMaU44

npaB co6CTBeHHOCTH H noMoranJ B pa3pa6OTKe oTpacneBblX TapH4)HbIX H npoqHX cor.iaweHHri

BMeCTe C npodcoIo3aMH UH pyrHMH opraHH3aUH$MH.

B pe3ynibTaTe npHBaTH3auLH nOlqTH 90% iieCo3arOTOB4TeJIbHbIX,

,aepeBOo6pa6aTbBaiolUHX H ueeJIJHOJIO3Ho-6yMa)KHblx npeAnxHpH51TH nOSABHJHCb HOBbIe

xonA,HHroBbie KoMnaHHM, KoTopb1e 3aMeHHJ1H co6o0i cTapyio cHcTeMy ynpaBJIeHHq. 9TU

XOJIAHHrOBbie KOMIIaHHH, opraHH3OBaHHbIe KaK aKUHOHepHbie o6WecTBa OTKpbITOrO THna,

HBJIASOTCA1 Aep)KaTenA$MH naKeTOB aKUHH flnO,KOHTpOflbHbIX HM npenpHRTHr4 H uM1elOT npaBo

3aHHMaTbCSl HHBeCTHUHOHHOH AeqTeJbHOCTbIO. BJIHHHHe Ha pa6oTy CBOHX fOaKOHTpOAbHbIX

npeAnpHATHH XOAAHHrOBbie KOMnaHHH oKa3blBaloT, yqaCTBYA B co6paHHqx aKULLOHepOB.

B Haqane 1996 roaa cylieCTBOBaIO OKOJO HSlTHaeCATH JIeconpoMbiuwIeHHbIX

XOJI,4HHOBbIX KoMnaHMHf, Ha floilo KOTOpbIX npHXOAHJ1OCb 6onee OAHOH TpeTH o6fero

o61beMa 3arOTOBKH apeBecHHbI, OLHa qeTBepTaA o6beMOB npoH3BoACTBa mHHoMaTepHanoB H

61% npo43BOACTBa ueJIHOJIO3bI. 94XeKTHBHOCTb npoH3BOaCTBa BO MHOrHX U3 3THX

xojIHHroBbIx KoMnaHHd 6bmLa HH3KOH, H JlUllIb OqeHb HeMHOrHe 13 HHX 3aHHMalOTCA

rmy6oKoR nepepa6oTKoVI ApeBeCHHbl, T.e. npOH3BOACTBOM npO.fyKUHH, Ha KOTOPYIO Bcerna

6bum OTHOCHTenbHO CTa6mbHbdi cnpoc. CeHqac o6pa3yloTcs 4)HHaHCOBO-npOMblwllleHHble

rpynnbI, B COCTaB KOTOpbIX BXO1AT TeXHoJIorHqeCKHe npeJnpHSTHA, KoMMepqeCKMe 6aHKm,

HHBeCTHUHOHHbie d)OHAbl H ,1pyrHe dJHHaHCOBbie opraHH3aumH.

PocnecnpoM He cMor 0o6HTbCs ycnexa B KaqeCTBe rocyDapCTBeHHoro opraHa

ynpaBMeHHR, B OCHOBHOM 3TO CB%3aHO C TeM, 'TO OH He 6bu1 HaCTOSHUl4M opraHOM

Page 195: Russian - World Bank Documents

191 1PHJIOIKEHHE 5

rocyIapCTBeHHOrO ynpaBEIeHHq. Bo MHOrHX OTHOweHHIX OH ocTaBajiCS KOMMepe4CKOKopraHH3auHeA H 6bLn Hecnoco6eH BbInOAHATb MHOrHe H3 BO3JoI)KeHHbIX Ha Hero (yHKUHR.TaK, HanpHMep, ripeanpHATHA npeKpaTHuH nepetiHcAeHHe cpeaCTB BO BHe6lO,KeTHbliA bOHaHa (bHHaHCHPOBaHHe HayKH, nO3TOMy PocnecnpoM oKa3aAcCl 6e3 cpeaCTB Ha npopa6oTKyHay4HO-TeXHHMeCKHX BOnpOCOB. HU3KHU CTaTyC PocnecnpoMa He aaBan emy BO3MOxKHOCTH3alUHWaTb HHTepeCbl AeCOnpOMbILWAeHHOrO KOMnAlleKCa B TaKHX Ba)KHbiX cq)epax, KaK HaAortHH KpeaHTbl. 3bIA npllHSAT PASU 3aKOHOB H HOpMaTHBHO-peryAiHpylOLUix AOKyMeHTOB,3aTparJBallHX AeCHOI ceKTop, KoTopbIe no cyTH HirHOPHPYIOT HHTepecbi AeCHOrinpOMbIlwjieHHOCTH.

,aAnq rOBblileHHS 3j4eKTHBHOCTH yripaBJeHH AeCOnpOMbIWlleHHb1M KOMnAeKCOMHa (be,aepaAbHOM YPOBHe B H1OHe 1996 roaa npe3HAeHTCKHM yKa3OM 6bLn ylpex)LeHFocy,apCTBeHHbIl KOMHTeT nO AecHOA, LteJIAlOO3HO-6yMa)KHO H UaepeBOo6pa6aTblBaioLueAnpOMbIl.UAeHHOCTH (FocKoMAecnpoM), Ha KOTOpbIU 6buAH Bo3Ao)KeHbl 4YHKLUHH,COOTBeTCTBY1OlUHe Tpe6oBaHH$M pbIHOqHOUi 3KOHOMHKH (CM. PHc. 1.6). Bce 4byHKUHHPocAecnpoMa 6buH nepeaaHbl [ocKomniecnpoMy. Co6CTBeHHO PocnecnpoM OCTaHeTcRHe6oAbUor KoMMep4ecKori opraHH3aLuHeH HuH 6yaeT npeo6pa3OBaH B aKLIHOHepHoeo6LuecTBo, KOHTpOJ1bHbli niaKeT aKUHUi KOTOpOrO 6yaeT HaXOaHTbCq B co6CTBeHHOCTHrocyaapcTBa. B OTJIHqHH OT PocAecnpoMa, KOTOpbIU, no CYWeCTBy, H 6bi KOMMep4eCKOr4opraHH3a[uHer, rocKoMAecnpoM 5BISITCS HaCTOHILHM opraHom beaepaAbHoro ynpasmeHHR,OTHOCRUHUMCA K HCHOJIHHTejbHOH CTpyKType rIOCyyapCTBeHHOH BjiaCTH. B rocKoMnecnpoMepa6oTaeT OKOAO 150 MeAOBeK2.

nepe,aaqa KOHTpOfbHO-KOOp,4HHHpy1O0IUHX 4FYHKUHri rocKoMnecnpoMyCBHUeTeAbCTBOBaAa o6 OCO3HaHHH npaBHTeAbCTBOM BaKHOI4 pojiH rocyaapCTBeHHoroperyAHPOBaHHA AecOnpOMblUjieHHOrO KOMrIAeKCa B POCCHUCKOU 3KOHOMHKe. OCHOBHOSi3a,LaMegi 3Toro perynIPOBaHHA ABJHeTCSI nOBblleHHe 3(4)eKTHBHoCTH npoH3BOaCTBaAeconpoMbiwAIeHHOrO KOMHJAeKca nyTeM:

* PeweHHs KAOioeBbIX OpraHH3aUHOHHbIX, 3KOHOMH4eCKHX H 4bHHaHCOBbIXnpo6neM, KOTOpbie BAISAIOT Ha pa6ory AeConpoMbIWAeHHbix npe,4npHl4THA,BKJHO'-afl 3auiHTy HX HHTepeCOB Ha YPOBHe HCnOJHHTeAbHOri H3aKOHOflaTeAbHOA BeTBerl BAaCTH.

* YTBepwaeHHH riporpamm CTpYKTYPHOi pe4bOpMbl AecHoro CeKTOpa,HarpaBAeHHb1X Ha roBbilleHHe 3("eKTHBHOCTH ero pa6OTbI H o6ecneqeHHe,aaJIHer4wuero pOCTa o6'ieMOB npOH3BOLCTBa KOHKypeHTOCnOCo6HORnpO2IyKUHH.

* YTBepwK4eHHR eaHHOU HayqHO-TeXHHqeCKOi HIO11HTUKH B o6AaCTTH pa3BHTHRr1pHOPHTeTHbIX HanpaBseHHuu TeXHHqeCKHX H TeXHoAorH4qeCKHx npoueccoB HOKa3aHHS no4ep)KKH 3aBoLaM AecHoro MalwIHHOCTpOeHHM.

* npHBJleqeHHe OTeqeCTBeHHbIX H HHOCTpaHHbIX HHBeCTHUHUi B AeCHOUCeKTOp.

2 B pe3yJIbTaTe o'epeH1Hof peopraHH3aLtH npaBmTenjbCTBa, B MapTe 1997 r. aaHHbIAf KOMU4TeT 6buIynpa3AHeH H ero qYHKuHm nepeaaHbl OAHOMY H3 noApa3AeneHHA MHHHcTePCTBa 3KOHOMHKU. (nlpmMetaHHepe,aKTopa pyccKoro l3aaHwq)

Page 196: Russian - World Bank Documents

192 lPIIJ1OKEHHE B

* OnpeaeneHHe nyTei pa3BHTH5I BHeWIIHe3KOHOMH1eCKOi afleTeJIbHOCTH,

BKAoI0aAl COTpyaHHieCTBO Co CTpaHaMHI CHF.

. Pa3pa6oTKa (BMecTe c npo4co[03aMi4) Taptid)HbIX H apyrHX cornawueHun4 no

3KOHOMH4eCKOU H COUHaJlbHOH 3a1U1Te IOuoerl, pa6oTaloLUHX B JieCHOM

X03flUCTBC U J1eConpoMbbiIJeHHOM KoMnHeKce.

* oarOTOBKa KpaTKo- H aojirocpO'4HbIX nporHO30H no 10eCHOMY ceKTopy.

OeA1epanbHbie liporpaMMbi no pa3BHTHIO niecHoro ceKTopa

OxpaHa necoB oT HoxapoB

Focy,aapCTBeHHafl nporpamma OXpaHbl AiCOB OT o)KsapOB Ha 1993-1997 roabi

6buia yTBep)KAeHa B cepeauffe 1993 roaa, oHa npeycmaTpHaia BbinOJIHeHHe cneJy10u.uHX

nepBoo'IepeJRHb[X 3aIaq:

* YKpenneHHe cyxic6 aBHaUlUOHHOfl H Ha3eMHOA OXpaHbl nieCOB OT nO)KapOB

(CM. Ta6JI. 5.3) H Co3,aaH4e HOBbIX noapa3JaeJieHHi TIAl paHHero

o6Hapy)KeHHA 14 TyLuIeHHI iieCHb1x no)KapoB.

* C03,D,aHUe cneu4aj13HpoBaHHbix noApa3aenieHui lA5 Ha3eMHOrO TylwleHH

nO)KaPOB B AeCHbIX perHOHax. 9TH noApa3LaeJIeHHA aOJIKHbi 6bITb

OCHa1LeHbl Be3lIeXOaHbIMH nO)KapHbIMH MaLuHHaMH.

*PacuWHpeHHe q3JIoTa aBHaTaHKepOB, rpeaHa3HateHHbIX =AJ TyweHIUH J1eCHbIX

no)KapoB.

* Pa3pa6oTKa H HCnOJnb3OBaHHe HOBOU CHyTHHKOBOU CHCTeMbl MOHHTOPHHra

JieCHbIX no)KaPOB H KoMnHieKCHOr CHCTeMbl HX o6HapyKeHHs.

. Co3aaHHe KoMflbIOTepH3HPOBaHHOr4 ceTH nepegaqH HHu OpMauHH H CBA3H

aA5 noapa3LaejieHH4 OXPaHbI ieCOB OT noKapOB.

OCHOBHOe BHHMaHHe B nporpamme yaeASleTCAI HayqHO-TeXHHqeCKOR aelTenjbHOCTH

H KOHBepCHH BOeHHbIX TeXHOJIOrHH =AX rpaA,aHCKoro HpHMeHeHHfl. CpeACTBa =JAI perUIOHOB

6YAYT BbiLeji5TbCA1 B COOTBCTCTBUU C o6WeroCyaapCTBeHHblMH riP4opTeTaMH H Pe3YnbTaTaMU

3KOHOMHUeCKOg OUeHKH peCypCOB, UX 3KOAorHiieCKHMH 4bYHKU451MH, 4aCTOTOA

B03HHKHOBeHH5i nO)CapOB H 3KOHOMHMeCKHM pa3BHTHeM Ka)Kioro peFHOHa B CpaBHeHHH C

ApyrHMH. 3Ta nporpamma ripeanojiaraeT, qTO Ha3eMHbie noapa3feJ1eHHA H

cneLHaHJIH3HPOBaHHbie aBHaUHtOHHbie 6a3bi 6yRyT OXpaHqlTb 770 MJIH. ra nIeCOB.

./CCOBOCCTNHOBJIeHfC

rocy,aapCTBeHHafl nporpamma JIecoBoCCTaHoBEieHHlq Ha 1993-1995 ro.bi 6bIJa

oAo6peHa nlpaBHTeJbCTBOM B cepealHHe 1993 roaa. UeJ1b 3TOU nporpaMMbl 3aKA1tloanYaCb B

Page 197: Russian - World Bank Documents

PHc. B.6: OpraHH3auHn rocyaapcTBeHHorO KOMHTeTa P(D no JiecHofl, uenmJ1J[ono3Ho-6yMaIKHOii HaepeBoo6pa6aTbIBamomeK upOM6iaeHHOCTH

| npaBHITeiiECTBO POCCCRUCKOR OegepauHH

FOCKOmHTeT Ho JIeCHoI', ilejuno- _K00PZ(HaUHA MHHnpom, PeztepanibHas .J103HO-6yMa2"oH0 H aepeBoo6pa6aTN 4- _ _ _ cnyiK6a AecHoro xo3AricTBa,Baioineu npom. (FOCKoMAecnpom) npo4He seaomcTBa .

ynpaMneHHe roc. naKCTaMH aKUHl

rocyaapcTBCHHbieXoJulHHroBue AKU~IHOHCHAC econpombiwulelH.6wecmTBa (AO) npcanpHsTH ||

co6CTBeuHOCTm

JlecoUpoMliuLTieHHlHe UPC2IUPNXThII IKOHTpaKTEi

AO "PoccHicKH1e C0I03 .iecnpombT|i CCOnpOMbIII- |I leo|ecHo UeHTpiIeHHHKH" HHO

AO "HauHoHaibH . AOJlecHaR 6Hpxa i|eCHOi1 6aHK" "UCHTppMe6eAb| AO "JlecMaaI"

IICTOqHHK: rOCKOMjiecnpoM POCCmH, 1996 r.

Page 198: Russian - World Bank Documents

194 HPJ]O)KEHIIE B)

pUHHflTHH OpraHH3auHOHHbIX H ()HHaHCOBbIX Mep noIlep)KK B pa3pa6oTKe

OpraHH3aUHOHHO-TeXHHIecKHx Tpe6oBaHHir no JIeCOBoCCTaHoBJIeHHo. nepe4eHb 3THX

Tpe6OBaHHf4 BKJmioxiaeT Hcnojib3oBaHHe cenieKUHOHHOrO nOCaalO4Horo maTepHaiia (ceMRH H

ceflHueB) H BHeApeHHe nepeaoBbIx TeXHAOFHiri nocaAKH nieca. B MHorojleCHbIX paiioHax

Heo6xo,aHMo yaeji5Tb oco6oe BHHMaHHe yjiyqLweHHIO BHJOBOrO cocTaBa H coa0eACTBHIO

eCTeCTBeHHOMY B03o6HOBJIeHHIO, BKJlIO4al coxpaHeHHe noaPOCTa tu co31aaH4e CeMeHHbIX

HacaxaeHHl4 KoMMepleCKH ueHHbIX BH,OB. HpeiaycMaTpHBanocb, HTO MepOnIlliqTHSI no

nIeCoBoccTaHoBneHHIo 6yayr OXBaTbIBaTb nfloLuaab, paBHyIo 1,33 MJIH. ra, U3 KOTOpbIX 400

TbIC. ra npeAHa3HaqaloTcCA HenocpeaCTBeHHO AnAl HOCa,LKH uinu noceBa. OAHaKo 4aKTH'ecKoe

4 HHaHCHpOBaHHe 3TOUl nporpaMMbI 6buLo 3Ha'HTeJIbHo 3aaep)KaHo, a OCHOBHbie

MeponPH5ITH5I nO3AHee 6bUIH BKJno4eHbl B Apyryio beaepajlbHyio nporpammy - "Jleca

Poccuu" (1996-2000), KOTOpa5l Bce euxe He yTBep)aeHa.

Pa3BHmC JICCOI7eOMMIIUrJICHOIV KOMIIJICKC8

B HosI6pe 1995 roila npaBHTeJIbCTBO npHHlJIO nporpaMMy pa3BHTH5I

JieconpoMbiwjmeHHoro KoMnneKca. 9Ta nporpaMMa npeaycMaTp4BaeT KoMnFieKCHoe

HCnOJIb3OBaHHe apeBeCHblIX peCypCOB, nOBbluweHHe KaqeCTBa H KOHKypeHTOcnoco6HOCTH

LlenIOlno3Ho-6yMa)KHoI npOaYKULHH H CHH)KeHHe YPOBHSI BpeaHbIX B03,aeHCTBH4l

JIeCO3arOToBHTeCJbHor4 H aepeBorepepa6aTbIBaoiueA oTpacieu Ha OKpyuKaioulylO cpeiay.

npHopHTeTHbIM HanpaBneHHeM AOJDKHO CTaTb pa3BHTHe nepepa6aTblealouWx npeRnpHsITHr B

MHOroJneCHbIX perHoHax, KOTOpoe nO3BOJnHIJo 6bl H36aBHTbCSI OT HeO6XOai4MOCTH

TpaHCnOpTHPOBaTb Cblpbe Ha 6oAbuiHe paCCTOSIHHS1 H HeCTH BbICOKHe TpaHCnOPTHbie 3aTpaTbI.

IIHBeCTHULUOHHbIe cpeCCTBa Ha OCyLueCTBJieHHe 3TOU npOrpaMMbi 6yayT nOCTynaTb B

OCHOBHOM OT npoMbIlwJIeHHOCTH; nAIaH4pyeTCq, 4TO H3 (beaepajibHoro H MeCTHbiX 6iojAeToB

6y,aeT BbiaejieHO TOJIbKO OKOJIo 20% Heo6xoattMbix cpeacTB. FocyaapcTBeHHblr4 ceKTop MO)KeT

BHOCHTb CBOU BKJiaa B 3Ty nporpaMMy 3a CqeT CHH)KUeHH. HanjorOB uuIH BpeMeHHbIX

HaorOBbIX JlbroT, nepecmoTpa )Kefe3HOaOpO)KHb1X Tapm(4oB HuH npeaOcTaBJeHHI JlbrOTHbIX

KpeAHTOB Ha Ce3OHHbie .Jeco3aroToBHTeJlbHbie pa6OTbl H .epeBonepepa6oTKy.

nporpaMMHbIMH uenj5lMH no J1eCO3aroToBHTeJIbHO4 oTpaciiH AIBJIOTcAl: co3XaaHHe

yCToAI4HBOA pecypcHoH 6a3bI XTAS 3arOTOBKH apeBeCHHbI Ha OCHOBe 6o0iee HHTeHCHBHOiI

JieCOBOACTBeHHOU ae5iTeAbHOCTH, BHeapeHHe COBpeMeHHbIX JiecO3arOTOBHTenJbHbIX

TexHoAormI, yBeeIH4eHHe o6'beMOB nepepa6oTKH apeBeCHHbI MqrKKOJ14CTBCHHbIX H

ManjoueHHbIx nopof B6jiH3H Jieco3aroToBHTeJIbHbIX njiouaae , cTPOHTenjbCTBO HOBbIX JIeCHblX

goPor B TeX paHOHaX, rre BbinOAHeHHe pa6oT 3aTpyaHqHOTCSI He6JaronpH4lTHblMH

KJIMaTH'eCKHMH yCJIOBHqMH. no ieconHHbHOii H aepeBonepepa6aTblBalo1uefl oTpacJlM

3ajaqa COCTOHT B MOaepH43aUHH o6opyAoBaHHI4f AnR nepexoaa K nPOH3BOICTBy 6onee

BbICOKOKa,eCTBeHHbiX nHjoMoaTepHajioB c KOHTpOJHl4pyeMOA BJIa)KHOCTblO, TeXHOJ]Or4qeCKOM

o6HOBjieHuH npeanpHATHuu no npOH3BOaCTBY ApeBeCHocTpyKceqHbIX nHIHT H Me6eJIH,

CTpOHTeJlbCTBe HOBbiX npeanpfHATHR nO H3rOTOBjieHHIo noinydja6pHKaToB JAn CTPoHTenJbCTBa

ILOMOB.

Focya,apcTsCHHaH HayIHo-7VXHH'IcCKaxf IpolpaMMa "POCCiCK"U nfec"

BCeCTOpOHH.qS1 npHpOpoOOXpaHHaq nOJ1HTHKa POCCHUlCKOU Oexeparu H 43JiO)KeHa B

nilaHe aeACTBHf npasuTenbcTBa P$D no oxpaHe oKpy)KaiouLgeg cpeabl, KOTOpbl4 6bmil

pa3pa6OTaH npH y'aCTHH MHHHcTepCTB, BeAOMCTB H cy6lbeKTOB POCCHUCKOU OeaepauuH H

paccMoTpeH MexoTpaciesBbIMH KoMHTeTaMH. B 3TOM niiaHe Cd)OpMyJIHpOBaHbl

Page 199: Russian - World Bank Documents

195 HPHJJO)KEHHE B

nepcneKTHBHbIe npeano)KeHHA no ynyLuweHHIO COCTOIHHSI oKpy)Kaiower cpeAbl B POCCuH. B'IaCTHOCTH, B HerO BKJliOMeHbi npOrpaMMbi JieCOBOCCTaHOBjieHHA, OXpaHbI JIeCOB OT no)KapoBH rocyAapCTBeHHaR HayMHO-TeXHHqecKa5i ripOrpaMMa "POCCHUCKHUU nec". HocnexeHAsIHBJmemTC 3KonorHIecKH OpHeHTHpOBaHHOUi riporpaMMor, HaxoAlUIuer4cq B BeAeHI4Hfocy,aapcTBeHHoro KOMHTeTa nO HayKe u TeXHoAorHRM.

rporpaMMa "POCCUUCKHUi nec", yrBep)KzteHHaS B ceHTq6pe 1993 roAa, HMeeTCnety1owHe tleTbipe OCHOBHblX HanpaBneHSH: JIecoBoccTaHoBAeHHe H necopa3BeAeHHe,neCOllOnb3oBaHHe H 3KOHOMHKa, oxpaHa AeCOB OT nO)KapOB H MOHHTOpHHr H 3alLXHTa AeCOB.Ee Lienb - nOBbileHHe 3KOAorHqecKori H 3KOHoMH4ecKoA 34*eKTHBHOCT4 .JecHoro CeKTopaH CTHMYIHPOBaHHe HayqHO-HccIeAOBaTenbCKHX HHCTHTyTOB rtOCpeACTBOM HX (DHHaHCOBOrOyKpenAeHHS.

HlporpaMMa "POCCHiCKHkii nec" npeIycMaTpHBaeT pewueHHe WlHpoKoro KpyraMeHCLHcUHnAHHapHbiX npo6neM niecHoro KoMnLeKca Ha OCHOBe B3aHMoAerUCTBeHR pa3HbIXyqpeA)AeHHA. Yxce onpeAeneHbI BeAy1.IHe opraHH3aUJHH, OTBeqaioLUHe 3a ocyluecTBJ1eHHe 3TOUinporpaMMbi, H HX poAH (Ta6n. 5.2). WHpOKHU cneKTp y'peAcAeHHri, KOTOpbIe AOJIAHblnpHHHMaTb y34aCTHe B peanH3aLXHH 3TOU iporpaMMbi, BKJIIOqaeT B ce6si pa3nHqHbleHHCTHTyTbl POCCHACKOi4 awKeMHH HayK, HHCTHTyrbI cIeAepanbHoR cnyIK6bi necHoroX0359UCTBa H JeconpoMbIUjieHHbIe o6'beAHHeHHA. 3Ta nporpaMMa AOI)KHa f HHaHCHPOBaTbCqrnaBHbIM o6pa3oM H3 (beAepaAbHoro 61oaKeTa. OHa oTpa)KaeT npeAcTaBneHH41 POCCUUICKHXBJacTeU O np0OpIHTeTaX B hIeCHOM ceKTope.

HH OAHa H3 ynOMSHyrbiX 33eCb nlpOrpaMM He nOflyMHna nOnHoro4)HHaHCHpOBaHHR, a HeKOTopble H3 HHX rofyqHJH He 6onee 20%. B pe3ynbTaTe, nporpaMMbiHe OCylLueCTBJAIlOTCs TaK, KaK 6bUIO 3aAyMaHO. lix peajIH3a[tHA HaMHOPO OTCTaeT OTHaMeMeHHbIX CpOKOB. KpaUHe Heo6XOAHMO, 4To6bi 9TH nporpaMMbi nony4anH AOCTaTOqHoe(HHaHCHPOBaHHe. HayqHo-HccneaoBaTenbcKHe HHCTHTyTbl no Bcefi POCCHH TOMCe CTpaAaiOTu3-3a cUHHaHCOBbIX npo6JIeM, He3aBHCHMO OT HCTOtIHHKa 43HHaHCHPOBaHHA. Ux 6 10KeTbiype3aHbl AO MHHHMyMa, H MHorHe H3 HHX 6blU1 BbIHyxKAeHbl 3aKpbITbCs HJIH nepeiTH HaHerionHylo pa6ol'ylo HeAenio. Te )Ke, icrO BbICUHJI, BeyryT HenpeCTaHHylo 6 0pb6y 3a TO, qTo6biCOXpaHHTb CBOHX AyqLIuHX yqeHblX.

ECTb HaAe)KAa, 'TO npOrpaMMa "POCCHUCKHU nec" 6yAeT cnoco6cTBOBaTbC03AaHHio nOCTOSHHOU CeTH fleCHb[X H 3KonorwiecKH OpHeHTHpOBaHHblX HHCTKTYTOB.Ceriac MHOrHe HHCTI4TyTbI 3aHHMalOTCM H3yMeHHeM OAHHX H Tex Xe npo6neM, HeB3aHMOAeriCTBy5 Apyr c LtpyrOM, nO3TOMy 3Ta nporpaMMa npeAycMaTpHBaeT HajTaKHBaHHeCOBMeCTHOUi pa6oTbI U KOOpAUIHaUHIO HccAe1OBaHHti. 9 KOJIorwfecKHe pe3ynbTaTblocyLuecTBneHHs rporpaMMbi "POCCHU1CKKti nec" MOWKHO 6bU1o 6bl 3HatiJTenbHo IOBbICHTb,BKJIOMHB B ee HHCTHTYRHOHanbHyrO CTpyKTypy npHpo1ooxpaHHbie HenpaBHTenbcTBeHHbieopraHK3aUHH.

Page 200: Russian - World Bank Documents

nPIJIO)KEH4E B

Ta6.nIHia r,.2. HpHopHTeTH'ie HanpaBeneHHi HccJieAoBaHHtI B JIeCHOM CeKTOpe

(cornacHo rocyAapcTBeHHoM HayqHo-TexHHqecKoA nporpaMMe "POCCHACKHt niec")

HanpamJ,eHrN, HJCAOBaf BCJeMC Op8lH3a3LNfH

I. JJCDoCaHonIeIN H JICOPH3BCAH

1.1. Pa3pa60TKa AOIrOCPOxHbjx nporpamm . HaylHo-ticCneaoBaTeAbCKHR HHCTHTYT (HUU) JieCHoAi

no yny'uweHHIo reHeTHi'ecKogi cTpyKTypbi H reHeTHKH H ce.ieKUHH

COCTOSIH4S1 necoB Poccuui C

JeCOBORHCTBeHHOA TOBKC 3PHH . U4HCTUTYT 3KOJ]OrtiqeCKHX nPHPOaHblX KoMnfIeKCOBCh6HpcKoro oTaeAeHHR POCCHAcKog aKaaeMHH HayK (CO

PAH)

* ApxaHrejbcKKHi HHcTHTyr iieca 1 AecoXHMH11

* UIHCTUTyT iiecoBeAeHH. PAH

. CaHicr-neTep6yprcKaq iiecoTexHHqecKaq aKa.eMHS

* MeAcAyHapoAHblA IIHCTHTyT iieca

1.2. Co3maHHe reHeTHKo-ceJieKUHOHHO$i * MOCKOBCKHU rocyAapcTBeHHbli YHHBepcHTeT iieca

OCHOBbl 4039 3aKniaAKH npomblwlneHHblX * Hayx1Ho-npoH3BoAcTBeHHoe o6'beRHHeHHe "4yHayK

KYJ1bTyp 4 BOCnpOH3BoaCTBa AeCOB

. CaHKTn-leTep6yprCKHt HUU iieCHOrO X03SIiCTBa

* CaHicr-neTep6yprcKaq ilecoTexHHuecKaa aKaaeMHS

1.3. Pa3pa6oTKa HaH6onee 3("eKTHBHbIX * ApxaHreAbcKKHf HHCTHTyT nIeca U IIeCOXHMHt

Mep no COaeACTBHiO ecTecTBeHHoMy * ApxaHreJbCKHR necoTeXH4eCKHA HHCTHTy

B03o6HoBJeHHI0 I

* CaHKT-neTep6yprcKaq jecoTexHHqecKa3i aKaLeMHlI

* U4HCTHTyr iieca KapejlbcKoro HayqHoro ueHTpa PAH

. CaHKT-neTep6yprCKHU HUI nieCHOrO XO3S1gCTBa

1.4. CO3aaHHe pauHOHaJIbHOA CHcTeMbl . CaHrcr-feTep6yprCKHl HUUl JIeCHOrO XO351tCTBa

BoCnPOH3BOAcTBa JneCOB, Aecopa3Be3eHHS H * CHBePCKaM HayqHo-npoH3BoaCTBeHHa.l .JecHas OnblTHaq

peKOHCTpyKUHH MeHee UeHHbIX HacvLucAeHHA CTMHUHR

Ha 3OHaJIbHO-T"nojiorHIeCKOri OCHOBe. BcepOCCHUUCKHU H1IlI npOTHBOnoXKapHOu OXpaHbi niecoB H

MeXaHU3aUUU iiecHoro X03RACTBa

* MOCKOBCKHU rocyYapcTBeHHblui yHHBepcHTeT .neca

. )DaajbHeBocTOqHblg HHIH JiecHoro X03.9rUCTBa

* BopoHecKII JiCecoTeXHHqeCKHA1 HHCTHTyT

* UeHTpa.nbHoe onbITHO-KOHCTpyKTOpCKoe 6iopo

jiecoxo3qUcrTBeH Horo MaWHHOCTpOeHHU

* CaHKT-neTep6yprcKas AeCOTexHHqecKaA aKaaeMmh

. BcepOCCH1iCKHll HUU nIeCOBOaCTBa U MeXaHU3aUU nIeCHOrO

X03RI4CTBa

* PoCCHi4CKoe o6uecTBo .ieCOBOJ1OB

. CH6HpcKas TeXHojiorFIeMaK aKaAeMHA

. KapenbCKHU HIU JIecHoH npOMbIWj1eHHOCTH

Page 201: Russian - World Bank Documents

IIPHJIOXEHHE B

Ta6nmma B.2. HpHopMcrHuc Ha.IpaBICH u HccJicAoBaHMi B JICCHOM CCIIOpC(cornacHo rocyAapcrseHHo# HayIHo-txwmccKoA iiporpame "PoccHnicKlii nec")(npoAOMnxCHC)

2 ACCODUkKC Y 3ua OHOM2.1. Pa3pa60rKa KoMninexcHoro nnaHa * BcepoccHMcKHR HHH uecomoicma H MexaHH3anHeJICCHOrOAecononb3oBaHNis, npeaycmaipHnajoiero xolalcTBaCOXpaHeHHe 3BIUHTHUX H npHponooxpaHHMx * PoccHAcKoe HayYHo-TeXHHqeCKoe o6iuecTBo4IyHKixHt niieca * MocKoBcKHH rOCyIapcTBeHHbIl yHHBepCHTeT neca

* BcepoccHI1cKH# HayqHo-HccjieAoBaTenLi6cKm# H nipoeKTHJHHHCTNTyT 3KOHOMHKH, OpraHH3aUHH fpOH3801CTBa HHH4W0pMauHH necHol, 0 epeBoo6pa6aTLzBaiomeA H neInioAoa3HO-6yMawCHo# npoMLinAeHHOCTH

2.2. Pa3pa6ora UejiOCTHO# CHCTOMU * BCcpOCCH#CKHH HHH AecoBojcTBa H MeXaHH3aIHH AeCHorOylnpaBAeHHH AeCaMH B yCJIOBHX phLHOYHoA xo3SRcTBa3KOHOMHKH * MocKoBCKxA rocy)apcTBCHHblI yHHBepcHTeT neca

* HHcTH1yr rOcyAapcTBa H npaBa PAH* CaHICr-HeTep6yprcKxU{ HHH aiecHoro xo3lmcTBa* CaHrT-neTep6yprcxaa necoTexHw,ecKaq aKamueMHg

2.3. Pa3pa6OTKa HayqHUX IIPHHIHIIOB H * HHCrHTyr JiecoBeeHHq PAHco3aHHC CHCTeMLI MHorouxeneBoro * Jana6HeBoCToqHiUiJl HHH jiecHoro Xo3a#cTBapaEwoiHamLHoro neconoAL3oBaHxH Ha ocHoBe * BCepOCCHiCKHA HM14 necoBoacTma N MeXaHH3maiH neCHoro

pHHHHIfHOB HeHcTo0MTCAbHocTH H xo3SrcTBaHe IpeCpUBHOCTH * BCepoccHNcKHH HayqHO-iHccjieloBaTem6cKHtt H HjopMaUH0HHLIN t

_eHmp no AeCHLIM pecypcam* MOCKOBCKHmi rocy)apcTBeHHJIt yHHBepcHTeT neca* HHCTHTyr neca Kapen6cKoro HayqHoro ueHTpa PAH* BopoHexJcKHil AeCOTeXHHqeCKH# HHCTHTyr* UHcTHTYT 3KoJorHiqecKHx IpHpouILJx KoMnneKCoB CO PAH* ApxaHren6cKHt HHCTHTyr nieca H JiecoxHMNH* KocTpoMclan .ecHaq OlabTHas cTaHuHR* CH6HpcKaH TexHo0jor0HecKaR aKaaeMHA

* HHM ropHoro AecoBoIcTBa H 3KoaorHH Aeca2.4. Pa3pa6oiKa TeXHOjiOrH# H MaBiNH AUiH * BCepoCCxHCKoe HayYHO-npOH3BonCTBeHHoe o6ieARHHeHHe 3ieCHopy6oK yXoA H 3arOTxoBKH Aeca npoMLimAeHHOCTH

* :aAMaToBcKoe npeCnpHsTHe "CTapT"* fleHTpanbHoe onuTHo-KoHCTpyKropcKoe 61opo

JIecoxo3uRlcTBeHHOrO MainiH0CoTpoetHI* BcepocCHJicKH# HHii necoBoAcTBa H MeXaHN3aUNN necHoro

X03akCTBa

3. OWN=a irCCoB ar ax0

3.1. CoajaHHe onTMManI6oH cHcTeMJ 60pB6bl * CaHKr-neTep6yprcKHH HHH11 necHoro xo3.HcTBac iloxapaMH * BcepoccHficKHR HHH TpaHCnOpTHOro MaiuHHOCTpOeHHq

* CH6HpcKaS TexHonorxqecKas aKareeMs* MexjyHapoArnLJ NHCTHTyT neca* 1jeHTp no npo6neMaM 3KOorNHH H rIpOUyKTABHOCTH JiecoB PAH* HHcTHTyr neca CO PAH* BcepoccHRcKHR H4 l4pOTHBODOMICapHOt* OXP.HLI JieCOB H

_________________________________ mexaHH3aBUHH iOecHoro x031[t1CTa

Page 202: Russian - World Bank Documents

198 nPHJo)KEHHE li

Ta6AnHua r.2. npHopwreTHble HanpaEMneHHR HCCJneAOBEaHH B iieCHOM CeKTOpe

(cornacHo rocyAapcTBeHHoR HayqHo-TexHHqecKoA nporpamme "PoCCHtrCKHU nec")

(npoAo.nxKeHHe)

Hanpaamemmm CcJleAOR|ffMR SCAyillif opraFBHR3RR

4. MorNRwpRHr J1 3R1 =

4.1. Co3.aaHHe Hay'lHOA, MeToaOnortmecKOR * MeKAyHapOAHbiZ HHCTHTyTneca

H TexHoAoriqecKogi OCHOBbl MOHHTOpHHra * HHCTHTyr neca CO PAH

nqeCOB * BcepOCCHA1CKH HHUi JeCOBOACTBa H MeXaHl3autm niecHoro

X03f iHCTBa

* MOCKOBCKHHi roCyaapCTBeHHbll yHHBepCHTeT iieca

* CaHKT-neTep6yprcKal JiecoTeXHHqecKaS aKaCMeSm

* YPanbCKHI neCoTCXHuqeCKHtA HHCTHTyT

4.2. H3y'4eHHe Bo3eAC1TBM TeXHoreHHOO * UHCTTryT neca KapenbcKoro HayqHoro ueHrpa PAH

3arpR3HeHH.q cpeabl Ha nieca H pa3pa6oTKa * MOCKOBCKHUi rocynapcTBeHHblru YHHBepcCTeT nieca

npo04HiJaKTHqeCKHX Mep noBbiueHHS . CaHKT-fleTep6yprcKMl HUIUi necHoro X03S1gcTBa

yCToqFIHBoCTH neCoB . BcepoccHiACKHA H14UU eCOBoncTBa H MexaHH3auIHH iiecHoro

X03.qgCTBa. BcepoccHSCKHu HUll XHMH3autm AecHoro X03H%ifCTBa

* UeHTp no npo6iieMaM 3Ko0orHH Hu npoAyKTurBHOCTH AecoB

PAH

4.3. Co3AaHme JleCOX03.0CTBeHH0iA CiCTeMbi * BCepOCCHiiCKHi HHH XHMHU3anUH necHoro X03sItCTBa

Anfl ieconoAb3oBaHHS B YCJIOBHSX * rHF1O "OrOHb H 3KoJIorHSI" npm TOMCKOM rocyaapcTBeHHOM

paAHoaKT HBHOrO 3apaKeHUHS yHHBepCHTeTe* EPHHCKHA TeXHOorHqeCCKHA UHCTUTyT

4.4. Pa3pa6oTKa MeToOnorHteCKMx * HHCTHTYT necoBeamHRH PAH

npHHUHnOB o0ieHKH ponuH .ieCOB B 0 HHCTHTYT ieca KapeJbcKoro Hay'lHoro ueHTpa PAH

rmo6anbHoM KpyroBopOTe yrnepoAa * CaHKT-neTep6yprcKas iiecoTexHHqecKas aKaAeMH.9

. UIHCTHTYr 6HoJ]orHH KOMU Hay'4Horo ueHTpa PAH

* U4HcTHTyr 6oTaHHKH KOMH HaysHoro ueHTpa PAH

4.5. Pa3pa6oTKa oCHoBonojlaraloluHx * UeHTp no npo6JieMaM 3KOnOrHH H npOAyKTHBHOCTI4 JiecoB

HayqHbIx npHHuHnoB nporHO3HpoBaHHS H PAH

nofaaneHHsl BcnblweK MaccoBoro * MOCKOBCKHU rocyJaPCTBeHHbi yHuBepCHTeT iieca

pa3MHo)KeHH.l ieCHCbIX HaceKomb1x . BeePOCCHtCKHti HIll JeCOBoaCTBa H MexaHH3auuIH JiecHoro

X03.ltiCTBa. HHH ropHoro iiecOBoAcTBa H 3KojiorHH nieca

* CaHrr-n2eTep6yprcKas ecoTeXHH4ecKas aKaAeMHq

HfcTovHaK: c(eAcpajIbHaql cuiy)K6a necHioro XO3SlrcTBa POCCHH.

06pa3oBaHHe, nOZio TOBKa KrapOB H HCCJleAOBaHHS B JieCHOM ceKope

B pOCCUiCKOM JIeCHOM ceKTope 3MHATO OKOJIO 238 TbIC. rocyaapCTBeHHbIX

cjiyiKaiumx (no COCTOSHHM0 Ha I qHBapSi 1996 roAa), 'ITO COCTaBJUIeT meHee 0,4% TpyaOBbIX

peCypCOB B POCCUH. 'leTBepTb U3 HHX (66 TbIC. 'ejioBeK) - 3TO flIO1U4, 3aHHMaOiUlHe pa3HbIe

AOA1KHOCTH Ha ynpaBJIeH'1eCKOM ypOBHe, U3 KOTOpbIX 37% MIelOT Bb[cwee o6pa3oBaHie H

51% - cpeAHee cneUHaIbHoe. Cpeaii pa6oTHHKo niieca, 3MHHMaioutx HHbie 4o0JcKHOCTH,

npHMepHO y 2% Bb[cwiee o6pa3oBaHHe H y 16% - cpeAHee cneui4aj1bHoe.

Page 203: Russian - World Bank Documents

199 PHA1O)KEHHE Ii

06L&Fee H cpC,Hee CHCHHGJIbHe o6pa3osaHHe

B 1980-e roabi 6bmia npoBeaeHa peopraHH3auHR pOCCI4hCKOUi CHCTeMbIo6pa3OBaHH.q. HaqHHaq c 6-7 JIeTHerO Bo3pacTa (nepBbIgi KJiacc), aeTH noroyqaaoTBOCbMUJeTHee o61uee o6H3aTeJIbHoe o6pa3oBaHMe B wKoJIax, 6oAbWHHcTBo H3 KOTOpbIXcyLueCTBYIOT 3a c4eT rOcyaapCTBeHHOi noraepxuKH (HeKOTOpbie aeT HaqHHalOT C HYJIeBoroKJacca, c LeCT4 JIeT). 3aTeM yqeHHKH MoryT BbI64paTb: HOATH pa6oTaTb cpa3y nocneOKOHqaHHA uWKOJbl nJIH npOaOjDKaTb y'e6y Ha KpaTKOCPO4HblX (OT HeCKOJlbKUX MeC.UeB LOO1aHoro rona) Kypcax no MHorHM crieIUHaJbHOCTSM, HJIH xKe npOAOJDKHTb yqHTbC5I B cpeaHer4WKonie (eLue TpU roaa), B npo0dTexyq4HJIHue, TeXHHKyMe Hun Koniniea)Ke (eiue 3-4 roaa).3aKOHqHB cpeaHIo0o WIKOJIy, yMqHuMiue, TeXHHKYM uuH KOJIe2PK, y'4eHHKH MOryT nOCTyiaTb BYHHBepCHTeT (HHCTHTYT, aKaAeMH1o). qTo6bi HOJIy'qITb Bblllee o6pa3OBaHHe (aHn.noMHH)KeHepa uHn MarHCTpa), Hy)KHO YqHTbCq 5-7 J1eT, H eiue 3 roaa A5 noniyOeHHHA cTefleHHKaHXUaHtaTa HayK.

,ao 1 930-x roaOB JleCOBOCCTaHOBHTeCJbHbIe H apyrHe pa6oTbl BbirOnHAIJTHCbce3OHHbIMH pa6o,Mum (KpeCTbAHaMH H3 6nMAHiewaiumx aepeBeHb, B OCHOBHOM XCeH1LtHaMH HaeTbMM). Korga xKe noIBHAHcb rocyaapCTBeHHbie JIeCXO3bl H PoccHM Haiaiia BKjiaabIBaTbCpedaCTBa B JeCO3aLUHTHbie CTaHUHH B CTenHblx paioHax (oco6eHHO Ha'rnHas C 1947 roaa),6buo npHHHTO Ha pa6oTy MHoro IOCTOAHHblx pa6OTHHKOB. B 1960 roay B JICCHOM XO3SACTBepa6oTano OKOAo 57 TbIC. qejiOBeK (OHM 3aHHManH4Cb nocarKo nieca, 6opb6o0i C Bpeal4TeJSlMH,AeCOBO1aCTBOM), MX pa6oTa oiaql4Ba.iaCb H3 rocyaapCTBeHHoro 6ioaxeTa; eLue 112 TbIC.'enOBeK nOJ1yqanJ 3apa6OTOK 3a cqeT npH6biAH (py6Ku ipoMeCKyToqHoro nOJIb3OBaHH4I,py6KH yxoaa, 3arOTOBKa neca H apyr4e iecorpOMbomblweHHbIe pa6oTbl). B 1990-x roaaxe)KeroIaHO rOTOBHJIH nO 15-20 TbIC. KBanJuHMq4POBaHHbIX pa6OqMx AAjl AeCHoro XO3SIiiCTBa.CerOnHR 3TO 4HcJIo orpaHtHiBaeTCH ipM4epHo 2 TbIC. 'eJIOBeK. B 3THX ueflIX B POCCHHaeruCTByeT ceAqac 22 yqe6HbIx 3aBeaeHHsl.

Cpc,gHwe cHerIan,HJe eccorexHmvecKffe yc6Himee aBe4eHmo H nOqBHA4Cb B 1925-30 roaax. K cepeaMHe 1950-x roIoB B cTpaHe 6buio 16 IieCOTexHHieCK4X WKOJI; ceroaHs,aerICTByeT TOJIbKO 3 TaKHX WKOJIbl (2950 y'aiuHxc). AeCOTexHi4ecKe KeWKObl aalOT 6a3OBylonoarOTOBKy no pa6oqHM CneLIHaJbHOCT5IM B IeCHOM XO3SACTBe U AeCHOri HpOMbiwJJeHHOCTHH no neCOXo3AACTBeHHbIM MawU4HaM, a TaKwe ripeayCMaTPHBaIOT MHTeHCMBHbie KypCbI noMapKHPOBKe aepeBbeB, py6KaM yxora, BaiKe nieca U ,apyrHM neCHblM pa6oTaM.

IfecHIbe IC XHHKYWM nOABHJIHCb B pe3ynbTaTe peopraH43auHm CMCTeMbIjieCOXO3RflCTBeHHoro o6pa3OBaHHz B 1920-x rogax. B HaCTOHuee BpeMH B PoccHH 23 AeCHbIXTeXHHKYMOB (B TOM 4HciAe 18 JieCXo3oB-TeXHHKyMOB), HO TOJIbKO TpH H3 HHX HaxoaATCq KBOCTOKY OT Ypaiia (B HOBOCH6HPCKOH o66JaCTH, B AJiTar4CKOM H Xa6apOBcKOM Kpasix).BoceMHa,auaTb ileCXO3OB-TeXHHKyMOB HMelOT CBOH AeCXO3bI C rIJOLUaablO JeCHoro q)OHXaoKoJIo 500 TbIC. ra nieCHbIX 3eMejlb. B 1996 roay Ha aHeBHbIX oTReeHHRIX jieCXO3OB-TeXHHKYMOB y'HJIOCb 9500 CTyaeHTOB H 5900 CTyaeHTOB - Ha 3aoqHb1X H4A BeqepHHXoTLaeAeHHAX.

JIeCXo3bl-TeXHHKyMbI HaXOaqTCq B 3aBHCHMOCTH OT qMHaHCHpOBaHSi HU3d,eAepauibHoro 61oaxeTa, KOTOpoe Bce BpeMH COKpaujaeTCAI. ,AAA y [iyqweHMA cCTyaumi Bo6AaCTM npOqjeCCHOHaJbHOR rOiarOTOBK4 pa6OTHHKOB uecHoro X03HiHCTBa $eaepanbHOAcnyxc6oiH uecHoro XO3SACTBa PoccHH 6bma pa3pa6oTaHa fIporpaMMa cpeaHero cneujamIbHoro

Page 204: Russian - World Bank Documents

200 rPJAO]KEHIE Ii

CmepfJanThoHcT Ha60p

(KoJrnecTBo yve6HbL Mecr)

JleCHoe 1 ca,oBo-napKoBoe XO351iCTBO 2.910

3KOHOMHKa necHoro XO3.[fiCTBa U4 700

6yxraJiTepcKHu yqeT

TexHonorHR py6oK 30

TeXHojiorHI aepeBoo6pa6OTK14 150

JleCOXo3HMCTBeHHaSI TeXHHKa u4 250

o6opyaoBaHHe

JiecOXo351ACTBeHHoro o6pa3OBaHHq Ha 1996-2000 rr. OLIHaKO B CB$13H c 6onbuWHMH

3a,oji)KeHHOCT51MH nO BbiaejieHHlo 6ioI)KeTHbIX cpeaCTB nOHT14 Bce noj1y4aeMbie cpeAcTBa

I4AYT Ha BbInJ1aTy 3apnJlaTbI; HeonHJaIeHHbIMH OCTalOTCS1 aa)Ke c'eTa 3a KOMMyHanJbHbie ycjiyrH

4 coxaepaKaHHe 3IlaHU4U H o6opyaoBaHUiq.

Biczuce o6pa3oBaHHC H HOBMJCHH/ K WIIH4KaLfHH CIICL(H8JHCTOB

B 1993 roay poccH4cKaq C1ICTeMa BMcJifero jieco7rxmHT woreoK o6pg3OB8HwnJ

OTMeTHia CBoe 190-ieTHe. B HacTo5Huee BpeMI HOArOTOBKa KaapOB Axvu necHoro xO3sItCTBa,

AeecHou H uejijilOJIO3HO-6yMaxHoH npoMbiiJiieHHOCTH ocyuLeCTBJsneTCq npHMepHO B 40

BbICWUIX yqe6HbIx 3aBeaeHHlHX, B TOM 4Hcjie B JiecoTexHH'eCKIx, nojiHTeXHH4eCKHX U

TexHoJIOri44eCKI4X HHCTHTyTax, YHHBepCHTeTaX H aKa,eMix. floarOTOBKa ocyLueCTBJIneTCq no

15 cneui4aJIbHOCTHM, BKAio4aq niecHoe XO3RACTBO, caaOBO-HapKOBoe XO3RifCTBO,

ieCOHH)KCeHepHoe Xejio, TeXHoJIorHIo aepeBoo6pa6OTKI, xHM1MKo-MexaHHMecKyIo TeXHOJ1orFHo

apeBeCHHbI 1 apeBeCHbIX MaTepuaTIOB, MaWHHbl H o6opyaoBaHi4e iieCHoro KoMnnfeKca H

3KOHOMHKY AecHoro XO351iCTBa.

THnOBOA Kypc noarOTOBKH pacc'iiTaH Ha 5-Ti4.neTHee o6yeIeH4e, B Cpe,HeM no 30

ayIU4TOPHbIX t4aCOB B HeaejilO B TeqeHie 10-MeCqP4Horo y'e6Horo roRa. PaHbuJe nporpaMMbi

BKJlio'IajiH B ce6,q AIHTenJbHy1o rpoN3BoflCTBeHHyIO npaKTHKy npoRoJI)KHTeJ1bHoCTbIO ao 2

MeC5iUeB B pa3HbIX perUOHax CTpaHbl. OaiHaKO y4aCTHe B 3TUX nOJ1eBb1X pa6oTax B nOcnel:Hme

rO,bi pe3KO COKpaTHJIOCb H3-3a HClnpHeMjeMO BbICOKOU CTOHMOCTH npoe31aa U TpyaHOrO

maTepHabHoro noo)KceHH51 CTyaeHTOB, KOTOpOe 3aCTasBjneT HX HCKaTb onna'HBaeMyio pa6oTy

Ha JieTO BMeCTO Toro, 'To6bi 6eCIlTiaTHO pa6OTaTb Ha nlpaKT4Ke.

I,.ns BbIHYCKH14KOB TieCX030B-TeXHHKyMOB, HMeMOUXHX OlnblT pa6oTbl B JAeCHOII

oTpaCJiH, eCTb BO3MO)KHOCTb HOJly4HTb yCKOpeHHYIO TpeXrOW4qHylO nOArOTOBKY B By3e

CTyzeHTbI B 3TOM cjiyqae nojiyqaioT 3apnnaTy no MecTy pa6OTbl. 3aKOHqHB o6yqeHHe,

CneU,UaHJHCTbl 06blqHO BO3BpaU.alOTC51 Ha CBOU4 npeanpHSTH51 U nojiyqaioT nOBblwueHHe no

cniyx6e (cTaHoBscb aHpeKTopaMH, pYKOBOLHTejiSlMH HJIH CTapwuHM1 cneuHail14cTaMH).

Page 205: Russian - World Bank Documents

201 rPHAJO)KEHHE r3

CyLlleCTByeT HeCKOJIbKO 4bOpM IoBmJeLH KBaIH4pHKaIIfH crieUHanAHCTOB. HOWTHB Ka)KCXlOM HHCTHTyTe eCTb OTaeAeHH5, Ha KOTOPbIX cnelluHanHCTbl-JeCHHKH MOrYTYCOBepweHCTBOBaTb CBOH 3HaHHS H HpO4eCCHOHaJbHbie HaBbIKH. ECTb TaKxe criLUHaJbHbi4BcepoccHHicKHi HHCTHTyT IOBblwUeHHA KBaAHqpHKaUHH PyKOBOalHTeCjeri H UCne uHanHCTOBieCHoro XO3S1HCTBa (BH4fIKJIX), KOTOpblH4 HaXOgHTCA B r. IYUIK4HO MOCKOBCKOH o6ijaCTH.3ToT HHCTHTyT HenOCpeaCTBeHHO nO'I4HHeH (Deaepaj1bHOR cjiy)K6e niecHoro xO3AACTBa. EroBbICOKOKBaTiHWIHUHpOBaHHbl4 npenoaaBaTeJIbCKHH COCTaB 3aHHMaeTCA TaKiKeHCcieILoBaHHAMH B o6nacTH aaMHHHcTpaTHBHoro H XO3SACTBeHHOrO yripaBeHIHHM JiecaMH H3KOHOMHKH. Eaje OaHH TaKOI UHCTHTyT HaxoIHTCS B aHBHOrOpCKe, He,aaeKO OTKpaCHOApCKa, OH Co3aaH aT rIOBblweHHS KBaBJIHUKaUHH pyKOBO0U4Te1ek H cnCeUHJaJHCTOBnecHoro XO3AACTBa Cu6upu HU )JaJbHero BocToKa.

JiecHai H8yxK

ImMeM 6o0iee qeM 200-iieTHHri OnbIT BeaeHHAR iecHoro xO3SAHCTBa, PoccHS qBJIMeTCqnPH3HaHHbIM JIHRepOM B o6nacTH ieCHbIX HccjTeaoBaHIH4 H pa3pa6oToK. OLHH TOJTbKOHayqHO-HccJie,aoBaTeflbcKHe HHCTHTYTbl $LeaepaIIbHori cnys6bi .TecHoro XO3MHfCTBa BeayTHCCJAegOBaHHA B OaHHHaAuaTH TeMaTHxeCKHX o60acTiax, BKJIIoIaS AeCoBORCTBO H 3Ko0orHIoneca (42% o6wero KoJiH'eCTBa npoeKTOB), MexaHH3auHio (18%), 3KOHOMHKY niecHoroXo3SArCTBa H 6yxraJTepcKHri yqeT (8,5%), iiecoycTporiCTBO (8%).

CHCTeMa JIeCHbIX HayqHO-HccAe,aOBaTeAbcKHx yqpeuKeHHA Bceraa 6bmIa B POCCHuxopoIwo pa3BHTa. OHa BKJloqaeT B ce6q 4HHaHCHpyeMyio H3 beaepaAbHoro 6IogweTacI4cTeMy HHl (I)eaepanbHOri cJyIK6bi JIecHoro xO3AAcTBa, B KOTOpYIO BXOa,T BOCeMbHCCJ1e)IOBaTeJbCKHX HHCTHTyTOB, O4HH HH4opMauHOHHblg LxeHTP H OaHH Hay'HO-IIpOM3BOACTBeHHblA UeHTp (CM. Ta6n. B.3). Ha JieCHyIO ripOMbIHIeHHOCTb pa6OTaeT eaje 25HccAe,oBaTenbCKHX HHCTHTYTOB, BoceMb H3 HHX MBJIAIOTCA rOcyaapCTBeHHblMH, 14 -HaxoA3iTCR B COBMeCTHOr4 CO6CTBeHHOCTH (aKUHOHepHbIe o61ueCTBa), H 3 HHCTHTYTanpHBaTH3HpOBaHbi. B CHCTeMe PocCHficKOrl aKaaeMHH HayK H ee perHOHaTIbHbIX oTLaejIeHHiiHMeeTCA weCTb HHCTHTYTOB meyHapOHOrO ypOBH5, cneL[HaH31PYIOUHXCA B O6JIaCTH4yHLIaMeHTaIbHbIX HccJeaoBaHH9 no necHOHi 3KOAorHH, 6Honor'HH H ApyrHM CBA3aHHbIM CJecoM AHcuuHuIAHHaM.

Kaic.zjbl JieCHOHi Hay4HO-HCcJeaOBaTeJbCK4H HHCTHTYT CHCTeMbi Pocrecxo3acneUHaJH3HpyeTCS no oripeaeeHHOMY y3KOMY cneKTpy oTpacJeBbIX npo6TeM, B KOTOpOM OH3aHHMaeT BeayLLee noJo)KeHHe. IIHCTHTyTbl, KpOMe TOrO, BbinOJIHqIOT KaKyio-JI46o perHo-HajIbHYIO 4)yHKUHlO, oxBaTbIBaA WHpOKHU Kpyr JeCHbIX npo6neM CBoero perHOHa, BKJIIO4aSpa3pa6OTKy perHOHaJbHOr4 AeCHOA nOnHTHKH. B BeaeH4H 3THX HHCTHTyTOB HaXOLARTCA 16JieCHbIX OrlbITHbIX CTaHUHI, paCnHOjio)KeHHbIX B pa3Hb[X perHOHax cTpaHbl. B POCCUH.LeriCTBYIOT 6onee 30 OITbITHbIX JleCXO30B H JIeCHHxeCTB, a TaKwe pu cneuHaniH3HPOBaHHbIXna6opaTopiui, AeCHbIX H4TOMH4KOB, KOHCTPYKTOpCKHX 6iopo H 3KCnep4MeHTa.ibHbIX 3aBOaOB.

B 1995 roay B CHCTeMe Hay'qHbIX y4peAcAeHHr4 Poc.necXo3a pa6oT'ano oKoiTo 1300HayqHbIX COTPYAHHKOB, BKAioqaA 45 AOKTOPOB H 6o0nee 400 KaHKaiiaTOB HayK. 3a nepuon c1990 no 1995 rol npoH30UJIO pe3Koe coKpaLIieHHe xHcJ1a HayqHbIX pa6oTHHKoB B JieCHOM

Page 206: Russian - World Bank Documents

202 nPHIO)KEHHE 6

CeKTope: B CHCTeMe PoCJnecxo3a - npHMepHo Ha 35%, a B CHCTeMe 6blBUIero PocJlecnpoMa -

Ha 75-85%.

JleCHbIMH HCCiieQOBaHHiqMH TpaaiLUI4OHHO 3aHHMaIOTC5l TaKwKe COTPYAHHKH pi,Ra

JieCoTexHHMeCKHX H noJIHTeXHHMeCKHX 4HCT4TyTOB, aKaaeeMHii H YHHBePCHTCTOB CiCTeMbi

BblClero o6pa3oBaHHA, POCCHUicKOU aKaAeMiH HayK, POCCHUiCKOUi aKaaeMmi

ceJIbCKox035IfiCTBeHHbIX HayK (PACXH), POCCUiUCKOU1 aKaReMmH eCTeCTBeHHbIX HayK (PAEH),

a TaioKe HHCT4TYTOB H opraH43auHig, nof llHOluHqXCl FocyaapCTBeHHOMy KOMHTeTy no

oxpaHe oKpyKaloluerl cpeabi, M1HHCTePCTBY ceJbCKoro XO3SlRCTBa H npOAOBOJIbCTBHS H ap.

BOJIbWIHHCTBO H3 3THX OpraHH3=UH1i HaXOqITCq B MocKBe, CaHKT-neTep6ypre, BpsiHCKe,

BopoHeKce, EKaTep4H6ypre, IloWKap-O.ne H KpaCHolpcKe (CM. Ta6.n. 5.3 H 5.4).

dJ'HH8HCHpOBaHHC ieCHOHff HayKIf H o6pa3oBaHHf

OKoao 85% 3aTpaT Ha JTeCHyTO HayKy H o6pa3OBaHHe B nocTe,aHHe roabi

4M4HaHCHpyeTC5I 3a C'eT cpeaCTB deaepanibHoro 6ioaxeTa, BbiaenjIeMbix FocyaapCTBeHHoMy

KOMHTeTy nO HayKe H TeXHOJIOFHAM H MHHHCTePCTBY o6uiero H npo(becc4OHajibHOrO

o6pa3oBaHHI4. 3To B KOpHe oTAH4uaeTCq OT HCTOwHHKOB 4bHHaHCHPOBaHHq HccjIeROBaHHrI H

nOArOTOBKH cneUHaJIHCTOB XIAS ieCHO14 npOMbiwielJHHOCTH H apyrHx CB513aHHbIX C HeU

oTpacnerl: 3LLeCb HayKa H o6pa3oBaHHe noJIytialOT H3 4eaepaJlbHoro 61oaxeTa TOJIbKo 8%

cBoero duHaHC4pOBaHH4. B 1995 ro,y jieCHoe XO35ICTBO DaKTHMecKH noJIyqHjIo TOjIbKo 40%

OT 3anHIaHHpOBaHHoro o6beMa aeHe)KHbIx cpeRCTB, Heo6xoa4Mbix ,Xnq nOKpbITIS TeKyIUiX

pacXOAOB Ha pa6oTy HaytqHo-HccIieaoBaTenbcK4x HHCTITYTOB, H 56% cpeaCTB, Heo6xoatMbIx

xiS ieCHbIX TexHHKyMoB. B 1996 roay MHHHManjbHbie TeKyIluHe 3aTpaTbl Ha

JieCOXO3IRuCTBeHHbie HccJieAoBaHH1R, no oueHKaM, COCTaBJInu 21,3 MJIpa. py6., a

4enepanbHbIg 61oAxeT Bbiaenu4JI TOJTbKO 13,5 MJIpA. py6. CHHKeHHe nHHplOTeTHOCTH

BJIO)KeHHA cpeaCTB B HaYKY B YCJTOBH5IX CUJlbHblX 61oaxeTHbIX OrpaHi'-IeHHUU npi4BeJIO K

cepbe3HOMY coKpaiLeHuLio 6ioaKeTa ieCHOgi HayKH: c 3,6% OT OnepaUULOHHOrO 61OaxeTa

neCHoro XO35riCTBa B 1989 roay ao 0,5% - B 1993 roAy. B nocnieAHee BpeMq 13 perHOHaJIbHbIX

61oIJxeToB yaaeTCA nofjyIaTb JIHUb OMeHb orpaHUMeHHble CpeaCTBa Ann (FHHaHCHPOBaHHS

JieCHOI HayKH U noarOTOBKH KanpoB, B OCHOBHOM OHH BbiIeAHlOTCq B CxieT TaK Ha3bIBaeMOrO

1,5-npoueHTHoro (DoHLa Ha HayqHbIe HccIieaoBaH4H H pa3pa6oTKH, npeaHa3HaIeHHoro ais

Hccjie,aoBaHHApermoHaOJbHbIx npo6IieM.

3apa6omaf IHiiam B JICCHOM CeKTOPC

Pe3Koe coKpaweHie aHana3oHa nieCHbIX HccieaOBaHHr4 B POCCHu 6buro Bbl3BaHO

rniaBHbIM o6pa3oM Kpar4He pe3KNM CHHxeHHeM peanlbHoro YPOBH5I onniaTbl Tpyaa B nieCHbIX

HHCTHTyTaX, qjMHaHC4pyeMbiX U3 beaepanibHoro 6ioaleTa. npoBeaeHHoe B HoI6pe 1995 rona

CTaTHCTH4qeCKoe HccAeaOBaHHe no 3apnnaTe pa6oTHHKoB roc6ioa)KeTHof4 ccjepbi noKa3ajio,

'TO B IieCHOM XO3AACTBe caMaB HH3KaS cpeRHeMeCAMHaq 3apnniaTa - 443.000 py6neui, B

JieconpoMbiIIueHHOM KoMrJneKce OHa COCTaBjiqeT 575.000 py6neu, a camas BbICOKaq

cpe,HemeCR4Ha5 3apnniaTa y juoaek, 3aHqTbIX B npOH3BOdCTBe npHPOAHOro ra3a - 2.075.800

py6neut. CpeaHqs 3apnnaTa no CTpaHe COCTaBEJi eT 615.700 py6neu4 B MecqlI. B CHCTeMe

c1e,aepaAbHOA clyxK6bi JIecHoro X035irUCTBa CpeAH5IH 3apnniaTa HayqHbIX pa6oTHHKOB

COCTaEBi1eT Bcero 85% OT cpeaHeri 3apnniaTbI no 3TOMy BeaoMCTBY. BOnbWU4HCTBO

TaBiaHTAHBb1X ripoqjeccHoHaAbHbIX Hay'4HbIX COTPYAHHKOB yEnuIH Ha 6o0iee

BblcoKoonHJa4HBaeMbie pa6OTbl B 'aCTHOM Hu CMmewaHHOM CeKTope (B OCHOBHOM B TOproBiio

Page 207: Russian - World Bank Documents

203 nPHAOICEHHE S

HAIH KoMMepiuHo). Cpe1HHri Bo3paCT HayqHbIX COTPYAHHKOB cHcTeMbi Hulll ()eAepanbHohcjiy)K6bl necHoro X035lACTBa ceAiac npeBbiuiaeT nITbAeCHT rIATb JIeT, YTO rOBOpHT OnOTeHLiHaj1bHOrU yrpo3e "BbIMHpaHHq" HeKorI a MOWHeriueUi cHcTeMbI .ieCHbIX HayqHbIXtiCCce,aoBaHHA B POCCHH.

Ta6.nrnia Ii.3. JAecHbie HayqHo-HccneiioBaTeAbcKme HHCTHIyrbi4DeAepambHoA cMyxK6b JIeCHoro xo3SIHcTBa POCCHH

HHff Irba OCHORHJ,ie HaIlpame/HA mccffCe4oHil corpyCO321f"COTHR

HIIKOBCaHKT-neTep6yprcKHI HUH 1928 OxpaHa .necoB OT no)KapoB, npo6neMbl JiecomeJiiopauIu, 180CecHoro XO3%rHCTBa xHMH'ecKHe cpencTBa arpoTexHHqecKoro yxosa 3a JecoM,

3KOHOMHKa, JiCcOyCTpOrCTBo, flecHbie nHTOMHHKH, AecHaspeKpeaufls (oco6eHHo Ha oxpaHqeMbIX TeppHToptiqx), npo6nemaoraH3aumi Tpyfla. KoopAutHauHq jiecoxo3XOAcTBeHHbIxHccjieztoBaHMH B CeBepo-3ananiHoM 3KoHOMHIqecKoM paAoHePoccuui

BcepoccHuucKua HHH 1934 nllanHipoBaHHe H KOOPAiHaHUHR Jiecoxo3SIrcTBeHHb[x 350iieCoBOJICTBa H MexaHH3aUHH mccAeaoBaHH1, py6KH npoMe>xyro'Horo nojjb3oBaHHH,JiecHoro Xo3liHCTBa, UIyWKHHO, JCCOBOCCTaHOMeHHe, MexaHH3aUHSI AecHoro XW3SUHCTBa,MocKoBcKafl o6.nacTb iiecoynpaBMeHHe H JiecoycTpoAcTBo, 3KOHOMHKa, oueHKa necHHblxpecypcoB, CTaHJapTm3auHf. KoopaHHauHli necoxo3slqcTBeHHbixHCCJemBaldHH B ueHTpanibHbIX perCOHax EBponercKoA 4aCTMPoccHH H YpambCKOM 3KOHOMHqeCKOM paHOHe.

ganbHeBocTo'Hbiti HHH 1939 JlecoBoccTaHoBAeHHC, pa3pa6oTKa HOBbIX TexHoj1orHs, JiecHasi 80njecHoro Xo3qrcTBa, Xa6apoBcK reHeTHKa H ceCeKUHxq, iieco3atumTa, 3KOHOMHqeCKaq oueHKa_ieCHbIX peCYpCOB, nniaHHPOBaHHe H ynpaBejeHHe, 3KOJ]orHR, npo6-_ieMbl cH6HpCKoro Keapa. Koopauiamiw JTCCOX03,3riCTBeHHbIX_fCcje.aoBaHHA B aaJbHeBOCToqHoM 3KoHoMN4qecKoM paHioHePOCCHH.

H HHH ropHoro jieCOBOACTBa u 1944 rOpHOe JieCOBOJICTBO, 3KOJIOrHf, BOAHOC X03flHCTBO Ha 453Ko.norHH nieca, Coq4u, Boaoc6opax, peKpeauHs, necoBoccTaHoBneHHe, HHTPOaYKUHlRKpaCHo,aapCKNH KpaH 11peBeCHbCX BHXOB, ceAeKuHq, MexlyHapOfaHbl o6MeH cemeHaMH.KoopamHaua flTeCOXo3fAcTBeHHblX HcciieaoBaHAH B CeBepo-KaBKa3cKoM 3KOHOMH'eCKOM paHOHe.

ApXaHrenjbCKHr HHCTUTyT Aeca 1958 BeareHme JiecHoro Xo3flHCTBa B npfTyH.UpoBbIx nlecax, 110u necoXHMHm, ApxaHrenbcK mcnojib3oBaHHe JlecocetHbIx OTXOaOB, noaco4Ka. KoopauHauHmljiecoxo3mAcTBeHHbIx HccJ1eAoBaHmH B CeBepHoM 3KOHOMHmeCKOMpaHoHe.

BcepoccuHcKHa HHH 1968 Pa3pa6ol-Ka H n1pHMeHeHUe cpeACTB, MeToaoB H o60pyaOBaHBlg MJIfl 60npOTHBOnO)KaPHOr OXpaHbi npeaomrpamueHiH, o6Hapy)KeHmR H TywICeHHq AeCHblx nozKapoB;InecoB H MexaH"3aumH AeCHOrO TexHomorHR KoMnCeKcHoH MexaHH3auHH jeCoxo3.qACTBeHHblXX03RiAcTBa, KpacHoflpcK pa6oT. Koo0PLHBum. jiecoXo3SIHCTBeHHbIX tfccAeaoBaHHA B

(Hlpo,onKeHHe Ta6AHHUbl Ha cnepyiowerl cTpaHHUe)

Page 208: Russian - World Bank Documents

HPHJIOIKEHHE B

Ta6AHuIJa B.3. JlecHble HayqHo-HccAeJeoDaTenIbcKHe KHCTHTyTbi

Pe,a,epanbHof cyK6bi iiecHoro xo3ficBa PoccHH (npoAonxeHHe)

Hiflf aoa OCHORHeC HmwIpmlkiHhw HCCJ4OBHHIfR crpyf|

CO34aHK.qcopy HHKOB

HUU JIecHogl reHeTHKH ui 1971 reHeTHKa, ceneKumsW, npoH3BOacTBO ceM%H1, HTpQyKutis apeBeCHbIX 90

cejieKUHH, BopoHe)K BUAOB, MeAwyHapqAHbihAo6McH ceMeHaMH. KoopauHaUHsI

jiecoxo3%AcrweHHbix HccJieaOSaHHA B aOYHbIX pernHoHax POCCH1I.

BcepoccmACKHu HUU 1973 3aLLuTa niecHbIx )KHBOTHbIX OT aHTpOnlOrtiHbIX Bo3.aeACTBrH, 120

XUMU3aUUiUi neCecHoro xo3.cTBa, Bbi6op 3KoAorHmecKH 6e3onacHblx necTCrHUKOB, H3y'eHHe

HBaHTeCBKa, MOCKOBCKasA no6O4HOFO aeAcTBHJ necTHuHaoB, neco3auITa, 6HoTeXHo0ormH,

o6.nacTb JieCHoe Xo3riCTsO B niecax, 3apa8KeHHbIX paAHOHyKJIHIaMH.

BcepoccHuiCKH1ii Hay'Ho- 1988 C6op, aHaAn3 H o6pa6oTKa HH4)opMaumm no JleCHbIM peCypCaM, 190

mcneamOaTeAbCKHR co3aaHme u aKTyajiH3auKH 6a3 aaHHb[X U NHWfOpMaUHOHHbIX

HH4pOpMaUHOHHbl UeHTp no CHCTeM no IeCHbIM peCypcaM, HHBCHTaPH3aLUHH H KapTHpoBaHHe,

nieCHbIM pecypcaM, MocKna 3KoJ1orHqecKHtl H peCypCHbIH MOHHTOpHHr, o6pa6oTiKa

a3pO4)OTOCHMMKOB H H3o6pa)KeHMH, nOJIymeHHblX C nOMOuIblO

alHCTaHUHOHHb]X O6cueOBeaoHH, H3MeHeHHe KYIMmaTa.

Hay'Ho-npoH3BoacT- 1995 HcnbITaHHe ceMrnH, ceneKuH., oT6op, o6pa6oTKa H 25

BeHiHbili ueHTp AeCHO- anpo6HposaHHe

ro ceMeHOBOaCTBa, I1yUIKHHO,

MOCKoBCKaS o6iaCTb

HCTo'HiIK: 4(eaepanbHaS cjiy)K6a uiecioro XO35ICTBa PoccmH.

Page 209: Russian - World Bank Documents

HnP4JIOKEHHE B

Ta6AH1Aa 1B.4. JAecHwe HayqHo-HcciieAoBaTejibcKHe HHCTHTyrbi H BbCIwUHe yqe6Hbie3aBeAeHHs, He BXOASUIHe B CHCTeMy 4I)eAepaAbHOI CJy26bi fieCHoro Xo3SiCTBa POCCHH

Ha3DaH,,e yVeCiQiCHMR I76AYmHem MeCr Ha8OX4clfH

__I___JIeCCHble HccjieaoBaHma_I Me*iayHapoaHbig HHCTU ,m neca U UeHTp PoccHicKaH aKaaeMlHi HaYK (PAH) MocKBano npo6neMaM 3KoJIorim U npoayKTHBHOCTH

_ n~~~~~~ecoB

2 HHCTUTyr necoBemeHKH POCCHACKaq aKaaeMLIH HayK (PAH) YcneHcKoe,MocKoBcKaq o6!acTb3 HHCTHTYT naDa3HTOJIOrUHH PoCCHcKaq aKaaeMHA HayK (PAH) MocKBa4 -J4HcCTHy iieca HM. Cyia'eBa CH6HpcKoe oTaeneHe PAH KpacHoRpcK5 FHCTHTyr 6HojiorHH CH6HPCKoe oTaejIeHHe PAH KpaCHOqPCK6 14HCTHTyr nieca YpanbcKoe oTaejieHHe PAH EKaTepHH6ypr7 HIHCTHTYr neca KapernbcKoe oT2eneHJHe PAH rieTpo3asoaCK

8 BcepoccHcCKHr HHH arpOneCoMenUOpaUUU MHHHCTePCTBO cenJbcKoro X03HHrcTBa U(BHI4AJIMIH) npoaoBOnbCTBlHR Bonirorpan9 BCepOCCHUCKH HHCTHTyrT eKaPCTBeHHbIX MHHHcTePCTBO cejibCKoro XO3HHCTBa HnaCTeHacTeHuH (B 14 JAP) pOfIOBOIbCTBH MocKEa

Bbiciuee necoTeXHHmecKoe o6pa3o0aHUeI ApXaHreCjbCKHrH JecoTexHHMecKmH HHCTHTyT MHHHcTePCTBO o6wero H npo4)eccmo-

______ ~~~~~~~~~~~~HanbHor-o o6pa3oBaHHUs ApxaHre.nbCK2 CaHKT-nleTep6yprcKaq AecoTeXHH'ecKaR MHHHCTePCTBO o6uero H npo4,eccHo- CaHKT-IleTep6ypraKaaeMeHq HaJbHoro o6pa3OBaHH_3 THMHp.H3eBCKaq ceJbCKoXo3IHAcTBeHHam MHHHCTePCTBO o6wero H npo4FeccHo-

aKazeMHR HajibHoro o6pa3oBaHHq MocKBa4 MOCKOBCKUHU rocy!apIsCTBeHHbIH MUHHHCTePCTBO o6wuero H npo(FeccHO- MbITHUIH,*_____ YHHBePCHTeT nieca HanjbHoro o6pa3OBaHHq MoCKoBCKaH o6.nacTb5 MaptiricKHci floAmTexHH'ICCKHH HiCTHTyT MuHHcTePCTBO o6wero H npodpeccHo-HaJIbHOrO o6pa3OBaHHH hoLllKap-Oma

6 BopoHeKccKaa JecoTexHHmecKaR aKaaeMiHi MHHHCTePCTBO o6wero H npo(MeCCHO-HanjbHOrO o6pa3oBaHHA BopoHeK _7 SPAHCKHA TeXHonorHUqeCKHU HHCTUTyT MHHHCTePCTBO o6wero H npo4eccHo-HanJbHOrO o6pa3oBaHHq FBPAHCK8 YpaJibCKaq rocyaapCTBeHHaq M;HHcTepCTBO o6wero U npoceCCHO-

JIecoTexHHqecKasi aKaaeMHA HajIbHOrO o6pa30BaHHA EKaTepHH6ypr9 CH6HpcKaq TeXHojlorHleCKaR aKaaeMHI MHHHCTePCTBO o6fero H npoeecCHo-

HanjbHOrO o6pa3oBaHUH KpaCHoH cK10 fleTpo3aBoAcKHA rOcyaapCTBeHHWbA MuHHcTePCTBO o6wero H npo4eCCHO-YHHBePCHTeT HanjbHoro o6pa3oBaH UH nleTpo3aBO4C KII KOCTPOMCKOU TexHoAoruiqeCKKIA HHCTUTyT MHHHCTePCTBO o6fuero H npo4~eccHo-

HajlbHoro o6pa3oBaHlH4 KOCTpOMa12 HoBo4epKaCCKHr HUH)KeHepHO- MuHHcTePCTBO o6wero H npo4,eccHo- HoBo9epKaCCK,MenHopaTHBHbli HHCTHTyr HajibHoro o6pa3oBaHHs POCTOBCKaR o6nacTb13 BaWIlKHPCKHA rOCy2apCTBeHHbIA MHHHCTePCTBO o6mero H npo4seccmo-

CeenbCKOX03H xo3H HcTBeHHblH YHHBepCuCTeT HaJlbHOrO o6pa3oBaHH.u Ydpa14 HHiKeropoaicKaH ceAbcKoXo3.qACTBeHHasi MHHHCTepCTBO o6fero U ripo4eCCHO- HHiCHH1 HoBropo1aKaaeCMH. HaJbHoro o6pa3oBaHUHl

IS YaMypTCKag ceJ1bcKoxo3,qiCTBeHHaA MHHHCTePCTBO o6fero H npo4peccHo- 14)KCBCKaKaaeMHq HaJbHOrO o6pa3OBaHH_ _

ICTYlHJmK.: $)e[epaAbHaa cAyIK6a JieCHoro X03AACTBa Pocci.

Page 210: Russian - World Bank Documents

206 HPIIPOXCEHHE B

JIHTEPATYPA

Oblivin, Alexander N. 1992. "Planning and Management of Training Specialists for Forestry

and Forest Industry Market Economy". In the Proceedings of the IUFRO

International Conference Integrated Sustainable Multiple-Use Forest Management

Under Market System, September 6-12, 1992, Pushkino, Moscow Oblast, Russia,

Copenhagen, Denmark.

Teplyakov, Victor K. 1994. "Forestry Education in Russia" The Forestry Chronicle, vol. 70

(6), November-December.

TermHIKOB B.K., Beprep ,D.C. 1994. "Hay'Hoe o6ecne4eHHe iiecHoro xo3lAicTBa." -

CHpaBovHHK ffecHHvero. noi peAaKUHze B.A. HoBocenbiteBa, B 2-x ToMax,

wecToe H3,aaHHe, r. MocKBa.

Page 211: Russian - World Bank Documents

IPHJO)KEKHE B

PA3BHTHE JTECHOrO 3AKOHO,AMTEJlbCTBA B POCCHRCKOR (DEAEPAUIH

npoHcXo,a,iIuHe B PoccHH HoJIHTHqecKHe H MaKpo3KOHOMHqeCKHe npeo 6 pa3OBaHHHCOrIpOBo)KalOTcA UeflbIM pqOM H3MeHeHHA B POCCUUCKOM JieCHOM 3aKOHoaaTeJTbcTBe nocnieHPHSHTHR B mapTe 1993 roaa "OCHOB JIeCHOIO 3aKoHoaaTeAbcTBa POCCHUiCKOU cPezAepaiuH"(xarIee HMeHyeMbIx "OCHOBbl"). K IHC;iy ,IpyrFHx ripaBOBbIx aoKyMeHTOB, HMeoWUHx Ba)KHoe3HaqeHHe AnA AeCHOrO CeKTopa cTpaHbl, OTHOCSTCA KOHCTHTYUHS POCCHUCKOU $DerepauuH(.aeKa6pb 1993 roga), FpaKLaHCKH14 Ko,eKC POCCUUjCKOU (DeaepauH4 (qacTb , OKTI6pb1994 rona H laCTb II, AeKa6pb 1995 roaa) U4 beaepaTIbHbie 3aKoHbI "06 3KoAorHqecKOKi3KCnepT43e" H "06 oco6o oxpaHAeMbIx HpI4pO24HbIX TeppHTopII5x". YKa3bI npe3HaeHTa P$D"O KoH1enuHH nepexoaa POCCUUjCKOU cIegepauKH K YCTOINHBOMy pa3BHTH4o" (anpeAb1996 roaa), "O 4eaepajibHOR ueJIeBou nporpaMMe rocyaapCTBeHHOr4 noA4ep)KKHrocy1apCTBeHHbIx npHpOgHbIx 3aHOBe24HHKOB H HaUHoHayIbHbIx napKoB Ha riepHoa Ao2000 roza" (oKTs6pb 1995 roaa) H apyrHe TaioKe qBEISIOTCS BaKHbIMH XnI POCCHiucKoronecHoro ceKTopa.

B aeKa6pe 1995 roga FocyaapCTBeHHaA ayMa (HH)KHAS nanIaTa rapJIaMeHTa) npuHHwlaHOBblUi .TeCHoi Ko,eKc. npe3HaeHT BepHyJI KoAeKC B ayMy =An rOBTOpHOFO paccMOTpeHHH.ayMa nepecMoTpena JIeCHOi KoAeKc, npuHHB BO BHHMaHHe 3aMeqaHHA npe3HAeHTa, H BHOBbnpOrOJIOCOBania 3a ero npHSHTHe B HIOJIe 1996 roaa. ORHaKo COBeT (DeaepaLuiu (BepxHAsnaJIaTa napJiaMeHTa) OTKJIOHHJI JAeCHOA KOaeKC Ha TOM OCHOBaHH4, qTO OH He COOTBeTCTByeTKOHCTHTYUHH H apyrHM 3aKOHaM POCCHUICKOU (PeaepauHH. B oKTs6pe-Hoq6pe 1996 roganpoeKT JecHoro KofeKca o6 cyxAancJ corJiaCHTejIbHOu KOMHCCHeri o6eHx naiaT napJIaMeHTaH npaBHTeJIbCTBa. no Coo 6 ILLeHHAM, o6cyycAeHHe HOqTH nOAHOCTbIO 6bUIO HOCBslUeHoBonpocaM nipaBa co 6 CTBeHHOCTH Ha iiecHOU djOHA H 6buI AOCTHrHyT KOMlPOMHCC nOCTaTbe 19, KOTOpaA Tenepb gonycKaeT 3Ha4HTeybHo 6 oJIbIiylo rH6KOcTb B pewIeHHHBOnpOCOB 0 co 6 CTBeHHOCTH Ha nieca cy6'beKTOB POCCHUCKOUi (PeepaLUHH. O)KcHanOcb, qTO C3TUM H3MeHeHHeM npoeKT JlecHoro KoaeKca gojnceH 6bum 6blTb HPIHHT ayMOrl 1 lI eKa6ps1996 ro4a 1. MaTepHanlbl HaCTOslU.ero fPpHOKxeHHA OCHOBaHbl Ha OdULHiajbHOM TeKCTeJlecHoro KoCeKca B peaaKLXHH OT 5 HIOJIS 1996 roaa (ornaBqeHHe Ko,eKca rpeaCTaBJeHO B,anOHOHeHuH 1 K ,aHHOMy rpHiOiKeHHIo).

TeKCT npOeKTa JIeCHorO KOCeKca (HIOnb 1996 roaa) cyIUeCTBeHHO oTjiHMaeTCA OTOCHOB 1993 roaa. B ero 2 0-TH riaBax H 13 8 -MH cTaTbsx coaep)KHTcA LUebnbl pRA HOBbIXnOHATHi H onpeaeAeHHri, a TaxxKe cyLteCTBeHHo nepecMoTpeHHbie cTaHLapTbi H npaBsuIna,perynnpyiouL4e HCnOJIb3oBaHHe, oxpaHy, 3aiuHTy JlecHoro 4OHaa H BOCnpOH3BOgCTBO necoB.CorlacHo 00e,epaAbHOri cJIyK6e necHoro XO3HliCTBa, OCHOBHbIMH LtenmMH HOBOrO AecHoroKogeKca ABJIAIOTCH yKpenrieHHe rOcygapCTBeHHOU CHCTeMbi ynpaBJIeHHA H BeaeHH4A JIecHoroXO3SArcTBa H o6ecneqeHHe Bceo6beMjiiowux rnpaBoBblx paMOK nA AA OJIrOCpOqHoroHCHOAb3OBaHHH nieCHbIX peCypcoB B YCAIOBHAX pbIHOqHOR 3KOHOMHKH.

I OKOH1iaTeJnbHbIi BapUiaHT AleCHoro KoaIeKca POCCHICKOi (DeaepauHH 6bln np1HHT rocyalapCTBeHHOU,ayMorl 22 qHBaps 1997 r. (nlpHMeiaHHe peaaKTopa pyccKoro H3AaHHr).

Page 212: Russian - World Bank Documents

208 nPHPAOKEHHE B

HOBEne KOHLtenUHH H onpeAejieHHn

npoeKT JlecHoro KoIeKca 60iee 4eTKO onpeaeJI5eT ccpy HpHMcHeHHJf JIecHoro

3aKOHO4BaTCJhCTB B POCCHUCKOU (DeaepaUHH. PerynHpoBaHie 4CXOaHT U3 npeaCTaBCeHHA o

niece KaK 0 COBOKyrHOCTH .iecHOu pacTHTeJIbHOCTH, 3eMJIH, )KHBOTHOrO MHpa H ApyrHX

KOMnOHeHTOB oKpy)KaiOLLeg npHpOAHOf4 cpeabi, HMeiOiLefU Ba)KHOe 3KOJIorHMecKoe,

3KOHoMHIecKoe H couHanibHoe 3HaqeHHe. B COOTBeTCTBHH C KoaeKcom BCe OTHOLUeHHI B

o6JIacH HcHo]Ib3oBaHHH, OxpaHbi, 3aLIJHTbi H BoCJ7poH3BOIaCTBa necoB peryffHpyIorcq

HCK"iOwHTeJbHO IeCHbIM 3aKoHoaaTe)ibCTBoM (CTaTbS 5). ,RpyrHe o6nacTH npaBa

(rpaInaHCKOe H aaMHHHCTpaTHBHOe 3aKOHOaaTeJlbCTBO H 3aKOHOaaTej1bCTBO O paCTHTejibHOM

MHpe, 3eMeJTbHOe H BOAHOe 3aKOHOAaTCJibCTBO) nepeq4CJIeHbl B KaqeCTBe npHM4eHHMbIX K

KOHKpeTHbIM acneKTaM JieCHbIX OTHOlweHHUi. I'cHOJTb3oBaHHe H oxpaHa 3eMeJIb iiecHoro

4)OHaa aOjDKHbi peryJIHpOBaTbCS COBMeCTHO IieCHbIM H 3eMeCJbHbIM 3aKOHOaaTeAbCTBOM.

"OTHoIueHHI B o6JaCTH HCIIOhb30BaHHu H OXPaHbi xKHBOTHOrO MHpa, BOaHbiX 06oeKTOB,

HeITp, aTMOc/epHOrO Bo3ayxa peryJIHpyIOTCH JeCHbMM 3aKOHOaaTeJIbCTBOM B TO# Mepe, B

KaKoA 3To Heo6xOIaHMo afff palHoHaoJIbHoro HcHoJb3oBaHHm, oxpaHbl, 3L(HTbI H

Bocnpom3BoIcTBm IecoB" (CTaTbA 5, qaCTb 5).

CnrCOK o6weKTOB nieCHbX OTHOIueHHi4 6bml pacluipeH, H onpeaejieHue JiecHoro

4ioHLaa 6buLo nepecMoTpeHO. B COOTBeTCTBIH Co CTaTbef4 6 KoaeKca "o6beKTraMH JIecHbJx

OTHOIFeHHlmf JB.IIOTCJ1 JecHoo JOHa POCCHACKOg 'eaepagHH ( aanee - IecHoJ OHq),

yYaCTKIH JCHOrO /oHoaa, HpaBa uofIb3oBaHH5 HMH, nieca, He BXoa(e B JieCHoI i1)OHn, HX

yqaCTKIf, ipaBa IOJhb30BaHBHH5 HMH, a(peBecHO-KycTapHHfKOBqJq pqCTfTCJIbHOCTb . CaMo

noHfTIc JecHoro oHo4a, onpeaejieHHoe B OcHoBax, KaK BKJmoMaloaoWee Bce .neca H Bce

3eMJTH, BbiLeJIeHHbie anA IieCHbIX uenieu, cyxKeHO B HOBOM KozeKce: "Bce ffeca, 3a

HCKjOvoeHHeM .lecOB, paCHOvOoxeHHbIX Ha 3eMjflX o6opoHm H 3eMjzqX HaCefeHHbiX I7yHKTOB

(nocejieHHfi), a TaioKe 3eMH IecHoro boHaa, He 7oKpbi bie mecHoJf pacTHTenbHocTbio

(.iIecHbie 3eMJiH H HeJIeCHbIC 3eMIIf), o6pa3yiOT JleCHOI OH'" (CTaTbs 7). OJHaKo 6onbma3l

,4aCTb roloJKeHHA KoaeKca 3aTparHBaeT KaK IieCHOu d)OHA, TaK H nieca, He Bxoa15uHe B

JieCHOH 4)OHA, H nO3TOMY HOBOe BBeAeHHOe paiimme Me)Ky aByMSA KaTerOpUIAMH

npe,acTaBjiSieTcS HCKyCCTBeHHbIM. 3To YCJIO)KH5eT BeAeH2 ei necHoro xO3SIcTBa, nOCKOJTbKy B

TOM, WTO KacaeTcs JieCOB, He BXOAIUHX B iieCHOg 4)OHA, KoaeKC He perynHpyeT TaKHe

Ba)KHb1e BOnpOCbl, KaK rOCyaapCTBeHHOe JieCOyCTpOHCTBO H MOH4TOp4Hr, CHCTeMa nniaTexeu

3a HX HCHOJnb3OBaHHe HuJH CTOqHHKH (bl4HaHCHPOBaHHR 3aTpaT Ha rocyIaPCTBeHHoe

ynpasBJeHHe H BseeHHe uiecHoro XO35lrCTBa.

nIpoeKT KoaeKca BBOAXIT nOHATme ny6ulHMHoro H MaCTHoro JieCHoro cepBHTyTa

(CTaTbS 21), HO COLepKHT JIHUb OqeHb o6Lue noJIo)KeHH1 o peryFJHPOBaHlHH

npeaocTasnieHHuq TaKHX CepBHTYTOB H nOP51AKe uHCnOJb3oBaHHu1 npi4MeHHMOFO rpaxKnaHCKoro,

3eMeJbHOrO HuH HHOrO 3aKOHoaaTeAbcTBa.

BoHpocm HpaBa Co6CTBcHHOCTH Ha JICHOff owoHR H yHpa/eHH

FpoeKT JeCHOrO KOleKCa BBO,4HT nOHiTH4e o6poTOcoco6HOcTH G6b c B J7iCCHhX

oTHoiieHHif. B COOTBeTCTBHH C rpaKlC4aHCKHM 3aKOHO,aTeJIbCTBOM POCCUUlCKOU (eAepauHi4

3eMJTH Hu pyrHe npHPOXHb1e pecypcbi MOrYT OTqyADaTbCs HiH nepeXOXIHTb OT OAHOrO AHua K

,LpyrOMy .ilO6bIM cnoco6oM B TOUi Mepe, B KaKOA HX o6opoT AOnyCKaeTCq 3aKOHOaaTejibCTBOM

o 3eMji H ,apyrHx npHPOJIHblX pecypcax ([pamnaHcKHf KoaeKc, CTaTbA 129). OAHaKo npoeKT

Page 213: Russian - World Bank Documents

209 lHPK4O)IKEHHE B

JiecHoro KoaeKca 3anpetuaeT KynJO,H npoaaxKy, yaep)KaHHe uinu HHbie caeJIKH, BeayCuH KOTY)KyLeHHIO JieCHoro dFOHaa Hum neCOB, He BXORALUS4X B AeCHOu (DOHA. TeM He MeHee, OHpa3peLmaeT caeCJKH, CBA3aHHbie C nepe,aaeg npaB Ha HcnoJb3OBaHHe niecHoro 4oi-Ha HinunieCOB, He BXO,S1WUHX B jieCHoA OHa, a TaKXKe nepeaaqy npaB Ha HCnOAb3OBaHHe apeBecHO-KycTapHHKOBOr4 pacTHTeJIbHOcTH, He BXOaLuIeri B ieCHOi bOHA.

3anpeT Ha KynFiJo, npoaaxKy, HaJIoKeHHe apecTa Hun juo6ypo apyryio caeJIKy, KOTOpaAnpHBO,aHT K OTqyxKaeHHIo nIecHoro cfOHaa H nTeCOB, He BXO,SIl1UHX B TeCHOA 4OHa,paBHO3HaqeH HX H3'b5ITH40 H3 rpaxKLaHCKoro o6opoTa. Fepe,aaqa npaBa Ha nOJlb3OBaHHeAeCHbIM 43OHAOM H AecaMi4, He BXOaS1UUHMH B ieCHo0 bOHa, perynHpyeTc5i CKOpeerpawK4aHCKHM KoaeKKCoM H 3eMejbHbIM 3aKOHoraTeJIbCTBOM, He)KseH JIeCHbIM3aKOHOAaTeAbCTBOM.

npOeKT JiecHoro KOaeKCa BBOAHT nOHMTHe co6CTBeHHOcTH. KOHCTHTYLIUHrpe,ycMaTpHBaeT BO3MO)KHOCTb (He aenas ee o6Al3aTeJibHori) COcyIlteCTBOBaHHlA pa3JlHqHbIx(bopM co6CTBeHHOCTH Ha Hp4pOAHb[e pecypcbl, BKJIIOqaM 3eMAIo H neca, a HMeHHO: 4acTHyIo,rocynapcTBeHHylO, MyHHuuHraAbHyMo H 4HHO (CTaTbm 9). FpawaaHcKoe 3aKoHoaaTeJ]bcTBopaccMaTpHBaeT nieca KaK HeRBHiKHMOCTb (FpaWaHcKHII KOaeKc, CTaTbS 130). Co 6 CTBeHHHKHTaKoro HMyLuecTBa MmelOT npaBo OT'Iy)IaTb ero B co 6 CTBeHHOCTb ApyrHM JH4ULaM,nepe,aaBaTb KM, OCTaBaR5Cb co6CTBeHH4KOM, npaBa BJIaAeHHI4, nOJIb3OBaHHS H pacnopADKeHHAHMyi1eCTBOM H COBepluaTb apyr4e aeACTBHA, He HpOTHBopeqauiHe 3aKOHY (rpaAQaHcKHi4Ko,aeKc, CTaTbS 209). BonpeKu 3THM KOHCTHTyUHOHHbIM HIOKoxeHHUAM, lIpOeKT JeCHoroKo,aeKca npeiaraaa B Huo1e 1996 roaa, MTo6bl Bce .neca necHoro (bOHaa H nieca,pacnoJIoKeHHbie Ha 3eMJI5Ix, BbIfejieHHbIX Ha LenuH o 6 opOHbl, HaxoaHjiHCb B beaepajIbHOAco6CTBeHHOCTH (CTaTbA 19). nocneyioLume nepecMorpeHHble BapuaHTbl 3TOU CTaTbH,KOTOpbIe ripeaycMaTpHBaloT 6onbuIylo rH6KOcTb H y'HTbIBaioT perHOHajibHbIe HHTepecbl, eweHe 6blJI B O¢HLLHanbHOM riopsiKe AOCTyHHbl B MOMeHT OKOH4aTenbHoU nOarOTOBKHHacToAwero ,omnaga. KpoMe Toro, rpoeKT JiecHoro KoaeKca onpeaejiHeT co 6 CTBeHHOCTb KaKKaTeropHIo, BKJlIO'aiOu.yio o6si3aTeJbCTBO Co6CTBeHHHKa HeCTH 6peMA 3aTpaT Ha OxpaHy,3auHTy, BOCrpOH3BOACTBO H opraHH3aLxHio paUHOHaIbHOro HCHOAb3OBaHH RpHHaHWe)KaLu[4xemy o6'beKTOB H ero ipaBO Ha ioAy4eHHe aOXOaOB OT HCnOJIb3OBaHHq 3THX pHHa14JHe)KauHxo6beKToB (CTaTbH 18, t aCTb 2).

Fpa>KLaHCKHI KOaeKC npeaycMaTpHBaeT, 'TO 3eMimH U ApyrHe npKpOAHbie pecypcbi(BKmIio'aA Tneca), He HaxOatHlleCH B co6cTBeHHOCTH rpaxKQaH, IOPH4,HH4eCK4X HU nuH6oMYHH[lHnaJ1bHbIX o6pa3OBaHHrl, HBJISoTCA rocyaapcTBeHHOA co6CTBeHHOCTbIO (CTaTbq 214,MaCTb 2). O6bABnieHHe rocyaapcTBeHHOA co6CTBeHHOCTH (beaepajibHOA co6CTBeHHOCTbIO Hnuco6CTBeHHOCTblO cy6'beKTa POCCHUCKOU (DeaepauHH (BKIlio'as pecny6.RiKH, KpaH, o6nacTH HOKpyra) 6yaeT npOXOaHTb B COOTBeTCTBHH C 3aKOHOM. CornaCHO npe3HLaeHTCKOMY YKa3Y "O4be,aepa.nbHbIx npHpOZ4HbIx pecypcax" (fleKa6pb 1993 roga), 3eMeIbHbIe Y4aCTKH H apyrHerpIpO,aHbie pecypcbl (BKnlio'aAi neca) moryT paccMaTpHBaTbcA KaK 4eaepajibHaHco6CTBeHHOCTb B cHny HX pacnojio)KeHHH uuHH HX Ha3HaqeHHR HAu Ha OCHOBe B3aHMHorocorJIaweHHA, AOCTHrHyTOrO Mexay qjeaepaAbHbIMH BAaCTSMIH H perHOHaAbHbIMH BjiaCTHMH.

KOHCTHTYUUHR (CTaTbH 72, 'aCTb 1-B) pacCMaTPHBaeT BOnPOCbl BAaaeHH,HOJIb3OBaHMH H pacnOpsAKeHHA 3eMAeri H apyrmMH npH4pOaHbIMH pecypcaMH (BKTIco'0aH Jleca)KaK HaXORALLWHeCH B COBMeCTHOM BeaeH4H4 POCCHU4CKOUi ()eaepaLtHH H cy6,beKTOBPOCCHHCKOH (DeaepaUH4H. B CHJIy 3T0oro noo0)KeHH4e JecHoro KoaeKca 0 TOM, 'TO Bce 3eMnuH4

Page 214: Russian - World Bank Documents

210 HPHJ1O)EHME B

JleCHoro 4OHaa H Bce nieca, 3a HCKJlio4eHHeM necoC,BH npHHa8Ae)KaWHX MyHHUHnaJIbHbIM

opraHam BJIaCTH, qBASIOTCSI 4)eAepaJIbHOR co6cTBeHHocTblo, Bbl3BaJIO BO3pa)KeHHe Lenoro

psAa ripaBHTejIbCTB cy6'beKTOB 4)egepaUHH, H KoaeKc 6bum OTKJTOHeH COBeToM (IeaepaLXHH.

OZHaKO He Bce noXaep)KaJIH 3TOT war. CornacHo c1eaepajibHoR cjiy)K6e aiecHoro xo3.9tkcTBa,

MHOrie jieCOH36blTOtIHbie perHOHbl COMHeBalOTCS B Jxenecoo6pa3HocTH FIpeTeH3HA Ha 3eMJiH

iieCHoro (DOHaa, iOCKOJIbKy 3T0 O3Haqajio 6bl npMHHTHe Ha ce6A Bcex CBq3aHHb[X C 3THM

pacxoioB 3a BeeeHme necHoro XO39riCTBa H Morno 6bl B KOHe4HOM cxeTe Co3aaTb npaBOBOUinpeLleZIeHT, KOTOpbiA nO3BOJnHji 6bl HeKOTOpbIM paiOHHbIM opraHam BJIlaCTH B COCTaBe

cy61beKTOB (DeAepaItHH npeTeHROBaTb Ha par4OHHOe npaBo co6CTBeHHOCTH Ha nyqWuHe

yqaCTKU IiecHoro 4oH,A,a. npoeKT KoaeKca npeaocTaBji5eT Ba)KHbie nOHJHOMOqH5 Cy6¶beKTaM

cDeixepauim no TaKHM BonpocaM, KaK BeaeHHe necHoro XO35RCTBa H BocnpOH3BOCTBO jiecOB

H 3aKmioteHHe 4OrOBOpOB AeconoJIb3oBaHHA.

BoHpocm peryIJpoBaHHLlJ H Be4cHNIJ )ccHoIo Xa3HA*CTBa

npoeKT JeCHoro KOaeKCa npeIyCMaTPHBaeT, 'TO rocyIapCTBeHHoe ynpaBeeHHe H

perynHpoeaHHe mcnoJIb3oBaHHsI, OXpaHbl, 3a1111Tbln iecHoro 4OHla H BOCnpOH3BOaCTBa niecoB

6y,aeT OCyLueCTBJIATbCq 4beaepaJIbHbIM npaBHTeCJbCTBOM HeriOCpeaCTBeHHO HJIH epe3

ynOAHOMO'eHHbie opraHbl HCnOAHHTeJTbHOii BjiaCTH. (YHKUHH Aio6oro TaKoro

4e,aepaAbHoro opraHa 6yayT onpeaeZi3TbCI npaBHTeAbCTBOM.

fpoeKT JlecHoro Ko0eKca TaKoKe H3MeHSeT pawefIeHme oTBCTCBHHOCTH MCexgy

p&31V HMMH YPOBHZMH F rCy48pCTBCHHOIO YHPaWCHH 3a HcnoJIb3oBaHHe, oxpaHy, 3aULHTY

necHoro (DOHaa m BOCnPOH3BOIICTBO JieCOB. HO7qHOMOHqH POCCHIcKO# 'Peaepawn, (KaK

3aKOHo,aaTeJIbHOi, TaK H HCrOJIHHTeSJbHOU BeTBrl BJaCTH) BKJloqalOT:

* BJIaaeHHe, nOJIb3OBaHHe H pacnops5KeHHe IieCHbIM 4jOHAOM, BKjHOMqa eAHHyIO

HHBeCTHUHOHHYIO nOJIHTHKY B o6JlaCTH HC4cOJIb3oBaHHS, OXpaHbI H 3aWHTbl

JieCHoro oHHa H BOCnpOH3BOaCTBa niecoB;

* nepeBOA iieCHbIX 3eMeJlb B HeiieCHbIe 3eMJIH B LueCJIx, He CBI3aHHbIX C BeaeHHeM

niecHoro XO3HACTBa H nOJb3OBaHHeM JTeCHbIM fOHROM H (Hnu) H3bSlTHe necHoro

4OH,Aa B necax nepBoA rpynnbI;

* o61bsqBeHHe y'aCTKOB JIeCHoro 4OHAa 30HaMH xipe3BbiqaAHbIX 3KoJIorWqecKHx

CHTyaUHUf H 30HaMH 3KojiorHqecKoro 6eaCTBHq.

17pec,JaiiaeTc., YTo6bi fO]JHOMOIH1 cCy6zeKToB PoccHucKo* OeCepaLlH BKJlioqa'iH:

* llpUHHqT4e peweHHHi O npe,OCTaBJIeHHH yiaCTKOB ieCHoro 4)OHaa B apeHAy,

6e3Bo3Me3fAHoe noJnb3OBaHH H KpaTKOCpO4Hoe nonb3oBaHue;

* YCTaHOBneHHe CTaBOK nieCHbIx noLsaTei H CTaBOK apeHAnoH nHaTbI (3a

HcKjno,4eHHeM MHHHManJbHbIX CTaBOK nIiaTbl 3a ApeBecHHy, OTnycKae Mylo Ha

KOpHIO), a TaioKe nniaTbl 3a nepeBoa nieCHbIX 3eMeCJb B HeCJeCHbIC 3eMIH;

Page 215: Russian - World Bank Documents

211 nPHIAO)KEHHE B

nepeBoa 11eCHbIX 3eMenJb B HeiieCHbIe 3eMJAH B uemAx, He CBs13aHHb1X C BeaeHHeMJieCHOrO X03HUCTBa H InOJib3OBaHHeM JIeCHbIM 4JOHaOM H (unu) H3bsTHe 3eMeJnbJleCHoro bOHHa B necax BTOPOU H TpeTber rpynn.

nOJIHOMO4uH opraHoB BjiaCTH cy6'beKToB POCCHIUCKOfl cDeaepauHH pacWHup.IOTC 3acqeT nepeaaMH HM 3Ha4HTeJlbHO 'iaCTH HOAHOMOMHHU paHOHHb1X OpraHOB BJlaCTH B o6.naCTHcnoAb3OBaHHA, oxpaHbl H 3alUHTbI .ieCHOro 4)oHaa H BOCnPOH3BOaCTBsa necoB. B HOBOMKo,aeKce He yKa3aH Kpyr nOJIHOMOMUH opraHOB MeCTHOrO CaMOyypaBJneHHS, OH TOJlbKOnpeAycMaTpHBaeT, 4TO rOCyIapCTBO MO)KeT nlpeOCTaBHTb 3THM OpraHam rlOJIHOMO'HR Bo6ilaCTH 4cnojib3oBaHHSI, OXpaHbl, 3aUHTbl SieCHoro 4OHaa H BOCFIpOH3BOLCTBa J1eCOB BCOOTBeTCTBHH C 3aKoHoaaTeAbCTBOM POCCHtiCKOU 4eeaepauHH. apyrHMH cJIoBaMH, MaCTbHbIHeWlHei KOMneTeHUHH opraHoB MeCTHOFO caMoynpaBJIeHHS nepeaaeTcs opraHam BJaCTHcy6beKToB cPeaepafLHH, H noao6HbIM o6pa3OM qaCTb HbIHeWHer KoMr1eTeHuHH opraHOBBJsaCTH cy6'beKTOB (PeaepaUHH nepeaaeTcs POCCHUCKOU (DeaepaLtHH.

npoeKT JeCHOrO KoaeKca npezaaraeT Ba)KHOe onpeaeneHHe 4)eaepanbHoro opraHaynpaBJ1eHHR AeCHbIM X0351rCTBOM (¢eaepanbHOU cJnyx6bi JieCHOrO X03sIqiCTBa) B KaqeCTBeroc2apcTBCHHorV oplaHa yrIpa& eHHz. (DaKTHqeCK4 HMeeTCA B BWay, 'TO 3TOT OpraH HeMO)KCeT 3aHHMaTbCq AesTeAbHOCTbIO, CBR3aHHOri C rony'ieHHeM ripH6bmuti, BKAlO'aSAocyweCTBneHHe py6oK riaBHoro nOJb3OBaHH4l H nepepa6oTKy noj1ymeHHOri npH 3TOMlapeBeCHHbl. noao6Hbie orpaHH'eHHS OTHOCATCA KO BCeM AOJDKHOCTHb1M iHLaM JileCHOHcnyx6bI, aeriCTByIOUHM B Ka'eCTBe rOCyaapCTBeHHbIX cAyxaWuHx. B CTaTbe 50 KoaeKcanoAI'epKHBaeTCA HeCOBMeCTHMOCTb KOMMepCecKoS py6KH nieca H nepepa6oTKHL apeBeC4Hbl c4IYHKUHAMm rOCyaapCTBeHHOrO ynpaBJTeHHI4 B o6iaCTTH 4CnOAb3OBaHHA, OXpaHbi, 3allUHTblnecHoro 4)oHaa H BOCnpOH3BOaCTBa necoB. KoaeKCc npeaycmaTpuaeT qeTKoe onpeaejieHHe4)YHKUHrl JieCXO30B H HiLiHOHanbHbIX napKOB. XOT5I le- ope OHH CTaHOBSTCA OpraHaMHrOcyIapCTBeHHOrO ynpaBJIeHHM, e-1aKmTo OHH OCTaiOTCA roCyaapCTBeHHbIMHnpeanrpHATHAIMH, 3aHHMaiOLlIHMHCA BeaeHHeM nieCHoro X03AIMCTBa. KaK H paHee, fleCXo3b1aOJ)DKHbI BblnOJIHSTb riaBHb1M o6pa3oM opraHH3auHoHHbie H KOHTpOJbHble, He)Ksena,aMHHHCTpaTHBHbie 4yHKuL4.

B COOTBeTCTBHH C ripoeKToM JecHoro KoaeKca JieCXO3bl H TeppHTOpHanlbHbIe opraHbicIe,aepaibHOi CJIy)K6bI TiecHoro X03sICTBa, SIBJ5IHCb opraHaMH rocyIapCTBeHHoroynpaBJleHHs, 6yayr HMeTb npaBO Ha ocBo6oAWeHHe OT HeKOTOpwlX HallOiOB H IL!IaTcxiif npHBe,[eHHH iieCHOrO XO3.IACTBa (CTaTbS 104, 'IaCTb 3). FpeaCTaBniqeTCs, 'TO (DOPMYJ1HPOBKa3TorO nOJIO)KeHHA ABJ1AeTCA He COBCeM TO'YHOU4, riOCKOJbKY B HeM He nPOBOaHTCA pa3JiHiHlIMe)Ay peryTIHPOBsaHHeM necHoro X03AACTBa (aAMHHHCTpaTHBHbie 4YHKLXHH) H BeaeHHeMniecHoro XO3SACTBa (3KOHOMH'eCKHie 4IYHKUH4). TeM He MeHee, no MHeHHlO cDeaepanbHOtlcny)K6bl necHoro xo3JIicTBa, "MeponpHSTHR no BeaeHHIO iiecHoro Xo3,qriCTBa ABJISIOTCS CYTbIOrocy,aapCTBeHHOrO ynpanBjeH1H AeCHbIM X03AflCTBOM B xo.e HbIHeWUHerO nepexoaHororiepHo,aa" (Ma.r4pSeB, flH'iHoe coo6iueHHe, ulonlb 1996 roaa). HanpHMep, B COOTBeTCTBHHCO CTaTberi 91 Ko,eKca, JieCXO3bi 6yuyT o66H3aHbI, ecnIH HeT HHOti opraH43aUUH, cnoco6HOriBbIIOJTHHTb 3Ty 3aAa'y, OCyLweCTBJIATb HpoqUHjiaKTH'eCKHe py6KH gLiJ nOBbIUweHUinpOLYKTHBHOCTH iieCOB. rloao6HbMM o6pa3OM npOdUHjiaKTH'IeCK4e py6KU OCBO6OwaalOTCS OTnieCHbIX noXaTerf, aa)Ke eCJIH OHH OCyUXeCTBJIAIOTCu KOMMep'eCKHM apeHraTopom neca(CTaTbS 103).

Page 216: Russian - World Bank Documents

212 flPHAOKEHHE B

Bonpocm JIecoI7oJIb3RaiH

npoeKT JIeCHorO KoaeKca coaep)KHT noj1o)KeHHu, perynupypoiume npouecc

npeAocTasBjeHHu H npeKpalueHH5 npaB Ha Hcnojib3OBaHue necHoro 4)OHaa H nIecOB, He

BXO,ALHUHX B J1eCHOri 4)OHA, H opH,aiHqecKyIO 3aiuTy TaKHx npaB. HOBbiU AecHoA KOaeKC

HecoMHeHHO qBjnieTCA Ba)KHbIM uwaroM B npO5ICHeHHH MCXBHH3MOB padci7nC4efIeHMIl H

HCIOff3OBaHNfl JIeCHmX peCypCOB (CTaTbH 31-45), KOTOpbIe BKJlio'alOT aOrOBOpbi apeHabi,

6e3Bo3Me3nHoro HoJIb3OBaHH5I, KOHLeCCHH yqaCTKOB iecHoro (bOHaa (Ha CPOK ao 49 nIeT) H

AOrOBOpbI KpaTKOCPO4Horo nOJIb3OBaHH5I (xao OAHoro roaa).

iJeCHme KOHKypCi (ayKULHoHbl) AOJDKHbI CTaTb OCHOBHblM MeTOQOM 3aKJIIoqeHH4l

,aorOBOpOB apeHabi. AyKlluHOHHasi KOMHCCHS RJODKHa BO3rJaBjiSqTbCq npeflCTaBtTeJTeM opraHa

rocy,aapCTBeHHOr BjTaCTH cy6lbeKTa O1eaepaUHH, a He paROHHOA aaMUHHHCTpaU1U4, KaK 3TO

6bmo npeaycMOTpeHO B 'OCHOBax". 9 TH KOMUCCUU )IOJDKHbl BKJHO'oaTb B ce6s

npeXICTaB4TejieA TeppHTOpHanJbHbIX opraHOB yipaBJIeHHIu iieCHbIM XO35IhCTBOM (3aMecTHTeAb

npeaceJaTenA), ynOflHOMo4eHHbIX opraHoB no oxpaHe oKpy4Kaio1leg cpeabi, a TaK)Ke

npeAcTaBHTeiieri DpyrHX 3aHTepeCOBaHHbX opraHM3aumrl. Pacw[HpeHHblr cocTaB

ayKlUHOHHOH KOMHCCUH o6ecneqHT BO3MO)KHOCTb KoJIjerFaHjbHoro pUIHHqTHS peweHHA

OTHOCHTeJbHO npeaoCTaBjieHN5 npaB Ha apeHAy yIaCTKOB neCHoro 4)oHAa. HO HCTeqeHuH

cpoKa apeHabl apeHayeMbie yqaCTKH He nepeaalOTc5l B co6cTBeHHocTb apeHIAaTopa.

06m3aT7TCTBa HN paBa ffecoHoJb3oBaTeeH Iii3[IaralOTC 6o0nee noRpo6HO B CTaTbSIX 23-30,

o6ecne'qHBaI XonHOAHHTejibHYIO npO3patHOCTb UX OTHOlwleHH1 C apeH,floaaTeji5Mm

(necxo3aMtH).

,4oroBop KOHueCCHfH yvacma 7ecHoro OOHaa - HOBOe nOHqITHC B pOCCHUCKOM ieCHOM

3aKOHOgaTejTbCTBe; OH MO)KeT 6bITb 3aKJioieH 4eaepajIbHbIM npaBi4TeCjbCTBOM HJIH ero

ynOJIHOmoqeHHbIM opraHoM (($eaepanbHas cnyx6a iieecHoro xo3iricTBa) c nIo6biM JIHuLoM,

HPH3HaBaeMbIM HHBeCTOpOM B COOTBeTCTBHe C pOCCH1iCKHM 3aKoHoaaTeJTbCTBoM. ,DoroBop

KOHL1eccHm LRoJDKeH 3aKJHo4aTbCg no pe3yJTbTaTaM npOBeLaeHH5 KOHKypca HuIn ayKUHoHa. B

LaorOBOp KOHUeCCHH y,.aCTKa iieCHOrO 4)OHaa BKJlioqalOTCH, B x4aCTHOCTH, cJleLyiolUHe

YCJIOB45u: nopqAOK pa3Aejia ao6blTblX iieCHbIX pecypcoB (npoayKuHH) nJIH npeaoCTaBeHH5R

ycJyr; nOPSAOK onpeaejieHHq H ynHIaTbl HajToroB, C6OpOB H ,pyrux nHJaTe)Keri; H

o6sI3aHH-ocTm HHBeCTOpa no CTpOHTenJbCTBY H coaep)KaHI4O aopor H apyrHx o6'beKToB

4H4?paCTpyKTypbl H HHbIe yCJIOBH51, npefycMOTpeHHble 3aKOHoXAaTCejbCTBOM POCCHUCKOU

4)e,aepauHH H onpe,ejieHHbie no corniaweHHIo CTOpOH. aOrOBOpbl KOHUCCCHH ymaCTKOB

.ieCHorO 4OHaa nloJie)KaT rOCyRapCTBeHHOU peri'CTpau14H B COOTBeTCTBUH C rpawAaHCKHM

3aKOHoAaTejibCTBOM H 3aKOHoaaTeAbCTBOM POCCHUiCKOU (DepaepauHH o KOHUeCciH.

npoeKT JIecHoro KoaeKca TaK)Ke 4)opManIH3yeT noHI5THe A'orowpa 6e3Bo3Me3aHoro

flofIb3oBaHJf, yvaCTKOM JIecHoro oHo4a. PewJeHHq o rpe,oCTaBneHuu yqaCTKOB niecHoro

4OH,aa IA5 TaKOrO BHJIa nojb3oBaHHq Ha CpOK ,ao 49 neT AOJD)KHbi npHHHMaTbCe

perHOHanJbHb[MH opraHamH BJIaCT4. npaBO Ha 6e3Bo3Me3,AHoe nOJ1b3OBaHHe Mo)KeT, B

IIaCTHOCTH, npeaoCTaBJIATbCS ceeJbCKOXO3HriCTBeHHbIM opraHH3aL\HR M. O61beaIHHeHHR

OXOTHHKOB TaK)Ke HMelOT npaBo HCnOJIb3OBaTb JIeCHbie 3eMj1H AMS opraHH3aUHH

nlo6HTeJIbcKog H CnOpTHBHOA OXOTbl.

"BXOgHme 6apbwpm" ,411Z 24efIfIbHOCTH HOBMX IcCnOJInfOBaTe7nJIeH CHH)KeHbI, HO He

ycTpaHeHbI nOJIHOCTbIO. B 4aCTH 3 CTaTbH 34 no-npe)KHeMy rpeaycmaTpHBaeTCq

Page 217: Russian - World Bank Documents

213 fPHJIO)KEHIE B

npexocTaBjieHHe yIaCTKOB niecHoro dOHzta B apeHay 6e3 HpOBeaeHHSA nieCHbIX KOHKypCOB (HaCpOK OT OAHOrO AO nHTH JAeT) Ha OCHOBaHHpH peweHHs perHOHaJibHOrO opraHa BJMaCTHJIeconoJIb3oBaTeCJIM, ¶,:vffTHeffbHOe BpCM5J ocywcCTBnfKILuHM CBOIO ,ZWZTeCTbHOCTb Ha a8HHOgTeppHTOpHH H HmeIOLaHM i7pOH3Bo0[CTBeHHbie MOLAHHOCTH /UH 3arOTOBKH H fepepa6oTKH/ipeBeCHHI HA pyrTHx necHblx pecypcoB boiee Toro, npoeKT JIecHoro KoaeKca He coaep)KHTMeTKHX aHThMOHOI7OJIbH"X HOIOXCeHHH, 3anpenaioL0uHx )erfCTBHU opraHa rocyaapcTBeHHOriBnaCTU no orpaHH'ieHHIO ocTyra K JIeCOnOb3OBaHHIO, al4CKpHMHHaUH llpOTHB HeKOTOpbIXneconOnb3OBaTeneA Hnu OTKa3y npeaoCTaBHTb apeHay no6eR14TernAM .eCHOrO KOHKypca HAHayKuliOHa. 9To no-npe)KHeMy OCTaBJI5ieT HeOnpe,eJIeHHOCTb B OTHOUweHHH BO3MO)KHOrOrocy,aapcTBeHHoro BMewlaTeCJbCTBa H d)aBOp4TH3Ma B AeCO3arOTOBHTeCbHOrinpOMbIwIIJIeHHOCTH, qTO TeM 6o0iee Ba)KHO nocnie HeaaBHHX HeOaHOKpaTHbIX H3MeHeHHricTaTyca rocyaapcTBeHHoro KOMHTeTa no JIeCHOA, aepeBoo6pa6aTb1BaloLueR U ueH lJoJIO3HO-6yMaKHori npOMbIwHJeHHOCTH H oMepeLHoH peopraHuH3aLuHH JeCHOHi ripoMblwJIeHHOCTH.

Bop'pocm 4JHHaHCHpOBaHHjJ ffecHoro Xo3fJIlCTBa

npoeKT JlecHoro KoaeKca TaKKe riepecMaTpHBaeT nOPS,OK c6opa niiaTe)Ke A 3anOJlb3OBaHHe AeCHbIM 4bOHAOM. fpoueaypa paCnpeeJlieHHH CpeaCTB, llpeaHa3Ha eHHbIX AsBocnpoH3BO,aCTBa, OXpaHbl H 3alulTbI nIeCOB, npeayCMOTpeHHbie B "OCHOBax, 6yLeTOTMeHeHa. JAeCHbEie ioLaTH, co6HpaeMble 3a KpaTKOCPO4Hoe HoJIb3OBaHHe y'aCTKaMHAecHoro 4(OHaa, pacnpocTpaHIOTCAS Ha Bce BH1bl JIecoClOAb3OBaHHA. CTaBKH noaaTeg 3aHOAb3OBaHHe JieCHbIMH pecypcaMH 6yayT YCTaHaBnHHBaTbCS perHoHajibHbIMH, a He MeCTHbIMHopraHamH Bj1aCTH Ho corJiacoBaHHIO C COOTBeTCTBYIOLUHMH TeppHTOPHanJbHbIMH opraHamHynpaBJIeHHA nIeCHbIM X03AACTBOM HAM no pe3ynJbTaTaM AeCHorO KOHKypca (ayKUHoHa).

B JIeCHOM KoaeKce npeLnaraeTCA BHeCTH KPynHbie H3MeHeHH5 B MexaHH3M,peryjiHpyioiuHrM nOTOKH 4bHHaHCOBblx cpeacTB HanpaBnA5eMbIX B ieCHOri ceKTop (CM. pHC. 1.6H 1.7 B OCHOBHOM aoinage). B COOTBeTCTBUH C OCHoBaMH, nHAaTexcKM aOJDKHb[ 6buninocTynaTb B paUiOHHbie (ropoRCcK4e) 6ioaxeTbl, H no ycMoTpeHHIO opraHOB MeCTHOrOcaMoynpasBAeHHA qaCTb rocTynnieHJi MorAa HanpaBJI5ITbCA Ha oxpaHy H 3a11.LHTy nlecoB.npoeic KoaeKca C03,aaeT COBepwUeHHO HObmbl mXeaHH3M v JHHaHCHpOBaHJ paCXO,OB,CBH3aHHbIX C yrpaBCeHHeM H BeaeHHeM AeCHOrO XO3AricTBa, KOTOpblUi, KaK noniaraeTc)e,aepanbHaA cnyxK6a AeCHoro xO3ir4CTBa, 6yaeT HPHHLtHHnHaAbHo 6ojiee yCTOiNHBbIM.CTaBK4 neCHbix roaaTeA 3a nOn b3OBaHHe JIecoM onpeaenjCIOTCq HO Ka)(oMy apeHayeCMoMyyqaCTKY AeCHoro bOHaa H no Ka)KLoMy BHULy CeconOJTb3OBaH1S1 Ha neCHbIX KOHKypcax(ayKuHOHax). 3TH CTaBKH AO,lKHbi 6blTb He MeHbwe MHHHMmanbHbIX CTaBOK nnaTbl 3a,fpeBecHHy, OTnyCKaeMylo Ha KOpHIO, KOTOpbIe YCTaHaBJIHBalOTCS 4PeaepaJIbHbIMnpaBHTeAbCTBOM.

COPOK npOLJeHTOB OT o6fbeMa MHHHMiJmbHbIX CTaBOK H,aeT HeriOCpeaCTBeHHO Bbe4epanbHbIi4 6ioxCeT, a weCTbaeCSIT HpOpoeHTOB - B perHOHaAbHblr4 610AXeT, OTKy,4a 3TUcpeAcTBa BbIaenSIAOTCS Ha BOCnpOH3BOnCTBO Aeca. YKa3aHHaas 4opMyAa ipHMHeHqeTcq iUilb KAeCOH36blTO4HbIM perHOHaM, B KOTOpbIX pacqeTHas iiecoceKa no py6KaM rnaBHoronOAb3OBaHxR npeBb[lwaeT I MHAAHOH Ky6oMeTpoB. Bce LapyrHe perHOHbl noyMlaT100 npOLteHTOB o6beMa MHHHMajTbHbIX CTaBOK rHaTbl 3a apeBeCHHy, OTnycKaeMYIO HaKOPHIO. OAHaKO MeCTHbie 610oaKeTbI He HoAY'yIaT aoXoaa 3a Hojib3oBaHue AecaMH,pacnoAo)KeHHbIMH Ha HX TeppHTOpHAx. HnaTeKH 3a 1o7lb3oBaHHCe JecoM Hif qpeHaHauq 7JaTa,I70fIyveHHbIe cBepx Pa3MePOB MHHHM&JIbHbMX CTRBOK 17ARTI 3a apeBecHHy, OTn7yCKaeMyIo Ha

Page 218: Russian - World Bank Documents

214 nPHAO)KEHHE B

KOpH0O, yCTaHOB&7eHHbIX oeaepafIbHbJM flpaBHTe,7bCTBOM, !OCTYj7alOT UpqMO A'eCX03aM,

OCBO60W4aJOTCuI OT Ha./OFa, llpHZpBHHBafJCb K 6boiveTHbIM CpeaCTBaM, H HCQimm3yiOTChI

htCk]IJOlfTe]THO oL/7fl HyK BCeeHHq .IeCHOFO XO3JICTBa (CTaTbS 106). TaKou nOPAl OK

pacnpexieneeHHA peCypCOB nPH3HaeT npaBO co6CTBeHHHKa nieca Ha noflMyeHiie xoxoAa OT

Hcnojib3oBaHHA nPHHaIne)KaWUHx eMy JIeCHbIX pecypcoB.

npenycMaTpHBaeTcAl TaK)Ke H3MeHeHHe nopSiaKa nOKpblTlT pacxoaOB Ha ynpasIeHu4e

H BseeHHe JieCHOrO X03.qfiCTBa. KaK o)KHxaeTcA, paCXOabl, CB5I3aHHbIe C AeAITeAbHOCTbIO

rOCY1aPCTBeHHbIX OpraHOB yripaBjieHH1 JieCHbIM X03flUCTBOM (3a ucKJIIOHeHHeM pacXoaOB Ha

BOCnPOH3BOACTBO iieca), aOJDKHbl (1HHaHCHPOBaTbCAI 13 4eaepaAbHoro 61o1AXeTa, B TO BpeMS1

KaK PaCXoXbI Ha BOCnPOH3BOACTBO neca, AOJDKHbl 4IHHaHCHPOBaTbcS1 H3 perHOHajibHbIX

6ioaxeTOB. TaKOu¶ xapaKTep dJHHaHCHPOBaHHl4 co3JaaeT HOBble 3KOHOMHteCKHe H

4HHaHCOBble OTHOlueHHA MeuKay 4egepaAbHblM npaBHTenjbCTBOM H opraHaMH BJ1aCTH

cy6'beKTOB cDeaepauHH, opraHaMH ynpaBjieHHA IeCHbIM X03flUCTBOM H iecoroJIb3OBaTeAqlMH.

npeAnaraeMaAl HOBal CHCTeMa nJIaTe)KeH 3a flOJ1b3OBaHHe jieCHblM 4)OHE4OM H

4.HHaHCHPOBaHHA iiecHoro XO3ligCTBa o6ecneCHBaeT JyMmUHR 6anaHc HHTepeCOB

4e,aepanbHbIX H perHOHaJIbHbIX opraHoB ynpaBneHHAI B ccfepe oxpaHbI, HCnOJ1b3OBaHHR9 H

BOCrpOH3BOACTBa JIeCHbIX peCypCOB. Pacxoabl Ha BeaeHHe JieCHoro X03SIHCTBa, KOTOpble

nOKpbIBaZjiCb HCKJIOqHTeSJbHO 4beaepambHblM 6loaeTOM, Tenepb 6yRyT pacnpeaenIATbcs

Me)(y 4egepajIbHbIM H perUOHanbHb1MH 6ioAxeTaMH; 4eaepaJbHbie H perHoHaHJbHb1e

610oxeTbi pa3.eJIlT TaioKe aOXOabl OT nnIaTe)Ker4 3a HCnOAb3OBaHHe JlecOB (KaK yKa3aHO

BblIlwe).

Bonpocm 9KoJIOIwfcCKOA 6e3ounCHOCTH H yvacTm o611recmeHHOcm

B OTJInH4e OT "OCHOB" 1993 roaa, npoeKT JecHoro KoaeKca pe3KO coKpawaeT

BJAH1HHe ynoAHoMoMeHHbIX opraHo Bno oxpaHe oKpyKaioLieg cpeabi Ha npoixecc npHHHTHq1

peuieHHri, KacaIoluHXCAl BeaeHHI .IeCHoro xO3AflCTBa. Bce Bonpocbl, CBl3aHHbie C

HcnoJb3OBaHmeM, oxpaHoPI, 3alLUHTo4 H BOCnpOH3BORCTBOM jieCOB, noanie)KaT peiyhHnpoBaHHIo

HcK,ITOYITeCJbHo jecCHbM 3aKOHoaiIaTefbCTBOM (CTaTbA 5). 3KOiorwiecKoe 3aKOHOAaTejbCTBO

YnOMHHaeTCA JIHLUb B KoHTeKCTe oco6o oxpaHfleMblx nplpORHbIX TeppHTOpHII -

3anOBeAHHKOB, HaLIHOHaJbHb1x napKOB H npHHOAHbIX napKOB (CTaTbH 125-127). B KoaeKce

HeT npSMO14 CCbLTIKH Ha POJb q)eepaflbHoro 3aKoHa "06 3KOJ1oruHecKori 3KcnepTH3e", XOTS

cama roCyXapCTBeHHaA 3KOJIOFHqCCKRf 3KCI77CTH3a YlOMUHaeTC51 B HeCKOJbKHX CTaTb51X

Kox,eKca.

npoeKT JlecHoro KO,aeKca rpeaycmaTpHBaeT npOBeXA,eHie rocyaapCTBeHHOri

3KoIorHmeCKOui 3KcnepTH3bI B MeCTax CTPOHTenJbCTBa o6beKTOB, BJI1H4qOjUHX Ha COCTOAHHe H

BOCnpOH3BOACTBO ineCOB (CTaTbs 65). IPeaepaJ1bHblr4 3aKOH "06 3Koj1orH4ecKori 3KcnepTH3e"

nepe'qcHisieT cdepbi npHMeHeHHA1 rOCyaapCTBeHHOR 3KoJIorHqecKori 3KcnepTH3bI, KOTOpb1e

3aTparHBalOT nieca, BKJio'aA 3eMjie- H jieconOOb3OBaHHe (B TOM 4IHcjie H npoeKTbI

OpraHH3avUH H pa3BHTHfl necHoro X03AliCTBa); MaTepHaJbi, noaTBepxKaloLuHe

Heo6XOLHMOCTb nepeBoaa nleCHbIX 3eMeJlb B HenJeCHble 3eMAH; coriiaweHHlq o pa3,Aene

nPODYKUHH H KOHueCCHA1X, KOTOpbIe npeAyCMaTpHBalOT HcnoJib3OBaHme npHpOAHbIX

peCypCOB. HeCMOTpA1 Ha pa3JiUMUH5 MexLy 3THMU 3aKOHOaaTejIbHbIMH aKTaMH, OHU

CBHAeTejibCTByIOT o 6oJIbuoM uucne o6JiacTe , KOTOpble no=ne)KaT o6s13aTenbHori

rOCyfapCTBeHHOi1 3KojiorHqecKor 3KcnepTH3e Ha 4)eaepaajbHOM ui perHOHaJbHOM ypOBHAlX.

Page 219: Russian - World Bank Documents

215 rIPH1O)KEEHHE B

HpaBa, npeaocTaBjiseMbie rpa)UaHaM U o6 LuecTBeHHbIM opraHH3auI4HM B CBS3H CHMeioiitegcR y HHX 03a60meHHOCTbIO o6 oKpyKa1oLueg cpeae, npeaycMaTp4BaloT KOHKpeTHbleuwaru AAS npeLoTBpaueHHA HeraTHBHOrO Bo3Xaer4CTBHR 3KOHOMH4ecKOI H apyrori

IeSATeJIbHOCTH Ha neca.

rlpoeKT JlecHoro KoTeKca BBOaHT o6Sl3aTejibHyIO CCpTNH/I)KaLYro apeBeCHHbi,OTnyCKaeMOU Ha KOpHIO, H BTOpOCTenIeHHbIX JIeCHbIX peCypCOB. OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3anpoBeneHHe cepTHd)HKauH BO3jio)KCeHa Ha (cteaepajibHyIO cnyx6y niecHoro XO3Sri"CTBa.nopqSLOK cepTH4HKauHH noIwexcHT onpeaeAeH HIO eaepaAbHbIM ITpaBHTeJTbCTBOM.

HH4OpMBWmi O 0ieCHOM 4)OHae, BKJ1io4aH aaHHbie O rocyaapCTBeHHOM yqeTe necHoro40OH,aa, JIeCHOM KaaaCTpe, JTeCOyCTpOiCTBe, MOHHTOpHHre JleCOB H HHbie aaHHbie,nojyyMeHHbie 3a cMeT 4eaepaAbHbIX cpeaCTB, o6&bABJIAIOTCS 4eaepaAbHoA co 6 CTBeHHOCTb[O(CTaTbA 75). nOPAaOK o6ecre'-eHHA aocTyna K 3TOU HH43OpMaUHH rpaxiaH H IOPHLIHMeCKHXJnHU 6yaeT onpeaejieH 4 eaepaAbHbIM npaBHTejibcTBoM.

CoxpaHAeTCA p5A HeqCHbIX MOMeHTOB B OTHOweHHH ffCCO.VOJIWBaHHff, B VaCTHOCTI,Ha oco60 oxpaHfeMi qpHpq,4Hhm TeppHTopNIx. flpoeKT JecHoro KoaeKca BBOaHT nOPAaOKH3bS1THI JeCHbIX 3eMeJlb, KOTOpblU4 ciieayeT nop5UaKy nepeBoaa J1eCHbIX 3eMenJb B HefleCHble3eMflH AAS HCHonJb3oBaHH5l HX B ueJIlx, He CB53aHHbIX C BeaeHHeM necHoro XO3qruiCTBa.npaBo oT4yxK eHHA 4ieaepanbHbIx iieCHbIX 3eMenlb npeaocTaBJTAeTcq 4eaepaIbHoMynpaBHTeJIbCTBy (neca rTepBOi rpynrlbl) H perHoHaJbHbIM opraHam (neca BTOpOU H TpeTbeUrpynnbl), OaHaKo 3TH ripoueaypbi npOTHBOpe4aT 3aKOHaM, npeaoCTaBJlAi,oWHM CO6 CTBeHHHKynpaBa no pacnopsxceHHIo 3eMj1eri (BKIloqa3 OTqyxIaeHHe 3eMenjbHblx y4acTKoB), HnpHpOIaooxpaHHOMy 3aKoHoAaTeJIbCTBy, KoTopoe 3anpeLuaeT 3TbATHe 3eMenJb H3 npHpOLHbIX3anOBe,aHHKOB, 3aKa3HHKOB H HaLiHOHaJbHbIX napKOB. TaKHM o6pa3oM, npoeKT JIecHoroKo01eKca SlBJieTCA 6onee nH6epanbHbIM, He)KsenH HbIHe aerCTBylOiuHe JiecHoe, 3eMeflbHoe H3KoJIorHqecKoe 3aKOHoAaTeJIbCTBa.

npoeKT KoaeKca OCTaBjS1eT HepeweHHbIM Bonpoc o rocyaapCTBeHHoM KOHTpone 3aOXpaHOUi, HcnoJIb3OBaHHeM H BOCnpOH3BOICTBOM nieCOB Ha TeppHTOpHH JneCX030B HHaUHOHaJIbHbIX napKOB, He BXOALWUHX B CHCTeMy $DeaepaJIbHori cnyx6bI niecHoro xo3shicTBa.CyLUeCTBeHHaA qaCTb oxpaHAeMbIx TeppHTOpHfl BblBJIeHa B npeaenax JeCHbIX 3eMeJIb HnoAnaaaeT nOA !OpHCAHKUHio KaK JiecHoro KoeKca, TaK H 4)eaepajibHoro 3aKOHa "06 oco6oOXpaHAeMbIX npHpOAHbIX TeppHTOpHAX, KOTOpbIe coaepxaT pa3JIHHbIe HOpMbI H npaBUJla.

B3aHMOCBS3b C o2KHJaeMbIMH H3MeHeHHAMM B ApyrHx c4)epax 3aKOHoAaTejibcTBa

npe=]araeMbIri JeCHOA KoaeKC COaepxKT pSA BaXHbIX noJioKeHHH-, pa3pewaLoiuHx HperyjiHpyioLuix MHoroo6pa3Hbie BHablI AeconoJIb3oBaHHR B repHori nepexona K PblHOKHOR3KOHOMHKe. HOBaA cTpyKTypa ynpaBJeHIlH nieCHbIM X035UCTBOM TaKwe npeaycMaTpHBaeT60Iblwyio rH6KOCTb B pacnpeaejieHHH OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH Meefly 4beAepaiIbHbIM HperHoHaIbHoM YPOBHeM opraHoB BIacT4. OaHaKO Bce TaKHe noAo)KeHHA HOCST, CKopee,peKoMeH,aaTenbHbIl, HeKeJiH o6a3aTeAbHbTir xapaKTep, OCTaBJSl51 3Ha4HTeAbHyIO CBo6oAy AAsnlpo,OJxceHHA 4)yHKUHOHHpOBaH H CyLLeCTByIOiuerU B ripOWJIOM He3q1eKTHBHOri CHCTeMbI.06cyxcnaeMblI KOaeKC He COBCeM CTblKyeTCA C UeJTbIM PRAOM 4eaepaj1bHbIx 3aKOHOB o6oxpaHe OKpyxcaioLuerU Cpeabi. MHorHx 3THX HeaOCTaTKOB MO)KHO 6bulo 6bl H36eXaTb, ecnu6bl Ha nOarfoToBHTeJIbHoA CTaim 6buo o6ecneqeHo 6o0nee aKTHBHoe yMaCTHe

Page 220: Russian - World Bank Documents

216 nPMAOKEHME B

o6WecTBeHHocTH, a camo o6cyxeHHe npoeKTa HOCHJio 6onee OTKpblTblH xapaKTep. TeM He

MeHee HeT HHKaKHx npaBOBblx npen3TCTB1Hi AnA BHeceHHH B JAeCHOA KoaeKc nonpaBoK

nocne Toro, KaK 3TOT KOXaeKC y;Ke npHHAT.

npe,acToAuuee npHHHTHe HOBOro 3eMenbHoro KoaeKca POCCHUCKOU (DeaepaLu4H H

BcTynnieHHe B CHJY rJIaBbI 17 FpaxnaHcKoro KoJeKca o npaBe co6CTBeHHOCTH H apyrHx

BelIIHbIX npaBax Ha 3eMjlO He436e)KHo nOTpe6yeT BHeceHHi4 ronpaBOK H B necHoe

3aKOHo,aaTejibCTBO. 1I3MeHeHH5I TaloKe noTpe6ylOTCs B CB9R34 C BBegeHmeM HHCTHTyTa

MYHHU4HnaTibHOri H U aCTHOA Co6CTBeHHOCTH Ha 3eMjiio, pa3XejieHHeM rocyaapCTBeHHOeo

3eMeflbHOU Co6CTBeHHOCTH Ha 4beaepajibHy1O H perHoHaJlbHyIo, pacnpocTpaHeHHeM npaBa

co6CTBeHHOCTH Ha 3eMenJbHbli yxMaCTOK TaK)KCe H Ha HaxoRJiuHec5 B rpaHHUaX 3Toro y'aCTKa

nec H paCTeHHq (FpaxcIaHCKHri KoaeKc, CTaTbS 261). Pa3Jn4'IHbie BH21bl co6CTBeHHOCTH Ha

nec TaioKe noTpe6yWoT IIPHA1TH5I HOBbIX HOPM H4 npasBuJI AqS perynCiJpOBaHHq nieCHbIX

OTHOluleHHfl Ha OCHOBe KOHKpeTHbIX xapaKTepUCTHK Ka)Kforo BH1a npaBa Co6CTBeHHOCTH.

1I3MeHeHHSI B CHCTeMe ynpanBAeHHR U BeaeHHI4 niecHoro X03,qriCTBa AOJDKHbI 6blTb

TeCHO CB5I3aHbl C pa3BHTHeM PbIHO4HOU 3KOHOMHKH nyTeM ynopSao'eHHS 3KOHOMH4eCKHX H

4HHaHCOBbIX OTHOUweHHri Mex)ay BjiaaenJbuaMl JecaMH H ero HOJIb3OBaTejSIMH. TaK)Ke 6yzeT

HeO6XO.UHMO BHeCTH H3MeHeHHR B CHCTeMy nnaTeKeH 3a OJ1b3OBaHHe necoM H

qMHHaHCHPOBaHHe yCHJIHu nO BeaeHH10 necHoro XO3$rlcTBa.

BO3MO)KHO TaKwKe noHaao6HTcS BHeCeHHe H3MeHeHUUi B necHoe 3aKoHoaaTenbcTBo

,AAA HpHBe,fleHHs ero B COOTBeTCTBHe C pe3ynbTaTamH CyUIeCTBeHHOHi peopraHH3auHH

CTpYKTYPbI H 4byHKUHi deaepaAbHoro npaBHTenbCTBa, npeayCMOTpeHHbIX yKa3aMH

npe3H,lleHTa N° 1176 H 1177 OT 14 aBrycTa 1996 roRa. B 3THX yKa3ax noaD-epK4BaeTcAs HOBoe

pacnpe,e4eneH4e nOjiHTHMeCKHX, peryjiHpy1oLJHx H aaMHHHCTPaTHBHbIX 4YHKUHR Me)Ky

pa3iiH4qHbIMH d eXaepaAbHbIMH ucnOJIHHTenJbHbIMH opraHaMH (MHH HiCTepCTBaMU,

rOCyaapCTBeHHbIMH KOMHTeTaMH H d)eaepaj1bHbIMK cnyXK6aMH). FIpoBoaAlueec5i HbiHe

yTOqHeHHe OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH yqpexaeHKA, OTBeValOWUHX 3a oxpaHy OKpy)KaioUIeH CpeAbI

(HOBblUi rocy,apCTBeHHbli KOMHTeT no oxpaHe oKpyxaioiueg cpeabi) H CfcnOJIb3OBaHHe

npHPOPHbIX peCYPCOB (HOBoe MHHHCTePCTBO rPHPOAHbIX peCYPCOB H FocyaapCTBeHHblri

KOMHTeT no neCHOfl, aepeBoo6pa6aTbIBaiouLeH U ejTlono3Ho-6yMa)KHoA npoMbILwneHHHocTH)

MO)KeT TaioKe noTpe6oBaTb HeKOTOpOro yTOMHeHHS necHoro 3aKOHoaaTenbCTBa.

Page 221: Russian - World Bank Documents

217 nPHIIOKEHHE B

)IOJIOJ1HEHHE I

JIECHOUi KOaEKC POCCHICKOR (DEEPAUIHH(FpHHHT rocyxaapcTBeHHoA ayMog 22 A HBapq 1997 rora)

CoAqepxaHue

OBIUI MACTb

PA3,AE 1: OIIHE nOJIO)IEHHA

[iiaBa 1. OCHOBHblie nooJKoeHH

CTaTbS 1. JIecHoe 3aKOHoaaTejibCTBO POCCHUCKOU (DeAepauirCTaTbH 2. 3aRaaH H Uuenju iecHoro 3aKOHoaaTejibCTBa POCCHUCKOU

(DeAepaLuKH

CTaTbH 3. JleCHoe 3aKOHOaaTeJIbCTBO POCCHUCKOUi cIeAepaUHH 14 HOPMbIMemKgyHapo1aHoro npaBa

CTaTbH 4. Ae1CTBHe niecHoro 3aKOHoaaTenJbCTBa POCCHICKOU (DeAepauHtiBO BpeMeHH

CTaTbm 5. OTHOweHHq, peryjiHpyeMbIe JieCHbIM 3aKOHoaaTejibCTBOMPOCCHUCKOU ($e,AepaIuuH

rnaBa 2. 06beKTbi neciEHLx oTHomeHuHM

CTaTbS1 6. 06IbeKTbI JeCHbIX OTHOweHHriCTaTbI 7. AeCHOA 4OHACTaTbi 8. 3eMjii necHoro )oHiaCTaTbA 9. YLaCTKH necHoro d)oHaaCTaTbm 10. Jieca, He BXOSILUHe B jieCHOi 4)OHACTaTb5l 11. ,LpeBeCHo-KyCTapHHKOBa5 paCTHTeJIbHOCTbCTaTb5i 12. O6opoTocnoco6HocTb o6'beKToB JIeCHbIX OTHOwIeHHU

riaBa 3. Cy6becrbl inecHbx OTHOwieHHr

CTaTbq 13. YqaCTHHKH JieCHbIX OTHOWeHH1CTaTbq 14. POCCHACKaq )De1aepaLHAl U cy6'beKTbl POCCHUCKOU (I)eaepaLtHH -

yqaCTHHKH JIeCHbIX OTHOwleHHUCTaTbH 15. MyHHuHrlnahbHbre o6pa3oBaHHA - y1 aCTHHKH neCHbIX

OTHOleHHr4CTaTbI 16. rpa)AaaHe H IOpJ4A1H4eCKHe JIHua - yMaCTHHKH JieCHbIX

OTHOwCeHHrCTaTbsi 17. JIecononb3OBaTeJIH

Page 222: Russian - World Bank Documents

218 PHA1O)KEHHE B

PA3,EA 11. HPABA COBCTBEHHOCTH HA JIECHOR (DOHA H HA JIECA, HEBXO,$UAHE B JIECHOR cDOHJA, H JAPYr[E nPABA nO1b3OBAHHSI

HX YMACTKAMH

rFnaBa 4. OCHOBHEle nOjiOxeHH5

CTaTbH 18. CoaepIcaHHe npaBa CO6CTBeHHOCTH Ha JieCHOH1 4bOHa H npaBa

co6CTBeHHOCTH Ha nieca, He BXOnlLHe B aeCHOk q30HA

CTaTbH 19. cDOpMbI CO6CTBeHHOCTH Ha JieCHOU 4)OHA H Ha He BXOISALHe B

neCHOU 4OHa nieca

CTaTbH 20. npaBO CO6CTBeHHOCTH rpaxIaH H iOpHaHMeCKHX JIHU Ha

,peBecHo-KycTapHHKoByIo pacTHTenbHocTb, pacnojioKceHHYIO Ha

3eMeflbHOM yMaCTKe

CTaTbH 21. AeCHbie CePBHTYTbl

CTaTbM 22. nlpaBa nOJIb3OBaHHH y'aCTKaMH neCHOrO 41OHXaa H npaBa

nOJnb3OBaHHA YMaCTKaMH IieCOB, He BXO,ALIHX B JJeCHOH bOH24

rnaBa 5. BO3HHKHOBeHHe, ocyi4ecTBj1eHHe, orpaHHMeHHe, npHocTaHOBjieHHe,

HpeKpaweHHe H 3aUAHTa npaB nOJIb3OBaHH5 yqaCTKaMH AeCHoro 4oHAz,a

U fIpaB IlOJIb3OBaHHS yqaCTKaMH IieCOB, He BXO1I5UHX B AeCHOM ()OHA

CTaTbA 23. OCHOBaHHS BO3HHKHOBeHH5{ ripaB nOJIb3OBaHHS yqaCTKaMHnieCHOrO 4OHia H ripaB nOJIb3OBaHH51 y4aCTKaMH AeCOB, He

BXO,4SIU.HX B JIeCHOIi bOHA

CTaTbA 24. nOPH,nOK BO3HHKHOBeHH5r npaB nOIlb3OBaHH4 Y4laCTKaMH

nieCHoro 4JOHaa H nPaB nOJIb3OBaHHA yqaCTKaMH JneCOB, He

BXOLI5IUMHX B jieCHOH 4)OHA

CTaTbAI 25. OcyweCTBjieHHe ripaB nOJIb3OBaHHS yqaCTKaMH SieCHoro bOH,aH nPaB HOJ1b3OBaHHA y'aCTKaMH .ieCOB, He BXO,4S51LHX B JieCHOH

(bOHA

CTaTbR 26. OrpaHHmeHHe H npHOCTaHOBjieHHe npaB nOnJb3OBaHHA

YLaCTKaMH AeCHOrO 43OHaa H nPaB nOJnb30BaHHH yMaCTKaMH

IiecOB, He BXOALSUHX B JieCHOH 4bOHJ

CTaTbR 27. HIOPHIOK orpaHH4eHHH H npHOCTaHOBjieHHS npaB nOJIb3OBaHHA

yqaCTKaMH necHoro 4)OH,a H npaB nOFOb3OBaHH5 y-4aCTKaMH

nIeCOB, He BXOL5HLUHX B jieCHOIi 4bOHa

CTaTb$ 28. OCHOBaHHA npeKpaLeHH5i npaB nOJ1b3OBaHH45 yMaCTKaMH

necHoro 4OHaa H npaB nOJ1b3OBaHH4l yqaCTKaMH IieCOB, He

BXO,5LIUHX B .ieCHOR qOH21

CTaTb.q 29. nOpqLaOK npeKpaiueHHs rpaB nOJIb3OBaHH5 yMaCTKaMH AeCHOrO

bOHAxa H npaB nOJIb3OBaHHI4 y'aCTKaMH nieCOB, He BXOqL5UHX B

iieCHOii bOHR

CTaTbA 30. Cyhae6Ha5 3alUHTa npaB nOOJb3OBaHHM5 y'aCTKaMH neCHOrO

4OH,aa H npaB nojib3OBaHHS1 yqaCTKaMH nieCOB, He BXO,4LLSIHX B

JieCHOA 4OHA

Page 223: Russian - World Bank Documents

219 HPHJ1OKEHHE B

rnaBa 6. ApeHAa y4acTKa neCHoro 4oHAa, 6e3BO3Mee3Hoe nojib3BaHHe,KOH1AeCCHA H KPaTKOCPOMHOe nOJIb3OBaHHe yacTKaMH JieCHOrO 4OH[Ra

CTaTbR 31. aOrOBOp apeHAbl yMaCTKa neCHoro 4oOHzaCTaTbR 32. qDOpMa H rocyaapCTBeHHaR perHcTpaUUit AoroBopa apeHAbi

yqacTKa jiecHoro 4boHaaCTaTbS 33. YCJIOBHS AorOBOpa apeHAbl y4aCTKa neCHoro 4bOH2aCTaTbM 34. HrpOpqOK npeaOCTaBJIeHHS YMaCTKOB necHoro 4OHaa B apeHayCTaTbH 35. HOpsaOK npOBeReHHq nIeCHbIX KOHKYPCOBCTaTbR 36. aorOBop 6e3BO3Me3aHoro nOflb30BaHHUq yMaCTKOM neCHOrO

(PoH,aaCTaTbH 37. aoroBOP KOHueCCHH yqaCTKa .feCHoro boHXaCTaTb3i 38. CTOPOHb aorOBOpa KOHUeCCHH yMaCTKa .ieCHoro 4OHLaCTaTbS 39. qPOpMa H roCyaapCTBeHHaA perUcTpaUiU aoroBopa KOHUeCCHI

yqacTKa JiecHoro JOH,aaCTaTbS 40. YCJIOBHS AOrOBopa KOHleCCHH Y9aCTKa .ieCHoro (DOHAaCTaTb.q 41. nOPqaOK 3aKjilOMeHHS aorOBOpa KOHUeCCHH YMaCTKa neCHOrO

4FoH,aCTaTbM 42. Jlecopy6o4Hblfl 6HTeT, opaep H fleCHOR 6HjieTCTaTbS 43. flOp5IROK ripeaOCTaBjieH4I "MaCTKOB neCHoro 40OHAa B

KpaTKOCpO4Hoe noHJb3OBaHHeCTaTb5I 44. HOPslOK HPOBeAeHHH neCHbIX aYKUHOHOBCTaTbh 45. [IPOTOKOJI ieCHoro aYKUUHOHa

Pa3Aen II1. rOCY,aAPCTBEHHOE YrPABJIEHHE B OEIACTHHCHIOJb3OBAHHAM, OXPAHbl, 3A1U1Tbi JAECHOrO DOHJJA HBOCnPOH3BOJACTBA AECOB

riiaBa 7. OCHOBE rOCyAapCTBeHHOrO ynpaBneiHsA B o6nacTH HCrOJI&3oBaHHA,oxpaHbl, 3aiLtHTbi JiecHoro f)oHAa H BOCHpOH3BOACTBa neCOB

CTaTbSI 46. HOAHOMOHSH POCCHUCKOU 'DeaepaUKH B o6.nacTHHCnoJb3oBaHHA, oXpaHbl, 3aLUHTbl nieCHoro 43oHaa HBOCnPOH3BOACTBa nIecOB

CTaTbA 47. HOJIHOMOMHA cy6beKTOB PoccHUcKoUi qPeaepauHH B o6AaCTHHcnoJIb3oBaHKA, oXpaHbI, 3aIUHTbl AecHoro 4)OHAa HBOCnpOH3BOACTBa nIecoB

CTaTbA 48. Pa3rpaHH4qeHHe nOnJHOMO4HUi Mme)KAY opraHaMHroCy,aapCTBeHHOrl BnJaCTU POCCUUCKOK 'DeAepauHH H OPraHaMHroCy,aapCTBeHHOr4 BiSaCTH Cy6beKToB POCCUHiCKOU ($eaepautm Bo6.nacTH HCnoJb3oBaHHH, oXpaHbI, 3aWlUTbI iiecHoro 4)oHAa uBOCrPOH3BO,aCTBa AeCoB

CTaTbS 49. HlOAHOMOq-HS OpraHOB MeCTHOrO camoynpaEneHuR B o6nacTHHcnoJIb3oBaHH4, oXpaHbl, 3allUHTbi iecHoro 4)OHAa HBOCHpOH3BOACTBa necoB

CTaTbA 50. OCHOBHbie npHHLtHnbi rOCy,aapCTBeHHOro yrpaBJleHHA Bo6.nacT Hcrojib3oBaHHA, oXpaHbl, 3alUHTbI .)ecHoro 4bOHAa HBOCnpOH3BOACTBa AecoB

Page 224: Russian - World Bank Documents

220 -HPHJIOKEHHE B

rnaBa 8. CUcTeMa OpraHOB HCnOnHHTenbHOUH BJiaCTH, OCYUeCTBSIOLU[X

rocyARapcTBeHHOe YnPaBJIeHHe B o6AaCTU HCnOnb3oBaHHU, oxpaHbl,

3allHTbi iieCHOrO 4boHAla H BOCnpOH3BOACTBa Aneco

CTaTbS 51. OeAepanbHbie opraHbI HcnoAHHTeCbHO BsnaCTu,

ocyuIecTBASHowL e FOCYaapCTBeHHoe ynpasneHie B o6JaCTH

HCHOJb3oBaHI, OXpaHbl, 3aLUHTbI AecHoro c1oHaa 14

BOCnPO43BOaCTBa AecoB

CTaTbM 52. OpraHbl HCHTOJIHHTeJlbHOUi BJaCT14 cy6'beKTOB POCCHUCKOU

(De,aepauim B o6AacTm 14CnoIb3OBaHH$, oxpaHbI, 3aLIlHTbi

JIeCHOrO 4)oH1a H BOCnpOH3BOaCTBa nTeCOB

CTaTbR 53. (DeaepajIbHblA opraH ynpaBjieHlH5 JieCHbIM X03.r4CTBOM

rjiaBa 9. OCHOBbl OpraHH3aLUHH neCHoro XO3SAHCTBa

CTaTbM 54. OcHoBHbie Tpe6oBaHq, npeAlbqBnAMeMbie K Be,AeHmIO leCHoro

X03SICTBaCTaTb2 55. Fpynnbi JieCOB u KaTerOpHu 3aLIUHTHOCT4 nYeCOB nepBOu rpynnbi

CTaTb5I 56. Jleca nepBOU rpynnblCTaTb2 57. Jleca BTOpOUi rpynnbI

CTaTbhq 58. Jleca TpeTbeU rpynnbl

CTaTbH 59. Onpeae.neHHe rpaHuU 3eMeJTb, 3aHqTbIX JiecaMH Ka)KAori rpynfbinIeCOB u Ka)KAor4 KaTerOpIH 3aLlUHTHOCTH necoB nepBou rpynnbi

CTaTb3i 60. nloPARoK OTHeCeHHA nieCOB K rpynnaM nieCOB U KaTerOPHASM

3a1UHTHOCTH nIeCOB nepBOu rpynnib

CTaTb5 61. nOPAlOK YCTaHOBAeHHU1 BO3paCTa py6OK

CTaTbS 62. PacMeTHaq niecoceKa H nOpI,OK ee YTBep)KeHH5

CTaTbhq 63. FopqaoK nepeBoaa J1eCHbIX 3eMeJIb B HenieCHbie 3eMj1H JIAS

HCHOJIb3OBaHH5 UX B LJeJIlx, He CBA3aHHb[X C BeaeHReM niecHoro

xo3SlICTBa, nOJIb3OBaHHeM JIeCHbIM 4bOH,OM, u(HJunu) nOpAAOK

H3bAiTHA 3eMeCJb niecHoro 4oHaa

CTaTbm 64. fopqAoK nepeBo,aa JIeCHbIX 3eMenJb B HeCJeCHbIe 3eMjiI anS

HcnOJIb3OBaHH5I HX B LIeCjix, CBI3aHHbIX C BeAeHHeM nieCHoro

XO3AHCTBa H UnoJTb3oBaHi4eM iieCHbIM d3OHLROM

CTaTbm 65. FIOPAaOK COriiaCOBaHHq MeCT CTPOHTeITbCTBa o6'beKTOB,

BJIHAIUOWUX Ha COCTOAHHe 14 BOCHPOH3BOaCTBO .necoB

CTaTbRq 66. FOpIOsoK npoBeaeHHs B JieCHOM 4OH1ae pa6oT, He CBA3aHHbIX C

BeADeHHeM AecHoro X03,qriCTBa U ocyLeCTBneHuem

JieconOJIb3OBaHH5

CTaTbSq 67. rocyAaPCTBeHHbIr y'eT jieCHoro 40OH,a

CTaTbR 68. rOcyAapCTBeHHblH JieCHOA KaaaCTp

CTaTb5I 69. MOHHTOPUHr JieCOB

CTaTbSI 70. rocyaapCTBeHHble npOrpaMMbi I4CnOJIb3oBaHHR, OXpaHbl,

3aLUHTbI niecHoro 4OH,aa H BOCnpOH3BOaCTBa nIecOB

CTaTbHq 71. 06H3aTeJIbHas5 CePTH4)HKaUHq nieCHbIX peCYPCOB

CTaTbH 72. JlecoycTpoAcTBO

CTaTbS 73. JIeCoycTpOHTeJIbHbie npoeKTbI

CTaTb1 74. CHcTeMa npOBe,AeHHA jiecoycTpoACTBa

Page 225: Russian - World Bank Documents

221 rPMAO)KEHHE B

CTaTbS1 75. 4H4OpMamuHl O .JeCHOM 4)oHaeCTaTbS1 76. FocyaapCTBeHHbIrl KOHTPOJb 3a cocToAHHeM, HcnoJIb3OBaHHeM,

oxpaHOA, 3aLUHTOri niecioro d3OHaa H BOCnPOH3BOaCTBOM nieCOBCTaTbS1 77. rocyaapcTBeHHaq niecHas oxpaHa POCCHUCKOU (DeaepaLuHHCTaTbSI 78. FocyaapCTBeHHaH 3aUHTaa OAXHOCTHbIX JnHu rocyaapCTBeHHOH

jieCHO OXpaHbl

PA3JAEJ1 IV. HCHOJlb3OBAHHE, OXPAHA, 3AIHTA H BOCnPOH3BOLACTBOJIECOB, KAK BXO),nLHX, TAK H HE BXOALRHX B JIECHOR(DOH&L, A TAKKE 3EMEJIb JIECHOrO 4DOHJtA, HE HOKPblTbIXAECHOU PACTHTEAbHOCTbIO

rnaBa 10. Hcnoinb3oBaHHe necHoro 4)oHAa H He BXO,1UAHX B JeCHOu4)oHA J eCOB

CTaTb5I 79. OcHoBHble Tpe6oBaHHH K HCnOJIb3OBaHHIO leCHoro 4IOHaa H HeBXO,a1IWUX B AeCHOA 4)OHA JeCOB

CTaTbSI 80. BHabj jiecononb3OBaHHSICTaTbM 81. JAuueH3uPOBaHue ae5lTeJTbHOCTH no HcnOJnb3OBaHH}o JTeCHoro

4joH,aCTaTbH 82. npaBa jieconOJnb3OBaTeneuC npH ocyUueCTBj1eHHu HMU

JIecolOAb3OBaHlHRCTaTbM 83. O6,l3aHHocTH .ieconoJIb3oBaTeJieI npu4 OCyiLeCTBjieHHU HMH

.jecoOHojib3OBaHH5ICTaTbA 84. 3aLHuTa H rapaHTuH npaB Jleconojlb3oBaTeJ]ekCTaTbS 85. Bo3MeuweHHe JIecxo3aM 4eaepajbHoro opraHa ynpaBIieHHq

nIeCHbIM XO35IHCTBOM y6blTKoB H rIOTepb niecHoro XO3HHCTBaCTaTbH 86. npe6bleaHHe Fpa)cKaH B necax

riaBa 1I. BocnpoH3BocTBo JieCOB H necopa3BeAeHHe

CTaTbSI 87. UeIH4 BOcnpO43BO,aCTBa nIecoB U iecopa3BeaeHHCTaTbH 88. OcHoBHbIe Tpe6oBaHH5 K rIOBbILueHHi llpOPayKTHBHOCTH .CeCOBCTaTbR 89. nOpqaOK BocnpOH3BOaCTBa niecoBCTaTbH 90. O6SI3aHHOCTH nieconOJnb3OBaTejneu HO BOcripoH3BOaCTBy niecoBCTaTbR 91. 06,l3aHHoCT nieCXo30sB 4eaepanbHoro opraHa yripaBJIeHHs

nieCHblM XO3HIgCTBOM no nOBbiweHHio HpOaYKTHBHOCT4 .necoB

inaBa 12. OxpaHa H 3aUHTa JieCHoro ()oHHAa H He BXOA1LtUHX B JieCHOH 4OHAAecOB

CTaTbH 92. Uej1H H 3a,AalH oxpaHbl H 3aiuHTbl jiecHoro qOHfaa H HeBXO,aI5LUL4X B J1eCHOR 4)OHA n1eCOB

CTaTbS 93. nopqaoK ocyiueCTBjieH4H MepoHpIHTHiu no oxpaHe H 3aLUHTeAieCOB

CTaTbR 94. O6R3aHHOCTH neconoAb30saTene9 no oxpaHe AecoB OT Oi)KapOBCTaTbH 95. rocyaapCTBeHHblri nO)KapHbIrl Haa3Op B J1eCHOM 4)OHae H B He

BXOAIUJHX B JieCHOU qOHA iiecax

Page 226: Russian - World Bank Documents

222 PHA1O)KEHME B

CTaTbSl 96. Y4aCTHe o6LueCTBeHHbIX 06o6eaHHeHHI4 B oxpaHe .JeCHoro 4OHna

H He BXOA51UXHX B jieCHOA 4)OH, iieCOB OT no)KaPOB

CTaTbS 97. ABHaLuHoHHai oxpaHa niecHoro 4OHaa H He BXOqRWHiX B JleCHOR

4OHxD IeCOB

CTaTbA 98. 3aWHTa JieCHoro (DOHaa H He BXOAAIUlHX B IieCHOH d3OHa IieCOB

OT Bpe,aHTeiierl H 6oJIe3Heri neca

CTaTbS 99. O6,q3aHHOCTH ACeconojb3OBaTeCjer4 nO 3aLu[lTe niecHoro fOHa,a H

He BXO21HWHX B n1eCHOU 4)OHA nIeCOB OT BpeatTeAeH H 6one3HeU

.necaCTaTbSI 100. YMaCTHe opraHOB rOCy1apCTBeHHOri BJTaCTH, Cy6'beKTOB

POCCHHCKOUi c)eaepaumHH B OpraHH3aUHH 6opb6bl C nIeCHbIMU

nO)KapaMH, BpeAHTeJii5MH H 6oJe3HAMH neca

CTaTbS 101. O6R3aHHocTH rpaAAaH H IOpHuaHqecKHx flHt nonpe,aoTBpaleHHIO HeraTHBHOrO B03,aeHCTBHA Ha COCTO$HHe

nieCOB

CTaTbM 102. YMaCTHe rpa4(aH H o6weCTBeHHbIX o6fte1DHHeHHA B

o6ecneqeHHH paHLHOHaBbHOrO HCrOAb3oBaHHSI, OXpaHbI, 3aWLUHTbI

H BOCnPOH3BOACTBa neCOB

PA3P,EJI V. HJIATE)KH 3A HOJIb3OBAHHE JIECHbIM (DOHAOM H(DHHAHCHPOBAHHE PACXOAlOB HA BEAEHHE JIECHOrOXO3ARICTBA

rnaBa 13. HnaaTexH 3a noL3OsBaHHe JIeCHb[M 4)OHPOM

CTaTbA 103. BHtibi nJiaTe)Keri 3a nOJ1b3OBaHKe AeCHblM 4)OHROM

CTaTbH 104. JIeCHbIe O,iaaTH

CTaTbA 105. ApeHaHasi njiaTa

CTaTbAI 106. PacnpeaeneHHe H HCnOAb3OBaHHe cpeacTB, nonyqaembix npH

B3maHMHH HiaTexKeH 3a nOJIb3OBaHHe .)eCHb[M 4JOHaOM

CTaTbH 107. JibrOTbl no nAaTexaKM 3a nOJ1b3OBaHHe jieCHblM 4)OHAOM

rnasa 14. (DHHaHcHpoBaHHe paCXOAOB Ha rocyAapcTBeHHoe ynpaB]IeHue B

o6nacTH HCnOjib3oBaHHSA, oXpaHbl, 3alluTbi neCHOFo 4oHAa H

BOCnpOH3BOACTBa AecoB H Ha BeAeHHe iiecHoro Xo3SICTBa

CTaTbA 108. (IDHHaHCHPOBaHHe PaCXOaOB Ha rocy,AaPCTBeHHOe ynpaBJIeHHe B

o6AaCTH HCnOAb3oBaHHS, OXpaHbI, 3aUIUTbl jieCHoro (DoHaa H

BOCnpOH3BO,aCTBa iieCOB H Ha BeAeHHe nieCHoro XO35HCTBa

PA3,EJI VI. PA3PEUIEHHE CnOPOB B OBJIACTH HCnOJIb3OBAHHIA, OXPAHbl,3AILIHTbl H BOCnPOH3BOJACTBA JIECOB H OTBETCTBEHHOCTb 3AHAPYIIIEHHE JIECHOrO 3AKOHO1AATE1bCTBA POCCHflCKOHIDEJAEPALUH H

rnaBa 15. Pa3pelueHHe CriOpOB B o6naCTH UCnOnb30BaHHU, OXpaHbl, 3autiTbi H

BOCnpOH3BOACTBa nIeCOB

Page 227: Russian - World Bank Documents

223 HlPHAO)KEHHE B

CTaTbA 109. nOpSIAOK pa3peweHAsi CnOpOB B o6nacTH ticnoJIb3oBaHHSl,

oxpaHbI, 3aUUHTbl H BOCnPOH3BOaCTBa necoB

UnjaBa 16. OrBeTCTBHHOCTb 3a HapyiiieHue JecHoro 3aKoHogaTeAbcTBa

PoCCHUcKoU (DeAepaLHH

CTaTbA 110. AAMHHHcTpaTHBHasA U yrojioBHas OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a

HapywieHHe .ecHoro 3aKOHoaaTejibCTBa POCCHUCKOU 4'eaepaLtuHCTaTbs II 11. OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb rpax)aH H iopHaHqeCKIX JInuU 3a npHqHHeHtHe

yiuep6a JieCHOMY 4)OHRy H He BXOAAtUHM B JIeCHOg 4OH,D, necam

CTaTbM 112. HeaeACTBHTenbHOcTb caenioK, coBepweHHbIX C HapyweHHeM

iiecHoro 3aKoHogaTeJ1bCTBa POCCHUCKOU (Deaepaumu

OCOEEHHAAI IACTb

PA3AEJl VII. OCOBEHHOCTH HCnOHJb3OBAHHA JIECHOFO OOH)JA, HEBXO,RSIItHX B RECHOR DOHA JIECOB, aPEBECHO-KYCTAPHHKOBOfl PACTUTEJlbHOCTU

UAaBa 17. Oco6eHHOCTH Hcrioji3OBaHHA iiecHoro 4oHAa

CTaTbA 113. 3aroToBKa ApeBecHHbl

CTaTbA 114. Cnoco6bl py6oK B 3aBHCHMOCTH OT rpynn IiecOB H KaTeropHH

3aTUHTHOCTH necoB nepBoui rpynnbiCTaTbs 115. rlpaBHuia py6oKCTaTbA 116. OpraHH3aUHA H nOPA1aOK 3aFOTOBKH apeBecHHbI npH py6KaxCTaTbAS 117. O6beM 3arOTOBKH apeBeCHHbl npH py6Kax rnIaBHoro

HOJIb3OBaHH5I

CTaTbA 118. OnpeaejieHHe o6feMa 3arOTOBKH lpeBecHHbl npH py6KaxnpoMe)KyTO4qHOrO nOJIb3OBaHHS1 H ipoqHx py6Kax

CTaTbA 119. oPSIA,OK 3arOTOBKH KHBHULbI

CTaTbA 120. HOPSAIOK 3arOTOBKH BTOpocTereHHbIX .ieCHbIX peCYpCOB H

ocyLieCTBjieHu4s no6o4HOM Jieconojib3OBaHH5ICTaTbA 121. rops1LAoK nOflb3OBaHHI yY4aCTKaMH JiecHoro 4)oHaa ARA HY)KA

OXOTHH4berO X03RflCTBa

CTaTbA 122. I1OPALROK HOhIb3OBaHH5I yqaCTKaMH nieCHoro 4oHAa AnA HayqHo-

HccAeAoBaTeJbCKHx Luejieg

CTaTbA 123. lop5laoK Hojib3OBaHHAs yqaCTKaMH necHoro FOH,Oa aqAR

KyJIbTypHO-030opOBHTeJIbHbIX, TYPHCTHMeCKHX K CnOPTHBHbIX

ueneie

CTaTbA 124. HIOPHLOK nOJIb3OBaHHA y'aCTKaMH necHoro 4OHAa Ha

TeppHTOpH5IX TpaAUHLHOHHOrO r1PO)K4BaHHA KOpCHHblX

MaJOqHCjieHHbIX HapOAOB H 3THHUeCKHX o6[UHocTegCTaTbAs 125. rocyaapCTBeHHbIe npHpOaHbie 3anoBeRHHKI, HaoXIsIUHecsC Ha

TCepHTOpH4 niecHoro 4OHaaCTaTbA 126. HautroHanbHble napKH, HaxoaALIueCAM Ha TeppHTOpHH iiecHoro

)oH,aa

Page 228: Russian - World Bank Documents

224 HPIIPO)KEHHE B

CTaTbH 127. nlpHpoRHbIe napK4, HaXOaALuHeCI Ha TeppHTOpHH nIecHoIo

4oHaaCTaTbH 128. JIeCXO3bl o6pa3oBaTenbHblx yqpeAczeHHH BblCwero

npod)ecciOHaAbHoro o6pa3oBaHHA, AeCXO3bl Hay'qHO-

HCCJiCe,OBaTeAbCKHX yqpexKLeHHri 4)e2epajibHoro opraHa

ynpaBAeHAs neCHbIM XO3SIgCTBOM

CTaTbS 129. FOPqaOK nOJIb3OBaHHS yMaCTKaMi4 iiecHoro 4OHaa B

nOrpaHHqHbIX 3OHaX

CTaTbH 130. Oco6eHHocTH i4cnoFIb3oBaHHA, oxpaHbI, 3aLfHTbl ieCHoro cjOHaa

H BOCHPpOK3BOACTBO iieCOB, paHee HaXOaHBmHXC51 BO BJiaaeHHH

cejTbCKOXo35qACTBeHHbIX opraHH3aLUHr

FnaBa 18. OCo6eHHOCTH HCnOJIb3oBaHHR, oxpaHbl, 3auJHTbI H BOCllPOH3BOACTBa

IieCOB, He BXOAlIHX B AeCHOIR 4OH,xA

CTaTbH 131. 061lHe Tpe6oBaHKI4 K HCnIOJIb3OBaHHIO JieCoB, He BXOaAlUHX B

jiecHor1 dJOHA

CTaTbI 132. JIeca, pacnojTo)KeHHbie Ha 3eMjnix o6opOHbl

CTaTbH 133. Jleca, pacnojio)KeHHbie Ha 3eMJTIX FOpOACKHX noceJieHHi

rnaBa 19. Oco6eHHOCTH Hcnojib3oBaHHS, oxpaHbI, 3alluHTbI H BOCdlpOH3BOACTBa

ApeBeCHO-KyCTapHHKOBOA paCTHTeCjbHOCTH

CTaTb5 134. apeBeCHO-KyCTapHHKOBa5 pacTHTejIbHocTb, pacnojio)KeHHas Ha

3eMJISX CeJIbCKOX03AHCTBeHHOIO Ha3HaqeHiqS

CTaTbSI 135. apeBecHo-KycTapHHKoBasi pacTHTeJIbHoCTb, pacnojio)KeHHaA Ha

3eMJISX )KeJie3HoLAopo)KHoro TpaHcnopTa

CTaTb5I 136. apeBeCHO-KyCTapH4KOBaSi pacTHTeJIbHocTb, pacnooKeHHa Ha

3eMJI5x aBToMo6HJIbHoro TpaHCnOpTa H 3eMJIHX BOaHOrO c1OHXa

3AKJ1IOH) TEJTbHAA 'ACTb

Diama 20. BBeAeHHe B AeUICTBHe HacToALiero KoAeKca

CTaTbhI 137. BBeaeHme B aerCTBHe HacToqwero KoaeKca

CTaTbhS 138. 0 nPH43HaHHN yTpaTHBLUHMH CnJIy HeKOTOPb1X 3aKOHoRaTeCjbHbIX

aKTOB PoccHUUcKoU $eAepauHH

Page 229: Russian - World Bank Documents

HPH1O)KEHHE r

COCTOAHHE JIECOFIPOMbILUWJEHHOrO KOMnAJEKCA, TOPrOBJIS, UEHbI U HAJ1OrOBb[EnOCTYnAEHUA

AecHas HpOMbliJIeHHOCTb

HpK CHCTeMe ueHTpa)1H3OBaHHOrO nHIaHHpoBaHHI4, HCnOJIb3OBaBweeHCH B CCCP,jiecHaq npOMbiliJeHHOCTb He OTHOCHJTaCb K CrIHCKY npHOpHTeTHbIX OTpacJierH, BCie'aCTBMe

3TOrO npouCecc 4JHaHCHPOBaHHq OTpacnm ocyWeCTBJsnlJIcS nO TaK Ha3blBaeMoMy

OCTaTOMHOMy npHH1H4ny. ,JIOJI KanHTajioB1o)KeHH4 B JIeCHyio rpOMbiliUeHHOCTb HaxoLiiiiacb

Ha YpOBHe OT ripMHepHO OaHOri TpeTH aO nOJIOBHHbI ee aOAH B BajiOBOM o6fbeMe

npOMbIwJIeHHoro rpOH3BoacTBa. HecMoTpAI Ha TO, 'ITO B nepHoa c 1980 no 1990 roa 3TO

COOTHOweHHe BO3pOCJIO, B rocJieyIoLLue rogb2 o Xo 14 4HHaHCHpOBaHH54, HanpaBeiemorO B

OTpaCJIb, CHOBa coKpaTH4iaCb ipHMepHO BaBoe no CpaBHeHHIO C YPOBHeM 1980 roAa.

C 1980 no 1995 FO,bl IPOH304UJIO coKpalueHme o6beMa ueHTpaAiH3OBaHHbIX

rOCy,aapCTBeHHbIX (dteaepaJlbHbIX 14 perHOHanIbHbIx) KanHTajioBjTo)KeHHA B JlecHO-H ceKTop H

yBeJImieHHe goiH KaH4TajioBjio)KeHHH 3a CxCT co6CTBeHHblX CpeaCTB IpelanpHmiTH. B UejoMypOBCHb ueHTPanH3OBaHHbIX KanHTaJ]OBjOo)KCHH4I B 3KOHOMHKY CTpaHbl CHH3H4ACR C 90% B

1980 FQOy ao 23% B 1995 roay; B .JeCHOM Ke ceKTope OH coKpaTHJCAI c 80% Ro 5%.(IHHaHCHpOBaHIe HHBCCTHLUHH 3a c'IeT co6cTBeHHbIx CpeaCTB rpejUnpHaTHA ToKe

coKpaTHnOCb H K 1995 roay B peanIbHOM BbIpa)KeHHH OHO COCTaBJIqUIO Bcero OX4Hy HSTylo

4aCTb OT YPOBHSl 1990 roLa.

1)egepajibHoe H PeFHOHaJIbHbie HpaBHTeJlbCTBa BbileJlIsOT He6ojibwor0 o6'eMCpeL,CTB B BHae cy6cHtigi4, a OCTajibHbiC CpeaCTBa npeaoCTaBJI5IOTC$I B OpMo e jIbrOTHbIX

KpeXU4TOB. HpH pa3MeCeHIHHH KanlHTaJIOiO)KeHHA HaH6oJlbwa5 4 HX aoJI5 BcerL4a

HanpaBMJAacb B AeCO3arOTOBHTenJbHYIO oTpacJlb, KOTOpaS C4HTaiiaCb rpHOpHTeTHoHi, npH3TOM [JenloJIo3HO-6yMaXKHaA H aepeB0o6pa6aTbIBaiowaH OTpaCJIH noJiy'aJiH ropa3goMeHbIwJe KanHTaJTOBjio)KeHIH. Co6cTBeHHbie CpeaCTBa npeanpHPKHTHH no-npe)KHeMy LIaaOT

JIbBHHYIO aOJ1IO cpeRCTB, HCHOJIb3yeMbIX B KaLeCTBC KanIHTaJIOBJIo)KeHHIi. 9TH CppeaCTBa,

aKKyMyIHpyIOTC5l rpearipHMTHAMH, rFiaBHbIM o6pa3oM 3a cdeT aMOPTH3aLIHOHHbIX

oTi4cjceHHt4, npoH3BOaCTBeHHbIx nphp6buiek, a B riocneRHee BpCMq TaKlKe 3a C'eT cpeLRCTB,

rIOJIyqeHHbIX OT HpHBaTH3aUHH U KalH4TaJIH3aUHH aKTHBOB. qaCTHbie HHBeCTOpbI (KaK

OTeCeCTBeHHbie, TaK H 3apy6e)KHbie) ceu'ac peaKO aejialoT aoJIrOCpoqHbieKanITanOBno)KeHRH B pa3BHTHC rpOMbIlieHHOCTI4, HTO o61bsCHqeTCq BbICOKHMH TeMnaMH

HH)J15ILHHH, HeOnpeaejieHHOCTb[O 3KOHOMHmeCKO9 CHTyaULHH H OTCYTCTBHeM 4leTKOr4

3aKOHo,aaTeJTbHOH 6a3bl H rpaBHji, peryiHpypomWx HHBeCTIH[OHHyIo eHTeJTbHocTb.

B 1996 roay B POCCHH aeACTBOBajio 3.348 iiecorpoMbwlIeHHbIX npeanpHATHR. KSHBapio 1996 roaa 3.194 npetrnpHsTHI 6birlH yKe HlpHBaTH3HpOBaHbl. B HaCTo0lLsee BpeMqrpe,arIpHATHAMH HCUIOJ]b3yeTCq TOIbKO IOJTOBHHa HMeiOWHXCH y HHX HPOH3BOACTBeHHbIX

MOULHOCTeH, a HMeiOwUeCA TeXHOJ1OFHH BO MHOrX cjly'aqx MBJIq[OTC5 YCTapeBUWiMH K

He3c1eKTHBHbIMH. KAjOHeBblMH npo6AeMaMH AeCHOH npOMblwjieHHOCTH, Tpe6yiOLi.HM

Page 230: Russian - World Bank Documents

226 HPtJIOK)IEHIIEr

pewCJeHHA (H 3TO B paBHOf mepe OTHOCHTCH1 KaK K FIpHBaT[43HpOBaHHbIM, TaK U K

rocy2apCTBeHHbIM npeAnpHATHRM), qBJIAIOTCA:

* HH3KaH npOH3BOAU4TeJlbHOCTb B JAeCO3arOTOBKTeJIbHOr4 H

faepeBonepepa6aTbIBaioiueri oTpaciiqx.

* HeaOCTaToqHaH rny6HHa aepeBonepepa6oTKH B Co3flaiO1LeM ao6aBMeHHyIoCTOHMOCTb npOH3BOACTBe 1apeBeCHbiX npO1RyKTOB.

* 3KOHOMHUecKUe H MaTepHaJbHO-TeXHH4ecK4e TPYAHOCTH, CBI3aHHbie C

TpaHCnOpTHPOBKOU Ha 6onbWHue paCCTOHHqH, pa3geJisoutHe npeInpHqTHA

H BHyTpeHHHe H Mex.AyHapOAHbIe pbIHKH.

* MejvieHHoe BHeapeHHe 3KonorHqecKH 6e3onaCHblx, paUl4OHaJbHbIX 14

HeHCTOI1IHTeJbHbIX MeTOAOB 3aFOTOBKH AeCHbIX pecypCOB.

* 1l36blTO4Hbie YPOBHH fleCOCe4Hb[X H OTXOROB, o6pa3yloIuu4XcH B pe3ynbTaTe

nepepa6oTKH apeBeCC4HbI

J,EWn pemueHiA 3THX npo6neM noTpe6yloTcH:

* KoppeKTHpOBKa nOJIHTHmecKHx YCTaHOBOK H HOpMaTHBHbIX MaTepHanoB,

peryuHPY1OIUHX OTHOllleHHH Co6CTBeHHOCTH npeanpHuTHrH, HHOCTpaHHbie

HHBeCTHL4UH H npouecc ueHoo6pa3oBaHH5, HanpaBneHHaH Ha JIHKBHLauHIo

orpaHHMeHHr H nepexoa K yCTOrPMHBOMy pa3BHTHIO JIeCHoro CeKTopa.

* Co3,aaHHe 6naronpHRTHbIX YCJ1OBH4r AAA AeHTeJIbHOCTH MaJibIX

npOH3BOIACTBeHHbIx npeanpHATHA 3a C4eT rpeCoCTaBjieHHq 3THM

npe,UrPHTHAM Ha Ha4aJbHOU cTauHH Hx pa6OTbI MeX(AYHapOAHOA

(bHHaHCOBOH H TeXHHtMeCKO noMoiuH, nepexaau TexHonorHr, a TaioKe

CTapTOBOrO KarIHTaIia.

* OrpaHHMeHHe pa3MepOB BbIpy6OK, o6pa3ylOlUHXCq B pe3yJAbTaTe npOBeReHH5CnJIOlUHbIX py6oK B eCTeCTBeHHbIX apeBOCTOHX, H BHeapeHHe

JieCOBOCCTaHOBHTenJbHbIX CHCTeM, cnoco6CTByIOIU4X CCTeCTBeHHOMY

B03o6HOBJeHHIO.

* OTKa3 OT HCnOJlb3OBaHH4l HaH6ojlee TS)KejOirO .ieCO3arOTOBHTeJIbHOrO

o6opy14oBaHHH, c iCeflblO yjiy'weHHH nO4BeHHbIX yCJIOBHH H BOAHOrO

pe)KHMa Ha AeCOKyj1bTypHbIX HnAOLUa,AX.

* EoAee paUHOHaJ]bHoe, HHTeHCHBHoe H 3c1eKT4BHoe HCnOJ1b3OBaHHe

CaHHTapHbIX py6oK u BTOpHWHbIX peCYPCOB Ha BCeX CTaaUfX pa6oTbl JieCHOH

npoMbRUwIeHHOCTH.

Page 231: Russian - World Bank Documents

227 HP;IJIOXEHHE r

THHmi feconpoMmmIcHHoA HpoUAKHH m Hx mcuoIboBsaHHe

ApeBeCHHa cU46HpCKHX XBOHHbIX rlOpO, B [enjOM C4HTaeTCA BbICOKOKaqeCTBeHHOri.1Bcjie,aCTBHe MeJAeHHbIX TeMrOB pOCTa, aepeBbA 3THX nOpoa HMelOT Ha cpe3epacnoJ1oKeHHbie 6JiH3KO Apyr K apyry roaHqHbie KOJ1bLua H 4eTKHH TeKCTYPHbIH pHiCYHOK.CYI4KH o6bl4HO He6oAbllHe 1 peaKHe, T.K. Y3Ki4e KpOHbl XBOH4HblX aepeBbeB,npoH3pacTaIoLuHx Ha BbICOKHX WUPOTax 6opeaAbHOH 3OHbl, HaxOAATCA nOa IOCTOqHHbIMBO3,aeACTBtieM CYpOBb[X KAHMaTHx4eCKi4X yCAOBHi4. Y 3THX aepeBbeB OTHOCHTeabHO y3KaA3a6oJiOHb (peAKO aocT4raioiuaA 3 CM B LHUHPHHY), HO3TOMy 6peBHa o6blrHO OCTaloTCSrPAMbIMH aa)Ke B YCJIOBHSX LnHTeJ1bHOrO xpaHeHHA H rpH 3aaep)KKax C nHIneHHeM necanocnie ero py6KH4.

,LpeBecHHa eJnu H nlHXTbl (T.H. "6eJIaA apeBec14Ha") TpaLHUHOHHO HMeeT XopoWuHePbIHKH c6bITa, a B parioHax, pacnoJIoKeHHbIx Ha 6eperax 5AnOHCKoro MOpA, Ha ioJIIo 3THXBKROB npHXOAHTCS 90% apeBeCHHbl, HcHoJIb3yeMorH B 3TOM perHOHe anA CTpoHTeJTbcTBaKHfbi. CnieUHarIHCTbl C4KTalOT, 'TO 3Ty apeBeCHHy MO)KHO npHpaBHsTb K ApeBecHHe TCyrHaMepHKaHCKOU H TCyrH pa3HOA14CTHOr4 (sugf), KOTOpaA ToIKe oTJiH4aeTCS 6o0ee MeJKM14MUCy"KaMH, yiyqlwIeHHOH OTaejiKOg H rfOBb1weHHOH npO4IHOCTbIO. 2 BenaM aA peBeCI4Ha IIIHpOKO14CnOJIb3yeTCR amn npoH3BoACTBa MHOrOCAOHHbIX onop H WHpOKoro cneKTpaKOHCTpyKLUHOHHbIX 3JieMeHTOB. B EBpone, rge enJb cH64pcKaq C'IHTaeTCA OH14M H3 caMbIXJIy'114X H3 HMe1oLLLHXCA BHAOB (ee apeBeciHa npO4Hee, qleM apeBec14Ha enH o 6 blKHoBeHHorl),apeBecHHa 3TorO BHaa HaxogHT Bce 6o0iee WIHupoKoe npHMeHeHHe B CTOJIApHOMHPOH3BOaCTBe.

B Haqane 1970-x rooB JT14CTBeHHiL4a cH6HpcKas CqHTanJaCb Bcero lHillbBTopoCTeneHHoH nopogort apeBecHHbl H c6blBaJlacb B KaqeCTBe maTepHana ARs CBarl. HonOCKOJ1bKy oHa o6naaaeT BbICOKOU npO4HOCTblO H BnaroCTor4KocTbio H He3HaqtiTenjbHOae4)OpMHpyeTCs B 6pycbAx KBaapaTHorO H npAMoyronbHoro ce'eHHH, JINHCTBeHHHLUaCi46HpCKaS cTaiia nocTeneHHo IlOJ1b3OBaTbCq nOBblweHHb1M ClpOCOM Ha 3apy6eKHbIXpblHKax. B HaCTOALLtee BpeMA OHa aOBOJIbHO H14POKO HCnOJIb3yeTCA IAI Liejioro pA1aaCneuL4dH'i4eCKHX rlpOAyKTOB H pa6OT. HO InOHCKOrI CHCTeMe HCr1bITaHH14 Ha rPO4HOCTb,JIHCTBeHHi4Ua CH6HpCKaS OTHOCHTCA K lyriaC14eBOfl-n14CTBeHHHHqHoH rpynne. [jenlJUIOnO3HO-6yMaKHbie KOM6HHaTbl B EpaTCKe, EaAKajTbCKe H CeeieHre HCUIOflb3yIOT B CBOeri,aeATeJbHOCTH aOBOJ1bHO 3Ha,IHTejibHbie o61eMbi J1HCTBeHHH1HOA LapeBeCHHbi no cpaBHeH14toc ,apeBeCH HOH ,Aepe BbeB apyrHx nopo, .

COCHa o6blKHOBeHHaA (Pinus sylvestris) Toxe BeCbMa ueHHTCA Ha 3apy6e)KHbIXpbIHKaX. OHa paCTeT MeLieHHee, ieM AIHOHCKaS KpaCHas COCHa H HM4eeT 6onee MenJKHeCyK1KH. B Ben14Ko6pl4TaH1414 BOCTOqHOCH64HpCKaS COCHa, oco6eHHO H3 KpaCHOHpCKOro KpaABoo6we CYHTaeTCA CaMoH ueHHOA (H3 BCex HMelOu.1HXCA) niopoaorl apeBeCHHbl.

I IJemrmaIumH BceMMpHoro 6aHKa nocenTIa COBpCMeHHbli 7eCOf7uRbHbrn 3aBoa, o 6OpyaOBaHHbllfKpyr7on,LHTbHbIMH CTaHKaMf (luBtaCKfMf 'ApH"), KOTOpMii CO BpeMeHeMalO.ffKCH o 6 zealflHHTbc CO CTpOgLI(HMC.qceiY'Iac 3aBOWOM HO BbilyCKy CApCBeCHAfX I7lAUT C 7pHKMIeeHHwMH KpOMKaMf B paMKaX coBMecTHoro 7peaiwpHqTmqC MeyHapo,aHog KOMmaHHeft IKEA. 3aecb mcnoawb3yeTCZ apeBecHHa XBO,iHbiX (B OCHOBHOM, COCHbI H eam)nopQa, a 177HTbi aOfl,KHbl 9KCl1OpTfpOBaTbCui (I7000m3O/ro) Ha MC6CRbHme gpgpHi7THR KOMI7aHHH IKEA B3anmHo# EBpone alM 17poH3BoacTBa aoporo# Me6JIH.

2 EmH IH n7HXT, ApewccHHa KOTopUIx OTTYHIaeTC OTHOCfTCIIbHO HH3KHM COWepXaHHeM CMO,7bl,HClIOIIb3yIOTCJa 17OYTH HCKAIOvY'TeC.bHO ,ZIIR IpOH3BOiaCcTfa LWAeJ/IOA3bl, YTO 06 b7iCHReTCl OTCyTCTBmeM TCXHOR7OrTHH o6opywoBaHH,? Heo6xoaiMbixagq 7 nepepa6oTKf CbipbH C bblCOKfM CoaepxaHHeM CMOwbi.

Page 232: Russian - World Bank Documents

228 HPHJ1OKEHHE F

JlecoMaTepHanbl H3 COCHbI, npO143pacTaoluLeg Ha CpeaHecH6t4pcKoM nulOcKoropbe, LUeHqTCA

3a HX MejiKocnoRHy1o Kpac14BY1O TeKcTypy H KoHKypeHTocnoco6HyIo ueHy, no cpaBHeHH1O C

nunomaTepuanamH 13 COCHbl, BbIpOCUweH B KaHaae. 3

Keap KOpeHcCKHi4 (Pinus koraiensis) U3 CU6HpiH LeHHTCu 3a paBHOmepHYKO

TeKCTypy rOBePXHOCTH H yCToHN14BOCTb npH aepeBoo6pa6OTKe, XOTA ee LeHHbie CBOHiCTBa

orpaHH'HBalOTCA TOJbKO KOMJIeM 6peBeH; BepXHHe qaCTH CTBOJIa o6bIqHO 143BHfl1CTble H He

npHrOaHbI AnA pe3b6bl no aepeBy. B AnoHH0H apeBeCHHa KOpeHcKorO Keapa, HMnOPTHpyeMaSH3 CH6upH, H npoayKTbI ee KOHelHoro HCnOJb3OBaHH5 ycneLuHO KOHKYPHpyIOT C

apeBecHHOA U3 l0ro-BOCTO4HOA A3HH. Ee HcnOJIb3ylOT He TOJIbKO AJA aepeBoO6pa6OTK1 U

H3rOTOBjieH4HA MoIeJeeH, HO H AIA npOH3BoACTBa BbICOKOKa4eCTBeHHbIX CTpOHTenJbHbIX

MaTepH4aJnOB. B o6weM, XOTA B a3i4aTCKOrl 'iaCTH POCCU14 BcTpeqaIOTCq "TBepable"

Jfl4CTBeHHbIe nOpOabi (ay6, qceHb, BA3, opex), 6oJIbLI1HCTBo JIHCTBeHHbIX nopoa - MArKHe, B

OCHOBHOM, 3TO - 6epe3a H OCHHa. 9TH nOpOabI iaepeBbeB o6blqHO C41TaKOTCA MaiJOUeHHbIMH

H HX B OCHOBHOM HCHOJIb3ylOT AAAS rPOH3BOaCTBa uenJUIOJIO3bl U dPaHepbi.

3arcTOBKa H TPBHCUOPTPOBKB JICCa

OCHOBHbIMH MmTOaaMi 3arOTOBKH neca IBJIIOTCA MeTOabi 3arOTOBKH H BbIB03KH

XIbCTOB, T.e. 3arOTOBKa H TpaHCnOpTHPOBKa Kpyrnioro Aeca (CTBOJIOB c o6py6AeHHblM14

BeTBAMH H BepwIHHaMH), H MeTO,Amb 3aJOTOBKH C BbOBo3KOM aepeBbeB, T.e. 3arOTOBKa H

TpaHCnOPTHPOBKa UeIAbIX aepeBbeB, BKlio4aA BepLHHbI 14 BeTBH. XJbCTbI, 3arOTOBJeHHbie B

xoae py6oK rIaBHoro noJIb3OBaHHA, TpaHcnOPTHPYIOTC51 Ha neCOBo3ax OT BepXHero cKmaaa yJIeCOBO3HOH aoporH Ha HH)KHHA cKiaa MexaHH3HpoBaHHorH nepBHqHOH nepepa6oTKi4, rae

npOHCXOR4T pacKpA)KeBKa H COPTHPOBKa roJ1y4eHHbIx 6peBeH no pa3Mepy. 'laCTb

3arOTOBJIeHHOrO neca nepepa6aTbleaeTcsl Ha He6oJIbUHx HnHAopaMax, HaxoaI5UHXCS PSA,OM C

MexaHH3HuOBaHHbIM HH)KHHM CKJIaLOM, HO y 3THX nHJIOpaM O'ieHb orpaHHMeHHaA

MOLIHOCTb, H OHH o6blrqHO npoH3BOaRT npoayKLuH1O TO.IbKO AAJ MeCTHOrO noTpe6JieHHlA.

OCHOBHaA qaCTb 6peBeH Ju60 TpaHcnOPTHpyeTC Ha ieconHJIbHbie npeanpHATHT ,

nlpeanlpHATMA Ho nPOH3BORCTBY 4aHepbI H LnOHa 14Jn14 Ha 3aBOabl RpeBeCHocTpy)KeMHb[X H

apeBeCHOBOJIOKHHCTbIX IJIHT, Jul60 OTipaBJTAeTCq Ha 3KCnOpT. ropa3ao MeHbLUe B POCCHH1

npHMeH.eTCA MmeTO COpTHMeHTHO 3arOTOBKH nieca, Koraa 6peBHa COpTHPYIOT H

paCKpAxeBbIBalOT B Aecy, H nO3TOMy nOrpy3Ka OCyLueCTBJIAeTC51 TOJlbKO OaHH pa3, a

TpaHCnOpTHbie pacXORbl COKpaWLalOTCq Hi B 3HaLH4TeJlbHOri CTeneHH OnJlaHiHBalOTCq

noKynaTeJAMH 3THX COpT14MeHTOB. 1jeHa Ha COPT14MeHTbl oripeaejIAeTCA CTOHMOCTblO

npORyKTOB KOHe4Horo IOJIb3OBaHHA.

flpi4 py6Kax yxoaa H py6Kax r11aBHOFO roOlb3OBaHHoS 6brIHO HCrIOJlb3ylOT elenHbie

MUMTbI POCCRACKOrO H pOCCHACKO-LmBeaCKOrO HIpOH3BOaCTBa 4 . npH nO1JHO1 MeXaHH3auL H

py6oK riiaBHoro nOJlb3OBaHHUA 4HcnOJIb3yIOT pOCCHr4CKHe BaJIO4HO-TpeJleBO4Hbie MaWl4Hbl H

BaJIO'HO-HaKeTHpyIOLLHe MawI4HbI, HeKOTOpbIe U3 HHX OCHaXLeHbl CBepXwHpOKHMH

3 aae.erawiz BE nocenuma 17peaflplflfTe, BlbJIyCKIozLUCC CTporaHbIii LU,70H (Ha o6opyaoBaHMlf qIJoHCKOg

4HfpMBI MapyHaKa), B foryqaHcKoM paA8oHe (Ha AHiape), rae pa3Hwe BifabI ()aHepbi 13 COCHbi 17p0f3B0LaBTC-q Ha

9KC7OPT B JnoHHIO.4 TpaawlfofHHo HCfII0,7b3yCMaB LleifH8fl fIH.a "4pyxK6a" C BUiCOKOIl pyKOHTKo01 6bma peKoHCTpylfpoBaHa H

nflBCmaHa B CooTBeTcTBife C MexayHapOHlbIMHf C7aH4apTaMu FnG 3prOHOMfKe, TeXHHKC 6e3onacHocTH H

ILuyMoBbIM orpaHlfqeHHM; 9Ta pa6oma ipoweieHa COBMeCTHbiM ipeanpiHeTHM Co LuBeacKoM KOMaIH1ef

Husquarna.

Page 233: Russian - World Bank Documents

229 HPHJIO)KEHKE r

ryceHHLiaMH, cpeaH HHX eCTb TaKwKe caMO3arpy)KaioHUec5I MaaWHHbI. FIPH nPUiMeHeHHICOpTHMeHTHOrO MeTOaa HcnOJIb3ylOT 4opBapAep c LUHPOKHMH WUHHaMH. H4cnojlb3oBaHHeHeKOTOpbIX BHAOB TADKeAoH JieCO3aroToBHTeJIbHO9 TeXHHKI HeaaBHo 6buo o61bqBnaeHonpOTHBO3aKOHHbIM, nOTOMY 'TO OHO BbI3bIBaeT Hpe3MepHbIe nOBpeKaeHHA llOYBbl. Ha3KcnepHMeHTaBJbHOH OCHOBe certac Hcnojib3ylOT o6opyAoBaHHe anq py6KH nieca 4HHCKoronpOH3BOaCTBa, BaOIMHO-TpeAeBOMHbIe MaUHHbl H qbOpBapaepbI.

1OY4TH BCS BbIBO3Ka nieca npOH3BOAHTCA nocpeaCTBOM TpeAeBKH xnjblCTOB Hnu,aepeBbeB. KoMJIH aepeBbeB IOaHHMaiOTC5i C 3eMAH H noMeLualOTCS1 Ha mawtiHy; KPOHbILepeBbeB OCTalOTCA Ha 3eMJIe, H 9TOT rpy3 nOATaCKHBaeTCA K rIJo1LU8aKe y aoporH unuH KBePXHeMY CKnaay. CTaHaapTHblr TpeneBOtHbll TPaKTOP - 3TO TA)KeCiaS1 MaUWHa HaryCeHHtHOM XOAy, OCHaweHHa3 fle6eaKoM H nOrpy33OxHbIM arperaToM c rHapaBJIHqeCKHMnpHBOANM. lNCHOJIb3ylOT TaK)Ke TpaKTOpbI Co CTpejori H KOHUKOM C 3a)HMHbIMH pblqaraMM.npu CaHHTapHbIX py6Kax o6pe3Ka BeTBer o6blqHo npOH3BO14HTCq C rOMOL.blO iLerIHOi HflH.IbInpAMO B niecy, a npH py6Kax riiaBHoro HOJIb3OBaHHS BeTBH, KaK npaBnJIo, o6pe3aloTcA HaHnowua,Ke y aoporH C noMOIIblO TSDKenJblX cyqKope3HbIX ryceHH4HbIX MalUiH TH4na JorMa.

BO BpeMA py6oK rilaBHoro nOAb3OBaHHS, Koraa y aoporm cKanHJBalOTCS 6onbwiMeo6beMbl apeBeCHHbl, naHMK XJIbICTOB norpy)KalOTCH Ha JIeCOBo3bl c nOMOLUbiO Tq)IeJIbIXryCeHH4HbIX HrOPY3O0HbIX TpaKTOpOB pOCCHiCKOrO HpoH3BOaCTBa, KOTOpbIe nOaHHMalOT rpy3H 3a6pacbIBaloT ero 3a ce6s Ha AeCOBO3; HMKaKHX pa3BOPOTOB TaKoro norpy3qjIKa HeTpe6yeTcsA. Jo CHX nop TaKxKe HcnoJIb3yeTC$ HeCKOAbKO norpy3qHKOB KaHaTHO-3JIeBaTOpHoroTHna. OHM ripH4qHH5OT MeHbile BpeAa oKpyxKaioweH cpeae, HO rH6KOCTb HHpoH3BoAHTeJ1bHoCTb npH HX CHnOJIb3OBaHHH HH)Ke. CaMbiM pacnpocTpaHeHHbIM CpeaCTBOMTpaHCnOPTHPOBKH ABJIAeTCS rpy3OBOu aBTomo6HJlb C noJIynpHuenoM. KoMjin XJbICTOB Jle)KaTHa rpy3oBHKe, a BepwHHbi no,BeWHBaIOTCH C nOMOlUbIO npHUera. noAe3HbIH rpy3 OAHORTaKOri Maw1iHbI COCTaBJIAeT 25 M3 .

I3OJIbWUHHCTBO HH)UHHX cKnaaoB HuH MexaHH3MPOBaHHbix nyHKTOB nePBH4HOHnepepa6oTKH o6OpyaOBaHo KO3JOBbIMM KpaHaMH Ha penbcax aAn pa3rpy3KH 6peBeH.rpy3ono,abeMHOcTb Kax(Aoro M3 HHX COCTaBJqeT 20-30 TOHH, tITO nO3BOnA$eT 3a OaUH pa3pa3rpywaTb BeCb JieCOBO3. XJIbICTbl oTaen5iloTCs apyr OT apyra C rOMomi1bio nonepetHbixKOHBeHepOB, rHapaBJIH4qeCKx KpaHOB H BpyqHYIO. PaCKPAlKeBKa XTibICTOB npOH3BOamTCAnOWTYMHO C rIOMOLUbIO pytHb1X U14PKYASIpHbIX nHJI, 3JieKTPOMOTOpHbIx uenHbIX nHuI uInuCTaHLIapTHbix 6eH3onrul.

I3peBHa TpaHCnOPTHPYIOTCA C nOMOlIblO UenHbIX nIeCoTpaHCnOpTepoB HCOPTHUYIOTCH B AeCoHaKonHTeJIH nJIu COpTHpOBOMHbIe KapMaHbl, KyAa OHM YKAlaAblBaiOTCiwTa6eJIASM. B HCKOTOPbIX cnyqaAx coeps)KHMoe Ka)uoro HaKonHHTeiS1 CB5l3blBalOT LtersAMH.PaCKp,KeBO'Hbie MeTKH BAOJlb XJIbICTa CTaBSTCS CnleL7HJabHO 06y'eHHbIM nlepCOHaJlOM, HOHa COBpeMeHHbIX MeXaHH3HPOBaHHbIX HHUKHHX cKiiaAax Am 9TOrO HCHOJIb3ylOT KOMrIblOTepbl,KpOMe TOro, KOMflblOTepbl HCrIOJb3ylOTCA 3AeCb B ueLAHx onTHMI43aUHH H BeaeHH51 yqeTa. B6opea.nbHbIX .necax, rAe AepeBbA He6oJIbwUe, pa3Mepbi 6peBeH OTHOCHTTebHo .nerKo MO)HOH3MepHTb, COPTHPOBKa 6peBeH no KaqeCTBY Mo)KeT npOH3BOAHTbCq KBanudHU4HpOBaHHbIMHcneLHUaJHCTaMH Ha MeCTe BanIKH neca. npH py6Kax yxoaa 3arOTaBAHBaloT OTHOCHTenjbHOMajiOMepHbIe gepeBbH, TO )Ke camoe OTHOCHTC5 H K py6KaM ipOMe)KyTOqHOrO nOJIb3OBaHHq, aInOCKOJIbKy LteHHOCTb npeACTaBJiHeT TOJIbKO KOMJeBaA tiaCTb 6peBeH, paCKp$DXeBKY MO)KHOnpOBOAUTb B niecy, H Tor1a MOXHO HCnIOJb3OBaTb COpTHMeHTHblrH MeTOA 3arOTOBKH CnOMOLUblO 4OpBapaepOB.

Page 234: Russian - World Bank Documents

230 HPHJIOKEHIE f

B CH6UpH H4 Ha AaAbHeM BocToKe nOTepHl ApeBeCHHbi npH 3arOTOBKe neca

o6br4HO oMeHb BeJIHKH. 3To SBBJI3eTCS, BO-nlepBbiX, npqMbiM pe3yJlbTaToM HCOJIlb30BaHH5I

TADKeJ1OA Ba)OlqHOj H TpeJieBOt4HO TeXHHKH, KOTOPYIO HeB03MO HO HCnoJib30BaTb AAS

3ar'OTOBKH Aeca Bbi6opOMHbIMH HJIH 3KOAOrH4eCKH 6e3onaCHblMH MeTOaaMH, H, BO-BTOpblX,

CAieACTBHeM npHMCHeHHSH MeTOaa 3arOTOBKH H BbIB03KH XJbICTaMH, nlpHBonRUerO K

coKpaiueHHlO Ko0HJ4eCTBa KpyrJIoro neca AAS npoLa)KH y HenOcpeAcTBeHHO y MeCTa

norpy3KH. XOTSI o0UuHaJlbHbie CTaTHCTHMeCKHe AaHHbie o6 3TOM OTCYTCTByIOT, oueHKH

o6LutX o6'eMOB py6KH H n1OTepb ApeBeCHHbl npH 3aroTOBKe iieca B 1980-x ro1ax yKa3bIBafOT

Ta6nrnia F.1: C0beMIb py6KH H InoTePH ApeBeCHHbi B xoAe fleCo3arOTOBHTeJIbHhix pa6oT B

6blIIBIeM COBeTCKOM CoIO3e B 1980-x roArax

KaTcmppmJ 06weM

MAN. KA!. M aOJfl.B X

06ua y6bUb ApeeeCHHhI H3 775 100npOAlHpyiOluWx nIecoBCnrOWUHble py6KH 329 42

Py6KH yxoAa 16 2

CaHUTapHble py6KH 43 6

Py6KU B ueniux CTPOHTeAbCTBa aopor H T.n. 24 3

061tH O6beM pY60OK 412 53

nlorepu npui 3aroToBKe neca 50D 7

nloTepH B cBq3ti C niecHblMui no)KapaMH6 50 7

florrepH B pe3yJ1bTaTe 6one3HeA U oTnaaa 263 34

06u1ite norepu 363 47

a Heo4mutUanbHble HCTOqHHKH JaHHb]X oueHHBalOT nOrepU npH 3arOToBKe neca B 175 MJIH. Ky6. M

6 cKiioqasi norepu OT leCHbX InO)KaPOB B COMKHYTblX Aecax.

4CTOMMMK: 4)eaepajbHaql cAy)K6a AecHoro XO3sltCTBa Poccuu

Ta6.nKIla F.2: 06,beMbl flpOH3BOACTBa AeCOllpOMilmuieHHOtI npOAyKlHIt B POCCHH,

1980-95

BKq nlpoIJL(H FA}NHEiW bBIUBMH PO.C_I 3MepeHhWq CCCP 1988 r.

190 1988 199 1991 1992 1993 199 1995

£apeBecHHa MJIH M3 389 328 354 304 269 238 175 119 115

liunoMaTepuajIbl MJIH. M3 103 80 84 75 66 53 41 31 27

aPaHepa MAH. M3 2.3 1.5 1.7 1.6 1.5 1.3 1.0 0.9 0.9

1cn MutH. M3 8.1 3.5 5.5 5.6 5.4 4.5 3.9 2.6 2.2

ABn MntH. M3 2.1 H.ja. I.6a H.A. 1 .5 H.A. H.n. 0.8 0.7

TlpeBecHaSl macca MnIH. T. 10.9 H.A. 10.46 H.a. 8.4 H.A. H.A. 4.2 5.4

UeIlJio.no3a MnlH. T. H.a. 6.8 H.A. 7.5 6.4 5.7 4.4 3.3 4.2

Bymara MJIH. T. 6.3 4.5 5.3 5.2 4.8 3.6 2.9 2.2 2.8

KapToH MnJIH. T. 4.5 2.5 3.2 3.1 2.6 2.2 1.6 1.2 1.3

Ha. - HeT AaHHbIXa nepeBo,a U3 KB. M B Ky6. M, HCXOfag H3 cpeAwHer TOnJltHHbi, paBHori 3,2 MM.

6 BKuniotasu 2,1 MJIH. TOHH aeepU6pUpoBaHHoA jipeBeCHOA macCbl.

UcCTOqHUK: rOCyaapCTBeHHblA KOMHTeT PO no CTaTHCTHKe.

Page 235: Russian - World Bank Documents

231 HPHAO)KEHHE F

Ha TO, MTO Ha JIeCOCe1 IHbIX rnJOLUaI4AX B cpeAHeM OCTaeTcSi no 10-15% o6fteManpoMbIwjJeHHOrO rPOH3BOACTBa apeBecHHbl (B FIpHMOPCKOM Kpae 3TOT noKa3aTeqb, HooueHKaM, aoXoaHfi ao 50%). B uienoM Ka)abIi roA TepeHTCAl FIOqTH nO3OBHHanOTeHuHanjbHoro o6beMa 3arOTOBKH pecypca (Ta6nHiua FA). nocKOAbKy B rocAeaHHe roabillpOH30JIO CHH)KeHHe 06'beMOB JieCO3arOTOBKH, 9TH nOTepH TO)Ke COKpaTHAHCb, nO KpaUHeUMepe, B HOKa3aTeiJ5ix bH3HqMeCKoro o06eMa. .lorHqeCKHri BbIBOA 3aKuuo4aeTcq B TOM, qTOHcnOJIb3YeMbIe cerOAHA nOAXOAbI H MeToablyrpaBjieHHA ieCO3aroToBHTenbHoA neTeJbHOCTHBeAYT K 3aHH)KeHHIo ueHHOCTH pecypca H 'pe3MepHbIM noTepsM.

,4CpeBoHepCpa6oTKa H c6dw npo,VyKfH

B 1988 rogy oRSA neconpoMbiwjieHHOH npOaYKUL44 B o6LLeM o61eMenpoMbiLJIeHHOro npoH3BOaCTBa cocTaBaJIla 5%, a 'HCJIeHHOCTb pa6OTalowuHX B JleCHOMKoMnnIeKce - 7% OT o6ieie IHCJieHHOCTH pa6OTaiOlIHX B IPOMbILwjeHHOCTH - TaKOB 6buiBKnIaA JieconpoMblwineHHOrO KoMrineKca B 3KOHOMHKy 6blBnero CoBeTCKoro C0o13a,OCHOBHylo qaCTb KOTOporO BHOCHJ1a Ta TeppHTOpHq, KOTOpaI ceriuac IBJSIeTCq POCCHUCKOU41egepauLHeh. OAHaKo, o6beM npOH3BORCTBa J1econpoMblwneHHOu HpOayKIuHH c 1988 rogacoKpaTHJCH, a C 1992 roaa 3TO coKpaiieHHe npHo6peJo o,4eHb pe3KHi xapaKTep (CM.Ta6.nHLy [.2).

B nepHog c 1990 no 1993 rog o6fteMbi CTpOHTeJlbHbIX pa6OT COKpaTHJIHCb Ha 43%,a o6fteMb1 CTPOHTeJlbCTBa HOBOrO )KHJIbS - Ha 32%5. YpoBeHb noTpe6JIeHHS 6yMarH CHH3H4CICgo 14 Kr Ha qeJIOBeKa, 3TO - O,HlHH H3 caMbIX HH3KUX noKa3aTejiek noTpe6neHHs B pa3BHTb1XcTpaHax MHpa. IIHBeCTHpOBaHHe B CeKTOp COKpaTHJIOCb Ha 87%, YpOBeHb 3aHATOCTH BrIpoH3BOACTBe HOHH3HJICS Ha 25%, a o61eM nPOH3BOaCTBa Ha oaHoro pa6OTaiowero - Ha48%. BOJIbLHHHCTBO H3 3025 o(3uHuHaJIbHO 3aperHcTpHpoBaHHbX iieconpOMblwieHHbIXnpearipHAsTHI, oco6eHHo rpeAnpHSTHq C BbICOK03aTpaTHOA CTpyKTypok H YCTapeB1HHMo6OpynoBaHHeM (HanpHMep, uejnlOJIo3HO-6yMaKHble npearIpHHTHIq), qBSAlOTCqHenJIaTe)Kecnoco6HbIMH.

Bce 6oAbue orpaHuH4BaeTC 3KCnOPT Kpyrnioro nieca H nHJIOMaTepHajiOB, eroo6'beMbl no cpaBHeHH1O C npeCbIIyui4HMH ypOBHAMH COKpaTHJIHCb Ha 20%. npaBHTeCJbCTBOHaMepeHO 3aMeHHTb 3TH CTaTbH 9KCriOpTa npOayKTaMH r1iy6OKOA nlepepa6OTKH, Co3gaiOLterl£ao6aBAeHHylO CTOHMOCTb. 14 XOTA OTMaCTH COKpaLueHHe o6beMOB 3KCHOpTa CB5I3aHO CCOOTBeTCTBYIOWUHM HarpaBjieHHeM rOCygapCTBeHHOU nOJHTHKT4, OHO TaKwe B 3HaqHTeJIbHOAmepe 06'bACHqeTCS CTpeMHTeJlbHbIM POCTOM TpaHCIIOpTHbIX paCXOaOB H apyrHMH BTHqHHSMHMlnepexoga K PbIHO4HOH 3KOHOMHKe. B HaCTOALLee BpeMS 3KOHOMHCeCKH onpaBgaHHOHRBJIAeTC5I TOJlbKO TpaHCrOPTHpOBKa Ha paCCTOSHHS, He rIpeBblwalOlUHe llpHMepHO 1.000 KM -gjis3 Kpyrnioro neca H 2.500 KM - Agfl nHHJOMaTepHaJIOB, a paCCTOMHH5I OT MHOFHX CblpbeBbIX6a3 Ao 6H1Kar4wero MOpCKOrO nOpTa npeBbIealOT 5.000 KM.

,aepeBonepepa6aTbIBaiowue npeanpHATHA HMmelOT rinoxoe o6opyRoBaHHe, H BbIXO'arlpOgYKUHH 3aeCb HaMHOrO HHxe, 'eM B CTpaHaX CeBepHOI U4 3anagHOA EBpOIbI Cnogao6HbiMH rlHUpOaHbIMH peCypCaMH. Bblxoa rpORYKUlHH MOKHO 6blIo 6bl 3HaqHTeJlbHOInOBbICHTb C r1OMOLflbIO BHeApeHHS COBpeMeHHbIX TeXHOJOHrm H MCTOAOB ylipaBweHHA.

5 B POCCHfH cpewHHI xiJmag FLOua,ab cocTaliJReT OKOJIO 18 KB. MCTPOB Ha qCelOBeKa, B TO BPCMR K8K BEspoiC - 30-35 KB M., a B CLUA - 50 KB M.

Page 236: Russian - World Bank Documents

232 1PKPHO)KEHHEr

He,aaBHo BBeLeHHoe B CTpOU aepeBoo6pa6aTbIBaioLuee npeHg,npATHue B fipaTcKe,

KOTOpOC 4 HHaHCHpyeTCS ripaBBTeJIbCTBOM FepMaHHuu, npeAHa3HaaeHo wisin nepepa6oTKH

MajiOMepHOU apeBeC4HbI C nOMOHUblO COBpeMeHHOU TeXHOJIOII4H npoH4ntIpOBsaHH5 6pyca U43

6peBeH C OLHOBpeMeHHbiM rojnyqeHKeM luenbI, KOTOpa flnO3BOfl5eT nepepa6aTblBaTb TOHKHe

6peBHa x4aMeTpoM OT 8 ao 18 CM.6 Ha 3TOM npear[PHATHH MO)KHO B Ka4eCTBe CbipbA

iCflOJib3OBaTb apeBeCHHy OT py6oK yxoaa H caHHTapHbIX py6OK, KOTOpa5 paHbwe npOCTO

nponaaana H3-3a OTCYTCTBHR COOTBeTCTByIOLUHX TeXHojioruHeCKHX Bo3Mo)KHocTerl H

He3aHHTepeCOBaHHOCTH B 3TOM, o6ycjioBeHHor HCKa)KeHHO4 CTpyKTypOU LIeH.

KpynHer4wj4A B PoccHH EpaTCKHu JIeCOnpOMbIwmAeHHblr4 KOMnHieKC nOJ1yqu4JT BO3MO)KHOCTb

peHHBeCTHPOBaTb CBOU 3KcnOPTHbie aOXOabI. OH nOJIYqHJI 3aeM B pa3mepe 10 MJIpa. py6neu

Ha MOaePHH3amLHIO cBoero 060pyaOBaH4H C ueLJblO Haiia)HBaHuI, npOH3BOaCTBa npOaYKTOB

6o0nee BbICOKOrO Ka'eCTBa no KOHKypeHToCnoCo6Hou LeHe. Ho TaKHCe yJyMUweHHS MOrYT B

3HaMKTeJbHOH Mepe nOTePSTb CBOIO ueHHOCTb H3-3a npo6AeM C nocTaBKaMH Cblpbs.

[UejuHonJo3Ho-6yMawKHal npoMbIlwIeHHOCTb U apyrHe 6bICTpopacTylue

npOK3BoLaCTBa OCHOBHblX npOayKTOB KOHe'HOro nOJnb3OBaHH5 cKopee Bcero 6yAyT oKa3blBaTb

CHJIbHOe BJIHS1HHe Ha pa3BHTHe npOH3BORCTBa H nepepa6oTKH CblpbA B 1eCOnpOMbIUlwJeHHOM

KoMnreKce. C POCTOM o6WecTBeHHoro cnpoca Ha ra3eTbl K KHHrK, H3aaTeAbCTBsa K tapyrHe

npOMbbIwHIeHHbIe noTpe6KTeCJI 6yMarH 6yayT Tpe6oBaTb 6yMary COOTBeTCTByilolero KaleCTBa

H nO KoHKypeHTOcHoco6HbIM UeHaM. KpoMe Toro. C pOCTOM o6lbeMoB npOH3BOaCTBa

HoTpe6KTeIbCKKx TOBapOB 6yaeT paCTH CnpOC Ha ynaKOBO 1IHyIO H KapTOHHYIO npOayKUHIO.

9TH BHT4bl nepepa6aTblMaIouxer npoMbIUJIeHHOCTH, cKopee BCero, TaayT HauHyJ uHe

B03MO)KHOCT4 A1J51 BjiO)KeHHR CpeaCTB oTeHieCTBeHHbIx H 3apy6e)KHbIx HHBeCTOpOB B

COBMeCTHbie npeAnpHATHA B 6mHxagweM 6yayweM.

B BSorylaHax IKEA HHBeCTHPOBsana CBOU cpeRCTBa B JieconJUbHoe npeHanpHSTHe,

KOTOpOC MO)KeT BbinyCKaTb apeBeCHbIe KJieeHHbie naHeiiH 143 MaCCHBHOh apeBeCHHbl,

HCrIOJb3yeMbIe ,AnR npoH3BoACTBa BbICoKoKa4eCTBeHHor4 Me6enK Ha 3anaH HoeBpOneHcKHx

Me6eJbHbIx 4a6pHKax KoMnaHIH IKEA.7 CyaA no ycnexam CoBMeCTHoro c IKEA

Me6eJIbHoro npeaCXplHTHAS B HIOJIbwe, B POCCHH TO)Ke eCTb nOTeHLIHaBJbHbie B03MO)KHOCT4

AlAA co3RaHHA aHaJorWmHOH npoH3BOACTBeHHoH MOUJHOCTH, OCHOBaHHOU Ha ao6aBneHHo0

CTOHMOCTU.

ELue OaHHM HeCaaBHHM pHM4epoM COBMeCTHOFO 4KHaHCHpOBaHHur npearpiSpTHiu

IBJIAeTC5I HHBeCTHpOBaHHe B UaJiaXHHHCKm9 6yMaKHbIi KOM6HHaT (AO "Bonra", r. BanaxHa

HH)Keropo,acKo0 o6nIaCTH), aKLIUOHepaMH KOTOporo IBJDl1OTCq KOMnaH-H Herlitz

International Trading (HIT) AG/Miinchen8 , MeXyHapoaHas q)u4HaHCOBaA KopnopauHA

6 C Llefbfo IIpOl3BOaCTBa MaTqpIIOJJOB AZ7 CTpOHTeAbCTBa )KKIIbH 4AR BOeHHOcAY)cKaLUHX COBCTCKOa

ApMHH, Bo3BpalaIoLUHxcR Ci3 BOCTOYHOU FepMaaHnfH, 3aeCb BbiflyCKaIOTC A/peBeCHbMC 17ATbl C MaCCHBHbIMH

fIpHKAeeHHbiMH KpoMKaMlf, KOTOpble lC0ob3yIOT, KaK 1707y/Ji6p KaTbI HTOB Hni HaCT11na nOnOB, KpOMC TOro,

nocTpoeHbLi i apyrfe aepeBof7epepa6aTbiBaIoLL(X flpeIZHpHRTHH: B CoKo,7e BoioroacKoIf o6acWTH (npoH3Baacrlo

OKOH) If B MagKojie KpacHoaapcKoro KpaR (,7pOU3BOiCTB0O ABepCIV.

7 I7epBoHavanbHoe KaflTamoBuio)eHKe B pa3Mepe 10 MnJH. $ CLUA, C4aenHHOe KoMnaHHmc IKEA, 11o Bceg

BepoMTHocTH, yBeCJiKYHioCb 40, KaK MmHHMyM, 30 MAH. $ CIUA B CBq3H C Cepbe3HblMlf tiHIHaHCOBblMH H

yn7paBlieHYeCKHfMH npO6iieMaMH pOCCH1lCKOO flapTMepa, 3TO qpe3Bb1qafiHo BbiCOKIf ypoBeHb

KaT7H7aJoB7o0KoeHi#i, 110 CpaBHHeHlfo C apyrfMH ifHBuecTlfuHMMf KoMfiaHuH IKEA. O704o6Hble HHBCCTHuLIfH 3a

py6exoM IKEA 06blYHO Q5HaHCfpyeT Yepe3 CBOIO ao0epHloHo 10fpMy SWEEDWOOD INTERNATIONAL

(LUlBCWBH,q), a SWEEDWOOD QpffB03HT CBOif flepcoHaA aiiM oKa3aHIH J0MOMOLU B ynpasBneHHHM IfHoCTpaHHOR

YaCTbIO j7peCalpIMTfff.8 HIT Baq7feTcT ToproBow KoMaaHHefi, cf7euHaJiH3fpyi0LUe#cfC Ha Ue,7Alion3HO-6yMaKHOHf HpO4lYKLiHf,

OHa npifH8aAieKHT KoHLepHy HERLITZ AC/Berlin. B 1993 if 1994 roaax HIT npoaaaa 300.000 MeTpHf!ecKfx

Page 237: Russian - World Bank Documents

233 rIPHIO)KEHHE r

(MOK) H apyrHe HHBecTopbI, a TaK)Ke TpyAOBOH KojijneKTHB npeanpH4ITHSI. Ilpe3H4IeHTOM3TOrO COBMeCTHOrO npearlpHITHI ABjiqeTCS KOMMep4eCKHh atHpeKTOP H3 KOMiafHHU HIT, aAupeKTopa nO 4bHHaHCaM H MapKeTHHry iMmeOT OnbIT pa6OTbl B apyrI4X Me)KAyHapOtaHblx'qaCTHbIX 4HpMax. B 1994 rogy o6w4rni of6eM HpOH3BOACTBa COCTaBHJi 270.000 TOHH. OKOJIO60% nporHO3HpyeMoro o6teMa npOH3BoacTBa, KOTOpblH4 paBeH 520.000 TOHH, 6yaeTOTnpaBIATbCST Ha 3KcrTopT, a OCTaWbHas 4aCTb HPoAYKLuWH 6yaeT ripoaaBaTbCA HapOCCHUCKOM pblHKe. 9 1lHTepeCHbiM aCneKTOM pa6oTbl 3TOrO npealrpHSATHR qBjI1eTCq TO, iTOOHO CaMO o6ecrle4HBaeT ce6fl CblpbeM, B TOM qHCJIe Ha OCHOBe HIpqMbIX AOrOBOpOB COpraHamH ynpaBjieHH5 nCcHbIM X03AHCTBOM HmHxeFOpOaCKOA o6JiaCTH. Cy6rioLpaqlHKaMH,JAIH npOBeaeHH4 JieCO3arOTOBHTeIbHbIX pa6OT ABRSHOTCH HHOCTpaHHbie cUlpMbl, HO MCCTHblU11eCX03 riiaHHpyeT HpHo6pecTH COBpeMeHHOe o6opyaoBaHHe, KOTOpOe HO3BOJIHT COKpaTHTbnpOH3BOACTBeHHbie 3aTpaTbl, H B35ITb 3Ty pa60Ty Ha ce6H. no cpaBHeHHIo c 3anaAoHOEBponorl, 3fleCb HaMHOrO HH)Ke CTOHMOCTb pa6o0eg CHJIbl, 3HepreTWCeCKHX H BOAHbIXpecypcoB. Hocnie 3aMeHbl CTapblX 6yMaro[e.jaTeJbHbIx MawllHH pe3KO COKpaTqTCq XHMHUeCKHeBbI6pOCbI.

MCX8HH'ICCJMff fepcpa6oTKa ,apeBCCJHM

HHi4OMaTepHaJIbl, 4aHepa, apeBeCHOCTpy)Ke4Hble H apeBeCHOBOJIOKHHCTbie lJIHTbI,B HeKOTOpOH CTeHeH4, CJIy)KaT 3aMeHHTCJ1e5MH apyr apyra B pa3JIHqHbIX BHmaX KOHe4HOrOnoJlb3OBaHHA. YCHJTeHHe ae4UHUHTa CbIpb3i £iA HpOH3BOaCTBa 4jaHepbl H HIPOaYKTOBJieCOnHJieHHA HpHBOaHT K POCTY ueH Ha apeBeCHHy, ITO B CBOiO OxIepeAb CTHMyJIHpyeTyBeJIqeHi4e o6'beMOB rpOH3BORCTBa peKOHCTpyHpOBaHHblX apeBeCHbUX nPOaYKTOB.OCHOBHbIM KOHe'4HbiM HOTpe6HTeJieM 3THX HpORyKTOB ABJWIOTCA CTpOHTelbHblenpe,alpHA4THS3. IHJIOBO'HbIe MaTepHanbi H apeBeCHbie HJIHTbl HCHOJlb3ylOT B.LepeBOo6pa6aTblBaiO llueH npOMbbiwjeHHOCTH H MawHHHOCTpOeHHH. B ynaKOBOqHOMnpOH3BOACTBe Tpe6ylOTCA, B OCHOBHOM, TapHblti KaPTOH H nHHJoMaTepHanbi, a B Me6eibHOAnpOMbbiwjeHHOCTH - 4aHepa, acn H pa3JTHMHbiC BHRbA ,peBeCHbIX rIIHT.

B 6blBeM COBeTCKOM C0103e nepBH-IHas aepeBoo6pa6OTKa npoH3BoaHjiaCb HaJieconHHJbHbIX 3aBoAax c nOMOLLIbJO nJIHHHH paMHbIX IHJI pOCCHICKoro npoH3BOaCTBa. Ha3THX 3aBOLaX He 6bUlJO HH KpyrJIOIlHJIbHbIX o6pe3HblX CTaHKOB, HH CYW1HJ1bHOrOo6opyAOBaHHI. HOqTH BCe HHJIOMaTep4HaJbl OTripaBJIHjiCb B CbIPOM HJIH HCaOCyweHHOMCOCTOAHHH, B He paCCOPTHPOBaHHOM H He CTpOraHHOM BHae. CuieUHaribHaq o6pa6OTKaflpOBOIRHiaJCb TOJTbKO Ha CneUHaSJbHbIX 3KCnOpTHbIX JieconHHjbHbIX rpe'arpH5ITHHx. 3TapyaHMeHTapHai TeXHoJioruH y)Ke yCTapeJla, a nepBH'Hbie nepepa6OT4HKH(neco3aroToBHTenH) 4)aKTHtleCKH cy6cHi,4HpyloT KOHe4HbIX nepepa6oTq4HKOB 3a c4eT nOCTaBOKHM CbIpbq Ho ueHaM HH)Ke pbIHOHHbIX. 4To6bl COXpaHHTb CBOe MeCTO Ha 3TOM pbIHKe, 3THllpe,aInpH.qTHI4 6yayT BbIHyxKLeHbl nepeXOalHTb K rJIy6OKOH nlepepa6OTKe, pa3MeLeHHOk 6JIHKeK MeCTaM nepBHqHOri nepepa6OTKH CblpbI.

TOHH 6yMar,t Ha cyMMy OKOJIO 120 MRH. aomAYapoB CLUlA. B pC3yJbTBC l7eperoBopoB OHIH F7poAq7fqH CBoH n7paBaHa ToproB//Ko Tofi f7pO,yK1IHeg Ha cawylJJoHife LiJecTb RUT, YTo CooTBeTCTByeT o6zemy f7po2a)K, paBHOMy 2,7 MJIH.Me7pm;reCKHX TOHH f1pH cpe2HeCi IeHe 560 ao. wapoa ClIUA 3a oaHy MCeTplf eCKyIO TOHHy9 B HacTOamee BpeMZ B AO "Bo.ma" pa6oTaeT 4.800 qejioBcK, KOTOPbIC HPOH3BOW1RT 6o0Ree 500.000 TOHHr1-3CTHo. 6yMarH B FOa. B KoHic 1994 rowa 6bl.la BBcWeHa B 3Kc1J7J7yarTaLto 6yMaro/eJ'aTewbHaf MaliIHHa No 9,oHa RBJJeTcH Oa1HOI 113 CaMbfX Kpyi7HblX Hf COBpCMeHHbiX 6yMaro/zeRaTeybHbix MaILuH B Mfpe.

Page 238: Russian - World Bank Documents

234 HPHJ]O)KEHHE F

3a 1994 roa npoH30UJmo He6oJIbmoe yBeCJ44eHHe B HCnIOJb3oBaHHl

npOH3BO,JCTBeHHOA MOIIXHOCTH npeanpH39TH, BbInYCKaioluHx V,CI, ue1j1flOIO3Y H 6yMary;

o61cmbi npOH3BO,aCTBa ,LLpeBeCHOrO Cblpbfl H nuJoMoaTePHanjoB coKpaTnJIHcb, a 43aHepbi, a)BH

H KaPTOHa OCTaJIHCb nO'TH npe)KHHMH (Ta6mHUa r.3). CTeneHb HCHOAb3OBaHHq

npOH3BOXACTBeHHbIX MOU.tHOCTeU COCTaBJiSUIa OT 36% B npOH3BO,RCTBe KaPTOHa (caMafl

HH3KaSI) ao 58% B nppOH3BO,LCTBe llpeBeCHoro CbIpbfl (caMa5I Bb1coKafl). B 1995 H AaiKe B 1996

ro,ay CTeneHb HCnOJlb30BaHH5i npoH3BOaICTBeHHbIX MOLWHOCTeIi B JieconpoMbILIJIleHHOM

KoMnJIeKce OCTaBaIiacb HH3KOR. Ee CHH)KeHHe npo43OU1IJO BMeCTe c naaeHHeM cnpoca Ha

nlpO,lyKTbi KOHeMHOrO HOTpe6JleHH5I H CoKpaLueHHeM nOCTaBOK Cblpbfl H

,apyrHx Heo6xo.uHMbIx qaKTOPOB npOH3BoaCTBa. FOMHMO HenoJlHoro HcnOAb3OBaHHu

Ta6JIHua r.3: Hcnonib3oBaHHe IIPOH3BOACTBeHHbIX MOlHOCTeA JiecoHpoMbblIIIeHHOrIO

KoMniieKca POCCuH, 1994 ro,

Kpyr'miA nec fniwoma- (PHepa aCf7 aB41 L(awio- Eywama KapH

(KW. MI) Trpma,mI (AnH. lf) (MAUH M3) (MMi. At) JosW (MIHi. T) (MInH. T)

(M/7H. Mf3) (MnfH. T)

YcTaHoaneHHbIeMOUHOCTU

I %iHBapq 1994 r. 205,7 56,3 1,76 6,11 0,48 8,66 6,01 3,40

I nHBapn 1995 r. 184,0 52,5 1,76 6,25 0,48 8,78 6,17 3,40

061beM 118,9 30,7 0,89 2,63 0,23 3,33 2,38 1,22

npOH3BOaCTRa

CTeneHb 58 55 51 43 48 39 40 36

YcI1oJT3obaHH51

MOI.UHOCTI (%)a

a 061beM npOH3BOaCTBa, Re.neHHbIli Ha MOULHOCTb Ha I S1HBapSi 1994 roAa H yMHo)KeHHb[i4 Ha 100.

HCTO4HHK: roCyaapCTBeHHblA KOMHTeT P(D no CTaTHcTMKe.

HPOH3BORCTBeHHbIX MOWHoCTeU, CyLueCTBY1OUHe npeAnPH5TH51 HCHOAb3ylOT He o4eHb

COBpeMeHHoe H 394eKTHBHoe o6opyaoBaHme.

J!pOH3BO,4CTBO ,apeBeCHbX IfVIT

ToJIbKo OKOJIO 14% o6uwero o6beMa npOH3BOACTBa faHepbi nocTynaeT U3 CH6upu

H c )IanbHero BocToKa. B nocjieaH4e 20 nieT o6teMbi HPOH3BOaCTBa 4aHepbI yBeJimHsBaACb

ropa3ao MemxneHHee, 4eM o6'beMbl BbInycKa npOYKLUHH ApyrHX oTpacneu

,aepeBonepepa6oTKH, TaKHX KaK npOH3BOLCTBO apeBeCHOCTpyXeeMHbIX H

ApeBeCHOBOJIOKHHCTbIX nIJIHT. Ho POCCHACKHie npernpHsTHAI no nPOH3BOaCTBy ()aHepbl

Bcer,aa 6bmu CHJIbHbIMt KOHKypeHTaMH Ha Me)KAyHapOaHOM pbIHKe, H HeCMOTpq Ha 40-

npoueHTHoe coKpaLUeHHe o6ibeMoB npOH3BoaCTBa, KOTopoe npOH30uJmO B nepH,oL c 1985 no

1993 ro,g, o6'eMbl 3KCnOpTa 4aHepbI yBeJIHuHJ1HCb Ha 100%. Ha 3KCllOpT HXIyT, B OCHOBHOM,

CTaHA,aPTHble COpTa qaHepbl, KOTOpb1e npoaaloTCA nO HU3KUM LueHaM. OCHOBHbIMH

TeH,ALeHIU5H,M4 pa3BHTH51 3TOU OTpaCJIH 5fBJISIOTC51: BbinyCK JIHCTOB (j)aHepbl 6OJlblUoro

pa3mepa H yBejmqeHHe B npOP3BOJtCTBe 43aHepbl aOJ14 XBOUHOrO Cblpbf.

Ha aojno Poccuu nptiXoa4AoCb 68% o6ufero o6fteMa nPO43BoflCTBa

,apeBeCHoCTpy)Ke4HbIX nIJIKT B 6bIeuIeM COBeTCKOM C0103e. FIOCKOJIbKy npot3BORCTBO

Page 239: Russian - World Bank Documents

235 HPHJIO)KEHHEr

lapeBeCHocTpy2KeqHbIX nJIHT 6bU1o BbICOKOnpHOpHTeTHOU OTpaCJIb1O JIeCHoriHpOMbIUIJieHHOCTH, B nepHoa C 1986 no 1990 ro, Ha 3aBOaax, BblnlyCKalou.UHx aCn, no BcericTpaHe 6buio yCTaHOBJAeHO nOBOJIbHO COBpeMeHHoe 3anagHoe o 6 opyA0BaHtie, XOTR Hanepepa6aTb[BaioLuHx ripeanpHSATHAx 0o CHX nop HCrIOJb3yloT yCTapeBwjee o6 OpytaOBaHHe aIAJIyLUeHHA H CTpOraHHs. HPOH3BOACTBO apeBeCHOcTpyxKeqHbIX nHAT nocTpaaa)1oHecoH3MepHMo MeHbwUe, 'eM ApyrHe aepeBoriepepa6aTb1BaioLLtHe oTpaciIH, OT4aCTH nOTOMy,'TO y Hero Bceraa 6buO cblpbe. HaH6onee pacnpocTpaHeHHbIM ABJAeTcS npOH3BOaCTBOApeBeCHocTpy)Ke'1Hbix ruIHT c ao6aBJIeHHeM ueMeHTa, HO B 6AW)KaUiweM 6 yayweMnnaHHpyeTCsl HaBaTb BbIlnYCK apeBeCHocTpyxceqHbIX rIHT cneLCuHaJbHorO Ha3Ha4eHHS AASHCHOJIb3OBaHHS B CTpOHTeCbcTBe (AAsA KPOBeCJbHbIx pa6oT H HecyLLIHX CTeH). B 1995 roay3KCHOpTHpoBanoCb OKOJIo 8% o6iuero o6beMa npOH3BOaCTBa, rJIaBHbIM o6pa3oM, 6 blBUHMTOprOBbIM napTHepaM no COBeTCKOMy 6.noKy H BO (DpaHLIH1o.

IkeffJo/lo3Ho-6yua4H,JWe KONM6MHH

B nep4oa pacnaga 6blBeLero CoBeTcKoro Com3a uCeniulOAO3Ho-6yMa)KHaqrpOMbmbiwIeHHOCTb HClblTbIBaJia cepbe3HbIe TpyRHOCTH. 65% ee TeXHHKH H o6 opyAoBaHHs6buio CTapbIM H CHUbHO H3HOweHHbIM. HpeanpHATHS oTpacJiH npq4HHAJH O4eHb 60jbWOSBpeC, oKpyxKaiouLef cpeae, 6 oJIbLUHHCTBO CyAbcIbHT-Luennjnioo3HbIx 3aBoRoB 6b1nO BblHyxIAeHO3aKpblTbCsI HAu 3Ha'HTenbHo CHH3HTb YpOBHH FTpOH3BOACTBa. B nociieaHHe HecKoAbKO AeTo6beMbI poccHucKoro npoH3BoACTBa UeAijilo3bl coKpaTHuHcb Ha 50%, XOTA AoAS 3TOUHlpO,yKUHH B 3KCIOpTe rIO'TH yZABOHJiaCb, 'ITO rOBOpilT O 6OJIbIOM rioTeHLHaJAe 3TOUOTpacHIU B 6 yayieM (3TOT 6yM ripoH3oLeJI B pe3yJIbTaTe Y,4BoeHHR MHpOBbIX geH).CJeIaCTBHeM 3KOHOMH4eCKOrO cnaga H KHHJIlAUHH B cTpaHe CTajiO CHH)KeHHe BHyTpeHHerocnpoca Ha 6yMa)KHyIo npoayKLuHio 6onee, '1eM Ha 55% B 1995 roay.

OKOJIO 40% UeCJIJIIOAO3HOUl npO2yKUUH - 3TO TOBapHaA ueAJAlOJA03a, KOTopaA HeHCnOJIb3YeTCS B npoueccax rIpoM3BO,CTBa 6yMarH H KapTOHa. EOAbWHHCTBO 3aBo,aoB,BbInyCKaIOIUHX TOBapHylO ueCJ0Jo0o3y, HaXOnMTCS B OT2aaeHHbIX paIiOHax BOCTO'HOUCH6HpH H JaajbHero BocToKa, OTHOCHTejibHO 6 JIH3KO K 3KCnopTHbIM pbIHKaM,rpeAnAara1oLLoHM 3aMaHqHBbIe ueHbl. flpOHCXO,4HT MeLVeHHoe yBeCAH'eHHe cpeaHHX pa3MepoBLteJIIoJlo3Hblx 3aBoAoB. B TO BpeMA, KaK 06'beM npOH3BOaCTBa OaHOrO 3oeKTHBHoroCOBpeMeHHoro 3aBoAa COCTaBJIHeT MHHHMyM 500.000 TOHH B ro,a, B POCCuu B 1990 ro,ycpeAHHu ueAiAOon3HbIH4 3aBOA BbInyCTHJn 130.000 TOHH 3a roa. B PoccHH Maao ueAJIlOAo3HbIx3aBOAoB 6OnbWOri MOlllHOCTH. POCCHI Bcer,a 6bmAa AHaepoM B npoH3BoACTBe paCTBOpHMOrueCAiOJIo3bl, HCroAb3yeMor4 B HpOH3BOACTBe HCKYCCTBeHHOU wepCTH (280.000 TOHH),BHCKo3Horo weIClKa (78.000 TOHH) H aUeTaTHbIX BOJTOKOH (300.000 TOHH) WIM KOp,4OB Kojiec,LLejijio4aHoBbIx H nHIaCTHKOBbIX MaTepHaJIoB H oCo6blX BHAOB 6yMarH. Ho c 1990 ronaHpOH3BOACTBO paCTBOpHMOtU LeTiloI0o3bl 3Ha'HTeCAbHO COKpaTHAOCb.

Haworoo6ffo.WeHmC IlJ7PCnpMzTI leConPOMMYA'eHHoM KOMnnIKca

HanoroBoe 6peMs IieconpoMbiwiAeHHoro KoMnAeKca POCCHu C4HTaeTCA OLHHM H3caMbIx cepbe3HbIx npenATCTBHt Ha nyTH K BOccTaHOBEneHHIO o6beMOB rpOH3BOaCTBa UpeHTa6eCbHOCTH. To )Ke caMoe OTHOCHTCA H K ApyrHM KOMMep4eCKHM npeanpHRTHsM.HanloroBoe 3aKoHoAaTeAbCTBo oTHii4aeTcTC 6 oAbwor CJO)KHOCTbIO H nHoXoir,aOKyMeHTHPOBaHHOCTbIO. Pa3bqCHHTeCAbHbie aOKyMeHTbi, co,aepKaLuHe noApo6Hbie

Page 240: Russian - World Bank Documents

236 nPHAOnKEHHE r

HHCTPYKUHH H TpaKTOBKH HajnoroBoro 3aKOHOAaTeAbCTBa, peaKo AOXOA5T a0 oTLajieHHbIX

patiOHOB. Co6i4paeMOCTb HanoroB, OaHaKO, O'eHb HH3Kaq.

Ha Hamano 1995 roaa qeTbIpbMS CaMbIMH BaJKHbIMH u3 6o0iee 20 HajiorOB 6bulJH:

* Haffor Ha gpH6ubI HpeC4IpHRTHA, B3HMaeMbIir B Haqanie KaLOPO KBapTaia

Ha OCHOBaHHH oueHKH BaJIOBOA RpH6blUH B Ha4aBweMCq KBapTane. B

HacToAiuee BpeM5I CTaBKa 3TorO Hanora paBHa 13% (4)eaepaAbHbiA) rinoc

22% (perHOHaJAbHbIli).

* HafforHa jo6amicHHyro CToHMOCTb (H1QC) B pa3mepe 20% HaqiC4c51eTCH Ha

roploqee, 3anqaCTH u4 o6opyaOBaHHe H apyrHe MaTepHaTbl c ao6aBJIeHHort

CTOHMOCTbIO.

* Hanior Ha oxpaHy H BocripomBO4cmBo iecHJC pwycoB nCe p HBOH a4 aibH0 Ha

perHOHaHJbHOM YPOBHe COCTaBJIJI 7%, 3aTeM 6buI 3aMeHeH 4)eaepajibHblM

HaJIoroM B pa3mepe 20%, KOTOpbWI B pe3ynbTaTe HaCTOTe1JbHorO

no66HpoBaHHr. CO CTOpOHbl JieCOnpoMbilwJeHHHKOB 6bulI CHHKeH ao 5%, a

3aTeM B anpene 1995 roaa COBceM OTMeHeH.

* Haforiw Ha 3apa60omy1o niary, oT'HcjieHuI4 Ha couHanJbHoe H MeatUL4HCKoe

CTpaXOBaHHe, B 4OHa 3aH$TOCT4 H B rleHCHOHHblg (DOHA, COCTaBJWIOT 40%

CTOHMOCTH pa6oqeg cHnbI.

,apyr4e HaJIorH BKJlioqaIOT:

* PemFoHafbHHme HafJom, B TOM qHcJIe: JIeCHble noaaTH (CTaBKH KOTOpblX

3aBHCIT OT nopoa aepeBbeB), aOHOAHHTeJlbHblri 20%-HbIl HLa C,

HaUiHCJi,qeMblA Ha OneHHHYIO H apeHaHyiO nliaTbI, pa3Mepbl KOTOpbIX

3aBHCflT OT OCHOBHbIX nOpOA H CPOKOB apeHAbl; a TaKie Hajior 3a

3eMnenonlb3OBaHHee.

* Pa#oHHIme (MyHwLnuznamHme) HaIoroj, COCTasBISouHo e ao 3% BanJOBoro

aoxo,aa HpeAnlpHHTHA, MOryr B3HMaTbCS ASI HCnOJIb3OBaHH51 B pa3JIHqHbIX

uernix (o6pa3oBaHHe, oxpaHa o6LfLecTBeHHoro nopgaKa, coAep)KaHHe wfbSl,

CaHHTapHbie cAy)K6bi, JIHueH3HPOBaHHe npeanpHHHMaTejibcKoi

aeATeJIbHOCTH, TpaHCnOPTHbie MarHcTpaiiH). MeCTHbIe pyKOBOAHTeJIH

)KaJAyIOTCS Ha TO, 'TO 3TOT Hanor (3%) He Bceraa oTIcJISleTCS B nOJIHOM

pa3Mepe.

* Pa3Hme HamomH - nOCTOAHHO pacmupmuLUaqcu KaTeropHs HajiorOB, Ha

IlOJIIO KOTOpOUi HHoraa npHXOAHTCS5 OMeHb 6OJIlbwa.l aCTb BCeX HaJiOrOBbIX

o6sl3aTenbCTB npeanpHsTKA. HpeanPH.9TH5M laCTo aeUeBJIe onnIaTHTb

wlTpad)bl 3a HapyuweHHe JiecocetHb1X H IpHpoP,OoxpaHHbIX Tpe6OBaHHri, 'eM

BKJlaabIBaTb CpeaCTBa B MepOnpHsTHs, o6ecne'nBalOLuHe cO6nlo11eHHe 3TUX

lpaBHJA H Tpe6OBaHHP; B 1993 ro1y 3TH wTpa4bl B Xa6apOBCKOM Kpae

npeBbICHJIH o6Luyio CyMMy nieCHbIx no21aTeri Ha 1000%. ",Jo6poBo.nbHbie"

niiaTe)KH B pa3mepe 1,5% OT o6feri CyMMbi npoLaaK B3HMalOTCS ALS'

OKa3aHH3S noLaLepXKKH oTpaciieBou HayKe. Ha npaKTHKe 9TUI niiaTe)Km 'aCTO

Page 241: Russian - World Bank Documents

237 HPHnJO)KEHHE r

npeBbIwHalOT aaHHbl ypOBeHb, lBJqACb CKpblTbIMU nHaTeT)KaMH B c1opMenUIaTbl 3a KOHCYJ1bTaLtHOHHbie H apyrHe yCJiyrH.

HanpHMep, B Xa6apOBCKOM Kpae Jieconepepa6aTblBaflOUe KOMnaHHH,HaxolaAwuecs 2aJieKO OT MOpCKHX rIOpTOB, H npeAlpHATH51, 3KCrIOpT UIPOayKU4HH KOTOpbIXorpaHwMeH, jTaTSIT 4pe3MepHO BbICOKHe HamOmu. MHorme HaBjor Ha4KCA5IIOTC HaOCHOBaHHU o6ullerl CYMMbI 3apa6oTHoA JIiaTbl BCex pa6OTHHKOB H ao6aBJieHHOA CTOUMOCTU,WTO CTaBHT B HeBbIrOaHoe HOJIO)KeHHe TpyTOeMKHe npOH3BOQCTBa, BbInyCKaiol(Ue

HpOJyKUHIO AAS BHyTpeHHerO pbIHKa. ECTb CBeaeHHS 0 TOM, qTO o4eHb 6 Onbwaq aOjjqaOXO,aOB JleCHOU npOMbIlwJeHHOCTH, a cJieaOBaTej1bHO H 3aAojn)KeHHOcTH no HajioroBbIMnJIaTeKaM, OCTaeTCI BHe aocAraeMOcTH degepanbHoro npaBJTeJIbcTBa. JIecO3arOTOBsuTeJIbHbieKOMnaHHH, HMeIOWUe aOCTyn K 3KCHOpTHbIM pbIHKaM, OCBo6ow(aIoTCA OT HLtC Ha3KCnOpTHpyeMyio npOAyKUHIO. C nOMOLUblO HaMepeHHOrO 3aHH)KeHH5I OUeHOK KaqeCTBa HKOJIHqeCTBa HpOYK(uHH 3KCrOpTepbl Kpyriioro nieca MOryT B OTqeTHbIX aOKyMCHTaxyKa3blBaTb 6o0iee HH3KHe aOXOabI OT npoaax. [Iepepa6aTbIBalouLe we npean,IrIpTHSI,BbInycKaiotuie npO,4yKULHIO AA BHyTpeHHero pbIHKa, HMelOT MeHbwue BO3MO)KHoCTeACKpblBaTb CBOH AOXOAbI.

3 aKoHo0,faMJBHaff 6a38a H I7PfHHlIbIpeiYffpOBaHWJz HHBCCTHOHHO0,# 1CTCJ,bHOC7MI

llpaBa H o 6 M3aHHOCTH HHBecTopoB oipeCenjqIOTcA 3aKOHOM "06 HHBeCTH[tHOHHOIu,ae1TenjbHOCTH B POCCHUCKOU cDeaepaXHH". lpenolonaraeTcI, 'TO 4)eaepaJlbHoenpaBHTeJlbCTBO AOJAKHO t)HHaHCHPOBaTb jiecHoe XO3AHrCTBO H C03,RaTb 6o0ee UeniOCTHyIOripaBOBylO OCHOBY AA pewlIeHHA BOrlpOCOB B TaKHX o6jracTqX KaK Hajioroo6JioKeHHe,aHTHMOHoHOJIbHbIe Mepbl, 3KOHOMHqeCKoe CTHMYUHPOBaHHe H ynpaBJIeHHe .TCCHbIMHpecypcaMH Ha OCHOBe HpHHUHnOB 3KoJIorHqecKH YCTOUi'HBOro pa3BHTHSI.

4aCTHbie HHBeCTHUHH MO)KHO npHBJIeKaTb TaKIe 'epe3 pa3BHTHe Pb[HKa LIeHHbIX6yMar. Hau6ojiee pacnpocTpaHeHHbIM THnOM ueHHbIx 6yMar, npoaaloLuHXCq B POCCuH,ABEIlIOTCA aKKL1HH HpHBaTH3HpOBaHHbIX npeanIpHATHu H 4HHaHCOBO-KpeaUTHb[XopraH43a[IuH. HHKaKHX 3aKoHoB, peryAHpyIouLx 3Ty aesTeJlbHOCTb He CyIUeCTByeT, XOTAeCTb ripe3HaeHTCKHA yKa3, KOTOpblHi perI'aMeHTHpyeT JIHUeH3HPOBaHHe HeKOTOpb[X B44OB

TaeATenbHOCTH 6aHKoB, CTpaxoBbIx KoMnaHHA, KpeaHTHbIX H apyri4x 44HaHCOBbIXyqpeA(zeHHi. 9 THM YKa3oM 6buza TaKwe Co3faaHa cteaepaJibHaA KOMHCCUIM Ho ueHHbIM6yMaraM. 3Ta KOM4CCHS H U BJIAeTCA roCyaapCTBeHHbIM opraHOM ynpaBjleHmq, KOTOpbIlOTBeqaeT 3a peryAHpOBaHHe pblHKOB UeHHblX 6yMar H 6 Hp)KeBbIX OriepauHH.

HHBHCTHLr'HOHHmCe HpHopHr7m . HaH6o0ee 6 AaronpHsTHbIe HHBeCTHUH4OHHblenepCreKTHBbl HMeeT npOH3BOACTBO npO,yKTOB XHMH4eCKOA H X4M4KO-MeXaHH4qeCKOr4nepepa6oTKH apeBecHHbl (6yMarH, KapTOHa, cbaHepbl, apeBeCHbIX nJIHT) H H3rOToBJIeHHeCTO1SIpHbIX H3LIej1HZi H3 ApeBeCHHbl H Me6eim. I3o6HJIHe Cblpbs, BOAHblX H 3HepreTHqeCKHXpeCypCOB, pa3BHTaH TpaHCHOpTTHas CeTb, KBaLUIH4U4POBaHHbie Kapbl 14 nOTeHULHabHbieMeCTHble H MeeAAyHapOAHbie PbIHKU o6ecnieqHBalOT XOpOWylO 3KOHOMHUecKyio 6a3y.HHBeCTHULOHHbie B03MO)KHOCT4 B KpaCHOMPCKOM Kpae BKTIOioalOT U4HaHCHpOBaHHeueJIJIIoJ]o3Ho-6yMa)KHbix npeanpHATIH, 3aBOAOB, BblnyCKaIoLUHx 14aHepy H apeBecHbie nTIHTblH MoAepHH3aLxumo HAH pacwHpeHHe ieconrTIbHbIx H LaepeBonepepa6aTblBalOuXHxnpe,aripHATHi4. B Xa6apOBCKOM Kpae CyLueCTByIOT B03MOXKHOCTH UHBeCTHPOBaHHR Bpa3BHTHe rTpeaUpHATKH rjiy6oKOl (co3,aaomer ao6aBJleHHylO CTOUMOCTb) nepepa6oTKm

Page 242: Russian - World Bank Documents

238 rPAJIO)KEHHE F

,apeBeCHHbl AUIA nOBbIweHUI4 3c4eKTHBHOCTH HCnOJb30BaH4H ueHHbIX JIHCTBeHHb[X BHUOB B

npOH3BOLaCTBe Me6eJI4, wLnoHa, napKeTa H 4aHepHbIX H31aejiHr cneTuHaJI3HpOBaHHoro

Ha3HaMqeHHSq.

rpHopHTeTbl pa3BHTH5 H HHBeCTH4OBsaHHS no pa3uHT4HbIM OTpacJT5M BKJlior4a[OT:

* JkCo3a0TTBMTCJILHaB olpacum: CO comaHH CTa6HJIbHOr4 H

paULHOHaJIH3HpOBaHHOA peCypCHOR 6a3bl, 6blCTpoe BOCCTaHOBJTeHHe

npOIyvUHpyIOUHX inecos, 6onee pauHOHanbHoe HCnOJIb3OBaHHe IieCHbIX

pecypcoB; npHMeHeHHe 6o0iee coBepweHHbIX MeTO),OB JIeCO3aroTOBKH

(B1K.loT4a51 py6Ku yxoaa) H co3.LaHHe HH41paCTpyKTypbi xI5I npoaLeHH5

jieCo3aroTOBHTeJIbHoro ce3oHa.

* IIecoIIHNaH H ,iepeBoHepepa6aTmmaiozas OTPaCffH: 3aMeHa yCTapeBilero

o6opyJaoBaHHA Ha HOBoe, MoaePH43aUHA H peKOHCTPYKUHS npeanpH5THr4,

nOBblwlleHHe KaiecTBa BblnyCKaeMOH npOAyKUHH, CHH)KeHHe YpOBHR

3arPAl3HeHHS OKpy)KZaO1ueH CpeAbi H Co3AaHHe HOBOH npOH3BOACTBeHHOH

MOUL.HOCTH ,XIAn BbInCKa npOayKTOB nojib3yioLuHxcAs nflOBbIweHHbIM

cnpocoM.

* HpOH3BOACTBO LfCJJl0fo3M H 6ymaNw MOaepHH3aUH o60pyflOBaHHA

uejinlOJIo3HO-6yMa)KHOA oTpacJiH aAJ, nOBblwleHH5 3q4eKTHBHOCTH H

yMeHbII1eHHR HeraTHBHorO BO3XAeACTBH.5 Ha oKpy)Kcaioylio cpegy.

3KCJOpTepm h HHOC7plaHHme HHBCyCTHIH. B KOH1te 1980-x roaoB 3KcnOpT

KpyrJIbix IecomaTepHaoB H apyro ieconpoMbIujieHHofi npoIAyKuHH 4aKTH-eCK4 qsBJIAJICs

MOHOnOAHeU KOHTpOJAHpyeMOH 4)eaepaj1bHbIM npaBHTeJibCTBOM 4HPMbl "3KcnopTlec",

KOTOpai HMeJia CBOH peaCTaBHTenbCTB B Xa6apoBcKoM Kpae, Ha CaXaJIAHe H B rp4MOpbe.

B 1990 roay AnI BbIlOJIHeHHS 3KCIOpTHbIX H HMIOpTHbIX onepaLUHi B JieCOnpOMbilJeHHOM

KOMniieKCe POCCHU 6buIO CO33faHO aKUUOHePHOe o6§leCTBO aaJ]bJ1ecnpoM. B TeieHHe

ciie,ayioLutx aBYX neT ,Laj1bjiecnpoM 3aHHMajic5i 3KCnOpTOM Kpyrnioro Aeca CBOHX KOMnaHUU,

MHorHe H3 KOTOPbIX npeCneioBaJH rInaBHbIM o6pa3OM CBOH cO6CTBeHHbie UHTepecbI. B

pe3yjnbTaTe, OU4UH1aj1bHbie TOprOBbie CAejIK4 CTanjU 3aKJIO4aTbCA C 3aaep)KKaMH, '-TO

npHBejiO K BbICTYnAeHHIO aKUHOHePOB IPOTHB aeHTeJIbHOCTH npaBmeHKA, KOTOPOe B

Pe3YnbTaTe 6buio nepeH36paHO. nPH HOBOM npaBneHHH, Hat4HaA C 1992 roaa .aanbecnpoM

YKpenUH CBOH nO3HUHH, KaK OCHOBHOH 3KCnOpTep B CTPaHbI A3HH, H ticnHOb3OBaji CBOHi

KanHTani H nOJI)KeHHe aIiS co3,aaHNsA MHO)KeCTBa nOaKOHTpOJIbHblx eMy KoMnaHHru,

3aHHMaiOWuHXC CTPaXOBaH4eM, 6aHKOBCKHM aejiOM H HMnOPTHbIMH OnePauHSMH. OH TaK)Ke

etue 6o.nbue yKpeni4HJ CBOH TeCHbie CB5314 C HeCKOnbKHMH 'IaCTHbIMH npeRnPHHHMaTejiqMH,

OTfleji4BWUIXC.q OT AaXjbneCnpoMa.

AKUHOHePHOe 06UleCTBO ")jaJlbHeBOCTO4Hblr JIeCHOJ KOMnIieKC" (AO ABJIK)

6bmo yqpexaeHO B 1992 roay B Ka4eCTBe JIHepa B nPUBaTH3aUUHH ieCOnpOMblwi]eHHOrO

KoMnHIeKca PoccHu. HepBbIMH aKU4OHepaMH 3Toro npeanptHTHuS CTa8AH roJiOBHbie

npe,anPHI4THU )Iaj1bJecnpoMa, HO nociie npoiecTa aKUHOHePOB ajajibecnpoMa B KOHUe 1992

ro,aa "JaajbHeBoCTO0HblI JieCHOHi KOMnIieKC" no CylueCTBY CTaJi qaCTHOR CTpOHTejTbHOri

KoMnaHHeu. B HacToniuee BpeMS 3TO aKUHOHePHOe o6LueCTBO CTPOHT 14 3KCnAYaTH4YpeT

npeanpH5THI no 3KCnOPTY Kpyrjioro nieca B npUMOPCKOM Kpae H noMoraeT B CTPOU4TenbCTBe

Page 243: Russian - World Bank Documents

239 PHAJO)KEHHE r

HOBOA 0ieCOB03HO ,aoporH, CB3blBaioWeue BHyTpeHHHe 1O)KHbie parOHbl Xa6apoBcKoro Kpasc no6epelKbeM oKeaHa.

,ao anpems 1996 roaa 3KCnOPTHb1e HOuJIHHbl B PoccHu 6bIJIH HaCTOJbKO BeJIHKH,'iTO nlpeaIFpHSTH5 BblHyxaeHbi 6bIJIH WpHOKO HCnO0lb3OBaTb rTpaKTHKy 4)aAbCH(jHKaUL4HCMeTOB H IaOKyMeHTOB. LIO 1990 roaa o6beMbl 3KCnOpTa 3ieconpoMbLwjieHHOl npoaIyKULHH 143PoccHH 6bum aOBOJTbHO BbICOKHMH, B 1992 roay OH pe3KO CoKpaTHJI4Cb, a 3aTeM B 1995roDy o6feM 3KcnopTa BOCCTaHOBHJIC5 AO npe)KHero ypOBHA, '{TO HpiHHecJo 4,2 MiPJI.aOm3aPOB CWlA BaJInOTHOUt BblpytIKH. B 1995 rOay BHeWUHe3KOHOMHUeCKaS aeSiTeJlbHOCTb (BOCHOBHOM - 3KcriOpT) 0Jon)KHa 6buia, cor.nacHo riporHo3aM, aaTb 20% 4)eaepanbHbIX61oJIeTHbIx ROXO,OB. )aOIn Bblpy'qK4 OT 3KCnOpTa Jeco6yMa)KHOh IlPORYKUHH COCTaBJ151anPHMePHO 5,8% o6weg CYMMbl 3THX nocTynIieHHu, OCTaAbHaq cyMMa 6bmia nonyiyeHa 3a C4eTnOCTyuieHHUi OT npoLa)K Kpyrnioro neca H rHJIoMaTepHaJIoB.

14H HCTpaHHbie 14HBeCTHULIH B pOCCHIUCKyIO npoMbIwJIeHHOCTb peryspyioTC3aKOHOM "06 HHOCTpaHHbIX HHBeCTH4L1IHX B POCCHUiCKOU cDeLepaULRH". B 3TOM 3aKOHeyKa3bIBalOTCS Te HHoCTpaHHble 4) 3H'IecKHe H iopi4AIHecKHe JILIa, KOTOpblM pa3peweHoHHBeCTHPOBaTb CBOH cpeacTBa B POCCHH. B COOTBeTCTBHH C 3aKOHOM, HHOCTPaHHbieHHBeCTHLUHH MoryT oCyiueCTBJATbCH WUHPOKHM KpyroM 4)H3HqeCKHX H 1OP1LHaHeCKHX Jliu -HHocTpaHHb1MH rpawKaHaMH, KOpnopaLiHSMK, npaBHTeJIbCTBaMH HHOCTpaHHbix rocyaapcTB, aTaloKe MeXayHaPO)jHbIMH opraHH3auL MH. I4HocrpaHHbie HHBeCTOpbl MoryT y'peuKaTbnpe,anpHSTHS, nOJIHOCTbIO HaXOaAlUIecq B UX co6CTBeHHOCTH, BJIaaeTb ripeanpmuTHMCOBMeCTHO C POCCHUCKUMH napTHepaMH, HoKynaTb pOCC14f1CKHe npeanpl4pSTH5I, aKUHH,o6jnHraLxHH, ueHHb1e 6yMarH H tiMyUIecTBO; a TaioKe npeocTaBJIslTb 3aAMbl, KpeR14Tbl 14unuHMYU1eCTBO B Ka'eCTBe HHBeCTHUUHf B oripeaejieHHblr4 BHa ae5lTenbHOCT4. 3THM 3aKOHOM,KpoMe TOrO, rPipeYCMaTP4BaiOTCA rOCyaapCTBeHHbie rapaHTH1 3aLUHTbi, 3aKOHHOropa3peweHHA CnopoB 1nu BOnPOCOB 0 AHKBHIaLLuH H 6ecnpenslTcTTBeHHbe nepe'itcJieHHAri31aTe)Keg (3a BbrIeT0M HaJIoroB) 3a rpaHHLly.

B Hamiane 1993 roaa B Ka'eCTBe o0bLLuHajbHoro rapaHTa .14n5 HOCTpaHHbIXHHBeCTOpOB 6buma y'peuKeHa FocyaapCTBeHHaM HHBeCTHU140HHaq KopnopaLtls4.I4HocTpaHHble HHBeCTOPbl MOrYT OCBo6o)KaTbCs OT HMriOPTHbIX rOiUowHH Ha TOBapbI,BBO3HMbie KaK 4aCTb HHBeCTHUHH, a 4UHpMbl, UenjiKOM HaXOALu.lecq B HHOCTpaHHOACO6CTBeHHOCT4, MorYT 3KCnOPT14POBaTb CBOU TOBaPbl 6e3 JIHueH3HH. Ho CTaBKH HajiOrOB CHHOCTPaHHblX HHBeCTOPOB He MOryT COCTaBJn5Tb meHee 50% OT CTaBOK HaJiOrOB,Ha,UHCJIReMbIX KaKOMy-Ji46o poccHr4cKoMy rpeaflpHATH4o.

no LaHHbIM rocyaapcTBeHHOro KOMHTeTa P$) no CTaTHCTHKe, B 1995 roay o6feMHHocTpaHHbIX HHBeCTHUL[Hh B poCCHrCKyiO ipoMbiwJieHHOCTb COCTaBHn 1,2 Mnpa. aonJIapOBCW1A Hu1H ripMHepHo 3% OT o6uero o6beMa HHBeCTHLtHU. HpeanolHTeHie oTaaBajioCbnPearIPHASTHSM TOrIJIHBHO-3HepreTH'eCKO4 OTPaCJnU (22%), rHUUeBoU rPOMblwUTieHHOCTH(24%) U4 IieCorpoMbIUIJeHHOMY KOMnHeKCY (13%). (IopMbI HHBeCT4POBaHHS BKJIoqalOTco3lIaHHe coBMeCTHblx npernpHATHul 14In1 ()HHaHCHpoBaHHe qepe3 rpaB14Ten3bCTBo n0o,npaBHTejbCTBeHHbie rapaHTHH, B TOM 'tIci3e qepe3 MeLyHapoaHHyIo 4HHaHCOByIOKOPnoPaL1HIO (MOI)K). CYAs nO BceMy, caMo0 HoHyAsIpHOh djOpMMOA noMeeiueHRAHHocTpaHHblX HHBeCT4UHl4 ABJIASIOTCS coBMeCTHble npeanpI4.qTHA. TaK, TOJlbKO B JieCHOMceKTope PoccHH pa6oTaeT 6o0ee 200 COBMeCTHb1X 1peanpHATH4iU. F)OJIbWIIHCTBO 13 HUX3aHHMaeTCA 3KCHopTHO-HMrOpTHbIMH H TOPrOBbIMH onepaULAMH, HO HeKOTOpbie U3 HHX3aHATbl H 11pOH3BOCTBeHHOA aeqTeJ]bHOCTbIO. YBejileiHe K0J1H'eCTBa coBmeCTHbIX

Page 244: Russian - World Bank Documents

240 HPHJ1O)KEHHE F

npeAnPH.qTHA, KOTOpoe npoH3OLWJIO C 1992 roia, yKa3bIBaeT Ha onpeAenleHHbliA pOCT

HHTepeca Co CTOPOHbl HHOCTpaHHb]X HHBeCTOpOB. B TO WKe BpCMq, MHOrl4e U3 3TUX

COBMeCTHbiX npenpH51THAi CylUeCTBYIOT nOKa TOfIbKO Ha 6yMare, a CaMH HHBeCTOpbI AKLyT

co3AaHwq 6oiee 6JiaronpH4,STHbix npaBOBbIX H aaMHHHCTpaTHBHb[X yCJ1OBHiu 23 cBoef

,leSTeJIbHOCTH H pa3BIiTH5 HH4)paCTpyKTypbI, B KaqeCTBe yCJIoBHi Ans Toro, 'lTo6bl HaiaTb

ocyiueCTBJneHHe CBOHX npOeKTOB.

HIpooHo3mpoBwHme pa3BIHm JecHoo cexTopa. (Ie)epajIbHbie H perHOHaJIbHbie

nporpaMMbl pa3BHTH14 IieCHOrO ceKTopa OCHOBaHbl Ha nporHo3ax HIHnl9H9JIecrpoMa. ajimpa3pa6oTKH 3THX nporHO3OB HcnOJIb3OBBaaCb 6a3a aaHHbIX, KOTOpaq BKA1OYaeT IHH¢opMaLumo

no MaKpO3KOHOMK4ecKHM nporHo3aM, COCTOSHHIO H HcnoJIb3oBaHHIO CblpbH (,apeBeCHHbl),

TeXHHMecKoMy YPOBHIO H BO3MO)KHOCTRM HCHOAb3OBaHHS npoH3BoACTBeHHbIX MO1UHOCTek B

OCHOBHbIX AeCOnpOMbIwIJeHHb1X oTpacnflx, cnpocy Ha Jieco6yMa)KHyEO npOaYKUIIO,

COCTOAHHIO npearUpHATHAi neCHoro MaUIHHOCTpOeHHq H KOJIH'-ieCTBeHHbIM 3cj4)eKTaM

pa3AHuqHbIX 3aKOHOaaTeCJbHb1X H HOpMaTHBHbiX aKTOB.

ejI,51Mm CyluIeCTBYIOLUHX rOCyaapCTBeHHbIX nporpamm pa3B4TH5I ileCHoro ceKTopa

SIBA51IOTCH: nOBbIweHHe KOiH,4eCTBa H KaqeCTBa BbinyCKaeMOrl npOaYKUUH, pa3BHTHe

perHoHaJnbHoro noTeHuHaJia OCBoeHH5s H HCnOAb3OBaHHi1 J1eCHOrO pecypca, yJIy4weHHe

HayqHO-TeXHH'1eCKog nofaep)KK4, COBeplUeHCTBOBaHHe CHCTeMbi Mep no oxpaHe

oKpy4Kaioiueg CpeAbI, paLXuOHanYbHoe ynpaBuieHHe JieCHb1MH pecypcamH (Ha OCHOBe

npHHLIHnOB 3KojioruHeCK4 yCTOMUHBoro pa3BHTHS) H npmBJeqeHHue 'aCTHbIX HHBeCTHUUH.

FoCy,aapCTBeHHble HpOFH03bl yKa3blBalOT Ha TO, 'TO nPu CTa64JIbHOA 3KOHOMHKe,

XapaKTepH3ylOlluerCs HeyKJAOHHb1M 3KOHOM4qeCKHM pOCTOM, peaAHJ3a14UH npOrpaMMbI

pa3BHTH5 npHpBeAeT K TpOeKpaTHOMY yBeAhIeHI410 o6'beMOB npOMbbiwJieHHOrO npOH3BOaCTBa

B AIeCOnpOMbIwAJIeHHOM KOMHnieKCe. K 2010 rogy 3TO yBe4JIHeHHe AOJIAHO COCTaBJISTb: 550%

- B rlPOH3BO)ICTBe KapTOHa, 450% - B npOpo3BO21CTBe apeBeCHbIX IUIHT H 370% - B

XHMHmeCKOU H XHMHKO-MeXaHH4eCKOA niepepa6oTKe apeBeCHHbI. YaeJlbHblg BCC CblPbSI B

o6lUHX o6beMax 3KcnOpTa coKpaTHTC51 c cerORHqWHHx 29% ao 6% B 2010 roay. BalHOTHaq

BbIpyMKa Mo)KeT yBeBiHqHTbCq Ha 400%. )i,Ar aOCT4)KUeHH 3THX ueAeui 80% Tpe6yioLUI4xcq

HHBeCTHUL4OHHbIX Cpe2CTB ROJI)KHO HOCTynHTb H3 qaCTHorO CeKTOpa, T.K. cjeJepaAbHbIi H

MeCTHbIe 61oLKeTbl nniaHupylOT BbiaeJISTb TOJbKO oKojio 20% OT CYMMbl HeO6xOaU4MbIX

CpeACTB.

MexnyHapoAHas TOpOBpo IieCOnpOMbIlJeHHbIMH ITpoAyKTaMH

ERo 1992 roaa MeAc2yHapoaHas TOproBJsn JieconpoMbILwACHHOu npoayKUi4erl 6bmia

cTporo ueHTPaJ1H3OBaHHOA H OCHOBHaS aOJIS TOpFOBoro o6OpOTa npHxoaHJloCb Ha

me)KnpaBHTeCbCTBeHHbe caeJIKH, 3aKJio'aeMble cneUHCalH3HPOBaHHbIMH BHelHeTOprOBbIMH

opraHH3auuHSMH. ToproBaq nojiHTHKa 6bmia HanpaBiieHa Ha no,aAep)KKY HepaCLuOHaSjbHbIX

LLeHOBbIX MexaHH3MOB, a 6apTepHb[e coriiaweHi4s 6bTIN OCHOBHblM BH4IOM caejioK. B HOpMax

H npaBHjiaX TOprOB.jH npaKTH4eCKH nOJHOCTb1O OTCYTCTBOBaJIH YHH¢UUUpOBaHHOCTb

flOKyMeHTauUHH H cTporai OTT-eTHOCTb.

Cor.naCHO TaMO)KeHHO4 CTaTHCTHKe, B 1992 roay o6Luaq cyMMa 3KCnOpTHbIX

nOCTynJieHUiU B POCCHH COCTaBIsnqa 54 Mwpg. aojUnapOB CWIA, a B 1995 roay oHa Bo3pOcn1a

Ao 78 Mjipa2. noniuapOB CWLA, B TO BpCMq KaK o6LurA o6feM HMnOpTa B 1992 roay COCTasBji

Page 245: Russian - World Bank Documents

241 rHPKJ1O)KEHzE r

43 MApa. aonnapoB CWA (npeBbIweHHe 3KCnOpTa Ha 14MIIOpTOM - 11 Mjip. aonJJapOBCWHA), a B 1995 roay - 47 MApa. aon.napoB CWIA (npeBblweHHe 3KcHOpTa Haa uMnOpTOM -31 Mjipa. aoJijapoB CLWA). ,onsI ToproBjuH PoccHu Co CTpaHaMH AajibHero 3apy6eKbAnpoaoJiKaeT yBeji4qHBaTbCA. OaHaKO OUeHKH o6ibeMOB TOprOBJIH CO CTpaHaMH CoapyKeCTBa

He3aBHCHMbIX rocyaapCTB (CH), cKopee BcerO, 3aHH)KeHbI, T.K. MHOrUie 6apTepHb[e caenJIKHHe perHCTpHpyIOTCAl.

B 1995 roay Ha aOJnHO BHeLUHer TOproBuiH J1econpOMblwieHHOr4 npo)ayKtuief

npHWJIOCb 5,4% OT o6iuero o6beMa 3KCnOpTa (4,2 Mjipa. aoJUiapoB CWUA) H - 1,7% OT

o6iuero o6beMa HMHOpTa (0,8 MApja. aojijiapOB CWJA) (CM. Ta6juITb, r.4 H [.5), ITOHaMHOFO npeBblwuaeT CTOHMOCTHbie H o6,beMHbie HoKa3aTeCA TOprOBA1H B 1994 roay (CM.

Ta6u4ubI r.6 H r.7). aOJIA poccCHcKoro 3KCHOpTa jieconpoMbIwJIeHHor4 npoayKLUHH B

cTpaHbl AaAbHerO 3apy6e)KbA (T.e. B CTpaHbl He BXoaqLutHe B CHr) yBeJIH'-IHJacb c 83% B

1994 roay ao 90%. B 1995 rogy 3InoHHSI cTaiia OaHHM H3 caMbIX KpynHblX HMnopTePOBpoccH14cKoro Kpyrjioro neca. B uenJoM aon0A HMHnopTa Poccueu JIeconpoMbIilmeHHOinpoIIyKUHH H3 CTpaH aaJIbHero 3apy6e)Kbq yBeJiH'-IjiaCb C 85% ao 92%. OCHOBHbIMU

CTaTbA1MH 3KCHOPTa ABJISIOTCS apeBeCHHa (Kpyrnbir niiec H nHuoMaTepHaJibl), LenjUlOJ1O3HaA

rIpOLIyKU4A (HepacTBopHMas CyJIb4DaTHa5 ueJIloJIO3a) H ra3eTHas 6yMara, Ha ROJnIO KOTOpbIX

B 1995 roay npHXOalHJIOCb 74% o6utero o6feMa 3KcHOpTa IieconpoMbIwjieHHoh ripoayKuHu.OCHOBHblMH CTaTb51MH HMnOpTa ABJIAIOTCS CTpOHTenJbHbIe MaTepuanIbI H3 apeBeCHHbl, 6yMaraH KaPTOH (c nponHTKOri), 6yMa)KHbIe CpeaCTBa rHrHeHbl H o6oH, KOTOpbie BMeCTeCOCTaBJIAJIH 51% o6iuero o6feMa HMHOpTa J1econpoMbimwIeHHoi rpoayKUHH B 1995 roay.

YCHJ]HA1 no jui6epaJIH3aLuHH ToproBoA HOJIHTHKH Ha'ajuH npeanpHHHMaTbCq

PoccHeru B 1992 rony. Kypc BanHOT y)Ke yHH4bLHUpOBaH, OH onpeaeJI5eTCA cHTyaUHeA Ha

PbIHKe H KOHBePTHPYeTCS nOqTH AAA BCeX TeKYLUHX 6yxraJiTePCKHX onepaLu4i. OCBO6o0eHbinOqTH BCe BHyTpeHHHUe ueHbl, oco6eHHo, Ha benepaJIbHoM ypOBHe. pnpOU30WuIO CHHUeHHe

ponuH ueHTpaIH3OBaHHOi Me)KnpaBHTejibCTBeHHOA ToproBjuI, 6onIbWIHHCTBOrocyAapCTBeHHbIx BHeWuHeTOprOBbIX opraHH3aUHf 6buiH ynpa3,aHeHbl IJIH npHBaTH3HpOBaHbl.EbLno pPa3peweHO YCTaHaBJIHBaTb nPAMbIe TOprOBbie CBA3H Mem)aY OTaenJbHbIMHrpe,anpu4ATHs4MH. B 3TOT Ke nep4oa 6buIH OTMeHeHbl MHorHe 3KcnOPTHbie nOlJIHHbl (OHU

COCTasBJIAJ[t 8% AnA KpyrJIoro iieca H nHHJoMaTepHajiOB H 10% n.nsi LlenJ]oJTO3bl) H

3KCnOPTHbie KBOTbI. EOonbwle He CylLueCTByeT HMnOpTHbIX cy6CHaH4, a HMrOPTHbie TapHuibICHH)KeHbl. Ynpa3,nHeHa TaKX(e perHcTpauLH 3KCnOpTepOB H HMnOpTepOB H o6R3aTe.nbHaq

perHcrpaLUHA TOBapOB-ripeaMeTOB TOprOBniH. $DaKTHUeCKH OTMeHeHbl JlbrOTbI no 3KCnOpTHbIMnOWJIHHaM H HMnOPTHbIM TapHq3aM, KPOMe TOrO, nPHHAT HOBblU4 TaMo)KeHHblr 3aKOH.

9TH pe4DOpMbl B TOprOBOH nOJIHTHKe ABJIASlOTCS 60JIblUHM ,aOCT4)KeHHeM. OHHnpHBeJIH K yBeJIHeHHiO 06obeMa TOproBJIH, rlOCTerieHHOMY nPH6JIHKeHHIO K MHPOBbIMYpOBHAM ueH H 6onee peaAHM4uqecKoMy KYPCY o6MeHa BaTlOT. B pe3ynbTaTe npOBeaeHHAnOA4T4KH, HanpasBjeHHOu Ha aOCTH)KeHHe MaKpO3KOHOMH4eCKOH CTa6HUbHOCTH, Ha4ajiOCbnocTeneHHoe yKpenneHHe py6.nA, T.e. nOBbIwueHHe ero CTOHMOCTU. C POCTOM CTOUMOCTH

py6nsi HMnOPT 6yneT CTaHOBHTbCA OTHOCHTenbHO LIeuweBse, a 3KcnOPT aopo)Ke, 'TO,BepOATHO, HpHBeaeT K Heo6xoaHMOCTH HPlpHHTHA CneHLHajbHb1X Mep, HaripaBJ1eHHbiX Ha3atWHTy pOCCHUCKHX npoM3BOnHTeJIeA.

Ha 13 aBrycTa 1996 roaa CTaBKH HMrOpTHbIX TapH4d)OB Ha iiecorpOMbILwJeHHYIonPO1YKUHIO COCTaBIRjiH OT 5% ao 30% (Ta6nHua f.8). C 1994 rona no 1996 roaYBeniH4HJHOCb KOjiH'ieCTBO BH1OB IPOIIYKUHH, Ha KOTOPbie pacnPOCTpaHAIOTCA UMIOPTHbie

Page 246: Russian - World Bank Documents

242 rPHJlO)KEH4E r

TapHd)bl. B anpene 1995 roaa 6bma ynpa3AHeHa CHCTeMa cneU3KCnopTepOB, AHUeH3MpoBaHMH

3KCIIOpTa H KBOT, HO AO CHX riop ReXiCTByeT 4o6poBonbHblAi KOHTPOJIb KOJIHMeCTBa, KaqecTBa

H ueH 3KCHOpTHpyeMbIX TOBaPOB nepea HX OTnpaBKOUi, a TaKKe npeaLuecTByioILasi OTnpaBKe

TOBapOB perHcTpaUHS 3KCnOPTHbIX KOHTpaKTOB.

Poccmu KaK MO)KHO 6blCTpee cneayeT BCTynlTb BO BceMHpHyIO TOprOBylo

opraHH3aiL.io (BTO) H BBeCTH peA)HM TOprOBJIH, COOTBeTCTBy1OLUHA OCHOBHbIM npMHUHnaM

H Tpe6oBaHHAM BTO. B IeAOM POCCuH Heo6xOIIMO nepexoaHTb OT 3KCnOpTa aeweBOrO

Kpyrnioro iieca K 9KCnOpTy AoporHx npOIIyKTOB rfly6oKok nepepa6oTKM apeBeCMHbI. TaKas

CTpaTerHR IIO3BOJIHJa 6bl POCCHH (KaK Ha HaUHOHaJIbHOM, TaK H Ha perHOHanJbHOM ypOBHe)

coKpaTHTb o6feMbi npOH3BOLCTBa H 3KcnOpTa Kpyrjioro nieca, coxpaHAq npu 3TOM

onpe,aejieHHblu YPOBeHb 3KCHOpTHbiX nocTynnieHHri. Pa3BHTMe rjiy6oKok nepepa6oTKM

ApeBeCHHbI MO)KeT TaloKe 6AaronpMsTHo CKa3aTbCS Ha 3KOHOMHKe per4OHOB, cnoco6CTByA

nOBblwJeHHIO YPOBH5 11OXOfOB H 3aHATOCTM MeCTHOrO HaCeJIeHHA.

1leHbl Ha CeconpoMbnUIeHHYIO npOIYKHIWO

)ao npoBeeeHHS JIH6epaJTH3aLuM IeH, UeHbl Ha iieconpoMbIl1ijieHHyIO HPOaYKLIHIO

KOHTPOJ1HPOBaJIHCb rOCyAapCTBOM H OCTaBaJIHCb OTHOCT4TeAbHO CTa6HJIbHbIMM Ha

npoTSxeHHu 1970-X H 198 0-x roaOB. 9TH Od)HUHaJlbHO yCTaHOBJIeHHbie LJeHbI He OTpaXa)Kai

peanJbHbIX 3aTpaT, 4To npIBO,R4AO K He343eKTHBHOMy McnOjIb3oBaHHIO pecypcoB, orpoMHbIM

nOTepAM H 3aTpaTaM, HU3KOU peHTa6ejIbHOCTH H np0H3BOACTBY HnpOaYKTOB HM3Koro

KaqeCTBa. npe3HueHTCKHrI yKa3 Ng 297 "O Mepax no iH6epaJIH3auMm ueH", nOam4caHHbIi 3

aeKa6pA 1991 roaa, rpeaycMaTpHBBaA OCBo6oKAeHHe ileH (B TOM qMHcJe H UeH Ha MHorI4e

BH.bI iieconpoMbiLUJeHHoH npOAyKUHH), HaMHHaq C 2 AHBap5 1992 ro.a. 3a mH6epaAH3auMeR

ueH nocneaoBaiia IH6epaJIH3aLIuH BHyTpeHHeri H BHeWHeCi ToproBiH. AiM6epaim3auim LLeH H

TOPrOBJTH Bbl3Bania pe3Koe nOBblweHHe ueH H CHH)KeHHe cnpoca Ha CeconpOMbUWAeHHYiO

npoIyKUi4o. 3apnnaTa B L.eLComM U oco6eHHO, 3apnriaTa B ieCHbIX paROHax, He ycneBana 3a

pOCTOM LIeH, B pe3yJIbTaTe qero npOH30umO CHH)KeHHe LAOXOAOB HaceJIeHHH. HecMoTp5 Ha

TO, 'ITO Ha (CeIepajlbHOM YPOBHe UeHbI 6buIM 60JbmeU tiaCTbio OCBO6o)IIeHbI, o6nlaCTHble

BnaCTH npoAonc)KalOT CKpbITO KOHTPOJ1HPOBaTb LIeHbl H TOPrOBAIO C nOMOUWblO

MeCKperHOHaJ]bHb1X TOpFOBbIX 6apbepos H KOHTPOJIq HaA TOprOBbIMH HaUeHKaMH.

CaMbIMH BaKHbIMH nepBH'qHbIMH JieCHbIMH npO2yKTaMH BJIASIOTCS KpyrAblii Jlec(He nepepa6oTaHHble JIecoMaTepHajibI) H nHJIoMaTepHajlbI. LeHbl Ha 9TH npOLyKTbi 3aBHCST

OT apeBeCHbIX nopoa, MeCTa npOH3paCTaHlHA (3aTpaTbl Ha TpaHcnOpTHpOBKY H o6pa6oTKy

o6bIlqHO BbICOKU) H OT KaqeCTBa apeBeCHHbI. BHyrpeHHHCe OnTOBbIe LeHbl (c qHBapA 1994roaa no aeKa6pb 1995 roaa) Ha KpyrlbIti nIec HU nHMJOmaTepCiailbi np4BOASTCS B Ta6.irnue r.9.LleHbl Ha o6a 3TH BHUa npOLYKUHH1 Bo3pOCnH, HO B py6nHx LIeHbI Ha KpyIfnblb nCec pOCJIH

6bicTpee, qeM ueHbl Ha IHJIOMaTepHaJlbI; K LeKa6pio 1995 roaa, no cpaBHeHilo C 5HBapeM

1994 rona, ueHbI Ha Kpyrj1bir n1ec yBeCJIM'IMHCb nO'TM B 10 pa3, a Ha nMHomaTepuHanbl - B 6pa3. OCHOBHOU npHMHHOA TaKOrO pOCTa LIeH qBiA5eTCS nocTeneHHaq KOppeKTHPOBKa UeH B

COOTBeTCTBHM C YCJIOBHqMH pbIHO'HO1 3KOHOMMKH H nOBbiUweHHe TpaHCrOpTHbIX paCXOaOB,

KOTOpbie COCTaBJwiOT 60o.buylO aOAIO B ueHaX Ha Kpyrnbiu niec. C apyrok CTOpOHbI, CTaBKH

nAaTbI 3a ApeBecHHy, OTnYCKaeMYIO Ha KOpHIO, He yBenMHJI HHCb H no-rnpe)KHeMy OCTaloTcA

KpagHe HH3KHMH.

Page 247: Russian - World Bank Documents

243 PHnJIO)KEHHE r

B Ta6n1ue r. 10 n1pHBOAKTCS 3KCnOPTHaS CTOHMOCTb eaHHHUbi npOayKLtHH noOTAenlbHbIM nieconpoMbIumIeHHblM npo.yKTaM B 1994 H 1995 rr. 'ITO KacaeTcAHenepepa6oTaHHOf4 apeBeCHHbI, cpeAHHe 3KcnOpTHbie ueHbI Ha Hee B 1994 rony 6bUmnoIqTH B qeTbipe pa3a BbIlwe BHyTpeHHHX OlnTOBbIX ueH (52 Aonnapa CW1A 3a Ky6oMeTpnPOTHB 14 xaoauiapOB CWLA 3a Ky6oMeTp), a B 1995 ro.y - B ABa pa3a (58 AOJnapOB CLUA 3a

Ky6oMeTp nPOTHB 30 aonjiapOB CiWA 3a Ky6oMeTp). 13 3TUX naHHbIX BH2HO, 'iTOBHYTpeHHHe OnTOBbIe ueHbl Ha Henepepa6oTaHHylo ApeBeCHHy npH6jIH)KaIoTcS KCOOTBeTCTBYIO1UHM 3KCnOPTHbIM ueHam. Ho 3aTpaTbl Ha TpaHCnOPTHPOBKY Ao MOpCKU4XnOpTOB o6brlqHO Bbllme, qeM 3aTpaTbl Ha TpaHCnOpTHpOBKY apeBeCHHbl Hanepepa6aTblBaloLuie nperPuHATHAS POCCHH.

B nOHHH LUeHbl C140) Ha KpyrnbIir nec H3 Tpex pOCCHUCKHX nopoj aepeBbeBO4eHb CHAbHO pa3nAHalOTCA: CaMbie HH3KHe ueHbI - Ha AHCTBeHHHLUy, a ueHbI Ha "6eJIyioApeBeCHHy" H KpaCHYIO COCHY npHMepHO oLHHaKoBbl (Ta6nHLua r.11). Ho B 5AnOHHH ueHbiCII(D Ha pOCCHU4CKHUi nec 6onee, leM BaBoe HH)Ke ileH CH4(D Ha aHanorH4HbIl KpyrnbIig nec13 ceBepHOA AMepHKH. UeHbl CH(I) Ha ApeBeCHHy COCHbl AyqHcTOr4 13 HOBOri 3enaHAxH BA11HOHH o6bIqHO Bb1LLUe (nocne rionpaBKH UeH ()OB Ha CTOHMOCTb 4paxTa), 'em ueHbl HaApeBeCHHy COCHbI CMOAHCToI4 U3 POccHH. 10 TO'HO TaKXe, B 1993-1995 rr. cpeaHHe ro1oBbieLxeHbl CW) Ha pOCCUHcKHe XBOVIHb1e nHJIoMaTepHajibl B BeAHKo6pHTaHHH cocTasBJAAHOKOAO aBYX TpeTbHX OT COOTBeTCTBYIOLUHX LLeH Ha fPOaYKUHio 13 KaHaabl (Ta6nHiLa r.12).XOTA 3TH pa3JIqIHA OTTqaCTH CBA3aHbI C pa3HHuerl B KaqecTBe ApeBeCHHbI H TpaHCriOpTHbIXpacxoaax, OHH TaKIKe oTpaxCalOT HH3KHe CTaBKH noneHHoti rmaTb1 B POCCHH.

,LaHHbie O 1eHaX noKa3blBalOT, wTO XOTA UeHbl Ha nec B PoccHH (KaK HaBHyTpeHHeM, TaK H Ha 3KCnOpTHOM pbIHKe) OCTalOTCS HHXe, qeM aHaoruHqHbie MHPOBbieUeHbI, OHH nocTeneHHO BbIpaBHHBaloTCS. BHyTpeHHHe 3aTpaTbi Ha TaKHe 4aKTopbinpOH3BoACTBa, KaK TpyA, 3HeprHA H TpaHcnOpT, npoAoflMKioT yBeIHtIHBaTbCs, a Kypc BaAiOTnpo,oJoKaeT paCTH. nocTeneHHO 3T,OJIXCHO npHBeCTH K nOBblweHHIO KaK BHyTpeHHHX, TaKH 3KCHOpTHb1X LteH. HH3KHe 1leHbI Ha nec (KaK B HacToALuee BpeMs, TaK H, BepoATHo, B6yayLueM) o6ycAoBneHbl rFaBHbIM o6pa3oM HH3KHMH ueHaMH Ha pecypC, T.e. HH3KHMHCTaBKaMH noneHHo1 nnaTbi. SACHO, qTO CyweCTBYlOT nOTeHLkHaAbHbie B03MO2KHOCTHnOBblUieHHA YPOBHerU noneHHotl nAaTbI, 3a cMeT 'ero MO)KHO yCTpaHHTb nmo6bie nepeKocbl HapbIHKe, H3-3a KOTOpbIX ueHbl Ha nec OCTalOTCA HH3KHMH, H o6ecnexlHTb nocTynrLeHHeHHBeCTHUHOHHbIX cpeaCTB, HeO6XO,IHMbiX AAA BeAeHHA necHoro XO3A4CTBa H cTa6HAbHoroflpOH3BOACTBa. KpoMe Toro, Heo6XO11HMO nOBbICHTb KaYeCTBO KaK Henepepa6OTaHHoR, TaK Hnepepa6oTaHHor apeBecHHbl, a TaioKe KaqeCTBO apyrHX BH,OB necHori npOyKULHH. npH6onbIuIHx pa3JHMM4HX B iLeHaX Ha He Hepepa6OTaHHyIO apeBeCHHy U H ecHbie npOayKTbiKOHeMHOrO nOAb3OBaHHS oco6oe BHHMaHHe AOADKHO TaloKe yeAASTbCA 3KcropTy neCHouinpO,ayKuHH, HMe1o[ueri ao6aBaieHHYIO CTOHMOCTb. 3To HMeeT Ba)KHoe 3Ha4eHHe anS ped)opMnOnATHKH, Heo6xOaHMbIX AAA npHBAeqeHHR qaCTHbIX HHBeCTHUHM c uenAbo pea6uAnTauHH HMO,aepHH3aLXHH neconpombiwneHHOrO KOMnAeKCa POCCHH.

10 TepMmH Me/jyHRpOqaHoI TOvFo81n CJJ o3HamvaeT "CTOMMOCTh, c7paxowHm H q5paxT', a (05 -

'"CB060MHO Ha 6opTy".

Page 248: Russian - World Bank Documents

244 flPHAPOKEHKE r

O'TeHrCHajibHbie HaJIOr0Bhe nIOCrylIeHHM B nieCHOM ceKTope

B POCCHH eCTb cyLueCTBeHHblu rOTeHuHaBJ riojIYyeHH5 HajiorOBbIX nocTynHJeHHiu

OT AeCHorO ceicopa. CyuleCTByeT, KaK MHHHMyM, TpH OCHOBHbIX HCTO4HHKa HaJOrOBbIX

nocTynUieHH4: AeCHbIe nogaTH, HanorH c JieCO3arOTOBHuTenbHbIX KOMnaHHi H HanoruH c

,aepeBonepepa6aTblBaiowHx npeanpH$TH4. B CB5134 C BbICOKU4M YPOBHeM HeonpeaeAeHHOCTHB niiaHe BO3MO)KHbIX o6beMoB yCTOUINHBOrO npOH3BOACTBa apeBecHHbi, 6yRy1uHx 3aTpaT H

LLeH, OUeHKa rIOTeHUHaJlbHbIX HaJIOrOBbIX nOCTyHJTeHHir¶ (B aojiapax CWA) aaeTCA xu9A ABYX

YPOBHeg npOH3BOACTBa apeBecHHbl H aAS Tpex ypOBHefg 3aTpaT H UeH. B HaCTOqLuee BpeMS

poccHrCcKHe LeHbI HH)Ke, 'eM MHpOBbie. OIHaKo npuH aanbHemueH JIH6epaJIH3aLWu LueH H

TOprOBJIH, pOCCHUCKHe LueHbI AOfDKHbi 6yayT CpaBHATbCS1 C MUpOBbIMH. HoCKonbKy B OCHOBe

paC4eTOB .ne)KaT KOHCepBaT14BHbie nporHO3bl, OueHKH nOTeHUHanJbHbIX Ha8JOrOBbIX

HOCTyHnieHHH TO)Ke HOCST KOHCepBaTHBHbIl4 xapaKTep. HanpHMep, B HacTosUuee BpeMS

cpelLHHi pa3mep IieCHbIx roaaTek B POCCH4H COCTaB5ieT MeHee 1 aoLJUiapa ClIA 3a

Ky6oMeTp, a no pe3ynbTaTam feCHbIX ayKL1HOHOB pa3MepbI IieCHbIX noaaTer B POCCHH H

HeKOTOPbIX coceaHHX cTpaHax npeBbILualOT 10 aoOjU1apOB CWIA 3a Ky6oMeTp. B

CKaH,aHHaBHH ypoBeHb noneHHoA nHiaTbl Mo)KeT aOCTHraTb 30 aoiuinapoB CHIA 3a Ky6oMeTp.

HCXO,aA H3 HaH6oJIee KOHcepBaTHBHbix npOrHO3OB, nOTeHuHajIbHbie HajiorOBbIe

nOCTyniieHHUq OT necHoro ceKTopa B POCCHH oueHHIBaIOTCq MUHHMYM B 0,9 MJIPa. aoJ1J]apOBCHIA B roa. OHH MorJIH 6bl IOCTHraTb 5,5 Mflpa. aoninapoB CWA B roa npuli OHTHManJbHbIX

aonyiiIeHHAX no o6beMaM npoH3BOIICTBa apeBecHHbl H peHTa6eJIbHocTH

JieCO3arOTOBHTenJbHbIX KoMnaHHAi H IepeBonepepa6aTbIBaioLuHx npea,npHSlTHr (CM. Ta6july

F.13). EcniH npaBHTejibCTBO He cMo)KeT pedJopMHpOBaTb nOJTHTHKY B JIeCHOM ceKTope,

yBeiHUIHTb CTaBKH IieCHbIX noaaTeH H InOBbICHTb co6HpaeMOCTb HajiOrOB, TO OHO He CMO)KeT

flOJlyIaTb 3TH nOTeHUHaJbHbie HanJOrOBbIe nocTynIieHHS. A 3TUX nOTeHuLLaJibHbIX HaYiOrOBbIX

nocTYynAeHH XBaTHJo 6bl He TOJIbKO Ha (bHHaHCHPOBaHHe Bcex pacXO,4OB, CBH3aHHbIX C

opraHH3auHer4 H BeLIeHHeM neCHoro X03.rUCTBa, BOCnpOH3BORCTBOM, oxpaHOu H 3aWlHTOA

n1eCOB H HX HeHCTOLU14TeJIbHbIM HCnOjib3OBaHH4M (6ioaxeTHbie paCXOabl Ha BeaeHH4e necHoro

XO35IHCTBa B 1996 roay cocTaBnAlOT npHMepHo 425 MJIH. aoJIJapOB CWIA), HO H Ha TO,

'TO6bl BHeCTH KpynHbIl BKJIaA B rOCyaapCTBeHHYIO Ka3Hy. KpoMe TOFO, nOBbIleHHe CTaBOK

JIeCHbiX noaaTerl JIHI4UHT nojib30BaTeJleA 3aHHTepeCOBaHHOCTH B Ipe3MepHOH 3KCrIIyaTauUHH

iieCHbIX peCYPCOB H CoKpaTHT nOTePH 3aFOTOBJeHHOH apeBecKHbI, H TeM caMbIM, 6y.neT

cnoco6CTBOBaTb nOBbllwCeHHIO 34"eKTHBHOCTH H yCTOAMHBOMy pa3BHTHIO iiecHoro CeKTOpa.

Pe4opMbl, npeaRiaraeMbie B aaHHOM aoKJIaae, OqeHb Ba)KHbi WinI HapaLUHBaHHSI o6feMa

nOTeHULHabHbIX HaJ1OrOBbIX AOXOaOB 3a c4eT 3KoHorHqecKi4 yCTOAI4HBoro pa3BHTHA nIeCHoro

CeKTOpa, HITO COOTBeTCTByeT ueJIH coxpaHeHHA 3KoJIorIHMeCKOH UeJTOCTHOCTH IieCHbIX

peCypCOB CTpaHbI.

Page 249: Russian - World Bank Documents

HPKPHO)KEHHE F

Ta6AHIua r.4: 9KcnopTr AieconpoMbiJimeHHOui npoayKIUHH 13 POCCHH, 1995 r.

Bia 17powyKufH Bcero 3a npegefmi CHr B cTpaHm CHr

Konf-Bo COvfTMOCTb Kat7-Bo C7roPMOCTb Ka5J-Bo CTo0Mocrb

(TblC. T) (MJIH. (TMC. T) (w,H. (TIc. T) (MJIH.ganDapoB) ,a0nvapoB) ,aTQasapoB)

,apeBecwHa u £ipeBeCHbie - 2.107,9 - 1.940,3 - 167,6lPOAfYKTbi

TonFABHafl ipeBeclHa 737,8 27,8 701,4 27,0 36,4 0,8Henepepa6oTaHHasl 18.446,0 1.064,5 17.948,8 1.040,8 497,1 23,6apeBectHa (M3)WnaAbl 168,6 25,3 4,9 0,7 163,7 24,6nwimoMaTeplan bl - 709,4 - 640,1 - 69,2LtpeBecHocTpyKe*IHbfe 21,5 3,6 18,0rl.UHTbl2ipeBecHoBo.noK- 32,0 - 21,1 - 10,9HI4CTble nflmTbl

q)aHepa (M3

) 670,5 193,2 657,0 188,9 13,5 4,3LiepeBslHHafl Tapa 102,8 12,8 44,0 6,6 58,9 6,2CTpoHmaTepHanbl 8,8 5,6 3,4 2,0 5,4 3,6Uenj1ifo.no3Han npoAyKuuf - 951,3 - 919,0 - 32,3

CyjbrwaTHam 79,5 85,8 76,7 82,5 2,8 3,3ueAjlojlo3a,paCTBOPMma5Cy,lbqrnHas 1092,7 762,7 1.062,6 743,5 30,1 19,2UeJnn0JIon .3aHepaCTBOPHMamlCyllb4HTHasl 159,6 96,4 151,5 90,7 8,1 5,8uejvoJno3a,HepaCTBOPHMaml

byMa)KHa npofayKUHs - 1.175,9 - 950,1 - 225,8Fa3eTHa5l 6yMara 1.005,1 598,3 916,4 542,3 88,7 56,0BYMara 11 KaPTOH 219,2 153,4 150,2 108,2 69,0 45,1HeMe.loBaHHbie

Kpa(PT-6yMara H 251,7 143,3 233,9 130,0 17,8 13.4KapTOH,HeMeJlOBaHHbieLlpyrue 13HRb1 6vMaru U 296,5 166,0 241,0 128,3 55,6 37,7KapTOHa,HeMeJJOBaHHbiebyMara 11 KaPTOH 8,5 7,9 5,7 3.4 2,8 4,5MeJlOBaHHblebyMara U KaPTOH 34,1 22,9 29,7 17,3 4,4 5,6FlPOnHTaHHbie06oH 4,9 7,2 1,1 1,0 3,8 6,2byMa)KHbIe CpeaCTBa 3,6 4,8 1,5 2,2 2,1 2,6ror"eHbIByNmaKHa5i u 34,8 33,5 9,4 8,0 25,4 25,5KaPTOH HaSa TapabyMaAKHbIe u 4,5 - 0,1 - 4,4KaPTOHHbIC 5pAbIKIH

lipyrFHe BH,lfbl 4,2 6,9 I, 0,8 3,1 6,16yMa)KHOi Ui

KapTOHHO H FPOUYKUIIH

Bcem I -1 4.235,1 | 3.809,4 1 1 425,7

HCTOIHtiK: TaMO>KeHHaS CTaTICTkIKa no BHeWHeri TOproBAe POCCHriCKOU Oeaepaumi, 1995.

Page 250: Russian - World Bank Documents

HPHJIOKEH4E r

Ta6niHia r.5: I4MnopT ieconpoMbLuIeHHOR npo ,uyKiHH B POCCHIO, 1995 r.

B,a nupqwn Bcemr 3a npeaefif CHr B cTp&Hm CHr

Ka,-a,o CTHMOCT rb Kon-Bo COromMOCrb Ka,-ao CrtmHMOCTh (MnH.

(muc. T) (M!/l. (Trc. T) (MfH. (Tmc. T) ,raiwapoo),aaWvapoB) jroazfapoB)

ApeBecuHa u apeBeCHbie - 186,7 - 179,0 - 7,7npOAyKTbI

TonJmHBHaR apeBecuHa 5,4 0,2 2,9 0,2 2,5 0,1Henepepa6oTaHHa9 975,6 25,6 970,7 25,3 4,9 0,3

ApeBecHHa (M3 )Llnanu 0,3 0,0 0,3 0,0 0,0 0,0rHHnomaTepHanbi - 7,7 - 6,3 - 1,4ApeBeCHOCTpyXKetHbie 8,7 8,4 0,3nJIHTblapeBeCHOBOJnOKHHC- - 6,9 - 6,6 - 0,3Thie nfuHTbI(DaHepa (M3 ) 54,2 2,7 52,3 2,3 1,9 0,4AlepeBsHHas Tapa 6,5 1,8 3,9 1,0 2,6 0,8CTpogMaTepHaJn,1 30,5 111,7 28,5 109,6 2,0 2,0Hpo6Ka U nponyKUtig - 2,2 - 2,2 - 0,0H3 Hpo6KH

Uejmnnio3Hasq - 23,0 - 19,0 - 4,0npOyaKUHA

CyJbq4aTHaSI 10,3 9,9 6,7 6,4 3,6 3,6

uejummlo3a,paCTBOPHMaRCyniiiammas 5,8 5,0 5,8 5,0 0,0 0,0

ueJllojio3a,HepacTBopHMaqCYJ1I4HTHaSI 6,1 6,5 6,1 6,5 0,0 0,0uejnT10213a,HepaCTh0PHMaS

ByMaKHaR H KapToHHal - 598,3 - 542,8 - 55,5nfpoayKUH.

ra3eTHas 6yMara 1,0 1,0 0,7 0,8 0,2 0,1Bymara H KaPTOH 11,2 13,1 6,9 8,6 4,3 4,5HeMeJIOBaHHbIeKpa4vr-6yMara H 6,6 4,6 1,3 1,8 5,3 2,7

KapToH,HeMeAOBaHHbieapyrHe BHAbi 6yMarH H 26,5 20,8 12,3 11,7 14,2 9,1KapTOHa,HeMeAoBaHHbieSyMara H KapToH 11,8 8,4 7,2 5,9 4,6 2,4MejiosaHHbieByMara H KaPTOH 57,2 127,4 51,8 119,3 5,4 8,0

nponulTaHHb1e060H 26,0 57,2 23,3 49,6 2,6 7,6ByMaIKHbie cpeacTBa 37,5 120,0 33,3 117,0 4,2 3,0rHrHeHbIbyMaxIHaR H 52,4 95,2 43,1 87,8 9,3 7,3KaproHHaR TapaByMa,KHEbie u - 42,1 - 41,7 - 0,3KapTOHHbIe RPJIbIKHALpyrHe BUAbi 18,9 31,8 14,7 25,4 4,2 6,46yMa3KHO1i HKapToHHo_ n_ _ __K_ _I

ero - 810,2- 743,0- 67,2

I4CTOIHHK: TaMO)KeHHaR CTaTHcTHKa no BHeWHeu ToproBne POCCHU1CKOU1 (1ezxepauHH, 1995.

Page 251: Russian - World Bank Documents

nPtiJO;KEH1E r

Ta6nIH"a F.6: 9Kcnoprr neconpombllleHHOR lpo,AYKuHH U3 PoccHH, 1994 r.

BHA napxauKamu &ero 3b nfipemwa CHr B crpfiHU CHr

Kaf-Do Orfmocrb Kaff-BO CTommocTb Kaff-,0 CTEHA¢OCTIb (Mg/H.(TUC. T) (WM-IH (TUfC. T) (IIOH. (TUrC. T) aaMlapOB)

4aAtpoB) AO"4nPOB)

ApeBecHHa uHapeBcCHbie 1664,8 1468,0 196,8npoAyKTbl

Tonnilfffaml apeBsectHa 778,9 24,3 694,8 21,5 84.1 2,7Henepepa6o0TaHHaSl 14850,3 765,3 13509,8 716,2 1340,6 49,1,apeBecl4Ha (M3)W nanbl 69,5 11,2 2,8 0,3 66,7 10,9nHJ]omaTepHam[l 623,7 549,4 74,3ApeBecHOCTpyxKeMHble 23,0 4,4 18,7niiHTbl

peBeCHOBOJIOK- 32,4 19,6 12,8HHCTble niiHTbl

ttaHepa (M3) 631,9 147,1 591,0 140,5 40,9 6,6aepeB.qHHa.q Tapa 164,0 14,8 40,7 5,4 123,3 9,4

C-rporimaTepmanbl 18,7 9,3 2,9 I ,5 15,7 7,7Uens10I0n3Hasq 384,6 347,7 36,9npo,ayKuH.q

Cynbi4aTHa.t 68,4 37,9 40,7 22,3 27,8 15,6uenisionio3a,paCTBOpHMaSI

CYnbepuTHast 774,6 309,3 729,5 293,2 45,1 16,0uenuuono03a,HepaCTBOpHMa.q

CYJnb4tpTHa.q 91,3 32,8 80,3 30,1 11,0 2,8uenmlono3a,HepaCTBOpHMaSI

S)ymaXHasq u KapToHHas l 521,5 321,9 199,6npoAyKUuœq

ra3eTHast 6ymara 680,4 196,9 574,1 164,8 106,3 32,1Symara H KapToH 230,8 91,7 85,3 32,3 145,5 59,4HemejiOBaHHble

Kpa(pT-6ymara u 215,0 62,0 176,9 51,4 38,1I 10,6KapToH,

HemejiOBaHHbleApyrue Bmabi 6ymari tu 244,3 69,4 168,1 45,4 76,2 24,0KapTOHa,HemejioBaHHbleBymara u KapToH 31,4 13,4 24,4 9,2 7,0 4,2nponHTaHHbie

06om 12,1 7,8 4,4 2,5 7,7 5,3Byma)KHbie cpeaCTBa 8,4 5,1 3,7 2,0 4,8 3,1rurHeHbiSyma)KHast H 73,1 43,6 14,6 5,3 58,5 38,3KapTOHHaSt Tapa

6ymawtibie ui 1,6 3,0 0,1 0,1 I1,4 2,9KapTOHHbie hpAblKH

Aipyruie BHKabl 5,7 4,0 I1,4 0,9 4,4 3,16yma)Kmo i Uxa2ltmoriO npoAZutiKUU _

IBcero 2571,0 2137,7 | 43,

IHCT04HHK: Tamo)KeHHasl cTaTHCTHKa no BHeulHeH rToproBnie POCCHHACKOA ()e,aepaumN, 1995.

Page 252: Russian - World Bank Documents

rPWPOKEHHE r

Ta6.nina r.7: HM nopTr ieconpoMbim eHHort InpO,AuIK HH B PoccHIo, 1994 r.

BRi npowilmm Bic 3aem np=aeff CHr B cTpaH^h CHr

Ka7-Bo 0 CToHMOCTh Ka,O-1o CwOmocmb KOA-bO CTOHMOCTb (MwH.

(Tbc. T) (Mwi. (rjc. T) (nH. (Tmw. T) ,aoJlapob)

aaWLpOB) aalWapOB)

,LpeBecHHa H apeBecHble - 88,5 - 77,7 - 10,8npO,ayKTbi

TonJnHBHaIi apesecHHa 0,3 0,1 0,2 0,1 0,0 0,0Henepepa6oTaHHa.q 328,9 5,2 310,7 4,7 18,2 0,5apeBecMHa (M3 )WJnanbi 1,6 0,3 0,9 0,1 0,7 0,2nHnoMaTepHa.nbl 5,2 - 3,7 - 1,5apeBecHoCTpy)IeHHble 4,8 3,5 1 ,4nfJ14TbI)IpeBecHoBoJIoKHHc- - 2,8 - 2,0 - 0,8Tbie n1iITbic1aHepa (M

3) 66,6 3,4 49,5 2,7 17,0 0,8

gepeBsiHHasI Tapa 10,2 2,7 1,1 1,7 9,1 1,0LpeBecHble 23,2 51,4 16,9 48,6 6,3 2,7CTpOiMaTep14anbiflpo6Ka m npolyKu1A - 2,0 - 1,9 - 0,1H3 npo6KH

Uien.rnHono3Haa - 2,2 - 0,3 - 1,9npOflYKUH

Cy.nb4aTHaA 0,0 0,1 0,0 0,1 0,0 0,0uejiiiojio3a,paCTBOPHMaSCyji4aTHaR 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0uejiiiojlo3a,HepaCTBOPMmaACyJu4PTHaA 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0ueiIojjlo3a,HepaCTBOPHMaS

EyMaxaiaH U KapTOHHaS - 289,3 - 245,6 - 43,7npOAYKUulL

ra3eTHan 6yMara 0,4 0,4 0,3 0,3 0,1 0,0ByMara 1 KapToH, 10,1 7,1 3,9 4,6 6,2 2,4HCMemeoBaHHbieKpa4xT-6ymara u 2,4 0,9 0,4 0,4 2,0 0,5KapToH,HeMeZJOBaHHbie,apyrHe B1UbI 6yMarm H 14,0 6,3 2,9 2,5 11,0 3,8KapToHa,HemeCOBaHHbieBymara m KapToH, 22,4 42,0 15,9 36,2 6,4 5,8nponuTaHHble060o 58,3 51,2 16,0 39,8 42,3 11,4ByMaKHble cpeaCTBa 15,4 52,4 13,1 51,3 2,3 1,1rur1eHbiByMaKHas U 30,6 38,2 18,5 33,4 12,1 4,8KaPTOHHaSI TapaEyMa)KHbie U 3,7 17,1 3,0 16,6 0,7 0,5KaPTOHHbIC RpjibIKH,pyrHe BHabl 16,1 20,3 8,8 14,1 7,3 6,26yMa)KHOA HKapToHHoAi npOayKUUH _I .

Bcero - 382,0 3255 3 | [ 56,5

IICTO'IHUK: TaMo)KeHHaS CT8THCTHKa no BHe[WHeC ToproBAe POCCUUCKOU (Penepaumi, 1995.

Page 253: Russian - World Bank Documents

HPPIJIO)KEHH4E F

Ta6AHua F.8: CTaBKH pOCCHHCKHX HMnOrTHbix TapH4)OB Ha iiecOnpOMbiLuIeHHYnpoAyKwuHio, 1994 - 95 rr.

Bwg npourywiKL [R CThBKM B X 07o crOtMOcrt Ha

I HroMn, 1994 r. [I HuI, 1995 r. 13 aBrycTa, 1996 r.

JapeBecHHa ui upeBecHbie npOaYKTbi 20 20TonAuMHasl apeBecuiHa 20 20 20Henepepa6oTaHHasq ApeBecuNHa 20 20 20p,pyri4e npOaYKTbi 13 TponriqeCKO1 apeBeCHtHbi 5 5 5Wnanbl 20 20 20rtunoMaTepHaJbi 20 20 20(1aHepa 13 Tpon['4CKOC apeBeCHHb[ 5 5 5,lpyrtie BUMbl (paHepbl 5 5,apeBecuHa ansi npOH3BOICTBa KapaHaaweg 15 15 IS,apeBeCHOCTpy)KeIHble nn UTbl 20 20 20,)peBeCHOcTpy)Ke'IHble nniliTbl, HeoTaeJIeaHHbie - 20 30,apeBecHoBoJ1OKHHCTble nfHTbl 20 20 20

aPaHepa 20 20 20EaepeB51HHa5I Tapa 20 20 20CTpouiMaTep14anbI U3 H peBeCHHbl 20 20 20Mo3aHIHblri napKeT 20 30,Epyrtie BMawb napKeTa 20 30fApyri4e npOUYKTbi 13 ABrl 20 20rlpoqtie apeBecHbie npOaYKTbl 20 20

npo6Ka U4 npo6KOBble llpoayKTb _ 0 5Uenfono3.03Haf npofYKuHsl 15 15

CyAbqpaTHasl UeAiojio3a, paCTBOPHMaR 15 15 15CyjibqaTHas ueAAlOA0lo3a, HepaCTBOpHMagI 15 15 15Cynbq)HTHasi Uejunloo3a, HepaCTBOptiMa5i 15 15 15

ByMara, KaPTOH U npOZYKTbi 13 HHX _ 15 15ra3eTHasi 6yMara 15 15 15ByMara H KapTOH, HeMejnoBaHHble 15 15 15ByMara ,1s4 o6oes 10 10 10Kpa4T-6yMara H KapToH, HeMejnoBaHHble 15 15 15Kpa¢T-6yMara ju1i. H3OJ1SiU414 1 5 5

(flpo,aojDiceHHe Ta6jiHUbI Ha cneTieyIou.teu cTpaHi4ue)

Page 254: Russian - World Bank Documents

nPiJIOKEHHE r

Ta6NIn[a r.8: CTaBKH pOCCHACKHX HMfnOpTHhix TapH4)OB Ha nieconpombumieHHrionpoAyKItHIO, 1994 - 95 rr. (npoAonw eHme)

.I _pixr Cmak B OTCWHMsOC771 Ha

I HJOJIH, 1994 r. I Imon, 1995 r. 13 aBrycia, 1996 r.

ApyrHe BH.Abl 6yMarH H KapTOHa, HeMeJlOBaHHbhe I5 15 15SyMara an.I ro.,pHPOBKH H3 reMmueCj1oA03bl 5 5CynbuTHasm o6epTo'HaR 6yMara 5 5 5lleprameHT, KaJbKa 5 5MHorochouHbie 6yMara H KaPTOH 5 5 5ByMara H KapToH ro(ppHpoBaHHbJe 20 20 20ByMara H KapToH, nponHTaHHblea 15 15 15ByMara H KapTOH 5 _ SBymara m KaPTOH U3 BOJIOKOH UeJLflIOJl03bl, npo'me _ 5BHablByMara, KaPTOH H noflOTHo 6

1 1 5PlcoBaa 6yMara I 5 506oH 15 15 ISByMa)KHbie cpeaCTBa rHrHeHbl 15 15 15TyaneTHas 6yMara 20 20 20ByMa)KHbie nonoTeHua 5nlpo2yKTbI, HcnoJb3yeMbIe B xHpyprm4ecKHx, 5Me,HUHHCKHX H rHrHeHH'ecKHx uenAxflpo4He 6yMa>KHbie cpencATBa rurmeHbl 5ByMaalKHacq H KapTOHHaq Tapa 10 10 10Kopo6KH 13 HerOxpHpOBaHHbIx 6yMarm H KapTOHa - 10 tonflc4e6yMa)KHbje MaTepHailbi 15 10 10ByMalKHble H KapTOHHbIe qp1JbhKH I 5 5PyJIOHbi, pOJIbl, KaTYuWKH 2 5 5flpoa'le BIlbi 6yMawKHoU H KapTOHHOri rlpO.lyKUNH 15 10 10Bymara H KapToH iiR 4)HJ1bTpOB I 5 5nepfoKapTbi 5 5 5Pa3J1HoBaHHaS 6yMara ann perFcTpaUHoHHoro I 5 5o6opyaoBaHIsByMara 1s1 MaUwiH 2 5 5KoHaeHcaTopHas 6yMara, npo%ime BSHbl I 5 5AepeBanepepa6aTbIBaiouee o6opyaoBaHHe 5 10 10CBepirnIbHble cTaHKU 5 5|Py6mnbHbie MawHiHbI 5 5

a Bymara H KaPTOH 13 ueAAoJI0o3HbIX BoJOKOH, 6enieHbIe, MeHee 150 r.

6 ByMara, KaPTOH U nloJIOTHO U3 ueJIJIIOJ03HbIX BOJIOKOH H np.

HICTOqHUK: TaMo)KeHHaq CTaTHCTHKa no BHeuwHeri Toprome POCCHRCKO (beaepaLuN, 1995 r.

Page 255: Russian - World Bank Documents

nPHJIOKEHME r

Ta6jnHxa r.9: HOMHHajibHbe exKeMeCAlqHbie iXeHbE npoAaxK no cyrTeJIbHbiM

AlCecoriMpillJbleHHbIM T0BapaM B POCCuH, 1994 H 1995 rr.

rO/McCln L(eHa B py6njfX 38 A3'6. M. Kypc BaIrTrT L(cHa a Aga/apax CILIA(py6./won. CMl4) 3a Ky6. M.

KpyrTf 1 xec | l,7ioMa- KpTffmIR iec | 7fiwoMa-

1994SIHBapb 18473 69495 1444 13 48(1eBpanb 22004 77307 1583 14 49MapT 23493 47091 1719 14 27Anpenb 26030 84101 1794 15 47Mau 29180 105808 1880 16 5614KOHb 3086 89668 1958 15 46W4Onb 30134 99314 2026 15 49ABryCT 30787 92264 2122 15 43CeHT%6pb 30875 106187 2347 13 45OKrA6pb 31217 115845 3044 10 38Hosi6pb 42341 127352 3151 13 40TIeKa6pb 52726 187812 3388 16 55CpeA. 3a ro[ 30612 100187 2212 14 45

1995SIHBapb 71249 249859 3858 18 65cDeBpanb 62559 293591 4259 15 69MapT 99623 210840 4749 21 44AnpeJ]b 116330 186332 5030 23 37Mau 127827 203476 5060 25 40JlIOHb 155567 222359 4709 33 47HIonb 159935 254977 4518 35 56ABryCT 164442 253872 4416 37 60CeHTsI6pb 173163 276384 4472 39 62OKTA6pb 164516 456322 4501 37 101Hom6pb 173659 457222 4544 38 101TJeKa6pb 175651 412332 4622 38 89CpeA. 3a roA 137043 290631 4566 30 64

npHMeqaHul:

1. aiaHHbIe B 3ToU Ta6rniue OTHOCSITCA K OnTOBbIM ueHaM.2. Kypc BaJllOTbl - 3To exKeMecSqHam CpeAHqq ayKUIOHHaS CTaBKa MOCKOBCKOU Me)K6aHKoBcKoAl BaJIOTHOri 6HpXKH.3. CpeRHeroaOBbie OnlTOBbie UeHbl (B TbIC. py6nieu) B 1993 H 1995 rr., coOTBeTCTBeHHO cocTaBjnihH: Ha Kpyrnibil nec - 7,4 H 89

3a Ky6. M; Ha nHnioMaTepuajibi - 22,6 u 284 3a Ky6. M; Ha 4aHepy - 116 H 1260 3a Ky6. M; Ha TAcn - 42 H 446 3a Ky6. M; Ha

ZaBn - 0.2 H 2,5 3a KBawpaTHbiri M; Ha ueCjLflOAO3Y - 165 H 3253 3a TOHHy; Ha 6yMary - 167 H 2847 3a TOHHy; H Ha KaPTOH -

110 H 2353 3a TOHHY. HCTOqHHK: HIMrll'l3linecnpoM Poccirn.

1HCT04HHK: rOCy3apCTBeHHbli KOMHTeT P(I) no CTaTHCTHKe, "IeHbl B POCCHH", 1996 r.

Page 256: Russian - World Bank Documents

IPI4J]O)KEIHI4E F

Ta6iiHAar[.i0: 9KCnOPTHasI cToHmocTb e1AHHHUbi POCCHJ4CKori J1CcoflombUIUMHHOt4

llpOJWKIHHM, 1994 H 1995 rr.(2 ao.,IapoB CLIL4 -a ToHHfy)

BHA nap aiwim 1994 1-995 _____

Bicemv 3a B crpatmfSw r 3a ] CTp3HbImpeaeffhi CHr! BC I flPCaiCJThI CHr!i - I CHF __CHr CHr

JapeBecHHa H a1peBecHbie nlpOZky]Ib[ToriLHBHaRn peBecrnHa 31 3 1 32 38 38 23Henepepa6oTaHHa5 .UpeBecHHa (3a m

3) 52 53 37 58 58 47

WnaAbib 161 107 163 ISO 149 150(13aHepa (3a m3) 233 238 162 288 287 321£AepeBSHHa.9 Tapa 90 134 76 124 150 105CTpoAMaTepHa.nbi m3JlpeBecHIHbi 497 517 493 637 589 667

Ueiulo'IOJ3Ha.a lpoIIyKUHRCyJ1bq)aTHa5i ueJUoJ!o3a, paCTBOPHmaq 553 546 561 1079 1076 1148Cyrn4aTHagi ueiiino3a, 399 402 357 698 700 637HepaCTBOPHMaS1Cynlbd)tTHa.q IIenjijioJI03a, 360 374 251 604 599 709HepaCTBOPHMasi

ByMara Hi KaPTOH i nlpoayKTbi M3 HHIXra3eTas 6ymara 289 287 302 595 592 631bymara Hi KapToH, HemeJIOBaHHb2e 397 379 408 700 720 654Kpaq)T-6ymara H KaPTOH, 288 291 278 569 556 749HemejloBaHHbieJIpyrHie EHKabi 6ymarH H KapToHa, 284 270 314 560 562 678HeMeiIoBaHHbieSymara H KapTOH, meJloBaHHbie H.A. H.Li. H.A. 919 594 1.579Bymara H KapTOH, npolPOlTaHHble 427 375 608 670 583 1.2580 6

OH1 641 562 686 1.459 848 1.645byma)KHbie cpe.aCTBa PlFtiHblH 601 548 642 1.326 1.469 1.223Byma)KcHaai H KaPTOHHa.H Tapa 597 366 654 962 851 1.003bymaACHbie H KaPTOHHbie S4pJIbIKH 1.922 1.015 1.995 H.4a. H.J1. HJ.;j,jlpyrHec BHaIbi 6yma)KHOAi H KaPT0HHOA 689 649 701 1633 724 1.956IIpOQ WKUHH I__I __ I I _ _ _ _ I _ _ _ _ I _ _ _ _ I

1ptiMe,iaHlie: 9KcnOPTHa.R CTOHIMOCTh eCmHHUbI FTpOaYKUl*H paBHa o6Wueg CT0I.IMOCTH4 3KcnIopTa, ej1ie]HHOHl Ha o6-bem '3KCnIOpTano KaX21Omy nlpo2yKTy.

I14CTO'iIHHK: TamoiKeHHasI cTaTHCTHKa no BHeuiueri ToproBjie POCCHriCK9OI 1ellepaumH, 1994 H 1995 rr.

Page 257: Russian - World Bank Documents

fPHJO)KEHIE F

Ta6nni a F.11: ,)HHaMHKa 3KCnopTHblIX LeH Ha pOCCHHCKHH H HoBo3eJIaH CKMH KpyrniblHnec B 5lnOHHH, 1993 - 95 rr.

(,aonmapoB CILUA 3a Ky6oMeTp)

r04|MeCRUT POccim#cKmi# KpyrJlhd iec (CHOiP) HOBaweIa,cCKxM KPyr#IhIiCC H3 COCHUb JIYVHCTOM

Eetff | ffMCTBCMMUa COCHa 4peBCCMHH CMOIfMCThR

1993OKTs6pb 112 92 Ito 85 90Hom6pb 112 90 114 85-90LleKa6pb 112 90 114 85-90

1994SHBapb 116 91 114 1o0(1eBpanb 125 91 120 110MapT 130 95 127 110AnpeAb 131 96 127 120Mau 131 96 127 120!IOHb 131 96 120 120

1410Jlb 131 96 118 113ABryCT 137 100 128 113CeHTm6pb 143 106 134 113OKTm6pb 143 106 134 ItoHosI6pb 144 108 142 110AeKa6pb 144 108 142 110

19955lHBapb 145 113 145 112(0eBpanb 145 117 147 112MapT 145 124 147 112Anpenb 138 128 140 124Mau 138 128 140 12414 oHb 128 124 127 12414oJlb 122 117 127 125ABryCT 119 115 127 125CeHTq6pb 1 00 110 127 125

flpHMe'aHH$1. POCCHA1CKaq 6enaa apeBecHHa, 22 - 30 cM; 3,65; 3,7; 3,8 M; CH1D B SiinOHCKHX MOPCKUX nopTax.

2. PoccHucKaq .INCTBeHHHua, 22 - 30 cM; 3,8; 4 M; CH B SBqnOHCKHX MOPCKHX nopTax.

3. POCCHACKaq cocHa cMonJHcTaI, 22 - 30 cM; 3,8; 4 M; CW14 B $inOHCKHX MOPCKUX nopTax.4. HoBo3enaHAcKaq COCHa iiyqrncTas, COpT, 00O5.

HCTOMHHK: Japan Lumber Reports, October 27, 1995.

Page 258: Russian - World Bank Documents

HPHJIOKEHHE r

Ta6mgI[a F.12: HMnoprHbue iCeHM (CH0D) Ha XBO1HbCe nHjioMaTepHaJIhl H3 POCCHH HKaHaMwb B BCIZHKo6pHTaHHH, 1993 - 95 rr.

&(awJapoB CLIA 38 Ky6OMCIp)

ragIN/M 9a L(eHhl CIHO COO7HOHIlCHHCe LH HaIpqdoxI4aN) 113 Poc2C H KaHm44T

(KaHoma = 100)__3 Pocciw 1f3 KaH44M _

1993SHBapb 155 185 840eBpanb 147 181 81Mapr 124 240 52Anpejb 155 239 65MaA 165 200 82HIoHb 154 210 73HIoJib 160 288 55AerycT 151 343 44CeHTm6pb 162 285 57OKTm6pb 152 152 100HoR6pb 162 173 94JIeKa6pb 162 243 67CpeA. 3a roA 154 228 67

1994AHiBapb 163 259 630DeBpanb 158 234 67MapT 100 230 43AnpeJib 178 321 55Mari 181 255 71HIOHb 193 307 63H4onb 201 262 77ABrYCT 197 233 84CeHTm6pb 207 261 79OKTr.6pb 171 268 64HoR6pb 218 322 67leKa6pb 222 295 75

CpeA. 3a roA 182 270 67

'995SHBapb 200 249 81ODeBpaJb 212 286 74Maprr 210 288 73AnpeAb 202 296 68Mari 204 308 66HIOHb 203 278 73HloJIb 208 228 91ABrycT 194 292 66CCHTR6pb 207 305 68OKTrs6pb 173 326 53HoA6pb 171 323 53

AeKa6pb 173 260 67CpeM. 3a roA 196 287 68

HCT0oHHKw: Timber Builletin. Vol. XLVIII (1995), No. I H Vol. XLIX (1996), No. 1, Forest Product Prices.

Page 259: Russian - World Bank Documents

HPIIPO)KEHME r

Ta6 nHa r.13. Anb'epHaTKBHhae CileHapHH noTeH1lHaJbHbiX FroOBbiX HaJorOBb1XnocrynneHHtk B iieCHOM ceKcrope PoccHH

(inH. JWJLlIBPOB CIlIA)

CL(CHapHn flo.IylCfHHi H8JIOIPR Upm O6zeMax flpO)38PCWlRf JI8lC#MHMf, PWBHUXI/O MJIH. Ky6OMeTpOB 300 M1IH. Ky6oMeTpo |

(CernzwH>iiilur ypOielb) (B3MOXHMU MKCHMYM qpMHCKC7DII(WJIhHOM

1. CTaBKH J1eCHbIX noaaTeriCueHapuiH 1:3 3iojU1./M 3 330 900CueHapmH 2: 6 aojm./M3 660 1800CueHapRtui 3: 10 .aoj./M 3 1100 3000

2. HaniorH C JIeco3aroToBITeJibHblX KoMnaHKHIA. CTOHMOCTb

CueHapUH 1: 20noju./M 3 2200 6000CueHapmi 2: 15 jnon./M 3 1650 4500CueHapiH 3: 10aoJIJI./M3 1100 3000

S. Baioeas npH6bjnzbCueHapHA 1: 2 nonn 1/M

3 220 600CueHapui 2: 4 .ojui./M 3 440 1200CueHapH4i 3: 5 aojJi./M 3 550 1500

B. Ha.nor (35%)CueHapHig 1 77 210CueHapiH 2 154 420CueHapHi 3 193 525

3. HaiorH Ha nepeBonepepa6oTKyA. rlpOH3BOaoCTBo UeJIJI]OJ103HOPi npO2YKUHN

(50% o6feMa npOH3BoacTBa apeBeCHHbl)a. CTOHMOCTb npOIYKUHH

CueHapHHi 1: npH 500,aonin. 3aTOHHY 4583 12500CueHapHA 2: npH 600 nonji. 3a TOHHY 5500 15000CueHapri4 3: npu 700 aonA. 3a TOHHY 6417 175006. BawioBaa npH6bulb (20%)

CueHapH H 1 917 2500CueHapUHi 2 1100 3000CueHapHA 3 1283 3500B. Hanor (35%)CueHapiiH I 321 875CueHapi4A 2 385 1050CueHapUHt 3 449 1225

B. flHuloMaTepHajibi (50% o6teMa nplO3BOJICTBaapeBeCHHbl)

a. CTOUMOCTb npOJ,YKUMMCueHapHi 1: npH 125 aonn./M3 2750 7500CueHapHw 2: npuH 150I 2onn./M3 3300 9000CueHapHHA 3: npu 175 2ojIjI./M3 3850 10500

(UIpoaooiuKeHHe Ta6iULLbI Ha cJ1eayloLefg cTpaHHUe)

Page 260: Russian - World Bank Documents

HPHJ1OKEHHE F

Ta6nRH1a F.13: AnbTepHaTHBHblie CLeHapHH noTeHLIHaabHbix roAOBbix HanOFOBbDX

nocTyrLJieHHRi B JieCHOM ceKcrope POCCHH (npOAoAxieHHe)(WMfH. 4OJIMPOB CILI)

CLCeHapMN flOJYYeCHHR H&aoOr> R npm o6ZeMax HPOM350/CTBa lr l paiHUxI ~~~~~~~~300 AH/I. KYtY0MCTJOB

(Bo3MoxNhfM/i MaIKCMMYM lip,ffHCNCW7DI4ECJThOM

6. BaAoBa.l npH6bulb (20%)CueHapuid 1 550 1500CueHapuu 2 660 1800CueHapHu 3 770 2100

B. Hanor (35%)CueHapHu I 193 525CueHapHu 2 231 630CueHapHtu 3 270 735

06uwa CyMMa HaJioroBbix nOCTyTUIeHHMtCueHapH 1 921 2510CueHap"H 2 1430 3900CueHapHri 3 2012 5485

rlpHMe'aHHW:

1. 3KcnopTHaH napHTeTHaS ueHa Ha Haenepepa6oTaHHylo apeBeCHHY C'lHTaeTcT paBHoH 55 Ao.n./M3

2. CpeaHHe 3aTpaTbl Ha BHyfpeHHJOIO TpaHcnopTHpOBKY CquTaioTcH paBHbIMH 30 Aonn./M3

3a Ky6oMeTp Kpyr.foro neca

(cpe,aHee B3BeCeHHoe pacCTOJHHUe nepeBO3KI no xKene3HO Aopore PaBHo npHMepHO 1000 KM).3. Pa3HHua MexKay 3KCnOpTHOA napHTeTHOH ueHOH H TpaHCnOpTHbiMH pacXoaaMH BKjiiomaeT B ce6H iiecHbie noflaTH, 3aTpaTbI

Ha JICC03arOTOBKY U BaJIoByio npti6bulb.4. Hanor Ha o6Luyio npU6blJb CMHraeTCm paBHbiM 35% BanOBO11 npH6bum. B 3Ty OuCHKY He BKJIOioeHbl apyrue BaxHbie HaniOrti

THna: HajiorOB Ha 3apa6oTHylo nfiaTy H Ha.nora Ha go6aBJieHHyIO CTOHMOCTb (HAC), KoTopbIe BMeCTe no pa3mepy paBHbiHajiory Ha npH6bulb.

5. BaaoBaA npH6bLTlb C4HTaeTCA paBHoN 20% OTr nporHO3HpyeMbix ueH Ha ueJnnO.9o3Hypo npOYKUHIO U nHunoMaTepHajibi.6. JliuA rPpOI.3BOaCTBa O11HOU TOHHbl uejijlIOJ1O3Hofi npoalyKuHm Tpe6yeTcR 6 Ky6oMeTpOB apeBecHHbI.7. OaMH Ky6oMeTp He nepepa6oTaHHoA ApeBecHHbl aaeT 0,4 Ky6H'eCKHX MeTpoB nuinoMaTepHajloB.

R4CTO1HHUK: OueHKH cneuHanjiHCTOB BceMHpHoro 6aHKa, 1996.

Page 261: Russian - World Bank Documents

nPHJI)OKEHHE A

3HAMEHME TPAHCHOPTA H lOPTOBbIX COOPY)KEHMA AM YCTOh4HBOrO PA3BHT1SIJIECOnPOMblWJIIIEHHOFO KOMnJ1EKCA

Pe4)opMa H CTPYKTYPHaA HepecTpouKa ITeCHOFO ceKTopa aoJDKHa OKa3aTb3HaMHTenJbHoe BJIHAHHe Ha pa3BHTHe TpaHCnOpTHOrl CHCTeMbi, oco6eHHo B CU6HpH H Ha,aaJ1bHeM BocToKe. HpH LteHTpaYIH3OBaHHOM nniaHHPOBaHHH TpaHCnOpT npeBpaTHJICSI B,ROTauHOHHyIO c4epy aeATeJlbHOCTH, COBepweUHHO He rTpHcnoco6jIeHHylo K noTpe6HocTqMpbIHOHIHOU 3KOHOMHKH. Hapqay c 6OJIbWUHHCTBOM apy'HX CeKTOpOB 3KOHOMHKH, BCATpaHCROPTHaA CHCTeMa POcCHH cTpaaaeT B HacToAmee BpeMA OT 43HHaHCOBOU H

a,aMHHHCTpaTHBHOr4 HeynopqaoMeHHOCTH. 1H()JDHLHOHHoe aBjieHiHe Ha YPOBeHb 3apa6oTHoAnHiaTbl H ueH Ha TOnHJHBO - B co0eTaHHH Cc naaeHHeM cnpoca H coKpaleHHem o6'beManpOH3BOTCTBa - co3LaaeT AOnOJHHTenJbHYIO Harpy3Ky Ha rocyaapCTBeHHbie ( HHaHCOBbiepecypcbl, 3a C'eT KOTOpbIX npHXoa04TCA 4)HHaHCHpOBaTb H3Laep)KKH, He nOKpblBaeMbIe2aOxOaaMH OT OCHOBHOU aeATeJIbHOCTH MHor4x TpaHCnOPTHbIX opraH43aLuHf.

I'cTopH'ecKH, )Kenje3HbIe H aBToMo6HJIbHbie aoporH, npoJIeraIoLuHe BaOAb IO)KHbIXrpaHHU CH6HpH H LaaJIbHero BocToKa npOBOIHJIHCb HO HanpasBeHHIO C 3anaaa Ha BOCTOK.9TH ,oporiH 6bUIH nOCTpoeHbi rFJaBHbIM o6pa3oM XIA Toro, IlTO6bI CBH3aTb 3anaaHbie paHOHbIPoccHH c 6oraTbIMH rpHp,OaHbIMH pecypcaMH TePPHTOpHAMH CH6HpH H laaJbHero BocToKa,o6ecneqHTb paciMupeHHe TOproBJIH H yaoBJ1eTBOp1Tb BoeHHbie Hy)KlI. TaK, B 4aCTHOCTH,OCHOBHbie nOTOKH AenjOBOu RpeBeCHHbI HanpalBJIAUHCb C ceBepa Ha ior B 3anaaHyIO qaCTb

POCCHH, B ceBCpHbIe nOpTbI Xn5 BbIBO3a 3a npegeIbi CTpaHbl; a TaKCKe B THXOOKeaHCKHenOpTbl, KyXa nlec, B OCHOBHOM, 3aBO3HJICH H3 pagOHOB BOCTOHHOU CH6HPH. 3HaqHTeAbHblHo6beM aeAoBoH apeBec4Hbi nepenpaBnAJIcq TaKX(e no peKaM H O3epaM. nO HMeloLUHMCAoueHKaM, no Mmepe yBeH4eHHI4 o6beMa jieCO3aroToBoK H rpoTADKeHHOCTH TpaHCnOpTHbIXMapWUIYTOB noTpe6HocTb B Keiie3HoaLopOKHoM TpaHCnOpTe 6yaeT paCTH.

BAbi TpaHcnopTa

B HaCTORLuee BpeMA AeConPO,yKUHR B POCCHH nePeB03HTCRI cleaYo}uHMo6pa3OM: no wKeJIe3HbIM aoporaM (60% o6Luero o6beMa); BHYTpeHHHM BOaHbIMH HYTHMH(24%); nio aBToMo6HJ1bHbIM aoporaM (11%), a TaKJKe cygaaMl MOPCKOFO ToproBoro 4UIoTa(4%). 3Ha'HTeJ¶bHaA IaCTb 3arOTOBAeHHoro nieca criaBJISIeTCA riO peKaM co6CTBeHHbIMHCHAiMH AeCorpoMbblUweHHb[X rpeanpHqTHV4 H, cKopee Bcero, He Yt1HTbIBaeTCq TpaHCrIOpTHOUiCTaT4CTHKOA. I,JA TpaHCnOpTHpOBKH neca IH4pOKO HCnOAb3ylOTCq ceumHaibHbie peqHbie HMOPCKHe TepMHHaJbl, KOTOpbie HMelOT COOTBeTCTByIOLLee norpy3oqHo-pa3rpy3oqHoeo6OpynOBaHHe, oTjiHUaIOLiteeCSq OT O6OpygOBaHHA, YCTaHOBjieHHOrO B peMHbIX H MOPCKHX

nopTax o6iuero Ha3HaMeHHA. Hau6onee MOWHbIM H aKTHBHO HCHOJTb3yeMb[X H3 HHX 5iBnAeTCMTepMH4HaT CaHKT- leTep6ypra, 4epe3 KOTOpblU4 TpaHCHOpTH4pyOTCA 3Ha'-HTeJIbHble o6'beMbl,aejiOBOu ,ApeBeCHHbl, npeAHa3Ha4eHHOr4 KaK AAA BHyTpeHHerO noTpe6jieHHH, TaK H Ha3KCnOpT.

Page 262: Russian - World Bank Documents

258 nPHJIJOEHIE )i,

)Kejie3HoAopoKHbie TapH4)b1 CoCTaBAR5OT B HacToAiuiee BpeMA 3Ha4HTenbHylo

MaCTb OT ueHbi nocTynaioweri Ha pbIHOK apeBecHHbH. B POCCHH AnA Bcex perFoHoB cTpaHbIyCTaHOBJeHa )KeCTKa$ TapH4)HaR CeTKa, B OCHOBY KOTOPOU nOflO)KeHbl He peanbHbieH3Aep)KKH no AOCTaBKe TOBapOB Ha pbIHOK, a peHTa6eJIbHOCTb nepeBO3HMOrO rpy3a 14

paCxo2bI, B03HHKaIOIUHe B npouecce nepeBO3KH (norpy3Ka/pa3rpy3Ka). FBiaroaaps TOMY 'ITO

TapH4bbl OAIlHaKOBbl fAAA Bcex perHOHOB, perHOHbl 4baKTH'eCKH cy6cHxHpyIoT apyr iapyra.

PeaxIbHbie TpaHCnOpTHbie H3XAePXKKH (H3 pacqeTa Ha OlaHy TOHHy rpy3a) Kone6jlioTcq OT

7,65-11,50 aojui. CHIIA (c OTnpaBKOr4 H3 Xa6apoBcKa) ao 45,80 ,aouin. CIWA (c OTnpaHBKO

H3 KpaCHOqpCKa B nOPT HaxogKa) ii 43,70 aoJIJIapOB CWA (U3 KpacHoApcKa jao

eBpOnIerCKHx nOpTOB). HeTpyaHo nOH5ITb, 'ITO BbIB03 B EBpony HuiH cTpaHbi THxooKeaHCKoro

perHoHa Henepepa6OTaHHOH IieCHOui npOaYKUHH uu114 npOfHyKIuH4, HMeiowei He6OJIbWyIo

,ao6aBneHHyIo CTOHMOCTb, ABnA5eTCA He3KOHOMH'IHbIM, npHHeM peHTa6eJIbHoCTb 6yIeT H

,aanbme CHH)KaTbCS no mepe npH6nw4ceHHs )KeIie3HOXaOpO)KHbIX TapH4OB K YPOBHIO peanbHbIX

H3,Aep)KeK.

B pamKax npoeKTa pa3BHTHS TpaHCnOpTHOFO KopHf,opa B YCTbe peKH TyMeH-

TyMaHHaS npez,naraeTcA Co3JaTb CKB03HOA )KeJie3HOXOpOXKHbl4 KOPHLIOp ao Tu4xoro oKeaHa3a c'eT nyCKa B 3KcnJIyaTaBuiHo neperoHoB qIok6ajicaH (MHP) - MaHbXcypisq (KHP) HXap6HH (KHP) - yCTbe peKH TyMeH-TyMaHHaA (rpaHnuua Poccuu H KHJIP). CornacHOoILeHKaM, 3Ta TpaHCnOPTHaS cHcTeMa 6y1eT HMeTb aOCTyn K 150 MJIH. noTpe6HTeneR B

CH6HpH H Ha IaaJbHeM BocToKe, B MOHrOJIHH, KHTae H KOpeUcKofi HapoaHori

)jeMOKpaTwiecKOH Pecny6nIHKe H K 2000 roay aOJDHa o6ecne'HTb e)KeroaHblHI rpy3oo6OpoT,

paBHblii 3 MJIH. TOHH (Kehr, 1994). 9Ta TpaHCnOpTHaS MarHcTpaJIb COKpaTHT pacCTOAHHue AAA

XaOCTaBKH pOCCHUCKHX 3KcnOPTHbix rpy3OB B CTpaHbi THxooKeaHcKoro perUOHa Ha 2 TbIC. KM.

Ha pa6oTy pel'Horo TpaHCnOpTa cyiUeCTBeHHoe BJIHAHHCe oKa3bIBaioT

KJIHMaTH'IecK4e yCJIOBHS, B qaCTHOCTH, TeMnepaTypbl Hi)Ke 0OC, KOTOpbIe, XOTA H

OrpaHH'IHBalOT ABH)KeHHe CyAOB, OAHOBpeMeHHO co3,alOT eieSAHbIe nyTH, nO3BOJISIOlLue

OpraHH30BaTb ,BH)KeHHe rpy30Boro aBTOTpaHCHOpTa. JEaw1bHeruee 3Ha HTeJbHOe yBenJI4IeHHe

o6,beMOB lepeBO3KH apeBeCHHbI pelqHbIM TpaHCHIOpTOM orpaHH4qHBaeTCq TeM, ITO

3KOHOMHi4eCKH AOCTynHbie JIeC03aFOTOBHTeJlbHbie peCypCbl B oKpeCTHOCTIX CyaOXOaHbIX peK

y)Ke B 3Ha'i4TeJIbHO4 mepe 4CTOLueHbl.

B CH6HpH H Ha ,aajIbHeM BocToKe aBTOTpaHCHOpT, no-rpe)KHeMy, HeaOCTaTO'HO

pa3BHT - OT'aCTH 3T0 o6ibsCHAeTCs TeM, -ITO B npoulIOM ero pa3BHTH1O He yeRen5U1Ocb

,AonJKHorO BHHMaHSA. KpoMe Toro, CHJIbHbIe Ce3OHHbie KjIMaTH'IeCKHe KoJIe6aHHS

orIpaHH'HBalOT aBTOTpaHCnOPTHb1e nepeBO3KH B pa3J1H'HbIX MeCTaX 3Toro perioHa KaK

JieTOM, TaK H 3HMO1. Ewe oaHa npo6fleMa 3aKmioLiaeTc$ B TOM, 'TO AAA nepeBO3KH 6peBeH,

BMeCTO o6Jier'eHHbIx 1 o6opyaOBaHHbIX CneuRaHJbHblMH npHcnoco6JIeHHqmH TpaHCnOPTHbIX

Cpe,ACTB, HcnoJIb3ylOTCH TH5DeKbIe rPY3OBHKH o6wuero Ha3Ha'eHHq, KOTOpbie pa3pywUaloTraOpOKHOe nOKpbITHe H 3eMeJIbHblH nOKPOB U HaHOCIT TeM CaMbIM TqxeCIblg YpOH

oKpyKaiolueH cpeae. ,LspyrHM orpaHH'IHBaiowuHM 4aKTopoM B HCnOJ1b3OBaHHH

aBTOTpaHCnOpTa ABASROTCS IOJIOMKH TpaHCnOPTHb1X CpeaCTB U npo6neMbl, CBM3aHHbie C

OTCYTCTBHeM B03MO)KHOCTH OiepaTHBHOU 3aKynKH 3anaCHb1X qacTer XIA peMOHTa, KOTOpbie

K TOMY wKe nOCTOASHHO paCTYT B LeHe. JOnOHOHHTenbHy1O npo6iieMy co3LaalOT 6onbWuHe

paCCTOAHHA Me)Ky nepepa6aTbIBaioiuHMH ripeCnpflH TH14MH u MeCTaMH fO6bIMH TpeBeC4Hbl.

B Ta6nI. ,R. I npHBeaeHa CBOaHaA HHOPMOLmuHA 0 POCCUUCKHX riopTax H HX

nponycKHorl cnoco6HocTH. BOJIbUIHHCTBO KpynHb1X nOpTOB Ha uaajbHeM BocToKe no-

Page 263: Russian - World Bank Documents

259 HPIIAO)KEHHEJa

npe)KHeMy npUHHWeAT)KHT dJeAepaJibHOMy npaBHTeJIbCTBy, XOTA HeKOTOpb1e TePMHHHJabI 6bijTHnpHBaTH3HuOBaHbi H CTanJH aKLKUHepHb[MH o6uaecTBaMti. B Tex cTy'aAIx, KorganpHBaTH3aLtH.I o6ecneMHna YCJIOBHAI AJIAI B03HHKHOBeHHA KOHKypeHUHH (KaK, HaripHMep, Bnopry COBeTCKaSI raBaHb, KOTOpbiU paHbwUe 6bm BOeHHbEM TepMUHajioM), nnaTa 3a nOpTOBOeo6cjiy)KHBaHHe yBeiJHqi4iiacb 3a nocJieAHHe TpU rona B 800 - 1000 pa3 (AlJu cpaBHeHHSl: nniaTa3a HOJIb3OBaHHe KeCJe3HbIMHa oporaMH Bo3pocna Ha 4000%).

ToproBEze MapTulpYTri H MOpCKHe CyAROXOARHbie KoMnaHHH

B Ta6ji. n.2 aaeTcsA cBOAHaAl HH4opMauHH O nepeBO3Ke JieconpoLIyKUH4 nopa3HbIM TOprOBbIM MapipyTaM 3a 1995 roA H B nepHOA Ao 1991 roAa. B Ta6ji. ,a.3 npHBeAeHnporHO3 ,AKHaMHKH nepeBO3OK pOCCHCKOrO iieca MOpCKHM TpaHCnOpTOM (c pa36HBKOA nonOPTOBbIM 6acceulHaM). OCHOBHbIMU MOpCKHMH repeBO3MHKamM B POCCHH (He Bce OHH3aHHMalOTCSA ToproBjiei JIecoM Hunu npoAyK.Umel H3 ApeBeCHHbl) SBJIASIIOTC:

* CeBepHoe MopcKoe napOXOACTBO (wTa6-KBapTipa AIKyTcKoro quHuHaiia B r.THKCH); ero (AOT COCTOHT rIiaBHbIM o6pa3oM H3 CyIOB AJIsl nepeBO3KH rpy3OBo6luero Ha3HaMeHl4, npHMeM MHOrHe H3 HHX OTHOCSATCA K cyaamM neAOKOJIbHoro

Knacca".

* Hau60inee AHBepCH4JHUHPOBaHHbIM H TeXHHMeCKH OCHaLueHHblM HepeBO3'IHKOMHMBJIReTCA F3aJITHUCKOe MOpCKOe napOXOACTBO, HMeioIee WTa6-KBapTHpy B r.CaHKT-HeTep6ypre. Y4aCTBy5I B 06CiyXCHBaHH1 KaK BHeliWHHX, TaK BHyTpeHHHXToprOBbIX onepaLuHuH 3KCnuiyaTipyqS 6o0iee 150 CyAOB, 3TO napOXOICTBO HMeeT 343aperlCTpHpOBaHHbIX neCoBo3a, HoIJHasl rpy3OHoAbeMHOCTb Ka)KAoro H3 HHXCOCTaBJIAeT 4.350 T.

* BTOpbM no pa3Mepy (nocnie E)aj¶TrHcKoro MopcKoro napOXOACTBa) nepeBO3'-HKOMSlBji5eTC5i aaAbHeBOCTO4HOe MOpCKOe napOXOACTBO, KOTOpOe He TOJIbKO BbinOJIHleTcaMble pa3HOnPO(DHIbHbie TpaHCUIOPTHbIe onepauHH, HO H o6cAy)KMBaeTnpaKTH4eCKH BeCb o6tbeM npH6peXKHOA TOprOBJIH B paroHe THXOOKeaHCKorOno6epeKbsi. IlcnOJIb3y$l 39 JieCOBO3OB (noJrHasl rpy3onoabeMHOCTb OT 4000 Ao 6000T), KOMraHH5I OCcylIeCTBJTIAeT lepeBO3KH H3 nopTa BAa,aHBOCTOK.

* KaM4aTCKoe napOXOTACTBO, CO WLTa6-KBapT4pOrl B lleTponaBjloBcKe-KaMwaTcKoM,HMeeT d)JIOT, COCTOSIlUH rifaBHbIM o6pa3oM H3 He6OJ1bLHX CyRoB 1AJs nepeBO3KH

reHepanibHbIx rpy3OB, KOPHYC KOTOpbIX yKpeniieH AAAI rpoXo)KAeHHA AbAOB.

* MypMaHcKoe napOXOACTBO, CO WTa6-KBapT4poH B MypMaHCKe, MieeTBHYWTHTejbHbli d)JIOT CyAOB-AeieOKOJIOB H o6wHpHyIO CCTb o6CJyKHBaeMbixTOPrOBbIX MaplIWDYTOB B 3anaaHyio EBPOny H CpeaH3eMHOMOPCKHA perHOH.

1~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Page 264: Russian - World Bank Documents

nPHJ1OKEHHE )

Ta6nrnHa A.1. nIpOryCKHaS CIIOCo6HoCTb pOCCHUiCKUX nOPTOB

(c pa36HBKoR no perHoHaM), Mfl. T

ppODyCKH9aE A TbTepHifTaHHme oJcHKH

C170C06HoCTh

fOpm, (COlo3MOPH,f If-npoeKT)

O0teHKa HosoC apynie He6amb- 061lau

Bce,dptpHo- CI 70Thl,90O 17pHV8JIM WLae rrpOn7yCK-

Iv 6aHKa nopTm Hfau CnO-CO6HOcTb

CeBepHliA 6accedHApxaHrejibcK 3,61 5,70 0 0 0 5,70

MypMaHcK 9,33 11,15 3,80 1,24 0 16,19

Apyruie nOpTbI 0 0 0 0 6,15 6,15

Bcero 12,94 16,85 3,80 1,24 6,15 28,04

BaJrrHMCKH61 6aCceKH

C.-neTep6ypr 12,48 19,3 4,80 3,53 0 27,63

KaumHiHrpaa 4,90 6,90 0 0 0 6,90

Apyriie nopTbi 0 0 0 0 2,31 2,31

Bcero 17,38 26,2 4,80 3,53 2,31 36,84

A3oBcKo-'lepHoMopcKHR6acceHH 47,19 47,83 0 2,90 0 50,73

HOBOPOCCH"CK 17,50 18,50 0 0 0 18,50

Tyance 0 0 0 0 0,69 0,69

ApyrHe nlOpTbl 64,69 66,33 0 2,90 0,69 69,62

Bcero

THxooKeaHCKHH 6acceCHBaHHHo 8,45 12,47 0 0 0 12,47

BocToiHbiU 10,30 14,3 0,40 0 0 14,70

HaxoJRKa 5,18 8,85 0,24 6,30 0 15,39

BjlaaJrBocToK 4,32 7,69 0,24 2,00 0 9,93

Xlpyrme nOpTbI 0 0 0 0 4,56 4,56

Bcero 28,25 43,31 0,88 8,30 4,56 57,05

Bce 6acceiHim 123,26 152,69 9,48 15t97 13,71 191,85

HcToYHHcfK BceMHpHbUi 6aHK, 1996 r.

Page 265: Russian - World Bank Documents

261 HIPHAO)KEHNEa

Ta6AlHia JJ.2. Toproanm AeCHOti npOAyKIuHer H ToproBbie Mapw IpyTbI B POCCHH,AVMli. T

TopnBMe MapliiDyrw If J7po5Lm2 4o 1991 r. [ 1995 r.ELacri1CkKoe if 6Joe MOpq

nIt1oBo0rHK U4 4aHepHblA Kp%DK 0,81 0,90BanaHcoBaa apeBecCiHa 3,95 0,80nI ijOMaTepHaJ1bi 2,54 1,40Llena 0,04

UejiAono3a 0,22 0,30|EyMara/KapToH 0,05 0,50

Bcero 7,52 3,90Twxif,# oKCaH

|nHloaoB4i*HK U qaHepHblr KP$DK 4,98 4.50BaflaHcoBaES apeBecHHa 1,38 1,50ni HAoMaTepua4bi 0,34 0,20Llena 0,31 0,20L l oiio3a 0,10 0,10

|Bcero 7,11 6,50VepHoe Mope

BanaHcoBas apeBecHHa 0,34 0,30r| iAoMoaTepHanbl 0,85 0,40Uennionio3a 0,26 0,20ra3eTHaSq 6yMara 0,17 1,00ByMara/KapToH 0,33 0,30

Bcero 1,95 2,30

fifworo 16,58 [ 12.60

HCToYHIIKf rocyaapCTBeHHblA TaMoCeHHbig KOMmTeT PoCcHUCKO Oeaepaumm.

Ta6.nHlHa J.3. HporHo3 3KciopTa neca, TpaHCHOpTUHpyeMOrO MOpCKHM HyTeM H3 POCCHH B2000 H 2005 rr. (c pa36HBKoA Ho 1OpTOBbiM 6acceriHaM), wH. T

17opToBbl. 6acceriH 2000 r. 2005 r.I oIMopHHJn7poeXr AnIbrpHarHHuMe CoiwmopHwmnpoeIrKT AmbTepHaTHoHme=_________________ I _______ ____ _ ____ OI4CHKII | fOO4CHKMCeBepHbIA 2,03 1.22 2,82 1,49SamTlhCKIIH 2,36 1,16 2,40 1,22'epHOMopCKH4I 0,79 0,43 0,80 0,51THxooKeaHcKHu 5,00 3,30 6,20 4,07Horo 10,1 6,12 12,22 7,29

HCTOYHHf/c. BceM14pHbJU 6aHK, 1996r.

* CeBepHoe napoXoacTBo 3aHUMaeTCA rZaBHbIM o6pa3oM nepeBo3Ko0irIHJIOMaTepHaJIOB, KapTOHa H 6aJJaHCOBOUi apeBeCHHbl 13 CeBepHb1X paUOHOB B3ana,aHyio EBpony, CpeAH3eMHoMopcK14i pertIoH, AdPpHKY H CoeaHHeHHbieWTaTbi AMepHKH. Ero 4uIOT cocTaBJ1$lOT 6o0ee 100 CyaOB AnA nepeBO3KI4 rpY3OB

o6Luero Ha3HaMeHHH nOAHoH rpy3ono,ibeMHOCTbIo OT 2500 ,Io 6000 TOHH.

Page 266: Russian - World Bank Documents

262 nPJ1O)KEH HE A

* HoBopoccHAcKoe napoXOLCTBO, CO WTa6-KBapTHpOrU B HoBopocCllhcKe, ycneWLHO

HaJaHJIO rapTHepcKHe OTHOTHoeHH5I CO CKaHiaHHaBCKHMH cTpaHaMH, OpraHH3OBaB

O4lWOpHbl CyaOXO,aHbIi 6H3Hec. 3HaqlTeJIbHylO 4aCTb ero 4fnoTa COCTaBnJj5OT

TaHKepbl aAR nepeBO3KH He)TH H He4bTenpOayKTOB, nOJIHaS rpy3OROabMMHOCTb

KOTOpbIx, B cpeAHem, COCTaBjiseT 5000 TOHH.

* npiMopcKoe napoxoacTBO, C leHTpajibHOfl 6a3o0 B r. HaxoAKa, nepeBO3T

riJaBHbIM o6pa3oM He4ITb H HeTenpOayKTbi, paCTHTenJbHbie Macna, menaccy H

Apyrylo aHajiorMHyIO npOayKlUHIO B A3Mno, EBpony H AbPHKy. Ee 4JIOT COCTOHT

rIiaBHbIM o6pa3oM U3 TaHKepOB anJ1 nepeBO3KH He4)TH H He()TenpoayKTOB.

* CaxajuHHcKoe napoXOACTBo, c ueCHTpanjbHor 6a3o0 B r. XOJIMCKe, pacnojio)KeHHOM

Ha HOJ1yOCTpOBe CaxajnH, ocylecCTJIieT riJaBHbIM o6pa3oM napoMHoe

o6cjiy)KHBaHHe "Mope-)Kejie3HaAa opora", a TaioKe Ka6oTa)KHbIe nepeBO3KH rpy3OB

o6mero Ha3HaqeHHsi, TO eCTb o6CJIy)KHBaeT npH6pe)KHyIO ToproBJIO.

Heo6xoAHMocTh yKpennieHHR TpaHCHOPTHOrO ceKcropa

HeCMOTpR Ha TO, 4TO JieCOnpOayKuH5R COCTaBA51eT OTHOCHTeCJbHO He60JlbLOi

nlpOLeHT OT o6iuero o6feMa CbipbR H MaTepHaJIOB, nepeBO3HMbIX Ha TeppUTOp1H

POCCHUUCKOU $egepauLH H BbIB03HMbIX 3a ee npeaeIbl, pa3BHTHe TpaHcnOpTHOr4 CHCTeMbi

Hepa3pblBHO CBR3aHO c 6yayluM JleCHOrO CeKTOpa, oco6eHHO B CH6upH H Ha aaAbHeM

BocToKe.

YKpenneHHe TpaHCnopTHoro ceKTopa 3KOHOMHKH Tpe6yeT peuweHHAl psqaa

npo6neM. I43MeHeHHe o6iue3KoHoMuHecKoA cHTyaUHH U4 MeTOAOB BeIeHH4R aeii B

npOMbIw1jeHHOCTH 6yAeT HenOCpeACTBeHHO onpeaejiHTb KaK xapaicrep, TaK H of6ieMbi H THnbl

TpaHcnOPTHbIX ycjiyr, Heo6xoa4MbbIx aAA o6cJyIKHBaHH5I necHoro ceKTopa:

* npaBHTejTbCTBO ALIOJDKHO CpOMHO 3aHqTbCA 4OPMHpOBaHUeM HopMaT4BHO-

npaBOBbIX OCHOB, KOTOpbie o6ecne4aT YCJIOBHq 9nSI peHTa6eJIbHor4 pa6oTbl

npHBaTH3HPOBaHHbIX TpaHCnIOPTHbIX npeanpHqTHr. B Tex cjiyMaax, Korja no

coo6paxeHH.qM COUHajIbHoro o6ecne4eHHrq Heo6xO1UMo npeaoCTaBJIATb cy6c4uHI4H

KOHKpeTHbIM perHoHam (HanpHMep, pariOHaM CeBepa), AOrOBOpbI O TpaHCnOpTHOM

o6cjiy)KHBaHHH ciieayeT 3aKmmOmTb Ha KOHKypCHOU OCHOBe.

* OpraHbl ynpaBAJeHH5[ AOJDKHbl HHBeCTHPOBaTb CpeACTBa He B pacwHpeHPHC unJu

MoaepHH3aUlIO TpaHcnOPTHOrO ceKTopa, a B Ba)KHer4Uwe pa6oTbl no ero

peKOHCTPYKUHH, TeXHH4eCKOMy o6CAy2KHBaHHIO H nOarOTOBKe KaapOB.

YBeuHYeHie nponyCKHOui cnoco6HOCTH - 3ajaaa MeHee aKTyaJIbHaq, leM

coxpaHeHHe HbIHeWHeri npOnyCKHOUI CnoCo6HOCTH.

* CKpbIToe cy6CHaHPOBaHHe 3HepronoTpe6JIeHHl4 SAB5ieTCS rJlaBHoIi npuH{HHOH

Ype3MepHO HHTeHCHBHOg 3KCnAyaTai4UH TpaHCnOpTa B PoccuH no cpaBHeHHIO C

ApyrHMH HHAYCTPH8abHO pa3BHTbIMH CTpaHaMH. HOBbiueHHe ueH Ha

3Hepropecypcbi Ao MHPOBOrO YPOBHS1 YCKOPHT nepexoA K 6onee paUHOHanYbHOMY H

Page 267: Russian - World Bank Documents

263 nPKJOnKEHHE ,i

3KOHOMH4HOMY TpaHCrOPTHOMY o6cJIy)KHBaHHIo H OaHoBpeMeHHO COKpaTHTpacXOAbl H yBeJi'HT ,oxoabi 6ioAxeTa.

noapo6HbJI aHlaAH3 eRATeAbHOCTH pOCCUiUCKHX riOpTOB, flpOBeaeHHbIfiBceMHpHbIM 6aHKOM (World Bank, 1996), noKa3an, qTO OTCYTCTBHe KOHKypeHUUH goporoo6xo,aHTcsl 3KOHOMHKe H HpHBOIU4T K yBeJIHUeHHIO H3Iaep)KeK, yXyaweHHIO KaqeCTBao6cAy)CHBaHHA H orpaHHqeHHIO HHBeCTHuLHi. FpaBHTeCjbCTBO aOJnKHO npocJIeaHTb 3a TeM,{TO6bl 3aHHMaioiuHe MOHOnOJIbHoe noo)KoeHIe aKUHOHepHbie o6uLecTBa, KOTOpbIe ceuiacRBJI1IOTCS1 OnepaTOpaMH rIOpTOB, HaXoLaHwCb B TaKOM lOJIO)KeHHH KaK MO)KHO 6onieeKOpOTKHU nepHoA BpeMeHH. Heo6xoaHMo co3AaTb YCJIOBHsA 2U15 6oflee aKTHBHOiu cnIa4u BapeHAy CHleUaJIH3HpOBaHHbiX nOPTOBbIX coopy)KeHHi TeM, KTO HenocpeACTBeHHO HXHcnoJIb3yeT. B ueJIAX pa3BHTHA KOHKypeHUHH MexAy nOpTaMH 6biJo 6bl )KeJIaTeJIbHO co3AaTbHe3aBHCHMyiO nOpTOBYWO aAMHHHcTpaUHIo B KauOM H3 HHX. B pe3yAbTaTe BbIHOIHeHCHH 3THXpeKoMeHaaLUHrt MO4KeT 6blTb COpMHPOBaHa npHeMjieMaA opraH43aUHOHHO-3KOHoMH4ecKaAOCHOBsa AR OCyLaeCTBJleHHS HHBeCTUHIUU B riOpTOBOe o6cAyJl4BaHHe H nOpTOBbleCoopy)KeHHS4, B CHH)KeHHe lOpTOBbIX c6opoB, a TaKiKe B nOBbIleHHe FIpOH3BOHUTeIbHOCTH H34XfeKTHBHOCTH nOpTOBbIX pa6OT, CB513aHHbIX C pOCCHUCKOU MOpCKOA ToproBJieg. 9THpeKOMeHAauHH OTHOCATCS KO BCeM HlOpTaM, BKJIIO4aA Te, KOTOpbIe y4aCTBYIOT riiaBHbIMo6pa3OM B o6CJiyKHBaHHH onepauHA no ToproBne JecHoH npoayK[uHeH.

Jl*TepaTypa

Holt, Jane. 1993, Strategies for the Russian Federation. Studies of Economies inTransformation, No. 9. Washington, DC: The World Bank.Kehr, K. H. 1994. Working Paper for Project Completion Report of China: Daxinganling

Forest Fire Rehabilitation Project. World Bank, Washington, DC.World Bank. 1996. Russian Federation: Restructuring Russia's National ports. Report No.1500-RU, Europe and Central Asia Region, The World Bank, Washington, DC.

Page 268: Russian - World Bank Documents

nP4JIOKEHHE E

HPHBATH3ALrnM B JIECHOM CEKTOPE H 3KOHOMWIECKNE PE4aOPMbl HA YPOBHE

nPEAnPI4.STt4Fi

CoBMecTHbWe npeAnnHSTHI H Apyrue 4OpMbI HHBeCTHUHik

COBMeCTHbIe J1econpoMb1WJueHHbie npeanpHSTH51 Co3XaalOTCAI Ha TeppHTOPHU BceU

cTpaHbl H 3aHHMalOTCql MHorHMH BHAaMH reRlTenbHocTH, BKJIIOqaf 3arOTOBKy nieca,

nepepa6oTKy apeBeCHHbl, npOH3BO1,CTBO uennlnOJIO3bI H 6yMarH, LapeBeCHOCTpy)Ke4HbIX nnuIHT H

4aHepbi. B EBponeucKoui 4aCTH POCCuH H Ha aaJ1bHeM BocToKe OTMe'eHO 6OAbwe

HHOCTpaHHb1X KanHTanoBjoKeHHO H 6ojiee BbICOKHUU YPOBeHb aKTHBHOCTH nOTeHi,HaBjbHbIX

HHBeCTopOB, no cpaBHeHI4O C pafioHaMH Ypana H CH6HpH. MHorme 3anaaHble KOMnaHHH

H3yqalOT B03MO)KHOCTH AAlA KanHTaJIOBJIOXKeHHii B 1eCHyio npOMbiwHJeHHOCTb POCCHu,

ygeji5ls 3Ha4HTejibHoe BpeM1 H CpeaCTBa AnIA Bbipa6OTKH BblrOXaHbIX qkOpM H YCJIOBHr

COTpyAHHU4eCTBa.

HaH6ojiee BaXKHoe 3HalieHHe aJl1 pa3BHTH5 pOCCHUiCKOU iieCHOfl npoMbiLUJeHHOCTH

HMeeT HecKoJIbKo noani4caHHbIX B 3TOU o6JiaCTH UBYCTOPOHHHX cOrJiaweHHiA. TaK

HanpHMep, corialameHHe, 3aKnIio4eHHoe POCCHUCKO-flnOHCKHM KOMHTeTOM no

3KOHOMW-eCKOMy COTpY,4HHmeCTBY B 1994 roay, co3,aaeT OCHOBY Axl aaAbHegwero

yrjiy6iieHHsI B3aHMOBbHroLXHbIX OTHOwUeHHP MexKy PoccHeri H 5InOHHeg 3a CMeT pa3BHTHl5

o6MeHa JieCHoH npOayKLUHH H3 POCCHH Ha o6opyaoBaHHe, 3anaCHbie qaCT4 H MaTeptaHibl H3

5nOHHH. MeMopaHayM 0 B3aBMOnOHHMaHUH Mex)ay npaBHTeCJbCTBaMH POCCuu H

COeaHHeHHbIX [WTaTOB, noLanHcaHHbli B 1994 roay, 4)OpMHpyeT OCHOBbI AnJl pa3BHTHS1

npouecca COTpyaHH'eCTBa MeK.fy npenPH5ITHS1MH AByx cTpaH JIeCHOA H LLejUlOAO3Ho-

6yMa)KHoP rpOMbIlUJIeHHOCTH, o6ecnel4HBaq 3aLuTy aMepHKaHCKHX HHBeCTHUU14 qepe3

3KcnopTHo-HMnopTHbIi 6aHK CWIA H AMepHKaHCKyIO KopnopaLuo no T4aCTHbIM

3apy6e)KHbIM HHBeCTHU4UHM (OPIC).

HHOcTpaHHbie ripeanpHATSIV BnepBbie nOSIBHJIHCb B JieCHOM ceKTope POCCHu B

1968 roDiy, Koraa 6oflrapcKaq H KopeAcKaH 4)HpMbi noJIyqwuH KOHTpaKT Ha 3aFOTOBKY nleca.

nO 3aKAiOoeHHbIM B TO BpeMql KOHTpaKTaM, 3arOTaBjlHBaeMasI apeBecUHa H UIOJlyqaeMa5l

npO,ayKLLHA pacnpe2eJI5IJIHCb cJ1eyiowuHM o6pa3oM: 60 npoueHTOB - CCCP H 40 npouLeHTOB

3apy6e)KHOfi cUHpMe-napTHepy. B pe3YJIbTaTe 3THX naPTHePCKHX OTHOLUCHHU 6blnO CO3,aaHO

HCCKOnbKO HOBbIX npearpHl4pTHfl. COrniaweHHe MewaY POCCHUcKoU (DeaeparuHef H

Pecny6nHKOU Kopefl npeaycmaTpUBaeT npOaOJi)KeHHe COTPYAHH4eCTBa B 3arOTOBKe,

o6pa6OTKe H BocnpoH3BOaCTBe nieca Ha 1995-1998 rOabi. B paMKaX 3TOrO cornawUeHI4

nniaHUPYeTC51 Co3llaHHe HIRTH COBMeCTHbIX nIeCO3arOTOBHTeJnbHblX npearnPIHSlTHH B AMYPCKOU

H Xa6apOBCKOA o6jiaCTTX, npUMqM 6bIJIa aOCTHrHyTa JOrOBOpeHHOCTb, '4TO Ha 3THX

nIpeanpH5ITHA1X 6yayT pa6oTaTb 7.000 KOperlCKHX pa6ot4x. Kope5i 6yaeT OnJiiaBHBaTb BbIB03

BCerl HpOgyKLum H3 POCCuH, H 3TBa IPOAYKLUf4l 6yaeT OCBo60oxeHa OT 3KCHIOpTHbIX HOIWJIHH.

apyrHM npHMepOM ycneWHoro COTpyRHH,-eCTBa qlBJISIeTCql pa6oTa pOCCUUCKO-

51nOHCKOrO COBMeCTHOrO nPe,rPiHqTH4 I "IrHpMa-TaHpHKH" B 4pKyTCKOr1 o6iiaCTT B

6accer4He peKH AHrapa, rae pacnoZo)KeHa 3OHa BbICOKOKa4eCTBeHHbIX COCHOBbIX JieCOB. 9TO

Page 269: Russian - World Bank Documents

265 nIPHnOAKEHHE E

npeCanpHATHe cneUHanjH3HpyeTC Ha BbInYCKe nHJOMoaTepHaH]OB Ha 3KCnOPT H C MOMeHTaCBOerO Co3,aH1H B 1989 roay exeroRHo yBenHqHi3aeT o6'beM BbIFlyCKaeMori HpOayKUH4.COBMeCTHOe pOCCIHCKO-4MHHCKoe npeanpHHTHe "jlaHaeHCO" OCBOHJO BbICOKO4HBCpcH4FHLLHPOBaHHblA uHKn onepauirH nO KOMUiTjeKCHOMY pa3BeaeHHIO, 3aFOTOBKe unepepa6oTKe nieca, BKJltOMqa cogepwKaHHe n4TOMHHKOB, BOCnpOH3BOaCTBO H oxpaHy,npOMe)KYTO4HYIO H CaHHTapHYlO py6Ky, CTpOHTAeAbCTBO ,opor, 3arOTOBKy, npOH3BOaCTBO

IHHjOMaTepHaYOB H Apyroe. 3To rpenpHHTHKe AOCTHrio ycnexoB He TOJIbKO BrpOMbmbiwJieHHOM pa3BHTHH, HO TaK)Ke B pewlleHHH COUHaAlbHbIX npo6AeM 3aHqTbIX B JleCHOMceKTope pa6oTHHKoB.

B HaCTOqluee BpeMS HHocTpaHHbIM bHpMaM, npaBHTejibCTBeHHblM areHTCTBaM3ana,aHbIX CTpaH H Me)AAYHHaPOXaHbIM OpraHH3aUH3iM npeaAaraeTcq ueAbiH pqa rpOeKTOB,npe,ayCMaTp4BaiOLUmX HHBeCTHUHH B JieCOHpOMb[mJweHHblg CeKTOp POCCHH, OCyWeCTB1HCMbIXrFJaBHbIM o6pa3oM B 4OpMe COBpeMeHHOrO o6OpyaOBaHHm H TeXHOJIorH4 nO 3arOTOBKe 14nepepa6oTKe .neca B o6MeH Ha npegoUameH4e KOHUeeccH4i. B KaqeCTBe npHmepa TaKoropo,ja KOMrIIeKCHOrO HHBeCTHUHOHHOrO COTTpyHHqeCTBa MOKHO BbilaeJIHTb HpOeKT,nIpe,ayCMaTpHBaiOLiHrH HOCTaBKH (DHRHj11aH4Herl B KapeAo10 BbICOK0394eKTHBHblX MaWH4H aAn3aFOTOBKH Aeca H riepepa6oTKH apeBeCHHbl, rIpeaOcTaBJIeHHe JibrOTHbIX aOJirOCpO4HbIXKpe,aMTOB C HX ioraweHHem rOTOBOH rpOayKutieh, npOH3BOaHMOA HOBbIMH npearipHqSTHHMH,H rIOCTaBKH 060pyaOBaHHA aMepHKaHCKOH d)HpMOH Ma4AepMOT B C'eT Kpeal4TOB,npe,aOCTaBji5IeMbIX qepe3 CHTH6aHK.

B 1991-1993 ronax 4)HHCKaq Hpma "AaKKO-neRpH" y4aCTBOBsaa B OCYlUCCTBJieHHHnpoeKTa no pa3pa6OTKe reHepanbHoro HLTaHa pa3BHTHs AecHoro XO3AriCTBa H AeCHOiirpOMbbiHJieHHOCTH eBpOHCeUCKOrH qaCTH POCCHH (OCHOBHble Tae)KHbie 3OHbI KOMH H KapeflHHH lweCTH rlPHAexKaWHx o6nacTet). Kaxwaq pecny6jIHKa H o6naCTb rOArOTOBHJ11 CBOUCo6CTBeHHbiA reHepaJlbHbir riiaH pa3BHTHq AieCHoro ceKropa C llpOrHO30M nOTpe6JIeHHsI HnpOH3BO,aCTBa apeBecHHbl go 2005 roaa. B pe3ynJbTaTe npoaeiaHHOr4 pa6oTbl BCSIHeo6xo,aHMaSI HHq3OpMaUuti 0 BeaeHHH niecHoro XO3HI4CTBa, 3aluHTe oKpyKaloWeri Cpcpeabi HMHOFOr3yHKLtHOHaAbHOM HCnOJTb3OBaHHH AeCHbIX pecypcoB 6bmla co6paHa,lOpaHaAJIH3HpOBaHa H BKJlO4eHa B 3TOT rIAJaH. EbIJI4 TaK?e CaefaHbl peKOMeHaaaUHHOTHOCHTeCJbHO ripOMe)KyTO4HOrO npOpeAKHBaHHS1, py6KH H HCKYCCTBeHHOFO BOCnPOH3BOaCTBaJIeCOB B paiOHax JIeCO3arOTOBOK.

AHajiorH4Hbif ripoeKT c KoprMopauter MI4,A-CllA" npeaycMaTpHBaeTocyLiueCTBjieHHe COTPYaHH4eCTBa B CueayiomuX o6nacTmx: BeaeHHe niecHoro XO3SIICTBa,TeXHOJOrHSA ieCOnHJAbHOrO HpOH3BOACTBa, TeXHOJIOrmi CYWKH H U[Tepepa6OTKa OTXOaOBLapeBeCHHbl, HCnOJlb3OBaHHe OTXOAOB iieCOrHHTbHOrO H nepepa6aTblBaloluero rHpOH3BOaCTBa,CO,aeRCTBHe B MapKeTHHre rlpO,4yKUHHH H apeHae pOCCHUCKHX niecoB. B HacTosiuee BpeMHocyHLeCTBJI,eTCsr npouecc oT6opa HecKOJIbKHX npeaflI4pHRTHA, KOTOPbIe MoryT HOnyqliTb4 HHaHCHPOBaHHe KaK OT pOCCUHiCKOrO nIpaBHTejJbCTBa, TaK H OT EBpOneUiCKoro 6aHKapeKOHCTPYKUHH H pa3BHTHq (EEPP), npHiqeM OAHO H3 TaKHX npeanpRATIH, JAeCHOerlpe,anpHATHe "Py3a" yKe Bbi6paHO, H rpoeKT nepeweji Ha noarOTOBHTeCibHYIO CTaauHO.

HpoIpaMMa IPHBaTK3aLtuH

fpaBHTeJAbCTBO POCCHUCKOHi $DeaepauHu HORrOTOBHJIO iTporpaMMy HpHBaTH3Lau4HrOcy,aapCTBeHHbIX npeallpHITHH, HaXO3RiWHXCS B 4eaepaJbHOA H MYH HUHUra)bHOU

Page 270: Russian - World Bank Documents

266 nPHJO)KEHHE E

co6CTBeHHOCTHI. B pe3ynbTaTe ocyuLeCTBeHH5I 3TOU nporpaMMbl, HOBbIM BAaaeJ1bUaMH 3THX

npeanpHA1THu AOJDKHbi 6blTb taCTHbie IOPHaHIeCKHe uH q3H3H4eCKHe JiTua. lipuiQeM

co6CTBeHHOCTb Ha 25 npoueHTOB KanHTaiia npeanpHATMA, npMHaaneHaiux 4eaepambHbiM,

perHOHaBJbHbIM HuH MYHHUHnaHJbHbIM opraHam BjiaCTH He MoryT 6bITb nepeaaHbl HHOMY

CO6CTBeHHHKy H aOJI)KHbl OCTaBaTbCS B CO6CTBeHHOCTH COOTBeTCTBYIOLUXH rOCyaapCTBeHHbIX

CTpYKTyp.

OCHOBHaA Luenb npiOpaMMbi npBsaTH3aLUHt COCTOHT B co31aaHHH MHOrOMHCAeHHOrO

cfo.q qaCTHbIX co6CTBeHHHKOB, KOTOpbIe 6yayT cnoco6CTBOBaTb pa3BHTHIO pbIHOqHOr4

3KOHOMHKH, nOBbIlaUi 3j4eKTHBHOCTb H npOH3BORHTeCJbHOCTb pa6oTbl rOCyaapCTBeHHbIX

npeanpHATHi. K 'H4CJIY apyrHx uejieu4 OTHOCSTCS 4uHaHCOBaq cTa64JIH3aUHS pOCCHUCKOU

3KOHOMHKH, pa3BHTHe KOHKypeHUIHH, npHBAeqeHie HHOCTpaHHbIX KanHTaj1OBAo)KeHHri H

o6ecneMeHHe CHCTeMbi couHanjbHbIx rapaHTHu, a TaKDe pa3BHTHe Heo6XolU4Morl

HH43pacTpyKTypbI. Bbuia TaK)Ke pa3pa6OTaHa nporpamma aAn co3flaHH5 yqpeKLeHHu H

o6beKToB HH4paCTpyKTypbl, Heo6xoaHMbIx anm pacWLUHpeHHS MacLUTa6OB npHBaTH3aUlH B

nocne,nyiolue repIHoAbl.

HOAX0O4 K HpHMaTH3aLrHH

,hIByM5 npaBHTenJbCTBeHHbIMH opraHM3auL MmH, OTBeqaioLuMiH 3a npo.aaKy

rocyHapCTBeHHblX rpeHnpHUTHI, 51BJISqOTCS rocyaapCTBeHHblrl KOMHTeT no ynpaBJIeHHIO

rOCyfapCTBeHHbIM HMyWeCTBOM (rK14) H POCCHUCKHU 43OHA HMyaieCTBa. B TO BpeMq KaK

rKIM qiBJIqeTCA riiaBHbIM nOUHTHMeCKHM OpraHOM, B 3aaaqti KOTOpOrO BXOaHT Bbipa6OTKa

o6iueg cTpaTerim npHBaTH3aU4H H pa3pa6OTKa HeKOTOpbIX KOHKpeTHbix npHBaTIT3aUHOHHbIX

npoiue,yp, 4)OHLL HMy1ieCTBa coaefPCTByeT nepeaaqe aKUH4r npeanpH5THI4 13

rocy,aapCTBeHHOH co6CTBeHHOCTH B 4aCTHbie pyKH.

Menxfe HpeCJpJIfJTHJ. MeJIKHMH npeanpuHTH$1MH CcqHTalOTCH npeHnpHSATHII C

q4cAoM pa6oTaioWaHx meHee 200 qejiOBeK H BeiH4qHHO4 OCHOBHOrO H o6OpOTHoro KanHTaJa

aO 10 MHJIJIHOHOB py6neu no COCTOflHHKO Ha SHBapb 1992 roAa. TaKHe npeanHpsHTHI4, KaK

npaBHJIO, npHHaH e)KaJiH MYHHUHnaAbHbIM opraHam BjiaCTH H BKJHo,4aAH XO3.IgCTBeHHble

eARHHHUbl, 3aHHMaioLuHecC OITOBOU H pO3HHUHOA ToproBJief, CTpOHTeJIbCTBOM, CenjbCKHM

X035WICTBOM, nepepa6oTKor4 nHHUeBbIX npOXAYKTOB H rpy3OBbIMH aBTOMo6HnJbHbIMH

nepeBO3KaMH. npeanpHqTH5I 3TOU rpynnbi 6bUH npHBaTTH3HPOBaHbI B pe3yAbTaTe

KOHKypCHbix ayKUHOHOB H TeHaepOB, npOBeaeHHbIX MeCTHbIMH KOMHTeTaMH1 no ynpaBJIeHHIO

rOCyflapCTBeHHbIM HmyLI.eCTBOM H MeCTHbIMH 4OHaaMH HmyIueCTBa. B Haqane npouecca

npHBaTH3auHH, TO eCTb B Te4eHHe 1992 roaa o6.s3aTeAbHaq npPBsaTH3aluiLH Tpe6oBanacb OT

BCeX OpraHH3aUHr H npeanpuHHTMA, 3aHHMaiolUHXCq CTpOHTeJhbCTBOM H npOH3BOACTBOM

CTpOHTenJbHbIX MaTepHajiOB, H Bcex y6blTO'4Hbix npeanpHIATRI, ecnu TOJIbKO B OTHOwleHHI

HHX He 6bIJIo npHHATO apyroro peuweH14.

I B 3TOM pa3aeme KpaTKo ofIcMBaercm fiporpaMMa !IpHBaTH3aLlHH POCCHfOCKO1 'PeCepaUR. C

O0iHfIJaAIbHMM TeKCTOM IlpOFPaMMbl MO)HO 03HaKoMfTbCq B pRae oE/HL(Hm7bHbix Hy6AiHKaLIHf TeKcTOB 3MKOHOB H

yKa3oB BKn7ovaR 3MKOH "O IPHBXaTH3aIIHH rocyaapcTBeHHbIX H MyHHLfH1fIa#bHbIX I7peai7pHZJfTH B POCCHICKOI

0c,aepawff" ('mOfb 1991 roaa), "rocyaapcrBeHHaq IporpaMMa HpHBaTH33auHm rocy2apcTBeHHbMx H

MYHHIIH!ITa9bHHbX I7peCaIpHZTHf POCCHrf cKoif weepaufH 1992 row" (fIOHHb 1992 roaa), YKa3 "06 YcKoPeHfH

gpifBaTH3aB(iH rocyaapcTBeHHbix H MyHHLHfnamHblix npeafpHTHfl (gHBapb 1992 roaa) H YKa3 "06

opranH3aLifoHHbix Mepax nof npeo6pa3owBaHmo rocyapcrTBeHHbix npeZflpHIITHf H ao6poBoAbHbx o6healfHHeHHI4

rocy,aapcTBeHHbIx I71p.Wl7pHfTHif B aKLlHoHepHbIe o6lIccTB " (iomn 1992 roaa).

Page 271: Russian - World Bank Documents

267 HPHJIOKEHHE E

E)OJbWUHHCTBO CpeAAHHX I KpyIIHUX Hpc4JlpHfRwk 6biH4 HAun 6y.iyTr npeo6pa3oBaHbl BOTKpblTbIe aKUHOHepHbie o6meCTBa, llpH 3TOM npeaycMaTpHBaeTcA, 4To qaCTb UeHHblX 6yMar_ oA)KHa 6bmia nepeIaHa uIAH npoaaHa Ha AbrOTHb1X ycJoIBi4x pa6oTHMKaM 3THXnpegllpHATHA. OCTaTOK aKUUM npOaaeTC5 pOCCUUACKHM H HHOCTpaHHbiM y4aCTHMKaM TOprOBB xojae KOHKYPCHbix ayKUHOHOB HAH TeHAepOB. B HacTo0uwee BpeMq He cyLeCTByeT_paKTrHeCKH HHKaKHX OrpaHHMeHMti B OTHOweHHH TOrO, KTO MO)KeT BJaAeTb 3TUMUUeHHbIMH 6yMaraMR, KaK IaCTO OHM moryr nepenpoIaBaTbCR. B TO xce BpeMSq eRCTByeTnpaBsuo, cor'AaCHO KOTOPOMY pa6oTHHKM npea,IpH3qTHS1 aOJDKHbl IIOAHOCTbIO OnJaTMTbBb,igJeAHHbIe HM Ha JAbrOTHbIX YCJIOBHATX aKUHH, npe)KIle qeM OHM MOryT npOaaTb HX HapbIHKe UeHHbIX 6yMar. H7peo6pa3oBaHMe rpea1lpKATHA B aKUHOHepHbie KOMflaHm4 Tpe6yeTTpaHC)opMaaUHH 1Op4UAHqeCKOA qOpMbl npe,rITpATHAs B TaKyiO 4jOpMy, KOTOpaS COBMeCTHMaC pa3BHBaiOLUeCr4c pbIHOqHORi 3KOHOMUKOU H corjacyeTcA C fOpHLL4xeCKHMM 4?opMaMMCo6CTBeHHOCT4, aerUCTBYIOWUMH B apyrHX cTpaHax.

|IporpaMMa nlpeLyCMaTp4BaeT, WTO oYeH ApyHHe IIpC17pHffTI (Ha KOTOpblXpa6oTaeT 6o0nee 10.000 pa6oqirx H peanlbHas CTOHMOCTb aKTMBOB KOTOpbIX npeBbiLiiaeT150 MHJAJHOHOB py6neri no COCTOAHHIO Ha AHBapb 1992 roaa) mory rpMBsaTH3HpOBaTbCqJIHuWb FKE rpuH oao6peHHI COOTBeTCTBYIOWHX MHHHCTepCTB. B 6ohbIHHcTBe cnyqaeB AAs_peweHHA Bonpoca o npHBaTH3MaLm Tpe6yeTcs ripOBeaeHMe KoMnAeKCHoro aHaAH3a Hno,aroToBKa aeTaAbHbIX nAaHOB. npeaycMaTpHBaeTcAs, 'TO [K4 coxpaHqeT 3a co6o0KOHTpOJIbHblU naKeT aKLxH1f Ha 3THX ripeallpHATHIX, KOTOpbIMH OH 6yaeT BJIaAeTb B TeqeHMeKOPOTKOO rnepHoxa BpeMeHH.

B 1992 rogy 6bmia co3zaaHa oco6&a KXaT7rpHZ aKTHBoB H IpeCDI7pMRM7f4 Henoznexcamumx npKBaTH3auHH. B 3Ty rpynny BXO,l5T BCe IieCHble peCypCbl, TeppMTOppm,KOTOpb1e oxpaHHl[OTCAI HAH o6eperaioTcs anS cneuHanbHoro HcnoJb3OBaHnq, YHHKanbHb1eKyAlbTypHbie H nppHORHbie HlaMSTHHKH H 06'beKUbl, KOTOpbIe OTHOCflTCA K MCTOpMqeCKOMy KKyJfbTYPHOMY HacmegLHo PoccHH, CJy)K6bl 3allUHTbl AeCOB H paCTeHHIi, cnyIc6bi3aHHMajo0uHecC reoAorHqeCKOfi KapTOrpad)merl, TOnOrpamerl H nporHo3uposaHueM noroabi,a TaioKe nOpTOBbIe CTPYKTypbl H COOpy)KeHM5I2.

MCX8HH3M IIPHB8TH38IhM

npaBHTeAbCTBO pa3pa6oTanO THnOBOfi yCTaB aKUHOHePHOrO o6LUecTBa, noAo)KeHu14KOTOpOrO AOJUKHO HCrIOJb3OBaTb KaAgOe BHOBb co3IaaBaeMoe aKUHOHepHoe o6WecTBO. BycTaBe orosapiusaeTcf OpraHu3agUOHHaR H yHnpaBeHqecKag cTpyKTypa KOMnaHM1. 3TOTyCTaB, B 4aCTHOCTM npeayCMarpHBaeT TO, 'TO B COBeT aHpeKTOPOB IOnxeH BXOaHTbreHepaJIbHbl4 at4peKTOp KOMnaHH4, npeacTaBHTeAb COOTBeTCTByol4ero 1OHaa MMYiUeCTBaHnu FKH4, npeaCTaBHTeAb TpyaoBorO KoAJIeKTHBa H npeacTaBHTeAb MeCTHblx BJacTeA. nocnenepe,aa'IH aKUHi HpeanpHAJTHq B 'IaCTHyJO co6CTBeHHOCTb, ep)KaTeSU o6blqHbix aKUHriMOfYT H3MeHHTb YCTaB Ha o6ueM co6paHMH aKLIHOHepOB, a TaK)Ke BHeCTJJ 143MeHeHMH BCOCTaB coBeTa aHpeKTopoB. nIpOH3BO,CTBeHHoe o6beauHeHHe Hun rpynna npeanpH5TMrt HeMO)KeT 06,bel4HRmTbCI H TpaHC4jOpMHpOBaTbCI B eAHHyIO KOM1aHU1O, HO eAHHOenpeAnPHlTHe MO)KeT noapa3,aej1lTbCA Ha He3aBMCHMb1e KOMiaHHH C yqeTOM AeACTBpyoueroaHTHMOHOHOAbHOFO 3aKOHOAaTeAbCTBa.

2 a7iec nO4po6,ro CM. rOCyaapCTBlCHHbIk KOMHTCr POCCHAfCKOH 0eaepawH 1no ynpaBeHmIofOCy,7qCTBeHHbiM HMYLLeCrBOM, 1992 roai. BO3MOKCHOCTH MHoCTpaHHbIX KanHTanoBnoAeHH B pOCCHtCKO4nporpamme npHBsaTH3aU[Hl 1992 roaa. PYKOBOaCTBO u7 17oTeHuIHaj7bHbX if CernOHwumHmX KHBeCTOPOB, MOCKBa.

Page 272: Russian - World Bank Documents

268 HPIP1O)KEHHE E

flpo,aaKa BayqepoB Hun "n1p4BaTH3aUHOHHbIX qeKOB" HaqaJ1aCb B OKTl6pe 1992 roaa.

Bjia,ejiblbI BayqepOB MOrJIM o6MeHHBaTb CBOH BayYepbl Ha aKUHH rOCyaapCTBeHHbIX

npe,anpt5T4HA no mepe HX npHBaTH3aUHH. 06MeH Bay4epoB npoHcxoHiii B xoie KOHKYpCHbIX

ayKUHOHOB, opraHH3yemblx perHOHa11bHb1MH OTaeJieHHsMH rKU H 14OHaaaM4 HmyUIeCTBa U

OTKpbITbIX JIHWIb ,J151 BJIaaeAbueB BayLepOB. npH 3TOM npecIieLoBa)iacb uej¶b, 'TO6bi KaK

MHHHMyM 50 npOUeHTOB aKUMA Kaxaoro npeanpHSTHS npoIaBajiHCb HCKji]Ot iHTeAbHO

,aep)KaTenAIM BayqepoB, a OCTanJbHaA 'aCTb noKynaniacb KaK Ha Bayqepbb, TaK H 3a HaIIHqHbIe.

Bay'epbl MOryT 6blTb riepenpoAaHbl JinuaM-Hepe3UMeHTaM, KOTOpbie B CBOKO O4epeAb

MOrYT TaIoKe HCnOj1b3OBaTb CBOU Bayqepbl BMeCTe C Ha8JHqHbIMH AAS noKynKH aKU149

KaKoro-iiH6o npeanpHATH4A. HOOIUpl5JIOCb pa3BHTMe qHHaHCOBbIX yqpeuKeHHA, CnoCo6HbIX

noMo4b HaceiieHHIO nOKynaTb rocyaapcTBeHHoe HmyiueCTBO nJIH O6MeHHBaTb CBOH Bayqepbl

Ha aKuHH. Th,i pewieHHs 3TOU 3aaaIM 6buiti C03lIaHbl HHBeCTHUHOHHb1e )OHAbI, Bjiaaeioui4e

aKUH5MH OT HMeHH MHOrOiHCAeHHb1X aep)KaTeJier 3THX ueHHb1X 6yMar.

FocTynnieHHA OT npoaaKH rocyLapCTBeHHoro tmylueCTBa HanparBJilOTCq Ha pewueHue

KOHKpeTHbIX 3aAu%, B 'IHCJIO KOTOPbIX BXO151T nOMaep)KaHHe CHCTeMbi COUHaJ1bHOrO

o6ecneqeHH5l, 3aluHTa OKpy)Kaiouteri cpebii, MoaepHH3auAS npOMbiwjieHHOCTH H

,aeMOHOHOAH3auLH., pa3BHTKe COUHaJTbHOH C4epbl u4 o6beicrOB 4H4)paCTpyKTypbt H nOKpblTHe

6ioaceTHOrO ae4bHUHTa, H pacnpeaensloTCq cpeZIH pa3jiHqHbIX ypOBHerl opraHoB BJTaCTH (CM.

Ta6nHuy E.1). MecTHbIe BJ1aCTH caMH peuwaloT, KaK cneAyeT pacnpeaej1HTb H nOTpaTHTb

CBOIO aJIOmo OT 3TUX nIOCTynJIeHH4.

Tpy,aOBOA KOJU1eKTHB H pyKOBOaHTeJIH Bcex rOcyaapCTBeHHbIX HpeInpHj Tu HCCYT

rjiaBHyIo OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a o6'beaxleHUe H HPHBaTH3aLtHIO CBOHX npeanpUiTHU. FIOMHMO

Bay'-epOB OHM noflyMaIOT TaioKe H apyrme 11brOTbl. OHM MMelOT npaBO KynHTb

HeorpaHH4eHHoe 4H4cao aKUHA CBOHX co6CTBeHHbix npeanpHATHU Ha JlbrOTHbIX yCJIOBH4IX.

COTPYAH4KH ripeallpH5THI HOJy'yaIOT TaioKe HeKOTOpyiO aOJI10 nOCTylJleHH14 OT npoaa)K4

BblnyCKaeMori npO4yKL1HH, HJuH 4aCTb aOXOaOB ecnuH x npeanpHSITHe npoaaeTci HHBeCTOpy,

HM MOryT TaKwKe 6blTb npeLJno)KeHbI CKHAKH Ha LeHbI aKUHHi npeanpHATH51 Hnu JilbrOTbI B

cjiyqae ero BblKyna. EcIM npeIIHnpHSTme IHKBHUapyeTCS, TO COTPYaHHKH4 npeanpH1THUA

nOAyLalOT HeKOTOpblrU HpOUeHT OT CYMMbl, Bbipy'eHHOHi B pe3yAbTaTe ero npoaa)KH4 Hnu Xe

OHM MoryT CXaTb B apeHAY cBoe npeAnpHSTHe C B03MOKHOCTbiO ero Bb1Kyna B 6yaylUeM.

FKM pYKOBOAHT H KOHTpOJIHpyeT npeo6pa3OBaHHe CpeLHHX H KpyflHbIX b4PM B

aKUHOHepHbie o6LuecTBa H OKa3blBaeT CoLeriCTBHe BCeM 4UHpMaM, noaHe0)KaLUM

npHBaTm3aumi B MOCKBe, OTaeAbHbIX perHoHax (o6nacTA x) U BO MHOrtIX KpynHbiX ropoaax.

[KM aoojDKeH TaKwe yTBepAKAaTb co3XaaHHe BCeX THnOB COBMeCTHblX npeHanpMHTHT,

4opMHpyeMbIX Ha 6a3e roCyIapCTBeHHbIX nIpeAlnpHATMH, B TOM qHCACe U npeanlpH5THU,

co3DaaBaeMbiX HHOCTpaHHbIMH HHBeCTOpaMH.

MMHHCTepCTBO (bHHaHCOB pericTpHpyeT npeanpHSATIS, Kyaa 6bLur caeXaHbl

HHOCTPaHHbe KanUHTaJIOBIO)KeHHA, H B3HMaeT HajiOrU C npU6bIfleUl HHOCTPaHHbIX KOMnaHKA,

nOAyMeHHOr4 OT MX aesTeAbHOCTH, a TaKwe C apyrMx aOXOaOB, BKAiOMaq rpoueHTbl Ha

HHBeCTHUMH, AOXOAbl OT apeHAbl H LIHBHaeH,Abl, nOAYyeHHbie Ha TePPHTOPHH POCCUU.

MHHHCTePCTBO 4j3HHaHCOB OKa3blBaeT CYiUeCTBeHHOe BJISAHHe Ha dOpMHpOBaHMe HajiOrOBOU

CHCTeMbI CTpaHbl H MO)KeT TaKHM o6pa3OM BASATb Ha peweHH51, KOTOpbie npUHHUMalOT

HaULOHaJbHbie H HHOCTpaHHbie HHBeCTOpbl njIA o6ecne'eH%R MaKCHMaBbHOti npH6bIJIbHocTM

CBoei AeqTeJIbHOCTH.

Page 273: Russian - World Bank Documents

269 nPHAO)KEHHE E

MHHHCTePCTBO BHeWllHHX 3KOHOMWleCKKX CB5I3eA, KOTOpOe ABJIMeTCq HaCjieHlHHKOMMHHHCTepCTBa TOproBnH, aKKpeaHTyeT oTaejieHtS1 u4HOCTpaHHbIX KOMnaHHs, aeuCTByIoWuHX BPOCCuH. OHO BbLLaeT 3KCnOPTHbie £iiueH3HH H UnpOBOaHT B )KH3Hb BHeWHeToprOBYlOn1OJnHTUKy POCCHH. OHO TaioKe BbilaeT pa3pewleHH51 pOCCHrCKUM XO3qruiCTBeHHbIM Cy6'beKTaMHHBeCTHpOBaTb CBOH Cpe,LCTBa 3a py6e)KoM. ToproBble npeaCTaBHTeJIbCTBa 3a rpaHlUeriHaxo,S1TcH nox ynpaBjieHHeM MHHHcTePCTBa uHOCTpaHHbIX aeji, KOTOpoe oKa3bIBaeTnoaaep)KKy HHOCTpaHHb[M KanHTajoBioB)KXeHH5M B PoccHlo B paMKaX mep no yKperineHHIO3KOHOMH4eCKKX OTHOweHHt C apyrHMH CTpaHaMH.

UeHTpaIbHbiH 6aHK PoccHH peryitipyeT HCnHoJb3OBaHHe pe3HIeHTaMH HHepe3HUeHTaMm KHoCTpaHHOr4 BaAlOTbl H py6iieu B POCCHH, BKJIlo0aA orpaH4qeHmR HaHCnOJb3OBaHHe UHOCTpaHHOH BajlOTbI pe3H.LeHTaMH. U15 perHcrpHpyeT KOMMep4eCKHe6aHKH H oTBeqaeT 3a co3JaaHHe 6aHKOBCKHX HOpM, TaKHX, KaK MHHHMaBjbHaA ripoueHTHaSCTaBKa KanHTanJH3aUHHA OXOAOB, pe3epBHbie YPOBHH H MaKcHManbHbie YPOBHH pHCKa.

Ta6nuHia E. 1: PacnpeAejleHHe nocTynneHHtl OT npHBaTH3aUHH nocneBbhnnaT Tpy1ROBbiM KOA3TeKTHBaM IIPHBaTH3HPYeMbLX nPeIUnPHSTHA

(B npoLLeHTax)

Iony'aTerjb | MyHHliHnaIbHoe PerHoHallbHoe Hj HMyulecTBo | cfeepajbHoe HMyICTBO ||

MecTHble 6iowxeTbl 45 10

Pecny6AHKaHCKHe, TeppHTopHanbHbIe, 25 45perHOHaAbHble 6ioaIceTbi; 6io4xeTblaBTOHOMHbIX OKpyrOB

4)e,aepaAbHbIi 6ioaxeT 20 35

rocy,aapcTBeHHbie opraHbI no npHBaTH3aL[HH, 10 10B TOM qHcAe cIOHa HMyWeCTBa Ha BcexypoBHsX, KOMHTeTbl no ynpaBneHuwoHMyWecTBoM, rKU U POCCHrCKHU1 4OHA

(beaepanbHoro HMyLueCTBa

HTOrO 100 100

1cTO'HHK: rKH.

npaBOBbMe paMKH AJIA HHOCTpaHHblX KanHTjioEuioxeHHiI

nporpaMMa npHBaTH3auuH npeaycmaTpHBaeT onpeaeAeHHblru Ha6op MeTOAOBnpo,aaci aKUHi BHOBb co32aaHHbIX pOCCHUCKHX KoMnaHH4, KOTOpbie He MOryT 6bITbnepeaaHbl HAH npoaaHbi pa6OTHHKaM npeanpUHTHA Hnu pOCCUUCKHM HHBeCTOpaM KaKHMnu6o apyrHM o6pa3oM. 3a HeCKOJIbKHMH HCKjloq4eHHqMH HOCTpaHHbie HHBeCTOPbI MOryTCBo6OAHO ytMaCTBOBaTb B npouecce TOprOBAH UeHHbIMH 6yMaraMH.

IIHOCTpaHHbie HHBeCTOpbI npHEuseKalOTCSI K y4aCTHIO B Toprax UeHHbiMM 6yMaraMHOTKpblTbIX aKLtMOHePHbIX o6wecTB, MOryr nOKynaTb Bay'epbI Ha BTOpH4HOM pbIHKe LLeHHb!X6yMar H HCnOAb3OBaTb UX ,q nOKYnKH aKuH Hu apyriHx UeHHblX 6yMar. IHOCTpaHubl MOryTnoKynaTb Bce npeanpHHTHR, KOTOpbIe He 6bmui co3LIaHbi B KaqeCTBe aKuMoHepHoro

Page 274: Russian - World Bank Documents

270 nPRJO)KEHHE E

o6lneCTBa, XOTA HeKOTOpbIe npealnpsATH4 MOryT HMeTb onpeaen1eHHbie OrpaHH4CeHHU C TO'4K43peHHS 3aHSTOCTH HJIH HHBeCTHUU14 B OTHOiJieHHH aesTeJibHOCTH. I4HOCTpaHHbie rpa)uaHeTaiKce MielOT rpaBO nOKyriaTb JIHKBRHUPOBaHHbie aKTHBbl HuiH CaMo npeInpsATHe B cAytiaenpUHHTHA pemneHu4A o ero JHKBHi4aLUHH. IIHocTpaHHbIe HHBeCTopbI MOryT nOKynaTbapeHiayeMoe npeanpHS4THe y TpyaOBOrO KonAJeKTHBa rpeanpflpTHA npH YCJIOBHH, 'ITO caMocorinauleHHe o6 apeHae He ucKinioqaeT TaKok B03MOXKHOCT4.

IlHocTpaHHbie KanHTaTioBJIo)KeHHq aonycKalOTC5 BO BCeX CeKTOpax pOCCHUICKOU3KOHOMHKH 3a aBYMA HcKJIIo'eHHAMH: uHocTpaHHbie HHBeCTOpbI MoryT noKyraTb Manbierpe,anpH51THA JIHIUb C pa3peuJeHHS COOTBeTCTByToLuero MeCTHOrO COBeTa H MoryT nOKyiaTbnpe,apHSHTHR B o6opOHHOr4 L,o6blBaioluefl, TOnHJIBHOU H 3HepreTHPlecKorf npOMbIwJleHHOCTHJuHb C pa3pelueHHs deaepaAbHbIx unI pecny6nHKaHcKux BJIacTeu. HHLKe aaeTcq KpaTKoeH3JIo)KeHHe HeKOTOpbIX nojoKeHHA pAAa Ba)KHbIX 4JeaepaAbHblx 33KOHOB uin yKa3oB,np4HSlTbIX nocnie 1990 roaa, no peryJIHpOBaHHIO HHocTpaHHbIX KaI4TaJoBJIo)KeHHt BPOCCuH. MHorHe 113 3TUX aoKyMeHTOB 6buIH BnocJieaCTBMH nepecMoTpeHbl MAnu aonOJHeHbl.[O3TOMy Ba)KHO, 'ITO6bi nOTeHuHanbHbIe HHOCTpaHHbie HHBeCTOpbl nOCTOAHHO cAneaHn 3aPOCCHUiCKHM 3aKoHoaaTenbCTBoM, peryAHpyIoILUHM HHOCTpaHHbie KanHTaAoBJIo)KeHHSA, C TeM'ITO6bi OCTaBaTbCA B Kypce ripaBOBOrO H MHBeCTHUHIOHHOrO KYIHMaTa.

3aKoH "06 HHOC7paHHbm HHBeCTHpIB¶ B PCEDCP" 4)OpMyJIHpyeT OCHOBHbieripaBoBbie HOpMbl, perynHpyIoLuHe co3AaHHe H aeATeJIbHOCTb B Poccuu npe,LnpRATHrl,HaXOlsU1HXCs B co6CTBeHHOCTM 4HOCTpaHHbix rpaK1aH. 3aKoH pa3pemaeT co3aaHHeHaxoamisuercsC B nOAHOA unu qaCTHqHOr4 co6CTBeHHOCTH KOMraHHri HAnu TOBapHLUeCTB HOKa3blBaeT HHocTpaHHbIM HHBeCTOpaM onpeAeneHHyIo npaBOBYIO 3awHTy. B COOTBeTCTBMH C3THM 3aKoHoM, MX HMyLUeCTBO He MOxKeT 6blTb HaLIUOHanH3HPOBaHO HAH KOHc1JHCKOBaHO 6e3KOMneHCaHUHH, H OHM HMelOT npaBO Ha BbIB03 npH6bIAH B HHOCTpaHHOri BanioTe nocneyriAaTbI HanorOB K c6opoB. IIHOCTpaHHbie HHBeCTOpbl MoryT TaKwe 3KCnOpTKpOBaTbBbInyCKaeMyio HMH npoayKuHio 6e3 Heo6xoaHMMocT4 Hofy4eHHA cneUHaTibHoi JiIUeH3HH(XOTA HeKOTOpbIe apyrHe 3aKOHbl BBOaAT JIM[eH3MoHHbie orpaHHqeHHA, KOTOpbie MOryFnpHMeH5ITbCA H K npearIpHATHAM C yMaCTHeM HHOCTpaHHOrO KanHTaAa). 9 TOT 3aKOH TaKwKenpe1ycMaTpHBaeT BO3MO)KHOCTb pa3peweHHs cnopa Au60 B pOCCUHCKOM, AH60 BHHOCTpaHHOM cyae. Bonpocbi 0 KOMneHCaLtHH 3a aeACTBH4A ripaBHTeAbCTBa, KOTOpb[enpHBeAH K y6b[TKaM aOA)KHbi pewlaTbCS B BepXoBHoM cyae POCCHUCKOH (t)eepaLuu unul BBbicLeM ap6MTpa)KHOM cyae, ecAH HHOe He npeaycMoTpeHo aOrOBOpOM. Ap6lirpa)KHoepa36HpaTeAbCTBo peryJIKpyeTCs 3aKOHOM "06 ap6HTp&affmx CY,4aX B POCCHACKOIi

De,arepaz(HHW" H Ap6HTpJCHbIM HpOL(eCCya9bHIMM KO,leKCOM.

3aKoH "0 qpeCaUpHRTHLX H HpearpHHHMaTeffbcKo,#IaeIITeI/bHOCTH" 3 (bopMyA KpyeTnpaBOBbie HOpMbI AA1i OpraHK3aumH npe)1rnpH5THr4, onpeaeAqeT iTpaBa K o6R3aHHOCTHnpeanpHATMH H npeaycMaTpHiBaeT HX perHCTpaLtHio H JIHKBHaauHio. 3aKoH "06aAwHoHepHmx o6w1cmax" perJiaMeHTHpyeT npouezypy co3AaHHq o6LLteCTB c OrpaHHKeHHOHiOTBeTCTBeHHOCTbIO, KOTOpbie MoryT 6blTb JIH6o OTKpblTOrO THi4a, TO eCTbnpenycMaTpHBaioWHe npo,aaKy aKUHji 6e3 orpaHHweHHrH, 1u60 3aKpblToro (npoaa)Ka aKUHAc orpaHH4qeHHSMH). B 3aKOHe yKa3blBaloTCs MHHHMaAbHbie o6'beMbl KanHTaAa,Heo6xoLaHMoro miU perMCTpaLIHH npeRripHATH4A.

3 3aKoH yTpaTmi cHsy c I sHBapq 1995 r. B CBh3H C BBeaeHHeM B aeACTBMe 4aCTH nepBOU rpaxKEaHCKOroKo,ReKca P(D. (IpHMe'IaHHe peaaKTopa pyCCKoro H3IiaHHA)

Page 275: Russian - World Bank Documents

271 nPHIO)KEHHE E

3aKOH "O Ha8JoIr Ha TpH6bmJJb IpeCaVpwffmI H OpmaHH3aLgN 13nqaraeT I1OJIHTHKY BOTHOlwleHHH Haniora Ha npi46bLiib, o6biMHO orpeaeAseMyio KaK aOXO0bl 3a Bbi4eTOM paCXOlOB.npe,npH4TH4l HMeCOT npaBo Ha HeKOTOpbIe HanorOBbie JIbrOTbi B TOM ciy4ae, ecAn OHUHCHOJIb3YIOT MaCTb rIpH6biJiH nIS KanHTaAoBj1o)KeHHri B HedTqHylo H yrOnbHylorpOMbbiwIeHHOCTb, B cfepe 3aILHTbl OKpy)Kailoule cpeabi, a TaKwKe An. no)KepTBOBaHHA6JiarOTBOPHTenbHbIM opraHH3aUHAM. 11oMHMO Hanora Ha npH6bLIb H ecnu OcBo6oXAeHHe OTHaJIOrOB He npenycMOTpeHO B Me)KrocyaapCTBeHHOM coriawieHHH o6 H36exCaHHH aBOAHoroHajloroo6JIo)KeHHS, Bce npeanpHSTHA aOJD)KHbi HJaTUTTb HanorH C aHBKaeHaOB, 4OXOROB HaBKJIa,bI H ROXOaOB, nojiyqeHHbIX OT BAaaeHHA co6CTBeHHOCTblO B apyrOM npearnpHATHt.Hpe,anpuAT4H aOADKHbl TaKIKe nAaTHTb HajioF Ha ao6aBjieHHyIO CTOHMOCTb C fpoaa)KHO4LteHbi 60JIbWUIHCTBa TOBapOB. KpoMe TOrO, pOCcHUiCKOe lpaBUBTenJbCTBO o6AaraeTnpe,anPHI4THAS uenbIM pAAOM ApyrHX HajiorOB, B TOM 'HCJe HaJOrOM Ha OnepaUHH cUeHHbIMH 6yMaraMH, HanioroM Ha HMyilueCTBO npegnpHsTHA, aKUH3HbIM c6opoM HaHeKOTOpbie rpegMeTbl POCKOWIUH HanTOrOM Ha 3eMJlO, HaXOaALUyIOCA BO BJIaeCHH4npeAnpHI4THR.

BpeMeNHHI HMfm op THfbJ 7TMOXeHHmMI mpH( POCCmNCKON Ocepaw(H, KOTOpblUo6blqHo repecmaTPHBaeTCq ABa pa3a B roa, o6naraeT HMriOPT TaMo)KeHHbIMH c6opaMHpa3ajlqHOii BeJI4HqHbl, KaK rpaBHJIO, B npeaeAax OT 5 ao 30 npOueHTOB OT CTOHMOCTHToBapa. 9KcnopTHbie KBOTbl H c6opbi, rnaBHbIM o6pa3oM Ha Cblpbe, 6buIH npeaycMOTpeHbi3aKOHOM B 1991 rogy. OaHaKO B anpenie 1995 roaa 3KCnOPTHb1e c6opbl Ha Bce BHabl j]ecCHofnpO,aYKUHH 6bmlH OTMeHeHbl. H4MnOpTHbie TapHUdbl Ha .lecHylo npOaYKLIHIO 06bl{HOCOCTaBJi5lOT OT 5 no 30 npoueHTOB.

npaBHJia H OrpaHH'eHHq B OTHOweHHH HCnIOJIb3OBaHHS HHOCTpaHHOA BaJlIOTblTpe6yloT, 4To6bl KyriLJ1 HJIH rpoaa)Ka HHOCTpaHHOf4 BanjiOTbl ocyIeCTBjsUiqaCb JIIUWbHMeiOlUHMH Ha 3TO pa3peLweHHe 6aHKaMH, 3anpeutaloT pOCCUUCKUM rpeHnpH5TH41MOTKpbIBaTb 6aHKOBCKHe cqeTa 3a rpaHHiueri 6e3 pa3pelweHHq LUeHTpanbHoro 6aHKa,orpaHHqHBalOT cneJIKH mexay pOCCHUCKHMU rpenPHS4THA1MH B HHOCTpaHHOrl BaTJHOTC UorpaHH4HBalOT BbirinaTy 3apriJaTbI HJIH npeMHr4 POCCHACKHM rpawnaHam B HHOCTpaHHOUBaJIloTe.

rpwaHcKxfIf KOw4mKC POCCNN#CKONI 4PCCpaL(HN H3JIaraeT rojoOKeHuHI o6feroKOMMepqeCKOrO npaBa POCCHH H COaep)KHT CTaHaapTHbie aOrOBOpHbie npHHL1H4nbl. BCOOTBeTCTBHH C 9THM KoAeKcoM, HHocTpaHHbie rpaxQaHe HMelOT paBHblr4 npaBOBOri CTaTYC CPOCCHUCKHMH rpaKnaHaMH.

3aKoH O CO6CTBHHOCTH KOHKpeTHO npeaocTaBjiAeT rpax)AaHam M H iOpU4HHeCKHMiH4LlaM ripaBo BJiaaeTb nlo6biM HMyULeCTBOM, KpOMe 3eMJTH. BniaaejibubI Co6CTBeHHOCTHHMelOT npaBO pacnropAxaTbCA co6CTBeHHOCTbIO no CBOeMy ycMoTpeHilo, nepenaaaTbco6cTBeHHocTb TpeTbHM qaCTHbIM HJIH IOPHnaHeCKHM JIHuaM H HcnoAb3OBaTb co6CTBeHHOCTbB KaqeCTBe 3aXJOrOBOrO o6ecneqeHHq. 4HOCTpaHLIbI MOryT HMeTb Co6CTBeHHOCTb B POCCHu HaTex )Ke yCAOBHsX, 'ITO H pOCCcHrCKi4e rpawaHe, 3a HCKJiO'oeHHeM TeX Cjiy'aeB, KOTOpbienpe,aycMoTpeHbl 3aKoHoaaTeJIbCTBoM.

l(ewm,I p11 yKa3oB Hpe33He)m POP Ho BoXpocasm 3cA(eJCo./b3oBaHHfI npenocTaEMqeTnpaBa Ha qaCTHYIO co6cTBeHHocTb, KynAio, nponaaKy, apeH,y H HriOTeqHbIi 3aaiorCeJlbCKOX03RHCTBeHHOU 3eMJIH. B HacToAiiiee BpeMsi napjiaMeHT rOTOBHT npoeKT HOBOro3eMenbHoro KoaeKca POCCHrCKOH (DenepaLuHH.

Page 276: Russian - World Bank Documents

272 HPHAIOKEHHE E

3aKoH "O KOHKypeHmp H oIpaHHqcHHH moHouoJHCTHqccKoif qcH7TeviLHOCTH Ha

TOBBapHlX pMHK8X" 3anpeLuaeT 3aKi11o4aTb coriiaweHHiq MeKLty KOHKypeHTaMtI,

YCTaHaBJIHBaTb L1eHb1 H nperipHHHMaTb Lpyrme aeACTBH5 no orpaHH4qeHHIO KOHKypeHLUHH 14

3anpeuxaeT pacnpocTpaH$Tb 3aBeaoMo joI)KHyio HJIH HCKa)KeHHYIO 1HHopMauilo, KOTOpaS

MO)KeT nOBpeaHTb KOHKypeHU4HH. AHTHMOHOnOJIbHblU KOMUITeT yHOJIHOMO4eH paccmaTpHBaTb

H yTBepxKaaTb HJIH He yTBep)aaTb CJIH5IHHS H norj1oiueHH4l KoMnaHHig, aaBaTb

paCnOpR5KeHH. 0 BHeCeHUH H3MeHeHHUi B aOrOBOpbl, HaZiaraTb ETpadbl Ha ytaCTHHKOB

pbIHO'-HOR aelTeSJbHOCTH H pa3yKpynHHTb npeallpH5THI4, 3aHHMaolwl.e ROM4HHpyiOlUee

nojio)KeHHe Ha pblHKe.

Ko,aeKc 3BKOHOB o Tpye, 3aKOHbI "06 HHoCpaHHbX -H HBHCTHL(HfHX B PCGPCP", "O

KojfeKTwJHbx AOfjoBOpaX Hr COrIaHieHHJIX" H "O rocY4lapCTBeHHwX HCHCHfHX B PC0DCP" -

BCe 3TH 3aKOHbl peryJIHpyIOT TPYAOBbie OTHOweHH41 Ha pOCCHUUCKX npeanpH5THIX. OHH

YCTaHaBBjiHBaOT CTaHgapTbl, YpOBeHb MUHHMajIbHOfl 3apnnHaTbl H o6cTosTeAbcTBa, npH

KOTOpbIX cAy)KaUHR MOxceT 6blTb yBojieH nJIH OCBo6o0eH OT 3aHHMaeMOg aOJIKHOCTH;

Tpe6yIOT OT HaHHMaTeJleg o6cyxgaTb H COrJ1COBbIBaTb KOJUieKTHBHb1e COrJlalweHUI4; H

YCTaHaBjiHBalOT B3HOCbl COUUaHJbHOrO CTpaXOBaHH$l CO CTOpOHbl HaHRMaTeJTerU B npOueHTHOU

,aojie OT paCXOaOB Ha 3apa6OTHyWO nIJaTy.

3aKoH "O 6aHKax H 6aHKoDcKot ,je9TCJfbHOCTH B PC0PCP" U3JIaraeT OCHOBHbie

Tpe6oBaHHrn K co31aaH410O H aeqTenbHOCTH 6aHKa. IIHOCTpaHHbIM 6aHKaM pa3peweHo

faeACTBOBaTb B POCCHH npH yC.IOBHH, Y4TO OHH nOJInyIH4 JHiueH3H1O OT UeHTpaJbHOrO 6aHKa

Poccuu. PoccHAcKcie 6aHKH MOryT TaK)Ke np4Haane)KaTb HHOCTpaHHb1M 4HBeCTOpaM.

3aKoH "06 oxpaHe oKpyxaoJeiW HpHJpboHoW cpe,.(b" pacnpeaen1eT o65l3aHHOCTH

Cpeau pa3J]HqHbIX ypOBHeh OpraHOB BJaCTH B (DeaepauHH H npeaycMaTpHBaeT

a,aMHHHCTpaTHBHYIO U YrOJ1OBHYIO OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a HapyweHHe 3aKOHa.

3aKOH "06 3KOJIOrNYCCKON 3KCIJP7TH3C" Tpe6yeT, 'YTo6bi o6s13aTeJbHaq

3KOnoruH4eCKa, OueHKa npOBOai4HJaCb 4)eaepanbHbIMH BjiaCTqM4 Ha BCeX COBMeCTHbIX

npeAnpu4qTH5MX C HHOCTpaHHbIMH Kan4TaIOBAoxceHHHMu, npeBblwaioLUHMH 500.000 aoRn.

CWlA, a TaKwce Bcex corAameHHI4 0 KOHUeCCHS1X H COBMeCTHOM npOH3BO,aCTBe.

3aKoH "O 3auH'v npaB uompe6mTeffe" Tpe6yeT, YITo6bl H13rOTOBHTeJIH B03MeLaJIH

nOTpe6HTeni5iM yLlep6, npHiHYUHeHHblg HM Hero6pOKa4eCTBeHHOg npOayKUHeA, U4 Tpe6yeT,

'YTo6bi H3rOTOB4TeCUH aeiazH mOCTYnHOA UHHOpMauH1o 0 CBOUX TOBapax.

J7OJoxeHHe O BmblyCKe H XO)WeHHH q4mHHMX 6ymar H aK4Hi B POCCHH

npeAycMaTpHBaeT pericTpautio UeHHbIX 6yMar B MuHHCTepCTBe 4WHaHCOB, a TaKiKe

o6ecne4eHHe 3MHTeHTaMH HHBeCTOpOB 4HqIOpMauLLeA O paCqeTHOU HpH6buIH Ha HX

HHBeCTHUH4.

Page 277: Russian - World Bank Documents

|HPHAO)KEHHE A

YPOBEHb BE4HOCTH, bE3PAbOTIU"A H CUCTEMA COIHAJAbHOI4 3A[UI4TbI B JIECHbIXPAUOHAX

Ha TeppHTOpHH CH6HpH H JgaabHero BocToKa HaXOL,5ITCR 3OHbl TyHapbl, iieCOTyHapbl(3Ha4HTenbHasi ee YaCTb - 3To rOpHble paHOHbI), 6opeajibHbIX H lHpOKOJ1HCTBeHHbIX nIeCOB, aTaKwKe 3acyllJHBbIX cTeneH H JTecocTerier.' YpoBeHb nJIOTHOCTH HaceeHiHHq Ha BCeH 3TOUTePPHTOPHH OMCHb HH30K - MeHee OAHOrO YeJOBeKa Ha KBaapaTHbIH KHAoMeTp. B TO we BpeM53,aecb eCTb par4OHbI H C 6o0nee BbICOKOH nHOTHOCTbIO, HariMpep B AOJIHHax MHOrO4HCjieHHbIXpeK, rae nJIOTHOCTb HaCeACHHq COCTaBJ1ieT OT OAHOrO aO aeCqTH 4eJIOBeK Ha KBaapaTHbliKHunoMeTp H paHOHbl B6JIH3H KpynHblx ropoaOB H AoAHHax XaKaCHH C nnOTHOCTblO HaceneHHSiOT aeCITH aO ABaauaTH nSTH 4enoBeK Ha KBaapaTHbIH K4AOMeTp. Ha 6onbweru qaCTH 3TOroperHoHa npO)KHBalOT ManoYHcAeHHbie HapOJbl CeBepa, noceAeHJI4H KOTOpbIX pacnoJoIKeHbl nH60OTaeJbHO, JIH60 BMeCTe C apyrUMH KOpCHHbIMH HapO)aMH.

CoUHEabHO-KyAbTypHbMe rpynnbi

EcnH aHaAH3HpOBaTb aeMorpajH4ecKyMO cHTyauHIo B uLeJoM, TO BCC HaCeAeHHe 3TOOperHoHa MOKHO roApa31aenHTb Ha TpH COUHaIbHO-KyIbTypHbIe rpynnbl: KOpeHHbIeMaAo4HcAeHHbie HapoLbi CeBepa, apyrHe 3THHYeCKHe rpynnbI KOpeHHOrO HaceneHHI4 HnepeceneHubl. Kaxaaq H3 3THX rpynn HMeeT pa3HyIO HCTOpH4O 3aceJeHHR aaHHoR TeppHTOpHH,pa3JH4HYIO aAHTeJIbHOCTb nepHoaa npO)KHBaHHA H 3KcrtAyaTaLIHH COOTBeTCTByloUiHx paHOHOBtzaHHOrO perHoHa, pa3JZHIHYIO CTeneHb COULHaJbHOrO pa3BHTH5i H y'aCTHA B TOpIOBOA HnpOMbwliIeHHOr ,aeSITeAbHOCTH. Pa3AH4Hbie rpynnTbl KOpeHHbIX HapOIOB, HMelOT HeOaHHaKOBbl4YPOBeHb 3aBHCHMOCTH, C TOYIKH 3peHH5] BbDKHBaeMOCTH, OT 6HoJIorH4ecKHX H apyrtHx peCypCOB,pacnoJoxKeHHbIX B 3OHe HX rlpO)KHBaHHA. 14 XOTS MeCKy 3THMH TpeMs rpynnaMH HeT 4eTKHXrpaHHU, Ky11bTypHbie pa3rpaHHUeHH5 CyWieCTBYIOT B yMaX H HCHXOJIOrHH JImOger, HaCeJiiOLHHX3TH 3eMAH, H oTpa)KeHbl B perHOHaJbHbIX H 4IeaepanbHOM 3aKOHOaaTeJbCTBax, perynHpylowHxpacnpe,aeAeHHe npHPO2HbIX peCypCOB.

KopeHHic MaflOYHCJIeHHHe Hapo)lb CeBepa B 20-x ro,zax Hawero CTOJieTH5i 6buAHo61b,BJieHbl "rpHMHTHBHbIMH H HeaOCTaTOYHO pa3BHTbIMH" H B COCTaBe CCCP nOnb30BaAHCbOnpe,aejieHHbIMH AbrOTaMH. 9TH HapOAbl, B OCHOBHOM, )KHBYT 3a C'eT pbI6OjiOBCTBa, OXOTbl HOJieHeBO,aCTBa H HaHMeHee aKTHBHO 3aaeHCTBOBaHbl B COBpeMeHHbIX OTpacisX 3KOHOMHKU. OHHC4HTaIOT CBOU o6pa3 )KH3HH ealHHCTBeHHbIM cnoco6oM COXpaHCHHH CBOeH KyJlbTypbl,OTAH4aiOWueiCA OT 6o0ee KPYHHbIX IoJIH3THH1ieCKHX nlOCeIeHHL, B KOTOpbIX OHH rpO)KHBalOT.

I HaC7OzlwUHlI aHa.I7h3 COILUaJbHO-3KOHOMHimeCKHX XapaKTepCCTHK rpyinn HacewoH,l 17po)KHBaloLfiX B 7cCHbiX3oHax BocToiHo# CH6HpHf if aa,bHero BocToKa, oxBarblBaCT TeppuTopuio Xa6apoBcKoro it KpacHozpcKoro KpaeB,Pecdy67,fK Caxa Hf XaKacHH, Ta AfMbipcKoro (6aloaraHo-HeHH Koro) H 9BeHKHfcKoro aBTOHOMHbIX OKpyroB HEsBepcKo1g aBToHoMHoJI o65acTH, T. e. o6utyio imoLa4b B pa3Mepe 5,5 MJIH. KB. KH.oMeTpoB. KOpeHHbUc 3THHvecKHerpy77bl, I7pO)KHBaIOLL(HC BapyrfHx perifoHax (oco6eHHo B Tex pa,#oHax 3angaHog CHf6HpH H Kof7bcKoro 17oJl7yocTpoBa,rae i7pom3BOmaHmCR ao6bpia HeCTfTH, ma3a, yriFfif ILHpyrHifx f7pHpOHbiX pecypcoB) B 3TOM fpHifwoxeHifH HepaccMaTpHBaIoTc,L Bce 3THf a.aMfHHHcTpaTHBHbie o6pa3oBaHHlo HMelOT paBHblf lOf7lHfHfqecKH# cTaryc B paMKaXaeaepawtm If HfMCIOT B cBOeM cocraBe ce.J7bcKHe paAfoHbi, FioceqlKHf H FOpoa - Ka)4big Co CBOlfM co6cTBeHHbiMOpraHOM yi7paBJeHHfH KaK npaifwo, YiHC7eHHoCTb HaCawHmf aBTOHOMHbiX palfOHOB If OKpyrOB orHocfHTe.bHo Maa, If3a8acTyIo OHH 3aKIiio'iaioT coJYamemHH o coBMecTHol# 3KoHoMHfqecKoHf aewTmHocTlH H coBMecTHoM ynpaBieHHfif C6coree KppfHbiMHf o6pa3oBaHHs7MHf, YTO 3a7pyaHRCT o6pa6oTKy cTaTHcTvecKHfxaaHHubix

Page 278: Russian - World Bank Documents

274 nPHJO)KEHHE )K

Uix o6pa3 )KH3HUi CJY)K(HT cBoero po,a TOpM030M alS HX Kyj1bTypHO4 H o6fuek aCCimHjU11HH C

ApyrHMH CJISoMH o6iueCTBaMH.

)JpyrHe KOpeHHbie HapOA,bi nOOBI4JTHCb 3Zaecb nO31RHee. 3To 6bIBwUe KOMCBHHKH-

CKOTOBOAbl (xaKaCbl, SKyTbl) unu HapORbI, BeayuLue MHoroOTpaciieBoe X03AUCTBO (pyccKHe

CTapO)KHJIbl ). nepeHqB MHOrHe HaBbIKH OT KOpeHHbIX MaJIo'HCJIeHHbIX HapO)aOB CeBepa H

pa3pa6OTaB CBOU co6cTBeHHbie 6o0iee 34*eKTHBHbie unJu COBpeMeHHbie MeTOabl

X03.qriCTBOBaHHA, 3TH Fpyllnbl HaCeiieHH5 TaKwe CtHTaIOT TaKHe TpaHULHOHHbie 3aHSTHf, KaK

oxoTa, pbi6ojiOBcTBO Hu ofleHeBOACTBo BaXHOA 4aCTbIO cBoero KYJIbTypHorO HacJTeralu. B OTJIHqHe

OT KopeHHbIX MaJIO4HCjieHHbIX HapOROB CeBepa, 3TU rpynnbl He paccMaTpHBalOT COBpeMeHHbie

MeTOfbl BeaeHHI4 X035riCTBa H aCCHMHJIUHI410 B COBpeMeHHOM o6uteCTBe KaK yrpO3y CBoeU

KyJlbTypHOu caMo6blTHOcTH. B ueJIOM, Ha Cyab6y 3THX KOpeHHbIX HapoaOB OKa3aJIu OrpOMHoe

BJIHAHHe poccifcKHe 3aBoeBaHHS1 KOHua ceMHaIuaToro BeKa. U x nnueMeHa J1n60 oyw1JH c

3aBoeBaHHbIX Tepp4TopHA, Ju6o npHSHJ1H rocnOacTBO POCCuu, nepeWuJH Ha oceARWb[ o6pa3

XKH3HH H CTaJIH 3aHHMaTbCS 3eMj1e[eJiHeM. PoccHucuie 3aBoeBaTehuI 3HnoX KOJIOHH3aUHH4

("cTapotuHbi") accHMnJ14POBaJiHCb cpeau MeCTHorO HaceJIeHH5, co3LIaB reHeTH4eCKH

CMewiaHHoe HaceJIeHHe.

Fpy,mm HepeCemieHieB, COCTORT, riJaBHbIM o6pa3oM, H3 3TH4,eCKHX PYCCKHX,

nOIBHBLIIIHXCA 3.IeCb nocnie BTOPOU MHpOBOU4 BOUHbI. BOAbWlUHCTBO H3 HHX npuexanqo cloaa TUT

Toro, 'To6bl pa6oTaTb B TaKHX COBpeMeHHbIX oTpacjiix 3KOHOMHKH, KaK ao6blqa noJIe3HbIX

HCKOnaeMbIX H TpaHCnTOpT, H XOTS HeKOTOpbie H3 HHX 3aHIJIHCb HpOMbICJIOBOU OXOTOU HJIH

npOMbICJIOBbIM pbi6oJTOBCTBoM, 60JIbIHUHCTBO OTHOCHTCS K 3TOMY BHay aeSTeJIbHOCTH KaK K

pa3BEe4eHHIO HJIH xo66u.

3THHMeCKHe rpynlbI H HX MeTOMbl HCflOJb3OBaHHU JieCHblX peCypCOB

BOJ1bWlHHCTBO KopeHHbIX HapoaoB, npO)KHBaiolWUX B gaHHOM perHoHe OTHOCRTCA K

MOHrOAOUioHOA pace, B TO Ke BpeMAI HeKOTOpbIe 3TH4eCKHue rpynnbl (oco6eHHo xaKacbi),

HMelOT ABHbIe npH3HaKH 6enoul pacbl, a IlpyrHe - 'epTbl ypaj1o-anTar4cKor' rpynnbl (FpyK, 1994).3TH HapOabi rOBOpAT Ha 513blKaX TIOpKCKOA, TyHryco-MaHb'DKypCKOri H ypajio-aJ1TariCKOrt ceMeg,

a TaK)Ke q3blKaX KeTOB, HHBXOB H IOKarHpOB, He BXO[>IUtHX HH B KaKYlO 5l3blKOBYlO CeMbiO (FpyK,

1981). MHorme KopeHHbIe 3THH4ecKHe rpynribI, 3a 4cKAIo4eHKeM ya3reiueB, npHHHUIH

XpHCTHaHCTBO. OaHaKO B nocieaHee BpeMS Ha6JHolLaeTCS BO3poxKefHfie UwaMaHCTBa - TpaHULHH,

TaK aO KOHua H He noaaBjieHHoA Ha npoTqDKeHHH COBeTCKoro nepHoaa (ny4lKOB, 1994).

K KopeHHJmm 9THHIecKwHM rpyniam OTHOCATCA:

* BCHKH H 9BeHb. Ha BceU TeppUTOpHH OT 3ananHoil CH6HpH no

TUXOOKeaHCKOFO nO6epe)KbAl 3BeHKH H 3BeHbl 3aHMialOTCS1 OXOTOU H

pbi6oJnOBCTBOM (ropoxoB, 1994a), a TaKwKe OJIeHeBOaCTBOM (B OCHOBHOM nSI

y,aOBAeTBOpeHHA CBOHX TpaHCnOPTHbIX Hya). 0IOKHbie 3BeHKH nepeuJmH Ha

3aHSiTIe 3eMeneeYIHeM H )KHBOTHOBOaCTBOM. 9BeHbl H ceBepHbie 3BeHKH

3aHHMiaOTCH nacT6HLUHbIM oJIeHeBOaCTBOM, nepeneBurascb B TeCIeHHe Bcero ropa

C MeCTa Ha MeCTO B nOHCKaX HOBbIX I1aCT6HLULHbIX yrOanHu (CUpulHa, 1994).

* HerwgaanbJm H IoKaIHph. HertinaJlbUbl H IOKarUpbI 3aHtMiaOTCqI nu60

npeHmylLeCTBeHHO pbi6ojiOBCTBOM H IaCTHMHO OXOTOUi, niH6o H OXOTOU H

pbi6ojiOBCTBOM OaHOBpeMeHHO. 9TH HapOAHOCTH TaKwe 3aHMmalOTC5

pa3uBeeHHeM ojieHeu, HCnOJIb3yeMblX riiaBHbIM o6pa3oM KaK TpaHCIOpTHOe

Page 279: Russian - World Bank Documents

275 H]PHJ1OKEHHE X

cpe,acTBo, a TaioKCe C6opoM nfAO,B H CaIOBOaCTBOM, 'TO CJIY)I(4T AAS HHXBa)KHbIM AonOJTHHTeJTbHbIM HCTOMHHKOM npO IryKTOB nIHTaHHS. 143BeCTHO, 'TOHerHfaaJIbLbl HHOraa npoMbIWUIJHOT TioneHeui (CMOJISK, 1994a). 06eHapOtaHOCTH Beeyr oceAnbit o6pa3 XH3HH (rOpOXOB, 19946).

OpowH m yl(31Vre1 . 9 TH rpynnbl 3aHHMalOTCA JieCHoUH OXOTOU, a TaKiepbi6HOU JIoBjiei H c6opoM HeapeBeCHoA neCHoi npOAYKU4HH - rnaBHbIMo6pa3oM, =A. 3arOTOBOK npO[yKTOB nHTaHHR Ha 3HMy. Opoqu H ya3rerunbirpO)KHBalOT B nOCTOSHHbIX nocenKax H He 3aHHMaioTcA OJIeHeBOJCTBOM(CMOJIAK, 19946). nonHas Bbipy6Ka JieCOB B HeKOTOpbIX parioHax 3acTaBHua4aCTb y,a3reguieB nepecenHTbcs B apyrHe MecTa, r,ae OHH CO BpeMeHeM HcMe3IH.Te, KTO ocTaJIHCb, cMorJIH, nO Bcefi BepOATHOCTH, BbDKHTb TOJIbKO nOTOMy, 'TOOHH COPOTHBJISflnHCb nOJIHOH Bbipy6Ke iieCOB Ha HX TeppHTOPHH(LHHHpeJIbMaH, 1993).

* HaHa# H fYbWf. IH3Ha4a)IbHO HaHarLIbi H yJIb'H 6bMH pbi6oniOBaMH H KpOMeTOrO HeMHOrO 3aHHMaWHCb OXOTOU H C6opoM ntHuHi (JiecHoi ripORyKLUHH HMOpCKHX BoIopocnei - B 3aBHCHMOCTH OT MeCTOHaxoA)aeHtHH noceJIKa). OHHoce,iJo npo)KHBalOT B CBOHX roceCKax. CerOAHH OHH 3aHHMaioTcSpbI6oJIOBCTBOM uHn (B OrpaHH'IeHHOM KoAiHqeCTBe) nowuJH pa6oTaTb Hanieco3aroToKuK HJIH npeLnPHATHA niecHoro XO3ASCTBa (MecWITbi6, 1994;CMOJAIK, 1994B).

HHBXN. HHBXH TpaALIUHOHHO 3aHHMaioTcA pbi6oJIoBCTBOM. OHH )KHBYT BnoOCTOAHHbIX HnIH nOJIYnOCTOSHHbIX noceniKax B YCTbRX peK HeaJieKO OToKeaHa. Ux cyleCTBOBaHie BO MHoroM 3aBHceJIo OT c6opa nHLUH B Mope, Ha6epery H B .necax. Koraa-To OHU 3aHHMaJIHCb npOMbICJIOM TiojieHeui H JieCHOtuOXOTOrl, riiaBHbIM o6pa3OM, uiA c6blTa nyLUHHHbI (TaKcaMH, 1981).

* Ken. KeTbl ABJIAIOTCS pbI6oAOBaMH H IieCHbIMH OXOTHHKaMH, KOTOpbie TaKX)e3aHHMalOTCS oneHeBo,4CTBoM. C6op rJOZOB HMeeT IAI HHX OTHOCHTenJbHOHe6oJIbluoe 3HaIeHHe. He TaK aaBHO KeTbl nepecTanH 3aHHMaTbCRnaCT6i.UHbIM oJIeHeBO24CTBOM H nepeWJIH Ha OXOTHH4UiU IPOMblCeTi nyWHUHHbI,a TaKiKe (B orpaHH'ieHHbIX MacWLTa6ax) Ha pbI6HyIo JIOBJIIO H c6op nfIOLaOB Ansco6CTBeHHoro noTpe6ieHHS (BarHWTeriH, 1994).

* CeibxyH H IllOptL. Pbi6onOBbl, OXOTHHKH H oJieHeBOAbl, CeJlbKynbI KOrAa-TO6buIH KOqeBHHKaMH, HO cenlaC Be,yT ocexibIr o6pa3 )KH3HH (BacHnbeB,1994B). OHH co6HpaloT nieCHbIe nOAbl Ui HIOBSAT pbl6y AAA CBoero co6CTBeHHoronoTpe6ieHHI4. CMeUIaHHbie 6paKH C PYCCKHMH (cenbiKynbi) H XaKaCaMH(wopubl) OKa3aiUH CHTIbHOe BUIHAHHe Ha A3blKH H Tpa,i4UHUOHHbIe 3aHTHAR 3TU4XHaPOAOB (BacHjibeB H MaJIHHOBCKaR, 1993; E5yTaHaeB, 1993).

• 4QalHm. aOJ1raHbl - 3TO MoAoioaA 3THHqecKaq rpynna (nosBHunacb B KOHue2IeBSTHaaLxaTOrO BeKa), CJIOX)KBwaACA B pC3yJ1bTaTe CMmeweHH KOpeHHbIXMaJOU4HCjieHHbIX HaPOfOB CeBepa C PYCCKHMH CTapo)KHAaMH. OHH 3aHHMalOTCSI1aCT6HUxHbiM oJneHeBOaCTBOM, npOMbICJIOM aUHKHX CeBepHbIX OJneHeU B uenIAX,ao6blUH MACa H wKyp, pbI6oJIOBCTBOM, a TaKwe c6opoM nnfOaOB, pacTyYlllHX BTyHZape. flpH TOM, qTo 60JIbWHHCTBO H3 HHX riepeceni4UiOCb B MeCTHbieropoacKHe rIOCeJIKH, OHU He 6pocaloT CBOH TpaHUXHOHHbie 3aHSTHS.

Page 280: Russian - World Bank Documents

276 HPHJIOKEHHE )K

HcHLIu, 3HI(M H HnIHaCaHM. )ZnIf 3THX o6HTaiolUX B TYHape 3THt4eCKHX

rpynn rIaBHbIM 3aHSTHeM no-npe)KHeMy OCTaeTCA naCT6HIuHoe oneHeBOAcTBO,

a aOnOnIHHTeAbHbIMH 3aHATH1MH qBJIqSIOTCA pbI6ojioBCTBO H npOMbIceni

CeBepHbIX oJIeHei A1 Ao6biNH wlKyp U MAICa (BacHAbeB, 19946).

B oTJuIme OT 3TUX KOpeHHbIX 3THH4eCKHX rpynn apy7we KOpIHHUc Ipyfmm aHHorO

perHoHa (sKyTbl, XaKaCbI H pYCCKHe CTapo)KHUbi) (3OPMHUpIOT OTaeSJbHbie COuL4aAbHO-

KyJnbTypHbie rpynnbl. ECJIH CTaTyc AKyTOB H xaKacoB KaK KOpeHHblX HapoaOB He BbI3blBaeT

HHKaKUX npo6AeM, TO TaKOe OnpexeJieHHe, KaK "KOpeHHbIe pyCCK4e", npo6JIeMaTH4qHO.

HepenHCb HaceieHuHAi 1926 r. BbaejiAiJia KopeHHbIX pyCCKHx, pOOaHBWJHXC51 B 3THX Kpaqx, H

nepecenieHieB (pyccKiie CTapocKHJbl). aByCMbIcJieHHoCTb BO3HHKaeT 6naroaap3l TOMy, HTOHeKOTOpbie "KOpeHHbIe" PYCCKHe MOryT 6blTb rOTOMKaMH Tex 3THHMeCKHX pyCCKHX, KOTOpble

nonanHu B CH6Hpb H Ha IaflbHHri BOCTOK B pe3ynfbTaTe MacCOBOA MHrpa[Lti HaceJieHHA,

HaqaBmeAcA npHiMepHO B 1905 r. IICT4HHO KOpeHHbie rpynnbI yKe IaBHO KOHTaKTHpYIOT C

KOpeHHbIMH MaJIo4HCAeHHbIMH HapoaaMH CeBepa H xopowo nOHHMalOT OCo6eHHOCTH

)KH3HeHHOrO yKIiaaa H IOBeaeHHe apyr Rpyra - jiyqwe, leM nepecenieHUbl nOHHM1alOT H TeX H

ApyrHx.

PyCCKHe C7IpOJfJm npO)HBalOT HO Bceg TeppHTOPHH 3Toro perHOHa, B OCHOBHOM, B

1aOJIHHax peK. lIx rnaBHoe 3aHqTHe - pbi6ojIOBCTBO B co4eTaHHH C 3eMJIeaeAieM Ha iore H OXOTOUi

Ha ceBepe. nepeceiieHUbI TaK H He nepeWmuI Ha oJIeHeBOaCTBO, XOTS KOraa-TO y HUX 6buIH

6oJmuIHe cTaj1a ofleHeri, KOTOpbIX nacni npeaCTaB4TeJI4 KOpeHHbIX HapoaoB (FyJIeBcKH4l H

CM4meHKO, 1994). Pocc4gCKHe Ka3aKM TO)Ke npHuH4CJIqOT ce6si K "KOpeHHbIM" HapOaaM, H B

Xa6apOBCKOM Kpae OHU aKTHBHO 6oplOTCA 3a npHCBoeHHe HM 3Toro CTaTyca, KOTOpblAi JaeT

npaBO Ha nojiyteHHe 6ecnJIaTHbIx JIHueH3MR Ha OXOTy H pbI6ojiOBCTBO, a TaKwKe 3eMenJbHbIX

yMacTKOB, Heo6JIaraeMbIx apeHaHOr4 niiaToP HJunu HajioroM. BpHa JInu, Ka3aKH ao6blOTCq ycnexa,

TIOCKOJIbKy Hx ipeTeH3HH iMelOT noH co60u He 6onbwe OCHOBaHH4r, LleM npeTeH3HH MHOrUIX

ApyruHX 3THH4eCKHX rpynn.

XaKacM - 3TO npUHHIBWHR XPHCTHaHCTBO TIOpKO-,q3blHbIg Hapoa, B COCTaB KOTOporo

BXOLAT 4eTblpe rIneMeHH. 3To OaHa H3 CaMblX yp6aHH3HpoBaHHbIx H "o6pyceBW1x" 3THHiqeCKHX

rpynn CH6HpH. nepBOHaLajIbHO, 3TH nIiemeHa 6buH no.IyKoMeBbIMH CKOTOBOaaaM4, KOTOPble

3aHHMaBJHCb pa3BeaeH4eM jjowaaeH H OBCU, a TaK)Ke Tpaa4UHOHHbiM rOpHbIM CeJbCKHM

X035rUCTBOM. Koraa-To OXoTa HM4eJIa ARA HHX orpoMHoe 3Ha4eHHe, H BOKpyr 3Toro pota

rae,qTeJbHOCT4 BO3HHKjio 6oAbuloe KOJIl-IeCTBO pa3J1H4HbIX o6pIaOB. C60p HCapeBeCHOH iieCHOi

npOaYKUHH4, oco6eHHo KopHenJIOaOB H KeapOBbIX opexoB, TaK)ce HMJei 6onbWuoe 3HaCeHHe DARA

nPHrOTOBjieHH51 UX TPaamUI4OHHOA nHHLU (byraHaeB, 1994).

RKy7M, KOTOpbIe TaKwe OTHOCATCA K Hpl4HHBLUM XpUCTHaHCTBO TIOpKO-,q3blqHbIM

HapOaaM, KOraa-TO EieAUHJICb Ha 35-40 rineMeH, HO ceuMac TaKoe aejieHHe HCqe3Jo. Ilx

Tpa4ULLHOHHbje 3aHqTH5 6bnUI aBHaJIOrHHbI 3aH51UTHAM xaKaCOB (B. lI4BaHOB, 1994) BnJIOTb ,DO

BOceMHaauaTOrO BeKa, KOrIaa Ta tiaCTb AKyTOB, KOTOpaA nepeceflTacb Ha ceBepo-3anaA, 6bmia

BblHyx.eHa OTKa3aTbCSI OT pa3BeeeHH4I JioLwaEDeh H KpynHOrO poraToro CKOTa B YCJIOBH5IX TyHapbl

H JTeCOTyHapbI. OHU nepeWJIH Ha OieHeBOoaCTBO B uenjix KpynHOMacuTa6HorO KOMMepCecKoro

npOH3BO,aCTBa MACa H WUKyp. 3Ta HOBaA rpynna, nOJIy'-HBwa5i Ha3BaHme "5IKyTOB-OAeHeBOROB",

HO51BHi4aCb B aeBATHaAUaTOM BeKe H co3Laajia, HaBepHoe, camoe HpOH3BOaHTeJIbHOe nacT6HIILHoe

OjieHeBOJtCTBO BO Bceri EBpa3HH. MHOrie SKYTbI He OTKa3a.1HCb OT 3TomO 3aHATHS4 H B COBeTCKOe

BpeMSl, HO OHH BOWAIH B nOJIH3THHLeCKHe COBXO3bI nJIu KOJIXO3bl.

Page 281: Russian - World Bank Documents

277 nPKJ1OXCEH4E K

HepeceCmIm COCTaBJIqIOT 6oAbWHHcTBo HaceAeHHq BO MHOrHX paHOHax. 5IBiSlCb, BOCHOBHOM, 3THM4eCKHMH pyCCKHMH, OHH TaKXe BKJlOMalOT yKpaHHUCB, 6enOpyCOB H TaTap; KaKnpaBHJIO, B KYJlbTYPHOM OTHOwIeHHH OHM nOXO)KH Ha "eBponeHcKHX PYCCKHX - no KpagHeUMepe, B ropoAax. CeflbcKoe HacenieHHe MCeeT 6onee CJIO)KHbliU xapaKTep, nOCKOJ]bKy 3AeCb mIoAlCTpeM3RTCA o6beaMHATbCA no nPH3HaKy o611HOCTH KYJIbTypHbIX UCTOKOB HnM ye3)KaTb B ropoAanocne TOrO, KaK 3apa6oTaJlH AOCTaTO4Hoe KOAHMeCTBO AeHer. B Luej1oM, camoe CHAbHoeKYJIbTypHOe caMOCO3HaHHe H CaMbIe 3Ha'HTeJTbHb1e rIoBeaeH4ecKMe oTjnHqHA XapaKTepHbl 21JH1npo)KHBalOIHX B CH6upu pyCCKHX, OCo6eHHO B CeJnbCKOU4 MeCTHOCTH. 9TH nepeceAeHUbl, KaKnpaBHAO, pa6oTaloT Ha rpeHnpHSTHAIX ropHoAo6blBaioLueH rpoMbnIwJeHHocTM, TpaHcrOpTe, BreoflorlqecKoH pa3BeAKe HuH Ha JieCO3arOTOB14TebHbIX npegripM1THAX H TOJbKO B BHUeHCKHO'ioeHHSI iXAyT pa6oTaTb B iiecHoe XO3Ar4CTBO nJIH TpaHULIHOHHbie ceKTopa MeCTHOA3KOHOMHKH. IIHTepeCHbIM Ha6AIOaeHHeM ABJIqeTCA TO, 'TO MHOrHe J1eCO3arOTOBHTeJiH - 3TO6biBUIHe 3aKJiOqeHHbie, KOTOpbIe, HOJIyq4B npOq3eccHIO BO BpeMI OT6blBaHlSI CpOKa B TpyAOBbIXnarep.qx, nocue OCBo6o)KaeHH5 CeiilTCq B 6num3exameH MeCTHOCTH.

HenpaBHTe.nbcTBeHHbie opraMmHu3mu

3a nocueAHMe roabI nOiBHAOCb MHo)KeCTBO HenpasuTenbCTBeHibiX opraHu3aUldi (HnO),BbiCTynaOlumX OT HMeHH KOPeHHbIX HaPOTOB. OHH 3aHHMalOTCS caMOH pa3HOH aeATeJbHOCTbIO -OT c6opa MHHqOpMaUMH O npo6IieMaX, KOTOpbIe CTOAT nepeA KOpeHHbIMH HapOIaMH, HBbICKa3bIBaHM5 cBOeu O3a6oMeHHOCTH B cpeACTBax MaccoBOh 1H(OpMauHH, Ao H3yqeHHR HKOMMep4ecKoro c6blTa TpaAiUHUOHHOA MY3bIKH H no33uu H oKa3aHH5 CO,AerCTBHS B pa3pa6OTKeKOHuenHLHri co3AaHHs yqaCTKOB npHpOLHbIX pecypcoB, OTBO,AHMbIX AAA TPaAHuHOHHOrOHcHoAb3oBaHHH KOpeHHbIMH HapoaaaMH. B CH6upu H Ha alaJibHeM BocToKe aKTHBHO pa6oTaloT HHeKOTOpbie MeKCyHapOAHbie HnO.

Hau6o0nee aKTHBHOH H BJIHSTeJIbHoI 13 Bcex HIO, MMeeioLeue CBOHX npeAcTaB4TeJ1e9 BOBcex alMMHHcTpaTHBHO-TeppMTOpHaAbHbIX o6pa3oBaHMAX, pafoHax H noceAKax, ABSCeTCAAccoLHaJuHS KopeHHbIX Majio'-cJIeHHbIX HaPOQOB CeBepa, Cu6HPu H AanjbHerO BoCTOKaPOCCHUCKOU $PeAepaLtMm, OCHOBaHHaA B KOHUC 1993 r. 9Ta rpynna HMeeT CBOIO OpraHH3aumioHa o6wepoccMAcKOM YPOBHe (TaK we, KaK H MeXayHapoaHblf4 4)OHA pa3BMTHST ManjOqHCJieHHbIXHapoAoB H 3THHMeCK4X rpynn, nJIaroTBOpHTeCbHbl (bOHA pa3B4TH5I KyAbTypbl CeBepa HManOqHCJTeHHb[X HapOAOB CeBepa, $POHA, COXpaHeHHq H pa3BHTH14 3KOHOMUKH H KyJIbTypblMajiou4cAeHHb1X HapoAoB CeBepa, MeXAyHapoAHas nura MaAoIHcOHeHHbIX HapOAOB H3THHqeCKHX rpynni, a TaKxe (oOHA ManjOq4cAeHHbIX HapoAOB CeBepa). JapyrHe HnO aekCTByIOTrniaBHbIM o6pa3OM Ha MeCTax unM AerUCTBYIOT OT HMeHH KOHKPeTHbIX 3THHqeCKHX rpynn uInurpynn, HaxoqSWHXCq B R3bIKOBOM unM KYJIbTYPHOM pOACTBe.

AccouHaUHH KopeHHbIX MaTio'HcAeHHbIX HapoAOB CeBepa (13BeCTHaS1 B pa3HblX perHoHaxnoa pa3HblMH Ha3BaHHl4MH), B 4aCTHoCTH, ee pertHoHajIbHoe oTAeJIeHHe, AeAcTBylOuee BTypyxaHCKOM H EHHCerCKOM paUiOHax KpaCHOqpCKOrO Kpaq H B 3BeHKHH, riPMHIMmanaHeHOCpeACTBeHHOe yqaCTHe B pa3pa6oTKe KOHUellUHH "TeppHTOpHUi TpaAHUMOKHOH O3eMJieClOJlb3OBaHMM" H KOHuenUCHU "KJaHa-CeMbH-o6LUHHbl". KpoMe TOIO, B COTPYAHtMieCTBe CpariOHHbIMH aAM4HHcCTpaUl4AMH H CrUMeJaICTaMH $eAepaTIbHOA CJiyx6bl ueCHoro X03SA4CTBaAccoLLHautiA OKa3blBaTia coaeCTBHe B opraHH3aLiHH o6LUMH H BbiaejieHHq MM 3eMeCjbHbIXyMaCTKOB.

CouHauIbHO-KynbTypHbwe npo6JleMbi

Fpo6ineMbl, CTOALuCe nepea KopeHHbIMH HapoAaMm Cu6upu H JaJJbHero BocToKa,aHBaorHMHbl npo6ueMaM noAo6Hblx rpynn HaceJIeHHiA BO BceM MHpe. YMeHbweHHe HAM

Page 282: Russian - World Bank Documents

278 nPIVIOACEHHE X

yBeniHteHHe pa3mepa TaKHX rPYnn MO)CeT CTaTb aln HHX COUHaJibHOH npo6JieMog, TaK Xe, KaK H

KyJ!bTypHasI aCCHMHJIAUH5 (nOTeps KyflbTypHbIX U nOBeaeHMeCKHX oco6eHHOCTeri H HaBbIKOB,

Heo6xo,aHMbIx xiSi COXpaHeHHS9 TpaaHUIIOHHbIX 3aHSATH Hnu pHTyaJIoB), a TaKwKe 3THH'eCKaS H

SI3bIKOBaSl accHMHAuLSHA, BKAio'aR Heo6paTIMoe 6ioAortiecKoe cMeweHHe C HeKOpeHHbIMt

HapO,aaMH. 9TH npo6neMbl ycyry6iSlIOTCI ,OBOJIbHO BblCOKHM YPOBHeM 6e3pa6oTUblI, 6eaHocTm

H anKOrOJIH3Ma - IBJeHHeM, HanpqMyiO CBH3aHHbIM C pe3KHM naAeHHeM COOTHOLeHHH

KOAHMeCTBa My)KIHH H )KeHUHWH no npHqH4He BbICOKOrO YpOBHA CMepTHOCTH Myx)HH

(CoKonoBa, 1990).

Y 6o0nJbHCTBa KopeHHbIX HapoaoB, 3a HcKnioHeHHeM ceAbKynOB U 3HueB, 4HcAeHHOCTb

HacejieHHH paCTeT KaK B OTHOCHTeJIbHbIX, TaK H B a6coAioTHbIx LUH(pax. 3Ta TeHaeHUHR Mo)KeT

YCHAHTbC51 H3-3a MacCOBOrO npHTOKa HeKopeHHbIX HapoaOB C CeBepa, KOTOpblU Ha6jHloaaeTCq C

Ha{ajia 1990-x roaoB, H npHBeCTH K TOMy, YTO B HeKOTOpbIX aaMHHHCTPaTHBHO-

TePPHTOPHaJ1bHbIX o6pa3oBaHHRx KOpeHHbie HapOglb 6yayr B 3Ha4HTeAbHoM MeHbllWHHCTBe.

)J,AR 6o0bWHHcTBa 3THX rpynn cepbe3Hy1o npo6JIeMy npeacTaBASHOT KyJ1bTypHaq H o6[uaA

aCcHMHA51UIH5 H 6HonorwmecKoe cMeIlIeHHe. HaceneHHe 60jibIIHHCTBa KOpeHHb1X HapO,IOB

MO)XCHO B Lue1omM pa3XeniHTb Ha TpH rpynnbl. OAHa rpynna HacenieHH5 no-npe)KHeMy )KHBeT B

Ko,qeBb1X HAH H3OAHPOBaHHbLX o6IUHHax. BTopaq rpynna - B nojuH3THHqeCKHX noceJiKax, HO no-

npeAKHeMy BeneT TpaHULtHOHHbli o6pa3 )KH3HH. TpeTbs - B KpYIHbIX nOAH3THHqeCKHX

HaCeiJeHHbiX nyHKTaX H pa6oTaeT B COBpeMeHHbIX, HeTpa,HULIHOHHbIX ceicopax 3KOHOMHKH. B

TpeTb1O rpynny nofa,aeT rpHMHepHo nOIOBHHa 3aHATOFO HaceheHH51 KopeHHbIX Hapo,aOB

(CoKofloBa, 1990).

HecMoTpH Ha TaKHe pa3uii4qHq B xapaKTepe pacceneHHr H o6pa3e )KH3HH, MHorHe

KOpeHHbIe HapOabI 'yBCTBYIOT IPO4HYIO CB513b npyr C apyrOM H ouTyUlaloT CBOIO

npHHaAIe)KHOCTb K OAHOMY KJiaHy, OAHOR o6wUHHe Hun 3THH1ecKoMy o6pa3oBaHHlo. Oco6eHHo

npo'IHbI CB5R3H Memuy He6OJIbLUHMH noceIKaMH, a TaiOKe KoMeBbIMH H H3OJI1POBaHHbIMH

rpynnaMH, npO)KHBaIOIUHMH B OT1ajieHHbIX cToR6Hiuax. KpoMe Toro, CyUReCTBYIOT

noIHTHUqeCKHe, KyJbTypHbie, o6pa3oBaTeflbHble, pORCTBeHHbie, 3KOHOMH4eCKHe H 513bIKOBbie

CB13H, a TaK)Ke TOPrOBJIH H COBMeCTHOe BJ1aAeHHe HMyHUeCTBOM MeKLy pa3JIH4Hb1MH nOCeeAKaMH.

TaK, HanpuMep, aeTH, npowKBaiioiue B nocenKax HAH ropoaax, npOBOaqT KaHHKynJbl CO CBOHMH

6a6yUiKaMH, eaeywKaMH H ApyrlHMH pOCTBeHHHKaMH B ofeHeBoaleCKHX nJIH pbi6oJIOBeUKHX

CTo6HuWax, rae OHM COBepweHCTBYIOT 3HaHHe pOOHOrO I3blKa, o6y'alOTCc TpaLuLHLOHHbiM

HaBb1KaM H HaMHHalOT owywLaTb o6LUHOCTb KYJIbTypbl H CBOIO CaMo6blTHOCTb.

I3blKOBaH accHMHJIqLUHR npOH30umja, rJaBHbIM o6pa3oM, 3a CqeT nepexoxaa Ha

HCnOJ1b3OBaHHe pyccKoro sI3blKa, a B AIKyTUH - Ha qKYTCKHe q3bIKH. Ho xaa,ce B TeX cjly'aqx,

Korna ruiemeHa KOpeHHb1X MaJO4HCjieHHbIX HapOAOB CeBepa nlepeXOAqT Ha O0U4H H3 3THX q3blKOB

us' ygo6CTBa, OHM no-npe)KHeMy 'eTKO owylualoT CBOIO 3THH1ecKyio caMo6bITHOCTb (Ky3HeuoB

H MHCCOHOBa, 1993). 3THHMecKaSI accHMHJIAULH5 npOHCXOaHT, rJaBHbIM o6pa3oM, cpeaH

KopeHHOrO HaceJeHH5, npO2KHBaioLtero B ropoaax, KorAa OHO y)Ke He Mo)KeT H3Bsneb TaKHe

BbIrO,bl H3 CTaTyCa 3THH4eCKOrO MeHbWHHCTBa, KaKHe H3BJieKalOT HX COpOaLUH4 B cejibcKog

MeCTHOCTH. reHeTuHecKoe cMewIeHHe (c HeKOpeHHbIMH HapOaaMH) HaCTOAbKO pacnpocTpaHeHO,

HTO POCT 'HCJIeHHOCTM CeJlbKynOB, KeTOB H HraHaCaHOB o6yCJiOBJIeH, rilaBHbIM o6pa3OM,

no.qBJleHHeM AeTeg OT CMewaHHbiX 6paKoB. 9To MO)KeT llpHBeCTH K pa3Mb1BaHH1O 3THHLeCK4X

rpaHHU H, 'ITO 6o0ee Ba)KHO, K nOTepe CBOH1CTB HacieaCTBeHHOti 6HonorrHecKog a,aHTaaau K

CypOBbIM YCAOBMSIM CeBepa (KnoKOB H KoploxHHa, 1994).

Page 283: Russian - World Bank Documents

279 HlPHAo)KEHHE K

Pacnpe,aeAeHHe 3eMeCJb Mex(y COCeaHHM4 KOpeHHbIMH MaajO1ioCiceHHbIMH HapoaaMHCesepa H apyrHMH KOpeHHbIMH HapogaMH, BKAiuOqaSI pa3,aeAeH4e OXOTHHiqbHX H pbi6oJiOBeUKHXyro,aHri H oJIeHbHX naCT6Hu, npOH3Ouio 6o0nee BeKa Ha3aa. He3aBHCHMO OT TOrO, HaCKOJIbKOTaKoe pacripeaejieHHe 6buo cnpaBeIAH4bIM, HbIHeWUHee pa3aejleHHe 3eMeJb H yFOauH]CyiueCTByeT y)Ke aaBHO H qBjSieTCR o6menpH3HaHHbIM, H BCe CTOpOHbI cerlqac C4HTalOT TaKOe.aejieHHe "eCTeCTBeHHbIM". TaKHM o6pa3OM, pa3TIejieHHe "o6WUHHHbIX 3eMenb" Mexay KYiaHaMH,ceMb$1M4 unJI o6UHHaMH He Bbl3blBaTiO COuJaHjbHOrO KOHrJIHKTa. B Tex cAy'aSx, Korga BeaeHHeKOJIXO3Horo H COBXO3Horo XO3sihCTBa noTpe6oBaJo nepeceneH[iq MHorI'x ceMee, BCKOJTbIXHYnaCbo6uiecTBeHHasl naMHTb 0 TOM, KaK BCe 6buIo o6yCTpoeHO B CTap4Hy, H 6bu¶o npoBeaeHo HOBoepa3rpaHHUIeHHe 3eMeJJb, BKJiO4aA B cJy'ae HeO6XoaHMOCTH o6MeH y'aCTKaMH. OaHaKO, KorLapyCCKHe CTapO)KHAbi H SIKyTbI rOKHLXalOT CBOH POAHbie 3eMjiH H ceJITCSI B HOBbIX MeCTax, MeC)ayHHMH H KOpeHHbIMH MaJoqHCJeHHbIMH HapOgaaMH MO)KeT BO3HHKHyTb riSpMoe COrepHiHeCTBO 3apa6oqHe MeCTa B TpaaLHtLOHHbix npOMbIcAax. TaKas ripo6nieMa He BO3HHKaeT, ecnu OHUcTpeM51TCR HaiTH pa6oTy Ha COBpeMeHHbix rpOMblwineHHbIX npeanpRITHAX HJIH TpaHCnOpTe.ByayMqH ripiuHeJbUaMH, 3TH J1IOAU MOryT o6HapyxcHTb, WTO K HUM OTHOCATCS1 KaK K"'nepeceJIeHuaM", a He KaK K "KOpCHHOMy HaCeJAeHH10", He3aBHCHMO OT 3THH4eCKOrO COCTaBaMeCTHoro coo6lueCTBa.

CaMbIe cepbe3Hbie CouHanTbHbie rpOTHBopetSI MCKeway rpyrinamu nepeceIeHUeB, a TaK)KeMe)Ky riepeceCneHuaMH H MeCTHbIM HJun KOpeHHbIM HacenieHHeM BO3HHKaIOT BoKpyr pa3IHqHb[XllpOMbiljieHHbIX ripeallpHATH. 3TU UIpOTHBOpCeHH, KaK HpaBHJIO, CBH3aHbI C3eMJerioJb3OBaHHMe, Jn6o HOTOMy, ITO 3KOJIOrH-eCKH He34)CeKTHBHOe yrpaBJIeHHenpe,anpHMTH5MM4 HOBpe)K,LaeT Hmn pa3pywIaeT nO4BeHHbl nOKpOB, Ju460 IOTOMy, 'ITO xapaKTep3eMjienOJb3OBaHH4l HapylwaeT YCTaHOBHBIUIYIOCA CTPYKTYPY pacnpeaenieHHW 3eMeAb,corAacOBaHHyIO C MeCTHbIM HaceIieHHeM eLue ao co3gaHHI ripoMbiwL)eHHOFO npeanpSiTHSI.HpHMepoM MOryT CnyJ)KHTb 4000-5000 reKTapos 3eMeCJb, eAceroaHO BbieAqSBWUHXCRreofloropa3Be,ao4HOMy ripernplATHIO B 3BeHKH1 B KOHLUC 1980-x roaoB. 3arps3HeHHe,Bbl3BaHHoe 6ypeHHeM Hpo6HbIX Hed)T5Hb1X CKBaXKHH, caeCjanio 3Ty 3eMJIIO He npH4rOaHOfi AnqOXOTbI, pbi6oJIOBCTBa Hmn riaCT6HLUHOrO ojieHeBOaCTBa.

TpaAHnuHOHHble 3aHMTK5 H KyJIbTrip

HOHATHe TpaLU4LtHOHHbIX 3aHSIT1H HaCeJeHHH B 3THX perUOHax wHpOKO HCHOj1b3yeTCq BpOCCHrICKOH JIHUTepaType, CpeACTBaX MaCCOBOU H H¢OpMaLuUH H aaMUHHHCTpaTHBHO-npaBOBbIXaOKYMeHTaX. OHO OTHOCHTCS K OXOTe Ha 3Bepek C UeCJblO ao6bi'rn nYWHHHbl H MHCa; OTAOBY HoxoTe Ha TIoACeHei H He6o.TbwHX KHTOB; JIOBJIC pbi6bl B peKaX, 03epaX H Ha MOPCKOM nO6epeKbe;oneHeBoIacTBy; c6opy HeapeBeCHOA JieCHOA npOAyKu4H, Haip4Mep, ArOA, Cbeao6HbIX paCTeHHA,opeXOB, rpu60B H TpaB; H3rOTOBJIeHHIO HaUHOHaAbHOH OaeACKbI H npeaMeTOB ,aOMaWHeA yTBapHH 3arOTOBKe HpO2IYKTOB rHTaHH5. MHOiHe H3 3THX TpaaHUHUOHHbIX 3aHSTHfl nipeTepneiHJ O'eHbCepbC3Hbie H3MeHeHHS B pe3yJIbTaTe KOAAeKTHBH3aUHH H MOaepH43aUiH, HarpHMep,HCHOAb3OBaHHe COBpeMeHHbIX CeTeH H MeXaHH3HpOBaHHbIX MOPCKHX CyaOB, riepexoa OTpa3Be,aeHHU1 OJeHerH KaK CpeaCTBa nepeaBHuKeHC4A K C03AaH41O KPYnHbiX naCT6HLUHbIX HoAeHeCBOLI4eCKHX ripeaHr TH ATH 1aA KOMMep4eCKOrO c6bITa Mqca u Hw[Kyp.

B nociieaHee BpeMq B alHCKYCCHHX MeCAy POCCU4UCKHMH 3KCnepTaMH H aKTHBHCTaMHaBH)KeHHA 3a npaBa KOpeHHbIX HapOaOB nORBHIOCb HOHSTHCe "HeOTpaawUL4OHaIH3M", TO eCTbpa3BTHCe TpaI4UIHOHHbIX 3aHSTHh B CO4eTaHHH C COBpeMeHHbIMH COuHaAbHbIMH HMefHUHHCKHMH yCSyraMH H CBM3aHHbIMH C HHMH TeXHOAOrHqMH4. 9To HOHHTHeripe,ayCMaTpHBaeT:

Page 284: Russian - World Bank Documents

280 nHPHJ1OKEH HE A

* FlepeceuieHHe cenJbCKHX )KHTeiieg 13 KpynHbIX HaCeJieHHblX nyHKTOB B He6ojlblHHe

nOCeAKH, pacrOJIO)KeHHbie Ha CJIO)KHBUWHXCq OXOTHHMbHX H pbi60jiOBeLKHX yrOJabqIX H

ojieHbHX nacT6HuLax.

* YBeJmIeHHe KantTaJiOBJIO)KeHHI4 B TPaaHUHOHHbie npOMbICAbl.

* EOnbbaA OPHeHTaUHS npOH3BOaCTBa Ha BHyTpeHHHe HY)K4bl B ueMjix AOCTI)KeH4H

caMoo6ecne'eHHOCTH .

* $)opMHpOBaHuie nocenJIKOBO o6LUHHbl KaK rIiaBHOU COUHaJibHO-3KOHOMiH'eCKOR H

KyJIbTypHOh opraHH3auHH, nOaOT1eTHOR CBoeMy HaceJleHHIo (nHKa H FpoxopoB,

1994).

OAHO H3 npOBeaeHHbIX HCCj1eAOBaHHli nOKa3aao, 'TO 6o0iee 90 npoueHTOB KOpCHHoro

HaCeIieHH5I TaUiMbipa, 3BeHKHH U KpaCHORPCKOrO Kpaq CM4TalOT, tlTO UX 6yayaLee - 3TO

Pa3BHTHC TpaAHUH4OHHbIX nPOMbICJIOB ([yjieBCKHU H CHM4eHKO, 1994). nO MHeHmIO

60JTbUIHHCTBa POCCUUCKUX 3THojiOrOB, Bbl)KHBaHHe KOpCHHbIX MaJIOWHCjieHHbIX HapOaOB CeBepa

3aBHCHT OT CoXpaHeHHA U pa3BHTHH HX TpamUUHOHHOA KyJIbTypbl H Tpaai4UOHHbIX 3aHATiHI

(111HHpenbMaH, 1994).

B uejiOM, CYweCTBYIOT RBa CeKTOpa 3KOHOMUKH, KOTOPbIe 3aBHCqT OT HCnOJTb3OBaHH5I

n1eCHbIX peCYPCOB Ha HYA(Abl 3THX rpynn HaceJieHHiu: neCHOA ceKTop, KOTOpblU BKnioHaeT

ynpaBjieHHe H HCHOJTb3OBaHHe apeBeCHbIX peCYpCOB, H yrOMHHHaBWHeCq Bblwe "TpamUH4OHHbie

npOMblCJnbl", BKJlio'aioluHe ucnOJnb3OBaHue HeapeBeCHbIX .IeCHbIX peCypCOB. JeCHOA CeKTOp

BKJiol{aeT KaK iiecHoe X03sIUCTBO, TaK H Jieconepepa6aTbIBalou.tylo npoMblwHIeHHocTb.

(DenepanbHasI cJIy)K6a AecHoro XO3SH4CTBa ocyuieCTBji5eT pyKOBOT,CTBO neCOXO33H4CTBeHHOA

,aeSITeAbHOCTb1O xiepe3 HH)KeCTOqiWu4e aaMHHHcCTpaTHBHbie OpraHbl (necXo3bl), KOTOpbIe HpOBORqT

TaKcaLUHIO Aeca, OCyLIeCTBJIAIOT KOHTPOJb 3a AecoHOJIb3oBaHHeM, OTBe'aIOT 3a CaHHTapHy1O

Bbipy6Ky, AecOBoccTaHOBjieHHe, caaq-y B apeHAYy H BbileAeHHe 3eMeAJbHbIX y'aCTKOB pa3JI4HHblM

nOJIb3OBaTeAIqM (i ji5 neCO3arOToBoK, OXOTbI HJun pbI6oJIOBCTBa); KpOMe TOrO, OHU OCYLueCTBnqOT

KOHTPOllb 3a aeATeJIbHOCTbIO 3THX IOJb3oBaTejieA. B 3TOM ceKTope pa6oTaloT nIeCOBObI,

AeCHHKH, a TaloKe nOCTOAHHbie HAu ce3OHHbIe TeXHH'ICCKHe pa6OTHHKH. CTaTHCTH4eCKHe

XaaHHbie O jieCHOH npOMbblHJIeHHOCTH BKJIlOeHbl B CTaTHCTiqeCKylO OTqeTHOCTb no ceJbCKOMY

X03S1CTBy. JIecHaA npOMbiwJeHHOCTb npeaCTaBJIeHa FocKoMjiecnpoMoM H OXBaTbIBaeT

AeCO3aFOTOBHTeJIbHbie rpeHnpHATuA, 3aBOabl no nepepa6OTKe apeBectiHbI H UenjiJoIo3HO-

6yMa)KHbie KOM64HaTbl.

43 OCTaBwegcq JeCHOU TePpHTOPHH 3TUX peri4OHOB 4% HaxoaqTCq B BeaeHHH

cenbCKOXO3AuCTBeHHbIX npeanpLITHfl B paMKax PocarponpoMa - COBX030B nJu1 KOAXO3OB, nJIH

(B nocneaHee BpeMS) aKLUHOHepHbIX nJIu KOonepaTHBHbIX npeHnpHI4THI4. 1I HaKOHeU, NO% 3TOU

TeppUTOpUH HaXOAHTCA B BeaeHH4 rocyaapcTBeHHoro KOMHTeTa no oxpaHe oKpy)KaioLWeH CpeabI

(npHpoZaHbie 3anoBeaH4KH) H 1% - B BeaeHHH Lpyr4x opraH43a1uui, HanpHMep, M4HHCTePCTBa

o6OpOHbI (HcnblTaTeAbHbie noju4rOHbl). TeopeTHiqeCKH, AecHas ripoMblwjiCHHOCTb He Mo)KeT

nOKa HCnOJb3OBaTb 3TH 3eMJiH.

HpH TOM, xITO HeKOTOPbIe CeJbCKOXO3sACTBeHHbie npeanpH$1TH51 3aHHMaKOTCA

TpaLHUHOHHbIM CeAbCKHM X035IACTBOM, HanpHMep, pa3BeaeHHeM KpynHoro poraToro CKOTa HAM

Aowa,aeg, TenHiH'IHbIM CaaOBOaCTBOM HAM BblpaU1LBaHBHeM ceJIbCKOXO3SIiCTBeHHbIX KyIbTyp,

MHOrHe pa6OTHHKH, Odmutia3bHO 3aperl'CTPHPOBaHHbie KaK "ceJTbCKOXO3,I icTBeHHbIe pa6o0tHe,,

Ha caMoM feAe ABJISlOTCq npO(3eCCHOHajlbHbIM4 OXOTHHKaMH, pbi6oAOBaMH H OAeHeBO,aaMM. 9TH

Page 285: Russian - World Bank Documents

281 fPPJIO)KEHKE XK

OXOTHHKH H pbi6oJIOBbl pa6OTalOT Ha rOCyaapCTBeHHbix npeanIHpHTH5X, KOTOpbiC 3aHHMa[OTCRnpOMbICJIOM aH4H H pbi6bl (rocnpoMxo3bl) H 3aqaCTyIO, oco6eHHo B ypO)KagHbie rogbi,HcnOJ1b3yKOT CBOHX pa6oTHHKoB Ha 3aFOTOBKe apyrHX HeapeBeCHblX pecypCoB. I4MeJOTCA TaK)KeHeKOTOpbie npeaCTaBHTenH KOpeHHbIX ManjOqHCjieHHbIX HapOaOB, KOTOpbIe 3a noci1eaHHe ro,gbiYuIJIH H3 KOOrepaTHBHbIX HuH aKIUHOHepHb1X ripeanpHATH49 H co3wami aCTHbie KJ1aHOBbie,ceMeIHbie HuH o6Lu1HHbie npegnpLH.UHTH. CyaeCTByIOT TaK)Ke KOjLijeKTHBHbie npearipH5ITHAI (TaKHa3blBaeMbiC KOorI3BepOHpOMX03bI), 3aHHM utOl1tHeCA pa3BezeHHeM nyWHbIX 3Bepeg, OXOTOU,pbi6ojiOBCTBOM, TpaHcHOPTHPOBKOI H pacnpeaejleHHeM TOBapOB nepBoi Heo6xoIIHMOCTH BceAbCKHX pagoHax, a TaicKe nepepa6oTKo4 H peanj]H3aLuHe HeapeBeCHO4 npOayKUiHH. KpoMeTOrO, HMmeOTCA pbi6oAOBeLUKHe KOAjieKTHBHbie npeaFHpHHTH4A HnH pb16o0OBeUKHe KOTIXO3bI.

3aBHCHMOCTb OT 6HoAorH4ecKux peCypcOB ieCOB

I4CHOub3OBaHHe 6HouIorwHecKHx pecypcoB nIeCOB HMeeT 6ojibwoe 3HaqeHHe ansRKOpeHHOrO HaCeJleHHA KaK HpIAMOi HCTO4HHK 3aHSTOCTH, Aeca cjiy)KaT HCTO4HHKOM apeBeCHHbI,aAns HpOH3BOLaCTBa CTpOHTeCbHbIX MaTepHanOB H TOnUIHBa, HCTOMHHKOM HeapeBeCHOUi rpOioyKUHHunai 6blTOBoro noTpe6AeHH5, HaTypaAbHoFO o6MeHa H ToproBJIH, a TaK)Ke KaK xo66H (oXoTa HpbI6oAoBCTBo). 9To o6uLecTBeHHo Ba)KHb[e MB5jeHHq. CTpOHTeJIbCTBO C H1CnOJIb3OBaHHiM,apeBecHHbl H noTpe6jTeHHe TonAHBHOi apeBecCHbl UAI OTormeHu4H H npHrOTOBJeHHA HiimtH HeTOJIbKO TpaaMU4HH KOpeHHbIX ManoJHcj1eHHbIX HapOaOB CeBepa H apyroro KOpeHHOrOHaCelleHH5I, HO H rIpaKTHKa, C FOTOBHOCTbIO BOCnpHHHATaA repeCeJieHuaMH, 6yab-TO CeJAbCKHe)KHTeu HAnu ropowKaHe, rpOKHBaioiuHe B aCpeBeHCKHX aOMax. $DerepaibHas cuyx6a .necHoroxO35lAcTBa, KaK ripaBHluO, cy6cHAHpyeT BeTepaHoB, HHBaiiH,!OB, KOpeHHoC HaceJIeH4e, a TaKwKepa6oTHHKoB AeCHOFO XO3A1HCTBa H npernpHHTHI4 AeCHOu npoMbILLUleHHOCTH, npeaAaraA HM6o0iee HH3KHe paCueHKH.

C6op qroa, opeXOB H rpuB60B ocyLueCTBji5eTCq OT4aCTH no 3KOHOMHqeCKHMcoo6paweHH4lM (oco6eHHo KOpeHHbIM HaceJTeHHeM, KOTOpOC 3aHHMaeTCA 3arOTOBKOUiTpa,2UHUHOHHbIX IPOaYKTOB nHTaHus), a OT'aCTH B peKpeaUHOHHbIX uenHX. Co6paHHbiri ypowKaknpaKTHmeCKH nOAHOCTbio noTpe6nMeTcs caMHMH c6opULHKaMH, Ha npoJaaKy HH'ero Him nO4THHHxerO He OCTaeTCq. C6op 3THX rpOaYKTOB ripOROJuKaeTCq H CCerOaHR npH nOAHOM

HFHOPMPOBaHHH Tpe6OBaHHR noAY4eHHI4 m4HUeH3HIi H co6AioaeHHI4 HopMaTHBOB. Pa6oTa noocyLUeCTBAeHI4O KOHTpOJIA 3a co6mnoaeHHeM 3THX HOpMaTHBOB npaKTH4qCKH He BeAeTCA.

OAHaKO B OTHOJeHUHHH OXOTbl H pbi6oIOBCTBa, KOTOpbIMH JIIOaH TaKKe 3aHHMiaOTC51 KaKJIAA Ro6blBaHI4 HHLUH4, TaK H B peKpeaUHOHHbIx ueCiix, C4TyaLt4A 4Haq. 3TH BH4,Ibl 3aH5THICTPOrO peryTIHpyIOTCI rnIaBHbIM o6pa3OM, B CBAI3H C TeM, UITO OHH nPHHOCAT aOXOabI. B6oJbWl4UHcTBe rOcyaapCTBeHHbIX rpeanpH5ITHu TOJIbKO 40-50% BCCX OXOTHHKOB H pb[6oJIoBoBpa6OTaloT Ha nOJIHyIO CTaBKy. OCTaAbHylO 'aCTb yJIOBa o6ecrieqHBaloT TaK Ha3blBaeMbieOXOTHHKH-jiIo6HTejuH, aAS KOTOpbIX HX "xo66Hu 5IBAeTCS OaHOBpeMeHHO H Ba)KHbIMHCTOqHHKOM AOXO,OB. Bo MHOFHX ciyiaqx 3TH OXOTHHKH HanpqMYIO KOHKYpHpyIOT Crpe,cTaBHTensAMH MaAo'iHcIeHHbIx HapOaOB CeBepa H apyrHX KOpeHHbIX HapOaOB. HH OUHpbi6oJIOB 3TOrO permoHa He MO)KeT 6bITb Ha3BaH "Jo64TejieM" B UIHCTOM BH,Le, nOCKO.IbKy pbl6a5BjiSeTC51 Ba)KHbIM ce3OHHbIM HpODayKTOM HpaKTHmeCKH ,DIA Bcero HaceCeHHHS 3THX pa4OHOB.MHorHe XlTeiH cenJbCKHX pbi6OJIoBeUKHX noceJIKOB, He gBnmoLuHecm npOq)eccHOHaAbHbIMHpbi6oJIOBaMH, HO HeCKOJIbKO Heaejib B rO,ay npOBOflHT 3a joOBAeu pbi6bi, 4To6bl npOKOpMHTb CBOHceMbH B Te.eHHe OCTaBweicA 'aCTH roaa.

Page 286: Russian - World Bank Documents

282 rPKJIOKEHtE 4EK

Bn4sHHHe COBpeMeHHWX 3KOHOMHqeCKHX npoiLeCCOB K nOJIHTHKH

B 1989 r. B pe3ynbTaTe coumoJIorFMeCKoro o6cneaoBaHH4I aBaDSaTti nTti nocenKoB, rige

pacnoJIoKeHbl 102 J1eCOXo3AucTBeHHbIx H JeCO3aIOTOBHTenbHblx npegnpliATHf c o6Lueg

4HcJIeHHOCTbIo pa6o'ieu cnJIbi 6.500 'ejioBeK, 6bulo ycTaHoBJIeHO, ITO 42% Bcero 3aHIToro

HaceIieHHSl pa6oTaeT B IeCHOh npOMbbIwiJeHHOCTH Ha TIecO3arOTOBHTeJTbHbIx, TpaHCnOPTHbIX H

faepeBonepepa6aTblBaloWux npeaipHusTHsix; 21% - TiecHHKH; Ha aoiio crieL1HanHCTOB no JieCHOMY

X03HI4CTBy H aAMHHHCTpaTHBHbIX COTpy,4HHKOB .eCO3arOTOBHTeJbHbIX npe,nrpH5ITHru

np4XOIWH1OCb no 12%; 4,5% - 3TO aLipeKTOpa H pyKOBOal4Teji4, HMeCOLLU1e CneUtHJlbHOe

o6pa3oBaHHe; 3 npouLeHTa - 3TO pa6OTHHKH .CeCHoro X0351iCTBa (Pe3yJIbTaTbl, 1990).

lionee CBe)KH4e aaHHb[e (1994 r.) HIOKa3blBalOT, ITO B Xa6apoBcKoM Kpae H3 598 TbICqq

pa6oTaioLuHx 5,5% pa6oTaeT B neCHOA npOMblwJIeHHOCTH, a 0,7% - B .ieCHOM XO35IACTBe. BKpacHOsipcKoM Kpae, BKnloqaR 3BeHKHlO U TauMbIp, H3 1,46 MnH. pa6OTaiomHx 5,8% 3aHqTbI B

JIecHOH npOMbbiwJIeHHOCTH (necO3arOTOBKH, RepeBoo6pa6OTKa, LueJIjiooJI3HO-6yMa)KHbIe

KoM6HHaTbl), a 0,5% - B JIeCHOM XO3AICTBe. C 1993 no 1994 rr. YPOBeHb 3aHqTOCTH B AeCHoR

npoMbiwjieHHOCTH coKpaTHJIC5 Ha 19.4% (3a TOT )Ke riepHOR 3aHATOCTb B MaWUIHOCTpoeHCH

coKpaT4jiaCb Ha 13,8 npOueHTOB, a B qneKTPO3HepreTHKe BO3pocJia Ha 3%).

3Ha'iHTeCnbHO COKpaTnJIOCb lHCnO pa6OTaioLuHx Ha JIeCO3arOTOBHTenJbHbIX npe,HnpHRTHIqX

KpacHoslpcKoro KpaAI. OalHHagLIaTb 13 COpOKa Tpex nperHpHASTHI He B COCTOSHHH nHIaTHTb

3apnjiaTy CBOHM pa6OTHHKaM. JTeCHHKH 4aBHO OTHOCATCS rpyrine pa6oTHHKoB C caMbIM HH3KHM

YPOBHeM onJiaTbI. B Haiarie 1995 r. HX 3apnnaTa COCTaBJI5iJa OKOJIO 90 TbIC.M py6neu B Mec .

Ha TOT )Ke nepHoa cpeaHeMecAl'Haq 3apa6oTHaq ninaTa B CeJlbCKOM X035lfiCTBe COCTaB^jiila 180TbIC5l4 py 6 ., a B npOMb[luJICHHOCTH - 231 TbICqqy py6.

14HHopMaUHH 0 3aHATOCTH H ,aoxo,tax B Tpa,fHLWUOHHOM CeKTOpe 3KOHOMUKC OqeHb Mario.

B 1993 r. B Xa6apoBcKoM Kpae 4,3% 3aH5ITorO HaceJieHHi pa6OTarlH B cenJbCKOM xO354cTBe, a

0,1% 3aHHMaJiHCb pbI6oJIOBCTBOM. HTO KacaeTcq ManTo'-iciieHHb[X HapOaOB CeBepa (141 TbICqIa

qeJIOBeK), TO H3 HHX 47% 6bul1 3aHqTbl B CCJIbCKOM X035UCTBe H Tpaag4UHHOHHbIX ceKTopax

(COKOJIOBa, 1994), a npiMepHo 25-30% Tpyaocnoco6HOro HacenieHHS 6buiH 6e3pa6oTHbIMH H

)KHJN 3a c'eT pbi6oJIOBCTBa, OXOTbI, c6opa npOayKTOB lHTaHl4R H oJleHeBOaCTBa. B TOM )e

HcCiie,aOBaHHH yTBepKLaeTcq, ITO OKOJIO 15% HaCeJieHHq Boo6ule He XOTIT pa6oTaTb (KjiOKOB H

KoploxHHa, 1994).

B KpacHOspcKoM Kpae (BKnloxiaq 3BeHKI4O H TajMbIp) noroJIOBbe ojleHef Ha

rocy,aapCTBeHHbIX npeanpHSATHAX COKpaT4JIOCb C 121 TbICqlH B 1981 r. ao 78 TbICII B 1993 r.(noronoBbe oJIeHeI, Haxori5lUtHXCq B IaCTHOM BJiaaeH4H, B03pOCJIO C 17 TbICq- B 1981 r. Ro 26TbIC.Mq B 1994 r.). ao6b'lMa pbi6bi COKpaT4jiaCb c 5.400 T B 1980 F. ao 3.300 T B 1993 r. ao6bi'anyLUHoro co6onsi B 1993 1. COCTaEJ5Ia Bcero IUWb 15 npOUeHTOB OT YpOBHA ao6bi-lH 1985 r. (noAaHHbIM 0 3aKynKax y OXOTHHKOB) (Hapo4Hoe X03MIiCTBo KpaCHOHpCKOrO KpaM, 1994).

HP['4HHa TaKoro COKpaiUeHHA BnOJIHe nOH5THa. Pe3Koe nOBbiHeHHCe UeH Ha TOHJI4BO H

na,eHHe MeCTHOrO cnpoca Ha MflCO H pbl6y, BcjieACTBHe 3Ha'IHTenbHOFO oTToKa HacenieHH5i H3

3THX paUOHOB, yCyry6HAH He3X1eKTHBHOCTb MHOFHX Tpaa4HUHOHHbIX npOMbiCJIOB, KOTOpbie

paHbiue aep)Ka]HCb Ha 6oJ]bWHX aOTaUHAX. B pe3yJIbTaTe Te, KTO 6b13] 3aHAT B TpaAH4uHOHHOM

ceicrope 3KOHOMUKH, Bce 6OJIbLue nepeKJiio'alOTCq Ha OXOTy, pbI6ojIoBcTBO H oj1eHeBOaCTBO AJI

yAoBneTBOpeHHA co6cTBeHHb[x HyAK . TaKHM ceMbqM Bce TpyaHee 3apa6OTaTb cpeaCTBa ARl

npHo6peTeH4H Heo6xoAiHMbIX TOBapOB. FjiaBHbIMH HJiony'aTeiHMH aOXOaOB BO MHorHx ceMbqx

Page 287: Russian - World Bank Documents

283 nPJIO)KEHIE K

SIBJISIOTCA reHCHOHepbI HJIH eTH, HMejoLHX ripaBO Ha LeTCKHe noco6Hs HJTH tiJeHbl ceMbH,KOTOpbie pa6oTaloT B rOCenjKOBbiX aaMHHHCTpaUHAX, llKoJIax HniH 6onbHHIuax.

B 1991 r. B 3BeHKHH 6bUIo 4BeHaauaTb COBXO3OB, npi4eM uleCTb H3 HIUXcneHLUaJIH3HPOBaJHCb Ha OJeHeBO2CTBe H OXOTe, a eleCTb ApyrHx - Ha pa3BeAeHHH nYWJHbIX3Beperl. Bce ABeHaauaTb HpearipHHTHU 6buliH 3KOHOMHqecKH He341eKTHBHbI H cyLLteCTBOBa)1H 3acl-eT rocyLapCTBeHHbIX aoTaULHi. TonbKo OJIOB4Ha H3 803 pa6oTHIUKOB 3TUIX COBX030B, KOTopbIenTpOdeCCHOHaJIbHO 3aHHMaJIHCb OXOTOU H pbI6oAOBCTBOM, 6bmH npeaCTaBHTJeISAMHMajIoqHcAeHHbIX Hapo01oB CeBepa. B 1992 r. TaKylo aeATeJIbHocTb BenfH IinTHaaLLaTb COBX030B HTpH KoJIJTeKTHBHbIX rpeeApnPHTHA. qHCJO npo4beccHOHanbHbIX OXOTHHKOB H pbi6ojloBoB,pa6oTalolurx Ha 3THX npearipH5THqx, COKpaTHJOCb Lo 230, npH'eM 78% H3 HHX 6burHnpeACTaBHTeJI5IMH KOpeHHOrO HaceIieHHS5.

B 1992 r. Ha TarMbipe 6bulo BoceMHaIuaTb COBXO3OB, OAHHO rocyaPCTBeHHoenpe,lnpHATHe, 3aHHMaIioieeCq OXOToiw H pbI6oJIOBCTBOM, H OLHO KoAjieKTHBHoe npeanpWiTHe,KOTOpoe 3aHHMaJIOCb pa3BeAeHHeM lUyWHbIX 3Beperl, OXOTOIH H pbi6oniOBCTBOM. Ha 3THXnpeHanpHATHAIX pa6oTano 995 npo(eccHoHanjbHbIX OXOTHHKOB H pbi6oJIOBOB. B TpaaHUHoHHOMceKcrope 6bulo 3aH5TO OKOAo 430 KoMeBbIX ceMeri (B Haqa.ne 1980-x roaOB HX 6bbUo 670) H 18ceMell KopeHHbIX HapOaOB, KoTOpbIe TaioKe BXOHIHAH B COBXO3bI. C Hat{ana 1970-x rr. 1o KOHL1a1980-x rr. cpeAHeroRoBoe npOH3BOACTBO MAca oloMaIUHeHHbIX oJleHeH COKpaTHJIOCb Ha 27rpOUeHTOB, ao6bi4a pbl6bI ocTaBanIacb Ha AOCTaTO'-HO CTa6HJtbHOM ypOBHe, a OXOTa Ha nyWUHblX3BepeA CTaJia B 6yKBanbHoM cMblcnIe HepeHTa6eAbHOri (FyneBcKui H CM4meHKO, 1994).

B Xa6apOBCKOM Kpae o6u.as nHAoula,b OXOTHHMbHX yrOAHH, BKJlIoaSq Te, KOTOpbIMHHOJIb3OBaJIOCb KOpeHHoe HaceJIeHHe, COBXO3bI H OXOTHHKH-JliO6HTeAH, COKpaTH4aaCb c 7,9 MAH. raB 1990 r. ao 60,1 MJIH. ra B 1993 r. (COCTOSiHHe oKpy)KaiowueH cpeLbI, 1994). B Kpae 6bu0o aBaCOBXO3a H O,1HH KOJIXO3, nfTb KOAjieKTHBHbIX pbi6oJIOBeLtKHX npe'tnpHRTHri, OaHOrocy1apCTBeHHoe OXOTHHUbe H pbi6oJIOBeLXKoe HpeLnplpHTHe H OAHO KOJUieKTHBHoenpearIpH5THe, rae pa3BOAKAHA nyWHbIX 3Beperi (FyjieBCKHul H CHMmeHKO, 1994). B nepHoa c 1970no 1988 rr. cpeIHeroloBoe npoH3BoaCTBO ojieHbero MAca OCTaBanJOCb oTHoCHTenbHOCTa6HAbHbIM, OXOTa Ha HyIJHbIX 3BepeH 6buma ro-npe)KHeMy peHTa6eJibHOr4, a ao6bria pbi6blB03pocnIa Ha 500 rpoLIeHTOB.

Ha KOHeL 1994 r. od)HUHaj1bHblg YPOBeHb 6e3pa6oTHIUbI cpeal KOpeHHorO HaceiieHHqXa6apoBcKoro KpaA cocTaBJIAJI 11%, HO B aeriCTBHTenbHoCTH OH 6bmI HaMHorO BbIlwe.flOCKOJbKy MHorHe pa6OTHHKH nepecTaiiH noJIyqaTb 3apniiaTy Ha CBOUX npeAnpH4ITHqX,KOTOpbie yKe He 4byHKUIHOH1pOBaJH, HO He 6bIJIH O(bHuHaJbHO 3aKpblTbI, claKTHUeCKHg YpOBeHb6e3pa6OTH4Lbl HpH6JIH3uHJICs K 30%. 3BeHbl H 3BeHKH, pa6OTaBwHe OJileHeBOaaMH B COBX03aXCeBepa, He nOJiyqaflH HHKaKHX aOXOROOB. KpaeBOii aenlapTameHT 3THK4eCKOri nOIHTHKHBbil,aBaJI HM 6ecnIJlaTHylO MyKy H apyrHe OCHOBHbie rpOipyKTbE nHTaHHR. AHaJIOrH4Ha.I KaPTHHaCKAatabIBaeTCsl H3 coo6weHHH npeaCTaBHTejieA opraHOB BjiaCTH 3BeHKHH.

K apyrFHM rIpO6neMaM (HeKOTOpble H3 HHX cyLueCTBOBaJIH eiue npu COBeTCKof BnacTH)OTHOCSTCA:

Hf17oxHe x)KUIHJHbic yC:iOBH5, B ppv we KOTOpblX 1710,fH lOKHaalOT IecHmbe)7oceCJKH. B 1989 r. 18% HaceneHHI5, 3aHRTOrO B JIeCHOM XO3SHiCTBe H HajiecO3arOTOBKaX, rPOXHBanIH B nieCHbIX noceAKax. B CpeaLHeM, B KaX(OM H3 TaKHXnocejiKOB npO)KHBajio 470 qejioBeK, 37% KOTOpblX pa6OTaTiH B JieCHOM ceKTope(Pe3yAbTaTbl, 1990). Korna MHorHie IeCO3aroTOBHTenJbHbie npernpHATHA

Page 288: Russian - World Bank Documents

284 UPHAJO)KEHME X

OCTaHOBHJIHCb, 3HaMHTenJbHaq 'aCTb HaCeJieHHS 6bula BbIHY)yxLeHa nepeexaTb B RpyrHe

mecTa, a o6beKrbT COuLaAbHOU 4H43paCTpyKTypbi (WKKOJIbI, Mara3HHbl, 6o0nbHIubl,

o6LueCTBeHHbli TpaHCnOPT ii Doporu) npHLuAH B HerOaHOCTb.

* HH3Kaq 3apa6oTHav flaTa. 3apa6oTHaq niiaTa Ha ripeanpu4H5TH5x jTeCHOFO X03SH'CTBa

Bcer,aa 6blna HH3KOg, a coLu4ojiorHMeCKHe 4ccjieaOBaHH.9 1989 roaa noKa3aJlH, YTOTOJIbKO 11% pa6OTHHKOB 3TOU1 OTpacJii 6bmui yaoBjieTBOpeHbl CBOHMH aoXoaaaMH. B

1988 r. cpelLHeMecqMHasq 3apa6oTHas nniaTa B CCCP cOCTaBn5iia oKoJIo 200 py6ner, HO

npH 3TOM 3apa6OTHaA niiaTa B JeCHOM ceKTope cocTaBTi5ia OT 116 go 170 py6neu

(BepxHHiri npeRen 3Toro aHana3oHa npeaHa3Ha'auics 4nA cneuQaHjiiCTOB npegnpHsTHir

AeCHOrO X03AACTBa H AeCO3aroToBHTeJbHor4 npOMbIwIeHHOCTH, HMeBWUHX

CneUHaJbHOe o6pa3oBaHHe). 9TH JI1OR[4 4aCTO 3aHi4MalOTCq TqxKeAbiM,

MaAOKBaJAHd)HUHpOBaHHbIM pyIHbIM TpyIOM, o6opyA0BaHHe BO MHOFOM He OTBe4aeT

HeO6XO,aHMbIM Tpe6OBaHH.9M, 'TO OCIO)KH$eT YCAJOBHS pa60Tbl. OKOnO 14% pa6o'wx H

iieCHHKOB H 15% cneuHaniHCTOB xoTenuH 6bl CMeHHTb CBOIO pa6oTy; TOJlbKO 15

npOLteHTOB XOTST, To6bi X HxeTH HMenH TaKylo we pa6oTy (Pe3yAbTaTbl, 1990).

* Heo6xo&aMocTb HMenTb 1o60oHbwe HCTOYHHKH N oxo,aa - rJfaBHbiM o6pa3oM, 3a cYeT

BeaeHHX JoIco6HorO xo3H,cTBa, a TaxKe 3aHJITHi OXOTON, pbJ6OJIoBCTBOM H c6opoM

2HK0PaCTY1LaX UIOaOB, BJqr0a, JpH60B H apyNHX flp pOaYKTOB ZHHTaHJqI. B pe3ynbTaTe

3TorO yMeHbwllaeTCR npOH3BOAHTeJbHOCTb Tpyaa H naaaeT FIpOaYKTHBHOCTb Ha

OCHOBHOM MeCTe pa6oTbI. COriiaCHO HpOBeaeHHbIM COUHOJIor'HeCKHM HCCJeaOBaHHUqM,

O43HLlHaj1bHaA 3apriJiaTa COCTaBJ15eT Bcero JIHIUb 41% OT o6Luero o6feMa AOXOaOB

noJyM,aeMbIx ceMbSMH, a OCTanbHoe aalOT noaco6Hoe XO3.qACTBO, neHCH5 HJIH apyrHe

BbIHJnaTbl iJIeHaM CeMbH. Pa6OTHHKH necHoro ceicopa no ABa-TpH qaca B ,aeHb

npOBOlL5lT Ha CBOHX HpHyCaae6HblX yqaCTKax. (Pe3yJIbTaTbI, 1990).

* Ihioxaz opraHH3aLHff ToproB.H, HoCTaBoK uoTpe6HTe]TbcKHx TOBapOB, Me,aHUHHCKOFO

06CffyXHBaHHJI H peKpeaCaHOHHOH IaeqTefIbHOcTH. TpHaijaTb O,L4H npOLIeHTpa6oTHHKOB AeCHOrO X0351iCTBa H J1eCO3arOTOBHTeAJbHbIX HipenpHRsTHAi )KHBeT B

nOCenKaX C HaCeAeHHeM MeHee 500 qej1OBeK, 34% - B noceJIKax C HaceJieHHeM OT 500

,ao 1000 'enoBeK, a 5% )KHBeT Ha OTaaJieHHbIX xyTOpax. TpeTb 3THX pa6OTHHKOB

C'qHTalOT caMou cepbe3HOH npo6.neMog n.noxoe CHa6)eH4e.

CeWqac npOHCXOAHT MHrpaULH HaCeJieHH41 H3 CeBepHbIX B IOXHble paU1OHbI CH6HpH H

,JajIbHero BocToKa HuH o6paTHO B EBpor1eUcKyiO iaCTb 6blBulero CCCP. BOJIbUHHCTBO

MIrpaHTOB - 3TO npeaCTaBHTeAH 6blBWHX nepeCeJieHLeB. TOJAbKO B 1994 r. H3 CeBepHblX

patiOHOB KpacHOApcKorO Kpaq yexano oKoAo 10 TbICqq qejioBeK, npUipHeM OJ1OBuHa H3 HHX

yexajia H3 cejlbcKOg MeCTHOCTH. Bo MHOrtX Cny'yaHx MHrPHPOBanjO Bce 3aHqToe HaceAeHHe,

pa6oTaBuIee Ha eaHHCTBeHHOM B oKpyre npeanIpH51THH. no OueHKaM 3KCnepTOB, CO BpeMeHeM U3

CeBepHb1X par4OHOB aanbHero BocToKa yereT nO[TH TpeTb HbIHeWJHerO HaceJieHHI.q

XOT5 TaKaq MHrpaUH5 BO3MO)KHo 6yaeT HMeTb H OnpeaeJIeHHOe nOJOo)KHTeCJbHOe

B03,aeRCTBHe, HO 3TOT npouecc 6yaeT HMeTb H MHo)KeCTBO OTpHUaTeCJbHbIX riocJleaCTBH4g, npexcae

Bcero, Am1 MaBJo'iHcJieHHbIX HapOANB CeBepa H apyrHx KopeHHbIX HapoaoB. K HHM OTHOCqTC51

coKpawUeHHe HJIH nHKBHUaauH5 BO3AYUHOrO H BO,HOrO TpaHCnOpTHOrO coo6uReHH41 C

patOHHbIMH HuH perHOHaBbHbIMH LteHTpaMH, o6ecne'iHBaioluero perynsipHyIo OCTaBKy TOBapOB

B MeCTHbIe Mara3HHbl; naAeHHe cnpoca Ha MqCO, pbl6y H nIyWUHHHy; nOTep51

KBaIiHq3HUHPOBaHHbIX npenO1AaBaTenbCKHX, MeaHULHHCKHX H apyrHX nPO4eCCHOHaj1bHb1X KaapOB;

JajibHeAhwee coKpaiLteHHe 3aHqTOCTH.

Page 289: Russian - World Bank Documents

285 nPJIO)4KEHHE X)

Bb,veAeHHe 3eMejibHbIX yr)OAHrfliA TpaAH1IHOHHoro 3eMAenoAb3oBaHHq 2

B npoeKTe (beaepanbHOro 3aKOHa o npaBOBOM cTaTyce KOpeHHbIX (Maoq4HcjieHHbIx)HapO,aOB pOCCHH4CKOro CeBepa npeAycMoTpeHo cneayiolUee:

* Co3,aaHHe qOHAOB pa3BHTHI KOpeHHbIX HapOaOB Ha 4)eCepaJibHOM, o6JiaCTHOM(KpaeBOM Hi4H pecny6JIHKaHCKOM) H paHOHHOM ypOBH5IX.

* npeaocTaBseHHe HerpaBHTeAbCTBeHHbIM opraHH3aUHqM KOpeHHbIX HapO1OB npaBaCo31aaHH4 CO6CTBeHHbIX cbOHaOB.

. OnpeaejieHHe rpaHHIU TePPHTOPHH, npefHa3HaqeHHbIX HCKJHOqHTeTIbHO AAATpaAH4UHOHHOrO HCHOJIb3OBaHH41 flpHpOLHbIX peCypCOB KOpeHHbIMH HapOAaMH,HCnOJIb3OBaHHe KOTOpbIX B AJO6blX HeTpaAHU40HHbIX uenrqx (B TOM IHcJie ani5JIeCO3arOTOBOK) Tpe6yIoT cornacHiq 60obInHHCTBa MeCTHOrO KOpeHHOrO HaceJ]eHH4.

* OnpeaefleHHe TpaaHUHOHHbIX 3aHqTHg H ipeAocTaBieHHe rapaHTHpOBaHHbIX rpaB KaKKOpCHHOMY HaceJieHHIO, TaK H HeKOpeHHOMY HaceIieHHIO, BeayiLeMy Tpaa4HUHOHHblrHo6pa3 )KH3HH, B nniaHe o6ecneqeHHR ce6.q CpeRCTBaMH K cyL1eCTBOBaHH10.

. BbUIaqa pa3pelJIeHIH AnJ HeTpafHUHOHHOrO HCnOJTb3OBaHHA 3eMeJIb,rpeTHa3Ha4eHHb[X AIS "TpaAHLIHOHHOrO 3aCeJieHH51 H TpaHI4HUHOHHOA 3KOHOMi4qeCKOH)ae,qTeJIbHOCTH", TOJlbKO C cormacms MeCTHOrO KOpeHHOrO HaceJIeHHqI C BbInAaTOHKOMneHCaURHH 3a JiO6oH npHqiHHeHHbIr4 3KOHOMH4eCKHA ywep6 H llpH Tpe6OBaHHH3KOAOrH'eCKH c6aAaHcHpoBaHHoro HCnOJIb3OBaHHA nmo6bix 6HoAori4eCKHX peCypCOB,no,aBepralowHxcH 3KcnJIyaTaUHH.

JaBa apyrHx 4eaepa.nbHbIX aOKyMCHTa o6paiueHbi K npo6JieMe 3eMeflbHb[X npaB KOpeHHbIXHapO1aOB. B COBMeCTHOM HOCTaHoBJIeHHH HpaBHTeJIbCTBa rOBOpHTCq o HIp4OHTeTHOMpa3BHTHH TpaaHUHOHHbIX 3aHATHH", "HCKKIO'oHTeflbHbIX npaBax Ha HCnOnb3OBaHHe6HonorHqeCKHX peCYpCOB B pa4OHax, 3aceJIeHHbix rpe myLeCTBeHHO 3THMH HapOaaMH", HBbL,aejieHH1 "Tepp4TopHHA ,LIJI Tpa4LtHLHOHHoro HcnOAb3OBaHHtiP nPHpOAHb[X pecypcoB KopeHHbIMHaCenIeHHeM". Oal4H H3 nocICeaH4X YKa3oB npe3HaeHTa Tpe6yeT, 'TO6bi o6AaCTHbleaAMKHHCTpaLuUH COTpyRHHqaj1H C aCCOUHaUHAMH KOpeHHbIX HapOROB (HrO) npH onpeaeJIeH44rpaHHLL Tepp4TOpHrH, npeaHa3HaqeHHbIX qJ1S Tpa4LXUUHOHHOrO HCnOJ1b3OBaHH5 npHpOLaHbIXpecypCOB.

B KpaCHOApCKOM Kpae aHajiorHqHoe 3aKOHoaaTeJTbCTBO O4bHUHaAbHO He npHHl4TO, HOeCTb rpOeKT 3aKOHa, OnpeaelAiOLLHi4 TpaaHUHOHHbie 3aHATHS1 H o6'b$1BAiqOoLuHH O BbilejieHHHTeppHTOpHH TOnbKO ]A5 "KOpeHHbIx 3THH4eCKHx rpyrin", KOTOpbIe He moryT 6bITbHCnOJIb3OBaHbl AAn OCyLeCTBjieHHA rIpOMblwIeHHOH eAHTeJAbHOCTH 6e3 corAaCHA 6oAbWumHcTBaMeCTHOrO HaCeIieHHS4. BpeMeHHoe 3aKOHOaaTeCJbCTBO TypyxaHcKoro H EHHceHCKOrO paHOHOBnPH3HaeT cyLueCTBOBaHHe iuecTHauaLaTH POAOBbIX o6lUHH H BbiaejieT HM Ha HeOrpaHH4eHHbl4CPOK OKOJIo 6 MJIH. reKTapoB (oKoAo 20% Bcerl nHJOLUWal 3THX paHOHOB) B KaqeCTBe o6UiHHHOr43eMAH. 9TH o6LUHbl HMelOT npaBo yTBep)KaTb HJI He yTBepaTb ocyUeCTBJeHHe Ha 3THX3eMAiX neCO3arOTOBHTeAbHOr4, rOpHOao6blBaiOtueH H CTpOHTeJIbHOrH aeATeJ]bHOCTH H44reOjiOrHI'eCKHX H3blCKaHHr, HO OHH He MmelOT npaBa roAy4aTb KOMneHcaUHIo 3a TaKY1OIaeATeflbHOCTb.

2 176opo6Hbilk aHafmH3 aocimaHHx co6biTuiI MOKHO HarT-H B pa6ore: .IMCKoB (1996).

Page 290: Russian - World Bank Documents

286 HPJIO)KEHHE AC

lpoeKT 3BeHKHUCKOrO 3aKoHa 0 3eMjie onpeaeJsAeT "TeppHTOpHH TpaAUHUHOHHOrO

HCrIOAb30BaHHSI flpHpOAHbIX peCypCOB MaJOMHCJIeHHbIMH HapoQaMH". CeS4ac

nepecmaipHmomi 3aKOHbl, peryJH¶pyIoIuHe OXOTOyCTpOtkCTBO H OXOTy, TeppHTOpHH

TpaAHUHOHHOrO KCrIOJIb3OBaHHH npHpOAHbIX peCYPCOB H XH3Hb pOAOBblX o6LUHH. B 3BeHKuHBO3HHKJIO MHo)KeCTBO pOlOBbIX o6LUHH, npHqeM B COCTaB 6o.nbiuHHCTBa H3 HHX BXOAHT OT nITH

AO flnTHaauaTH pa6oTalowux IjieHOB. PoccHAcKHe CTaPO)KHAbI H U KYTCKHe o6ILtHHbl MOryT

co3aaBaTb KoonepaTHBbI HAH 'aCTHbie XO3s91CTBa, HO npeAnoqTeHHe npH pacnpeaeneHHt 3eMeJb

oT1aaeTCA 3BeHKaM H KeTaM.

B KOHLue 1992 r. Pecny6nHKa 5IKyTHS np4Hpsna 3aKOH, pa3peiualoLuLHi MaJIo'HcJeHHbIM

HapO,aaM CeBepa H apyrHM KOpeHHbTM 3THH4eCKHM rpynnaM, BeayUwHM TpaaUHLHOHHbli 06pa3

)KH3HH, co3zaBaTb POXOBbIe 06oUHHbI. 3TOT 3aKOH TaKXCe rnacHT, MITO 3eMjIR, Bo3O6HOBMIeMbIe

npHPOaHbie pecypcbl, ceJbcKOXO35flkcTBeHHbie, OXOTHHUbH H pbi6ofoBeUKHe yrOabS, a TaioKe

neca H BHyTpeHHHe BOabI 6yayT 6ecnnaTHo nepeLaHbl B noIb3OBaHMe 3THM o6U1HHaM "Ha

HeorpaHHxeHHbli CpOK", H ITO 6e3 pa3peweHUH o6lUMHbl 3Ta 3eMfI He MoxeT 6blTb

Hcnonb3OBaHa B npoMbIuweHHblX HuH KaKHx-JiH6o ApyriHx uen5lx. KpoMe TOrO, 3TOT 3aKOH

npeJycMaTpHBaeT onpeAeAeHHe rpaHHU 3eMenb, KOTOpbIe OTBOASTCA AAA co3AaHHS HOBbIX

o6U14H KOpeHHbIX HapOAOB B KaKLAOM patiOHe, HaceneHHe KOTOpOrO BeAeT TpaLIHuHOHHbIiR 06pa3

XKH3HH. no TariMbipy HAH XaKaCHH TaKOri 4HH4OpMaUHH HeT.3

CHryaiwHA B Xa6apoBcKoM Kpae

B HOpMaTHBHb1X aKTax, HpHHSITbIX HCnOJHHTeJbHbIM KOMHTeTOM KpaeBoro COBeTa B 1991

r., onpe,ejleHbi TpaAHUHOHHbie 3MHATKA H TeppHTOpMH, npeAHa3Ha.eHHbie AAS TpaHLHHOHHOrO

HcnoJb3oBaHHS, BKJio'laSq oJeHbH nacT6Hwa, OXOTHHMbH H pbi6ojioBeUKHe yroabs, paflOHbl

c6opa Arog H KeJpOBbIX OpeXOB, neca, HepeCTOBbie 03epa, peKH H MOPCKHe 3aJIHBbI, a TaiOKeMeCTa OTnpaBJeHHU T8paAHUHOHHbIX peJiirHHO3HbIX 06 p5RoB. 9 TH TeppHTOPHH nepeaaioTCs Ha

HeOrpaHMqeHHbl4 CPOK KOpeHHbIM 3THUiMeCKKM rpynnlaM, KOTOpbIe nIpeACTaBJleHbI parOHHblMH

HAM noceAKOBbIMH acco[uHaUHAMM. Ha 3THX 3eMJIqX He pa3pewaeTCs pa3BMTHe

npoMbIlwJeHHOCTH, a neca nepeBoJ,TcSI B nepByio rpynny, AAA KOTOpOU B aAabHeriweM3anpeluaeTcs. CnAOuHa5R Bbipy6Ka. ,LapyrHe CTaTbH pa3peinaloT npoMbICJOBYlO OXOTY H

ripoMbIcjnoBoe pbI6oJoBcTBo HeKopeHHbIM HapoaaM, ecnH Ha 3TO coriaCHO KOpeHHOe HaCefeHHe,

c6op HelpeBeCHOIi JeCHOtU npO,YKUHH H pbi6oJOBCTBO AnA JlHIIHbIX HY)KA 6e3 KaKog-AH6o

KoMneHcauMH MaAoIMcJIeHHbIM HapoAaM CeBepa, a TaioKe py6Ky aepeBbeB AAs 6blTOBbIX HyXKL

MaJIo4HcJeHHbIX HaPO,4OB CeBepa MniH MX npeAnpH5qTHr nOA KOHTpoJ1eM cJIyI6bi niecHoro

XO3qrfCTBa.

B HacToqwee BpeMA cyuJeCTByeT ABa BHAa 3eMenlbHbIX pecypcoB, BbieleneHHbIX

MaJlO'MUCHeHHbIM Haponam CeBepa, a HMeHHO TePPHTOPHH Tpal4MUHOHHOFO HcnoJb3oBaHHSI H

o6LUHHHbIe 3eMJiH. TePPHTOPHM Tpa,fHUHOHHOrO HCnOJb3OBaHH51 npe2sHa3Ha'eHbl AnA TaKHX

TpaUHUHOHHbIX 3aHATHII, KaK OXOTa, pbi6oJIOBCTBO H ojieHeBOACTBO. MaJOqHcjieHHbIe HapOabi

CeBepa HMelOT npHOPHTeT npH Bbi6ope onpeneJieHHblX yqaCTKOB 3TUX TeppHTOpU4i B KaMeCTBe

o6wKUHHbIX 3eMeJb, KOTOpbIe nepenaIOTCs B MX HCKJIIOMHTeAJbHOe InOJb3oBaHHe. 06LUMHHaS

3 CormacHo locCJIcaHHM coo6uteHMm, Ha aeKa6pb 1995 r. B PeCCy6&HKC Caxa (7KyTHqs) 6bmAf c03AaHbH 195

pO,AOBiX 06o6HH, YrO 6Oflwue 'eM BaBOe pCBbMLUaCT YpOBCHb KOHUM 1993 roaa. QwHaKo q5mHaHCmpOBaHMR 4,72

t1o0wepxKK 3Tmx o6LumH BMawcHO He 6uwo, 11 MHOrCe H3 H11X HaYaJ1M 06oftaamHmbCg, YTO6bi BKxllrb. C ye7TOM

MoM, YTO OHM HaXOJaflTCJ7 Ha 3Th11C 3KCI7CpHMCHTHPOBaHRJ7 HAM cTaHOammHM, '1C7mHHoCTJ MX HBCCJ1CHHR MOJKCT

COKXPTMTbCh1 (HAM B03paCTH) B 3aBHCMMOCTM OT HawcM'uJI rOCyaapCTBcHHO# f7oucpxKf, YaCTHbJX MHBeCTTHUIM1 H

Z1pyrIHX yaKTOpOB (FeRW OuiepeHKo, IHCTHTYT apKTM'CCKHX HcCneCoBaHH4J 4'apTMyTCKMf, KOAMaX, -IHVHOe

coo6LUeHmc 23 MaR 1996 r.).

Page 291: Russian - World Bank Documents

287 nPUAO)KEHME )K

3eMJISI nepegaeTcs rocyaapcTBOM B apeHAy KOHKpeTHOMY pO1y, ceMbe nHu o6urnHe Hnpe,aHa3HaqeHa, rInaBHbIM o6pa3oM, =AS BegeHKA XO3RHCTBeHHOA aeSTeAbHocTH. TaKor poa4aKTMceCK4 aeACTByeT KaK KOonepaTHBHoe npeCnplHHTHe, a npaBo Ha 3Ty o6LUL4HHyIO 3eMAionoAyqalOT TOJlbKO "pa6oTaloLuHe -jieHbi" (T.e. Te, KTO 3aHHMaeTC5I Ha 3TOUl 3eMJieTpa,aHLLHOHHbIM4 BHaaMH aeSITeAbHOCTH). MIO1L1aab o61UMHHOA 3eMJIH 3aBHCHT OT HMcAapa6oTaloLuMx jieHOB po0a, H KaKlThir 'IAeH HMeeT MCKJnloqMTeAbHbie npaBa Ha onpeaeJIeHHyIOqaCTb 3TOU 3eMJIH, a TaioKe npaBo 3aBetLaTb 3Ty 3eMJllo CBoeMy CbiHy Hnu aoqepH. Cynpyr HAucynpyra pa6oTaloLuero MAeHa poaa (eCAH OH HJIH OHa qBJIReTCH npeaCTaBHTeAeM ManoqiMcAeHHbiXHapOIaOB CeBepa) HMeeT npaBO Ha 4aCTb 3TOU 3eMAH B TOM cAyqae, ecAH OH HJH OHa3aHHMaeTCa TpaHUUHOHHOA aeATeAbHOCTbIO Ha 3TOU 3eMAe, a He pa6oTaeT, HanpMmep, B ropoge.

npH rioaaqe 3aIBOK Ha nOAy'.ICHHe TaKx o6WUHHHbIX 3eMenb rpynrnbI ManoMHcAeHHbIXHapOIAOB CeBepa HMelOT ripOpMTeTHOe npaBO Bbi6opa 3eMeJbHbIX y'{aCTKOB, oCBo6oxwaeHMH OTynnIaTbI 3eMeAbHOrO Haanora Hun Han.OrOB Ha HCHOAb3OBaHHe HpIpO,4HbIx pecypcoB, a TaKKcenoJIyqeHm5I 6ecnAaTHbIX JiiLteH3Mii Ha onpeeeAeeHHbie BU14bl OXOTHHMbero H pbl6oAOBHorOnpOMblcAna AAS TeX xiJieHOB po0a, KOTOpbIe pa6oTaIoT Ha rOCyaapCTBeHHbIX Hun KOAJTeKTHBHbIXnpe,InpHHTHAX TpaUHUMOHHOrO ceKTOpa. '-iAeHaM poga 3anpemeHo aapMTb HAMn caBaTb B apeHAyKaKylO-AM6o 'aCTb BbileJTeHHbIX MM 3eMenb AIo6biM CTOpOHHHM opraH43aIu.iHM HAM 4)13M4ecKHMAiHIaM; MM 3anpeiieHuo HCnOAb3OBaTb Aio6ble M4Hepa.TbHbie HAn AeCHbie pecypcbI o6LU1HHbIX3eMenb =A5 KaKHX-AM6o HHbIX ueneu, KpOMe CTpOMTejbCTBa M OTOnAeHH5I co6cTBeHHbIx )KJIHLLI;MM 3anpemueHo npOaaBaTb AMLteH3HM Ha HCHnOb3OBaHHe 3eMAiH apyrHM AHHuaM; MM 3anpeLJueHOOCTaBIHTb 3TH 3CMAH HeUCHOAb3OBaHHbIMH B Te4eHHe cpoKa, npeBblwuaiouRero orpeAenAeHHbIunepHO11 BpeMeHH (aBa-TpH roga); H KpoMe Toro, OHM o6A3aHbl co6iioaaTb ce3OHbl OXOTbl Hpbi6oAoBcTBa H He IOADKHbl HapywaTb npaBsua, 3anpeCLaLoLuHe OTJOB oripeaeAeHHbIX BHAOB)KHBOTHbIX.

K npeHMyweCTBaM rpHHa=HeKHOCTH K KaKOMy-AH6o pOay, CeMbe HAM o6luMHeOTHOCSTCS aoTrocpoqHaA apeHAa 3eMAH 3TOU o61ul4HOri, CaMOCTOqTeJIbHOe peryAHpOBaHMe BceXMOMeHTOB, CBH3aHHbIX C 3TOA apeHAOA, a TaioKe ncHXoAorM4eCKHe BblrOAbl OT COBMeCTHOUipa6OTbl i npO)KHBaHMR C AIIOabMM, KOTOpbie MMelOT o6Wue B3FJIqbl Ha pa6oTy, np4poJLy Ho6LueCTBO.

CeroAHR B Xa6apoBcKoM Kpae 34 MAH. ra OTHOCHTCS K "TeppHTOpH4AM TpaaHLUHOHHoroHcnOTIb3OBaHMH"; M3 HUX 13,5 MnH. ra 6bluI Bbi4enieHbl KaK o6LUMHHbie 3eMIM. anlq cpaBHeHMA:M3 77 MAH. ra AeCHbIX 3eMenb 3Toro perHoHa o6was nJ]OLLtaab npHHOaHbIX 3anOBe4H4KOBCOCTaBJIAeT Bcero MLUHb 1,3 MnH. ra. B HeKOTOPbIX paHoHax B pe3yJIbTaTe o6bABAeHMH 3eMenbTeppHTOpHqMM4 TpaLLUMLLOHHOrO HCHOCJb3OBaHMH" 3HaIHTeAbHO COKpaT4JCq o6'beM Bbipy6KH -

3TO OaHa H3 npH4HH, noqemy rOcyaapCTBeHHblg KOMHTeT no oxpaHe oKpyKaio[Let cpeabiCMHTaeT 3TH 3eMAM OAHHM U3 gBeHaAuaTH BUd,OB oxpaH5eMb1X TeppHTOpHM.

HecMoTps Ha od)HuLtaJIbHoe 3aKOHoaaTeAbCTBO, B XKH3HM BCe o6CTo4T HHa'e. B Aecax,OTHeceHHb1X K riepBOu rpynne (rile 3anpeiueHa c1TAoW1HaS Bblpy6Ka), TaKaA Bbipy6Ka no-npe)KHeMy npOH3BOaI4TCq. CHeLtRaiUctbt AecHoro X03ArICTBa H AeCHofl riOMbIlw1eHHOCTHHrHOpHpyIOT 3TH roAOKoeHHA B CHuy OTCYTCTBHR KaKoro-JiH6o qeAepanhbHoro 3aKOHOaaTeAbCTBa.OLHaKO OqeHb HeMHOrHe rpyrirIbI MaJOMCj1eHHbIX HapOgOB CeBepa rpOTeCTYlOT HpOTHB TaKOrOHe3aKOHHOrO MCnOAb3OBaHHA peCypCOB, nOTOMy 4To jiCO3arOTOBHTenbHbie ripeanpiASTHA1 gaIOTHM pa6oTy, B KOTOpO1 OHM TaK OCTpO HyxKaalOTCA, o6ecne4MBalOT TpaHCHOpTHOe coo6uleHHe CpaBiOHHbIMH LICHTpaMM H CHa6)KaJOT TOBapaMH MeCTHb1e Mara3HHbl. Ha CaMOM ,aeie, HeKOTOpbieo6LUHHbl (HanpMmep, pOAOBas o6wHHa yAbqei B BaHHHCKOM paAOHe) CaMH OCylUeCTBA5IOTcnHAOLIHylO Bbipy6Ky, noapqiKsa Ha 3T0 3arOTOBMTeAerl-nepeceAeHueB, HeCMOTpA Ha CTPOrUe

Page 292: Russian - World Bank Documents

288 HPICIO)KEHHE A

3anpeTbl. MeCTHaq ciiyx6a necHoro Xo359iSCTBa OTKa3biBaeTCS cjieAHTb 3a HconJIHeHHeM 3aKOHa,

nOa,MepKHBa51, YTO 3TH 3eMJIH HY)KHO HCnOjib3OBaTb AS nieCO3aroToBoK. B pe3ynbTaTe cnjo1HOr

Bbipy6KH I436eralOT TOJIbKO Te iieca, KOTOpbIe HaXOaqTC5 B HenOCpeaCTBeHHOU 6JIH30CTH OT

nocejiKOB ManjoqHcjieHHbIX HapOaOB CeBepa.

PeKoMeHuyeMasi oTpacnesaH noIHTHKa

0,opoBJfeHHe COI(HaJlbHUX yCffOBNHN B pa#OHaX M paigNH. n1OMHMO MalOMHCj1eHHbIX

HapO,ROB CeBepa 1 apyroro KopeHHOrO HaceIieHHSl, KOTOpbIe, cKopee Bcero, OCTaHyTCq B

nocTpaD,aBUIWX paiOHax, TaM MOFyT OCTaTbCq HeKOTOpbIe pa6OTHMKM JIeCHoro, OXOTHtiberO H

pbi6Horo xO3SHicTBa, a TaK)Ke rHapoMeTcy)yx6b1. pJn1 Toro, YTo6bi 3TO CTaJO BO3MO)KHbIM,

Heo6xo,AIMo rapaHTHpoBaTb npeaOcTaBseH4e couHanbHbIX YCAyr (B TOM q'IcJie TpaHcnOpTHOro

coo6ULeH41) B03MO)KHO, 3a c4eT BbiLejieHMSI TpaHCnOPTHbIX AOTaLUHA B Mpe3BblaiaKHbIX

CHTYaUHHX HJIH B ciyqae nepee3AoB aJ51 nonY4eHHq npOq3eCCHOHaT1bHOr4 noarOTOBKH H

o6pa3oBaH4. B KaqeCTBe ajibTepHaTHBbI, o6ecnetHTb nepecenreHHe )K4TeJIeg, qepe3 pakOHHble

OpraHbl BJIaCTH, BKAiOYas HX pa3meiueHHe H npO43eCCHOHajIbHYIO nOArOTOBKY B HOBbIX MeCTaX

npO)KH4BaHHSl.

CoBepLmieHcTBoBaHme pa6Tmi c.hyx6m necHoro xo3RJcTBa H 4py)wX cffw6,3aHWMaioJH4WxC. yIlpaB./IeHNeCM HPHpO,)bX pecypcoB. B teJIoM, Heo6xoai4Mo nOBbICHTb YPOBeHb

3apa6OTHOR nHaTb1 pa6OTHMKOB necHoro X03RUCTBa U npeqoCTaB4Tb aapecHbie TpaHCnOpTHb1e

cy6cHxaHli TeM, KTO pa6oTaeT B OTRaJieHHbIX par4OHaX. npeRCTaBHTeJIAM MaJIOtnHCJieHHblX HapOAOB

CeBepa u ,Apyroro KopeHHorO HaceneHHS, KOTOpbIe MoryT pa6oTaTb J1eCOBoaaMH H JieCHHKaMH,

HY)KHO Co31aaTb B03MO)KHOCTM flJI o6y4eHHq.

Pa3BNme Tp4!HLfffoHHOIv ceKTopa 9KOHOMHKm. Ipexge BCerO, HY)KHO BOCCTaHOBHTb

TpaHcnOpTHoe coo6uieHHe, 'lTo6bi MeCTHOe HaceIieHHe nojiy'IHJIo BO3MO)KHOCTb c6blTa CBOeU

npo,ayKu4H. ,5iis TaKHX BHaOB aeSTeJIbHOCTM, KaK TYp43M, pa3BeaeHHe riUWHb[X 3Beper Hiun

nepepa6OTKa HeApeBeCHoH npO,4yKUHI4, nOTpe6yeTCI onpeaej1eHHb1I HaYajIbHbl4 KanHTani.

o6ecneveHHe 3cMeC]bHHX npaB MafOf CJIeHHbIX HapO,)OB CeBepa. JIio6as (bl)HaHCOBaS

nOMOUb ROJDKHa 6blTb YB53aHa C aaJ1bHerUIMm pa3'bqCHeHHeM u np4HSITmeM 4eaepajibHb1X

3aKOHOB 0 CTaTyce H npaBax MajiO4HCjieHHbIX HapOAOB CeBepa. TaKaA nOMOUb MO)KeT TaK)Ke

o6eCne4MTb 3alUHTY npaBa 3TUX o6LU14H Ha noj1y'eHi4e cnpaBe)3JIHBOA KoMneHcaU4H 3a

HCnoj1b3OBaHHe HX 3CMenJb JIHUaMH, He 5iBwIgOLUMMMCH YjieHaMH o6lUHH, OCo6eHHO B Tex

cjiylaRx, Kor2aa HCTOtalOTCH HeBO3o6HOBJIqeMbIe pecypcbl. Kpome Toro, 'eTKoe onpeaenieHie u

peaAM3auHM5 CTaTyca OXpaHAeMbIX TeppHTOpI4i 6yaeT CJ1Y)KHTb Bb1nOJIHeHH41O KaK COtUHaIbHbIX,

TaK H npHpOpOOXpaHHbIX 3aAaq.

OKBa3aHHe CO04CICTBHIW HCHpaBBh7eJJCTBeHHMM OPI'HH33aRL(M MafhOVHCJIeHHMX HapO4OB

CeBepa. Heo6xoatiMo C03,aaTb bOH,a (npl,aaB emy CTaTyC HIO) anH OKa3aHl4M5 coaeACTBMsl

qneHaM o6WUH ManoMMcJCHHbIX HaPOZROB CeBepa B o6yMeHHH AeCHOMy XO35H4CTBy,

OXOTOyCTpOiCTBy H ynpaBjieHHH pbi6HbiMU peCypCaMm; (bHaHCHpOBaHH4 yte6bi 'UleHOB 3TUX

rpynn HaceJIeHHA B Kojnieapax H yHKBepcHTeTax, co3aRaHMM npeFnpMATHI no nepepa6oTKe

npOfyKuUH TpaEHUMOHHOrO CeKTOpa; opraHH3auHR crneHaLJlbHbIX KYPCOB H nOarOTOBKM KaXpOB,

BKlOqaSA o6yeieHHe TpaaKUH4OHHbIM 3aHSTM5iM; Cy6CHlHpOBaHHl TpaHCnOPTHOrO coo6uleHMs4 C

patOHHb1MH UeHTpaMl.

Page 293: Russian - World Bank Documents

289 nPHJ1O)EHE )K

PacLmtpeHme L(ke,eBbmX Hay'IHMx ifCc,7IgaOBaHHI B o6&acm 6opeafwHoro ./ecHorvxoaq#cma. Heo6xoai4Mo d HHaHCMpOBaHHe aAS npOBegeHHI4 ueLjeBb[X HaY4HbIX HccneLot3aHHiATaKHX npo6AeM, KaK 3KOAoIrHMeCKH yCTOAIHBOe HCnOJIb3OBaHHe JIeCHbIX peCypCOB B paiOHaxnpO)KHBaHHA MaJO'oHCJIeHHbIX HaPOIOB CeBepa, COUHanbHO-3KOHOMH4eCKHe YCJOBHSTpaaHULHOHHOrO CeKTOpa, pa3pa6OTKa CTpaTerUH KOMnIIeKCHOrO HCF1OJlb3OBaH H 3THXTeppHTOpHu .jeCIeHOH rpOMbiLUJIeHHOCTbIO, 3aHSTOCTb MaJ1O4HCJICHHbIX HapOT,OB CeBepa BTpaBUUHOHHOM ceKTOpe. (DHHaHCOBaI HOMO1lb aOADKHa 6blTb npeIOCTaBneHa TeMopraHH3aUHAM, KOTOpbIe npOBOaqT noao6Hbie HccneAOBaHHq.

Op/MHH3a(INHZf If !IPOBCeAHMC COLJHOJIOI7PCCHfx MCcQe,4oBqHHif B paMKaX BCCX 6yA,WHxnpocK7Kv. Heo6xoauMo npOBeaeHHe peryjiRpHbIX H BCeCTOpOHHHX 4ccAeIOBaHHf c yqaCTHeMCOUHOJIOrOB, aemorpaqOB H 3KOHOMHCTOB paUOHHbIX amlM4HHUCTpaUHi4 B ueJ1ix noAy'eHuIACOBpeMeHHOH H noapo6Hog 4HHopMaUHH 0 TeKyLueu CHTyaLrnH. Euie go pa3pa6OTKM npoeKTOBH))KHO npOBOaHTb HCCAeaOBaHH51 B nOceJKaX, KOTOpbie 3TH npOeKTbl MOrYT 3aTpOHYTb(HCTOqHHKOM HH4OpMaUUH IBJIRIOTCl aOMOBbie KHHrH, HMelO1LUeCA y rIOCeAKOBbIXa,LMHHHCTpaUHU), H npOBOaHTb OIPOCbi rJaB riOCeAKOBbIX a,aM4HHcTpauLi4, ,pyrHxnpe,aCTaBHTeJAeR nOCeAKOBbIX OpraHOB BJIaCTH H MeCTHbIX )4cHTeJieg. 3TH 4CCJAeaOBaHHS4 HY)KHOHlpOBOXLHTb C ipUHBAJeeHHeM CaMbIX WUHPOKHX COeB HaCeAeHHA, H OHH 0A)XHbi 6blTbHanlpaBAeHbl Ha pa3pa6OTKy CTUpaTerH H BO3MO)KHbIX BapHaHTOB nocnie npOBeaeHHMKOHCyJIbTaUUHr C npeaCTaBHTeJITM4 BCeX cJIoeB o6wecTBa, BKAIO1a1 KO'eBbie H H30HpOBaHHblenOnYAuLHH, noceAKOBoe H IOpOXaCKoe HaceCeHHe.

JlHTepaTypa

rpyK, C.14. 1981. HaceAeHHe MHpa. 3THo-,aeMorpawiiecKl4i crpaBoqHHK. MocKBa:H3,aaTeJbCTBO "HayKa".

. 1994. "PacoBbli cocTaB HaceAeHHR PoccuH". B KH.: HapoAbl POCCHu. MocKBa:143,aaTeJlbcTBo "PoccCHcKaS 3HLU4KJorieaU4R. CTp. 37-41.

by'raHaeB, B. 1993. "3THOnOAIHTHqecKHe H 3THOKYAbTyPHbie npouecCbl B Pecny6JwKe XaKacHM".B KH.: HCccAeaoBaHHq HO npHKJiaaHOr4 H HeOTAO)KHOR 3THoIormH. MocKBa: IIHCTHTyT3THOJOIHH H aH'TpOnOJorHH4. CTaTbS N° 38.

BacHnbeB, B.lH. H C.M. MaiiHHOBCKaq. 1993. "KoHuIenrutH 3THOnOJIHTH'eCKOro,3KoHOMHi4eCKOro H KyJIbTypHOFO pa3BHTHA Man)O4HCieHHb[X HapOAOB ceBepa TOMCKOUio6JiaCTH". B KH.: 14ccJieaOBaHHR no npHKj]a,HOA H HeOTJIOKHOI 3THOJ]orHH. MOcKBa:IIHCTHTYT 3THOJorIH H aHTponoJTorHH. CTaTbA N° 54.

BaAHWTefiH, C.1I. 1994. "KeTbl". B KH.: Hapoabi CeBepa H CH6HpH B YCaOBHqX 3KOHOMH4eCKHXpe4OpM H AeMoKpaTWIeCKHx npeo6pa3oBaHHri. MocKBa: 1HHCTHTYT 3THOJorRI4 HaHTponojiorHH. cTp. 355-373.

BacHlbeB, B.1'I. 1994a. "Jao.nraHbl". B KH.: Hapoabl PoccHH. MOCKBa: M3,aaTeJ]bCTBO"POCCHUCKaR 3HuHKmOneHm". cTp. 149-150.

FopoxoB, C.H. 1994a. "3BeHKH". B KH.: Hapoabi POCCHH. MoCKBa: 143,aaTejibCTBO "PoccH4icKaR3HuHKionea1H". crp. 416-419.

Page 294: Russian - World Bank Documents

292 nPHPIoKEHHE XC

. 1994B. "CenbKynbi". B KH.: Hapoabi POCCHH. MOCKBa: 1H3,aaTenbcTBo "PocCHricKas

3HUHKAone,aH.". cTp. 312-314.

TaKcaMH, 4. 1981. "HUBXU". B KH.: Pacbl H Hapoabi. TOM. 11. cTp. 212-220.

Yamskov, Anatoliy N. 1996. "Conflicts over Defining and Allocating Territories for the Traditional

Use of Natural resources by Aboriginal Peoples in Russia", joint IUAES/IGU Congress,Linkoping, Sweden, August 22, 1996.

1 I994B. "YAbmH". B KH.: Hapo.nbl PoccHH. MOCKBa: I143laTeAbcTBO "PoccHicKas

3HUHKoneAR". cTp. 366-369.

Xa6apOBCKHU KpaeBOi aenaPTameHT cTaTHCTHKH. 1994. CocTosAHe oKpy)4KaioLUer4 cpeabl B

Xa6apoBcKoM Kpae B 1993 rony. Xa6apoBcK: Xa6aposcKlu4 KpaeBof4 aenapTaMeHT

CTaTHCTHKH.

. 1994. "XaKacbl". B KH.: Hapoabi PoccHH. MocKBa: 1H3,aTeAbcTBO "PoccKIIcKas

3HuHKaone,aiU.". cTp. 374-380.

AIMCKOB A.H. 1996. "TeppHTopHH Tpa,aHUHOHHOrO 3eMj1e1enJIH B Xa6apoecKoM Kpae." B KH.

H4ccJienoBaHHs no np4KJiaaJHOk H HeOTIOXKHOiU 3THOOrFHH. Ng 96. MocKBa.

Page 295: Russian - World Bank Documents

nPHAOKEHHE 3

CHCTEMA OCOr,O OXPAHAEMbJX TPHPOJIHbIX TEPPHTOPIHr B PAMKAX AECHOFOCEKTOPA

OrpoMHbie TePPHTOPHH POCCHUCKOU ()eAepaLtHH ripeAcTaBEuSHOT co6o0 OaHy H3nociieAHHx BO3MO)KHOCTeR COXpaHHTb Ha Haleri niiaHeTe HeTpOHyTbIe 3KOCHCTeMbi,,LOCTaTOMHO MaculTa6Hbie 1AA TOrO, tiTo6bi o6ecneqHTb YCJIOBHI AAA eCTeCTBeHHorO1JpOTeKaHHA 3KOAOrtMeCKKX npOULeCCOB H pa3BHTHR B eCTeCTBeHHbIX YCJTOBHAX rloUTynA5u1lHuaHKHX )4HBOTHbIX. YHHKanbHble rpynnbi nopoa aepeBbeB, pacTyWUHX B parioHe BoJIbworoKaBKa3a H Ha gaaAbHeM BocToKe POCCuH, no CBoemy pa3Hoo6pa3HIo H YPOBHIO3H,aeMHqHOCTH ripeBoCXoST nieca yMepeHHoro nosca B nAo6ok TOqKe Mi4pa.

Macurra6b CHCTeMbi oco6o oxpaHAeMbUx TeppHTOPHr

'4aCTb 3TorO YHHKanbHOrO IpIpOaHOrO pa3Hoo6pa3Hs oxpaHieTCH CHCTeMOrlIPHPOIHbIX 3aHOBeAHHKOB POCCHH, KOTOpaA OXBaTbiBaeT 11OqTH 6% TeppUTOPU1 cTpaHbl.

3TO KpynHeriwaA, oAHa H3 Ba)KHewU1HX H AO HejaBHero BpeMeHH HaU4JTY4UHM o6pa3OMOpraHH3OBaHHbIX TaKoro poAa CHCTeM B MHpe. CHcTeMa oxpaHqeMbIX TeppHTOpHi4 POCCHHCOCTOHT H3 cTporo OXpaHReMb1X IpHpOAHbMX 3anoBe,HHKOB, HCnOJIb3yeMbIX An1A Hay4HbIXHccie,aOBaHHI H coxpaHeHHS 6Hoc4)epbi H 31MHHMaiolux 1,42% TeppHTOPHH cTpaHbI;HaUHOHanJbHblX rapKOB, 3aHHMaiOUwX 0,38% TeppHTOPHH POCCHH, KOTOPb[e AB5lIOTCAOXpaHAeMbiMH TeppHTOpHMMH, rAe B OrpaHHMeHHbIX MaclllTa6ax pa3peueHo pa3BsTHeTypH3Ma, cenbcKoro XO31i"CTBa H Bblnac CKOTa; cneIHajabHbIe 3aKa3HHKH, co3aaBaeMbieo6bl4HO Ha onpeaeJeHHblH CpOK ARA5 OXpaHbl OTaeAbHbIX nOnYIALUHi ()JIOpbi H (jayHbl H3MHHMaolume 4% pOCCHACKOR TeppHTOpUH; H naMuTHHKH flpHpOlIbI.

B 1995 r. B POCCUH HMenOCb 89 npHPOlHbIX 3anOBeAHHKOB o6weH nHJOWaabio 229MnH. ra, H 28 HaUHOHanJbHblX napKOB o6iaeri nOIuaAbKO OKOJIO 6,5 MJIH. ra. no IaaHHbIMKa,aacrpa 1991 r. Hact1HTbIBaeTCA CBblwle 1000 3aKa3HHKOB o6teii rIjiOIaabio 44 MJIH. ra; 69H3 HHX OTHOCHTCA K q eepalbHOMY ypOBHIO H 3aHHMaeT TePPHTOPH1O 11,4 MJIH. ra.

HecMOTps Ha TO, 'TO npHpOaHbie 3anOBe,HHKH C03AaHbi BO BceX TpHHaauaTH4)H3HKo-reorpadtiecKHx o6AacTAX (ApKTHKa, (DeHHO-CKaHAKHaBHA, PycCKaA PaBHHHa,KaBKa3, Ypaii, 3anaaHas CH6Hpb, KacnHricKo-TypraHcKaA 3OHa, CpeaHsuI CH6Hpb, IOKHO-CH6HpCKHe rOpbl, AHO-KKOnbiMcKasi 3OHa, baAKajio-4~Acyra)KypCKHi4 rOpHbl paHOH,AMypcKo-CaxajIHHcKaSl 3oHa, CeBepHbIir THXOOKeaHCKHR paHOH), OHH pacHnpe genSlomHepaBHOMepHO. HanpHMep, B npeaejiax PycCKoUi PaBHHHbI HMeeTCA 22 nPHPO1aHbIX3anOBe,aHHKa, B TO BpeMs, KaK B ApKTHMecKoH o6nacTT UX scero aBa.

B BeAeHHH rocyaapcTBeHHorO KOMHTeTa no oxpaHe oKpyKaiouteg cpeLlbi (6blBwueroMHHHcTepCTBa OXpaHbl oKpy)calouei Ccpe,bl UH npHpOLAHbIX pecypcoB), HaXOa,lTCq 82InPPOHAHbIX 3anIOBeAHHKa, wTO cocTaBnqeT 6onee 40% cTporo oxpaHAeMbIX nptppOaHbIXTeppHTopHfl Bcero MHpa (KaTeropHR I no KAaccH4mKauHH MCOI). PoccHR HMeeTAJIHTeJlbHyIO HCTOpHIO HccjieaoBaHHr, npOBO41IMbIX B 3THX 3arOBe,IHHKax, weCTb H3KOTOpbIX BKj1OioeHbi B MHPOBYIO CeTb 6Hoc4epHbIX 3anOBeaHHKOB. B pe3ynbTaTe

Page 296: Russian - World Bank Documents

294 nPHIO)IKEHHE 3

Hccie,aoBaHHA, npOBOaHBWu1XCc9 B 3THX 3anoBeaHHKaX B Te4eHHH HeCKOJ1bKHX aeCmwTieTHA,

6bIJO HaKonnieHO orpoMHoe KOJHqeCTBO ueHHbIX HayqHbIX aaHHbIX.

B npHpOaHbIX 3anoBeaHHKax PoccuH oxpaHqeTCq 3HaMHTeJIbHoe KOJH4eCTBO BHUOB

pacTeHHri H )KHBOTHbIX, MHorHe H3 KOTOpbIX BKlioqeHbl B POCCHrCKyIO H MeeKgyHapOaHyIo

KpaCHble KHHrH peAKHX H Hc'e3aolLUHX npeacTaB4TeAerl paCTHTenJbHOrO H )KHBOTHOrO MHpa.

B CnpaBKe 3.1 npeAcTaBJIeHa AOnOJIHHTeJbHa5I HH4opMamUH1 0 COCTaBe BHaOB )HBOTHbIX,

npe,aCTaBMeHHbIX B cHcTeMe oxpaHReMbIX TeppHTopHP.

CnpaBKa 3.1: BuAba xUBOTHbiX, oxpaHmembie B nIpHPOAHb[X 3anOBeAHHKax PoCCHH

rlocAeleHHe HmewmKHbie aaHHbie O KOJIH4eCTBe BHAOB, oxpaHAeMbix B nlpHPOaHbIX 3anOBeAHHKaX, aaTHpyIOTCs

1987 r., Korla B PoCCHH HaCYHTbIBaJIOCb 89 npHpoaHbIx 3anoBeAHmKoB. C Tex nop 6bulo co3LaaHo HeMaJ1O HOBbIX

3aliOBe,aHHKOB, n1O3TOMy nlPHBOaHMbie UH4pb) JIHUb CBHU4eTeJibCTByxOT 0 BaEKHOi poJIH oxpaHSeMbIX TeppHTOpi4l

B COXpaHeHHH cpea o6HTaHmH. B 1987 r. B lpHPOJIHbIX 3anlOBeAHHKaX OXpaHHUOCb:

* 168 BHAOB MneKonITaiOWiux (69% Ha3eMHbix MJIeKonuTalOIHx, o6iTamOUJuX B PoccHII). 13 65 BHAOB

MJieKon1HTalIIHX, BKJIiOqeHHbIX B KpaCHylO KHHry PocCu, 25 BHAOB (U3 HHX 3 BHaa MOpCKHX

MJIeKonHTaIOLLtHX) 3aperHCTpHPOBaHO B nlpHPOJHbIX 3anlOBeAHHKax.

* 515 BsaOB nTflTl (83% nTHU, o6rTaiowlIx B PoCCHH). 13 109 BHZAOB nITHU, 3aHeCeHHbIX B KpaciiyIO KHHry

POCCHH, 60 3aperCCTPHPOBaHo B nlpHpOAHbIX 3anoBe,4HHKax.

* 40 BHAOB penTHnuH (61% penTHJIIiui, o6HTaiotUHx B PoccHM). U3 11 BHAOB penTHrnAli, 3aHeceHHbIX B

KpaCHyiO KHHry POCCHH, 5 3aperICTpHpoBaHO B nlpHpOAHblX 3anOBeJHHKax.

* 26 BHAOB 3eMHOBOAHbIX (96% 3eMHOBOAHbIX, o6HTalOLUHX B POCCuH). 13 4 BH1OB 3eMHoBoaHbIx,

BKJllomeHHblX B KpaCHyIO KHUry PoccHH, 3 3aperHCTPHPOBaHO B npHpOJHbX 3anOBeAHHKax.

IlMeeTcH Manio aaHHbIX o pa3Hoo6pa3HI BHAOB H THnaX 3KOcUCTeM, HMelOIUHXCA B HaUHOHaJbHbIX napKaX.

OAHaKo npH6jlM3mTeJTbHbie OueHKH nlOKa3biBaO'r, YTO B HaUHOHaBJbHbix napKax 3apermCTpHpOBaHO OKOJ1o 800

BHUaOB COCYAHCTblX paCTeHHi H 200 BsaOB nO3BOHo0HbIX (190 nTHu H 50 MJeKonHTaloIuHx).

Boniee Haae)KHbie aaHHbie o pa3Hoo6pa3HH BHJAOB Ha TePpHTOPHH cnelLHanbHbIX 3aKa3HHKoB H naMqTHHKOB

nPHPO,Rbl OTCYTCTBYIOT.

npo6.neMbi cHcTeMbi oco6o oxpaHsembix npHPOJAHbIX TeppHTopHt

,ae.qTe.nbHOCTb B paMKaX HCTOpHqeCKH CJIO)KHBlwe4CS CHCTeMbl 3anOBeaHHKOB

npeIacTaBJTSleT co6o0 CHCTeMaTH'IecKyIo H KOMnHieKCHYIO pa6oTy no CoxpaHeHilo

3HaMHTeJIbHO4 IaCTH MHPOBoro 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3Hr. OaHaKo B nocfleLHHe rofabl 3Ta cHCTeMa

CTaJIKHBaeTcH c cepbe3HbIMH npo6neMaMH. He MeHee nOAOBHHbl npHpoaHbIx 3anoBe,RHHKOB

H4 OAHOt TpeTH HauHOHaSjbHbIX napKoB POCCHH Haxo0qTCR B KPHTWqecKoM COCTOAHHH uuH

npH6JIH)xalOTCA K HeMy, a cama cHcTeMa Haxo0HTcA noA yrpo3ori pa3pyueH HA. npHnonyCTHTeJIbCTBe, a qaCTO H npuH riogAep)KKe MeCTHb1X aBMHHHCTpaLUHI paCTYT MacLJTa6bi

3KcnjiyaTaUHH npHpOLHbIX peCYPCOB Ha TePpHTOPHH 3anoBeAHHKoB. Eouiee HHTCHCHBHoe

HCnonb3oBaHHe H lUHPOKHU AOCTyn K rOCyIlapCTBeHHbIM 3eMjiqM B pe3yj1bTaTe npHBaTH3aUulH

H AeLteHTpaJIH3aUHH rOCyaapCTBeHHOr4 BnaCTH YCHJiBnalOT YUPo3Y Dn5 OXpaHReMbIX

TeppHTOpH]k, a npHuieraioiuae 3eMjiH MaCTO CTaHOBATCA o60beKToM CnnOUWHbIX py6oK,

reonorHmecKHx pa3pa6oToK, CejibCKOX03AriCTBeHHOri aeATeSJbHOCT4 HU npoMblwUJeHHOrO

3arpR3HeHHR. OTCyTCTByeT MeTKoe HU nocneroBaTeJIbHoe 3aKoHoflaTejTbcTBo, rapaHTupyIoiuee

BbDKHBaHHe H ,lonroCpoMHoe 4 HHaHCHpOBaHHe CHCTeMbi OXpaH5ieMbIX TeppHTOpHR (CM.

Page 297: Russian - World Bank Documents

295 nP4JIOKEHHE 3

CnpaBKa 3.2). K 3THM npo6iieMaM o6aBAseTcsA CTpeMUiTeJbHOe CHH)KeHHe o6ibeMOB41HHaHCHpOBsaHHS ceTH oxpaHHeMbIX 3anoBeaHb[X TeppHTopHA. B peanbHOM Bbipa)KeHHi4o06eM 4bHHaHCOBbIX CpeaCTB, BbiaejA5eMbIX Ha noAaep)KKy CHCTeMbi HPHPOxHbIX3anoBeaHHKOB, CHH43HA1CAI HaCTOJIbKO, 'ITO COCTaBJiHeT MeHee 22% OT YPOBHSI 1985 r.

CnpaBKa 3.2: 3aKoH "06 oco6o oxpaHSeMbix npHPOnHb[X TeppHTOpHRX"

3aKoH "06 oco6o oxpaHsembix I1pHpOaHbIX TeppHTOpHAX", nlpHSTbIA B mapTe 1995 r., o6ecne'HBaeT OCHOBEbARM yKpenAeHHfl U KOOPAHHaUHH ae1STeRbHOCTH CHCTeMbi oxpaH.9CMbIX TeppHTOpHu. 3To nepBbIiHaUHOHaJIbHbil 3aKoH, nOCBSHWeHHbiH uiCKTIIOqHTeCjbHO oxpaHqeMbiM TeppHTopHRM. B HeM npeacTaineHbinpaBOBble OCHOBbl nrIaHHpOBaHH5 H ynpaBjieHHs AAsM BCeX THnlOB 3anOBeAHHKOB. B 3aKOHe perCameHTHpyeTc pa3,aeneHHe OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH 3a ynpanBeHHe pa3J[HqHbIMI THnaMH OXpaH5eMbIX TeppHTOpUU Mexy yCe,aepaAbHbIMH H perHOHaJIbHblMH opraHaMm BJaCTH. CpeRu CHAbHbIX CTOpOH HOj3OrO 3aKOHa MOKHO OTMeTHTbcAejlyiouLee:

* PacwjHpeHHe nOJIHOMOqHH erepCKHX (KOHTTpOAbHblX) cAy)K6 npHpoaHbix 3anOBseHHKOB H HaUHoHanbHbIXnapKOB ilO ypoBH5s, COnOCTaBHMoro C nOJIHOMOqHqMH flOJIHnuHH.

* 3anpeT Ha npHBaTH3aUmio co6CTBeHHOCTI Ha oxpaHHeMbix TeppHTOpHsqx.

B aonojiHeHHe K oxpaHe n1pHpOabi H HayBHbIM HCciieQOBaHHsM, OTMeqaeTCs H BOCnHTaTeJlbHaq POJlbnpHpOAHb]X 3anoBeAHHKoB. OAHaKo 3aKOH HeaOcTaTOqHO qeTKO onpeaemeiT 4HHaHCOBble npaBa H o6A3aHHocTHpyKOBO,aHTeAeh oxpaHseMbix TeppHTopHi. HanpHMep, OTCYTCTByioT 'eTKHe yKa3aHHsM 0 TOM, KaKa,aMHHHcTpaltHH oxpaHAseMbIX TePPHTOPHPi MOryT Hcnojib3oBaTb uwTpa(Jbi m apyrtie BbInAaTbI, nojiyteHHbIe OTHapywHTeJieu oxpaHHoro pe)KHMa, B TOM tlHCjie qaCTHbIX JIHU H opraHH3auLH.

OpraIHHaL(HoHHme aciixKm H yiipaawmw

11OMHMO pe3KOro yMeHbw1eHUH 4)IHaHCHpOBaHHSl, B03MO)KHOCTH CHCTeMbioxpaH5ieMbIX TeppHTOPHH npHcioca6JH4BaTbCS K HOBbIM H MeHAIOU4MCqI peaAHSlMpOCCHiCKHX yCAOBHA orpaHwtIHBaIOTcAI Cepbe3HbIM14 a,AMHHHCTpaTHBHbIMH HynpaBAeHJHecKC4MH npo6neMaMH. O4eBHUHbl HeaOCTaTKH Ha BCeX YPOBHAX ynpaIBjeHHMOXpaHAeMbIMH TeppHTOpHHM4: B nAaHe Me)KBe,4OMCTBeHHOrO COTpy,aHH4eCTBa, 4JYHKUHrynpaBAeHHri H ,aeqTeAbHOCTH OT,aelbHbIX oxpaH51eMbIX TeppHTOpHi4. YnpaBAeH'ecKHeCTpYKTypbl B paMKaX FOAOBHblX 4)eaepanbHbIX Be,aOMCTB ,aerCTByIOT He3("eKTHBHO Hpa3o6LUeHHo.

,4aCXJIWbHOCTh Ha OXpaHIembmX TCPPHTOWpHJX

n11aHHpOBaHHe fpHpO,4OOXpaHHbIX flporpaMM B OT,aeJIbHbIX 3aHOBe,aHHKax Heo6ecne'IHBaeTcsI Ha aOA)JKHOM ypOBHe. TaK, HaHpHMep, HH HaLuHOHaAlbHbie rlapKH, H143aHOBe,aHHKH He o6Mq3aHbI COCTaBAITb nAaHbl ynpasBeH14A CBOerl aeqTeAbHOCTbIO.,T,OCTaTO4Hbie CTHMyAbl nAA rIpOBe.eHHq Heo6xo414MbIx HOBOBBeaeHHA npHH nAaHHpOBaHHIHHuH ocyULeCTBJIeHHAI rpOeKTOB, KOTOpbIe MoIJH 6bl cnoco6cTBoBaTb paUHOHaBbHOMYHCflOJb3OBaHHiO npHpOaHbIX peCypCOB 3aqacTyio IOIPOCTY OTCYTCTBYIOT. Pe3y.nbTaTblHay'HbIX pa6oT, ocy[UeCTBJIAeMb1x B IPHPO,aHbIX 3aHOBeaHl Kax Hay'lHbIMH COTpYaHHKaMH,YqHTbIBaiOTCSA ABHO He1aOCTaTOqHO llpH (4)OpMHpOBaHH4 nOJIHTHKH H CHCTeMbl ynpaBA1eHH4loxpaHAeMbIMH TeppHTOpHSiM4. lla)Ke Te orpaHH'LeHHbie cpeaCTBa, KOTOpbie BbilaeAJSoTCAOT,eAbHbIX OXpaHAeMbiM TeppHTOpH5M, He 4CHOJTb3yiOTCH 39jeKTHBHO. bIoxeTbI3anOBeAHHKOB npaKTHMeCKH nOAHOCTbIO paCXOLyIOTCs Ha BbiriIiaTy 3apa6OTHOR riAaTbi,KOTOpa5 He aOCTHraeT aa)Ke YPOBH51 IPO)KHTO'IHOrO M4HHmyMa. HyAAbl coaep)KaHHS

rHoppacTpyKTypbi I4HOpHpyIOTC. nOMeLueHHS, Aa6opaTopHH, TpaHCnOpTHbIC CpeaCTBa H

Page 298: Russian - World Bank Documents

296 HPHJIO)KEHKIE 3

npoYee o6opyAoBaHNe npMXOAST B HerOAHOCTb. B pe3yAbTaTe 3To0O, MHOrHe oxpaH5eMbie

TePpHTOpHU npaKTH4YeCKH He MOrYT npOTHBOCTOATb pacryuAemy aaBneHI4o BOKPyr ux

rpaHHu.

O6y0CHeHHC IICpCOHaa H pJ OBO,4KTefeW OXPaHgeMJwX TqppHwpmif

EOJIbWHHCTBy AHpeKTOPOB npHpOAHbIX 3anOBe,HHKOB H HaUMOHaj]bHbIX rapKOB He

XBaTaeT Heo6xoaHMoro onbITa Hun riOArOTOBKH B o6JiaCTT ynpaBJleHHU9 OXpaHeMbIMH

TeppHTOpH5MH, HeCMOTp5 Ha TO, 'YTO OHH 4aCTO o6.na,alOT pa3Hoo6pa3HbIMH H UeHHbIMM

3HaHH5IMH U HaBbIKaMH. OuxyuiaeTc.i 601bwa5 HeXBaTKa nporpaMM o6y'eHHIu ,Ansi nepcoHana

H PYKOBOAHTeAeA OXpaH.1eMbIX TeppHTOpHfl, YqHTbIBaIOIUHX HX OfibiT H HanpaBAeHHbIX Ha

OpMHPOBsaHme o6luero nOHHMaHHB 3a,a4 npHpOAHbIX 3anOBeaHHKOB. MeHSHOLUHecq

YCAOBHA H nepCnCKTHBbl TaabHegwero ae4)HUHTa 4JHHaHCHPOBaHHU9 HaCTO,9TeJTbHO Tpe6ylOT

yaeSJIHTb BHmaHmU o6yqeHHIO HOBblM rIoaXOaaM K yipaBjieHHIO H UI nJaHpOBaHHIO

TaeATeJIbHOCTH OXpaHqeMbIX TeppHTOpHi. KaapoBasq nOJIHTHKa aODKHa pa3pa6aTbIBaTbCq C

yMeTOM Heo6xo,LiMOcTM HcnoJIb3oBaHH4l MeHbILero 'Hcjia 6o0iee noArOTOBAeHHbIx H

KBaBjIHML)HpOBaHHbIX COTPyaHHKOB.

Ho,kW4epxIa o6eCTBceHHOCTm

HaceieHHe POCCuH MajiO 3HaeT 0 ceTH OXpaH5eMbIX TeppHTOpHU, H J1MUIb HeMHOrl4e

rpynnbl HaCeCieHM5I, nPOXHBaiOlUHe B POCCHUCKOU (1e,epaUHH nony4aloT BbIroIay OT

RHeTeJbHOCTH TaKHX TeppHTOpHA. 06ecneYeH4e nOaaep)KKH CO CTOPOHbl o6LUeCTBeHHOCTH

HMKOraa He 6buio 'aCTbIO CTpaTerHH ynpanBjeHHH H pa3BHTHq OXpaHieMb[X TePpHTOpHR

PoccHm. B pe3yibTaTe 3TOrO, o6WuecTBo B UejiOM MaXjO 3HaeT 0 BeSjiKHX HaUU4OHajibHbIX

HpHpO,fjHbIX COKPOBHiUaX PoccHm. OTCyTCTBHe o6LuecTBeHHo9 mOwepAKKH 'aCTM4HO

o61bAcHAeTcA o6feg RORHTHKOA OTcTpaHeHHA HaceieHHA$ OT y'aCTHA B )KH3HH OXpaHHeMbIX

TeppHTOpUIU. )KH3Hecnoco6HOCTb OXpaHqeMbIX TeppHTOpHU 3aBHCHT OT o6LUeCTBeHHOA

noAaep)iKKH HaceiAeHHS POCCH4 B uejioM, MeCTHbIX )KHTeiek, IPO)KHBaioLUHX BOKpyr

oxpaHHeMbIX TeppMTOpH4, a TaIOKe perHoHaAbHb[X H MeCTHbIX opraHoB BJaCTH. B HacToArnee

BpeMA TaKaS noAaep)KKa HaXOAHTCSl Ha M4H4MaMJbHOM ypOBHe.

Heo6xo1aHMocTb pacWHpeHHS CeTH oco6o OXpaHAeMblX npHpO,1HbIX TeppHTOpHUi

,aJ,5I TOrO, qTo6bI pOCCHirCKaM CMCTeMa OXpaHqeMbIX TeppUTOpHA aOADKHbIM o6pa3oM

peuwaia nOCTasBjeHHbie nepea,HeH 3a,aaw, TO eCTb o6ecneYUBaAa COXpaHeHMe

6Hopa3Hoo6pa3lA, 3TM CHCTeMa aOJDKHa 6blTb CyLUeCTBeHHO pacuWHpeHa. B TeqeHMe

HeCKOnbKHX nocAeCyioLuHx IieT, nOKa OTHoweHHA B cfepe co6CTBeHHOCTH Ha 3eMjiio eLue

TOJbKO CKAaabIBalOTCA, npaBHTejibCTBO MMeeT YHHKaBJbHYIO B03MO)KHOCTb BbiaeCj]Tb Fog

3anOBe,aHMKH 6OJTbUIHe y4aCTK4 3eMJIH 6ecnCiaTHO HunM paKT4meCKH 6ecniiaTHo. OaHaKO B

HaCTOALuee BpeMA YCTaHaBJIHBaKOTCR ueHbl Ha 3eMji1o, H OHM oco6eHHO BbICOKH B paHoHax,

6oraTblx npMpORHbIM4 pecypcaMH. UeHbI npeLnoniOOKTeCAbHo 6 yXyT paCTH no mepe

ycKopeHHH npouecca npHBaTM3aUHM H McnOAb3OBaHHA npHpOaHbIX pecypcoB. B

nocCeAypo1me HeCKOAbKO AeT ROI)KHbi 6blTb npFIHHTbl 3c4eKTMBHbie Mepbl, HanpaBBneHHble

Ha coxpaHeHMe oGUIpHbIX HeoxpaHSeMbix aeBCTBeHHbIX paROHOB, KOTOpbie enie

He,aOCTaTOLIHO nlpeaCTaBAeHbl B CeTM OXpaHReMbIX Tepp4TOpKA. BO3MOKHO B CKOPOM

BpeMeHH npaBHTeAbCTBO He 6yieT HMeTb 6oAbme d3MHaHCOBbIX B03MO)KHOCTerI Co3JtaBaTb

HOBbie OXpaH5eMbIX TeppHTOp4H, nO3TOMY Ba)KHOe 3Ha'1eHMe nO3HULH H o6sI3aTeAbcTB

opraHOB BnaCTH nO BOnpOCaM OXpaHbl oKpy)KaloLuefl cpeCbl H COXpaHeHH5I HpIpOLIbl TpyXLHO

nepeoueHHTb.

Page 299: Russian - World Bank Documents

HPHAO)KEHHE H

YnPABJTEHUE PECYPCAMH JIIKHX 4KUBOTHbIX 11 YCTOr4tlBOE PA3BUTUE JIECHOrOCEKTOPA I

YnpaBineHHe pecypcaMH ,UHKHX AKRBOTHbUX Ha 4beAepajibHOM ypOBHe

,eHnap7aMeHT OXOTHIPIbAX peCYJpCOB

)lo 1992 roaia FJaBHoe ynpaBneHHe OXOTHHqbHX pecypcoB 6buIo He3aBHCHMORopraHMaLume - HMeno npeacTaBHTeJIbCTBa B KamKaoM perioHe H HaxoauJIOCb B ITPAMOMno,aqHHeHHH CoBeTa MHHUCTpOB PCDCP. B 1991 ro,y fIpaBHTeJIbCTBO POCCHHiCKOU&(De,epaL4HH, B uejiqX coKpameHH5I yripaBjieHqecKoro annapaTa, co3AaYio MHHHCTepCTBO3KoJIor4H, o6ibeaHHHB KpynHegHIe pecypcHbie BeaoMCTBa POCCHH B paMKax OgHOIamlMHHHcTpaTHsBHO4 CTpyKTypbl. B 1992 rony, B COOTBeTCTBHH C ABYM5 rOCTaHoBJeHHSMH,KOMHTeTbl, peryA14py1ow0 e peCypconoJIb3oBaHHe, 6blIH oTae2eHbl OT KoMHTeTOB,o6ecneqHBalolux oxpaHy peCypCoB. DIaBHoe ynpaBnieHHe OXOTHHqbHX pecypcoB 6buloBriocAe,aCTBH4 npHcoeHUHeHO K M1HHCTePCTBy CenbCKOFO XO3SH4CTBa H 1ipoaOBOJTbCTBHI4POCCUH, B BeaeHH4 KOTOporo aeriapTaMeHT HaxoLHTCS3 H B HaCTOM[uee BpeMq. EroodmLIaJAbHoe Ha3BaHHe - ,L,eTapTaMeHT nO oxpaHe H paLIHOHanJbHOMY HCnOIb3OBaHHIOOXOTHHqbHX pecypCoB. aenapTaMeHT BO3rAasBneT 3aMeCTHTeJIb MUHHCTpa ceCIbCKoroXo3,qruCTBa.

4)YHKUHH H o61q3aHHOCTH aenapTaMeHTa OXOTHHqbHX peCypCOB onpeaejIHIoTcSq)e,aepawbHbiM 3aKoHoM "O KU4BOTHOM M4pe" (1995 r.), KOTOpblU o6ecneqHBaeT npaBOBy1oOCHOBy aeMTeJIbHOCTH aenapTaMeHTa. BnocneaCTBHH B 3aKOH BHOCHJIHCb He3HaHtCTenbHbleH3MeHeHH5 H nonpaBKH, B OCHOBHOM KacaioiuHecs KiaacCHcfrKaUiH HPOMbICJOBbIX BZ,aOB)K4BOTHbIX. B JenioM aenapTaMeHT OTBeqaeT 3a ynipaJeHHC H HcnOnb3OBaHHenpH6JIH3HTeCJbHo CeMW4aeCITH 3aKOHoaaTeJIbHO YCTaHOBJIeHHbIX BHROB npOMbICJOBbIX)KHBOTHbIX Ha BCeri TeppUTOpH4H POCCuH, KpOMe ObLHuHaAbHO OXpaH5eMbMX TePPHTOPU1U,TaKHX, KaK 3aroBeaJiHKH. OcHoBHbIe o6A3aHHIocTH aenapmmeWa OXOTHHUbHX peCYPCOB BKpaTKOu d)opMe rpeacTaBAeHbl B Ta6iuue 14.1.

B llOCTaHoBseHuH "O crTeLtHaAbHo yHOJIHOMOqeHHbiX rocyaapCTBeHHb X opraHaxPOCCHUCKOU ($eaepauKH B o6AacTH OXpaHbI H 4CnOJ1b3OBaHH41 o6'beKTOB )K4BOTHOrO MUpa HHx MecToo6HTaHHl4" (ceHTq6pb 1993 r.) onpeaeniAioTc5i npaBa H o6Al3aHHocTH 6blBweroM4HnpHpoH1hbI B OTHOIeIHHH npOMbICAOBbIX )K4BOTHbiX. IOMUMO KOHTpOJI5 3a HcrOAHeHCHeM3aKoHoB, 6blBee MHHrpH4poabi, COBMeCTHO C aenapTameHTOM OXOTHHqbHX peCypCoB,YTBepxKanO KBOTbl Ha OTCTpeiJ OCHOBHbIX rPOMbICJIOBbIX BHAOB )KHBOTHb[X. Pbi6Hbiepecypcbl HaXO,ATCH B BegeHMH rocyaapCTBeHHorO KOMHTeTa no pbI6HOMy XO3MirCTBy,aBTOHOMHOrO opraHa, IOa,'IHHHoI[erOCA HeriocpenCTBeHHO npaB4TeJIbCTBy.

1 MaTepmanbl aaHHoro uptJiOKoeHMA B OCHOBHOM oTpa)KalOT COCTOSHHe aeu Ha HaqaJo 1996 r.(npHMeqaHme pe4aKTopa PyCCKOFO U3maHai.)

Page 300: Russian - World Bank Documents

298 nPIIJIO)KEH11E H

CorinacHo noCTaHoBJIeHI4O npaBFiTenJbCTBa "06 oxpaHe H peryAHPOBaHit4I

HCnOJIb3OBaHH4l o61beKToB )KHBOTHOrO Mmpa", M4HnpHpOabl (HbIHe rOCKOM3KoJOrHuu)

ynOJIHOMo'leHO o6ecnewiHBaTm (rapaHTHpoBaTb) oxpaHy U pery,7HpoBaTb JificOJilb3oBHme

o6beKToB 1UHKOA' fIpHpOaIbI, KpOMe BK[IIOveHHbiX B 7pHJIaraeMblg CuHlCOK JpOMbiCJOBbiX

BHlaOB HIH IHMelOioliwx J7oaTBepxaeHHylO KOMMepYeCKyiO iIeHHOCTb. 0TRHaKO B

nOCTaHOBJeHHH OTCYTCTByeT onpeaejieHHe TepM4Ha "IaHKaq npHpoJaa". TaIcKe OTCYTCTBYIOT

qeTKHe YKa3aHHS 0 TOM, HaXOR51TC51 JIH B BeaeHHH FOCKOM3KoJIOrUH Bce HenPOMblCJnOBbie

BH,IbI, BKJlO'laAS 250 BHUOB )KHBOTHblX H 500 BHXOB paCTeHHR, BKJlOIoeHHbIX B KpaCHYIO

KHHry POCCHH (H3A. 1984 r.), HeKOTOpbie He o6ecne4eHbl KaKou-iH6O npaBoBoA oxpaHOA. B

HacTo5Hutee BpeM5 [ocKoM3KOJoFHH4 o6HOBJIqeT CnHCKH KpacHOu KHHUIr.

Ta6JiHua 14.1. OCHOBHbie )YHKUHH JenaPTaMeHTa OXOTHHUbUX pecypcOB

C2JCpa9VTHqM# YPOBCHb PcrmoHaffbHml ypOBeHb

* YnpaBeaeHHe HcnoJIb3oBaHHeM H oxpaHa pecypcoB * CaHKUHoIHupoBaHme, npoBeaeHme H ytacTHe B

A1HKNX 2KHBOTHbIX (ToJbKo npOMbICnOBb1C BMAbN) HHBeHTapH3auHH peCypCOB AHKHX )KHBOTHb]X

* YTBepKLeHHe HOPM oTcTpejia * nlpeInoweHme H pacnpocTpaHeHue HOPM oTcTpena

* O6pa6oTKa me)KBeaoMCTBeHHbIX 3anpocoB, cperH rpynn noTpe6HTeaeg

CBH3aHHbIX C pecypcaMu AHKKX )KHBOTHbZX, Ha * PacnpocTpaHeHi4e U nponaaKa JuIueH3HH Ha

4enepaJlbHoM YpOBHe oTcTpenJ

* CoaeAcTBHe B pa3pewIeHHH KOH4)J1HKTOB, * C6op H o6ecnet4eHne CTaTHCTH1eCKHX aaHHbIX

CBS3aHHbIX C Hcnojib3OBaHHeM 3eMenb H * KoHTrpoJb 3a BbinOAHeHHeM HopMaTHBOB oTcTpeiia

nlpHpO,HbiX peCypCoB H 3aKOHOB O aHKHX )KHBOTHbIX, npfBJeIeHHe K

* noaroToBKa H BbURaaqa perioHam JIHLteH3Hr Ha OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH HapyUIHTeAet, c6op wTpa4oB

oTcTpein, a TaKwKe nOArOTOBKa gpyrou * npeacTaBneHHe HHTepeCOB JaenapTaMeHTa

AoKyMeHTaUHH OXOTHH4bHX pecypcOB B perHOHaJbHbIX

me)KBeRoMCTBeHHblX KOMHCCHU X

. OpraHH3aUHn H ynpaBJIeHi4e KOMMep'eCKHMH H

npo4HMH aoroBopaMH o6 apemae OXOTHHIbHX

YrOLHA

HecMOTPM Ha TO, 'ITO MHHHCTePCTBO OXPaHbl oKpy)Kaioweg Cpeabl i npHPOflHbIX

peCYPCOB (MUHnPHPOH4bl) C MOMeHTa CBoerO o6pa3OBaHUI4 B 1988 ro'ay 6brno

peopraHH3OBaHO H OCHOBHaA qaCTb ero 4)yHK.UHA B 1996 roay 6bmia nepexaHa

rocyxLapcTBeHHOMy KOMHTeTy no oxpaHe oKpyKaiollte cpeabi, ero 3aaa4eg no-npe)KHeMy

5sBJnieTCq oxpaHa np4poabi. He HMel o4HLuHajlbHoro MaHaaTa, M4Hnptppoabi npeanptHHJIo

HecKojibKo nOnbITOK nOnytluTb iopHuaHecKHe nOJIHOMOMHH B o6niaCT OXpaHbl fJlOpbl H

4ayHbi. 3aKOHOaaTeibHblr npOeKT, OXBaTbIBaiOWHui BCe aCneKTbI OXpaHbl (bJOpbIlH 4uayHbl

POCCHH, paHee nOarOTOBJAeHHbli MHHnpHpKLO,bl, He 6bm1 yTBepweH COBeToM MUHHCTPOB.

nlapjlaMeHT nOaFOTOBI4JI co6CTBeHHblr BapHaHT 3aKOHoaaTeAbcTBa, HO OH TaKIKe He

yTBepyaeH. no MHeHHIO MHHnpHpo,Abl, cTapoe 3aKOHoaaTeJIbCTBO B o6JiacTH peryjinpOBsaH H

pecypcOB LHKHX )KHBOTHblX npOTHBope4HT nojio)KeHHM HOBOU KOHCTHTYLI4H. 2

2 HOBbiA (DeaepaJAbHbIA 3aKOH "O )4CBOTHOM MHpe" 6blJ nlilHH5T B anpe.ne 1995 r. (rlpiM. pea. PYCCKoro

H321aHHU.)

Page 301: Russian - World Bank Documents

299 nIPJAO)KEHHE H

PoccHifcAaff accoLH,alH o6ziecim OXOMHHKOB Hf pbM6&MIOBOB

PoccHicKaH accouHaulm o6[uecTB OXOTHHKOB H pbi6oAOBOB(PocoxoTpbl6ojloBco0o3), OCHOBaHHaS B 1945 roay, mBJiReTCA cTaperiwle1 H KpynHeriwerHenpaBHTenbCTBeHHOA opraHH3aLuier (Hno) PoccHn. AccouHautim, o6beauHsHioimaq 3 MJTH.'qUeHOB, HMeeT 78 perHOHanJbHbIX oTaeJIeHHf4 BO BCeX cy6lbeKTax POCCHUCKOU (J)eepaUuu(pecny6nuKax, Kpaqx, o6.nacTqx). HeKoTopble perHoHajibHbie o6[uecTBa 6buIH co3IaaHbi 6oneecTa .neT Ha3aa. B BeaeHiH AccouHauHH HaXOaHTC5 250 MJIH. ra 3eMenJb H 4 MJIH. ra BOnHblXpeCypCOB (apeHayeMbIX C UeJIbJ OXOTbl).

OCHOBHbIMH 43yHKuHSiMH AccoUmaumH 5BJInSOTCS ripeacTaBJIeHHe HHTepeCOBCBOHX 'UIeHOB Ha HaLLHOHaJIbHOM U4 perHOHanJbHOM YPOBHAX, noTJaep)KKa MeCTHbIX OTaeJIeHHriH c6blT OXOTHHMbHX H pbi6OJIOBHbIX npHHawJe)KHOCTeri qepe3 perHOHaJIbHbIe oTaeJIeHHM.AccouHaLtuH BHecIia KOHCTpyKTHBHbflU BKjiaa B nOarOTOBKY pOCCHriCKorO 3aKOHoaaTenJbCTBaB o6jiacTH OXOTbl. OHa ycneWHo jio66npoBaZia 3aKOHbl 0 npaBe Ha BJaaeHHe opy)KHeM,npe,IcTaBjslAa Ha paccMoTpeHHe ,aenapTaMeHTa OXOTHHMbMX pecypcoB npoeKTbl 3aKo-Ho,aaTeJIbHbIX H HOpMaTHBHbIX AoKyMeHTOB, OpraHH3OBsaia H ripoBoAnHIa MeXKfyHapOaHbieKoH4jepeHUHH no oxoTe H pbi6oJIOBCTBy (HanpHMep, KOH43epeHUnH no aTJiaHTHL4eCKOMYJIOCOCIO, COBMeCTHO C KaHaaori H CWLA). AccouiauiaA ABJIAieTCS UTIeHOM HeCKOJIbKHXMeK,ayHapoAHbIX OXOTHHUIbHX H pbi6oAOBHbIX opraHH3auHr.

)apyrHe HeripaBHTejbCTBeHHble OpraHI43aUi, CBI3aHHbie C OXOTOU, HMelOTOTHOLwleHHe K apMHH, KOTOPSa rO-npe)KHeMy Bjia,aeeT co6CTBeHHbIMH OXOTHH4bHMHYrOAb$IMH Ha TePpHTOpHH POCCUUCKOU (DeaepaLtu. KaKKe-nH6o aaHHbie o6 3TUX yrOabqXOTcyrCTByIoT. no aaHHbIM L.aenapTaMeHTa OXOTHHUbHX peCypcoB, B POCCuH HaCMUTbIBaeTCq6onee 4 TbIC. OXOTHH'IbHX H pbi6oJIOBHbIX Kny6oB H 500 He3aBHCHMbIX OXOTHHUbHXIPOMbICAOBblX npegnpHiTHrl.

YnpaBJIeHHe pecyWCaMHHKHX XHBOTHbIX Ha perHOHaJbHOM ypOBHe

KpaCHORpCKnH H Xa6apOBCKntri KpaSI 6blJIH Bbi6paHbl B KaMeCTBeperpe3eHTaTHBHbIX parHOHOB CH6HpH H AaabHero BOCTOKa aLT paCCMOTpeHHq COCTOjHHASLaeji Ho ynpasnenHIo pecypcamni AHKHX KHBOTHbIX. B Ta6nnue 14.2 ipeAcTaEBieHbI HeKOTopbIeCTaTHCTHtIeCKHe AaHHbie.

,(eIiapTamemT OXOT/IIHF'HX pCCYJpCOB

KpaCHOApCKnH Kpafl COCTOHT H3 44 par4oHoB. rJiaBHoe ynpaBeneHne aenapTaMeHTaOXOTHHqbHX peCypCOB pacnoioIxeHO B r. KpacHoqpcKe. -eTbipe perHoHa0ibHbIX oTAejieH HKOHTpOJIHpYIOT pa6oTy 44 paiiOHHbIX OTaeneHHA, B WTaTe KOTOpblX COCTOHT 86 erepeui-HHCneKTOpOB. J1onoJIHHTeAbHoe CrpyKTypHoe noapa3geneHHe o6ecneqtiBaeT MaTepHajibHO-TeXHHIeCKOe CHa6)KeHHe qeTbipex perHOHajIbHbIX oTaejieHUHj. OCHOBHbIMH 'IyHKUHiMH Ho65l3aHHOCTHMH erepeu SBJsioTcA o6ecneqeHHe co6AioaeHH4 npHMeHAeMbIX Ha TeppHTOpHHKpai rlpaBHJ OXOTbl H HOpM npHpOaOnOAb3OBaHHRS, a TaioKe yeT 3anacOB aHKHX )KHBOTHbIX,HCnOJb3yeMbIX Ha OCHOBe apeH,abi, H KOHTpOJb 3a OCyWeCTBj1eHHeM OXOTHHMberO npoMbIcAa.ErepA HMieOT npaBO Ha 50% I1wTpa4OB 3a HapyweHuiH ripasnii IpTpHIAOnOAb3OBaHHli, 4TOBAsnieTCR KaK CTHMyJIOM AAh 3aaep4KaHHs HapywHTeAeri, TaK H npSIMbIM nOBOaOM AnSKoppynHuu. KoppynuHA CTaHOBHTCA Cepbe3HOA npo6AeMorl, T.K. pOCT 3apa6OTHOH ruiaTbl,

Page 302: Russian - World Bank Documents

300 nPHROKEHHE H

BblnJia4HBaeMOi HHcneKTopaM, OTCTaeT OT TeMnOB HHAJIqU4H. B 1995 ro,ny 3apnnaTa ereps B

KpaCHORpCKOM Kpae COCTaBanuia 84 TblC. py6. B MecRu, a Mec5'-HaS 3apnnaTa necH141ero

6bma paBHa 300 TbIC. py6. KpaeBou UwTaT aienapTaMeHTa OXOTHHqbI4X pecypcoB TeXHH4eCK14

cna6o OCHaLueH, He HMeeT cpeaCTB Ha coaep)KaHHe TpaHcnopTa, BbLLaLy erepsm roploqero,

CHapSDKeHHS, ()opMeHHO4 oae)K1Rbi H T.L. MopailbHoe COCTOAHHe COTPYJ1HHKOB 3at4acTy1o

HaXOJUHTC5 Ha HH3KOM ypOBHe, y MHOrHX U3 HHX OTCYTCTBYIOT 3HTy3la3M H CTHMYJ1bl K

BbInOJ1HeHH10 rpO4eCCHOHajTbHb[X o6sl3aHHoCTeg.

Ta6airnua H.2. CTaTHcTHqecKHe LaHHbie no KpacHospcKoMy H Xa6apoBcKoMy KpaSM, 1994 r.

Ka7mropum KpCHOJipC1 kpaI X paa XaUCKo# cA

06uias n.noUa.nb KpaA 237 MniH. ra 82 MJH. ra

KoitwiecTBo paIOHOB 52 17

PaccToqHtieC ceBepa Ha lor

3.000 KM 2.000 KM

C BOCTOKa Ha 3anaa 1.300 KM 400 KM

3KOHOMIU Ka (npHOpHTeTHmbe HanpaBneHH l) 3oAoroalo6biBaiotuasl 3onoToao6blBaIoLnal

npOMbiWJWeHHOCTb n pOMblwAeIHiHOCTb

npOH3BOjCTBo OpyX;HA JleCHoe X03flICTBO

JlecHoe X03SIACTBO OxoTa

OxoTa

JlecHoe Xo03ACTBo (KOJIHmeCTBo npeanpHUsTHtU) 3.600 2.700

JlecHble 3eMnH 80 MjiH. ra 48 MnH. ra

nlpoMbic.oBble nieca 52 MJIH. ra HeT aaHHbIx

PacqeTHan AecoceKa 54 Mini. M3 29 MnH. M

3

(4aKTHIeCKHtu o06beM py6oK 8 MJH. M3 6 MJIH. M

3

Korn1'ecTOo iiecHbix no)KapOB 1000 700

3anoBenaHHKH 31,8 MAH. 1,3 MJIH. ra

06wee 'iHcJio OXOTHH4bHX X03RUCTB 105 HeT aaHHbIX

KoJIWeCTBo ereperi-oxoTHNKoB 86 76

HapyweHH., cBi3aHHble C pecypcaMH InuKHX

)KHBOTHbIX 4.500 837

HaceieHNNe, B T.4. 3,03 MJni. 1,5 MAnH.

B ropoyiax 2,19 Mni. 1,2 MJIH.

B CeJlbCKOU MeCTHOCTH 0,84 MJIH. - _ 0,3 MnH.

ICTovHfIfH. KoMHTeTbl flecHoro X03AhicTBa KpacHosipcKoro H Xa6apOBcKorO KpaeB, 1995 r.

YnpaB.ieHHe OXpaHbl RUHK4X )KHBOTHbIX KpaeBoro KOMI4TeTa OXpaHbi npHpOabl

napaiiAenbHo c ,enapTaMeHTOM OXOTHHUbHX pecypCoB ocyLLuecCTBseT KOHTpOJb 3a

np4po,anonAb3oBaHHeM, O.HaKO HOPMbl OTcTpeiia onpeaejliOTCs COBMeCTHO. OTHOCITejIbHO

TeCHb1e CBR3H Cyy.ueCTByIOT MexJy rpynniaMH noTpe6HTeAer4 pecypcoB ,LHKHX )KHBOTHbIX 14

PerHoHanbHblM UeHTPOM perIcTpauHH H nporHO3a COCTOSHH4I OXOTHH4b14X pecypcoB,

KOHCynbTaTHBHoro opraHa aLenapTaMeHTa OXOTHIqbi4X pecypcOB. B ueiioM lenapTaMeHT

OXOTHHUbHX peCypCOB KpacHoAspcKoro Kpaq HeLoCTaTo4HO yKoMniUeKTOBaH KaapaMH, cna6o

OCHalueH o6opyaoBaHNeM H HeaononyqaeT q31HaHCHpOBaHHe. B pe3ylbTaTe 3Toro

Hapy1iHJ4Cb CBI3H Meway rUfaBHb1M ynpaBjieHHem H paiOHaMH.

143 88 COTPYLaHHKOB aeHapTaMeHTa OXOTHH4b1X pecypcoB 12 pa6oTaloT B FnaBHOM

ynpaBneHHH H 76 - B 17 pa4oHHb1X oTJIeneHHAx. B 3aBt4CHMOCTH OT pa3MepOB paiOHa UI

3Ha4eHHH ero npHpOaHbIX pecypcoB ero o6cjiyIcHBaeT OAHH HuIH TPH erep. Hnoulua,b

Page 303: Russian - World Bank Documents

301 HPiJ]OXEHHE H

paoioHB COCTaBAIeT oKoJ!o 87 MJIH. ra. nO CJIOBaM PYKOBOIHTeISi aenapTaMeHTaOXOTHHMbHX pecypcOB, YqHTbIBaS HeXBaTKY TpaHCnOpTHbIX Cpe)ICTB H CHapSDKeHHS, nrIO[uaab,KOHTPOAHupyeMa OaHHM erepeM, He AOJDKHa npeBbIwuaTb 20 TbIC. ra. ,Ejis 3TorO B MacJJITa6axKpa5i Tpe6yeTcq 4300 erepeH, xTO HepeaAbHO B YCJIOBH5X OrpaHHqeHHA 610ioKeTHorO(l4HHaHCHPOBaHHA.

Ha TepppTOmHH Xa6apoBcKoro Kpaq pacnonoceHo 20 3aKa3HHKOB o6ulerinnfoLua4bio 20 MnH. ra, 15 H3 HHX OTHOCATCS K oxpaHAeMbIM TePPHTOPIHRM o6JiaCTHoroYPOBHS H 5 HMeIOT 4beaepanbHblri CTaTyc. B 3aKa3HHKaX 3anpeLueHa oxoTa, HO pa3peweHapy6Ka nieca. Py6KH aonycKalOTCA B TOM cJyMae, ecniH OHH He OKa3blBalOT oTp4uaTeJ]bHoroBO3,eriCTBHA Ha nOHYIMALHH npOMbICJIOBbX )KHBOTHbIX, HO B peanjbHOCTH npaBHjia py6oK HHOpMbI IieCHOrO XO3HqACTBa HOBCeMeCTHO HapywllalOTCS B CBS3H C OTCYTCTBHeM LOn)KHOrOKOHTPOflq. )le$lTeAbHOCTb 20 3aKa3HHKOB KOHTPOAHupyeTCS UlTaToM H3 21 COTpyRHKKa 14(bHHaHCHpyeTCA H3 CpeaCTB TePPHTOPHanbHoro doHaa. (DOHa 43opMHpyeTCS H3 AOXO,OB OTfpO)IaXH OXOTHI4MbHX jIHueH3Hil, wTpafoB 3a HapyweHIHR npaBHji HOJIb3OBaH4H pecypcamu1aHKHX 4HBOTHbIX H ao6poBonbHbTx BKnaIOB. B 1994 rojy cpeaCTBa bOHra cocTaBJIqlnH 400MnH. py6., H3 HHX 120 MJIH. py6. 6buio nepeqHcjieHO B patOHbI Ha iTpHppoaooxpaHHbie LtenH,a 180 MnH. py6. 6buO H3pacXOaOBaHO Ha nOKpblTeT 3KcnjiyaTaUOHHbIX H3,RepK(eK rJaBHoroyripaBAeHHA H 3aKa3HHKOB. )IenapTaMeHT OXOTHHMbHX peCYPCOB B Xa6apOBCKOM KpaeHCnbITbIBaeT Te )Ke TPY,4HOCTH, 'TO H B KpaCHOApCKOM. KoMHTeTbI 6blBeero MUHHnpKpOabl BKpasx aeACTByIOT riapai1eJlbHO c )aenapTaMeHTaMH OXOTHHqbHX peCypCOB, ripH4eM CTeneHbHX B3aHMOaerUCTBHq B Xa6apoBcKoM Kpae HHxe, 'eM B KpaCHOApCKOM Kpae. CTOJlb xeCAa6bi CBA3H B Xa6apoBcKe C Hay'Ho-HccAeaoBaTeJ]bcKHM HHCTHTyTOM oxpaHbi npl4pOabi,KOTOpblU npeaocTaBJIseT HayqHbIe aaHHbIe AAS pa3pa6OTKH HOPM OTCTpeJIa.OaHaKO, HeCMOTpA Ha BCe TpyAHOCTH, ypOBeHb o6pa3OBaHHs ynpaBJIeH'eCKoroCOCTaBa H erepei4-HHcneKTopoB AOCTaTOqHO BbICOK. PYKOBOALu[He LOJDKHOCTH 3aHMlalOTnpo4)eccHoHajlbI, HMeioiaHe YHHBepcHTeTcKoe o6pa3oBaHme B o6flacTH 6HoAorHI HunHCXO,aHbJX cneUHanH3auHi HJuH u aHnIJOMbI OAHoro H3 4ByX yqe6HbIx 3aBeaeHH4i POCCHH,o6ecne'uBaiouXHx o6pa3oBaHHe B c4Pepe ynpaEuBeHHR OXOTHHqbHMH pecypcaMH. 9TH By3bl,pacnOJIO)KeHHbie B ropoaax KHpoBe H IlpKyrcKe, exceroIIHo BbInYCKa1OT oKojio 50cneUHajiHCTOB. noaroToBKa ereperu H apyrHx cneLtHaHAHCTOB B OCHOBHOM ocyWeCTBJIeTCS BABYX TexHHKyMaX, paCnOJ1OxeHHbIX B ropoaax IIpKyrCKe U H aYiawHxe, eceroaHo BblnyC-KaIou.Hx OKOAo 30 cneLLHBaHCTOB. HeKoTopble erepq ABJIASOTCH 6blBUIHMH rIpo4ecc4o-HanJbHbIMH OXOTHHKaMH.

YveT, KB07W, 07oIPc H 6paKoImepcmo

Y'ieT npOMb1CJ1OBb1X BH4AOB 4HBOTHbIX H rTHUU HaXOaHTCS B BeaeHI4H3aKOHo,aTenlbHbIX OpraHOB, HMeioutHx 0opHaHqeCKHe ripaBa Ha HCHOJIb3OBaHHe H c6blTnpOMbICflOBbIX BH)OB Ha ycTaHoBMeHHOii TePPHTOPHH OXOTHH4bHX X03AriCTB. Y4eTKOHKpeTHbIX BHUOB X(HBOTHbIX BeAeTCA B COOTBeTCTBHH C MeTOAaMH H rTpaBHAaMH,pa3pa6OTaHHbiMH LIeHTpaBjbHOH HayqHo-HccJ1eaOBaTeAbCKOu ua6opaTopHek OXOTHHxibe roX03Ar4CTBa H 3anOBeAHHKOB.

POCCHA HMeeT YHHKaIbHYIO Tpaa,HUHOHHyIO CHCTeMy yqeTa 3ariacos LHKHX)KHBOTHbIX, o6,beC4HHAIOIUyIO BCe 3aHHTepecoBaHHbie CTOpOHbl B TpeXCTyneHtaTOM npouecce.npH cTapori cHcTeMe KOHTPOJIb 3a BeaeHHeM y'eTa ocyweCTBJIqjiH ereps H HayqHbieCOTpy,aHHKH perHOHaBJbHbIX oTae1CeHHri AenapTaMeHTa OXOTHH'JbHX peCypCOB. B KaA)KoM

Page 304: Russian - World Bank Documents

302 nPHJIO)KEHJE 11

perHOHe CylueCTBOBaii CO6CTBeHHblfi He3wBHCHMbik HHCTHTyT, KOTOpblI BeeX HayLHbIe

pa3pa6oTKH, co6Hpani cTaTHCTHqecKHe alaHHble 0 3anacax npOMblCJIOBbIX BH2OB H HPOBOAHJ

exKero,aHbil yqeT H HayqHbIe HCccJIeAoBaHHq, Heo6xoai4Mbie Ansi onpeaeiTeHtiq HOpM oTCTpeiia

KOHKpeTHbIX BH1OB )KHBOTHbIX. KBOTbI OTcTpeJla Ha paHOHHOM YPOBHe OnlpeaeJlqIUHCb Ha

OCHOBe o6'beaHHeHHbIX pe3yJlbTaTOB TpeXCTyneHqaToro yqeTa U HCCnieaoBaHHrU. EAHHCT-

BeHHbIM HeAOCTaiowHM 3BeHOM B CHCTeMe 6bUlH 6HoUH3HMecKUe KapTbI MeCT o6HTaHHS

AHKHX )KHBOTHbIX, HeO6xOaHMbIe Am OueHKH nOTeHUHaaTa 6HoJIorHqecKoro pa3Hoo6pa3HR

KaAcAOA cpeabI o6HTaHHR.

B pe3ylbTaTe npHBaTH3aUHH H u ApyrHX H3MeHeHH A HaPYIUHJiaCb BCS

BCnOMOraTejibHaR cTpyKTypa ynpaBjieHHR peCypCaMH IHKHX UKHBOTHbiX. Hpexne xopoino

OpraHH3OBaHHbie npOMbICJIOBbIe npeAnPHSTHS, rOCYNapCTBeHHbie KoonepaTHBbl, 3BepOBOL-

'lecKHe DepmbI H opraHbl perynupoBaHus nPOMbICAOBblX pecypcoB JIH6o npeKpaTHuiH CBOIO

,aeHTeAbHoCTb, JIH6o 0CTanjHcb 6e3 pyKoBoAcTBa. MHorHe KBajiH4HuHupOBaHHbie H OnbITHbie

CnleUHaJIHCTbI nOTepq5IH pa6oTy. YCJIOBHS HOBOR CHcTeMbI n1O3BOJIqSOT 'aCTHbIM JHliUaM,

Kny6aM HJIH rpynnam 6paTb B apeHAy OXOTHHqbH yrOAbq C UeJiblO 3KCniiyaTaUHH lpOMbiC-

JIOBbIX peCypCOB. npu OTCYTCTBHH cTpororo KOHTPOJI1 H HaieC)KxaUHX PYKOBONiuHX

yKa3aHHi 3TO C03flaeT HzeaAbHbie yCJIOBHq AJS 3JioyHoTpe6JieHHik H KOppyrllHhH.

PelyimpoBaHle OXOThI H cTahTcvecKHe,4aHHwme

,LenapTaMeHTbl OXOTHHUbHX pecypcoB KpaCHoqpcKorO H Xa6apoBcKoro KpaeB

H3,aaloT e)KeroAHbie cnpaBO'IHHKH no OXOTe, B KOTOpbIX npeAcTaBJieHbI o6u[He CBseeHHA 0

npaBOBbIX acneKTax OXOTbl, HCHOJb3OBaHHH Co6aK H COKOJIHHOHi OXOTbI, npo0OJDKHTeAJbHOCT4

ce3OHOB OXOTbl ,ALJIH KOHKpeTHbIX BHOB 3Bepe H nITHL, JIHMHTaX Ha ao6biMy, BpeAHbIX

BH41ax, a TaK*oe HaKa3aHH5IX H LTpafax. CjieAyeT OTMCTHTb HopMaTHBbi, KacaiowuHecA

npoMblCJIOBO JIOBJIH neBsqHx nTHU (KoTopas no-npe)KHeMy ocTaeTcS 3aKOHHOA), npaBa

OXOTbl Ha HHbie BU,Dbl )KHBOTHbIX C ueLJblO Ao6bwH cpeACTB K CyLueCTBOBaHHI0 BO BpeMS

pa6oTbl B niecy, npaBa KopeHHbIX HaPOAOB Ha BeAeHHe TpaUHLIHOHHbIX npoMbICJIOB (OXOTa C

uenjblO Ao6bl4H CpeACTB K cyiIeCTBoBaHHIO) H npaBa Ha c6bIT npoMblcJ1OBo0U npoAYKUHH.

KOHKpeTHbie BHlbi npoMbICJIOBofl npOaYKUHH, pa3peweHHofi ,ALJIq C6blTa, BKJlIOqaiOT MICO,

Mex, pora MOJIObIX H B3pOCJblX ojieHe4, apomaTuecKHe)KeJie3bl, )KeniHbie ny3bipH, a TaKxKe

neB'-Hx nTHU. Bce BHAbl, He BKJlOqeHHbIe B CHCTeMy HOpMHPOBaHHI npOMbICJiOBbIX BHUOB,

MOrYT OTCTpeJIHBaTbCH CBo6OAHo, ecniH ripasBHJaMH OXOTbI He npeaycMaTpHBalOTcg KaK4e-

jiH6 orpaHHqeHuiqX Ao6bl44.

HopMbi OTCTpeJIa, B 3aBHCHMOCTH OT BHfa, COCTaBJiqlOT 10-20% 'qHcjieHHOCTH

nonyjSIiUHH. KBOTbl 1An Ka)K0oro patiOHa no BCeM BHJaM, no0L1e)KaLuHM y4eTy, KBOTbI,

paCCMHTbIBalOTCR HayqHO-HCCJ1eaoBaTefIbCKHMH HHCTHTYTaMH H HarlpasBsAIOTC51 Ha

o6cyxAeHHe B perlHOHaAbHbie oT.eJIeHH JenapTaMeHTa OXOTHI4bHX peCypCOB. 3aTeM KBOTbI

KoppeKTHPYlOTCH H HanpaBASHOTCq Ha paCCMoTpeHHe roCKoM3KoJIorHH B MOCKBe. ,aanee

yTBepAeHHbie KBOTbl qepe3 perloHanbHbIe ynpaBJeHH5 OXOTHHMbHX pecypcoB CnyCKalOTCq

Ao par4OHHoro YPOBH5I H OBOLSTCH AO CBeAeHH5 apeHILaTopOB. 3To KpaHHe

6iopoKpaTH4ecKHu npouecc.

PeweHHe o Bbi1e1jeHHH KBOT npUHHHMaeTCq Ha YPOBHe parUOHHOR aDMUHHiCTpaUHH.

nO AaHHbIM Xa6apoBcKoR accouHauHH OXOTHU4KOB H pbi6oflOBOB, 6onblwas '4aCTb KBOT

BbiLeJSieTC XIAS MeCTHbIX OXOTHHKOB, U TOJIbKO HeKoTopa0 i IaCTb JIHUeH3HI npoaaeTcs

Page 305: Russian - World Bank Documents

303 nPHJIO)KEHHE H1

Me)LAyHapoIHbIM CnOpTCMeHaM-OXOTHHKaM. He cywecTByeT HHKaKHX o iw4uHarbHbIX HpaBnHJBbiAeAeHH51 KBOT, 'ITO OTKpblBaeT B03MOXCHOCTH AAI aJoynoTpe6ieHHi.

B Ta6niHue 11.3 npeaCTaBJeHbl aaHHbie o6 oTcTpefie npOMb1CJIOBbIX BHLOBIKUBOTHbIX B KpacHo0lpcKoM Kpae B COOTBeTCTBHH C BbwejieHHb[MH KBOTaM4.npeAnonaraeMbie aaHHbie o6 oTcTpeJTe BKJ1oIalOT H He3aKOHHbIi npoMbicen. b)paKoHbepCTBoB OCHOBHOM cOBepwuaeTCs C ueJblO ao6b1qH CpeaCTB CyLueCTBOBaHUI4 (no aaHHbIMKpaCHOspCKOrO aenapTameHTa OXOTHHqbHX peCypCoB), KpOMe TeX cAy'aeB, Kor,a peCb HUeTo TaKHx ujeHHbIX BHlax, KaK co6OJb, Ka6apra, 6ypbi MeenBeab H 6o6p. n03TOMY Heo6xoT4HMonpHHAITb CpO4Hbie Mepbl nO 3aLuHTe 3THX BH4IOB )KUBOTHbIX. CTaTHCTH'IeCKHe JaaHHbie noXa6apoBcKoMy Kpaio 3a 1994 rog noKa3blBalOT, xITO BbICOKUU YpOBeHb 6paKOHbepCTBa, BxiaCTHOCTH He3aKoHHbl4 OTCTTpei Ka6aprH H MeABegq, BCKOpe MO)KeT HOCTaBHTb HOa yrpo3yCOCTOAHHe nonyJSiui4r ,IBYX 3THX BHAOB (CM. Ta6JiHUe A.4).

Ta6imiHla H.3. OTcT'peii lpOMbICJIOBblX BIHAOB 24(HBOTHblX B KpaCHOApCKOM Kpae

B_____a_____ 1991 r. 1992 r. 1993 r. 1994 r.

PawesreHNS 0srgaMbHue afHMMC, (BKf. 6pa-KB aiaHHAfC KOHbCpCTbO)

Iocib 2.143 2.360 1.255 3.500 1.091 4.000b5iaroponHbig oj1eHb 404 332 375 800 362 1.000Kocynn 511 753 1.200 2.000 1.132 10.000CeBepHbIi oneHb 41.503 63.102 251 1.000 183 500Ka6apra 85 70 91 oxpameTcq 0 2.000Ka6aH 36 63 60 400 72 240Eypbl MeflBeab 61 152 130 500 75 300Co6oJlb 48.282 34.865 22.504 63.960 16.072 50.000So6p D 189 _ _121 _ _53 __258 __ 54__ 2.000HcToHHmK: aenapTaMeHT OXOTHm4qbHX pecypcoB KpaCH0opCKorO KpaR H KpacHoqpcKHAi HH14 OXpaHbw npuppoabl.

CTaTHCTHqeCKHe aaHHbie o MeCTHOA pbIHO4HOPi CTOHMOCTH npOMbiCJIOBbIX)KHBOTHbIX nOKa3bIBaIoT, 'qTO KOrlb1THble )KHBOTHbie B OCHOBHOM OTCTpeJ1HBalOTC51 H3-3a M5iCa(3a HcKJi0o'eHHeM HeKOTOpbIX BHLOB C LteHHb[MH naHTaMH H Ka6aprH u3-3a apoMaTH'eCK4XKeJie3), a nyWHbie 3Bepu - H3-3a mexa (3a HcKnioqeHHeM 6yporo MeaBeaq, y KOTOporoLIeHHOCTb npeAcTaBJISleT KeJIEiHbifl Hy3blpb, H 6o6pa H3-3a MycKyca). B 1994 rogy BKpacHoRpCKoM Kpae CyMMapHaA CTOHMOCTb npOMbICJJOBbIX )KHBOTHbIX Ha 'IepHOM PbIHKeoijeHHBaBJaCb npH6JIH3HTeJIbHo B 28 Mnpa. py6.; peanbHas pbIHO'HaS CTOUMOCTb MO)KeT 6blTb3Ha,UHTeCJbHO Bbile.

O'eHb TpyRHo aaTb TO0IHY1O 3KOHOMHqecKyIo oueHKY CTOUMOCTU npoMbICJiOBbJXXKHBOTHb1X B CH6upu H Ha AanbHeM BOCTOKe. OKOJIO 90% MeXOB B 6blBweM COBeTCKOMCoIo3e ao6blBaYiocb B 3TUX aByX perHoHax. HocAe pacnaaa 6biBmero CoBeTcKoro CoI03aHc'Ie3IH OCHOBHbie noTpe6HTeJuI npOMbIcOBbEX XKHBOTHb1X. OJIbUwaSI qaCTb dU4KUX XK4BOT-HbIX OTCTpeJIHBaeTCSI He3aKOHHO, 'aCTO BO MHOrO pa3 npeBbwLUaA pa3pewJeHHbie KBOTbl.HeCOMHeHHO, 'ITO Ha aaHHOM 3Tare pa3BHTHA1 pbIHO'HOr4 3KOHOMHKU OXOTa SiBJI51eTC5AHCTO'HHKOM CpelCTB K CyLueCTBOBaHH1O A,AJAS MHOriHX 1Oieoe B PoccH4. B ceJ1bCKOr4MeCTHOCTH MSACO llpOMbICJIOBbIX )KHBOTHbIX H pbi6 SlBJIqeTCA OCHOBHbIM npOLayKTOM nHTaHHlR14 HMeeT Ba)KHeur4wee 3HaqeHH4 2nR BbDKHBaH14SA HaceJIeHHS. CneaoBaTeJlbHo, Heo6xo414MoALOJA)KHbIM o6pa3oM o6'bea4HHTb H CKOOPLIHHHPOBaTb yripaBjieHHe peCypCaMH ,llKUX)KHBOTHbIX C yHpaBjieHHeM JIeCHb1MH peCypCaMH.

Page 306: Russian - World Bank Documents

304 nPHAJO)KEHHE H

PemoHaJrbHlme HaYqHO-HfCCJC4OBaTCJIbCKKHI HHCIHYTMU OXPaH, Hp7po,aru

,ao 1994 roaa HaYHbie HccjieAoBaHKsq B o6AaCTH ynpaBneHHU pecypcamH

lpOMbICJIOBbIX )KHBOTHbIX B POCCHH B OCHOBHOM flpOBOAHJliCb BH1414 OXOTHHqbero

XO35IiSCTBa H 3BepOBO.CTBa, pacnojiaraBWU4MCs B r. KHpOBe H HMeBWIIM OTAleAeHHUs BO BCeX

3KOHOMH'eCKHX per4OHax. HanpHMep, B BeAeHlH KpaCHOqpCKOrO OT4eJAeHH4 HaXOaHJIC,9

KpaCHOApCKu1u Kpag, a Xa6apoBcKoe oTaeJIeHHe KYpHpOBaJIo Xa6apoBcKIu H HIPHMOPCKHrU

KpaSI, a TaioKe CaxaniHHCKyIO H AMypcKyio o6iiacTH. locAe 1994 roaa BHH1403 6bmn

nepe,aaH B BeaeHHe POCCHUCKOU aKaIeMHH CeJlbCKOXO3R[iCTBeHHbIX HaYK (PACXH). KaxbiU

Ta6nuHia 14.4. O7cTpeni lPOMbICJIOBbDC BHAOB KHBOTHblX B Xa6apoBCKoM Kpae (1994 r.)

Biwi a aHHMe O pa3Mepie Hf oxpMpmpaaMonyAOrl faHHwe no L(eHa

Pa3paceH- 0 7.peI MLICH3HWf CyMMa-

,2enapTa- HHH Hag KBa arenapmMmeH- fpcu,afa- SipaKoHb- OrM'pe P.HM

MCHT OXpaHM O7prCNa ra OXOT. ireMa cpcmo (% OaHom ,gox4a

OXOTH. HpapoW pecypcoB OllCHKa oaeH) xmBor- (MJH.

pecypcOB HOIro py6.)(PJi-)

JIOCb 25.200 17.444 1.700 900 1.007 100 41.000 82.574

6iJaropo,aHbIibIojieHb 95.000 9.500 700 350 373 120 30.750 25.233

CeaepHbir ojleHb 14.800 14.867 1.500 140 134 20 20.500 3.296

Kocynsi 7.600 7.589 400 350 oxpaHAeTcI 20.500

Ka6apra 18.000 18.051 1.000 160 115 500 14.350 9.901

Ka6aH 4.300 4.372 500 320 109 20 28.700 3.753

Co6oimb 110.000 107.500 35.000 23.000 21.856 50 2.050 67.207

Bbmpa 3.800 3.847 250 70 65 100 1.230 1.599

Bypbi1i MeaBeCb 4.500 4.530 550 156 156 150 41.000 82.574

Pblcb - HeT XaHHbIX - - 5 1000 - -

PocoMaxa - HeT AaHHbIX - - 27 HeT liaHHbIx - -

Kyi*rua - 23.108 - - 6.454 40 - -

HopKa -15.658 - -1.416 90 --EHOTOBHAHaSq - 2.989 - - 664 50 - -

co6aKa JlHcuiua - 2.079 - - 56 100

BOJIK - 1.283 - - 30 HeT aaHHb[x - -

neKaH - 11.664 - - 483 HCTaaHHbIX - -

BeJlKa -200.000 - -51.800 30 --OHiaTpa - 11.885 - - 7.745 40 - -

3asru - 32.324 - - 2.764 HeT aaHHb[x -

Pai6'HK - 207.000 - - T eaaHHbIX HeT aHKbix - -

CHeiwHbig 6apaH 2.000 - - - 24 HeT aHHbIX - -

dcToqHifKgf: .enapTaMeHT oXoTHUIYbUX peCypCOB Xa6apo8cKoro Kpaa ii Xa6apoBcKHII H4HU OXPaHbi nptppoabi.

HHCTHTYT MOr CTaTb 4aCTb1O HOBOU CTpyKTypbl HAu OCTaTbcsi He3aBHcHMbiM. KpaCHOqpCKHir

HHCT4TYT Bbi6paJi He3aBHCHMbli CTaTYC H Tenepb Ha3blBaeTCq PerHOHa.ibHbiM iLeHTPOM

perHCTpaUHH H npOrHO3a COCTOSIHHq OXOTHUYbHX peCypCOB. Xa6apOBCKMA 4HCTHTYT

npe,anoMen OCTaTbC51 no,n 3FH21or POCCHUCKOg aKa,eeMHH CeeJbCKOX03SIr4CTBeHHbIX HayK,

Ha,ze.Cb Ha jiyqwee o6ecneqeHHe 6ioX,KeTHb1M4 CpeIICTBaMH (10% 61ogKeTa HHCTHTyTa

Bbiaeji5IeTC5I AKa,aeMHeg). B HaCTOiuXee BpMem UHCTHTYT Ha3bIBaeTCq HM114 OXPaHbi nPHPOabi

H 3BepOBO0ICTBa (,gnq KpaTKOCTH, H1414 OXPaHbl npHPOabl ,IZajbHerO BoCTOKa).

Page 307: Russian - World Bank Documents

305 HPPIO)KEHHE 1

OCHOBHOU o6Al3aHHOCTbIO Hay4HO-HcciTeaoBaTeJ]bcKHx HHCT4TyTOB 6bu1 c6op.LaHHbIX 0 COCTORH4HU noHyJTuHm ipOMblCJIOBbIX )KHBOTHbIX, peaIKHX H Hc4e3aioUHX BHIAOB,nepenJeTHbiX nTHU H cpea o66HTaHHSlA Al4KHX )KHBOTHbIX. C6op aaHHbiX HpOBOAiHJICq noKOHKpeTHbIM BHaaM, a He no cpejam o66HTaHH4. 143y'eHHe BH4,aOB )KI4BOTHbIX, HeOTHOC1ULHXCH K HpOMbICJIOBbIM, IPOBOaHJIOCb no mepe Heo6xoaHMoCTH. np4H CTaporlCHCTeMe HHCTHTYTbI HOJIy'aJIH aOCTaToqHoC (bHHaHCHPOBaHHe H e)KeroaHro HPOBOAHJIHMacUITa6HbiH roacCeT qHCjieHHOCTH KpynHbIX MnIeKonHTaIou.Hx, BOaOnjiaBaioLUHx nHTHU Hy'eT cpea o6HTaHHM C HCnOJ1b3OBaHHeM aBHiaLHOHHOR TeXHHKH. KpoMe TOrO, npOBOAlHJI1HCbnoneBbIe HCCJIeIOBaHHS, HanpasBjeHHbie Ha onpeaejieHHe BHAOCneCuLHqHeCKOH CTpyKTypb1nonyjisU4H (Bo3paCTHoe pacnpeaejieHHe, qHcJIeHHoe COOTHOweiHHe HOJIOB, pO)aaeMOCTb,penpo,yKTHBHoe roBeaeHHe, cMepTHOCTb H npoqHe aHajiorHqHbie aaHHbIe). noAyqeHHaqHH4bOpMaLluS1 HCHOJ1b3OBaJnacb npH oTpeaeJieHHH KBOT Ha OTCTpeJi, JIHMHTOB ao6bIl4 HCpOKOB OXOTHHqberO ce3oHa. BoOabWylo qaCTb aaHHb[X OT6HpaJIH WHTaTHb1C COTPYaHHKHHHCTHTyTa, aonOoJHHTeJIbHbie 6HoflorH4ecKIe o6pa3Ubl H japyryIo HHMopMaLuHonpe,aoCTasBiALuH npo4ecCHoHajibHble OXOTHUKH H npo'iHe nOTpe6HTeJIH npOMbICJ1OBbIXpeCypCoB.

HaqHHaM C 1994 roaa pa6oTa HHCTHTyTOB 6bIJIa npaKTH'ecKCH rapa.TJ43OBaHa BCBS3H C pe3KHM coKpaLLeHHeM rocyaapcTBeHHoro qjIHHaHCHPOBaHHM (ao 90% BKpacHofpcKoM H Xa6apOBCKOM 4HCTHTyTaX) H OTTOKOM cieiLtHaYiCToB. IIHCTHTyTbiBblHyxWeHbl HCKaTb co6cTBeHHbIe HCTOYHUKH 4kHHaHCHPOBaHHsl H B 6oAbwoH CTe eHH3aBHCeTb OT CpeaCTB, BbiaJeIeCMb1X TeppHTOpHaJIbHbIMH KOMHTeTaMH 6blBlerO MHHllpHpOablH KOMHTeTaMH Ho 3KojiorHH nHpH aAMHHHcTpa1LHqX KpacHoApcKoro H Xa6apoBcKoro KpaeB.OHH TaK)4e nonyqaloT HeKOTOpble cpeaCTBa OT pefHOHaJlbHbIX ,aeHapTaMeHTOB OXOTHH4bHXpecypcoB no aOrOBOpaM Ha onpeaejieHHe exKerogHbix KBOT Ha OTCTpeJh aHKHX )KHBOTHbIX.(DaKTH4eCKH HHCTHTyrbi yTpaTlJ1H He3aBHCHMOCTb H HaXOWITCA BO BJilaCTH )apyrHXopraHH3auHi4 C TIpyFHM HanpasBjeHHeM eSTejibHOCTH.

Co3jaaBweecsi noHo)KeHHe TOYHO oxapaKTepH3OBanj pyKOBOalHTeJIb KpacHoApcKoroHay4HO-HccAe,aoBaTeJIbcKorO 4HCTHTyTa, KOTOpblU, B '4aCTHOCTH, CKa3ax:

"MaccHB BbiCOKOKaeCCTBeHHbiX 3KoJIorFHecKHx H 6Ho.florHecKHxaxHHbiX OBCeX BH/J'aX 17pOMbICAlOBbIX BOTHbIX, a TaKXe peaKHX H HCVe3I0I1(HX BH1a8XxKHBOTHbiX KpacHogpcKoro KpaH, CHCTeMaTHieCKH oT6HpaeMbMx B TeqeHHeILWTHa,al8TH JCeT a7BdaI(dTbhO KBa3ffAH0HIHpOBaHHbIMH H 017,bITHbLIMH C17eIHa-J!HcTaMH, HaxoaTcTC nlo, yrpo3of B CBH3H C HeXBaTKOg CpeaCTB H paCF!alOMBCflOMOraTeClbHOHI CTpyKTypbi. HenpepbIBHocm RoTOKa IaaHHbiX He 6yweTo6ecfeqeHa. B HacTo0IWCee BpeMH HccJeaoBaHmH coCpeaoTo0eHbi Ha 3eMJJJ?x,i7pe,aHa3HaqeHHbiX a1ff cAaaY B apegay, a 6o6flbwaH IacTb apyrHx paRoHoBoCTeTCJ7 6e3 BHHMaHmHu H3-3a OTCyTCTBHHI CpCeaCTB. OCHOBHaf/ qaCTbCOTpy,aHHKOB HHCThyTT cegqiac pa60TmeT B LuTaTe KpacHogpcKoro yHHBep-cHTeTa, owHoBpeMeHHo BbiJm7OHH zA MeTHoro JeniapTaMeHTa OXOTHHl bHXpecypcoB BaKHeHLuHCe HCCICeaOBaHhffh H yYCT peCypCOB a'HKHX xKHBOTHbiX HaJOrMBOpHOO OCHOBC e.

KpaCHOHpCKHA HuH OXpaHbl HpHpOnbl B CBOeri aeqTejibHOCTH BCe 60JIbwe noJlaraeTCs HaAaHHbie BOlpOCHUKOB, 3arHOJ1HAeMbiX apeHaaTOpam4 3eMeJTb, Ha TeppHTOPHH KOTOPbIXHaXOJUTCH 60JlbWUHCTBO OXOTHHYbHX yrOAHii. HeT CpeaCTB TAn ripOBepKH T014HOCTHnlpe,aOCTaBJMReMOH HH4OpMaUHH. YqeT HenpOMbICJIOBbIX BHAOB )KHBOTHbIX, KOTOpblHi Bceria

Page 308: Russian - World Bank Documents

306 HPHAIOKEHME 14

6buI meHee npHOpHTeTHb1M HanpaBCeHHeM, B KpaCHOqpCKOM Kpae nlpaKTH4eCKH He BeaeTCs,

3a HCKJIO'oeHHeM HeKOTOpb1X BHXaOB pa6oT no nepenieTHblM nTHuaM.

Xa6apoBcKHi H141i OXpaHbi npHPORbI HaXOagHTC5 B HeCKOJIbKO JlyIU1eM

nojio)KeHH4. fOCTOqHHblA WTaT COTPYAHHKOB BKJllO4aeT LueCTb HayqHbIX COTPYAHHKOB, TpeX

na6opaHToB H weCTb Hay4HbIx accHCTeHTOB (ao 1992 r. B WllTaTe COCTOIJIO 25 CoTpyAH14KoB).

B 1994 roay 6ioAxeT HHCTHTyTa COCTaBnqJI 64 MnH. py6., 13 HHX 29 MJIH. py6. 6buIo

H3pacXO,gOBaHO Ha BbIniiaTy 3apa6oTHoA fnaTbi. ToAbKo 6 MAH. py6. 6buIo BbUaenJeHO

PocCHUUCKoU aKaaeMHef CeAbCKOX0351iCTBeHHbIX HayK. 143-3a 610AKxeTHblX orpaHI4eHHUU

HHCTHTyT 6bm BblHy)KaeH 3aKpbITb 6oJIbuylo 4aCTb nolesBbIX CTaHLHR U4 pe3KO COKpaTHTb

o&beM noJIeBbIX pa6oT. B HacToRiulee BpeMq aeeTeJIbHOCTb H 1414 HanpaBAeHa Ha KOHTpOJIb

nonyJISIUHI npOMbICJIOBbIX BHIOB )KHBOTHblX, 3KoJIOr'HMeCKyiO OueHKy OXOTHH'bHX peCypCOB,

pa3pa6oTKy CneHLHaJlbHbIX HCCJIieOBaTeJIbCKHX HpOeKTOB B npHpOaHbIX 3anOBeaHIKaX H

HaRuOHaJlbHbiX napKax, pa3pa6oTKy npaBHJI OXOTbl, KOHTpOJlb H OUCHKY 3KOHOMHKH

npOH3BO,aCTBa HeApeBeCHbIX BH,40B .JeCHOr npOaYKUH4 H O1eHKY Bo3,aerlCTBH51 Ha

oKpy)KaiOlwyilO cpeay. I4HCT4TYT TaioKe pa3pa6aTblBaeT TeXHH'eCKHe pyKOBOACTBa H KpHTepHH

,i1q5 yqeTa npOMblCJIOBblX BHIOB )KHBOTHbIX, ocyweCTBJqiemoro C HCnOJlb3oBaHHeM OrpOCHb1X

JIHCTOB iAS apeHaaTopoB OXOTHHbHX yronHuu.

COTPYAHHKK HHCTHTyTa iM1eOT TeCHbie CB53H C TaKHMH MCe)KyHapOaHbIM4

OpraHH3aLLH5lMH, KaK BceMHpHbli (DOHA IHKOR npHpoabi (npoeKT rio 3aLuiHTe THrpa, pa6oTa

Ha oXpaHSeMbIX TeppHTOpHAX) H (DOHa XoMoKepa. B HacTosqiee BpeM5 rIpu MeXKIyHapOaHori

noAaep)KKe ocyWeCTBji5eTCA pa6oTa no coxpaHeHI4o peAKHx u4 HcMe3aluOLLU4x BH4LOB, a TaioKe

onpeneneHHIO 3KOCHCTeM, Hy)KaaiOlUHXCA B oco60u4 oxpaHe. I4HCTHTyToM TaK)Ke pa3pa6oTaHa

BbICOKOKaMeCTBeHHaS reorpajM4HecKas 4HHOpMoaUHOHHaS CHCTeMa (FMC), iTpHMeHReMaS

npH paciCuIpeHP41 oxpaHAeMbIX TeppHTopH14i, AJ1 onpe,aeneH4l rpaHuU cpeR o6HTaHHI4

Hc'4e3aioLUHX BH1OB, TaKHX, HanpIMep, KaK yCCypHi'ICKHf THrp, U XIA KOHTpOJ11

pauHOHanbHOrO HcnOAb3OBaHH5 fplHPOHbIX pecypcoB KpaA.

CoIo3 3BCPOBOaCTBM H OX077fYb} KOOI7CepTIBMB

nIpH paHee aehCTBy1OLuer4 CHCTeMe npOMblCJIOBa5 aeATeAbHOCTb, CB5I3aHHa5 CO

3BepoBoJXCTBoM, OTJOBOM )KHBOTHbIX H OXOTOU, HaXOJi4iiaCb B BeAeHHH Iaj1bHeBOCTo4Horo

oTj1enleHH5 C0103a 3BePOBOJCTBa H OXOTbl (UeHTpoc0o03). CnieLuaJmbHblfi oTxaen lJeHTpoCo1o3a

3aHHMamiC y'eTOM npoMbICJoBbIX )KHBOTHbIX, KOTOpbliU npOBO,lJcSq Ka)Kable 10 nieT

3KcneAuHLIHMMu, o6bI'HO BKJHoqaioLLHMH cneUHajIHCTa no 3Ko0jorHH AlHKX )KHBOTHbIX,

npobeccCHOHaj1bHoro OXOTHHKa H nOMOLUHHKa. CHCTeMa yqeTa OXBaTbIBaiJa KOHTpOJ1bHbIe

yMaCTKH nJIOWBaabIO OT 1.000 ao 2.000 ra C nOCTOSIHHbiMH npoaoAbHbIMH MapwpyTaMH.

MapWpyTbl y'eTa qtiCJieHHOCTH AHKHX )KHBOTHbIX '4aCTo CoBHaaanJu C mapwpyTamt

HHBeHTapH3aULHH J1eCHbIX peCypCOB, KOTOpa51 TaloKe npoBoaHIiacb Ha OCHOBe ,eC5ITHJIeTHHX

UHKYIOB.

,a,aHHbie y'IeTa Hcnojib3OBsaAICb B KaqeCTBe OCHOBbI XI51 pa3pa6OTKH reHepajibHbIX

nniaHOB ynpaBJeHHA pecypcamH aHKHX AKMBOTHbIX, aHJa1ormHHbIx ninaHaM ynpaBJIeHHsl

JiecaMH. TaK, B nniaHax ynpaBJIeHH5 pecypcamH aHKHX vKHBOTHbiX np4BOaIHjIHCb Hay4Hble

o6oCHOBaHH.q no yMaCTKaM, Ha KOTOPbIX BpeMeHHO nJIH nOCTOSHHO 3anpeuxaiiacb OXOTa, a

TaK)Ke no BHAOcneeuH4bweCKOMy HcnOAb3OBaHHIO pecypcoB npOMbICJ1OBbIX )KHBOTHbIX.

Pe3ynbTaTbl y'eTa Ha paU1OHHOM YPOBHe co6Hpajnlcb paUOHHbIMH OTaeAeHRAMH

Page 309: Russian - World Bank Documents

307 HPUJO)KEHHE H

JenapTaMeHTa OXOTHHqbHX pecypcoB, nepecbmnanlHcb B rnlaBHbie oTaeOeHHq B KpaCHOsipCKe HXa6apoBcKe, a owTyaa nocTynaJIH B perHoHanbHbIe HHCTHTyTbl oxpaHbi rlpHpOabi AAAo6pa6oTKH H apxHBaUHu.

HaMHHaA c 1994 roaa 3KcneaHUIHH no yqeTy pecypcoB aUHKHX )K[iBOTHbIX HenpOBORATCR. HeKOTOpble rpyrinbl Bbi6HpaIOT Co6 CTBeHHbie y4aCTK4, npeaHa3HaqeHHbIe =ARc,aqH B apeHay aeflapTaMeHTOM OXOTHHqbHX peCypCOB, apyrHe npe1AaraIoT CBOH yClyrH BKaqecTBe KOHCyJIbTaHTOB Ha HHAHBayajibHOA OCHOBe. B Xa6apoBcKoM Kpae no 3aAaHHioAaj1bHeBOCTOqHoro AeCoyCTPoHTeJIbHoro ripeanpHSTHA OeaepajibHoA cjiyx6bi .JecHoroXO3s1iHCTBa Poccuu npouuia scero oAHa TaKas 3KcneAHUHR B cocTaBe Tpex ienoBeK.

JlOm3oRBaM peCCpeCOB aNHX AHBOTHbLX

,ao pacnaaa CoBeTcKoro C0103a noTpe64TenSiMH pecypcoB AHKHX )KHBOTHbIX6burn rocyaapcTBeHHbie npOMbICIOBbie OXOTHHUbH XO3ArfCTBa, OXOTHHqbH KoonepaTHBbl HJIHOXOTHU4bH KJIy6bI. C HpHHATHeM rpOrpaMMbI npHBaTH3aUHH MHOrHe rocyaapCTBeHHblenpeFnpHSlTHR pacnaJnHcb, a HeKOTOpbie H3 HHX CTaJIH apeHAHbIMH npeHnpHRTHRMH.rlepexoaHblri nepHoa ropo0HIi 6onbulylo nyTaHHLy, H noTpe6yeTcq MHorO BpeMeHH, 'TO6bICHTyaLHIU BHOBb OKa3aiiaCb roil KOHTpOAeM.

06o3a7rnH"W yver. YqeT HpOMbICAOBbIX BHOOB 4CHBOTHbIX B TeqeHHe oojiroroBpeMeHH BXOAHA B o 6 A3aHHocTH noTpe6HTeJieH pecypcoB AHKHX XKHBOTHbIX. B HacToqLLeeBpeMS1 apeHLlaTopbl OXOTHH4bHX ylaCTKOB AOJDKHbI exKeroaHo npOBOaHTb yqeT KOHKpeTHbIXBHUOB npOMbICJIOBbIX )KHBOTHbIX. 4enapTaMeHT OXOTHHUbUX pecypcoB Tpe6yeT npOBOLiHTbyqeT TOAbKO TeX BHAOB, AAA KOTOpblX paccqHTbIBaeTCs HOpMa OTCTpena. H1414 oxpaHbInpHPOlIbl B Xa6apOBCKe H KpaCHOApCKe npOBOJlT CO6 CTBeHHbie exerOaHbie iCCJieaOBaHMqno yery OonFOAHHTeAbHbIx BUaOB )CHBOTHbIX.

BMeCTO crUoWIHoro y4eTa Ha Bceil TeppHTOpHH KpaeB ceriqac BeaeTcs yMeT TOAbKOHa y4aCTKaX, roUnewKauHx cRame B apeHAy. YqeT npOBOaHTcA nO3L1Hek 3HMOU H paHHeHBeCHOHi C HCnOAb3OBaHHeM MeTOaOB, aHaniorHqHblx MeTOaHKe, npHMeHReMOH B 3KCneaUHLIHX.JAaHHbie yqeTa aOJIXCHbi 6bITb npeacTaBAeHbl B pafiOHHbIe oTlaeAeH RA RenapTaMeHTaOXOTHH4bHX pecypcoB Ao 15 aripeJsI. aaHHbie 0 'IHcJIeHHOCTi MeaBeaerl aOJI)CHbi 6blTbnpeacTaBJIeHbl nu60 B HIoHe (nocne Toro, KaK MeRBeaH BbliAyT H3 cHrAqK4), JIH6o oceHbIo.YMeT no3aHerl oCeHbO H paHHeri BeCHOrl ripeACTaBJIAeT co6o0u nofcleT "BbDKHBIIHX" oco6eriH HCnOJIb3yeTcSq nAR oueHKH pa3mepa nonyiSiqui nocne 3HMHeH cMePTHOCTH. BKpaCHOAPCKOM Kpae o6si3aTeJIbHOMy yqeTy no.lex)aT 606pbl. OqeHb HH3Ka3 mHCJIeHHOCTbnOIYJISLIuHH, KOTOpasl oLIeHHBaeTCA B 2 TbIC. oco6eri Ha Bceii TeppHTOpHH Kpaq, CBH-AeTe.nbcTByeT 0 KpYnHOMacI.UTa6HOM HapywlIeHHH cpeAbl o6HTaHHS (3eMsle4epnaTenbHble pa-6OTbl Ha peKax H pyMbAX C ueAblo ao6bIqH 30OTa H MacuwTa6HbIe criUoiWHbIe py6KH) HH36blTOMHOM OTCTpene.

O*mwHNa",bmHe CTpyxTyphi OXOTHHqbLcF XO2xkCa. rocnpoMxo3b[ npeacTaBsnloTco6ori rocyaapCTBeHHble OXOTHHqbe-npOMbIc.nOBbie npeanpliATHA, HaaefleHHbie npaeaMH BOTHOwUeHHH 3aKoHoOaTeAbHo yCTaHOBneHHbIX TeppHTopHUi. B npowUAoM rocnpoMxo3bl BOCHOBHOM 6buH pacnonoxKeHbI Ha ceBepe CH6HpH H Ha )gaabHeM BocToKe H HMenm B CBoeMpacnopAxKeHHu 6 OlblUHe y4aCTKH 3eMenb. B HacToqwee BpeMq TpU npegnpHqTHS no-ripeKHeMy OeHCTByIOT B Xa6apoBcKoM Kpae Ha TeppHTOpHH 4 MAH. ra H HMelOT wTaT 13 200

Page 310: Russian - World Bank Documents

308 nPHIIO)KEHHE U4

'enoBeK - 120 npodPeCCHOHajIbHbIX OXOTHU4KOB iu 80 COTPYAHHKOB aaM4HtICTpaTHBHoro

annapaTa H cneHtuHamcToB no c6blTy.

Koon3BeponpoMxo3bl npeacTaBJSIoT co6o0i KoonepaTeBbl, Ha,ejTeHHbie

npe4myUieCTBeHHbIM npaBoM OXOTbl H OTJIOBa npOMblCJIOBblX )KHBOTHbIX Ha TeppHTOpUHI

onpe,aenieHHbIx OXOTHH4bHX yroaHA. B 6blBUweM COBeTCKOM Co0O3e 3T0 6bmU4 HaH6oJIee

pacnpocTpaHeHHble 04rUHajbHble CTpYKTypbl OXOTHHtiberO XO3AACTBa, KOTOpbie TOJIbKO B

Xa6apoBcKoM Kpae KOHTPOAHPOBaiiH 6onee 80% OTCTpeia nlpOMbICJIOBbIX )KHBOTHbIX.

HecMoTrpA Ha TO ITO 6OJIbUHHCTBO KoonepaTHBOB pacnaIOcb, aeCRTb Bce eiie aefiCTBYIOT B

Xa6apOBCKOM Kpae Ha TeppHTOpHt OKOJIO 20 MJIH. ra H o6ecne'HBaloT pa6oTori OKOJIO 500

'lejioBeK B paRiOHax, He6jlaronplUTHbIx C TOMKH 3peHH39 3aHSTOcTH.

AccoLHalN(H OXO THHKOB H pbi6ooBoB. B PoccHuu accouHauHH OXOTHHKOB H

pbI6ojiOBOB TpaHULLHOHHO npeRCTaBji5unH co6o0 opraHHl3aUHH MeCTHOrO 3Ha'eHuHR. HecMoTpR

Ha TO, 'TO Kaw4big rpa)KaaHHH Poccuu, HMeOiUUH m1UeH31Io, HMeeT npaBO OXOTt4TbCA B

JHo6oM paiOHe, OXOTHHKY Heo6XoaHMo nojiyqMTb pa3peuweHHe Ha aocTyn B TOT paUOH, rae

OH )KeniaeT OXOTHTbCq. Pa3peweHHs BbiXAalOTCS o3HuLHaj1bHbIMH nOJIb3OBaTeJI]MH 3Toro

y'acTKa 3eMJI HunH 'iepe3 OXOTHH'l4H KAy6, HMeiourUA npaBO Ha OXOTy Ha cnelLHanbHO

YCTaHOBjieHHbIX TeppHTOpH5IX. Acco[UiaLuHH OXOTHHKOB H pbi6oJIOBoB o6cnyxKHBaloT TOJIbKO

crIOpTCMeHOB-OXOTHHKOB, noKynaio1uHx JIHueH3HH Ha Ce3OHHOr4 OCHOBe.

Xa6apoBcKaA accouHaLLuR OXOTHHKOB H pbi6oJIOBOB Bo6ebeaHHeT 39 TbIC. IjieHOB H

apeH.ayeT 3eMJH4 o6uerl nruowa,LuIo 8 MJIH. ra. HeCMOTps Ha TO HTO 60.nbWiKHCTBO 'UTeHOB

accouiLHUHH OXOTHTCS Pa8H yROBOAbCTBH5 H JH'qHoro HCnOJIb3OBaHHA npOMblCJIOBbIX

)KHBOTHbIX (Mexa H MqCa), HM O4HUHaJlbHO pa3peweHo npOaaBaTb y6HTbIX HMH )KHBOTHbIX.

Pa3Mep roaoBbIX 'UIeHCKHX B3HOCOB COCTaBJISAeT OKOJIO 2 aonji. CWIA. Ocyu[ecTBIseMble

aCCOuHaLUHMA IpOrpaMMbp raOMOLbu AHKHM )KHBOTHbIM BKJlo4alOT aOHOJIHHTeAbHoe

KOpMJIeHHe KOnbITHbIX )KHBOTHbIX B CYPOBbie 3HMbl, YCTaHOBKY H coAep)KaH4e COJIRHbIX

HCTO'qHHKOB, a TaKiKe y'eT HCJIeHHOCTH LHKHX )KHBOTHbIX.

H7powe HoTpe6mwm'. B qIHCjIo npoIHX rpynn noTpe6HTenerl BXOaqT KopeHHble

HapolbI, HHaHB4,LayaIbHbie apeHAaTOpbl H TOBapHLUeCTBa apeHaaTOpOB. Co BpeMeHeM BCe

rOCnpOMXo3bl H KOOn3BepOnpOMX03bl 3aMeHHT HOBa5i CHCTeMa apeHabl. IOpHplH'eCKHe

Tpe6OBaHHH H npaBa, H3j1o)KeHHbie B ripaBujiax OXOTbI H nOCTaHOBJIeHHqX KpacHo5lpcKoro H

Xa6apoBcKoro KpaeB, OAHHaKOBbl AAs Bcex rpynn noTpe6iTeneg, KpoMe KOpeHHbIX Hapo,fOB

(KOTOpblM pa3pewneHo 6ecnnaTHo OXOTHTbCA C ueJIblO ao6blIH CpeaCTB K cyLuecTBoBaHHIO).

npelanOnaraeTCH, 'ITO C MeCTHbIMH Coo6LUeCTBaMH 6yayT 3aKAi0o'aTbCS CHeULiaHJbHbie

AOrOBOpbl.

Bce rpynnbi noTpe6HTeneri o6s3aHbl, KpoMe exero,AHoro y'eTa npoMbICJIOBbIX

peCyPCOB, OXpaHATb UHKHX )KHBOTHbIX OT 6paKOHbepOB, yJiylwaTb YCJIOBHH cpeabi o6HTaH5iq

(opraHH3aLuHo KOpMOBbIX y'aCTKOB, nOCa,DKy KYCTapHHKa H nJIOaOBbIX aepeBbeB), ycTa-

HaBjiHBaTb COJI5Hbie HCTOq4HHKH Ha cTpaTerFHeCKHX y'acTKaX, npul Heo6xoauHMOCT4 o6ec-

ne'IHBaTb ,OnOJIHHTeJIbHOe KOpMjieHHe )KHBOTHbIX, paL\HOHanJbHO HCnOJ1b3OBaTb pecypcbl

AHKHX )KHBOTHbIX, Ha pOTaLl,UOHHOr4 OCHOBe 3anpeiuaTb OXOTy Ha onpe1aejIeHHbix yHaCTKax Ha

TeppHTOPHH OXOTHHqbHX yroLaMH, a TaK)Ke KOHTpOJIHpOBaTb '-HCJIO XHLUHHKOB U npyrHe BHLAbI

yrpO3bl J151 ,UHKUX )KHBOTHbIX.

Page 311: Russian - World Bank Documents

309 HPK4IO)KEHHE H

Apcwja OXoTHHvblmX yoz,#I

Bonpocbi, CB513aHHbie C apeHAoA OXOTHH14bHX yroHiig, pewialoTcH C paHOHHbIMHaIMHHHCTpauwHMH. nppH OTCYTCTBI4H O4JHLtHaAbHbIX pYKOBOaAl.U14X yKa3aHHri peweHu4e oTOM, KaKie Tpe6OBaHH5I npea'blBJIAlOTCH K apeHaaTOpy, OrTHMaJIbHOM pa3mepe OXOTHi4qberoyrOAbH, penpOayKTHBHOM nOTeHuLiaJie aHKHX )KHBOTHbIX Ha TePPHTOpUH apeHayeMoroy4aCTKa H ueHe apeHAbl OCTaeTCS Ha yCMOTpeHHe MeCTHOU aaMHHHCTpaLUHH. KaK TO4HOoxapaKTeP3OBan nojio)KeHHe OAHH U3 BbICOKOrIOCTaBJTeHHbIX npelaCTaBHTeJeA Xa6apoBcKoAaccouHauHH OXOTHHKOB H pbi6oJIOBOB, "apeHaa BbilaejmeTCA Ha OCHOBe apyICeCKHX HLaeAOBbIX CBReW'.

Xa6apoBcKHIi IenapTaMeHT OXOTHH4bHX pecypcoB rpHHHJ nOCTaHoBJIeHHe "06HCHOJb3OBaHHH OXOTHHMbHX TeppHTopHi4I B Xa6apoBcKoM Kpae", o6si3aTeAbHoe KBbinOAHeHiHHO B paMKaX BCeX AOrOBOPOB o6 apeHae. CorJaCHo ero nono)eHHAM, yqaCTKH3eMA14 BbileJSAOTCA B apeHay 'aCTHblM AHLUaM, TOBapHUIeCTBaM H OXOTHH4bHM KJIy6aM npHco6Jio,aeH4H HMH onpeaeJeHHbIx yCAOBHrI: apeHaaTop aolJDKeH HMeTb o4fHUHaTibHoeyAocToBepeHHe npod)eccHoHaJbHoro OXOTHHKa H B03MO)KHOCTH ASA npoBeaeHHA exKerolIHoroyleTa 'HcJeHHOCTH aHKHX )KHBOTHbIX. B KpacHOApCKOM Kpae 3TH KpHTepHH TacKieBKJHloalOT ycneWHoe OKOHqaHHe Kypca rOiarOTOBKH OXOTHHKOB.

B fOCTaHOEAeHH4 TaK)ce perameHTHpyoTCA pa3Mepbi apcH,ayeMbix yqaCTKOB,COCTaBJTAioULHe OT 50 TbIC. ao 80 TbIC. ra Ha ceBepe KpaA H OT 10 TbIC. jao 25 TbIC. ra B1O)KHOU 'acTH. Ha ceBepe KpaA YPOBeHb BocnpoH3Bo14CTBa aHKX )KHBOTHbIX HH)Ke, roO3ToMyBbilexieMbie ami apeHAbl ytMaCTKH HMelOT 6onbWylo nJIOiuaab. Eonbuwas 'aCTb noc-TaHOBAeHHA nocBsiweHa npeainonaraeMorl CTpyKType LeHoo6pa3OBaHHh, BbIaeAeHHIO KBOT,nepe,aaxie npaB Ha apeHay, OTMeHe apeHabl, o4LHuHaJIbHoMy onpeLejIeHC4Ho TeXHH4eCKHXYCJOB4i1, HaKa3aHH5M H wTpa4aM.

B Xa6apoBcKoM Kpae ,o HaacToALuero BpeMeHH B apeHAY BbiJeJIeHO 120 yqaCTKOB(54 H3 HHX - qaCTHbIM jImuaM), no MHOriM apyrtiM y'aCTKaM BeyTCSq neperOBOpbl.MJuJIHoHbi reKTapOB 3eMH4, paHee HaXoalHBWHeCA B Be,aeHHH rocyaapCTBeHHbXnpOMbICJ¶OBbIX npeInpHHTHA, CTpeMHTeAbHO pa3flejSilOTC5I Ha yqaCTK4 (B AAHO-MaRCKOMpaioHe Xa6apoBcKoro KpaA TeppuHTOPHA njioluaabIO 17 MJIH. ra, B rpOWJOM HaxoaHBwaACSB co6cTBeHHocTH OaHoro apeHaaTopa, 6bmla pa3TaeAeHa Ha 17 oTaenbHblx apeHayeMbIxy4aCTKOB). JaaHHbie 0 KOnUHeCTBe apeHayeMbIx y'aCTKOB B KpacHoApcKoM KpaeOTCyTCTByIOT. Cnaaa 3eMJIH B apeHAYy IPOBOA4TCA B KpaCHOApCKOM Kpae Ha CpOK D,O 10 ieT,a B Xa6apoBcKoM Kpae - ao 25 JIeT.

HOp*zWOK YC7aHORIICHH2 iz4aTM 3a apeofy 3CMJH H OXOTHVbAH JlHL(CH3HH

nHiaTa 3a apemay OXOTHH4bt4X yrOAuH B KpaCHOqpCKOM Kpae ycTaHaBJIHBaeTcS Ho6cyxAaeTCA Ha YPOBHe paiOHHOUi aaMHHKCTpaULHH H MO)KeT COCTaBHTb OT 5 ao 1000 py6. 3areKTap (B ueHax 1995 r.), B 3aBHCHMOCTH OT yaaJieHHOCTH y'aCTKa, cnpoca, a TaKiKepa3Hoo6pa3HI4 H KOJHMeCTBa rpOMbICJ1OBbIX Bl4AOB )KHBOTHb[X. B Xa6apoBcKoM KpaenOP31,aOK orinaTbl perJaMeHTHpyeTc5 FIOCTaHoBjieHHeM "06 HCnOAb3OBaHIH OXOTHHqbHX Tep-pHTOpHU". CorfaCHO riOAO)KeHH3M 3TOrO ,aOKyMeHTa, CTOHMOCTb 1000 ra B CeBepHOU1 qaCTHKpaA COCTaBjiHeT II % MHHHMaBJbHOR 3apa6OTHori nHaTbI, YCTaHOBAeHHOr Ha 4)eaepaBjbHOM

Page 312: Russian - World Bank Documents

310 HPIPHO)KEHME H

ypOBHe, a B IOXKHOH MaCTH - 35%. PacLLeHKH 3a 1000 ra MOFYT aOCTHraTb 80% MHHHMaAJbHOi

3apa6OTHOR niiaTbI.

CyiIeCTBYloIUHt nOpq,4OK YCTaHOBjieHHqR UeH Ha OXOTHH4bH JIHUeH3HH H

JIHUeH3HOHHbie BbIlnIaTbI HepaCHOHaOieH H Hy2KAaeTCS B CpOHHOM nepecMoTpe.

PerHoHanbHble opraHbl BMaCTH npe1snoMjiH 6bl HMeTb qeTKHe HHCTPyKUHHi, yTBep)AeHHbIe Ha

fe,aepaAbHOM ypoBHe. TaK, nnaTa 3a pa3peU1eHHe Ha OTcTpeni onpeejLenHHbIX BHI4OB

(XCHBOTHbIX, AnH KOTOpbIX YCTaHoBBeHa KBOTa) H AiueH3HOHHbie BbinIIaTbl B o6oHx Kpaqx

OCHOBaHbl Ha npOpueHTaX OT MHHHMaJlbHOUi 3apa6OTHOiR nIJaTbI. TaKas CHCTeMa CJIOXHa U

3anyTaHHa. B KpaCHOAPCKOM Kpae JlHueH3HH AAA5 npOMbICJIOBbIX OXOTHHKOB o6blqHO CTOST

BABoe MeHbwUe, leM Ans OXOTHH4bHX KnIy6oB. HanpHMep, nnaTa 3a pa3peneHuie Ha OTCTpeCi

ceBepHoro oneHAs COCTaBjiSieT 0,7% MHHHMaabHOPi 3apnjiaTbI E SAM npOMblCJIOBbIX OXOTHHKOB H

100% - AAA OXOTHHKOB-CnopTcMeHOB. Pa3pemueHHe Ha oTCTpeni Ka6aHa CTOUT 1,4%

MHHHMaJbHOti 3apfLJiaTbI AnA npOMbICAOBbIX OXOTHHKOB H 100% 90 3An5 OXOTHHKOB-

CnopTCMeHOB, pa3pewCieHHe Ha OTCTpei 6yporo MeABea2 paBHO AByM MHHHManJbHbIM

3apruiaTam anS o6eHx rpynn noTpe6HTener, a pa3peuieHHe Ha oTcTpeJi nocsi, mapajia H

KOCyJIH COOTBeTCTByeT TpeM MHHHMaIIbHbIM 3apniiaTaM. B KpacHospcKoM Kpae oxoTa Ha

co6oJIR H 6o6pa pa3peiineHa TOJIbKO AiAS npOMbICJIOBbIX OXOTHHKOB. UIoJToBsHa DOXOAOB OT

JHlUeH3HOHHbIX BbnnlaT H wTpa4oB nocTynaeT B perHOHaJ1bHbll 3KoAorH4ecKHfl 4)OHA, a

nOJ1OBHHa ocTaeTC51 y erepeW.

B Xa6apoBcKoM Kpae CTOHMOCTb JIHUeH3HH Ha oTcTpenJ JIocq COCTaBESeT 200%

MHHHMaj1bHOt1 3apniaTbl, a ieHa Ha oTcTpenJ 6naropo2Horo oJIeHS, KOCyjIH, ceBepHoro

oJIeHq, Ka6aprH, cHexHoro 6apaHa, Ka6aHa, 6yporo Me21BeA5, co6oiSI H BbI21pbI paBHa 150%

MHHHManbHOR 3apruaTbi. OxoTa Ha 1pyrtHe BHabi HpOMbICAOBbiX ICHBOTHUbX npOBOaHTCS

6ecCnaTHo, BKAlOoSla TaKHe UeHHble nyulHbie BH2bi, KaK pUbCb H KYHHUa. O2HaKo nOPAAOK

B3HMaHHS c6opoB H nHueH3HOHHbIX BblniaT HeaOCTaTOMHO npopa6oTaH. Pa3Mep nnfaTbl

'KaCTO MeHAeTCS C yqeTOM HH4)JIqLlHH, o6iueg 3KOHoMH'KecKor o6CTaHOBK14 u CcneLkRaJbHblX

peweHuR aBMHHHCTPaUHH.

Page 313: Russian - World Bank Documents

lPHJIO)KEH14E K

MEK!YHAPO0,Hb1f OnbIT YCnEWHOR PEAiII3AUIH nPOrPAMM no YCTOfM4UBOMYPA3BITMIO JIECHOrO CEKTOPA

IOPHi4HtIeCKH 3aKperneHHbIX MeXQYHapO4HbIX HOPM H Tpe6oBaHHA noAecoynpaBjseHHIo H OCBOeHHIO JeCHbIX TeppHTOpHii Ha OCHOBe KOHUenUHH yCTOgq4HBoropa3BHTH5 (T.e. no c6alaHcHpoBaHHoMy ynpaBJIeHHIO JiecaMH H HX HeHCTOCLUHTeenbHOMYHcnoJTb3oBaHHIo) He cywecTByeT. Ho BO MHOriHX cTpaHax paCTeT HeyaoBAeTBOpeHHOCTbTpaHUI4HoHHoA napa,4HrMoou HOCTo5IHHoro npoMbljieHHoro JIecorOJIb3OBaH45. Ceiqac Bce6onbule noaIepKHBaeTcq Heo6xoalHMocTb nepexoa K paULHOHaIbHOMy ynpaBJeHHIO AeCHbIMH3KOCHCTeMaMH, KaK OCHOBe yCTO1iHBoro pa3BHTHq iieCHoro ceKTopa.

KPHTepHH paiLHOHaJbHorO H HeHCTOUwHTeAbHoro OCBOeHHSI neCoB

'IeTKoe onpeaeJeHHe BO3MOXCHOH poJIH pauHoHaAbHoro ynpaBJIeHH. IieCHbIMH3KOCHCTeMaMH B Pa3BHTHI iiecHoro ceKTopa 6blTO CqOPMYJIHPOBaHO B paMKaX pa3JIHqHbIXMeKLyHaPOnHbX HHUHHuaT4B, LIeJbiO KOTOPbIX 6blna pa3pa6oTKa KPHTepHeB H 4HaHKaTOPOBYCTOHquBOCTH pecypcoB. Ha MexYgyHapOrHOM YPOBHe 3TH BOnPOCbl BnePBbie BO3HHKJIH BKOHTeKCTe ynpaBjieH4, TpOnHT4eCKHMH niecaMH. Mex1yHapoAHas opraHH3auHm noTponumeCKOA apeBeCHHe nP4HHJIa uejiyio cepHio peKoMeHaaTeJIbHbIx aoKyMeHTOB noeCTeCTBeHHbIM necam (IITO 1991, 1992, 1993a) H HCKyCCTBeHHbIM iecoHacaK1eHH5IM (ITTO1993b) Ha Me)KnpaBHTeJlbCTBeHHOM ypOBHe. XOTA 3TH aoKyMeHTbl He Bo3JIaraIOT HHKaKHXIOPHLIHMeCKHX o6H3aTe.nbCTB Ha CTpaHbI-y4aCTHHUbl, OHH oTpa)KaIOT MeXlYHaPOaHbiepeKoMeHaaLUHH, Ha OCHOBe KOTOPbIX KaW)aK cTpaHa MO)KeT pa3pa6aTblBaTb co6CTBeHHbie,6o0ee KOHKpeTHbie HopMaTHBHbie aoKyMeHTbI, Tpe6OBaHHA H npaKTH4eCKHe nOaXOabI.

B npHHUHnaX BseeHH4 iecHoro Xo3AACTBa, pa3pa6oTaHHblx KoHqepeHuHeA OOHno oKpy)KaioWei cpeae H pa3BHTHIO (UNCED), noAqepKHBaeTcs Heo6xoa1uMOCTb UeJIocTHorono,axoaa K pewUeHHiO JIeCoXo3slCTBeHHbIx npo6ineM, OCHOBaHHOrO Ha JiorUIHeCKHnocneaOBaTenbHbIx nPHHUHnaX 3KOJIorHqeCKH YCTOWqHBOrO pa3BHTHSI nPHMeH HTenJbHO KOBCeM iecam H BCeM CTpaHaM. B 1980-e roabI BHHMaHHe MeKayHapoAHoro coo6LueCTBa 6buIococpeLIoTo4eHO B OCHOBHOM Ha TponHqeCKHX niecax, HO K HaMajiy 1990-x roaOB CTalOoMeBHLIHbIM, 'ITO nieca yMepeHHOA H 6opeanbHoH 30H TO)Ke HMeIOT rJTo6anbHoe 3Ha'eHiie Ui'4TO pal4lOHaJIbHOCTb H HeHCTOLUHTeJIbHOCTb MHOrHX U3 HCHnob3yeMbxx MeTOAOB BeaeHHSXO3.qACTBa B 3THX iecax TO)Ke BbI3bIBaeT 6o0nbWnHe COMHeHHq (Botkin and Talbot 1992; Dudley1992).

B 1994 roay B )KeHeBe 6bma co3LaaHa Pa6o'as rpynna no KPHTepiiqM HHH2IHKaTOpaM paUHoHaTIbHoro ynpaBJleHHsI npHpoaooxpaHHOR OpHeHTaULHH ZnSI JnecoByMepeHHOU H TpOnHHeCKOA 30H C LLeJblO pa3pa6OTKH H corFacoBaHHSl Ha MeW4yHapOaHOMYPOBHe KpHTepHeB H HHAHKaTOpOB aAA OLueHKH H COXpaHeHHA nieCOB yMepeHHOH H6opeanbHOu 30H. 3Ta pa6oTa cTana 4aCTbIO TaK Ha3blBaeMoro "MOHpeaTIbcKoro npouecca". BynOMRHYTYIO BbIlle rpynny BOWUJTH npeacTaBHTejiH ABcTpamH, KaHaabl, qwI4, KHTaR,5lnoHHi., Pecny6nHKH Kopeq, MeKCHKH, HOBOH 3eJ¶aHAHH, POCCHHCKOUi cOeaepaLuHH H

Page 314: Russian - World Bank Documents

312 rHPHJ1O)KEHUE K

CIWA. B 3aceaaH 14Ax Pa6o0eru rpynnbI TaioKe npuHHMaIiH yqacTHe HecKOJIbKO

Me)AKyHapO,aHbiX H enpaBHTebCTBeHHbl opraH43auHti u apyrHe CTpaHbl.

B 4eBpaie 1995 roaa Pa6o'as rpynna yTBep4i4jTa KOMnnJeKCHylo cCHcTeMy

KpHTepieB H HHAHKaTOpOB pauHoHabHOrO iiecoynpaBieHHAi npHpoooxpaHHOu opP4eHTaLIHH,

KOTOpaS nOJIHOCTbIO oTpa)KeHa B "CaHTb rcKor4 aeKmapaUHH". XOTA 3TU KPHTeptH U

HHAHKaTOpbl He 3aKpenHieHbl C nOMOLUbIO KaKoro-IiH6o 4HCTpyMeHTa Me)uyHapOAHOrIO

npaBa, OHH HMelOT o'eHb BaKHoe 3HaeHHe Aini ynpaBjieHHH JIecaMH, nOTOMY 'iTO Ha aonioCTpaH - yqaCTHHU 3TOUi Pa6o'erl rpynnbi nPHXOXaHTCq 90% TecOB yMepeHHori H 6opeanbHori

30H B MHpe. 3TU KpHTepHH npeaCTaBjiSlOT co6o0l MexayHapOaHyiO "TOqKy OTC'eTa" ILYA

oueHKH onTHMaJbHblX MeTOLOB H AoruMecKyio OCHOBy AAaSa jbHegweri pa6oTbl.

KpHNrpHM Hf HH4HKaTO7M PaL(HOHaYbHHO JI7PaBJICHHJf Jieca&ii YIICpCHHOg N 6 OJpJ&AHO

30H

bblJO npHHHATO CeMb KPHTepHeB H COOTBeTCTBY[O1He U M UHaHKaTOpbi

pauHOHanJbHOFO ynpaBneHHs JIecaMH yMepeHHOti H 6opeajTbHOf 30H npHPOaooxpaHHOV

OpHeHTaUHH. OHM OTHOCUTCS K YCJIOBMHM fleconpoH3pacTaHHs4, CBOUCTBaM unJu bYHKUH%IM

nIeCOB H BblroaaM, CBH3aHHbIM C TeMH 3KojiorHMeCKHMH H COUHaYIbHO-3KOHOMHMeCKHMH

ToBapaMH H yCJIyraMH, KoTopbIe aaloT neca. AaHHbIH nepetieHb KpHTepCeB H MHHHKaTOpoB

,aH 6e3 y'eTa uX npHOpHTeTHoCT4.

KpHTepHi 1: CoxpaHeHHe 6HoJIorHMecKoro pa3Hoo6pa3m

Pa3Hoo6pa3He 3KOCHCTem

a) nnowaxw Kawaoro THna nieca H ero ROJIq B o6ueg nHioLwagH nIeCoB.

6) notuaab KaK,aorO THna nieca H KamcAoro BO3paCTHoro Kiiacca unJIu cTa[HH4

cyKUeccHH.

B) nnoluaab KaxKorO THrna iieca Ha oxpaHqeMbIX TeppHTop45Xx: nO KaKaolu KaTeropHH

OXpaH5leMbIX TeppHTOpHU, corniacHo KiiaCcH4(HKauH5M MexcgyHapOAHoro c0103a

oxpaHbi npHpoabl (MCOFI) HAu apyrHM KJIacci4)HKaUHOHHb1M cHcTeMaM.

r) nJo1ua,4b Ku(aorO THna iieca Ha oxpaHSeMbIX TePPHTOPHAIX nO BO3paCTHb1M

KiaccaM HJIH CTaAH5M cyKUecCHH.

a) O>parMeHTaUH5 THnOB jieca.

Pa3Hoo6pa3Hc B,VAOB

a) KOJIH'eCTBO JieCHb1X BHfOB.

6) CTaTYC (Hc'e3aloLuHe, penKHe, Ys3BHMbie, BblMepIIwme) nieCHbIX BH4AOB, KOTOPbIM,

cornacHo 3aKOHOaaTejibHbIM aOKyMeHTaM H Hay'qHbIM OUeHKaM, yrpoxaeT OnaCHOCTb

nOTepH KH3Hecnoco6HbIX HOnynSAu4LH.

Page 315: Russian - World Bank Documents

313 HPPIO)KEHHE K

reCe7MVCCKOO pa3Hoo6pa3HC

a) KoJIH.eCTBO JIeCHbIX BHJOB, KOTOpbIe Tenepb 3aHHMalOT IHUWb mailyio 4aCTb CBoeronpeKHero apeajia.

6) '-HcJIeHHOCTb norynquLii pellpe3eHTaTtiBHb!X BH1OB H3 pa3HbIX MeCT o6HTaHHS,oxBa,IeHHbIX MOHHTOpHHroM nO BceMy Hx apeajiy.

KpwTepHR 2: CoxpaHeHHe npOAYKTHBHOCTH IieCHLIX 3KocHcTeM

a) M6umas nfjoLab JTeCHbIX 3eMenJb H njiouLaab .JeCHbIX 3eMeJIb, ocTaioliasIcsq qAnpOH3BOXaCTBa apeBecHHbl.

6) 06wun 3anac nieca Ha KOpHIO, KaK nO KoMMep4eCKH ueHHbIM nopoaaM, TaK H noMaTioueHHbIM, Ha JieCHbIX 3eMASx,aocTynHbIX anS npOH3BOACTBa apeBeCHHbl.

B) noiuaab H 3anac ieCHbIX KYJIbTyp KOpeHHb1X H 3K30TH'eCKHX BHUOB.

r) FOaOBOA o6'beM 3arOTOBKH ApeBeCHbIX npO1yKTOB B CpaBHeHHH C 06beMOM,KOTOpbIlU C4HTaeTCA He4CTOLU14TeJIbHbIM.

,a) FOfOBOsi o61beM 3arOTOBKH HeapeBeCHbIX IieCHbIX npO1yKTOB (riyWHHHbl, sroA,rpH60B, aH4H) B CpaBHeHHH C ypOBHeM, KOTOpblI CqHTaeTCS1 HeHCTO0LJHTeJlbHbIM.

KpWrepHi 3: CoxpaHeHHe 3OpOBbM H XH3HeCrioCo6HocTH 3KOCHCTCM

a) njiouaab H AIoAH (B rpoueHTax) nJeCOB, nopa)KeHHbIx npoLeccaMH HJIn (faKTopaMH,HaXOALuuHMHCS 3a rpeaejiaMl4 HCTOpHuecKoro aHana3OHa BapbI4pOBaHHH (HaceKoMble,6oJie3HH, KOHKypeHUHS CO CTOpOHbI 3K30THMeCKHX BHIOB, roKapbi, 6ypH, yTajieHHepaCTHTenbHOro nOKpOBa, rOCTO5HHOe 3aTonJIeHHe, 3acoJIeHHe nO4Bbl H AoMaUHiHeXKHBOTHbIe).

6) HAoWa,ab H aoIAS (B rpOUeHTax) JIeCHbIX 3eMeJIb, nOaBepKeHHbIX BO3,aeUCTBHIOKOHKpeTHbIX 3arp53HHTeJierl B03ayxa (cyJIbbaToB, HHTpaTOB, 03OHa) HnuyJlbTpa4uHofeToBoro H3fTiyqeHH4 B, KOTOpbIe MoryT OTpHuaTejibHo CKa3blBaTbCS HafleCHbIX 3KOCHCTeMax.

B) Hnoouaab H AOnœ (B npOueHTax) fleCHbIX 3eMenJb C HerOJTHblM Ha6opOM6HonorH'leCKHX KOMHOHeHTOB, 'TO mBJI5eTCA CHMnTOMOM H3MeHeHUi B OCHOBHblX3KOJIoruHeCKHX npoueccax (KpyrOBOpoTe iHTaTejibHbIX BeWLeCTB B H4OMBe,pacceHBaHHH ceMAH, orbITeHHH) HH ripepblBaHHA 3KOJorH4qeCKHX Ha6JioaeHtii(MOHHTOPHHre 4YHKLUHOHaTibHO Ba)KHbIX BH1OB, HanpUmep rp460B, apeBeCHbIX3nHHbt43, HeMaTOL, )KyKOB, oc).

KpHTepHUi 4: CoxpaHeHHe nIOMBeHHIX H BOlHbIX peC)CCOB

a) nnoLuaab U ,aOnIq (B npoUeHTax) JIeCHbIX 3eMeJlb, 3Ha4HTeJibHO nOpa)KeHHbIX3pO3HeA nOMBbl.

6) ULioLLaLb H ionsI (B npOLueHTax) TeX JIeCHbIX 3eMeJlb, Ha KOTOpblX OCHOBHOU LUeJlblOJIecoynpaBJIeHHA 5IBnAeTCM coxpaHeHHe H KCrIOJ1b3OBaHHe HX 3aWLulTHblX 4JyHKUUH(BoRoperyiiHpyIoLuHe 4yHKLUHH Ha BOAOC6opax, 3aLHTa OT HaBO,4HeH4fiI, 3aUHTa OTJ1aBHH 1 3aLu.Ta npH6pe)KHbIx 30H).

Page 316: Russian - World Bank Documents

314 HPlJIOXKEHHE K

B) HpOpoeHT ,IUHHbI (KM) peK Ha nOKpblTbIX JiecoM BoaoC6opax, rae Te4eHHe 14 CPOKH

pa3JIHBOB 3Ha'HTeJIbHO OTKJIOHHJIHCb OT HCTOpHMeCKOrO UalHaa30Ha BapbHpOBaHHs.

r) IljoUWab H AOIOH (B npoUeHTax) JIeCHbIX 3eMeJlb CO 3HMaMTmmbHO CHwKeHHbIM

COAep)KaHHeM B noqBe opraHH4ecKHx BeLueCTB HuH apyrHMH H3MeHeHHSM4 B

XHMH'IeCKKX CBOUCTBaX nOMBbI.

,a) ljiou.aab H AnOA (B npoueHTaX) JleCHbIX 3eMeJlb CO 3HatiHTejlbHbIM ylnjOTHeHHeM

noqBbl HuIH apyr4MH H3MeHeHHqMH qUH3iMeCK4X CBOUCTB HO4BbI B pe3ynbTaTe

tiejioBeVecKorA aeqTeJIbHOCTH.

e) aonji (B HpoUeHTax) BOgOeMOB Ha iieCHbIX njioLuaa5ix (OT AIHHbI peK U4 njoLaAH

03ep) CO 3HaU4TeJ]bHbIM OTKJIOHeHHeM B 6HOJIOrtMeCKOM pa3Hoo6pa3UiU OT

HCTOpHmecKoro aHla3nHa BapbHpOBaHHq.

X) DOJIq (B npoueHTax) B0oOeMOB Ha nieCHbIx nAoiua,A5x (OT ,IJUHbl peK 1 nHjoIua,H

03ep) CO 3Ha'IHTeJIbHbIM OTKJ1OHeHHiM OT npeaeAOB HCTOpH4eCKOrO al4ana3OHa B

nniaHe pH, coaep)KaHHA paCTBOpeHHOrO KHcAopoaa, YPOBHeg coJep)aHuiH

XHMHUeCKHX BeLueCTB (3ieKTpOnpOBORI4MOCTH), CeaHMeHTaLtHH H TeMnepaTypbl.

3) njioiua,b u aousl (B rpoueHTax) JIeCHbIX 3eMeJTb, Ha KOTOpblX npOHCXOlHT

HaKoniieHHe yCTONMHBbIX TOKCHmeCKHX BelIIeCTB.

KpmTepHiI 5: CoxpaHeHHe poJIM IieCOB B rjio6aBJbHOM KpyroBopoTe yrAepola

a) 06iuHii o6feM 6HoMaccbI JiecHog 3KOCHCTeMbI H 3anac yrjiepoaa: nO THnaM nieca,

KJiaccaM Bo3paCTa H CTaHqSM cyKueccmu, npH Heo6xoaHMocTH.

6) BjiH$IHHe AeCHbIX 3KOCHCTeM Ha o6lUuH rJIo6allbHbl yruiepoAHbui 6iopaxeT,

BKJlio4as5i nornIoueHHe H Bb1,enfeHHe yrniepoaa (yr.iepoaa, coaepxaiuerocH B AHBOA

6HoMacce, apeBeCHbIX OCTaTKax, TOp4e U no4Be).

B) PoJlb .feCHblX nPpOaYKTOB B rJo6anbHOM yrjiepO,lHOM 610oIeTe.

KpwTePHA 6: CoxpaHeHHe H npHyMHoXKCeHHe AoJrocpOqHbEX COIAHaJIbHo-

3KOHOMHIIeCKHX Bblrl'O MHOrOL1eCJeBOrO nCconiojib30oaH

a) CTOHMOCTb H of6beM nPOH3BOPCTBa APeBeCHHbI H apeBeCHOrl npOLYKUUIU, BKji1O4aq

Xao6aBjieHHYIO CTOHMOCTb, o6pa3ylOLUyIcOC 3a c4eT 6onee r.ny6oKor; nepepa6oTK4.

6) CTOHMOCTb U4 o06eMbi nPOH3BOaCTBa HeaPeBeCHbIX nieCHbIX npOXYKTOB.

B) npOU3BOPCTBO U nOTpe6jieHHC aPeBeC4Hbl H aPeBeCHOrl nPOXYKUHH, BKA1Oioaq

noTpe6ueHHe Ha nyWy HaceiieHHq.

r) ,Loni CTOHMOCTH nPOH3BOACTBa aPeBeCHHbl H IaPeBeCHOR nPOPYKUHH B BBri (B

npouLeHTax).

,L) CTeneHb BTOPU4HOU nepepa6oTKH HCnOAb3OBaHHb1X JIeCoMaTePHa)iOB.

e) HpOH3BOACTBO H noTpe6JieHHe HeapeBeCHbix npOpyKTOB.

Page 317: Russian - World Bank Documents

315 HPHUIOKEHME K

PCKpea(mKJ N /pN3M

a) nLiowaab H AOJIq (B COOTHOwUeHHU c o6feu nnowaAbIo) nieCHbIX 3eMenb, HaKOTOPbIX UeIJblO BeaeHHA X03HHCTBa HBJISHOTCA peKpeauiAr H TYPH3M.

6) KOJIHqeCTBO H TUllbl peKpeaUHOHHbIX H TYPHCTH4eCKHX COOpy)KeHHUg H o6yCT-pOeHHblX yqaCTKOB B COFIOCTaBjTeHHH C tHCJieHHOCTbIO HaCeJieHHA H nJIOWaAb[O JIeCOB.

B) HoceiuaeMOCTb (B 4eJIOBeKO-aH5lX) peKpeauHOHHO-TypHCTHMeCKHX 30H B conoc-TaBjieHHH C 4HcJIeHHOCTbIO HaceieHHA H nHOLaWAbIO necoB.

J,HBecmpoRaHze B JIeCHOJI cexKop

a) Pa3Mepbl HHBeCTHU[HU, BKAIOMqSa HHBeCTHpOBaHHe B BbipaUHBaHHe neca, neco-3aIIHTy H JieCOXo3S1rCTBeHHYIO eSATeJAbHOCTb, nleCHble KyJlbTypbI, AepeBolnepepa6oTKy,peKpeauHIo H TypH3M.

6) YpOBeHb paCXO,4OB Ha HCCJ]eAOBaHHA, pa3pa6oTKH H o6pa3oBaHHe.

B) BHeapeHme H HCnOJib3oBaHHe HOBbIX H ycoBepueHCTBOBaHHb[X TeXHoJIorHU.

r) Ko3qFHLtHeHTbl oKynaeMOCTH KanHTajioBnoKeHH.

KyJ,MTpHMC, COL(HIHMC HN /IOBHMC HIOTpC6HOCTH H LCMHOCM

a) HI oluaab H aOJIH (B COOTHOwIIeHHH C o6weR FTfouLaAblo) iieCHbIX 3eMeJJb, rLeX0351rCTBeHHaS AeSTeflbHoCTb HanpaBiieHa Ha coxpaHeHHe iteiioro psuaa KyJIbTypHbIX,COUHaHYbHbIX H ayXOBHbIX LLeHHOCTei H yAOBJieTBOpeHHe noTpe6HOCTer AllO,1eU B 3THXueHHOCTAX.

6) JAecHbie nojie3HOCTH HenoTpe6HTeAbCKoro nojib3oBaHHA.

3amHZTOCTb H IO?7pc6HOCTH HacrhcHHJI

a) npIMas H KOCBeHHaS1 3aHITOCTb B JieCHOM ceKrope H 3aHHTOCTb B JTeCHOM CeKTOpeB npOLLeHTHOM OTHOweHHH K o6iueg 3aHATOCTH.

6) CpeAHHe cTaBKH 3apnnfaTbI H YPOBeHb TpaBMaTH3Ma no OCHOBHbIM KaTerOpHRM3aH51TOCTH B JieCHOM CeKTope.

B) )KH3HeCHioCo6HOCTb H HpHCIHoCo6JIAeMOCTb HaCeJ1eHUH JieCHbIX paHiOHOB, BKJ]iO4aAKOpeHHOe HaceJIeHHe, K H3MeHeHHAM B 3KOHOMH4eCKHX yCJIOBHSX.

r) nljoLuaab H OJIAS (B npOueHTax) AeCHbIX 3eMeJlb, HCnOFOb3yeMbIX MeCTHbIMHaceJieHHeM lUfl, nOIyqeHHA CpeaCTB K CyI1eCTBOBaHHIO.

Page 318: Russian - World Bank Documents

316 HPHJ1O)KEHKE K

KpmepHi 7: HpaBoBme, MHCTHT)WHOHaAbHEae H 3KOHOMHIeCKHe IpHHIAHlI

c6aAaHcHpoBaHHOTO ylpaBhIeHH5 iecaMH

IJPJIOBaD OCHOBR

a) npaBa Co6CTBeHHOCTH, yCTaHOBj1eHHe HeO6XOatMbiX OTHOLiIeHRr4 B o6AaCTH

3eMAneBjiaBeHHS H 3eMjienojib3oBaHH51, TpaAHUHOHHbIe npaBa KOpeHHbIX HapOAOB U

cpe,aCTBa pa3pewuleHsi CnOpOB o npaBax Co6CTBeHHOCTH Ha OCHOBe 3aKoHa.

6) nepHo0nHqecKoe nnTaHHPOBaHHe H ouIeHKa Aecoxo3sliCTBeHHOA aesITeAbHOCTH 1U

aHaJIH3 nojiHTHKH C yMeToM pa3nAHtHbIX Hojie3HbIX pecypcoB nieca H Bbiroa, BKJIIO'-aS

B3amMO,aeACTBHe C COOTBeTCTBYIOLLtHMH oTpaCJiRMH.

B) BO3MO)KHOCTH yMaCTHR o6iueCTBeHHOCTH B pa3pa6OTKe rOCyaapCTBeHHOri HiOJHTHKH

H npHPHHTHH peweHM4i nO BonpocaM, cBS3aHHbIM C necamH, a TaK)Ke aocTyro6iIreCTBeHHOCTH K HH4bopMaUHH.

r) licnojib3OBaHHe jiyqwLHx o6pa3LOB BseeHH5 jiecHoro xo3SACTBa.

,) YnpaBAeHHe .lecaMH C Lejibio coxpaHeHHR oco6blx npHpo,HbIX, KyJIbTypHbIX,

COUIHaAbHbIX H HaytHbIX ueHHOCTetl.

HHCYTyl(HOHf8ffBH2fI C7pyK7YPB

a) YqaCTHe o6iueCTBeHHOCTH B yripaBjieHHH IieCaMm, rOCyXaPCTBeHHbIe npOrpaMMbio6pa3oBaHHA H npocBeLUeHHS, BHeapeHHe HOBbIX nOfAXOAOB H 4HHIOpMaaulHOHHOe

o6ecneqeHHe no necHbIM npo6.neMaM.

6) nepHo1H4ecKoe niaHHPOBaHHe UH oueHKa jiecoxo3HACTBeHHOA aeSTeJIbHOCT4 H

aHaJH3 nOAHTHKHK, BKOoqaiOtUWH B ce6SI mexKoTpacneBoe nAaHHPOBaHHe H

KOOpLUHHauHio c apyrHMH oTpaCAqmH.

B) HOBblwueHHe KBaJIUHdHKaLUHH CneLjiAUJ4CTOB HO COOTBeTCTBylOlUlM 4f4CLUnHJI4HaM.

r) HarHqiie 3d4eKTHBHOH 4)H3HMecKoH HH4)paCTPYKTypbl AVSI IpOH3BOaCTBa JIeCHb1X

npOIAYKTOB H yciyr C LlejibiO OKa3aHHS nO,Aep)KKH JieCHOMY XO3SACTBy.

,a) BBeaeHHe H KOHTPOJ1b 3a co6juo,aeHHeM 3aKoHoB, npaBHJI, HOpM H Tpe6oBaHHU.

3KoHoMHvecKaff c7pyKTypa

a) IIHBeCTHIUHOHHaSI H Hajoi'oBaA nOJIHTHKa H cHcTeMa peryJIHpoBaHH5[, yqH-

TbIBaIOiUHe AOArOCpOMHOCTb HHBeCTHUHri H IloryCKaiOlume, 'TO nOTOKH KanmTaTia

MOryT BXO4llTb B IieCHOri CeKTOp H BbIXO,HTb 3a ero npeaeJbl B 3aBHCHMOCTH OT

CHTyaLiAH Ha pblHKe, 3KOHOMHMeCKaH OueHKa HepbIHOqHbIX noJIe3HbIX peCypCOB,

pewleHHR no rocyaapCTBeHHOA nOJIHTHKe, HanpaBneHHbie Ha yaoBJneTBopeHHe

lLoArocpoqHoro cnpoca Ha .JeCHbie npoXLyKTbi H ycnyrH.

6) HeAHCKPHMHHaUHOHHaA IIOhHTHKa B o6naCTH TOprOBJIH JIeCHbIMH npollyKTaMH.

Page 319: Russian - World Bank Documents

317 nPKJIO)KEHHE K

KowQJ CcTBeHHaJI Om(eHKM H MOHHTOpHHr H3MmHCHHH

a) HanuHMe H KOJIH'eCTBO nOCTOSHHO o6HOBJAleMbiX aaHHbIX, CTaTHCTHKH H apyrHxBHIROB HH41opMaUHH, BaXKHOA ARA KOAH4eCTBeHHOHi OueHKH H onFicaHKM HHHAHKaTOPOBnO BceM ceMH KpHTepHSIM.

6) OXBaT, 'acToTa H CTaTHCTHxieCKaS aOCTOBePHOCTb pe3yJlbTaTOB KHBeHTapH3aUHH,OueHKH H MOHHTOpHHra neCOB H npoqeu 3HaqHMOR HHKIopMaLfHH.

B) COBMeCTHMOCTb cHcTeM c6opa KOJIHMeCTBeHHbIX aaHHbIX, MOHHTOpHHra HoTqeTHOCTH no HHAHKaTOpaM C TaKHMH cHcTeMaMH B apyrHx cTpaHax.

HccffeaOBaHHR H pa3pa6oTKH

a) YrAy6neHHe HayqHoro r1OHHMaHHA xapaKTePHCTHK H 4IyHKUHlH n1eCHbIX 3KoCHcTeM.

6) Pa3pa6oTKa MeTODOB pac'eTa 3KonorHuecKHx H COLuHaIbHb[X 3aTpaT U pe3yJbTaTOB,HX HHTerpaLIHq B pbIHOMHbIe rpoUeCCbl H B npouecc pa3pa6oTKH rOCyXapCTBeHHOiJieCHoH noJIHTHKH, a TaKwKe HX HcHoJIb3OBaHHe AnA oTpaKeHHA CTeneHH HCTOLIeHH51H)H npHYMHo)KeHHA AeCHbIX H CBS3aHHbIX C JIecoM peCYPCOB B HaLUOHa0JbHb1XCHCTeMax y4eTa.

B) Pa3pa6oTKa HOBbIX TeXHo0or0Hr H CpeaCTB AAS oueHKH COULHabHO-3KOHOMH'4eCKHX

nocJ1eACTBHri BHefpeHHS HOBbIX TeXHo0orHi.

r) PacwHpeHHe B03MO)KHOCTerH nporHO3HpOBaHHSI B03,aer4CTBH4 qenOBeqeCKO,aeATejibHOCTH Ha nieca.

,a) PacwLHpeHHe B03MOIKHocTeg nporHO3HPOBaHHq B03AeACTBHti Ha nieca rIoTeH-UHa)bHOrO H3MeHeHHA KJiHMaTa.

HOECHeNHIno oT1e70HmfbHM7 XH7rplfM H HH4HKaTOPaM

HHKce pa3'bACHAIOTCA 3Ha4eHHB oTReJebHb1X KpHTipHm B H HHAHKaTOpOB HOCHOBaHHS AAA HX OTHeCeHHM K Ba)KHblM aCrieKTaM oLteHKK npouecca paUHOHaTbHOrO

ynpaBJeHHA JiecaMH npHipoaooxpaHHo0 HarpaBjieHHOCTH. Hu OfHH oTAeJlbHO B3ATblriKPHTepi4k HIiH uuH,HKaTOp He Mo0KeT 6bITb nOKa3aTenjeM yCTO4H1BOCTH. OTaeJbHble KpUTepUHH HHAHKaTOPbI AOJ1KHbI paccmaTpHBaTbCA B KOHTeKCTe apyrHx KpHTepHeB K HHaHKaTopOB.

KpwTCpHi 1: CoxpaHeHHe 6HonorHqecKoro pa3Hoo6pa3Hs

UleAb CoXpaHeHHS 6UofOrHmeCKoro pa3Hoo6pa3KsI 3aKfiO4aeTCA B COXPaHeHHUBKaOB H BHYrPHBHaOB0i reHeTHMeCKOR H3MeHqtHBOCT4. )KH3HeCnOCO6HbIe nOnYjILAHH BHaOB UHX rIPHPOfHaA reHeTHMeCKaAs H3MeH'IHBOCTb ABASIOTCS 4aCTbIO B3aHMO3aBUCHMblX bH3H4eCKHXH 6HoAorHqecKHx CHCTTM H rPOLueCCOB. COCTOAHHe H pacnpocTpaHeHHe n1eCHblX coo6uLeCTBHMelOT 6o0JbUoe 3HaqeHKe KaK =An OCHOBHbIX 3Ko0jorHqeCKHX nPoLIeCCOB K CHCTeM, TaK H AAS6y,ayiiero 6Ho.norHqecKoro pa3Hoo6pa3HA JIeCOB H CBA3aHHbIX C HHM CHCTeM.

Page 320: Russian - World Bank Documents

318 H1PHRJOKEHHE K

Pk3Hoo6pa311e 9KOCHCc7M

a) TiMin'4Hbie an2 IiecHbix 3KOCHCTeM 3K0oj0orMeCKe npoueccbi H KM3Hecnoco6Hbie

nOnYJIRLHH BH,aOB o6bl4Ho 3aBHCAT OT coceRHerl 3KOCi4CTeMbi Huin 3KOCHCTeM

onpe1ejieHHorO MHHHMajIbHoro pa3Mepa. FeHeTHlecKoe pa3Hoo6pa3Me B npeenenax

nonyjiSLtHH Toro HnIH HHOrO BHaa 3aBHCHT OT COXpaHHOCTH cy6nonynsi.Ru H

Cyl4eCTBOBaHHA J1eCHbIX 3KOCHCTeM, OXBaTbIBalOUlMX 6oflblUylO 'laCTb HX

eCTeCTBeHHoro apeaJia. Jleca MoryT 3aHHMaTb BCIO cpeay o64TaHrs, Heo6xoaHMylo AAq

BbDKHBaHHA BHUOB, HJIH ee tlaCTb.

6) 3KonorwiecKMe npoLLeccbI H y'aCTBy1OiuHe B HHX BM,Abl B npeeRenax nio6or JiecHOI

3KOCHCTeMbi uInH THna iieca onpeAejiRIoT CTPYKTypy paCTHTeJIbHOrO nOKPOBa (Bo3pacT

pacTeHHi UX HaHaMeTp H BbICOTy) H CTaAHIM cyKLeCCHH (cMeHa BHROB paCTeHHfl).

B) Pa3Mep TOU YaCTH iieCHOU 3KOCHCTeMbi, KOTOpaH OTBO4HTCS nOA TOT nIH HHOU THn

OXpaHAeMbiX TeppHTOpHU, SiBJIqeTCS noKa3aTeiiem o6tueCTBeHHOri npHOpUTeTHOCTti

COXpaHeHHA penpe3eHTaTHBHblX y4aCTKOB AaHHOAi 3KOCHCTeMbi.

r) (DparmeHTa4UH KaKoro-AM6o THna nieca MO)KeT Bbl3bIBaTb HapywueHHq HeKOTOpbIX

3KoJIorHqecKHx npoLeccoB H pa3pyweHHe cpeabi o6HTaHHS. 06pa3ylowuHecs B

pe3yJIbTaTe 4)parMeHTaUHH pa3pO3HeHHbie yaCTKH iieca MOlyl 6blTb CJIHWKOM MaJbi

AAS coxpaHeHHA )KM3Hecnoco6HbIx nonyJISIuHIi BHAOB. PaCCTO HHU MeKY 3TUMU

pa3pO3HeHHb1MH yqaCTKaMH MOryT npenITCTBOBaTb onbTiJeHHu0, pacceHBaHI4O CeMAH H

riepeABH)KeHHIO aHKHX )KHBOTHbIX OT yqaCTKa K yqaCTKY H HX pa3MHOKeH[410.

B KOHeqHOM HTore qpe3MepHasT 4parMeHTauHS MO)KeT yBeiiHWHTb nOTePH BKAOB

pacTeHHi M )KHBOTHbIX, KOTOpb1e He clloco6Hbi aAanlTHPOBaTbCS K TaKHM yCJIOBHiqM. Ha

nnIoluaASx, nepeBeeeHHbIx B ceAbCKoXo3Hi"CTBeHHoe noAb3OBaHHe, ocTaBm4ecA 4)parMeHTbI

nepBoHaqaJIbHOrO necHoro noKpOBa MOrYT CJTYKHTb "y6exHuueM" AAI MHOrHX, XOTfl K He AAq

Bcex, KOMnOHeHTOB MCXOaHOrO pa3Hoo6pa3H4I.

Pfa3Hoo6pa3Me BJY4OB

a) )J,sA oueHKH 6nonorMMecKoro pa3Hoo6pa3HsI Heo6XOlRMmo npOBOn4tTb yqeT

KOJIH4eCTBa BHIOB.

6) 9KonorHiecKHe npoueccbi H BHAbl, BOBJIeMeHHbie B 3TH npOueCCbi, MOryT MeH51TbCS

B 3aBHCHMOCTM OT nflOIUaAH, COCTORHHA HJIH fParMeHTauMH KOHKpeTHorO THna neca.

FeHeTYVCCKOC pa3Hoo6pa3MC

a) JlecHbie BUAbI C HH3KOU qi4cJIeHHOCTb[O fIOnyJ15tIHIu u4nuI 3HaqHTenbHO

COKpaTHBUIMCSA apeaniom noABep)KeHbl oraCHOCTH nOTepH Ba)KHb1X reHeTHMeCKHX

npH3HaKOB (anineneri) U3 CBoero reHO4bOHAa. '-TO KacaeTCs BHflOB C "paCCeqHHbIM"

eCTeCTBeHHbiM apeaCjOM, TO 3TO MO)eT npOHCXOAHTb Ha YPOBHe aAanTHpOBaBwUXCq K

MeCTHbIM yCJIOBHsM cy6nonyARLuuii (npoHcxoweHHri), Bbl3bIBaq CHH)KeHMe

npHcriOcO6JIieMOCTH BH14OB K H3MeHeHHMM B oKpyxaioieU cpe,e.

Page 321: Russian - World Bank Documents

319 HPH1O)KEHHE K

6) MOHHTOpHHr xiHcJIeHHOCTH nonyfiquHA peripe3eHTaTHBHbIX BHAOB oHpeaeAeHHbIX6HOTOnOB HAH 3KOCHCTeM HO BceMy HX apeaniy BbIqBjiqeT cnoco6Hocm 3THX 6HoTonoBo6ecneMHBaTb BbIKHBaHHe Tex BHAOB H cy6nonyjiHuHq BHaOB, KOTOpbie 3aBlC51T OTaHJaOjrHqHbIX YCJIOBHr o6HTaHHI4.

KpHTepHu 2: CoxpaHeHHe IIPOJyKTHBHOCTH AeCHbIX 3KocHcTeM

a) Bo MHorHx cTpaHax HOTeHuiHajIbHbie o6'beMbI npOH3BOaCTBa apeBeCHOrl npOayKumHTpaaHUHOHHO paccxHTbIBaloTcs Ha OCHOBaHHH HJIOLUagu JIeCOB, IocTynHbIX AAAnpOH3BO1aCTBa JiecoHpoMblmjieHHOg npOayKW4 H. JIeCHble 3eMjiH CqHTaIOTCqHe,aocTynHbIMH An51 3arOTOBKH apeBecHHbI, ecjiH OHH He COOTBeTCTByioT MHHHManbHOnpHeMjieMbIM Tpe6OBaHH5IM nO BocnpOH3BOaCTBy JiecoB, no npHpocTy, no CTOHMOCTHHnI 4H3HMecKok aocTyrHOCTH. ayXOBHbie, peKpeaUHoHHbie, HayqHbie H yMe6HbieueHHOCTH ToKe MOrYT C4HTaTbC1 6o0nee npHOPHTeTHbIMH Ho cpaBHeHHIO C TOBapHbIMnpOH3BO,aCTBOM. Pa3HHua Me)Kzty o6tueri nHoLouaablO nIeCHbIX 3eMeCb H rIJIOLI.agb[OnIeCHbIX 3eMeJnb, aOCTyHHbIX An5I npOH3BOaCTBa apeBecHHbI, 6yzeT CJIY)KHTbnOKa3aTeCeM npHrOAHOCTH HnMH aOCTynHOCTH iieCOB JIA HpOH3Bo,4cTBaiieconpoMbIwleHHoH IPOAyKUHH, Heo6xoaHMori aAn yaoBJIeTBopeHHq noTpe6HocTerio61UeCTBa B apeBeCHbIX HpOayKTax.

6) aaHHbie nO 3aHacy AHKBHaHOA H HeuHKBKaHOi apeBeCHHbl oTpaKaloT B03-MO)KHOCTH npOH3BORCTBa ApeBecHoro Cblpbs.

B) AecHbie KyAbTypbl moryT 6bITb Ba)KHbIM HCTO'HHKOM apeBeCHbIX H HerpeBecHblxAeCHbIX HIPOAYKTOB, B 3TOM CMbIcAe OHH MOrYT 3aMeHSTb HnH AOrOJIHHTbecTeCTBeHHbie neca. B HeKOTOpbIX cTpaHaX B KaMeCTBe aJIbTepHaTHBbi JleCHblX KyJIbTypHCHOJIb3yeTCA BegeHHe X03$IiCTBa B eCTeCTBeHHbIX necax. nAouajb AeCHbIX KYJIbTypABnA5eTCA HOKa3aTenJeM 34(bIeKTHBHOCTM AecoynpaBJTeHH4 H CHH)KeHIHs YPOBHS3aBHCMMOCTH OT eCTeCTBeHHbIX IeCOB B rinaHe 6yayLuero npOH3BOaCTBaJleConpOMbbiwIJeHHOi ripOayKui4H. KpoMe TOrO, eCTb MHeHHe, 'TO HaYH'iHe JIeCHbIXKyIbTyp YKa3blBaeT Ha BO3MO)KHbIe H3MeHeHHA B 3KOAorHMecKoM H reHeTWIeCKOMxapaKTepe AeCHblx nHjoLuaaerl. MHOrie JeCHbie KyJbTypbI 6buIM 3a0oxKeHbl C LtenbloMeIHOpaUHm aerpaatHpOBaHHbIX 3eMeJb, HOTepABeHX 3KOIlorHqecKHe H reHeTMqeCKHexapaKTepHCTHKH pocwero 3LaeCb paHbwe ecTeCTBeHHOrO nIeca.

r) MOHHTOpHH-r 4XaKTHi4eCKHX rOaOBbIX o6fbeMOB 3arOTOBKH H BbIB03KH apeBeCHbIX HHeapeBeCHbIX JeCHb1X npOJYKTOB H ero COrOCTaBJIeHHe C HeMCTOLUHTeAbHbIM o6tbeMoM3aFOTOBKM H BbIB03KH OTpa)KalOT crioco6HOCTb nieca HenpepblBHO npOH3BOLaHTb JieCHblenpoL,yKTbI, a TaKwe 3KOHOMHIeCKHe H JieCOX035IHCTBeHHbie B03MO)KHOCTM.

KpHTepHii 3: CoxpaHeHHe 3AOpOBbA H )K3HeCCOCO6HOCTH JieCHbIX 3KOCHCTeM

a) AHTponoreHHoe BJIHSlHHe Ha JIeCHbie 3KOCHCTeMbl BKJlOoaeT B ce6H: nepeBo,AeCHbIX 3eMeJlb B apyri4e BHUDbI HOAb3OBaHH4I, 3arOTOBKy iieCHbIX nPOaYKTOB,HHTPOYKLULHIO HOBbIX B4,aOB, noLaaeeHHe eCTeCTBeHHbIX LHKJOB no)capOB HHaBOJIHeHHr4 H HHTpO,ayKLUH4O HeMeCTHbIX BH,aOB, oco6eHHo naToreHOB. 9TH 4faKTOpblBO3,aeAcTByIoT Ha 3KonorHqecKHe rpoueccbI, a qepe3 HHX H Ha BHILbl IeCHbIXpaCTeHHr4 H )KHBOTHbIX.

Page 322: Russian - World Bank Documents

320 HlPI4J]OIEHHE K

6) ECTb nollO3peHHe, 'TO 3HaqHTeJlbHbIH KYMYJHTHBHblH 344eKT Ha J1eCHbie

3KOCHCTeMbI OKa3blBalOT 3arpH3HHTeJIH BO3,Ryxa, 3TO CKa3bIBaeTCq Ha BO3o6HoBJIeHiH,

npOAYKTHBHOCTH H BHaOBOM cocTaBe JieCOB. ConocTaBMeHHe CTaTHCTi4qeCKHX aaHHbIX

H pe3ynJbTaTOB HHBCHTapH3aumH nieCOB H iieconaTOJIorFH4eCKX o6cneaOBaHHiH C

XaaHHbIMH nO 3arpI3HeHHIO BO3ayXa O3BOJI51T rlOJIyqHTb jiyIlwee rpe4CTaBjieHHe o

BJIH5IHHH 3THX 3arpA3HHTejieR. HOBblwleHHe YPOBHq yAbTpaqHoieTOBoro 13Jy'eHH.9,

Bbl3BaHHoe H3MeHeHHI4MH B aTMocd)epe 3eMAH, TO)Ke HaHOCHT Bpea paCTeHHAlM.

B) C noMOLUbIO MOHHTOpHHra CTpyKTypbI JIecOB HuH TaKHX JIHHeOHOB, KaK

nO3BOHOqHbie (KpHTepiH4 1), H3MeHeHH41 B 3KoJIori4'eCKHX npoueccax MO)KHO 6y)leT,

cKopee Bcero, BbIABHTb TOJnbKO CRYCTH aeC51THAeTH5 nocnie UX HaqaJIa. MOHHTOPHHr

)Ke BHaOB C OMeHb KOpOTKHM CPOKOM )KH3HH, CB53aHHbIX C TaKHMH cneUL4qm'eCKNMH

3KojiorHMeCKHMH npoueccaMH, KaK pao3IOKeHHm H KpyrOBOpOT nHTaTeCjbHbIX BeLLeCTB,

nomoraeT 6blcTpee o6Hapy)KHBaTb 13MeHeHHIu B 3KOJIOrHWecKHx npoueccax, HMelOWJHe

nOTeHuHaYIbHO Ba)KHoe 3Ha'eHHe xiJ nIeCOB.

KPHTePHUi 4: OxpaHa H COXPaHCHHe nOqBeHHbIX H BOARHbIX peCYPCOB

a) no4BeHHbie peCypCbl sBJISIOTCsl 6a3oBbIM KOMnOHeHTOM BCeX Ha3eMHbIX 3KOCHCTeM.

[IOBpexKaeHHIR nO'qBeHHbIX pecypcoB rOBJIHqIOT Ha )KH3Hecnoco6HOCTb H BHaOBOA

COCTaB neCHbIX 3KOCHCTeM. O6wuHpHbie nHoLuaaiH IO4BeHHOr4 3pO3HH MoryT oqeHb

CHJIbHO CKa3aTbCH Ha peKpeaLIHOHHbIX B03MOWKHOCTqX, HCTO'H4HHKaX nHTbeBOA BOabl,

CpOKax cny)K6bi peCHbIX HHd3paCTpyKTyp H BOaHbIX 3KOCHCTeMax, CBA3aHHbIX C

AecaMH.

6) OnpejieneHHe nHoiuaaIH JIeCHbIX 3eMeJIb, rae X03JiiCTBO BeaeTCS1 B nepBylo o4epeab

c ueCJblO HCHOJIb3OBaHH5 3a1lHTHbIX q)YHKUHH nIeCOB, nO3BOJ15eT noj1y4aTb aaHHbie no

COXpaHeHHIO UeHHbIX yqaCTKOB oKpy)KaiOweg CpeabI, o6ecne4HBalomHx YHCTbIrl

BO3AyX, 3al.HTy BOAHbIX H nO4BeHHbIX peCypcoB, a TaiKce 3al1lHTY OT HaBOHeHlHHf H

asBHH (4)yHKu14, o6ecneMHBaIoume coxpaHeHHe 3LaOpOBbsl H 6e3OnaaCHOCTb nKoaeg).

B) Jleca qBJIqIOTCS Ba)KHOA COCTaBHOA 'laCTbIO rHflpoJIorH4eCKHx LUUKJOB 3eMjiH.

Oco6eHHo Ba)KHa UX pOJIb B perynHpOBaH4H nOBepXHOCTHOrO H noanOqBeHHoro

CTOKa. 143MeHeCH14 HCTOp4qeCKOFO xapaKTepa H CPOKOB CTOKOB, npHBOS1uHe K

HaBOLHeHHAlM HnH o6e3BO)KHBaHHIO peK, MOryT nOBEUiSTb Ha COCTOAHHe BOaHbIX

3KOCHCTeM, a TaKeKC Ha XO3flHCTBeHHYIO aeITeCJbHOCTb Ha COOTBeTCTBYIOLuiHX JieCHbIX

Iolua]xx H ceCbCKOXo35H1CTBeHHbIX 3eMJI51X B HH3OBb34X peK H HX coxpaHeHHe.

r) Coaep)KaLuHecA B nO4Be opraHHCeCKHe BeCueCTBa HrpalOT Ba)KHYlO pOJIb B

3aaep)KaHH4 BjsarH, HaKOnHe1HHU yrjiepoaa H )KH3HH nO'BeHHbIX opraHH3MOB, OHH

TaKwe ( BAISlOTC5l HHaHKaTOpOM pe)KHMa nO'BCHHbIX nHTaTeCJbHbIX BeuXeCTB.

II3MeHeHHe coaep)KaHHli B nOIBe opraHHi4eCKHX BeCueCTB MO)KeT nOBHi[4Tb Ha

KH3HeCnOCo6HOCTb JiCCHbIX 3KOCHCTeM, Bbl3bIBaq CHHKeCHHe pereHepaLHOHHOHi

cnoco6HocTH aepeBbeB, 3aMeaieHHe HX POCTa H H3MeHeHHq B B1,aOBOM COCTaBe.

,a) ,aOCTynHOCTb fXlq iieCHOg paCTHTejibHOCTH HHTaTCJ]bHbIX BeLUeCTB H BJsari 3aBHCHT

OT qH3HqeCKOH Clnoco6HOCTH KOPHeBOA CHCTCMbI paCTH H rOirjOLULaTb nUTaTenJbHbie

BelueCTBa, Bnary H KHCJIOPOa U3 nO'Bbl. 3Ta cnoco6HocTb, B CBOIO oIepeRb, 3aBHCHT

OT MexaH4qeCKoro COCTaBa H CTPYKTYPbl IO'Bbl. HOXIHO4BeHHbie rxapoSorUieCKHe

npoueCCbI MOryT TaKIKe HapyUaTbC51 H3-3a YnHJOTHeHHH HO'IBbl, Bbl3blBaeMoro

3KCTeHCHBHOH qeJIOBseecKoI ReATeJ1bHOCTH.

Page 323: Russian - World Bank Documents

321 H1PHAO)KEHHE K

e) 3To 4aCTO HBJIHeTCH HHaHKaTOpOM COCTORHHiU rOiyJiHUHri 6eHTOca (opraHH3MOB,o6HTa]OIUHX Ha AHe BO,oeMOB). BeHTHiecKaq 4ayHa O4eHb MYBCTBHTeJlbHa KOBceBO3MO)KHbIM H3MeHeHHRM B BOAHbIX 3KOCHCTeMaX, HanpMmep K 3aHJHBaHNIo,

I3MeHeHHAM YPOBHek KHcjiopoa 1 TeMnepaTypbl. TaKHe H3MeHeHHR MoryT 6bITbpe3yAbTaTOM H3MeHeHHri, npoHcXo11HuHX B ropHbIX .necax.

)K) MOHHTOpHHr KaqeCTBa BOUbl Ha 6oAbuWHx TePpHTOpHAX MOA(HO HCnOJIb3OBaTb ';lqriepBOHaMabHOrO BbISBneHHA Bo3UeACTBHA ReqTeCJbHOCTH B niecy nHJ1 3a eronpeaeniamu Ha COCTOAHHe 3KOCHCTeMbi.

KpHwepHR 5: CoxpaHeHHe ponu neca B rJIo6aJibHoM KpyroBopoTe yrnepojRa

a/6) HaKorileHHe 6HoMaccbl B BHUe )KHBOA paCTHTeAbHOCTH, OpraHH4eCKHXOCTaTKOB, TOp4ba H nO4Bbl (yrAepoaHoro nynia) 5BJIAeTTCH Ba)KHOU (byHKUHer4 JneCOB Bperys4pOBaHHH co,epxKaHHq yrjiepoAa B aTMocqjepe. EHojiorHIeCKaA npOayKT4BHOCTbTOxKe MO)KeT 6blTb noKa3aTeJIeM COCTOSH45 H )lKH3Hecnoco6HOCT4 nieca.

B) 3KOJ0Or1HeCKH 3ApaBoe U paLHoHaHJbHoe BeAeHHe niecHoro XO3.qriCTBa B3KCnjiyaTaUHOHHbIX niecax H aoJIroCpo4Hoe HCnOJnb3OBaHHe JieCHou npo0,yKLIHH MoryTBHOCHTb CBOH BKjiaI B peryjiIpOBaHHe nocTyrmeHH5 yrJiepoaa B aTMOcDepy 3eMnH.

KoHKpeTHmIe nporpaMMJ ycTo#-qXBoro ynpaBJIeHHA JieCHbIMH pecypcami

MeWHapo,aHaH J7POFPaMM8 C03,4aHHW COTH MOaTCfhHAM JIeCOB

C ueflblO coxpaHeHHR nieCOB anS 6 yAymi4x nOKojieHHu KaHaaa H PoccUSnpHCTyHIJIH K OCyIiueCTBJ1eHHIO npOrpaMMbI COTpyAHHqeCTBa, rHpeayCMaTpHBalOWeHpa3pa6oTKy H peanjH3atLHio oeACTByIOaUHX MoAejief4 paLHoHajibHoro ynpaBjieHHH niecaMH. npunoaaep)KKe ($eaepaj¶bHoA cyK6bu JIeCHoro X03,IriCTBa PoccHH H npaBHTeJIbCTBa KaHarbI BpaMKax MeXyHapoaHbIx HHHuLiaTHB no ocyweCTBeIHHIO "3eIieHoro nnIaHa" B o6emxcTpaHax 6buIH BbIleJIeHbi nnIowaauH .ieCHbIX 3eMeJIb, KOTOpbie ROJI)KHbI CTaTb -iaCTbIO CeTHUaeCTBYIOLUHX Moaeier pauHOHanJbHOro yipaBjieHH4 jiecaMH. nporpamma AOJDKHa nOMO-bonpe,IejJHTb, KaK HaAO H3MeHHTb CHCTeMy yonrocpoqHoro ynpaBjieHHH JIecaMH, qTO6bl MO)KHO6bulI o6eclneHmTb BbICOKY1O HpOayKTHBHOCTb, 3LaOpOBOe BO3o6HoBjieHHe H 3KOJiOrH'WeCKOe

pa3Hoo6pa3He B 6yayLueM Ha OCHOBe COUHaJlbHbIX, 3KOHOMH'eCKHX H 3KOJO]H4qeCKHXUeHHOCTerH.

CeTb MOaeJ]bHbIX nieCOB npeanoniaraeT pacm4pefue TpaaiHUHOHHOA KOHUerLuHHnecoynpaBeeHHA 3a C4eT BKJIOioeHHS B HeC TaKHX napaMeTpOB, KaK MeCTa o6HTaHHq a4KHX)ICHBOTHbIX H pbI6bi, reHeTHqeCKoe pa3Hoo6pa3He H 4CTOpH4 KyJIbTyp, KOTOpbIe, no o6LueMynpH3HaHHIO, HMelOT Ba)KHOe 3HaleHHe H 1IOJDKHbl YqHTbIBaTbCH npH BbI6ope cnoco6oBynpaBjieHl4A jiecaMH. KpoMe Toro, TaKO9 nOaXOU K JiecoynpaBJleHU1io nO3BOJlReT MeCTHOMYHaCeAeHHIO HIpaTb aKTHBHYIO POJIb B HIPHHqTH4 peweHHHI, 6naroRaps qemy nieca 6yayTllPHHOCHTb BblrOUbI TeM, KTO AKHBeT B HHX unu PqaOM C HHMH.

FaccHHcKA MO,4cJTHAij iec (XaipoBcIfi Kpagi). FaCCHHCKHi4 MOReJbHbIir nec BXa6apOBCKOM Kpae IBjiReTCS 'aCTblO MeW)KyHapORHOri CeTH 4bYHKULHOHHpylOWHX MOgeJIbHbIXiieCOB, KOTOpaA BKJIiO4aeT B ce6A aeCHTb TaKHX JIeCOB B KaHaae, aBa - B MeKCHKe HnJIOWa,LuIH, HameeHHbe 4JIA BbiLeneHH rIO, TaKHe MOeJIH B MaJiarl3tH, CWA H apyrtx

Page 324: Russian - World Bank Documents

322 nPHAOKEHHIE K

cTpaHax. Bcs CeTb OXBaTblBaeT 6opeajlbHbie neca POCCHu H OCHOBHbie 3K00orHMeCKHe

perHoHbl CeBepHoH AMepHKH H IOro-BocTo'iHor4 A3uu. C riMomU.blO 3TOH ceTH MoaenlbHbIX

neCOB MO)KHO ynpaBnslTb pa3Hoo6pa3HbIMH 3KOCHCTeMaMH4 H pewUaTb CJIOKHbie COUHajibHO-

3KOHOMHMeCKHe npo6JleMbI nepexoaa K YCTOWqHBOMy pa3BHTHIOa1aHHbIX JIeCHbIX TeppHTOpI4I.

FaccdHHCKH Mo0eflbHbl4 nec fuHaHC4pyeTCsl B PoccHu Xa6apOBCKHM

ynpaBjleHHeM iiecaMH, $eaepajTbHoR cjlyK6ori niecHoro Xo35IiicTBa PoccHu H

AaMHHIHCTpaLIHeu Xa6apoecKoro KpaSI H AJenapTaMeHToM nptipOIHbIX pecypCoB.

1MH4opMauHsI, nocTynaioiuasl 13 raccHHcKoro MoeDenbHoro neca, 6yaeT npeaoCTaBJIqTbCH

BceM y4aCTHHKaM CCTH MO1eAbHbIX niecoB, a TaK)Ce pyKOBOAU4TelqSM RpyrHx JIeCHbIX XO3s1rCTB

Poccuu, MeCTHbIM rpag)aHaM 1 opraH43au m H MeXyHaPO0,HOMy coo 6uLeCTBy.

PacnpocTpaHeHHe 3TOU HH4IopMaijHH 6yaeT ocylueCTBJIlTbCq 'epe3 nepeHoc TeXHOJTorHui H

nporpamMMb1 HPOCBeLLLeHHs1 HaceJieHHsH.

raccHHcKHA MoaeJIbHbll nec 3aHHMaeT 384 TbIC. ra Tae)KHbIX nIeCOB B npeetenax

HaHaiicKoro pafioHa Xa6apoBcKoro KpaH, ero rpaHHUbl npOXOIST P.I OM c xpe6ToM CUXOT-3

AJiHHb H no peKe AMyp. JIaHawUIa(T - 3TO XOJIMHCTbie H rOpHbIe y4acTK4, nepemeXaloiuHecsi

C HH3MeHHOCT5IMH H paBHHHHbIMH y4aCTKaMH. Jlec IBSA2CTC5[ CaMbIM HaCeiJeHHbIM paUOHOM

UeHTpaiTbHOU 'aCTH O0JIHHbl peKH AMyp. 06wasA 'ICjieHHOCTb HaceCJeHHS4 IleCTI noceJKOB,

Haxo,flSUHXCA Ha TeppHTOpHH raccHHCKoro MoaenbHoro neca H pSi,aOM C HHM, COCTaBnSieT

4700 qenoBeK, KOpeHHbie )KHTeJii CoCTaBJSiIoT npHMepHo 40% HaceAeHusl. OcHoBHbie BHfbl

3aH5ITOCTH 3THX )KHTenerl CB53aHbI C HCHonJb3OBaHHeM JIeCHbIX pecypCoB.

B 3TOM necy npeo6JiaaaIoT TaKHe BHabl, KaK enlb a$THcKaq, 6epe3a MaHbqDKypcKaq H

Ke,4p KOpeACKHP. 32Iecb pacTyT TaKHe LueHHble nOpoabl, KaK JIHCTBeHHH4ua, nunra, HCeHb, BA3,

Ry6 U TonOJTb. Ba)KHbIM BH4,,OM xo3SliCTBeHHo4 AeSITeJIbHOCTH B 3TOM niecy qBgSIeTCSI

3arOTOBKa opexoB, nO3TOMy 6onee 55 TbIC. ra neca oxpaHA1eTCsq C 3TOA ueeIbio. K XapyrHM

OXpaH5ieMbIM y4aCTKaM OTHOCSITC5I HepeCTHJIHia LueHHbIX BHfOB nOCOCeBbIX pbI6. Hnioumaab

nieca, OTBegeHHasI Ho, npOH3BOACTBO apeBecHHbI, cocTaBjisieT 208 TbIC. ra H CJIy)KHT CbipbeBOH

6a3O0 Ag5l weCTH JIeCO3arOTOBHTejibHbIX H AepeBoo6pa6aTb1BaioLuWx npeAnpI4sTHH

HaHarcKoro par4oHa.

K apyrHM Ba)KHbIM BHaaM Xo35IUCTBeHHOA Ae5ITeJlbHOCTH B 3TOM niecy OTHoOCSTCSI:

ceJIbCKoe XO3sIgCTBO, OXOTa, pbi6ojiOBCTBO H 3arOTOBKa HeJpeBeCHbIX HnpoayKTOB,

BKTiotaSi Mea, JieKapCTBeHHbie paCTeHHSI, nJIo,bl H SrOAbl, a TaKwCe npHPOAHbie CMOJIbl H

MacJIa. Hp1i TaKOM pa3Hoo6pa3HH AHK4X )K4BOTHbIX (3Aecb BO,45ITCq CH6HPCKUH1 TH4rp, Ka6aH

H JIOCb) B 3TOM necy MO)KHO 6onee UwipOKO HCHOJ1b3OBaTb TypHCTH'-eCKHe U peKpeaLUHOHHble

B03MO)KHOCTH. ,aHHbl4 MoaeJTbHblrU nec 6yqeT OaHOBpeMeHHO 6a3O0 JIqs 3TUX BHfOB

X0351iUCTBeHHOR aeqITeJbHOCTR H o61beKToM OXpaHbl npHpOAHOA oKpyxaioLieu CpeabI.

3,aecb 6ynyT npOBOaHTbCqI i4ccjieAOBaHHi4 no necHog 3KonormH, BOaHbIM

3KOCHCTeMaM, cpeae o6HTaHHiq RHK4X )K4BOTHbIX H pbI6bI, oxpaHe neCOB OT HO)aPOB U

JIecoynpaBneHI4o. HeoTbeMneMog MaCTbIO 3THX HCccJieAOBaHHI 6yReT H3yMeHHe

3KonorHueCKHx, COUUHaYbHbIX, KYJIbTypHbIX H 3KOHOMH4eCKHX 4aKTOpOB C ueJblO pa3pa6oTKH

HOBbIX HOaXOaOB K YCTONHQBOMy pa3BHTH4o 3Toro par4oHa.

Ycnex nio6oro npoeKTa no MOaeJlbHbIM necaM 3aBHCHT OT HOXLePXKK CO CTOPOHbl

caMblx pa3HbIX 3aHHTepecOBaHHbIX CTOpOH. B pamKax aaHHoro HpoeKTa 6bIAt YCTaHoBjieHbl

OTHOwleHH1 napTHepcTBa Me)y npeACTaBHTen5iMH Bcex ypOBHeU ynpaBJieH IN, HaHaUCKoro

Hapo,aa, npoMbIwIneHHOCTH, HaYKH H MeAflYHapOAHbIX opraH43auL4H. ECTb HaaeAKna, 'TO

pe3yJIbTaTOM 3Toro COTrpyaH4qeCTBa 6yaeT ocyLueCTBJeHiHe C6aJiaHcHpOBaHHOH npOrpaMMbi

coxpaHeHHAS H OCBoeHHA nIeCHblx peCYPCOB Ha 6naro Bcero MeCTHoro HaceneHHI4.

Page 325: Russian - World Bank Documents

323 1PHJAOKEHHE K

B paMKax MeAKLYHapOaHOf4 CeTH MOeCJbHbIX JIeCOB 6yaeT HaIa)KeH o6MeHTeXHH4IeCKOA HH(DOPMaLUHeg H apyrHe BHabl B3aHMonoMoUt Mme)wY COTPYaHHKaMHFaccHHcKoro MoaenbHoro nieca H MaKrperopcKoro MoaeIbHoro neca B npHHC-,a1KopA*e(15PHTaHcKasI KOJyM6H4, KaHaAa). HlapTHepbl H3 MaKrperopcKoro MoaenbHoro .neca 6yayTOKa3bIBaTb nOMOUAb B pa6oTe H noarOTOBKCe cneuHanHcToB no BceM acneKTaMjiecoynpaBAeHHA. TaKHe CBq3H MexAY MOaejlbHbiMH AecaMH paCWHPAT o6MeH 3HaHHliMH,HaBbIKaMH H MeTOaaMH CpeAH 3aHHTePeCOBaHHbIX CTOPOH, MTO npHBeaeT K 6o0ee93"eKTHBHOMY ynpaBjleHHIO J1eCaMH BO BceM MHpe.

POJThMo,AJTHRnX JICCOB B pa3pa6oTKe cTpaTerHH paz(HoHaffhHoJo yITpa8IeHJ fIecamH1

B POCCHH eCTb MHOFO opraHH3a[LHH, aesTeAbHOCTb KOTOPbIX TaK HJIH HHaqeCBA3aHa c iiecaMH. KOOp,4HHa1UHq HX aeATCjibHOCTH He COOTBeTCTBYeT TeMnaM CerORHALHHXpedjopM, a HX 4)HHaHCHpOBaHHe O4eHb orpaHH'eHHO. Mexo1TpacAeBbie CBq3H pa3oPBaHbl.PewleHH., HpHHHMaeMbIe Ha 43eaepaJIbHOM ypOBHe, 'aCTO He Bb[rOJHqIOTCR HaperHOHaJbHOM H MeCTHOM YpOBH5X. PeaJlbHasl BjlaCTb, TaK we KaK H PeanibHOe ieCHoeXO3ASHCTBO HaXoQIHTCH Ha PerHOHanTbHOM YPOBHe. npoBeaeHHe nPaKTHHeCKHX MepOnpHATHUHa 6naro AeCOB 3aBHCHT OT amlRMHHHCTpaLuH4 pakoHoB, aHPeKTOPOB JeCXO30B H neCHH'IHX.Heo6xo,aHMo HCKaTb KOMnpOMHCCbi MeAXLy HHTepeCaMH CaMbIX pa3HbIX 3aHHTepeCOBaHHblXCTOPOH - JecHoro XO3AH4CTBa, AeCHoi ripoMbHllJIeHHOCTH, CeJbCKOrO xo3sArCTBa, pbl6HorO HBO,aHOro X03MHCTBa, ao6blBalowHx oTpaclel npoMbIwIeHHOCTH, 3KOJOrH4eCKHX BeaOMCTB,HerPaBHTenbCTBeHHbIX opraHH3aUHIi, KOMMePqeCKHX CTPYKTYP H qaCTHb1X nperipHATHA -Ha OCHOBe OTKpblTOO ro eMOKpaTHweCKoro o6cyicKeHHA LIA pewIIeHH B3aMHMOCB13aHHbIXnpo6neM COCTOAHHSI H HCnOJ1b3OBaHHH AeCHbIX pecypcoB POCCHH, 3KOnOrHqeCKHXnocJ1e,aCTBHi4 3KCj1yaTaLuHH nieCOB H coxpaHeHHH 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3Hl4. Moae.JbHbie .necaPOCCHU SIBJIAIOTCS5 npHMepoM TaKorO KoMHpoMHcca.

ATh COXpaHeHH .neCoB POCCHH Heo6xoaHMbi aeACTBH5 CO CTOPOHbl npaBHT4eJbCTBaH apyriHx OpraHH3aL4HH, HaripaBseHHb1e Ha AOBeaeHHe ao CBeaeHHA o6[ueCTBeHHOCTH TOrO4aKTa, WTO neca SBASIOTCS )KH3HeHHO Ba)KHOA qaCTbIO 3eMjieroJIb3oBaHHq. Heo6xoaHMoHaUTH HOBbie nOaXObI K COXpaHeHHIO iieCOB, COXpaHeHHIo 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3Hs HperyAHPOBaHHIo KJIHMaTa. YqlHTbIBaH cogepwKaHHe npHHHTbIX B 1993 roay OCHOB necHoro3aKOHo,aaTeAbCTBa POCCHUCKOU (DeaepauHH H BOrpOCbi COXpaHeHH neCOB H ynpasBeHHSHMH, BKJHoqeHHbie B "HOBeCTKy AHA Ha XXI BeK", MO)KHO CKa3aTb, 'TO A,lA BbInOAHeHH53THX 3aLaa4 Heo6xo1HMo:

* Pa3pa6aTblBaTb H ocyweCTBJI5Tb HauHOHaAbHbie nraHbl aeHCTBIH4 rio JiecaMB COOTBeTCTBHH C HaUHOHaJbHbIMH TpaAHIHlMMH, OrbITOM BeAeHH. AecHoroXO3qrICTBa H MeeK1IyHapoaHbIM OnbITOM COXpaHeHHA neCOB H pa1LHOHaJIbHOrOynpaBAeHH5A HMH.

* COBeplweHCTBOBaTb HaUHOHaJbHYIO AecHylo nOJUTHKY Ha OCHOBaHHHKpHTepHeB H HHIaHKaTOpOB paLIHOHaJbHOrO yipaBAeHHA necaMHrpHpo,ooxpaHHOA opHeHTaUHH, KOTOPb1e 6blnU pa3pa6oTaHbl B paMKaX"Xe.bCHHKCKoro", "MOHpean bCKOrO" H ApyrHX MeK,LYHapO,HbIX

/ 3TOT pa3aeA ocHoBaH Ha a'oKyMeHTax, !ioroTOBieHHbix OeacpaAbHoi c7yxK6ofi iiecHoro xO3JliCTBaPoccHN.

Page 326: Russian - World Bank Documents

324 HPHRO4CEHHE K

npoueccoB, HarnpaBJIeHHbIX Ha nepexoA K paUHOHaJlbHOMY JiecoynipaBeieHHIO

npHpO,aOOXpaHHOR opHeHTaUHH.

* CoaeuCTBOBaTb pa3BHTHIO H JiH6epajin3aUHH MeeWAyHapOaHOA TOproBJII

AecHori npoayKUHeA.

* Co3,aTb HHK4OpMaUHOHHbie CHCTeMbI Jnq MOHHTOpHHra paUHOHan1bHoro

necoynpawneHHA npHpoaooxpaHHOA OpHeHTaLUHH Ha MeCTHOM,

perHOHaJIbHOM, HaUHOHanJbHOM U rno6aAbHoM yPOBHAX.

* Co3jaaTb HaUHOHaSjbHbie H Me)KayHapOaHbie CHCTeMbi CepTHqKUKaH4H

AecHoR npO,yKUHH, OCHOBaHHble Ha npHHITbIX KPHTepH$X paUHOHanbHoro

ynpaBneHI4HS iiecaMH (3KonorH4ecKoe MapKHpOBaHHe).

Pa[tHoHanbHoe necoynpaEiieHue npHpoaooxpaHHOA OpHeHTauHH Ha

HauHOHanJbHOM H MeCTHOM YPOBHAIX o3HaqaeT 6onee 3KCTeHCHBHoe BKJlioqeH4e iieCHbIX

npo6ineM, HMieoluHx 6ojTbwoe o6LueHaUHoHanbHoe, 3KoJ1orHqecKoe H 3KOHOMiMeCKOe

3HaMeHHe, B npouecc coxpaHeHHA ieCOB H ynpaBjieHHR HMH, yqHTbIBa5 rno6aJlbHoe 3HaqeHHe

necoB KawaOU cTpaHbl.

B CBA3H C y4aCTtiM POCCHu B MeKgyHapOaHbix npoueccax nepeu Heri BCTaloT eLue

HeCKOJIbKO Aaam no ynpaBnieHHio ee JIeCHbIMH pecypcaMH:

* C4OPMyJIHpOBaTb npHHumnbI pOCCHfCKOA BHeWHeM nOJTHTHKH Ha

OCHOBaH4H meXC YHapOaHbIX aOKyMeHTOB no niecam H ,aTb 'eTKoe

orlpeaeJieHHe HHTepeCOB POCCuH B MeA(AYHaPOaHbIX amCKyCCH1X no IiecaM H

IieCHOMY CeKTOpy.

. CornacoBaTb Ha MeWAYHaPOAHOM ypOBHe KpHTepHUH H HHAHKaTOpbi

pauHoHaHJbHoro H 3KonorHmecKH OpmeHTHpOBaHHOrO ynpaHBeHuH iiecaMH

POCCHH.

* Co3IaaTb HaUHOHajIbHYIO CHCTeMy CepTKq)HKaUHH IieCHofR npOAYKLUlH H

o6ecne4HTb yqacTHe POCCuH B Me)IIyHapOAHOu cHcTeMe cepTTHHKaguH4

flecHOui npoayKuH4i, OCHOBaHHOU Ha KHpUTePHIX paHOoHanbHoro

ynpaBjieHuA iiecaMH.

* 06ecnem4Tb TeXHt'ieCKylO H TeXHonorwqecKy1O He3aBHCHMOCTb iiecHoro

ceKTopa 3KOHOMHK4 POCCHH.

JlecoynpaBJleHHe B Poccuu y)e aaBHO OCHOBbIBaeTCS Ha nIPHHuHne

HeHCTOIUHTenJbHOrO HcnoJIb3oBaHHA TieCHbIX pecypcOB. OnpeaeneHHe 3Toro npHHLHna,

KOTopoe BbIpa6aTbIBaJIoCb Ha npoTASKeHiH nOqTH Tpex BeKOB, 6buJo BK.lio4eHO B OCHOBbl

.recHoro 3aKOHOaaTeJIbCTBa H aoKyMeHTbI, periameHTHpyLuHe aesTeJlbHOCTb

roCyXaPCTBeHHOFO opraHa ynpaBseHHsi iieCHbIM X03SACTBOM, T.e. (DeaepajibHOA cAy)K6bi

iieCHoro XO3.qACTBa POCCuu, HanptIMep "06ecneqeHHe HeHCTOLU1HTejibHOrO Henpepb[BHoro

HCnoJIb3oBaHKA, BOCnpoH3BOACTBa, OXpaHbl H 3aLAUTbI pOCCHUCKHX nIeCOB".

ECTeCTBeHHO, B03HHKaeT BOnpOC 0 TOM, 5BjineTC5 ni cjioBocoC4eTaHHe

paUHOHaMbHOe ynpaBieHHe iieCaMH" CHHOHUMOM BbIpa)KeHU4S HnpHHLLHn

HeHCTOLXHTeJIbHOFO H HenpepbiBHOrO HCnOJIb3OBaHHH, BOCnpOH3BOaCTBa, OXpaHbi H 3aLUHTbl

pOCCHUCKHX iiecoB". Ha 3TOT BOripOC HeT OaHO3Ha'qHOrO OTBeTa, nOTOMY -TO B pa3JUV4HbIX

perHOHax POCCHH cTpyKTypa U KaMeCTBO nHOUaouer, KOTOpbie OqUHUaAbHO OTHeCeHbl K

Page 327: Russian - World Bank Documents

325 nPHJIO)KEHHE K

JieCHb[M 3eMARM, O'eHb HeOAHOpO.Hbl. O0lHaKO OqeBH4AHO, qTO nOHRTHe yynpaBneHKe"Wupe, qeM nOHSATHe "4cnojib3oBaHHe".

HUKTO He BO3pa)KaeT nPOTUB TOrO, qTO niecoynpaBneHUe MO)KcT K aOJ)KHOo6ecneqHBaTb H 6epe'b 9KOJIOrWieCKHe 4YHKUIHH AeCOB H UX 3KOHOMH'eCKNe LjeHHOCTH.OQHaKO, B CHJIY TOrO 'ITO BO BCeX cTpaHax, BKJ]OioaAI POCCUIO, nIeCHbIe peCypCbl, npeAnPlUTflTH4no HX HCnOJIb3OBaHHIo H CnpOC Ha J1eCHYIO npOaYKUHIO pacnpeaejAIHoTCS o4eHbHepaBHOMepHO, Heo6xoaUMo nocToqHHO KoopAHHHpoBaTb aeACTBHS Bcex riapTHePOB nOJaaHHOMY npOeKTy, 'TO nOapa3yMeBaeT onpeaeneHHbie o6A3aTenbCTBa H KOMnPOMHCCbl. 3TO -nYTb K yCTOAi'IBOMy pa3BHTHIO, KOTOpOe MO4CHO o6ecneqHTb C noMoilblo pauKOHaTibHorOYHPpaBJIeHHU IiCcaMH B yCJOBHsAX pbIHO'HOr4 3KOHOMUKH. MozeenbHblg nec MO)KeT CTaTb3KcHeptiMeHTaJIbHOH 6a3o0 ISA 13yqeHHS MeTOIOB pa3pewIeHHA KOHd)JIIKTOB 14 BbIpa6OTKHcoruiaieHlU4 MmeKy pa3JIH'qHbIMH opraHH3aLLHMH H MeCTHbIM HaceAeHHCM, KOTOpOe

CIcnOIb3yeT AeCHbie peCypCbI Ha aaHHOH TeppHTOp4H.

PaL4 HoHa/mHoe fJecoyHpaneHHe Nf Mc,eJIbHmf niec

B OCHOBC aaHHOPt KOHUelUUH MOmaJebHOrO Aeca Ae)KHT aHaAH3 KaHaaCKoRCHCTCMbI MoaeCbHbIX AecoB, npoBe2eHHbl rpynnou crieuHaAHCTOB lpeaepaAbHOR cAy)K6bjAeCHOrO XO3AUCTBa U3 Xa6apoBcKoro KpaA H MOCKBbl B aeKa6pe 1993 roQa, KU co3,aaHieFaccI4HcKoro MoaeAbHoro neca B Xa6apOBCKOM Kpae. B Pe3YJnbTaTe CnOPOB H o6cyKaeHUU6bmia Bblpa6OTaHa cAe,ayioiuaq 4OpMynHpOBKa:

,4e9CTByIOIau MCI WeTb YCTO,#VHBOrO pa3BHTHff .eCHbIX pa8foHOB, KOTOp,9 Ia.1OnHdqyHKL(HOHHpOBaTb KaK JIecoxo3JL4XcTBeHHoe gpeagpmff THe Ha OCHOBeMHOrOpeCypCHOmO yJpaB.JeHIHJI flcCaMH, BKmiOvaiOLe(O B ce6& MecTHyio riepepa6oTKyapeBeCHIbIX H HeApeBeCHMX peCypCOB, Co3,a8HHe COOTBeTCTBYlO0UHX 3KOHOMHIeCKHX

CTpyKTyp, C y-ICTOM HHTepeCOB BCeX napTHepOB, H B J7CpBYIO OqVepe,b MCCTHOIOHCHaCeJeHif Hf KOpeHHMlX Hapo0/OB, H 6e3 ywep6a awff qKoIIoFHvecKHx 0yHKuHR HCBOAfCTB JCcoB H 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3Hff Ha aaHHO#f TeppHTOphH.

MoAeAbHbie Aeca PoccHH cAeayeT paccmaTpHBaTb KaK 3KCnepHMeHTaAbHy1o 6a3yaAA mccAeaOBaHKi4 K BHeapeHHA HOBbIX TeXHoAorHM B BeayLuHx o6AacTqx AecHoro ceKTOpa,BKnto1a51 pa3pa6OTKy TeXHOnOFH4u AeconOJb3OBaHHS H LepeBoriepepa6OTKH K 6onee nOAHoeHCnOAb3OBaHHe HeapeBeCHbIX JiecHbIx pecypcoB, a TaKwce H3y'eHHe pbIHO'HOrO cnpoca HaAecHyIo npoQAYKUHIO.

JlecHOH CeKTOp HyKlaaeTCS B HOBbIX TeXHoAorIliX H TeXHHKe, BO-nepBbIX, ,anA TOrO,'ITo6bl POccHs morjia BbInOAHATb CBOH MemyHapOaHbie o6SI3aTeJbCTBa no paUHOHaAbHOMY KHeCHCTOWUITCebHOMY OCBoeHHIO BCeX THrOB AecoB, BO-BTOpbIX, AAA Toro, 'ITo6bl BbIBCCTHAeCHOH CeKTOP K3 TOFO KP13Hca B o6JacTK BOCnPOH3BOaCTBa peCYPCOB, B KOTOpOM OH ceuMacHaxoLiHTCA. MoaeJbHblg Aec - 3TO peaA]HCTH'ecKaA rorIbITKa HaUTH HOBblU4 noa1XO KBe,aeHKIO AecHoro XO35I4CTBa Ha Bceri njioiuaaH AeCHbIX 3eMeJb Poccuu H IcHOIb3oBaHlio eeAeCHbIX pecypCoB.

KaHa,aCKK4f 3KCnepHMeHT C MOaeAbHbIMK AecaMH rlOKa3bIBaeT, KaK Ha OCHOBeopraHH3auHH COBMeCTHOh pa6oTbl npaBHTeAbCTBa, rpOMbIlwlIeHHOCTH K 'aCTHb[Xnpe,HnplHiTH4 MO)KHO npHXOaU4Tb K KOMHpOMHCCaM MeuIy riapTHepamm paaH COXpaHeHHUA KICHOAb3OBaHH5I cnoco6HocTH AeCoB BbirOAHSqTb CBOH 3KOHoMH'eCKK4e, COIUHaAbHbIe,LayXOBHbie, KyAbTypHbie, 3KOAorHqeCKHe H npHpOaHble ctyHKUHH.

Page 328: Russian - World Bank Documents

326 nPHA1OGEHHE K

HPHHHMaSA peweHHA o C03,aaH4H HaUHOHajIbHOi CeTH MOaeJIbHbIX nTeCOB,

HeO6XOAHMO npoaHauH3HPOBaTb u o6cyRHTb pPA BOnpOCOB (co6CTBeHHOCTb, npOeKTbi J1eCHbIX

HccAepoBaHHI9, coxpaHeHie 64opa3Hoo6pa3Hs) H onpeaejiHTb cTpaTer4qecK4e uenu:

* IICnOJIb3OBaHHe 4HOpMaomU4H nO COCTOSHHIO Tex nOKpblTbIX necoM 3eMeJIb,

rie AOJDKHbI HaxoAHTbCA MoLejibHbIe nieca, 'qTO6bi onpeaejiHTb YCJIOBH4I H

nepCneKTHBbl HHBeCTHpOBaHHA B IaHHblii nec, a TaKwCe B

cejibCKOXo3.qriCTBeHHbie H JapyrHe CMe)KHbIe oTpacJiH 3KOHOMUKH C 4enlbIO

c6anaHcHpoBaHHsI Hx pa3BHTHA Ha gaHHOR TeppHTOpHU.

* Pa3pa6oTKa perHoHaJlbHbIX Moaejieg pa3BHTHAi necHoro X03,lqCTBa,

ceflbcKoro X0351UCTBa H arponecomeHuopauim Ha TeppHTOpU4 MOmaeAbHbIX

nIeCOB H pa3BHTie HpeAnpHHHMaTeJ1bCKOr4 aeATeJIbHOCTH Ha OCHOBe Bcex

4OpM Co6CTBeHHOCTH.

* Co3,RaHHe HOBbIX npeanpHATHiI X~A5 pa3BHTII1 HH4JpaCTpyKTypbi,

BbipalUHBaHHA nIecoB, JIeconoJIb3OBaHHq, nepBH4Ho9 nepepa6OTKH

LapeBeCHHbl, npOH3BOX4CTBa 6yMarH, JiecoxHMMiqecKoro npOH3BOaCTBa,

ceJIbCKOXo35IfCTBeHHbix npOH3BOaCTB H ApyrHx BHIOB aeHTenjbHOCT4 Ha

OCHOBe pa3JIHiHbiX 4OpM CO6CTBeHHOCTH Ha TeppHTOPHH MoaejibHbIX JieCOB.

* COaer4CTBHe COXpaHeHHio 6&opa3Hoo6pa3Hs, CBH3aHHOMY C 3TUMH iieCaMH,

H B3aHMoReACTBMe B o6nacTH npeaOTBpaiueHHs rno6anbHoA KJiMaTHmCecKor

KaTaCTpOqbi nyTeM BbipaLUHBaHHA HOBbIX nieCOB, KOTOpbie 6yayT norjioLLaTb

yrnepoa.

PaL(HOHa9bTHOC YIjpaBjeHHfe Hnpo6Ciemm co6CTBHHOCTW

PaUHOHanbHoe yripaBJleHHe JAeCaMH 3aBHCHT OT c6a.naHCHpOBaHHoro

HcnOJIb3OBaHHA nIeCHbIX pecypcoB H coxpaHeHHS 4yHKUHi H CBOUICTB necoB Ha 6naro Hauwero

H 6yaymi4x noKojieHtig. AA,AS yCTOU4HBOrO pa3BHTHA Heo6xoaHMo c6aniaHcHpoBaTb HHTepeCbl

pa3JiHIHbIX rpynn HaceiieHHA, npoMbiLLjieHHOCTH H opraHoB ynpaBJIeHHA iieCHbIM

X03AAUCTBOM, OTBeHaioLUHX 3a HcnOJIb3OBaHHe ieCHbIX pecypcoB, BKmO1aA apeBeCHbie H

He,DpeBeCHbie pecypcbI, H 3a pa3BHTHe Heo6xoai4Mbix 3KOHOMH4eCKHX CTpYKTyp H 3aHqTOCTb

6e3 yuLep6a AnA 3KOJ1orHWeCKHX CBOUCTB H 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3Hr .necoB.

RAns ROCT)KeCHHUA 3TOU ueju1 6yaeT Heo6xoaHMo H3MeHHTb opraHH3aLLUOHHYIO

cTpyKTypy ynpaBneHI41 iiecaMH. TaKasR BHaOU43MeHeHHaq cTpyKTypa aojnKHa o6ecneuHBaTb

HenpepblBHOCTb nOTOKa HHcjopMaumi no iiecaM, BKJlioIas RaHHbIe no cnpocy H

npeAno)KeHHIO JieCHoR npO)1yKUHH. 9AA POCCHu, KOTOpaS B HaCTOIu.ee BpeM5I nepeXHBaeT

nepexoA K pblHO4HOU 3KOHOMHKe H ped)OPMHPOBaHHe rOCyaapCTBeHHbiX aAMUHHCTpaTHBHbIX

OpraHOB, COBepweHCTBOBaHUe CTPYKTyPbl ynpanBjeHH5I iiecaMi TeCHO CBA3aHO C COXpaHeHHeM

rocy,aapCTBeHHOR co6CTBeHHOCTH Ha Bce neca.

CJIO)KHBwJJaAC5 B PoccuHu rocy6apCTBeHHa co6CTBeHHOCTb Ha neca npeacTaBjsieT

co6ou peanJHCTHecKyio 6a3y AMI coMeTaHHA HHTepecoB perHOHOB H rocygapcTBa B cjOpMe

c6ajiaHCHpOBaHHOu neCHOu nOJ]HTHKH, OCHOBaHHOUi Ha qeTKOM pacnpeAeneHH npasB H

o6fl3aHHocTeri Mew.Ay 4jeaepaAbHbIM H perfOHajIbHbIMH YPOBH1MH ynpaBneHJiH JecaaMH, KaK

nlpeAYCMaTPHBaeTCA B iieCHOM 3aKOHoAaTeJlbCTBe POCCHt. YM4TbIBaA pa3Mep H

xapaKTePHCTHKH poccHHCcKoro iieca (HH3Kaq flpO)4yKTHBHOCTb, OTCYTCTBHe COBpeMeHHOR

HH4)paCTpyKTypbi), MOKHO nOHSTb, 'ITO TOJIbKO rOCyAapCTBO HMeeT I)HHaHCOBbie H

MaTepHanbHble pecypcbl, Heo6xoaHMbie aq.I co3XaaHH41 CTpYKTypbl niecoynpaBjieHHR H ee

Page 329: Russian - World Bank Documents

327 HP14OAKEHHE K

o6ecneqeHHul KBaJH4)HUY1POBaHHbIMH cneutianHcTaMH, COBpemeHHOU TeXHHKOh, TexHoAorHeuH HHBeCTHUH51MH B HH4DpaCTpyKTypy necHoro xo3flAcTBa.

PRl#OHa/MMHOe ffeco,y77paeHmwC f HakYa

B aeKa6pe 1994 roaa COCTOAJTCA "MeAgyHapoAHblA HojiHTN4eCKHrh uatior nonpo6neMaM HayKH, niecHoro XO3,qACTBa H yCTOr4PHBoro pa3BHTH4I" (H1HAoHe3Hsi), B pe3ynJbTaTeKOTOpOrO 6buIo KOHCTaTHpOBaHO, qTO neCHaAl HayKa Bce elue He cnoco6Ha o6ecneq4BaTbpyKOBO,AHTeJiek AOCTOBePHOu H y6eaHTeJibHOA HH4PopMaUHeH, HeO6XOfHMog AnCBOeBpeMeHHOrO npHH5ITHq peweHHr. PeweHHAI, npHHHMaeMbie Ha OCHOBaHUH HeBepHO&UHAH Hea,eKBaTHOi 4HH)opMauHH, MoryT oTpHiuaTenjbHO HOBJI4,qTb Ha pa6oTy no o6ecneqeHj.noyCTOWUHBOrO pa3B4TI4T . nO3TOMy Heo6xoaWMO BeCTH Hay'4Hbie HCCJ1CaOBaHHfl AAnfaAeKBaTHoro HH4)OpMaUHOHHOrO o6ecneqeHHS npoueccoB npHfHH1TH peweHMA Ha BcexypOBH5lX. H4H4PopMauHSI AoJDKHa 6blTb aoCTynHOR, CBOeBpeMeHHOH 14 BbirOAHOA B nHaHe3aTpaT Ha ee nojiy4eHHe.

YqHTbIBaA BC1O HeOTJIO)KHOCTb 3TOUt Hpo6JieMbi, 3KCflepTbl pa3HbIX CTpaH HpHuWIHB Bb1BOAy, 4TO yMeHbie JieCHbIX oTpaciieU AOJDKHbl paClUHPHTb CBOU ropH3OHTbI 14 HpHHATbcneayilotue npHOpHTeTbI:

* YnpaBseHHe, coxpaHeHHe, HenpepblBHoe OCBoeHHe H yjiyweeHHe BcexTHnOB nieCOB B uenji5x yaOBJeTBOpeHHAl HY)KA HaceCieHHA.

* YTBePKaeHHe KPHTepHeB H UHaHUKaTOpOB pauHOHaTibHoro ynpasBeHHAJecaMi.

* OnpegeAeHHe npo6AeM ToprosnBJ H ynpaBIeHHAI.

* Bbi6op HORXOaOB K Mo6UHWI3aUmH 4HaHCOBbIX peCypCOB H 3Kojior4qeCKH6e3BpeRHblX TexHoTorHu.

* YCTaHOBjieHHe OpraHH3aLIHOHHbIX (4HCTHTyUHOHaYIbHbIX) CB513eri.

* BoBIeqeHHe B ynpaBJleHie TIeCaMH pa3HbIX CTOpOH, BKJ1iOLafl TaKHXnapTHepoB, KaK HenpaBHTejibCTBeHHbie opraHH3auHH H T4aCTHbie AHua.

* Me)KoTpacAeBbie CB513H H HHTerpaUlHA.

!UeJ¶blo onpeaej1eHHql MeponpHI4THH no coxpaHeHI4O nIeCHbIX peCypCOB, X3KoJIorHIHeCKHX 4)yHKUHui H ynpaBjieHH1O UMH 5IBJ15AeTCq o6ibeaHHeHHe YCHunH HayqHo-HccAe,aOBaTeAbCK4X H cneuHuaHuH3HPOBaHHbIX yqe6HbIX 3aBeaeHHA AAn pa3pa6oTKH r1porpaMMnOArOTOBKH cHeUL4aTIHCTOB, CHCTeM ynpasBeHHA AecaMH H yqeTa neCHbIX pecypcoB, a TaK)Ke=ml aTicHBH3aUHH o6LUeHaUnoHajIbHoro aHaAora o CyRb6e niecoB.

B o6cyvAweHi-H rpo6iieM, CB5[3aHHbIX C coxpaHeHHeM nieCOB, 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3HeM uKnJ1MaToperyAHPYIOLeru pOAb1O necoB, aOJIDKHbi ipHHHMaTb yqaCTHe caMbIe pa3Hble rpYnnbiHacenleHH5I. liX BOBJETiqeHHC B pa6oTy no CHBeHTapO3aUM4 neCOB H COBepweHCTBOBaHHlOTeXHOJIOFHrl neconOnb3OBaHul4 H BOCnpOH3BORCTBa AeCHbIX peCypCoB, crioco6CTByIOLUIXCoxpaHeHulo 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3Hl4 H IOBbIWUeHHIO KjiHMaTOperyjiPpyioLLLCe ponuH JneCoB, AOJDKHOnOMOqb yCTaHoBjieHlHo CBfl3U MeXKAY Hacen1eHHeM H JiecaMH.

B pe3yJ1bTaTe MHoroj]eTHeri 3KcnUiyaTaUl[H iiecoB BO MHorFx pertioHax PoccHufleCHbIe pecypcbl npeTepneniH KaqeCTBeHHb[e H3MeHeHH5. KpH3HC B JieCHOM XO3AriCTBePOCCHH llpHBefl K CHHxeHH10 YPOBHR 3aH51TOCTH B JieCO3arOTOBHTeSJbHb[X par4OHax. HOBaSI

Page 330: Russian - World Bank Documents

328 HPIPHO)KEHHE K

necHasi noJTHTHKa, HanpasBjeHHaq Ha nepexoxj K paUHOHaIbHOMy ynpaBJieHUIO POCCHUCKHMH

IiecaMH, aoJnKHa o6ecnemHTb coxpaHeHue H noJ.epKaHHe TpaXULHOLHHoro o6pa3a )KH3HH

MeCTHOIO HaceneHH5l.

PaWfoHaffbHoC fICCOYJ7paJHH H COXpaHeHHC 6Hopa3Hfoo6pa3Mxf

AAA noAaepKaHHI4 YpoBHA 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3Hq 3a ctieT coxpaHeHHu JiaHLuIa4ITa

(noqBbl, TonorpabHH H paCTHTeJIbHOCTH), 6HOTOnOB H 3KOJIOrUHeCKHX HHU, KOTOpbIe BMeCTe

oHpeaenTlOT opraHH3auH0 )KHBbIX OpraHH3MOB Ha reHeTH'eCKOM, BHAOBOM H 3KOCUCTeMHOM

ypOBH.qX, Tpe6yeTCs 60Jlbwe HHqOpMaUHH, qeM HMeeTCA B HaCTOqiuee BpeMI. Heo6xoAHMo

npOBOJaHTb HHBeHTapH3aUHIO BCeX THnOB JIeCHbIX 3KOCHCTeM H 6HOTonOB pa31HlqHbIX jieCHbIX

30H.

Ha 3KcnniyaTaUHOHHbIX yqaCTKax nIecoB 3BOJ1o04uOHHO H HcTopu4eCKH

CJTO)KHBwIaAc. M03aHKa 6HoTonoB, onpeAeniioLuasA 6uopa3Hoo6pa3He iieCHoP 3KOCKCTeMbl,

YCJIO)KH$IeTCR H3-3a HpHCyTCTBHs pa3HbIX CTanHu CyKueccCHOHHOr AHHaMHKH. Heo6xoAHMo

COXpaHHTb Te CyiUIeCTBYIOllWHe AHHaMHteCKHe KOMnHieKCbl CO BCeMH HX BHaaMH H

reHeTHMecKHM pa3Hoo6pa3HeM, KOTOpbIe npH6AH)KaIoTca K KTIHMaKCHOMY ypOBHIO.

PauuoHanbHoe ynpaBAeHue jiecamu 3T0rO Tuna AOJDKHO OCHOBbIBaTbCS Ha KOMnblOTepHOM

MO,IeAUHPOBaHHH nporHO3HPYeMbIX pe3ynjbTaTOB AeCO3aroToBHTeAbHog aeqTenjbHOCTH

pa3JIiHHOr4 HHTeHCHBHOCTH, Ha pa3HbiX nJIOuaqIX H B pa3Hbie CPOKH.

B YCJIOBH5IX HHTeHCHBHbix aHTpOnoreHHbIX Harpy3OK Ha ineca coxpaHeHue

KiiMHaKCHbIX nIeCOB H OCTaTKOB aeBCTBeHHbIX nIeCOB C Hx eCTeCTBeHHOu (bnJIOpO H q)ayHoR

CTaHoBHTC.q oco6o TpyAHOA 3aAaqeri. Hau6o0iee noAxoAULHuM MeTOaOM coXpaHeHHS

reHeTH4qeCKoro H BHl4OBOrO pa3Hoo6pa3Hs KJIHMaKCHbIX H npeAKJiHMaKCHbiX niecOB IBJIqSeTCS

C03aaHUe OXpaHAeMbiX ieCHbIX TePPHTOpHI B pa3HbiX rTpHpO1HbIX yCJIOBHMX. 9TH TePPHTOPHU

peKOMeHfayeTC.q BKJIIOtaTb B MOaeJlbHble neca. Ba)KHOr qaCTbIo pa6oTbl no coxpaHeHHIO

6Hopa3Hoo6pa3HH IBjiAeTCS BbiXeJTeHHe JTeCHbIX 3KOCHCTeM H iiaHAwa)TOB, KOTOpblM

yrpO)KaIOT HeO6paTHMbie H3MeHeHHS. TaKHe JiaHaWad)Tbl Toxe HafO BKJlOoqaTb B MOaeJ]bHble

nieca.

B oxpaHseMbie TeppHTOpHH aOJDKHbI BXOaWTb nieca, HMeioLu[He Ba)KHoe 3HaqeHHe

ans coxpaHeHHR H noAaepKaHH51 YPOBHS 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3H5s, a TaioKe .neca, HMe1OLLtHe

6oYIbWoe KynbTypHoe H HcTopHqeCKoe 3HaMeHHe. K cTporo oxpaHqeMbiM TeppHTOpHAM

AOJDKHbl OTHOCHTbCS neCHbIe 3anOBeAHHKH H AeBCTBCHHbie nleca, a TaK)Ke Jleca, B KOTOpblX

)KHBYT KOpeHHbil Hapoabi, 4eu TpamUHHOHHblr o6pa3 )KH3HH (oXoTa, pbi6ojioBCTBo, 3aroToBKa

AleCHbIX npOayKTOB) 3aBHCHT OT 3THX .feCOB. KpoMe TOrO, oxpaHqeMble TeppHTOpUUH AOJIKHbl

BKjiiloqaTb nieca, KOTOpbie YHHKKabHbl no cBoeMy BHAOBOMy COCTaBy, npOaYKTHBHOCTH H

reHeTHqeCKHM npH3HaKaM, H neca, KOTOpbie 5IBJISIOTCA tlaCTbIO KOPMOBOU 6a3bl H cpeiubi

o6HTaHHq )KH4BOTHbIX, KOTOPbIM yrpo)KaeT BbIMHpaHHe. 9TH CTpOrO OXpaHReMble JIeCHble

nnoiuapH peKOMeHAyeTCA BKJliOtaTb B TeppHTOpHH MoejibHbIX .ieCOB.

Fffo6a'mHoe 3HaveHHe niecoB

Fno6anbHoe 3HatieHHe JIeCOB CTaHOBHTCq Bce 6ojiee otieBHHbiM no mepe

Hcqe3HOBeHHS1 JieCHoro noKpoBa. KOHbepeHKLHS OOH no oKpyxaioLueui cpeAe H pa3BHTHIO

(PHo-Ae-)KaHeilpo, 1992) RCHO noKa3aJia, tITO CTOAeTHerl aBHOCTH BOllpOC o6

HcnoJIb3oBaHHH B03o6HOBJI5eMbiX peCypCOB Tuna ppeBeCHHbi 6onbwe Hejib3S paCCMaTpHBaTb

B OTpblBe OT HeapeBeCHbIX H HePbIHO4HbIX pecypCOB neca. POCCHR BnaAeeT OAHOA n.9Totl

Page 331: Russian - World Bank Documents

329 I4PHAOXEHHE K

nieCHbIX pecypCOB MHpa (nO 3anacaM npeBecUHbl). 3TO 03HaqaeT, 4TO paILHOHabHOeynpaBMeHHe, HeHCTOLUHTenjbHOe HCnoAb3oBaHHe, oxpaHa, 3aLU1Ta H BOCnpOH3BOaCTBO J1eCHbIXpCeCycOB POCCHU M5BieTCA He TOJIbKO HaUHOHajibHOr4 npo6neMorl, HO H rjio6ajibHOr4.HaUHOHanbHasi CeTb MOenjbHbIX iieCOB MO)KeT BHeCTH 6oj0blo1i BKJaa B peajm3aumo HOBOHifleCHOrl FIOAHTHKH POCCHH.

JlTepaTypa

Botkin, D.B., and Talbot, L.M. 1992. "Biological Diversity in Forests." In N.P. Sharma, ed.,Managing the Worlds Forests.- Looking for the Balance Between Conservation andDevelopment. Dubuque, Iowa: Kendal-Hunt Publishing Company.

Dudley, N. 1992. Forests in Trouble.- A Review of the Status of Temperate ForestsWorldwide. Gland, Switzerland: World Wildlife Federation.

ITFO (International Tropical Timber Organization). 1991. Guidelines for the SustainableManagement of Natural Tropical Forest. Policy Development Series No. 1.Yokohama, Japan: International Tropical Timber Organization.

*____ .1992. Criteria for the Measurement of Sustainable Tropical Forest Management.Policy Development Series No. 3. Yokohama, Japan: International Tropical TimberOrganization.

__. 1993a. Guidelines for the Establishment and Sustainable Management of PlantedTropical Forests. Policy Development Series No. 4. Yokohama, Japan: International TropicalTimber Organization.

.1 993b. Guidelines on the Conservation of Biological Diversity in TropicalProduction Forests. Policy Development Series No. 5. Yokohama, Japan: InternationalTropical Timber Organization.

Page 332: Russian - World Bank Documents

nP4J]OKEHI4E nI

MECWYHAPO,RHblE nPOrPAMMbl B JIECHOM CEKTOPE POCCUU

B POCCUU HMeeTCq OTHOCHTeJIbHO XOPOWO Pa3BHTaS ieCHas

1H4jpacTpyKTypa, BbICOKOKBajiHdck4UHPOBaHHble y4eCHbie, MHOrO'HcHjieHHbIe J1eCHbIe

npen,npH4ATH5 H onpeaejieHHasi CHCTeMa mep 3alUHTbl H peryJIHpoBaHHsI, KOTOpbie

moryT CIY)KHTb OCHOBOU win 6bicTporo H npOayKTHBHOrO pa3BHT4S1 CeKTOpa. O21HaKo

LLJI5I yCTOUYHBOrO pa3BHTH5 iiecHoro ceKTopa Heo6XOaHMbl CylueCTBeHHbIe

UHBeCTHUHH B MoRepH43auHio, TeXHHMecK1O nOAepP)KKy H o6ecneqeHHe OCHOBHbIMH

maTepHaiamH (oco6eHHo TeXHoJIorHqecKHMm). Bce 3TO HYXCHO RJIAJ Toro, 4TO6bI

pacWLHPHTb B03MO)KHOCT4 creLUHaJIHCTOB no o6ecne4eHHiO 3KOJ1oriMeCKH

c6anaHcHpoBaHHoro pa3BHTHf1 .necHoro ceKTopa. OCHOBHaq 'acTb MeWayHapOAHO4

nOMOLUH JieCHOMY CeKTOPY HaipaBjieHa Ha nOBbwllIeHHe npO2YKTHBHOCTH u

yCTOiYUHBOCTH nieCOB H COBepUeHCTBOBaHHe ynpaBieHuH5 iieCHbIMH pecypcaMH.

npoeKT no co3AaHMIO yrIepo,AoAenoHHpyilouHx jiecHbLX HacaxceHHH H oxpaHe

oKpyKailoueri cpeArbi

FpoeKT Ho co3,aaaHl4o yrjiepoaoaenoH4pylOLuHX nieCHbIX HacaxLeHHA H

oxpaHe oKpyxKaioluer cpeabi (1993 - 1996 rr.) qBJI5eTCTq COBMeCTHOA pa6oTori

YHHBepCHTeTa WlTaTa OperoH, CapaToBcKoro yTipaBJIeHHq niecaMH H

MeAcayHapoQHoro HHCTHTyTa ieca. UeJIb 3Toro npoeKTa 3aKJiio4aeTCq B KOHcepBaUHH

H CBR3blBaHHH yrnepoaa H o6ecneMeHH4 3KJojorFHecKoA 3aLUHTbl CapaToBcKoH

o6iiacT4. 3To nO3BOJIHT POCCHu BblnOJIHHTb CBOH o6sI3aTeJIbcTBa (nonyoyHTb "3a4eT")

no cHH)KeHH[O YPOBHA napHHKOBbIx ra3OB B COOTBeTCTBHH C PaMO4HOfI KOHBeHUHeA

no H3MeHeHHIO KiiHMaTa.

YHHBepcHTeT UlTaTa OperoH nomoraeT CBOHM pOCCUUCKHM napTHepaM B

3aKiia,aKe JneCHblX KYJIbTyp H COBCpwUeHCTBOBaHHH ynpaBjieHH5 iecaMH, a TaK)Ie

opraHH3yeT o6MeH HH(popMalu4eu4 nO KOJTHeCTBeHHOI oLueHKe 64ojtortiecKHx,

3KOHOMHi4eCKHX H nlpOMblwJ1eHHb1X pe3yJ1bTaTOB 3TOU pa6oTbl. B xoie pean)H3aUHH

npoeKTa 6yRyT TaKwe BblBJI5ITbC5 6apbepbl, npenHTCTBY10LoHie nOCTynneHHi0o 'aCTHbIX

HHBeCTHUIH, H HlyTH HX npeOaOJieHm5. nepBas 4ja3a npOeKTa COCTOHT B co3AaHHH

COBMeCTHOrO 3KCnepHMeHTanbHOrO riOeKTa B CaPaTOBCKOUi o6nIaCTH, Hana)KHBaHHH

KOHTaKTOB H pewLeHHH OpraHH3auHOHHbIX BOnpOCOB Me)KAy napTHepaMH. BTopaq

4)a3a ipoeKTa npeaycMaTpHBaeT C03aaH4e MoaeJIH iiecHoro XO351HCTBa aniq JaajbHero

BOCTOKa.

PalHOHajIbHOe HCIIOjb30BaHHe J1eCHb1X peCCwCOB CH6Hpu

PoccHucKa1 aKa,aeMH5 HaYK Hu (DeaepajIbHaq cjiyK6a jiecHoro XO3AAuCTBa

Be,ayT COBMeCTHYIO pa6oTy c Mex(nyHapOAHbIM HHCTHTlTOM npKAaLIHoro CHCTeMHOrO

aHlai3a (IIASA B JlaKceH6ypre, ABCTPH51) B paMKax npoeKTa no Kojt4HeCTBeHHOA

OueHKe 3KOHOMH4eCKHX 1 COuHajbHbIX (YHKUlH4 JieCHbIX 3KOCHCTeM CH6Hpu H

pa3pa6OTKe KOHKpeTHOA cTpaTertm niecHoro ceKTopa Ha nepHoa 2ao 2000 roaa. 3ToT

Tpexi1eTHHA npoeKT (1993-1996 rr.) 4I4HaHC4POBajicSi IIASA, pqaoM MewayHapOa-

HbIX 41OHAOB H pa3JIH4HbIMH pOCCHUCKHMU OpraHH3aLUmMi4 (BKJIUO4aq c4eepaA1bHbie

Page 333: Russian - World Bank Documents

331 rHPHAO)KEHHEJI

H MeCTHbie opraHbl ynpaBieHH4l), o6uwit pa3mep 4HHaHCHpOBaHHUA paBeH 305 MnH.gonin. CWllA.

Pa6oTbl no 3TOMy npoeKry npeaycMaTpHBalOT: aHTaiU3 COCTOSHHACH6HPCKHX JieCOB C iOMOllbIO C03,aaHHbIX B xole OCyLaeCTBAeHHM ripoeKTa 6a3,aaHHbIX; OUeHKy 6HoccjepHor4 pOJIH CU6UpCKUX JIeCOB, HX BJIHAHHU Ha rno6ajibHbieH3MeHeHHA, COCTaB aTMOC4bepHbix ra3oB H KpyrOBOpOT yrnepoaa; pa3pa6OTKyaHaJIHTH,eCKoro MeToaa MO,4eJ1HpOBaHHR aNHaM4KH pa3BHTKA CU6HPCKHX iieCOB H4OpMyAHpOBaH4e cTpaTerHH pa3BHTH5I rpOMbbIwIeHHOCT4, HH4)paCTpyKTypbl Ko6WeCTBa B JieCHOM CeKTOpe. Cer4,ac co3,LaHa 6a3a aaHHb[X, B KOTOpOU COaep)KHTCSUHH4OpMaLlUS O no4Bax, KJiHMaTe, JIeCHOh HpOMbIwIJeHHOCTH H COUHaJIbHO-3KOHOMHueCKHX acrieKTax. Uenlb aaHHOA pa6oTbl COCTOHT BO BKJlHOMeHHH 3TOU 6a3bl,aaHHbIX B reorpa4MH4eCKyiO HHOpMpaUHOHHYIO CHCTeMy (FHC) H npOBeiaeH4HaHaJIH3a COCTOSHHA H HCHOAb3OBaHHA AeCHbIX peCypCOB, rojio)KCeHH41 aeJi B JieCHOUnpOMbiwieHHOCTH H Ha pbEHKax, a TaioKe 6aiaHca ITaPHHKOBbiX ra3OB H H3MeHeHHAKIHMaTa.

raccHHcKxii MoLejibHbA iiec

B Ha4aTIe 1993 ro,aa B Xa6apOBCKe COCTOAJICA ceMHHap, nocnie KOTOporoMew4yHapolaHaA ceTb MOaeJIbHb1X n1eCOB npHHAiia npeAJoKeHHe o Co311aHHHFaccHHcKoro MoUeJIbHoro neca B Xa6apOBCKOM Kpae (cM. npHJIoKeHHe K).KaHa,MCKoe ipaBHTenjbCTBO BbiAenfHjio Ha 3TOT npOeKT 3 MJIH. aojLnapoB CWA.PeAbe4 MeCTHOCTH B 3OHe npoeKTa xapaKTepU3yeTCq HaJIHMHeM 3aTOfjIqIeMbiX aOJIHHH XOJIMOB, 3aeCb TaKXe npoTeKaioT 4eTbipe KpynHbie peKH. HPpeo6JIaaaoluOMHropo,AaM H,epeBbeB ABEIAIOTCS eJIb, 6epe3a, cocHa H JIHCTBeHHHUa. OCHOBHOri BKjian BMeCTHYI0 3KOHOMHKy 3AeCb BHOCHT JiecOXO3MIiCTBeHHaS aesTejibHOCTb, TaK*Ce BeAeTCAcenJbCKoe X03AACTBO H pbi6HaA JIOBJIA BO BHyTpeHHHX BAoIeMoB. Cpea4 HaceJIeHHI43HaqHTenJbHYIO Aon0)o COCTaBJISIOT KopeHHbIe HapOAbL. n[aH pa6OT Ha 1994-95 rr.BKJIIOqanj B ce6s pa3pa6OTKy reorpa4DH4ecKo HH4)opMaUHOHHOiu CHCTeMbi (Fi-C),npoew,eHHe WHpOKOMaCluTa6HO1 HHBeHTaPH3aUHH IieCHbIX peCypCOB,HCno0Jb3OBaHHe YCOBepleHCTBOBaHHbIX MeTOaOB JieCOBoaqeCKO ReSATeJIbHOCTH,oxpaHy nieCOB OT rio)KapoB H HX 3alUHTY OT BpeagTeJieg. npeaycMaTpHBaeTCs TaKwepa3BHTHe npOH3BOjCTBa HeTpaUHLLHOHHbIX AeCHbIX rIpOayKTOB H TypH3Ma.

npoecKT 1o paLTHOHanJbHOMY ynpaELneHHIO HpHpoAHbIMH pecypcaMH Ha JaJIbHeMBocToKe

I oHiyIaA (bHHaHc4poBaHme OT AreHTCTBa no MeKayHapoAHOMy pa3BHTHlOCLUA (USAID), aaHHblI4 npoeKT 6yzeT ocyHIeCTEJISTbCR non PYKOBOACTBOMKOOp,aHHaUHOHHbIX KOMHTeTOB nIpOeKTa, B COCTaB KOTOpbIX BOAAyT ripeACTaBHTeJI4Xa6apoBcKoro H npHMOpCKoro KpaeB, 3KOJIoruiqeCKHx H JTeCOX03HriCTBeHHbIXopraHoB ynpaBJIeHHH, HerpaBHTeCJbCTBeHHbIX opraH3aLMLH H apyrHX3aHHTepecoBaHHblX CTOpOH. nIpealoJIaraeMaA CMeTHa5 CTOUMOCTb npoeKTacocTaBJqAeT 16,7 MAH. Ao.IuI. CHWA, HcKRioqas BKAaa pOCCHUCKOU CTOpOHbl, apyr4xAOHOpOB H paCXo0bl Ha HOgrOTOBKy CHeuUiaJiKCTOB H rIpHO6peTeHHe o6opyaoBaHHqqepe3 pa3JiHxHbie aMepHKaHCKHe rporpaMMbl TeXHw4eCKOU H HayqHOh noMo0lg.UenIAMH WToro npoeKTa ABJS3IOTCSI nepexoi K HeCCTOLU14TeJIbHOMY MHOroLe1jeBOMYHCHOJlb3OBaHHI0 npHPOLIHbIX pecypcOB JIeCOB H paUHOHaHJbHOMY ynpaBe.eHo10 HMH,

Page 334: Russian - World Bank Documents

332 HPtJIOKEHHE Jn

BKJlHoMaioixeMy 3aLUNTY BHROB, KOTOpbIM yrpo)KaeT Hcqe3HoBeHHe, H KpHTHUeCKUX

6HOTOHOB B paROHe C4XOT3-AJIHH, a TaoKCe co3,aaHHe npO'HO9 HHCTHTYUHOHajibHOK

6a3bl =nq KOMnHJeKCHOrO fiJiaHHuPBaHHIA XO35iCTBeHH0I aeqTenJbHOCTI H

XaeMOHcTpauHH ee pe3yJIbTaToB.

ECTb Haaewaa, MTO B pe3yjibTaTe ocyLueCTBAneHH5 3Toro npoeKTa 6yaeT

co3aaHa OCHOBa aJm CHH)KeHH4R nonJHTHecKHx, npaBOBbIX H HHCTHTYLIUOHajbHbIX

6apbepoB, mewaioLiUx 'aCTHOMy CeKTOpy y4aCTBOBaTb B paluOHanJbHOM ynpasBJeHI4

iiecaMH U pa6oTe no coxpaHeHHuo 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3Hs; AnS IIOCT4)KeHHS 3TOU ueJnu

6yLeT co3,aaHO aBamuaTb HAu 6onee MeJIKHX iieCHbIx npeanpH5THri H nH5TbaeCsqT HuH

6o0ee MeJIKHX 'aCTHbIX dHpM, 3aHHMailOuHxcq npoH3BOACTBOM CB5I3aHHbIX C IiecoM

TOBaPOB H ycnyr H aepeBoo6pa6oTKoA. Eiue oaHofi uenJb1o 3Toro npoeKTa 1BJI5eTC5I

nOBblweHHe ponAH MeCTHOrO HacenieHHl H HenpaBHTeOabCTBeHHbHX opraHf3aLrh B

npoueccax npHHTHSR nOJIHTHtecKHX H nporpaMMHbIX peCwCeHH Ha OCHOBe

COTpynHHMeCTBa C MeCTHbIMH H perHOHaJbHbIMH opraHamH ynpaBJieHH59.

MOHUTopHHr HenapHoro meniKonpipaa (a3HaTcKoR pachi), po3oBoro muenlconpsva H

MeJIKonpsIza MOHalUeHKa

3TOT COBMeCTHbrlU npoeKT OCylueCTBJiueTCq C uenJbIO YCTpaHCHUI4 yrpO3bl

HHTPOaYKLUHH 3K3OTH4ecKHX BHAOB H3 nieCOB, pacTyWuHx B paRoHax UIOpTOB

BJIa,aHBOCTOK, HaxoaKa H BOCTO4HblA. BO3HHKHOBeHHe 3TOU yrpO3bl CBq3aHO C

HHTeHCbHUKauIteR BHeWUHe TOprOBJIH. HenapHbIl uweIKonpra pa3HbIX pac y)Ke

nOpa3HJI KaHaay H CW1A, a, no OUeHKaM JIeCHOA cJnyx6bi ClWA, yLUep6, KOTOpblH

Mo)KeT HaHeCTH HenapHblgweJIKonpqa a3IaTcKoR pacbi Mor 6bi npeBbICHTb 3,5 Mjipa.

,nouu. CWIA. 3TOT npoeKT CTOHMOCTbIO B 200 TbIC. ,gonu. ClIA IBJIqeTCq COBMeCTHOH

pa6oTou JIeCHoI cnyx6bi CIlWA, CJIyxc6bi BeTepHHapHoro H )4TonaToJIorHIeCKoFo

KOHTpOJI.S (CWIA), ODeaepajIbHou cnyiK6bi iiecHoro xo35qACTBa POCCHU, MOCKOBCKOU

cneUHaJH3HPOBaHHOA neCOyCTPOHTeAbHOi; 3KcneaHuUHH, npHMopCKOrO ynpaBeHJI4H

jiecaMH H aaAbHeBOCTO4HOrO Hay4Ho-HccIieaoBaTeAbcKoro HHCTHTyTa iieCHoro

X03sHCTBa. Pfa ycjiyr 6yaeT npeaoCTaBJIqTbc5 (I eaepanbHoA cuyK6o4 nIecHoro

X03SrUCTBa POCCHH B qopme MaTepHajiOB, o6opyaoBaHHr H TeXHoJIOrHr4.

Ue[ji5MH npoeKTa AEBAlIOTCS c6op HHd)opMaumL , KOTOpaI rOMO)KCeT

onpeaeJIHTb CpOKH rIpOBeaeHH$ 3aLUHTHbIX MepOnlpH4ITUI9, Heo6xoaHMbIX ax's

CHH)KeHHMR BepOATHOCTH 3apaAKeHH5 30lUeKiaaKaMH CYAOB H KOHTer4HepOB B nOpTaX, U

rlepHOabi MaKCHManJbHOrO PHCKa 3apa)KeHHS CyLoB, a TaK)Ke COBepCleHCTBOBaHHC H

pa3pa6oTKa MeTOLOB HaA3Opa 3a 3THMH BpeA4TeiiqMH H yJIy'weHU4e CBS3eA H

nepe,aa'14 UHH4opMaLxHH no oL1eHKe H ycTpaHeHuiO yrpO3bl pacnpOCTpaHeHH51 3Toro

Bpe,HTeafi.

3KcnepHMeHT no J1OCOBOCCTaHOBJleHHIO Ha pIaJ1bHeM BocToKe

B 1989 roay AIMHHHcTpauHu1 Xa6apoBcKoro KpaA, ,Iaj]bHeBOCTO4HblI

HayqHO-HCCJeIROBaTeJlbCKHR HHCTHTYT niecHoro X03ArHCTBa, KOnnriHCKUiI JIeCOKOM-

6HHaT H aMepHKaHCKaS 4upma Weyerhaeuser aorOBOP4JIHCb o npOBCeeHHH 3Kcne-

pIMeHTa no JieCOBOCCTaHOBjieHHIO B paflOHe nOpTa BaHHHO, Ha 3ana,flHOM 6epery

TaTapcKoro npouHBa. aaHHb1I 3KCnepHMeHT npOBOaHTCq C ueJblO Co3JLaHHI, YCJIOBHH

JAI BbipaULHBaHHA B nHTOMHHKaX BbICOKOKa4eCTBeHHOrO noCagO'iHoro MaTePHaiia

Page 335: Russian - World Bank Documents

333 IPHJIOICEHHEJ J

HY)pHbIX ropoL llepeBbeB, co3,aaHHA 6a3bl aaHHbIX A151 pa3pa6OTKH TeXHOJIOriHHHCKYCCTBeHHOrO JieCOBOCCTaHOBJeHH5 H HCrIOJIb3OBaHHul 3TOrO rOCa2OqHoromaTepHania anm HOCaAKH neca Ha Bblpy6Kax H rapsx. UeJIb 3THX pa6oT - iToaaBrTbecTeCTBeHHoe Bo3o6HOBJIeHHe MeHee )KeiiaTenJbHb1x nopog, THna 6epe3bl H OCHHbI.

L[o CHX nop nocaaOqHblru maTepuayi BbipauLHBaniH B TenHJiUHaX UeHTpaJ1ecoBOCCTaHoBJieHH51 KoMnaHHH Weyerhaeuser H ,ocTaBJIAJIH B KornHHHCKHIi JeCXo3H apyrHe npeanpHSTHu1 ARA 3aKJIaAKH 3KCnepHMeHTaJbHbIX KyJIbTyp. 3a niepHoii C1991 no 1994 roa 6bUio nocTaBneHo 6o0iee 135 TblC. ceSqHLeB. KpoMe Toro, KOMnaHH51Weyerhaeuser oKa3blBaAa nOMOIlib B 3aKynKe o6opy4oBaHH4A 21315 xpaHeHHR ceMqH(240 TbIC. ,AIonn. CWIA). B HacTosAuee BpeM5 16 TenHJIU, HaXOAHuHXCSA HeaaneKO OTXa6apoBcKa, npOH3BOaST no 13 MJIH. ceAHUeB B roa, 3Toro xBaTaeT 2131AyAoBJIeTBOpeHHR noTpe6HocTeu Bcero Xa6apoBcKoro Kpas.

3aKna,Ka OnITTHUX CecoceMeHHLUX nmaHTalmu COCHbl H enH

MHHHcTepCTBO cenJbCKorO H niecHoro XO3s1ACTBa 0KHHAlH,AIH 14rocy,aapcTBeHHbl4 KOMHTeT CCCP no niecy Toro BpeMeHH (ceWiac OH pa3,eneieH HaCOOTBeTCTBYIOiUHe BeloMCTBa Mexay POCCHUiCKOA (DeaepauHei4 H YKpaHHOIU)aOrOBOpHJIHCb 0 3aKJIlAKe OllbITHblX iieCOCeMeHHbiX HniaHTauUHr H3 ueHHbIX KJOHOBCOCHbl H enH B SApociaBCKOfI, KOcTpoMCKOUi H CMojieHcKOh o6JIacTAx.PaccqHTaHHbIi Ha 20 JieT, 3TOT ripOeKT MHeeT CBOefl LeJiblO lIPOH3BOaCTBOBbICOKOKaMeCTBeHHbIX CeMSH AAS i1eCOBOCCTaHOBJIeHHS1 B npHPO21HbIX YCTOBHHXPHHASAHAK1H H CeBepHoti EBponbl nOCpeaCTBOM yJIy4UeHHA HaCJIeaCTBeHHbIX CBOUCTB(6onee HHTeHCHBHoe H YCKOpeHHoe nJOIOHO=eHHe, cBoeBpeMeHHoe)H3HoAorHMeCKoe CO3peBaHHe ceMSH H T.n.) ceAHueB. CorIacHO pacqeTaM, o6wascMeTHaA CTOHMOCTb 3TorO ripoeKTa B npeaejiax POCCHUiCKOr (e,aepaUtll COCTaBEAeTpHMHepHo 4 M.iH. 4UHHCKHX MapoK.

JIeCoxo3IflCTBeHHbie npeanpHslTHsI, ocyLIeCTEISAioloHe aaHHblI npoeKT,yxe nPOBsenH noIroToBKy floqBbl H B3SIAH Ha ce6A o6s3aHHOcTH no orpa)KzteHHIOTeppHTOpHH, 3aiuHTe nOCaaOK H arpOTeXHH4eCKOMy YXOay 3a HHMH. Cegqac OHH3aBepHlalOT CTpOHTeJibCTBO JieCHbIX KOpAOHOB, yJIy'weHHbIX Aopor U CaHHTapHbiepy6KH B HaCa)KxleHHAIX COCHbI H eJi B 6y4)epHOA 3OHe 9THX nHJaHTaUUH.

HayqHO-TexHHUqecKHcIi npoeKT "TAfirA"

npoeKT "TAhrA" (TaeKHbie a3pOKOCMHuqeCKHe HccueaOBaHH5 cHCnOJIb3OBaHHeM FHC 13l aHaiH43a) OCHOBaH Ha cOrJiaweHHH MewayHaUHoHaJIbHbIM ynpaeieHHem CWA no a3pOHaBTHKe H HCccjieLoBaHHIOKOCMHqecKoro npocTpaHCTBa (HACA) H POCCHUCKOU aKa,eMHef HayK. B paMKax3TOrO npOeKTa B KpaCHOApCKe 6yAeT yCTaHOBJleHa CTaHLIHS npUema nepe,aa COCnYTHHKOB KOCMH4eCKHX H3o6pa)KeHHri BbiCOKOrO pa3peWeHHS H co3LIaHapOCCHiCKa5i Ha3eMHaA CHCTeMa LAOCTOBepHbix aaHHbIX nO pOCCHrCKHM 6opeambHblMJIeCaM B (popMe FHC. 3Ta HH(bOpMaUxHA 6yaeT HCnOJ1b3OBaTbCS AAA H3y4eHHInpO11yKTHBHOCTH JieCOB, HX COCTOSHHS, nO)KapOOnaCHOCTH H HCTOPHH IOxcaPOB BKOHTeKcTe rflo6anlbHoro KpyrOBOPOTa yrnepo11a.

Page 336: Russian - World Bank Documents

334 nPHJ1OKEH4E A

npoeicr "CHXoT-ARHHb"

3TOT npoeKr qBji5eTCH COCTaBHOU 'aCTbIO rpoeKTa no paUHOHajYbHOMY

npHpUo1oHrIJlb30BaHHI0, KOTOpbifl 4IHHaHCHpyeT USAID. OH OXBaTb1BaeT TeppuTOPulo

nHJlUa,AbIO npHMepHO B 500 TblC. ra B CHXOT3-AAn4HCKHx ropax B,AOJb TaTapcKoro

npOJIHBa, ero ueji: 3auHTa nonySiLA4HH THrpa, KOTOpOU yrpo)KaeT Hc'e3HoBeHHe, Ui

CO,aerICTBHe COuLHabHO-3KOHOMH4ecKoMy pa3BHTHIO KOpeHHOrO yA3relcKoro

HaceJieHH5l. PacMeTHaA CTOHMOCTb 3Toro npoeKTa paBHa I MJIH. AiouIJ. CWA. B ero

3aRaauH BXOAHT: 3KoJIoruHecKoe onHcaHKe H y4eT nOnyFJIMLUH THrpa H ero cpeRbl

o6HTaHH41, a TaioKe npHHATHe mep no coxpaHeHHuo 3TOR nonynjiUHI4 THrpa. Eiue

o,aHa H3 3aLaa COCTOUT B onpeaeCOeHuLHC HaJLbHO-3KOHOMH4eCKHx npo6neM

ya3reAcKoro Hapoaa B CBA34 C o)KHJaeMort Me)KayHapOAHOA 41HHaHCOBOR nOMOLUbIO

alnAS ero pa3BHTHA.

PeKpeaiAHoHHbie pecypcEi H pa3BHTHe 3KoJIorUHecKoro TypH3Ma B Xa6apOBCKOM Kpae

3To - CoBMeCTHblui npoeKT, B KOTOpOM HpHH14MalOT yqaCTHe: KaHaaCKaq

necHasi cniy)K6a, Xa6apoBcKoe ynpaBjieHHe niecaMH, IaanbHeBOCTO0Hbl4 HayqHO-

Hccne,aoBaTeAbCKH4r HHCTHTYT necHoro X0351iCTBa H pa3JIH'lHbie 3KoJIOFrH-lecKHe

opraHH3aLuH. OH COaeACTByeT pa3BHT110 3KOTYpH3Ma nloCpeACTBOM C03,aaHHS FMC

no peKpeaUHOHHbIM pecypeaM, OPraHH3aULu TypHCTH'iecKoro ueHTpa H pa3pa6oTKe

KOHuenTyanbHO-4yHK1LHOHajIbHOU MoaeJIH opraHIH3aUL1H 3KOTYPH3Ma H npyrux BHXOB

peKpeau4OHHOrO HCnOJIb3oBaHHS 6a3b1 flpHpORHbIX peCypCOB. KaHaaCKHU BKJ1aa B

3TOT npOeKT 6yaeT COCTaBJISTb MaKCiMYM 3 MJIH. KaHa,TCKHX ,onnapoB.

Pa3pa6oTKa MeTOAOB HCnojib3oBaHHS1 KOCMHUeCKHX CHHMKOB H rMC AqnHHBeHTapH3alAHH H MOHHTOPHHra nIeCOB

3To - COBMeCTHbflU npOeKT 4)paHUy3CKOrO HayYHO-HCCJieJOBaTeJIbCKoro

HHCTHTyTa ceJIbCKOFO H niecHoro XO3RiCTBa (CEMAGREF) H pOCCwiACKOrO

MeWxAyHapoLLHoro HHCTHTyTa nieca. QiaHHbir npOeKT BASieTCqI pe3yJbTaTOM

corAaLweHHu MeCay OPraHH3aUH5MH, 3aHHMaiOltUHMHCq KOCMHqCCKHMH

HCCJIe,OBaHH51MH B 3THX ABYX CTpaHax. $DpaHUy3CKaq CTOpOHa 6yaeT 6ecnniaTHo

npeCOCTaB1iTb PocCHH XaHHbie, noJIy-qeHHbie c 4X CnYTHHKa "SPOT". [IeAb npoeKTa

- c6op CIYTH1KOBOr4 UHHjOpMauKHH AAL pa3BHTH5[ CHCTeMbi 4HBeHTapm3aLIum,

npeAHa3HaqeHHOiA ARA KapTHpOBaHHl5 H aHaiH3a H3MeHeHHU B JileCHOM 4)OHae,

npOHCXOJU1LItHX B pe3y.TbTaTe aHTponoreHHOA Harpy3KH (py6Ka .neca) H nIeCHbIX

no)KapOB.

npoeKr BceMHpHoro 6aHKa H ruo6anbHoro 3KojiorH'lecKoro oOHAa (r3-I0) no

CoxpaHeHHio 6Hopa3Moo6pa3mm

FIpaBHTeJIbCTBO POCCHUCKOU c)eaepaUI4H B niHuue Focy,apcTBeHHoro

KOMHTeTa no oxpaHe oKpy)KaioIueA cpeP4bI U npH u y'aCTHH ($eaepajlbHOri cRy)K6bl

JieCHOrO XO3SACTBa B HacToiuiee BpeMH ocyuXeCTBJ5eT npoeKT no CoxpaHeHHIO

6Hopa3Hoo6pa3H.s, KOTOpblU qaCTHqHO 4)HHaHCHpyeTC5I BceMHpHblM 6aHKOM qepe3

rjio6a3bHblg 3Konorw4eCKHA1 4OHA (M3(), BbieJIHUBWBUI4 Ha 3TOT ripOeKT UeLjeBOe

4HHaHCHpoBaHHe B pa3mepe 20,1 MnH. AuonIB. CWlIA. ELue 1,1 MJIH. aOJInn. CWIIA

Page 337: Russian - World Bank Documents

335 11PHIO)KEHRE Jn

npe,aocTaBeieHo B KaqecTBe rpaHTa npaBHTenJbCTBOM WBeeuapHH qepe3 BCeMUpHbiH4OH aAHKOA nplpOabi.

npoeKT BKJloqaeT B ce6M nporpammy no coxpaHeHHio 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3HA BcTpaHe, KpoMe Toro, OH CBA3aH c npoeKToM no ynpaBeeHtIo oKpy)KaioLueri cpeaog,KOTOpblH4 (HHaHCHpyeTCq BCeMHpHblM 6aHKoM. OCHOBHaq LLeCJb npoeKTa r[3$ -rlOMOqb POCCUHCKOU $DeaepauLHH riOaepKHBaTb OnTHMaJIbHbie YpOBHH6Hopa3Hoo6pa3HH B COOTBeTCTBHH C HPHHlfflHMH 3KOHOMU4qeCK4 H 3KOJ]OrH4eCKH3,apaBOrO H yCTOh4HBoro pa3B4THq. 3TOT npoeKT noMo)KeT o6ecneqtHTb 6onee3("eKTHBHyIO 3aWUHTy 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3Hs Ha OXpaHMeMbIX TeppHTOpH5IX H 3a uxnpenejlaMH B COOTBeTCTBHH C KOHBeHat4eri no 6HoAorHtecKoMy pa3Hoo6pa3H4O.Eoniee KOHKpeTHbie uenu HanpasBjeHbI Ha: no=UePXKY B pa3pa6oTKe beaepajibHbIX HpermoHa71bHbIX CTpaTerHHi CoxpaHeHH5 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3Hs; pa3pa6OTKy H peana3auHIoMeXaHH3MOB H nOAXOAOB, KOTOpbIe 6yayT o6ecneqHBaTb HHTerpaUoH1o Hpo6JieMcoxpaHeHHA 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3HA H oxpaHbl oKpyxaioLuer cpeabl B rpoueccbIpa3pa6oTKH nOJIHT4KH; OueHKY HHCTHTyUHOHaBbHOtU CTpyKTYpbl OXpaHAeMbiXTeppHTOpHi H nocneaymouee nOBbliueHHe ee 34"eKTHBHOCTH; co3AaHHe ycJIOBHH ir4 sAy4aCTHA B pa6oTe no coxpaHeHlio 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3Hsi Bcex 3aHHTepecoBaHHbIX CTOpOH,BKJlO'4aA KOpeHHbie HapOabi H MeCTHOe HaceJieHHe; co3zaHHe MexperHOHaJbHOHMOgeJi COXpaHeHHA 6Hopa3Hoo6pa3HA H 3KOJIOrHqeCKH pauHOHaSJbHOrOnpHuPOflOOJTb3OBaHH4A B BahKaAbCKOM parloHe (Pecny6nHKa EypSATHq, HpKyTCKas HqHTHHCKaA o6iiacT).

Opr-aHH3alAHM upmpoHoOOjIb3oBaHHA B 6accegHe o3epa BaRKani

FpoeKT no opraHH3aIJH npHpOaOHOAlb3OBaHH4 B 6acceHHe 03epa EahKau(coKpaLieHHo "FaHKahlbcK1H4 npoeKT"), 4HHaHCHpyeMblr4 EBponeHcKHM CO0O30M BpaMKax nporpaMMbI TACIS (2,8 MJH. 3K10), rOMO)KeT HpaBHTJeIbCTBY Pecny6AJHKH5yps,THs H aMHHHCTpaUHH HpKyTCKOHi o6flaCTH B pa6oTe no coxpaHeHI4O YA3BHMbIXnpHpO,aHbIX peCYPCOB perioHa ryTeM 6o0iee 34IeKTHBHoro ynpaBnieHuRi JTeCHbIM4 HnacT6HuuHbIMH 3eMJI5MH AAA nepexoaa K yCTOHiqHBOMy pa3BHTHIO. nIpOeKTOMnpe,aycMaTpHBa[OTC5I nOKa3aTeCJbHbie Mepo[PHRTHR no niiaHHPOBaHI41OnpHpoLaononJb3oBaHsA, COBepweHCTBOBaHH1O MeTOaOB 3arOTOBKH nieca HHCnOJIb3OBaHHIO MooaejeH 3KOHOMHqeCKH paUl4OHaHibHoro ynpaBneHHA naCT6HUWHblMHyrO,4bAMH. npOecKT noMo)KeT yCOBepweHCTBOBaTb paUHoHaBjbHoe ynpanBeHHCe necaMHH MeTOabl pa3BeaeHI41 nIeCOB, rOBbICHTb 344eKTIBHOCTb H peHTa6eJIbHOCTb JICCHOHnpOMblwlJeHHOCTH perHoHa H rpOipeMOHCTp4pyeT c6aTIaHCHPOBaHHoe 3KOnOrHqeCKoeynpaBneHHe naCT6HWLHbIMH 3eM.TIAMH.

9KOuJOrHqeCKH yCTOriiHBOe pa3BHTHe B paHoHe o3epa bariKaA

3TOT u4HaHCHpyeMbt9 USAID rpoeKT HanpaBjeH Ha pu3BHTHCTeppHTOpHf B paroHe 03epa BaAKaji, nruoaLaAb KOTOpbIX cocTaBnAeT 6o0nee 4,5 MJIH.ra JieCHbIX 3eMeCJb. B npoeKT BKJnIoqeHbl MeporpHMTHAS, Heo6xoaRMbie =AuYCTO4HqBOrO pa3BHTHA 3anOBeaHHKOB, HaUIHOHaAbHbIX napKOB H Tepp4TOpHf4, HaKOTOpblX o6HTalOT lHKHe )KHBOTHbIe; pa3BHTH5 3KOTypH3Ma, paUHOHaJibHO4opraHH3aUau iiecHoro H cejibcKoro X03sliCTBa, npOH3BORCTBa AeconpoMbiwlenHHOHrIpo,yKuHH, a TaioKe pnA OKa3aHHS TeXHHqeCKOi rIOMOLUH B HpaKTH4eCKOHOpraHH3aLUH 3eMJIenOJIb3OBaHH5 H pa3BHTH5 CHCTeMbi OXpaHReMbIX TeppHTTOpHA.

Page 338: Russian - World Bank Documents

336 HPPJIOKEHJiE JI

Ue[Jb ripoeKTa 3aKJllO4aeTCA B YCTaHOBJieHHH OTHOWeHHA nlapTHepCTBa Me)KLy

pOCCIUUCKHMH 'aCTHbIMH npeanpl4pUTHqMH H aMepHKaHCKHMH KOMnaHHqMH, KOTOpbIe

MOryT npe1aOCTaBHTb HHBeCTHUHH, TeXHOjOrUHH H 3KCnepTHYIO HH4jOpMaLti4io no

BHyTpeHHHM H 3KCnOpTHbIM pbIHKaM C6biTa rIpOayKUHH.

KoMMepqecKoe COAeiCTBHe AecHOVI npOMbiuueHHOCTH

HOMHMO 3TOrO, pOCCHUCKHU iieCHOU KOMnieKC BblrOAHO HCnOjib3OBaJI

InOMOWb, rpeaOCTaBneHHYIO KOMMep4eCKHMH KpyraMH pa3HbIX CTpaH MHpa, B

qaCTHOCTH, KoMnaHuHMH CWIA, (I)HnJIqHaHH H apyrHx eBponercKHx cTpaH.

Page 339: Russian - World Bank Documents

Distributors of COLOMBIA GERMANY ISRAEL NEPAL PORTUGAL SWITZERLANDWInoenlace Ltd. UNO-Verag Yozrnot Literature Ud Everest Medca Interational Services (P) Ltd. Livraria Portugal Librairie Payot Service InstittionnelW orld Bank Carrera 6 No. 51-21 Poppelsdorler Alee SS PO. Box 56055 GPO Box 5443 Apartado 2681, Rua Do Carno 70-74 C6tes-de-Monthenon 30P u s blications ^ Apartado Aereo 34270 53115 Bonn 3 Yohanan Hasadlar Street Kathrnandu 1200 Usbon 1002 LausannePublications Santaf de Bogota, D.C. Tel: (49 228) 212940 T 1eAviv61560 Tel: (977 1)472 152 Tel: (1) 347-4982 Tel: (41 21) 341-3229Prices and credit terms van from Tel:(57 1)285-2798 Fax: (49 228) 217492 Tel: (9723) 5285-397 Fax: (977 1)224431 Fax (1) 347-0264 Fax: (41 21)341-3235countr ountry. Consult your Fax: (571) 285-2796 Fax: (972 3) 5285-397local distributor before placing an GREECE NETHERLANDS ROIIANIA ADECO Van Diermen EdcionsTechniquesorder. COTE D'IVOIRE Papasotriu S.A. R.OY Intemratixonal De Lheaboor/tnOr-Pubtikahes Compani De Librarii Bucuresti S.A. Ch. de Lacueez 41Center dcEdtion el de Difusion Atricahies 35, Stoumara Sr. PO Box 13D56 P0. Boo 202, 74o0 AEtHaasberges Str. Lipsacni no, 26, secor 3 CH1de7BloryayARGENTINA (CEDA) 106 82 Athens Tel Aviv 61130 Tel: (31 53)574-004 Bucharest Tel (41 21)9432673Oficina del Lbro Intemacinal 04 BP 541 Tel: (301) 364-1826 Tel: (972 3) 5461423 Fax: (31 53) 572-9296 Tel: (401() 613 9645 Fax: (41 21) 943 3605Av. Cordoba 1877 Abidjan 04 Fax: (301) 364-8254 Fax: (9723) 5461442 E-mail: lindebooworkdonflinenl Fax: (40 1)312 40001120 Buenos Aires Tel: (225)246510;246511 E-mail: royiltnetvision.net.H URL: hltpJAwwm.worlkdnbe.ntt-linceboo TANZANIATel: (541) 8154354 Fax: (225) 25 0567 HAMT RUSSIAN FEDERATION Oxford University PressFax: (54 1) 81548156 Cudtunre Dusion Pahtsiniar AuttrotylMidde East NEW ZEALAND tsdatetsto <Ves M> Maktaba Street, PO Box 5299CYPRUS 5, Rue Capois hIdex hInfornatin Services EBSCO NZ Ltd. 9a, Lotpachriy Pereutbk Dar es SataamAUSTRALIA,FUPPUA NEW GUINEA, CenterorAppliedResearch C.P257 PO.B. 19502Jerusaebm PrivateMalBag99914 MoscowtO1831 Tel:(25551)29209SOLOUON SLANDS, VANUATU, AND CyprusColege Porlau-Prince Tel: (9722)6271219 New Market Tel: (7095) 917 87 49 Fax: (255 51) 46822WESTERN SAMOA 6, Dbgenes Street, Engorni Tel: (5091) 3 9260 Fax: (972 2) 6271634 Auctddnd Fax: (7 095) 917 92 59D.A. hbmatbin Serices P0. Box 2006 Tel: (64 9) 524-8119 THFLAND648 WtidtehorseRad NicoDia HONG KONG, MACAO ffALY Fax: (649) 524-867 SINGAPORE, TAIWAN, Central Books DistrtutinMkdwn 3132 Te: (357 2) 44-1730 Asia 2000 LId. Licosa Cownanuonria Sansoni SPA MYNA,RNI306 Sioma RoadVcbria Fax: (357 2) 46-2051 Sates & CculatiDn Department Via Duca Di Caabria, 1/1 NIGERIA AsahWga PubUishing Asia PacEtic Pie. W. Bangl ok 10500Tel: (61) 3 9210 7777 Seabid House, unit 110142 Casela Postale 552 University Press ULited 41 Kalang Pudding Road t04-03 Tel: (66 2) 235-5400Fax: (61) 3 9210 7708 CZECH REPUBLIC 22-28 Wyndhem Street, Central 50125 Fffenze Three Crowns Buildig Jericho Goklen Wheel Buxding Fax: (66 2) 237-321E-mail: serviceOdadirect.com.au National tnfmatbon Center Hong Kong Tel: (SS) 645415 Privr,e Mel Bag 5095 Singppore 349318URL: hmpi/wwe .dadirect.com.au proDepa, Konviktsta S Tel: (852) 2530-1409 Fax: (55) 641-257 badan Tel: (65) 741-5166 TRINIDAD & TOBAGO,CS -113 57 Prague 1 Fax: (852)2526-1107 E-nail: [email protected] Tel: (234 22) 41-1356 Fax: (65) 742-9356 AND THE CARRtBBEANAUSTRIA Tel: (42 2) 2422-9433 E-mal: salesOasia2000.com.hk Ud: hNpi/rww .ffbccitticosa Fax: (234 22) 41-2056 E-mai: [email protected] Systematics Studies UnitGeroid a Co. Fax: (42 2) 2422-1484 URL: htlpJAeww asia2000.com.hk 9 Waes StreetWeihburggasse 26 URL: hIpVJAww .nis.cz/ JAMAICA NORWAY SLOVENtA Curepe41011 Wen HUNGARY tan Randl Pubrishers Ud. NlC hnio AS Gospodarski Vestnik Pubishing Group Trhindad, West hidesTel: (43 1)512-47-314- DENMARK Euro tso Service 206 Old Hope Road, Kigton 6 Book Department, Posthoks 6512 Eterstad Dnajska cesta S Tel: (809) 662-5654Fax: (431) 512-47-31-29 SarrdmdxsLferatur Margdszgeti Euxpa Haz Tel: 909-927-2085 N-606 Oslo 1000 Ljrbera Fax: (809) 662-5654URL:hllpJireww.gerld.coat.onlrne Rosenoerns Ald 11 H-1138Budapest Fax:809-977-0243 Tel: (472)(97-4500 Tel: (38661)1338347;1321230 E-mai:tobeOtrinkiad.netDK-1970 Frederiksberg C Tel: (361)1 1 6061 E-mail: irplfcois.corm Fax: (47 22) 97-4545 Fax: (386 61)133 80 30BANGLADESH Tel: (45 31) 351942 Fax: (361) 302 5035 E-mad: [email protected] UGANDAMicro Industries Development Fax: (45 31) 357822 E-mail: eurohinhdmail.mabv.hu JAPAN PAKISTAN Gustro Ld.Assistance Society (MIDAS) Eastem Book Service Mirza Book Agency SOUTH AFRICA, BOTSWANA PO Box 9997, Madhvani BuilIgHouse 5, Road 16 ECUADOR INDIA 3-13 Hongo 3rchome, Bunkyo-ku 65, Shahreh-e-4uad-e-Azam Inlematinel Subscriptkn Servce Plot 1614 Jina Rd.Dhanmond RtArea LtriMMundi Allied PubtishersLtd. lTkyo 113 LahoreS4000 PO. Box41095 KampalaDhaka 1209 Lbnrria Itdemaacinal 751 Mount Road Tel: (81 3) 38184861 Tel: (92 42) 735 3601 Craighat Tel: (256 41) 254 763Tel:(8802)326427 PO.Box17-01-3029 Madras-600002 Fax:(81 3)3819-0864 Fax:(9242)5763714 Johamnesburg2024 Fax:(25641)251 468Fax: (880 2)811186 Juan Leon Mesa 851 Tel: (9144) 852-3938 E-mail: orders@*svt-ebs.co.p Tel: (2711)880-1448Oudo Fax: (91 44)852-0649 URL: htp-J/www.bekkoame.orjp/-svt-ebs Oxford University Press Fax: (27 11)880-6248 UNITED KINGDOMBELGIUM Tel: (593 2) 521-606; (593 2) 544-185 5 Bangalore Town E-mail: [email protected] Microhhn Ltd.Jean De Lannoy Fax: (59322) 504-209 INDONESIA KENYA Sharae FaLatP PO. Box 3, Aton, Harmpshire GU34 2PGAv. du Rui 202 E-mfail libresrul @11brhinundi.cDrn.ec Pt. Incira Limited Atrira Book Service (E.A.) Ltd. PO Box 13033 SPAIN Englan1060 Brussels E-mail: ibrinu21brinund.com.ec Jalan Borobudur 20 Quaran House, Mlangano Street Karachi-75350 Mundi-Prensa Lbos, S.A. Tel: (44 1420) 86848Tel: (32 2) 538-5169 PO. Box 191 PO. Box 45245 Tel: (92 21) 446307 Castello 37 Fax: (44 1420) 89989Fax: (32 2) 538-0841 EGYPT, ARAB REPUBLIC OF Jakarta 10320 Nairobi Fax: (92 21) 4547640 28001 Madrid E-mad: [email protected] Ahram Dilstution Agency T 1: (62 21) 390-4290 Tel: (254 2) 223 641 E-mail: [email protected] Tel: (34 1) 431-3399 URL: httpiAww .mkirohho.co.ukBRAZIL At Gaba Street Fax: (62 21) 4214289 Fax: (254 2) 330 272 Fax: (341) 575-3998Publicaciles Tecnicas Intemacionais Ltd. Cairo Pak Book Corporation E-mail: [email protected] VENEZUELARuaPesoto Gomide, 209 Tel: (202) 5786083 IRAN KOREA, REPUBLIC OF Aziz Charnbers 21, Queens Road URL: hxpitwww.rnunc1iprensa.es/ 1ecri-Ciencia Lbros, SA.01409 Sao Paulo, sP Fax: (20 2) 578-6833 Ketab Sara Co. Publishers Daejosn Trading Co. Ltd. Lahore Centm Cura Comercil TamancoTel: (55 11)259-6644 Khaled Esamboli Ave., 6th Street PO. Box 34, Youida, 706 Seoun Bldg Tel: (9242) 6363222; 636 0885 Mundi-Prnnsa Barcelona Nivel C2, CaracasFax: (55 11) 25896990 The Middle East Observer Kusheh Delafrooz No. 8 44-6 Youbdo-Dong, Yeongchengpo-Ku Fax: (92 42) 636 2328 Consell de Cent, 391 Tel: (58 2) 959 5547; 5035; 0016E-mail: postxmasterdlpti.tol.br 41, Sherd Street PO. Box 15745-733 Seoul E-mail: pbhcbrain.net.pk 08009 Barcelona Fax: (58 2) 959 5636URL: hltp://ww .uol.br Cairo Tehran Tel: (82 2) 785-1631/4 Tel: (34 3) 488-3492Tel: (202) 393-9732 Tel: (98 21) 8717819 8716104 Fax: (822)794-0315 PERU Fax: (343)487-7659 ZAMBIACANADA Fax. (202) 393-9732 Fax: (9821)8712479 Edidorisl Desarmio SA E-mail: barcelona0mundiprensa.es University Bookshop, Universityd o ZambiaRenou Publishing Co. Ltd. E-mail: [email protected] MALAYSIA Apartado 3824, Lima 1 Great East Road Canpus5369 Canotek Road FINLAND University ol Malaya CDoperatie Tel: (51 14) 285380 SRI LANKA, THE MALDIVES PO. Box 32379Ottawa, Ontario K1J 93 Akateemian Kirtakauppa Kowkab Publishers Bookshop, Limied Fax: (51 14) 296628 Lake House Bookshop LusakaTel: (613)745-2665 P0. Bux 128 PO. Bax 19575-511 PO. Box 1127 100, Sir Chittampalam Gardiner Mawatha Tel: (2601)252576Fax: (613) 745-7660 FIN-00101 Hetsirki Tehran Jalan Pants, Baru PHILIPPINES Cobrrbo 2 Fax: (260 1) 253 952E-mail: order.dept0renoutbooks.com Tel: (3500)121 4418 Tel: (9821)256-3723 59700 Kual Lwapur lntemational Booksource Center Inc. Tel: (94 1)32105URL:httpJ/www.renoxlbooks.cam Fax- (3580)121-4435 Fax: (90 21) 250-3723 Tel:(603)756-5000 1127-A Antipolo St, Barangay,Venezuela Fax: (941)432104 ZIMBABWEE-mail: [email protected] Fax: (603) 7554424 Makati City E-mail: LHLsr.lanka.net Longman Zimbabwe (Pvt.)Ltd.CHINA URL: httpJ/Avww.akateeminen.coxrr IRELAND Tel: (63 2)896 6501;6505; 6507 Toude Road, ArdbennieChina Financial & Economic Govemment Supplies Agency MEXICO Fax: (63 2) 896 1741 SWEDEN PO. Box STi 25Publishing House FRANCE Ohig an tSob6thair INFOTEC Wennergren-Williams AB Southerton8, Da Fo Si Dong Jb Wodd Bank Publications 4-5 Harcoun Road Av. San Femando No.37 POLAND PO. Bux 1305 HarareBeijing 66, avenue d lena Dublin 2 Col. Torello Guerra Intemationa Publishing Service S-171 25 Solna Tel: (263 4) 6216617Tel: (8610)6333-8257 75116 Pads Tel: (353 1)661-3111 14050 Mexico, D.F Ul. Piekna31/37 Tel: (46 8) 705-97-50 Fax: (2634)621670Fax: (86 10) 6401-7365 Tel: (331) 40-69-30-56/57 Fax: (353 1) 475-2670 Tel. (52 5) 624-2800 00-677 Warzawa Fax: (46 8) 27-00-71Fax: (33 1) 40-69-30-68 Fax: (52 5) 624-2822 Tel: (48 2) 628-609 E-mail: mail 0wwi.se

E-mai: nlatec@rtnlxetimx Fax: (48 2) 621-7255URL: hftpi/rtn net mx E-mail: books%ipsiikpamrcomn.pl

07URL: httipwvw .ipscg waw.ptlips/exponlt

Page 340: Russian - World Bank Documents
Page 341: Russian - World Bank Documents
Page 342: Russian - World Bank Documents

28760

IBRD 27086R IBRD 27087R

POCCWMCKA51 $EiLEPALALI1 POCCV1HCKASI cE)EPALALIR

0630P J1ECHOf4 nOJ1MT4KI 0530P JiECHOL nfOJltTMKHTfnbl iECOB I OXPAH5IEMblE TEPPMTOP1IH JlECHA51 WHHYCTPLIR 1 nlOTOKV llECHbIX rPY30B

flP11i J1EcHoA mHAyCpmH B 1902 r.

HT &W: ........ IO)KHA 0 r pAHi*AA PAcnPOCTPAHEHAR MHoroI1ETHEV1 MEP3flOTbl OTPAQJ1H nlECHOR HHnYCTPHM: HA flYWY HACEIl _Efl HAC PE-+-- )KEnE3HblE Aoporw

JIECOrYHAPOBlE U l-ECO3AFOTOBLATEPbHAq

3HAH14TE]1bHO HOWKE CPEAHEP 0 HACEnEHHbIE nYHKTbi

"J IO)KHAS 3AUWbITHAsA nolJocA nlPMThHAPOBbIX JiECOB - CYLLUECTBYIOLLtAF

TAEIKHblE TEMHOXBOr4HblE 1 AEPEBOOEPAGATbUBAIOLLAS HI)KE CPEAHE 6 CTon1LA rOCYAAPCTBA

! \ TAEIKHblE CBETJ1QXB01HbJE K0K- IOKHAP 3ALU4THAHF nOJIOCA nP'TYHAPOBbIX JIECOB - nPEAAArAEMAb LEfJIOJO3HO-rYMA)KHA5l CPEAHRA no CTPAHE PEKU1

TAEIKHblE U nOATAEDKHblE COCHOBblE O 9 T PECOXIMJHECKAA BbUWE CPEAHE0 rpAHI4Ubi 3KOHOM. PAROHOB

nO.TAE)KHblE CMEWAHHblE * 3AnoBEaHKA JEconPOMblmWjEHHblE KOMnIJEKCbi 3HA4ATEJ1bHO BblIWE CPEAHEU rPAHI4b CYSbEKTOB PO

/ oWMP0KOJ1RCTBEHHb]E * HAU4oHAJbHblE npuPOAHblE nAPKL4 OCHOBHblE nOTOKU JIECHbIx rPY3OB OCHOBHblE MOPCKUE nOPTbi (1o rPAHL4Ab CYSbEKTOB PO

nECOCTEnHUE rPYBOObOPOTY XECHblX rPY30B B 1993 r.l:~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~PYOOOPTYI1CHbX l'3O B103 .1

J1EcocTEnlHbJE 0 HACEJ1EHHb1E n1YHKTbi rP300PT)E P38-193r rOCYAAPCT18EHHbIE rpAH*1LtbI

3AbOJIOHEHHbE EAO 50 TblC. T B rOg

CTOjli4UA rOCYAAPCTBA

: bE3JECHblE TEPPUTOPUU PEKU C. OT 500 TbC. T B rOA

roPHbE TEPPUTOPUUM _. _ rOCYAAPCTBEHHblE FPAHLUbl CBblIE b00 TUC. T B roA

IBRD 28353 BARD 2835

POCCHlCKAS $EREPALAL4R POCC-lICKAS (EAEPAILA-1

0630P J1ECHOf4 llOJUITUKUI 0630P JIECHOU4 flO1NlTNKI

OXPAHA J1ECOB OT llO)KAPOB OPrAHI3AL7Wi flECOYCTPOrCTBA L JIECHOr HAYKM

. fECOYCTPIOWTE[1bHbJE flpEAnlPRRTMA

4DAKTH4ECKAS rOPHMOCTb J1ECOB-: * bA3bl ABRA)1ECOOXPAHbl 0E EPAJIbHOT C1Y3(BlblE JIECHOFO X035CTBA 0 HACE:nEHHbE nYHKTbi

OHEHb BblCOKA9 0 HACEJlEHHblE nlYHKTbl JIECHbUE HCCJiEAOBATEJibCKHE LIHCT14TYTbi 6 CTOjiwLLA rOCYAAPCTbA

' qEHb BbICOKA9I CTOnU4A D _ bE4AEPAJbH011 CJY)K5bi JlECHOrO X039ACTBA

I | BbUCOKAR 1TOJIWL~A

FOCYAAPCTBA JIECHblE C CCJIEAOBATEJIbCKHE UHCTUTYTbP

PEKU4 POCCAHCKOR AKAAEMUU HAYK rPAHbLI4b 3KOHOMH4ECKUX PAPIOHOB

/ nOBbIWEHHAR- -, _ ._rOCYAAPCTBEHHbIE rPAHHLb9J JIECHblE CCJIEAOBATEJIbCKHE UHCTUTYTrb rPAHLA4bJ CYbbEKTOB DEAEPAt4RA

F , YMEPEHHA9 A MUHUCTEPCTBA CEnbCKOrO XO39VICTBA

.. __ __ rPAHU4U CY6bEKTOB zDE;EPA4UU~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~rPHRb C5bKOB0EEALM

HU3KA9 H BblCWIIE yWEBHblE 3ABE1EHI4A JIECHOrO nPooHnlA

.4C T 0 4 H W K: W Hc n yr ne Ga C O P A H m m. B. H. C yKa4 a, 1990 (Y H U B E PC AT ET bl , A K A A EM UH , U H C T1 4TYT bl ) - - rO C Y A APC T B E H H bU E FPA H I4U b

' UCT09HUK: L4H~CTTYr nieca CO PAH aM. B.H.CYxaieMa, 1990

MAY 1997

Page 343: Russian - World Bank Documents

IBRD 27086R

UNITED STATES OF AMERICAThis osop s pod.uced by RUSSIAN FEDERATIONthe Mop Des.iq Unit of The

c dolcrs, .daninati- -onnd FOREST POLICY REVIEW-ny olher inb,o-otion shownto onis asap d-to on FOREST TYPES AND PROTECTED AREAS .J ,

G p. ou r judf ment on the 8

^

IZoI *sta ofany tesroy[ FOREST TYPES: ...... SOUTHERN LIMIT OF PERMAFROSTor any -ndorsement or A A Iacceptance of such FOREST TUNDRA A EXISTING SOUTHERN BOUNDARY OF

boundr[ries BOREAL (SPRUCE & FIR) NORTHERN PROTECTED ZONE (A

BOREAL (LARCH) PROPOSED SOUTHERN BOUNDARY OF .sBOREAL (LARCH) ~~~~~NORTHERN PROTECTED ZONE s' 5

0Aai

BOREAL & SUB BOREAL (PINE) PROTECTED AREAS: it

UNITED , *- SUB BOREAL (MIXED FORESTS) S ZAPOVEDNIKS ;0 S .5UTA

KINGDOM TEMPERATE (BROADLEAF) 0 NATIONAL NATURE PARKS X ¢ t , r E +

FOREST-STEPPE 0 SELECTED TOWNS AND CITIES 35s r - , '

MARSH ® NATIONAL CAPITAL

NO ,/. N WORESJED AREAS RIVERS ; N OR yAY CIPS AREAS -.- INTERNATIONAL BOUNDAYBO 5 M

NOR WAY MyTu*U JJ ,,~

-- 'i- ' -''! 1 1W -i.CI;' &ci sra ,E' e RN °' ^ I

NETHERLANDS SWEDEN , _DENMARK r .f,

i .19 g~~~oMu-man!k , 1 $**.t->

GERMANY F I N LAND K,, . ropa.Io .k

RUSSIAN *4ai

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~SONIA ( A N .. ...:"; 'Au

'LATVIA o" ACrea

P0 L AN D PeTHte "'AkFa e-

|~~~ \F BESLAb R @(br=szt*fSX/wUwS ) h; .1 Y+>h a ku%; /(tsk 0

H UNGAR 5 'I z a, 00

s._ ARMENIAs.} ~~~~~~'s_A. *OdkF,rrnrl 'IS@ ',

'_, BELARUSMYakutskC0 R P,.j, _, " 1 20 s

E YR z CIRAt ;A:AEdbAAN , _'~nz( //UZ/E S. AN- 0 40 60 O KhalyOMES t Ai O N~ G O~ AL I A - \KCRA5OCYOuZ)s1

A.~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~A

0 Syk"ko0r,nocrr Tyumen -~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ - A ~~~~~~AN A..e&~ .A5 AA\~ Nikolayvsk no* JAPAN

7~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~--' 'Ar-.~ Ilb A

O /A\~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ /~

a 4 f A /A,\ Y~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~\ A~~~~~\ I. 6 -1~-' ~ ~ It,~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~~~~~.,--9" J/r 4. YL(A' -,4AOd YUZ

'A n' 001(o)ftsk , ,slaivoto

K ~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~' KAZAKSTAN -~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~I4\N ' , I r -t~~~ ISLAMIC REP. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 1 100 200 300 400 500 MILES 5)~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~M\A Tp4A' M\

SYRIAN ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ OF I~~~~~~~/A I DJPPRNARAB REP. Vk~~~~~~~~'AZERBAISrJAvN / 0 200a /A /v7 OFIAj' UZBEKISTAN s / /TKOREA

Page 344: Russian - World Bank Documents

IBRD 27087R

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

This mp o,o psod-ced by RUSSIAN FEDERATION ,tb. Mosp Deon tUnitof The

cwolors, denom-nthons and FOREST POLICY REVIEW CnuK k' ,-any .*.r infannatian shownOse pd=f The k WOOD INDUSTRY LOCATIONS AND WOOD FLOW PATTERN Leo < Graap, s , jd d an #ela t any Ymenitny, WOOD INDUSTRY LOCATIONS: PER CAPITA SHARE OF FOREST INDUSTRY IN 1992: , RAILROADSor any endorse.men or

epsosce of such * LOGGING MUCH LOWER THAN AVERAGE 0 SELECTED TOWNS AND CITIES

I ~ WOOD PROCESSING LOWER THAN AVERAGE NATIONAL CAPITALI ~ PULP AND PAPER AVERAGE RIVERS 1 ' Anodyr

Nj c. ['.' q rn Se o E WOOD CHEMICALS FACILITIES HIGHER THAN AVERAGE ECONOMIC REGION BOUNDARIES PevekUNITED , I--Iq eaUINGTEDOMj ; ,,, r; s^: 1 5 e a WOOD PROCESSING CENTERS MUCH HIGHER THAN AVERAGE OBLAST, KRAI OR REPUBLIC BOUNDARIES IESKINGDOM

- PRODUCT FLOWS SIGNIFICANT TIMBER PORTS (1993): AUTONOMOUS OBLAST, OKRUG OR -~~50,000 TONS/YR. ~~~~REPUBLIC BOUNDARIES

<50,000 TONS/YR. - - INTERNATIONAL BOUNDARIES/

50,000 - 500,000 TONS/YR. - , I B

.500,000 TONS/YR. . an - . I ~':-.efM ~~~~ .. K

NORWAY , ;

NETHERLANDS DENMARK SWEDE N -7.. - -- sora

C /- r M '-'GERMANY F I N L A N D F . ' Tiksi

J ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~~A.Petropavlovsk 0

r ; SS ee g t :r-R

-' / ~~RUSSIANf ED. -~

s~~~~~~~~~1 -. _ RMNIAX 0_ MkhachalgaAEo*- --- '- _

P0 L AN D ? ~ sruIIOhtig MgdnKmkrl,V JLI~~~1TH UANIA ~ ,- PT$rolsnods

'k ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~Vorkuto I S -

HUNGARY / ,s BELARUS ,N Y5kutsJN/6lKoyevsk no Amure

< >

,~~~~~~~ . -~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~Manssys kbOkRlink[~~ So Uf~~~, k Igvshhn" ', vk JAPAN

Sochi (~~~~~~~~~~~SM~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

an ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~' ladivostok

TURKEY sC H IN AI MkhcFko K AZAKSTAN rnAtyk ~ _O~'

-5 ~~ARMENIAy'_~ akhch 'sA-uI*-. ISLAMIC REP ~ ~ t 0 100 200 300 400 SOO MILES *'../5

SYRIAN OF IRAN/II 5 k'- )D.PRARAB REP. *)I'~AIEJAAN/ 0 200 400 600 800 KILOMEItERK'"- -- M 0 N G 0 L I A S. OF

/ ~~~RAQ" ,-.~~~~~~~ ~~~ 'Q---. *~~~~~~~-~~~ / I ts-viSfAN. <~~~~~~~~~~~~- ~~~'. KOREA~~KRE

OCTOBER 1996

Page 345: Russian - World Bank Documents

IBRD 28353UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

This ap pmnduced by.Map ben Unit of tf RUSSIAN FEDERATIONWorld Bank. The budries, ' ;

any nib. snrtiand,cusu FOREST POLICY REVIEW 9Cr--onthis map do. nol 1 -pC, onrop, jsnfdrwt - -I- FOREST FIRE PROTECTIONlal staus of any ribtry,

or any end-rse-ent ora/cceptance of suchbaundanes

.~ce -h FOREST FIRE POTENTIAL': A FOREST FIRE CONTROL AIR BASES

X HIGH POTENTIAL ° SELECTED TOWNS AND CITIES 0 nadyrNATIONAL CAPITAL PevekUNITED uc tn e r7 RIVERS

KINGDOM , / _ I_ INTERNATIONAL BOUNDARIES

LOW POTENTIAL

'SOURCE: Sukochev Forest Inst., 1990

N O R W A Y

Ossoro

NETHERLANDS DENMARK S W E D E N J 9 .-

~~~~~~~~ot ri c Is * - -._' 0 Murmonsk

GERMANY Q an >k 9FINLAND rfl ondoIok,ts~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Tiksi~~~~~~Tis| |GLhMANY F I N L A N D V ,. / PetropovlovAs;fr 'p 7l ! \\ I7 /'/ '/ eAKgloaadoyn KoamchatskiyRUSSIAN J J / ' . ,

M: P CEL A N D < w / /, 0 °VolLUt N rilsL 'STONIA -; - /-.

~ POLAND V, \LTIy146 rhrgls oisk //, / ,

N , , 1 'A ., t . " a'>U z~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~od $kNois| xovowssysL9 NoFvogo 0 FPLIM ,}j_,_*w + To m sl: l hnflsk49 * ;> 0 / q hlagoveshchenoL+wow-^6< j \ ,

N TU KEY $; * ovoghorh ld K A Z A K / TA / /1)1 0Vor=ALctoA . -- /, / = -'> >o rt- n

SYRIA \ O IRAj i j \ 0 00 40 /0 80 KILME" R ,/< ./7 // O / G O7 r 7/A7, / oREl ARB RE .m UKRAIN5AERBIA j UZEITN te /77/TBE 19

HUNG7 0 V-.Id. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~/ 7~/O~~~~~ 5I ,, ,.,' ' / / / 7/ . / ,/$~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~' k~~~~~ Vaninob ~~~~~~~~~~~~uNzolynoOAaAmrr <

T. rr.hamio 'e7 7 / ocoisz V n / 7../7

::E 18) UKRAINE ~ ~ ~ ~~t N/i"' "7 1rJo 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 7/7 c AA

S oron tov zanoo 7

- 0UFo ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~/ I '~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~T il

Donu a 0/90k /77~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~brvs AA

O-Rostoy no V.oI~so-st / ..- - - lgvscus Novorossiysk9 Br' /N ,

Sochip $xa%e~0nsk, 2 o §or, t , N Vt,., 4 <r ;ZP"Y/ / A.~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ e,NoklsodhaNov sibSirsk X'ar'-\ b

Astrolshon .c.* >~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ / / / r ¶ I ChitoK / /Iodivostok~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~f advotoTURKEY / ' *ljIon-Ude~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ts-d/a~ /n ' &/-c-

%A ' 7 7 5 k San

K % ~O(MokhochkaiK A T \ GornoAltoysk OA < -7 7k ~ . .. /* ,.'~~45 ARMENIANC ~~' A p;C,:KTh i 0 100 200 300 400 500 MILES D.P.R.,4S%d

ISLAMIC REPA 3 L'-/ OF___________SYRIAN N OF I I I KOREArn./ 5

ARAB REP ~~~~t-, 0 200 400 600 800 KILOMETERS M 0 N G 0 [ I A I/KRAOTBR19

Page 346: Russian - World Bank Documents

IBRD 28354UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

This mnp -as pndsucd byieMap D- itUnd of Th. RUSSIAN FEDERATION-coor, deno-intion and ~. -n ii inrII- Iny°'° ina6mnatin don FOREST POllCY REVIEW-

on thins map do not imply an; i -

G-p, -v mdg-- nrtadft- FOREST MANAGEMENT AND RESEARCH INSTITUTIONSI.gdI AMtu of ry terntoy. Ff ayu d n ,es " . }

FOREST INVENTORY ENTERPRISES 0 SELECTED CITIES

_ FEDERAL FOREST SERVICE 6 NATIONAL CAPITAL OAnadyr_ RESEARCH INSTITUTIONS RIVERS

UNITED ! r I Ci a n S e a FOREST RESEARCH INSTITUTES OF 0 PevekKINGDOM ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~RUSSIAN ACADEMY OF SCIENCES ECONOMIC REGION BOUNDARIES

FOREST RESEARCH INSTITUTES OF OBLAST,KRAI OR REPUBLIC BOUNDARIESTHE MINISTRY OF AGRICULTURE AND FOOD AUTONOMOUS OBLAST, OKRUG

r--- FORESTRY GRADUATE SCHOOLS OR REPUBLIC BOUNDARIESLJ (UNIVERSITIES, ACADEMIES AND INSTITUTES) - - INTERNATIONAL BOUNDARIES

NORWAY s _, - a.r,

NETHERLANDS DENMARK S W E D E N - B Ossora

,~~~~EMR r B ,,r . s ,\1of Bothnia,

r g f;_'0 MurmanskGERMANY 0- 0

GERMANY = F I N L A N D T i- 1

La Tiksi) Mogodon 0 Potropovlovsk 0~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~eroalos ,!t-! 1 ic S e a Magodon O Kamchotskiy

'- / RUSSIAN jF1D..-

Koliningrad \ , L;,IA ESTONtA a0 KhatongaI *^ '\ \ \ ~~~LATVIA} 4 - rh-e.

~POLAND *< P 'g PLITHUANIAj* JersouiiodskN / *...,_,r NovogoroOl 0 Norilsk o

0 ff - /L.~\ 0, -_-> 9' - .Vorkutop'^ _ _,r * BBELARUS ia *kutskOHUNGARY Vologdo

| Lle"I * UKor, i. I 0 ' Nikolayevsk no Amure

| ME i ° ;1(U K R A I N E MOCO ~ f 0Z Vlanino{ __~'

E t. <wr. ! i - --- r F - Khonty-0 0 Yuzhno05) ' - : \1 <[V&ronezI, -t 'rX ,__,V Ko < Par Mansiysk 0 Sakholinskr zz < r r Perm . ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~Tyndo 0

F---YoYekotorinburg T haborovsk JAPANSorotov 0 C 0 0 0 ,-tj,) - /2 ^ f 4 ; Samar' Ufa ,.; ,. ° Vol ograod-'^ Chelyobinsk - ( .

,>Rostov nacN t3 _ 0 - Blogoveshchnsk sk,~ "'5 ,NovorossiyskO ponu ' i Tm Brotsk

'- -' 't 4§ /* ~ @ </, 'v--.,o,-._^> Tomsk ° j kOmsk

| SochiC <U j W 0 C\-"--'l f L-x Novosibrsk -6 Krasnoyorsk CSochi e-i ~~N ~Novosilbirsk Chita VNkoh* - -,.~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~ *~~~~~~~

1-- ':/ O*~~~~~~~~~~0 0p ko h

Astrokton . o. *-- _,'an ... Irkutsk Ulon-Ude Vlivostok

- ~~~~~~0 Abakan 0 *~- ldvso

TURKEY \C H I N ACI

)x~t . OMkhachkolh K A ZAKSTAN Gorno-Altaysko o'-iARMENIANK '

ISLAMI8 v; Ccs REP.0 100 200 300 400 500 MILES . ' *DPR.

SYRIAN OF RAN O / 20 40 60 00 KILOMETERS F.,s M L I AA O OFRAB REP. kj.AZERBAIJAN 0 O0 0 0 0 IOEESm 0N GO0 L ARA RE./IA UZBEKJSTAN - KOREA

OCTOBER 1996

Page 347: Russian - World Bank Documents

- - I -- I

sq$_zey- .- "I

Page 348: Russian - World Bank Documents

BCEMU4PHbIl BAHK

1i8I H Street. N.W.

Waishiigton D C. 20433 IJSA

Teje(>iOH: 202-477-1234

Te.ie(JlKc: 202-477-6391

Te.ieKc: ICI 64145 WORLDBA.NK

NCI 248423 WORLD)BANK

AtpeC :1v1 Te:1erp.l\1\1: INTBAFRADWASH INGTON[)C

World Wide Web: llttp://www.worldbaniki org,/

B leKTpOH HH.N r11OITId: books':worldibank.org

10111 l 14ll°

9 780821 340059

ISBN 0-8213-4005-0