7/30/2019 PuntoEdu Ao 8, nmero 264 (2012)
1/16
$km{Rkweq}fq kd ldkfKl d{kwi Sir}fl mk Rkweq}fq S[AS
kq {df slf}fgirof, klfbirfmf sir kl
Qeq}kof mk Beblei}kafq, v{k rkaijk
u fjr{sf lf ailkaaed mk rkweq}fq
kme}fmfq sir d{kq}rfq meq}ed}fq
{demfmkq fafmoeafq$ XSjq$ 0/5_
]iof di}f> sid}k oiqaf urkmfa}f bekd$Wemf kq}{mefd}el>fsd}f}k f lf Gkref mk Sriuka/}iq$ Aidwiaf}iref> qk edeaef kl
EEE Ailiv{ei mk Kq}{mefd}kq mk Geliqigfu ]kirf mkl Mkrka`i$A{l}{rf>Bfnf Sf/rfqi, eoskrmeblk$Fjkdmf> ]krrf Diq/}rf, afr}ijrfgf mk Rfeoidme$Kd kl afo/s{q> Gkref mk Km{afaed mk Q`fdj`e$
(V
Lf }krakrf rkwil{aed
edm{q}refl u kl Skr
Fi 0 D 27=Mkl 65 fl 2; mk diwekobrk mkl 2362
s{d}ikm{Cs{as$km{$sk
Meq}reb{aed jrf}{e}f
S{bleafaed mk lfSid}estaef [dewkrqemfm Af}leaf mkl Skr
Wewk lf Af}leaf&
Kd kq}k jrfd kda{kd}ri fafmoeai, mkq}fafmiq kqskaefleq}fqdfaeidflkq k ed}krdfaeidflkq fdfle~frid kq}f d{kwf rkwil{aed
edm{q}refl, u kqbi~frid q{ eosfa}i liafl u o{dmefl$ XSjq$ 2/=_
zzz$s{d}ikm{$s{as$k
m{$sk
Kq}k VR }k llkwf fd{kq}rf zkb fl edq}fd}k$
7/30/2019 PuntoEdu Ao 8, nmero 264 (2012)
2/16
edgirok
qilliae}stai u}aileai
2|$m|LEOF, mkl 65 fl 2; mk diwekobrk mkl 2362
LKQ SRKQKD]FOIQ FLJ[DFQ MK LFQ EOJKDKQ U
MKALFRFAEIDKQ OQ EOSIR]FD]KQ MK F[LF OFJDF 2362, [DI
MK D[KQ]RIQ KWKD]IQ OQ EOSIR]FD]KQ MKL FI, V[K LLKW
SIR ]][LI LF ]KRAKRF RKWIL[AED EDM[Q]REFL U KL SKR$
f{Lf Ofjdf 2362
M
kl 62 fl 6= mk di/
wekobrk qk rkfle~
lf PWE kmeaed mk F{/
lf Ofjdf, {di mk liq
kwkd}iq fafmoeaiqoq eosir}fd}kq mk d{kq}rf
[dewkrqemfm, v{k rkdk, afmf
fi, f kqskaefleq}fq liaflkq k
ed}krdfaeidflkq$ Kd kq}f d{k/
wf kmeaed, qk fbirm {d }kof
}fd fa}{fl aioi lf}kd}k> lf }kr/
akrf rkwil{aed edm{q}refl$ Qk
}rf}f mk {d aidaks}i kqbi~fmi
sir kl qiaeliji u kaidioeq}f
Sirrkfd S{dk{
kq}fmi{demkdqk Nkrkou Reghed,
v{ekd qk mkmea f edwkq}ejfr liq
afobeiq aekd}geaiq u }kadil/
jeaiq kd lf kaidiof, kl okmei
fobekd}k u lf qiaekmfm$
Kd liq }rkq mfq v{k m{r kl
kwkd}i, liq kqskaefleq}fq kqbi/
~frid lfq emkfq u flafdakq mkkq}f d{kwf rkwil{aed edm{q/
}refl, u kl eosfa}i v{k }ekdk kd
lfq qiaekmfmkq mk }imi kl o{d/
mi$ Lf edf{j{rfaed mkl kwkd/
}i kq}{wi f afrji mkl rka}ir mk
d{kq}rf afqf mk kq}{meiq, kl Mr$
Ofraefl R{bei, v{ekd mkq}fa
lf eosir}fdaef mkl mkbf}k faf/
moeai qibrk kl }kof$
Lf }krakrf rkwil{aed edm{q/
}refl, i }fobed llfofmf rkwi/
l{aed aekd}geaf u }kadilje/
af, }{wi q{ irejkd l{kji mk ge/
dfle~fmf lf EE J{krrf O{dmefl$
G{k kd kq}k d{kwi aid}kp}i kd
kl v{k fsfrkaekrid edwkd}iq ai/
oi lf gebrf s}eaf u lf g ebrf mkwemrei$ Lf ed}krdk} }fobed gir/
of sfr}k alfwk kd kq}k sriakqi
mk rkwil{aed }kadiljeaf$ Kd
kqf ldkf mk emkfq, liq kpsiqe}i/
rkq mkq}fafrid lf eosir}fdaef
v{k a{oslkd lfq {dewkrqemf/
mkq kd liq sriakqiq mk edwkq}e/
jfaed aekd}geaf u mkqfrrilli
mk }kadilijfq, u qk s{qi kqsk/
OSrO$ Lfq f{}iremfmkq mk d{kq}rf [dewkrqemfm sfr}eaesfrid kd F{lf Ofjdf u rf}egeafrid kl aiosrioeqi mk lf S[AS aid kl mkqfrrilli mkl Skr$
aefl dgfqeq kd lf aidqilemfaed
mk afrrkrfq ed}krmeqaesledfrefq
sfrf v{k kl sfq edjrkqk mk llk/
di kd kl afoedi mk lf }krakrf
rkwil{aed edm{q}refl$ Sir i}ri
lfmi, }fobed qk are}ea lf sf/
qewemfm mkl Kq}fmi sfrf giro{/
lfr sil}eafq v{k srio{kwfd klkq}{mei kd lf aekdaef u lf }kadi/
lijf$ Lf }krakrf rkwil{aed kq
{d }kof v{k diq }iaf f }imiq,
kd kqskaefl f {df qiaekmfm ai/
oi lf d{kq}rf, v{k mkbkrf
b{qafr kd kl mkqfrrilli aekd}/
geai u }kadiljeai lfq si}kdaef/
lemfmkq v{k mkqskj{kd kl arkae/
oekd}i ed}kjrfl mkl sfq$
OFREI LFAh
7/30/2019 PuntoEdu Ao 8, nmero 264 (2012)
3/16
S[AS|$m|1
fjf$ Lf jrfd aida{rrkdaef f F{lf Ofjdf qejdegeaf {df b{kdf qkfl sfrf kl arkaeoekd}i mkl sfq$ Fafmoeaiq u kosrkqfreiq qk mekrid ae}f sfrf meflijfr u fsir}fr$
Kl sfdkl mk fskr}{rf igrkae
{d bflfdak mk lf }krakrf rk/
wil{aed edm{q}refl u lfq ]EA$
Lf kpsiqeaed edeaefl kq}{wi f
afrji mk Wa}ir Afq}kli (Oedeq/
}krei mk Km{afaed u Aekdaef
mk Kqsff%, faiosffmi sir
N{fd Eda`{q}kj{e (]KAQ[S%, u
Nfwekr Ej{e~ (Fa{krmi Dfaei/
dfl%8 kd lf qkj{dmf sfr}eaesf/
rid kl Mr$ Kgrfd Jid~flkq mk
Ilfr}k, weakrrka}ir fafmoeai
mk lf S[AS8 Bkdnfod Afq}fk/
mf, miakd}k mk lf Qkaaed Klka/
}reaemfm u Klka}rdeaf S[AS8 u
L{eq A`fwkq (EDAFLSFAF ]SP%$
Oimkr lf Mrf$ Skse Sf}rd, we/akrrka}irf mk Edwkq}ejfaed$
Qk fbirm lf qe}{faed mk lf rk/
jed rkqska}i f lf krf meje}fl$
Kl sreokr kpsiqe}ir g{k Grfd/
aeqai Qfjfq}e (GIRI Dfaeidfl
Ed}krdfaeidfl u srkqemkd}k mkl
GEDAu]%, v{ekd kq}{wi faio/
sffmi sir Grfdaeqai Qfd
Ofr}d (OEDHF% u Km{frmi We/
llfd{kwf (Mksfr}fokd}i mkAio{deafaeidkq%$ Kl qkj{dmi
g{k ]fmfi ]fhf`fq`e (Afs}{li
Brfqelki mk lf Qiaekmfm Ed}kr/
dfaeidfl mk Ed}krdk} u Rkm Df/
aeidfl mk Edwkq}ejfaed mk Brf/
qel%$ Aiokd}frid Nifv{d J{k/
rrkri (MEF% u Afrliq Qda`k~
(IQES]KL%$ Oimkr d{kq}ri we/
akrrka}ir fafmoeai$
SFDKL 6
SFDKL 2
L }a wilae emq}el u l mqilli
foea L}e u l }a wilae emq}el
Wr fkL j{rrk~Merka}ir mk Edgrfkq}r{a}{rf kd k/Aekdaef mkl Oedeq}krei mk Km{afaed uAekdaef mk Kqsff
Lfq rkmkq mk edwkq}ejfaed kq}d afobefd/
mi kl o{dmi$ Kq}fq rkmkq `fd arkaemi aid
liq fda`iq mk bfdmf, v{k srisiraeidfd ai/
dkpeidkq kqskaeflkq sfrf mk}kroedfmiq sri/
uka}iq aiiskrf}ewiq k{riskiq sfrf }kofq mk
fl}fq srkq}faeidkq mk aios{}faed$ Lfq sri/
sefq rkmkq mk edwkq}ejfaed dfaeidflkq kd K{risf kq}d }e/
rfdmi gebrfq fq}f lf grid}krf, sfrf aidka}fr sfqkq u fakr
{df rkm srisef$ Kd Skr, lfq wkliaemfmkq di qid o{u jrfd/
mkq, skri lf kwil{aed llkjfr }fobed$ Lfq rkmkq qid {d se/
lfr mk lf }krakrf rkwil{aed edm{q}refl$ Lf q{skraios{}f/
aed kq flji g{dmfokd}fl sfrf lf edwkq}ejfaed, qkjd li
v{k dkakqe}koiq$ Lf aiosfr}eaed kq g{dmfokd}fl kd ed/
grfkq}r{a}{rfq u kd emkfq$
ff fhf`f`Srkqemkd}k mkl Afs}{li Brfqelki mk lf Qiaekmfm Ed}krdfaeidfl mkEd}krdk}
Kd {df qiaekmfm, lfq skrqidfq }ekdkd v{k }k/
dkr aidgefd~f$ Kd kq}k fqska}i, Brfqel }ekdk
sriblkofq sirv{k lf qiaekmfm kq} mewememf$
Airkf i Nfsd qid gfd}q}eafokd}k b{kdiq
sirv{k fu {d qkd}emi mk {demfm$ @fu sfqkq
v{k }ekdkd pe}i kd kq}f }krakrf rkwil{aedsir wfrefq rf~idkq> sirv{k }ekdkd {df weqed o{u ofrafmf
mk v{ kq kl sfq u v{ mkbk qkr kqk sfq, sirv{k a{fdmi fr/
ofd sriuka}iq li fakd wkrmfmkrfokd}k, sirv{k }ekdkd i
b{qafd rka{rqiq sfrf mkqfrrillfr sriuka}iq, sirv{k a{fdmi
frofd sriuka}iq dfaeidflkq }ekdkd v{k llkjfr f afmf sriwed/
aef, sirv{k }ekdkd v{k }kdkr afse}flemfm, u sirv{k }ekdkd
fmfs}fbelemfm, uf v{k o{a`fq wkakq di qfbkoiq aoi ofd/
}kdkr lfq aiqfq u fmfs}frlfq f lfq aera{dq}fdaefq$
kgrfd jd~fLk k LfrkWeakrrka}ir fafmoeai mk lf S[AS
Liq afobeiq }kadiljeaiq kq}d kd kl irejkd
mk afobeiq kaidoeaiq, qiaeflkq u sil}eaiq$
Lf edm{q}refle~faed kq arkf}ewemfm u }rfdq/
girofaed k eddiwfaed, v{k jkdkrf {d sri/
akqi mk edwkdaed edmkgedemf$ Kl }kof edm{q/
}refl, mkqmk lf sreokrf rkwil{aed, kq aoi
arkfr aiqfq d{kwfq f sfr}er mk lfq kpeq}kd}kq$ Kq {d }kof
fa{o{lf}ewi sirv{k weweoiq kd g{daed mk {d frqkdfl mk
srim{a}iq v{k fd oknirfmi d{kq}rfq wemfq$ Lfq rkwil{aei/
dkq edm{q}reflkq di qili fd afobefmi lf srim{aaed, qe/
di }imf lf kaidiof$ Kl simkr v{k }ekdk lf eddiwfaed u lf
edwkq}ejfaed kq o{u jrfdmk$ Afmf rkwil{aed edm{q}refl
`f f{okd}fmi lf }fqf mk arkaeoekd}i kaidoeai skri }fo/
bed lfq mkqej{flmfmkq$
grfd fjfG{dmfmir k edwkq}ejfmir mk GIRI Dfaeidfl Ed}krdfaeidfl
]kdkoiq lf iblejfaed mk mkqfrrillfr d{kq/
}rf srisef ed}krsrk}faed mkl o{dmi$ M{rfd/
}k o{a`i }ekosi diq `koiq faiq}{obrfmi f
qkr aidq{oemirkq sfqewiq mk lfq ed}krsrk}faei/
dkq v{k wekdkd kd K{risf, KK[[, Fqef u megk/
rkd}kq l{jfrkq8 skri arki v{k kd Foreaf Lf/}edf uf }kdkoiq lf ofm{rk~ sfrf kosk~fr f igrkakr di qili
{df ed}krsrk}faed mk d{kq}rf rkjed, qedi mkl o{dmi kd}k/
ri weq}i mkqmk d{kq}rf fa$ Ok sfrkak v{k kq}foiq kd {d oi/
okd}i alfwk sfrf lf `{ofdemfm, {d afobei mk siaf aioi
di li `fbfoiq weq}i mkqmk kl Rkdfaeoekd}i, aid kl q{rje/
oekd}i mk lf rkwil{aed aekd}geaf u, siq}kreirokd}k, lf rk/
wil{aed }kadiljeaf k edm{q}refl v{k qk srim{ni faef gedkq
mkl qejli PWE u sredaeseiq mkl PWEE$
OFREI LFAh
7/30/2019 PuntoEdu Ao 8, nmero 264 (2012)
4/16
=|$m|LEOF, mkl 65 fl 2; mk diwekobrk mkl 2362
EDGIROK> f{Lf Ofjdf 2362
V aialqeiq l mn q}fl O9Lf sreokrf kq v{k lf }krakrf
rkwil{aed kq {d `ka`i rkfl,
jlibfl u fl v{k }kdkoiq v{k
kd}rfr mk ofdkrf fa}ewf$ Lf
qkj{dmf kq v{k kq}f }krak/
rf rkwil{aed edm{q}refl diq
o{kwk kl seqi f lfq {dewkrqe/
mfmkq sirv{k diq meak v{k
}kdkoiq v{k afobefr wfreiq
}kofq kd lf girofaed v{k
mfoiq$ Lf girofaed meqae/
sledfr kq o{u leoe}fmf u lf
}kdmkdaef kq er f afrrkrfq ed/
}krmeqaesledfrkq$ Lf }krakrf kqv{k kd kl Skr kq}foiq f}rf/
qfmiq sir o{a`iq gfa}irkq>
kl oimkli mk mkqfrrilli v{k
}kdkoiq, oq oiwemi sir lf
rkd}f v{k sir lf jfdfdaef, ed/
`ebk lf eddiwfaed }kadilje/
af$ Mk i}ri lfmi, di fu {df
}rfmeaed mk rklfaed kosrk/
qf/{dewkrqemfm sfrf lf edwkq/
}ejfaed$ Lfq kosrkqfq srkgek/
rkd aiosrfr lf }kadilijf eo/
sir}fmf, u aid {d mlfr bfrf/
}i kq o{a`i oq aidwkdekd/
}k$ Sfrf klliq, lf eddiwfaed
di kq {df }frkf edokmef}f$
V qlemq q sm eosl/o} } q} }os/oe}i9Gfl}fd sil}eafq$ Kl Kq}fmi di
}ekdk {df sil}eaf mk aekdaef
u }kadilijf sfrf kl mkqfrri/
lli kd lf a{fl lfq {dewkrqemf/
mkq }kdjfd v{k n{jfr {d ril
ar{aefl, u kqi kq {d mkqskr/
Ka{fmir u diqi}riq$ D{kq}rf
fqserfaed kq sfqfr, sir liokdiq, f lf qkj{dmf meweqed$
Kq}f F{lf Ofjdf diq f qkrwe/
mi sfrf fakr {d mefjdq}eai
mk mdmk kq}foiq8 u, alfri, kq/
}f rkwil{aed iblejf f lfq {de/
wkrqemfmkq f girofr jkd}k sf/
rf v{k qkf sfr}k mk kq}f$
l mb q l il ml kq}/mi9Arkfr sil}eafq mk aekdaef u
}kadilijf sfrf kl mkqfrri/
lli$ @fbrf v{k mkgeder lf si/
l}eaf mk edwkq}ejfaed kd kl
Skr u f mdmk v{ekrk llkjfr$
Kd KK$[[$ qk edwekr}k kl 1+ mkl
SBE, kq mkaer, {diq 6; bellidkqmk mlfrkq, kd afobei, AID/
AU]KA }ekdk {d srkq{s{kq/
}i mk 63 oellidkq mk mlfrkq$
D{kq}ri sfq mkbkrf edwkr}er,
fsripeofmfokd}k, oel oe/
llidkq mk qilkq fl fi kd sil/
}eafq mk edwkq}ejfaed u mkqf/
rrilli$ Kq}iq gidmiq mkbkrfd
wkder mkl afdid u qkr iskrf/
miq sir {d oedeq}krei mk aekd/
aef, }kadilijf, eddiwfaed u
km{afaed q{skreir$ Sfr}k mk
kq}iq gidmiq mkbk mkq}edfrqk
f lf girofaed mk mia}irkq$
@fu v{k }kdkr kd a{kd}f v{k
liq edjrkqiq, srim{a}i mk lf
ed}klejkdaef, mk lf arkfaedmk d{kwiq srim{a}iq, d{kwiq
qeq}kofq, d{kwfq edm{q}refq,
d{kwi aidiaeoekd}i, qid o{/
a`i oq kq}fblkq v{k liq mk lf
oedkrf i liq mk liq rka{rqiq
df}{rflkq$ Liq sfqkq v{k uf
`fd edwkr}emi kd kq}i diq li
kq}d mkoiq}rfdmi$
Lfq rkwil{aeidkq }rfkd mkqej{flmfm skrioknirfd kl edjrkqi sriokmei
r$ kgrfdjd~fLk kLfrkWeakrrka}ir fafmoeaimk lf S[AS
OFREI LFAh
mk liq sfqkq$ Kq}f }krakrf rkwi/
l{aed edm{q}refl kq} mknfdmi
f}rq fl Kq}fmi dfaed, s{kq
lfq kosrkqfq kq}d kd }imi klo{dmi, lf jkd}k wefnf sir }imi
kl o{dmi u kl slfdk}f qk f k/
a`i kl kqsfaei df}{rfl$
l q l lbi m l ewqe/mm sio aioi q}9Lfq {dewkrqemfmkq }kdkoiq v{k
aidwkr}erdiq kd liq srioi}i/
rkq mkl afobei f sfr}er mk lf ed/
wkq}ejfaed }kadiljeaf u fsle/
afmf$ Kq eosiqeblk skdqfr v{k
}rfbfnfoiq qiliq, kq eosir}fd/
}k }rfbfnfr kd rkmkq$ Kd kl Skr
}kdkoiq mek~ {dewkrqemfmkq
v{k kq}d kd aidmeaeidkq mk ed/
wkq}ejfr kd rkm u fl}krdfr aid
{dewkrqemfmkq mkl kp}kreir$ Lfq
{dewkrqemfmkq mk edwkq}ejfaed
qid {dewkrqemfmkq kd midmk liq
srigkqirkq }ekdkd mia}irfmiq k
edwkq}ejfd$ Diqi}riq di wfoiq
f `fakr lf rkwil{aed edm{q/
}refl, kq}f uf kq} kd afoedi, mk/
bkoiq ed}rim{aerdiq kd kllf$
k v qe}ae q} l Sai qsa}i i}iq sqq mq} e9Kq}foiq kd }krakrf meweqed$ Kd
sreokrf meweqed kq}d Brfqel,
Opeai u Frjkd}edf$ Kd lf qk/
j{dmf, Ailiobef, A`elk, Wkdk/
~{klf$ U kd lf }krakrf, Sfrfj{fu,
Liq edjrkqiq
srim{a}i mkL
aidiaeoekd}i
qid o{a`i oq
kq}fbLkq v{k Liq
mk Lf oedkrf i Liq
mk Liq rka{rqiq
df}{rfLkq$
kdgiai
meaei mk rka{rqiq `{ofdiq$
D{kq}ri f}rfqi }ekdk v{k qkrq{bqfdfmi u, sfrf klli, fu v{k
rkskdqfr d{kq}rfq {dewkrqemf/
mkq kd g{daed mk lf }krakrf rk/
wil{aed edm{q}refl$ Qk rkv{ek/
rkd afrrkrfq o{a`i oq glkpe/
blkq u kq dkakqfrei gir}flkakr lf
girofaed mkl srkjrfmi kd }i/
miq liq a{rqiq bqeaiq$ @fu v{k
ilwemfrqk mk mfr kqskaefle~faei/
dkq kd srkjrfmi, s{kq kq}fq mk/
bkd wkder kd siqjrfmi$
lq qi lq }o}eaq lqv q mb eaeme s l i/oae m ewq}emiq9Mkbkoiq }rfbfnfr qkrefokd}k
kl }kof kdkrj}eai, v{k kq sfr/}k eosir}fd}k mkl }kof mk lf
}krakrf rkwil{aed edm{q}refl$
Lf edwkq}ejfaed qibrk kdkrjf
}ekdk v{k akd}rfrqk kd aoi me/
qkfr u aidq}r{er g{kd}kq v{k
}kdjfd }rkq afrfa}krq}eafq> v{k
qkfd qiq}kdeblkq, v{k {}eleakd
siaf kdkrjf u v{k di lf mkq/
skrmeaekd$ Fmeaeidflokd}k, mk/
bk qkr bfrf}f$
{q}m meni v lq wilaeiqemq}elq }obe } ai/qei mqelmm$Kgka}ewfokd}k, skri oknirfd
kl edjrkqi sriokmei$ Kl }kof kq
v{k afmf rkwil{aed edm{q}refl
rkmkgedk kl simkr u }ekdk kgka/
}i kd lf sil}eaf$ Liq reaiq mk lf
qkj{dmf rkwil{aed uf afqe di
kpeq}kd u di }ekdkd edgl{kdaef
kd kl simkr sil}eai$ Liq Girm,
NS Oirjfd, liq Riahkgkllkr uf
afqe di kpeq}kd$ Kl simkr qk rk/
mkgedk oq fll mk lfq grid}krfq
SirfrL grfd
Qk b{qa srioiwkr lf edwkq}e/jfaed kd lfq {dewkrqemfmkq$
Lf sreokrf kpsiqeaed g{k mkl
Mr$ Bkdnfod Ofr}eairkdf, nk/
gk mk lf Igeaedf mk Kwfl{faed
mk lf Edwkq}ejfaed mk lf S[/
AS8 liq aiokd}freq}fq g{krid
Flgrkmi Diwif (Kai Kdkrjfq%
u Mfwem A`wk~, miakd}k mkl
Mksfr}fokd}i mk Edjkdekrf$Lf qkj{dmf kq}{wi f afrji mk
Jeqkllf Irnkmf (AIDAU]KA%8
liq sfdkleq}fq g{krid L{eq Fl/
gfri, ([DFQ, Frkv{esf% u Dkl/
qid Ofdrev{k, miakd}k mkl Mk/
sfr}fokd}i mk AAQQ$ Oimkr
d{kq}ri weakrrka}ir fmoedeq/
}rf}ewi, Mr$ Afrliq Giqaf$
SFDKL 1
kl S u l }a wilae emq}el
jkLLf rkfSrkqemkd}f mk AIDAU]KA
Qe v{krkoiq llkjfr f {df
kaidiof mkqfrrillfmf,
`fu v{k srioiwkr lf jkdk/
rfaed mk aidiaeoekd}i
mkqmk kl Jibekrdi$ Lf }frkf
mk AIDAU]KA kq srioiwkr
lf sil}eaf mk aekdaef u }kadilijf, eos{l/
qfr lf edwkrqed kd jkdkrfaed mk aidiae/
oekd}i, srioiwkr kl mkqfrrilli mkl afse/
}fl {ofdi, lf edwkq}ejfaed aekd}geaf u
lf eddiwfaed kosrkqfrefl$ Kl Skr dkak/
qe}f rkgir~fr lf edgrfkq}r{a}{rf kd edq}e}{/
}iq sbleaiq mk edwkq}ejfaed kd aekdaef u
}kadilijf$ ]kdkoiq v{k srksfrfrdiq sf/
rf edaemer kd lf qigeq}eafaed mk liq dkji/aeiq f }rfwq mk lf edairsirfaed mk aidi/
aeoekd}i mk liq srim{a}iq$ Fl oimkli mk
mkqfrrilli srim{a}ewi qk lk mkbk ffmer
aekdaef u }kadilijf, u faiosffrli mk af/
se}fl `{ofdi aflegeafmi$
BkdfOd OfrrkdfNkgk mk lf Iaedf mk Kwfl{faed mk lf Edwkq}ejfaed
Lf rk{ded mk aekdaef u a{l/
}{rf kq kl s{d}i akd}rfl mk
lf fjkdmf mkl qejli 26> kl mk
lf }krakrf rkwil{aed edm{q/
}refl$ Qed kllf, lf faklkrfaed
mk lf `eq}iref mknfr f}rq liq
wflirkq mk lf aidwewkdaef {ofdf$ Skdqfr kd
lfq afrrkrfq mkl g{}{ri kq aidq}r{er s{kd}kq
kd}rk lfq mewkrqfq meqaesledfq$ Edjkdekrf qed
`{ofdemfmkq, kaidiof qed kailijf, edm{q/
}ref u km{afaed qed sf{}fq mk rkqsidqfbele/
mfm qiaefl i of}ko}eafq qed fr}k diq llkwf/
rd f lf r{edf mk lf kqskaek$ Lfq afrrkrfq mk ed/
jkdekrf, aekdaefq kpskreokd}flkq u aekdaefq
giroflkq }kdmrd {d edafla{lfblk si}kdaeflsfrf kl mkqfrrilli qiq}kdeblk u lf edal{qed
qiaefl$ Fqeoeqoi, lfq afrrkrfq mk {ofdemf/
mkq u aekdaefq qiaeflkq di s{kmkd mknfr mk lf/
mi {df mk lfq sra}eafq oq {ofdeq}fq mk lf
okd}k> lf edwkq}ejfaed aekd}geaf$krkrf f$ Qk kdgf}e~ kd kl ril edwkq}ejfmir mk lfq {dewkrqemfmkq$
OFREI LFAh
7/30/2019 PuntoEdu Ao 8, nmero 264 (2012)
5/16
S[AS|$km{|;
Sfrf kl Aeali Kqailfr mk Wkrfdi
Kd Aksrks{a
FRA@EWI MAE
Lf lebrkrf /kd fa{krmi aid lf
kme}ireflFdfjrfof/ kq} igkr/
}fdmi lebriq mk kq}f kme}irefl
aid kl ;3+ mk mkqa{kd}i qibrk
kl srkaei mk k}ev{k}f$ Lf igkr}f
aid}ekdk aekd}iq mk }}{liq mk
lfq ailkaaeidkq Sfdirfof df/
rrf}ewf, Dfrrf}ewfq `eqsdeafq,
Frj{okd}iq, Ardeafq u I}rf
w{kl}f mk ]{kraf$ Simrq kd/
aid}rfr lebriq mk Sf{l F{q}kr,@fdeg H{rkeq`e, Ribkr}i Bilfi,
Kdrev{k Welf / Of}fq, Qkrjei Se/
}il, @frilm Bliio, Ilewkr Qfah,
Flkqqfdmri Bfreaai, Ru~frm Hf/
s{qaedqhe, kd}rk i}riq$ Fsrf/
}k, v{k lf igkr}f qili qkr m{/
rfd}k diwekobrk$
]ekdkq {d kq}eli mk wemf qfl{/
mfblk9 ]k fleokd}fq airrka/
}fokd}k9Aioi sfr}k mk lf ede/
aef}ewf mkl Srijrfof S[AS Qf/
l{mfblk, lf Merkaaed mk Fq{d}iq
Kq}{mefd}elkq f klfbirfmi {df
kda{kq}f v{k qkr }el sfrf kp/
slirfr liq kq}eliq mk wemf mk liq
kq}{mefd}kqu qkrwer mk bfqk
sfrf rkfle~fr srijrfofq v{k
liq bkdkgeaekd$ Qe krkq fl{o/
di u lf kda{kq}f }k llkj f }{
airrki, fdof}k f aid}kq}frlfu f ailfbirfr$ Qili }k }iofr
{diq oed{}iq$ Rka{krmf v{k kq/
}f kq {df krrfoekd}f v{k qkr/
wer sfrf v{k oknirkq }{ aflemfm
mk wemf$ Fsriwa`flf$
Igkr}f kd lf Lebrkrf S[AS
Kda{kq}f
Wfoiq f lkkr
Lebriq mk sreokrf
Sfrf wewer oknir
@fblfdmimk Peokdf
Kl n{kwkq sfqfmi qk llkw f afbi, kd
}imi kl sfq, {d d{kwi qeo{lfari mk
qeqoi u }q{dfoe$ D{kq}rf [dewkrqemfm
di kq}{wi fl ofrjkd u sfr}eaes fa/
}ewfokd}k$ Fq, qkjd edgirofaed
srisiraeidfmf sir lf Merkaaed mk
Fmoedeq}rfaed u Gedfd~fq, kq}f wk~
`{bi {df sfr}eaesfaed mkl 02+ mk lf
aio{demfm S[AS srkqkd}k kd kqk oi/
okd}i kd kl afos{q$ Aid klli, q{skrf/
oiq sir }rkq s{d}iq lf aegrf flafd~fmfkd kl qeo{lfari fd}kreir$ F skqfr mk lf
oknirf, mkbkoiq }rfbfnfr sfrf li/
jrfr kl 633+$ Fqeoeqoi, mkbkoiq
rkairmfr v{k fu v{k }iofrdiq o{u
kd qkrei kq}fq sra}eafq$
Sfrf kq}fr srkwkdemiq
Qeo{lfari mk qeqoi u }q{dfoeJFBREKLF A@EFSSK
Sir edeaef}ewf mk Jid~fli AfdiRidafjleili, kpfl{odi mk lf
Gfa{l}fm Sqeailijf u fa}{fl
srigkqir mk mea`f {demfm faf/
moeaf, kq} kd ofra`f {d
sriuka}i qilemfrei v{k aidqeq/
}k kd lf aidq}r{aaed mk {df
beblei}kaf sfrf {d flbkrj{k mk
oq mk 033 deiq `{rgfdiq
mk lf aio{demfm Qfjrfmf Gf/
oelef, kd Wkd}fdellf$ Lf ede/
aef}ewf Ui airri, klliq lkkd
aidqeq}k kd v{k Afdi airrf
sfrf wkdmkr liq helok}riq
v{k rkairrkr sfrf aidqkj{er
gidmiq$ Qe v{ekrkq fu{mfr,
bqafliq kd Gfakbiih aioi
Ui airri, klliq lkkd$
Q{ofdmi kqg{kr~iqUi airri, klliq lkkd
Aioi sfr}k mk lf edeaef}ewf
Wfoiq f lkkr, lf Merkaaed mk
Fa}ewemfmkq A{l}{rflkq (MFA[%
mk d{kq}rf [dewkrqemfm edwe}f f
lf aio{demfm S[AS f lf okqf
rkmidmf mkdioedfmf Mk}rq
mk Peokdf mk miq afoediq, v{k
aid}fr aid lf srkqkdaef mk lf
sik}f Afrokd Ill, lf Lea$ Df/
}flef Ej{e~, lf Mrf$ Q{qfdf Gre/
qfda`i u lf Lea$ Fdf L{af ]klli,
v{ekdkq fdfle~frd u mkbf}erd
kd }irdi f lf diwklf mk Lf{rf
Rekqai$ Kq}f kq lf l}eof fa}e/wemfm mkl fi mk Wfoiq f lkkr$
Di }k lf sekrmfq sir dfmf$ Lf
ae}f kq kq}k n{kwkq, f lfq 62>13
s$o$, kd kl F{me}irei mk @{/
ofdemfmkq$ Kl edjrkqi kq lebrk$
Kl mioedji = mk diwekobrk qk rkfle~ lf PE
Srksr{kbf Aksrks{a merejemf f fl{odiq mk = mkqka{dmfref$ ]imiq liq sfr}eaesfd}kq rkaebek/
rid {d edgirok skrqidfle~fmi u mk}fllfmi qibrk
q{q gir}flk~fq u mkbelemfmkq fafmoeafq kd lfq
aiosk}kdaefq sfrf lf wemf {dewkrqe}fref$Fqeoeq/
oi, qk srkoe f liq 2= sreokriq s{kq}iq aid bk/
afq, qkoebkafq u a{fr}iq mk bkaf sfrf kq}{mefr
kd kl Aeali Kqailfr mk Wkrfdi, mk kdkri f gkbrkri
mkl 2361$ Lkq rkairmfoiq v{k, mkqmk kl wekr/
dkq 6= fl oerailkq 65 mk meaekobrk, }imiq
liq ed}krkqfmiq s{kmkd of}rea{lfrqk sfrf kl
Aeali mk Wkrfdi sfrf kqailfrkq mk Aksrks{a$
Sfrf oq edgirofaed u rkv{qe}iq kd}rf f>
zzz$aksrks{a$s{as$km{$sk
lfri}idmf
Niq L{eq Ofrd$ Infl v{k di }kdjf kloeqoi mkq}edi mk lf Igeaedf Dfaeidfl Fd}e/airr{saed (IDF%, mk Afriledf Le~rrfjf$
Skmri Aeqdkriq$ Q{q sreokrfq g{daeidkqmkbkrfd qkr mkq}fsfr fv{kllfq oflfq jkq/}eidkq mkd}ri mkl Kq}fmi$ Kq}i kq oiq}rfrliq ofliq ofdkniq kd}rk n{kakq u mk}ka}frsriblkofq mk airr{saed kd}rk srigkqirkqu merka}irkq mk kqa{klfq kq}f}flkq$ V{k di qkv{kmk kd {d diobrk ed}krkqfd}k u bide}i$
Aqfr Afq}elli V{ed}fdf$ Q{ arkfaedkq} bekd$ Ok srkia{sf oq q{ qiq}kdebe/lemfm kd kl }ekosi, u mkbkrf kosk~fr sirliq oq fl}iq afrjiq, s{kq klli qkrf knko/slfr sfrf lf qiaekmfm$
@klo{} Ofr}ed B{qa`$ Q{ g{daedmkbkrf qkr mkalfrfrlk lf j{krrf f lf airr{s/aed, fmkoq fakr sr{kbfq sir okmei mkfjkd}kq kda{bekr}iq u wkr v{edkq qid liqairr{s}iq$
Afrliq Wfrjfq Sfrkmkq$ Aioi merfDfsilkd, qe v{ekrkq v{k flji qk kd}ekrrk uilwemk, arkf {df aioeqed$ Arki v{k kq oq
b{riarfaef kd l{jfr mk oq jkd}k aflegeaf/mf u kgka}ewf, oknirkq okmeiq, oq rka{r/qiq, k}a$
L{eq Km{frmi Frwfli$ Aid}ril u f{me/}irfq skrofdkd}kq mk lf ofuirf mk kd}e/mfmkq sbleafq, qibrk }imi mk fv{kllfq v{krkaf{mfd u ofdknfd fl}iq gidmiq kaid/oeaiq$
V[ ISEDFQ MK LF ARKFAED MK LF AIOEQED MK FL]I DEWKL FD]EAIRR[SAED U A[LKQ MKBKD QKR Q[Q G[DAEIDKQ9
)s{as Cs{asWIAKQMKL
7/30/2019 PuntoEdu Ao 8, nmero 264 (2012)
6/16
iseded
Qk fakraf kl aekrrk mk kq}f }kosirfmf u, aid l, lf k}f/
sf oq fje}fmf mkl aflkdmfrei fafmoeai mk lf [de/
wkrqemfm> diwekobrk qk afrfa}kre~f sir qkr kl okq mk
ofuir dokri mk fa}ewemfmkq irjfde~fmfq sir d{kq/
}rf edq}e}{aed$
Kd kq}f kmeaed koiq mfmi {d kqsfaei kqskaefl sf/
rf edgirofr qibrk {df mk lfq fa}ewemfmkq fafmoe/
afq oq eosir}fd}kq v{k qk f rkfle~fmi kd kl fi>
F{lf Ofjdf 2362$ Fq, kl kqsfaei v{k }rfmeaeidfl/
okd}k mkmeafoiq fl fdleqeq mk }kofq mk aiu{d}{/
rf (sjq$ 2/=%, li koiq {}ele~fmi sfrf igrkakrlkq fl/
j{dfq mk lfq eojkdkq u mkalfrfaeidkq oq eosir/
}fd}kq mk kq}k jrfd kda{kd}ri v{k, kd kq}f isir}{/
demfm, llkw sir }}{li Lf }krakrf rkwil{aed edm{q/
}refl u kl Skr$
Sir i}ri lfmi, kd kq}k dokri }fobed lkq srkqkd}f/
oiq aid o{a`i kd}{qefqoi kl d{kwi Sir}fl mk Rk/
weq}fq S[AS (sjq$ 0 u 5%$ Qk }rf}f mk {d jrfd sfqi,
eos{lqfmi sir d{kq}ri Qeq}kof mk Beblei}kafq, sfrf
meg{dmer kd ldkf d{kq}rfq rkweq}fq fafmoeafq$ @fq/
}f kl oiokd}i qk s{kmkd kdaid}rfr 2: }}{liq, skri,
siai f siai, qk erd edairsirfdmi d{kwiq$
Aioi simrd wkr, kq}f kmeaed mk S{d}iKm{,VuDkikq} rkslk}f mk edgirofaed u fa}ewemfmkq v{k, kq}f/
oiq qkj{riq, qkrd mk q{ ed}krq, qed kobfrji, di
v{krkoiq mknfr mk okdaeidfr u rkaiokdmfr lf kd/
}rkweq}f v{k lk eaekrid liq srigkqirkq Oej{kl Je{q}e
u Gemkl ]{bedi fl rkaidiaemi ed}klka}{fl ]~wk}fd ]i/
miriw (sj$ 67%$
KME]IREFL
Llkdiq mk fa}ewemfmkq
[D JRFD ]RFBFNFMIR MK LF S[AS
Mid Afrliq Qi}iofuir
Kd kl srkqkd}k fi 2362,
l{kji mk oq mk a{frkd/
}f fiq mk kq}fr weda{lf/
mi f lf S[AS, kl edjkdekri Afr/
liq Qi}iofuir f s{kq}i ged f
q{q lfbirkq aioi }rfbfnfmir
mk lf [dewkrqemfm$
Mid Afrliq Km{frmi Qi}i/
ofuir ]klli edjrkq f lf Af}/
leaf kd kl fi 6570 u kq}{me
Fjridiof, {df mk lfq afrrk/
rfq v{k sir fv{kl kd}idakq
kpeq}f aioi kqskaeflemfm mk
Edjkdekrf$ A{loed q{q kq/}{meiq, qk }e}{l mk Edjkdekri
Fjrdioi k edeae q{q lfbi/
rkq }rfbfnfdmi kd lf [dewkrqe/
mfm sir {d lfrji skreimi v{k
`f aidal{emi kq}k fi$
A{fdmi l llkj aioi
fl{odi fl fa}{fl afos{q {de/
wkrqe }frei, lfq ed q}flfaei dkq
krfd o{u skv{kfq, uf v{k,
kd rkflemfm, lf [dewkrqemfm qk
{beafbf kd {d srkmei r{rfl mk/
meafmi f lf fjrea{l}{rf$
Mid Afrliq Qi}iofuir, kd
q{q a{frkd}f fiq mk }rfbfni,
`f mkqkoskfmi ol}eslkq
}frkfq u fq{oemi eosir}fd/
}kq rkqsidqfbelemfmkq kd lf we/mf fmoedeq}rf}ewf {dewkrqe}f/
ref$ @f weq}i arkakr u afobefr
lf S[AS kd q{q liaflkq, kd q{q
qkrweaeiq u kd q{ arkaeoekd}i
edq}e}{aeidfl aioi [dewkrqe/
mfm v{k girof ae{mfmfdiq u
srigkqeidflkq$
F Mid Afrliq Qi}iofuir qk
bf mdmk kq}fbfd lfq glirkq,
lfq slfd}fq, liq rbilkq, liq wk/
dfmiq u lfq frmellfq kd kl afo/
s{q, u sirv{k }kdf {df wflei/
qf wiafaed mk qkrweaei sfrf
qil{aeidfr sriblkofq, jkq}ei/
dfr }roe}kq u mkoiq}rfr v{k
kl mkqki mk qkrwer q{skrf sri/
blkofq u rkq{klwk aidglea}iq,
fq qk aidwer}e kd {d foeji
mk }imiq$
Kd liq l}eoiq fiq, g{k me/
rka}ir fmn{d}i mk Fmoedeq/
}rfaed, ed}kdmkd}k mkl Afo/s{q u nkgk mk Ofd}kdeoekd}i,
}frkfq v{k a{osle aid mkme/
afaed fq}f kl l}eoi mf mk
q{ skrofdkdaef$
Kd lf wemf {dewkrqe}fref,
a{fdmi qk rk}erf {d fafmoe/
ai qekosrk qk mf rka{krmi mk
q{ }rfuka}iref u q{ knkosli mk
wemf$ Mid Afrliq Q i}iofuir
g{k {d fmoedeq}rf}ewi, }fo/
bed g{k {d kpfl{odi mk lf
S[AS, skri q{q a{frkd}f fiq
}rfbfnfdmi kd lf [dewkrqemfm
aid idrfmk~ u mkmeafaed,
arki, fokre}fd {dfq ldkfq mk
rka{krmi, mk fjrfmkaeoekd}i
sir li bekd v{k li `e~i qed kq/skrfr rkaioskdqfq u qekosrk
a{l}ewfdmi kqf kp}rfirmedf/
ref aidm{a}f mfmf sir lf flk/
jrf mk qkrwer$
@fu {df a{l}{rf mkl }rfbf/
ni aioi wflir qiaefl k edq}e}{/
aeidfl$
Qfl{miq, Mid Afrliq$
SirKDREV[KJID^LK^ AFRRFd}risliji u merka}irmk lf Merkaaed mkFa}ewemfmkq A{l}{rflkq
KD Q[Q A[FRKD]FFIQ MK ]RFBFNI$@F WEQ]I ARKAKR UAFOBEFR LF S[ASKD Q[Q LIAFLKQ,KD Q[Q QKRWEAEIQ UKD Q[ ARKAEOEKD]I
EDQ]E][AEIDFL$
lk rka{krmf sir lf si}kdaef u
alfremfm mk q{ wi~$ Sir q{ sre/
welkjefmf okoiref v{k lk skr/
oe}f rkairmfr liq diobrkq u
lfq g{daeidkq mk lf ofuirf
mk }rfbfnfmirkq$ Sirv{k qf/
7|$km{|LEOF, mkl 65 fl 2; mk diwekobrk mkl 2362
MEG[QED MKL AIDIAEOEKD]I
Lf Afqf mk lf Le}krf}{rf Skr{fdf u q{ fsir}k f lf a{l}{rf
Lf Afqf mk lf Le}krf}{rf Sk/
r{fdf (AFQLE]% fbre q{q
s{kr}fq kd ia}{brk mkl
2335 aid kl ibnk}ewi mk meg{d/
mer lf le}krf}{rf skr{fdf u sri/
oiwkr lf kq}eo{lfaed f lf lka/
}{rf kd}rk kqailfrkq, miakd}kq,
fofd}kq mk lf le}krf}{rf u kl
sbleai jkdkrfl$ [beafmf kd lf
fd}ej{f Kq}faed mk Mkqfosf/
rfmiq, lf AFQLE] rkaebk f {d s/
bleai afmf wk~ oq ofqewi, v{k
o{a`fq wkakq di f }kdemi fa/
akqi f {d kqsfaei a{l}{rfl jrf/
}{e}i, kd kl v{k s{mekrf fsripe/
ofrqk f lf le}krf}{rf di qilimkqmk lfq kpsiqeaeidkq }kosi/
rflkq i skrofdkd}kq, qedi mkq/
mk liq aealiq mk aedk, }fllkrkq mk
fdeofaed f lf lka}{rf, a{kd/
}fa{kd}iq, qkoedfreiq mk ar/
}eaf u kqare}{rf, aidgkrkdaefq
u {df foslef jfof mk kwkd}iq
v{k b{qafrid llkdfr kqk wfai
a{l}{rfl v{k Leof rkqekd}k$
Kd}rk liq wfleiqiq
fsir}kq v{k f ka`i
mkq}fafd lfq o{kq}rfq
mkmeafmfq f Ofr}d
Fmd, Aeri Flkjrf, Re/
afrmi Sflof, Niq Of/
rf Kj{rkd, Lkidemfq
Ukriwe, Afrliq Km{fr/
mi ^fwflk}f, kd}rk
i}riq$ ]fobed qk `f
rkdmemi }reb{}i f lf le/
}krf}{rf fof~deaf, f
lfq rkweq}fq wfdj{frmeq}fq, fl le/
bri edgfd}el skr{fdi, fl }kf}ri
skr{fdi mkl qejli PP, f lf le}k/
rf}{rf frkv{eskf, f lf jkdkrf/aed si}eaf mkl aeda{kd}f u f
lf ar}eaf le}krfref skr{fdf$ Fqe/
oeqoi, o{a`fq mk lfq kpsiqe/
aeidkq fd wefnfmi f sriwed/
aefq aioi sfr}k mkl Srijrfof
mk Mkqakd}rfle~faed Le}krfref$
Kd lfq l}eofq qkofdfq,
{df edkqskrfmf di}eaef llkd
mk n{q}egeafmfq o{kq}rfq mk rk/
]imi sfrkak edmeafr v{k lfq wi/
akq mk v{ekdkq lkwfd}frid q{
sri}kq}f g{krid kqa{a`fmfq$ U
kq v{k, qe qk b{qaf lf edal{qed,
kl faakqi jrf}{e}i k ej{fle}frei
f lf a{l}{rf aidq}e}{uk {d sfqi
g{dmfokd}fl kd kq}f bqv{k/
mf$ Qe lf arkfaed mk lf Afqf mk
lf Le}krf}{rf q{s{qi kl rkaidi/
aeoekd}i mk kq}f sreiremfm, q{
skrofdkdaef rksrkqkd}f {d
fwfdak sfrf lf a{l}{rf u sfrf
}imiq liq skr{fdiq$ Qili v{kmf,
kd}idakq, qkj{er }rfbfnfdmi kd
lf meg{qed mk d{kq}rf le}krf}{/
rf, {df mk lfq oq wfrefmfq u rk/aidiaemfq mkl aid}edkd}k fok/
reafdi8 kd kl kq}o{li f lf lka}{/
rf mkqmk lfq oq }kosrfdfq jk/
dkrfaeidkq8 u kd lf mkqakd}rfle/
~faed mkl aidiaeoekd}i8 sred/
aesflkq ibnk}ewiq v{k skrqej{k
lf Afqf mk lf Le}krf}{rf, liq a{f/
lkq fbr mk a{osler, iu oq
v{k d{daf$
SirLEA$ JRFAEFFDJ[LI GLIRKQEdwkq}ejfmirf mk lfAFQLE] u nkgk mk sra}eafqmkl Ms}i$ mk @{ofdemfmkq
}krfrei u kl kq}o{li
f lf lka}{rf mkqmk lf
oq }kosrfdf kmfm
kq}d jfrfd}e~fmiq$
Qed kobfrji, f{d
oq jrfwk v{k kq}i
rkq{l}fbf lf gfl}f mk
are}krei mk v{ekdkq
b{qafbfd srioiwkr
kq}f okmemf, qed fm/
wkr}er v{k, kd {d sfq
aioi kl d{kq}ri, lf
a{l}{rf mkbk mknfr mk
qkr {d l{ni fl v{k qili faakmk
{df le}k8 mkbk mknfr mk ia{sfr
{d l{jfr rklkjfmi kd lf fqejdf/
aed mkl srkq{s{kq}i sbleai
sfrf sfqfr f aidwkr}erqk kd lf
sreiremfm mk {d sfq v{k b{qaf
lf }fd fdqefmf edal{qed qiaefl$
Fgir}{dfmfokd}k, kq}f di}e/
aef uf v{km mkq}krrfmf, kd }fd/
}i kl srkqemkd}k Illfd}f @{of/
lf qkfl v{k lf Afqf qkj{er
g{daeidfdmi aid diroflemfm$
a`f~i lfq rkmkq qiaeflkq u flj{/
diq okmeiq kqare}iq$ Qk }rf}fbf
mk lf }kd}f}ewf mk lf Srkqemkd/
aef mkl Aidqkni mk Oedeq}riq mkaidwkr}er kl liafl midmk fa}{fl/
okd}k g{daeidf lf AFQLE] kd
{d akd}ri mk igeaedfq fmoedeq/
}rf}ewfq$ Qe kq}k ed}kd}i `{bek/
qk }rfqakdmemi, kl sbleai v{k,
mefref i kqsirmeafokd}k, fqeq/
}k f lf AFQLE] {bekrf skrmemi
{d wfleiqi kqsfaei kd midmk lf
meg{qed mkl aidiaeoekd}i le/
7/30/2019 PuntoEdu Ao 8, nmero 264 (2012)
7/16
Mkl qbfmi 20 mk ia}{brk
fl wekrdkq 2 mk diweko/
brk qk mkqfrrill kd Le/
of lf PPEEE Ileosefmf Of}k/
o}eaf mk Sfqkq mkl Aidi Q{r
(PPEEE IOSAQ%, kd lf v{k sfr/
}eaesfrid mklkjfaeidkq aio/
s{kq}fq sir fl{odiq okdi/
rkq mk 67 fiq mk Frjkd}edf,
Bilewef, Brfqel, A`elk, Ka{fmir,
Sfrfj{fu, Skr u [r{j{fu$ Liq
fl{odiq skr{fdiq ib}{wek/
rid miq okmfllfq mk iri u miq
okmfllfq mk slf}f, u }i}fle~f/rid 230 s{d}iq mk 2=3 ib}kde/
blkq, aid li a{fl qk {beafrid
kd sreokr l{jfr kd}rk lfq mk/
lkjfaeidkq sfr}eaesfd}kq, aid
{df wkd}fnf mk 12 s{d}iq rkq/
ska}i f lf mklkjfaed v{k v{k/
m kd qkj{dmi l{jfr$ [di mk
liq fl{odiq skr{fdiq Rfl
A`wk~ Qfroekd}i, aidiaemi
aioi Rf{le}i, g{k kl deai mk
liq srkoefmiq v{k ib}{wi kl
iri skrgka}i fl rkqilwkr f af/
bflemfm liq qkeq sriblkofq mk
lf aiosk}eaed$
]imiq kq}iq `ka`iq, kwe/
mkd}kokd}k, kdirj{llkakd f
a{flv{ekr skr{fdi u qid oi/}ewi mk srig{dmf flkjrf mk
v{ekdkq wkdeoiq } rfbfnfdmi
kd ileosefmfq of}ko}eafq
mkqmk `fak o{a`iq fiq kd
oe afqi, mkqmk 6500 sir wi/
afaed of}ko}eaf u miakd/
}k$ Qid kl rkq{l}fmi mk {d }rf/
bfni skrofdkd}k mk liq sri/
gkqirkq v{k kq}d akraf f liq
fl{odiq skr{fdiq o{a`iq
mk klliq kpiloseaiq u mk
skrqidfq k edq}e}{aeidkq ai/
oi lf Sid}egeaef [dewkrqemfm
Af}leaf mkl Skr, v{k mkqmk
6500 fsiuf lfq ileosefmfq
of}ko}eafq$ Af{qf jrfd qf/
}eqgfaaed v{k mkqmk kl 233=
kl Oedeq}krei mk Km{/
afaed `fuf fq{oe/
mi afmf fi lf irjf/
de~faed mk lfq Ileo/
sefmfq DfaeidflkqKqailfrkq mk Of}k/
o}eafq (IDKO% kd
aiirmedfaed aid lf
Aioeqed mk Ileo/
sefmfq mk lf Qiaek/
mfm Of}ko}eaf Sk/
r{fdf, u v{k kq}k
fi `fuf fq{oemi
}fobed lf aiirjf/
de~faed mk lf PPEEE
IOSAQ, v{k diq kq}
bredmfdmi liq lf{riq skr{f/
diq v{k aiokd}foiq ldkfq
frrebf$ Qk fd q{ofmi wfrefq
edq}e}{aeidkq aioi f{qseaef/
mirfq, kd}rk lfq v{k mkq}fafd
mk ofdkrf kqskaefl lf O{de/aesflemfm Ok}risile}fdf mk
Leof, lf S[AS u kl Edq}e}{}i
mk Of}ko}eafq u Aekdaefq Fge/
dkq (EOAF%$ Aedai srigkqirkq
mk lf S[AS sfr}eaesfrid kd lf
irjfde~faed u mkqfrrilli mk
kq}f aiosk}eaed fafmoeaf
ed}krdfaeidfl$
PPEEE ILEOSEFMF OF]KO]EAF MK SFQKQ MKL AIDI Q[R
]re{dgi skr{fdi kd Of}ko}eafq
SirMR$ [LMFREAIOFLFQSEDF
Miakd}k mklMksfr}fokd}i mkAekdaefq
EEE AIDGKRKDAEF ED]KRFOKREAFDF MK KQ][MEFD]KQ MK AID]FBELEMFM
Girofr aid}fmirkq sfrf kd}irdiq jlibflkq> kl mkqfgi
@iu kd mf sfrkak v{k rk/
gkrerdiq f lf jlibfle~f/
aed kq edkwe}fblk fl
fbirmfr a{flv{ekr fjkdmf qi/
brk kl mkqfrrilli mk }imf meq/
aesledf i srigkqed$ Klli di
ibkmkak f {df qeoslk oimf$
Lf sis{lfremfm mk lf v{k ji/
~f lf jlibfle~faed qk bfqf kd
v{k kq {d gkdokdi v{k
a{fl qfk}f wkli~ k edkl{meblk
flafd~ f }imi }esi mk skrqi/
dfq, kd}emfmkq u a{l}{rfq qi/
brk kl irbk$
[df sfr}ea{lfremfm mk lf
}fd edwiafmf jlibfle~faedkq v{k sfrf v{k fgka}k d{kq/
}rfq wemfq di kq dkakqfrei v{k
qfljfoiq g{krf mk lfq grid}k/
rfq mk d{kq}riq sfqkq> }frmk
i }kosrfdi, qkr lf jlibfle~f/
aed lf v{k wkdmr f d{kq}ri
kda{kd}ri$ Mea`i mk i}ri oi/
mi> o{a`fq kd}emfmkq isk/
rfd kd kd}irdiq jlibflkq qed
qev{ekrf rkfle~fr iskrfaeidkq
mk eosir}faeidkq i kpsir}f/
aeidkq mk bekdkq i qkrweaeiq$
Kd li v{k fl mkqfrrilli mk
lf srigkqed aid}fblk qk rk/
gekrk, kq}foiq wewekdmi {df
k}fsf mk srig{dmiq afobeiq$
Afobeiq v{k qfa{mkd, kd o{/
a`iq afqiq, lfq }rfdv{elfq bf/
qkq kd lfq v{k qk fqkd}fbfd liq
v{k`fakrkq oq bekd liaflkq
mk liq aid}fmirkq srigkqeidf/
lkq, u v{k diq rka{krmfd v{k
liq }ekosiq v{k weweoiq mk/
ofdmfd rkqs{kq}fq megkrkd/
}kq mk lfq v{k kq}bfoiq faiq/}{obrfmiq f mfr$
Kl jrfd skdqfmir aid}ko/
sirdki mk liq gkdokdiq
jlibflkq ^ujo{d} Bf{ofd
kqarebe v{k qkr liafl kd {d
o{dmi jlibfle~fmi kq {df qk/
fl mk skd{ref u mkjrfmfaed$
Skdqfr kd aid}ed{fr girofd/
mi f aid}fmirkq aid `fbele/
mkl ed}krq jkd{edi v{k kpeq/
}k kd lijrfr aid}fmirkq jlibf/
lkq$ U di qk } rf}f mk v{k qkfd
qilfokd}k okriq rkqsidmk/
mirkq mk lfq mkofdmfq mkl
o{dmi jlibfle~fmi, qedi v{k
}fobed s{kmfd ed}krsklfr
mefla}eafokd}k f kq}k o{d/
mi mkl v{k di mknfd mk qkr
sfr}k u aid}reb{er, aid kq/
}f ed}krfaaed, f lf aidq}r{a/
aed mk {d o{dmi afmf mf
oq mejdi mk qkr fbe}fmi$
.Kq oekobri mkl QOK Eoslk/
okd}f}eid Jri{s mkl EFQB u mkl
Aioe} Aidq{l}ewi kd DEEG mk lf
FEA$ Lfq isedeidkq aid}kdemfq
kd kl srkqkd}k fr}a{li qid lfq
mkl f{}ir, u di rksrkqkd}fd,
dkakqfrefokd}k, liq s{d}iq mk
weq}f igeaeflkq mk lfq edq}e}{aei/
dkq aid lfq a{flkq qk kda{kd}rf
weda{lfmi$
Sir@KRDD SFBLIAFQEDKLLEAid}fmir sbleaifrjkd}edi.
[DFSFR]EA[LFREMFM MKLF ]FD EDWIAFMFJLIBFLE^FAED KQV[K SFRF V[K FGKA]KD[KQ]RFQ WEMFQ DIKQ DKAKQFREI V[KQFLJFOIQ G[KRF MKD[KQ]RIQ SFQKQ$
Fl }ekosi v{k diq mfd flk/
jrfq liq rkq{l}fmiq mk lf PPEEE
IOSAQ, }fobed diq q{qae}fd
rkglkpeidkq u diq slfd}kfd mk/
qfgiq kd }irdi f lf km{afaed
of}ko}eaf kd d{kq}ri sfq$
Kq alfri v{k kl Skr kq {df si/
}kdaef iloseaf kd of}ko/
}eafq f dewkl ebkrifokreafdi,
skri }fobed kq alfri v{k fu
g{kr}kq mkgeaekdaefq kd lf gir/
ofaed of}ko}eaf mk lf of/
uirf mk d{kq}riq deiq mk km{/
afaed bqeaf$ Qe bekd kq aekr}i
v{k liq }re{dgiq kd lfq ileo/sefmfq of}ko}eafq v{k fi
f fi diq }rfkd lfq mklkjfaei/
dkq skr{fdfq qid {d kq}o{/
li sfrf d{kq}riq deiq u nwk/
dkq, }fobed kq aekr}i v{k gfl}f
{df sil}eaf kpslae}f mk fsiui
f lfq ileosefmfq of}ko}eafq$
Kq}fq mkbkd kq}fr oq edqkr}f/
S[AS|$km{|:
gkrkdaef Ed}krfokreafdf mk
Kq}{mefd}kq mk Aid}fbelemfm,
v{k qk llkw f afbi kd Leof,
liq mfq 67 u 6: mk diwekobrk
mk 2362, irjfde~fmf sir lf
Fqi aef ae d Ed}kr fokr eaf df
mk Aid}fbelemfm, u lf Gfa{l}fm
mk Fmoedeq}rfaed u Aid}fbe/
lemfm mk lf Sid}egeaef [dewkr/
qemfm Af}leaf mkl Skr$ Kq}iu
skrq{fmemi mk v{k kq}k o/
be}i `f qemi kl sriseaei sfrf
rkglkpeidfr fakraf mk liq mk/
qfgiq f liq v{k diq kdgrkd}f/
oiq aioi srigkqeidflkq u ib/
}kdkr {df oerfmf rkjeidfl mk{df eosir}fd}k a{kq}ed> dk/
akqe}foiq girofr aid}fmi/
rkq df}ewiq/jlibflkq, aid `f/
belemfmkq sfrf fa}{fr kd kd/
}irdiq oq aioslkniq v{k liq
v{k i}rirf aidiaekrid d{kq/
}riq srkmkakqirkq$
Lf foslef aidwiaf}iref mkl
kwkd}i kq {df o{kq}rf afbfl
mfq kd liq slfdkq mk km{afaed
kd aekdaef u }kadilijf, s{kq
q{ kpaklkd}k ril mk sriwiafr kl
a{l}ewi mk lf of}ko}eaf u mk
mkqa{brer nwkdkq aid }flkd}i
of}ko}eai di s{kmk v{kmfr
qili kd }fl mkqa{breoekd}i, qe/
di v{k mkbk qkr mkbemfokd/
}k aioslkokd}fmi aid qkj{e/
oekd}iq fafmoeaiq,
fsiuiq, }{}irfq, bk/
afq, k}a$, u aid}reb{er f
v{k d{kq}riq fl{odiq
u sri gkqirkq gir}flk~/afd q{ arkf}ewemfm u q{
afsfaemfm mk rkqilwkr u
arkfr sriblkofq, f v{k
kq}d oq aiosriok/
}emiq aid lfq of}ko}e/
afq u v{k meqgr{}kd }fd/
}i mk q{ jrfd {}elemfm
aioi mk q{ fqiobriqf
bkllk~f$
Lfq ileosefmfq of/
}ko}eafq, aid fl fsi/
ui mk lf S[AS u mkl EOAF, wek/
dkd faekdmi fsir}kq fl Skr
di qili aid kl lijri mk okmf/
llfq$ Fa}{flokd}k, fu a{f}ri
miakd}kq kd lf S[AS, kpilo/
seaiq, v{k mkgkdmekrid q{q }k/qeq mia}irflkq kd kl EOSF mkl
Brfqel fd}kq mk a{loedfr q{q
kq}{meiq mk bfa`ellkrf}i {de/
wkrqe}frei$ Kq}d `faekdmi mi/
akdaef k edwkq}ejfaed u s{ble/
afdmi kd eosir}fd}kq rkweq/
}fq kqskaefle~fmfq mkl kp}rfd/
nkri$ I}rf o{kq}rf mkl si}kd/
mfmkq sfrf fa}{fr kd okmeiqkpal{qewfokd}k liaflkq di kq
{df `es}kqeq rkfleq}f sfrf
mfr rkqs{kq}fq f lfq mkofd/
mfq aid lfq v{k `iu kl o{d/
mi kdgrkd}f u li qkj{er rkf/
le~fdmi f liq srigkqeidflkq
mk lf aid}fm{rf sbleaf$ Sir
klli, aklkbri aid bkdkslae}i
lf rkfle~faed mk kq}f EEE Aid/
Kq {df s{bleafaed mk lf Sid}estaef[dewkrqemfm Af}leafmkl Skr$Fw$ [dewkrqe}fref 6036, Qfd Oej{kl$ Mksqe}i Lkjfl> D233;/6770$Eosrkqi kd V{fm)Jrfs`eaq Skr Q$F$Liq }kp}iq s{bleafmiq qk s{kmkd rksrim{aer ae}fdmi lf g{kd}k u aidqejdfdmi liq arme}iq$
Aidqkni kme}irefl> Ewd @ediniqf (srkqemkd}k% , Fd}idei Skf N{osf, Ofr}d]fdfhf, Wflv{eref Rfoiq, Wkrdeaf Qflko u Ofrf Sf~ mk lf Ar{~$Kme}irkq>Ofrf Sf~ mk lf Ar{~ u Wkrdeaf Qflko$Q{bkme}irkq>Qfdmrf Frb{lu J{fmfl{sk Sfrmi$ Meqki>L{eq Fok~ u F{j{q}i Sf}ei$$km{
aefl of}ko}eai v{k }kdkoiq
kq v{k kd kq}f PPEEE IOSAQ,
}fd}i lf Srkqemkdaef u Weaksrk/
qemkdaef mkl N{rfmi Ed}krdf/
aeidfl aioi liq }reb{dflkq mk
aflegeafaed u lf aioeqed mk
sriblkofq, fd kq}fmi aidgir/
ofmiq sir kpiloseaiq v{k qk
`fd mkqkoskfmi brellfd}k/
okd}k, aioi li `fd ofdegkq/
}fmi wfreiq nkgkq mk mklkjfaed
kp}rfdnkriq$ @fu, s{kq, o{kq/
}rfq alfrfq mk v{k lfq ileosef/
mfq of}ko}eafq wfd mfdmiq{q gr{}iq, u kq}i mkbk qkr {df
rf~d oq sfrf f{dfr kqg{kr/
~iq u fsiufr kd jkdkrfl f mkq/
a{brer u gir}flkakr }flkd}iq
of}ko}eaiq$ ]kdji lf qkj{/
remfm mk v{k fu o{a`iq de/
iq u nwkdkq skr{fdiq aid
jrfd }flkd}i of}ko}eai v{k
fd di `fd qemi mkqa{bekr/
}iq, v{k s{kmkd `fakr jrfd/
mkq fsir}kq f d{kq}ri sfq kd
kl afosi mk lf aekdaef u lf }ka/
dilijf$ Aekr}fokd}k, fu o{/
a`i sir fakr, u v{ekdkq kq}f/
oiq aiosriok}emiq aid lfq
ileosefmfq of}ko}eafq aid/
}ed{frkoiq d{kq}ri aiosri/oeqi, skri kq eosir}fd}k v{k
liq kqg{kr~iq di qkfd feqlfmiq$
Mkbkoiq fa}{fr {demiq edq}e/
}{aeidflokd}k, b{qafdmi lf
ofdkrf s}eof mk gir}flkakr
fd oq kl jrfd si}kdaefl of/
}ko}eai v{k kpeq}k kd d{kq}rf
n{wkd}{m$
7/30/2019 PuntoEdu Ao 8, nmero 264 (2012)
8/16
0|$km{|LEOF, mkl 65 fl 2; mk diwekobrk mkl 2362
edwkq}ejfaed
Lf S[AS, f }rfwq mkl
Qeq}kof mk Beblei}k/
afq, kq} eos{lqfd/
mi lf arkfaed mk
`krrfoekd}fq sfrf
v{k lf srim{aaed fafmoeaf
u aekd }g eaf mk q{q fl{odiq,
miakd}kq k edwkq}ejfmirkq kq/
}d f meqsiqeaed mk }imf lf
aio{demfm {dewkrqe}fref u
kl sbleai ed}krkqfmi kd aid/
q{l}fr of}krefl mk aflemfm$
Kd kq}k qkd}emi, kl fi sfqf/
mi qk ark kl Rksiqe}irei Me/
je}fl mk ]kqeq S[AS, v{k }ekdk
{df ailkaaed mk oq mk oel
}kqeq mk Leakdaef}{rf, Ofkq/}rf u Mia}irfmi$
Kq}k fi, d{kq}rf [dewkr/
qemfm f v{kremi mfr {d sfqi
oq u f meqkfmi {df d{kwf
slf}fgirof v{k rkainf lf ai/
lkaaed mk rkweq}fq v{k kme}f/
oiq f }rfwq mk lfq meq}ed}fq
{demfmkq fafmoeafq$ Qk }rf/
}f mkl d{kwi Sir}fl mk Rkweq/
}fq S[AS, v{k qkr srkqkd}fmi
igeaeflokd}k kq}k oerailkq,
f lfq 1 s$o$, kd kl F{me}irei mk
Kq}{meiq Jkdkrflkq Lk}rfq$ Kd
q{ kq}rkdi, kq}k sir}fl igrkak
faakqi f {df leq}f mk 2: rkweq/
}fq (wkr rka{fmri%, skri oq
fmklfd}k qk erd edairsirfd/mi d{kwiq }}{liq$ Lf emkf kq
akd}rfle~fr }imfq lf s{bleaf/
aeidkq klka}rdeafq mk d{kq/
}rfq rkweq}fq kd {df slf}fgir/
of fmka{fmf v{k diq wf f
skroe}er meg{dmer kq}iq }rf/
bfniq kd lf zkb, kd liq dme/
akq mk bqv{kmf aioi Jii/
jlk u kd i}riq dmeakq kqskaef/
le~fmiq mk rkweq}fq midmk diq
s{kmfd kdaid}rfr, kpsleaf
Rfl Qeg{kd}kq, nkgk mk F{}i/
of}e~faed mkl Qeq}kof mk Be/
blei}kafq$
BEBLEI]KAFQ MEJE]FLKQ$
Kl sriuka}i mk `fakr {dfq{kr}k mk beblei}kaf meje}fl,
v{k sidjf kd we}redf d{kq}rf
srim{aaed, dfae fak miq
fiq$ Kd kl 2363, kl Rka}irf/
mi, f }rfwq mk q{ igeaedf mk
Fqkqirf ]adeaf , f af rj mkl
Edj$ Nirjk Qilq, irjfde~ {d
Aioe} mk Rfdhedjq sfrf kwf/
l{fr lf qe}{faed mk lf [dewkr/
Aidiaeoekd}i kd lSirWFDEF RFOIQ
D[KWI SIR]FL MK RKWEQ]FQ S[AS
qemfm kd liq rfdhedjq o{d/
meflkq kd meq}ed}iq obe}iq>
kd lf zkb, kd edwkq}ejfaed,
kd}rk i}riq$ Kl Qeq}kof mk Be/
blei}kafq sfr}eaes kd kq}k ai/
oe}, u f` wei lf dkakqemfm mk
}rfbfnfr kd lf meje}fle~faed
mk lfq }kqeq, v{k uf kq}fbfd
qekdmi }rfbfnfmfq sir lf Me/
rkaaed mk Edgiro}eaf Faf/
moeaf, skri v{krf mrqklk
{d kdgiv{k oq beblei}kai/
ljeai fl }kof$ Sir kqi, kl 6;mk n{dei mkl 2366 qk lfd~ kl
Rksiqe}irei mk ]kqeq$ F sfr}er
mk kd}idakq, kl oeqoi aioe}
rkaiokdm }rfbfnfr lfq rkweq/
}fq aid kq}k oeqoi kdgiv{k,
aiokd}f Qeg{kd}kq$
Kl ibnk}ewi sredaesfl kq v{k
kl srpeoi fi d{kq}ri Qeq}k/
of mk Beblei}kafq a{kd}k aid
{d Rksiqe}irei Edq}e}{aeidfl
v{k kdjlibk }imfq lfq s{ble/
afaeidkq u lfq edwkq}ejfaeidkq
mk lf S[AS kd girof}i meje}fl$
@koiq kosk~fmi aid }kqeq,
f`irf kq}foiq }rfbfnfdmi lfq
rkweq}fq, skri wfoiq fs{d}fd/
mi f }kdkr {d rksiqe}irei edq}e/}{aeidfl, v{k mkbkrf qfler kd
kl sreokr qkokq}rk mkl 2361
kpsleaf Qeg{kd}kq$ Kqk rksiqe/
}irei wf f }kdkr liq rkjeq}riq mk
lfq }kqeq, rkweq}fq u, fmkoq, qk
sekdqf edal{er lf srim{aaed
aekd}geaf i fafmoeaf mk af/
mf {demfm mk lf [dewkrqemfm$
Fq, l fq meq} ed}fq gfa{l}fmkq ,
}fle~fmiq kd K{risf, skri }k/
dkoiq flj{dfq ailkaaeidkq
mk lebriq deaiq, v{k di kq/
}d kd i}rfq sfr}kq, u kqk qk/
r d{kq}ri fsir}k f lf aio{/
demfm fafmoeaf, qkflf Qe/
g{kd}kq$
Lfq ailkaaeidkq mk skr{f/
diq wfleiqiq v{k `fd qemi mi/
dfmfq f lf S[AS wfd f kq}fr
}fobed meqsideblkq sfrf qkr
aidq{l}fmfq kd ldkf$ ]kdk/
oiq lf ailkaaed mk Ofr}d
Fmd, liq a{fmkrd iq mk L{eq
@krddmk~, lfq afr}fq mk Aeri
Flkjrf, kl fra`ewi Qfbriqi
aid mia{okd}iq eosir}fd}kqmkl qedmeafleqoi skr{fdi8
kd ged, }kdkoiq wfrefq ailka/
aeidkq v{k qk wfd f er meje}fle/
~fdmi siai f siai u qk wfd f
er irjfde~fdmi mkd}ri mk kq/
}k rksiqe}irei sfrf girofr {d
a{krsi mk mia{okd}iq eo/
sir}fd}k qibrk }kofq kqska/
geaiq, meak kl kqskaefleq}f$
Fqeoeqoi, uf qk `fd meje/
}fle~fmi 6: }}{liq mkl Gidmi
Kme}irefl mk lf S[AS v{k qk
kdaid}rfrd kd kq}f slf}fgir/
of wer}{fl$ Skri di qili flbkr/
jfr }kp}iq> liq mia{okd}iq
mk f{mei u wemki }fobed }kd/
mrd {d l{jfr kd kq}f beblei/
}kaf wer}{fl$ Wfoiq f sidkr
wemkiq mk ed}krq fafmoeai
i aekd}gea i v{k }kdkoiq, uf
qkf f{meiq i kd}rkweq}fq f skr/
qidflemfmkq mkl Skr, mk liq
a{flkq uf }kdkoiq liq mkrk/
a`iq sfrf simkr s{bleafrliq,
mk}fllf$
[df wk~ `fbele}fmi kl rk/siqe}irei aid kl of}krefl mkl
Qeq}kof mk Beblei}kafq, lfq mk/
oq {demfmkq kq}d edwe}fmfq
f kdwefr q{q mia{okd}iq$ Kq/
}k kqsfaei qkr emkfl sfrf f/
akr sbleafq lfq edwkq}ejfaei/
dkq i liq fwfdakq mk lfq oeq/
ofq, rkfle~fmfq sir miakd}k i
fl{odiq$ Qeg{kd}kq diq mk}f/
llf flj{diq
a`ewi mk lf
mkbk }kdkr
mia{okd}i
}kq, simr k
siqe}irei8 f
aed mk Jk
}ejfaed i l
}fmkq }fob
{df a{kd}f
oknirkq }rf
diq$ F lf lf
aidn{d}i m
meq}ed}fq r
Fmkoq
v{k ib}kd
aele}fr kl famia{okd}i
`fak dgfq
of}krefl v{
}f deaf sl
aid lfq f{}i
sidmekd}kq
rf q{ s{ble
r mk faakq
kl sbleai$
edq}e}{}iq { igeaedfq }kdmrd
{df a{kd}f kd kqk rksiqe}irei
sfrf v{k ailiv{kd liq mia{/
okd}iq mk ed}krq$
]KQIRIQ MK LF S[AS$ Qi/
li kl of}krefl mk d{kq}rf Be/
blei}kaf Akd}rfl q{of {d }i/
}fl mk 6: oel fra`ewiq (kd}rk
}kp}iq aid}kosirdkiq u fd/
}ej{iq, f{meiq u wemkiq%, u lf
emkf kq v{k kl srpeoi fi qk
simr faakmkr f }imiq kq}iq
mkqmk kl Rksiqe}irei Edq}e}{/
aeidfl$ Qk wf f kosk~fr f ai/
liafr sreokri kl of}krefl v{k
}ekdk lf Beblei}kaf Akd}rfl$ Kq/}f }ekdk ailkaaeidkq o{u eo/
sir}fd}kq v{k uf kq}d meje/
}fle~fmfq i wfd f kd}rfr f {d
sriakqi mk meje}fle~faed$ Sir
knkosli, wfoiq simkr weq{f/
le~fr sfr}e}{rfq o{qeaflkq i
ofsfq fd}ej{iq mkl Skr$ ]k/
dkoiq wfreiq lebriq fd}ej{iq,
o{a`iq mk klliq uf kq}d meje/
RFLQEG[KD]KQNkgk mkF{}iof}e~faedmkl Qeq}kof mkBeblei}kafq
Lf emkf kqakd}rfle~fr }imfqlfq s{bleafaeidkqklka}rdeafq mkd{kq}rfq rkweq}fqkd {df slf}fgiroffmka{fmf$
KL LFD^FOEKD]I MKL D[KWI SIR]FL MK RKWEQ]FQ S[AS KQ [DI MK LIQ SREOKRIQ SF
RKSIQE]IREI V[K FJR[SK U @FJF OQ WEQEBLK D[KQ]RF WFQ]F SRIM[AAED FAFM
7/30/2019 PuntoEdu Ao 8, nmero 264 (2012)
9/16
S[AS |$km{|5
dkf Lf Rkqsidqfbelemfm Qiaefl [dewkrqe}f/ref (RQ[% kq {d kdgiv{k v{k srisidkd{kwfq girofq mk weda{lfaed kd}rklf {dewkrqemfm u lf qiaekmfm8 mk kq}fofdkrf, qk }rf}f mk fsrkdmkr mk lfq
fa}ewemfmkq u sriuka}iq v{k qk llkwfd
fmklfd}k, u v{k kq}iq rkq{l}fmiq rk}ir/
dkd f lf {dewkrqemfm aioi sris{kq/
}fq mk afobei kd lf girofaed$ Qk }rf/
}f fq mk rk/skdqfr mk ofdkrf skrof/
dkd}k lf girofaed v{k igrkakoiq,
fq aioi lf edwkq}ejfaed v{k eos{l/
qfoiq$
Kd kq}k aid}kp}i, lf Merkaaed Faf/moeaf mk Rkqsidqfbelemfm Qiaefl
(MFRQ% irjfde~f kl EW Gidmi Aida{r/
qfblk sfrf Miakd}kq$ Kd kq}f isir}{/
demfm qk srkqkd}fd miq oimflemfmkq>
6$ A{rqiq qiaeflokd}k rkqsidqfblkq$
2$ Sriuka}iq mk mkqfrrilli> sriuka}iq
mk air}i slf~i (`fq}f = okqkq mk m{/
rfaed% u mk okmefdi slf~i (`fq}f 62
okqkq mk m{rfaed%$ Liq miakd}kq ed/
}krkqfmiq s{kmkd mkqafrjfr liq ledkf/
oekd}iq u giro{lfreiq mk edqaresaed
f }rfwq mk liq kdlfakq s{bleafmiq kd
lf zkb mk lf MFRQ$ ]ekdkd `fq}f kq}k
n{kwkq (22 mk diwekobrk% sfrf llkdfr
kq}iq giro{lfreiq u kdwefrliq f mfrqC
s{as$sk Sfrf a{flv{ekr m{mf i aid/
q{l}f, s{kmkd aio{deafrqk aid L{aef
Brfaai (l{aef$brfaaiCs{as$km{$sk, 727/2333 fdkpi 26=6%$
(edgirofaed>`}}s>))mfrq$s{as$km{$sk)
Lf Igeaedf mk Aiiskrfaed Ed}krdfaei/
dfl mk lf MFRE edgirof v{k kl Edq}e}{}i
mk Fl}iq Kq}{meiq mk Foreaf Lf}edf
E@KFL (Grfdaef% aidwiaf f miakd}kq kedwkq}ejfmirkq kqskaefleq}fq kd Aekd/
aefq Qiaeflkq kd kl rkf mk Foreaf Lf/
}edf f sfr}eaesfr kd lfq a}kmrfq mk lf
[dewkrqemfm Qirbidf D{kwfSfreq 1,
fq aioi f i}rfq {dewkrqemfmkq k edq}e/
}{aeidkq grfdakqfq u k{riskfq$
Liq siq}{lfd}kq mkbkrd qkr miakd/
}k fa}ewiq, di }kdkr oq mk 7; fiq u
qkr }e}{lfrkq mk {d mia}irfmi$ Qk rkae/
berd }imfq lfq sris{kq}fq mk @{ofde/
mfmkq u Qiaeflkq, qed kobfrji, qk }kd/
mr kqskaefl aidqemkrfaed sir lfq qe/
j{ekd}kq }ko}eafq> kaidiof mkl mk/
qfrrilli, rklfaeidkq ed}krdfaeidflkq,
`eq}iref mk Foreaf Lf}edf kd kl qejli
PP, qiaeilijf i fd}risilijf mkl mkqf/
rrilli r{rfl, u d{kwfq }kadilijfq mk lfedgirofaed$ Qk mkbk srkqkd}fr }rkq i
qkeq sris{kq}fq mk a{rqiq, }kdekdmi kd
a{kd}f kl }ekosi mk lf kq}fdaef v{k mk/
qkf rkfle~fr ({d qkokq}rk i {d fi%$
Liq = jfdfmirkq }kdmr {d q{klmi
okdq{fl i}irjfmi sir kl E@KFL, u lf
MFRE a{brer q{q sfqfnkq frkiq ufqqeq}
afrm$ Kl aekrrk mk lf aidwiaf}iref kq kl
l{dkq 27 mk diwekobrk$
(edgirofaed>`}}s>))blij$s{as$km{$sk)blij
)aiiskrfed}krdfaeidfl
Kl Akd}ri mk Edwkq}ejfaed, Afsfae}f/
aed u Fqkqirf N{rmeaf (AEAFN% aidwi/
af f fl{odiq, miakd}kq u kjrkqfmiq mk
lf Gfa{l}fm mk Mkrka`i fl sriakqi mk
qklkaaed mk }rfbfniq mk edwkq}ejfaed
n{rmeaf sfrf q{ s{bleafaed kd lf qk/
rek A{fmkrdiq mk ]rfbfni mkl AEAFN$
Kl ibnk}ewi mk lf qkrek kq giokd}fr lf
klfbirfaed u s{bleafaed mk }rfbfniq
mk edwkq}ejfaed n{rmeaiq k ed}krmeq/
aesledfreiq$
Kd kl afqi mk liq fl{odiq, kl }kp}i
simr qkr srkqkd}fmi sir {di i oq
f{}irkq$ Kl f{}ir i f{}irkq rkaeberdsir a{fmkrdi mk }rfbfni s{bleafmi
{df rk}reb{aed kaidoeaf mk Q)$ 6,
;333$ Fqeoeqoi, afmf rbe}ri rkaebe/
r {df rk}reb{aed kaidoeaf mk Q)$
;33 u afmf aiokd}freq}f, Q)$ 2;3$
Kd kl afqi mk liq srigkqirkq, kl }kp/
}i simr qkr srkqkd}fmi sir {di i
oq f{}irkq, qekosrk v{k kl f{}ir
sredaesfl qkf {d miakd}k mkl Mksfr}f/
okd}i Fafmoeai mk Mkrka`i$ Kl f{/
}ir i f{}irkq rkaeberd sir a{fmkrdi
mk }rfbfni s{bleafmi {df rk}reb{aed
kaidoeaf mk Q)$ 2, ;33, afmf rbe}ri
rkaeber {df rk}reb{aed kaidoeaf
mk Q)$ ;33 u afmf aiokd}freq}f, Q)$ 2;3$
Gedflokd}k, kd kl afqi mk liq kjrk/
qfmiq, simrd sfr}eaesfr kjrkqfmiq
a{ufq }kqeq mk leakdaef}{rf fufd ib/
}kdemi lf okdaed mk O{u bekd i
Qibrkqflekd}k u `fufd qemi q{q}kd/
}fmfq kd}rk kdkri mkl 2366 u diweko/
brk mkl 2362$ Kl f{}ir rkaeber sir a{f/mkrdi mk }rfbfni s{bleafmi {df rk}re/
b{aed kaidoeaf mk Q)$ 6,:;3, afmf
rbe}ri rkaeber {df rk}reb{aed kai/
doeaf mk Q)$ ;33 u afmf aiokd}freq/
}f, Q)$ 2;3$
Liq }kp}iq mkbkrd qkr kdwefmiq f
aeafnCs{as$km{$sk fq}f kl 13 mk di/
wekobrk$
@FQ]F KQ]K N[KWKQ
L]EOF Q KOFDF
SFRF MKRKA@I
Gidmi Aida{rqfblk sfrf Miakd}kq
A}kmrfq mkl Edq}e}{}i mk Fl}iqKq}{meiq mk Foreaf Lf}edf
A{fmkrdiq mk }rfbfniosliq> kl Fr/ewkrqemfm, v{kf afd}emfm mk
o{u eosir}fd/
eberqk kd kl rk/
eqoi, lf Merka/
d mk lf Edwkq/
meq}ed}fq gfa{l/
simrfd fbrer
rf s{bleafr liq
iq mk liq fl{o/
, qk arkfr {d
ia{okd}iq mk
$
lf weqebelemfm
lf S[AS fl gf/
i f }imiq kq}iqRfl Qeg{kd}kq
d v{k }imi kl
rkaiselk kd kq/
girof aid}fr
faeidkq airrkq/
q{q f{}irkq sf/
ed, uf v{k qk/
brk sfrf }imi
d kp}krdi, qed
}kdkr {df a{kd}f, simr aid/
q{l}fr {df }kqeq, wkr {df rkweq/
}f i aidq{l}fr {d lebri fd}e/
j{i meje}fle~fmi$ ]fobed, qe
v{ekrk, simr arkfr {df a{kd/
}f sfrf v{k kl qeq}kof lk fwe/
qk afmf wk~ v{k qk `f arkfmi
{d d{kwi mia{okd}i kd mk/
}kroedfmf ailkaaed$ Di wf f
}kdkr rkq}reaaed flj{df, ge/
dfle~f$
Di `fu m{mf mk v{k kq}iq
kqg{kr~iq fakrafrd, f {d s/
bleai oq foslei, liq }rfbf/
niq mk edwkq}ejfaed fafmoe/
af u srim{aaed aekd}geaf mk
d{kq}riq fl{odiq, miakd}kq kedwkq}ejfmirkq$
Weqe}f kl Sir}fl mk Rkweq}fqS[AS kd `}}s>))rkweq}fq$s{as$km{$sk
Kd lf zkb>
F[J[Q]IS
F]EI
aidwiaf}irefq
RKWEQ]FQMEJE]FLE^FMFQ
@fq}f kl oiokd}i, lfq 2: rkweq/
}fq v{k simrq kdaid}rfr kd kl
Sir}fl mk Rkweq}fq S[AS qid>
E WFRMFDMK$ Rkweq}f Klka}rde/
af mk Qkoe}eaf u Gkdiokdili/
jf N{rmeafq, Flkpfdmrf> Rkweq/
}f mk Aekdaefq mk lf Edgirofaed,
Fd}`risilijeaf, Frk}, Frhkiq,
Fr}k u sra}eaf, Bilk}d mk
Frv{kilijf S[AS, Bilk}d ERF,
Afdfl, Aid}fbelemfm u dkjiaeiq,
Mkbf}kq kd Qiaeilijf, Mkrka`i
S[AS, Kaidiof, Km{afaed,
Kd blfdai u dkjri, Kqsfaei umkqfrrilli, Kq}{meiq mk Geliqi/
gf, @eq}reaf, @ilq}eaf, Lkpeq,
Sflfbrfq Ofuirkq, Skdqfoekd}i
Aidq}e}{aeidfl, Sri Of}`kof/
}eaf, Rkweq}f mk lf Ofkq}rf kd
Mkrka`i Sriakqfl, Rkweq}f mk
Sqeailijf, Rkweq}f mk V{oeaf
u Q{oof @{ofde}f}eq$
IQ SFRF AIDGIROFR [D JRFD
AF, ED]KLKA][FL U AEKD]GEAF$
7/30/2019 PuntoEdu Ao 8, nmero 264 (2012)
10/16
63|$km{|LEOF, mkl 65 fl 2; mk diwekobrk mkl 2362
di}eaefq
Kl Edq}e}{}i mk Aekdaefq mk lf
Df}{rflk~f, ]krre}irei u Kdkr/
jfq Rkdiwfblkq mk lf Sid}ege/
aef [dewkrqemfm Af}leaf mkl
Skr (ED]K S[AS% irjfde~f
kl aidwkrqf}irei Km{afaed
u qiq}kdebelemfm> sris{kq}fq
}kreafq u kpskrekdaefq sra/
[df ok}rsile kd kpsfdqed
aioi Leof igrkak d{okriqiq
mkqfgiq sfrf lf jkq}ed v{k
q{sidk {d aidiaeoekd}i srk/
wei mk lfq girofq kd v{k qk fd
aidgirofmi liq }knemiq u rkmkq
{rbfdfq$
D{kq}ri Akd}ri mk Edwkq}e/
jfaed mk lf Frv{e}ka}{rf u lf
Ae{mfm (AEFA% edwe}f f srigkqi/rkq, fl{odiq u sbleai kd jk/
dkrfl fl qkoedfrei mk Fwfdakq
mk edwkq}ejfaed> Leof u liq
mkqfgiq mk jkq}ed sfrf {df
ok}rsile mk Foreaf Lf}edf>
qkjrkjfaed, oiwelemfm u ji/
bkrdfbelemfm, v{k qk rkfle~f/
r kl n{kwkq u wekrdkq, kd kl f{lf
FRV 636$
Km{afaed u qiq}kdebelemfm Qkjrkjfaed, oiwelemfmu jibkrdfbelemfm
AIDWKRQF]IREIQKOEDFREI
LF SRPEOF QKOFDF
@eq}ireaemfm,a{l}{rf u o{dmimk lf wemf
KD LF D[KWF ZKB MKL WRFM SIMRD AIDIAKR MK AKRAF ]IMF LF
EDGIROFAED RKQSKA]I FL FWFDAK U MKQFRRILLI MK LF JKQ]ED
FMOEDEQ]RF]EWF KD LF S[AS U, FL OEQOI ]EKOSI, KPSRKQFR Q[ ISEDED$
B{qafdmi fr}ea{lfr
q{ }rfbfni u kl mk q{q
{demfmkq, aid kl ged
mk mkqfrrillfr {dfjkq}ed edq}e}{aei/
dfl qlemf u kgeaekd}k v{k bred/
mk rkfl qisir}k f lfq fa}ewemf/
mkq sreoirmeflkq mk lf [dewkr/
qemfm, d{kq}ri Weakrrka}irf/
mi Fmoedeq}rf}ewi (WRFM% kq/
}rkdf q{ d{kwf sjedf zkb$ Qk
}rf}f mk {d kqsfaei v{k }ekdk
aioi ibnk}ewi v{k lf aio{de/
mfm {dewkrqe}fref aidi~af mk
akraf }imf lf edgirofaed rkq/
ska}i fl fwfdak u mkqfrrilli mk
lf jkq}ed fmoedeq}rf}ewf kd lf
S[AS, u v{k, fl oeqoi }ekosi,
s{kmf kpsrkqfr q{ iseded$
Kq}foiq qkj{riq mk v{k kq/
}k rka{rqi wer}{fl lkq qkr }elu faa kqebl k, fqe oeqoi, diq
aiosriok}k oq aid d{kq/
}rfq faaeidkq mefrefq aid kl
v{k`fakr mk lf [dewkrqemfm
sfrf ailfbirfr aid kl a{osle/
oekd}i mk liq ibnk}ewiq edq}e/
}{aeidflkq$
[d kqsfaei sfrf lfjkq}ed {dewkrqe}fref
WEAKRRKA]IRFMI FMOEDEQ]RF]EWI KD LDKF
Rkweqf kq}f d{kwf zkb kd`}}s>))weakrrka}irfmi$s{as$km{$sk)fmoedeq}rf}ewi)
Kd lf zkb>
qfrrilli qiq}kdeblk, aid lf ge/
dflemfm mk meg{dmer lfq kpsk/
rekdaefq aidark}fq kd Flkof/
def u kl Skr$ Liq sidkd}kq
qkrd Qidnf Rea`}kr k Edqf
I}}k, mkl Edq}e}{}i mk Aio{/
deafaed Fobekd}fl u mk Qiq/
}kdebelemfm mk lf [dewkrqe/
mfm Lk{s`fdf mk Ldkb{rj
(Flkofdef%8 Afrliq Rinfq
Ofraiq, merka}ir mk Km{af/
aed, A{l}{rf u Ae{mfmfdf
Fobekd}fl, mkl OEDFO8 u Rk/
bkhhf Rke}qa`oem}, fqkqirf
}adeaf mkl Sriuka}i Kailk/
jeiq, mkl JE^$ Kq} merejemi f
srigkqeidflkq u kq}{mefd}kq
mk km{afaed, merka}irkq u
srigkqirkq mk ailkjeiq k ed}k/
rkqfmiq kd kl }kof$
(edgirofaed>`}}s>))ed}k$s{as$km{$sk)
Kl Ara{li Skr{fdi mk Gkdiok/
dilijf u @krokd{}eaf (AE/
s`KR%, kl Akd}ri mk Kq}{meiq
Geliqgeaiq (AKG% u lf Kqa{klf
mk Siqjrfmi mk lf S[AS irjfde/
~fd lfq WEEE Nirdfmfq Skr{fdfq
mk Gkdiokdilijf u @krok/
d{}eaf> eq}ireaemfm, a{l}{rf
u o{dmi mk lf wemf$ Kq}k kwkd}i
qk rkfle~fr mkl 20 fl 13 mk di/
wekobrk, mk ; f 0 s$o$, kd kl F{/
me}irei mk @{ofdemfmkq$
Kd}rk liq }kofq mk lf gkdi/
okdilijf mk @{qqkrl v{k
oq fd eosfa}fmi kd kl mk/qfrrilli mk lf geliqigf aid}e/
dkd}fl k{riskf mk liq qejliq
PP u PPE, u v{k fd afrfa}kre/
~fmi q{ skrgel meq}ed}ewi grkd/
}k f i}rfq }rfmeaeidkq geliqge/
afq mioedfd}kq kd kqk skrei/
mi, kq}d fv{klliq v{k aidwi/
afd f lfq nirdfmfq mk kq}k fi>
kl o{dmi mk lf wemf, aidn{d}f/
okd}k aid kl mk eq}ireaemfm
u a{l}{rf$ Kl rkaidiaeoekd}i
mkl afra}kr q{bnk}ewi/rklf}ewi,
aid}kp}{fl, kdafrdfmi, gede}i
k `eq}reai mkl q{kli v{k q{b/
}ekdmk }imfq lfq wflemfaeidkq
mk qkd}emi mk lf `{ofdemfm
aioi {d }imi `f }kroedfmisir sidkr ged fl oe}i oimkr/
di mk {df rf~d mkqkdafrdf/
mf v{k, qe bekd rkaidiaf lf me/
okdqed `eq}reaf, lf fbirmf/
bf mkqmk g{krf aid oerfmfq mk
qibrkw{kli$ Kd kq}f iafqed,
mk lf ofdi mk @{qqkrl, Qa`k/
lkr, @kemkjjkr, Jfmfokr, Lkwe/
dfq u Okrlkf{/Sid}u, rkglkpei/
dfrkoiq qibrk lfq meokdqei/
dkq mk meq}ed}iq aidaks}iq sf/
rfmejo}eaiq mk d{kq}rf krf$
(edgirofaed>`}}s>))rkm$s{as$km{$sk)aes`kr)
EDGIROFAED V[KKDAID]RFRQ KD KQ]FD[KWF SLF]FGIROF
Kq}k kwkd}i }kdmr aioi ed/
we}fmi kqskaefl f Fdmrq Bir/
}`fjfrfu, merka}ir mk Sriuka}iq
sfrf Foreaf Lf}edf mkl Edq}e/
}{}i sfrf lf Ae{mfm kd Oiwe/
oekd}i ([dewkrqemfm mk B{k/
diq Ferkq%, v{ekd fblfr qibrk
liq rkq{l}fmiq mk lf jrfd edwkq/
}ejfaed qibrk lf jkq}ed mk lf
afllk llkwfmf f afbi sir mea`fedq}e}{aed$ Fmkoq, qk aid}f/
r aid lf srkqkdaef mk liq kpsi/
qe}irkq Jrfaeklf Gkrddmk~ mk
Armiwf, N{fd Afrliq Mkp}rk,
Ofr}f Welklf u Weh}ir Bkdq{q$
(edgirofaed>aefaCs{as$km{$sk u 727/2333
fdkpi =333
}eafq, v{k qk rkfle~fr `iu, f
lfq 7 s$o$, kd kl F{me}irei mk
Qiaeflkq$
Kq}k kwkd}i b{qaf sriseaefr
kl meliji kd}rk lfq edq}e}{aei/
dkq mkmeafmfq f lf km{afaed
fakraf mk lfq sra}eafq km{af/
}ewfq kd lf skrqska}ewf mkl mk/
KL WRFM>
V{ kq kl WRFMu v{ {demfmkq liaidgirofd9
KL SLFD
KQ]RF]JEAI>
V{ kq kl SlfdKq}rf}jeai
Edq}e}{aeidfl 2366/236: u a{lkq qidq{q ibnk}ewiq9
MKQAFRJFQ>
]imiq liq mia{okd}iqkqkdaeflkq sfrfv{k s{kmfdaiosrkdmkr liqsriakqiq mk jkq}edfmoedeq}rf}ewf mk lf[dewkrqemfm$
SRIUKA]IQ>A{lkq qidlfq faaeidkqeoslkokd}fmfq kd
edgrfkq}r{a}{rf,rka{rqiq `{ofdiqu jkq}ed9
AEGRFQ>Qk srkqkd}fdrkq{l}fmiq kedmeafmirkq kd lfqrkfq mk gedfd~fq,srkq{s{kq}iq,bkafq u kq}r{a}{rfedgiro}eaf$
7/30/2019 PuntoEdu Ao 8, nmero 264 (2012)
11/16
S[AS|$km{|66
Geklm Qa`iil Srijrfo kq {dfedeaef}ewf v{k giokd}f lf llk/
jfmf mk fl{odiq kp}rfdnkriq,
m{rfd}k brkwkq kq}fmfq, sf/
rf v{k }kdjfd {df kpskrekd/
aef oq fll mk li fafmoeai$
D{kq}rf [dewkrqemfm, f }rfwq
mk lf Merkaaed Fafmoeaf
mk Rklfaeidkq Edq}e}{aeidflkq
(MFRE%, eos{lqf kq}k srijrf/
of, u kq}k fi, kd n{lei, qk ir/jfde~frid miq mkq}ediq mk ed/
wkq}ejfaed> L f Lebkr}f m (Kq /
a{klf mk Afosi Qfd Niq mk
Oiri, irekd}fmf f lf Frv{ki/
lijf% u A{~ai (kqa{klfq mk K}/
dio{qeailijf, u mk Kqsfil
u A{l}{rf Edaf%$ Oerf {d wemki
mkl wefnk f A{~ai kd zzz$s{d/
}ikm{$s{as$km{$sk
Kqa{klf mk afosiD[KWI WEMKI
Irv{kq}fqedgdeaf S[AS
D{kq}rf Kqa{klf mk Oqeaf liq
edwe}f f girofr sfr}k mkl sre/
okr sriuka}i irv{kq}fl qedg/
deai S[AS$ Liq rkv{eqe}iq qid>
qkr sfr}k mk lf aio{demfm S[/
AS, }iafr fljd edq}r{okd}i
u simkr lkkr sfr}e}{rfq f dewkl
bqeai$
Qe kq}q ed}krkqfmi, di }k
sekrmfq lf a`frlf edgirof}ewf
v{k qk rkfle~fr kq}k n{kwkq, f lfq7 s$o$, kd kl liafl mk d{kq}rf Kq/
a{klf mk Oqeaf (Oflkad Jrf{
=::, A`irrelliq%$ V{ekdkq wfufd
f fqeq}er, di ilwemkd llkwfr q{
edq}r{okd}i$ Fdokdqk f gir/
ofr sfr}k mk kq}f irv{kq}f$
(edgirofaed>kqo{qeafCs{as$km{$sk
AIDWIAF]IREF
MKQMK KL OERAILKQ
SREOKR AIDJRKQI DFAEIDFL
W Qkoedfrei mk edwkq}ejfaed km{af}ewf
Lkfd Aidq}r{a}eid
Kl Mksfr}fokd}i mk Km{af/aed, lf Aiirmedfaed mk Ed/
wkq}ejfaed mkl Akd}ri mk Ed/
wkq}ejfaeidkq u Qkrweaeiq Km{/
af}ewiq (AEQK%, lf Ofkq}rf kd
Km{afaed u kl Mia}irfmi kd
Aekdaefq mk lf Km{afaed mk lf
S[AS irjfde~fd kl W Qkoedf/
rei mk edwkq}ejfaed km{af}ewf,
v{k }ekdk aioi ibnk}ewi meg{d/
mer liq l}eoiq fsir}kq kd km{/
afaed v{k qk bfqfd kd edwkq/
}ejfaeidkq rkfle~fmfq mkqmk kl
2363 sir miakd}kq mk d{kq}rf
[dewkrqemfm fq aioi sir kq}{/
mefd}kq jrfm{fmiq mkq}fafmiq$
Liq }kofq v{k qk fbirmf/
rd kd kq}k qkoedfrei kq}d
K l 6 k r $ A i d j r k /
qi Dfaeidfl Lkfd
Aidq}r{a}eid 2362
(ADLA% kq {df nir/
dfmf v{k b{qaf aid/
wia fr f liq q}fhk`il/
mkrq mk lf edm{q}ref mk
lf aidq}r{aaed sfrf
ed}krafobefr kpskrekd/
aefq, afqiq mk pe}i, eo/slkokd}faed u i}riq
fqska}iq mk lf geliqigf
Lkfd Aidq}r{a}eid$
Kq}k kwkd}i, v{k qk rkf/
le~fr iu u offdf kd kl
@i}kl Liq Mklkgedkq (Qfd Eqe/
mri% u d{kq}ri Aileqki Silemk/
sir}ewi, kq irjfde~fmi sir kl
Afs}{li Skr{fdi Lkfd Aidq/
}r{a}eid Edq}e}{}k u AIQ]IQ
QFA Jr{si Q63, u kq} mere/
jemi f kosrkqfreiq, aid}rf}eq/
}fq, edjkdekriq aewelkq, edjk/
dekriq mk oedfq, frv{e}ka}iq
u mewkrqiq srigkqeidflkq mk lf
rklfaeidfmiq aid ed}kra{l}{/rflemfm, emkd}emfm dfaeidfl,
sriuka}iq kqailfrkq, girof/
aed miakd}k, skraksaeidkq
mkl miakd}k, kd}rk i}riq$ Kl
kwkd}i qk rkfle~fr kl 26, 22
u 21 mk diwekobrk, mk = s$o$
f 5 s$o$, kd kl F{me}irei mk
Aekdaefq Qiaeflkq$
Afbk mkq}fafr v{k lfq aid/
gkrkdaefq ofjeq}rflkq kq}frd
f afrji mk }rkq kqskaefleq}fq
lf}edifokreafdiq kd edwkq}e/
jfaed km{af}ewf> lf Mrf$ Luf
Kq}`kr Qf{mi (Opeai%, mkl
Edq}e}{}i Q{skreir mk Edwkq}e/
jfaed u Miakdaef sfrf kl Of/
jeq}krei, v{ekd mea}fr Lf sri/
m{aaed mkl aidiaeoekd}i kdkm{afaed, {df weqed mkqmk lf
}eaf8 kl Mr$ Flknfdmri Wellfli/
biq (A`elk%, mk lf [dewkrqemfm
mk Aidaksaed, a{uf sidkdaef
qk }e}{lf Lf edwkq}ejfaed km{/
afaeidfl kd kl qfbkr skmfjje/
ai aid}kosirdki8 u kl Mr$
Fdmrq Skrfgd (Ailiobef%, mk
lf [dewkrqemfm Skmfjjeaf Df/
aeidfl, v{k `fblfr qibrk Kl
skdqfoekd}i mk liq miakd}kq>
fsripeofaeidkq sfrf q{ aio/
srkdqed$ Kl aiq}i mk edqares/
aed kq mk Q)$ 23$
(edgirofaed>
`}}s>))aeqk$s{as$km{$sk)
aidq}r{aaed, fq aioi kq}{/
mefd}kq mkl l}eoi fi mk lf
afrrkrf$
Liq sredaesflkq sidkd}kq
qkrd Jlkd Bfllfrm, aig{dmf/
mir u merka}ir mk edwkq}ejf/
aed mkl Lkfd Aidq}r{a}eid
Edq}e}{}k (LAE%8 Jrkj @izkll,
v{ekd merejk rkj{lfrokd}k f
65 MK DIWEKOBRK Aidgkrkdaef Km{afaedsfrf lf jkq}ed mkl fj{f kdlf rkjed Fdmedf$ Kpsiqe/}irkq> ]krkqf Ir (S[AS%, Afr/liq Skrkurf (FDF% u R{}jkrmBiklkdq ([dewkrqemfm mk Zfjk/dedj{kd%$ Irjfde~f> Mksfr}f/okd}i mk Aekdaefq Qiaeflkq, uJr{si mk Kq}{meiq Fobekd}k uQiaekmfm$ @irf> 7 s$o$ L{jfr>Qflf Ofr~fl (Ms}i$ mk AAQQ%$Qkoedfrei D{kwf LkuSriakqfl mkl }rfbfni$ Sfr/}eaesfrd mkq}fafmiq kpsiqe}i/rkq aioi Jeiwfdde Sreire, Iofr]ilkmi, Nirjk ]iufof, Afrliq
Jlfwk, L{eq Wedf}kf, Klokr Frak,J{ellkroi Bi~f, Ofr}d Qi}kri,Ribkr}i Of}fllfdf, RkudflmiB{q}fofd}k, Wlfmeoer Sfmellf uOfrei Sfqai$ Irjfde~f> Kl Sri/jrfof mk Qkj{dmf mk Kqskaefle/mfm kd Mkrka`i Sriakqfl Lfbi/rfl mk lf Gfa{l}fm mk Mkrka`i$@irf> 0 s$o$ L{jfr> Fdge}kf}riOidq$ Mfookr}$ Edgirokq> ofq/of}Cs{as$km{$sk
23 MK DIWEKOBRK
Mkqfu{di/aidgkrkdaefLf}ediforeaf f 2313>eosleafdaef kd kl o{dmi mkliq dkjiaeiq$ Kl fa}{fl aid/
}kp}i jlibfl, liq ofsfq mkl g{}{/ri, }kdmkdaefq, lf qedj{lfremfm}kadiljeaf, liq d{kwiq oimk/liq mk dkjiaeiq u oq$ Irjfde/~f> Akd}r{o Af}leaf$ @irf> 0f$o$ L{jfr> Qzeqqi}kl mk Leof$Oq edgirofaed> `}}s>))zzz$akd}r{o$s{as$km{$sk)]fllkr aiiskrfaed Q{r/Q{r kd }kofq mk aiokraeiu gedfdaefoekd}i> si}kd/aeflemfmkq u lkaaeidkq mk lfrkjed mk Foreaf Lf}edfu kl Afrebk$ Qk eosfr}erd =qkqeidkq mk 1 `irfq afmf {df(mk 7 f 5 s$o$%, mkl 23 fl 21$ Lfsfr}eaesfaed kd kl }fllkr kq jrf/
}{e}f u qk kd}rkjfr aidq}fdaefmk sfr}eaesfaed$ L{jfr> f{lfN/16=$ Edgirokq> nsir}iafrrk/ri}Cs{as$km{$skKwkd}i Mkrka`i mk lfqAidakqeidkq$ B{qaf {dffsripeofaed u ar}eaf f lfqd{kwfq girofq mk aidakqed uf lfq srkrrijf}ewfq v{k bredmflf fmoedeq}rfaed f liq aidak/qeidfreiq$ Irjfde~f> Ara{limk Mkrka`i Fmoedeq}rf}ewi$@irf> 7 s$o$ L{jfr> F{me}ireimk KKJJLL$ Oq edgirofaed>zzz$amf$irj$skAidwkrqf}irei Sir v{mkqfrrillfr wemkin{kjiq9$
Qk fbirmfr lfq }kdmkdaefqv{k kdjlibfd kl mkqfrrilli mkliq wemkin{kjiq kd kl Skr u q{si}kdaefl arkaeoekd}i$ Irjfde/~f> Mesliof}{rf kd Mkqfrrillimk Wemkin{kjiq$ @irf> : s$o$
Edgirokq> bqafliq kd Gfakbiihaioi Mkqfrrilli mk Wemkin{k/jiq kd kl Skr$
26 MK DIWEKOBRK
Qkoedfrei Aiokd}freiqf lf kpskrekdaef mkl frbe/}rfnk kd lfq aid}rf}faei/dkq mkl Kq}fmi, sredaesflkqsriblkofq u siqebelemfmkqf srisqe}i mk lf oimegeaf/}iref lkjfl, Lku D 250:1$B{qaf srig{dme~fr kl fdleqeqmkl }kp}i mk kq}fq meqsiqeaei/dkq u slfd}kfr rkqs{kq}fq f lfqm{mfq v{k s{kmkd jkdkrfr q{fsleafaed$ Irjfde~f> Akd}ri mk
Fdleqeq u Rkqil{aed mk Aid/glea}iq S[AS$ @irf> : s$o$ L{jfr>Akd}ri Kosrkqfrefl S[AS (AfllkKqv{elfa`k 1:6, Qfd Eqemri%$ Oqedgirofaed> }}s>))aidqkdqiq$s{as$km{$sk)
22 MK DIWEKOBRK
Aidwkrqf}irei Kl air}iqejli mk Krea @ibqbfzo$Qk aid}fr aid lf srkqkdaef mkFlmi Sfdgea`e, Dklqid Ofdrev{ku Fd}idei fsf}f, v{ekdkq meq/a{}erd liq sredaesflkq fsir}kqmkl eq}irefmir ofrpeq}f f lf eq/}ireijrfgf skr{fdf u o{dmefl$Irjfde~f> Kq}{meiq Jkdkrflkq
Lk}rfq, kd aiirmedfaed aid q{Akd}ri Gkmkrfmi u {d jr{si mkkq}{mefd}kq u kjrkqfmiq mk lfKqskaeflemfm mk @eq}iref$ @irf>62 s$o$ L{jfr> F{me}irei mkKKJJLL$Qkoedfrei kp}rfa{rre/a{lfr Lf sfr}eaesfaedmk lfq o{nkrkq kd kl a{l}ikq}f}fl edaf$ [d kq}{mei mklf eaidijrfgf akroeaf$Girof sfr}k mk liq Qkoedfreiqkp}rfa{rrea{lfrkq mkl Srijrf/of mk Kq}{meiq Fdmediq (SKF%,u kq}fr f afrji mk lf Oj$ Bf}/foe Fr}~e ([dewkrqemfm @kbrkfmk Nkr{qfld%$ Irjfde~f> SKF$
@irf> ;>6; s$o$ L{jfr> Qflf mkJrfmiq mk lf Gfa$ mk LL u AA$@@$Merejemi f fl{odiq mkl SKF,mk lfq ofkq}rfq kd @eq}iref ukd Ledjq}eaf, u mkl Srijrfofmk Kq}{meiq mk Jrfm{fmiq kdFd}risilijf, fq aioi f edwkq/}ejfmirkq u srigkqirkq$
21 MK DIWEKOBRK
Qkoedfrei / }fllkr Ed}ri/m{aaed f lfq rkmkq qiaef/lkq$ Qkr mea}fmi sir Ofr}dQfd}iq Fdfuf, mia}ir kd Qiaei/lijf sir lf [dewkrqemfm mk Zeq/aidqed u miakd}k mk lf S[AS$Irjfde~f> Kl Akd}ri mk Edwkq/
}ejfaeidkq Qiaeiljeafq, Kai/doeafq, Sil}eafq u Fd}risi/ljeafq (AEQKSF%$ @irf> 63 f$o$L{jfr> F{lfq edgiro}eafq mklOfa Jrkjir$ Oq edgirofaed>`}}s>))aeqksf$s{as$km{$sk
aflkdmfreifafmoeai
Rkweqf liq kwkd}iq mk lf qkofdf u q{bk }{ edgirofaed kd
`}}s>))fjkdmf$s{as$km{$sk)
jr{siq mkl qka}ir qibrk
lf dkakqemfm mk rkwil{/
aeidfr kl qeq}kof mk sri/
m{aaed kd kl meqki u
lf aidq}r{aaed8 Nirjk
L{eq E~v{ekrmi, srkqe/
mkd}k mkl Afs}{li Sk/
r{fdi mk Lkfd Aidq/
}r{a}eid Edq}e}{}k8
Aqfr J{~od, weak/srkqemkd}k mkl Af/
s}{li Skr{fdi mk
Lkfd Aidq}r{a}eid
Edq}e}{}k8 Ofd{kl
Rfork~, arkfmir mkl Qeq}k/
of Q63 sfrf lf jkq}ed mk
sriuka}iq kd aidq}r{aaed8
u Io fr Fl gf ri , sr kq em kd /
}k mkl Aioe} BEO mkl Skr
u Oekobri mkl Afs }{li Sk/
r{fdi mk Lkfd Aidq}r{a}eid
Edq}e}{}k$
(edgirofaed>`}}s>))zzz$adla$sk)
7/30/2019 PuntoEdu Ao 8, nmero 264 (2012)
12/16
62|$k{|LEO, mkl 65 fl 2; mk iwekobrk mkl 2362
gkaoa
s `ak qaqq a okq
Kq}{mefr {d siqjrfmi
qk `f aidwkr}emi, mk
{d }ekosi f kq}f sfr/
}k, kd {df dkakqemfm$
Uf qkf sfrf is}fr sir
{d oknir s{kq}i mk }rfbfni,
b{qafr {df kqskaefle~faed i
foslefr }{q skrqska}ewfq faf/
moeafq, qid afmf wk~ oq liq
siq}{lfd}kq v{k qk ed}krkqfd
sir aid}ed{fr q{q kq}{meiq kd
{d srijrfof mk ofkq}rf i
mia}irfmi$
D{kq}rf Kqa{klf mk Siqjrf/
mi igrkak oq mk :3 srijrfofqkd mewkrqfq rkfq mk aekdaefq u
lk}rfq, fmkoq mk wfrefq ofkq/
}rfq ed}krmeqaesledfrefq$
[D SIQJRFMI KD LF S[/
AS$ Llkwfr {d siqjrfmi kd
d{kq}rf [dewkrqemfm }ekdk wf/
refq wkd}fnfq$ Kd lf S[AS wfd
f kdaid}rfr {d fl}i dewkl faf/
moeai, {df girofaed qlemf
u liq oknirkq srigkqirkq$ Kqi
q{ofmi f beblei}kafq u lfbi/
rf}ireiq fa}{fle~fmiq sfrf q{q
}rfbfniq mk edwkq}ejfaed, kp/
sleaf lf Mrf$ Kq}rkllf J{krrf, me/
rka}irf knka{}ewf mk lf Kqa{klf
mk Siqjrfmi$Afbk mkq}fafr v{k lf Kqa{k/
lf mk Siqjrfmi `f arkfmi wf/
reiq }esiq mk fsiui sfrf v{k liq
fl{odiq qibrkqflekd}kq s{k/
mfd faakmkr f bkafq u gedfdaef/
oekd}iq, }fd}i kd ofkq}rf ai/
oi kd mia}irfmi$ ]kdkoiq lfq
Bkafq Freq}}klkq, kd lfq v{k qk
`fak {d rairm kd g{daed mkl
rkdmeoekd}i fafmoeai u qk
lkq i}irjf lf aibkr}{rf mk liq
mkrka`iq fafmoeaiq mkl aeali$
]fobed kq} kl Srkoei Jflelki
sfrf aidal{er lf }kqeq$ Fqeoeq/
SirreAfrmi rK}KJ[e
oi, lfq Bkafq @{erfaia`f, v{k
skroe}kd f liq kq}{mefd}kq mk
mia}irfmi mkmeafrqk f }ekosi
aioslk}i f q{q kq}{meiq, s{kq
qk }rf}f mk bkafq ed}kjrflkq v{k
a{brkd liq mkrka`iq fafmoe/
aiq u, fmkoq, mf {d kq}eskdmei
okdq{fl, kpsleaf lf Mrf$ J{k/
rrf$ Mk i}ri lfmi, qk igrkak {d
63+ mk mkqa{kd}i kd liq mkrk/
a`iq fafmoeaiq (di edal{ukAkd}r{o% sfrf }imiq fv{klliq
v{k wkdjfd mkl srkjrfmi mk lf
S[AS $ Sir kl oiokd}i, fv{k/
lliq fl{odiq v{k wekdkd mkl
srkjrfmi mk d{kq}rf [dewkrqe/
mfm rksrkqkd}fd siai okdiq
v{k {d }kraei mkl }i}fl, u v{krk/
oiq v{k kqf aegrf q{bf, kpsle/
af lf merka}irf knka{}ewf$
KWFL[FAED MK AIOSK/
]KDAEFQ$ Sfrf kq}f d{kwf
aidwiaf}iref mkl aeali 2361/6
qk `f eoslkokd}fmi kd flj{/
EdQARESAEIdKQ Kd LdK
uf Kq} fBeKr}f lf AidwiAf}iref sfrf liq Oq mK :3
srijrfOfq vK irKAKr Kl srPeOi fi lf KqAKlf
mK siqjrfmi mK lf sAs, vK fAfBf mK AOsler =3
fiq mK KPeq}KdAef$
diq srijrfofq mk siqjrfmi lfKwfl{faed mk Aiosk}kdaefq
Fafmoeafq, {df sr{kbf mk 73
srkj{d}fq v{k }ekdk kl ibnk}ewi
mk skroe}er f liq srijrfofq qf/
bkr kl dewkl mk fbelemfmkq faf/
moeafq aid kl v{k llkjfd liq
siq}{lfd}kq$ Kq}f kwfl{faed,
v{k kq} meqkfmf }fd}i sfrf
siq}{lfd}kq f lfq rkfq mk aekd/
aefq u lk}rfq, aidq}f mk }rkq bli/
v{kq }ko}eaiq mk kwfl{faed>
Aiosrkdqed mk }kp}iq fafm/
oeaiq, Aio{deafaed kqare}f
(girofl% u Rf~idfoekd}i of/
}ko}eai i Rkqil{aed mk sri/
blkofq of}ko}eaiq$ Aid lf
edairsirfaed mk kq}f kwfl{f/aed, qk f fbekr}i {d qeq}kof
mk bkafq sfrf v{ekdkq, m{rfd}k
lf siq}{lfaed, ia{skd liq }rkq
sreokriq s{kq}iq kd afmf {df
mk lfq rkfq$
EDWKQ]EJFAED$ Lf Mrf$
J{krrf rkqfl}f lf eosir}fdaef
v{k, fa}{flokd}k, lf Kqa{klf mk
Siqjrfmi lk kq} mfdmi f lf ed/
wkq}ejfaed u f lf rkfle~faed mk
lfq }kqeq> Fmkoq mk liq wfreiq
gedfdaefoekd}iq, kq}foiq sri/
oiwekdmi kl }rfbfni aidn{d}i
kd}rk kl fqkqir u kl }kqeq}f$ ]fo/
bed kq eosir}fd}k rkqfl}fr v{k
lf sris{kq}f a{rrea{lfr b{qafv{k liq kq}{mefd}kq di mknkd
sfrf kl gedfl kl }rfbfni aid q{q
}kqeq, qedi, oq bekd, qk ed}kd}f
v{k qkf {d sriakqi aid}ed{i u
v{k kl kq}{mefd}k a{loedk q{
siqjrfmi aid lf }kqeq leq}f$
Aioi wkrq, lf igkr}f kq fo/
slef u liq bkdkgeaeiq o{a`iq$
[d siqjrfmi kq {df kpaklkd}k
ofdkrf mk ofd}kdkr}k fa}{fle/
~fmi, }kd}fr oknirfq fafmoe/
afq u, sir v{ di, kaidoeafq$
Lfq edqaresaeidkq sfrf kl srpe/
oi fi uf kq}d fbekr}fq$ d
mrf$KQ}rKllfJ[KrrfMerka}irf
knka{}ewf mklf Kqa{klf mkSiqjrfmi
K sAs ka{ kaoa, {goa oknkgkk$
ld{kw Okq k Kkj> kq} merejemf,qibrk }imi, f ejkekriq okaeaiq (f{v{k ikq kpal{uk}k%$ Lf ofllf a{rrea{lfr qk ak}rf k lfoknirf mk afsfaemfmkq mkl kq}{mef}k sfrf kl sri/uka}i u mkqfrrilli mk qeq}kofq kkrj}eaiq qkjrkv{kreoek}iq kqskageaiq, u qk ak}rf, qibrk}imi, k kl a{emfmi u srkqkrwfae mkl fobek}k$
lrk~ok k ma k mkka`>kq} irek}fmi, kqkaeflok}k, f lf ewkq}ejfae
n{rmeaf k e}krmeqaeslefref$ Kl fl{oi llkwfr fafbi lf }kqeq mia}irfl, u rkaeber fsiui u irek}f/ae sfrf srig{me~fr k kl aiiaeoek}i u {qi mklfq krrfoek}fq }kreafq v{k lk skroe}f mkqf/rrillfr q{ ewkq}ejfae k { fl}i ewkl fafmoeai$
lfQ diKmfmKQlMkqmk iu s{kmk ejrkqfr f lf zkb mk lf Kqa{klf mk Siqjrfmi(`>))qj${a$k{$k% k eqareberqk k lkf$ Kl sfjimk Mkrka`iq afmoeaiq qk s{kmk rkfle~fr f sfr}er mk offf$ Lfsrkqk}fae mkl kpskmek}k ai liq mia{ok}iq qileae}fmiq qkrmkl = fl 0 mk gkbrkri mkl 2361$ Lf Kwfl{fae mk Aiosk}kaefq af/moeafq, sfrf liq srijrfofq v{k li qileae}k, qk rkfle~fr kl 63 mkgkbrkri$ Geflok}k, liq rkq{l}fmiq qk s{bleafr kl 22 mk gkbrkri$
lf AidiAf}iref
7/30/2019 PuntoEdu Ao 8, nmero 264 (2012)
13/16
[kqaq
Aioi rkq{l}fmi mkl
WE E Qe osiq ei Ed /
}krdfaeidfl mk Fr/
v{kilijf S[AS qk
kme} kl Bilk}d mk
Frv{kilijf S[AS D6= Lkd/
j{fq u qiaekmfmkq kd kl fd}e/
j{i Skr> `faef {d kdgiv{k
ed}krmeqaesledfrei, v{k qk
srkqkd}fr kq}k n{kwkq, f lfq :
s$o$, kd kl Akd}ri A{l}{rfl Re/
afrmi Sflof (Oerfglirkq%$ Klfrv{kliji Sk}kr Hf{leahk u kl
ledjeq}f Rimilgi Akrrd Sfli/
oedi, kme}irkq mk mea`f s{ble/
afaed, diq kpsleafd aoi qk
fbirm u mkqfrrill kq}k }rfbf/
ni ed}krmeqaesledfrei$
Ao qk aokok /v{kj u j{qa9SH>[d ed}krq sredaesfl mk kq/
}k bilk}d u mk liq qeosiqeiq kq
giokd}fr kl }rfbfni ed}krmeqae/
sledfrei mkqmk lf frv{kilijf$
V{krkoiq lijrfr megkrkd}kq
sf{}fq v{k skroe}fd kl meli/
ji kd}rk lf frv{kilijf u i}rfq
meqaesledfq, f`irf li koiq`ka`i aid lf ledjq}eaf, skri,
fd}kreirokd}k, qk rkfle~ aid
lf `eq}iref u, kd aekr}f okme/
mf, aid lfq aekdaefq okmei fo/
bekd}flkq$
d
SirQ[Qfdf dffrri
RAS> Mkqmk `fak {d b{kd
}ekosi qk v{krf v{k liq led/
jeq}fq v{k }rfbfnfoiq kd kl
rkf fdmedf sfr}eaesfrfd kd
kq}k }esi mk }rfbfni$ @f qemi {d
wekni fd`kli, uf v{k kq}foiq
aidwkdaemiq mk v{k liq eq}i/
refmirkq, frv{klijiq u mkoq
`fd }rfbfnfmi edmkskdmekd}k
mk liq ledjeq}fq v{k }fobed
}rfbfnfd kd kl }kof$ @fak o{/
a`i }ekosi, ed}krafobefoiqemkfq qibrk lf dkakqemfm mk
sfr}eaesfr, ed}krmeqaesledfref/
okd}k, liq rksrkqkd}fd}kq mk
mewkrqfq meqaesledfq qiaeflkq$
Kq}f s{bleafaed kq kl rkq{l}f/
mi mk {d sriakqi mk {df meq/
a{qed foslef u grfdaf, v{k
o{kq}rf kl mkbf}k rkfle~fmi u
{d fbfdeai mk srkia{sfaeidkq
qibrk lf srk`eq}iref mk d{kq/
}riq s{kbliq fdmediq$
A{ q q ga{kq v{kka k{ kqq qqaq9SH> Kl }rfbfni ed}krmeqaesle/
dfrei qekosrk kq oq aiosle/afmi sirv{k {dk kqskaeflemf/
mkq v{k `fd }kdemi {df wemf
srisef u {df ok}imilijf me/
gkrkd}k$ Qed kobfrji, kd}rk
qiaekmfm u lkdj{f qekosrk
SAS|$k{|61
MRKQ$ SK]KR HLEAHK U RIMILGI AKRRd SLIOEdI, miak}kq mkl Mksfr}fok}i mk @{ofemfmkq
LEBRI MK KdQUIQ
`f fbemi {df weda{lfaed,
f{dv{k kq}{wekrid qksfrfmfq
sir megkrkd}kq rf~idkq8 f`i/
rf, n{d}fr d{kwfokd}k lfq miqmeqaesledfq diq sfrkak o{u
eosir}fd}k, di qili sfrf qf/
bkr mk lf a{l}{rf of}krefl, qe/
di }fobed qibrk li v{k lf
jkd}k `f `fblfmi, f{dv{k qkf
{baak
Kq}K KwKq qK srKqKd}f Kl
BilK}d mK frvKilijf sAs
d6= lKdjfq u qiAeKmfmKq Kd Kl
fd}eji sKr> @fAef d KdivK
ed}KrmeqAesledfrei$
[d `iokdfnk f lf eofjkd u f
lf errfmefaed mk q{ qkd}emi$
Kd liq kdqfuiq mkKlijei mk lf
l{~ u i}riq foirkq, kl aedkfq}f,
ar}eai a{l}{rfl u kqare}ir Ni/q Afrliq @{fu`{faf (miakd/
}k mkl Mksfr}fokd}i mk Ai/
o{deafaeidkq% fbirmf kl oi/
weoekd}i, k l fr }k, lf of jef ,
kd}rk i}riq$ Qkjd kpsleaf, kl
f{}ir/sri}fjideq}f wf rkjeq/
}rfdmi q{q kpskrekdaefq kpeq/
}kdaeflkq u deafq, afsfakq mk
fgka}fr d{kq}rfq wemfq mkqmk kl
oiokd}i kd v{k qk wewkd$
Kq}k lebri, srkqkd}fmi lf qk/
ofdf sfqfmf kd kl Akd}ri A{l/
}{rfl Kl Ilewfr, rkaijk fdle/
qeq ar}eaiq, skri }fobed `eq/}irefq mk foir$ Kd q{ a{reiqi
obe}i, kl fr}k bri}f kd okmei
mk lf wemf u lf wemf kd okmei
mkl fr}k$ Fq, liq kdqfuiq kq}{/
mefd f lf wk~ v{k aklkbrfd
kl o{dmi mk lfq eojkdkq, qkf
v{k fsfrk~afd kd lf sfd}fllf,
lf sjedf, kl kqakdfrei, kl lekd/
~i, {d lb{o, f{d kd liq wefnkq
K o{ k q ojkkqu kd lfq afllkq mk }imiq liq mfq$
Qk }rf}f mk edae}faeidkq f oe/
rfr kl o{dmi aid ed}kdqemfm$
Lf ofuirf mk liq }kp}iq rkaije/
miq fd qemi s{bleafmiq mk of/dkrf meqskrqf kd rkweq}fq mk ai/
u{d}{rf, fr}k u ar}eaf a{l}{rfl
kd mewkrqfq siafq$ Liq }kp}iq
mkmeafmiq f lf oqeaf, rkgekrk
kl srisei @{fu`{faf, qid ai/
okd}freiq brkwkq kqare}iq `f/
aef 65:0 f skmemi mk {df foejf
f v{ekd rkjfl {d afqqk}}k aid
q{q sek~fq srkmelka}fq$
ed}KrmeQAesledfrei$ Kq}f kmeae kq kl rkq{l}fmi mk { sriakqi mk meliji k}rk lf frv{kilijf u lf lejq}eaf$
lBik} mk frv{kiijs[As d6= lkj{q uqiaekmmkq k k }ej{iskr> ae { kgiv{ke}krmeqaeereiS$ Hf{leahk, R$ Akrr Sflioei,
S$ @kjjfr}u u M$ Bkrkqgirm
ikq (kmq$%
Leof> Gimi Kme}irefl SAS, 2362
Ka{}rfli k lf Lebrkrf SAS
f Q)$ 03
lKijei mk {~ u i}riqoirkqiq Afrliq @{fu`{faf
Leof> Gimi Kme}irefl SAS, 2362
Ka{}rfli k lf Lebrkrf SAS
f Q)$ =;
}riq$ Kq}i kq sirv{k fu aekr/
}f ejdirfdaef qibrk i}riq afo/
siq, aioi sfqf f wkakq aid lf
`eq}iref, u mk }imfq lfq g{kd}kq
v{k s{kmkd qkr eosir}fd}kq$
Kqi }fobed sfqf aid flj{diq
ailkjfq mk i}rfq kqskaeflemf/
mkq v{k qfbkd siai mk frv{ki/
lijf$ Sreokri `fu v{k wkr
mdmk kq}d liq sriblkofq, u,
f`irf v{k liq wkoiq bfq}fd}k
alfriq, simkoiq fwfd~fr kdliq kq}{meiq$
RAS> Kq}f di kq {df gro{lf
d{kwf, qeoslkokd}k kq}foiq
rk}iofdmi {df weknf }rfme/
aed v{k kpeq}f u v{k, sir rf/
~idkq mk q{bkqskaefle~faed
mk d{kq}rfq meqaesledfq, qk g{k
fbfdmidfdmi$ F`irf, {d led/
jeq}f mkl rkf fdmedf uf di
s{kmk ejdirfr liq }rfbfniq mkl
frv{kliji, kq {d sriakqi mk
fsrkdme~fnk u di qekosrk kq g/
ael$ ]fobed arki v{k kqf oeq/
of dkakqemfm lf qekd}kd liq fr/
v{klijiq u liq eq}irefmirkq$
Lf jfdfdaef kq bfq}fd}k sir/
v{k {di lijrf q{skrfr srkn{e/aeiq mk}kroedfmiq sir d{kq/
}rfq srisefq meqaesledfq$ Kl }rf/
bfni ed}krmeqaesledfrei kq ed/
kwe}fblk u ofrafr lfq sf{}fq
mkl }rfbfni f g{}{ri$ d
@{fu`{faf ib}{wi lf bk/
af J{jjkd`keo kd 6552 u kl
sreokr srkoei mkl Aida{rqi
Dfaeidfl mk Aedkof}ijrfgf
kd 6557$ Kd}rk q{q lebriq qk
a{kd}fdKl k dejof mk lf sfd/
}fllf (6505%8 Ofr }d A`fo be,
gi} jrfgi (6556%8 @iobrk q mk
lf grid}krf (2336%8 Aedk kqare}i(2337%8 Weqeidkq mk Ofa`{ Sea/
a`{ (2366%$ @f merejemi lfq
skla{lfqSri gkq ed> mk} ka} ewk
(6507% uA{fdmi kl o{dmi iqa{/
rkae(650:%, u kd kl 2335 a{l/
oed {df qkrek mk fmfs}faei/
dkq le}krfrefq fl okmei f{mei/
weq {fl , }e }{lfmf Be ble i}ka f
sfrf Oerfr$ d
aiosleafmi sir di }kdkr g{kd/
}kq kqare}fq$
RAS> Kl }rfbfni kq aiosleaf/
mi, skri, f lf lfrjf, ui arki v{k
kl rkq{l}fmi kq o{u sriok}k/
mir$ Li v{k `koiq `ka`i kd
{d sreokr kqg{kr~i kq }rf}fr
mk fsripeofrdiq liq {diq f
liq i}riq, mkndmidiq kd}kd/
mkr u `faekdmi {d kqg{kr~i
sir aiosrkdmkr fl i}ri, uf
v{k ofdknfoiq meq}ed}iq o/}imiq u megkrkd}kq ibnk}iq mk
kq}{mei$ @fu {df srkia{sf/
aed sir kqalfrkakr mewkrqfq qe/
}{faeidkq mk lfq lkdj{fq u qi/
aekmfmkq kd s{kbliq qed }rfme/
aed kqare}f, u f{dv{k di `k/
oiq llkjfmi f fa{krmiq slk/
diq, arki v{k koiq fwfd~fmi
u qk fd simemi mkqafr}fr {df
qkrek mk oe}iq v{k kpeq}fd kd
}irdi f lfq diaeidkq mk lkd/
j{f u a{l}{rf$ Kl afoedi kq}
fbekr}i sfrf qkj{er }rfbfnfd/
mi kd kqf merkaaed$
A{ kq oa k /
bn kqa9SH> Arki v{k }imfwf fu aekr/}fq rkqkrwfq sir sfr}k mk fr/
v{klijiq v{k m{mfd mk v{k
kl fakrafoekd}i f lf ledjq/
}eaf qkf wkd}fniqi sfrf diqi/
7/30/2019 PuntoEdu Ao 8, nmero 264 (2012)
14/16
`rroe eje$ Fmf Fk}f, miakd}k mkl Mksf}fkd}i mk @{fdmfmkq, {}l~f lf s~ff klka}daf sff ma}f kl a{qi Sflkijfgf u Msli}af$
oFre Fh
oFre Fh
6=|$km|eoF, mkl 65 fl 2; mk diwkbk mkl 2362
k WI kd lf lfkFlj{dq mk d{kqq makdkq uF {ele~Fd Wk FF meaF q{q
a{qq FWka`Fdm lF kadljF v{k kqk kqFae lkq gkak$
FF v{k qk `FjFd {dF emkF, lkq kqkdFoq {dq knkolq$
SiI{rq oIa`e~{he
Uf qkf sfrf }rfbfniq
mk edwkq}ejfaed kd
jr{si, bredmfr }k/
lkaidgkrkdaefq, mea/
}fr a{rqiq srkqkd/
aeflkq u wer}{flkq, kd}rk i}rfq
aiqfq, WKI sriwkkr, f v{ekd
li rkv{ekrf, mk liq rka{rqiq u
lfq krrfoekd}fq dkakqfrefq$
Lf deaf aidmeaed> qkr sfr}k
mk lf aio{demfm S[AS u }kdkr
kd okd}k {d sriuka}i mk air}k
fafmoeai$
Odeaf Sedkmf, aiirmedfmi/
rf mk kq}k eddiwfmir kqsfaei,
rkaioekdmf f liq srigkqirkq
fakrafrqk u aidiakr liq rka{r/qiq, s{kq kq}iq qk kda{kd}rfd
f q{ meqsiqeaed u igrkakd siqe/
belemfmkq sfrf oknirfr lf med/
oeaf mk q{q a{rqiq u simkr f/
akrliq oq ed}krfa}ewiq$ WKI
igrkak mewkrqfq `krrfoekd}fq
}kadiljeafq, aioi lf se~frrf
klka}rdeaf, }fblk}q, kv{esiq
owelkq, aios{}fmirfq mk {l/
}eof jkdkrfaed u qig}zfrk,
fmkoq mk lf fqkqirf dkakqf/
ref sir sfr}k mkl q}fggsfrf si/
mkr ofdknfrliq$ Qibrk }imi, si/
mkoiq faidqknfrlkq aoi edwi/
l{arfr kq}iq klkokd}iq f gfwir
mk q{ a{rqi i sriuka}i$ Lf emkf
kq v{k liq srigkqirkq wkdjfd ukpslirkd lf }kadilijf v{k lkq
s{kmk qkr mk {}elemfm, qkflf$
KpsKreKdaefq wer}{f/
lKq$Fmf Frrek}f, miakd}k mkl
Mksfr}fokd}i mk @{ofdemf/
mkq, mea} kq}k qkokq}rk {d a{r/
qi mkqmk WKI> Sflkijrfgf u Me/
slio}eaf, mk lf kqskaeflemfm
mk @eq}iref$ Fq, kl kq}{mei mk
lfq kqare}{rfq u liq mia{okd}iq
fd}ej{iq qk wei si}kdaefle~fmi
jrfaefq f kq}fq `krrfoekd}fq$
Lf se~frrf klka}rdeaf fu{m f
fjele~fr kl sriakqi mk kdqkfd/
~f, uf v{k di }kdf v{k kq}fr bi/
rrdmilf, simf fakr 23 i 13se~frrfq u sfqfrlfq, qed skrmkr/
lfq$ Fmkoq, ok mei lf siqebele/
mfm mk kpsleafr kd mk}fllk af/
mf qejdi, fl}krdfdmi megkrkd/
}kq ailirkq, u aioslkokd}fr kl
fdleqeq mk }kp}iq aid srkqkd/
}faeidkq kd Sizkr Sied} k ed/
girofaed kd ldkf, li v{k, kd
jkdkrfl, `e~i lfq alfqkq o{a`i
oq medoeafq$ Lf fsleafaed
Wer][Fe^FeD
@FBF S[S
mk kq}iq rka{rqiq klka}rdeaiq
`f qemi o{u }el kd lf kdqkfd/
~f mk lf sflkijrfgf$ Lf se~frrf
ok sfrkae o{u wfleiqf sfrf
oe a{rqi, }imiq oeq fl{odiq
v{kmfrid gfqaedfmiq, a{kd}f
Fmf, v{ekd fmkoq mk srigkqi/
rf kq nkgf mkl Fra`ewi @eq}reai
mkl Edq}e}{}i Rewf/Fjkri$ Kl
fsir}
lof {d wmki qibk kl a{qiSflkijfgf u Msli}af,ma}fmi kd WK si lf sigkqifFmf Fk}f, kd zzz$sd}ikm$ss$km$sk
d lf zkb>
q qq WI
Weda{lfr, Kpskreokd}fr u Ibqkrwfr qid liq aidaks}iq mk}rq mk
kq}k kqsfaei, {beafmi kd kl sreokr seqi mkl Ofa Jrkjir, v{k a{kd/
}f aid }rkq qflfq aid meq}ed}iq srisqe}iq> Qflf W, kd lf v{k s{k/
mkq rkfle~fr srim{aaed meje}fl mk aid}kdemiq (arkfaed mk fr}k
meje}fl,}kq}edjmk fsleafaeidkq, mkqfrrilli o{l}eokmef, k}a$%8 Qflf
K, kd lf v{k s{kmkq `fakr kp`ebeaeidkq fafmoeafq (wemkiaidgk/
rkdaef, alfqkq o{l}eokmef u a`frlfq v{k edwil{arkd lf }kadilijf
mk lf qflf%8 u Qflf I, {}ele~fmf sfrf kl aid}fa}i u lf weq{fle~faed
(`f qemi eoslkokd}fmf sfrf bredmfr edgirofaed u gfaele}fr lfq
rk{deidkq mk miakd}kq%$ ]kd kd a{kd}f v{k sfrf rkqkrwfr kq}fq
qflfq, mkbkq kdwefr {d airrki f wkiCs{as$sk
qIr rIjro
@irfrei> n{kwkq, f lfq 1 s$o$]rfdqoeqed kd wewi> zzz$
s{d}ikm{$s{as$km{$sk
Kdwf }{q srkj{d}fq m{rfd}k
lf }rfdqoeqed sir ]ze}}kr (C
s{as% u Gfakbiih (zzz$gfak/
biih$aio)s{as%
Srijrfofq jrfbfmiq> zzz$
ui{}{bk$aio)s{as
a{rqi Sflkijrfgf u Meslio}e/
af qk mea}f kd lfq oimflemfmkq
wer}{fl u srkqkdaefl, u }ekdk, kd
}i}fl, 71 fl{odiq edqare}iq, kd/
}rk kq}{mefd}kq dfaeidflkq u kp/
}rfdnkriq$
Mkqmk q{ edf{j{rfaed, kd
ofui, o{a`fq qid lfq fa}ewemf/
mkq fafmoeafq v{k fd }kdemi
l{jfr kd WKI$ Sir knkosli, kl
Jr{si mk Fl}fq Kdkrjfq, lemk/
rfmi sir kl srigkqir Flbkr}i Jf/
ji, {}ele~f kq}k kqsfaei mkqmk
n{lei sfrf meq}ed}fq rk{deidkqmk }rfbfni$ Fqeoeqoi, kl srigk/
qir Aqfr Fj{elkrf, mk lf Kqsk/
aeflemfm mk Edjkdekrf Edgiro/
}eaf, }fobed f mea}fmi mkqmk
f` kl a{rqi Mkqfrrilli mk Sri/
jrfofq 2$ Sir i}ri lfmi, }fo/
bed qk fd mkqfrrillfmi mewkr/
qiq kwkd}iq fafmoeaiq, aioi
lf Qkofdf mkl Faakqi Fbekr}i
IFH Zkkh 2362$
i kskfl}f mk lf {a kd wwiQe }k ed}krkqfd liq }kofq mk ai/
u{d}{rf u fa}{flemfm, k l sri/
jrfof mk kd}rkweq}fq @fblf
S[AS kq sfrf }e$ Lf aidm{aaed
kq} f a