REFLECT:RETOUCH:REDEFINE BY LUCIA ULC
Mar 20, 2016
WHAT IS THIS ALL ABOUT?Over the span of the past two centuries the introduction
of technological mediums has given way to new methods
by which to represent our society and ourselves.
Traditional tools of self-reflection have been replaced as
the Internet and our online identity have created means
through which we become the authors of ourselves as we
appear to the masses. Social media, specifically Facebook,
has created platforms for idealizing and optimizing our
identity, which begs the question, how does this malleable
medium change how we define our identity in society and
how we view ourselves as individuals?
WHY IS IT RELEVANT?The merit in dissecting the shifting role of the social media
user exists in the sheer number of present online brands.
As of January 2012 Facebook has accumulated 845 million
users. The amount of time and energy spent engaging in
online outlets for communication and information can
also be attributed to the act of redefining ourselves on
the Internet. There exists a virtual community that we are
all, in some way, populating and contributing to. Moving
away from the common argument that users utilize social
media to communicate with friends and keep updated
on current events, online networking has shifted how we
view ourselves as individuals and how we view ourselves
as we relate to a larger society.
m y u i f j g k l c d n w e y
9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d
. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e
, m i u e r g v a z q t y i h
m y u i f j g k l c d n w e y
9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d
. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e
, m i u e r g v a z q t y i h
m y u i f j g k l c d n w e y
9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d
. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e
m y u i f j g k l c d n w e y
9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d
. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e
, m i u e r g v a z q t y i h
m y u i f j g k l c d n w e y
9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d
. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e
, m i u e r g v a z q t y i h
m y u i f j g k l c d n w e y
9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d
. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e
Chaper 1 discusses how users become subjects through their activity and involvement, and individually fi nd merit
in various components of social media websites. The wide-spread use of networks such as Twitter and Facebook,
as well as the growing collection of Smartphone applications, have supplied the tools that transform people into
photographers, news transmitters, social commentators, scrap bookers, fashion/music critics, etc. This type of
interaction has, to some degree, integrated itself into everyone’s day-to-day lives. As subjects we are the active
observers of other online entities, which indicates the existence of our second typecast: that of an object.
01
02
03
USER AS SUBJECT
USER AS OBJECT
USER AS SPECTACLE
The ability to act as an author-of-self puts greater focus on how users brand themselves as objects, and how
Facebook has, quite possibly, created an environment for self-actualization. All users have consequently become
designers. Their role as the communication-planners of their online brand involves varying degrees of subterfuge.
Whether it be diminishing or highlighting aspects of self, this idealized persona is carefully cultivated and
subsequently transmitted to the online community. Chapter 2 details how users have transformed themselves
into the products and commodities of social media, all meticulously packaged and submitted into circulation as
advertisements of an online brand.
Due to the evolution of mediums, identity is no longer based on the mind and body relationship with self, but
instead on the perceptions of others. Traditionally, mirrors acted as the dominating instrument for self-refl ection;
pensively observing yourself you are able to see yourself as others see you. Following mirrors came photographs
and videos; all mediums that garner an audience. We become objective evaluators of ourselves, and therefor
become self-conscious. Our most recent tool for self-refl ection is the visual structure that comes along with our
online identity. The relevancy of this contemporary medium for self-refl ection lies in its ability to be edited. We
have essentially been handed a mirror with which can refi ne ourselves as we appear to an audience.
m y u i f j g k l c d n w e y
9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d
. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e
, m i u e r g v a z q t y i h
m y u i f j g k l c d n w e y
9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d
. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e
, m i u e r g v a z q t y i h
m y u i f j g k l c d n w e y
9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d
. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e01. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
01. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e01n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e
, m i u e r g v a z q t y i h01, m i u e r g v a z q t y i h
m y u i f j g k l c d n w e y01m y u i f j g k l c d n w e y
9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d019 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d
. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x01. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e01n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e
m y u i f j g k l c d n w e ym y u i f j g k l c d n w e y
9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d
. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b en u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e
, m i u e r g v a z q t y i h, m i u e r g v a z q t y i h
m y u i f j g k l c d n w e ym y u i f j g k l c d n w e y
9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d
. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e
, m i u e r g v a z q t y i h
m y u i f j g k l c d n w e y
9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d
. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e
USER ASSUBJECT
We have all become crafters.
We have all become publishers.
We have all become engagers.
We have adopted new expertise and skill.
WE HAVE EMPLOYED OURSELVES UNDER A DIGITAL UMBRELLA OF DISCIPLINES.
The evolution of social media has created a new role for the frequent user. The fi rst of these is the typecast of subject.
We have become the subjects of interactive experiences and applications. We have been handed the means to transform
into roles that would have otherwise not been possible.
5
PHOTOGRAPHERS
take photo of someone taking picture with
iphone, similar to facing page
PHOTOGRAPHERS
FX PHOTO STUDIOCAMERA GENIUS
INSTAGRAMHIPSTAMATICPIXL-0-MATIC
CAMERA+PICFRAME
SIMPLY HDRSNAPSEEDANTICROP
CAMERABAGCOLOR SPLASHTOONCAMERA
TILTSHIFTARTISTʼS TOUCHQUAD CAMERA
TOY CAMERAIFLASHREADYJUXTAPOSER
PHOTO FXPANO
PHOTOGENESHAKEITPHOTO
MILL COLOURMONOPHIX
DASHOFCOLORPHOTOCALC
SHOOT PLANNERPROCAMERA
MAGIC SHUTTERPRO HDR
FILTERSTORMIRIS PHOTO SUITE
PHOTOSHOP EXPRESS
TH
AN
K Y
OU
lucia catharinalucia catharina
The only camera we now need comes with our cell phone. Those who pursued the traditional craft of photography are
becoming exceedingly marginalized as the vast majority of social media consumers have been handed the means to create,
edit, and share photographs in lightning speed. We’ve all become photographers. No longer used to just document moments
and people, this new media has shifted mundane photos into works of art. Color, tone, contrast, lighting, framing, fi lm leaks,
etc at the tap of a touch screen.
REPORTECOMMENTATO
BROADCASTE
“Electric circuitry profoundly involves men with one
another. Information pours upon us, instantaneously
and continuously. As soon as information is acquired,
it is very rapidly replaced by still newer information”
- Marshall Mcluhan
The Medium is the Massage
TR
11
Twitter is at the forefront of information communication,
giving users the roles of newscasters - many times lacking
credibility. Twitter has famously reported the deaths of
hundreds of celebrities, many times inaccurately. Barrack
Obama, Aretha Franklin, and Eddie Murphy round off the
top three spots of a long list of falsifi ed celebrity deaths1.
The speedy nature of Twitter’s information spread was
also the forefront source announcing the 2011 December
Tottenham riots, receiving thousands of online mentions
before reporters and journalists had even reached the riot
scene2. Additionally, Osama bin Laden’s death had become
old news by the time President Obama made his televised
offi cial announcement of the al Qaeda leader’s death3.
Thanks to ‘trending topics’ and the infamous hashtag,
users have taken on the role of news broadcasters and
commentators. We actively feed off of our ability to engage
in this revolutionary means to communicate news and events.
Thanks to Facebook status updates, ReTweets, Instant Messaging and the tool of text message communication in general,
we no longer rely on newspapers to keep us up-to-date on current events. News now spreads like wildfi re, and beyond
simply passing information along we are also weighing in and communicating opinions along with the sweeping of reports.
AIt has become common knowledge that the ‘thumbs up’ icon
signifi es a ‘like’ on Facebook, the blue bird button ReTweets
to Twitter, and the +1 corresponds to the Google+ social
network. Everything has become commented, blogged, and
tweeted and everyone has been given a voice. Almost every
existing product, article, service and person that exists online
has submitted themselves into the ‘like’ culture4; the display
of approval through a large number of networks is readily
available and actively pursued. In this way, social media users
are able to cast their vote of opinion on almost any topic and
have therefore been given yet another engaging role to fi ll.
BE THE FIRST ONE OF YOUR FRIENDS TO LIKE THIS
The last subjective role social media users have engaged
themselves in is that of a designer. The user has been handed
the ability to design their brand and implement a process by
which they market themselves to others. Communicating
visually how, in an idealized environment, they wish to be
seen to an audience, networking has provided users with
endless tools to shape personality aspects, traits, hobbies,
and an overall sense-of-self.
In the same way that celebrities and products are the
results of identity branding, we have begun building brand
equity for ourselves. Whether it’s for a business audience, a
potential romantic audience, a network of friends, or simply
for ourselves as our idealized versions, we are all presently
designers in light of this.
m y u i f j g k l c d n w e y
9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d
. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e
, m i u e r g v a z q t y i h
m y u i f j g k l c d n w e y
9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d
. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e
, m i u e r g v a z q t y i h
m y u i f j g k l c d n w e y
9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d
. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e02. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
02. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e02n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e
, m i u e r g v a z q t y i h02, m i u e r g v a z q t y i h
m y u i f j g k l c d n w e y02m y u i f j g k l c d n w e y
9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d029 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d
. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x02. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e02n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e
m y u i f j g k l c d n w e ym y u i f j g k l c d n w e y
9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d
. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b en u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e
, m i u e r g v a z q t y i h, m i u e r g v a z q t y i h
m y u i f j g k l c d n w e ym y u i f j g k l c d n w e y
9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d
. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e
, m i u e r g v a z q t y i h
m y u i f j g k l c d n w e y
9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d
. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e
USER ASO B J E C T
We have all become crafted.
We have all become published.
We have all become products.
WE HAVE TRANSMITTED OURSELVES INTO A REALM OF CIRCULATION.
The second typecast we’ve been transformed into is that of an object. As many of the social media services are free, we
are no longer the customers but have instead become the products. The concept of user in the simulated environment
of social networking has transformed our identity into a packaged and trasmitted commodity. Our online brand has
taken the transparent question of identity and created a structured version of self, along with the millions of users we
have lined ourselves up next to.
19
how would you feel about going somewhere isolated and being alone
there with your thoughts? what are some major changes in your
personality that have happened in the past three years? what areas of
your life/aspects of your personality do you feel you conceal the most?
how important is your appearance to you, versus your intelligence
or your hobbies? give fi ve words you feel describes your personality
as you interact face-to-face. how do you feel people confi de in
you or see you as trustworthy/sympathetic? what opinion do you
want people to have of you when they fi rst meet you? what are
three good things about you regarding relationships with others?
what are three bad things about you regarding relationships with
others? where do you see yourself in fi ve years? - hopefully and
realistically? how much do your hobbies and friends come before
a relationship? what are some faults they might fi nd after getting
to know you? how much do you feel like an adult vs. a child and
still learning? how willing are you to put people’s needs in front
of your own? give fi ve words you feel describe the way you see
yourself. what are some of the largest obstacles you’ve overcome?
what is your role at a party where you know everyone? how
important is being fi nancially successful to you? what is your role
at a party where you know no one? do you feel you know your
identity very well? how important is human interaction for you?
what types of people irritate you the most? how important is
music to you and why? how important is it for you to be liked?
how do you typically meet people? do you consider yourself
cultured? when do you feel most attractive? do you see yourself
as attractive? what do you lie about the most? how important is
family to you? do you consider yourself smart? what are your guilty
pleasures? what are some of your fears? do you get irritated easily?
WHAT CONSTITUTES THE CRITERIA?1
24
3
5
??how would you feel about going somewhere isolated and being alone
?how would you feel about going somewhere isolated and being alone
there with your thoughts? what are some major changes in your
?there with your thoughts? what are some major changes in your
personality that have happened in the past three years? what areas of
?personality that have happened in the past three years? what areas of
your life/aspects of your personality do you feel you conceal the most?
?your life/aspects of your personality do you feel you conceal the most?
how important is your appearance to you, versus your intelligence
?how important is your appearance to you, versus your intelligence
or your hobbies? give fi ve words you feel describes your personality
?or your hobbies? give fi ve words you feel describes your personality or your hobbies? give fi ve words you feel describes your personality
?or your hobbies? give fi ve words you feel describes your personality
as you interact face-to-face. how do you feel people confi de in
?as you interact face-to-face. how do you feel people confi de in as you interact face-to-face. how do you feel people confi de in
?as you interact face-to-face. how do you feel people confi de in
you or see you as trustworthy/sympathetic? what opinion do you
?you or see you as trustworthy/sympathetic? what opinion do you you or see you as trustworthy/sympathetic? what opinion do you
?you or see you as trustworthy/sympathetic? what opinion do you
want people to have of you when they fi rst meet you? what are ?want people to have of you when they fi rst meet you? what are want people to have of you when they fi rst meet you? what are ?want people to have of you when they fi rst meet you? what are
three good things about you regarding relationships with others? ?three good things about you regarding relationships with others? three good things about you regarding relationships with others? ?three good things about you regarding relationships with others?
what are three bad things about you regarding relationships with ?what are three bad things about you regarding relationships with what are three bad things about you regarding relationships with ?what are three bad things about you regarding relationships with
others? where do you see yourself in fi ve years? - hopefully and ?others? where do you see yourself in fi ve years? - hopefully and others? where do you see yourself in fi ve years? - hopefully and ?others? where do you see yourself in fi ve years? - hopefully and
realistically? how much do your hobbies and friends come before ?realistically? how much do your hobbies and friends come before realistically? how much do your hobbies and friends come before ?realistically? how much do your hobbies and friends come before
a relationship? what are some faults they might fi nd after getting ?a relationship? what are some faults they might fi nd after getting a relationship? what are some faults they might fi nd after getting ?a relationship? what are some faults they might fi nd after getting
to know you? how much do you feel like an adult vs. a child and ?to know you? how much do you feel like an adult vs. a child and to know you? how much do you feel like an adult vs. a child and ?to know you? how much do you feel like an adult vs. a child and
still learning? how willing are you to put people’s needs in front ?still learning? how willing are you to put people’s needs in front still learning? how willing are you to put people’s needs in front ?still learning? how willing are you to put people’s needs in front
of your own? give fi ve words you feel describe the way you see ?of your own? give fi ve words you feel describe the way you see of your own? give fi ve words you feel describe the way you see ?of your own? give fi ve words you feel describe the way you see
yourself. what are some of the largest obstacles you’ve overcome? ?yourself. what are some of the largest obstacles you’ve overcome? yourself. what are some of the largest obstacles you’ve overcome? ?yourself. what are some of the largest obstacles you’ve overcome?
what is your role at a party where you know everyone? how ?what is your role at a party where you know everyone? how
important is being fi nancially successful to you? what is your role ?important is being fi nancially successful to you? what is your role
at a party where you know no one? do you feel you know your ?at a party where you know no one? do you feel you know your
identity very well? how important is human interaction for you? ?identity very well? how important is human interaction for you?
what types of people irritate you the most? how important is ?what types of people irritate you the most? how important is
music to you and why? how important is it for you to be liked? ?music to you and why? how important is it for you to be liked?
how do you typically meet people? do you consider yourself ?how do you typically meet people? do you consider yourself
cultured? when do you feel most attractive? do you see yourself ?cultured? when do you feel most attractive? do you see yourself
as attractive? what do you lie about the most? how important is ?as attractive? what do you lie about the most? how important is
family to you? do you consider yourself smart? what are your guilty ?family to you? do you consider yourself smart? what are your guilty
pleasures? what are some of your fears? do you get irritated easily??pleasures? what are some of your fears? do you get irritated easily?
It’s close to impossible to answer how you would defi ne your
identity. When asked, we instead choose to use facts - our
heritage, our appearance, our hobbies, our relationships, etc.
The actual answer is too fl uid and abstract to put into words,
and is unwelcome in many ways because we exist in a realm
of feelings. You might consider the people you surround
yourself with best refl ect your identity. You might consider
your experiences growing up best refl ect your identity. You
might consider your relationship with your family describes
you, or the approach you take to meeting new people.
Everyone shifts himself or herself and their actions based on
situational circumstances, and because of this it becomes
impossible to confi dently communicate to others and, more
importantly, to yourself how you defi ne yourself.
How can one confi dently list their fi ve best qualities? Or
worst qualities? How can one confi dently consider how they
appear through the eyes of an observer? These questions that
are impossible to answer, and especially when meticulously
considered, can make any person feel marginalized. The role and structure of social media makes this question
much easier to answer. The tactile records of your photographs,
favorite quotes, correspondence, likes and dislikes, statuses,
refl ections on events, education history, relationship status,
etc, create defi nitive boundaries within which we package
and transmit our brand. We’ve been handed, what can be
considered, a valid record of our actions and personality
aspects as we appear to the rest of the world.
YOUR SECOND BRAND HAS VISUALUNSURE? DEFINING YOUR BRAND IS DIFFICULT.
+
Wall
h
What’s
on your mind?
Attach:
Full Name
Share
ViewPhotos of M
e (#)
ViewVideos of M
e (#)
Neque porro quisquam est qui
dolorem ipsumInform
ation
Friends
ideo
Notes
Vivamus vel purus eu ligula consequat rutrum
.
Date & Time Com
ment • Like • See Wall-to-Wall
Options
User Name Sed in libero sed
ipsum suscipit gravida
on (Date) clear
Networks:Relationship Status:
Birthday:Current City:
Donec nibh magna
Donec lacus libero, ullamcorper
in porttitor eget
Month Day,y,y YearYearY
Praesent lacinia ornare
# friends
lelbum Nam
e
about
) agoCreated about
(blank) ago
2 of # videos
See All
See All
Video Name
Video Name
Video Length Added about (blank) agoVideo Length Added about (blank) ago
# of Notesote Name
me
ime & Date Posted | # of Comments
Posted | # of Comments
Info
Photos
Boxes
RECENT ACTIVITY
(User) posteda link to (Full Nam
e)’s Wall.
(User) is attending(Event)
Comm
ent • Like • Invite Guests
(User) andFull Nam
e are now friends. Comm
ent • Like
Full Name
Duis quis tincidunt arcu.
Date & Time Com
ment • Like • See Wall-to-Wall
User Name
Etiamvel felis sit am
et mauris bibendum
sodales.
Date & Time • Com
ment • Like
Full Name and Full Nam
e like this.
Write a comment...
Write a comment...
Full Name Nullam
vitae massa vel nunc consequat
pellentesque. Praesent malesuada.
Date & Time • Delete
Full Name
Nulla vel tellus a lorem ornare luctus.
Date & Time Com
ment • Like • See Wall-to-Wall
ull Name
Ut porttitor comm
odo imperdiet. Donec laoreet erat ut.
& Time Com
ment • Like • See Wall-to-Wall
Name
Aliquamvolutpat lectus orci. M
orbi id lectus enim, a fringilla arcu.
e & Time Com
ment • Like • See Wall-to-Wall
RECENT ACTIVITY(User) wrote on (Full Nam
e)’s Wall.
(User) andFull Nam
e are now friends. Comm
ent • Like
(User) comm
entedon (Full Nam
e)’s photo.
(User) wrote on (Full Name)’s W
all.
RECENT ACTIVITY
(User) comm
entedon (Full Nam
e)’s photo.
(User) comm
entedon (Full Nam
e)’s photo.
# of similar stories
Write a comment...
User Name Nullam
vitae massa vel nunc consequat
pellentesque. Praesent malesuada.
Date & Time • Delete
Full Name
Ut porttitor comm
odo imperdiet.
Date & Time Com
ment • Like • See Wall-to-Wall
Full Name uspendisse venenatis, nunc vitae pellentesque
fermentum
, purus semaliquam
odio.
Date & Time • Delete
Full Name
Donec lacinia adipiscing suscipit. Vestibulum
odio nunc, posuere eget tempus id, gravida.
Date & Time Com
ment • Like • See Wall-to-Wall
Full NameIn these photos: User Nam
e
Album Nam
eDate &
Time • View
album
Older Posts
Create an
Proin pellentesque, nunc
eu auctor cursus, mauris
turpis dictum libero,
tristique.Like
Donec dapibus nisl sit
amet erat lobortis
elementum
. Suspendisse
aliquet sapienLike
x
Namdapibus vulputate
sapien, id malesuada
tortor molestie eu.
Curabitur et consequat
orci.
Like
x
More Ads
1
2
3
4
5
6
Photos
Vide
See All
FullName
FullName
FullName
FullName
FullName
FullName
2 of # albums
See All
Album Nam
eAlbu
Created ab
(blank)C
FuDate &Full Nam
Date &
23
MAGGIE, 23SINGLEPUBLISHER SERVICES MANAGERB.A. IN MUSIC BUSINESSDENVER, CO
53 47DURINGTHE DAY
PERCENTOF THE T IME
POSTS
DURINGTHE NIGHT
PERCENTOF THE T IME
ABOUT ME TOPIC RAT IOS
POST RAT IOS
L IKED I T
FOUND IT
SHARED I T
AVERAGE MOOD/TONE
SAD HAPPY
OTHERSHOPPING
FOOD
SPORTS
TECH
TRAVEL
“date night with desiree.. sushi
& sunsets”
“iced tea and a sandwich for breakfast.. itʼs like a summer
afternoon at my house”
“i still plan on wearing my tebow shirt all football season”
“imperfectionis beauty,madness is
genius”
“canʼt tellthe difference between hipster and homeless anymore”
“Dear Sir/Madam, the fact that your car has blue balls hanging from the trailer hitch does not make me respect you”
MOST POPUL AR UPDATE
“The wor ld at once present and absent which the spectacle
makes visible
what it is is the wor ld of the commodity dominat ing al l that is l ived. The wor ld of the commodity is thus shown for
because i ts movement is ident ical to the estrangement of men among themselves and in relat ion to their global product”
- Guy Debord The Society of the Spectacle
As has been the case for centuries, members of society have fi lled the role of spectacle to the general audience of peers.
However, as it refers to our development into a commodity, social networking pushes the boundaries of product quality into
product quantity. We have online versions of ourselves that are manufactured, produced and transmitted to the public, and
as we submit ourselves into circulation the commodities and surpluses of social media continue to grow. Engaging in these
digital communities we’ve developed a generally overlooked skill of pattern recognition; skimming the Facebook News Feed
we focus attention on familiar imagery and icons to gauge each commodity’s personal worth and connection to us. Just as
we are both subject and object, we are also consumers and commodities.,
The development of the millions of online human commodities transforms social media into so much more than a ‘service’,
as most would refer to it as. It has a structured means through which we can mold our brand, and an enormous built-in
audience that each user can tailor themselves towards. These interactions, which have now become second nature, lessens
awareness of humans as commodities rather than friends, followers, or connections. The habitual brand creation we subject
ourselves to another defi nition to add to the long list of social media purposes, but in a personal sense a lot can be brought
to light if users form a stronger awareness towards these tendencies they’ve developed.
m y u i f j g k l c d n w e y
9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d
. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e
, m i u e r g v a z q t y i h
m y u i f j g k l c d n w e y
9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d
. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e
, m i u e r g v a z q t y i h
m y u i f j g k l c d n w e y
9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d
. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e03. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
03. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e03n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e
, m i u e r g v a z q t y i h03, m i u e r g v a z q t y i h
m y u i f j g k l c d n w e y03m y u i f j g k l c d n w e y
9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d039 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d
. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x03. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e03n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e
m y u i f j g k l c d n w e ym y u i f j g k l c d n w e y
9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d
. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b en u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e
, m i u e r g v a z q t y i h, m i u e r g v a z q t y i h
m y u i f j g k l c d n w e ym y u i f j g k l c d n w e y
9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d
. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e
, m i u e r g v a z q t y i h
m y u i f j g k l c d n w e y
9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d
. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e
USER ASWe have all become observed.
We have all gained an audience.
We have all become reflected.
WE HAVE REPLACED THE EYE OF THE BEHOLDER WITHTHE EYE OF THE PUBLIC.
As the mediums of refl ection continue to evolve, so does has the intimacy of the moment to now include a greater
audience than just ourselves. We no longer gaze upon ourselves with our eyes, but instead through the eyes of our
audience. How do we use these mediums to better refl ect on how we are perceived? What does social media as a
medium for refl ection mean for our self esteem as we observe and contemplate?
SPECTACLE
35
WE OBSERVE OURSELVES
IS AN INTIMATE MOMENT DURING WHICH WE LOOK THROUGH THE EYES OF AN AUDIENCE.
The act of observing oneself or refl ecting on oneself
introduces a paradoxal question: how we view our role as an
individual and how we view our role in society. The intimacy
of this questioning, and its resulting drop in self esteem, is
consistent with the vast majority of humans. We utilize
refl ection tools to contemplate our identity as we believe we
are seen through the perspective of an outside observer.
THE MEDIUM OF OBSERVATION HAS SHIFTED SIGNIFICANTLY OVER TIME
The key signifi cance of its shift over the course of history fi nds merit
in the intimacy of the moment. The privacy of the environment
within which the user becomes pensive has evolved to include a
greater audience, therefore shifting perception of identity.
T I M E
WA
TE
R
The medium that initiated refl ection and self-awaress: water. As
Greek legend has it, the origin of the word narcissism comes from
Narcissus, the son of the river god Cephissus, who fell in love with
his own refl ection after he was instructed by his nemisis to look into
a pool of water. Narcissus subsequently wasted away and died, as
he was unable to pry himself away from the refl ection of his beauty5.
The invention of the mirror revolutionized our consciousness, and
created a greater awareness of humans as objects. Its uneditable
nature has been proven to lower self esteem, especially in the
minds of women. The ability to watch and judge an exact replica, or
essentially what can be considered a state of simulacrum, opened
up the human mind to the idea of having an audience which
now spread to include ourselves. Engaging with a mirror triggers
three states; body awareness - a physical observation - and the
mental consideration of private self-consciousness and public self-
consciousness.
MIR
RO
R
Photographs are the extension of the singular moment of private
refl ecting, and also make the moment reproducible. With the
inclusion of video, the aspect of time becomes a factor which raises
self-conscioussness. Photography produced the most eff ective craft
that refl ects and represents people as they appear to the masses,
especially since the image of self is able to be entered into public
circulation. A picture is worth a thousand words, and for this reason
the visual psychological cues and interpretations of information we
receive with this medium can alter a sense of identity when we have
become the subject matter.
PH
OT
OG
RA
PH
The revolutionary concept of social media and the online brand
have become second nature activities to the common user. In
regards to a widely unknown additional use for social media, the act
of identity refl ection has been reformed through this new medium.
The contemporary user has been handed an environment within
which they can not only represent themselves, but can shape their
character and brand to transmit a more idealized version of self.
SO
CIA
L M
ED
IA
Using social media as a medium for refl ection is widely successful in regards to self esteem because of its multiple dimensions,
which includes appearance, history, communication, thoughts, hobbies, etc. Following the ability to shape the engaging and
interactive replication of our brand, a heightened level of self esteem is a uniform result for the majority of social networkers.
It also houses archives of what can be considered the user’s inner development, such as personality traits, as well as the
user’s outer development, which includes physical appearance and relationships. Its structure makes it the most tactile form
of refl ection to date. For the fi rst time, the user has the ability to act as an author-of-self and revolutionize the concept of
identity. Following Marshall McLuhan’s theories that a change in medium results in a change of sensory experience, social
networking can be considered more than just a tool for communication but also a medium. It has become the new mirror; it
is a window into observing how we shape our idealized self and why.
47
SOURCES MacLuhan, H. M., & Fiore, Q. (1971). The Medium is the Massage: Inventory of Effects. Harmonsworth: Penguin Books.
Debord, G. (1977). The Commodity as the Spectacle, 37. In Society of the Spectacle. Detroit: Black and Red.
1 Fontaine, S. D. (2011, December 11). Top 11 Fake Deaths On Twitter. NewsOne. Retrieved from http://newsone. com/2000722/top-11-fake-deaths-on-twitter/
2 Ball, J., & Lewis, P. (2011, December 07). Twitter and the riots: How the news spread. The Guardian. Retrieved from http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2011dec/07/twitter-riots-how-news-spread
3 Sutter, J. D. (2011, May 02). How bin Laden news spread on Twitter. CNN. Retrieved from http://articles.cnn. com/2011-05-02/tech/osama.bin.laden.twitter_1bin-tweet-twitter-user?s=PM:TECH
4 Strauss, N. (2011, July 2). The Insidious Evils of ‘Like’ Culture. The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved from http://online. wsj.com/article/SB1000142405270230454004576415940086842866.html
5 Keys, D. (2004, May). The Ugly End of Narcissus. BBC History Magazine, 5, 9. Retrieved from http://www.papyrology. ox.ac.uk/POxy/news/narcissus.html
m y u i f j g k l c d n w e y
9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d
. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e
, m i u e r g v a z q t y i h
m y u i f j g k l c d n w e y
9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d
. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e
, m i u e r g v a z q t y i h
m y u i f j g k l c d n w e y
9 4 f j b m d k 1 z j f m v d
. j k i o v f r u h j e w z x
n u y m . f g 4 e q 7 8 g b e