Page 1
© Copyright 2012, Cardinal Health. All rights reserved. CARDINAL HEALTH, the Cardinal Health LOGO and
ESSENTIAL TO CARE are trademarks or registered trademarks of Cardinal Health.
February 24, 2012
Overview of OFCCP’s Proposed
Regulation Regarding Individuals
with Disabilities
Candee J Chambers, SPHR, CAAP
Mgr, AAP/EEO Compliance
Page 2
© Copyright 2012, Cardinal Health. All rights reserved. CARDINAL HEALTH, the Cardinal Health LOGO and
ESSENTIAL TO CARE are trademarks or registered trademarks of Cardinal Health.
2
Background
• “One of the most significant advances in protecting the
civil rights of workers with disabilities since the
passage of the Americans with Disabilities Act.”
- Secretary of Labor Hilda Solis
• “For nearly 40 years, the rules have said that
contractors simply need to make a „good faith‟ effort to
recruit and hire people with disabilities. Clearly, that‟s
not working.”- OFCCP Director Patricia Shiu
• “Sea change” in OFCCP‟s enforcement.
- OFCCP Director Patricia Shiu
Page 3
© Copyright 2012, Cardinal Health. All rights reserved. CARDINAL HEALTH, the Cardinal Health LOGO and
ESSENTIAL TO CARE are trademarks or registered trademarks of Cardinal Health.
3
Hiring/Utilization Goal
• Would mandate a 7% goal for disabled individuals in each job group in
the Contractor‟s workplace
– “Should be attainable by complying with all aspects of affirmative
action requirements”
• Must use the same job groups established for race and gender analyses
• Must develop action-oriented programs to attain the goal
• If goal is not met in one or more job groups, contractors could be subject
to enforcement penalties and possible debarment
• Requires annual utilization analysis to evaluate the number of disabled
individuals in each job group
• OFCCP also considering a sub-goal of two percent for individuals with
certain particularly severe disabilities, including: Total deafness,
blindness, missing extremities (hand, foot, arm or leg), partial paralysis,
complete paralysis, epilepsy, severe intellectual disability, psychiatric
disability, and dwarfism
Page 4
© Copyright 2012, Cardinal Health. All rights reserved. CARDINAL HEALTH, the Cardinal Health LOGO and
ESSENTIAL TO CARE are trademarks or registered trademarks of Cardinal Health.
4
Invitations to Self-Identify as Disabled
• PRE-OFFER: Must provide to each applicant an OFCCP
prescribed invitation that is separable or detachable from the
application
– Question of consistency with the ADAAA
– “In making hiring decisions, contractors shall consider applicants who
are known to have disabilities for all available positions for which they
may be qualified when the position(s) applied for is unavailable.”
• POST-OFFER: Any time after offer but before employment
begins, must provide to each applicant an OFCCP prescribed
invitation to self-identify in an anonymous manner
• EXISTING EMPLOYEES: Must annually provide each employee
an OFCCP prescribed invitation to self-identify in an anonymous
manner
• Must keep all information confidential and in a separate „data
analysis‟ file
Page 5
© Copyright 2012, Cardinal Health. All rights reserved. CARDINAL HEALTH, the Cardinal Health LOGO and
ESSENTIAL TO CARE are trademarks or registered trademarks of Cardinal Health.
5
Outreach and Recruitment, Including Job Listings
• Contractors required to engage in a minimum number of outreach and
recruitment efforts, including:
– Listing of all employment opportunities, with limited exceptions, with the
nearest One-Stop Career Center
– Required linkage agreements and ongoing relationships with local
Vocational Rehabilitative Services Agency or a local organization listed in
the Social Security Administration‟s Ticket to Work Employment Network
Directory
– Required linkage agreement with at least one of several groups for
purposes of recruitment and development of training opportunities,
including, Employer Assistance and Resource Network (EARN); nearest
Department of Veterans Affairs Regional Offices; local disability groups,
organizations, or Centers for Independent Living
– Required to consult the Employer Resources section of the National
Resource Directory, a partnership and online collaboration between DOL,
Department of Defense and Veterans Affairs
Page 6
© Copyright 2012, Cardinal Health. All rights reserved. CARDINAL HEALTH, the Cardinal Health LOGO and
ESSENTIAL TO CARE are trademarks or registered trademarks of Cardinal Health.
6
Outreach and Recruitment, Including Job Listings,
con’t.
• On an annual basis, contractors are required to review and document
its outreach and recruitment efforts and evaluate their effectiveness
– Contractor must keep track of individuals with disabilities who were referrals
from state employment services, applied for positions, and were hired for
the current year and two previous years in self evaluation
– OFCCP is considering whether contractors must provide the data to the
agency annually
– If contractor determines efforts are not effective, contractor is required to
identify and implement one or more alternative efforts in proposed
regulations
• Contractors are also required to document its linkage agreements and
activities and retain these documents for five years.
Page 7
© Copyright 2012, Cardinal Health. All rights reserved. CARDINAL HEALTH, the Cardinal Health LOGO and
ESSENTIAL TO CARE are trademarks or registered trademarks of Cardinal Health.
7
Reasonable Accommodation Requirements
• Although a contractor‟s obligation to consider and make
reasonable accommodations is covered under the ADA and
EEOC‟s regulations, the requirement to develop a specific
implementation plan is exclusive to the OFCCP
• Must develop and implement written procedures for
processing reasonable accommodation requests
• Specific requirements of the reasonable accommodation
procedures may vary depending upon the size, structure,
and resources of the contractor
Page 8
© Copyright 2012, Cardinal Health. All rights reserved. CARDINAL HEALTH, the Cardinal Health LOGO and
ESSENTIAL TO CARE are trademarks or registered trademarks of Cardinal Health.
8
Reasonable Accommodation Requirements, con’t.
• Required Elements:
– Must describe steps for processing requests, including the process for
rendering a final determination
– Must process requests as expeditiously as possible, but no longer than 10
business days when supporting medical documentation is not needed, and
no longer than 30 days when supporting medical documentation or special
equipment is needed
– Requests may be either oral or written
– Written confirmation of receipt of request must be provided by either letter
or email
– Any denial or refusal must be provided in writing and include:
• The reason for the denial
• A statement of the requestor‟s right to file a discrimination complaint with
OFCCP; and
• Information about any internal appeals or reconsideration process the contractor
may have
Page 9
© Copyright 2012, Cardinal Health. All rights reserved. CARDINAL HEALTH, the Cardinal Health LOGO and
ESSENTIAL TO CARE are trademarks or registered trademarks of Cardinal Health.
9
Reasonable Accommodation Requirements, con’t.
• Must identify to whom an employee or third party must submit an
accommodation request
• Must disseminate the reasonable accommodation procedures to all employees
by inclusion in an employee handbook and/or by email or electronic posting,
including those who work off-site
• Must inform all applicants, including those using the contractor‟s online or other
electronic application systems, of the reasonable accommodation procedures
regarding the application process
• Must give all applicants contact information for contractor staff able to assist the
applicant, or their representative, in making a request for accommodation
• Must provide annual training for supervisors and managers regarding the
implementation of reasonable accommodation procedures
Page 10
© Copyright 2012, Cardinal Health. All rights reserved. CARDINAL HEALTH, the Cardinal Health LOGO and
ESSENTIAL TO CARE are trademarks or registered trademarks of Cardinal Health.
10
Priority Hiring Program for People with Disabilities
• Priority Consideration– Contractors to voluntarily develop and implement programs to provide
priority consideration to individuals with disabilities in recruitment and in
hiring
• Contractor will include a description in its AAP– Examples of possible programs include:
• Assigning weighted value or additional points for job applicants who self-identify
as disabled
• Developing job training program focused on needs of individuals with specific
types of disabilities‟
• Using linkage agreements to recruit program trainees
• OFCCP cautions contractors not to use programs to
segregate disabled individuals
Page 11
© Copyright 2012, Cardinal Health. All rights reserved. CARDINAL HEALTH, the Cardinal Health LOGO and
ESSENTIAL TO CARE are trademarks or registered trademarks of Cardinal Health.
11
Affirmative Action Obligations
• Must ensure electronic or online job application systems are compatible
with assistive technology commonly used by people with disabilities
• Must annually review and document the outreach and recruitment
efforts to evaluate their effectiveness in identifying and recruiting
qualified individuals with disabilities
• “The Contractor‟s conclusion as to the effectiveness of its outreach
efforts shall be reasonable as determined by OFCCP in light of these
regulations.”
• Must train all personnel involved in recruiting, screening, selecting,
promoting, and disciplining employees on the benefits of employing
disabled individuals, having appropriate sensitivity toward disabled
applicants and employees, and the legal obligations of the contractor
Page 12
© Copyright 2012, Cardinal Health. All rights reserved. CARDINAL HEALTH, the Cardinal Health LOGO and
ESSENTIAL TO CARE are trademarks or registered trademarks of Cardinal Health.
12
Administrative Requirements
• Must annually review all physical and mental job qualification standards and
document the methods used and any actions taken in response
• In each case where a disabled applicant or employee is either selected or
rejected for employment, promotion or training, contractors must prepare a
statement of the reason and a description of any accommodation considered
• Must be able to identify each vacancy and training program for which each
disabled applicant was considered
• Must create contemporaneous records documenting the specific subject
matter(s) covered in the training, who conducted the training, who received the
training, and when the training took place
• Must create and retain a contemporaneous statement of reasons supporting the
belief that a direct threat exists for a disabled individual
Page 13
© Copyright 2012, Cardinal Health. All rights reserved. CARDINAL HEALTH, the Cardinal Health LOGO and
ESSENTIAL TO CARE are trademarks or registered trademarks of Cardinal Health.
13
Paperwork Requirements
• Must document and maintain the following computations or comparisons
pertaining to applicants and hires on an annual basis:
– Number of referrals of disabled individuals from employment service delivery systems
– Number of referrals of disabled individuals received from other entities, groups, or
organizations the contractor has linkage agreements with
– Number of applicants who self-identified, or who are otherwise known to be disabled
– Total number of job openings, total number of jobs filled, and the ratio of jobs filled to
job openings
– Total number of applicants for all jobs
– Ratio of disabled applicants to all applicants
– Number of disabled applicants hired
– Total number of applicants hired; and
– Ratio of disabled individuals hired to all hires
Page 14
© Copyright 2012, Cardinal Health. All rights reserved. CARDINAL HEALTH, the Cardinal Health LOGO and
ESSENTIAL TO CARE are trademarks or registered trademarks of Cardinal Health.
14
Annual Report Required of All Contractors
• Contractors would be required to provide the OFCCP with an annual
report containing these measurements and also the percentage of
applicants, new hires, and total workforce for each EEO-1 category,
regardless of whether the contractor has been selected for a
compliance evaluation
• Requirement would add another annual report (in addition to the EEO-1
and the Vets-100 or 100A) to the contractor‟s reporting obligations
• Apparent principal purpose seems to make the OFCCP‟s job easier in
determining which contractors to audit, i.e., lower percentage of people
with disabilities reported compared to workforce would result in great
chance of selection for audit
Page 15
© Copyright 2012, Cardinal Health. All rights reserved. CARDINAL HEALTH, the Cardinal Health LOGO and
ESSENTIAL TO CARE are trademarks or registered trademarks of Cardinal Health.
15
Enforcement
• Proposal‟s 7% benchmark combined with applicant and hiring ratios and
substantial documentation requirements makes it difficult to comply in each
required area
• OFCCP may establish benchmarks for a contractor‟s outreach, recruitment,
hiring, or other employment activities in any conciliation agreement
– The purpose of such benchmarks is to create a quantifiable method by which the
contractor‟s progress in correcting identified violations and/or deficiencies can be
measured
• OFCCP may extend the temporal scope of the desk audit beyond that set forth
in the scheduling letter if OFCCP deems it necessary
• Contractors are to produce requested records in format selected by the OFCCP
• Pre-award compliance evaluations for contracts of $10 million or more –
contractor must be found to be in compliance with Section 503 and the OFCCP
may provide findings to the awarding agency
Page 16
© Copyright 2012, Cardinal Health. All rights reserved. CARDINAL HEALTH, the Cardinal Health LOGO and
ESSENTIAL TO CARE are trademarks or registered trademarks of Cardinal Health.
16
Particular Issues and Challenges
• What happens if the contractor does not meet the 7% goal?
– Will prompt a close examination of all elements of employer‟s recruiting and hiring
practices
– Will lead to conciliation agreements that impose numerical goals
– In other words: Failure to meet the goal is not a violation, per se, but would likely be
viewed as an indicator of other violations, triggering closer scrutiny and enforcement
actions
• Legal Basis for the Goal
– No authority in the statutory language of Section 503 for numerical goals
– Meant to establish a benchmark, not a “quota”
– Quotas have been explicitly rejected as a component of Affirmative Action
• Statistical Basis for the Goal
– 7% goal reflects 5.7% of workforce with “disability” plus presumed 1.7% “discouraged
workers” (i.e., disabled but discouraged from seeking work)
– No basis for 2% “severely disabled” goal
– Census uses different definition of “disability” than the Americans with Disabilities Act
– 7% goal does not account for differences in local labor forces or job groups
Page 17
© Copyright 2012, Cardinal Health. All rights reserved. CARDINAL HEALTH, the Cardinal Health LOGO and
ESSENTIAL TO CARE are trademarks or registered trademarks of Cardinal Health.
17
Impact on Workforce and Talent Management
• New hiring in each job group must meet the 7% and 2% benchmark
each year
– What if there is an insufficient pool of available workers with disabilities within a job
group?
• Existing workforce in each job group must also meet these benchmarks,
regardless of percentages of new hires
– If employer has stable workforce with little or no hiring, how will it meet the goal?
– How will a contractor know how many existing employees have disabilities if the
annual survey is anonymous?
• Achievement of numerical goals would be based on number of
applicants and employees “self-identifying”
– Can the employer count an employee who clearly has a disability if the employee
fails to self-identify?
– Will individuals be afraid to self-identify for fear of being discriminated against?
– Will applicants misidentify disability status in the hopes of getting a preference?
Page 18
© Copyright 2012, Cardinal Health. All rights reserved. CARDINAL HEALTH, the Cardinal Health LOGO and
ESSENTIAL TO CARE are trademarks or registered trademarks of Cardinal Health.
18
Impact on Workforce and Talent Management,
con’t.
• Who is “Disabled?”
– Americans with Disabilities Act definition
• “Disability” means, with respect to an individual -
• “(1) A physical or mental impairment that substantially limits one or
more of the major life activities of such individual;
• (2) A record of such an impairment, or
• (3) Being regarded as having such an impairment.”
– Subject of considerable litigation, struggles by Congress, the courts,
employers and employees
– Proposed regulations meant to bring more consistency with the ADA
Amendments Act
• Do job seekers and current employees know how a „disability‟ is
defined?
Page 19
© Copyright 2012, Cardinal Health. All rights reserved. CARDINAL HEALTH, the Cardinal Health LOGO and
ESSENTIAL TO CARE are trademarks or registered trademarks of Cardinal Health.
19
On-Boarding Challenges
• Applicant tracking systems not configured for proposed
record-keeping requirements
• Must evaluate/track applicants for all “available” positions,
regardless of interest of qualifications
– Significant departure from current DOL Internet Applicant Rule
– Rule was introduced to help contractors manage flood of online
applications
• Anticipate costly changes to on-boarding processes,
software systems, recordkeeping
Page 20
© Copyright 2012, Cardinal Health. All rights reserved. CARDINAL HEALTH, the Cardinal Health LOGO and
ESSENTIAL TO CARE are trademarks or registered trademarks of Cardinal Health.
20
Congressional Challenges
• Letter written to Hilda Solis, Secretary of the DOL on January 27th from the US House of
Representatives, Committee on Education and the Workforce
• Questioned the legal authority under Section 503 permitting OFCCP to establish a
numerical hiring standard
– Concerned a hiring standard would, in effect, institute a quota, “…which has been
met with great scrutiny from the Supreme Court.”
• Requirement to ask job seekers to self-identify appears to conflict with statutory language
of the ADA, which prohibits employers from asking disability-related questions before an
offer of employment has been made
• Concerned about the potential burdens associated with the new paperwork and
recordkeeping requirements, in light of President Obama‟s comments related to,
“…sometimes, rules and regulations have gotten out of balance, placing unreasonable
burdens on business – burdens that have stifled innovation and have had a chilling effect
on growth and jobs”
• Requested a 90-day extension to the comment period, originally scheduled to end on
February 7th
Page 21
© Copyright 2012, Cardinal Health. All rights reserved. CARDINAL HEALTH, the Cardinal Health LOGO and
ESSENTIAL TO CARE are trademarks or registered trademarks of Cardinal Health.
21
Congressional Challenges, con’t.
• Solis‟ response required to Congress by February 10th, 2012
• Asked specifically, to:
– “Identify and explain OFCCP‟s statutory authority under Section 503 to establish a
numerical hiring standard.”
– “Identify and explain OFCCP‟s statutory authority to require contractors to ask job
applicants to self-identify as a qualified individual with a disability, given that the ADA
prohibits disability-related questions before an offer of employment has been made.”
– “Identify and explain the basis for OFCCP‟s assumption that job applicants and
contractors‟ current employees would understand the legal definition of „disability,‟ as
defined in the NPRM‟s prescribed self-identification notice.”
– “Under proposed section 60-741.44, OFCCP assumes contractors would spend 30
minutes per year to draft and provide written statements of reasons explaining the
circumstances for rejecting individuals with disabilities for vacancies and training
programs. Simple math would suggest the amount of time required would far exceed
this estimate. Explain how OFCCP determined the 30 minutes per year estimate.”
– “Under proposed section 60-741.44, OFCCP failed to consider the costs federal
contractors would incur…Explain why OFCCP failed to consider the costs of
contractors‟ compliance with these provisions…”
Page 22
© Copyright 2012, Cardinal Health. All rights reserved. CARDINAL HEALTH, the Cardinal Health LOGO and
ESSENTIAL TO CARE are trademarks or registered trademarks of Cardinal Health.
22
Latest Developments
• Comment period extended late on February 6th to February 21st
• Final rule must be published by November 23, 2012, in order to become
effective before January 20, 2013
• With this being an election year, what is the likelihood this proposed rule will
actually become a new regulation? The Obama Administration is fully
committed to its implementation…
• What preparations are your organizations making in case this does go into
effect?
• Are the time constraints and cost estimates in line with your organization‟s
expectations of being compliant with these proposed regulations? The OFCCP
estimates $473 per contractor establishment, or a total annual cost of $81.1
million…
• Are these new recordkeeping requirements just a pre-cursor of what is to come
with regard to all aspects of our AAP‟s?
Page 23
© Copyright 2012 Cardinal Health. All rights reserved. CARDINAL HEALTH, the Cardinal Health LOGO and
ESSENTIAL TO CARE are trademarks or registered trademarks of Cardinal Health.
23
Q&A
Page 24
© Copyright 2012 Cardinal Health. All rights reserved. CARDINAL HEALTH, the Cardinal Health LOGO and
ESSENTIAL TO CARE are trademarks or registered trademarks of Cardinal Health.
24
Thank you!