Page 1
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 1/49
Mediterranean PaPer SerieS 2012
reverSing the viciouS circle in north africa’S
Political econoMy
confronting rural, urban, and youth-related challengeS
M cs P
h a
gë g
J-ys Mss
Page 2
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 2/49
© 2012 Te German Marshall Fund o the United States. All rights reserved.
No part o this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any orm or by any means without permission in writing
rom the German Marshall Fund o the United States (GMF). Please direct inquiries to:
Te German Marshall Fund o the United States
1744 R Street, NW
Washington, DC 20009
1 202 683 2650
F 1 202 265 1662
E [email protected]
Tis publication can be downloaded or ree at www.gmus.org/publications. Limited print
copies are also available. o request a copy, send an e-mail to [email protected] .
gMf Pp Ss
Te GMF Paper Series presents research on a variety o transatlantic topics by sta, ellows, and partners o the German
Marshall Fund o the United States. Te views expressed here are those o the author and do not necessarily represent the
views o GMF. Comments rom readers are welcome; reply to the mailing address above or by e-mail to [email protected] .
a gMf
Te German Marshall Fund o the United States (GMF) is a non-partisan American public policy and grantmaking institu-
tion dedicated to promoting better understanding and cooperation between North America and Europe on transatlantic
and global issues. GMF does this by supporting individuals and institutions working in the transatlantic sphere, by conven-
ing leaders and members o the policy and business communities, by contributing research and analysis on transatlan-
tic topics, and by providing exchange opportunities to oster renewed commitment to the transatlantic relationship. In
addition, GMF supports a number o initiatives to strengthen democracies. Founded in 1972 through a gi rom Germany
as a permanent memorial to Marshall Plan assistance, GMF maintains a strong presence on both sides o the Atlantic. In
addition to its headquarters in Washington, DC, GMF has seven oces in Europe: Berlin, Paris, Brussels, Belgrade, Ankara,
Bucharest, and Warsaw. GMF also has smaller representations in Bratislava, urin, and Stockholm.
a M P Pm
Te Mediterranean Policy Program promotes transatlantic analysis and dialogue on issues aecting Southern Europe, North
Arica, the Levant, and the Mediterranean basin. Priority areas include: understanding trends in Mediterranean societies;
exploring opportunities or south-south cooperation and integration; research on key unctional issues aecting Mediter-ranean security and development; and strengthening the North American policy debate on the region and transatlantic
cooperation on Mediterranean strategy.
a is a iz
Te Istituto Aari Internazionali (IAI), ounded by Altiero Spinelli in 1965, does research in the felds o oreign policy,
political economics, and international security. A non-proft organization, the IAI aims to disseminate knowledge through
research studies, conerences, and publications. o that end, it cooperates with other research institutes, universities, and
oundations in Italy and abroad and is a member o various international networks. More specifcally, the main research
sectors are European institutions and policies, Italian oreign policy, trends in the global economy and internationalization
processes in Italy, the Mediterranean and the Middle East, deense economy and policy, and transatlantic relations. Te IAI
puts out an English-language quarterly (Te International Spectator ), an online webzine ( AfarInternazionali), a series o
research papers (Quaderni IAI) and an Italian oreign policy yearbook (La Politica Estera dell’Italia).
Cover photo: A local armer and his son sell tomatoes to customers o the back o his truck throughout the villages o theDakhla Oasis, Egypt.
© Jason Larkin/arabianEye/Corbis
Page 3
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 3/49
Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’sPolitical Economy
Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challenges
Mediterranean Paper Series
may 2012
M C P, H A, Gë G,3 J-Y M4
R, I A I (IAI), R.
G, Ué P 8 (S-D), A U C.
3 A P, Ué P Pé S.
4 S R F, I R Dé, P.
F
M C P
A P N A C: T, E, M. B
F D S M
H A 1
T A S U G C N A C
G G J-Y M 13
Y E N A C: C C
M C P 23
P I F T P
M C P 39
Page 4
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 4/49
Reversing the vicious circle in North Africa’s political economy iii
Foreword Maria Cristina Paciello
M , N A . A
- . A N A, , - q, , k . A HA , N A
. I -, U R G E T, ,, . I NA , (, , ) .3 Y , N A
, , , , . C - , k , - .
S ; H. A, “S T : ,” Rw f AfP Em, V.38, I.9, , . 467–479.
R H A .
3 R Gë G J-Y M .
T , -, , q. A N A j , ,
.4
T . A , k , k N A . I M A,
q, k.
T T E, , . Y, I , , ,
, k .
4 I k, , . I N A , , — — .
Page 5
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 5/49
The German Marshall Fund of the United Statesiv
M, E T , .Uk , j ’ q . T, E T ,
, -k .
S , , k . T
— — : , , .
T H A E, T, M 95 , . T N A , 8 . T , , . T
q , .A , k N A , , . H, , , k
.
I , Gë G J-YM N A , , q, k. T, A k , , , . P
, , q , , , . A , , .
T k N A M C P . T k . S
Page 6
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 6/49
Reversing the vicious circle in North Africa’s political economy v
, T E, k A M, . U, , N A . T k q - k
: I , T E, .
Page 7
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 7/49
Reversing the vicious circle in North Africa’s political economy 1
Agricultural Policies in Tunisia, Egypt,and Morocco: Between Food Dependencyand Social Marginalization*Habib Ayeb
1
A , A ,
,, “” T,E, L. T A Y, S, B, A, M. I , 8 T k
G . I E, 6 MA-K N .
O , , T E L. B , , , . W
, , , .I .
O , , , , - , , , . T j ,
k. T A .
I T, E, M, 95 .C j , q (, , -, ) . I 95 96, , . T ,
98 99 j “” , P G A N’ E T.
T . T 95 96, N E, H B T, K H II M ( , ) . T A H D E E T.
*T F D A
Page 8
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 8/49
The German Marshall Fund of the United States2
T k ,, , , , , .
T , , , , , -. N, “,” 8 , , q . T A .
T E, T, M
’ , 8.
Agricultural Policy: Irrigation as a Solution
(The Ideology of Irrigation)
The Mobilization of Hydraulic Resources
S , , , , - .E , , k q k. I ,
k . W k N V D E, S, A, M, ,
.
Egypt: The Now-Complete Mastery of the Nile
I E, N - k, M A 9 E, E N, A H D ( N
964). T k , . T ,k 3.5 , - , .
I k, 9 , , . D ,
Page 9
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 9/49
Reversing the vicious circle in North Africa’s political economy 3
D. T E “”, 3.5 .B q - , , q E N, . F 4.5 8, E 5.4 846, 9.734 897, .9 97,
.67 97, 8.97 947, 9, 3 966, 5 986, 6 996, 83 .
T 95 j N .I, q k . T , 98
j, - . H - j, , , Tk, S 995 S W E.
D , k , Lk N . CAPMAS ( E ) .35 95 /3.
H, 96, 46,
CAPMAS, Au qu 1995-2003, E, 4, ..
. T “” .
M, 3.5 E , “” , .
T, E . E , k , .
Agriculture in Tunisia: From the Hope for Food
Security to the Confirmation of Food Dependency
I , T - k.I
’ . T 956 99, q. I, , , , k 99.
T, , T’ -
j . G
A.-M. J, “E M,” Ch Op
Méé, I Aq Méé M, F, 999, .3.
Page 10
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 10/49
The German Marshall Fund of the United States4
9-95 4.8 . T- () , 5 k, , .3 Tk , 65, 956 5, 99, 4.5, 33, 999
4, 9, 7.5 .4
I , , . O , G Gè G .O
, k . V , . F , 96( ,3 ),
.5
F 99, “” k
3 W Bk, “E q ,” Eu, E-m, Déppm u - Rég M-O Afqu u N W Bk, N. 3539-TN, 6, .47.
4 M. E, “L N D ’A T-,” Pé é IRMC/IRA/SRC, TRu Egp Tu: Qu Pp Cé,T, T, D 6, 9.
5 A.-M. J, p , .3.
/ . T / , .6 T , , ( ) q .
Morocco and the Royal Demand
for a Million Irrigated Hectares
I M, T, k . T .
T, M , k T, F ’ . T ,q , k . I K H II M
6 M. E, “R R-F P D A G D RN,” Rô Au D L’ F-m Dpf Fm Ru Pu Dé-ppm, C I R “FA R” (F), T, T, M 9-3, 8.
Page 11
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 11/49
Reversing the vicious circle in North Africa’s political economy 5
k 96 .
T . I 967, M 3,7. I 44,85 975,748,3 99, ,6,7 6.7 I , .3 k - k(88, ) (48, ).8 T M .3 ; .9
T S . T - , - . A . N, (6, 5, ), - q , - 3 .
I, . H, j ,
-
7 A.-M. J, “Cq ’ ,” P. B (.), Du Mgh u Ph-O: éf ’guu, P, H, , . -3.
8 I
9 I
, , , k - .
The Policy of Food Security Exacerbates
Competition for Resources
E ,
k k . I, q (, , .) (,, , .) .
A k , . O
- k k j .T , , k “ .”T - , , q,
. T k , , ,, , , , , .S
Page 12
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 12/49
The German Marshall Fund of the United States6
k, q. I, E, T, M, .
I , , , 94 95 . S -, , , q ( ), q , .
T - T (99–96) “
, , , .” T S Aj P T 987. T . T , NA .
T . P . U
, K, , . T , , q k. I,K 8 . B - , -
N Iq, k 99 K, .
Food Security, Economic Liberalization,
and Social Marginalization
D , , , , , , , . T : ) , ; ) . T , -
, “” .
O k , . I ,
Page 13
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 13/49
Reversing the vicious circle in North Africa’s political economy 7
, k , , . Uq , , , . S , , , ,
, , . I , , , , - ’ .
I ,
, k .
S 95, E T M, .F - , , .T , 99 , , , j , I M F WBk.
M,
“” , , , . F . S .
T Gè T . O 3, . L , k . A , .I E M, T.
N, , , .
T - k, , . T E 99 ( 96/9), 95 N . B 997 , .S k .
S N V “” ,
Page 14
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 14/49
The German Marshall Fund of the United States8
. O , - . T , .
Despite Technical Modernization and
Reforms, Food Dependency Continues
T 8 k
k. I , , , k / q , k . I , E,
, q, 5 . I k, 3 , , , k, E k.I k k, , q, . T
, , . W
T .T , , . F .
,
Trade Balances in Deficit
I 8, , . A , k, . S k k 8 , I, B,, , C. T , , ( ) k ,
. T N, , .
I N A , , , k, k, . T , - , k k
Page 15
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 15/49
Reversing the vicious circle in North Africa’s political economy 9
B , . O , , (.7 ), 7.3 .56 , 3.83 . T , , . P
E F R S P - Bq N A(BNA).4
T ( ) , ,
- , . I , , .
D ,, , , , , q , - . T
4 I
8 . T F A O (FAO)
96, , . T , .
E , T j ’ . W j 988–9 .7 , 99 995, 7.94 . F , (9. -.5 ) (94.7 -6.7 ). T , 4.5
988 99 . 99 995. S 994 995 988 989. I , , , - .3
FAO S, ://..//Dk-D.PID=535#
I
3 BAD (D D L’ D O - OPEV),Tu - Pgmm D’jum Du Su - Agp ,R ’é -(REPP),, .9.
Page 16
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 16/49
The German Marshall Fund of the United States10
, , . I 4 A C S O “P’ C FS,” .T C ,, ,
. I , ,, .6
I, “ ” , , . I , qk ,
996 NGO VC W F S R. I , V C “ .”
Conclusions
I , 8, k T E M,
, .T ,
6 M. W J. Jé, F Sg Twm z f m, FIAN-I, ITDGP, 5, .5.
8 , , , “” k , , , . I 8.5
T , . T , , - , q , , , . F , k , , q,
, .
A A , , , , . I , k k
5 A. F, Hg Aguu f Dpm , OR R, S 9, ://..//..//----599.
Page 17
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 17/49
Reversing the vicious circle in North Africa’s political economy 11
. H, . I , T A , .L, , , k, - , , q
- .
T T, E, M ( k ) I ( ), . I ,
k , - , . M , M B, , k .
, . T ’ k -à- - .
T (, , .) ( , , .) k , , k . S q , - , .
W ,
, , , . T - ( ) . S .
T, , q k
. C, -k , j
Page 18
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 18/49
Reversing the vicious circle in North Africa’s political economy 13
2The Arab Spring and Urban GovernanceChallenges in North African Countries*Gaëlle Gillot and Jean-Yves Moisseron
T A . B j
A , - j k. S , , A - , . A k ,
, , .T A , “ ,” , , . S k, . T -, , - , M .
A k , q. I k “A S” . E A A S, j - . N,
, .
From Medinas to Modern Cities:
An Incomplete Transition
A A ,
“” A .A , k ( mî, “”). C : uk, fuk ( ’ ), hmmm, q q, hmmm q.7 O , j . T , , q . T, k k . W , k k
.B 9 C M,L, S, j . S Muqm
I Kû, . S , j - A . M, -, - ,
7 M. B , L j S, Yém,B, C Fç ’Aé S S S, U A B, 4.
*T F D A
Page 19
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 19/49
The German Marshall Fund of the United States14
.8
T A M ME F, , “” , k k E. A, , q , F u. S k “”
9 93,9 A . E , , E , “” , .T 93,
, ( F , “ ,” C, 93).
I . A j “” , A 93 ,
8 S.-A. S (.), V mum, L
SEDET-CNRS, C G M M-O (GREMAMO) .8, P, L’H,5.
9 J. R, L’um ux p pux .-, N, L é ’, 93 935.
G. G, “L M: ,, , ,” F. L (.), L m u, P, EHESS, .
95.
I - , . T A, T M. D 96 , - , . A
M , 66 T A 5 M E. T
. F - 98, k , - . T : - A .
T k - . D ( T, 979), , -, . T k
. S - , . T ,
J.-F. T, L mép Su , P, E, .
Page 20
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 20/49
Reversing the vicious circle in North Africa’s political economy 15
, ’ ( , , , , hmmm, k, ). A k , , , . T,
T.T
( g ).
T ( , -, , ), , . Tk , , (
k k ), .
T : , , . O , , , . T , ,
F. D F. N-B, G u é-ppm u ég é h , P,L’H, .
.
The Heterogeneity of the Urban World:
The Coexistence of Gleaming Malls
and Shanty Towns
O 3 , A . I , , -, q. Y ( 8-35 ) , ,
. S, ,
j q q, . Y ’ j . IE,
j , kk k , j q.3 W , . A
k , - - .
I , , . T C, 8 . T : , , , - ;
k
3 S M. A, “Y L Mk Tj: 98 99,” A. R (.), Th Egp L
Mk f Rfm, C, E R F,; J.-Y M E. O, “L ’é E,” M-Mk N.6,W /, . 7–39.
Page 21
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 21/49
The German Marshall Fund of the United States16
, k k. S- , q , , k .4
S- k , . I C, , k , 7 .5
T . I 95 96, , , . I 97, k - , . O j A , 95, .T j . T k k, k .
4 A. D, “U
j: M E ,” Bu m V.36, .9, J ,.46–6; F. B, “L’ é ’é D ’E,” Ru gégph ’E V.49, .4, 9, ://../98#q
5 T, p ; M. L, B.A. D, G. D A M.L, U guu Méé: f mpémé, P, L’H/CIHEAM, 995.
M, . T , jk , k .6 T
j , , -q.
S q, q . B k, , ,
E , . M, M E, -S E.7 C , k .
T E A ,
6 D N-B, p ; V. C, Lqu égu Buh, u h jux f uqu u u , B, I ç P-O (I), 8.
7 A. Bâ (.), L Mgh à ’épu mg u-h; Immg u mg, P, L’H, 9.
Page 22
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 22/49
Reversing the vicious circle in North Africa’s political economy 17
j .8 O Kû, .I A BW , . P k
.T, , : , , -, , , .C ; k; ,
, ( , , , );9 - ; , .3 T
8 P. S (.) ., L’u m : Pqu,um u, P, CNRS , 999.
9 D, p
3 N. F N, “L q ’é à B,”V T u M-O N. , 6.
-- . P q. T C L, S C, j C, , j E.3 T , , , ,
k , .
F k k, , q — — , j ’ j, .
F , NGO -, - .3 T , , , . S
3 B. F, “Ré é - C,”Géfu V.85, ., , .9–8.
3 A. S, “Q ”: L é ’ P: ,”Gé V.85, ., , .9–4.
Page 23
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 23/49
The German Marshall Fund of the United States18
C. T -- (â), , .33
The Urban Stakes of the Arab Revolts
P A , j , — , — . A S B, T
, A S . I , , M B . T - T, q , R G. T
8, “A S.”
B , (P K, ’ T, T Sq C), , . T , , k k
. T k , . T E T Sq
33 F, p
“ E,” .34
T , , q , . T , . B , T , j .O , k q q , ,
.
I k A S . T A B T TSq C. T E S J T Sq.T M B. T ,
34 M.B. A, “D è “é,” S. B. N B. D (.), P ,éu Tfm u pqu Mé-é , R T M, A C, ,.9– 9 ://.-./IMG//RTM_HS______.
Page 24
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 24/49
Reversing the vicious circle in North Africa’s political economy 19
, k, , D . T S - E, M B.C , , “” .S q “” k k
, , .
T T Sq A989 , k : R P B, q .N, “.”
O k A S
, , k . A , .F , T, M H k 8. I k T q .35
35 J. Ak, “L ééé ,” P “A q Mé-é (MEDYSOC): L é é,” P, N 7-8, . P - ://-.-./IMG//J_MEDYSOC_8.
E L, B F C. T .36
I - j , . I , , k k , , . Tq - .
T
A k . S B A Mk, (P K, P B, A B T, T Sq E). T . T , , k q j. T , , I , j M E, A. I T, A-N ( j)
36 F. G, “R ’ ç L,” Mgh-Mhk N., , W /.
Page 25
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 25/49
The German Marshall Fund of the United States20
, E. T M B, j, A-N , , k , k .T N D P
. T k E , .
T , , , , .
The Impact of the Changes in the Arab World
on City GovernanceW A S F , , k . T I A , , . T , , S. I
Tk , J D P, I, , , . T
A .
T . I ( ), , A 99. T , , .
T . I q , . T , , ,
. T - .
A . T M, - , - ,, . I , , , k , q. C
T, - -j, .W k C, .
Page 26
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 26/49
Reversing the vicious circle in North Africa’s political economy 21
T , - . B , .U, A A S, , , j - .
Page 27
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 27/49
Reversing the vicious circle in North Africa’s political economy 23
3Youth Exclusion in North African Countries:Continuity or Change?
Maria Cristina Paciello
Y k N
A , J F, Z E A B A T HMk E. T N A . A k ,
. O N A , k , , , T E, .
A , k
. U, , T E, k A M, . U, , N A. T , E T, k
q - . T k : I , T E
; -.
Growing Unemployment and Insecurity
Among the Youth
O ( 7), E,T, M qk k- , -
. S ,A’ . I E (-6) T(-7), (GDP) 5 , 7 6.3 7, A (-7) 4. .37 H, N A , k , ,
.
T j k , .T . I A,
37 G. A, “E’ R G: A ‘E SS’,” Dpm Vwp, N. , SOAS, F 9, ://...k/733//DV-.; I M F (IMF), Ag: 2008
A IV Cu—Sff Rp; Pu Ifm N h Exu B Du; m h Exu- D f Ag, IMF C R, N. 9/8, A9 ://../////9/98.; IMF, Tu: 2010 A IV Cu—Sff Rp; Pu Ifm N h Exu B Du-; m h Exu D f Tu, IMFC R, N. /8, S , ://..//////8..
Page 28
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 28/49
The German Marshall Fund of the United States24
( 8); E, 4.4 6, 9.7 998; T, -BA , 44.9 9 . 999, , B A’ , .38 I M, ( 3.8 997 3. 6).39 T ’
N A .4
T , , k N A , , j .4 T k N A (
38 F A, L. A, “S é à ô éé. L é ’ M,” Cg
Pp, N. 3, N . F E, R. A,“L S, E U EE, 988-6,” ERF Wkg Pp , N. 7, 7.F T I. H, “C q’ jééé,” L p Tu, F 6, ://../6/973/--q----- j-.; M. B R, Tu: E, Em Séé, T, S E, .
39 M. B E, “Dôé ô M:q é ’ ,”L’Aé u Mgh, . 3, 7.
4 M. C. P R. P, “G D SC N A,” P M
Mm w h W h A-Mum W , I- C, P, N 3-4, .
4 B. H, H. M, M. H, Tu f 14 Ju p m: Th u k fgu f Eup P, E-M HR Nk (EMHRN), J ; M. B R, p .; L. A, . .; R. Bk-H F. T, “LMk P M F A,” E C D-G E F A, Lu mk pfm mg,T, M, A, B, ; R. A, p .
T E), j , , .4
O , k N A . IA M, - j . I T E, - k , j . T L, , ’ - , k T, E, L.T k . I T, , B A, 5.8 3.7 ,
3.9 43.8 .43
G k j , , - S, K, J, G, . I E, -Mk , 8.9 q .4
4 M. C. P, “T I E C E-M R,” Th I Sp , V. 45, I
3, S , . 5–69; M. C. P, “L’ è M,” Mgh-Mhk, N. 6, W/, . 73–98; E. G-O J.-Y M, “L ’é É,” Mgh-
Mhk, N. 6, W /, . 7–39.
43 H. T, “L’ é T: Aé ,” L, J 7, ://.//--------=7375
Page 29
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 29/49
Reversing the vicious circle in North Africa’s political economy 25
, k , k .44
Economic Liberalization Reforms Biased
Against the Youth
T k ,
.
D k- , N A k, ,
j ( A E) k ( / E, M, T).45 T T,
E A, k, k , j
44 “E’ .4 ,” Egp Ip , F 8, ://.-.//66578; “E 54 O,” Ahm O, D , ://.../NC/3//849/B/E/E--------O./
45 F E, E. G-O J.-Y. M, p; S. A, “T P E R E,” CgPp, N. 5, O, 7; N. E-M, “T I R M L Mk P J C E,” ERF Wkg Pp , N. 3, M 7. F A L. A, ..; R . Bk-H F. T, p .;F. T A. H, “L’é é ’ à ’,” Mgh-Mhk, N. 6, W /,. 99–3.
k . T -, - (/ ), q k j k.46 A , 9 j 8 .47 S, , T’ , , , k N
A , , , .48
D , N A . A , , , q.49 A N A, , ,
- (SME), k , (.., , , , k , ). G k ,
46 B. H ., p .; M. B R, p .; L. A, p
47 M. S A. V-C, “L MkD T: T I Y U,”A D Bk, Wkg Pp S, N. 3,F .
48 B. H , p .
49 F E, L. A, p .; R. E-M P. M,Egp: A Mm f Chg, L, Z P, 9.F T, W Bk (WB), Dmqu ’Emp
Aéqu Fm pm Dpômé U,W Bk, 9; M. S ., p .; M. B R-, . .; F A, ; L. A, p .; R. Bk-H F. T, p .
Page 30
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 30/49
The German Marshall Fund of the United States26
( ) NA , , k . S, (FDI) M, E, T j , .5 I A, FDI ,
- ( j), - .5 M, , , - j .5
F, k
N A . I , - . I ,
5 S. A, p ; N. E- M, . .; L. A, p ; M.H B, M. A C, H. B H,“T B : T ,” Th Ju f Nh
Af Su, V.4, I. , J 9, . 3–44.5 L. A, p .
5 B. H ., p .; I , A,O ; G. B, “G j: A E,” Th D Nw Egp , F , ://../k--/-j---------.
.53
I , j, , - . S, , jk. T, -
. T j , k k , , .
F, j I M F W Bk, 99 E, A, , , ,
q q .54 E T, ,
53 F k , L. A, p .; B. H .,p ; R. Bk-H F. T, p ; M. C,B. D, E. V, L’E f ux ému u Mgh Fm, p ,K, ; A. B, “E é,” Ju Afqu,N. 368, M 8–J 3, 6; A. Mj, “L MkP M F T,” EC D-G E FA, L Mk Pfm Mg, Tu,
M Ag, O P 6, . , .
54 M. C. P, “E’ L D: T q,” D. P (.), Egp: A -uh g h w f hg, GMF/IAI MP, M ://..//-/GMF-IAI/M-_.; A. L,“A: C, T, S P O,” V.M M. K (.), S P h ME: P, Em G Dm, L,P M, 9.
Page 31
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 31/49
Reversing the vicious circle in North Africa’s political economy 27
q .55 T q N A q k, k q , k .
North African Government Responsesto Youth Economic Exclusion in the
Post-Popular Uprisings of Early 2011
I E T, k - , , , . T , - T E
- . I , j , k .56
I T,
k -
55 B. H , p .; M. B R, p
56 A A M, .
M F J A A , .T k k: A (“” A) , k B A; , - k , $; , j . A , , k
k . T A , j , k. I - j k ( - ); k ; k k - . A ,
- k T , , k , , .
T J P, - - - T S , ,
- k A. T , , k , - , T’ , T
Page 32
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 32/49
The German Marshall Fund of the United States28
. I , , , j .H, - j , , k, q , .
I E, ’ - , , -. T - , SC A F (SCAF) J 4, Mk ( , , ).A k
SCAF. W ’ , k , , q .
The Political Economy of Youth Exclusion:
Explaining Continuity and Change
T N A k , j . A , k-
, ( E A), ’ - .57 E N A j -, , q, q, .58 T
, , - . I , j , , -, -, -k .
T , k
, , , , . I T, BA-T k
57 S, B. H, L F ’é Em pqu ép Tu, P, L Dé, 6;S. H (.), Nwk f Pg h M ETh P f Em Rfm R , N Yk, 7; S.A, . .
58 A , U T ’I, C ’A (UTICA) T; F- E I (FEI) G F C C (GFCC) E; Céé- Géé E Aé (CGEA), Céé- Aé P (CAP), Céé N P Aé (CNPA), A F C’E (SEVE), Céé I P Aé (CIPA) A.
Page 33
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 33/49
Reversing the vicious circle in North Africa’s political economy 29
, k .59 W , , N A , .
J q, , .6 T G, J 8 T , . T k ’ j , G PC (GPC), k . T
, k .
I , E
59 S N. M,“L é ’ é è B A,” L P, F 7, ://../7/89/-----------.; B. H , p ; B. H, ..; R. F. G, “C T: C q à ’,” Tu Wh, D4, ://../=366; A.H, “Y T R,”
C P P F, ://..//A_H,_Y___T_R,_S_-CPPF_%.
6 A. A. K, “T’ P-B A C: A P,”MERIP, J 6, ://..//6.; J. H H. E-S, EmLz, S Cp Im Wf P,L, P M, 9; B. H, , p
T . T E T . IE, SCAF, E , , ,
k . G j -Mk , - . F , , S R, -J, Mk J , ,H B, k- .T , M E-S,
’ F M Y B G Mk.
I T, M G, B A, k .6 R , G k , k
6 B. H ., p
Page 34
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 34/49
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
.6
T , Bj C E, B A 994 , , ( S ), J P - . H, , k , Bj C-E, ,
(84) , .63 M, j k , j, , k ,k , .
T , E ’
Mk. T , F E I (FEI), -à- . I T, , q
6 M. C. P, “T: C
,” S. C N. T (.), Th Chgf S Su h M, IAI WkP, S ://../.=&=665
63 E. G, “T: ‘L j Béj Cï E’,” L M, F 8, ://../q////8/---------_4867_3.
, -, -à- . A , - - T, , -k. W U T ’I, C ’A(UTICA), B A’
, - ,64 WB, B A.T , C E C T (CONECT), , UTICA. A
T (.., , , ), k ,65 - T.
64 S B A, UTICA, S ’U M R, , k , , k
. T .65 I , T, S . A “CONECT, ,” Tu Nw,S 4, ://.-.//_53_+++.; “T: CONECT é é,”Wmg C, S 4, ://.//-38--------
Page 35
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 35/49
Reversing the vicious circle in North Africa’s political economy 31
F, -k . I E, SCAF - , , , , .66 I Mk,
P’A. T R C A, Mk, , -A P, , .
A T , - ,
H C P R(I S R Oj R), 45 , , U T S U UG.67 A, S A, B A , J . H,
,
66 M. C. P, “E: C ,” p
67 M. C. P, “T: C ,” p
-k , - . P , A M . M, (.., M J T L R J L) (.., Ak Mq U U G) q
3, CA O . I , , I k .68
What are the Prospects for Rethinking
Economic Policies and Reshaping
the Political Economy in the Post-Arab
Uprising?
I - , k
T E : k I , q . W I , , A , ,
-k
68 T , , I ’ .
Page 36
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 36/49
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
The Electoral Success of Islamist Parties
O , I E, T, M . T q . A-N T F J P (FJP) E q k , .69
B k k .7 A k , I , , , , . I E, , FJP
69 S “E B : M- k,” Ahm O, O 8, ://.../NC/3//5348/B/E/E-B--M--k.; “T’ E k k :A,” A O, O 7, ://.../NC/3//55/B/E/T-E-k--k----A..
7 F A-N, “H J ’ Sé 6 ,” Wmg, N 4, ://..//-348--j---------6---; “TI - ,” AhmO, O 6, ://.../NC/3//59/B/E/T-I----.; “T:E é ,”
AfquJ , N , ://.qj./--796.; F FJP, “E I ,” AhmO, D 8, ://.../NC/3//339/B/E/E-I------.
j-k,7 A-N P . M, - T ( C A) E ( P), I k k (.., T E) . H,
- ’ .
T , I T E, . W I j N A .T I
E T k , k j; I . I I k-
j k
. I T, , A-N k
F , q I ’ . A,
7 S FJP , ://..k//739553-FJP-P-E
Page 37
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 37/49
Reversing the vicious circle in North Africa’s political economy 33
, I , , - , -à-
k.
M, I , FJP E A-N T, , , k , , - . F , , , , - , ;
j.7 A , ,
q .73 I T, , A-N , , . T j .74 I
7 F FJP, F. E-S, “Q&A A SF J P A S G. T E FJP ,”
Bu T Egp , F , ://-.////I:36/Q-A--A-S/I:3
73 I
74 “T, E é ’ ,” G , N , ://../-/---------/--35.
, I - k Tk, A,L, G . I , - L . I , ,
- , , .
T - T E , k , q
. I E, I , , . T , k , , SCAF. I , , .R, , M B
FJP. M, I k k , . W M B , -Mk , k
Page 38
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 38/49
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
, SCAF q . F, k SCAF, M B E ,75 -, k, , . I , k FJP Mk k . T k
I , k- , , - . Y, , , E .
A T , A-N
89 7 C A , , . A , A-N I E . M, T, ’ . T O
— A-N, C R, Ek — k ,
75 S ’ -à- M B.
k . N k . F ,H D, , B A .76 M, T E
- . A , , , Rk A, -- R G, A-N’, - , .
Opportunities and Challenges for Youth Activism
T E T . Y : - . T k
.
S Mk, E (.., A 6 , U R’ Y, R’
76 Y. R, “T q,” A Jz, A , ://.j.////3/337493543.
Page 39
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 39/49
Reversing the vicious circle in North Africa’s political economy 35
Y C, ) E , k .T k k , , ; Mk, , ; Mk’ ; . Y ’
, . A SCAFq , , ’ , q .
I T, B A,
G. Y , , O 3 , -k , , .77 I , k
. B ,
77 A , k Duu, T, U TS, . S K. J, “T:O B,” Op Dm, D 8, ://../k-j/--
, .78 I , E , I J 5, , M B I q - .79
H, , k -k - . T E . I , , , ,
. I Mk Y R C (YRC), J 5 .8 P
78 F T, : Ik (“C”) J Ié- Dé Ak Mq(“ ”) , S A. F E,, , “L’ ”
H Mk LC A A F.
79 A. E S, “M B - ,” Th D S, J , - ://.../O/C//J-/6474----------.#KWNL9
8 I , C, J .
Page 40
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 40/49
The German Marshall Fund of the United States36
-à- SCAF, , E .8 G .
Y , , . T R C , k , . T , E, ’ . Y, , Mk, j k, , ,
k’.8 I , .
Conclusion
I k ’ N A , k
8 M. C. P, “E: C ,” p
8 T j , A 6 YM M E-B k E F , , k.
’ , - . T q . A, :
• ;
• k I L O
(ILO) ;
• ;
• k ;
• q ;
• j , .
A q - - . I , j k
, j, k , k , . A -
Page 41
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 41/49
Reversing the vicious circle in North Africa’s political economy 37
, , -, . I , -k .
A T E , , , . A , k k . H, I T E, . O , - , -
j ,I k k . O - . I , k- , , ,
j. I ,
k , . I , , (.., - , , , .),
, j .
T k , -k, . Y , j , , , , - . T , , ;k - -à- , - ; ; . T , , k . I , , k , k
k k (.., , ’ , ). F - , . I , .
Page 42
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 42/49
Reversing the vicious circle in North Africa’s political economy 39
T , ,
k A . A , , , .
A H. A , , k, , - , j E, T, M , ,, , ’ . S j N A’ .T
8.T , , N A k / q , k .
I N A , G. G J.-Y.M , , k , . T NA . W
, - , q , . M, j , . P , C C, , q . Y,
, .
E , M C P .D k- ,
N A k, , j k . T N A q. T FDI M, E, T j
j. M, , - j . A , q , q
Policy Implicationsfrom a Transatlantic Perspective
Maria Cristina Paciello4
Page 43
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 43/49
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
k. L, - k, .
I , j , T E, A M, - . C k . I E T, - , - . A , N A k
, , , k , , .
A H. A, NA k , . T N A , ’ , ,
. I q, , N A k . T k k , N A ’ , , ,
, , , .83
W , G. G J.-Y. M , -
, ( ). T N A, ,
. M, k ,- , , .
A - , M. C. P. T . T :
• ( - )
83 S H. A’ . A L V C- I P M ://..//
Page 44
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 44/49
Reversing the vicious circle in North Africa’s political economy 41
;
• k k I L O (ILO) ;
• ;
• k ;
• q ;
• j , .
A
q - - . S N A , . T : k
, ; - ;
, .84 F , . C, , , , j . B , q , ’ , N A (
, , , .) -k, .85
T j T E - , M. C. P,
. I , j k , j, k , , , k , q (, , j, .), . M,
84
I , R. E M P. M, p ; R. B, “C D Nk R L, P A R E,” Bh Ju f M E Su, V. 38, I. 3,, . 39–45.
85 S R. B, . ; R. E M P. M, p ; D.S (.), C C: G, U Sp G M, T A U C P,9.
Page 45
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 45/49
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
, , -, . M, (.., , , , ) -k. I,
- .O . A G. G J.-Y. M , - k NA .
A , k q -
. T I E, T, M k- , .86 I , H. A, k . S, A
A S, , G. G J.-Y.M. T , ,
86 S M. C. P’ .
k, T E, M. C. P .
Y, I T E, . O - , - j , I k k .87 T . M, , , -
-k .
A , j , , , - ; k - -à- , - ;
87 I; S. C, “T I Tj: FR P,” S C, P C,J K (.), Nw S-P A Nh
Af: A T Pp, F 4, , ://../-/_/____.
Page 46
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 46/49
Reversing the vicious circle in North Africa’s political economy 43
; . T , , k . I , , k , k k k (.., , ’ , ).88 F ,
. W , , , k- , .89
I , k N A :
, , .A , U S EU NA q. W EU U S ( ),
, E T. I - T E,
88 F , P. C, “C S,Y I,” S C, P C, JK (.), p
89 F E, R. B, p
’ N A ( ,, ) - . I , ’
.
W - N A , U S EU :
• A , k , ;9
• ( - - );
• k ;
• .
I ,
- , EU U S . F , ,
9 A. Mk B. A, Th m f h A Spg,OxC Rh Pp 79, D ://....k/k//---3.
Page 47
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 47/49
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
- , q N A , .
A , , EU U S, k NA , - ,9 -à- .C . F, - - , ,
.E , NA k “ ,” .
I , q ’ . I E T, , :
• j, , ;
9 H , p
•
;
• k ;
• q .9
B - , . F , . A , EU U S q N A
A , , . F, EU U S .T , -
(.., - -, , ,
9 J.-P. C N. T, “Rk EU’ M- P P-/,” IAI Wkg Pp, N. 6, ://..//DIAI/6.
Page 48
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 48/49
Reversing the vicious circle in North Africa’s political economy 45
, , ).
S, , EU U S - .93 I , EU U.S. N A j .
93 O, “P P R EU’ A S,” Oxfm Bfg N, N 4, ://..//..//------4-.
Page 49
8/2/2019 Reversing the Vicious Circle in North Africa’s Political Economy: Confronting Rural, Urban, and Youth-Related Challe…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/reversing-the-vicious-circle-in-north-africas-political-economy-confronting 49/49
Off i c e s