R …………… u e R V S p R W R h ¾ Y j R S a R S v R ...hrlibrary.umn.edu/arab/MHRJPL4ar.pdf: Z» i [ T Y W» n w Y s W T i T v w S U ] T h O u ` i T .2000¿ i W L/ U l 14 ~

:99

……………

.

"

-

100 :

1996

*****

19851990

1990

198119691950

*****

R (94) 121.

1

. . :1982

1990 .

14/2000.:org.ibanet.www://http.

-

:101

1-

.

..

2-

.

.

. .

.

.

.

.

.

-

102 :

.2.

.

.

103 ."

"4.

3-

.

. .

..

.

.

.

2E/CN.4/2000/3

87.3E/CN.4/Sub.2/1993/25

1.4.

-

:103

5 . .

.

.

.

.

4-

4-1

." "" " .

.

14)1 (" ""

""

"6 . .

7)1 (" ")" (

5E/CN.4/2000/61

74Attacks on Justice - The Harassment and Persecution of Judges and Lawyers (Centre for the Independenceof Judges and Lawyers (CIJL), Geneve), 10th edn., January 1999-February 2000, 499 pp.

6263/1987)28/1992 (A/48/40)205-2.

-

104 :

")" ( ."26" ."7"

"""7.

8)1 ("

."

6)1 ("

."

.10"

."

4-21985

19858 .

.

:‘1 ‘‘2 ‘‘3 ‘‘4 ‘‘5 ‘‘6 ‘ .

.

4-3 :

" "" " .

." "

7ACHPR, Civil Liberties Organisation, Legal Defense Centre, Legal Defense and Assistance Project v. Nigeria, of the text published 3.p,2001May 7 -April 23 th Ordinary session, 29 , decision adopted during the 98/218.Communication No

; emphasis added html.98-218/comcases/Africa/humanrts/edu.umn.1www://httpon 840/3229/198540/14613/1985.

-

:105

"-

"9 ." :

"10.

" ""."11

" "14)1" (

"12 . :"

"" """13 .

.

4-4

.1:

" .."

7:

"."

.

9)1985 (2.S.C.R Valiente v. The Queen 673, to be found at2., at p.thml.0673_2scr1985/html/2vol1985/bup/en/scc-cec/ca.umontreal.lexum.www:/http.

10.11.12387/1989 .)23/1992(

A/48/40)(1207-2.13Eur. Court HR, Case of Dektaras V. Lithuania, Judgment of 10 October 2000, para. 30

:int.coe.echr://http.

-

106 :

4-4-1

."14"

."

4-4-2

7 .

.

.

-- .

14.

4-4-3

1" " ."

.

.

4:

" .

"15.

14 :

:html.report/juriciary/govaffairs/org.abanet.www://http.

15R (84) 12") ."1-2--‘1‘ (

-

:107

4

.

4-4-4

3" ...

"16.

36)6 (32)2 (.

4-4-5

4-5-8.

:

.

-

)1-2--‘4‘.(16

R (84) 12") "1-2--‘3‘.(

-

108 :

4-5

. :

.

.

:

4-5-1

.10:

" .

.

."

.

..

*****

" "" ...

.""17 .

""18.

17A/53/40)(132.18A/52/40)(224.

-

:109

"

.""14"19.

14

.

" .""

20.

" "14)1 ("

"21 ."

"22.\

.

" ""

"23.

" "14" .""

"24.

19A/51/40202.20A/52/40)(379.21A/55/40)(279.22280.23A/55/40)(405.24A/50/40288301.

-

110 :

1425.*****

" "10

26.*****

:

"" "6-1

"27.

6)1 ( . .

28 ." .

29 ."

" ""6)1."(30

" ""

6"31.

25

10E/CN.4/2000/61/Add.1

:60-64. :)

1966(302 .1-2-R (94) 12 .

Judicial Organization in Europe (2000( ,Strasbourg, Council of Europe Publication, 2000, 352 pp.26ACHPR, Media Rights v. Nigeria Communication No. 224/98, decision adopted during the 28th session, 28 October - 6

.html.98-224/comcases/Africa/humanrts/edu.umn.1www://httpat60. para,2000November 27Eur. Court HR, Case of Incal v. Turkey, judgment of 9 June 1998, Reports 1998-IV, p. 1571, para. 65.28Eur. Court HR, Case of Lauko v. Slovakia, judgment of 2 September 1998, Reports 1998-VI, pp. 2497-2498,

paras. 12-17.29250664.30.312507.

-

:111

6)1 (32.

64-7 .

":"

" .

. .

(...)33.

******

:

"

"34.

")un adecuado proceso de nombramiento(""con una duracion en el cargo(""con una garantia

contra presiones externas("35

32250625076465 .

:"""6)1 ( .Eur. Court HR, Case of Stalinger and Kuso v. Austria, Judgment of 18 March 1997, Reports 1997-II,

p. 667, para. 37.23Eur. Court HR, Case of Incal v. Turkey, judgment of 9 June 1998, Reports 1998-IV, p. 1572-1573, para. 7134OAS doc. OEA/Ser.I/V/II.95, doc. 7 rev., Annual Report of the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights 1996, p.

761.35I-A Court HR, Constitutional Court Case (Aguirre Roca, Rey Terry and Revorado Marsano v. Peru), judgment of 31 January 2001

75 :html._ ESP71C_/serie_c/cr.or.corteidh.www://http.

-

112 :

4-5-2

.11

"."

12:

""36.

111237 .

.

*****

""38.

."

."""39 ."

"40.

"

."""41.

361-3R (94) 1212.37"

."""E/CN.4/2000/61/Add.1169).(

38A/54/40)(104.39A/51/40352.40364.41A/53/40)(173.

-

:113

14)1 (.

4-5-3

11.

.

..

)("11) (

"42 .

.

."11) (""

."43

" "

.""44 ."

"45.

42(1997) 3 S.C.R. Manituba Prrovincial Judge Assn. V. Manitugba (Minister of Judge) 3, at5. at p_html3scr1997/html/3vol/1997/bup/en/scc-cec/ca.umontreal.lexum.www://http.

4312.44 .

.45.

-

114 :

4-5-4

13" ."

46 .

47.

4-5-5

..

*****

" ...

"48 ." ""

." "

"49.

" "14)1 (

.

1720:

46R (94) 12"

" ")

12-1-2-.(47

:Miles to Go 2000; Progress of Minorities in the Legal Profession . .

minorities/org.abanet.www.48A/53/40)(149.49A/54/40)(299-300.

-

:115

"17- .

..

18-.

19-.

20- .

."

17" "20"

."14)1 (

50.

*****

.1987 .

51 .181952 .

50

R (94) 12

:1 (2 (3 (4 ()

-1 .(""" .""

) "-2 .(-1-2 "

."") "-3.(

51ACHPR, Mouvement Burkinabe des Droits de l'Homme et des Peoples v. Burkina Faso, Communication No. 204/97,23/-7/200138:

jtml97-204/comcases/Africa/humanrts/edu.umn.1www://http.52.

-

116 :

157)1)( (53.

*****

28/1997 .1992

.1996112 .

7" "54 .

55 .825.

8-

-56 .

.57 .

."")extremadanmente corto(" .

58.

25 .

) (59 .

"

5340.54I-A Court HR, Constitutional Court Case, Competence, judgement of September 24, 1999, in OAS doc.

OEA/Ser.I/V/III.47, dic. 619992374-378.55I-A Court HR, Constitutional Court Case, (Aguirre Aoca, Rey Terry and Revrado Masano v. Peru), , judgment of 31 January 2001,

67 :html._ESP71C_/serie_c/cr.or.corteidh.www://http.5684.5778.5883.59975627.

-

:117

."

.60.

*****

.

8.

4-5-6

..

8:

"

"61.

4-5-7

. .

62.

" ...

6096.61R (94) 12"

."62A/54/40)(

134A/53/40) (132.

-

118 :

""

"63.

" "

64.

/)9.(

4-5-8

.6:

"."

716

.)4.(

*****

" "" .""

"65.

.6)1 ("

63A/55/40)(280.64"

")1996 (html96Iec/sg.org.sal.www89 .-3-

"."65A/54/40)(299.

-

:119

"""66 .

6)1(67.

*****

.14)1 (

14)3)( (" "14)5 (68.

:

.

4-6

.14)1 (

7)1 (8)1 (6)1 (.

66Eur. Court HR, Case of Higgins and Others v. France, judgment of 19 February 1998, Reports 1998-I, p. 60, para. 42.676143.68283/1988 .)1/1991(

A/47/4028492838-5)14)5 ((377/1988 .

)29/ (A/49/49)(7713-5)14)3)( ()5 (

.(

-

120 :

2:

"

."

*****

." "14)1 (

"

"69 ."/

...

14"70 ." . .

. ."71 .

""72 ."

"1473.

74.

*****

7)1)( () (

.

69387/1989 .)23/1992(

A/48/40)(1207-2.70.711207-3.721172-31196-3.731207-3.74731/1996)29/2000 (

A/55/40)(9-4128"."

-

:121

"75 .7)1)( (" "

") ()125 ( .""76.

*****

6)1 (

." "" ""

"77 . " "".78 .

."

"79.

6)1 (

80 ."

"81 ." "6)1(82 .

"

75ACHPR, Constitutional Rights Project v. Nigerian, Communication No. 87/93, para. 13; for the text of the judgment,

See also ACHPR, International Pen, Constitutional Rights ,html93-87/comcases/Africa/humanrts/edu.umn.1www://http.g.see eProject, Interrigths on behalf of Ken Saro-Wiva Jr. and Civil Liberties Organization v. Nigeria, Communications Nos. 137/94, 139/94, 154/96 and 161/97, decision of 1 October 1998, para. 86; for the text see

.html97-161_96-154_94-139_94-137/comcases/Africa/humanrts/umnedu.1www://http7614.77Eur. Court HR, Case od Dektaras v. Lithuania, judgment of 10 October 2000, para. 30.78.7932.80Eur. Court HR, Case of Oberschlick v. Austria (1), judgment of 23 May 1991, Series A, No. 204, p. 13 , para. 16 and p.

15, para. 22 for similar cases, see also Eur. Court HR, Case of Catilo Algar v. spain, judgment of 28 October 1998, Reports 1998-VIII, p. 3124 ff. and Eur. Court HR, the Case of de Haan v. the Netherlands, judgment of 26 August 1997, Reports 1997-IV, p. 1379 ff.

81Eur. Court HR, the Case of de Haan v. the Netherlands, judgment of 26 August 1997, Reports 1997-IV, p.1393, para.54.82Eur. Court HR, the Case of Kingsley v. United Kingdom, judgment of 7 November 2000, para.51; for the text of the

./int.coe.echr.www://phttjudgment, see

-

122 :

"83 .6)1.(84

6)1 ("

"85

.

. .

86 . .

""87 ."

."88.

.6)1 (

."

6-1"89 . ."""

""

"90 .""

""91.

6)1 ("

83Eur. Court HR, the Case of Bryan v. the United Kingdom, judgment of 22 November 1995, Series A, No. 335-A, p. 17,para. 45.

84Eur. Court HR, the Case of Kingsley v. United Kingdom, judgment of 7 November 2000, para. 59.85Eur. Court HR, the Case of Dektaras v. Lithuania, judgment of 10 October 2000, para.38.8631.87.8836.

98 for the text of the judgment, see ;34. p,2000May 9the United Kingdom, judgment of .Court HR, Case of Sander v.Eur./int.coe.echr.www://http

90.91 .Eur. Court HR, Case of Diennet v.

France, judgment of 26 September 1995, Series A, No. 325-A (no violation); and the cases mentioned under the section dealing with "Military and other special courts or tribunals".

-

:123

"] ... ["92 .

--"93.

.

.

4-7

.

1314"

"94 . .

"95 .

14"96.

." "

14"14 """97 .

""98 .

" "

92Eur. Court HR, Case of Remli v. France, judgment of 30 March 1996, Reports 1996-II,p. 574, para. 48.93.941234.95.96.97577/1994 .)6/1997 (

A/53/40)(438-8.98 ."

"14)2( .688/1996 . .)27/2000 (A/55/40)(6010-5.

-

124 :

"99 .""100.

"

"101 ." .""

14"102 ." "

14 .""

141 ""

14"103.

."

"104 ."

.""

"105 ." ""

"106 ." ""

"107.

*****

99A/51/406235064363.

10062350.10151278.10253293.103A/53/402021104.104A/55/40)(215216.105A/56/40) (9620.1066115.107A/52/40)(55344.

-

:125

7)1)( (

) .( .

"

."7)1)( (

""108.

)(media Rights Agenda

The Diet .109 .

:

" .

."110.

" ."111.

7)1)( (5:

" .

108) (

60/913/19943637/chr/za.ac.up.www://http

) (87/93/19943031.

109Media Rights Agenda)(224/982823/-6/200068

:html.98_224/comcases/Africa/humanrts/edu.umn.1www://http.11062111.

-

126 :

."

26""112.

.:

..." . .

"113.

"7

."13"

" " ."

""114 ." "

" ":

" .

"115.

116.

*****

11266.113ACHPR, Civil Liberties Organisation, Legal Defense Centre, Legal Defense and Assistance Project v. Nigeria,

Communication No. 218/98, 23/-7/20013:html.98_218/comcases/Africa/humanrts/edu.umn.1www://http.

114.115644.116.

-

:127

"8)1 (

"117 .1992"

" ."

" ""118 .:

"128- ...

. .

.

. .

129- .

" ..."119.

130-8)1 ( .

. .

. .

"120.

" ""

117I-A Court HR 1999, Castillo Petruzzi el al., case v. Peru, Judgment of May 30, 1999 in OA doc. OEA/Ser.I./V/III.47,

doc 6, Annual Report I-A Court HR 1999, Appendix IX, p. 263, para. 132.118262127.119.120262-263128-130.

-

128 :

."""121.

122

""

123 .

" "

..." ...

"124.

" " "] [

-"125.

.

..."2

"126.

*****

121263133" "OEA/Ser.I/V/II.95, doc. 7 rev

1996736-737.122I-A Court HR, Genie Lacayo Case, judgment of January 29, 1997, in OAS doc. OAS/Ser.I/V/III.39, doc. 5, Annual

Report I-A Court HR 1997, p. 54, para. 84.1235485.1245486.12587.126OAS doc. OEA/Ser.L/V/II.95, doc.7 rev, Annual Report of the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights 1996,

p. 761.

-

:129

" "

"] ["127 .

"

"128 .

" .

."129.

" "6)1 ( .

""""130 .

" .""

"131 ." "" ...

"132.

" ""

1278/1999.128.129 :Eru. Court HR, Case of Incal v. Turkey, judgment of 9

June 1998, Reports 1998-IV, p. 1547 ff.; Eur. Court HR, Case of Ciraklar v. Turkey, judgment of 28 October 1998, Reports 1998-VI, p. 3059 ff.; and Eur Court HR, Case of Okcuoglu v. Turkey, judgment of 8 July 1999; for the text of this judgment, see

.int.coe.echr.www://http13021/1997

1997-28174.13128275.13276.

-

130 :

"133 .

..."" "

" "6-1"134.

.

.

14

.

5-

5-11990

.

1990") ".(

24 :

13377.134):Eur. Court HR, Case of Coyne v. the United

Kingdom, ,judgment of 24 September 1997, Reports 1997-V,p. 1842 ff., andEur. Court HR, Case of Cable and Others v. the .int.coe.echr.www://http, see 1997February 18 United Kingdom, judgment of

-

:131

.

" ...

... ."""."

5-2

12" "

" ""

."2) (

."

5-3

") "3("

) "4 .("

) "5 .(""

") "67.(

.

5-4

" ""

."" "

)8.(

-

132 :

5-5

") "10 .(

"

) "11.(

" "

"

) "12.(

"

"

) "15.(

"

."

) "16.(

" "

."" "

2)3 (914135.

135

A/52/40)(402.

-

:133

5-6

)1819 (.

5-7

"

" " "

)21.(

.:

).(

6-6-1

1990:

..."

."

-

134 :

:

.

.

.

6-2

12" "13:

)(

)(

)(."

"

) "14(") "15.(

6-3

16:

":) () (

) (

."

") "17.(

..

-

:135

7)1)( ("

"136.

*****

18" ."

1998" ""

"137 ." .""

"138 .--"

"139 ..

.

..

19:

"

."

20:

"

."

136ACHPR, International Pen, Constitutional Rights Project, Interights (on behalf of Ken Savu-Wiva Jr. And Civil

Liberties Organization) v. Nigeria, Communication Nos. 137/94, 139/94, 154/96 and 161/97, decision adopted on 31 October 1998 101:html97-161_96-154_94-139_94-137/comcases/Africa/humanrts/edu.umn.1www://http.

137E/CN.4/1998/39-1.138.1392.

-

136 :

6-4

23:

" .

.."

24"

."" ."

." "

" "140.

6-4-1

."

3/1997

.""

""

"141 .142.

" ""

""14"143.

******

140E/CN.4/1995/3972.

141A/53/40150.142.143A/54/40134.

-

:137

14.

6-4-2

.11

10 . .

.""144" ""

"145 .

"112

."146.

"" "11147 .

.

6-4-3

" "1993 .

12831148.

" " " "

" ."

144Eur. Court HR, Ezelin v. France judgment of 26 April 1991, Series A, No. 202, p. 20, para. 38.1452351.14652.14753.148ACHPR, Civil Liberties Organization v. Nigeria (in respect of the Nigerian Bar Association), Communication No. 101/93

/19951/chr/za.ac.up.www://http.

-

138 :

""149 .

..."

."150.

"

10"151.

6-4-4

10500

."

.""152 ."-

- ""

"153 .:

" .

. ...

.

"154.

14924.15025.15126.152Eur. Court HR, Schipfer case v. Switzerland, judgment of 20 May 1998, Reports 1998-III, p. 1052, para. 29.1531053.1541053-105433.

-

:139

" " ."

" ""

"""155.

6-5

26:

"."

" ""

) "27 .("

) "28 .( ") "29.(

.

.:

.

.

155105434.

-

140 :

7-

. .

. :

.

..