RENEWING THE SECTIONAL STRUGGLES- 1848— 1854 Chapter 18.

RENEWING THE SECTIONAL

STRUGGLES- 1848—1854

Chapter 18

The Popular Sovereignty Panacea

Mexican American War set the stage for Slavery Controversy

Threatened to divide the union Issue: What to do with new territory? Wilmot Proviso

What it said What happened to it

Whigs and Democrats wanted to keep lid on Slavery Controversy

Election of 1848 Polk is in ill-health from over-work and does not

run again. Democrats nominate Lewis Cass. Not very warm

or easy for the electorate to like. Democratic platform is silent on slavery, but

Cass is the reputed father of “popular sovereignty.

What is Popular Sovereignty? Popular Sovereignty is very popular with the

people.

Election of 1848 Whigs nominated Zachary Taylor,

hero of the Mexican-American war. (Va.-born, slave-owner).

Taylor had never even held office Why Clay not nominated. Whig platform is silent of slavery

and generally is wishy-washy. Taylor does not take a position on

slavery, but he is assumed safe for the southern Whigs. Why?

Free Soil Party Splits the Vote

Northern Whigs unhappy with Taylor because he’s a slave owner.

Free Soil Party. Agreed with the Wilmot Proviso and stood against

slavery. This is primary issue. Supported free government homesteads for settlers in

Western territories. Types of people in party?

Enough Northern Dems vote Free Soil, especially in New York, to give the election to Whigs and Taylor.

California Gold

The discovery of Gold in California in 1848 blew the lid off the slavery issue.

Why and How?

California Gold Rush California Gold Rush CountryCountry

California Constitution

Citizens write a constitution and apply or statehood as non-slave state.

This will put slave states in the minority. The feces hits the fan in the South. South rises in violent opposition to

admission of California.

Why Was South So Concerned?

South had the presidency, majority of the cabinet, and majority of the Supreme Court.

The cotton economy was good and seemingly held the north and Europe in an economic bind.

South not concerned about the immediate outright abolition of slavery. Why?

Concerns of the South

Loss of balance in Senate Rest of the Mexican Cession Slavery in D.C. Texas land claims Biggest Concern: Run-Away Slaves and

enforcement of Fugitive Slave law

Underground Railroad Underground Railroad Harriet Tubman

Stay Focused

Fugitive Slave Law

South demanded a harsher fugitive slave law.

Why? Only losing about 1000 slave a year out of

population of 2 Million. More slaves are freed by self-purchase and

manumition.

Twilight Of The Senatorial Giants

1850 all these issues come to a head. Southern fire-eaters

threaten cession Crisis was looming. Three Senatorial Giants

tackle the issue in the Senate. Henry Clay, John C. Calhoun, and Daniel Webster.

Webster and Clay urge compromise and reasonable concession to south.

Calhoun argues for Const. Amendments to protect the South.

Deadlock in the Senate

The Young Guard from the North. William Seward, Senator from New York. Seward’s position. Deadlock seemed certain as debate

progressed. And if there was deadlock the south would likely secede.

Breaking The Logjam Taylor was poised to veto the

compromise. Why? 1850 President Taylor suddenly died;

Vice President Millard Fillmore took the presidency.

Fillmore supports the compromise Clay, Webster and Stephen Douglas

work hard to get Compromise supported in North, and it generally is.

Fire-eaters in South unhappy. Nashville convention

Second (short lived) era of good feelings.

Terms of the Compromise

Pro-North: Cal. admitted as a free state; Terr. in dispute between TX and NM goes to NM, so

more likely to go free abolition of slave-trade (but not slavery) in Wash. DC.

Pro-South: NM and Utah slavery issue to be decided by popular

sovereignty; more stringent Fugitive Slave Law. $3.10 Million to Texas

Stay Focused

Accessing the Compromise Who got the better deal?

Backfiring Slave Law

Reaction in North to Fugitive Slave Law. Provisions:

Slaves not allowed to testify and denied a jury trial. Commissioner who handled the case got twice as

much if the slave was returned. Northerners who aided slaves to freedom subject to

heavy fines and jail. Northerners could be ordered to assist in capture of

run-aways

How does the law backfire against the South?

Election of 1852 Dems. Hopelessly divided. Nominate Franklin Pierce, a

pro-southern, northerner. Compromise candidate. Weak and indecisive. Scant public record, and thus not

much to offend either part of party

Platform for Compromise of 1850 and Fugitive Slave Law

Election of 1852--Whigs

Nominate Winfield Scott. Great general, but not well

liked by people. Stuffy. Whigs hopelessly divided.

Why? Election turned largely on

issues of personality. Pierce wins in a landslide. Effective end of Whig Party.

President Pierce The Expansionist

Pierce cabinet full of southerners Jefferson Davis is Sec. of War

South needs more slave states Can’t find in US, so start looking over

southern border Fueled by ideas of Manifest Destiny.

Nicaragua--William Walker Clayton-Bulwer Treaty

Coveted Cuba

The South saw Cuba as the most desirable slave territory available. Right off our Southern shore and perfect for a slave

economy. Already had lots of slaves there. Carved into several states it would restore the north-

south balance Pierce offers Spain 100 Mil. to buy. Spain

refuses. Pierce and cabinet plot to seize it.

Ostend Manifesto Consequences

The Gadsden Purchase

Nation desperately needs a trans-continental RR to tie California to nation.

Both North and South want the route. Why?

Southern Route is easier. Gadsden Purchase. Nebraska territory. South doesn’t want this. Why?

Gadsden Purchase, 1853

Kansas-Nebraska Act

Stephen A. Douglas proposes Kansas-Nebraska Act.

Terms. Assumptions about Kansas Impact on Missouri

Compromise Abolitionist Reaction Reaction of moderates

The “Little Giant”

Kansas and Nebraska, 1854

One of the most momentous measures to pass Congress. Led to open warfare in Kansas and the unofficial opening of the Civil War.

End of Chapter