Presentation on CSP integration with conventional power plants Solar market in India 2013 7 th – 8 th May 2013, New Delhi Dr. J.T.Verghese – Managing Director Steag Energy Services India Pvt. Ltd.
Dec 14, 2015
Presentation on
CSP integration with conventional power plants
Solar market in India 2013 7th – 8th May 2013, New Delhi
Dr. J.T.Verghese – Managing Director Steag Energy Services India Pvt. Ltd.
• Steag and it’s services
• Hybridization concept examined for NTPC plant at Anta
• Hybridization studies for waste heat recovery boiler
• Hybridization studies at Steag power plants
• Hybridization concept for integrated solar biomass desalination plant
Topics for discussion
Steag’s Activities
Steag Germany - Key figures (as of Dec. 2011)
•External sales 3,066 € m
•Capital expenditure on fixed assets 1,283 € m
•Employees 5,800
Steag India Activities• Engineering Consultancy• O&M services – ~ 5000 MW• System Technology –
Simulators and Plant optimization systems
• Training and advisory services
Steag India – Solar activities• Several DPRs and feasibilities• Ebsilon Solar – Proprietary
thermodynamic design software• Solar simulator - with Trax• Owners Engineer NTPC Anta• Training on Solar – With IITJ
• Identification of specific projects
WindWind
• 50 MW plant at Arenales
SolarSolar
Steag Projects
STEAG holds a strong position in the renewable energy market
PlantsPlantsInstalled capacity
Installed capacity
• since 2002• #3 in Germany
• since 2007• First own biogas plant
commissioned
• since1908• #1 in Germany
• since 1961• #2 in Germany
• since 1994• #1 in Germany
Total
Sites of Evonik New Energies GmbH
SubsidiariesBiomass*Biomass*
BiogasBiogas
Mine gasMine gas
ContractingContracting
GeothermalGeothermal
66
177
77
--
319
154
139
905
71
1,271
MWel MWth
13
108
100
2
223
Steag has a 26% stake Planned start date – Sept. 2013 O&M shall be done by Steag Technical concept comparable to
Andasol 3 Capacity of the plant: 49.9 MW Wet cooling tower implemented Solar field with 156 Loops
Parabolic Collectors Thermal Storage (salt) for up to
7h of full load operation Gross electricity production:
about 170 GWhel p.a. Planned operation period: 40 Yrs
The implemented technical concept is state of the art for CSP plants in Spain
Arenales 50 MW plant in Spain
• Steag and it’s services
• Hybridization concept examined for NTPC plant at Anta
• Hybridization studies for waste heat recovery boiler
• Hybridization studies at Steag power plants
• Hybridization concept for integrated solar biomass desalination plant
Topics for discussion
• CCPP Capacity 419.38 MW (Design)
• 3x 88.70MW GT13D2 -ABB Gas Turbine
• 1x 153.28 MW Alstom- Steam Turbine
• 3 HRSG WAAGNER-BIRO, Forced circulation / Vertical
arrangement
• 220 kV Switchyard
• Year of commissioning:1989
EXISTING CONFIGURATION of NTPC’s ANTA CCPP
SOLAR FIELD LAYOUT WITH CCPP INTEGRATION
15 MW Capacity, 132 Collectors, Solar Field Size Optimized Based On Margin Available In Existing Anta CCPP
LIMITING BOUNDARY CONDITIONS
1. Steam Turbine maximum main steam flow limited to 488 tph to HP-Turbine and 601 tph to LP-Turbine according to heat balance diagram “peak load”.
2. Condenser main steam flow limited to 601 tph according to heat balance diagram.
3. ST generator transformer rated at 195MVA
INTEGRATION OPTIONS
1. Solar Steam integration in to HP Drum of each of 3 existing HRSGs
2. Solar Steam integration in to HP Super Heater of each of 3 existing HRSGs
3. Solar Steam @ 3700 C integration in to HP Main Steam Header (4850 C) before Steam Turbine
4. Solar Steam with separately fired Super Heater and Integrating in to HP Main Steam Header before Steam Turbine
5. New BPST integrated at existing LP main steam header
6. New Condensing Steam Turbine Integrated at existing condenser.
7. Standalone Power Plant.
7.1 Standalone Power Plant generation at 6.6kV level.
7.2 Standalone Power Plant generation at 15.75kV level.
7.3 Standalone Power Plant generation at 11kV/220kV level.
7.3 A Standalone Power Plant 18MW capacity generation at 11kV/220kV level.
7.3 B Standalone Power Plant 21MW capacity generation at 11kV/220kV level.
Exploring different options by modeling on EBSILON software
● User friendliness by intuitive handling (100 % Windows compliant)● Graphical objects for components and pipes (component library)● Complete observance of physical laws ● No restrictions regarding variety and size of the model ● Easy expandability of existing models
● Design and part load calculation possible
● Extension by self-defined components (Macros) possible● Large number of fluids considered (water/steam, air, fluegas, coals, oils, gases,
refrigerants, seawater, mixtures, self-defined fluids)● Fast diagnosis of topology- and specification errors ● Multilingual User Interface (German, English, French, Spanish, Turkish, Chinese)● different Unit Systems (SI, BTU + other units)
EBSILON®Professional - Salient features
A tool for the simulation of all kinds of thermal power plants (fossile, nuclear, CSP, CHP, ORC, refrigeration)
11
Sun
12
• Provides methods to calculate the sun position and incident angles on single axis tracking surfaces
• Flexibility to either use the calculated values from geographical data and time or to directly enter any specific value.
• It is possible to change irradiance data and ambient data globally for all components
• Possible to override globally specified values and enter unique value for any specified component.
Sun
13
Line-focussing solar collector
• This component represents a single line-focussing solar collector which can be of parabolic trough or linear Fresnel type.
• The underlying models calculate the energy balance from direct solar irradiation to usable heat in the heat transfer fluid / water
• For efficiency data, the user has the possibility to:
o define the coefficients in standard formulations,
o to use an adaptation function or
o to define data tables for interpolation 14
Calculation of heat added to the fluid
M1*(H2-H1) = QEFF
QEFF = QSOLAR - QLOSS
QSOLAR = DNI * ANET * FOPT_0 * KIA * FOCUS * ETASHAD * ETAENDL * ETASPILL * ETA_CLEAN
DNI Direct normal irradiance in W/m**2
ANET Net aperture area ANET=LENGTH*AWIDTH*NRATIO
FOPT_0 Peak optical efficiency (parameter FOPT0)
KIA Incident angle correction (cosine losses already included)
FOCUS Focus state of the collector
ETASHAD Factor to include shading losses
ETAENDL Factor to correct end loss effects determined from model
ETASPILL Factor to include optical losses due to wind impact
ETA_CLEAN Factor to correct for actual mirror cleanliness ETA_CLEAN=CLEANI
15
End loss and End Gain
End loss
End lossEnd Gain
16
Incident angle correction
• At non-perpendicular incident of the sun additional losses due to shading of collector structure elements, a longer optical path of the reflected sun rays and angle-dependent optical properties of mirrors and absorber tube occur.
• These optical effects are summarized in the incident angle correction KIA which also includes the cosine losses.
I
IH
B
COS I = B-H
17
Heat loss parameters and calculations
QLOSSA0 Coefficient for standard formulation (constant Term in dT)
QLOSSA1 Coefficient for standard formulation (linear Term in dT)
QLOSSA2 Coefficient for standard formulation (^2 Term in dT)
QLOSSA3 Coefficient for standard formulation (^3 Term in dT)
QLOSSA4 Coefficient for standard formulation (^4 Term in dT)
QLOSSB0 Coefficient for standard formulation (const. Term in dT)
QLOSSB1 Coefficient for standard formulation (lin. Term in dT)
QLOSSB2 Coefficient for standard formulation (^2 Term in dT)
EQLOSS for FQLOSS=1 adaptation function for receiver heat losses. Result: [W/m]
qloss = QLOSSA0 + QLOSSA1*dT + QLOSSA2*dT**2 + QLOSSA3*dT**3 + QLOSSA2*dT**4 + QLOSSB0 * RDNI * r_opt + QLOSSB1 * RDNI * r_opt *dT + QLOSSB2 * RDNI * r_opt *dT**2
where r_opt = KIA * FOCUS * ETASHAD * ETAENDL * ETASPILL * ETA_CLEAN18
Distributing Header
• Intended to model a header that equally distributes a fluid stream on a number of branches.
• In addition to mass it offers a heat and momentum balance too
• Only one "representative branch" is modeled via connection point 2
• The branching points along the header may have different enthalpies and pressures due to heat and pressure loss effects 19
Collecting Header
• Used in conjunction with distributing header to model the collection from number of branches having equal mass flows into one header.
• The user has to specify the number of junction points along the header
• Some of the collecting header parameters are normally identical to the ones of the distributing header therefore both can be synchronized
20
Model created on Ebsilon for evaluatingdifferent integration options
21
OPTION -1 SOLAR STEAM INTEGRATION IN TO HP DRUM OF EACH OF 3 EXISTING HRSGS
BRIEF DESCRIPTION • Up to approx. 80 TPH solar steam is equally injected into
the HP Drums of all 3 HRSGs
HP DRUM
OPTION -1 SOLAR STEAM INTEGRATION IN TO HP DRUM OF EACH OF 3 EXISTING HRSGS
IMPLICATIONS– All the 3 HRSG’s will require
major modification
– Steam flow in HRSG will increase substantially
– Increased steam flow will have to pass into the HP Turbine and then on into LP Turbine.
– Existing ST Generator transformer has 195 MVA rating. Margin for additional Solar power evacuation at 0.8 power factor is very little.
RISKS– Increased steam flow in HRSG
could disturb HRSG dynamics.
– Max generation would be limited by max steam flow permitted in Steam Turbine.
– It would be difficult to determine contribution of solar steam generation for tariff purposes
– Consultation with OEM will be necessary. Even if feasibility is technically established, risk of OEM Guarantees remains owing to age (20Years) of the units.
– Solar Power can be evacuated keeping the power factor close to unity. This can impose limitation on flexibility in operating the plant
OPTION -2SOLAR STEAM INTEGRATION IN TO HP SUPER HEATER OF EACH OF 3 EXISTING HRSGS
BRIEF DESCRIPTION
Up to approx. 80 TPH solar steam at 70 bar pressure, 3700 C is equally injected into Super Heater inlet Headers of all 3 HRSGs
OPTION -2SOLAR STEAM INTEGRATION IN TO HP SUPER HEATER OF EACH OF 3 EXISTING HRSGS
IMPLICATIONS– All the 3 HRSG’s will require
major modification
– Steam flow in the HRSG will be substantially increased.
– This increased steam will have to pass into the HP Turbine and then on into LP Turbine.
– Existing ST Generator transformer having 195 MVA rating. Margin for additional Solar power evacuation at 0.8 power factor is very little.
RISKS– Increased steam flow in HRSG
could disturb HRSG dynamics.– Max generation would be
limited by max steam flow permitted in Steam Turbine.
– It would be difficult to determine contribution of solar steam generation for tariff purposes
– Consultation with OEM will be necessary. Even if feasibility is technically established, risk of Guarantees remains owing to age (20Years) of the units.
– Solar Power can be evacuated keeping the power factor close to unity. This can impose limitation on flexibility in operating the plant.
OPTION -3SOLAR STEAM @ 3700 C INTEGRATION IN TO HP MAIN STEAM HEADER (4850 C) BEFORE STEAM TURBINE
BRIEF DESCRIPTION
Up to approx. 80 TPH Solar steam at 70 bar pressure, 3700 C is mixed in the HP Main Steam Header ( 4850 C) before steam turbine with suitable mixing arrangement.
IMPLICATIONS
– Large Temperature difference between Solar steam and HP Steam from HRSG.
– Existing ST Generator transformer having 195 MVA rating. Margin for additional Solar power evacuation at 0.8 power factor is very little.
RISKS
– Max generation would be limited by max steam flow permitted in Steam Turbine.
– Consultation with OEM will be necessary. Even if feasibility is technically established, risk of Guarantees remains owing to age (20Years) of the units
– It would be difficult to determine contribution of solar steam generation for tariff purposes.
– Solar Power can be evacuated keeping the power factor close to unity. This can impose limitation on flexibility in operating the plant.
OPTION -3SOLAR STEAM @ 3700 C INTEGRATION IN TO HP MAIN STEAM HEADER (4850 C) BEFORE STEAM TURBINE
BRIEF DESCRIPTION
Up to approx. 80 TPH Solar steam at 70 bar, 3700 C is superheated in a separately fired super heater and solar steam temperature raised up to 4850 C matching the Main Steam HP Header parameters before introducing into steam turbine.
OPTION -4SOLAR STEAM WITH SEPARATELY FIRED SUPER HEATER AND INTEGRATING IN TO HP MAIN STEAM HEADER BEFORE STEAM TURBINE
IMPLICATIONS– Separate fired
superheater would need supplementary heating by gas-fired burners. This would increase fossil fuel consumption at low efficiency.
– Existing ST Generator transformer having 195 MVA rating. Margin for additional Solar power evacuation at 0.8 power factor is very little.
RISKS– Additional fossil fuel
consumption will be unacceptable.
– Solar Power can be evacuated keeping the power factor close to unity. This can impose limitation on flexibility in operating the plant.
– It would be more difficult to determine contribution of solar steam generation for tariff purposes compared to options 1-3
OPTION -4SOLAR STEAM WITH SEPARATELY FIRED SUPER HEATER AND INTEGRATING IN TO HP MAIN STEAM HEADER BEFORE STEAM TURBINE
OPTION-5NEW BPST INTEGRATED AT EXISTING LP MAIN STEAM HEADER
BRIEF DESCRIPTION
Up to approx. 80 TPH Solar steam at 30 bar,3700 C is introduced in to New Back Pressure Steam Turbine(BPST). The BPST exhaust will be connected to existing plant LP Main steam header before LP turbine. BPST designed in such a way that the exhaust steam parameters will be matched with the LP Main Steam Header Parameters .
BPST generator will use the existing Steam Turbine Generator Transformer for power evacuation.
IMPLICATIONS
– The BPT exhaust steam which will be mixed with LP steam entering the LPT is limited by the steam flow capacity of the LPT. Balance of the BPT exhaust steam will have to be dumped into condenser.
– Large quantity of BPT exhaust steam needs to be dumped. Total generation by BPT is not very high.
– Existing ST Generator transformer having 195 MVA rating. Margin for additional Solar power evacuation at 0.8 power factor is very little.
RISKS
– Max generation would be limited by max steam flow permitted in LP Turbine.
– Solar Power can be evacuated keeping the power factor close to unity. This can impose limitation on flexibility in operating the plant.
OPTION-5NEW BPST INTEGRATED AT EXISTING LP MAIN STEAM HEADER
OPTION-6NEW CONDENSING STEAM TURBINE INTEGRATED AT EXISTING CONDENSER
BRIEF DESCRIPTION
Up to approx. 80 TPH Solar steam at 30 bar, 3700 C is introduced in to a New Condensing Steam Turbine (CST). The CST exhaust steam will be dumped in to existing Condenser.
CST generator will use the existing Steam Turbine Generator Transformer for power evacuation
IMPLICATIONS
– The CST exhaust steam, which can be exhausted to condenser, is limited by the steam flow capacity of the condenser.
– Max generation would be limited by max steam flow permitted in condenser.
– Existing ST Generator transformer having 195 MVA rating. Margin for additional Solar power evacuation at 0.8 power factor is very little.
RISKS
– Installing a new CST will require new pedestal close to the existing STG. This might be a serious problem. Also it may not feasible to inject CST steam into the condenser via a new opening in condenser neck.
– Solar Power can be evacuated keeping the power factor close to unity. This can impose limitation on flexibility in operating the plant.
– Very small cost advantage, hardly technical advantages from this integration concept
OPTION-6NEW CONDENSING STEAM TURBINE INTEGRATED AT EXISTING CONDENSER
OPTION -7 STAND-ALONE POWER PLANT
BRIEF DESCRIPTION
This option is for a completely independent power plant with steam from solar system. The new equipment will include Steam Turbine Generator, Condenser, Condensate and feed water pumps, deaerator, feed water heater, turbine auxiliaries, Condenser Cooling Water system.
Following possible options are considered:
• Generation at 6.6 kV, feeding into 6.6 kV bus• Generation at 15.75 kV, feeding into primary of existing
Generator Transformer• Generation at 11 kV, feeding into new 11/ 220 kV Generator
Transformer and cabled into switchyard. 3 possible Solar Generation capacities are considered.
• Steag and it’s services
• Hybridization concept examined for NTPC plant at Anta
• Hybridization studies for waste heat recovery boiler
• Hybridization studies at Steag power plants
• Hybridization concept for integrated solar biomass desalination plant
Topics for discussion
• Existing generation data (for 1 year) was studied to establish the spare capacity of turbine. About 5 MW found.
• Design and capacity of other components (condenser, generator, headers etc.) was examined for taking this extra load if provided – Found OK
• Site surveyed and three plots identified. All of them were rectangular areas with longer side in almost NS direction. Land identification is a challenge in retrofits.
• Modeling was done on Ebsilon to evaluate the potential for integrating the proposed solar fields with the existing plant. This would establish the solar field size with reference to the DNI and plots available.
• Modeling was also done for various injection points of steam and extraction points for water and the cumulative power production was calculated in each case for TMY.
5 MW proposed Solar integration at a Cement Cement – Steps & Methodology
Existing Setup
• Heat from three kilns.
• Each kiln contributes flue gasses from two areas. Pre-heater (low temp) and Kiln Cooler (high temperature)
• So six boilers. Three HP boilers – HP header. Three LP boilers - LP header
• Dual injection turbine.
• HP injection at 19 bar and 370 degrees
• LP injection at 4.5 bar and 179 degree
Modeling option 1 – Water tapping from BFP inlet
Modeling option 2 – Water tapping GSC outlet
• Steag and it’s services
• Hybridization concept examined for NTPC plant at Anta
• Hybridization studies for waste heat recovery boiler
• Hybridization studies at Steag power plants
• Hybridization concept for integrated solar biomass desalination plant
Topics for discussion
•The plants are owned by Steag•Studies have been done by Steag – Germany
o 2 x 660 MW coal-fired power plant Sugözü in Turkeyo 165 MW coal-fired power plant Termopaipa in Colombia o Coal-fired power plants in Brazil
Hybridization studies by Steag Germany
Options for topping in Steag’s 2X660 MW plant at Turkey
Bypasses the original heaters.Similar concept proposed by NTPC.
• Steag and it’s services
• Hybridization concept examined for NTPC plant at Anta
• Hybridization studies for waste heat recovery boiler
• Hybridization studies at Steag power plants
• Hybridization concept for integrated solar biomass desalination plant
Topics for discussion
Exterior View of the 12MWe Combined Solar Biomass Desalination Plant from the Desalination
Side including Air Cooled Condenser
Exterior View of the 12MWe Combined Solar Biomass Desalination Plant from the Solar Field side
WHAT IS SPECIAL ABOUT THIS PROJECT
SOLAR THERMAL
FIELD10% of Heat
Desalination unit
Solar Biomass Hybrid Power Plant with Desal WTP
BIOMASS FLOW RATE = 12.8 TPHJULI FLORA up to 100%COTTON STALK 20%
12MW
WATER PRODUCTION OF 160 M3/DAY DM WATER QUALITY