r'rli;la- ' ;j?.; \ ! --l-- Eril / qgJt[IeIoI IofGgIIeR[" TGI-6I{ g-AcI - [email protected]-{Jil52 - ahd.bih.nic.in 6:€{q /B-arur - 0612 -22t5962t2231)s42 qtri.F - 7 {sro (4) qqo (rffi)-04l2017 Bdio- erricr qT{ilq gar ql{t.rq, qeqt al{r $osqododlo {Iqr-279a/2a11n{rc q{igidlF \-i s=rr qflq $iq lr{Ti{ Tq 3rq ii ft{i6 tsos:or: ol qfto qq ftoJq, d Fni}'c f}qrqrrr glr (operative Part) : "Ihus, the impugned revised fina gradatlon list dated 26.11.2010 (Annexure-1) cannot be sLrstained and s hereby set aside. The result would be that fin.l gradat on lisr a, publirhed on 01 08.2006 (Annexure-5) revives and would be deemed to be operative at alltimes. Consequent y, all actions taken by state, pursuant to th€ revised fnal gradation list (Afnexure 1), in granting promotions to the priv.te respondenis to the prejud ce of the petitloners cannot be sustalned nor denial of promot ons due to the pettioners on basis of the final gradation list dated 01.08.2006 be susta ned. They must get their promotions frorn due date accordingly with ful monetary benefits and other consequentia benefits treat ng them as senior to the privat€-respondents. These adjustments must be done with I three mofths, the respons b ty whereof will be on the Director, Anirnal ll!sbandry, Government of Bihar, Patna. With these observations and dir€ctlons, the writ petition s al owea d 3r-.id qT+q Ta qTqtdq, q-cr dnr l?.nJlq qrFb-,{oss, fuqiq :o rr zoro Em fuie q{uc rrdrqd d siTrftn dfiq qfrTfl r1ff ftrrt{"r ol efirar ritfi-c ori Ec q{i6-313i, f-{i- oi 08 2006 cl{r Fnh rgul sr€Tirbl d 3iliq Fq Q qrq{qR-fi oftqm rtdt fu.'Js'r ol nq qq q-q 6q{ f-qr rrcl qFTffq rlq arrqrdq. rr+ em wfto s+{qd qrq ffq d faTE gq: qm{lq gd qrqrdq, qenl q ETrr{ L.p.A. No. r+rzTzor:, q?w qlw gd 3l{ firq d{E Tl$s. r6 \-i erq i fiqio-zr.oz.zor z o) qfto qrqricr d f-tqifua ftlqrq+c aiYr (operative part) : The present Letters Patent Appeal has no merit. lt ls dlsmissed as such." d Al{I iillDn T]Iit{ qfftrfir n qfto qrq f-'roiq qjl refito sor rrtn i r srf, qFrilq sar ;qrqrdq. .rrcl dRr dlosqoio€lo qsn zzso,/:ot t ilrr< q$rn--rri T4 s-r crlTs {rdr qlqR 1.i er< ii f+.ri* rs.os.:ot: .i qrRd qrqt{ d;n"ila i uEwan ftl:rr"rq, Rn, qeer d grcrF[,ld qgtr.l Tr€rqf, Fq,l ft1 tl{rqar q4 {i.ilild et-fo :t:t, i?flm or os zooo d sT.io ii q{irtfrl gs n'i.qdr d 3nE.R w ffiq drqfi r1ftfd d1-1-{i6 2811 2017 oi rrl{d tdo n fu ru F-iq/3r$rq gi fd qwm n,-r* - l#-i?.@ p,o-.X''L:-# fi,id i D d sroio ti vg w aan rirnur ft\-rr (q:lqm{ tF1-r-r), fiers. qdrr "r- etflq {4 : lrrirtr qtruliflii d ortrrn qur rrerqtn ti FteFofuo 38 (ersdm) Fffii d mrdnlar W oG/ftffftq .rl'tqr qq qRrelq irff rd rq q€tqei S ertnr w ft+ fd.Tl.t ; qRqr €st-2074, fi r 04.01. less vs qllqf, €sr zozo (i0), f-cir-2a 12 2o0s nql utltr- fi"n r I qP.rlrcqt toq, ficm og or.rqs: i Fftd flsrrri Tq q{ Tq q*x riFrq=i ftq-Ft, ladR, q-n d 3iBTIfl{r {isn 1173 (Fo) s qio rjsr rrz,r (fto). R{iq 02.06 2014 Er{l Fr4e q1lri srdru-b s{,1 (,rfr Cd ear rrn)
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
qT{ilq gar ql{t.rq, qeqt al{r $osqododlo {Iqr-279a/2a11n{rc q{igidlF \-is=rr qflq $iq lr{Ti{ Tq 3rq ii ft{i6 tsos:or: ol qfto qq ftoJq, d Fni}'c f}qrqrrr glr
(operative Part) :
"Ihus, the impugned revised fina gradatlon list dated 26.11.2010 (Annexure-1) cannot be
sLrstained and s hereby set aside. The result would be that fin.l gradat on lisr a, publirhed on 01 08.2006
(Annexure-5) revives and would be deemed to be operative at alltimes. Consequent y, all actions taken by
state, pursuant to th€ revised fnal gradation list (Afnexure 1), in granting promotions to the priv.te
respondenis to the prejud ce of the petitloners cannot be sustalned nor denial of promot ons due to thepettioners on basis of the final gradation list dated 01.08.2006 be susta ned. They must get theirpromotions frorn due date accordingly with ful monetary benefits and other consequentia benefits
treat ng them as senior to the privat€-respondents. These adjustments must be done with I three mofths,
the respons b ty whereof will be on the Director, Anirnal ll!sbandry, Government of Bihar, Patna.
With these observations and dir€ctlons, the writ petition s al owea d 3r-.id qT+q
Ta qTqtdq, q-cr dnr l?.nJlq qrFb-,{oss, fuqiq :o rr zoro Em fuie q{uc rrdrqd d siTrftn
dfiq qfrTfl r1ff ftrrt{"r ol efirar ritfi-c ori Ec q{i6-313i, f-{i- oi 08 2006 cl{r Fnh rgul
sr€Tirbl d 3iliq Fq Q qrq{qR-fi oftqm rtdt fu.'Js'r ol nq qq q-q 6q{ f-qr rrcl
qFTffq rlq arrqrdq. rr+ em wfto s+{qd qrq ffq d faTE gq: qm{lq
gd qrqrdq, qenl q ETrr{ L.p.A. No. r+rzTzor:, q?w qlw gd 3l{ firq d{E Tl$s. r6 \-ierq i fiqio-zr.oz.zor z o) qfto qrqricr d f-tqifua ftlqrq+c aiYr (operative part) :
The present Letters Patent Appeal has no merit. lt ls dlsmissed as such." d Al{I iillDn T]Iit{ qfftrfir n
qfto qrq f-'roiq qjl refito sor rrtn i r
srf, qFrilq sar ;qrqrdq. .rrcl dRr dlosqoio€lo qsn zzso,/:ot t ilrr< q$rn--rri
T4 s-r crlTs {rdr qlqR 1.i er< ii f+.ri* rs.os.:ot: .i qrRd qrqt{ d;n"ila i uEwan
or os zooo d sT.io ii q{irtfrl gs n'i.qdr d 3nE.R w ffiq drqfi r1ftfd d1-1-{i6 2811 2017 oirrl{d tdo n fu ru F-iq/3r$rq gi fd qwm n,-r* - l#-i?.@ p,o-.X''L:-#fi,id i D d sroio ti vg w aan rirnur ft\-rr (q:lqm{ tF1-r-r), fiers. qdrr
"r- etflq {4 : lrrirtrqtruliflii d ortrrn qur rrerqtn ti FteFofuo 38 (ersdm) Fffii d mrdnlar W oG/ftffftq.rl'tqr qq qRrelq irff rd rq q€tqei S ertnr w ft+ fd.Tl.t ; qRqr €st-2074, fi r 04.01. less
vs qllqf, €sr zozo (i0), f-cir-2a 12 2o0s nql utltr- fi"n r I qP.rlrcqt toq, ficmog or.rqs: i Fftd flsrrri Tq q{ Tq q*x riFrq=i ftq-Ft, ladR, q-n d 3iBTIfl{r {isn 1173 (Fo)
s qio rjsr rrz,r (fto). R{iq 02.06 2014 Er{l Fr4e q1lri srdru-b s{,1 (,rfr Cd ear rrn)
fiq1i d €IqI i 3Tri Ela lw unw rremdi ot f:#1 orur+s rffi €i fr .t{1 i,srd lirq fi qE Srj*d rEr rq * qr?q ii f:t$ rcFR d Ze,/!lri@ qi] nIH w A.dt qffi d qe/dyitDd F{ Rqr Grtrn gs oiqo A .rs rfir dl Tq{fi/qFTtr 6{d] Bd-risaoq tfl{qlq i if,q Fl fir,'fwr RdT{ 1\sl €l-dr d ftqq 78 (6) 0 dQn trf, fa\-rrr dqRqf, risr 660. f+cis o8.o2.i9ee d "ilid6 fiqq 22 d GTI]R dFn t
qrl:r S eiF -d 6ff GEi i lrqli d iErd€ i w1ll{.rfdero d .rs q{ tffi dt filo iq<r+fii-a rrqd qtjl t sqf,q vgu r +fiero d ft+r r< qr q{{flTc tg 3rfu G\r-l ilf-+id Er.[ I
:r ffi n ftxn.n r.'qftq o'inr{i o"t qmqjto sftE'll or a+c €i dlT L
FA,/'(rdr+rr erc)
fti:to, q{qeqqE.n- 15, f{qim .Ll1.2^/ zott;fo n :- " 1..t o 4/ r10 ,q -? -04 zot, . .Q.D-1..?.b" '