23
Chapter IINTRODUCTIONBackground of the Study Due to increase in
knowledge regarding new methods of protecting plants from pests and
enhancement of plant nutrition, people have overlooked the possible
results that may lead to even more disastrous outcomes such as
infertility of soil.Soil contaminated with pesticide decreases the
soils fertility. It also decreases the biodiversity in the soil for
the pesticide not only kills the intended pests, but also the other
organisms living there. Bodies of water near agricultural fields
are contaminated because of runoffs which causes widespread
pollution in the area. Pesticide disrupts the plants cycle, making
it become more dependent on the chemicals provided by the
pesticide. Crops absorb the pesticide and the toxins are being
distributed to the plant cells therefore making it toxic and unsafe
to eat. People, especially children, who consume these infected
plants, are put at a vulnerable state for acquiring diseases. Thus,
humans required nourishment and soil fertility are compromised
(Dudeja and Singh, 2008).Mycoremediation is a form of
bioremediation that enlists the biological activity of fungi to
restore polluted environments to a less polluted state (Singh,
2006). The term 'mycoremediation' was coined by mycologist Paul
Stamets and relates specifically to the ecological functionality of
fungal mycelium rather than 'mushrooms' which are the fruiting
bodies of the mycelium. Bioremediation has been common practice for
a very long time, and can be traced back as far as 600bc when the
Romans used bacteria to treat their waste water (Singh, 2006).
Mycoremediation is however a younger branch of the science of
bioremediation and has only been practiced since the beginning of
the 20th century. There is a lack of fundamental knowledge within
the field which has translated to slow advancement of the science
(Sasek, 2003).Working with fungi can lead to hastened process of
soil recovery. The natural behavior of some fungi to work within
and support a larger community of organisms seems to be the key
part of their role. Fungi with known abilities in breaking down
complex plant cell structures, the lignin decomposing (white-rot)
Basidiomycotina, have been the primary case studies thus far in
mycoremediation, but a much wider array of soil borne fungi and
endophytes with lesser understood natural roles are becoming more
important subjects of inquiry. (Potera, Carol)Since the role of
fungi in the environment is widely recognized, the researchers have
inferred that fungi species found in mangrove areas are possible
species that can be used in remediating soil contaminated with
pesticide because there are already several fungi species that were
identified to have successfully remediated pollutants. The present
study was therefore, designed to evaluate the mycoremediation
potential of endophytic fungi on Chlorpyrifos.Statement of the
Problems This study aimed to assess the mycoremediation potential
on the pesticide chlorpyrifos of fungal isolates from mangrove
areas in Sagay, Camarines Sur. It also aims to answer the following
questions:1. Was there any growth of fungi observed upon applying
them with the pesticide (5 ml, 10 ml, and 15 ml)?2. Did the three
endophytic fungi show a change in its color and in its medias
color?Statement of the HypothesesFor the main problem:H:Fungal
isolatestaken from mangrove areas cannot be used on the
mycoremediation of pesticide.H:Fungal isolates taken from mangrove
areas can be used on the mycoremediation of pesticide.Based on the
two specific problems, four hypotheses were stated.H1: There was no
growth of fungi observed after the pesticide of 15 ml was applied
with fungi.Ha1: There was fungi growth observed after the pesticide
of 5 ml was applied with fungi.H2: The three endophytic fungi did
not show a change in its color and in its medias.H2: The three
endophytic fungi showed a change in its color and in its medias
color.
Significance of the StudyAgricultural FieldsMaintaining soil
fertility is an important factor in agricultural fields for soil
plays a vital role in promoting plant growth. Since most fields are
being contaminated with pesticide, the researchers have sought of a
method to lessen the toxicity of the soil by degrading the
pesticide. Since Brodan, which contains chlorpyrifos is one of the
most common pesticides used; the researchers may help farmers in
lessening the pesticide in their soil.Departments and Agencies in
the Philippines which focus on AgricultureDifferent agricultural
agencies such as the Department of Environmental and Natural
Resources (DENR), Department of Agriculture (DA), and Bureau of
Agricultural Research (BAR) may be helped by this study for it will
give them further knowledge on the importance of biotechnology in
the country which they may use to spread to the Filipino
citizens.
Field of BioremediationThis study also adds further knowledge in
the field of bioremediation for fungal species that is isolated in
the mangrove tree and it is put into consideration in remediating
soil by lessening pesticide. Scope and DelimitationThe study will
utilize three different endophytic fungi species obtained from the
roots of mangrove trees in Sagay, Camarines Sur and will be
isolated in three separate petri dishes and will then be cultured
using Potato Dextrose Agar (PDA) because it is a nutrient rich
media used for culturing a wide variety of microorganisms. The
culturing of the isolates will be done in the Biology Laboratory of
Philippine Science High School Bicol Region Campus.This study
focuses if the fungi isolates have a mycoremediation potential on
the pesticide chlorpyrifos. The pesticide with the commercial name,
Brodan together with Potato Dextrose Broth will be used as
treatment. The pesticide will have three different volumes, 5 ml,
10 ml and 15 ml. Potato Dextrose Broth will have the same volume in
each flask which is 55 ml. The nine treatments will be analyzed by
qualitative evaluation after the experiment to observe the changes
made. Mycelial growth, change in the fungis color, and change in
the medias color will be observed during the qualitative
evaluation. The extraneous factors in the set-up are the rate of
proliferation and fungal growth.
Chapter IIREVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE AND STUDIESRelated
LiteratureMycoremediationMycoremediation is an innovative
biotechnology that uses conditioned fungi and fungal mycelium
applied to surface soils to remove and degrade contaminants (Aston,
L.M., Cullinan, V.I., Thomas, S.A., Woodruff, D.L., 2009).According
to Stamets, P. (2005), also known as the renaissance mycologist,
mushroom suffered from biological racism. Due to this observation,
he propelled the higher fungi into the 21st century. In alliance
with several public and private organizations, he pioneered the use
of mycoremediation and mycofiltration technologies. Baker, L.
(2002) expounded that these comprised the cultivation of mushrooms
to clean up contaminated waste sites, and upgrade ecological and
human health.Stamets, P. (2005) explained that mycoremediation is
the use of various species of fungus as a technique to clean toxins
and excess nutrients out of an environment. The word
mycoremediation came from the prefix myco-, fungus and remediation,
the action of remedying. This method works because of the mycelium.
The mycelium is a loose network of the delicate filaments hyphae
that form the body of a fungus. Mycelium is the one responsible for
the production of extacellular enzymes and acids that can dismantle
long chains of hydrogen and carbon, the base structure common to
pesticides.FungiFungi are adept molecules that are able to break
down long chained toxins into simpler less toxic chemicals. They
essentially use and assimilate these toxins as nutrients. Mycelial
enzymes can decompose some of the most impervious and resistant
materials made by humans or nature. This is due to the fact that
many of the bonds that hold the plant material together are similar
to the bonds found in petroleum products. These products include
diesel, oil, herbicides and pesticides. Toxins such as textile dyes
and estrogen-based pharmaceuticals are susceptible to the enzymes
secreted by the mycelia. Some mushroom species can reduce the
toxicity of several of these, while others are more selective
(Stamets, 2005).In 2002, Caryn Sykes tackled about the
effectiveness of fungi in the bioremediation field. According to
her, this remediation process is inexpensive, easy to use, requires
no liability for secondary waste, and even allows the treated
material to be reused afterwards. Since it is a natural system, and
does not introduce any corrosive or other chemicals for cleanup,
there would be a higher probability that the public would accept
this method. Also, the use of fungi only requires minimal handling
and low maintenance of sites. In terms of safety, it is expected to
be safer than most other alternatives for it does not require
digging up contaminated products, and later disposing it off at
waste sites. It restores value to depleted land. Most of all, its
upshot is nontoxic. As stated by Sykes, C. (2002), although no
matter how beneficial it is, it also has a few drawbacks. There are
certain approaches to this remediation wherein they are only
suitable for particular situations. Some organizations are finding
it hard to convince others of this method for often times, people
prefer to rely on proven and existing technologies.Mangrove FungiIn
the study of Chandralata in 2005, he stated that mangrove fungi
usually possess several metabolites of industrial and environmental
importance. It has a potential on the bioremediation field and can
possibly be used against harmful substances such as pesticides
which is described by the National Institute of Environmental
Health Sciences as any substance used to kill, repel, or control
certain forms of plant or animal life that are considered to be
pests.ChlorpyrifosThe wide application of organophosphorous (OP)
insecticides such as Chlorpyrifos are employed for plant protection
against insect pests. This organophosphorous pesticide is one of
the major chemicals responsible for the contamination and
deterioration of soil and groundwater, particularly in the close
vicinities of agricultural fields (Jayashree and Vasudevan, 2006).A
decline in the population of beneficial soil microorganisms can be
instigated due to heavy treatment of soil with pesticides.
According to soil scientist Dr. Elaine Ingham, If we lose both
bacteria and fungi, then the soil degrades. Overuse of chemical
fertilizers and pesticides have effects on the soil organisms that
are similar to human overuse of antibiotics (Savonen,
1997).SoilSoil is a natural body of mineral and organic
constituents differentiated into horizons usually unconsolidated of
variable depth which differs among themselves as well as from the
underlying parent material in morphology, physical makeup, chemical
properties and composition and biological characteristics
(Dokuchaiev, 1900; Hilgard, 1892; Joffe, 1936; Whitney, 1982).
Related Studies In the study of Kumari et al (2011) entitled
Fungal degradation of chlorpyrifos by Acremoniumsp. strain (GFRC-1)
isolated from a laboratory-enriched red agricultural soil, an
enrichment technique was used to isolate the mixed and the pure
fungi from three soils. The enriched mixed fungal culture was
capable of biodegrading chlorpyrifos (300 mg L -1) when cultivated
in Czapek Dox medium. The identified pure fungal
strain,Acremoniumsp., utilized chlorpyrifos as a source of carbon
and nitrogen. The highest chlorpyrifos degradation (83.9%)
byAcremoniumsp. strain GFRC-1 was found when cultivated in the
nutrient medium with full nutrients. Desdiethyl chlorpyrifos was
detected as a major biodegradation product of chlorpyrifos. The
isolated fungal strain will be used for developing bioremediation
strategy for chlorpyrifos-polluted soils. The study Enzymatic
degradation of organophosphorus insecticidechlorpyrifosby fungus
WZ-I by Xie et al (2005) stated that the degradation
characteristics ofchlorpyrifosinsecticides was determined by the
crude enzyme extracted from the isolated strain WZ-I ( Fusarium LK.
ex Fx). The best separating condition and the degrading
characteristic ofchlorpyrifoswere studied. Rate of degradation
forchlorpyrifosby its intracellular enzyme, extracellular enzyme
and cell fragment was 60.8%, 11.3% and 48%, respectively. The
degrading enzyme was extracted after this fungus was incubated for
8 generations in the condition of noninducement, and its enzymic
activity lost less, the results show that this enzyme is an
intracellular and connatural enzyme.According to Fang et al with
their study entitled Fungal degradation of chlorpyrifos
byVerticilliumsp. DSP in pure cultures and its use in
bioremediation of contaminated soil and pakchoi, the degradation
characteristics of chlorpyrifos by an isolated fungal
strainVerticilliumsp. DSP in pure cultures, soil, and on pakchoi
(Brassica chinensisL.) were investigated. Degradation rate of
chlorpyrifos in the mineral salts medium was proportional to the
concentrations of chlorpyrifos ranging from 1 to 100mgl1. The rate
of degradation for chlorpyrifos (1mgl1) in the mineral salts medium
was 1.12 and 1.04 times faster at pH 7.0 than those at pHs 5.0 and
9.0, and the degradation at 35C was 1.15 and 1.12 times faster,
respectively, than those at 15 and 20C. The addition of the fungal
strain DSP into the contaminated soils was found to significantly
increase the degradation of chlorpyrifos.Most of the study used the
same method in knowing the degradation of chlorpyrifos. In the
study of Harish et al (2013) Biodegradation of Organophosphate
Pesticide by Soil Fungi, two fungal isolates isolated by enrichment
technique were studied in Burkes liquid mineral medium supplemented
with ethion andchloropyrifios at concentration of 100 PPM
respectively, to quantify cellgrowth. The growth of Rhizopus
nodosus and Trichoderma harznaium was monitored by observing the
growth and turbidity of the media. The growth was maximum after 48
h. which was visualized with increase in their cell size and mass.
The absence of turbidity was an indication of their growth
utilizing pesticide as sole carbon source. It was observed that
Chlorpyrifos and Ethion gradually declined over period of 21 days.
After gathering relevant information regarding the currently being
asserted topic, the researchers believe that the relevant
information collected strongly support the feasibility of the
proposed topic.
Chapter IIIMETHODOLOGYPresented in this chapter were the methods
conducted in the aforementioned study which aimed to assess the
mycoremediation potential on the pesticide chlorpyrifos of fungal
isolates from mangrove areas in Sagay, Camarines Sur.Causal Model
of the Study Degradation by fungi
Mangrove endophytes utilized in the degradation; amount of
pesticide
Change in volume and color of pesticide
Rate of proliferation; fungal growth
Figure 1. Interactions among the variables in the experiment
In Figure 1, the type of fungi used in the degradation of the
contaminant served as the independent variables. The fungal species
were utilized in the degradation of chlorpyrifos and were isolated
by the researchers as part of their methodology. Nine Erlenmeyer
flasks that contained Lorsban, which was the brand name of the
pesticide used, were used as treatment. The effects of these
factors in the degradation of contaminants were measured by
comparing if there was a significant change in the chemical
contents of the pesticide. The rate of degradation of the fungi was
the linking variable. The rate of proliferation of the fungal
species was the extraneous variable because this could not be
manipulated by the researchers. The natural life cycle of the fungi
which followed the exponential growth curve could not be held back
by the researchers but it could have affected the rate of
degradation.
Materials and EquipmentThe materials and equipment used included
the following: incubator, analytical balance, autoclave, graduated
cylinder, beaker, cotton, aluminum foil, nine Erlenmeyer flasks,
distilled water, thermometer, pH meter, shaking incubator, Lorsban,
Potato Dextrose Agar. Potato Dextrose Agar was the medium used in
the culturing of fungi and as substrate in the degradation
process.
Procedure A. Isolation of MicrobesFungal strains were isolated
from mangrove areas in Sagay, Camarines Sur. Repeated sub culturing
was done to get pure cultures. Strains were maintained in the
Potato Dextrose Agar.B. Sterilization of MaterialsNine Erlenmeyer
flasks, two 100 ml beakers, stirring rod, and graduated cylinder
were autoclaved before use.C. Preparation of MediaA mixture of 13.5
g of Potato Dextrose Agar and 500 ml distilled water were divided
and put into nine Erlenmeyer flasks each containing 55 ml of the
broth. D. Inoculation of Pure Cultures in the MediaThe pure
cultures were mixed with the pesticide in nine Erlenmeyer flasks.
The diluted pesticide was divided into nine treatments. Each
treatment contained 5 ml, 10 ml, and 15 ml of the 10% active
ingredient Chlorpyrifos. This part of the methodology was based
mainly on the study of Harish published on March 2013.E.
Qualitative AnalysisThe nine treatments were analyzed by
qualitative evaluation after the experiment to observe the changes
made. Mycelial growth, change in the fungis color, and change in
the medias color were observed during the qualitative evaluation.
The data that were gathered from the observation were recorded.F.
Disinfection of MaterialsThe materials were all cleaned before and
after use. The media were properly disposed along with the fungi
and petri dishes. The laboratory and the equipment were also
cleaned before and after the experimentation.
Schematic Representation of the Methodology Isolation of
mangrove fungal endophytes
Identification of Microbes
Extraction of Chlorpyrifos
Inoculation of Microbes on the Pesticide
Qualitative analysis
Chapter IVRESULTS AND DISCUSSIONThree different fungal
endophytes obtained from mangrove areas in Sagay, Camarines Sur
were each subjected to three different volumes of pesticide: 5 ml,
10 ml, and 15 ml to assess their mycoremediation potential on the
pesticide chlorpyrifos. Mycoremediation is an innovative
biotechnology that uses conditioned fungi and fungal mycelium
applied to surface soils to remove and degrade contaminants (Aston,
L.M., Cullinan, V.I., Thomas, S.A., Woodruff, D.L., 2009).
Qualitative analysis, which is comprised of observing the mycelial
growth, change in the fungis color, and change in the medias color,
was done to assess the experiment.The tables below show the data
gathered through the experiment conducted.Table 1. Corresponding
volume of diluted pesticide (ml) in each fungusVolume of diluted
pesticide (ml)
Fungus 151015
Fungus 251015
Fungus 351015
Table 2. Observations in the three fungi using qualitative
analysisMycelial GrowthChange in Fungis ColorChange in Medias
Color
Fungus 1NoneNoneNoneNoneNoneNoneNoneNoneNone
Fungus 2NoneNoneNoneNoneNoneNoneNoneNoneNone
Fungus 3NoneNoneNoneNoneNoneNoneNoneNoneNone
There are no changes in the color of the fungi and media nor is
there any presence of mycelial growth. This shows that none of the
three fungi obtained from Sagay, Camarines Sur has a
mycoremediation potential.
Lorsban: Pesticide used which contains chlorpyrifos as the main
active ingredient
Obtaining of the pure cultures
Fungi in different volumes
Chapter VCONCLUSIONSoil contaminated with pesticide decreases
the soils fertility and also affects the organisms living there.
This study then aimed to assess the mycoremediation potential on
the pesticide chlorpyrifos of fungal isolates from mangrove areas
in Sagay, Camarines Sur.Fungal strains were first isolated from
mangrove areas in Sagay, Camarines Sur and repeated sub culturing
was done to get pure cultures. Strains were maintained in Petri
dishes containing Potato Dextrose Agar. A mixture of 13.5 g of
Potato Dextrose Agar and 500 ml distilled water were divided and
put into nine Erlenmeyer flasks each containing 55 ml of the broth.
The pure cultures were mixed with the pesticide in nine Erlenmeyer
flasks. The diluted pesticide was divided into nine treatments.
Each treatment contained 5 ml, 10 ml, and 15 ml of the 10% active
ingredient Chlorpyrifos. Using qualitative analysis, which is
comprised of observing for changes in mycelial growth, fungis
color, and medias color, data were gathered and recorded.From the
qualitative evaluation conducted, it was observed that there was
neither any change in the color of the fungi and media, nor in the
mycelial growth. This then resulted to an acceptance of the null
hypotheses. Thus, it is concluded that the three fungal isolates
obtained from Sagay, Camarines Sur have no mycoremediation
potential on the pesticide chlorpyrifos.BIBLIOGRAPHYBaker, L.
(2002, November 25). How mushrooms will save the world.Salon.com.
RetrievedFebruary23, 2013, from
http://wordspy.com/words/mycoremediation.aspDefinition of Soil,
Approaches of Soil Study. (n.d.).My Agriculture information bank.
Retrieved from
http://www.agriinfo.in/default.aspx?page=topic&superid=4&topicid=246Enhanced
solubilization of rock phosphate by Penicillium bilaiae in
pH-buffered solution culture. (2006, November 1).
RetrievedFebruary28, 2013, from
http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-164595964.htmlfacts about
Penicillium - Evi. (n.d.).Evi | Ask me anything. Retrieved from
http://www.evi.com/q/facts_about__penicilliumFriesen, T. J.,
Holloway, G., Hill, G. A., & Pugsley, T. S. (2007, January 18).
Biocontrol Science and Technology. RetrievedFebruary28, 2013, from
http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/09583150500258263?journalCode=cbst20Manimegalai,
Selvaraj, & Ambikapathy (2011). Studies on Isolation and
Identification of VAM Fungi in Solanum viarum Dunal ofMedicinal
Plants.Archives homepage. Retrieved
fromhttp://archives.evergreen.edu/masterstheses/Accession86-10MES/Rogers_TMES_2012.pdfMycoremediation
: The sustainability wiki. (n.d.).Appropedia. Retrieved from
http://www.appropedia.org/MycoremediationObire, & Putheti
(1996). FUNGI IN BIOREMEDIATION OF OIL POLLUTED ENVIRONMENTS.Year
of Energy 2009. Retrieved
fromhttp://energy.sigmaxi.org/wp-content/uploads/2009/09/obire_putheti_bioremediation.pdfParkinsons
(n.d.). A method for isolating fungi from soil microhabitats -
Springer.Home - Springer. Retrieved
fromhttp://link.springer.com/article/10.1007%2FBF01394646Rogers, T.
(2012).Archives homepage. Retrieved from
http://archives.evergreen.edu/masterstheses/Accession86-10MES/Rogers_TMES_2012.pdfSoil
Management. (n.d.).Welcome to College of Tropical Agriculture and
Human Resources, University of Hawaii. Retrieved from
http://www.ctahr.hawaii.edu/mauisoil/a_comp.aspxSridhar, K. R.,
ed.Frontiers in Fungal Ecology, Diversity and Metabolites. I. K.
International Publishing House Pvt. Ltd., n.d. Web. 28June2013.
Sykes, C. (2002, February 26). Magical Mushrooms: Mycoremediation.
RetrievedFebruary23, 2013, from
http://www.frost.com/sublib/display-market-insight-top.do?id=SSAI-57QV3KThomas
(n.d.).People ForPuget Sound: Our vision is a clean and healthy
Puget Sound. People For Puget Sound. Retrieved1999,
fromhttp://pugetsound.org/science/puget-sound-science/reports/mycoremediation-pilot-project-near-the-dungeness-riverWord
Spy - mycoremediation. (n.d.).Word Spy. Retrieved from
http://wordspy.com/words/mycoremediation.aspPotera,C. (2007).
Pesticides Disrupt Nitrogen Fixation.Environmental Health
Perspectives,115(12). Retrieved from
http://www.questia.com/library/journal/1G1-173712890/pesticides-disrupt-nitrogen-fixation#articleDetails
.