Reading Words: The Instructional Road to Automaticity Dr. Kathleen J. Brown Director: University of Utah Reading Clinic www.uurc.org 801-265-3951
Reading Words: The Instructional Road to Automaticity
Dr. Kathleen J. Brown
Director: University of Utah Reading Clinic
www.uurc.org 801-265-3951
Expert Reading=Word Rec X Comp
Word Recognition is Automatic
accurate fast effortless
Comprehension is both Automatic & Strategic
accurate, fast, effortless
know how to troubleshoot flexible persistent
(Adams, 1990; Rayner, Foorman, Perfetti, Pesetsky, & Seidenberg, 2001)
Novice Reading=Word Rec X Comp
Word Recognition is Necessarily Strategic
often inaccurate slow effortful
Comprehension is both Automatic & Strategic
accurate, fast, effortless
know how to troubleshoot flexible persistent
(Adams, 1990; Rayner, Foorman, Perfetti, Pesetsky, & Seidenberg, 2001)
Novice Reading=Word Rec X Comp
Word Recognition is Necessarily Strategic:
often inaccurate slow effortful
Word Recognition Must Become Automatic.
Most children need explicit, systematic instruction phonics & practice in text.
Some need basic word rec. intervention!
A few need intensive word rec. intervention!
Age is Almost Irrelevant…
Phonics & Text Should Target the Child’s Instructional Level & Move as Mastery is Achieved!!!!
Identify Child’s Instructional Level: Text That Can Be Read With:
at least 93% accuracy, and rate of:
primer (mid G1)- at least 30 wpm end G1 - at least 40 wpm mid G2 – at least 60 wpm end G2 - at least 80 wpm mid G3 - at least 80 wpm end G3 – at least 110 wpm end G4 – at least 120 wpm
Three Questions to Ask Every Day about Every Child:
1. Right now, what is already “in this child’s head” for these words:
- cup?- spurt?- skullduggery?
a.k.a. representation in memory
2. Where should I go next with phonics to extend what is “in the head?”
3. What type of text is best for extending what is “in the head?”
IMPLICATION:
Phonics and Text Type should change over the course of development to:
1. reinforce what is already known and
2. help the child progress as quickly as possible
Know the “Race Course” of Word Recognition Development
STARTING LINE Learning About Print
pre-alphabetic to partial alphabetic reader K students
Breaking the Code (a.k.a. Glued to Print) **** partial alphabetic to full alphabetic reader
early to midG1
(Ehri, 2005; Stanovich, 2000)
What Needs To Be In Place to “Break the Code?”
Letter-sound correspondences (e.g., c = /k/)
Concept of word (1-to-1 voice to print match)
Identify and isolate first consonant phoneme in words
Short vowel sounds
What Kind of Phonics? Text?
Phonics: - explicitly teach blending a.k.a. “sound it out” with 3 letter, 1 syllable words with 1 short vowel
- drill vowel sound cards- speed check for accuracy & fluency (no<35 in 1min; no>2 errors)
Text Type: interesting texts with repetition of easy high frequency words; most other words are decodable (e.g., A Present for Baby Bear, Bob Books)
Text Levels: 4-8 (approximately) = oct-dec G1
Phonics: Short Vowels – Closed Syllables
cat win mom
Phonics: Short Vowels – Closed Syllables
cat win mom
lappigjob
Phonics: Short Vowels – Closed Syllables
cat win mom
lap pig job
hit
hop
flat
van
chip
rock
High Freq. Words for G1 Level Readers (beginners & strugglers)
get a list (e.g., Dolch) start with easiest & gradually complex use “flash” presentation
read off the deck sort into 2 piles: automatic vs. wrong or >3
second hesitation re-do “trouble” pile when deck n=25, retire 15 and build up again
for G1 readers, do not build “torture decks” every “trouble” word needs 5 fairly solid words
Three Questions to Ask Every Day about Every Child:
1. Right now, what is already “in this child’s head” for these words:
- cup?- spurt?- skullduggery?
a.k.a. representation in memory
2. Where should I go next with phonics to extend what is “in the head?”
3. What type of text is best for extending what is “in the head?”
Know the “Race Course” of Word Recognition Development
STARTING LINE Learning About Print
pre-alphabetic to partial alphabetic reader K students
Breaking the Code (a.k.a. Glued to Print) **** partial alphabetic to full alphabetic reader
early to midG1
Going for Fluency **** full alphabetic to early consolidated reader
endG1 – endG2 PARTIAL FINISH LINE & onward…
What Needs To Be In Place to “Go for Fluency?”
everything in the “learning about print” phase
automaticity for 50-75 high frequency words (e.g., the, said)
ability to quickly blend unfamiliar 3-5 letter 1 syllable words
What Kind of Phonics? Text?
Phonics: - explicitly teach chunking strategy with 4 and 5 letter 1 syllable words with most common phonograms (e.g., turn spurt)
- augment & drill vowel sound cards- speed check for accuracy & fluency (no<35 in 1min; no>2 errors)
Text Type: interesting “easy reader” texts that gradually increase in difficulty (e.g., Sammy the Seal Frog and Toad Nate the Great)
Text Levels: 8-12/16 (approximately) = jan-june G1
Phonics: Vowel Patterns – Syllable Types
cat lake barn
lap gate park
brain
sharpflame
van
tail
flat
rain
paid
High Frequency Words for G2+ Level Struggling Readers
get a list (e.g., Dolch) gradually build a word deck from oral reading
errors & list use “flash” presentation
read off the deck sort into 2 piles: automatic vs. wrong or >1.5
second hesitation re-do “trouble” pile when deck n=25, retire some and add as
needed
Irregular & High Frequency Words
For persistent “trouble” words, try: Letter-Sound-Trouble Analysis Make-n-Break 2,2,&2
For persistent “trouble” words, child must: Say word aloud as often as possible
Ask “What word?” Spell word aloud Physical manipulatives can help! Visualization can help!
Three Questions to Ask Every Day about Every Child:
1. Right now, what is already “in this child’s head” for these words:
- cup?- spurt?- skullduggery?
a.k.a. representation in memory
2. Where should I go next with phonics to extend what is “in the head?”
3. What type of text is best for extending what is “in the head?”
What Kind of Phonics? Text?
Phonics: - explicitly teach syllable types, division, & morphemic knowledge (e.g., skullduggery, disruptive)
a.k.a. representation in memory
Text Type: interesting texts with some control that gradually increase in difficulty (e.g., Marvin Redpost Magic Tree House )
Text Levels: 18 and up = end G1 and on
Types of Syllables: Driven by Orthography & Morphology
cup, branch
the, of, who, enough
lake, barn, tail
hopped, pretest, provoke, incandescent
Closed syllables
High Frequency & Irregular
Vowel patterns
Words with affixes and polysyllabic words
(Henry, 1990; Moats, 2000; Morris, 2005; UURC, 2006; Wilson, 2006)
“Breaking Up” Big Words: Syllable Types & Morphemes
velvet decline
hobo rumple
incandescent boisterous
confirmatory disruptive
Three Questions to Ask Every Day about Every Child:
1. Right now, what is already “in this child’s head” for these words (e.g., cup, burn, skullduggery)?
a.k.a. representation in memory
2. Where should I go next with phonics to extend current representations?
3. What type of text is best practice for extending current representations?
Resources for Educators & Parents
Discover Intensive Phonics Wilson Language/Fundations LETRS (Language Essentials for Teachers of
Reading & Spelling) Texts by Louisa Moats, Marcia Henry, Isabel
Beck, Words Their Way group
University of Utah Reading Clinic (UURC) 801-265-3951 or www.uurc.org