Top Banner
- uating po- gical andards e- aluating ypo- ogical tandards valuating Typo- logical Standards Re- valuating Typo- ogical Standards Re- valuating Typo- logical Standards Re- valuating Typo- ogical Standards valuating Typo- logical Standards Re- valuating Typo- logical Standards Re- valuating Typo- logical Standards Re- valuating Typo- logical Standards uating po- ical ndards Re- valuating Typo- logical Standards Re- valuating Typo- logical Standards valuating Typo- logical Standards Re- valuati Typo- logical Standa Re- valuatin Typo- logical Standa Re- valuat Typo- logica Stand Re- valuating Typo- ogical Standards Re- valuating Typo- logical Standards Barch Design Report 01 Benjamin Hale Year 05 Manchester School of Architecture Semester 01 Fez Medina Reconnecting a City through Post- Impact Led Conservation Magda Sibley & Griff Evans Semester 02 Manchester, New Islington Gemischtgenuzte Hochäuser Projekt Manchester Griff Evans & Isabelle Doucet. Architecture as Urban Catalyst
50

Revaluating Typological Standards

Mar 21, 2016

Download

Documents

Benjamin Hale

A 5th Year Design Report from the University of Manchester School of Architecture
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Revaluating Typological Standards

B

enja

min

Hal

e

S

TU

DIO

1 &

2 D

ES

IGN

RE

PO

RT

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Barch Design Report 01Benjamin Hale

Year 05

Manchester School of

Architecture

Semester 01Fez Medina

Reconnecting a City through Post-

Impact Led Conservation

Magda Sibley & Griff Evans

Semester 02Manchester, New Islington

Gemischtgenuzte Hochäuser

Projekt Manchester

Griff Evans & Isabelle Doucet.

Architecture as Urban Catalyst

Page 2: Revaluating Typological Standards

!!

!"#$%&"#$$%&'(&")%*'%%+"*',"-'%$$!+./"0%1"2%-!+(3"4,567%8"(5*9,6/",'+

Title: [Re]valuating Typological Standards

A Design Report on Work Produced by Benjamin Hale

2(+79%/*%6"479,,$",: "#679!*%7*56%

2(+79%/*%6";+!<%6/!*&2(+79%/*%6"2%*6,=,$!*(+";+!<%6!/*&

0!:*9">%(6"

#5*9,68"?%+@(A!+3B3C($%B5*,6/8"2(.-("4!)$%&D"E6!:: "F<(+/"(+-"G/()%$$%"H,57%*

'()*+,-./#.0.*%1

G+",6-%6"*,"5+-%6*(I%"*9%"',6I"7(66!%-",5*"*9!/"&%(6D"G"',5$-"$!I%"*,"%J*%+-"A&"*9(+I/"*,"A&"*5*,6/D"2(.-("4!)$%&D"E6!:: "F<(+/" (+-" G/()%$$%" H,57%*3" K!*9,5*" *9%!6" .5!-(+7%" (+-"=%6/%<%6(+7%"A&" ',6I" ',5$-" 9(<%" +,*" -%<%$,=%-" *," *9%"%J*%+*"!*"9(/3"G"',5$-"($/,"$!I%"*,"*9(+I"*9%"/*5-%+*/",: "*9%"5+!<%6/!*&" ,: " 0%1D" :,6" *9%!6" 7,+*!+5%-" 7,,=%6(*!,+" !+" *9%"

L,=&6!.9*"M"?%+@(A!+C($%"479(+1"NOPN

!!!"#$%#%&'$(#)'#*&)+,-."+,-./0-#"'-"*1!!!"%&'$(#)'#*&)%/*&+%2'%#%,3/#"+,-./0-#"'-4

Page 3: Revaluating Typological Standards

!!!

Page 4: Revaluating Typological Standards

!<

Page 5: Revaluating Typological Standards
Page 6: Revaluating Typological Standards

<!

!"#$%&'#(&)"'!*+)",!-+#!&!./*&

Page 7: Revaluating Typological Standards

<!!

2.3%&"Q6,@%7*"!A(.%/":6,A"4%A%/R*%6"S+%"T"B',",: "#(;L3"4,567%8"(5*9,6/"(6*',6I

B9%"#679!*%7*56%"(/";6)(+"L(*($&/*"/*5-!,"5+!*"7%+*6%/",+"*9%"%J=%6!A%+*(*!,+"(+-"5+-%6/*(+-!+.",: "*9%"-!::%6%+*"/9(=%/"(6R79!*%7*56%" 7(+" *(I%" !+" ,6-%6" *," :5+7*!,+" (/" (+" 56)(+" 7(*($&/*3"B9%",<%6($$"(!A",: "*9%"/*5-!,"!/"*,")%7,A%"("=$(7%":,6"*%/*!+."*9%"+,*!,+",: "7(*($&/*"!+"-!::%6%+*".%,.6(=9!7($D"A%*9,-,$,.!7($"(+-"*9%A(*!7"/%**!+./

Page 8: Revaluating Typological Standards

<!!!

Page 9: Revaluating Typological Standards

!J

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

4*%5+/6(%"+*7 7 7 7 P" " " " " "" "8$9:%.57;<86-%659-7 8+*%.=%7 "&7 !.1:+*1.7 %+7 >%6/"+7?*"%7@5+:+1"%"+*7 7>.0.1%.57A*.

C!/*,6!7($"(+-"B9%,6%*!7($"Q,/!*!,+" " UF+<!6,+A%+*D"Q$(7%"(+-"47($%" " V

>.0.1%.57B,+

C!/*,6!7($"(+-"B9%,6%*!7($"Q,/!*!,+" " PPF+<!6,+A%+*D"Q$(7%"(+-"47($%" " PP

8$9:%.57;C86-%659-78+*%.=%7""&[email protected]+*9-7!.1:+*1.

>.0.1%.57A*.L6!*!7($"W5-.%A%+*/" " " PXL,+*%A=,6(6&"L,+*%J*" " " PX

>.0.1%.57B,+

8$9:%.57;DE.1"#*7F78+006*"(9%"+*&7A6%-"*.7+3 7G.957H7>%6/"+7I+5)7 7 7 7 77>.0.1%.57A*." " " " "?6!%: " " " " " PV?6!%: "#==6(!/($" " " " PVH%/!.+"2%*9,-,$,.&"" " " NOL,+/*657*!,+"L,+*%J*"" " " NO7 7 7>.0.1%.57B,+" " " " "?6!%: " " " " " NP?6!%: "#==6(!/($" " " " NPH%/!.+"2%*9,-,$,.&"" " " NPL,+/*657*!,+"L,+*%J*"" " " NP

8$9:%.57;JE"11.5%9%"+*&7'K1%59(%" " " " " "#)/*6(7*"" " " " PV"

8$9:%.57;HLM.*%7N+*%$&7N9*($.1%.57"*7N+%"+*" " " " " "B9%"#6+-($%"G+*%6<%+*!,+" " " NX

77 7 7 7 7 78$9:%.57;ON9*9#.0.*%729,79*/7@59(%"(.&7@5+3.11"+*9-7>%6/".17

Y%7*56%/"(**%+-%-"T"45AA(6&" " NU06,+*"Q(.%" " " " NV

8$9:%.57;PB.($*+-+#Q79*/7L*M"5+*0.*%

R888@7:5.1.*%9%"+*7S75.:+5%T

8$9:%.57;U

"" " " " " ""!

#0123124+++

Page 10: Revaluating Typological Standards

P

%12506782901

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

(+($&/!/" (+-" 6%/%(679" 7,+-57*%-" =6%<!,5/$&" !+" *9%" /%RA%/*%63"B9%"L96!/*A(/")6%(I":,$$,'%-"("/5=%6R76!*![5%"'!*9!+"*9%"/79,,$"'9%6%"*9%/%"!-%(/"'%6%"=6%/%+*%-"*,",*9%6" 5+!*/" (+-" (" 7,+/*657*!<%" %<($5(*!,+"'(/" /,5.9*3"

/%A%/*%6"*',3"B9%"/%A%/*%6"*',"=9(/%",: "*9%"5+!*D"'(/"+(A%-" \C,5/!+." *9%" 2(//%/8" Y%(6+!+." :6,A" ?%6$!+]3"B9%"5+!*"6%<,$<%-"(6,5+-"("6%/%(679%-")(/%-"\-!/7,<%6&]"=6,7%//3"FJ!/*!+."A(//"9,5/!+."*&=,$,.!%/"'%6%"%J(AR!+%-"!+"?%6$!+"("7!*&"'9%6%"*9%6%"9(/")%%+"A579"%J=%6!RA%+*(*!,+"'!*9"9,5/!+."*9%"!+9()!*(+*/",: "(+"!+-5/*6!($"

G/()%$$%"H,57%*"(+-"E6!:: "F<(+/"'(/"+,*"%//%+*!($$&"("

*9%" /*5-%+*" 9(-" )%%+"',6I!+." !+" *9%" 5+!*" ',6I/9,=/"

$%7*56%")&"%!*9%6"E6!:: "F<(+/",6"G/()%$$%"H,57%*3"G+"A&"7(/%"G"-!-"(66!<%"(*"("=,!+*"'9%6%"G"*9,5.9*"!*"=,//!)$%"*,"=5/9"*9%"-%/!.+":56*9%6"(+-"*9!/"6%/5$*%-"!+"(+"%(6$&"7,+7%=*5($"/79%A%3"#"76,//R5+!*"76!*![5%"'(/"(.(!+"9%$-"

R!+./"(+-"*9%")%.!++!+./",: "("<!()$%"7,+7%=*3"

Page 11: Revaluating Typological Standards

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

N

>.0.1%.57A*.7AM.5M".,

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

2(.-("4!)$%& >.0.1%.57B,+7AM.5M".,

N26O)4)/#)&6#!-65$)68&'$(#)'#*&)6%/69&+%26:%#%,3/#6/#*<(-6*2(#6')2#)&/6-26#$)6)@0)&(4)2#%#(-26%2<6*2<)&/#%2<(2.6-? 6 #$)6<(??)&=)2#6/$%0)/6%&'$(#)'#*&)6'%26#%1)6(26-&<)&6#-6?*2'#(-26%/6%26*&+%26'%#%,3/#"65$)6-B)&%,,6%(46-? 6 #$)6 /#*<(-6 (/6 #-6+)'-4)6%60,%')6 ?-&6#)/#(2.6#$)62-#(-26-? 6'%#%,3/#6 (26<(??)&)2#6.)-.&%0$('%,>64)#$-<-=,-.('%,6%2<6#$)4%#('6/)##(2./"6N26#$)6%'%<)4('63)%&6PQRR=PQRP>6#$(/6 (2B)/#(.%#(-26 ?-'*/)/6 -26 '-,,)'#(B)6 $-*/(2.6 /'$)4)/6 #$%#6 '%26+)6&)%<6%/6*&+%26)2#(#()/6'-40-/)<6-? 6(2<(B(<*%,67'),,/;6?-&6,(B(2.6D#$&-*.$6 0&-')//)/6 -? 6 &)0)#(#(-2>6 D*&+%2E6 0%##)&2>6 %)/#$)#('6 %2<6?-&4%,6$-4-.)2(H%#(-2E6%2<6*&+%2>6'-,,)'#(B)6?*2'#(-2/6D,%*2<)&=)##)/>6/$-00(2.>6.%&<)2/E6#$%#6-?#)26#*&26/*'$6,%&.)=/'%,)6/'$)4)/6(2#-6'(#()/=!(#$(2=#$)='(#3"

5$)6/)4)/#)&6!(,,6?-'*/6-26S)&,(26%2<6I%2'$)/#)&"6S)&,(26'%26+)6/))26%/6%6+-#$6$(/#-&('%,6%2<6'-2#)40-&%&36,%+-&%#-&36-? 6$-!6(<)=-,-.()/>6*#-0(%/6%2<6'&)%#(B(#36%&)6)@0&)//)<6#$&-*.$6%&'$(#)'#*&%,6%2<6*&+%26 0&-C)'#/"6 N#/6 %/#-2(/$(2.,36 &('$6 $(/#-&36 #*&2)<6S)&,(26(2#-6%26(2/#&*'#(B)67,%+-&%#-&3;6?-&6%&'$(#)'#*&)6%2<6*&+%26<)/(.2>6%2<6#$(/62-#6#$)6,)%/#6!$)26(#6'-4)/6#-6$-*/(2.6)@0)&(4)2#/"6N2=<))<>6%#62*4)&-*/6$(/#-&('%,6-''%/(-2/6S)&,(26!%/6?-&')<6#-6&%<(='%,,36&)#$(216%2<6(22-B%#)6$-!6(#6!%/6#-6$-*/)6#$)64%//)/K6%/6%6+--4(2.6 (2<*/#&(%,6 '(#36 DRT#$)6:)2#*&3E>6 %64-<)&264)#&-0-,(/>6%26 (2#)&!%&6 '(#3>6 %60-/#=!%&6<(B(<)<6 '(#36 #-&26+)#!))26 /-'(%,(/46%2<6'%0(#%,(/>6%2<6%60-/#=RTUT6'(#360,*2.(2.6 ?&-46%&'$(#)'#*&%,6)*0$-&(%6(2#-6%6'(#36#$%#6(/6%&46%+)&6/)@3"

H6"G/()%$$%"H,57%*

Page 12: Revaluating Typological Standards
Page 13: Revaluating Typological Standards

^

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

Page 14: Revaluating Typological Standards

X

Page 15: Revaluating Typological Standards

_

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

Page 16: Revaluating Typological Standards

Cultural Context I: Response to Unit Proposition - Semester One

#7:275;:+#0123<2+%=+

"34>0143+20+)192+?50>0492901

H5%" *," *9%"+(*56%",: " *9%"5+!*" (+-" !*]/" /%=(6(*!,+" !+*,"*'," /%A%/*%6/" G" '!$$" (**%A=*" *," $!+I" *9%A" !+" /579" ("

'9!$/*"(77%=*!+."*9%":(7*"*9(*"($*9,5.9"),*9"/%A%/*%6/"7,+7%+*6(*%",+"*9%"(+($&/!/",: "%J!/*!+.")5!$-!+."*&=,$,R.!%/":,5+-"!+"*9%"56)(+"/%**!+."*9%&",:*%+"-,"/,"'!*9,5*"("76,//",<%6"!+*,"("7,AA,+"*9%,6%*!7($"$(+-/7(=%"(+-"G"'!$$"9(<%"*,"7,AA5+!7(*%"A&"6%/=,+/%")&"/%=(6(*!+."*9%/%"7(/%/3

>.0.1%.57A*.8+65%Q95/7V+61"*#

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`%++%*9"06(A=*,+]/"%//(&"\B,'(6-/"(" L6!*!7($" a%.!,+($!/A]" G" )%7(A%" !+*%6%/*%-" !+" *9%" %:R:%7*/" ,: " .$,)($!1(*!,+" ,+" *9%" 9,A,.%+!1(*!,+" ,: " 6%R.!,+($"(679!*%7*56($"(%/*9%*!7/"(+-" *%79+,$,.!%/"9(<!+."

%J=%6!%+7%-"/,A%",: "*9%"/(A%"7,+7%=*/"A%+*!,+%-"!+"R

*%6%-"-,'+" !+*,"7,+/%6<(*!,+"(+-" !*"'(/" *9!/" 6%.!,+($":,75/",: "*9%"5+!*"(+-"!*]/"(==6,(79"*9(*"-6%'"A&"(**%+R*!,+3"B9%"7,+7%=*"*9(*")5!$-!+./"(6%"A%6%$&":6%%/*(+-!+."=!%7%/",: "=,$!*!7($D"(%/*9%*!7($",6"75$*56($" !7,+/"/9,5$-")%"76!*!7($$&"79($$%+.%-3"B9!/"'(/"79($$%+.%-"!+"*9%"5+!*")&"(--6%//!+."(")6,(-"6(+.%",: "(679!*%7*56($"[5%/*!,+/"6%$(*%-" *," 56)(+" 7,+*%J*D" *9%" *(+.!)$%" (+-" !+*(+.!)$%"9%6!*(.%D" 75$*56($" (+-" /,7!($" 7(=!*($D" 6%.%+%6(*!,+D" +%'"*&=%/",: "=,=5$(*!,+/"b%J=(*6!(*%/")5&!+."9,5/%/"!+"0%1"(+-"*9%"79(+.!+."-%A,.6(=9!7",: "*9%"6%.!,+c3"?&"[5%/R*!,+!+."'9%*9%6"*9%"6,$%",: "*9%"7,56*&(6-"9,5/%"!+"*9%"56)(+"/%**!+."(+-"!*]/"7(*($&*!7"%::%7*/D"*9%"(679!*%7*56($"=6,)$%A(*![5%/",: "*9!/"*&=,$,.&"(6%"6(!/%-")%&,+-"*9%"A%6%" =6(7*!7%" ,: " (679!*%7*56%" (+-" (!A/" *," 7,A%" *," ("76!*!7($"5+-%6/*(+-!+.",: "*9%"6,$%",: "-%/!.+"(+-"/=(*!($"!+*%6<%+*!,+/"!+"7,+*%A=,6(6&"(+-"9!/*,6!7"7,+*%J*/3"

G+",6-%6" *," *%/*" *9%"6%/!$!%+7%",: " *9%" *&=,$,.&"G"A(-%"(+"%(6$&"/5..%/*!,+"*9(*"*9%"7,+7%=*"A!.9*"+,*"%+*!6%$&"!+<,$<%"("6%7,+/*657*%-"7,56*&(6-"9,5/%/D"+%!*9%6"("6%R!+*%6=6%*(*!,+" ,: " (" -'%$$!+." )5*" !+" 5/!+." *9%" %J!/*!+.":()6!7"d6%e!+/%6*"("75$*56($"95)")(7I"!+*,"*9%"A%-!+(3"G+"

',6I/" =6,-57%-" !+" *9%"A%-!+(" *," *9%" :,6%!.+" *,56!/*3"B9!/"=6,7%//",: " !+*%.6(*!+."A!J%-"=6,.6(A/"9(/")%%+"("7,AA,+":%(*56%",: "/,A%",: "*9%"A,6%"6%7%+*"56)(+"6%.%+%6(*!,+"!+!*!(*!<%/"!+"*9%"-%<%$,=%-"',6$-")5*"(/",: "&%*"!/"5+*6!%-"(+-"5+*%/*%-"!+"*9!/"/7%+(6!,3"

Page 17: Revaluating Typological Standards

U

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

V"1%+5"(9-79*/7B$.+5.%"(9-7@+1"%"+*7

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b*9%"Z,6*9"#:6!7(+"

(+-"49(-6(79"K,,-/"b'9,"$(*%6",+"',5$-")%7,A%"$%(-R!+."B%(A"PO"A%A)%6/c"!+"*9%"%J*%+/!,+",: ",+%",: "F7,R9(6-]/" =6,@%7*/" !+"L(/()$(+7(D"L(66!%6%/"L%+*6($%3" B9%"(+($&/!/",: "(**%A=*/"(*"(//!A!$(*!+."*9%"7,56*&(6-"9,5/%"!+*,"("/%*",: "A,-%6+"-%/!.+"/*6(*%.!%/"9(/"'!-%$&")%%+"6%.(6-%-"(/"(":(!$56%"'!*9!+"(679!*%7*56($"-!/7,56/%3"B9%":,75/"(*"*9!/"/*(.%",: "*9%"5+!*"6%/*%-",+"6%R-!/7,<%6!+."*9%"*6!%-"(+-"*%/*%-"*%79+![5%/",: "!+*%6<%+*!,+"7(66!%-",5*")&"(679!*%7*/"(*"*9!/"*!A%"75$A!+(*!+."!+"("6%=,6*",: "

=,6*:,$!,":,6"&,56"<!%'!+.3"B9%"',6I"7(66!%-",5*"9%6%"(7*%-"A%6%$&"(/"(+"!+*6,-57*!,+"*,"*9%"\=6,)$%A(*![5%/]"/," *9(*"'9%+"A(I!+."-%7!/!,+/" $(*%6",+" !+"-%<%$,=!+."("7,+7%=*"*9%/%",5*7,A%/"7,5$-"!+:,6A"/,A%"I!+-",: "7,+7%=*5($"=6,=,/($3" "#*"*9!/"%(6$&"/*(.%D"-%7!/!,+/",+"=6,.6(A"9(-"+,*")%%+"A(-%"(+-"*9%6%"'(/"+%<%6"(")%R$!%: "*9(*"9,5/!+."',5$-":,6A"*9%")(/!/",: "("=6,=,/($D"!+R/*%(-"*9%6%"'(/"(+"!+*%6%/*"!+"$!+I!+."(+&".!<%+"7,+7%=*"'!*9"*9%"'!-%6"A%-!+("(+-"*9%":6(.A%+*%-"7!*&",: "0%1"b("6%/5$*",: "*9%"06%+79"Q6,*%7*,6(*%"-%<!(*!+.":6,A"!*]/"/*(+-(6-")5$$-,1%6"(==6,(79"(+-"!+/*%(-"/!A=$&")5!$-R

!+."("\+%'"7!*&]"*',"A!$%/"*,'(6-/"*9%"'%/*c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

!A=(7*"7,+/%6<(*!,+]"'(/"A%+*!,+%-D"(/":(6"(/"7,+/%6R<(*!,+"!/"7,+7%6+%-D"*9!/"'(/"'9%+"*9%"A%-!(+"(+-"*9%"7!*&",: "0%1"(/"("'9,$%"/('"!*]/".6%(*%/*"%J=(+/!,+"'!*9"

R*!,+",: "<($5()$%",)@%7*/"*9(*"A(&"$!I%$&")%7,A%"%J*!+7*3"B,-(&D"!*".,%/")%&,+-"("A%6%"7%$%)6(*!,+",: "(+"9!/*,6!R7($"!7,+3"B9%"=6%//56%",: "95A(+"+%%-/",+"56)(+"9%6!*R(.%"/!*%/"9(/"'!-%+%-"*9%"/7,=%",: "7,+/%6<(*!,+"!+"*9(*"!*"+,'"$!%/"!+"*(+-%A"'!*9"/,7!($"(+-"%7,+,A!7"-%<%$,=RA%+*3"L,+/%6<(*!,+!/*/"7(A%"*,"6%($!1%"*9(*"*9%!6"*(/I",: "/765*!+!1!+." /*,+%/" (+-" 7$%(+!+." /56:(7%/" !/" +%.(*!<%$&"(::%7*%-")&"("-%(6*9",: ":5+-!+.3"B9%"=6%//!+."+%%-",: "*9%" =%,=$%"'9,/%" 9%6!*(.%" !/" (" $!<!+." (+-"+,*" (" /*(*!7"$%.(7&"!/"7,+/%[5%+*$&"-(/9%-3

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a!79(6-" 43" Y%<!+%" -%/76!)%/" (/" *9%" \+%/*%-" 6%($A/]" ,: "/,7!($"(+-"75$*56($"A(.+%*/"*9(*"A(I%"(+"9!/*,6!7"7!*&"("

<!/!,+" )%:,6%" !A=$%A%+*(*!,+" ,: " =9&/!7($" =6,@%7*/" !/"%A)(6I%-"5=,+3"C,'%<%6D"*9!/"<!/!,+"/9,5$-"+,*")%"(/R/5A%-"*,")%"("A%6%"=(6(795*%-"!-%(",6"7,A=$%J"%[5(R*!,+")5*"!+<,$<%"("6(*9%6"A,6%"9,$!/*!7"(==6,(79D"'9!79"

Page 18: Revaluating Typological Standards

V

Cultural Context I: Response to Unit Proposition - Semester One

7(+")%"*6(+/$(*%-"!+*,"(7*!,+"!+"*9%"7,+/%6<(*!,+"/*6(*R%.&3

B9%"=$(++!+."*9%,6!%/"*9(*":,6%7(/*"'9(*"("7!*&"/9,5$-"$,,I" $!I%" !+" *9%" +%J*" *'," ,6" *96%%" -%7(-%/" +," $,+.%6"/*(+-"*,-(&3"B9%6%:,6%D"!+/*%(-",: "/=%+-!+."A579"*!A%",+"=6%=(6!+." (" $,+.R*%6A"56)(+" /7%+(6!,D" (" $%//" *!A%R7,/*$&" ($*%6+(*!<%" !/" +,'" )%!+." -!/75//%-" )&" =$(++%6/3"B9!/"($*%6+(*!<%"!/"$%(6+!+.":6,A")%/*"=6(7*!7%"(+-"(<%6*R!+."*9%"6!/I/"(+-"%66,6/",)/%6<%-3"#/"%(79"56)(+"/!*%"9(/"!*/"=%75$!(6!*!%/"*9%"(66(&",: "*9%!6"<(/*"=6,)$%A/"/9,5$-"*9%6%:,6%")%"7,+/!-%6%-3

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

*9%"a5%"E5%6+!/"C;?"(7*!+."(/"("7(*($&/*":,6"*9!/"=6,R7%//3""L*M"5+*0.*%7@-9(.79*/7>(9-.

?&"5*!$!1!+."*9%"%J!/*!+."/*657*56%"(+-"/!A=$&"6%,6.(+R!1!+."*9%".6!-"*9%"/7($%"(+-"/=(7%",: "*9%"=6,=,/%-"!+R

E56%+!/D" +,6" %::%7*" *9%" 6,,: " $%<%$" ,: " *9%" )5!$-!+." !+"6%$(*!,+"*,"*9%"/566,5+-!+.")5!$-!+./3"B9%".6!-"'(/"76%R(*%-"5/!+."*9%"%J!/*!+."7,56*&(6-/"(/"$!+%(6".5!-%/D"-!/R/%7*!+."*9%":,56"@5J*(=,/%-"7,56*&(6-"/=(7%/"(+-"76%(*R!+." !+*%6%/*!+."=,!+*/",: " !+*%6(7*!,+"'9%6%"*9%/%".6!-/"A%%*D"*9!/"!/"'9%6%"(6*!/*!7"$!7%+/%"9(/"*(I%+"=6%7%-%+*"!+"*9%"=6,=,/%-"/79%A%"&%*"-,%/"+,*"-%*6(7*":6,A"*9%",6!.!+($":%%$",: "*9%")5!$-!+./3"B9%"5/%6/",: "*9%")5!$-!+."

'!$$" )%"=6!+7!=($$&" *,56!/*/"'9!$/*" ($/," %+7,56(.!+." $,R7($"!+<,$<%A%+*"!+"*9%"/=(7%"!/"%//%+*!($"*9%"7%+*%6"'!$$")%"A(!+*(!+%-")&" /*(:: " (+-" 7$!A(*!7($$&" 7,+*6,$$%-"5/R!+."%J!/*!+."*%79+![5%/",: "7,,$!+.3"2(-%"%(/!%6")&"*9%"A(!+*(!+%-"7,56*&(6-"<,!-/" *9(*" (7*" (/"+(*56($" 7,,$%6/",: "*9%"/=(7%3"

B+:7!"#$%&"0%/D"2%-!+(D"%J=(+/!,+"=6,.6%//!,+3"4,567%"8"#5*9,6/"S'+

!"#$%&"0%1D"2%-!+("?$5%"E(*%D"PVNO4,567%"8";ZF4LS

Page 19: Revaluating Typological Standards

PO

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

Page 20: Revaluating Typological Standards

PP

Cultural Context I: Response to Unit Proposition - Semester Two

>.0.1%.57B,+V+61"*#7%$.7N911.1

B9%"5+!*" :,75/%-",+"7,$$%7*!<%"9,5/!+." !+" *9%" /%7,+-"/%A%/*%6D"7,A=,/%-",: "!+-!<!-5($"7%$$/"/!**!+."(A,+./*"("$(6.%6"=(*79',6I",: ",*9%6"!+*%6$,7I!+."7%$$5$(6"5+!*/3"B9%"=6,7%//",: "6%=%*!*!,+"'(/"%+7,56(.%-"(*"*9!/"/*(.%D"

#f?" /!*D" A!66,6%-" !+" (" 9,6!1,+*($" =,/!*!,+" 65++!+."(76,//" *9%"/!*%D"7,5+*%6!+." *9%"A(!+"(J!($"=(*9" $%(-!+.":6,A"*9%"6,(-"*,"*9%"7(+($"%-.%3"B9%"*5*,6/"/%*",5*"*9%"=6,7%//",: "',6I!+."'!*9!+" *9%"5+!*"(+-"($$,'%-"5/" *,":,$$,'",56",'+"(!A/"(+-"*9%,6%*!7($"(==6,(79%/3"?%6$!+D"(" L!*&" =,//%//!+." A(+&" %J(A=$%/" ,: " 9,5/!+." %J=%6!RA%+*(*!,+" (7*%-" (/" (")(7I-6,=",: "A579",: " *9%"',6I"=6,-57%-"'!*9!+"*9%"5+!*"(+-"5$*!A(*%$&"9(-"("=6,:,5+-"%::%7*"5=,+"A&",'+"/79%A%3

K!*9!+"*9%";+!*%-"`!+.-,A"*,-(&"*9%"*%+/!,+/"(6!/!+."

6(=!-$&" %J=(+-!+." 7!*!%/" !/" !+76%(/!+.3"C,5/!+." !/" ,+$&"=(6*",: "(" $(6.%6"=!7*56%",: "56)(+"/=6('$3"B9%"69%*,6!7"

56)(+"7%+*%6/"*,"($$%<!(*%"*9%"=6,)$%A/":(7%-")&"-%<%$R

/!*%/"9(<%"+,'")%%+"7$%(6%-"(+-"5+-%6"*9%" $(/*" $(),56"

7%+*%6/" !+*%+/!:&!+." (+-" *9%"A!--$%/" 7$(//%/" 6%*56+!+."*," *9%" 7!*&" 7%+*%6/3" B9%" =6,7%//" 9,'%<%6" 6%$!%-" 5=,+"

B9!/"7,56/%"6%/5$*%-"!+"7,+*%J*5($"/79%A%/")5*" $(7I%-"

!+"9!/";6)(+"B(/I"0,67%"6%=,6*"!/"*,")%7,A%"("+%7%//!*&"!+"*9%":5*56%D"%::%7*!<%"5/%",: "$(+-"!/"<!*($$&"!A=,6*(+*3"

*,"56)(+"6%R5/%"5/5($$&"*(I%/"=$(7%")&"*9%"/%=(6(*%"/5)-!R<!/!,+",: "*9%"/%=(6(*%"$(+-9,$-!+./"(+-"!/"/5)@%7*"*,"*9%"=6,)$%A/",: "/7(**%6%-"$(+-"(+-")5!$-!+."-%<%$,=A%+*D"

Y(),56"E,<e"!+"*9%"=6,<!/!,+",: "=5)$!7"5*!$!*&"(+-"6,(-"',6I/D" $(+-" /9,6*(.%/D" %J7%//!<%" $(+-" /=%75$(*!,+" (+-"

R*!,+"/,A%"A(&"/(&":(!$%-"!+"*9%"A%*9,-,$,.!%/"(-,=*%-"!+"*9%":,6A",: "9,5/!+.3"?&"!+76%(/!+.")5!$-!+."9%!.9*D"56)(+"-'%$$%6/"7,5$-")%"9,5/%-"!+".6%(*%6"+5A)%6/",+"/A($$%6"=$,*/",: "$(+-3"C,'%<%6"A(+&",: "*9%/%"=6,@%7*/D"\Q(6I" C!$$D" a,)!+" C,,-" E(6-%+/]" )%7(A%" (//,7!(*%-"'!*9"-(6ID"-(A="(+-"5+7,A:,6*()$%"7!675$(*!,+"/=(7%/"

(+-"5+6%($!1%-".6%%+"/=(7%"/566,5+-!+."*9%/%"/79%A%/3"G+"6%/=,+/%"*,"*9!/"*9%6%"9(/")%%+"$(6.%R/7($%"7,+-%AR+(*!,+",: "A(+&"9!.9R6!/%"9,5/!+."=6,@%7*/3"B9!/"$%(<%/"

!/"*9!/"'9!79"A&"=6,@%7*/"(!A/"*,"*(7I$%3

V"1%+5"(9-79*/7B$.+5.%"(9-7:+1"%"+*

B96,5.9"("=6,7%//",: "($A,/*"%J=%6!A%+*(*!,+"(+-"6%R

+,*"("\,+%",:: ]"-%/!.+"-%7!/!,+"(+-"A(+&",: "*9%"%(6$&"%JR=%6!A%+*/D"($,+."'!*9"!+:,6A%-"6%(-!+./"/579"(/"2(*9!R(/"C%&-%+]/" \F<,$<!+."Q(6*!7!=(*,6&"H%/!.+8"#"a%=,6*":6,A"?%6$!+D"a%(79!+."?%&,+-]"(+-"0$,6!(+";6)(+/"(6*!R7$%"!+"*9%"W,56+($",: "*9%"4,7!%*&",: "#679!*%7*56($"C!/*,R6!(+/"%+*!*$%-"\a%7,<%6!+."F//%+7%"*96,5.9"H%A,$!*!,+]"

R(/"7,5$-")%"*%/*%-")(/%-"5=,+"(//5A=*!,+/"(+-",)/%6R<(*!,+/"A(-%"!+"*9%"6%(-!+./"(+-"$%7*56%/".!<%+")&"),*9"G/()%$$%"H,57%*"(+-"E6!:: "F<(+/3"2&",'+"=%6/,+($"!+R*%6=6%*(*!,+/",: "\A(//"9,5/!+.]"'%6%"($/,"(--%-"*,"*9%"A!J3"#"=9!$,/,=9&"G"9(-"-%<%$,=%-"!+"=6(7*!7%3"G"9(<%",)/%6<%-D",+"7,5+*$%//",77(/!,+/"*9%"=6,)$%A/":(7%-")&"-%/!.+%6/"'9%+"(/I%-"*,"76%(*%"-!/*!+7*!<%D"A(//"9,5/R!+." *&=,$,.!%/" *," 9,5/%" *9%"A!--$%" (+-" $,'%6" 7$(//%/3"a%R76%(*!+." 7,AA5+!*!%/" 9(/" ,:*%+" )%%+" +%.$%7*%-" !+"6%7%+*"=6!<(*%"(+-"=5)$!7"=6,@%7*/"!+"*9%"=56/5!*",: "=6,:R!*D"7,/*"(+-"/=%%-",: "7,+/*657*!,+3"B9!/"!/"'9%6%"G":%%$"(679!*%7*/"9(<%"!+"*9%"=(/*"(+-"/9,5$-",+7%"(.(!+"=6,R<!-%"("<!*($"6,$%3"S::%6!+."*9%A/%$<%/"(/",6(7$%/",: "*6!%-"(+-"*%/*%-"7,+7%=*/"(+-"*(I!+.":6,A"*9%/%"!+/=!6(*!,+D"'9!$/*"=6,A,*!+."*9%"=6,7%//%/"*9(*"7(+"',6I"!+"(".!<%+"7,AA5+!*&",6"7,+*%J*3"

L*M"5+*0.*%7@-9(.79*/7>(9-.

06,A" PV_O" 5+*!$" *9%" 6!/%" ,: " =,/*" A,-%6+!/A" !+" *9%"PVUO]/D" ,6!%+*(*!,+"'(/"'!-%$&" 6%.(6-%-" (/" (" =6!+7!=($"-%*%6A!+(+*"!+"*9%":,6A"(+-"$(&,5*",: "9,5/!+."'!*9!+"*9%";+!*%-"`!+.-,A3"B9%"\6!.9*"*,"/5+$!.9*]")%7(A%"(+"!A=,6*(+*" :(7*,6" !+" =%,=$%]/" $!<%/3" B9!/" )%7(A%" %/=%R7!($$&" *65%" !+" *9%" $,'%6" /,7!($" 7$(//%/D" 5+()$%" *," *6(<%$"()6,(-3"B9%" 6%/5$*"'(/" 7,66%7*$&",6!%+*(*%-"=$(+/" *9(*"*,,I"(-<(+*(.%",: "/,$(6".(!+/3"

K!*9"*9%"%A=9(/!/",+"9!.9"56)(+"-%+/!*&"*9%/%"=6!+7!R=$%/D"'9!79"9(-"!+"(+&"7(/%")%7,A%"/,A%'9(*"-!/76%-R!*%-" (/" (" 6%/5$*" ,: " *9%" 5+/(*!/:(7*,6&"=6!,6!*&" .!<%+" *,",6!%+*(*!,+"6(*9%6"*9(+"/*6%%*"(+-"=$(7%"A(I!+.D"/%%A"*,"9(<%")%%+",<%6$,,I%-3"0$(*/"!+"9!.9R-%+/!*&D"/%A!R56)(+"-%<%$,=A%+*/" $!I%"Z%'" G/$!+.*,+" 9(<%" +,*" ,+$&" 9(<%"*9%!6"=6!+7!=($"$!<!+."6,,A/":(7!+."F(/*",6"%<%+"Z,6*9D"

!"#$%&74!%A%+//*(-*D"?%6$!+D"9,5/!+."-%<%$,=A%+*3"4,567%8"Q(5$3K3W,9+"

Page 21: Revaluating Typological Standards

PN

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

Page 22: Revaluating Typological Standards

Cultural Context I: Response to Unit Proposition - Semester Two

)5*")&"=$(++!+." *9%A",+"%!*9%6" /!-%",: "("7%+*6($" 7,6R6!-,6D" *9%&",+$&"9(-"("/!+.$%"(/=%7*D"A(I!+."*9,/%"+,*".%**!+."-!6%7*"/5+$!.9*"-(6I"(+-".$,,A&D"(+-"*9,/%"'!*9",<%6"=6%/76!)%-"(77%//"*,"/5+$!.9*"(*"6!/I",: ",<%69%(*R

6%.(6-%-"(/"("+%7%//!*&D".,,-"-%/!.+"A5/*"6%-!/7,<%6"*9%"R

$&1!+."*9%"/I&"<!%'":(7*,6/",: "7,AA,+$&":,5+-"56)(+"9,5/!+."*&=,$,.!%/"("/%$%7*!,+"7(+")%"A(-%",+"*9%"*&=%"A,/*" /5!*%-" :,6" 9!.9" -%+/!*&" $!<!+." *9(*" ($/," !+7,6=,R6(*%/"*9%"5/%6/"+%%-/":,6":(A!$!(6!*&3"G+",6-%6"*,"(79!%<%"-%+/!*&"'9!$/*"/*!$$"()!-!+."*,"*9%"$('/",: "/,$(6",6!%+*(R*!,+D"G"-%/!.+%-"("9&)6!-"*&=,$,.&"*9(*"!+7,6=,6(*%/"*9%"(-<(+*(.%/",: "*9%"%J!/*!+."-%/!.+"A%*9,-,$,.!%/",: "($$"

9,5/%D"*9%"A,-%6+!/*"/$()D"*9%"=,!+*")$,7ID"*9%"=%6!AR%*%6")$,7I"(+-"*9%"/I&/76(=%6"6%/5$*!+."!+"*9%"\G/$!+.*,+"?$,7I]3"#"*&=,$,.&"A!J!+."4g0"b4I&"g!%'"0(7*,6/c"(+-"("7,A:,6*()$%"-%.6%%",: "56)(+!*&" !+" *9%" :,6A",: "-!/R/%7*!+."/*6%%*/D"6%*(!$"5+!*/"(+-"("*6%%"$!+%-"(J!($"6,5*%3

G+"*9!/"\:(I%]"56)(+"/%**!+."("/%+/%",: "=$(7%"%J!/*/"'9%+"6%/!-%+*/"9(<%"("=%6A(+%+*"('(6%+%//",: ")%$,+.!+."*,"

+%!.9),69,,-",6"%<%+"'!*9"("7,A=,+%+*",: "("+%!.9),6R9,,-"*9(*"',6I/D"(+-"A,/*"!A=,6*(+*$&D"!/"%/*%%A%-")&"6%/!-%+*/3"G: "'%"(77%=*"*9(*"("/%+/%",: "=$(7%"9(/"!A=,6R*(+7%D",)<!,5/"[5%/*!,+/"(6%8"9,'"$(6.%"-,%/"("/79%A%"9(<%"*,")%")%:,6%"!*"7(+"%+:,67%"("\/%+/%",: "=$(7%]D"(+-"!*"

,: "*9%"/79%A%3

B9%"(+/'%6"A(&"($/,"$!%"!+"("=%67%!<%-"\$,+.%<!*&]",: "("

/9%$: "$!:%",: "_O"&%(6/"(+-"6%:56)!/9%-"9,5/!+."("$!:%",: "

$,7($R(5*9,6!*&" )5!$-!+." /=6%%" ,: " *9%" %(6$&" =,/*R'(6"&%(6/D" A(+&" /,7!($R9,5/!+." =6,.6(A/" /'!*79%-" :6,A"+%'R)5!$-" *," 6%:56)!/9!+."+!+%*%%+*9R7%+*56&" *%66(7%/3"

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

#79!%<!+."("\/%+/%",: "=$(7%]"!/"76%(*%-")&"5/!+."A(*%6!($/"(+-"(679!*%7*56($"A%*9,-,$,.!%/"*9(*"6%A(!+"7,+*%J*5($"&%*"7,+*%A=,6(6&3"`%&":(7*,6/"!+"76%(*!+."("/79%A%"*9(*":%%$/"6,,*%-"(+-"!/"+,'"7,+/!-%6%-"*,"&!%$-"/577%//:5$"7,AA5+!*!%/"),*9"!+"*9%";+!*%-"`!+.-,A"(+-"()6,(-3"

4*7>60095Q

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

!"#$%78.*%5.&7B9%"!-%(",: "$,+.%<!*&"7(+")%"%+7(=/5$(*%-"5/!+."(679!R*%7*56($"%$%A%+*/")5*"("\9!/*,6&]"!/"($'(&/"9(6-"*,"(79!%<%"4,567%8"

(5*9,6/",'+3

Page 23: Revaluating Typological Standards

P^

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

Page 24: Revaluating Typological Standards

PX

Cultural Context II: Personal Proposition - Semester One

#7:275;:+#0123<2+%%=+

?35401;:?50>0492901

>.0.1%.57A*.8+65%Q95/7V+61"*#

85"%"(9-7W6/#0.*%1

B9%" -%/!.+" =6,7%//" :,$$,'%-" (+" %J*%+/!<%" 6%/%(679"=9(/%/" !+*," *6(-!*!,+($" 7,56*&(6-" 9,5/!+.D" /%A!R7,+R*%A=,6(6&" /*&$%/D" %3.3" *9%" ',6I" ,: " C(//(+" 0(*9&" (+-"A,<!+." !+*," *9%"A,6%"A,-%6+!/*"=6,=,/($/",: "#B#?"#:6![5%3" G+" *%6A/" ,: " (" -%/!.+" =6,7%//"'%"'%6%" .!<%+"(" $,,/%" =6,7%//" (+-" *9!/" ($$,'%-"A%" *," %/*()$!/9" A&",'+"',6I!+."A%*9,-/3"G"76%(*%-"("A!J",: "A,-%$/"(+-"=6,-57%-"("+5A)%6",: "!+!*!($"-6('!+./"*,"%+()$%"*,"A%"

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h(-%"(+-")&"(-9%6!+."*,";ZF4LS"7,+/%6<(*!,+"/*(+-(6-/"G"!+R*%+-%-" *,"A(!+*(!+" *9%" /7($%" (+-" :%%$" ,: " *9%" %J!/*!+."'($$/")&"/!A=$&"!+*%6%/*!+."*',"+%'"%+*6(+7%/D",+%"A,6%"=6,+,5+7%-"*9(+"*9%",*9%63"B9!/"*,,I"!+/=!6(*!,+":6,A"

/,A%",: "*9%"6%$!.!,5/"/79,,$/":,5+-"!+"*9%"A%-!+("(+-"',5$-"(7*"(/"("/!.+($"*,"=(//%6/")&",: "*9%"$,7(*!,+",: "*9%"%+*6(+7%"(/"*9!/"7,5$-"9(<%")%%+"5+9%%-%-"!+"(+"(6%(",: "*9!/"/=(*!($"7,A=$%J!*&3

8+*%.0:+595Q78+*%.=%

a%/*,6!+."*9%"<!6*5%/",: "(+"(6%("$!I%"*9%"A%-!+("!+"0%/"

!/"/%%+"(/"("/!+.5$(6"%+*!*&D"7,+/%6<(*!,+",: "(+&")5!$-R!+."A5/*"=6,<!-%" ("5*!$!*&" :,6" *9%" 7,AA5+!*&" (+-" *9%"

/=(7%3"B9%"A%-!+("A5/*"+,*")%"/%%+"(/"("+,/*($.!7"%+<!R6,+A%+*"(+-"G")%$!%<%"A&"/79%A%D"'!*9"!*]/"A!J*56%",: "

$!*%6($$&"7,+/%6<(*!,+"(+-"/,7!($"(+-"(679!*%7*56($"7,+R/%6<(*!,+3"B9%"A%-!+(D" (/" (+"%+*!*&"9(/"79(+.%-",+"("+5A)%6",: ",77(/!,+/"(+-"!*"!/"*96,5.9"%<,$5*!,+"*9(*"!*"'!$$"/56<!<%3"L,+/%6<(*!,+!/*/")%$!%<%"*9(*"*9!/"A(&"/=%$$"*9%"%+-":,6"/577%//:5$"6%/*,6(*!,+/D"5*!$!1!+.",6!.!+($"%$%RA%+*/3"?5*"!+"(+"(6%("(/"=(*79"',6I%-"(/"*9!/"+,*9!+."

R

A&"/79%A%"(79!%<%/"*9!/3"?&"5*!$!1!+."A,-%6+")5!$-!+."*%79+![5%/"(+-"%$%A%+*/"'9!$%"/*!$$"6%/*,6!+."*9%"%J!/*!+."/*657*56%"(+-"/9,'!+."!*"!+"!*/":5$$"$!.9*"*9!/"=6,7%//"'!$$"

(),5*" *9%" +(*56%" ,: " A,-%6+" 7,+/%6<(*!,+" !+" =6,*%7*";ZF4LS"C%6!*(.%"/!*%/"/579"(/"*9!/3

!"#$%78.*%5.&7B9%"%+*6(+7%"*,"*9%"a5%"E5%6+!/"L5$*56($"L6(:*/"L%+*6%"

4,567%8"(5*9,6/",'+3

Page 25: Revaluating Typological Standards

P_

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

Page 26: Revaluating Typological Standards

Cultural Context II: Personal Proposition - Semester Two

>.0.1%.57B,+V+61"*#7%$.7N911.1

85"%"(9-7W6/#0.*%1

G+"*%6A/",: "I%&"A,A%+*/",6"=9(/%/"!+"*9%"-%/!.+"=6,R7%//"*9%/%"%J!/*%-"!+"*9%":6,A",: "*96%%"-!/*!+7*"(+-"!+R*%+/%"6%/%(679"%J%67!/%"=9(/%/"7,A)!+%-"'!*9"("/%*",: "6%(-!+./3" F(79" =9(/%/" $(/*!+." ,+%" '%%I" *9!/" .(<%" *9%"5+!*"(-%[5(*%"*!A%"*,"*%/*"(+-"!A=6,<%"5=,+"*9%"',6I"7(66!%-" ,5*" !+" *9%" (:*%6+,,+" ',6I/9,=/3" B9%" =9(/%/"

R*65&"2!%*/I(/%6+%D" *9%"G+*%6R'(6"4!%-$5+.%+"(+-"Q,/*R'(6"B6()(+*%+/*(%-*%3"G+"*9%/%"6%/%(679"=9(/%/"'%"'%6%"

*&=,$,.&D"*%/*!+."!*"!+"(+",6!.!+($"-%/!.+",6"(--!+."!*"*,"(+"($6%(-&".6,'!+."(66(&",: "!-%(/"(+-"7,+7%=*/"=6%/%+*R%-"(+-"',6I%-"5=,+" !+" *9%"(:*%6+,,+"',6I/9,=3"B9%"#+7,(*/"(6%(D"(+-"(/"!*"!/"+,'"I+,'+"*9%"Z%'"G/$!+.*,+"(6%("9(/"("9!/*,6&",: "*%+%A%+*")5!$-!+."/!A!$(6"*,"*9(*":,5+-"!+"*9%"?%6$!+"2!%*/I(/%6+%D"'!*9"("/9(6%-"7,56*R&(6-i=5)$!7"6%($A"/!**!+."(*"*9%"A!--$%",: "*9%"7,A=$%J3"G" :,5+-" *9!/" :(/7!+(*!+." (+-" =56/%-" *9!/" (==6,(79" !+"A(+&",: "*9%"%(6$&"A,-%$/"G"=6,-57%-3"B6&!+."*,"(79!%<%"

-%+/!*&" *,"("-%.6%%"'9%6%"/%+/%",: "=$(7%"'(/"+,*"5+R-%6A!+%-3"#/"A(+&",: " *9%/%" \2(+79%/*%6"B%+%A%+*/]"9(<%")%%+"-%A,$!/9%-"(+-"*9%"?%6$!+"*&=,$,.&"$!A!*!+."-5%"*,"!*]/"=6(7*!7($"-%/!.+"G"-%7!-%-"*,"!+7,6=,6(*%"%$%RA%+*/" ,: "A,6%"A,-%6+!/*" .6!-" (+-" 7%$$5$(6" =$(++!+.D"

R*56%/" !A=$%A%+*%-")&"B%(A"POD"/579"(/" \a,)!+"C,,-"E(6-%+/]"-%/!.+%-")&"#$!/,+"(+-"Q%*%6"4A!*9/,+3"B9%"A,-%$"A(I!+." =6,7%//" ,: "A&" -%/!.+" /*6(*%.&" :,6A%-"(+" !+*6!+/!7" %$%A%+*" !+" ($$,'!+."A%" *," ,<%67,A%" *9%",)/*(7$%" ,: " 76%(*!+." (" [5(/!" $!I%" /%$:R!A=,/%-" \56)(+R!*&]"*9(*":%$*".6,5+-%-"!+"*9%"/566,5+-!+."(6%(3"a%$&!+."5=,+"A(*%6!($!*&"!/"+,*"/!A=$&"*9%",+$&"'(&"!+"'9!79"*,"(79!%<%"/%+/%",: "=$(7%"(+-"*9%"A(/*%6=$(++!+.",: " *9%"/!*%" :,6A%-" *9%"=6!+7!=($" :,75/"=,!+*",: "A579",: "A&"',6I3"E%**!+."*9!/"6!.9*"'(/"*9%"A(!+":,75/"(+-"5=,+"

/7($%/"(+-"7,A=$%J!*&"'%6%"=6,-57%-"*,"*6&"(+-"*%/*"*9%"7,+7%=*/"=6%/%+*%-"*,"A%"!+"*9%"A,6+!+."$%7*56%/3"G"(6R6!<%-"%<%+*5($$&"(*"*9%"9&)6!-"\Z%'"G/$!+.*,+]")$,7I"<!("("/%6!%/",: "A,-%$/"(+-"-!/75//!,+/"'!*9"A&"*5*,6D"*9!/"=6,7%//"'(/"6%7,6-%-"!+"*9%":,6A",: "(+"\(7*!<%"(679!<R

,+"*9%"',6I"=6,-57%-3"B9!/"=6,7%//",: "',6I!+."!/"+,*"7,AA,+" !+" *9%" /79,,$" &%*" !*" ($$,'%-"A%" *,"(79!%<%"("9!.9" $%<%$",: "/,=9!/*!7(*!,+" !+"A&"-%/!.+",<%6"("/9,6*"=%6!,-",: "*!A%3"

8+*%.0:+595Q78+*%.=%

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

/=(7%/D" b76%(*%-")&" $,7(*!+."=(6I!+."(*")(/%A%+*" $%<%$c"%+7,56(.%/" 7,AA5+!*&" !+*%6(7*!,+" *9,5.9" %<%+*/" (+-"79!$-"=$(&3" G: " *9%6%"'(/",+%"76!*!7!/A",: "A(+&",: " *9%"A,-%6+!/*"9,5/!+."=6,@%7*/"!*"'(/"*9(*"=5)$!7"/=(7%"'(/"

=6,@%7*"=5)$!7"/=(7%"=$(&%-"("I%&"6,$%":6,A"*9%",5*/%*"(+-"'(/"A(6I%-",5*"!+"*9%"A,-%$"A(I!+."=6,7%//3"K!*9R!+"*9%"-!/7!=$!+%"!*/%$: "*9%"=6,@%7*",::%6/"($*%6+(*!<%/"*,"9!.9R6!/%" (+-" $,'R6!/%" /,7!($" 9,5/!+." /5..%/*!+." *9(*"9!.9"-%+/!*&"-,%/"+,*"($'(&/"A%(+"$(7I",: "7,AA5+!*&D"(" 76!*!7!/A",: "A(+&",: " *9%"A,-%6+!/*"9,5/!+.")$,7I/"*9(*"'%"/('"-%A,$!/9%-"!+"*9%"PVVO]/3

!"#$%&7g!%'"*96,5.9"(=(6*A%+*D"\C,5/!+."*9%"2(//%/]"/%A%/*%6"*',"

=6,@%7*3"4,567%8"(5*9,6/",'+3

Page 27: Revaluating Typological Standards

PU

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

Page 28: Revaluating Typological Standards

PV

Design and Communication: Outline of 5th Year Studio Work - Semester One

@349A1+B+#0CC7198;2901=+

D72:913+0E+/3;5+F+*27690+G05H

>.0.1%.57A*.8+65%Q95/7V+61"*#

B9%":,$$,'!+."79(=*%6" !/",6.(+!1%-" !+"/579"("'(&"*9(*"%(79" /*5-!," )6!%: " !/" =6%/%+*%-" (+-" *9%+" (" /5AA(6&"5+-%6" *9%"9%(-!+./" 6%[5!6%-" !+" (77,6-(+7%"'!*9"#a?"$%(6+!+." L6!*%6!(3" B9%/%" /5AA(6!%/" '!$$" )%" )6!%: " )5*"9!.9$!.9*"*9%"<($!-"7,+*6!)5*!,+/"(+-"6%/=,+/%"A(-%"*,R'(6-/"*9%"/%*")6!%:/3

)@%4(2)66'-*&#3%&</66%/664('&-=',(4%#)66'&)%#-&/666%#666+-#$666+*(,<=(2.666%2<666*&+%2666/'%,)/666%2<666#$)(&6660-#)2#(%,666&-,)666%/666*&+%2666'%#%,3/#666?-&666F'-666'(#()/"65$)666'-2')0#/666-? 666*&+%2666'%#%,3/#/666%2<666F'-'(#()/666!(,,666+)666)@0,-&)<666+)?-&)666&)B()!(2.666#$)666,(#)&%#*&)666%&-*2<666'-*&#3%&<66$-*/(2.66%/66%66B)&2%'*,%&66?-&4>66%<-0#)<66%2<66%<%0#)<66(266B%&(-*/66',(4%#('>66/-'(%,66%2<66'*,#*&%,666'-2#)@#/"666V)!666?-&4/666-? 666'-*&#3%&<666$-*/(2.666%&)666)4)&.(2.666(2666#$)6669W666/*'$666%/666#$)666XNS8666%!%&<666!(22(2.6668''-&<(%66<)B),-04)2#66(266:%4+&(<.)66+366G)(,<)266:,)..66S&%<,)3668&'$(=#)'#/66%2<66Y-223+&--166A*%&#)&66+3666Z)#)&66S%&+)&"665$)/)66%2<66-#$)&66$-*/(2.660&-C)'#/66!(,,66+)66*/)<66#-66<(/'*//66,-!66&(/)66$(.$66<)2/(#366$-*/(2.666(266#$)669W66%2<66#$)66%<-0#(-266-? 662)!664-<),/"66

O#*<)2#/666!(,,666!-&1666(26660%(&/666#-666<)B),-0666%2666*2<)&/#%2<=(2.666-? 666#$)666%&'$(#)'#*&%,666%2<666)2B(&-24)2#%,666A*%,(#()/6-? 6+-#$6B)&2%'*,%&6%2<66'-2#)40-&%&366'-*&#3%&<66$-*/(2.66#$&-*.$66

/#*<3666(2666#$)6664)<(2%666-? 666I%&&%1)'$666!(,,666+)666-&.%2(/)<666/-666#$%#666/#*<)2#/666%'A*(&)666%2666)@0)&()2#(%,666*2<)&/#%2<=(2.666-? 666#$)666I-&-''%2666B)&2%'*,%&666'-*&#3%&<666$-*/)666%2<666-? 666*&+%2666/0%')/666(2666#$)666$(/#-&('666,-!666&(/)666$(.$666<)2/(#3666

'(#36665$)6660&-@(4(#3666-? 666#$)666G&)2'$666:-,-2(%,666'(#3666!(,,666%,,-!666/#*<)2#/666#-666*2<)&/#%2<666#!-666B)&3666<(??)&)2#666*&+%26664-&0$-,-.()/666%2<666#$)(&666%//-'(%#)<666+*(,<(2.666#30-,-.()/666%2<666

%2<666#-666#$)666&%0(<,3666'$%2.(2.666/-'(%,>666'*,#*&%,666%2<666)'-2-4('666'-2<(#(-2/666+-#$666(2666I-&-''-666%2<666(2666#$)6669W"6665$)666/#*=

I%2'$)/#)&666%2<666(2666#$)666$(/#-&('666?%+&('666-? 666I%&&%1)'$666(2666-&<)&666#-666<)B),-066#$)66<)/(.266-? 66%66'-2#)40-&%&366',*/#)&66-? 66'-*&#3%&<66$-*/)/66%/66*&+%266'%#%,3/#/"66

2(.(-("4!)$%&"R"#(;L"4%A%/*%6"S+%"?6!%:

Y%//,+/"$%(6+*"!+"*9%"%(6$&"/*(.%/",: "*9%"6%/%(679"=6,R7%//"=6,<!-%-"A%"'!*9"*9%"*9%,6%*!7($".6,5+-!+.":6,A"'9!79"*,"7,+7%!<%"(+-"7,+/*657*"A%"-%/!.+3"S56"<!/!*"*,"0%/"=6,<!-%-"A%"'!*9"(+"!+/!.9*"!+*,"9,'"A(+&",: "*9%" 7,56*&(6-" 9,5/%/" +,'" /%6<%" (" -!::%6%+*" =56=,/%"(+-"*9%!6"(-(=*()!$!*&"!/"/,A%'9(*":(/7!+(*!+.3"B9%"/!AR=$!7!*&" ,: " *9%!6" $(&,5*" ($$,'/" :,6" (" <%6&" 9!.9" $%<%$" ,: "

!+"*9%"2%-!+("!+"0%/3"2&"6%/=,+/%"*,"*9%")6!%: "79(+.%-"/,A%'9(*" (/" *9%" /%A%/*%6" =6,.6%//%-" *96,5.9" .5!-R(+7%":6,A"A&"*5*,6/3"B9!/"'(/"-5%"*,"*!A%"7,+/*6(!+*/"

=6,7%//" ,: " -%/!.+!+." (" \7,56*&(6-" 9,5/%]" =%6" /%" '(/"()(+-,+%-" (+-" G"-%7!-%-" *,"=56/5%" (" 6%/*,6(*!,+" (+-"7,+/%6<(*!,+" 6,5*%" '9!$/*" 5*!$!1!+." A&" 5+-%6/*(+-!+.",: " *9%" 7,56*&(6-" 9,5/%" (/" (+" (-(=*()$%" %+*!*&]3" " B9%"I+,'$%-.%".(!+%-"*96,5.9"6%/%(679"'(/"+,*"'(/*%-"(+-"A&"=%6/,+($"6%/=,+/%"*,"*9%")6!%: "($*9,5.9"+,*"-!6%7*D"-!-"!+7,6=,6(*%"/,A%",: "*9%"I%&"=,!+*/"6(!/%-"!+"*%6A/"

06(7*($".6,'*9"=(*R*%6+"%J=%6!A%+*/3"4,567%8"(5*9,6/"

,'+3

Page 29: Revaluating Typological Standards

NO

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

5*!$!1!+."*9%"7,56*&(6-"/=(7%"(/"\A!76,7$!A(*!7"76%(*,6/]"(+-"A&"6%/=,+/%"*,"*9%"-%)(*%",: "*9%!6"6%$%<(+7%"*,"F7,"L!*!%/"!+"("=6,*%7*%-"56)(+"%+<!6,+A%+*3

E.1"#*7N.%$+/+-+#Q

2,-%$"A(I!+."=$(&%-"("$(6.%"6,$%"!+"5+-%6/*(+-!+."*9%"/566,5+-!+.":()6!7"(+-"/7($%-"A,-%$",: "*9%"=6,J!A!*&"A%-!+("'(/"=6,-57%-3"B9!/"%+()$%-"5/"*,"A%(/56%"*9%"!A=(7*"!+"(".6,5="*9(*",56"+%'"(--!*!,+/"',5$-"9(<%3"G"($/,"7,+-57*%-"("+5A)%6",: "7,A=5*%6"/76!=*!+."%J=%6!RA%+*/"!+",6-%6"*,".(5.%"*9%"%::%7*/"A&"(--!*!,+"',5$-"9(<%",+"*9%":5*56%".6,'*9",6"7,+*6(7*!,+",: "*9%"A%-!+(D"*9!/"'(/"7(66!%-",5*"5/!+."Q,/*"Q6,7%//!+."/,:*'(6%"(+-"-!/=$(&%-"*9%"7,+*6(7*!,+"(+-"%J=(+/!,+",: "*9%"A%-!+(",<%6"("/%*"=%6!,-3"#"'(J"A,-%$"'(/"($/,")5!$-"!+",6-%6"*,"($!.+"*9%"7,56*&(6-"/=(7%/",+"*9%"/!*%"*,"*9%"/=(7%/"79,/%+"(/" *9%"A(!+"(6%(/",: " :,75/D"%::%7*!<%$&"9%$=!+."A%"*,"(//%//",+7%"(.(!+"*9%"%::%7*",+"/=(7%D"9%!.9*"(+-"($!.+A%+*"A&" =6,=,/%-" 6%/*,6(*!,+"',5$-" 9(<%" 5=,+"*9%"/566,5+-!+."-'%$$!+./"(+-"',6I/9,=/3"

B9%"!+!*!($"7,+7%=*/"'%6%"*%/*%-D"(+-"6%*%/*%-"5/!+."=$(+",<%6$(&/"(+-"/A($$R/7($%"A,-%$/"!+",6-%6"*,"(/7%6*(!+"*9%"

,+"("=6,@%7*",: "*9!/"/7($%"(+-"<(6&!+."(.%/",: "*9%"(-@(R7%+*"-'%$$!+./"'9%6%"7,+/*657*!,+"*%79+![5%/"-!::%6"(/"'%$$"(/"$%<%$"79(+.%/3"B9%"=9&/!7($"A,-%$"=$(&%-"("=(6*"!+"9%$=!+."5/"*,"5+-%6/*(+-"*9%/%"79(+.%/"(+-"'(/"5/%-"%J*%+/!<%$&"*96,5.9,5*"*9%"-%/!.+"=6,7%//3"G+",6-%6"*,"=6%/%+*" *9%"A,/*" 7%+*6($" (/=%7*/" ,: "A&" -%/!.+" G" %AR)(6I%-"5=,+"=6,-57!+."("/%*",: "<!/5($/"*9(*"',5$-":5$R

!A=,6*(+*"6,$%"!+"=6%/%+*!+."A&"-%/!.+"A%*9,-,$,.&3"

8+*1%56(%"+*78+*%.=%

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

Page 30: Revaluating Typological Standards

NP

Design and Communication: Outline of 5th Year Studio Work - Semester Two

>.0.1%.57B,+V+61"*#7%$.7N911.1

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

/'%,)>6 #30)6 %2<6 /'-0)6 -? 6 #$)6 (2#)&B)2#(-2"6 )"."6 0*+,('6 $%,,!%3/>6

<).&))6-? 60*+,('2)//6-? 6/$%&)<6/0%')/6D'-&&(<-&/>6$%,,!%3/>62*4+)&6-? 6&--4/>6<--&/E>6(2#).&%#(-260*+,('6%2<60&(B%#)6/0%')/"6O#*<)2#/6%&)6)@0)'#)<6#-60&)/)2#6#$)(&6<)/(.26&)/)%&'$6#$&-*.$6#$&))6)@)&='(/)/>6-? 6!$('$60-//(+,36+*#62-#62)')//%&(,36-2)6!(,,6+)6!-&1)<6-*#6(2#-6.&)%#)&6<)#%(,"65$)6<)/(.2)&,36&)/)%&'$6NO6#$)60&-C)'#>6/-6!)6<-2;#6%(46#-6'-2/(<)&6#$)/)6#$&))6)@)&'(/)/6%/6%2%,3/(/6#-6!$('$6#$)26%6<)/(.26!(,,6?-,,-!"6N2/#)%<6#$)36!(,,6'&)%#)6%267%'#(B)6%&'$(B);6-&6&)%,=#(4)6 &)'-&<(2.6 -? 6 #$)(&6 ,)%&2(2."6Y)0)2<(2.6 -26 '$-/)26 &)=/)%&'$6<)/(.26?-'*/)/>6/#*<)2#/6%&)6)@0)'#)<6#-60&)/)2#6#$)(&6!-&16#$&-*.$6'-2')0#*%,6<&%!(2./>6<(%.&%4/>6#)@#/>6#$&-*.$6#30-,-.('%,6

=#(-26-? 6%2<64%/#)&(2.6-? 6&)0&)/)2#%#(-2%,6#--,/6%&)6'-2/(<)&)<6%/60%&#6-? 6#$)6<)/(.26&)/)%&'$6)@)&'(/)"

H63" G/()%$$%"H,57%*"T"E6!:: "F<(+/" R"#(;L"4%A%/*%6"B',"?6!%:

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

7,+7%=*3"G+",6-%6"*,"*%/*"*9%"7,+7%=*"(.(!+/*"*9%")6!%: "/%*",5*")&"*9%"*5*,6/"G"=6,-57%-"("+5A)%6",: "A,-%$/"*,"*%/*"*9%"!-%(",: "=5)$!7"/=(7%D"*9%/%"'%6%"=9,*,.6(=9%-"(+-"6%7,6-%-"(+-"=6,<!-%-"A%"'!*9"(".6,5+-%-D"*%/*%-"(+-" *9%,6%*!7($$&" )(/%-" =,/!*!,+" :6,A" '9!79" *," =6,R.6%//"A&"-%/!.+3"2&"=9!$,/,=9!7($"(==6,(79"'(/")(/%-"

(6,5+-" *9%" 7,+7%=*" (+-"'%$$" 6%/%(679%-"=,/!*!,+" *9(*"/,7!($"9,5/!+.",: "*9%" $(/*" *'%+*&"&%(6/"9(/"/*($$%-"-5%"*,"*9%":(!$56%/D"(+-"(-,=*!,+",: "*%79+![5%/"=6%/%+*%-"!+"*9%"PV_O]/3"B9%"<%6&")%/*"%J(A=$%/",: "=5)$!7"9,5/!+."(*"*9!/"*!A%"',6I%-"'%$$"(+-",:*%+"(79!%<%-"("A%(/56()$%"-%.6%%",: "!A=6,<%-"$!<!+.3"B9%/%"*%79+![5%/"'%6%"6%=R$!7(*%-"(+-"/,A%'9(*"-!$5*%-"!+":56*9%6"/79%A%/"(76,//"*9%";+!*%-"̀ !+.-,A3"B9%",5*7,A%",: "*9!/"'(/"/79%A%/"*9(*"$(7I%-"(+&"*9%,6%*!7($",6"(7(-%A!7".6,5+-!+.3"L,+R*%J*"'(/"!.+,6%-"(+-"'9(*":,$$,'%-"'(/"*9%"()(+-,+RA%+*",: "*9%/%"9!.9R-%+/!*&"9,5/!+."=6,@%7*/3"B9%"=,/!R*!,+" G" *,,I" :6,A"(+"%(6$&"=,!+*"'(/" *9%" 6%-%$!<%6&",: "*9%/%"/79%A%/")5*"'!*9"($*%6(*!,+/"A(-%"*,"%+:,67%"*9%"7,+*%A=,6(6&" !-%($",: " $!<!+."(+-"/5/*(!+()!$!*&3"C,5/R!+."!/"(*"("/9,6*(.%"!+"*9!/"7,5+*6&D"(+-"*,"(".6%(*%6"-%R.6%%" /,7!($" (+-"(::,6-()$%3" G: " *9!/" !/" *,")%" /,$<%-"(+-"*9%"*%79+![5%",: ")5!$-!+."(::,6-()$%"9,A%/")%7,A%"("

(6%(/" (+-" $!.9*!+."A5/*"+,*")%7,A%" *9%"+,6A3"B9%/%"=6,7%//%/"($,+."'!*9"*9%"(-,=*!,+",: "=5)$!7"/=(7%/"(/"("<!*($"-%/!.+"7,+/*6(!+*"($$,'%-"A%"*,"-%/!.+"("/79%A%"*9(*"(-9%6%/"*,"*9%/%"!+9%6%+*"=6!+7!=$%/3"

E.1"#*7N.%$+/+-+#Q

B9%"*%/*!+.",: "!-%(/"'(/"7(66!%-",5*"5/!+."("/%*",: "7,ARA5+!7(*!,+"A%-!5A/3"Q6%/%+*(*!,+",: "7,+7%=*/"*,"*9%"5+!*"(+-"A&"=%%6/"(7*%-"(/"(".,,-"'(&",: "*%/*!+."("+%'"!-%(" (/" '%$$" (/" ,::%6!+." 5=" +%'" ($*%6+(*!<%/3" Q9&/!7($"(6%(/" ,: " *9%"A,-%$/" =6,-57%-"'%6%" ($/,"A%(/56%-" !+"

/,:*'(6%RA%(/56!+." *%79+![5%/3"B9%" (-,=*!,+",: " (5.RA%+*%-"6%($!*&"!+"*9%"-%/!.+"=6,7%//"($/,"($$,'%-"A%"*,"*%/*"A&"7,+7%=*/"!+"6%($"*!A%D"(+-"($$,'%-":,6"(":(6"A,6%"

?&"-!(.6(AA!+."(+-"A(==!+."*9%"',6I!+."=6,7%//"G"(-R9%6%-"*,"*9%"=6!+7!=$%/"/%*",5*"!+"*9%"=6,@%7*")6!%:3"B9%"76%(*!,+",: "\!A(.%/]",6"\A,+*(.%/]"!+"=6%/%+*!+."(+"!-%("'(/"=(6(A,5+*"(+-" *9!/" :,6A%-" *9%")(/!/",: "A&" 6%=R6%/%+*(*!,+"=6,7%//3"B9%"\(7*!<%"(679!<!+.]"=6,7%//"'(/"6%7,6-%-"!+"*9%":,6A",: "("\',6I!+."*!A%"$!+%]"*9(*"'(/"

=6,7%//"($,+."*9%"*!A%$!+%",: "*9%"/%<%+"'%%I"',6I!+."=%6!,-3"

N9"*[email protected].*%9%"+*7N./"601

Q9,*,"A,+*(.!+.#5.A%+*%-"a%($!*&2,-%$"2(I!+.4I%*79!+.iQ$(+",<%6$(&"-!(.6(AA!+.

!"#$%7B+:&7;*!$!/!+."(5.A%+*%-"6%($!*&"<!/5($!/(*!,+"*%79+![5%/"*,"*%/*"-%/!.+3"

4,567%8"(5*9,6/",'+3

H%/!.+!+."'!*9"A,-%$/3"\C,5/!+."*9%"2(//%/]"/%A%/*%6"

*',3"4,567%8"(5*9,6/",'+3

Page 31: Revaluating Typological Standards

NN

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

Page 32: Revaluating Typological Standards

Dissertation

@944352;2901=+

!I425;82

B"%-.

L$,+%RL!*&"R"C(/"*9%"Z,*!,+",: "\Q$(7%]"?%%+";+-%6A!+%-")&"L566%+*"2,-%$/"!+"a%*(!$"Q$(++!+."(+-"H%/!.+j

'K1%59(%7

B9%"56)(+"$(+-/7(=%",: "4,5*9"K($%/]"*',"$(6.%/*"7!*!%/D"Z%'=,6*"(+-"L(6-!:: "9(/")%%+" !+"(" /*(*%",: "7,+/*(+*"*6(+/:,6A(*!,+"/!+7%"*9%"!+*%6R'(6"=%6!,-/D"(77%$%6(*%-"!+"*9%"PV_O]/"'!*9"*9%"7$%(6!+.",: "*9%"!+-5/*6!($"7%+*6%/",: "*9%/%"*',"7!*!%/"(+-"*9%"=6,.6%//!,+"*,"("/%6<!7%")(/%-"%7,+,A&3"B9%"5+/5!*()$%"-%<%$,=A%+*($"+(*56%",: "*9%"7%+*6($"(6%(/",: " *9%/%" \*,'+/]D"'9%6%" *9%"6%A+(+*/",: "

$(6.%"-%<%$,=%6/3"B9!/"=(<%-"*9%"'(&":,6"*9%"#A%6!7(+!R1(*!,+",: "*9%";`]/"6%*(!$"$(+-/7(=%"'9%6%"$(6.%",5*",: "*,'+"/9,==!+."\Z,+R=$(7%/]"(7*%-"(/"(")(7I-6,=":,6"*9%"

'(/"/,,+"(".,<%6+A%+*($"/9!:*"!+",=!+!,+"(+-"=,$!7&"(/"*,"*9%"/5!*()$%"+(*56%",: "/579"-%<%$,=A%+*/D"*9%"$(6.%"/7($%"()(+-,+A%+*",: "*,'+"7%+*6%/D"!+-%=%+-%+*"6%*(!$R%6/" 7($$!+.",5*" :,6" 9%$=" (+-" *9%"=,$!*!7($" %$!*%" %79,!+."*9%!6"76!%/3"#"=,$!7&"/9!:*"*,'(6-/"("/%6!%/",: "\a%*(!$R$%-]"56)(+" 6%.%+%6(*!,+" =6,@%7*/" /,,+" )%7(A%" *9%" +,6AD"A(/I!+." *9%A/%$<%/" (/" *9%" 756%" *," -%.%+%6(*!,+" (+-"!+<%/*A%+*3" #/" F56,=%(+" 7!*!%/" )%7(A%" A,6%" \A($$R

(+-"A%-!5A"/!1%-"6%*(!$/" /9!:*!+."5='(6-/" !+"/!1%D" *9%"7!*&"9(/"/9!:*%-",+7%"(.(!+"*,"("/9,==!+.RA($$"=(/*!79%3"B9!/"9(/".!<%+"6!/%"*,"*%6A/"/579"(/"\L$,+%"B,'+]/]"(+-"\L,=&7(*"H%<%$,=A%+*/]"'9%6%"*9%"<%6&"+(*56%",: "7,+R*%A=,6(6&"-%<%$,=A%+*/"9(/"($$,'%-":,6"("/7%+(6!,",: "

=6,<!/!,+" ,: " -!<%6/!*&D" (" :(7*,6" (7I+,'$%-.%-" (/" <!*($"*,"*9%"/577%//",: ",56"!++%6"7!*&"%+<!6,+A%+*/"6%A(!+/"

5+,)*(!+()$%bW(+%" W(7,)/"PV_Pc3"B9%"7,A=%*!*!,+" *9(*"'(/",+7%"'(.%-")%*'%%+"7!*&"(+-"/5)56)D"9(/"A!.6(*%-"

R=,6*"(+-"L(6-!:: ":(7%"(".6%(*%6"-(+.%6":6,A"(+"($$!(+7%",: "6%*(!$%6/"'!*9!+"*9%"7!*&D"*9(+":6,A"/9,==!+."7%+*6%"/5)56)/D")5*"*9%/%"*',"7!*!%/"9(<%")%%+"7,A=%*!+."'!*9"%(79" ,*9%6" (+-" *9%" 6%.!,+" (/" (" '9,$%3" Z%'=,6*" /5:R:%6!+."5+-%6"*9%"'%!.9*",: "!*]/")!..%6")6,*9%6D"L(6-!::3"#/"),*9"7!*!%/" %A)(6I"5=,+"=6,A,*!+." *9%A/%$<%/" (/".$,)($" =$(&%6/" (+-" 7,A=%*!+." (.(!+/*" *9%!6" F56,=%(+"7,5+*%6=(6*/"9(<%"*9%&")%7,A%"@5/*"(+,*9%6"A%*6,=,$!R*(+"<,!7%",: " \Q,/*RG+-5/*6!($"a%<!<($]"'9%6%"*9%" !+9%6R%+*"+(*56%",: "*9%!6"(-,=*%-".$,)($!/(*!,+"9(/"=,*%+*!($$&"

=,$!7&",: "\),,/*%6!/A]"(+-"Z%'=,6*"!/":,$$,'!+.")$!+-$&"

*9!/"7,+*%J*"*9%"+,*!,+",: "\=$(7%]"(+-"\!-%+!*&]"9(/"(6.5R()$&")%%+"$,/*"*,"\)6(+-95)/]"(+-"7,+/5A%6"$(+-/7(=%/3"

-,'+*56+",6"-,%/"*9%"=6,)$%A"$!%"!+"*9%"<%6&"+(*56%",: "*9%"A(79!(<%$$!(+":,6A",: "7(=!*($!/A"(+-"*9!/"/*(.%",: "\L$,+%"B,'+]".$,)($!/(*!,+"*9(*"4,5*9"K($%/"9(/"(-,=*R%-D"'9%6%"*9%"(".6(-5($"9,A,.%+!1(*!,+",: "(679!*%7*56%"!/" 6%.(6-%-" (/" (77%=*()$%j"K9," 76%(*%/" \=$(7%]" !+" ,56"7!*!%/"(+-"'9,"(6%"*9%"=(6*!%/"!+<,<$%-"!+"*9!/"=6,77%//j"?(7I.6,5+-"G+:,6A(*!,+L(6-!:: ]/"+,*()$%"/577%//",: "$(*%"A5/*")%"(**6!)5*%-"*,"("'!-%"6(+.%",: ":(7*,6/"9,'%<%6"!*"-,%/"9(<%"("7,6%"/%*",: "=,$!7!%/D" ,5*$!+%-")&" !*]/" -%<%$,=A%+*" (.%+7&D" (-,=*%-":6,A",*9%6";`"7!*!%/3"B9%/%"(6%" $(6.%$&"6%R6%=6%/%+*(R*!,+/" ,: " *6!%-" (+-" *%/*%-"A%*9,-/" (+-"9(<%" =6,<!-%-"L(6-!:: "'!*9"/,A%"/577%//3"C,'%<%6"*9%"%::%7*/",: "$(6.%"6%*(!$",+"!*]/"9!.9R/*6%%*"9(/"($6%(-&"76%(*%-"("/,A%'9(*"-!/@,!+*%-"7!*&"'9%6%"*9%",$-"/9,==!+."(6%(/"9(/")%.(+"*,"/9,'"/!.+/",: "-%.%+%6(*!,+3"B9!/"!/"($/,"%<!-%+*",+"("A(76,"/7($%"'!*9"*9%"7(/%",: "Z%'=,6*D"$,/!+.",5*",+"

#"<!/5($"76%(*%-"*,"=6%/%+*"*9%,6!%/"(+-"7,+7%=*/"=6%/%+*%-"!+"A&"-!//%6*(*!,+3"

4,567%8"#5*9,6/",'+

Page 33: Revaluating Typological Standards

N^

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

A579"!+<%/*A%+*",<%6"*9%"$(/*"*%+"&%(6/"*,"L(6-!::3"B9%"/!.+/" ,: " 6%*(!$" -%.%+%6(*!,+" (6%" 7$%(6$&" %<!-%+*" !+" *9%"

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

!.3.-.(%"+*7F7!.-.M9*(.7%+7>%6/"+7>%6/Q

B9%"-!//%6*(*!,+" ($$,'%-"A%" *,"=56/%" (" $,+.R/*(+-!+.":(/7!+(*!,+" '!*9" *9%" 6%*(!$" (+-" %J=%6!%+7%" %7,+,A&"$(+-/7(=%" ,: " ,56" +(*!,+3" a%.(6-%-" (/" (+" !A=,6*" !+*,"*9%";+!*%-"`!+.-,AD"*9%"6%/%(679",::%6%-"(+"!+*%6%/*R!+."!+/!.9*"!+*,"*9%"%::%7*"(":,6%!.+"\*&=,$,.&]"7(+"9(<%",+"*9%"%+<!6,+A%+*"(+-"56)(+"A!J",: "("*&=!7($"?6!*!/9"

/*(6*$!+."6%/5$*/"!+"*%6A/",: "*9%"=,$!*!7($"(+-"=,$!7&"%+R.(.%A%+*"*9(*"%+*%6"56)(+"-%/!.+"(+-")%$!%<%"*9(*"*9!/"!+<,$<%A%+*"9(/" (*" *!A%/"9(A=%6%-"-%<%$,=A%+*" (+-"*9%"/577%//",: "/,A%",: ",56"6%.!,+($"7!*!%/3"B9%"-!//%6*(R*!,+"($/,"($$,'%-"A%"*,"-%$<%" !+*,"(".6,'!+."7,+7%6+":(7!+.",56" +(*!,+/" 7!*!%/3"B9%" 7,+7%6+",: " *9%" (==%(6R(+7%",: "\L$,+%"B,'+/]"(/"*9%"Z(*!,+($"F7,+,A!7"0,R65A"6%:%6/"*,"*9%A3"B9%/%"L$,+%"B,'+/"(6%".,<%6+%-")&"$(6.%R/7($%"6%*(!$%6/"(+-"9(<%")%.5+"*,"*6(+/:,6A",56"+(*!,+/"7!*!%/" !+*,"=$(&.6,5+-/",: " /*%6!$!*&"(+-"%J=%6!R%+7%"%7,+,A&"%+<!6,+A%+*/3

Page 34: Revaluating Typological Standards

NX

msa - Event Month

'J312+K012L=+

K;18L34235+91+K02901N9*($.1%.574*7N+%"+*&7'*7.M.*%756*7917:95%7+3 7%$.70197.M.*%170+*%$7:5+#590

2(+79%/*%6"!+"A,*!,+"'(/"("5+!*"76%(*%-")%*'%%+":,56"A%A)%6/":6,A"*9%"5+!*"#679!*%7*56%"(/";6)(+"L(*($&/*3"

R-%+*/"@,!+%-"A&/%$: "(+-"*9%"*96%%",*9%6"A%A)%6/"!+"("',6I/"=6,.6(A"65+"(/"("A%(+/",: "=6,<!-!+."/,A%":,6A",: "/&+%6.&")%*'%%+"/*5-%+*/"!+"*9%"/79,,$3

B9%",6!.!+($")6!%: ":,6"\2(+79%/*%6"!+"2,*!,+]"'(/"76%R(*%-"*,"%+7,56(.%"*9%"/*5-%+*/"*,"%J=$,6%"*9%"7!*&"!+"("A%-!5A"*9%&"A(&"+,*"9(<%"*9,5.9*",: ",56"%J=%6!%+7%-")%:,6%3"B9%" /,$%" (!A",: " *9%"=6,.6(A"'(/" *," 76%(*%" ("

*9(*"',5$-"/5AA(6!1%"*9%!6"*9%,6%*!7($"/*(+-=,!+*"(+-"R

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

*9%",6!.!+($")6!%: "*,"/,A%9,'"!+7,6=,6(*%"*9!/"+%'",=R=,6*5+!*&3"

B$.7'5*/9-.74*%.5M.*%"+*

B9%"#6+-($%",6!.!+($$&"7(A%"*,"5/"'!*9"(")6!%: ":,6"5/"*,"-%/!.+"/,A%"I!+-",: "!+*%6<%+*!,+",6"'($$"(6*":,6"(" ]N^"9,56]"7,66!-,6"$,7(*%-"+%(6"*9%"A(6I%*"!+"*9%"2(+79%/R*%6"#6+-($%"/9,==!+."7%+*%63"G+",6-%6"*,"6%*(!+"("$!+I"*,"*9%",6!.!+($")6!%: "(+-"*9!/"+%'"=6,/=%7*!<%"=6,@%7*"'%"-%7!-%-"*,"%+7,56(.%"*9%"/*5-%+*/"*,"/*!$$"-%<%$,="(+-"

(+($&1%" *9%" 6%*(!$" (6%(/",: " *9%" 7!*&" (+-"=6%/%+*" *," *9%"

'(/"*9%+"76!*![5%-")&"*9%"/*5-%+*"*5*,6/"(+-"',5$-"$(*%6":,6A"*9%")(/!/",: "*9%!6"]N^"\9,56"7,66!-,6]"=6,=,/($3"K%")%$!%<%-" *9(*" *9%" #6+-($%" 9(-" ,::%6%-" *9%" /*5-%+*/" (":(+*(/*!7",==,6*5+!*&"*,"-%<%$,="("7,+7%=*"(+-"=6%/%+*"!*" *," ("),(6-D" *9!/" %J=%6!%+7%" !/" ($A,/*"5+9%(6-",: " (*"

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

4*7>60095Q

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

!"#$%&7Q6%/%+*(*!,+/"(+-"\(7*!<%"(679!<!+.]"=6,7%//",: "

A/("%<%+*"A,+*9"=6,.6(AA%3"4,567%8"#5*9,6/",'+

Page 35: Revaluating Typological Standards

N_

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

Page 36: Revaluating Typological Standards

msa - Event Month

MSA_EVENTS 2011-12 event #**

Project title Manchester In Motion_An architectural exploration of digital mediaB.Arch unit/s ARCHITECTURE AS URBAN CATALYST5th year students

Samuel D. W. WestbrookBryn T. LeeBenjamin T. HaleRobert J. Rostron

Brief Description of Event

We have entered the Age where digital media techniques are a vital attribute in an Architect’s repertoire. !is event will be based on utilising this skill by displaying an intervention or ‘spectacle’ in an urban setting in Manchester. Literature in"uenced for this event and very much recommended include Kevin Lynch’s Image of City and Francois Penz’s Architect’s of Illusion.

Day 1:Introduction to project & showcase of previous examples; Visit to each site (sites tbc); Record initial discover-ies on each site (mixed media: sketching, photographs sound & video recordings, you choose!)

Day 2:Discussion of initial #ndings; what is useful? Why? Perception of the area, what do you want to represent in a digital media format?A collection of #ndings presented with order and structure.

Day 3:Present thoughts on choice of spectacle; how can it be introduced into the site? Introduction to video editing using digital media collected

Day 4:Initial testing and experimentation of spectacle on site; How can this be re#ned?

Day 5:Consider alternative methods of representation; what is the most e$ective way to present your intervention?

Day 6:Group presentations of active archive & #nal digital media production. A prize will be given to the group with the most re#ned and creative outcome.

Aims and Outputs

To promote an abstract and creative response of urban space through digital media by imaginatively interacting with the space and the public, thus creating a spectacle or an ‘experience.’ To analyse and reinterpret the narrative embodied in urban space.To think innovatively how to create an urban intervention and how that can be present in a digital media format.To develop media skills and presentational techniques.Event will culminate in digital media presentations showing interventions in the Manchester Arndale Shopping Centre!

Page 37: Revaluating Typological Standards

NU

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

K;1;A3C312+?5;82983+;16+.;M=+

?50E+*2769342SH;YF"P"8R""2#Z#EF2FZB"S0"QaSWFLB4E'BL7<P7W'XG+*6,-57*!,+"(+-"2,*!<(*!,+"/=%%7943Q,'%$$E'BL7CJ7W'XY%.($"2(/*%67$(//L,+*6(7*/D"Y('D"Y(+-D"#HaZ3K(66!+.E'BL7D<7W'XCf4D"?3LSZBaSY43K(&+%

Q$(++!+."(+-"L,+/%6<(*!,+"2(/*%67$(//QY#Z]E"Y#K" "QSYGL>iYH0" HFg3LSZB"QQ4XiY?Q3W,9+

" " " "GZBaS" " LSZBa#LBSa" FZH" E2^

" " " "Fk;#YGB>" #LLF44G?GYGB>"" FZH"HG4#?YFH"YGg3"LFZB

HSL;2FZB#BGSZ"2#4BFaLY#44"" "LS22;ZGL" ?aGF0GZE" 4QFL" "LQGiGQH" ?G2E'BL7O7N'!" " " " "aSYF4" " QaSWFLB"2#Z3"FZHE'BL7<D7N'!"0FF4"" #QQSGZB2FZB"E'BL7C;7N'!"g#Y;FiLS4BiQaGLF" HFgFYSQ2FZB" 2#4RBFaLY#44" " "HF4GEZ"HFgFYSQ2FZB" "g#Y;F"QY#ZZGZE" "LS4B"QY#Z" Q a G L RGZE"E'BL7C;7'@!7" "LS;a4FKSa`"4;?2G44GSZ

4*7>60095Q

C(<!+." ($6%(-&" 7,A=$%*%-" (" .,,-" (A,5+*",: " *!A%" !+"=6(7*!7%"bPXA,+*9/"6%.!/*%6%-"QFHac"($,+."'!*9"("*,R*($",: "*',"&%(6/"%J=%6!%+7%"',6I!+."!+"(+"(679!*%7*56($"=6(7*!7%" G" :,5+-" *9%" 2(+(.%A%+*" Q6(7*!7%" (+-" Y('"A,-5$%"<%6&"%+@,&()$%3"a%7%+*$&" *9%6%"9(/")%%+"A579"-%)(*%"'!*9!+",56"=6,:%//!,+"'9%*9%6"(679!*%7*/"(7*5($$&"

R7(*!,+($"<!7%",6"*,"(7*5($$&")%7,A%"/577%//:5$")5/!+%//RA%+",6"',A%+3"G")%$!%<%"*9%"$(**%6"*,")%"A,6%"!A=,6*(+*"(+-"*9(*"*,-(&D"*9%6%"%J!/*/"5+'!$$!+.+%//",6"/,A%'9(*",: " (+" %A)(66(//A%+*" '9%+" (679!*%7*/" (6%" [5%/*!,+%-"

,: ")%!+."("-%/!.+%63"G*":,6"*9!/"6%(/,+"*9(*"G")%$!%<%"*9!/"A,-5$%"!/"<!*($"*,"*9%"/577%//",: ",56"=6,:%//!,+3"

2&"=6,:%//!,+($/"/*5-!%/"=6,@%7*"!+7$5-%-"*%+"[5%/*!,+/D"'!*9!+"*9%/%"[5%/*!,+/"G"'(/"(/I%-"*,"=6%/%+*"%<!-%+7%",: "("<!()$%"7,/*"7,+*6,$"A%79(+!/A"!+"*9%":,6A",: "("7$!R%+*i(679!*%7*"7,+*6(7*"(+-"6%/,567%"7,+*6,$"*()$%3"Q6,R.6(AA!+."*9%"%+*!6%"7,+/*657*!,+"(+-"-%/!.+"/79%-5$%3

Page 38: Revaluating Typological Standards

NV

Management Practice and Law

Gwyn Hall

Professional Practice Submission Y05 Manchester School of Architecture Benjamin Hale 07208138

Page 39: Revaluating Typological Standards

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

2.3%&7\E'&+"C($$]"Q6,:%//!,+($"4*5-!%/"=6,@%7*":6,+*"7,<%63"

4,567%8"#5*9,6/",'+

Page 40: Revaluating Typological Standards

Technology & Enviroment

>;524+!N+,=

###?+?534312;2901+B+"3>0524,7!%*&"(==%(6/"7(5.9*"!+"("*6(="'!*9"+,"'(&",5*3"\?5/!R+%//" (/" 5/5($]" !/" +," $,+.%6" (+" ,=*!,+3"C,'%<%6D" 9($*R!+."(+-"6%<%6/!+.",56"7,+/5A=*!,+",: "A,6%"(+-"A,6%"\/*5:: ]" (==%(6/" $!I%$&" *," *6!..%6" (" A(//!<%" -%=6%//!,+"'!*9" /%6!,5/" 5+%A=$,&A%+*" (+-" =,<%6*&3" B9!/" !/" 7%6R*(!+$&"*65%"!: "($$"'%"-,"!/"\(==$&"*9%")6(I%/]"'!*9,5*":5+R-(A%+*($$&"6%-%/!.+!+."*9%"'9,$%"/&/*%A3"K%"(6%":(7!+."("/%6!%/",: "!+*%6$!+I%-"/&/*%A!7"=6,)$%A/"l"7,+/5A!+."

%J=5$/!,+",: "*9%"<%6+(75$(6"(+-"(")6%(I-,'+"!+"*9%"6%R$(*!,+/9!=")%*'%%+"\A,6%]"(+-"\)%**%6]3"B9%",+$&"'(&"*,",<%67,A%"*9%/%"/&/*%A!7"=6,)$%A/"!/"*96,5.9"("/%*",: "/,$5*!,+/"'9!79"*9%A/%$<%/"(--6%//"*9%"!-%(",: ",5*",: "-(*%"56)(+"=$(7%"A(I!+."(+-"/,7!($"/*657*56%/3

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

(6%"9%(-!+."*,"("/!A!$(6"/9!:*"!+"75$*56%"(+-"=6,.6%//!,+3""

B9%"B6(+/:,6A(*!,+"2(+!:%/*,",: "#679!*%7*56%"(+-"4,R7!%*&D"(/"("9,A(.%"*,"B9%"E6%(*"B6(+/:,6A(*!,+D"'6!*R

*%+")&"`(6$"Q,$(+&!" !+" *9%"PV^O/3"K9!$%" !+"(" 6%$(*!<%$&"/9,6*"6%=,6*"/579"(/"*9!/"'%"7,5$-"+,*"9,=%"*,"(79!%<%"(+&*9!+."6%A,*%$&"7,A=(6()$%"*,"Q,$(+&!]/".6%(*"',6ID"*9%" /7($%",: " *9%"79(+.%"'%"+%%-" *," /%%" !/" (*" $%(/*" *9%"%[5($",: "*9%"79(+.%/"9%"-%/76!)%-3

Q,$(+&!"(+($&/%-"9,'"A(6I%*"=6,7%//%/"!+"*9%"!+-5/*6!($"6%<,$5*!,+" (+-" 7(=!*($!/A"9(-" 76%(*%-" /%<%6%" 65=*56%/"!+"*9%":()6!7",: "/,7!($"$!:%D"(+-"(6.5%-"/*6,+.$&"*9(*"'%"

*9%"!+-!<!-5($"(+-"*9%"7,AA5+!*&3

[86<(??)&)2#6?*#*&)6(/62-#6C*/#62)')//%&3>6(#6(/6%,/-60-//(+,)"\

!.-9%"+*1$":7%+7>%6/"+7?*"%

G+",56"/*5-!,"5+!*D"#679!*%7*56%"(/"(+";6)(+"L(*($&/*D"'%" 9(<%" :,75//%-" ,+" *9%" 7,56*&(6-" 9,5/%" !+" *9%" 0%1"2%-!+(3"K%"9(<%" %J(A!+%-"9,'" *9%" 7,56*&(6-" 9,5/%"(7*/"(/"("A!76,7$!A(*!7"76%(*,6D"(*"),*9")5!$-!+."(+-"56R)(+"/7($%D"(+-"*9%!6"=,*%+*!($"6,$%"(/"56)(+"7(*($&/*/":,6"F7,"7!*!%/3"K%"'%+*",+"(" /*5-&" *6!=" *,"0%1"(+-" $%(6+*"9,'"*9%"7,56*&(6-"9,5/%" !+" *9%"2%-!+("-%A,+/*6(*%/"5+![5%" /5/*(!+()$%" =6!+7!=$%/D" '9!79" %/*()$!/9%-" ,56"

5/%",: "56)(+"/=(7%D"%::%7*!<%"7$!A(*!7"6%/=,+/%",: "*9%"(679!*%7*56%"(+-"*9%"!A=,6*(+7%",: "$,7($!*&3"K%")%$!%<%"!*"!/"*9%/%"=6!+7!=$%/"*9(*"A(I%"*9%"A%-!+("!+"0%1"(+"%JR*6%A%$&"/5/*(!+()$%"=$(7%"*,"$!<%"!+3"B9%":(7*"*9(*"*,-(&]/"'(&",: "$!:%"!+"*9%"A%-!+("9(/"+,*"79(+.%-":,6"7%+*56!%/"

0%/D"A%-!+(3"4,567%8"E,,.$%"F(6*9"NOOV

Page 41: Revaluating Typological Standards

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

-!/=$(&/":56*9%6"*%/*(A%+*"*,"!*/"/577%//"(/"("/5/*(!+()$%"/,7!%*&3"

B9%6%"(6%",)<!,5/$&"$!A!*(*!,+/"*,",56"*9%,6%*!7($"=,/!R*!,+"(+-"'%"(6%"+,*"/5..%/*!+."*9%"0%1":,6A5$(" !/"*9%"=%6:%7*"A,-%$3"C,'%<%6D"(/"'%"'!$$"%J=$,6%D"A(+&",: "*9%"/5/*(!+()$%"=6!+7!=$%/"(+-"'(&/",: "$!:%"!+"*9%"0%1"A%-!+("9(<%"($6%(-&")%%+"%/*()$!/9%-",6"(6%")%!+."!+*6,-57%-"!+",*9%6"7,5+*6!%/3"#/"A(+&"56)(+!/*/"(+-"(679!*%7*/"$,,I"*,"*9%":5*56%":,6"9!.9R*%79"/,$5*!,+/"*,"7$!A(*%"79(+.%D"'%"(6%"/5..%/*!+."*9%"(+/'%6"A(&"($6%(-&")%"9%6%3

[X),('/6-? 6%6+3.-2)6)&%"6:(#()/6(26#$)60%/#6!)&)6?)<6+36#$-*/%2</6-? 6(2<(B(<*%,/\

4*7>60095Q

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

2,/*" =%,=$%]/" 7,+7%6+" (),5*" 7(6),+" %A!//!,+/" ,6" ("7(6),+" :,,*=6!+*" 7%+*%6/" (6,5+-" .(/R.511$!+." 7(6/" ,6"

*,"9,A%D",6"!+-%%-"!+"*9%"9,A%3"Y!.9*!+."(+-"9%(*!+.")5!$-!+./" .%+%6(*%/" XOm" ,: " ?6!*(!+]/" 7(6),+" -!,J!-%"%A!//!,+/" '9!$%" *9%" =6,-57*!,+" ,: " )5!$-!+."A(*%6!($/"(77,5+*/":,6"(":56*9%6"POm3

#+-"!*"!/"+,*"@5/*"7(6),+"%A!//!,+/"*9(*"(6%"*9%"=6,)$%A3"B9%"7,+/*657*!,+"!+-5/*6&".%+%6(*%/",+%"*9!6-",: "($$"*9%"'(/*%"!+"?6!*(!+"'9!$%"NOm",: "+%'")5!$-!+."A(*%6!($/",+"*9%"(<%6(.%")5!$-!+."/!*%"(6%"/!A=$&"*96,'+"('(&"(*"*9%"%+-",: "*9%"@,)3

%(79"&%(6"R"*9%"%[5!<($%+*",: "UU"E!1("=&6(A!-/"!+"F.&=*3"

&%(6/D"*!A%"(+-"/=(7%"!/"65++!+.",5*3

B9%"#679!*%7*"(/"*9%"\=$(7%"A(I%6]"9(/"/,$%"6%/=,+/!)!$R!*&",: ")%7,A!+." *9%" \/5/*(!+()$%"76%(*,6]3"B9%" 6,$%",: "*9%" #679!*%7*" 9(/" 79(+.%-" 7,+/!-%6()$&" ,<%6" *9%" $(/*"*96%%"-%7(-%/"(+-"'(/"6%7%+*$&"(**(7I%-")&"*9%"?6!*!/9"

E,<%6+A%+*":,6"!*/"=%6<%6*%-":(/7!+(*!,+"'!*9"75$*56($")5!$-!+./"*9(*"'%6%":(/9!,+%-"'!*9,5*"(+&"7,AA5+!*&"7,+/5$*(*!,+"(*"($$3"C,'"7(+"*9%/%")5!$-!+./")%"+(A%-"\75$*56($"7%+*%6/]"'9%+"75$*56%"!/"!.+,6%-"!+"*9%!6"76%(R*!,+j"#679!*%7*/"(+-"56)(+"=$(++%6/"9(<%")%7,A%"A,6%"7,+7%6+%-"'!*9"7$!%+*"/(*!/:(7*!,+"*9(+"(7*5($"5/%6":5$R

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

G+"*9!/"6%=,6*"'%"=6%/%+*%-"("7(/%"/*5-&",: "*9%"0%1"A%-!R+(D"'%",5*$!+%-"*9(*"=(//!<%"%+<!6,+A%+*($"*%79+,$,.!%/"($6%(-&"%J!/*"9%6%3"G+"*9!/"%+<!6,+A%+*D" $,7($"A(*%6!($/"(6%"5*!$!/%-"(+-"%+%6.&"7,/*/"A!+!A!/%-"*96,5.9" !+*%$R$!.%+*"-%/!.+3"K%"(6%"-!6%7*$&"=6,A,*!+."*9!/"(+-"(6%",: "*9%"(//5A=*!,+"*9(*"*9!/" !/"-!6%7*$&"*6(+/:%6()$%"*,",56"A,-%6+"56)(+"%+<!6,+A%+*/3"B9%/%"=(//!<%" *%79+,$,R

-%<%$,=%-"*9%A",<%6"A!$$%++!("*,"-%($"'!*9"*9%"7$!A(*!7"7,+/*6(!+*/" ,: " *9%" %+<!6,+A%+*" !+" '9!79" *9%&" :,5+-"*9%A/%$<%/3"G*"!/",+$&"!+"*9!/"6%7%+*".$,)($!/%-"',6$-"*9(*"'%"9(<%")%7,A%"5+('(6%"(+-"9(<%"-%7!-%-"*,"%A)6(7%"*9%"\-%:(5$*]":,6A",: "#679!*%7*56($"*6%+-/"(+-"=$(++!+."=,$!7&D"'9!79"9(/"$%-"*,"*9%"7,66,/!,+",: "*9%"<%6+(75$(63"

'%$$"(/"$,7($"7,AA5+!*&"(*"!*/"7,6%3

Page 42: Revaluating Typological Standards

Technology & Enviroment

Page 43: Revaluating Typological Standards

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

Page 44: Revaluating Typological Standards

Conclusion - Critical Self-Re!ection year 5

#018:74901=+

S<%6"*9%"7,56/%",: "*9%"&%(6"G"9(<%"=6,-57%-"("+5A)%6",: "-,75A%+*/"(+-"6%=,6*/"*9(*"G":%%$"*9,6,5.9$&"9!.9R$!.9*"A&"9%!.9*%+%-" ('(6%+%//",: " (679!*%7*56($" !//5%/D"*9%,6&"(+-"-%/!.+3"B9%"&%(6"9(/"*(5.9*"A%"A(+&"$%//,+/"(+-"G]<%"%J=%6!%+7%-"("6%($"-%=*9",: "*%79+![5%/"'9!$/*"7,$$(),6(*!+."'!*9"A&"=%%6/3"B9%"=6,7%//"9(/"-!::%6%-":6,A" =(6*" ,+%" !+" /579" ("'(&" *9(*"A579" ,: "A&"',6I"

(+-"*9%,6!%/"-%<%$,=%-"'9!$/*"!+"=6(7*!7%3"B9%"&%(6"9(/"

=6%/%+*(*!,+D" A,-%$" A(I!+.D" -!(.6(AA!+." (+-" A(=R=!+."(+-"/,:*'(6%"7,$$(),6(*!,+3"G*"9(/"%+()$%-"A%"*,"!+76%(/%"A&"/I!$$")(/%/"*9(*"'!$$",+$&"%+9(+7%"A&"7,ARA5+!7(*!,+"/I!$$/"(/"(+"(679!*%7*3"

E"11.5%9%"+*

B9%"/5)@%7*",: "A&"-!//%6*(*!,+"9(/"($'(&/")%%+"/,A%R

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i/9%" !/"'!$$!+." *," =56/%" *9%/%"

N9*9#.0.*%7!.:+5%

B9%" A(+(.%A%+*" 6%=,6*" '(/" (" /%6!,5/$&" !A=,6*(+*"

=6,7%//"(/"'%$$"(/")5!$-!+."7,+*6,$3"06,A"*9!/"A,-5$%"G".(!+%-"(".,,-"-%.6%%",: "6%/=%7*":,6",*9%6"7,+/5$*(+*/"

*9(*"*9%"-%$!<%6&"=6,7%//"!+<,$<%/"!+=5*":6,A"("+5A)%6",: "-!::%6%+*"=(6*!%/3"B9%"(679!*%7*"6%A(!+/"+,"$,+.%6"*9%"A(/*%6")5!$-%6D")5*"!+/*%(-"9(/")%7,A%"*9%"\@(7I",: "($$"*6(-%/]3"B9(*" !/"("7,A=$!A%+*" !+"*9%"/%+/%"*9(*"*9%"(6R

)5*"($/,"5+-%6/*(+-!+.",: " *9%" 6%[5!6%-" !+=5*" :6,A"($$"

=6,756%A%+*"A%*9,-3

B.($*+-+#Q7F7L*M"5+*0.*%

R*!,+" *(5.9*"A%"A579" !+" *9%"'(&",: "=6%/%+*!+." ("+%'"\!-%(]"*,"A%A)%6/",: "A&"=6,:%//!,+"(+-"*6&!+."*,".(5.%"

R*!,+"G" *9!+I" *9%" \6%=,6*]",::%6%-" *9%"A,/*" !+" *%6A/",: ".!<%"A&/%$: "(+-"A&"*',"',6I!+."=(6*+%6/" *!A%"*,"-%R<%$,=" ,56" (6.5A%+*" (+-" =6%/%+*" (" 7,9%/!<%" =$(+" *9(*"6%/=,+-%-"*,",56"5+!*"%*9,/"'9!$/*"($/,"%+.(.!+."'!*9"*9%"*%(79!+./",",56"A,-5$%"*5*,6/D"L6(!."2(6*!+3

Page 45: Revaluating Typological Standards

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

Page 46: Revaluating Typological Standards

Bibliography

2"%.59%65.

G++,<(*!<%"0,,-"Q(7I(.!+."B%79+,$,.!%/D"G+/*!*5*!,+",: "0,,-"B%79+,$,.!%/"bNOOVc

4*%%$D"L(6,$&+3D"NOOV3"45==$&!+."*9%"L!*&3"G+8"C5+.6&"L!*&8"C,'"0,,-"49(=%/"S56"Y!<%/3"Y,+-,+8"g!+*(.%"?,,I/3"L93"N3

27H,+,5.9D"K"(+-"?6(5+.(6*D"23"bNOOVc3"L9(=*%6"̂ 8"K(/*%"F[5($/"0,,-3"G+8"L6(-$%"*,"L6(-$%8"a%R2(I!+."*9%"K(&"

a(&-(+D"H3D"a(**!D"L3"T"4*%%A%6/D"`3D"bNOO_c3"L9(=*%6"PN8"L,56*&(6-/8"(")!,7$!A(*!7":,6Aj"G+8"F-'(6-/D"?3D"L,56*R

!+"0%1D"2,6,77,3"Y5+-";+!<%6/!*&3"4'%-%+3

434=6(**D"#34!AA/D"F3Z%!*1%6*"(+-"W3aRL,$$!+/"bNOO_c3"B9%"E6%(*"B6(+/!*!,+8"#"*($%",: "9,'"!*"*56+%-",5*"6!.9*3"B9%"Z%'"F7,+,A!7/"0,5+-(*!,+"bZF0cD"Y,+-,+D";+!*%-"`!+.-,A3

I.K1"%.1

9**=8ii'''3(:6!7(+%7,+,A!7,5*$,,I3,6.i%+i-(*(/*(*!/*!7/

C,5/%/

Page 47: Revaluating Typological Standards

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

Page 48: Revaluating Typological Standards

Conclusion - Critical Self-Re!ection year 5

Page 49: Revaluating Typological Standards

^O

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

Page 50: Revaluating Typological Standards