Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual Conference September 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia “Informal Complaint Resolution” Irene Clarke, Katja Lutte, Cheryl McDougall College of Physicians & Surgeons of Ontario Expect the Unexpected: Are We Clearly Prepared?
46
Embed
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual Conference September 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia “Informal Complaint Resolution” Irene Clarke, Katja Lutte, Cheryl McDougall.
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
“Informal Complaint Resolution”
Irene Clarke, Katja Lutte, Cheryl McDougall
College of Physicians & Surgeons of Ontario
Expect the Unexpected: Are We Clearly Prepared?
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Framework for Resolution
• Backdrop
• Past Processes
• Current Processes
• Case Examples
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Issues Involved in Public Complaint Investigations
5
5
6
16
36
63
65
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70
Communication issues
Care issues
Conduct and behaviour issues
Records / Report issues
Financial issues
Consent issues
Sexual Abuse
% of time
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Committee Resolutions 100 cases
Outcome Agreement – 20% No Agreement – 80%
WhyComplainants
Process starts too late (after 1 year) Process too slow (6-12mo) Lawyer involvement
Physicians Process too slow Mediator: no clinical knowledge
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Informal Staff Resolution1997-2001
Complainants consented to resolution
Via phone or letter Patient Records Written Physician Response Written information
Committee Chair Approval
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Informal Staff Resolutions Results -2001
40% vs. 20% resolve
157 days vs. 547 + days
$500,000 vs $600,000
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Complaints Process Survey2001
Telephone Interviews
Satisfaction Indicators process quality outcome
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Complaints Process Survey 2001
Satisfaction Level Desired Outcome
TimeContinual CommunicationInvestigator with clinical knowledge
Resolution vs. Decision
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Current Process
2001 – present
Proactive Staff Resolution
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Complaints Per Area of Practice
Others(22% )
General Practice(49% )
Psychiatry(6% )
Obstetrics and Gynaecology
(6% )
InternalMedicine
(6% )
Orthopaedic Surgery(4% ) Paediatrics
(2% )
GeneralSurgery(5% )
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Proactive Staff Resolution
Designated Staff
nurses, physiotherapists, social workers
Withsignificant clinical practice background management or teaching experience know health care system
Can communicate
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Investigator on Call
Calls from our general inquiries area
letters
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Investigator on Call2005
366 telephone inquiries forwarded to on-call investigators;
26 converted to complaints.
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Investigator on Call2005
145 letters earmarked for on call resolution
9 converted to formal complaint
(of those 9, 6 were resolved pre-committee review)
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Resolution Criteria
misunderstanding or miscommunication;
a known or common complication of a treatment/procedure;
an isolated incident of less serious conduct unbecoming a physician (i.e. not sexual abuse);
assistance to intervene beyond our jurisdiction;
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Resolution Criteria
isolated incident of minor clinical mishap or oversight;
systems issue;
complainants indicate their wish to resolve;
complainant and respondent have agreed to the resolution process;
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
No Resolution When …
serious concern regarding clinical practice and/or conduct;
the complainant and/or subject physician are not receptive to resolution
the subject physician has a history of complaints pointing to a trend toward conduct or care that was inappropriate;
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
What Investigators Do
Telephone/MeetComplaint as a “whole” Records Provide Context Physician Verbal Response
Joint meeting
Medical Director Approval
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
What They Do
Joint Resolution with Hospitals
MeetComplainantPhysician/sChief of StaffPatient Rep
Records available at meeting
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
What are Key Actions?
Speedy assignment/ and contact Establish rapport with both parties Updates Language Paperless process ‘See’ care in records Collaborate with Chiefs of Staff Systems Approach Appreciation Letter
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
What Makes it Work? Complainant open to explanation Complainant wants ‘error’ fixed Physician open to explaining Physician willing to acknowledge No Lawyers Investigator Flexibility
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
How Did We Do?2004
58% resolved (up from 40%)
62% resolved
65 days (down from 157 days)
$315,000 (down from $500,000)
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Benefits
Support for Process CMPA Chiefs of Staff Hospital Risk Managers/Patient Reps Individual Physicians
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Benefits
Educational Value System Improvements
Increase in satisfaction for all parties, including investigators
Positive College Image
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Benefits
Patient Safety (Lucian Leape, MD)Responding to the patientWhat do patients want? 1. Know what happened (98%)2. Receive an apology3. Be assured the hospital/doctor is doing
all that can be done to prevent a recurrence
**$ is way down the list of patient “wants”
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Benefits
Patient Safety (Leape)The power of silence - destroys the patient’s trust - destroys the physician’s
integrity - “wall of silence” is
devastating for patients
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Fools rush in where angels fear to thread
• Cannot compel physicians to apologize
• Can ask or convey the complainant’s wish for an apology
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Negotiating an Apology
• The complainant request apology and the physician volunteers to apologize
• The complainant wants an apology and the physician needs encouragement
• No request for apology, but one would be the best way to resolve a complaint
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Myth: Apology = Admitting Guilt
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Apology without implied guilt
• I apologize if my behavior…• I apologize for causing you to
believe I was angry• Please forgive me if I offended you,
it was not my intention
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Components of suitable apology letter
• Apologizes/regrets the behavior• Explains what happens• Conveys sincerity by expressing
remorse and displaying empathy• Reflects on the learning
experience• Reiterates regrets and apology
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Apology Busters
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Wrapping it up
• Ask the physician to cc me on letter• One to two weeks after letter sent, I
contact the complainant to discuss• Obtain agreement to close the file• Obtain authorization to close the file
from the medical director• Notify physician and complainant of
closure
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Example # 1
• 28 years of age, TB, previously healthy
• Same Dr. for extended family• Pt so stigmatize, she can’t ever
utter “T.B.” – “ I have a disease”• In following up the contacts, the
secretary confirms the identity of the index case to a family member
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Example # 1 (cont’d)
• The complainant wants the Dr. to be disciplined and to apologize (LOC)
• The Dr. was very stressed about the complaint, wanted to apologize, did not know how to begin
• A sample letter was provided
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Example #2
• 16 year old in ER with back pain, swollen abdomen, urine positive for pregnancy, the nurse hears fetal heart beat, patient never had sexual relations
• Patient told she is pregnant, in denial• Mother not told anything because the
patient is 16• Patient is discharged
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Is “I’m sorry”, an apology?
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Is “I’m sorry”, an apology?
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
QUESTIONS ???
Presented at the 2006 CLEAR Annual ConferenceSeptember 14-16 Alexandria, Virginia
Speaker Contact Information
Irene Clarke, Katja Lutte, Cheryl McDougall
College of Physicians & Surgeons of Ontario80 College St., Toronto, ON, M5G 2E2