Raising Exploration Capital in Southern Africa A Diamonds Perspective James AH Campbell Managing Director, Botswana Diamonds plc Mining Investment Botswana 2019
Raising Exploration Capital in Southern AfricaA Diamonds Perspective
James AH Campbell
Managing Director, Botswana Diamonds plc
Mining Investment Botswana 2019
2
Mining Investment Botswana 21-22 May 2019, Gaborone
Raising Exploration Capital in Southern Africa: A Diamonds Perspective
Outline
⧫ Diamond industry fundamentals
⧫ Global exploration trends
⧫ Why Southern Africa
⧫ Developing diamond projects
⧫ Financing exploration projects
⧫ Discussion & Conclusions
2Mining Investment Botswana 2019
3
Diamond Industry Fundamentals
Mining Investment Botswana 2019
Mining Investment Botswana 2019
Positive Supply & Demand Outlook
⧫ ‘Moderately optimistic’ long-term outlook: rough diamond supply predictable and stable until 2030; rough diamond demand expected to grow 2-4% (nominal) per annum
⧫ Continued growth of middle class in China and India underpins growth forecast
⧫ Key challenges: US-China trade war; substitution from laboratory-grown diamonds; financial stability of midstream segment
⧫ Digital technologies delivering improved efficiencies throughout the value chain
Source: Bain & co., 2018
Mining Investment Botswana 2019 4
Mining Investment Botswana 2019
Rough and polished prices trending up
Source: Bain & co., 2018
⧫ Rough and polished prices trended up during the first half of 2018
⧫ Macroeconomic fundamentals driving both polished and rough diamond prices remain positive in the longer term
⧫ The forecast supply-demand shortfall will trend diamond prices generally upwards in the years ahead
Mining Investment Botswana 2019
Diamond price stability
Mining Investment Botswana 2019
⧫ Fastest commodity to recover following the GFC
⧫ Less prone to volatility than mainstream commodities
⧫ Rough diamond prices expected to continue outperforming gold in years ahead
⧫ Diamonds attracting interest as an investment category
6
7
Global Exploration Trends
Mining Investment Botswana 2019
8
Global exploration spend on the rise
⧫ Global exploration activity strengthening on the back of rising bulk commodity prices
⧫ Global budgets expected to increase by 5-10% in 2019
⧫ Gold accounted for half of global exploration budgets in 2018
⧫ SA exploration budgets have steadily declined over the past 10 years
⧫ Why isn’t Southern Africa attracting a larger share of exploration budgets?
Sources: S&P Global; Stockhead
Mining Investment Botswana 2019
Global exploration budgets are still below 2014 levels
9
Grassroot exploration spend declining
⧫ Grassroots exploration budgets declining since the 1990’s
⧫ Minesite budgets upward trend reflects industry risk aversion
⧫ Projects developed by majors with existing cash flows and some bank funding
⧫ Juniors are not benefiting from the rising annual exploration budgets
Mining Investment Botswana 2019
10
Why Southern Africa
Mining Investment Botswana 2019
11
A highly prospective diamond region
⧫ Prospective Archean cratons hosting significant
diamond deposits
⧫ Solid track record of economic diamond production
⧫ One third of global carat production in 2018
⧫ Limited competition
Bain & co., 2018
Mining Investment Botswana 2019
Kimberlites in southern Africa. Source: De Wit et al, June 2016
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
40 45 50 55 60 65 70 75 80 85
Dia
mo
nd
pro
spec
tivi
ty r
anki
ng*
Mining investment attractiveness**
Cumulative diamond production (2008-2017) for selected African countries***
12
*Author’s own research, **Adapted from Fraser Institute, 2018, *** Kimberley Process data, 2017
High exploration attractiveness
Change since 2017
South Africa
Namibia
DRC
Botswana
Zimbabwe
Angola (2015)
Tanzania
Mining Investment Botswana 2019
Investors deterred by perceived risk
13
Southern Africa is becoming more attractive, however perceptions of hostile investment environments still deter investors
Investment Attractiveness Index (Fraser Institute, 2018): a composite of mineral investment and policy perception factors.
⧫ Botswana is the highest ranked African country
⧫ SA and Zimbabwe’s policy rankings have improved significantly in the last year
⧫ Unclear legislation is a concern for investors
⧫ DRC and Zimbabwe policy perceptions rank in the bottom 10 globally
⧫ Africa ranks as the second least attractive region for investment globally
Mining Investment Botswana 2019
Mining Investment Botswana 2019
Few key players, limited local funding
Company Listing Country of activity Producer (P) Explorer (E)
Market Cap(various currencies)
Alrosa MCX Angola, Zimbabwe E, P 10.5 BN USD
BlueRock Diamonds AIM South Africa P 1.5 M ZAR
Botswana Diamonds
AIM Botswana, South Africa, Zimbabwe
E 4 M GBP
De Beers N/A Botswana, Namibia, South Africa, Angola
P, E N/A
Diamcor Mining TSX-V, OTC South Africa P 8.6 M CAD
Firestone Diamonds AIM Lesotho P 12.1 M GPB
Gem Diamonds LSE Botswana, Lesotho 123 M GBP
Lucapa Diamond ASX Angola, Lesotho, Botswana
P, E 81.8 M AUD
Lucara Diamond TSX, BSE Botswana, Lesotho P, E 661 M CAD
Pangolin Diamonds TSX-V Botswana E 5.7 M CAD
Petra Diamonds LSE Botswana, South Africa, Tanzania
P 180.6 M USD
Trans Hex JSE South Africa P, E 63 M ZAR
Tsodilo Resources TSX-V Botswana, South Africa
E 9.1 M CAD
⧫ Predominantly foreign-listed
juniors and mid-tier
⧫ Limited production cashflow
to fund exploration activities
⧫ Primarily funded through
equity capital out of the UK,
Canada and Australia
⧫ Subject to full extent of
onerous regulatory and
reporting obligations
⧫ No significant projects in the
pipeline, beyond Alrosa’s
Luaxe
⧫ No evidence of exploration
activities gaining momentumSource: company websites, Mincosa
14
15
Developing Diamond Projects
Mining Investment Botswana 2019
Mining Investment Botswana 2019
Risk reduction investment begets investor appetite
Mapping, sampling,
geophysics
Core drilling or trenching (100’s kg)
Initial bulk sampling
(10-100’s t)
Infill drilling; bulk sampling
(1000’s t)
Inferred Resource
Indicated Resource
Diamond potential; surface size estimate
Preliminary grade estimate; prelim. geological model
Global grade; preliminary value
estimate
Geological, density, volume, grade, revenue models
Technical Economic Evaluation
Pre-Feasibility Study
Bankable Feasibility Study
MineralisationTarget / Anomaly
Act
ivit
yO
utc
om
esM
iner
al
Res
ou
rce
Eco
no
mic
St
ud
ies
Duration: months
Cost: USD thousands
Duration: years
Cost: USD millions
⧫ Investors’ appetite grows with confidence, as do costs and timeframes
⧫ Compressing timeframes without compromising on quality
⧫ Maximising optionality (phased approach)
⧫ Reliable resource models
⧫ Extract value or cut losses early
⧫ Deep expertise and technology are key differentiators
16
INCREASING COSTS & TIMEFRAMES
DECREASING UNCERTAINTY & RISK
17
Stakeholders’ expectations
Revenue
Job creation
Beneficiation
Sustainable development
Political stability
Good governance
Security of investment
Diamond prospectivity
Track record of economic production
Security of tenure
Tax incentives
Enabling regulatory environment
Economic growth
Credit rating
Social licence
to operate
Investors
Explorers
Governments
Commercial
return
Mining Investment Botswana 2019
Mining Investment Botswana 2019
Junior regulatory compliance similar to majors
⧫ Mineral reporting requirements vary across jurisdictions
⧫ Most reporting standards share common codes and guidelines, e.g. CIM, JORC, SAMREC
⧫ Public reporting by Competent Persons (‘CPs’) must adhere to minimum standards set by professional codes of practice
⧫ Relevance and transparency of reporting is critical to attracting junior funding, yet onerous
⧫ TSX, AIM and ASX host the bulk of junior and mid-tier exploration companies
Source: PWC, Stock Exchanges, Mining Association of Canada
Mining Investment Botswana 2019 18
19
Funding Exploration Projects
Mining Investment Botswana 2019
Value creation and risk
20Mining Investment Botswana 2019
Share price growth from one AFD share on listing (2005): 25x at Lucara peak share price
⧫ Early investors recognized the potential, took the risk and extracted substantial value from African Diamonds plc share price growth
⧫ Would AK6 be Karowe Mine today, were it not for ‘Friends, Family & Fools’?
Fast-forward more than ten years: has anything changed?
Potential: early gains and long-term value
21Mining Investment Botswana 2019
Mining Investment Botswana 2019
Traditional or alternative funding?
⧫ Traditional equity and debt
financing has been
constrained by falling
commodity prices and
continued uncertainty
⧫ Alternative funding sources
better suited to junior and
mid-tier miners
⧫ Investors with higher risk
appetite and faster decision-
making than banks
⧫ Alternatives seldom accessible
to early stage ‘greenfield’
project developers
Modified after PwC, 2013
22Mining Investment Botswana 2019
Mining Investment Botswana 2019 23
SA’s exploration funding incentive is failing
Mining Investment Botswana 2019
⧫ Mining funds designed to benefit from tax concessions in the South African Income Tax Act (2009) have emerged recently
⧫ Section 12J grants venture capital companies (VCCs) a 100% deduction of the amount invested in a mining company before it can generate taxable income from production
⧫ The mining company must be unlisted, or a junior listed on the AltX of JSE
⧫ Section 12J initiative was intended to boost junior exploration funding in South Africa, similarly to the Flow-through share scheme in Canada
⧫ Sadly, Section 12J has not achieved the purpose it was designed for.
Mining Investment Botswana 2019
Funders with expertise, such as HDI, 162 Group and Lundin Group, have effectively applied a mix of entrepreneurial skills, business experience and risk appetite in the resources space to develop opportunities with potential.
24
Where are the new mining incubators?
Hunter Dickinson Inc. Lundin Group 162 Group Burgundy Diamonds
For over 30 years, HDI have successfully identified, acquired and developed mineral assets with high growth potential. Their portfolio has featured over 15 private and listed companies with projects around the world. HDI have raised more than CAD 1.9 billion in equity financing since 1985 and generated healthy returns on equity capital for shareholders.
Founded in 1971 by Adolf Lundin, theLundin Group has raised billions of dollars to fund resource projects in the mining and oil/gas sectors. Progressive and true to its visionary founder’s philosophy, today it comprises twelve listed companies operating in over twenty countries.
Focused on high potential natural resource start-ups, the 162 Group has negotiated over 30 joint ventures with multinationals and established 15 listed resources companies with interests across the globe, including AIM-listed Botswana Diamonds. The162 Group’s core strategy is to identify opportunities, create the project, work with partners and develop.
A new entity focussed on the diamond exploration sector, Burgundy Diamonds seeks to establish itself as a niche project incubator operating within the “gap” between Juniors and Majors, providing risk funding and project development in partnership with owners of diamond projects.
Mining Investment Botswana 2019
Mining Investment Botswana 2019
⧫ CSEF, or Crowd Sourced Equity Funding, enables project owners to raise funds through secured online platforms from a large number of small investors who can own equity in emerging mining companies for as little as $500
⧫ Dedicated crowdfunding platforms for mining companies have been launched in Canada and Australia and others are in development in the UK
⧫ Regulators in Canada and the US have already adopted rules allowing the sale and purchase of securities via crowdfunding portals. Lobbying is ongoing in Australia to change the legislation in support of crowdfunding
⧫ The viability of crowdfunding platforms in the diamond exploration space remains to be ascertained.
25
Is crowdfunding a viable alternative?
Mining Investment Botswana 2019
26
Discussion & Conclusions
Mining Investment Botswana 2019
Southern Africa’s competitiveness
27
STRENGTHS♦ Highly prospective diamond region♦ Track record of commercial
production♦ Evolved regulatory environment with
strong judiciaries♦ Mostly growing economies♦ Improved mining attractiveness
rankings
WEAKNESSES♦ Capital constrained explorers♦ Local HNWI* not investing in local
exploration♦ Insignificant local listings of junior
explorers ♦ Governments’ exploration databases♦ Licence application processes
OPPORTUNITIES♦ Developed financial markets♦ Juniors driving greenfields exploration♦ HNWI*: over 40,000 in SA; over 3,000
in Botswana♦ SA’s 12J (or equivalent) as potential
flow-through schemes♦ Crowdfunding for exploration
THREATS♦ Onerous regulatory requirements♦ Uncertainty and complexity of mining
policy♦ Investors’ perceptions of resource
nationalism♦ Governments’ royalties and free carry
expectations
*HNWI = high net worth individuals with total wealth >$1M
Mining Investment Botswana 2019
(12 000)
(10 000)
(8 000)
(6 000)
(4 000)
(2 000)
0
SA Bots Bots Kalahari Zim Swazi land Lesotho
NPV
18.8%
4.5%
-11.2%
5.51%7.68%
5.29%
NPV and IRR
28
Economic competitiveness analysis
⧫ SA ranks best of the five in terms of IRR (and NPV), mainly due to lower royalties
⧫ High rates of royalties in Botswana will effectively turn off marginal projects
⧫ Botswana Kalahari model would only work for a substantial deposit, subject to some fiscal change
Mining Investment Botswana 2019
Hypothetical primary diamond resource tested against five Southern African diamond mining fiscal regimes: SA, Botswana (x2), Zimbabwe, Swaziland, Lesotho
29
Economic competitiveness analysis (cont’d)
(10 000)
(5 000)
0
5 000
10 000
15 000
20 000
25 000
30 000
35 000
SA Bots Bots Kalahari Zim Swazi land Lesotho
Cash Flow
Royalties WHT Taxes Dividends - free carry inc WHT BOD (Net of WHT)
⧫ SA’s higher absolute returns (lower royalties and lower costs of operation) make it more attractive than the other four jurisdictions
⧫ Discount rates account for perceptions of SA’s higher political and legislative risk (viz. uncertainty around the Mining Charter).
Mining Investment Botswana 2019
Mining Investment Botswana 2019
Balanced, stable fiscal regimes are most competitive
⧫ An ideal mining fiscal regime would combine a royalty and a tax targeted explicitly to economic rents, along with the standard corporate income tax
⧫ Calculating economic rent is complex, whereas royalties are easier to administer
⧫ Investors regard ad valorem royalties as a regressive form of taxation; royalty taxes based on their ability to pay (income or profits) are favoured
⧫ Botswana’s fiscal regime is considered exemplary within the African context
⧫ Namibia has scrapped the proposed local ownership requirements
⧫ The revised SA Mining Charter is silent on equity requirements for exploration companies: an opportunity or a threat?
⧫ Can a better balance be struck between governments’ and investors’ fiscal expectations?
Source: Fasken, PWC, University of Dundee
Mining Investment Botswana 2019 30
Improving exploration attractiveness
31
Government’s role Explorers’ role
Entrepreneur-friendly regulatory environment
Risk mitigation through portfolio approach and rigorous reporting
Clarity in legislation and policy Advocacy, lobbying
Business incubators for junior explorers
Partner with individuals with solid track record
Incentivisation of local & foreign investment
Deploy new technology & innovative approaches to exploration (especially in mature areas)
Rigorous licensing process; stringent data filing obligations
Regulatory compliance & prompt submission of exploration data
Mining Investment Botswana 2019
Exploration dollars are ‘orphans’ in need of a home
Mining Investment Botswana 2019
Conclusions
⧫ Diamond demand is forecast to grow, while supply is diminishing
⧫ Exploration expenditure is on the increase
⧫ The case for diamond exploration in Southern Africa is strong
⧫ Junior diamond explorers’ struggle to access greenfields funding continues
⧫ Instruments designed to benefit investors from tax concessions (e.g. SA) are not directly supporting exploration
⧫ Expert entrepreneurial investors have taken risks and reaped rewards
⧫ Appealing to the more entrepreneurial HNWIs is key
Mining Investment Botswana 2019 32
Image courtesy of Lucara Diamond
Questions?
33Mining Investment Botswana 2019
About the Author
⧫ James Campbell is Managing Director of Botswana Diamonds plc and has spent over thirty years in the diamond industry in a variety of leadership roles both in major and junior companies. He is also a Non Executive Director of Shefa Yamim ATM (a precious stones explorer in Israel, listed on the LSE).
⧫ Previous roles include Chief Executive Officer and President of Rockwell Diamonds Inc; Non Executive Director of Stellar Diamonds plc; Vice President - New Business for Lucara Diamond Corp, Managing Director of African Diamonds plc; Executive Deputy Chairman of West African Diamonds plc.
⧫ James worked at De Beers for over twenty years; his roles included General Manager for Advanced Exploration & Resource Delivery and Nicky Oppenheimer's Personal Assistant.
⧫ James holds degrees in Mining & Exploration Geology from the Royal School of Mines (Imperial College, London University) and an MBA with distinction from Durham University. He is a Fellow of the Institute of Mining, Metallurgy & Materials, South African Institute of Mining & Metallurgy and Institute of Directors of South Africa. He is also a Chartered Engineer (UK), Chartered Scientist (UK) and a Professional Natural Scientist (RSA).
⧫ James is also chairman of Common Purpose SA (a not-for-profit organization that develops leaders who can cross boundaries and is synonymous with the terms ‘cultural intelligence’ and ‘leadership beyond authority’).
34
https://twitter.com/JAHC1https://www.linkedin.com/in/jamesahcampbell/https://www.slideshare.net/JamesAHCampbell1
https://www.youtube.com/JamesCampbell_JAHC
Mining Investment Botswana 2019
Mining Investment Botswana 2019 35
162 Clontarf RoadClontarfDublin 3
Ph: +27 83 457 3724
Web: www.botswanadiamonds.co.ukTwitter: @BotswanaDiamond
Email: [email protected]