Top Banner
Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current Samples and Applications
47

Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Dec 20, 2015

Download

Documents

Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA)

Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley)

Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame)

Supernovae at the CfA Current Samples and Applications

Page 2: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

MOUNT HOPKINS, ARIZONA

Page 3: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

& SCP

& KAIT

Supernovae in the IAU Circulars

Page 4: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Spectroscopy at Mount Hopkins

FLWO 1.5-m Tillinghast reflector

FAST spectrograph

●3700–7500Å

●Recent upgrade to optics

Three or four spectra per night, ~300 spectra per year

Reliable service observers on site

Page 5: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Capability of Spectrograph

SN with R = 19.8 mag

Page 6: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Recent Examples

Page 7: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Classification of Supernovae

560 nearby (low-z) SNe discoveredin last three years

495 have spectroscopic classifications

Mt. Hopkins program responsible for 195 (39%!)

Spectra available on CfA web page

Email alerts to immediately disseminate information

http://cfa-www.harvard.edu/cfa/oir/Research/supernova/RecentSN.html

Page 8: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Spectroscopy Results – SN 2001V

Page 9: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Spectroscopic Database

● 387 Type Ia Spectra for SNe with calibrated light curves

● Epoch of spectra ranges from –14 days to several months past maximum

● 201 spectra from day –14 to day +14

● Δm15

range 0.85 ― 1.93

● All galaxy types

● Once photometry complete, spectroscopic sample will double

● All spectra from same instrument/telescope combination

● All spectra reduced in same manner

● Systematics for comparison are reduced

Page 10: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Spectroscopic Database – Distribution by Age

Page 11: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Spectroscopy Results – SN 1998aq

Page 12: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Spectroscopy Results – SN1998aq

SYNOW fit at day -9

Page 13: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Spectroscopy Results – SN1998aq

SYNOW fit at day 0

Page 14: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Spectroscopic Database--Heterogeneity

Page 15: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Spectroscopic Database – Day –10

Page 16: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Spectroscopic Database – Day 0

Page 17: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Spectroscopic Database – Day +10

Page 18: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Spectroscopy Results – SN 1999by

Effect of titanium strength on the spectrum

Page 19: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Spectroscopic Database – Titanium

Bright, Slow Dim, Fast

Page 20: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Spectroscopy Results – SN 1999gi

Leonard et al. 2002

Page 21: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Photometry at Mount Hopkins

FLWO 1.2-m reflector

4shooter camera

11' X 11' per chip

One SN per night in UBVRI

One night per dark run for photometric calibration, templates,etc.

Service observing during scheduled programs

Page 22: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Capability of CCD Camera

SN 2001V, discovered at FLWOGood U-band Response

Page 23: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

IR Photometry at Mt. Hopkins

FLWO 1.2-m Reflector with Stelircam

One SN per night in JHK

Service observing during scheduled programs

Jha et al. 1999

2Mass Camera and Telescope coming soon: Josh Bloom

Page 24: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

A Couple of UBVRI Light Curves...

SN 1998bu in M 96 SN 2001V in NGC 3987

Page 25: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Even More Photometry Results

Jha et al. 1999

Page 26: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

A “U”nique Data Set

U-band composite light curve

Page 27: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Measuring distances: MLCS2k2

Page 28: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

MLCS2k2 Templates

Page 29: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Extinction Zeropoint

(B-V)35 = 1.055 ± 0.024 mag

Page 30: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Hubble-Flow SNe Ia80 SNe Ia with cz ≥ 2500 km/s in CMB frame

one parameter fit: aV = log cz - 0.2mV0

aV = 0.6838 ± 0.0045 (random) ± 0.0120 (systematic)

Page 31: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Measuring the Hubble Constant

Page 32: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Cepheid-Calibrated SNe Ia80 SNe Ia with cz ≥ 2500 km/s in CMB frame

same supernova data! same Cepheid data!

Page 33: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Going with the Flows

Page 34: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

ESSENCEEquation of State: SupErNovae Trace Cosmic Expansion

Page 35: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Claudio Aguilera --- CTIO/NOAO

Brian Barris --- Univ of Hawaii

Andy Becker --- Bell Labs/Univ. of Washington

Peter Challis --- Harvard-Smithsonian CfA

Ryan Chornock --- UC Berkeley

Alejandro Clocchiatti --- Univ Catolica de Chile

Ricardo Covarrubias --- Univ of Washington

Alex V. Filippenko --- UC Berkeley

Peter M. Garnavich --- Notre Dame University

Malcom Hicken--Harvard-Smithsonian CfA

Stephen Holland --- Notre Dame University

Saurabh Jha --- UC Berkeley

Robert Kirshner --- Harvard-Smithsonian CfA

Kevin Krisciunas --- CTIO/NOAO

Bruno Leibundgut --- European Southern Observatory

Weidong D. Li --- UC Berkeley

Thomas Matheson --- Harvard-Smithsonian CfA

Anthony Miceli --- Univ of Washington

Gajus Miknaitis --- Univ of Washington

Armin Rest --- Univ of Washington/CTIO

Adam G. Riess --- Space Telescope Science Institute

Brian P. Schmidt --- Mt. Stromlo Siding Springs Observatories

Chris Smith --- CTIO/NOAO

Jesper Sollerman --- Stockholm Observatory

Jason Spyromilio --- European Southern Observatory

Christopher Stubbs --- Harvard-Smithsonian CfA

Nicholas B. Suntzeff --- CTIO/NOAO

John L. Tonry --- Univ of Hawaii

ESSENCE Survey Team

Page 36: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

ESSENCEEquation of State: SupErNovae Trace Cosmic

Expansion

● NOAO Survey on CTIO 4m, MOSAIC for 5 years

● Shares frame subtraction pipeline with SuperMacho project, scheduled in “other” halves of SuperMacho nights

● Expect ~ 200 supernovae with 0.1 < z < 0.8

● 3 band photometry: V,R,I (observer frame)

● 2 sets of fields, so t=4 days

● Goal is to determine the distance to each redshift bin (z = 0.1) to 2%

● ~3% photometry at peak SN brightness

Page 37: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.
Page 38: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Essence Survey Goal: w

Monte Carlo of

Page 39: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Supernovae, CMB, and large scale structurewill determine w to 10%

This cannot fail to be interesting! or something else.

Page 40: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Gajus Maknaitis, U of Washington

Page 41: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

The GOODs ACS Treasury Program &

The Higher-Z Supernova Search Team

Sees farther than others:1.2< z < 1.8supernovae

Riess (STScI)Strolger (STScI)Tonry (UH)Filippenko (UCB)Kirshner (CfA)Challis (CfA)Casertano, (STScI)Dickinson (STScI)Giavalisco (STScI)Ferguson (STScI)

Adam Riess

Page 42: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Expansion History of the Universe

Page 43: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

The Rise and Fall of Aphrodite

Aug 1Sept 22Oct 1Oct 5Oct 10Oct 20Oct 30Oct 31Nov 17Nov 25

Page 44: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Our first higher-z SN Ia, Aphrodite

Aphrodite (1<z<1.5)

ACS grism spectrum

NICMOS F110W

ACS F850lp

viz

Page 45: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Looking back to the time when the Universe was decelerating!

Page 46: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

Evidence for a change in cosmic acceleration: cosmic jerk

Future:

Acceleration without end?

Page 47: Robert P. Kirshner, Peter Challis, Tom Matheson, Malcom Hicken (CfA) Saurabh Jha (UC Berkeley) Peter Garnavich (Notre Dame) Supernovae at the CfA Current.

CfA Work:

Spectra for Classification

Spectra for Analysis

Lightcurves: UBVRI

MLCS2k2

ESSENCE: onset of acceleration => w

Higher Z: era of deceleration => jerk, w’