Public Comments & DWR Responses August 17, 2005

11

Public Comments & Public Comments & DWR ResponsesDWR ResponsesAugust 17, 2005August 17, 2005

Public Review DraftPublic Review Draft

California Water Plan California Water Plan Update 2005Update 2005

22

Results of Public Comment PeriodResults of Public Comment Period

Overview of Public Comment ProcessOverview of Public Comment Process

Summary of CommentsSummary of Comments

Outline of DWR ResponsesOutline of DWR Responses

Discussion & AC FeedbackDiscussion & AC Feedback

33

Overview of Public Overview of Public Comment ProcessComment Process

44

7 Ways to Comment7 Ways to CommentApril 13 – July 22, 2005April 13 – July 22, 2005

1.1. Public Input WorkshopsPublic Input Workshops2.2. Phone-In SessionsPhone-In Sessions3.3. On-line Comment FormOn-line Comment Form

4.4. EmailEmail

5.5. Snail MailSnail Mail

6.6. FaxFax

7.7. PhonePhone

55

13 Public Input Workshops &13 Public Input Workshops & 2 Phone-In Sessions in June 2 Phone-In Sessions in June

EurekaEureka ReddingRedding Sacramento (2)Sacramento (2) OaklandOakland TracyTracy FresnoFresno BakersfieldBakersfield

San Luis ObispoSan Luis Obispo Los AngelesLos Angeles ChinoChino CoachellaCoachella San DiegoSan Diego 2 Evening Phone-In 2 Evening Phone-In

SessionsSessions

66

Workshop HostsWorkshop Hosts Association of Bay Area Association of Bay Area

Governments Governments County of Shasta County of Shasta UC Agricultural Center - UC Agricultural Center -

EurekaEureka City of Tracy City of Tracy San Diego County San Diego County

Water AuthorityWater Authority CA Department of CA Department of

General Services General Services (Fresno) (Fresno)

Metropolitan Water District Metropolitan Water District of Southern California of Southern California

Southern Low Desert Southern Low Desert Resource Conservation & Resource Conservation & Development Council Development Council

Kern County Water Agency Kern County Water Agency Central Coast Regional Central Coast Regional

Water Quality Control Water Quality Control BoardBoard

Inland Empire Utilities Inland Empire Utilities District District

77

Advisory Committee PresentersAdvisory Committee Presenters

Scott Cantrell Scott Cantrell Marci Coglianese Marci Coglianese Grant Davis Grant Davis Martha Davis Martha Davis Nick Di Croce Nick Di Croce Mary Ann Dickinson Mary Ann Dickinson Anisa Divine Anisa Divine Fran Garland Fran Garland Steve Macaulay Steve Macaulay

Todd Manley Todd Manley John Mills John Mills Cathy Pieroni Cathy Pieroni Betsy Reifsneider Betsy Reifsneider Jack Sullivan Jack Sullivan Michael Warburton Michael Warburton Arnold Whitridge Arnold Whitridge Carolyn Yale Carolyn Yale

88

Advisory Advisory Committee Committee

ViewView

99

Thank You !Thank You !

1010

WorkshopWorkshopAttendanceAttendance

&&Letters and EmailsLetters and Emails

1111

Workshops & LettersWorkshops & Letters 13 Public Workshops13 Public Workshops

244 attended244 attended High: 44 in Los AngelesHigh: 44 in Los Angeles Low: 6 in Eureka and ChinoLow: 6 in Eureka and Chino Typical: 15-20Typical: 15-20 400 questions & comments recorded (~100 unique)400 questions & comments recorded (~100 unique)

2 Phone-in Sessions2 Phone-in Sessions (6 participants) (6 participants)

138 Letter & Emails138 Letter & Emails 98 Organizations98 Organizations 40 Individuals 40 Individuals

1212

1313

Summary ofSummary ofPublic CommentsPublic Comments

1414

1515

Comment TypesComment Types

PolicyPolicy

TechnicalTechnical

Graphics / PresentationGraphics / Presentation

LikesLikes

OtherOther

1616

Table 1: Comments by TypeTable 1: Comments by Type

# %Policy Comments: 201 33%Technical Comments: 276 45%Graphical/Presentation Comments: 27 4%"Liked" Comments: 68 11%Other Comments: 43 7%Comments in Progress: 0 0%Total Number of Comments: 615 100%

1717

Water Plan Update OrganizationWater Plan Update Organization

Water Plan Highlights (Brochure w/ CD-Rom)Water Plan Highlights (Brochure w/ CD-Rom)

Vol. 1 > Strategic PlanVol. 1 > Strategic Plan

Vol. 2 > 25 Resource Management StrategiesVol. 2 > 25 Resource Management Strategies

Vol. 3 > 12 Regional ReportsVol. 3 > 12 Regional Reports

Vol. 4 > Reference Guide (60+ online articles)Vol. 4 > Reference Guide (60+ online articles)

Vol. 5 > Technical Guide (Online documentation)Vol. 5 > Technical Guide (Online documentation)

1818

Table 2: Comments by VolumeTable 2: Comments by Volume

# %Vol 1 / Highlights 354 58%Vol 2 156 25%Vol 3 94 15%Vol 4 10 2%Vol 5 1 0.2%Total Number of Comments: 615 100%

1919

Table 3: Comment Type by VolumeTable 3: Comment Type by Volume

# % # % # % # % # %Policy Comments: 144 41% 42 27% 15 16% 0 0% 0 0%Technical Comments: 96 27% 99 63% 74 79% 6 60% 1 100%Graphical/Presentation Comments: 21 6% 4 3% 2 2% 0 0% 0 0%"Liked" Comments: 61 17% 4 3% 2 2% 1 10% 0 0%Other Comments: 32 9% 7 4% 1 1% 3 30% 0 0%Total Number of Comments: 354 100% 156 100% 94 100% 10 100% 1 100%

Volume 1 / Highlights Volume 3 Volume 4 Volume 5Volume 2

2020

Outline ofOutline ofDWR ResponsesDWR Responses

2121

Response TypesResponse Types

Type 1: In the Water PlanType 1: In the Water Plan

Type 2: Within CWP purview; DWR revising for Type 2: Within CWP purview; DWR revising for clarification or contentclarification or content

Type 2A: Within CWP purview; Not changedType 2A: Within CWP purview; Not changed

Type 3: Within CWP purview; Consider next timeType 3: Within CWP purview; Consider next time

Type 4: Not within CWP purviewType 4: Not within CWP purview

2222

Table 4: Responses by TypeTable 4: Responses by Type

Response Type # %1 157 26%2 247 40%2A 55 9%3 122 20%4 24 4%In Progress 10 2%

Total: 615

2323

Table 5: Responses by VolumeTable 5: Responses by Volume

Response Type # % # % # % # % # %1 126 36% 25 16% 5 5% 1 10% 0 0%2 112 32% 68 44% 64 68% 2 20% 1 100%2A 29 8% 24 15% 2 2% 0 0% 0 0%3 75 21% 33 21% 13 14% 1 10% 0 0%4 11 3% 0 0% 8 9% 5 50% 0 0%In Progress 1 0% 6 4% 2 2% 1 10% 0 0%

354 156 94 10 1

Volume 5Volume 1 / Highlights Volume 2 Volume 3 Volume 4

2424

Table 6: Responses by Comment TypeTable 6: Responses by Comment Type

Response Type # % # % # % # %1 50 25% 24 9% 7 26% 8 19%2 65 32% 154 56% 15 56% 13 30%2A 26 13% 21 8% 1 4% 7 16%3 43 21% 64 23% 4 15% 12 28%4 15 7% 5 2% 0 0% 3 7%In Progress 2 1% 8 3% 0 0% 0 0%

354 144 96 21

Policy Comments Technical Comments Graphics Comments Other Comments

2525

Table 7: Responses by Comment TypeTable 7: Responses by Comment TypeHighlights & Volume 1Highlights & Volume 1

Response Type # % # % # % # %1 41 28% 10 10% 6 29% 8 25%2 42 29% 47 49% 11 52% 12 38%2A 20 14% 3 3% 1 5% 5 16%3 33 23% 33 34% 3 14% 6 19%4 8 6% 2 2% 0 0% 1 3%In Progress 0 0% 1 0% 0 0% 0 0%

144 96 21 32

Policy Comments Technical Comments Graphics Comments Other Comments

2626

Policy Comment TopicsPolicy Comment Topics

** See Handout **** See Handout **

2727

Production ScheduleProduction Schedule Public Review DraftPublic Review Draft

Public WorkshopsPublic Workshops

Content ChangesContent Changes

Doc. Layout DesignDoc. Layout Design

Get Approval to PrintGet Approval to Print

Final Water PlanFinal Water Plan

- April 2005April 2005

- June/JulyJune/July

- Mid-SeptemberMid-September

- OctoberOctober

- Nov - DecNov - Dec

- Dec 2005- Dec 2005

2828

DiscussionDiscussion