Top Banner
Rare Event Simulations Theory 16.1 Transition state theory 16.1-16.2 Bennett-Chandler Approach 16.2 Diffusive Barrier crossings 16.3 Transition path ensemble 16.4
19

Rare Event Simulations Theory 16.1 Transition state theory 16.1-16.2 Bennett-Chandler Approach 16.2 Diffusive Barrier crossings 16.3 Transition path ensemble.

Dec 16, 2015

Download

Documents

Keira Shippy
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Rare Event Simulations Theory 16.1 Transition state theory 16.1-16.2 Bennett-Chandler Approach 16.2 Diffusive Barrier crossings 16.3 Transition path ensemble.

Rare Event Simulations

Theory 16.1Transition state theory 16.1-16.2Bennett-Chandler Approach 16.2Diffusive Barrier crossings 16.3Transition path ensemble 16.4

Page 2: Rare Event Simulations Theory 16.1 Transition state theory 16.1-16.2 Bennett-Chandler Approach 16.2 Diffusive Barrier crossings 16.3 Transition path ensemble.

Diffusion in porous material

Page 3: Rare Event Simulations Theory 16.1 Transition state theory 16.1-16.2 Bennett-Chandler Approach 16.2 Diffusive Barrier crossings 16.3 Transition path ensemble.

Theory:macroscopic

phenomenological

A BChemical reaction

d

dtA

A B A B A B

c tk c t k c t

d

dtB

A B A B A B

c tk c t k c t

Total number of molecules

d0

dtA Bc t c t

Equilibrium:

0A Bc t c t

A B A

B A B

c k

c k

Make a small perturbation

A A Ac t c c t

d

dtA

A B A B A A

c tk c t k c t

B B Ac t c c t

0 expA A A B B Ac t c k k t 0 expAc t

1

A B B Ak k

11 1 BA B A B

A B

ck c c

k

Page 4: Rare Event Simulations Theory 16.1 Transition state theory 16.1-16.2 Bennett-Chandler Approach 16.2 Diffusive Barrier crossings 16.3 Transition path ensemble.

Theory:microscopic

linear response theory

Microscopic description of the reaction

Reaction coordinate

*q qReactant A:

Product B: *q q

Perturbation: 0 *AH H g q q

Lowers the potential energy in AIncreases the concentration of A

* 1 * *Ag q q q q q q

Heaviside θ-function

0 * 0*

1 * 0

q qq q

q q

0A A Ac c c

0A A Ac g g

Probability to be in state A

βF

(q)

q

q*

q

Reaction coordinate

Page 5: Rare Event Simulations Theory 16.1 Transition state theory 16.1-16.2 Bennett-Chandler Approach 16.2 Diffusive Barrier crossings 16.3 Transition path ensemble.

2 2

00

AA A

cg g

Very small perturbation: linear response theory

0A A Ac g g

0 *AH H g q q

Outside the barrier gA =0 or 1:gA (x) gA (x) =gA (x)

0 01A Ag g

0 0 0 01A A A Bc c c c

Switch of the perturbation: dynamic linear response

00

A A

A AA B

g g tc t c

c c

0 expAc t

Holds for sufficiently long times!

Linear response theory: static

0H H B

0A A A

0

00

d exp

d exp

A HA

H

0

0

d exp

d exp

A H BA

H B

0 0

2

0

0 0

2

0

d exp d exp

d exp

d exp d exp

d exp

AB H B H BA

H B

A H B B H B

H B

0 0 0

AAB A B

Page 6: Rare Event Simulations Theory 16.1 Transition state theory 16.1-16.2 Bennett-Chandler Approach 16.2 Diffusive Barrier crossings 16.3 Transition path ensemble.

0exp

A A

A B

g g tt

c c

For sufficiently short t

01exp

A A

A B

g g tt

c c

Derivative

Δ has disappeared because of derivative

0A A

A B

g g t

c c

0A A

A BA

g g tk t

c

* ** A B

A

g q q g q qg q q q q

q q

0 *0 B

B

A BA

g q qq g t

qk t

c

' 0d

A t B t tdt

' ' 0A t B t t A t B t t

0 ' 0 'A B t A B t

Stationary

Page 7: Rare Event Simulations Theory 16.1 Transition state theory 16.1-16.2 Bennett-Chandler Approach 16.2 Diffusive Barrier crossings 16.3 Transition path ensemble.

Eyring’s transition state theory

0 *0 B

B

A BA

g q qq g t

qk t

c

0 0 * *

*

q q q q t q

q q

At t=0 particles are at the top of the barrier

Only products contribute to the average

Let us consider the limit: t →0+

0lim *

tq t q q t

0 0 *

*TSTA B

q q q qk t

q q

* 1 * *B Ag q q g q q q q

**Bg q q

q qq

* 1 * *Ag q q q q q q

Page 8: Rare Event Simulations Theory 16.1 Transition state theory 16.1-16.2 Bennett-Chandler Approach 16.2 Diffusive Barrier crossings 16.3 Transition path ensemble.

Transition state theory

• One has to know the free energy accurately

• Gives an upper bound to the reaction rate

• Assumptions underlying transition theory should hold: no recrossings

Page 9: Rare Event Simulations Theory 16.1 Transition state theory 16.1-16.2 Bennett-Chandler Approach 16.2 Diffusive Barrier crossings 16.3 Transition path ensemble.

Bennett-Chandler approach

0 0 * *

*A B

q q q q t qk t

q q

0 0 * * 0 *

*0 *A B

q q q q t q q qk t

q qq q

Conditional average:given that we start on top of the barrier

0 *q q t q Probability to find q on top of

the barrier

Computational scheme:

1. Determine the probability from the free energy2. Compute the conditional average from a MD simulation

Page 10: Rare Event Simulations Theory 16.1 Transition state theory 16.1-16.2 Bennett-Chandler Approach 16.2 Diffusive Barrier crossings 16.3 Transition path ensemble.

cage window cage

βF

(q)

q

q*

cage window cage

βF

(q)

q

q*

Reaction coordinate

Page 11: Rare Event Simulations Theory 16.1 Transition state theory 16.1-16.2 Bennett-Chandler Approach 16.2 Diffusive Barrier crossings 16.3 Transition path ensemble.

Ideal gas particle and a hill

q1 is the estimated transition state

q* is the true transition state

Page 12: Rare Event Simulations Theory 16.1 Transition state theory 16.1-16.2 Bennett-Chandler Approach 16.2 Diffusive Barrier crossings 16.3 Transition path ensemble.
Page 13: Rare Event Simulations Theory 16.1 Transition state theory 16.1-16.2 Bennett-Chandler Approach 16.2 Diffusive Barrier crossings 16.3 Transition path ensemble.
Page 14: Rare Event Simulations Theory 16.1 Transition state theory 16.1-16.2 Bennett-Chandler Approach 16.2 Diffusive Barrier crossings 16.3 Transition path ensemble.
Page 15: Rare Event Simulations Theory 16.1 Transition state theory 16.1-16.2 Bennett-Chandler Approach 16.2 Diffusive Barrier crossings 16.3 Transition path ensemble.

Bennett-Chandler approach

• Results are independent of the precise location of the estimate of the transition state, but the accuracy does.

• If the transmission coefficient is very low– Poor estimate of the reaction coordinate– Diffuse barrier crossing

Page 16: Rare Event Simulations Theory 16.1 Transition state theory 16.1-16.2 Bennett-Chandler Approach 16.2 Diffusive Barrier crossings 16.3 Transition path ensemble.

Transition path sampling

0exp

A A

A B

g g tt

c c

01 exp

A B t

BA

h x h xC t h t

h

1 in

0 elsewhereA

Ah

0 0 0

0 0 0

d

d

A B t

A

x N x h x h xC t

x N x h x

xt is fully determined by the initial condition

,B t A t

C t h x 0 0path AP h x N x

Path that starts at A and is in time t in B: importance sampling in these paths

Page 17: Rare Event Simulations Theory 16.1 Transition state theory 16.1-16.2 Bennett-Chandler Approach 16.2 Diffusive Barrier crossings 16.3 Transition path ensemble.
Page 18: Rare Event Simulations Theory 16.1 Transition state theory 16.1-16.2 Bennett-Chandler Approach 16.2 Diffusive Barrier crossings 16.3 Transition path ensemble.

Walking in the Ensemble

Shooting

Shifting

A

r0o r0

n

B

rTn

rTo

r0o

r0n

AB

rt

ptn pt

o

p

rTo

rTn

Page 19: Rare Event Simulations Theory 16.1 Transition state theory 16.1-16.2 Bennett-Chandler Approach 16.2 Diffusive Barrier crossings 16.3 Transition path ensemble.