Resettlement Planning Document - Asian Development Bank

Resettlement Planning Document

This report has been submitted to ADB by the Rajasthan Urban Infrastructure Development Project, Jaipur and is made publicly available in accordance with ADB’s public communications policy (2011). It does not necessarily reflect the views of ADB.

This resettlement plan is a document of the borrower. The views expressed herein do not necessarily represent those of ADB's Board of Directors, Management, or staff, and may be preliminary in nature. In preparing any country program or strategy, financing any project, or by making any designation of or reference to a particular territory or geographic area in this document, the Asian Development Bank does not intend to make any judgments as to the legal or other status of any territory or area

Project Number: 40031-033 April 2015

IND: Rajasthan Urban Sector Development Investment Program - Tranche 2

Submitted by

Rajasthan Urban Infrastructure Development Project, Jaipur

Fw: L2506-IND RUSDIP: Submission of Revised / Final updated SRP for Sikar Urban Transport and Road (ST) Tr-2Pushkar Srivastava to: Ralf Starkloff 04/29/2015 01:11 PM

Cc: Sourav Majumder, Pooja Awasthi, Bhawna B. Kulshreshtha

FYI and record.

----- Forwarded by Pushkar Srivastava /INRM/ADB on 04/29/2015 01:09 PM -----

From: ProjectDirector RUIDP <[email protected]>To: psrivastava <[email protected]>Date: 04/22/2015 03:01 PMSubject: Re: L2506-IND RUSDIP: Submission of Revised / Final updated SRP for Sikar Urban Transport

and Road (ST) Tr-2

We agree with the change and confirm the same.

Project Director, RUIDP

On Tue, Apr 21, 2015 at 9:29 PM, <[email protected]> wrote:

Dear Mr Mahajan:

Thank you for sending us the revised RP document for Sikar roads. The revision of the RP forgot to make a correction in para 14 of the Executive Summary, which was done in para 17 of the main text. To ensure consistency, we have deleted the last sentence of para 14 of the Executive Summary. Please see the file with track changes. If you agree with this change, please send us a confirmatory email, to help us approve the RP

document.

Best regards,

Pushkar SrivastavaSenior Project Officer (Urban) India Resident Mission, Asian Development BankTel: 91-11-24107200/24194368

Fax: 91-11-26870975

www.adb.org/inrm

From: ProjectDirector RUIDP <[email protected]>

To: psrivastava <[email protected]>

Date: 04/16/2015 01:38 PM

Subject: Re: Fw: Submission of Revised / Final updated SRP for Sikar Urban Transport and Road (ST) Tr-2

Resettlement Planning Document

Short Resettlement Plan for:

(1) Sikar Road Up-gradation Sub-Project; (Package No: RUSDIP/TR-02/SKR/ST-02);

(2) Construction of Sikar Roads & Other Allied Works/Widening and Strengthening of Roads & Construction of Drain Works (Package No: RUSDIP/TR-02/SKR/ST-03) which has now become Package No: RUSDIP/TR-02/SKR/ST-05 due to re-tendering;

and

(3) Road from Jhunjhunu Bypass to Bus Stand at Sikar (Package No: RUSDIP/TR-02/SKR/ST-04)

Document Stage: Final

Project Number: 40031 Revised/Updated: April 2012 Revised/Updated: October 2014

India: Rajasthan Urban Sector Development Investment Program –Widening and Strengthening of Various Roads at Sikar Town Subproject

Prepared by Local Self Government Department The Resettlement plan is a document of the borrower. The views expressed herein do not necessarily representthose of ADB’s Board of Directors, Management, or staff, and may be preliminary in nature.

ABBREVIATIONS

ADB Asian Development Bank AP Affected Persons

BDO Block Development Officer BPL Below Poverty Line CBO Community Based Organization

CPR Common Property Resources GoI Government of India

GoR Government of Rajasthan IP Indigenous Peoples IR Income Restoration ISA Initial Social Assessment

LA Land Acquisition LAA Land Acquisition Act LIG Lower Income Group M&E Monitoring and Evaluation NGO Non-Government Organization

NIT Notice Inviting Tender NOC No Objection Certificate

NTP Notice To Proceed PAF Project Affected Family PAH Project Affected Household

PAP Project Affected Person PDP Project Displaced Person

PIU Project Implementation Unit PMU Project Management Unit

PRI Panchayat Raj Institution

RP Resettlement Plan ROR Record of Rights

RoW Right of Way R&R Resettlement and Rehabilitation

RUIDP Rajasthan Urban Infrastructure Development Project

RUSDIP Rajasthan Urban Sector Development Investment Programme SC Scheduled Caste

SES Socio-Economic Survey SHG Self Help Group ST Scheduled Tribe UDD Urban Development Department SC Supervision Consultant

CONTENTS

Executive Summary ......................................................................................................... i-iii

I. PROJECT DESCRIPTION ............................................................................................... 1 II. SCOPE OF LAND ACQUISITION AND RESETTLEMENT ............................................ 1 III. INFORMATION DISSEMINATION, CONSULTATION, PARTICIPATORY APPROACHES AND DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENTS ........................................................ 3 IV. GRIEVANCE REDRESS MECHANISMS ........................................................................ 4 V. POLICY AND LEGAL FRAMEWORK ............................................................................. 5 VI. ENTITLEMENTS .............................................................................................................. 6 VII. RELOCATION OF HOUSING AND SETTLEMENTS ..................................................... 9 VIII. INCOME RESTORATION AND REHABILITATION ....................................................... 9 IX. RESETTLEMENT BUDGET AND FINANCING PLAN ................................................... 9 X. IMPLEMENTATION SCHEDULE .................................................................................. 10 XI. INSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR RESETTLEMENT ............................................ 11 XII. MONITORING & EVALUATION .................................................................................... 12

APPENDIX 1SCOPE OF WORK IN APRIL 2012 AND MAY 2014 ...................................... 13 APPENDIX -2MAPS & DRAWINGS ...................................................................................... 24 APPENDIX 3SUB-PROJECT COMPONENTS AND RESETTLEMENT IMPACTS ............ 29 APPENDIX 4 SOCIO-ECONOMIC SURVEY SUMMARY OF AFFECTED PERSONS ....... 32 APPENDIX 5POLICY FRAMEWORK AND ENTITLEMENTS ............................................. 49 APPENDIX 6PUBLIC CONSULTATIONS ............................................................................ 55 APPENDIX 7CONSULTATION AND DISCLOSURE ............................................................ 78 APPENDIX-8APROCEEDINGS OF THE MEETING OF THE CLC DATED 22.10.2011..... 81 APPENDIX 8 BLAND DONATION/VOLUNTEER LAND FOR PROJECT BENEFIT .......... 86 APPENDIX 8 CNOC FROM ZILASAINIK WELFARE BOARD ............................................ 87 APPENDIX-9CERTIFICATES OF MITIGATION OF IMPACT ON 17 APS .......................... 88 APPENDIX-10CERTIFICATE GIVEN BY WARD PARSHAD MISSING APS .................. 105 APPENDIX-11CERTIFICATE GIVEN BY WARD PARSHAD REFUSAL OF AP.............. 139 APPENDIX-12CERTIFICATE GIVEN BY WARD PARSHAD DEATH OF AP .................. 144

i

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

1. Government of Rajasthan (GoR) has launched the Rajasthan Urban Sector Development Investment Program (RUSDIP) for development of infrastructure in 15 towns of the state with the financial assistance of Government of India (GoI) and the Asian Development Bank (ADB). The overall objectives of the Program are to meet basic human needs, improve quality of life and stimulate sustainable economic development. The 15 towns have been divided into three Design & Supervision Consultancy (DSC) units: I, II and III; under each unit there are 5 towns. Sikar comes under DSC-II. 2. Sikar located at 27032’ N latitude and 75016’ E longitude, is an important town of Shekhawati region of Rajasthan. The town also occupies a position of significance from the point of tourism and traffic. 3. The Infrastructure sectors that are being developed in Sikar under this Program are:

(i) Water Supply Rehabilitation and Expansion (ii) Solid Waste Management (iii) Drainage; and (iv) Development/ Up-gradation of Roads

4. Each sector listed above constitutes Sub-Projects. The DSCs have or are developing Detailed Project Reports (DPRs) for each sub-project. The DSCs will also provide supervision consultancy during the execution of the sub-projects. 5. The Road Sector in Sikar comprises of three packages at present and this SRP covers: (i) Sikar Road Up-gradation Sub-Project; (Package No: RUSDIP/TR-02/SKR/ST-02); (ii) Construction of Sikar Roads & Other Allied Works/Widening and Strengthening of Roads & Construction of Drain Works (Package No: RUSDIP/TR-02/SKR/ST-03) which has now become Package No: RUSDIP/TR-02/SKR/ST-05 due to re-tendering; and (iii) Road from Jhunjhunu Bypass to Bus Stand at Sikar (Package No: RUSDIP/TR-02/SKR/ST-04). The DPR of all the three sub-projects have been approved by IPMU, the Implementing Agency (IA), and implementation has already taken-off. 6. The town has a road network of 225 km, consisting of 30 km bituminous roads, 133 km cement concrete roads, 12 km WMM roads the rest 50 kms are earthen roads. The Municipal Council of Sikar is maintaining 78% of total roads and the rest 22% of road network is maintained by Public Works Department (PWD). Some roads have side drains, but most are without drains or drains in in-operational condition. Consequentially, the roads get submerged in the rainy season and the condition of the roads gets further deteriorated. 7. This Resettlement Plan (RP) has been prepared in tune with the ADB Involuntary Resettlement Policy, 1995,and the agreed Resettlement Framework (RF). The Methodology prescribed by ADB was scrupulously adhered to, to find out any adverse or Involuntary Resettlement impact in the project area. This RP is based on Transect Walks on all the 31 Roads to undergo development, widening, up-gradation; 100% Census and Socio-Economic Survey of Project Affected Persons (APs); and Consultations with the APs. The primary objective of this RP is to mitigate the adverse impacts of the intervention and to assist the APs in resettlement and restoration of their livelihood. The total number of APs in this subproject was 260 (in April 2012), i.e. above the capping limit of 200 APs for a full RP. But according to the Resettlement Framewok (RF), since there has been no physical displacement from housing or neither have 10% or more of their income generating assets lost, the impacts from this subproject were considered“insignificant”; and therefore, a Short Resettlement Planwas prepared. (Please refer to page 13 of RF, para 16 and footnote 16). This is therefore, a Category B sub-project as per the policy of ADB.

ii

8. It was assessed (in April 2012) that there would be temporary impact on the livelihood of 260 persons (APs in ST-02: 162 + APs in ST-03 or 05: 84 + APs in ST-04: 14).Due to change in alignment,change in the scope of work and civil works in the night, the number of affected persons was reduced from 260 to169 in June 2014. Since “Missing” of APs and “Unwillingness” to receive compensation by some APs, was delaying disbursement of compensation, it was decided in consultation with ADB experts thata certificate attested by concerned elected Ward member (of the LSG) locally called ‘ward parshad’ with genuine reasons would authenticate reason for deletion of such APs from the list of APs (see Appendix 10, 11 & 12).and provision in the SRP should be made for only other entitled persons. That way, name of 41 persons has been deleted from the list of APs in November 2014, and the number of APs now stands at 128. Summary of sub-project components, Maps and Drawingsare attached at Apendix 1.Sub-Project Components and Resettlement Impacts may be seen at Appendix 3.List of 128APs is attached as Appendix 4.Further, provision has been made for Vulnerable Persons/HHs.Provision has also been made for an encroached structure which was to be demolished for widening of the road. 9. Under ST-02, land acquisition is required near Dak Bungalow Circle on Fatehpura Road and Beed Road. All together, 3499.62 sq.mtrs are to be acquired. On Fatehpura road land belongs to other government department while on Beed road, the authorities of Sree Gopinath Gausala have donated/handed over 2152 sq.mtrs of their land to the EE, (RUIDP/IPIU) unconditionally for up-gradation and beautification of the road.(The copy of the letter may be seen at Appendix –8B). In the CLC Meeting held on 22.10.2011, it has been decided that land belonging to other government department will be made available to RUIDP by the District Administration in collaboration with the Municipal Council. The Proceedings of the Meeting is attached at Appendix–8A. For other two packages, land acquisition is not required as all the construction work will be within the ROW, which is Government land. 10. During Transect Walks, Census and Survey, Public Consultations and personal interviews were conducted. APs in particular and the public in general were informed about the (i) ADB supported Program, (ii) Outline and components of the Sub-Projects, (iii) Safeguards, (iv) Resettlement Framework and (v) Entitlements. The Resettlement Plan was prepared in consultation with the stakeholders. 11. Since for Resettlement Plan preparation, Census and Survey for the 3 Packages were conducted on different dates, the Cut-Off datefor ST-2, ST-03 /05and ST-04 is respectively 18th January 2012, 28th January 2012 and 25th April 2012. The Cut-Off dates will remain unchanged as additions have not been made in the revised list of APs. 12. The Policy Framework and Entitlements for all the Sub-Projects are based on National Laws and Policy, such as, the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (amended in 1984), the National Resettlement Policy & Rehabilitation Policy (NRRP) 2007; Policy on Involuntary Resettlement, 1995 of ADB; and the agreed Resettlement Framework (RF); notwithstanding the Sub-Project has IR impact or not(see Appendix 5). 13. Thirty days before the commencement of work, the APs will be notified to ensure zero or minimal disruption in livelihood. If required, they will also be assisted to temporarily shift to a location for continued economic activity. Compensation for lost income or a transitional allowance for the period of disruption, whichever is greater will be provided. 14. Affected Persons can bring their grievances to the notice of the implementing NGO and the Social Development Expert (SDE) of the DSC. If the decision given by the NGO and SDE is not satisfactory, grievances will be referred to the City Level Committee (CLC) which will act as the Grievance Redress Committee (GRC). The GRC will try to resolve the

iii

grievance within a month of receiving the grievance. If the GRC fails to deliver satisfactory decision or delays more than one month, appeal can be made to the Inter-Ministerial Empowered Committee. 15. Institutional Framework, Resettlement Costs and Implementation Schedule: The Inter-Ministry Empowered Committee (EC) is the apex body that provides policy guidance to the Executing Agency, that is, the Local Self Government Department. The Executing Agency is responsible for overall technical supervision and execution of the sub-projects. The Implementing Agency (IA) in this Program is the Investment Program Management Unit (IPMU). The Investment Program Management Consultant (IPMC) is responsible for managing the Program and for technical quality assurance. The program area has been divided into three Design and Supervision Consultancy (DSC) zones. Each DSC is responsible for designing the infrastructure, supervision of implementation and construction. The City Level Committee (CLC) is the town-level organization that prioritizes the infrastructure needed for the town. NGOs have been appointed for resettlement plan implementation, community development and empowerment to ensure participation and collaboration of the community in the Program 16. Monitoring and Evaluation mechanism has been built in this program for proper implementation of the Resettlement Plan. The Resettlement Plan embodies regular and periodic Internal Monitoring and Evaluation, as well as, External Monitoring and Evaluation.

1

I. PROJECT DESCRIPTION

1. The Investment Program will optimize social and economic development in 15 selected towns1 in Rajasthan through investments in urban infrastructure (water supply, wastewater management, solid waste management, urban drainage, and urban transport and roads), social infrastructure, and infrastructure support to cultural heritage. The Program will also provide policy reforms to strengthen urban governance, management, and support for urban infrastructure and services.2 This Short Resettlement Plan (SRP) has been prepared for the Widening and Strengthening of Roads & Construction of Drain Works sub-project in Sikar 2. Roads are arteries of development. In view of the importance of Sikar, but shortcomings in roads sector, it has been decided to widen/develop and up-grade 31 roads within the boundary of the municipal area. The sub-projects are: (i) Sikar Road Up-gradation Sub-Project; (Package No: RUSDIP/TR-02/SKR/ST-02 – 5 Roads); (ii) Construction of Sikar Roads & Other Allied Works/Widening and Strengthening of Roads & Construction of Drain Works (Package No: RUSDIP/TR-02/SKR/ST-03/05 after re-tendering – 25 Roads); and (iii) Road from Jhunjhunu Bypass to Bus Stand at Sikar(Package No: RUSDIP/TR-02/SKR/ST-04 – 1 Road). 3. In the package ST-02 on Fatehpur road, a rotary at Dak Bunglow Circle and 45 M road stretch has been cancelled as per changed scope of work as on May 2014. In the package ST-03/05 scope has been reduced and deleted as per changed scope of work as on May 2014 in a road.Package-wise, the details of the 31 roads and the scope of work in April 2012 and May/June 2014 may be seen at Appendix 1. Maps and Drawings of each package are attached just after the Scope of Work at Appendix 2.

II. SCOPE OF LAND ACQUISITION AND RESETTLEMENT

4. In accordance with ADB Guidelines on Resettlement, Initial Social Assessment and ground realities, certain Methods, Techniques, Tools were adopted under RUIDP/RUSDIP for preparation of Resettlement Plans for the Widening/ Development/ Up-gradation of the Roads Sub-Projects (ST-02, ST-03/05after re-tendering and ST-04) in Sikar. 5. To estimate the temporary impacts, initially a series of Transect Walks were conducted along all the 31 roads; this was followed by a 100% census and a socio-economic survey conducted in the impacted areas. This was conducted with the help of a predesigned tool.The Census was conducted using a questionnaire with a battery of questions. In May/June 2014, Transect Walks were also undertaken in view of the Changed Scope of Work. 6. For ST-02, land acquisition is required near Dak Bungalow Circle on Fatehpura Road and Beed Road. All together, 3499.62 sq.m are to be acquired. The details of land acquisition are: (i) The Sainik Kalyan Area- 165 sq. mtrs, PWD Dak Bungalow- 834 sq. m., AVVNL Area- 150 sq. m., PWD Office Area- 198.32 Sq. Mtrs; and Gausala (Beed Road) – 2152.30 sq. mtrs. On 13.12.2011, the authorities of Sree Gopinath Gausala have donated/handed over 2152 sq.mtrs of their land to the EE, (RUIDP/IPIU) unconditionally for up-gradation and beautification of the road. (The copy of the letter may be seen at Appendix

1 Particularly district headquarters and towns with significant tourism potential.

2 The assistance will be based on the State-level framework for urban reforms, and institutional and governance

reforms recommended by the Government of India through the Jawaharlal Nehru National Urban Renewal Mission and Urban Infrastructure Development Scheme for Small and MediumTowns.

2

–8 B. In the CLC Meeting held on 22.10.2011, it has been decided that land belonging to Sainik Kalyan Board (165 sqm), AVVNL (150 sqm), PWD Dak bungalow (834 sqm) and PWD Office (198 sqm) will be made available to RUIDP by the District Administration in collaboration with the Municipal Council. (The Proceedings of the Meeting is attached at Appendix – 8A, 8C). It is pertinent to mention here that land acquisition is not within the purview of RUIDP as land required for any sub-project has to be provided by the Line Department, and in this case by the ULB with the help of the District Administration. Gopinath Gausala has already donated their land. Under ST-02, an encroached structure is to be demolished and the AP will be compensated as per the RF. 7. For the Widening, Strengthening of twenty-five roads under ST-03 (25 Roads) and ST-04 (1 Road) and construction of side drains, land need not be acquired as all roads and drains will be within the ROW. Flora, fauna and CPRs will not get affected due to the project intervention.Package wise sub project component with Resettlement Impacts are depicted as Appendix 3. 8. In April 2012, it was estimated that construction of the 31 roads would affect the livelihood of 260 persons/households temporarily and one encroached structure permanently.It is important to mention here that under ST-02, civil works was done during night which mitigated the impact on commercial activities of 17 APs (Station Road: from Salasar Stand to the junction of Municipal Council Office), written statements of these 17 AP were also documented and annexed as Appendix 9. In May 2014 it was observed that due to change in the Scope of Work, change in alignment, construction work in the night,livelihood of 169 persons (instead of 260 APs as estimated earlier)wouldbe affected temporarily during the time of construction of the roads.Subsequently it was observed that41 APsshould not to be considered in the Resettlement Budget, due to their“missing” status from their location (34 in number - Appendix 10)., not “willing” to receive the compensation (5 in number - Appendix 11 ) and ‘death’of APs before commencement of civil works (2 in number – Appendix 12) respectively This issue was discussed with ADB and it was decided that a certificate is required with the attestationof the concerned elected ward member (of the LSG) with genuine reason for deleting their names from the list of APs.Consequent upon this exercise, the number of APs now stands at 128. 9. Survey of the impact areas was concluded for ST-2, ST-03 or 05 and ST-04 on 18th January 2012, 28th January 2012 and 25th April 2012 respectively. Hence, the Cut-Off dates are 18th January 2012 for ST-02,28th January 2012 for ST-03 or 05 and 25th April 2012 for ST-04.Survey of corridor of impact under the changed Scope of work was undertaken in May/June 2014. The Cut-Off dates will remain unchanged as additions have not been made in the number of APs. 10. Affected Persons (households) will be assisted in adjusting his/her shop in the vicinity of their original place. As confirmed during the census and socio-economic survey these temporary shops will not have to move to other distant places, hence there would be no displacement. The affected persons would be able to re-establish their shops near the original place once the construction work is completed. During construction work, access would be ensured by the implementing agency. It has been confirmed that 14 days would be required for development/ up-gradation of 200 mtrs of road work. Vulnerable affected households would be eligible for additional assistance. The rehabilitation assistance estimated for potential affected persons has been included in the resettlement budget. 11. It has been confirmed that there would be no impact on built up properties like housing, shops & commercial buildings, religious and public infrastructureexcepting one encroached structure. Social Impacts are confined mostlyto movable properties placed on government land (RoW). Total 128 Persons’ livelihood would be temporarily affected.

3

The average household size of affected households is 6.8Majority of temporary impacts will be on vendors dealing in fruits followed by vendors selling betel, cigarettes, flowers, fast food or providing services. The average earning of these people is approximately 219/- per day and the average household income works out to be 6574/- per month.But taking into consideration the Minimum Wages in Rajasthan (as on date), the average per day income per AP comes to Rs.239/-. The Resettlement Budget has been prepared on the basis of minimum wages in vogue.

Table – 1: Summary of Resettlement Impacts of 128 APs

Magnitude of Resettlement Impact Number

Permanent Land Acquisition (in ha) 0 Temporary Land Acquisition (in ha) 0 Temporarily Affected Persons/Households 128 Titleholder Affected Persons/Households 0 Non-Titleholder Affected Persons/Households 128 Female Headed Households 02 IP/STAP 0 Below Poverty Line affected Person (Temporarily Affected) 7 Schedule Caste (SC) 10 Physically disabled/Challenged 01 Total Vulnerable* 20 Affected Trees and Crops 0 Temporarily Affected CPRs 0 Demolition of Encroached structure & Replacement/Compensation for the Structure

01

Average Family Size 6.8 Average Household Income (per month) ( @ Rs. 219/-) 6574 Average HH Income on the basis of minimum wages (per month) (@ Rs. 239/-)

7181

Income Sources From vending various items and goods, and repairing, providing services.

* Vulnerable households consist of households belonging to Schedule Castes, Scheduled tribe, Women headed, below poverty line and physically disabled

12. Out of the 128APs, 69belongto Other Backward Classes (OBC),49to General Caste and 10 to Scheduled Caste.There are 20vulnerable APs, 7 APs are Below Poverty Line,Women Headed Households number 02 and 10 SC households. Only one AP having apermanent structure is going to be affected, 25 APs have Semi-Permanent structures locally called thaddi, 22APs have wodden cabinsand the rest 80APs are Mobile Vendors. Majority of the APs (59) vend fruit and vegetables, 25 tea seller, 13junk food cum ice cream parlour, 6 General Store, 25others such as Bettle Shop, Barber, Blacksmith etc.(For details please see the List of APs at Appendix 4)

III. INFORMATION DISSEMINATION, CONSULTATION, PARTICIPATORY APPROACHES AND DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENTS

13. The Resettlement Plan was prepared in consultation with stakeholders. Meetings and individual interviews were held involving stakeholders, particularly potentially temporarily Affected Persons (APs); and transect walks, census, survey and interviews were conducted to determine the potential impacts of sub-project construction to prepare the subproject Resettlement Plan. Community perception and opinions on issues related to the involuantary resettlement impacts of the Project and mitigate measures were discussed in particular. All

4

relevant aspects of project planning and development were discussed with both primary and secondary stakeholders including directly with APs and other local administrative agencies and departments. A series of Consultations were held at different locations with stakeholders and particularly with APs in June/July 2010, April 2011, and January 2012. Issues discussed mainly are:

• Community’s perception on likely strength and weaknesses of the Sub-Project,

• Community’s Perception on Likely Disturbances during Sub-Project Construction

Work,

• Anticipated Impacts on Livelihood due to Construction Work of the Sub-Project

14. The public in general were informed about the (i) ADB supported Program, (ii) Outline and components of the Sub-Project, (iii) Safeguards, (iv) Resettlement Framework and (v) Entitlements (refer to Appendix 6). 15. Following the model developed for the Multi-tranche Financing Facility (MFF), a town-wide stakeholder consultation workshop was conducted which provided an overview of the Program and subprojects to be undertaken in Sikar; Government and ADB’s resettlement policies and potential resettlement impacts of the subprojects in Sikar were discussed. During the workshop, Hindi versions of the Resettlement Framework was provided to ensure stakeholders understood the objectives, policy principles and procedures for any land acquisition, compensation and other assistance measures for any affected person. During consultations, (i) participants had expressed satisfaction that this subproject will take care of their needs; and (ii) they were not hesitant to move or shift if necessary to accommodate the work. 16. Information continues to be disseminated to affected persons and beneficiaries through various media. English and Hindi versions of the Resettlement Framework are placed in the Urban Local Body (ULB) office and affected persons have accesses to Resettlement Plan. The NGO engaged to implement the Resettlement Plan will continue consultations, information dissemination, and disclosure. A strategy for continued consultations and participation is in the Resettlement Framework. The finalized Resettlement Plan will also be disclosed in the website of ADB, the State Government, the local government, and the IPMU. ADB review and approval of the Resettlement Plan is required prior to award of civil works contracts; and compensation/assistance of affected persons is required to be disbursed prior to commencement of civil works. Consultation and disclosure activities to be followed are in as Appendix 7.

IV. GRIEVANCE REDRESS MECHANISMS 17. Grievances of affected persons will first be brought to the attention of the implementing NGO or Social Development Specialist (SDS). Grievances not redressed by the NGO or SDS will be brought to the City Level Committees (CLC) set up to monitor project implementation in each town. The CLC, acting as a grievance redress committee (GRC) is chaired by the District Collector with representatives from the ULB, state government agencies, IPIU, community-based organizations (CBOs) and NGOs. As GRC, the CLC will meet every month. The GRC will determine the merit of each grievance, and resolve grievances within a month of receiving the complaint, failing which the grievance will be addressed by the inter-ministerial Empowered Committee (EC). The Committee will be chaired by the Minister of Urban Development and Local Self Government Department (LSGD), and members will include Ministers, Directors and/or representatives of other relevant Government Ministries and Departments. Failing the redressal of grievance at any stage, Affected Person may take the case to Court of Law The IPIU will keep records of all grievances received including: contact details of complainant, date that the complaint was received, nature of grievance, agreed corrective actions and the date these were effected, and final outcome. The grievance redress process is shown in Figure 1.

5

Figure 1: Grievance Redress Process

18. All costs involved in resolving the complaints will be borne by the IPMU. The GRCs will continue to function throughout the project duration.

V. POLICY AND LEGAL FRAMEWORK

19. The Legal Framework and entitlements for the Program are based on National Laws, The Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (and as amended in 1984) and the National Rehabilitation and Resettlement Policy (NRRP) for Project Affected Persons, 2007; ADB’s Policy on Involuntary Resettlement, 1995; and the agreed Resettlement Framework (RF). Based on these, the following core involuntary resettlement principles applicable are:

(i) Land acquisition and other involuntary resettlement impacts will be avoided or minimized exploring all viable alternative sub-project designs;

(ii) Where unavoidable, time-bound Resettlement Plans will be prepared and affected persons (APs) will be assisted in improving or at least regaining their pre-program standard of living;

(iii) Consultation with affected persons on compensation, disclosure of resettlement information to affected persons, and participation of affected persons in planning and implementing sub-projects will be ensured;

(iv) Vulnerable groups will be provided special assistance3; (e.g. BPL, WHH, disabled, minority and indigenous people);

(v) Payment of compensation to affected persons including non-titled persons (e.g., informal dwellers/squatters and encroachers) for acquired assets at replacement rates;

3 Including poor households, households headed by women, the elderly, the disabled, schedule caste and

scheduled tribes considered vulnerable based on the agreed Indigenous Peoples Development Framework

(IPDF).

NGO/SDS

If Not Addressed

Affected Persons

IPMU

GRC/CLC

Grievances

If Not Addressed

6

(vi) Payment of compensation and resettlement assistance prior to the contractor taking physical acquisition of the land and prior to the commencement of any construction activities;

(vii) Provision of income restoration and rehabilitation; and

(viii) Establishment of appropriate grievance redresses mechanisms.

VI. ENTITLEMENTS

20. Policy framework and entitlements are further discussed in Appendix 5. The entitlement matrix4 for the sub-project based on the above policies and Section D of this RP are in Table-2.

4 While no impacts are noted on common resources, such row is included in the entitlement matrix as there is a

probability of impacts on common resources should alignments change after detailed design.

7

Table 2: Entitlement Matrix

Sl. No

Type of Loss

Application Definition of Entitled Person

Compensation Policy Implementation Issues

Responsible Agency

1 Temporary disruption of livelihood

Legal Titleholders 30 days advance notice regarding construction activities, including duration and type of disruption

Contractor’s5 actions to ensure there is no income6/access loss consistent with the IEE.7 Assistance to mobile vendors/hawkers to temporarily shift for continued economic activity8 For construction activities involving unavoidable livelihood disruption, compensation for lost income or a transitional allowance for the period of disruption, whichever is greater

Identification of alternative temporary sites to continue economic activity

Valuation Committee will determine income loss.

Contractors will perform actions to minimize income/access loss.

2 Impacts on vulnerable affected persons

All impacts Vulnerable affected persons

Livelihood. Vulnerable households will be given priority in project construction employment

Vulnerable households will be identified during the Census

NGO will verify the extent of impacts through a 100% survey of affected households, determine assistance, verify and identify vulnerable households.

5As mentioned in Clause 93.1 of Section VIII: Particular Condition of Contract of Bid Document 6Minimum wage in Rajasthan is Rs189 per day(Rajasthan: Minimum Wages w.e.f. January 1,2014) 7 This includes: leaving spaces for access between mounds of soil, providing walkways and metal sheets to maintain access across trenches for people and vehicles where required, increased

workforces to finish work in areas with impacts on access, timing of works to reduce disruption during business hours, phased construction schedule and working one segment at a time and one side of the road at a time.

8 For example assistance to shift to the other side of the road where there is no construction.

8

Sl. No

Type of Loss

Application Definition of Entitled Person

Compensation Policy Implementation Issues

Responsible Agency

3 Loss of commercial structure

Commercial structure and other assets

Encroachers and squatters

• 60 days advance notice to shift from occupied land

• Transitional allowance based on three months minimum wage rates.

• Shifting assistance for households.

• Right to salvage materials from structure and other assets.

• Additional compensation for vulnerable households.

Vulnerable households will be identified during the census.

NGO will verify the extant of impact through a 100%survey of affected households, determine assistance, verify and identify vulnerable households

4 Any other loss not identified

Unanticipated involuntary impacts will be documented and mitigated based on the principle of the Resettlement Framework (RF)

NGO will ascertain the nature and extent of such loss. IPMU will finalize the entitlements in line with the RF

IEE-Initial Environmental Examination, IPMU- Investment Program Management Unit, NGO- Non-Governmental Organization

9

VII. RELOCATION OF HOUSING AND SETTLEMENTS

21. In this sub-project there will be no relocation of Housing, Settlements and other structures, including replacement of housing, replacement of cash compensation, and/or self-selection.

VIII. INCOME RESTORATION AND REHABILITATION

22. Should construction activities result in unavoidable livelihood disruption, compensation for lost income or a transitional allowance for the period of disruption whichever is greater will be provided. Vulnerable affected persons will be given priority in project construction employment. Compensation and assistance to affected persons must be made prior to possession of land/assets and prior to the award of civil works contracts. 23. In this sub-project, 128persons have been identified whose livelihood will be temporarily affected. They will be compensated for temporary income loss. During consultation, the mobile vendors agreed to shift to a convenient location. Similarly, the semi-permanent kiosk/cabin/thadi owners said that they would shift to a convenient location when construction work starts. 24. Affected Persons will be provided 30 days advance notice to ensure no or minimal disruption in livelihood. If required, they will also be assisted to temporarily shift for continued economic activity. For example they will be assisted to shift to the other side of the road where there is no construction. Ensuring there is no income or access loss during subproject construction is the responsibility of contractors. Consistent with the initial environmental examination, contractors will ensure: leaving spaces for access between mounds of soil, providing walkways and metal sheets to maintain access across trenches for people and vehicles where required, increased workforces to finish work in areas with impacts on access, timing of works to reduce disruption during business hours, phased construction schedule and working one segment at a time and one side of the road at a time.

IX. RESETTLEMENT BUDGET AND FINANCING PLAN

Table -3: Summary of Land Acquisition and Resettlement Costs

SN Item Unit Affected Persons

Rate Rs. Cost

A Compensation for Loss of Livelihood, Relocation & Transfer, Additional Assistance to Vulnerable, Compensation for Structure

1 Loss of Income / Livelihood 14Days. 128 239* 428288 2 Shifting assistance (only to

Cabin/Thaddi owners) No 48 200 9600

3 Additional assistance to Vulnerable APs/HHs

14Days 20 350 98000

4 Compensation for structure: L 7’ x W 6’ x H 7’ with RC Roof

LS

10000**

Sub Total Item 1 545888

B Administrative & Implementation costs Implementing NGO covering NGO

engagement, cost of census and survey of APs and inventory of assets, cost of information and consultations, training and monitoring (including evaluation by

Lump Sum 100,000

10

SN Item Unit Affected Persons

Rate Rs. Cost

independent agency), and rental of office space and required physical facilities and materials.

C Contingencies 1 Price (5%) of Project Cost 32293 2 Physical (20%) for unanticipated

impacts such as temporary impacts on structures or temporary loss of land

129172

Total 807353 Note: Based on assessment made during the socio-economic survey, the average daily income of APs is Rs.219/-. *If AP’s daily income is less than Minimum Wages as per Government of Rajasthan Minimum Wages Act,then Compensation rate has to be calculated on the basis of minimum wages, which is Rs. 189/- in November 2014.The daily wage has been calculated on this basis. **Basis of computation-BSR, 2010. (at Contractor’s Cost) Please Note: Any structure which gets affected partially or fully due to the project implementation would be restored/re-constructed again by the contractor/in-charge of that sub-project. This has been included in the TOR of the contractor and RUIDP will ensure that this gets done. Note- Additional Assistance to Vulnerable Vendors/Shop Owners for loss of Livelihood. Less than 3 days impact- @ Rs 500/-per day, Between 4 to 7 days impact-@ Rs 400/-per day, Between 8 to 15 days impact-@ Rs 350/-per day, Between 16 to 31 days impact-@ Rs 300/-per day, More than 31 days impact- A lump sum of Rs 10000/-

X. IMPLEMENTATION SCHEDULE

Table -4: Schedule of Resettlement Implementation

Activity Months i. Establishment IPIU

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18

ii. Appointment of SDS (IPIU)

iii. Appointment of NGOs

iv. Briefing of the CLC on GRC functions

v. Census and socio-economic surveys(issuance of ID cards)

vi. Consultations and disclosure

vii. Confirmation of government land to be used and transfer from other departments

viii. RP preparation** ix. RP review and approval (PMU and ADB) ***

x. Issue notice to APs

xi. Compensation

11

Activity Months and resettlement assistance xii. Relocation as required

xiii. Skills training as required

xiv. Takeover possession of acquired property

xv. Internal monitoring

xvi. Handover land to contractors

xvii. Start of civil works

xviii. External monitoring

xix. Rehabilitation of temporarily occupied lands

Immediately after construction

XI. INSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR RESETTLEMENT

25. The LSGD is the Executing Agency (EA) responsible for overall technical supervision and execution of all sub-projects funded under the Program. The Implementing Agency (IA) is the Project Management Unit of the ongoing RUIDP, which has been expanded and assigned as the IPMU, to coordinate construction of subprojects and ensure consistency across the towns. The EC provides LSGD with central policy guidance and coordination. The IPMU is assisted by: Investment Program Management Consultants (IPMC) who manages the Program and assure technical quality of the design and construction; and Design and Supervision Consultants (DSC), who are designing the infrastructure, managing the tendering of Contractors, and supervising construction. 26. IPIUs have already been established in the project towns to manage implementation of subprojects in their area. CLCs will monitor sub-project implementation in each town. They will appoint Construction Contractors (CC) to build elements of the infrastructure in a particular town (supervised by DSC). Once the infrastructure begins to operate, responsibility will be transferred to the appropriate state or local Government Agency (GA), who will be given training, support and financial assistance through the Program where necessary to enable them to fulfill their responsibilities. They will employ local Operations and Maintenance Contractors (OMC) to maintain and repair the infrastructure as required. 27. Resettlement issues are coordinated by a Social Development Specialist (IPMU SDS) within the IPMU, who ensures that all sub-projects comply with involuntary resettlement safeguards. A Resettlement Specialist (RS) who is part of the IPMC team assists the SDS. SDS, as part of the DSC, have been appointed to work with each IPIU to update the Resettlement Plan in the detailed design stage, and to prepare Resettlement Plans for new subprojects, where required to comply with Government and ADB policies. NGOs are appointed to implement Resettlement Plans. The resettlement costs, implementation schedules and the responsible agencies are provided in Table 3, 4, and 5, respectively.

12

Table 5: Institutional Roles and Responsibilities Activities Agency

Responsible

Sub-project Initiation Stage Finalization of sites/alignments for sub-projects IPMU Disclosure of proposed land acquisition and sub-project details by issuing Public Notice Meetings at community/household level with APs of land/property Formation of Valuation Committees

IPMU NGO IPMU

RP Preparation Stage Conducting Census of all APs IPMU/IPIU/NGO Conducting FGDs/meetings/workshops during SIA surveys IPIU/NGO Computation of replacement values of land/properties proposed for acquisition and for associated assets

VC/IPIU

Categorization of APs for finalizing entitlements IPIU/IPMU Formulating compensation and rehabilitation measures Conducting discussions/meetings/workshops with all APs and other stakeholders

IPIU/IPMU IPIU/NGO

Fixing compensation for land/property with titleholders VC/IPMU Finalizing entitlements and rehabilitation packages IPIU/IPMU Disclosure of final entitlements and rehabilitation packages IPIU/NGO Approval of RP IPMU/ADB Sale Deed execution and payment Taking possession of land

IPMU

Resettlement Plan Implementation Stage Implementation of proposed rehabilitation measures NGO/SDS Consultations with APs during rehabilitation activities NGO/SDS Grievances redressal NGO/SDS/GRC Internal monitoring IPIU External monitoring External Agency

AP=affected person, VC=Valuation Committee, FGD=focus group discussions, GRC = Grievance Redress Committee, NGO = nongovernmental organization, IPMU = investment program management unit, IPIU = investment program implementation unit, SDS = Social Development Specialist, RP=resettlement plan, SIA=social impact assessment.

XII. MONITORING & EVALUATION

28. Resettlement Plan implementation will be closely monitored to provide the IPMU with an effective basis for assessing resettlement progress and identifying potential difficulties and problems. Internal monitoring will be undertaken by the IPIU with assistance from the IPMU. Internal monitoring will involve: (i) administrative monitoring to ensure that implementation is on schedule and problems are dealt with on a timely basis; (ii) socio-economic monitoring during and after any resettlement impact utilizing baseline information established through the socio-economic survey of APs undertaken during project sub-preparation, and (iii) overall monitoring to assess AP status. Job charts will be given to the SDS. The job charts will indicate the targets to be achieved during the month. Monthly progress report will be prepared and submitted to the IPMU, reporting actual achievements against the targets fixed in their respective job charts and reasons for shortfalls, if any. The IPIU will be responsible for managing and maintaining AP databases, documenting results of AP census, and verifying asset and socio-economic survey data which will be used as the baseline for assessing RP implementation impacts. The EA will appoint an independent agency to undertake external monitoring to document: (i) restoration of income levels; (ii) changes and shifts in occupation pattern; (iii) changes in AP type of housing; (iv) assessment of APs access to amenities, such as water, electricity, and transportation; and (v) performance of NGO, IPIU, and IPMU in resettlement implementation. The independent agency will monitor sub-projects twice a year and submit reports directly to the EA (IPMU). The Executing Agency will submit all external monitoring reports to ADB for review. Further details are in the Resettlement Framework.

13

APPENDIX 1

Scope of Work in April 2012 and May 2014

ST-02 A

Scope of work as in April 2012 B

Changed scope of work as in May 2014

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Sl. No

Name/ Description of the Road/ Pocket

Road Length (in m)

Physical Status

Proposed Work Name/ Description of the Road/ Pocket

Road Length (in m)

Physical Status

Proposed Work Remarks

01. Fatehpur Road Total Length: 150 m + 25 m + 10 m = 185 m.;

Width: 21 m.

BT Construct a rotary of 5 m radius on Dak Bungalow circle. The Shiv Cinema stretch, Kalyan Circle stretch and Bridge stretch of the road are proposed to be upgraded with 6 lanes divided with median. The existing width of the carriage way is 13 m which is proposed to be widened to 21 m with a median of 1.2 m for a stretch of 150 m, 25 m and 10 m respectively. Footpaths having width of 1.5 m each side is also proposed to be developed on both sides of the roads.

Fatehpur Road Total Length: 130 m + 0 m + 10 m = 140 m.;

Width: 21 m.

BT The Shiv Cinema stretch, Kalyan Circle stretch and Bridge stretch of the road are proposed to be upgraded with 6 lanes divided with median. The existing width of the carriage way is 13 m which is proposed to be widened to 21 m with a median of 1.2 m for a stretch of 150 m, 25 m and 10 m respectively. Footpaths having width of 1.5 m each side is also proposed to be developed on both sides of the

Construct a rotary of 5 m radius on Dak Bungalow circle cancelled.

Road stretch towards Kalyan Circle, cancelled due to road already constructed by RSRDC.

14

ST-02 A



1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Sl. No


Road Length (in m)

Physical Status


Road Length (in m)

Physical Status


roads.

02. Beed Road (From Palwas Road to Salasar Road)

Total Length: 930 m Width: 14 m

BT Up-gradation and Widening of the Road. This road is proposed to be upgraded to develop it as a link road to Salasar road. It is proposed to upgrade the Beed Road from existing single lane of 3.5 m wide carriage way to 4 lane with 14 m width carriage way. A median of 2 m width is proposed to be laid on one side of the road over the proposed drain.

Beed Road (From Palwas Road to Salasar Road)

Total Length: 930 m Width: 14 m

BT Up-gradation and Widening of the Road. This road is proposed to be upgraded to develop it as a link road to Salasar road. It is proposed to upgrade the Beed Road from existing single lane of 3.5 m wide carriage way to 4 lane with 14 m width carriage way. A median of 2 m width is proposed to be laid on one side of the road over the proposed drain.

15

ST-02 A



1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Sl. No


Road Length (in m)

Physical Status


Road Length (in m)

Physical Status


03. Devipura Road Total Length: 190 m;

Width: 10.5 m +

Total Length: 110 m; Width: 7.5 m

BT

Earthen/

Non-existent

Up-gradation and Widening of Devipura Road between Ajmer Stand and Pathan Auto Centre via Dujod Gate. This road has been divided into 2 stretches. The 1st stretch is from Ajmer Stand to Dujod Gate. The length of the stretch is 190 mtrs. This stretch is proposed to be upgraded from existing carriage way width of 5.5 m to 10.5 m The 2nd stretch is from Dujod Gate to Pathan Auto Centre. Length of this stretch is 110 m. It is proposed to upgrade a non-existent carriage way to 7.5 m carriage way width. The existing drain on both sides of the road is to be dismantled and a new box drain with culvert is to be laid along right

Devipura Road Total Length: 190 m;

Width: 10.5 m +

Total Length: 110 m; Width: 7.5 m

BT

Earthen/

Non-existent

Up-gradation and Widening of Devipura Road between Ajmer Stand and Pathan Auto Centre via Dujod Gate. This road has been divided into 2 stretches. The 1st stretch is from Ajmer Stand to Dujod Gate. The length of the stretch is 190 mtrs. This stretch is proposed to be upgraded from existing carriage way width of 5.5 m to 10.5 m The 2nd stretch is from Dujod Gate to Pathan Auto Centre. Length of this stretch is 110 m. It is proposed

16

ST-02 A



1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Sl. No


Road Length (in m)

Physical Status


Road Length (in m)

Physical Status


side of the road from Dujod Gate to Pathan Auto. After Pathan Auto to chainage 360 there will be bypass arrangement with RCC pipes to remove bottlenecking of existing drain and to ensure free flow of rain water.

to upgrade a non-existent carriage way to 7.5 m carriage way width. The existing drain on both sides of the road is to be dismantled and a new box drain with culvert is to be laid along right side of the road from Dujod Gate to Pathan Auto. After Pathan Auto to chainage 360 there will be bypass arrangement with RCC pipes to remove bottlenecking of existing drain and to ensure free flow of rain water.

04. Station Road

Length: 2380 m

Width: 10 to 14 m

BT Up-gradation of Station Road will start from Kalyan Circle connecting Ajmer Stand via Surajpole Gate and will

Station Road

Length: 2380 m

Width: 10 to 14 m

BT Up-gradation of Station Road will start from Kalyan Circle connecting Ajmer Stand via

17

ST-02 A



1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Sl. No


Road Length (in m)

Physical Status


Road Length (in m)

Physical Status


go upto Ghantaghar Chandpole. The Road is 2380 m long. Up-gradation of the road will involve dismantling of existing drains on both sides of the road and construction of new ones. The average width of the existing carriage way varies from 14 m from Kalyan Circle to Bank of Baroda and thereafter the average width of the carriage way is 10 m

Surajpole Gate and will go upto Ghantaghar Chandpole. The Road is 2380 m long. Up-gradation of the road will involve dismantling of existing drains on both sides of the road and construction of new ones. The average width of the existing carriage way varies from 14 m from Kalyan Circle to Bank of Baroda and thereafter the average width of the carriage way is 10 m

05. Salasar Road Length: 200 m

Width: 5.5 to 7 m

BT The average width of the existing carriage way varies from 5.5 m. to 7 m In view of unavailability of

Salasar Road Length: 200 m

Width: 5.5 to

BT The average width of the existing carriage way varies from

Location of Sump well shifted so Road not

18

ST-02 A



1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Sl. No


Road Length (in m)

Physical Status


Road Length (in m)

Physical Status


land for widening of the road, it is proposed to lay 500 mm DI and 90 mm HDPE pipes and up-grade the road for 200 m to remove accumulation of rain water behind Vikram School area.

7 m 5.5 m. to 7 m In view of unavailability of land for widening of the road, it is proposed to lay 500 mm DI and 90 mm HDPE pipes.

Required.

19

ST-04

A

Scope of work as in April 2012

B


1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Sl. No

Name/Description of the Road/Pocket

Road Length (in

m)

Physical Status

Proposed Work Name/Description of the

Road/Pocket

Road Length (in m)

Physical Status Proposed Work Remarks

1. Bus Stand to Jhunjhunu bypass Road via Circuit House in Sikar town

4100 m BT (1) Improvement and Widening of the Road from existing 7.0 m to 14.0 m with a median of 1.20 m and paved shoulder of 1.5 m on both sides. (2) Rainwater Harvesting Structure at Circuit House

Bus Stand to Jhunjhunu bypass Road via Circuit House in Sikar town

4175m (1) BT & CC Road – 3582 & 593m (2)Median – 3082 m (3)Paving Block – 2446 m

(1) Improvement and Widening of the Road from existing 7.0 m to 14.0 m with a median of 1.20 m and paved shoulder of 1.5 m on both sides. (2) Rainwater Harvesting Structure at Circuit House

20

ST-03/05

A Scope of work as in April 2012

B Changed scope of work as in May 2014

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Sl. No


Road Length (in m)

Physical Status

Proposed Work Name/Description of the Road/Pocket

Road Length (in m)

Physical Status

Proposed Work

Remarks

01 From Dispensary No.2 to Shastri Nagar via Rishikul Marg

1000 B.T Road Development with Side Drain

From Dispensary No.2 to Shastri Nagar via Rishikul Marg

1465 BT & CC Road Development with Side Drain

02 Tehsil Office to District Collectorate office

2300 EARTHEN & CC

Road Development with Side Drain

Tehsil Office to District Collectorate office

760 Scope Reduced

CC Road Development with Side Drain

240 m work Left

03 Fatehpur Road to Buchyani via ,Bakra Mandi & Mohalla Khatikan

1650 EARTHEN & CC


Fatehpur Road to Buchyani via ,Bakra Mandi & Mohalla Khatikan


04 Chokdi ka Bhawan to Din Mohd. Rd via Islamiya School

500 WBM & CC


Chokdi ka Bhawan to Din Mohd. Rd via Islamiya School

Scope deleted

05 Shanitar Mandir to Gayatri mandir via kumharo ka mohallaha Nageshwar Bagichi , Maru school

900 CC Road Development with Side Drain

Shanitar Mandir to Gayatri mandir via kumharo ka mohallaha Nageshwar Bagichi , Maru school


06 Lakshmi Market to S.K College via Saini Dharmshala


Lakshmi Market to S.K College via Saini Dharmshala

500 BT Road Development

07 Sharamdan Marg & Road behind Hospital

500 BT Road Development with Side Drain

Sharamdan Marg & Road behind Hospital

500 BT & CC Road Development

08 Silver jubilee Rd. Dhanvantri to RTO till bypass


Silver jubilee Rd. Dhanvantri to RTO till bypass


21

ST-03/05



1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Sl. No


Road Length (in m)

Physical Status


Road Length (in m)

Physical Status

Proposed Work

Remarks

09 Sheetla chowk to Ranisati mandir

900 WBM, BT & CC


Sheetla chowk to Ranisati mandir


10 Durga Colony, Jiya Colony,Shekhawat Colony

3000 EARTHEN


Durga Colony, Jiya Colony,Shekhawat Colony


11 Bismillah Colony, in Jakriya Masjid area

2200 EARTHEN


Bismillah Colony, in Jakriya Masjid area


12 From Bhanwarji Saini ki dukan to Bidami's house, to Jhunjhunu bypass

2400 WBM, BT & CC


From Bhanwarji Saini ki dukan to Bidami's house, to Jhunjhunu bypass


13 Pologround area 3000 EARTHEN


Pologround area 3000 BT Road Development with Side Drain

14 Rani sati road, Shastri nagar area

4300 Precast Blocks & Earthen


Rani sati road, Shastri nagar area


15 From Mohallah Narvan to Nehru Park via Swamiyan

700 EARTHEN


From Mohallah Narvan to Nehru Park via Swamiyan


16 From Asrar house to Fatehpur Rd. via Roshangunj Masjid


From Asrar house to Fatehpur Rd. via Roshangunj Masjid

2500 BT & CC Road Development

22

ST-03/05



1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Sl. No


Road Length (in m)

Physical Status


Road Length (in m)

Physical Status

Proposed Work

Remarks

17 From Police line to Purohit ki Dhani

3500 EARTHEN & WBM


From Police line to Purohit ki Dhani


18 From Saini Dharamshala to Prem ji Saini ki gali

800 CC & BT Road Development with Side Drain

From Saini Dharamshala to Prem ji Saini ki gali

Scope deleted

19 From Radhakishpura govt quarters to Piprali Road

1200 CC, BT & EARTHEN


From Radhakishpura govt quarters to Piprali Road


20 From Nawalgarh Rd, Janta Colony to Surya Nagar

1800 EARTHEN


From Nawalgarh Rd, Janta Colony to Surya Nagar


21 From Tagore School to Bhartiya School

600 EARTHEN


From Tagore School to Bhartiya School


22 Housing Board Zone 1600 BT & EARTHEN


Housing Board Zone 1600 BT & CC Road Development with Side Drain

23 From Bhujiya factory to Railway line

1000 EARTHEN


From Bhujiya factory to Railway line


23

ST-03/05



1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Sl. No


Road Length (in m)

Physical Status


Road Length (in m)

Physical Status

Proposed Work

Remarks

24 Charansingh nagar near Railway line


Charansingh nagar near Railway line


910 m Done 210 m Left

25 Bharupura Road 5000 EARTHEN


Bharupura Road 1747 BT Road Development with Side Drain

24

APPENDIX -2

MAPS & DRAWINGS

ST-2[Drawings]

25

26

27

ST-03 [Drawing]

28

ST-04 [Drawing]

29

APPENDIX 3

ST-02

SUB-PROJECT COMPONENTS AND RESETTLEMENT IMPACTS

TABLE: A 1 Sl. No.

Components IR Impact

i Fatehpur Road- Development of Dak Bungalow Circle [Total Length: 150 mtrs + 25 mtrs + 10 mtrs = 185 mtrs.; Width: 21 mtrs.]

Livelihood of 31Persons will be affected temporarily

ii Beed Road (From Palwas Road to Salasar Road) – Upgradation and Widening of the Road. [Total Length: 930 mtrs.; Width: 14 mtrs.]

Livelihood of 01 Person will be affected temporarily. 01 Encroached permanent structure will have to be demolished

iii Devipura Road – Up-gradation and Widening of Devipura Road between Ajmer Stand and Pathan Auto Centre via Dujod Gate. [Total Length: 190 mtrs; Width: 10.5 mtrs + Total Length: 110 mtrs; Width: 7.5 mtrs.]

Livelihood of 06 Persons will be affected temporarily

iv Station Road Total Length: 2380 mtrs; Width: 10 to 14 mtrs.

Livelihood of 45Person will be affected temporarily

v Salasar Road The average width of the existing carriage way varies from 5.5 mtrs. to 7 mtrs. In view of unavailability of land for widening of the road, it is proposed to lay 500 mm DI and 90 mm HDPE pipes and up-grade the road for 200 mtrs. to remove accumulation of rain water behindVikram School area.

No IR Impact

Total Number of APs 83

30

ST-03 Now 05

SUB-PROJECT COMPONENTS AND RESETTLEMENT IMPACTS

TABLE: A 2

Sl. No

Name/Description of the Road/Pocket IR Impact

01 From Dispensary No.2 to Shastri Nagar via Rishikul Marg NIL

02 Tehsil to District Collectorate office NIL

03 Fatehpur Road to Buchyani via ,Bakra Mandi & Mohalla Khatikan 03APs

04 Chokdi ka Bhawan to Din Mohd. Rd via Islamiya School (Dropped) NIL

05 Shanitar Mandir to Gayatri mandir via kumharo ka mohallaha Nageshwar Bagichi , Maru school

01 APs

06 Lakshmi Market to S.K College via Saini Dharmshala NIL

07 Sharamdan Marg & Road behind Hospital 7APs

08 Silver jubilee Rd. Dhanvantri to RTO till bypass 13APs

09 Sheetla chowk to Ranisati mandir 01 AP

10 Durga Colony, Jiya Colony,Shekhawat Colony NIL

11 Bismillah Colony, in Jakriya Masjid area NIL

12 From Bhanwarji Saini ki dukan to Bidami's house, to Jhunjhunu bypass

NIL

13 Pologround area NIL

14 Rani sati road, Shastri nagar area NIL

15 From Mohallah Narvan to Nehru Park via Swamiyan NIL

16 From Asrar house to Fatehpur Rd. via Roshangunj Masjid NIL

17 From Police line to Purohit ki Dhani 07 APs

18 From Saini Dharamshala to Prem ji Saini ki gali NIL

19 From Radhakishpura govt quarters to Piprali Road NIL

20 From Nawalgarh Rd, Janta Colony to Surya Nagar NIL

21 From Tagore School to Bhartiya School NIL

22 Housing Board Zone 01 AP

23 From Bhujiya factory to Railway line NIL

24 Charansingh nagar near Railway line NIL

25 Bharupura Road NIL

Total: 33 APs

31

ST-04 SUB-PROJECT COMPONENTS AND RESETTLEMENT IMPACTS

TABLE: A 3

Sl. No


Road Length (in m)

Physical Status

Proposed Work IR Impact

01 Bus Stand to Jhunjhunu bypass Road via Circuit House

4100 BT Improvement and Widening of the Road from existing 7.0 m to 14.0 m with a median of 1.20 m and paved shoulder of 1.5 m on both sides. Rainwater Harvesting Structure at Circuit House

Livelihood of 12 Persons will be affected temporarily

Total Number of APs 12

32

Appendix4 A

SOCIO-ECONOMIC SURVEY SUMMARY OF AFFECTED PERSONS (ST-02)

TABLE: A 1: APs Present CUT-OFF DATE: 18th January 2012

S.No. Location Name of AP Business Type of Structure

Type of Family

No. of Family

Members

Social Category

Vulnerability

Daily Income (in Rs.)

Impact Rehabilitation Option/Remarks

DEVIPURA ROAD

1. Ajmer Bus Stand to Dujod Gate near Shitla Chouk.

Taj Parkash Sharma

Betel shop Semi-permanent (thadi)

Joint 10 General NA 500 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com+SA


Ram Narayan Dikshit

Betel shop Semi-permanent (thadi)

Joint 9 General BPL 500 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com+SA+AAV


Sandeep Tiwari Betel shop Semi-permanent (thadi)

Joint 3 General BPL 500 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com+SA+AAV


Vinod Sharma Betel shop Semi-permanent (thadi)

Nuclear 5 General NA 500 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com+SA


Vijay Singh Fast food & Tea shop

Semi-permanent (thadi)


Com+SA


Chhitar Parkash Joshi

Florist Semi-permanent (thadi)


Com+SA

BEED ROAD

7. Rai Ji Ka Kua Nand Kishore Tyre repair

Permanent (Stone walls with RC roof)

Joint 7 General NA 400

Temporary Impact on livelihood Demolition of the structure on encroached land

Com+SA +Compensation for Structure

STATION ROAD

8. Near Railway Station

Srawan Kumar Tea Shop Semi-permanent (thadi)

Nuclear 5 SC SC 500 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com+SA+AVV

9. Near Janana Ravindra Readymade Mobile Nuclear 3 OBC No 150 Temporary Impact Com

33


Type of Family

No. of Family

Members

Social Category

Vulnerability



Hospital Kumar Clothes Vendor on livelihood

10. Near Janana Hospital

Lal Chand Mesawani

Sweetmeat Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 5

General No 150 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com


Ramkishore Jat Ice Cream Vender

Mobile Vendor

Joint 8

OBC No 100 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com


Ganpat Ram Jat

Ice Cream Vender

Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 5


Com


Bhajan Lal Rajput

Chat Shop Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 6


Com


Imamudeen Fruit Vender Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 7


Com


Jagannath Dewanda

Ice Cream Vendor

Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 4


Com


Jagdish Bhargav/ Vashudev Bhargav

Readymade Clothes

Mobile Vendor

Nuclear

6


Com


Vinod Saini/ Narayan Saini


Joint 6


Com


Raju Susawah/ Dhanna Rom


Joint 20

SC SC 200 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com+AVV

19. Near Tapariya Bagichi

Mohamad Ahashan

Watch & Belt Shop


Joint 9

General BPL 200 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com+SA+AAV

20. Near Char Batti Jatiya bazar

Shahrukha Grocery Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 5


Com


Badami Devi Vegetable ven.

Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 4

OBC WHH 150 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com+AAV


Mohamad Yonus

Grocery Mobile Vendor

Joint 8


Com


Mohamad Sariph

Fruit ven. Mobile Vendor

Joint 8


Com


Mohd. Jakeer Fruit ven. Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 8


Com


Mohd. Sattar urf Abdul Sattar


Nuclear 7


Com

26. Near Char Batti Mohamad Parik Fruit ven. Mobile Nuclear 6 General No 150 Temporary Impact Com

34


Type of Family

No. of Family

Members

Social Category

Vulnerability



Jatiya bazar Vendor on livelihood


Mohamad Jamil Fruit ven. Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 6


Com


Parmanand Sindhi

Vegetable ven.

Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 6


Com

29. Near Head Post Office

Muneer Mohd. Fruit ven. Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 9


Com


Pawan Kumar Vegetable ven.

Mobile Vendor

Joint 6


Com


Narayan Das Vegetable ven.

Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 6


Com


Mohd. Asif Fruit ven. Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 3


Com


Lal Chand Sindhi

Vegetable ven.

Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 4


Com


Tolaram Vegetable ven.

Mobile Vendor

Joint 5


Com


Mohamad Ameen

Vegetable ven.

Mobile Vendor

Joint 8


Com


Mohamad Saleem


Joint 7


Com


Mohamad Tafik Vegetable ven.

Mobile Vendor

Joint 8


Com


Mohamad Asif Fruit ven. Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 6


Com


Mohamad Ramjan

Vegetable ven.

Mobile Vendor

Joint 8


Com


Wasir S/OJamal Mali


Nuclear 5


Com


Sajid Hussain Fruit ven. Mobile Vendor

Joint 7


Com


Shokat Ali Fruit ven. Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 6


Com


Iqbal Fruit ven. Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 5


Com

44. Opposite Suraj Pole Gate

Hussain Fruit ven. Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 8


Com

35


Type of Family

No. of Family

Members

Social Category

Vulnerability




Mohamad Arif Vegetable ven.

Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 7


Com


Sareef Fruit ven. Mobile Vendor

Joint 8


Com


Kailash Chand Sindhi

Vegetable ven.

Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 6


Com


Pankeej Sindhi Vegetable ven.

Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 5


Com


Puran Mail Vegetable ven.

Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 4


Com


Mani Devi Vegetable ven.

Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 4

OBC WHH 250 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com+AAV


Banwari Lal Vegetable ven.

Mobile Vendor

Joint 6


Com


Babulal Paliwal Vegetable ven.

Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 6


Com+AAV

FATEHPUR ROAD

53. Fatehpur Road to Maru School

Rakesh Kumar Nayak

Cold drinks shop


Joint 7


Com+SA+AAV


Satish Kumar Nayak

Tea shop Semi-permanent (thadi)

Nuclear 5

SC SC & BPL

100 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com+SA+AAV


Ramswroop Shansi

Cobbler Semi-permanent (thadi)

Nuclear 4


Com+SA+AAV


Brai Mohan Jat Tea shop Semi-permanent (thadi)

Nuclear 6

OBC BPL 500 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com+SA+AAV


Shohan Lal Saini

Tea shop Semi-permanent (thadi)

Joint 6

OBC NA 150 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com+SA


Mulchand Saini Vegetables and Fruit shop


Nuclear 5

OBC NA 400 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com+SA

59. Fatehpur Near Ummerdi Vegetable Mobile Nuclear 2 General No 150 Temporary Impact Com

36


Type of Family

No. of Family

Members

Social Category

Vulnerability



Tanki ven. Vendor on livelihood

60. Fatehpur Near Tanki

Latif Gulam Fruit ven. Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 6


Com+AAV


Makhan Lal Saini


Nuclear 5


Com


Shishpal Fruit ven. Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 4


Com


Sakur Sarif Fruit ven. Mobile Vendor

Joint 10


Com

64. Near Sainik Kalyan Off.

Budharam Nayak


Joint 8

SC SC & BPL


Com+AAV


Mohan Nayak Fruit ven. Mobile Vendor

Joint 8

SC SC & BPL


Com+AAV


Salim Fruit ven. Mobile Vendor

Joint 15


Com


Jawed Ali Fruit ven. Mobile Vendor

Joint 18


Com

68. Near Dak Banglow Babu Lal Saini Juice Centre Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 5


Com

69. Near Dak Banglow Faruk S/OSultan


Nuclear 6


Com

70. Near Dak Banglow Indra Kumar Soni

Chat Vendor Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 7


Com

71. Near Dak Banglow Tofik Khan Peanuts Vendor

Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 8


Com

72. Near Dak Banglow Mohamd Rafik Fruit ven. Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 6


Com

73. Near Dak Bungalow

Mohd. Iqbal Fruit ven. Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 3


Com


Mohd. Rafeek Fruit ven. Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 6


Com


Mohd. Babu Fruit vendor. Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 4


Com

76. Near Dak Banglow Sona Ram Blacksmith Semi-permanent (thadi)

Nuclear 4


Com+SA+AAV

77. Near Dak Banglow Iqbal Fruit vendor. Mobile Nuclear 5 General No 200 Temporary Impact Com

37


Type of Family

No. of Family

Members

Social Category

Vulnerability



Vendor on livelihood

78. Near Dak Banglow Jawed Ali Toy Seller Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 3

General Disabled


Com+AAV

79. Near Dak Banglow Rajesh Kumar Vegetable vendor.

Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 5


Com+AAV

80. Near Dak Banglow Kalu Ram Luhar

Blacksmith Semi-permanent (thadi)

Nuclear 4


Com+SA

81. Near Dak Banglow Banwari Ram Luhar

Blacksmith Semi-permanent (thadi)

Nuclear 4


Com+SA

82. Near Dak Banglow Narhar Mal Saini

Vegetable vendor.

Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 6


Com

83. Near Dak Banglow Tayub Ali Vegetable vendor.

Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 4


Com

Cash Compensation for Loss of Income- Com Shifting Assistance - SA Additional Assistance to Vulnerable – AAV

38

TABLE: A 2: APs Missing

Sl.No Location Name of AP Business Type of Structure

Type of Family

No. of Family

Members

Social Category

Vulnerability



STATION ROAD

1. Near Kalyan Circle Lakha Raj Fast food Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 5 General No 300 Temporary Impact on livelihood

AP Missing


Anish Ahmad Ready-made Colthes

Mobile Vendor


AP Missing


Shah Nawas Ready-made Colthes

Mobile Vendor

Joint 12 General No 200 Temporary Impact on livelihood

AP Missing


Mohd Sarfraz Chat Vendor Mobile Vendor


AP Missing


Babu Lal Ice Cream Vendor

Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 7 OBC No 200 Temporary Impact on livelihood

AP Missing


Abdullah Sattar Grocery Mobile Vendor

Joint 7


AP Missing


Jaffar Hussain Grocery Mobile Vendor

Joint

6


AP Died before commencement-His son not prepared to provide detail


Shabeer Ali Grocery Mobile Vendor

Joint 7


AP Missing


Tahil Grocery Mobile Vendor

Joint 7


AP Missing


Juber Khan Fruit ven. Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 6


AP Missing


Iqbal S/o allahdin


Nuclear 14


AP Missing


Devi Lal Choudhary

Ice Cream Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 5


AP Missing


Abdul Sattar Vegetable ven.

Mobile Vendor

Nuclear 4


AP Missing

14. Near PWD Office Subhash Barwar

Vegetable Vendor

Mobile Vendor

Joint 6


AP Missing

15. Near Dak Banglow Mamraj Sharma

Tea Stall Semi-permanent (thadi)

Nuclear 5


AP Missing

39

Appendix 4B

SOCIO-ECONOMIC SURVEY SUMMARY OF AFFECTED PERSONS (ST-03/5) TABLE: A 1 : APs Present

CUT-OFF DATE: 28th January 2012

Sl.No

Location Name of AP Business

Type of Structure

Type of Family

No. of Family

Members

Social Category

Vulnerability


Impact Rehabilitation

Option/Remarks

Road No. 1 From Dispensary No.2 to Shastri Nagar via Rishikul Marg NIL

Road No. 2 Tehsil Office to District Collectorate office NIL

Road No. 3 Fatehpur Road to Buchyani via Bakra Mandi Road & Mohalla Khatikan

1.

Syamshad Tailor Vegetable

Cabin Single 7 OBC No 100 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com+SA

2. Ajay Singh/ Arvind Singh Chat Mobile Single 5 OBC No 150 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com

3. Rajesh Saini Chat Cabin Joint 5 OBC No 200 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com+SA

Road No. 4 Chokdi ka bhawan to Deen Mohd. road via Islamiya School NIL

Road No. 5

Shanitar Mandir to Gayatri Mandir via Kumharo Ka Mohallaha, Nageshwar Bagichi , Maru Balika School

4.

Kalu Ram Moyal Tailor Cabin Single 5 OBC No 300 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com+SA

Road No. 6 Lakshmi Market to S.K College via Saini Dharmshala NIL

40

Sl.No


Type of Structure

Type of Family

No. of Family

Members

Social Category

Vulnerability



Option/Remarks

Road No. 7 Sharamdan Marg & Road behind Hospital

5.

Balu Ram Jeenwas Tea Stall Cabin Single 5 OBC No 100 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com+SA

6. Sharwan Ram Tea Stall Cabin Joint 10 OBC No 200 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com+SA

7. Matadeen Sharma Tea Stall Cabin Single 5 General No 100 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com+SA

8. Dhura Ram Choudary Tea Stall Cabin Single 7 OBC No 100 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com+SA

9. Bhagirath Mal Jakher Tea Stall Cabin Single 5 OBC No 200 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com+SA

10. Ramuram Mawaliya Tea Stall Cabin Single 5 OBC No 200 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com+SA

11. Bhadu Ram Gurjar Tea Stall Cabin Single 4 OBC No 300 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com+SA

Road No. 8 Silver Jubli Road Dhanvantri to R.T.O till bypass

12.

Parveen Kumar Saini Tea Stall Mobile Single 11 OBC No 200 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com

13. Sanwar Mal Saini Gen & Item

Mobile Single 5 OBC No 100 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com

14. Girdhari Lal Tea Stall Cabin Single 5 OBC No 150 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com+SA

41

Sl.No


Type of Structure

Type of Family

No. of Family

Members

Social Category

Vulnerability



Option/Remarks

15. Parbhu Dayal Chat Mobile Single 7 OBC No 150 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com

16. Ashok Chat Mobile Joint 15 OBC No 150 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com

17. Ramdev Tea Stall Cabin Joint 11 OBC No 200 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com+SA

18. Omprakash Tea Stall Cabin Single 5 General No 200 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com+SA

19. Govind Ram Saini Chat Mobile Single 5 OBC No 150 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com

20. Gopal Saini Fruits Cabin Joint 20 OBC No 300 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com+SA

21. Dhanraj Sharma Tea Stall Cabin Single 8 General No 400 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com+SA

22. Shokat Ali Khatri General Store


Com+SA

23.

Surendra Saini Fruits Mobile Single 10 OBC No 200

Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com

24. Suresh Singh Tea Stall Cabin Single 5 OBC No 300


Com+SA

42

Sl.No


Type of Structure

Type of Family

No. of Family

Members

Social Category

Vulnerability



Option/Remarks

Road No. 9 Sheetla chowk to Ranisati Mandir Road

25.

Mukesh Tiwari Genral store

Cabin Joint 8 General No 200 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com+SA

Road No. 10

Durga Colony, Jiya Colony, Shekhawat Colony

Road No. 11 Bismillah Colony, in Jakriya Masjid area NIL

Road No. 12 From Bhanwarji Saini Ki Dukan to Bidami's House, to Jhunjhnu bypass NIL

Road No. 13 Pologround area NIL

Road No. 14 Ranisati Road, Shastri Nagar area NIL

Road No. 15 From Mohallah Narvan to Nehru Park via Swamiyan NIL

Road No. 16 From Asrar House to Fatehpur Road via Roshangunj Masjid

Road No. 17 From Police Line to Purohit Ji Ki Dhani

26.

Rudmal Saini Pan Pal. Cabin Single 7 OBC No 150 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com+SA

27. Kamal Kumar Barber Cabin Joint 8 OBC No 350 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com+SA

28. Rameshwar Lal Vegetable

Mobile Single 2 General No 150 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com

29. Ghanshyam Ram Barber Cabin Single 5 OBC No 300 Temporary Impact on

Com+SA

43

Sl.No


Type of Structure

Type of Family

No. of Family

Members

Social Category

Vulnerability



Option/Remarks

livelihood

30. Babulal Saini Tea Stall Mobile Single 7 OBC No 100 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com

31. Madan Lal Tea Stall Mobile Single 4 OBC No 100 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com

32. Mahaveer Parsad Genral store


Com

Road No. 18 From Saini Dharamshala to Prem Ji Saini Ki Gali NIL

Road No. 19 From Radhakishpura Govt. Quarter to Piprali Road NIL

Road No. 20 From Nawalgarh Road, Janta Colony to Surya Nagar Road NIL

Road No. 21 From Tagore School to Bhartiya School NIL

Road No. 22 Housing Board Zone

33.

Bairang Lal Dhobi Dhobi Table Single 6 OBC BPL 300 Temporary Impact on livelihood

Com+SA+AAV

Road No. 23 From Bhujiya Factory to Railway Line NIL

Road No. 24 Charansingh Nagar near Railway Line NIL

Road No. 25 Bharupura Road (New) NIL

Cash Compensation for Loss of Income – Com, Shifting Assistance - SA Additional Assistance to Vulnerable - AAV

44

Table A 2: Missing APs

Sl.No


Type of Structure

Type of Family

No. of Family

Members

Social Category

Vulnerability


Impact Rehabilitation Option/Remark

s

Road No. 3 Fatehpur Road to Buchyani via Bakra Mandi Road & Mohalla Khatikan

1)

Shokat Ali Gen & Item

Cabin Joint 4 OBC No 100 Temporary Impact on livelihood

AP Missing

Road No. 5

Shanitar Mandir to Gayatri Mandir via Kumharo Ka Mohallaha, Nageshwar Bagichi , Maru Balika School

2)

Sugan Saini Chat Mobile Single 4 OBC No 200 Temporary Impact on livelihood

AP Missing

3)

Asif Ali Chat Mobile Single 4 OBC NO 100 Temporary Impact on livelihood

AP Missing

Road No. 7 Sharamdan Marg & Road behind Hospital

4)

Moti Lal Saini Pan Pekec


AP not ready to provide detail and take compensation

5) Sita Ram Saini Fruits Mobile Single 6 OBC No 150 Temporary Impact on livelihood


6) Balbeer Meel Juice Cabin Single 4 OBC No 200 Temporary Impact on livelihood


7) Dhanvantri Choudhary Juice Cabin Single 4 OBC No 200 Temporary Impact on livelihood


45

Sl.No


Type of Structure

Type of Family

No. of Family

Members

Social Category

Vulnerability



s

8) Sunil Sharma Tea Stall Cabin Single 8 General No 300 Temporary Impact on livelihood

AP Missing

9)

Harful Ram Tea Stall Cabin Single 5 OBC No 200 Temporary Impact on livelihood

AP Missing

10)

Mukund Ram Tea Stall Cabin Single 5 SC SC 300 Temporary Impact on livelihood

AP Missing

Road No. 8 Silver Jubli Road Dhanvantri to R.T.O till bypass

11)

Narotam Saini Chat Mobile Joint 9 OBC No 250 Temporary Impact on livelihood

AP Missing

12) Mahendra Juice Mobile Single 6 OBC BPL 200 Temporary Impact on livelihood

AP Missing

13) Veeru Bhaiyaa Chat Mobile Single 2 OBC No 100 Temporary Impact on livelihood

AP Missing

14)

Dasurath Meena Chat Mobile Single 4 SC SC 300 Temporary Impact on livelihood


15) Anurag Chat Mobile Single 4 OBC BPL 150 Temporary Impact on livelihood

AP Missing

16) Ramdhan Fruit Mobile Single 7 SC SC 150 Temporary Impact on livelihood

AP Missing

17) Dipak Kumar Chat Mobile Single 4 OBC No 100 Temporary Impact on livelihood

AP Missing

18) Tara Chand Barber Mobile Single 7 OBC No 200 Temporary Impact on livelihood

AP Missing

46

Sl.No


Type of Structure

Type of Family

No. of Family

Members

Social Category

Vulnerability



s

19) Sita Ram Fruits Cabin Single 2 OBC No 250 Temporary Impact on livelihood

AP Missing

20) Ramzan Khatri General Store

Cabin Single 7 OBC No 200


AP Died before commencement-His son not ready to provide detail

Road No. 10

Durga Colony, Jiya Colony, Shekhawat Colony

21) Suta Ram Rathore

Vegetable


AP Missing

Road No. 16 From Asrar House to Fatehpur Road via Roshangunj Masjid

22) Abdy Kaadir

Genral store

Mobile Joint 9 OBC No 150 Temporary Impact on livelihood

AP Missing

Road No. 17 From Police Line to Purohit Ji Ki Dhani

23)

Birju Saini Tea Stall Cabin Single 4 OBC No 150 Temporary Impact on livelihood

AP Missing

24) Jagdish Saini Genral store

Mobile Single 5 OBC No 300 Temporary Impact on livelihood

AP Missing

47

Appendix 4C SOCIO-ECONOMIC SURVEY SUMMARY OF AFFECTED PERSONS (ST-04)

TABLE: A 1: APs Present CUT-OFF DATE: 25th April 2012

Sl.No Location Name of AP Business

Type of Structure

Type of Family

No. of Family

Members

Social Categor

y

Vulnerability



Jhunjhunu by pass to Bus Stand

1) RICCO Mode Mr. Sagarmal Saini Tea Semi-

permanent (thadi)

Nuclear 6 OBC No 175 Temporary Impact on livelihood Com+SA

2)

Mr. Niwas Saini Tea Semi-permanent (thadi)


3) Mr. Pintu Saini Tyre

Repairing Semi-permanent (thadi)

Joint 5 OBC No 150 Temporary Impact on livelihood Com+SA

4) Mr. Akhtar Khan Car

Decorator


Nuclear 2 SC SC 125 Temporary Impact on livelihood Com+SA+AAV

5) Krishi Mandi (Gate-1)

Mr. Sohan Lal Saini

Fruit Mobile Nuclear 7 OBC No 200 Temporary Impact on livelihood Com

6) Mr. Manoj Sen Barber Semi-

permanent (thadi)


7) Mr. Sanwar Mal Gurgel

Tea Semi-permanent (thadi)


8) Krishi Mandi (Gate-1)

Mr. Khem Chand Saini

Tea Semi-permanent (thadi)


9) Mr. Gopal Ram Jat Tea Semi-

permanent (thadi)


48


Type of Structure

Type of Family

No. of Family

Members

Social Categor

y

Vulnerability



10)

Mr. Gordhan Ram Jat

Fruit Mobile Joint 8 OBC No 200 Temporary Impact on livelihood Com

11) Mr. Kalash Kumar Balai

Fruit Mobile Joint 11 OBC No 150 Temporary Impact on livelihood Com

12) Mr. Banwari Lal Siani

Vegetable

Mobile Joint 10 OBC No 175 Temporary Impact on livelihood Com

Cash Compensation for Loss of Income - Com Shifting Assistance - SA Additional Assistance to Vulnerable - AAV

Table A 2: Missing APs


Type of Structure

Type of Family

No. of Family

Members

Social Categor

y

Vulnerability



Jhunjhunu by pass to Bus Stand

1)

Mr. Suresh Saini Fast Food

Mobile Nuclear 1 OBC No 175 Temporary Impact on livelihood AP Missing

2)

Mr. Ragveer Singh Chat Mobile Joint 10 OBC No 175 Temporary Impact on livelihood AP Missing

49

Appendix 5

POLICY FRAMEWORK AND ENTITLEMENTS

A. Policy and Legal Framework

The policy framework and entitlements for the Program are based on national laws: The Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (LAA, amended in 1984) the National Resettlement and Rehabilitation Policy, 2007 (NRRP); and ADB’s Policy on Involuntary Resettlement, 1995. The salient features of Government and ADB polices are summarized below.

1. Government Policy

a. National Resettlement and Rehabilitation Policy, 2007

The NRRP stipulates the minimum facilities to be ensured for persons displaced due to the acquisition of land for public purposes. The objectives of the Policy are:

(i) to minimize displacement and to identify non-displacing or least displacing alternatives;

(ii) to plan resettlement and rehabilitation of project affected families (PAFs) or project affected households (PAHs), including tribal and vulnerable households;

(iii) to provide improved standard of living to PAFs or PAHs; and (iv) to facilitate a harmonious relationship between the requiring body and PAFs.

Though NRRP is applicable for projects where over 400 PAFs in the plains or 200 PAFs in hilly or tribal areas are displaced, the basic principles can be applied to resettling and rehabilitating PAFs regardless of the number affected. NRRP’s provisions are intended to mitigate adverse impacts on PAFs. While key principles of NRRP are similar, and for some items go beyond ADB’s Policy on Involuntary Resettlement (1995), NRRP excludes linear projects (which acquire only narrow strips of land). Linear impacts and temporary linear impacts (which is the likely impact of the Program) are not covered by NRRP. Further, there is no law on resettlement in the country. The law relating to the acquisition of privately owned immoveable property is the Land Acquisition Act of 1894 (LAA, amended 1984) discussed in the following section.

b. Land Acquisition Act, 1894

The LAA provides a framework for facilitating land acquisition in India. LAA enables the State Government to acquire private land for public purposes. LAA ensures that no person is deprived of land except under LAA and entitles APs to a hearing before acquisition. The main elements of LAA are:

(i) Land identified for the purpose of a project is placed under Section 4 of the LAA. This constitutes notification. Objections must be made within 50 days to the District Collector (DC, the highest administrative officer of the concerned District).

(ii) The land is then placed under Section 6 of the LAA. This is a declaration that the Government intends to acquire the land. The DC is directed to take steps

50

for the acquisition, and the land is placed under Section 9. Interested parties are then invited to state their interest in the land and the price. Under Section 11, the DC will make an award within one year of the date of publication of the declarations. Otherwise, the acquisition proceedings shall lapse.

(iii) In case of disagreement on the price awarded, within 6 weeks of the award, the parties (under Section 18) can request the DC to refer the matter to the Courts to make a final ruling on the amount of compensation.

(iv) Once the land has been placed under Section 4, no further sale or transfer is allowed.

(v) Compensation for land and improvements (such as houses, wells, trees, etc.) is paid in cash by the project authorities to the State Government, which in turn compensates landowners.

(vi) The price to be paid for the acquisition of agricultural land is based on sale prices recorded in the District Registrar's office averaged over the three years preceding notification under Section 4. The compensation is paid after the area is acquired, with actual payment by the State taking about two or three years. An additional 30 percent is added to the award as well as an escalation of 12 percent per year from the date of notification to the final placement under Section 9. For delayed payments, after placement under Section 9, an additional 9 percent per annum is paid for the first year and 15 percent for subsequent years.

2. ADB’s Policy on Involuntary Resettlement, 1995

The three important elements of ADB’s involuntary resettlement policy are (i) compensation to replace lost assets, livelihood, and income; (ii) assistance for relocation, including provision of relocation sites with appropriate facilities and services; and (iii) assistance for rehabilitation to achieve at least the same level of well-being with the project as without it.

For any ADB operation requiring involuntary resettlement, resettlement planning is an integral part of project design, to be dealt with from the earliest stages of the project cycle, taking into account the following basic principles:

(i) Involuntary resettlement will be avoided whenever feasible. (ii) Where population displacement is unavoidable, it should be minimized. (iii) All lost assets acquired or affected will be compensated. Compensation is

based on the principle of replacement cost. (iv) Each involuntary resettlement is conceived and executed as part of a

development project or program. APs need to be provided with sufficient resources to re-establish their livelihoods and homes with time-bound action in co-ordination with civil works.

(v) APs are to be fully informed and closely consulted. (vi) APs are to be assisted to integrate economically and socially into host

communities so that adverse impacts on the host communities are minimized and social harmony is promoted.

(vii) The absence of a formal title to land is not a bar to ADB policy entitlements. (viii) APs are to be identified and recorded as early as possible to establish their

eligibility, through a census which serves as a cut-off date, and prevents subsequent influx of encroachers.

(ix) Particular attention will be paid to vulnerable groups including those with out legal title to land or other assets; households headed by women; the elderly

51

or disabled; and indigenous groups. Assistance must be provided to help them improve their socio-economic status.

(x) The full resettlement costs will be included in the presentation of project costs and benefits.

C. Comparison of Borrower’s Policy with the RF

The NRRP represents a significant milestone in the development of a systematic approach to address resettlement issues in India. LAA, 1894 however gives directives for acquisition of land in public interest and provides benefits only to titleholders. Table 1 presents a comparison of Government polices (LAA and NRRP) in comparison with the RF which is consistent with ADB’s involuntary resettlement policy.

Table 1: Comparison Between the Borrower’s and ADB’s Involuntary Resettlement Policy

Policy Principles LAA NRRP Remarks

Compliance of proposed RF with ADB’s IR

Policy

1. Involuntary resettlement should be avoided where feasible.

� �

LAA is applicable wherever private land is to be acquired by Government for public purpose.

This is addressed in the RF. The locations for project components have been identified in such a manner that IR is avoided to the extent possible. These IR impacts shall be further minimized during detailed designs.

2. Where population displacement is unavoidable, it should be minimized by exploring viable project options.

� �

LAA is applicable wherever private land is to be acquired by Government for public purpose.

This is addressed in the RF. The locations for project components have been identified in such a manner that IR is avoided to the extent possible. These IR impacts shall be further minimized during detailed designs.

3. If individuals or a community must lose their land, means of livelihood, social support systems, or way of life in order that a project might proceed, they should be compensated and assisted so that their economic and social future

� �

According to the ADB’s IR policy full RP is required when 200 or more people will experience major impacts. A Short RP is required when resettlement is insignificant when less than 200 people will

The RF addresses the IR impacts. The entitlements to the APs are outlined in the Entitlement Matrix.

52



Policy

will generally be at least as favorable with the project as without it. Appropriate land, housing, infrastructure, and other compensation, comparable to the without project situation, should be provided to the adversely affected population, including indigenous groups, ethnic minorities, and pastoralists who may have usufruct or customary rights to the land or other resources taken for the project.

experience major impacts. According to the NRRP, RP should be prepared when it involves resettlement of more than 500 families (roughly about 2,000 persons) in plain areas and 200 families (roughly about 1,000 people) in hilly areas, Desert Development Programme (DDP) blocks, areas mentioned in Schedule V and Schedule VI of the Constitution of India.

4. Any involuntary resettlement should, as far as possible, be conceived and executed as a part of a development project or program and resettlement plans should be prepared with appropriate timebound actions and budgets. Resettlers should be provided sufficient resources and opportunities to reestablish their homes and livelihoods as soon as possible.

� �

According to the ADB’s IR policy full RP is required when 200 or more people will experience major impacts. A Short RP is required when resettlement is insignificant when less than 200 people will experience major impacts. According to the NRRP, RP should be prepared when it involves resettlement of more than 400 families (roughly about 2,500 persons) in plain areas and 250 families (roughly about 1,250 people) in hilly areas, Desert Development Programme (DDP) blocks, areas mentioned in Schedule V and Schedule VI of the Constitution of India.

The RF addresses the IR impacts. The entitlements to the APs are outlined in the Entitlement Matrix.

LAA does not provide for resettlement. However, it specifies the time limit for acquisition, though the project / program for which it is conceived need not necessarily be time-bound.

A time-bound action plan and implementation schedule for the IR activities is outlined. The key RP activities are identified and the responsibilities for the same outlined.

5. The affected people should be fully informed and closely consulted on resettlement and compensation options. Where adversely affected people are particularly vulnerable, resettlement and

� �

LAA recognizes only titleholders, who are to be notified prior to acquisition.

Consultations have been carried out with APs. This will be further consolidated by the RP

53



Policy

compensation decisions should be preceded by a social preparation phase to build up the capacity of the vulnerable people to deal with the issues.

implementing NGO. The plan for information disclosure in the project, including the RF.

6. Appropriate patterns of social organization should be promoted, and existing social and cultural institutions of resettlers and their hosts should be supported and used to the greatest extent possible. Resettlers should be integrated economically and socially into host communities so that adverse impacts on host communities are minimized. One of the effective ways of achieving this integration may be by extending development benefits to host communities.

� � -

This is addressed in the Entitlement Matrix.

7. The absence of formal legal title to land some affected groups should not be a bar to compensation. Affected persons entitled to compensation and rehabilitation should be identified and recorded as early as possible, preferably at the project identification stage, in order to prevent an influx of illegal encroachers, squatters, and other nonresidents who wish to take advantage of such benefits. Particular attention should be paid to the needs of the poorest affected persons including those without legal title to assets,, female-headed households and other vulnerable groups, such as indigenous peoples, and appropriate assistance provided to help them improve their status.

� �

LAA provides for every affected person to receive a notification prior to acquisition and for a hearing in case of any objection. Acquisition under the Act is permitted within one year from the date of declaration of intent to acquire, failing which, the process has to start again. LAA does not regard non-titleholders as APs. The Rajasthan Urban Housing and Habitat Policy, 2006 aims to provide tenurial rights to urban slum dwellers with special emphasis on persons belonging to scheduled castes, scheduled tribes, weaker sections, physically handicapped and widows. This is consistent with recognizing those without legal titles and the vulnerable.

The process for verification of impacts and establishing the eligibility of the APs is outlined in the RF.

8. The full costs of resettlement and compensation, including the costs of social preparation and livelihood programs as well as the incremental

� �

According to the ADB’s IR policy full RP is required when 200 or more people will experience major impacts. A Short RP is

The RF addresses the IR impacts. The entitlements to the APs are

54



Policy

benefits over the “without project” situation, should be included in the presentation of Project costs and benefits.

required when resettlement is insignificant when less than 200 people will experience major impacts. According to the NRRP, RP should be prepared when it involves resettlement of more than 500 families (roughly about 2,500 persons) in plain areas and 250 families (roughly about 1,250 people) in hilly areas, Desert Development Programme (DDP) blocks, areas mentioned in Schedule V and Schedule VI of the Constitution of India.

outlined in the Entitlement Matrix.

The NRRP’s concept of replacement cost is not clearly defined. However, the NRRP does consider various compensation packages to substitute the losses of APs.

This is addressed in the Entitlement Matrix

9. To better assure timely availability of required resources and to ensure compliance with involuntary resettlement procedures during implementation, eligible cots of resettlement and compensation may be considered for inclusion in Bank loan financing for the project, if requested.

� � -

The impacts have been assessed and RP costs according to the entitlement matrix have been worked out. These costs are included in the Project Costs.

55

Appendix 6

PUBLIC CONSULTATIONS

NAME OF THE SURVEYOR: Kalidatta Das, Govind Singh, Vikram Rathore

DATE OF SURVEY & CONSULTATION: June and July 2010

LOCATION ADDRESS: i) Fatehpur Road (as per Drawing in the DPR).

Mostly commercial area with couple of

Government and Private Offices. Volume of

traffic is quite heavy.

ii) Beed Road (From Palwas Road to Salasar

Road). Raiji ki Kuaa a historical site. Two

temples also there. Drain on one side of the

road and fallow land on the other. Sparsely

populated.

iii) Devipura Road (Ajmer Stand to Dujod Gate).

Commercial area. Residences behind shops

and establishments. From Dujod Gate to Pathan

Auto is residential area. Narrow kuttcha road

ISSUES DISCUSSED

1. Community’s perception on likely Strength and Weaknesses of the Sub-Project

(i) A better and widened road was considered to be the strength. But the same better

and widened road was considered as a threat to pedestrians if proper traffic

management was not imposed. Secondly, the respondents felt that unless inter-

departmental coordination was ensured, there might be disruption.

2. Community’s Perception on Likely Disturbances during Sub-Project Construction Work.

(i) The Respondents are aware that construction of road would create some disturbance;

but that is to be tolerated.

(ii) The affected persons said that they would either move to the edge of the ROW or to

some other suitable place so as not to create any hindrance in the work.

(iii) The affected persons said that they would relocate themselves according to their

convenience.

(iv) The affected persons said that since they are sitting on government land, they would

accept whatever assistance is given to them by government.

3. Anticipated Impacts on Livelihood due to Construction Work of the Sub-Project

(i) The affected persons anticipated limited impact as they would move out convenient

places to continue with their earning of livelihood.

(ii) Not willing to labor work as they have never done such work.

56

DETAILS OF PARTICIPANTS

Name Occupation

1. Rakesh Kumar Nayak Betel shop

2. Dillip Kumar Nayak Student

3. Lalchand Nayak Laborer

4. Bikash Kumar Nayak Laborer

5. Ram Chander Lakhad Business/ General Store

6. Kailash Saini Business/General Store

7. Babulal Saini Juice vendor

8. Shiv Bhagwan Saini Juice vendor

9. Satya Narayan Rana Business

10. Narendra Ram Service Provider (Tyre repair)

11. Suraj Sharma Business

12. Vikash Bhatt Service

13. Ajmal Khan Service

14. Tej Prakash Sharma Betel Shop

15. Ram Narayan Dikshit Betel Shop

16. Sandeep Tiwari Betel Shop

17. Vinod Sharma Betel Shop

18. Vijay Singh Fast Food Shop

19. Vijay Singh Tea Shop

20. Chittar Prakash Joshi Florist

21. Prakash Sharma Business (Stationery Shop)

22. Ashok Saini Business ( Cloth Shop)

23. Rajendra Kumar Service

24. Akash Bhatti Student

25. Manohar Joshi Student

26. Dillip Agarwal Business

27. Shyam Agarwal Business

57

PUBLIC CONSULTATIONS

NAME OF THE SURVEYOR: Kalidatta Das, Govind Singh, Vikram Rathore

DATE OF SURVEY & CONSULTATION: 08 – 12 April 2011

LOCATION ADDRESS: i) Fatehpur Road (as per Drawing in the DPR). Mostly commercial area with couple of Government and Private Offices. Volume of traffic is quite heavy.

ii) Beed Road (From Palwas Road to Salasar Road). Raiji ki Kuaa a historical site. Two temples also there. Drain on one side of the road and fallow land on the other. Sparsely populated.

iii) Devipura Road (Ajmer Stand to Dujod Gate). Commercial area. Residences behind shops and establishments. From Dujod Gate to Pathan Auto is residential area. Narrow kuttcha road.

iv) Station Road (Kalyan Circle to Ajmer Stand via Surajpole Gate upto Ghantaghar Chandpole). Mostly Commercial area. Initially the road is wide (14 mtrs) and subsequently narrows (10 mtrs). The traffic is quite heavy.

v) Salasar Road (near VikramSchool area). Residential area. The road width is mostly 7 mtrs.

ISSUES DISCUSSED


(ii) A better and widened road was considered to be the strength. But the same better

and widened road was considered as a threat to pedestrians if proper traffic

management was not imposed. Secondly, the respondents felt that unless inter-

departmental coordination was ensured, there might be disruption.


(i) The Respondents are aware that construction of road would create some disturbance;

but that is to be tolerated.

(ii) The affected persons said that they would either move to the edge of the ROW or to

some other suitable place so as not to create any hindrance in the work.

(v) The affected persons said that they would relocate themselves according to their

convenience.

(vi) The affected persons said that since they are sitting on government land, they would

accept whatever assistance is given to them by government.


(i) The affected persons anticipated limited impact as they would move out convenient places to continue with their earning of livelihood.

(ii) Not willing to labor work as they have never done such work.

58


Name Occupation

1. Rakesh Kumar Nayak Betel shop

2. Dillip Kumar Nayak Student

3. Lalchand Nayak Laborer

4. Bikash Kumar Nayak Laborer

5. Ram Chander Lakhad Business/ General Store

6. Kailash Saini Business/General Store

7. Babulal Saini Juice vendor

8. Shiv Bhagwan Saini Juice vendor

9. Satya Narayan Rana Business

10. Narendra Ram Service Provider (Tyre repair)

11. Suraj Sharma Business

12. Vikash Bhatt Service

13. Ajmal Khan Service

14. Tej Prakash Sharma Betel Shop

15. Ram Narayan Dikshit Betel Shop

16. Sandeep Tiwari Betel Shop

17. Vinod Sharma Betel Shop

18. Vijay Singh Fast Food Shop


20. Chittar Prakash Joshi Florist

21. Prakash Sharma Business (Stationery Shop)

22. Ashok Saini Business ( Cloth Shop)

23. Rajendra Kumar Service

24. Akash Bhatti Student

25. Manohar Joshi Student

26. Dillip Agarwal Business

27. Shyam Agarwal Business

28. Kalu Ram Saini Fruit Vendor

29. Farooque Vegetable Vendoor

30. Usman Gani Fruit Vendor

31. Sabir Ahmed Vegetable Vendor

32. Abid Vegetable Vendor

33. Nisar Fruit Vendor


35. Md. Islam Business

36. Amit Kumar Joshi Advocate

37. Bega Ram ji Business

38. Desh Raj Laborer

59

60

PUBLIC CONSULTATION (SIK/ST/02)

NAME OF THE SURVEYOR: Kalidatta Das, Vikram Rathore, Shaitan Singh

DATE OF SURVEY & CONSULTATION: 10.1.2012

LOCATION ADDRESS: Near Ajmer Bus Stand to Dujod Gate & Beed Road.


Sl.No Name of AP Occupation Devipura Road at Ajmer Bus Stand to Dujod Gate near Shitla Chouk.

1 Taj Parkash Sharma Betel shop 2 Ram Narayan Dikshit Betel shop 3 Sandeep Tiwari Betel shop 4 Vinod Sharma Betel shop 5 Vijay Singh Fast food & Tea shop 6 Chhitar Parkash Joshi Florist

Beed Road at Rai Ji Ka Kua

7 Narendra Ram Tyre repair



LOCATION ADDRESS: Station Road near Railway Station.


Sl.No Name of AP Occupation Station Road Near Railway Station

1 Srawan Kumar Tea Stall 2 Harish Kumar Dhirwani General Store 3 Chotu Ram General Store 4 Thakur Das General Store 5 Tulsi Ram Saini Chat Vendor 6 Uday Singh Chat Vendor 7 Mukesh Kumar Saini Chat Vendor 8 Puran Singh Egg. Vender 9 Hardev Yadav Tea Stall 10 Nishar Ahamad Fruit Vendor 11 Nemichand Chat Vendor 12 Mohamad Arif Fruit Vendor 13 Choti Devi Vegetable Vendor 14 Shanker Lal Jain Vegetable Vendor 15 Manohar Lal Saini Juice Center 16 Raju Juice Center 17 Dhana Ram Vegetable Vendor 18 Akhil Shah Chat Vendor 19 Abdul Kareem Fruit Vendor 20 Logama Chat Vendor 21 Sajjan Singh Chat Vendor

61

22 Parbhu Singh Chat Vendor 23 Bholu Saini Chat Vendor 24 Aladeen Gori Fruit Vendor 25 Lal Mohamad Fruit Vendor 26 Ameen Fruit Vendor 27 Abdul Razak Fruit Vendor 28 Lakha Raj Fast Food



LOCATION ADDRESS: Station Road near Janana Hospital.


Sl.No Name of AP Occupation Station Road near Janana Hospital

1 Anish Ahamed Readymade Clothes 2 Shah Nawas Readymade Clothes 3 Mohamad Sarfaz Chat Vendor 4 Babu Lal ICE Cream Vendor 5 Ravindra Kumar Readymade Clothes 6 Lal Chand Mesawani Sweetmeat 7 Ramkishan Jat ICE Cream Vendor 8 Ganpat Ram Jat ICE Cream Vendor 9 Bhajan Lal Kasab Chat Vendor 10 Imamudeen Fruit Vendor 11 Jagannath Choudhary ICE Cream Vendor 12 Jagdish Sharma/ Vashudev Bhargav Readymade Clothes 13 Vinod Saini/Narayan Saini Chat Vendor 14 Raju Susawah/Dhanna Rom Chat Vendor 15 Mohamad Ahashan Watch & Belt Shop



LOCATION ADDRESS: Station Road near Char Batti Jatiya Bazar & Head Post Office.


Sl.No Name of AP Occupation

Station Road near Char Batti Jatiya Bazar & Head Post Office 1 Abdullah Sattar Crockery 2 Jaffar Hussain Crockery 3 Shabber Ali Crockery 4 Shahrukha Crockery 5 Tahil Crockery 6 Badami Devi Vegetable Vendor

62

7 Mohamad Yonus Crockery 8 Mohamad Sariph Fruit Vendor 9 Juber Khan Fruit Vendor 10 Mohd. Jakeer Fruit Vendor 11 Mohd. Sattar Fruit Vendor 12 Mohamad Parik Fruit Vendor 13 Mohamad Jamil Fruit Vendor 14 Iqbal S/o allahdin Fruit Vendor 15 Parmanand Sindhi Vegetable Vendor 16 Muneer Mohd. Fruit Vendor 17 Pawan Kumar Vegetable Vendor 18 Narayan Das Vegetable Vendor 19 Mohd. Asif Fruit Vendor 20 Lal Chand Sindhi Vegetable Vendor 21 Tarun Rajwai Sindhi Vegetable Vendor 22 Mohamad Ameen Vegetable Vendor 23 Mohamad Saleem Fruit Vendor 24 Mohamad Tafik Vegetable Vendor 25 Mohamad Asif/Hussain Chanda Fruit Vendor



LOCATION ADDRESS: Station Road near Head Post Office.



Station Road near Head Post Office

1 Mohamad Arif Fruit Vendor 2 Sita Ram Juice Center 3 Rafik Vegetable Vendor 4 Mohamad Yusuf Fruit Vendor 5 Mohamad Ramjan Vegetable Vendor 6 Wasir Jamal Mali Fruit Vendor 7 Sajid Hussain Fruit Vendor 8 Mohamad Irfan Fruit Vendor 9 Mohamad Aslam Vegetable Vendor

10 Shokat Ali Fruit Vendor 11 Abdul Hameed Fruit Vendor 12 Iqbal Fruit Vendor 13 Mohamad Rafik Vegetable Vendor 14 Mohamad Sabir Fruit Vendor 15 Tayab Hussain Fruit Vendor

63



LOCATION ADDRESS: Station Road near Surajpole Gate.



Station Road near Surajpole Gate

1 Mohamad Arif Fruit Vendor 2 Mohamad Ameen Fruit Vendor 3 Imran Fruit Vendor 4 Hussain Fruit Vendor 5 Mohamad Arif Vegetable Vendor 6 Babu Fruit Vendor 7 Sareef Fruit Vendor 8 Kailash Chand Sindhi Vegetable Vendor 9 Pankeej Sindhi Vegetable Vendor

10 Puran Mail Vegetable Vendor 11 Bhanwar Lal Vegetable Vendor 12 Nagar Mali Saini Vegetable Vendor 13 Banwari Lal Vegetable Vendor 14 Baby Vegetable Vendor 15 Mani Devi Vegetable Vendor 16 Shakur Ganni Fruit Vendor 17 Banwari Lal Vegetable Vendor 18 Diya Bux Vegetable Vendor 19 Mohamad Hussain Fruit Vendor 20 Babu Paliwal Vegetable Vendor



LOCATION ADDRESS: Fatehpur Road


Sl.No Name of AP Occupation Fatehpur near Maru School to Collectorate via Tanki Stand,PWD Dak Banglow,

Sainik Kalyan Office etc.

1 Rakesh Kumar Nayak Cold drinks shop 2 Satish Kumar Nayak Tea Stall 3 Ramswroop Shansi Cobbler 4 Bri Mohan Jat Tea Stall 5 Shohan Lal Saini Tea Stall 6 Mulchand Saini Vegetables and Fruit shop 7 Ummerdi Vegetable Vendor 8 Latif Gulam Fruit Vendor 9 Makhan Lal Saini Fruit Vendor 10 Shishpal Fruit Vendor 11 Devi Lal Choudhary ICE Cream Vendor 12 Abdul Sattar Vegetable Vendor 13 Sakur Sarif Fruit Vendor 14 Budharam Nayak Fruit Vendor

64

Sl.No Name of AP Occupation Fatehpur near Maru School to Collectorate via Tanki Stand,PWD Dak Banglow,

Sainik Kalyan Office etc.

15 Mohan Nayak Fruit Vendor 16 Jawed Ali/ Jaffar Hussen Fruit Vendor 17 Musalim Ali Fruit Vendor 18 Sundar Nayak Fruit Vendor 19 Imran Vegetable Vendor 20 Saddam Hussen Fruit Vendor 21 Salim Fruit Vendor 22 Jawed Ali Fruit Vendor 23 Mohamd Ramjan Fruit Vendor 24 Mohamd Rafeek Fruit Vendor 25 Addil Fruit Vendor 26 Mohamd Ramjan Fruit Vendor 27 Anil Fruit Vendor 28 Bajrang Singh Readymade Clothes 29 Mohand Khan Fruit Vendor 30 Rahim Fruit Vendor 31 Raju Nayak Belt Shop 32 Subhash Barwar Vegetable Vendor 33 Babu Lal Saini Juice Center 34 Faruk Sultan Fruit Vendor 35 Indra Kumar Soni Chat Vendor 36 Tofik Khan Peanuts Vendor 37 Mohamd Rafik/ Ramjan Fruit Vendor 38 Mohd. Iqbal S/o Sultan Fruit Vendor 39 Mohd. Rafeek S/o Sultan Fruit Vendor 40 Mohmad Faruk S/o Sultan Fruit Vendor 41 Mohd. Babu S/o Sultan Fruit Vendor 42 Sona Ram S/o Saitan Ram Blacksmith 43 Iqbal S/o Jammal Fruit Vendor 44 Mamraj Sharma Tea Stall 45 Jawed Ali Toy 46 Mool Chand Saini Vegetable Vendor 47 Barijmohan Tea Stall 48 Rajesh Kumar Vegetable Vendor 49 Kalu Ram Luhar Blacksmith 50 Banwari Ram Luhar Blacksmith 51 Narhar Mal Saini Vegetable Vendor 52 Tayub Ali Vegetable Vendor

ISSUES DISCUSSED: The public in general were informed about the (i) ADB supported Program,(ii) Outline and components of the Sub-Project, (iii) Safeguards, (iv) Resettlement Framework and (v) Entitlements.


(i) A better and widened road was considered to be the strength. But the same better and widened road was considered as a threat to pedestrians if proper traffic management was not imposed. Secondly, the respondents felt that unless inter-departmental coordination was ensured, there might be disruption.

65


(i) The Respondents are aware that construction of road would create some disturbance; but that is to be tolerated.

(ii) The affected persons said that they would either move to the edge of the ROW or to some other suitable place so as not to create any hindrance in the work.

(iii) The affected persons said that they would relocate themselves according to their convenience.

(iv) The affected persons said that since they are sitting on government land, they would accept whatever assistance is given to them by government.


(i) The affected persons anticipated limited impact as they would move out convenient places to continue with their earning of livelihood.

Not willing to work as laborer as they have never done such work.

66

Consultation with APs Near Railway station (St-02)

Consultation with APs Near Railway station (ST-02)

67

PUBLIC CONSULTATION SIK/ST/05

NAME OF THE SURVEYOR: Kalidatta Das, Shaitan Singh, Mukesh Jangir


LOCATION ADDRESS: Tehsil Office to District Collectorate Office

Sl.No Name of the AP Occupation 01 Harish Kumar Readymade clothes 02 Manoj Kumar Readymade clothes 03 Raj Kumar Readymade clothes 04 Sharwan Kumar Meena Tea Stall 05 Saleem Ahmed Fruits 06 Harun Fruits 07 Isuaq Fruits 08 Irfan Khan Fruits 09 Mohamd Ayub Khan Fruits 10 Nisar Ahmmed Fruits 11 Rajendra Singh Cosmetic 12 Muslim Khan Cosmetic 13 Mohamd Jakir Cosmetic 14 Dharmveer Chat 15 Iliyas Khan Cosmetic 16 Mohamd Rabbani Cosmetic

NAME OF THE SURVEYOR: Kalidatta Das, Shaitan Singh, Mukesh Kumar Sharma


LOCATION ADDRESS: Fatehpur road to Buchyani via Bakra Mandi Road & Mohalla Khatikan


1 Syamshad Tailor Vegetable

2 Ajay Singh Chat

3 Shokat Ali Gen & Item

4 Rajesh Saini Chat

68

NAME OF THE SURVEYOR: Kalidatta Das, Shaitan Singh, Rahul Prajapat


LOCATION ADDRESS: Chokdi ka bhawan to Deen Mohd. road via Islamiya School.

Sl.No Name of AP Occupation 1 Gopi Chand Nayak Chat

NAME OF THE SURVEYOR: Kalidatta Das, Shaitan Singh, Rajendra Siyag


LOCATION ADDRESS: Shanitar Mandir to Gayatri Mandir via Kumharo Ka Mohallaha Nageshwar Bagichi , Maru Balika School.


1 Sugan Sani Chat 2 Asif Ali Chat 3 Kalu Ram Moyal Tailor

NAME OF THE SURVEYOR: Kalidatta Das, Shaitan Singh, Mukesh Kumar Jangir


LOCATION ADDRESS: Lakshmi Market to S.K College via Saini Dharmshala.


1 Lalu Prasad Gen & Item

NAME OF THE SURVEYOR: Kalidatta Das, Shaitan Singh, Mukesh Sharma


LOCATION ADDRESS: Sharamdan Marg & Road behind Hospital.


1 Moti Lal Saini Pan Pekec

2 Sita Ram Saini Fruits

3 Balbeer Meel Juice

4 Dhanvantri Choudhary Juice

5 Balu Ram Jeenwas Tea Stall

6 Sharwan Ram Tea Stall

69


7 Matadeen Sharma Tea Stall

8 Dhura Ram Choudary Tea Stall

9 Sunil Sharma Tea Stall

10 Bhagirath Mal Jakher Tea Stall

11 Ramuram Mawaliya Tea Stall

12 Bhadu Ram Gurjar Tea Stall

13 Harful Ram Tea Stall

14 Mukund Ram Tea Stall



LOCATION ADDRESS: Silver Jubli Road Dhanvantri to R.T.O till bypass.

Sl.No Name of AP Occupation 1 Narotam Saini Chat 2 Fool Chand Saini Tea Stall 3 Sanwar Mal Saini Gen & Item 4 Girdhari Lal Tea Stall 5 Parbhu Dayal Chat 6 Mahendra Juice 7 Veeru Bhaiyaa Chat 8 Ashok Chat 9 Ramdev Tea Stall 10 Omprakash Tea Stall 11 Govind Ram Saini Chat 12 Dasurath Meena Chat 13 Anurag Chat 14 Ramdhan Fruits 15 Gopal Saini Fruits 16 Dipak Kumar Chat 17 Dhanraj Sharma Tea Stall 18 Tara Chand Barber 19 Sita Ram Fruits 20 Shokat Ali Khatri General Store 21 Ramzan Khatri General Store 22 Surendra Saini Fruits 23 Suresh Sani Tea Stall

70



LOCATION ADDRESS: Sheetla chowk to Ranisati Mandir Road.

Sl.No Name of AP Occupation 1 Mukedh Tiwari Genral store 2 Sandeep Tiwari Pan 3 Manoj Sharma Chat



LOCATION ADDRESS: Durga Colony, Jiya Colony, Shekhawat Colony.


1 Suta Ram Rathore Vegetable



LOCATION ADDRESS: From Mohallah Narvan to Nehru Park via Swamiyan.


1 Natyu Ram General store



LOCATION ADDRESS: From Asrar House to Fatehpur Road via Roshangunj Masjid.


1 Abdy Kaadir General store

71



LOCATION ADDRESS: From Police Line to Purohit Ji Ki Dhani.


1 Kulda Ram Saini Pan Pal. 2 Birju Saini Tea Stall 3 Kamal Kumar Barber 4 Rameshwar Lal Vegetable 5 Ghanshyam Ram Barber 6 Jagdish Saini Genral store 7 Babulal Saini Tea Stall 8 Madan Lal Tea Stall 9 Mahaveer Parsad Genral store



LOCATION ADDRESS: From Saini Dharamshala to Prem Ji Saini Ki Gali.


1 Raju Yadav Chat 2 Mahesh Sahy Chat 3 Manohar Lal Vegetable 4 Maqsud Taili Fruits 5 Prakash Tea Stall



LOCATION ADDRESS: Housing Board Zone.


1 Raju Gawariya Tea & Veg.

2 Bairang Lal Chubi Dhobi

72

ISSUES DISCUSSED: The public in general were informed about the (i) ADB supported Program, (ii) Outline and components of the Sub-Project, (iii) Safeguards, (iv) Resettlement Framework and (v) Entitlements.

Reaction of the Community/APs

• An improved road with side drain was considered by the people to be the strength of the project. They felt that improvement of road and side drains was a long felt need. They felt that the work should be completed within a reasonable time. Otherwise delay will be the weakness of the project.

• The Respondents are aware that construction of road would create some disturbance; but that is to be tolerated.

• The affected persons said that they would either move to the edge of the ROW or to some other suitable place so as not to create any hindrance in the work

• The affected persons said that they would relocate themselves according to their convenience.

• The affected persons said that since they are sitting on government land, they would accept whatever assistance is given to them by government.

• The affected persons anticipated limited impact as they would move out to convenient places to continue with their earning of livelihood.

• They showed no interest to work as laborers as they have never done such work.

73

COSULTATION WITH APS (ST-02 & ST-03)

Silver Jubli road to RTO till bypaas (ST-03) Laxmi Market to S.K.College via Saini

Dharmshala (ST-03)

Shitla chouk to Rani SatiRoad (ST-03) Consultation with APs at Shitla chouk to

Rani Sati Road (ST-03)

Tahsil to collectorate road (ST-03)

74

Shramdan marg behind hospital (ST-03) Road

no-7 Laxmi market to S.K. College via Saini

Dharmshala(ST-03) RoadNo-6

Dhanvantri to RTO by Pass (ST-03)

Road no-8 Police Line to purohit ji ki Dhani (ST-03) Road

No-17

Dhanvantri to RTO by Pass (ST-03) Road no-8

Shitla chowk to Rani sati mandir (ST-03) Road no-9

75

Near railway station (ST-02) Near headpost office (ST-02

Near janana hospital (ST-02 Near char Batti Jatia Bazar(St-02

76

PUBLIC CONSULTATION SIK/ST/04



LOCATION ADDRESS: RICCO Mode.

Sl.No Name of the Person Occupation Mr. Sagarmal Saini Tea Mr. Niwas Saini Tea Mr. Pintu Saini Tyre Repairing Mr. Akhtar Khan Car Decorator Mr. Suresh Saini Fast Food Mr. Ragveer Singh Chat



LOCATION ADDRESS: Krishi Mandi (Gate No.1).

Sl.No Name of the Person Occupation

Mr. Sohan Lal Saini Fruit Shop Mr. Manoj Sen Barber Mr. Sanwar Mal Gurgel Tea Shop Mr. Khem Chand Saini Tea Shop Mr. Gopal Ram Jat Tea Shop Mr. Gordhan Ram Jat Fruit Shop Mr. Kalash Kumar Balai Fruit Shop Mr. Banwari Lal Siani Vegetable Shop

ISSUES DISCUSSED: The public in general were informed about the (i) ADB supported Program, (ii) Outline and components of the Sub-Project, (iii) Safeguards, (iv) Resettlement Framework and (v) Entitlements.

Reaction of the Community/APs

• An improved road with side drain was considered by the people to be the strength of the project. They felt that improvement of road and side drains was a long felt need. They felt that the work should be completed within a reasonable time. Otherwise delay will be the weakness of the project.

• The Respondents are aware that construction of road would create some disturbance; but that is to be tolerated.

• The affected persons said that they would either move to the edge of the ROW or to some other suitable place so as not to create any hindrance in the work

• The affected persons said that they would relocate themselves according to their convenience.

• The affected persons said that since they are sitting on government land, they would accept whatever assistance is given to them by government.

• The affected persons anticipated limited impact as they would move out to convenient places to continue with their earning of livelihood.

77

• They showed no interest to work as laborers as they have never done such work.

Consultation With APs, Krishi Mandi Gate no-1

Consultation With AP, RICCO Mode

Consultation With AP, RICCO Mode

Consultation with Hawkers/Venders on 29.5.2014

Consultations were held with the hawkers and venders located between Salasar Stand to

the junction of the Municipal Council Office. They categorically said that construction of the

road was done after business hours; the work was undertaken overnight; and the work was

completed the next day before the business time started. There was no loss in their income.

And for that they do not need any compensation.

Their statement may be seen in the Appendix 9

78

Appendix 7

CONSULTATION AND DISCLOSURE

A. Consultation

1. Consultations will be held with special emphasis on vulnerable groups. Encouraging public participation in consultations informs the public of the Program and serves as a venue for the public to express their opinion on priorities which the Program should address.

2. The key stakeholders to be consulted during Resettlement Plan implementation

and Program implementation includes: (i) all affected persons, including vulnerable households; (ii) program beneficiaries; (iii) host populations in resettlement sites; (iv) elected representatives, community leaders, and representatives of

community-based organizations; (v) local NGOs; (vi) local government and relevant government agency representatives; and (vii) Program staff, IPMU, IPIU, and consultants.

3. Consultations conducted during Resettlement Plan implementation will identify

help required by affected persons during rehabilitation. Continuing involvement of those affected by sub-projects is necessary in the resettlement process. The IPIU will ensure that affected persons and other stakeholders are informed and consulted about the sub-project, its impact, their entitlements and options, and allowed to participate actively in the development of the sub-project. This will be done particularly in the case of vulnerable APs, who will be encouraged to choose options that entail the lowest risk. This exercise will be conducted throughout the sub-project—during preparation, implementation, and monitoring of sub-project results and impacts.

4. The implementing NGOs will ensure that views of affected persons, particularly

those who are vulnerable, related to the resettlement process are looked into and addressed. The NGOs will ensure that APs consulted are informed of the outcome of the decision-making process, and will confirm how their views were incorporated. Since resettlement is a continuous process and baseline data/information will be collected, the implementing NGO will regularly update the baseline information.

B. Disclosure

5. Information was and continues to be disseminated to affected persons for the sample sub-projects. Finalized Resettlement Plans will be disclosed in ADB’s website, IPMU websites, and IPIU or town websites; and information dissemination and consultation will continue throughout program implementation.

6. The IPIU SDS will conduct consultations and disseminate information to all

affected persons. Resettlement Plans will be translated into the local language and made available at offices of the: (i) Urban Local Bodies (ULBs); (ii) relevant local government line agencies; and (iii) IPMU and IPIUs. RPs will also be kept in the public libraries, accessible to citizens as a means to disclose the document and at the same time creating wider public awareness.

79

7. The Resettlement Framework and Resettlement Plans will be disclosed in the following websites: IPMU, IPIU, State Government, local governments, and ADB. The IPMU will issue notification of implementation start dates for each sub-project. The notice will be issued by the IPMU in local newspapers one month ahead of implementation. This will create awareness of project implementation. The IPMU and IPIUs will provide information on Involuntary Resettlement policies and features of the Resettlement Plan. Basic information such as sub-project location, impact estimates, entitlements, and implementation schedule will be presented in the form of a brochure that will be circulated among affected persons. Posters containing basic Resettlement Plan information will also be posted in different localities to increase awareness. Copies of Resettlement Plan summaries will be kept in the IPMU and IPIU offices and will be distributed to any affected person consulting on resettlement issues. The Resettlement Framework will be made available in local language during public meetings. This will enable stakeholders to provide inputs on the resettlement process, prior to award of civil work contracts.

8. An intensive information dissemination campaign for affected persons will be

conducted by the IPIU with assistance from the implementing NGO at the outset of Resettlement Plan implementation. All the comments made by the affected persons will be documented in the sub-project records and summarized in sub-project monitoring reports. A summary of consultation and disclosure activities to be followed for each sub-project are in Table 1.

Table: Consultation and Disclosure Activities

Program Phase Activities Details Responsible Agency

Investment Program Bridging Phase

Mapping of the Program areas

Area to be mapped, clearly showing survey numbers of titleholders of land/property proposed for acquisition

IPMU in coordination with DC’s offices and other local bodies.

Stakeholder identification Cross section of stakeholders to be identified in order to facilitate their participation in the Program.

IPMU and IPIUs in consultation with stakeholders.

Program/sub-project information dissemination; Disclosure of proposed land acquisition

Leaflets containing information on the Program and sub-project to be prepared. Public notice issued in local newspapers (and disclosed on IPMU/IPIU websites) including survey numbers and names of titleholders for land to be acquired concurrent with consultation with titleholders.

SDS and RS from IPMU. IPMU may seek the assistance of CAAP consultants for leaflet preparation. Notice will be issued from the DC’s office. SDS IPMU and SDS IPIU to disclose on the web.

Stakeholder consultations Further consultations with affected titleholders and households. Consultations with non-titled APs and other stakeholders during sub-project scoping.

SDS IPIU and NGO.

RP Preparation Phase

SIA surveys Surveys to be conducted. Summary RF to be disclosed in local language though printed materials to APs particularly those who are vulnerable and other stakeholders.

IPIU to conduct surveys. SDS IPIU to disclose RF to stakeholders (including making it available in IPMU/IPIU offices and government agency offices), SDS IPMU to disclose on the web.

Formulating compensation and resettlement assistance measures

Conducting stakeholder consultations particularly APs in and reflecting issues raised in revised RP.

SDS IPIU and NGO.

80

Program Phase Activities Details Responsible Agency

Disclosure of final entitlements and rehabilitation packages

Provision of RPs to all stakeholders particularly APs. Conducting consultations and distributing local language versions of the summary RP.

SDS IPMU, and SDS IPIU to disclose on the web. SDS IPIU and NGO to conduct consultations.

RP Implementation Stage

Disclosure of RP Review and approval of RP by EA. Review and approval of RP by ADB. Web disclosure of the RP.

EA to provide ADB with RP for review and approval. SDS IPMU, and SDS IPIU to disclose on the web.

Consultation with APs during RP implementation

Consultations with APs. NGO with monitoring from IPIU and external agency.

ADB= Asian Development Bank, IPIU = Investment Program Implementation Unit, IPMU = Investment Program Management Unit, NGO = Nongovernmental Organization, SIA = Social Impact Assessment

81

APPENDIX-8A

Proceedings of the Meeting of the CLC dated 22.10.2011

82

83

84

85

Decision Taken

In the CLC Meeting held on 22.10.2011, it has been decided that land belonging to Sainik Kalyan Board (165 sqm), AVVNL (150 sqm), PWD Dak bungalow (834 sqm), PWD Office (198 sqm) and Gausala will be made available to RUIDP by the District Administration in collaboration with the Municipal Council.

86

APPENDIX 8 B

LAND DONATION/VOLUNTEER LAND FOR PROJECT BENEFIT

Letter of Sree Gopinath Gausala for Donation of Land.

Translation of letter from General Secretary Gausala

To

IPIU, Sikar

It is submitted that as per the map given by you, the land of gopinath gausala is being handed over 2152 sqm land (as decided by Gopinath Gausala commeetee) without any conditions (Voluntarily) for development of road from Raji ka kua to Shastri Nagar Moure. We don’t have any objection on utilization of this land for road extension and development work.

General Secretary

Gopinath Gausala

87

APPENDIX 8 C

NOC from ZilaSainik Welfare Board

Translation of letter from ZilaSainik Welfare Board To IPIU, Sikar Sub: - up-gradation and beautification of the road infront of Dak Bangla The copy of NOC of the Director ZilaSainik Welfare Board vide letter no. 7552-53 dated 06.08.2012 is enclosed for your reference and further action.

Officer ZilaSainik Welfare Board

88

APPENDIX-9

CERTIFICATES OF MITIGATION OF IMPACT ON 17 APS (WORK WAS COMPLETED IN NIGHT)

I Surendra Saini S/o Bihari Lal Sainihaving business of Vegitable (Mobile Vendor)hereby certify that the work carried out by RUIDP Sikar in Salasar Bus Stand to Nagar Parishad Office till the Choraha area was done after the business hours on 25.10.2013 (after 8 PM) and the work was completed well before the commencing of business hours on the next day.

This work excuted has not affected my livelihood and I won’t claim any compensation in future from RUIDP.

89

I Iqbal s/o Mohd. Sajid having business of Fruit (Mobile Vendor) hereby certify that the work carried out by RUIDP Sikar in Salasar Bus Stand to Nagar Parishad Office till the Choraha area was done after the business hours on 25.10.2013 (after 8 PM ) and the work was completed well before the commencing of business hours on the next day.


90

I Abdul Kayum s/o Abdul Sattar having business of Fruit (Mobile Vendor) hereby certify that the work carried out by RUIDP Sikar in Salasar Bus Stand to Nagar Parishad Office till the Choraha area was done after the business hours on 25.10.2013 (after 8 PM ) and the work was completed well before the commencing of business hours on the next day.


91

I Mohamad Shabir s/o Nasir Ahmad having business of Fruit (Mobile Vendor) hereby certify that the work carried out by RUIDP Sikar in Salasar Bus Stand to Nagar Parishad Office till the Choraha area was done after the business hours on 25.10.2013 (after 8 PM ) and the work was completed well before the commencing of business hours on the next day.


92

I Ramavtar Saini s/o Anandi Lal having business of Vegitable (Mobile Vendor) hereby certify that the work carried out by RUIDP Sikar in Salasar Bus Stand to Nagar Parishad Office till the Choraha area was done after the business hours on 25.10.2013 (after 8 PM ) and the work was completed well before the commencing of business hours on the next day.


93

I Sumshu Deen s/o Noor Mohamad having business of Fruit (Mobile Vendor) hereby certify that the work carried out by RUIDP Sikar in Salasar Bus Stand to Nagar Parishad Office till the Choraha area was done after the business hours on 25.10.2013 (after 8 PM ) and the work was completed well before the commencing of business hours on the next day.


94

I Ram Singh Luhar s/o Bagdaya Ram having business of Knife/ other kitchen utensils Vendor (Mobile Vendor) hereby certify that the work carried out by RUIDP Sikar in Salasar Bus Stand to Nagar Parishad Office till the Choraha area was done after the business hours on 25.10.2013 (after 8 PM ) and the work was completed well before the commencing of business hours on the next day.


95

I Kailash Saini s/o Nanak Ram Saini having business of Vegetable and Fruit (Mobile Vendor) hereby certify that the work carried out by RUIDP Sikar in Salasar Bus Stand to Nagar Parishad Office till the Choraha area was done after the business hours on 25.10.2013 (after 8 PM ) and the work was completed well before the commencing of business hours on the next day.


96

I Mange Lal Saini s/o Mahaveer Prasad Saini having business of Fruit (Mobile Vendor) hereby certify that the work carried out by RUIDP Sikar in Salasar Bus Stand to Nagar Parishad Office till the Choraha area was done after the business hours on 25.10.2013 (after 8 PM ) and the work was completed well before the commencing of business hours on the next day.


97

I Ram Sahai s/o Harprasad Kushwaha having business of Ready Food – Junk Food (Mobile Vendor) hereby certify that the work carried out by RUIDP Sikar in Salasar Bus Stand to Nagar Parishad Office till the Choraha area was done after the business hours on 25.10.2013 (after 8 PM ) and the work was completed well before the commencing of business hours on the next day.


98

I Vinod Kumar Sharma s/o Radha Krishna Sharma having business of Vegetables (Mobile Vendor) hereby certify that the work carried out by RUIDP Sikar in Salasar Bus Stand to Nagar Parishad Office till the Choraha area was done after the business hours on 25.10.2013 (after 8 PM ) and the work was completed well before the commencing of business hours on the next day.


99

I Bihari Lal Saini s/o Anandi Lal Saini having business of Fruit (Mobile Vendor) hereby certify that the work carried out by RUIDP Sikar in Salasar Bus Stand to Nagar Parishad Office till the Choraha area was done after the business hours on 25.10.2013 (after 8 PM ) and the work was completed well before the commencing of business hours on the next day.


100

I Manoj Singh s/o Durga Singh having business of Fruit (Mobile Vendor) hereby certify that the work carried out by RUIDP Sikar in Salasar Bus Stand to Nagar Parishad Office till the Choraha area was done after the business hours on 25.10.2013 (after 8 PM ) and the work was completed well before the commencing of business hours on the next day.


101

I Suresh Chodhary s/o Chagan Lal Chodhary having business of Ice Cream (Mobile Vendor) hereby certify that the work carried out by RUIDP Sikar in Salasar Bus Stand to Nagar Parishad Office till the Choraha area was done after the business hours on 25.10.2013 (after 8 PM ) and the work was completed well before the commencing of business hours on the next day.


102

I Pooran Mal Saini s/o Bhiwa Ram having business of Tea (Mobile Vendor) hereby certify that the work carried out by RUIDP Sikar in Salasar Bus Stand to Nagar Parishad Office till the Choraha area was done after the business hours on 25.10.2013 (after 8 PM ) and the work was completed well before the commencing of business hours on the next day.


103

Specimen / English Translation of Certficate for no claim

Certificat

I Ajmer Khan s/o Ramjan Khan having business of Redemade Cloth Mobile Vendor hereby certify that the work carried out by RUIDP Sikar in Salasar Bus Stand to Nagar Parishad Office till the Choraha area was done after the business hours on 25.10.2013 (After 8 PM) and the work was completed well before the commencing of business hours on the next day.


104

Specimen / English Translation of Certficate for no claim

Certificat

I Aarifs/o Jakirhaving business of General Goods (Mobile Vendor)hereby certify that the work carried out by RUIDP Sikar in Salasar Bus Stand to Nagar Parishad Office till the Chorahaarea was done after the business hours on 25.10.2013 (after 8 PM ) and the work was completed well before the commencing of business hours on the next day.

This work excuted has not affected my livelihood and I won’t claim any compensation in

future from RUIDP.

105

APPENDIX-10

CERTIFICATE GIVEN BY WARD PARSHAD (ELECTED REPRESENTATIVE) ABOUT MISSING AFFECTED PERSON

106

Certificate Given by Ward Parshad (Elected Representative) about Missing Affected Person

107


108


109


110


111


112


113


114


115


116


117


118


119


120


121


122


123


124


125


126


127


128


129


130


131


132


133


134


135



136

English Translation

This is certified that , visit was done to the Station Road under RUIDP Package ST -05 Today i.e. 02.07.2014, enquiryregarding AP Mr Iqbal s/o Alladeenwas done as this AP is not tracable from long time. It was told by people that there are two Iqbal, out of which one is already paid under RUIDP but the other person is fruit vendor doing business on Surajpole Gate to Amer Stand road. Discussion were also done with this person and he has clarified that he is doing business in this area i.e Surajpole Gate to Amer Stand road from last 10 years but since this area is not under RUIDP he is not the person and he has never carried out his business in RUIDP road area and never suffered loss due to RUIDP work

Ward Parshad

137


138


139

APPENDIX-11

CERTIFICATE GIVEN BY WARD PARSHAD (ELECTED REPRESENTATIVE) REGARDING REFUSAL OF AP

English Translation

This is certified that , visit was done to the Vande Matram Choraha under RUIDP Package ST -05 Today i.e. 28.06.2014, discussions with AP Mr. Dashrath Meena was again done and he was told to give required documents. Which he refused as he has done in past and also refused to take any compensation.

Ward Parshad

140

Certificate Given by Ward Parshad (Elected Representative) regarding refusal of AP for providing documents / taking compensation

English Translation

This is certified that , visit was done to the Shram Dan Marg under RUIDP Package ST -05 Today i.e. 28.06.2014, Thadi of Mr. Balbeer Meal was also visited. The thadi is being run by the representative of Balbeer, the representative refused to give documents required for compensation. In past also Mr. Balbeer has been contacted over telephone but he has refused to provide any documentation.

Ward Parshad

141


English Translation This is certified that , visit was done to the Shram Dan Marg under RUIDP Package ST -05 Today i.e. 28.06.2014, discussions with AP Mr. Sitaram Saini was again done who is refusing to give the documents required for compensation. He was once again explained about the compensation being provided and for compensation an ID card needs to be issued which require few document. The AP once again refused to give the documents and did not agreed for signing any document.

Ward Parshad

142


English Translation

This is certified that , visit was done to the Shram Dan Marg under RUIDP Package ST -05 Today i.e. 28.06.2014, discussions with AP Mr. Moti Lal was again done who is refusing to give the documents required for compensation. Mr Moti Lal conveyed that he will not give any documents and he is not going to take any compensation. He further added that he believes in self labour and earning. The AP refused to sign any document.

Ward Parshad

143


English Translation

This is certified that , visit was done to the Shram Dan Marg under RUIDP Package ST -05 Today i.e. 28.06.2014, discussions with AP Ms Dhanwantari Chodhary having a Juice Center and she, refused to give document and also rufesed for compensation.

Ward Parshad

144

APPENDIX-12

CERTIFICATE GIVEN BY WARD PARSHAD (ELECTED REPRESENTATIVE) REGARDING DEATH OF AP

English Translation

This is certified that , visit was done to the Station Road under RUIDP Package ST -05 Today i.e. 03.07.2014, enquiry regarding AP Mr Ramjan Khatrihad been running a general store, considered as a AP and was not tracable from last 3 years.

It was told by his brother Shaukat Ali that Mr. Ramjan has died around 3 years back and no one from the family is doing any business from this area.

Ward Parshad

145

Certificate Given by Ward Parshad (Elected Representative) regarding Death of AP and refusal of AP for providing documents / taking compensation

English Translation

This is certified that , visit was done to the char batti Zaria Bazar under RUIDP Package ST -02 Today i.e. 26.06.2014, enquiry regarding AP Mr Jaffar Husen was done as this AP is not tracable from long time.

It was revealed that Mr. Jaffar has died 8-10 year back and his son was running a grocery shop from this location. When the discussion was done with his son (inpresence of public), he straightforward refused to give documents for compensation and clarified that he is not interested to take any compensation. He also refused to give sign on any paper.

Ward Parshad

146

THE SCHEDULE FOR RESETTLEMENT PLAN

S.

No

Short resettlement Plan for

Start dates of public consultation/dissemination of information

Start dates of RP disclosure to the entitled APs

Close dates of public consultation/dissemination of information

1 Sikar Roads

(RUSDIP/TR-02/SKR/ST/01)

Retendered as (RUSDIP/TR-02/SKR/ST/02)

June, July 2010, April 2011 & Jan 2012

Within 15 days after approval

(RUSDIP/TR-02/SKR/ST/03)

Retendered as (RUSDIP/TR-02/SKR/ST/05)

Jan 2012 Within 15 days after approval

RUSDIP/TR-02/SKR/ST/04)

April 2012 Within 15 days after approval

2. Authors name: DSC II

3. Consultant Firm name: M/s SNC Lavalin.

4. Government ministry: Rajasthan Urban Infrastructure development Project (RUIDP).

Resettlement Planning Document - Asian Development Bank

Documents