Primeiras Jornadas de Análise do Discurso : JADIS I 12 & 13 de dezembro 2011. Are you being served? The discourse of service encounters in Portuguese produced ELT coursebooks. Nicolas Hurst, The Department of Anglo-American Studies, The Faculty of Letters, The University of Porto. http://web.letras.up.pt/nrhurst/
21
Embed
Primeiras Jornadas de Análise do Discurso JADIS I 12 & 13 ...web.letras.up.pt/nrhurst/JADIS I NRH 12.12.2011.pdf · Primeiras Jornadas de Análise do Discurso : JADIS I ... crossword
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Primeiras Jornadas de Análise do Discurso : JADIS I 12 & 13 de dezembro 2011.
Are you being served? The discourse of service encounters
in Portuguese produced ELT coursebooks.
Nicolas Hurst,
The Department of Anglo-American Studies,
The Faculty of Letters,
The University of Porto.
http://web.letras.up.pt/nrhurst/
Motivation for this study:
“Materials aimed at explicit learning usually contrive examples of language which focus on the feature to be taught. Usually these examples are presented in short, easy texts or dialogues and it is argued that they help the learner by focussing attention on the target feature.”
Tomlinson, B. in Carter, R. & Nunan, D. 2001: 68.
One of the first books I ever used
(in 1982!!)
Paperback: 160 pages
Publisher: Longman (September 1967)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 058252329X
ISBN-13: 978-0582523296
The present study: the Extreme series
The books by Belita Carlo Almeida, Edite Frias & Elisabete Caldas Almeida cover the national programme of English for ‘3º ciclo do ensino básico’ (7º, 8º e 9º anos), published by Porto Editora.
2004 2005 2006
The use of dialogues in the “Extreme” series of coursebooks 7th grade: 2004 8th grade: 2005 9th grade: 2006
p.41 Conversation 2 adults Exchange style: informal exchanges Turns: 9 Topic: gossip about family neighbours L2 work: possessive adjectives Task type: gap filling
p.15 interview with a doctor Exchange Style: Q &A Turns: 14 Topic: acne/growing up L2 work: vocabulary + comprehension Task type: matching pictures and vocabulary
p.71 interview with a student Exchange Style: Q &A Turns: 10 Topic: careers and school life L2 work: past simple tense Task type: gap filling
p.61 interview with a street luger Exchange Style: Q &A Turns: 17 Topic: radical sports L2 work: listening comprehension + vocabulary Task type: gap filling + definition matching
* p.17 follow-up to the above
3 mini-role plays/dialogues to “act” about teen dilemmas
The use of dialogues in the “Extreme” series of coursebooks
7th grade: 2004 8th grade: 2005 9th grade: 2006
p.41 Conversation 2 adults
Exchange style: informal exchanges Turns: 9
Topic: gossip about family neighbours
L2 work: possessive adjectives
Task type: gap filling
pp.30/31 interview with a travel agent
Exchange Style: Q &A Turns: 16
Topic: Ecotours
L2 work: vocabulary + comprehension
Task type: crossword + sentence completions
p.15 interview with a doctor
Exchange Style: Q &A Turns: 14
Topic: acne/growing up
L2 work: vocabulary + comprehension
Task type: matching pictures and vocabulary
p.71 interview with a student
Exchange Style: Q &A Turns: 10
Topic: careers and school life
L2 work: past simple tense
Task type: gap filling
p.61 interview with a street luger
Exchange Style: Q &A Turns: 17
Topic: radical sports
L2 work: listening comprehension + vocabulary
Task type: gap filling + definition matching
* p.17 follow-up to the above
3 mini-role plays/dialogues to “act”
about teen dilemmas
p.105 Conversation 2 teens
Exchange Style: Q&A Turns: 4
Topic: CDs
L2 work: possessive pronouns
Task type: gap filling
Unit 1 opening “chat”
p.14
3 turns on holidays and space
travel
Unit 4 opening “chat”
p.102
3 turns on eating disorders
p.91 Guided dialogues x 2
Exchange Style: informal exchanges Turns: 9
Topic: unemployment
L2 work: exponents of emotions
Task type: role play
p.124 service encounter: shop
Exchange Style: Q &A + comments Turns: 20
Topic: buying trainers
L2 work: mixed functions + Q-tags
Task type: text search + gap filling
Unit 2 opening “chat”
p.40
3 turns on sports and good
health
Unit 5 opening “chat”
p.126
3 turns on films and radio
CATEGORIES:
Page number + type of dialogue
Exchange style
Number of turns
Topic
L2 work
Task type
p.130 service encounter: restaurant
Exchange Style: Q &A + comments Turns: 24
Topic: choosing/ordering food
L2 work: comprehension + some/any/no
Task type: sentence completion + gap filling
Unit 3 opening “chat”
p.72
5 turns on shopping and fashion
victims
Unit 6 opening “chat”
p.152
5 turns on gaming and
technology
p.140 Conversation 2 adults
Topic: holidays Turns: 13
Exchange Style: informal exchanges
L2 work: comprehension + vocabulary
Task type: chart filling + synonyms
Gilmore (2004): nine discourse features of spoken language in service encounters.
1. Length of ‘text’ 2. Lexical density
3. False starts 4. Repetitions
5. Pauses 6. Terminal overlap
7. Latching 8. Hesitation devices
9. Back channels
[article seeking to compare real interactions with dialogues in Japanese coursebooks: ELT Journal 58/4]
1. LENGTH OF TEXT T.1 = 16 turns: 138 words
Average: 8.6 words per turn
Info.Giver: 7.1 words per turn
Info.Getter: 7.4 words per turn
T.2 = 24 turns: 251 words
Average: 10.5 words per turn
Info.Giver: 6.6 words per turn
Info.Getter: 14.3 words per turn
2. LEXICAL DENSITY LD = 100 x Lexical words/Total
T.1
LD = 36.9%
Lower figures consistent with spoken texts
-» Language graded by writers for 7th grade?
-» more explicit language = more concrete lexis?
-» reduced processing load to increase ease of comprehension?
T.2
LD = 32.3%
3. FALSE STARTS
T.1
No examples
T.2
No examples
4. REPETITIONS
T.1
No examples
T.2
Mobiez.3: Are you trying to tell us there’s no pizza??!! …
Waiter.7: I’m sorry but there’s no pizza.
&
Waiter.11: Here are the steaks. Rare, as you asked.
Mobiez.7: Rare? We said well-done. And they’re so small …
5. PAUSES
T.1
No examples
T.2
Waiter.2: Certainly … Here you are.
Mobiez.2: I see … Well, I’m sure there some pizza
6. TERMINAL OVERLAP
T.1
No examples
T.2
No examples
7. LATCHING Difficult to determine, but perhaps:
T.1
Shop Assistant.3: Very well. What size do you take?
Scott.3: Size 8, please.
or
Shop Assistant.4: And what colour would you like?
Scott.4: Black.
T.2
Waiter.3: Are you ready to order?
Scott.2: Yes, we are. We would like …
or
Scott.2: … the tomato soup for a starter and Lasagna Verdi for the main course.
Mobiez.1: And two cokes to drink, please.
8. HESITATION DEVICES
T.1
No examples
T.2
Scott.3: Hum … Could we have Spaghetti Bolognese, then?
Waiter.6: Well …
9 .BACK CHANNELS
T.1
No examples
T.2
No examples
Displaying Gilmore’s features?
1. Length of ‘text’ ARTIFICIAL BUT QUITE ACCURATE
2. Lexical density APPROXIMATE BUT NOT RIGHT
3. False starts NONE
4. Repetitions TWO EXAMPLES ONLY IN 40 TURNS
5. Pauses NONE
6. Terminal overlap NONE
7. Latching DIFFICULT TO IDENTIFY
8. Hesitation devices TWO EXAMPLES IN 40 TURNS
9. Back channels NONE
Discourse derived implications
“The language in some coursebooks represents a ‘can do’ society in which interaction is generally smooth and problem free, … the conversation is neat, tidy and predictable.”
Carter, 1998: 47
“If our goal is to prepare learners for independent language use … we are obliged at some stage to present them with realistic models of discourse, messy and unpredictable as it is”
Gilmore, 2004: 367
Conclusions: “The contrived materials of traditional textbooks have often presented learners with a meagre, and frequently distorted, sample of the target language to work with and have failed to meet many of their communicative needs. Authentic materials, particularly audio-visual ones, offer a much richer source of input for learners and have the potential to be exploited in different ways at different levels to develop the learners’ communicative competence.”
Gilmore, 2007: 103 “… the language used in EFL coursebooks has been based on an idealised native speaker’ model, existing above regional varieties and cultures (Alptekin, 2002). Such a native speaker, though, is a non-existent abstraction. … Unless coursebooks expose learners to real language, it will be impossible to foster communicative and sociolinguistic competence.”
Thanasoulas, 2005:30
Thank you for being here
If you’d like to discuss any of the issues raised in this talk, please contact me,