Top Banner
Loyola University Chicago Loyola University Chicago Loyola eCommons Loyola eCommons Dissertations Theses and Dissertations 2013 Kant's Change of Heart: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation Kant's Change of Heart: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation Christina Drogalis Loyola University Chicago Follow this and additional works at: https://ecommons.luc.edu/luc_diss Part of the Ethics and Political Philosophy Commons Recommended Citation Recommended Citation Drogalis, Christina, "Kant's Change of Heart: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation" (2013). Dissertations. 512. https://ecommons.luc.edu/luc_diss/512 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Theses and Dissertations at Loyola eCommons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Loyola eCommons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 License. Copyright © 2013 Christina Drogalis
194

Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

Sep 11, 2021

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

Loyola University Chicago Loyola University Chicago

Loyola eCommons Loyola eCommons

Dissertations Theses and Dissertations

2013

Kant's Change of Heart: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation Kant's Change of Heart: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

Christina Drogalis Loyola University Chicago

Follow this and additional works at: https://ecommons.luc.edu/luc_diss

Part of the Ethics and Political Philosophy Commons

Recommended Citation Recommended Citation Drogalis, Christina, "Kant's Change of Heart: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation" (2013). Dissertations. 512. https://ecommons.luc.edu/luc_diss/512

This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Theses and Dissertations at Loyola eCommons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Loyola eCommons. For more information, please contact [email protected].

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 License. Copyright © 2013 Christina Drogalis

Page 2: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

!"#"!$%&'()*+,(-#%./(.$0"

1$'-2,%./$'0*%"3%/*$+-4%+$5(.$!%*)(!%$'5%6"+$!%-+$',3"+6$-("'

$%5(,,*+-$-("'%,&76(--*5%-"

-/*%3$.&!-#%"3%-/*%0+$5&$-*%,./""!

('%.$'5(5$.#%3"+%-/*%5*0+**%"3

5".-"+%"3%8/(!","8/#

8+"0+$6%('%8/(!","8/#

7#

./+(,-('$%5+"0$!(,

./(.$0"9%(!!('"(,

6$#%:;<=

Page 3: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

.>?@ABCDE%F@%.DABGEBHI%5A>CIJBG9%:;<=

$JJ%ABCDEG%AKGKALKMN

Page 4: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

$.1'"O!*506*'-,

(%P>QJM%JBRK%E>%EDIHR%EDK%SIH@%?K>?JK%PD>%SIMK%PABEBHC%EDBG%MBGGKAEIEB>H%?>GGBFJKN%

3BAGE9%EDIHR%@>Q%E>%EDK%MBAKTE>A%>U%S@%MBGGKAEIEB>H9%5AN%)BTE>ABI%OBRK9%PD>GK%

KHT>QAICKSKHE9%TJKIA%IHM%DKJ?UQJ%BHGBCDEG9%IHM%QHKHMBHC%PBJJBHCHKGG%E>%AKIM%TDI?EKA%

MAIUEG%H>E%>HJ@%DKJ?KM%SK%E>%MBGT>LKA%EDK%IACQSKHE%EDIE%(%PIHEKM%E>%SIRK%FQE%EIQCDE%SK%

D>P%E>%I??A>ITD%I%?A>VKTE%GQTD%IG%EDBGN%$%G?KTBIJ%EDIHR%@>Q%E>%EDK%AKGE%>U%S@%T>SSBEEKK4%

-DIHR%@>Q%E>%5AN%$HMAKP%.QEA>UKJJ>%U>A%@>QA%GQ??>AE%EDA>QCD>QE%CAIMQIEK%GTD>>J%IHM%

@>QA%CKHKA>GBE@%PBED%@>QA%EBSK%IHM%EIJKHEN%-DIHR%@>Q%E>%5AN%/QCD%6BJJKA9%U>A%@>QA%BHEKAKGE%

BH%EDBG%?A>VKTE%IHM%@>QA%DKJ?UQJ%BHGBCDEGN%-DIHR%@>Q%E>%5AN%1@JI%*FKJGW5QCCIH%U>A%@>QA%

PBJJBHCHKGG%E>%EIJR%IF>QE%S@%P>AR%IHM%IF>QE%?DBJ>G>?D@%BH%CKHKAIJN%#>QA%I??A>ITD%E>%

?DBJ>G>?D@%DIG%SIMK%SK%EDBHR%BH%HKP%PI@G%IF>QE%S@%P>ARN

-DIHRG%IJG>%E>%HQSKA>QG%>EDKA%?K>?JK%PD>%DILK%G>%CKHKA>QGJ@%DKJ?KM%SK%CKE%E>%EDBG%

?>BHEN%-DIHRG%E>%5AN%-D>SIG%.IAG>H9%U>A%@>QA%CQBMIHTK%IHM%GQ??>AE%GBHTK%S@%UBAGE%MI@%>U%

CAIMQIEK%GTD>>JN%-DIHRG%IJG>%E>%5AGN%/IHHK%XIT>FG%IHM%XITYQKJBHK%,T>EEN%#>Q%F>ED%DILK%

FKKH%G>%PBJJBHC%E>%?A>LBMK%SK%PBED%CQBMIHTK%PDKH%(2LK%HKKMKM%BE%S>GEN%-DIHR%@>Q%E>%

8DBJJB?%1AIUE9%U>A%DBG%IGGBGEIHTK%>H%S@%AKGKIATD%IHM%U>ASIEEBHCN%-DIHRG%E>%5AGN%+BTDIAM%

1J>H>GRB%IHM%OBJJBIS%+>PK9%PBED>QE%PD>S%(%P>QJM%JBRKJ@%H>E%DILK%U>QHM%S@%J>LK%>U%

?DBJ>G>?D@%IHM%>U%EKITDBHC%IHM%?QAGQKM%EDBG%TIAKKAN

(%>PK%G>%SQTD%E>%S@%UISBJ@9%PD>%DILK%FKKH%I%T>HGBGEKHE%G>QATK%>U%GQ??>AEN%-DIHR%

@>Q%E>%S@%S>EDKA9%-KAKGI9%PD>%BG%AKG?>HGBFJK%U>A%G>%SQTD%>U%S@%GQTTKGG9%U>A%BHGEBJJBHC

BBB

Page 5: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

BH%SK%EDK%BS?>AEIHTK%>U%KMQTIEB>H%IHM%>U%DIAM%P>ARN%-DIHRG%IJG>%E>%S@%UIEDKA9%XKM9%PD>%

DIG%IJPI@G%FKKH%S@%FBCCKGE%TDKKAJKIMKA%BH%PDIEKLKA%(2S%?QAGQBHCN%-DIHRG%E>%S@%GBFJBHCG9%

5BIHI9%XISKG9%IHM%6BTDIKJN%(%IS%G>%JQTR@%E>%FK%@>QA%GBGEKA%IHM%E>%FK%IFJK%E>%AKJ@%>H%IJJ%>U%

@>QN

$HM%EDIHRG%E>%EDK%SIH@%UABKHMG%PD>%DILK%GQ??>AEKM%SK%EDA>QCD%EDK%?A>TKGG%>U%

PABEBHCN%.IAJ>9%EDIHR%@>Q%U>A%>QA%SIH@%T>UUKK%GEQM@%SKKEBHCG9%@>QA%?K?%EIJRG9%IHM%@>QA%

?IEBKHTK%BH%JBGEKHBHC%E>%IJJ%S@%BMKIG%IHM%?A>FJKSGN%$HM@9%EDIHR%@>Q%U>A%FKBHC%S@%UBAGE%

CAIMQIEK%GTD>>J%UABKHM%IHM%U>A%IJPI@G%AKSBHMBHC%SK%IF>QE%EDK%FBCCKA%?BTEQAKN%'IEIJBK9%

EDIHR%@>Q%U>A%FKBHC%S@%KSIBJ%ZIHM%AKIJ[%UABKHM%EDA>QCD%I%?IAEBTQJIAJ@%J>HC%GQSSKA%>U%

PABEBHCN%(2S%G>%JQTR@%E>%DILK%@>QA%KHT>QAICKSKHE%IHM%UABKHMGDB?N

3BHIJJ@9%EDIHRG%E>%5AKP9%U>A%@>QA%?ABMK%BH%S@%P>AR9%@>QA%PBJJBHCHKGG%E>%M>%

IH@EDBHC%BH%>AMKA%E>%SIRK%SK%JIQCD9%IHM%U>A%@>QA%QHUIBJBHC%T>HUBMKHTK%EDIE%(2JJ%IJPI@G%

ITDBKLK%PDIE%(%GKE%>QE%E>%M>N

BL

Page 6: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

->%S@%CAIHMUIEDKA9%!KPBG%*N%X>GK?D

Page 7: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

-$7!*%"3%."'-*'-,

$.1'"O!*506*'-, %%%%%%%%%%BBB

('-+"5&.-("' <

./$8-*+%"'*4%-/*%('-+"5&.-("'%"3%+$5(.$!%*)(!%('%1$'-2,%6"+$!%%%%%

%%%8/(!","8/# \

%%%(HEA>MQTEB>H \

%%%-DK%!"#$%$&'%5>KG%'>E%.>DKAK%PBED%EDK%+KGE%>U%1IHE2G%.>A?QG ]

%%%%%%-DK%+KITEB>H%>U%1IHE2G%.>HEKS?>AIABKG ]

%%%%%%.>HEBHQBHC%+KGBGEIHTK%BH%EDK%,KT>HMIA@%!BEKAIEQAK %%%%%%%%%%<<

%%%1IHE2G%5BGTQGGB>H%>U%+IMBTIJ%*LBJ4%-DK%.>HEKHE %%%%%%%%%% %%%%%%%%%%<^

%%%%%%$%5KUBHBEB>H%>U%+IMBTIJ%*LBJ %%%%%%%%%%<\

%%%%%%+IMBTIJ%*LBJ%IG%I%3AKK%.D>BTK %%%%%%%%%%::

%%%%%%+IMBTIJ%*LBJ%IG%(HHIEK%IHM%&HBLKAGIJ %%%%%%%%%%:=%

%%%%%%%%%(HHIEKHKGG%BH%/QSIH%'IEQAK %%%%%%%%%%:\%

%%%%%%%%%8A>>U%>U%EDK%&HBLKAGIJBE@%>U%+IMBTIJ%*LBJ =_

%%%%%%-DK%8>GGBFBJBE@%>U%7KT>SBHC%6>AIJJ@%0>>M _;

%%%1IHE2G%.JIBS4%(EG%.>HHKTEB>HG%E>%/BG%*IAJBKA%6>AIJ%8DBJ>G>?D@ %%%%%%%%%%_:

%%%.>HTJQGB>H %%%%%%%%% %%%%%%%%%%^:

./$8-*+%-O"4%-/*%!()*+*,-.,%+"!*%('%-/*%5*)*!"86*'-%"3%1$'-2,%

%%%-/*"+#%"3%6"+$!%(68+")*6*'- %%%%%%%%%%^=

%%%(HEA>MQTEB>H %%%%%%%%%% %%%%%%%%%%^=

%%%5BUUKAKHTK%FKEPKKH%EDK%-P>%5>TEABHKG%>U%6KED>M %%%%%%%%%%^^

%%%%%%-DK%&GK%>U%*`IS?JKG%BH%6>AIJ%*MQTIEB>H %%%%%%%%%%^a

%%%%%%,BHCQJIA%.D>BTKG%LKAGQG%0AIMQIJ%8A>CAKGG %%%%%%%%%%\^

%%%*`?JIBHBHC%EDK%5BUUKAKHTK4%-DK%+IMBTIJ%*LBJ%.JIBS %%%%%%%%%%\a

%%%%%%8IAIJJKJG%FKEPKKH%EDK%!"#$%$&'/IHM%EDK%0"123456$76/&8/0&92#6 ////////// //////////b<

///'KP%$G?KTEG%>U%6>AIJ%5KLKJ>?SKHE%BH%EDK%!"#$%$&' //////////ba

//////1H>PBHC%ODIE%(E%6KIHG%E>%FK%6>AIJJ@%0>>M %%%%%%%%%%%%% %%%%%%%%%%a;

%%%%%%&HMKAGEIHMBHC%EDK%"LKAT>SBHC%IG%8>GGBFJK%U>A%&G%E>%$TT>S?JBGD %%%%%%%%%%a=

%%%.>HTJQGB>H %%%%%%%%%% %%%%%%%%%%ab

./$8-*+%-/+**4%O/*-/*+%-/*%")*+."6('0%"3%+$5(.$!%*)(!%(,%$%

%%%6"+$!%8",,(7(!(-# %%%%%%%%%%aa

%%%(HEA>MQTEB>H %%%%%%%%% %%%%%%%%%%aa

%%%-DK%6>SKHEG%>U%.DIHCK%BH%EDK%"LKAT>SBHC%+IMBTIJ%*LBJ %%%%%%%%%%]_

%%%%%%-DK%+"6$'':'%/.D>BTK %%%%%%%% %%%%%%%%<;:

%%%%%%-DK%6>AIJ%+KFBAED %%%%%%%%<;=

%%%%%%-DK%.I?ITBE@%E>%(S?A>LK%EDK%6>AIJ%O>AED%>U%8IAEBTQJIA%$TEB>HG %%%%%%%%<<:

%%%&HMKAGEIHMBHC%-DKGK%6>SKHEG%>U%.DIHCK%IG%8>GGBFJK %%%%%%%%<<^

%%%%%%&HMKAGEIHMBHC%EDK%8>GGBFBJBE@%>U%EDK%+"6$'':'%%.D>BTK %%%%%%%% %%%%%%%%<<\

%%%%%%&HMKAGEIHMBHC%EDK%.I?ITBE@%E>%(S?A>LK%EDK%6>AIJ%O>AED%>U%"QA%$TEB>HG %%%%%%%%<:=

LB

Page 8: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

%%%%%%-DK%*?BGEKS>J>CBTIJ%8A>FJKS%>U%&HMKAGEIHMBHC%EDK%8>GGBFBJBE@%>U%EDK%6>AIJ%%%%%%%%%

%%%%%%%%%+KFBAED %%%%%%%%<:a

%%%%%%&HMKAGEIHMBHC%EDK%.>HMBEB>HG%U>A%EDK%8>GGBFBJBE@%>U%EDK%6>AIJ%+KFBAED4%$%6IEEKA

%%%%%%%%%>U%7KJBKU %%%%%%%%<:]

%%%%%%%%%$%+KLBKP4%-DK%'KKM%U>A%6>AIJ%7KJBKU%IHM%/>?K %%%%%%%%<=;

%%%%%%%%%-DK%+>JK%>U%6>AIJ%7KJBKU%BH%EDK%.IGK%>U%EDK%6>AIJ%+KFBAED %%%%%%%% %%%%%%%%<=^

%%%(G%5BLBHK%$BM%EDK%"HJ@%(MKI%EDIE%.IH%XQGEBU@%6>AIJ%/>?Kc %%%%%%%%<_:

%%%%%%5>KG%1IHE%-DBHR%EDIE%7KJBKU%BH%5BLBHK%$BM%BG%EDK%"HJ@%,>JQEB>Hc %%%%%%%%<_=

%%%%%%-DK%8>GGBFBJBE@%>U%$H>EDKA%(MKI%5>BHC%EDK%,ISK%O>AR %%%%%%%%<_a

%%%.>HTJQGB>H %%%%%%%%<^<

./$8-*+%3"&+4%-/*%8!$.*%"3%+$5(.$!%6"+$!%(68+")*6*'-%('%

%%%1$'-2,%-/*"+#%"3%6"+$!%5*)*!"86*'- %%%%%%%%<^=

%%%(HEA>MQTEB>H %%%%%%%%<^=

%%%-AIMBEB>HIJ%OI@G%>U%+KIMBHC%EDK%8JITK%>U%+IMBTIJ%6>AIJ%(S?A>LKSKHE %%%%%%%% %%%%%%%%<^_

%%%/>P%+IMBTIJ%6>AIJ%(S?A>LKSKHE%BG%,BEQIEKM%BH%1IHE2G%$TT>QHE%>U%6>AIJ%%%%%%

%%%%%%5KLKJ>?SKHE %%%%%%%%<\^

%%%%%%-DK%-BSKJKGGHKGG%$ACQSKHE %%%%%%%%<\\

//////-DK%6BGEIRK%>U%.>HUJIEBHC%EDK%-P>%,EICKG %%%%%%%%<b:

%%%.>HTJQGB>H %%%%%%%%<b\

."'.!&,("' %%%%%%%%<bb

+*3*+*'.*%!(,- %%%%%%%%<a<

)(-$ %%%%%%%%<ab

LBB

Page 9: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

!"#$%&'(#!%"

!))*+,-./0*+123/!"#$%$&'()$*+$'(*+"(,&-'./0$"1(&2(3"0"(!"/1&'4(45611-+/6+/789:;/

1<=6>*..</?*3/@--+/6A+B5-C/B5/)63,+C-531BBC/6+/1?-/3->B+C*5</.61-5*1,5-/36+>-/613/

=,@.6>*16B+D/E->*,3-/3B)-/BF/1?-/.*+A,*A-/1?*1/0*+1/,3-3/*+C/1?-/>.*6)3/1?*1/?-/)*G-3/6+/

1?63/4B5G/*==-*5/1B/@-/6+>B+3631-+1/461?/1?-/5-31/BF/?63/=?6.B3B=?<;/>B))-+1*1B53/?*H-/

5-3631-C/,36+A/1?63/4B5G/*+C/1?-/>.*6)3/6+/61/1B/?-.=/,3/1B/@-11-5/,+C-531*+C/B1?-5/=*513/BF/

?63/=?6.B3B=?<D/!+/1?-/.*31/F-4/C->*C-3;/?B4-H-5;/)B5-/*11-+16B+/?*3/@--+/A6H-+/1B/1?63/

4B5GD/I-H-5*./>B))-+1*1B53/?*H-/@-A,+/1B/)*G-/1?-/>*3-/1?*1/1?-/!"#$%$&'(+B1/B+.</

>B?-5-3/461?/1?-/5-31/BF/0*+123/=?6.B3B=?</@,1/*.3B/?-.=3/1B/>.*56F</*+C/J,316F</>.*6)3/1?*1/

?-/)*G-3/6+/B1?-5/4B5G3;/*+C/3=->6F6>*..</6+/?63/)B5*./=?6.B3B=?<D

!+/1?63/=5BJ->1;/!/*6)/1B/JB6+/1?-3-/>B))-+1*1B53/6+/1?63/-FFB51/1B/*5A,-/FB5/1?-/

>B?-5-+>-/BF/1?-/!"#$%$&'(461?/0*+123/)B5*./=?6.B3B=?<;/@,1/!/6+1-+C/1B/-K=*+C/1?63/

*5A,)-+1/6+1B/+-4/1-5561B5<D/#?*1/63;/!/46../>.*6)/1?*1/1?-/!"#$%$&'/>*+/?-.=/,3/1B/A*6+/*/

>.-*5-5/,+C-531*+C6+A/BF/0*+123/1?-B5</BF/?,)*+/)B5*./C-H-.B=)-+1;/B5/6)=5BH-)-+1D/

LB5-/3=->6F6>*..<;/!/46../C-)B+315*1-/1?*1/0*+123/6+15BC,>16B+/BF/1?-/[email protected])/BF/,+6H-53*./

5*C6>*./-H6./6+/?,)*+3/6+/1?63/4B5G/3-5H-3/*3/*/1,5+6+A/=B6+1/6+/1?-/C-H-.B=)-+1/BF/?63/

1?-B5</BF/)B5*./6)=5BH-)-+1;/6+3BF*5/*3/61/6+15BC,>-3/1?-/=5B>-33/BF/BH-5>B)6+A/5*C6>*./

-H6./*3/*/C6316+>1;/FB,+C*16B+*./31*A-/BF/C-H-.B=)-+1/1?*1/),31/B>>,5/=56B5/1B/*+/

6)=5BH-)-+1/6+/1?-/)B5*./4B51?/BF/B,5/*>16B+3/6+/=*516>,.*5/>*3-3D

#5*C616B+*..<;/4?-+/>B))-+1*1B53/-K=.*6+/0*+123/*>>B,+1/BF/)B5*./C-H-.B=)-+1;

7

Page 10: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

M

/1?-</=56)*56.</N/B5;/6+/)*+</>*3-3;/3B.-.</N/.BBG/1B/?63/)*JB5/4B5G3/B+/)B5*./=?6.B3B=?<;/

6+>.,C6+A/1?-/50&-'.)&06(&2(*+"(3"*/7+81$91(&2(3&0/#14(1?-/:0$*$;-"(&2(<0/9*$9/# (

!"/1&'4(*+C/1?-/3"*/7+81$91(&2(3&0/#1=(O3/!/46../3?B4/6+/4?*1/FB..B43;/6F/4-/B+.</.BBG/

1B/1?-3-/4B5G3;/4-/F6+C/A*=3/*+C/*==*5-+1.</>B+F.6>16+A/31*1-)-+13/*@B,1/?B4/?,)*+3/

@->B)-/)B5*..</ABBC;/*/[email protected])/1?*1/?*3/@--+/*>G+B4.-CA-C/@</)*+</>B))-+1*1B53D/

E</1*G6+A/*/>*5-F,./.BBG/*1/0*+123/C-3>56=16B+/6+/1?-/!"#$%$&'/BF/?B4/*/=-53B+/>*+/

BH-5>B)-/5*C6>*./-H6.;/4-/>*+/F6+C/1?-/3B,5>-/BF/1?-3-/*==*5-+1/C63>5-=*+>6-3/B5/)B)-+13/

BF/,+>.*561</6+/?63/)*JB5/)B5*./4B5G3D/!+C--C;/6F/4-/,+C-51*G-/1?63/>*5-F,./-K*)6+*16B+;/

4-/46../F6+C/1?*1/0*+123/6+15BC,>16B+/BF/1?-/[email protected])/BF/5*C6>*./-H6./*+C/?63/3B.,16B+/1B/

BH-5>B)6+A/61/15*+3FB5)3/?63/-*5.6-5/*>>B,+1/BF/)B5*./C-H-.B=)-+1;/6+3BF*5/*3/61/

6+15BC,>-3/+-4/[email protected])3/*+C/+-4/)-1?BC3/BF/@->B)6+A/)B5*..</ABBCD

!1/63/)</?B=-/1?*1/)</=5BJ->1/46../+B1/B+.</5-3,.1/6+/*/)B5-/*>>,5*1-/*+C/>B)=.-1-/

,+C-531*+C6+A/BF/0*+123/*>>B,+1/BF/)B5*./C-H-.B=)-+1/@,1/1?*1/61/46../*.3B/?-.=/1B/5-3B.H-/

3B)-/B,131*+C6+A/*5-*3/BF/>B+1-+16B+/6+/1?-/3->B+C*5</.61-5*1,5-/5-A*5C6+A/0*+123/1?-B5</

BF/5*C6>*./-H6.D/#?-5-/63/A5-*1/C-@*1-/5-A*5C6+A/?B4/61/63/[email protected]/1B/BH-5>B)-/5*C6>*./-H6./

*+C/4?*1/1?63/BH-5>B)6+A/),31/-+1*6.D/E->*,3-/BF/1?63;/!/46../3=-+C/)B5-/1?*+/?*.F/BF/)</

=5BJ->1/C-1*6.6+A/1?-/3B513/BF/>?*+A-3/1?*1/*/5*C6>*..</-H6./=-53B+/),31/,+C-5AB/*+C/

6+H-316A*16+A/?B4/4-/>*+/,+C-531*+C/1?-3-/>?*+A-3/1B/@-/[email protected]/FB5/?,)*+3/1B/

*>>B)=.63?D/!+/CB6+A/3B;/!/46../*CC5-33/14B/)*JB5/*5-*3/BF/C-@*1-P/Q7R/4?-1?-5/?,)*+3/

?*H-/1?-/>*=*>61</1B/BH-5>B)-/5*C6>*./-H6./B+/1?-65/B4+;/5*1?-5/1?*+/5-S,656+A/1?-/

*33631*+>-/BF/*+/[email protected]/@-6+A/3,>?/*3/TBC;/*+C/QMR/4?-1?-5/1?63/BH-5>B)6+A/BF/

5*C6>*./-H6./63/16)-.-33/6+/1?-/3-+3-/1?*1/61/>*++B1/@-/=.*>-C/6+/*/3-S,-+>-/BF/-H-+13/6+/

16)-D/!/46../@56-F.</B,1.6+-/)</*+34-53/1B/1?-3-/S,-316B+3/@-.B4D

Page 11: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

U

L</=5BJ->1/46../=5B>--C/*3/FB..B43D/!+/(?*=1-5/%+-;/!/46../*CC5-33/1?-/B@J->16B+3/

F5B)/0*+123/>B+1-)=B5*56-3/*+C/)B5-/5->-+1/>B))-+1*1B53;/4?B/>.*6)/1?*1/1?-/!"#$%$&'4 (

*+C/3=->6F6>*..</0*+123/>.*6)/1?*1/*../?,)*+3/*5-/,+6H-53*..</5*C6>*..</-H6.;/63/6+>B?-5-+1/

461?/1?-/5-31/BF/?63/>B5=,3D/%+/1?-/>B+15*5<;/!/46../C-)B+315*1-/14B/G-</4*<3/1?*1/1?-/

!"#$%$&'(*+C/1?-/>.*6)/*@B,1/1?-/,+6H-53*.61</BF/5*C6>*./-H6./J,316F</*+C/>.*56F</0*+123/

)B5*./=?6.B3B=?<P/Q7R/@</-K=.*6+6+A/1?-/3B,5>-/BF/)B5*./-H6./6+/?,)*+3/*+C/QMR/@</

>.*56F<6+A/?B4/61/63/[email protected]/FB5/*/?,)*+/1B/F5--.</>?BB3-/)B5*./-H6.D/%+/1?-3-/A5B,+C3;/!/

46../*5A,-/1?*1/4-/?*H-/5-*3B+/1B/,+C-531*+C/1?-/!"#$%$&'(*3/>B?-5-+1/461?/1?-/5-31/BF/

0*+123/=?6.B3B=?</*+C/1B/,3-/1?63/4B5G/*+C/1?-/>.*6)3/6+/61/1B/-+?*+>-/B,5/,+C-531*+C6+A/

BF/B1?-5/=*513/BF/?63/=?6.B3B=?<D

!+/(?*=1-5/#4B;/!/46../*5A,-/1?*1/1?-5-/63/*+B1?-5;/.*5A-.</BH-5.BBG-C;/4*</1?*1/1?-/

!"#$%$&'(>*+/?-.=/,3/1B/,+C-531*+C/0*+123/)B5*./=?6.B3B=?<;/6+/=*516>,.*5D/!+/3?B51;/!/46../

*5A,-/1?*1/0*+123/6+15BC,>16B+/BF/1?-/[email protected])/BF/5*C6>*./-H6./*+C/?63/=5B=B3-C/3B.,16B+/1B/

BH-5>B)6+A/61;/@B1?/FB,+C/6+/1?-/!"#$%$&'4(3-5H-/*3/*/1,5+6+A/=B6+1/6+/1?-/C-H-.B=)-+1/BF/

?63/*>>B,+1/BF/)B5*./6)=5BH-)-+1D/!+/B5C-5/1B/3,==B51/1?63/*5A,)-+1;/!/46../>B)=*5-/14B/

=B516B+3/BF/0*+123/FB5)*./*>>B,+1/BF/)B5*./C-H-.B=)-+1;/1?-/&B>156+-3/BF/L-1?BC/F5B)/

1?-/:0$*$;-"(&2(<0/9*$9/#(!"/1&'4(45611-+/@-FB5-/1?-/!"#$%$&'4(*+C/F5B)/1?-/3"*/7+81$91 (

&2(3&0/#14(45611-+/*F1-5/1?-/!"#$%$&'=(!+/1?63/>B)=*563B+;/!/6..,315*1-/14B/G-</C6FF-5-+>-3/

6+/1?-3-/*>>B,+13P/Q7R/1?-/4*</6+/4?6>?/0*+1/,3-3/-K*)=.-3/6+/?63/C63>,336B+/BF/)B5*./

6)=5BH-)-+1/*+C/QMR/*+/-)=?*363/6+/1?-/.*1-5/4B5G/B+/1?-/+--C/FB5/*/36+A,.*5/)B5*./

15*+3FB5)*16B+/H-53,3/1?-/3B.-/+--C/FB5/*/A5*C,*./=5B>-33/BF/)B5*./>?*+A-/6+/1?-/-*5.6-5/

4B5GD/!/1?-+/C-)B+315*1-/1?*1/1?-3-/C6FF-5-+>-3;/4?6>?/?*H-/@--+/?6+1-C/*1/@,1/+B1/

*C-S,*1-.</-K=.*6+-C/@</B1?-5/>B))-+1*1B53;/*5-/1?-/5-3,.1/BF/0*+123/6+15BC,>16B+/BF/1?-/

Page 12: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

:

[email protected])/BF/*+C/3B.,16B+/1B/5*C6>*./-H6./6+/1?-/!"#$%$&'=(#?,3;/!/1*G-/1?-/=B3616B+/1?*1;/6+/

B5C-5/1B/*11*6+/*+/*>>,5*1-/*+C/F,../,+C-531*+C6+A/BF/0*+123/*>>B,+1/BF/)B5*./

C-H-.B=)-+1;/4-/),31/,16.6V-/0*+123/>.*6)3/F5B)/1?-/!"#$%$&'(6+/B,5/6+1-5=5-1*16B+3D

!+/(?*=1-5/#?5--;/!/C-1*6./4?*1/3B513/BF/>?*+A-3/*5-/+->-33*5</FB5/?,)*+3/1B/

,+C-5AB/6+/B5C-5/1B/BH-5>B)-/5*C6>*./-H6./*+C/-K=.B5-/?B4/4-/>*+/,+C-531*+C/1?-3-/

>?*+A-3/1B/@-/[email protected]/FB5/?,)*+3/1B/*>>B)=.63?D/!1/63/-33-+16*./1B/=5BH6C-/*+/*>>B,+1/BF/

1?-/[email protected]</BF/1?-3-/>?*+A-3/FB5/14B/5-*3B+3D/W6531;/0*+1/*5A,-3/1?*1/6F/4-/CB/+B1/

,+C-531*+C/?B4/61/[email protected]/1B/BH-5>B)-/5*C6>*./-H6.;//1?-+/4-/5,+/1?-/563G/BF/F*..6+A/6+1B/

C-3=*65/*+C/@-6+A/,+*@.-/1B/)B5*..</6)=5BH-D/I->B+C;/*3/+B1-C/*@BH-;/!/463?/1B/>.*6)/

1?*1/1?-/BH-5>B)6+A/BF/5*C6>*./-H6./63/*/FB,+C*16B+*./*+C/C6316+>1/31*A-/BF/)B5*./

6)=5BH-)-+1D/'+.-33/4-/>*+/-K=.*6+/?B4/1?63/BH-5>B)6+A/63/[email protected]/FB5/?,)*+3/1B/

*>?6-H-;/4-/>*++B1/6+>.,C-/1?63/31*A-/6+/*+/*>>B,+1/BF/)B5*./C-H-.B=)-+1/461?B,1/

>B+15*C6>16+A/0*+123/>.*6)/1?*1/4?*1-H-5/6)=5BH-)-+13/?,)*+3/),31/)*G-/6+/B5C-5/1B/

@->B)-/)B5*..</ABBC/),31/@-/[email protected]/FB5/1?-)/1B/*>>B)=.63?D

!+/=5BH6C6+A/*+/*>>B,+1/BF/?B4/?,)*+3/>*+/>B)-/1B/,+C-531*+C/1?-/[email protected]</BF/

BH-5>B)6+A/5*C6>*./-H6.;/!/46../-+1-5/6+1B/*+/-K6316+A/C-@*1-/6+/1?-/3->B+C*5</.61-5*1,5-/

5-A*5C6+A/4?-1?-5/?,)*+3/>*+/BH-5>B)-/5*C6>*./-H6./B+/1?-65/B4+/B5/4?-1?-5/1?-</

5-S,65-/1?-/*33631*+>-/BF/*+/[email protected]/@-6+A;/3,>?/*3/TBCD/!/46../*5A,-/1?*1/1?-5-/63/*/

)63,+C-531*+C6+A/5-A*5C6+A/4?*1/G6+C/BF/-K1-5+*./*6C/0*+1/1?6+G3/1?*1/?,)*+3/+--C/*+C;/

F,51?-5;/1?*1/-H-+/1?-/G6+C/BF/*6C/1?*1/0*+1/3,AA-313/1?*1/4-/+--C/)*</+B1/@-/+->-33*5<D

!+/(?*=1-5/WB,5;/?*H6+A/-31*@.63?-C/1?*1/1?-/BH-5>B)6+A/BF/5*C6>*./-H6./63/=5B=-5.</

,+C-531BBC/*3/*/=*51/BF/0*+123/1?-B5</BF/)B5*./C-H-.B=)-+1/*+C/1?*1/61/63/[email protected]/FB5/

?,)*+3/1B/*>?6-H-;/!/46../C-)B+315*1-/4?*1/=.*>-/4-/3?B,.C/A6H-/1B/1?63/BH-5>B)6+A/6+/

Page 13: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

X

1?-/?,)*+/=5B>-33/BF/@->B)6+A/)B5*..</ABBCD/!+/3?B51;/!/46../C-F-+C/)</>.*6)/1?*1/61/

3?B,.C/@-/,+C-531BBC/*3/*/C6316+>1/*+C/FB,+C*16B+*./31*A-/BF/)B5*./6)=5BH-)-+1/1?*1/

),31/B>>,5/>?5B+B.BA6>*..</=56B5/1B/*+/6)=5BH-)-+1/6+/1?-/)B5*./4B51?/BF/B,5/*>16B+3/6+/

=*516>,.*5/>*3-3D/O3/?*3/@--+/+B1-C/*@BH-;/1?-/BH-5>B)6+A/BF/5*C6>*./-H6./?*3/+B1/

15*C616B+*..</@--+/A6H-+/*/=.*>-/6+/0*+123/*>>B,+1/BF/)B5*./C-H-.B=)-+1D/YB4-H-5;/6+/1?-/

?631B56>*..</5*5-/6+31*+>-3/4?-+/61/?*3/@--+/*>G+B4.-CA-C/*3/*/=*51/BF/1?63/=5B>-33;/61/?*3/

@--+/)63,+C-531BBC/1B/@-/*/>?*+A-/1?*1/63/16)-.-33/*+C/1?-5-FB5-/+B1/*@.-/1B/@-/=.*>-C/6+/

*/1-)=B5*./3-S,-+>-/BF/-H-+13/*3/*/C6316+>1/31*A-/BF/6)=5BH-)-+1D/!/46../*5A,-/*A*6+31/

,+C-531*+C6+A/1?-/BH-5>B)6+A/BF/5*C6>*./-H6./6+/1?63/4*</*+C/=5BH6C-/)</*5A,)-+1/6+/

F*HB5/BF/,+C-531*+C6+A/1?63/BH-5>B)6+A/@B1?/*3/?*H6+A/>B)=B+-+13/BF/>?*+A-/1?*1/B>>,5/

6+/16)-/*+C/*3/@-6+A/*@.-/1B/@-/=.*>-C/6+/*/>?5B+B.BA6>*./3-S,-+>-;/6+3BF*5/*3/61/63/

6+F.,-+>-C/N/1?B,A?/+B1/C-1-5)6+-C/Z/@</-H-+13/6+/16)-/*+C/613/>B+3-S,-+>-3/*==-*5/6+/

16)-D

Page 14: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

!"#$%&'()*&

%"&(+*%'),-!%+)*().('#,+!#/(&0+/(+*(1#*%23(4)'#/($"+/)3)$"5

!"#$%&'(#)%"

6789(1:9;(<=>;8(!"#$%$&'()$*+$'(*+"(,&-'./0$"1(&2(3"0"(!"/1&'(?4$"(!"#$%$&'(

$''"0+/#5(."0(60"'7"'(."0(5#&8"'(9"0'-'2*@A(B9(ACDE:(78(B9;=>FGH8F(:(98<(:9FI(;>(J:9K(

:;(;78(;BJ8I(LG=M=BLB9N(:LM8H;(>O(7BL(M7BP>L>M7KQ(7BL(HP:BJ(:R>G;(;78(G9BS8=L:PB;K(>O(=:FBH:P(

8SBP(?0/.$;/#"(,<1"@(B9(7GJ:9LTU((+9(;7BL(<>=VI(1:9;(HP:BJL(;7:;(:PP(7GJ:9L(:=8(J>=:PPK(

8SBP(R>;7(RK(9:;G=8(:9F(;7=>GN7(:(O=88(RG;(98H8LL:=K(H7>BH8T(%78(B9;=>FGH;B>9(>O(;7BL(

H>9H8M;(7:L(R889(=8O8==8F(;>(:L(;78(P:L;(;7B9N(;7:;(:(=8:F8=(<>GPF(8WM8H;(B9(1:9;2L(

<=B;B9NLTX*%78(H>9H8M;(>O(=:FBH:P(8SBP(<:L(LG=M=BLB9N(;>(1:9;2L(H>9;8JM>=:=B8L(:9F(

H>9;B9G8L(;>(R8(LG=M=BLB9N(;>(=8:F8=L(;>F:K(O>=(:(9GJR8=(>O(=8:L>9LT("89=K(&T(#PPBL>9(

9>;8L(;7:;(B;(<:L(:9(G98WM8H;8F(HP:BJ(FG=B9N(1:9;2L(;BJ8(FG8(;>(YB;L(LGNN8L;B>9(>O(;78(

F>H;=B98(>O(>=BNB9:P(LB9I(;78(O8:;G=8(>O(!7=BL;B:9(>=;7>F>WK(;7:;(<:L(J>L;(B9BJBH:P(;>(;78

A +JJ:9G8P(1:9;I(4$"(!"#$%$&'($''"0+/#5(."0(60"'7"'(."0(5#&8"'(9"0'-'2*(?":JRG=NQ('T("BJJ8P78R8=(Z(!>TI(AD[\@T(.>=(;7BL(M=>]8H;I(+(<BPP(R8(GLB9N(;78(!:JR=BFN8(8FB;B>9(>O(;78(!"#$%$&'(O>=(&9NPBL7(;=:9LP:;B>9L(?+JJ:9G8P(1:9;I(!"#$%$&'()$*+$'(*+"(,&-'./0$"1(&2(3"0"(!"/1&':(8FT(:9F(;=:9LT(#PP89(6>>F(:9F(^8>=N8(FB(^B>S:99BT(!:JR=BFN8Q(!:JR=BFN8(-9BS8=LB;K($=8LLI(ADD_T@T(.=>J(78=8(>9I(+(<BPP(=8O8=(;>(;7BL(<>=V(:L(;78(!"#$%$&'=

U %78(R>>V(H>9LBL;8F(>O(O>G=(8LL:KLI(Y)O(;78(':FBH:P(&SBP(B9("GJ:9(*:;G=8I`(Y!>9H8=9B9N(;78(a:;;P8(>O(;78(^>>F(:N:B9L;(;78(&SBP($=B9HBMP8(O>=(,>JB9B>9(>S8=(;78("GJ:9(a8B9NI`(Y%78(0BH;>=K(>O(;78(^>>F($=B9HBMP8(>S8=(;78(&SBP($=B9HBMP8I(:9F(;78(.>G9FB9N(>O(:(1B9NF>J(>O(^>F(B9(&:=;7I`(:9F(Y)O('8PBNB>9(:9F($=B8L;H=:O;I`(:9F(:(M=8O:H8T(67BP8(;78(P:;;8=(;<>(8LL:KL(<8=8(98<I(1:9;(7:F(L89;(;78(OB=L;(;<>(8LL:KL(;>(:(H89L>=(O>=(:MM=>S:P(;>(MGRPBL7(;78J(B9(.8R=G:=K(:9F(bG98(>O(ACDUI(=8LM8H;BS8PKT(67BP8(;78(OB=L;(8LL:K(<:L(M8=JB;;8F(;>(R8(MGRPBL78F(R8H:GL8(;78(H89L>=(;>>V(B;(;>(R8(:FF=8LLB9N(M7BP>L>M78=LI(=:;78=(;7:9(;78(MGRPBHI(;78(L8H>9F(<:L(=8]8H;8F(R8H:GL8(B;(<:L(H>9LBF8=8F(;78>P>NBH:P(:9F(9>;(LGB;:RP8(O>=(;78(MGRPBH(R8H:GL8(>O(B;L(H>9;=>S8=LB:P(9:;G=8(B9(LGNN8L;B9N(=8PBNB>GL(O=88F>JT(?388(4:9O=8F(1G879I(>/'*? (@(,$&%0/A+B(?!:JR=BFN8Q(!:JR=BFN8(-9BS8=LB;K($=8LLI(UccA@I(X\X(d(C_T@

X 388(1:=P(a:=;7I(C0&*"1*/'*(D+&-%+*(20&E(!&-11"/-(*&(!$*1F+#:(;=:9LT(a=B:9(!>e89LT(?*8<(5>=VQ(3BJ>9(:9F(3H7GL;8=IAD\D@I(AC\T

\

Page 15: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

C(BF8:PL(>O(;78(&9PBN7;89J89;`(:9F(FG=B9N(>G=(><9(;BJ8(R8H:GL8(>O((Y;78(:MM:=89;(

J8;:M7KLBH:P(8WH8LL8L(>O(1:9;fL(:HH>G9;I(M:=;BHGP:=PK(;78(BF8:(>O(:(;BJ8P8LL(H7>BH8(>O(

FBLM>LB;B>9I(:9F(M:=;PK(O=>J(;78(8;7BH:P(=BN>=BLJ(G9F8=PKB9N(7BL(:9:PKLBLI(<7BH7(L88JL(

>OO89LBS8(;>(J>F8=9(L89LBRBPB;B8LT`E(#L(:(=8LGP;(>O(;78(L7>HVB9N(9:;G=8(>O(;78(B9;=>FGH;B>9(

>O(=:FBH:P(8SBPI(;7B9V8=L(R>;7(H>9;8JM>=:=K(;>(1:9;(:9F(B9(>G=(><9(;BJ8I(<7>J(+(<BPP(

B9;=>FGH8(B9(<7:;(O>PP><LI(7:S8(<>9F8=8F(:R>G;(;78(MP:H8(>O(LGH7(:(H>9H8M;(B9(1:9;2L(

J>=:P(M7BP>L>M7KT(4>=8(LM8HBOBH:PPKI(;78K(gG8L;B>9(<78;78=(1:9;(B9;=>FGH8L(LGH7(:(

H>9H8M;(O>=(9>9hM7BP>L>M7BH:P(=8:L>9LI(LGH7(:L(G998H8LL:=BPK(B9L8=;B9N(;78>P>NK(B9;>(7BL(

M7BP>L>M7K(B9(>=F8=(;>(N:B9(!7=BL;B:9(=8:F8=L(>=(B9(>=F8=(;>(:MM8:L8($=GLLB:9(H89L>=LT[(

,G8(;>(;78L8(H=B;BHBLJLI(;78=8(7:L(;=:FB;B>9:PPK(R889(PB;;P8(H>9L89LGL(=8N:=FB9N(<7K(1:9;(

<>GPF(B9;=>FGH8(LGH7(:(H>9H8M;(B9;>(7BL(<=B;B9NLT

+;(<BPP(R8(JK(;:LV(B9(;7BL(H7:M;8=I(;789I(;>(=8LM>9F(;>(;78L8(>R]8H;B>9L(RK(L7><B9N(

;78(J:]>=(<:KL(;7:;(;78(B9;=>FGH;B>9(>O(=:FBH:P(8SBP(78PML(;>(8WMP:B9(:9F(HP:=BOK(M>=;B>9L(

>O(1:9;2L(M=B>=(J>=:P(M7BP>L>M7KT\($=B>=(;>(;78(!"#$%$&':(1:9;(H>GPF(98B;78=(8WMP:B9(7><(B;(

<:L(M>LLBRP8(O>=(7GJ:9L(;>(O=88PK(H7>>L8(:9(8SBP(J:WBJ(9>=(H>GPF(78(:F8gG:;8PK(P>H:;8(

;78(L>G=H8(>O(8SBP(B9(7GJ:9LT(+;(<:L(>9PK(<B;7(7BL(B9S8L;BN:;B>9(B9;>(;78(J>=:P(L;:;GL(>O(

7GJ:9(9:;G=8(:9F(7BL(H>9HPGLB>9(=8N:=FB9N(=:FBH:P(8SBPI(R>;7(>O(<7BH7(:MM8:=(B9(;78(

!"#$%$&':(;7:;(78(H>GPF(]GL;BOK(:9F(HP:=BOK(;78L8(HP:BJL(J:F8(B9(7BL(8:=PB8=(M=:H;BH:P(<>=VLT(

%78(!"#$%$&'(:9F(7BL(HP:BJ(:R>G;(;78(G9BS8=L:PB;K(>O(=:FBH:P(8SBP(:=8(;78=8O>=8(O:=(O=>J(

E "89=K(&T(#PPBL>9I(Y)9(;78(08=K(+F8:(>O(:($=>M89LB;K(;>(&SBPI`(D+"(G&-0'/#(&2(9/#-"(H'I-$0B(X\(?UccU@Q(XXCT

[ .>=(:(=8SB8<(>O(;7B9V8=L(<7>(7:S8(78PF(;7BL(M>LB;B>9I(L88(&JBP(/T(.:HV8978BJI(Y1:9;(:9F(':FBH:P(&SBPI`(J'$K"01$*B(&2(D&0&'*&(L-/0*"0#B(UX(?AD[E@T

\ 67BP8(+(<BPP(>9PK(:=NG8(B9(;7BL(H7:M;8=(;7:;(;78(HP:BJL(:R>G;(=:FBH:P(8SBP(O=>J(;78(!"#$%$&'(78PM(;>(HP:=BOK(:9F(8WMP:B9(M:=;L(>O(1:9;2L(M=B>=(J>=:P(M7BP>L>M7KI(+(<BPP(:=NG8(B9(;78(O>PP><B9N(H7:M;8=L(;7:;(;78L8(HP:BJL(:PL>(78PM(;>(F>(;78(L:J8(O>=(M>=;B>9L(>O(1:9;2L(J>=:P(M7BP>L>M7K(;7:;(O>PP><(;78(!"#$%$&':(:L(<8PPT

Page 16: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

_R8B9N(B9H>78=89;(>=(B9H>9LBL;89;(<B;7(7BL(J>=:P(M7BP>L>M7KT(':;78=I(:L(+(<BPP(L7><I(;78K(

:=8(:9(8LL89;B:P(M:=;(>O(7BL(8;7BH:P(M=>]8H;T

a8B9N(:RP8(;>(L7><(7><(=:FBH:P(8SBP(HP:=BOB8L(:9F(78PML(;>(8WMP:B9(M:=;L(>O(1:9;2L(

J>=:P(M7BP>L>M7K(<BPP(7:S8(LBN9BOBH:9;(M7BP>L>M7BH:P(BJMPBH:;B>9L(O>=(=8:FB9NL(>O(1:9;2L(

8;7BHLT(+O(B;(;G=9L(>G;(;7:;(;7BL(HP:BJ(F>8L(78PM(GL(;>(8WMP:B9(M:=;L(>O(7BL(J>=:P(M7BP>L>M7KI(

B;(<BPP(R8(98H8LL:=K(;>(;:V8(<7:;(1:9;(L:KL(:R>G;(=:FBH:P(8SBP(B9;>(:HH>G9;(<789(<8(

B9;8=M=8;(H8=;:B9(M:=;L(>O(7BL(8;7BHLT(-M(;>(;7BL(M>B9;I(;7BL(7:L(9>;(R889(F>98(B9(:(LBN9BOBH:9;(

<:K(B9(;78(L8H>9F:=K(PB;8=:;G=8TC

+9(<7:;(O>PP><LI(+(<BPP(OB=L;(B9;=>FGH8(;78(H7:=N8L(:N:B9L;(;78(!"#$%$&'=(#L(<8(<BPP(

L88I(L8S8=:P(H>9;8JM>=:=B8L(>O(1:9;(:9F(J>=8(J>F8=9(B9;8=M=8;8=L(>O(;7BL(<>=V(7:S8(

:=NG8F(;7:;(B;(8B;78=(O:BPL(;>(H>78=8(<B;7(;78(=8L;(>O(1:9;2L(H>=MGL(>=(<:L(<=B;;89(O>=(

;78>P>NBH:PI(=:;78=(;7:9(M7BP>L>M7BH:PI(=8:L>9LT(*8W;I(+(<BPP(F8;:BP(;78(J:]>=(H>JM>989;L(

>O(1:9;2L(HP:BJ(;7:;(:PP(7GJ:9L(:=8(=:FBH:PPK(8SBP(R>;7(RK(9:;G=8(:9F(;7=>GN7(:(O=88(RG;(

98H8LL:=K(H7>BH8T(+(<BPP(B9S8L;BN:;8(<7:;(1:9;(J8:9L(RK(Y=:FBH:P(8SBP`(:9F(<7K(78(;7B9VL(

;7:;(;7BL(L;:;8(BL(G9BS8=L:P(;>(:PP(7GJ:9LT(.B9:PPKI(+(<BPP(=8LM>9F(;>(;78(H7:=N8L(:N:B9L;(;78(

H>78=89H8(>O(;7BL(<>=V(<B;7(;78(=8L;(>O(1:9;2L(H>=MGL(RK(L7><B9N(;<>(V8K(<:KL(;7:;(;78(

!"#$%$&'(:9F(;78(HP:BJ(:R>G;(;78(G9BS8=L:PB;K(>O(=:FBH:P(8SBP(8WMP:B9(:9F(HP:=BOK(1:9;2L(

J>=:P(M7BP>L>M7KQ(RK(8WMP:B9B9N(;78(L>G=H8(>O(J>=:P(8SBP(B9(7GJ:9L(:9F(HP:=BOKB9N(;78(

7GJ:9(M>LLBRBPB;K(>O(O=88PK(H7>>LB9N(;>(R8(J>=:PPK(8SBPT

C #L(!7=BL(/T(.B=8L;>98(:9F(*:;7:9(b:H>RL(9>;8(B9(H'(4"2"'1"(&2(>/'*M1(!"#$%$&'(?+9FB:9:M>PBLQ(+9FB:9:(-9BS8=LB;K($=8LLI(Ucc_T@I(Y;78(]G=K(>O(H>9;8JM>=:=K(1:9;(B9;8=M=8;8=L(=8J:B9L(F8:FP>HV8F(>S8=(7><(R8L;(;>(G9F8=L;:9F(1:9;2L(!"#$%$&'`(?A@T(+9(PBN7;(>O(;7BL(F8:FP>HVI(;78=8(7:L(R889(9>(H>9L89LGL(;7:;(;78(!"#$%$&'(L7>GPF(R8(H>9LBF8=8F(:(J:]>=(;8W;(B9(1:9;2L(H=B;BH:P(M7BP>L>M7K(:9F(GL8F(B9(B9;8=M=8;B9N(>;78=(M:=;L(>O(7BL(<=B;B9NL(?AI(UXU@T

Page 17: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

D+,-*!"#$%$&'*.%-/*0%#*1%,-$-*2)#,*#,-*3-/#*%4*56"#7/*1%$8'/

%78('8:H;B>9(>O(1:9;2L(!>9;8JM>=:=B8L

1:9;2L(B9;=>FGH;B>9(>O(=:FBH:P(8SBP(B9(;78(!"#$%$&'(<:L(H>9;=>S8=LB:P(O=>J(;78(S8=K(

L;:=;T(3>J8(>O(1:9;2L(H>9;8JM>=:=B8LI(LGH7(:L(^>8;78(:9F(3H7BPP8=I(<7>(7:F(>9H8(M=:BL8F(

1:9;(:L(:(M=>M>989;(>O(7GJ:9(FBN9B;K(:9F(O=88F>J(9><(:HHGL8F(7BJ(>O(7:SB9N(GP;8=B>=(

J>;BS8L(B9(B9;=>FGHB9N(;7BL(YLH:9F:P>GL`(H>9H8M;T_(3H7BPP8=I(B9(M:=;BHGP:=I(:HHGL8F(7BJ(>O(

B9;=>FGHB9N(=:FBH:P(8SBPI(<7BH7(78(PBV898F(;>(;78(!7=BL;B:9(H>9H8M;(>O(>=BNB9:P(LB9I(>9PK(B9(

>=F8=(;>(:;;=:H;(!7=BL;B:9(O>PP><8=L(;>(7BL(M7BP>L>M7KTD(+9;8=8L;B9NPKI(;7BL(<>=V(:PL>(F=8<(

:9(>MM>LB;8I(;7>GN7(8gG:PPK(L;=>9NI(=8:H;B>9(O=>J(.=8F8=BHV(6BPPB:J(++I(;78(VB9N(>O(

$=GLLB:(FG=B9N(;7BL(M8=B>FT(1:9;(=8H8BS8F(:9(>=F8=(B9L;=GH;B9N(7BJ(;>(L;>M(MGRPBL7B9N(>9(

LGH7(;>MBHL(R8H:GL8(7BL(M7BP>L>M7K(FBL;>=;8F(:9F(FBLM:=:N8F(=8PBNB>9TAc(%7BL(>=F8=(:HHGL8F(

7BJ(>O((YJBLGLiB9Nj(7BL(M7BP>L>M7K(;>(FBLM:=:N8(=8PBNB>9I`AA(J8:9B9N(!7=BL;B:9B;KT(67BP8(

>98(H>9;B9N89HK(O>G9F(1:9;(;>(R8(M:9F8=B9N(;>(!7=BL;B:9L(B9(;78(!"#$%$&':(:9>;78=(

:HHGL8F(7BJ(>O(F8O:JB9N(;78(R8PB8OL(>O(;78(L:J8(=8PBNB>GL(N=>GMT

%78L8(>MM>L8FI(RG;(8gG:PPK(H=B;BH:PI(=8LM>9L8L(:=8(9>;(LG=M=BLB9NI(NBS89(;78(M8=B>F(

B9(<7BH7(1:9;(<=>;8(;78(!"#$%$&'=(1:9;(<=>;8(;7BL(<>=V(B9($=GLLB:(FG=B9N(;78(

&9PBN7;89J89;(?.$"(@2;#N0-'%@I(:(;BJ8(>O(GM78:S:P(>O(;=:FB;B>9:P(;7>GN7;(B9(J:9K(OB8PFLI(

_ .>=(:9(>S8=SB8<(>O(;78(=8:H;B>9(>O(1:9;2L(H>9;8JM>=:=B8LI(L88(.:HV8978BJI(Y1:9;(:9F(':FBH:P(&SBPI`(XXD(d([XT

D .=B8F=BH7(3H7BPP8=(;>(^T(1>8=98=I(U_(.8R=G:=K(ACDXI(B9(OF+$##"01(,0$"2":(8FT(.T(b>9:L(?3;G;;N:=;I(9TFT@I(+++I(U__T

Ac 1G879I(>/'*?(@(,$&%0/A+B:(XC_(d(CDT

AA .>=(:(F8;:BP8F(8WMP:9:;B>9(>O(;78(H>==8LM>9F89H8(R8;<889(;78(1B9N2L(=8M=8L89;:;BS8L(:9F(1:9;(=8N:=FB9N(;7BL(J:;;8=I(L88(1G879I(>/'*?(@(,$&%0/A+B:(XC_(d(_UT("8=8I(1G879(8WMP:B9L(;7:;(;78(1B9N(N:S8(1:9;(;7BL(>=F8=(R8H:GL8(78(O8P;(;7:;(7BL(<=B;B9NL(:FS>H:;8F(=8PBNB>GL(O=88F>JI(<7BH7(>MM>L8F(;78(1B9N2L(YM:;8=9:P(MG=M>L8`(>O(M=>;8H;B9N(!7=BL;B:9B;KT(1:9;(=8LM>9F8F(RK(<=B;B9N(;>(;78(1B9N(;7:;(7BL(M7BP>L>M7KI(>9(;78(H>9;=:=KI(FBF(9>;(:FF=8LL(!7=BL;B:9B;K(:;(:PPI(RG;(78(98S8=;78P8LL(:N=88F(;>(H8:L8(<=B;B9N(:R>G;(=8PBNB>9T(%7BL(BL(:(M=>JBL8(;7:;(78(FBF(9>;(V88MT

Page 18: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

AcB9HPGFB9N(M7BP>L>M7K(:9F(;78>P>NKT(67BP8(;78=8(<:L(:(FBS8=LB;K(>O(;7>GN7;(:J>9N(

&9PBN7;89J89;(;7B9V8=LI(;78K(;89F8F(;>(R:L8(=8PBNB>GL(;7>GN7;(GM>9(;78(M=8LGMM>LB;B>9(

;7:;(7GJ:9(9:;G=8(BL(9:;G=:PPK(N>>FT(%7B9V8=L(>O(;7BL(;BJ8(;89F8F(;>(F89K(;78(=8:PB;K(>O(

>=BNB9:P(LB9I(B9L;8:F(:=NGB9N(;7:;(7GJ:9L(:=8(N>>F(RK(9:;G=8T(a8H:GL8(>O(;7BL(M>LB;B>9I(

;78K(:PL>(:=NG8F(;7:;(:9K(O:PP(O=>J(N>>F98LL(H>GPF(9>;(R8(;78(O:GP;(>O(;7:;(M8=L>9(RG;(;78(

O:GP;(>O(L>J8;7B9N(8W;8=9:PI(PBV8(BN9>=:9H8(>=(L>HB:P(M=8LLG=8TAU(b8:9(b:HgG8L('>GLL8:GI(

:9>;78=(H>9;8JM>=:=K(>O(1:9;I(BL(M8=7:ML(;78(R8L;(8W:JMP8(>O(;7BL(M:=;BHGP:=(

&9PBN7;89J89;(M8=LM8H;BS8TAX(("8(:=NG8F(;7:;(J>=:PB;K(BL(9>;(:(9:;G=:P(M:=;(>O(7GJ:9B;K(RG;(

;7:;(:PP(7GJ:9L(:=8(R>=9(N>>FI(;7>GN7(9>;(B9(;78(L89L8(>O(R8B9N(SB=;G>GLT(%78K(>9PK(:H;(

R:FPK(R8H:GL8(>O(:(L>HB:P(O:PP(:9F(:=8(;78=8O>=8(9>;(=8LM>9LBRP8(O>=(;78B=(8SBPTAE

1:9;2L(98<(H>9H8M;I(;789I(L;:9FL(B9(FB=8H;(>MM>LB;B>9(;>(;78(N898=:P(;>98(>O(J>=:P(

;7>GN7;(B9(;78(&9PBN7;89J89;T(+;(BL(;78=8O>=8(8:LK(;>(L88(<7K(1:9;2L(B9;=>FGH;B>9(>O(;78(

BF8:(;7:;(:PP(7GJ:9L(:=8(9:;G=:PPK(=:FBH:PPK(8SBP(:9FI(OG=;78=I(;7:;(;78K(:=8(=8LM>9LBRP8(O>=(

;7BL(8SBPI(<>GPF(R8(J8;(<B;7(=8LBL;:9H8T(%7BL(B9;=>FGH;B>9(BL(8S89(J>=8(>G;(>O(MP:H8(<789(

<8(;:V8(B9;>(:HH>G9;(;7:;(1:9;(7BJL8PO(<:L(:9(&9PBN7;89J89;(;7B9V8=I(8S89(<=B;B9N(:(

<>=V(8WMP:B9B9N(:9F(:FS>H:;B9N(;78(LH7>>P(>O(;7>GN7;TA[(4>=8>S8=I(;7BL(HP:BJ(L88JL(;>(R8(

>MM>L8F(;>(H8=;:B9(HP:BJL(1:9;(J:V8L(B9(7BL(><9(J>=:P(M7BP>L>M7KT(#L(4BH7:PL>9(9>;8LI(

Y=:FBH:P(8SBP(BL(F8OB98F(B9(LGH7(:(<:K(:L(;>(MG;(B9(gG8L;B>9(>G=(:RBPB;K(;>(L:S8(>G=L8PS8L(d(

AU(((^>=F>9(&T(4BH7:PL>9I(b=TI(P/##"'(P0"".&E(?!:JR=BFN8Q(!:JR=BFN8(-9BS8=LB;K($=8LLI(ADDc@I(E_(d(EDT

AX 0B9H89;(#T(4H!:=;7K(J:V8L(;7BL(:=NGJ89;(B9(L-"1*(2&0(/(C+$#&1&A+$F/#(G"1-1I(?4:H>9I(^8>=NB:Q(48=H8=(-9BS8=LB;K($=8LLI(AD_\@I(CET

AE .>=(;7BL(:=NGJ89;I(L88(b8:9(b:HgG8L('>GLL8:GI(O"F&'.(4$1F&-01":(Q'(*+"(Q0$%$'(/'.(P&-'./*$&'1(&2 (H'"I-/#$*B(/E&'%(3"':(B9(D+"(4$1F&-01"1(/'.(Q*+"0(R/0#B(C&#$*$F/#(S0$*$'%1:(8FT(0BH;>=(^>G=8SB;H7T(?!:JR=BFN8Q(!:JR=BFN8(-9BS8=LB;K($=8LLI(ADDC@T

A[ +JJ:9G8P(1:9;T(Y#9(#9L<8=(;>(;78(kG8L;B>9Q(67:;(BL(&9PBN7;89J89;l`(B9(C0/F*$F/#(C+$#&1&A+B:(;=:9LT(:9F(8FT(4:=K(bT(^=8N>=T(?!:JR=BFN8Q(!:JR=BFN8(-9BS8=LB;K($=8LLI(ADD\@T

Page 19: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

AA:9(>FF(=8LGP;(O>=(:(;7B9V8=(<7>(J:V8L(7GJ:9(:G;>9>JK(;78(78:=;(>O(7BL(M7BP>L>M7BH:P(

SBLB>9T`A\(+;(BL(B9F88F(:9(>FF(HP:BJ(BO(>9PK(O>=(;78(M=>RP8J(;7:;(B;(L8;L(GM(O>=(1:9;2L(><9(

J>=:P(M7BP>L>M7KT(%7>GN7(;78(Y>GN7;(BJMPB8L(H:9`(M=B9HBMP8AC(BL(BJMPBHB;(B9(7BL(J>=:P(

;78>=KI(;78(HP:BJ(;7:;(:PP(7GJ:9L(:=8(=:FBH:PPK(8SBP(J:V8L(;78(J>=:P(>GN7;(L88JB9NPK(

BJM>LLBRP8(;>(:H7B8S8(O>=(7GJ:9LT(#L(<8(<BPP(L88(O=>J(;78(F8OB9B;B>9(>O(=:FBH:P(8SBPI(B9(

<7:;(O>PP><LI(R8B9N(=:FBH:PPK(8SBP(L88JL(;>(;:V8(:<:K(;78(M>LLBRBPB;K(>O(R8H>JB9N(J>=:PPK(

N>>FI(<7BH7(JGL;(R8(M>LLBRP8(B9(1:9;2L(:HH>G9;(>O(8;7BHLT(#L(<8(H:9(L88I(;78(H>9H8M;(>O(

=:FBH:P(8SBP(BL(9>;(LG=M=BLB9N(>9PK(R8H:GL8(B;(F>8L(9>;(OB;(B9;>(;78(B9;8PP8H;G:P(J>S8J89;(B9(

<7BH7(1:9;(F8S8P>M8F(B;(RG;(:PL>(R8H:GL8(B;(F>8L(9>;(L88J(;>(OB;(<B;7B9(;78(N898=:P(LMB=B;(

>O(1:9;2L(><9(J>=:P(M7BP>L>M7KT(

!>9;B9GB9N('8LBL;:9H8(B9(;78(38H>9F:=K(/B;8=:;G=8

19><B9N(;78(H>9;8W;(B9(<7BH7(1:9;(<=>;8(B;I(B;(J:K(9>;(R8(LG=M=BLB9N(;7:;(;78(

!"#$%$&':(:9F(M:=;BHGP:=PK(7BL(B9;=>FGH;B>9(>O(=:FBH:P(8SBP(:9F(7BL(L>PG;B>9(;>(>S8=H>JB9N(

B;I(<7BH7(+(<BPP(FBLHGLL(B9(<7:;(O>PP><LI(=8J:B9L(H>9;=>S8=LB:P(B9(M=8L89;(F:K(L8H>9F:=K(

PB;8=:;G=8T($8=7:ML(;78(J>L;(LBN9BOBH:9;(;>MBH(<B;7(<7BH7(H>JJ89;:;>=L(9><(;:V8(BLLG8(BL(

S8=K(LBJBP:=(;>(;78(>98(;:V89(GM(RK(;7B9V8=L(H>9;8JM>=:=K(;>(1:9;(h(7><(;78(B9;=>FGH;B>9(

>O(;78(98<(H>9H8M;(>O(=:FBH:P(8SBP(OB;L(B9(<B;7(;78(=8L;(>O(7BL(<=B;B9NLT(

%78(OB=L;(J>F8=9(F:K(H>JJ89;:;>=(;7:;(+(<BPP(;G=9(;>(BL($7BPBM(/T(kGB99T("8(7>PFL(

:(M>LB;B>9(;7:;(;89FL(;>(OB;(LgG:=8PK(<B;7(;78(>98(;:V89(RK(1:9;2L(M7BP>L>M7BH:P(

H>9;8JM>=:=B8LI(;7:;(;78(!"#$%$&'(BL(:9(:;;8JM;(;>(=:;B>9:PBe8(H8=;:B9(M:=;L(>O(

A\ 4BH7:PL>9I(P/##"'(P0"".&E:([T

AC +JJ:9G8P(1:9;I(T0$*$I-"(&2(C-0"(!"/1&':(;=:9LT(:9F(8FT($:GP(^GK8=(:9F(#PP89(6T(6>>FT(?!:JR=BFN8Q(!:JR=BFN8(-9BS8=LB;K($=8LLI(ADDC@I((#[ECma[C[T(Y*><(;7BL(2>GN7;2(8WM=8LL8L(:(M>LLBRP8(:H;B>9TTT`

Page 20: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

AU!7=BL;B:9B;KTA_(+9(;7BL(=8:FB9NI(78(7>PFL(;7:;(1:9;(FBF(9>;(7:S8(M7BP>L>M7BH:P(=8:L>9L(O>=(

7BL(B9;=>FGH;B>9(>O(;78(H>9H8M;(>O(=:FBH:P(8SBPI(>=(;78(H>9H8M;L(;7:;(L88J(;>(98H8LLB;:;8(B;L(

B9;=>FGH;B>9I(RG;(=:;78=(;7:;(78(<:L(;=KB9N(;>(B9L8=;(=8PBNB>9(B9;>(7BL(M7BP>L>M7K(B9(:(<:K(

;7:;(FBF(9>;(9:;G=:PPK(O>PP><(O=>J(7BL(;78>=B8LT(kGB99(<=B;8L(;7:;

i1:9;2Lj(F>H;=B98(>O(=:FBH:P(8SBP(BL(B9;89F8F(:L(:(=:;B>9:P(=8MP:H8J89;(O>=(;=:FB;B>9:P(S8=LB>9L(>O(;78(F>H;=B98(>O(>=BNB9:P(LB9T("8(=8H>JJ89FL(B;(O>=(R8PB8O(>9(;78(N=>G9FL(;7:;(B;(BL(B9;8=9:PPK(H>9LBL;89;I(;7:;(B;(BL(8W;8=9:PPK(H>9LBL;89;(<B;7(8S8=K;7B9N(<8(H:9(V9><(<B;7B9(;78(O=:J8<>=V(>O(7BL(J:;G=8(M=:H;BH:P(M7BP>L>M7KI(:9F(;7:;I(B9(:FFB;B>9I(B;(BL(LGMM>=;8F(RK(B9FGH;BS8(8SBF89H8(;>(;78(8W;89;(LGH7(LGMM>=;(BL(M>LLBRP8(<B;7B9(;7:;(O=:J8<>=VTAD

kGB99(R:L8L(7BL(HP:BJ(;7:;(;78(B9;=>FGH;B>9(>O(=:FBH:P(8SBP(L8=S8L(;>(]GL;BOK(;78(!7=BL;B:9(

;78>=K(>O(>=BNB9:P(LB9(GM>9(;78(HP:BJ(;7:;(1:9;(F=:<L(GM>9(!7=BL;B:9(B9;GB;B>9L(:9F(

M=8LGMM>LB;B>9L(B9(;78(!"#$%$&'=(3M8HBOBH:PPKI(kGB99(BF89;BOB8L(;<>(>O(;78L8(Y!7=BL;B:9(

M=8LGMM>LB;B>9L`(h(;78(M=8LGMM>LB;B>9(;7:;(<8(H:9(:LLBN9(J>=:P(<>=;7(;>(;78(H7:=:H;8=(:9F(

:H;B>9L(>O(B9FBSBFG:P(7GJ:9(R8B9NL(:9F(;78(M=8LGMM>LB;B>9(;7:;(;7BL(<>=;7(BL(:H7B8S8F(

;7=>GN7(;78(GL8(>O(O=88F>JT("8(;7B9VL(;7:;(1:9;(:PL>(:HH8M;L(;78(O>PP><B9N(Y!7=BL;B:9(

B9;GB;B>9L`Q(;7:;(:PJ>L;(:PP(7GJ:9L(7:S8(:(H7:=:H;8=(;7:;(BL(L;:B98F(B9(LGH7(:(<:K(;7:;(B;(

H:99>;(R8(]GFN8F(;>(R8(J>=:PPK(N>>F(:9F(;7:;(>9PK(:(M8=O8H;PK(N>>F(7GJ:9(H7:=:H;8=(H:9(

R8(P>>V8F(GM>9(<B;7(O:S>=(RK(^>FTUc

%78L8(M=8LGMM>LB;B>9L(:9F(B9;GB;B>9LI(<7BH7(kGB99(BF89;BOB8L(<B;7(!7=BL;B:9B;KI(:=8(

<7K(kGB99(;7B9VL(;7:;(1:9;(B9;=>FGH8L(=:FBH:P(8SBPI(:L(:(H>9H8M;(;7:;(:=BL8L(O=>J(LGH7(

M=8LGMM>LB;B>9LT(a8H:GL8(kGB99(BF89;BOB8L(;78J(:L(!7=BL;B:9(:LLGJM;B>9LI(78(;7B9VL(;7:;(

=:FBH:P(8SBP(B;L8PO(:=BL8L(B9(;78(!"#$%$&'(:L(:(;78>P>NBH:PI(=:;78=(;7:9(M7BP>L>M7BH:PI(

A_ $7BPBM(/T(kGB99I(Y)=BNB9:P(3B9I(':FBH:P(&SBPI(:9F(4>=:P(+F89;B;KI`(P/$*+(/'.(C+$#&1&A+B(AT(UT(?AD_E@Q(A__(d(UcUT

AD kGB99I(Y)=BNB9:P(3B9I`(A_DT

Uc kGB99I(Y)=BNB9:P(3B9I`(UccT

Page 21: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

AXH>9H8M;T(+9(>;78=(<>=FLI(kGB99(;:V8L(;78(M>LB;B>9(;7:;(=:FBH:P(8SBP(F>8L(9>;(O>PP><(O=>J(

;78(=8L;(>O(1:9;2L(M7BP>L>M7BH:P(?J>=8(LM8HBOBH:PPKI(J>=:P@(;78>=K(RG;(=:;78=(BL(B9L8=;8F(>9(

;78(R:LBL(>O(9>9hM7BP>L>M7BH:P(;78>P>NKT(%78=8O>=8I(;>(;:V8(kGB992L(M>LB;B>9(BL(;>(:=NG8(

;7:;(;78(!"#$%$&'(F>8L(9>;(H>78=8I(B9(;78(L89L8(>O(O>PP><B9N(9:;G=:PPK(:9F(M7BP>L>M7BH:PPKI(

<B;7(;78(=8L;(>O(1:9;2L(H>=MGLT()9(M7BP>L>M7BH:P(N=>G9FLI(B;(BL(:9(G9]GL;BOB8F(R=8:V(O=>J(

;78(=8L;(>O(1:9;2L(<=B;B9NLT

5B=JBK:7G(5>S8PI(B9(7BL(>/'*(/'.(*+"(C+$#&1&A+B(&2(U$1*&0B:UA(L7:=8L(;7BL(;KM8(>O(

=8:FB9NI(;7>GN7(78(]GL;BOB8L(B;(RK(:(FBOO8=89;(=>G;8T(':;78=(;7:9(:=NGB9N(;7:;(=:FBH:P(8SBP(

:=BL8L(:L(:(H>9H8M;(B9(1:9;2L(J>=:P(;78>=K(R8H:GL8(B;(O>PP><L(O=>J(=8PBNB>GL(

M=8LGMM>LB;B>9LI(78(;7B9VL(;7:;(1:9;(B9;=>FGH8L(B;(B9(>=F8=(;>(H>9FGH;(:(FB=8H;(:;;:HV(>9(

=8PBNB>9I(:;(P:=N8T("8(7>PFL(;78(M>LB;B>9(;7:;(JGH7(>O(<7:;(BL(L:BF(B9(;78(!"#$%$&'(BL(L:BF(

8PL8<78=8(B9(1:9;2L(8;7BHL(:9F(<7:;(BL(98<(BL(J8=8PK(Y:9(G9H>JM=>JBLB9N(:;;:HV(GM>9(

;78(8WBL;B9N(=8PBNB>9L(:9F(:9(:;;8JM;(;>(8PBJB9:;8(;78J(O=>J(;78(7BL;>=BH:P(LH898T`UU(/BV8(

kGB99I(78(BL(S8=K(HP8:=(;7:;(1:9;(7:L(:9(GP;8=B>=(J>;BS8I(R8K>9F(J8=8PK(:FS:9HB9N(7BL(

><9(M7BP>L>M7BH:P(;78>=B8LI(B9(7BL(<=B;B9N(>O(;7BL(<>=VT(5>S8P(:HHGL8L(7BJ(>O(:;;8JM;B9N(

;>(F8L;=>K(:9K;7B9N(B9(=8PBNB>9(;7:;(M=:H;BH:P(=8:L>9(H:99>;(H>9F>98T("8(;7B9VL(;7:;(1:9;(

:H7B8S8L(7BL(N>:P(>O(;78(Y7BL;>=BH:P(M=>M:N:;B>9(>O(J>=:PB;K`(;7=>GN7(YLGNN8L;B>9(:9F(

M8=LG:LBS8(;8H79BgG8LI`(:L(<8PP(:L(;=:9LP:;B9N(M:LL:N8L(B9(3H=BM;G=8(B9;>(J>=:P(;8=JLTUX(

5>S8P(HP:BJL(;7:;(1:9;(FBF(9>;(<=B;8(;78(!"#$%$&'(B9(>=F8=(;>(F8S8P>M(:9K(M:=;L(>O(7BL(

J>=:P(;78>=K(RG;(J8=8PK(;>(B9]8H;(:(=8PBNB>GL(LMB=B;(B9;>(B;(:9F(;78=8RK(8P8S:;8(B;L(

UA 5B=JBK:7G(5>S8PI(>/'*(/'.(*+"(C+$#&1&A+B(&2(U$1*&0B:(?$=B9H8;>9I(*bQ($=B9H8;>9(-9BS8=LB;K($=8LLI(AD_c@T

UU 5>S8PI(>/'*(/'.(*+"(C+$#&1&A+B(&2(U$1*&0B:(UcUT

UX 5>S8PI(>/'*(/'.(*+"(C+$#&1&A+B(&2(U$1*&0B:(UcU(d(UcXT

Page 22: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

AEBJM>=;:9H8(B9(>G=(F:BPK(PBS8LTUE(+OI(RK(;7BL(=8:FB9NI(<8(H:9(HP:BJ(;7:;(;78(!"#$%$&'(H>78=8L(

<B;7(;78(=8L;(>O(;78(H>=MGLI(B;(BL(>9PK(B9L>O:=(:L(B;L(H>9H8M;L(8B;78=(:=8(:P=8:FK(O>G9F(B9(

>;78=(<>=VL(>=(;7:;(B;(GL8L(;78L8(H>9H8M;L(B9(>=F8=(;>(:H7B8S8(:(=8PBNB>GL(:N89F:T(

$7BP>L>M7BH:PPK(LM8:VB9NI(BO(<8(:=8(;>(:HH8M;(5>S8P2L(M8=LM8H;BS8I(<8(H:99>;(L:K(;7:;(;7BL(

<>=V(H>78=8L(<B;7(;78(=8L;(B9(:9K(J8:9B9NOGP(<:KI(B9(;78(L89L8(;7:;(B;(OG=;78=(F8S8P>ML(

H>9H8M;L(>=(7:L(;78(L:J8(M7BP>L>M7BH:P(J>;BS:;B>9T

#(OB9:P(J8JR8=(>O(;7BL(H:JM(BL(^>=F>9(&T(4BH7:PL>9I(<7>(:=NG8LI(H>9;=:=K(;>(

5>S8P2L(HP:BJI(;7:;(1:9;(B9;=>FGH8L(;78(98<(H>9H8M;(>O(=:FBH:P(8SBP(B9(;78(!"#$%$&'(J8=8PK(

;>(J:V8(7BL(J>=:P(;78>=K(:J89:RP8(;>(=8PBNB>GL(:9F(;78>P>NBH:P(H>9H8=9LT(67BP8(78(F>8L(

9>;(:;;=BRG;8(J>;BS:;B>9L(>O(FBL7>98L;K(>=(G9F8=7:9F8F98LL(;>(1:9;(O>=(<=B;B9N(;7BL(<>=VI(

78(F>8L(;7B9V(;7:;(;78=8(BL(:(LBN9BOBH:9;(FBOO8=89H8(R8;<889(;7BL(<>=V(:9F(1:9;2L(>;78=LT(

"8(FB=8H;PK(L;:;8L(;7:;(78(F>8L(9>;(:N=88(<B;7(B9;8=M=8;:;B>9L(>O(;7BL(<>=V(;7:;(M=8L89;(:(

!"#$%$&'(;7:;(H>78=8L(<B;7(;78(=8L;(>O(;78(H>=MGLT("8(<=B;8LI

i%7BL(VB9F(>O(=8:FB9Nj(L88JL(;>(G9F8=S:PG8(;78(S8=K(=8:P(H7:9N8(B9(L89LBRBPB;K(B9;=>FGH8F(RK(;78(OB=L;(;<>(R>>VL(>O(;78(!"#$%$&'T(%78L8(:=8(9>;(<=B;B9NL(;7:;(OB;(H>JO>=;:RPK(<B;7B9(;78(&9PBN7;89J89;I(9>=(:=8(;78K(;78(M=8FBH;:RP8(O>PP><hGM(8OO>=;(;>(LJ>>;7(>G;(=>GN7(O8:;G=8L(>O(;78(P&-'./*$&'1(&2(*+"(3"*/A+B1$F1(&2 (3&0/#1(:9F(;78(T0$*$I-"(&2(C0/F*$F/#(!"/1&'=(a>;7(;78(R:LBH(M>LB;B>9(:9FI(8LM8HB:PPKI(;78(;>98(>O(;78(!"#$%$&'(:=8(LGOOBHB89;PK(FBOO8=89;(:L(;>(J:V8(B;(8W;=8J8PK(M=>RP8J:;BH(;>(MP:H8(;>>(JGH7(8JM7:LBL(>9(H>9;B9GB;KT(aG;(B;(JGL;(R8(L:BF(;7:;(B;(BL(]GL;(:L(FBOOBHGP;(;>(MB9M>B9;(;78(=8:L>9L(O>=(:(H7:9N8(B9(1:9;2L(M>B9;(>O(SB8<(>9(;78(J:;;8=(>O(J>=:P(8SBPTU[

67BP8(78(F>8L(9>;(R8PB8S8(;7:;(1:9;(BL(;=KB9N(;>(8B;78=(:;;:HV(=8PBNB>9(>=(:MM8:L8(!7=BL;B:9(

=8:F8=LI(78(BL(HP8:=(;7:;(78(:PL>(F>8L(9>;(R8PB8S8(;7:;(<8(L7>GPF(:PP><(<7:;(BL(L:BF(B9(;78(

!"#$%$&'(;>(B9OPG89H8(>G=(=8:FB9N(>O(>;78=(M:=;L(>O(1:9;2L(J>=:P(;78>=KT("8(;7B9VL(;7:;(;>(

UE 5>S8PI(>/'*(/'.(*+"(C+$#&1&A+B(&2(U$1*&0B:(UcD(d(AcT

U[ (4BH7:PL>9I(P/##"'(P0"".&E:(E_T

Page 23: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

A[GL8(;78(;78>=K(>O(=:FBH:P(8SBP(;>(]GL;BOK(>=(8WMP:B9(>;78=(M:=;L(>O(;78(H>=MGL(<>GPF(R8(:(

JBL;:V8(R8H:GL8(>O(;78(:MM:=89;(P:HV(>O(H>9;B9GB;K(R8;<889(;78(=8L;(>O(;78(H>=MGL(:9F(;7BL(

<>=VT

56"#7/*.)/('//)%"*%4*36&)(69*:;)9<*+,-*1%"#-"#

+9(>=F8=(;>(=8LM>9F(;>(;78L8(H7:=N8L(>O(B9H>78=89H8I(B;(BL(98H8LL:=K(OB=L;(;>(HP:=BOK(

<7:;(1:9;(L:KL(:R>G;(;78(H>9H8M;(>O(=:FBH:P(8SBP(B9(;78(!"#$%$&'=(%7:;(BLI(<8(JGL;(

G9F8=L;:9F(<7:;(78(J8:9L(RK(;7BL(H>9H8M;(:9F(RK(;78(L;:;8J89;(;7:;(:PP(7GJ:9L(:=8(

=:FBH:PPK(8SBP(RK(9:;G=8(:9F(;7=>GN7(:(O=88(RG;(98H8LL:=K(H7>BH8T(#O;8=(;7BL(8WMP:9:;B>9I(+(

<BPP(;789(8WMP>=8(;78(=8:L>9L(<7K(1:9;(JBN7;(7:S8(B9;=>FGH8F(;7BL(H>9H8M;(:9F(J:F8(;7BL(

HP:BJ(=8N:=FB9N(G9BS8=L:PB;K(:9F(F8O89F(<7K(B;(F>8LI(B9(O:H;I(H>78=8(<B;7(;78(=8L;(>O(7BL(

H>=MGLT

#P;7>GN7(;78(]GL;BOBH:;B>9(O>=(1:9;2L(HP:BJ(:R>G;(;78(G9BS8=L:PB;K(>O(=:FBH:P(8SBP(BL(

=:;78=(H>JMPBH:;8FI(;78(H>9;89;(>O(;7BL(HP:BJ(BL(JGH7(J>=8(L;=:BN7;O>=<:=FT(a8O>=8(

M=>H88FB9N(;>(;78(=8:L>9L(<7K(1:9;(J:K(7:S8(B9;=>FGH8F(B;(:9F(7><(B;(H>78=8L(<B;7(;78(

=8L;(>O(7BL(<=B;B9NLI(+(<BPP(=8SB8<(;78(J:]>=(H>JM>989;L(>O(1:9;2L(HP:BJ(;7:;(:PP(7GJ:9L(

:=8(=:FBH:PPK(8SBPT(%78=8(:=8(O>G=(J:]>=(M:=;L(>O(7BL(HP:BJT(.B=L;I(78(F8OB98L(=:FBH:P(8SBP(:L(

:(LGR>=FB9:;B>9(>O(;78(B9H89;BS8(>O(;78(J>=:P(P:<(;>(;78(B9H89;BS8L(>O(B9HPB9:;B>9(B9(>982L(

OG9F:J89;:P(J:WBJT(38H>9FI(78(:LL8=;L(;7:;I(B9(>=F8=(;>(R8(=:FBH:PPK(8SBPI(;7BL(

LGR>=FB9:;B>9(>O(B9H89;BS8L(JGL;(R8(O=88PK(H7>L89(:9F(;7GL(BJMG;:RP8(;>(;7>L8(<7>(

H7>>L8(B;T(%7B=FI(;7BL(H7>BH8(>O(:9(8SBP(OG9F:J89;:P(J:WBJ(BL(G9BS8=L:P(B9(7GJ:9L(:9F(

B99:;8(;>(7GJ:9(9:;G=8T(.B9:PPKI(B;(JGL;(R8(M>LLBRP8(;>(>S8=H>J8(=:FBH:P(8SBPI(8S89(;7>GN7(

B;(J:K(9>;(R8(M>LLBRP8(O>=(7GJ:9L(;>(F>(;7BL(RK(;78B=(><9(M><8=LT

Page 24: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

A\#(,8OB9B;B>9(>O(':FBH:P(&SBP

%78(OB=L;(J:]>=(H>JM>989;(>O(1:9;2L(:=NGJ89;(O>=(;78(G9BS8=L:PB;K(>O(=:FBH:P(8SBP(

BL(:(F8OB9B;B>9(>O(;7BL(;8=JT(+9(L7>=;I(;>(R8(=:FBH:PPK(8SBP(BL(;>(7:S8(:(H>==GM;8F(

OG9F:J89;:P(J:WBJT($=B>=(;>(;78(!"#$%$&':(1:9;(7:F(>9PK(FBLHGLL8F(;78(H>9H8M;(>O(

J:WBJL(B9(;78(H:L8(>O(M:=;BHGP:=(:H;B>9L(RG;(7:F(9>;(FBLHGLL8F(;78(8WBL;89H8(>O(:(

OG9F:J89;:P(J:WBJTU\*#(J:WBJI(:HH>=FB9N(;>(1:9;I(BL(Y;78(A0$'F$A#"(&2(K&#$*$&'(B9(

:HH>=F:9H8(<B;7(<7BH7(;78(:H;B>9(BL(F>98T`UC(6789(:(7GJ:9(M8=O>=JL(:9(:H;B>9I(78(7:L(

;<>(H:;8N>=B8L(>O(M>LLBRP8(B9H89;BS8L(GM>9(<7BH7(;>(:H;Q(;78(B9H89;BS8L(>O(;78(M=B9HBMP8(>O(

;78(J>=:P(P:<(:9F(;78(78;8=>9>J>GL(B9H89;BS8L(>O(B9HPB9:;B>9TU_(%78L8(:=8(R>;7(M>LLBRP8(

B9H89;BS8L(R8H:GL8(7GJ:9L(:=8(R>;7(=:;B>9:PI(O=88(R8B9NL(:9F(:PL>(L89LBRP8(R8B9NLTUD*+9(;78(

H:L8(>O(8:H7(:H;B>9I(;789I(:(M8=L>9(O=88PK(F8;8=JB98L(7BL(><9(<BPP(RK(F8HBFB9N(GM>9(<7BH7(

M=B9HBMP8LI(>=(J:WBJLI(;>(:H;T(%7=>GN7>G;(;78(60&-'.)&0;(&2(*+"(3"*/A+B1$F1(&2(3&0/#1 (

?60-'.#"%-'%(7-0(3"*/A+B1$;(."0(O$**"'@(:9F(;78(T0$*$I-"(&2(C0/F*$F/#(!"/1&'(?>0$*$; (

U\ %7BL(7:L(R889(;78(;=:FB;B>9:P(<:K(>O(=8:FB9N(1:9;2L(H>9H8M;(>O(J:WBJL(B9(7BL(M=:H;BH:P(M7BP>L>M7KT("><8S8=I(L>J8(H>9;8JM>=:=K(M7BP>L>M78=L(7:S8(R8NG9(;>(H7:PP89N8(;7BL(SB8<I(:=NGB9N(;7:;(J:WBJL(:=8(9>;(=8:L>9L(R87B9F(M:=;BHGP:=(:H;B>9L(RG;(B9L;8:F(:=8(L>J8;7B9N(PBV8(N898=:P(=GP8L(O>=(PBSB9NT(.>=(:(J>=8(F8;:BP8F(FBLHGLLB>9(>O(R>;7(;78(98<(:9F(;=:FB;B>9:P(SB8<(>O(;78(=>P8(>O(J:WBJL(B9(1:9;2L(8;7BHLI(L88('BH7:=F('T(4H!:=;7KI(Y4:WBJL(B9(1:9;2L($=:H;BH:P($7BP>L>M7KI`(G&-0'/#(&2(*+"(U$1*&0B(&2(C+$#&1&A+B(EET(AT(?b:9(Ucc\@T(#PL>(L88("89=K(&T(#PPBL>9I(>/'*M1(D+"&0B(&2(P0"".&E(?!:JR=BFN8Q(!:JR=BFN8(-9BS8=LB;K($=8LLI(ADDc@Q(_[(d(DE(O>=(:(=8SB8<(>O(S:=B>GL(<:KL(>O(F8OB9B9N(:(J:WBJT(#;(;7BL(M>B9;(B9(JK(M=>]8H;I(+(<BPP(:F78=8(;>(;78(;=:FB;B>9:P(<:K(>O(SB8<B9N(>O(;78(=>P8(>O(J:WBJLI(:;(P8:L;(B9(1:9;2L(8:=PB8=(M=:H;BH:P(<>=VL(M=B>=(;>(;78(!"#$%$&':(R8H:GL8I(O=>J(;78(<:K(78(F8OB98L(;78(;8=JI(1:9;(:MM8:=L(;>(R8(H>9H8=98F(:R>G;(J:WBJL(>O(M:=;BHGP:=(:H;B>9L(B9(;78L8(8:=PK(<>=VLT

UC +JJ:9G8P(1:9;I(60-'.#"%-'%(7-0(3"*/A+B1$;(."0(O$**"':(?":JRG=NQ(08=P:N(S>9(.8PBW(48B98=I(AD\[@T(.>=(&9NPBL7(;=:9LP:;B>9LI(+JJ:9G8P(1:9;I(60&-'.)&0;(&2(*+"(3"*/A+B1$F1(&2(3&0/#1:(B9(C0/F*$F/# (C+$#&1&A+B:(8FT(:9F(;=:9LT(4:=K(bT(^=8N>==(?!:JR=BFN8Q(!:JR=BFN8(-9BS8=LB;K($=8LLI(ADD\@I(EQXDD(d(EQEccT(?YTTT$E(C0$'7$A(."1(S$##"'1:(G9:9N8L8789(F8=(n<8HV8I(FB8(FG=H7(L>PH78(":9FPG9N(R8<B=V;(<8=F89(Vo9989pTTT`@(.=>J(78=8(>9I(+(<BPP(=8O8=(;>(;7BL(<>=V(:L(;78(60&-'.)&0;=

U_ 1:9;I(60&-'.)&0;I(EQEccT

UD 67BP8(1:9;(;:PVL(:R>G;(;7BL(O8:;G=8(>O(7GJ:9B;K(B9(L8S8=:P(MP:H8L(B9(7BL(<=B;B9NLI(78(P:KL(B;(>G;(gGB;8(98:;PK(B9(!"#$%$&'(\QU\I(<78=8(78(9>;8L(;7:;(7GJ:9L(:=8(PBSB9NI(>=(L89LBRP8I(R8B9NLI(=:;B>9:P(R8B9NLI(:9F(:PL>(J>=:P(R8B9NLT

Page 25: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

AC."0(C0/F*$1F+"'(9"0'-'2*@:Xc(1:9;(O>HGL8L(GM>9(J:WBJL(:;(;7BL(P8S8P(>O(M:=;BHGP:=(:H;B>9LT

aG;(9><I(B9(;78(!"#$%$&':(1:9;(B9;=>FGH8L(:(98<(P:K8=(;>(7BL(H>9H8M;(>O(J:WBJLQ(

;78(8WBL;89H8(>O(:(6"1$''-'%I(>=(:(J>L;(OG9F:J89;:P(J:WBJI(B9(8:H7(M8=L>9TXA(6B;7(;7BL(

B9;=>FGH;B>9I(78(NBS8L(GL(:(MBH;G=8(>O(:(;<>h;B8=8F(7B8=:=H7K(>O(J:WBJLT(%78(6"1$''-'%(BL(

:(M8=L>92L(YLGM=8J8(J:WBJ`(?.$"(&5"01*"(3/V$E"@IXU(>=(<7:;(BL(H>JJ>9PK(;=:9LP:;8F(:L(

>982L(YFBLM>LB;B>9T`XX(#L(B9(;78(H:L8(>O(P><8=(J:WBJLI(:(M8=L>9(H7>>L8L(78=(6"1$''-'%(RK(

F8HBFB9N(GM>9(:(M=B9HBMP8(>O(:H;B>9I(8B;78=(B9H89;BS8L(>O(B9HPB9:;B>9(>=(;78(B9H89;BS8(>O(

FG;KT(%7BL(M=B9HBMP8(B9OPG89H8L(;78(H7>BH8(>O(:9K(P><8=(J:WBJLTXE(.>=(8W:JMP8I(:HH>=FB9N(

;>(1:9;2L(;78>=KI(>982L(F8HBLB>9(;>(:F>M;(:(J:WBJ(>O(L8POhP>S8(B9(:(M:=;BHGP:=(H:L8(<>GPF(

Xc +JJ:9G8P(1:9;I(>0$*$;(."0(C0/F*$1F+"'(9"0'-'2*:(?/>9F>9Q('>G;P8FN8m%7>8JJ8L($=8LLI(ADDE@T(.>=(&9NPBL7(;=:9LP:;B>9LI(+JJ:9G8P(1:9;I(T0$*$I-"(&2(C0/F*$F/#(!"/1&':(+9(C0/F*$F/#(C+$#&1&A+B:(8FT(:9F(;=:9LT(4:=K(bT(^=8N>==(?!:JR=BFN8Q(!:JR=BFN8(-9BS8=LB;K($=8LLI(ADD\@Q([Q([C(d([Q\CT(.=>J(78=8(>9I(+(<BPP(:RR=8SB:;8(;7BL(<>=V(B9(O>>;9>;8L(:L(Y!$='T`

XA )9>=:()2*8BPP(=8O8=L(;>(;7BL(98<(B9;=>FGH;B>9(:L(B9;=>FGHB9N(;78(FBOO8=89H8(R8;<889(J:WBJL(;7:;(:=8(O>=(;78(L7>=;(;8=J(?<7:;(+(H:PP(J:WBJL(>O(M:=;BHGP:=(:H;B>9L@(:9F(O>=(;78(P>9N(;8=J(?:9(G9F8=PKB9N(J:WBJ@(?DC@T(388(>/'*?(!/*$&'/#$*B(/1(C0/F*$F/#(!"/1&':(B9(%78()WO>=F(":9FR>>V(>O(':;B>9:PB;KI(8FT(#PO=8F(bT(48P8(:9F($B8=L(':<PB9NT(?)WO>=FQ()WO>=F(-9BS8=LB;K($=8LLI(UccE@Q(DX(d(AcDT

XU 1:9;I(!"#$%$&':(\QXAT

XX %78=8(:=8(LBN9BOBH:9;(M=>RP8JL(<B;7(;=:9LP:;B9N(;78(<>=F(Y^8LB99G9N`(B9;>(&9NPBL7T(?388(3;8M789('T($:PJgGBL;I(B9;=>FGH;B>9(;>(!"#$%$&'()$*+$'(*+"(,&-'.1(&2(,/0"(!"/1&':(RK(+JJ:9G8P(1:9;I(;=:9LT(68=98=(3T($PG7:=(?+9FB:9:M>PBLQ(":HV8;;($GRPBL7B9N(!>I(+9HTI(UccD@@T(#L(3;8M789($:PJgGBL;(8WMP:B9LI(;78(;<>(J>L;(H>JJ>9(;=:9LP:;B>9L(O>=(;7BL(<>=FI(8B;78=(YFBLM>LB;B>9`(>=(Y:;;B;GF8I`(F>(9>;(M=>M8=PK(H:M;G=8(;78(J8:9B9N(>O(;78(^8=J:9(<>=FT(a>;7($:PJgGBL;(?WWSBBB'@(:9F(68=98=($PG7:=(?AE@(:N=88(;7:;(YFBLM>LB;B>9`(BL(R>;7(;>>(S:NG8(:9F(LGNN8L;L(;7:;(6"1$''-'%(BL(J>=8(J8;:M7KLBH:P(>=(R87:SB>=:P(;7:9(B;(:H;G:PPK(BLT(Y#;;B;GF8I`(>9(;78(>;78=(7:9FI(BL(Y;>>(S:NG8(:9F(;>>(8JMB=BH:P`(;>(H:M;G=8(;78(L;:RBPB;K(>O(>982L(6"1$''-'%(:9F(;78(M><8=(;7:;(;78(6"1$''-'%(7:L(;>(FB=8H;(:(M8=L>9(;><:=FL(;78(H7>BH8(>O(P><8=(J:WBJL(?WWSBBB'WT(.>=(;78L8(=8:L>9LI($:PJgGBL;(P8:9L(;><:=F(GLB9N(:(<>=F(PBV8(YH>9SBH;B>9`(:L(:(R8;;8=(;=:9LP:;B>9T("8(L:KL(;7:;(<8(L7>GPF(G9F8=L;:9F(;7BL(;8=J(9>;(:L(:(Y=8:L>98F(?M=>M>LB;B>9:P@(H>9HPGLB>9`(RG;(:L(Y:(78:=;hH89;8=8F(0"1&#K"(*&(/F*($'(/(F"0*/$'()/B`(?WWSBBB'@T(+(:J(L;=>9NPK(B9HPB98F(;>(:N=88(<B;7($:PJgGBL;(>9(O:S>=B9N(:(<>=F(PBV8(YH>9SBH;B>9`(R8H:GL8I(:L(<8(<BPP(L88(B9(!7:M;8=(%7=88I(;78=8(:=8(H>JM8PPB9N(=8:L>9L(;>(R8PB8S8(;7:;(>982L(6"1$''-'%(BL(:(H>JJB;J89;(>=(=8L>PG;B>9I(=:;78=(;7:9(:(;89F89HK(>=(:(O88PB9NT("><8S8=I(R8H:GL8(;7BL(;=:9LP:;B>9(H=8:;8L(H>9OGLB>9(<B;7(;78(H>JJ>9(;=:9LP:;B>9(?H>9SBH;B>9@(>O(;78(<>=F(YqR8=e8GNG9NI`($:PJgGBL;(>M;L(;>(=8H>JJ89F(:N:B9L;(;7BL(;=:9LP:;B>9(B9(;78(!"#$%$&'=(a8H:GL8(;78=8(F>8L(9>;(:MM8:=(;>(R8(:(FB=8H;(&9NPBL7(H>G9;8=M:=;(;>(;7BL(<>=F(:9F(R8H:GL8(;78(;=:FB;B>9:P(<:KL(>O(;=:9LP:;B9N(B;(O:BP(;>(H:M;G=8(B9(;78(H>9H8M;(B9(BJM>=;:9;(<:KLI(+(<BPP(GL8(;78(^8=J:9(6"1$''-'%(;7=>GN7>G;(;7BL(<>=VT

XE #L(.B=8L;>98(:9F(b:H>RLI(H'(4"2"'1"(&2(>/'*M1(!"#$%$&':(AEAI(9>;8I(Y;7BL(J:WBJI(:L(1-A0"E":(BL(:(LB9NP8(=GP8(=8N:=FB9N(;78(J>=:P(P:<(N898=:PPKI(:9F(GP;BJ:;8PK(F8OB98L(>G=(J>=:P(9:;G=8T`

Page 26: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

A_9>;(R8(:9(:=RB;=:=K(F8HBLB>9T(+;(<>GPF(R8(N=>G9F8F(B9(;7:;(M8=L>92L(6"1$''-'%T(+9(;7BL(

H:L8I(;78(6"1$''-'%(<>GPF(R8(:(J>=8(N898=:P(H>JJB;J89;(;>(M=B>=B;BeB9N(B9HPB9:;B>9LI(

LGH7(:L(L8POhP>S8I(:R>S8(;78(J>=:P(P:<(:L(;78(J>;BS:;B>9(O>=(>982L(:H;B>9LT

+;(BL(9>;(>RSB>GL(<7K(:(H7>BH8(>O(:9(8SBP(>=(N>>F(6"1$''-'%(<>GPF(NG:=:9;88(;7:;(

:(M8=L>92L(P><8=(J:WBJL(JGL;(:PL>(R8(8SBP(>=(N>>FT(#;(;7BL(M>B9;I(B;(L88JL(M>LLBRP8(;7:;(:(

M8=L>9(H>GPF(R8(N898=:PPK(H>JJB;;8F(;>(M=B>=B;BeB9N(B9HPB9:;B>9L(:R>S8(;78(J>=:P(P:<(RG;(

>HH:LB>9:PPK(L;=:K(O=>J(;7BL(H>JJB;J89;(:9F(:H;(O=>J(;78(J>=:P(P:<(B9(:(M:=;BHGP:=(H:L8T(

+9(>=F8=(;>(G9F8=L;:9F(<7K(1:9;(;7B9VL(;7:;(;7BL(VB9F(>O(F8SB:;B>9(O=>J(>982L(J>L;(

OG9F:J89;:P(H>JJB;J89;(BL(BJM>LLBRP8I(<8(JGL;(P>>V(;>(1:9;2L(G9F8=L;:9FB9N(>O(;78(

7GJ:9(<BPPT(+9(7BL(P:;8=(<>=VLI(B9HPGFB9N(;78(!"#$%$&':(;78(L8H>9F(T0$*$I-":(:9F(J>L;(

8WMPBHB;PK(B9(;78(3"*/A+B1$F1(&2(3&0/#1(?4$"(3"*/A+B1$;(."0(O$**"'@:X[(1:9;(R8NB9L(;>(GL8(

;<>(FBOO8=89;(<>=FLI(S$##"(:9F(S$##;X0I(;>(F8LH=BR8(;<>(FBOO8=89;(OG9H;B>9L(>O(;78(7GJ:9(

<BPPTX\(6789(;=:9LP:;8F(B9;>(&9NPBL7I(;78L8(;<>(^8=J:9(<>=FL(:=8(R>;7(;=:9LP:;8F(:L(

Y<BPPI`(<7BH7(J:V8L(;7BL(FBL;B9H;B>9(FBOOBHGP;(?BO(9>;(BJM>LLBRP8@(;>(F8;8H;T(%78=8O>=8I(+(

<BPP(=8O8=(;>(;78J(RK(;78B=(^8=J:9(9:J8LT(S$##"(BL(;78(P8NBLP:;BS8(OG9H;B>9(>O(;78(O:HGP;K(

>O(S>PB;B>9(?:PL>(H:PP8F(S$##"@I(:9F(S$##;X0(BL(;78(8W8HG;BS8(OG9H;B>9I(>=(;78(M><8=(>O(

H7>BH8T(#HH>=FB9N(;>(b>79('T(3BPR8=I(B9(Y%78(&;7BH:P(3BN9BOBH:9H8(>O(1:9;2L(!"#$%$&':`XC(

;78L8(;<>(OG9H;B>9L(>O(;78(<BPP(FBOO8=(R>;7(B9(;7:;(>98(:H;L(:9F(;78(>;78=(F>8L(9>;(:9F(;7:;(

X[ +JJ:9G8P(1:9;I(4$"(3"*/A+B1$;(."0(O$**"'=(?.BLH78=I(ADDc@T(.>=(&9NPBL7(;=:9LP:;B>9LI(+(<BPP(GL8(3"*/A+B$1F1(&2(3&0/#1:(B9(C0/F*$F/#(C+$#&1&A+B:(;=:9LT(:9F(8FT(4:=K(bT(^=8N>=(?!:JR=BFN8Q(!:JR=BFN8(-9BS8=LB;K($=8LLI(ADD\@T((.=>J(78=8(>9I(+(<BPP(:RR=8SB:;8(;7BL(<>=V(B9(O>>;9>;8L(:L(Y44T`

X\ #PPBL>9I(>/'*M1(D+"&0B(&2(P0"".&E:(AUD(h(Xc=("8=8I(#PPBL>9(M>B9;L(>G;(;7:;(1:9;2L(GL8(>O(;78L8(;<>(;8=JL(:MM8:=L(B9(:(O8<(>O(1:9;2L(J>=:P(<=B;B9NLT(%78(GL8(>O(;78L8(;8=JL(OB=L;(:MM8:=L(B9(;78(L8H>9F(T0$*$I-"(RG;(MP:KL(:(JGH7(P:=N8=(=>P8(B9(;78(!"#$%$&'=(%78(FBL;B9H;B>9(BL(J>L;(HP8:=PK(F8S8P>M8F(B9(;78(3"*/A+B1$F1(&2 (3&0/#1:(7><8S8=T

XC b>79(3BPR8=I(O>=8<>=F(;>(!"#$%$&'()$*+$'(*+"(Y$E$*1(&2(!"/1&'(@#&'"Z(>=I(Y%78(&;7BH:P(3BN9BOBH:9H8(>O(1:9;2L(!"#$%$&':`(RK(+JJ:9G8P(1:9;T(?*8<(5>=VQ(":=M8=()98I(AD\c@T

Page 27: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

AD>98(BL(O=88(:9F(;78(>;78=(BL(9>;T("8(<=B;8LI

-9PBV8(S$##;X0:(7><8S8=I(S$##"(F>8L(9>;(J:V8(F8HBLB>9L(>=(:F>M;(J:WBJLp(B;(F>8L(9>;(:H;T(':;78=(B;(BL(;78(L>G=H8(>O(:(L;=>9N(:9F(8S8=(M=8L89;(B9H89;BS8(B9(S$##;X0: (:9FI(BO(L;=>9N(89>GN7(;>(R8(:F>M;8F(RK(S$##;X0(B9;>(;78(J:WBJ(>O(B;L(H7>BH8I(S$##" (YH:9(F8;8=JB98(;78(S$##;X0[(:9F(;789(YB;(BL(M=:H;BH:P(=8:L>9(B;L8PO`(i"8(HB;8L(%T1T(#RR>;;2L(;=:9LP:;B>9(>O(;78(!"#$%$&'TjTTT%78(S$##"(=8M=8L89;L(;78(<BPP2L(><9(F8J:9F(O>=(L8POhOGPOBPPJ89;(RK(H>JJ:9FB9N(S$##;X0:(;7:;(:LM8H;(>O(;78(<BPP(<7BH7(H:9(8B;78=(OGPOBPP(>=(:R98N:;8(B;L(O=88F>JI(;>(:H;G:PBe8(B;L(O=88(9:;G=8(RK(<BPPB9N(B9(:HH>=F:9H8(<B;7(;78(P:<(?:9F(H>9FB;B>9@(>O(O=88F>JT(%78(J>L;(BJM>=;:9;(FBOO8=89H8(R8;<889(S$##"(:9F(S$##;X0(BL(:MM:=89;(78=8T(678=8:L(S$##;X0(BL(O=88(;>(:H;G:PBe8(8B;78=(;78(:G;>9>J>GL(>=(78;8=>9>J>GL(M>;89;B:PB;B8L(>O(;=:9LH89F89;:P(O=88F>JI(S$##"(BL(9>;(O=88(:;(:PPT(S$##"(BL(=:;78=(;78(P:<(>O(O=88F>JI(;78(9>=J:;BS8(:LM8H;(>O(;78(<BPPI(<7BH7(:L(:(9>=J(BL(98B;78=(O=88(>=(G9O=88TX_

+;(BL(;78(S$##;X0I(;789I(;7:;(J:V8L(F8HBLB>9L(=8N:=FB9N(<7BH7(J>;BS:;B>9L(;>(M=B>=B;Be8(

<789(O>=JGP:;B9N(:(J:WBJT(68(9><(H:9(L88(;7:;(<789(<8(L:K(;7:;(:(M8=L>9(H7>>L8L(:(

6"1$''-'%I(<7:;(<8(:=8(=8O8==B9N(;>(BL(:(H7>BH8(J:F8(RK(:(M8=L>92L(S$##;X0(;>(R8(

J>;BS:;8F(8B;78=(RK(B9HPB9:;B>9L(>=(;78(J>=:P(P:<(B9(:PP(B;L(H7>BH8LI(8S89(H7>BH8L(>O(P><8=(

J:WBJLT(1:9;(<=B;8L(;7:;(>982L(H7>BH8(>O(6"1$''-'%(Y:MMPB8L(;>(;78(89;B=8(GL8(>O(O=88F>J(

G9BS8=L:PPKT`XD(S$##;X02L(H7>BH8(>O(J>;BS:;B>9(B9(;78(6"1$''-'%I(;789I(<BPP(:PL>(R8(B;L(

H7>BH8(>O(J>;BS:;B>9(B9(:PP(M:=;BHGP:=(H:L8LT(%7BL(=GP8L(>G;(;78(M>LLBRBPB;K(>O(H7>>LB9N(:(

H8=;:B9(OG9F:J89;:P(J:WBJ(RG;(9>;(:P<:KL(H7>>LB9N(P><8=(J:WBJL(;7:;(:HH>=F(<B;7(B;T(

%78(S8=K(L:J8(OG9H;B>9(>O(;78(<BPPI(S$##;X0:(R>;7(H7>>L8L(>982L(J>L;(OG9F:J89;:P(J:WBJI(

>=(6"1$''-'%I(:9F(;78(J:WBJL(>O(M:=;BHGP:=(:H;B>9L(:L(<8PPTEc

1:9;(BL(HP8:=(;7:;(;7BL(6"1$''-'%I(:9F(P><8=(J:WBJL(:L(<8PPI(H:9(>9PK(8B;78=(R8(

N>>F(>=(8SBPT()982L(6"1$''-'%(H:9(98S8=(R8(J>=:PPK(98G;=:P(>=(R>;7(N>>F(:9F(8SBPT("8(

X_ 3BPR8=I(Y%78(&;7BH:P(3BN9BOBH:9H8(>O(1:9;2L(!"#$%$&'I`(HBST

XD 1:9;I(!"#$%$&':(\QU[T(?YN87;(:PPN8J8B9(:GO(F89(N:9e89(^8R=:GH7(F8=(.=8B78B;`@

Ec 388(3BPR8=I(Y%78(&;7BH:P(3BN9BOBH:9H8(>O(1:9;2L(!"#$%$&':`(HWSB(O>=(:(OGPP8=(8WMP:9:;B>9(>O(;78(S$##;X02L(=>P8(B9(;7BL(6"1$''-'%(H7>BH8T

Page 28: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

Uc=8O8=L(;>(;7BL(HP:BJ(B9(;78(!"#$%$&'(:L(:=BLB9N(O=>J(:(LH7>>P(>O(;7>GN7;(H:PP8F(Y=BN>=BLJ`(

?!$%&0$1E-1@T*.>PP><8=L(>O(;7BL(LH7>>P(R8PB8S8(;7:;(98B;78=(:H;B>9L(9>=(7GJ:9(H7:=:H;8=L(

H:9(R8(YJ>=:PPK(B9;8=J8FB:;8T`EA("8(H>9;=:L;L(;7BL(<B;7(;78(LH7>>P(>O(;7>GN7;(V9><9(:L(

YP:;B;GFB9:=B:9BLJI`(<7BH7(7>PFL(;7:;(:H;B>9L(:9F(H7:=:H;8=(H:9(R8(R>;7(J>=:PPK(N>>F(:9F(

J>=:PPK(8SBPTEU("8(8WMP:B9L(7><(;7BL(SB8<M>B9;I(<7BH7(1:9;(;:V8L(;>(R8(:(M=:BL8<>=;7K(

>98I(89;:BPL(;7:;(:(M8=L>92L(OG9F:J89;:P(J:WBJ(JGL;(R8(8B;78=(N>>F(>=(8SBPI

*>=(H:9(:(7GJ:9(R8B9N(R8(J>=:PPK(N>>F(B9(L>J8(M:=;LI(:9F(:;(;78(L:J8(;BJ8(8SBP(B9(>;78=LT(.>=(BO(78(BL(N>>F(B9(>98(M:=;I(78(7:L(B9H>=M>=:;8F(;78(J>=:P(P:<(B9;>(7BL(J:WBJT(#9F(<8=8(78I(;78=8O>=8I(;>(R8(8SBP(B9(L>J8(>;78=(M:=;I(LB9H8(;78(J>=:P(P:<(>O(H>JMPB:9H8(<B;7(FG;K(B9(N898=:P(BL(:(LB9NP8(>98(:9F(G9BS8=L:PI(;78(J:WBJ(=8P:;B9N(;>(B;(<>GPF(R8(G9BS8=L:P(K8;(M:=;BHGP:=(:;(;78(L:J8(;BJ8Q(<7BH7(BL(H>9;=:FBH;>=KTEX

1:9;(BL(HP8:=(B9(;78(60&-'.)&0;(&2(*+"(3"*/A+B1$F1(&2(3&0/#1(;7:;(;78(J>=:P(<>=;7(>O(

:H;B>9L(BL(F8;8=JB98F(RK(;78(J:WBJ(>O(;78(:H;B>9TEE(+9(>=F8=(O>=(:9(:N89;2L(:H;B>9(;>(R8(

H>9LBF8=8F(J>=:PPK(N>>FI(;789I(;78(:N89;(JGL;(7:S8(J:F8(;78(M=B9HBMP8(>O(S>PB;B>9(B9(;7:;(

M:=;BHGP:=(H:L8(;78(J>=:P(P:<T(+9(LBJMP8=(;8=JLI(;78(:N89;(JGL;(R8(J>;BS:;8F(RK(FG;K(B9(

>=F8=(O>=(;78(:H;B>9(;>(R8(H>9LBF8=8F(J>=:PPK(N>>FT*6789(;78(<BPP(BL(9>;(F8;8=JB98F(RK(

EA 1:9;I(!"#$%$&':(\QUU(d(\QUXT

EU .>=(:(P>9N8=(FBLHGLLB>9(>O(;78(FBOO8=89H8(R8;<889(;78L8(;8=JL(:9F(1:9;2L(:=NGJ89;(O>=(<7K(<8(L7>GPF(R8(J>=:P(=BN>=BL;LI(L88(.B=8L;>98(:9F(b:H>RLI(H'(4"2"'1"(&2(>/'*M1(!"#$%$&'I(AU_(d(XUT

EX 1:9;I(!"#$%$&':(\QUE(h(\QU[T(?Y&=(V:99(:GH7(9BH7;(B9(8B9BN89(3;rHV89(LB;;PBH7(NG;I(B9(:9F8=89(eGNP8BH7(RoL8(L8B9T(,899(BL;(8=(B9(8B98J(NG;I(L>(7:;(8=(F:L(J>=:PBLH78(^8L8;e(B9(L8B98(4:WBJ8(:GON89>JJ89p(L>PP;8(8=(:PL>(B9(8B98J(:9F8=89(3;rHV8(eGNP8BH7(RoL8(L8B9I(L>(<r=F8I(<8BP(F:L(J>=:PBLH78(^8L8;e(F8=(a8O>PNG9N(F8=($OPBH7;(rR8=7:GM;(9G=(8B9(8B9eBN8L(G9F(:PPN8J8B9(BL;I(FB8(:GO(F8LL8PR8(R8e>N898(4:WBJ8(:PPN8J8B9I(eGNP8BH7(:R8=(9G=(8B98(R8L>9F8=8(4:WBJ8(L8B9p(<8PH78L(LBH7(<BF8=LM=BH7;T`@

EE 1:9;I(60&-'.)&0;:(EQXDD(d(EQEccT(Yi#j9(:H;B>9(O=>J(FG;K(7:L(B;L(J>=:P(<>=;7('&*($'(*+"(A-0A&1"(;>(R8(:;;:B98F(RK(B;(RG;(B9(;78(J:WBJ(B9(:HH>=F:9H8(<B;7(<7BH7(B;(BL(F8HBF8F(GM>9I(:9F(;78=8O>=8(F>8L(9>;(F8M89F(GM>9(;78(=8:PBe:;B>9(>O(;78(>R]8H;(>O(;78(:H;B>9(RG;(J8=8PK(GM>9(;78(A0$'F$A#"(&2(K&#$*$&'(B9(:HH>=F:9H8(<B;7(<7BH7(;78(:H;B>9(BL(F>98(<B;7>G;(=8N:=F(O>=(:9K(>R]8H;(>O(;78(O:HGP;K(>O(F8LB=8T`(?YTTT8B98(":9FPG9N(:GL($OPBH7;(7:;(B7=89(J>=:PBLH789(68=;('$F+*($'(."0(@51$F+*:(<8PH78(F:FG=H7(8==8BH7;(<8=F89(L>PPI(L>9F8=9(B9(F8=(4:WBJ8I(9:H7(F8=(LB8(R8LH7P>LL89(<B=FI(7s9N;(:PL>(9BH7;(S>9(F8=(6B=VPBH7V8B;(F8L(^8N89L;:9F8L(F8=(":9FPG9N(:RI(L>9F8=9(RP>t(S>9(F8J(C0$'7$A(."1(S&##"'1:(9:H7(<8PH78J(FB8(":9FPG9N(G9:9N8L8789(:PP8=(^8N89L;s9F8(F8L(a8N87=G9NLS8=JoN89L(N8LH78789(BL;T`@

Page 29: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

UA;78(B9H89;BS8(>O(FG;K(:9FI(;78=8O>=8I(;78(J:WBJ(>O(;7:;(M8=L>92L(:H;B>9(BL(9>;(;78(J>=:P(

P:<I(7BL(<BPP(JGL;(7:S8(R889(F8;8=JB98F(RK(:9>;78=(M=B9HBMP8I(>98(J>;BS:;8F(RK(

B9HPB9:;B>9TE[(!7>>LB9N(;>(M=B>=B;Be8(>98(>O(;78L8(B9H89;BS8L(8WHPGF8L(;78(>;78=(:L(;78(

F8;8=JB9B9N(N=>G9F(>O(;78(<BPPT(%78=8O>=8I(:9(:H;B>9(H:9(>9PK(8B;78=(R8(O=>J(FG;KI(:9F(

;7GL(7:S8(J>=:P(<>=;7I(>=(9>;(O=>J(FG;KI(R8H:GL8(:(M8=L>9(H:9(>9PK(8B;78=(M=B>=B;Be8(:(

J>=:PPK(<>=;7K(J:WBJ(?;7>L8(:H;B>9L(J>;BS:;8F(RK(;78(J>=:P(P:<@(>=(:(J>=:PPK(G9<>=;7K(

J:WBJ(?;7>L8(:H;B>9L(J>;BS:;8F(RK(B9H89;BS8L(>;78=(;7:9(;78(J>=:P(P:<@I(RG;(98S8=(R>;7(:;(

;78(L:J8(;BJ8(>=(98B;78=T(a8H:GL8(>O(;7BL(G9F8=L;:9FB9N(>O(;78(<BPPI(;78=8(H:9(R8(9>(LGH7(

;7B9N(:L(:(J>=:PPK(98G;=:P(:H;B>9T

a8H:GL8(>982L(6"1$''-'%(BL(:(J:WBJI(;7BL(H>9HPGLB>9(:PL>(:MMPB8L(;>(;78(

6"1$''-'%T(+;I(;>>I(H:99>;(R8(J>=:PPK(98G;=:P(>=(J>=:PPK(:JRBNG>GLT(1:9;(<=B;8L(:;(;78(

R8NB99B9N(>O(;78(!"#$%$&'(;7:;(Y67898S8=(<8(;78=8O>=8(L:KI(2%78(7GJ:9(R8B9N(BL(RK(

9:;G=8(N>>FI2(>=I(2"8(BL(RK(9:;G=8(8SBPI2(;7BL(>9PK(J8:9L(;7:;(78(7>PFL(<B;7B9(7BJL8PO(:(OB=L;(

N=>G9F(?;>(GL(B9LH=G;:RP8@(O>=(;78(:F>M;B>9(>O(N>>F(>=(8SBP(?G9P:<OGP@(J:WBJLT`E\(#(

M8=L>9(H:9(>9PK(R8(8B;78=(N>>F(>=(8SBPI(;789I(R8H:GL8(>982L(6"1$''-'%(H:9(>9PK(8B;78=(R8(

N>>F(>=(8SBPT(#(M8=L>92L(6"1$''-'%(BL(F8;8=JB98F(RK(;78(M=B>=B;K(L78(NBS8L(;>(8B;78=(;78(

J>=:P(P:<(>=(B9HPB9:;B>9L(:L(;78(J>;BS8(O>=(78=(:H;B>9LT(1:9;(<=B;8LI(Y"89H8(;78(

FBOO8=89H8I(<78;78=(;78(7GJ:9(R8B9N(BL(N>>F(>=(8SBPI(JGL;(9>;(PB8(B9(;78(FBOO8=89H8(

R8;<889(;78(B9H89;BS8L(;7:;(78(B9H>=M>=:;8L(B9;>(7BL(J:WBJ(?9>;(B9(;78(J:;8=B:P(>O(;78(

E[ 388(1:9;I(60&-'.)&0;:(EQEccT(Y*><I(:9(:H;B>9(O=>J(FG;K(BL(;>(MG;(:LBF8(89;B=8PK(;78(B9OPG89H8(>O(B9HPB9:;B>9(:9F(<B;7(B;(8S8=K(>R]8H;(>O(;78(<BPPT`(?Y*G9(L>PP(8B98(":9FPG9N(:GL($OPBH;(F89(&B9OPGt(F8=(*8BNG9N(G9F(JB;(B7=(]8F89(^8N89L;:9F(F8L(6BPP89L(N:9e(:RL>9F8=9TTT`@

E\ 1:9;I(!"#$%$&':(\QUAT(?Y6899(<B=(:PL>(L:N89Q(F8=(489LH7(BL;(S>9(*:;G=(NG;I(>F8=Q(8=(BL;(S>9(*:;G=(RoL8I(L>(R8F8G;8;(FB8L8L(9G9(L>SB8P(:PLQ(8=(89;7sP;(8B989(?G9L(G98=O>=LH7PBH789@(8=L;89(^=G9F(F8=(#9987JG9N(NG;8=(>F8=(F8=(#9987JG9N(RoL8=(?N8L8;e<BF=BN8=@(4:WBJ89I(G9F(e<:=(:PPN8J8B9(:PL(489LH7I(JB;7B9(L>I(F:t(8=(FG=H7(FB8L8PR8(eGNP8BH7(F89(!7:=:V;8=(L8B98=(^:;;G9N(:GLF=rHV;T`@

Page 30: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

UUJ:WBJ@(RG;(B9(;78B=(1-5&0.$'/*$&'(?B9(;78(O>=J(>O(;78(J:WBJ@Q()+$F+(&2(*+"(*)&(+"(E/;"1(

*+"(F&'.$*$&'(&2(*+"(&*+"0=[EC(%7:;(BLI(BO(:(M8=L>9(NBS8L(M=B>=B;K(;>(;78(J>=:P(P:<(=:;78=(;7:9(

B9HPB9:;B>9LI(L78(7:L(:(N>>F(6"1$''-'%T(+O(:(M8=L>9(NBS8L(M=B>=B;K(;>(B9HPB9:;B>9L(=:;78=(

;7:9(;78(J>=:P(P:<I(L78(7:L(:9(8SBP(6"1$''-'%T(%78(M8=L>9(H:9(>9PK(8B;78=(H7>>L8(;>(R8(

OG9F:J89;:PPK(H>JJB;;8F(;>(:H;B9N(O=>J(;78(J>=:P(P:<(>=(OG9F:J89;:PPK(H>JJB;;8F(;>(

:H;B9N(O=>J(J>;BS8L(>O(B9HPB9:;B>9T(+9(>=F8=(;>(R8(R>;7(N>>F(:9F(8SBPI(:(M8=L>9(<>GPF(

7:S8(;>(R8(:RP8(;>(8gG:PPK(M=B>=B;Be8(R>;7(;78(J>=:P(P:<(:9F(B9HPB9:;B>9L(:L(;78(N=>G9F(>O(

7BL(J:WBJLI(<7BH7(BL(9>;(M>LLBRP8T(+9(>=F8=(;>(R8(J>=:PPK(98G;=:PI(:(M8=L>9(<>GPF(7:S8(;>(

M=B>=B;Be8(98B;78=T(#HH>=FB9N(;>(1:9;I(;7BL(BL(:PL>(BJM>LLBRP8T(%78=8O>=8I(:(M8=L>9(JGL;(R8(

8B;78=(J>=:PPK(N>>F(>=(J>=:PPK(8SBPT(6789(1:9;(GL8L(;78(;8=J(Y=:FBH:P(8SBPI`(;789I(78(

B9;89FL(;7:;(:(M8=L>9(7:L(M=B>=B;Be8F(B9H89;BS8L(>O(B9HPB9:;B>9(:R>S8(B9H89;BS8L(>O(;78(

J>=:P(P:<(B9(7BL(OG9F:J89;:P(J:WBJTE_

':FBH:P(&SBP(:L(:(.=88(!7>BH8

%78(L8H>9F(H>JM>989;(>O(1:9;2L(HP:BJ(=8N:=FB9N(;78(G9BS8=L:PB;K(>O(=:FBH:P(8SBP(BL(

;7:;I(B9(>=F8=(O>=(:(M8=L>9(;>(R8(=:FBH:PPK(8SBPI(78(JGL;(7:S8(:;;:B98F(:9(8SBP(6"1$''-'%(

;7=>GN7(7BL(><9(O=88(H7>BH8T(1:9;(<=B;8LI(Y%78(7GJ:9(R8B9N(JGL;(J:V8(>=(7:S8(J:F8(

+$E1"#2(B9;>(<7:;8S8=(78(BL(>=(L7>GPF(R8H>J8(B9(:(J>=:P(L89L8I(N>>F(>=(8SBPT(%78L8(;<>(

iH7:=:H;8=Lj(JGL;(R8(:9(8OO8H;(>O(7BL(O=88(M><8=(>O(H7>BH8(iS$##;X0jI(O>=(>;78=<BL8(;78K(

H>GPF(9>;(R8(BJMG;8F(;>(7BJ(:9FI(H>9L8gG89;PKI(78(H>GPF(R8(98B;78=(E&0/##B(N>>F(9>=(

EC 1:9;I(!"#$%$&'I(\QX\T(?Y#PL>(JGt(F8=(-9;8=LH7B8FI(>R(F8=(489LH7(NG;(>F8=(RoL8(L8BI(9BH7;(B9(F8J(-9;8=LH7B8F8(F8=(%=B8RO8F8=9I(FB8(8=(B9(L8B98(4:WBJ8(:GO9BJJ;(?9BH7;(B9(FB8L8=(B7=8=(4:;8=B8@I(L>9F8=9(B9(F8=(-9;8=>=F9G9N(?F8=(.>=J(F8=L8PR89@(PB8N89Q(<8PH78(S>9(R8BF89(8=(eG=(a8FB9NG9N(F8=(:9F8=89J:H7;T`@

E_ 388(1:9;:(!"#$%$&':(\QXCT

Page 31: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

UX8SBPT`ED(#HH>=FB9N(;>(1:9;I(>9PK(O=88(:H;B>9L(H:9(7:S8(J>=:P(<>=;7T*!:JBP8(#;VB9L>9(

8WMP:B9LI

&SBP(H:99>;(R8(:;;=BRG;8F(;>(9:;G=:P(B9HPB9:;B>9LI(O>=(;7:;(<>GPF(J8:9(>G=(L89LG>GL(9:;G=8u>S8=(<7BH7(<8(7:S8(9>(H>9;=>PuBL(;78(F8;8=JB9B9N(N=>G9F(>O(;78(<BPP(:9F(<8(<>GPF(R8(9>(FBOO8=89;(;7:9(:9BJ:PLT(#L(=:;B>9:P(R8B9NLI(O=88F>J(BL(:9(BF8:(<7BH7(BJM>L8L(B;L8PO(GM>9(GL(:L(:(98H8LL:=K(H>9FB;B>9(O>=(J>=:P(:H;B>9(:9F(=8LM>9LBRBPB;KT[c(

#L(9>;8F(:R>S8I(;>(L:K(;7:;(:(M8=L>9(BL(=:FBH:PPK(8SBP(BL(;>(L:K(;7:;(L78(7:L(:9(8SBP(

6"1$''-'%T(#L(J:WBJLI(6"1$''-'%"'(H:9(>9PK(R8(F8;8=JB98F(<789(:(M8=L>9(<BPPL(;>(

7:S8(:(H8=;:B9(J>;BS:;B>9T(%78=8(:=8(>9PK(;<>(>M;B>9L(O>=(J>;BS:;B>9Q(;>(R8(F8;8=JB98F(

:G;>9>J>GLPKI(>=(O=88PKI(>=(78;8=>9>J>GLPKI(>=(RK(B9HPB9:;B>9LT(#L(#;VB9L>9(M>B9;L(>G;I(

1:9;(H:99>;(J:V8(;78(HP:BJ(;7:;(7GJ:9L(:=8(=:FBH:PPK(8SBP(:9F(;7:;(;7BL(L;:;8(BL(FG8(;>(>G=(

B9HPB9:;B>9LI(>S8=(<7BH7(<8(7:S8(9>(H>9;=>PT(+O(;7BL(<8=8(;78(H:L8I(;7BL(<>GPF(9>;(R8(:(

J>=:P(HP:BJ(:;(:PPI(B9L>O:=(:L(J>=:P(N>>F98LL(:9F(8SBP(M=8LGMM>L8(O=88F>J(:9F(;7GL(

BJMG;:RBPB;KT(68(JGL;I(;789I(R8(BJMG;:RP8(O>=(>G=(J>=:P(8SBPI(:9F(>G=(8SBP(6"1$''-'%(

JGL;(R8(H7>L89(:G;>9>J>GLPKT

':FBH:P(&SBP(:L(+99:;8(:9F(-9BS8=L:P

!G=B>GLPKI(;78(;7B=F(:LM8H;(>O(1:9;2L(HP:BJ(=8N:=FB9N(;78(G9BS8=L:PB;K(>O(=:FBH:P(

8SBP(BL(;7:;(=:FBH:P(8SBP(BL*G9BS8=L:P(B9(7GJ:9L(:9F(B99:;8(;>(7GJ:9(9:;G=8T*%7BL(BL(M8=7:ML(

;78(J>L;(H>9;=>S8=LB:P(M:=;(>O(1:9;2L(HP:BJI(M:=;BHGP:=PK(R8H:GL8(>O(7BL(M=8SB>GL(HP:BJI(

;7:;(=:FBH:P(8SBP(JGL;(R8(R=>GN7;(:R>G;(RK(O=88(H7>BH8(:9F(;7GL(BL(BJMG;:RP8(;>(;7>L8(<7>(

:=8(=:FBH:PPK(8SBPT[A("8(<:9;L(;>(HP:BJ(9>;(;7:;(L>J8(M8>MP8(:=8(=:FBH:PPK(8SBPI(<7BH7(

ED 1:9;I(!"#$%$&':(\QEET(?Y6:L(F8=(489LH7(BJ(J>=:PBLH789(3B998(BL;(>F8=(<8=F89(L>PPI(NG;(>F8=(RoL8I(F:eG(JGt(8=(LBH7(L8PRL;(J:H789(>F8=(N8J:H7;(7:R89T`@

[c !:JBPP8(#;VB9L>9I(Y1:9;(>9("GJ:9(*:;G=8(:9F(':FBH:P(&SBPI`(C+$#&1&A+B(/'.(D+"&#&%B(ADT(AhUT(?UccC@Q(UA\T

[A ^>=F>9(&T(4BH7:PL>9I(Y%78(+9LH=G;:RBPB;K(>O(4>=:P(&SBP(B9(1:9;I`(D+"(D+&E$1*([AT(UT(?AD_C@Q(U\\T(

Page 32: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

UEO>PP><L(O=>J(7BL(F8OB9B;B>9(>O(=:FBH:P(8SBPI(RG;(;7:;(:PP(M8>MP8(:=8(=:FBH:PPK(8SBP(RK(9:;G=8T(

1:9;(<=B;8LI

Y"8(BL(8SBP(5B('/*-0"`(LBJMPK(J8:9L(;7:;(R8B9N(8SBP(:MMPB8L(;>(7BJ(H>9LBF8=8F(B9(7BL(LM8HB8Lp(9>;(;7:;(;7BL(gG:PB;K(J:K(R8(B9O8==8F(O=>J(;78(H>9H8M;(>O(7BL(LM8HB8L(?iBT8Tj(O=>J(;78(H>9H8M;(>O(:(7GJ:9(R8B9N(B9(N898=:PI(O>=(;789(;78(gG:PB;K(<>GPF(R8(98H8LL:=K@I(RG;(=:;78=(;7:;I(:HH>=FB9N(;>(;78(H>N9B;B>9(<8(7:S8(>O(;78(7GJ:9(R8B9NI(8S89(;78(R8L;T[U

+9(>=F8=(;>(J:V8(;7BL(HP:BJ(;7:;(<8(:=8(=:FBH:PPK(8SBP(RK(9:;G=8I(1:9;(<=B;8L(;7:;(78(988FL(

;>(BF89;BOK(L>J8;7B9N(;7:;(H:9(R8(O>G9F(G9BS8=L:PPK(B9(7GJ:9LI(Y:9F(789H8(iR8P>9NLj(;>(

;78(H7:=:H;8=(>O(7BL(LM8HB8LT`[X();78=<BL8I(78(7:L(9>(N=>G9FL(GM>9(<7BH7(;>(H:PP(B;(B99:;8(

B9(7GJ:9LT("8(F>8L(;7BL(RK(J:VB9N(;78(:9;7=>M>P>NBH:P(HP:BJ(;7:;(8S8=K(7GJ:9(7:L(<7:;(

78(H:PPL(:(M=>M89LB;K(?U/'%@(;>(8SBPT(#(M=>M89LB;K(BL(Y:(LGR]8H;BS8(F8;8=JB9B9N(N=>G9F(>O(

;78(M><8=(>O(H7>BH8(*+/*(A0"F"."1("K"0B(."".`(?"$'"'(1-5\";*$K"'(,"1*$EE-'%1%0-'.(."0 (

S$##;X0:(."0(K&0(\"."0(D/*(K&0+"0(%"+*@[E(RG;(BL(>9PK(:(H>9;B9N89;(M:=;(>O(;78(9:;G=8(>O(

F8LH=BR8L(;78(M=>RP8J(>O(<7K(<8(<>GPF(:PP(H7>>L8(8SBP(6"11$'-'%"'(:L(YG;;8=PK(G9:HH>G9;:RP8(>9(1:9;2L(;8=JLT`

[U 1:9;I(!"#$%$&'I(\QXUT(?Y&=(BL;(S>9(*:;G=(RoL8I(78Bt;(L>SB8P(:PLQ(FB8L8L(NB;P(S>9(B7J(B9(L8B98=(^:;;G9N(R;=:H7;8;p(9BH7;(:PL(>R(L>PH78(kG:PB;s;(:GL(L8B98J(^:;;G9NLR8N=BOO8(?F8J(8B98L(489LH789(rR8=7:GM;@(Vo998(N8O>PN8=;(<8=F89(?F899(:PLF:99(<s=8(LB8(9>;<89FBN@I(L>9F8=9(8=(V:99(9:H7(F8JI(<B8(J:9(B79(FG=H7(&=O:7=G9N(V899;I(9BH7;(:9F8=L(R8G=;8BP;(<8=F89I(>F8=(J:9(V:99(8L(:PL(LGR]8V;BS(9>;<89FBN(B9(]8F8JI(:GH7(F8J(R8L;89(489LH789(S>=:GLL8;e89T`@

[X 1:9;(<=B;8L(;7:;(<8(H:9(H:PP(L>J8;7B9N(?B9(;7BL(H:L8I(:(M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBP@(9:;G=:P(;>(7GJ:9(R8B9NL(BO(<8(H:9(:LLGJ8(;7:;(;7:;(O8:;G=8(YR8P>9NL(;>(;78(7GJ:9(R8B9N(G9BS8=L:PPK(?:9F(789H8(;>(;78(H7:=:H;8=(>O(7BL(LM8HB8L@`(?Y:PL(:PPN8J8B9(eGJ(489LH789(?:PL>(:PL(eGJ(!7:=:V;8=(L8B98=(^:;;G9N@`@(?!"#$%$&':(\QUD@T(

[E 1:9;I(!"#$%$&':(\QXAT*1:9;(:PL>(F8OB98L(:(M=>M89LB;K(:L(Y;78(LGR]8H;BS8(N=>G9F(>O(;78(M>LLBRBPB;K(>O(:9(B9HPB9:;B>9(?7:RB;G:P(F8LB=8I(F&'F-A$1F"'*$/@I(B9L>O:=(:L(;7BL(M>LLBRBPB;K(BL(H>9;B9N89;(O>=(7GJ:9B;K(B9(N898=:P`(?YS8=L;878(BH7(F89(LGR]8V;BS89(^=G9F(F8=(4oNPBH7V8B;(8B98=(*8BNG9N(?7:RB;G8PP89(a8NB8=F8I(F&'F-A$1F"'*$/@`@(?!"#$%$&':(\QUD@T(+(H7>>L8(;>(O>HGL(GM>9(;78(F8OB9B;B>9(;7:;(+(F8;:BP(B9(;78(R>FK(>O(;7BL(<>=VI(=:;78=(;7:9(;7BL(F8OB9B;B>9I(R8H:GL8(B;(J>=8(HP8:=PK(F8LH=BR8L(:(J>=:PI(=:;78=(;7:9(:(M7KLBH:PI(M=>M89LB;KT(1:9;(FBL;B9NGBL78L(R8;<889(;78L8(;<>(VB9FL(B9(!"#$%$&':(\QXAT(%78(M7KLBH:P(M=>M89LB;K(=8O8=L(;>(7GJ:9L(:L(9:;G=:P(R8B9NLI(:9F(;7GL(<>GPF(B9S>PS8(;7B9NL(PBV8(B9HPB9:;B>9L(:9F(7:RB;G:P(F8LB=8LI(<78=8:L(;78(J>=:P(M=>M89LB;K(=8O8=L(;>(7GJ:9L(:L(J>=:P(R8B9NLI(:9F(;7GL(F8:PL(<B;7(>G=(GL8(>O(O=88F>JT(.>=(:9(8WMP:9:;B>9(>O(;7BL(FBL;B9H;B>9I(L88($:GP(.>=J>L:I(Y1:9;(>9(;78(':FBH:P(&SBP(>O("GJ:9(*:;G=8I`(D+"(C+$#&1&A+$F/#(P&0-E(X_T(XT(?UccC@T

Page 33: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

U[7GJ:9LT[[

+;(BL(8:LB8L;(;>(G9F8=L;:9F(;78(H>9H8M;(>O(:(M=>M89LB;K(BO(<8(H>9;=:L;(B;(<B;7(<7:;(

1:9;(B9;=>FGH8L(B9(;78(!"#$%$&'(:L(:9>;78=(B99:;8(O8:;G=8(>O(7GJ:9(9:;G=8I(:(

M=8FBLM>LB;B>9(?@'#/%"@=(#(M=8FBLM>LB;B>9I(:HH>=FB9N(;>(1:9;I(BL(L>J8;7B9N(;7:;(B99:;8PK(

R8P>9NL(;>(;78(H>9H8M;(>O(:(7GJ:9(R8B9NT(%7:;(BLI(B;(BL(8LL89;B:P(;>(;78(H>9H8M;(>O(:(7GJ:9(

R8B9NT(+O(:(R8B9N(<8=8(9>;(;>(7:S8(LGH7(:(H7:=:H;8=BL;BHI(B;(H>GPF(9>;(R8(H>9LBF8=8F(:(

7GJ:9(R8B9NT(/BV8<BL8I(7GJ:9(R8B9NL(H:99>;(P>L8(:(M=8FBLM>LB;B>9I(P8L;(;78K(L;>M(R8B9N(

7GJ:9T[\(

1:9;(F8OB98L(M=8FBLM>LB;B>9L(:L(Y;78(H>9L;B;G89;(M:=;L(=8gGB=8F(O>=(B;(:L(<8PP(:L(;78(

O>=JL(>O(;78B=(H>JRB9:;B>9(;7:;(J:V8(O>=(LGH7(:(R8B9NT`[C(a8H:GL8(;78L8(M:=;L(:=8(=8gGB=8F(

O>=(;78(R8B9N(;>(R8(;78(VB9F(>O(R8B9N(;7:;(B;(BLI(;78L8(M:=;L(JGL;(R8(OBW8F(B9(B;L(9:;G=8I(M=B>=(

;>(>G=(8W8=HBL8(>O(O=88F>JT[_(%78K(H:99>;(R8(=8J>S8FT(#L(^>=F>9(&T(4BH7:PL>9(<=B;8LI(

Y%78(9>;B>9(>O(:(2M=8FBLM>LB;B>92(BL(1:9;2L(<:K(>O(;:PVB9N(:R>G;(R:LBH(7GJ:9(9:;G=8(:L(B;(BL(

M=B>=(;>(:9K(:H;G:P(8W8=HBL8(>O(O=88F>JT(68(:=8(9>;(2=8:PPK2(<7:;(<8(8LL89;B:PPK(:=8(G9;BP(

<8(8W8=HBL8(>G=(O=88F>Jp(RG;(<8(:=8(1&E"*+$'%(M=B>=(;>(;7:;(M>B9;I(:9F(;78(BF8:(>O(:9(

>=BNB9:P(M=8FBLM>LB;B>9(89:RP8L(1:9;(;>(J:M(>G;(<7:;(;7:;(BLT`[D!4>=8(LM8HBOBH:PPKI(1:9;(

HP:BJL(;7:;(<8(7:S8(:(M=8FBLM>LB;B>9(;>(N>>F(B9(>G=(9:;G=8I(<7BH7(78(FBSBF8L(B9;>(;7=88(

VB9FLT((&:H7(=8P:;8L(;>(:(FBOO8=89;(:LM8H;(>O(7GJ:9B;KT(%78L8(:=8(;78(M=8FBLM>LB;B>9(;>(

:9BJ:PB;KI(;78(M=8FBLM>LB;B>9(;>(7GJ:9B;K(?:L(:(PBSB9N(:9F(=:;B>9:P(R8B9N@I(:9F(;78(

[[ 1:9;I(!"#$%$&':(\QUDT

[\ +RBF:(\QU_T

[C +RBF:(\QU_T

[_ 4BH7:PL>9I(Y%78(+9LH=G;:RBPB;K(>O(4>=:P(&SBP(B9(1:9;I`(U[[T

[D 4BH7:PL>9I(Y%78(+9LH=G;:RBPB;K(>O(4>=:P(&SBP(B9(1:9;I`(U[XT

Page 34: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

U\M=8FBLM>LB;B>9(;>(M8=L>9:PB;K(?:L(:(=:;B>9:P(:9F(=8LM>9LBRP8(R8B9N@T\c(%78L8(M=8FBLM>LB;B>9L(

:=8(:PP(R>;7(98N:;BS8PK(N>>FI(B9(;78(L89L8(;7:;(;78K(YF>(9>;(=8LBL;(;78(J>=:P(P:<I`(:9F(

M>LB;BS8PK(N>>FI(B9(;7:;(;78K(YF8J:9F(H>JMPB:9H8(<B;7(B;T`\A(

"><8S8=I(;78(J8=8(M=8L89H8(>O(;7BL(M=8FBLM>LB;B>9(;>(N>>F(F>8L(9>;(J8:9(;7:;(<8(

:H;G:PPK(:=8(J>=:PPK(N>>FT\U(68(H:9(H7>>L8(<78;78=(;>(F>(N>>F(;7B9NL(>=(8SBP(;7B9NL(<B;7(

;78JT\X(.>=(8W:JMP8I(>G=(M=8FBLM>LB;B>9(;>(7GJ:9B;K(89;:BPL(:(9:;G=:P(L8POhP>S8(B9(<7BH7(

<8(H>JM:=8(>G=L8PS8L(;>(>;78=L(B9(>=F8=(;>(F8;8=JB98(>G=(<>=;7T(67BP8(<8(H>GPF(GL8(;7BL(

B9HPB9:;B>9(;>(R8H>J8(:L(N>>F(>=(R8;;8=(;7:9(>;78=(M8>MP8(B9(:(<:K(;7:;(H>JMPB8L(<B;7(;78(

J>=:P(P:<I(1:9;(:PL>(;7B9VL(;7:;(B;(H:9(P8:F(;>(]8:P>GLK(:9F(=BS:P=K(<B;7(>;78=LT\E(+;(BL(:(

=8LGP;(>O(>G=(O=88(H7>BH8(<78;78=(<8(J:V8(;78L8(OBW8F(B9HPB9:;B>9L(B9(>G=(9:;G=8(B9;>(N>>F(

>=(8SBP(:H;B>9LT

H''/*"'"11($'(U-E/'(]/*-0"

%78(J:]>=(FBOO8=89H8(R8;<889(M=8FBLM>LB;B>9L(:9F(M=>M89LB;B8L(BL(;78(<:K(B9(

<7BH7(1:9;(H>9LBF8=L(8:H7(;>(R8(B99:;8(;>(7GJ:9(9:;G=8T(67BP8(1:9;(HP:BJL(;7:;(R>;7(:=8(

B99:;8(;>(7GJ:9L(:9F(M:=;(>O(7GJ:9(9:;G=8I(78(BL(HP8:=(;7:;(;78(=8:L>9L(<7K(78(H>9LBF8=L(

8:H7(:(M:=;(>O(7GJ:9(9:;G=8(FBOO8=T(4>=8(LM8HBOBH:PPKI(:(M=8FBLM>LB;B>9(BL(:9(B9HPB9:;B>9(

\c 1:9;I(!"#$%$&':(\QU\T

\A +RBF:(\QU_T

\U .B=8L;>98(:9F(b:H>RLI(H'(4"2"'1"(&2(>/'*M1(!"#$%$&':(=8O8=(;>(M=8FBLM>LB;B>9L(:L(Y9:;G=:P(B9HPB9:;B>9LI(<7BH7(J:V8(GL(LGLH8M;BRP8(;>(;78(F=:<(>O(H8=;:B9(B9H89;BS8L`(?AXE@T(%78K(HP:=BOK(;7:;(J8=8PK(7:SB9N(;78L8(B9HPB9:;B>9L(F>8L(9>;(F8;8=JB98(>G=(M><8=(>O(H7>BH8T(#FFB;B>9:PPKI(4BH7:PL>9I(Y%78(+9LH=G;:RBPB;K(>O(4>=:P(&SBP(B9(1:9;I`(M>B9;L(>G;(;7:;(;7BL(B9;=>FGH;B>9(:PP><L(1:9;(;>(J:V8(;78(FBL;B9H;B>9(R8;<889(7GJ:9L(R8B9N(YH=8:;8F(O>=(N>>F`(:9F(R8B9N(Y:P=8:FK(:H;G:PPK(N>>F`(?U[[@T(a8H:GL8(M=8FBLM>LB;B>9L(:=8(M=8L89;(R8O>=8(>G=(OB=L;(GL8(>O(O=88F>JI(<8(H:99>;(R8(=8LM>9LBRP8(O>=(;78L8(M=8FBLM>LB;B>9L(:9F(;7GL(<8(H:99>;(R8I(RK(9:;G=8I(J>=:PPK(N>>FT("><8S8=I(;78(M=8L89H8(>O(;78L8(M=8FBLM>LB;B>9L(B9(>G=(9:;G=8(F>8L(M=>SBF8(GL(;78(M>LLBRBPB;K(>O(R8B9N(N>>FT

\X 1:9;I(!"#$%$&':(\QU_T

\E +RBF:(\QUCT

Page 35: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

UC;7:;(BL(OBW8F(B9(>G=(9:;G=8(O=>J(RB=;7(M=B>=(;>(>G=(OB=L;(GL8(>O(O=88F>JI(RG;(<8(H:9(O=88PK(

H7>>L8(7><(;>(GL8(;7:;(B9HPB9:;B>9(;7:;(BL(M=8L89;(B9(>G=(9:;G=8T(#P;8=9:;BS8PKI(:(M=>M89LB;K(

BL(>9PK(M=8L89;(B9(>G=(9:;G=8(;7=>GN7(:9(8W8=HBL8(>O(O=88F>J(:9F(;78=8O>=8(H>GPF(9>;(R8(

M=8L89;(B9(>G=(9:;G=8(O=>J(RB=;7T

67BP8(M=8FBLM>LB;B>9L(:=8(OBW8F(M:=;L(>O(>G=(9:;G=8(;7:;(<8(O=88PK(H7>>L8(7><(;>(

G;BPBe8I(M=>M89LB;B8L(>9PK(8WBL;(B9(>G=(9:;G=8(R8H:GL8(<8(O=88PK(H7>L8(;78J(;>(R8(M:=;(>O(

>G=(9:;G=8T(1:9;(;7B9VL(;7:;(<8(7:S8(B9(>G=(9:;G=8(:(M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBPI(>=(Y;78(LGR]8H;BS8(

N=>G9F(>O(;78(M>LLBRBPB;K(>O(:9(B9HPB9:;B>9I`(B9(;7BL(H:L8I(>O(;78(M>LLBRBPB;K(>O(H7>>LB9N(

8SBPT\[(1:9;(;7B9VL(;7:;(<8(7:S8(;7=88(VB9FL(>O(M=>M89LB;B8L(;>(8SBPQ\\(O=:BP;KI(>=(;78(YN898=:P(

<8:V98LL(>O(;78(7GJ:9(78:=;(B9(H>JMPKB9N(<B;7(;78(:F>M;8F(J:WBJLI`\C(BJMG=B;KI(>=(Y;78(

M=>M89LB;K(;>(:FGP;8=:;8(J>=:P(B9H89;BS8L(<B;7(BJJ>=:P(>98LI`\_(:9F(M8=S8=LB;KT(+;(BL(;7BL(

;7B=F(VB9FI(M8=S8=LB;K(>O(;78(78:=;I(;7:;(1:9;(BL(H>9H8=98F(<B;7(B9(;78(H:L8(>O(=:FBH:P(8SBPT(

6789(:(M8=L>9(7:L(:(M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBP(B9(;7BL(L89L8I(L78(7:L(Y;78(M=>M89LB;K(>O(;78(M><8=(

>O(H7>BH8(;>(J:WBJL(;7:;(LGR>=FB9:;8(;78(B9H89;BS8L(>O(;78(J>=:P(P:<(;>(>;78=L(?9>;(J>=:P(

>98L@T`\D(+9(L7>=;I(;7BL(J8:9L(;7:;(7GJ:9L(7:S8(:(YH>9;B9N89;`Cc(;89F89HK(;>(=8S8=L8(;78(

M=>M8=(>=F8=(>O(J:WBJL(RK(M=B>=B;BeB9N(J:WBJL(>O(L8POhP>S8(:R>S8(J:WBJL(>O(FG;KT

\[ +RBF:(\QUDT

\\ +;(BL(BJM>=;:9;(;>(9>;8(;7:;(1:9;(FBL;B9NGBL78L(R8;<889(;<>(VB9FL(>O(M=>M89LB;B8LQ(M7KLBH:P(:9F(J>=:P(?!"#$%$&':(\QXA@T(68(H:99>;(R8(78PF(=8LM>9LBRP8(O>=(M7KLBH:P(M=>M89LB;B8LI(<7BH7(:=8(M=>M89LB;B8L(YR:L8F(>9(L89>=K(B9FGH8J89;`(?!"#$%$&':(\QXA@I(R8H:GL8(;78K(>9PK(M8=;:B9(;>(GL(:L(9:;G=:PI(=:;78=(;7:9(J>=:P(R8B9NLT(%7:;(BLI(<8(H:99>;(O=88PK(H7>>L8(<78;78=(;>(7:S8(;78L8(M=>M89LB;B8LT(%78(M=>M89LB;B8L(;7:;(+(:J(LM8:VB9N(>O(B9(;7BL(H7:M;8=(:=8I(;78=8O>=8I(J>=:P(M=>M89LB;B8LI(O>=(<7BH7(<8(:=8(78PF(=8LM>9LBRP8T

\C 1:9;I(!"#$%$&':(\QUDT

\_ +RBFT

\D +RBFI(\QXcT

Cc +RBFI(\QUDT

Page 36: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

U_+9(>=F8=(;>(J:V8(;7BL(H>9;B9N89;(;89F89HK(M:=;(>O(>G=(9:;G=8(:L(7GJ:9LI(7GJ:9L(

JGL;(O=88PK(H7>>L8(;>(F>(L>T(1:9;(<=B;8L(;7:;(<8(H7>>L8I(RK(J8:9L(>O(>G=(S$##;X0:(

<78;78=(;>(J:V8(;7BL(;89F89HK(>G=(J>L;(OG9F:J89;:P(J:WBJI(>=(6"1$''-'%:(>=(9>;TCA(%7:;(

BLI(<8(F8HBF8(<78;78=(;>(J:V8(:(J8=8(;89F89HK(;>(=8S8=L8(;78(M=>M8=(>=F8=(>O(B9H89;BS8L(

B9(>G=(J:WBJhJ:VB9N(B9;>(:(OG9F:J89;:P(M=B9HBMP8(;7:;(L7:M8L(>G=(H7>BH8(>O(:PP(P><8=(

J:WBJLI(>=I(B9(>;78=(<>=FLI(B9;>(>G=(6"1$''-'%T(%7BL(H7>BH8(7:L(H>9L8gG89H8L(O>=(>G=(

S$##;X0=(+O(<8(H7>>L8(;>(J:V8(;78(M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBP(>G=(6"1$''-'%:(>G=(S$##;X0(R8H>J8L(

B9H:M:RP8(>O(:F>M;B9N(;78(J>=:P(P:<(:L(;78(B9H89;BS8(O>=(H7>BH8L(B9(M:=;BHGP:=(H:L8LI(:(

L;:;8(<7BH7(1:9;(H:PPL(7:SB9N(:9(Y8SBP(78:=;T`(+O(<8(F>(9>;(H7>>L8(;>(F>(L>I(1:9;(L:KL(;7:;(

<8(:=8(L;BPP(H:M:RP8(>O(H7>>LB9N(J>=:PPK(<>=;7K(J:WBJL(B9(H:L8L(:9F(;7GL(7:S8(:(YN>>F(

78:=;T`CU(

%78(:R>S8(FBLHGLLB>9(H:9(P8:F(;>(L>J8(H>9OGLB>9(=8N:=FB9N(;78(FBOO8=89H8(

R8;<889(;78(M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBP(:9F(;78(6"1$''-'%(R8H:GL8(;78K(:MM8:=(;>(R8(F8OB98F(B9(

8W;=8J8PK(LBJBP:=(<:KL=(+9(O:H;I(;78=8(:=8(89>GN7(LBJBP:=B;B8L(R8;<889(;78L8(;<>(H>9H8M;L(

O>=(J:9K(;7B9V8=L(;>(:=NG8(;7:;(1:9;(GL8L(;78(;8=JL(YM=>M89LB;K`(:9F(^6"1$''-'%[(

B9;8=H7:9N8:RPKTCX(#L(<82S8(L889(B9(;78(:R>S8(FBLHGLLB>9(>O(;78(6"1$''-'%I(;78(M:=;(>O(

7GJ:9L(;7:;(L8=S8L(:L(;78(N=>G9F(>O(;78(M>LLBRBPB;K(>O(8B;78=(F8SB:;B9N(O=>J(>=(:F78=B9N(;>(

;78(J>=:P(P:<(BL(>982L(J>L;(OG9F:J89;:P(J:WBJI(>=(6"1$''-'%T(+9F88FI(<789(F8LH=BRB9N(

;78(M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBPI(1:9;(GL8L(P:9NG:N8(;7:;(L>G9FL(S8=K(LBJBP:=(;>(;78(<:K(78(

CA 388($:PJgGBL;I(B9;=>FGH;B>9I(WWST

CU 1:9;I(!"#$%$&':(\QUDT

CX 388($:GP(.>=J>L:I(Y1:9;(>9(;78(':FBH:P(&SBP(>O("GJ:9(*:;G=8I`(UUEp("89=K(#PPBL>9I(>/'*M1(D+"&0B(&2(P0"".&EI(A[Xp(:9F(4:;;78<(!:L<8PPI(Y1:9;2L(!>9H8M;B>9(>O(;78("BN78L;(^>>FI(;78(6"1$''-'%:(:9F(;78(%78>=K(>O(':FBH:P(&SBPI`(>/'*_O*-.$"'(DCT(UT(?Ucc\@Q(ADDT

Page 37: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

UDF8LH=BR8F(;78(6"1$''-'%=("8(<=B;8L(;7:;(;78(M=>M89LB;K(BL(:(F88F(B9(;78(L89L8(;7:;(B;(BL(

Y;78(GL8(>O(O=88F>J(;7=>GN7(<7BH7(;78(LGM=8J8(J:WBJ(?8B;78=(B9(O:S>=(>OI(>=(:N:B9L;I(;78(

P:<@(BL(:F>M;8F(B9(;78(M><8=(>O(H7>BH8I(:L(;>(;78(GL8(RK(<7BH7(;78(:H;B>9L(;78JL8PS8L(

?J:;8=B:PPK(H>9LBF8=8FI(BT8T(:L(=8N:=FL(;78(>R]8H;L(>O(;78(M><8=(>O(H7>BH8@(:=8(M8=O>=J8F(

B9(:HH>=F:9H8(<B;7(;7:;(J:WBJT`CE

"><8S8=I(:P;7>GN7(>982L(M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBP(:9F(>982L(6"1$''-'%(J:K(R8(BF89;BH:PI(

;78K(F>(9>;(98H8LL:=BPK(988F(;>(R8T(":SB9N(:(M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBP(<>GPF(>9PK(R8(;78(L:J8(:L(

7:SB9N(:9(8SBP(6"1$''-'%(BO(<8(H7>L8(;>(J:V8(;78(M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBP(>G=(6"1$''-'%T(%7:;(

BLI(;78L8(;<>(H>9H8M;L(>9PK(>S8=P:M(R8H:GL8I(:L(<8(<BPP(L88(R8P><I(1:9;(R8PB8S8L(;7:;(<8(

F>I(B9(O:H;I(G9BS8=L:PPK(H7>>L8(;>(J:V8(>G=(M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBP(M:=;(>O(>G=(9:;G=8(:L(

7GJ:9LT(%7BL(BL(<7K(1:9;(;:PVL(:R>G;(>G=(M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBP(9>;(J8=8PK(:L(:(;89F89HK(RG;(

:L(>G=(LGM=8J8(J:WBJT(+O(<8(B9L;8:F(H7>L8(;>(7:S8(:(N>>F(6"1$''-'%:(<8(H>GPF(L;BPP(

7:S8(:(M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBPT(+9(;7BL(H:L8I(>982L(M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBP(<>GPF(9>;(R8(BF89;BH:P(;>(

>982L(6"1$''-'%=(%7:;(M=>M89LB;K(<>GPF(LBJMPK(R8(:(H>9;B9N89;(;89F89HK(;>(=8S8=L8(;78(

>=F8=(>O(>982L(J:WBJL(L>(;7:;(>98(M=B>=B;Be8L(J:WBJL(>O(L8POhP>S8(:R>S8(J:WBJL(>O(FG;KI(

;7>GN7(>982L(6"1$''-'%(<>GPF(R8(:(H>JJB;J89;(;>(F>B9N(;78(>MM>LB;8T

"><8S8=I(1:9;(F>8L(;7B9V(;7:;(<8(G9BS8=L:PPK(H7>>L8(;>(J:V8(>G=(M=>M89LB;K(;>(

8SBP(>G=(6"1$''-'%=(6789(<8(H7>>L8(;>(7:S8(:9(8SBP(6"1$''-'%:(<8(H7>>L8(;>(J:V8(>G=(

M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBPI(>=(>G=(;89F89HK(;>(M=B>=B;Be8(J:WBJL(>O(L8POhP>S8(:R>S8(J:WBJL(>O(

FG;KI(>G=(J>L;(OG9F:J89;:P(J:WBJT(-9PBV8(:(M=8FBLM>LB;B>9I(;7BL(M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBP(

H:99>;(R8(OBW8F(B9(>G=(9:;G=8(M=B>=(;>(>G=(OB=L;(GL8(>O(O=88F>JT(':;78=I(B;(>9PK(8WBL;L(B9(>G=(

CE 1:9;I(!"#$%$&':(\QXAT(?YTTT^8R=:GH7(F8=(.=8B78B;(N8P;89I(<>=FG=H7(FB8(>R8=L;8(4:WBJ8(?F8J(^8L8;e8(N8Jst8(>F8=(eG<BF8=@(B9(FB8(6BPPVr=(:GON89>JJ89I(:PL(:GH7(S>9(F8J]89BN89I(F:(FB8(":9FPG9N89(L8PRL;(?B7=8=(4:;8=B8(9:H7I(FTBT(FB8()R]8V;8(F8=(6BPPVr=(R8;=8OO89F(?]898=(4:WBJ8(N8Jst8(:GLN8rR;(<8=F89T`@

Page 38: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

Xc7GJ:9(9:;G=8(BO(<8(<BPP(B;(;>(R8(L>(R8H:GL8(>G=(OG9F:J89;:P(J:WBJ(H:9(>9PK(R8(

F8;8=JB98F(<789(<8(>G=L8PS8L(F8;8=JB98(B;T(%7BL(BL(<7:;(1:9;(J8:9L(<789(78(L:KL(;7:;(:(

M=>M89LB;K(YH:9TTTR8(;7>GN7;(>OTTT?BO(8SBP@(:L(50&-%+*(RK(;78(7GJ:9(R8B9N(-A&'(7BJL8POT`C[(

#L(+(<BPP(8WMP:B9(R8P><I(>9H8(;7BL(O=88(H7>BH8(BL(J:F8I(;78(M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBP(R8H>J8LI(B9(

:(LM8HBOBH(L89L8I(OBW8F(B9(>G=(9:;G=8I(B9(;7:;(<8(H:99>;(=8J>S8(B;(RK(>G=(><9(M><8=LT(+9(

;7BL(L89L8I(B;(BL(J>=8(;7:9(:(H>9;B9N89;(;89F89HK(RG;(:9(B99:;8(M:=;(>O(>G=(9:;G=8(:L(

7GJ:9LT

#L(<8(H:9(L88(J>=8(HP8:=PK(9><I(1:9;(H:99>;(R8(GLB9N(;78(;8=J(YB99:;8`(B9(;78(

L:J8(<:K(B9(;78(H:L8(>O(M=8FBLM>LB;B>9L(:9F(M=>M89LB;B8LT(#P;7>GN7(1:9;(HP:BJL(;7:;(R>;7(

:=8(B99:;8(O8:;G=8L(>O(7GJ:9(9:;G=8I(7GJ:9L(:=8(B9(L>J8(<:K(=8LM>9LBRP8(O>=(M=>M89LB;B8L(

B9(:(<:K(;7:;(;78K(:=8(9>;(=8LM>9LBRP8(O>=(M=8FBLM>LB;B>9LT($=8FBLM>LB;B>9L(:=8(B99:;8(

B9L>O:=(:L(;78K(:=8(8LL89;B:P(;>(;78(H>9H8M;(>O(7GJ:9(R8B9NL(:9F(;78K(:=8(;7GL(O8:;G=8L(

;7:;(<8(:=8(R>=9(<B;7T($=>M89LB;B8LI(>9(;78(>;78=(7:9FI(:=8(B99:;8(RG;(YH>9;B9N89;(O>=(

7GJ:9B;K(B9(N898=:PT`C\(6B;7>G;(;78(M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBPI(:(R8B9N(H:9(L;BPP(R8(H>9LBF8=8F(:(

7GJ:9T(#L(1:9;(F8LH=BR8L(B;I(M=8FBLM>LB;B>9L(:=8(Y>=BNB9:P`(;>(7GJ:9L(B9L>O:=(:L(Y;78K(

R8P>9N(<B;7(98H8LLB;K(;>(;78(M>LLBRBPB;K(>O(;7BL(R8B9NI`(:9F(M=>M89LB;B8L(:=8(YH>9;B9N89;`(

B9L>O:=(:L(Y;78(R8B9N(B9(gG8L;B>9(BL(M>LLBRP8(B9(B;L8PO(:PL>(<B;7>G;(;78JT`CC(*>;7B9N(:R>G;(

;78(H>9H8M;(>O(:(7GJ:9(R8B9N(=8gGB=8L(:(M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBPI(;789TC_

C[ +RBFI(\QUDT

C\ +RBFI(\QUDT

CC +RBFI(\QU_T

C_ (388(!"#$%$&':(\QUDT(Y-9;8=(8B98J(":9N8(?A0&A"'1$&W(S8=L;878(BH7(F89(LGR]8V;BS89(^=G9H7(F8=(4oNPBH7V8B;(8B98=(*8BNG9N(?7:RB;G8PP89(a8NB8=F8I(F&'F-A$1F"'*$/W:(L>O8=9(LB8(Or=(FB8(489LH778B;(rR8=7:GM;(eGOsPPBN(BL;T(&=(G9;8=LH78BF8;(LBH7(F:=B9(S>9(8B98=(#9NP:N8I(F:t(8=(e<:=(:9N8R>=89(L8B9(V:99I(:R8=(F>H7(9BH7;(:PL(L>PH78=(S>=N8L;8PP;(<8=F89(F:=OI(L>9F8=9(:GH7(?<899(8=(NG;(BL;@(:PL(8=<>=R89(>F8=(?<899(8=(RoL8(BL;@(:PL(S>9(F8J(489LH789(L8PRL;(LBH7(eGN8e>N89(N8F:H7;(<8=F89(V:99T(&L(BL;(:R8=(7B8=(9G=(S>J(":9N8(eGJ(&BN89;PBH7(d(FTBT(eGJ(4>=:PBLH7haoL89I(FB8('8F8p(<8PH78LI(F:(8L(9G=(:PL(

Page 39: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

XA+O(:(M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBP(BL(9>;(8LL89;B:P(;>(;78(H>9H8M;(>O(7GJ:9B;K(:9F(BL(L>J8;7B9N(

;7:;(<8(R=B9N(:R>G;(;7=>GN7(>G=(><9(O=88(H7>BH8I(B;(BL(G9HP8:=(<7K(1:9;(HP:BJL(;7:;(B;(BL(

M:=;(>O(7GJ:9(9:;G=8T(+;(BL(H8=;:B9PK(9>;(B99:;8(;>(7GJ:9(9:;G=8(B9(;78(<:K(<8(;KMBH:PPK(

G9F8=L;:9F(;7BL(;8=JI(:L(L>J8;7B9N(M=8L89;(O=>J(RB=;7T(#(HP>L8=(:9:PKLBL(>O(;78(<:K(1:9;(

GL8L(;78(;8=J(YRK(9:;G=8I`(<789(78(;:PVL(:R>G;(;78(M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBPI(H:9(=8S8:P(<7K(;7BL(

BL(;78(H:L8T(%7=>GN7>G;(;78(L8H;B>9(B9(;78(!"#$%$&'(>9(;78(M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBPI(1:9;(

LM8HBOB8L(<7K(78(GL8L(;7BL(;8=JT(.B=L;I(1:9;(HP:=BOB8L(7BL(GL8(>O(;78(;8=J(YRK(9:;G=8`(<789(

78(<=B;8L(;7:;I(

+;(<BPP(R8(9>;8F(;7:;(;78(M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBP(BL(78=8(8L;:RPBL78F(?:L(=8N:=FL(:H;B>9L@(B9(;78(7GJ:9(R8B9NI(8S89(;78(R8L;p(:9F(L>(B;(JGL;(R8(BO(B;(BL(;>(R8(M=>S8F(;7:;(;78(M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBP(:J>9N(7GJ:9(R8B9NL(BL(G9BS8=L:PI(>=I(<7BH7(78=8(:J>G9;L(;>(;78(L:J8(;7B9NI(;7:;(B;(BL(<>S89(B9;>(7GJ:9(9:;G=8TCD

1:9;(8gG:;8L(7BL(GL8(>O(;78(;8=J(Y<>S89(B9;>(7GJ:9(9:;G=8`(<B;7(L>J8(L>=;(>O(

G9BS8=L:PB;K(B9(7GJ:9LT(%7:;(BLI(78(BL(HP:BJB9N(;7:;I(BO(8S8=K(LB9NP8(7GJ:9(R8B9N(O=88PK(

H7>>L8L(:9(8SBP(6"1$''-'%(?:(HP:BJ(<7BH7(=8gGB=8L(J>=8(B9S8L;BN:;B>9(R8P><@I(;789(<8(

H:9(L:K(;7:;(;7BL(M=>M89LB;K(BL(:(M:=;(>O(7GJ:9(9:;G=8T(a8H:GL8(1:9;(F>8L(;7B9V(;7:;(8S8=K(

7GJ:9(H7>>L8L(;7BLI(78(H>9HPGF8L(;7:;(B;(BL(M:=;(>O(7GJ:9(9:;G=8T

&S89(BO(1:9;2L(M=8JBL8I(;7:;(8S8=K(7GJ:9(H7>>L8L(:9(8SBP(6"1$''-'%I(BL(;=G8I(B;(BL(

9>;(HP8:=(<7K(1:9;(;7B9VL(;7:;(G9BS8=L:PB;K(:9F(B99:;898LL(;>(7GJ:9(9:;G=8(Y78=8(:J>G9;L(

;>(;78(L:J8(;7B9NT`(68(H:9(OB9F(L>J8(HP:=BOBH:;B>9(O>=(;7BL(BO(<8(H>9;B9G8(>9(B9(;78(

a8L;BJJG9N(F8=(O=8B89(6BPPVr=(JoNPBH7(BL;I(FB8L8(:R8=(:PL(NG;(>F8=(RoL8(9G=(FG=H7(B7=8(4:WBJ89(R8G=;8BP;(<8=F89(V:99I(B9(F8J(LGR]8V;BS89(^=G9F8(F8=(4oNPBH7V8B;(F8=(#R<8BH7G9N(F8=(4:WBJ89(S>J(J>=:PBLH789(^8L8;e8(R8L;8789(JGt(G9FI(<899(FB8L8=(L8B98=(^:;;G9N@(N87o=BN(:9N89>JJ89(<8=F89(F:=OI(8B9(9:;r=PBH78=(":9N(F8L(489LH789(eGJ(aoL89(N899:9;(<8=F89(<B=FT`

CD +RBFI(\QXcT(?Y4:9(<B=F(R8J8=V89I(F:t(F8=(":9N(eGJ(aoL89(7B8=(:J(489LH789I(:GH7(F8J(R8L;89(?F89(":9FPG9N89(9:H7@I(:GON8L;8PP;(<B=FI(<8PH78L(:GH7(N8LH78789(JGtI(<899(FB8(#PPN8J8B978B;(F8L(":9N8L(eGJ(aoL89(G9;8=(489LH789(>F8=I(<8PH78L(78B=(F:LL8PR8(R8F8G;8;I(F:t(8=(JB;(F8=(J89LH7PBH789(*:;G=(S8=<8R;(L8BI(R8<B8L89(<8=F89(L>PPT`@

Page 40: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

XUM:LL:N8I(7><8S8=T(%78=8(L88J(;>(R8(;<>(=8:L>9L(<7K(1:9;(;7B9VL(<8(H:9(8gG:;8(;78L8(

;8=JLT(.B=L;I(1:9;(L:KL(;7:;(78(=8O8=L(;>(;78(M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBP(:L(B99:;8(R8H:GL8I(>9H8(

H7>L89I(B;(H:99>;(R8(8=:FBH:;8F(O=>J(7GJ:9(9:;G=8T("8(<=B;8L(;7:;(;78(M=>M89LB;K(;>(J>=:P(

8SBP(BL(L:BF(;>(R8(B99:;8(YR8H:GL8(B;(H:99>;(R8(8=:FBH:;8F(?O>=(;78(LGM=8J8(J:WBJ(O>=(;7:;(

<>GPF(7:S8(;>(R8(;78(J:WBJ(>O(;78(N>>FI(<78=8:L(B9(;7BL(M=>M89LB;K(;78(J:WBJ(7:L(R889(

:LLGJ8F(;>(R8(8SBP@T`_c(%7:;(BLI(BO(8S8=K(7GJ:9(7:L(L8P8H;8F(:9(8SBP(6"1$''-'%(:9FI(>9H8(

H7>L89I(B;(H:99>;(R8(=8J>S8F(O=>J(:9K>98(RK(;78B=(><9(M><8=I(;789(<8(H:9(L:K(;7:;(;78(

M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBP(BL(B99:;8(;>(7GJ:9B;KI(:L(:(N=>GMT(+;(BL(:L(;7>GN7(B;(<8=8(M:=;(>O(7GJ:9(

9:;G=8T(

aG;I(1:9;(L:KLI(;7BL(BL(9>;(;78(H7B8O(=8:L>9(<7K(<8(H:PP(B;(B99:;8(B9(7GJ:9LT(%78(

J:]>=(=8:L>9(BL(;7:;(Y<8(:=8(]GL;(:L(B9H:M:RP8(>O(:LLBN9B9N(:(OG=;78=(H:GL8(O>=(<7K(8SBP(

7:L(H>==GM;8F(;78(S8=K(7BN78L;(J:WBJ(B9(GLI(;7>GN7(;7BL(BL(>G=(><9(F88FI(:L(<8(:=8(O>=(:(

OG9F:J89;:P(M=>M8=;K(;7:;(R8P>9NL(;>(>G=(9:;G=8T`_A*a8H:GL8(;78(H7>BH8(;>(J:V8(>982L(

M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBP(B9;>(>982L(6"1$''-'%(BL(:(O=88(H7>BH8I(<8(H:99>;(LM8:V(>O(B;(:L(R8B9N(

H:GL8F(RK(:9K;7B9N(8PL8T(%78=8O>=8I(1:9;(;7B9VL(;7:;(<8(H:9(PBV89(;7BL(M=>M89LB;K(;>(:(

O8:;G=8(>O(>G=(7GJ:9(9:;G=8I(<7BH7(:PL>(H:99>;(R8(:LLBN98F(:(7BN78=(H:GL8T(+;(L88JLI(

;789I(;7:;(1:9;(BL(9>;(L:KB9N(;7:;(;78(M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBP(BL(B99:;8(B9(;78(L:J8(L89L8(;7:;(;78(

M=8FBLM>LB;B>9(BLT(':;78=I(<8(H:9(;:PV(:R>G;(B;(/1($2($*()"0"(:(M:=;(>O(>G=(7GJ:9(9:;G=8(O>=(

;78(=8:L>9L(PBL;8F(:R>S8T

+9F88FI(;7BL(FBOO8=89H8(B9(;78(<:K(1:9;(;:PVL(:R>G;(;78(B99:;898LL(>O(

_c +RBFI(\QXAT(?YTTT<8BP(8=(9BH7;(:GLN8=>;;8;(<8=F89(V:99(?:PL(<>eG(FB8(>R8=L;8(4:WBJ8(FB8(F8L(^G;89(L8B9(Jrt;8I(<8PH78(:R8=(B9(]898J(":9N8(L8PRL;(:PL(RoL8(:9N89>JJ89(<B=F@pTTT`@

_A +RBFI(\QXUT(?YS>=987JPBH7(:R8=I(<8BP(<B=(F:S>9Q(<:=GJ(B9(G9L(F:L(aoL8(N8=:F8(FB8(>R8=L;8(4WBJ8(S8=F8=R;(7:R8I(>RNP8BH7(FB8:L8L(N8=:F8(G9L8=8(8BN898(%:;(BL;I(8R89L><89BN(<8B;8=(8B98(-=L:H78(:9N8R89(Vo9989(:PL(S>9(8B98=(^=G9F8BN89LH7:O;I(FB8(eG(G9L8=8=(*:;G=(N87o=;T`@

Page 41: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

XXM=8FBLM>LB;B>9L(:9F(M=>M89LB;B8L(7BN7PBN7;L(;78(HP:=BOBH:;B>9(;7:;(1:9;(J:F8(=8N:=FB9N(

J>=:P(8S:PG:;B>9L(:R>G;(7GJ:9(9:;G=8(:;(;78(L;:=;(>O(;78(!"#$%$&'(:9F(78PML(;>(8WMP:B9(

<7:;(B;(J8:9L(;>(R8(=:FBH:PPK(8SBP(RK(9:;G=8=("8(<=B;8L(;7:;I(<78;78=(>G=(9:;G=8(BL(J>=:PPK(

N>>F(>=(8SBPI(;7BL(N>>F(>=(8SBP(H:9(R8(H:PP8F(

TTTB99:;8(?:L(;78(LGR]8H;BS8(OB=L;(N=>G9F(>O(;78(:F>M;B>9(>O(;7BL(>=(;7:;(J:WBJ(<B;7(=8LM8H;(;>(;78(J>=:P(P:<@(>9PK($'(*+"(1"'1"(;7:;(B;(BL(M>LB;8F(:L(;78(N=>G9F(:9;8H8F89;(;>(8S8=K(GL8(>O(O=88F>J(NBS89(B9(8WM8=B89H8(?O=>J(;78(8:=PB8L;(K>G;7(:L(O:=(R:HV(:L(RB=;7@(:9F(BL(;7GL(=8M=8L89;8F(:L(M=8L89;(B9(;78(7GJ:9(R8B9N(:;(;78(J>J89;(>O(RB=;7(d(9>;(;7:;(RB=;7(B;L8PO(BL(;78(H:GL8T_U

67:;8S8=(;78(J>=:P(H7:=:H;8=(>O(>G=(7GJ:9(9:;G=8(BLI(<8(JGL;(7:S8(O=88PK(H7>L89(B;I(

1:9;(L:KLT(%78(J>=:P(H7:=:H;8=(>O(>G=(9:;G=8(BLI(>O(H>G=L8I(FBOO8=89;(O=>J(>G=(R:LBH(7GJ:9(

9:;G=8I(<7BH7(H:99>;(R8(N>>F(>=(8SBP(R8H:GL8(B;(8WBL;L(M=B>=(;>(>G=(OB=L;(GL8(>O(O=88F>JT(

%7BL(BL(9>;(:(LG=M=BLB9N(FBL;B9H;B>9I(NBS89(;7:;I(O>=(1:9;I(J>=:P(<>=;7(M=8LGMM>L8L(:(O=88(

H7>BH8T

+9(;7BL(J>=:P(L89L8(>O(:(7GJ:9(9:;G=8I(>G=(M=8FBLM>LB;B>9(;>(N>>F(H:99>;(J:V8(GL(

J>=:PPK(N>>F(RK(9:;G=8T(%7>L8(M=8FBLM>LB;B>9L(;>(N>>F(H:99>;(L8=S8(:L(:(LGR]8H;BS8(OB=L;(

N=>G9F(>O(;78(:F>M;B>9(>O(J:WBJL(R8H:GL8(;78K(:=8(9>;(O=88PK(H7>L89(RK(GLT(':;78=I(;78K(

8WBL;(B9(>G=(9:;G=8(M=B>=(;>(>G=(GL8(>O(O=88F>JT()9(;78(>;78=(7:9FI(R8H:GL8(<8(7:S8(

M=>M89LB;B8L(;>(8SBP(;7:;(1:9;(HP:BJL(8S8=K(7GJ:9(7:L(O=88PK(H7>L89(;>(7:S8I(;789(>G=(

7GJ:9(9:;G=8(BL(J>=:PPK(8SBPI(B9(;78(L89L8(;7:;(:9(8SBP(J:WBJ(d(>G=(8SBP(6"1$''-'%(h(

L8=S8L(:L(;78(LGR]8H;BS8(OB=L;(N=>G9F(>O(;78(:F>M;B>9(>O(J:WBJLT(1:9;(BL(H>JJB;;8F(;>(

L:KB9N(;7:;(;78(M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBP(BL(>9PK(B99:;8(;>(7GJ:9(9:;G=8(B9(;7BL(M:=;BHGP:=(J>=:P(

J8:9B9N(d(=:;78=(;7:9(B9(;78(L89L8(;7:;(B;(BL(B99:;8(O=>J(RB=;7(h(R8H:GL8(>O(;78(=>P8(>O(

_U +RBFI(\QUUT(?Y?:PL(F8=(LGR]8V;BS8(8=L;8(^=G9F(F8=(#9987JG9N(FB8L8=(>F8=(]898=(4:WBJ8(B9(#9L87G9N(F8L(J>=:PBLH789(^8L8;e8L@(RP>t(B9(F8J(3B998(:9N8R>=F89I(:PL(8L(S>=(:PP8J(B9(F8=(&=O:7=G9N(N8N8R8989(^8R=:GH78(F8=(.=8B78B;(?B9(F8=(O=r78L;89(bGN89F(RBL(eG=(^8RG=;(eG=rHV@(eGJ(^=G9F8(N8P8N;(<B=F(G9F(L>(:PL(JB;(F8=(^8RG=;(eGNP8BH7(BJ(489LH789(S>=7:9F89(S>=N8L;8PP;(<B=Fp(9BH7;I(F:t(FB8(^8RG=;(8R89(FB8(-=L:H78(F:S>9(L8BT`@

Page 42: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

XE7GJ:9(O=88F>J(B9(B;L(:HgGBLB;B>9T

C0&&2(&2(*+"(J'$K"01/#$*B(&2(!/.$F/#(RK$#

68(H:9(9><(L88(;7:;(;7BL(HP:BJI(;7:;(<8(H:9(L:K(;7:;(;78(M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBP(?:9FI(B9(

;G=9I(=:FBH:P(8SBP@(BL(B99:;8(;>(7GJ:9(9:;G=8I(7B9N8L(>9(:9>;78=(>O(1:9;2L(HP:BJLQ(;7:;(:PP(

7GJ:9LI(G9BS8=L:PPKI(H7>>L8(;>(7:S8(:9(8SBP(6"1$''-'%T(%7BL(G9BS8=L:PB;K(HP:BJ(=8J:B9L(

>98(>O(;78(J>L;(B9;89L8PK(F8R:;8F(;>MBHL(=8N:=FB9N(;78(!"#$%$&'=(+;(BL(8W;=8J8PK(

H>9;=>S8=LB:P(R8H:GL8*1:9;2L(]GL;BOBH:;B>9(>O(;78(HP:BJ(B9(;78(!"#$%$&'(BL(P8LL(;7:9(

L:;BLOKB9N(:9FI(L>J8(L:KI(9>98WBL;89;T_X*+9(;78(!"#$%$&':(78(OB=L;(HP:BJL(;7:;(:(M=>>O(BL92;(

98H8LL:=K(;>(L7><(<7K(:PP(7GJ:9L(:=8(=:FBH:PPK(8SBPT(Y68(H:9(LM:=8(>G=L8PS8L(;78(O>=J:P(

M=>>O(;7:;(;78=8(JGL;(R8(LGH7(:(H>==GM;(M=>M89LB;K(=>>;8F(B9(;78(7GJ:9(R8B9NI(B9(SB8<(>O(

;78(JGP;B;GF8(>O(<>8OGP(8W:JMP8L(;7:;(;78(8WM8=B89H8(>O(7GJ:9(."".1(M:=:F8L(R8O>=8(GLI`(

78(<=B;8L(:9F(N>8L(>9(;>(HB;8(J:9K(8W:JMP8L(>O(H=G8P;K(:9F(8SBP(7GJ:9(:H;B>9LT_E("BL(OB=L;(

:=NGJ89;(BLI(B9(L7>=;I(;7:;(<8(F>92;(988F(:(O>=J:P(M=>>O(O>=(;78(G9BS8=L:PB;K(>O(=:FBH:P(8SBP(

R8H:GL8(7GJ:9(:H;B>9L(;7=>GN7>G;(7BL;>=K(L7><(GL(;7:;(B;(JGL;(R8(;=G8T

67BP8(;7BL(8JMB=BH:P(:=NGJ89;(J:K(78PM(;>(8WMP:B9(;7:;(J:9KI(>=(8S89(J>L;I(

M8>MP8(F>(H7>>L8(:9(8SBP(6"1$''-'%I(B;(F>8L(9>;(LGOOBHB89;PK(LGMM>=;(7BL(HP:BJ(>O(

G9BS8=L:PB;KT(#L(!7=BL(/T(.B=8L;>98(:9F(*:;7:9(b:H>RL(MG;(B;Q

TTT1:9;(H:9(=8:L>9:RPK(LGNN8L;(;7:;(B;(1""E1(J>L;(H7>>L8(8SBPp(78(H:9(8S89(L:K(;7:;(;7BL(1""E1(;>(R8(;78(J>L;(H>JJ>9(7GJ:9(H7>BH8p(RG;(1:9;(H:99>;(:LL8=;(;7:;(

_X (388($:GP(.>=J>L:I(Y1:9;(>9(;78(':FBH:P(&SBP(>O("GJ:9(*:;G=8I`(<78=8(78(HP:BJL(;7:;(1:9;(7:L(9>;(NBS89(LGH7(:(M=>>O(R8H:GL8(B;(BL(BJM>LLBRP8(;>(NBS8T(#PL>(L88(38B=B>P(4>=N:9I(Y%78(4BLLB9N(.>=J:P($=>>O(>O("GJ:9B;K2L(':FBH:P(&SBP(B9(1:9;2L(2'8PBNB>9I2`(D+"(C+$#&1&A+$F/#(!"K$")(AAET(AT(?b:9TI(Ucc[@T("8=8I(4>=N:9(HP:BJL(;7:;I(:P;7>GN7(1:9;(7:L(9>;(NBS89(LGH7(:(M=>>OI(>98(H:9(=8H>9L;=GH;(>98(RK(F8PSB9N(B9;>(;78(!"#$%$&'=

_E (1:9;I(!"#$%$&':(\QXU(d(\QXXT(?Y,:t(9G9(8B9(L>PH78=(S8=F8=R;8=(":9N(BJ(489LH789(N8<G=e8P;(L8B9(JrLL8I(F:=rR8=(Vo9989(<B=(G9LI(R8B(F8=(489N8(LH7=8B89F8=(a8BLMB8P8I(<8PH78(G9L(FB8(&=O:7=G9N(:9(F89(%:;89(F8=(489LH789(S>=(#GN89(L;8PP;I(F89(Oo=JPBH789(a8<8BL(8=LM:=89T`@

Page 43: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

X[=:FBH:P(8SBP(BL(G9BS8=L:P(BO(7BL(9>;B>9(>O(;78(N=>G9FB9N(FBLM>LB;B>9(BL(LGH7(;7:;(8:H7(B9FBSBFG:P(H7>>L8L(7BL(>=(78=(><9(FBLM>LB;B>9(:9F(7BL(>=(78=(LM>9;:98>GL(8W8=HBL8(>O(O=88F>J(H>GPF(7:S8(H7>L89(;78(N>>FT(.=>J(LGH7(:(L;:9FM>B9;I(9>(HP:BJ(;>(;78(G9BS8=L:PB;K(>O(8SBP(H:9(R8(J:F8T_[

%78(=8:L>9(<7K(LGH7(8JMB=BH:P(8SBF89H8(<BPP(9>;(<>=V(:L(:(M=>>O(O>=(;7BL(HP:BJ(BL(

R8H:GL8(1:9;2L(HP:BJ(:R>G;(=:FBH:P(8SBP(BL(>98(:R>G;(:9(>R]8H;(>O(<7BH7(<8(H:9(7:S8(9>(

V9><P8FN8(;7=>GN7(8JMB=BH:P(8SBF89H8T(%7BL(BL(R8H:GL8(7GJ:9(V9><P8FN8(;:V8L(MP:H8(

<B;7B9(;78(PBJB;L(>O(LM:H8(:9F(;BJ8T()982L(H7>BH8(>O(6"1$''-'%I(<7BH7(>HHG=L(;7=>GN7(:9(

:H;(>O(O=88F>JI(BL(>G;LBF8(>O(LM:H8(:9F(;BJ8I(B9L>O:=(:L(B;(BL(G9F8;8=JB98FT(%78=8O>=8I(

J8=8PK(P>>VB9N(;>(8JMB=BH:P(8SBF89H8(H:9(NBS8(GL(L>J8(BF8:(>O(<7:;(6"1$''-'%"'(:=8(PBV8(

RG;(H:99>;(NBS8(GL(FB=8H;(V9><P8FN8(>O(;78JT(48=8PK(9>;B9N(;7:;(J>L;(7GJ:9L(L88J(;>(F>(

J:9K(8SBP(:H;L(<BPP(9>;(M=>S8(;7:;(8S8=K(7GJ:9(98H8LL:=BPK(7:L(:9(8SBP(6"1$''-'%T

1:9;(F>8L(=8;=:H;(7BL(HP:BJ(;7:;(:(O>=J:P(M=>>O(BL(9>;(988F8F(:9F(;7:;(<8(H:9(=8PK(

GM>9(8JMB=BH:P(8SBF89H8(>9PK(:(O8<(M:=:N=:M7L(P:;8=(B9(;78(!"#$%$&'=("8(<=B;8L(;7:;(;78(

VB9F(>O(8JMB=BH:P(8SBF89H8(;7:;(78(8:=PB8=(7:F(P:R8P8F(:L(LGOOBHB89;(;>(M=>S8(7BL(HP:BJ(H:9(

>9PK(8L;:RPBL7(Y;78(8WBL;89H8(>O(;7BL(M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBP(B9(7GJ:9(9:;G=8`(RG;(9>;(Y;78(=8:P(

9:;G=8(>O(;7:;(M=>M89LB;K(>=(;78(N=>G9F(>O(;7BL(=8LBL;:9H8(i;78(J>=:P(P:<jT`_\(%78(=8:L>9(

1:9;(HB;8L(O>=(<7K(8JMB=BH:P(8SBF89H8(H:99>;(NBS8(GL(;7BL(V9><P8FN8(BL(LBJBP:=(;>(

.B=8L;>98(:9F(b:H>RL2L(>R]8H;B>9(:R>S8T(%7BL(V9><P8FN8(>O(;78(9:;G=8(>O(;78(M=>M89LB;K(;>(

8SBPI(1:9;(<=B;8LI(Y7:L(;>(F>(<B;7(:(=8P:;B>9(>O(;78(O=88(M><8=(>O(H7>BH8(?;78(H>9H8M;(>O(

<7BH7(BL(9>;(8JMB=BH:P@(;>(;78(J>=:P(P:<(?>O(<7BH7(;78(H>9H8M;(BL(8gG:PPK(MG=8PK(

B9;8PP8H;G:P@`(:9F(L>(;78(V9><P8FN8(JGL;(R8(YH>N9Be8F(/(A0$&0$(O=>J(;78(H>9H8M;(>O(

_[ .B=8L;>98(:9F(b:H>RLI(Y+9(,8O89L8(>O(1:9;2L('8PBNB>9I`(AEET

_\ 1:9;I(!"#$%$&':(\QX[T

Page 44: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

X\8SBPT`_C(%789I(1:9;(L:KL(;7:;(78(<BPP(F8S8P>M(;7BL(H>9H8M;(B9(<7:;(O>PP><LT(

( +9;8=8L;B9NPKI(9>(LGH7(F8S8P>MJ89;(O>PP><LT(67BP8(1:9;(F>8L(N>(>9(;>(;:PV(:R>G;(

;78(H>9H8M;(>O(8SBPI(78(F>8L(9>;(F>(L>(B9(:(<:K(;7:;(8WMPBHB;PK(LGMM>=;L(7BL(G9BS8=L:PB;K(

HP:BJT(+9(O:H;I(B9(:(O>>;9>;8I(78(<=B;8L(;7:;(;78(M=>>O(BL(9>;(B9(;7BL(L8H;B>9I(RG;(B9(:(

M=8SB>GL(>98T("8(H>9OB=JL(;7:;(Y8WM8=B89H8(H:9(98S8=(8WM>L8(;78(=>>;(>O(8SBP(B9(;78(

LGM=8J8(J:WBJ(>O(:(O=88(M><8=(>O(H7>BH8(B9(=8P:;B>9(;>(;78(P:<I(O>=I(:L($'*"##$%$5#"(F88FI(

;78(J:WBJ(M=8H8F8L(:PP(8WM8=B89H8T`__(%78(M=8SB>GL(L8H;B>9(;7:;(78(=8O8=L(;>(:MM8:=L(;>(R8(

Y!>9H8=9B9N(;78($=>M89LB;K(;>(&SBP(B9("GJ:9(*:;G=8T`("><8S8=I(;78=8(F>8L(9>;(:MM8:=(;>(

R8(LGH7(:(M=>>O(B9(;7BL(L8H;B>9I(8B;78=T(#L($:GP(.>=J>L:(8WMP:B9LI

,>8L(1:9;(F8PBS8=(>9(;78(M=>JBL8F(M=>>O(8PL8<78=8(B9(;78(;8W;l("8(F>8L(9>;I(:;(P8:L;(8WMPBHB;PKI(L88J(;>(F>(L>T(1:9;(F>8L(NBS8(M:=;L(>O(;78(=8gGB=8F(M=>>OI(RG;(O:BPL(;>(8WMPBHB;PK(R=B9N(;78(J:;;8=(;>(:9K(F8OB9B;8(H>9HPGLB>9T(+9F88F(1:9;(>O;89(N>8L(>G;(>O(7BL(<:K(;>(FBLHGLL(7GJ:9B;KfL(8SBP(M=>M89LB;K(>9PK(:L(:9(G9M=>S89(M>LLBRBPB;KI(>O;89(M=8O:HB9N(7BL(=8J:=VL(<B;7(:(7KM>;78;BH:P(YBO(`(HP:GL8I :P;7>GN7(B;(BL :PL>(HP8:=(;7:;(78(;7B9VL(>G=(8SBP(M=>M89LB;K(BL(9>;(>9PK(H>9H8M;G:PPK(M>LLBRP8I(RG; :H;G:PPK(F8LH=BR8L(>G=(7GJ:9(H>9FB;B>9T_D

6B;7>G;(LGH7(:(M=>>OI(B;(BL(G9HP8:=(7><(1:9;(B9;89FL(;>(]GL;BOK(7BL(HP:BJTDc("><8S8=I(O=>J(

;7BL(O>>;9>;8I(B9(<7BH7(78(HP:BJL(;7:;(78(7:L(NBS89(LGH7(:(M=>>OI(<8(H:9(:;(P8:L;(MB8H8(

;>N8;78=(<7:;(1:9;(;7B9VL(BL(98H8LL:=K(O>=(;7BL(M=>>OT(.>=J>L:(<=B;8L(;7:;I(O=>J(;7BL(

O>>;9>;8I(<8(H:9(L88(;7:;(1:9;(F>8L(=8H>N9Be8(;7:;(78(988FL(;>(NBS8(:(O>=J:P(M=>>O(>O(7BL(

_C +RBFI(\QX[(d(\QX\T

__ +RBFI(\QXD9T(?YTTT<8PH78(:R8=(9B8(FB8(6G=e8P(F8L(aoL89I(B9(F8=(>R8=L;89(4:WBJ8(F8=(O=8B89(6BPPVr=(B9(a8eB87G9N(:GOL(^8L8;eI(:GOF8HV89(V:99I(FB8(:PL(B9;8PPBNBR8P8(%:;(S>=(:PP8=(&=7:O=G9N(S>=78=N87;T`@

_D .>=J>L:I(Y1:9;(>9(;78(':FBH:P(&SBP(>O("GJ:9(*:;G=8I`(UU[T

Dc +9;8=8L;B9NPKI(;78(P:HV(>O(:(F8OB9B;BS8(:9L<8=(:R>G;(7BL(M=>>O(>O(=:FBH:P(8SBP(R8:=L(:(L;=>9N(LBJBP:=B;K(<B;7(;78(<:K(;7:;(1:9;(;:PVL(:R>G;(;78(988F(O>=(:(M=>>O(>O(;78(8WBL;89H8(>O(;78(J>=:P(P:<T("8(<=B;8L(;7:;(;78(J>=:P(P:<(H:99>;(R8(M=>S89(;7=>GN7(:(F8FGH;B>9(:9FI(B9(O:H;I(=8gGB=8L(9>(LGH7(M=>>O(?1:9;I(!$='I([QE\(h([QEC@T(#;(>98(M>B9;I(78(LBJMPK(H:PPL(B;(:(YO:H;(>O(MG=8(=8:L>9I`(>O(<7BH7(<8(:=8(Y:(M=B>=B(H>9LHB>GL`(:9F(<7BH7(BL(Y:M>FBH;BH:PPK(H8=;:B9`(?!$='I([QEC@T

Page 45: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

XCHP:BJI(;7:;(78(R8PB8S8L(78(N:S8(LGH7(:(M=>>O(YRK(=8:L>9`(B9(;78(L8H;B>9(R8O>=8(78(HP:BJL(

;7:;(8WM8=B89H8(LM:=8L(GL(;78(988F(O>=(LGH7(:(M=>>OI(:9F(;7:;(78(;7B9VL(Y7BL(M=>>O(=8L;L(B9(

M:=;(>9(;78(2=BN>=BL;2(SB8<(;7:;(;78=8(BL(9>(J8:9(R8;<889(:9(8SBP(:9F(:(N>>F(M=>M89LB;KT`DA

a8H:GL8(;78(;8W;(B;L8PO(BL(gGB;8(G9HP8:=I(J:9K(H>JJ89;:;>=L(LM8HGP:;8(:L(;>(<7:;(

1:9;(JBN7;(R8(F>B9N(78=8T(%78K(8B;78=(;7B9V(;7:;(1:9;(7:L(7BFF89(:(M=>>O(<B;7B9(7BL(

<>=VDU(>=(;7:;(<8(H:9(NBS8(:(M=>>O(;7:;(1:9;(B9;89F8F(;>I(RG;(O>=(L>J8(=8:L>9(FBF(9>;I(

B9HPGF8T(#;(P8:L;(>98(;7B9V8=I(^>=F>9(&T(4BH7:PL>9I(b=TI(7:L(H>J8(;>(;78(H>9HPGLB>9(;7:;(

1:9;(BL(G9:RP8(;>(LGMM>=;(;7BL(HP:BJTDX(4>L;(9>;:RPKI("89=K(#PPBL>9(:;;8JM;L(;>(H>9L;=GH;(:(

O>=J:P(M=>>O(>9(R87:PO(>O(1:9;TDE

6B;7B9(JK(M=>]8H;I(+(<BPP(9>;(:;;8JM;(;>(=8L>PS8(;7BL(BLLG8I(:L(J:9K(H>JJ89;:;>=L(

:P=8:FK(7:S8(M=>SBF8F(;7>GN7;OGP(M=>>OL(:9F(F8O89L8L(>O(1:9;2L(HP:BJT("><8S8=I(+(<BPP(

M>LB;(:(LGNN8L;B>9I(R:L8F(>9(.>=J>L:2L(>RL8=S:;B>9L(:R>G;(1:9;2L(G9BS8=L:PB;K(HP:BJT(

.>=J>L:(M>B9;L(>G;(;7:;I(<7BP8(1:9;(L:KL(;7:;(:(O>=J:P(M=>>O(BL(98H8LL:=K(O>=(7BL(HP:BJ(

:9F(;7:;(78(7:L(NBS89(LGH7(:(M=>>OI(78(F>8L(9>;(;:PV(:R>G;(;78(M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBP(:L(

L>J8;7B9N(;7:;(78(7:L(M=>S89(;>(8WBL;(B9(7GJ:9L(G9BS8=L:PPKT(':;78=I(78(GL8L(LGH7(

7KM>;78;BH:P(P:9NG:N8(:L(Y;78(M=>M89LB;K(i;>(8SBPjI(BO(;78=8(BL(>98`D[(:9F(;8PPL(=8:F8=L(;7:;(

Y8S8=K>98(H:9(F8HBF8(RK(7BJL8PO`(<78;78=(;78=8(BL(:(G9BS8=L:P(M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBPTD\(67BP8(

.>=J>L:(;7B9VL(;7:;(1:9;(GL8L(LGH7(P:9NG:N8(R8H:GL8(78(7:L(O:BP8F(;>(M=>S8(7BL(

DA((.>=J>L:I(Y1:9;(>9(;78(':FBH:P(&SBP(>O("GJ:9(*:;G=8I`(UU_T

DU**388(38B=B>P(4>=N:9I(Y%78(4BLLB9N(.>=J:P($=>>O(>O("GJ:9B;K2L(':FBH:P(&SBP(B9(1:9;2L(2'8PBNB>9T2`

DX((4BH7:PL>9I(Y%78(+9LH=G;:RBPB;K(>O(4>=:P(&SBP(B9(1:9;I`(U\CT

DE((#PPBL>9I(>/'*M1(D+"&0B(&2(P0"".&E:(A[[(d([CT

D[((1:9;I(!"#$%$&':(\QEAT

D\((+RBFI(\QXDT

Page 46: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

X_G9BS8=L:PB;K(HP:BJIDC(;78=8(JBN7;(R8(:9>;78=(=8:L>9(;7:;(1:9;(F>8L(;7BLT

+JMPBHB;(B9(1:9;2L(G9BS8=L:PB;K(HP:BJ(BL(;78(HP:BJ(;7:;(:PP(7GJ:9L(G9BS8=L:PPK(

H7>>L8(;>(7:S8(:(M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBP(R8H:GL8(B;(BL(YLGR]8H;BS8PK(98H8LL:=K`(?1-5\";*$K (

'&*)"'.$%@=(#L(:PPGF8F(;>(:R>S8I(1:9;(F89B8L(;7:;(;78(M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBP(BL(98H8LL:=K(;>(

;78(H>9H8M;(>O(7GJ:9B;K(RG;(;7:;(Y:HH>=FB9N(;>(;78(H>N9B;B>9(<8(7:S8(>O(;78(7GJ:9(R8B9N(

;7=>GN7(8WM8=B89H8I(78(H:99>;(R8(]GFN8F(>;78=<BL8I(B9(>;78=(<>=FLI(<8(J:K(M=8LGMM>L8(

8SBP(:L(LGR]8H;BS8PK(98H8LL:=K(B9(8S8=K(7GJ:9(R8B9NI(8S89(;78(R8L;T`D_#L(<8(H:9(L88(78=8I(

1:9;(L;=8LL8L(;7:;(;78=8(BL(:(FBOO8=89H8(R8;<889(J:VB9N(:(HP:BJ(;7:;(:(gG:PB;K(BL(98H8LL:=K(

:9F(;7:;(>98(BL(LGR]8H;BS8PK(98H8LL:=KT(+9F88FI(78(JGL;(J:V8(LGH7(:(FBL;B9H;B>9(R8H:GL8(>O(

:9>;78=(HP:BJ(BJMPBHB;(B9(7BL(FBLHGLLB>9(>O(=:FBH:P(8SBP(d(;78(HP:BJ(;7:;(:(M=>M89LB;K(JGL;(

R8(H>9;B9N89;(;>(;78(H>9H8M;(>O(7GJ:9B;KT(%7BL(FBL;B9H;B>9(BL(9>;(8WMP:B98F(78=8(B9(;78(

!"#$%$&'I(RG;(;7BL(M7=:L8I(YLGR]8H;BS8PK(98H8LL:=KI`(:MM8:=L(B9(:(O8<(>;78=(>O(1:9;2L(

<>=VLI(9:J8PK(;78(L8H>9F(:9F(;78(;7B=F(T0$*$I-"L=DD(

+9(;78(;7B=F(T0$*$I-"I(78(8WMP:B9L(;7:;(:(LGR]8H;BS8(98H8LLB;K(BL(9>;(:(98H8LLB;K(;7:;(

BL(B978=89;(B9(>G=(H>9H8M;L(RG;(BL(L;BPP(G9BS8=L:P(B9L>O:=(:L(;78=8(BL(:9(8LL89;B:P(

H>998H;B>9TAcc(#FFB;B>9:PPKI(B9(;78(L8H>9F(T0$*$I-":(1:9;(GL8L(;78(;8=J(YLGR]8H;BS8(

98H8LLB;K`(;>(F8LH=BR8(;78(988F(;>(M>LB;(;78(8WBL;89H8(>O(^>FT("8(<=B;8L(;7:;(B;(BL(

98H8LL:=K(;>(M>LB;(^>F2L(8WBL;89H8I(RG;(;7:;(;7BL(BL(9>;(:9(>R]8H;BS8(98H8LLB;KT(+O(B;(<8=8(:9(

>R]8H;BS8(98H8LLB;KI(<8(<>GPF(M>LB;(;78(8WBL;89H8(>O(^>F(Y:L(:(N=>G9F(>O(:PP(>RPBN:;B>9(B9(

DC((.>=J>L:I(Y1:9;(>9(;78(':FBH:P(&SBP(>O("GJ:9(*:;G=8I`(UXD(d(UEcT

D_((1:9;I(!"#$%$&':(\QXUT

DD +JJ:9G8P(1:9;I(T0$*$I-"(&2(*+"(C&)"0(&2(G-.%E"'*:(8FT($:GP(^GK8=I(;=:9LT($:GP(^GK8=(:9F(&=BH(4:;;78<LT(?!:JR=BFN8Q(!:JR=BFN8(-9BS8=LB;K($=8LLI(Uccc@T(.=>J(78=8(>9I(+(<BPP(=8O8=(;>(;7BL(<>=V(B9(O>>;9>;8L(:L(Y!$bT`

Acc 1:9;I(!$bI([QUX\(d([QUXCT

Page 47: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

XDN898=:PT`AcA("><8S8=I(R8H:GL8(:PP(>RPBN:;B>9(=8L;L(>9(;78(:G;>9>JK(>O(=8:L>9I(;7BL(BL(9>;(

98H8LL:=KT(':;78=I(B;(BL(LGR]8H;BS8PK(98H8LL:=K(;>(M>LB;(^>F2L(8WBL;89H8(R8H:GL8(>G=(=8:L>9(

H:99>;(G9F8=L;:9F(;78(M>LLBRBPB;K(>O(YL;=BSB9N(;>(M=>FGH8(:9F(M=>J>;8(;78(7BN78L;(N>>F(B9(

;78(<>=PF`(<B;7>G;(M>LB;B9N(;78(8WBL;89H8(>O(LGH7(:(YLGM=8J8(B9;8PPBN89H8T`AcU(+9(;7BL(

L89L8I(;789I(;78(8WBL;89H8(>O(^>F(BL(9>;(B978=89;(B9(>G=(H>9H8M;(>O(FG;KT("><8S8=I(<8(

JGL;(L:K(;7:;(M>LB;B9N(;7BL(8WBL;89H8(BL(98H8LL:=K(B9(;78(L89L8(;7:;(;78=8(BL(:9(8LL89;B:P(

H>998H;B>9(R8;<889(FG;K(:9F(^>F(B9L>O:=(:L(;78(M>LLBRBPB;K(>O(OGPOBPPB9N(>G=(FG;K(H:99>;(

R8(H>JMP8;8PK(G9F8=L;>>F(<B;7>G;(;7BL(M>LB;B9NT

aK(GLB9N(;7BL(M7=:L8I(;789I(B;(L88JL(=8:L>9:RP8(;>(:LLGJ8(;7:;(1:9;(<:L(

LGNN8L;B9N(;7:;(9>;7B9N(:R>G;(;78(H>9H8M;(>O(:(7GJ:9(R8B9N(:PP><L(GL(;>(H>N9Be8(/(A0$&0$ (

;7:;(:PP(7GJ:9L(<BPP(O=88PK(H7>>L8(=:FBH:P(8SBPT(+9F88FI(;7BL(G9F8=L;:9FB9N(>O(YLGR]8H;BS8(

98H8LLB;K`(H:9(78PM(8WMP:B9(<7K(1:9;(GL8L(7KM>;78;BH:P(P:9NG:N8(:9F(;8PPL(=8:F8=L(;7:;(

;78K(JGL;(F8HBF8(O>=(;78JL8PS8L(<78;78=(;7BL(HP:BJ(BL(;=G8T(+O(;78=8(BL(:(G9BS8=L:P(=GP8(;7:;(

8S8=K(7GJ:9(B9FBSBFG:P(<BPP(H7>>L8(=:FBH:P(8SBP(RG;(<8(H:99>;(M=>S8(;7BL(G9BS8=L:PB;K(RK(

;=:FB;B>9:P(M=>>OLI(;789(B;(J:V8L(L89L8(;7:;(1:9;(;8PPL(GL(;7:;(<8(8:H7(988F(;>(M=>SBF8(>G=(

><9(]GL;BOBH:;B>9(O>=(;7BL(HP:BJT(+;(BL(L>J8;7B9N(;7:;(<8(V9><(J8=8PK(LGR]8H;BS8PKI(B9L>O:=(

:L(L>J8;7B9N(:R>G;(;78(H>9H8M;(>O(7GJ:9(9:;G=8I(M8=7:MLI(B9FBH:;8L(;>(GL(;7:;(;78=8(BL(:9(

8LL89;B:P(d(;7>GN7(9>;(>R]8H;BS8PK(98H8LL:=K(d(H>998H;B>9(R8;<889(7GJ:9L(:9F(;78(H7>BH8(

;>(R8(=:FBH:PPK(8SBPT

67BP8(;7BL(LGNN8L;B>9(BL(9>;(OGPPK(F8S8P>M8F(>=(F8O89F8FI(B;(L88JL(:;(P8:L;(M>LLBRP8(

;7:;(;78(GL8(>O(;78(;8=J(YLGR]8H;BS8(98H8LLB;K`(H>GPF(78PM(;>(8WMP:B9(<7K(1:9;(F89B8L(;7:;(

AcA 1:9;I(!$='I([QAU\T

AcU +RBFT

Page 48: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

Ec8WM8=B89;B:P(8SBF89H8(:P>98(H:9(M=>S8(7BL(G9BS8=L:PB;K(HP:BJ(RG;(;7:;(78(O:BPL(;>(NBS8(:9(

8WMPBHB;(O>=J:P(M=>>OT("><8S8=I(+(<BPP(P8:S8(;78(H>JMP8W(BLLG8(>O(F8O89FB9N(;7BL(HP:BJ(O>=(

9><(:9F(J8=8PK(;:V8(B;(:;(O:H8(S:PG8T(#;(;7BL(M>B9;I(B;(BL(89>GN7(;>(:HV9><P8FN8(;7:;(1:9;(

F>8L(R8PB8S8(7BL(HP:BJ(;>(R8(;=G8(:9F(;7:;(J:9K(;7B9V8=L(7:S8(M=>SBF8F(MP:GLBRP8(F8O89L8L(

>O(;7BL(HP:BJT(6B;7>G;(L8;;PB9N(>9(>98(<:K(;>(F8O89F(;7BL(HP:BJI(<8(H:9(L;BPP(F8;8=JB98(

<7K(1:9;(JBN7;(7:S8(B9;=>FGH8F(;78(H>9H8M;(>O(=:FBH:P(8SBP(B9;>(7BL(M7BP>L>M7K(:9F(B9(

<7:;(<:KLI(BO(;=G8I(B;(<>GPF(H>78=8(>=(O:BP(;>(H>78=8(<B;7(7BL(J>=:P(M7BP>L>M7KT

%78($>LLBRBPB;K(>O(a8H>JB9N(4>=:PPK(^>>F

1:9;2L(HP:BJ(;7:;(:PP(7GJ:9L(:=8(=:FBH:PPK(8SBPI(:L(9>;8F(:R>S8I(H=8:;8L(:(L8=B>GL(

M=>RP8J(O>=(7BL(J>=:P(M7BP>L>M7KT("8(HP:BJL(;7:;(8S8=K(7GJ:9(M=B>=B;Be8L(B9H89;BS8L(>O(

B9HPB9:;B>9(:R>S8(;78(B9H89;BS8(>O(;78(J>=:P(P:<I(RG;(;7BL(HP:BJ(J:V8L(B;(L88JB9NPK(

BJM>LLBRP8(O>=(7GJ:9L(;>(R8H>J8(J>=:PPK(N>>F(R8H:GL8(;78K(:=8(G9:RP8(;>(:H;(GM>9(N>>F(

J:WBJLTAcX(+;(BL(8LL89;B:P(;7:;(7GJ:9L(:=8(:RP8(;>(R8H>J8(J>=:PPK(N>>F(R8H:GL8(B;(BL(<7:;(

;78(J>=:P(P:<(H>JJ:9FL(>O(GLI(:9F(;78(=8:PB;K(>O(=:FBH:P(8SBP(F>8L(9>;(H7:9N8(;7BL(

H>JJ:9FTAcE(1:9;(HP:BJL(;7:;(;78(>GN7;(>O(;78(J>=:P(H>JJ:9F(BJMPB8L(;7:;(<8(H:9(

:HH>JMPBL7(<7:;(BL(H>JJ:9F8FTAc[(6B;7>G;(;7BL(:RBPB;KI(;78(H>JJ:9F(BL(J8:9B9NP8LLT

+9F88FI(;78(HP:BJ(;7:;(:PP(7GJ:9L(7:S8(8SBP(6"1$''-'%"'(:MM8:=L(;>(J:V8(;78(

H>JJ:9F(;>(R8H>J8(J>=:PPK(N>>F(J8:9B9NP8LLT(#(M8=L>9(<B;7(:9(8SBP(6"1$''-'%(H:9(

M8=O>=J(:H;B>9L(;7:;(:MM8:=(;>(R8(N>>FI(B9L>O:=(:L(;78K(:=8(B9(:HH>=F:9H8(<B;7(;78(J>=:P(

P:<(?;7:;(BLI(;78K(:=8(;78(L:J8(:H;B>9L(;7:;(;78(J>=:P(P:<(<>GPF(;8PP(GL(;>(F>@I(RG;(LGH7(:(

AcX 678;78=(B;(BL(:H;G:PPK(;=G8(;7:;(=:FBH:PPK(8SBP(7GJ:9L(H:99>;(:H;(>9(N>>F(J:WBJL(BL(:9(BLLG8(;7:;(+(<BPP(:FF=8LL(B9(!7:M;8=(%7=88T

AcE 388(1:9;:(!"#$%$&':(\Q[c(d(\Q[AT

Ac[ +RBFI(\QE[T

Page 49: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

EAM8=L>9(H:9(98S8=(:H;G:PPK(M8=O>=J(:(N>>F(:H;B>9T(%7BL(BL(R8H:GL8(:(N>>F(:H;B>9(=8gGB=8L(:(

N>>F(J:WBJI(>=(:(J:WBJ(;7:;(BL(J>;BS:;8F(RK(FG;KT(%78(M=8L89H8(>O(:9(8SBP(6"1$''-'%I(>=(

:(M=B>=B;K(>O(B9HPB9:;B>9L(:R>S8(;78(J>=:P(P:<I(B9OPG89H8L(;7:;(M8=L>92L(M:=;BHGP:=(J:WBJL(

:9F(78(BL(;78=8RK(H>JJB;;8F(;>(:P<:KL(L8P8H;(8SBP(J:WBJLT

67BP8(+(<BPP(=8L8=S8(:(OGPP(FBLHGLLB>9(=8N:=FB9N(1:9;2L(M=>M>L8F(L>PG;B>9(;>(;7BL(

M=>RP8J(G9;BP(!7:M;8=(%7=88I(B;(BL(BJM>=;:9;(;>(9>;8(;7:;(1:9;(F>8L(;7B9V(;7:;(B;(BL(M>LLBRP8(

;>(>S8=H>J8(>G=(8SBP(6"1$''-'%"'(:9F(R8H>J8(J>=:PPK(N>>FT(1:9;(HP:BJL(;7:;I(BO(<8(:=8(

<BPPB9N(;>(:HH8M;(;7:;(7GJ:9L(H:9(N>(O=>J(R8B9N(J>=:PPK(N>>FI(B9(;78(L89L8(>O(7:SB9N(:(

N>>F(M=8FBLM>LB;B>9I(;>(J>=:PPK(8SBPI(<8(L7>GPF(:PL>(:HH8M;(;7:;(;78(=8S8=L8(BL(M>LLBRP8I(

8S89(;7>GN7(<8(H:99>;(OGPPK(G9F8=L;:9F(8B;78=TAc\(%7BL(BL(R8H:GL8(;78(J>=:P(>GN7;(8WBL;L(B9(

>G=(=8:L>9T("8(8WMP:B9LI(Y.>=I(B9(LMB;8(>O(;7:;(O:PP(i;>(8SBPjI(;78(H>JJ:9F(;7:;(<8(&-%+*(;>(

R8H>J8(R8;;8=(7GJ:9(R8B9NL(L;BPP(=8L>G9FL(G9:R:;8F(B9(>G=(L>GPLp(H>9L8gG89;PKI(<8(JGL;(

:PL>(R8(H:M:RP8(>O(B;I(8S89(BO(<7:;(<8(F>(BL(>O(B;L8PO(B9LGOOBHB89;(:9FI(RK(SB=;G8(>O(B;I(<8(

>9PK(J:V8(>G=L8PS8L(=8H8M;BS8(;>(:(7BN78=(:LLBL;:9H8(B9LH=G;:RP8(;>(GLT`AcC(67:;(1:9;(BL(

LGNN8L;B9N(78=8(BL(;7:;(;78=8(BL(:(<:K(;>(>S8=H>J8(8SBPI(8S89(BO(<8(H:99>;(BF89;BOK(

H:M:HB;B8L(<B;7B9(>G=L8PS8L(;7:;(<>GPF(J:V8(B;(M>LLBRP8T(#L(<8(<BPP(L88(B9(!7:M;8=(%7=88I(

1:9;2L(L>PG;B>9(=8L;LI(B9(M:=;I(GM>9(7BL(LGNN8L;B>9(;7:;(L>J8(VB9F(>O(LGM8=h7GJ:9(

Ac\ 1:9;(:LVLI(YaG;I(LB9H8(RK(>G=(M=8SB>GL(:FJBLLB>9(:(;=88(<7BH7(<:L(?B9(B;L(M=8FBLM>LB;B>9@(>=BNB9:PPK(N>>F(FBF(R=B9N(O>=;7(R:F(O=GB;LI(:9F(LB9H8(;78(O:PP(O=>J(N>>F(B9;>(8SBP(?BO(<8(L8=B>GLPK(H>9LBF8=(;7:;(8SBP(>=BNB9:;8L(O=>J(O=88F>J@(BL(9>(J>=8(H>JM=8789LBRP8(;7:9(;78(:LH89;(O=>J(8SBP(R:HV(;>(;78(N>>FI(;789(;78(M>LLBRBPB;K(>O(;7BL(P:L;(H:99>;(R8(FBLMG;8F`(?!"#$%$&':(\QEE(d(\QE[@T(?Y,:(:R8=(F>H7(9:H7(F8J(S>=78=(:RN8P8N;89(^8L;s9F9BLL8(8B9(G=LM=r9NPBH7(?F8=(#9P:N8(9:H7@(NG;8=(a:GJ(:=N8(.=rH7;8(78=S>=N8R=:H7;(7:;(G9F(F8=(08=O:PP(S>J(^G;89(B9L(aoL8(?<899(J:9(<>7P(R8F89V;I(F:t(:GL(F8=(.=8B78;(89;LM=B9N;@(9BH7;(R8N=8BOPBH78=(BL;(:PL(F:L(6BF8=:GOL;8789(:GL(F8J(aoL89(eGJ(^G;89I(L>(V:99(FB8(4oNPBH7V8B;(F8L(P8;e;8=89(9BH7;(R8L;=B;;89(<8=F89T`@

AcC 1:9;I(!"#$%$&':(\QE[T(Y,899(G9N8:H7;8;(]898L(#RO:PPL(8=LH7:PP;(F>H7(F:L(^8R>;Q(<B=(L>PP89(R8LL8=8(489LH789(<8=F89I(G9S8=JB9F8=;(B9(G9L8=8=(388P8p(O>PNPBH7(JrLL89(<B=(8L(:GH7(Vo9989I(L>PP;8(:GH7(F:LI(<:L(<B=(;G9(Vo9989I(Or=(LBH7(:PP8B9(G9eG=8BH789F(L8B9I(G9F(<B=(G9L(F:FG=H7(9G=(8B98L(Or=(G9L(G98=O>=LH7PBH789(7o78=89(a8BL;:9F8L(8JMOs9NPBH7(J:H789T`

Page 50: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

EU:LLBL;:9H8(J:K(R8(:S:BP:RP8(;>(GLI(;>(78PM(GL(;>(>S8=H>J8(=:FBH:P(8SBPT(+;(BL(HP8:=(;7:;(<8(

J:K(988F(L>J8(VB9F(>O(78PMI(RG;I(B9(>=F8=(;>(J:V8(;7BL(H7:9N8(J8:9B9NOGP(?B9(;7:;(B;(BL(:(

O=88I(J>=:P(H7>BH8@I(<8(JGL;(R8(BJMG;:RP8(O>=(B;T(%7BL(BL(<7K(1:9;(O>HGL8L(>9(;78(7GJ:9(

8OO>=;(>O(J:VB9N(>G=L8PS8L(Y<>=;7K(>O(=8H8BSB9N`(>=(Y=8H8M;BS8(;>`(;7BL(78PMTAc_(1:9;(=8O8=L(

;>(;78(H7:9N8(O=>J(7:SB9N(:9(8SBP(6"1$''-'%(;>(7:SB9N(:(N>>F(>98(:L(:(Y=8S>PG;B>9(>O(

6"1$''-'%`(?"$'"(!"K&#-*$&'($'(."0(6"1$''-'%@IAcD(<7BH7(B9S>PS8L(:(YH7:9N8(>O(78:=;`(

?`'."0-'%(."1(U"07"'1@T

+9(!7:M;8=(%7=88I(+(<BPP(FBLHGLL(B9(N=8:;(F8;:BP(<7:;(;7BL(=8S>PG;B>9(89;:BPL(:9F(

7><(:(M8=L>9(H:9(N>(:R>G;(R8H>JB9N(<>=;7K(>O(B;T(.>=(9><I(B;(<BPP(R8(89>GN7(;>(

G9F8=L;:9F(;7:;(1:9;(F>8L(;7B9V(;7:;(;78(>S8=H>JB9N(>O(8SBP(BL(M>LLBRP8I(8S89(BO(7GJ:9L(

JBN7;(9>;(7:S8(;78(M><8=(;>(H>JMP8;8(;7BL(H7:9N8(>9(;78B=(><9T(+O(<8(F>(=8gGB=8(

:LLBL;:9H8I(78(L;:;8L(;7:;(<8(H:99>;(V9><(:9K;7B9N(:R>G;(;7BL(:LLBL;:9H8(R8H:GL8(;78(

:H;G:P(H7:9N8(>HHG=L(>G;LBF8(>O(;BJ8(:9F(LM:H8I(B9L>O:=(:L(B;(BL(:(O=88(F8HBLB>9T("><8S8=I(

78(L:KL(;7:;(<8(H:9(V9><(<7:;(7GJ:9L(JGL;(F>(;>(N:B9(;7BL(:LLBL;:9H8I(:9>;78=(M>B9;(;7:;(

+(<BPP(FBLHGLL(B9(N=8:;(F8;:BP(P:;8=(B9(;7BL(M=>]8H;TAAc

56"#7/*196)=<*!#/*1%""-(#)%"/*#%*>)/*:6$9)-$*?%$69*@,)9%/%8,A

68(7:S8(:P=8:FK(FBLHGLL8F(;78(H>9;89;(>O(1:9;2L(HP:BJ(=8N:=FB9N(;78(G9BS8=L:PB;K(

>O(=:FBH:P(8SBP(:9F(;78(;=:FB;B>9:P(>R]8H;B>9L(;>(N=:9;B9N(B;(:(MP:H8(B9(>G=(=8:FB9NL(>O(

1:9;2L(J>=:P(M7BP>L>M7KT(+9(;7BL(L8H;B>9I(+(<BPP(=8LM>9F(;>(;78L8(>R]8H;B>9L(RK(8WMP>=B9N(

7><(;78(B9;=>FGH;B>9(>O(;7BL(H>9H8M;(J:K(R8(L889(;>(O>PP><(O=>J(1:9;2L(M=B>=(<=B;B9NLAAA(B9(

Ac_ +RBFI(\QEE(d(\QE[T

AcD +RBFI(\QECT

AAc +RBFI(\Q[UT

AAA aK(YR8(L889(;>(O>PP><(O=>J(1:9;2L(M=B>=(<=B;B9NLI`(+(B9;89F(:(M=>]8H;(JGH7(PBV8(7><("89=K(&T(#PPBL>9(

Page 51: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

EX>=F8=(;>(L88(7><(;7BL(HP:BJ(OB;L(B9;>(7BL(J>=:P(M7BP>L>M7KI(LM8HBOBH:PPKI(:9F(<7K(78(JBN7;(

7:S8(B9;=>FGH8F(B;T

.B=L;I(B9(>=F8=(;>(L7><(;7:;(;7BL(HP:BJ(:R>G;(;78(G9BS8=L:PB;K(>O(=:FBH:P(8SBP(F>8L(

H>78=8(<B;7(1:9;2L(J>=:P(M7BP>L>M7KI(<8(JGL;(B9S8L;BN:;8(<78;78=(B;(O>PP><L(O=>J(>=(

H>9;=BRG;8L(;>(7BL(M=8SB>GL(J>=:P(<=B;B9NL(B9(L>J8(<:KTAAU(67BP8(;78(<:K(;7:;(;7BL(HP:BJ(

O>PP><L(O=>J(:9F(:FFL(;>(1:9;2L(M=B>=(J>=:P(;78>=K(7:L(R889(F8LH=BR8F(B9(L8S8=:P(FBOO8=89;(

<:KL(B9(=8H89;(L8H>9F:=K(PB;8=:;G=8I(;78(G9BOKB9N(O8:;G=8(:J>9N(;78(J:]>=B;K(>O(;78L8(

8WMP:9:;B>9L(BL(;7:;(;7BL(HP:BJ(:R>G;(G9BS8=L:PB;K(:9F(;78(HP:BJL(LG==>G9FB9N(B;(L>J87><(

HP:=BOK(:9F(78PM(;>(F8S8P>M(1:9;2L(H>9H8M;L(>O(O=88F>J(:9F(;78(7GJ:9(<BPPTAAX(

3M8HBOBH:PPKI(J>L;(;7B9V8=L(7:S8(O>HGL8F(GM>9(7><(;7BL(HP:BJ(:9F(;78(B9S8L;BN:;B>9(>O(

7GJ:9(9:;G=8(LG==>G9FB9N(B;(8WMP:B9L(:9(G9=8L>PS8F(BLLG8(B9(1:9;2L(J>=:P(M7BP>L>M7K(h(

7><(B;(BL(M>LLBRP8(O>=(7GJ:9L(;>(O=88PK(H7>>L8(;>(R8(G9O=88I(>=(;>(F>(J>=:PPK(8SBP(:H;B>9LI(

:9F(<78=8(;78(L>G=H8(>O(;7BL(H7>BH8(;>(R8(8SBP(PB8LT(#L(9>;8F(:R>S8I(;78(>9PK(<:K(;7:;(:(

7GJ:9(H:9(:H;(BJJ>=:PPK(BL(;>(H7>>L8(;>(R8(J>;BS:;8F(RK(B9HPB9:;B>9LI(<7BH7(BL(;>(

LG==89F8=(>982L(O=88F>J(:9F(R8(J>S8F(RK(:9(8W;8=9:P(H:GL8T($=B>=(;>(;78(!"#$%$&':(:9F(

LM8HBOBH:PPK(B9(;78(60&-'.)&0;(:9F(;78(L8H>9F(T0$*$I-":(1:9;(7:F(J:F8(;78(HP:BJ(;7:;(

:H;B9N(BJJ>=:PPK(<:L(BJMG;:RP8I(RG;(B;(<:L(G9HP8:=(7><I(BO(:H;B9N(BJJ>=:PPK(<:L(:9(

F8LH=BR8L(7BL(><9T(+9(:(H7:M;8=(>O(7BL(R>>VI(>/'*M1(D+"&0B(&2(P0"".&E:(78(<=B;8L(;7:;(78(<BPP(Y:;;8JM;(;>(L7><(;7:;(1:9;2L(F>H;=B98(>O(=:FBH:P(8SBP(BL(9>;(>9PK(B9(:HH>=F(<B;7(RG;(:PL>(:(H>9L8gG89H8(>O(;78(R:LBH(M=B9HBMP8L(>O(7BL(J>=:P(M7BP>L>M7K`(?AEC@T

AAU +9(;7BL(L8H;B>9I(+(<BPP(:FF=8LL(;78(J>L;(<BF8PK(=8H>N9Be8F(<:K(;7:;(;78(B9;=>FGH;B>9(>O(=:FBH:P(8SBP(H>9;=BRG;8L(;>(1:9;2L(M=8SB>GL(J>=:P(M7BP>L>M7KT("><8S8=I(:L(+(<BPP(:=NG8(B9(!7:M;8=(UI(+(F>(9>;(R8PB8S8(;7BL(;>(R8(;78(>9PK(<:K(;7:;(=:FBH:P(8SBP(78PML(;>(8WMP:B9(:9F(HP:=BOK(7BL(J>=:P(;78>=KT

AAX %<>(M=>M>989;L(>O(;7BL(SB8<I(!7=BL(/T(.B=8L;>98(:9F(*:;7:9(b:H>RLI(B9(;78B=(H'(4"2"'1"(&2(>/'*M1 (!"#$%$&'I(:=;BHGP:;8(;7BL(=8LM>9L8(B9(:(78PMOGP(:9F(HP8:=(<:KT(%78K(:=NG8(;7:;(;78(!"#$%$&'(BL(=8P8S:9;(;>(1:9;2L(J>=:P(M7BP>L>M7K(B9(;7:;(B;(YG9M:HViLj(G9F8=F8S8P>M8F(H>9H8M;L(O=>J(7BL(H=B;BH:P(M7BP>L>M7K(B9(<:KL(;7:;(:=8(B9;=BH:;8(:9F(B9LBN7;OGPI(:9F(B9(<:KL(;7:;(:=8(9>;(>9PK(H>78=89;I(RG;(:PL>(=8PBNB>GLPK(:9F(;78>P>NBH:PPK(:OOB=J:;BS8`(?UXX@T(+;(BL(;7BL(G9M:HVB9N(>O(G9F8=F8S8P>M8F(H>9H8M;L(;7:;(+(<BPP(O>HGL(>9T

Page 52: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

EEG9O=88(:H;I(:(M8=L>9(H>GPF(R8(78PF(=8LM>9LBRP8(O>=(B;TAAE(+9(;7BL(L8H;B>9I(;789I(+(<BPP(L7><(

7><(;78(B9;=>FGH;B>9(>O(=:FBH:P(8SBP(:9F(;78(LG==>G9FB9N(8WMP>=:;B>9(>O(7GJ:9(9:;G=8(:9F(

;78(<BPP(78PM(;>(HP:=BOK(;78L8(8:=PB8=(HP:BJLT

+9(;78(60&-'.)&0;:(1:9;(B9;=>FGH8L(;78(7GJ:9(<BPP(:L(;78(:RBPB;K(;>(:H;(:HH>=FB9N(

;>(P:<L(>=(M=B9HBMP8LI(>=(M=:H;BH:P(=8:L>9T("8(<=B;8LI(Y)9PK(:(=:;B>9:P(R8B9N(7:L(;78(

H:M:HB;K(;>(:H;($'(/FF&0./'F"()$*+(*+"(0"A0"1"'*/*$&'(>O(P:<LI(;7:;(BLI(B9(:HH>=F:9H8(<B;7(

M=B9HBMP8LI(>=(7:L(:()$##=(3B9H8(0"/1&'(BL(=8gGB=8F(O>=(;78(F8=BS:;B>9(>O(:H;B>9L(O=>J(P:<LI(

;78(<BPP(BL(9>;7B9N(>;78=(;7:9(M=:H;BH:P(=8:L>9T`AA[(aG;I(:HH>=FB9N(;>(1:9;I(;78(7GJ:9(<BPP(

BL(J>=8(;7:9(]GL;(M=:H;BH:P(=8:L>9T(%78(<BPP(JGL;(:PL>(R8(O=88T(+O(;78(7GJ:9(<BPP(BL(9>;(O=88(

;>(H7>>L8(O>=(>=(:N:B9L;(M=:H;BH:P(=8:L>9I(<8(H>GPF(9>;(R8(78PF(=8LM>9LBRP8(O>=(<7:;(<8(

<BPPTAA\("><8S8=I(;7BL(FG:P(F8OB9B;B>9(NBS8L(=BL8(;>(:(M=>RP8J(O>=(1:9;2L(J>=:P(M7BP>L>M7KT(

#L(3BPR8=(8WMP:B9LI

#HH>=FB9N(;>(;78L8(F8OB9B;B>9LI(:(O=88(<BPP(:9F(:(<BPP(:H;B9N(:HH>=FB9N(;>(P:<LI(;7:;(BLI(J:WBJL(H:M:RP8(>O(G9BS8=L:PBe:;B>9I(<8=8(>98(:9F(;78(L:J8T(1:9;(;78=8O>=8(H>9HPGF8FI(B9(:(J:998=(=8JB9BLH89;(>O($P:;>I(;7:;(;78(O=88(<BPP(BL(;78(<BPP(:H;B9N(:HH>=FB9N(;>(J>=:P(P:<LT(aG;(<7:;(>O(;78(<BPP(;7:;(=8]8H;L(;78(J>=:P(P:<(B9(B;L(:H;B>9LlTTT3GH7(:(<BPPI(L:BF(1:9;(B9(;78(60&-'.)&0;:(BL(78;8=>9>J>GLp(;7:;(BLI(;78(Y<BPP(F>8L(9>;(NBS8(B;L8PO(;78(P:<I(RG;(;78(>R]8H;(i>O(F8LB=8j(F>8L(L>(B9(SB=;G8(>O(B;L(=8P:;B>9(;>(;78(<BPP`(?EQEEA@TAAC

AAE 3BPR8=I(Y%78(&;7BH:P(3BN9BOBH:9H8(>O(1:9;2L('8PBNB>9I`(B9;=>FGH8L(;7BL(M=>RP8J(:L(;78(M=>RP8J(>O(;78(M>LLBRBPB;K(>O(:(H:;8N>=BH:P(>RPBN:;B>9T("8(<=B;8LI(Y3B9H8(:(F/*"%&0$F/#(=8P:;B>9(BL(:(98H8LL:=K(>98(:9F(LB9H8(&5#$%/*$&'(M=8LGMM>L8L(O=88F>JI(1:9;(7:F(;>(L7><(7><(98H8LLB;K(H:9(R8(H>JRB98F(<B;7(O=88F>J(B9(:(LB9NP8(=8P:;B>9L7BM`(?PWWWB@T($=B>=(;>(;78(!"#$%$&':(3BPR8=(;7B9VL(;7:;(B;(BL(G9HP8:=(7><(:(O=88(<BPP(H:9(R8(98H8LL:=BPKI(=:;78=(;7:9(7KM>;78;BH:PPKI(>RPBN:;8F(;>(F>(L>J8;7B9NT

AA[ 1:9;I(60&-'.)&0;:(EQEAUT(?Y*G=(8B9(S8=9r9O;BN8L(68L89(7:;(F:L(08=JvN89I('/F+(."0(9&01*"##-'%(F8=(^8L8;e8(FTBT(9:H7($=B9eBMB89(eG(7:9F8P9I(>F8=(8B989(S$##"'=,:(eG(#RP8B;G9N(F8=(":9FPG9N89(S>9(^8L8;e89(9"0'-'2*(8=O>=F8=;(<B=FI(L>(BL;(F8=(6BPP8(9BH7;L(:9F8=8L(:PL(M=:V;BLH78(08=9G9O;T`@

AA\ 388(1:9;:(60&-'.)&0;:(EQEEC(d(EQEE_T

AAC 3BPR8=I(Y%78(&;7BH:P(3BN9BOBH:9H8(>O(1:9;2L('8PBNB>9I`(PWWWBBT

Page 53: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

E[%78(M=>RP8J(78=8(BL(HP8:=TAA_(a8H:GL8(1:9;(F8OB98L(;78(7GJ:9(<BPP(:L(R>;7(M=:H;BH:P(

=8:L>9I(>=(;78(NBS8=(>O(;78(J>=:P(P:<I(:9F(O=88I(B9L>O:=(:L(B;(BL(:G;>9>J>GLI(;78(<BPP(H:9(

>9PK(R8(H>9LBF8=8F(O=88(<789(B;(H7>>L8L(;>(R8(J>;BS:;8F(RK(FG;KI(>=(;78(J>=:P(P:<T("8(

<=B;8L(;7:;(YiBjO(;78(<BPP(L88VL(;78(P:<(;7:;(BL(;>(F8;8=JB98(B;(/'B)+"0"("#1"(;7:9(B9(;78(

OB;98LL(>O(B;L(J:WBJL(O>=(B;L(><9(NBSB9N(>O(G9BS8=L:P(P:<TTT78;8=>9>JK(:P<:KL(=8LGP;LT`AAD(

6789(;78(<BPP(:H;L(78;8=>9>J>GLPKI(B;(BL(R8B9N(J>S8F(RK(B9HPB9:;B>9L(:9F(9>;(:H;B9N(

O=88PKT(a8H:GL8(;78(<BPP(BL(9>;(:H;B9N(O=88PKI(B;(H:99>;(R8(78PF(=8LM>9LBRP8(O>=(B;L(H7>BH8LT(

%78=8O>=8I(7GJ:9L(H:9(>9PK(R8(=8LM>9LBRP8(O>=(:H;B>9L(BO(;7>L8(:H;B>9L(:=8(J>=:PPK(N>>FT

&JBP(.:HV8978BJ(:=;BHGP:;8L(;7BL(:L(:(M=>RP8J(>O(J:VB9N(J>=:P(O=88F>J(

J8:9B9NOGPT("8(9>;8L(;7:;I(:HH>=FB9N(;>(;7BL(8:=PK(G9F8=L;:9FB9N(>O(;78(<BPPI(<789(<8(F>(

9>;(:H;(O=>J(;78(J>=:P(P:<I(<8(:=8(H7>>LB9N(;>(:H;(>9(9>(M=B9HBMP8(:;(:PPI(>=(;>(O>=N>(>G=(

O=88F>J(:9F(=8LM>9LBRBPB;KT(aG;(78(F>8L(9>;(R8PB8S8(;7:;(;7BL(BL(;78(H:L8T("8(8WMP:B9LI

4:92L(H7>BH8(BL(9>;(R8;<889(:H;B9N(>9(;78(N>>F(:L(M=B9HBMP8I(>=(9>;(:H;B9N(>9(M=B9HBMP8(:;(:PPT(%78(H7>BH8(BL(9>;(R8;<889(:(N>>F(<BPP(:9F(;78(:RL89H8(>O(<BPPT(4:9(:P<:KL(:H;L(>9(M=B9HBMP8(:9F(O=88PKp(:9F(78(BL(:P<:KL(=8LM>9LBRP8T(aG;(7BL(M=B9HBMP8(<BPP(8B;78=(R8(;78(J>=:P(P:<I(MG=8(:9F(LBJMP8I(>=(;78(F8SB:;B>9(;78=8O=>JI(>HH:LB>9:P(>=(>;78=<BL8TTT+9(>;78=(<>=FLI(78(BL(O=88(;>(H7>>L8(R8;<889(N>>F(:9F(8SBPTAUc

.:HV8978BJ2L(HP:BJ(78=8(BL(;7:;(;7BL(G9F8=L;:9FB9N(>O(J>=:P(O=88F>J(F>8L(9>;(:PBN9(<B;7(

>G=(YJ>=:P(H>9LHB>GL98LLI`AUA(>=(>G=(J>=:P(B9;GB;B>9(:R>G;(;78(H>9H8M;(>O(O=88F>JT(6789(

<8(;:PV(:R>G;(J>=:P(O=88F>JI(<8(H>JJ>9PK(J8:9(L>J8;7B9N(PBV8(;78(H>9LHB>GLI(

AA_ 'BH7:=F(bT(a8=9L;8B9(:PL>(M>B9;L(>G;(;7BL(M=>RP8J(B9(!/.$F/#(RK$#?(@(C+$#&1&A+$F/#(H'*"00&%*$&':(?)WO>=FQ($>PB;K($=8LLI(UccU@Q(AXT("8(9>;8L(;7:;(1:9;2L(H>9;8JM>=:=KI('8B97>PFI(M>B9;8F(>G;(;7BL(M=>RP8J(B9(1:9;2L(<=B;B9NL(:;(;78(;BJ8I(:9F(;78(H=B;BHBLJ(7:L(H>9;B9G8F(;>(;>F:KT

AAD 1:9;I(60&-'.)&0;:(EQEEAT

AUc .:HV8978BJI(Y1:9;(:9F(':FBH:P(&SBPI`(XE_T

AUA +RBFT

Page 54: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

E\B9;89;B>9:P(H7>BH8(R8;<889(F>B9N(N>>F(>=(F>B9N(8SBPI(9>;(]GL;(R8;<889(F>B9N(N>>F(>=(

:H;B9N(<B;7>G;(:9K(M=B9HBMP8(:;(:PPT(68(F>(9>;(R8PB8S8(;7:;(<8(:=8(>9PK(=8LM>9LBRP8(:9F(

O=88(<789(<8(M8=O>=J(J>=:PPK(N>>F(:H;B>9LT(':;78=I(1:9;(JGL;(R8(:RP8(;>(8WMP:B9(7><(

<8(H:9(R8(8gG:PPK(O=88(:9F(=8LM>9LBRP8(<789(<8(H7>>L8(8SBP(J:WBJLT

+9(;78(!"#$%$&':(1:9;(BL(OB9:PPK(:RP8(;>(=8L>PS8(;7BL(BLLG8(<B;7(7BL(B9;=>FGH;B>9(>O(

;78(FG:P(OG9H;B>9L(>O(;78(7GJ:9(<BPPT(+9(3BPR8=2L(Y%78(&;7BH:P(3BN9BOBH:9H8(>O(1:9;2L(

!"#$%$&':`(78(:LL8=;L(;7:;(;78(!"#$%$&'(BL(]GL;(:L(BJM>=;:9;(:L(;78(60&-'.)&0;(:9F(;78(

L8H>9F(T0$*$I-"(B9(;8=JL(>O(78PMB9N(GL(;>(G9F8=L;:9F(7BL(8;7BHLTAUU(%7BL(BL(R8H:GL8(B;(BL(B9(

;7BL(<>=V(;7:;(<8(OB9F(1:9;2L(J>L;(B9hF8M;7(FBLHGLLB>9(>O(;78(7GJ:9(<BPP(:9F(O=88F>JI(

<7BH7(:=8(V8K(H>JM>989;L(>O(7BL(8;7BH:P(;78>=KT(3BPR8=(<=B;8LI

1:9;2L(8;7BH:P(L;:;BHLI(;>(R>==><(:(;8=J(O=>J(M7KLBHLI(J:K(R8(O>G9F(B9(S:=KB9N(F8N=88L(>O(LKL;8J:;Be:;B>9(B9(J>L;(>O(7BL(M>L;hH=B;BH:P(<>=VLT()9PK(B9(;78(!"#$%$&':(7><8S8=I(F>(<8(OB9F(<7:;(JBN7;(R8(H:PP8F(1:9;2L(8;7BH:P(FK9:JBHLTTTB9(;78(!"#$%$&'(78(:FF=8LL8L(7BJL8PO(;>(;78(M=>RP8J(>O(8SBP(d(B;L(9:;G=8I(B;L(>=BNB9I(:9F(;78(M>LLBRBPB;K(>O(B;L(8=:FBH:;B>9TTT68(;78=8O>=8(OB9FI(B9(;78(!"#$%$&'I(B9(7BL(L;=GNNP8(<B;7(;78(M=>RP8J(>O(8SBPI(1:9;2L(J>L;(8WMPBHB;(:9F(LKL;8J:;BH(:HH>G9;(>O(;78(<BPP(:9F(>O(7GJ:9(O=88F>J(d(:9(:HH>G9;(<7BH7I(B9(;G=9I(HP:=BOB8L(7BL(89;B=8(LKL;8J(>O(8;7BHLTAUX

3BPR8=(:=NG8L(;7:;(1:9;2L(8;7BH:P(;78>=K(BL(N=>G9F8F(B9(L8S8=:P(V8K(H>9H8M;LI(B9HPGFB9N(

7GJ:9(O=88F>J(:9F(=8:L>9T("8(9>;8L(;7:;I(G9;BP(;78(!"#$%$&'I(1:9;(F>8L(9>;(NBS8(7BL(

=8:F8=L(:(HP8:=(8WMP:9:;B>9(O>=(7><(;78L8(H>9H8M;L(:=8(B9;8==8P:;8FT(%78(HP:BJ(=8N:=FB9N(

=:FBH:P(8SBP(78PML(;>(=8L>PS8(;7BL(BLLG8(B9(1:9;2L(J>=:P(M7BP>L>M7K(R8H:GL8(B;(O8:;G=8L(7BL(

J>L;(B9(F8M;7(8WMP>=:;B>9(>O(;78(7GJ:9(<BPP(:9F(O=88F>JI(M:=;BHGP:=PK(B9(7BL(FBLHGLLB>9(>O(

;78(<BPP(:L(H>9LBL;B9N(>O(;<>(OG9H;B>9LQ(S$##"(:9F(S$##;X0=AUE

AUU 3BPR8=I(Y%78(&;7BH:P(3BN9BOBH:9H8(>O(1:9;2L(!"#$%$&'I`(HWWSBBT

AUX 3BPR8=I(Y%78(&;7BH:P(3BN9BOBH:9H8(>O(1:9;2L(!"#$%$&'I`(PWWWT

AUE 388(#PPBL>9I(>/'*M1(D+"&0B(&2(P0"".&E:(AUD(d(AXcT(%78(FBL;B9H;B>9(R8;<889(;78L8(;<>(OG9H;B>9L(>O(;78(<BPP(F>8L(:MM8:=(B9(;78(L8H>9F(T0$*$I-":(RG;(B;(BL(9>;(:L(;7>=>GN7PK(FBLHGLL8F(B9(;7BL(<>=V(:L(B;(BL(B9(;78(

Page 55: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

EC%7BL(98<(FBL;B9H;B>9(>O(;78(FG:P(OG9H;B>9(>O(;78(<BPPI(<7BH7(+(F8LH=BR8F(B9(F8;:BP(B9(

;78(L8H>9F(L8H;B>9(>O(;7BL(H7:M;8=I(78PML(;>(8WMP:B9(7><(;78(7GJ:9(<BPP(H:9(R>;7(R8(;78(

NBS8=(>O(;78(J>=:P(P:<I(>=(M=:H;BH:P(=8:L>9I(:9F(:PL>(O=88(;>(H7>>L8(<78;78=(;>(:H;(O=>J(;78(

J>=:P(P:<(<B;7>G;(=G99B9N(B9;>(;78(M=>RP8J(>O(G9O=88(BJJ>=:P(:H;B>9LT(1:9;(B9;=>FGH8L(

;7BL(FG:P(OG9H;B>9(G9F8=L;:9FB9N(>O(;78(<BPP(B9(>=F8=(;>(L7><(7><(;78(<BPP(BL(R>;7(FBSBF8F(

B9(B;L(OG9H;B>9L(:9F(G9B;8F(:L(:(<7>P8TAU[*aK(FBSBFB9N(;78L8(B9;>(;<>(OG9H;B>9L(>O(;78(<BPPI(

;78(<BPP(H:9(O=88PK(H7>>L8(;>(R8(G9O=88I(;7=>GN7(;78(M><8=(>O(S$##;X0:(<7BP8(L;BPP(R8B9N(

:G;>9>J>GL(:L(;78(P:<NBS8=I(;7=>GN7(;78(M><8=(>O(S$##"I(:9F(;7GL(L;BPP(R8(=8LM>9LBRP8(O>=(

;7:;(H7>BH8T(%78(<BPPI(;789I(F>8L(9>;(7:S8(;>(BN9>=8(B;L(=:;B>9:P(9:;G=8(:9F(:H;(B==:;B>9:PPK(

B9(>=F8=(;>(H7>>L8(8SBPT

68(H:9(OB9F(:9(8W:JMP8(>O(;7BL(FG:P(OG9H;B>9B9N(>O(;78(<BPP(B9(;78(!"#$%$&'=(6789(

1:9;(F8LH=BR8L(;78(H7>BH8(B9(<7BH7(:(M8=L>9(F8HBF8L(<78;78=(;>(J:V8(7BL(6"1$''-'%(N>>F(

>=(8SBPI(78(GL8L(;78(<>=F(S$##;X0(;>(F8LH=BR8(;7BL(OG9H;B>9(>O(;78(<BPPTAU\((#L(3BPR8=(

8WMP:B9LI(Y+9(>=F8=(;>(B9OPG89H8(S$##;X0:(<7BH7(BL(:(O:HGP;K(>O(F8LB=8I(S$##"(JGL;(R8(:RP8(;>(

:=>GL8(F8LB=8L(>=(:S8=LB>9L(B9(S$##;X0T(%78(O88PB9N(;7:;(H:9(R8(:=>GL8F(RK(S$##"(BL(H:PP8F(

J>=:P(O88PB9N(:9F(H>9LBL;L(B9(;78(2LBJMP8(=8LM8H;(O>=(;78(J>=:P(P:<T2`AUC(+9(L7>=;I(S$##;X0(

<BPP(>9PK(H7>>L8(;78(J>=:P(P:<(:L(;78(J:WBJ(>O(:9(:H;B>9(BO(S$##"(H:9(:=>GL8(=8LM8H;(O>=(

!"#$%$&'=("><8S8=I(1:9;(M=8L89;L(7BL(J>L;(8WMPBHB;(O>=JGP:;B>9(>O(;78(FBOO8=89H8L(R8;<889(;78L8(;<>(OG9H;B>9L(B9(;78(3"*/A+B1$F1(&2(3&0/#1I(<7BH7(<:L(<=B;;89(:O;8=(;78(!"#$%$&'=(67BP8(;78(S$##"(a(S$##;X0 (FBL;B9H;B>9(BL(9>;(>9PK(FBLHGLL8F(B9(;78(!"#$%$&':(B;(BL(;78(OB=L;(<>=V(B9(<7BH7(1:9;(R8NB9L(;>(GL8(;7BL(FBL;B9H;B>9(B9(:(J:]>=(<:KT

AU[ (#PPBL>9I(>/'*M1(D+"&0B(&2(P0"".&E:AXcT

AU\ Y4:9(V:99(9>H7(7B9eGL8;e89I(F:t(FB8(:GL(F8J(9:;r=:PBH789(":9N8(89;=LM=B9N89F8(.s7BNV8B;(>F8=(-9Os7BNV8B;(F8=(6BPPVr=I(F:L(J>=:PBLH78(^8L8;e(B9(L8B98(4:WBJ8(:GOeG987J89(>F8=(9BH7;I(F:L(NG;8(>F8=(RoL8("8=e(N899:9;(<8=F8`(?1:9;:!"#$%$&':(\QUDT@

AUC 3BPR8=I(Y%78(&;7BH:P(3BN9BOBH:9H8(>O(1:9;2L('8PBNB>9I`(HBS(d(HST

Page 56: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

E_;78(J>=:P(P:<(<B;7B9(;7:;(M8=L>92L(S$##;X0T(a8H:GL8(S$##;X0(BL(:(O:HGP;K(>O(F8LB=8I(B;(BL(

H:M:RP8(>O(R8B9N(J>S8F(R>;7(RK(=8LM8H;(O>=(;78(J>=:P(P:<(:9F(RK(B9HPB9:;B>9LI(LGH7(:L(

L8POhP>S8T(%7BL(BL(<7KI(8S89(;7>GN7(M:=;(>O(;78(7GJ:9(<BPP(BL(M=:H;BH:P(=8:L>9(B;L8POI(<7BH7(

BL(;78(NBS8=(>O(;78(J>=:P(P:<I(;78(<BPP(F>8L(9>;(:P<:KL(H7>>L8(;>(:H;(J>=:PPKT(%7BL(H7>BH8(

F8M89FL(>9(<7:;(S$##;X0(H7>>L8L(:L(B;L(J>;BS:;B>9=

%78(=:FBH:P(8SBP(HP:BJ(9>;(>9PK(8WMP:B9L(;78(M>LLBRBPB;K(>O(O=88PK(H7>>LB9N(8SBP(RG;(

:PL>(HP:=BOB8L(1:9;2L(8WMP:9:;B>9(>O(;78(L>G=H8(>O(J>=:P(8SBPT(+9(1:9;2L(<>=VL(M=B>=(;>(;78(

!"#$%$&':(B;(:MM8:=8F(;7:;(J>=:PPK(8SBP(:H;B>9L(>HHG==8F(R8H:GL8(:(M8=L>9(H7>L8(:(J:WBJ(

;7:;(<:L(J>;BS:;8F(RK(B9HPB9:;B>9L(:P>98(=:;78=(;7:9(RK(FG;KI(B9(8OO8H;(BN9>=B9N(;78B=(

=:;B>9:P(9:;G=8T(/BV8<BL8I(B;(:MM8:=8F(;7:;(J>=:PPK(N>>F(:H;B>9L(>HHG==8F(<789(:(M8=L>9(

H7>L8(:(J:WBJ(>O(FG;K(:9F(;>(L8;(:LBF8(;78B=(L89LBRP8(9:;G=8T(.>=(B9L;:9H8I(B9(;78(

60&-'.)&0;:(1:9;(;:PVL(:R>G;(:H;B>9L(:L(;7>GN7(;78K(:=8(8B;78=(M8=O>=J8F(O=>J(FG;K(>=(

O=>J(B9HPB9:;B>9TAU_(#L('BH7:=F(bT(a8=9L;8B9(M>B9;L(>G;I(1:9;2L(8W:JMP8L(>O(J>=:PPK(N>>F(

:H;B>9L(B9(;78(60&-'.)&0;(YLGNN8L;(;7:;(;78(M:=:FBNJ:;BH(8W:JMP8L(>O(:H;B9N(J>=:PPK(

>HHG=(>9PK(<789(;78=8(BL(:9(>S8=;(HP:L7(R8;<889(<7:;(<8(9:;G=:PPK(F8LB=8(:9F(<7:;(<8(

=8H>N9Be8(:L(>G=(FG;KI(<7:;(<8(>GN7;(;>(F>T`AUD(%7BL(H=8:;8L(;78(:MM8:=:9H8(;7:;(;78(

FBOO8=89H8(R8;<889(J>=:PPK(N>>F(:9F(8SBP(:H;B>9L(PB8L(B9(<7BH78S8=(LBF8(>O(>G=(9:;G=8(d(

8B;78=(=:;B>9:P(>=(L89LBRP8(d(<8(:PP><(;>(B9OPG89H8(>G=(<BPP(:9F(<7BH7(>98(<8(R=:HV8;T(+9(

;7BL(J>F8PI(>G=(=:;B>9:P(:9F(L89LBRP8(9:;G=8L(JGL;(:P<:KL(R8(:;(>FFL(<B;7(>98(:9>;78=(

R8H:GL8(;>(R8(J>=:PPK(N>>F(>=(8SBP(BL(;>(:H;(>9(:(J:WBJ(;7:;(>9PK(H>9;:B9L(;78(B9H89;BS8L(

>O(>98(:LM8H;(>O(>G=(9:;G=8I(=:;78=(;7:9(;78(>;78=T

AU_ 1:9;:(60&-'.)&0;:(EQXDC(d(EQXD_T

AUD a8=9L;8B9I(!/.$F/#(RK$#:A[T

Page 57: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

ED+9(>=F8=(;>(R8(J>=:PPK(N>>FI(:HH>=FB9N(;>(;7BL(G9F8=L;:9FB9NI(:(M8=L>9(<>GPF(988F(

;>(L>J87><(>S8=H>J8(>=(;=:9LH89F(7BL(L89LG>GL(9:;G=8T(#(7GJ:92L(L89LG>GL(9:;G=8I(>=(

B9HPB9:;B>9LI(;78=8O>=8I(:MM8:=L(;>(R8(;78(L>G=H8(>O(J>=:P(8SBPT("><8S8=I(1:9;(BL(HP8:=(;7:;(

;78=8(BL(9>;7B9N(8SBP(:R>G;(B9HPB9:;B>9L(;78JL8PS8LT(#L(#PP89(6>>F(9>;8LI

.=>J(<7:;(<8(7:S8(:P=8:FK(>RL8=S8F(:R>G;(;78(=8P:;B>9(R8;<889(=8:L>9(:9F(L89LBRBPB;K(B9(;78(H=B;BH:P(J>=:P(M7BP>L>M7KI(;78=8(:=8(:P=8:FK(N>>F(N=>G9FL(M=BJ:(O:HB8(O>=(F>GR;B9N(;7:;(B9HPB9:;B>9L(:P>98(H>9L;B;G;8(;78(>RL;:HP8L(7B9F8=B9N(H>9O>=JB;K(>O(;78(OB9B;8(=:;B>9:P(<BPP(<B;7(P:<T(%78(9:;G=:P(89FL(F8=BS8F(O=>J(B9HPB9:;B>9(:=8(9>;(:L(LGH7(>MM>L8F(;>(J>=:PB;KI(:9F(B9(O:H;(H>9L;B;G;8(:(M:=;(>O(;78(N>>F(O>=(J>=:PB;KI(<789(PBJB;8F(:9F(H>9FB;B>98F(RK(;78(<>=;7B98LL(;>(R8(7:MMKTAXc(

+9F88FI(:L(FBLHGLL8F(B9(;78(OB=L;(L8H;B>9(>O(;7BL(H7:M;8=I(1:9;(BL(HP8:=(;7:;(B9HPB9:;B>9LI(:L(:(

M:=;(>O(>G=(B99:;8(M=8FBLM>LB;B>9(;>(N>>FI(<8=8(H=8:;8F(O>=(;78(N>>FT(+O(B9HPB9:;B>9L(:=8(

H=8:;8F(O>=(N>>FI(B;(BL(9>;(HP8:=(<7K(<8(<>GPF(988F(;>(R=:HV8;(;78JI(>=(BN9>=8(;78JI(B9(

>=F8=(;>(R8(J>=:PPK(N>>FT(67BP8(B9HPB9:;B>9L(H>GPF(R8(:(98H8LL:=K(M:=;(>O(;78(L>G=H8(>O(

J>=:P(8SBPI(B9L>O:=(:L(1:9;(9>;8L(;7:;(B9HPB9:;B>9L(H:9(R8(GL8F(O>=(8B;78=(N>>F(>=(8SBPI(;78K(

H:99>;(R8(:(LGOOBHB89;(L>G=H8(>O(J>=:P(8SBPTAXA

&S89(BO(;78(B9HPB9:;B>9L(<8=8(;78(L>G=H8(>O(8SBPI(B;(<>GPF(R8(BJM>LLBRP8(;>(LBJMPK(

BN9>=8(;78J(>=(R=:HV8;(;78J(>OO(B9(L>J8(<:KT(#L(7GJ:9LI(<8(:=8(:P<:KL(LGR]8H;(;>(R>;7(

=8:L>9(:9F(B9HPB9:;B>9(R8H:GL8(R>;7(:=8(M:=;L(>O(>G=(9:;G=8I(O=>J(RB=;7TAXU(#L(M:=;(>O(>G=(

9:;G=8I(<8(H:99>;(H7>>L8(;>(=8J>S8(8B;78=(>O(;78L8T(%78=8O>=8I(;>(H>9L;=G8(J>=:P(

N>>F98LL(:9F(J>=:P(8SBP(:L(;78(M=8L89H8(>O(J:WBJL(;7:;(7:S8(B9H89;BS8L(;7:;(H>J8(8B;78=(

O=>J(;78(J>=:P(P:<(>=(O=>J(B9HPB9:;B>9LI(=8LM8H;BS8PKI(;789(<8(<>GPF(:P<:KL(R8I(:;(;78(

AXc #PP89(6T(6>>FI(>/'*M1(3&0/#(!"#$%$&':(?+;7:H:Q(!>=98PP(-9BS8=LB;K($=8LLI(ADCc@Q(AcDT

AXA 388(6>>FI(>/'*M1(3&0/#(!"#$%$&':(Ac_(d(AcDT

AXU '8H:PP(1:9;2L(FBLHGLLB>9I(B9(;78(!"#$%$&':(=8N:=FB9N(;78(M=8FBLM>LB;B>9L(;>(N>>FT(68I(:L(7GJ:9LI(9:;G=:PPK(7:S8(:(M=8FBLM>LB;B>9(;>(:9BJ:PB;KI(<7BH7(BL(>G=(L89LBRP8(B9HPB9:;B>9LI(:9F(:(M=8FBLM>LB;B>9(;>(7GJ:9B;KI(<7BH7(BL(>G=(=:;B>9:P(9:;G=8(?\QU\@T

Page 58: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

[cL:J8(;BJ8I(R>;7(J>=:PPK(N>>F(:9F(J>=:PPK(8SBP(R8H:GL8(<8(:=8(:P<:KL(B9OPG89H8F(RK(R>;7(

;KM8L(>O(B9H89;BS8LTAXX(#L(9>;8F(B9(;78(OB=L;(L8H;B>9(>O(;7BL(H7:M;8=I(1:9;(=GP8L(>G;(;78(

M>LLBRBPB;K(>O(R8B9N(R>;7(J>=:PPK(N>>F(:9F(8SBPT("GJ:9L(JGL;(8B;78=(R8(J>=:PPK(N>>F(>=(

J>=:PPK(8SBPT

.>=;G9:;8PKI(;78(:9L<8=(;>(;7BL(M=>RP8J(>O(P>H:;B9N(;78(L>G=H8(>O(J>=:P(8SBP(H:9(R8(

O>G9F(B9(;78(!"#$%$&'=AXE(#L(4BH7:PL>9(9>;8LI

68(H:9(R8NB9(;>(L88(;7:;(J>=:P(8SBP(<BPP(7:S8(B;L(J>L;(LM8HBOBH(P>HGL(B9(;78(PB9V(R8;<889(O=88F>J(:9F(J:WBJhJ:VB9NT($:=;(>O(;78(BJM>=;:9H8(>O(;78(!"#$%$&'(=8LBF8L(M=8HBL8PK(B9(;78(O:H;(;7:;I(B9(;7BL(R>>VI(1:9;(<>=VL(>G;(;7BL(PB9V:N8(:9F(B;L(BJMPBH:;B>9L(B9(:(J>=8(LGL;:B98F(<:K(;7:9(:9K<78=8(8PL8I(;78=8RK(OBPPB9N(>G;(O8:;G=8L(>O(7BL(J>=:P(M7BP>L>M7K(;7:;(7:F(M=8SB>GLPK(R889(LV8;H7K(>=(:JRBNG>GLTAX[

3M8HBOBH:PPKI(1:9;(M=>SBF8L(HP:=B;K(;>(<7:;(B;(J8:9L(;>(O>=J(:(J>=:PPK(N>>F(>=(8SBP(

J:WBJT(+9(F>B9N(L>I(78(BL(:RP8(;>(P>H:;8(;78(L>G=H8(>O(J>=:P(8SBP(B9(L>J8;7B9N(>;78=(;7:9(

;78(B9HPB9:;B>9L(d(;7:;(BLI(B9(>G=(O=88(H7>BH8(;>(J:V8(>G=(M=>M89LB;K(;>(8SBP(:9(B99:;8(M:=;(

>O(>G=(7GJ:9(9:;G=8T

+9(;78(!"#$%$&':(1:9;(8WMPBHB;PK(F89B8L(<7:;(:MM8:=8F(;>(R8(7BL(BJMPBHB;(M>LB;B>9(B9(

7BL(8:=PB8=(H=B;BH:P(M7BP>L>M7KI(;7:;(L>J8(J:WBJL(LBJMPK(7:S8(J>=:PPK(N>>F(H>9;89;(<7BP8(

>;78=L(7:S8(8SBP(H>9;89;T(#L(4BH7:PL>9(9>;8LI(J>=:P(8SBP(:9F(N>>F98LL(:=8(9>;(:(J:;;8=(>O(

;78(H>9;89;(>O(J:WBJLI(RG;(:(J:;;8=(>O(;78(O>=J(>O(J:WBJLTAX\(%7:;(BLI(J:WBJL(:=8(9>;(

AXX (4BH7:PL>9I(P/##"'(P0"".&E:(XE(d(X[T

AXE 4BH7:PL>9(8JM7:LBe8L(;7:;(<7:;(1:9;(<=B;8L(B9(;78(!"#$%$&'(:R>G;(J>=:P(8SBP(:9F(N>>F98LL(:9F(J:WBJhJ:VB9N(BL(9>;(L>(JGH7(Y:(H7:9N8(>=(:P;8=:;B>9(>O(7BL(R:LBH(H=B;BH:P(;8:H7B9NTTT:L(B;(BL(:(F88M89B9N(>O(:(H89;=:P(B9LBN7;(=G99B9N(;7=>GN7(;78(P&-'./*$&'1(&2(*+"(3"*/A+B1$F1(&2(3&0/#1(:9F(;78(T0$*$I-"(&2(C0/F*$F/#(!"/1&'`(?P/##"'(P0"".&E:(XE@T(67:;(1:9;(L:KL(B9(;78(!"#$%$&':(;789I(F>8L(9>;(L>(JGH7(=8MP:H8(1:9;2L(8:=PB8=(SB8<(RG;(J8=8PK(HP:=BOB8L(:9F(78PML(;>(=8L>PS8(;89LB>9L(B9(7BL(8:=PB8=(<=B;B9NLT

AX[ (4BH7:PL>9I(P/##"'(P0"".&E:(XET

AX\ (+RBFI(X[T

Page 59: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

[AN>>F(>=(8SBP(R8H:GL8(:(M8=L>9(BL(:RP8(;>(R=:HV8;(>OO(8B;78=(=8:L>9(>=(B9HPB9:;B>9L(:9F(>9PK(

R8(B9OPG89H8F(RK(>98(>O(;78L8T(':;78=I(;78(J:WBJL(>O(7GJ:9L(:P<:KL(H>9;:B9(R>;7(

B9H89;BS8L(>O(=8:L>9(:9F(>O(B9HPB9:;B>9(R8H:GL8(<8(:=8(:P<:KL(B9OPG89H8F(RK(R>;7(>O(;78L8(

:;(;78(L:J8(;BJ8TAXC(#L(9>;8F(B9(;78(OB=L;(L8H;B>9(>O(;7BL(H7:M;8=I(1:9;(<=B;8L(B9(;78(

!"#$%$&'(;7:;I(<789(:(M8=L>9(H7>>L8L(:(J:WBJ(>O(:9(:H;B>9I(78(H7>>L8L(9>;(GM>9(<7BH7(

L>P8(B9H89;BS8(;>(:H;(:9F(<7BH7(;>(FBLH:=F(RG;(7><(;>(>=F8=(;78L8(;<>(B9H89;BS8LI(>=(<7BH7(

;>(M=B>=B;Be8T(%7:;(BLI(78(8B;78=(LGR>=FB9:;8L(B9H89;BS8L(>O(;78(J>=:P(P:<(>=(B9H89;BS8L(>O(

FG;KT

%7BL(HP:=BOBH:;B>9(>O(J:WBJhJ:VB9N(78PML(GL(;>(P>H:;8(;78(L>G=H8(>O(J>=:P(8SBPT(

%7BL(G9F8=L;:9FB9N(78PML(GL(;>(L88(;7:;(B9HPB9:;B>9L(:=8(:(98H8LL:=K(RG;(9>;(LGOOBHB89;(

L>G=H8(>O(8SBPT(67BP8(<8(H8=;:B9PK(JGL;(7:S8(B9HPB9:;B>9L(B9(>=F8=(;>(R8(8SBPI(B;(BL(B9(;78(

H7>BH8(>O(LGR>=FB9:;B9N(B9H89;BS8L(>O(;78(J>=:P(P:<(;>(;78(B9H89;BS8L(>O(;7>L8(B9HPB9:;B>9L(

;7:;(+(F>(:9(8SBP(:H;B>9T(#L(6>>F(8WMP:B9LI

+;(BL(9>;(RK(7:SB9N(B9HPB9:;B>9L(;7:;(<8(R8H>J8(8SBPI(;789I(RG;(=:;78=(RK(:(20""(/F* (&2(F+&$F"(B9(<7BH7(<8(LGR>=FB9:;8(;78(B9H89;BS8L(>O(FG;K(;>(;7>L8(M=>SBF8F(RK(;78L8(B9HPB9:;B>9LT(%78(J>=:P(>RL;:HP8L(B9(7GJ:9(9:;G=8(:=8(9>;(H>9L;B;G;8F(RK(B9HPB9:;B>9LI(RK(7GJ:9(OB9B;GF8(>=(L89LBRBPB;K(:L(LGH7I(RG;(RK(:(LM8HB:P(H7:=:H;8=BL;BH(>O(J:92L(O=88(M><8=(>O(H7>BH8(?S$##;X0@TAX_

%7BL(O=88(:H;(>O(H7>BH8I(<7BH7(BL(;78(L>G=H8(>O(8SBPI(BL(;78(H7>BH8(;>(7:S8(:(M=>M89LB;K(;>(

8SBPI(>=(:9(8SBP(6"1$''-'%T(1:9;2L(B9;=>FGH;B>9(>O(;78(HP:BJ(;7:;(:PP(7GJ:9L(:=8(

G9BS8=L:PPK(=:FBH:PPK(8SBPI(;789I(BL(GP;BJ:;8PK(7><(78(8WMP:B9L(;78(LGOOBHB89;(H>9FB;B>9(O>=(

7GJ:9(J>=:P(8SBPT

AXC (6>>FI(>/'*M1(3&0/#(!"#$%$&':(AAAT

AX_ (6>>FI(>/'*M1(3&0/#(!"#$%$&':AAUT

Page 60: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

[U1%"(9'/)%"

68(H:9(L88(9><(;7:;(;78(!"#$%$&':(:9F(;78(HP:BJ(;7:;(:PP(7GJ:9L(:=8(=:FBH:PPK(8SBPI(

B9(M:=;BHGP:=I(8WMP:B9L(:9F(HP:=BOB8L(;78L8(;<>(J:]>=(M:=;L(>O(1:9;2L(J>=:P(M7BP>L>M7KQ(;78(

M>LLBRBPB;K(>O(O=88PK(H7>>LB9N(8SBP(:9F(;78(P>H:;B>9(>O(;78(L>G=H8(>O(8SBP(B9(7GJ:9LT(+;(<:L(

>9PK(<B;7(1:9;2L(B9S8L;BN:;B>9(B9;>(;78(J>=:P(L;:;GL(>O(7GJ:9(9:;G=8(:9F(7BL(H>9HPGLB>9(

=8N:=FB9N(=:FBH:P(8SBP(;7:;(78(H>GPF(8WMP:B9(:9F(HP:=BOK(;78L8(HP:BJL(J:F8(B9(7BL(8:=PB8=(

M=:H;BH:P(<>=VLT(.>=(;7BL(=8:L>9I(B;(BL(HP8:=(;7:;(;78(H=B;BHL(<7>(<=B;8(>OO(;78(!"#$%$&'(:9F(

B;L(FBLHGLLB>9(>O(=:FBH:P(8SBP(:L(B9H>78=89;(>=(9>9hM7BP>L>M7BH:P(J:V8(G9O>G9F8F(HP:BJL(

:R>G;(;7BL(<>=VT(a8H:GL8(>O(;7BLI(<8(F>(7:S8(=8:L>9(;>(G;BPBe8(1:9;2L(:=NGJ89;L(B9(;78(

!"#$%$&'(;>(78PM(GL(;>(HP:=BOK(>G=(=8:FB9NL(>O(7BL(J>=:P(M7BP>L>M7KT(+9(;7BL(98W;(H7:M;8=I(+(

<BPP(B9;=>FGH8(K8;(:9>;78=(<:K(;7:;(<8(J:K(R8(:RP8(;>(GL8(;78(!"#$%$&'(;>(HP:=BOK(M:=;L(>O(

1:9;2L(8;7BHLI(RK(OBPPB9N(B9(N:ML(B9(7BL(;78>=K(>O(J>=:P(F8S8P>MJ89;T

Page 61: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

!"#$%&'(%)*

%"&(!"#$%$&'(+('*,&(-.(%"&(/&0&,*$1&.%(*2(3#.%4+(%"&*'5(*2(

1*'#,(-1$'*0&1&.%

!"#$%&'(#)%"

-6(!789:;<(*6;=(-(>;?;6>;>(:7;(:7;@A@(:78:(386:4@(9<;@;6:8:AB6(B?(:7;(9<BCD;E(B?(

<8>AF8D(;GAD(7;D9@(:B(FD8<A?H(86>(;I9D8A6(98<:@(B?(7A@(EB<8D(97ADB@B97HJ(#@(6B:;>(A6(:78:(

F789:;<=(:7;(EB@:(9B9KD8<(L8H(B?(>;?;6>A6M(:7A@(FD8AE(A6(:7;(@;FB6>8<H(DA:;<8:K<;(78@(C;;6(

:B(@7BL(:78:(386:4@(FD8AE(8CBK:(:7;(K6AG;<@8DA:H(B?(<8>AF8D(;GAD(N(86>(:7;(FD8AE@(

@K<<BK6>A6M(A:(N(7;D9(:B(;I9D8A6(:7;(9B@@ACADA:H(86>(@BK<F;(B?(EB<8D(;GADJ("BL;G;<=(8@(-(

LADD(8<MK;(A6(:7A@(F789:;<=(:7;<;(A@(<;8@B6(:B(C;DA;G;(:78:(:7;(!)*+,+-.(F86(7;D9(K@(:B(

;I9D8A6(86>(FD8<A?H(H;:(86B:7;<(98<:(B?(386:4@(EB<8D(97ADB@B97HO(7A@(:7;B<H(B?(EB<8D(

>;G;DB9E;6:=(B<(7BL(8(7KE86(F86(C;FBE;(EB<8DDH(MBB>J

-:(A@(M;6;<8DDH(<;FBM6AP;>(:78:(:7;<;(8<;(@BE;(>A??;<;6F;@(C;:L;;6(386:4@(;8<DH(86>(

D8:;<(L<A:A6M@(B6(EB<8D(;>KF8:AB6(86>(>;G;DB9E;6:JQ("BL;G;<=(G;<H(DA::D;(8::;6:AB6(78@(

C;;6(98A>(:B(:7;(<;8@B6@(L7H(:7;@;(F786M;@(EAM7:(78G;(8<A@;6JR(-6(:7A@(F789:;<=(-(LADD(

?BFK@(K9B6(B6;(F786M;(A6(98<:AFKD8<=(L7AF7(78@(6B:(C;;6(9BA6:;>(:B(;I9DAFA:DH(A6(:7;

Q +;;(186?<;>(3K;76=(S386:(B6(&>KF8:AB6=(#6:7<B9BDBMH=(86>(&:7AF@=T(A6(/0.120.32"34501+-.62$.1)787)101+-.920.32:-;;).107<=2;>J(3D8@('B:7(86>(!7<A@()J(+K<9<;686:(U.;L(5B<VO('BK:D;>M;=(RWQRXJ

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

_`

Page 62: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

_a(@;FB6>8<H(DA:;<8:K<;O(8(@7A?:(?<BE(8(FB6F;<6(LA:7(7BL(:B(M<8>K8DDH(E8V;(8(9;<@B6(EB<8DDH(

MBB>(A6(:7;(@;6@;(B?(8F:A6M(B6(MBB>(E8IAE@(A6(98<:AFKD8<(F8@;@=(A6(:7;(;8<DA;<(L<A:A6M@(B6(

EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:=(:B(8(FB6F;<6(LA:7(8(VA6>(B?(@A6MKD8<(EB<8D(:<86@?B<E8:AB6(:78:(LADD(

E8V;(8F:A6M(B6(MBB>(E8IAE@(A6(98<:AFKD8<(F8@;@(9B@@ACD;=(A6(:7;(D8:;<(L<A:A6M@(B6(EB<8D(

>;G;DB9E;6:J(-6(B<>;<(:B(>;EB6@:<8:;(:7A@(F786M;=(-(LADD(:8V;(:LB(@8E9D;@(?<BE(L78:(A@(

FB6@A>;<;>(:B(C;(386:4@(?B<E8D(8FFBK6:(B?(EB<8D(;>KF8:AB6=(7A@(/BF:<A6;@(B?(1;:7B>(

U@)1A-3).*)A7).XJ`(-(LADD(FBE98<;(:7;(/BF:<A6;(B?(1;:7B>(?<BE(B6;(B?(7A@(;8<DA;<(EB<8D(

LB<V@=(:7;(:7+1+B4)2-C2D7051+50*2!)09-.2UQ\]]X=(:B(:7;(/BF:<A6;(B?(1;:7B>(A6(B6;(B?(7A@(

D8:;<(EB<8D(LB<V@=(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*92UQ\[\X?2-6(:7A@(FBE98<A@B6=(-(LADD(@7BL(:78:(

:7A@(@7A?:(899;8<@(A6(8(:LB?BD>(L8HO(UQX(A6(:7;(L8H(:78:(386:(K@;@(;I8E9D;@(A6(;8F7(LB<V(

86>(URX(A6(8(EBG;(?<BE(>A@FK@@AB6(B?(EB<8D(AE9<BG;E;6:(8@(8(@BD;DH(M<8>K8D(9<BF;@@(:B(8(

>;@F<A9:AB6(B?(A:(8@(8D@B(<;bKA<A6M(8(@A6MKD8<(:<86@?B<E8:AG;(F7BAF;J

#?:;<(ADDK@:<8:A6M(:7A@(V;H(>A??;<;6F;(C;:L;;6(:7;@;(:LB(LB<V@=(-(LADD(8<MK;(:78:(

:7A@(@7A?:(A6(386:4@(8FFBK6:(B?(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:(F86(C;(;I9D8A6;>(CH(7A@(FD8AE(8CBK:(:7;(

K6AG;<@8DA:H(B?(<8>AF8D(;GAD(A6(:7;(!)*+,+-.=2L7AF7(L8@(9KCDA@7;>(A6(:7;(@986(B?(:AE;(

C;:L;;6(:7;@;(:LB(LB<V@(UQ\[aX?2%78:(A@=(-(8<MK;(:78:(:7A@(A@(86B:7;<(L8H(A6(L7AF7(:7;(

!)*+,+-.2?K<:7;<(FD8<A?A;@(386:4@(;:7AF@J(-(LADD(@7BL=(:7<BKM7(98<8DD;D@(A6(D86MK8M;(86>(

:B9AF@(A6(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*9286>(:7;(!)*+,+-.=(:78:(:7A@(>A??;<;6F;(C;:L;;6(386:4@(

;8<DA;<(86>(D8:;<(8FFBK6:@(B?(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:(A@(<BB:;>(A6(386:4@(@BDK:AB6@(:B(

BG;<FBEA6M(<8>AF8D(;GADJ!%78:(A@=(C;F8K@;(B?(:7;(6;;>(:B(BG;<FBE;(<8>AF8D(;GAD=(8(9<BCD;E(

:78:(>A>(6B:(8<A@;(K6:AD(:7;2!)*+,+-.=(386:(78>(:B(8D:;<(7A@(8FFBK6:(B?(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:(A6(

` +;;(cJ(2;DAFA:8@(1K6P;D=(S386:(B6(1B<8D(&>KF8:AB6=(B<(4&6DAM7:;6E;6:4(86>(:7;(,AC;<8D(#<:@=T(EA)2!)F+)G2-C2@)108A<9+592_\J(QJ(U+;9:J=(RWW`XO(a_(N(adJ((";<;=(@7;(6B:;@(:78:(:7;(/BF:<A6;@(B?(1;:7B>=(?<BE(:7;(;6>@(B?(386:4@(E8eB<(L<A:A6M@=(8<;(:H9AF8DDH(FB6@A>;<;>(:B(C;(7A@(?B<E8D(8FFBK6:(B?(EB<8D(;>KF8:AB6J

Page 63: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

__B<>;<(:B(8FFBEEB>8:;(:7A@(BC@:8FD;(:B(EB<8D(MBB>6;@@J(Y;F8K@;(B?(A:@(:<86@?B<E8:AG;(<BD;=(

L;(@7BKD>(K:ADAP;(:7;2!)*+,+-.2A6(B<>;<(:B(7;D9(K@(C;::;<(K6>;<@:86>(386:4@(8FFBK6:(B?(

EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:J

*)++,$,"(,-.,#/,,"-#0,-1/%-*%(#$)",2-%+-3,#0%&

#@(-(78G;(E;6:AB6;>(8CBG;=(A:(A@(M;6;<8DDH(<;FBM6AP;>(:78:(:7;<;(A@(8(F786M;(BG;<(

:AE;(A6(386:4@(:7;B<H(B?(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:J(-6(B<>;<(:B(>A@9D8H(:7A@(F786M;=(-(LADD(

FBE98<;(7A@(>A@FK@@AB6@(B?(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:(?<BE(7A@(;8<DA;<(L<A:A6M@(:B(7A@(D8:;<(

L<A:A6M@J(+9;FA?AF8DDH=(-(LADD(DBBV(:B(:LB(@8E9D;(LB<V@O(:7;(:7+1+B4)2-C2D7051+50*2!)09-.2

UQ\]]X=(L7AF7(A@(B6;(B?(386:4@(?A<@:(E8eB<(LB<V@(B6(EB<8D(97ADB@B97H=286>(:7;(

@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*92UQ\[\X=(L7AF7(A@(B6;(B?(:7;(D8@:(LB<V@(:78:(386:(L<B:;(C;?B<;(7A@(

>;8:7?21B<;(@9;FA?AF8DDH=(-(LADD(DBBV(:B(:7;(/BF:<A6;@(B?(1;:7B>(U@)1A-3).*)A7).X(A6(;8F7(

B?(:7;@;(LB<V@J(386:4@(/BF:<A6;@(B?(1;:7B>(?8DD(8:(:7;(;6>(B?(EB@:(B?(7A@(E8eB<(LB<V@a(

86>(FB6:8A6(386:4@(GA;L(B6(7BL(:7;(9<A6FA9D;@(B?(7A@(F<A:AF8D(97ADB@B97H(F86(C;(:8KM7:(:B(

9K9AD@J-cJ(2;DAFA:8@(1K6P;D(L<A:;@(:78:(S:7;@;(9B<:AB6@(f:7;(/BF:<A6;@(B?(1;:7B>g(B?(:7;(

:;I:@(:8V;6(:BM;:7;<(8<;(386:4@(?B<E8D=(F<A:AF8D(8FFBK6:(B?(EB<8D(;>KF8:AB6JT_(YH(K:ADAPA6M(

:7;@;(LB<V@=(-(LADD(A>;6:A?H(A6(L78:(L8H@(386:4@(:7A6VA6M(8CBK:(7BL(7KE86@(F86(FBE;(:B(

C;(EB<8DDH(MBB>(F786M;@(BG;<(:AE;=(86>(:7;6(-(LADD(EBG;(:B(EH(8<MKE;6:(:78:(FD8AE@(:78:(

386:(E8V;@(A6(:7;(!)*+,+-.28<;(:7;(F8K@;(B?(:7A@(F786M;J

%7;(S/BF:<A6;(B?(1;:7B>(B?($K<;($<8F:AF8D(';8@B6T(F86(C;(?BK6>(8:(:7;(;6>(B?(:7;(

a +;;(+:;?86B(Y8FA6=(S%7;(1;86A6M(B?(:7;(:7+1+B4)2-C2D7051+50*2!)09-.2?B<(1B<8D(Y;A6M@O(:7;(/BF:<A6;(B?(1;:7B>(B?($K<;($<8F:AF8D(';8@B6=T(A6(/0.1(92!<A:AbK;(B?($<8F:AF8D(';8@B6O(H2:7+1+50*2%4+3)=2;>J(#6><;L@(';8:7(86>(h;6@(%AEE;<E86(U!8EC<A>M;O(!8EC<A>M;(Z6AG;<@A:H($<;@@=(RWQWXJ(-6(:7A@(9A;F;=(Y8FA6(;I9D8A6@(L7H(386:(L<B:;(8(/BF:<A6;(B?(1;:7B>(8:(:7;(;6>(B?(EB@:(B?(7A@(E8eB<(LB<V@J(%7;(CB>H(B?(:7;(LB<V(L8@(A6:;6>;>(:B(;I9D8A6(S8(:7;B<H(B?(:7;(FBE9B6;6:@(B?(<;8@B6A6M=T(L7AD;(:7;(/BF:<A6;(B?(1;:7B>(L8@(A6:;6>;>(:B(S@7BL(7BL(<KD;@(EK@:(C;(FB<<;F:DH(899DA;>T(UQ[]XJ(Y8FA6(L<A:;@(:78:(;8F7(/BF:<A6;(B?(1;:7B>(SA@(8>89:;>(:B(:7;(@9;FA?AF(FB6:;I:(:B(L7AF7(A:(A@(899DA;>T(86>(S@K99DA;@(A6@:<KF:AB6@(B6(7BL(:7;(>A@FA9DA6;4@(8AE(A@(:B(C;(8F7A;G;>T(UQ[[XJ

_ 1K6P;D=(S386:(B6(1B<8D(&>KF8:AB6=T(a_(N(adJ

Page 64: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

_d@;FB6>(:7+1+B4)?2-:(A@(A6(:7A@(@;F:AB6(:78:(386:(;I9D8A6@(7BL(SB6;(F86(9<BGA>;(:7;(D8L@(B?(

9K<;(9<8F:AF8D(<;8@B6(LA:7(055)992:B(:7;(7KE86(EA6>(86>(+.C*4).5)2B6(A:@(E8IAE@=(:78:(A@=(

:7;(L8H(A6(L7AF7(B6;(F86(E8V;(BCe;F:AG;DH(9<8F:AF8D(<;8@B6(94IJ)51+F)*<29<8F:AF8D(8@(

L;DDJTd(#@(+:;?86B(Y8FA6(;I9D8A6@=(386:(K@;@(:7A@(@;F:AB6(:B(@7BL(S7BL(87051+50* 2

FB6F;9:@(86>(9<A6FA9D;@(8<;(:B(C;(9K:(A6:B(9<8F:AF;JT\(386:(>B;@(:7A@(CH(@7BLA6M(7BL(B6;(

F86(9<BGA>;(:7;(EB<8D(D8L(8FF;@@(:B(:7;(7KE86(EA6>(86>(LADD=(7BL(B6;(F86(E8V;(

BCe;F:AG;(9<8F:AF8D(<;8@B6(@KCe;F:AG;DH(9<8F:AF8D=(86>(7BL(BK<(8F:AB6@(F86(C;(E8>;(:B(6B:(

B6DH(8FFB<>(LA:7(:7;(EB<8D(D8L(CK:(C;(EB:AG8:;>(CH(:7;(EB<8D(D8L(A:@;D?J](-6(@7B<:=(386:(A@(

?BFK@;>(B6(;I9D8A6A6M(7BL(:7;(D8L@(B?(9K<;(9<8F:AF8D(<;8@B6(F86(FBE;(:B(AE98F:(BK<(

7KE86(LADD@(86>=(:7K@=(BK<(E8IAEiE8VA6MJ

%7;(/BF:<A6;(B?(1;:7B>(?<BE(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*92?8DD@(8:(:7;(;6>(B?(:7;(

/BF:<A6;(B?(0A<:K;=(:7;(@;FB6>(98<:(B?(:7A@(LB<VJ(386:(>AGA>;@(:7A@(/BF:<A6;(A6:B(:LB(98<:@O(

S%;8F7A6M(&:7AF@T(86>(S&:7AF8D(#@F;:AF@JT(%7;(MB8D(B?(:7A@(LB<V(A@(:B(;I9D8A6(7BL(GA<:K;=(

B<(EB<8D(MBB>6;@@=[(F86(C;(8FbKA<;>JQW(-6(S%;8F7A6M(&:7AF@=T(386:(;I9D8A6@(7BL(8(9;<@B6(

d 386:=(!$<'=(_OQ_QJ(USLA;(E86(>;6(c;@;:P;6(>;<(<;A6;6(9<8V:A@F7;6(0;<6K6?:(&A6M86M(A6(>8@(E;6@F7DAF7;(c;Ej:(&A6?DKk(8K?(>A;(18IAE;6(>;@@;DC;6(G;<@F78??;6=(>JAJ(>A;(BCe;V:AG(9<8V:A@F7;(0;<6K6?:(8KF7(@KCe;V:AG(9<8V:A@F7(E8F7;6(Vl66;JTX

\ Y8FA6=(S%7;(1;86A6M(B?(:7;(:7+1+B4)2-C2D7051+50*2!)09-.=T(RWWJ

] %7A@(:7<;;(98<:(?B<EKD8:AB6(B?(386:4@(BG;<8<F7A6M(MB8D(A6(:7A@(/BF:<A6;(B?(1;:7B>(A@(:8V;6(?<BE(Y8FA6=(S%7;(1;86A6M(B?(:7;(:7+1+B4)2-C2D7051+50*2!)09-.=T(RWWJ("A@(?A68D(?B<EKD8:AB6=(L7AF7(-(8<:AFKD8:;(8@(8F:A6M(6B:(B6DH(A6(8FFB<>(LA:7(>K:H(CK:(?<BE(>K:H=(A@(6B:(@:8:;>(A6(:7;@;(LB<>@J

[ )7AD;(:7;<;(78@(C;;6(<;F;6:(@;FB6>8<H(DA:;<8:K<;(:78:(;I9DB<;@(:7;(6K86F;>(>A@:A6F:AB6(C;:L;;6(:7;(FB6F;9:@(B?(GA<:K;(86>(EB<8D(MBB>6;@@(A6(M;6;<8D(U+;;(2;DAFA:8@(c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bK8:;>J

QW +;;(386:=(11=2dOa\\J

Page 65: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

_\F86(C;(:8KM7:(:B(8>B9:(GA<:KBK@=(B<(EB<8D=(E8IAE@=QQ(L7AD;(A6(S&:7AF8D(#@F;:AF@=T(7;(

>A@FK@@;@(:7;(8@9;F:@(B?(GA<:K;(:78:(F866B:(C;(:8KM7:JQR(%7;@;(8@9;F:@(A6FDK>;(:7;(9<B9;<(

?<8E;(B?(EA6>=(@KF7(8@(F7;;<?KD6;@@=(:78:(EB<8DA:H(<;bKA<;@JQ`(-6(:7A@(LB<V=(386:(;I9D8A6@(

7BL(:B(>;G;DB9(8(@:K>;6:4@(K6>;<@:86>A6M(B?(EB<8D(FB6F;9:@=(L7AF7(F86(C;(:8KM7:(:7<BKM7(

EB<8D(;>KF8:AB6J(%7;6(8(@:K>;6:(EK@:(>;FA>;=(B6(7A@(BL6=(:B(8F:K8DDH(8>B9:(EB<8D(

9<A6FA9D;@=(B<(F7BB@;(EB<8DDH(MBB>(E8IAE@JQa

#@(L;(F86(@;;(?<BE(:7A@(C<A;?(BG;<GA;L=(:7;(MB8D@(B?(:7;@;(LB<V@(G8<H(@DAM7:DH(A6(

>;:8AD@(CK:(78G;(8(FB6@A@:;6:(BG;<8<F7A6M(8AE(N(:B(@7BL(7BL(7KE86@(F86(8F7A;G;(EB<8D(

MBB>6;@@=(;A:7;<(:7<BKM7(;>KF8:AB6(86>(FKD:AG8:AB6(B<(:7<BKM7(:7;A<(BL6(8>B9:AB6(B?(

F;<:8A6(9<A6FA9D;@J(386:(A@(FB6F;<6;>=(A6(CB:7=(8CBK:(E8VA6M(7KE86@(EB<8DDH(MBB>=(86>(

7;(@8H@(A6(CB:7(LB<V@(:78:(:7A@(F86(C;(8F7A;G;>(CH(FBEA6M(:B(?B<EKD8:;(86>(F7BB@;(MBB>(

E8IAE@J(&G;6(386:4@(@:8:;E;6:(A6(:7;(/BF:<A6;(B?(1;:7B>(?<BE(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C 2

@-70*92:78:(F;<:8A6(98<:@(B?(GA<:K;(F866B:(C;(:8KM7:(A@(6B:=(B6(:7;(@K<?8F;=(A6FB6@A@:;6:(

LA:7(:7;(/BF:<A6;(B?(1;:7B>(?<BE(:7;(@;FB6>(:7+1+B4)J(";(A@(E;<;DH(E8VA6M(;I9DAFA:(

L78:(L8@(:8V;6(?B<(M<86:;>(A6(:7;(@;FB6>(:7+1+B4)2O2:78:(8(9;<@B6(F866B:(C;(FB;<F;>(B<(

FBE9;DD;>(A6:B(F7BB@A6M(EB<8DDH(MBB>(E8IAE@JQ_(%7;H(EK@:(C;(F7B@;6(?<BE(>K:H(8DB6;JQd

QQ -CA>J

QR 386:=(11=2dOa]a(N(dOa]_J

Q` +;;(+K<9<;686:=(S386:4@(!B6:<ACK:AB6(:B(1B<8D(&>KF8:AB6=T(Q(N(RJ

Qa +;;(+K<9<;686:=(S386:4@(!B6:<ACK:AB6(:B(1B<8D(&>KF8:AB6=T(](N([(86>(!7<A@:A6;(3B<@M88<>=(:7)01+.,21A)2/+.,3-;2-C2".39=2U!8EC<A>M;O(!8EC<A>M;(Z6AG;<@A:H($<;@@=(Q[[[XO(RRWJ

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

Qd +;;(+K<9<;686:=(S386:4@(!B6:<ACK:AB6(:B(1B<8D(&>KF8:AB6=T(]i[J

Page 66: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

_]Y;F8K@;(7;(A@(>;@F<ACA6M(8(>;G;DB9E;6:(:78:(8AE@(8:(:7;(@8E;(;6>(N(:7;(EB<8D(

MBB>6;@@(B?(7KE86@(i(A6(CB:7(LB<V@=(A:(A@(<;8@B68CD;(:B(8@@KE;(:78:(86H(>A??;<;6F;(

9;<:8A6A6M(:B(:7;(L8H(8(9;<@B6(F86(C;FBE;(EB<8DDH(MBB>(:78:(8<A@;@(C;:L;;6(:7;E(A@(8(

6B:;LB<:7H(F786M;(A6(386:4@(:7;B<H(B?(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:J(-(9B@A:(:78:(:7;<;(8<;=(A6>;;>=(

:LB(@KF7(F786M;@J(2A<@:=(:7;(L8H@(:78:(386:(K@;@(;I8E9D;@(?B<(:7;(9K<9B@;@(B?(EB<8D(

;>KF8:AB6(>A??;<(A6(:7;@;(:LB(LB<V@J(#@(-(LADD(;I9D8A6=(:7;(>A??;<;6F;(A6(:7;(K@;(B?(

;I8E9D;@(9BA6:@(:B(8(EB<;(?K6>8E;6:8D(FB6F;<6(8CBK:(EB<8D(AE9<BG;E;6:(A6(:7;(D8:;<(

LB<V(B?(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*9?2+;FB6>=(A6(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*9=2386:(C;MA6@(:B(

:8DV(A6(8(6;L(L8H(8CBK:(:7;(F786M;(6;F;@@8<H(:B(C;FBE;(EB<8DDH(MBB>J()7AD;(A6(:7;(

@;FB6>(:7+1+B4)2386:(B6DH(>;@F<AC;>(A:(8@(8(M<8>K8D(F786M;(8F7A;G;>(BG;<(:AE;=(7;(:8DV@(

8CBK:(EB<8D(F786M;(8@(<;bKA<A6M(8(@A6MKD8<(:<86@?B<E8:AG;(>;FA@AB6(A6(:7;(D8:;<(LB<VJ

%7;(Z@;(B?(&I8E9D;@(A6(1B<8D(&>KF8:AB6

%7;(?A<@:(L8H(:B(@;;(:7A@(>A??;<;6F;(A@(CH(DBBVA6M(8:(386:4@(>A@FK@@AB6@(<;M8<>A6M(

:7;(K@;(B?(;I8E9D;@(A6(EB<8D(;>KF8:AB6J(386:(E8V;@(:7;(FD8AE(A6(CB:7(LB<V@(:78:(

;I8E9D;@(8<;(;@@;6:A8D(?B<(EB<8D(;>KF8:AB6JQ\(*6(:7;(?8F;(B?(A:=(:7;6=(:7;<;(>B;@(6B:(899;8<(

:B(C;(8(>A??;<;6F;(A6(:7;@;(8FFBK6:@(B6(:7A@(9BA6:J("BL;G;<=(L7;6(L;(DBBV(EB<;(FDB@;DH(8:(

:7;(<;8@B6@(L7H(386:(:7A6V@(:78:(L;(6;;>(:B(E8V;(K@;(B?(;I8E9D;@(A6(;8F7(LB<V=(L;(F86(

@;;(:78:(:7A@(9BA6:@(:B(:7;(FKD:AG8:AB6(B?(K6AbK;(8@9;F:@(B?(EB<8D(MBB>6;@@J

%B(;I9D8A6(:7A@(>A??;<;6F;(A6(:7;(K@;(B?(;I8E9D;@=(-(LADD(:K<6(:B($8KD(cKH;<4@Q](86>(

Q\ +;;(386:=(11=2dOa\[J(S%7;()P8)7+;).10*(U:;F76AF8DX(E;86@(?B<(FKD:AG8:A6M(GA<:K;(A@(,--32;I8E9D;(B6(:7;(98<:(B?(:;8F7;<(U7A@(;I;E9D8<H(FB6>KF:X(86>(5041+-.07<2;I8E9D;(A6(B:7;<@=(@A6F;=(?B<(8(@:ADD(K6>;G;DB9;>(7KE86(C;A6M=(AEA:8:AB6(A@(:7;(?A<@:(>;:;<EA68:AB6(B?(7A@(LADD(:B(8FF;9:(E8IAE@(:78:(7;(8?:;<L8<>@(E8V;@(?B<(7AE@;D?JT

Q] $8KD(cKH;<=(S&I8E9D;@(B?(1B<8D($B@@ACADA:H=T(A6(/0.120.32"34501+-.62$.1)787)101+-.920.32:-;;).107<=2;>J(3D8@('B:7(86>(!7<A@()J(+K<9<;686:J(U.;L(5B<VO('BK:D;>M;=(RWQRXJ

Page 67: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

_[*6B<8(*4.;ADD4@Q[(LB<V@(B6(;I8E9D;@(A6(386:4@(:7;B<H(B?(EB<8D(;>KF8:AB6J(*4.;ADD(9BA6:@(

BK:(:78:(386:(K@;@(:LB(VA6>@(B?(;I8E9D;@(A6(7A@(EB<8D(97ADB@B97HO(7H9B:7;:AF8D(86>(

B@:;6@AG;=(B<(<;8D=(;I8E9D;@J(+7;(L<A:;@=

+BE;(;I8E9D;@(8<;(A<8-1A)1+50*O2:7;H(FB6@A@:(B?(EB<;(B<(D;@@(@9;FA?AF(9<A6FA9D;@(B?(9B@@ACD;(8F:AB6(U;JMJ(:7;(9<A6FA9D;@(B?(F7;8:A6M(8(MKDDACD;(FK@:BE;<=(B<(B?(@H@:;E8:AF(<;?K@8D(B?(7;D9(:B(B:7;<@XJJJ*:7;<(;I8E9D;@(8<;(-91).9+F)62:7;H(9BA6:(BK:(8F:@(B<(9;<@B6@(B<(DAG;@(@BE;(B?(L7B@;(?;8:K<;@(8<;(7;D>(:B(C;(EB<8DDH(@AM6A?AF86:(U;JMJ(:8VA6M(:7;(DA?;(B?(!7<A@:(8@(8(EB>;D(?B<(AEA:8:AB6@=(B<(:7;(8F:AB6(B?(@BE;(B:7;<(8@(8(L8<6A6M(B<(F8K:AB68<H(:8D;XJRW

%7;@;(;I8E9D;@=(@7;(@8H@=(8<;(K@;>(CH(386:(?B<(9K<9B@;@(B?(EB<8D(;>KF8:AB6(86>(

FKD:AG8:AB6J(cKH;<(9AFV@(K9(B6(*4.;ADD4@(>A@:A6F:AB6(86>(EB<;(?KDDH(>;@F<AC;@(:7;(L8H(:78:(

386:(K@;@(;8F7(VA6>(B?(;I8E9D;(A6(EB<8D(;>KF8:AB6=(8<MKA6M(:78:(;8F7(FB<<;@9B6>@(:B(8(

>A??;<;6:(8AE(B?(EB<8D(;>KF8:AB6J(";(L<A:;@(:78:(386:(K@;>(7H9B:7;:AF8D(;I8E9D;@(A6(B<>;<(

:B(;>KF8:;(@:K>;6:@(:B(:7;(SFB6:;6:(B?(:7;(EB<8D(D8L(86>(A:@(<;D8:AB6@(:B(EB@:(B:7;<(

?K6>8E;6:8D(FB6F;9:@(B?(EB<8DA:H=(@KF7(8@(>K:H=(LB<:7=(86>(7899A6;@@=T(:78:(A@=(8(9<AB<A(

FB6F;9:@(B?(EB<8DA:HJRQ(386:(K@;>(:7A@(VA6>(B?(;I8E9D;(C;F8K@;(7;(:7BKM7:(:78:(:7BKM7:(

;I9;<AE;6:@=(L7AF7(E8V;(K@;(B?(7H9B:7;:AF8D(;I8E9D;@=(F86(C<A6M(BK<(8(9<AB<A(V6BLD;>M;(

B?(:7;(EB<8D(D8L(A6:B(BK<(8L8<;6;@@J

*6(:7;(B:7;<(786>=(<;8D(;I8E9D;@=(@KF7(8@(;I8E9D;@(>;<AG;>(?<BE(CABM<897A;@=(F86(

:;8F7(K@(S6B:(B6DH(L78:(:7;(EB<8D(D8L(>;E86>@T(CK:(8D@B(S:78:(A:(A@(<;8DDH(9B@@ACD;(:B(DAG;(

K9(:B(:7A@(>;E86>(?<BE(<;8D(;I8E9D;@(B?(GA<:KBK@(7KE86(FB6>KF:JTRR-';8D(;I8E9D;@(8<;(

EB<;(;??;F:AG;(?B<(:7A@(9K<9B@;(:786(7H9B:7;:AF8D(B6;@(?B<(:LB(<;8@B6@J(2A<@:=(:7;(@9;FA?AF(

Q[ *6B<8(*4.;ADD=(S%7;($BL;<(B?(&I8E9D;@=T(DA+*-9-8A<2dQ(UQ[]dX

RW *4.;ADD=(S%7;($BL;<(B?(&I8E9D;@=T(\J

RQ cKH;<=(S&I8E9D;@(B?(1B<8D($B@@ACADA:H=T(QR]J

RR cKH;<=(S&I8E9D;@(B?(1B<8D($B@@ACADA:H=T(Q`\J

Page 68: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

dW>;E86>@(B?(>K:H=(98<:AFKD8<DH(AE9;<?;F:(>K:A;@=(F866B:(C;(;I9D8A6;>(:7<BKM7(<KD;@(:78:(

FBG;<(;G;<H(9B@@ACD;(@A:K8:AB6J(%7;(B6DH(L8H(:B(:;8F7(8(@:K>;6:(7BL(:B(?KD?ADD(@KF7(>K:A;@(

LADD(C;(CH(E;86@(B?(;I8E9D;J(2K<:7;<=(:7;(EB@:(;??;F:AG;(L8H(:B(:;8F7(8(@:K>;6:(:78:(A:(A@(

9B@@ACD;(?B<(7AE(:B(8F:(EB<8DDH=(>;@9A:;(BC@:8FD;@(:B(>BA6M(@B=(LADD(C;(:B(@7BL(7AE(

;I8E9D;@(B?(8F:K8D(9;B9D;(L7B(78G;(8FFBE9DA@7;>(:7A@JR`(cKH;<(8D@B(:7A6V@(:78:(:7;<;(A@(8(

:7A<>(K@;(?B<(;I8E9D;@=(:;8F7A6M(@:K>;6:@(:7;(FB6:;6:(B?(98<:AFKD8<(>K:A;@=(CK:(386:(D;8G;@(

B9;6(L7;:7;<(<;8D(B<(7H9B:7;:AF8D(;I8E9D;@(F86(C;(K@;>(:B(:;8F7(:7A@(;6>JRa(

)7AD;(cKH;<(7AE@;D?(>B;@(6B:(C<;8V(>BL6(A6(86(B<>;<DH(L8H(L7AF7(:H9;(B?(

;I8E9D;@(899;8<(A6(L7AF7(B?(386:4@(LB<V@(B<(A6(L78:(L8H(:7B@;(VA6>@(B?(;I8E9D;@(8<;(

K:ADAP;>=(A:(A@(6B:(>A??AFKD:(:B(>B(@B(A6(:7;(F8@;(B?(:7;(/BF:<A6;@(B?(1;:7B>J(YH(

A6G;@:AM8:A6M(L7AF7(@B<:(B?(;I8E9D;@(386:(A@(K@A6M(A6(:7;(:LB(/BF:<A6;@(B?(1;:7B>(:78:(

L;(8<;(FBE98<A6M(86>(?B<(L78:(9K<9B@;(7;(A@(K@A6M(:7;E=(L;(F86(EB<;(FD;8<DH(>;:;<EA6;(

L78:(@B<:(B?(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:(386:(?BFK@;@(K9B6(A6(;8F7(LB<VJ

-6(:7;(@;FB6>(:7+1+B4)4@2/BF:<A6;(B?(1;:7B>=(386:(<;DA;@(B6(B6DH(<;8D(;I8E9D;@(

86>=(A6(?8F:=(L8<6@(8M8A6@:(:7;(>86M;<@(B?(K@A6M(7H9B:7;:AF8D(;I8E9D;@JR_(%7;(VA6>@(B?(

;I8E9D;@(:78:(386:(8>GBF8:;@(K:ADAPA6M(8<;(:7B@;(?BK6>(A6(86FA;6:(86>(EB>;<6(

CABM<897A;@J(#:(B6;(9BA6:=(7;(@9;FA?AF8DDH(@KMM;@:@(K@A6M(;I8E9D;@(?<BE(#66;(YBD;H64@(

DA?;JRd(";(A@(8D@B(FD;8<(:78:(7;(>B;@(6B:(:7A6V(:78:(;I8E9D;@(:78:(8<;(6B:(<;8D(8<;(899<B9<A8:;(

?B<(EB<8D(;>KF8:AB6J(";(L<A:;@(:78:=(SL78:;G;<(<K6@(K9(A6:B(;E9:H(LA@7;@(86>(DB6MA6M@(

R` cKH;<=(S&I8E9D;@(B?(1B<8D($B@@ACADA:H=T(Q`R(N(Q``J

Ra cKH;<=(S&I8E9D;@(B?(1B<8D($B@@ACADA:H=T(Q`\J

R_ +;;(386:=(!$<'=(_OQ_a(N(_OQ__J(%7A@(A@(6B:(:B(@8H(:78:(386:(6;G;<(K@;@(7H9B:7;:AF8D(;I8E9D;@(A6(7A@(;8<DA;<(LB<V@(A6(EB<8DA:HJ(-6>;;>=(8@(-(>A@FK@@(D8:;<=(7;(>B;@(K@;(@KF7(;I8E9D;@(A6(:7;(%7-4.3G-7M?

Rd 386:=(!$<'=(_OQ_a(N(_OQ__J

Page 69: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

dQ?B<(A68FF;@@ACD;(9;<?;F:AB6(9<B>KF;@(E;<;(7;<B;@(B?(<BE86F;(L7B=(L7AD;(:7;H(9<A>;(

:7;E@;DG;@(B6(:7;A<(?;;DA6M(?B<(;I:<8G8M86:(M<;8:6;@@=(<;D;8@;(:7;E@;DG;@(A6(<;:K<6(?<BE(

:7;(BC@;<G86F;(B?(FBEEB6(86>(;G;<H>8H(BCDAM8:AB6=(L7AF7(:7;6(@;;E@(:B(:7;E(

A6@AM6A?AF86:(86>(9;::HJTR\("A@(FB6F;<6(7;<;(899;8<@(:B(C;(:78:(6B6i<;8D(;I8E9D;@(FBKD>(

D;8>(8(9;<@B6(:B(C;(K6FB6F;<6;>(LA:7(:7;(>K:A;@(B?(;G;<H>8H(DA?;=(L7AF7(LADD(@;;E(

K6AE9B<:86:(A6(FBE98<A@B6J

cAG;6(:7A@(7;D9?KD(>A@:A6F:AB6(B?(K@;@(?B<(;I8E9D;@=(L;(F86(@8H(EB<;(8CBK:(L7H(

386:(EAM7:(78G;(:7BKM7:(7H9B:7;:AF8D(;I8E9D;@(@7BKD>(6B:(C;(K@;>(A6(EB<8D(;>KF8:AB6(

;G;6(:7BKM7=(8@(L;(LADD(@;;=(7;(>B;@(K@;(:7;E(A6(B:7;<(LB<V@J(%7A@(<;8@B6=(A6(?8F:=(A@(

DAV;DH(C;F8K@;(B?(:7;(98<:AFKD8<(VA6>(B?(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:(:78:(386:(A@(A6:;<;@:;>(A6(

FKD:AG8:A6M(A6(:7A@(LB<VJ(386:(LBKD>(B6DH(E8V;(@KF7(8(@:8:;E;6:(A?(7A@(<;8@B6(?B<(K@A6M(

;I8E9D;@(A6(:7A@(/BF:<A6;(B?(1;:7B>(L8@(6;A:7;<(:B(7;D9(8(@:K>;6:(?A6>(8(9<AB<A(EB<8D(

FB6F;9:@(LA:7A6(7;<(BL6(<;8@B6(6B<(:B(7;D9(:7;E(<;8DAP;(:7;(FB6:;6:(B?(:7;(EB<8D(D8LJ(-:(A@(

FD;8<(L7H(:7;(?A<@:(A@(:7;(F8@;J(#@(6B:;>(8CBG;(CH(cKH;<=(:7A@(?A<@:(MB8D(B?(K@A6M(;I8E9D;@(

F86(B6DH(C;(8F7A;G;>(:7<BKM7(7H9B:7;:AF8D(;I8E9D;@-C;F8K@;(B?(:7;A<(K@;(A6(:7BKM7:(

;I9;<AE;6:@(?B<(><8LA6M(8(9<AB<A(FB6F;9:@(A6:B(B6;4@(FB6@FABK@6;@@J(%7;(@;FB6>(9<B9B@;>(

;6>(B?(MAGA6M(;I8E9D;@=(:B(<;8DAP;(:7;(FB6:;6:(B?(:7;(EB<8D(D8L=(F86(C;(8F7A;G;>(;A:7;<(

:7<BKM7(7H9B:7;:AF8D(B<(<;8D(;I8E9D;@J(%7;<;?B<;=(A?(:7A@(L;<;(:7;(<;8@B6(:78:(386:(L8@(

8>GBF8:A6M(:7;(K@;(B?(;I8E9D;@(A6(:7A@(/BF:<A6;(B?(1;:7B>=(7;(LBKD>(6B:(8>GA@;(8M8A6@:(

K@A6M(7H9B:7;:AF8D(;I8E9D;@J(-:(EK@:(C;(:<K;=(:7;6=(:78:(386:(8>GA@;@(<;8>;<@(:B(K:ADAP;(<;8D(

;I8E9D;@(A6(:7A@(/BF:<A6;(B?(1;:7B>(C;F8K@;(7;(A@(FB6F;<6;>(LA:7(:7;(8AE(B?(:;8F7A6M(

R\ 386:=(!$<'=(_OQ__J(USJJJL8@(8K?(D;;<;()j6@F7;(K6>(+;76@KF7:;6(68F7(K6;<@:;AMDAF7;<(0BDDBEE;67;A:(7A68K@DmK?:(D8K:;<('BE867;D>;6(7;<GB<<A6M:=(>A;=(A6>;E(@A;(@AF7(8K?(A7<(c;?j7D(?j<(>8@(jC;<@F7L;6MDAF7(c<Bk;(GA;D(PKMK:;(:K6=(@AF7(>8?j<(GB6(>;<(Y;BC8F7:K6M(>;<(M;E;A6;6(K6>(M86MC8<;6(+F7KD>AMV;A:=(>A;(8D@>866(A76;6(6K<(K6C;>;K:;6>(VD;A6(@F7;A6:=(?<;A@9<;F7;6JTX(

Page 70: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

dR@:K>;6:@(:7;(>;E86>@(B?(:7;(EB<8D(D8L(86>(:78:(8F:A6M(EB<8DDH(A@(9B@@ACD;=(:7;(;6>(:78:(A@(

8F7A;G;>(@BD;DH(CH(:7;(K@;(B?(<;8D(;I8E9D;@J

-6(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*94@(/BF:<A6;(B?(1;:7B>=(386:(>B;@(6B:(<;@:<AF:(7AE@;D?(

:B(B6DH(K@A6M(<;8D(;I8E9D;@=(:7BKM7(7;(>B;@(>A@FK@@(:7A@(VA6>(B?(;I8E9D;J2";(@:8:;@(:78:(

B6;(L8H(:B(FKD:AG8:;(GA<:K;(A@(:B(K@;(;I8E9D;@(B?(MBB>(B<(C8>(FB6>KF:J(-:(A@(BCGABK@(:78:(

7;(A@(:8DVA6M(8CBK:(<;8D(;I8E9D;@(7;<;(C;F8K@;(7;(<;?;<@(:B(:7;@;(;I8E9D;@(8@(S:7;(

FB6>KF:(B?(B:7;<(7KE86(C;A6M@=T(@KF7(8@(:7;(:;8F7;<(7AE@;D?(B<(B:7;<(@:K>;6:@JR]("A@(MB8D(

?B<(K@A6M(<;8D(;I8E9D;@(A6(:7A@(98@@8M;(A@(FD;8<J(386:(L<A:;@(:78:(S#(MBB>(;I8E9D;(

U;I;E9D8<H(FB6>KF:X(@7BKD>(6B:(@;<G;(8@(8(EB>;D(CK:(B6DH(8@(8(9<BB?(:78:(A:(A@(<;8DDH(

9B@@ACD;(:B(8F:(A6(FB6?B<EA:H(LA:7(>K:HJTR[(%7;(<;8@B6(?B<(K@A6M(:7A@(VA6>(B?(;I8E9D;(:7K@(

?8DD@(K6>;<(cKH;<4@(@;FB6>(K@;(?B<(;I8E9D;@(86>(>B;@(6B:(>A??;<(?<BE(:7;(MB8D(B?(:7;(K@;(

B?(;I8E9D;@(A6(:7;(@;FB6>(:7+1+B4)?

"BL;G;<=(:7A@(A@(6B:(:7;(B6DH(VA6>(B?(;I8E9D;(:78:(386:(K@;@(A6(:7A@(LB<VJ(";(:7;6(

EBG;@(B6(:B(:8DV(8CBK:(7H9B:7;:AF8D(;I8E9D;@=(:7;(VA6>(B?(;I8E9D;(8>GBF8:;>(8M8A6@:(A6(

:7;(@;FB6>(:7+1+B4)J(%7A@(;I8E9D;(DA;@(A6(L78:(7;(:A:D;@(8(S?<8ME;6:(B?(8(EB<8D(

F8:;F7A@EJT`W(";<;=(7;(MAG;@(8(@8E9D;(B?(L78:(8(EB<8D(F8:;F7A@E(C;:L;;6(8(:;8F7;<(86>(

@:K>;6:(EAM7:(DBBV(DAV;J(%7;(:;8F7;<(MAG;@(:7;(@:K>;6:(8(6KEC;<(B?(7H9B:7;:AF8D(;I8E9D;@(

86>(:7BKM7:(;I9;<AE;6:@(:B(FB6@A>;<=(CK:(6B(<;8D(;I8E9D;@J(2B<(;I8E9D;=(:7;(:;8F7;<(8@V@(

:7;(@:K>;6:(:B(S+K99B@;=(?B<(;I8E9D;=(:78:(8(@A:K8:AB6(8<A@;@(A6(L7AF7(HBK(FBKD>(M;:(8(

M<;8:(C;6;?A:(?B<(HBK<@;D?(B<(HBK<(?<A;6>(CH(E8VA6M(K9(8(@KC:D;(*+)2:78:(LBKD>(78<E(6B(

R] 386:=(11=(dOa\[(N(dOa]WJ(

R[ -CA>=2dOa]WJ(US/8@(MK:;(&I;E9;D(U>;<(;I;E9D8<A@F7;()86>;DX(@BDD(6AF7:(8D@(1K@:;<=(@B6>;<6(6K<(PKE(Y;L;A@;(>;<(%7K6DAF7V;A:(>;@($?DAF7:Em@@AM6;(>A;6;6JJJTX

`W -CA>J

Page 71: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

d`B6;O()78:(>B;@(HBK<(<;8@B6(@8H(8CBK:(A:nT`Q(386:(@:8:;@(:78:(:7;(MB8D(B?(K@A6M(:7;@;(

7H9B:7;:AF8D(;I8E9D;@(A@(:B(7;D9(:7;(@:K>;6:(>;G;DB9(FB6F;9:@(:78:(8<;(8D<;8>H(A6(7A@(

<;8@B6=`R(68E;DH=(8@(cKH;<(9BA6:@(BK:=(7A@(S8(9<AB<A(V6BLD;>M;(B?(:7;(EB<8D(D8LJT``

#@(L;(78G;(@;;6=(:7A@(K@;(B?(7H9B:7;:AF8D(;I8E9D;@(>A>(6B:(899;8<(A6(:7;(@;FB6>(

:7+1+B4)(92/BF:<A6;(B?(1;:7B>J(-6(DAM7:(B?(*4.;ADD4@(86>(cKH;<4@(7;D9?KD(>;@F<A9:AB6@(B?(

L78:(@B<:(B?(;I8E9D;@(8<;(K@;>(CH(386:(?B<(L78:(;6>@=(:7A@(6;L(K@;(B?(;I8E9D;(A6(:7;(

@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*92F8627;D92K@(:B(@;;(:7;(@AM6A?AF86F;(B?(:7A@(>A??;<;6F;(A6(:7;(K@;(B?(

;I8E9D;@J(%7A@(>A??;<;6F;(A6>AF8:;@(:78:(386:(A@(FB6F;<6;>(LA:7(8(6;L(VA6>(B?(;6>(?B<(

EB<8D(;>KF8:AB6(A6(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*9O(:7;(K6FBG;<A6M(B?(8(9<AB<A(EB<8D(FB6F;9:@(

LA:7A6(BK<(BL6(<;8@B6J(%7A@(A@(6B:(B6DH(8(6;L(8AE(B?(EB<8D(;>KF8:AB6(CK:(8(EB<;(

?K6>8E;6:8D(8AE(:78:(K6>;<DA;@(:7;(8AE(B?(MBB>(E8IAEiE8VA6MJ(Z6FBG;<A6M(B6;4@(8(9<AB<A(

V6BLD;>M;(B?(EB<8D(FB6F;9:@(A@(8(@:;99A6M(@:B6;(:B(8F:A6M(A6(EB<8DDH(LB<:7H(L8H@=(L7AF7(

A@(B6;(B?(:7;(8AE@(B?(:7;(K@;(B?(;I8E9D;@(A6(:7;(@;FB6>(:7+1+B4)J(-6>;;>=(L;(F866B:(8F:(

K9B6(MBB>(E8IAE@(LA:7BK:(8D<;8>H(78GA6M(>;G;DB9;>(BK<(K6>;<@:86>A6M(B?(:7;@;(

FB6F;9:@J`a(%B(9K:(A:(EB@:(C8@AF8DDH=(L;(F866B:(8F:(?<BE(>K:H(LA:7BK:(?A<@:(V6BLA6M(L78:(

>K:H(A@J(%7A@(8AE(B?(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:(:78:(8<A@;@(LA:7(:7;(K@;(B?(7H9B:7;:AF8D(;I8E9D;@(

A6(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*92>B;@(6B:(eK@:(9BA6:(:B(8(6;L(8AE(B?(>;G;DB9E;6:(CK:(8(EB<;(

?K6>8E;6:8D(B6;J

Y;?B<;(EBGA6M(B6=(A:(A@(AE9B<:86:(:B(@:<;@@(:78:(A:(A@(6B:(:7;(VA6>@(B?(;I8E9D;@(:78:(

`Q -CA>=(dOa]QJ(USoJYJ();66(>A<(;A6(28DD(GB<VBEE:=(>8(>K(>K<F7(;A6;(?;A6(8K@M;>8F7:(,jM;(>A<(B>;<(>;A6;6(2<;K>;6(;A6;6(M<B@@;6(0B<:7;AD(G;<@F78??;6(V866@:=(e8(6BF7(>8PK(>8>K<F7(8KF7(V;A6;E(#6>;<;6(@F78>;@:=(L8@(@8M:(>8PK(>;A6;(0;<6K6?:nTX

`R((((-CA>=(dOa\]J

`` cKH;<=(S&I8E9D;@(B?(1B<8D($B@@ACADA:H=T(QR[J

`a +;;(+K<9<;686:=(S386:4@(!B6:<ACK:AB6(:B(1B<8D(&>KF8:AB6=T(]J

Page 72: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

da386:(K@;@(:78:(9BA6:(:B(:7;(;6>(B?(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:(CK:(:7;(<;8@B6@(L7H(7;(K@;@(8(

F;<:8A6(VA6>J(-6(?8F:=(L7AD;(386:(>B;@(6B:(K@;(7H9B:7;:AF8D(;I8E9D;@(A6(:7;(@;FB6>(

:7+1+B4)=27;(>B;@(K@;(:7;E(A6(86B:7;<(;8<DA;<(LB<V=(:7;(%7-4.3G-7M?22B<(;I8E9D;=(A6(:7A@(

LB<V=(386:(K@;@(:7;(;I8E9D;(B?(8(7H9B:7;:AF8D(@7B9V;;9;<(:B(ADDK@:<8:;(:7;(>A??AFKD:H(B?(

>;:;<EA6A6M(:7;(EB:AG8:AB6@(C;7A6>(86(8F:AB6J`_(%7;(<;8@B6(L7H(L;(F86(@:ADD(@8H(:78:(

386:4@(K@;(B?(7H9B:7;:AF8D(;I8E9D;@(A6(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*929BA6:@(:B(8(6;L(8AE(B?(

>;G;DB9E;6:(A@(C;F8K@;(7A@(K@;(B?(7H9B:7;:AF8D@(A6(:7;@;(:LB(LB<V@(>A??;<(A6(86(AE9B<:86:(

L8HJ(-6(:7;(;8<DA;<(LB<V=(386:(K@;@(:7A@(VA6>(B?(;I8E9D;(:B(;I9D8A6(7A@(EB<8D(:7;B<H(:B(7A@(

<;8>;<@(L7AD;=(A6(:7;(D8:;<(LB<V=(7;(A@(K@A6M(:7;@;(;I8E9D;@(?B<(:7;(9K<9B@;@(B?(EB<8D(

;>KF8:AB6=(B<(:B(A6@:<KF:(7A@(<;8>;<(7BL(:B(:;8F7(9K9AD@(7BL(:B(EB<8DDH(AE9<BG;J(

-6(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*9=28@(6B:;>(8CBG;=(386:(K:ADAP;@(7H9B:7;:AF8D(;I8E9D;@(

A6(:7;(FB6:;I:(B?(EB<8D(;>KF8:AB6J(";(L<A:;@(:78:(:7;@;(;I8E9D;@(8<;(7;D9?KD(A6(FKD:AG8:A6M(

GA<:K;J(%7K@=(:7;(;6>(B?(K@A6M(:7A@(VA6>(B?(;I8E9D;(A6(:7A@(LB<V(A@(:B(MAG;(8(9;<@B6(

V6BLD;>M;(B?(:7;(EB<8D(D8L(?B<(:7;(;6>(B?(EB<8D(AE9<BG;E;6:J(*6(:7;(B:7;<(786>=(L7;6(

386:(K@;@(:7;@;(;I8E9D;@(A6(:7;(%7-4.3G-7M=2A:(A@(A6(:7;(FB6:;I:(B?(;I9D8A6A6M(:7;(

FB6F;9:@(B?(>K:H(86>(:7;(EB<8D(LB<:7(B?(8F:AB6@(CK:(6B:(A6(:7;(FB6:;I:(B?(EB<8D(;>KF8:AB6J(

";<;(7;(A@(8::;E9:A6M(:B(;I9D8A6(:7;(FB6:;6:(B?(:7;(EB<8D(D8L(?B<(:7;(9K<9B@;@(B?(

;I9D8A6A6M(7A@(:7;B<H(B?(;:7AF@J(";(A@(6B:(H;:(;I9D8A6A6M(7BL(L;(F86(C;FBE;(EB<8DDH(

MBB>(B<(A6(L78:(L8H(L;(@7BKD>(MB(8CBK:(AE9<BGA6M(BK<@;DG;@(EB<8DDHJ(%7;<;?B<;=(L7AD;(

:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*92A@(6B:(:7;(?A<@:(9D8F;(:78:(386:(K@;@(7H9B:7;:AF8D(;I8E9D;@=(A:(A@(

:7;(?A<@:(9D8F;(:78:(7;(K@;@(:7;E(A6(:7;(FB6:;I:(B?(EB<8D(AE9<BG;E;6:J(/;@9A:;(:7;(

;I8E9D;@(A6(:7;(%7-4.3G-7M=2:7;6=(L;(F86(@:ADD(@8H(:78:(386:=(?B<(:7;(?A<@:(:AE;(A6(7A@(

`_ 386:=(%7-4.3G-7M=2aO`[]J(386:(8D@B(K@;@(B:7;<(7H9B:7;:AF8D(;I8E9D;@=(@KF7(8@(8(97AD86:7<B9A@:(UaO`[]X(86>(9;<@B6(@K??;<A6M(?<BE(86(ADD6;@@(UaO`[[XJ

Page 73: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

d_;:7AF8D(LB<V@=(A@(9BA6:A6M(:B(8(6;L(8AE(B?(EB<8D(;>KF8:AB6J

+A6MKD8<(!7BAF;@(G;<@K@(c<8>K8D($<BM<;@@

%7;<;(A@(86B:7;<(>A??;<;6F;(C;:L;;6(:7;@;(:LB(/BF:<A6;@(B?(1;:7B>(:78:(7AM7DAM7:@(

386:4@(6;L(A6:;<;@:(A6(:7;(FB6>A:AB6@(?B<(:7;(9B@@ACADA:H(B?(EB<8DDH(MBB>(8F:AB6@O(7A@(

@:8:;E;6:=(A6(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*94@(/BF:<A6;(B?(1;:7B>=(:78:(B6;(EK@:(E8V;(8(

@A6MKD8<(>;FA@AB6(:B(C;FBE;(EB<8DDH(MBB>J(-6(:7;(;8<DA;<(/BF:<A6;(B?(1;:7B>=(386:(L8@(

FD;8<(:78:(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:(BFFK<@(M<8>K8DDHJ(%7;<;=(7;(>;@F<AC;@(:7;(E86H(@:8M;@(:78:(

B6;(EK@:(MB(:7<BKM7(A6(B<>;<(:B(D;8<6(:B(8F:(EB<8DDHJ(2B<(;I8E9D;=(7;(L<A:;@(:78:(S:7;<;(A@(

6B(>BKC:(:78:(:7A@(;I;<FA@;(86>(:7;(FB6@FABK@6;@@(B?(8(FKD:AG8:AB6(B?(BK<(<;8@B6(A6(eK>MA6M(

E;<;DH(8CBK:(:7;(9<8F:AF8D(8<A@A6M(?<BE(:7A@(;I;<FA@;=(EK@:(M<8>K8DDH(9<B>KF;(8(F;<:8A6(

A6:;<;@:(A6(<;8@B64@(D8L(A:@;D?(86>(7;6F;(A6(EB<8DDH(MBB>(8F:AB6@JT`d(*G;<(86>(BG;<(8M8A6=(

7;(K@;@(:7;(D86MK8M;(B?(M<8>K8D(F786M;(86>(FKD:AG8:AB6(:78:(:8V;@(9D8F;(BG;<(:AE;J`\

)7AD;(386:(FB6:A6K;@(:B(K@;(:7;(D86MK8M;(B?(M<8>K8D(F786M;(A6(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C 2

@-70*9(92/BF:<A6;(B?(1;:7B>=`](7;(8D@B(:8DV@(8CBK:(8(>A??;<;6:(VA6>(B?(6B6iM<8>K8D(F786M;(

:78:(A@(6;;>;>(?B<(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:?2386:(L<A:;@=

JJJ:7;(+:BAF@(E;86:(B6DH(:78:(GA<:K;(F866B:(C;(104,A12E;<;DH(CH(FB6F;9:@(B?(>K:H(B<(CH(;I7B<:8:AB6@(UCH(98<8;6;@A@X=(CK:(EK@:(A6@:;8>(C;()P)75+9)3286>(FKD:AG8:;>(CH(;??B<:@(:B(FBEC8:(:7;(A66;<(;6;EH(LA:7A6(:7;(7KE86(C;A6M(U8@F;:AFA@EX^(?B<(B6;(F866B:(@:<8AM7:L8H(>B(8DD(:78:(B6;(G0.192:B(>B=(LA:7BK:(78GA6M(?A<@:(:<A;>(BK:(86>(;I;<FA@;>(B6;4@(9BL;<@J(YK:(:7;(3)5+9+-.2:B(>B(:7A@(EK@:(C;(E8>;(8DD(8:(B6F;(86>(FBE9D;:;DH=(@A6F;(8(>A@9B@A:AB6(U0.+;49X(:B(@K<<;6>;<(8:(:AE;@(:B(GAF;=(A6(B<>;<(:B(C<;8V(8L8H(?<BE(A:(M<8>K8DDH=(LBKD>(A:@;D?(C;(AE9K<;(86>(;G;6(GAFABK@=(86>(@B(

`d 386:=(!$<'=(_OQ_[(N(_OQdWJ(US.K6(A@:(V;A6(oL;A?;D=(>8k(>A;@;(pCK6M(K6>(>8@(Y;LKk:@;A6(;A6;<(>8<8K@(;6:@9<A6M;6>;6(3KD:K<(K6@;<;<(CDBk(jC;<(>8@($<8V:A@F7;(K<:;AD;6>;6(0;<6K6?:(;A6(M;A@@;@(-6:;<;@@;=(@;DC@:(8E(c;@;:P;(>;<@;DC;6=(EA:7A6(86(@A::DAF7(MK:;6("86>DK6M;6(68F7(K6>(68F7(7;<GB<C<A6M;6(Ej@@;JTX

`\ +;;(386:=(!$<'=(_OQ_d(86>(_OQ_[(?B<(;I8E9D;@J(

`] %7A@(A@(BCGABK@(A6(386:4@(>A@FK@@AB6(B?(GA<:K;(8@(@BE;:7A6M(:78:(F86(C;(:8KM7:(BG;<(:AE;(U386:=(11=(dOa\\XJ

Page 74: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

ddFBKD>(C<A6M(8CBK:(6B(GA<:K;(UL7AF7(A@(C8@;>(B6(8(@A6MD;(9<A6FA9D;XJ`[

2<BE(:7A@(98@@8M;=(L;(F86(@;;(:78:(386:(A@(@:ADD(FB6GA6F;>(:78:(EB<8D(AE9<BG;E;6:(

<;bKA<;@(M<8>K8D(F786M;(86>(FKD:AG8:AB6J("BL;G;<=(7;(C<A6M@(A6(8(6;L(?;8:K<;(B?(EB<8D(

F786M;(:78:(>A>(6B:(899;8<(A6(:7;(/BF:<A6;(B?(1;:7B>(?<BE(:7;(:7+1+B4)2-C2D7051+50* 2

!)09-.O(:7;(6;;>(?B<(8(@A6MKD8<=(:<86@?B<E8:AG;(F786M;(:7<BKM7(8(B6;i:AE;(F7BAF;J2%7;(

A6:<B>KF:AB6(B?(:7;(6;;>(?B<(8(@A6MKD8<(>;FA@AB6(:B(C<;8V(8L8H(?<BE(GAF;(A6>AF8:;@(:78:(

386:(78@(C;MK6(:B(:7A6V(>A??;<;6:DH(8CBK:(:7;(L8H(A6(L7AF7(EB<8D(F786M;(:8V;@(9D8F;J

186H(FBEE;6:8:B<@aW(78G;(9BA6:;>(:B(:7A@(@7A?:(A6(386:4@(EB<8D(:7;B<HJ($8KD(

2B<EB@8(78@(<;?;<<;>(:B(:7A@(:;6@AB6(8@(:7;(S<;GBDK:AB6(:;6@AB6T(86>(>;?A6;@(A:(8@(86(

8998<;6:(FB6?DAF:(C;:L;;6(SM<8>K8D(>;G;DB9E;6:8D(9<BM<;@@(:7<BKM7(;>KF8:AB6(86>(:7;(

@K>>;6(EB<8D(<;GBDK:AB6JJJTaQ(#@(L;(F86(@;;(?<BE(:7;(@8E9D;(B?(:7;@;(:LB(/BF:<A6;@(B?(

1;:7B>=(A6(>A??;<;6:(98<:@(B?(7A@(EB<8D(:7;B<H=(386:(CB:7(8>GBF8:;@(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:(

:7<BKM7(M<8>K8D(F786M;(CH(E;86@(B?(EB<8D(;>KF8:AB6(86>(:7<BKM7(8(@K>>;6=(B6;i:AE;(

F7BAF;(L7AF7(F866B:(C;(:8KM7:(:7<BKM7(;>KF8:AB6JaR(186?<;>(3K;76(9BA6:@(BK:(:78:(:7A@(

`[ 386:=(11=(dOa\\?2!USJJJ@B(E;A6:;6(>A;(+:BAV;<(6K<=(>A;(%KM;6>(Vl66;(6AF7:(>K<F7(CDB@@;(0B<@:;DDK6M;6(>;<($?DAF7:=(>K<F7(&<E876K6M;6(U98<m6;:A@F7X(M;D;7<:=(@B6>;<6(@A;(Ej@@;(>K<F7(0;<@KF7;(>;<(Y;VmE9?K6M(>;@(A66;<;6(2;A6>;@(AE(1;6@F7;6(U8@F;:A@F7X(VKD:AGA<:=(M;jC:(L;<>;6^>;66(E86(V866!6AF7:(8DD;@(@B?B<:=(L8@(E86(LADD=(L;66(E86(6AF7:(GB<7;<(@;A6;(3<m?:;(G;<@KF7:(K6>(M;jC:(78:=(LBPK(8C;<(?<;ADAF7(>A;(&6:@F7DA;@@K6M(8K?(;A6E8D(GBDD@:m6>AM(M;6BEE;6(L;<>;6(EK@@^L;AD(>A;(c;@A66K6M(U86AEK@X(@B6@:(C;A(;A6;<(!89A:KD8:AB6(EA:(>;E(,8@:;<=(KE(;@(8DDEm7DAM(PK(G;<D8@@;6=(86(@AF7(K6D8K:;<(K6>(@;DC@:(D8@:;<78?:(@;A6(Lj<>;=(EA:7A6(8KF7(V;A6;(%KM;6>(U8D@(>A;(8K?(;A6;E(;A6PAM;6($<A6PA9(C;<K7:=X(7;<GB<C<A6M;6(Vl66:;JTX

aW 2B<EB@8=(S2<BE(/A@FA9DA6;(:B(#K:B6BEHO(386:4@(%7;B<H(B?(1B<8D(/;G;DB9E;6:^T(,;LA@()7A:;(Y;FV=(S386:(B6(&>KF8:AB6JT

aQ 2B<EB@8=(S2<BE(/A@FA9DA6;(:B(#K:B6BEH=T(Q\`J

aR 386:(:8DV@(8CBK:(8(@AEAD8<(VA6>(B?(@A6MKD8<(:<86@?B<E8:AG;(F786M;(A6(H.1A7-8-*-,<2C7-;202D70,;01+52D-+.12-C2Q+)G2U!8<CB6>8D;=(-,O(+BK:7;<6(-DDA6BA@(Z6AG;<@A:H($<;@@=(Q[\]XO(\OR[a(i(\OR[_J2)7AD;(:7A@(F786M;(A@(>A??;<;6:(?<BE(:7;(B6;(:8DV;>(8CBK:(A6(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*92@9;FA?AF8DDH(A6(:78:(A:(A@(6B:(8(F7BAF;(:B(C<;8V(8L8H(?<BE(GAF;(CK:(<8:7;<(8(F7BAF;(:B(;@:8CDA@7(F78<8F:;<(U:A070M1)7X=(A:(A@(@AEAD8<(A6(:78:(CB:7(8<;(<;@BDK:AB6@(:78:(EK@:(C;(E8>;(8:(B6F;=(<8:7;<(:786(M<8>K8DDH=(86>(CB:7(F866B:(8<A@;(?<BE(;>KF8:AB6J

Page 75: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

d\:;6@AB6(>B;@(6B:(8<A@;(A6(386:4@(8FFBK6:(B?(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:(K6:AD(7A@(D8:;<(LB<V@=(@KF7(

8@(:7;(H.1A7-8-*-,<2C7-;202D70,;01+52D-+.12-C2Q+)G2UQ\[]X(86>(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C 2

@-70*92UQ\[\XJ(-6(:7;@;(LB<V@=(7;(C;MA6@(:B(L<A:;(:78:(EB<8D(MBB>6;@@(<;bKA<;@(E8VA6M(8(

@A6MKD8<(<;@BDK:AB6(:B(C;(EB<8DDH(MBB>Ja`()7AD;(3K;76(86>(B:7;<@aa(78G;(C;;6(@KFF;@@?KD(

A6(A>;6:A?HA6M(:7A@(F786M;(A6(386:4@(:7A6VA6M(8CBK:(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:=(:7;H(B?:;6(?8AD(:B(

A>;6:A?H(8(@BK<F;(B?(:7A@(F786M;J(-:(A@(6B:(FD;8<(L7H(386:(FBE;@(:B(C;DA;G;(:78:(EB<8D(

>;G;DB9E;6:(<;bKA<;@(8(@K>>;6(86>(B6;i:AE;(F7BAF;(:B(C;(EB<8DDH(MBB>(A6(7A@(E8:K<;(

L<A:A6M@J

&G;6(LA:7BK:(K6>;<@:86>A6M(L7H(386:(>;FA>;>(:78:(EB<;(:786(M<8>K8D(9<BM<;@@(

:7<BKM7(;>KF8:AB6(A@(6;F;@@8<H(?B<(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:=(L;(F86(FBE;(:B(@BE;(FB6FDK@AB6@(

8CBK:(L78:(:7;(8>>A:AB6(B?(:7;(6;;>(?B<(8(@K>>;6(F786M;(AE9DA;@(?B<(386:4@(EB<8D(:7;B<HJ(

)7;6(7;(:8DV@(8CBK:(:7A@(VA6>(B?(F786M;=(A:(A@(FD;8<(:78:(A:(A@(8(F786M;(:78:(K6>;<DA;@(:7;(

9B@@ACADA:H(B?(M<8>K8D(9<BM<;@@J(-6(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*9=2386:(C;MA6@(:7;(/BF:<A6;(B?(

1;:7B>(CH(@:8:A6M(:78:(GA<:K;(EK@:(C;(8FbKA<;>(86>=(:7;<;?B<;=(:8KM7:(:B(8(9;<@B6J(";(

A6:<B>KF;@(:7;(6;;>(?B<(86(8>>A:AB68D=(@A6MKD8<(>;FA@AB6(?B<(EB<8D(F786M;(CH(L<A:A6M(:78:(

:7A@(@B<:(B?(M<8>K8D(FKD:AG8:AB6(B?(GA<:K;(?A<@:(<;bKA<;@(:7;(>;FA@AB6(:B(C<;8V(8L8H(?<BE(

GAF;Ja_(2<BE(:7A@(98@@8M;=(L;(F86(@;;(:78:(:7A@(@A6MKD8<=(:<86@?B<E8:AG;(F786M;(EK@:(C;(

E8>;(9<AB<(:B(:7;(VA6>(B?(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:(:78:(A@(M<8>K8DJ();(F86(@;;(:78:(FKD:AG8:A6M(

GA<:K;=(:7<BKM7(8(M<8>K8D(9<BM<;@@(B?(;>KF8:AB6=(?A<@:(<;bKA<;@(8(C<;8VA6M(8L8H(?<BE(GAF;=(

L7AF7(F86(B6DH(C;(>B6;(:7<BKM7(:7A@(@A6MKD8<(>;FA@AB6J(-6(86B:7;<(98@@8M;=(?<BE(:7;(

a` 3K;76=(S386:(B6(&>KF8:AB6=(#6:7<B9BDBMH=(86>(&:7AF@=T(_[J

aa +;;(Y;FV=(S386:(B6(&>KF8:AB6=T(86>(2B<EB@8=(S2<BE(/A@FA9DA6;(:B(#K:B6BEHJT

a_ +;;(386:=(11=(dOaddJ(SYK:(:7;(3)5+9+-.2:B(>B(:7A@(f:B(FKD:AG8:;(GA<:K;g(EK@:(C;(E8>;(8DD(8:(B6F;(86>(FBE9D;:;DHJJJT

Page 76: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

d]&:7AF8D(#F;:AF@=(A:(C;FBE;@(FD;8<(:7A@(@A6MKD8<(>;FA@AB6(@BE;7BL(<;EBG;@=(B<(:8E;@=(B6;4@(

68:K<8D(BC@:8FD;@(:B(GA<:K;(@B(:78:(8(9;<@B6(F86(8F:(EB<8DDH(A6(98<:AFKD8<(@A:K8:AB6@Jad(%7A@(

@A6MKD8<(F7BAF;=(:7;6=(F<;8:;@(:7;(9B@@ACADA:H(B?(M<8>K8D(EB<8D(9<BM<;@@J

%7A@(>A??;<;6F;=(L7;6(98A<;>(LA:7(:7;(>A??;<;6F;(A6(386:4@(K@;(B?(;I8E9D;@=(D;8>@(

K@(:B(FB6FDK>;(:78:=(A6(:7;(@986(B?(:AE;(C;:L;;6(:7;(@;FB6>(:7+1+B4)286>(:7;(@)108A<9+59 2

-C2@-70*9=(386:(78@(C;FBE;(FB6F;<6;>(6B:(B6DH(LA:7(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:(A6(:7;(@;6@;(B?(

M<8>K8DDH(FBEA6M(:B(?B<EKD8:;(86>(8F:(K9B6(EB<8DDH(MBB>(E8IAE@(A6(98<:AFKD8<(F8@;@(CK:(

8D@B(A6(:7;(@;6@;(B?(F<;8:A6M(LA:7A6(:7;(8M;6:(:7;(FB6>A:AB6@(:78:(E8V;(:7A@(MBB>(E8IAEi

E8VA6M(9B@@ACD;J(%7A@(6;L(FB6F;<6(@7BL@(A:@;D?(A6(:7;@;(:LB(>A??;<;6F;@(A6@B?8<(8@(386:(

6BL(;E978@AP;@(:7;(6;;>(:B(>A@FBG;<(8(9<AB<A(EB<8D(FB6F;9:@=(L7AF7(E8V;(A:(9B@@ACD;(:B(

?B<EKD8:;(MBB>(E8IAE@=(86>(:B(E8V;(8(@A6MKD8<(>;FA@AB6(:B(C<;8V(8L8H(?<BE(GAF;=(L7AF7(

E8V;@(9B@@ACD;(M<8>K8D(EB<8D(9<BM<;@@(:BL8<>@(EB<8D(MBB>6;@@(A6(98<:AFKD8<(F8@;@J

45678)")"9-#0)2-*)++,$,"(,:-10,-;8&)(87-4<)7-=78)>

.BL(:78:(L;(78G;(A>;6:A?A;>(8(V;H(>A??;<;6F;(C;:L;;6(:7;(:7;B<A;@(B?(EB<8D(

>;G;DB9E;6:(A6(:7;@;(:LB(/BF:<A6;@(B?(1;:7B>=(L;(EK@:(DBBV(?B<(8(L8H(:B(;I9D8A6(L7H(

386:(LBKD>(78G;(C;FBE;(6;LDH(FB6F;<6;>(A6(7A@(D8:;<(L<A:A6M@(LA:7(8(VA6>(B?(@A6MKD8<=(

:<86@?B<E8:AG;=(86>(?K6>8E;6:8D(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:(A6(8>>A:AB6(:B(7A@(BD>;<(FB6F;<6(LA:7(

8(M<8>K8D(AE9<BG;E;6:(B?(:7;(EB<8D(LB<:7(B?(98<:AFKD8<(8F:AB6@J(#(68:K<8D(L8H(:B(?A6>(

@KF7(86(;I9D868:AB6(A@(:B(:K<6(:B(:7;(LB<V@(386:(L<B:;(A6(:7;(:AE;(C;:L;;6(:7;(@;FB6>(

:7+1+B4)286>(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*9J(%7;(EB@:(BCGABK@(F86>A>8:;(?B<(:7A@(A@(:7;(

!)*+,+-.=26B:(B6DH(C;F8K@;(A:(L8@(9KCDA@7;>(C;:L;;6(:7;@;(:LB(CK:(C;F8K@;=(A6(:7A@(LB<V=(

386:(;I9DAFA:DH(>A@FK@@;@(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:J

ad +;;(386:=(11=(dOa]_=(L7;<;(386:(6B:;@(:78:=(L7;6(B6;(FBEC8:@(B6;4@(68:K<8D(AE9KD@;@(S@K??AFA;6:DH=T(@7;(F86(SE8@:;<(:7;E(L7;6(8(@A:K8:AB6(FBE;@(K9(A6(L7AF7(:7;H(:7<;8:;6(EB<8DA:HJT

Page 77: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

d[%<8>A:AB68DDH=(:7;(!)*+,+-.278@(6B:(C;;6(FB6@A>;<;>(:B(C;(8(?B<E8D(98<:(B?(386:4@(

:7;B<H(B?(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:Ja\(%7A@(BEA@@AB6(DAV;DH(F86(C;(8::<ACK:;>(:B(:7;(?8F:(:78:(:7;(

!)*+,+-.(78@(:H9AF8DDH(6B:(;G;6(C;;6(FB6@A>;<;>(:B(FB7;<;(LA:7(386:4@(EB<8D(97ADB@B97H=(

8:(D8<M;=(8@(>A@FK@@;>(A6(!789:;<(*6;J-"BL;G;<=(8@(-(78G;(@7BL6(A6(:7;(9<;GABK@(F789:;<=(

:7;<;(A@(@:<B6M(;GA>;6F;(:78:(:7;(!)*+,+-.2>B;@(FB7;<;(LA:7(7A@(EB<8D(97ADB@B97H(A6@B?8<(

8@(A:(;I9D8A6@(86>(FD8<A?A;@(:LB(V;H(98<:@(B?(7A@(EB<8D(97ADB@B97H=(;I9D8A6A6M(CB:7(:7;(

@BK<F;(B?(EB<8D(;GAD(A6(7KE86@(86>(:7;(9B@@ACADA:H(B?(?<;;DH(F7BB@A6M(:B(C;(;GADJ(Y;F8K@;(

B?(:7A@=(A:(A@(LB<:7(FB6@A>;<A6M(L7;:7;<(:7;(!)*+,+-.2EAM7:(7;D9(K@(:B(FD8<A?H(7A@(EB<8D(

97ADB@B97H(A6(86B:7;<(L8H(N(A6(:7;(>;G;DB9E;6:(B?(7A@(:7;B<H(B?(EB<8D(AE9<BG;E;6:J(-(

LADD(:K<6=(:7;6=(:B(86(A6G;@:AM8:AB6(B?(L7;:7;<(L78:(A@(L<A::;6(A6(:7A@(LB<V(EAM7:(C;(:7;(

@BK<F;(B?(:7;(>A??;<;6F;(:78:(899;8<@(A6(7A@(:7;B<H(B?(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:(A6(7A@(E8eB<(

LB<V@(B6(EB<8D(97ADB@B97HJ

-6(:7;(!)*+,+-.=2386:(A6:<B>KF;@(8(6;L(FB6F;<6(<;D8:;>(:B(:7;(A@@K;(B?(7BL(7KE86@(

F86(C;FBE;(EB<8DDH(MBB>O(:7;(9<BCD;E(B?(BG;<FBEA6M(<8>AF8D(;GADJ(#@(>A@FK@@;>(A6(

!789:;<(*6;=(386:4@(8<MKE;6:(:78:(8DD(7KE86@(8<;(<8>AF8DDH(;GAD(F<;8:;@(8(@;<ABK@(A@@K;(?B<(

7A@(EB<8D(97ADB@B97H=(A6@B?8<(8@(A:(8998<;6:DH(E8V;@(8(9;<@B6(K68CD;(:B(E8V;(EB<8DDH(

MBB>(F7BAF;@=(86>(:7;<;CH(A6:<B>KF;@(:7;(6;;>(?B<(8(@BDK:AB6(:B(BG;<FBEA6M(:7;(9<BCD;E(

B?(<8>AF8D(;GAD(86>(B6F;(8M8A6(B9;6A6M(:7;(9B@@ACADA:H(B?(C;A6M(EB<8DDH(MBB>J(386:4@(

@BDK:AB6(:B(:7A@(9<BCD;E(A@(:7;(A6:<B>KF:AB6(B?(:7;(<;GBDK:AB6(B?(B6;4@(%)9+..4.,=(L7AF7(

a\ -6(:7;(@;FB6>8<H(DA:;<8:K<;(B6(386:4@(:7;B<H(B?(EB<8D(;>KF8:AB6(86>(>;G;DB9E;6:=(:7;(!)*+,+-.2A@(:H9AF8DDH(K@;>(B6DH(8@(8(LB<V(:78:(FD8<A?A;@(@BE;(FB6F;9:@(K@;>(A6(:7;(EB<8D(97ADB@B97HJ(-:(A@(<8<;DH=(A?(;G;<=(9K:(?B<:7(8@(8(E8eB<(LB<V(A6(386:4@(?B<E8D(:7;B<H(B?(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:J(2B<(;I8E9D;@=(@;;(,;LA@()7A:;(Y;FV=(S386:(B6(&>KF8:AB6^T(Y8<C8<8(";<E86=(S%<8A6A6M(:B(#K:B6BEHO(386:(86>(:7;(qK;@:AB6(B?(1B<8D(&>KF8:AB6=T(DA+*-9-8A)792-.2"34501+-.62>+91-7+50*2D)798)51+F)9=2;>J(#ErDA;(*V@;6C;<M('B<:H(U.;L(5B<VO('BK:D;>M;=(Q[[]X^(38:;(#J(1B<86=(S!86(386:("8G;(86(#FFBK6:(B?(1B<8D(&>KF8:AB6nT(N-47.0*2-C2DA+*-9-8A<2a`J(aJ(URWW[X^(86>(cJ(2;DAFA:8@(1K6P;D=(S386:(B6(1B<8D(&>KF8:AB6=(B<(4&6DAM7:;6E;6:4(86>(:7;(,AC;<8D(#<:@JT

Page 78: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

\WA6GBDG;@(8(SF786M;(B?(7;8<:JTa](";(L<A:;@=(S-?(CH(8(@A6MD;(86>(K68D:;<8CD;(>;FA@AB6(8(

7KE86(C;A6M(<;G;<@;@(:7;(@K9<;E;(M<BK6>(B?(7A@(E8IAE@(CH(L7AF7(7;(L8@(86(;GAD(7KE86(

C;A6M(U86>(:7;<;CH(9K:@(B6(8(46;L(E864X=(7;(A@(:B(:7A@(;I:;6:=(CH(9<A6FA9D;(86>(8::A:K>;(B?(

EA6>=(8(@KCe;F:(<;F;9:AG;(:B(:7;(MBB>JJJTa[(cB<>B6(&J(1AF78D@B6=(h<J(<;?;<@(:B(:7A@(F786M;(

8@(SEB<8D(<;M;6;<8:AB6=T(B<(S:7;(:<86@?B<E8:AB6(B?(:7;(K6>;<DHA6M(>A@9B@A:AB6(N(B<(

@K9<;E;(E8IAE(N(?<BE(;GAD(:B(MBB>JT_W

386:(A@(FD;8<(:78:(:7A@(VA6>(B?(EB<8D(F786M;(A@(>A??;<;6:(?<BE(:7;(VA6>(B?(EB<8D(

F786M;(:78:(7;(:8DV;>(8CBK:(A6(9D8F;@(@KF7(8@(:7;(@;FB6>(:7+1+B4)?2-6(:7;(!)*+,+-.=27;(

>A@:A6MKA@7;@(C;:L;;6(:7;(<;GBDK:AB6(B?(%)9+..4.,=(8@(8(VA6>(B?(EB<8D(AE9<BG;E;6:=(86>(

86(AE9<BG;E;6:(A6(:7;(EB<8D(MBB>6;@@(B?(8(9;<@B64@(8F:AB6@(86>(F7BAF;@J(%7;(E8eB<(

>A??;<;6F;(C;:L;;6(:7;@;(A@(:78:(:7;(?B<E;<(VA6>(B?(AE9<BG;E;6:(BFFK<@(:7<BKM7(8(

@A6MKD8<=(:<86@?B<E8:AG;(>;FA@AB6(:B(F786M;(:7;(9<A6FA9D;(:78:(B<>;<@(B6;4@(9<AB<A:AP8:AB6(B?(

A6F;6:AG;@(U;A:7;<(@;D?iDBG;(B<(>K:HX(L7AD;(:7;(D8::;<(BFFK<@(:7<BKM7(M<8>K8D(9<BF;@@(BG;<(

:AE;J(386:(L<A:;@(:78:(:7;(B6;i:AE;(>;FA@AB6(:B(78G;(8(MBB>(?K6>8E;6:8D(E8IAE(E8V;@(8(

9;<@B6(MBB>(A6(:7;(@;6@;(:78:(7;(A@(S<;F;9:AG;(:B(:7;(MBB>T_Q(86>(?K6>8E;6:8DDH(

FBEEA::;>(:B(9<AB<A:APA6M(:7;(EB:AG;@(B?(>K:H(8CBG;(EB:AG;@(B?(@;D?iDBG;(CK:(C;FBEA6M(

MBB>(A6(:7;(@;6@;(B?(9;<?B<EA6M(MBB>(8F:AB6@(<;bKA<;@(M<8>K8D(9<BM<;@@J(";(L<A:;@(:78:(

B6F;(8(9;<@B6(K6>;<MB;@(:7;(<;GBDK:AB6=(S7;(F86(7B9;(N(A6(GA;L(B?(:7;(9K<A:H(B?(:7;(

9<A6FA9D;(L7AF7(7;(78@(8>B9:;>(8@(:7;(@K9<;E;(E8IAE(B?(7A@(9BL;<(B?(F7BAF;=(86>(A6(

a] 386:=(!)*+,+-.=2dOa\J

a[ 386:=(!)*+,+-.=2dOa]J(USJJJL;66(;<(>;6(BC;<@:;6(c<K6>(@;A6;<(18IAE;6=(LB>K<F7(;<(;A6(Cl@;<(1;6@F7(L8<=(>K<F7(;A6;(;A6PAM;(K6L86>;DC8<;(&6:@F7DA;kK6M(KEV;7<:(UK6>(7;A<EA:(;A6;6(6;K;6(1;6@F7;6(86PA;7:X=(@B(A@:(;<(@B?;<6=(>;E($<A6PA9(K6>(>;<(/;6VK6M@8<:(68F7=(;A6(?j<@(cK:;(;E9?m6MDAF7;@(+KCe;V:JJJTX

_W 1AF78D@B6=(R0**).2R7))3-;=(\\J

_Q 386:=(!)*+,+-.=2dOa]J

Page 79: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

\QGA;L(B?(:7;(@:8CADA:H(B?(:7A@(9<A6FA9D;(N(:B(?A6>(7AE@;D?(K9B6(:7;(MBB>(U:7BKM7(68<<BLX(

98:7(B?(FB6@:86:(87-,7)992?<BE(C8>(:B(C;::;<JT_R()7AD;(:7;(<;GBDK:AB6(B6DH(<;bKA<;@(8(

@A6MKD8<(F786M;=(A6@B?8<(8@(A:(<;bKA<;@(:7;(F7BAF;(:B(C;FBE;(EB<8DDH(MBB>(A6(:7;(@;6@;(B?(

78GA6M(8(MBB>(?K6>8E;6:8D(E8IAE=(C;A6M(EB<8DDH(MBB>(A6(:7;(@;6@;(B?(E8VA6M(MBB>(

F7BAF;@(A6(98<:AFKD8<(F8@;@(LADD(@:ADD(<;bKA<;(M<8>K8D(F786M;(BG;<(:AE;J

$8<8DD;D@(C;:L;;6(:7;(!)*+,+-.(86>(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*9

#:(:7A@(9BA6:=(A:(A@(FD;8<(:78:(:7;<;(A@(8(@7A?:(A6(386:4@(8FFBK6:(B?(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:(

A6(:7;(:AE;(C;:L;;6(:7;(@;FB6>(:7+1+B4)286>(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*9=2B<=(EB<;(

M;6;<8DDH=(C;:L;;6(7A@(;8<DA;<(8FFBK6:(B?(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:(86>(7A@(D8:;<(8FFBK6:?2-:(A@(

8D@B(FD;8<(:78:(386:(A6:<B>KF;@(8(6;L(:H9;(B?(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:(A6(:7;(!)*+,+-.=28(LB<V(

:78:(L8@(L<A::;6(86>(9KCDA@7;>(C;:L;;6(:7;@;(:LB(LB<V@(UQ\[aXJ(YK:(:7A@(A@(6B:(H;:(

;6BKM7(;GA>;6F;(:B(@7BL(:78:(L78:(386:(@:8:;@(8CBK:(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:(A6(:7;(!)*+,+-.2

A@(<;@9B6@ACD;(?B<(:7A@(>A??;<;6F;(A6(7A@(8FFBK6:(B?(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:(A6(7A@(EB<8D(

97ADB@B97H=(B<(;G;6(:78:(A:(AE98F:@(7A@(:7;B<H(B?(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:(8:(8DDJ(%B(@K99B<:(:7A@(

FD8AE=(:7;6=(:7;(A6?DK;6F;(B?(:7;(!)*+,+-.2B6(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*92EK@:(C;(E8>;(

EB<;(;I9DAFA:J-);(EK@:(C;(8CD;(:B(?A6>(:7;(@BK<F;(B?(:7A@(>A??;<;6F;(A6(:7;(!)*+,+-.J

-(LADD(9<BGA>;(:7A@(@B<:(B?(;I9DAFA:(;GA>;6F;(CH(@7BLA6M(:78:(386:4@(6;L(A>;8@(

8CBK:(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:(:78:(8<A@;(A6(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*928<;(<BB:;>(A6(7A@(

>A@FK@@AB6(B?(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:(?<BE(:7;(!)*+,+-.?2-6(?8F:=(:7;<;(8<;(E86H(9BA6:@(A6(:7A@(

/BF:<A6;(B?(1;:7B>(8:(L7AF7(386:(A@(K@A6M(:7;(@8E;=(B<(;I:<;E;DH(@AEAD8<=(:;<E@(86>(

97<8@;@(:78:(7;(K@;>(L7;6(>;@F<ACA6M(:7;(<;GBDK:AB6(B?(%)9+..4.,(A6(:7;(!)*+,+-.? 2

_R -CA>J(USJJJ;<(V866(7B??;6=(>8k(;<(C;A(;A6;<(@BDF7;6(';A6AMV;A:(>;@($<A6PA9@=(L;DF7;@(;<(@AF7(PK<(BC;<@:;6(18IAE;(@;A6;<()ADDVj<(M;66BE;6(78:=(K6>(>;<(2;@:AMV;A:(>;@@;DC;6=(@AF7(8K?(>;E(MK:;6(UBCLB7D(@F7E8D;6X();M;(;A6;@(C;@:m6>AM;6(2B<:@F7<;A:;6@(GBE(+F7D;F7:;6(PKE(Y;@@;<;6(C;?A6>;JTX

Page 80: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

\RY;F8K@;(:7A@(:H9;(B?(D86MK8M;(>B;@(6B:(BFFK<(A6(7A@(L<A:A6M@(C;?B<;(:7;(!)*+,+-.=2A:(A@(

<;8@B68CD;(:B(8@@KE;(:78:(386:(A@(K@A6M(:7;(FB6F;9:@(86>(8<MKE;6:@(:78:(7;(9<;@;6:;>(A6(

:7;(!)*+,+-.2:B(A6?DK;6F;(7A@(8FFBK6:(B?(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:(A6(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*9? 2

Y;?B<;(D8HA6M(BK:(:7;(;GA>;6F;(?B<(EH(FD8AE=(A:(A@(AE9B<:86:(:B(6B:;(:78:=(L7AD;(?;L(

FBEE;6:8:B<@(FB6@A>;<(:7;(!)*+,+-.2:B(C;(8(?B<E8D(98<:(B?(386:4@(:7;B<H(B?(EB<8D(

>;G;DB9E;6:(86>(;>KF8:AB6=(:7;<;(8<;(FBEE;6:8:B<@(L7B(9BA6:(:B(@BE;(FB66;F:AB6@(

C;:L;;6(:7;(!)*+,+-.286>(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*9J(%7;@;(:7A6V;<@(9<AE8<ADH(K@;(

98@@8M;@(?<BE(:7;(!)*+,+-.2A6(B<>;<(:B(FD8<A?H(@;F:AB6@(A6(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*9=286>(

B:7;<(LB<V@(:78:(L;<;(L<A::;6(8?:;<(:7;(!)*+,+-.=2@KF7(8@(:7;(H.1A7-8-*-,<?22B<(;I8E9D;=(

Y8<C8<8(";<E86(K@;@(:7;(!)*+,+-.2:B(;I9D8A6(L78:(7KE86(68:K<;(EB<8D(;>KF8:AB6(8AE@(:B(

:<8A6_`(86>(386:4@(K6>;<@:86>A6M(B?(:7;(7KE86(LADDJ_a(#>>A:AB68DDH=(L7;6($8KD(2B<EB@8(

>A@FK@@;@(:7;(:;6@AB6(C;:L;;6(:7;(:LB(:H9;@(B?(EB<8D(F786M;=(L7AF7(7;(F8DD@(M<8>K8D(86>(

EBE;6:8<H=(A6(386:4@(EB<8D(:7;B<H=(7;(K@;@(:7;(!)*+,+-.28@(86(;I8E9D;(B?(EBE;6:8<H(

F786M;J__(%7;<;?B<;=(L7AD;(A:(A@(6B:(:H9AF8D(A6(:7;(@;FB6>8<H(DA:;<8:K<;(:B(9BA6:(:B(:7;(

!)*+,+-.28@(:7;(@BK<F;(B?(F786M;@(A6(386:4@(8FFBK6:(B?(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:=(A:(A@(M;6;<8DDH(

<;FBM6AP;>(:78:(:7;<;(8<;(@BE;(FB66;F:AB6@(C;:L;;6(L78:(386:(@8H@(A6(:7A@(LB<V(86>(

L78:(7;(L<A:;@(A6(LB<V@(8?:;<(A:=(@KF7(8@(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*9?

%7;(>A??;<;6F;@(C;:L;;6(386:4@(;8<DA;<(86>(D8:;<(8FFBK6:@(B?(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:(

9BA6:;>(:B(A6(:7;(?A<@:(@;F:AB6(N(UQX(8(F786M;(A6(:7;(K@;(B?(;I8E9D;@(86>(URX(8(6;L(FB6F;<6(

?B<(8(@A6MKD8<=(:<86@?B<E8:AG;(>;FA@AB6(:B(C;(EB<8DDH(MBB>(N(CB:7(F86(C;(@7BL6(:B(C;(

<BB:;>(A6(:7;(!)*+,+-.4@(8FFBK6:(B?(7BL(8(9;<@B6(F86(BG;<FBE;(<8>AF8D(;GADJ(-(LADD(:<;8:(:7;(

_` ";<E86=(S%<8A6A6M(:B(#K:B6BEH=T(R_]J

_a -CA>=(RdQJ

__ 2B<EB@8=(S2<BE(/A@FA9DA6;(:B(#K:B6BEH=T(Q\`J

Page 81: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

\`;GA>;6F;(?B<(:7;@;(:LB(>A??;<;6F;@(C;A6M(<BB:;>(A6(:7;(!)*+,+-.29)80701)*<?(2A<@:=(8@(L;(

78G;(@;;6(A6(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*9=2386:(C;MA6@(:B(K@;(;I8E9D;@(B?(8(>A??;<;6:(VA6>(

N(7H9B:7;:AF8D=(<8:7;<(:786(<;8D(i(86>(?B<(8(>A??;<;6:(9K<9B@;(:786(7;(>B;@(A6(:7;(8FFBK6:(B?(

EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:(A6(:7;(@;FB6>(:7+1+B4)?(%7A@(6;L(86>(>A??;<;6:(K@;(B?(;I8E9D;@(A@(:B(

7;D9(K@(:B(DBF8:;(8(9<AB<A(EB<8D(FB6F;9:@(LA:7A6(BK<(BL6(<;8@B6J(-6:;<;@:A6MDH=(8(G;<H(

@AEAD8<(K@;(B?(;I8E9D;@(A@(?BK6>(A6(:7;(!)*+,+-.?ST2-6(:7A@(LB<V=(8@(6B:;>(8CBG;=(386:(

L<A:;@(:78:(EB<8D(MBB>6;@@=(A6(:7;(@;6@;(B?(78GA6M(8(MBB>(%)9+..4.,=(F866B:(C;(8F7A;G;>(

LA:7BK:(?A<@:(DBF8:A6M(:7;(FB6F;9:(B?(EB<8D(MBB>6;@@(LA:7A6(B6;4@(BL6(<;8@B6=(CH(E;86@(

B?(:7;(7H9B:7;:AF8D(;I8E9D;(B?(:7;(EB<8D(9<B:B:H9;J(-6(CB:7(LB<V@=(:7;6=(386:(K@;@(:7;(

@8E;(VA6>(B?(;I8E9D;=(7H9B:7;:AF8D=(?B<(:7;(@8E;(;6>J

YB:7(LB<V@(A6@:<KF:(:7;(<;8>;<(:B(?A6>(:7;(FB6F;9:(B?(:7;(EB<8D(MBB>(LA:7A6(7;<(

<;8@B6(A6(:7;(@8E;(L8H(N(:7<BKM7(:7;(K@;(B?(8(EB<8D(9<B:B:H9;=(L7AF7(;IA@:@(A6(BK<(BL6(

<;8@B6J(-6(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*4@(/BF:<A6;(B?(1;:7B>=(386:(L<A:;@(:78:(8-

MBB>(;I8E9D;(U;I;E9D8<H(FB6>KF:X(@7BKD>(6B:(@;<G;(8@(8(EB>;D(CK:(B6DH(8@(8(9<BB?(:78:(A:(A@(<;8DDH(9B@@ACD;(:B(8F:(A6(FB6?B<EA:H(LA:7(>K:HJ(+B(A:(A@(6B:(FBE98<A@B6(LA:7(86H(B:7;<(7KE86(C;A6M(L78:@B;G;<(U8@(7;(A@X=(CK:(LA:7(:7;(+3)02UB?(7KE86A:HX=(8@(7;(BKM7:(:B(C;=(86>(@B(FBE98<A@B6(LA:7(:7;(D8L=(:78:(EK@:(@;<G;(8@(:7;(FB6@:86:(@:86>8<>(B?(8(:;8F7;<4@(A6@:<KF:AB6J_\

%7A@(@BK6>@(G;<H(EKF7(DAV;(386:4@(>;@F<A9:AB6(B?(:7;(EB<8D(9<B:B:H9;(A6(:7;(!)*+,+-.= 2

L7;<;(7;(6B:;@(:78:(L;(F86(B6DH(?B<E(8(FB6F;9:(B?(L78:(A:(E;86@(:B(C;(EB<8DDH(MBB>(A?(

L;(F86(DBF8:;(:7;(S9;<@B6A?A;>(A>;8(B?(:7;(MBB>(9<A6FA9D;=T(B<(:7;(EB<8D(9<B:B:H9;(A6(BK<(

BL6(<;8@B6J_]

);(F86(@;;=(?<BE(:7;@;(@AEAD8<A:A;@(A6(D86MK8M;(86>(8<MKE;6:=(:78:(386:(EAEAF@(

_d +;;(386:=(!)*+,+-.=2dOdW(N(dOdRJ

_\ 386:=(11=2dOa]WJ

_] 386:=(!)*+,+-.=2dOdW(i(dOdQJ

Page 82: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

\a7A@(6;L(:7;B<H(B?(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:(?<BE(:7;(!)*+,+-.=(8:(D;8@:(A6(98<:=(A6(:7;(

@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*94@(/BF:<A6;(B?(1;:7B>J(Y;F8K@;(:7;(!)*+,+-.4@(K@;(B?(7H9B:7;:AF8D(

;I8E9D;@(B?(8(9;<?;F:(7KE86A:H(8AE;>(8:(7;D9A6M(8(9;<@B6(:B(?A6>(:7;(FB6F;9:@(B?(EB<8DA:H(

LA:7A6(7;<(BL6(<;8@B6(A@(6B:(@;;6(A6(386:4@(:7;B<H(B?(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:(9<AB<(:B(:7;(

!)*+,+-.2CK:(>B;@(899;8<(A6(:7;(E8eB<(EB<8D(LB<V(9KCDA@7;>(8?:;<(A:=(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C 2

@-70*9=2:7;<;(A@(MBB>(<;8@B6(:B(C;DA;G;(:78:(:7;(!)*+,+-.2F86(;I9D8A6(:7A@(F786M;J(%7;(

@AEAD8<A:A;@(A6(D86MK8M;(A6(:7;(!)*+,+-.286>(:7;(/BF:<A6;(B?(1;:7B>(?<BE(:7;(@)108A<9+59 2

-C2@-70*92B6DH(@:<;6M:7;6@(BK<(<;8@B6@(?B<(C;DA;GA6M(:7A@J

+;FB6>=(386:4@(A6:<B>KF:AB6(B?(:7;(6;;>(?B<(8(<;GBDK:AB6(B?(%)9+..4.,(A6(:7;(

!)*+,+-.27;D9@(:B(;I9D8A6(:7;(:8DV(B?(:7;(6;;>(?B<(8(@K>>;6=(B6;i:AE;(F7BAF;(:B(C;(EB<8DDH(

MBB>(A6(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*9=2L7AF7=(8@(6B:;>(8CBG;=(78@(6B:(C;;6(@K??AFA;6:DH(

;I9D8A6;>(CH(:7A6V;<@(A6(:7;(@;FB6>8<H(DA:;<8:K<;?()7;6(L;(FBE98<;(:7;(!)*+,+-.2LA:7(:7;(

@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*9=(A:(A@(;8@H(:B(@;;(:78:(386:4@(FD8AE(:78:(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:(<;bKA<;@(

8(@A6MKD8<=(:<86@?B<E8:AG;(>;FA@AB6(F86(C;(;I9D8A6;>(CH(FD8AE@(:78:(8<A@;(<;M8<>A6M(<8>AF8D(

;GAD(:7;(!)*+,+-.?2386:(K@;@(G;<H(@AEAD8<(D86MK8M;(A6(>;@F<ACA6M(:7A@(>;FA@AB6(A6(:7;(:LB(

LB<V@J(2A<@:=(A6(:7;(!)*+,+-.=2386:(L<A:;@(:78:-S8(7KE86(C;A6M4@(EB<8D(;>KF8:AB6(EK@:(

C;MA6=(6B:(LA:7(86(AE9<BG;E;6:(B?(EB<;@=(CK:(LA:7(:7;(:<86@?B<E8:AB6(B?(7A@(8::A:K>;(B?(

EA6>(86>(:7;(;@:8CDA@7E;6:(B?(8(F78<8F:;<=(8D:7BKM7(A:(A@(FK@:BE8<H(:B(9<BF;;>(B:7;<LA@;(

86>(:B(?AM7:(GAF;@(A6>AGA>K8DDH=(L7AD;(D;8GA6M(:7;A<(K6AG;<@8D(<BB:(K6>A@:K<C;>JT_[(

+AEAD8<DH=(A6(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*9=27;(L<A:;@(:78:(S:7;(>;FA@AB6(:B(>B(:7A@(f:B(C;(

GA<:KBK@g(EK@:(C;(E8>;(8DD(8:(B6F;(86>(FBE9D;:;DH=(@A6F;(8(>A@9B@A:AB6(U86AEK@X(:B(

@K<<;6>;<(8:(:AE;@(:B(GAF;=(A6(B<>;<(:B(C<;8V(8L8H(?<BE(A:(M<8>K8DDH=(LBKD>(A:@;D?(C;(

_[ 386:=(!)*+,+-.=2dOa]J

Page 83: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

\_AE9K<;(86>(;G;6(GAFABK@=(86>(@B(FBKD>(C<A6M(8CBK:(6B(GA<:K;(UL7AF7(A@(C8@;>(B6(8(@A6MD;(

9<A6FA9D;XJTdW("A@(A6:<B>KF:AB6(B?(:7A@(6;;>(?B<(@KF7(8(F7BAF;(A6(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:(FD;8<DH(

;F7B;@(:7;(D86MK8M;(?<BE(:7;(!)*+,+-.?2YB:7(9<;@;6:(:7A@(VA6>(B?(@A6MKD8<(F7BAF;=(FB6:<8@:(

A:(LA:7(8(M<8>K8D(F786M;=(86>(>A@FK@@(L7H(:7A@(VA6>(B?(F7BAF;(A@(EB<;(;??;F:AG;(A6(?AM7:A6M(

GAF;@J

%7;<;(A@(?K<:7;<(9<BB?=(:7BKM7=(:78:(386:(A@(DAV;DH(:8DVA6M(8CBK:(:7;(G;<H(@8E;(

@A6MKD8<=(:<86@?B<E8:AG;(F7BAF;(A6(CB:7(LB<V@=(:7;(F7BAF;(B?(8(F786M;(A6(%)9+..4.,J(

%7;<;(8<;(:LB(<;8@B6@(?B<(:7A6VA6M(:78:(:7A@(F7BAF;(:78:(386:(:8DV@(8CBK:(A6(:7;(

@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*92A@(:7;(@8E;(F7BAF;(8@(A6(:7;(!)*+,+-.J(2A<@:=(:7<BKM7(8(98<8DD;D(A6(

D86MK8M;=(L;(F86(@;;(:78:(386:(A@(DAV;DH(8@@KEA6M(:7;(@8E;(@:8<:A6M(9D8F;(?B<(EB<8DA:H(

:78:(7;(>A>(A6(:7;(!)*+,+-.2O(7KE86@(8@(<8>AF8DDH(;GADJ(-?(7;(A@(8@@KEA6M(:78:(7KE86(EB<8D(

>;G;DB9E;6:(EK@:(@:8<:(LA:7(7KE86@(A6(8(@:8:;(B?(<8>AF8D(;GAD=(:7;6(:7;(B6;i:AE;(>;FA@AB6(

:78:(7;(@8H@(A@(6;F;@@8<H(?B<(:7;(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:(A6(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*92A@(DAV;DH(

:7;(@8E;(F7BAF;(:78:(386:(A@(:8DVA6M(8CBK:(A6(:7;(!)*+,+-.=2A6@B?8<(8@(CB:7(8<;(F7BAF;@(:B(

BG;<FBE;(:7;(BC@:8FD;(B?(<8>AF8D(;GAD?dQ(+;FB6>=(A6(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*9=2386:(

;F7B;@(:7;(D86MK8M;(B?(:7;(6;;>(?B<(8(F786M;(B?(7;8<:(:78:(899;8<@(A6(:7;(!)*+,+-.?2-6(:7;(

!)*+,+-.=2:7A@(97<8@;(L8@(;bK8:;>(LA:7(:7;(F786M;(A6(%)9+..4.,(?<BE(;GAD(:B(MBB>J

)7AD;(386:(>B;@(6B:(;I9DAFA:DH(@:8:;(:78:(7;(8@@KE;@(8(@:8<:A6M(9D8F;(B?(<8>AF8D(;GAD(

A6(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*9=27;(;F7B;@(:7;(D86MK8M;(A6(:7;(!)*+,+-.2:78:(7;(K@;@(:B(

dW 386:=(11=2dOa\\J

d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bKA<;@=(A:(F86(@:ADD(C;(FB6@A>;<;>(:7;(@8E;(F7BAF;(A6@B?8<(8@(CB:7(8AE(8:(:7;(@8E;(MB8D(N(BG;<FBEA6M(:7;(BC@:8FD;(B?(<8>AF8D(;GADJ

Page 84: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

\d;I9D8A6(L7H(L;(@7BKD>(8FF;9:(:78:(8DD(7KE86@(8<;(<8>AF8DDH(;GADJ(-6(:7;(!)*+,+-.=27;(L<A:;@(

:78:(

f8g(E;EC;<(B?(:7;(&6MDA@7($8<DA8E;6:(;IFD8AE;>(A6(:7;(7;8:(B?(>;C8:;O(4&G;<H(E86(78@(7A@(9<AF;=(?B<(L7AF7(7;(@;DD@(7AE@;D?J4(-?(:7A@(A@(:<K;(U86>(;G;<HB6;(F86(>;FA>;(CH(7AE@;D?XJJJ:7;6=(L78:(:7;(#9B@:D;(@8H@(EAM7:(A6>;;>(7BD>(:<K;(B?(7KE86(C;A6M@(K6AG;<@8DDH=(4%7;<;(A@(6B(>A@:A6F:AB6(7;<;=(:7;H(8<;(8DD(K6>;<(@A6(N(:7;<;(A@(6B6;(<AM7:;BK@(UA6(:7;(@9A<A:(B?(:7;(D8LX=(6B=(6B:(B6;J4dR

";<;=(386:(K@;@(8@(8(VA6>(B?(9<BB?(?B<(:7;(K6AG;<@8DA:H(B?(<8>AF8D(;GAD(:78:(;G;<H(9;<@B6(

78@(8(9<AF;(8:(L7AF7(7;(LBKD>(@;DD(7AE@;D?=(B<=(A6(B:7;<(LB<>@=(:78:(L;(8<;(8DD(@K@F;9:ACD;(

:B(:7;(:;E9:8:AB6@(B?(A6FDA68:AB6J(

%7;<;(8<;(;F7B;@(B?(:7A@(98@@8M;(?<BE(:7;(!)*+,+-.(A6(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*9? 2

S2B<(K6D;@@(:7;(>AM6A:H(B?(GA<:K;(A@(;I8D:;>(8CBG;(;G;<H:7A6M(;D@;(A6(8F:AB6@=(:7;(FB6F;9:(

B?(>K:H(A:@;D?(G86A@7;@(86>(>A@@BDG;@(A6:B(E;<;(9<8ME8:AF(9<;F;9:@=(@A6F;(8(7KE86(C;A6M4@(

FB6@FABK@6;@@(B?(7A@(BL6(6BCADA:H(:7;6(>A@899;8<@(86>(7;(A@(?B<(@8D;(86>(F86(C;(CBKM7:(?B<(

8(9<AF;(:78:(:7;(@;>KF:AG;(A6FDA68:AB6@(B??;<(7AEJTd`(-6(:7A@(98@@8M;=(7;(A@(:8DVA6M(8CBK:(:7;(

6;;>(?B<(8(@A6MD;(EB<8D(9<A6FA9D;(:78:(9<AB<A:AP;@(GA<:K;(8CBG;(GAF;(6B:(C;F8K@;(B?(86H(

FB6@;bK;6F;@(B?(;A:7;<(CK:(C;F8K@;(B?(:7;(A67;<;6:(>AM6A:H(B?(GA<:K;J(-6(:7;(bKB:;(8CBG;=(

7;(A@(9BA6:A6M(BK:(:78:=(A?(B6;(>B;@(6B:(9<AB<A:AP;(GA<:K;(8CBG;(GAF;=(:78:(9;<@B6(LADD(

C;FBE;(@K@F;9:ACD;(:B(:7;(:;E9:8:AB6@(B?(A6FDA68:AB6J(%7A@(A@(;@@;6:A8DDH(:7;(@8E;(9BA6:(

:78:(7;(E8>;(A6(:7;(!)*+,+-.=2L7;6(7;(K@;>(:7;(D86MK8M;(B?(C;A6M(@BD>(?B<((9<AF;J(-6(CB:7(

LB<V@=(7;(A@(9BA6:A6M(:B(:7;(9<BCD;E(B?(<8>AF8D(;GAD=(L7AF7(8<A@;@(L7;6(:7;(EB<8D(D8L(A@(

6B:(9<AB<A:AP;>(BG;<(:7;(EB:AG8:AB6@(B?(A6FDA68:AB6@J(Y;F8K@;(B?(:7A@(98<8DD;D(D86MK8M;=(A:(A@(

dR 386:=(!)*+,+-.=2dO`[J

d` 386:=(11=2dOa]`J(US/;66(L;66(>A;()j<>;(>;<(%KM;6>(A6("86>DK6M;6(6AF7:(jC;<(8DD;@(;<7BC;6(LA<>=(@B(G;<@F7LA6>;:(>;<($?DAF7:C;M<A??(@;DC@:=(K6>(P;<<A66:(A6(CDB@@;(9<8ME8:A@F7;(0B<@F7<A?:;6^(>8(>866(>;<(#>;D(>;@(1;6@F7;6(A6(@;A6;E(;AM;6;6(Y;LK@@:@;A6(G;<@F7LA6>;:=(K6>(;<(?j<(;A6;6($<;A@:(?;AD(A@:(K6>(PK(38K?(@:;7:=(>;6(A7E(G;<?j7<;<A@F7;(.;AMK6M;6(86CA;:;6JTX

Page 85: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

\\<;8@B68CD;(:B(8@@KE;(:78:(386:(A@(9BA6:A6M(:B(:7;(9<BCD;E(B?(<8>AF8D(;GAD(?<BE(:7;(

!)*+,+-.2A6(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*9?2);(@7BKD>(:8V;(:7A@(98@@8M;=(:7;6=(:B(A6>AF8:;(:B(

K@(:78:(386:(A@(FB6F;<6;>(8CBK:(<8>AF8D(;GAD=(L7AF7(A@(86(A6A:A8D(BC@:8FD;(:B(EB<8D(

>;G;DB9E;6:J(-?(7;(8FV6BLD;>M;@(:7;(9<BCD;E(B?(<8>AF8D(;GAD=(:7;6(:7;(VA6>(B?(@A6MKD8<(

F7BAF;(:78:(7;(:8DVA6M(8CBK:(A@(DAV;DH(:7;(>;FA@AB6(:B(C<;8V(8L8H(?<BE(<8>AF8D(;GAD(86>=(

A6@:;8>=(9<AB<A:AP;(:7;(EB<8D(D8L=(B<(GA<:K;=(8CBG;(A6FDA68:AB6@=(B<(GAF;=(C;F8K@;(6B(

@KC@;bK;6:(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:(F86(BFFK<(LA:7BK:(?A<@:(BG;<FBEA6M(:7A@(BC@:8FD;J

%7;(@;FB6>(A6@:86F;(B?(98<8DD;D(D86MK8M;(:78:(A6>AF8:;@(:B(K@(:78:(386:(A@(:8DVA6M(

8CBK:(:7;(@8E;(@A6MKD8<=(:<86@?B<E8:AG;(F7BAF;(A6(CB:7(LB<V@(A@(7A@(K@;(B?(F786M;(B?(7;8<:(

D86MK8M;J(-6(:7;(!)*+,+-.=2386:(6B:;@(:78:(<8>AF8D(;GAD(MAG;@(K@(8(SFB<<K9:;>(7;8<:Tda(

UF)73)7I1).2>)7U).X(86>(:78:=(A6(B<>;<(:B(6B:(C;(<8>AF8DDH(;GAD(86HEB<;=(L;(EK@:(K6>;<MB(

8(SF786M;(B?(7;8<:T(UV.3)74.,23)92>)7U).9X=(8(F786M;(:78:(<;@KD:@(?<BE(8(F786M;(A6(BK<(

%)9+..4.,(?<BE(;GAD(:B(MBB>Jd_(386:(>B;@(6B:(;I9DAFA:DH(F8DD(?B<(8(F786M;(B?(7;8<:(A6(:7;(

@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*9=2CK:(7;(>B;@(@:<;@@(:78:(B6;(EK@:(78G;(8(F;<:8A6(VA6>(B?(7;8<:(A6(

:7A@(/BF:<A6;(B?(1;:7B>J(-6(:7;(S&:7AF8D(#@F;:AF@=T(:7;(98<:(B?(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C 2

@-70*9(92/BF:<A6;(B?(1;:7B>(:78:(F866B:(C;(:8KM7:=(386:(L<A:;@(:78:(EB<8D(MBB>6;@@(

<;bKA<;@(86(S;G;<iF7;;<?KD(7;8<:JTdd((%7A@(A@(6B:;LB<:7H(C;F8K@;(:7A@(<;bKA<;E;6:(DA;@(A6(

:7;(@;F:AB6(B?(:7;(/BF:<A6;(B?(1;:7B>(:78:(386:(@8H@(>;@F<AC;@(:7;(VA6>(B?(GA<:K;(:78:(A@(

<;bKA<;>(?B<(EB<8D(MBB>6;@@(CK:(F866B:(C;(:8KM7:J('8:7;<=(A:(EK@:(C;(F7B@;6(CH(:7;(

@:K>;6:(A6(:7A@(@A6MKD8<(F7BAF;J(Y;F8K@;(B6;(8FbKA<;@(:7A@(6;F;@@8<H(VA6>(B?(7;8<:(:7<BKM7(

:7A@(VA6>(B?(>;FA@AB6=(:7;<;(A@(<;8@B6(:B(C;DA;G;(:78:(:7A@(>A@FK@@AB6(B?(:7;(9<B9;<(VA6>(B?(

da 386:=(!)*+,+-.=2dOaaJ

d_ -CA>=2dOa\J

dd 386:=(11=2dOa]_J

Page 86: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

\]7;8<:(A6(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*92<;?;<@(C8FV(:B(:7;(FB6F;<6(8CBK:(78GA6M(8(F;<:8A6(VA6>(

B?(7;8<:(A6(:7;(!)*+,+-.=2L7AF7(8D@B(FBE;@(8CBK:(:7<BKM7(:7;(B6;i:AE;(F7BAF;J(%7A@(

9<BGA>;@(;G;6(@:<B6M;<(@K99B<:(?B<(:7;(FD8AE(:78:(:7;(F7BAF;(386:(:8DV@(8CBK:(A6(:7;(

@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*92A@(:7;(G;<H(@8E;(F7BAF;(7;(:8DV@(8CBK:(A6(:7;(!)*+,+-.?

?,/-@26,(#2-%+-3%$87-*,<,7%6>,"#-)"-#0,-"#$%&%'(

.BL(:78:(L;(78G;(;@:8CDA@7;>(:78:(:7A@(@7A?:(A6(386:4@(:7;B<H(B?(EB<8D(

>;G;DB9E;6:(A6(7A@(;:7AF8D(LB<V@(F86(DAV;DH(C;(8::<ACK:;>(:B(7A@(FD8AE(<;M8<>A6M(:7;(

K6AG;<@8DA:H(B?(<8>AF8D(;GAD(A6(:7;(!)*+,+-.=2A:(A@(6;F;@@8<H(:B(FB6@A>;<(L78:(:7;(!)*+,+-.2

FB6:<ACK:;@(:B(:7A@(:7;B<HJ()7AD;(L;(78G;(8D<;8>H(@;;6(:78:(A:(A6:<B>KF;@(:7;(6;;>(?B<(8(

@A6MKD8<=(:<86@?B<E8:AG;(F7BAF;(:78:(F<;8:;@(:7;(FB6>A:AB6@(?B<(:7;(9B@@ACADA:H(B?(86(

AE9<BG;E;6:(A6(:7;(EB<8D(LB<:7(B?(BK<(98<:AFKD8<(8F:AB6@=(:7;<;(A@(EKF7(EB<;(:B(C;(@8A>(

<;M8<>A6M(L78:(:7A@(@A6MKD8<=(:<86@?B<E8:AG;(F7BAF;(;6:8AD@(86>(7BL(A:(?A:@(A6:B(386:4@(

BG;<8<F7A6M(8FFBK6:(B?(7BL(8(7KE86(C;FBE;@(EB<8DDH(MBB>J(Y;F8K@;(-(LADD(@9;6>(:7;(

<;E8A6>;<(B?(:7A@(9<Be;F:(>;:8ADA6M(:7;(G8<ABK@(FBE9B6;6:@(B?(:7;(BG;<FBEA6M(B?(<8>AF8D(

;GAD=(-(LADD(7;<;(9<BGA>;(B6DH(8(C<A;?(BG;<GA;L(B?(L78:(:7A@(BG;<FBEA6M(;6:8AD@=(A6(B<>;<(:B(

9<BGA>;(8(E89(?B<(D8:;<(>A@FK@@AB6@J

#@(6B:;>(;8<DA;<=(L7;6(386:(A6:<B>KF;@(7A@(FD8AE(:78:(8DD(7KE86@(8<;(<8>AF8DDH(

;GAD=(7;(;E978@AP;@(:78:=(A6(@9A:;(B?(:7A@=(7KE86@(EK@:(@:ADD(C;(F898CD;(B?(BG;<FBEA6M(

<8>AF8D(;GAD(86>(C;FBEA6M(EB<8DDH(MBB>Jd\(%7;(<;8DA:H(:78:(L;(8<;(8DD(<8>AF8DDH(;GAD(A@(

E;<;DH(8(6;L(U:7BKM7(@AM6A?AF86:X(BC@:8FD;(A6(8::8A6A6M(7BDA6;@@(B?(:7;(LADD=(L7AF7(386:(

68E;@(8@(:7;(SFB6@:86:(:7BKM7(K68::8A68CD;T(MB8D(B?(BK<(EB<8D(AE9<BG;E;6:Jd]()7;6(L;(

d\ 2B<(86(;I8E9D;(B?(:7A@=(@;;(386:=(!)*+,+-.=2dOa_J

d] 386:=(!$<'=(_O]`=(_O]aJ(386:(6B:;@(:78:(:7A@(MB8D(A@(K68::8A68CD;(C;F8K@;=(A6(B<>;<(:B(78G;(8(7BDH(LADD=(L;(LBKD>(6;;>(:B(<A>(BK<@;DG;@(B?(8DD(A6FDA68:AB6@(:78:(FB6?DAF:(LA:7(BC;HA6M(:7;(EB<8D(D8L=(@KF7(:78:(:7;(EB<8D(D8L(F;8@;@(:B(C;(8(FBEE86>(86>(A6@:;8>(C;FBE;@(@BE;:7A6M(:78:(8DAM6@(LA:7(8DD(BK<(A6FDA68:AB6@J(

Page 87: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

\[FB6@A>;<(386:4@(8FFBK6:(B?(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:=(:7;6=(A:(A@(6;F;@@8<H(:B(:8V;(A6:B(

FB6@A>;<8:AB6(:7;(6;;>(:B(BG;<FBE;(<8>AF8D(;GADJ()A:7BK:(BG;<FBEA6M(BK<(;GAD(

%)9+..4.,).=2L;(F866B:(C;FBE;(EB<8DDH(MBB>(A6(:7;(@;6@;(:78:(386:(:8DV@(8CBK:(A6(:7;(

/BF:<A6;(B?(1;:7B>(A6(:7;(@;FB6>(:7+1+B4)=(L7AF7(A@(8F:A6M(B6(EB<8DDH(LB<:7H(E8IAE@=(

C;F8K@;(78GA6M(86(;GAD(%)9+..4.,2E;86@(:78:(L;(F866B:(F7BB@;(:B(>B(@B(A6(98<:AFKD8<(

F8@;@Jd[(-6(B<>;<(:B(EB<8DDH(AE9<BG;=(L;(:7;<;?B<;(EK@:(K6>;<MB(L78:(386:(F8DD@(8(

S<;GBDK:AB6T(B?(%)9+..4.,=2A6(L7AF7(B6;(E8V;@(8(@A6MKD8<(>;FA@AB6(L7AF7(S<;G;<@;@(:7;(

@K9<;E;(M<BK6>(B?(7A@(E8IAE@(CH(L7AF7(7;(L8@(86(;GAD(7KE86(C;A6M(86>(:7;<;CH(9K:@(B6(

8(46;L(E86J4T\W(%7A@(<;GBDK:AB6(LADD(8DDBL(8(9;<@B6=(L7B(L8@(9<;GABK@DH(<8>AF8DDH(;GAD=(:B(

@;:(BK:(B6(:7;(98:7(B?(M<8>K8D(AE9<BG;E;6:(A6(:7;(EB<8D(LB<:7(B?(7A@(8F:AB6@J\Q(-(LADD(

>A@FK@@(:7;(A6:<AF8FA;@(B?(:7A@(<;GBDK:AB6=(A6FDK>A6M(B:7;<=(<;D8:;>(F786M;@(:78:(EK@:(BFFK<=(

A6(EKF7(EB<;(>;:8AD(A6(!789:;<@(%7<;;(86>(2BK<J

)7AD;(:7A@(<;GBDK:AB6(B?(%)9+..4.,286>(A:@(B:7;<(<;D8:;>(F786M;@(FB6@:A:K:;(:7;(

DA:;<8D(BG;<FBEA6M(B?(<8>AF8D(;GAD(i(A6@B?8<(8@(:7;(F7BAF;(:78:(E8>;(B6;(<8>AF8DDH(;GAD=(:7;(

F7BAF;(:B(78G;(86(;GAD(%)9+..4.,=2A@(<;9D8F;>(CH(:7;(F7BAF;(:B(78G;(8(MBB>(%)9+..4.,2W2

386:(8D@B(E8V;@(6B:;(B?(8(?;L(:7A6M@(:78:(8(9;<@B6(EK@:(>B(9<AB<(:B(E8VA6M(:7A@(F7BAF;(:B(

<;G;<@;(B6;4@(9<AB<A:H(B?(A6F;6:AG;@=(L78:(-(LADD(F8DD(8(@:8M;(B?(S9<;i<;GBDK:AB68<H(

AE9<BG;E;6:JT()7AD;(7;(>B;@(6B:(D8H(:7;@;(BK:(A6(8(>A@:A6F:(B<(@H@:;E8:AF(L8H=(7;(

%78:(A@=(A:(LBKD>(C;(@BE;:7A6M(:78:(L;(LBKD>(?BDDBL(SMD8>DHT(U_O]`XJ("KE86@(8<;(6B:(F898CD;(B?(:7A@(C;F8K@;(L;(F866B:(;G;<(SC;(8D:BM;:7;<(?<;;(?<BE(>;@A<;@(86>(A6FDA68:AB6@(L7AF7=(C;F8K@;(:7;H(<;@:(B6(97H@AF8D(F8K@;@=(>B(6B:(B?(:7;E@;DG;@(8FFB<>(LA:7(:7;(EB<8D(D8L=(L7AF7(78@(bKA:;(>A??;<;6:(@BK<F;@T(U_O]aXJ(

d[ %7A@(A@(C;F8K@;=(8@(6B:;>(A6(!789:;<(*6;=(B6;4@(%)9+..4.,2@789;@(B6;4@(F7BAF;(B?(DBL;<(E8IAE@=(86>(:7K@(86(;GAD(%)9+..4.,2SFB<<K9:f@gJJJ:7;(G;<H(M<BK6>(B?(7A@(E8IAE@T(U386:=(!)*+,+-.=2dO`RXJ

\W 386:=(!)*+,+-.=2dOa\(N(dOa]J

\Q 386:=(!)*+,+-.=2dOa]J

Page 88: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

]W9<BGA>;@(K@(LA:7(;6BKM7(A6?B<E8:AB6(:B(M8:7;<(:78:(8:(D;8@:(@BE;(VA6>(B?(AE9<BG;E;6:(B<(

F786M;(A@(6;F;@@8<H(9<AB<(:B(:7;(<;GBDK:AB6(A:@;D?J(%7;@;(9<;98<8:B<H(F786M;@=(8:(EA6AEKE=(

A6FDK>;(UQX(C;FBEA6M(8L8<;(B?(:7;(EB<8D(D8L(86>(:7;(9<B:B:H9;(B?(8(9;<?;F:DH(MBB>(

7KE86(C;A6M=(L7AF7(8<;(?BK6>(LA:7A6(BK<(BL6(<;8@B6=(86>(URX(FBEA6M(:B(78G;(FB6?A>;6F;(

:78:(L;(F86(BG;<FBE;(<8>AF8D(;GAD(86>(C;FBE;(9;<?;F:DH(EB<8DDH(MBB>=(;G;6(:7BKM7(L;(

F866B:(78G;(:7;B<;:AF8D(V6BLD;>M;(B?(7BL(:7A@(A@(9B@@ACD;J(-6(9D8A6;<(:;<E@=(A6(B<>;<(:B(

BG;<FBE;(<8>AF8D(;GAD=(A:(@;;E@(:78:(L;(EK@:(V6BL(L78:(A:(E;86@(:B(C;(EB<8DDH(MBB>(86>(

K6>;<@:86>(:78:(A:(A@(9B@@ACD;(?B<(K@(:B(C;FBE;(EB<8DDH(MBB>J

36BLA6M()78:(-:(1;86@(:B(C;(1B<8DDH(cBB>

2A<@:=(C;?B<;(L;(8<;(8L8<;(B?(BK<(BL6(F898FA:H(:B(C;FBE;(EB<8DDH(MBB>=(L;(EK@:(

C;FBE;(8L8<;(B?(:7;(A>;8(B?(:7;(EB<8D(D8L(A:@;D?=(CB:7(A6@B?8<(8@(L;(8<;(8L8<;(B?(:7;(

EB<8D(MBB>=(M;6;<8DDH=(86>(V6BL(L78:(A:(E;86@(:B(C;(8(EB<8DDH(MBB>(7KE86(C;A6M=(

@9;FA?AF8DDHJ(';F8DD(?<BE(:7;(9<;GABK@(@;F:AB6@(:78:(386:(A6>AF8:;@(A6(CB:7(:7;(!)*+,+-.2

86>(A6(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*92:78:(8(9;<@B6(EK@:(K6FBG;<(F;<:8A6(8(9<AB<A(EB<8D(

FB6F;9:@(A6(B<>;<(:B(C;FBE;(EB<8DDH(MBB>J(%7A@(A@(8(9<AE;(;I8E9D;(B?(8(F8@;(A6(L7AF7(

386:(:7A6V@(:78:(8(9;<@B6(EK@:(>B(:7A@(A6(B<>;<(:B(EB<8DDH(AE9<BG;J(";(6B:;@(A6(@;G;<8D(

98@@8M;@(:78:(:7;(BG;<FBEA6M(B?(<8>AF8D(;GAD(<;bKA<;@(86(8L8<;6;@@(B?(:7;(EB<8D(D8L(86>=(

EB<;(@9;FA?AF8DDH=(B?(L78:(7;(F8DD@(8(EB<8D(9<B:B:H9;J\R(-6(:7;(!)*+,+-.=2386:(>;@F<AC;@(:7;(

>K:H(:B(BG;<FBE;(<8>AF8D(;GAD(8@(:7;(>K:H(:B(S)*)F01)2BK<@;DG;@(:B(f:7;g(A>;8D(B?(EB<8D(

9;<?;F:AB6JT\`(#(DBMAF8D(@:8<:A6M(9D8F;(?B<(<8>AF8D(EB<8D(AE9<BG;E;6:=(:7;6=(A@(:7;(

\R 2B<(;I8E9D;@=(@;;(!)*+,+-.=(dOa[(N(dO_W=(L7;<;(386:(FD8AE@(:78:(86(8L8<;6;@@(B?(BK<(BL6(9<;>A@9B@A:AB6(:B(MBB>=(L7AF7(E8V;@(A:(9B@@ACD;(?B<(K@(:B(BG;<FBE;(<8>AF8D(;GAD(86>(C;FBE;(EB<8DDH(MBB>=(78@(86(;??;F:(B6(:7;(EA6>(:78:(SFBK6:;<@T(BK<(9<B9;6@A:H(:B(;GAD=(86>(dOdW(i(dOdR=(L7;<;(386:(@:<;@@;@(:7;(6;;>(:B(DBF8:;(:7;(EB<8D(9<B:B:H9;(LA:7A6(BK<(BL6(<;8@B6J

\` 386:=(!)*+,+-.=2dOdQJ

Page 89: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

]QA>;6:A?AF8:AB6(B?(:7A@(BCe;F:AG;(A>;8(B?(EB<8D(9;<?;F:AB6J()A:7BK:(:7;(FB6@FABK@6;@@(B?(:7;(

A>;8(B?(:7;(EB<8D(D8L=(L7AF7(L;(EK@:(?BDDBL(A6(B<>;<(:B(C;(EB<8DDH(MBB>=(A:(LBKD>(6B:(

B6DH(C;(AE9B@@ACD;(:B(V6BL(L78:(:7;(8AE(B?(BK<(EB<8D(AE9<BG;E;6:(A@(CK:(A:(LBKD>(8D@B(

C;(AE9B@@ACD;(:B(;G;6(<;FBM6AP;(:78:(L;(FK<<;6:DH(?8DD(@7B<:(B?(:7A@(A>;8DJ

"BL;G;<=(A:(A@(6B:(@K??AFA;6:(:B(78G;(V6BLD;>M;(B?(:7;(A>;8(B?(EB<8D(9;<?;F:AB6(

M;6;<8DDHJ();(EK@:(V6BL(L78:(:7A@(EB<8D(9;<?;F:AB6(DBBV@(DAV;(A6(:7;(F8@;(B?(7KE86@J(

386:(FB6:;6>@(:78:(L;(F86(M8A6(@KF7(8L8<;6;@@(CH(DBF8:A6M(:7;(FB6F;9:(B?(8(EB<8D(

9<B:B:H9;(UX7I+*3X=(B<(8(EB<8DDH(9;<?;F:(7KE86(C;A6M=(LA:7A6(BK<(BL6(<;8@B6J(";(

>;@F<AC;@(:7A@(EB<8D(A>;8D(8@(?BDDBL@O

);(F866B:(:7A6V(:7;(A>;8D(B?(8(7KE86A:H(9D;8@A6M(:B(cB>(U7;6F;(B?(@KF7(EB<8D(9;<?;F:AB6(8@(A@(9B@@ACD;(:B(8(C;A6M(9;<:8A6A6M(:B(:7A@(LB<D>(86>(>;9;6>;6:(B6(6;;>@(86>(A6FDA68:AB6@X(;IF;9:(A6(:7;(A>;8(B?(8(7KE86(C;A6M(LADDA6M(6B:(B6DH(:B(;I;FK:;(A6(9;<@B6(8DD(7KE86(>K:A;@=(86>(8:(:7;(@8E;(:AE;(:B(@9<;8>(MBB>6;@@(8CBK:(7AE(8@(?8<(LA>;(8@(9B@@ACD;(:7<BKM7(:;8F7A6M(86>(;I8E9D;=(CK:(8D@B=(:7BKM7(:;E9:;>(CH(:7;(M<;8:;@:(:;E9:8:AB6=(:B(:8V;(K9B6(7AE@;D?(8DD(@K??;<A6M@=(K9(:B(:7;(EB@:(AM6BEA6ABK@(>;8:7=(?B<(:7;(MBB>(B?(:7;(LB<D>(86>(;G;6(?B<(7A@(;6;EA;@J(i(2B<(7KE86(C;A6M@(F866B:(?B<E(?B<(:7;E@;DG;@(86H(FB6F;9:(B?(:7;(>;M<;;(86>(:7;(@:<;6M:7(B?(8(?B<F;(DAV;(:78:(B?(8(EB<8D(>A@9B@A:AB6(;IF;9:(CH(<;9<;@;6:A6M(A:(@K<<BK6>;>(CH(BC@:8FD;@(86>(H;:(N(A6(:7;(EA>@:(B?(:7;(M<;8:;@:(9B@@ACD;(:;E9:8:AB6@(N(GAF:B<ABK@J\a

386:4@(9BA6:(7;<;(A@(:78:(:7;(B6DH(L8H(:78:(7KE86@(F86(K6>;<@:86>(L78:(A:(E;86@(:B(78G;(8(

MBB>(%)9+..4.,(A@(:B(FB6F;9:K8DAP;(8(9;<?;F:DH(MBB>(7KE86(C;A6MJ(%7A@(A>;8D(EK@:(C;(8(

7KE86(C;A6M=(<8:7;<(:786(8(9;<?;F:=(6B6i7KE86=(<8:AB68D(C;A6M=(C;F8K@;(:7;(8AE(B?(78GA6M(

8(MBB>(%)9+..4.,(A@(B6DH(E;86A6M?KD(A6(<;M8<>@(:B(7KE86@J(#(7KE86(F86(6;G;<(C;(

EB<8DDH(MBB>(A6(:7;(@;6@;(:78:(@7;(6B(DB6M;<(@:<KMMD;@(LA:7(:;E9:8:AB6@(B?(8F:A6M(?<BE(

A6FDA68:AB6@=(L7AF7(A@(:7;(@;6@;(A6(L7AF7(86(A6:;DDAMACD;(C;A6M(DAV;(cB>(A@(EB<8DDH(MBB>J\_(

\a 386:=(!)*+,+-.=(2dOdQJ

\_ !$<'=(_O]aJ(S2B<=(C;A6M(8(F<;8:K<;(86>(:7K@(8DL8H@(>;9;6>;6:(LA:7(<;M8<>(:B(L78:(7;(<;bKA<;@(?B<(FBE9D;:;(@8:A@?8F:AB6(LA:7(7A@(FB6>A:AB6=(7;(F86(6;G;<(C;(8D:BM;:7;<(?<;;(?<BE(>;@A<;@(86>(A6FDA68:AB6@(L7AF7=(C;F8K@;(:7;H(<;@:(B6(97H@AF8D(F8K@;@=(>B(6B:(B?(:7;E@;DG;@(8FFB<>(LA:7(:7;(EB<8D(D8L=(L7AF7(78@(

Page 90: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

]R'8:7;<=(:B(C;(EB<8DDH(MBB>(86>(7KE86(A@(:B(9<AB<A:AP;(:7;(EB:AG8:AB6(B?(:7;(EB<8D(D8L(

8CBG;(:7;(EB:AG8:AB6@(B?(A6FDA68:AB6@J(%7A@(>B;@(6B:(E;86=(7BL;G;<=(:78:(A6FDA68:AB6@(

>A@899;8<J(%7;H(8<;(E;<;DH(6B:(9<AB<A:AP;>(8CBG;(A6F;6:AG;@(B?(:7;(EB<8D(D8LJ

386:(>;@F<AC;@(:7;(EB<8D(9<B:B:H9;(8@(8(ScB>iDAV;(7KE86(C;A6MT\d(L7B(

;I9;<A;6F;@(:7;(@8E;(BC@:8FD;@(:B(EB<8D(MBB>6;@@(:78:(L;(;I9;<A;6F;(CK:(6;G;<(?8AD@(:B(C;(

EB<8DDH(MBB>J(";(L<A:;@(:78:(<;FBM6A:AB6(B?(:7;(EB<8D(9<B:B:H9;(A@(:7;(B6DH(L8H(?B<(

7KE86@(:B(K6>;<@:86>(L78:(A:(E;86@(:B(78G;(8(MBB>(?K6>8E;6:8D(E8IAE=(A6@B?8<(8@(:7A@(

;I8E9D;(@7BL@(K@(L78:(A:(LBKD>(C;(DAV;(:B(78G;(8(MBB>(%)9+..4.,2S@K<<BK6>;>(CH(

BC@:8FD;@(86>(H;:(N(A6(:7;(EA>@:(B?(:7;(M<;8:;@:(9B@@ACD;(:;E9:8:AB6@(N(GAF:B<ABK@JT\\(#@(

$8KD(cKH;<(;I9D8A6@=(7KE86@(<;bKA<;(8(E8:;<A8D(9AF:K<;(B?(L78:(A:(DBBV@(DAV;(:B(C;(EB<8DDH(

9;<?;F:J(";(L<A:;@(:78:(S%7;(<8:AB68DA@:(A>;8(:78:(L;(EK@:(8DL8H@(@:<AG;(:B(E8IAEAP;(

9;<?;F:AB6=(?B<(;I8E9D;=(A@(K@;D;@@(LA:7BK:(8(@KC@:86:AG;(8FFBK6:(B?(L78:(EB<8D(9;<?;F:AB6(

A@JT\](YH(DBF8:A6M(:7A@(;I8E9D;(B?(:7;(9<B:B:H9;=(L;(C;MA6(:B(@;;(L78:(A:(LBKD>(DBBV(DAV;(

?B<(8(7KE86(:B(C;(EB<8DDH(MBB>=(;G;6(:7BKM7(L;(F866B:(?A6>(@KF7(86(;I8E9D;(A6(BK<(

;I9;<A;6F;J

&G;6(A?(8(EB<8DDH(9;<?;F:(7KE86(L;<;(:B(;IA@:=(L;(FBKD>(6;G;<(V6BL(:7A@(C;F8K@;(

L;(F866B:(78G;(V6BLD;>M;(B?(8(9;<@B64@(%)9+..4.,=2L7AF7(>B;@(6B:(899;8<(A6(:AE;(86>(

@98F;J(-6@:;8>=(386:(6B:;@(:78:(:7;(EB<8D(9<B:B:H9;(F86(C;(?BK6>(LA:7A6(;G;<H(9;<@B64@(

<;8@B6=(B<=(EB<;(@9;FA?AF8DDH=(A6(BK<(SEB<8DDHiD;MA@D8:AG;(<;8@B6JT\[("BL;G;<=(E;<;DH(

bKA:;(>A??;<;6:(@BK<F;@JJJT

\d 386:=(!)*+,+-.=2dOdQJ

\\ -CA>J(USJJJ8D@(L;66(;<(@A;(EA:("A6>;<6A@@;6(<A6M;6>(K6>(K6:;<(>;6(M<lk:ElMDAF7;6(#6?;F7:K6M;6(>;66BF7(jC;<LA6>;6>(@AF7(GB<@:;DD:JTX

\] cKH;<=(S&I8E9D;@(B?(1B<8D($B@@ACADA:H=T(]J

\[ 386:=(!)*+,+-.=(dOdRJ

Page 91: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

]`C;F8K@;(A:(A@(?BK6>(LA:7A6(BK<(<;8@B6(>B;@(6B:(E;86(:78:(L;(F<;8:;>(:7A@(A>;8J(386:(A@(

G;<H(FD;8<(:78:(:7;(A>;8(B?(:7;(EB<8D(9<B:B:H9;(S78@(<8:7;<(;@:8CDA@7;>(A:@;D?(A6(:7;(7KE86(

C;A6M(LA:7BK:(BK<(FBE9<;7;6>A6M(7BL(7KE86(68:K<;(FBKD>(78G;(;G;6(C;;6(<;F;9:AG;(B?(

A:JT]W(%78:(A@=(:7A@(A>;8(A@(?BK6>(LA:7(A6(:7;(<;8@B6(B?(8DD(7KE86(C;A6M@(86>(F86(C;(8FF;@@;>(

CH(8DD(7KE86(C;A6M@=(;G;6(:7BKM7(L;(F864:(K6>;<@:86>(7BL(8(7KE86(FBKD>(;G;<(8F7A;G;(

A:J

Z6>;<@:86>A6M(:7;(*G;<FBEA6M(8@($B@@ACD;(?B<(Z@(:B(#FFBE9DA@7

%7;(@;FB6>(<;bKA<;E;6:(B?(:7A@(9<;i<;GBDK:AB68<H(@:8M;(A@(:78:(L;(EK@:(6B:(B6DH(

V6BL(L78:(A:(E;86@(:B(C;(EB<8DDH(MBB>(CK:(8D@B(78G;(FB6?A>;6F;(:78:(L;(78G;(:7;(

F898FA:H(:B(C;FBE;(EB<8DDH(MBB>=(>;@9A:;(BK<(<8>AF8DDH(;GAD(@:8:;@J(%7A@(6;;>(8<A@;@(A6(

DAM7:(B?(386:4@(FB6F;<6(:78:=(A?(L;(>B(6B:(78G;(@KF7(FB6?A>;6F;=(L;(LADD(?8DD(A6:B(>;@98A<(

86>(6;G;<(EB<8DDH(9<BM<;@@=(8(9<BCD;E(:78:(-(LADD(>A@FK@@(?K<:7;<(A6(!789:;<(%7<;;J-386:(

>B;@(6B:(:7A6V(:78:(A:(A@(;6BKM7(:B(K6>;<@:86>(L78:(A:(E;86@(:B(C;(8(EB<8DDH(MBB>(7KE86(

C;A6MJ('8:7;<=(L;(EK@:(K6>;<@:86>(:7;(BG;<FBEA6M(B?(<8>AF8D(;GAD(8@(9B@@ACD;(86>=(

<;D8:;>DH=(:B(C;FBE;(FB6?A>;6:(:78:(L;(8<;(F898CD;(B?(C;FBEA6M(EB<8DDH(MBB>=(>;@9A:;(BK<(

<8>AF8DDH(;GAD(@:8:;@J(

#@(L;(LADD(@;;(CB:7(A6(L78:(?BDDBL@(A6(:7A@(F789:;<(86>(A6(!789:;<(%7<;;=(:7A@(

6;;>(F<;8:;@(@;<ABK@(;9A@:;EBDBMAF8D(9<BCD;E@(?B<(386:4@(:7;B<H(B?(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:J(

.8E;DH=(LA:7BK:(86(K6>;<@:86>A6M(B?(EB<8D(AE9<BG;E;6:(8@(9B@@ACD;(?B<(7KE86@(86>(8(

FB6?A>;6F;(:78:(L;(F86(8F7A;G;(A:(BK<@;DG;@=(L;(<K6(:7;(<A@V(B?(?8DDA6M(A6:B(>;@98A<(86>(

?8ADA6M(:B(@;;V(EB<8D(AE9<BG;E;6:J]Q(#@(6B:;>(A6(!789:;<(*6;=(8@(7KE86@(L7B@;(

]W 386:=(!)*+,+-.=2dOdQJ

]Q +;;(386:=(!)*+,+-.=2dOdQ(86>(dOdRJ

Page 92: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

]a:7;B<;:AF8D(V6BLD;>M;(A@(DAEA:;>(:B(:78:(L7AF7(899;8<@(A6(:AE;(86>(@98F;=(L;(F866B:(78G;(

:7;B<;:AF8D(V6BLD;>M;(B?(7BL(A:(A@(9B@@ACD;(:B(BG;<FBE;(<8>AF8D(;GAD(86>(C;FBE;(EB<8DDH(

MBB>J("BL;G;<=(C;F8K@;(:7;(EB<8D(D8L(FBEE86>@(:78:(L;(EK@:(BG;<FBE;(<8>AF8D(;GAD=(

386:(7BD>@(:78:(L;(EK@:(K6>;<@:86>(:7A@(VA6>(B?(EB<8D(AE9<BG;E;6:(8@(9B@@ACD;(?B<(K@=(

>;@9A:;(BK<(<8>AF8DDH(;GAD(@:8:;J]R(%7K@=(A6(B<>;<(:B(E8V;(:7;(@A6MKD8<(F7BAF;(:B(78G;(8(

MBB>(%)9+..4.,286>(:7;<;CH(BG;<FBE;(<8>AF8D(;GAD=(L;(EK@:(C;DA;G;(:78:(A:(A@(8(F786M;(

:78:(A@(9B@@ACD;(?B<(K@(:B(8FFBE9DA@7J(

%B(8GBA>(:7;(9<BCD;E(B?(>;@98A<=(:7;6=(L;(EK@:(K6>;<@:86>(:7;(BG;<FBEA6M(B?(

<8>AF8D(EB<8D(AE9<BG;E;6:(8@(9B@@ACD;(?B<(K@J(-(LADD(<;@;<G;(:7A@(>A@FK@@AB6(?B<(:7;(6;I:(

F789:;<(C;F8K@;(A:(<;bKA<;@(8(F8<;?KD(868DH@A@(B?(L78:(:7;(BG;<FBEA6M(B?(<8>AF8D(;GAD(

;6:8AD@(86>(7BL(;8F7(FBE9B6;6:(B?(F786M;(LA:7A6(:7A@(BG;<FBEA6M(F86(C;(K6>;<@:BB>(8@(

9B@@ACD;J(-(LADD(8>><;@@(8:(D;6M:7(A6(!789:;<(%7<;;(L78:(:7;@;(FBE9B6;6:@(8<;(86>(7BL(

L;(EAM7:(FBE;(:B(K6>;<@:86>(:7;E(8@(9B@@ACD;J-"BL;G;<=(;G;6(:7BKM7(:7A@(>A@FK@@AB6(B?(

7BL(L;(F86(K6>;<@:86>(:7;@;(F786M;@(8@(9B@@ACD;(LADD(C;(A6FDK>;>(A6(8(>A@FK@@AB6(B?(:7;(

<;GBDK:AB6(A:@;D?=(A:(A@(AE9B<:86:(:B(V;;9(A6(EA6>=(8@(-(@:<;@@(A6(:7;(6;I:(F789:;<=(:78:(L;(

EK@:(K6>;<@:86>(:7;@;(F786M;@(8@(9B@@ACD;(C;?B<;(L;(F86(BG;<FBE;(<8>AF8D(;GADJ(%7K@=(

L7AD;(:7;(8F:K8D(BG;<FBEA6M(A@(6B:(98<:(B?(:7;(9<;i<;GBDK:AB68<H(@:8M;=(FBEA6M(:B(

K6>;<@:86>(:7;(BG;<FBEA6M(8@(9B@@ACD;(A@(98<:(B?(:7A@(9<;98<8:B<H(@:8M;J()A:7BK:(@KF7(86(

K6>;<@:86>A6M=(386:(:7A6V@(:78:(L;(FBKD>(6;G;<(K6>;<MB(:7;(<;GBDK:AB6J

)7AD;(-(LADD(6B:(H;:(>A@FK@@(:7;(?KDD(DA@:(B?(:7;(F786M;@(6;F;@@8<H(:B(BG;<FBE;(

<8>AF8D(;GAD(86>(7BL(L;(F86(K6>;<@:86>(;8F7(8@(9B@@ACD;=(-(>B(LA@7(:B(>A@FK@@(C<A;?DH(7;<;(

L78:(:7;(A>;8(B?(:7;(EB<8D(9<B:B:H9;(FB6:<ACK:;@(:B(BK<(K6>;<@:86>A6M(B?(:7;(9B@@ACADA:H(B?(

]R -(78G;(8DDK>;>(:B(:7A@(A6(!789:;<(Q(86>(LADD(>A@FK@@(A:(A6(EKF7(EB<;(>;:8AD(A6(!789:;<(`J

Page 93: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

]_:7;(BG;<FBEA6MJ()7AD;(A:(>B;@(6B:(MAG;(K@(A6@AM7:(A6:B(:7;(9B@@ACADA:H(B?(;G;<H(VA6>(B?(

6;F;@@8<H(F786M;=(A:(>B;@(8DDBL(K@(:B(<;FBM6AP;(:78:(L;(78G;(F;<:8A6(F898FA:A;@(:78:(E8V;(

A:(9B@@ACD;(?B<(K@(:B(C;FBE;(EB<8DDH(MBB>J(/;@9A:;(8(D8FV(B?(8(?KDD(K6>;<@:86>A6M(B?(7BL(

:B(C;FBE;(DAV;(:7A@(EB<8D(9<B:B:H9;=(86(8L8<;6;@@(B?(:7A@(9<B:B:H9;=(?BK6>(LA:7A6(BK<(

BL6(<;8@B6=(>B;@(C<A6M(:B(DAM7:(F;<:8A6(F898CADA:A;@(:78:(L;=(8@(7KE86@=(78G;(:78:(F86(

FB6:<ACK:;(:B(BK<(BG;<FBEA6M(B?(<8>AF8D(;GADJ(.8E;DH=(C;FBEA6M(8L8<;(B?(:7;(EB<8D(D8L(

86>(98<:AFKD8<DH(:7;(A>;8(B?(8(9;<?;F:DH(MBB>(7KE86(C<A6M@(:B(DAM7:(:78:(L;(8DD(78G;(8(

9<;>A@9B@A:AB6(:B(MBB>=(B<(L78:(386:(F8DD@(S:7;(M;<E(B?(:7;(MBB>JT]`(

YH(M8A6A6M(86(8L8<;6;@@(B?(:7;(9<B:B:H9;=(L;(F86(C;MA6(:B(C;DA;G;(:78:=(A6@B?8<(8@(

L;(8<;(7KE86(DAV;(:7;(9<B:B:H9;(86>(:7K@(78G;(:7;(@8E;(F898FA:A;@(8@(:7;(9<B:B:H9;=(A?(L;(

L;<;(A6(:7;(@8E;(@A:K8:AB6@(B?(:;E9:8:AB6(8@(:7;(9<B:B:H9;=(:78:(L;(FBKD>(8F:(8@(:7;(

9<B:B:H9;(LBKD>J(%78:(A@=(L;(FBKD>(AE9<BG;(@B(:78:(L;(LBKD>(8DL8H@(C;(EB<8DDH(MBB>J]a(

%7A@(A@(C;F8K@;(:7;(EB<8D(9<B:B:H9;(A@(6B:(B6DH(86(;I8E9D;(CK:(A@(8D@B(S9<BB?(:78:(@B(9K<;(

86>(;I8D:;>(8(EB<8D(MBB>6;@@(F86(C;(9<8F:A@;>(86>(8::8A6;>(I<249=T]_(A6@B?8<(8@(:7;(EB<8D(

9<B:B:H9;(@78<;@(8DD(BK<(S6;;>@(86>(7;6F;(8D@B(:7;(@8E;(@K??;<A6M@=T(S:7;(@8E;(68:K<8D(

A6FDA68:AB6@(86>(7;6F;(8D@B(:7;(@8E;(:;E9:8:AB6@(:B(:<86@M<;@@AB6JT]d(*6F;(L;(FBE;(:B(

C;DA;G;(A6(:7;(<;8DA:H(B?(:7;(EB<8D(9<B:B:H9;=(8@(8(7KE86(L7B(A@(@KCe;F:(:7;(@8E;(

:;E9:8:AB6@(8@(L;(8<;=(L;(F86(C;MA6(:B(;I9;F:(:78:(L;(8<;(F898CD;(B?(C;FBEA6M(DAV;(:7;(

]` 386:=(!)*+,+-.=2dO_\J

]a +;;(2A<;@:B6;(86>(h8FBC@=($.2Y)C).9)2-C2/0.1(92!)*+,+-.=2Q\WJ(*?(FBK<@;=(L;(LBKD>(6;;>(:B(78G;(eK@:A?A;>(<;8@B6@(?B<(78GA6M(:7A@(VA6>(B?(7B9;J(-(LADD(>A@FK@@(:7;(FB6F;9:@(B?(EB<8D(7B9;(86>(EB<8D(?8A:7=(B<(C;DA;?=(A6(EKF7(M<;8:;<(>;:8AD(A6(!789:;<(`J

]_ 386:=(!)*+,+-.=2dOdaJ

]d -CA>J

Page 94: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

]dEB<8D(9<B:B:H9;=(B<=(A6(B:7;<(LB<>@=(B?(BG;<FBEA6M(<8>AF8D(;GADJ]\

YH(D8HA6M(BK:(:7A@(<BKM7(8FFBK6:(B?(9<;i<;GBDK:AB68<H(9<;98<8:AB6@=(-(>B(6B:(A6:;6>(

:B(FD8AE(:78:(;G;<H(9;<@B6(EK@:(MB(:7<BKM7(8(@H@:;E8:AF=(DB6Mi:;<E(9<BF;@@(B?(EB<8D(

AE9<BG;E;6:(9<AB<(:B(:7;(<;GBDK:AB6J(-6(?8F:=(386:(MAG;@(@B(?;L(>;:8AD@(A6(:7;(!)*+,+-.2

<;M8<>A6M(:7;(:AE;(8?:;<(:7;(F7BAF;(:B(C;FBE;(<8>AF8DDH(;GAD(CK:(9<AB<(:B(:7;(<;GBDK:AB68<H(

F7BAF;(:B(C;FBE;(MBB>(:78:(A:(@;;E@(9B@@ACD;(:78:(:7;<;(8<;(8(G8<A;:H(B?(98:7@(:78:(B6;(

FBKD>(:8V;(:B(:7A@(<;GBDK:AB6=(<86MA6M(?<BE(86(A6:;6:AB68D=(FB6:A6K;>(@:<AGA6M(:B(C;FBEA6M(

F898CD;(B?(E8VA6M(:7A@(<;GBDK:AB68<H(F7BAF;(:B(8(DA?;(:78:(A@(E8<V;>(CH(8(>A@A6:;<;@:(A6(N(

B<=(A6(?8F:=(86(8G;<@AB6(:B(N(8F:A6M(EB<8DDH(K6:AD(:7;(G;<H(EBE;6:(8:(L7AF7(B6;(78@(8(

FB6G;<@AB6iDAV;(;I9;<A;6F;J("BL;G;<=(A:(A@(FD;8<(:78:(;G;6(A?(B6;(:8V;@(:7A@(D8::;<(98:7=(

:7;H(@:ADD(EK@:(78G;(?KD?ADD;>(:7;@;(EA6AE8D(<;bKA<;E;6:@(:78:(E8V;(@KF7(8(F7BAF;(

9B@@ACD;J(%78:(A@=(;G;6(A?(8(9;<@B6(A@(>A@A6:;<;@:;>(A6(EB<8DA:H(K6:AD(:7;(G;<H(EBE;6:(7;(

>;FA>;@(:B(K6>;<MB(:7;(<;GBDK:AB6=(A:(LBKD>(@:ADD(C;(6;F;@@8<H(?B<(7AE(:B(C;(8L8<;(B?(:7;(

EB<8D(D8L(86>(:7;(EB<8D(9<B:B:H9;(86>(:B(K6>;<@:86>(:7;(8::8A6E;6:(B?(EB<8D(MBB>6;@@(8@(

9B@@ACD;(?B<(7AE(:B(8FFBE9DA@7=(>;@9A:;(7A@(FK<<;6:DH(<8>AF8DDH(;GAD(@:8:;J()A:7BK:(:7A@(

V6BLD;>M;(B?(L78:(A:(E;86@(:B(C;(EB<8DDH(MBB>(86>(8(C;DA;?(A6(:7;(A>;8(B?(8(EB<8DDH(MBB>(

7KE86(C;A6M=(8(9;<@B6(LBKD>(6B:(V6BL(L78:(7;(L8@(FBEEA::A6M(7AE@;D?(:B(L7;6(7;(

F7BB@;@(8(MBB>(%)9+..4.,?2,AV;LA@;=(LA:7BK:(86(K6>;<@:86>A6M(:78:(C;FBEA6M(EB<8DDH(

MBB>(A@(9B@@ACD;=(A:(LBKD>(6B:(C;(<;8@B68CD;(:B(FBEEA:(B6;@;D?(:B(8(DA?;(:78:(9K<@K;@(:78:(

;6>J(

]\ 2A<;@:B6;(86>(h8FBC@=($.2Y)C).9)2-C2/0.1(92!)*+,+-.=(>;@F<AC;(:7A@(8@(?BDDBL@=(S2B<(386:=(:7;(9<B:B:H9;(9<BGA>;@(7B9;(?B<(BK<(@9;FA;@=(6B:(C;F8K@;(7;(A@(8(EB<8D(;I;E9D8<=(CK:(C;F8K@;(7;(9B@@;@@;@(86>(8F:K8DAP;@(:7;(A>;8D(>A@9B@A:AB6(:78:(L;(D8FVJ(YH(8>B9:A6M(:7A@(9<A@:A6;(>A@9B@A:AB6(N(:78:(A@=(CH(98<:AFA98:A6M(A6(B<(D8HA6M(7BD>(B?(:7A@(>A@9B@A:AB6=(B<(68:K<;=(A6(:7;(EB@:(DA:;<8D(@;6@;(N(L;(:BB(F86(7B9;(:B(C;FBE;(9D;8@A6M(:B(cB>O(:7;(>A@9B@A:AB6(?<BE(L7AF7(7899A6;@@(?BDDBL@(A6(:7;("AM7;@:(Y;A6M(A@(6BL(?BK6>(A6(K@T(UQdaXJ

Page 95: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

]\=%"(7'2)%"

2<BE(:7A@(FBE98<A@B6(B?(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*92LA:7(:7;(!)*+,+-.=2A:(C;FBE;@(

FD;8<(:78:(386:4@(<8>AF8D(;GAD(FD8AE(F86(7;D9(K@(:B(C;::;<(K6>;<@:86>(7A@(8FFBK6:(B?(EB<8D(

>;G;DB9E;6:(A6(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*9?2-6>;;>=(:7;(F786M;@(:78:(L;(F86(@;;(8<A@A6M(

C;:L;;6(7A@(;8<DA;<(?B<E8D(8FFBK6:(B?(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:=(A6(:7;(@8E9D;(B?(:7;(/BF:<A6;(

B?(1;:7B>(?<BE(:7;(@;FB6>(:7+1+B4)=(86>(7A@(D8:;<(8FFBK6:=(A6(:7;(@8E9D;(B?(:7;(/BF:<A6;(

B?(1;:7B>(?<BE(:7;(@)108A<9+592-C2@-70*9=2FD;8<DH(F86(C;(;I9D8A6;>(CH(DBBVA6M(:B(:7;(

9<BCD;E(B?(BG;<FBEA6M(<8>AF8D(;GAD(A6(7KE86@=(L7AF7(8<A@;@(A6(:7;(!)*+,+-.?2Y;F8K@;(B?(

:7A@(AE98F:=(:7;<;(A@(MBB>(<;8@B6(:B(9BA6:(:B(:7;(!)*+,+-.28@(8(LB<V(:78:(F86(;6786F;(BK<(

K6>;<@:86>A6M(B?(L78:(386:(:7A6V@(A@(6;F;@@8<H(?B<(C;FBEA6M(8(EB<8DDH(MBB>(9;<@B6J

-6(:7A@(F789:;<=(-(78G;(C;MK6(8(>A@FK@@AB6(<;M8<>A6M(L78:(:7;(!)*+,+-.28>>@(:B(

386:4@(8FFBK6:(B?(EB<8D(>;G;DB9E;6:=(A?(L;(:8V;(7A@(FD8AE@(A6(:7A@(LB<V(:B(9D8H(8(

:<86@?B<E8:AG;(<BD;(A6(:7A@(BG;<8<F7A6M(8FFBK6:J(%7;<;(F;<:8A6DH(A@(EKF7(EB<;(:78:(F86(C;(

@8A>(<;M8<>A6M(:7A@(9<;i<;GBDK:AB68<H(@:8M;(:78:(-(78G;(C;MK6(:B(>A@FK@@(86>(7BL(:7;@;(

9<;98<8:AB6@(F<;8:;(:7;(6;F;@@8<H(FB6>A:AB6@(?B<(:7;(F7BAF;(:B(BG;<FBE;(<8>AF8D(;GADJ(-(LADD(

@9;6>(:7;(6;I:(F789:;<(;I9DB<A6M(8:(D;8@:(98<:(B?(:7A@(>A@FK@@AB6J(+9;FA?AF8DDH=(-(LADD(D8H(BK:(

:7;(VA6>@(B?(F786M;@(:78:(L;(EK@:(K6>;<MB(A6(B<>;<(:B(BG;<FBE;(<8>AF8D(;GAD(86>(:7;6(

A6G;@:AM8:;(7BL(L;(F86(K6>;<@:86>(;8F7(VA6>(B?(F786M;(8@(9B@@ACD;J(%7A@(;I8EA68:AB6(

LADD(@;<G;(CB:7(8@(86(;I9D868:AB6(B?(7BL(L;(EAM7:(MB(8CBK:(?KD?ADDA6M(:7;(9<;i

<;GBDK:AB68<H(6;;>(:B(K6>;<@:86>(:7;(BG;<FBEA6M(B?(<8>AF8D(;GAD(8@(9B@@ACD;(86>(8D@B(8@(86(

868DH@A@(B?(L78:(:7;(BG;<FBEA6M(B?(<8>AF8D(;GAD(;6:8AD@J

Page 96: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

!"#$%&'(%"'&&

)"&%"&'(%"&(*+&'!*,-./(*0('#1-!#2(&+-2(-3(#(,*'#2($*33-4-2-%5

!"#$%&'(#)%"

-6(!789:;<(%=>?(-(8<@A;B(:78:(:7;(9<>C;DD(>E(>F;<C>GH6@(<8BHC8I(;FHI?(><(=78:(HD(

D>G;:HG;D(C8II;B(<8BHC8I(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:?J(D7>AIB(K;(C>6DHB;<;B(:>(K;(8(98<:(>E(L86:MD(

:7;><N(>E(G><8I(B;F;I>9G;6:O(">=;F;<?(8D(-(6>:;B(H6(:7;(9<;FH>AD(C789:;<?(K;E><;(-(C86(

8BB<;DD(;P8C:IN(=78:(9I8C;(:7HD(9<>C;DD(78D(H6(:7;(C>A<D;(>E(G><8I(B;F;I>9G;6:?(H:(HD(

6;C;DD8<N(:>(H6F;D:H@8:;(=7;:7;<(=;(C86(8C:A8IIN(86:HCH98:;(:7;(>CCA<<;6C;(>E(<8BHC8I(

G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:(H6(>A<(IHF;D?(H6D>E8<(8D(H:(HD(8(G><8I(9>DDHKHIH:N(E><(7AG86DO(%7HD(

;P9I868:H>6(=HII(K;C>G;(C<ACH8I(:>(>A<(A6B;<D:86BH6@(>E(:7;(<;I8:H>6D7H9(K;:=;;6(:7;(

>F;<C>GH6@(>E(<8BHC8I(;FHI(86B(86(HG9<>F;G;6:(H6(>A<(98<:HCAI8<(8C:H>6DO(

#:(EH<D:(<;8BH6@?(H:(899;8<D(:78:(H:(D7>AIB(6>:(K;(F;<N(BHEEHCAI:(E><(AD(:>(A6B;<D:86BQ(

:7;(>F;<C>GH6@(>E(<8BHC8I(;FHI(8D(8(G><8I(9>DDHKHIH:N(H6(>A<(IHF;DO(1A;(:>(:7;(>A@7:(HG9IH;D(

C86(9<H6CH9I;?(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:(E>II>=D(E<>G(:7;(C>GG86BD(>E(:7;(

G><8I(I8=?(<;@8<BI;DD(>E(=78:(>KD:8CI;D(D:86B(H6(>A<(=8NO(-6B;;B?(8D(L86:(6>:;D?(RHE(:7;(

G><8I(I8=(C>GG86BD(:78:(=;(!"#$%&:>(K;(K;::;<(7AG86D(K;H6@D(6>=?(H:(H6;DC898KIN(

E>II>=D(:78:(=;(GAD:(K;('()(*+,&>E(K;H6@(K;::;<(7AG86(K;H6@DS(T-,..&/,..&0(1

J 3;;(2;DIH;(#O(,AI7>II86B?(R0<;;B>G(86B($<>FHB;6C;(H6(L86:MD(#CC>A6:(>E(';IH@H>6U(%7;($<>KI;G(>E(&P9H8:H>6?S(H6(2(.%31&4$5+!1!)$6&!7&8,+5#5!.&8,'!.150,9,0:(;BO($7HIH9(VO('>DDH(86B(,HC78;I()<;;6(T-6BH8689>IHDU(-6BH868(W6HF;<DH:N($<;DD?(JXXJYO(#I:;<68:HF;IN?(/><B>6(&O(,HC78ID>6?(V<O?(;(++,.&;9,,0!<:(<;E;<D(:>(:7HD(9<>C;DD(8D(RG><8I(<;@;6;<8:H>6OS

Q W6I;DD(>:7;<=HD;(6>:;B?(-(=HII(AD;(:7;(:;<G(RA6B;<D:86BS(H6(:7;(C>II>ZAH8I(D;6D;?(<8:7;<(:786(H6(:7;(D;6D;(>E(:7;(L86:H86(E8CAI:N(>E(A6B;<D:86BH6@O

[[

Page 97: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

[X&<!9(+51'$,&=,1,%>&#,*5,%,%:&/59&1!++,.&?,%>%&*,11,9,&@,.1'$,.&1,5.:&1!+&7!+#%&

"."<#A.#+5'$:&/59&<B11,.&,1&("'$&CD..,.Y?\*;F;6(HE(=;(8<;(CA<<;6:IN(<8BHC8IIN(;FHIO(

">=;F;<?(H6(:7;(8,+5#5!.:&L86:(HD(CI;8<(:78:(=;(GAD:(A6B;<D:86B(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(

>F;<C>GH6@(<8BHC8I(;FHI(H6(8(GAC7(G><;(9;<D>68I(=8NO();(GAD:(A6B;<D:86B(:78:(=;(78F;(

:7;(C898CH:H;D(6;C;DD8<N(:>(K;C>G;(G><8IIN(@>>B(86B(C86(<;8D>68KIN(;P9;C:(:78:(=;(=HII(

K;C>G;(G><8IIN(@>>B(H6(:7;(EA:A<;?(HE(=;(B>(C;<:8H6(:7H6@DO]

W6B;<D:86BH6@(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(>F;<C>GH6@(<8BHC8I(;FHI(H6(:7HD(=8N(HD(6>(DHG9I;(

:8D^(E><(7AG86DO(L86:(=<H:;D(:78:(<;8D>6(RKN(68:A<;(EH6BD(G><8I(I8K><(F;PH6@OS_(%78:(HD?(

9A<;(<;8D>6(C866>:(78F;(^6>=I;B@;(>E(>A<(C898CH:H;D(:78:(=HII(8II>=(AD(:>(>F;<C>G;(

<8BHC8I(;FHI(K>:7(K;C8AD;(>A<(=,15..".#,.&:7;GD;IF;D(8<;(A6^6>=8KI;(:>(AD(86B(K;C8AD;(

:7;(>F;<C>GH6@(GAD:(>CCA<(KN(G;86D(>E(8(E<;;(C7>HC;O("AG86D(C86(6;F;<(78F;(:7;><;:HC8I(

^6>=I;B@;(>E(>A<(>=6(H6:;IIH@HKI;(C78<8C:;<(T><(:7;(H6:;IIH@HKI;(C78<8C:;<(>E(>:7;<DY(

K;C8AD;(>A<(=,15..".#,.&B>(6>:(899;8<(H6(:HG;(86B(D98C;O*#BBH:H>68IIN?(=;(C866>:(78F;(

^6>=I;B@;(>E(:7;(:<86DE><G8:H>6(:78:(=>AIB(C786@;(>A<(=,15..".#&E<>G(;FHI(:>(@>>B(

K;C8AD;?(8D(:7;(<;DAI:(>E(8(E<;;(C7>HC;?(:7HD(:<86DE><G8:H>6(>CCA<D(>A:DHB;(>E(:HG;(86B(

D98C;O`(0><(:7;D;(<;8D>6D+*=;(C86(6;F;<(78F;(C>G9I;:;(^6>=I;B@;(>E(7>=(:7;(>F;<C>GH6@(

\ L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`U_aO

] 3;;(8,+5#5!.:&`U_J(b(`U_Q?(=7;<;(L86:(D:8:;D(:78:(H:(HD(R;DD;6:H8I(:>(^6>=(/$(%&(&$"<(.&*,5.#&$(1&%!&0!&$5<1,+7&H6(><B;<(:>(K;C>G;S(G><8IIN(@>>B(86B(:78:(=;(GAD:(K;(8KI;(:>(;P9;C:(:78:?(KN(B>H6@(=78:(HD(=H:7H6(>A<(>=6(9>=;<D?(=;(=HII(K;C>G;(G><8IIN(@>>BO

_ L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`U_JO

` 3;;(L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`U_JO(R#DDA<86C;(>E(:7HD(C866>:(>E(C>A<D;(K;(8::8H6;B(KN(:7;(7AG86(K;H6@(68:A<8IIN?(6;H:7;<(FH8(HGG;BH8:;(C>6DCH>AD6;DD(6><(FH8(:7;(;FHB;6C;(>E(:7;(IHE;(7;(78D(7H:7;<:>(I;B?(E><(:7;(B;9:7D(>E(7HD(>=6(7;8<:(T:7;(DAKc;C:HF;(EH<D:(@<>A6B(>E(7HD(G8PHGDY(8<;(:>(7HG(H6DC<A:8KI;OS(TRdA<(eK;<f;A@A6@(8K;<(7H;<F>6(^866(6A6(f=8<(B;<(,;6DC7(68:g<IHC7;<=;HD;(6HC7:(@;I86@;6?(=;B;<(BA<C7(A6GH::;IK8<;D(4;=Ah:D;H6(6>C7(BA<C7(B;6(4;=;HD(D;H6;D(KHD(B87H6(@;Eg7<:;6(2;K;6D=86B;IDi(=;HI(BH;(%H;E;(B;D(";<f;6D(TB;<(DAKc;^:HF;(;<D:;(/<A6B(D;H6;<(,8PHG;6Y(H7G(D;IKD:(A6;<E><DC7IHC7(HD:OOOSY

Page 98: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

Xa>E(<8BHC8I(;FHI(>CCA<D(><(;F;6(>E(=7;:7;<(:7HD(>F;<C>GH6@(78D(;F;<(>CCA<<;B(H6(86N(

9;<D>6MD(IHE;Oj(#I:7>A@7(=;(^6>=(:78:(=;(GAD:(K;(8KI;(:>(8CC>G9IHD7(:7HD(:<86DE><G8:H>6?(

H6D>E8<(8D(:7;(G><8I(I8=(C>GG86BD(H:?(<;8D>6(I;8F;D(AD(=H:7(@89D(H6(>A<(A6B;<D:86BH6@(>E(

7>=(:7HD(:<86DE><G8:H>6(C>AIB(K;(9>DDHKI;O[()H:7>A:(78FH6@(^6>=I;B@;(>E(7>=(:7HD(

<;F>IA:H>6(C>AIB(<;DAI:(E<>G(>A<(8C:H>6D(86B(C898CH:H;D?(=;(C866>:(A6B;<D:86B(:7;(

9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:(H6(>A<(>=6(IHF;DO

4;C8AD;(=;(8<;(A68KI;(:>(^6>=(7>=(:7;(>F;<C>GH6@(>E(<8BHC8I(;FHI(HD(9>DDHKI;(E><(

AD(:>(8CC>G9IHD7?(=;(8<;(H6(B86@;<(>E(E8IIH6@(H6:>(8(D:8:;(>E(B;D98H<(86B(=HII(E8HI(:>(9A<DA;(

:7;(>F;<C>GH6@(>E(;FHI(K;C8AD;(=;(:7H6^(:78:(H:(HD(HG9>DDHKI;OX(">=;F;<?(KN(EHIIH6@(H6(:7;(

@89D(H6(>A<(^6>=I;B@;(H6(:=>(=8ND?(=;(C86(CH<CAGF;6:(:7HD(IHGH:8:H>6O(0H<D:?(L86:(=<H:;D(

:78:(=;(GAD:(78F;(8(C>6EHB;6C;(TE"%9(",.Y(:78:(=;(78F;(:7;(C898CH:N(:>(G><8IIN(HG9<>F;O(

%78:(HD?(=;(GAD:(A6B;<D:86B(>A<D;IF;D(8D(K;H6@D(=7>(78F;(:7;(C898CH:N(:>(K;C>G;(

G><8IIN(@>>BOJa(3;C>6B?(L86:(=<H:;D(:78:(=;(GAD:(78F;(7>9;(TF!77,.Y(:78:(RKN(:7;(

;P;<:H>6(>E(k>A<(>=6l(9>=;<S(=;(C86(K;C>G;(G><8IIN(@>>BO(%7HD(7>9;(D7>AIB(K;(

A6B;<D:>>B(8D(8(^H6B(>E(<8:H>68IIN(cAD:HEH;B(;P9;C:8:H>6(:78:(D>G;:7H6@(=HII(7899;6OJJ(%78:(

j 3;;(L86:?(8,+5#5!.&`U]_?(`U]j?(86B(`U_aO

[ L86:(8C^6>=I;B@;D(:78:(<;8D>6(C866>:(9<>FHB;(AD(=H:7(8(C>G9I;:;(A6B;<D:86BH6@(>E(C;<:8H6(8D9;C:D(>E(G><8IH:N?(BA;(:>(H:D(IHGH:8:H>6D(:>(:78:(=7HC7(899;8<D(H6(D98C;(86B(:HG;O(39;CHEHC8IIN?(7;(=<H:;D(:78:(<;8D>6(78D(86(RHG9>:;6C;(:>(D8:HDEN(H:D(G><8I(6;;BDS(T8,+5#5!.:&`U_QYO(-(=HII(78F;(GAC7(G><;(:>(D8N(8K>A:(:7HD(HG9>:;6C;(86B(7>=(<;8D>6(8::;G9:D(:>(C>G9I;:;(>A<(A6B;<D:86BH6@(>E(G><8IH:N?(H6(D9H:;(>E(:7HD(I8C^?(H6(=78:(E>II>=DO

X L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`U`J(86B(`U`QO

Ja 3;;(L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`U`[O(-6(:7HD(98DD8@;?(L86:(HD(8BB<;DDH6@(:7;(6;;B(:>(78F;(C>6EHB;6C;(:78:(=;(78F;(8(@>>B(=,15..".#:&8E:;<(=;(78F;(>F;<C>G;(<8BHC8I(;FHI?(B;D9H:;(>A<(H68KHIH:N(:>(^6>=(:7;(D:8:;(>E(>A<(=,15..".#G&%7HD(C>6EHB;6C;(HD(6;C;DD8<N(E><(>A<(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:(K;C8AD;(=;(GAD:(A6B;<D:86B(:78:(=;(78F;(:7;(C898CH:N(:>(HG9<>F;(:7;(G><8I(=><:7(>E(>A<(8C:H>6D?(I;D:(=;(E8II(H6:>(B;D98H<O

JJ '>;(0<;GD:;B8I?(RLH;<^;@88<BMD(B>AKI;(G>F;G;6:(>E(E8H:7(86B(L86:MD(G><8I(E8H:7?S(8,+5#5!"1&H%"05,1&][O(QO(TVA6;(QaJQYU(Qa\O

Page 99: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

XJHD?(H:(HD(86(86:HCH98:H>6(>E(D>G;:7H6@(:78:(8(9;<D>6(78D(8(cAD:HEH;B(<;8D>6(E><(;P9;C:H6@(:78:(

H:(C86?(H6B;;B?(7899;6O(%7;D;(:=>(:;<GD(8<;(BHD:H6C:(KA:(H6:HG8:;IN(C>66;C:;BO(%7HD(

C>6EHB;6C;(H6(>A<(C898CH:N(:>(HG9<>F;(@HF;D(AD(7>9;(:78:(=;(C86(H6B;;B(K;C>G;(G><8IIN(

@>>BOJQ(4N(<;INH6@(A9>6(C>6EHB;6C;(86B(7>9;(E><(86(;P9I868:H>6(>E(7>=(=;(C86(>F;<C>G;(

<8BHC8I(;FHI?(=;(=HII(K;(8KI;(:>(8F>HB(B;D98H<(86B(:>(9;<DHD:(H6(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:O

4;N>6B(8F>HBH6@(:7;(9<>KI;G(>E(B;D98H<?(:7;<;(HD(86>:7;<(G8c><(<;8D>6(=7N(8(

:7><>A@7(;P8GH68:H>6(>E(7>=(=;(C86(;P9I8H6(:7HD(9>DDHKHIH:N(HD(6;C;DD8<N(9<H><(:>(8(

BHDCADDH>6(>E(:7;(9I8C;(>E(:7HD(>F;<C>GH6@(H6(L86:MD(8CC>A6:(>E(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:O(-E(H:(

HD(HG9>DDHKI;(E><(7AG86D(:>(>F;<C>G;(<8BHC8I(;FHI?(:7;6(:7HD(>F;<C>GH6@(C866>:(K;(@HF;6(

8(9I8C;(H6(86(8CC>A6:(>E(:7;(=8N(:78:(7AG86D(K;C>G;(G><8IIN(@>>BO(-E(=;(C866>:(;P9I8H6(

7>=(H:(HD(9>DDHKI;(:>(>F;<C>G;(<8BHC8I(;FHI?(=;(GAD:(;H:7;<(B;CI8<;(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:?(

H6CIABH6@(:7;(8KHIH:N(:>(9;<E><G(G><8IIN(@>>B(8C:H>6D?(HG9>DDHKI;(E><(7AG86D?(8CC><BH6@(

:>(L86:MD(97HI>D>97N?(><?(8D(78D(K;;6(:7;(C8D;(H6(GAC7(>E(:7;(IH:;<8:A<;?(D;:(8DHB;(L86:MD(

CI8HG(:78:(8II(7AG86D(8<;(<8BHC8IIN(;FHI(86B(7HD(8CC>A6:(>E(>F;<C>GH6@(;FHI(=7;6(

C>6DHB;<H6@(7HD(:7;><N(>E(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:O(%7;(EH<D:(HD(8(=7>IIN(A6B;DH<8KI;(

C>6D;ZA;6C;(E><(86N>6;(=7>(B>;D(6>:(=HD7(:>(A6B;<GH6;(L86:MD(;6:H<;(97HI>D>97HC8I(

DND:;G?(86B?(8D(=;(=HII(D;;?(H:(<;DAI:D(H6(86(H68CCA<8:;(<;8BH6@(>E(7HD(CI8HGD(86B(

8<@AG;6:DO(%7;(D;C>6B?(8D(-(78F;(8<@A;B(H6(!789:;<(%=>?(8ID>(=>AIB(6>:(K;(86(8CCA<8:;(

<;8BH6@(>E(7HD(:7;><N(K;C8AD;(>E(:7;(HG9><:86:(:<86DE><G8:HF;(<>I;(:78:(L86:MD(CI8HG(

JQ L86:(=<H:;D(:78:?(;F;6(:7>A@7(8(9;<D>6(C866>:(78F;(^6>=I;B@;(>E(=7;:7;<(7;(8C:A8IIN(HG9<>F;D?(ROOO7;(GAD:(K;(8KI;(:>($!),&:78:?(KN(:7;(;P;<:H>6(>E($51&!/.&9>=;<?(7;(=HII(8::8H6(:>(:7;(<>8B(:78:(I;8BD(H6(:78:(BH<;C:H>6?(8D(H6BHC8:;B(:>(7HG(KN(8(EA6B8G;6:8IIN(HG9<>F;B(BHD9>DH:H>6S(T`U_JYO(";(=<H:;D(H6(86>:7;<(D;C:H>6(:78:?(HE(=;(B>(6>:(78F;(C>6EHB;6C;(:78:(=;(78F;(:7;(C898CH:N(:>(K;C>G;(G><8IIN(@>>B(TH6(:7HD(C8D;?(7;(HD(<;E;<<H6@(:>(8I<;8BN(78FH6@(8(@>>B(=,15..".#:&=7HC7(@HF;D(AD(:7;(C898CH:N(:>(HG9<>F;(:7;(G><8I(=><:7(>E(>A<(8C:H>6DY?(=;(=HII(6>:(K;(8KI;(:>(9;<D;F;<;(H6(>A<(HG9<>FH6@(T`U`[YO(%7;D;(:=>(C>6C;9:D?(C>6EHB;6C;(86B(7>9;?(8<;(<;I8:;B(H6D>E8<(8D(L86:(6>:;D(:78:(C>6EHB;6C;(H6(>A<(C898CH:N(:>(HG9<>F;(@HF;D(AD(7>9;(:78:(=;(=HII(DACC;DDEAIIN(G><8IIN(HG9<>F;(T`U`[YO

Page 100: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

XQ<;@8<BH6@(:7;(A6HF;<D8IH:N(>E(<8BHC8I(;FHI(CI;8<IN(9I8ND(H6(7HD(G><8I(97HI>D>97NO(-6(><B;<(:>(

@HF;(86N(9I8C;(b(I;:(8I>6;(86(8CCA<8:;(>6;(b(:>(:7;(>F;<C>GH6@(>E(<8BHC8I(;FHI(H6(L86:MD(

8CC>A6:(>E(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:?(=;(GAD:(K;(8KI;(:>(;P9I8H6(7>=(H:(HD(9>DDHKI;(E><(7AG86D(

:>(8C7H;F;(H:O

-6(><B;<(:>(8F>HB(K>:7(>E(:7;D;(9<>KI;GD?(=;(GAD:(K;(8KI;(:>(A6B;<D:86B(:7;(

>F;<C>GH6@(>E(<8BHC8I(;FHI(8D(G><8IIN(9>DDHKI;(H6(>A<(>=6(IHF;DO(%>(B>(:7HD?(=;(GAD:(EH<D:(

^6>=(=78:(DAC7(86(>F;<C>GH6@(=>AIB(;6:8HI?(=7HC7(C86(K;(B;:;<GH6;B(E<>G(:7;(C>6C;9:(

>E(8(<;F>IA:H>6(86B(HD(I8HB(>A:(E><(AD(KN(L86:O(1;D9H:;(:7;(E8C:(:78:(L86:(:8I^D(8K>A:(:7;(

>F;<C>GH6@(>E(<8BHC8I(;FHI(8D(>CCA<<H6@(H6(>6;?(DH6@AI8<(:<86DE><G8:H>6?J\(-(=HII(8<:HEHCH8IIN(

8KD:<8C:(:7HD(:<86DE><G8:H>6(H6:>(:7<;;(D;98<8:;(G>G;6:DU(TJY(:7;(C7>HC;(:>(<;9<H><H:Hf;(

>6;MD(EA6B8G;6:8I(G8PHG(DAC7(:78:(>6;(78D(8(@>>B(=,15..".#&<8:7;<(:786(86(;FHI(>6;?(TQY(

:7;(<;KH<:7(>E(8(9;<D>6(E<>G(78FH6@(86(;FHI(G><8I(HB;6:H:N(:>(78FH6@(8(@>>B(>6;?(86B(T\Y(

8CZAH<H6@(:7;(C898CH:N(:>(HG9<>F;(:7;(G><8I(=><:7(>E(>6;MD(98<:HCAI8<(8C:H>6DO(

%7;(<;8D>6(:78:(-(=HII(BHFHB;(:7;(>F;<C>GH6@(>E(<8BHC8I(;FHI(H6:>(:7;D;(:7<;;(

BHD:H6C:(G>G;6:D(>E(C786@;(HD(K;C8AD;?(8D(=;(=HII(D;;?(:7;(9<>KI;G(>E(>A<(;9HD:;G>I>@HC8I(

IHGH:8:H>6D(:78:(B>(6>:(8II>=(AD(:>(A6B;<D:86B(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(>F;<C>GH6@(<8BHC8I(;FHI(

B>(6>:(899IN(:>(;F;<N(G>G;6:(>E(C786@;(H6(:7;(>F;<C>GH6@O()7HI;(L86:(B>;D(CI8HG(:78:(

=;(C866>:(78F;(:7;><;:HC8I(^6>=I;B@;(>E(:7;(;6:H<H:N(>E(:7;(>F;<C>GH6@(>E(<8BHC8I(;FHI?(H:(

B>;D(899;8<(:78:(=;(C86(78F;(^6>=I;B@;(>E(8:(I;8D:(D>G;(>E(:7;D;(G>G;6:D(>E(C786@;(

T:7>A@7(C;<:8H6IN(6>:(8II?(=7HC7(=>AIB(C>6:<8BHC:(L86:MD(CI8HG(>E(>A<(;9HD:;G>I>@HC8I(

IHGH:8:H>6D(<;@8<BH6@(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:YO(-6(:7;D;(C8D;D(H6(=7HC7(=;(C86(78F;(DAEEHCH;6:(

^6>=I;B@;?(=;(=>AIB(6>:(6;;B(:>(<;IN(A9>6(CAI:HF8:H6@(C>6EHB;6C;(86B(7>9;(K;C8AD;(=;(

J\ 3;;(L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`U][O

Page 101: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

X\8I<;8BN(78F;(:7;(6;C;DD8<N(^6>=I;B@;(H6(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(8C7H;FH6@(:7;(C786@;(8:(786B(

:>(C>6:H6A;(>6(:7;(98:7(>E(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:O(%7AD?(A6B;<D:86BH6@(:7;(>F;<C>GH6@(>E(

<8BHC8I(;FHI(8D(9>DDHKI;(<;ZAH<;D(AD(:>(I>>^(8:(:7;D;(:7<;;(C786@;D(D;98<8:;INO

#D(=;(=HII(D;;?(H6(:7;(C8D;(>E(:7;(EH<D:(86B(:7H<B(G>G;6:D(>E(C786@;?(:7;<;(HD(8(

E8H<IN(D:<8H@7:E><=8<B(=8N(>E(A6B;<D:86BH6@(7>=(;8C7(HD(9>DDHKI;(H6(>A<(>=6(IHF;D?(;H:7;<(

:7<>A@7(:7;><;:HC8I(^6>=I;B@;(><(:7<>A@7(=78:(L86:(=HII(C8II(8(RG><8I(;D:HG8:;?S(=7HC7(

HD(D>G;:7H6@(=;8^;<(:786(:7;><;:HC8I(^6>=I;B@;(KA:(DAEEHCH;6:(E><(>A<(A6B;<D:86BH6@(>E(

G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:(8D(9>DDHKI;O(">=;F;<?(H6(:7;(C8D;(>E(:7;(G><8I(<;KH<:7?(=;(8<;(A68KI;(

:>(A6B;<D:86B(:7HD(^H6B(>E(C786@;(8D(9>DDHKI;(K;C8AD;(=;(C866>:(8CZAH<;(:7;(^6>=I;B@;(

6;C;DD8<N(:>(8DD;GKI;(8(C>G9I;:;(A6B;<D:86BH6@(>E(7>=(DAC7(8(C786@;(C>AIB(:8^;(9I8C;(

H6(>A<(IHF;DO(#D(-(=HII(BHDCADD(K;I>=?(H6(DAC7(8(C8D;?(L86:(:7H6^D(:78:(=;(GAD:(CAI:HF8:;(8(

K;IH;E(H6(C;<:8H6(>Kc;C:D(:78:(=>AIB(8CC>A6:(E><(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(:7;D;(C786@;DO(-6(>:7;<(

=><BD?(7AG86D(GAD:(9>DH:(86(>Kc;C:?(><(>Kc;C:D?(:78:(;P9I8H6(:7;(C>6BH:H>6D(E><(:7;(

9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(DAC7(8(C786@;OJ]

-6(:7;(C8D;(>E(C786@;D(H6(=7HC7(=;(GAD:(CAI:HF8:;(K;IH;ED?(=;(C86(:7;6(AD;(:7;D;(

K;IH;ED?(=7HC7(=HII(K;(@<>A6B;B(H6(<;8D>6?(:>(DA99><:(>A<(7>9;(:78:(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:(HD(

9>DDHKI;O(%7HD(K;IH;E(=HII(@HF;(AD(:7;(6;C;DD8<N(C>6EHB;6C;(:>(9;<DHD:(H6(G><8I(

HG9<>F;G;6:(:78:(L86:(=><<H;D(8K>A:(K;C8AD;?(8CC><BH6@(:>(L86:?(E8H:7?(><(K;IH;E?(HD(8(

E><G(>E(C>6EHB;6C;O(-6(:7;(:7H<B(I95%5J",:&L86:(;ZA8:;D(=+("*,.:&><(K;IH;E?(=H:7(

C>6EHB;6C;O(";(=<H:;D?(R08H:7(k=+("*,.l&TDHG9IN(D>(C8II;BY(HD(C>6EHB;6C;(kK,9%9(",.l(H6(

:7;(8::8H6G;6:(>E(86(8HG(:7;(9<>G>:H>6(>E(=7HC7(HD(8(BA:N(KA:(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(:7;(

J] #D(-(=HII(BHDCADD(I8:;<?(L86:(DA@@;D:D(/>BMD(@<8C;(8D(:7HD(6;C;DD8<N(9>DH:;B(>Kc;C:O

Page 102: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

X]<;8IHf8:H>6(>E(=7HC7(H:(HD(6>:(9>DDHKI;(E><(AD(:>(78F;(H6DH@7:(H6:>OOOSJ_(#D(-(=HII(

B;G>6D:<8:;?(H6(:7;(C8D;D(H6(=7HC7(=;(GAD:(CAI:HF8:;(K;IH;ED?(=;(C86(:7;6(AD;(:7;D;(

K;IH;ED?(=7HC7(=HII(K;(@<>A6B;B(H6(<;8D>6?(:>(DA99><:(>A<(7>9;(:78:(=;(=HII(G><8IIN(

HG9<>F;O(%7AD?(8D(6>:;B(8K>F;?(>6C;(=;(78F;(8CZAH<;B(C>6EHB;6C;(H6(>A<(C898CH:H;D(:>(

HG9<>F;?(><(=78:(=;(=HII(6>=(C8II(K;IH;E?(=;(C86(8CZAH<;(:7;(6;C;DD8<N(7>9;O

(-6(:7HD(C789:;<?(-(EH<D:(=HII(<;FH;=(:7;D;(:7<;;(^H6BD?(><(G>G;6:D?(>E(C786@;(:78:(

C>6D:H:A:;(:7;(>F;<C>GH6@(>E(<8BHC8I(;FHIO(%7;6?(-(=HII(8BB<;DD(;8C7(D:;9(D;98<8:;IN?(

H6F;D:H@8:H6@(7>=(=;(C86(A6B;<D:86B(;8C7(^H6B(>E(C786@;(8D(9>DDHKI;O(#D(=;(=HII(D;;?(

7AG86D(C866>:(A6B;<D:86B(8D(9>DDHKI;(>6;(>E(:7;D;(:7<;;(^H6BD(>E(C786@;?(:7;(G><8I(

<;KH<:7?(:7<>A@7(^6>=I;B@;(8I>6;O(-6(IH@7:(>E(:7HD?(-(=HII(D9;6B(:7;(<;G8H6B;<(>E(:7;(

C789:;<(C>6DHB;<H6@(7>=(L86:(HD(D:HII(8KI;(:>(;P9I8H6(7>=(=;(C>AIB(A6B;<D:86B(:7HD(D><:(>E(

C786@;(8D(9>DDHKI;(86B(=7;:7;<(:7;<;(HD(86>:7;<(=8N(>E(A6B;<D:86BH6@(:7HDO

,-.*/%0."#1*%2*3-4"5.*)"*#-.*67.$(%0)"5*%2*84&)(49*:7)9

-6(><B;<(:>(A6B;<D:86B(=78:(HD(6;C;DD8<N(:>(>F;<C>G;(<8BHC8I(;FHI?(=;(GAD:(EH<D:(

A6B;<D:86B(E<>G(=7;<;(=;(GAD:(K;@H6(:7HD(^H6B(>E(HG9<>F;G;6:O(%7HD(D:8<:H6@(9I8C;?(8D(H:(

:A<6D(>A:?(=HII(7;I9(AD(:>(C>6D:<AC:(:7;(<>8BG89(>E(7>=(:>(<;G>F;(>A<D;IF;D(E<>G(H:O(#E:;<(

L86:(CI8HGD(:78:(8II(7AG86D(8<;(A6HF;<D8IIN(<8BHC8IIN(;FHI?(7;(C86(6>(I>6@;<(K;@H6(7HD(

8CC>A6:(>E(G><8I(B;F;I>9G;6:(=H:7(:7;(8DDAG9:H>6(:78:(8II(7AG86D(8<;(G><8IIN(H66>C;6:O(

'8:7;<?(;F;<N(9;<D>6(K;@H6D(G><8I(B;F;I>9G;6:(E<>G(8(D:8<:H6@(9I8C;(>E(<8BHC8I(;FHIO(L86:(

=<H:;D?(H6(:7;(8,+5#5!.?(:78:(:7;(9<;D;6C;(>E(<8BHC8I(;FHI(H6(7AG86D(B>;D(6>:(C786@;(=78:(

BA:N(B;G86BD(>E(AD?(><(RG><8I(B>@G8:HCDS(T<!9(+51'$,.&-!#<(%5CY:(KA:(H:(B>;D(HG98C:(

J_ R1;<(/I8AK;(TDC7I;C7:7H6(D>(@;6866:Y(HD:(;H6(+;<:<8A;6(fA(B;<(&<<;HC7A6@(;H6;<(#KDHC7:?(B;<;6(4;Em<B;<A6@($EIHC7:?(BH;(,m@IHC7^;H:(B;<(#ADEg7<A6@(B;<D;IK;6(8K;<(Eg<(A6D(6HC7:(,5.>"1,$,.(HD:(TE>I@IHC7(8AC7(6HC7:(BH;(B;<(;H6fH@;6(Eg<(A6D(B;6^K8<;6(4;BH6@A6@;6YS(TL86:?(!$V?(_U]jQYO(

Page 103: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

X_RG><8I(BHDCH9IH6;S(T<!9(+51'$,.&L1C,%5CYO*";(=<H:;D?(R);(C866>:(D:8<:(>A:(H6(:7;(;:7HC8I(

:<8H6H6@(>E(>A<(C>68:A<8I(G><8I(9<;BHD9>DH:H>6(:>(:7;(@>>B(=H:7(86(H66>C;6C;(=7HC7(HD(

68:A<8I(:>(AD(KA:(GAD:(<8:7;<(K;@H6(E<>G(:7;(9<;DA99>DH:H>6(>E(8(B;9<8FH:N(>E(>A<(9>=;<(>E(

C7>HC;(H6(8B>9:H6@(G8PHGD(C>6:<8<N(:>(:7;(><H@H68I(;:7HC8I(9<;BHD9>DH:H>6OOOSJ`(-E(=;(8<;(:>(

9<>9;<IN(A6B;<D:86B(L86:MD(EAII(8CC>A6:(>E(G><8I(B;F;I>9G;6:?(:7;6?(=;(GAD:(I>>^(8:(7>=(

:7;(9<;D;6C;(>E(G><8I(;FHI(8I:;<D(7>=(=;(=HII(@>(8K>A:(EAIEHIIH6@(>A<(BA:N(:>(K;C>G;(

G><8IIN(@>>B?(=7HC7(<;G8H6D(A6C786@;BO

)78:(HD(:7;(BHEE;<;6C;?(:7;6?(K;:=;;6(D:8<:H6@(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:(E<>G(8(9I8C;(>E(

H66>C;6C;(86B(E<>G(8(9I8C;(>E(<8BHC8I(;FHIn(#D(#II;6()O()>>B(9A:D(H:?(R%7;(<8BHC8I(;FHI(

=;(78F;(K<>A@7:(A9>6(>A<D;IF;D(:7AD(HG9>D;D(>6(AD(B;EH6H:;(C>6BH:H>6D(A6B;<(=7HC7(

8I>6;(=;(9A<DA;(G><8I(9;<E;C:H>6OSJj(4;C8AD;(>E(:7;(9<;D;6C;(>E(<8BHC8I(;FHI?(=;(C866>:(

K;C>G;(G><8IIN(@>>B(G;<;IN(KN(CAI:HF8:H6@(>A<(68:A<8I(9<;BHD9>DH:H>6(:>(@>>BO('8:7;<?(

=;(GAD:?(8D(L86:(D8ND?(C>GK8:(:7;(R8C:HF;(86B(>99>DH6@(C8AD;(>E(;FHIS(T*,75.0+5'$,&

,.%,#,#,./59C,.0,&M91('$,&0,1&ND1,.Y&=7HC7(IH;D(=H:7H6(ADOJ[(%7HD(C8AD;?(8D(=;(78F;(

D;;6?(HD(>A<(G>D:(EA6B8G;6:8I(G8PHGO("8FH6@(86(;FHI(=,15..".#(HD(86(HG9;BHG;6:(:>(

@>>B(86B(GAD:(K;(8BB<;DD;B(K;E><;(CAI:HF8:H6@(:7;(@>>B(H6(ADO

L86:(B<8=D(8(BHD:H6C:H>6(K;:=;;6(:=>(^H6BD(>E(G><8I(C78<8C:;<(86B(8<@A;D(:78:(

:7;D;(^H6BD(>E(C78<8C:;<(8<;(HG9<>F;B(H6(BHEE;<;6:(=8NDO(%7;(EH<D:(^H6B(>E(C78<8C:;<?(

;G9H<HC8I(C78<8C:;<(T,<)5951'$,.&I$(9(C%,9Y?*HD(B;EH6;B(8D(R:7;(EH<G(<;D>IF;(:>(C>G9IN(

J` L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`U_JO(TRk)lH<(^m66;6(H6(B;<(DH::IHC7;6(#ADKHIBA6@(B;<(86;<DC78EE;6;6(G><8IHDC7;6(#6I8@;(fAG(/A:;6(6HC7:(F>6(;H6;<(A6D(68:g<IHC7;6(W6DC7AIB(B;6(#6E86@(G8C7;6?(D>6B;<6(GgDD;6(F>6(B;<(+><8ADD;:fA6@(;H6;<(4mD8<:H@^;H:(B;<()HII^g<(H6(#66;7GA6@(H7<;<(,8PHG;6(B;<(A<D9<g6@IHC7;6(DH::IHC7;6(#6@I8@;(fA=HB;<(867;K;6OOOSY

Jj )>>B?(2(.%31&@!9(+&8,+5#5!.:(QQjO

J[ L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`U_jO

Page 104: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

X`=H:7(BA:NOOO8D(8(78KH:S(T-,9&>"9&;,9%5#C,5%&#,/!90,.,&7,1%,&K!91(%>&5.&N,7!+#".#&1,5.,9 &

47+5'$%&$,5O%&("'$&P"#,.0YGJX(%7HD(G8^;D(8(9;<D>6(@>>B(H6(:7;(I;@8I(D;6D;?(H6D>E8<(8D(:7;(

G8PHGD(>E(7;<(8C:H>6D(C>6E><G(=H:7(BA:NO(%7HD(HD(8::8H6;B(:7<>A@7(8(I>6@(9<>C;DD(>E(

78KH:A8:H>6(86B(@<8BA8I(<;E><G?(:7<>A@7(=7HC7(8(9;<D>6(C>G;D(:>(G8^;(:7;(G8PHGD(>E(

7;<(8C:H>6D(8IH@6(=H:7(=78:(BA:N(<;ZAH<;DO(*6(:7;(DA<E8C;?(:7;<;(HD(6>:7H6@(=<>6@(=H:7(

78FH6@(>6;MD(8C:H>6D(C>6E><G(=H:7(BA:NO(">=;F;<?(:7HD(K;C>G;D(8(9<>KI;G(HE(8(9;<D>6MD(

8C:H>6D(!.+6(C>6E><G(=H:7(BA:N(<8:7;<(:786(8C:A8IIN(K;H6@(G>:HF8:;B(KN(BA:N(H:D;IE?(86B(8(

G;<;(HG9<>F;G;6:(H6(;G9H<HC8I(C78<8C:;<(C866>:(I;8B(:>(:7HD(;6BOQa(-E(8(9;<D>6(>6IN(

8::;G9:D(:>(HG9<>F;(:7HD(^H6B(>E(C78<8C:;<?(D7;(=HII(6;F;<(K;C>G;(G><8IIN(@>>B(KA:(>6IN(

<;G8H6(I;@8IIN(@>>BO(%>(AD;(86(;P8G9I;(>E(L86:MD?(8(9;<D>6(A6B;<@>H6@(:7HD(^H6B(>E(

HG9<>F;G;6:(GH@7:(C786@;(E<>G(K;H6@(8(IH8<(:>(:;IIH6@(:7;(:<A:7(E><(:7;(D8^;(>E(7;<(

<;9A:8:H>6?QJ(KA:(D7;(=HII(6>:(K;@H6(:>(:;II(:7;(:<A:7(E><(:7;(D8^;(>E(BA:NO()7HI;(:7HD(^H6B(>E(

HG9<>F;G;6:(B>;D(G8^;(8(9;<D>6(899;8<(:>(K;(@>>B?(H6(:7;(D;6D;(:78:(D7;(9;<E><GD(8II(>E(

:7;(8C:H>6D(:78:(8(9;<D>6(8C:H6@(E<>G(BA:N(=>AIB?(H:(B>;D(6>:(C786@;(8(9;<D>6MD(><H@H68I(

;FHI(=,15..".#G

-6(><B;<(:>(>F;<C>G;(<8BHC8I(;FHI?(:7;6?(8(9;<D>6(GAD:(8::;G9:(:>(C786@;(6>:(7HD(

;G9H<HC8I(C78<8C:;<(KA:(7HD(H6:;IIH@HKI;(C78<8C:;<(T5.%,++5#5*,+,.&I$(9(C%,9Y(TQ59%"1 &

.!"<,.!.R&=7HC7(HD(=7;<;(:7;(C8AD;(>E(;FHI(IH;DOQQ()7;6(8(9;<D>6(78D(8(@>>B(H6:;IIH@HKI;(

C78<8C:;<?(7;(HD(RH6(6;;B(>E(6>(>:7;<(H6C;6:HF;(:>(<;C>@6Hf;(8(BA:N(;PC;9:(:7;(

JX L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`U]jO

Qa #D()>>B(9>H6:D(>A:?(=H:7>A:(8(C786@;(H6(7HD(=,15..".#?(8(9;<D>6(C866>:(A6B;<@>(R@;6AH6;(G><8I(9<>@<;DD?S(KA:(>6IN(8(9<>@<;DD(H6(:7;(899;8<86C;(>E(>6;MD(8C:H>6D(T2(.%31&@!9(+&8,+5#5!.:&QQj(b(QQXYO

QJ 0><(L86:MD(BHDCADDH>6(>E(:7HD(^H6B(>E(HG9<>F;G;6:?(D;;(8,+5#5!.:&`U]jO

QQ #II;6()>>B?(H6(2(.%31&@!9(+&8,+5#5!.:(<;E;<D(:>(:7HD(8D(8(9;<D>6MD(RDA9;<D;6DHKI;(G><8I(C78<8C:;<S(TQQ[YO

Page 105: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

Xj<;9<;D;6:8:H>6(>E(BA:N(H:D;IES(T/,+'$,9&/,..&,9&,%/(1&(+1&47+5'$%&,9C,..%:&C,5.,9&(.0,9. &

P95,*7,0,9&/,5%,9&*,0(97&(+1&05,1,9&K!91%,++".#&0,9&47+5'$%&1,+*1%YGQ\*)7;6(8(9;<D>6(78D(8(

@>>B(H6:;IIH@HKI;(C78<8C:;<?(7HD(8C:H>6D(B>(6>:(DHG9IN(C>6E><G(=H:7(BA:N(KA:(8<;(

9;<E><G;B(E><(:7;(D8^;(>E(BA:N?(86B(:7;(9;<D>6(HD(:7;<;E><;(G><8IIN(b(86B(6>:(DHG9IN(

I;@8IIN(o(@>>BO(4;C8AD;(8II(9;>9I;(8<;(68:A<8IIN(<8BHC8IIN(;FHI?(L86:(:7H6^D?(:7;N(GAD:(

K;@H6(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:(=H:7(86(HG9<>F;G;6:(H6(H6:;IIH@HKI;(C78<8C:;<O('8BHC8I(;FHI(

@HF;D(AD(86(H6:;IIH@HKI;(C78<8C:;<(:78:(78D(6>(G><8I(=><:7(K;C8AD;(=;(8<;(A68KI;(:>(

9;<E><G(8C:H>6D(:78:(8<;(G>:HF8:;B(KN(BA:NO(-6(><B;<(:>(:<AIN(<;G>F;(:7;(C8AD;(>E(;FHI?(=;(

6;;B(:>(A6B;<@>(=78:(L86:(C8IID(8(R<;F>IA:H>6?S(=7HC7(H6F>IF;D(8(RC786@;(>E(7;8<:?S(>E(

>A<(H6:;IIH@HKI;(C78<8C:;<OQ](

)7HI;(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(>E(=,15..".#&86B(:7;(C786@;(>E(7;8<:(8<;(:8I^;B(8K>A:(KN(

L86:(8:(:HG;D(8D(:7>A@7(:7;N(G8N(K;(:7;(D8G;(^H6B(>E(C786@;?Q_(:7;N(8<;?(H6(E8C:?(BHD:H6C:(

T:7>A@7?(8D(-(=HII(D7>=(I8:;<(H6(:7HD(C789:;<?(E>A6B8:H>68IIN(IH6^;BY(C786@;DO(-6B;;B?(L86:(

=<H:;D(:78:(:7;(D:8:;(>E(>6;MD(7;8<:?(=7;:7;<(@>>B(><(;FHI?(HD(8(C898CH:N(><(H6C898CH:N(>E(:7;(

S5++CB9&R:>(8B>9:(><(6>:(:>(8B>9:(:7;(G><8I(I8=(H6(H:D(G8PHGD?S(86B(:78:(:7HD(C898CH:N(><(

H6C898CH:N(8<HD;D(E<>G(>6;MD(EA6B8G;6:8I(G8PHGOQ`(%7;(C7>HC;(>E(:7;(D:8:;(>E(>6;MD(

R7;8<:?S(86B(:7AD(:7;(C786@;(>E(7;8<:?(HD(D>G;:7H6@(:78:(E>II>=D(8D(8(C>6D;ZA;6C;(>E(>6;MD(

C7>HC;(>E(=,15..".#G

*6C;(=;(78F;(C7>D;6(8(6;=?(@>>B(=,15..".#&86B(A6B;<@>6;(:7HD(C786@;(>E(7;8<:?(

=;(6>=(78F;(:7;(C898CH:N(:>(K;@H6(HG9<>FH6@(>A<(;G9H<HC8I(C78<8C:;<O(4;C8AD;(=;(=HII(

Q\ L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`U]jO

Q] -KHB?&`U]jO

Q_ -KHBO

Q` -KHB:&`UQXO

Page 106: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

X[78F;(C7>D;6(8(@>>B(H6:;IIH@HKI;(C78<8C:;<(T><(=,15..".#Y(86B(:7AD(6>=(78F;(:7;(C898CH:N(

:>(8B>9:(:7;(G><8I(I8=(H6(>A<(98<:HCAI8<(G8PHGD(K;C8AD;(>E(>A<(@>>B(7;8<:?(:7HD(=><^(>6(

>A<(;G9H<HC8I(C78<8C:;<(C86(8C:A8IIN(I;8B(:>(86(HG9<>F;G;6:(H6(:7;(G><8I(=><:7(>E(>A<(

8C:H>6D(H6(98<:HCAI8<(C8D;D(86B(6>:(G;<;(I;@8IH:N(>E(8C:H>6DOQj(

L86:(@HF;D(AD(EA<:7;<(H6DH@7:(H6:>(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(EAIEHIIH6@(>6;MD(BA:N(:>(K;(8(

G><8IIN(@>>B(9;<D>6(A6B;<(:7;(C>6D:<8H6:D(>E(<8BHC8I(;FHI(KN(;P9I8H6H6@(6>:(>6IN(=78:(

^H6B(>E(C78<8C:;<(6;;BD(:>(C786@;(=H:7H6(AD(KA:(=78:(^H6B(>E(C786@;(HD(6;;B;BO(%7HD(

;P9I868:H>6(7;I9D(:>(CI8<HEN(=78:(H:(G;86D(:>(C786@;(>6;MD(H6:;IIH@HKI;(C78<8C:;<?(=7;6(>6;(

A6B;<@>;D(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(>E(=,15..".#G&";<;?(7;(H6:<>BAC;D(8(BHD:H6C:H>6(K;:=;;6(8(

9;<D>6MD(RG>B;(>E(:7>A@7:S(T-,.C".#1(9%Y?(=7HC7(78D(K;;6(B;DC<HK;B(8D(86(8::<HKA:;(>E(

>6;MD(H6:;IIH@HKI;(C78<8C:;<?&86B(8(9;<D>6MD(RG>B;(>E(D;6D;S(TH5..,1(9%Y?(><(86(8::<HKA:;(>E(

>6;MD(;G9H<HC8I(C78<8C:;<GQ[(#I:7>A@7(BA:N(D:HII(<;ZAH<;D(:78:(8(9;<D>6?(;F;6(HE(D7;(HD(

<8BHC8IIN(;FHI?(G8^;D(7;<D;IE(G><8IIN(@>>B(H6(:7;(EAII(D;6D;(>E(K>:7(78FH6@(8(@>>B(

=,15..".#(86B(9;<E><GH6@(8C:H>6D(E<>G(BA:N?(:7HD(HD(D;;GH6@IN(HG9>DDHKI;(K;C8AD;(>E(:7;(

9<;D;6C;(>E(>6;MD(;FHI(EA6B8G;6:8I(G8PHGO(-:(HD(78<B(:>(C>6C;HF;(7>=(:7HD(<;F>IA:H>6(

8I>6;(=HII(G8^;(8(9;<D>6(G><8IIN(@>>B(H6(K>:7(>E(:7;D;(8K>F;(D;6D;DO(#D(6>:;B(8K>F;?(

L86:(8::;G9:D(:>(CI8<HEN(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(KN(98<DH6@(>A:(:78:(BA:N(<;ZAH<;D(8(<;F>IA:H>6(>6IN(

H6(>6;MD(=8N(>E(:7H6^H6@(KA:(6>:(<;F>IA:H>6(H6(>6;MD(=8N(>E(D;6DH6@O(%7HD(BHD:H6C:H>6(C86(

7;I9(AD(:>(98<D;(>A:(;P8C:IN(=78:(GAD:(C786@;(H6(8(9;<D>6(H6(><B;<(:>(>F;<C>G;(<8BHC8I(

;FHIO(L86:(;P9I8H6D?

%7;(>6IN(=8N(:>(<;C>6CHI;(:7HD(HD(KN(D8NH6@(:78:(8(<;F>IA:H>6(HD(6;C;DD8<N(H6(:7;(G>B;(>E(:7>A@7:(T-,.C".#1(9%R&KA:(8(@<8BA8I(<;E><G8:H>6(H6(:7;(G>B;(>E(D;6D;(

Qj 3;;(-KHB:&`U]`(b(]jO

Q[ 3;;(/O(0;IHCH:8D(,A6f;I?(2(.%31&I!.',)%5!.&!7&@!9(+&I$(9('%,9:&Q_6O

Page 107: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

XXTH5..,1(9%Y(T=7HC7(9I8C;D(>KD:8CI;D(H6(:7;(=8N(>E(:7;(E><G;<Y?(86B(k:78:(K>:7l(GAD:(:7;<;E><;(K;(9>DDHKI;(8ID>(:>(:7;(7AG86(K;H6@O(%78:(HDU(-E(KN(8(DH6@I;(86B(A68I:;<8KI;(B;CHDH>6(8(7AG86(K;H6@(<;F;<D;D(:7;(DA9<;G;(@<>A6B(>E(7HD(G8PHGD(KN(=7HC7(7;(=8D(86(;FHI(7AG86(K;H6@(T86B(:7;<;KN(9A:D(>6(8(R6;=(G86SY?(7;(HD(:>(:7HD(;P:;6:?(KN(9<H6CH9I;(86B(8::H:AB;(>E(GH6B?(8(DAKc;C:(<;C;9:HF;(:>(:7;(@>>Bi(KA:(7;(HD(8(@>>B(7AG86(K;H6@(>6IN(H6(H6C;DD86:(I8K><H6@(86B(K;C>GH6@i(HO;O?(7;(C86(7>9;(b(H6(FH;=(>E(:7;(9A<H:N(>E(:7;(9<H6CH9I;(=7HC7(7;(78D(8B>9:;B(8D(:7;(DA9<;G;(G8PHG(>E(7HD(9>=;<(>E(C7>HC;?(86B(H6(FH;=(>E(:7;(D:8KHIH:N(>E(:7HD(9<H6CH9I;(b(:>(EH6B(7HGD;IE(A9>6(:7;(@>>B(T:7>A@7(68<<>=Y(98:7(>E(C>6D:86:()9!#9,11&E<>G(K8B(:>(K;::;<OQX

%7HD(98DD8@;(<;ZAH<;D(D>G;(A698C^H6@O(-:(HD(G>D:(7;I9EAI(H6(;6786CH6@(>A<(A6B;<D:86BH6@(

>E(=78:(:7HD(<;F>IA:H>6(;6:8HID(H6D>E8<(8D(H:(CI8<HEH;D(:78:(L86:(B>;D(6>:(H6:;6B?(H6(E8C:?(:78:(

:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(D7>AIB(K;(;P9;C:;B(:>(G8^;(AD(G><8IIN(@>>B(H6(:7;(D;6D;(>E(9;<E><GH6@(

@>>B(8C:H>6D(H6(98<:HCAI8<(C8D;D?(><(78FH6@(8(7>IN(=HIIO(L86:(HD(CI;8<(7;<;(:78:(:7;(

<;F>IA:H>6(H:D;IE(>6IN(9;<:8H6D(:>(>A<(-,.C".#1(9%?(><(=8N(>E(:7H6^H6@?(86B(6>:(H5..,1(9%?(

><(=8N(>E(D;6DH6@O(%7;(<;F>IA:H>6(H6(-,.C".#1(9%&G8^;D(7HG(>6IN(<;C;9:HF;(:>(:7;(@>>B(

KA:(6>:(8C:A8IIN(@>>BO(%>(K;C>G;(8C:A8IIN(@>>B?(:78:(9;<D>6(GAD:(:7;6(C786@;(7HD(

H5..,1(9%&:7<>A@7(@<8BA8I(9<>@<;DD(:>=8<BD(:7;(@>>BO

L86:(HB;6:HEH;D(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(7;<;(8D(D>G;:7H6@(:78:(GAD:(:8^;(9I8C;(H6(8(9;<D>6MD(

-,.C".#1(9%G&-6(:7;(:<86DI8:H>6(AD;B(8K>F;?(:7HD(=><B(HD(:<86DI8:;B(H6(:7HD(98DD8@;(8D(

RG>B;(>E(:7>A@7:?S(:7>A@7(H:(C86(8ID>(K;(:<86DI8:;B(8D(RG>B;(>E(:7H6^H6@?S\a(><(R8::H:AB;(

QX L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`U]j(b(][O(TR1H;D;D(HD:(6HC7:(86B;<D(fA(F;<;H6H@;6?(8ID(B8h(BH;(';F>IA:H>6(Eg<(BH;(1;6^A6@D8<:?(BH;(8IIGp7IHC7;(';E><G(8K;<(Eg<(BH;(3H66;D8<:(T=;IC7;(c;6;<("H6B;<6HDD;(;6:@;@;6D:;II:Y(6>:=;6BH@(A6B(B87;<(8AC7(B;G(,;6DC7;6(Gm@IHC7(D;H6(GAhO(18D(HD:U(=;66(;<(B;6(>K;<D:;6(/<A6B(D;H6;<(,8PHG;6?(=>BA<C7(;<(;H6(KmD;<(,;6DC7(=8<?(BA<C7(;H6;(;H6fH@;(A6=86B;IK8<;(&6:DC7IH;hA6@(AG^;7<:(TA6B(7H;<GH:(;H6;6(6;A;6(,;6DC7;6(86fH;7:Y?(D>(HD:(;<(D>E;<6?(B;G($<H6fH9(A6B(B;<(1;6^A6@D8<:(68C7?(;H6(Eg<D(/A:;(;G9Ep6@IHC7;D(3AKc;^:i(8K;<(6A<(H6(^>6:H6AH;<IHC7;G()H<^;6(A6B();<B;6(;H6(@A:;<(,;6DC7U(BOHO(;<(^866(7>EE;6?(B8h(;<(K;H(;H6;<(D>IC7;6(';H6H@^;H:(B;D($<H6fH9D?(=;IC7;D(;<(DHC7(fA<(>K;<D:;6(,8PHG;(D;H6;<()HII^g<(@;6>GG;6(78:?(A6B(B;<(0;D:H@^;H:(B;DD;IK;6?(DHC7(8AE(B;G(@A:;6(T>K=>7I(DC7G8I;6Y();@;(;H6;D(K;D:p6BH@;6(0><:DC7<;H:;6D(F>G(3C7I;C7:;6(fAG(4;DD;<;6(K;EH6B;OSY

\a L8:;(#O(,><86(AD;D(:7HD(:<86DI8:H>6(H6(7;<(K>>^(I!<<".5%6&(.0&49!#9,11&5.&2(.%31&@!9(+&4$5+!1!)$6&T)8D7H6@:>6?(1O!OU(%7;(!8:7>IHC(W6HF;<DH:N($<;DD?(QaJQYO

Page 108: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

Jaa>E(GH6BOS(4;C8AD;(H:(HD(:7;(G>D:(D:<8H@7:E><=8<B?(86B(-(:7H6^?(7;I9EAI?(&6@IHD7(:<86DI8:H>6?(

-(=HII(:<86DI8:;(H:(8D(R=8N(>E(:7H6^H6@S(7;<;O(4A:(=78:(B>;D(L86:(G;86(=7;6(7;(D8ND(:78:(

=;(GAD:(78F;(8(C;<:8H6(R=8N(>E(:7H6^H6@S(H6(><B;<(:>(K;(G><8IIN(@>>Bn(L8:;(#O(,><86(

9<>FHB;D(8(7;I9EAI(B;DC<H9:H>6(>E(=78:(L86:(G;86D(KN(:7;(:;<G(-,.C".#1(9%G&37;(=<H:;D(

:78:(:7HD(=8N(>E(:7H6^H6@(GAD:(K;(D>G;:7H6@(:78:(=;(<8:H>68IIN(C>6:<>I(KA:(6;;B(6>:(

6;C;DD8<HIN(K;(D>G;:7H6@(:78:(=;(8<;(8I=8ND(C>6DCH>AD(>E(78FH6@O(%78:(HD?(>A<(=8N(>E(

:7H6^H6@(C866>:(K;(D>G;:7H6@(:78:(HD(78KH:A8I(K;C8AD;(=;(8<;(<;D9>6DHKI;(E><(H:O(">=;F;<?(

H:(B>;D(6>:(6;;B(:>(K;(D>G;:7H6@(:78:(=;(8<;(8I=8ND(8=8<;(>E(8D(C>6DCH>ADIN(EHI:;<H6@(>A<(

;P9;<H;6C;DO(%7HD(=8N(>E(:7H6^H6@(HD(D>G;:7H6@(:78:(B;F;I>9D(H6(<;D9>6D;(:>(>6;MD(

8=8<;6;DD(>E(>6;MD(<;D9>6DHKHIH:H;D(BA;(:>(:7;(G><8I(I8=O\J(#D(=;(=HII(D;;?(:7;<;(8<;(:=>(

^H6BD(>E(-,.C".#1(9%&T&>6;(:78:(HD(E>A6B(H6(8(<8BHC8IIN(;FHI(9;<D>6(86B(>6;(:78:(HD(E>A6B(

H6(8(G><8IIN(@>>B(9;<D>6O(&8C7(<;DAI:D(E<>G(8(BHEE;<;6:(<;D9>6D;(:>(>6;MD(8=8<;6;DD(>E(

>6;MD(BA:NO

)H:7H6(:7;(8,+5#5!.:&L86:(<;E;<D(:>(8(9;<D>6(=7>(HD(<8BHC8IIN(;FHI(8D(78FH6@(8(

C><<A9:;B(-,.C".#1(9%G&%7HD(G;86D(:78:?(K;C8AD;(>E(:7;(E<;;(C7>HC;(:>(K;(<8BHC8IIN(;FHI?(8(

9;<D>6MD(=8N(>E(:7H6^H6@(78D(K;;6(=8<9;B(DAC7(:78:(:7;N(FH;=(G><8IIN(;FHI(8C:H>6D(8D(

9;<GHDDHKI;(86B?(:7;<;KN?(FH;=(:7;GD;IF;D(8D(G><8IIN(@>>B(=7;6(:7;N(8<;(6>:O(#(9;<D>6(

=7>(HD(<8BHC8IIN(;FHI(C7>>D;D(:>(K;(BHD7>6;D:(H6(:7;(E8C;(>E(BA:N(86B(IH;(:>(7;<D;IE(8K>A:(

=78:(HD(6;C;DD8<N(:>(K;(G><8IIN(@>>BO(%7HD(=8N(>E(:7H6^H6@(G8^;D(8(9;<D>6(FH;=(8C:H>6D(

:78:(C>G9IN(=H:7(:7;(G><8I(I8=(8D(FH<:A>AD(K;C8AD;(H:(G8^;D(:7;G(E>CAD(>6(I;@8I(

\J ,><86?(I!<<".5%6&(.0&49!#9,11:(JJJ(b(JJQO(,><86(>6IN(:8I^D(8K>A:(G><8IIN(@>>B(-,.C".#1(9%&86B(:7AD(B;DC<HK;D(H:(8D(D>G;:7H6@(:78:(8<HD;D(K;C8AD;(>E(>6;MD(8=8<;6;DD(>E(>6;MD(BA:N(86B(H6(><B;<(:>(8DDHD:(>6;(H6(EAIEHIIH6@(:78:(BA:NO(">=;F;<?(H6(:7;(C8D;(>E(G><8IIN(;FHI(-,.C".#1(9%:&H:(D;;GD(:78:(8(9;<D>6(C86(78F;(:7;(>99>DH:;(<;8C:H>6(H6(:7;(E8C;(>E(>6;MD(BA:N(86B(H6D:;8B(C7>>D;(:>(K;(BHD7>6;D:(:>(>6;D;IE(8K>A:(=78:(HD(<;ZAH<;B(E><(BA:NO

Page 109: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

JaJ@>>B6;DD(<8:7;<(:786(:7;(H6C;6:HF;D(H6(:7;(G8PHGD(>E(>6;MD(8C:H>6DO\Q(-6(:7;(C8D;(>E(8(

<8BHC8IIN(;FHI(9;<D>6?(:7;6?(7HD(=8N(>E(:7H6^H6@(8II>=D(7HG(:>(E>CAD(>6(:7;(I;@8IH:N(>E(

8C:H>6D(<8:7;<(:786(:7;(H6C;6:HF;D(>E(8C:H>6D(86B(:7;<;KN(K;IH;F;(:78:(I;@8IIN(@>>B(8C:H>6D(

8<;(G>:HF8:;B(KN(BA:NO

%7HD(HD(:7;(=8N(>E(:7H6^H6@(:78:(GAD:(A6B;<@>(8(<;F>IA:H>6(H6(><B;<(E><(8(9;<D>6(:>(

K;C>G;(G><8IIN(@>>BO()7HI;(:7;(D:8:;(>E(>6;MD(-,.C".#1(9%&=7;6(>6;(HD(<8BHC8IIN(;FHI(HD(

E8H<IN(CI;8<?(L86:(B>;D(6>:(B;DC<HK;(:7;(-,.C".#1(9%&H6(8(G><8IIN(@>>B(9;<D>6(8D(CI;8<IN(

H6(:7;(8,+5#5!.G&">=;F;<?(7;(B>;D(:8I^(8K>A:(:7;(6;;B(E><(8(RG><8I(=8N(>E(:7H6^H6@S(

T15%%+5'$,9&-,.C".#1(9%Y&H6(:7;(@,%()$615'1&!7&@!9(+1:&86B(:7HD(98DD8@;(C86(9<>FHB;(AD(

=H:7(G><;(B;:8HID(8K>A:(:7;(8HG(>E(:7HD(<;F>IA:H>6O(-6(:7;(-!'%95.,&!7&K59%",:&L86:(=<H:;D(

:78:(8(9;<D>6(78D(8(BA:N(:>(8CZAH<;(8(G><8I(-,.C".#1(9%O(";(B;DC<HK;D(H:(8D(8(D:8:;(H6(

=7HC7(R:7;(+(/&K;C>G;D(8ID>(:7;(H6C;6:HF;(:>(7HD(8C:H>6D(:78:(C>6E><G(=H:7(BA:N(86B(7;(

>K;ND(:7;(I8=(E<>G(BA:NOS\\(%7HD(HD(8(CI;8<(C>6:<8D:(:>(:7;(<8BHC8IIN(;FHI(-,.C".#1(9%:&H6(

=7HC7(8(9;<D>6(HD(A6C>6C;<6;B(=H:7(:7;(H6C;6:HF;(>E(8C:H>6D(:78:(C>6E><G(=H:7(BA:NO(%7;(

<;F>IA:H>6(H6(>6;MD(=8N(>E(:7H6^H6@?(:7;6?(H6F>IF;D(K;C>GH6@(C>6C;<6;B(=H:7(:7;(

H6C;6:HF;D(>E(>6;MD(8C:H>6D(86B(8(<;8IHf8:H>6(:78:(>6IN(8C:H>6D(=H:7(G8PHGD(:78:(8<;(E<>G(

BA:N(8<;(G><8IIN(@>>B(8C:H>6DO

\Q R.>=?(;F;6(:7>A@7(8(I8=I;DD(8C:H>6(86B(8(9<>9;6DH:N(:>(DAC7(8(C>6:<8<H;:N?(HO;O?(Q5',:&B>(6>:(8I=8ND(><H@H68:;(E<>G(H:?(:7;(8::H:AB;(>E(GH6B(:78:(C>6D:<A;D(:7;(8KD;6C;(>E(FHC;(8D(8I<;8BN(K;H6@(C>6E><GH:N(>E(:7;(051)!15%5!.&:>(:7;(I8=(>E(BA:N(THO;O(8D(FH<:A;Y(HD(6>6;:7;I;DD(H:D;IE(:>(K;(68G;B(8(<8BHC8I(9;<F;<DH:N(H6(:7;(7AG86(7;8<:(TE><(H6(:7HD(C8D;(6>(8::;6:H>6(8:(8II(HD(@HF;6(:>(:7;(H6C;6:HF;D(H6(:7;(G8PHG(KA:(>6IN(:>(C>G9IH86C;(=H:7(:7;(I;::;<(>E(:7;(I8=S(TR);66(7H;<8AD(6A6(@I;HC7(6HC7:(;K;6(HGG;<(;H6;(@;D;:f=HB<H@;("86BIA6@(A6B(;H6("86@(B8fA?(BOHO(B8D(28D:;<(;6:D9<H6@:?(D>(HD:(BH;(1;6^A6@D8<:?(DHC7(BH;(#K=;D;67;H:(B;DD;IK;6(DC7>6(Eg<(#6@;G;DD;67;H:(B;<(/;DH66A6@(fAG(/;D;:f;(B;<($EIHC7:(TEg<(%A@;6BY(8ADfAI;@;6(TB8(7H;<K;H(8AE(BH;(%<H;KE;B;<(B;<(,8PHG;(@8<(6HC7:?(D>6B;<6(6A<(8AE(BH;(4;E>I@A6@(B;D(/;D;:f;D(B;G(4AC7D:8K;6(68C7(@;D;7;6(=H<BY?(D;IKD:(DC7>6(;H6;(<8BH^8I;(+;<^;7<:7;H:(HG(G;6DC7IHC7;6(";<f;6(fA(6;66;6OSY(TL86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`U\jYO

\\ L86:?(,,:&`U\[jO

Page 110: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

JaQ*6C;(=;(78F;(A6B;<@>6;(:7HD(<;F>IA:H>6(H6(-,.C".#1(9%:&=;(C86(:7;6(C>6DHB;<(

>A<D;IF;D(:>(K;(RA9>6(:7;(@>>B(T:7>A@7(68<<>=Y(98:7(>E(C>6D:86:()9!#9,11&E<>G(K8B(:>(

K;::;<OS\]&%78:(HD?(=;(8<;(6>=(C898KI;(>E(A6B;<@>H6@(8(@<8BA8I(<;E><G8:H>6(>E(>A<(

H5..,1(9%G&/O(0;IHCH:8D(,A6f;I(B;DC<HK;D(:7;(H5..,1(9%&8D(>6;MD(RG;6:8I(86B(;G>:H>68I(

8::<HKA:;D?(H6CIH68:H>6D?(D:8:;D(8D(:7;D;(8<;(;G9H<HC8IIN(;FHB;6:(H6(97NDHC8I(86B(IH6@AHD:HC(

E><GD(>E(;P9<;DDH>6OS\_(37;(6>:;D(:78:(:7;D;(8::<HKA:;D(K;I>6@(:>(>6;MD(;G9H<HC8I?(<8:7;<(

:786(H6:;IIH@HKI;?(C78<8C:;<O()7;6(=;(78F;(A6B;<@>6;(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6?(:7;6?(=;(C86(K;@H6(

:>(E>CAD(A9>6(:7;(@<8BA8I(C786@;D(:78:(GAD:(>CCA<(H6(><B;<(E><(AD(:>(K;(8KI;(:>(9;<E><G(

G><8IIN(@>>B(8C:H>6D?(><(8C:H>6D(:78:(8<;(G>:HF8:;B(KN(BA:NO(L86:(:8I^D(8K>A:(:7;(C8AD8I(

<;I8:H>6D7H9(K;:=;;6(>6;MD(-,.C".#1(9%&86B(H5..,1(9%&H6(:7;(EH<D:(I95%5J",G&";(=<H:;D(:78:(

R:7;(;G9H<HC8I(C78<8C:;<(kH5..,1(9%l&HD(>6C;(8@8H6(B;:;<GH6;B(H6(:7;(H6:;IIH@HKI;(C78<8C:;<(

TH6(:7;(G>B;(>E(:7>A@7:(k-,.C".#1(9%lYOS\`()H:7>A:(86(HG9<>F;G;6:(H6(>A<(-,.C".#1(9%: &

86(HG9<>F;G;6:(H6(>A<(H5..,1(9%&HD(HG9>DDHKI;(H6D>E8<(8D(8(C786@;(H6(>A<(;G9H<HC8I(

C78<8C:;<(=>AIB(6>:(@;:(AD(86N(CI>D;<(:>(:7;(8KHIH:N(:>(9;<E><G(G><8IIN(=><:7N(8C:H>6D(

=H:7>A:(8(9<H><(C786@;(H6(>A<(=,15..".#O(%7HD(HD(:7;(D;6D;(H6(=7HC7(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(9A:D(AD(

>6(:7;(98:7?(><(@HF;D(AD(:7;(C898CH:N?(:>(HG9<>FH6@(:7;(G><8I(=><:7(>E(>A<(8C:H>6DO

%7;(=,15..".#(!7>HC;

#D(6>:;B(8K>F;?(H6(><B;<(:>(>F;<C>G;(<8BHC8I(;FHI(86B(A6B;<@>(:7HD(C786@;(:78:(

@HF;D(AD(8(6;=(=8N(>E(:7H6^H6@(T-,.C".#1(9%Y?(8(9;<D>6(GAD:(C786@;(7HD(=,15..".#:&

=7HC7(HD(:7;(D>A<C;(>E(<8BHC8I(;FHIO(L86:(=<H:;D(:78:(BA:N(<;ZAH<;D(:78:(=;(K;C>G;(

RFH<:A>AD(8CC><BH6@(:>(:7;(H6:;IIH@HKI;(C78<8C:;<(k>E(FH<:A;l(TQ59%"1&.!"<,.!.Y(86B(:7AD(H6(

\] L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`U][O

\_ ,A6f;I?(2(.%31&I!.',)%5!.&!7&@!9(+&I$(9('%,9:(Q_6O

\` L86:?(!$'?(#__Jq_jXO

Page 111: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

Ja\6;;B(>E(6>(>:7;<(H6C;6:HF;(:>(<;C>@6Hf;(8(BA:N(;PC;9:(:7;(<;9<;D;6:8:H>6(>E(BA:N(H:D;IEOS\j(

-:(HD(>A<(BA:N?(H6(E8C:?(:>(R,+,Q(%,&>A<D;IF;D(:>(k:7;l(HB;8I(>E(G><8I(9;<E;C:H>6OS\[*%7HD?(

7>=;F;<?(C866>:(K;(8C7H;F;B(D>(I>6@(8D(8(9;<D>6(D:HII(78D(86(;FHI(EA6B8G;6:8I(G8PHG?(><(

=,15..".#O(%7;<;E><;?(8(9;<D>6(GAD:(A6B;<@>(8(<;F>IA:H>6(>E(=,15..".#?(=7HC7(L86:(

B;DC<HK;D(8D(R8(:<86DH:H>6(:>(:7;(G8PHG(>E(7>IH6;DD(>E(BHD9>DH:H>6S(T,5.,.&U*,9#(.#&>"9&

@(V5<,&0,9&F,5+5#C,5%&0,91,+*,.YO\X(";(=<H:;D(:78:(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(HD(6>:(>6IN(8(C786@;(H6(

>6;MD(=,15..".#(E<>G(;FHI(:>(@>>B(KA:(8ID>(H6F>IF;D(^H6B(>E(<;KH<:7?(H6(=7HC7(8(9;<D>6(

K;C>G;D(8(R6;=(C<;8:H>6S(86B(78D(R8(C786@;(>E(7;8<:OS]a*0H<D:?(:7>A@7?(:7HD(<;F>IA:H>6(

<;ZAH<;D(:7;(C7>HC;(:>(78F;(8(6;=?(@>>B(=,15..".#O(-(=HII(<;E;<(:>(:7HD(C7>HC;(8D(:7;(

R=,15..".#&C7>HC;OS(%7HD(HD(8(E<;;(C7>HC;(:>(9<H><H:Hf;(:7;(H6C;6:HF;D(>E(:7;(G><8I(I8=(

8K>F;(:7;(H6C;6:HF;D(>E(H6CIH68:H>6O(-(=HII(BHDCADD(:7HD(C7>HC;(H6(GAC7(G><;(B;:8HI(H6(:7;(

E>II>=H6@(D;C:H>6O

%7;(,><8I(';KH<:7

%7;(=,15..".#&C7>HC;?(7>=;F;<?(B>;D(6>:(;6:8HI(:7;(;6:H<;:N(>E(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(BA;(

:>(=78:(L86:(<;E;<D(:>(8D(:7;(R@<;8:;D:(BHEEHCAI:NS]J(H6(<;@8<BD(:>(A6B;<D:86BH6@(:7;(

9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6U(:7;(9<>KI;G(>E(H6EH6H:;(@AHI:(TH'$"+0,.YG]Q(L86:(:7H6^D(:78:(

\j L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`U]jO

\[ -KHB?&`U`JO(TR.8:g<IHC7;(.;H@A6@;6(DH6B?(86(DHC7(D;IKD:(K;:<8C7:;:?(@A:?(BOHO(A6F;<=;<EIHC7?(A6B(;D(HD:(6HC7:(8II;H6(F;<@;KIHC7?(D>6B;<6(;D(=p<;(8AC7(DC7pBIHC7(A6B(:8B;I78E:?(DH;(8AD<>::;6(fA(=>II;6OOOSY

\X L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`U]jO

]a -KHBO

]J -KHB?&`UjQO

]Q %7;(=><B(R3C7AIB;6S(78D(K;;6(:<86DI8:;B(H6:>(&6@IHD7(9<HG8<HIN(8D(;H:7;<(RB;K:S(><(R@AHI:GS(-(=HII(8F>HB(:7HD(I86@A8@;(>E(B;K:(86B(H6D:;8B(E8F><(7HD(I86@A8@;(>E(H6EH6H:;(@AHI:(K;C8AD;(>E(:7;(I>8B;B(68:A<;(>E(:7;(:;<G(RB;K:OS(-(K;IH;F;(:78:(A6B;<D:86BH6@(>A<(C7>HC;(:>(K;(<8BHC8IIN(;FHI(8D(K<H6@H6@(8K>A:(8(B;K:(G8^;D(:7;(G>D:(D;6D;(=7;6(=;(A6B;<D:86B(H:(H6(:7;(C>6:;P:(>E(<;IH@H>6?(><?(8D(L86:(=>AIB(D8N?(=7;6(=;(:8^;(:7;(C>GG86BD(>E(BA:N(:>(K;(BHFH6;(C>GG86BD(TL86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`UJa\(b(`UJa]YO(*6(:7;(>:7;<(786B?(A6B;<D:86BH6@(>A<(C7>HC;D(8D(K<H6@H6@(8K>A:(86(H6EH6H:;(@AHI:(G8^;D(D;6D;(;F;6(=7;6(=;(FH;=(>A<(

Page 112: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

Ja]G;<;IN(C7>>DH6@(8(@>>B(=,15..".#(HD(6>:(;6>A@7(:>(C>G9I;:;(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(K;C8AD;(86N(

9;<D>6(=7>(78D(>6C;(K;;6(<8BHC8IIN(;FHI(D:HII(<;:8H6D(:7;(@AHI:(E<>G(:78:(C7>HC;(>E(86(;FHI(

=,15..".#(86B(HD(:7;<;E><;(6>:(N;:(<;K><6(H6:>(8(R6;=(C<;8:H>6OS(";(=<H:;D?(R)78:;F;<(

7HD(D:8:;(H6(:7;(8CZAHDH:H>6(>E(8(@>>B(BHD9>DH:H>6?(86B?(H6B;;B?(7>=;F;<(D:;8BE8D:IN(8(

7AG86(K;H6@(G8N(78F;(9;<D;F;<;B(H6(DAC7(8(BHD9>DH:H>6(H6(8(IHE;(C>6BAC:(C>6E><G8KI;(:>(

H:?(7;(6;F;<:7;I;DD(D:8<:;B(E<>G(;FHI?(TD>(75.#&,9&0!'$&Q!<&ND1,.&(.:&".0&05,1,&

K,91'$"+0".#&51%&5$<&.5,&("1>"+D1'$,.&<D#+5'$Y&86B(:7HD(HD(8(B;K:(k@AHI:l(=7HC7(HD(

HG9>DDHKI;(E><(7HG(:>(=H9;(>A:OS]\(%7HD(><H@H68I(@AHI:(K;C>G;D(;P:<;G;IN(HG9><:86:(H6(:7;(

D:><N(>E(>F;<C>GH6@(<8BHC8I(;FHIO(#D(#B8GD(B;DC<HK;D?(RHE(:7;(>6;(:7H6@(A6ZA8IHEH;BIN(

@>>B(HD(8(@>>B(=HII?(=;(C866>:(D8N(:78:(H:(B>;D(6>:(G8::;<(=7;:7;<(>6;MD(=HII(HD(><(78D(

K;;6(@>>BO(*6(:7;(C>6:<8<N?(:78:(GAD:(K;(=78:(G8::;<D(G>D:(>E(8II(8K>A:(>6;MD(IHE;OS]](-:(HD(

;DD;6:H8I?(:7;6?(:78:(=;(8<;(C898KI;(>E(>F;<C>GH6@(:7HD(>KD:8CI;O

-6(><B;<(:>(A6B;<D:86B(=7N(L86:(B>;D(6>:(:7H6^(:78:(7AG86D(C86(R=H9;(>A:S(:7HD(

@AHI:(>6(:7;H<(>=6?(H:(HD(6;C;DD8<N(:>(A6B;<D:86B(:7;(68:A<;(>E(:7HD(@AHI:(86B(=7N(L86:(

I8K;ID(H:(8D(RH6EH6H:;OS(-6(D7><:?(L86:(:7H6^D(:78:(=;(H6CA<(86(H6EH6H:;(@AHI:(=7;6(=;(G8^;(

:7;(C7>HC;(:>(78F;(86(;FHI(=,15..".#(K;C8AD;(:7HD(C7>HC;(HD(86(H6EH6H:;(>6;O(";(=<H:;D?

.>=?(G><8I(;FHIOOOK<H6@D(=H:7(H:(86(5.75.5%6&>E(FH>I8:H>6D(>E(:7;(I8=?(86B(7;6C;(86(5.75.5%6&>E(@AHI:OOO?(6>:(D>(GAC7(K;C8AD;(>E(:7;(5.75.5%6&>E(:7;(7H@7;D:(I8=@HF;<(=7>D;(8A:7><H:N(HD(:7;<;KN(>EE;6B;B(TE><(=;(A6B;<D:86B(6>:7H6@(>E(DAC7(H6:86@HKI;(<;I8:H>6D(>E(:7;(7AG86(K;H6@(:>(:7;(7H@7;D:(K;H6@Y(KA:(K;C8AD;(:7;(;FHI(HD(H6(:7;(051)!15%5!.&86B(:7;(G8PHGD(H6(@;6;<8I(TH6(:7;(G866;<(>E(".5Q,91(+&)95.'5)+,1&8D(C>6:<8D:;B(=H:7(H6BHFHBA8I(:<86D@<;DDH>6DYU(C>6D;ZA;6:IN?(;F;<N(7AG86(K;H6@(78D(

C7>HC;D(8D(K;H6@(cAB@;B(KN(>A<(>=6(<;8D>6?(=78:(L86:(C8IID(R:7;(cAB@;(=H:7H6S(T`UjjYO

]\ L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`UjQO

]] '>K;<:(,;<<H7;=(#B8GD?(H6:<>BAC:H>6(:>(8,+5#5!.&/5%$5.&%$,&N!".0(95,1&!7&@,9,&8,(1!.:&:<86DO(86B(;BO(#II;6()>>B(86B(/;><@;(BH(/H>F866H(T!8GK<HB@;U(!8GK<HB@;(W6HF;<DH:N($<;DD?(QaJaYU(PFHHO

Page 113: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

Ja_:>(;P9;C:(5.75.5%,&9A6HD7G;6:(86B(;PCIADH>6(E<>G(:7;(LH6@B>G(>E(/>BO]_

);((C86(D;;(E<>G(:7HD(98DD8@;(:78:(:7;(H6EH6H:;(@AHI:(HD(6>:(H6EH6H:;(K;C8AD;(=;(78F;(

BHD>K;N;B(I8=D(>E(86(H6EH6H:;(I8=@HF;<?(DAC7(8D(/>BO('8:7;<?(:7;(H6EH6H:;(68:A<;(>E(>A<(

@AHI:(8<HD;D(K;C8AD;(>E(:7;(H6EH6H:;(68:A<;(>E(:7;(=,15..".#(:78:(=;(78F;(C7>D;6O(

-6(><B;<(:>(;P9I8H6(:7HD(H6EH6H:;(68:A<;?(-(=HII(<;IN(>6(86(H6:;<9<;:8:H>6(KN(28=<;6C;(

$8D:;<68C^O]`($8D:;<68C^(;P9I8H6D(:78:(>A<(C7>HC;(:>(K;(<8BHC8IIN(;FHI(HD(H6EH6H:;(H6D>E8<(8D(

H:(HD(86(RHG9IHCH:(C>6B>6H6@S(>E(86(RA6IHGH:;B(6;@I;C:(>E(G><8IH:N?S]j(<8:7;<(:786(86(8C:A8I(

9;<E><GH6@(>E(86(H6EH6H:;(6AGK;<(>E(8C:D(:78:(FH>I8:;(:7;(G><8I(I8=O($8D:;<68C^(;P9I8H6D?(

R)7;6(=;(C7>>D;(:>(9<H><H:Hf;(D;IEoH6:;<;D:(>F;<(G><8IH:N?(=;(G8N(6>:(K;(C7>>DH6@(86N(

D9;CHEHC(8C:(>E(HGG><8IH:N?(6><(8<;(=;(9>DH:HF;IN(C7>>DH6@(HGG><8IH:N(E><(:7;(D8^;(>E(

HGG><8IH:N?(KA:(=;(8<;(C7>>DH6@(:>(:8^;(B>=6(8(K8<<H;<(:>(>A<(C>6BAC:(=7HC7(C8<<H;D(=H:7(

H:(8(=HIIH6@6;DD(:>(C>GGH:(HGG><8I(8C:D(=7;6(C8II;B(E><(>A:(>E(D;IEoH6:;<;D:OS][(#D(-(=HII(

8<@A;(I8:;<(H6(:7HD(C789:;<?(:7;(C7>HC;(:>(78F;(8(C;<:8H6(=,15..".#(HD(6>:(:7;(C7>HC;(:>(

8C:A8IIN(K;(;H:7;<(G><8IIN(@>>B(><(G><8IIN(;FHIO(-:(HD?(<8:7;<?(8(C>GGH:G;6:(:>(9<H><H:Hf;(

]_ L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`UjQO(TR18(6A6(B8D(3H::IHC7o4mD;(TeK;<:<;:A6@(B;D(G><8IHDC7;6(/;D;:f;D(8ID(@m::IHC7;6(/;K>:;D?(3g6B;(@;6686:Y(6HC7:(D>=>7I(=;@;6(B;<(W6;6BIHC7^;H:(B;D(7mC7D:;6(/;D;:f@;K;<D?(B;DD;6(#A:><H:p:(B8BA<C7(F;<I;:f:(=><B;6(TF>6(=;IC7;G(gK;<DC7=;6@IHC7;6Y(+;<7pI:6HDD;(B;D(,;6DC7;6(fAG(7mC7D:;6();D;6(=H<(6HC7:D(F;<D:;7;6Y?(D>B;<6(8ID(;H6(4mD;D(H6(B;<(/;DH66A6@(A6B(B;6(,8PHG;6(gK;<78A9:(T=H;(8II@;G;H6;(/<A6BDp:f;(F;<@I;HC7A6@D=;HD;(@;@;6(;H6f;I6;(eK;<:<;:A6@;6Y(;H6;(W6;6BIHC7^;H:(F>6(+;<I;:fA6@;6(B;D(/;D;:f;D?(GH:7H6(B;<(3C7AIB(K;H(DHC7(Eg7<:(T=;IC7;D(F><(;H6;G(G;6DC7IHC7;6(/;<HC7:D7>E;?(B;<(6A<(B8D(;H6f;I6;(+;<K<;C7;6?(GH:7H6(6A<(BH;(%8:(A6B(B8<8AE(K;f>@;6;?(6HC7:(8K;<(BH;(8II@;G;H6;(/;DH66A6@(H6(4;:<8C7:(fH;7:?(86B;<D(HD:Y?(D>(=g<B;(c;B;<(,;6DC7(DHC7(;H6;<(A6;6BIHC7;6(3:<8E;(A6B(+;<D:>hA6@(8AD(B;G(';HC7;(/>::;D(fA(@;=p<:H@;6(78K;6OSY

]` 28=<;6C;($8D:;<68C^?(RL86:(>6(:7;(1;K:(>E(3H6?S(;(5%$&(.0&4$5+!1!)$6&QJO(JO(TV86A8<N?(QaJQYO(%7;<;(8<;(>:7;<(=8ND(>E(;P9I8H6H6@(=7N(:7HD(@AHI:(HD(H6EH6H:;?(KA:(-(EH6B($8D:;<68C^MD(:>(K;(:7;(G>D:(7;I9EAI(86B(:<A;(:>(L86:MD(:;P:O(0><(86(8I:;<68:HF;(;P9I868:H>6?(D;;(#B8GD?(H6:<>BAC:H>6O(";(8<@A;D(:78:(:7HD(@AHI:(HD(H6EH6H:;(K;C8AD;(>A<(C7>HC;(>E(=,15..".#(HD(:HG;I;DD(TPF(b(PPHYO()7HI;(:7HD(HD(8CCA<8:;?($8D:;<68C^MD(;P9I868:H>6(HD(GAC7(G><;(8CC;DDHKI;(K;C8AD;(H:(E>CAD;D(A9>6(:7;(C7>HC;(>E(=,15..".#(8D(8(C>GGH:G;6:(:>(86(H6EH6H:;(6AGK;<(>E(>EE;6D;D?(:7AD(G8^H6@(AD(H6EH6H:;IN(@AHI:NO

]j $8D:;<68C^?(RL86:(>6(:7;(1;K:(>E(3H6?S(\\O

][ $8D:;<68C^?(RL86:(>6(:7;(1;K:(>E(3H6?S(\\O

Page 114: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

Ja`;H:7;<(H6C;6:HF;D(>E(H6CIH68:H>6(><(>E(BA:N(H6(>6;MD(8C:H>6D(H6(:7;(EA:A<;O(%7AD?(HE(8(9;<D>6(

C7>>D;D(86(;FHI(G8PHG?(7;(HD(C7>>DH6@(:>(C>GGH:(7HGD;IE?(H6(86(A6IHGH:;B(6AGK;<(>E(

8C:H>6D(H6(:7;(EA:A<;?(:>(9<H><H:HfH6@(H6C;6:HF;D(>E(D;IEoI>F;(8K>F;(H6C;6:HF;D(>E(BA:NO(%7HD(

HD(:7;(=8N(H6(=7HC7(=;(C86(A6B;<D:86B(>A<(=,15..".#(C7>HC;(:>(K;(86(H6EH6H:;(>6;O(%7;(

9<>9;<(D><:(>E(@AHI:(:78:(D7>AIB(K;(8::8C7;B(:>(:7HD(^H6B(>E(C7>HC;?(L86:(:7H6^D?(HD(8ID>(86(

H6EH6H:;(>6;O

4;E><;(G>FH6@(>6?(H:(HD(HG9><:86:(:>(ZA;D:H>6(=7N(L86:(:7H6^D(:78:(8(@AHI:(><(

9A6HD7G;6:(HD(8::8C7;B(:>(>A<(FH>I8:H>6D(>E(:7;(G><8I(I8=?(98<:HCAI8<IN(K;C8AD;(7;(HD(6>:((&

)95!95&C>GGH::;B(:>(:7;(K;IH;E(:78:(:7;<;(HD(8(/>B(=7>(9A6HD7;D(>A<(DH6DO(%7HD(HD(8(I;DD(

<;IH@H>ADINoK8D;B(C>6C;<6(:786(H:(G8N(D;;G(>6(:7;(DA<E8C;O(#D('>K;<:(#B8GD(7;I9EAIIN(

;P9I8H6D?(:7;(ZA;D:H>6(>E(=7;:7;<(8(9;<D>6(HD(8C:H6@(H6(8(=8N(:78:(B>;D(><(B>;D(6>:(B;D;<F;(

9A6HD7G;6:(B>;D(6>:(<;ZAH<;(8(K;IH;E(H6(8(7H@7;<(9>=;<(=7>(=HII(;68C:(:78:(9A6HD7G;6:O(

'8:7;<?(:7;(ZA;D:H>6(>E(=7;:7;<(>6;MD(8C:H>6D(><(=,15..".#,.(B;D;<F;(9A6HD7G;6:(HD(8^H6(

:>(:7;(ZA;D:H>6(>E(7>=(>6;(RC86(K;(8(9;<D>6(:78:(=>AIB(K;(=;IIo9I;8DH6@(H6(:7;(DH@7:(>E(

7HD(>=6(9A<;(9<8C:HC8I(<;8D>6(HE(7;(^6;=(7HD(>=6(7;8<:(8D(/>B(^6>=D(H:OS]X(L86:(:7AD(

:7H6^D(:78:(=;(H6CA<(86(H6EH6H:;(@AHI:(:78:(HD(=><:7N(>E(9A6HD7G;6:(K;C8AD;?(HE(=;(C>AIB(

D;;(>A<(>=6(;FHI(=,15..".#?(>A<(9A<;(9<8C:HC8I(<;8D>6?(=7HC7(HD(:7;(@HF;<(>E(:7;(G><8I(

I8=?(=>AIB(cAB@;(AD(:>(K;(=><:7N(>E(DAC7(9A6HD7G;6:O(#D(#B8GD(9>H6:D(>A:?(K;C8AD;(

=78:(G8::;<D(G>D:(8K>A:(>A<(G><8I(IHE;(HD(:78:(=;(78F;(8(G><8IIN(@>>B(=HII?(HE(=;(8<;(

G><8IIN(D;<H>AD(8K>A:(K;C>GH6@(@>>B?(=;(D7>AIB(cAB@;(>A<D;IF;D(:>(K;(@AHI:N(HE(=;(78F;(

;FHI(=,15..".#,.O_a

]X #B8GD?(H6:<>BAC:H>6?(PFHO(#B8GD(9>H6:D(>A:(L86:MD(AD;(>E(:7;(97<8D;(R:7;(cAB@;(=H:7H6S(T8,+5#5!.:&`UjjY(=7;6(:8I^H6@(8K>A:(:7HDO

_a #B8GD?(H6:<>BAC:H>6?(PFHHO

Page 115: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

Jaj#D(=;(78F;(D;;6?(L86:(HD(CI;8<(:78:(7AG86D(C866>:(K;(<;IH;F;B(>E(:7HD(H6EH6H:;(@AHI:(

>6(:7;H<(>=6O(">=;F;<?(7;(HD(;ZA8IIN(CI;8<(:78:(6>(>6;(;ID;(C86(<;IH;F;(:7HD(@AHI:(>6(8(

9;<D>6MD(K;78IEO_J(%7;(=><^(:>(>F;<C>G;(:7HD(GAD:(K;(B>6;(KN(:7;(@AHI:N(9;<D>6O(%7;(

:<8BH:H>68I(=8N(>E(<;D>IFH6@(:7HD(9<>KI;G?(H6(:7;(D;C>6B8<N(IH:;<8:A<;?(78D(K;;6(:>(8<@A;(

:78:(7AG86D(C866>:(<;G>F;(:7;(C78<8C:;<HD:HC(:78:(G8^;D(:7;G(@AHI:N?(D>(=;(6;;B(D>G;(

>:7;<(9;<D>6(b(8D(=;(=HII(D;;?(86(H6:;IIH@HKI;(K;H6@(DAC7(8D(/>B(o(:>(RcAD:HENS(AD?(H6(:7;(

D;6D;(>E(;H:7;<(K;H6@(E><@HF;6(><(K;H6@(C>A6:;B(8D(G><8IIN(6;=(9;>9I;(;F;6(:7>A@7(=;(

8<;(6>:(8C:A8IIN(G><8IIN(6;=(9;>9I;O*%7HD(<;8BH6@(8<HD;D(9<HG8<HIN(E<>G(8(98DD8@;(H6(

=7HC7(L86:(=<H:;D(:78:(:7;(R<;D>IA:H>6(:>(:7;(BHEEHCAI:NS(>E(A6B;<D:86BH6@(7>=(=;(C86(

>F;<C>G;(:7;(>KD:8CI;(>E(H6EH6H:;(@AHI:(H6F>IF;D(:7;(R?"1%575'(%5!.&>E(8(7AG86(K;H6@(=7>(HD(

H6B;;B(@AHI:N(KA:(78D(98DD;B(H6:>(8(BHD9>DH:H>6(=;IIo9I;8DH6@(:>(/>BOS_Q(

!>GG;6:8:><D?(DAC7(8D('>K;<:(#B8GD?(78F;(H6:;<9<;:;B(:7HD(:;<G(RcAD:HEHC8:H>6S(:>(

G;86(8(^H6B(>E(E><@HF;6;DDO_\(#B8GD(=<H:;D?(R#6B(=78:(HD(G;86:(HD(.!%&8(9;<D>6MD(K;H6@(

cAD:HEH;B(H6(K;IH;FH6@(><(B>H6@(D>G;:7H6@O(%78:(=>AIB(K;(G;<;IN(86>:7;<(=8N(>E(D9;8^H6@(

>E(cAD:HEHC8:H>6(>E(8(K;IH;E(><(86(8C:H>6O()78:(HD(G;86:(HD(D>G;:7H6@(GAC7(CI>D;<(:>(:7;(

E><@HF;6;DD(>E(DH6DO(%7HD(AD;(>E(:7;(:;<G(McAD:HEHC8:H>6M(HD(E8GHIH8<(>6IN(H6(:7;>I>@NOS_](";(

@>;D(>6(:>(;P9I8H6(:78:?(K;C8AD;(=;(C86(6;F;<(8C:A8IIN(<;G>F;(:7;(ZA8IH:N(:78:(G8^;D(AD(

_J L86:(=<H:;D(:78:(RH:(HD(6>:(8(:<86DGHDDHKI;(IH8KHIH:N(=7HC7(C86(K;(G8B;(>F;<(:>(D>G;K>BN(;ID;?(H6(:7;(G866;<(>E(EH686CH8I(B;K:OOOS(T8,+5#5!.:&`UjQYO(T0,..&15,&51%&C,5.,&%9(.1<5115*,+,&K,9*5.0+5'$C,5%:&05,&,%/(:&/5,&,5.,&=,+01'$"+0GGG("7&,5.,.&(.0,9,.&B*,9%9(#,.&/,90,.&C(..GGOY(

_Q L86:?(8,+5#5!.?(`UjQ(b(`Uj\?(`Uj`O(TRB;<(-B;;(;H6;<(';C7:E;<:H@A6@(B;D(f=8<(F;<DC7AIB;:;6?(8K;<(B>C7(fA(;H6;<(/>::(D>7I@;EpIIH@;6(/;DH66A6@(gK;<@;@86@;6;6(,;6DC7;6SY

_\ %7HD(<;8BH6@(C86(8ID>(K;(E>A6B(H6(8(F8<H;:N(>E(>:7;<(=<H:H6@DO(0><(;P8G9I;D?(D;;(/><B>6(&O(,HC78ID>6?(R,><8I(';@;6;<8:H>6(86B(1HFH6;(#HB(H6(L86:?S(8,+5#5!"1&H%"05,1&Q_O(\O(T3;9:O?(JX[XY?(H6(=7HC7(7;(8<@A;D(:78:(/>B(cAD:HEH;D(AD(KN(D;;H6@(>A<(G><8I(9<>@<;DD(8D(8(RC>G9I;:;B(=7>I;S(TQ`[Y?(86B(V>76(3HIK;<?(R%7;(&:7HC8I(3H@6HEHC86C;(>E(L86:MD(';IH@H>6OS

_] #B8GD?(H6:<>BAC:H>6?(PFO

Page 116: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

Ja[H6EH6H:;IN(@AHI:N?(=;(GAD:(K;(HG9A:;B(<H@7:;>AD6;DD(:78:(=;(78F;(6>:(N;:(;8<6;B?(:7>A@7(

=;(78F;?(:7<>A@7(:7;(=,15..".#&C7>HC;?(C>GGH::;B(:>(9<>@<;DDH6@(:>=8<BD(:78:(

<H@7:;>AD6;DD(86B(:7AD?(8CC><BH6@(:>(L86:?(C86(K;(D8HB(:>(78F;(;8<6;B(H:?(=7;6(>A<(IHF;D(

8<;(FH;=;B(E<>G(8(6>AG;68I(9;<D9;C:HF;O__(-6(D7><:?(8I:7>A@7(=;(8<;(6>:(G><8IIN(6;=(

9;>9I;(E<>G(86(;G9H<HC8I(9;<D9;C:HF;?(/>B(HD(8KI;(:>(FH;=(>A<(IHF;D(E<>G(8(6>AG;68I(

9;<D9;C:HF;?(D;;(:78:(>A<(=,15..".#(78D(K;;6(C786@;B?(86B(=HII(C>A6:(AD(:>(K;(G><8IIN(

6;=?(@>>B(9;>9I;O_`

%7;<;(8<;(:=>(D;<H>AD(<;8D>6D(:>(ZA;D:H>6(:7HD(<;8BH6@(>E(7>=(=;(C86(>F;<C>G;(

:7;(>KD:8CI;(>E(H6EH6H:;(@AHI:O(0H<D:?(H:(B>;D(6>:(899;8<(:>(K;(:<A;(:78:(=;(C866>:(8C:A8IIN(

<;G>F;(:7;(C78<8C:;<HD:HC(:78:(G8^;D(AD(H6EH6H:;IN(@AHI:N(86B(:7;<;KN(K;C>G;(G><8IIN(

@>>BO(3;C>6B?(:7;<;(HD(<;8D>6(:>(K;IH;F;(:78:?(=7;6(L86:(D8ND(:78:(:7;(DH66;<(<;ZAH<;D(

RcAD:HEHC8:H>6?S(L86:(H6:;6BD(:78:(=;(<;ZAH<;(8(^H6B(>E(;P9I8H6H6@(>E(:7;(G><8I(9>DDHKHIH:N(

>E(:7;(G><8I(<;KH<:7?(><(86(;9HD:;G>I>@HC8I(8HB?(<8:7;<(:786(8(^H6B(>E(E><@HF;6;DDO(%7HD(

<;8BH6@(C86(K;(DA99><:;B(:7<>A@7(98DD8@;D(H6(=7HC7(L86:(:8I^D(8K>A:(:7;(cAD:HEHC8:H>6(8D(8(

^H6B(>E(cABHCH8I(F;<BHC:(>E(>A<(8C:A8I(G><8I(H6:;IIH@HKI;(C78<8C:;<(86B(KN(98NH6@(8::;6:H>6(

:>(:7;(DA<<>A6BH6@(98DD8@;(H6(=7HC7(L86:(K<H6@D(A9(:7HD(>KD:8CI;O

0H<D:?(H6(><B;<(:>(A6B;<D:86B(7>=(=;(C86(<;G>F;(:7HD(@AHI:(>A<D;IF;D?(=;(GAD:(

<;:A<6(K8C^(:>(:7;(C>6F;<D8:H>6(<;@8<BH6@(:7;(D>A<C;(>E(:7HD(@AHI:U(>A<(C7>HC;(>E(86(;FHI(

=,15..".#O(-6(><B;<(:>(<;G>F;(:7HD(@AHI:?(:7;6?(=;(GAD:(<;G>F;(:7HD(;FHI(G8PHG(8D(>A<(

G>D:(EA6B8G;6:8I(G8PHG(86B(<;9I8C;(H:(=H:7(8(@>>B(>6;O(%7HD(HD(:7;(F;<N(B;DC<H9:H>6(:78:(

L86:(9<>FHB;D(>E(:7;(=,15..".#&C7>HC;?(R8(DH6@I;(86B(A68I:;<8KI;(B;CHDH>6(k:7<>A@7(

__ #B8GD?(H6:<>BAC:H>6?(PPHHH(b(PPHFO

_` ,HC78ID>6?(R%7;(-6DC<A:8KHIH:N(>E(,><8I(&FHI(H6(L86:?S(Q`[O

Page 117: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

JaX=7HC7l(8(7AG86(K;H6@(<;F;<D;D(:7;(DA9<;G;(@<>A6B(>E(7HD(G8PHGD(KN(=7HC7(7;(=8D(86(

;FHI(7AG86(K;H6@(T86B(:7;<;KN(9A:D(>6(8(M6;=(G86MYOOOS_j(-E(:7;(D>A<C;(>E(:7;(H6EH6H:;(@AHI:(

=8D(>A<(;FHI(=,15..".#?(:7;6(C786@H6@(:7HD(=,15..".#(<;G>F;D(:7;(D>A<C;(>E(:7;(@AHI:?(

86B(:7AD(:7;(@AHI:(H:D;IEO(-6(E8C:?(L86:(D:8:;D(:78:(G8^H6@(:7HD(B;CHDH>6(@HF;D(AD(8(R6;=(

ZA8IH:NS(T.,",.&W"(+5%A%RG_[*28=<;6C;($8D:;<68C^(D:<;DD;D(:7HD(9>H6:(=7;6(7;(D:8:;D(:78:(

RDH6C;(:7;(G><8I(C78<8C:;<HD:HCD(=7HC7(9A:(:7;(>IB(G86(H6:>(:7;(D:8:;(>E(DH6(8<;(6>:(9<;D;6:(

H6(:7;(6;=(G86?(:7;(6;=(G86(B>;D(6>:(K;8<(:7;(B;K:O(-6(:7;(;F;6:(>E(G><8I(

:<86DE><G8:H>6?(:7;(B;K:(cAD:(@;:D(=H9;B(>EE(:7;(K>>^D?(D>(:>(D9;8^OS_X(4;C8AD;(:7;(@AHI:(

C86(>6IN(K;(C8<<H;B(KN(:7;(9;<D>6(=7>(78D(:7;(C78<8C:;<HD:HC(:78:(I;8BD(7HG(:>(K;(cAB@;B(:>(

78F;(DAC7(8(@AHI:?(KN(C7>>DH6@(8(6;=(=,15..".#(86B(:7AD(<;G>FH6@(:7HD(C78<8C:;<HD:HC?(:7;(

@AHI:(HD(6>(I>6@;<(899<>9<H8:;IN(8::<HKA:;B(:>(:78:(9;<D>6O(-6B;;B?(DAC7(8(9;<D>6(B;D;<F;D(

ZAH:;(:7;(>99>DH:;(cAB@;G;6:O(#(9;<D>6(=H:7(8(@>>B(=,15..".#(78D(C>GGH::;B(:>(8C:H6@(

8CC><BH6@(:>(H6C;6:HF;D(>E(BA:N(H6(86(H6EH6H:;(6AGK;<(>E(DH:A8:H>6D(H6(:7;(EA:A<;O

*E(C>A<D;?(:7;<;(HD(D:HII(:7;(HDDA;(>E(=78:(L86:(G;86D(=7;6(7;(=<H:;D(:78:(DH66;<D(

GAD:(K;(RcAD:HEH;BOS();?(8D(:7>D;(=7>(=;<;(>6C;(<8BHC8IIN(;FHI?(GAD:(6>:(>6IN(<;G>F;(:7;(

@AHI:(8DD>CH8:;B(=H:7(DAC7(;FHI(KA:(K;(cAB@;B(:>(78F;(<;G>F;B(:7;(@AHI:(86B(:7;<;KN(78F;(

K;C>G;(G><8IIN(6;=(9;>9I;O(-E(=;(I>>^(C8<;EAIIN(8:(=78:(:7HD(cABHCH8I(F;<BHC:(<;ZAH<;D?(=;(

C86(D;;(:78:(H:(HD(6>:(8(E><@HF;6;DD(KA:(<8:7;<(8(FH;=H6@(>E(=78:(=;(78F;(8I<;8BN(B>6;(H6(

:7;(=,15..".#&C7>HC;O(L86:(D:8:;D(:78:(8(9;<D>6(GAD:(K;(R<;IH;F;BS(T,.%1'$+(#,.Y`a(o(6>:(

E><@HF;6(o(>E(:7HD(@AHI:(KN(G;86D(>E(8(cABHCH8I(F;<BHC:(:78:(>A<(=,15..".#,.(8C:A8IIN(78F;(

_j L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`U][O

_[ L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`Uj\O

_X $8D:;<68C^?(RL86:(>6(:7;(1;K:(>E(3H6?S(]]O

`a L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`UjQO

Page 118: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

JJaC786@;B?(8E:;<(:7;(=,15..".#&C7>HC;O(";(=<H:;D?(R%7;(<;D>IA:H>6(:>(:7HD(BHEEHCAI:N(<;D:D(>6(

:7;(E>II>=H6@(C>6DHB;<8:H>6O(%7;(cABHCH8I(F;<BHC:(>E(>6;(=7>(^6>=D(:7;(7;8<:(>E(:7;(

8CCAD;B(GAD:(K;(:7>A@7:(8D(K8D;B(>6(:7;(A6HF;<D8I(BHD9>DH:H>6(>E(:7;(I8::;<?(6>:(>6(:7;(

899;8<86C;D(>E(7HD(BHD9>DH:H>6OS`J(-E(7AG86D(C86(G8^;(:7;(C7>HC;(:>(C786@;(:7;H<(

=,15..".#,.?(:7;6(8II(:78:(HD(<;ZAH<;B(KN(:7;(H6:;IIH@HKI;(cAB@;(HD(:>(78F;(^6>=I;B@;(>E(

:7;(=,15..".#(86B(<AI;(:78:(=;(78F;(8C:A8IIN(K;C>G;(6;=(9;>9I;O`Q(%7HD(A6B;<D:86BH6@(

>E(:7;(6;;B(E><(86(H6:;IIH@HKI;(cAB@;(:>(;H:7;<(DA99I;G;6:(>A<(HG9<>F;G;6:(H6(D>G;(=8N(

><(cAB@;(AD(:>(78F;(B>6;(D>G;:7H6@(:78:(=;(78F;(6>:(B>;D(6>:(D;;G(:>(7>IB(A9(:>(=78:(

L86:(D:8:;D(H6(:7;D;(98DD8@;DO

-6B;;B?(:7HD(H6:;<9<;:8:H>6(K;C>G;D(;F;6(G><;(C>6FH6CH6@(HE(=;(I>>^(:>(:7;(

98DD8@;(H6(=7HC7(:7;(RcAD:HEHC8:H>6S(CI8HG(HD(G8B;(KN(L86:O(L86:(G8^;D(:7HD(D:8:;G;6:(H6(

8(D;C:H>6(H6(=7HC7(7;(HD(:<NH6@(:>(;P9I8H6(7>=(=;(C86(G8^;(RC>G9<;7;6DHKI;(:>(ADS(R:7;(

9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(<;8IHfH6@(H6(AD(:7;(HB;8(>E(8(7AG86H:N(=;IIo9I;8DH6@(:>(/>B?S`\(><?(H6(>:7;<(

=><BD?(:>(K;C>G;(G><8IIN(@>>B(9;>9I;O(-6(:7HD(D;C:H>6?(L86:(;G978DHf;D(:7;(9<>KI;G(>E(

K;H6@(<;IH;F;B(>E(H6EH6H:;(@AHI:O`](.>:;(:78:(:7HD(HD(8(9<>KI;G(6>:(>E(7>=(=;(8C:A8IIN(B>(

K;C>G;(<;IH;F;B(>E(H6EH6H:;(@AHI:(KA:(>E(7>=(7AG86D(C86(A6B;<D:86B(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(

`J -KHB?&`Uj\O(TR1H;(#AEImDA6@(BH;D;<(3C7=H;<H@^;H:(K;<A7:(8AE(E>I@;6B;GO(1;<('HC7:;<8ADD9<AC7(BH6;D(";<f;6D^g6BH@;<D(GAh(8ID(;H6(D>IC7;<(@;B8C7:(=;<B;6?(B;<(8AD(B;<(8II@;G;H6;6(/;DH66A6@(B;D(#6@;^I8@:;6?(6HC7:(8AD(B;6(&<DC7;H6A6@;6(B;<D;IK;6?(B;6(F>G(/;D;:f;(8K=;HC7;6B;6(>B;<(B8GH:(fAD8GG;6D:HGG;6B;6("86BIA6@;6(@;f>@;6(=><B;6OSY

`Q #D(0H<;D:>6;(86B(V8C>KD?(X.&-,7,.1,&!7&2(.%31&8,+5#5!.:(;P9I8H6?(:7;(>F;<C>GH6@(>E(;FHI(B>;D(6>:(<;ZAH<;(:7;(E><@HF;6;DD(>E(@AHI:?(=7HC7(=>AIB(6>:(K;(DAEEHCH;6:(TJj](o(Jj_YO(L86:(K><<>=D(:7;(4HKIHC8I(I86@A8@;(>E(!>I>DDH86D(\UXoJa(86B(B;DC<HK;D(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(8D(K>:7(R:7;(9A::H6@(>EE(>E(:7;(>IB(G86(86B(:7;(9A::H6@(>6(>E(:7;(6;=S(T0(1&L*+,#,.&0,1&(+%,.&".0&0(1&L.>5,$,.&0,1&.,",.&@,.1'$,.R&TL86::&8,+5#5!.: &`Uj]YO #(C><BH6@(:>(0H<;D:>6;(86B(V8C>KD?(R-6(:7;(C>6:;P:(>E(4>>^(%=>?(:7HD(9A%%5.#&!77&9,E;<D(D9;CHEHC8IIN(:>(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(H6(BHD9>DH:H>6?(=7;<;(:7;(C>6F;<:(8B>9:D(:7;(k@>>B(BHD9>DH:H>6lOOOH6(9I8C;(>E(7HD(><(7;<(H668:;?(C><<A9:(BHD9>DH:H>6S(TJj`YO!

`\ L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`U``O

`] L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`UjQO

Page 119: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

JJJB>H6@(D>O(%7;(>KD:8CI;(:78:(D;;GD(:>(D:86B(H6(:7;(=8N(>E(:7HD(C>G9<;7;6DHKHIH:N(HD(>A<(

IHGH:;B(;G9H<HC8I(9;<D9;C:HF;(8D(7AG86DO(L86:(<;H:;<8:;D(G86N(:HG;D(H6(:7HD(98DD8@;(:78:?(

HE(=;(8<;(:>(8C:(8D(:7;(cAB@;(>E(>A<(>=6(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:?(=;(=>AIB(8I=8ND(<;6B;<(

>A<D;IF;D(@AHI:N(K;C8AD;(=;(C866>:(78F;(^6>=I;B@;(>E(>A<(>=6(=,15..".#,.O`_(0><(

;P8G9I;?(7;(=<H:;D(:78:(R4$615'(++6(TkHO;Ol(C>6DHB;<;B(H6(7HD(;G9H<HC8I(C78<8C:;<(8D(8(

D;6DHKI;(K;H6@Y(7;(D:HII(HD(:7;(D8G;(7AG86(K;H6@(IH8KI;(:>(9A6HD7G;6:?(86B(7;(GAD:(K;(

cAB@;B(8D(DAC7(K;E><;(8(G><8I(:<HKA68I(>E(cAD:HC;(86B(7;6C;(KN(7HGD;IE(8D(=;IIOS``(

4;C8AD;(>E(:7HD(IHGH:8:H>6?(L86:(K<H6@D(H6(R:7;(HB;8(>E(8(?"1%575'(%5!.(>E(8(7AG86(

K;H6@S(H6(><B;<(:>(G8^;(:7HD(G><8I(<;KH<:7(C>G9<;7;6DHKI;(:>(7AG86DO(-E(=;(9>DH:(:7;(HB;8(

>E(86(H6:;IIH@HKI;(cAB@;(=7>(C86(^6>=(>A<(H6:;IIH@HKI;(C78<8C:;<?(R=;(D;;(:78:(H:(HD(9>DDHKI;(

:>(:7H6^(>E(8KD>IA:H>6(E><(8(7AG86(K;H6@(KA<B;6;B(=H:7(@AHI:OS`j(-(=HII(;P9I><;(:7HD(

9>DH:H6@(>E(86(H6:;IIH@HKI;(cAB@;(GAC7(EA<:7;<(H6(=78:(E>II>=D?(KA:(E><(6>=?(H:(HD(;6>A@7(:>(

8C^6>=I;B@;(:78:?(C>6:<8<N(:>(=78:(G86N(:7H6^;<D(D:8:;?(L86:(K<H6@D(H6(:7;(HB;8(>E(86(

H6:;IIH@HKI;(cAB@;(H6(><B;<(:>(;P9I8H6(7>=(7AG86D(C86(A6B;<D:86B(:7;(G><8I(<;KH<:7?(=7HC7(

:7;N(C866>:(A6B;<D:86B(BA;(:>(:7;(IHGH:;B(68:A<;(>E(:7;H<(C>@6H:H>6O(%7AD?(=;(6;;B(6>:(

A6B;<D:86B(:7HD(H6:;IIH@HKI;(K;H6@(8D(D>G;>6;(=7>(@<86:D(AD(D>G;:7H6@(:78:(=;(78F;(6>:(

;8<6;B(KA:(G;<;IN(D>G;>6;(=7>(;P9I8H6D(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(:7;(<;G>F8I(>E(H6EH6H:;(@AHI:(

KN(@<86:H6@(AD(8(9;<D9;C:HF;(:78:(=;?(8D(7AG86D?(B>(6>:(78F;O

#(C>GG>6(98DD8@;(AD;B(:>(cAD:HEN(:7;(8<@AG;6:(:78:(86(H6:;IIH@HKI;(cAB@;(HD(

RC>A6:H6@(ADS(8D(G><8IIN(@>>B(=7;6(=;(8<;(6>:(N;:(G><8IIN(@>>B(HD(H6(8,+5#5!.&`Uj_O(

`_ -KHB?&`Uj]?(`Uj_?(86B(`UjjO

`` -KHB?&`Uj]O(TR*K(;<(8ID>(@I;HC7(97NDHDC7(TD;H6;G(;G9H<HDC7;6(!78<8^:;<(8ID(3H66;6=;D;6(68C7(K;:<8C7:;:Y(;K;6B;<D;IK;(D:<8EK8<;(,;6DC7(HD:(A6B(8ID(;H6(D>IC7;<(F><(;H6;G(G><8IHDC7;6(/;<HC7:D7>E;?(GH:7H6(8AC7(F>6(H7G(D;IKD:(@;<HC7:;:(=;<B;6(GAhOOOSY

`j -KHB?&`Uj`O

Page 120: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

JJQ";<;?(L86:(=<H:;D(:78:

";<;?(:7;6?(HD(:78:(DA<9IAD(>F;<(:7;(G;<H:(E<>G(=><^D(E><(=7HC7(=;(E;I:(:7;(6;;B(;8<IH;<?(>6;(=7HC7(HD(HG9A:;B(:>(AD(*6&#9(',G&0><(=78:(H6(>A<(;8<:7IN(IHE;(T86B(9;<789D(;F;6(8II(EA:A<;(:HG;D(86B(H6(8II(=><IBDY(HD(8I=8ND(>6IN(8(G;<;(*,'!<5.#&T68G;IN?(>A<(K;H6@(8(7AG86(K;H6@(=;IIo9I;8DH6@(:>(/>BY(HD(HG9A:;B(:>(AD(8D(HE(=;(8I<;8BN(9>DD;DD;B(H:(7;<;(H6(EAIIO(#6B(:>(:7HD(=;(H6B;;B(78F;(6>(<H@7:EAI(CI8HG(T8CC><BH6@(:>(>A<(;G9H<HC8I(C>@6H:H>6(=;(78F;(>E(>A<D;IF;DY?(D>(E8<(8D(=;(^6>=(>A<D;IF;DOOO`[

%7HD(HD(G;<;IN(8(D:8:;G;6:(8K>A:(:7;(=8N(:78:(=;(9;<C;HF;(>A<D;IF;D(F;<DAD(:7;(=8N(:78:(

86(H6:;IIH@HKI;(K;H6@(B>;DO(%7HD(H6:;IIH@HKI;(cAB@;(HD(6>:(7;<;(RC>A6:H6@(8D(8(=7>I;S(=78:(

=;(78F;(6>:(8C:A8IIN(8C7H;F;B(KA:(G;<;IN(>F;<<HBH6@(>A<(;G9H<HC8I(C>@6H:H>6(>E(

>A<D;IF;DO(.>:;(:78:?(8(E;=(98DD8@;D(K;E><;(:7HD?(L86:(B>;D(D:8:;(:78:?(:7<>A@7(:7;(

=,15..".#&C7>HC;?(=;(8C:A8IIN(C86(:8^;(>6(8(6;=(=,15..".#(:78:(HD(=;IIo9I;8DH6@(:>(/>BO(

4;C8AD;(>E(=78:(=;(78F;(C>6CIAB;B(8K>F;(8K>A:(:7;(<;G>F8I(>E(:7;(D>A<C;(>E(>6;MD(@AHI:?(

H6(:7HD(98DD8@;?(L86:(C866>:(K;(D8NH6@(:78:(=;(8<;(6>:(8C:A8IIN(=;IIo9I;8DH6@(:>(:7HD(

H6:;IIH@HKI;(cAB@;(KA:(G;<;IN(:78:(=;(B>(6>:(899;8<?(E<>G(86(;G9H<HC8I(9;<D9;C:HF;?(:>(K;(

=;IIo9I;8DH6@(:>(DAC7(8(cAB@;(K;C8AD;(=;(C866>:(D;;(>A<(>=6(=,15..".#,.O(%7;<;E><;?(H6(

><B;<(:>(K;(<;IH;F;B(>E(>A<(@AHI:?(=;(B>(6>:(<;ZAH<;(8(E><@HF;6;DD(KA:(G;<;IN(8(6;=(

F86:8@;(9>H6:(E<>G(=7HC7(:>(K;(cAB@;BO

%7;(!898CH:N(:>(-G9<>F;(:7;(,><8I()><:7(>E($8<:HCAI8<(#C:H>6D

&F;6(>6C;(8(9;<D>6(78D(G8B;(:7;(=,15..".#&C7>HC;(86B(K;;6(G><8IIN(<;K><6?(:7;(

>F;<C>GH6@(>E(<8BHC8I(;FHI(HD(6>:(N;:(C>G9I;:;(A6I;DD(8(9;<D>6(78D(@8H6;B(:7;(C898CH:N(:>(

HG9<>F;(:7;(G><8I(=><:7(>E(7;<(8C:H>6DO(L86:(;P9I8H6D(:7HD(H6($8<:(%=>(>E(:7;(8,+5#5!.G &

`[ L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`Uj_O(TR"H;<(HD:(6A6(B;<c;6H@;(eK;<DC7Ah(gK;<(B8D(+;<BH;6D:(B;<();<^;?(B;<(>K;6(F;<GHh:(=A<B;?(A6B(;H6(+;<BH;6D:?(B8D(A6D(8AD(/68B;6(fA@;<;C76;:(=H<BO(1;66(B8GH:(B8D?(=8D(K;H(A6D(HG(&<B;6I;K;6(TFH;II;HC7:(8AC7(H6(8II;6(^g6E:H@;6(d;H:;6(A6B(8II;6();I:;6Y(HGG;<(6A<(HG(KI>h;6();<B;6(HD:(T6pGIHC7(;H6(/>::(=>7I@;EpIIH@;<(,;6DC7(fA(D;H6Y?(A6D?(@I;HC7(8ID(>K(=H<(DC7>6(7;H<(HG(F>II;6(4;DH:f(B;DD;IK;6(=p<;6?(fA@;<;C76;:(=;<B;?(B8fA(78K;6(=H<(B>C7(=>7I(^;H6;6(';C7:D86D9<AC7(T68C7(B;<(;G9H<HDC7;6(3;IKD:;<^;66:6HDYi(D>=;H:(=H<(A6D(D;IKD:(^;66;6OOOSY

Page 121: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

JJ\";(=<H:;D?(

%7;(BHD:86C;(K;:=;;6(:7;(@>>B6;DD(=7HC7(=;(>A@7:(:>(;EE;C:(H6(>A<D;IF;D(86B(:7;(;FHI(E<>G(=7HC7(=;(D:8<:(HD?(7>=;F;<?(H6EH6H:;?(86B?(D>(E8<(8D(:7;(B;;B(HD(C>6C;<6;B(b(HO;O(:7;(C>6E><GH:N(>E(:7;(C>6BAC:(>E(>6;MD(IHE;(:>(:7;(7>IH6;DD(>E(:7;(I8=(b(H:(HD(6>:(;P78AD:HKI;(H6(86N(:HG;O(.;F;<:7;I;DD?(:7;(7AG86(K;H6@MD(G><8I(C>6D:H:A:H>6(>A@7:(:>(8@<;;(=H:7(:7HD(7>IH6;DDO(%7;(I8::;<(GAD:(:7;<;E><;(K;(8DDAG;B(H6(7HD(BHD9>DH:H>6?(H6(:7;(A6HF;<D8I(86B(9A<;(G8PHG(>E(:7;(8@<;;G;6:(>E(C>6BAC:(=H:7(:7;(I8=?(8D(:7;(@;<G(E<>G(=7HC7(8II(@>>B(HD(:>(K;(B;F;I>9;B(b(kH6(8(BHD9>DH:H>6l(=7HC7(9<>C;;BD(E<>G(8(7>IN(9<H6CH9I;(8B>9:;B(KN(:7;(7AG86(K;H6@(H6(7HD(DA9<;G;(G8PHGO(#6B(:7HD(HD(8(C786@;(>E(7;8<:(=7HC7(GAD:(H:D;IE(K;(9>DDHKI;(K;C8AD;(H:(HD(BA:NO`X

1A:N(<;ZAH<;D(:78:(=;(6>:(>6IN(78F;(8(@>>B(EA6B8G;6:8I(G8PHG(KA:(8C:(E<>G(BA:N(H6(8II(

98<:HCAI8<(C8D;DO(">=;F;<?(8C:A8I(7>IH6;DD(H6(7AG86D(C866>:(K;(8C7H;F;B(H6(:7HD(IHE;(

K;C8AD;(=;(=HII(8I=8ND(K;(DAKc;C:(:>(:7;(H6EIA;6C;(>E(H6CIH68:H>6D?*D>(:7;(C786@;(>E(7;8<:(

:78:(HD(6;;B;B(HD(:7;(C7>HC;(>E(8(@>>B(EA6B8G;6:8I(G8PHG?(=7HC7(=HII(D7>=(:78:(>6;MD(

G><8I(C>6D:H:A:H>6(HD(H6(8@<;;G;6:(=H:7(7>IH6;DD(H6D>E8<(8D(>6;(78D(C7>D;6(:>(78F;(8(

S5++CB9&:78:(HD(C898KI;(>E(C7>>DH6@(G><8IIN(@>>B(G8PHGD(H6(98<:HCAI8<(C8D;D?(:7>A@7(

8C:A8I(7>IH6;DD(C866>:(K;(8::8H6;BO(%7;(=,15..".#&C7>HC;?(:7;6?(HD(G;<;IN(8(C>GGH:G;6:(

:>(K;C>GH6@(7>IN?(<8:7;<(:786(8(:<86DH:H>6(:>(8C:A8I(7>IH6;DDO(L86:(B;DC<HK;D(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(

8D(9A::H6@(8(9;<D>6(RA9>6(:7;(@>>B(T:7>A@7(68<<>=Y(98:7(>E(C>6D:86:()9!#9,11&E<>G(K8B(:>(

K;::;<S(T15'$&("7&0,<&#"%,.&Y!*/!$+&1'$<(+,.R&S,#,&,5.,1&*,1%A.05#,.&;!9%1'$9,5%,.1&

Q!<&H'$+,'$%,.&>"<&N,11,9,.&*,75.0,RGja

#BBH:H>68IIN?(H6(:7;(L.%$9!)!+!#6:&L86:(B;DC<HK;D(8(9;<D>6MD(C7>HC;(>E(

`X -KHB:&`U``(b(`U`jO(TR1H;(&6:E;<6A6@(8K;<(B;D(/A:;6?(=8D(=H<(H6(A6D(K;=H<^;6(D>II;6?(F>6(B;G(4mD;6?(=>F>6(=H<(8AD@;7;6?(HD:(A6;6BIHC7(A6B(D>E;<6?(=8D(BH;(%8:?(BOHO(#6@;G;DD;67;H:(B;D(2;K;6D=86B;ID(fA<(";HIH@^;H:(B;D(/;D;:f;D(K;:<HEE:?(H6(^;H6;<(d;H:(;<<;HC7K8<O(/I;HC7=>7I(D>II(BH;(DH::IHC7;(4;DC78EE;67;H:(B;D(,;6DC7;6(GH:(H7<(gK;<;H6D:HGG;6O(3H;(GAh(8ID>(H6(BH;(/;DH66A6@?(H6(BH;(8II@;G;H6;(A6B(I8A:;<;(,8PHG;(B;<(eK;<;H6D:HGGA6@(B;D(+;<78I:;6D(GH:(B;GD;IK;6(8ID(B;6(L;HG?(=><8AD(8II;D(/A:;(;6:=HC^;I:(=;<B;6(D>II?(@;D;:f:(=;<B;6?(BH;(F>6(;H6;G(7;HIH@;6($<H6fH9(8AD@;7:?(=;IC7;D(B;<(,;6DC7(H6(D;H6;(>K;<D:;(,8PHG;(8AE@;6>GG;6(78:O(&H6;(3H66;Dp6B;<A6@?(BH;(8AC7(Gm@IHC7(D;H6(GAh?(=;HI(DH;($EIHC7:(HD:OSY

ja L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`U][O

Page 122: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

JJ]-,.C".#1(9%?(=7HC7?(8D(6>:;B(8K>F;?(HD(86(8::<HKA:;(>E(>6;MD(H6:;IIH@HKI;(C78<8C:;<?(8D(

H6BHC8:H6@(:>(AD(R=78:(G86(HD(9<;98<;B(:>(G8^;(>E(7HGD;IEOSjJ(%78:(HD?(:7;(C7>HC;(:>(

A6B;<@>(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6?(86B(:7AD(:>(78F;(8(C;<:8H6(=,15..".#?(<;F;8ID(>6IN(H6(=7HC7(

G><8I(BH<;C:H>6(b(@>>B(><(;FHI(b(8(9;<D>6(78D(C>GGH::;B(7HGD;IEO(#D()>>B(;P9I8H6D?(

R=7;6(L86:(D9;8^D(>E(:7;(@>>B(G86MD(7H@7;D:(G8PHG(8D(M:7;(G8PHG(>E(7>IH6;DD(>E(:7;(

BHD9>DH:H>6?M(7;(HD(6>:(<;E;<<H6@(:>(:7;(G8PHG(>E(8(=HII(=7HC7(HD(H:D;IE(7>IN?(KA:(:>(8(G8PHG(

>E(9<>@<;DD(:>=8<B(7>IH6;DD?(:7;(G8PHG(>E(MH6C;DD86:(C>A6:;<8C:H>6M(8@8H6D:(G86MD(

9<>9;6DH:N(:>(;FHIOSjQ(%7;(=,15..".#&C7>HC;(HD(6>:(8(C7>HC;(:>(K;(7>IN(KA:(:7;(C7>HC;(:>(

C>GGH:(>6;D;IE(:>(:7;(9A<DAH:(>E(7>IH6;DDOj\

*6C;(8(9;<D>6(78D(A6B;<@>6;(:7;(C>G9I;:;(<;F>IA:H>6?(:7;6?(:7;N(D:HII(78F;(GAC7(

G><;(G><8I(B;F;I>9G;6:(:>(A6B;<@>(A6:HI(:7;N(C86(K;(C>6DHB;<;B(G><8IIN(@>>BO(#D(3HIK;<(

;P9I8H6D?(

%7;(BHD9>DH:H>68I(8C:(C>6C;<6D(:7;(=HIIH6@(><(:7;(<;c;C:H6@(>E(:7;(D9H<H:(>E(:7;(G><8I(I8=(86B(;D:8KIHD7;D(:7;(<!9(+5%6&>E(:7;(8C:D(>E(:7;(S5++CB9:&:7;(A6B;<INH6@(H6:;6:H>68I(@<>A6B(>E(8II(H:D(D9;CHEHC(8C:D(86B(:7;<;E><;(H:D(C78<8C:;<O(%7;(D9;CHEHC(8C:D(>E(S5++CB9:&>6(:7;(>:7;<(786B?(B>(6>:(;D:8KIHD7(:7;(G>:HF;(>E(8C:H>6(KA:(8<;(I8<@;IN(:7;(9<>BAC:D(>E(:7;(G>:HF8:H>68I(E><C;(>E(:7;(BHD9>DH:H>68I(8C:O(#D(C>6C<;:;(;P9<;DDH>6D(>E(:7;(BHD9>DH:H>68I(G>:HF;?(:7;N(G8N(;P9<;DD(:78:(G>:HF;(8CCA<8:;IN(><(=H:7(8(BHD:><:H>6(<;DAI:H6@(E<>G(:7;(H6EIA;6C;(>E(H6:;<F;6H6@(E><C;D(=H:7H6(:7;(S5++CB9Gj]

&F;6(8E:;<(:7HD(=,15..".#&C7>HC;(86B(<;KH<:7?(:7;<;(HD(D:HII(=><^(:>(K;(B>6;(>6(8(9;<D>6MD(

98<:HCAI8<(8C:H>6D?(><(;G9H<HC8I(C78<8C:;<O(-:(HD(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(:78:(D7>AIB(G8^;(:7HD(

9<>C;DD(9>DDHKI;?(86B(:7AD(>6;(98<:(>E(:7;(9<>C;DD(>E(<8BHC8I(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:(GAD:(K;(

jJ L86:?(L.%$9!)!+!#6:&Z[Q[_O

jQ )>>B?(2(.%31&@!9(+&8,+5#5!.:(Q\aO

j\ ,A6f;I?(2(.%31&I!.',)%5!.&!7&@!9(+&I$(9('%,9:(<;E;<D(:>(>6;MD(=,15..".#?(IH^;(>:7;<(G8PHGD?(8D(RC78<8C:;<oKAHIBH6@(B;FHC;D?S(<8:7;<(:786(8D(8(<;9<;D;6:8:H>6(>E(>6;MD(8C:A8I(C78<8C:;<(T`[YO

j] 3HIK;<?(R%7;(&:7HC8I(3H@6HEHC86C;(>E(L86:MD(';IH@H>6?S(CPFHO

Page 123: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

JJ_;6DA<H6@(:78:(8(9;<D>6(HD(9<;98<;B(:>(K;@H6(:7;(9<>C;DD(>E(HG9<>FH6@(7HD(98<:HCAI8<(

8C:H>6DO

;"&.$1#4"&)"5*,-.1.*/%0."#1*%2*3-4"5.*41*<%11)=9.

%7AD(E8<(H6(:7HD(C789:;<?(=;(78F;(<;FH;=;B(=78:(:N9;D(>E(C786@;D(L86:(:7H6^D(:78:(

<8BHC8IIN(;FHI(7AG86D(GAD:(A6B;<@>(H6(><B;<(:>(EAIEHII(BA:N(86B(>F;<C>G;(>A<(<8BHC8IIN(

;FHI(D:8:;DO(%7;D;(C786@;D(78F;(H6CIAB;B(:7;(B;CHDH>6(:>(78F;(8(@>>B(=,15..".#?(:7;(

G><8I(<;KH<:7?(86B(:7;(8CZAHDH:H>6(>E(:7;(C898CH:N(:>(G8^;(:7;(DAKD;ZA;6:(6;C;DD8<N(

HG9<>F;G;6:D(:>(:7;(G><8I(=><:7(>E(>6;MD(8C:H>6DO();(78F;(6>:(N;:(8BB<;DD;B(:7;(HDDA;?(

7>=;F;<?(>E(=7;:7;<(=;?(8D(7AG86D?(C86(A6B;<D:86B(:7;D;(C786@;D(8D(9>DDHKI;(H6(>A<(>=6(

IHF;DO(-6(C8D;D(H6(=7HC7(=;(C86(78F;(D>G;(E><G(>E(^6>=I;B@;(8K>A:(7>=(DAC7(8(C786@;(

=>AIB(K;(9>DDHKI;?(=;(C86(;8DHIN(8CZAH<;(C>6EHB;6C;(:78:(:7HD(^H6B(>E(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:(

HD(9>DDHKI;O(#D(=;(=HII(D;;?(:7HD(B>;D(D;;G(:>(K;(9>DDHKI;(=H:7(:=>(^H6BD(>E(C786@;(H6(:7HD(

D:8@;?(:7;(=,15..".#&C7>HC;(86B(:7;(C898CH:N(:>(HG9<>F;(:7;(G><8I(=><:7(>E(>A<(8C:H>6DO(

">=;F;<?(:7;<;(HD(>6;(CI;8<(98<:(>E(<8BHC8I(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:(:78:(C866>:(K;(A6B;<D:>>B(

8D(9>DDHKI;(:7<>A@7(86N(E><G(>E(^6>=I;B@;O(.8G;IN?(=;(C866>:(8CZAH<;(^6>=I;B@;(>E(

7>=(:7;(G><8I(<;KH<:7(=>AIB(K;(9>DDHKI;(E><(AD(:>(8C7H;F;O

L86:(<;8BHIN(8BGH:D(:78:(7HD(<8BHC8I(;FHI(CI8HG(899;8<D(:>(9<;F;6:(86N(9>DDHKHIH:N(

E><(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:O(";(=<H:;D?(R4A:(B>;D(6>:(:7;(:7;DHD(>E(:7;(H668:;(C><<A9:H>6(>E(:7;(

7AG86(K;H6@(=H:7(<;D9;C:(:>(8II(:78:(HD(@>>B(D:86B(H6(BH<;C:(>99>DH:H>6(:>(:7HD(<;D:><8:H>6(

:7<>A@7(>6;MD(>=6(;EE><:n(*E(C>A<D;(H:(B>;DOOOSj_*">=;F;<?(7;(HD(ZAHC^(:>(6>:;(:78:(:7HD(HD(

>6IN(86(8998<;6:(9<>KI;G?(H6D>E8<(8D(:7;(<8BHC8I(;FHI(CI8HG(G8^;D(H:(HG9>DDHKI;(E><(AD(:>(

78F;(C.!/+,0#,(>E(7>=(=;(C86(>F;<C>G;(<8BHC8I(;FHIO(1;D9H:;(>A<(H68KHIH:N(:>(@8H6(

j_ L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`U_aO(TR#K;<(BH;D;<()HB;<7;<D:;IIA6@(BA<C7(;H@;6;(L<8E86=;6BA6@(D:;7:(c8(B;<(38:f(F>6(B;<(86@;K><;6;6(+;<B><K;67;H:(B;<(,;6DC7;6(Eg<(8II;D(/A:;(E;<8B;(;6:@;6;6n(#II;<BH6@DOOOSY

Page 124: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

JJ`^6>=I;B@;(>E(C;<:8H6(8D9;C:D(>E(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(:7;(>F;<C>GH6@(>E(<8BHC8I(;FHI?(L86:(

8<@A;D(:78:(:7;<;(HD(D:HII(8(=8N(:>(@8H6(D>G;(A6B;<D:86BH6@(>E(:7HD(9>DDHKHIH:NO(-6(:7;(

;6B6>:;(:>(:7;(/;6;<8I(';G8<^&>E(4>>^(*6;(>E(:7;(8,+5#5!.:&L86:(;P9I8H6D(7>=(=;(

GH@7:(K;(8KI;(:>(A6B;<D:86B(:7HD(9<>C;DDO(";(=<H:;D(:78:(9><:H>6D(>E(=78:(7;(78D(;P9I8H6;B(

H6(:7;(/;6;<8I(';G8<^:&=7HC7(H6CIAB;D(C;<:8H6(98<:D(>E(:7;(9<>C;DD(>E(>F;<C>GH6@(<8BHC8I(

;FHI(B;:8HI;B(H6(:7;(9<;FH>AD(D;C:H>6D(>E(:7HD(C789:;<(T8,+5#5!.&`U]](b(_\Y?(B>(6>:(E8II(H6:>(

:7;(K>A6B8<H;D(>E(9A<;(<;8D>6O(";(=<H:;D?

%7;D;(8<;?(8D(H:(=;<;?()(9,9#(&:>(<;IH@H>6(=H:7H6(:7;(K>A6B8<H;D(>E(9A<;(<;8D>6i(:7;N(B>(6>:(K;I>6@(=H:7H6(H:(N;:(K><B;<(>6(H:O(';8D>6?(C>6DCH>AD(>E(H:D(HG9>:;6C;(:>(D8:HDEN(H:D(G><8I(6;;BD?(;P:;6BD(H:D;IE(:>(;P:<8F8@86:(HB;8D(=7HC7(GH@7:(G8^;(A9(E><(:7HD(I8C^?(:7>A@7(H:(HD(6>:(DAH:;B(:>(:7HD(;6I8<@;B(B>G8H6O(';8D>6(B>;D(6>:(C>6:;D:(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(><(8C:A8IH:N(>E(:7;(>Kc;C:D(>E(:7;D;(HB;8Di(H:(cAD:(C866>:(H6C><9><8:;(:7;G(H6:>(H:D(G8PHGD(>E(:7>A@7:(86B(8C:H>6Oj`

L86:(:7H6^D(:78:(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(8:(I;8D:(D>G;(>E(:7;D;(C>G9>6;6:D(>E(G><8I(

HG9<>F;G;6:(C866>:(K;(;P9I8H6;B(KN(9A<;(<;8D>6(K;C8AD;(>E(>A<(H68KHIH:N(:>(78F;(8(

C>@6H:H>6(>E(>Kc;C:D(:78:(B>(6>:(899;8<(H6(:HG;(86B(D98C;O()7;6(<;8D>6(;6C>A6:;<D(DAC7(8(

IHGH:8:H>6?(H:(GAD:(9>DH:(C;<:8H6(>Kc;C:D?(=7HC7(=;(C866>:(78F;(:7;><;:HC8I(^6>=I;B@;(>E?(

H6(><B;<(:>(;P9I8H6(7>=(DAC7(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:(HD(9>DDHKI;O(-E(H:(B>;D(6>:(B>(:7HD?(=;(

C866>:(A6B;<D:86B(7>=(=;(8<;(8KI;(:>(B>(=78:(BA:N(C>GG86BD(>E(ADO(-6(:7;(<;G8H6B;<(>E(

:7HD(D;C:H>6?(:7;6?(-(=HII(<;FH;=(;8C7(>E(:7;D;(6;C;DD8<N(G>G;6:D(>E(C786@;(86B(B;:;<GH6;(

7>=(=;(C86(A6B;<D:86B(;8C7(8D(9>DDHKI;O

W6B;<D:86BH6@(:7;($>DDHKHIH:N(>E(:7;(=,15..".#(!7>HC;

-:(HD(9>9AI8<(H6(:7;(D;C>6B8<N(IH:;<8:A<;(:>(<;8B(:7;(=,15..".#&C7>HC;(8D(D>G;:7H6@(

j` -KHB?&`U_QO(TR1H;D;(DH6B(@I;HC7D8G($8<;<@8(B;<(';IH@H>6(H66;<78IE(B;<(/<;6f;6(B;<(<;H6;6(+;<6A6E:i(DH;(@;7m<;6(6HC7:(H66;<78IE(B;<D;IK;6?(8K;<(D:>h;6(B>C7(86(DH;(86O(1H;(+;<6A6E:(HG(4;=Ah:D;H6(H7<;D(W6F;<Gm@;6D?(H7<;G(G><8IHDC7;6(4;Bm<E6HD(;H6(/;6g@;(fA(:A6?(B;76:(DHC7(KHD(fA(gK;<DC7=;6@IHC7;6(-B;;6(8AD?(BH;(c;6;6(,86@;I(;<@p6f;6(^m66:;6?(>76;(DH;(B>C7(8ID(;H6;6(;<=;H:;<:;6(4;DH:f(DHC7(fAfA;H@;6O(3H;(K;D:<;H:;:(6HC7:(BH;(,m@IHC7^;H:(>B;<()H<^IHC7^;H:(B;<(/;@;6D:p6B;(B;<D;IK;6?(8K;<(DH;(^866(DH;(6A<(6HC7:(H6(H7<;(,8PHG;6(fA(B;6^;6(A6B(fA(786B;I6(8AE6;7G;6OSY

Page 125: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

JJj:78:(C866>:(K;(A6B;<D:>>B(8D(9>DDHKI;(=H:7>A:(:7;(;P:;<68I(8DDHD:86C;(>E(86(H6:;IIH@HKI;(

K;H6@?(><?(H6(>:7;<(=><BD?(6>:(9>DDHKI;(KN(7AG86(9>=;<D(8I>6;Ojj(-E(:7HD(HD(:<A;?(:7;6(

7AG86D(C866>:(78F;(^6>=I;B@;(>E(7>=(:7HD(C7>HC;(HD(9>DDHKI;(K;C8AD;(=;(C866>:(78F;(

^6>=I;B@;(>E(DAC7(8(K;H6@O(%7HD(<;8BH6@(HD(:N9HC8IIN(@<>A6B;B(H6(L86:MD(>=6(ZA;D:H>6D(

8K>A:(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(>F;<C>GH6@(<8BHC8I(;FHIOj[!0><(;P8G9I;?(H6(:7;(8,+5#5!.:&L86:(

=<H:;D(R4A:(HE(8(7AG86(K;H6@(HD(C><<A9:(H6(:7;(F;<N(@<>A6B(>E(7HD(G8PHGD?(7>=(C86(7;(

9>DDHKIN(K<H6@(8K>A:(:7HD(<;F>IA:H>6(KN(7HD(>=6(E><C;D(86B(K;C>G;(8(@>>B(7AG86(K;H6@(

>6(7HD(>=6nSjX(,HC78ID>6?(H6(7HD(=><^(R08II;6(0<;;B>G?S(8<@A;D(:78:(L86:(6;F;<(86D=;<D(

:7HD(ZA;D:H>6(86B?(:7AD?(=;(D7>AIB(6>:(:8^;(D;<H>ADIN(:7;(HB;8(:78:(:7;(=,15..".#&C7>HC;(HD(

9>DDHKI;(:7<>A@7(7AG86(9>=;<D(8I>6;O[a(,HC78ID>6(CI8HGD(:78:(86(;FHI(=,15..".#(<AI;D(

>A:(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(;F;<(C7>>DH6@(8(@>>B(=,15..".#(K;C8AD;(H:(D789;D[J(8II(>A<(

98<:HCAI8<(G8PHGDO(-6(E8C:?(7;(=<H:;D(:78:?(;F;6(HE(>6;MD(S5++CB9&=86:;B(:>(C7>>D;(8(@>>B(

jj #6(;P8G9I;(>E(8(:7H6^;<(=7>(DA99><:D(:7HD(<;8BH6@(HD($7HIH9(r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rAH66(:7H6^D(:78:(=;(C86(A6B;<D:86B(:7;(C786@;(E<>G(86(;FHI(=,15..".#&:>(8(@>>B(>6;?(7;(:7H6^D(:78:(L86:(78D(E8HI;B(:>(;P9I8H6(7>=(<8BHC8I(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:(HD(9>DDHKI;O

j[ ,HC78ID>6?(;(++,.&;9,,0!<:(CH:;D(D;F;<8I(;P8G9I;D(>E(:7HD?(H6CIABH6@(8,+5#5!.&`U]jO

jX L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`U]jO(TR);66(B;<(,;6DC7(8K;<(HG(/<A6B;(D;H6;<(,8PHG;6(F;<B;<K:(HD:?(=H;(HD:(;D(Gm@IHC7?(B8h(;<(BA<C7(;H@;6;(L<pE:;(BH;D;(';F>IA:H>6(fAD:86B;(K<H6@;(A6B(F>6(D;IKD:(;H6(@A:;<(,;6DC7(=;<B;nSY

[a ,HC78ID>6?(;(++,.&;9,,0!<?(X](b(X_O

[J L86:(B>;D(6>:(:7H6^(:78:(>6;MD(C7>HC;(>E(=,15..".#(B;:;<GH6;D(>6;MD(I>=;<(G8PHGD(C>G9I;:;IN(86B(H6(8II(C8D;D?(:7>A@7(7;(B>;D(:7H6^(:78:(H:(D;<F;D(8D(:7;(DAKc;C:HF;(DA9<;G;(@<>A6B(>E(I>=;<(G8PHGD(T`U\jYO(0><(;P8G9I;?(;F;6(:7>A@7(8(9;<D>6(78D(>F;<C>G;(<8BHC8I(;FHI(86B(C7>D;6(8(@>>B(G8PHG?(L86:(D:HII(:7H6^D(:78:(7;(6;;BD(:>(B>(=><^(:>(HG9<>F;(:>(:7;(9>H6:(>E(8I=8ND(C7>>DH6@(@>>B(G8PHGD(H6(98<:HCAI8<(C8D;D(T`U][YO(-E(>6;MD(=,15..".#(B;:;<GH6;B(>6;MD(I>=;<(G8PHGD(C>G9I;:;IN?(:7HD(=>AIB(6>:(K;(:7;(C8D;O(-6:;<;D:H6@IN?(:7>A@7?(7;(B>;D(6>:;(:78:(86(;FHI(=,15..".#&B>;D(<AI;(>A:(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(8C:H6@(>6(8(@>>B(G8PHG(H6(8(98<:HCAI8<(C8D;(T`U\jYO

Page 126: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

JJ[=,15..".#:(H:(=>AIB(>6IN(I;8B(:>(RB;D98H<(:78:(k>6;l(C>AIB(;F;<(G8<D78II(:7;(<;D>A<C;D(>E(

=HII(:>(8C:(>6(:78:(D;6D;(>E(>KIH@8:H>6OS[Q(

%7HD(HD(86(HG9><:86:(9I8C;(:>(;P9I8H6(H6(=78:(D;6D;(:7;(=,15..".#&C7>HC;(HD(8(

A6HZA;(86B(C>G9I;P(^H6B(>E(C7>HC;(H6(L86:MD(;:7HCD(86B?(:7AD?(=7N(:7;<;(C>AIB(K;(8(

BHEE;<;6C;(K;:=;;6(>A<(7AG86(8KHIH:N(:>(G8^;(:7;(=,15..".#&C7>HC;(86B(>A<(8KHIH:N(:>(

C7>>D;(:7;(G8PHGD(>E(>A<(8C:H>6D(H6(98<:HCAI8<(C8D;D?(=7;6(=;(8<;(H6(8(D:8:;(>E(<8BHC8I(

;FHIO(*6(:7;(DA<E8C;?(H:(78D(G86N(DHGHI8<H:H;D(=H:7(:7;(C7>HC;(:>(8C:(>6(8(@>>B(G8PHG(H6(8(

98<:HCAI8<(C8D;O(-6(K>:7(H6D:86C;D?(:7;(C7>HC;(HD(8(6>AG;68I?(E<;;(C7>HC;(:>(78F;(:7;(G><8I(

I8=(D;<F;(8D(:7;(B;:;<GH6H6@(@<>A6B(>E(:7;(=HII?(><(:>(D;I;C:(8(@>>B(G8PHGO(">=;F;<?(8D(

6>:;B(8K>F;?(:7;(=,15..".#&C7>HC;(HD(6>:(8C:A8IIN(8(C7>HC;(:>(('%(>6(8(@>>B(G8PHGO(-:(HD(

>6IN(8(C7>HC;(:>(K;(C>GGH::;B(:>(G8^H6@(G8PHGD(:78:(8<;(G>:HF8:;B(KN(BA:N(H6(:7;(EA:A<;(

H6(98<:HCAI8<(C8D;D?(86B?(:7AD?(H:(G;<;IN(D7>=D(=78:(8(9;<D>6(HD(9<;98<;B(:>(G8^;(>E(

7HGD;IE(G><8IINO(%7;(=,15..".#&C7>HC;(DAKD;ZA;6:IN(BHC:8:;D(>6;MD(C7>HC;(>E(G8PHGD(H6(

98<:HCAI8<(C8D;D?(H6D>E8<(8D(H:(HD(>6;MD(@;6;<8I(C>GGH:G;6:(8K>A:(>6;MD(EA:A<;(98<:HCAI8<(

G8PHGDO(%7HD(HD(:7;(^;N(=8N(:78:(:7;D;(:=>(C7>HC;D(BHEE;<O()7HI;(K>:7(8<;(E<;;?(6>AG;68I(

C7>HC;D?(:7;(C7>HC;(>E(G8PHGD(H6(98<:HCAI8<(C8D;D(HD(:7;(C7>HC;(:>(8C:A8IIN(8C:(>6(8(C;<:8H6(

G8PHG(H6(8(D9;CHEHC(C8D;O(#I:;<68:HF;IN?(:7;(=,15..".#&C7>HC;(HD(>6IN(8(C>GGH:G;6:(

;H:7;<(:>(8C:(G><8IIN(><(:>(6>:(8C:(G><8IIN(H6(:7;(EA:A<;O(%7HD(HD(=7N(,HC78ID>6(D:8:;D(:78:(

86(;FHI(=,15..".#(<AI;D(>A:(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(8C:H6@(A9>6(@>>B(G8PHGDO(-E(=;(8<;(

C>GGH::;B(:>(8C:H6@(E<>G(G>:HF;D(>E(H6CIH68:H>6?(<8:7;<(:786(BA:N?(:7;6(=;(8998<;6:IN(

C866>:(D;I;C:(@>>B(G8PHGD(H6(98<:HCAI8<(C8D;DO

';:A<6H6@(:>(:7;(ZA;D:H>6(8:(786B?(:7;(8<@AG;6:(:78:(<8BHC8IIN(;FHI(7AG86D(B>(6>:(

[Q ,HC78ID>6?(;(++,.&;9,,0!<?(X_O

Page 127: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

JJX78F;(:7;(C898CH:N(:>(G8^;(:7;(=,15..".#&C7>HC;(B>;D(D;;G(9I8ADHKI;?(HE(=;(8DDAG;(:78:(

:7;(C7>HC;(>E(86(;FHI(=,15..".#?(><(:7;(C>GGH:G;6:(:>(C7>>D;(G8PHGD(G>:HF8:;B(KN(

H6CIH68:H>6(<8:7;<(:786(BA:N?(<AI;D(>A:(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(;F;<(8C:H6@(>6(86N(@>>B(G8PHGD(

H6(:7;(EA:A<;?(;F;6(:7;(@>>B(G8PHG(:>(C786@;(>6;MD(=,15..".#O(-:(HD(:<A;?(H6(E8C:?(:78:(

L86:(:7H6^D(:78:(86(;FHI(=,15..".#&C><<A9:D(:7;(F;<N(@<>A6B(>E(8(9;<D>6MD(G8PHGD?[\(:7AD(

G8^H6@(:7;(C7>HC;(>E(@>>B(98<:HCAI8<(G8PHGD(HG9>DDHKI;O(">=;F;<?(=;(GAD:(^;;9(H6(

GH6B(:7;(BHD:H6C:H>6(K;:=;;6(:7;(=,15..".#&C7>HC;(86B(:7;(C7>HC;(>E(G8PHGD(H6(

98<:HCAI8<(C8D;DO()7HI;(H:(HD(>KFH>AD(=7N(86(;FHI(=,15..".#(D7>AIB(<AI;(>A:(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(

>E(C7>>DH6@(8(@>>B(G8PHG(H6(8(98<:HCAI8<(C8D;?(H:(HD(6>:(8D(>KFH>AD(=7N(>A<(CA<<;6:(

=,15..".#(D7>AIB(<AI;(>A:(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(G8^H6@(8(6;=(C>GGH:G;6:(8K>A:(>A<(EA:A<;(

G><8I(IHE;O(-6(E8C:?(L86:(6;F;<(;P9IHCH:IN(G8^;D(:7;(CI8HG(:78:(86(;FHI(=,15..".#(<AI;D(>A:(

;F;6(:7;(C898CH:N(:>(C7>>D;(8(6;=?(@>>B(=,15..".#O(%7;(CI>D;D:(L86:(C>G;D(:>(D8NH6@(

:7HD(HD(=7;6(7;(=<H:;D?

%7HD(;FHI(k:7;(9<>9;6DH:N(:>(;FHIl(HD(9(05'(+:&DH6C;(H:(C><<A9:D(:7;(@<>A6B(>E(8II(G8PHGDi(8D(68:A<8I(9<>9;6DH:N?(H:(HD(8ID>(6>:(:>(K;(,V%59)(%,0&:7<>A@7(7AG86(E><C;D?(E><(:7HD(C>AIB(>6IN(7899;6(:7<>A@7(@>>B(G8PHGD(b(D>G;:7H6@(:78:(C866>:(:8^;(9I8C;(HE(:7;(DAKc;C:HF;(DA9<;G;(@<>A6B(>E(8II(G8PHGD(HD(9<;DA99>D;B(:>(K;(C><<A9:;BO(5;:(H:(GAD:(;ZA8IIN(K;(9>DDHKI;(:>(!Q,9'!<,&:7HD(;FHI?(E><(H:(HD(E>A6B(H6(:7;(7AG86(K;H6@(8D(8C:H6@(E<;;INO[]

";<;?(L86:(B>;D(G8^;(:7;(CI8HG(:78:?(=7;6(8(9;<D>6(78D(8(C><<A9:;B(@<>A6B(>E(G8PHGD?(

D7;(C866>:(E><GAI8:;(@>>B(G8PHGDO(">=;F;<?(H:(HD(HG9><:86:(:>(6>:;(7;<;(:78:(:7HD(CI8HG(

HD(8(G><;(G>B;D:(>6;(:786(H:(G8N(8:(EH<D:(D;;GO(L86:(>6IN(D8ND(:78:(=;(C866>:(E><GAI8:;(

:7;(@>>B(G8PHGD(6;C;DD8<N(:>(,V%59)(%,(TQ,9%5+#,.Y*E<>G(>A<(68:A<;(:7;(9<>9;6DH:N(:>(;FHI?(

[\ L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`U\jO

[] L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`U\jO(TR1H;D;D(4mD;(HD:(<8BH^8I?(=;HI(;D(B;6(/<A6B(8II;<(,8PHG;6(F;<BH<K:i(fA@I;HC7(8AC7(8ID(68:g<IHC7;<("86@(BA<C7(G;6DC7IHC7;(L<pE:;(6HC7:(fA(F;<:HI@;6?(=;HI(BH;D;D(6A<(BA<C7(@A:;(,8PHG;6(@;DC7;7;6(^m66:;?(=;IC7;D?(=;66(B;<(>K;<D:;(DAKc;^:HF;(/<A6B(8II;<(,8PHG;6(8ID(F;<B;<K:(F><8AD@;D;:f:(=H<B?(6HC7:(D:8::EH6B;6(^866OOOSY

Page 128: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

JQa=7HC7(78D(K;C>G;(>A<(;FHI(=,15..".#(:7<>A@7(>A<(E<;;(C7>HC;O[_(";(B>;D(6>:?(7>=;F;<?(

CI8HG(:78:(=;(C866>:(B>(=78:(HD(6;C;DD8<N(:>(>F;<C>G;&T"*,9/5,#,.Y&<8BHC8I(;FHI(:7<>A@7(

E<;;(8C:H>6O

0><:A68:;IN(E><(>A<(C898CH:N(:>(K;C>G;(G><8IIN(@>>B?(H:(B>;D(6>:(8C:A8IIN(899;8<(

:78:(L86:(:7H6^D(H:(HD(6;C;DD8<N(:>(;P:H<98:;(>A<(9<>9;6DH:N(:>(;FHI(KA:(G;<;IN(:>(>F;<C>G;(

H:(8D(>A<(C7>D;6(=,15..".#O[`(L8:;(#O(,><86(9>H6:D(:>(8(BHEE;<;6C;(K;:=;;6(>F;<C>GH6@(

86B(;P:H<98:H6@O(37;(6>:;D(:78:?(=7;6(L86:(=<H:;D(:78:(:7;(9<>9;6DH:N(:>(;FHI(C866>:(K;(

;P:H<98:;B(KN(7AG86(9>=;<D?(7;(HD(:8I^H6@(8K>A:(:7;(HG9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(C>G9I;:;IN(

;IHGH68:H6@(H:(E<>G(>A<(68:A<;O(">=;F;<?(8D(,><86(9>H6:D(>A:?(L86:(HD(6>:(=<H:H6@(>EE(:7;(

9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(G;<;IN(>F;<C>GH6@(;FHI?(=7HC7(8998<;6:IN(C86(K;(B>6;(:7<>A@7(E<;;(

C7>HC;O[j(%7;(>F;<C>GH6@(>E(;FHI(HD(BHD:H6@AHD7;B(E<>G(:7;(<;G>F8I(>E(<8BHC8I(;FHI?(KA:(

=78:(B>;D(H:(G;86(:>(>F;<C>G;(;FHIn(!I;8<IN?(H:(78D(D>G;:7H6@(:>(B>(=H:7(K;H6@(8KI;(:>(

C786@;(>A<(=,15..".#?(=7;<;H6(<8BHC8I(;FHI(IH;D?(=H:7>A:(78FH6@(:>(EH<D:(<;G>F;(:7;(;FHI(

=,15..".#(:78:(=;(>6C;(C7>D;O(

( 4N(:A<6H6@(:>(:7;(:;P:(>E(:7;(8,+5#5!.:&=;(C86(D;;(:78:(L86:(:8I^D(8K>A:(:7;(

RFHC:><NS*>E(@>>B(>F;<(;FHI?(H6(:7;(C8D;(>E(<8BHC8I(;FHI?(8D(8(G8::;<(>E(9<H><H:HfH6@(>6;(

=,15..".#(>F;<(86>:7;<(<8:7;<(:786(<;G>FH6@(86B(<;9I8CH6@(8(=,15..".#O(-6($8<:(%=>(>E(

:7;(8,+5#5!.:&L86:(B;DC<HK;D(<8BHC8I(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:(8D(8(RD:<A@@I;S(><(RC>6EIHC:S(

K;:=;;6(:7;(R;FHI(9<H6CH9I;S(86B(:7;(R@>>B(9<H6CH9I;?S(G;86H6@(>A<(C7>D;6(;FHI(

[_ ";(6>:;D(8@8H6(:78:(:7;(9<>9;6DH:N(:>(;FHI(HD(RH6;P:H<98KI;S(H6(98DD8@;(`U_J(>E(:7;(8,+5#5!.G

[` 3;;(,><86?(I!<<".5%6&(.0&49!#9,11:(X\O(37;(=<H:;D?(R4A:(:7;<;(HD(8(D;6D;(H6(=7HC7(8(7>9;(E><(:7;(;IHGH68:H>6(>E(;FHI(HD(8(KH:(>E(8(<;B(7;<<H6@?(DH6C;(H:(HD(6>:(;F;6(CI;8<(:78:(DAC7(;IHGH68:H>6(HD(6;C;DD8<N(E><(G><8I(9<>@<;DD(><(G><8I(9;<E;C:H>6OS

[j ,><86?(I!<<".5%6&(.0&49!#9,11:&X\O(37;(9>H6:D(:>(8,+5#5!.&`U\j?(=7;<;(L86:(D:8:;D(:78:(H:(GAD:(K;(9>DDHKI;(E><(7AG86D(:>(>F;<C>G;(<8BHC8I(;FHI?(E><(cAD:HEHC8:H>6(E><(:7HDO(#II;6()>>B(G8^;D(8(DHGHI8<(D:8:;G;6:(=7;6(7;(=<H:;D*R)78:(51&=H:7H6(7HD(k8(7AG86MDl(9>=;<(HD(:7;('!".%,9('%5!.&>E(:7HD(9<>9;6DH:N?(:7;(8B>9:H>6(>E(8(BHD9>DH:H>6(:>(@>>B(86B(:7;(I;8BH6@(>E(8(IHE;(>E(9<>@<;DD(E<>G(K8B(:>(K;::;<S(TQ]_YO

Page 129: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

JQJ=,15..".#(86B(8(@>>B(=,15..".#O**6C;(8(<8BHC8IIN(;FHI(9;<D>6(78D(C7>D;6(:>(78F;(8(@>>B(

=,15..".#?(=7;:7;<(:7HD(K;(:7<>A@7(7AG86(9>=;<D(8I>6;(><(=H:7(D>G;(D><:(>E(8DDHD:86C;?(

:7;<;(D:HII(GAD:(K;(8(D:<A@@I;(K;:=;;6(:7;(:=>?(:>(B;:;<GH6;(=7HC7(:8^;D(9<H><H:N(>F;<(:7;(

>:7;<O(4A:(L86:(HD(CI;8<(:78:(:7HD(HD(6>:(8(<;G>F8I(>E(;FHIO(";(=<H:;D?(

3>(:7;(G><8I(>A:C>G;(>E(:7HD(C>6EIHC:OOOHD(6>:(<;8IIN(:7;('!.J",95.#&>E(:7;(;FHI(9<H6CH9I;(b(E><(H:D(^H6@B>G(D:HII(;6BA<;D(86B?(H6(86N(C8D;?(8(6;=(;9>C7(GAD:(N;:(C>G;(H6(=7HC7(H:(HD(:>(K;(B;D:<>N;B(b(KA:(>6IN(:7;(K<;8^H6@(A9(>E(H:D(C>6:<>IIH6@(9>=;<(H6(7>IBH6@(8@8H6D:(:7;H<(=HII(:7>D;(=7>(78F;(D>(I>6@(K;;6(DAKc;C:(:>(H:?(6>=(:78:(86>:7;<(G><8I(B>GH6H>6(TDH6C;(:7;(7AG86(K;H6@(GAD:(K;(DAKc;C:(:>(D>G;(B>GH6H>6(><(>:7;<Y(78D(K;;6(<;F;8I;B(:>(:7;G(8D(E<;;B>G?(86B(H6(H:(:7;N(C86(EH6B(9<>:;C:H>6(E><(:7;H<(G><8IH:N(HE(:7;N(=86:(:>(E><D8^;(:7;(>IB(>6;O[[

-6(D7><:?(:7;(>F;<C>GH6@(>E(<8BHC8I(;FHI?(IH^;(:7;(C7>HC;(>E(8(G8PHG(H6(8(98<:HCAI8<(C8D;?[X(

<;ZAH<;D(AD(:>(9<H><H:Hf;(>6;(C7>D;6(=,15..".#?(><(EA6B8G;6:8I(G8PHG?(8K>F;(86>:7;<(

<8:7;<(:786(:>(<;G>F;(>6;(=,15..".#(;6:H<;IN(86B(D;I;C:(8(6;=(>6;(:>(:8^;(H:D(9I8C;O(%78:(

HD?(>6C;(=;(78F;(C7>D;6(:7;(;FHI(=,15..".#?(=;(B>(6>:(78F;(:>(<;G>F;(H:(H6(><B;<(:>(

K;C>G;(G><8IIN(@>>BO();(>6IN(78F;(:>(9<H><H:Hf;(8(@>>B(EA6B8G;6:8I(G8PHG(8K>F;(H:O(

%7AD?(:7;<;(HD(6>(<;8D>6(:>(8DDAG;(:78:(=;(GAD:(K;(8KI;(:>(78F;(:7;(9>=;<(:>(8C:A8IIN(

<;G>F;(>A<(;FHI(=,15..".#(H6(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6O();(G;<;IN(78F;(:>(DAK><BH68:;(H:(:>(:7;(

@>>B(=,15..".#(=;(78F;(6>=(C7>D;6O

4A:(:7HD(D>IA:H>6(B>;D(6>:(N;:(EAIIN(8BB<;DD(:7;(9<>KI;G(>E(=7;:7;<(=;(C86(C7>>D;(

[[ L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`U[Q(b([\O(TR#ID>(HD:(B;<(G><8IHDC7;(#AD@86@(BH;D;D(3:<;H:;D(8AE(3;H:;6(B;D(";IB;6(BH;D;<(/;DC7HC7:;(TKHD(fAG(%>B;(B;DD;IK;6Y(;H@;6:IHC7(6HC7:(BH;(4;DH;@A6@(B;D(KmD;6($<H6fH9Di(B;66(D;H6(';HC7(=p<:(6>C7?(A6B(;D(GAh(8II;6E8IID(6>C7(;H6;(6;A;(&9>C7;(;H6:<;:;6?(H6(B;<(;D(f;<D:m<:(=;<B;6(D>II?(o(D>6B;<6(6A<(4<;C7A6@(D;H6;<(/;=8I:?(BH;?(=;IC7;(H7G(D>(I86@;(A6:;<:86(@;=;D;6(DH6B?(6HC7:(=HB;<(H7<;6()HII;6(fA(78I:;6?(H6B;G(H76;6(;H6;(86B;<;(G><8IHDC7;(";<<DC78E:(TB;66(A6:;<(H<@;6B(;H6;<(GAh(B;<(,;6DC7(D:;7;6Y(8ID(0<;HD:8::(;<mEE6;:(=H<B?(H6(B;<(DH;(3C7A:f(Eg<(H7<;(,><8IH:p:(EH6B;6(^m66;6?(=;66(DH;(BH;(8I:;(F;<I8DD;6(=>II;6OSY

[X ';C8II(:78:(:7HD(HD(F;<N(DHGHI8<(:>(:7;(=8N(L86:(BHDCADD;D(:7;(C7>HC;(>E(98<:HCAI8<(G8PHGDO(-:(HD(6>:(:78:(=;(6;;B(:>(C>G9I;:;IN(<;G>F;(:7;(H6EIA;6C;(>E(H6C;6:HF;D(>E(H6CIH68:H>6(H6(><B;<(:>(8C:(G><8IINO();(G;<;IN(78F;(:>(9<H><H:Hf;(:7;(H6C;6:HF;(>E(:7;(G><8I(I8=(8K>F;(:7;D;(H6C;6:HF;DO(2H^;=HD;?(=;(B>(6>:(6;;B(:>(<;G>F;(;6:H<;IN(>A<(;FHI(EA6B8G;6:8I(G8PHG(H6(><B;<(:>(>F;<C>G;(<8BHC8I(;FHIO(0><(G><;(>6(:7HD?(D;;(!789:;<(*6;O

Page 130: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

JQQ:>(9<H><H:Hf;(8(@>>B(=,15..".#(=7;6(=;(D:HII(78F;(86(;FHI(>6;O(-6(E8C:?(L86:(B>;D(G8^;(

C;<:8H6(D:8:;G;6:D(:78:(D;;G(:>(H6BHC8:;(:78:(=;(B>(78F;(:7;(9>=;<(:>(C7>>D;(8(6;=(

=,15..".#?(<;@8<BI;DD(>E(:7;(D:8:;(>E(>A<(CA<<;6:(=,15..".#O(0><(;P8G9I;?(H6($8<:(%7<;;(

>E(:7;(8,+5#5!.:&7;(=<H:;D(:78:(;F;6(>6C;(8(9;<D>6(78D(C7>D;6(8(@>>B(=,15..".#?(R7;(D:HII(

<;G8H6D(6>:(86N(:7;(I;DD(;P9>D;B(:>(:7;(8DD8AI:D(>E(:7;(;FHI(9<H6CH9I;OSXa(-E(8(9;<D>6(=H:7(8(

@>>B(EA6B8G;6:8I(G8PHG(C86(C7>>D;(:>(78F;(86(;FHI(>6;(8@8H6?(:7;6(>6;MD(CA<<;6:(

=,15..".#(GAD:(6>:(IHGH:(7HD(G8PHGoG8^H6@(H6(:7;(C8D;(>E(8(=,15..".#&C7>HC;O(

#BBH:H>68IIN?(KN(I>>^H6@(8:(=78:(L86:(D8ND(8K>A:(:7;(=,15..".#&C7>HC;(86B(:7;(6;;B(E><(

;P:;<68I(8DDHD:86C;(H6(:7;(8,+5#5!.:&H:(B>;D(D;;G(:78:(7;(K;IH;F;D(=;(C86(G8^;(:7HD(C7>HC;(

>6(>A<(>=6O(-6(G86N(98DD8@;D(H6(=7HC7(L86:(:8I^D(8K>A:(:7;(IHGH:D(>E(7AG86D(H6(G8^H6@(

:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(9>DDHKI;(86B(:7;(DAKD;ZA;6:(6;;B(>E(;P:;<68I(8DDHD:86C;(:>(G8^;(H:(9>DDHKI;?(

L86:(:8I^D(8K>A:(:7HD(6;;B(E><(8HB(>6IN(8E:;<(8(9;<D>6(8I<;8BN(78D(C7>D;6(8(@>>B(

=,15..".#OXJ(%7HD(6;;B(E><(;P:;<68I(8DDHD:86C;(B>;D(6>:(899;8<(:>(899IN(:>(:7;(=,15..".#&

C7>HC;(H:D;IE(KA:(:>(D>G;(>:7;<(98<:(>E(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6O(-:(899;8<D?(:7;6?(:78:(=7HI;(>A<(

8KHIH:N(:>(C7>>D;(G8PHGD(H6(98<:HCAI8<(C8D;D(HD(B;:;<GH6;B(KN(>A<(C7>HC;(>E(=,15..".#?(

=;(D:HII(G8N(<;:8H6(:7;(8KHIH:N(:>(E<;;IN(C7>>D;(8(6;=(=,15..".#?(<;@8<BI;DD(>E(:7;(D:8:;(>E(

>A<(CA<<;6:(>6;O

)H:7(:7HD(G><;(C>G9I;P(A6B;<D:86BH6@(>E(=78:(:7;(=,15..".#&C7>HC;(;6:8HID?(H:(HD(

CI;8<(:78:(7AG86D(C86?(H6B;;B?(78F;(^6>=I;B@;(>E(7>=(DAC7(8(C7>HC;(HD(9>DDHKI;O(*E(

C>A<D;?(;F;6(=H:7(:7HD(<;8BH6@?(8(7AG86(C866>:(78F;(^6>=I;B@;(>E(=7;:7;<(7HD(C7>HC;(:>(

K;(C>GGH::;B(:>(8C:H6@(E<>G(:7;(G><8I(I8=(78D(8C:A8IIN(DACC;;B;B(H6(C786@H6@(7HD(

Xa L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`UX]O(TR1;6(#6@<HEE;6(B;D(I;:f:;<;6(KI;HK:(;<(6HC7:DB;D:>=;6H@;<(6>C7(HGG;<(8AD@;D;:f:OOOSY

XJ 0><(;P8G9I;D?(D;;(`U][?(`UjQ?(86B(`Uj\O(

Page 131: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

JQ\=,15..".#:&86B(DAKD;ZA;6:IN(@HF;6(7HG(8(6;=?(@>>B(7;8<:?(><(:7;(C898CH:N(:>(C7>>D;(

G><8IIN(@>>B(G8PHGD(H6(98<:HCAI8<(C8D;DO()7HI;?(8D(=;(=HII(D;;?(:7HD(IHGH:8:H>6(>E(7AG86(

^6>=I;B@;(8<HD;D(8D(8(9<>KI;G(E><(:7;(C>G9I;:H>6(>E(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6?(H:(B>;D(6>:(9<;F;6:(AD(

E<>G(K;H6@(8=8<;(>E(:7;(C>GGH:G;6:(:78:(=;(78F;(G8B;(H6(:7;(=,15..".#&C7>HC;O

W6B;<D:86BH6@(:7;(!898CH:N(:>(-G9<>F;(:7;(,><8I()><:7(>E(*A<(#C:H>6D

#D(BHDCADD;B(;8<IH;<?(8E:;<(:7;(=,15..".#&C7>HC;?(=;(GAD:(8ID>(A6B;<@>(8(G><8I(

<;KH<:7(H6(><B;<(:>(C>G9I;:;(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6O(">=;F;<?(K;C8AD;(A6B;<D:86BH6@(:7;(

9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(:7;(G><8I(<;KH<:7(HD(DAKc;C:(:>(D>G;(DAKD:86:H8I(;9HD:;G>I>@HC8I(9<>KI;GD?(-(

=HII(<;D;<F;(:78:(BHDCADDH>6(E><(I8:;<(H6(:7HD(C789:;<O(0H<D:?(-(=HII(8BB<;DD(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(

@8H6H6@(:7;(C898CH:N(:>(HG9<>F;(:7;(G><8I(=><:7(>E(>A<(8C:H>6DO

%>(<;FH;=?(H6(><B;<(:>(C>G9I;:;(:7;(EAII(C>A<D;(>E(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:(86B(

:<86DE><G(>A<D;IF;D(E<>G(<8BHC8IIN(;FHI(9;>9I;(:>(G><8IIN(@>>B(9;>9I;?(H6(K>:7(

=,15..".#(86B(8C:H>6D?(=;(GAD:(HG9<>F;(:7;(G><8I(=><:7(>E(>A<(8C:H>6DO(%7;(<;F>IA:H>6(

HD(DA99>D;B(:>(K;(8KI;(:>(9A:(AD(>6(:7;(98:7(:>(86(HG9<>F;G;6:(H6(>A<(8C:H>6DO(%7;(G8c><(

9<>KI;G(=H:7(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(K;@H66H6@(86(HG9<>F;G;6:(H6(>A<(8C:H>6D(HD(A6B;<D:86BH6@(

:78:(H:(HD(9>DDHKI;(E><(AD?(=7>(=;<;(>6C;(<8BHC8IIN(;FHI?(:>(6>=(G8^;(:7HD(^H6B(>E(

HG9<>F;G;6:O(%78:(HD?(;F;6(=7;6(=;(78F;(A6B;<@>6;(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(86B(8<;(C898KI;(>E(

:7HD(C786@;?(=;(GAD:(8BBH:H>68IIN(A6B;<D:86B(H:(8D(9>DDHKI;(E><(AD(:>(8C7H;F;O(#D(=H:7(:7;(

>:7;<(98<:D(>E(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:?(A6I;DD(=;(78F;(8(<8:H>68IINo@<>A6B;B?XQ(><(cAD:HEH;B?(

;P9;C:8:H>6(:78:(=;(=HII(K;(8KI;(:>(HG9<>F;(>A<(8C:H>6D(K;C8AD;(>E(>A<(C786@;B(

=,15..".#?(L86:(:7H6^D(:78:(=;(=HII(6>:(K;(8KI;(:>(B>(D>O(0><(;P8G9I;?(L86:(=<H:;D(:78:(

XQ 4N(:7;(<;ZAH<;G;6:(:78:(:7HD(7>9;(HD(R<8:H>68IINo@<>A6B;B?S(-(H6:;6B(:>(CI8<HEN(:78:(H:(C866>:(K;(8(7>9;(:78:(HD(6>:(DA99><:;B(KN(>A<(<;8D>6O(0><(;P8G9I;?(-(C866>:(7>9;(:78:(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(78D(>CCA<<;B(H6(GN(IHE;(K;C8AD;(-(AD;B(:>(78F;(D:<8H@7:(78H<(86B(6>=(-(78F;(CA<IN(78H<O

Page 132: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

JQ]R=H:7>A:(86N(C>6EHB;6C;(H6(:7;(BHD9>DH:H>6(T=,15..".#Y(>6C;(8CZAH<;B?(9;<D;F;<86C;(H6(H:(

=>AIB(78<BIN(K;(9>DDHKI;OSX\(-6(>:7;<(=><BD?(8CZAH<H6@(:7;(C898CH:N(:>(HG9<>F;(>A<(8C:H>6D(

B>;D(6>:(>6IN(;6:8HI(:7;(C>6BH:H>6(>E(C786@H6@(>A<(=,15..".#&86B(K;H6@(G><8IIN(<;K><6(

KA:(8ID>(:7;(C>6BH:H>6(>E(78FH6@(C>6EHB;6C;(:78:(:7HD(HG9<>F;G;6:(HD(9>DDHKI;O(%>(CI8<HEN?(

=;(GAD:(6>:(>6IN(A6B;<D:86B(7>=(H:(HD(9>DDHKI;(E><(8(9;<D>6(:>(9>DD;DD(:7HD(C898CH:N?(H6(

><B;<(:>(8F>HB(E8IIH6@(H6:>(B;D98H<?(KA:(=;(8ID>(GAD:(A6B;<D:86B(:78:(=;(>A<D;IF;D(6>=(

9>DD;DD(:7HD(C898CH:NO

W6B;<D:86BH6@(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(9>DD;DDH6@(DAC7(8(C898CH:N(:>(HG9<>F;(>A<(8C:H>6D(

<A6D(A9(8@8H6D:(;9HD:;G>I>@HC8I(C>G9IHC8:H>6DO(#D(H6(:7;(C8D;(>E(:7;(G><8I(<;KH<:7?(

7AG86D(C866>:(78F;(^6>=I;B@;(>E(:7;(D:8:;(>E(:7;H<(=,15..".#,.&K;C8AD;(:7;D;(B>(6>:(

899;8<(H6(:HG;(86B(D98C;O(*6IN(:7;(;EE;C:D(>E(>6;MD(=,15..".#(8<;(9<;D;6:(H6(:7;(I;@8IH:N(

>E(86(8C:H>6(T:78:(HD?(=7;:7;<(H:(C>6E><GD(=H:7(:7;(G><8I(I8=Y?(>E(=7HC7(=;(C86(78F;(

^6>=I;B@;O(%7;<;(HD(6>(=8N(>E(^6>=H6@(E><(C;<:8H6?(:7;6?(=7;:7;<(8(9;<D>6(78D(

A6B;<@>6;(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(86B(8::8H6;B(8(@>>B(=,15..".#&86B(A6B;<@>6;(8(G><8I(<;KH<:7O(

L86:(;P9I8H6D?

0><(TK;(H:(=;II(6>:;BY(=;(C866>:(K8D;(:7HD(C>6EHB;6C;(A9>6(86(HGG;BH8:;(C>6DCH>AD6;DD(>E(:7;(HGGA:8KHIH:N(>E(>A<(BHD9>DH:H>6?(DH6C;(=;(C866>:(D;;(:7<>A@7(:>(:7;(I8::;<(KA:(GAD:(8:(K;D:(H6E;<(H:(E<>G(:7;(C>6D;ZA;6C;(:78:(H:(78D(>6(:7;(C>6BAC:(>E(>A<(IHE;OOOH6(:7;(8KD;6C;(>E(EA<:7;<(C>6BAC:(A9>6(=7HC7(:>(K8D;(>A<(cAB@G;6:(>E(>A<(G><8I(=><:7?(;F;6(:7>D;(;G9H<HC8I(9<>>ED(>E(:7;(@;6AH6;6;DD(>E(86(HG9<>F;B(BHD9>DH:H>6(8<;(;6:H<;IN(I8C^H6@?(86B(:7;(A68F>HB8KI;(C>6D;ZA;6C;(>E(8(<8:H>68I(;D:HG8:;(>E(>A<(G><8I(D:8:;(HD(8(E;;IH6@(>E(7>9;I;DD6;DDOX]

X\ L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`U`[O(TROOO8II;H6(>76;(8II;D(+;<:<8A;6(fA(D;H6;<(;H6G8I(86@;6>GG;6;6(/;DH66A6@(=g<B;(^8AG(;H6;(4;78<<IHC7^;H:?(H6(B;<D;IK;6(E><:fAE87<;6?(Gm@IHC7(D;H6OS

X] L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`UjJO(TR1;66(T=8D(=>7I(fA(G;<^;6(HD:Y(=H<(^m66;6(BH;D;D(dA:<8A;6(6HC7:(8AE(;H6(A6GH::;IK8<;D(4;=AhD:;H6(B;<(W6F;<p6B;<IHC7^;H:(A6D;<;<(/;DH66A6@;6(@<g6B;6?(=;HI(=H<(BH;D;(6HC7:(BA<C7DC78A;6(^m66;6?(D>6B;<6(=H<(GgDD;6(8II;6E8IID(6A<(8AD(B;6(0>I@;6(B;<D;IK;6(HG(2;K;6D=86B;I(8AE(DH;(DC7IH;h;6OOOB8(c;6;(;G9H<HDC7;6(4;=;HD;(B;<(&C7:7;H:(B;<D;IK;6(@8<(G86@;I6?(H6B;G(^;H6(2;K;6D=86B;I(fA<(4;@<g6BA6@(B;D(W<:;HIDD9<AC7;D(A6D;<;D(G><8IHDC7;6();<:;D(G;7<(@;@;K;6(HD:?(A6B(%<>D:I>DH@^;H:OOOBH;(A6F;<G;HBIHC7;(0>I@;(F>6(B;<(F;<6g6E:H@;6(4;A<:;HIA6@(D;H6;D(DH::IHC7;6(dAD:86B;D(HD:OSY

Page 133: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

JQ_

)H:7>A:(:7HD(^6>=I;B@;?(7AG86D(<A6(H6:>(:7;(9<>KI;G(>E(86(H68KHIH:N(:>(HG9<>F;(:7;H<(

8C:H>6D(K;C8AD;(:7;N(B>(6>:(78F;(8(<;8D>6(:>(K;IH;F;(:78:(:7;N(8<;(C898KI;(>E(:7HD(^H6B(>E(

HG9<>F;G;6:O*$8:<HC^(0<H;<D>6(8<:HCAI8:;D(:7HD(9<>KI;G(8D(E>II>=D?(R*6;(C>6FH6C;B(>E(7HD(

>=6(B;;9(G><8I(C><<A9:H>6?(;F;6(T9;<789D(;D9;CH8IINY(HE(7;(<;C>@6Hf;D(:78:(C><<A9:H>6(HD(

7HD(>=6(E8AI:?(G8N(C>II89D;(H6:>(98<8INfH6@(G><8I(B;D98H<O(%7HD(B;D98H<(HD(;D9;CH8IIN(

IH^;IN(@HF;6(L86:MD(G><8I(<H@><HDGU(:7;<;(HD(6>:7H6@(:78:(C86(G8^;(H:(D>(:78:(>6;((+/(61&

>K;ND(:7;(G><8I(I8=?(DH6C;(>6;(78D((+9,(06&E8HI;BOSX_(-6(8(D:8:;(>E(DAC7(B;D98H<?(9A::H6@(

>A<D;IF;D(>6(:7;(98:7(:>(86(HG9<>F;G;6:(H6(>A<(8C:H>6D(HD(HG9>DDHKI;OX`

&F;6(=H:7>A:(:7;(8KHIH:N(:>(78F;(^6>=I;B@;(>E(>A<(=,15..".#?(L86:(B>;D(:7H6^(

:78:(=;(C86(CAI:HF8:;(8(C>6EHB;6C;(:78:(>A<(=,15..".#&78D(C786@;B(8E:;<(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6O(

L86:(:7H6^D(:78:(>A<(C786@;B(=,15..".#(H:D;IE(C86(9<>FHB;(AD(=H:7(:7;(D;;B(E><(:7HD(

C>6EHB;6C;?(:7>A@7(=;(C866>:(78F;(^6>=I;B@;(>E(H:OXj(#D(L86:(78D(6>:;B(H6(>:7;<(

98DD8@;D?(=7HI;(=;(C866>:(78F;(^6>=I;B@;(>E(>A<(=,15..".#?(=;(C86(I>>^(:>(;G9H<HC8I(

;FHB;6C;(:>(@;:(D>G;(8DDA<86C;(:78:(>A<(=,15..".#(78D(IH^;IN(K;;6(C786@;B(:>(8(@>>B(

>6;?(><(:>(@;:(=78:(L86:(78D(C8II;B(8(RG><8I(;D:HG8:;S(>E(>A<(IHF;DOX[*0><(H6D:86C;?(HE(=;(

X_ $8:<HC^('O(0<H;<D>6?(;9,,0!<&(.0&L.%$9!)!+!#6&5.&2(.%31&@!9(+&4$5+!1!)$6&T!8GK<HB@;U(!8GK<HB@;(W6HF;<DH:N($<;DD?(Qaa\YU(_JO

X` 3;;(2;DIH;(#O(,AII7>II86B?(R0<;;B>G(86B($<>FHB;6C;(H6(L86:MD(#CC>A6:(>E(';IH@H>6U(%7;($<>KI;G(>E(&P9H8:H>6?S(H6(2(.%31&4$5+!1!)$6&!7&8,+5#5!.&8,'!.150,9,0:&;BO($7HIH9(VO('>DDH(86B(,HC78;I()<;;6O(T-6BH8689>IHDU(-6BH868(W6HF;<DH:N($<;DD?(JXXJYU([](b([_O(R%7;(HG9><:(>E(:7HD(I8C^(>E(^6>=I;B@;(HD(:78:(;F;<N>6;(GAD:(899<>8C7(;F;<N(CH<CAGD:86C;(8D(HE(9<;D;6:;B(86;=(=H:7(:7;(9<>KI;G(>E(<;c;C:H6@(:7;(;FHI(G8PHG(H6(E8F><(>E(:7;(@>>B(G8PHGOOODH6C;(6>(>6;(^6>=D(=7;:7;<(:7;(@>>B(G8PHG(78D(K;;6(C7>D;6?(;8C7(GAD:(8C:(8D(HE(7;(><(D7;(78D(6>:(N;:(K;C>G;(@>>BS(T[_YO

Xj 3;;(L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`Uj`O(ROOO8D(<;@8<BD(C>GE><:?(DAC7(8(@>>B(BHD9>DH:H>6(8I<;8BN(K<H6@D(H:(=H:7(H:(T8D(C>GE><:(86B(7>9;?(6>:(8D(C;<:8H6:NY(:>(86N>6;(C>6DCH>AD(>E(H:(H6(7HGD;IEOS

X[ 3;;(L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`Uja6?(=7;<;(L86:(=<H:;D(R#6B(DH6C;(=;(C86(B<8=(H6E;<;6C;D(<;@8<BH6@(:7;(BHD9>DH:H>6(>6IN(>6(:7;(K8DHD(>E(8C:H>6D(T=7HC7(8<;(H:D(899;8<86C;DY?(E><(:7;(9A<9>D;(>E(8(kG><8Il(;D:HG8:;OOOS

Page 134: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

JQ`D;;(D>G;(HG9<>F;G;6:(H6(>A<(8C:H>6D?(<;I8:HF;(:>(7>=(=;(8C:;B(K;E><;(=;(G8B;(:7;(

=,15..".#&C7>HC;?(H6D>E8<(8D(:7;N(899;8<(:>(K;(G>:HF8:;B(KN(BA:N(T:7>A@7(=;(C86(6;F;<(

^6>=(E><(DA<;(HE(:7HD(HD(:7;(C8D;Y?(=;(C86(<;8D>68KIN(8DDAG;(:78:(D>G;(C786@;(78D(

>CCA<<;B(H6(>A<(=,15..".#O(L86:(=<H:;D?(R);(C86?(7>=;F;<?(EH6B(:7HD(C>6EHB;6C;?(=H:7>A:(

B;IHF;<H6@(>A<D;IF;D(:>(:7;(D=;;:6;DD(><(:7;(86PH;:N(>E(;6:7ADH8DG?(KN(C>G98<H6@(>A<(IHE;(

C>6BAC:(D>(E8<(9A<DA;B(=H:7(:7;(<;D>IA:H>6(=;(>6C;(;GK<8C;BOSXX(*6C;(=;(CAI:HF8:;(:7HD(

C>6EHB;6C;?(=;(8<;(8KI;(:>(=><^(>6(HG9<>FH6@(:7;(G><8I(=><:7(>E(>A<(8C:H>6D(K;C8AD;(=;(

78F;(C>6EHB;6C;(H6(:7;(D:8KHIH:N(>E(>A<(@>>B(=,15..".#?(;F;6(=7;6(=;(8<;(78FH6@(:<>AKI;(

9;<E><GH6@(G><8IIN(@>>B(8C:H>6D(C>6DHD:;6:INOJaa

( 4;C8AD;(8(9;<D>6(78D(;G9H<HC8I(;FHB;6C;(:78:(7HD(=,15..".#(IH^;IN(78D(K;;6(

C786@;B(:>(8(@>>B(>6;?(7;(6>=(78D(:7;(8KHIH:N(:>(;P9;C:(:78:(7;(78D(:7;(C898CH:N(:>(

HG9<>F;(7HD(8C:H>6D?(H6D>E8<(8D(:7;(9<;D;6C;(>E(8(@>>B(=,15..".#(8II>=D(E><(:7;(

9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(9;<E><GH6@(G><8IIN(@>>B(8C:H>6DO(L86:(=<H:;D?(Rk";l(C86(N;:(8ID>(

<;8D>68KIN(7>9;(:78:(H6(:7HD(IHE;(7;(=HII(6>(I>6@;<(E><D8^;(7HD(9<;D;6:(C>A<D;(KA:(=HII(

<8:7;<(9<;DD(H6(H:(=H:7(;F;<(@<;8:;<(C>A<8@;?(DH6C;(7HD(8BF86C;D?(9<>FHB;B(:78:(:7;H<(

9<H6CH9I;(HD(@>>B?(=HII(8I=8ND(H6C<;8D;(7HD(1%9,.#%$&E><(EA:A<;(>6;DOOOSJaJ(%7HD(C>6EHB;6C;?(

98H<;B(=H:7(86(8C:A8I(C786@;B(=,15..".#&86B(7;8<:?(=HII(8II>=(8(9;<D>6(:>(9;<D;F;<;(

:7<>A@7(86(HG9<>F;G;6:(H6(7;<(8C:H>6DO(%7AD?(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(78D(B>6;(=78:(L86:(78D(D8HB(

XX L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`U`[O

Jaa R%7;(@>>B(86B(9A<;(BHD9>DH:H>6(>E(=7HC7(=;(8<;(C>6DCH>AD(T86B(=7HC7(=;(C86(C8II(8(@>>B(D9H<H:(:78:(9<;DHB;D(>F;<(ADY(:7AD(C8<<H;D(C>6EHB;6C;(H6(H:D(>=6(9;<D;F;<86C;(86B(D:8KHIH:N?(:7>A@7(H6BH<;C:IN?(86B(HD(>A<(!>GE><:;<(T$8<8CI;:;Y(=7;6;F;<(>A<(I89D;D(G8^;(AD(86PH>AD(8K>A:(H:D(9;<D;F;<86C;S(TR1H;(@A:;(A6B(I8A:;<;(/;DH66A6@(TBH;(G86(;H6;6(@A:;6(A6D(<;@H;<;6B;6(/;HD:(6;66;6(^866Y?(B;<;6(G86(DHC7(K;=Ah:(HD:?(Eg7<:(8ID>(8AC7(B8D(dA:<8A;6(fA(H7<;<(4;78<<IHC7^;H:(A6B(0;D:H@^;H:?(>Kf=8<(6A<(GH::;IK8<?(K;H(DHC7?(A6B(HD:(B;<(%<mD:;<(T$<8^I;:Y?(=;66(A6D(A6D;<;(0;7I:<H::;(=;@;6(H7<;<(4;78<<IHC7^;H:(K;D><@:(G8C7;6OS(TL86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`UjJYO

JaJ L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`U`[O

Page 135: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

JQjH:(GAD:(B>U(9A:(8(9;<D>6(>6(:7;(98:7(:>(HG9<>F;G;6:(7;<(8C:H>6DO

%7;(&9HD:;G>I>@HC8I($<>KI;G(>E(W6B;<D:86BH6@(:7;($>DDHKHIH:N(>E(:7;(,><8I(';KH<:7

W9(:>(:7HD(9>H6:?(=;MF;(D;;6(:78:(:7;<;(HD(D:<>6@(:;P:A8I(;FHB;6C;(E><(A6B;<D:86BH6@(

:7;(=,15..".#&C7>HC;(86B(:7;(8CZAHDH:H>6(>E(:7;(C898CH:N(E><(86(HG9<>F;G;6:(H6(>A<(

8C:H>6D(8E:;<(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(8D(HG9<>F;G;6:D(:78:(C86(K;(DAEEHCH;6:IN(A6B;<D:>>B(8D(

9>DDHKI;(E><(7AG86D(:>(8CC>G9IHD7G&">=;F;<?(:7;D;(:=>(D:;9D(B>(6>:(N;:(C>G9I;:;(:7;(

>F;<C>GH6@(>E(<8BHC8I(;FHIO(#D(=;(G8N(<;C8II(E<>G(:7;(8K>F;(D;C:H>6D?(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(B>;D(

6>:(G;<;IN(;6:8HI(D;I;C:H6@(8(@>>B(=,15..".#G&-:(8ID>(;6:8HID(:7;(6;;B(:>(K;(<;K><6(H6:>(8(

6;=(G><8I(HB;6:H:NO(';C8II(E<>G(;8<IH;<(D;C:H>6D(:78:(>6;MD(H6EH6H:;(@AHI:(C86(>6IN(K;(

<;G>F;B(KN(8(G><8I(<;KH<:7?(><(:7;(D7;BBH6@(>E(>6;MD(>IB(G><8I(HB;6:H:N(8D(8(D8C<HEHC;(E><(

>6;MD(@AHI:(86B(:7;(:8^H6@(>6(>E(8(6;=(G><8I(HB;6:H:N(86B(:78:(:7HD(<;ZAH<;D(8(cABHCH8I(

F;<BHC:(:>(K;(G8B;(8K>A:(:7;(D:8:;(>E(>6;MD(=,15..".#&><(7;8<:OJaQ(-6B;;B?(H:(899;8<D(:78:(

:7;<;(;PHD:D(8(G8c><(D:AGKIH6@(KI>C^(:>(8(C>G9I;:;(^6>=I;B@;(>E(7>=(:7HD(G><8I(C786@;(

>CCA<DU(:7;(HG9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(;H:7;<(K;H6@(8KI;(:>(8C:(8D(:7;(cAB@;(>E(>A<(>=6(H6:;IIH@HKI;(

C78<8C:;<?(=7HC7(=;(C866>:(B>(BA;(:>(>A<(IHGH:;B(;G9H<HC8I(9;<D9;C:HF;?(><(>E(K;H6@(8KI;(

:>(78F;(^6>=I;B@;(>E(D>G;(>:7;<(K;H6@(:78:(C86(9I8N(:7HD(<>I;?(K;C8AD;(=;(C866>:(78F;(

^6>=I;B@;(>E(86(H6:;IIH@HKI;(K;H6@(:78:(=>AIB(K;(8KI;(:>(FH;=(>A<(=,15..".#O

#D(BHDCADD;B(8K>F;?(=;(C866>:(78F;(:7;><;:HC8I(^6>=I;B@;(>E(>A<(H6:;IIH@HKI;(

C78<8C:;<?Ja\(86B(:7HD(HD(=78:(L86:(G;86D(=7;6(7;(D8ND(:78:(=;(C866>:(=H9;(>A:(:7HD(B;K:(

JaQ 4;C8AD;(:7;(C7>HC;(:>(78F;(8(@>>B(><(;FHI(=,15..".#&6;C;DD8<HIN(I;8BD(:>(78FH6@(;H:7;<(8(@>>B(><(;FHI(7;8<:?(<;D9;C:HF;IN?(:7;(cAB@;(C>AIB(K;(D8HB(:>(;H:7;<(cAB@;(>6;MD(=,15..".#&><(>6;MD(7;8<:O(-6(E8C:?(L86:(D=H:C7;D(K;:=;;6(:7;D;(:=>(>Kc;C:D(=7;6(7;(:8I^D(8K>A:(:7HD(HDDA;(T8,+5#5!.:&`Uj](b(`Uj`YO(-(=HII(:7;<;E><;(AD;(:7;D;(:=>(=><BD(H6:;<C786@;8KIN(E><(:7;(9A<9>D;D(>E(:7HD(D;C:H>6O

Ja\ -(B>(6>:(H6:;6B(:>(CI8HG(:78:(=;(C86(6;F;<(^6>=(86N:7H6@(8K>A:(>A<D;IF;D(8D(H6:;IIH@HKI;(K;H6@DO();(C86(^6>=(:78:(=;(8<;(E<;;(G><8I(8@;6:D?(E><(;P8G9I;O(">=;F;<?(=7;6(=;(cAB@;(>A<D;IF;D(G><8IIN?(L86:(HD(CI;8<(:78:(=;(C86(>6IN(cAB@;(>A<(;G9H<HC8I(C78<8C:;<(K;C8AD;(=;(C866>:(^6>=(:7;(D:8:;(>E(>A<(H6:;IIH@HKI;(C78<8C:;<(=H:7(C;<:8H6:NO

Page 136: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

JQ[>A<D;IF;D?(;F;6(HE(=;(C86(<;G>F;(:7;(D>A<C;(>E(:7;(B;K:(>A<D;IF;D?(:7<>A@7(:7;(=,15..".#&

C7>HC;O(-E(=;(8<;(:>(cAB@;(>A<D;IF;D?(;F;6(8E:;<(:7;(=,15..".#&C7>HC;?(=;MB(cAB@;(

>A<D;IF;D(:>(K;(:7;(D8G;(G><8I(9;<D>6(K;C8AD;(=;(C86(>6IN(8DD;DD(>A<(G><8I(=><:7(>6(:7;(

K8DHD(>E(>A<(;G9H<HC8I(C78<8C:;<OJa](-E(=;(8<;(:>(K;(C>6DHB;<;B(:>(78F;(6;=(G><8I(

HB;6:H:H;D?(:7>D;(HB;6:H:H;D(GAD:(K;(C>66;C:;B(:>(>A<(C7>HC;(>E(=,15..".#?(><(>A<(

H6:;IIH@HKI;(C78<8C:;<?(K;C8AD;(:78:(HD(:7;(D>A<C;(>E(>A<(G><8I(C78<8C:;<OJa_(%7;(9<>KI;G(>E(

:7HD(<;KH<:7?(:7;6?(K;C>G;D(>A<(H68KHIH:N(:>(^6>=?(=H:7(C;<:8H6:N?(=7;:7;<(=;(78F;(:8^;6(

>6(8(6;=(C78<8C:;<(86B(:7AD(78F;(8(6;=(G><8I(HB;6:H:NO(#D(7AG86D?(=;(8<;(>6IN(8KI;(:>(

cAB@;(>A<D;IF;D(G><8IIN(K8D;B(A9>6(>A<(;G9H<HC8I(C78<8C:;<?(=7HC7(899;8<D(H6(:HG;(86B(

D98C;O(%7HD(^H6B(>E(C78<8C:;<?(7>=;F;<?(B>;D(6>:(C786@;(8E:;<(:7;(=,15..".#&C7>HC;Ja`(86B(

HD(6>:(:7;(K8DHD(A9>6(=7HC7(=;(cAB@;(8(9;<D>6MD(G><8I(HB;6:H:NOJaj

4;C8AD;(:7;(RcABHCH8I(F;<BHC:S(<;@8<BH6@(=7;:7;<(>6;(78D(D8C<HEHC;B(>6;MD(>IB(

HB;6:H:N(86B(:7AD(<;98HB(:7;(H6EH6H:;(B;K:(GAD:(K;(G8B;(KN(8(cAB@;(R=7>(^6>=D(:7;(7;8<:(

>E(:7;(8CCAD;B?SJa[(E><(:7HD(HD(:7;(>6IN(=8N(:>(^6>=(=7;:7;<(8(9;<D>6(78D(A6B;<@>6;(:7HD(

C786@;O(-E(>6;(78D(8(@>>B(7;8<:?(:7;6(D7;(78D(C7>D;6(8(@>>B(=,15..".#G&-E(>6;(78D(86(;FHI(

7;8<:?(:7;6(D7;(78D(6>:(N;:(G8B;(:7;(=,15..".#&C7>HC;O("AG86D?(IHGH:;B(KN(86(;G9H<HC8I(

9;<D9;C:HF;?(C866>:(;F;<(^6>=(=H:7(C;<:8H6:N(=7;:7;<(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(78D(>CCA<<;BO()7HI;(

=;(C86(^6>=(HE(=;(78F;(8::;G9:;B(:>(G8^;(:7;(=,15..".#&C7>HC;?(H6D>E8<(8D(=;(:<N(:>(

Ja] L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`Uj]O

Ja_ 3;;(#B8GD?(H6:<>BAC:H>6?(PFHHHO

Ja` 3;;()8I:;<(398<6?(RL86:MD(1>C:<H6;(>E(#:>6;G;6:(8D(8(%7;><N(>E(3AKc;C:HFH:N?S(H6(2(.%31&4$5+!1!)$6&!7&8,+5#5!.&8,'!.150,9,0:&;BO($7HIH9(VO('>DDH(86B(,HC78;I()<;;6O(T-6BH8689>IHDU(-6BH868(W6HF;<DH:N($<;DD?(JXXJYU(Ja_O(R-6B;;B?(H6(:;<GD(>E(7HD(;G9H<HC8I(C78<8C:;<?(7;(D:HII(HD(:7;(*IB(,86OS

Jaj L86:(=<H:;D(:78:(8(9;<D>6(C866>:(K;(cAB@;B(8D(78FH6@(8(6;=(HB;6:H:N(K8D;B(A9>6(R:7;(899;8<86C;D(>E(7HD(BHD9>DH:H>6?(kHO;Ol(>6(8C:H>6D(:78:(;H:7;<(BHF;<@;(E<>G(:7;(I8=(><(8@<;;(=H:7(H:S(T8,+5#5!.:&`Uj\YO

Ja[ L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`Uj\O

Page 137: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

JQXC>GGH:(>A<D;IF;D(:>(C7>>DH6@(G><8IIN(=><:7N(G8PHGD(E<>G(:78:(9>H6:(>6?(=;(C86(6;F;<(

K;(DA<;(=7;:7;<(:7HD(C>GGH:G;6:(78D(K;;6(DACC;DDEAI(H6(C786@H6@(>A<(7;8<:DOJaX(%7;(

<;KH<:7(<;ZAH<;D(86(H6:;IIH@HKI;(9;<D9;C:HF;?(><(:>(D;;(:7H6@D(8D(:7;N(8<;(H6(:7;GD;IF;D(

T<8:7;<(:786(7>=(:7;N(899;8<(H6(:HG;(86B(D98C;Y?(=7HC7(7AG86D(B>(6>:(78F;O(">=;F;<?(H6(

8BBH:H>6(:>(6>:(K;H6@(8KI;(:>(78F;(^6>=I;B@;(>E(>A<(>=6(=,15..".#,.?(=;(8ID>(C866>:(

78F;(^6>=I;B@;(>E(DAC7(86(H6:;IIH@HKI;(K;H6@(K;C8AD;(:7HD(D><:(>E(K;H6@?(=7>(HD(6>:(

DAKc;C:(:>(:HG;(86B(D98C;?(:7AD(=>AIB(6>:(899;8<(H6(:HG;(86B(D98C;O(%7;<;E><;?(=;(C866>:(

78F;(^6>=I;B@;(>E(7>=(H:(HD(9>DDHKI;(E><(AD(:>(K;(<;IH;F;B(>E(>A<(H6EH6H:;(@AHI:O

%7;<;(:7AD(;PHD:D(8(@89(K;:=;;6(>A<(<;8D>6(86B(>A<(A6B;<D:86BH6@(H6(<;@8<BD(:>(

:7;(G><8I(<;KH<:7O()7HI;(=;(^6>=(:78:(<;8D>6(C>GG86BD(:78:(=;(K;C>G;(G><8IIN(6;=?(

@>>B(9;>9I;?(=;(C866>:(78F;(^6>=I;B@;(>E(:78:(=7HC7(=>AIB(G8^;(EAIEHIIH6@(:7HD(

C>GG86B(9>DDHKI;O(4;C8AD;(=;(C866>:(@8H6(8(C>G9I;:;(A6B;<D:86BH6@(>E(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(

>E(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6?(=;(GAD:(I>>^(:>(D>G;:7H6@(>:7;<(:786(:7;><;:HC8I(^6>=I;B@;(:>(cAD:HEN(

>A<(7>9;(H6(:7HD(9>DDHKHIH:NO(3AC7(8(D>IA:H>6(=HII(H6F>IF;(8(@<;8:(B;8I(>E(;P9I868:H>6?(86B(

:7;<;E><;(-(=HII(:8^;(:7HD(A9(H6(:7;(<;G8H6B;<(>E(:7HD(C789:;<O

M.0,91%(.05.#&%$,&I!.05%5!.1&7!9&%$,&4!115*5+5%6&!7&%$,&@!9(+&8,*59%$[&L&@(%%,9&!7&N,+5,7

#D(=;(=HII(D;;?(H6(:7;(8KD;6C;(>E(^6>=I;B@;(>E(7>=(:7;(G><8I(<;KH<:7(HD(9>DDHKI;?(

<;8D>6(GAD:(9>DH:(D>G;(C>6BH:H>6(:78:(=HII(cAD:HEN(>A<(7>9;(H6(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(

>F;<C>GH6@(<8BHC8I(;FHIO(4N(CAI:HF8:H6@(8(G><8I(K;IH;E(=7;<;(=;(C866>:(@8H6(^6>=I;B@;?(

JaX -(IH^;6(:7HD(:>(:7;(9<>KI;G(>E(6;F;<(^6>=H6@(HE(>A<(98<:HCAI8<(8C:H>6D(8<;(G><8IIN(@>>B?(B;D9H:;(>A<(K;D:(;EE><:D(:>(9;<E><G(G><8IIN(@>>B(8C:H>6DO(-6(:7;D;(C8D;D?(;F;6(HE(=;(:7H6^(:78:(=;(8<;(8C:H6@(E<>G(BA:N?(=;(G8N(K;(B;C;HFH6@(>A<D;IF;D(8K>A:(=78:(>A<(<;8I(G>:HF8:H>6D(8<;?(><(=;(G8N(DHG9IN(6>:(78F;(8B;ZA8:;(8=8<;6;DD(>E(>A<(<;8I(G>:HF8:H>6DO()7HI;(=;(C86(>E:;6:HG;D(K;(E8H<IN(C>6EHB;6:(:78:(=;(78F;(><(78F;(6>:(8C:;B(G><8IIN(T><?(H6(:7HD(C8D;?(C>GGH:;B(>A<D;IF;D(:>(IHFH6@(8(G><8IIN(@>>B(IHE;Y?(L86:MD(:7;><N(>E(:7;(IHGH:D(>E(7AG86(^6>=I;B@;(<;D:<HC:(AD(E<>G(;F;<(D8NH6@(:78:(=;(^6>=(=H:7(C>G9I;:;(C;<:8H6:N(:7;(DACC;DD(><(E8HIA<;(>E(>A<(G><8I(8::;G9:DO

Page 138: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

J\aL86:(:7H6^D(:78:(=;(C86(D:HII(K;(cAD:HEH;B(T:7>A@7(6>:(;9HD:;G>I>@HC8IIN(cAD:HEH;BY(H6(

7>9H6@(E><(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(:>(>CCA<(H6(>A<(>=6(IHF;DO(#D(-(=HII(;P9I8H6(H6(=78:(E>II>=D?(

L86:(8<@A;D(:78:(DAC7(8(C>6BH:H>6(HD(:7;(;PHD:;6C;(>E(/>BMD(@<8C;?(><(8(D9;CHEHC(^H6B(>E(

BHFH6;(8DDHD:86C;O

#(';FH;=U(%7;(.;;B(E><(,><8I(4;IH;E(86B(">9;

#D(BHDCADD;B(8K>F;?(L86:(:7H6^D(:78:?(H6(:7;(8KD;6C;(>E(:7;><;:HC8I(^6>=I;B@;?(

7AG86D(GAD:(78F;(7>9;(:78:(:7;(>F;<C>GH6@(>E(;FHI(HD(9>DDHKI;?(><(:7;N(=HII(E8II(H6:>(

B;D98H<(86B(E8HI(:>(9;<D;F;<;(H6(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:O(4;E><;(9<>C;;BH6@?(H:(HD(6;C;DD8<N(:>(

H6F;D:H@8:;(=78:(;P8C:IN(L86:(G;86D(KN(:7HD(:;<G(R7>9;S(TF!77,.YO('>;(0<;GD:;B8I?(H6(7HD(

868INDHD(>E(L86:MD(:7;><N(>E(G><8I(E8H:7(86B(@<8C;?(B;DC<HK;D(L86:MD(AD;(>E(:7;(C>6C;9:(>E(

7>9;(8D(R86(;P9;C:86CN(>E(@>>B(=7;6(:7;(>A:C>G;(HD(T:7;><;:HC8IINY(A6C;<:8H6OSJJa(-6B;;B?(

E<>G(8II(=;(C86(@8:7;<(E<>G(:7;(8,+5#5!.:&:7HD(B>;D(D;;G(IH^;(86(8CCA<8:;(A6B;<D:86BH6@(

>E(:7HD(C>6C;9:O(L86:(9>H6:D(:>(:7;(6;;B(E><(7>9;(=7;6(=;(C866>:(78F;(:7;><;:HC8I(

^6>=I;B@;(>E(7>=(H:(HD(9>DDHKI;(E><(AD(:>(8C7H;F;(:7;(>A:C>G;(>E(G><8I(@>>B6;DDOJJJ(

#BBH:H>68IIN?(:7;(7>9;(:78:(7;(:8I^D(8K>A:(HD(8I=8ND(:7;(7>9;(:78:(=;(C86(K;C>G;(G><8IIN(

@>>BOJJQ(%7;(G><8I(7>9;(:78:(L86:(C8IID(E><(HD?(:7AD?(D>G;(D><:(>E(;P9;C:8:H>6(:78:(C;<:8H6(

8C:H>6D(=HII(G8^;(AD(G><8IIN(@>>B?(;F;6(:7>A@7(=;(C866>:(78F;(^6>=I;B@;(>E(7>=(:7HD(

C86(7899;6O

0<>G(:7HD?(=;(C86(@8:7;<(:78:(7AG86D(>6IN(<;8IIN(6;;B(7>9;(E><(G><8I(

HG9<>F;G;6:(H6(:7;(C8D;D(H6(=7HC7(=;(C866>:(K;(:7;><;:HC8IIN(C;<:8H6(>E(7>=(=;(C86(

JJa 0<;GD:;B8I?(RLH;<^;@88<BMD(B>AKI;(G>F;G;6:(>E(E8H:7?S(Qa\O

JJJ 0><(;P8G9I;D?(D;;(8,+5#5!.&`U][:&`U_Q?(86B(`U`[O(

JJQ 3;;(8K>F;(;P8G9I;D(T`U][?(`U_Q?(86B(`U`[YO

Page 139: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

J\JK;C>G;(G><8IIN(@>>BO(#D(-(78F;(8IIAB;B(:>(8K>F;?(:7;<;(HD(>6;(^H6B(>E(C786@;JJ\(

6;C;DD8<N(:>(>F;<C>GH6@(<8BHC8I(;FHI(:78:(=;(C866>:(;P9I8H6(=H:7(:7;><;:HC8I(C;<:8H6:NU(:7;(

G><8I(<;KH<:7(:78:(C>G9I;:;D(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6O(-6(:7HD(C8D;?(L86:(:7H6^D(:78:(=;(GAD:(

CAI:HF8:;(G><8I(E8H:7?(><(K;IH;E?*H6(><B;<(:>(K<HB@;(:7;(@89(K;:=;;6(<;8D>6(86B(

A6B;<D:86BH6@?(D>(:78:(=;(C86(8F>HB(B;D98H<(86B(G><8IIN(HG9<>F;O(%7;(=><B(:78:(L86:(

AD;D(:>(<;E;<(:>(:7;(C>6C;9:(>E(E8H:7(:7<>A@7>A:(:7HD(=<H:H6@D(HD(R=+("*,.G\&";(BHDCADD;D(

:7HD(:;<G(H6(;8<IH;<(I;C:A<;D(86B(=><^D?(=7;<;(7;(:8I^D(8K>A:(H:(8D(>6;(>E(:7<;;(

9<>9>DH:H>68I(8::H:AB;D?(8I>6@(=H:7(^6>=I;B@;(TS511,.R&86B(>9H6H>6(T@,5.".#RO(&8C7(>E(

:7;D;(8::H:AB;D(B;DC<HK;D(8(<86@;(>E(=8ND(:>(7>IB(8(C;<:8H6(9<>9>DH:H>6O(*9H6H>6(<;E;<D(:>(

7>IBH6@(8(9<>9>DH:H>6(:>(K;(:<A;(H6(8(<8:7;<(I>>D;(=8N?(H6(D9H:;(>E(8(I8C^(>E(D:<>6@(

;9HD:;G>I>@HC8I(cAD:HEHC8:H>6O(L6>=I;B@;(HD(8(EH<G(7>IBH6@(>E(8(9<>9>DH:H>6(:78:(78D(

D:<>6@(;9HD:;G>I>@HC8I(cAD:HEHC8:H>6O(4;IH;E?(>6(:7;(>:7;<(786B?(HD(8(GHP(>E(:7;D;(8::H:AB;DO(

-:(HD(86(8::H:AB;(:78:(=;(:8^;(:>=8<B(9<>9>DH:H>6D(:78:(8<;(EH<GIN(7;IB(KA:(6>:(D:<>6@IN(

;9HD:;G>I>@HC8IIN(cAD:HEH;BOJJ](%7HD(8::H:AB;(78D(K;;6(B;DC<HK;B(I;DD(E><G8IIN(8D(8(

DAKc;C:HF;(E;;IH6@(>E(C>6EHB;6C;(:78:(:7;(9<>9>DH:H>6(:78:(>6;(7>IBD(HD(:<A;OJJ_

,><8I(K;IH;E?(B;D9H:;(6>:(K;H6@(;9HD:;G>I>@HC8IIN(cAD:HEH;B?(HD(6;F;<:7;I;DD(6>:(

C>G9I;:;IN(A6cAD:HEH;BO(-6(:7;(C8D;(>E(G><8IH:N?(=;(C86(C>6DHB;<(8(K;IH;E(:>(K;(8(I;@H:HG8:;(

JJ\ %7;<;(HD?(>E(C>A<D;?(6>(=8N(:>(@8H6(:7;><;:HC8I(C;<:8H6:N(8K>A:(=7;:7;<(>A<(=,15..".#(78D(8C:A8IIN(C786@;B(8E:;<(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6O(4A:?(8D(-(78F;(BHDCADD;B(H6(:7HD(C789:;<?(L86:(:7H6^D(:78:(=;(C86(@8H6(;6>A@7(C;<:8H6:N(:7<>A@7(;G9H<HC8I(>KD;<F8:H>6(:>(C>6EHB;6:IN(D;:(>A:(>6(:7;(98:7(:>(HG9<>FH6@(>A<(98<:HCAI8<(8C:H>6DO(%7AD?(:7;><;:HC8I(C;<:8H6:N(6><(7>9;(8<;(6;C;DD8<N(E><(:7HD(C786@;O

JJ] %7HD(;P9I868:H>6(>E(:7;D;(8::H:AB;D(78D(K;;6(K><<>=;B(E<>G(28=<;6C;($8D:;<68C^?(R%7;(1;F;I>9G;6:(86B(3C>9;(>E(L86:H86(4;IH;EU(%7;("H@7;D:(/>>B?(:7;($<8C:HC8I($>D:AI8:;D?(86B(%7;(08C:(>E(';8D>6?S(2(.%]H%"05,.&JaQ(TQaJJYU(QXa(b(QXJO(*-6(:7;(EH<D:(I95%5J",:&L86:(8ID>(<;E;<D(:>(K;IH;E(8D(8(7>IBH6@(:>(K;(:<A;(T;B9/($+$(+%,.Y(:78:(HD(DAKc;C:HF;IN(KA:(6>:(>Kc;C:HF;IN(DAEEHCH;6:(T#[QQq4[_aYO

JJ_ 0<;GD:;B8I?(RLH;<^;@88<BMD(B>AKI;(G>F;G;6:(>E(E8H:7?S(Qa\O(#BBH:H>68IIN?(L86:(6>:;D(:78:(:7;(6;C;DD8<N(E8H:7(HD(6>:(8(E8H:7(R=7HC7(866>A6C;D(H:D;IE(:>(K;(8(C.!/+,0#,\&KA:(<8:7;<(HD(8(E8H:7(R=H:7(<;D9;C:(:>(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(:7HD(D>G;:7H6@S(T8,+5#5!.:&`U_QYO

Page 140: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

J\Q7>IBH6@o:>oK;o:<A;(T;B9/($+$(+%,.R&=7;6(H:(HD(6;C;DD8<N(:>(9<>FHB;(AD(=H:7(8(C>G9I;:;(

A6B;<D:86BH6@(>E(G><8IH:NO(,><;(D9;CHEHC8IIN?(:7;<;(8<;(C;<:8H6(8D9;C:D(>E(G><8IH:N(>E(

=7HC7(=;(C86(78F;(:7;><;:HC8I(^6>=I;B@;?(DAC7(8D(:7;(G><8I(I8=(86B(>A<(BA:N(:>(>K;N(

:7HD(I8=O(">=;F;<?(:7;<;(8<;(>:7;<(8D9;C:D(>E(G><8IH:N?(8D(=;(78F;(D;;6(8K>F;?(>E(=7HC7(

=;(C86(6;F;<(9>DDHKIN(78F;(:7;><;:HC8I(^6>=I;B@;O(-6(:7;D;(C8D;D?(K;IH;E(H6(8(9<>9>DH:H>6(

HD(8(I;@H:HG8:;(7>IBH6@o:>oK;o:<A;(K;C8AD;(H:(HD(9<8C:HC8IIN(6;C;DD8<N(:>(C>G9I;:;(>A<(

A6B;<D:86BH6@(>E(G><8IH:NO(-6(E8C:?(H6(:7;(:7H<B(I95%5J",:&L86:(B;EH6;D(=+("*,.(8D(R:<AD:(H6(

:7;(8::8H6G;6:(>E(86(8HG(:7;(9<>G>:H>6(>E(=7HC7(HD(8(BA:N(KA:(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(:7;(

<;8IHf8:H>6(>E(=7HC7(H:(HD(6>:(9>DDHKI;(E><(AD(:>(78F;(H6DH@7:(H6:>OOOSJJ`()7;6(BA:N(

C>GG86BD(8(C;<:8H6(8C:H>6?(DAC7(8D(:7;(>F;<C>GH6@(>E(<8BHC8I(;FHI?(KA:(<;8D>6(C866>:(

78F;(:7;><;:HC8I(H6DH@7:(H6:>(7>=(:78:(8C:H>6(HD(9>DDHKI;?(8(9;<D>6(HD(cAD:HEH;B(H6(

R9<;DA99>DH6@(H6(68:A<;(:7;(C>6BH:H>6D(K;EH::H6@(H:?S(><?(H6(>:7;<(=><BD?(H6(8DDAGH6@(R=78:(

HD(6;C;DD8<N(E><(H:D(>Kc;C:HF;(9>DDHKHIH:NOSJJj(%7AD?(=7HI;(=;(C866>:(78F;(>Kc;C:HF;IN(

DAEEHCH;6:(@<>A6BD(A9>6(=7HC7(:>(B;CI8<;(:7;(9<>9>DH:H>6(:78:(=;(7>IB(:>(K;(:<A;(TH6D>E8<(

8D(=;(C866>:(;9HD:;G>I>@HC8IIN(cAD:HEN(H:Y?(=;(B>(78F;(8(DAKc;C:HF;IN(DAEEHCH;6:(@<>A6B(

A9>6(=7HC7(:>(EH<GIN(7>IB(:7HD(9<>9>DH:H>6U(:7;(DAKc;C:HF;(6;;B(:>(;P9I8H6(:7;(>Kc;C:HF;(

9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(G><8IH:NO(L86:(B;DC<HK;D(7>IBH6@(8(9<>9>DH:H>6(H6(:7HD(=8N(:>(C>6D:H:A:;(

78FH6@(8(RG><8IS(KA:(6>:(8(RI>@HC8IS(C;<:8H6:N(K;C8AD;(H:(B;9;6BD(>6(DAKc;C:HF;?(<8:7;<(

:786(>Kc;C:HF;?(@<>A6BDOJJ[(-6(>:7;<(=><BD?(B;D9H:;(6>:(78FH6@(;9HD:;G>I>@HC8I(

JJ` L86:?(!$<'?(_U]jJO(-6(:7HD(D8G;(=><^?(L86:(B;DC<HK;D(RG8::;<D(>E(=+("*,.S&8D(R>Kc;C:D(:78:(GAD:(K;(C>6C;HF;B((&)95!95&H6(<;I8:H>6(:>(:7;(AD;(>E(9A<;(9<8C:HC;(<;8D>6(H6(8CC><B86C;(=H:7(BA:NOOOKA:(=7HC7(8<;(;PC;DDHF;(E><(H:D(:7;><;:HC8I(AD;OOOS(T_U]`XYO

JJj L86:?(!$<'?(_UJ]\6O(L86:(8ID>(:8I^D(8K>A:(G><8I(K;IH;E(H6(:7HD(=8N(H6(:7;(EH<D:(I95%5J",G&";<;?(L86:(=<H:;D(:78:(=;(8<;(cAD:HEH;B(H6(A:HIHfH6@(E8H:7(:>(EHII(H6(:7;(@89D(>E(^6>=I;B@;(=7;6(RH:(HD(8KD>IA:;IN(6;C;DD8<N(:78:(D>G;:7H6@(GAD:(7899;6?(68G;IN?(:78:(-(EAIEHII(:7;(G><8I(I8=(H6(8II(9>H6:DS(86B(=7;6(=;(C866>:(@8H6(:7;><;:HC8I(^6>=I;B@;(>E(7>=(:7HD(>A:C>G;(HD(9>DDHKI;O

JJ[ L86:?(!$'?(#[Q[q4[_`(b(#[\Jq4[_XO(L86:(E8G>ADIN(6>:;D(:78:?(H6(:7;(C8D;(>E(G><8IH:N?(7;(R78B(:>(B;6N(

Page 141: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

J\\cAD:HEHC8:H>6?(:7HD(K;IH;E(HD(D:HII(cAD:HEH;B(H6D>E8<(8D(=;(GAD:(EH<GIN(7>IB(C;<:8H6(

9<>9>DH:H>6D(:>(K;(:<A;(H6(><B;<(:>(EHII(H6(:7;(@89D(>E(>A<(:7;><;:HC8I(^6>=I;B@;O

%7HD(HD(H6B;;B(:7;(F;<N(<;8D>6(=7N(:7;(6;;B(E><(G><8I(K;IH;E(8<HD;D(H6(:7;(

8,+5#5!.G&#D(L86:(=<H:;D(H6(:7HD(=><^:(R';8D>6?(C>6DCH>AD(>E(H:D(HG9>:;6C;(:>(D8:HDEN(H:D(

G><8I(6;;BD?(;P:;6BD(H:D;IE(:>(;P:<8F8@86:(HB;8D(=7HC7(GH@7:(G8^;(A9(E><(:7HD(I8C^?(

:7>A@7(H:(HD(6>:(DAH:;B(:>(:7HD(;6I8<@;B(B>G8H6OSJJX(";<;?(L86:(HD(C>6DHB;<H6@(<;8D>6MD(

H68KHIH:N(:>(;P9I8H6(7>=(7AG86D(C86(>F;<C>G;(<8BHC8I(;FHIO(#I:7>A@7(:7;<;(8<;(9I8C;D(H6(

:7;(8,+5#5!.&H6(=7HC7(L86:(AD;D(:7;(:;<G(=+("*,.&H6(8(GAC7(G><;(C8DA8I(=8N?JQa(H:(HD(

CI;8<(:78:?(H6(:7HD(C8D;?(7;(HD(ADH6@(:7HD(:;<G(H6(:7;(D8G;(=8N(B;DC<HK;B(8K>F;O(";<;?(7;(

<;E;<D(:>(:7HD(6;C;DD8<N(K;IH;E(8D(8(R<;EI;C:HF;(E8H:7S(86B(BHD:H6@AHD7;D(:7HD(E<>G(8(

B>@G8:HC(E8H:7?(R=7HC7(866>A6C;D(H:D;IE(:>(K;(8(C.!/+,0#,GSJQJ(";(6>:;D(:78:(H:(HD(8(E8H:7(

R=H:7(<;D9;C:(:>(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>ES(86(HB;8(86B(:78:(<;8D>6(RC866>:(H6C><9><8:;S(:7;(

>Kc;C:D(>E(:7HD(HB;8(RH6:>(H:D(G8PHGD(>E(:7>A@7:(86B(8C:H>6OSJQQ

4N(CAI:HF8:H6@(8(G><8I(K;IH;E?(=;(C86(K;(cAD:HEH;B(H6(EH<GIN(7>IBH6@(8(9<>9>DH:H>6(

:>(K;(:<A;?(B;D9H:;(>A<(I8C^(>E(;9HD:;G>I>@HC8I(cAD:HEHC8:H>6O(%7HD(K;C>G;D(HG9><:86:(E><(

:7;(6;;B(:>(78F;(G><8I(7>9;(H6(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(>F;<C>GH6@(<8BHC8I(;FHIO(&F;6(H6(C8D;D(

H6(=7HC7(=;(C866>:(78F;(^6>=I;B@;(>E(7>=(H:(HD(9>DDHKI;(:>(>F;<C>G;(<8BHC8I(;FHI?(DAC7(

8D(H6(:7;(C8D;(>E(:7;(G><8I(<;KH<:7?(=7HC7(-(=HII(8BB<;DD(H6(:7;(6;P:(D;C:H>6?(=;(C86(K;(

^6>=I;B@;(H6(><B;<(:>(G8^;(<>>G(E><(E8H:7S(T4sssYO

JJX L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`U_QO

JQa 3;;($8D:;<68C^?(R%7;(1;F;I>9G;6:(86B(3C>9;(>E(L86:H86(4;IH;E?S(\aQ(86B(L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`UJ`]?(E><(;P8G9I;O

JQJ L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`U_QO

JQQ -KHBO

Page 142: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

J\]cAD:HEH;B(H6(7>9H6@(:78:(:7HD(>F;<C>GH6@(HD(H6B;;B(9>DDHKI;O(

#BH68(18FHB>FHC7(9<>FHB;D(8(7;I9EAI(B;DC<H9:H>6(>E(:7;(<;I8:H>6D7H9(K;:=;;6(E8H:7(

86B(7>9;(H6(7;<(=><^(R">=(:>(';8B(';IH@H>6(=H:7H6(:7;(2HGH:D(>E(';8D>6(#I>6;OSJQ\(

";<;?(D7;(=<H:;D?

%7HD(:7>A@7:(k:7;(>Kc;C:D(>E(:7;(HB;8D(>E(<;EI;C:HF;(E8H:7l(78D(:7;(9;CAIH8<(D:8:AD(:78:?(=7HI;(H:(C866>:(K;(:8^;6(H6:>(G><8I(G8PHGD(86B?(:7;<;E><;?(C866>:(B;:;<GH6;(:7;(=HII?(H:(78D(8(9;B8@>@HC8I(<>I;(H6(:78:(H:(G8N(D:<;6@:7;6(:7;(=HII(TS5++CB9Y(:>(;P;CA:;(:7;(G><8I(B;C<;;(KN(9<>FHBH6@(E><(H:(8(C>6C<;:;(FHDH>6(>E(:7;(EH68I(G><8I(;6B?(8(FHDH>6(>E(:7;(^H6@B>G(>E(/>BOOOk'l;EI;C:HF;(E8H:7OOOHD(8(:<AD:(:78:?(AI:HG8:;IN?(68:A<;(HD(C>6:<HF;B(:>(G8^;(9>DDHKI;(:7;(>6IN(>Kc;C:(=7HC7(HD(86(;6B(H6(H:D;IEU(HO(;O?(8(G><8I(K;H6@OOO)H:7(<;@8<B(:>(:7;(H6BHFHBA8I(H:(G;86D(:78:(8(G><8I(8@;6:(C86(7>9;(:>(K;C>G;(FH<:A>ADOJQ]

(%7HD(B;DC<H9:H>6(HD(7;I9EAI(H6D>E8<(8D(H:(7H@7IH@7:D(:78:(;F;6(:7>A@7(9<>9>DH:H>6D(:78:(=;(

G;<;IN(78F;(8(K;IH;E(H6(C866>:(7;I9(AD(:>(K;C>G;(G><8IIN(@>>B(KN(D;<FH6@(8D(:7;(

B;:;<GH6H6@(@<>A6B(>E(>A<(=HII?(:7;N(C86(8DDHD:(AD(KN(9<>FHBH6@(E><(AD(8(cAD:HEH;B?(

C>G9I;:;(9HC:A<;(>E(G><8IH:NO(%7HD(K;IH;E(:7AD(@HF;D(AD(8(cAD:HEH;B(@<>A6B(E><(>A<(G><8I(

7>9;(H6(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(>F;<C>GH6@(<8BHC8I(;FHI(86B(K;C>GH6@(G><8IIN(@>>BO

-6*:7;(D8G;(D;6D;(:78:(>A<(K;IH;E(HD(>6IN(cAD:HEH;B(86B(I;@H:HG8:;(HE(H:(8<HD;D(E<>G(86(

>Kc;C:HF;(6;;B(>E(<;8D>6?(>A<(G><8I(7>9;(K;C>G;D(cAD:HEH;B(86B(I;@H:HG8:;(=7;6(H:(HD(

@<>A6B;B(H6(:7HD(^H6B(>E(K;IH;EO();(C86(D;;(8(7H6:(>E(:7HD(<;I8:H>6D7H9(KN(I>>^H6@(:>(8(

98DD8@;(H6(=7HC7(L86:(98H<D(:>@;:7;<(E8H:7(86B(7>9;O(-6(:7;(8,+5#5!.:&7;(=<H:;D?(R-6(:7;(

)9('%5'(+&7(5%$&5.&%$51&H!.&!7&=!0&k:7;(G><8I(9<>:>:N9;lGGG:7;(7AG86(K;H6@(C86(:7AD(7>9;(

:>(K;C>G;(9I;8DH6@(:>(/>BOSJQ_(#D(=;(C86(D;;(E<>G(:7HD(D7><:(98DD8@;?(H:(HD(CI;8<(:78:(L86:(

JQ\ #BH68(18FHB>FHC7?(R">=(:>(';8B(';IH@H>6(=H:7H6(:7;(2HGH:D(>E(';8D>6(#I>6;?S(2(.%]H%"05,.&[_O(JO(TJXX]Y

JQ] 18FHB>FHC7?(R">=(:>(';8B(';IH@H>6(=H:7H6(:7;(2HGH:D(>E(';8D>6(#I>6;?S(_O

JQ_ L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`U`QO(TR-G(9<8^:HDC7;6(/I8AK;6(86(BH;D;6(3>76(/>::;D(TD>E;<6(;<(F><@;D:;II:(=H<B?(8ID(78K;(;<(BH;(G;6DC7IHC7;(.8:A<(86@;6>GG;6Y(^866(6A6(B;<(,;6DC7(7>EE;6?(/>::(=>7I@;EpIIH@(TB8BA<C7(8AC7(D;IH@Y(fA(=;<B;6OSY

Page 143: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

J\_:7H6^D(:78:(>A<(K;IH;ED(D>G;7>=(I;@H:HG8:;(>A<(G><8I(7>9;DO(-6(:7;(C8D;(>E(:7;(G><8I(

9<>:>:N9;?(8D(=;(78F;(D;;6(H6(9<;FH>AD(C789:;<D?(KN(K;IH;FH6@(H6(:7;(FH8KI;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(8(

G><8IIN(9;<E;C:(7AG86?(=;(C86(7>9;(:>(K;C>G;(IH^;(:7;(G><8I(9<>:>:N9;O*-E(8(9;<D>6(

EH<GIN(7>IBD(D>G;(9<>9>DH:H>6(:>(K;(:<A;?(DAC7(8D(8(C>6BH:H>6(:78:(G8^;D(H:(9>DDHKI;(E><(

7AG86D(:>(K;C>G;(G><8IIN(@>>B?(:7;6(7;(F;<N(68:A<8IIN(D7>AIB(78F;(86(;P9;C:8:H>6(:78:(

:78:(9<>9>DH:H>6(C86(H6B;;B(7899;6?(@HF;6(:7;(<H@7:(CH<CAGD:86C;DO

%7;('>I;(>E(,><8I(4;IH;E(H6(:7;(!8D;(>E(:7;(,><8I(';KH<:7

.>=(:78:(=;(78F;(D;;6(=78:(<>I;(G><8I(K;IH;E(C86(9I8N(@;6;<8IIN(H6(>A<(9A<DAH:(>E(

G><8I(@>>B6;DD?(=;(GAD:(I>>^(G><;(CI>D;IN(8:(7>=(L86:(:7H6^D(:78:(G><8I(K;IH;E(C86(EHII(

H6(:7;(@89D(H6(>A<(^6>=I;B@;(H6(:7;(C8D;(>E(:7;(G><8I(<;KH<:7(D9;CHEHC8IINO();(GAD:(

B;:;<GH6;(=78:(C>6BH:H>6(<;8D>6(C86(9>DH:(H6(><B;<(:>(cAD:HEN(>A<(7>9;(H6(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(

:7;(<;F>IA:H>6O(%78:(HD?(=78:(HB;8(C86(<;8D>6(9>DH:(:78:(=HII(8II>=(AD(:>(78F;(7>9;(H6(:7;(

9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(=78:?(E<>G(86(;G9H<HC8I(9;<D9;C:HF;?(899;8<D(HG9>DDHKI;n(#D(=;(78F;(D;;6(

;8<IH;<(H6(:7HD(C789:;<?(<;8D>6(GAD:(K;(8KI;(:>(;P9I8H6(:7;(C>6BH:H>6D(E><(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(

:7;(G><8I(<;KH<:7?(D>G;:7H6@(>E(=7HC7(H:(C866>:(78F;(:7;><;:HC8I(^6>=I;B@;O

%>(<;FH;=?(L86:(:7H6^D(:78:(=;(GAD:(A6B;<@>(8(G><8I(<;KH<:7(H6(><B;<(:>(K;(

<;IH;F;B(>E(:7;(H6EH6H:;(@AHI:(:78:(:7;(C7>HC;(:>(K;(<8BHC8IIN(;FHI(K<H6@D(=H:7(H:O(%7HD(@AHI:(HD(

>6IN(<;G>F;B(>6C;(=;(78F;(C7>D;6(8(@>>B(=,15..".#(86B?(8BBH:H>68IIN?(78F;(K;;6(

cAB@;B(:>(78F;(K;;6(<;IH;F;B(>E(>A<(H6EH6H:;(@AHI:O(">=;F;<?(=;(C866>:(78F;(8(C>G9I;:;(

A6B;<D:86BH6@(>E(7>=(:7HD(G><8I(<;KH<:7(HD(9>DDHKI;(K;C8AD;(=;(C866>:(78F;(8(:7;><;:HC8I(

^6>=I;B@;(;H:7;<(>E(>A<(C786@;B(=,15..".#(><(>E(86N(K;H6@(=7>(C86(78F;(^6>=I;B@;(>E(

>A<(C786@;B(=,15..".#O()H:7>A:(D>G;(K;H6@(:>(C>@6Hf;(>A<(C786@;?(=;(C866>:(K;(cAB@;B(

:>(78F;(K;;6(<;IH;F;B(>E(>A<(H6EH6H:;(@AHI:O(/HF;6(:7HD?(H6(><B;<(:>(;P9I8H6(7>=(8(cABHCH8I(

Page 144: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

J\`F;<BHC:(C86(K;(G8B;(8K>A:(8(9;<D>6MD(=,15..".#?(=;(GAD:(;H:7;<(9>DH:(8(C>6BH:H>6(:78:(

8II>=D(AD?(8D(7AG86D?(:>(FH;=(>A<(>=6(=,15..".#(T=7HC7?(KN(68:A<;(>E(K;H6@(7AG86?(HD(

HG9>DDHKI;Y(><(9>DH:(D>G;(>:7;<(K;H6@(=7>(C86(FH;=(>A<(=,15..".#,.&86B(:7AD(9I8N(:7;(

<>I;(>E(cAB@;O

-6(><B;<(:>(K<HB@;(:7;(@89(K;:=;;6(>A<(<;8D>6(86B(A6B;<D:86BH6@(H6(:7HD(C8D;?(L86:(

9>DH:D(:7;(HB;8(>E(/>BMD(@<8C;?(><(BHFH6;(8DDHD:86C;?JQ`(8D(8(C>6BH:H>6(E><(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(

:7;(G><8I(<;KH<:7O(L86:(B;EH6;D(@<8C;(8D(R8(DA9;<H><MD(B;CHDH>6(:>(@<86:(8(@>>B(E><(=7HC7(

:7;(DAK><BH68:;(78D(6>(G><;(:786(TG><8IY(<;C;9:HFH:NOSJQj(/><B>6(&O(,HC78ID>6?(V<O(

B;DC<HK;D(:7HD(HB;8(8D(R8(DA99I;G;6:(:78:(;68KI;D(AD(:>(C>G9I;:;(:7;(G><8I(:8D^(8DD>CH8:;B(

=H:7(:7;(B;G86B(:>(>F;<C>G;(<8BHC8I(;FHIOSJQ[(%7;(HB;8(>E(BHFH6;(8HB(HD(=78:(L86:(C8IID(8(

R98<;<@8S(:>(9A<;(<;8D>6O(-:(HD(6>:(D>G;:7H6@(>E(=7HC7(=;(C86(78F;(^6>=I;B@;?(KA:(H:(HD(

86(HB;8(=7HC7(7;I9D(:>(86D=;<(7>=(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(HD(9>DDHKI;?(D>G;:7H6@(=7HC7(<;8D>6(

C866>:(B>(=H:7>A:(DAC7(86(HB;8OJQX(,HC78ID>6(;P9I8H6D(:7;(;9HD:;G>I>@HC8I(D:8:AD(>E(:7HD(

HB;8(8D(E>II>=DU

);(C866>:(G8^;(^6>=I;B@;(CI8HGD(8K>A:(DAC7(:>9HCD(8D(@<8C;?(KA:(6;H:7;<(C86(=;(DHG9IN(BHDGHDD(DAC7(6>:H>6D(8D(G><8IIN(=><:7I;DD(><(A::;<IN(BHD9;6D8KI;OOO%7;(899;8I(:>(BHFH6;(8HB?(:7;6?(78D(<>A@7IN(:7;(D8G;(D:8:AD(8D(:7;(9>D:AI8:;D(>E(:7;(HGG><:8IH:N(>E(:7;(D>AI(86B(:7;(;PHD:;6C;(>E(/>BO(2H^;(:7;(9>D:AI8:;D?(BHFH6;(8DDHD:86C;(H6(>A<(G><8I(<;C>F;<N(HD(8(R6;C;DD8<N(7N9>:7;DHDS(:78:(C86(6;F;<(K;(86(>Kc;C:(>E(:7;><;:HC8I(^6>=I;B@;(KA:(GAD:(K;(H6C><9><8:;B(8D(86(H6BHD9;6D8KI;(E;8:A<;(>E(:7;(EAIINoB;DC<HK;B(G><8I(IHE;O(#D(I>6@(8D(=;(B>(6>:(8II>=(:7;(7>9;(E><(

JQ` R";<;?(:7;6?(HD(:78:(DA<9IAD(>F;<(:7;(G;<H:(E<>G(=><^D(E<>G(=7HC7(=;(E;I:(:7;(6;;B(;8<IH;<?(>6;(=7HC7(HD(HG9A:;B(:>(AD(*6&#9(',\&T8,+5#5!.:&`Uj_YO

JQj L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`Uj_6O(TRB;<('8:DC7IAh(8K;<(;H6;D(*K;<;6(fA<(&<:;HIA6@(;H6;D(/A:;6?(=>fA(B;<(W6:;<@;><B6;:;(6HC7:D(=;H:;<(8ID(BH;(TG><8IHDC7;Y(&G9Ep6@IHC7^;H:(78:OOOS

JQ[ ,HC78ID>6?(R,><8I(';@;6;<8:H>6(86B(1HFH6;(#HB(H6(L86:?S(Q`]O*#BBH:H>68IIN?(3:;97;6($8IGZAHD:(<;E;<D(:>(:7HD(8D(R:7;(;:7HC8IIN(;G9>=;<H6@(C>6C;9:H>6(>E(BHFH6;(@<8C;S(T_\_YO(3;;(RL86:tD(&:7HCD(>E(/<8C;U($;<D9;C:HF8I(3>IA:H>6D(:>(:7;(,><8I(1HEEHCAI:H;D(=H:7(1HFH6;(#DDHD:86C;?S(P$,&^!"9.(+&!7&8,+5#5!.(Xa(TQaJaYO

JQX 3;;(8,+5#5!.:&`U_Q(b(`U_\O

Page 145: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

J\jBHFH6;(8DDHD:86C;(:>(=;8^;6(>A<(>=6(G><8I(<;D>IF;?(DAC7(7>9;(HD(6>:(>6IN(I;@H:HG8:;?(H:(HD(EAIIN(<8:H>68I(8D(=;IIOJ\a

%7HD(9<>9>DH:H>6?(:78:(:7;<;(HD(8(/>B(=7>(=HII(@<86:(:7;(8DDHD:86C;(6;C;DD8<N(:>(C>G9I;:;(

:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(:>(:7>D;(=7>(8<;(=><:7N(>E(H:?(HD(>6;(:78:(=;(C86(EH<GIN(7>IB(;F;6(=H:7>A:(

;9HD:;G>I>@HC8I(cAD:HEHC8:H>6(K;C8AD;(H:(HD(6;C;DD8<N(:>(>A<(A6B;<D:86BH6@(>E(G><8IH:NO(

%7AD?(=;(8<;(cAD:HEH;B(H6(7>IBH6@(:7HD(9<>9>DH:H>6(:>(K;(:<A;?(><?(H6(>:7;<(=><BD?(K;IH;FH6@(

H6(H:O()H:7(:7HD(HB;8(>E(@<8C;?(=;(8<;(8KI;(:>(;P9I8H6(:7;(G><8I(<;KH<:7?(=H:7>A:(6;;BH6@(:>(

78F;(^6>=I;B@;(>E(7>=(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(HD(9>DDHKI;O(#D(,HC78ID>6(9>H6:D(>A:?(K;IH;E(H6(:7HD(

9<>9>DH:H>6?(D>(I>6@(8D(=;(B>(6>:(FH;=(H:(8D(D>G;:7H6@(:78:(:8^;D(8=8N(86N(>E(>A<(G><8I(

<;D9>6DHKHIH:N?(@HF;D(AD(8(I;@H:HG8:;?(cAD:HEH;B(@<>A6B(E><(>A<(G><8I(7>9;O

);(D:HII(GAD:(8BB<;DD?(:7>A@7?(7>=(8(K;IH;E(H6(:7;(HB;8(>E(/>BMD(@<8C;(C86(

C>G9I;:;(>A<(A6B;<D:86BH6@(>E(:7;(G><8I(<;KH<:7O(%78:(HD?(=78:(8<;(=;(9>DH:H6@(:78:(/>B(

B>;D(E><(AD(H6(:7;(<;KH<:7n(-6(D7><:?(=;(8<;(9>DH:H6@(86(;9HD:;G>I>@HC8I(DA99I;G;6:O(#D(=;(

78F;(BHDCADD;B(8K>F;?(7AG86D(C866>:(;P9I8H6(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(:7;(G><8I(<;KH<:7(K;C8AD;(

>E(>A<(IHGH:;B?(D;6DA>AD(H6:AH:H>6O(4;C8AD;(=;(C866>:(78F;(^6>=I;B@;(>E(:78:(=7HC7(B>;D(

6>:(899;8<(H6(:HG;(86B(D98C;(86B?(EA<:7;<?(K;C8AD;(=;(C866>:(78F;(^6>=I;B@;(>E(86N(

>:7;<(K;H6@(=7>(C86(78F;(DAC7(^6>=I;B@;?(=;(C866>:(78F;(^6>=I;B@;(>E(7>=(:7HD(G><8I(

<;KH<:7(;F;<(:8^;D(9I8C;O(%7;<;E><;?(=7;6(=;(D8N(:78:(=;(GAD:(9>DH:(/>BMD(@<8C;?(=;(8<;(

K;IH;FH6@(:78:(:7;<;(HD(86(H6:;IIH@HKI;(K;H6@?(/>B?(=7>(HD(8KI;(:>(FH;=(>A<(=,15..".#,.&

86B(G8^;(:7;(cABHCH8I(F;<BHC:(:78:(=;(8<;(<;IH;F;B(>E(>A<(H6EH6H:;(@AHI:(>6C;(=;(78F;(

C7>D;6(8(6;=?(@>>B(=,15..".#OJ\J

J\a ,HC78ID>6?(R,><8I(';@;6;<8:H>6(86B(1HFH6;(#HB(H6(L86:?S(Q``O

J\J R-6(:7;(EH<D:(!<H:HZA;?(L86:(;D:8KIHD7;B(:78:(<8:H>68I(K;H6@D(8<;(IHGH:;B(KN(:7;H<(9>DD;DDH>6(>E(8(G;<;(MD;6DA>AD(H6:AH:H>6M?(=7HC7(G;86:(T8G>6@(>:7;<(:7H6@DY(:78:(=;(C866>:(;P9;<H;6C;(:7H6@DoH6(:7;GD;IF;D(KA:(C86(>6IN(78F;(;P9;<H;6C;(:78:(HD(:7;G8:Hf;B(H6(:;<GD(>E(:7;(9A<;(H6:AH:H>6D(>E(D98C;(86B(:HG;O(/>B?(>6(:7;(>:7;<(786B?(HD(BHD:H6@AHD7;B(H6(98<:(KN(/>BMD(9>DD;DDH>6(>E(86(H6:;II;C:A8I(H6:AH:H>6O(/>B(B>;D(

Page 146: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

J\[-6B;;B?(:7HD(HD(:7;(=8N(:78:(L86:(:8I^D(8K>A:(:7;(<>I;(>E(/>B(H6(<;@8<BD(:>(:7;(

G><8I(<;KH<:7(H6(:7;(8,+5#5!.G*";(B;DC<HK;D(:7;(<>I;(>E(/>BMD(@<8C;(8D(:78:(>E(8(cAB@;O(R0><(

=78:(H6(>A<(;8<:7IN(IHE;(T86B(9;<789D(;F;6(H6(8II(EA:A<;(:HG;D(86B(H6(8II(=><IBDY(HD(8I=8ND(

>6IN(H6(G;<;(*,'!<5.#&T68G;IN?(>A<(K;H6@(8(7AG86(K;H6@(=;IIo9I;8DH6@(:>(/>BY(HD(

HG9A:;B(:>(AD(8D(HE(=;(8I<;8BN(9>DD;DD;B(H:(7;<;(H6(EAIIOSJ\Q(#D(BHDCADD;B(8K>F;?(:7HD(

98DD8@;(78D(:N9HC8IIN(K;;6(A6B;<D:>>B(8D(B;DC<HKH6@(8(@<8C;(:78:(DA99I;G;6:D(>A<(;EE><:D(

H6D>E8<(8D(H:(C>A6:D(9<>@<;DDH6@(:>=8<B(K;H6@(@>>B(8D(8C:A8IIN(K;H6@(@>>BO(">=;F;<?(

@HF;6(>A<(A6B;<D:86BH6@(>E(H6EH6H:;(@AHI:(8D(D>G;:7H6@(:78:(HD(8C:A8IIN(<;G>F;B(TKA:(

=H:7>A:(:7;(cAB@G;6:(:78:(=;(78F;(N;:(B>6;(D>Y(=7;6(=;(C7>>D;(8(@>>B(=,15..".#:&H:(HD(

CI;8<;<(:78:(:7HD(98DD8@;(G;<;IN(G;86D(:78:(/>B(D;;D(>A<(H6:;IIH@HKI;(C78<8C:;<?(<8:7;<(:786(

>A<(;G9H<HC8I(C78<8C:;<?(86B(G8^;D(:7;(cAB@G;6:(:78:(>A<(B;K:(78D(K;;6(;<8D;BO(/>B(HD(6>:(

C>A6:H6@(>A<(=><^(8D(D>G;:7H6@(:78:(H:(HD(6>:O('8:7;<?(7;(HD(FH;=H6@(>A<(7;8<:(86B(6>:H6@(

:78:(=;(8<;(RG><8IIN(86>:7;<(K;H6@S(T<!9(+51'$&,5.&(.0,9,9YOJ\\

%7;(>Kc;C:(>E(>A<(G><8I(K;IH;E?(H6(:7;(C8D;(>E(:7;(G><8I(<;KH<:7?(:7;6?(HD(:7;(HB;8(>E(

8(/>B(=7>(=HII(8HB(AD(H6(:7;(G><8I(<;KH<:7(H6D>E8<(8D(7;(C86(FH;=(>A<(G><8I(C786@;(E<>G(

86(H6:;IIH@HKI;(9;<D9;C:HF;?(=7HC7(=;(B>(6>:(78F;(8CC;DD(:>O(%7HD(8HB(HD(I;DD(>E(8(RB>H6@S(

86B(G><;(>E(8(R9;<C;HFH6@OS(#D(3:;97;6($8IGZAHD:(;P9I8H6D?(:7HD(^H6B(>E(E8H:7(HD(8(K;IH;E(

RH6(8(/>B(=7>(9;<C;HF;D(:7;(D98:H>:;G9><8I(B;:8HID(>E(7AG86(K;H6@D(IHF;D(8D(8(C>G9I;:;B(

=7>I;?(E<>G(8(M6>AG;68IM(9;<D9;C:HF;(A68F8HI8KI;(:>(7AG86(K;H6@DO 4N(C>6:<8D:?(=;(

;P9;<H;6C;(:7H6@DoH6o:7;GD;IF;D?(6>AG;68I(8D(>99>D;B(:>(97;6>G;68I(<;8IH:N(o(8(BHFH6;(8::<HKA:;(:78:(HD?(8D(H:(=;<;?(86(;9HD:;G>I>@HC8I(868I>@A;(:>(/>BMD(G><8I(>E(8(=HIIMOS(T,HC78ID>6?(R,><8I(';@;6;<8:H>6(86B(1HFH6;(#HB(H6(L86:?S(Q`[Y

J\Q L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`Uj_O(TR1;66(B8GH:(B8D?(=8D(K;H(A6D(HG(&<B;6I;K;6(TFH;II;HC7:(8AC7(H6(8II;6(^g6E:H@;6(d;H:;6(A6B(8II;6();I:;6Y(HGG;<(6A<(HG(KI>h;6();<B;6(HD:(T6pGIHC7(;H6(/>::(=>7I@;EpIIH@;<(,;6DC7(fA(D;H6Y?(A6D?(@I;HC7(8ID(>K(=H<(DC7>6(7H;<(HG(F>II;6(4;DH:f(B;DD;IK;6(=p<;6OOOSY

J\\ L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`Uj]O

Page 147: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

J\X7AG86(K;H6@D(8<;(IHGH:;B(:>(:7;(M97;6>G;68IM(9;<D9;C:HF;?(=7;<;KN(=;(9;<C;HF;(>6IN(

D9;CHEHC(B;;BD(86B(C7>HC;D(H6(HD>I8:H>6(E<>G(:7;(:>:8IH:N(:78:(G8^;D(A9(8(9;<D>6MD(G><8I(

IHE;OSJ\]()7;6(L86:(D:8:;D(:78:(=;(<;ZAH<;(8(K;IH;E(H6(/>BMD(@<8C;?(:7;6?(H:(HD(6>:(8(K;IH;E(H6(

8(/>B(=7>(H6:;<F;6;D(H6(>A<(G><8I(IHF;D(H6(DAC7(8(=8N(:78:(7;(DA99I;G;6:D(>A<(8C:HFH:H;D(

KA:(G;<;IN(:78:(7;(9;<C;HF;D(=78:(=;(C866>:O

-:(HD(HG9><:86:(:>(<;H:;<8:;(:78:(:7HD(^H6B(>E(@<8C;(B>;D(6>:(H6F>IF;(/>B(B>H6@(86N(

^H6B(>E(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:(E><(AD(:78:(=;(78F;(6>:(8C7H;F;B(>6(>A<(>=6O(/>B(G;<;IN(

FH;=D(:7;(=><^(:78:(=;(78F;(8I<;8BN(B>6;O(';C8II(:78:(:7;(=,15..".#&C7>HC;(HD(G;<;IN(:7;(

C>GGH:G;6:(:>(C7>>DH6@(G><8IIN(@>>B(G8PHGD(H6(:7;(EA:A<;O(.>:7H6@(8K>A:(:7;(

<;F>IA:H>6(<;ZAH<;D(:78:(=;(GAD:(8C:A8IIN(78F;(K;C>G;(G><8IIN(@>>B?(KA:(G;<;IN(I;@8IIN(

@>>BO(%7AD?(=7;6(L86:(D:8:;D(:78:(/>BMD(@<8C;(C>G9I;:;D(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(H6D>E8<(8D(H:(

D;<F;D(8D(86(;9HD:;G>I>@HC8I(8HB(TK;C8AD;(86(H6:;IIH@HKI;(K;H6@(C86(FH;=(AD(H6(8(=8N(:78:(

=;(C866>:(FH;=(>A<D;IF;DY?(7;(HD(6>:(D:8:H6@(:78:(/>B(HD(RC>A6:H6@S(AD(8D(G><8IIN(=><:7N(

=7;6(=;(8<;(6>:O(/>B(HD(G;<;IN(FH;=H6@(=78:(78D(8I<;8BN(7899;6;B(b(86B?(H6B;;B?(:7HD(

H6:;IIH@HKI;(K;H6@(HD(FH;=H6@(AD(8D(=;(8<;(b(8I<;8BN(G><8IIN(@>>B(H6D>E8<(8D(=;(78F;(

D;I;C:;B(8(@>>B(=,15..".#O(%7HD(C>6EADH>6(8<HD;D(E<>G(8(C>6EADH>6(<;@8<BH6@(=78:(:7;(

<;F>IA:H>6(;6:8HIDO(-:(B>;D(6>:(;6:8HI(7>IH6;DD?(=7HC7(=;(78F;(6>:(;8<6;B?(KA:(G;<;IN(8(

@>>B(EA6B8G;6:8I(G8PHG?(=7HC7(HD(8(C>GGH:G;6:(:>(8C:H6@(E<>G(G><8IIN(@>>B(G8PHGD(

H6(:7;(EA:A<;O

4N(7>IBH6@(8(K;IH;E(H6(/>BMD(@<8C;?(=;(C86(8F>HB(:7;(>KD:8CI;(>E(B;D98H<(:78:(

7AG86D(E8C;O(L86:(:7H6^D(:78:(:7HD(HB;8(@HF;D(AD(RH6C;6:HF;D(E><(<;D>IF;(86B(<;8IHf8:H>6SJ\_(

J\] $8IGZAHD:?(RL86:MD(&:7HCD(>E(/<8C;?S(_]O

J\_ L86:?(!$'?(#[J\q4[]JO

Page 148: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

J]aH6D>E8<(8D(H:(@HF;D(<;8IH:N(:>(:7;(G><8I(I8=(8D(8(C>GG86B(86B(@HF;D(AD(:7;(C>6EHB;6C;(H6(

:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(:78:(=;(<;ZAH<;(H6(><B;<(:>(6>:(E8II(H6:>(B;D98H<(86B(E8HI(:>(

G><8IIN(HG9<>F;OJ\`(-6(D7><:?(G><8I(K;IH;E(H6(:7;(HB;8(>E(BHFH6;(8HB(8II>=D(AD(:>(9;<D;F;<;(

=7;6(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:(K;C>G;D(BHEEHCAI:(K;C8AD;(=;(:<AD:(:78:(=;?(H6B;;B?(8<;(8KI;(:>(

K;C>G;(G><8IIN(@>>B?(:7>A@7(=;(C866>:(78F;(^6>=I;B@;(>E(:7HDOJ\j(#D(18FHB>FHC7(

<;GH6BD(AD?(R-6 8,+5#5!.(:7;(H6BHFHBA8I(C86(>F;<C>G;(98<8INfH6@(B>AK:D(C>6C;<6H6@(:7;(

9>DDHKHIH:N >E(G><8I(<;KH<:7(>6IN(=H:7(<;EI;C:HF;(E8H:7(H6(BHFH6;(8DDHD:86C;OSJ\[

#(K;IH;E(H6(@<8C;(78D(:7;(8BBH:H>68I(K;6;EH:(>E(H6E><GH6@(AD(8K>A:(=78:(=;(GAD:(B>(

H6(><B;<(:>(HG9<>F;?(H6D>E8<(8D(H:(H6E><GD(AD(8K>A:(7>=(:>(K;C>G;(=><:7N(>E(:7HD(

8DDHD:86C;O(#D(6>:;B(8K>F;?(HE(=;(K;IH;F;(:78:(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(HD(9>DDHKI;?(=;(78F;(<;8D>6(

:>(;P9;C:(:78:(H:(=HII(7899;6O(">=;F;<?(:7;<;(HD(8(C8F;8:(:>(:7HD(D:8:;G;6:O();(C86(>6IN(

;P9;C:(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(H6(>A<(IHF;D(HE(=;(78F;(EH<D:(K;C>G;(=><:7N(>E(H:O(-6(><B;<(:>(K;C>G;(

=><:7N(>E(:7;(8DDHD:86C;(:78:(8(9;<D>6(6;;BD(H6(C>G9I;:H6@(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6?(7;(GAD:(EH<D:(

C7>>D;(8(@>>B(=,15..".#(86B(B>(8II(:78:(7;(C86(:>(G><8IIN(HG9<>F;OJ\X(%7AD?(H6(:7HD(D:8@;?(

H6(><B;<(:>(CAI:HF8:;(:7;(;P9;C:8:H>6(:78:(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(=HII(7899;6(H6(>6;MD(>=6(IHE;?(>6;(

GAD:(:H;(:7HD(7>9;(:>(:7;(G><8I(8C7H;F;G;6:D(:78:(7;(78D(G8B;(:7<>A@7(7HD(>=6(9>=;<DO(

%78:(HD?(:7HD(^H6B(>E(7>9;(HD(>6IN(9>DDHKI;(HE(8(9;<D>6(^6>=D(:78:(7;(78D(B>6;(=78:(HD(

J\` -6(:7;(8,+5#5!.:&L86:(6>:;D(:78:(R=H:7>A:((.6&C>6EHB;6C;(H6(:7;(BHD9>DH:H>6(>6C;(8CZAH<;B?(9;<D;F;<86C;(H6(H:(=>AIB(78<BIN(K;(9>DDHKI;S(T`U`[YO(";(@>;D(>6(:>(D8N(:78:(C>6EHB;6C;(HD(6;C;DD8<N(K;C8AD;(H:(@HF;D(8(9;<D>6(7>9;(:78:(7HD(C>A<D;(>E(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:(=HII(K;(DACC;DDEAI(86B(:7;(D:<;6@:7(:>(C>6:H6A;(>6(:7HD(98:7O(#D(BHDCADD;B(H6(:7;(9<;FH>AD(C789:;<?(:7HD(C>6EHB;6C;(HD(8::8H6;B?(H6(98<:?(:7<>A@7(8(E8H:7(:78:(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(HD(9>DDHKI;O()H:7>A:(:7HD(E8H:7?(:7;6?(>6;(C866>:(78F;(:7HD(C>6EHB;6C;(86B(=HII(6>:(DACC;DDEAIIN(9;<DHD:(H6(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:O

J\j 0<;GD:;B8I?(RLH;<^;@88<BMD(B>AKI;(G>F;G;6:(>E(E8H:7?S(Qa_O

J\[ 18FHB>FHC7?(R">=(:>(';8B(';IH@H>6(=H:7H6(:7;(2HGH:D(>E(';8D>6(#I>6;?S(JQO

J\X L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`U_QO

Page 149: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

J]J6;C;DD8<N(:>(K;C>G;(=><:7N(>E(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6O(*:7;<=HD;?(8(9;<D>6(78D(6>(<;8D>6(:>(7>9;(

E><(:7HDO(L86:(=<H:;D(:78:?(;F;6(:7>A@7(=;(C866>:(78F;(^6>=I;B@;(>E(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(:7;(

<;F>IA:H>6?(8(9;<D>6(RGAD:(K;(8KI;(:>($!),&:78:?(KN(:7;(;P;<:H>6(>E($51&!/.&9>=;<?(7;(=HII(

8::8H6(:>(:7;(<>8B(:78:(I;8BD(H6(:78:(BH<;C:H>6?(8D(H6BHC8:;B(:>(7HG(KN(8(EA6B8G;6:8IIN(

HG9<>F;B(BHD9>DH:H>6OSJ]a(%78:(HD?(HE(8(9;<D>6(^6>=D(:78:(7;(78D(G8B;(:7;(=,15..".#&

C7>HC;(86B(78D(B>6;(8II(:78:(HD(=H:7H6(7HD(>=6(9>=;<(:>(HG9<>F;(86B(HD(cAD:HEH;B(H6(

K;IH;FH6@(H6(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6?(7;(HD(8KI;(:>(;P9;C:(:78:(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(=HII(

K;(C>G9I;:;B(86B(:78:(7;(=HII(K;(G><8IIN(<;K><6O

%7;(HB;8(>E(@<8C;(H6E><GD(AD(8K>A:(=78:(=;(GAD:(B>(H6(><B;<(:>(8C7H;F;(:7;(

<;F>IA:H>6(86B(:7AD(8II>=D(AD(:>(K;IH;F;(:78:(HE(=;(B>(8II(:78:(=;(GAD:(:>(K;C>G;(=><:7N(

>E(H:?(=;(C86(8C7H;F;(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6O(4;C8AD;(=;(^6>=(=78:(=;(GAD:(B>(:>(K;C>G;(

=><:7N(>E(8DDHD:86C;(H6(C>G9I;:H6@(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6?(=;(=HII(K;(8KI;(:>(:<AD:(H6(H:D(

9>DDHKHIH:N?(>6C;(=;(78F;(B>6;(:7>D;(:7H6@DO(L86:(=<H:;D(:78:?

E<>G(:7;(B;BAC:H>6(8D(8BBAC;B(=;(D;;(:78:(H:(HD(9>DDHKI;(:>(:7H6^(>E(8KD>IA:H>6(E><(8(7AG86(K;H6@(KA<B;6;B(=H:7(@AHI:?(K;E><;(7;8F;6IN(cAD:HC;?(>6IN(>6(:7;(8DDAG9:H>6(>E(8(:>:8I(C786@;(>E(7;8<:i(:78:?(:7;<;E><;?(6>(;P9H8:H>6D?(K;(:7;N(>E(:7;(9;6H:;6:H8I(><(:7;(C;<;G>6H8I(D><:?(6>(H6F>C8:H>6D(><(;P8I:8:H>6D(T;F;6(:7>D;(>E(:7;(FHC8<H>AD(HB;8I(>E(/>BMD(3>6Y(C86(G8^;(A9(E><(:7;(I8C^(>E(:7HD(C786@;(>E(7;8<:(><?(HE(:7;(C786@;(HD(:7;<;?(H6(:7;(I;8D:(H6C<;8D;(H:D(F8IHBH:N(K;E><;(:7;(7;8F;6IN(:<HKA68Ii(E><(:78:(HB;8I(GAD:(K;(8B>9:;B(H6(>A<(BHD9>DH:H>6(K;E><;(H:(C86(D:86B(H6(9I8C;(>E(:7;(B;;BOJ]J

,><8I(K;IH;E(:78:(=;(C86(8C7H;F;(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(HD(8HB;B(KN(:7HD(HB;8(K;C8AD;(H:(H6E><GD(AD(

J]a L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`U_JO(TRGAh(;<(7>EE;6(^m66;6?(BA<C7(;H@;6;(L<8E:86=;6BA6@(fA(@;I86@;6i(=;HI(;<(;H6(@A:;<(,;6DC7(=;<B;6(D>II?(8K;<(6A<(68C7(B;Gc;6H@;6?(=8D(H7G(8ID(F>6(H7G(D;IKD:(@;:86(fA@;<;C76;:(=;<B;6(^866?(8ID(G><8IHDC7o@A:(fA(K;A<:;HI;6(HD:OSY

J]J L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`Uj`O(TR1;66(G86(DH;7:(8AD(B;<(@;B8C7:;6(1;BA^:H>6?(B8h(6A<(A6:;<(B;<(+><8ADD;:fA6@(B;<(@p6fIHC7;6(";<f;6Dp6B;<A6@(DHC7(Eg<(B;6(GH:(3C7AIB(K;I8D:;:;6(,;6DC7;6(F><(B;<(7HGGIHDC7;6(/;<;C7:H@^;H:(2>DD9<;C7A6@(B;6^;6(I8DD;?(GH:7H6(8II;(&P9H8:H>6;6?(DH;(Gm@;6(F>6(B;<(Kgh;6B;6(>B;<(E;H;<IHC7;6(#<:(D;H6?(8II;(#6<AEA6@;6(A6B(">C79<;HDA6@;6(TD;IKD:(BH;(B;D(D:;IIF;<:<;:;6B;6(-B;8ID(B;D(3>76;D(/>::;DY(B;6(,86@;I(B;<(;<D:;<;6(6HC7:(;<D;:f;6(>B;<?(=;66(BH;D;(B8(HD:?(H7<;(/gI:H@^;H:(F><(c;6;G(/;<HC7:;(6HC7:(HG(GH6B;D:;6(F;<G;7<;6(^m66;6i(B;66(BH;D;D(-B;8I(GAh(H6(A6D;<;(/;DH66A6@(8AE@;6>GG;6(D;H6?(AG(86(B;<(3:;II;(B;<(%8:(fA(@;I:;6OSY

Page 150: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

J]Q:78:(=;(C86(>6IN(@;:(:7;(8HB(:78:(=;(6;;B(:>(8C7H;F;(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(HE(=;(G8^;(:7;(

=,15..".#&C7>HC;(86B(8II(:7;(9<;98<8:H>6D(:78:(G8B;(H:(9>DDHKI;(:>(G8^;(:78:(C7>HC;O(-:(

@HF;D(AD(8(cAD:HEH;B(K8DHD(E><(7>9;O(-E(=;(^6>=(:78:(=;MF;(G8B;(:7HD(C7>HC;?(86B(=;(

K;IH;F;(H6(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(:7;(C>6BH:H>6D(E><(:7;(G><8I(<;KH<:7?(:7;6(=;(C86(7>9;(:78:(H:(

HD(9>DDHKI;(:78:(=;(=HII(K;(cAB@;B(:>(78F;(K;;6(G><8IIN(<;K><6OJ]Q

!1*>)7)".*?)&*#-.*6"9@*!&.4*#-4#*34"*A'1#)2@*/%$49*B%C.D

-:(HD(CI;8<(:78:(L86:(:7H6^D(:78:(@<8C;?(><(BHFH6;(8HB?(HD(86(>Kc;C:(>E(K;IH;E(:78:(C86(

cAD:HEN(>A<(G><8I(7>9;?(H6D>E8<(8D(H:(DA99IH;D(8(6;;B;B(C>6BH:H>6(E><(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(

>F;<C>GH6@(<8BHC8I(;FHI(86B(:7AD(K<HB@;D(:7;(@89(K;:=;;6(>A<(<;8D>6(86B(A6B;<D:86BH6@O(

%7;(ZA;D:H>6(:7;6(8<HD;D(8D(:>(=7;:7;<(BHFH6;(8HB(HD(:7;(>6IN(HB;8(:78:(<;8D>6(C86(9>DH:(:>(

9I8N(:7HD(<>I;O(%78:(HD?(HD(K;IH;E(H6(BHFH6;(8HB(K>:7(8(DAEEHCH;6:(86B(6;C;DD8<N(C>6BH:H>6(E><(

7AG86D(:>(>F;<C>G;(<8BHC8I(;FHIn(,><;(9>H6:;BIN?(8CC><BH6@(:>(L86:?(C86(>6IN(9;>9I;(

=7>(K;IH;F;(H6(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(BHFH6;(8HB(>F;<C>G;(<8BHC8I(;FHIn(-E(:7;(86D=;<(:>(:7HD(

ZA;D:H>6(HD(N;D?(:7;6(:7HD(=>AIB(<;D:<HC:(:7;(@<>A9(>E(7AG86D(=7>(8<;(C898KI;(>E(8::8H6H6@(

G><8I(@>>B6;DD(:>(:7>D;(=7>(K;IH;F;(H6(8(/>B(=7>(=HII(@<86:(AD(@<8C;(86B(:>(:7>D;(=7>(

8<;(8@6>D:HC(8K>A:(:7;(G8::;<(KA:(D:HII(K;IH;F;(H6(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(BHFH6;(8HBOJ]\(%7HD?(>E(

C>A<D;?(;PCIAB;D(9;>9I;(=7>(B>(6>:(K;IH;F;(H6(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(:7;(;PHD:;6C;(>E(/>B(8:(

8II(86B(:7>D;(=7>(B>(6>:(K;IH;F;(H6(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(:7;(;PHD:;6C;(>E(DAC7(8(/>B(=7>(

J]Q 18FHB>FHC7?(R">=(:>(';8B(';IH@H>6(=H:7H6(:7;(2HGH:D(>E(';8D>6(#I>6;?S(]O

J]\ ';C8II(:78:?(8D(8(<;EI;C:HF;(E8H:7?(:7HD(E8H:7(HD(G;<;IN(8(C>6EHB;6C;(H6(:7;()!115*5+5%6&>E(86(>Kc;C:O(%7HD(^H6B(>E(E8H:7?(:7;6?(C86(K;(7;IB(KN(:7>D;(9;>9I;(=7>(CI8HG(6>(^6>=I;B@;(>E(=7;:7;<(8(/>B(=7>(=>AIB(@<86:(:7HD(^H6B(>E(@<8C;(8C:A8IIN(;PHD:D(><(B>;D(6>:(;PHD:(KA:(B>(@<86:(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(DAC7(8(/>BO(-6:;<;D:H6@IN?(#II;6()>>B?(H6(8(BHDCADDH>6(<;@8<BH6@(86>:7;<(9I8C;(H6(L86:MD(;:7HCD(H6(=7HC7(7;(D;;GD(:>(C8II(E><(8(K;IH;E(H6(:7;(;PHD:;6C;(>E(/>B?(B;DC<HK;D(:7;(^H6B(>E(E8H:7(:78:(HD(6;C;DD8<N(E><(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:(8D(8::8H68KI;(KN(8@6>D:HCDO(%7HD(HD(K;C8AD;(:7;(^H6B(>E(E8H:7(:78:(=;(6;;B(H6(L86:MD(;:7HCD(B>;D(6>:(<;ZAH<;(:7;><;:HC8I(9<>>E(>E(/>BMD(;PHD:;6C;(KA:(G;<;IN(DAKc;C:HF;(><(G><8I(<;8D>6D(E><(K;IH;FH6@(:78:(";(GH@7:O(3;;(#II;6()>>B?(R';IH@H>6?(&:7HC8I(!>GGA6H:N?(86B(:7;(3:<A@@I;(#@8H6D:(&FHI?S*;(5%$&(.0&4$5+!1!)$6&JjO(]O(TQaaaYO

Page 151: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

J]\=>AIB(H6:;<F;6;(H6(>A<(IHF;D(H6(:7;(IHGH:;B(=8N(L86:(:7H6^D(HD(6;;B;B(:>(C>G9I;:;(:7;(

<;F>IA:H>6O(-6(><B;<(:>(B;:;<GH6;(HE(:7HD(HD(8C:A8IIN(8(C>6D;ZA;6C;(>E(L86:MD(:7;><N(>E(

G><8I(B;F;I>9G;6:?(=;(GAD:(8D^(=7;:7;<(:7;<;(HD(D>G;(>:7;<(HB;8(:78:(C86(B>(:7;(D8G;(

=><^(>E(BHFH6;(8HB(H6(9<>FHBH6@(:7;(C>6BH:H>6D(E><(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(>F;<C>GH6@(<8BHC8I(

;FHIO(%7HD(HD(:7;(ZA;D:H>6(:78:(-(=HII(:8^;(A9(H6(:7;(<;G8H6B;<(>E(:7HD(C789:;<O

1>;D(L86:(%7H6^(:78:(4;IH;E(H6(1HFH6;(#HB(HD(:7;(*6IN(3>IA:H>6n

%7;<;(HD(86(H6:;<;D:H6@(C8D;(:>(K;(G8B;(E><(:7;(8<@AG;6:(:78:(K;IH;E(H6(BHFH6;(8HB(HD(

6>:(;DD;6:H8I(:>(L86:MD(:7;><N(>E(<8BHC8I(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:O(%7HD(HD(6>:(:>(D8N(:78:(=;(

C866>:(AD;(:7;(HB;8(>E(BHFH6;(8HB(H6(><B;<(:>(EHII(H6(:7;(@89D(>E(>A<(^6>=I;B@;(>E(G><8IH:N(

86B(:7AD(cAD:HEN(>A<(7>9;(H6(<8BHC8I(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:O('8:7;<?(H:(HD(G;<;IN(:7;(8<@AG;6:(

:78:(L86:MD(;:7HCD(B>;D(6>:(D:8:;(><(HG9IN(:78:(:7;(HB;8(>E(BHFH6;(@<8C;(HD(A6HZA;(H6D>E8<(8D(

H:(HD(:7;(>6IN(HB;8(:78:(9<>FHB;D(:7;(C>6BH:H>6D(E><(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(:7;(C>G9I;:H>6(>E(:7;(

<;F>IA:H>6O(4;E><;(9<>C;;BH6@(:>(C>6DHB;<H6@(=7;:7;<(>:7;<(HB;8D(C>AIB(9I8N(:7HD(<>I;?(-(

=HII(C>6DHB;<(:7;(C8D;(E><(K;IH;FH6@(:78:(8(K;IH;E(H6(BHFH6;(8HB(HD(6>:(;DD;6:H8I(:>(>A<(G><8I(

B;F;I>9G;6:O

0H<D:?(BA:N(H:D;IE(B>;D(6>:(C>GG86B?(8D(>Kc;C:HF;IN(6;C;DD8<N?(:78:(8(9;<D>6(GAD:(

K;IH;F;(H6(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(/>BMD(@<8C;O*-6(E8C:?(8D(=;(78F;(D;;6?(L86:(G8^;D(CI;8<(:78:(

:7;(6;;B(:>(9>DH:(/>BMD(@<8C;(HD(>6IN(RDAKc;C:HF;IN(6;C;DD8<NOS()7HI;(L86:(B>;D(6>:(G8^;(

:7HD(CI8HG(H6(:7;(8,+5#5!.&H:D;IE?(7;(B>;D(:8I^(8K>A:(BHFH6;(8HB(H6(:7HD(=8N(H6(86>:7;<(>E(7HD(

=><^D?(:7;(D;C>6B(I95%5J",G&-6(:7HD(=><^?(L86:(HD(6>:(N;:(C>6C;<6;B(=H:7(:7;(BHFH6;(8HB(

:78:(;P9I8H6D(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(KA:(<8:7;<(=H:7(86>:7;<(^H6B(>E(BHFH6;(

EHIIH6@oH6(>E(^6>=I;B@;(b(:7;(HB;8(>E(:7;(;PHD:;6C;(>E(/>B(8D(:7;(7H@7;D:(H6B;9;6B;6:(

Page 152: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

J]]@>>BOJ]](4>:7(>E(:7;D;(HB;8D?(7>=;F;<?(8<HD;(E<>G(:7;(D8G;(6;;B(>E(<;8D>6(b(:7;(6;;B(:>(

;P9I8H6(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(K;C>GH6@(G><8IIN(@>>B(o(86B(9I8N(:7;(D8G;(<>I;(>E(EHIIH6@(H6(:7;(

@89D(H6(>A<(A6B;<D:86BH6@(>E(G><8IH:N?(:7AD(;P9I8H6H6@(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(K;C>GH6@(

G><8IIN(@>>B(86B(8II>=H6@(AD(:>(C>6:H6A;(:>(9<>@<;DD(:>=8<B(G><8I(@>>B6;DDOJ]_(%7AD?(

=78:(L86:(=<H:;D(8K>A:(:7;(6;C;DDH:N(>E(>6;(HB;8(D7>AIB(899IN(:>(:7;(>:7;<(HB;8O(

-6(:7;(I95%5J",&!7&49('%5'(+&8,(1!.:(L86:(D:8:;D(:78:(E8H:7(H6(:7;(;PHD:;6C;(>E(/>B(

RHD(6>:(C>GG86B;B(KA:(b(K;H6@(8(F>IA6:8<N(B;:;<GH68:H>6(>E(>A<(cAB@G;6:?(C>6BACHF;(:>(

:7;(G><8I(TC>GG86B;BY(9A<9>D;(86B(G><;>F;<(78<G>6HfH6@(=H:7(:7;(:7;><;:HC8I(6;;B(>E(

<;8D>6(:>(8DDAG;(:78:(;PHD:;6C;(86B(:>(G8^;(H:(:7;(K8DHD(>E(:7;(EA<:7;<(AD;(>E(<;8D>6OOOSJ]`(

08H:7(H6(/>B?(8CC><BH6@(:>(L86:?(HD(DAKc;C:HF;IN(b(6>:(>Kc;C:HF;IN(b(6;C;DD8<N(E><(:7;(

8::8H6G;6:(>E(G><8I(@>>B6;DDO(%7HD(HD(K;C8AD;?(=7HI;(H:(HD(86(>Kc;C:HF;(G><8I(C>GG86B(:>(

K;C>G;(G><8IIN(@>>B?(H:(HD(RG;<;IN(DAKc;C:HF;S(:78:(>A<(<;8D>6(C866>:(8::8H6(8(EAII(

A6B;<D:86BH6@(>E(:7HD(9>DDHKHIH:N(86B(:7AD(:7;(HB;8D(:78:(=;(AD;(:>(EHII(H6(:78:(

A6B;<D:86BH6@(8<;(8ID>(G;<;IN(DAKc;C:HF;IN(6;C;DD8<NOJ]j(L86:(B;DC<HK;D(:7;(AD;(>E(86(HB;8(

>E(9<8C:HC8I(<;8D>6(H6(:7HD(C8D;(8D(8(R1"*?,'%5Q,&C>6BH:H>6(>E(<;8D>6SJ][(86B(8(RF>IA6:8<N(

B;:;<GH68:H>6(>E(>A<(cAB@G;6:OSJ]X(4;C8AD;(>E(:7HD?(L86:(6>:;D(:78:(R%$,&/(6&H6(=7HC7(/,&

8<;(:>(:7H6^(k8K>A:(:7HD(9>DDHKHIH:Nl(78D(H6(H:(D>G;:7H6@(=H:7(<;D9;C:(:>(=7HC7(=;(78F;(8(

'$!5',?(DH6C;(:7;><;:HC8I(<;8D>6(B;CHB;D(6>:7H6@(=H:7(89>BHC:HC(C;<:8H6:N(8K>A:(H:?(86B(

J]] 3;;(!$<'?(_UJ\\O

J]_ -KHB:&_UJ]Q(b(J]\O

J]` -KHB?(_UJ]_(b(J]`O

J]j -KHB?(_UJ]_O

J][ -KHBO

J]X -KHB?(_UJ]`O

Page 153: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

J]_=H:7(<;D9;C:(:>(:7HD(:7;<;(C86(K;(8(G><8I(H6:;<;D:(=7HC7(:A<6D(:7;(DC8I;OSJ_a(-:(D;;GD?(:7;6?(

:78:(:7;(HB;8(:78:(=;(AD;(:>(EHII(H6(:7;(@89(H6(>A<(<;8D>6(<;@8<BH6@(G><8IH:N(GH@7:(6>:(

6;C;DD8<HIN(K;(:7;(>6;D(:78:(L86:(I8ND(>A:(E><(ADO

#BBH:H>68IIN?(=H:7H6(:7;(8,+5#5!.:&=7HI;(L86:(B>;D(8DD;<:(:78:(:7;(HB;8(>E(BHFH6;(

8HB(C86(K;(AD;B(:>(@<>A6B(>A<(G><8I(7>9;?(7;(8IG>D:(6;F;<(;P9IHCH:IN(<AI;D(>A:(:7;(

9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(9>DH:H6@(8(BHEE;<;6:(HB;8(:78:(C86(B>(:7;(D8G;(=><^O(4;C8AD;(=;(C866>:(78F;(

^6>=I;B@;(>E(7>=(7AG86D(C>AIB(>F;<C>G;(<8BHC8I(;FHI(:7<>A@7(:7;H<(>=6(9>=;<D(8I>6;?(

L86:(R@<86:D(:78:S(7AG86D(G8N(6;;B(DA9;<68:A<8I(8DDHD:86C;?(H6(:7;(E><G(>E(:7;(@<8C;(>E(

/>B?(H6(8C7H;FH6@(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6OJ_J(.>:;(:78:(7;(B>;D(6>:(D:8:;(:78:(G><8IH:N(6;C;DD8<HIN(

<;ZAH<;D(:7;(HB;8(>E(DA9;<68:A<8I(8DDHD:86C;(KA:(>6IN(:78:(7AG86D(GAD:(K;(8KI;(:>(

>F;<C>G;(:7;H<(;FHI(EA6B8G;6:8I(G8PHGD?(;F;6(:7>A@7(=;(C86(6>:(A6B;<D:86B(7>=(:7;N(

8<;(C898KI;(>E(H:(>6(:7;H<(>=6OJ_Q(";(<;D>IF;D(:7HD(9<>KI;G(KN(#9(.%5.#&%$(%(DA9;<68:A<8I(

7;I9(HD(6;C;DD8<N(86B(D:8:H6@(:78:?(HE(H:(HD(6;C;DD8<N?(7AG86D(GAD:(B>(8II(:7;N(C86(:>(

HG9<>F;(G><8IIN(86B(:7;6(GAD:(8CC;9:(:7HD(7;I9(KN(H6C><9><8:H6@(H:(H6:>(:7;H<(G8PHGDO(-:(

D;;GD?(:7;6?(:>(K;(8(9>:;6:H8I(D>IA:H>6(:>(:7HD(^6>=I;B@;(9<>KI;G(KA:(9>DDHKIN(6>:(:7;(

>6IN(D>IA:H>6O(-:(HD(8(<>I;(:78:(/>BMD(@<8C;(C86(9I8N(86B(>6;(:78:(7;I9D(L86:(:>(D>IF;(:7HD(

9<>KI;G(KA:(6>:(>6;(:78:(/>BMD(@<8C;(GAD:(9I8NO

#D(=;(78F;(D;;6?(:7;(HB;8(>E(/>BMD(@<8C;(HD(:7;(HB;8(>E(86(;9HD:;G>I>@HC8I(8HB?(6>:(

86(8C:A8I(H6:;<F;6:H>6(:78:(DA99I;G;6:D(>A<(8C:H>6DO(%78:(HD?(:7;(HB;8(>E(BHFH6;(8HB(HD(6>:(8(

J_a -KHB?(_UJ]_O

J_J L86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`U]]O

J_Q R%7HD(;FHI(HD(9(05'(+:&DH6C;(H:(C><<A9:D(:7;(@<>A6B(>E(8II(G8PHGDi(8D(68:A<8I(9<>9;6DH:N?(H:(HD(8ID>(6>:(:>(K;(,V%59)(%,0&:7<>A@7(7AG86(E><C;D?(E><(:7HD(C>AIB(>6IN(7899;6(:7<>A@7(@>>B(G8PHGD(b(D>G;:7H6@(:78:(C866>:(:8^;(9I8C;(HE(:7;(DAKc;C:HF;(DA9<;G;(@<>A6B(>E(8II(G8PHGD(HD(9<;DA99>D;B(:>(K;(C><<A9:;BO(5;:(H:(GAD:(K;(;ZA8IIN(K;(9>DDHKI;(:>(!Q,9'!<,&:7HD(;FHI?(E><(H:(HD(E>A6B(H6(:7;(7AG86(K;H6@(8D(8C:H6@(E<;;INS(TL86:?(8,+5#5!.:&`U\jYO

Page 154: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

J]`FHC8<H>AD(D>IA:H>6(:>(>A<(G><8I(E8HIH6@D(KA:(8(=8N(>E(8II>=H6@(AD(:>(A6B;<D:86B(:78:(=;(

C86(>F;<C>G;(<8BHC8I(;FHI(>6(>A<(>=6O(';C8II(:78:(L86:(B>;D(6>:(:7H6^(:78:(BHFH6;(8HB(HD(

6;C;DD8<N(K;C8AD;?(8D(<8BHC8IIN(;FHI(7AG86D?(=;(8<;(A68KI;(:>(8A:>6>G>ADIN(>F;<C>G;(

>A<(;FHI(D:8:;DOJ_\("AG86D(B>6M:(6;;B(:7;(HB;8(>E(BHFH6;(8HB(K;C8AD;(=;(6;;B(86(

H6:;IIH@HKI;(K;H6@(=7>(78D(DA9;<o7AG86(9>=;<D(:>(H6:;<F;6;(86B(D8F;(AD(E<>G(>A<(@AHI:O(

);(DHG9IN(6;;B(:7;(HB;8(>E(86(H6:;IIH@HKI;(9;<D9;C:HF;(H6(><B;<(:>(cAD:HEN(>A<(7>9;(H6(:7;(

9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6O();(C86?(H6(E8C:?(<;G>F;(:7;(D>A<C;(>E(>A<(H6EH6H:;(@AHI:(>6(

>A<(>=6O(%7HD(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:(=>AIB(>CCA<(=7;:7;<(><(6>:(=;(78F;(E8H:7(H6(/>BMD(

@<8C;O(-:(HD(G;<;IN(6;C;DD8<N(:>(;P9I8H6(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(K;H6@(cAB@;B(:>(78F;(C786@;B(H6(

:7;(6;C;DD8<N(=8NDO()7;6(L86:(D8ND(:78:(/>B(cAB@;D(AD(:>(K;(G><8IIN(@>>B?(6;=(9;>9I;?(

:7HD(HD(K;C8AD;(=;(8C:A8IIN(8<;(G><8IIN(@>>B?(6;=(9;>9I;O();(78F;(;8<6;B(:7HD(cAB@G;6:?(

:7>A@7(=;(8<;(A68KI;(:>(G8^;(H:(>A<D;IF;DO(';C8II(:78:(#B8GD(T86B(L86:Y(B;DC<HK;D(

K;C>GH6@(=><:7N(H6(:7;(;N;D(>E(8(BHFH6;(cAB@;(8D(K;C>GH6@(=><:7N(:>(:7;(H6:;IIH@HKI;(

cAB@;(=H:7H6(>A<D;IF;DO($>DH:H6@(:7;(HB;8(>E(/>BMD(@<8C;(@HF;D(AD(8(=8N(:>(A6B;<D:86B(

7>=(=;(C86(K;(cAB@;B(=><:7N(KN(>A<D;IF;D?(HE(=;(C>AIB(:8^;(>6(86(H6:;IIH@HKI;(

9;<D9;C:HF;O

%7AD?(:7;(HB;8(>E(BHFH6;(8HB?(<8:7;<(:786(:7;(HB;8(>E(/>B(;6:;<H6@(>A<(98:7(>E(G><8I(

HG9<>F;G;6:(86B(;8<6H6@(G><8I(@>>B6;DD(E><(AD?(HD(86(HB;8(:78:(K<HB@;D(:7;(@89(K;:=;;6(

>A<(<;8D>6(86B(>A<(A6B;<D:86BH6@O(4;C8AD;(<;8D>6(C866>:(9<>FHB;(>A<(A6B;<D:86BH6@(=H:7(

8(C>G9I;:;6;DD(:>(H:D(8CC>A6:(>E(G><8I(B;F;I>9G;6:?(H:(9>DH:D(86(HB;8?(DAC7(8D(:7;(HB;8(>E(

BHFH6;(@<8C;?(:>(K<HB@;(:7HD(@89O(%7;(HB;8?(:7;6?(D;<F;D(8D(8(@<>A6B(E><(;P9I868:H>6(E><(>A<(

J_\ %7HD(HD(8:(>BBD(=H:7(,HC78ID>6MD(CI8HG(:78:(<8BHC8I(;FHI(HD(RD>(C<H99IH6@(k>El(>A<(G><8I(8KHIH:H;D(:78:(H:(9A:D(H6(ZA;D:H>6(>A<(C898CH:N(:>(D8F;(>A<D;IF;D(:7<>A@7(>A<(>=6(8A:>6>G>AD(8C:H>6S(TR%7;(-6DC<A:8KHIH:N(>E(,><8I(&FHI(H6(L86:?S(Q_XYO

Page 155: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

J]jA6B;<D:86BH6@?J_](6>:(8D(R8(FHC8<H>AD(D8IF8:H>6S(E><(>A<(RG><8I(H6DAEEHCH;6CNOSJ__();(8<;(

EAIIN(8KI;(:>(B>(8II(>E(:7;(8C:H>6D(:78:(8II>=(AD(:>(>F;<C>G;(;FHI(8A:>6>G>ADIN?(H6D>E8<(8D(

=;(G8^;(>A<D;IF;D(=><:7N(>E(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(86B(C>GGH::;B(:>(G><8I(@>>B6;DD?(:7<>A@7(

>A<(=,15..".#&C7>HC;(86B(HG9<>F;G;6:D(G8B;(H6(:7;(9<;o<;F>IA:H>68<N(D:8@;O

#6H:8(18FHB>FHC7?(H6(E8C:?(@>;D(D>(E8<(8D(:>(D8N(:78:(K;IH;FH6@(H6(:7;(HB;8(>E(BHFH6;(

8HB(HD(G;<;IN(8(=8N(E><(AD(:>(K;IH;F;(:78:(68:A<;(HD(D;:(A9(H6(DAC7(8(=8N(:78:(=;(C86(

G><8IIN(DACC;;BO(-6B;;B?(:7HD(B>;D(D;;G(:>(K;(:7;(C8D;O(1HFH6;(@<8C;(HD(8(=8N(>E(

A6B;<D:86BH6@(:78:(:7;<;(HD(8(6;=(9;<D9;C:HF;(E<>G(=7HC7(=;(C86(FH;=(>A<(G><8I(

HG9<>F;G;6:DO(37;(=<H:;D?

';C8IIH6@(L86:MD(899;8I(:>(E8H:7(H6(BHFH6;(C>>9;<8:H>6(H6&8,+5#5!.: =;(<;8IHf;(:78:(8II(:78:(<;EI;C:HF;(E8H:7(8II>=D(AD(HD(:>(K;IH;F;?(=7;6(=;(=><<N(8K>A: :7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(>A<(;F;<(@8H6H6@(8(G><8I(BHD9>DH:H>6?(:78:(>A<(68:A<;(G8^;D(>A< G><8I(<;KH<:7(9>DDHKI;OOO0<>G(8(<;EI;C:HF; FH;=9>H6:(=;(C86(D;;(:78:(G><8I(@AHI:(:<H@@;<D(<;G><D;(=7HC7(<;DAI:D(H6(>A<(D:<HFH6@ E><(8(6;=(7;8<:O();(C>G;(:>(D;;(DH6(6>:(8D(86(;:;<68IIN(B8G6H6@(E8HIA<;(KA:(8D(:7; =><^(>E(:7;(CA66H6@(>E(<;8D>6(H6(>A<(>=6(68:A<;i(=;(;P9;<H;6C;(:7HD(8=8<;6;DD(8D 8(BHFH6;(E><@HF;6;DD(:78:(HD(<8:H>68IIN(cAD:HEH;BO(0><@HF;6;DD(HD(6>(I>6@;<(86(8<KH:<8<N H6BAI@;6C;?(KA:(86(8C^6>=I;B@G;6:(:78:(G><8I(<;E><G(I;8BD(:>(8(K;::;<(IHE;(86B(:> :7;(<;8IHf8:H>6(>E(:7;(^H6@B>GOJ_`

-6(D7><:?(=7;6(<;8D>6(9>DH:D(:7;(HB;8(>E(BHFH6;(8HB?(H:(HD(AD;EAI(K;C8AD;?(KN(:<AD:H6@(:78:(

:7;<;(HD(86(H6:;IIH@HKI;(FH;=9>H6:(E<>G(=7HC7(>A<(G><8I(IHF;D(C86(K;(FH;=;B?(=;(EH6B(:78:(

=;?(H6(E8C:?(8<;(C898KI;(>E(>F;<C>GH6@(<8BHC8I(;FHIO();(>6IN(:7>A@7:(:78:(=;(=;<;(6>:(8KI;(

:>(B>(D>(K;C8AD;(>E(:7;(IHGH:8:H>6D(>E(>A<(;G9H<HC8I(9;<D9;C:HF;O(4;C8AD;(=;(C>AIB(6>:(

78F;(^6>=I;B@;(>E(>A<(C786@;B(=,15..".#,.?(=;(C>AIB(6>:(A6B;<D:86B(7>=(=;(C>AIB(

J_] VO!O(2AH^?(R%7;(#GKH@AH:N(>E(L86:H86(08H:7?S(H'!%%51$&^!"9.(+&!7&P$,!+!#6&\`O(\O(T#A@AD:?(JX[\YU(\]]

J__ 3;;(18FHB>FHC7?(R">=(:>(';8B(';IH@H>6(=H:7H6(:7;(2HGH:D(>E(';8D>6(#I>6;?S(_O

J_` 18FHB>FHC7?(R">=(:>(';8B(';IH@H>6(=H:7H6(:7;(2HGH:D(>E(';8D>6(#I>6;?S(JQO(18FHB>FHC7(AD;D(:7;(I86@A8@;(>E(BHFH6;(E><@HF;6;DD(:78:(-(78F;(8<@A;B(8@8H6D:(ADH6@(8K>F;O(1;D9H:;(:7HD?(7;<(9>H6:(<;G8H6D(899IHC8KI;(;F;6(:>(8(<;8BH6@(:78:(:8^;D(BHFH6;(8HB(:>(K;(86(H6:;IIH@HKI;(cAB@G;6:(<8:7;<(:786(86(8C:(>E(FHC8<H>AD(D8IF8:H>6O

Page 156: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

J][>F;<C>G;(>A<(G><8I(@AHI:?(><(K;(G><8IIN(<;K><6O(&F;6(=7;6(=;(C7>D;(8(6;=(=,15..".#:&

=;(899;8<;B(A6C786@;B(:>(>A<D;IF;DO(*6C;(=;(:<AD:(:78:(H:(HD(9>DDHKI;(:>(FH;=(>A<D;IF;D(

E<>G(86>:7;<(9;<D9;C:HF;(:78:(HD(6>:(8F8HI8KI;(:>(AD(b(8D(/>B(=>AIB(HE(DAC7(8(/>B(;PHD:;B(

b(=;(8<;(8KI;(:>(A6B;<D:86B(7>=(<8BHC8I(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:(HD(9>DDHKI;(E><(ADO(#D(

18FHB>FHC7(D8ND?(=;(C86(D;;(:78:(>A<(HG9<>F;G;6:D?(DAC7(8D(:7;(=,15..".#&C7>HC;?(B>(

I;8B(:>(C786@;D(H6(>A<(H6:;IIH@HKI;(C78<8C:;<?(:7>A@7(:7HD(C78<8C:;<(<;G8H6D(7HBB;6(:>(ADO(

08H:7(H6(BHFH6;(8HB(:7AD(@HF;D(AD(8(D:><N(:>(:;II(8K>A:(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(G><8I(HG9<>F;G;6:(

KN(K<H6@H6@(:>(IH@7:(>A<(>=6(8A:>6>G>AD(9>=;<(:>(>F;<C>G;(<8BHC8I(;FHIOJ_j

%7;($>DDHKHIH:N(>E(#6>:7;<(-B;8(1>H6@(:7;(38G;()><^

-E(:7;(HB;8(>E(BHFH6;(8HB(HD(6>:(C>GG86B;B(KN(BA:N(86B(HE(:7;(HB;8(HD(>6IN(AD;EAI(

H6D>E8<(8D(H:(7;I9D(AD(:>(EHII(H6(:7;(@89(K;:=;;6(>A<(<;8D>6(86B(>A<(A6B;<D:86BH6@?(:7;<;(

D;;GD(:>(K;(8(C>G9;IIH6@(C8D;(:78:(H:(HD(8:(I;8D:(9>DDHKI;(:78:(D>G;(>:7;<(HB;8(C86(9I8N(:7;(

D8G;(<>I;O(*E(C>A<D;?(EH6BH6@(DAC7(86(HB;8(HD(6>(DG8II(:8D^O(-6B;;B?(H:(B>;D(D;;G(:78:(:7;(

HB;8(>E(BHFH6;(8HB(HD(9;<789D(:7;(G>D:(C>6F;6H;6:(D>IA:H>6O(1;D9H:;(:7HD?(:7;<;(B>;D(6>:(

D;;G(:>(K;(8(CI;8<(<;8D>6(=7N(D>G;(>:7;<(HB;8(GH@7:(6>:(K;(8KI;(:>(B>(:7HD(=><^O(%7HD(

9>:;6:H8I(C>6BH:H>6(GAD:(;P9I8H6(7>=(:7;(cABHCH8I(F;<BHC:(C86(K;(G8B;(<;@8<BH6@(>A<(

H6:;IIH@HKI;(C78<8C:;<O(#D(D:8:;B(GAC7(;8<IH;<(H6(:7HD(C789:;<?(:7HD(C>6BH:H>6(GAD:(;H:7;<(

;P9I8H6(7>=(7AG86D(C86(D;<F;(8D(:7HD(cAB@;(><(9>DH:(D>G;(>:7;<(K;H6@(=7>(C86(B>(:7HD(

=><^O(4;C8AD;(=;(8<;(8::;G9:H6@(:>(9>DH:(86(HB;8(>:7;<(:786(/>BMD(@<8C;?(-(=HII(E>CAD(

A9>6(=7;:7;<(=;(C86(9>DH:(D>G;(C>6BH:H>6(:78:(G8^;D(H:(9>DDHKI;(E><(7AG86D(:>(D;<F;(8D(8(

J_j(R-D(H:(9>DDHKI;(:>(EH6B(86(;P9;BH;6:(:>(7;I9(:7;(=HII(:>(<;8IHf;(H:D(8A:>6>GNn L86:MD(86D=;<(HD(:>(K;(E>A6B(H6&8,+5#5!.G("HD:><HC8I(<;IH@H>6(HD(8(6;PAD(>E(B>@G8 86B(<H:A8I(:78:(9<>FHB;D(:7;(<;ZAH<;B(;P9;BH;6:DO(-:(B>;D(D>(KN(9><:<8NH6@(86 ;DC78:>I>@HC8I(9HC:A<;(>E(8(=><IB(7HD:><NO(4N(:;IIH6@(:7;(D:><N(>E(:7;(=><IB(8D(C<;8:;B KN(8(BHFH6;(<AI;<?(<;IH@H>6(9<>FHB;D(:7;(G><8I(8@;6:(8(C>6C<;:;(HG8@;(K>:7(>E(:7; <;8IHf8:H>6(>E(:7;(;6BD(>E(G><8IH:N(86B(>E(:7;(<;8I(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(G><8I(8C:H>6OS(T18FHB>FHC7?(R">=(:>(';8B(';IH@H>6(=H:7H6(:7;(2HGH:D(>E(';8D>6(#I>6;?S(J\YO

Page 157: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

J]XcAB@;D(>E(H6:;IIH@HKI;(C78<8C:;<O

-:(HD(>KFH>AD(:78:(>6;(C>6BH:H>6(:78:(C866>:(EHII(H6(:7;(@89(H6(>A<(^6>=I;B@;(HD(:7;(

C>6BH:H>6(:78:(7AG86D(8<;(8KI;(:>(@8H6(^6>=I;B@;(>E(:7;H<(>=6(/;DH66A6@(><(:7;(

=,15..".#,.&>E(>:7;<DO(4N(68:A<;(>E(K;H6@(7AG86?(=;(78F;(8(IHGH:;B(;G9H<HC8I(

9;<D9;C:HF;O(4N(9>DH:H6@(:7HD(C>6BH:H>6?(=;(=>AIB(K;(9>DH:H6@(:78:(7AG86D(8<;(6>(I>6@;<(

7AG86DO(%7HD(C>6BH:H>6(=HII(>KFH>ADIN(6>:(=><^O(">=;F;<?(H:(B>;D(D;;G(9>DDHKI;(:78:(=;(

C86(9>DH:(D>G;(C>6BH:H>6(:78:(@HF;D(AD(D>G;:7H6@(DAEEHCH;6:IN(CI>D;(:>(^6>=I;B@;(>E(>A<(

>=6(=,15..".#O(';C8II(:78:(L86:(:7H6^D(:78:(=;(C86(@8H6(D>G;(HB;8(>E(>A<(>=6(C786@;B(

=,15..".#,.(KN(C>G98<H6@(>A<(8C:H>6D(K;E><;(:7;(=,15..".#&C7>HC;(:>(>A<(8C:H>6D(8E:;<(

:7;(=,15..".#&C7>HC;O*";(:7H6^D(:78:(:7HD(^H6B(>E(RG><8I(;D:HG8:;S(=>AIB(K;(;6>A@7(:>(

cAD:HEN(>A<(7>9;(:78:(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(78D(7899;6;B(H6(>A<(>=6(IHF;DO(-:(D;;GD?(:7;6?(:78:(KN(

c>H6H6@(H6:>(BHDCADDH>6D(=H:7(>:7;<D(<;@8<BH6@(C786@;D(:78:(:7;N(78F;(;P9;<H;6C;B(8E:;<(

G8^H6@(:7;(=,15..".#&C7>HC;?(=;(C86(K;(cAD:HEH;B(H6(K;IH;FH6@(H6(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(:7;(

<;F>IA:H>6(E><(7AG86D?(86B(:7AD(H6(7>9H6@(:78:(H:(C86(7899;6(H6(>A<(IHF;DOJ_[

0>II>=H6@(18FHB>FHC7MD(I;8B?(86>:7;<(=8N(>E(cAD:HENH6@(>A<(K;IH;E(H6(:7;(

9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(GH@7:(K;(9>DH:H6@(:78:(=;(8<;(K;H6@D(=7>(C86(C786@;(H6(K>:7(

;G9H<HC8I(86B(H6:;IIH@HKI;(=8ND?(:7>A@7(=;(C866>:(78F;(^6>=I;B@;(>E(:7>D;(H6:;IIH@HKI;(

C786@;D?(86B(:78:(68:A<;(HD(D;:(H6(A9(H6(DAC7(8(=8N(:78:(C;<:8H6(HG9<>F;G;6:D(=;(G8^;(H6(

:7;(;G9H<HC8I(=><IB(=HII(78F;(8(<;I8:H>6D7H9(=H:7(C786@;D(H6(>A<(H6:;IIH@HKI;(C78<8C:;<DOJ_X(

J_[ *E(C>A<D;?(:7;<;(HD(GAC7(G><;(:>(K;(D8HB(8K>A:(:7HD(HB;8?(:7>A@7(-(=HII(6>:(BHDCADD(H:(86N(EA<:7;<(H6(:7HD(98<:HCAI8<(=><^O(%7HD(D9;CAI8:H>6(9>H6:D(:>(:7;(9>:;6:H8IIN(HG9><:86:(<>I;(>E(7AG86(BHDC>A<D;(86B(C>GGA6H:N(H6(G><8I(B;F;I>9G;6:O(-6B;;B?(H6(<;C;6:(N;8<D?(D;F;<8I(:7H6^;<D(78F;(=<H::;6(8K>A:(:7;(HG9><:86:(<>I;(>E(C>GGA6H:N(H6(L86:MD(;:7HCD(86B(<;IH@H>6O(0><(;P8G9I;D?(D;;(L8:;(#O(,><86?(I!<<".%6&(.0&49!#9,11&5.&2(.%31&@!9(+&4$5+!1!)$6(86B(/O(0;IHCH:8D(,A6f;I?(2(.%31&I!.',)%5!.&!7&@!9(+&I$(9('%,9O

J_X -(=HII(9<>FHB;(8(GAC7(I>6@;<(BHDCADDH>6(>E(=78:(:7HD(R<;I8:H>6D7H9S(GH@7:(;6:8HI(H6(!789:;<(0>A<O

Page 158: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

J_a';C8II(:78:(:7;(HB;8(>E(BHFH6;(@<8C;(8II>=D(AD(:>(A6B;<D:86B(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(:7;(

<;F>IA:H>6(K;C8AD;(=;(C86(78F;(:<AD:(:78:?(:7>A@7(=;(C866>:(78F;(^6>=I;B@;(>E(>A<(

=,15..".#,.?(:7;<;(HD(D>G;(H6:;IIH@HKI;(9;<D9;C:HF;(E<>G(=7HC7(=;(H6B;;B(78F;(K;C>G;(

G><8IIN(6;=(9;>9I;O(%7HD(B>;D(6>:(D;;G(:>(<;ZAH<;(8(E8H:7(H6(BHFH6;(@<8C;(KA:(<8:7;<(

G;<;IN(8(K;IH;E(:78:(=;(78F;(K>:7(86(;G9H<HC8I(86B(H6:;IIH@HKI;(C78<8C:;<(86B(:78:?(=7;6(

=;(=><^(:>(G><8IIN(HG9<>F;?(=;(8<;(C786@H6@(E<>G(:7HD(H6:;IIH@HKI;(9;<D9;C:HF;(:78:(=;(

B>(6>:(78F;(8CC;DD(:>O(4;C8AD;(/>BMD(8DDHD:86C;(>6IN(9<>FHB;D(AD(=H:7(86(;9HD:;G>I>@HC8I(

8HB(H6D>E8<(8D(H:(@HF;D(AD(9;<D9;C:HF;(H6:>(>A<(H6:;IIH@HKI;(C78<8C:;<?(H:(D;;GD(9I8ADHKI;(:78:(

=;(C86(78F;(8(K;IH;E?(H6D:;8B?(H6(:7;(BA8I?(98<:H8IINo7HBB;6(68:A<;(>E(>A<(>=6(G><8I(

C78<8C:;<O()7HI;(:7HD(B>;D(6>:(@HF;(AD(^6>=I;B@;(>E(>A<(C786@;B(=,15..".#,.?(H:(=>AIB(

8:(I;8D:(cAD:HEN(>A<(K;IH;E(:78:(=;(8<;(C898KI;(>E(C786@H6@(H6(=8ND(:78:(9<>FHB;(:7;(

C>6BH:H>6D(E><(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(>F;<C>GH6@(<8BHC8I(;FHIO(

-6B;;B?(DAC7(8(K;IH;E(H6(:7;(8CC><B86C;(>E(68:A<;(=H:7(G><8I(9<>@<;DD(78D(

9<;C;B;6C;(H6(L86:MD(G><8I(97HI>D>97NO(-6(:7;(D;C>6B(I95%5J",:&L86:(I;8F;D(<>>G(E><(:7;(

9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(68:A<;(8CC><BH6@(=H:7(G><8I(C786@;(H6(8(DHGHI8<(=8NO(-6(:7HD(=><^?(L86:(HD(

C>6C;<6;B(=H:7(:7;(8998<;6:(HG9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(68:A<;(<;=8<BH6@(>A<(G><8I(@>>B6;DD(=H:7(

7899H6;DD(H6(;P8C:(9<>9><:H>6O(">=;F;<?(7;(D8ND(7;<;(:78:(:7HD(HG9>DDHKHIH:N(HD(RG;<;IN(

DAKc;C:HF;OS(";(=<H:;D?

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b(:78:(HD?(D;:(E><:7(DAEEHCH;6:IN(>6(>Kc;C:HF;(@<>A6BD(b(:7;(HG9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(H:(H6(8CC><B86C;(

Page 159: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

J_J=H:7(A6HF;<D8I(I8=D(>E(68:A<;OJ`a

%7;<;(HD(@>>B(<;8D>6(:>(K;IH;F;?(E><(:7;(<;8D>6D(-MF;(BHDCADD;B(8K>F;?(:78:(:7;(8998<;6:(

HG9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(>A<(G><8I(<;KH<:7(HD(8ID>(G;<;IN(8(DAKc;C:HF;(HG9>DDHKHIH:NO(#D(H6(:7;(

DH:A8:H>6(:78:(L86:(:8I^D(8K>A:(8K>F;?(=;(C>6C;HF;(:7;(G><8I(<;KH<:7(:>(K;(HG9>DDHKI;(

K;C8AD;(=;(>6IN(78F;(8CC;DD(:>(:7;(97;6>G;68I(=><IBO(*A<(<;8D>6(EH6BD(H:(HG9>DDHKI;(:>(

C>6C;HF;(7>=(=;(C>AIB(78F;(@8H6;B(8(6;=(G><8I(HB;6:H:N(K;C8AD;(=;(C86(>6IN(9;<C;HF;(

>A<(;G9H<HC8I(C78<8C:;<(86B(6>:(>A<(H6:;IIH@HKI;(C78<8C:;<O(4A:?(8D(H6(:7;(C8D;(8K>F;?(>A<(

<;8D>6(C866>:(9<>F;(>6(DAKc;C:HF;(@<>A6BD(:78:(H:(HD(6>:(9>DDHKI;(:78:(>A<(G><8I(68:A<;(HD(

D;:(A9(H6(DAC7(8(=8N(:78:(>A<(H6:;IIH@HKI;(C78<8C:;<(78D(H6B;;B(C786@;B?(;F;6(=7;6(=;(

C866>:(9;<C;HF;(:7HD(C786@;O(%7HD(G;<;IN(899;8<D(HG9>DDHKI;(K;C8AD;(>E(>A<(IHGH:;B(

7AG86(<8:H>68I(C898CH:H;DO(4N(9>DH:H6@?(H6(D9H:;(>E(>A<(I8C^(>E(^6>=I;B@;(>E(:7HD?(:78:(8(

C786@;(H6(>A<(H6:;IIH@HKI;(C78<8C:;<(HD(9>DDHKI;(BA;(:>(>A<(BA8I(68:A<;(8D(7AG86D(86B(:78:(

=;(=HII(A6B;<@>(:7HD(C786@;(HE(=;(G8^;(:7;(=,15..".#&C7>HC;?(=;(C86(cAD:HEN(>A<(7>9;(

:78:(>F;<C>GH6@(<8BHC8I(;FHI(HD(9>DDHKI;(E><(ADO

3%"(9'1)%"

#D(=;(78F;(BHDC>F;<;B(H6(:7HD(C789:;<?(L86:(B>;D(9<>FHB;(7HD(<;8B;<D(=H:7(8(=8N(

:>(;P9I8H6(:7;(9>DDHKHIH:N(>E(:7;(G><8I(<;KH<:7(86B(:7AD(8(=8N(:>(7>9;(:78:(:7;(>F;<C>GH6@(

>E(<8BHC8I(;FHI(HD(9>DDHKI;(E><(7AG86DO(4;IH;E(H6(BHFH6;(8HB(8II>=D(AD(:>(K<HB@;(:7;(@89(

K;:=;;6(<;8D>6(86B(A6B;<D:86BH6@(H6(DAC7(8(=8N(:78:(=;(C86(A6B;<D:86B?(B;D9H:;(>A<(

IHGH:8:H>6D(H6(^6>=I;B@;?(:7;(<;F>IA:H>6(8D(D>G;:7H6@(:78:(=;(C86(8C7H;F;O(.>=(:78:(

=;MF;(I8HB(>A:(6>:(>6IN(=78:(HG9<>F;G;6:D(8<;(6;C;DD8<N(H6(><B;<(:>(>F;<C>G;(<8BHC8I(

;FHI(KA:(8ID>(;D:8KIHD7;B(:78:(:7>D;(HG9<>F;G;6:D(8<;(G><8IIN(9>DDHKI;?(=;(C86(9<>C;;B(H6(

J`a L86:?(!$<'?(_UJ]_O

Page 160: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

J_Q:7;(6;P:(C789:;<(:>(B;:;<GH6H6@(=78:(9I8C;(:7HD(>F;<C>GH6@(78D(H6(L86:MD(>F;<8<C7H6@(

:7;><N(>E(G><8I(B;F;I>9G;6:O

Page 161: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

!"#$%&'()*+'

(%"&($,#!&(*)('#-.!#,(/*'#,(./$'*0&/&1%(.1(2#1%34(%"&*'5(*)(

/*'#,(-&0&,*$/&1%

!"#$%&'(#)%"

'67896:(;<=6:(8;>=<?@;@AB*C6D(A<B(C8DB<=896::E(F@@A(9<AD87@=@7(B<(C6?@(6(>:69@(

6D(6(78DB8A9B(DB6G@(8A(26AB3D(H<=;6:(BC@<=E(<H(;<=6:(7@?@:<>;@ABI(.A(BC@(D@9<A76=E(

:8B@=6BJ=@K(=67896:(;<=6:(8;>=<?@;@AB(C6D(F@@A(@8BC@=(<?@=:<<L@7(9<;>:@B@:E(6D(6(DB6G@(<H(

;<=6:(7@?@:<>;@ABK(6D(D@@A(8A(!C6>B@=(%M<K(<=(><=B=6E@7(6D(AJ;@=896::E(87@AB896:(B<(BC@(

>=<9@DD(FE(MC89C(6(>@=D<A(8;>=<?@D(BC@(;<=6:(M<=BC(<H(C@=(69B8<ADK(6D(.(M8::(DC<M(8A(

MC6B(H<::<MDI(#D(.(M8::(@N>:<=@(8A(BC8D(9C6>B@=K(BC8D(<;8DD8<A(6A7(BC@(9<AH:6B8<A(<H(BC@(

>=<9@DD(<H(<?@=9<;8AG(=67896:(@?8:K(MC89C(C6D(F@@A(:687(<JB(8A(!C6>B@=(%C=@@K(M8BC(6A(

8;>=<?@;@AB(8A(BC@(;<=6:(M<=BC(<H(<J=(>6=B89J:6=(69B8<AD(96A(F@(6BB=8FJB@7(B<(BC@(

8AB@=>=@B6B8<A(<H(BC@(<?@=9<;8AG(<H(=67896:(@?8:(6D(B8;@:@DDK(8A(BC@(D@AD@(BC6B(8B(=@OJ8=@D(6A(

69B(<H(A<J;@A6:(?<:8B8<A(BC6B(96AA<B(F@(:<96B@7(6B(6(9@=B68A(><8AB(8A(BC@(B@;><=6:(D@OJ@A9@(

<H(6(>@=D<A3D(:8H@(6A7(8D(A<B(8AH:J@A9@7(FE(<J=(69B8?8B8@D(8A(BC@(D@AD8F:@(M<=:7I(.H(=67896:(

@?8:(96A(<A:E(F@(<?@=9<;@(FE(6(?<:8B8<A6:(69B(BC6B(8D(<JBD87@(<H(B8;@(6A7(HJ=BC@=K(8D(A<B(

8;>69B@7(FE(BC6B(MC89C(<99J=D(8A(B8;@K(BC@A(M@(96AA<B(?8@M(8B(6D(>6=B(<H(6(B@;><=6:(

D@OJ@A9@(DJ9C(6D(CJ;6A(;<=6:(7@?@:<>;@ABK(MC89C(B6L@D(>:69@(8A(D<;@(L8A7(<H(

9C=<A<:<G896:(>=<9@DDK(=6BC@=(BC6A(8A(6(D@=8@D(<H(8D<:6B@7(7@98D8<ADI

.(M8::(=@D><A7(B<(BC@D@(B=678B8<A6:(=@678AGD(FE(7@;<ADB=6B8AG(BC6B(BC@=@(6=@(A<

PQR

Page 162: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

PQS

(9<;>@::8AG(=@6D<AD(H<=(JA7@=DB6A78AG(BC@(<?@=9<;8AG(<H(@?8:(6D(B8;@:@DD(8A(BC8D(DB=89B(

D@AD@I(TC8:@(BC8D(L8A7(<H(8;>=<?@;@AB(8D(9@=B68A:E(B8;@:@DD(8A(BC@(D@AD@(BC6B(8B(=@OJ8=@D(6(

H=@@K(JA7@B@=;8A@7(9C<89@(<H(!"#$%%&%'K(8B(8D(A<B(B8;@:@DD(8A(BC8D(;<=@(;EDB@=8<JD(M6E(

BC6B(D@?@=D(8B(9<;>:@B@:E(H=<;(BC@(8AH:J@A9@(<H(69B8?8B8@D(8A(BC@(>C@A<;@A6:(M<=:7(6A7(

H=<;(6(=@:6B8<ADC8>(M8BC(BC6B(MC89C(<99J=D(8A(B8;@I(%C8D(B=678B8<A6:(8AB@=>=@B6B8<A(8D(

:6=G@:E(F6D@7(<A(6(;8D=@678AG(<H(26AB3D(<MA(@N>:898B(9:68;D(6F<JB(BC@(>=<9@DD(<H(

<?@=9<;8AG(=67896:(@?8:(6A7(8BD(=@:6B8<ADC8>(B<(B8;@I

#D(.(M8::(7@;<ADB=6B@(8A(BC8D(9C6>B@=K(BC@=@(8D(DB=<AG(B@NBJ6:(@?87@A9@(8A(F<BC(BC@(

(")$'$*%+6A7(BC@(H8=DB(,-$.$/&"(H<=(F@:8@?8AG(BC6B(BC@(9C<89@(<H(6(G<<7(!"#$%%&%'K(<=(MC6B(

.(96::(UBC@(!"#$%%&%'+9C<89@KV(96A(F@(D687(B<(C6?@(6(>:69@(8A(6(B@;><=6:(D@OJ@A9@(<H(

@?@ABD(8AD<H6=(6D(<J=(69B8<AD(8A(BC@(>C@A<;@A6:(M<=:7(D@B(BC@(DB6G@(H<=(WBC<JGCK(DB=89B:E(

D>@6L8AGK(7<(A<B(96JD@X(DJ9C(6(9C<89@(6A7(BC@(9<AD@OJ@A9@D(<H(BC6B(9C<89@K(8A(BJ=AK(6>>@6=(

8A(BC@(>C@A<;@A6:(M<=:7I(TC8:@(BC@(!"#$%%&%'+9C<89@(8BD@:H(;6E(A<B(<99J=(8A(B8;@K(BC@=@(

8D(6(9:@6=(=@:6B8<ADC8>(F@BM@@A(BC8D(A<J;@A6:(9C<89@(6A7(BC6B(MC89C(<99J=D(8A(B8;@I(.A(

:8GCB(<H(BC8DK(.(9<AB@A7(BC6B(BC@=@(8D(G<<7(=@6D<A(B<(F@:8@?@(BC6B(BC@(<?@=9<;8AG(<H(=67896:(

@?8:(96A(F@(9<AD87@=@7(6(AJ;@=896::E(78DB8A9B(6A7(H<JA76B8<A6:(DB6G@(<H(BC@(>=<9@DD(<H(

;<=6:(7@?@:<>;@ABI(#D(.(M8::(DC<MK(=67896:(;<=6:(8;>=<?@;@ABK(MC89C(8A9:J7@D(BC@(

=@?<:JB8<A(8BD@:HK(;JDB(<99J=(9C=<A<:<G896::E(>=8<=(B<(6A(8;>=<?@;@AB(8A(BC@(;<=6:(M<=BC(

<H(<A@3D(69B8<ADK(8AD<H6=(6D(8B(9=@6B@D(BC@(9<A78B8<AD(H<=(BC@(><DD8F8:8BE(<H(BC8D(D@9<A7(L8A7(

<H(8;>=<?@;@ABI(YE(<?@=:<<L8AG(BC8D(DB6G@(<H(=67896:(;<=6:(8;>=<?@;@ABK(M@(H68:(B<(HJ::E(

JA7@=DB6A7(26AB3D(9<;>:@B@(BC@<=E(<H(;<=6:(7@?@:<>;@ABI

+$,&)#)%",-*.,/0*%1*23,&)"4*#53*6-,(3*%1*2,&)(,-*7%$,-*!89$%:383"#

#D(78D9JDD@7(8A(!C6>B@=(%M<K(H@M(BC8AL@=D(8A(BC@(D@9<A76=E(:8B@=6BJ=@(C6?@(

Page 163: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

PQQ

9<AD87@=@7(C<M(BC@(A@@7(B<(<?@=9<;@(=67896:(@?8:(8AH:J@A9@D(26AB3D(699<JAB(<H(;<=6:(

7@?@:<>;@AB(H<JA7(8A(C8D(;<=6:(>C8:<D<>CEI(#D(A<B@7(6F<?@K(<A@(<H(BC@(=@6D<AD(H<=(BC8D(8D(

BC@(><>J:6=(?8@M(BC6B(BC@(=@?<:JB8<A(BC6B(8D(=@OJ8=@7(B<(<?@=9<;@(=67896:(@?8:(8D(D<;@C<M(

;EDB@=8<JD:E(B8;@:@DD(8A(BC@(D@AD@(BC6B(8B(96AA<B(F@(>:69@7(8A(6(B@;><=6:(D@OJ@A9@(<H(

@?@ABD(8A(BC@(@;>8=896:(M<=:7(6A7(96AA<B(F@(8AH:J@A9@7(FE(69B8?8B8@D(8A(BC@(@;>8=896:(

M<=:7I(%C8D(8D(>=<F:@;6B89(H<=(=67896:(;<=6:(8;>=<?@;@AB3D(=@:6B8<ADC8>(M8BC(26AB3D(

699<JAB(<H(;<=6:(7@?@:<>;@AB(F@96JD@K(8H(BC@(=@?<:JB8<A(8D(D@?@=@7(H=<;(B8;@(8A(BC8D(M6EK(

BC@(=@?<:JB8<A(96AA<B(F@(><8AB@7(B<(6D(<99J==8AG(6B(6(><8AB(8A(6(D@OJ@A9@(<H(;<=6:(

7@?@:<>;@AB(<=(6D(8AH:J@A9@7(FE(8;>=<?@;@ABD(M@(;6L@(B<(<J=(@;>8=896:(9C6=69B@=(8A(BC@(

M<=:7I(#D(Z<=7<A(&I(/89C6:D<A(7@D9=8F@D(BC@(>=<F:@;K(U/<=6:(6G@A9E(<99J=D(B@;><=6::EK(

6D(26AB3D(<MA(:6AGJ6G@(6>>@6=D(B<(67;8BI(YJB(26AB3D(B=6AD9@A7@AB6:(87@6:8D;(C6D(A<(

DEDB@;6B89(M6E(<H(8AB@G=6B8AG(BC@(;<=6:(6A7(BC@(B@;><=6:K(;6L8AG(8B(?8=BJ6::E(8;><DD8F:@(

H<=(26AB(B<(@N>:68A(C8D(><8AB(M8BC8A(C8D(<MA(>C8:<D<>C896:(B@=;DIVP(%C6B(8DK(MC8:@(H=@@(

;<=6:(9C<89@D(;JDB(<99J=(<JBD87@(<H(B8;@K(;<=6:(6G@A9E(D@@;8AG:E(<99J=D(8A(B8;@K(8AD<H6=(

6D(M@(;6L@(;<=6:(7@98D8<AD(6B(9@=B68A(><8ABD(8A(B8;@I('67896:(;<=6:(8;>=<?@;@ABK(8A(

>6=B89J:6=K(8D(DJF[@9B(B<(BC8D(>=<F:@;I

#:BC<JGC(26AB(JD@D(B@;><=6:(:6AGJ6G@(B<(7@D9=8F@(BC@(=@?<:JB8<AK\(;6AE(BC8AL@=D(

6=@(9<A?8A9@7(BC6B(26AB(69BJ6::E(7<@D(A<B(8AB@A7(B<(8A7896B@(BC6B(BC8D(8D(6(B@;><=6:(9C6AG@I(

#::@A(T<<7(69LA<M:@7G@D(BC6B(26AB(JD@D(:6AGJ6G@(BC6B(M<J:7(6>>@6=(B<(7@D9=8F@(BC@(

P /89C6:D<AK(U/<=6:('@G@A@=6B8<A(6A7(-8?8A@(#87(8A(26ABKV(\]SI()<=(;<=@(<A(BC@(8DDJ@(<H(BC@(8AB@G=6B8<A(

<H(BC@(;<=6:(6A7(B@;><=6:K(D@@($6J:(4B@=AK(U%C@($=<F:@;(<H("8DB<=E(6A7(%@;><=6:8BE(8A(26AB86A(&BC89DKV(

("0$"1+*2+3".4567#$8#+R^I(WP^_]X(6A7(-6A8@:(*3!<AA<=K(UZ<<7(6A7(&?8:(-8D><D8B8<AKV(94%.:;.&<$"%+`]I(WP^_QX

\ .A(BC@((")$'$*%=+26AB(7@D9=8F@D(BC@(=@?<:JB8<A(6D(6(UB=6AD8B8<AV(W>?"-'4%'X+W]aS`XK(6(U=@F8=BCV(W@$"<"-'"?&-.X(W]aS`XK(6A7(6D(<99J==8AG(BC=<JGC(6(UD8AG:@(6A7(JA6:B@=6F:@(7@98D8<AV(W"$%A$'"+&%14%<")?4-"+B%.#86)$"C&%'X(W]aS_XI(%C@D@K(6A7(<BC@=(B@;><=6:(B@=;D(BC6B(26AB(JB8:8b@D(B<(7@D9=8F@(BC8D(<?@=9<;8AG(<H(@?8:K(6::(DJGG@DB(BC6B(8B(<99J=D(6B(6(9@=B68A(><8AB(8A(B8;@I(

Page 164: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

PQ]

=@?<:JB8<A(6D(B6L8AG(>:69@(6B(6(9@=B68A(B8;@(8A(6(>@=D<A3D(:8H@I("@(M=8B@DK(U$C=6D@D(:8L@(

39C6AG@(<H(C@6=BK3(3=@?<:JB8<AK3(39<A?@=D8<AK3(BC@(3B=6ADH<=;6B8<A(<H(<A@3D(96DB(<H(;8A7K3(6::(

96==E(M8BC(BC@;(BC@(DB=<AG(DJGG@DB8<AD(<H(6(DJ77@A(."D5*-4)+9C6AG@K(6D(BC<JGC(BC@(F=@6L(

M8BC(@?8:(M@=@(6(9<AD>89J<JD(D*D"%.+8A(6(;6A3D(:8H@IVR(-@D>8B@(BC8D(:6AGJ6G@K(C<M@?@=K(

T<<7(6=GJ@D(BC6B(26AB(7<@D(A<B(8AB@A7(BC6B(BC@(=@?<:JB8<A(96A(F@(D687(B<(<99J=(6B(6(

;<;@AB(8A(B8;@I("@(96JB8<AD(BC6B(M@(DC<J:7(A<B(F@(U;8D:@7V(FE(BC@D@(B@;><=6:(M<=7DI(

'6BC@=K(C@(BC8ALD(BC6B(26AB3D(9<AB=6DB(<H(BC@(=@?<:JB8<A(M8BC(BC@(>=<9@DD(<H(G=67J6:(

=@H<=;6B8<A(BC6B(:@67D(B<(6A(8;>=<?@;@AB(8A(BC@(;<=6:(M<=BC(<H(<J=(>6=B89J:6=(69B8<AD(8D(6(

9:@6=(8A7896B8<A(BC6B(BC@(=@?<:JB8<A(8D(A<B(DJ9C(6(9C6AG@IS(#778B8<A6::EK(C@(><8ABD(B<(26AB3D(

9:68;(BC6B(BC@(G<<7(!"#$%%&%'=(<A9@(9C<D@AK(8D(A<B(;JB6F:@(6A7(8D(A<B(UH:J9BJ6B8AG(8A(

B8;@IVQ(26AB(;6L@D(BC8D(9:68;(8A(C8D(M<=L(U%C@(&A7(<H(#::(%C8AGDIV("@=@K(26AB(M=8B@D(

BC6B(BC@(!"#$%%&%'(8D(UA<B(6(>C@A<;@A<AIIIFJB(D<;@BC8AG(DJ>@=D@AD8F:@K(C@A9@(A<B(

6:B@=6F:@(M8BC(B8;@IV](T<<7(B6L@D(BC8D(B<(;@6A(BC6BK(F@96JD@(BC@(!"#$%%&%'(96AA<B(F@(

9C6AG@7(M8BC(B8;@K(BC@(9C<89@(<H(!"#$%%&%'(96AA<B(F@(D<;@BC8AG(BC6B(<99J=D(8A(B8;@I

*BC@=(BC8AL@=D(C6?@(D8;8:6=(8AB@=>=@B6B8<AD(<H(BC@(=@?<:JB8<AI(Z<=7<A(&I(/89C6:D<A(

c=I(M=8B@D(BC6BK(MC@A(M@(B6:L(6F<JB(BC@(9C<89@(B<(=@;<?@(<J=(@?8:(!"#$%%&%'(6A7(8ADB@67(B<(

C6?@(6(G<<7(<A@K(M@(;JDB(9<;;8B(B<(BC@(UD@?@=8AG(<H(BC@(9<AA@9B8<A(F@BM@@A(B8;@(6A7(

BC@(;<=6:(:8H@IV`(.H(BC8D(9C<89@(8D(B<(F@(6(H=@@(<A@K(/89C6:D<A(6=GJ@DK(BC@A(M@(96AA<B(D6E(

BC6B(8B(8D(8A(B8;@(F@96JD@(8B(8D(A<B(>6=B(<H(6(96JD@7(D@OJ@A9@(<H(@?@ABDI(#778B8<A6::EK('<F@=B(

R T<<7K(94%.E#+3*-4)+(")$'$*%=+\\^I

S 4@@(26ABK((")$'$*%=+]aS`I

Q T<<7K(94%.E#+3*-4)+(")$'$*%=+\\^(d(\ReI

] .;;6AJ@:(26ABK(U%C@(&A7(<H(#::(%C8AGDKV(8A((")$'$*%+1$.6$%+.6"+F*&%<4-$"#+*2+3"-"+("4#*%+4%<+G.6"-+@-$.$%'#=+@7I(#::@A(T<<7(W!6;F=87G@a(!6;F=87G@(+A8?@=D8BE($=@DDK(P^^_IXa(_aRRSI

` /89C6:D<AK(H4))"%+H-""<*DK(_RI

Page 165: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

PQ`

/@==8C@M(#76;D(7@D9=8F@D(BC@(=@?<:JB8<A(6D(BC@(UB8;@:@DDK(A<J;@A6:(9<==@:6B@(6A7(

G=<JA7(<H(>=<G=@DD(B<M6=7(C<:8A@DDKV_(BC<JGC(A<B(6(>6=B(<H(BC8D(>=<G=@DDK(DB=89B:E(D>@6L8AGI(

"@K(:8L@(T<<7K(96JB8<AD(BC6B(26AB3D(:6AGJ6G@(<H(U9<AH:89BV(6A7(U=@?<:JB8<AV(DC<J:7(A<B(F@(

=@67(8A(BC@(<=78A6=EK(B@;><=6:(M6E(BC6B(M@(BE>896::E(JA7@=DB6A7(BC@D@(B@=;DI^(TC8:@(BC@(

=@?<:JB8<A(8D(9@=B68A:E(BC@(F@G8AA8AGK(<=(G=<JA7K(<H(;<=6:(7@?@:<>;@ABK(BC@D@(BC8AL@=D(7<(

A<B(F@:8@?@(BC6B(8B(DC<J:7(F@(9<AD87@=@7(6(>6=B(<H(BC@(>=<9@DD(<H(;<=6:(7@?@:<>;@ABI

TCE(7<(D<(;6AE(BC8AL@=D(78D=@G6=7(26AB3D(B@;><=6:(:6AGJ6G@(8A(H6?<=(<H(6(

B8;@:@DD(=@678AGf(%C@=@(6=@(6B(:@6DB(BM<(>:69@D(8A(26AB3D(M=8B8AGD(BC6B(M@(96A(><8AB(B<(6D(

BC@(D<J=9@(<H(BC8D(8AB@=>=@B6B8<AI()8=DBK(6A7(;<DB(<F?8<JD:EK(26AB(8D(?@=E(9:@6=(BC6B(MC@A(

M@(;6L@(H=@@(9C<89@D(JD8AG(<J=(>J=@(=@6D<AK(BC<D@(9C<89@D(6=@(A<B(UDJF[@9B(B<(BC@(

9<A78B8<AD(<H(BC@(B@;><=6:(D@OJ@A9@KVPe(<=K(7<(A<B(<99J=(8A(B8;@(6A7(6=@(A<B(7@B@=;8A@7(FE(

BC6B(MC89C(<99J=D(8A(BC@(D@AD8F:@(M<=:7I(%CJDK(MC@A(M@(JD@(<J=(>J=@(=@6D<A(B<(;6L@(

9C<89@DK(BC@D@(9C<89@D(6=@(A<B(96JD@7(6A7(7<(A<B(6>>@6=(8A(B8;@I(26AB(M=8B@DK(U%C@(

96JD6:8BE(<H(=@6D<A(8A(BC@(8AB@::8G8F:@(9C6=69B@=(7<@D(A<B(6=8D@(<=(DB6=B(M<=L8AG(6B(6(9@=B68A(

B8;@(8A(>=<7J98AG(6A(@HH@9BI()<=(BC@A(8B(M<J:7(8BD@:H(F@(DJF[@9B(B<(BC@(A6BJ=6:(:6M(<H(

6>>@6=6A9@DK(B<(BC@(@NB@AB(BC6B(BC8D(:6M(7@B@=;8A@D(96JD6:(D@=8@D(8A(B8;@K(6A7(8BD(96JD6:8BE(

M<J:7(BC@A(F@(A6BJ=@(6A7(A<B(H=@@7<;IVPP(.A(DC<=BK(8H(BC@(69BD(<H(<J=(>J=@(=@6D<A(787(

6>>@6=(B<(JD(8A(B8;@(6A7(D>69@K(BC@E(M<J:7(F@(DJF[@9B(B<(B8;@(6A7(D>69@(6A7(BC@=@H<=@(

M<J:7(F@(7@B@=;8A@7(6A7(JAH=@@I

)=@@K(A<J;@A6:(9C<89@D(7<(A<B(D8;>:E(A<B(<99J=(8A(B8;@K(FJBK(8A(H69BK(26AB(BC8ALD(

_ #76;DK(8AB=<7J9B8<AK(NNI

^ #76;DK(8AB=<7J9B8<AK(NNI

Pe 26ABK(!$'K(#QQPgYQ`^I

PP .F87I

Page 166: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

PQ_

BC6B(BC@E(96AA<B(F@(96JD6::E(7@B@=;8A@7(FE(BC6B(MC89C(6>>@6=D(8A(B8;@(F@96JD@(=@6D<A(

96AA<B(F@(7@B@=;8A@7(FE(6AEBC8AG(FJB(8BD@:HI($6B=89L()=8@=D<A(6>B:E(7@D9=8F@D(BC8D(>=<F:@;(

6D(H<::<MDI("@(><8ABD(<JB(BC6B(26AB(C<:7D(BC@(><D8B8<A(BC6B(UhCiJ;6A(F@8AGD(6=@(

B=6AD9@A7@AB6::E(H=@@K(8A(BC@(D@AD@(BC6B(@;>8=896:(8AH:J@A9@D(96A(C6?@(A<(@HH@9B(<A(BC@(

;<=6:(DB6BJD(<H(6(CJ;6A(F@8AG(6A7(8A(BC@(D@AD@(BC6B(9C<89@(8D(HJA76;@AB6::E(>=8<=(B<(

A6BJ=6:(7@B@=;8A6B8<AIVP\(.H(BC8D(8D(B=J@K(BC@A(MC6B(M@(7<(8A(BC@(D@AD8F:@(M<=:7(B<(8;>=<?@(

<J=D@:?@D(>=8<=(B<(BC@(=@?<:JB8<A(96A(C6?@(A<(96JD6:(8;>69B(<A(<J=(A<J;@A6:(9C<89@(B<(

C6?@(6(G<<7(!"#$%%&%'+6A7(BC@=@FE(JA7@=G<(BC@(=@?<:JB8<AI(TC8:@(<J=(A<J;@A6:(9C<89@D(

7<(G=<JA7(9C6AG@D(8A(BC@(@;>8=896:(M<=:7K(<F[@9BD(8A(BC@(@;>8=896:(M<=:7(96AA<B(

7@B@=;8A@(A<J;@A6:(9C<89@DI

Y@96JD@(BC@(9C<89@(B<(C6?@(6(9@=B68A(!"#$%%&%'(8D(6A(69B(<H(A<J;@A6:(?<:8B8<AK(8B(

D@@;D(B<(H<::<M(BC6B(BC@(=@?<:JB8<AK(MC89C(=@OJ8=@D(BC8D(!"#$%%&%'+9C<89@K(96AA<B(F@(>6=B(

<H(6(B@;><=6:(D@OJ@A9@IPR(#(B@;><=6:(D@OJ@A9@K(DJ9C(6D(;<=6:(7@?@:<>;@ABK(=@OJ8=@D(BC6B(

MC@A(M@(M<=L(B<(9C6AG@(9@=B68A(BC8AGD(6F<JB(<J=(A6BJ=@(<=(9C6=69B@=K(BC6B(M<=L(M8::(

=@DJ:B(8A(HJ=BC@=(9C6AG@D(8A(BC@(HJBJ=@I(-@?@:<>;@AB(8D(6(96JD6:K(B@;><=6:(>=<9@DD(8AD<H6=(

6D(<A@(9C6AG@(DC<J:7(F=8AG(JD(9:<D@=(B<(BC@(@A7(<H(;<=6:(G<<7A@DDI("<M@?@=K(8H(MC6B(M@(

7<(8A(BC@(D@AD8F:@(M<=:7(C6D(A<(=@:6B8<ADC8>K(<=(C6=;<AEK(M8BC(BC@(A<J;@A6:K(B8;@:@DD(

9C<89@(B<(C6?@(6(G<<7(!"#$%%&%'K+BC@A(BC@(=@?<:JB8<A(96AA<B(F@(D687(B<(F@(6(>6=B(<H(6(

>=<9@DD(<H(;<=6:(7@?@:<>;@AB(8A(6AE(;@6A8AGHJ:(M6EI('6BC@=(BC6A(F@8AG(6(>6=B(<H(BC8D(

P\ )=8@=D<AK(H-""<*D+4%<+I%.6-*5*)*'7K(RI

PR Z<=7<A(&I(/89C6:D<AK(c=IK(8A(C8D(6=B89:@(U26ABK(BC@(Y8F:@K(6A7(BC@('@9<?@=E(H=<;('67896:(&?8:V(W94%.E#+I%4.*D7+*2+B0$)=+@7I(4C6=<A(#A7@=D<AjZ<:7(6A7($6F:<(/J9CA8LI(W!6;F=87G@a(!6;F=87G@(+A8?@=D8BE($=@DDK(\ePeXXK(7@D9=8F@D(BC8D(>=<F:@;(6D(H<::<MDa(UT8BC8A(26AB3D(H=6;@M<=LK(B@;><=6:8BEK(8A?<:?8AG(BC@(

?@=E(87@6(<H(F@H<=@j6A7j6HB@=K(8;>:8@D(7@B@=;8A8D;III%C@(H=@@(69B(6DD<986B@7(M8BC(6(;<=6:(JA7@=B6L8AG(

96A(A@?@=(F@(DC<MA(B<(F@(396JD@7K3(6D(DJ=@:E(H<::<MD(H<=(26AB(H=<;(:<96B8AG(DJ9C(6A(69B(8A(6(F@H<=@j6A7j

6HB@=(D@OJ@A9@I(4J9C(6A(69B(6=8D@D(8ADB@67(<JB(<H(6(=6B8<A6:(FJB(A<J;@A6:(G@DBJ=@(DJGG@DB8?@(<A:E(<H(BC@(

;EDB@=8@D(<H(;<=6:(8;>=<?@;@AB(6A7(A<B(<H(BC@(>=@789B6F:@(=@GJ:6=8B8@D(<H(BC@(>CED896:(JA8?@=D@I(YE(

26AB3D(G=<JA7(=J:@DK(6A(69B(<H(G@AJ8A@(H=@@7<;(8DK(OJ8B@(:8B@=6::EK(3A<B(8A(B8;@3V(W]\(d(RXI

Page 167: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

PQ^

D@OJ@A9@K(BC8D(9C<89@(;EDB@=8<JD:E(@N8DBD(D<;@MC@=@(<JBD87@(<H(d(6A7(JAB<J9C@7(FE(j((BC@(

M<=L(M@(7<(8A(BC@(D@AD8F:@(M<=:7I

4@9<A7K(BC8D(?8@M(6:D<(6=8D@D(F@96JD@(<H(26AB3D(78=@9B(DB6B@;@AB(6F<JB(BC@(

B8;@:@DDA@DD(<H(6(9@=B68A(9C<89@(<H(!"#$%%&%'(8A(BC@((")$'$*%J+.A(C8D(78D9JDD8<A(<H(=67896:(

@?8:K(26AB(DB6B@D(BC6B(<A@3D(8AA6B@(!"#$%%&%'(96AA<B(F@(D687(B<(C6?@(F@@A(U@6=A@7(8A(B8;@V(

W%$86.+$%+<"-+K"$.+"-1*-?"%+#"$XIPS*26AB(;6L@D(BC8D(DB6B@;@AB(6D(C@(B=8@D(B<(7@D9=8F@(C<M(6(

>@=D<A(9<J:7(@8BC@=(F@(;<=6::E(G<<7(<=(@?8:(FE(A6BJ=@K(7@D>8B@(BC8D(;<=6:(DB6B@(=@OJ8=8AG(6(

H=@@(9C<89@I(YE(BC@(DB6B@;@AB(BC6B(<A@3D(;<=6:(A6BJ=@(C6D(A<B(F@@A(@6=A@7(8A(B8;@K(26AB(

7<@D(A<B(;@6A(BC6B(6(>@=D<A(8D(A<B(=@D><AD8F:@(H<=(C8D(!"#$%%&%'(FJB(D8;>:E(BC6B(<A@(

96AA<B(><8AB(B<(6(;<;@AB(8A(6(>@=D<A3D(:8H@(8A(MC89C(C@(67<>B@7(BC6B(!"#$%%&%'I("@(

M=8B@DK(UYJB(BC@=@(96AA<B(F@(6AE(HJ=BC@=(9<GA8B8<A(<H(BC@(DJF[@9B8?@(G=<JA7(<=(BC@(96JD@(<H(

BC8D(67<>B8<A(W6:BC<JGC(M@(96AA<B(6?<87(6DL8AG(6F<JB(8BXK(H<=(<BC@=M8D@(M@(M<J:7(C6?@(B<(

677J9@*DB8::(6A<BC@=(;6N8;(8AB<(MC89C(BC@(!"#$%%&%'(M<J:7(C6?@(B<(F@(8A9<=><=6B@7K(6A7(

BC8D(;6N8;(;JDB(8A(BJ=A(C6?@(8BD(G=<JA7IVPQ*%C8D(8D(6(>=<F:@;(<H(6A(8AH8A8B@(=@G=@DDI(

Y@96JD@(BC8D(H8=DB(9C<89@(<H(6(!"#$%%&%'(8D(6(H=@@(9C<89@(6A7(BC@=@H<=@(JA96JD@7K(M@(

96AA<B(:<<L(B<(6A(<=8G8A6:(96JD@(<H(8B(8A(6(D@OJ@A9@(<H(@?@ABDK(6A7(BCJD(M@(;JDB(D6E(BC6B(8B(

C6D(A<B(F@@A(@6=A@7(8A(B8;@I

( 4@?@=6:(BC8AL@=D(MC<(C<:7(BC@(B8;@:@DDA@DD(=@678AG(<H(BC@(=@?<:JB8<A(C6?@(><8AB@7(

B<(BC@D@(>6DD6G@D(6D(6(D<J=9@(<H(8AH<=;6B8<A(A<B(<A:E(6F<JB(BC@(9C<89@(B<(C6?@(6A(@?8:(

PS 26ABK((")$'$*%=+]a\QI

PQ .F87I(WU0<A(78@D@=(#AA@C;JAG(L6AA(A89CB(M8@7@=(7@=(DJF[@LB8?@(Z=JA7(<7@=(78@(+=D69C@(@=L6AAB(

M@=7@A(W<FM<C:(76A69C(bJ(H=6G@A(JA?@=;@87:89C(8DBk(M@8:(D<ADB(M87@=J;(@8A@(/6N8;@(6AG@HlC=B(

M@=7@A(;lmB@K(8A(M@:9C@(78@D@(Z@D8AAJAG(6JHG@A<;;@A(M<=7@AK(78@(@F@AD<(M87@=J;(8C=@A(Z=JA7(

C6F@A(;JmIVX

Page 168: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

P]e

!"#$%%&%'(FJB(6:D<(6F<JB(BC@(:6B@=(9C<89@(B<(C6?@(6(G<<7(!"#$%%&%'IP](/89C6:D<AK(8A(H69BK(

=@H@=D(B<(26AB3D(7@D9=8>B8<A(<H(BC@(=67896:(@?8:(9C<89@(6A7(C8D(7@D9=8>B8<A(<H(=67896:(;<=6:(

8;>=<?@;@AB(6D(U>6=6::@:(699<JABWDXIVP`(/89C6:D<A(H8A7D(BC@D@(96D@D(B<(F@(>6=6::@:(8A(BC@(

D@AD@(BC6B(F<BC(=@OJ8=@(A<J;@A6:(9C<89@DK(MC89C(;JDB(F@(<JBD87@(<H(B8;@K(6A7(6:D<(BC6B(

F<BCK(8H(BC@E(7<(=@OJ8=@(H=@@(9C<89@DK(F@G(BC@(OJ@DB8<A(<H(BC@8=(9C=<A<:<G896:(<=8G8AIP_(

/89C6:D<A(6=GJ@D(BC6B(26AB(>=<?87@D(JD(M8BC(6(B@;><=6:(7@D9=8>B8<A(<H(BC@D@(9C<89@DK(

@?@A(BC<JGC(C8D(>C8:<D<>CE(9<;;8BD(C8;(B<(7@AE8AG(BC6B(DJ9C(9C<89@D(<99J=(8A(6(

9C=<A<:<G896:(D@OJ@A9@K(FJB(BC8D(7@D9=8>B8<A(DC<J:7(A<B(F@(B6L@A(:8B@=6::EI(#99<=78AG(B<(

/89C6:D<A3D(699<JABK(M@(DC<J:7(JA7@=DB6A7(26AB3D(B@;><=6:(:6AGJ6G@(6D(;@=@(8;6G@=E(

=6BC@=(BC6A(>C8:<D<>C896:(6=GJ;@ABDIP^

.AB@=@DB8AG:EK(D<;@(<H(BC@(BC8AL@=D(MC<(67C@=@(B<(BC8D(L8A7(<H(=@678AG(C6?@(

A@?@=BC@:@DD(6BB@;>B@7(B<(8AB@G=6B@(=67896:(;<=6:(8;>=<?@;@AB(8AB<(26AB3D(<?@=6=9C8AG(

699<JAB(<H(;<=6:(7@?@:<>;@AB(FE(=@BC8AL8AG(MC6B(8B(M<J:7(;@6A(H<=(BC@(9C<89@(<H(6(

!"#$%%&%'(B<(F@(B8;@:@DDI(%C@E(7<(BC8D(FE(6=GJ8AG(BC6B(8B(8D(<A:E(B8;@:@DD(8A(BC@(D@AD@(BC6B(

8B(7<@D(A<B(C6>>@A(6B(6(D>@98H89(><8AB(8A(B8;@(FJB(=6BC@=(DB=@B9C@D(<JB(<?@=(BC@(9<J=D@(<H(

<A@3D(:8H@K(<99J==8AG(6:<AGD87@(6AE(8;>=<?@;@AB(8A(<A@3D(69B8<ADI(Y@96JD@(<H(BC@(

6DDJ;>B8<A(<H(B8;@:@DDA@DDK(BC@D@(BC8AL@=D(B@A7(B<(=@G6=7(BC@(<?@=9<;8AG(<H(=67896:(@?8:(

P] -6?87(4JDD;6A(9<;@D(B<(C8D(9<A9:JD8<A(6F<JB(BC@(B8;@:@DDA@DD(<H(BC@(=@?<:JB8<A(FE(DB6=B8AG(M8BC(BC@(

OJ@DB8<A(<H(C<M(BC@(9C<89@(B<(F@(=67896::E(@?8:(96A(F<BC(9<AD8DB(<H(6(H=@@(69B(6A7(F@(:<G896::E(>=8<=(B<(BC@(

H8=DB(JD@(<H(H=@@7<;I(T8BC<JB([JDB8H896B8<AK(C@(BC@A(@N>6A7D(BC8D(>=<F:@;(B<(6(>=<F:@;(<H(9C<<D8AG(6AE(

!"#$%%&%'K(MC@BC@=(8B(F@(BC@(9C<89@(<H(<A@3D(U8AA6B@V(!"#$%%&%'(<=(BC@(9C<89@(B<(C6?@(6(G<<7(!"#$%%&%'K(6D(8A(BC@(96D@(<H(=67896:(;<=6:(8;>=<?@;@AB(W-6?87(4JDD;6AK(U$@=?@=D8BE(<H(BC@("@6=BKV(L6"+M6$)*#*56$84)+("0$"1+PPSI(\I(W#>=IK(\eeQXa(P`P(d(P`\XI

P` Z<=7<A(&I(/89C6:D<AK(U26ABK(BC@(Y8F:@K(6A7(BC@('@9<?@=E(H=<;('67896:(&?8:KV(8A(94%.E#+I%4.*D7+*2 +B0$)=+@7I(4C6=<A(#A7@=D<AjZ<:7(6A7($6F:<(/J9CA8L(W!6;F=87G@a(!6;F=87G@(+A8?@=D8BE($=@DDK(\ePeXa(]]I

P_ .F87I

P^ .F87K(]QI

Page 169: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

P]P

6D(6(L8A7(<H(7@?@:<>;@AB(BC6B(8D(A<B(78DB8A9B(H=<;(6A(8;>=<?@;@AB(8A(BC@(;<=6:8BE(<H(

>6=B89J:6=(69B8<ADI(%C8D(G=<J>(><D8BD(BC6B(=67896:(;<=6:(8;>=<?@;@AB(6A7(BC@(G=67J6:(

8;>=<?@;@AB(<H(BC@(;<=6:(M<=BC(<H(<A@3D(;6N8;D(6A7(69B8<AD(6=@(A<B(AJ;@=896::E(78DB8A9B(

DB6G@D(<H(;<=6:(7@?@:<>;@AB(8AD<H6=(6D(BC@E(6=@(699<;>:8DC@7(BC=<JGC(BC@(D6;@(>=<9@DDI(

T@(96A(H8A7(BC@(F@DB(=@>=@D@AB6B8<A(<H(BC8D(6=GJ;@AB(8A(M<=LD(FE(-6?87(4JDD;6A(6A7(

!C=8DB8A@(2<=DG66=7I*%C8D(6=GJ;@AB(96A(F@(H<JA7(;<DB(@N>:898B:E(8A(-6?87(4JDD;6A3D(

U$@=?@=D8BE(<H(BC@("@6=BKV\e(8A(MC89C(C@(7=6MD(J><A(BC@(M<=L(<H(2<=DG66=7I(.A(BC8D(6=B89:@K(

4JDD;6A(6BB@;>BD(B<(@N>:68A(26AB3D(9:68;(BC6B(BC@(9C<89@(B<(F@(=67896::E(@?8:K(<=(B<(C6?@(

6A(@?8:(!"#$%%&%'K(;JDB(F@(F<BC(>=8<=(B<(6A7(6(9<AD@OJ@A9@(<H(<J=(H8=DB(JD@(<H(H=@@7<;I(

#99<=78AG(B<(BC8D(9:68;K(<J=(9C<89@(B<(F@(=67896::E(@?8:(8D(6(H=@@K(A<J;@A6:(9C<89@(BC6B(

G=<JA7D(<J=(JD@(<H(H=@@7<;(8A(>6=B89J:6=(96D@DI("<M@?@=K(BC8D(9C<89@(;JDB(6:D<(F@(6(H=@@(

69B(8BD@:HI(.B(8D(A<B(9:@6=K(BC@AK(C<M(BC8D(8AB@::8G8F:@(69B(H8BD(8AB<(<J=(JD@(<H(H=@@7<;(8A(BC@(

D@AD8F:@(=@6:;I\P

.A(BC8D(6=B89:@K(4JDD;6A(@N>6A7D(BC8D(8DDJ@(6A7(6>>:8@D(8B(A<B([JDB(B<(BC@(>=<F:@;(<H(

9C<<D8AG(6A(@?8:(!"#$%%&%'(FJB(6:D<(B<(BC@(8DDJ@(<H(C<M(M@(9C<<D@(6(G<<7(!"#$%%&%'K(

<A9@(@?8:I("@(BC8ALD(BC6B(BC8D(>=<F:@;(6>>:8@D(B<(BC@(9C<89@(<H(!"#$%%&%'+8A(F<BC(96D@DI(

4JDD;6A(=@D<:?@D(BC8D(6>>6=@AB(8DDJ@(FE(6=GJ8AG(BC6B(BC@(9C<89@(B<(C6?@(6(G<<7(

!"#$%%&%'(6A7(BCJD(<?@=9<;@(=67896:(@?8:(<99J=D(A<B(8A(6(;<;@AB6=E(9C<89@(>=8<=(B<(6A(

8;>=<?@;@AB(8A(BC@(;<=6:8BE(<H(<A@3D(>6=B89J:6=(69B8<AD(FJB(=6BC@=(<99J=D(D8;J:B6A@<JD:E(

M8BC(BC8D(8;>=<?@;@AB(<H(69B8<ADI("@(F@:8@?@D(BC6B(BC8D(=@D<:?@D(6AE(>=<F:@;D(96JD@7(FE(

MC6B(C@(D6ED(8D(26AB3D(9:68;(BC6B(BC@(!"#$%%&%'+9C<89@(8D(UB8;@:@DDV(F@96JD@(8B(8D(6A(

\e -6?87(4JDD;6AI(U$@=?@=D8BE(<H(BC@("@6=BKV(PQR(d(P``I

\P .F87K(P`P(d(P`\I

Page 170: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

P]\

8AB@::8G8F:@(69BI\\('6BC@=(BC6A(BC8D(F@8AG(6(;EDB@=8<JD(;@B6>CED896:(9:68;K(4JDD;6A(6=GJ@D(

BC6B(8B(;@=@:E(;@6AD(BC6B(8B(7<@D(A<B(<99J=(6B(6(78DB8A9B(;<;@AB(<H(6(B@;><=6:(<=7@=I(

.ADB@67K(BC@(!"#$%%&%'+9C<89@(8D(>6=B(<H(<J=(;<=6:(:8?@D(6D(6(MC<:@I\R(%C6B(8DK(BC@(69B8<AD(

M@(>@=H<=;(<?@=(BC@(9<J=D@(<H(<J=(MC<:@(:8?@D(D<;@C<M(U677(J>V(B<(F@(<J=(9C<89@(<H(

!"#$%%&%'I(4JDD;6A(G=<JA7D(C8D(BC@D8D(8A(6A(6=GJ;@AB(FE(!C=8DB8A@(/I(2<=DG66=7(

=@G6=78AG(BC@(=<:@(<H(=@D<:JB8<AD(8A(?8=BJ@(69OJ8D8B8<AI\S(4JDD;6A(M=8B@D(BC6BK(8A(

2<=DG66=73D(6=B89:@(U/<=6:8BE(6D()=@@7<;KV(DC@(UDJGG@DBD(BC6B(BC@(8AB@::8G8F:@(69B(BC6B(

@DB6F:8DC@D(<J=(78D><D8B8<AV(8D(A<B(UAJ;@=896::E(78DB8A9B(H=<;(BC@(<=78A6=E(9<J=D@(<H(<J=(

:8?@DIV;<

%C@(6=GJ;@AB(H=<;(2<=DG66=7(BC6B(4JDD;6A(7=6MD(J><A(9<;@D(H=<;(6A(6=B89:@(8A(

MC89C(2<=DG66=7(B=8@D(B<(B69L:@(BC@(>=<F:@;(<H(C<M(6(=@D<:JB8<AK(MC89C(8D(6(?<:8B8<A6:(69BK(

B<(9C6AG@(<J=(D@AD8F:@(A6BJ=@(96A(F@(DJ99@DDHJ:I(4C@(6=GJ@D(BC6B(=@D<:JB8<AD(96AA<B(:@67(

8;;@786B@:E(B<(BC@(69OJ8D8B8<A(<H(6(?8=BJ@(<=(BC@(=@;<?6:(<H(6(?89@(F@96JD@(F<BC(6=@(>6=BD(

<H(<J=(D@ADJ<JD(A6BJ=@(6A7(BCJD(:8L@:E(B<(F@(U=@96:98B=6ABIV('6BC@=K(DC@(BC8ALD(BC6B(M@(96A(

<A:E(6BB=8FJB@(6(=@D<:JB8<AK(DJ9C(6D(BC@(=@D<:JB8<A(B<(C6?@(6(G<<7(!"#$%%&%'K(B<(6(>@=D<A(

<A9@(BC@E(C6?@(6:=@67E(F@GJA(B<(7<(MC6B(C6D(F@@A(=@D<:?@7I(.A(BC@(96D@(<H(BC@(!"#$%%&%'+

9C<89@K(DC@(BC8ALD(BC6B(M@(96A(<A:E(D6E(BC6B(6(>@=D<A(C6D(9C<D@A(6(G<<7(!"#$%%&%'(<A9@(

\\ .(JD@(BC@(OJ6:8H8@7(:6AGJ6G@(<H(U6>>6=@ABV(6A7(UMC6B(C@(D6EDV(F@96JD@(8B(8D(A<B(9:@6=(B<(;@(BC6B(4JDD;6A(

8D(9<==@9B(8A(C8D(6DDJ;>B8<A(BC6B(BC@(9C<89@(B<(C6?@(6(G<<7(!"#$%%&%'(8DK(:8L@(BC@(9C<89@(B<(C6?@(6A(@?8:(!"#$%%&%'K(;EDB@=8<JD:E(B8;@:@DDI(.(M8::(@N>:<=@(BC@(=@6D<AD(H<=(BC8D(8A(BC@(:6DB(D@9B8<A(<H(BC8D(9C6>B@=I(#D(.(M8::(DC<MK(BC@=@(7<@D(A<B(D@@;(B<(F@(DJHH898@AB(G=<JA7D(8A(BC@((")$'$*%+B<(9<A9:J7@(BC6B(BC@(9C<89@(B<(C6?@(6(G<<7(!"#$%%&%'+;JDB(F@(B8;@:@DD(8A(BC@(D6;@(D@AD@(6D(BC@(9C<89@(B<(C6?@(6A(@?8:(!"#$%%&%'J

\R 4JDD;6AK(U$@=?@=D8BE(<H(BC@("@6=BKV(P`RI

\S 4@@(!C=8DB8A@(/6=8<A(2<=DG66=7K(U/<=6:8BE(6D()=@@7<;KV(8A(,-"4.$%'+.6"+9$%'<*D+*2+B%<#+W!6;F=87G@a(!6;F=87G@(+A8?@=D8BE($=@DDK(P^^]XI

\Q 4JDD;6AK(U$@=?@=D8BE(<H(BC@("@6=BKV(P`\I

Page 171: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

P]R

BC@E(C6?@(6:=@67E(F@GJA(B<(>=<G=@DD(;<=6::EI\](

2<=DG66=7(BC8ALD(BC6B(BC8D(8D(26AB3D(@N>:898B(?8@M(8A(BC@((")$'$*%I\`(4C@(M=8B@D(BC6B(

BC@(!"#$%%&%'+9C<89@(96A(F@(?8@M@7(H=<;(<A@(<H(BM<(>@=D>@9B8?@DK(7@>@A78AG(<A(MC6B(

6D>@9B(<H(;<=6:(9C6AG@(M@3=@(B=E8AG(B<(699<JAB(H<=I(2<=DG66=7(><8ABD(B<(>6DD6G@(]aS`(d(S_(

8A(BC@((")$'$*%+H<=(>=<<H(<H(BC8DI*.A(BC8D(>6DD6G@K(26AB(M=8B@D

.H(FE(6(D8AG:@(6A7(JA6:B@=6F:@(7@98D8<A(6(CJ;6A(F@8AG(=@?@=D@D(BC@(DJ>=@;@(

G=<JA7(<H(C8D(;6N8;D(FE(MC89C(C@(M6D(6A(@?8:(CJ;6A(F@8AG(W6A7(BC@=@FE(

>JBD(<A(6(UA@M(;6AVXK(C@(8D(B<(BC8D(@NB@ABK(FE(>=8A98>:@(6A7(6BB8BJ7@(<H(

;8A7K(6(DJF[@9B(=@9@>B8?@(B<(BC@(G<<7k(FJB(C@(8D(6(G<<7(CJ;6A(F@8AG(<A:E(

8A(8A9@DD6AB(:6F<=8AG(6A7(F@9<;8AGIII)<=(C8;(MC<(>@A@B=6B@D(B<(BC@(

8AB@::8G8F:@(G=<JA7(<H(BC@(C@6=B(WBC@(G=<JA7(<H(6::(BC@(;6N8;D(<H(BC@(><M@=(

<H(9C<89@XK(H<=(C8;(B<(MC<;(BC8D(@A7:@DD(>=<G=@DD(8D(6(JA8BEK(8I@I(H<=(Z<7K(

BC8D(8D(BC@(D6;@(6D(69BJ6::E(F@8AG(6(G<<7(CJ;6A(F@8AG(W>:@6D8AG(B<(C8;Xk(

6A7(B<(BC8D(@NB@AB(BC@(9C6AG@(96A(F@(9<AD87@=@7(6(=@?<:JB8<AI()<=(BC@(

[J7G;@AB(<H(CJ;6A(F@8AGDK(C<M@?@=K(MC<(96A(6DD@DD(BC@;D@:?@D(6A7(BC@(

DB=@AGBC(<H(BC@8=(;6N8;D(<A:E(FE(BC@(J>>@=(C6A7(BC@E(G68A(<?@=(BC@(D@AD@D(

8A(B8;@K(BC@(9C6AG@(8D(B<(F@(=@G6=7@7(<A:E(6D(6A(@?@=j9<AB8AJ8AG(DB=8?8AG(H<=(

BC@(F@BB@=III\_

2<=DG66=7(6=GJ@D(BC6B(M@(<A:E(B6:L(6F<JB(BC@(!"#$%%&%'+9C<89@(6D(6(=@?<:JB8<A(6A7(6(

78DB8A9B(=@D<:JB8<A(F@96JD@(M@(A@@7(B<(BC8AL(<H(8B(8A(BC8D(M6E(B<(@N>:68A(;<=6:(

=@D><AD8F8:8BEI\^*"<M@?@=K(DC@(9<A9:J7@D(H=<;(BC8D(>6DD6G@(BC6B(BC@(!"#$%%&%'+9C<89@K(8A(

8BD@:HK(=6BC@=(BC6A(6D(8B(6>>@6=DK(8D(=@6::E(<A:E(6(G=67J6:(9C6AG@(6A7(A<B(69BJ6::E(6(

\] 2<=DG66=7K(U/<=6:8BE(6D()=@@7<;KV(P_e(d(P_PI

\` 2<=DG66=7K(U/<=6:8BE(6D()=@@7<;KV(P_PI

\_ 26ABK((")$'$*%=+]aS_I(WUhTi@AA(@=(7@A(<F@=DB@A(Z=JA7(D@8A@=(/6N8;@AK(M<7J=9C(@=(@8A(FnD@=(/@AD9C(M6=K(7J=9C(@8A@(@8Ab8G@(JAM6A7@:F6=@(&ABD9C:8@mJAG(J;L@C=B(WJA7(C@8=;8B(@8A@A(A@J@A(/@AD9C@A(

6Ab@8CBXK(D<(8DB(@=(D<H@=AK(7@;($=8Ab8>(JA7(7@=(-@ALJAGD6=B(A69CK(@8A(Hl=D(ZJB@(@;>HoAG:89C@D(4JF[@LBk(

6F@=(AJ=(8A(L<AB8AJ8@=:89C@;(T8=L@A(JA7(T@=7@A(@8A(GJB@=(/@AD9CIII-8@D(8DB(Hl=(7@A[@A8G@AK(7@=(7@A(

8AB@::8G8F@:@A(Z=JA7(7@D("@=b@AD(W6::@=(/6N8;@A(7@=(T8::Ll=X(7J=9CD9C6JBK(Hl=(7@A(6:D<(78@D@(

+A@A7:89CL@8B(7@D()<=BD9C=8BB@D(&8AC@8B(8DBK(7I8I(Hl=(7@A[@A8G@AK(7@=(7@A(8AB@::8G8F@:@A(Z=JA7(7@D("@=b@AD(

W6::@=(/6N8;@A(7@=(T8::Ll=X(7J=9CD9C6JBK(Hl=(7@A(6:D<(78@D@(+A@A7:89CL@8B(7@D()<=BD9C=8BB@D(&8AC@8B(8DBK(

7I8I(Hl=(Z<BB(D<?8@:K(6:D(M8=L:89C(@8A(GJB@=(W8C;(G@Ho::8G@=X(/@AD9C@A(6F@=K(78@(D89C(JA7(78@(4Bo=L@(8C=@=(

/6N8;@A(AJ=(A69C(7@=(*F@=C6A7K(78@(D8@(lF@=(78@(48AA:89CL@8B(8A(7@=(p@8B(G@M8AA@AK(D9CoBb@A(LnAA@AK(

8DB(D8@(AJ=(6:D(@8A(8;;@=(H<=B76J@=A7@D(4B=@F@A(bJ;(Y@DD@=@AIIIVX

\^ 2<=DG66=7K(U/<=6:8BE(6D()=@@7<;KV(P_PI

Page 172: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

P]S

=@?<:JB8<AI(%C@=@H<=@K(<J=(9C<89@(8D(;67@(<A:E(<?@=(BC@(9<J=D@(<H(G=67J6:(8;>=<?@;@AB(<H(

<J=(69B8<ADI(.B(8D(A<B(6(78DB8A9B(69BI

Y6D@7(<A(BC8D(6=GJ;@ABK(4JDD;6A(9<A9:J7@D(BC6B(UBC@(;<=6:(F8<G=6>CE(<H(6AE(

=6B8<A6:(6G@AB(8BD@:H(C6D(BC@(<?@=6::(DB=J9BJ=@(<H(6A(8AB@AB8<A6:(69BIVRe(%C6B(8DK(BC@(

!"#$%%&%'+9C<89@(DC<J:7(A<B(F@(?8@M@7(6D(6(=@D<:JB8<A(B<(C6?@(6(G<<7(!"#$%%&%'(BC6B(

<99J=D(>=8<=(B<(6A(8;>=<?@;@AB(8A(<J=(69B8<ADI()<::<M8AG(2<=DG66=7K(C@(BC8ALD(BC6B(DJ9C(6(

=@D<:JB8<A(96A(<A:E(F@(6D9=8F@7(B<(6(>@=D<A(6HB@=(DC@(C6D(6:=@67E(F@@A(M<=L8AG(B<(8;>=<?@(

C@=(69B8<ADI(%C@=@H<=@K(BC@(!"#$%%&%'+9C<89@(8D(A<B(6(=@D<:JB8<A(BC6B(96A(F@(D@>6=6B@7(

H=<;(69BD(BC6B(96==E(<JB(BC@(=@D<:JB8<AI('6BC@=K(BC@(=@D<:JB8<A(B<(C6?@(6(G<<7(!"#$%%&%'+

<99J=D(<A:E(6D(6(>@=D<A(8D(:8?8AG(<JB(C@=(:8H@(8A(DJ9C(6(M6E(BC6B(DC<MD(BC6B(DC@(8D(

6BB@;>B8AG(B<(8;>=<?@(C@=(69B8<ADI

%C8D(8D(6(D<;@MC6B(9<JAB@=8ABJ8B8?@(9:68;K(6A7(4JDD;6A(6>>@6=D(B<(=@9<GA8b@(BC8DI(

"@(A<B@D(BC6B(BC@(!"#$%%&%'+9C<89@(D@=?@D(6D(BC@(UH<=;6:(G=<JA7(<H(6::(BC@(;<=6::E(

6DD@DD6F:@(9C<89@D(8A(<A@3D(:8H@IVRP(%E>896::EK(M@(>=@DJ;@(BC6B(6(9C<89@(BC6B(D@=?@D(6D(6(

H<=;6:(G=<JA7(;JDB(<99J=(9C=<A<:<G896::E(>=8<=(B<(MC6B(8B(G=<JA7DI("<M@?@=K(4JDD;6A(

6=GJ@D(BC6B(M@(H=@OJ@AB:E(7<(9@=B68A(69BD(U8AB@AB8<A6::EV(M8BC<JB(H8=DB(C6?8AG(;67@(6A(

@N>:898B(8AB@AB8<A(B<(7<(D<I("8D(@N6;>:@D(8A9:J7@(D><AB6A@<JD:E(G<8AG(H<=(6(M6:L(<=(

DB6=B8AG(6(9<A?@=D6B8<AI(4JDD;6A(BC8ALD(BC6BK(@?@A(BC<JGC(M@(;6L@(A<(78DB8A9B(9C<89@(<H(

8AB@AB8<A(8A(BC@D@(96D@DK(BC@(8AB@AB8<A(B<(7<(BC@(69B8<A(DB8::(D@=?@D(6D(BC@(H<=;6:(G=<JA7(H<=(

BC@D@(69B8<ADI(%C6B(8DK(;@=@:E(F@G8AA8AG(BC@(69B8<A(6A7(9<AB8AJ8AG(B<(7<(BC6B(69B8<A(9<JABD(

6D(H<=;8AG(6A(8AB@AB8<A(B<(7<(BC6B(69B8<AI(%C@(8AB@AB8<A(BC6B(D@=?@D(6D(BC@(H<=;6:(G=<JA7(

Re 4JDD;6AK(U$@=?@=D8BE(<H(BC@("@6=BKV(P`\I

RP 4JDD;6AK(U$@=?@=D8BE(<H(BC@("@6=BKV(P`\I

Page 173: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

P]Q

6A7(BC@(69B8<A(BC6B(8D(G=<JA7@7(FE(BC6B(8AB@AB8<A(<99J=(D8;J:B6A@<JD:E(6A7(6=@(A<B(

78DB8A9BIR\

4JDD;6A(6>>:8@D(BC8D(6=GJ;@AB(B<(BC@(96D@(<H(BC@(!"#$%%&%'+9C<89@I("@(M=8B@D(BC6B(

U*A(BC@(>89BJ=@(.(C6?@(DL@B9C@7K(BC@(69B(<H(9C<<D8AG(6(G<<7(78D><D8B8<A(8D(B<(F@(H<JA7(8A(

BC@(9<J=D@(<H(6(:8H@(BC6BK(6D(6(MC<:@K(9<JABD(6D(;6L8AG(J>(<A@3D(;8A7(B<(:8?@(;<=6::E(6A7(

6JB<A<;<JD:EI(%C8D(HJA76;@AB6:(=@D<:JB8<A(B<(:8?@(;<=6::E(8D(A<(;<=@(78DB8A9B(H=<;(6A(

<FD@=?6F:@(:8H@(<H(;<=6:(>=<G=@DD(BC6A(6(7@98D8<A(B<(M6:L(A@@7(F@(78DB8A9B(H=<;(6(

D><AB6A@<JD(DB=<::IVRR(%C@(;<=6:(>=<G=@DD(8A(<A@3D(69B8<ADK(BC@AK(9<JABD(6D(BC@(!"#$%%&%'+

9C<89@K(699<=78AG(B<(BC8D(6=GJ;@ABI(*A:E(<A9@(6(>@=D<A(C6D(6:=@67E(F@GJA(B<(8;>=<?@(C8D(

69B8<AD(96A(M@(D6E(BC6B(C@(C6D(;67@(BC@(9C<89@(B<(C6?@(6(G<<7(!"#$%%&%'I

=%>*2,&)(,-*7%$,-*!89$%:383"#*)0*?)#',#3&*)"*@,"#A0*B((%'"#*%1*7%$,-*

C3:3-%983"#

#HB@=(BC@(78D9JDD8<A(8A(!C6>B@=(%C=@@(=@G6=78AG(BC@(9<A78B8<AD(H<=(BC@(><DD8F8:8BE(

<H(BC@(=@?<:JB8<AK(8B(8D(A<MK(.(C<>@K(DJHH898@AB:E(9:@6=(BC6B(BC<D@(MC<(=@67(BC@(=@?<:JB8<A(6D(

6(;<=6:(9C6AG@(BC6B(96AA<B(<99J=(6B(6(9@=B68A(;<;@AB(8A(6(>@=D<A3D(:8H@(<=(;JDB(<99J=(

6:<AGD87@(6A(8;>=<?@;@AB(8A(69B8<AD(C6?@(A<B(HJ::E(B6L@A(8AB<(699<JAB(BC@(?6=8<JD(

9<;>:@N(>6=BD(<H(BC@(=@?<:JB8<AI(#D(.(M8::(7@H@A7(8A(BC8D(D@9B8<AK(BC@=@(6>>@6=D(B<(F@(G<<7(

=@6D<A(B<(F@:8@?@(BC6B(=67896:(;<=6:(8;>=<?@;@AB(<99J=D(8A(B8;@K(8A(BC@(D@AD@(BC6B(8B(96A(

F@(>:69@7(8A(6(B@;><=6:(D@OJ@A9@(<H(@?@ABDI(&?@A(BC<JGC(8BK(8A(>6=BK(<99J=D(BC=<JGC(6A(69B(

<H(A<J;@A6:(?<:8B8<A(6A7(8D(BC@=@H<=@(<JBD87@(<H(B8;@(6A7(D>69@(8A(BC8D(=@G6=7K(8B(8D(

8;>69B@7(FE(6A7(C6D(9@=B68A(9<AD@OJ@A9@D(8A(BC@(>C@A<;@A6:(M<=:7RS(BC6B(6::<M(JD(B<(B6:L(

R\ .F87I

RR .F87I

RS .(M8DC(B<(B6:L(6F<JB(BC@(9<AD@OJ@A9@D(<H(BC@(=@?<:JB8<A(8A(BC@(>C@A<;@A6:(M<=:7(8A(6(96=@HJ:(M6EI(.(7<(

Page 174: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

P]]

6F<JB(8B(6D(<99J==8AG(6D(>6=B(<H(BC@(B@;><=6:(D@OJ@A9@(<H(<J=(;<=6:(8;>=<?@;@ABI(

%C@(%8;@:@DDA@DD(#=GJ;@AB

#D(=@?8@M@7(8A(BC@(H8=DB(D@9B8<A(<H(BC8D(9C6>B@=K(BC@(;6[<=(>=<F:@;(<H(>:698AG(BC@(

=@?<:JB8<A(8A(6(BC@<=E(<H(;<=6:(7@?@:<>;@AB(C6D(F@@A(BC6B(;<=6:(8;>=<?@;@ABK(BE>896::E(

JA7@=DB<<7K(8A?<:?@D(6(B8;@:8A@(<H(@?@ABD(6A7(8;>=<?@;@ABD(BC6B(8;>69B(HJ=BC@=(@?@ABD(

6A7(8;>=<?@;@ABDI(%C6B(8DK(<J=(69B8<AD(6A7(8;>=<?@;@ABD(8A(B8;@(DC<J:7(;<?@(JD(B<M6=7(

BC@(G<6:(<H(F@8AG(;<=6::E(G<<7I("<M@?@=K(8H(<?@=9<;8AG(@?8:(<99J=D(BC=<JGC(6(9C<89@(BC6B(

8D(<JBD87@(<H(B8;@(6A7(96AA<B(F@(8;>69B@7(FE(>C@A<;@A6:(69B8?8B8@DK(BC@A(BC@(=@?<:JB8<A(

96AA<B(F@(D687(B<(F@(6(>6=B(<H(BC8D(L8A7(<H(8;>=<?@;@ABI(.A(BC8D(D@9B8<AK(.(M8::(>=<?87@(;E(

6=GJ;@AB(H<=(MCE(BC@(9C<89@(B<(JA7@=G<(BC@(=@?<:JB8<A(96A(F@(8;>69B@7(d(BC<JGC(A<B(

7@B@=;8A@7(d(FE(@;>8=896:(69B8?8B8@D(6A7(DC<J:7(A<B(F@(?8@M@7(6D(JA6F:@(B<(F@(>:69@7(6B(6(

;<;@AB(<H(6(>@=D<A3D(:8H@I

)8=DBK(.(M8::(677=@DD(MC6B(.(F@:8@?@(B<(F@(BC@(;6[<=(BM<(=@6D<AD(H<=(DJ>><=B8AG(BC@(

B=678B8<A6:(=@678AGK(677=@DD@7(8A(BC@(H8=DB(D@9B8<A(<H(BC8D(9C6>B@=I()8=DBK(BC@=@(@N8DBD(6(

9<;;<A:E(C@:7(F@:8@H(BC6B(6::(A<J;@A6:(9C<89@D(;JDB(F@(B8;@:@DD(8A(BC@(D@AD@(BC6B(BC@E(

96AA<B(<99J=(8A(6(D@OJ@A9@(<H(@?@ABD(8A(B8;@I($6J:(ZJE@=(=@H@=D(B<(BC8D(6D(BC@(U7<9B=8A@(<H(

B8;@:@DD(@?@ABD(<H(A<J;@A6:(9C<89@IVRQ(ZJE@=K(8A(6(=@?8@M(<H("@A=E(&I(#::8D<A3D(U26AB3D(

%C@<=E(<H()=@@7<;KVR]*>=<?87@D(6(C@:>HJ:(=@D><AD@(B<(BC<D@(MC<(C<:7(BC8D(7<9B=8A@K(

>6=B89J:6=:E(8A(BC@(96D@(<H(BC@(!"#$%%&%'+9C<89@I(ZJE@=(><8ABD(<JB(D<;@(=@6D<AD(B<(7<JFB(

A<B(8AB@A7(B<(D6E(BC6B(BC@(=@?<:JB8<A(<H(!"#$%%&%'(6JB<;6B896::E(G8?@D(6(>@=D<A(6(G<<7(@;>8=896:(9C6=69B@=I(%C8DK(<H(9<J=D@K(DB8::(=@OJ8=@D(G=67J6:(>=<G=@DD(<?@=(B8;@I("<M@?@=K(8B(7<@D(;6L@(BC8D(G=67J6:(

>=<G=@DD(8A(<A@3D(@;>8=896:(9C6=69B@=(><DD8F:@(6A7(BC@=@H<=@(;JDB(F@(D687(B<(C6?@(D<;@(9<AD@OJ@A9@(

=@G6=78AG(MC6B(M@(6=@(96>6F:@(<H(8A(B8;@I

RQ $6J:(ZJE@=K('@?8@M*<H(94%.E#+L6"*-7+*2+H-""<*D=(FE("@A=E(&I(#::8D<AK(L6"+N*&-%4)+*2+M6$)*#*567(_^I(\I(W)@FIK(P^^\Xa(Pe]

R] "@A=E(&I(#::8D<AI(94%.E#+L6"*-7+*2+H-""<*DJ

Page 175: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

P]`

BC6B(A<J;@A6:(9C<89@D(;JDB(F@(9<AD87@=@7(B8;@:@DD(8A(BC8D(D@AD@I(.A(C8D(=@>:E(B<(#::8D<A3D(

6=GJ;@AB(BC6B(A<J;@A6:(69BDK(DJ9C(6D(BC@(9C<89@(<H(6(!"#$%%&%'K(6=@(B8;@:@DDK(C@(M=8B@DK

"<:78AG(6(>=8A98>:@(;6E(F@(6(78D><D8B8<A(=6BC@=(BC6A(6A(@?@ABK(FJB(8B(8D(DB8::(

B@;><=6:K(6D(8D(<F?8<JD(H=<;(BC@(H69B(BC6B(<A@(96A(DB6=B(<=(9@6D@(B<(C<:7(6(

>=8A98>:@K(6D(8A(7@9878AG(B<(67<>B(8B(<=(DJ==@A7@=(8BIII&?@A(8H(8B(8D(A<B(7<A@(D@:Hj

9<AD98<JD:E(6A7(8BD(B@;><=6:(:<96B8<A(96AA<B(F@(>8Aj><8AB@7K(8B(8D(DB8::([JDB(6D(;J9C(

6(B@;><=6:(@?@AB(6D(BC@(<99J==@A9@(<H(h6i(7@D8=@(hB<(MC89C(M@(6>>:E(BC@(>=8A98>:@iK(

MC89C(;6E(A<B(F@(6(9<AD98<JD(6A7(>=@98D@:E(76B6F:@(@?@AB(@8BC@=IR`

ZJE@=3D(6=GJ;@ABK(8A(DC<=BK(8D(BC6B(8B(8D(<F?8<JD(BC6B(<J=(!"#$%%&%'+9C<89@(6A7(BC@(

DJFD@OJ@AB(C<:78AG(<H(BC6B(>=8A98>:@(8A(BC@(DB=J9BJ=@(<H(<J=(M8::(6=@(B@;><=6:(8A(D<;@(

D@AD@I(%C8D(8D(;67@(<F?8<JD(;@=@:E(FE(BC@(H69B(BC6B(26AB(BC8ALD(BC6B(M@(96A(DB6=B(6A7(DB<>(

C<:78AG(9@=B68A(!"#$%%&%'"%(6D(<J=(>=8<=8B8b@7K(HJA76;@AB6:(;6N8;I(%C8D(><8AB(8D(;67@(

@?@A(;<=@(H<=9@HJ::E(8H(M@(D8;>:E(9<AD87@=(BC6BK(:8L@(BC@(!"#$%%&%'+9C<89@K(@?@=E(9C<89@(

B<(7<(6(;<=6::E(G<<7(69B8<A(8A(>6=B89J:6=(96D@D(8D(6A(69B(<H(A<J;@A6:(?<:8B8<AIR_(.H(69BD(<H(

A<J;@A6:(?<:8B8<A(;JDB(F@(B8;@:@DD(8A(BC@(6F<?@(D@AD@K(BC@A(@?@=E(9C<89@(B<(7<(6(G<<7(

69B8<A(;JDB(6:D<(F@(JA6F:@(B<(F@(>:69@7(8A(6(D@OJ@A9@(<H(@?@ABD(8A(<J=(:8?@DI(%C8D(8D(

9:@6=:E(A<B(BC@(96D@I(&?@A(8H(M@(96AA<B(>8A><8AB(MC@A(BC6B(9C<89@(<99J==@7K(M@(7<(C6?@(6(

G@A@=6:(87@6(<H(MC@A(M@(;67@(6(H=@@(9C<89@(B<(7<(6(G<<7(69B8<A(F@96JD@(M@(96A(<FD@=?@(

BC@(=@DJ:B(<H(8Ba(BC@(69B8<AI(,69L8AG(BC@(LA<M:@7G@(<H(BC@(B8;@(6B(MC89C(BC@(9C<89@(<99J=D(

7<@D(A<B(=J:@(<JB(BC@(><DD8F8:8BE(BC6B(8B(7<@D(<99J=(6B(6(D>@98H89(B8;@I

c<CA(48:F@=(<HH@=D(6A<BC@=(6=GJ;@AB(8A(H6?<=(<H(7<JFB8AG(BC6B(A<J;@A6:(9C<89@D(

6=@(B8;@:@DD(8A(BC8D(D@AD@(8A(C8D(6=B89:@(U%C@(&BC896:(48GA8H896A9@(<H(26AB3D((")$'$*%JV("@(

M=8B@D(BC6BK(7@D>8B@(26AB3D(DB6B@;@ABD(B<(BC@(9<AB=6=EK(M@(;JDB(>=@DJ>><D@(6(C6=;<AE(

R` (ZJE@=K(=@?8@MK(Pe]I

R_ *H(9<J=D@K(F@96JD@(<H(BC@(DB=J9BJ=@(<H(BC@(CJ;6A(M8::K(BC@D@(9C<89@D(<H(;6N8;D(8A(>6=B89J:6=(96D@D(6=@(

8AH:J@A9@7(FE(<A@3D(9C<89@(<H(!"#$%%&%'I("<M@?@=K(BC@E(6=@(DB8::(B@9CA896::E(H=@@(9C<89@D(8AD<H6=(6D(BC@E(6=@(6JB<A<;<JDI

Page 176: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

P]_

F@BM@@A(BC@(>C@A<;@A6:(6A7(A<J;@A6:(M<=:7D(8A(<=7@=(B<(@N>:68A(C<M(M@(6D(A<J;@A6:(

F@8AGD(96A(M8::(9@=B68A(@A7D(8A(BC@(>C@A<;@A6:(M<=:7I(.A(H69BK(C@(G<@D(D<(H6=(6D(B<(9:68;(

BC6B(26AB(C6D(;67@(6(;8DB6L@(8A(7@AE8AG(BC6B(BC@(A<J;@A6:(=@6:;(8D(A<B(B@;><=6:K(UH<=(

;<=6:(?<:8B8<A(8D(8A@:J9B6F:E(B@;><=6:I(%C@(M8::(8D(B@;>B@7(8A(B8;@K(7@987@D(8A(B8;@K(6A7K(

7@>@A78AG(<A(8BD(7@98D8<AK(H@@:D(GJ8:BE(<=(D6B8DH8@7(8A(B8;@IVR^("@(><8ABD(B<(26AB3D(JD@(<H(

B@;><=6:(:6AGJ6G@(H<=(;<=6:(?<:8B8<A(6D(>=<<H(<H(BC8DI(%CJDK(@?@A(BC<JGC(26AB(7@A8@D(6A(

8AB@=69B8<A(F@BM@@A(BC@D@(M<=:7D(F@96JD@(<H(C8D(9<;;8B;@ABD(6A7(6DD@=B8<AD(8A(BC@(H8=DB(

,-$.$/&"+=@G6=78AG(CJ;6A(H=@@7<;KSe(48:F@=(BC8ALD(BC6B(M@(;JDB(=@9<GA8b@(BC6B(26AB(

C8;D@:H(9:@6=:E(DC<MD(BC6B(DJ9C(6A(8AB@=69B8<A(8D(A@9@DD6=EK(8A(<=7@=(B<(@N>:68A(;<=6:(

6G@A9EI(.A(H69BK(26AB(;JDB(C6?@(=@9<GA8b@7(BC@(>=<F:@;D(BC6B(BC@(D@?@=8AG(<H(BC@D@(M<=:7D(

96JD@D(H<=(C8D(;<=6:(BC@<=E(F@96JD@(C@(6BB@;>B@7(B<(D<:?@(8B(FE(;6L8AG(BC@(;<7@DB(

DB6B@;@AB(BC6B(A<J;@A6:(?<:8B8<A(96A(F@(9<AD87@=@7(=@GJ:6B8?@:E(B<(F@G8A(d(BC<JGC(A<B(

96JD@(j(9@=B68A(B@;><=6:(D@OJ@A9@D(8A(BC@(>C@A<;@A6:(M<=:7ISP(%C@D@(<FD@=?6B8<AD(

8A7896B@(BC6B(BC@(=@:6B8<ADC8>(F@BM@@A(A<J;@A6:(9C<89@D(6A7(BC6B(MC89C(<99J=D(8A(B8;@(

;6E(A<B(F@(6D(9JB(6A7(7=E(6D(BC8AL@=D(C6?@(8A7896B@7(6A7(BC6B(B@;><=6:8BE(6>>:8@D(B<(

A<J;@A6:(?<:8B8<AK(8A(D<;@(D@AD@I

TC8:@(.(M8::(A<B(=@D<:?@(BC@(8DDJ@(<H(C<M(@;>8=896:(9C6AG@D(96A(8;>69B(6(

A<J;@A6:K(H=@@K(JA7@B@=;8A@7(9C<89@K(.(M8::(;6L@(6(DJGG@DB8<A(6F<JB(C<M(B<(BC8AL(6F<JB(

BC@(=@:6B8<ADC8>(F@BM@@A(BC@(BM<I*/E(DJGG@DB8<A(M8::(F@(BC6B(M@(BC8AL(6F<JB(@;>8=896:(

9C6AG@D(6D(8AH:J@A98AG(FJB(A<B(7@B@=;8A8AG(<J=(A<J;@A6:(9C<89@DI(#(C@:>HJ:(78DB8A9B8<A(

H<=(BC8D(>=<F:@;(8D(BC@(78HH@=@A9@(F@BM@@A(7@B@=;8A8AG(6A7(8AH:J@A98AGI(TC8:@(@?@ABD(8A(

R^ 48:F@=K(U%C@(&BC896:(48GA8H896A9@(<H(26AB3D('@:8G8<AKV(N9?888(d(N98NI

Se 4@@(.F87K(N9?88I

SP 4@@(.F87K(N9?888(6A7(26ABK(!$'K(#QQ\gYQ`^I

Page 177: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

P]^

BC@(@;>8=896:(M<=:7(96AA<B(7@B@=;8A@(<J=(H=@@K(A<J;@A6:(?<:8B8<AK(8B(7<@D(D@@;(BC6B(<J=(

@;>8=896:(69B8?8B8@D(96A(8AH:J@A9@(<J=(A<J;@A6:(9C<89@D(M8BC<JB(;6L8AG(BC@;(JAH=@@(6A7(

96JD@7I(%C8D(7<@D(A<B(D<JA7(B<<(H6=(<HH(H=<;(<BC@=(>6DD6G@D(8A(26AB3D(@BC89DI*)<=(@N6;>:@K(

8A(BC@(3".4567#$8#+*2+3*-4)#=+26AB(DJGG@DBD(BC6B(BC@(9J:B8?6B8<A(<H(9@=B68A(H@@:8AGD(96A(

C@:>(JD(B<(69B(;<=6::EKS\(BC<JGC(;<=6::E(G<<7(9C<89@D(DB8::(;JDB(F@(;67@(6JB<A<;<JD:EK(

<=(M8BC<JB(F@8AG(7@B@=;8A@7(FE(@NB@=A6:(H<=9@D(DJ9C(6D(8A9:8A6B8<ADI

&?@A(8H(<J=(@;>8=896:(69B8<AD(96A(8;>69B(<J=(A<J;@A6:(9C<89@D(8A(D<;@(M6EK(8A(

MC6B(D@AD@(96A(M@(>:69@(BC6B(A<J;@A6:(9C<89@(B<(<?@=9<;@(@?8:(8A(6(D@OJ@A9@(<H(@?@ABD(

8A(B8;@f(T@(96A(H8A7(D<;@(6ADM@=D(B<(BC8D(FE(BJ=A8AG(B<($6B=89L()=8@=D<AK(MC<(C@:>D(B<(

6=B89J:6B@(8A(MC6B(D@AD@(BC@(=@?<:JB8<A(8D(6A7(8D(A<B(B@;><=6:(8A(C8D(M<=L(H-""<*D+4%<+

I%.6-*5*)*'7+$%+94%.E#+3*-4)+M6$)*#*567J*"@=@K(C@(A<B@D(BC6B(BC@(=@?<:JB8<A(U8D(%*. +

B@;><=6:(8A(BC@(D@AD@(BC6B(8B(7<@D(A<B(8A(8BD@:H(8A?<:?@(G=67J6:(=@H<=;III'6BC@=(BC6A(

8AB=<7J9@(6(B@;><=6:(A<B8<AK(BC@(MC<:@(><8AB(<H(BC@(B@=;(-"0*)&.$*%+8D(B<(DC8HB(4147+H=<;(

BC8AL8AG(<H(BC8D(9C6AG@(B@;><=6::EIVSR(%C6B(8DK(8B(96AA<B(F@(D687(B<(F@(6(B@;><=6:(@?@AB(8A(

BC@(BE>896:(D@AD@(F@96JD@(8B(96AA<B(B6L@(>:69@(<?@=(6(D@=8@D(<H(;<;@ABD(8A(B8;@I(.H(8B(787K(8B(

M<J:7(F@(6(G=67J6:(9C6AG@(8A(MC89CK(6B(9@=B68A(><8ABDK(M@(6=@(>6=B:E(G<<7(6A7(>6=B:E(@?8:I(

Y@96JD@(<H(26AB3D(9<;;8B;@AB(B<(=8G<=8D;K(BC8D(96AA<B(F@(BC@(96D@I(T@(;JDB(@8BC@=(F@(

HJ::E(G<<7(<=(HJ::E(@?8:(6A7(D<(BC@(=@?<:JB8<A(8BD@:H(96AA<B(DB=@B9C(<JB(<?@=(6(D@=8@D(<H(

;<;@ABDI

"<M@?@=K(6D(M@(C6?@(D@@A(8A(BC@(>=@?8<JD(BM<(9C6>B@=DK(=67896:(;<=6:(

8;>=<?@;@AB(7<@D(A<B(;@=@:E(8A?<:?@(BC@(9C<89@(B<(C6?@(6(G<<7(!"#$%%&%'(BC6B(96A(F@(

S\ 4@@(26ABK(//K(]aR^^I

SR )=8@=D<AK(H-""<*D+4%<+I%.6-*5*)*'7=+P\RI

Page 178: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

P`e

9<AB68A@7(8A(6(D8AG:@(?<:8B8<A6:(69BI('6BC@=K(BC@=@(;JDB(F@(>=@>6=6B8<A(8A(B8;@(BC6B(:@67D(B<(

JD(F@9<;8AG(M<=BCE(<H(BC@(=@?<:JB8<A(6A7(DJFD@OJ@AB(M<=L(8A(B8;@(<A(>=@>6=8AG(

<J=D@:?@D(B<(8;>=<?@(BC@(;<=6:(M<=BC(<H(<J=(>6=B89J:6=(69B8<ADI(%CJDK(MC8:@(BC@(69BJ6:(

DC8HB8AG(<H(<J=(!"#$%%&%'(H=<;(@?8:(B<(G<<7(96AA<B(F@(DB=@B9C@7(<JB(<?@=(6(D@=8@D(<H(

;<;@ABD(H<=(BC@(=@6D<AD(;@AB8<A@7(8A(BC@(>=@?8<JD(>6=6G=6>CK(BC@(@AB8=@(>=<9@DD(<H(

=67896:(;<=6:(8;>=<?@;@AB(;JDB(C6?@(D<;@(=@:6B8<ADC8>K(<=(C6=;<AEK(M8BC(BC6B(MC89C(

<99J=D(8A(B8;@I(#D()=8@=D<A(A<B@DK(U<A@(M8::(A<B(D8;>:E(<?@=9<;@(@?8:(BC=<JGC(8D<:6B@7(

9C<89@DI('6BC@=K(<A@(;JDB(@HH@9B(9C6AG@D(8A(BC@(@;>8=896:(8AH:J@A9@D(<A(<A@3D(9C6=69B@=IVSS(

Y@96JD@(=67896:(;<=6:(8;>=<?@;@AB(8A?<:?@D(;<=@(BC6A(6(D8AGJ:6=(A<J;@A6:(?<:8B8<A(B<(

F@(;<=6::E(G<<7(6A7(8ADB@67(=@OJ8=@D(BC8AGD(:8L@(87@AB8HE8AG(BC@(;<=6:(:6M(6A7(BC8AL8AG(

6F<JB(<J=D@:?@D(6D(F@8AGD(MC<(96A(<?@=9<;@(=67896:(@?8:KSQ(BC@=@(6=@(9:@6=:E(BC8AGD(BC6B(

M@(;JDB(7<(8A(B8;@(B<(>=@>6=@(<J=D@:?@D(F@H<=@(6A7(6HB@=(BC@(!"#$%%&%'+9C<89@(8A(<=7@=(B<(

HJ::E(9<;>:@B@(BC@(=@?<:JB8<AI(TC8:@(.(M8::(A<B(G<(8AB<(;<=@(7@B68:(6F<JB(BC8D(>=<9@DD(

M8BC8A(BC8D(9C6>B@=K(8B(8D(@A<JGC(B<(69LA<M:@7G@(BC6BK(MC8:@(A<J;@A6:(9C<89@D(BC@;D@:?@D(

;6E(F@(B8;@:@DD(8A(BC@(D@AD@(BC6B(9=8B89D(C6?@(><8AB@7(<JBK(=67896:(;<=6:(8;>=<?@;@AB(

96AA<B(F@(9<AB68A@7(8A(BC8D(L8A7(<H(9C<89@(6:<A@I('6BC@=K(8B(8D(6(;J9C(;<=@(9<;>:@N(

>=<9@DD(BC6B(8A?<:?@D(9@=B68A(@;>8=896:(9C6AG@D(M8BC8A(B8;@(BC6B(D@B(BC@(DB6G@(H<=(<=(

9<;>:@B@(BC8D(A<J;@A6:(9C<89@I

#D(M@(96A(D@@K(BC@=@(6=@(G=<JA7D(J><A(MC89C(M@(96A(D6E(BC6B(B@;><=6:8BE(6>>:8@D(

B<(=67896:(;<=6:(8;>=<?@;@ABK(7J@(B<(BC@(=@:6B8<ADC8>(F@BM@@A(A<J;@A6:(9C<89@D(6A7(

MC6B(<99J=D(8A(B8;@I(.H(BC8D(8D(B=J@K(BC@A(M@(96A(D6E(BC6B(8B(F@:<AGD(B<(6(D@OJ@A9@(<H(@?@ABD(

SS .F87K(PRQI

SQ 4@@(!C6>B@=D(\(6A7(RI

Page 179: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

P`P

8A(B8;@K(8AD<H6=(6D(M@(96A(;6L@(G=67J6:(9C6AG@D(B<(<J=D@:?@D(8A(B8;@K(MC89C(8;>69B(<J=(

:8L@:8C<<7(<H(;6L8AG(BC@(A<J;@A6:(9C<89@(B<(JA7@=G<(BC@(=@?<:JB8<AI(.A(BJ=AK(<A9@(M@(

C6?@(9C<D@A(6(A@MK(G<<7(!"#$%%&%'K(BC8D(A<J;@A6:(9C<89@(M8::(C6?@(9<AD@OJ@A9@D(8A(BC@(

@;>8=896:(M<=:7K(8A(B8;@I(TC8:@(M@(;6E(A<B(F@(6F:@(B<(>8A><8AB(BC@(B8;@(6B(MC89C(BC@(

=@?<:JB8<A(<99J=DK(M@(96A(9@=B68A:E(D6E(BC6B(8B(8D(>6=B(<H(6(D@OJ@A9@(<H(7@?@:<>;@AB6:(

@?@ABD(BC6B(DC<M(BC@;D@:?@D(8A(B8;@I

%C@(D@9<A7(D<J=9@(<H(DJ>><=B(H<=(BC8D(B=678B8<A6:(?8@M(<H(B8;@:@DDA@DD(D@@;D(B<(

6=8D@(H=<;(26AB3D(7@D9=8>B8<A(<H(BC@(9C<89@(B<(F@(=67896::E(@?8:(6D(C6?8AG(A<B(F@@A(@6=A@7(

8A(B8;@I(#D(.3?@(DC<MA(8A(BC@(H8=DB(D@9B8<A(<H(BC8D(9C6>B@=K(26AB3D(DB6B@;@AB(BC6B(BC@(9C<89@(

B<(F@(=67896::E(@?8:(96AA<B(<99J=(8A(B8;@(C6D(F@@A(?8@M@7(6D(6:D<(6>>:E8AG(B<(BC@(9C<89@(B<(

C6?@(6(G<<7(!"#$%%&%'(F@96JD@(F<BC(=@OJ8=@(;6L8AG(6(A<J;@A6:K(6A7(BC@=@H<=@(B8;@:@DDK(

9C<89@I("<M@?@=K(BC8D(?8@M(<?@=:<<LD(6(L@E(78DB8A9B8<A(F@BM@@A(BC@D@(BM<(9C<89@D(<H(

!"#$%%&%'I(%C@(>6DD6G@(8A(MC89C(26AB(DB6B@D(BC6B(BC@(9C<89@(B<(F@(=67896::E(@?8:(96AA<B(

F@(D687(B<(<99J=(8A(B8;@(W]a\QX(8D(6(>6DD6G@(8A(MC89C(26AB(8D(B=E8AG(B<(@N>:68A(C<M(M@(96A(

D6E(BC6B(CJ;6AD(C6?@(6(;<=6:(9C6=69B@=K(8A(BC8D(96D@K(;<=6:(@?8:K(FE(A6BJ=@(FJB(6:D<(

BC=<JGC(6(H=@@(9C<89@I(.A(<=7@=(B<(9:68;(BC6B(BC8D(H=@@(9C<89@(7@B@=;8A@D(6(>@=D<A3D(A6BJ=@(

H=<;(F8=BC(d(BC6B(8DK(F@H<=@(C8D(H8=DB(JD@(<H(H=@@7<;(d(26AB(9<;;8BD(C8;D@:H(B<(BC@(

DB6B@;@AB(BC6B(B<(D6E(BC6B(<A@(C6D(6(!"#$%%&%'(FE(A6BJ=@(U6D(6A(8AA6B@(9C6=69B@=8DB89V(8D(

BC@(D6;@(6D(D6E8AG(BC6B(BC6B(!"#$%%&%'(UC6D(A<B(F@@A(@6=A@7(8A(B8;@IVS](Y@96JD@(M@(

96AA<B(H8A7(6(DJF[@9B8?@(G=<JA7(H<=(BC8D(9C<89@K(8AD<H6=(6D(8B(8D(6(H=@@(9C<89@(6A7(BC@=@H<=@(

JA96JD@7K(26AB(DB6B@D(BC6B(8B(8D(>6=B(<H(<J=(A6BJ=@(=6BC@=(BC6A(C6D(F@@A(9C<D@A(6B(6(9@=B68A(

><8AB(8A(B8;@I

S] 26ABK((")$'$*%=+]a\QI

Page 180: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

P`\

%C@(=@6D<A(MCE(26AB(;6L@D(BC8D(DB6B@;@AB(6F<JB(BC@(B8;@:@DDA@DD(<H(BC@(=67896:(

@?8:(9C<89@(7<@D(A<B(6>>:E(B<(BC@(9C<89@(B<(C6?@(6(G<<7(!"#$%%&%'K(C<M@?@=I(%C@(9C<89@(

B<(C6?@(6(G<<7(!"#$%%&%'K(<A9@(<A@(8D(6:=@67E(=67896::E(@?8:K(8D(A<B(BC@(9C<89@(<H(<A@3D(

U8AA6B@V(;<=6:(A6BJ=@I(%C@(8AA6B@A@DD(8DDJ@(A<(:<AG@=(A@@7D(B<(F@(@N>:68A@7(8A(BC8D(96D@I(

26AB(8D(A<B(9:68;8AG(BC6B(6(>@=D<A(8D(9C<<D8AG(6(!"#$%%&%'(BC6B(M8::(F@(?8@M@7(6D(BC@(

;<=6:(9C6=69B@=(BC6B(C@(C6D(C67(D8A9@(F8=BCK(F@H<=@(C8D(H8=DB(JD@(<H(H=@@7<;I('6BC@=K(8A(BC@(

96D@(<H(=67896:(;<=6:(8;>=<?@;@ABK(BC@(<A:E(8DDJ@(8D(=@9<A98:8AG(A<J;@A6:(?<:8B8<AK(BC@(

H=@@(9C<89@(B<(C6?@(6(G<<7(!"#$%%&%'K(M8BC(BC@(B@;><=6:(D@OJ@A9@(<H(BC@(@;>8=896:(M<=:7I(

%C@=@(8D(A<(=@6D<A(B<(F@:8@?@K(BC@AK(BC6B(26AB(8AB@A7@7(BC@(DB6B@;@AB(BC6B(6(!"#$%%&%'+

UC6D(A<B(F@@A(@6=A@7(8A(B8;@V(B<(6>>:E(B<(BC@(9C<89@(<H(6(G<<7(!"#$%%&%'K(6D(M@::I(T@(

7<A3B(C6?@(B<(@N>:68A(C<M(BC8D(!"#$%%&%'(8D(8AA6B@(6A7(BC@=@H<=@(>6=B(<H(<J=(A6BJ=@(D8A9@(

F8=BCI(

%C@(/8DB6L@(<H(!<AH:6B8AG(BC@(%M<(4B6G@D

.H(M@(96A(D6EK(6D(.(C6?@(6=GJ@7K(BC6B(=67896:(;<=6:(8;>=<?@;@AB(<99J=D(6B(6(9@=B68A(

><8AB(8A(6(D@OJ@A9@(<H(@?@ABD(8A(<J=(:8?@DK(BC@A(M@(DC<J:7(=@?8@M(MC6B(;JDB(<99J=(>=8<=(B<(

BC8D(9C6AG@(6A7(MC6B(96A(<99J=(6HB@=M6=7DI(.(C6?@(6:=@67E(8A?@DB8G6B@7(BC8D(><8AB(B<(6(

:6=G@(@NB@AB(8A(>=@?8<JD(9C6>B@=DK(FJBK(H<=(BC@(D6L@(<H(BC8D(>6=B89J:6=(6=GJ;@ABK(8B(8D(M<=BC(

=@?8D8B8AG(BC8D(8DDJ@I(%C@=@(8D(DB=<AG(B@NBJ6:(DJ>><=B(H<=(BC@(BC@D8D(BC6B(BC@(=67896:(;<=6:(

8;>=<?@;@AB(;JDB(<99J=(>=8<=(B<(6A(8;>=<?@;@AB(8A(<J=(>6=B89J:6=(;6N8;D(6A7(69B8<ADI(

%C8D(BC@D8D(DB6A7D(8A(9<AB=6DB(M8BC(BC@(<A@(DJ>><=B@7(FE(4JDD;6A(6A7(2<=DG66=7K(

78D9JDD@7(8A(BC@(H8=DB(D@9B8<A(<H(BC8D(9C6>B@=I(%C@=@(6=@(D@?@=6:(=@6D<AD(H<=(=@[@9B8AG(BC@8=(

8AB@=>=@B6B8<A(<H(=67896:(;<=6:(8;>=<?@;@ABI()8=DBK(26AB(C8;D@:H(;6L@D(D@?@=6:(DB6B@;@ABD(

8A(BC@((")$'$*%+8A7896B8AG(BC6B(BC@(=@?<:JB8<A(;JDB(A@9@DD6=8:E(<99J=(>=8<=(B<(d(=6BC@=(BC6A(

Page 181: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

P`R

6:<AGD87@(j(6A(8;>=<?@;@AB(8A(<J=(69B8<ADI(4@9<A7K(BC@(=@?<:JB8<A(;JDB(<99J=(

9C=<A<:<G896::E(>=8<=(B<(6A(8;>=<?@;@AB(8A(<J=(69B8<AD(F@96JD@(8B(9=@6B@D(BC@(9<A78B8<AD(

H<=(BC@(><DD8F8:8BE(<H(DJ9C(9C6AG@I

%C@(H8=DB(=@6D<A(B<(=@[@9B(BC@(9<AH:6B8<A(<H(=67896:(;<=6:(8;>=<?@;@AB(M8BC(6A(

8;>=<?@;@AB(8A(<J=(>6=B89J:6=(69B8<AD(8D(F6D@7(<A(26AB3D(<MA(DB6B@;@ABD(6F<JB(BC@(

=@:6B8<ADC8>(F@BM@@A(BC@D@(BM<(L8A7D(<H(9C6AG@I(#D(A<B@7(6F<?@K(26AB(=@;6=LD(BC6B(BC@(

>=@D@A9@(<H(=67896:(@?8:(7<@D(A<B(9C6AG@(MC6B(7JBE(=@OJ8=@D(<H(JDI("<M@?@=K(C@(7<@D(BC8AL(

BC6B(8B(9C6AG@D(<J=(699<JAB(<H(;<=6:(@7J96B8<AI("@(M=8B@DK*(UhMi@(96AA<B(DB6=B(<JB(8A(BC@(

@BC896:(B=68A8AG(<H(<J=(9<A6BJ=6:(;<=6:(>=@78D><D8B8<A(B<(BC@(G<<7(M8BC(6A(8AA<9@A9@(

MC89C(8D(A6BJ=6:(B<(JD(FJB(;JDB(=6BC@=(F@G8A(H=<;(BC@(>=@DJ>><D8B8<A(<H(6(7@>=6?8BE(<H(<J=(

><M@=(<H(9C<89@(8A(67<>B8AG(;6N8;D(9<AB=6=E(B<(BC@(<=8G8A6:(@BC896:(>=@78D><D8B8<AIIIVS`(

26AB(8D(9:@6=(BC6BK(<A9@(M@(=@9<GA8b@(BC6B(CJ;6AD(6=@(=67896::E(@?8:(UFE(A6BJ=@KV(M@(;JDB(

9C6AG@(<J=(87@6D(<H(MC6B(8D(A@9@DD6=E(H<=(;<=6:(7@?@:<>;@ABI('67896:(;<=6:(

8;>=<?@;@AB(;JDB(<99J=(>=8<=(B<(6A(6BB@;>B(B<(8;>=<?@(BC@(;<=6:8BE(<H(<A@3D(69B8<AD(

F@96JD@(M@(;JDB(H8=DB(7@6:(M8BC(<?@=9<;8AG(<J=(>=<>@AD8BE(B<(@?8:I(26AB(DB6B@D(BC8D(@?@A(

;<=@(@N>:898B:E(8A(6A<BC@=(>6DD6G@(MC@A(C@(M=8B@D(BC6B(UhHi=<;(BC8D(8B(H<::<MD(BC6B(6(

CJ;6A(F@8AG3D(;<=6:(@7J96B8<A(;JDB(F@G8AK(A<B(M8BC(6A(8;>=<?@;@AB(<H(;<=@DK(FJB(M8BC(

BC@(B=6ADH<=;6B8<A(<H(C8D(6BB8BJ7@(<H(;8A7(6A7(BC@(@DB6F:8DC;@AB(<H(6(9C6=69B@=IIIVS_("@(8D(

9:@6=(BC6B(BC@D@(BM<(L8A7D(<H(9C6AG@(7<(A<B(<99J=(D8;J:B6A@<JD:E(FJB(<A@(W6A(

8;>=<?@;@AB(8A(;<=@DX(;JDB(F@(>=<9@@7@7(FE(BC@(<BC@=(W=67896:(;<=6:(8;>=<?@;@ABXI

%C@D@(DB6B@;@ABD(C8GC:8GCB(BC@(L@E(78HH@=@A9@(F@BM@@A(=67896:(;<=6:(

S` 26ABK((")$'$*%=+]aQPI

S_ 26ABK((")$'$*%=+]aS^I

Page 182: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

P`S

8;>=<?@;@ABK(6A7(BC@(!"#$%%&%'+9C<89@(8A(>6=B89J:6=K(6A7(BC@(9C<89@(B<(7<(;<=6::E(G<<7(

69B8<AD(8A(>6=B89J:6=(96D@DI(4JDD;6A(6A7(2<=DG66=7(8AB@=>=@B(BC@(<?@=9<;8AG(<H(=67896:(

@?8:(6D(@DD@AB86::E(<A:E(=@OJ8=8AG(BC@(9C<89@(<H(6(A@MK(G<<7(!"#$%%&%'I(#D(M@(C6?@(D@@AK(

BC8D(8D(A<B(BC@(96D@I('67896:(;<=6:(8;>=<?@;@AB(6:D<(=@OJ8=@D(DJ9C(BC8AGD(6D(BC@(

>=@>6=6B<=E(M<=L(<H(87@AB8HE8AG(BC@(;<=6:(>=<B<BE>@(6A7(9J:B8?6B8AG(C<>@(8A(BC@(

><DD8F8:8BE(<H(BC@(=@?<:JB8<A+>=8<=(B<(BC@(!"#$%%&%'+9C<89@=+6(;<=6:(=@F8=BC(BC6B(9<;>:@B@D(

BC@(=@?<:JB8<AK(6A7(BC@(67<>B8<A(<H(9@=B68A(F@:8@HD(BC6B(G8?@(JD(C<>@(BC6B(8B(8D(A<M(><DD8F:@(

B<(8;>=<?@(BC@(;<=6:(M<=BC(<H(<J=(69B8<ADI(%<(DB6B@(BC6B(6(>@=D<A(96A(G=67J6::E(7@?@:<>(6(

9<;;8B;@AB(B<(BC@(;<=6:(:6M(<?@=(B8;@(FE(D@:@9B8AG(;<=6::E(G<<7(;6N8;D(8A(>6=B89J:6=(

96D@D(8D(B<(<?@=:<<L(BC@(9<;>:@N8BE(<H(=67896:(;<=6:(8;>=<?@;@AB(6A7(BC@(;<;@AB6=E(

A6BJ=@(<H(BC@(=@?<:JB8<A(8BD@:HI()<=(8ADB6A9@K(6D(78D9JDD@7(6F<?@K(<A@3D(!"#$%%&%'+9C<89@(

96AA<B(D>6A(6(D@=8@D(<H(;<;@ABD(8A(B8;@I(.H(BC8D(M@=@(BC@(96D@K(6(>@=D<A(9<J:7K(6B(BC@(D6;@(

B8;@K(F@(F<BC(;<=6::E(G<<7(6A7(;<=6::E(@?8:I(.B(8D(<F?8<JDK(BC@AK(BC6B(BC@(=@?<:JB8<A(

96AA<BK(6D(BC@E(9<AB@A7K(G=67J6::E(<99J=(6:<AGD87@(6A(8;>=<?@;@AB(8A(<J=(69B8<ADI(&?@A(

HJ=BC@=K(BC<JGCK(8H(BC8D(M@=@(BC@(M6E(BC6B(=67896:(;<=6:(8;>=<?@;@AB(B<<L(>:69@K(8B(8D(

JA9:@6=(C<M(;<=6:(=@F8=BC(9<J:7(@?@=(<99J=(F@96JD@(8B(;JDB(B6L@(>:69@(6D(BC@(!"#$%%&%'+

9C<89@(B6L@D(>:69@K(8A(<=7@=(H<=(BC@(=@?<:JB8<A(B<(F@(9<;>:@B@7I(.H(BC@(!"#$%%&%'+9C<89@(8D(

6(G=67J6:(<A@K(BC@A(BC@=@(8D(A<(9:@6=(><8AB(6B(MC89C(M@(C6?@(D69=8H89@7(<J=(<:7(D@:?@D(6A7(

96A(F@([J7G@7(B<(F@(;<=6::E(A@M(>@<>:@I

#(D@9<A7(=@6D<A(H<=(=@[@9B8AG(BC8D(8AB@=>=@B6B8<A(8D(BC@(=@6D<A(MCE(26AB(DB6B@D(BC6B(

BC@(=@?<:JB8<A(;JDB(>=@9@7@(6A(8;>=<?@;@AB(8A(<J=(69B8<ADI(TC8:@(4JDD;6A(8D(9<==@9B(8A(

7@D9=8F8AG(BC@(=@?<:JB8<AK(6A7(BC@(!"#$%%&%'+9C<89@(8A(>6=B89J:6=K(6D(UH<JA76B8<A6:KV(C@(8D(

A<B(JD8AG(BC8D(B@=;(8A(6(M6E(BC6B(699<=7D(M8BC(26AB3D(7@D9=8>B8<AI(.A(<=7@=(B<(@N>:68A(BC8D(

Page 183: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

P`Q

78DB8A9B8<A(8A(BC@(D@AD@(<H(BC@(M<=7(UH<JA76B8<A6:KV(=@96::(4JDD;6A3D(@N6;>:@(<H(G<8AG(H<=(

6(M6:LI("@(6=GJ@D(BC6B(BC@(!"#$%%&%'+9C<89@(8D(H<JA76B8<A6:(8A(BC@(D@AD@(BC6B(BC@(9C<89@(

<H(BC@(8AB@AB8<A(B<(B6L@(6(M6:L(8D(H<JA76B8<A6:I("@(BC8ALD(BC6BK([JDB(6D(E<J(96A(H<=;(6A(

8AB@AB8<A(B<(G<(H<=(6(M6:L(6D(E<J(6=@(M6:L8AGK(E<J(96A(H<=;(E<J=(9C<89@(<H(!"#$%%&%'+6D(

E<J(6=@(6:=@67E(69B8AGI("<M@?@=K(.(>=<><D@(6(78HH@=@AB(@N6;>:@(BC6B(8D(B=J@=(B<(26AB3D(

699<JAB(<H(BC@(=@?<:JB8<AI(%C@(9C<89@(<H(!"#$%%&%'+8D(A<B(H<JA76B8<A6:(B<(BC@(

8;>=<?@;@AB(<H(<J=(>6=B89J:6=(69B8<AD(8A(BC@(D@AD@(BC6B(BC@(8AB@AB8<A(B<(B6L@(6(M6:L(8D(

H<JA76B8<A6:(B<(G<8AG(H<=(6(M6:LI('6BC@=K(8B(8D(H<JA76B8<A6:(8A(BC@(D@AD@(BC6B(H8=DB(C@6:8AG(

<A@3D(F=<L@A(:@G(8D(H<JA76B8<A6:(B<(G<8AG(H<=(6(M6:LI(.B(;JDB(A@9@DD6=8:E(<99J=(F@H<=@C6A7(

F@96JD@(8B(9=@6B@D(BC@(?@=E(><DD8F8:8BE(<H(BC@(69BI(#D(26AB(@N>:68ADK(UD<(:<AG(6D(BC@(

H<JA76B8<A(<H(BC@(;6N8;D(<H(BC@(CJ;6A(F@8AG(=@;68AD(8;>J=@K(h8Bi(96AA<B(F@(@HH@9B@7(

BC=<JGC(G=67J6:(-"2*-DJJJOS^+4JDD;6A3D(@N6;>:@(7<@D(A<B(96>BJ=@(BC6B(BC@(=@?<:JB8<A(8D(

H<JA76B8<A6:(8A(BC8D(D@AD@I

%C@=@(6=@(D@?@=6:(=@6D<AD(MCE(BC@(=@?<:JB8<A(8D(H<JA76B8<A6:(8A(BC8D(D@AD@I(.(C6?@(

=@?8@M@7(;6AE(<H(BC@D@(6F<?@K(FJB(.(M8::(DJ;;6=8b@(BC@;(8A(BC8D(D@9B8<A(6D(M@::I()8=DBK(

JA:@DD(M@(9C6AG@(<J=(HJA76;@AB6:(;6N8;(H=<;(@?8:(B<(G<<7K(M@(96AA<B(69B(J><A(G<<7(

;6N8;D(8A(>6=B89J:6=(96D@DI(#D(A<B@7(6F<?@K(BC@(DB6B@(<H(<J=(!"#$%%&%'(7@B@=;8A@D(6::(

:<M@=(;6N8;DI(%C6B(8DK(6(G<<7(!"#$%%&%'(;@6AD(BC6B(M@(6=@(9<;;8BB@7(B<(69B8AG(<A(G<<7(

;6N8;D(8A(>6=B89J:6=(96D@DK(6A7(6A(@?8:(<A@(;@6AD(BC6B(M@(6=@(9<;;8BB@7(B<(8GA<=8AG(BC@(

;<=6:(:6M(6A7(69B8AG(H=<;(8A9:8A6B8<A(8ADB@67I(T8BC<JB(9C6AG8AG(<J=(!"#$%%&%'K(BC@AK(M@(

6=@(JA6F:@(B<(69B(<A(G<<7(;6N8;D(8A(>6=B89J:6=(96D@D(6A7(BCJD(M@(96AA<B(8;>=<?@(BC@(

;<=6:(M<=BC(<H(<J=(69B8<ADI(4@9<A7K(26AB(8D(9:@6=(BC6B(M@(A@@7(B<(C6?@(C<>@(BC6B(M@(C6?@(

S^ 26ABK((")$'$*%=+]aS`I

Page 184: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

P`]

6(G<<7(HJA76;@AB6:(;6N8;(8A(<=7@=(B<(>=<9@@7(<A(BC@(>6BC(<H(8;>=<?8AG(<J=(69B8<ADI(

T8BC<JB(C6?8AG(9C6AG@7(BC6B(;6N8;(H=<;(@?8:(B<(G<<7K(MC89C(<A:E(<99J=D(BC=<JGC(BC@(

=@?<:JB8<AK(M@(C6?@(A<(M6E(<H(G68A8AG(BC8D(A@9@DD6=E(C<>@I(.ADB@67K(M@(M<J:7(H6::(8AB<(

7@D>68=(BC6B(;<=6:(8;>=<?@;@AB(8D(8;><DD8F:@I

D%"(-'0)%"

#D(M@(96A(D@@(H=<;(BC@(78D9JDD8<A(9<AB68A@7(8A(BC8D(9C6>B@=K(BC@(B=678B8<A6:(

=@6D<AD(H<=(F@:8@?8AG(BC6B(=67896:(;<=6:(8;>=<?@;@AB(96AA<B(F@(87@AB8H8@7(6D(6(JA8OJ@K(

78DB8A9B(DB6G@(8A(26AB3D(BC@<=E(<H(;<=6:(7@?@:<>;@AB(7<(A<B(C<:7(J>(B<(6(9:<D@(=@678AG(<H(

26AB3D(DB6B@;@ABD(6F<JB(BC@(<?@=9<;8AG(<H(=67896:(@?8:I(%C@(F@:8@H(BC6B(BC@(<?@=9<;8AG(<H(

@?8:(8D(6(;EDB@=8<JD(@?@AB(BC6B(C6D(A<(=@:6B8<ADC8>(B<(B8;@(=@DBD(J><A(6(H68:J=@(B<(9<AD87@=(

BC@(8AB=89698@D(8A?<:?@7(8A(BC@(>=<9@DD(:@678AG(J>(B<(6A7(H<::<M8AG(BC@(A<J;@A6:(9C<89@(B<(

9C6AG@(H=<;(C6?8AG(6A(@?8:(!"#$%%&%'(B<(6(G<<7(<A@I(YE(=@9<GA8b8AG(=67896:(;<=6:(

8;>=<?@;@AB(6D(6(78DB8A9B(DB6G@(<H(;<=6:(7@?@:<>;@AB(BC6B(96A(F@(D687(B<(<99J=(6B(6(

9@=B68A(><8AB(8A(<J=(B@;><=6:(:8?@DK(M@(96A(9<;@(B<(6(7@@>@=(JA7@=DB6A78AG(<H(26AB3D(

<?@=6=9C8AG(BC@<=E(<H(;<=6:(7@?@:<>;@ABI(#D(.(C6?@(DC<MAK(BC@(<?@=9<;8AG(<H(@?8:(8D(A<B(

;@=@:E(6(78DB8A9B(DB6G@(<H(7@?@:<>;@AB(FJB(6(H<JA76B8<A6:(<A@(BC6B(;JDB(F@(699<;>:8DC@7(

F@H<=@(6A(8;>=<?@;@AB(8A(<A@3D(69B8<AD(96A(<99J=I

Page 185: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

!"#!$%&'"#

()*)+,*-)./)*01*)+2-*3/04,5)6*'*-,)*07)*)0*8,90:-)/.),*)+.)*;.:)<-*2:)/0875)20:*01*)+,*

3/0=>,9*01*/.825.>*,?2>*2:*)+,*!"#$%$&'6*1./*1/09*=,2:@*2:50+,/,:)*A2)+*+2-*90/.>*

3+2>0-03+B6*-,/?,-*.-*.*5/752.>*)7/:2:@*302:)*2:*)+,*8,?,>039,:)*01*+2-*)+,0/B*01*90/.>*

293/0?,9,:)C*D0/,*-3,52125.>>B6*'*./@7,8*)+.)*)+,*0?,/5092:@*01*/.825.>*,?2>6*.*:,,8*

2:)/0875,8*2:*)+,*!"#$%$&'()2-*.*82-)2:5)*.:8*107:8.)20:.>*-).@,*01*;.:)<-*)+,0/B*01*+79.:*

90/.>*8,?,>039,:)*)+.)*+.-*=,,:*>./@,>B*2@:0/,8*.:8*92-7:8,/-)008*2:*)+,*-,50:8./B*

>2),/.)7/,C*'*+03,*)+.)*'*+.?,*:0A*9.8,*9B*5.-,*-711252,:)>B*5>,./*.:8*)+.)*)+2-*3/04,5)*

9.B*=,*)+,*293,)7-*10/*17)7/,*2:?,-)2@.)20:*0:*)+,*)0325*01*/.825.>*90/.>*293/0?,9,:)C

E0*/,?2,A6*'*12/-)*/,-30:8,8*)0*)+,*5+./@,*[email protected]:-)*)+,*!"#$%$&'))+.)*2)*1.2>-*)0*

50+,/,*A2)+*;.:)<-*3+2>0-03+25.>*3/04,5)-*.:8*50/37-6*@,:,/.>>B6*=B*2>>7-)/.)2:@*)A0*

2930/).:)*A.B-*)+.)*)+2-*A0/F*50:)/2=7),-*)0*;.:)<-*90/.>*3+2>0-03+BG*=B*,H3>.2:2:@*+0A*

+79.:-*5.:*1/,,>B*5+00-,*90/.>*,?2>*.:8*=B*302:)2:@*)0*)+,*-07/5,*01*90/.>*,?2>*2:*

+79.:-C*E+,-,*)A0*2--7,-6*3/20/*)0*)+,*!"#$%$&'()+.8*,2)+,/*=,,:*7:47-)212,8*0/*7:5>,./*2:*

;.:)<-*A/2)2:@-C*#,H)6*'*2:)/0875,8*.*3/,?207->B*0?,/>00F,8*5.-,*2:*A+25+*)+,*!"#$%$&')

5.:*50:)/2=7),*)0*07/*7:8,/-).:82:@*01*;.:)<-*90/.>*3+2>0-03+BG*)+,*5.-,*01*+79.:*90/.>*

293/0?,9,:)C*E+/07@+*.*5093./2-0:*01*;.:)<-*A0/F-*0:*90/.>*,875.)20:*A/2)),:*=,10/,*

.:8*.1),/*)+,*!"#$%$&'()'*-+0A,8*)+.)*8211,/,:5,-*2:*)+,-,*A0/F-*)+.)*0)+,/*5099,:).)0/-*

+.?,*302:),8*)0*=7)*1.2>,8*)0*.8,I7.),>B*,H3>.2:*5.:*=,*5>./212,8*=B*>00F2:@*)0*;.:)<-*

5>.29*2:*)+,*!"#$%$&'))+.)*.>>*+79.:-*./,*/.825.>>B*,?2>*.:8*97-)*0?,/509,*)+2-*-).),

JKK

Page 186: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

JKL

*)+/07@+*.*/.825.>*90/.>*)/.:-10/9.)20:C

'*-3,:)*)+,*-,50:8*+.>1*01*9B*3/04,5)*>.B2:@*07)*A+.)*)+,*0?,/5092:@*01*/.825.>*

,?2>*,:).2>-*.:8*+0A*A,*5.:*7:8,/-).:8*2)-*30--2=2>2)B6*2:*!+.3),/*E+/,,6*.:8*)+,:*./@72:@*

10/*2)-*3>.5,*.-*.*82-)2:5)*.:8*107:8.)20:.>*-).@,*01*90/.>*8,?,>039,:)6*2:*!+.3),/*M07/C*

':*802:@*-06*'*:0)*0:>B*3/0?28,8*.*8,).2>,8*.5507:)*01*A+.)*;.:)*)+2:F-*2-*:,5,--./B*)0*

0?,/509,*/.825.>*,?2>*.:8*+0A*2)*12)-*2:*A2)+*)+,*/,-)*01*+2-*)+,0/B*01*90/.>*8,?,>039,:)*

=7)*/,-30:8,8*)0*-,?,/.>*./,.-*01*8,=.),*2:*)+,*-,50:8./B*>2),/.)7/,C*

':*!+.3),/*E+/,,6*'*./@7,8*[email protected]:-)*/,.82:@-*01*/.825.>*90/.>*293/0?,9,:)*)+.)*

5+./.5),/2N,*2)*.-*2930--2=>,*)+/07@+*+79.:*30A,/-*.>0:,*.:8*.-*/,I72/2:@*)+,*

-733>,9,:)./B6*)+07@+*7:,./:,86*.28*01*.:*2:),>>2@2=>,*=,2:@C*'*828*-0*=B*=/,.F2:@*80A:*

/.825.>*90/.>*293/0?,9,:)*2:)0*.=-)/.5)6*82-)2:5)*909,:)-*O*)+,**"+$'','%)5+025,6*)+,*

90/.>*/,=2/)+6*.:8*)+,*.)).2:9,:)*01*)+,*5.3.52)B*)0*293/0?,*3./)257>./*.5)20:-*P**.:8*

-+0A2:@*+0A*,.5+*507>8*=,*7:8,/-)008*=B*+79.:-*.-*30--2=>,C*':*!+.3),/*M07/6*'*./@7,8*

[email protected]:-)*)+,*3037>./*/,.82:@*01*/.825.>*90/.>*293/0?,9,:)*.-*)29,>,--*2:*)+,*-,:-,*)+.)*2)*

5.::0)*=,*3>.5,8*2:*.*-,I7,:5,*01*,?,:)-*2:*)29,*.:86*/,>.),8>B6*.-*0557//2:@*.>0:@-28,*.:*

293/0?,9,:)*2:*07/*3./)257>./*.5)20:-C*':*0/8,/*)0*80*)+2-6*'*>.28*07)*.:*.>),/:.)2?,*.5507:)*

01*)29,>,--:,--*)+.)*-)2>>*.>>0A-*/.825.>*90/.>*293/0?,9,:)*)0*0557/*2:*.*),930/.>*

-,I7,:5,*01*90/.>*8,?,>039,:)*.:8*./@7,8*)+.)*/.825.>*90/.>*293/0?,9,:)*.:8*.:*

293/0?,9,:)*2:*07/*3./)257>./*.5)20:-*5.::0)*=,*50:1>.),86*2:-01./*.-*)+,*10/9,/*97-)*

0557/*=,10/,*)+,*>.)),/C

'*-,,*9B*3/04,5)*.-*+.?2:@*)A0*3/29./B*@0.>-*.:8*30),:)2.>*50:)/2=7)20:-*)0*)+,*

-,50:8./B*>2),/.)7/,6*A+25+*'*.>>78,8*)0*2:*)+2-*3/04,5)<-*2:)/0875)20:*=7)*828*:0)*17>>B*

,H3>.2:C*M2/-)6*'*A2-+*)0*./@7,*)+.)*A,*97-)*2:50/30/.),*/.825.>*90/.>*293/0?,9,:)*2:)0*

Page 187: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

JKQ

07/*/,.82:@*01*;.:)<-*.5507:)*01*90/.>*8,?,>039,:)C*':*1.2>2:@*)0*+.?,*80:,*-0*2:*)+,*

3.-)6*5099,:).)0/-*+.?,*1.>>,:*-+0/)*01*.*17>>*.:8*.557/.),*7:8,/-).:82:@*01*)+,*

2:)/25.52,-*01*+2-*.5507:)*01*+0A*.*+79.:*5.:*=,509,*90/.>>B*@008C*RB*2:5>782:@*)+,*

:,,8*)0*0?,/509,*/.825.>*,?2>6*A,*@.2:*.*/25+,/*-)0/B*O*0:,*)+.)*2:?0>?,-*:0)*0:>B*)+,*:,,8*

)0*293/0?,*3./)257>./*.5)20:-*2:*-3,521256*2-0>.),8*5.-,-*=7)*.>-0*)+,*:,,8*)0*50992)*

07/-,>?,-*17:8.9,:).>>B*)0*)+,*).-F*01*=,5092:@*90/.>>B*@008C

DB*-,50:8*@0.>6*A+25+*2-*2:,H)/25.=>B*)2,8*)0*)+,*12/-)6*2-*)0*50:)/2=7),*)0*.*90/,*

.557/.),6*>,--*9B-),/207-*7:8,/-).:82:@*01*/.825.>*90/.>*293/0?,9,:)*2)-,>1C*

%:8,/-).:82:@*)+,*0?,/5092:@*01*/.825.>*,?2>*.-*,2)+,/*2930--2=>,*0/*.-*7:.=>,*)0*=,*

3>.5,8*2:*.*-,I7,:5,*01*,?,:)-*2:*07/*),930/.>*>2?,-*2-*=0)+*2:.557/.),6*.-*'*+.?,*-+0A:6*

.:8*9.F,-*2)*2930--2=>,*10/*7-*)0*).>F*.=07)*2)*.-*.*82-)2:5)*.:8*50:5/,),*3./)*01*90/.>*

293/0?,9,:)C*(-*'*+.?,*-+0A:*A2)+*,?28,:5,*1/09*)+,*-"./012+$3+)&4)-&5/#+();.:)*

5>,./>B*2:),:8,8*10/*)+2-*0?,/5092:@*)0*=,*.*:,5,--./B*.:8*107:8.)20:.>*3./)*01*+79.:*

90/.>*293/0?,9,:)C*':*0/8,/*)0*2:),/3/,)*)+2-*)/.:-10/9.)20:*.-*;.:)*2:),:8,86*A,*97-)*

509,*)0*/,.8*)+,*0?,/5092:@*01*/.825.>*,?2>*.-*.*-).@,!)+.)*2-*5093.)2=>,*A2)+*)+,*

293/0?,9,:)-*A,*9.F,*2:*07/*,932/25.>*>2?,-C

DB*+03,*2-*)+.)*9B*3/04,5)*A2>>*1.52>2).),*17/)+,/*/,-,./5+*O*=0)+*2:*9B*0A:*A0/F*

.:8*2:*)+,*A0/F*01*0)+,/-*P*)+.)*-,,F-*)0*8,9B-)21B*)+,*3/05,--*01*0?,/5092:@*/.825.>*,?2>*

.:8*/,50@:2N,*2)-*2930/).:5,*2:*;.:)<-*90/.>*3+2>0-03+BC*E+,/,*2-*975+*)0*=,*-.286*=0)+*

2:*;.:)<-*,)+25-*.:8*@,:,/.>>B6*.=07)*A+.)*2)*9,.:-*)0*50992)*07/-,>?,-*)0*90/.>2)B*3/20/*

)0*293/0?2:@*)+,*90/.>*A0/)+*01*07/*3./)257>./*.5)20:-C*":,*1/72)17>*./,.*01*17)7/,*

/,-,./5+*2-*.:*2:?,-)2@.)20:*01*A+.)*)+,*17>>*-3.:*01*;.:)2.:*+79.:*90/.>*293/0?,9,:)*

>00F-*>2F,6*1/09*)+,*=,@2::2:@*-).@,*01*/.825.>*,?2>6*)+/07@+*)+,*3/,P/,?0>7)20:./B*

Page 188: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

JLS

3/,3./.)20:-6*)0*)+,*0?,/5092:@*01*/.825.>*,?2>*.:8*)+,*-7=-,I7,:)*293/0?,9,:)*01*

3./)257>./*.5)20:-C*(*3/04,5)*01*)+2-*-0/)*+.-*:0)*B,)*=,,:*.55093>2-+,8*2:*;.:)2.:*

-,50:8./B*>2),/.)7/,6*.:8*'*+03,*)0*50:)2:7,*9B*3/04,5)*2:*)+2-*82/,5)20:C*E+2-*3/04,5)*

A07>8*/,I72/,*.*8,,3,/*2:?,-)2@.)0:*01*)+,*/,>.)20:-+23*=,)A,,:*)+,**"+$'','%)5+025,6*0/*

)+,*50992)9,:)*)0*=,5092:@*90/.>>B*@0086*.:8*.*17)7/,*>21,*01*@/.87.>*90/.>*3/0@/,--C*'*

+03,*)0*50:)2:7,*)0*,H3>0/,*)+2-**"+$'','%)5+025,6*-0*)+.)*A,*9.B*509,*)0*.*=,)),/*

7:8,/-).:82:@*01*A+.)*-75+*.*5+025,*,:).2>-C*')*2-*B,)*7:8,),/92:,86*2:*)+,*-,50:8./B*

>2),/.)7/,6*A+,)+,/*;.:)*)+2:F-*)+.)*.*3,/-0:*97-)*9.F,*.:*,H3>252)6*50:-5207-*8,52-20:*)0*

50992)*)0*.5)2:@*1/09*)+,*90/.>*>.A*0/*A+,)+,/*2)*5.:*=,*.*-7=)>,/6*90/,*293>252)*5+025,*

)+.)*2-*10>8,8*2:)0*07/*>2?,-*2:*.*>,--*50:-5207-*A.BC*E+2-*2-*.:*./,.*)0*A+25+*'*+03,*9B*

17)7/,*A0/F*A2>>*3/0?28,*5>./2)BC

Page 189: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

!"#"!"$%"&'()*

+,-./0&!12345&63447839:&(;541,<=571;&51&!"#$%$&'()$*+$'(*+"(,&-'./0$"1(&2(3"0"(

!"/1&'4(2>&(..-;<3?&@-;5:(*4-;/?-53,&-;,&3,753,&2>&+??3;&A11,&-;,&B314C3&,7&

B71D-;;70&D77&E&FFF77:&%-.247,C3G&%-.247,C3&H;7D34/75>&I43//0&JKLK:

+??7/1;0&M3;4>&":&5/'*61(7+"&08(&2(90"".&:;(%-.247,C3G&%-.247,C3&H;7D34/75>&I43//0&

LNNK:

+??7/1;0&M3;4>&":&OP;&583&Q34>&(,3-&1R&-&I41S3;/75>&51&"D7?:T&7+"(<&-0'/#(&2(=/#-"(

>'?-$08(UV&WJKKJXG&UUY&E&Z[:

+5\7;/1;0&%-.7?3:&O@-;5&1;&M<.-;&$-5<43&-;,&!-,7=-?&"D7?:T&@+$#&1&A+8(/'.(7+"&#&%8(

LN:&LEJ:&WJKKYXG&JL]&E&JZ:

^-=7;0&)53R-;1:&O*83&63-;7;C&1R&583&B0$*$?-"(&2(@0/C*$C/#(!"/1&'(R14&614-?&^37;C/G&583&

_1=547;3&1R&63581,&1R&I<43&I4-=57=-?&!3-/1;:T&(;&5/'*61(%4757`<3&1R&I4-=57=-?&

!3-/1;G&D(B0$*$C/#(E-$."4(3,753,&2>&+;,439/&!3-58&-;,&a3;/&*7..34.-;0&LNY&b&

JL]:&%-.247,C3G&%-.247,C3&H;7D34/75>&I43//0&JKLK:

^-4580&@-4?:&@0&*"1*/'*(7+&-%+*(20&:(!&-11"/-(*&(!$*1C+#;&*4-;/?-53,&2>&^47-;&%1c3;/:&

$39&d14\G&)7.1;&-;,&)=8</5340&LNVN:

^3=\0&'397/&A8753:&O@-;5&1;&",<=-571;:T&7;&F11/81(&'(5/'*(/'.(G-:";(*4-;/?-53,&2>&

'397/&A8753&^3=\;($39&M-D3;G&d-?3&H;7D34/75>&I43//0&LNY[:

^34;/537;0&!7=8-4,&a:&!/.$C/#(FH$#I(D(@+$#&1&A+$C/#(>'*"00&%*$&';(PFR14,G&I1?75>&I43//0&

JKKJ:

%-/93??0&6-55839:&O@-;5e/&%1;=3S571;&1R&583&M7C83/5&B11,0&583&E"1$''-'%4(-;,&583&

*8314>&1R&!-,7=-?&"D7?:T&5/'*JK*-.$"'(NY:&J:&WJKKVXG&L[Z&E&JKN:

%->C7??0&M19-4,:&OH;,34/5-;,7;C:T&(;&D(5/'*(L$C*$&'/08;(",753,&2>&M19-4,&%->C7??:(

PFR14,G&^?-=\93??&I<2?7/87;C0&LNN]:

_-D7,1D7=80&+,7;-:&OM19&51&!3-,&!3?7C71;&97587;&583&'7.75/&1R&!3-/1;&+?1;3:T&5/'*J

K*-.$"'([]:&L:&WLNNZXG&L&E&LZ:

#-=\3;837.0&".7?&':&O@-;5&-;,&!-,7=-?&"D7?:T&M'$H"01$*8(&2(7&0&'*&(N-/0*"0#8(JU&

WLN]ZXG&UUN&b&]U:

L[L

Page 190: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

L[J

#743/51;30&%847/&':&-;,&$-58-;&a-=12/:&>'(L"2"'1"(&2(5/'*61(!"#$%$&';((;,7-;-S1?7/G&

(;,7-;-&H;7D34/75>&I43//0&JKK[:

#14.1/-0&I-<?:&O@-;5&1;&583&!-,7=-?&"D7?&1R&M<.-;&$-5<43:T&7+"(@+$#&1&A+$C/#(9&0-:(

U[:&U:&WJKKYXG&JJL&E&Z]:

#14.1/-0&I-<?:&O#41.&_7/=7S?7;3&51&+<51;1.>G&@-;5e/&*8314>&1R&614-?&_3D3?1S.3;5:T&

(;&5/'*(/'.(F.-C/*$&'I(>'*"0A0"*/*$&'1(/'.(B&::"'*/080&3,753,&2>&@?-/&!158&

-;,&%847/&A:&)<4S43;-;50&LVU&E&YV:&$39&d14\G&!1<5?3,C30&JKLJ:

#43./53,-?0&!13:&O@734\3C--4,e/&,1<2?3&.1D3.3;5&1R&R-758&-;,&@-;5e/&.14-?&R-758:T&

!"#$%$&-1(K*-.$"1(Z[:&J:&Wa<;3&JKLJXG&LNN&b&JJK:

#4734/1;0&I-547=\&!:&90"".&:(/'.(D'*+0&A&#&%8($'(5/'*61(3&0/#(@+$#&1&A+8;(%-.247,C3G&

%-.247,C3&H;7D34/75>&I43//0&JKKU:

B<>340&I-<?:&O"F-.S?3/&1R&614-?&I1//727?75>:T&(;&5/'*(/'.(F.-C/*$&'I(>'*"0A0"*/*$&'1(

/'.(B&::"'*/084(3,753,&2>&@?-/&!158&-;,&%847/&A:&)<4S43;-;50&LJZ&E&U[:&$39&

d14\G&!1<5?3,C30&JKLJ:

B<>340&I-<?:&!3D739&1R&5/'*61(7+"&08(&2(90"".&:4&2>&M3;4>&":&+??7/1;:&7+"(<&-0'/#(&2(

@+$#&1&A+8&[N:&J&W#32:0&LNNJXG&NNELLK:

M34.-;0&^-42-4-:&O*4-7;7;C&51&+<51;1.>G&@-;5&-;,&583&f<3/571;&1R&614-?&",<=-571;:T&

(;&@+$#&1&A+"01(&'(F.-C/*$&'I(G$1*&0$C/#(@"01A"C*$H"14(3,753,&2>&+.g?73&

P\/3;234C&!145>0&J]Z&b&YL:($39&d14\G&!1<5?3,C30&LNN[:

@-;50&(..-;<3?:&O+;&+;/934&51&583&f<3/571;G&A8-5&7/&";?7C853;.3;5hT&(;&@0/C*$C/#(

@+$#&1&A+84(LY&E&JJ;(%-.247,C3G&%-.247,C3&H;7D34/75>&I43//0&LNNV:

@-;50&(..-;<3?:&O*83&";,&1R&+??&*87;C/:T&(;&!"#$%$&'()$*+$'(*+"(,&-'./0$"1(&2(3"0"(

!"/1&'(/'.(O*+"0(P0$*$'%1;(",753,&2>&+??3;&A11,&-;,&B314C3&,7&B71D-;;70&LN]&E&

JK]:&%-.247,C3G&%-.247,C3&H;7D34/75>&I43//:&LNN[:

@-;50&(..-;<3?:&D'*+0&A&#&%8(20&:(/(@0/%:/*$C(@&$'*(&2(=$");(*4-;/?-53,&2>&Q7=514&

'>?3&_19,3??:&%-421;,-?30&('G&)1<5834;&(??7;17/&H;7D34/75>&I43//0&LNY[:

@-;50&(..-;<3?:&B0$*$?-"(&2(@0/C*$C/#(!"/1&';((;&@0/C*$C/#(@+$#&1&A+84(54-;/?-53,&-;,&

3,753,&2>&6-4>&a:&B43C140&LU]&E&JYL:&%-.247,C3G&%-.247,C3&H;7D34/75>&I43//:&

LNNV:

@-;50&(..-;<3?:&B0$*$?-"(&2(*+"(@&)"0(&2(<-.%:"'*;(",753,&2>&I-<?&B<>34:&*4-;/?-53,&2>&

I-<?&B<>34&-;,&"47=&6-55839/:&%-.247,C3G&%-.247,C3&H;7D34/75>&I43//:&JKKK:

@-;50&(..-;<3?:&L$"(3"*/A+81$Q(."0(K$**"';(#7/=834:&LNNK:

Page 191: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

L[U

@-;50&(..-;<3?:&L$"(!"#$%$&'($''"0+/#R(."0(E0"'S"'(."0(R#&T"'(="0'-'2*;(M-.2<4CG&!

M7..3?83234&i&%1:&LN]V:

@-;50&(..-;<3?:&E0&-'.)&0Q(&2(*+"(3"*/A+81$C1(&2(3&0/#1;((;&@0/C*$C/#(@+$#&1&A+84((

54-;/?-53,&-;,&3,753,&2>&6-4>&a:&B43C140&ZU&E&LK[:(%-.247,C3G&%-.247,C3&

H;7D34/75>&I43//:&LNNV:

@-;50&(..-;<3?:&E0-'.#"%-'%(S-0(3"*/A+81$Q(."0(K$**"';(M-.2<4CG&Q34?-C&D1;&#3?7F&

637;34:&LNV]:

@-;50&(..-;<3?:&50$*$Q(."0(@0/C*$1C+"'(="0'-'2*;('1;,1;G&!1<5?3,C3j*813..3/&I43//:&

LNNZ:

@-;50&(..-;<3?:&3"*/A+8$1C1(&2(3&0/#1;(7;&@0/C*$C/#(@+$#&1&A+8;%-.247,C3G&%-.247,C3&

H;7D34/75>&I43//:&LNNV:(

@-;50&(..-;<3?:&!"#$%$&'()$*+$'(*+"(,&-'./0$"1(&2(3"0"(!"/1&';(*4-;/?-53,&-;,&3,753,&

2>&+??3;&A11,&-;,&B314C3&,7&B71D-;;7:&%-.247,C3G&%-.247,C3&H;7D34/75>&I43//:&

LNN[:

@14/C--4,0&%847/57;3&6-471;:&O614-?75>&-/&#433,1.:T&(;&B0"/*$'%(*+"(5$'%.&:(&2(F'.14(

2>&%847/57;3&6-471;&@14/C--4,0&L]N&E&L[Y:(%-.247,C3G&%-.247,C3&H;7D34/75>&

I43//:&LNNV:

@14/C--4,0&%847/57;3:&B0"/*$'%(*+"(5$'%.&:(&2(F'.1;(%-.247,C3G&%-.247,C3&H;7D34/75>&

I43//0&LNNN:

@<38;0&6-;R43,:&O@-;5&1;&",<=-571;0&+;5841S1?1C>0&-;,&"587=/:T&(;&5/'*(/'.(

F.-C/*$&'I(>'*"0A0"*/*$&'1(/'.(B&::"'*/084(3,753,&2>&@?-/&!158&-;,&%847/&A:&

)<4S43;-;50&]]&b&V[:&$39&d14\G&!1<5?3,C30&JKLJ:

@<38;0&6-;R43,:&5/'*I(D(,$&%0/A+8;(%-.247,C3G&%-.247,C3&H;7D34/75>&I43//0&JKKL:

'<7\0&a:%:&O*83&+.27C<75>&1R&@-;57-;&#-758:T&KC&**$1+(<&-0'/#(&2(7+"&#&%8(UV:&U:&

W+<C</50&LN[UXG&UUN&b&UZV:

6=%-458>0&!7=8-4,&!:&O6-F7./&7;&@-;5e/&I4-=57=-?&I87?1/1S8>:T&<&-0'/#(&2(*+"(G$1*&08(&2 (

@+$#&1&A+8(ZZ:&L:&Wa-;:0&JKKVXG&V]&b&[U:

6=%-458>0&Q7;=3;5&+:&N-"1*(2&0(/(@+$#&1&A+$C/#(<"1-1;(6-=1;0&B314C7-G&634=34&

H;7D34/75>&I43//0&LN[V:

67=8-?/1;0&B14,1;&":&O614-?&B3;34-571;&-;,&_7D7;3&+7,&7;&@-;5:T&!"#$%$&-1(K*-.$"1(J]:&

U:&W)3S5:0&LN[NXG&J]N&b&JYK:

Page 192: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

L[Z

67=8-?/1;0&B14,1;&":&O*83&(;/=4<5-27?75>&1R&614-?&"D7?&7;&@-;5:T&7+"(7+&:$1*(]L:&J:&

WLN[YXG&LYN&E&LNZ:

67=8-?/1;0&a4:0&B14,1;&":&O@-;50&583&^72?30&-;,&583&!3=1D34>&R41.&!-,7=-?&"D7?:T&(;&

5/'*61(D'/*&:8(&2(FH$#4(3,753,&2>&)8-41;&+;,34/1;EB1?,&-;,&I-2?1&6<=8;7\0&]Y&

E&YU:&%-.247,C3G&%-.247,C3&H;7D34/75>&I43//0&JKLK:

67=8-?/1;0&a4:0&B14,1;&":&9/##"'(90"".&:;(%-.247,C3G&%-.247,C3&H;7D34/75>&I43//0&

LNNK:

614-;0&@-53&+:&O%-;&@-;5&M-D3&-;&+==1<;5&1R&614-?&",<=-571;hT&<&-0'/#(&2(

@+$#&1&A+8(ZU:&Z:&WJKKNXG&ZYL&b&Z[Z:

614-;0&@-53&+:&B&::-'*8(/'.(@0&%0"11($'(5/'*61(3&0/#(@+$#&1&A+8;(A-/87;C51;0&_:%:G&

*83&%-581?7=&H;7D34/75>&I43//0&JKLJ:

614C-;0&)37471?:&O*83&67//7;C&#14.-?&I411R&1R&M<.-;75>e/&!-,7=-?&"D7?&7;&@-;5e/&

e!3?7C71;:eT&7+"(@+$#&1&A+$C/#(!"H$")(LLZ:&L:&Wa-;:0&JKK]XG&VU&b&LLZ:

6<?81??-;,0&'3/?73&+:&O#433,1.&-;,&I41D7,3;=3&7;&@-;5e/&+==1<;5&1R&!3?7C71;G&*83&

I412?3.&1R&"FS7-571;:T&(;&5/'*61(@+$#&1&A+8(&2(!"#$%$&'(!"C&'1$."0".4(3,753,&2>&

I87?7S&a:&!1//7&-;,&67=8-3?&A433;0&]Z&E&YU:&(;,7-;-S1?7/G&(;,7-;-&H;7D34/75>&

I43//0&LNNL:

6<;c3?0&B:&#3?7=75-/:&5/'*61(B&'C"A*$&'(&2(3&0/#(B+/0/C*"0I(7+"(UB0$*$C/#V(W$'Q(&2(

3&0/#$*84(D'*+0&A&#&%84(/'.(!"2#"C*$H"(<-.%:"'*;(%87=-C1G&H;7D34/75>&1R&%87=-C1&

I43//0&LNNN:

6<;c3?0&B:&#3?7=75-/:&O@-;5&1;&614-?&",<=-571;0&14&e";?7C853;.3;5e&-;,&583&'7234-?&

+45/:T&7+"(!"H$")(&2(3"*/A+81$C1(]Y:&L:&WJKKUXG&ZU&b&YU:

Pe%1;;140&_-;73?:&OB11,&-;,&"D7?&_7/S1/7571;:T&5/'*JK*-.$"'(YV:&WLN[]XG&J[[&b&UKJ:

Pe$37??0&P;14-:&O*83&I1934&1R&"F-.S?3/:T&@+$#&1&A+8(VL&WLN[VXG&]&b&UV:

Pe$37??0&P;14-:(U@-;5G&!-571;-?75>&-/&I4-=57=-?&!3-/1;;T(7;&7+"(OX2&0.(G/'.R&&Q(&2(

!/*$&'/#$*80&3,753,&2>&+?R43,&a:&63?3&-;,&I734/&!-9?7;C0&NU&E&LKN:&PFR14,G&PFR14,&

H;7D34/75>&I43//0&JKKZ:

I-?.`<7/50&)53S83;&!:&(;541,<=571;&51&!"#$%$&'()$*+$'(*+"(,&-'.1(&2(,/0"(!"/1&'4(2>&

(..-;<3?&@-;5:&*4-;/?-53,&2>&A34;34&):&I?<8-4:&(;,7-;-S1?7/G&M-=\355&I<2?7/87;C&

%10&(;=:0&JKKN:

I-?.`<7/50&)53S83;:&O@-;5k/&"587=/&1R&B4-=3G&I34/S3=57D-?&)1?<571;/&51&583&614-?&

_7RR7=<?573/&9758&_7D7;3&+//7/5-;=3:T&7+"(<&-0'/#(&2(!"#$%$&'&NK&WJKLKG&]UKb&]]U:

Page 193: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

L[]

I-/534;-=\0&'-943;=3:&O@-;5&1;&583&_325&1R&)7;:T&9/$*+(/'.(@+$#&1&A+8(JL:&L:&Wa-;<-4>0&

JKLJXG&UK&b&]J:

I-/534;-=\0&'-943;=3:&O*83&_3D3?1S.3;5&-;,&)=1S3&1R&@-;57-;&^3?73RG&*83&M7C83/5&

B11,0&583&I4-=57=-?&I1/5<?-53/0&-;,&*83&#-=5&1R&!3-/1;:T&5/'*JK*-.$"'(LKJ&

WJKLLXG&JNK&b&ULU:

f<7;;0&I87?7S&':&OP47C7;-?&)7;0&!-,7=-?&"D7?0&-;,&614-?&(,3;575>:T&9/$*+(/'.(@+$#&1&A+8(

L:&J:&WLN[ZXG&L[[&b&JKJ:

!1<//3-<0&a3-;&a-=`<3/:&K"C&'.(L$1C&-01"4(O'(*+"(O0$%$'(/'.(9&-'./*$&'1(&2(>'"?-/#$*8(

/:&'%(3"';&(;&7+"(L$1C&-01"1(/'.(O*+"0(F/0#8(@&#$*$C/#(P0$*$'%14(3,753,&2>&

Q7=514&B1<43D75=8:&%-.247,C3G&%-.247,C3&H;7D34/75>&I43//0&LNNY:

)=87??340&#473,47=8:&'35534&51&B:&@134;34&J[&#32:&LYNU:&(;&KC+$##"01(,0$"2";&3,:&#:&a1;-/&

W)5<55C-450&;:,:X0&(((0&J[[:

)7?2340&a18;:&O*83&"587=-?&)7C;7R7=-;=3&1R&@-;5e/&!3?7C71;lT&14&(;541,<=571;&51&!"#$%$&'(

)$*+$'(*+"(W$:$*1(&2(!"/1&'(D#&'"4(2>&(..-;<3?&@-;50&?FF7F&E&=FFF7D;($39&d14\G&

M-4S34&P;30&LNVK:

)S-4;0&A-534:&O@-;5e/&_1=547;3&1R&+51;3.3;5&-/&-&*8314>&1R&)<2m3=57D75>:T&(;&5/'*61(

@+$#&1&A+8(&2(!"#$%$&'(!"C&'1$."0".4(3,753,&2>&I87?7S&a:&!1//7&-;,&67=8-3?&

A433;0&LKU&E&LLJ:&(;,7-;-S1?7/G&(;,7-;-&H;7D34/75>&I43//0&LNNL:

)534;0&I-<?:&O*83&I412?3.&1R&M7/514>&-;,&*3.S14-?75>&7;&@-;57-;&"587=/:T&!"H$")(&2(

3"*/A+81$C1(UN&WLN[VXG&]K]&b&Z]:

)<4S43;-;50&%847/&A:&O@-;5e/&%1;5472<571;&51&614-?&",<=-571;:T&(;&5/'*(/'.(F.-C/*$&'I(

>'*"0A0"*/*$&'1(/'.(B&::"'*/084(3,753,&2>&@?-/&!158&-;,&%847/&A:&)<4S43;-;50&L&

b&LL:&($39&d14\G&!1<5?3,C30&JKLJ:

)<//.-;0&_-D7,:&OI34D34/75>&1R&583&M3-45:T&7+"(@+$#&1&A+$C/#(!"H$")(LLZ:&J:&W+S4:0&

JKK]XG&L]U&E&YY:

A11,0&+??3;&A:&5/'*61(3&0/#(!"#$%$&';((58-=-G&%14;3??&H;7D34/75>&I43//0&LNYK:

A11,0&+??3;:&O!3?7C71;0&"587=-?&%1..<;75>0&-;,&583&)54<CC?3&+C-7;/5&"D7?:T!9/$*+(/'.(

@+$#&1&A+8(LY:&Z:&WP=5:0&JKKKXG&ZN[&b&]LL:

d1D3?0&d74.7>-8<:&5/'*(/'.(*+"(@+$#&1&A+8(&2(G$1*&08;(I47;=351;0&$aG&I47;=351;&

H;7D34/75>&I43//0&LN[K:

Page 194: Radical Evil and Moral Transformation

Q(*+

%847/57;-&_41C-?7/&9-/&214;&-;,&4-7/3,&7;&P?,&#14C30&I3;;/>?D-;7-:&)83&43=37D3,&

-&^-=83?14&1R&+45/&7;&I87?1/1S8>&-;,&I1?757=-?&)=73;=3&R41.&583&H;7D34/75>&1R&)=4-;51;&7;&

JKK[&-;,&-&6-/534&1R&+45/&7;&I87?1/1S8>&R41.&'1>1?-&H;7D34/75>&%87=-C1&7;&JKLL:

%847/57;-e/&43/3-4=8&?73/&S47.-47?>&7;&583&-43-/&1R&@-;5&/=81?-4/87S&-;,&.14-?&

58314>:&)83&7/&-?/1&7;5343/53,&7;&S87?1/1S8>&1R&43?7C71;0&/1=7-?&-;,&S1?757=-?&S87?1/1S8>0&

-;,&7//<3/&/<441<;,7;C&.14-?&3,<=-571;:&)83&7/&=<443;5?>&-;&(;/54<=514&-5&'1>1?-&

H;7D34/75>&%87=-C1&-;,&?7D3/&7;&%87=-C10&(':

L[Y