Top Banner
An International Journal of MINERALOGY, CRYSTALLOGRAPHY, GEOCHEMISTRY, ORE DEPOSITS, PETROLOGY, VOLCANOLOGY and applied topics on Environment, Archaeometry and Cultural Heritage DOI: 10.2451/2013PM0015 Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297 PERIODICO di MINERALOGIA established in 1930 PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern Sicily-Italy) Gaetano Ortolano 1,* , Roberto Visalli 1 , Rosolino Cirrincione 1 , Gisella Rebay 2 1 Università degli Studi di Catania, Dipartimento di Scienze Biologiche, Geologiche e Ambientali, Corso Italia 57, I-95129 Catania (Italy) 2 Università degli Studi di Pavia, Dipartimento di Scienze della Terra e dell’Ambiente, Via Ferrata 1, 27100 Pavia (Italy) * Corresponding author:[email protected] Abstract Garnet micaschists nearby Santa Lucia del Mela - Peloritani Mountains (North-eastern Sicily, Italy), were studied by integrating information obtained from petrographic and image- assisted analyses of mineral phase compositions by using X-ray maps and thermodynamic modeling. These rocks are characterized by the presence of atoll garnets, and preserve a continuous array of textures from pristine garnets, through peninsula or island textures, to atoll textures. Completely substituted garnets represent the final stage of the process. These textures result from the metamorphic evolution of the rocks, consisting of two main stages of recrystallization-deformation events. The sequence of mineral parageneses associated to successive deformation events is as follows: early D1 is characterized by the assemblage wm1 + chl1 + bt1 + pl1 + grt1 + qtz + ilm + ap; late D1 by grt2 + wm2 + chl2+ bt2 + pl2 + qtz + ilm + ap + hem; D2 (associated to garnet core transformation) by grt3 + bt3 + pl3 + wm3 + qtz + chl3 + ilm. On the basis of textural observations and mineral parageneses, the atoll formation is related to the substitution of garnet cores during the D2 stage, with the consumption of garnet cores (grt1) and production of new garnet rim (grt3) with wm, bi, qtz and pl. The recognition of the different stages of garnet growth and associated parageneses has been obtained using image analysis coupled with compositional maps, performed via multivariate statistical analysis of four selected X-Ray map arrays. Following the textural and mineral-chemical analyses, PT conditions associated to the three recrystallisation stages have been determined via pseudosection computations. Results indicate that the analyzed rock- types have recorded a clock-wise PT trajectory during the Variscan orogeny, defined by a prograde evolution, in amphibolite facies conditions, preserved in relic garnet cores, followed by an initial decompressional evolution toward lower amphibolite facies conditions associated
41

PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

Apr 11, 2023

Download

Documents

Mauro Giorgieri
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

An International Journal ofMINERALOGY, CRYSTALLOGRAPHY, GEOCHEMISTRY,ORE DEPOSITS, PETROLOGY, VOLCANOLOGYand applied topics on Environment, Archaeometry and Cultural Heritage

DOI: 10.2451/2013PM0015Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

PERIODICO di MINERALOGIAestablished in 1930

PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atollshaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia

del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern Sicily-Italy)

Gaetano Ortolano1,*, Roberto Visalli1, Rosolino Cirrincione1, Gisella Rebay2

1Università degli Studi di Catania, Dipartimento di Scienze Biologiche, Geologiche e Ambientali,Corso Italia 57, I-95129 Catania (Italy)

2Università degli Studi di Pavia, Dipartimento di Scienze della Terra e dell’Ambiente,Via Ferrata 1, 27100 Pavia (Italy)

*Corresponding author:[email protected]

Abstract

Garnet micaschists nearby Santa Lucia del Mela - Peloritani Mountains (North-easternSicily, Italy), were studied by integrating information obtained from petrographic and image-assisted analyses of mineral phase compositions by using X-ray maps and thermodynamicmodeling. These rocks are characterized by the presence of atoll garnets, and preserve acontinuous array of textures from pristine garnets, through peninsula or island textures, toatoll textures. Completely substituted garnets represent the final stage of the process. Thesetextures result from the metamorphic evolution of the rocks, consisting of two main stages ofrecrystallization-deformation events. The sequence of mineral parageneses associated tosuccessive deformation events is as follows: early D1 is characterized by the assemblage wm1+ chl1 + bt1 + pl1 + grt1 + qtz + ilm + ap; late D1 by grt2 + wm2 + chl2+ bt2 + pl2 + qtz +ilm + ap + hem; D2 (associated to garnet core transformation) by grt3 + bt3 + pl3 + wm3 +qtz + chl3 + ilm. On the basis of textural observations and mineral parageneses, the atollformation is related to the substitution of garnet cores during the D2 stage, with theconsumption of garnet cores (grt1) and production of new garnet rim (grt3) with wm, bi, qtzand pl. The recognition of the different stages of garnet growth and associated parageneseshas been obtained using image analysis coupled with compositional maps, performed viamultivariate statistical analysis of four selected X-Ray map arrays. Following the textural andmineral-chemical analyses, PT conditions associated to the three recrystallisation stages havebeen determined via pseudosection computations. Results indicate that the analyzed rock-types have recorded a clock-wise PT trajectory during the Variscan orogeny, defined by aprograde evolution, in amphibolite facies conditions, preserved in relic garnet cores, followedby an initial decompressional evolution toward lower amphibolite facies conditions associated

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:41 Pagina 257

Page 2: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

258 G. Ortolano et al.Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

Introduction

Petrological investigations of zoned crystalshave played a key role in obtaining informationon the mineral-chemical equilibria developedduring the multistage P-T evolution ofmetamorphic rocks. For this purpose garnet isone of the most suitable mineral since, due to itsslow cationic diffusion, is able to preserve shellswith an original chemical composition (Ague andCarlson, 2013), often accompanied by a rapidgrowth after nucleation, allowing the inclusion ofsyn-kinematically matrix minerals. Since thepioneering work of Hollister (1966) and Tracy(1982), growth zoning pattern analyses have beenwidely used to reconstruct prograde andretrograde P-T history (Arenas et al., 1997;Cheng et al., 2007; Evans, 2004; Zuluaga et al.,2005; Cirrincione et al., 2008; Robyr et al., 2009;Angì et al., 2010; Faryad et al., 2010; Ruiz Cruz,2011). One of the most rapid methods to highlightthe chemical zoning patterns of minerals has beenthe use of X-ray maps. In this way, besidesqualitative images to be combined withquantitative spot mineral-data, the possiblepresence of chemical gradients are individuatedand quantified. More recently digital imageanalysis has been improved with the developmentof several software packages dedicated to image

processing (e.g. Cossio and Borghi, 1998; Cossioet al., 2002; Flesche et al., 2000; De Andrade etal., 2006; Fryel and Lyman, 2006; Lanari et al.,2014). These improvements, recently directlyimplemented in the modern micro-analyticaldevices, only in part allow the extrapolation ofquantitative information from multispectralimage analysis, such as X-ray maps. Moreover,these software are often characterized by highimplementation costs involved by the neededtime consuming training. In this view, the recentdevelopment of a new user-friendly GIS-basedimage-processing procedure (i.e. X-Ray MicroAnalyzer - Ortolano et al., 2014), makesaffordable a multivariate statistical analysis of X-ray maps (Launeau et al., 1994; Bonnet, 1995,1998). This procedure is useful in decipheringquantitative textural and modal parameters fromselected thin section micro-domains, contributingto minimize the subjectivity of the operator indetermining the effective equilibriumparagenesis. For instance, it makes possible toevidence zoning patterns that may be due tofractionation (e.g. Fiannacca et al., 2012). The useof this tool allows to distinguish and toquantitatively determine different compositionalregions within a rock or mineral that are linkedto the sequential mineral growth stages occurringduring metamorphism. Moreover it provides

to a partial heating. During this last stage the multi stadial atollization process took place,retrogradely evolving toward a green-schist facies conditions, constrained through thecompositions of the pseodomorphyc mineral aggregates gradually substituting previouslyformed garnets.

Key words: X-Ray Map Analyzer; Thermodynamic modeling; Perple_X; Southern CalabrianPeloritani Orogen.

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:41 Pagina 258

Page 3: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

essential compositional information to constrainthe P-T evolution via pseudosection calculationsusing equilibrium thermodynamic based software(Holland and Powell, 1998; Connolly and Petrini,2002; Connolly, 2005; de Capitani andPetrakakis, 2010). In the following, the chemicalzoning of atoll garnets from Santa Lucia del Melazone (northeastern Sicily, Italy) will be subjectedto image analysis.

The atoll texture is a particular kind of coronatexture consisting of a garnet ring surroundingan aggregate of mineral phases, usually quartz,micas, plagioclase and Fe oxides (Passchier andTrouw, 1998). Despite various studies on atollgarnets (Atherton and Edmunds, 1966; Cooper,1972; Smellie, 1974, 1989; Spiess et al., 2001;Dobbs et al., 2003; Homam, 2003, 2006; Chenget al., 2007; Faryad et al., 2010; Ruiz Cruz, 2011;Hibraim, 2012; Robyr et al., 2014), the geneticmechanisms and the conditions of formation ofthese peculiar structures have not yet beenunambiguously defined. Several models havebeen proposed in different geologic contexts,such as selective replacement (Smellie, 1974;Homam, 2003, 2006; Cheng et al., 2007; Faryadet al., 2010), rapid poikiloblastic growth(Atherton and Edmunds, 1966), multiplenucleation and coalescence processes (Spiess etal., 2001; Dobbs et al., 2003) and, finally, achange in the stoichiometry of the reactions thatlead to the transition from a poykilitic core to aneuhedral rim devoid of inclusions (Robyr et al.,2014). Nevertheless, the possibility ofidentifying the simultaneous activity of differentmechanisms is not rare (Ruiz Cruz, 2011).

The aim of this work is to use quantitative

textural data, obtained from image-assistedanalysis of four selected garnet domains relatableto different stages of “atollization” process, inorder to reconstruct the sequential order ofcrystallization of this peculiar texture from uppergreen-schist facies to amphibolite facies inmetapelites outcropping in the northern part ofthe Peloritani Mountains. The results are alsouseful to ascertain which one of the atollizationmechanisms suggested in the literature can beinvoked in this case, and to constrain thedifferent stages of recristallization undergone bythe selected samples during their PT evolution,witnessed by this relic portion of the southernEuropean Variscan Chain (Cirrincione et al.,2012). This last analysis, associated with theintegration of microstructural investigations, hasbeen executed by thermodynamic modeling viaPT pseudosection calculation using the softwarePerplex (Connolly and Petrini, 2002; Connolly,2005).

Geological setting

Samples characterized by the presence of atollgarnets come from the area of Santa Lucia delMela, Peloritani Mountains (North-easternSicily), a portion of the southernmost part ofCalabrian-Peloritani Orogen (CPO), whichrepresents the innermost tectonic element of theApennine-Maghrebian orogen and geographicallyextends from the north of Calabria to the northeastof Sicily (Figure 1 a,b), to continue up to theBetic-Rif belt. In its crystalline basement units,this orogenic segment preserves evidence of apolyorogenic multistadial evolution resulting

259PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of ...Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:41 Pagina 259

Page 4: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

260 G. Ortolano et al.Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

Figure 1. Regional geological framework of the study area: a) Distribution of Variscan relict metamorphicbasements in Europe, after von Raumer, 2002; b) Geological map of the Calabrian metamorphic complexes,after Angì et al., 2010; c) Geological sketch map of the Peloritani Mountains and Aspromonte Massif crystallinebasement complexes with the subdivision of the tectono-metamorphic units (after Cirrincione et al., 2012,modified).

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:41 Pagina 260

Page 5: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

261PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of ...Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

from the Alpine reworking of original late-Paelozoic (i.e. Variscan orogeny) (Cirrincione etal., 2008, 2012) or possibly older (De Gregorio etal., 2003; Ferla, 2000; Messina et al., 2004)basement rocks.

From a physiographic point of view, the CPOis constituted by the north-south trending domaincomposed by the Catena Costiera and Sila (i.e.Northern CPO), and by the NE-SW trendingalignment of the Serre-Aspromonte Massif(Calabria), which continues in Sicily with the E-W trending orogenic belt of the PeloritaniMountains (i.e. Southern CPO, Cirrincione et al.,1999; Piluso et al., 2000; Cella et al., 2004; Festaet al., 2004) (Figure 1b). According toCirrincione et al. (1999, 2012) the PeloritaniMountains can be described as a nappe-pilesubdivided into a Lower and an Upper Complex(Figure 1c). The Lower Complex includes threetectonic units (the Capo S. Andrea Unit, theLongi Taormina Unit and the S. Marcod’Alunzio Unit, from bottom to top) croppingout in the southern part of the PeloritaniMountains. These units consist of late-Paelozoicvery low-grade basement rocks that have aMesozic-Caenozoic continental marginsedimentary cover with no Alpine metamorphicoverprint. The overlying units, belonging to theUpper Complex, consist of two main overturnedtectonic slices, comprehensive of low tomedium-high grade Variscan metamorphic rocks(the Mandanici and Aspromonte-PeloritaniUnits), which have an Alpine metamorphicoverprint. The rocks belonging to the MandaniciUnit are low-grade phyllites, crystallinelimestones, phyllitic schists, greenschists and

interbedded quartzites affected by a Variscanpolyphase metamorphism from uppergreenschist- to lower amphibolites-facies (T =550 °C, P = 2-3 kbar; Atzori and D’Amico, 1972;Cirrincione and Pezzino, 1991; Ferla, 2000). TheAspromonte-Peloritani Unit outcrops also in theAspromonte Massif (southern Calabria), devoidof Mesozoic sedimentary cover. This unitconsists of medium to high-grade amphibolitefacies metamorphic rocks: paragneisses, ortho-derived augen gneisses and minor micaschists,amphibolites and marbles characterised by anamphibolites facies Variscan-type polyphasemetamorphism (Pezzino et al., 1990; Puglisi andPezzino, 1994; Cirrincione et al., 2008). Theseterranes have been subsequently intruded by lateHercynian granitoids (315-290 Ma, Rb/Sr ages;Rottura et al., 1990; Fiannacca et al., 2008) whena widespread late-Paeleozoic temperatureincrease took place. This evolution was followedby an Alpine multistage overprint, preservedalong the contact with the underlying MandaniciUnit. The atoll garnet-bearing samples werecollected from some outcrops located 6 Kmsouth-east from the town of Santa Lucia delMela in the area between the Mela andFloripotema rivers belonging to the Aspromonte-Peloritani Unit (Figure 2).

Methodological approach

A preliminary microstructural analysis bymeans of optical microscope has been performedon about twenty thin sections in order torecognize the textural relationships, and theassociated mineral parageneses, in which a

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:41 Pagina 261

Page 6: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

262 G. Ortolano et al.Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

Figure 2. a) Geological sketch map of the study area with sample location: b’) and b’’) stereoplots of the northernand southern plane poles of the main foliation with relative average planes (S2).

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:41 Pagina 262

Page 7: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

263PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of ...Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

reconstruction of the history of the blasto-deformational sequence recorded by theanalyzed samples can be grounded.

Such an investigation was integrated by thedetermination of the whole-rock chemicalanalyses (Table 1), in order to obtain thecomposition of the equilibrium volume relativeto the early metamorphic stages, used for thecalculation of the P-T pseudosections. Bulk rockchemistry was obtained by XRF on pressedpowder pellets using a Philips PW 2404spectrometer equipped with a Rh anticathode atthe Department of Biological, Geological andEnvironmental Sciences of Catania University.FeO/Fe2O3 ratio was determined by titration withKMnO4; H2O was measured as weight loss onignition (L.O.I.) and was determined withstandard gravimetric procedures, after heatingthe powder at ~ 900 °C for about 6 h.

Four garnet micro-domains representative ofdifferent atoll development were chosen onselected polished thin sections of three selectedsamples (Figure 2 - Table 2) and analyzed at theLaboratory of Electron Microscopy ofDepartment of Biological, Geological andEnvironmental Sciences, University of Catania.Microanalytical data for major elementabundances on garnet, plagioclase, ilmenite,biotite, white mica and chlorite (Appendix A)

were obtained by means of a Tescan Vega-LMUscanning electron microscope equipped with anEDAX Neptune XM4-60 micro-analyzeroperating by energy dispersive systemcharacterized by an ultra-thin Be window coupledwith an EDAX WDS LEXS (wavelengthdispersive low energy X-ray spectrometer)calibrated for light elements. Operatingconditions were 20 kV accelerating voltage and0.2 nA beam current. Repeated analyses oninternationally certified Alm-rich garnet, Na-richplagioclase, biotite and glass inner standardsduring the analytical runs ensure precision for allthe collected elements in the order of ± 3%. X-ray maps, useful to highlight compositionalvariations, were obtained on the same domains toderive Al, Ca, Fe, K, Mg, Mn, Na, Si and Tidistribution and concentration. These maps are512*400 pixels and each pixel corresponds toabout 2 m per side. Maps were obtained with adwell time of 500 ms per 128 frame,corresponding to an average acquisition time of 4hours and 20 minutes. The results of the spot-chemical analyses have been processed by meansof Minpet 2.02 software (Richard, 1985) torecalculate the formula of each mineral. Garnetformulae have been recalculated on the basis of12 oxygens and 8 cations; micas on 24 oxygensand 12 cations, respectively, and feldspars on 8

Table 1. XRF Bulk rock composition of representative samples.

Sample SiO2 Al2O3 FeOtot MnO MgO CaO Na2O K2O Total

Me 17 64.04 16.93 7.39 0.09 3.96 1.72 2.03 3.85 100

Sam 3 58.94 17.60 8.82 0.25 4.76 3.71 2.51 3.40 100

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:41 Pagina 263

Page 8: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

oxygens; all the iron was regarded as FeO. The above routinely performed investigations

were supported by a new software platform ofimage analysis (i.e. X-Ray Map Analyzer -XRMA, Ortolano et al., 2014) capable to generategraphical outputs useful for classifying chemicallyhomogeneous zones as well as extractingquantitative textural information through thestatistical data handling of X-ray maps. In thepresent research XRMA was used to evidence thecompositional differences and the micro-texturalrelationships between, and within, individualmineralogical phases, possibly related to thedifferent stages of P-T evolution (e.g. Fiannaccaet al., 2012). To this aim, the X-ray maps of thefour selected domains have been processedthrough the following two analytical cycles:

1) the first one consisted in the analysis of theentire selected domains, in order to recognize allthe existing mineral phases. The principalcomponent analysis (PCA), was followed by theimage classification performed by means of amaximum likelihood classification (MLC)

algorithm, which assigns to each pixel a specificarbitrary color. In this way a distribution mineralmap was obtained, that allows to recognizemicrometer mineral phases such as inclusiontrails, thus defining textural relationshipsbetween mineral constituents in great detail(Appendix B);

2) the second one consisted in a furtheranalysis of the previously recognized garnets inorder to point out further potential subdivisions,such as those related to mineral zoning or thoseindicative of mineral reactions. To do this, thesoftware offers two options: i) through the firstone (sub-classification of mineral phases) a sub-zoning map of the garnet was obtained; ii)through the second one the density distributionof selected elements within garnet was obtained(Appendix B).

Finally P-T pseudosections, representing atotal phase diagram section related to a specificbulk composition, were calculated with thePerplex software package (Connolly and Petrini,2002; Connolly, 2005). The equilibrium volumes

264 G. Ortolano et al.Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

Table 2. Sample location and related paragenesis.

Sample Coordinates* Observed minerals Litotype

N E

Me 02 38° 07’ 31’’ 15° 17’ 13’’ Qtz, Pl, Bt, Wm, Grt, Chl(Ilm, Sph, Ap, Rt) Garnet micaschist

Me 17 38° 04’ 57’’ 15° 19’ 09’’ Bt, Qtz, Wm, Pl, Grt, Chl(Ilm, Ap, Tur) Garnet micaschist

Sam 3 38° 04’ 33’’ 15° 19’ 28’’ Qtz, Pl, Bt, Wm, Grt, Chl(Ilm, Ap, Hem) Garnet micaschist

* Coordinates were collected by GPS and are expressed according to the WGS84 system.

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:41 Pagina 264

Page 9: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of ... 265

of the former metamorphic evolutionary stageswere determined using the XRF bulkcompositions. Then, a modal based effectivebulk rock chemistry determination, assisted byimage analysis, has been derived to constrain theP-T evolution during the different stages of theatoll shaped garnet formation.

In this way it was possible to calculate theeffective bulk rock chemistry for the retrogradePT steps, by applying a computational approachbased on the volume percentage of theinterpreted parageneses.

Petrography

Petrographic investigations have been focusedon twenty thin sections of medium to fine

grained garnet-mica-schists, characterized by aneterogranular anisotropic texture with a prevalentgrano-lepidoblastic structure.

The sequence of the blasto-deformation eventscan be completely ascribed to the former up to thefirst retrograde stages of the Variscanmetamorphic cycle. The first one (D1) brings tothe formation of an axial plane schistosity (S1)along which a synkinematic assemblage given bywm1 + chl1 + bt1 + pl1 + grt1 + qtz + ilmcrystallize during the earlier stage, followed by alater metamorphic stage given by grt2 + wm2 +chl2+ bt2 + pl2 + qtz + ilm + ap + hem (Figure 3).

The first stage evolves toward a non coaxialdeformational (D2) which brings to theformation of the dominant foliation, representedby a well-developed schistosity (S2). This last

Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

Figure 3. Synoptic representation of the deformation - recrystallization relationships.

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:41 Pagina 265

Page 10: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

G. Ortolano et al.266

deformational stage largely obliterates earlierschistosity (S1), presently highlighted by theoccurrence of deformed relict biotite and whitemica at high angle to S2 (Figure 4a) or bywidespread relics of micro-fold hinges withinmicrolithons, preserved as tight to isoclinal foldhinges (Figure 4b).

S2 is defined by the parallel arrangement offine grained granoblastic layers of xenoblasticplagioclase and quartz grains with unduloseextinction alternating with phyllosilicate-richlayers of biotite, with abundant zircon inclusions,and fine grained white mica. Locally accessorytourmaline also occurs. These layers wrap syn-to late-S1 garnet porphyroblasts, characterizedby euhedral to sub-euhedral shape and rangingin size from 1 to 3 mm. They are often stronglyaltered and fractured, and most of them havecores with inclusion trails of quartz, white micaand locally chloritized biotite. Accessory smallilmenite crystals parallel to the main foliation(i.e. S2) or included in the core of garnet are alsocommon, while syn- to late-S1 apatite and, attimes, subordinate sub-euhedral hematite locallyoccurs, rarely accompanied by rutile, occurringas detrital relicts of the original protolith.

Locally, inclusion-rich garnet cores arepartially to completely pseudomorphosed, withthe formation of the atoll shaped garnets as aconsequence of a retrograde breakdown reactionwith formation of an association of grt3 + bt3 +pl3 + wm3 + qtz + chl3 + ilm + ap + sph (Figures3,4c). The formation of this third garnetgeneration is preferentially concentrated alongthe main fractures of the almost integer garnets(Figure 5a) or in the inner- and outer-rim portion

Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

Figure 4. General description of garnet-micaschistsmicrostructures. a) Fine grained granoblastic layers ofxenoblastic plagioclase and quartz phyllosilicate-richlayers of biotite and white mica defining the mainfoliation (S2), with micro-fold hinges withinmicrolithons testyfing an early schistosity (S1)(parallel polarizers). b) Deformed relict biotite andwhite mica at high angle to S2 in D1 fold hinges(crossed polarizers). c) Example of atoll shaped garnetcharacterized by a quasi complete euhedral garnet ringsurrounding a core substituted by a biotite + muscovite+ plagioclase + quartz + chlorite+ garnet3 aggregate.

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:41 Pagina 266

Page 11: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of ... 267

of the advanced atoll shaped ones (Figure 5b).According to Faryad et al., (2010), theseevidences suggest that the main mechanisms ofatollization that can be invoked for our samplesis the selective replacement of garnet cores,facilitated by the opening of fractures, instead ofthe others mechanism such as the rapidpoikiloblastic growth (Atherton and Edmunds,1966) or the multiple nucleation and coalescenceprocesses (Spiess et al., 2001; Dobbs et al., 2003)as well as the change in the stoichiometry of thereactions during the transition from poykiliticgarnet cores to euhedral rim devoid of inclusions

(Robyr et al., 2014).Four micro-domains identified in three of the

collected samples (Table 2) have been chosen tofurther investigate the processes of formation ofthe atoll shaped garnet (Figure 6). The followingselected micro-domains were considered asrepresentative of the progressive stages of theatollization process: i) Me17, where differentquantities of garnet substitution are found (frompristine garnet - Figure 6a) to almost completelycorroded core (Figure 6c); ii) Sam3, where garnetscores are often preserved as a peninsula within theatoll (Figure 6b); and iii) Me02, where garnets are

Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

Figure 5. Examples of garnet zoning pattern: a) almost complete garnet characterized by two growing generationshighlighted by an inclusion free garnet (grt2) replaced, along fractures, by garnet with cryptocrystallineinclusions (grt3) (parallel polarizers); b) second and third garnet generation preferentially crystallizing in theouter and inner rim position of the atoll ring, respectively (parallel polarizers).

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:41 Pagina 267

Page 12: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

G. Ortolano et al.268 Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

Figure 6. Microphotographs of sequential steps of atoll garnet formation, with atoll process increasing from a tod (crossed and parallel polarizers, respectively). a) “Pristine” fractured garnet; b) Preserved garnet core, relictouter core is partially transformed to biotite, muscovite, plagioclase, quartz aggregate; outer rim is preserved; c)typical atoll texture where a rim of garnet surrounds a white mica, biotite, chlorite, plagioclase and quartzaggregate; d) garnet completely pseudomorphed by white mica, biotite, chlorite, plagioclase and quartz aggregate.

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:41 Pagina 268

Page 13: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of ... 269

completely pseudomorphed (Figure 6d). The first step of atoll textural evolution, is

characterized by the presence of a completegarnet, which is wrapped by S2 foliation andpreserves an inclusion-rich (ilmenite, white mica,chloritized biotite apatite) core, rimmed by aninclusion-poor outer core and rim (Figure 6a).

The second step of atoll textural evolution(Figure 6b) is represented by a garnet with apartly resorbed core, characterized by thepresence of sigma shaped inclusion trails,testifying the syn-D1 growth event followed bythe progressive crenulation of the formerschistosity (S1) in non-coaxial regime until theformation of the main schistosity (S2) (Robyr etal., 2007). The recognition of an outer euhedralinclusion-poor mantle likely indicates a later D1quasi-static porphyroblast growth. Thecrystallization of Bt, Pl, Wm and Chl localizedalong fractures is correlated with a retrogrademetamorphic event (D2).

The third step of atoll textural evolution (Figure6c) represents the most advanced state ofatollization. Here garnet cores are totally replacedby plagioclase, quartz, biotite, and white mica incontact with inclusion-free garnet ring. Thecrystallographic orientation of biotite and whitemica, seems to be controlled by the formation of111 garnet planes in the inner part of the ring,while they are randomly-oriented, compared tothe main external foliation (Figure 5b).

The last stage of atollization is represented inthe fourth selected micro-domain characterizedby the total substitution of garnet by anassemblage of white mica, biotite, chlorite,plagioclase and quartz (Figure 6d).

Image analysis and mineral-chemicalevolution

BSE images and X-ray map arrays of the foursequential steps of atoll shaped garnet formationwere here integrated with the multivariatestatistical analysis undertaken with the softwareX-Ray Map Analyzer (Ortolano et al., 2014), inorder to define the sequence of garnet zones withdifferent compositions linked to the recognizedmetamorphic evolution.

BSE images of the complete garnet (Figure7A) evidence the presence of inclusionspreferentially concentrated into the inner garnetportion and decreasing towards the rim. X-raymaps highlight a typical bell shaped profile,interrupted by an anomalous increase of Mnconcentration which is especially evident alongthe fractures that connect the inner garnet portionwith the external matrix minerals (Figure 7B -ME17a). The result of the first analytical cycleevidences the distribution and the nature of theinclusions mostly constituted by ilmenite(1.02%), biotite (0.97%), quartz (0.73%) andwhite mica (0.58%) and minor phases (Figure 7C- ME17a - Appendix C). The late-D1overgrowing stage is also well defined by sub-euhedral garnet with few or no inclusions, whichaccount in total for the 97.18%, considering as100% the portion of the rim domain (AppendixC).

BSE image of the second microdomainevidenced the presence of a peninsula constitutedby an inclusion-rich garnet, bracketed in part byplagioclase and biotite and by the overgrowth ofthe late-D1 inclusion-poor garnet (Figure 7A -

Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:41 Pagina 269

Page 14: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

G. Ortolano et al.270 Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

Figu

re 7

. Bac

k sc

atte

red

elec

tron

imag

es (c

olum

n A

); X

-ray

map

s (c

olum

n B

); fir

st c

ycle

imag

e cl

assi

ficat

ion

resu

lts (c

olum

n C

) for

the

first

two

sequ

entia

l ato

lliza

tion

step

s.

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:41 Pagina 270

Page 15: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of ... 271

SAM3). X-ray maps evidence that the originalbell-shaped profile of Mn is here almostcompletely obliterated by the formation of a newgarnet richer in Mn than the core. This suggeststhat, in this case, the fluids derived from thepartial resorption of the relic inner core wereenriched in Mn during the atoll-formingretrograde reactions due to the enrichment of thiselement in the core (Figure 7B - SAM3). Theabove features are in agreement with the resultsof the first analytical cycle, which recognizes thepresence in the garnet core of a sigma shapedinclusions, constituted by qtz - pl - ilm - wm - bt- ap (Figure 7C - SAM3 - Appendix C),overgrown by the late-D1 garnet formation.

In the third micro-domain, representative ofthe total garnet inner core pseudomorphosys,BSE image has evidenced the textural relationsbetween the phases replacing the core (mostlyplagioclase and white mica) and the inner rim atthe contact (Figure 8A - ME17b). X ray mapsevidence a peculiar zoning pattern of the garnetring, characterized by an increasing content ofMn especially along the fractures as well as inthe inner rim portion of the ring (Figure 8B -ME17b). The first analytical cycle hashighlighted the presence of biotite in contactwith neoblastic garnet (grt3) with rational sharpboundaries associated to plagioclase and smallmuscovite flakes (wm 3) (Figure 8C - ME17b).The BSE image of the last selected domain,representative of the total pseudomorphosys,evidences the presence of a qtz - pl - bt - sph -wm - chl aggregate that completely substitutesgarnet, whose presence is here suggested only byits shape as it is completely pseudomorphed

(Figure 8A - ME02). X ray maps seem todelineate (especially in the Ca-Fe-Mg channels)the old inclusion trails within the core, whereasthe Si channel allow to emphasize the presenceof plagioclase clearly depicted the original garnetboundary (Figure 8B - ME02). This last evidencehave been then confirmed by the output of thefirst analytical cycle which delineates theboundary of the preexisting garnet through theshape of the plagioclase in the upper rightportion of the map, characterized by analignment along the 111 planes of the previouslyexisting garnet (Figure 8C - ME02).

The second analytical cycle consists in thechemical sub-classification as well as in thecomputation of the kernel density distribution ofan element within a selected phase (Ortolano etal., 2014). Results on the garnets of the first threedomains, allow to define the peculiarcompositional zoning pattern, which includes upto four distinct regions related to different atollgarnet formation stages, permitting at the sametime to interpret the results of the mineral-chemical analysis. In this view, a new set ofacronyms are proposed in order to outline theevolutionary stages of the atolls formation eventhough they are not always observed at the sametime in all the selected microdomains: i) RIC(Relic Inner Core); ii) ROC (Relic Outer Core);iii) RR (Relic Rim) and iv) NR (New Rim) (Table3).

The RIC zone, recognized in the garnets ofsamples Me17 and Sam3 is characterized by lowcontents in almandine and pyrope and highcontent in spessartine and grossular (Figure 9a,b) ranging from Alm59Grs24Pyr6Sps11 to

Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:41 Pagina 271

Page 16: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

G. Ortolano et al.272 Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

Figu

re 8

. Bac

k sc

atte

red

elec

tron

imag

es (c

olum

n A

); X

-ray

map

s (c

olum

n B

); fir

st c

ycle

imag

e cl

assi

ficat

ion

resu

lts (c

olum

n C

) for

the

last

two

sequ

entia

l ato

lliza

tion

step

s.

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:41 Pagina 272

Page 17: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of ... 273

Alm63Grs18Pyr6Sps13 (Figure 10 - Appendix D).The ROC zone was observed in all selecteddomains and is characterized by a decrease inspessartine and a simultaneous increase inalmandine and, to a lesser extent, in pyrope(Figure 9 a,b,c). Compositions vary fromAlm65Grs15Pyr11Sps9 to Alm69Grs17Pyr10Sps4

along the outer edge, exhibiting a gradualreduction of spessartine from the inner core tothe garnet rim and by the decrease in grossular(Figure 10 - Appendix D). The RR zone(Alm68Grs16Pyr8Sps8 to Alm70Grs15Pyr11Sps4)(Figure 10 - Appendix D) has been recognizedonly in sample Sam3 (Figure 9b). It ischaracterized by a sharp discontinuity defined bya steep increase in almandine and pyropeassociated with a decrease in grossular andspessartine, clearly visible in the compositionalprofiles of Figure 10. In all analyzed domains a

NR zone, localized along fractures(Alm63Grs15Pyr8Sps14) and along the outermargins (Alm67Grs6Pyr10Sps17), has beenobserved (Appendix D). This zone ischaracterized by a sharp increase in spessartinecontent, suggesting that a garnet core consumingreaction took place (Figure 9 a,b,c), and that theMn held in the core was incorporated in the newgarnet rims. (i.e the reaction grt1+ includedminerals + fluids(?) = grt3 + wm + bt + pl + qtz).

The growth sequence is clearly visible inFigure 10 as well as in Appendix D, where thegarnet composition from RIC to RR ischaracterized by an increase in Grs and Alm,whereas the NR garnet composition is noticeablySpess rich. This evidence can be explainedthrough the selective resorption of the originalgarnet cores composition which allowed toenrich the retrograde reaction fluid with Mn. The

Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

Table 3. Subdivision of garnet zones after the XRMA 2nd analytical cycle.

Image analysis zones Mineralogicalphases Sample Composition Inclusions Deformation

stage

RIC Relic InnerCore Grt 1 Me17;

Sam3

(Alm59Grs24Pyr6Sps11)to

(Alm63Grs18Pyr6Sps13)

Ilm + Qtz +Wm ± Chl Sin-S1

ROC Relic OuterCore Grt 2 Me17;

Sam3

(Alm65Grs15Pyr11Sps9)to

(Alm69Grs17Pyr10Sps4)

Ilm + Qtz +Wm + Bt + Ap Late-S1

RR Relic Rim Sam3(Alm66Grs16Pyr9Sps9)

to(Alm70Grs15Pyr11Sps4)

Ilm + Ap +Hem

NR New Rim Grt 3 Me17;Sam3

(Alm63Grs15Pyr8Sps14)to

(Alm67Grs6Pyr10Sps17)

Qtz + Ap + Bt+ Pl Sin-S2

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:41 Pagina 273

Page 18: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

G. Ortolano et al.274

new garnet (i.e. NR) forms from the reaction ofold inner cores garnet connected by fractures withmatrix minerals.

White mica occurs both in the matrix, aligned

parallel to the S2 foliation, and inside the atollstructure, as a replacement phase. It is a muscovitewith Si ranging from 3.09 to 3.17 a.p.f.u, with alow to intermediate phengite content (Appendix

Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

Figure 9. Second cycle of the image classification results for the three garnet characterized by an increasingstage of atollization (RIC = Relic Inner Core, ROC = Relic Outer Core, RR = Relic Rim and NR = New Rim):a) Outputs relative to the first microdomain of the Me17 sample; b) Outputs relative to the microdomains of theSam3 sample; c) Outputs relative to the second microdomain of the Me17 sample.

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:41 Pagina 274

Page 19: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of ... 275Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

Figure 10. Compositional profiles of the three garnet characterized by the increasing stage of atollization processrelative to the first microdomain of Me17, Sam3 and the second microdomain of the Me17 samples (for spotanalysis location see yellow dots on Figure 9).

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:41 Pagina 275

Page 20: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

G. Ortolano et al.276 Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

A). Muscovite with low Si content is observedinside the atoll, whereas syn-S2 muscovite is morephengite-rich.

Plagioclase is found either as a replacement inthe atoll core, or as a granoblastic phase in thematrix (syn-S2). It has andesine composition(from An32 to An37) in the atolls, whereas it hashigher An content (from An37 to An50, AppendixA) in the matrix.

Biotite has XFe (= Fe/Fe + Mg) ranging from0.27 to 0.55 inside the atoll, whereas the syn-S2crystals show a smaller range (XFe from 0.44 to0.48) in the matrix.

Chlorite compositions (pseodomorphs afterbiotite and subordinately after garnet) arecharacterized by XFe from 0.37 to 0.51, typical ofpycnochlorite.

Ilmenite has a relatively significant pyrophanitecontent (Mn-ilmenite) ranging from 9.4 to 10.7mol% in the atolls, whereas a wider range (from2.8 to 15.1 mol%) can be detected in the matrix,(Appendix B).

Thermodynamic modeling and PTpseudosection computation

Two pseudosections were calculated forsamples SAM3 and ME17 using the Perple_Xsoftware package (updated to March 2014,http://www.perplex.ethz.ch/). XRF compositionswere chosen to represent the effective bulk rockchemistry. In both cases the pseudosectionsencompass a relatively restricted PT range of T= 500-650 °C and P = 0.3-1.1 GPa, consideredsufficient to bracket the PT constraints of theobserved parageneses. MnO-Na2O-K2O-FeO-

MgO-Al2O3-SiO2-H2O (MnNKFMASH) systemwas used. SiO2 and H2O were considered inexcess and the CORK fluid equation of state(EOS) of Holland and Powell (1998) was usedto model the fluid phase behavior. The solidsolution models were: (a) Ti-Fe3+ biotite ofTajcmanova et al., (2009) extended for Mnsolution after Tinkham et al., (2001); (b) aquaternary garnet model of Holland and Powell(1998); (c) the white mica model of Holland andPowell (1998) valid for Na-poor compositions;(d) the chlorite model of Holland et al., (1998);(e) a binary plagioclase solid solution (Newtonet al., 1980). According to Evans (2004) andCirrincione et al. (2008), in order to derivereliable P-T constraints, the intersections of atleast three isopleths per time were consideredfrom the different garnet compositions texturallyconstrained by means of the image processing.As the specific garnet compositional range is inequilibrium with the bulk-rock chemistry, it ispossible to calculate the P-T conditions of thedifferent garnet growth stages within an averageestimated error of ± 30 °C and ± 0.1 GPa (e.g.Cirrincione et al., 2008), assuming that smallvolumes have preserved the equilibriumassemblages and compositions.

The Me17 garnet isopleths intersections in RIC(Alm59-63Grs18-24Prp5-6Sps11-13) define a PTinterval of T = 545-560 °C and P = 0.68-0.72 GPa,whereas those of ROC (Alm65-69Grs15-17Prp10-

14Sps4-9) define a slightly larger area with T =567-590 °C and P = 0.72-0.83 GPa (Figure 11 a,b).

The Sam3 garnet isopleths intersectionsrelated to RIC (Alm58-62Grs17-20Prp7-9Sps12-15)delimit an area enclosed between T = 555-565

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:41 Pagina 276

Page 21: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of ... 277

°C and P = 0.59-0.63 GPa, whereas the ROC(Alm64-65Grs18-19Prp10-11Sps6-8) defines a rangeof T = 580-585 °C and P = 0.68-0.72 GPa. TheRR (Alm65-67Grs14-17Prp8-11Sps6-9) falling in anarea corresponding to lower pressures and highertemperatures compared with the ROC, and it isbetween T = 590-600 °C and P = 0.58-0.66 GPa(Figure 12 a,b).

In order to estimate the P-T conditionsassociated with the retrograde metamorphicevolution responsible for the breakdown of thegarnet inner core and for the consequent NR

formation, a representative portion of the relativeequilibrium volume from Me17 and Me02samples has been used to calculate a neweffective bulk rock chemistry, isolating, bymeans of ArcGis raster analysis (Dainelli et al.,2010), the portion of the aggregate substitutingthe core + grt3 (Figure 13). Once the modalamount of the new phases and their compositionwas known (Tables 4a and 5a), the bulkcomposition of this volume can be determined(Tables 4b and 5b).

The new computed pseudosection for Me17

Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

Figure 11. Pseudosections calculated for Me17 with effective bulk rock chemistry derived from XRF. a) Isoplethsintersections for garnet composition in sample Me17; b) pseudosection of sample Me17 with light areasevidencing isopleths intersections for RIC (red) and ROC (dark blue).

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:41 Pagina 277

Page 22: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

G. Ortolano et al.278

(former garnet core) was calculated, assuming theeffective bulk rock chemistry from Table 4b in the(MnNKFMASH) system, using the same solidsolution models and EOS as before. NR garnetisopleth intersection (Alm61-67Grs8-12Prp0-23Sps8-

19) in equilibrium with anorthite (An31-35) andphengite (Ph8-12), in association with an averageXFebiotite of 47%, delimit an area characterizedby temperatures ranging from 563 to 600 °C andby pressures from 0.48 to 0.70 GPa, which fallsat a higher temperature and lower pressure with

respect to the previously constrained P-Tconditions for D1 (Figure 14 a,b).

Effective bulk rock chemistry for Me02 (Table5b), representative for the total garnetpseudomorphosis, was used to calculate a newpseudosection in the NaKFMASH system, withthe same EOS and solid solutions, and addingFe-Mg-Mn staurolite ideal model after Hollandand Powell (1998) because stable in some fieldsof the right portion of the new computedpseudosection. The plagioclase (An13-15),

Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

Figure 12. Pseudosections calculated for Sam3 with effective bulk rock composition derived from XRF. a)Isopleths for garnet composition in sample Sam3; b) pseudosection of sample Sam3 with light areas evidencingisopleths intersections for RIC (red), ROC (dark) and RR (green). See text for explanation of abbreviations andtextures.

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:41 Pagina 278

Page 23: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of ... 279Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

Figure 13. Image resulting from the combination of the two cycles of image analysis for atoll garnet Me17 (a)and for pseudomorphed garnet in sample Me02 (b). The areas occupied by garnets are evidenced in order todetermine the equilibrium volume that reacted during the D2 event. Obtained effective bulk rock chemistry wasthen used to calculate the retrograde pseudosections of Figure 14.

Table 4a. Quantitative output data of the supervised image classification from Me17b selected domain and fromisolated retrograde reactant portion.

Quantitative data of Me17 total domain Quantitative data of Me17isolated polygon

Mineral phasespolygon/domain

Mineral Pixel count Percentage Pixel count Percentage PercentageNR 28203 13.77 3834 5.57 1.87Qtz 51318 25.06 1782 2.59 0.87Pl 33239 16.23 11704 16.99 5.71Bt 62774 30.65 43672 63.40 21.32Wm1 19089 9.32 4801 6.97 2.34Chl 2159 1.05 830 1.20 0.41Ilm 1597 0.78 870 1.26 0.42Ap 564 0.28 279 0.41 0.14Holes 177 0.09 50 0.07 0.02Fracture 2943 1.44 713 1.04 0.35FeOx 28 0.01 4 0.01 0.00Wm2 2709 1.32 343 0.50 0.17Total 204800 100.00 68882 100.00 33.63

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:41 Pagina 279

Page 24: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

G. Ortolano et al.280

phengite (Ph6-9) and XFe average value forchlorite of 46%, permitted to obtain isoplethsintersections delimiting a relatively wide portionof the PT space between T = 500-600 °C and P= 0.46-0.70 GPa, suggesting a retrogradeevolution towards greenschist facies conditions(Figure 15 a,b).

Discussion

Thermodynamic modeling via PTpseudosection computation constrained bymeans of textural relationships of four micro-domains from micaschist belonging to theAspromonte Peloritani Unit, were hereperformed in order to reconstruct the PTevolution of the rocks involved in the Variscan

Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

Table 4b. Oxides modal amount computation inside mineral phases of the isolated polygon (Me17b).

Garnet oxides computationOxides SiO2 TiO2 Al2O3 Cr2O3 FeO MnO MgO CaO Na2O K2O TotalAverage composition (wt%) 38.11 0.13 21.47 0.14 27.48 5.89 2.12 4.28 0.00 0.00 99.61Normalized to 100 38.26 0.13 21.55 0.14 27.59 5.91 2.12 4.29 0.00 0.00 100.00Garnet polygon oxides 0.72 0.00 0.40 0.00 0.52 0.11 0.04 0.08 0.00 0.00 1.87

Feldspar oxides computationAverage composition (wt%) 62.17 0.00 24.45 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 5.09 7.67 0.00 99.38Normalized to 100 38.26 0.13 21.55 0.14 27.59 5.91 2.12 4.29 0.00 0.00 100.00Feldspar polygon oxides 0.72 0.00 0.40 0.00 0.52 0.11 0.04 0.08 0.00 0.00 1.87

Biotite amount compuationAverage composition (wt%) 37.91 1.45 20.08 0.00 15.91 0.21 11.52 0.00 0.37 8.50 95.94Normalized to 100 39.52 1.51 20.93 0.00 16.58 0.21 12.00 0.00 0.38 8.86 100.00Biotite polygon oxides 8.43 0.32 4.46 0.00 3.54 0.05 2.56 0.00 0.08 1.89 21.32

White mica oxides computationAverage composition (wt%) 47.39 0.63 36.11 0.00 0.88 0.00 0.69 0.00 1.22 9.03 95.95Normalized to 100 49.39 0.66 37.63 0.00 0.92 0.00 0.72 0.00 1.27 9.41 100.00Wm polygon oxides 1.24 0.02 0.94 0.00 0.02 0.00 0.02 0.00 0.03 0.24 2.51

Chlorite oxides computationAverage composition (wt%) 29.32 0.00 20.55 0.00 22.50 0.00 15.93 0.00 0.00 0.00 88.30Normalized to 100 33.20 0.00 23.27 0.00 25.48 0.00 18.04 0.00 0.00 0.00 100.00Chl polygon oxides 0.14 0.00 0.10 0.00 0.10 0.00 0.07 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.41

Sum of the oxides to detect new effectively bulk chemistry for isolated D2-polygonOxides SiO2 TiO2 Al2O3 Cr2O3 FeO MnO MgO CaO Na2O K2O TotalDomain Oxides 14.82 0.34 7.31 0.00 4.18 0.16 2.69 0.37 0.55 2.13 32.55Normalized to 100 45.53 1.05 22.46 0.00 12.84 0.48 8.27 1.15 1.70 6.53 100.00

Normalized to 100 (- TiO2)in order to obtain new bulkchemistry

46.01 0.00 22.69 0.00 12.98 0.49 8.36 1.16 1.72 6.60 100.00

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:41 Pagina 280

Page 25: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of ... 281Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

Tale 5a. Quantitative output data of the supervised image classification from Me02 selected domain and fromisolated reacted portions.

Quantitative data of Me02 total domain Quantitative data of Me02isolated polygon

Mineral phasespolygon/domain

Mineral Pixel count Percentage Pixel count Percentage PercentageQtz 59067 28.84 19058 21.71 9.31Pl 37823 18.47 15993 18.22 7.81Chl 21825 10.66 14930 17.00 7.29Bt 24383 11.91 12143 13.83 5.93Wm1 15343 7.49 9002 10.25 4.40Wm2 40959 20.00 15103 17.20 7.37Ap 976 0.48 227 0.26 0.11Rt 153 0.07 8 0.01 0.00Ilm 2251 1.10 661 0.75 0.32Sph 1677 0.82 614 0.70 0.30FeOx 343 0.17 60 0.07 0.03Total 204800 100.00 68882 100.00 33.63

Table 5b. Oxides modal amount computation inside mineral phases of the isolated polygon.

Feldspar oxides calculationOxides SiO2 TiO2 Al2O3 FeO MnO MgO CaO Na2O K2O TotalAverage composition (wt%) 63.75 0.00 22.73 0.00 0.00 0.02 3.92 8.83 0.00 99.25Normalized to 100 64.23 0.00 22.90 0.00 0.00 0.02 3.95 8.90 0.00 100.00Feldspar polygon oxides 5.02 0.00 1.79 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.31 0.69 0.00 7.81

White mica oxides calculationAverage composition (wt%) 47.03 0.74 34.56 2.09 0.00 1.24 0.00 0.85 9.36 95.87Normalized to 100 49.06 0.77 36.05 2.18 0.00 1.29 0.00 0.89 9.76 100.00Wm polygon oxides 3.81 0.06 2.80 0.17 0.00 0.10 0.00 0.07 0.76 7.77

Chlorite oxides calculationAverage composition (wt%) 28.64 0.00 20.91 23.13 0.00 15.86 0.00 0.00 0.08 88.62Normalized to 100 32.32 0.00 23.60 26.10 0.00 17.89 0.00 0.00 0.09 100.00Chl polygon oxides 2.36 0.00 1.72 1.90 0.00 1.30 0.00 0.00 0.01 7.29

Biotite oxides calculationAverage composition (wt%) 28.64 0.00 20.91 23.13 0.00 15.86 0.00 0.00 0.08 88.62Normalized to 100 32.32 0.00 23.60 26.10 0.00 17.89 0.00 0.00 0.09 100.00Bt polygon oxides 2.36 0.00 1.72 1.90 0.00 1.30 0.00 0.00 0.01 7.29

Sum of the oxides to detect new effectively bulck chemistry for isolated D2-polygonDomain Oxides 22.49 0.06 6.39 2.20 0.00 1.49 0.29 0.73 0.78 34.44Normalized to 100 65.31 0.18 18.57 6.38 0.00 4.33 0.85 2.12 2.28 100.00Normalized to 100 (- TiO2)in order to obtain new bulkchemistry

65.42 18.60 6.39 0.00 4.34 0.85 2.12 2.28 100.00

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:42 Pagina 281

Page 26: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

G. Ortolano et al.282

orogeny. With the support of a multivariatestatistical image analysis of X-Ray maps, thisapproach also allowed to reconstruct theprogressive steps of atoll garnet formation duringthe retrograde PT evolution: Atoll garnetformation can be here related to the substitutionof garnet cores during the D2 stage, with theconsumption of garnet cores (grt1) andproduction of a third generation of garnet (grt3).Garnet 3 is in fact concentrated along fractures

or as thin rims around the relic garnet ring inadvanced state of atollization. Grt3 resultedclearly in textural equilibrium with wm3, bi3, qtzand pl3, well preserved within the atoll as a resultof the reaction between the previously formedinclusion-rich garnet inner-core (grt1),interacting with matrix minerals via fluid flowthrough fractures linking the innermost part ofthe garnet with the matrix itself.

The petrographic investigations evidence the

Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

Figure 14. Pseudosections calculated for Me17 using bulk composition determined after evaluation of the volumethat reacted during the D2 event (Table 4b). a) Isopleths for garnet composition in sample Me17; b)pseudosection of sample Me17 with light areas evidencing isopleths intersections for aggregates substitutinggarnet cores.

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:42 Pagina 282

Page 27: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of ... 283

presence of three different garnet generations.The recognition of the stages of garnet growthand the definition of the associated parageneseshas been obtained using image analysis coupledwith compositional maps, performed with adedicated software (Ortolano et al., 2014). Thisapproach allowed: (a) to couple texturalobservation at the microscope, with texturalobservations obtained from compositional mapsand; (b) to individuate a series of garnets that

exemplify different steps of the atoll formation:from garnets preserving intact zonings, togarnets that are partially substituted, to garnetsthat show a completely developed atoll texture.Each of these steps is characterized by peculiarand specific garnet compositions. The observedchanges of mineral phases compositions duringthe progressive steps of the development of theatoll texture and the successive deformationepisodes determining recrystallization of the

Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

Figure 15. Pseudosections calculated for Me02 using bulk composition determined after evaluation of the volumethat reacted during the D2 event (Table 5b): a) Isopleths for garnet composition in sample Me02; b)pseudosection of sample Me02 with light areas evidencing isopleths intersections for aggregates substitutinggarnet cores.

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:42 Pagina 283

Page 28: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

G. Ortolano et al.284

rocks, allowed the reconstruction of themetamorphic history registered by the samples,as well as. the recognition of the mechanisms offormation of atoll structures.

PT conditions associated to the threerecrystallization phases have been determinedfrom pseudosections. Equilibrium volumesduring the different stages of the metamorphicevolution were determined using XRF bulkcompositions for the early garnet growth stagesand by modal analysis via image analysis, for thelate atoll shaped garnet formation.

As a matter of fact, the bulk rock compositionapproximates reasonably the equilibrium volumeof the first stages of recrystallization, permittingto predict the assemblages associated to S1 andS2. In order to determine the compositionrepresenting the equilibrium volume during garnetcore consumption, it was necessary to calculatethe volume representing the part of the thinsection that reacted during this stage, comparingit with the composition of preserved garnet coresand their inclusions, in order to verify thecompatibility of the two compositions. Thiscompatibility supports the textural observationsthat the “atollization” process took place duringD2 and was the result of the transformation ofgarnet cores become instable at the new PTcondition, and possibly substituted by a new, morestable assemblage only along fractures, pathwaysof fluid circulation. Models allow to predict thatthe four analyzed micro-domains from the threemodeled samples share a common evolution, andpreserve evidence of a prograde transformationfrom upper greenschist to amphibolite facies (D1to D2). Peak conditions are represented by late-

D1 parageneses and indicate P = 0.72-0.82 GPaand T = 565-585 °C (Figure 11). Successively adecrease of pressure associated with a slighttemperature increase (P = 0.46-0.70 GPa, T = 500-600 °C), contemporaneous to recrystallization,was attained during the former stages ofexhumation at the end of the Variscan orogeny(Figure 16).

Conclusions

The aim of this work is to constrain thedifferent stages of re-equilibration witnessed bythe selected samples during their PT evolutionby means of the image assisted analysis and, atthe same time, to ascertain which one of theatollization mechanisms suggested in literaturecan be properly invoked. Selected garnetmicaschist nearby Santa Lucia del Mela recorda prograde evolution to amphibolite faciesconditions preserved in garnet cores, followedby decompression associated with slight heatingto lower amphibolite up to greenschist facies(Figure 16). This evolution was constrainedusing thermodynamic modelling of theequilibrium assemblages and isoplethsintersections with the software perplex involumes in which microstructural evidencesindicate the attainment of equilibrium.

The microstructural analysis supplemented bythe use of assisted image analysis allowed therecognition of two stages of a singlemetamorphic cycle. The first one wasresponsible for the garnet formation and can besubdivided in an early stage represented byinclusion-rich garnet cores, followed by a late

Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:42 Pagina 284

Page 29: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of ... 285

stage of euhedral to sub-euhedral garnetovergrowth almost without of inclusions. Thegarnet core grew during D1 accompanied bysimple shear and continued to growth staticallybefore being wrapped by the S2 foliation. Thesecond stage, also developed during a non-coaxial deformational regime is responsible ofthe well developed crenulation schistosity as

well as of the garnet inner core breakdown withthe formation of the atoll shaped structure.

It is likely that in our case the alreadysuggested hypotheses implying selectivedissolution of the cores of pre-existing garnetsmay be compatible with the following evidences:1) the resorption of a Sps-rich core and thesuccessive formation of a Mn-rich garnet, related

Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

Figure 16. Reconstruction of the final P-T path reporting the sequential stages of atoll-garnet formation.

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:42 Pagina 285

Page 30: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

G. Ortolano et al.286

to fluid circulation associated with garnet-coredissolution, and concentrated along fractures; 2)the composition of the last garnet, correspondsto the sum of the relic Mn-rich inner core plusthe overgrowing zone of the new rim; 3) in thethird stage of atollization the presence of thisnew rim is recognizable also in the inner portionof the relic garnet, which clearly points to thefact that the observed chemical pattern cannot bethe result of a multiple coalescence nor a changein the stoichiometry of the reactions that lead tothe transition from a poykilitic core to aneuhedral rim devoid of inclusions.

Acknowledgements

This work has benefited from the constructivesuggestions of several colleagues among whichP. Fiannacca and R. Punturo. Special thanks toAntonio Pezzino for his precious guide on thegeology and petrology of the PeloritaniMountains and to Giuseppe Guzzetta for hismeticulous and critical reading of the paper.Richard Spiess, Martin Robyr and María D. RuizCruz meticulous reviews improved the originalmanuscript and gave us many more occasions ofdiscussion.

References

Amodio Morelli L., Bonardi G., Colonna V., DietrichD., Giunta G., Ippolito F., Liguori V., Lorenzoni S.,Paglionico A., Perrone V., Piccarreta G., Russo M.,Scandone P., Zanettin Lorenzoni E. and Zuppetta A.(1976) - L’Arco Calabro-Peloritano nell’orogeneappenninico-maghrebide. Memorie della SocietàGeologica Italiana, 17, 1-60.

Ague J.J. and Carlson W.D. (2013) - Metamorphismas Garnet Sees It: The kinetics of nucleation and

growth, equilibration, and diffusional relaxation.Elements, 9, 439-445.

Angì G., Cirrincione R., Fazio E., Fiannacca P.,Ortolano G. and Pezzino A. (2010) - Metamorphicevolution of preserved Hercynian crustal section inthe Serre Massif (Calabria-Peloritani Orogen,southern Italy). Lithos, 115, 237-262.

Arenas R., Abati J., Martinez Catalan J.R., DiazGarcia F. and Rubio Pascual F.J. (1997) - P-Tevolution of eclogites from the Agualada Unit(Ordenes Complex, northwest Iberian Massif,Spain): Implications for crustal subduction. Lithos,40, 221-242.

Atherton M.P. and Edmunds W.M. (1966) - Anelectron microprobe study ofsome zoned garnetsfrom metamorphic rocks. Earth Planetary ScienceLetters,1, 185-193.

Atzori P. and D’Amico C. (1972) - Rapporti tra gneissocchiadini e filladi a Savoca (Peloritani, Sicilia).Mineralogica et Petrographica Acta, 18, 83-96.

Bonnet N. (1995) - Processing of images and imageseries: A tutorial review for chemical microanalysis.Mikrochimica Acta, 120, 195-210.

Bonnet N. (1998) - Multivariate statistical methods forthe analysis of microscope image series:applications in material science. Journal ofMicroscopy, 190, 2-18.

Cella F., Cirrincione R., Critelli S., Mazzoleni P.,Pezzino A., Punturo R., Fedi M. and Rapolla A.(2004) - Gravity Modeling in Fold-Thrust Belts: AnExample from the Peloritani Mountains, SouthernItaly. International Geological Review, 46 (11),1042-1050.

Cirrincione R. and Pezzino A. (1991) - Caratteristrutturali dell’evento Alpino nella serie mesozoicadi Alì e nell’Unità metamorfica di Mandanici(Peloritani Orientali). Memorie della SocietàGeologica Italiana, 47, 263-272.

Cirrincione R., Atzori P. and Pezzino A.(1999) - Sub-greenschist facies assemblages of metabasites inSouth-Eastern sector of Peloritani range.Mineralogy and Petrology, 67, 193-212.

Cirrincione R., Ortolano G., Pezzino A. and PunturoR. (2008) - Poly-orogenic multi-stage metamorphicevolution inferred via P–T pseudosections: anexample from Aspromonte Massif basement rocks(Southern Calabria, Italy). Lithos, 103, 466-502.

Cirrincione R., Fazio E., Ortolano G., Pezzino A. andPunturo R. (2012) - Fault-related rocks as a tool for

Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:42 Pagina 286

Page 31: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of ... 287

the comprehension of structural and metamorphicevolution of an accretionary wedge in a collisionalbelt (Peloritani Mountains, NE Sicily).International Geological Review, 54, 940-956.

Cheng H., Nakamura E., Kobayashi K. and Zhou Z.(2007) - Origin of atoll garnets in eclogites andimplications for the redistribution of trace elementsduring slab exhumation in a continental subductionzone. American Mineralogist, 92, 1119-1129.

Connolly J.A.D. (2005) - Computation of phaseequilibria by linear programming: a tool forgeodynamic modeling and its application tosubduction zone decarbonation. Earth PlanetaryScience Letters, 236, 524-541.

Connolly J.A.D. and Petrini K. (2002) - An automatedstrategy for calculation of phase diagram sectionsand retrieval of rock properties as a function ofphysical conditions. Journal of MetamorphicGeology, 20, 697-708.

Cooper A.F. (1972) - Progressive metamorphism ofmetabasic rocks from the Haast Schist Group ofsouthern New Zealand. Journal of Petrology, 13,457-492.

de Capitani C. and Petrakakis K. (2010) - Thecomputation of equilibrium assemblage diagramswith Theriak/Domino software. AmericanMineralogist, 95 (7), 1006-1016.

Dobbs H.T., Peruzzo L., Seno F., Spiess R. and PriorD.J. (2003) - Unravelingthe Schneeberg garnetpuzzle. A numerical model of multiple nucleationand coalescence. Contriution of Mineralogy andPetrology, 146, 1-9.

Cossio R. and Borghi A. (1998) - PETROMAP: MS-DOS software package 1 for quantitative processingof X-ray maps of zoned minerals. Computers andGeosciences, 24, 797-803.

Cossio R., Borghi A. and Ruffini R. (2002) -Quantitative modal determination of geologicalsamples based on X-ray multielemental mapacquisition. Microscopy and Microanalysis, 8, 139-149.

Dainelli N., Bonechi F., Spagnolo M. and Canessa A.(2010) - Cartografia numerica: Manuale pratico perl’utilizzo dei GIS. Dario Flaccovio, Palermo, 372 pp.

De Andrade V., Vidal O., Lewin E., O’Brien P. andAgard P. (2006) - Quantification of electronmicroprobe compositional maps of rock thinsections: an optimized method and examples.Journal of Metamatical Geology, 24, 655-668.

Evans T.P. (2004) - A method for calculating effectivebulk composition modification due to crystalfractionation in garnet-bearing schists: implicationsfor isopleths thermobarometry. Journal ofMetamorphic Geology, 22, 547-557.

Faryad S.W., Klápová H. and Nosál L. (2010) -Mechanism of formation of atoll garnet duringhigh-pressure metamorphism. MineralogicalMagazine, 74, 111-126.

Ferla P. (2000) - A model of continental crustalevolution in the geological history of the PeloritaniMountains (Sicily). Memorie della SocietàGeologica Italiana, 55, 87-93.

Festa V., Messina A., Paglionico A., Piccarreta G. andRottura A. (2004) - Pre-Triassic history recorded inthe Calabria-Peloritani segment of the Alpine chain,southern Italy. An overview. Periodico diMineralogia, 73, 57-71.

Fiannacca P., Williams I.S., Cirrincione R. andPezzino A. (2008) - Crustal contributions to Late-Hercynian peraluminous magmatism in theSouthern Calabria-Peloritani Orogen, SouthernItaly: petrogenetic inferences and the Gondwanaconnection. Journal of Petrology, 49, 1497-1514.

Fiannacca P., Lo Po’ D., Ortolano G., Cirrincione R.and Pezzino A. (2012) - Thermodynamic modelingassisted by multivariate statistical image analysis asa tool for unraveling metamorphic P T-d evolution:an example from ilmenite-garnet-bearing metapeliteof the Peloritani Mountains, Southern Italy.Mineralogy and Petrology, 106 (3-4), 151-171.

Flesche H., Nielsen A.A. and Larsen R. (2000) -Supervised mineral classification with semi-automatic training and validation set generation inscanning electron microscope energy dispersivespectroscopy images of thin sections. MathematicalGeology 32, 337-366.

Friel J.J. and Lyman C.E. (2006) - X-ray mapping inelectron-beam instruments. Microscopy andMicroanalysis, 12, 2-25.

Hibraim A.A. (2012) - Formation of Atoll Garnets inthe Banded Iron Formation of Maru Schist Belt.American International Journal of ContemporaryResearch, 2 (5), 210-221.

Holland T.J.B. and Powell R. (1998) - An internallyconsistent thermodynamic data set for phases ofpetrological interest. Journal of MetamorphicGeology, 16, 309-343.

Holland T., Baker J. and Powell R. (1998) - Mixing

Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:42 Pagina 287

Page 32: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

G. Ortolano et al.288

properties and activity-composition relationships ofchlorites in the system MgO-FeO-Al2O3-SiO2-H2O.European Journal of Mineralogy, 10, 395-406.

Hollister L.S. (1966) - Garnet zoning: an interpretationbased on the Rayleigh fractionation model Science,154, 1647-1651.

Homam S.M. (2003) - Formation of atoll garnet in theArdara aureole, NW Ireland. Journal of Sciences,Islamic Republic of Iran, 14, 247-258.

Homam S.M. (2006) - The occurrence and origin ofatoll garnet in hornblende schists from the contactaureole of the Mashhadgranite, NE Iran. IranianJournal of Science and Technology, 30, 127-132.

Lanari P., Vidal O., De Andrade V., Dubacq B., Lewin,E., Grosch E. and Schwartz S. (2014) - XMapTools:a MATLAB©-based program for electronmicroprobe Xray image processing andgeothermobarometry. Computers and Geosciences,62, 227-240.

Launeau P., Cruden A.R. and Bouchez J.L. (1994) -Mineral recognition in digital images of rocks: anew approach using multichannel classification.Canadian Mineralogist, 32, 919-933.

Messina A., Somma R., Macaione E., Carbone G. andCareri G. (2004) - Peloritani Continental CrustComposition (Southern Italy): geological andpetrochemical evidence. Bollettino della SocietàGeologica Italiana, 123, 405-441.

Newton R.C., Charlu T.V. and Kleppa O.J. (1980) -Thermochemistry of the high structural stateplagioclases. Geochemica et Cosmochimica Acta,44, 933-41.

Ortolano G., Zappalà L., Mazzoleni P., (2014) - X-RayMap Analyzer: a new ArcGIS® based tool for thequantitative statistical data handling of X-ray maps(Geo- and material-science applications).Computers and Geosciences, 72, 49-64.

Passchier C.W. and Trouw R.A.J. (1998) -Microtectonics. Springer, Berlin, 289 pp.

Pezzino A., Pannucci S., Puglisi G., Atzori P., IoppoloS. and Lo Giudice A. (1990) - Geometry andmetamorphic environment of the contact betweenthe Aspromonte-Peloritani Unit (Upper Unit) andMadonna dei Polsi Unit (Lower Unit) in the centralAspromonte area (Calabria). Bollettino dellaSocietà Geologica Italiana, 109, 455-469.

Piluso E., Cirrincione R. and Morten L. (2000) -Ophiolites of the Calabrian Peloritan Arc and theirrelationships with the crystalline basement (Catena

Costiera and Sila Piccola, Calabria, Southern Italy)in GLOM 2000 Excursion Guide-Book. Ofioliti, 25(2), 117-140.

Puglisi G. and Pezzino A. (1994) - Metamorphism inthe central Aspromonte area: geological,mineralogical and petrogenetic relationships.Periodico di Mineralogia, 63, 153-168.

Richard L.R. (1995) - Minpet: Mineralogical andPetrological Data Processing System, version 2.02.MinPet Geological Software, Quebec, Canada.

Robyr M., Vonlanthen P., Baumgartner L.P. andGrobety B. (2007) - Growth mechanism of snowballgarnets from the Lukmanier Pass area (Central Alps,Switzerland): A combined µCT/EPMA/EBSDstudy. Terra Nova, 19 (4), 240-244.

Robyr M., Carlson W.D., Passchier C. andVonlanthenP. (2009) - Microstructural, chemical and texturalrecords during growth of snowball garnet. Journalof Metamorphic Geology, 27, 423-437.

Robyr M., Darbellay B. and Baumgartner L.P. (2014)- Matrix-dependent garnet growth inpolymetamorphic rocks of the Sesia zone, ItalianAlps. Journal of Metamorphic Geology, 32, 3-24.

Rottura A., Bargossi G.M., Caironi V., Del Moro A.,Maccarrone E.,Macera P., Paglionico A., Petrini R.,Piccarreta G. and Poli G. (1990) - Petrogenesis ofcontrasting Hercynian granitoids from the CalabrianArc, southern Italy. Lithos, 24, 97-119.

Ruiz Cruz M.D. (2011) - Origin of atollgarnet inschists from the Alpujarride Complex (Central zoneof the Betic Cordillera, Spain): Implications on theP-T evolution. Mineralogy and Petrology, 101, 3-4, 245-261.

Smellie J.A.T. (1974) - Formation of atoll garnetsfrom the aureole of the Ardara pluton, Co. Donegal,Ireland. Mineralogical Magazine, 39, 878-888.

Smellie J.A.T. (1989) - Atoll garnet. In: Browes D.R.(Ed.) The Encyclopedia of Igneous andMetamorphic Petrology. Van Nostrand Reinhold,New York, 42-43.

Spear F.S. (1993) - Metamorphic Phase Equilibria andPressure-Temperature-Time Paths. MineralogicalSociety of America, Washington, D.C. 799 pp.

Spiess R., Peruzzo L., Prior D.J. and Wheeler J. (2001)- Development of garnet porphyroblasts by multiplenucleation, coalescence and boundarymisorientation driven rotations. Journal ofMetamorphic Geology, 19, 269-290.

Tajcmanová L., Connolly J.A.D. and Cesare B. (2009)

Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:42 Pagina 288

Page 33: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of ... 289

- A thermodynamic model for titanium and ferriciron solution in biotite. Journal of MetamorphicGeology, 27, 153-64.

Tinkham D., Zuluaga C.A. and Stowell, H.H. (2001)- Metapelite phase equilibria modeling inMnNCKFMASH: The effect of variable Al2O3 andMgO/(MgO+FeO) on mineral stability. GeologicalMaterials Research, 3 (1), 1-42.

Tracy R.J. (1982) - Compositional zoning andinclusions in metamorphic minerals. Reviews inMineralogy, 10, 355-397.

von Raumer J.F., Stampfli G.M., Borel G. and BussyF. (2002) - The organization of pre-Variscanbasement areas at the north-Gondwanan margin.International Journal of Earth Sciences, 91, 35-52.

Zuluaga C.A., Stowell H.H. and Tinkham D.K. (2005)- The effect of zoned garnet on metapelitepseudosection topology and calculatedmetamorphic P-T paths. American Mineralogist, 90,1619-1628.

Submitted, May 2014 - Accepted, September 2014

Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:42 Pagina 289

Page 34: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

G. Ortolano et al.290 Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

Tabl

e A1.

Rep

rese

ntat

ive

min

eral

ana

lysi

s of g

arne

t.

Sam

ple

Me1

7Sa

m3

Zone

RIC

RO

CN

RR

ICR

OC

RR

NR

SiO

237

.73

37.7

537

.66

37.8

537

.59

38.4

537

.66

TiO

20.

210.

120.

200.

210.

170.

180.

2A

l 2O3

21.1

821

.13

20.7

821

.23

21.2

721

.30

20.7

8C

r 2O

30.

120.

120.

300.

180.

060.

120.

3Fe

OTo

t26

.48

30.3

728

.51

26.0

530

.19

28.5

628

.51

MnO

4.25

1.81

7.22

4.64

2.38

3.65

7.22

MgO

1.39

3.12

2.41

1.39

2.77

2.14

2.41

CaO

7.86

4.91

2.80

8.20

5.02

5.37

2.8

Tota

l99

.22

99.3

399

.88

99.7

599

.45

99.7

799

.88

Si3.

044

3.03

03.

041

3.03

63.

023.

086

3.04

1A

lIV0

00

00

00

Sum

_T3.

044

3.03

03.

041

3.03

63.

023.

086

3.04

1A

lVI

2.01

21.

997

1.97

62.

006

2.01

22.

013

1.97

6Fe

30

00

00

00

Ti0.

013

0.00

70.

012

0.01

30.

010

0.01

10.

012

Cr

0.00

80.

008

0.01

90.

011

0.00

40.

008

0.01

9Su

m_A

2.03

32.

012

2.00

72.

032.

026

2.03

22.

007

Fe2

1.78

72.

039

1.92

51.

748

2.02

81.

917

1.92

5M

g0.

167

0.37

30.

290

0.16

60.

332

0.25

60.

290

Mn

0.29

0.12

30.

494

0.31

50.

162

0.24

80.

494

Ca

0.67

90.

422

0.24

20.

705

0.43

20.

462

0.24

2Su

m_B

2.92

42.

957

2.95

22.

934

2.95

42.

883

2.95

2Su

m_C

at8

88

88

88

Num

ber o

f O2

1212

1212

1212

12A

lm61

.109

68.9

3665

.232

59.5

6668

.661

66.4

9465

.232

Grs

22.8

4613

.892

7.23

423

.438

14.4

3315

.622

7.23

4Pr

p5.

718

12.6

249.

829

5.66

611

.230

8.88

29.

829

Sps

9.93

44.

161

16.7

3110

.746

5.48

28.

607

16.7

31U

vr0.

393

0.38

60.

973

0.58

40.

193

0.39

60.

973

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:42 Pagina 290

Page 35: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of ... 291Appendix A

Rep

rese

ntat

ive

min

eral

che

mis

try a

naly

sis f

or g

arne

t, ilm

enite

, pla

gioc

lase

, bio

tite,

whi

te m

ica

and

chlo

rite.

Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

Tabl

e A2.

Rep

rese

ntat

ive

min

eral

ana

lysi

s of i

lmen

ite a

nd p

lagi

ocla

se.

Ilmen

itePl

agio

clas

eSa

mpl

eM

e17

Me1

7Sa

m3

Me0

2Zo

neIn

clus

ion

With

in a

toll

Mat

rixW

ithin

ato

llW

ithin

ato

llPs

eudo

mor

phos

isSi

O2

0.00

0.00

62.0

859

.77

57.2

965

.11

TiO

251

.51

54.0

20.

000.

000.

000.

00A

l 2O3

0.00

0.00

23.9

825

.53

27.6

822

.08

FeO

Tot

46.5

543

.30.

000.

000.

000.

00M

nO1.

292.

520.

000.

000.

000.

00M

gO0.

640.

160.

000.

000.

000.

00C

aO0.

000.

008.

137.

127.

422.

98N

a 2O

0.00

0.00

5.16

7.16

6.68

8.86

K2O

0.00

0.00

0.00

0.00

0.00

0.00

Tota

l10

010

099

.35

99.5

899

.21

99.2

1Si

0.00

00.

000

2.75

52.

668

2.57

42.

872

Al

0.00

00.

000

1.25

31.

342

1.46

41.

147

Fe3

0.00

00.

000

0.00

00.

000

0.00

00.

000

Ti1.

962

2.03

40.

000

0.00

00.

000

0.00

0Fe

21.

972

1.81

30.

000

0.00

00.

000

0.00

0M

g0.

048

0.01

20.

000

0.00

00.

000

0.00

0C

a0.

000

0.00

00.

387

0.34

00.

357

0.14

1M

n0.

055

0.10

70.

000

0.00

00.

000

0.00

0N

a0.

000

0.00

00.

444

0.62

00.

594

0.75

8K

0.00

00.

000

0.00

00.

000

0.00

00.

000

Sum

_Cat

4.03

73.

966

4.83

94.

974.

989

4.93

1A

b53

.40

64.6

62.5

84.3

An

46.6

035

.437

.515

.7

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:42 Pagina 291

Page 36: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

G. Ortolano et al.292 Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297Ta

ble A

3. R

epre

sent

ativ

e m

iner

al a

naly

sis o

f bio

tite,

whi

te m

ica

and

chlo

rite.

biot

itew

hite

mic

ach

lorit

eSa

mpl

eM

e17

Sam

3M

e02

Me1

7M

e02

Zone

Mat

rixW

ithin

ato

llW

ithin

ato

llPs

eudo

mor

phos

isM

atrix

With

in a

toll

Mat

rixPs

eudo

mor

phos

isSi

O2

36.4

441

.71

39.6

539

.30

48.3

47.5

626

.68

28.4

3Ti

O2

1.53

0.92

0.9

0.27

0.67

0.67

0.00

0.00

Al 2O

319

.59

22.3

822

.86

20.8

34.1

436

.32

23.3

520

.88

FeO

Tot

17.8

59.

4514

.77

19.2

70.

960.

8721

.85

24.4

5M

nO0.

140.

090.

20.

000.

000.

000.

000.

00M

gO11

.17

14.0

213

.62

13.0

41.

240.

7216

.82

15.4

4N

a 2O

0.20

0.44

0.82

0.00

0.90

1.21

0.00

0.00

K2O

8.42

7.13

3.04

4.36

9.43

9.04

0.00

0.00

Tota

l95

.33

96.1

495

.86

97.0

595

.64

96.3

988

.70

89.2

0Si

2.84

93.

031

2.91

12.

928

3.17

23.

094

5.41

35.

800

AlIV

1.15

10.

969

1.08

91.

071

0.82

80.

906

2.58

72.

220

AlV

I0.

653

0.94

70.

888

0.75

61.

818

1.87

72.

993

2.81

7Ti

0.09

00.

050

0.05

00.

015

0.03

30.

003

0.00

00.

000

Fe2

1.16

70.

574

0.90

71.

205

0.05

30.

047

3.70

84.

172

Mg

1.30

21.

519

1.49

11.

454

0.12

10.

070

5.08

84.

696

Mn

0.00

90.

006

0.01

20.

000.

000

0.00

00.

000

0.00

0N

a0.

030

0.06

20.

117

0.00

0.11

50.

153

0.00

00.

000

K0.

839

0.66

10.

285

0.41

40.

790

0.75

00.

000

0.00

0Su

m_C

at8.

090

7.81

97.

750

7.84

66.

924

6.93

019

.789

19.6

85N

umbe

r of O

212

1212

1212

1236

36X

Mg

0.53

0.73

0.62

0.54

0.70

0.60

0.58

0.53

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:42 Pagina 292

Page 37: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of ... 293

Appendix B

Graphical representation of the sequence of the image analysis procedure: BSE (Back ScatteredElectron image); PCA1 (Principal Component Analysis for the first analytical cycle); MLC1/2(Maximum Likelihood Classification for the first and second analytical cycle, respectively).

Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:42 Pagina 293

Page 38: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

G. Ortolano et al.294

Appendix C

Quantitative extrapolation of the volume percentage of the inclusions within first and second garnetgrowth generation in the samples Me17 (microdomain a) and sample Sam3 by means of map algebrafunctions.

Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:42 Pagina 294

Page 39: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of ... 295

Appendix D

Compositional ranges and ternary diagram of the garnet growth stages for each three selectedgarnet microdomain: RIC (Relic Inner Core - red); ROC (Relic Outer Core - blue); RR (Relic Rim -green); NR (New Rim - grey).

Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:42 Pagina 295

Page 40: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

G. Ortolano et al.296 Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:42 Pagina 296

Page 41: PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of peculiar zoning pattern in atoll shaped garnets via image assisted analysis: an example from the Santa Lucia del Mela garnet micaschists (northeastern

PT-path reconstruction via unraveling of ... 297Periodico di Mineralogia (2014), 83, 2, 257-297

ortolano_periodico 25/09/14 10:42 Pagina 297