Top Banner
RHESSI Studies of Solar RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1 , David M. Smith 2 , A. Gordon Emslie 4 , Martin Fivian 3 , Gordon J. Hurford 3 , Robert P. Lin 3 , and James M. Ryan 1 1 Space Science Center, University of New Hampshire, Durham, NH 2 Dept. Of Physics, U.C. Santa Cruz, Santa Cruz, CA 3 Space Sciences Laboratory, U.C. Berkeley, Berkeley, CA 4 Physics Department, University of Alabama, Huntsville, AL
35

RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

Dec 14, 2015

Download

Documents

Jayla Matthys
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray PolarizationHard X-Ray Polarization

Mark L. McConnell1, David M. Smith2, A. Gordon Emslie4, Martin Fivian3, Gordon J. Hurford3,

Robert P. Lin3, and James M. Ryan1

1Space Science Center, University of New Hampshire, Durham, NH2Dept. Of Physics, U.C. Santa Cruz, Santa Cruz, CA

3Space Sciences Laboratory, U.C. Berkeley, Berkeley, CA4Physics Department, University of Alabama, Huntsville, AL

Page 2: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

Polarization in Solar FlaresPolarization in Solar Flares

The hard X-ray continuum is dominated by electron bremsstrahlung emission.

Measurements of hard X-ray polarization can shed light on the geometry of the acceleration process.

Models predict polarization levels as high as 20 or 30%.

Model parameters include :

1) pitch angle distribution

2) B-field geometry

3) viewing angle

4) atm density profile

Page 3: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

The Polarization SignatureThe Polarization Signature

For a fixed Compton scatter angle (), the azimuthal distribution of scattered photons contains the polarization signature.

The amplitude of the modulation defines the level of polarization.

The scattering angle corresponding to the minimum of the distribution defines the plane of polarization.

2000

1500

1000

500

0

Counts

350300250200150100500

Azimuthal Scatter Angle (degs)

C-max

C-min

polarization angle

C η( ) = A cos2(η−ϕ)+B

1

10

100

Asymmetry Ratio

1201008060Scattering Angle (degrees)

50 keV

100 keV

250 keV

500 keV

1 MeV

Asymmetry Ratio

Page 4: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

RHESSI as a Polarimeter (20 – 100 keV)RHESSI as a Polarimeter (20 – 100 keV)

A small (3 cm diam by 3.5 cm high) cylinder of Be serves as a Compton scattering element.

The Ge detectors measure the distribution of the scattered radiation.

The rotation of the spacecraft rotation provides an effective method for fine sampling of the scatter distribution.

Page 5: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

RHESSI as a Polarimeter (20 – 100 keV)RHESSI as a Polarimeter (20 – 100 keV)

Complications :

Varying background as a function of spacecraft spin angle.

Scattering of solar flux from parts of the spacecraft other than the Be block.

Scattering of solar flux off atmosphere (spin-dependent).

Page 6: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

The Polarization Signal - Simulated ResultsThe Polarization Signal - Simulated Results

40 keV

40 keV

80 keV

80 keV

Top row shows results for narrow incident beam (no

spacecraft scattering).

Bottom row shows results for wide

incident beam (with spacecraft scattering).

Note the significant degradation of signal

at 80 keV.

Page 7: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

Polarimeter Mode – Effective AreaPolarimeter Mode – Effective Area

The effective area is defined for both a narrow beam and a broad beam.

The broad beam simulation incorporates the effects of scattering of solar flux into

the rear Ge segments, which leads to an increase in effective area at higher

energies .0.01

0.1

1

10

10 100

Energy (keV)

RHESSI Polarimeter ModeEffective Area

Narrow Beam

Broad Beam

Page 8: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

Polarimeter Mode – Modulation FactorPolarimeter Mode – Modulation Factor

The modulation factor is a measure of the quality of the polarization signal.

Scattering of incident solar flux reduces the quality of the polarization signal. (The scattered flux is not

modulated.)

1.0

0.8

0.6

0.4

0.2

0.010 100

Energy (keV)

RHESSI Polarimeter ModeModulation Factor

Narrow Beam

Broad Beam

Page 9: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

Polarimeter Mode – Figure of MeritPolarimeter Mode – Figure of Merit

The figure-of-merit is a measure of the intrinsic capability to measure

polarization.

Here, it is defined as the product of (effective area)1/2 and the modulation factor.

As defined here, it does not incorporate the effects of

detector background.

0.6

0.5

0.4

0.3

0.2

0.1

0.010 100

Energy (keV)

RHESSI Polarimeter ModeFigure of Merit

Narrow Beam

Broad Beam

Page 10: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

Nature of the RHESSI DataNature of the RHESSI Data

Rear Segment Data(20 – 40 keV)

X4.8 Flare - 23 July 2002

00:27 – 00:43 UT

12000

10000

8000

6000

4000

2000

BGD Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Detector Roll Angle

12000

10000

8000

6000

4000

2000

FLR Counts

FLR interval BGD interval

Ge112000

10000

8000

6000

4000

2000

BGD Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Detector Roll Angle

12000

10000

8000

6000

4000

2000

FLR Counts

FLR interval BGD interval

Ge3

12000

10000

8000

6000

4000

2000

BGD Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Detector Roll Angle

12000

10000

8000

6000

4000

2000

FLR Counts

FLR interval BGD interval

Ge412000

10000

8000

6000

4000

2000

BGD Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Detector Roll Angle

12000

10000

8000

6000

4000

2000

FLR Counts

FLR interval BGD interval

Ge5

12000

10000

8000

6000

4000

2000

BGD Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Detector Roll Angle

12000

10000

8000

6000

4000

2000

FLR Counts

FLR interval BGD interval

Ge6

12000

10000

8000

6000

4000

2000

BGD Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Detector Roll Angle

12000

10000

8000

6000

4000

2000

FLR Counts

FLR interval BGD interval

Ge7

12000

10000

8000

6000

4000

2000

BGD Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Detector Roll Angle

12000

10000

8000

6000

4000

2000

FLR Counts

FLR interval BGD interval

Ge812000

10000

8000

6000

4000

2000

FLR Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Detector Roll Angle

12000

10000

8000

6000

4000

2000

BGD Counts

FLR interval BGD interval

Ge9

Page 11: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

An Initial Approach to RHESSI AnalysisAn Initial Approach to RHESSI Analysis

Three pairs of detectors with similar background : detectors 8/9, detectors 3/5 and detectors 4/6.

The data from detectors 3-6 can be used as background estimate for the polarimeter mode detectors 8/9.

Limitations :

• Does not use detector #1

• Assumes symmetric geometry

• No modeling of Earth albedo

Page 12: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

Nature of the RHESSI DataNature of the RHESSI Data

Rear Segment Data(20 – 40 keV)

X4.8 Flare - 23 July 2002

00:27 – 00:43 UT

12000

10000

8000

6000

4000

2000

BGD Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Detector Roll Angle

12000

10000

8000

6000

4000

2000

FLR Counts

FLR interval BGD interval

Ge112000

10000

8000

6000

4000

2000

BGD Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Detector Roll Angle

12000

10000

8000

6000

4000

2000

FLR Counts

FLR interval BGD interval

Ge3

12000

10000

8000

6000

4000

2000

BGD Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Detector Roll Angle

12000

10000

8000

6000

4000

2000

FLR Counts

FLR interval BGD interval

Ge412000

10000

8000

6000

4000

2000

BGD Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Detector Roll Angle

12000

10000

8000

6000

4000

2000

FLR Counts

FLR interval BGD interval

Ge5

12000

10000

8000

6000

4000

2000

BGD Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Detector Roll Angle

12000

10000

8000

6000

4000

2000

FLR Counts

FLR interval BGD interval

Ge6

12000

10000

8000

6000

4000

2000

BGD Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Detector Roll Angle

12000

10000

8000

6000

4000

2000

FLR Counts

FLR interval BGD interval

Ge7

12000

10000

8000

6000

4000

2000

BGD Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Detector Roll Angle

12000

10000

8000

6000

4000

2000

FLR Counts

FLR interval BGD interval

Ge812000

10000

8000

6000

4000

2000

FLR Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Detector Roll Angle

12000

10000

8000

6000

4000

2000

BGD Counts

FLR interval BGD interval

Ge9

Page 13: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

X4.8 Flare of 23-July-2002X4.8 Flare of 23-July-200225000

20000

15000

10000

5000

0

Counts per 5 sec Time Bin

00:20 00:30 00:40 00:50

Time (UT)

FLR207230120 - 40 keV

FLR BGD1 (24 hrs before) BGD2 (24 hrs after)

25000

20000

15000

10000

5000

0

Counts per 5 sec Time Bin

00:20 00:30 00:40 00:50

Time (UT)

FLR207230140 - 60 keV

FLR BGD1 (24 hrs before) BGD2 (24 hrs after)

25000

20000

15000

10000

5000

0

Counts per 5 sec Time Bin

00:20 00:30 00:40 00:50

Time (UT)

FLR207230160 - 80 keV

FLR BGD1 (24 hrs before) BGD2 (24 hrs after)

25000

20000

15000

10000

5000

0

Counts per 5 sec Time Bin

00:20 00:30 00:40 00:50

Time (UT)

FLR207230180 - 100 keV

FLR BGD1 (24 hrs before) BGD2 (24 hrs after)

Analysis Interval : 00:27 – 00:43 UT

Page 14: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

X4.8 Flare of 23-July-2002X4.8 Flare of 23-July-2002

10000

5000

0

-5000

Counts per 15°

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

20 – 40 keV

10000

5000

0

-5000

Counts per 15°

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

20 – 40 keV

10000

5000

0

-5000

Counts per 15°

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

40 - 60 keV

10000

5000

0

-5000

Counts per 15°

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

40 - 60 keV

10000

5000

0

-5000

Counts per 15°

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

60 - 80 keV

10000

5000

0

-5000

Counts per 15°

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

60 - 80 keV

10000

5000

0

-5000

Counts per 15°

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

80 - 100 keV

10000

5000

0

-5000

Counts per 15°

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

80 - 100 keV

“Background”-subtracted data

Page 15: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

An Initial Approach to RHESSI AnalysisAn Initial Approach to RHESSI Analysis

Two Component Analysis

1. Systematic Component:• Single sinusoid component.

2. Polarization Signal• Double sinusoid component.

f (η ) = A + B sin2(η −ϕ ) + C sinα (η −ψ )

10000

5000

0

-5000

Counts per 15°

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

20 – 40 keV

10000

5000

0

-5000

Counts per 15°

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

20 – 40 keV

Page 16: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

Background SystematicsBackground Systematics

-4000

-2000

0

2000

4000

FLR Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Detector Roll Angle

Ge4/6 - Ge5/3

Page 17: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

X4.8 Flare of 23-July-2002X4.8 Flare of 23-July-2002

10000

5000

0

-5000

Counts per 15°

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

20 – 40 keV

10000

5000

0

-5000

Counts per 15°

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

20 – 40 keV

10000

5000

0

-5000

Counts per 15°

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

40 - 60 keV

10000

5000

0

-5000

Counts per 15°

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

40 - 60 keV

10000

5000

0

-5000

Counts per 15°

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

60 - 80 keV

10000

5000

0

-5000

Counts per 15°

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

60 - 80 keV

10000

5000

0

-5000

Counts per 15°

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

80 - 100 keV

10000

5000

0

-5000

Counts per 15°

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

80 - 100 keV

“Background”-subtracted data

Page 18: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

X4.8 Flare of 23-July-2002X4.8 Flare of 23-July-2002

6000

4000

2000

0

Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR2072301 : 20 - 40 keV

6000

4000

2000

0

Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR2072301 : 20 - 40 keV

-2000

-1000

0

1000

2000

Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR2072301 : 60 - 80 keV

-2000

-1000

0

1000

2000

Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR2072301 : 60 - 80 keV

-2000

-1000

0

1000

2000

Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR2072301 : 40 - 60 keV

-2000

-1000

0

1000

2000

Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR2072301 : 40 - 60 keV

-2000

-1000

0

1000

2000

Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR2072301 : 80 - 100 keV

-2000

-1000

0

1000

2000

Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR2072301 : 80 - 100 keV

Residual Polarization Signal

Page 19: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

X4.8 Flare of 23-July-2002X4.8 Flare of 23-July-2002

6000

4000

2000

0

Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR2072301 : 20 - 40 keV

χν2 ( ) = 3.32polar

χν2 ( ) = 9.46line

6000

4000

2000

0

Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR2072301 : 20 - 40 keV

χν2 ( ) = 3.32polar

χν2 ( ) = 9.46line

-2000

-1000

0

1000

2000

Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR2072301 : 40 - 60 keV

χν2 ( ) = 3.90polar

χν2 ( ) = 3.88line

-2000

-1000

0

1000

2000

Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR2072301 : 40 - 60 keV

χν2 ( ) = 3.90polar

χν2 ( ) = 3.88line

-2000

-1000

0

1000

2000

Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR2072301 : 60 - 80 keV

χν2 ( ) = 1.72polar

χν2 ( ) = 1.67line

-2000

-1000

0

1000

2000

Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR2072301 : 60 - 80 keV

χν2 ( ) = 1.72polar

χν2 ( ) = 1.67line

-2000

-1000

0

1000

2000

Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR2072301 : 80 - 100 keV

χν2 ( ) = 0.62polar

χν2 ( ) = 0.92line

-2000

-1000

0

1000

2000

Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR2072301 : 80 - 100 keV

χν2 ( ) = 0.62polar

χν2 ( ) = 0.92line

Residual Polarization Signal

Page 20: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

X1.5 Flare of 21-April-2002X1.5 Flare of 21-April-2002

3000

2500

2000

1500

1000

500

0

Counts per 5 sec Time Bin

01:05 01:10 01:15 01:20 01:25

Time (UT)

FLR204210120 - 40 keV

FLR BGD1 (24 hrs before) BGD2 (24 hrs after)

3000

2500

2000

1500

1000

500

0

Counts per 5 sec Time Bin

01:05 01:10 01:15 01:20 01:25

Time (UT)

FLR204210140 - 60 keV

FLR BGD1 (24 hrs before) BGD2 (24 hrs after)

3000

2500

2000

1500

1000

500

0

Counts per 5 sec Time Bin

01:05 01:10 01:15 01:20 01:25

Time (UT)

FLR BGD1 (24 hrs before) BGD2 (24 hrs after)

FLR204210160 - 80 keV

3000

2500

2000

1500

1000

500

0

Counts per 5 sec Time Bin

01:05 01:10 01:15 01:20 01:25

Time (UT)

FLR204210180 - 100 keV

FLR BGD1 (24 hrs before) BGD2 (24 hrs after)

Analysis Interval : 1:12 – 1:18 UT

Page 21: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

X1.5 Flare of 21-April-2002X1.5 Flare of 21-April-2002

400

300

200

100

0

-100

-200

Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR2042101 : 20 - 40 keV

400

300

200

100

0

-100

-200

Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR2042101 : 40 - 60 keV

400

300

200

100

0

-100

-200

Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR2042101 : 60 - 80 keV

400

300

200

100

0

-100

-200

Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR2042101 : 80 - 100 keV

Residual Polarization Signal

Page 22: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

X1.5 Flare of 21-April-2002X1.5 Flare of 21-April-2002

400

300

200

100

0

-100

-200

Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR2042101 : 20 - 40 keV

χν2 ( ) = 0.42polar

χν2 ( ) = 0.37const

400

300

200

100

0

-100

-200

Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR2042101 : 20 - 40 keV

χν2 ( ) = 0.42polar

χν2 ( ) = 0.37const

400

300

200

100

0

-100

-200

Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR2042101 : 40 - 60 keV

χν2 ( ) = 0.77polar

χν2 ( ) = 0.60const

400

300

200

100

0

-100

-200

Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR2042101 : 40 - 60 keV

χν2 ( ) = 0.77polar

χν2 ( ) = 0.60const

400

300

200

100

0

-100

-200

Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR2042101 : 60 - 80 keV

χν2 ( ) = 0.99polar

χν2 ( ) = 1.05const

400

300

200

100

0

-100

-200

Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR2042101 : 60 - 80 keV

χν2 ( ) = 0.99polar

χν2 ( ) = 1.05const

400

300

200

100

0

-100

-200

Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR2042101 : 80 - 100 keV

χν2 ( ) = 2.09polar

χν2 ( ) = 1.58const

400

300

200

100

0

-100

-200

Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR2042101 : 80 - 100 keV

χν2 ( ) = 2.09polar

χν2 ( ) = 1.58const

Residual Polarization Signal

Page 23: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

X3.9 Flare of 03-November-2003X3.9 Flare of 03-November-200335000

30000

25000

20000

15000

10000

5000

0

Counts per Time Bin

09:45 09:50 09:55 10:00

Time (UT)

FLR311031620 - 40 keV

FLR BGD1 (24 hrs before) BGD2 (24 hrs after)

35000

30000

25000

20000

15000

10000

5000

0

Counts per Time Bin

09:45 09:50 09:55 10:00

Time (UT)

FLR311031640 - 60 keV

FLR BGD1 (24 hrs before) BGD2 (24 hrs after)

35000

30000

25000

20000

15000

10000

5000

0

Counts per Time Bin

09:45 09:50 09:55 10:00

Time (UT)

FLR311031660 - 80 keV

FLR BGD1 (24 hrs before) BGD2 (24 hrs after)

35000

30000

25000

20000

15000

10000

5000

0

Counts per Time Bin

09:45 09:50 09:55 10:00

Time (UT)

FLR311031680 - 100 keV

FLR BGD1 (24 hrs before) BGD2 (24 hrs after)

Analysis Interval : 9:48 – 9:53 UT

Page 24: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

X3.9 Flare of 03-November-2003X3.9 Flare of 03-November-2003

6000

4000

2000

0

Counts

360300240180120600

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR3110316 : 20 - 40 keV

6000

4000

2000

0

Counts

360300240180120600

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR3110316 : 20 - 40 keV

1500

1000

500

0

-500

-1000

Counts

360300240180120600

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR3110316 : 40 - 60 keV1500

1000

500

0

-500

-1000

Counts

360300240180120600

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR3110316 : 40 - 60 keV

1500

1000

500

0

-500

-1000

Counts

360300240180120600

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR3110316 : 60 -80 keV1500

1000

500

0

-500

-1000

Counts

360300240180120600

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR3110316 : 60 -80 keV

1500

1000

500

0

-500

-1000

Counts

360300240180120600

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR3110316 : 80 - 100 keV1500

1000

500

0

-500

-1000

Counts

360300240180120600

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR3110316 : 80 - 100 keV

Residual Polarization Signal

Page 25: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

X3.9 Flare of 03-November-2003X3.9 Flare of 03-November-2003

6000

4000

2000

0

Counts

360300240180120600

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR3110316 : 20 - 40 keV

χν2 ( ) = 3.55polar

χν2 ( ) = 3.82const

6000

4000

2000

0

Counts

360300240180120600

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR3110316 : 20 - 40 keV

χν2 ( ) = 3.55polar

χν2 ( ) = 3.82const

1500

1000

500

0

-500

-1000

Counts

360300240180120600

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR3110316 : 40 - 60 keV

χν2 ( ) = 1.73polar

χν2 ( ) = 2.12const

1500

1000

500

0

-500

-1000

Counts

360300240180120600

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR3110316 : 40 - 60 keV

χν2 ( ) = 1.73polar

χν2 ( ) = 2.12const

1500

1000

500

0

-500

-1000

Counts

360300240180120600

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR3110316 : 60 -80 keV

χν2 ( ) = 0.82polar

χν2 ( ) = 1.21const

1500

1000

500

0

-500

-1000

Counts

360300240180120600

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR3110316 : 60 -80 keV

χν2 ( ) = 0.82polar

χν2 ( ) = 1.21const

1500

1000

500

0

-500

-1000

Counts

360300240180120600

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR3110316 : 80 - 100 keV

χν2 ( ) = 0.97polar

χν2 ( ) = 1.58const

1500

1000

500

0

-500

-1000

Counts

360300240180120600

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR3110316 : 80 - 100 keV

χν2 ( ) = 0.97polar

χν2 ( ) = 1.58const

Residual Polarization Signal

Page 26: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

X2.5 Flare of 10-November-2004X2.5 Flare of 10-November-2004

25000

20000

15000

10000

5000

0

Counts per 5 Sec Time Bin

02:00 02:05 02:10 02:15 02:20 02:25 02:30

Time (UT)

FLR411100220 -40 keV

FLR BGD2 (24 hrs after)

25000

20000

15000

10000

5000

0

Counts per 5 Sec Time Bin

02:00 02:05 02:10 02:15 02:20 02:25 02:30

Time (UT)

FLR411100240 - 60 keV

FLR BGD2 (24hrs after)

25000

20000

15000

10000

5000

0

Counts per 5 Sec Time Bin

02:00 02:05 02:10 02:15 02:20 02:25 02:30

Time (UT)

FLR411100260 - 80 keV

FLR BGD2 (24 hrs after)

25000

20000

15000

10000

5000

0

Counts per 5 Sec Time Bin

02:00 02:05 02:10 02:15 02:20 02:25 02:30

Time (UT)

FLR411100280 - 100 keV

FLR BGD2 (24 hrs after)

Analysis Interval : 2:06 – 2:15 UT

Page 27: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

X2.5 Flare of 10-November-2004X2.5 Flare of 10-November-2004

800

400

0

-400

Counts

360300240180120600

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR4111002 : 20 - 40 keV

800

400

0

-400

Counts

360300240180120600

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR4111002 : 40 - 60 keV

800

400

0

-400

Counts

360300240180120600

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR4111002 : 60 -80 keV

800

400

0

-400

Counts

360300240180120600

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR4111002 : 80 - 100 keV

Residual Polarization Signal

Page 28: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

X2.5 Flare of 10-November-2004X2.5 Flare of 10-November-2004

800

400

0

-400

Counts

360300240180120600

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR4111002 : 20 - 40 keV

χν2 ( ) = 1.52polar

χν2 ( ) = 1.89const

800

400

0

-400

Counts

360300240180120600

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR4111002 : 20 - 40 keV

χν2 ( ) = 1.52polar

χν2 ( ) = 1.89const

800

400

0

-400

Counts

360300240180120600

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR4111002 : 40 - 60 keV

χν2 ( ) = 1.37polar

χν2 ( ) = 1.36const

800

400

0

-400

Counts

360300240180120600

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR4111002 : 40 - 60 keV

χν2 ( ) = 1.37polar

χν2 ( ) = 1.36const

800

400

0

-400

Counts

360300240180120600

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR4111002 : 60 -80 keV

χν2 ( ) = 1.54polar

χν2 ( ) = 1.98const

800

400

0

-400

Counts

360300240180120600

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR4111002 : 60 -80 keV

χν2 ( ) = 1.54polar

χν2 ( ) = 1.98const

800

400

0

-400

Counts

360300240180120600

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR4111002 : 80 - 100 keV

χν2 ( ) = 1.03polar

χν2 ( ) = 1.18const

800

400

0

-400

Counts

360300240180120600

Azimuthal Scatter Angle

FLR4111002 : 80 - 100 keV

χν2 ( ) = 1.03polar

χν2 ( ) = 1.18const

Residual Polarization Signal

Page 29: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

Selected FlaresSelected Flares

11-Nov-2004N8W62

23-Jul-2002 S13E72

03-Nov-2003 N08W77

21-Apr-2002S14W84

Page 30: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

X4.8 Flare of 23-July-2002X4.8 Flare of 23-July-2002

20 - 40 keV Polarization

Flare location : S13E72

8000

6000

4000

2000

Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Scatter Angle (η)

2072301FLR20-40 keV

µp = 0.10 ± 0.04

Π ≈ 18%Φ = 79° ± 3°

Page 31: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

X4.8 Flare of 23-July-2002X4.8 Flare of 23-July-2002

8000

6000

4000

2000

Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Scatter Angle (η)

2072301FLR20-40 keV

µp = 0.10 ± 0.04

Π ≈ 18%Φ = 79° ± 3°

8000

6000

4000

2000

0

Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Scatter Angle (η)

µp = 0.15 ± 0.06

Π ≈ 27%Φ = 86° ± 2°

FLR207230120-40 keV

(Ge8-Ge3)+(Ge9-Ge5)

8000

6000

4000

2000

0

Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Scatter Angle (η)

µp = 0.07 ± 0.05

Π ≈ 13%Φ = 66° ± 4°

FLR207230120-40 keV

(Ge8-Ge6)+(Ge9-Ge4)

Page 32: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

X4.8 Flare of 23-July-2002X4.8 Flare of 23-July-2002

8000

6000

4000

2000

Counts

360300240180120600

Scatter Angle (η)

2072301FLR20-30 keV

µp = 0.07 ± 0.04

Π ≈ 12%Φ = 74° ± 3°

8000

6000

4000

2000

Counts

360°300°240°180°120°60°0°

Scatter Angle (η)

2072301FLR20-40 keV

µp = 0.10 ± 0.04

Π ≈ 18%Φ = 79° ± 3°

1400

1200

1000

800

600

400

200

Counts

360300240180120600

Scatter Angle (η)

2072301FLR30-40 keV

µp = 0.33 ± 0.16

Π ≈ 60%Φ = 92° ± 4°

Page 33: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

SummarySummary

Addition of a Be scattering block provides HESSI with significant polarimetric capability.

Polarization sensitivity predicted to be less than a few percent for some X-class flares.

First analysis includes four events :

1) 23-July-2002

2) 21-April-2002

3) 03-November-2003

4) 10-November-2004

Only the July 23rd event shows evidence of polarization (at the ~18% level in the 20-40 keV energy range).

Page 34: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

In ProgressIn Progress

Draft paper should be ready soon :Draft paper should be ready soon :

description of methoddescription of method

positive results for 23-July-2002positive results for 23-July-2002

null results for 21-Apr-2002, 3-Nov-2003, 10-Nov-2004 null results for 21-Apr-2002, 3-Nov-2003, 10-Nov-2004

Simulations with proper input spectra.Simulations with proper input spectra.

Quantify resultsQuantify results

Time-dependence of July 23rd event.Time-dependence of July 23rd event.

Page 35: RHESSI Studies of Solar Flare Hard X-Ray Polarization Mark L. McConnell 1, David M. Smith 2, A. Gordon Emslie 4, Martin Fivian 3, Gordon J. Hurford 3,

Polarization Measurements with Coronas-FPolarization Measurements with Coronas-F

Uses similar concept for polarization measurements (Be scattering into CsI).

Looked at data from three events:

1) 28-Oct-2003

2) 29-Oct-2003

3) 04-Nov-2003

Polarization detected only for 29-Oct-2003

40-60 keV polarization >75%