Top Banner
83

Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster

Mar 28, 2015

Download

Documents

Maryam Griffin
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 2: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 3: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 4: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Maryam Griffin
Page 5: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Page 6: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Unclear on this
Page 7: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Page 8: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Althusser says that the content of the knowledge is what maintains domination and NOT the form of education whereby the bourgeoisie are imparting anything on the working class.
Maryam Griffin
For Ranciere, the division between science and ideology (where the first is real, the second is not knowledge) is central to maintaining the domination of the class who possesses "real knowledge."
Page 9: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Relationship between intelligence and knowledge??
Page 10: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Page 11: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Storytelling varifies equality.
Maryam Griffin
Presuming equality rather than trying to implement it...
Page 12: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 13: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 14: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Page 15: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Page 16: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
The superior intelligence transmits knowledge to the inferior intelligence according to the latter's capacities and then the former assesses whether the latter understands sufficiently.
Maryam Griffin
The more he is enlightened, the more he'll insist on the spirit over the letter...!Also, a focus on method, or methodical thinking...
Page 17: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
***How does this coalesce with beliefs about false consciousness and hegemony?
Maryam Griffin
What about the perhaps "superior" intelligence of crafting and assigning the exercise?? What about his engagement in evaluating their comprehension?
Page 18: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
***What counts is the "capacity to say what one thinks in the words of others" - this is troubling and also a bit confusing!Counts for what? Who determines and how?
Page 19: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
*But doesn't this domination of one will over another presume the dominant will knows better about what the subordinate will should do/know/learn??
Maryam Griffin
Emancipation is the act of an intelligence obeying only itself while the will obeys another will???
Page 20: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Pedagogical relation: ignorance vs science; philosophical relation: stultification vs. emancipation
Maryam Griffin
Emancipated student is obliged to use his own intelligence - then master can teach what he doesn't know...
Page 21: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Page 22: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Page 23: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Page 24: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Page 25: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Page 26: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Page 27: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 28: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Maryam Griffin
Page 29: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Maryam Griffin
Page 30: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 31: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 32: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Maryam Griffin
Page 33: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 34: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 35: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 36: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 37: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 38: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 39: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 40: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 41: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 42: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 43: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 44: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 45: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 46: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 47: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 48: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 49: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 50: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 51: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 52: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 53: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 54: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 55: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 56: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 57: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 58: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 59: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 60: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 61: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 62: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 63: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 64: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 65: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 66: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 67: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 68: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 69: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 70: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 71: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 72: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 73: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 74: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 75: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 76: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 77: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 78: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 79: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 80: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 81: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 82: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster
Page 83: Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster

Related Documents
'The Ignorant Schoolmaster' by Jacques Ranciere€¦  · Web view[This is my very rough translation of an address given by Ranciere. It should be noted that the word "master" that

'The Ignorant Schoolmaster' by Jacques Ranciere€¦  ·.....

Category: Documents
THE OLD AND THE NEW SCHOOLMASTER

THE OLD AND THE NEW SCHOOLMASTER

Category: Documents
Le maître ignorant - ekladata.comekladata.com/.../Ranciere-Le-Maitre-Ignorant.pdf · Le maître ignorant cinq leçons sur l’émancipation intellectuelle Jacques Rancière Librairie

Le maître ignorant -...

Category: Documents
Ranciere Disagreement Police

Ranciere Disagreement Police

Category: Documents
Ranciere the Ignorant Schoolmaster

Ranciere the Ignorant Schoolmaster

Category: Documents
RANCIERE- ESPECTADOR EMANCIPADO

RANCIERE- ESPECTADOR EMANCIPADO

Category: Documents
the Ignorant Schoolmaster

the Ignorant Schoolmaster

Category: Documents
Ranciere Althusser's Lesson

Ranciere Althusser's Lesson

Category: Documents
The Ignorant Schoolmaster (Five Lessons in Intellectual Emancipation) - Jacques Rancière

The Ignorant Schoolmaster (Five Lessons in Intellectual...

Category: Documents
Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster[1]

Ranciere - The Ignorant Schoolmaster[1]

Category: Documents
the Village Schoolmaster[1]

the Village Schoolmaster[1]

Category: Documents
Jacques Ranciere

Jacques Ranciere

Category: Documents