Responsibility in Self-Deception（自己欺瞞における責任の所在）

ƴĄŢƒJ*1^Ǟ MĪá�íƄǽòȍ*ƸMŨïòìôȎ [email protected] ŗ�ŭÚôƕƛ¡ 2013.4.27�

��

��.���

! ƾŵMǞ ǥÍ ƣŘMUJƑƌ7EǞ bÛ',A �HM[(IÆşF&_Ǟ bǜ(R-� ȍŻƥ�ǔǗ�²IHȎ ! ƣŘM�ǐ©�J*'E�ƾŵƩ,£bĢß7�šũ7E'?+bƔ^3GNDZǃ�

��

¬ě�šũJƑƌ9^ĢØ�

! ¬ěYšũJL8_,Ƃ8�=_,ƾŵMč-DzGIB?MF&_O�ƾŵ@1FI/=MÆşTF?HBEǞ bĆ9+H(+b¾ń9R- �

! HM[(I¬ěYšũMZ,U, ! HM[(J7EƾŵbƂ85;^+

�bŇƖJ9^Ęǃ,&^ Ǟ bÛa_^Z,c@¬ěM&]ŅG7E�ƴĄŢƒ�bG]&2^�

��

�ƴĄŢƒ�MìT+IöƧ�

¬ěpbXBE'^G-J¬ě¬pb&)E¬8ǣX(G9^żĤ ȍ§ȎőŐj�F&^3GbƔ]I,\Ę:ū^G¬8^�IH� �ƴĄŢƒbƾIBE'^ǭ¼bǹ1OţćI¾ńÂb±)E'^�býǚG9^ȍėƙƪĎYƠƙƉğNýǚêȎ�

��

ƴĄŢƒNI<ǞW\_^+�

! �ƴĄŢƒ�G'(NJƼMg��o ['GN')I' =_ƴ¢�ȂǿMłƲF¦ƃ5_(^ I<+Ȓ ! �Ţƒȍ�b@T9Ȏ�G'(ĵ^Ƶ'ƴ¢,ŏT7/I'

! ��N¬8?G*]MƾÆ*[PƊNJb9R-F&]�£MŚIJXI/=_GȈ'Ǫ(NJÆb7?]¬ěbé)ENI\I'�G'(�ÔƀĞMǃǕ��

��

ƴĄŢƒƩJǞ bÛ)^+�

! X7��ƴĄŢƒȑƴ¼b@T9�FNI'G7?\Ȓ

! Ǟ bÛa_^?WMŕ�bƴĄŢƒƩ,Ų?7E'I'G7?\Ȓ

ƴĄŢƒƩJǞ bÛ(3G,Ę:7XðĐ@GN')I/I^MFNȒ

��

ŒƊǀMƌŞ�

! ƴĄŢƒƩMǞ b×ö9^Neil LevyM�ďMĭ¾ƋŜnjbǧ7E��ÔƀI¬ěbXC3Gƴ¢MǞ M&]+bÛ(

! 2CMǖŴ �LevyMǖǏƴ¢JÛȆNI'+ �ǖǏJÛȆ,I/EX�=3+\ƴĄŢƒMµǞNÿ+_^+�

�

Neil Levy�ƳƙƢ­ƀôM��ƴƅĢęYǩĖƋǞ MȅãFĈĊ/ŮǠ ȍ2009ĉ�ŗ�ìôȉæk���pJŖņȎ

! ����1addiction,+���5�!.$��*�3-0##42'��5%$(*�3��-" )�����.���5���

�

HM[(I�Ǟ �bĬ(+�

! ƣŘJ*1^ǩĖƋǞ  �A,B7?ȍ7I+B?Ȏ�3GJǞ ,&^ ȑ�A,B7?ȍ7I+B?Ȏ�3GJ[]ŏT7/I'ƣŘ,Ƃ8�=M3GFAbȂǿ9^3G,ÒƱF&^ �ȍĢßƋȎƾŵ ŏT7+\KƣŘ�MßČb»ƊŴG9^,�ĢßƋFI/GXǞ ,Û)^3Gb�ď�

��

ƴĄŢƒbW0^ÚôƋǙǖ�

! ĢßǓȐƴĄŢƒNĢßƋƾŵF&^ " pF&^G¬8E'^ƴ¼b@T7E¬pG¬85;[(G9^

" @T5_^¬ěpG@T9¯M¬ě¬p,Õ��ŹMėJóá9^

! ÆşǓȐƴĄŢƒNĢßGNŽƜJ�šũYȇŏIHbÆşG7EƂ8^ " pbǁ�1^ǏIJbL8Ō2E¬pG¬8^MU

" pb¬8^�¢G¬pb¬8^�¢,Õ��ŹM�Jóá9^MFNI'�

���

ĢßǓFƂ8^��zulp�

! ȁƋ(static)��zulp: pG¬pbÕʼnJ¬8^I\O��p�¬p�b¬8^3GJI^

�¸ùMƓƏ� ! ÆƋ(dynamic)��zulp N8W+\p,ƐF&]�¬p,°F&^3G,a+BE'I,\¬pb¬8^3GN�ÒƱ

�¬pb¬8^³-J*1^ƓƏ� � ���

ÆşǓ�

! pb¬8E'^,�¬pb¬8?'&T]Jpbǁ�1^ǏIJbŶDžorǮÔ[/Ljǰ

! ƴĄŢƒJĘǃIMN�Z,c@ŅŭFǏIJbĶ)�=_bXGJ¬ěbXC�3G@1�=_�êNĘǃI'

�x��ƋƜæ�(Mele [2001])

ƓƏ9^¬ěN·ó7I' ��zulpMÜǬ�

���

ƴĄŢƒǙǖ�TGW�

Ɯæ� ¸ù� ¬ěǶMǷª� ľijƩ�

ĢßǓ� pb¬8E'^ƴ¼J¬pb¬85;[(G9^ ȍ�ƴ¼Fƴ¼b@T9�Ȏ�

pG¬pNÕʼnJóá�

Demos, Davidson, Bermúdez, etc.

ÆşǓ� p[]¬pb¬8?'šũ+\pMǏIJb¬ȕJŎ¿I[(JŤŌ7E¬pb¬8^�

p+\¬pQ� Mele, Barnes, Levy, etc.�

���

Ǟ MǙǖGM++a]�

! ĢßǓMXGFN�ƴĄŢƒƩJǞ bĆ9^3G,ùňF&^ ȓơœIÁĹȔƾŵ,ĢßƋF&_OǞ ,ƊƂ9^ ����l�d�y�§M[(IźťI�§N�ÜNýǚêG9^

"ÛȆ#ÆşǓMXGF��ĢMTTJI\I'šũJ+\_E¬ěbL8Ō2^æÔFX��ƴĄŢƒƩJǞ bÛ)^+Ȓ

���

LevyJ[^Ǟ ÜǬMǙǖ�

LevyȐƴĄŢƒƩJNǞ bÛ)I' 2ŦǻMǖǏ "ƞ1Ŧǻ#ĢßǓM×ö "ƞ2Ŧǻ#ÆşǓMXGFMǞ ĆĂÒƱĞM×ö ƴĄŢƒƩN¬ěMm�y���bŠ'E'^3GbƜǏ�

���

ĢßǓM×öȐƓƏ9^¬ě�

Levy: ƴĄŢƒJ*'EƎÐ9^¬ěpG¬ě¬p/� &) ,

! pb¬8E'^�Mī´J¬pbţĐÈ9^ǏIJ,&]�=MǏIJbţ7/ǐ©F-?G7EX�¬pb¬8E'^GNǸ\I'

! ǏIJƱÂJý9^ǐ©bDŽǒBE�&?+X¬pb¬8E'^+M[(IǴdžJǺBE'^@1

���

ĢßǓM×öȐƓƏ9^¬ě�

?@7�ƴĄŢƒJĢßƋI¯ȃ,&^3GNǑW^ ¬ěŤŌM?WMŝ�IĽ¥ȍ�¿IæȃQMƍȃbǬ1^�ǮÔM['LjǰIHȎNĢßƋJI5_^ ƴĄŢƒN�ǶĸƋJ�ĢßƋF&^�

��

Ǟ ĆĂM�ÒƱĞ(1)�Fisher & RavizzaJ[^Ǟ ŕ�Ȑ ƾŵƩJƾŵMǞ ,Ƃ8^MN… " ƾŵƩ,�¢ƋJƾŵbÿ/�jgs�p�m�y����,óá7?G-

ȍ5\JȎjgs�p�m�y���bƾ¦7?GNJ)^MN… " ſ÷Jƾŵbÿ'E'^�i|q�,�ƚ®IƀƅĚƟĞ�b±)E'^G-

(Fisher & Ravizza [1998], Ŕ� [2010], ųă[2003])

��

Ǟ ĆĂM�ÒƱĞ(2)�ÆşǓ+\DŽ_O�ƴĄŢƒƩNFisher & Ravizza Mŕ�JĐENT\I' " ƴĄŢƒƩM¬ěN��¢ƋJȍĢßƋJȎ¬8^�G')^?WMjgs�p�m�y���bŠ'E'^

…JX++a\:�ÆşǓľijƩJXƴĄŢƒƩMǞ bǎù9^è,ë' �ƴŷFNȒ

���

Ǟ ĆĂM�ÒƱĞ(3)�

! Meleȍ�ǀƋIÆşǓľijƩȎȐ �Ĩ�NĢĜŪöMǼJŹ�Mƶ7Ġ7(pros and cons)bÖØ9^[(ƴ¼JNJ'ƫ+;^�(Mele[2002], p. 103)

� ÖØbĝ_OǞ bÛa_(^ �ƴĄŢƒƩJ3M[(I¬ěMÖØ,ÒƱ@`(+Ȓ

���

Ǟ ĆĂM�ÒƱĞ(4)�! Ź�bÖØ9^?WMŕ� (1)DZǃĞŕ�Ȑ¬ěM�Ȇ,DZǃI3GF&^ AƘJĀƭ9^+BƘJ9^+bŪW^ǼHA\,M>T7'+[/ƨ)^,�����J9^+t��}�J9^+FNƨ)I'

(2)ƈěŕ�Ȑ¬ěM�Ȇ,ƐF&^+H(+JƈěbXBE'^

�3_\2CMŕ�JĔB?�F¬8E'^+H(+,�=M¬ěJǞ bĆ9^3G,F-^+H(+MĴdzGI^

���

MeleJý9^LevyMÐǖ�!  (1)JC'E DZì�@+\G'BEćJƶ7Ġ7, ƨĥ5_^a1FNI' ƿÆƋJƣñ�Ǿñ9^3GXÒƱ

! =_FXƶ7Ġ7bƨ)^Ęǃ,&^āȃ,&^G9_O… ƴ¼ƴǡMpersonality,ýǚJ(Demos [1960]) �personalitybĮĺ9^ʼnŴFƴĄŢƒJǺ^ÒƱĞN&^ $ÕöÛȆ(identification problem%

���

BarnesJý9^LevyMÐǖ�!  (2)JC'E ǧćN(1),Ų?5__Oƈ'Nķǹ5_�

(2),ħƜ9^ĘǃNI'�,… ! ƈėŋȋ+\ƴĄŢƒJǟ^3G,&^ !  Barnes:ƴĄŢƒ+\Ǟ ,Ƃ8^MNįà5_?ƈě,&^+\ ƈěJƅŖ9^�õ,&_O=_QMýºbũW\_�=_bĝ_OǞ bǥÍ5_(^

BarnesMƜæ,ţ71_O(2)NǞ bǜ(?WMŕ�G7EşƱ9^N:�

���

BarnesMäŒƋƜæ�

! ÆşǓľijƩ ! ƴĄŢƒMƌƋ*[PËÝN��õMǢŰ�

! �DŽ��õ,Ǣ/IBE'^[(JNĜ)I'�L8_?ƴĄŢƒ�JXǫƃ7(^(Barnes [1997])�

���

BarnesQMÐǖ���õMóáNǞ JGBEĘŷƋFNI' ȍMeleMx��ƋƜæȎ�p�gz16ÌŸ �¬ěpG��õbX?\9¬ěqGMǷǨJ¬ěƩ,ŧD+I1_OǞ MG][(,I'

" �õbX?\7pG¬85;^¬ěM¸ùNĘ:7X¬pF&^GNǸ\I' " ƴĄŢƒMưŊJ&^M,pGNŶǷªJDŽ)^¬qQM�õ@B?\ǷǨJŧD/3G,F-^+�

���

BarnesJý7E(LevyMЧȎ�ȍ§Ȏǝ7'ƁçFƮB?&^ìûǛ ! ƺìIûbĕ?MNǝÞ,�ƂJs��ob�)^3Gb÷ģ7?+\@G¬8E'^ȍpȐƴĄŢƒƋ¬ěȎ

! ħÃ,ǝÞI�ƂJ[^XMFNI'ȍ¬pȎ3GQM�õbŃ1^?WFNI/�ƴ¼NüùI�ǶFNI'ȍ¬qȎ3GQM�õ+\Ǧ_^?W " t��wfQMú�bıV3Gb�ǝ7'�JNƴÂFƜAƍBEš7'+\�IHGţĐÈ9^

���

Levy MBarnesQMÐǖ�!  ¬qbÑ1¶_I'3GFìûǛNǞ bÛa_(^

! � ǝ7'ƁçFƮB?,Z)JħÃ7?!G¬8^3G�G��ƴ¼N�üùF&^�!G¬8^3GJý9^�õGMÝŘǷªJŧD/3G,I1_O�ƴĄŢƒMǞ bG][(,I'

! ƴ¼M¬ě,�MHM¬ěȍQM�õȎG++a]ÔBE'^+bţ7/ĮĺF-I'*=_,&^�$ÕöÛȆ%¹P�

��

Mele, BarnesQMÐǖMĆƣ�

! DZǃĞŕ�Gƈěŕ� �¬ěJǞ bXC?WJN¬ěMÖØ,F-I1_OI\I'�G'(MeleM�ďMĘǃŕ�G7EǍö

! ÏŅb×ö9^3GMĢØ ¬ěMÖØȑ�¢ƋIm�y���M�ŅMŕ�M�ÒƱĞbƜǏ�

��

33TFMTGW�

�ƴĄŢƒMǞ ,ÒƱGI^?WJN¬ěM~gepbX?\9�i|q�bīĿ9ºƦbƾ(3G,F-I1_OI\I' �ƴĄŢƒJ*'EƓƏ7?¬ěNóá7I'MF�=M[(I�i|q�,ƊÆ9^3GXŧD/3GXI' ��i|q�JŧD+I1_OºƦbƾ)I' �ƴĄŢƒƩJNǞ bÛ)I'

���

�ƈÛ�MeleMƜæMĶ)Ņ�

MeleMłƲJ*'EN�3MčƃMŦǻFǞ MÛȆJNlj_\_E'I' ! �Ź�Mƶ7Ġ7bÖØ9^�3GGǞ GMǷǨJNƈÛM¤â&]

! �¬ěMÖØ�ƴ¢MƌƋN�îŁ�bǬ1^3GJ&^+X7_I' ��îŁ�NĘ:7XǞ bǥÍ5_^XMO+]FNI'

���

Ǟ JCI,\I'§�

ìôÑȊ ! ęŏřJ¶ôF-^+H(+NDZìF&]�ÔśF-^+H(+JXĦƈƋF&](^ ȍ�DZǃĞŕ���ƈěŕ��bŲ?9Ȏ ! ÖØbĝBEÑȊJîŁ7?G7EX�=M3GFǞ ,Ƃ8^GN+.\I' îŁMĒȄ,Œ�MUJGHT^+.]�Ǟ bÛa_^3GNI' �MeleM�ď+\NǞ JC'E£XNJ(3GNF-I'�

���

LevyMƜæQMƈÛ�?@7� ÑȊMîŁJ[BE�LJ,ƻƯ7?G9_O�=MƻƯJý7EǞ NƂ8(^ ! ǃũ5_^ŕ� �¬ěMÖØbĝ^� ����ȏ �¬ěMÖØM�ʼ5,��QMǤġ*[PøbÍS9��

���

LevyMƜæQMƈÛ�

Ǟ G��ƩQMø�MǷǨ Linehan,ĴĻ(Linehan [1982])

�ǞW\_^R-ŶƔ(culpable ignorance)� ?G)øbÍS93GbƔ\I/EX�ƾŵ,ƣŘG7EøbÍS9I\OǞ bǜ(R-

���

LinehanM�ď(1)�

ȍ§ȎƌƋbƔ\:JȀǯi�b{tp�zgvJ¨Ƥ7E'?Éą �ēNƐ÷bCGWEƔ^T'G7E-?(He had workded very hard not to know)� Ɣ^T'G7E-?≠Ɣ`(G7I+B?

ȍǩĖƋIǪ'Ȏ�

���

LinehanM�ď(2)�

! ÉąNƽŹJC'EMþǵƋƔǘ,&]�Ɛ÷bƔ^3G,F-^żŬJ&B? ÉôƋƔǘbij?I'Ʃ,ƽŹGƔ\:JźöMÇUMÑ1ű7b5;\_?MGNżŬ,ƇI^

! Ɛ÷bƔ^3G,F-^ƱÂbŎ7I,\=_bƾ¦;:�=M3GJ[BEø,Ƃ8?MI\OǞ ,ƊƂ9^�

���

LevyÍPLinehanM�ďMǐ©�

! LevyMǞ ĆĂŕ�N�ƩQMøQMƨĥbŠ'E'^

! �ŅLinehanM[(J�ø,Ƃ8_OǞ ,&^�G'(ƜæJX�7J/'

! LinehanMÉą,ǞW\_^R-IMNƐ÷bƔ^ÄÂbĝB?+\FNI/��¬ěbƔ^T'GÄW?�G'(đF¬ěMm�y���bƾIBE'^+\���ĢßƋI¬ěĽ¥

���

LevyÍPLinehanM�ďMǐ©�

! ?G)ƴĄŢƒ=MXM,ÆşJ[^XMF&BEX�ǏIJMţĐĞJ~gepb+1¬ěbL8Ō2^�ǨMĽ¥,ÒƱI\O�Ǟ bÜǬF-I'MFNI'+Ȓ

(LevyƴǡXǑW^[(JȎ�

��

ƎÐ9^¬ěMóáȒ�

! LinehanM§�¹ƨ ÉąN�ƴ¼M¦ÙN�Ùbŀ(3GF&^�(p)G'(¬ěbx�h�yG7EXBE'^ ! ÕʼnJ�ƴ¼,��m�pyJǷ�7E'^�(q)G'(¬ěbXŇƗƋFI'đFXBE'?MFNI'+ �qN3MæÔ¬pJƎĐ9^ĢØbXC ¬ěpG¬ě¬pNÕʼnJóá9^MFN

��

ƎÐ9^¬ěMóáȒ�

ȓÉąNqbg�r���F½WEƔ\5_?M@+\�=_TFNqb¬8EN'I+B?MFNI'+Ȕ ! ¬ěMýǚNĘ:7XƐFNI' ! ǒ]b¬8^3GX&_O�Njţ5_EX¬ěbļÜ7I'3GX&^

! Njţ5_EX=_bÑ1¶_^+H(+M¾ńb«Ɔ7E*/3G,F-^

!  qN=MƐƀ,ǥÍ5_I'TT«Ɔ5_E'?MFN�

���

ƎÐ9^¬ěMóáȒ�

! 3M¬ěMĶ)Ņ,ţ71_O… Levy,ĹƗ7?¬ěpG¬pM�Ɯ�ÒƱĞJƈÛƝ, ! jgs�p�m�y���,Ƃ8^?WJN�¬ěpG¬ě¬pM':_+,ŋȌƋIđFóá7E'I1_OI\I'MFNȒ

���

ƣǖ�

1.  ¬ěƩ,ƎÐ9^¬ěbȍ':_+,ŇƗƋFI'đFȎXBE'^

2.  =_\M¬ěbm�y���F-^ 3.  =_bĝ^3GF��QMø,Ƃ8(^

3_\Mŕ�,=`B?G-JN�ƴĄŢƒQMǞ ,Ƃ8(^�

���

Ìƨłž��

! Barnes, A. [1997], Seeing through Self-Deception, Cambridge University Press.

! Demos, R. [1960], “Lying to Oneself,” Journal of Philosophy 57: 588-595

!  Fischer, J. and Ravizza, M. [1998], Responsibility and Control. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

���

Ìƨłž��

! Levy, N. [2004], Self-Deception and Moral Responsibility, Ratio 17, 294-311.

! Linehan, E. A. [1982], “ Ignorance, Self-Deception and Moral Accountability,” Journal of Value Inquiry 16:101-115, 57: 588–95.

! Mele, A. [2001], Self-Deception Unmasked, Princeton University Press.

���

Ìƨłž��

! Ŕ�Î� [2010], �ƾŵƩĞGǩĖƋǞ ��fun��G��fvdMǞ ǖ�� ­ƀôĉå!59Ó�203�216�

! ųăǂƷ [2003], Ǟ MĢØGÀċ�ǜİ+\ĚƟQ!�Åƹōĩ� �

���

4ůƬ&],G(46'T7?

���