Removal of perfluoroalkyl acids from the drinking water ...€¦ · Removal of perfluoroalkyl acids from the drinking water production chain Christian Eschauzier and Pim de Voogt.

Plaats hier de titel van de presentatie

© KWR Watercycle Research Institute - 11/10/2016 1

Removal of perfluoroalkyl acids from the drinking water production chainChristian Eschauzier and Pim de Voogt.

2Watercycle Research Institute

Outline

• Introduction

• Sources of PFAA to groundwater

• Behavior of PFAA in drinking water production

• Conclusions

2

Plaats hier de titel van de presentatie

© KWR Watercycle Research Institute - 11/10/2016 2

Perfluoroalkyl acids - properties

• Chain length varies nCF2 +F = 3 to 17

• Very persistent, possibly bioaccumulative and toxic.

• Water solubility: 9.5 g/L � high!

• Multiple uses

Acid

hydrophilic

Perfluoroctanoic acid (PFOA)

Very stable bond

Fully fluorinated chain

hydrophobic

Introduction

• PFAA in environmental compartments

• Surface water, biota, air

• Human serum

• Exposure pathways (denHollander, 2010)

• Drinking water(Vestergren, 2009)

Plaats hier de titel van de presentatie

© KWR Watercycle Research Institute - 11/10/2016 3

5Watercycle Research Institute

Introduction

Perfluoroalkyl acids in drinking water: Sources, fate and removal.

• Sources: to groundwater and surface waters

• Fate: During treatment

• Removal: Affinity adsorption

6Watercycle Research Institute

Introduction

6

•PFAA in surface waters

•Surface vs. Drinking water

•Background concentrations:

• low ng/L level e.g. Ericson(2009)

•In surface waters or groundwater contaminated areas: high concentrations

•Unknown concentrations in Dutch drinking water •Info mainly focuses on PFOA and PFOS•Info does not focus on different treatment steps

Takagi, 2008

PFOA

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

450

Mar-06 Oct-06 Apr-07 Nov-07 Jun-08 Dec-08 Jul-09 Jan-10

Datum

Co

nc

. n

g/L

Hochbehälter „Vogled“

Übergabeschacht Marktl

Hochbehälter Eschelberg

LGL, 206 to 2009

Plaats hier de titel van de presentatie

© KWR Watercycle Research Institute - 11/10/2016 4

• Low concentrations in general (ng/L)

• Much less info available

• Sources

• fire fighting practise

• Landfills

• Producing/using companies

• Drinking water treatment less thorough

7Watercycle Research Institute

Sources to groundwater

8Watercycle Research Institute

Case study

Plaats hier de titel van de presentatie

© KWR Watercycle Research Institute - 11/10/2016 5

Groundwater: Case study

• Chain length dependent behaviour

• PFOS not mobile

• Point source: Landfill

• Diffuse source: Rainwater

• PFOS mobility

• Removal from groundwater…?

9Watercycle Research Institute

Fate: During treatment

•Drinking water production of Amsterdam•Two sampling rounds •Hydrological retention time taken into account•More than 60 samples analyzed in duplicate over two seasons

Plaats hier de titel van de presentatie

© KWR Watercycle Research Institute - 11/10/2016 6

11

F

Drinking

Water

Production

from river

Rhine water

in NL

with sampling

points

Drinkingwater treatment

12Watercycle Research Institute

G

H I

J

Drinkingwater treatment

Plaats hier de titel van de presentatie

© KWR Watercycle Research Institute - 11/10/2016 7

PFAA behaviour during DW treatment

•Similar PFAA profile in

the surface water as through

the pre-treatment process

•PFAA present in all samples

• PFBA (52 ng/L max)

• PFBS (42 ng/L max) (in raw water)

Inf.

Lek c

anal

Effl. c

oagula

tion

Effl. r

apid

san

d filtr

atio

n

0

5

10

15

Co

nc.

ng

/L

Afte

r dune

passa

ge

Effl. r

apid

san

d filtr

atio

n

Effl. o

zonat

ion

Infl

GAC fi

ltrat

ion

Effl. F

irst G

AC fi

ltrat

ion

Effl. G

AC fi

ltrat

ion

Drin

king w

ater

0

5

10

PFBA

PFHxA

PFOA

PFNA13

36

28

32

Inf.

Lek c

anal

Effl. c

oagula

tion

Effl. r

apid

san

d filtr

atio

n

0

10

20

30

40

Co

nc.

(ng

/L)

Afte

r dune

passa

ge

Effl. r

apid

san

d filtr

atio

n

Effl. o

zonat

ion

Infl

GAC fi

ltrat

ion

Effl. F

irst

GAC fi

ltrat

ion

Effl. G

AC fi

ltrat

ion

Drin

king w

ater

0

10

20

30PFBSPFHxSPFOS

A B

C D

Results 2GAC filtration

•No removal of PFAA throughout the purification process except for GAC filtration.

•No removal of ≤C8 carboxylic acids and ≤ C5 sulfonic acids

•Filter age dependency of the removal capacity

-100

-80

-60

-40

-20

0

20

Lead PFCALag PFCA

C5 C6 C7 C8 C9 C10

Lead PFSALag PFSA

ALkyl chain length

Rem

oval (%

)

Plaats hier de titel van de presentatie

© KWR Watercycle Research Institute - 11/10/2016 8

15Watercycle Research Institute

PFOA

0.1 1 10 1000.1

1

10

100

JapanUSUK

Influent (ng/L)

Eff

luen

t (n

g/L

)

PFOS

0.1 1 10 1000.1

1

10

100

JapanUSUK

Influent (ng/L)

In a broader perspective

Conclusions

• From all tested processes only GAC removes PFAA

• No removal of short chained PFAA• PFBS which is used PFOS substituent

• PFHxA which is partly replacing PFOA

• Margins to existing guidelines are large

• 300 ng/L PFOS + PFOA

• PFBA 7000 ug/L (Wilhelm, 2010)

Plaats hier de titel van de presentatie

© KWR Watercycle Research Institute - 11/10/2016 9

17Watercycle Research Institute

Acknowledgments

• EU project PERFOOD (KBBE-227525)

• TTIW Wetsus

• BTO

• Wellington Laboratories

18Watercycle Research Institute