Rics.org RICS Scotland Housing Commission Emerging Issues Housing Policy Advisory Group Meeting 28 th January 2014 rics.org.

rics.org

RICS Scotland Housing CommissionEmerging Issues

Housing Policy Advisory Group Meeting

28th January 2014

rics.org

rics.org

Context to Commission

• RICS UK Commission: ‘More Good Homes and Better United Kingdom’ published in June 2013

• Thorough & comprehensive analysis lacked Scottish detail given:– Differences in housing system operation– Level of devolved powers that affect housing

• RICS Scotland Chair: short term, independent, solutions focused Commission for Scotland

rics.org

Purpose of the Commission:

1.Provide a sector-wide view of current condition of the Scottish housing system

2.Pinpoint the most significant barriers to effective housing system operation

3.Develop new, consensual ideas to alleviate them

Aims of Commission:

1.Deliver an objective & credible housing system assessment

2.Define policy options for practitioners and enablers

3.Shift housing to a higher position on political & media agenda

rics.org

Scope of Commission

1. Panel of 10 Commissioners with remit to:– Assess & evaluate the evidence provided – Ask further questions for clarification– Discuss evidence & develop recommendations

2. Process for submitting evidence: 3 Methods1. Respond to set Commission questions

2. Submit proposals on any element of housing system operation which could be improved

3. Provide examples of innovation & good practice

rics.org

Scope of Commission

3. Scope of evidence – Oral evidence: 22 evidence providers– Written evidence: 38 written submissions

rics.org

Themes & Recommendations

In order to develop a housing system that functions for all…

rics.org

Planning Housing: Emerging Issues

1. The strategic assembly of a generous & more effective land supply is essential– Land premiums are a signal of housing system dysfunction

that needs action

2. Strategic planning should be elevated on corporate & political agendas to address short-termism 1. Drive innovation/collaboration to enable housing

development

3. Planning authorities must improve certainty by taking strategic action on infrastructure & enabling delivery– Do we expect the private sector to do too much?

rics.org

Planning Housing: Emerging Issues (cont.)

4. Master-planning must focus on building communities through good design/density & connectivity to economic & social infrastructure

5. HNDA analysis should be demystified & improved• We need better intelligence of household circumstances

& consumer intentions across all tenures• The impact of intermediate housing in meeting housing

need must be recognised• Leadership is needed on using HNDA intelligence to set

housing supply targets & define 5-year land supply

rics.org

Paying for Housing: Emerging Issues

1. House price to earnings ratios are too high despite (some) price readjustment during recession– Rising interest rates could exacerbate problems & create

repossession risks for those highly indebted

2. SME builders are struggling to access bank finance & development funding

3. Risk profile of social housing sector is changing: finance over shorter period & less favourable terms– Innovative funding/joint venture models need to emerge

4. Potential impact of Land & Building Transaction Tax

rics.org

Building Housing: Emerging Issues

1. Lack of viable/reliable land supply & low levels of prime land in locations where people want to live

2. A de-skilling of the construction industry is a genuine risk– Evidence of reduction in industry capacity, a loss of skills &

apprenticeships & deficit in the material supply chain

3. Clyde Gateway, Ravenscraig & Dundee Waterfront are exemplary housing regeneration projects: we need more!– Collaboration, strategic land assembly, infrastructure

investment on a major scale

4. Energy & carbon reduction agenda increases build costs– Puts further pressure on a weakened construction sector

rics.org

Managing Housing: Emerging Issues

1. Improving the condition of Scotland’s private housing stock is an urgent priority– Homeowners need support to invest in conservation & repair– Low cost finance, reductions in VAT for refurbishment

2. Investing in empty homes delivers real benefits: – From a cost efficiency, sustainability, environmental &

regeneration perspective

3. Given its increasing influence, the growth & improvement of the PRS needs strategic focus, leadership & investment

4. We need to make the case for housing in Scotland– Impact on economic growth, health, well-being & attainment

rics.org

Timetable & Next Steps

• End of January: Emerging issues presented at RICS Scotland Residential Conference: further sound-boarding

• Mid February: Approval of draft report by Commissioners

• End of February/Early March: Commission reconvenes to consider recommendations

• Mid March: Report finalised

• Mid April: Report launched