Retail sector in India postrecession 1) India: After the recession gloom it is time for a good run for the branded retail sectorBy Nirmal BangIn India µretail¶ is not a new word. But there is still something very new about the sector today in terms of the shift f rom roadside pavement retail to small shops, from departmental stores to the huge state-of-the-art malls. Today two businessmen might b e producing simil ar goods and have s ame-siz ed balance sheets, but if one does a lot of advertising and publicity and the other doesn¶t, it is the former who emerges with a µbrand¶. Yes, we are certainly living in the age of branding. Whether you buy Lux soap from a kirana shop or a supermarket ± you are ultimately buying the brand. Branding has today transformed into multi-faceted stores in shopping malls, exclusive standalone stores as well as high-end boutiques, which burn a hole in your pocket. The Indian retail market saw a slump following the global recession and is now recovering, emerging as one ofthe top attractive investment destinations. Currently, the share of retail to the country¶s GDP is about 12%, which is estimated to rise to 22% by 2010. Within this market, apparels form the second largest segment in terms ofvalue, growing annually at the rate of 10%. With the opening up of the economy and globalization, India¶s retail industry has witnessed a huge change over the years and with FDI now allowing up to 51% in single brand retail, the demographics of this industry have substantially improved and are further expected to shine. Of all market categories retail offers in itself the broadest canvas for any brand to show its true colors, to portray itself in front of the consumer and finally put the brand in the consumer¶s hands. Changing consumer patterns, rising income levels and the emerging middle class, which will constitute more than half of the total population is set to drive growth in this sector. The slowdown did bring with it some bad news for the retail industry. The Retailers Association of India revised its estimates for organized retail penetration to 10.4% in 2012 from 16%. While some said the bubble had burst, others said these brakes were necessary as otherwise this sector would have created trouble for India¶s economy in the future. Recently, India slipped to the sixth position from second in export of clothing (US$ 10.17 billion in 2008-09). The current fiscal saw garment export growth rates declining to 7% from 9%, a year before. The declining trend has been visible since Jun ¶08 and has carried on till February this year with demand picking up with signs of a global economic recovery in the latter half of the year. Post Sept ¶08, clothing exports from India have declined each month (except Jan ¶09). The provisional figures forthe September-March period are US$ 5.52 billion versus US$ 5.90 billion in the corresponding period last year, that is a decline of approximately 4.75%. Date:27 October 2009Contributed byNirmal Bang
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
India: After the recession gloom it is time for a good run for the branded retail
sector By Nirmal Bang
In India µretail¶ is not a new word. But there is still something
very new about the sector today in terms of the shift from
roadside pavement retail to small shops, from departmentalstores to the huge state-of-the-art malls.
Today two businessmen might be producing similar goods and have same-sized balance sheets, but if one does
a lot of advertising and publicity and the other doesn¶t, it is the former who emerges with a µbrand¶.
Yes, we are certainly living in the age of branding. Whether you buy Lux soap from a kirana shop or a
supermarket ± you are ultimately buying the brand. Branding has today transformed into multi-faceted stores in
shopping malls, exclusive standalone stores as well as high-end boutiques, which burn a hole in your pocket.
The Indian retail market saw a slump following the global recession and is now recovering, emerging as one of
the top attractive investment destinations. Currently, the share of retail to the country¶s GDP is about 12%, which
is estimated to rise to 22% by 2010. Within this market, apparels form the second largest segment in terms of
value, growing annually at the rate of 10%. With the opening up of the economy and globalization, India¶s retail
industry has witnessed a huge change over the years and with FDI now allowing up to 51% in single brand retail,the demographics of this industry have substantially improved and are further expected to shine.
Of all market categories retail offers in itself the broadest canvas for any brand to show its true colors, to portray
itself in front of the consumer and finally put the brand in the consumer¶s hands. Changing consumer patterns,
rising income levels and the emerging middle class, which will constitute more than half of the total population is
set to drive growth in this sector.
The slowdown did bring with it some bad news for the retail industry. The Retailers Association of India revised
its estimates for organized retail penetration to 10.4% in 2012 from 16%. While some said the bubble had burst,
others said these brakes were necessary as otherwise this sector would have created trouble for India¶s economy
in the future.
Recently, India slipped to the sixth position from second in export of clothing (US$ 10.17 billion in 2008-09). Thecurrent fiscal saw garment export growth rates declining to 7% from 9%, a year before.
The declining trend has been visible since Jun ¶08 and has carried on till February this year with demand picking
up with signs of a global economic recovery in the latter half of the year.
Post Sept ¶08, clothing exports from India have declined each month (except Jan ¶09). The provisional figures for
the September-March period are US$ 5.52 billion versus US$ 5.90 billion in the corresponding period last year,
Major plans by leading retailers, both from India and abroad, have been revealed and are much talked about.
Among these, the leading names are Marks & Spencer, Carrefour SA, Gitanjali Group Mahindra Retail,
Pantaloon Retail India (PRIL), Bharti Retail, Aditya Birla Retail, Reliance Retail and Shoppers Stop. The
government has permitted 100% FDI in the cash-and-carry wholesale formats. Franchisee arrangements have
also been allowed in retail trade.
According to industry experts, the next phase of growth is expected to come from rural markets, with rural India
accounting for almost half of the domestic retail market, valued at over US$ 300 billion.
Rural India is set to witness an economic boom, with per capita income having grown by 50% over the last 10
years, mainly on account of rising commodity prices and improved productivity.
According to retail and consumer products division, E&Y India, basic infrastructure, generation of employment
guarantee schemes, better information services and access to funding are also bringing prosperity to rural
households. The rural market, which requires constant innovation, will need to go beyond routine ideas.
All in all, there¶s no stopping India¶s retail sector. As the middle class steadily grows, the rich continue to tune in
to the finer things in life and poverty is reduced greatly each year, contributing to the retail industry in their own
little ways.
Those with established brands are taking their companies to newer levels with each financial year and there are
a number of brands that are being launched almost every other day ± adding to the massive industry thus,
helping it to grow by leaps and bounds.
2)
This section attempts to capture key trends and provides insights into the Indian organised retail sectorthrough two sub sections. In each section, D&B India presents the insights derived from a detailedanalysis of data gathered through primary and secondary sources. The first section presentsoperational insight and the second section presents the impact of economic slowdown on the Indianretail sector and the way forward. The insights are derived from the 123 eligible companies for whichmore than 80% of the information sought was available.
Section I
Economic boom lures more retail players into the sector
Organised retail took shape in India through various phases. The sector reached its glorious periodpost-economic reforms, when economic prosperity encouraged many Indian players to enter the sector.
Out of the companies that responded to this survey, 23% were established before 1990. Players likeTribhovandas Bhimji Zaveri, Nilgiris, and Bombay Swadeshi Stores, to name a few, have been
successfully operating in the sector for decades. Over the past five decades many of today¶s retailmajors like Vijay Sales, Khadim¶s, Fabindia, Rhythm House and Apollo Pharmacy made headway for thesector and mostly operated only in the metros; however, the scenario changed dramatically post-liberalisation.
As mentioned, many players ventured into the retail sector post-liberalisation; 34% of the respondentsestablished their retail business in India during 1990-2000 and opened stores in various parts of thecountry. Some retail companies that established their foothold in the sector during this period are
Shopper¶s Stop, Pantaloons, Spencer, and Vivek¶s. The Indian organised retail sector witnessed a seachange with the entry of new players. Few foreign players like McDonalds and Dominos¶ also forayedinto the Indian market in collaboration with domestic companies and their presence unfolded a newchapter in the highly unorganised sector. The noteworthy development during this period, however,was the emergence of new retail formats like departmental stores, hypermarkets and supermarketsthat gained nationwide popularity. Post-2000, organised retail sector emerged as one of the fastest-growing sectors in India. Over 43% of the surveyed companies started their retail operations after2000; some of these companies are renowned names today ± Liberty Retail Revolutions, WelspunRetail Ltd, Hypercity Retail (India) Ltd and METRO Cash and Carry India Pvt Ltd. The sector witnessed acomplete makeover with the advent of cash and carry format stores popularised by foreign players inrecent times.
More than 55% of the respondent companies were private limited companies followed by public limitedcompanies (24.5%) and proprietorship & partnerships/JV companies account for the remaining.
Among the private and public limited companies the apparel and textile segment is the most preferredsegment. For the private companies, the second most-preferred segment after textile is food, groceryand beverages segment (26%). For the public companies, home décor and furnishing segment is thesecond most-preferred segment after textile.
The organised retail segment is mainly dominated by the apparel and textile segment (25.7% of therespondent companies operate in this segment), followed by the food, grocery and beverages segment(16.1% share). The food, grocery and beverages segment dominates the entire retail market (bothorganised and unorganised), but its penetration in the organised retail side is relatively low, which isclearly revealed in the survey.
The emergence of other segments like home décor and furnishing, footwear, jewellery, consumerdurables and electronics and health, beauty and pharmaceuticals to name a few, has been the highlight
of this decade.
Franchise model gains popularity
The organised retail players predominantly operate under a direct business model; however, over thelast couple of years, players have started operating on both franchisee and direct models, and fewcompanies have started operating exclusively under the franchise model. Besides, the leading foreign
retail brands operate through the franchisee model in India as 100% FDI is not allowed in the segment.These companies have formed master franchises with Indian companies to leverage their foreignbrands in India. For instance, a number of global brands such as McDonalds, Pizza Hut, D¶damas areoperating in India under the franchise or joint venture model with their Indian business partners. Underthe franchise model, companies (franchisor) can be present in the market by incurring lower capitalexpenditure and gaining higher flexibility. Therefore, this concept is rapidly catching up in India, as thecountry offers ample growth opportunities in the organised retail segment.
According to the survey results, 72.7% of the respondents are operating under a direct model, 19.3%are operating under both direct as well as franchisee models and 8% companies are operatingexclusively under a franchisee model.
Big companies also join the fray
The retail sector¶s growth has been supported by the strengthening economic fundamentals, favourabledemographics, change in lifestyle etc. The sector has undeniably benefitted from the gradualliberalisation (51% Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) is allowed on single brand through ForeignInvestment Promotion Board (FIPB) route, and 100% FDI is allowed on cash and carry format throughthe automatic route) even though 94-95% of the Indian retail sector is unorganised. The rapidlyevolving shopping centres, multi-storeyed lifestyle malls, giant complexes that offer shopping, food and
entertainment concepts in tier I, II and III cities are overwhelming and they are attracting companiesto invest in the rapidly growing Indian organised retail space. Retail companies are focussing onincreasing their footprint in the flourishing new retail formats such as departmental stores,supermarkets, hypermarkets, convenience stores, specialty stores; as a result, investments in theIndian organised retail sector have risen incredibly. India¶s leading business houses like RelianceIndustries Ltd, Aditya Birla Group, Tata Group etc have also set their footprint in the sector over thepast few years. Some companies have expanded their presence in the booming market through theinorganic route by acquiring existing retail players; for instance, the Aditya Birla Group took overTrinethra supermarkets and Indiabulls acquired Piramyd Retail Ltd.
The top 10 players in terms of floor space accounted for 77.2% of the total floor space of therespondent companies and operated in multi-segments and different formats spread across major citiesin the country. Evidently, majority of the top 10 companies concentrated on the food, grocery andbeverages segment, and the apparel and textile segment. Nonetheless, the consumer durable andelectronic goods segment is fast-evolving as another important segment for retail companies. Majorretail players like Reliance Retail (Reliance Digital), Pantaloon Retail Ltd (eZone and ElectronicBazaars), Videocon (Next Retail Ltd), Tata Sons (Croma), Sumaria Appliances and Vijay Sales areretailing in this space.
In the endeavour to maximise returns on average floor space and store, retail companies are adoptingvarious promotional/discount activities to retain customers, especially in the current economicslowdown. Alliances with foreign brands are also gaining momentum with rapid lifestyle changes,particularly in metros and this set-up benefits both parties as they get to leverage on each other¶sreach and brand.
West-based companies constitute lion¶s share of the total floor space
According to the survey, companies from the western region had the highest share (67.1%) in the total
floor space in India, followed by companies from the north (19.1%), south (7.8%) and east region(6.0%), respectively. Likewise, in terms of average floor space per store, the western region had thehighest space at 5,345 sq ft as compared with the national average of 3,491 sq ft, while the southernregion was second at 2,789 sq ft, followed by the northern region at 1,894 sq ft and the eastern regionat 1,872 sq ft. Majority of the companies in the western region are based in the commercial capital of India, Mumbai.
As per the survey, the total store count of the respondent companies as on Dec 2008 was 19,989. Interms of region-wise contribution to total retail outlets, the western region had the largest share at
43.1%, followed by the southern region with 24.1% share, and the northern and eastern regions at20.7% and 12.1%, respectively (see chart below). Majority of these stores is specialty, conveniencestores, supermarkets/hypermarkets that are spread across the country; companies are increasinglyfocusing on various retail formats to enhance their presence in all major locations in a city/ town tocater to all sections, societies and communities of people.
Mumbai emerges as the preferred location for retailing
In the study, among 24 popular locations for organised retail in India, Mumbai was found to be themost p3.referred location as 7% of the respondent companies reported to have retail stores/ outlets inMumbai, and 6.5% respondents had stores/outlets in Bengaluru. Nonetheless, the northern region isalso popular among these companies as 35.6% of the companies denoted their preference to have theirretail stores in the northern region. This region has been riding high on the success of the IT and ITeS-BPO companies operating in the region, especially the NCR that has witnessed a spurt in thedevelopment of shopping malls, which appears as the primary reason for the region¶s increasingpreference among retailers.
y According to the study, two cities from the south feature among the top five locations ±Bengaluru and Hyderabad
y On an overall basis, 29% of the respondent companies have presence in the western region andthree cities from this region (Mumbai, Pune, and Ahmedabad) are among the top 10 preferredlocations for organised retail in India, according to this study
y The top five cities as a combination ± Mumbai, Bengaluru, Kolkata, Delhi and Hyderabad ± werepreferred by 31.8% of the respondent companies
R etail ± an important employment generator
Since the retail revolution, the retail segment has churned out employment opportunities in India. Theorganised retail segment particularly has bettered job prospects for the younger generation. Accordingto the survey results 84% of the employees were employed on a fulltime basis and the remaining oncontract basis.
The retail sector employs a high number of under-graduates who work as sales executives in thestores. The survey revealed that 56% of the employees employed by the respondent companies areunder-graduates. This was followed by graduates and post-graduates with 36% and 8% respectively.Graduates and post-graduates can not only handle daily work but are also an important tool inretaining and attracting consumers, because they could better understand consumer needs and betterinteract with them. Recently, many leading retailers have also tied up with various educationalinstitutions to provide specialised courses in retail management.
In 2008, India¶s working population (in the 15-49 years age group) constituted around 53% of thepopulation as compared with 48.6% in the UK, 49% in the US, and 53% in Russia. In addition, this
population is more dynamic than the previous generations because their consumption is driven bywants rather than needs. Thus, the organised retailing, which thrives on lifestyle products, is expectedto receive a boost because of the young population by 2020.
The survey revealed that a majority of the respondent companies (48.1%) cater to age group of 25-40,followed by 41% of the companies catering to the age group of 18-25.
The survey also revealed that a majority of retail companies, 33.6%, cater to the customers falling inRs 100,000 to Rs 500,000 income bracket, followed by 26.2% companies catering Rs 500,000 to Rs1,000, 000 income brackets.
High volume-low margin business model more popular
The survey revealed that 38% of the respondent companies operate in the high volume±low margin
business model and cater to the value segment. The supermarkets and discount stores that providedaily usage products to consumers at a discounted price come under this category. As per the survey,33% companies operate in the high volume±high margin business model and cater to the lifestylesegment.
Private labels gain importance
Private labels generally offer 5-7% higher margins to retailers and are therefore considered a very safeand profitable bet. These labels offer higher margins because they exclude the middlemen and otherrelated charges. Besides, these labels also offer many added benefits to retailers, which are along thelines of building consumer loyalty, improving market position and offering more variety to consumers.
According to the survey results, 56% of the respondent companies retail private labels in their stores.Among this 56%, the apparel segment had the maximum representation in private labels and had a40% share in the private label¶s pie, followed by the food and grocery segment that had a 12% share.
A quick glance at the share of private labels in the total sales of the respondent companies revealedthat for a majority of companies, 34%, private labels constituted 10-25% of the total sales followed by25-50% and more than 75% share for 22% companies each.
In the long run, private labels will be a very important product in a retailer¶s basket; in fact the Indianretail companies will be looking at increasing the share of private labels from the current rate to 20-40%.
Inventory management plays a key role
Inventory management is the most crucial aspect for any retailer, regardless of whether the retailer isfrom the organised or unorganised segment. A retailer needs to be accustomed to not only the markettrend but also consumer behaviour, which will help him stock the right inventory mix in his warehouse.
The inventory turnaround time, which varies from segment to segment and product to product, alsoplays a very important role in effective and efficient inventory management.
According to the survey results, a majority of the respondent companies (40%) maintained an averageinventory level of 30 to 60 days. Most of these companies were found to be operating in the lifestyle
retailing category that follows a high margin-low volume business model. On the other hand,companies operating in the value-retailing category, which included the food, grocery and beveragessector, maintained an average inventory level of less than 15 days. Evidently, higher inventory levels(of more than 60 days) were observed among the highpriced, luxury goods retailers.
R etailers use outsourcing to improves efficiencies
Transportation is the most outsourced activity for the retail companies that responded to this survey,as 48% companies were found to depend on third party logistic management companies; the other
most outsourced activities were warehousing/storage activity (12%), distribution (12%) and inventorymanagement (11%) in that order. Transportation, warehousing and inventory management, are vitalactivities in terms of costs, which is why companies are re-arranging their focus on reducing inventorylevels and adopting just-in-time approach. Besides lowering inventory carrying costs outsourcing alsoenables retailers to capitalise on the specialised services provided by outsourcing partners, whichinadvertently lowers costs substantially.
Internal accruals most preferred funding option
The respondent companies are poised to meet their funding requirements through internal accruals.These companies ranked internal accruals as the most-preferred financing option for their workingcapital requirements as well as for future expansion plans. Loans from banks/FIs and funding frompromoters were the two most preferred external sources of funding for the retail companies, accordingto the survey results.
Expansion, working capital requirements top fund utilisation priorities
The retail companies are confident about the future of organised retail in India and are thereforeplanning to utilise a majority of their funds for further expansion. Among the respondent companies,66.7% want to utilise funds for business expansion. The other two options for using their funds are forfulfilling working capital requirements followed by marketing and advertising.
R etailers attribute their success to a thriving economy
As a part of the survey, the selected companies were asked to rank the factors that they think haveaided the retail sector¶s strong performance. These factors were given in the survey and were to beranked on a scale where 1 was most important and 9 was least important. The analysis revealed that amajority of the retailers ranked the flourishing Indian economy as one of the key growth drivers.According to Technopak, the organised retail industry is set to reach US$ 94.4 billion by FY12 and Indiahas all the potential needed to support this growth. The Indian economy has been the one of thefastest-growing economy in the world and has shown resilience when the major economies of the worldwere facing difficult times, by staging a decent growth. As per revised estimates of CSO, India¶s GDP atfactor cost has recorded a growth rate of 6.7% in FY09 and is expected to grow at around 6% in FY10.All these factors augur well for the Indian retail industry. Growing disposable incomes and youngpopulation were rated second and third growth drivers, respectively, in the survey.
Section II
Economic slowdown pinches retail sector
The economic slowdown has been affecting the global retail sector significantly, both from the demand
side and supply side. The global demand has been falling consistently over the past one year followingthe crisis in the US mortgage market. The resultant job losses and the fall in income have aggravatedthe impact on consumer demand. Besides, job uncertainty (in anticipation of job losses) has led to dropin consumer spending. The global economy, especially the developed economies, has been witnessingcontraction in GDP growth over the last couple of quarters; the global GDP growth rate is expected tocontract by 2.9% in 20091. On the supply side, however, many retailers are slowing down theirexpansion plans and many real estate developers are falling behind schedules in their shopping mallprojects, considering the credit crunch. The economic slowdown has deeply affected the Indian
organised retail sector in terms of deceleration in retail sales growth, footfalls, store expansions,employment rates and most importantly, profitability.
According to this D&B survey, around 88% of the respondents opined that economic slowdown hasaffected the sector badly, while the remaining 12% respondents opined that the slowdown has not
affected their business. Majority of the retailers who opined to be not affected by the slowdown operatein the food and restaurant segment, which has been spared from the slowdown. Majority of therespondents who felt that they were affected by the slowdown operated in the apparel and textilesegment.
The survey revealed that apart from the slowdown in the economy, understanding consumer behaviourand customer retention are the other major issues and challenges that the Indian retailers face. Giventhe current situation, retailers are concerned about decreasing consumer spending, as consumers aredeferring their purchases, and the sector is witnessing a paradigm shift from, what is being called, µconspicuous consumption to conscious consumption¶. Moreover, any dip in customer footfall and weakconversion ratio has an impact on retailers¶ inventory turnover, which increases their working capitalrequirements.
Inventory management is crucial to rebound in present times
According to the survey, majority of the respondent companies prioritise inventory management as animportant instrument to combat the current slowdown. Proper inventory management helps retailers tohave a better understanding about their stocks in the store; therefore, retailers can utilise the floorspace optimally. Unnecessary inventory involves costs to retailers in terms of interest, space,manpower, handling damages etc.
Another strategy to combat the challenges is collaborating with suppliers and manufacturers, sinceretailers are finding it difficult to manage their expenses, especially that of raw materials. The retailerscan persuade suppliers or manufacturers; increase their bargaining power over longer credit periods, or
further integrate their supply chain to lower working capital requirements.
Revenue/profit sharing with real estate players is emerging as an important strategy in view of thecurrent slowdown, because real estate expenses constitute anything between 10-12% of retailers¶ sales. The stupendous rise in real estate prices over the last couple of years has become a majorchallenge for retailers who are exploring the option of re-negotiating rentals or of forging alliances withbuilders for revenue/profit sharing to distribute their risks.
Furthermore, retailers are also adopting strategies to retain customers through discounts, lower prices,value-added services and increased choice of products by entering JVs with foreign brands.
Expansion plans continue undeterred
As mentioned earlier, the retailers in India are optimist about growth of the industry in spite of globalslowdown. A majority of the respondent companies (49.1%) feel that the industry will achieve an
annual growth rate of 15-25% in the next two years while 36.1% companies feel that the industry willgrow annually by 5-15% during the same period. India has achieved moderate growth during the timewhen most of the countries across the globe are falling prey to slowdown and recession and this is oneof the key reasons why an average Indian retailer is confident about the growth of the industry.
1 World Bank- Global Development Finance Report 2009