Top Banner
Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts T o Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech M Okuyama and KT, Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts to Adiabaticity, JPSJ 86, 043002 (2017) Editors’ Choice M Okuyama and KT, From Classical Nonlinear Integrable Systems to Quantum Shortcuts to Adiabaticity, PRL 117, 070401 (2016) OIST, March 22, 2017
38

Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Jun 01, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Quantum-Classical Correspondence

of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity

Kazutaka TakahashiTokyo Tech

M Okuyama and KT, Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts to Adiabaticity, JPSJ 86, 043002 (2017) Editors’ Choice

M Okuyama and KT, From Classical Nonlinear Integrable Systems to Quantum Shortcuts to Adiabaticity, PRL 117, 070401 (2016)

OIST, March 22, 2017

Page 2: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Summary

STA extended from Q to C systems

Solvable systems in Q/C STA

Q-C correspondence of STA

► talk for non-general audience:

somewhat formal, technical, and too many equations!

► your ideas on interesting applications welcome

Page 3: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Principle of STA: Dynamical Invariant

State given by an instantaneous eigenstate of F

Hamiltonian divided into two parts:

► CD Driving: CD term obtained for a given H0

► Inverse Engineering: H designed for a given F

Implementations:

CD term

Lewis-Riesenfeld (1969)

► state is an instantaneous eigenstate of H0

► CD term prevents nonadiabatic transitions

Page 4: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Brief History of STA

1969 Lewis-Riesenfeld Dynamical Invariant

2000 Emmanouilidou Zhao Ao Niu Early application to 2-level system

03, 05 Demirplak-Rice CD driving

08 Masuda-Nakamura Fast-Forward

09 Berry Formula of CD Driving

10 Bilbao G Inverse Engineering, “STA” named

13 Jarzynski C-STA, Scale-Invariant Driving

13 del Campo Scale-Invariant Driving

13 KT Quantum Brachistochrone

16 Okuyama-KT Nonlinear Integrable Systems

17 Okuyama-KT C-STA

Page 5: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Issues

Q Commutator and C Poisson Bracket

- simple replacement?

CD Term for Q/C STA

- same or not

Q/C Adiabatic Theorems

- look different

Adiabatic Invariant (C)

- role in Q system

Yes

Not the same

Imply some relation(not completely understood)

Page 6: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Q Commutator and C Poisson Bracket

CD Term for Q/C STA

Q/C Adiabatic Theorems

Adiabatic Invariant (C)

06/28

Page 7: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

CD DrivingBerry’s formula (2009)

Jarzynski (2013): Q

Jarzynski (2013): C

► microcanonical average on equienergy (H0=E0) plane► only for periodic trajectories?

► H0-eigenstate basis

CD term

Page 8: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Classical STA

► applicable to general systems► arbitrariness: {ξ,H0}={ξ’,H0}

: time derivative

: eq of motion

: instant energy of H0 “conserved”

Page 9: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Classical STA

► applicable to general systems► arbitrariness: {ξ,H0}={ξ’,H0}

: time derivative

: eq of motion

: instant energy of H0 “conserved”

Formula of CD driving in C-STA

Slightly different from Jarzynski formula

A different formula derived later

Page 10: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Scale-Invariant Systems

► translation (x0) + dilation (γ)

► same for Q and CJarzynski (2013)

Deffner-Jarzynski-del Campo (2014)

► energy independent of x0

Page 11: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Solvable Systems

All eigenvalues of F independent of t: Infinite conserved quantities

Lax equation

Lax pairLax (1968)

► Lax pairs known infinitelyKDV, Toda, Sine-Gordon, Nonlinear Schrödinger, …

Hierarchical structures: Scale-invariant systems in the simplest hierarchy

Okuyama-KT (2016)

Relation to C nonlinear integrable systems

Page 12: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

KdV for C Nonlinear Systems and Q-STA

KdV Equation

Q-STAC Nonlinear Systems

► multiple solitons

► potential satisfies KdV► integrability of KdV

Page 13: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Toda Lattice and Q Spin

Toda equations

Isotropic XY spin chain

Toda lattice

Page 14: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Toda Lattice and Q Spin

Isotropic XY spin chain

Toda lattice

Toda equations Lax pair (L,M) ↔ CD driving (H0,ξ)

Integrability and adiabaticity

Simulate nonlinear systems in Q dynamics

Page 15: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

From Q to C

KdV equation Dispersionless KdV equation

Q-STA C-STA

► E0=const

► different solutions

Page 16: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Dispersionless KdV Equation

DKdV solved by Hodograph Method

► f: arbitrary function► no soliton solutions

Page 17: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Dispersionless KdV Equation

DKdV solved by Hodograph Method

► f: arbitrary function► No Soliton Solutions

DKdV hierarchy for C-STA

Q-STA and C-STA are different

Exception: Scale-invariant systems

Page 18: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Other Applications?

TodaC-limit of discrete system?

Nonlinear Schrödingeruse NLS to solve NLS? (cf. Use KdV to solve Schrödinger eq in a KdV potential)

AKNStwo-block Hamiltonian

Q Nonlinear Integrable SystemsQ Lax

1D Heisenberg model ► mathematically interesting

► physics?

Page 19: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Q Commutator and C Poisson Bracket

CD Term for Q/C STA

Q/C Adiabatic Theorems

Adiabatic Invariant (C)

16/28

Page 20: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

For ,

adiabatic state (instantaneous state with a phase)

is an approximate solution of the Schrödinger equation

if

Adiabatic Theorem: Q

► adiabatic condition removed by CD term (STA!)

Page 21: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Adiabatic Theorem: C

α: constant α(t): varied

Adiabatic invariant

is conserved if► periodic trajectories only

► condition removed by CD term?

α(t1)

α(t2)

Page 22: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Adiabatic Theorem Holds Exactly

► adiabatic condition removed by CD term

Page 23: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Adiabatic Theorem Holds Exactly

► adiabatic condition removed by CD term

Q/C adiabatic theorems look different

Relation?

C adiabatic invariant for general trajectory

Page 24: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Adiabatic Invariant for General Trajectories?

1D, periodic Hamilton’s characteristic function(Abbreviated action)► for general systems

► from Hamilton-Jacobi theory

Page 25: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Adiabatic Invariant for General Trajectories?

1D, periodic Hamilton’s characteristic function(Abbreviated action)► for general systems

► from Hamilton-Jacobi theory

Adiabatic invariant for general systems

Develop Hamilton-Jacobi theory of STA

Q and C systems related by HJ theory

Page 26: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Generalized Action

Time-dependent α(t): With CD term

Hamilton’s characteristic function (Abbreviated action)

► independent of history of x and α

Time-independent α: No CD term

► independent of history of x

► energy-conserved system

Action

Generalized Action

Page 27: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Hamilton-Jacobi Equation

Use of S

Use of S0

Time-dependent α(t): With CD term

Time-independent α: No CD term

Page 28: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Hamilton-Jacobi Equation

Use of S

Use of S0

Time-dependent α(t): With CD term

Time-independent α: No CD term

Fundamental formula of C-STA

Formula written instantaneously

Generalized action plays an important role

Page 29: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Scale-Invariant System

HJ eqsPotential

Page 30: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Dispersionless KdV

HJ eqsDKdV eq

► assume constant E0

► from HJ theory

Page 31: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Dispersionless KdV

HJ eqsDKdV eq

► assume constant E0

► from HJ theory

HJ theory useful for applications

Page 32: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Adiabatic Invariant

► DKdV system► oscillating α

► nonperiodic ► Ω(T)=J► proved by action-angle variables

Page 33: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Adiabatic Invariant

► nonperiodic ► Ω(T)=J► proved by action-angle variables

► DKdV system► oscillating α

Adiabatic invariant from nonperiodic trajectory

Page 34: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Semiclassical Approximation

► action at zeroth order► eq for generalized action in DKdV system

KdV system in Q

Schrödinger eq (STA)

Potential satisfies KdV

Semiclassical expansion

Page 35: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Semiclassical Approximation

KdV system in Q

Schrödinger eq (STA)

Potential satisfies KdV

Semiclassical expansion

► action at zeroth order► eq for generalized action in DKdV system

DKdV is C limit of KdV

Generalized action appears in wf phase

Page 36: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Role of Generalized Action in Q

► dependent on α (not t) except the dynamical phase

Adiabatic State

► Q analogue of generalized action

Page 37: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Role of Generalized Action in Q

Adiabatic State

► Q analogue of generalized action

► dependent on α (not t) except the dynamical phase

Q/C correspondence by Ω

CD term from Ω

Ω: Fundamental role in Q/C dynamics

Page 38: Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticityktaka/files/1703oist.pdf · Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts To Adiabaticity Kazutaka Takahashi Tokyo Tech

Summary

► STA tested in C systems (easier than Q, hopefully)

► new aspects of dynamics: Hamiltonian consists of two parts

► many-body systems: work and heat?

STA extended from Q to C systemsfrom commutator to Poisson bracket

Solvable systems in Q/C STAKdV/DKdV hierarchy

Q-C correspondence of STAgeneralized action

M Okuyama and KT, Quantum-Classical Correspondence of Shortcuts to Adiabaticity, JPSJ 86, 043002 (2017) Editors’ Choice

M Okuyama and KT, From Classical Nonlinear Integrable Systems to Quantum Shortcuts to Adiabaticity, PRL 117, 070401 (2016)