Page 1
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 1 of 56
REPORT TO SUBCOUNCIL 03
1. ITEM NUMBER:
2. SUBJECT: MINUTES: WARDS COMMITTEE FOR WARDS 1, 4, 5, 107 & 113
ISIHLOKO: IMIZUZU : IIKOMITI YEWADI: 1, 4, 5, 107 & 113
ONDERWERP: WYKSKOMITEE NOTULE VIR WYKE 1, 4, 5, 107 & 113
3. PURPOSE
To present the Subcouncil with minutes of the Ward Committee meetings
held for:
Ward 1 on 25 August 2021
Ward 4 on 3 August 2021
Ward 5 on 12 August 2021
Ward 107 on 17 August 2021
Ward 113 on 31 August 2021
It is recommended that the Subcouncil support the recommendations
contained in the minutes of Wards 1, 4, 5, 107 & 113.
4. FOR DECISION BY
The Subcouncil, Delegation 1 (1).
To assess the performance of service delivery generally within their area of
jurisdiction (outcomes monitoring)
5. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Due to the fact that Ward Committees have no formal powers; they can
make submissions/recommendations to the Subcouncil through the Ward
Councillor and/or through the Ward Committee meetings. For this reason,
Page 2
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 2 of 56
the minutes of Ward Committee meetings must be supported by the
Subcouncil in order for such recommendations to be executed.
6. RECOMMENDATIONS
Recommended:
A. That the recommendations as noted in the minutes attached and
marked ANNEXURES A, B, C, D & E be supported by the Subcouncil.
B. That the Subcouncil Manager be tasked with, where applicable,
directing and/or referring the items for action arising from the minutes,
to the relevant departments for action/input/feedback due to the
operational and/or policy implications of these matters.
C. That the actions of the Subcouncil Manager in forwarding the
aforegoing to the relevant line departments directly after the ward
committee meetings be condoned.
AANBEVELING(S)
A. Dat daar van die konsepnotule van die wykskomitees-vergaderings vir
wyk 5, aangeheg aanhangsels A, B, C, D, & E asook die aanbevelings
soos vervat in die notules, ondersteun word.
B. Dat die subraadsbestuurder die taak opgelê word om, waar toepaslik
die items voortspruitend uit die notules, na die betrokke departemente
te herlei en/of te verwys vir beleidsimplikasies ten opsigte van hierdie
aangeleenthede.
C. Dat die aksies van die subraadsbestuurder met die aanstuur van die
voormelde aan die betrokke lyndepartemente direk aan die
wykskomiteesvergaderings gekondoneer word.
IZINDULULO
A. Ukuba iBhungana malixhase izindululo ezibhalwe kwingxelo nemizuzu
ephawulwe njengeziHlomelo A yeeKomiti zeeWadi A, B, C, D, & E,
gokulandelelana kwazo.
B. Ukuba uMphathi/uManejala weBhungana makanikwe uxanduva,
apho kufanelekileyo, wokuhlenga-hlengisa kwakhona okanye
agqithise le mibandela ilandelayo kumasebe afanelekileyo ukuze
Page 3
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 3 of 56
ifezekiswe/kuvakaliswe uluvo/kunikwe ingxelo ngenxa yendlela
emiselwa ngayo kwakhona nemiphumela kumgaqo-nkqubo yale
mibandela.
C. Ukuba makwamkelwe amanyathelo oMphathi weBhungana
angokugqithisa imibandela edlulileyo kumasebe afanelekileyo emva
kokuba kuchotshelwe intlanganiso yeForam yewadi.
7. DISCUSSION/CONTENTS
The main function of Ward Committees is assisting the democratically
elected Ward Councillor to effectively carry out their mandate to
represent the people of the ward. Ward Committees have no formal
powers other than they can make submissions/recommendations to the
Subcouncil directly or through the Ward Councillor and/or through the
Ward Committee meetings.
7.1. Constitutional and Policy Implications
N/A
7.2. Sustainability implications
Does the activity in this report have any
sustainability implications for the City?
No X Yes
7.3. Legal Implications
None
7.4. Staff Implications
Does your report impact on staff resources or result in any
additional staffing resources being required?
No
X
Yes
Page 4
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 4 of 56
7.5. Other Services Consulted
N/A
ANNEXURES
ANNEXURE A: MINUTES: WARD COMMITTEE MEETING WARD 1
ANNEXURE B: MINUTES: WARD COMMITTEE MEETING WARD 4
ANNEXURE C: MINUTES: WARD COMMITTEE MEETING WARD 5
ANNEXURE D: MINUTES: WARD COMMITTEE MEETING WARD 107
ANNEXURE E: MINUTES: WARD COMMITTEE MEETING WARD 113
FOR FURTHER DETAILS, CONTACT:
NAME Elizabeth Jacobs
CONTACT NUMBERS 021 444-4861
E-MAIL ADDRESS [email protected]
DIRECTORATE AREA BASED MANAGEMENT
FILE REF NO
Page 5
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 5 of 56
ANNEXURE A
MINUTES OF A VIRTUAL MEETING OF THE WARD COMMITTEE FOR WARD 1 ON 25
AUGUST 2021 AT 15:00
Present:
Ward Committee members
Cllr Cheryl Visser Chairperson & Ward Councillor
Cllr Demetrius Dudley PR (ACDP)
Cllr Nicky Rheeder Chairperson Subcouncil 3
Elizabeth Simpson Abeille Ruche School
William Verschoor District Watch
Barry Haschick Grace Presbyterian Church
JJ Pieterse Ramasibi Guest House
Paul Kruger PWP Neighbourhood Watch
Pierre Gouws MVRRA
Dave Smith Richwood Residence Ratepayers Association
Sophia Swart Monte Vista Primary School
Cllr Demetrius Dudley PR (ACDP)
Subcouncil staff
Elizabeth Jacobs Secretariat: Subcouncil 3
WC1 01/08/21 OPENING AND PRAYER
The Chairperson, Councillor Cheryl Visser welcomed the members
present. Cllr Visser asked that a moment of silence be held.
WC1 02/08/21 LEAVE OF ABSENCE
With apologies
Samantha Fraser Eden Learning Innovations (Pty) Ltd
Roxanne Moses Manager Subcouncil 03
Without apologies
None
Page 6
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 6 of 56
WC1 03/08/21 ANNOUNCEMENTS BY CHAIRPERSON
Councillor Visser welcomed the members to the fourth ward
committee meeting in 2021. Cllr Visser referred to the application
for possible extension of the Election that is currently scheduled for
27 October 2021. Ward Committee Members will be kept up to
date as soon as confirmation of the Election date is announced.
NOTED
WC1 04/0821 CONFIRMATION OF MINUTES
RESOLVED TO RECOMMEND
That the minutes of the Ward Committee Meeting held on 10 June
2021 be confirmed without any amendments. The minutes were
approved by Cllr Demetrius Dudley and seconded by Mr Pierre
Gouws.
NOTED
WC1 05/08/21 PRESENTATIONS:
None
WC1 06/08/21 SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT POLICY
The Chairperson eluded to the SCM policy in her Chairperson’s
opening address. Due to the voluminous size of the policy itself, it
was attached to the appointment on the Skype for Business link.
NOTED
WC1 07/08/21 METRO POLICE SAFETY AND SECURITY REPORT FOR THE MONTH OF
JUNE 2021
The Chairperson eluded to the Metro Police Safety and Security
Report in her Chairperson’s opening address. Due to the
voluminous size of the report itself, it was attached to the
appointment on the Skype for Business link.
NOTED
Page 7
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 7 of 56
WC1 08/08/21 TRAFFIC SERVICES REPORT FOR THE MONTH OF JUNE 2021
The Chairperson eluded to the Traffic Services Report in her
Chairperson’s opening address. Due to the voluminous size of the
report itself, it was attached to the appointment on the Skype for
Business link.
NOTED
WC1 09/08/21 LAW ENFORCEMENT REPORT – WARD 1
The Chairperson eluded to the Law Enforcement Report in her
Chairperson’s opening address. Due to the voluminous size of the
report itself, it was attached to the appointment on the Skype for
Business link.
NOTED
WC1 10/08/21 EPIC REPORT
The Chairperson eluded to the EPIC Report in her Chairperson is
opening address. Due to the voluminous size of the report itself, it
was attached to the appointment on the Skype for Business link.
NOTED
WC1 11/08/21 STORM WATER WINTER READINESS REPORT
The Chairperson eluded to the Storm Water Winter Readiness
Report in her Chairperson’s opening address. Due to the
voluminous size of the report itself, it was attached to the
appointment on the Skype for Business link.
NOTED
WC1 12/08/21 ANNUAL WEEDSPRAYING MAINTENANCE PLAN
The Chairperson eluded to the Storm Water Winter Readiness
Report in her Chairperson’s opening address. Due to the
voluminous size of the report itself, it was attached to the
appointment on the Skype for Business link.
NOTED
Page 8
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 8 of 56
WC1 13/08/21 WARD COMMITTEE MEMBERS SECTOR FEEDBACK
Councillor Visser requested the ward committee members to
continue to submit their feedback forms to the Subcouncil on or
before each Ward Committee Meeting.
Following is a brief synopsis on feedback from the ward
committee members:
Barry Haschick – Barry said that with the third wave in place it is
challenging because only 50 members may join a service at
any given time. Barry will contact Riana de Wet, Chairperson of
the MVRRA and Paul Kruger for assistance with food parcels in
his area.
Paul Kruger – Paul reported that crime has come down in
Plattekloof and Panorama. SAPS assists with the removal of
vagrants.
Paul said that he is concerned with the blocked storm water
canals on the National roads close to Plattekloof that are not
being cleaned properly.
William said that the Security companies are definitely seeing
the worst of Covid since the third wave.
Many staff are off sick with Covid-19.
There has been great LPR arrests recently with all NHW and
security companies together. District Watch has noted the
concern around the taxis on the Plattekloof road. William
thanked everyone for the robots that are back in working order
on the Giel Basson / Plattekloof Road.
Dave Smith – Reported on ongoing projects:
1. Feedback from the Annandale project
2. Giel Basson speed camera's
3. Potholes need to be fixed
4. Lights for our parks - 2 attacks in our parks
5. COCT must find funds to complete the fence project!
Elizabeth Simpson – Elizabeth said that all schools are doing their
best and currently it is mostly online learning interventions.
Page 9
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 9 of 56
Pierre Gouws – said that residents are mostly irate with their high
municipal accounts ito electricity and water bills.
Pierre said that at a recent meeting with Ald JP Smith all Safety
and Security departments in the City came together with all
private security companies to stand together with assisting the
City’s residents should any looting occur in C.T. The outcome of
the meeting was extremely successful in that this proved to the
City that private security companies could work together with
the City very successfully.
Pierre said that all LPR and human detection cameras are
working well.
Sophia said that the schools are implementing strict protocols
and that they are very blessed that, to date they have had a
very low number of incidents with scholars.
Cllr Dudley said that he attended a monthly feedback meeting
that was also attended by Cllr Visser regarding feedback on
Social and Law Enforcement regarding Homeless People. Cllr
Dudley was happy to see that Ald JP Smith was to interact with
legal to ensure that applications to the court will be able to
protect the NHW members when doing their duties.
Cllr Visser informed the members of the new tender that has
been awarded for the road reinstatements and potholes in the
COCT.
All outstanding C3 notifications in this regard will be attended to.
Cllr Visser requested the members to contact Riana de Wet,
Chairperson of the Monte Vista R&R Association and Paul Kruger
if there are people in Ward 1 that are in need of food.
The Chairperson, Cllr Rheeder thanked Cllr Visser for visiting her
meeting and that it is great to see what her ward committee
members are accomplishing.
In closing the meeting, Cllr Visser extended her heartfelt thanks
to all the members who are doing so much hard work in the
ward. She wished all members well.
RESOLVED TO RECOMMEND
That the ward committee’s feedback be NOTED.
Page 10
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 10 of 56
DATE, TIME AND VENUE OF NEXT WARD COMMITTEE MEETING
The Chairperson thanked everyone for attending the meeting and said that the
next meeting is scheduled for 14 October 2021.
CLOSING OF THE MEETING
The meeting ended at 16:30
_______________________________________
COUNCILLOR CHERYL VISSER CHAIRPERSON:
WARD COMMITTEE WARD 1
Page 11
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 11 of 56
ANNEXURE B
MINUTES OF THE WARD COMMITTEE MEETING FOR WARD 4, HELD ON TUESDAY 03
AUGUST 2021 AT 17:30 VIA SKYPE FOR BUSINESS
WC4 01/08/21 OPENING AND PRAYER
Councillor Mlulami Ngeyi welcomed all present and declared
the meeting open. It was noted that the Chairperson thanked all
the ward committee members for their presence.
Present:
Ward Committee members:
Cllr Mlulami Ngeyi Ward Councillor
Cllr Ursula Barends PR Councillor
Ms Jacqui Pember Milnerton Ridge Neighbourhood Watch
Mr Wolsley Jacobson Lions Club International
Mr Gary Bower Montague Gardens – Marconi Beam
Improvement District
Mr Thabo Diniso Khazimla Development Network
Mr Vincent Alexander Summer Greens Ratepayers Association
Ms Liete Van Der Eems Milnerton Central Ratepayers Association
Ms Raquel Croeser Summer Greens Neighbourhood
Watch
Mr Craig Ludwig Sunset Beach Neighbourhood Watch
Officials:
Ms Roxanne Moses Subcouncil 3 Manager
Ms Kyla Miller Secretariat, Subcouncil 3
Absent with apologies:
Ms Linda Mqikela Phoenix Ratepayers Community
Forum
Absent without apologies:
Ms Lungisa Haai Siphekela Isizwe Empowerment
Page 12
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 12 of 56
WC4 02/08/21 LEAVE OF ABSENCE
It was noted that Ms Linda Mqikela has submitted an apology for
not being able to attend the meeting.
WC4 03/08/21 ANNOUNCEMENTS BY CHAIRPERSON
The Chairperson Councillor Ngeyi mentioned that he is quite
happy that the taxi violence war has ended. It was noted that
the Chairperson briefly spoke about the possible postponement
of the Local Government Elections. Councillor Ngeyi mentioned
that a reading programme would commence within the
following week in the Summer Greens area. Furthermore,
Councillor Ngeyi reiterated the importance regarding the
COVID-19 vaccination and encourage the ward committee
members to vaccinate.
A copy of Cllr Ngeyi’s speech is attached to the minutes.
RESOLVED TO RECOMMEND
That the contents of the report be noted.
WC4 04/08/21 CONFIRMATION OF MINUTES – 08 JUNE 2021
Ms Jacqui Pember said that she has not had a chance to read
through the minutes and Mr Gary Bower concurred that the
minutes was not received on time.
It was noted that the Ward Committee Agenda was published a
day before the meeting.
Mr Alexander has confirmed that he has read the minutes
however he was not present at the previous meeting.
The Chairperson Councillor Ngeyi apologised on behalf of the
Subcouncil as the late agenda items prolonged the publishing of
the agenda to the ward committee members.
Page 13
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 13 of 56
Councillor Ngeyi reiterated that the ward committee members
should submit their request for items on time.
It was noted that no late items would be accommodated.
RESOLVED
That the minutes of the ward committee meeting held on 08
June 2021 BE CONFIRMED at the next scheduled ward
committee meeting to be held on 05 October 2021.
OTHER MATTERS SUBMITTED
WC4 05/08/21 REQUEST SUBMITTED BY CLLR U BARENDS
The request was submitted by Councillor Barends in order for the
Solid Waste Department to provide guidance about the
different departments within Solid Waste including their functions
and who the relevant contact persons are. It was noted that the
relevant official could not attend the meeting due to other
commitments.
Councillor Barends said that she has noticed that there seems to
be confusion regarding the different inter-departments within
Solid Waste and she personally thinks a lot of time is wasted by
logging C3 service requests incorrectly. Her request for the Solid
Waste Department to attend the meeting was merely for the
department to explain the correct process on how to proceed
with logging of C3 notifications.
It was noted that the above item would be dealt with at the next
ward committee meeting.
RESOLVED TO RECOMMEND
A. That the contents of the report be noted.
B. That the item be resubmitted to the next Ward Committee
Meeting.
Page 14
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 14 of 56
ACTION: KYLA MILLER
WC4 06/08/21 ITEMS SUBMITTED BY MR V ALEXANDER
Mr Alexander referred to the increase of railway line squatters
who are situated against the borders of the residents’ properties
within Summer Greens. It was noted that the ratepayers of the
Summer Greens area had a site visit to assess the area and it was
ascertained that these squatters are causing a number of issues
such as fire hazards, noise disturbances, and littering.
Mr Alexander said that the community as a whole has sent
through a list of C3 notifications, communicated with the Ward
Committee Chairperson who is also the respective Ward
Councillor, Councillor Mlulami Ngeyi.
Mr Alexander further stated that the community feels that it is
time to take action as there has been an increase in the number
of squatters and they strongly feel to take matter into their own
hands. Mr Alexander said that if this matter is not curbed, there
would be bigger problems for the City of Cape Town.
Mr Alexander mentioned that the community suggested that a
petition could be drafted and should be handed in either to the
Ward Councillor or the City of Cape Town to heed to their call to
remove these squatters to a safer area.
It was reiterated by Mr Alexander that he is afraid that the
community will take the law into their own hands and projected
that this is going to happen shortly.
Mr Alexander asked the Chairperson including the ward
committee members to come up with ideas so that they can go
forward because this is happening in other areas within the
Ward.
The Chairperson Councillor Ngeyi thanked Mr Alexander for
raising the issue and mentioned that he has visited the area with
various stakeholders.
Page 15
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 15 of 56
It was noted that this matter has been referred to Inspector
Gomis from Law Enforcement.
Councillor Ngeyi mentioned that there are many other issues
that are prohibiting the City of Cape Town to act decisively with
regards to the structures within the City of Cape Town as a
whole.
Councillor Barends stated that it should be determined whether
PRASA should be involved in the above matter as Mr Alexander
referred to the railway lines, which is not part of Local
Government.
Mr Alexander stated that this is not a problem for PRASA at the
moment as the people are bordering the properties of the
residents and this would become a volatile situation.
Mr Alexander said that what he would suggest because the City
of Cape Town is so slow in doing things and Law Enforcement
coming out to talk to the public, the community is going to take
the law into their own hands.
Furthermore, Mr Alexander also mentioned that the only
ratification is that the squatters have no legal rights to be there
other than the owners who have the legal rights, as they own the
properties. Mr Alexander said that he does not see this going
anywhere, where these squatters can take them to court.
Mr Alexander said that the Summer Greens is a very fragile
community and the squatters does not want to reform.
Councillor Barends thanked Mr Alexander for providing clarity
and said that to her understanding this sounds similar to the
matter that happened at Democracy Park where there was a
fire outbreak.
Councillor Barends proposed that the relevant officials needs to
be called in to discuss the matter to avoid this from happening
Page 16
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 16 of 56
to the properties in Summer Greens, which would cause
damage to residents’ properties.
The Chairperson Councillor Ngeyi said that he would take the
above matter up with Inspector Gomis and suggested that a
meeting be arranged with the relevant parties to discuss the
situation at hand.
Councillor Barends suggested that a meeting first be arranged
with the relevant line departments to discuss the matter internally
and then they could revert back to the ratepayers and
neighbourhood watches within the Summer Greens area.
Mr Alexander referred to the footbridge that crosses over
Bosmansdam Road and when it gets cold and during rainy
weather, there are people who light fires under the bridge,
which creates the pillars of the bridge to become fragile, and
eventually it would collapse and fall over into the road.
Mr Alexander requested that City officials attend to the problem
to avoid any catastrophe and suggested that the area could
possibly be fenced off or other avenues needs to be looked in
order to find ways for the vagrants not to be able to have
access under the bridge in order for them to make those fires.
Councillor Ngeyi said that what he understands is that this matter
also refers to the vagrants as previously discussed on the first item
Mr Alexander has raised and the suggestion was to arrange a
meeting with the internal line departments and they would then
revert back to the various community stakeholders.
Councillor Barends stated that the item raised by Mr Alexander
involves vagrants however this is a different item as he is referring
to the bridge that needs to be checked out as there could be
possible damages and a meeting would need to be arranged
with the officials of the relevant department.
Page 17
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 17 of 56
Councillor Barends proposed that Ms Kyla Miller find out which
relevant department would be responsible as far as the bridge is
concerned.
Ms Jacqui Pember referred to Page 36 of the agenda and said
that Mr Alexander has clearly stated three issues and they are all
separate.
The Chairperson Councillor Ngeyi said that he thinks the urgent
matter at hand is the issue of the vagrants because even the
concern of the bridge is the cause of vagrancy.
Mr Alexander referred to the collapsed wall in Summer Greens,
which encroaches onto his property and stated that this matter
has been outstanding for eight years.
Mr Alexander said that they have previously spoken to Mr
Dewaldt Smit who was the previous building inspector/manager
who had to revert to them however; nothing has been resolved
thus far.
Mr Alexander said that City of Cape Town went to investigate
and found out that the developers had no plan for the wall,
which was more than thirty years ago and this, might become a
problem that could result into a legal battle with the City of
Cape Town.
Mr Alexander reiterated that this matter has been outstanding
for eight years and they have heard absolutely nothing.
Mr Alexander mentioned that this is the following problems with
the wall:
1. There is no plan within the City of Cape Town for the wall.
2. The wall has no foundation and could collapse at any time,
which could result, into killing someone.
Page 18
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 18 of 56
Mr Alexander referred to a previous occasion where he has said
that the officials of the City of Cape Town is useless and it seems
to him that his words are becoming true.
Mr Alexander expressed his disappointment as he has spoken
many times to City officials regarding this matter and needs this
matter to be attended to urgently.
The Chairperson Councillor Ngeyi suggested that Mr Alexander
provide him with all the relevant paperwork and
correspondences regarding this matter in order to trace what
went wrong and to refer the matter to the right department in
order to find an amicable solution to it.
Councillor Barends recommended that the Subcouncil office
also source for documentation as mentioned by Mr Alexander.
Mr Alexander said that this matter was being dealt with at the
time when Councillor Solomon was still responsible for this ward.
It was noted that Mr Alexander would submit all supporting
documentation pertaining to this matter via email.
RESOLVED TO RECOMMEND
1. That a meeting be arranged by the office of the Ward
Committee Chairperson, Councillor Ngeyi to address the
vagrants issues within the Summer Greens area
2. That relevant feedback of the scheduled meeting be
provided to the relevant community stakeholders within
Summer Greens Area.
3. That Mr Alexander provide all relevant information pertaining
to the matter of the collapsed wall via email.
4. That the contents of the report be NOTED.
ACTION: KYLA MILLER/CLLR MLULAMI NGEYI
Page 19
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 19 of 56
WC4 07/08/21 ITEM SUBMITTED BY MR G BOWER
Mr Bower referred to the outstanding drains from Water and
Sanitation and requested that this matter be escalated to Mr
Siswana (Director: Area North) as this has been coming on for
too long.
Furthermore, Mr Bower said that the matter on the street lighting
is self-explanatory, as he has been introduced to Messrs Skuce
and Skippers. Should there be no movement on the commitment
made telephonically, Mr Bower would like to have that also
escalated.
Mr Bower stated that the commitment and the partnership that
he is getting from Mr Titus is chalk and cheese as what he is
getting from Water and Sanitation as 80% of what he requested
was done.
Councillor Ngeyi said that during the week some responses has
been received, the Subcouncil Manager and Subcouncil
Chairperson are attending to the matters of Mr Bower as they
are keeping him posted. Further to this, meetings are in place
with the relevant departments.
Mr Bower requested that if possible, that he be invited to the
meetings.
It was noted that feedback would be provided to Mr Bower
accordingly.
RESOLVED TO RECOMMEND
1. That the Subcouncil be tasked to escalate the matter
regarding the outstanding drains to Mr Siswana (Director:
Area North)
2. That the contents of the report be NOTED.
ACTION: KYLA MILLER
Page 20
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 20 of 56
STANDING MATTERS
WC4 08/08/21 WARD COMMITTEE MEMBER SECTOR FEEDBACK
The Chairperson Councillor Ngeyi asked whether there were any
outstanding sector feedback forms.
Ms Kyla Miller confirmed that there were five feedback forms
outstanding.
Ms Jacqui Pember said that she has sent her form accordingly.
Councillor Ngeyi said that there has been a developing trend for
quite some time now as the obligation of the submission of the
forms are not taken seriously.
Mr Alexander said that he believes these sector feedback forms
are not user-friendly, they are not easy for someone to answer
the questions, which is sometimes not relevant to them in
particular, or the things that they do within the community.
Mr Alexander asked whether there is any way that they could
have any input in adding certain things on here to be much
broader than it is at the moment. There is no other section, which
allow one to add any other items.
Ms Kyla Miller said that the form provided is more standardised
and quite easy to complete.
It was noted that Ms Kyla Miller presented the sector feedback
form and referred to the sector feedback form that Mr Bower
has submitted as an example in order to briefly explain to the
ward committee members how the form needed to be
completed.
Mr Alexander said that it is easy to say however, he just feels that
the form should be in a much easier format and some of the
things listed on the form does not happen within their areas.
Page 21
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 21 of 56
The Chairperson Councillor Ngeyi said that Ms Kyla Miller is only
trying to assist him in how to complete the form and that the
form is very easy to fill in.
Councillor Ngeyi said that he has noticed that the ward
committee members are doing the opposite and that they are
supposed to be reporting about the sector that they represent
and not their area.
The Chairperson Councillor Ngeyi requested that Mr Alexander
remain quiet until he had finished as Mr Alexander already had
his opportunity to speak on the matter.
Mr Alexander then said he was not allowed to speak on the
subject.
Councillor Ngeyi said that that they were trying to explain that
the feedback forms must be completed properly in future and
reiterated that ward committee members must address matters
that addresses issues of the sector that they individually represent
and should not focus on matters pertaining to the area where
the reside in.
Mr Alexander said that the Councillor is only hearing his own
voice and is not hearing what is coming from the members and
that the Councillor wants it his way. Mr Alexander asked that the
Subcouncil Manager should attend the meetings.
The Chairperson Councillor Ngeyi responded that the problem
with Mr Alexander is that he does not listen. Mr Alexander said
that it is not about listening, it is about doing what is right for the
communities.
It was then requested by the Chairperson that Ms Kyla Miller
should mute Mr Alexander.
Mr Alexander said that he could be muted however; he will take
Councillor Ngeyi on by reporting the matter to the Chief Whip.
The Chairperson Councillor Ngeyi advised Mr Alexander do to so.
Page 22
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 22 of 56
Ms Jacqui Pember asked to leave the meeting at that stage.
The Chairperson Councillor Ngeyi again requested Ms Kyla Miller
to mute Mr Alexander however; Mr Alexander said that he would
mute himself.
Councillor Ngeyi said that it is unfortunate that this is not the first
time that Mr Alexander is doing this.
Councillor Ngeyi said that Ms Kyla Miller was still busy explaining
how the form should be completed as the understanding of the
form is very simple.
It was noted that part of the function of a ward committee
member, is to represent the Sector under which he/she has been
registered. The member therefore, represents all the
organisations in the same Sector pertaining to that specific ward.
It is therefore a requirement of ward committee members to
complete their feedback forms as it literally speaks to the other
organisations that falls within that category. Every member
should submit his or her own feedback form even if there are
more than one member in the ward committee under the same
sector.
Upon Councillor Barends enquiry regarding Ms Pember’s
feedback form that she submitted and awaiting feedback, Ms
Kyla Miller said that she has checked her emails however; it
could be that the emails sent from Ms Pember bounces back as
there was no record of Ms Pember’s submission. It was noted
that in future should the problem persist, Ms Pember would
engage Ms Kyla Miller by form of WhatsApp communication in
order to submit her feedback forms.
Mr Wolsley Jacobson said that he has served on other ward
committees and this form is the standardised version used by all
ward committees throughout the City of Cape Town.
Page 23
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 23 of 56
Councillor Ngeyi thanked Mr Jacobson for his input and further
said that we learn from one another and would get to the point
where we need to do the right thing.
Ms Jacqui Pember referred to the feedback forms and the
sector that she represents and said that she thinks there is still a
misconception that people on the committee are not aware
they represent the entire Ward 4.
Councillor Ngeyi responded to Ms Pember’s comment, that, that
is the biggest problem as he has alluded earlier that some of the
ward committee members think they are members to represent
their own area.
Ms Pember said that as a member of an established CPF Forum it
is easy for her however, it might be more difficult for the other
participants as they do not have a specific overarching forum to
discuss matters.
The Chairperson Councillor Ngeyi said that the other ward
committee members can do something about it by organising
themselves to have a forum of a CPF nature and he knows that
they are capable to do so.
Ms Raquel Croeser said that she also just wanted to understand,
as she might be slightly confused and always presumed that the
order of it all was to represent Summer Greens and not the entire
ward as explained by Councillor Ngeyi.
Ms Croeser further said that they would normally take the
feedback received from the CPF meeting and would discuss the
information with the general members of the neighbourhood
watch.
The Chairperson Councillor Ngeyi briefly made an example of
the Security sector and said that as a sector all the ward
committee members need to meet accordingly. Ms Croeser
asked whether it made sense to have all the representatives
from the Security Sector.
Page 24
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 24 of 56
Councillor Ngeyi said that fortunately enough the regulations
and requirements of the City of Cape Town allows more than
two people from one sector.
Furthermore, Councillor Ngeyi said that at times it is very
advantageous when the sector feedback form is submitted;
their sector can submit one document that would represent that
sector and said that it is very important that they come together.
It was noted that Ms Raquel Croeser would engage Ms Pember
in terms of submitting the feedback report.
Ms Moses apologised for her late attendance due to a late site
visit she had to attend within the Subcouncil.
Ms Moses said that she just wanted to comment on the
allocation of the sectors and further mentioned that the ward
can decide on the layout of the sectors and if the need is
greater in terms of Safety and Security, more membership in the
field could be added in order for the impact and focus to be
more.
It was reiterated by Ms Moses that the sectors need to provide
feedback on the entire ward as a whole.
Mr Alexander stated that he has been part of ward committees
since the inception thereof and that he has done thousands of
reports.
Mr Alexander expressed his unhappiness about the comment
that was made by the Chairperson, Councillor Ngeyi and felt
that it was ‘out of line’.
Mr Alexander reiterated that he also attends other ward
committees, he knows exactly what goes on in those ward
committees and currently this ward committee is in absolute
shambles, as people have no clarity on what needs to be done.
Mr Alexander suggested that Ms Catherine Overmeyer needs to
come do some representation on the functioning of the ward
Page 25
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 25 of 56
committees and it should also be looked at why the meeting
only takes place every two months as this should be a monthly
meeting due to the many issues.
Furthermore, Mr Alexander expressed his concerns and said that
he is not happy with the fact on how this ward committee
functions as he is going to report this matter to the office of the
Chief Whip.
The Chairperson Councillor Ngeyi said that we would be in the
position to accommodate a ward committee workshop and the
Subcouncil Manager confirmed that this could be arranged
accordingly.
It was noted that the request of the Chairperson is that the
workshop should highlight many things that needs to be done
and improved in order for the members to submit their inputs
and participate fully as ward committee members.
Councillor Barends recommended that an option should be
given to the members whether they would want to partake in
the workshop, as the old members might not deem the
workshop necessary.
RESOLVED TO RECOMMEND
A) That a training workshop on the functioning of the ward
committees be arranged for the ward committee members of
Ward 4.
B) That the contents of the report be NOTED.
ACTION: KYLA MILLER
The Chairperson thanked everybody for their attendance and
reminded the ward committee members that the next ward
committee meeting is scheduled to take place on the 05th of
October 2021.
Page 26
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 26 of 56
CLOSING OF THE MEETING
The meeting ended at 19:38
_____________________ ___________________
COUNCILLOR MLULAMI NGEYI DATE
CHAIRPERSON
Page 27
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 27 of 56
CLLR M. NGEYI WARD COMMITTEE SPEECH DATE: August 2021
Good Afternoon to all, and welcome to our Ward Committee meeting today. I
would like to welcome Ward Committee members, Sub Council 3 staff and the
members of the public to the meeting. I hope and wish that your families and
friends are doing well during this time of the Pandemic.
Yes, please remain vigilant as the 3rd Wave surge is expected soon. Continue
adhering to the Regulations and Stay Safe. Let us continue to observe the
following Regulations:
a. Always Wear your Mask
b. Always Practice Social Distancing
c. Always Sanitize your Hands
Stay Safe as activities of criminal elements is cropping up. Let us encourage our
residents to report these matters to the South African Police Service for action.
I wish you all the best in your sectors and please submit your Reports.
Enkosi kakhulu!! Baie Dankie!! and Thank You!!
Page 28
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 28 of 56
ANNEXURE C
MINUTES OF THE WARD COMMITTEE MEETING FOR WARD 5, HELD ON THURSDAY 12
AUGUST 2021 AT THE EDGEMEAD LIBRARY
Present:
Ward Committee members:
Cllr Helen Carstens Ward 5 Councillor, Chairperson
Mr Dave Morley Bothasig Community Police Forum
Mr Paul Innes Scouts South-Africa Bothasig
Mr Gregory Stokell Edgemead Primary School
Ms Zelda Kabeya Bethal Christian Ministry (Virtual)
Officials:
Mrs Deidre Prinsloo Secretariat, Subcouncil 3
Mrs Bridget French Ward Clerk – Ward 5
Mr Peter Cookson Social Development & Early
Childhood
Absent with apologies:
Mr Desmond Wallace Zone 4 NHW
Ms Cindy Thomas Bothasig Health Committee
Mr Patrick Pillay De Grendel Lions Club
Ms Roxanne Moses Subcouncil 3 Manager
WC5 01/08/21 OPENING AND PRAYER
The Chairperson, Cllr Helen Carstens extended a word of
welcome to all present, thanked everyone for their availability
and opened the meeting with a moment of silence.
WC5 02/08/21 LEAVE OF ABSENCE
It was noted that Messrs Desmond Wallace and Patrick Pillay and
Mmes Cindy Thomas and Roxanne Moses are absent with
apologies.
Page 29
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 29 of 56
WC5 03/08/21 ANNOUNCEMENTS BY CHAIRPERSON
Cllr H Carstens delivered her chairperson’s report of which a
copy is attached to the minutes (Annexure A).
NOTED
WC5 04/08/21 CONFIRMATION OF MINUTES – 15 JULY 2021
On the proposal of Mr Paul Innes and seconded by Mr Dave
Morley of the ward committee the minutes of the meeting of 15
July 2021 was approved.
NOTED
WC5 05/08/21 PRESENTATION: THE REINTERGRATION OF STREET PEOPLE
Mr Peter Cookson (Social Development) was invited to attend
the ward committee meeting to discuss and present on the
reintegration of street people in area north.
Mr Peter Cookson presented and comprehensively explained
the responsibilities, challenges and successes experienced by
Social Development in their workings with Street People.
WC5 06/08/21 AIR QUALITY MANAGEMENT
This item served on the July 2021 Subcouncil Agenda.
The purpose of the report is to give the Ward Committee the
opportunity to comment on the proposed draft amendment to
the Air Quality Management Bylaw, 2016, for the City of Cape
Town, and to be informed of the planned public participation
process.
RESOLVED TO RECOMMEND
That the contents of the report be noted.
Page 30
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 30 of 56
WC5 07/08/21 LIBRARY AND INFORMATION SERVICES
This item served on the July 2021 Subcouncil Agenda.
The purpose of the report was to inform the Ward Committee of
the activities of the Department for the period 1 January 2021 to
31 March 2021.
RESOLVED TO RECOMMEND
That the contents of the report be noted.
WC5 08/08/21 WINTER READINESS REPORT
This item served on the July 2021 Subcouncil Agenda.
The purpose of the Report was to inform the Ward Committee of
the Winter Readiness Program within Transport: Road
Infrastructure and Management (RIM), District 3 Service area,
covering their constituency.
RESOLVED TO RECOMMEND
That the contents of the report be noted.
WC5 09/08/21 PROPERTY MATTERS: ERF 8353, MILNERTON, SITUATED AT NO 35 ADAM
TASS AVENUE, BOTHASIG, ZONED OPEN SPACE 2 AND TRANSPORT 2
(TR2)
This item served on the July 2021 Subcouncil Agenda.
The purpose of the Report was for noting and information purposes.
RESOLVED TO RECOMMEND
That the contents of the report be noted.
Page 31
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 31 of 56
WC5 10/08/21 PROPERTY MATTERS: ERF 3372, MILNERTON, SITUATED AT GOEDE
GOEDE HOOP STREET, BOTHASIG, MILNERTON:MINERALOGICAL
SOCIETY OF SOUTHERN AFRICA (061-850 NPO)
This item served on the July 2021 Subcouncil Agenda.
The purpose of the Report was for noting and information
purposes.
RESOLVED TO RECOMMEND
That the contents of the report be noted.
WC5 11/08/21 STANDING OPERATING PROCEDURE: CLOSING OF PADESTRIAN
AND CYCLE LANES AND THE LEASE/SALE OF THAT LAND TO
ABUTTING PROPERTY OWNERS
This item served on the July 2021 Subcouncil Agenda.
The purpose of the Report was for noting and information
purposes.
RESOLVED TO RECOMMEND
That the contents of the report be noted.
WC5 12/08/21 PREPAID ELECTRICITY
The purpose of this item was for noting and information purposes.
RESOLVED TO RECOMMEND
That the contents of the report be noted.
WC5 13/08/21 MEDIA RELEASE – VEHICLE LICENSE RENEWALS – ONLINE SERVICES
The purpose of this item was for noting and information purposes.
RESOLVED TO RECOMMEND
Page 32
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 32 of 56
That the contents of the report be noted.
WC5 14/08/21 C3 NOTIFICATIONS REPORT
This item served on the July 2021 Subcouncil Agenda.
To purpose of this item was so present the Ward Committee with
feedback regarding calls and complaints that were registered
on the COCT’s Notifications Programming Schedule for the
period 1 to 30 June 2021.
RESOLVED TO RECOMMEND
That the contents of the report be noted.
WC5 15/08/21 COVID-19 REPORT: AS OF 7 JULY 2021
To purpose of this item was for noting and information purposes.
RESOLVED TO RECOMMEND
That the contents of the report be noted.
WC5 16/08/21 LAW ENFORCEMENT REPORT – MAY 2021
This item served on the July 2021 Subcouncil Agenda
The purpose of this item was for noting and information purposes.
RESOLVED TO RECOMMEND
That the contents of the report be noted.
Page 33
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 33 of 56
WC5 17/08/21 TRAFFIC REPORT – MAY & JUNE 2021
This item served on the July 2021 Subcouncil Agenda
The purpose of this item was for noting and information purposes.
RESOLVED TO RECOMMEND
That the contents of the report be noted.
WC5 18/08/21 METRO POLICE REPORT – APRIL, MAY & JUNE 2021
This item served on the July 2021 Subcouncil Agenda
The purpose of this item was for noting and information purposes.
RESOLVED TO RECOMMEND
That the contents of the report be noted.
WC5 19/08/21 WARD COMMITTEE MEMBER SECTOR FEEDBACK
It was noted that no sector feedback forms were received from
the ward committee in time to form part of the agenda.
Feedback was provided from each members in the meeting. Cllr
H Carstens informed the committee members of the importance
of submitting sector feedback.
RESOLVED TO RECOMMEND
That the contents of the report be NOTED.
CLOSING OF THE MEETING
The meeting ended at 16:40
_____________________ ___________________
HELEN CARSTENS DATE
Page 34
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 34 of 56
Ward 5 Ward Committee
Ward Councillor and Chair Report: Cllr Helen Carstens
12 August 2021
As your Ward Councillor, I have called on the departments to fulfil their
responsibility to maintain the pedestrian lanes and thoroughfares throughout the
area.
At a recent inspection of several municipal amenities and other infrastructure I
was shocked at the appalling and inexcusable condition of the pedestrian
thoroughfares in Bothasig as these lanes are important pedestrian thoroughfares
which connect many of the roads to the public transport routes. They are
overgrown with weeds and cluttered with litter which obviously make it very
difficult and dangerous for pedestrian access and virtually impossible for people
pushing trolleys or prams.
It is the policy of the City to regularly clean and clear road verges, open spaces
and pedestrian thoroughfares, but that some of these lanes
were badly neglected, were deplorable and requires urgent attention from the
departments.
I have been engaging with the SC in order to revisit the closing of redundant
lanes, just as the motion was raised from this committee. It is an involved process
and after much deliberation and investigation, the process must be initiated
from a resident or a group of residents. With this in mind I will be following up
with the residents who have requested the closing of certain lanes, we will then
have to tackle it lane by lane and not a blanket closing. Please note that there
will be public engagement as well.
Unfortunately, the problem is becoming worse and something must be done as
there are horrendous health issues and safety issues. The intention of these lanes
were that of movement back in 1965, Modes of transport have progressed and
Bothasig is nowhere how it was back in 1965 or 1980 for that matter. Much has
changed and much will continue to change and although the City favours
pedestrian movement, this must coincide with the safety of the pedestrian and
with health standards.
I would also like to encourage the sectors here to provide feedback to me
should they be engaged with residents who live abutting these lanes so that we
can fast track this.
Page 35
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 35 of 56
Good news is that Food Lover’s Market are on site and the demolition of the old
Super Plants site will commence shortly. Needless to say there will be dust and
noise as this takes place however the end result will be very worth it when the
area of Bothasig will host the flag ship store of Food Lover’s and where most
shopping can be done. At last, the entrance to the Ward will be much more
appealing as Food Lover’s will maintain the entire perimeter of the site as well.
Bothasig Mall is also on the way for an upgrade and this has begun with the
changes to the entrance and exit and the new anchor tenant of Checkers.
Checkers is busy expanding to make the current site bigger. Further additions
will be a few drive-through restaurants and the upgrade to the walkways and
the removal of all the brick paving to replace with tiles. There are a number of
further upgrades that will continue to take place as time goes on but again this
will be another great asset for the area.
I must add that there is a lot of rubbish at the back which is understandable as
they are busy building there so the issues raised by residents about the dump site
are not totally to point. It would be good to have a bit of patience while the
transition and building takes place.
I am indeed a grateful and proud councillor as we sit here today in the extension
of the Edgemead Library. The official hand over from the contractor was on
Tuesday so this area now is officially part of the Edgemead Library. As I said on
Tuesday – they have done a remarkable job with a container……… when I
originally started floating this through the system, it was as a container as I knew
it would be difficult to get a new building, and I even had the container ready
and waiting to be delivered. That idea was not very popular and we then
moved to prefab and that was not too popular either and then we ended up
with brick and mortar and to what we have here today. As we sit here today,
this is bigger and better than what we expected, but we are so grateful and so
happy. Edgemead Library can now hold their activities here and have their
reading corner and have a place to put more books. This will benefit them for
many years to come and I am grateful that I dug my feet in and kept pushing.
I want to touch on the state of the roads. They are disgusting and I am in
agreement with everyone on this. I am not an engineer and I do not fill pot
holes but I do engage with the relevant authority on this which is the Road
Department. The roads are their assets and they are responsible for the upkeep
of their roads. In my role of oversight, I engage them and enquire why, when
and what with regard to the state of the roads and I then communicate this
Page 36
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 36 of 56
back to the community. To be perfectly honest, the issue with the roads is across
the City and not just in our suburbs. The main issue that seems to pop up is that
of tenders and the process to appoint tenders. We are currently, through the SC
going more in-depth into this with feedback meetings on a two-weekly basis.
Projects in the ward are taking a slow start and this is due to tender issues as well
as COVID infections because unfortunately there are a number of staff who
have contracted COVID and this is affecting delivery of projects and delivery of
servce. I hope to be able to give feedback on the status of projects by our next
meeting and hopefully we will be able to see them taking shape.
The Urban Gardens are progressing however the winter weather has all but
destroyed our crop that was due for harvest now. Nonetheless, we now have
the three gardens – Bothasig Community Hall, Edgemead Library and Bothasig
Library at the same stages so planting will begin soon and these three will harvest
at the same time.
Wolraad Woltemade and Tafelberg are running with their gardens and Tafelberg
have even increased the size of their garden. Edgemead High and Bothasig
Scouts are lagging behind but I am sure they will catch up soon enough.
As we sit here COVID free, let us remember that this virus is all around us and
whether we are vaccinated or not, have had COVID before or not, the new
mutations mean that the current form out and about is the one that we have to
deal with.
The golden rule is to keep a distance, keep your hands clean and wear a clean
mask. Wearing the same mask day in a day out does not do anything as you
are merely keeping the virus particles and dirt on your mask. Your mask should
be washed every time you take it off and you should not touch it at all and only
touch it by the elastic on the side. The paper masks should be thrown away after
use. We hear this all the time, but do we take notice of it? Do we abide by it?
The stats of the ever increasing number of infections says that we don’t adhere
to this.
ENDS.
Page 37
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 37 of 56
ANNEXURE D
MINUTES OF THE WARD COMMITTEE MEETING FOR WARD 107, HELD ON THURSDAY
17 AUGUST 2021 VIA SKYPE FOR BUSINESS
Present:
Ward Committee members:
Cllr Nicky Rheeder Chairperson - Ward 107 Councillor
Ms Ankarien Oelofse Table View Angels
Mr Kasagan Moodley Parklands Hindu Cultural Society
Mr Eric Basson Parklands Home Owners Association
Mr Kenneth Spies Table View Community Police Forum
Ms Yvette Huysamer Rescue Rehab South Africa
Officials:
Mrs Deidre Prinsloo Secretariat - Subcouncil 3
Ms Natalie Newman Coastal & Environmental Management
Absent with apologies:
Ald Ian Nielson PR Councillor Ms Mandy Da Matta Table View Ratepayers Association
MS Lorraine Bastick Nutty Knitters Mr Roy Fuller-Gee Friends of the Blaauwberg Conservation Area
WC107 01/08/21 OPENING AND PRAYER
The Chairperson, Cllr Nicky Rheeder extended a word of
welcome to all present, thanked everyone for their availability
and opened the meeting with a moment of silence.
WC107 02/08/21 LEAVE OF ABSENCE
It was noted that Alderman Ian Nielson, Mr. Roy Fuller-Gee
and Mmes Mandy Da Matta and Lorraine Bastick are absent
with apologies.
Page 38
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 38 of 56
WC107 03/08/21 ANNOUNCEMENTS BY CHAIRPERSON
Cllr N Rheeder delivered her chairperson’s report of which a
copy is attached to the minutes (Annexure A).
NOTED
WC107 04/08/21 CONFIRMATION OF MINUTES – 17 JUNE 2021
On the proposal of Ms. Ankarien Oelofse and seconded by
Mr. Eric Basson of the ward committee the minutes of the
meeting of 17 June 2021 was approved.
NOTED
WC107 05/08/21 PRESENTATION: THE BEACH FRONT UPGRADE
Ms. Natalie Newman (Environmental Management) was
invited to attend the ward committee meeting to discuss and
present on the Beachfront Upgrade.
Ms. N Newman delivered a thorough and fruitful presentation
and thereafter responded to the questions asked by the ward
committee members.
RESOLVED TO RECOMMEND
That the contents of the motion be noted.
WC107 06/08/21 MOTION: NEED FOR MANAGED PARKING IN PARKLANDS/
PARKING ENFORCEMENT
The purpose of this item was to bring the motion submitted by
Mr. Eric Basson to the attention of the Ward Committee.
It is for discussion and noting purposes
Page 39
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 39 of 56
It was noted that this item will now serve on the ward
committee agenda under matters receiving attention until
the motion has been concluded.
RESOLVED TO RECOMMEND
That the contents of the motion be noted.
WC107 07/08/21 REPORT ON ACTIVITIES FOR TRAFFIC SERVICES FOR THE MONTHS
OF MAY & JUNE 2021
This item served on the July 2021 Subcouncil 3 Meeting
Agenda.
The purpose of this item was to inform the Ward Committee of
the enforcement activities for the specific area of jurisdiction.
RESOLVED TO RECOMMEND
That the contents of the report be noted.
WC107 08/08/21 LAW ENFORCEMENT MONTHLY REPORT FOR AREA NORTH
This item served on the July 2021 Subcouncil 3 Meeting
Agenda.
The purpose of the report was to provide an overview of the
functioning and activities of Law Enforcement Services for the
period.
RESOLVED TO RECOMMEND
That the contents of the report be noted.
Page 40
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 40 of 56
WC107 09/08/21 METRO POLICE REPORT – APRIL, MAY & JUNE 2021
This item served on the July 2021 Subcouncil Agenda
The purpose of this item was for noting and information
purposes.
RESOLVED TO RECOMMEND
That the contents of the report be noted.
WC107 10/08/21 WARD COMMITTEE MEMBER SECTOR FEEDBACK
It was noted that sector feedback forms were received from
the Mr. Kenneth Spies in time to form part of the agenda.
Feedback was provided from each members in the meeting.
Cllr N Rheeder informed the committee members of the
importance of submitting sector feedback.
RESOLVED TO RECOMMEND
That the contents of the report be noted.
CLOSING OF THE MEETING
The meeting ended at 17:12
_____________________ ___________________
NICKY RHEEDER DATE
CHAIRPERSON
Page 41
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 41 of 56
Good afternoon and welcome to all the ward committee members,
Sadly, this wave of covid has left the City with many losses. I would like to take a
moment of silence in memory of all those lost within the City as well as across the
country.
Please do stay safe. Whilst we are all tired of the protocols we now have to
follow, please ensure that you continue to sanitize and wear your masks in an
effort to keep everyone safe.
I’m excited that we get to hear from Ms. Natalie Newman from Coastal
Management this month. Last month we heard about the challenges of the
broader coastline and this month we are being updated on the progress closer
to home, Table View Beachfront. This project has come a long way and I am so
thankful that we finally have a dedicated department tasked to care for our
coastline.
Speaking of water, our dam levels as of yesterday are at 98.1%. I was lucky
enough to drive past the Clanwilliam dam over the weekend and it was
amazing to see a few of the sluice gates open. It is hard to believe how little
water we had at a stage and how we used to use water without a thought
before we were faced with a drought. It is however fantastic to see how many
people have kept many of their habits of water saving and wise water use.
One of the challenges we are facing across the Subcouncil is cable theft. This
impacts us in several ways. Not only is there an increased financial burden which
is not planned for but some of the reconnections need to be done by Eskom. An
example is the intersection at Sandown Rd and Parklands Main Rd, Malibongwe
intersection and the N7 Plattekloof intersection. We have had several
engagements with Eskom but have thus far not been successful in making
progress. We have escalated the matter to the office of the MAYCO as well and
will continue to pursue the matter until it is resolved. Thankfully the section of
cables that were stolen along the R27 at Sunset Beach fall within the City’s
jurisdiction and after a small supply chain delay in obtaining cable, we have
commenced with the repairs. If you suspect that there is active cable theft in an
area and have witnessed it, please report it to the Cable Theft Unit via 0800 222
771 or the City’s emergency number 021 480 7700.
You will remember that in August last year, due to covid, we had a significant
backlog in vehicle license renewals. This has led to a significant amount of
people needing to renew their licenses this month. Senior citizens, pregnant and
Page 42
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 42 of 56
disabled customers are urged to move to the front of the queue where they will
be assisted as soon as possible. For those that are able, we would like to
encourage you to complete your renewals online.
Lastly, it is fantastic to note that the City has finalised 117 building and land use
cases which appeared in the City’s municipal courts since 1 April to 30 June
2021. Municipal Planning By-law and National Building Regulations transgressions
are the reasons these cases find their way to court. The majority of the cases
dealt with building work without approved plans and can see fines between
R500 and R5 000 each. We encourage the public to report any illegal building
work and land uses to us. This needs to be done by completing a form which
can be found on the City’s website (https://www.capetown.gov.za/City-
Connect/Report/Report-illegal-land-use/report-illegal-land-use-building-or-
development/Report%20illegal%20land%20use,%20building%20or%20developme
nt). I will be sure to send the link on the Ward Committee whatsapp group and
Deidre will distribute the link via email as well.
In one of our previous ward committee meetings there was a request for a site
visit at Potsdam WWTW. Deidre is in the process of arranging this for us. We might
have another ward committee or 2 from other wards joining us so as soon as we
finalise the numbers we will finalise the dates. Please also look out for the monthly
feedback report on our Subcouncil agenda with regards to the plant upgrade
and related information.
Thank you once again for joining me and I look forward to our meeting today.
Page 43
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 43 of 56
ANNEXURE E
MINUTES OF A MEETING OF THE WARD COMMITTEE FOR WARD 113 HELD ON
TUESDAY, 31 AUGUST 2021 AT 17:00 VIA SKYPE FOR BUSINESS
Present:
Ward Committee members:
Councillor Joy Solomon Chairperson & Ward Councillor
Anthony Bantich Tableview Community Police Forum
Kasper Wiehahn Killarney Gardens Property Owners Association
Marie Enslin Friends of the Blaauwberg Conservation Area
Isabella Ormandy The Milnerton Theatre
Chris Potgieter Milnerton Lions Club
Other Councillors:
Councillor Nicky Rheeder Subcouncil Chairperson
Officials:
Liezel Kruger-Fountain Spatial Planning and Environment
Yolandie Louwrens Secretariat: Subcouncil 3
WC113 01/08/21 OPENING AND PRAYER
The Chairperson, Councillor Joy Solomon welcomed all
present to the meeting. She extended a special word of
welcome to Councillor Nicky Rheeder for attending the
meeting. A moment of silence was observed.
WC113 02/08/21 LEAVE OF ABSENCE
With apologies:
Alderman JP Smith (PR Councillor: Ward 113)
Dirk van Niekerk - Greater Table View Action Forum
Page 44
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 44 of 56
WC113 03/08/21 ANNOUNCEMENTS BY CHAIRPERSON
The Chairperson Councillor Joy Solomon delivered her speech
of which a copy is attached to the minutes.
NOTED
WC113 04/08/21 CONFIRMATION OF MINUTES
On the proposal of Anthony Bantich seconded by Marie Enslin
the Ward Committee
RESOLVED
That the minutes of the Ward Committee held on 22 June
2021 be CONFIRMED without any amendments.
NOTED
WC113 05/08/21 PRESENTATION – POTSDAM SUSTAINABILITY CAMPUS
Councillor Solomon welcomed Ms Liezel Kruger-Fountain
(Spatial Planning and Environment) to the meeting.
Ms Kruger-Fountain delivered and informative presentation of
which a copy is attached to the minutes.
After some discussion it was UNANIMOUSLY RESOLVED TO
RECOMMEND
That the contents of the presentation be noted.
Page 45
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 45 of 56
WC113 06/08/21 UPDATE TO SUB-COUNCILS 3 AND 15 ON THE MEASURES TO
ADDRESS POLLUTION OF THE DIEP RIVER/MILNERTON LAGOON
DURING THE MONTH OF JULY 2021
The purpose of the report is to update the Ward Committee
Members on measures to reduce pollution in the Diep
River/Milnerton Lagoon.
Councillor Solomon worked through Annexures A to F in the
agenda.
She also informed the members of various site visits at the
Racecourse Pump Station, Erica Road Outfall, Phoenix Pump
Station and the Theo Marais Pump Station/Canal.
After some discussion it was RESOLVED TO RECOMMEND
That the contents of the report be noted.
WC113 07/08/21 WARD ALLOCATION OVERVIEW
The purpose of the report is to inform the Ward Committee
Members of the upcoming 2021/2022 Ward Allocation
projects.
The following projects were discussed for Ward 113:
CCTV Cameras – R110 000 – Capital Project
Upgrade of Parks – R 250 000 – Capital Project
Traffic Calming – R120 000 – Capital Project
Park Maintenance – R80 000 – Operating Project
Maintenance CCTV/LPR Cameras – R90 000 –Operating
Project
Law Enforcement Overtime – R200 000 – Operating Project
Seniors Programme – R30 000 – Operating Project
After some discussion it was RESOLVED TO RECOMMEND
That the contents of the report be noted.
Page 46
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 46 of 56
WC113 08/08/21 REINSTATEMENT OF ROADS AND WATER PIPE REPLACEMENTS IN
WARD 113
The Chairperson Councillor Solomon informed the meeting
that reinstatements and water pipe replacements are an
ongoing matter in the ward.
After some discussion it was RESOLVED TO RECOMMEND
That the contents of the report be noted.
WC113 09/08/21 FOOD TRUCK INITIATIVE
The purpose of the report is to inform the Ward Committee
Members that Area Economic Development North is busy
working on a cooperative effort with the Recreation and Parks
Department to identify possible sites for the placement of
food trucks to address a substantial demand in the area.
Councillor Solomon said that a Memorandum of
Understanding will be prepared between the two
departments to govern the cooperative project with the goal
of placing food trucks in high demand areas.
The Ward Committee Members were encouraged to identify
possible sites where these food trucks can be placed in Ward
113. It was noted that the proposed sites must fall within areas
allotted to City Parks as part of the MOU.
RESOLVED TO RECOMMEND
That the contents of the report be noted.
WC113 10/08/21 TRAFFIC AND LAW ENFORCEMENT STATISTICS FOR MAY AND
JUNE 2021
The purpose of the report is to inform the Ward Committee
Members of recent Traffic and Law Enforcement statistics.
Page 47
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 47 of 56
It was noted that the statistics as presented in the agenda
served at the Subcouncil meeting of 22 June 2021 (Law
Enforcement) and 26 August 2021 (Traffic).
RESOLVED TO RECOMMEND
That the contents of the report be noted.
WC113 11/08/21 SECTOR FEEDBACK FROM WC MEMBERS
The Chairperson, Councillor Solomon gave the Ward
Committee members the opportunity to provide feedback on
their respective organisations as indicated on their Ward
Committee Sector feedback forms.
RESOLVED TO RECOMMEND
That the contents of the report be NOTED.
Councillor Solomon thanked the Ward Committee members for their
involvement and everything that they do in and for the community and said that
it does not go unnoticed.
CLOSING OF THE MEETING
The meeting ended at 18:30.
___________________ ______________
COUNCILLOR JOY SOLOMON DATE
CHAIRPERSON
Page 48
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 48 of 56
Good afternoon everyone
It seems like ages since we last met and I hope you are all still very well?
This is theoretically our last official ward committee meeting for this year,
presupposing that the election goes ahead as planned on 27 October without
delay.
All the dilly-dallying back and forth about registration and the election is
unsettling .. we are prepared, ready and would just like to get things done and
move on , but instead we are in limbo , courtesy of the ANC. The reason for their
delay is that they are definitely in disarray and actually have not even fielded
candidates in 30% of the wards.
But as the ruling party, I guess that is their prerogative and we wait patiently and
in readiness for the announcement of the election.
We welcome our new Metro Mayoral Candidate , Geordin Hill-Lewis, into our
midst. He is no stranger, as he is actually an Edgemead resident and one time
Constituency head for our area. We look forward to working with him.
With water bodies, vleis and rivers across the City polluted with sewage effluent,
we certainly have a job on our hands to be summer ready. Our own Rietvlei has
been closed since 26 June, with no sign of opening anytime soon , as the source
of the pollution has not yet been identified.
As the ward councillors, we have been in meetings with the Mayor, the
management of the Water and Waste Directorate and Special Caucus
meetings to find the underlying cause of the state we are in and the answers are
still not clear. A task team has been set up and we will follow through.
In 2012, I started with requests for an overlay zone along Blaauwberg Rd to
prevent further densification, due to the known engineering constraints already
in existence.
This was ignored … I then followed up with a request for a moratorium in 2019,
via a motion to SC, which was also ignored and the pipes kept popping and the
sewers kept overflowing.
Finally, a moratorium has been issued by Prov Government against further
densification in the area until the Potsdam WWTW capacity has been expanded
by another 50kL, which will only be completed by 2025.
Page 49
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 49 of 56
So that is finally some really good news .. and the Spatial Planners have
accepted this.
The new ward allocation budget has kicked in as at July 2021 and as you know ,
I allocate funding to Traffic Dept and Law Enforcement for afterhours
interventions in ward 113.
W113 in the month of August had 4 traffic operations, where 231 fines were
issued to a value of R214,000.00 … Im sure that was a big shock to the system
and a big up to Chief Liebenberg and her team.
The lights in Flamingovlei have been dim ever since I can remember, partially
obscured by the big trees on our verges. After repeatedly asking, Study Street will
receive new lights, all along its length
Area North Economic Dev are investigating the idea of Food trucks at or near
parks in the area .. Food trucks are a novel idea to assist restaurateurs and other
folk who are not employed due to COVID to try and make a living. When the
notices go out , please bring it to the attention of your sectors, encouraging
them to give input. Their opinion is valued as representatives of the community.
In my interactions with the community in ward 113, esp with the older members
like Living Legends and Vue du Cap retirement village, I became aware that
many of these older folk who had planned for a great retirement in their younger
years were actually now facing a stark reality that the funding set aside has
been outstripped by inflation and rising costs. Many have had to give up their
little luxuries , incl medical aid , and are now dependent on state care.
However, despite having a clinic facility on our ward , there is no facility for
geriatric medicine and they have to go to Albow Gardens or Dunoon for
healthcare. This is a huge problem as many of them are frail and cannot hop
into taxis .. buses do not readily go in that direction so , in their twilight years they
are left to fend for themselves, which is unthinkable.
A Geriatric clinic has been requested via a motion to Sub Council for the TV
Clinic facility to also accommodate our elderly state patients. The item has been
referred via Social Development to the Prov Health system and we await their
response.
Thank you for your attention .. are there any comments or questions of clarity ?
If not, lets move straight on to the minutes of the previous meeting.
Page 50
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 50 of 56
Page 51
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 51 of 56
Page 52
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 52 of 56
Page 53
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 53 of 56
Page 54
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 54 of 56
Page 55
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 55 of 56
Page 56
Report minutes of WC meetings in August 2021 Page 56 of 56